EXPRESSION OF HETEROLOGOUS GENES IN PLANT SYSTEMS 1069
Comparative characteristics of stable and transient expression of genes in plants
Stable expression Transient expression
Characteristic
agrobacterial
transformation
Nuclear transformation
bioballistic
transformation
protoplast
transformation
Plastid
transformation
bioballistic
transformation
agroinfiltration viral infection
Dependence on genotype Dependent Less dependent Dependent Less dependent Dependent Dependent
Host plant range Wide Wide Limited Limited Limited Limited
Vectors Complex Simple Simple Complex Complex Complex
Possibility to use linear DNA No Yes Yes Yes No No
Transfer of genes with a size
of over 1000 Kb
Possible Possible Possible Impossible Possible Possible
Copy number (number
of insertions)
Low copy number Multiple T-DNA
integrations and rearrangements
Low copy number Single copy? Without integration Without integration
Posttranslational modifications
of protein products
Possible Possible Possible Impossible Possible Possible
Expression level Medium Low Low High** High High
Transformation efficiency High* Medium Low Very low High High
Specific expensive equipment Not required Required Not required Required Not required Not required
Complexity of procedures Simple Simple Complex Complex Simple Simple
Biosafety Relative*** Relative*** Relative*** High**** High***** High*****
* High transformation efficiency for some species, but special protocols are required.
** Usually from several percent of the total soluble protein to the physiological maximum >50% of the total soluble protein.
*** Special approaches are required to prevent the release of a transgene into the environment.
**** Maternal inheritance of plastids, the pollen is free of plastids.
***** Transgenic plants are not generated. Most recombinant proteins can be produced under controlled conditions.
RUSSIAN JOURNAL OF GENETICS Vol. 48 No. 11 2012