23.07.2017 Views

e-flight-Journal01-2017-small

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

Electric Aviation, VTOLS, Multicopter,<br />

Rotor wings, Fixed Wing, Hybrid Technoilogy, Rule making news, Test Reports * Electric Aviation, VTOLS, Multicopter, Rotorwings, Hybrid Technoilogy, Rule making News,<br />

eFlight VoFlight VFlight lFlight l.Flight Journal<br />

Quarterly Vol. 1-<strong>2017</strong><br />

17<br />

www.e-<strong>flight</strong>-journal.com<br />

w.<br />

-j<br />

l.<br />

.c<br />

om<br />

supported by<br />

UBER Elevate<br />

The Industry Booster<br />

Zunum & Co<br />

When will airliners be electric ?<br />

Overview<br />

VTOL Aircraft<br />

Lilium Jet<br />

German VTOL takes off<br />

Siemens EXTRA Power<br />

& more at<br />

AERO & Paris Airshow<br />

Pipistrel Alpha Electro<br />

E-<strong>flight</strong> training around the World


E-Flight.<br />

An An exciting future.<br />

“By entering<br />

“By entering<br />

the<br />

the<br />

field<br />

field<br />

of highly<br />

of highly<br />

innovative<br />

innovative<br />

aircraft<br />

aircraft<br />

propulsion<br />

propulsion<br />

technology,<br />

technology,<br />

we‘re<br />

we‘re<br />

opening<br />

opening<br />

a new<br />

a new<br />

chapter<br />

chapter<br />

in E-Mobility.<br />

in E-Mobility.<br />

Collaboration<br />

Collaboration<br />

with<br />

with<br />

Airbus<br />

Airbus<br />

Group<br />

Group<br />

will<br />

will<br />

create<br />

create<br />

new<br />

new<br />

perspectives<br />

perspectives<br />

for<br />

for<br />

our<br />

our<br />

company<br />

company<br />

and<br />

and<br />

open<br />

open<br />

us up<br />

us<br />

even<br />

up even<br />

more<br />

more<br />

to disruptive<br />

to disruptive<br />

innovation.“<br />

innovation.“<br />

Siemens<br />

Siemens<br />

President<br />

President<br />

and<br />

and<br />

CEO<br />

CEO<br />

Joe<br />

Joe<br />

Kaeser<br />

Kaeser<br />

siemens.com/innovation<br />

siemens.com/innovation


e ditorial<br />

e-<strong>flight</strong> Needs a Platform to Take off<br />

EElectric aviation-related technologies and products have<br />

been developing quickly in the past decade. More innovative<br />

concepts occur in the electric aviation area than any other<br />

aerospace sector. New electric aircraft take maiden <strong>flight</strong>s on<br />

a regular basis. Due to the announcement of the electric aircraft<br />

projects of Siemens, Airbus, Uber, Kitty Hawk, Zunum<br />

and many others, we will very likely witness hybrid passenger<br />

airplanes and electric on-demand VTOL in service in the<br />

next decade.<br />

However, this is also the critical time for the growing electric<br />

aviation industry. The application of electric aircraft in <strong>flight</strong><br />

training, recreational <strong>flight</strong> and specific operations like aerobatics<br />

and glider towing are imminent, but the rules must be<br />

developed and the manufacturers and most importantly the<br />

pilots and future customers must want this new e-Aviation.<br />

Due to this, the aviation community and the general public<br />

must be informed and be kept up-to-date.<br />

Some great designs evoked are possible by electric aviation<br />

technologies such as multi-rotor manned VTOL aircraft and<br />

on-demand aerial mobility and may still seem exotic to policy<br />

makers, but the success of the new designs and operation<br />

business models depends on their critical understanding<br />

and support. Moreover, electric aviation has significant<br />

cross-over effect in many relevant industries such as microchip,<br />

sensor, software, synthetic materials, battery, automation,<br />

and so on, but some of these industries or companies<br />

have not been well aware of the new market development<br />

opportunities.<br />

Therefore, we believe that this is the critical time for this new<br />

aviation to take off and to do this there needs to be a platform.<br />

The e Flight Journal strives to be the communication part<br />

of this platform. Dedicated to electric aviation, which effectively<br />

consolidates all communication and marketing channels<br />

concerning e-<strong>flight</strong> and promotes the whole industry. It<br />

is urgently necessary for the exponent and long-term growth<br />

of the electric aviation market and industry.<br />

This journal will serve as a good communication channel between<br />

industry players, regulators, investors, market - the<br />

general public and last but not least politicians. It will be a<br />

loudspeaker, a bridge, a platform and any other roles necessary<br />

to help propel forward electric aviation innovation.<br />

The e Flight Journal is committed to raise the awareness of<br />

electric aviation among the public, pilots and politicians<br />

(PPP) so that the readers learn that electric aviation is an imminent<br />

technology able to be deployed commercially in the<br />

near future instead of a far-fetched phenomenon. To spearhead<br />

the electric aviation market trend so that GA community<br />

including manufacturers and operators know how they<br />

could prepare for the advent of the electric aviation, to showcase<br />

the contemporary state-of-the-art electric aviation technologies<br />

from leading players in the industry, to review the<br />

policymaking situation related to electric aviation and autonomous<br />

<strong>flight</strong> certification and operation from key policymaking<br />

agencies, i.e. FAA, EASA, CAAC etc.<br />

We will do this in every possible way printed (at special occasions<br />

like Airventure and AERO), and of course online, with<br />

the website and social media channels. The difference from<br />

the Journal opposed to many existing blogs is its filtered information<br />

designated and condensed by experienced aviation<br />

editors so that professionals can access the info in a<br />

short time and the public will understand as well.<br />

Electric aviation is more than aviation technology innovation.<br />

It will have a profound social and economic impact, just similar<br />

to what jet aircraft did to the society over 60 years ago,<br />

making flying accessible to “normal” people.<br />

Electric aviation will create more and new types of jobs,<br />

more technology innovation in many other industries, a bigger<br />

market for aviation products, and most importantly, make<br />

aviation more friendly to the environment and flying more accessible<br />

to people. Especially when electric aircraft is bundled<br />

with renewable energy. No more noise complaints from<br />

the neighboring communities, no more concern about the<br />

fuel cost at the end of <strong>flight</strong>. Commuting between and inside<br />

cities would be much easier and quicker. Flying long<br />

distance would be at lower cost and more accessible. Even<br />

the flying experience itself will be more easy (assisted), and<br />

pleasant in a quieter cabin. Electric aviation will make flying<br />

do better what was invented for: to overcome obstacles and<br />

to bring people together.<br />

But until the bright future of electric aviation arrives, we need<br />

your help to get it done.<br />

Here are 3 ways you can help:<br />

First, share as much news with our editorial staff so that we<br />

can investigate and edit the info to accelerate the communication<br />

in the scene by helping eliminate issues and solve<br />

problems together. For example, when new infrastructure is<br />

built in several countries at the same time with little coordination.<br />

By solving problems together we can help eliminate issues<br />

along the way.<br />

Second, share your news with us so that we can inform pilots,<br />

the public and politicians by keeping them up-to-date<br />

and motivated to work for the e-revolution.<br />

Thirdly, support the magazine by distributing the access<br />

links to get the info to as many persons as possible. If possible,<br />

by commercial support as well because to get the info<br />

mass distributed the magazine must be free and also from<br />

the advertising side, there will not be much income as the<br />

markets still have to develop. So as long as there are not<br />

many e-aircraft sold there are no marketing budgets and no<br />

advertising.<br />

So support us and together we can make electric aviation<br />

take off faster and fly higher while everyone enjoys the ride.<br />

Willi Tacke<br />

Xin Gou<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

2


i<br />

lt<br />

Content / Imprint<br />

Electric Aviation, VTOLS, Multicopter, Rotor wings,<br />

Fixed Wing, Hybrid Technoilogy, Rule making news, Test Reports * Electric Aviation, VTOLS, Multicopter, Rotorwings, Hybrid Technoilogy, Rule<br />

Quarterly rly Vol. 1-<strong>2017</strong><br />

www.e-fl ight-journal.com<br />

supported by<br />

UBER Elevate<br />

The Industry Booster<br />

Zunum & Co<br />

When will airliners be electric ?<br />

Siemens EXTRA Power<br />

Overview<br />

& more at<br />

VTOL Aircraft<br />

AERO & Paris Airshow<br />

Lilium Jet<br />

Pipistrel Alpha Electro<br />

German VTOL takes off<br />

E-ight training around the World<br />

Categories<br />

editorial 2<br />

Imprint 3<br />

eNews 4<br />

eDates 7<br />

9 • eTraining & more: One of the best time<br />

in aeronautical history?<br />

13 • AERO & e-<strong>flight</strong> expo & e-<strong>flight</strong> show /<br />

Germany, 25th anniversary:<br />

A Celebration of Electric Aviation<br />

17 • From e-<strong>flight</strong> to „on-demand mobility“<br />

Is the UBER-plane Coming Next?<br />

21 • Fight Training in Whisper Mode<br />

Around he World<br />

24 • Ivo Boscarol – Mr. Electric<br />

27 • Le Bourget Airshow <strong>2017</strong><br />

Paris in the sign of big e<br />

31 • GAMA: The Early Days of a Revolution<br />

Increased Electrification & Automation<br />

We the e Flight Journal (e FJ) founders are<br />

a team of aviation journalists and enthusiasts<br />

who created Flying-Pages.<br />

Publishing several aviation publications<br />

around the world. It started with<br />

the interest in electric flying in 2009.<br />

We co-founded the e-Flight-Expo in<br />

Friedrichshafen/Germany as part of the<br />

AERO, and established it as the largest<br />

show for electric aviation worldwide.<br />

The e FJ is supported by the GAMA EPIC<br />

committee and many others.<br />

33 • Zunum Aero - Think BIG<br />

35 • eVTOL to be in trial use in Dubai<br />

37 • Aurora’s eVTOL approach<br />

39 • Electric Flight Plans of the Norwegian<br />

Government: e-Flight Up North<br />

41 • e-Visions Become Reality<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

www.flying-pages.com<br />

Publisher, Flying-pages GmbH, Buttersteig 11,<br />

D-16831 Rheinsberg OT Zühlen<br />

• phone: D-033931/80 60 27, Fax.: D-030/34 70 91 24<br />

• info@flying-pages.com • www.flying-pages.com<br />

ADVERTISING<br />

Worldwide Willi Tacke, • phone :+49 (0)8841 / 487 515,<br />

mob:+49 (0)171 69 808 71, fax:+49(0)8841 / 496 012,<br />

US Cell: +1 920 385 8495 • willi@flying-pages.com<br />

Germany & other Countries, Rosi Berkemeier<br />

• phone: +49 (0)33931/80 60 27 • Fax +49 (0)30 / 3470 9124<br />

• rosi@flying-pages.com<br />

USA, Bettina C. Larrarte • phone.: +1 970 310 1410<br />

Fax: +1 970 449 0566 • bc@flying-pages.com<br />

EDITORIAL<br />

Robby Bayerl, Marino Boric, Greg Bowls, René Coulon, Dimitri Delemarle, Jan<br />

Fridrich, Mike Friend, Xin Guo, Martin Hardung, Dan Johnson, Klaus Köhmstedt,<br />

Germán Larrarte, Werner Pfändler, Peter Raab, Jan Otto Reimers, Torkell<br />

Saetervade, Christian Tacke, Julia Tacke, Willi Tacke, Dave Unwin; Qinyin<br />

Zhang, Markus Villinger, Jean-Marie Urlacher (Photo).<br />

Managing Editor, Design: Bettina Cosima Larrarte<br />

Technical Proofreader/USA: Renée Larrarte<br />

Online: Achim Holzmann<br />

© <strong>2017</strong> Flying-Pages GmbH. No part of this publication may be reproduced,<br />

stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form, or by any means,<br />

electrical, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without the prior<br />

permission of the copyright owner.<br />

DISCLAIMER<br />

This publication consists largely of information supplied by traders and<br />

manufacturers. Flying-Pages GmbH and its associates do not take any<br />

responsibility for the data, facts, wording, addresses, prices and spelling of<br />

the items published and do not claim the market survey to be complete. The<br />

publisher has made every effort to ensure its accuracy and completeness, and<br />

has queried many facts during its compilation, but cannot be held responsible<br />

for errors or omissions, or for any problems arising from them, or for the use<br />

to which the information is put.<br />

3 e Flight Journal


e News<br />

E-Flight Formation: two Magnus e-Fusion taking off<br />

Electric airplane for 3D mapping<br />

over a populated area<br />

The first demonstration using an electric airplane for 3D mapping<br />

over a populated area was carried out in June. PC Aero’s Elektra One<br />

Solar aircraft flew at 300 m over the old town of Landshut in Southern<br />

Germany in order to map the entire city in three dimensions at very<br />

high resolution using the German company Vialight’s laser transmission<br />

equipment. The Elektra One Solar flew autonomously on a predetermined<br />

path over Landshut while carrying a complex payload<br />

of sensors, cameras and high-speed data links, which transmitted<br />

the data to a ground station. The system was able to transmit real<br />

time video in 4K resolution up to 40 km and subsequently map the<br />

entire town in three dimensions to an accuracy of 2 cm. The obvious<br />

advantage of using a solar electric aircraft for such mission is that it<br />

can fly within a few hundred meters of any city without disturbing the<br />

residents. The direct operational costs are also very low.<br />

SolarStratos’ solar plane made<br />

the maiden <strong>flight</strong> in May<br />

The prototype was made by PC Aero. In late 2016, PC-Aero and<br />

Elektra UAS merged to form Elektra Solar GmbH with a particular<br />

emphasis on electric propulsion and robotic concepts. SolarStratos<br />

plans for manned stratospheric <strong>flight</strong> (up to 80,000ft) with an<br />

unmanned version for day-night solar stratospheric <strong>flight</strong>s under<br />

construction. The original Elektra single seater has been flying<br />

since 2011, with that aircraft now developed as the Elektra One<br />

Solar with solar panels on the much longer wings.<br />

Embry-Riddle formed Hybrid<br />

Consortium<br />

in collaboration with Argonne National Laboratory, Airbus, Boeing,<br />

GE Aviation, Textron, Rolls Royce, Hartzell and Cape Air in June. Led<br />

by the university’s Eagle Flight Research Center (EFRC) based at its<br />

Daytona Beach, FL. campus, the Embry-Riddle Hybrid Consortium<br />

explored the design space for turbine/electric aircraft propulsion systems<br />

that reduce noise, emissions and operating costs. The ultimate<br />

goal is to produce a commercially viable, nine-passenger hybrid turboprop<br />

by 2025, and a large hybrid-electric jet by 2035.<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

4


e News<br />

Zenair STOL CH750 transfers<br />

into electric bush plane<br />

Solar Ship and Zenair have reached an agreement in June<br />

to convert the Zenair STOL CH750 into an electric bush<br />

plane with ground solar charge stations. This new aircraft<br />

will provide extreme short takeoff and landing (XSTOL)<br />

capability enabling pilots to takeoff in areas without runways.<br />

The aircraft is recharged by either a battery swap<br />

or electric vehicle rechargers. It will not use any fossil fuel<br />

and will be available as a bush plane, float or amphibious.<br />

The Zenair electric planes are part of Solar Ship’s selfreliant<br />

infrastructure package to support critical cargo and<br />

air ambulance service in remote areas. The electric bush<br />

plane project is part of Zenair and Solar Ship’s ongoing<br />

partnership since 2011 when Zenair developed the fuselage<br />

for Solar Ship’s Zenship 11, a hybrid aircraft able to<br />

takeoff and land from a soccer field to deliver critical cargo<br />

for disaster relief.<br />

Joby Aviation is developing VTOL<br />

drone<br />

Fixed wing eVTOL aircraft developer Joby Aviation is developing a novel<br />

VTOL drone called Lotus, which has unique configuration with 2-bladed<br />

rotors mounted on the wingtip providing thrust in takeoff and landing, but<br />

scissor close in <strong>flight</strong> to become part of the wing. Lotus project is under contract<br />

with NASA and has its roots in the NASA “Dos Samara” UAV concept.<br />

Lotus project intends to develop a fixed wing VTOL with better cruising efficiency<br />

and lower noise. A future 275 lb-class hybrid-electric model development<br />

of this configuration has the potential to become the first VTOL aircraft<br />

to achieve 24-hour endurance.<br />

First World Future Sports Games in<br />

Dubai end of December <strong>2017</strong><br />

Dubai Museum of the Future Foundation announced that it will organize<br />

World Future Sports Games in December <strong>2017</strong> as the first initiative of its<br />

kind in the world featuring innovation and futuristic technology based<br />

sports competitions including manned drones. The World Future Sports<br />

Games was unveiled as Dubai announced Future Sports as a new innovation<br />

driven economic sector. The first edition of the World Future Sports<br />

Games will be hosted in Dubai from December 28-30, <strong>2017</strong>. The games<br />

will be held over three days once every two years, and will be open for participation<br />

from individuals, companies, academic institutions and research<br />

centers from around the world. The Games will feature nine competitions<br />

that employ modern technology and artificial intelligence: driverless car<br />

racing, robotic soccer, robotic running competitions, manned drones racing,<br />

robotic swimming, robotic table tennis, robotic wrestling, drones races<br />

and cybathlon competition.<br />

Echodyne with $ 29 million in<br />

new funding<br />

Echodyne, a Seattle startup<br />

building compact beam<br />

scanning radar units to<br />

help drones/automatic flying<br />

air taxi detect and avoid<br />

terrains and obstacles, has<br />

$ 29 million in new funding<br />

from Bill Gates and<br />

Paul Allen in May. Echodyne’s<br />

major product is<br />

the Metamaterial Electronically<br />

Scanning<br />

Array (MESA), a radar array that is <strong>small</strong> enough to mount<br />

on a drone or a manned autonomous aerial mobility vehicle.<br />

In November 2016, Echodyne demonstrated a MESA system<br />

that can automatically detect and evade oncoming aircraft<br />

and other obstacles. Their latest version can pick out<br />

a <strong>small</strong> Cessna aircraft from the equivalent of thirty football<br />

fields away, and a hobbyist DJI Phantom drone from 750<br />

meters.<br />

Electric aircraft fly-in in<br />

Switzerland<br />

The Swiss electric aviation advocate group Smartflyer Challenge<br />

is going to hold an electric aircraft fly-in on 9-10 September<br />

<strong>2017</strong> at Grenchen airport (LSZG) in Switzerland.<br />

There will be a static and air display for a variety of different<br />

electric- or hybrid powered aircraft including aerobatic airplanes,<br />

gliders, multicopters and so on.<br />

Pipistrel formed MAHEPA<br />

(Modular Approach to Hybrid-Electric Propulsion Architecture)<br />

in cooperation with Compact Dynamics, DLR, University<br />

of Ulm, H2Fly, Politecnico di Milano, TU Delft and University<br />

of Maribor. The main result of MAHEPA project will<br />

be novel, modular and scalable hybrid-electric powertrains<br />

capable of running on alternative fuels or on hydrogen with<br />

zero emissions.<br />

5 e Flight Journal


e News<br />

Toyota use wind turbine power to generate<br />

hydrogen from water<br />

Toyota began a new trial program with updated equipment to use wind turbine power<br />

to generate hydrogen from water in July. The trial program started in 2015 and has produced<br />

hydrogen to power 2 test forklift trucks. This new updated program will produce<br />

enough hydrogen to power 12 forklift trucks. Besides the energy program, Toyota has direct<br />

participation in electric aviation by providing about $ 35,0000 USD financial support<br />

to a flying car project that intends to be used to light the torch at the opening ceremony<br />

of the Tokyo Olympic Games in Summer 2018. Toyota also sent senior engineers to the<br />

UBER Elevate Summit conference in Dallas.<br />

The future of Transportation<br />

First US state governor to ride<br />

autonomously piloted aircraft<br />

Terry McAuliffe, the Virginia Governor, became the first US<br />

state governor to ride an autonomously piloted aircraft when<br />

he was the passenger in a Diamond DA-42 of the Aurora<br />

company in May. Terry McAuliffe has been heavily promoting<br />

the drone and autonomous <strong>flight</strong> technologies business in<br />

Virginia. Aurora’s DA-42 can be flown as an optional piloted<br />

airplane (OPA) with full autonomous <strong>flight</strong> control capability<br />

including autonomous takeoff and landings. In addition, Aurora’s<br />

robotic co-pilot rig has successfully landed a Boeing<br />

737 simulator. The robotic co-pilot rig can be adoptable and<br />

fitted in existing airplane models fairly quickly. Aurora is also<br />

one of the five current partner companies of UBER’s Elevate<br />

eVTOL on-demand aerial mobility project.<br />

At the “Future of Transportation World Conference” (July 5-6, in Cologne /<br />

Germany) in the session on “Getting Transportation Off the Ground” there<br />

were next to known players also some new e-<strong>flight</strong> concepts presented:<br />

Alma Flexcraft: The Portuguese company Almadesign works on a very-<br />

Short Take-Off and Landing (vSTOL) Flexcraft, with hybrid-electric power<br />

plant, 2 fan-in-wings and a pusher engine in the back between the two<br />

booms. This 8-passenger concept is part of the NewFACE, a cooperation<br />

of Almadesign, INEGI, SET and Embraer Compósitos, and the Technical<br />

University of Lisbon. Different propulsion schemes are being considered,<br />

as well as fuel cells for energy storage. Also there is the Israeli company Urban<br />

Aeronautics whose subsidiary Aurora Aircraft GmbH (founded in June<br />

<strong>2017</strong>) works on the Falcon XP, a 14-passenger version of the 4-passenger<br />

Urban Aeronautics/Metro Skyways CityHawk. “The aircraft will first run on<br />

jet fuel, later a hydrogen electric version is planed”.<br />

Geely acquired flying car<br />

company Terrafugia<br />

The Chinese car manufacturer Geely announced in July that<br />

they have acquired the flying car company Terrafugia. Chris<br />

Jaran, a former Vice President-China for Bell Helicopters and<br />

COO-Sikorsky Global Helicopters, was appointed as CEO of<br />

Terrafugia as of July <strong>2017</strong>. Geely is the owner of Volvo and<br />

Lotus and is active in electric mobility and autonomous technology<br />

development. Besides the Transition flying car that<br />

Terrafugia has been developing light sports aircraft qualified,<br />

in May 2013 Terrafugia announced the successor of the Transition<br />

called the TF-X which would be a plug-in hybrid tilt-rotor<br />

VTOL vehicle and would be a fully autonomous flying car.<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

6


e News<br />

RX1E is getting upgrade with<br />

battery rescue system<br />

The Chinese electric light sports airplane RX1E is developing<br />

an upgrade model with large battery capacity and BRS’<br />

whole airframe rescue parachute system. Issued with a LSA<br />

type approval and production certificate by the Chinese<br />

civil aviation administrator, RX1E was the first type certified<br />

electric airplane model in the world. The current production<br />

model has a <strong>flight</strong> time of about one hour.<br />

NASA Cafe EAS in Oshkosh<br />

The Comparative Aircraft Flight Efficiency (CAFE) foundation will hold the<br />

<strong>2017</strong> Electric Aircraft Symposium on 22-23 July <strong>2017</strong> at the University of<br />

Wisconsin Oshkosh. The subject of this year will be “Urban Air Mobility:<br />

Emerging Technologies and Early Market Opportunities”. Keynote speakers<br />

from NASA, GAMA, Siemens, Pipistrel, Zee Aero, Eviation, and various investor<br />

groups and other companies will cover all relevant issues of electric<br />

aviation from regulation and policy to electric airplane model update and<br />

implementation programs. Beginning in 2007, CAFE foundation’s Electric<br />

Aircraft Symposium is the earliest electric aviation event in the US. This<br />

year’s conference will coincide with EAA Airventure’s date and location so<br />

as to make it easier to participate.<br />

Electric Flight Forum in November in<br />

Beijing<br />

The first global e-<strong>flight</strong>-forum, organized by Flying Pages GmhH and local<br />

partners, will be held in Beijing China in November <strong>2017</strong>. This will be the first<br />

electric aviation themed event in China. Besides the global players in electric<br />

aviation, Chinese high-profile participants will include the Chinese policymakers,<br />

national research groups, major general aviation operators and<br />

various investor groups. As the Chinese central government has set a high<br />

goal for the general aviation development in China by 2020 and explicitly<br />

supports new energy aircraft designs and e-mobility at large, electric aviation<br />

has drawn significant attention in China, for example, the Chinese RX1E<br />

LSA became the first type certified electric airplane in the world in 2015.<br />

Kitty Hawk and more e-<strong>flight</strong><br />

at Airventure<br />

Kitty Hawk, the electric aviation startup founded by Google’s<br />

Larry Page, is going to present its single seat eVTOL preproduction<br />

model to the public for the first time at EAA Airventure<br />

this month. Kitty Hawk may also make demo <strong>flight</strong>s<br />

at the seaplane base at Lake Winnebago. Kitty Hawk has<br />

begun accepting order deposits for this single seat FAR103<br />

compliant ultralight eVTOL which, if launched at the end of<br />

this year as planned, will be the world’s first commercially<br />

available eVTOL.<br />

At the EAA Airventure in July, aerospace innovation products<br />

will be on display at Aviation Gateway Park, home of the Innovation<br />

Center at AirVenture Oshkosh. Presenting products<br />

will include the Workhorse SureFly eVTOL aircraft, Kitty Hawk<br />

single seat eVTOL and a Detroit Flying Cars prototype as<br />

well as Pipistrels Alpha elektro the sunflyer and much more..<br />

7 e Flight Journal


e News<br />

Tecnam delivered P2006T Twin NASA X-57<br />

electric powered propulsion program<br />

Tecnam delivered the second P2006T Twin for NASA X-57<br />

electric powered propulsion program in July. X-57 is the first<br />

NASA X-plane to feature a fully distributed electric propulsion<br />

system, which researchers will use to demonstrate an<br />

increase in cruise energy efficiency, as well as reductions in<br />

carbon emission and aircraft noise. The wing will be manufactured<br />

and integrated on the P2006T fuselage by the US<br />

based company Xperimental. Researchers hope to fly an<br />

early version of the modified Tecnam P2006T piloted X-plane<br />

early next year, enabling NASA engineers to easily compare<br />

the performance of the X-57 version with the standard production<br />

Tecnam P2006T Twin.<br />

Man flying an electric multicopter<br />

delivered soccer ball<br />

At the Portuguese Soccer Cup Final game in May, a man<br />

flying an electric multicopter delivered the soccer ball to the<br />

referee. Footage of the amazing futuristic stunt shows a man<br />

riding an obvious electric multicopter at around a 70 m height<br />

in rain before landing by the match official near the halfway<br />

line and handing the ball over and then flying away. The editor’s<br />

warning: do not attempt this at home. The rider’s feet<br />

were only centimeters away from spinning propellers and in<br />

case of a crash landing the flying height was too high without<br />

causing serious injury or worse too low to use a parachute.<br />

For those who are more curious about the game, Benfica<br />

won the game 2-1, beating Vitória de Guimarães and they<br />

completed their 11th league and cup double.<br />

MAKS:<br />

Electric aircraft from Russia<br />

At the Russian MAKS Airshow Sergey Korotkov, chief designer<br />

of the Russian United Aircraft Corporation (UAC),<br />

announced on Thursday, July 20th, <strong>2017</strong> that “UAC is proceeding<br />

with the development of electric aircraft for civil and<br />

military use. Yesterday, for example, a range of agreements<br />

on batteries were signed that will provide planes with new<br />

energy.”<br />

Lilium Jet test flew two-seat<br />

prototype of eVTOL<br />

Lilium Jet successfully test flew its two-seat prototype of the<br />

eVTOL by remote control in April. The novel feature of the<br />

design is the setup of the series of electric fans on the flaps<br />

of the main wing and the canard wing so that it can generate<br />

lift with <strong>small</strong> wing area to reach high cruising speed while<br />

maintain low speed controllability. The near full wing span<br />

electric fans blowing over the wing surface at cruising stage<br />

also help maintain laminar flow to lower the drag. Lilium Jet<br />

plans to develop up to 5-seater model to be used for ondemand<br />

aerial mobility.<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

8


e Training & more<br />

ONE OF THE BEST TIME<br />

in aeronautical history?<br />

Zunum, the company financed by<br />

Boeing and Jetblue, wants to fly hybrid<br />

electric with passengers soon.<br />

XTI starts vertically and then flies quick like a jet - thanks<br />

to e-fans which you can swivel.<br />

Now may be the best time for aircraft designers ever<br />

since the jet age. Taking the advantages of <strong>small</strong>er, faster<br />

and cheaper computer chips and sensors, cheaper<br />

and more powerful batteries and motors, autonomous<br />

software from smart phones, consumer drones, and automobile<br />

industries, electric aircraft and new concepts<br />

for electric vertical <strong>flight</strong> are mushrooming. In fact there<br />

are so many new electric vertical takeoff and landing<br />

(eVTOL) designs showing up since the last issue of WDLA,<br />

that a newly added “multirotor” category in the WDLA issue<br />

of this year says for itself.<br />

This eVTOL concept became a hot topic when Uber released<br />

its white paper on an on-demand eVTOL urban mobility called<br />

“Elevate” last October, and became viral after the Elevate Summit<br />

conference in Dallas, USA this April. When anything draws the attention<br />

of Silicon Valley, it is on the fast track. Silicon Valley has the<br />

passion, determination, capital(lots of), and the desire to succed.<br />

Kitty Hawk’s eVTOL is now open for pre-order. Elon Musk has<br />

mentioned the supersonic (that’s correct) eVTOL aircraft at a dozen<br />

occasions. Even Airbus set up its eVTOL branch at Silicon<br />

Valley. The Elevate Summit is a gathering of who’s who in the<br />

aerospace community. Almost all the names you have heard of<br />

or are about to hear of in the industry showed up. Uber ended up<br />

forming partnerships with five aircraft manufacturers to design, build<br />

and test eVTOL prototypes by 2020. Dubai has partnered with<br />

Volocopter to test fly their X2 multirotor in the Dubai city by the end<br />

of year. Dallas, US is also eager to try out the urban aerial mobility<br />

concept. Tilt wings, tilt rotors, multirotor, multi electric ducted fans<br />

(EDF), fixed wings, helicopters are all the indicators of the diversity,<br />

possibilities and excitement brought about by electric aviation.<br />

Startups and Sillicon Valley are not the only players in this game.<br />

Incumbant are all in. Just look at the member companies of electric<br />

population and innovation committee (EPIC) of GAMA. Airbus has<br />

set up two separate entities for electric aviation research, in silicon<br />

Valley developing the Vahana eVTOL planned for test <strong>flight</strong> within the<br />

year, and the Urban Air Mobility division at the head office respectively.<br />

Airbus has decided to upgrade its F-Fan fixed wing project to E-Fan X,<br />

a hybrid/electric regional passenger airplane. Boeing, jointly with Jet<br />

Blue, invested in Zunum Aero to develop hybrid/electric regional aircraft<br />

as well. Bell helicopter and Embraer signed up with Uber to develop<br />

eVTOL technologies.<br />

9 e Flight Journal


e Training & more<br />

This e-heli flew in 2016 - now<br />

the French manufacturer<br />

Aquinea wants to build a<br />

two seater as well.<br />

The “Workhorse” of the US manufacturer Surefly was<br />

shown in Paris airshow <strong>2017</strong> and flies hybrid-electric.<br />

Electric aviation shows a powerful cross-over application among<br />

different industries. The collaboration between Airbus and<br />

Siemens have proved that. Many technologies and products<br />

such as autonomous vehicle control, detect and avoid, battery<br />

and motor, advanced composite manufacturing progress can be<br />

utilized by many other industries. The line between aviation and<br />

other industries becomes so blurred. Some electric aviation startups<br />

have already hired much more electric engineers than aeronautical<br />

engineers.<br />

For pilots and especially for new pilots who are just about to begin<br />

training, the cheaper, quieter and more environmental and neighbor<br />

community friendly electric <strong>flight</strong> now becomes more practical<br />

and closer to reality than ever. Not only several electric airplanes<br />

have obtained certification such as Pipistrel’s Alpha Electro (UL/<br />

LSA in Australia) and the Chinese RX1E (LSA).<br />

But although the situation light –electric Aircraft in many countries<br />

is still unclear for the Microlight in Europe (demand for weight increase<br />

pending) and LSA in USA (no electric motors allowed in<br />

LSA class) several electric <strong>flight</strong> training programs have been set<br />

up.<br />

Pipistrels´ Alpha Electro is going<br />

to be used in <strong>flight</strong> training<br />

programs around the world -<br />

France, Switzerland and USA are<br />

starting this summer.<br />

The Swiss company AlpinAirPlanes is going to deploy ten Alpha<br />

Electro at ten trial airfields with <strong>flight</strong> schools, Each airfield has a<br />

solar power recharging station and the distance between the airfields<br />

is so that with the 1.5 hours of endurance of the aircraft<br />

you always can reach at least 1 of the other fields. A similar project<br />

will start this summer in Fresno county in California (USA) a team<br />

around Joseph Oldham.<br />

They will purchase 4 Alpha electro and use it in <strong>flight</strong>shools from 4<br />

airfields. Interresting that both projects are financed by sponsors and<br />

state support and in both countries the authorities allowed to fly in<br />

this Testphase in the <strong>flight</strong> Training with permit to fly.<br />

Two more <strong>flight</strong> trainings using the Alpha electro one is organized<br />

by SpaceX because after an old US law all astronauts must have<br />

a pilots licence. So the private space travel organizer is going<br />

to train the future space tourist on the 2 Alpha Electro which will<br />

be delivered at Oshkosh <strong>2017</strong>. And finally the French Aeroclub<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

10


e Training & more<br />

Siemens Power for the Extra: The aerobatic aircraft tows the glider with a speed of 9.5 m/s.<br />

Federation Française Aeronautique (FFA) announced at the Paris<br />

Airshow <strong>2017</strong> that they purchased 3 Alpha electro which will fly with<br />

first Permit to Fly and than later CS-VLA The French authorities will<br />

handle the operations and Pipistrel do the certification with EASA.<br />

In all cases also standard Rotax Alphas will be available to assure<br />

that the new pilots also can fly with combustion engine aircraft.<br />

The most exciting news about electric <strong>flight</strong> training came at the<br />

Paris Airshow when the French Federation of Aeronautics announced<br />

they will using Alpha Electro as a private pilot training<br />

program. Now that’s serious stuff.<br />

Another example for e-development getting practice news has<br />

been the worlds first e-<strong>flight</strong>-show which accompanied the e-<strong>flight</strong>expo<br />

at the AERO exhibition.<br />

The diversity and implementation of electric aviation is more<br />

than eVTOL and <strong>flight</strong> training. The Swiss company H55, is<br />

now working with the Solar Impulse project co-founder and pilot<br />

André Borschberg, they used the Silence Aircraft Twister and<br />

with Siemens they developed a single seat aerobatic airplane. At<br />

the AERO <strong>2017</strong> another Siss company MSW presented the project<br />

Evolaris an electric aerobatic plane with an empty weight of<br />

500 KG and 221 Kw e engine power.<br />

Finally at the moment the most impressive e-Plane<br />

the Extra 330 LE, another high performance electric<br />

aerobatic airplane jointly developed by Extra Aircraft and Siemens,<br />

have successfully demonstrated the aerobatic performance as<br />

well as the capacity of glider towing and has beaten several world<br />

Nikhil Goel from UBER at “Elevate” conference<br />

in Dallas April <strong>2017</strong> which gave a big<br />

push to the VTOL scene.<br />

11 e Flight Journal


e Training & more<br />

eVolos 2X will start passenger transport test in Dubai in <strong>2017</strong>.<br />

records. At Paris Airshow the aircraft towed up an aerobatic glider<br />

to 1000 Meter (with an average climb rate of 9.5 Meters per second)<br />

than the glider performed aerobatics while the Extra landed<br />

and then after the glider landed the Extra, without recharging, took<br />

off again and for an impressive aerobatic show with 260 Kw on<br />

the prop.<br />

Even more serious is when a national government wants to explore<br />

the possibility of using electric aircraft and wants to become<br />

a leading country in this fiel, like the Norwegian Government has<br />

announced in spring <strong>2017</strong>. The country which achieved the highest<br />

density of electric cars per inhabitant in the past 10 years over<br />

a government program is evaluating the possibilities of electrifying<br />

the network of state owned Airfields around the country. The<br />

conditions are ideal. As Norway has money in the budget from the<br />

oil, and a production of electric energy from water turbines which<br />

exceeds its consumption. It also has a net of airfield from which a<br />

lot of commuter <strong>flight</strong>s with mostly under 300 KM distance are operated<br />

as part of the state transport plan, because the road network is<br />

very loose and ground transport out of the centers slow.<br />

The brave new world of electric aviation is forming. We sincerely<br />

hope that you are as excited as we are to read the intriguing new<br />

electric aircraft designs in the following pages in nearly all categories<br />

and the new VTOL - aviation section of WDLA, and to look forward<br />

even just five years from today.<br />

The Multicopter Whisper<br />

from France flies with eight<br />

Plettenberg motors.<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

12


Expo<br />

Market Watch<br />

25 th ANNIVERSARY<br />

„<br />

A Celebration of<br />

Electric Aviation<br />

For the celebration of the 25th AERO in Friedrichshafen/Germany, there was<br />

not only an in-house celebration but also a series of world premieres which<br />

included the largest scale e-<strong>flight</strong>-expo to date as well as the world’s first e-<br />

<strong>flight</strong>-show with e-Aerobatic and the first electric formation <strong>flight</strong>.<br />

In 25 years AERO has developed into the largest<br />

general aviation trade show in Europe,<br />

as well as the leading fair for innovative aviation<br />

technologies in the world. The best showcase<br />

of AERO’s innovative nature is e-<strong>flight</strong>-expo<br />

which AERO founded together with Flying<br />

Pages GmbH in 2009. In its 9th year, the e-<br />

<strong>flight</strong>-expo was bigger than ever. It has grown<br />

so much that it no longer fits into its original location<br />

in the Forum West, but instead now occupies<br />

the entire hall A7 spanning 6200 square<br />

meters. A7 hall is conveniently located directly<br />

at the East entrance and thus is also at Forum<br />

East, where the e-<strong>flight</strong>-expo lectures occur.<br />

The move to the hall A7 was also necessary<br />

The pilots of the worlds first e-<strong>flight</strong>-show with its organization<br />

team Willi Tacke (left) and Roland Bosch (3rd from left).<br />

13 e Flight Journal


e Flight expo<br />

& E Flight show<br />

Market Watch<br />

because the hall has large hangar doors and access to the<br />

airfield. This is important because the e-<strong>flight</strong>-expo also had<br />

wings in <strong>2017</strong> and launched for the world’s first time the e-<br />

<strong>flight</strong>-show celebrating the premiere of AERO!<br />

In addition to the NASA-awarding hybrid touring motor glider<br />

E-Genius, three aircraft powered by Siemens electric motors<br />

took off at e-<strong>flight</strong>-show: an E-Extra 330LE and two e-<br />

Fusions showed the world’s first e-formation <strong>flight</strong>. The Extra<br />

completed an aerobatics sequence, along with the aerobatic<br />

performance of Hangar 55 Hamilton aEro, an E-robatic<br />

aircraft from Switzerland. The Antares of Lange Aviation,<br />

the most sold and so far the only series produced e-plane,<br />

also participated in the e-<strong>flight</strong>-show. The pure electric flying<br />

show took place twice during AERO, on Tuesday, for the<br />

press day for media representatives and invited guests and<br />

on Saturday to celebrate the 25th anniversary of AERO, a<br />

mixed <strong>flight</strong> show with electric and conventionally driven<br />

engines.<br />

Day one of the AERO experience was a review of the electric<br />

aircraft innovations. This is a rapidly changing technology<br />

with both motors and applications showing up all over<br />

the place. The main concentration of electric systems is in<br />

Hall A7, where everyone from <strong>small</strong> startups with <strong>small</strong> motor<br />

solutions all the way up to the heavyweight in the industry,<br />

Siemens, are all in this location. Just as the show has<br />

many prototype aircraft, which may have never flown before,<br />

Hall A7 has prototype motors that may have never been installed<br />

on a production aircraft.<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

14


Expo<br />

Of course it takes a while for prototype motors to make their<br />

way onto production aircraft. So a walk around the halls<br />

quickly reveals that the motors from another German company,<br />

Geiger Engineering, are becoming popular. Geiger is<br />

currently producing five motors ranging from 12 KW to 50<br />

KW (16 hp - 68 hp) making them popular for a variety of airframes.<br />

Even more appealing is that Geiger is one of the<br />

companies offering complete systems from battery packs<br />

designed for aviation all the way through propellers.<br />

Many of the motors are for very light applications such as<br />

light weight shift control trikes or gliders. But motors are becoming<br />

more powerful with the increase in power; new technical<br />

problems need to become overcome. For example, the<br />

larger the power capability of the motor, the more cooling is<br />

required for the motor. Smaller motors are mostly air-cooled,<br />

but some of the medium and larger motors require liquid<br />

cooling. This doesn’t mean that the motors have radiators,<br />

but liquid is built into the motor to help keep heat away from<br />

hot spots that are created when electricity is converted to<br />

mechanical power. This seems to parallel thermal engines,<br />

where <strong>small</strong> engines are air cooled, but larger engines need<br />

more complex cooling systems. There are three components<br />

to electrical power systems. You have the motor itself,<br />

the batteries, and the controller. The controller makes sure<br />

that the proper amount of electricity is delivered to the motor.<br />

Most of the electric motor developers are also developing<br />

controllers for their motors since the two work with each other<br />

so closely. Some companies, such as the German company<br />

Geiger, are offering complete systems from batteries to<br />

motor, and sometimes even propellers.<br />

Furthermore, in Hall A7 the improved Volocopter, the world’s<br />

most advanced electric gyrocopter and the world’s most advanced<br />

hybrid amphibian can be seen. A detailed list can be<br />

found on the following pages. The lecture and forum program<br />

is also bigger and more meaningful than ever.<br />

The e-<strong>flight</strong> lecture program took place again in the Forum<br />

East. After Tom Gunnarson’s first talks about “Electric<br />

Propulsion Standard Development”, Tom Gunnarson<br />

opened the round at Wednesday, 1.45 pm, with a high-profile<br />

panel discussion on “From Today’s Electric Aircraft - to<br />

Electric On Demand Mobility.” In addition to leading managers<br />

of aircraft and engine manufacturers, EASA and the<br />

well-known American transport-on-demand company UBER<br />

were also present. Ever since UBER released the Elevate<br />

program whitepaper last October, on-demand electric vertical<br />

takeoff and landing (eVTOL) became a phenomenal concept<br />

in the mass media. For your information, Daimler is also<br />

involved in the company. At the e-<strong>flight</strong>-forum Mark Moore<br />

of UBER gave an extensive presentation of the Elevate program.<br />

Mark Moore is a NASA veteran who was the head of<br />

the NASA Electric Xplane program before joining UBER. On<br />

the final day of e-<strong>flight</strong>-forum, the prestigious e-<strong>flight</strong>-award<br />

was announced and presented to AlpinAirPlanes, an electric<br />

airplane training program in Swiss using Pipiestral’s Alpha<br />

Electric.<br />

One company is not only developing a motor and controller,<br />

Qinetix, a German company, is placing the controller in<br />

the case along with the engine. It means that aircraft builders<br />

only have to mount the motor and run power leads to it. The<br />

QPD-40 is an integrated system that is actually designed to<br />

be an electric replacement for the old Rotax 503 2-stroke engine.<br />

The designer explained that he had a trike with that<br />

engine and wanted the replacement for himself. He figured<br />

others would want it, too. The motor is still being tested and<br />

should be available later this year. Expected specs are: 40<br />

KW (53 hp) power and 12 Kg (26 lbs) weight.<br />

15 e Flight Journal


Expo<br />

h<br />

HIGHLIGHTS OF THE e-FLIGHT-EXPO IN <strong>2017</strong> ARE:<br />

Siemens: the leading e-aviation technology developer<br />

Votec221: new electric aerobatic airplane from Swiss.<br />

The engine almost matches Siemens’ power/weight ratio.<br />

Ground tested, not flown yet. Unusual paint scheme done<br />

by an artist.<br />

aEro: electric aerobatic airplane jointly developed by<br />

Silence, Siemens, Hamilton and Hanger 55. Test flown last<br />

year. Serial production down the road.<br />

Eurosport Crossover: new hybrid power system this year<br />

with new combustion engine as generator.<br />

Equator P2 Xcursion: hybrid amphibian new design from Norway,<br />

full electric version and another hybrid/electric four-seat cruiser airplane<br />

in vision.<br />

Pipistrel: the leading<br />

company in electric aviation<br />

is going to begin several<br />

e-<strong>flight</strong> training programs<br />

in Switzerland, US<br />

and France.<br />

Autogyro eCavalon: the first electric gyroplane jointly developed<br />

with Bosch.<br />

Nirvana driving motor: an innovative electric driving front<br />

wheel design for existing gyroplane models. Already certified<br />

for road drive in Czech Republic. Retrofit available now<br />

for various gyroplane models. Turn your gyroplane into a flying<br />

car simply and easily.<br />

Senkel flying bicycle: an innovative electric flying bicycle<br />

design. Combining the light weight of both a bicycle and<br />

a powered parachute, it is an easy and simply conversion<br />

from an electric-assisted incumbent bicycle to an electric<br />

powered parachute. The designer also proposed an open<br />

source program for electric motor design.<br />

e-genius: the winner of multiple e-aviation competition and<br />

the holder of several e-aviation world record. It presents a<br />

new hybrid power system. University of Stuttgart / Germany,<br />

where this e-airplane is born, also presented.<br />

Comos Ikarus e-C42: an<br />

electric version of the popular<br />

C-42 using Geiger<br />

motor.<br />

Engiro motor: new hybrid<br />

power system. 30kw generator<br />

model in production,<br />

60kw down the road<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

16


Uber UBER Elevate<br />

UBER Elevate chief engineer Mark Moor (ex NASA X-plane developer) with VTOL designers from all over the world.<br />

From e-<strong>flight</strong> to „on-demand mobility“<br />

Is the UBER-plane<br />

Coming Next?<br />

In recent years, hardly has an event has inspired the imagination of<br />

aircraft developers, pilots and investors like the announcement of<br />

the online co-driver company UBER with its program ELEVATE to<br />

create a worldwide platform for a passenger service with a vertical<br />

air taxi.<br />

If designers are fantasizing about fantastic<br />

new aircraft ideas, then usually only a few insiders<br />

move. Even for serious world conglomerates<br />

such as Airbus or Siemens and others from electric aviation,<br />

“that is still years away” but UBER may have a different<br />

mindset. After all, Uber has managed to catapult its stock<br />

market value to more than $60 billion US in less than 5 years.<br />

What is significant in terms of business model is that Uber<br />

is still in a deficit today, but it thrives solely due to the vision<br />

that makes the almost impossible possible. This mindset is<br />

certainly necessary for the Elevate program, because Uber<br />

not only needs to overcome the technical obstacles of the<br />

low battery density, but also needs to find a way to convince<br />

the certification regulators and traffic control authorities.<br />

At the end of April at the UBER Elevate meeting in Dallas, not<br />

only companies that wanted to share the vision and make<br />

technology possible were there, but also the air traffic authorities.<br />

The FAA has teamed with a whole team, which together<br />

with the GAMA (the General Aviation Manufacturers<br />

Association), to hold a full day seminar on how to integrate<br />

the new electric aircraft with a vertical takeoff option<br />

into the new Part 23 registration requirements that the FAA<br />

are currently working on. Especially, when looking into the<br />

17 e Flight Journal


Uber UBER elevate Elevate<br />

Ivo Boscarol, CEO of Pipistrel and one of the UBER partners, explains his Vision of WTOL: flying from window at home to the<br />

window at work.<br />

future, these eVTOL aircraft can also be used as computer-controlled<br />

“on demand” air taxis. All possible options<br />

were considered, from the construction of the power supply<br />

for the inner city landing places for these machines<br />

to the noise problem. And why - at least in the opinion of<br />

the UBER-Elevate chief technician, multi-rotor concepts<br />

are preferable in any case to conventional helicopters.<br />

Illustrate list of partners<br />

The list of participating company representatives is somewhat<br />

like the “Who’s Who” of modern technology: car and<br />

motorcycle manufacturers such as Toyota, Yamaha, And<br />

Kawasaki, Boeing Embrair and Airbus, tech companies like<br />

Siemens and GE - it was all represented for what the future<br />

wants to design. Larry Page has already put more than 100<br />

million dollars in the companies Zee AERO and Kitty Hawk.<br />

Amazon has long established its department of drones and<br />

next to Intel is now also Microsoft due to its purchase of<br />

Skype, which has the European VTOL company Lilium.<br />

At the same time, the requirements of UBER are very specific<br />

when one looks at the capabilities that the machines<br />

should have. Besides vertical takeoff capability the aircraft<br />

should fly only with battery, can carry four people,<br />

and can cover a distance of up to 80 miles with up to 160<br />

mph. “In my opinion, just because of the range, pure multicopter<br />

sets are excluded,” explains Mark Moore, the UBER<br />

Elevate chief who has served a long career at NASA where<br />

he studied distributed propulsion systems, which produced<br />

an effective interplay between propellers and fixed<br />

wings to make an optimization aerodynamic solution.<br />

It was noted that Volocopter was not invited to the presentation,<br />

but Daniel Wiegand head of Lilium was.<br />

Just three days before the conference, Lilium’s unmanned<br />

prototype had its first <strong>flight</strong>. Interestingly, although<br />

the requirements are very specific, the concepts<br />

are very different. Also interesting is the selection<br />

of the partners that UBER presented at the conference.<br />

There was the American helicopter manufacturer Bell<br />

Helicopter along with the general aviation manufacturer<br />

Mooney. Another partner was Gyrocopter pioneer Jay Carter<br />

that has a gyrocopter concept, which starts and lands by<br />

means of the electric drive of the main rotor and the thrust propeller.<br />

Uber’s third partner is AURORA, an American technology<br />

developer and defense contractor who has recently been<br />

developing a huge unmanned electrically driven transporter.<br />

The concept, which AURORA presented at the UBER conference<br />

in Dallas, is a multicopter with eight rotors and<br />

wings. “The wings are necessary, because they consume<br />

much less energy than the multicopter to generate<br />

the boost during the cruise <strong>flight</strong> or helicopter.”<br />

The fourth manufacturer at the presentation was the<br />

Brazilian airline and military aircraft manufacturer Embraer.<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

18


UBER Elevate<br />

After the<br />

successful<br />

first <strong>flight</strong>,<br />

Daniel<br />

Wiegand<br />

from Lilium<br />

explaines the<br />

concept of<br />

the Lilium<br />

Jet, which is<br />

a VTOL with<br />

300 km/h<br />

top speed.<br />

Greg Bowls from GAMA explains how the manufacturers<br />

association is already working with the FAA and others on<br />

certification guidelines.<br />

Pipistrel is on board<br />

The actual surprise for most of those present was the fifth<br />

of Uber’s chosen partners. It is the company Pipistrel from<br />

Slovenia! They are mostly previously known for ultra-light<br />

aircraft with high performance and good processing, as<br />

for the electrification. Pipistrel chief engineer Tine Tomaciz<br />

gave the technical presentation of the company. He was,<br />

as usual brilliant, but in the end he gave no answer to the<br />

question as to what Pipistrel’s VTOL project would look<br />

like.<br />

Jay Carter of Carter Copter works - together with Mooney -<br />

on a electrical operated gyro with vertical takeoff capabilities<br />

and fixedwings.<br />

From VTOL to WTOL<br />

On the other hand, Ivo Boscaroll, who also gave a presentation<br />

on the best plan of a transport system with taxis. One<br />

more thing: At the end of his presentation, he said: “We do<br />

not need VTOL but WTOL.” The “W” stands for Windows<br />

and means that the <strong>flight</strong> taxis will in the future pick up<br />

their passengers directly at the window of their apartment<br />

on the floor of a high-rise building and then fly directly to<br />

the window of their office. He ended his entertaining PPT<br />

by saying that although a large investment from China had<br />

been received last year, it was certainly necessary for the<br />

The AirspaceX MOBi from Airspace Experience Technologies<br />

in Birmingham, Michigan, USA.<br />

Olaf Otto<br />

from<br />

Siemens<br />

explains in a<br />

discussion,<br />

how e-<strong>flight</strong><br />

will be able<br />

to reduce<br />

noise in<br />

flying.<br />

Pipistrels Ivo Boscarol together with Yuneec boss Tian Yu<br />

(right), who also presented VTOL concepts in Dallas which<br />

he is evaluating for manned and unmanned purpose.<br />

19 e Flight Journal


UBER Elevate<br />

development of WTOL and that this was a good investment.<br />

Investors, this was an interesting point at the Dallas conference!<br />

On the evening of the first day, there was a panel<br />

discussion of five bosses from major investment firms<br />

who expressed their willingness to provide good technical<br />

developments in this area with capital, and one investment<br />

project was also immediately announced: an e-<strong>flight</strong><br />

VTOL-UBER-fund.<br />

From Siemens to Yuneec<br />

It was also interesting to see who else was among the<br />

speakers. Siemens, for example, showed the latest development<br />

of the Extra 300 LE. Though the electric version<br />

might look otherwise identical to the combustion version,<br />

the electrical variant is not only significantly quieter, but also<br />

even the noise also felt more pleasant.<br />

Conclusion<br />

The development at UBER is certainly to be observed closely<br />

for various reasons. Due to the fact that many top companies<br />

from different areas with money and developments,<br />

UBER Elevate will in any case promote the development<br />

of e-mobility and assist the autonomous flying. One aspect<br />

that needs to be considered is that it has a potentially<br />

negative note alongside all the positive ones in the context<br />

of environmental protection. If, indeed, some taxis and delivery<br />

trucks are going to fly through the cities and cities,<br />

will there still be room for human pilots who simply want to<br />

fly? Probably not possible, because human-controlled airplanes<br />

are just as disruptive as pedestrians and cyclists to<br />

a self-driving car on the open road. For the complete presentation<br />

and panel discussion, you can watch the videos<br />

of the UBER event at www.e-<strong>flight</strong>-expo.com.<br />

Aurora - a<br />

UBER partner<br />

- has<br />

experience<br />

in VTOL<br />

design and<br />

is working<br />

on its eVTOL<br />

(left photo).<br />

Investor<br />

panel: five<br />

venture<br />

capital investors<br />

showed<br />

that they<br />

are willing<br />

to invest in<br />

a “Demand<br />

Air Vehicle”<br />

(right<br />

photo).<br />

Large presence<br />

from<br />

the media:<br />

Mark Moore<br />

from UBER<br />

explains to a<br />

TV journalist<br />

the UBER<br />

approach.<br />

German Arne Stoschek from Silicon Valley Airbus subsidiary<br />

A³, explains how Vahana will revolutionize passenger<br />

transportation.<br />

The first test<br />

scenarios<br />

are already<br />

planned<br />

for 2020 in<br />

Dallas and<br />

Dubai.<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

20


e Training<br />

Fight Training<br />

in Whisper Mode<br />

Around the World<br />

The training of pilots and the resulting high number of takeoff’s and<br />

landings are increasingly perceived as very disturbing by the neighbors<br />

of the airport. Several initiatives around the world try to solve<br />

the issue by using electric airplanes.<br />

AlpinAirPlanes GmbH in Switzerland:<br />

Jean-Luc Charron<br />

(middle),<br />

Christian Stuck<br />

(right) and<br />

Ivo Boscarol<br />

(left) at Paris<br />

Airshow <strong>2017</strong>.<br />

A new approach from Switzerland now wants to take the<br />

wind out of the sails. The company AlpinAirPlanes GmbH is<br />

based on the fully electric Alpha Electro airplane of Pipistrel,<br />

an advancement of the Pipistrel Alpha trainer. With a secured<br />

<strong>flight</strong> time of 45 minutes Alpha Electro is very suitable<br />

for the training <strong>flight</strong>. Now the photovoltaic specialist<br />

SolSystems GmbH became the focus of AlpinAirPlanes<br />

and the project. The idea of a whole network of e-airfields in<br />

Switzerland was born.<br />

21 e Flight Journal


e Training<br />

SOLAR EQUIPMENT FOR E-Airfields<br />

Specifically, this project will look like this: First of all, a fleet<br />

of Alpha Electro airplanes will be distributed across this alpine<br />

republic among 10 flying schools under the leadership<br />

of «Eco<strong>flight</strong>» in Mollis. In addition, each of these e-<strong>flight</strong> bases<br />

will receive a charging station with a solar system for the<br />

ecological generation of electricity. This would allow the stations<br />

to recharge the e-airplanes at the airfields.<br />

All FOCO-registered <strong>flight</strong> schools in Switzerland are invited<br />

to participate in this project. The corresponding applications<br />

have to be submitted by the end of April. The cost for the aircraft,<br />

charging stations and solar power add up to around<br />

200,000 Swiss francs, but a leasing model is also possible<br />

on a per hour basis, in particular for the solar system. In principle,<br />

<strong>flight</strong> school partners should operate their e-airplane<br />

for at least 300 hours per year. The corresponding monthly<br />

reports will be collected and evaluated by the project initiator<br />

AlpinAirPlanes GmbH, since the project also aims to improve<br />

and further develop the technology.<br />

Beginning in Summer <strong>2017</strong><br />

The project will start in summer <strong>2017</strong> and will run until<br />

September 30, 2018. The delivery of the e-aircraft will be with<br />

a frequency of one airplane per month. Therefore, the last<br />

<strong>flight</strong> school partner will not receive their aircraft until spring<br />

2018. They are, of course, not obligated until September<br />

2018 to reach the planned 300 hours of use. Rather, the project<br />

tends to bring all ten aircraft together to 2500 <strong>flight</strong> hours.<br />

The maintenance and upgrades of the fleet are organized<br />

and implemented by AlpinAirPlanes in collaboration with<br />

local certified CAMOs. In this first phase, AlpinAirPlanes will<br />

incur the maintenance costs. A replacement aircraft, which<br />

is based at the base of AlpinAirPlanes, will ensure the permanent<br />

availability of ten aircraft from spring 2018 onwards.<br />

The AlpinAirPlanes will also draw up a curriculum for the<br />

<strong>flight</strong> schools. The necessary permits in Switzerland have<br />

already been obtained.<br />

Fresno, California<br />

Subsidized by local funds from Fresno County, a fleet of four<br />

Pipistrel Alpha Electro trainers will be made available for primary<br />

training in California’s Central Valley late this year, program<br />

organizers hope. Fresno County will be installing chargers<br />

for the aircraft at four local airports: Mendota, Reedley,<br />

Fresno Chandler and a fourth airport is to be determined.<br />

The Alpha Electro has an 85-knot cruising speed making<br />

round-trip, cross-country <strong>flight</strong>s a stretch. Joseph Oldham,<br />

Sustainability Manager for the City of Fresno, said that the<br />

fourth airport will ideally be just over 50 NM, permitting the<br />

Alphas to make one-way <strong>flight</strong>s meeting private pilot crosscountry<br />

training requirements, recharge in about 45 minutes<br />

and return home. The fallback plan is for students to<br />

do cross-country training in the piston-powered version of<br />

the Alpha.<br />

Fresno county hopes to have the new aircraft on hand and<br />

high-voltage chargers installed at the four chosen airports<br />

by the fall of this year. The FAA has not yet released a paradigm<br />

for approving electric propulsion airplanes, either in<br />

certified aircraft or in light sports, as Pipistrel plans for the<br />

Alpha Electro. Oldham is working with the FAA about approval<br />

of electric LSAs, the last major hurdle in Fresno’s<br />

Pipistrel Alpha‘s<br />

electric<br />

identity is<br />

distinctive,<br />

indicating the<br />

company‘s<br />

faith in the<br />

technology.<br />

All four of the<br />

current training<br />

programs<br />

chose Alpha<br />

as the trainer.<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

22


e Training<br />

race to get the Alpha Electros into service. The aircraft will<br />

likely be available for rent by area pilots, but the priority users<br />

of the aircraft will be veterans and low-income youth<br />

seeking primary <strong>flight</strong> training.<br />

SpaceX’s electric <strong>flight</strong> training program<br />

SpaceX, the private space company founded by Elon Musk,<br />

is seeking to provide <strong>flight</strong> training for its space tourism clients<br />

with Pipiestral’s Electro Alpha. Due to an existing requirement<br />

by NASA, all space travelers launched in the US<br />

must be licensed pilot in the first place. Obviously NASA did<br />

not envision the advent of private space tourism open to<br />

general public back then when the requirement policy was<br />

drafted. No less a disruptive technology innovator than its<br />

peer companies Tesla and SolarCity, which are also founded<br />

by Elon Musk, it is only natural for SpaceX to want its<br />

<strong>flight</strong> training to be as innovative and environmentally friendly<br />

as Tesla’s electric cars. It is reported that Pipietral is going<br />

to delivery two Electro Alpha trainers to SpaceX’s designated<br />

<strong>flight</strong> training partners at Oshkosh Airventure in July<br />

<strong>2017</strong>. It remains to be quite interesting to be seen what the<br />

participation of SpaceX in electric <strong>flight</strong> will do to the industry.<br />

Do not forget that Elon Musk has explicitly mentioned in<br />

at least a dozen occasions that he might want to design an<br />

electric VTOL supersonic jet if no one else comes up with<br />

such an airplane. Now that’s exciting!<br />

Alpha Electro‘s specially designed propeller can recharge the battery<br />

to extend the <strong>flight</strong> time. A very useful feature in <strong>flight</strong> training<br />

when most <strong>flight</strong>s are in takeoff and landing pattern.<br />

France<br />

During the Paris Air Show, a letter of intent was signed between<br />

Mr. Jean-Luc Charron, representing the French<br />

Federation of Aeronautics (FFA), Finesse Max S.a.r.l, represented<br />

by Mr. Christian Stuck, and Ivo Boscarol, the General<br />

Manager of Pipistrel, regarding great future of electric aircraft<br />

in France: for the first time in European history it will<br />

be possible to do the legal training for a private pilot license<br />

– on an electric aircraft. More details about this project is in<br />

the Paris Air Show article of this issue.<br />

Pipistrel Alpha Electro is the first electric airplane in the world<br />

whose <strong>flight</strong> time is longer than the battery charging time. The battery<br />

compartment is easily accessible for quick change if needed.<br />

23 e Flight Journal


e Personality<br />

Ivo Boscarol – Mr. Electric<br />

No company has had more innovative projects<br />

in the past 10 years than the Slovenian<br />

ultralight and LSA manufacturer Pipistrel.<br />

Starting with the first serial 2 seater Motorglider<br />

Taurus-e, then winning the Nasa Green<br />

Flight Challenge with the Pipistrel G4, the four<br />

Seater Panthera which is planned to have a<br />

hybrid powertrain which Pipistrel is developing<br />

with partners like Siemens, the Alpha<br />

Elektro a 2 Seat electric trainer, up to the participation<br />

in the Hy4 Program of the German<br />

DLR and a firewall forward kit for electrification<br />

of existing Light Sport and ultralight Aircraft.<br />

The Mastermind behind all this is Ivo<br />

Boscarol.<br />

WWhen the now 62-year-old started his aviation business UL<br />

flying was forbidden in Yugoslavia so he tested his flying<br />

machines at dawn when it was nearly dark, that’s why the<br />

neighbors called them Pipistrelle (meaning bat). The company<br />

kept this name and is now one of the leading Ultralight<br />

and LSA manufacturers of the world.<br />

The Taurus G4 won the Nasa Green<br />

Flight Challenge<br />

In the end of the 2000’s Ivo started to take interest in electric<br />

alternatives. First came the electrification of his two seater<br />

Motorglider Taurus, which soon after was certified not<br />

only in Slovenia but also in other countries like France as<br />

an Ultralight.<br />

Ivo Poscarol pulls the political strings - here with EU commissioner<br />

Violetta Bulc from Slovenia and BW-Minister from<br />

Germany Winfried Hermann at the AERO.<br />

Ivo receives the first Chinese validated for the certification<br />

of his Viruy directly from the Chinese Vice-transport<br />

Minister Feng Zhenglin.<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

24


e Personality<br />

Pipistrel also offers a firewall forward modification kit for existing<br />

aircraft which has been sold to several manufacturers.<br />

The Emrax motor in this kit comes from the Slovenian<br />

company ENSTROJ d.o.o and has 40 or 60 kW. Pipistrel<br />

produces the engine and battery controller as well as the<br />

battery pack which are produced from cells which are combined<br />

and controlled in the Pipistrel factory.<br />

One of the secrets to so much innovation and many new<br />

products is Ivo’s team of engineers like his Chief Developer<br />

Tine Tomacic and the Hybrid Program Leader Igor Perkon<br />

which are not only brilliant but also know how to sell their<br />

ideas to others.<br />

Fuel Cell - The Alternative<br />

Fast and elegant: the Panthera is Pipistrels first 4-seat aircraft which will<br />

be offered with combustion engine and as a Hybrid.<br />

The ranking of the challenge was dependent on the fuel per<br />

passenger, so he combined 2 Taurus fuselages with an electric<br />

motor on a middle piece between the fuselages therefore<br />

beating all other competitors which only carried 2 persons.<br />

Also, the second placed E-Genius was based on<br />

the Taurus Motorglider. In 2014 Ivo surprised the aviation<br />

world again at the French Ultralight Tradeshow in Blois in<br />

September when he released the Watts-Up (later called the<br />

Alpha Electro.<br />

Although the energy density has grown a lot over the last<br />

decade the batteries are still the biggest problem in realizing<br />

electric <strong>flight</strong> for everybody. Hybrid with a combustion<br />

engine as a powersource is an option but the aircraft loses<br />

its green footprint because fuel is burned.<br />

Also, here Ivo Boscarol is active with the German National<br />

Aromautic Research Institute when it started the Hy4<br />

Project in October 2015. Partnered with the other companies<br />

is again Pipistrel.<br />

The DLR Aircraft is based on the NASA Green Flight<br />

Challenge winner G4 which is basically two fuselages of<br />

the Taurus Motorglider combined with 2 reinforced Taurus<br />

wings with extended wingspan and a middle part which<br />

Two fathers and a baby: Ivo Boscarol (right) and his<br />

Chief developer Tine Tomazic with the Alpha Electro<br />

When German president Joachim Gauk (left) visited, the Slovenian counterpart<br />

Borut Pahor (right) brought him to Pipistrel.<br />

25 e Flight Journal


e Personality<br />

carries the HY4’s electric motor and has an output of 80 kW<br />

and allows for a maximum speed of approximately 200 kilometers<br />

per hour and a cruising speed of 145 kilometers<br />

per hour. Depending on velocity, altitude and load, a range<br />

of between 750 and 1500 kilometers is possible. The most<br />

striking feature of the HY4 is the two fuselages, which are<br />

firmly connected to each other by the wing. This twin fuselage<br />

design allows an optimal distribution of the drive components<br />

and a higher total loading capacity. Each one can<br />

seat two occupants. The maximum weight of the HY4 is<br />

1500 kilograms. Maiden Flight took place in Autumn 2016,<br />

in Stuttgart. Pipistrel is planning further so the next step after<br />

the Panthera Hybrid is a planned version where a combustion<br />

engine isn’t but rather a fuel cell is delivering the<br />

energy. In the future, there is also a project for a 19-seater<br />

electric Commuter aircraft where one version will have a fuel<br />

cell that will deliver the energy.<br />

Certifications and Political Connections.<br />

As Pipistrel comes from the <strong>small</strong> Slovenia, with all its technology,<br />

it is now a flagship company of the country. So, for<br />

example when the German President Joachim Gauk visited<br />

his Slovenian counterpart Borut Pahor he was taken to visit<br />

Ivo’s factory in Ajdovscina not far from the Italian Border.<br />

This factory is worth a visit itself. The high-tech bulking<br />

with solar cells produces so much energy that it is not only<br />

enough for the production buts also pays all the building<br />

maintenance costs.<br />

In the last year, they now opened a new RND center in<br />

Slovenia and as Ivo is a true European a production plant<br />

for the Panthera in Italy is under construction.<br />

The EU Commissioner Viloetta Bulc, also from Slovenia,<br />

has been at Pipistrel several times. Ivo also managed that<br />

the Chinese Vice Transport Minister Feng Zhenglin, was<br />

hosted by the Slovenian government and in the end visited<br />

Pipistrel and signed a bilateral agreement for validation<br />

of Ultralight type certifications between Slovenia and<br />

China (in Europe only the Czech Republic has a similar<br />

agreement).<br />

Now who would wonder why the first aircraft validated were<br />

three planes from Pipistrel, which surely will also help with<br />

the certification of Pipistrel’s electro planes in China.<br />

China Connection and UBER Partner<br />

With all these innovations, it is not surprising that Chinese<br />

investors partnered with Pipistrel. There was a deal made<br />

for more than $350 Million Euros announced in which the<br />

Sino GA Company around Danny Wu signed a contract<br />

for a license production and partnership with Pipistrel. The<br />

interesting point: the first aircraft that will be produced in<br />

China will be the Alpha Electro followed by the Panthera<br />

Hybrid Two electric aircraft and when UBER was looking<br />

for partners for its Elevate Program there was not only giants<br />

like Bell Helicopters and Embrair but as well as the little<br />

Pipistrel from Slovenia was chosen. So overall in the future<br />

we can expect many coups from Mr. Electric.<br />

Chief developer Tine Tomazic explains the Panthera Hybrid<br />

to Vice-Minister and the Chinese Pipistrel partner Danny Wu.<br />

Taja Boscarol, Ivos daughter, is giving an overview<br />

on Pipistrels Green Factory.<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

26


e-personality<br />

e Airshow<br />

Le Bourget Airshow <strong>2017</strong><br />

Paris in the Sign of Big<br />

e<br />

Ultralight aircraft made big news for<br />

electric <strong>flight</strong> during this year’s Paris<br />

Airshow and it was not the Ultralight<br />

Association that made the announcement,<br />

it was the French Aeroclub!<br />

The Alpha Electro in front of the Ariane rocket in Paris.<br />

27 e Flight Journal


e Airshow<br />

FFA President Jean Luc Charron signed a “Letter of Intent”<br />

together with the Pipistrel Importer Christian Stuck and<br />

Ivo Boscarol CEO of Pipistrel that FFA will purchase three<br />

Pipistrel Alpha Electro aircraft to use for <strong>flight</strong> training in the<br />

French Federation. The interesting thing is that the aircraft,<br />

which the Aeroclub has chosen, is designed as an ultralight<br />

but will now fly with “Permit to fly” and later as a LSA. Two<br />

years ago the e-Fan was the big hype at the Le Bourget show.<br />

Dr Mueller-Wiesner, Project Manager of the e-Fan Program,<br />

stated in Le Bourget: “We already talked with DGAC and the<br />

French Aeroclubs and we want to establish private pilot <strong>flight</strong><br />

training on an electric aircraft as soon as possible,” but then<br />

the Airbus program stopped so the Aeroclub was left on its<br />

e-plans without a plane.<br />

Profit from Airbus work<br />

The French Pipistrel importer Christian Stuck explains the electric<br />

Flight Trainer to the pilots from tomorrow.<br />

On the other hand is Pipistrel: they developed the Alpha<br />

Electro and presented it as an e-Flight-trainer 2014 in Blois.<br />

However, Pipistrel´s Alpha is an ultralight, although it is flying<br />

in the US with 600 Kg as an LSA, in Europe it’s limited<br />

to the 475.5 Kg MTOW as all ultralights are. Ivo Boscarol<br />

and several other manufacturers tried to get the EU institutions<br />

to raise the weight limit to 600 Kg but the rule change<br />

is still pending. The European Council, European Parliament<br />

and European Commission have differing opinions on this<br />

so they are still negotiating. So for Pipistrel, which has the<br />

Alpha Electro ready for production and even sold a production<br />

license to China, the aircraft could not be sold in Europe.<br />

Airbus announced that - after the end of the EFAB 1 and 2 - they are working<br />

on the e-Fanx (passenger plan) and showed the city airbus as model.<br />

eViation showed a scaled model of its all-electric airplane.<br />

It’s designed to fly 600 nautical miles at a price similar to<br />

travel by airliner over the same distance.<br />

Next year the Israeli startup plans to build a prototype of<br />

the three-engine distributed-propulsion aircraft that would<br />

feature one electric motor at the tail and one on each<br />

wingtip for more aerodynamic efficiency. The motors on the<br />

wingtips are designed to enable significant drag reduction<br />

and the motors can also be used for controlling the aircraft<br />

(this engine control will be managed by a computer).<br />

The company wants to show the first full size prototype<br />

at AERO next year and the production model is planned to<br />

arrive in 2020.<br />

The goal is six to nine passengers maximum. The engines<br />

will mostly likely come from the German Siemens e-aircraft.<br />

The aircraft shall fly fully electric and shall carry 6,000<br />

pounds of batteries. The planned MTOW is about 12,000<br />

pounds, (cruise speed 240 ktas).<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

28


e-Airshow<br />

Franchois Chopard was with his investment company<br />

Starbust Accelerator, which was one of the organizers of<br />

the Paris Airlab; several innovative companies like XTI from<br />

USA presented their projects under the wing of an old<br />

Concord.<br />

The initiative of Pipistrel’s Importer for France Christian<br />

Stuck was in the interest of several players so they all<br />

agreed to work out a test program.<br />

Pipistrel will deliver three aircraft: the first will start to fly under<br />

an LSA “Permit to Fly” from EASA. Meantime Pipistrel<br />

starts the EASA CSA certification with the Alpha the next aircraft<br />

can fly under CS-LSA later. That means, at the same<br />

time the DGAC will coordinate the operations of the aircraft,<br />

EASA will do the certification and the French Aeroclub will<br />

operate the aircraft in several different clubs so that several<br />

<strong>flight</strong> instructors can gather experience.<br />

Like in other e-Programs, for example in Switzerland, there<br />

will also be Alpha’s with conventional Rotax motors available<br />

so that the students in the end will receive a fully compatible<br />

private pilots license.<br />

Siemens demonstrated<br />

the Extra in glider<br />

towing action in Paris<br />

in public for the first<br />

time. The 260 kW<br />

strong motor did pull<br />

the French aerobatics<br />

champion up to<br />

1000 meters and then<br />

both aircraft performed one after the other an aerobatics<br />

show.<br />

Comment<br />

The Alpha Electro is an ultralight but because several associations<br />

(for example the French UL Association FFPLUM)<br />

are fighting against a weight increase for ultralights in<br />

Europe, due to the higher weight electric aircraft cannot be<br />

operated in the UL-class and the technology and development<br />

will move to GA and LSA.<br />

With all its advantages like low noise, general public and<br />

politicians acceptance the French UL Association hinders<br />

electric ultralights coming to use in all Europe by blocking<br />

the weight increase.<br />

The UK drone company presented next to new<br />

drone technology their ideas for a manned<br />

“Motorbike-drone” the Airquadone.<br />

The Slovakian Flying Car AEROmobil is on the ground<br />

driven by electric motors in the wheels; a later model could<br />

be hybrid electric.<br />

29 e Flight Journal


e-personality<br />

Seen . in public for the first time was the Surefly Workhorse<br />

in Le Bourget. The manufacturer of electric vehicles for delivery<br />

services from the US has developed a delivery drone<br />

for Amazon. On this basis they presented the prototype of<br />

this double-seat multicopter, which has been publicly presented.<br />

The two-seater is powered by eight Emrax e-motors<br />

from Slovenia. In their workhorse the Americans aren’t<br />

fully set on a hybrid as there are some lithium ion batteries<br />

in the four foldable rotor arms, but these are only for<br />

short <strong>flight</strong>s. The main energy source is a two-cylinder fourstroke<br />

engine in the back of the machine and with almost<br />

200 hp it powers a generator. The first <strong>flight</strong> is planned for<br />

the end of <strong>2017</strong>.<br />

The Event to bring your products and ideas to China<br />

&<br />

Electrify China’s sky and your business<br />

The first forum on<br />

electric aviation<br />

in China:<br />

VTOL-, LSA-, Hybrid,<br />

Engine-,<br />

Battery-<br />

Manufacturers,<br />

Regulators,<br />

Investors<br />

from<br />

around the World<br />

Where: Beijing downtown<br />

When:Early November <strong>2017</strong><br />

Who: The who is who<br />

in electric <strong>flight</strong><br />

www.e-ight-forum.com<br />

America & Europe: Willi@e-<strong>flight</strong>-forum.com<br />

China & Asia: Xin@e-<strong>flight</strong>-forum.com<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

30


e Organizations<br />

The Early Days of a Revolution:<br />

Increased Electrification & Automation<br />

tTraditionally, technology flows into aviation once it has matured<br />

in other sectors because the level of safety we all expect<br />

and the time and resource investments to bring aviation<br />

innovation has required a methodical approach to development.<br />

Over the last decade, developments in micro-electronics,<br />

software and battery capacities have resulted in significant<br />

societal changes which are beginning to take shape<br />

within the aviation domain. Two general technology vectors<br />

seem to be oriented in a manner that will have a profound<br />

impact on aviation as we know it: increased automation & increased<br />

electrification. These technological advancements<br />

along with new efficiencies gained as EASA implements<br />

the new CS-23 are resulting in beneficial alignment like we<br />

haven’t seen since the early days of aviation.<br />

Increased Automation<br />

Increased levels of automation which are becoming common<br />

in everyday life (smart home technology, simplified<br />

weather information, navigation with traffic information,<br />

smart cruise control, drone stability control, etc.) are beginning<br />

to find their way into integrated aviation applications. A<br />

major shift in society is expected as all the major car manufacturers<br />

have indicated plans to include significant levels of<br />

automation in the next 2-3 years.<br />

As any certified <strong>flight</strong> engineer could tell you, aviation has pioneered<br />

automation since the early days. The levels of information<br />

and technology in light general aviation and business<br />

jets has grown tremendously in the last several decades but<br />

for the most part, these systems are always supplementary<br />

and backed up by the pilot or <strong>flight</strong> crew. In most of<br />

these modern aircraft, the takeoff and landing are nearly always<br />

flown manually while the climb, cruise and approach<br />

are typically flown by automation based on pilot or crew<br />

Pete Bunce, President and CEO<br />

of GAMA, with a business delegation<br />

from Shenyang / China.<br />

31 e Flight Journal


e Organizations<br />

management. Current automation relies on cross checking<br />

and validation which defaults to a manual mode in the event<br />

of anything out of the ordinary.<br />

There is growing interest in more robust levels of automation<br />

which continue to operate across more portions of the<br />

<strong>flight</strong> envelope (including takeoff and landing) and automation<br />

systems that will continue to operate even during certain<br />

failure or out of the ordinary conditions. At the farther end of<br />

increased automation, there is a significant level of interest<br />

among a number of manufacturers in the “on-demand mobility”<br />

space. Conceptually, aircraft (both conventional takeoff<br />

and landing and vertical takeoff and landing) can become<br />

more integrated into day to day life as the reliability and simplified<br />

operation of increased automation takes hold. While<br />

technologically, these are steps forward, beginning to take<br />

operational credit for these technologies (less training burden<br />

on pilots and <strong>flight</strong> crews, simplified ratings and licensing,<br />

etc.) will require a bit of a leap.<br />

In the coming year, the GAMA Electric Propulsion Innovation<br />

Committee (EPIC) will take on the task of identifying and addressing<br />

areas where increased automation will likely contribute<br />

to the safety and utility of aviation to assure pilots and<br />

<strong>flight</strong> crew training and licensing can be appropriately adjusted<br />

and simplified.<br />

Increased Electrification<br />

In the larger segments of aviation (commercial airlines and<br />

business jets) the strong desire for longer distances and<br />

more efficient operations has pushed many of the traditionally<br />

mechanical or pneumatic systems to become electrified<br />

(electric environmental systems, electric anti-ice, electric actuation,<br />

etc.). As experience is gained with these systems<br />

and as battery energy densities continue to grow, this trend<br />

for increased electrification is speeding up. In most aviation<br />

design circles, concepts for hybrid and electric propulsion<br />

are the next obvious step forward and there is much activity<br />

in this space. In the lighter segments of general aviation,<br />

there are already all electric aircraft flying with second generation<br />

designs following immediately after.<br />

The pressures moving the industry towards increased electrification<br />

(range, efficiency, reliability, etc.) are certain to increase<br />

and the benefits of this direction will continue to grow.<br />

Reliable data indicates that Lithium Ion battery energy density<br />

has increased by 3% for each of the last 10-years and<br />

this trend is expected to accelerate or continue into the foreseeable<br />

future. While approaching the energy density of liquid<br />

fuel is still many decades out, the efficiencies and design<br />

characteristics of electric propulsion already make sense for<br />

lighter aircraft today.<br />

These are truly the exciting early days of hybrid and electric<br />

propulsion and increased automation in aviation. The new<br />

degrees of freedom enabled by these technologies and the<br />

more nimble and responsive design certification environment<br />

have invigorated what was once a sleepy aviation community<br />

into an exciting incubator for growing the not too distant<br />

future of aviation.<br />

Greg Bowles<br />

GAMA’s Vice President for Global Innovation & Policy,<br />

Manager of GAMA Electric Propulsion and Innovation<br />

Committee (EPIC)<br />

For more information on<br />

GAMA and EPIC, contact<br />

Greg Bowles at gbowles@gama.aero<br />

or +32 (2)0 550 39 00<br />

Greg Bowles, Vice President GAMA and<br />

Manager of EPIC presenting at the Dallas<br />

UBER Elevate conference in April <strong>2017</strong>.<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

32


e Visions<br />

Zunum Aero - Think BIG<br />

Siemens and Airbus are convinced that the next generation of mid<br />

range passenger airliners will be hybrid electric. They announced<br />

their partnership with UBER so everybody was asking where is Boeing<br />

in this technology field …the answer is Zunum. The company announced<br />

in early April <strong>2017</strong> that with funding from Boeing HorizonX<br />

and JetBlue Technology Ventures they would develop a regional hybrid<br />

electric airliner, which will fly in early 2020.<br />

ZZunum Aero was founded in 2013 by Ashish Kumar (former<br />

Microsoft and Google manager). Their dream is to create a<br />

“regional electric air network,” offering travellers other options<br />

besides highways and high-speed rails. So it’s not only<br />

making <strong>small</strong> airliners electric but as well revitalizing aviation<br />

for short and middle transport distances.<br />

The electric planes would fly up to 700 miles when it launches<br />

and could go more than 1,000 miles by 2030. The aircraft<br />

would have 10 to 50 seats and will make electric air travel<br />

“fast and affordable,” Zunum Aero said.<br />

The company, which is based in Kirkland, Washington, plans<br />

to utilize more than 5,000 underused U.S. airports.<br />

“The shift in the industry to large aircraft and long ranges<br />

driven by gas turbines has concentrated almost all air traffic<br />

to just two percent of our airports, creating a massive transport<br />

gap over regional distances where there is no highspeed<br />

alternative,” says CEO of Zunum Aero Ashish Kumar,<br />

“As a result, door-to-door times for most journeys are no better<br />

than they were 50 years ago. Hybrid propulsion is an industry-changing<br />

solution, enabling mid-sized aircraft on regional<br />

routes to have better cost efficiencies than airliners.”<br />

He gives the example that travellers would be able to fly from<br />

regional airports in Boston to Washington D.C. for half the<br />

fare and in half the time it currently takes door-to-door by using<br />

closer by regional airports.<br />

The hybrid electric aircraft would lower emissions by 80<br />

33 e Flight Journal


e Visions<br />

percent and could drop to zero when battery densities improve<br />

and renewable energy is used. Short distance <strong>flight</strong>s<br />

could be done fully electric sooner and reducing the noise<br />

and emissions in metropolitan areas dramatically.<br />

Technically the aircraft would be driven by two ducted fans,<br />

which will be driven by electric motors. As an energy source<br />

there will be batteries (mainly for takeoff) and a gas turbine<br />

that sits in the middle of the V-tail.<br />

For the question of why they use ducted fans, as there is<br />

no successful aircraft in history with this concept and Airbus<br />

just stopped it’s e-Fan project, Mike Friend a retired former<br />

Technical Director of Boeing and now Zunum consultant explains<br />

the reason, “ Zunum believes that ducted fans are the<br />

right answer for several reasons. The first is noise, as use<br />

of <strong>small</strong> airports close in to cities will require an airplane quiet<br />

enough not to raise objections from those living close to<br />

those airports. The second is the robust low speed static<br />

thrust generated by a ducted fan that will help the Zunum airplanes<br />

use short runways of 2,500 to 3,500 ft. Several years<br />

ago, a study was made with potential passengers with images<br />

of the same aircraft one time with ducted fans one time<br />

with open propellers and asked the question, which aircraft<br />

you find more safe and in which aircraft you would like<br />

to board.? The answer was very clear the large majority preferred<br />

the Fan Type.”<br />

Attractive Operating Costs<br />

The operating costs with Zunum Aero would be at 40 percent<br />

to 80 percent lower than current airplanes operated by<br />

<strong>small</strong> regional airlines, the company says.<br />

Together with other electric Aviation companies Zunum has<br />

worked with the US Federal Aviation Administration (FAA)<br />

since 2014 to create the certification standards for electric<br />

aircraft (now based in the ASTM). The company said it expects<br />

a complete set of standards for electric aircraft by next<br />

year, with the first electrics likely to be certified in 2020 when<br />

Zunum planes go on the market.<br />

Ambitious Plans<br />

Zunum plans to start that process with <strong>small</strong>er, 10-passenger<br />

aircraft and then scale up the airframes as technology<br />

improves.<br />

It’ll still be a while until consumers can buy those $100 fares<br />

though. As a venture-backed startup, Zunum undoubtedly<br />

has years of prototyping and developing to endure as well as<br />

lengthy inspection and oversight by the FAA.<br />

There is a good chance that Zunum become Boeing’s horse<br />

in the international race with Airbus Embraer and Co in the<br />

for the world first electric airliner<br />

The time schedule of Zunum is ambitious “The first <strong>flight</strong> of<br />

the proof of concept for a 10 passenger e-Jet should be done<br />

in only 2 years” says Mike Friend a retired former Director of<br />

new Technologies at Boeing and now Zunum consultant.<br />

Despite the challenges that lie ahead, Zunum seems to have<br />

attracted a solid series of investors and is entering the market<br />

at a point when electric vehicles are really gaining traction<br />

and electric aviation gets more new players every day.<br />

One day Zunum may become “The Tesla of Aircraft” like<br />

Forbes magazine said and like Tesla’s stock exchange value<br />

in <strong>2017</strong> exceeded Ford’s; Zunum may some day overtake<br />

Boeing.<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

34


e Visions<br />

eVTOL to be in trial use in Dubai<br />

Volocopter and Dubai’s Road and Transport Authority (RTA) announced<br />

that they signed a deal to begin testing Volocopter’s 18-rotor VC200<br />

multicopters as a flying taxi service later this year. The news cements<br />

the city’s reputation as a testing ground for some of the transportation<br />

world’s more futuristic and outlandish ideas.<br />

AAccording to the plan, Volocopter’s Dubai experiment will<br />

start in the fourth quarter of <strong>2017</strong>, and is scheduled to last<br />

five years under the agreement with the RTA, said Alexander<br />

Zosel, co-founder of Volocopter, in a statement. “We are very<br />

grateful and proud that the RTA has selected us as their partner<br />

after rigorous testing,” he added, citing his company’s<br />

“stringent safety standards” as among the reasons his company<br />

was selected.<br />

RTA expects the trial run to continue and follow up the issuance<br />

of the legislation required for operating such kind<br />

of vehicles for about five years during which all operational<br />

aspects would be assessed and security & safety issues<br />

verified. The official operation hinges on the readiness of<br />

companies and the availability of legislation governing this<br />

type of autonomous aerial vehicles. As air traffic control of<br />

autonomous aircraft either manned or unmanned and the<br />

certification of eVTOL aircraft are new and are imminent issues<br />

for regulators around the world. Dubai’s trial program<br />

may well pave the ground for eVTOL’s certification framework<br />

in the world.<br />

Volocopter’s prototype VC200 took its first crewed <strong>flight</strong> last<br />

year and at the AERO trade show in April, the company revealed<br />

its first production model, the 2X. It has a maximum<br />

range of 17 miles when flying at a speed of 43 mph. Its maximum<br />

<strong>flight</strong> time is 27 minutes at an optimal cruise speed of<br />

31 mph. The maximum speed is 62 mph.<br />

35 e Flight Journal


e Visions<br />

1<br />

2<br />

In May 2016 Volocopter VC200 two-seat multicopter made the successful<br />

maiden manned <strong>flight</strong> in Germany (top and bottom photo)<br />

3<br />

1. Volocopter uses 18 motors to provide redundant lifting power.<br />

2. The propeller of Volocopter’s each motor is fixed pitch for simplicity.<br />

3. Soon this scene may become a normal reality in Dubai, an eVTOL ondemand<br />

aerial mobility vehicle.<br />

Actually Volocopter VC200 is not the first eVTOL signing a<br />

deal with Dubai RTA. The Chinese consumer drone company<br />

Ehang signed a deal with RTA last year to test its singleperson<br />

Ehang 184 in Dubai. However, Ehang 184 has not<br />

yet demonstrated a practical <strong>flight</strong> performance. In addition,<br />

the Chinese media reported that Ehang has been in financial<br />

trouble so it is hard to tell how far Ehang 184 or even the<br />

company can go in the near future.<br />

Though Volocopter is not a partner (yet) with UBER’s Elevate<br />

program, UBER has already been in talks with Dubai to publicly<br />

demonstrate its own flying taxi service planned in 2020.<br />

If Volocopter’s demo program could go well as planned, it<br />

will be big propulsion for UBER’s efforts as well.<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

36


e Visions<br />

Aurora’s eVTOL approach<br />

Photos: Aurora Flight Sciences<br />

Aurora Flight Sciences is an American aviation, aeronautics research<br />

company which primarily specializes in the design and construction<br />

of special-purpose Unmanned aerial vehicles. Founded in 1989 Aurora<br />

has a heritage of highly efficient aerodynamic designs and innovative<br />

projects including human-powered airplane and solar airplanes.<br />

NNot a newcomer to the VTOL arena, Aurora has developed<br />

its own line of <strong>small</strong> vertical takeoff UAVs known as<br />

GoldenEye, but XV-24A lightning is really what catches people’s<br />

eyes. XV-24A is created by Aurora along with partners<br />

Rolls-Royce and Honeywell. It is funded by the Defense<br />

Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA) and is developed<br />

for the Vertical Take-Off and Landing Experimental<br />

Aircraft (VTOL X-Plane) program. LightningStrike is the first<br />

aircraft designed to demonstrate the distributed hybrid-electric<br />

propulsion ducted fans, innovative synchronous electricdrive<br />

system, both tilt wing and canard for vertical takeoff<br />

and landing and high efficiency in both hover and highspeed<br />

forward <strong>flight</strong>.<br />

Aurora is not only experienced in VTOL designs, but also is<br />

a leading company in autonomous <strong>flight</strong> control. As early as<br />

in 2012, Aurora has successfully demonstrated fully autonomous<br />

takeoff and landing capability in a converted Diamond<br />

DA42 optional piloted aircraft (OPA). In May <strong>2017</strong>, Aurora<br />

trumpeted the fact that one of its robots has successfully<br />

landed a simulated Boeing 737. What Aurora has built in the<br />

form of the robot rig uses “in-cockpit machine vision, robotic<br />

components to actuate the <strong>flight</strong> controls, an advanced tablet-based<br />

user interface, speech recognition and synthesis”<br />

to do the job. This accomplishment makes readers wonder<br />

if an auto robot arm could land a passenger jet, how easily<br />

would it be to land a <strong>small</strong> aircraft?<br />

Aurora’s advantages are obvious: they have experiences in<br />

airframe design, autonomous <strong>flight</strong> control and VTOL. These<br />

three elements are really a perfect combo when designing<br />

an autonomous eVTOL. This is perhaps the reason why<br />

UBER partnered with Aurora at the UBER Elevate conference<br />

in April of this year.<br />

Aurora’s design principles of their eVTOL are: keep it simple,<br />

design for efficient cruise, and base design on existing technology.<br />

If these requirement may sound too conservative,<br />

perhaps it also indicates Aurora’s intention to get the eVTOL<br />

prototype airborne as soon as possible. After all, according<br />

to UBER’s plan, the first test bed <strong>flight</strong>s are scheduled to begin<br />

in 2020, only three years from now. To achieve the goal,<br />

Aurora’s initial prototypes may only have 25 miles range at<br />

the beginning, and the commercial available models may<br />

37 e Flight Journal


e Visions<br />

have up to 40 miles range, which is sufficient<br />

in inter-urban environment. Aurora plans to<br />

have the eVTOL fly fully autonomously, even<br />

beginning from taxiing, but it will accommodate<br />

a safety human pilot at the beginning.<br />

A technology-oriented company with solid<br />

project development record, a simple design<br />

approach, a highly capable and motivated<br />

business partner. Aurora’s eVTOL<br />

prototype deserves to be watched closely.<br />

Now the only thing remains uncertain is<br />

what actual name Aurora will give to the eV-<br />

TOL project.<br />

Infrastructure<br />

• Aurora’s eVTOL aircraft will provide on-demand transportation<br />

to minimize long commutes due to heavy traffic and<br />

urbanization in populated areas.<br />

• The infrastructure plan includes urban “vertiports” for passenger<br />

boarding and vehicle servicing.<br />

• eVTOL aircraft will operate a “hub-to-hub” service between<br />

designated vertiports.<br />

• The first test bed <strong>flight</strong>s are scheduled to begin in 2020<br />

in Dallas, Texas USA and Dubai, The United Arab Emirates.<br />

Capabilities<br />

• The eVTOL will be used for short-haul transport of passengers<br />

or cargo.<br />

• Current configuration allows for two passengers including<br />

the pilot plus luggage.<br />

• Offerings will include specific configuration options to address<br />

mission requirements for civil and military operations.<br />

Operational Overview<br />

• The eVTOL aircraft includes eight lift rotors for vertical takeoff<br />

and cruise propeller and wing to transition to high-speed<br />

forward cruise.<br />

• At destination hub, the aircraft transitions back to rotorborne<br />

<strong>flight</strong> for vertical landing.<br />

• Fully electric operation decreases or eliminates emissions<br />

and noise pollution for a quieter <strong>flight</strong>.<br />

• While initially operated with a safety pilot, the eVTOL aircraft<br />

is designed for fully autonomous operations.<br />

• The <strong>flight</strong> capability for eVTOL aircraft is three times more<br />

efficient than a multi-copter aircraft.<br />

Aurora Corporate Headquater<br />

9950 Wakeman Dr<br />

Manassas, VA 20110<br />

phone: 703.369.3633<br />

eMail: info@aurora.aero<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

38


e Visions<br />

Electric Flight Plans of the Norwegian Government<br />

e-Flight Up North<br />

Despite<br />

many legal<br />

restrictions,<br />

sea planes<br />

are popular<br />

in the<br />

Norwegian<br />

general aviation<br />

community.<br />

The first<br />

Norwegian<br />

built electric<br />

aircraft is an<br />

amphibian.<br />

In many parts of the world developers are working on electric aircraft<br />

of all kind. But nowhere do governments make eAviation as part of<br />

the national transport plan, however a little country in Europe’s North<br />

wants to change this …Norway. The Government published a whitepaper<br />

and the Transport Ministry and the national airport operator<br />

Avinor are evaluating the possibility of electrifying all airports and using<br />

electric aircraft for the grid of short distance Flights that are part<br />

of the national transport system in the less populated country.<br />

TThe conditions are ideal, Norway has money from oil, a<br />

strong production of renewable electricity by waterpower<br />

and a grid of state owned <strong>small</strong> airfields. This grid is owned<br />

by the state through the state owned operator Avinor. Many<br />

short and medium distance commuter <strong>flight</strong>s are part of the<br />

national transport system by aircraft like the Dash 8. That’s<br />

because the country is in most parts only sparsely populated<br />

and the roadnet around the fiords and mountains is very<br />

dense so sometimes it may take you half a day on the road<br />

for an air-distance of only 50 kilometres.<br />

There is one more factor, which predestines Norway as testbed.<br />

In the last 10 years Norway pushed the use of electric<br />

cars by a government program, so that now it is the country<br />

with the highest density of electric cars per person in the<br />

world.<br />

Together with Norges Luftsportforbund (NLF) (The<br />

Norwegian Air Sports Federation) Avinor (the state-owned<br />

Norwegian airport operator and air navigation service provider)<br />

has initiated a long-term project aimed at introducing<br />

electric <strong>flight</strong> in Norway. Avinor states that their airport infrastructure<br />

is an ideal platform for research and testing within<br />

the field of electric aviation, and is willing to offer expertise<br />

and financial development support.<br />

The Norwegian government has for the first time in the national<br />

transport plan context promoted its own innovation initiative.<br />

It was published in National Plan for Transport (2018–<br />

2029) issued by the Norwegian government on April 5th this<br />

year:<br />

39 e Flight Journal


e Visions<br />

Photos (3): Lars Brede Grøndahl / Flynytt<br />

Norway has<br />

a vibrant general<br />

aviation<br />

community,<br />

and Norges<br />

Luftsportforbund<br />

(The<br />

Norwegian<br />

Air Sports<br />

Federation) is<br />

now seeking<br />

to introduce<br />

electric<br />

aircraft.<br />

The reason for the initiative is that the transport sector is expected<br />

to change in a number of ways at the same time as<br />

new business models; new players and changes in user behavior<br />

accompany new technology. The government will facilitate<br />

the rapid adoption of new technology in the transport<br />

sector through the development of new solutions and by<br />

adapting existing solutions suited to Norwegian conditions.<br />

Norway should be well suited for early use and use of electric<br />

aircraft for commercial traffic. The short field and narrow<br />

distance network of airports in Norway seems to fit well with<br />

expected performance on the first electric aircraft, both in<br />

terms of passenger capacity, distances, short-circuit characteristics<br />

and infrastructure for electrical energy.<br />

So what is the plan now and what are the next steps? Avinor<br />

assigned Jan Otto Reimers to do a study on “How the conversion<br />

to an electric aviation is possible” and how Norway<br />

can be one of the leading countries in this development.<br />

Jan Otto is ideal for this Job, even though he is not a pilot<br />

he is former president of the Norges Luftsportsforbund<br />

(Norwegian Aero Club) and was also leading the introduction<br />

of electric cars in Norwegian cities.<br />

After he delivered his first Report in May <strong>2017</strong>, Avinor and the<br />

government are now evaluating the options and will decide<br />

by the end of September which way the development will go.<br />

The following options are possible:<br />

A - Establish a sketch for cooperation with development organizations<br />

for electric aircraft to ensure that development<br />

also fit Norwegian conditions. (The short field and narrow<br />

distance network of airports in Norway may be interesting as<br />

an early user scenario.)<br />

B - Investigate possible collaboration with Norwegian companies<br />

and development organizations to build expertise in<br />

Norway, such as establishing a testing and competence center<br />

for electric aircraft.<br />

C - Details of the consequences of electrification of the short<br />

field and narrow distance network of airports, including the<br />

need for development, operation on short field airports, electrical<br />

infrastructure, passenger basis, aircraft sizes, energy<br />

consumption, emissions, approaches, noise, digitalized air<br />

traffic control, autonomous systems, etc.<br />

D - Prepare details for electrification of sport aviation: installations,<br />

infrastructure for charging, noise, energy consumption,<br />

emissions, etc.<br />

E - Assessing incentives and grants/funding schemes for the<br />

introduction of electric aircraft, operation of electric aircraft<br />

at an early stage and development of facilities/infrastructure.<br />

We will keep you updated.<br />

Ketil Solvik-Olsen (left), Norway’s minister of transport,<br />

Didier Esteyne (middle), designer and test pilot of Airbus<br />

E-Fan, and Dag Falk-Petersen, Avinor’s CEO, at the 2016 Zero<br />

Emission Resource Organization Conference in Oslo.<br />

Aircraft designer<br />

Tomas<br />

Brødreskrift (left)<br />

is demonstrating<br />

Norway’s first<br />

hybrid electric<br />

aircraft, Equator<br />

P2 Xcursion,<br />

to secretary<br />

general of the<br />

Norwegian Air<br />

Sports Federation<br />

John Eirik Laupsa<br />

(middle) during<br />

Aero <strong>2017</strong> in<br />

Friedrichshafen.<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

40


Market Watch<br />

The EAC Whisper is a multicopter<br />

that has 8 arms with<br />

one Prop each of this props is<br />

driveb by a Plettenberg motor<br />

with a 30 kW power and 6 kg<br />

weight.<br />

Visions Become Reality<br />

In science fiction movies such as The Fifth Element (1997) or Minority<br />

Report (2002), countless autonomous flying cars flit through<br />

the gullies of the skyscrapers of future megacities. At the moment<br />

it looks as if these impressive visions of Hollywood about the inner<br />

city traffic of the future will soon become reality.<br />

We are in the year <strong>2017</strong>: The development of the inner city individual<br />

air traffic is in a gold rush mood. Almost 20 companies are<br />

currently working on various VTOL (Vertical TakeOff and Landing)<br />

concepts, starting from aeronautical industry giants like Airbus and<br />

Bell to <strong>small</strong> innovative start-ups such as eVolo, Lilium and Zee-<br />

Aero. A few designs have already been flown and other maiden<br />

<strong>flight</strong>s are planned for <strong>2017</strong>, but most of these VTOL concepts are<br />

still in the early stage of the development. Aerospace experts believe<br />

that the electrification of the propulsion will enable many innovative<br />

designs. The rapid development in the electric propulsions<br />

and the automatic <strong>flight</strong> controls brought the era of fully-automatic<br />

on-demand flying taxis within reach. The development in <strong>2017</strong><br />

was boosted by the «Elevate» initiative of the car-sharing service<br />

UBER. The favorite of the US stock market (over 60 billion US Dollar<br />

market value) works concretely on ride-sharing concepts with<br />

VTOL taxis. The criteria for the vehicles are: full electric, 60 miles<br />

range and 160 mph maximum speed.<br />

In order to reflect this development, we have introduced an<br />

independent class «Multicopter and VTOL». Only some of these<br />

models flew already and many are still in the early project stage.<br />

For this reason, the technical data of the aircraft part are still<br />

mostly not complete. Nevertheless, we are sure this class will<br />

grow in the coming years.<br />

Qinyin Zhang<br />

NAME OF THE MANUFACTURER<br />

Short description<br />

NAME OF THE MODEL<br />

Photo of the model<br />

FULL NAME OF THE MANUFACTURER<br />

Address<br />

E-mail • Homepage<br />

EW MTOW PA BA PD Engine Power St Vmax Vc Vz ES Endurance Price (estimate) Kit Plan<br />

« EW »<br />

Empty weight<br />

kilograms<br />

(1kg = 2.20lb)<br />

« MTOW »<br />

Maximum all-up<br />

weight<br />

kilograms<br />

(1kg = 2.20lb)<br />

« PA »<br />

Number of<br />

Propellers<br />

« BA »<br />

Number of<br />

propeller<br />

blades<br />

« PD »<br />

Diameter of<br />

propeller<br />

« Engine »<br />

Engine<br />

« Power »<br />

(Hp or kW)<br />

« St »<br />

Number of<br />

seats<br />

« Vmax »<br />

Maximum<br />

speed<br />

kilometres per<br />

hour<br />

(km/h)<br />

(km/h)<br />

« Vz »<br />

Climb rate<br />

metres per second<br />

(m/s)<br />

(1m/s = 197ft/min)<br />

« Vc »<br />

Cruise speed<br />

kilometres per hour<br />

(in Litre or kWh)<br />

« Endurance »<br />

Max Endurance<br />

(in hours - h)<br />

« ES »<br />

Energy storage<br />

« Kit »<br />

Kit price<br />

Excluding local and<br />

national taxes<br />

« Price (estimate) »<br />

Excluding local and<br />

national taxes<br />

« Plan »<br />

Plan price<br />

Excluding local and<br />

national taxes<br />

41 e Flight Journal


Market Watch<br />

A3<br />

Vahana is a full-electric VTOL vehicle designed by A3 based in Santa Clara, California. The venture capital company<br />

A3 is founded in 2015 by Airbus Group as an innovation outpost in Silicon Valley. Vahana is a tandem tiltwing<br />

aircraft, where four variable-speed, variable-pitch propellers are mounted both on the forward and the main wing.<br />

The propellers and the wings tilt up during vertical takeoff and tilt horizontal for cruise <strong>flight</strong>. The demonstrator uses<br />

45-kW motors and Lithium Polymer batteries. The current version of Vahana is a single-seater designed for autonomous<br />

ride-sharing or air taxi services. The first fully autonomous <strong>flight</strong>s will be performed before end of <strong>2017</strong>. Yet it<br />

is planned for 2020 to have a certifiable and producible vehicle with two seats.<br />

VAHANA<br />

A3 AIRBUS 3000 Sand Hill Road - 1-120 • Menlo Park 94025 • California • USA • Phone : +1 703 889-0535<br />

hello@airbus-sv.comm • www.airbus-sv.com<br />

EW MTOW PA BA PD Engine Power St Vmax Vc Vz ES Endurance Price (estimate) Kit Plan<br />

725 8 2 8x45 kW 360 kW 1 173 1/2h - -<br />

AURORA FLIGHT SCIENCE<br />

At the Uber Elevate Summit in April <strong>2017</strong>, Aurora Flight Science unveiled its two-seat eVTOL air vehicle concept for<br />

Uber’s flying taxi service. Aurora Flight Science has more than 20 years of experience in developing special-purpose<br />

unmanned aerial vehicle (more than 30 unmanned aircraft developed). For this aircraft, Aurora’s design logic was to<br />

keep the architecture simple and emphasizes the cruise efficiency. For this reason, its eVTOL aircraft features eight<br />

lift propellers distributed along two booms for the vertical takeoff, while a single pusher propeller delivers the propulsion<br />

for the horizontal <strong>flight</strong>. For the cruise <strong>flight</strong>, the lift propellers will be stopped and the lift is generated by three<br />

aerodynamic surfaces, i.e. the canard, wing and tail. Even the aircraft is designed for fully autonomous <strong>flight</strong>s, the<br />

two-seater can provide place for a safety pilot due to current certification constraints. The first full-scale <strong>flight</strong> tests of<br />

the aircraft are scheduled to 2020 in Dallas and Dubai.<br />

AURORA FLIGHT SCIENCE CORPORATION 9950 Wakeman Drive • Manassas, Virginia 20110 • USA •<br />

Phone : +1 703 369 3633<br />

info@aurora.aero • http://www.aurora.aero<br />

AURORA FLIGHT SCIENCE 1<br />

EW MTOW PA BA PD Engine Power St Vmax Vc Vz ES Endurance Price (estimate) Kit Plan<br />

- - 8 + 1 2 - - 2 - - - - - - - -<br />

E-VOLO<br />

The VC200 made by the e-volo team in Germany had its unmanned maiden <strong>flight</strong> on November 17, 2013, and its<br />

first manned <strong>flight</strong> in March 2016. It is a world exclusive design, and so far the only two-seat multicopter. It is a sideby-side<br />

450kg MTOW ultralight ‘volocopter’ with 18 electric motors and 18 rotors with each rotor 1.8 m in diameter.<br />

It comes with fly-by-wire technology, and is a fully carbon built aircraft. The rotor arms are detachable for transport<br />

and hangar storage. In <strong>2017</strong>, e-volo signed an agreement with Dubai’s transport authority to begin testing VC200<br />

as part of a flying taxi service in the fourth quarter of <strong>2017</strong>.<br />

VC200<br />

E-VOLO GMBH Oestliche Rheinbrueckenstr. 50 • 76187 Karlsruhe • GERMANY • Phone : +49 (0)721 754 000-0, Fax : +49<br />

(0)721 754 000-99<br />

info@volocopter.com • www.e-volo.com<br />

EW MTOW PA BA PD Engine Power St Vmax Vc Vz ES Endurance Price (estimate) Kit Plan<br />

290 450 18 2 1.8 18x3 kW 54 kW 2 100 50 17.5 kWh 30 min - -<br />

EHANG INC.<br />

The EHang 184 is an Autonomous Aerial Vehicle (AAV) designed by Guangzhou EHang Inc. and it was first shown<br />

to the public on CES 2016. The designator “184” stands for “1 passenger, 8 propellers, and 4 arms”. The EHang<br />

184 has eight unducted 1.6 m diameter propellers arranged in a quadcopter configuration, where two counter-rotating<br />

propellers are mounted on each of the four so called “propulsion arms”. According to the manufacturer, the<br />

empty weight of EHang 184 is about 240 kg and a maximum gross takeoff weight is 360 kg. The lithium polymer<br />

batteries enable the drone a cruise speed of 60 km/h and an endurance of about 30 minutes. Currently, EHang<br />

184 is performing test <strong>flight</strong>s in Dubei and Nevada (USA).<br />

EHANG 184<br />

EHANG INC. Building No.3 of Yixiang Science Park,No.72 • 510700 Huangpu District, Guangzhou Guangdong •<br />

Guangdong • CHINA • Phone : +86 020-29028899<br />

service@ehang.com • www.ehang.com<br />

EW MTOW PA BA PD Engine Power St Vmax Vc Vz ES Endurance Price (estimate) Kit Plan<br />

240 360 8 2 1.6 8x19 kW 152 kW 1 60 17 kWh 30 - -<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

42


Market Watch<br />

ELECTRIC AIRCRAFT CONCEPT (EAC)<br />

On AERO <strong>2017</strong> a <strong>small</strong> and relatively unknown company from France, EAC (Electric Aircraft Concept)<br />

presented a multicopter. The development started three and a half years ago and the multicopter is<br />

shown to the public for the first time. The Multicopter has eight propellers from the company E-Props,<br />

and they are each driven by a Plettenberg engine (30 kW power and 6 kg weight). The power is supplied<br />

by Li-Po batteries. The Multicopter has an empty weight of 350 kg, with a load of 200 kg. The<br />

MTOW is thus 550 kg.<br />

WHISPER<br />

ELECTRIC AIRCRAFT CONCEPT (EAC) 1002 Route du Barroux • 84330 CAROMB • FRANCE • Phone :<br />

+33 0033(0)6-03-48-28-37<br />

info@eac-whisper.com • www.eac-whisper.com<br />

EW MTOW PA BA PD Engine Power St Vmax Vc Vz ES Endurance Price (estimate) Kit Plan<br />

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - -<br />

KITTY HAWK CORPORATION<br />

Kitty Hawk Corporation is a flying car company financially backed by Google founder Larry Page. In April <strong>2017</strong>,<br />

a video of its Kitty Hawk Flyer was first time released. The Flyer is a full-electric VTOL aircraft within the Ultralight<br />

category (empty weight about 100 kg). It has 8 propellers and is designed to be flown over water. In USA, it can be<br />

flown over uncongested areas without pilot license. The official sale start is planned for the end of <strong>2017</strong>, and the<br />

go-to-market Flyer will have a different design than the working prototype in the video footage.<br />

KITTY HAWK FLYER<br />

KITTY HAWK CORPORATION 2700 Broderick Way • Mountain View, 94043 • California • USA • Phone :<br />

+1 650)265-0451<br />

hello@kittyhawk.aero • https://kittyhawk.aero<br />

EW MTOW PA BA PD Engine Power St Vmax Vc Vz ES Endurance Price (estimate) Kit Plan<br />

100 - 8 2 - - 1 - 40 - - - - - -<br />

LILIUM AVIATION<br />

Lilium Eagle is full-electric VTOL vehicle designed by a start-up company Lilium Aviation located in Gilching near<br />

Munich. The maiden <strong>flight</strong> of the full-scale 2-seater prototype “Eagle” was performed on April 20, <strong>2017</strong>. As the<br />

wording “Jet” implies, the air stream is accelerated by 36 impellers located on the wings (12 on the forward wing<br />

and 24 on the main wing). During takeoff, the impellers point downward to provide vertical lift (helicopter mode),<br />

while the impellers are tilted into the <strong>flight</strong> direction to provide propulsion force for the cruise <strong>flight</strong> (airplane mode).<br />

The yaw control is achieved with variating the impeller differently left and right, therefore, no vertical stabilizer is<br />

needed. After the successful first <strong>flight</strong> of the 2-seater, the maiden <strong>flight</strong> of a 5-seater version is planned for 2019.<br />

LILIUM EAGLE<br />

LILIUM GMBH Friedrichshafener Strasse 1 • 82205 Gilching, • GERMANY • Phone : +49 0)81 0577 277 87<br />

info@lilium-aviation.com • www.lilium-aviation.com<br />

EW MTOW PA BA PD Engine Power St Vmax Vc Vz ES Endurance Price (estimate) Kit Plan<br />

400 600 36 12 0.25 - 2 400 300 - - 1 h - - -<br />

SUREFLY WORKHORSE<br />

The manufacturer of electric vehicles for delivery services has developed a delivery drone for Amazon. On this<br />

base they now presented the prototype of this double-seat multicopter, which has been publicly presented at the<br />

Paris Airshow <strong>2017</strong> for the first time. The two-seater is powered by 8 Emrax e-motors from Slovenia. In their workhorse<br />

the Americans fully set on hybrid. There are some Licium, ion batteries in the four foldable rotor arms, but<br />

these only for short <strong>flight</strong>s. The main energy source is a two-cylinder four-stroke engine in the back of the machine<br />

with its almost 200 hp it drives a generator. First <strong>flight</strong> planned for end of <strong>2017</strong>.<br />

WORKHORSE<br />

SUREFLY 100 Commerce Dr. • Loveland, Ohio 45140 • USA • Phone : +1 513-360-4704<br />

http://workhorse.com<br />

EW MTOW PA BA PD Engine Power St Vmax Vc Vz ES Endurance Price (estimate) Kit Plan<br />

500 680 4 2 - 8 * 30 kW Emrax - - - - - - - - - -<br />

43 e Flight Journal


Market Watch<br />

WATERS TRUST<br />

The Vision VTOL (Vertical Take-off and Landing) from the U.S. is designed by Mike Waters specifically for the<br />

imminent evolution of electric power storage and energy breakthroughs. The Vision is the beginning of a new<br />

breed of transportation that is specifically designed for ultra long range electric power and storage - point to point<br />

transportation. First designed over 10 years ago, all technologies required are now almost fully developed. This is<br />

the single seat prototype. It uses a slightly modified, sailplane fuselage with two pairs of tilting and canalized fans.<br />

VISION VTOL<br />

WATERS TRUST Fairfield, PA • USA • Phone : +1 574 849 6236<br />

hpcconcepts@yahoo.com • http://visionvtol.weebly.com<br />

EW MTOW PA BA PD Engine Power St Vmax Vc Vz ES Endurance Price (estimate) Kit Plan<br />

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -<br />

XTI AIRCRAFT<br />

The American Company lead by founder David Brody and Rober Labelle (Former CEO of Agusta Westland North<br />

Amerika) started developing this 6 seat VTOL Aircraft in 2012 . The three electric Motors (with 250 KW each) are<br />

driving multi blade ducted Fans and receive their energy from two turboshaft engines. After vertical take off the<br />

two front Rotors are turned into <strong>flight</strong> direction. The third fan is covered for reducing the drag. The aimed maximum<br />

speed is 350 Miles per hour. And the max Cruise altitude shall be 30 000 feet. For the electric Integration<br />

Gorge Bye from the Sunflyer project is part of the Team.<br />

TRIFAN 600<br />

XTI AIRCRAFT 13000 East Control Tower Road • Englewood Colorado 80112 • USA • Phone : +1 303 503<br />

5660<br />

LiftUp@xtiaircraft.com • http://www.xtiaircraft.com<br />

EW MTOW PA BA PD Engine Power St Vmax Vc Vz ES Endurance Price (estimate) Kit Plan<br />

- - - - - 3 x 250 max 2600 6 >700 630 - - - - - -<br />

MORE VTOL PROJECTS AROUND THE WORLD<br />

MBesides these concrete projects above, of which several are already flying, there are many more companies around the globe<br />

working on private VTOL projects. Some work very silent while others make a big wave. As we do not have reliable data on<br />

these VTOLs, in the following we give an overview with a name, image and web address. Info is changing quickly and there<br />

will be more projects every month, this is where we stand as of July <strong>2017</strong>. More info always on www.e-<strong>flight</strong>-expo.com.<br />

ZEEAREO / ZP1 www.zee.aero<br />

JOBY AVIATION / S2 S4 www.JobyAviation.com<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

44


Market Watch<br />

AIRSPACEX / MOBI www.airspacex.com<br />

NEVA AERO / AIRQUAD 1 www.neva-aero.com<br />

AIRBUS / CITYAIRBUS www.airbus-xo.com<br />

EMBRAER / VTOL http://www.embraer.com<br />

DELOREAN AER. / DR-7 www.deloreanaerospace<br />

CARTER-MOONEY / SR/C www.cartercopters.com<br />

45 e Flight Journal


Market Watch<br />

BELL HELI. / EVTOL www.bellhelicopter.com<br />

TECHNOPLANE SAS / MINI-BEE www.technoplane.com<br />

PIPISTREL / PROJECT VTOL www.pipistrel.si<br />

JETPACK AVIATION / EVTOL www.jetpackaviation.com<br />

This chapter was taken from the new edition of the<br />

World Directory of Light Aviation <strong>2017</strong>/18<br />

* The World Directory of Light Aviation <strong>2017</strong>/18 lists with images, descriptions<br />

and technical data over 1000 aircraft: ultralights, microlights,<br />

LSA, gyrocopter, ul-helicopters, certified aircraft, kitplanes, trikes, ultralight<br />

and certified gliders & motor-gliders, VTOLs and multicopters, instruments,<br />

engines, propellers and accessories.<br />

* The World Directory of Light Aviation <strong>2017</strong>/18 is available in four languages:<br />

English, French and German. The Chinese version will be on the<br />

market at the end of September.<br />

* The World Directory of Light Aviation <strong>2017</strong>/18 is now available at all<br />

EAA merchandise outlets at AirVenture or online at http://lightaviationguide.com<br />

(in USA) or www.flying-pages.com (worldwide).<br />

Guide<br />

<strong>2017</strong>-18 > Australia $15.50 • USA $16.99 • UK £6.99<br />

Buyer's<br />

Marktübersicht<br />

<strong>2017</strong>-18 > alle Euroländer 9,95 E • CH 16,50 SFr<br />

8 Zugelassene Flugzeuge 8 Trikes 8 Gyrokopter 8 Helikopter 8 Motorsegler...<br />

Welt Index<br />

LtraLEIcht<br />

<strong>2017</strong><br />

2018 & FLUGzEUG<br />

Flügel<br />

Flügel - das Magazin<br />

8 Certified Aircraft 8 Trikes 8 Gyroplanes 8 Helicopters 8 Motorgliders...<br />

World Directory of<br />

Light AviAtion<br />

special issue of<br />

lügel<br />

MAGAZINE<br />

flügel - das Magazin<br />

<strong>2017</strong><br />

2018<br />

1000 AircrAft...<br />

Microlights & LSA<br />

LSA<br />

,<br />

ul m<br />

8 Pendulaires 8 Autogires 8 Hélicos 8 Motoplaneurs...<br />

instrumente<br />

+motoren<br />

ProPeller - funk<br />

avionik - gPs und mehr!<br />

hors-série<br />

<strong>2017</strong>-18<br />

gzeUge...<br />

Ultraleichte<br />

Guide<br />

+motors<br />

instruments<br />

propellers - radio<br />

avionics - gps & more!<br />

new<br />

VTOL & multicopter<br />

Hors-série Vol Moteur <strong>2017</strong>-18 > France/Andorre/Belgique 9.95 E • DOM 11,30 E • Lux 11,30 E • CH 16,90 FS • CAN 15,99 $ca • ITA/PORT CONT 11,30 E • TOM 1850 xpf<br />

,<br />

Guide d achat ul m + l s a<br />

Neu<br />

1000<br />

ULM & LSA<br />

VTOL & muLTicOpTer<br />

instruMents<br />

+Moteurs<br />

hélices - radios<br />

avioniques - gps...<br />

nouveau<br />

VTOL & multicoptEres<br />

L 14258 - 24 H - F: 9,95 € - RD<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

46


Buyer's Guide<br />

8 Certified Aircraft 8 Trikes 8 Gyroplanes 8 Helicopters 8 Motorgliders...<br />

World Directory of<br />

Light AviAtion<br />

special issue of<br />

Flügel<br />

flügel - das Magazin<br />

<strong>2017</strong><br />

2018<br />

MAGAZINE<br />

1000 AircrAft...<br />

Microlights & LSA<br />

+motors<br />

instruments<br />

propellers - radio<br />

avionics - gps & more!<br />

<strong>2017</strong>-18 > Australia $15.50 • USA $16.99 • UK £6.99<br />

Buyer's<br />

new<br />

AVAILABLE AT ALL EAA SALES<br />

OUTLETS - AIRVENTURE <strong>2017</strong><br />

VTOL & multicopter<br />

EAA MEMBERS<br />

save $ 2<br />

Reg. $ 16.99<br />

EAA price $ 14.99


The Future ofAviation<br />

April, 18.- 21. 2018<br />

Friedrichshafen - Germany<br />

即 将 开 启<br />

coming soon<br />

The e-<strong>flight</strong>-expo is part of the annual AERO in Friedrichshafen /<br />

Germany.<br />

You will find the most advanced electric, hybrid, fuel-cell and solar<br />

aircraft and propulsion systems.<br />

e-<strong>flight</strong>-forum<br />

China <strong>2017</strong><br />

www.e-<strong>flight</strong>-expo.com

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!