Vatican II ABOUT FACE! - Chiesa viva

172
fore all men the doctrine concerning Bishops,
the successors of the Apostles, who together
with the successor of Peter, the Vicar of Christ,
the visible Head of the whole Church, govern the
house of the living God.»
Now, saying that “with the Successor of Peter, the Bishops
govern the house of the living God” is more than a
misunderstanding, because it can lead us into an error, in
a serious way, for not having emphasized the subordination of
the Bishops to the Pope, which would contradict the First
Vatican Council.
At N° 19 we read: “Jesus formed the Twelve after the
manner of a college or a established group, over which He
placed Peter chosen from among them.” And further
ahead:
«And the apostles (…) gather together the universal
Church, which the Lord established on
the Apostles and built upon blessed Peter, their
chief, Christ Jesus Himself being the supreme
cornerstone.»
As we can see, it does not refer to the text: “You are Peter
and on this rock I will build My Church”, so that the
phrases “put Peter at its head,” and “their chief,” or
“head,” have the meaning of a simple “primacy of honor.”
At N° 20, the misunderstanding remains; in fact, it says:
«And just as the office granted individually to
Peter (…) so also the Apostles’ office of nurturing
the Church is permanent, and is to be exercised
without interruption by the sacred order
of Bishops. Therefore, the Sacred Council
teaches that bishops by divine institution have
succeeded to the place of the apostles, as shepherds
of the Church …»