Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
Spring 2013 Volume 22 • Number 1<br />
Published Quarterly by The Society of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong><br />
Jim Emmerton and Arthur Close <strong>INSIDE</strong>: <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> <strong>Law</strong> <strong>Institute</strong><br />
Publications Mail Agreement: 40010827
Kumsheen today<br />
This could be you!<br />
More than 250,000 fans have loved rafting<br />
the Thompson River with Kumsheen.<br />
From a raft & a VW van in 1973 to a stunning,<br />
family-friendly and family-run rafting resort<br />
today. In 40 epic years, we’ve matured—a lot.<br />
1973<br />
This summer bring your family,<br />
raft the Thompson River, and<br />
delight in our hospitality.<br />
You’ll be glad you did.<br />
1.800.663.6667<br />
Visit our website at www.kumsheen.com
BC Notaries Are Respected in Their Communities.<br />
What Does it Take to Become a BC Notary Public?<br />
• Strong entrepreneurial and people skills<br />
• The highest degree of honesty and integrity<br />
• University degree and 5 years’ related experience<br />
• Fluency in English; other languages an asset<br />
• Financial backing<br />
• Dedication to serving the public<br />
Those are the characteristics of a BC Notary Public.<br />
There are business opportunities for Notaries in various communities throughout <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong>.<br />
As a BC Notary, you will have<br />
the opportunity to enjoy a rewarding<br />
career as an independent<br />
businessperson who serves the<br />
public, and sets the example<br />
of integrity and trust for which<br />
Notaries are known throughout<br />
the world.<br />
If you have the qualities<br />
noted above, and are looking<br />
for a new career path,<br />
consider our Master of Arts<br />
in Applied Legal Studies (MA<br />
ALS) program for BC Notaries,<br />
conducted through Simon<br />
Fraser University.<br />
For more information, please<br />
contact The Society of Notaries<br />
Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong><br />
1-800-663-0343<br />
or visit our Website<br />
www.notaries.bc.ca.
Published by The socieTy of NoTaries Public of bc<br />
THE PRESIDENT OF THE SOCIETY<br />
Our Choices Here in BC 6<br />
John Eastwood<br />
FEATURES<br />
THE CEO/SECRETARY OF THE SOCIETY<br />
Putting Plans into Action 7<br />
Wayne Braid<br />
KEYNOTE<br />
Spotlight on Some of BC’s <strong>Law</strong> Organizations 8<br />
Val Wilson<br />
BCLI Overview 11<br />
Establishing the Samoa <strong>Law</strong> Reform Commission 18<br />
Laura Tamblyn Watts<br />
What Does it Take to Become a BC Notary Public? 3<br />
The Scrivener: What’s in a Name? 5<br />
BC Notaries Speak Your Language 53<br />
Services a BC Notary Can Provide 61<br />
MEET OUR BOARD OF DIRECTORS<br />
Patricia Wright: A Love of <strong>Law</strong> and Music 20<br />
PROFILE OF A BC NOTARY<br />
SECHELT AND THE SUNSHINE COAST<br />
Tracy Parker: Blues-Berries Anyone? 24<br />
Dear Mum 28<br />
Leta Best<br />
WHERE ARE THEY NOW?<br />
Roy Bishop: Nonstop Since Retiring! 30<br />
Building Better Communities, one grant at a time<br />
The Board of Governors and Funds Earned 32<br />
COVER STORY<br />
<strong>Law</strong> Reform at Work<br />
in <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> 10<br />
The MiX<br />
Business to Business 23<br />
THE BIG PICTURE<br />
Practising International Development at Home 34<br />
Nigel Atkin<br />
CHARITABLE GIVING<br />
How to Customize Your Giving 36<br />
David Watts<br />
POWER OF ATTORNEY<br />
Avoiding Elder Abuse by a Rogue “Attorney”* 38<br />
Alternatives to Enduring Powers of Attorney 40<br />
Kevin Smith<br />
COMMUNITIES<br />
Award for Service with Distinction 43<br />
Tammy Morin-Nakashima<br />
THE REAL ESTATE FOUNDATION OF BC<br />
Creating Sustainable Food Systems in BC 44<br />
Some of the Sustainable Food Systems Grants 45<br />
Celina Owen<br />
LETTERS 47<br />
CONTINUATION<br />
Wills, Estates and Succession Act from page 7 47<br />
PROPERTY IN BRITISH COLUMBIA<br />
A Day in the Life of a Real Estate Appraiser 48<br />
Paul Fischer<br />
Editor’s 49<br />
TAKE 5 FOR FITNESS<br />
Relax and Rejuvenate 50<br />
MaryAnne Galey<br />
SUCCESS<br />
3 Small Habits that Will Change Your Life Forever 52<br />
Carla Rieger<br />
4 The Society of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013<br />
www.wildmanphotography.com
MEDIATION<br />
What is Mediation?<br />
Renee Collins Goult<br />
SERVING SENIORS<br />
54<br />
No Easy Answers<br />
Rhonda Latreille<br />
OUR ENVIRONMENT<br />
56<br />
Bringing Back Herring in Howe Sound<br />
Dr. Jonn Matsen<br />
TAXES<br />
58<br />
PST, HST, GST—SOS!<br />
Andrea Agnoloni<br />
60<br />
Test Your Skills!<br />
COMMUNITY<br />
62<br />
Building Connections<br />
Elise Willson<br />
WILLS & ESTATES<br />
63<br />
Severance of Joint Tenancies by Course of Conduct<br />
Trevor Todd, Judith Milliken, QC<br />
HISTORY OF BRITISH COLUMBIA<br />
64<br />
The Sockeye Special<br />
Ron Hyde<br />
68<br />
Recollections of Lulu Island<br />
Hugh Cooper<br />
69<br />
A Nickel for Your Thoughts?<br />
Susan Freeborn<br />
ASSOCIATION OF BC LAND SURVEYORS<br />
71<br />
Fantastic AGM for 2013<br />
Chuck Salmon<br />
TRAVEL<br />
72<br />
Colombia is Safe, But Don’t Pack Laundry Soap<br />
Trevor Todd<br />
TECHNOLOGY<br />
74<br />
The Latest and Best for Spring 2013<br />
Akash Sablok<br />
HONOURS & EVENTS<br />
76<br />
PEOPLE 78<br />
Where in the World Has The Scrivener Been? 78<br />
The Scrivener: What’s in a Name?<br />
“A professional penman, a copyist, a scribe . . . a Notary.” Thus the<br />
Oxford English Dictionary describes a Scrivener, the craftsman charged<br />
with ensuring that the written affairs of others flow smoothly, seamlessly,<br />
and accurately. Where a Scrivener must record the files accurately,<br />
it’s the Notary whose Seal is bond.<br />
We chose The Scrivener as the name of our magazine to celebrate<br />
the Notary’s role in drafting, communicating, authenticating, and getting<br />
the facts straight. We strive to publish articles about points of law and<br />
the Notary profession for the education and enjoyment of our members,<br />
our allied professionals in business, and the public.<br />
Published by<br />
The Society of Notaries Public<br />
of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong><br />
Editor-in-Chief Val Wilson<br />
Legal Editors Wayne Braid, Ken Sherk<br />
Magazine Filip de Sagher, Chair<br />
Committee Kate manvell<br />
Zoë Stevens<br />
marny morin, Staff Liaison<br />
Administration Amber Rooke<br />
Courier Lightspeed Courier & Logistics<br />
The Scrivener<br />
Telephone: 604 985-9250<br />
email: scrivener@society.notaries.bc.ca<br />
Website: www.notaries.bc.ca/scrivener<br />
The Society of Notaries Public of BC<br />
604 681-4516<br />
To send photographs to The Scrivener,<br />
please see the Editor's column on page 49.<br />
All rights reserved. Contents may not be<br />
reprinted or reproduced without written<br />
permission from the publisher. This journal<br />
is a forum for discussion, not a medium<br />
of official pronouncement. The Society does not,<br />
in any sense, endorse or accept responsibility<br />
for opinions expressed by contributors.<br />
CANADA PoST: PUBLICATIoNS mAIL<br />
AgREEmENT No. 40010827<br />
Postage Paid at Vancouver, BC<br />
RETURN UNDELIVERABLE CANADIAN<br />
ADDRESSES To CIRCULATIoN DEPT.:<br />
THE SOCIETY OF NOTARIES<br />
PuBLIC OF BC<br />
SuITE 1220 – 625 HOWE STREET<br />
BOx 44<br />
VANCOuVER, BC V6C 2T6<br />
SCRIVENER@SoCIETy.NoTARIES.BC.CA<br />
Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013 The Scrivener 5
THE PRESIDENT Of THE SOCIETY<br />
our Choices Here in BC<br />
<strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong>ns value<br />
the freedom to make their<br />
own decisions throughout<br />
their lives . . . to make choices.<br />
Let me give you some examples<br />
of those choices.<br />
• Many families choose the services<br />
of a midwife to assist in the<br />
birth of their children, in place<br />
of or alongside an obstetrician/<br />
gynecologist or general practitioner.<br />
• Parents and their children have<br />
the choice of schools in our<br />
public system—charter schools<br />
and French immersion schools.<br />
Postsecondary students can<br />
attend a college or university and<br />
choose from over 1900 programs,<br />
depending on their education<br />
interests; many qualify for<br />
government-assisted tuition fees.<br />
• Individuals can choose<br />
a variety of health care<br />
providers—a medical doctor,<br />
naturopath, chiropractor,<br />
occupational therapist,<br />
physiotherapist, ophthalmologist,<br />
optometrist, or optician, to name<br />
a few.<br />
• We can now obtain a flu shot from<br />
an alternative trained medical<br />
practitioner such as a pharmacist.<br />
• In the purchase and sale<br />
of property, we have the choice<br />
of arranging financing through<br />
a mortgage broker or directly with<br />
our financial institution . . . and<br />
we can use the services of either<br />
a BC Notary or a lawyer for the<br />
legal conveyance/mortgage.<br />
We enjoy having choices.<br />
• When preparing a Will, Power<br />
of Attorney, and other advance<br />
planning documents, we have<br />
a similar choice of service<br />
providers.<br />
• <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> is 1 of only<br />
2 provinces and territories<br />
in Canada to offer people<br />
the choice of working with<br />
a professional Notary to prepare<br />
their legal documents.<br />
• A recent poll found that<br />
77 percent of all BC residents<br />
have a favourable impression<br />
of Notaries. For those who have<br />
used the services of a BC Notary,<br />
that number rises to 88 percent.<br />
For some time, our government<br />
has been discussing access to justice<br />
and access to affordable legal<br />
services. There is no doubt that the<br />
cost of some legal services and the<br />
access to justice can be unaffordable<br />
to the average income-earner.<br />
BC Notaries can be part of an<br />
affordable solution. We are increasingly<br />
being asked by clients if we can help<br />
them with additional legal services<br />
such as these.<br />
• Probating Wills<br />
• Preparation of family-related<br />
documents—prenuptial and marriage<br />
or end-of-marriage agreements<br />
and uncontested divorce<br />
• Incorporation of companies,<br />
corporate filings, and corporate<br />
record-keeping<br />
• Other noncontentious legal<br />
services<br />
John Eastwood<br />
The Society of Notaries Public<br />
of BC has on several occasions<br />
surveyed the people of <strong>British</strong><br />
<strong>Columbia</strong>. In September 2010, the<br />
Mustel Group asked <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong>ns<br />
about their interest in alternative legal<br />
services and found this.<br />
• 66% of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong>ns<br />
would like to see more choices<br />
of professionals to provide legal<br />
services, in addition to lawyers.<br />
• 75% would support legislation<br />
that would expand the field<br />
of those services.<br />
You may wish to make your<br />
opinion known. There is an opportunity<br />
to do so in the coming provincial<br />
election on May 14. If and how you<br />
may become involved is your choice,<br />
but you can take part in determining<br />
who will represent you in our next<br />
provincial government.<br />
I encourage you to become<br />
involved . . . to get out and vote<br />
for your choice of legislative<br />
representative and show your support<br />
for that candidate by working with<br />
the candidate to gain the support<br />
of other voters and, if you are able,<br />
through financial contribution to the<br />
candidate’s campaign.<br />
You also have the opportunity<br />
to influence the views of your<br />
candidate toward legislation that<br />
supports the freedom of choice for<br />
the people of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> and,<br />
if you are so inclined, to lend your<br />
support to my first choice—improved<br />
access to affordable legal services<br />
and alternative legal service providers:<br />
BC Notaries. s<br />
6 The Society of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013<br />
www.TheBigPictureStudio.com
THE CEO/SECRETaRY Of THE SOCIETY<br />
our Cover Story interview<br />
describes some of the<br />
great works of the<br />
<strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> <strong>Law</strong> <strong>Institute</strong><br />
and provides a look at two<br />
of the leaders of the BCLI.<br />
I have appreciated the work of the<br />
BC <strong>Law</strong> <strong>Institute</strong>, their dedicated staff,<br />
and the many Board members who<br />
have lent a hand to direct and guide<br />
the organization over the years.<br />
Shortly after I took on the<br />
responsibilities I now enjoy at<br />
The Society, one of my first connections<br />
with BCLI was to meet Arthur Close.<br />
I recall our first lunch meeting at the old<br />
(now new again!) Georgia Hotel. Arthur<br />
kindly, carefully, and expertly filled me<br />
in on the history of the organization and<br />
gave me a glimpse of its vision for the<br />
future. That was nearly 10 years ago.<br />
Many of Arthur’s ideas have come to<br />
pass or are in process.<br />
Our Notary Foundation has<br />
supported a number of the <strong>Institute</strong>’s<br />
projects over the years.<br />
They include Real Property Review,<br />
Phase 1; the Community <strong>Law</strong> Reform<br />
Project that focused on a series<br />
of shorter projects, resulting in 14<br />
publications on a variety of topics<br />
and 8 final reports: Unfair Contract<br />
Terms, Unregistered Leases and the<br />
Putting Plans<br />
into Action<br />
Top Line Case, Recognition of Adult<br />
Guardianship Orders from Outside the<br />
Province, Appointing a Guardian and<br />
Standby Guardianship, Post-Accident<br />
Remedial Measures, Spoliation of<br />
Evidence, Builder’s Liens After the<br />
Shimco Case, Builders Liens, and the<br />
Pipeline Problem; Commercial Tenancy<br />
Act Reform; Dealing with Potential<br />
Undue Influence; Common <strong>Law</strong><br />
Capacity; and Strata Property <strong>Law</strong>,<br />
Phase 1.<br />
Our Notary Foundation<br />
has supported a number<br />
of the <strong>Institute</strong>’s projects<br />
over the years.<br />
The Wills, Estates and Succession<br />
Act will become effective March 31,<br />
2014. The changes are the result<br />
of a collaboration between the<br />
BCLI and the Ministry of Justice.<br />
The new Act will change<br />
significantly the law of Wills and<br />
estates in our province. The highlights<br />
are listed for you on page 47.<br />
Proclamation of the Wills, Estates<br />
and Succession Act has had to await<br />
the reform of the Probate Rules. While<br />
that project has taken longer than<br />
anticipated, it is believed that the new<br />
Probate Rules represent a significant<br />
improvement over the previous rules.<br />
Wayne Braid<br />
BC Notaries have already received<br />
a great deal of training around the<br />
changes in the Wills area. Now that<br />
the implementation date has been<br />
announced, Notaries can concentrate<br />
on drafting checklists and precedents<br />
that will incorporate the changes.<br />
BCLI issued a report following<br />
a review of the Strata Property Act<br />
and have made it known they are<br />
looking to issue a second report,<br />
“Phase 2 of the Strata Property Act.”<br />
BC Notaries will endeavour to work<br />
with BCLI to influence and participate<br />
in some changes to the legislation<br />
to help produce a statute that will<br />
work for <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong>ns and the<br />
way they manage the affairs in their<br />
Strata corporations.<br />
When I was a young man,<br />
I belonged to an organization called<br />
the Jaycees, an organization that<br />
provides leadership training for young<br />
people through the work of a service<br />
club. Before our meetings were called<br />
to order, we would stand together<br />
and recite the Jaycee Creed. Today,<br />
we would call it a mission statement<br />
or mandate.<br />
Part of that creed states,<br />
“We believe that governments should<br />
be of laws rather than of men.”<br />
It is my firm belief that the work<br />
of the BCLI meets the spirit of that<br />
statement and I look forward to their<br />
future success. s<br />
Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013 The Scrivener 7<br />
www.wildmanphotography.com
KEYNOTE<br />
Spotlight on Some<br />
of BC’s <strong>Law</strong> organizations<br />
In the Cover Story interview<br />
that follows, we are<br />
highlighting the work of the<br />
<strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> <strong>Law</strong> <strong>Institute</strong><br />
(BCLI).<br />
Distinguishing among the various public<br />
organizations in BC with legal names<br />
and mandates can be a challenge.<br />
Here is a brief summary of some of the<br />
organizations.<br />
• The Society of Notaries Public<br />
of BC is the governing body for<br />
BC Notaries, governed by the<br />
Notaries Act, BC.<br />
• The Notary Foundation of BC receives<br />
the interest on funds in BC credit<br />
unions, Canadian chartered banks,<br />
and trust companies when they are<br />
held in trust by a BC Notary Public.<br />
The Notary Foundation distributes<br />
the funds in accordance with<br />
its legislated mandate.<br />
• The <strong>Law</strong> Society of BC is the<br />
governing body of BC lawyers who<br />
provide legal services in accordance<br />
with the Legal Professions Act, BC.<br />
• The <strong>Law</strong> Foundation of BC is the<br />
recipient of the interest on funds<br />
held in lawyers’ pooled trust<br />
accounts maintained in financial<br />
institutions. The <strong>Law</strong> Foundation<br />
distributes the funds in accordance<br />
with its legislated mandate.<br />
• The Legal Services Society<br />
(LSS), created by the Legal<br />
Services Society Act, provides<br />
legal information, advice, and<br />
representation services to people<br />
with low incomes.<br />
• The <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> <strong>Law</strong> <strong>Institute</strong><br />
is an independent, charitable<br />
not-for-profit agency that focuses<br />
on legal research, law reform,<br />
and outreach and education<br />
relating to those areas. BCLI is the<br />
independent law reform agency<br />
of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong>.<br />
Why is independent legal research<br />
and law reform work important? Why<br />
do governments need independent<br />
agencies to support new law-making?<br />
The answers are not necessarily<br />
obvious.<br />
Why is independent legal<br />
research and law reform<br />
work important?<br />
First, governments are perennially<br />
challenged to find sufficient financial<br />
resources to carry out needed programs.<br />
Especially in recent years, the urgent<br />
requirements in health and education<br />
have constrained government’s abilities<br />
to focus on longer-term law reform<br />
needs. In addition, governments in<br />
democracies such as Canada are<br />
constantly facing near-term elections,<br />
which mitigates against the longer-term<br />
research and policy development needed<br />
to address complex law reform issues.<br />
As an independent resource,<br />
BCLI provides several important<br />
approaches not available<br />
to government.<br />
1. BCLI provides a nonpartisan,<br />
nonpolitical focus that seeks<br />
good solutions to policy issues<br />
independent of any political lens.<br />
Val Wilson<br />
2. BCLI’s many volunteer experts<br />
contribute legal expertise and<br />
client-based experience not<br />
available to government.<br />
3. When needed, BCLI can undertake<br />
longer, comprehensive reviews<br />
of areas such as strata property<br />
law that merit comprehensive<br />
lengthy review.<br />
BCLI often consults with<br />
governments about future needs.<br />
One such meeting occurred with the<br />
Honourable Alice Wong, Minister of State<br />
for Seniors, Canada, on January 16,<br />
2013. [See photo on page 13.] A key<br />
message to Minister Wong in this session<br />
was that “continuing low interest rates<br />
in Canada are hollowing out the ability<br />
of the private sector to fund meritorious<br />
social programs and services.”<br />
While low interest rates have<br />
served well in recent years to assist<br />
recovery in various economies<br />
including Canada, an unintended<br />
consequence has been to substantially<br />
reduce funds available to institutions<br />
such as the Notary Foundation of BC.<br />
The dramatic decreases in funds<br />
available are negatively impacting<br />
many worthy activities including<br />
legal research and law reform work.<br />
BCLI has encouraged government<br />
to take near-term measures to support<br />
this important sector of the economy<br />
while interest rates remain low.<br />
We trust you will enjoy reading<br />
about the <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Legal<br />
<strong>Institute</strong> and the outstanding efforts<br />
of this organization. s<br />
Thanks to Jim Emmerton, BCLI,<br />
for the above information<br />
8 The Society of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013<br />
www.wildmanphotography.com
UBC Real Estate Division<br />
Professional Development Courses www.realestate.ubc.ca<br />
Today’s successful real estate professional is creative, analytical, adaptable, and committed to lifelong<br />
learning. The Real Estate Division at UBC’s Sauder School of Business offers a series of short online<br />
professional development courses aimed at real estate practitioners’ continuing education needs.<br />
All UBC Real Estate Division continuing professional development (CPD) courses are offered through<br />
distance education in self-study format or as a live online webinar. Completion of a CPD course will earn<br />
you a UBC award of completion. To find out how these courses can also earn you continuing professional<br />
development credits, visit www.realestate.ubc.ca/cpd.<br />
Topics offered include:<br />
• Valuing Green Properties: Residential and Commercial<br />
• Financial Reporting: Real Property Appraisal and IFRS<br />
• Requests for Proposals (RFPs) – Winning Strategies<br />
• Exposure & Marketing Time: Valuation Impacts<br />
• Adjustment Support in the Direct Comparison Approach<br />
• Residential Appraisal Basics / Commercial Appraisal Basics<br />
• Valuation of Property Impairments and Contamination<br />
• Speciality Valuation: Agricultural, Multi-Family, Business<br />
Enterprise, Submerged Land, Hotel, Office, Seniors Facilities,<br />
Machinery and Equipment Valuation<br />
To find out more, visit www.realestate.ubc.ca/cpd<br />
Contact Us<br />
Toll-free: 1.877.775.7733 Email: cpd@realestate.sauder.ubc.ca<br />
Fax: 604.822.1900 Web: www.realestate.ubc.ca<br />
THE UNIVERSITY OF BRITISH COLUMBIA<br />
• Creative Critical Thinking<br />
• Decision Analysis<br />
• Highest and Best Use Analysis<br />
• Appraisal Review<br />
• Lease Analysis<br />
• Urban Infrastructure<br />
• Expropriation Valuation
COVER STORY<br />
THE SCRIVENER: Arthur, you are a generalist. Please tell us<br />
about your career.<br />
ARTHUR: My career has been spent in law reform. I had<br />
25 years with the <strong>Law</strong> Reform Commission of BC. To<br />
survive in that territory, you have to be a generalist. The<br />
work covered a wide spectrum of private law matters, things<br />
like contracts, Wills and estates, and family law where there<br />
are huge issues. They are matters for provincially based law<br />
reform rather than federal topics like criminal law.<br />
One topic that has occupied a lot of my time has been<br />
builder’s lien legislation. For almost 40 years, I’ve had that<br />
on my plate.<br />
COVER STORY<br />
Author<br />
Jim Emmerton, Executive Director, and Arthur Close, QC,<br />
retired founding Executive Director of the <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> <strong>Law</strong> <strong>Institute</strong><br />
<strong>Law</strong> Reform at Work in <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong><br />
In Conversation with Val Wilson<br />
For this interview, Jim Emmerton and Arthur<br />
Close and I met on January 16, 2013, in the<br />
offices of the <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> <strong>Law</strong> <strong>Institute</strong><br />
on the UBC Campus. Their knowledge and focus<br />
on the work of the BCLI are very impressive!<br />
www.wildmanphotography.com<br />
THE SCRIVENER: How is it progressing?<br />
ARTHUR: Well, we did get a new Act in 1997 that moved<br />
things forward, but there’s still lots of room for improvement.<br />
JIM: Time for a major rework, in effect.<br />
ARTHUR: Yes, although there may not be widespread<br />
agreement as to what constitutes an improvement. Many<br />
people think of the construction industry as being monolithic<br />
but there are a lot of competing interests within the<br />
industry. What helps somebody in a certain sector may<br />
not work well for someone in a different sector. It’s really<br />
a complicated legislative matter. Other jurisdictions have<br />
wrestled with trying to find ways to provide some protection<br />
for the subtrades, the material suppliers, and so on.<br />
The Canadian approach is generally to enact builder’s<br />
lien legislation. In Australia, other approaches have been<br />
tried. I’ve had some communication with a barrister in New<br />
South Wales who is conducting an inquiry, trying to come<br />
up with a new scheme that’s not lien-based but based more<br />
on trust law, to try to promote protection. I’ll be interested<br />
to see what he comes up with.<br />
10 The Society of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013
THE SCRIVENER: Excellent. Did you litigate in your earlier<br />
career?<br />
ARTHUR: I practised for only 2 years and did a bit<br />
of court work during that time. It was interesting. I got the<br />
experience but I can’t say my heart was in it. When the<br />
opportunity came to get out of practice and move to the<br />
newly created BC <strong>Law</strong> Reform Commission, I jumped at it.<br />
<strong>Law</strong> reform has been my focus ever since.<br />
THE SCRIVENER: Let’s talk about you, Jim.<br />
JIM: I graduated from the University of Western Ontario<br />
<strong>Law</strong> School and worked for 20 years with John Labatt<br />
as in-house counsel, treasurer, and general counsel—about<br />
10 years in London and 10 in Toronto. In 1997, I joined<br />
Methanex in Vancouver, first as VP General Counsel and<br />
later as SVP Corporate Development.<br />
THE SCRIVENER: Did you litigate?<br />
JIM: I did a small amount of litigation in Small Claims<br />
Court when I was articling as well as assisting to prepare<br />
cases for Provincial Criminal, County, and Supreme Courts.<br />
Litigation wasn’t one of my great loves. Much time is spent<br />
in case preparation—drafting forms, pleadings, and so on.<br />
The court time you see on TV is about 1 percent of what<br />
litigation lawyers actually do.<br />
Like the Phoenix, the current BC <strong>Law</strong> <strong>Institute</strong><br />
rose from the <strong>Law</strong> Reform Commission.<br />
THE SCRIVENER: Like the Phoenix, the current BC <strong>Law</strong><br />
<strong>Institute</strong> rose from the former BC <strong>Law</strong> Reform Commission.<br />
Why did the Commission close?<br />
ARTHUR: Although it always saw itself as being independent<br />
in the way it operated, the <strong>Law</strong> Reform Commission<br />
was a government program with about 80 percent of its<br />
funding coming from the Ministry of Attorney General.<br />
For reasons best known to the government of the day,<br />
a decision was made late in 1996 that they were no longer<br />
going to fund it. I was Chair at the time and got the news<br />
that beyond March 31 in 1997, there would be no <strong>Law</strong><br />
Reform Commission.<br />
There were hints that if outside funding could be found<br />
to replace the government’s support, it might continue.<br />
It was my assessment that that wasn’t in the cards. It would<br />
have called for massive outside funding. Those who might<br />
provide such funding would want an entity much more<br />
independent of government and perhaps with a broader<br />
focus than the <strong>Law</strong> Reform Commission was able to take.<br />
THE SCRIVENER: What did you do?<br />
ARTHUR: We consulted with the <strong>Law</strong> Foundation because<br />
it had provided close to 20 percent of the Commission’s<br />
operational funding. We essentially wanted to see if<br />
the proposed <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> <strong>Law</strong> <strong>Institute</strong> could step<br />
into the shoes of the <strong>Law</strong> Reform Commission to at least<br />
assume that support as seed money.<br />
Sidebar BCLI OVERVIEW overview<br />
The <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> <strong>Law</strong> <strong>Institute</strong> (BCLI) is an<br />
independent, professional, nonpolitical law reform<br />
agency—effectively the law reform agency of BC.<br />
The Canadian Centre for Elder <strong>Law</strong> (CCEL), a division<br />
of BCLI, also carries out scholarly research, writing, and<br />
analysis for law reform that is focused on older adults<br />
in Canada. We do an extensive amount of educational<br />
work in both areas. Specific activities include the<br />
following.<br />
• Issue Identification: Initially investigating social and<br />
legal issues through formal and informal discussions<br />
and processes to determine law reform needs<br />
• Defining a <strong>Law</strong> Reform Project: Describing,<br />
defining, prioritizing law reform issues as potential<br />
projects for legal research and law reform work<br />
• Creating a Plan: Developing legal research<br />
and law reform project plans, including<br />
funding plans for projects<br />
• Project Approvals: Obtaining approvals<br />
and funding for projects<br />
• Research, Writing, and Consultation: Carrying out the<br />
legal research, analysis, writing, and consultation<br />
for projects<br />
• Knowledge Mobilization: Carrying out knowledge<br />
mobilization activities to obtain feedback<br />
about issues, raise awareness of issues, and<br />
develop discussion and consensus relating<br />
to recommendations<br />
• Ongoing Outreach and Education: Ongoing outreach<br />
and educational activities to support understanding<br />
of law reform needs and maintain and develop key<br />
stakeholder relationships<br />
The effective successor of the <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong><br />
<strong>Law</strong> Reform Commission, BCLI retains various<br />
reports and materials of the former Commission.<br />
The BCLI Board is composed of 16 members<br />
who meet about 10 times a year.<br />
<strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> <strong>Law</strong> <strong>Institute</strong><br />
Strong, Dedicated Volunteer Board 2013<br />
R. C. Tino Di Bella, Chair<br />
Prof. Joost Blom, QC<br />
mimi Chen<br />
Jan Christiansen<br />
Richard Evans, Notary Public<br />
margaret Hall<br />
Prof. Doug Harris<br />
Prof. Robert Howell<br />
Fiona Hunter<br />
Hon. Ken mackenzie, QC<br />
Lisa Peters<br />
geoff Plant, QC<br />
D. Peter Ramsay, QC<br />
Andrea Rolls<br />
Stanley Rule<br />
Thomas Spraggs<br />
Arthur Close, QC, emeritus<br />
greg Steele, QC, emeritus<br />
Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013 The Scrivener 11
This picture was taken in April 1997 at the first formal meeting of the initial members<br />
of the BC <strong>Law</strong> <strong>Institute</strong>, held to develop the program and plan the future course<br />
and activities of the <strong>Institute</strong>. The venue was the premises<br />
of the Public Legal Education Society (People’s <strong>Law</strong> School).<br />
From left: Tom Anderson (founding member); Dr. A. J. McClean (UBC nominee);<br />
Hon. Martin Taylor (founding member); Dean Jamie Cassels (UVic nominee);<br />
Sholto Hebenton (<strong>Law</strong> Society nominee); Ann McLean (CBA nominee);<br />
Greg Steele (founding member); Gordon Turriff (founding member);<br />
Arthur Close (founding member); Prof. James MacIntyre (<strong>Law</strong> Society nominee)<br />
Missing: Douglas Robinson (CBA nominee)<br />
At the date of the photo, no Attorney General nominees had yet been designated.<br />
We also received a start-up grant<br />
of $10,000 from the Canadian Bar<br />
Association, which also provided<br />
some sustaining funding for about<br />
5 years, until they ran into their own<br />
set of financial problems with the<br />
loss of universal memberships and<br />
everything that went with it.<br />
THE SCRIVENER: Where did the BC <strong>Law</strong><br />
<strong>Institute</strong> set up shop?<br />
ARTHUR: The <strong>Law</strong> Society had a bit<br />
of spare office space in an older<br />
structure right next to the <strong>Law</strong> Society<br />
building that housed the professional<br />
legal training program. Three small<br />
offices weren’t being used. They said,<br />
“If you can run a law reform body out<br />
of there, then welcome to it.” So we<br />
did have a roof over our heads. But I’m<br />
getting a bit ahead of the story.<br />
Let’s talk about the decision<br />
to start the <strong>Institute</strong>. I consulted<br />
with a number of people. Essentially,<br />
there were five of us who decided,<br />
in December of 1996, to press ahead<br />
with the incorporation of the <strong>Institute</strong>.<br />
This was a leap of faith on our part<br />
Essentially, there were<br />
five of us who decided,<br />
in December of 1996, to press<br />
ahead with the incorporation<br />
of the <strong>Institute</strong>.<br />
since there was really no promise<br />
of financial support at the time.<br />
THE SCRIVENER: Who were the other<br />
four, Arthur, in addition to you?<br />
ARTHUR: Greg Steele, QC, was one<br />
of the founding members and the<br />
first Chair of the <strong>Institute</strong> for a period<br />
of 8 years. He is now an emeritus<br />
member, as am I.<br />
Mr. Justice Martin Taylor was<br />
a great supporter of law reform.<br />
Gordon Turriff, QC, was another<br />
strong supporter of law reform. He<br />
later became President of the <strong>Law</strong><br />
Society matters and about 3 years<br />
ago, took on the independence of the<br />
legal profession as his personal cause.<br />
Tom Anderson, QC, had been<br />
a senior staff lawyer and a member<br />
of the <strong>Law</strong> Reform Commission.<br />
JIM: Tom continued on the <strong>Institute</strong>’s<br />
Board for a number of years. An expert<br />
in pension law, he is currently doing<br />
a project for the BC <strong>Law</strong> <strong>Institute</strong><br />
relating to that.<br />
ARTHUR: Tom’s particular<br />
area of expertise is the division<br />
of pensions on marriage breakdown.<br />
That came out of a major report by the<br />
<strong>Law</strong> Reform Commission. He was the<br />
principal author of the report and<br />
architect of the current scheme. The<br />
new Family <strong>Law</strong> Act reflects some<br />
fine-tuning from Tom. He continues<br />
to provide guidance to people and<br />
organizations in relation to pension<br />
division issues. We incorporated the<br />
<strong>Law</strong> <strong>Institute</strong> in January 1997. That<br />
followed a debate about the structure<br />
and membership framework it should<br />
have. We moved into the space the<br />
<strong>Law</strong> Society provided and it served us<br />
well for the first 2 years.<br />
Our extensive library—a very<br />
substantial one inherited from the <strong>Law</strong><br />
Reform Commission—was essentially<br />
put in storage and eventually had to be<br />
disposed of when the <strong>Institute</strong> moved<br />
here to UBC. The university has its own<br />
vast library resources. There was very<br />
little point in maintaining a general<br />
library of our own. Our library now<br />
focuses on law reform material.<br />
THE SCRIVENER: I understand the<br />
Ontario <strong>Law</strong> Reform Commission<br />
also closed in the late ‘90s. Has it<br />
resurfaced as another legal entity?<br />
ARTHUR: It has, but it took almost<br />
10 years to do it. Ontario was without<br />
any kind of law reform body<br />
for a number of years. What finally<br />
emerged was a body called the <strong>Law</strong><br />
Commission of Ontario, created at<br />
the initiative of a group of Ontario law<br />
schools.<br />
JIM: It started officially in 2007.<br />
ARTHUR: Yes. The BC <strong>Law</strong> <strong>Institute</strong><br />
is almost 10 years older.<br />
THE SCRIVENER: Please tell us about<br />
your work with elder law and the launch<br />
of the Canadian Centre for Elder <strong>Law</strong><br />
(CCEL).<br />
12 The Society of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013
JIM: The BC <strong>Law</strong> <strong>Institute</strong>’s general<br />
law focus is very much focused on<br />
legal research and law reform with<br />
less outreach and education; the<br />
work on elder law is much more<br />
community- and outreach-directed,<br />
looking to produce outcomes that<br />
don’t necessarily require legislation<br />
or similar official action.<br />
ARTHUR: One of the factors that<br />
led to our creation of the Canadian<br />
Centre for Elder <strong>Law</strong> was our work<br />
on a couple of small projects with<br />
issues of particular concern to seniors.<br />
That attracted a lot of attention from<br />
outside groups concerned with age and<br />
aging. They were very glad to find an<br />
entity that brought a legal perspective<br />
to the issues that concerned them.<br />
After we finished those small<br />
projects, which we saw as another<br />
kind of law reform exercise, requests<br />
came in for our people to speak<br />
to their groups. There were a couple<br />
of invitations for our people to join the<br />
Boards of some of the groups and so<br />
on. It became clear there was a need<br />
out there in the community for some<br />
kind of body that would provide a focal<br />
point for legal issues of concern to the<br />
elderly and senior citizens.<br />
That started us thinking.<br />
We looked at what was happening<br />
elsewhere in Canada. To our<br />
astonishment, no law school<br />
in Canada had established any kind<br />
of internal organization with a focus<br />
on what we were now beginning to call<br />
“elder law.” We thought why not<br />
integrate that into our work?<br />
It provided an outlet for outreach<br />
and work that was not focused so<br />
much on legislative reform. That<br />
was one of the concerns that came up<br />
when we were transitioning from <strong>Law</strong><br />
Reform Commission to the BC <strong>Law</strong><br />
<strong>Institute</strong>—those providing financial<br />
support wanted something more<br />
than legislative law reform. Carving<br />
out a speciality area, like elder law,<br />
provided an outlet to address those<br />
concerns.<br />
It became clear there<br />
was a need out there in the<br />
community for some kind<br />
of body that would provide<br />
a focal point for legal issues<br />
of concern to the elderly and<br />
senior citizens.<br />
THE SCRIVENER: And it was so<br />
timely. About a thousand individuals<br />
in Canada are turning 60 each day.<br />
JIM: It’s a growing issue.<br />
ARTHUR: I’m astonished that we<br />
managed to be there first, particularly<br />
being as young an organization as we<br />
were at the time. July will see the 10th anniversary of our resolution to create<br />
the Canadian Centre for Elder <strong>Law</strong>.<br />
Although it is located in our offices,<br />
we endeavour to have a national focus.<br />
JIM: It’s a bit of an anomaly that<br />
BCLI is primarily a provincial law<br />
reform body with a division that<br />
has a national focus.<br />
THE SCRIVENER: Are other provinces<br />
following the BCLI?<br />
JIM: To some extent, yes. The<br />
<strong>Law</strong> Commission of Ontario<br />
has a significant focus on elder law<br />
issues. Their previous law reform body<br />
had done some work that affected<br />
older adults but they don’t have the<br />
focus we do. At this point, about half<br />
our work is on the elder law side.<br />
THE SCRIVENER: Please tell us<br />
more about your relationship with<br />
government.<br />
JIM: We have extensive relationships<br />
with both the federal and provincial<br />
governments. I was one of about<br />
15 people who met this morning<br />
with Alice Wong, Minister of State<br />
for Seniors in the federal government.<br />
She wanted to get a group of people<br />
together to make suggestions about<br />
priorities and budget issues for the<br />
federal government.<br />
We do not lobby. We are explicitly<br />
nonpartisan and nonpolitical. When<br />
asked any legal research or law reform<br />
question, the answer will emerge<br />
from the research and analysis, not<br />
Minister of State for Seniors group with Alice Wong<br />
Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013 The Scrivener 13
otherwise. That approach has served<br />
us well and we will continue<br />
to work to maintain a reputation<br />
as a professional, objective,<br />
nonpartisan, and nonpolitical agency.<br />
THE SCRIVENER: What success are you<br />
enjoying in the area of law reform?<br />
ARTHUR: We do have some<br />
major successes. Our work on Wills<br />
and succession and the law reform<br />
package that emerged from it<br />
was a huge project for us. Government<br />
moved quickly to implement it.<br />
It was a good learning exercise<br />
in many ways. That project is probably<br />
our largest to date. We mobilized the<br />
greatest number of lawyer volunteers.<br />
I think inside every lawyer is a law<br />
reformer trying to get out. The key is<br />
to provide an outlet for them.<br />
JIM: That’s probably true of Notaries,<br />
too.<br />
LAUGHTER<br />
ARTHUR: The secret is in providing<br />
volunteers with adequate support.<br />
I don’t know how many times I’ve seen<br />
volunteer committees struck by various<br />
bodies. The volunteers are busy people<br />
who don’t have the necessary support<br />
and so the initiative falls apart and<br />
goes nowhere.<br />
JIM: Our strategy, which we developed<br />
from the beginning, has been to use<br />
as much volunteer input as we can,<br />
whether in the form of a project<br />
committee or advisory panels, and<br />
to make sure they’re well supported<br />
by our staff. Our staff members<br />
carry out the legal research and<br />
analysis, take the options to our<br />
committees, then follow up according<br />
to the committee’s decisions<br />
to translate them into documents<br />
such as consultation papers, study<br />
papers, and final law reform reports.<br />
Volunteers are recruited to provide<br />
their wisdom, experience, and advice.<br />
Unlike Arthur, who is steeped<br />
in law reform, I know virtually nothing<br />
about law reform. I know a little bit<br />
about organization and management<br />
and project development and<br />
fundraising and spend most of my<br />
time doing those things.<br />
THE SCRIVENER: Please tell us about the<br />
Uniform <strong>Law</strong> Conference of Canada.<br />
ARTHUR: The Uniform <strong>Law</strong> Conference<br />
of Canada has been around for over<br />
90 years. It was modelled on a similar<br />
American body. Its mandate is the<br />
development of model legislation to be<br />
adopted in the provinces and territories.<br />
Its delegates tend to be representatives<br />
of governments, along with a significant<br />
number of law reformers and lawyers<br />
in private practice. The Conference<br />
has carried out a number of projects<br />
over the years that have impacted<br />
in BC. For example, our Limitation Act<br />
that has just been passed was basically<br />
modelled on the uniform Limitation Act<br />
promulgated about 6 years ago.<br />
Part of the methodology<br />
we developed for our<br />
conventional law reform<br />
projects involves in-house<br />
legislative drafting. The final<br />
product is a fully drafted Act.<br />
A lot of BC legislation has its roots<br />
in uniform laws and there has been<br />
a cross-fertilization. For example,<br />
after the <strong>Institute</strong> finalized its report<br />
recommending a new Trustee Act<br />
for <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong>, it was considered<br />
by a group called STEP—the<br />
Society of Estate Trust and Estate<br />
Practitioners. STEP liked the report<br />
and recommendations very much<br />
and recommended that they serve<br />
as a model for new Trustee Act<br />
legislation across the country.<br />
STEP approached the Uniform<br />
<strong>Law</strong> Conference and in essence said,<br />
“Can you people devise a uniform<br />
Trustee Act that is based on the work<br />
of the BC <strong>Law</strong> <strong>Institute</strong>?”<br />
The Uniform <strong>Law</strong> Conference<br />
of Canada embraced that suggestion<br />
and created an excellent working group<br />
that included Donovan Waters, Dean<br />
of Trust <strong>Law</strong> Academics in Canada.<br />
We also had significant buy-in from the<br />
province because the working group<br />
was chaired by a lawyer attached<br />
to the Ministry of Attorney General<br />
and included one of its legislative<br />
drafters. After 3 years of work by the<br />
Conference, a uniform Trustee Act<br />
was finalized in August 2012. We hope<br />
to see action on it soon.<br />
For the BC <strong>Law</strong> <strong>Institute</strong>, that<br />
was a major project, 1 of the first<br />
3 projects we initiated in 1997. The<br />
BCLI project committee worked on<br />
it for about 8 years, which was much<br />
longer than it should have taken.<br />
That timeline simply reflects the kind<br />
of limited resources we had. And it’s<br />
a credit to the people who were part<br />
of the project committee . . . that<br />
they stuck with it that long to bring<br />
it to its final form. The quality of the<br />
final product commended itself<br />
to nationwide adoption.<br />
THE SCRIVENER: That’s outstanding!<br />
JIM: Our Senior Staff <strong>Law</strong>yer Greg<br />
Blue, QC, has spent much of his<br />
professional life on Trustee Act reform,<br />
first in carrying out initial research<br />
on this topic as part of the BCLRC<br />
legal staff. The work-in-progress then<br />
became the starting point for the<br />
<strong>Institute</strong>’s Trustee Act project, which<br />
he carried forward. It was followed<br />
by participation in the ULCC project<br />
to develop the uniform Act. Greg is<br />
expected to be an advisor in relation<br />
to implementation<br />
ARTHUR: Part of the methodology<br />
we developed for our conventional<br />
law reform projects involves in-house<br />
legislative drafting. The final product<br />
is a fully drafted Act. That is normally<br />
done by one of our staff lawyers,<br />
although occasionally we’ll get<br />
help from the professional drafters<br />
in Victoria. Our reports usually provide<br />
a lengthy introduction that sets the<br />
stage. That is followed by a sectionby-section<br />
commentary on the draft<br />
Act that goes into detail. We’ve found<br />
that provides the most acceptable way<br />
to present law reform.<br />
THE SCRIVENER: How many staff<br />
lawyers do you have?<br />
JIM: Four here. We also retain<br />
Laura Tamblyn Watts,<br />
who was a staff lawyer<br />
here and now lives<br />
in Toronto. She assists<br />
us part-time while she is<br />
working on her PhD at<br />
the University of Toronto.<br />
14 The Society of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013
THE SCRIVENER: Laura’s fine article<br />
about your Samoa project follows this<br />
interview.<br />
JIM: Yes. Back in 2008, we were<br />
contacted by a person who had<br />
been appointed as the Executive<br />
Director of the Samoa <strong>Law</strong> Reform<br />
Commission. Leilani Tuala-Warren had<br />
been hired by the Attorney General<br />
of Samoa to put together a law reform<br />
commission. She was a lawyer but had<br />
no idea how to do that. She asked if<br />
we could help out, so we did.<br />
Leilani<br />
Tuala-Warren<br />
We invited Leilani<br />
over here. She stayed<br />
with us for a few weeks<br />
and observed work<br />
on our projects and<br />
attended committee<br />
meetings to get an<br />
understanding of what<br />
was needed. She<br />
showed us the program the Attorney<br />
General in Samoa had asked her<br />
to accomplish. We said to her,<br />
“Leilani, that would be about 10 years<br />
of work for a law reform body like<br />
ours.” The first thing was to adjust the<br />
expectation for what could be done,<br />
then get it started.<br />
Samoa is a long way from<br />
anywhere. Leilani was the only staff<br />
person on the project. We shipped<br />
some legal texts to her. It’s been<br />
a great success. Now they are<br />
established as a small <strong>Law</strong> Reform<br />
Commission and they are very grateful<br />
for our help and support.<br />
THE SCRIVENER: That is an<br />
accomplishment! Please tell us about<br />
your Great Debate event and your other<br />
projects.<br />
JIM: In October 2012, we hosted<br />
the 5th GREATdebate, co-sponsored<br />
by Boughton <strong>Law</strong> in Vancouver. The<br />
debate topic was that HST should be<br />
continued in BC. We will likely host<br />
another GREATdebate in 2013.<br />
We’ve also held several elder law<br />
conferences. The first was in 2005.<br />
We had a great conference again this<br />
year in terms of content and speakers.<br />
One of our challenges is that in<br />
recent years there just isn’t funding<br />
for people to attend many conferences<br />
so they’re difficult to run these days,<br />
from a financial point of view.<br />
BCLI has produced significant<br />
results, having published about 20<br />
reports in the last 5 or 6 years.<br />
Currently, we have about 10 active<br />
funded projects.<br />
We’ve just completed and released<br />
the Report on Strata Property:<br />
Phase One that was looking at what<br />
major issues might be reviewed<br />
in a Strata Property: Phase Two<br />
project.<br />
We get ideas from<br />
government. We get<br />
ideas from funding<br />
bodies. We get ideas from<br />
BC Notaries about projects.<br />
THE SCRIVENER: Do groups come to you<br />
with ideas for projects?<br />
JIM: We get ideas from everywhere.<br />
The program committee of the Board<br />
meets a couple of times a year.<br />
Arthur is one of the members on the<br />
committee. We have an ongoing list<br />
of topics that we are considering,<br />
including Builder’s Liens, as Arthur<br />
mentioned. That topic is becoming<br />
more important again.<br />
We get ideas from government.<br />
We get ideas from funding bodies.<br />
We get ideas from BC Notaries<br />
about projects. The idea for the<br />
Strata Property project came from<br />
Wayne Braid, CEO and Secretary<br />
of the BC Notaries.<br />
And we are always asking members<br />
of the public, lawyers in particular,<br />
what they think and the areas where<br />
they feel reform is needed.<br />
We’re working on a Technology<br />
project about accessibility, remoteness,<br />
and evidence. It’s all about looking<br />
at the technologies that are available<br />
in various courts and tribunals and the<br />
processes that can assist people who<br />
need them. We also need to advise<br />
legal professionals about the technology<br />
that is available out there.<br />
Another project is examining the<br />
Test of Mental Capacity. There are<br />
different tests for capacity under<br />
common law. The test is different<br />
if you want to get married than if you<br />
want to become separated or you<br />
wish to make a Will. This project is<br />
looking at the various common law<br />
tests as opposed to statutory tests and<br />
seeing if it makes sense to standardize<br />
them in some way.<br />
ARTHUR: There is also a big Assisted<br />
Living project. Jim is Chair of that<br />
committee.<br />
JIM: Yes. Assisted Living is a project<br />
to look at the assisted living regime<br />
in <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong>. It’s been<br />
going on for 3 years; we have had<br />
30 committee meetings. There’s<br />
a consultation paper out right now.<br />
We’re looking for comment on the<br />
recommendations.<br />
The Older Women’s Dialogue<br />
project is another project of CCEL.<br />
It’s a project to engage, in the Lower<br />
Mainland, communities of older<br />
women to get them to identify issues<br />
that may translate into legal issues.<br />
People don’t necessarily identify their<br />
problems as legal problems. The<br />
purpose is to identify legal problems<br />
that are unique to older women.<br />
THE SCRIVENER: You also have<br />
a project around a Franchise Act.<br />
JIM: Yes. BC has no Franchise Act.<br />
Many people are surprised when they<br />
hear that because we have thousands<br />
of franchisees across the province. The<br />
Uniform <strong>Law</strong> Conference developed<br />
a uniform Franchise Act. Arthur?<br />
ARTHUR: It was about 5 years ago<br />
and it was a good project. The leading<br />
lawyers advising various participants<br />
in the franchising industry came to the<br />
table to help develop this Act. The<br />
previous 20 years had been a rocky<br />
road for franchise legislation. The first<br />
off the mark was Alberta that came up<br />
with something that looked more like<br />
a Securities Act. It was a dismal failure,<br />
which discouraged lawmakers in other<br />
provinces.<br />
Then Ontario introduced<br />
a different model that won acceptance<br />
in other parts of the country. The<br />
Ontario approach was essentially<br />
picked up by the Uniform <strong>Law</strong><br />
Conference.<br />
Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013 The Scrivener 15
JIM: Yes, with some changes. And now<br />
PEI and Manitoba have adopted it.<br />
We’re now in the process of developing<br />
a draft Act for BC based on the<br />
uniform Act.<br />
ARTHUR: I might describe the interplay<br />
between the Uniform <strong>Law</strong> Conference<br />
and the work of the <strong>Institute</strong>.<br />
Some kinds of uniform legislation,<br />
of necessity, require kind of a one-sizefits-all<br />
approach to make it applicable<br />
nationally. It will involve a variety<br />
of compromises, options, or openended<br />
provisions. When adoption<br />
in a particular province is considered,<br />
it requires very close scrutiny to make<br />
sure appropriate choices are made and<br />
that it interfaces properly with other<br />
provincial legislation. We must ensure<br />
there are no hidden bumps in the road<br />
that you might encounter if we simply<br />
adopted it without change. The uniform<br />
Franchise Act falls into that category<br />
as does the uniform Liens Act that<br />
would replace two BC Acts: Repairers<br />
Lien Act and the Warehouse Lien Act.<br />
When useful legislation like the<br />
uniform Liens Act emerges, we look<br />
at it, see what is needed to make it<br />
work in BC, and issue a report saying,<br />
“Let’s adopt it and here are the kinds<br />
of changes that need to be made<br />
to make it is a good fit with BC law.”<br />
JIM: We’re also working to review<br />
an aspect of the Negligence Act.<br />
A minor, obscure part is contribution<br />
after settlement. That concerns the<br />
situation where you have several<br />
defendants and one person wants<br />
to settle. Let’s say you’re a plaintiff.<br />
You’re suing Arthur and me. You<br />
agree with me that if I pay $20,000,<br />
that will be fine and I will have no<br />
further liability to you. When the<br />
case is finally decided by the judge,<br />
the judge can say, “Well, hold on<br />
a minute. The total amount of the<br />
claim was $200,000 and I think that<br />
you, Emmerton, should have paid<br />
$40,000.”<br />
Over the years,<br />
so many good people<br />
and volunteers have been<br />
involved in the project.<br />
It’s difficult to keep track.<br />
ARTHUR: Understand that a judge<br />
would not say directly that Emmerton<br />
must pay more. The ordinary<br />
rule of liability is that I, the other<br />
defendant, would have to pay the<br />
extra amount that Emmerton should<br />
have paid. I might or might not have<br />
an action to pursue Emmerton for that<br />
extra amount.<br />
JIM: That is where the law is unclear,<br />
which is why we’re doing the project.<br />
The real deterrent to settlement is<br />
where there are multiple defendants.<br />
If I don’t know what the law is, I may<br />
decide not to settle with you because<br />
I don’t know whether that’s the end<br />
of the legal road.<br />
Artist’s rendering of Allard Hall,<br />
Canada’s first new purpose-built university law school building in 30 years<br />
JIM: Another initiative we are working<br />
on relates to the BC probate rules.<br />
We did a project to recommend<br />
updating the Probate Rules, which is<br />
a necessary part of the reforms of the<br />
new Wills, Estates and Succession<br />
Act. We’ve completed that project<br />
and issued the report. New rules<br />
need to be created; we’ve submitted<br />
appropriate recommendations<br />
THE SCRIVENER: I understand<br />
BC Notaries have been actively<br />
involved in your projects.<br />
JIM: Absolutely. Nanaimo Notary Rick<br />
Evans was on the Succession project.<br />
Sidney Notaries Susan Davis Mercer<br />
and Laurie Salvador have been on at<br />
least two of the project committees,<br />
including the Undue Influence project<br />
and on subcommittees. Laurie did<br />
other work with Margaret Hall and<br />
Dr. Martha Donnelly.<br />
THE SCRIVENER: Laurie’s practice<br />
focuses on Wills and personal<br />
planning. Because of her expertise and<br />
experience, she is often interviewed<br />
and quoted in the media.<br />
ARTHUR: Over the years, so many<br />
good people and volunteers have been<br />
involved in the project. It’s difficult<br />
to keep track.<br />
I’d like to mention something<br />
that has been a trend over the<br />
years—bringing a person from the<br />
provincial government on side,<br />
as an observer or a member of our<br />
project committees. That implies<br />
a certain buy-in with the government<br />
and the officials. More than that, it<br />
means someone on the government<br />
side has a good knowledge of what<br />
the project is about. That was so<br />
important in carrying forward the<br />
Wills, Estate, and Succession project.<br />
One of the people from the policy<br />
branch of the Ministry of Attorney<br />
General sat in on our meetings<br />
for a solid 2 years. When the time<br />
came to implement, he knew what had<br />
happened and he knew the answers<br />
to most of the questions raised.<br />
I’m talking about the involvement<br />
of someone from a ministry that is<br />
part of a project for many years—an<br />
observer, simply—on the government<br />
side, who is really knowledgeable<br />
16 The Society of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013
about how things were developed. That<br />
person can answer the hard questions<br />
that may concern Government and act<br />
as a go-to person about the project.<br />
JIM: We try to do that on all our general<br />
projects—have someone from a relevant<br />
ministry. In some cases, it will be the<br />
Ministry of Justice. For example, in our<br />
project on Strata Property <strong>Law</strong>, we have<br />
a person from the ministry responsible<br />
for housing.<br />
We have lots of ongoing ideas<br />
for legal research, law reform and<br />
outreach, and education projects in the<br />
areas of general law and elder law.<br />
One important topic is something<br />
I call “the future of law”—where is the<br />
legal system going? How should legal<br />
professionals be regulated? That’s<br />
a question Notaries and lawyers are<br />
asking. Currently, in BC, a joint task<br />
force is addressing it.<br />
THE SCRIVENER: How is technology<br />
affecting the law?<br />
JIM: Advances in technologies in the<br />
last few years have dramatically<br />
We have lots of ongoing<br />
ideas for legal research,<br />
law reform and outreach,<br />
and education projects…<br />
changed the way legal information can<br />
be provided and delivered and gives<br />
rise to questions about regulation and<br />
how legal information and services will<br />
be provided in future. People today<br />
are more sophisticated because of the<br />
Internet. All kinds of legal information<br />
is available online, yet people really<br />
don’t know if it’s accurate. And you<br />
can hire a professional online from<br />
New Zealand or India or Ontario<br />
to provide you with legal research work<br />
but that advisor might not know the<br />
law in your specific jurisdiction.<br />
ARTHUR: The list of things that<br />
are changing goes on. <strong>Law</strong>yers<br />
or Notaries may be asked to help<br />
a self-represented litigant who wants<br />
a professional to look at a legal<br />
document and offer an opinion.<br />
THE BEST ADVICE YOU CAN GIVE<br />
IS TO HELP YOUR CLIENTS GIVE WISELY.<br />
There is the whole question<br />
of interdisciplinary partnerships<br />
or a conglomeration of lawyers,<br />
Notaries, accountants, and<br />
other disciplines where there is<br />
a certain synergy by coming together<br />
to help mutual clients.<br />
How do we regulate those<br />
partnerships? To what extent should<br />
they be regulated? There will be<br />
concerns about, say, the lawyers’<br />
insurance funds and concerns about<br />
insuring negligence on the part<br />
of the accountant who is part of the<br />
partnership. There will be myriad<br />
issues like that.<br />
JIM: Regulation is an area where much<br />
legal research work will be needed.<br />
The BC <strong>Law</strong> <strong>Institute</strong> is an excellent<br />
organization to do some of that<br />
research because we have worked on<br />
a multidisciplinary basis with lawyers<br />
and Notaries and with the medical<br />
profession and social organizations<br />
and so forth.<br />
We’re headed into a whole new<br />
world in the legal system! s<br />
The Victoria Foundation is one of the oldest community foundations in Canada.<br />
With total assets of over $180 million we grant over $10 million annually to worthy<br />
causes. Recommending the Victoria Foundation as the recipient of legacy gifts<br />
offers your clients maximum flexibility to contribute to causes they care about.<br />
Learn more about how to connect people who care with causes that matter.<br />
Call Sara Neely at 250.381.5532 or email sneely@victoriafoundation.bc.ca www.victoriafoundation.bc.ca<br />
VICFO_7363_VF098.indd 1 12-06-18 2:44 PM<br />
Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013 The Scrivener 17
fEaTURE<br />
Establishing the<br />
Samoa <strong>Law</strong> Reform<br />
Commission<br />
Talofa!<br />
(Hello and Welcome!)<br />
In 2008, the newly appointed<br />
Attorney general of Samoa,<br />
ming C. Leung Wai, had<br />
a dream: To establish a brand<br />
new law reform commission<br />
for his country—something<br />
that had never existed<br />
in Samoa before.<br />
Samoa, like so many smaller<br />
nations in the Pacific, had inherited<br />
its laws from a mix of previous<br />
influencer or colonial nations and<br />
the books were badly out of date.<br />
Additionally, Samoa’s Attorney General<br />
had sights firmly set on ensuring<br />
that Samoa was at the cutting edge<br />
of international standards established<br />
in human rights law and international<br />
conventions. Having appropriate and<br />
up-to-date laws can be a requirement<br />
of critical international aid funding.<br />
It was clear to Attorney General<br />
Leung that Samoa had a great deal<br />
of work to do to develop a system<br />
of up-to-date modern laws. The laws<br />
must also continue to reflect or, when<br />
appropriate, incorporate into legislation<br />
the rich cultural heritage and<br />
indigenous customs of Samoa.<br />
With minimal financial<br />
resources and essentially<br />
no legal research and<br />
law reform expertise<br />
within Samoa itself, Attorney<br />
General Leung faced<br />
a daunting challenge.<br />
Laura Tamblyn Watts<br />
With minimal financial<br />
resources and essentially no legal<br />
research and law reform expertise<br />
within Samoa itself, Attorney General<br />
Leung faced a daunting challenge.<br />
Notwithstanding the almost impossible<br />
nature of the task, the Honourable<br />
Mr. Leung set out to recruit a law<br />
reform leader for a new Samoa <strong>Law</strong><br />
Reform Commission (SLRC). He<br />
persuaded local barrister and solicitor<br />
Ms. Leilani Tuala-Warren, a brilliant,<br />
personable, well-known lawyer,<br />
with the task to establish the SLRC<br />
and within a short time provide<br />
recommendations for new legislation<br />
across a broad front, including both<br />
criminal and civil laws. No small task<br />
indeed!<br />
About the same time, the <strong>British</strong><br />
<strong>Columbia</strong> <strong>Law</strong> <strong>Institute</strong> (BCLI)<br />
completed its first Strategic Plan<br />
including a statement of values that<br />
included “respect for people, and<br />
valuing—justice, the rule of law,<br />
independent law reform, continuous<br />
improvement, diversity, and<br />
community engagement.” Community<br />
engagement includes continuously<br />
seeking ways to expand the circle<br />
of stakeholders and collaborators<br />
and seek and provide mutual support<br />
where practical.<br />
Ms. Leilani Tuala-Warren<br />
©iStockphoto.com/Colonel<br />
18 The Society of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013
In September 2008, Jim<br />
Emmerton, BCLI’s Executive Director,<br />
and Laura Tamblyn Watts, then<br />
National Director of the Canadian<br />
Centre for Elder <strong>Law</strong>, met Ms. Tuala-<br />
Warren in Vanuatu at the Australian<br />
<strong>Law</strong> Reform Agencies Conference.<br />
During discussions it became<br />
evident that Ms. Tuala-Warren,<br />
the newly appointed Executive<br />
Director of the SLRC, had a significant<br />
need for assistance to successfully<br />
establish the new SLRC. The SLRC<br />
had a small office supplied by the<br />
Ministry in Samoa but no staff<br />
except for Ms. Tuala-Warren, no<br />
research materials of any kind, and<br />
no experience with developing and<br />
carrying out a law reform project—<br />
not to mention a complete and<br />
comprehensive law reform program.<br />
BCLI is a nonprofit organization<br />
committed to working collaboratively<br />
and creatively to support law reform<br />
efforts in Canada and around the<br />
world. The beginnings of a long-term<br />
and mutually beneficial relationship<br />
were then struck.<br />
BCLI was able to provide<br />
assistance for Ms. Tuala-Warren<br />
to come to Canada and visit BCLI.<br />
Ms. Tuala-Warren was hosted<br />
in Vancouver by staff and was<br />
wholeheartedly welcomed into the<br />
Ms. Leilani Tuala-Warren<br />
and Attorney General Leung<br />
BC law reform community. Her visit<br />
was well timed to coincide with the<br />
Federation of <strong>Law</strong> Reform Agencies<br />
of Canada [FOLRAC] conference<br />
hosted by the BCLI in Victoria, BC.<br />
That provided her with the opportunity<br />
to meet and connect with members<br />
of the law reform community from<br />
across the country as well as key<br />
members of the Notary Foundation, the<br />
<strong>Law</strong> Foundation, and members of the<br />
Canadian judiciary and governments.<br />
BCLI is exceptionally<br />
proud to have had the<br />
opportunity to develop such<br />
an important relationship<br />
with the SLRC<br />
at the critical nascent stage<br />
of its development.<br />
A freak snowstorm also offered Ms.<br />
Tuala-Warren her first real look at snow!<br />
The folks in Victoria looked equally<br />
confused by the weather at the time.<br />
At FOLRAC, Samoa was warmly<br />
offered connections and met ongoing<br />
law reform colleagues at that event.<br />
While in Vancouver, Ms. Tuala-<br />
Warren actively participated in BCLI’s<br />
legal research and law reform projects<br />
and processes, worked on developing<br />
capacity and strategic planning, and<br />
delved into the systematic processes<br />
required of objective, nonpolitical law<br />
reform work.<br />
BCLI and its staff then began<br />
to dig for further resources to support<br />
the SLRC. BCLI was able to provide<br />
the first foundational research<br />
textbooks and tools as a donation<br />
to the SLRC library.<br />
©iStockphoto.com/gprentice<br />
The relationship was very much<br />
a mutual one. BCLI continues to benefit<br />
from the ongoing exchanges and<br />
perspectives of the SLRC and its staff.<br />
The Alberta <strong>Law</strong> Reform <strong>Institute</strong><br />
also reached out to Ms. Tuala-Warren,<br />
generously hosting her in Edmonton<br />
and providing her with invaluable<br />
opportunities to compare structures,<br />
consultation processes, and project<br />
organization.<br />
On returning to Samoa, Ms. Tuala-<br />
Warren took three things of great value<br />
for the SLRC.<br />
1. She returned to Samoa with key<br />
expertise and experience on<br />
how to organize the SLRC, how<br />
to establish priorities for best<br />
results, and how to organize and<br />
carry out law reform projects.<br />
2. Though they took a slower “tramp<br />
steamer” route, several legal<br />
textbooks provided by BCLI helped<br />
begin a law library.<br />
3. A number of webcams were<br />
attached to the computers of the<br />
SLRC. State-of-the-art at the time,<br />
the webcams opened the world<br />
to the SLRC and allowed for the<br />
exchange and community-building<br />
to continue.<br />
BCLI is exceptionally proud<br />
to have had the opportunity to develop<br />
such an important relationship with<br />
the SLRC at the critical nascent<br />
stage of its development. The<br />
relationships between the SLRC and<br />
BCLI remain very close and mutually<br />
beneficial. We appreciate the great<br />
relationship established with our two<br />
Pacific jurisdictions.<br />
Faamanu!<br />
(Thank you!) s<br />
Laura Tamblyn Watts was called<br />
to the Bar in 1999 and has worked<br />
with the BCLI/CCEL since 2004.<br />
A researcher, frequent author, and<br />
commentator on law and aging issues,<br />
she is committed to independent law<br />
reform in Canada and around the<br />
world. Laura is currently pursuing her<br />
doctorate in law and dreams of moving<br />
to Samoa.<br />
lwatts@bcli.org<br />
Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013 The Scrivener 19
BC NOTaRIES<br />
mEET oUR BoARD oF DIRECToRS<br />
Patricia Wright: A Love of <strong>Law</strong> and music<br />
I<br />
was born in mission, BC.<br />
my father was a logger so we<br />
moved around the province<br />
a lot. my mother and father<br />
moved to Williams Lake when<br />
I was 3 and started the Williams<br />
Lake Logging Company.<br />
Mom and I<br />
Pat and Elvis<br />
Shortly thereafter, my father<br />
was killed in a logging accident at age<br />
34, leaving my mother at 30 with three<br />
girls to raise—ages 8, 3, and 1. There<br />
were debts to pay and no money coming<br />
in. To add to the situation, some of the<br />
workers—worried they would not be<br />
paid—absconded with the equipment,<br />
leaving my mom in a horrible situation.<br />
How do you say thank you<br />
for what a mom does for you<br />
. . . Mom was my biggest<br />
cheerleader through life.<br />
The bank came knocking and my<br />
mom managed to pull through all the<br />
adversity. She moved us back down<br />
to Coquitlam and provided a home<br />
and everything we needed. She walked<br />
miles to work the midnight shift at<br />
Fraser Mills, pulling sheets of plywood<br />
from a machine. She taught us that<br />
a woman can do anything she puts her<br />
mind to do if she works hard and does<br />
not give up.<br />
Mom did marry again and we were<br />
blessed with another sister. My mother<br />
passed away last December but her<br />
memory will stay in my heart forever.<br />
How do you say thank you for what<br />
a mom does for you . . . Mom was my<br />
biggest cheerleader through life. Her<br />
strength and wisdom helped guide me<br />
and her zest for life and fun always<br />
inspired me. She was an amazing<br />
woman. I was truly blessed to have her<br />
as my mother.<br />
After graduating from high school<br />
and a trip to Europe, I returned to my<br />
home town of Port Coquitlam and went<br />
to work for a sole practitioner lawyer<br />
who practised in real estate, Wills, and<br />
estates. It was a great way to learn<br />
because we two were the only people<br />
in the office; we prepared all the<br />
documents. It was a great one-on-one<br />
learning experience and introduction<br />
to the legal world.<br />
20 The Society of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013
My 25th Notary Anniversary at Whistler<br />
I became a BC Notary 30 years<br />
ago, commissioned at the age<br />
of 10—the youngest Notary ever!<br />
I had worked for law firms since<br />
leaving school and liked real estate<br />
and mortgage work immensely.<br />
As a paralegal mainly in small firms,<br />
I was used to taking the files from<br />
start to finish. We would even attend<br />
on execution of the documents at<br />
that time. I was often in the office<br />
10 hours a day. Dealing with the<br />
clients was especially rewarding.<br />
By that time, I was living and<br />
working in downtown Vancouver.<br />
I was also instructing Conveyancing at<br />
the Robson Media Centre and at three<br />
colleges and teaching a day course<br />
for the BC Notary students.<br />
Then I realized I wanted to be<br />
a Notary! When I applied to take the<br />
training, I was interviewed by our<br />
dear then-Secretary Bernard Hoeter.<br />
I happened to be teaching one<br />
of his assistants in a conveyancing<br />
class. My interview with the highly<br />
capable and very stern Dr. Hoeter<br />
was a question-and-answer quiz on<br />
the topic. I still perspire when I think<br />
of that day! I was able to work with<br />
Dr. Hoeter on a number of occasions<br />
because our offices were so close.<br />
He always inspired me.<br />
In the past few years, I have<br />
been mentoring new students. We are<br />
welcoming some wonderful new Notaries<br />
into our profession, each one bringing<br />
unique qualities. I think the future<br />
of The Society will be in good hands.<br />
I have been very blessed with<br />
wonderful clients, knowledgeable<br />
staff, and great Realtors and mortgage<br />
brokers. Many of them have become<br />
close dear friends. I enjoy working with<br />
our clients and assisting them to buy<br />
their first home or their dream home<br />
or to assist them to refinance or make<br />
a Will. Those can be stressful times<br />
and I want every client coming through<br />
the door to feel comfortable.<br />
I ensure we spend enough time<br />
with them, even on the first phone<br />
contact and that they receive full<br />
and thorough reports about our work<br />
for them. I am always happy to hear<br />
the sound of laughter in our office;<br />
it makes me feel we are making the<br />
transaction more relaxed for the client.<br />
Last year, I ran for a position on<br />
the Board of Directors of The Society<br />
of Notaries because I wanted to give back<br />
to a profession that has been so good<br />
to me. I have always appreciated the<br />
way The Society has been there for me.<br />
It has been a real eye-opener to see<br />
the amount of work our Directors and<br />
Executive put in. I am delighted to be<br />
a new kid on our great team!<br />
I have always appreciated<br />
the way The Society<br />
has been there for me.<br />
At my office, there have been some<br />
fun and interesting Christmas parties<br />
. . . lots of great times with our clients<br />
including conga lines around the filing<br />
cabinets, surprise Mexican bands, and<br />
even Marilyn Monroe actors attending.<br />
My team<br />
We won’t even mention who fell into the<br />
punch bowl but I do have video! You<br />
just never know what can happen.<br />
I’ve also notarized documents<br />
and done files for certain celebrities<br />
and have visited film sets, studios,<br />
and concert venues. As well, we have<br />
done work for hockey players and<br />
management and football players and<br />
management. One of our clients isn’t<br />
allowed into the office without his<br />
Stanley Cup ring on! Those files are<br />
always fun and make for an exciting day.<br />
We all have to put in long hours<br />
in this occupation. I am fortunate<br />
to have such a supportive husband<br />
as my James. We live with our beloved<br />
doggie Elvis, a bearded collie who is<br />
now 15. James and I love to travel<br />
when we can get away from the office,<br />
which isn’t that often.<br />
With my husband James Black<br />
Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013 The Scrivener 21
Crest Realty<br />
Independently Owned<br />
and Operated<br />
Estate<br />
Litigation<br />
I can help.<br />
• Past President, TLABC<br />
• Past Chair Wills &<br />
Trusts Section, CBA<br />
• Over 38 years of<br />
litigation experience<br />
Trevor Todd<br />
Estate Litigation<br />
Referrals Welcome.<br />
P | 604 264-8470 www.disinherited.com<br />
E | rttodd@disinherited.com<br />
Pat and James in the ‘70s<br />
We also keep up with James’s<br />
musical career. A member of a number<br />
of bands in the ‘70s and ‘80s,<br />
he was the singer, guitarist, and<br />
songwriter for the band May Blitz,<br />
which still has quite a following. The<br />
group was formed around the worldfamous<br />
drummer Tony Newman. Very<br />
popular in Europe, May Blitz was the<br />
first group ever taken on by Paramount<br />
Studios. They are now with Universal<br />
Music. They toured Europe extensively<br />
and the Eastern Seaboard of the USA.<br />
It is amazing to see how much<br />
information is on the Internet about<br />
May Blitz and how many fans have<br />
made YouTube videos for them (my<br />
favourite is Josephine Baker dancing<br />
to their song Firequeen). Their two<br />
albums have been re-mastered<br />
numerous times. A group from<br />
Germany recently found some old<br />
footage of a concert May Blitz did<br />
at the Essen Festival and re-mastered<br />
it in CD and vinyl form.<br />
Their music still sells throughout<br />
the world. We are always surprised<br />
to see sales in Japan and Korea where<br />
the band did not tour. Now some of the<br />
younger bands in England are recording<br />
their songs. It is all very exciting. When<br />
the guys get together, there’s always<br />
a lot of craziness and fun.<br />
I am still working on getting<br />
James and our doggie Elvis on the road<br />
as The Two Elvises. I think that would<br />
sell and I would be a great manager!<br />
What is most important in my<br />
life? Family, friends, and my Notary<br />
practice! s<br />
22 The Society of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013
www.greglitwin.com<br />
Follow us on Facebook<br />
Alex Ning<br />
Notary Public, Mediator,<br />
Immigration & Refugee Counsel<br />
Member<br />
www.greglitwin.com<br />
Follow us on Facebook<br />
Business To Business<br />
Tracy D. Parker<br />
NOTARY PUBLIC<br />
Certified Senior Advisor<br />
604-885-5017<br />
tparker@sunshinecoastnotary.ca<br />
5772 Cowrie Street<br />
PO Box 460<br />
Sechelt, BC VON 3A0<br />
Fax: 604 885-5064<br />
www.sunshinecoastnotary.ca<br />
a SerVIce yOU caN TrUST<br />
Alexander Ning Notary Corporation<br />
Suite 230, 8911 Beckwith Road<br />
Richmond, BC Canada V6X 1V4<br />
Email: alex@annc.ca<br />
Fax: 604 270-4751<br />
Direct: 604 270-8155<br />
Telephone: 604 270-8384<br />
GREGORY J. LITWIN<br />
NOTARY PUBLIC<br />
#1 – 699 Main Street<br />
Penticton, <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> V2A 5C9<br />
Phone: 250-770-8888<br />
Fax: 250-492-2288<br />
Email: greg@greglitwin.com<br />
vicki@greglitwin.com<br />
kim@greglitwin.com<br />
sheri@greglitwin.com<br />
**Offices also in Oliver and Keremeos<br />
Westcoast Surveys Ltd.<br />
Registered member of ASTT of BC<br />
Site surveys for Mortgage Purposes<br />
Don Prokopetz<br />
AScT, RSIS<br />
Tel 604 543-8665 Fax 604 543-8610<br />
NOTARIES PUBLIC<br />
“Knowledgeable & Capable”<br />
ROY CAMMACK, M.B.A., C.S.A. #106 - 1656 Martin Drive<br />
NOTARY PUBLIC (1982) Surrey, <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong><br />
Telephone: (604) 536-7288 Canada V4A 6E7<br />
Fax: (604) 538-4477 e-mail: roy@cammack.ca<br />
Appointments Appreciated Website: www.cammack.ca<br />
Real Estate Documents ✧ Subdivisions ✧ Transfers ✧ Mortgages<br />
Leases ✧ Liens ✧ Powers of Attorney ✧ Wills & Affidavits<br />
COMMERCIAL FISHING SUPPLIES<br />
250 656-3951<br />
101 – 9830 Second Street<br />
Sidney, BC V8L 3C6<br />
Real Estate<br />
Estate Planning<br />
GARY NAKASHIMA<br />
President<br />
3731 Moncton Street<br />
Steveston, <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong><br />
Canada V7E 3A5<br />
www.pacificnetandtwine.com<br />
Telephone: 604-274-7238<br />
Facsimile: 604-271-2914<br />
Cellular: 604-250-0638<br />
US & CAN: 1-800-895-GEAR<br />
gary@pacificnetandtwine.com<br />
Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013 The Scrivener 23
BC NOTaRIES<br />
I<br />
was born at the end<br />
of may 1965, during planting<br />
season on a tobacco farm<br />
in Southwestern ontario’s snow<br />
belt, close to Lake ontario.<br />
My young years were idyllic—fun<br />
and play, both in Winter and Summer,<br />
with lots of room to roam. I have very<br />
fond memories of spending hours<br />
fishing with my dad. I started figure<br />
skating when a nearby town built an<br />
arena and enjoyed years improving<br />
in that sport. I even have a couple<br />
of gold medals from competitions!<br />
To finance my social life, I had<br />
the usual odd jobs after school and<br />
on weekends.<br />
I attended college in Sarnia,<br />
Ontario, and left the day I finished<br />
Madeira Park<br />
Marina, in Pender<br />
Harbour, a quaint<br />
fishing village<br />
where I live<br />
to move out to <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong>.<br />
My parents, my adventurous friend<br />
from college, and a very sick cat<br />
made the trip. Between blizzards<br />
outside Portage La Prairie, Manitoba,<br />
that left us stranded on the Trans<br />
Canada Highway and a vehicle<br />
breakdown in Edson, Alberta, it<br />
was quite a journey. We arrived at<br />
our destination in northern <strong>British</strong><br />
<strong>Columbia</strong>—Granisle, on beautiful<br />
Babine Lake—in early May 1984.<br />
There we discovered the best rainbow<br />
trout fishing ever!<br />
My young years were<br />
idyllic—fun and play,<br />
both in Winter and Summer,<br />
with lots of room to roam.<br />
I relocated that Winter to Hazelton<br />
and at 19, started my first “real” job<br />
after college—legal secretary for Peter<br />
Grant, a very talented litigator and<br />
the primary lawyer on the landmark<br />
“Gitksan” First Nation land claim that<br />
eventually received judgment at the<br />
Supreme Court of Canada. I worked<br />
from a little log cabin in the middle<br />
of nowhere and had to build a fire<br />
in the woodstove every morning before<br />
I started work . . . not to mention the<br />
switchbacks on the steep driveway<br />
to get there!<br />
I learned so much from Peter,<br />
who treated me with much respect<br />
for a “young’un”; my years working<br />
for him were great experience. I left<br />
shortly after the first Gitksan trial<br />
began in Smithers and the case went<br />
on for many years.<br />
All Photos: Madison Zazulak, Zazulak Photography<br />
PRoFILE oF A BC NoTARy:<br />
SECHELT AND THE SUNSHINE CoAST<br />
Tracy Parker:<br />
Blues-Berries Anyone?<br />
24 The Society of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013
Ruby Lake on the Sunshine Coast on the way to the Earl’s Cove ferry terminal, one of my favourite spots on the Coast<br />
I taught figure skating both<br />
before and after my first child<br />
Madison was born. The skating<br />
program we put together was a great<br />
success—80 kids, ages 2 to 18. Wow!<br />
What a challenge! Producing a skating<br />
carnival was one of most challenging<br />
things I have ever had to do. Madison<br />
loved to be in the backpack when<br />
I skated fast down the ice. She would<br />
laugh and squeal and everyone loved<br />
her. Madison took all the beautiful<br />
photo images you see in this article.<br />
My only sibling, my sister Vicky,<br />
followed us out to BC and became<br />
a logging truck driver. Now she lives<br />
in Campbell River and drives semis up<br />
and down Vancouver Island. I always<br />
worry about her, especially when she’s<br />
on the Malahat!<br />
Moving to the Sunshine Coast<br />
in 1989 turned out to be a wonderful<br />
So, as a single parent<br />
with three kids, two jobs,<br />
and a mortgage,<br />
I launched into the<br />
Notary Preparatory Course…<br />
decision. I worked for a couple<br />
of lawyers here but that wore thin after<br />
a few years . . . I can be a bit restless.<br />
It was 1994 when I took a job that<br />
turned out to be life-changing for me.<br />
I went to work for Arne Tveit-Pettersen,<br />
a BC Notary Public.<br />
Having grown up in Ontario,<br />
I didn’t really know what a Notary<br />
Public was—BC Notaries have a much<br />
broader scope of services than<br />
Ontario Notaries. Arne was willing<br />
to teach me and I was eager to learn.<br />
He was my mentor—a kind, intelligent,<br />
and charming man who strongly<br />
encouraged me to apply to the Notary<br />
Society. He said I had what it took<br />
to be a good Notary. I hope I have<br />
made him proud. He has retired now<br />
and is still running half-marathons.<br />
Amazing.<br />
So, as a single parent with three<br />
kids, two jobs, and a mortgage,<br />
I launched into the Notary Preparatory<br />
Course, a long, arduous but<br />
exhilarating ride I will never forget.<br />
Without the selfless support of my<br />
parents and friends, I don’t think<br />
I would have made it. I am eternally<br />
grateful.<br />
Graduated and installed in the<br />
Year 2000, I was ready to go! At that<br />
point I was working with Karen Kidd,<br />
Notary Public in Sechelt.<br />
Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013 The Scrivener 25
Husband Brent and I relaxing in Zihuatanejo, Mexico . . .<br />
our first REAL vacation together<br />
Karen shared a lot of practical tips<br />
with me. I bought her practice and<br />
opened my door on August 4, 2000.<br />
The time since has flown quickly!<br />
I was so lucky to marry my<br />
husband Brent in 2002. He loves me<br />
more than I deserve. We have raised<br />
a blended family of 5 healthy kids—my<br />
3 and his 2: Chris 17, Jack 20, Jeremy<br />
22, Rebecca 22, and Madison 25.<br />
They are all great friends and it is a lot<br />
of fun when we are all together. I can’t<br />
believe it is almost 13 years later!<br />
The eldest Madison was married<br />
at our home in Pender Harbour this<br />
past Summer and now we are entering<br />
a whole new phase of our lives. I can<br />
see some pretty big turkey dinners<br />
in the years to come.<br />
We are starting to do some<br />
travelling now and have booked<br />
a family ski vacation at Panorama,<br />
BC, for Christmas. I am really looking<br />
forward to it. Then maybe someplace<br />
warmer after that.<br />
My Notary practice is located<br />
in sunny Sechelt, a half-hour drive<br />
from Gibsons, off the ferry from<br />
Horseshoe Bay. I am fortunate<br />
to have a great office location on the<br />
main street—bright and cheery with<br />
lots of sunshine and fresh air.<br />
I think one of the most<br />
important things we do<br />
as BC Notaries is simply<br />
helping people.<br />
My secretary Dianne—she likes<br />
to be called a secretary—is also my<br />
very good friend. She has skills beyond<br />
measure that help me every day to be<br />
a better person and Notary. Dianne<br />
takes such pride in her work and always<br />
tries to present our services and my<br />
image in the most positive light. You<br />
will always get a smile from Dianne<br />
when you come through our door! We<br />
have a very special and comfortable<br />
work environment and I believe this<br />
“vibe” is passed on to our clients.<br />
I think one of the most important<br />
things we do as BC Notaries is simply<br />
helping people. Yes, we do the regular<br />
work—conveyancing, Wills, and so on—<br />
but I have noticed that at least here on<br />
the Sunshine Coast, people sometimes<br />
just need a little help . . . you know,<br />
trying to make sense of government<br />
forms, not knowing where to get a letter<br />
of invitation, or even what it is. Things<br />
like that, especially if English is not<br />
their first language.<br />
Maybe it’s because we have an<br />
older demographic living here, but<br />
helping them out and sending them on<br />
their way is personally very satisfying.<br />
I think I like helping my older folks the<br />
most. They trust me and it warms my<br />
heart to see them smile and give me<br />
a hug when they leave the office. After<br />
all the years they’ve been here and all<br />
the things they’ve seen, they deserve<br />
my sincere respect.<br />
For the last couple of years,<br />
I have been working from my home<br />
in Pender Harbour on Wednesdays<br />
and meeting clients there. Since it is<br />
only a half-hour drive north of Sechelt,<br />
many people are grateful for my<br />
service in that area and I really enjoy<br />
it. Hopefully in the future I can spend<br />
even more time in Pender Harbour.<br />
That is one of my goals.<br />
Dianne and I with some of our<br />
“Blues-Berry Tarts.” We add the<br />
whipped cream just before delivery!<br />
Recently we launched a Blues-<br />
Berry Tarts campaign and that<br />
has been fun. We have been delivering<br />
blueberry tarts to the people with<br />
whom we work—banks, Realtors, and<br />
so on—to help chase away the January<br />
blues. Dianne has been helping me<br />
bake the tarts; we pick and freeze the<br />
blueberries from our bushes every year.<br />
We have about 36 very large<br />
blueberry bushes down by the lake<br />
and last year we had kazillions<br />
of berries! We also had a “Blueberry<br />
Tea” event in the blueberry patch last<br />
August. We spend a lot of time in the<br />
Spring pruning the bushes and in the<br />
Summer, picking the fruits of our<br />
labours. Dianne is the one who looks<br />
like she is jumping out of the bushes<br />
in the photo, always with a SMILE!<br />
26 The Society of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013
With my friends Dianne and Airlie picking<br />
their own at our “Blueberry Tea” event<br />
I love that photo; it makes me laugh<br />
so hard! Now we are trying to figure<br />
out the best ideas of what to do with<br />
all the berries.<br />
Obviously we have awesome<br />
smoothies all year long and they make<br />
really good blueberry vinaigrette.<br />
Maybe we will try dehydrating them<br />
this year.<br />
Being members of the Sechelt and<br />
Pender Harbour Chambers of Commerce<br />
and the Sechelt Downtown Business<br />
Association, my husband and I attend<br />
as many community functions as we<br />
can. We especially love the musical<br />
talent that comes to the Sunshine Coast<br />
and try to be involved in the multiple<br />
music festivals Pender Harbour hosts<br />
each year.<br />
I have spent more time speaking<br />
at small community groups over the<br />
past year, educating people about<br />
advance care planning. We also belong<br />
to the Royal Canadian Legion—they<br />
are our best neighbour—and we<br />
volunteer there when we can. Now that<br />
the kids are growing up, Brent and<br />
I hope to have more time for that kind<br />
of community service.<br />
I am so grateful for the<br />
opportunity to give back and to help<br />
people wherever possible. From what<br />
I know of the others in my profession,<br />
that is what being a BC Notary is all<br />
about. s<br />
Please<br />
#845 –<br />
Note:<br />
1200 West<br />
WE HAVE<br />
73rd<br />
MOVED!<br />
Avenue<br />
#210 – 10451 Shellbridge Way<br />
Vancouver, <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> V6P 6G5<br />
Richmond, BC V6X 2W8<br />
New<br />
t: 604.266.8287<br />
Phone: 604 284-5515<br />
New f: 604.266.3034<br />
Fax: 604 284-5514<br />
Info@appraisal.bc.ca<br />
info@appraisal.bc.ca<br />
www.appraisal.bc.ca<br />
GEORGE E.H. CADmAN,* Q.C.<br />
604 647-4123 Cell 604 290-8947<br />
gehcqc@boughton.ca www.boughton.ca<br />
Real Estate, Corporate Litigation<br />
and Dispute Resolution<br />
BOUGHTON LAW CORPORATION<br />
Suite 1000, 595 Burrard St., P.O. BOx 49290,<br />
VancOuVer, Bc V7x 1S8<br />
tel 604 687-6789 Fax 604 683-5317<br />
*law cOrPOratiOn<br />
We Value<br />
Canada<br />
Canada’s most<br />
authoritative voice in<br />
real property valuation!<br />
When the market’s changing, whom can you trust?<br />
Call the experts: AIC professionals.<br />
We’re Canada’s leading authority in real property valuation.<br />
Designated AIC members can help you make smarter choices<br />
with in-depth analysis, market insights and practical solutions —<br />
from acquisition and development to management and disposal.<br />
Get the real property experts working for you.<br />
Consult an AIC professional.<br />
Look for members who hold the AACI, P.App, or CRA designation.<br />
Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013 The Scrivener 27
BC NOTaRIES<br />
D ear M um,<br />
It has been nearly 5 years since you left us<br />
and I still miss you very much.<br />
The past few months, I have<br />
thought about you all the time.<br />
Valentine’s Day was the 100th anniversary of Dad’s birth and May 31<br />
will be the 100th anniversary of your<br />
birth. <strong>Law</strong>son, your youngest greatgrandchild,<br />
will have his first birthday<br />
the same day. I wish both you and<br />
Dad were here and in good health<br />
to experience these days.<br />
I keep thinking about you and<br />
what you have meant to me during my<br />
lifetime. As you know, I was 65 this<br />
year. I graduated from high school<br />
in 1965, so the class of ‘65 turned 65.<br />
Several of “the girls” in my graduating<br />
class got together for lunch in December<br />
when the last of us had her birthday.<br />
We had our pictures taken with our gold<br />
cards. It was such fun and you would<br />
have loved to hear about it.<br />
Not only do I miss not being able<br />
to share my life with you, I am sorry<br />
you never got to know how much<br />
you taught me in the last few years<br />
of your life. The life experiences we<br />
had together are being put to good use<br />
in my professional and private life.<br />
After nearly 46 years working on<br />
Fort Street in Victoria, I closed my<br />
office last year and began working<br />
from home. The routine of not getting<br />
up and going to work every day<br />
seemed strange at first but it gave me<br />
a freedom I had never experienced<br />
before. I am able to look out the same<br />
window as you did for so many years<br />
and enjoy all the things you enjoyed.<br />
I keep thinking about you<br />
and what you have meant<br />
to me during my lifetime.<br />
. . . Watching the buds begin to burst<br />
on the trees in the front yard<br />
. . . Enjoying the squirrels running<br />
around on the lawn across the<br />
street<br />
. . . Marvelling as the Winter turns<br />
into Spring with the return of the<br />
birds and flowers<br />
I even have the time to remember<br />
how you used to fuss at the blossoms<br />
falling from the chestnut tree and<br />
With my father Alex and my mother Alice Caddell<br />
Leta Best<br />
©iStockphoto.com/YinYang<br />
Leta at Grad<br />
driving you crazy with the mess<br />
they made on the driveway. Do you<br />
remember how you would have to go<br />
out and sweep them up to keep<br />
everything tidy?<br />
Well, in that respect, I’m not like<br />
you. I enjoy having the lawn covered<br />
in blossoms and the experience<br />
brought you much closer to me.<br />
I believe you would say I have finally<br />
stopped to smell the roses.<br />
As you would also note, it wasn’t<br />
the roses I would smell but the weeds.<br />
Those weeds were my wild flowers<br />
in the garden. To you they were simply<br />
weeds. To the delight of us both, your<br />
flowers and my weeds are getting<br />
along well in our garden.<br />
As the Summer turned to Autumn,<br />
I had the time to watch the leaves fall<br />
and cover the lawn. This time I was like<br />
you and had to sweep up the leaves<br />
and pile them next to the road for<br />
collection. Well, that’s not quite true,<br />
I had someone sweep and pile them up<br />
for me but at least they were removed.<br />
Oh, I have to share one more<br />
observation I have made since<br />
I slowed down. As I sit in my chair<br />
at night, I look down at my feet and<br />
I see your feet on the end of my legs.<br />
I then wonder in what other ways I am<br />
my mother’s daughter. Hopefully, I am<br />
your daughter in all the best ways.<br />
28 The Society of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013
To get to the point of my Thank<br />
You letter to you, my life has changed<br />
a great deal in the past year since<br />
bringing my office home. Instead<br />
of having the clients come to me,<br />
I often go to them.<br />
As I was speaking<br />
to the family with the<br />
social worker, it was<br />
a moment of déjà vu.<br />
That is the experience I would<br />
like to share with you the most. Mum,<br />
I know you often felt you were not<br />
a part of my business life. How proud<br />
you would be today to know just how<br />
much you taught me in the last years<br />
of your life and how I am taking those<br />
lessons and using them today.<br />
A few months ago, I was at one<br />
of the senior homes interviewing<br />
family members, as well as my client,<br />
for the legal documents they required<br />
and I felt your presence.<br />
As I was speaking to the family<br />
with the social worker, it was<br />
a moment of déjà vu. The clock<br />
stopped and moved back to 2005<br />
when you had your stroke and<br />
I was talking to the social worker at<br />
Victoria General Hospital, making<br />
plans for the rest of your life. It was<br />
a bewildering, scary moment when<br />
I realized I would have to make all the<br />
decisions for you in the future.<br />
In a matter of months, you who<br />
loved to golf and bowl and play<br />
badminton were robbed of all that was<br />
so special to you. Oh, I know you had<br />
been nearly blind and partially deaf for<br />
many years but you still had a quality<br />
of life. That was now changed. How<br />
fortunate we were that we had already<br />
done some preplanning and at least<br />
had a Power of Attorney in place. Your<br />
insistence that you would always be<br />
able to fend for yourself—and you<br />
are not the only one with a stubborn<br />
streak—kept you from doing anything<br />
more than the Power of Attorney.<br />
Heaven forbid you should<br />
ever entertain the notion of a<br />
Representation Agreement. You were<br />
going to stay in your home till the day<br />
you died and were adamant that you<br />
could look after yourself and did not<br />
require any assistance.<br />
Well, guess what? The future had<br />
other plans for you. We were very<br />
fortunate that we were able to manage<br />
with just the Power of Attorney, but<br />
how times have changed in the past<br />
few years.<br />
More and more, the health care<br />
system is requesting that Powers<br />
of Attorney, Representation<br />
Agreements, and Advance Health Care<br />
Directives are in place. My experiences<br />
with you have given me a greater<br />
understanding of both the system and<br />
what is required.<br />
I was sitting with a family going<br />
through the same transition as I went<br />
through with you. While I was speaking<br />
to them, I felt you very close to me<br />
and guiding me. The lessons I learned<br />
through you were applied with them;<br />
I felt confident in counselling the family.<br />
Although the guidance I was<br />
giving them was very different than the<br />
advice of the social worker, I was able<br />
to use my knowledge as a BC Notary<br />
Public and my experience with you<br />
to assist the family and their loved one<br />
to make informed decisions on the legal<br />
documentation they would require.<br />
More and more over the past<br />
year, I have been going to the clients’<br />
homes, the hospital, hospice, and<br />
long-term care facilities to assist the<br />
aging or terminally ill people with their<br />
end-of-life decisions.<br />
My years as a Notary gave me<br />
the education, but you, my dearest<br />
mother, gave me the compassion and<br />
the passion to assist these members<br />
of our community.<br />
As Mother’s Day approaches,<br />
I just wanted to say how much I love<br />
you and how much I appreciate<br />
your guidance and the opportunities<br />
you gave me.<br />
Thank you, M um.<br />
Your loving<br />
daughter,Leta<br />
xoxoxo s<br />
Judi Whyte RI<br />
Inaugural Professional Excellence Award<br />
Real Estate Board of Greater Vancouver<br />
Cell: 604.868.9812<br />
judiwhyte@telus.net<br />
Robbi-Layne Robertson<br />
Cell: 604.351.9417<br />
robbilaynerobertson@gmail.com<br />
Selling Homes<br />
for over 35 years ~<br />
www.JudiWhyte.com<br />
Call us for real estate advice<br />
and service you can trust.<br />
Prudential Sussex Realty 2397<br />
Marine Drive, West Vancouver, BC<br />
V7V 1K9<br />
Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013 The Scrivener 29
Margot R.<br />
Rutherford*<br />
Notary Public<br />
A Member of The Society<br />
of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong><br />
*Denotes Professional Notarial Corporation<br />
981 Fitzgerald Avenue<br />
Courtenay, BC V9N 2R6<br />
Tel: 250 338-6251<br />
Fax: 250 338-5337<br />
email: mrrutherford-notary@shaw.ca<br />
Thousands of<br />
BC Decision-Makers<br />
Read The Scrivener,<br />
quarterly<br />
• BC Notaries<br />
• Land Appraisers<br />
• RI(BC) Designates<br />
• Land Surveyors<br />
• <strong>Law</strong>yers<br />
• Real Estate Professionals<br />
• Accountants<br />
• CPCAs: Age-Friendly Designated<br />
Professionals<br />
• CAFBs: Age-Friendly Certified<br />
Businesses<br />
• Life Insurance Brokers and Agents<br />
• Financial Institution Managers<br />
Summer Advertising Deadline:<br />
June 12<br />
scrivener@society.notaries.bc.ca<br />
604 985-9250<br />
Quarterly Press Run: 12,000+ Copies<br />
BC NOTaRIES<br />
WHERE ARE THEy NoW?<br />
Roy Bishop:<br />
Nonstop Since Retiring!<br />
my very early years<br />
were spent in Northern<br />
ontario where we<br />
kids walked 3 miles to school<br />
in Winter weather, even when<br />
it was -40°!<br />
None too soon, we moved<br />
to Toronto where I grew up. I naturally<br />
migrated to BC because I dreamed<br />
of seeing the land beyond the mountains<br />
and also the mountains themselves.<br />
When I got here, I could not bear<br />
to leave again for the frozen East!<br />
I became a Notary because some<br />
of my friends were Notaries. They<br />
suggested I contact then-Secretary<br />
Alex Matthew.<br />
With son Bill when Roy was presented<br />
with his 50-year Masonic Lodge pin<br />
After I passed the course, I set<br />
up shop in Vancouver and practised<br />
20+ years.<br />
One of the most enjoyable aspects<br />
of my practice was serving on the Board<br />
of Directors and as President, through<br />
some trying times for The Society.<br />
One of the most interesting and<br />
exciting times was when I was<br />
invited to sit in the Gallery of the<br />
Legislature when our new Notaries Act<br />
was proclaimed in 1986.<br />
Since retiring, I have played<br />
much tennis, some golf, and<br />
a lot of duplicate bridge.<br />
Roy and a local dude<br />
on a recent visit to Dubai<br />
We recently returned from a trip<br />
to the Middle East where we visited<br />
several Arab countries including<br />
Petra in Jordan and Wadi Rum,<br />
where <strong>Law</strong>rence of Arabia was filmed.<br />
We ended up in Dubai, a place that<br />
has always fascinated me.<br />
The most important thing<br />
in life is family and friends, as well<br />
as reasonably good health! s<br />
30 The Society of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013
BC Notaries Susan Tong and Katy Roohani<br />
at the BC Real Estate Convention 2013 in March<br />
KABAN<br />
PROTECTIVE<br />
Your Security<br />
and Protective Specialists<br />
• CRIMINAL & CIVIL INVESTIGATION<br />
• DUE DILIGENCE<br />
• CORPORATE INTELLIGENCE<br />
Tel.: 604 251-2121<br />
Fax: 604 251-2323<br />
Toll Free: 1-866-451-2121<br />
okaban@telus.net<br />
www.kabanprotective.com<br />
Associates in 63 Countries<br />
Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013 The Scrivener 31
Susan<br />
Davis<br />
Ken<br />
Sherk<br />
John<br />
Eastwood<br />
Akash<br />
Sablok<br />
Rhoda<br />
Witherly<br />
Building Better Communities,<br />
one grant at a time<br />
The Board of Governors of the Notary<br />
Foundation of BC is comprised of<br />
• 8 members of the Board of Directors<br />
of The Society of Notaries Public of BC;<br />
• 1 representative from the Attorney<br />
General’s office in Victoria;<br />
• 2 Directors-at-Large, appointed by the<br />
Attorney General; and<br />
• the Executive Officer.<br />
The members from The Society are elected<br />
by the Directors of The Society from among<br />
their ranks, for a 3-year period.<br />
The Current Governors<br />
Susan Davis, Chair<br />
Ken Sherk<br />
John Eastwood<br />
Akash Sablok<br />
Rhoda Witherly<br />
Tammy Morin-Nakashima<br />
David Moore<br />
Leta Best<br />
Lisa Nakamura<br />
Filip de Sagher<br />
G. W. (Wayne) Braid, Executive<br />
Officer of the Notary Foundation,<br />
is responsible for the<br />
administration of the office and<br />
staff, and the diverse investment<br />
funds of the Foundation.<br />
Wayne Braid The Board of Governors meets<br />
quarterly to consider applications for funding<br />
from various organizations and to set policy,<br />
review the Foundation’s financial status,<br />
and provide direction for the administration<br />
of the Foundation.<br />
The Governors of the Foundation have the<br />
responsibility of guiding the Foundation<br />
in its mandate to disperse the funds generated<br />
by interest on BC Notaries’ Trust Accounts.<br />
Tammy<br />
Morin-<br />
Nakashima<br />
David<br />
Moore<br />
Lisa<br />
Nakamura<br />
The Notary Foundation funds are used for the following purposes.<br />
1. Legal education<br />
2. Legal research<br />
3. Legal aid<br />
4. Education and Continuing Education for BC Notaries and<br />
applicants who have enrolled to become BC Notaries<br />
5. Establishment, operation, and maintainance of law libraries in BC<br />
6. Contributions to the Special Fund established<br />
under the Notaries Act of BC<br />
Leta<br />
Best<br />
Filip<br />
de Sagher<br />
$41,255,725<br />
30 MiLLion<br />
24 MiLLion<br />
18 MiLLion<br />
12 MiLLion<br />
6 MiLLion<br />
Funds earned to date from<br />
BC Notaries’ Trust Accounts.<br />
as at february 28, 2013<br />
32 The Society of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013
ONE RULE OF BUSINESS<br />
IS NEVER GOING TO<br />
CHANGE. THERE’S<br />
ALWAYS A<br />
BIGGER JOB.<br />
MBA PROGRAMS AT THE SEGAL GRADUATE SCHOOL<br />
Prepare for real-world success. Each individual program has been<br />
designed for a specifi c category of emerging leaders. Choose from a full-<br />
time MBA, Executive MBA, Management of Technology MBA, MSc Finance<br />
and the online Graduate Diploma in Business Administration. Visit<br />
beedie.sfu.ca/infosession to register for an information session today. ENGAGING THE WORLD.<br />
Peter, EMBA 2010
THE BIG PICTURE<br />
Is it time . . .<br />
• to practise international<br />
development at home<br />
to better our own<br />
communities;<br />
• to reconfigure and<br />
develop more sustainable<br />
economies;<br />
• to ensure our health and<br />
education systems evolve<br />
to meet the needs of the<br />
population;<br />
• to ensure the governance<br />
of our jurisdictions<br />
has appropriate institutions<br />
of modern democracy?<br />
Reconstruction Overseas<br />
In the past few years, we have seen<br />
the extremes of conflict, witnessed<br />
the unravelling of many societies<br />
as they descended into the abyss<br />
of ethnic cleansing into the dark<br />
terrain of warlords, of religious hatred<br />
unleashed, and we have often seen<br />
the barely tethered mounts of<br />
The Four Horsemen.<br />
The MiX<br />
Practising<br />
International Development<br />
at Home<br />
The global community has poured<br />
billions of dollars into those societies<br />
moving from command economies<br />
to ones driven by the market. Where<br />
dictators have fallen we have driven<br />
capital into training, into rights,<br />
into participatory planning, and<br />
into the rule of law.<br />
With the best of nations, we have<br />
also seen close-hand reconstruction,<br />
the building of the institutions of good<br />
governance, the resurgence of agriculture,<br />
the paving of transportation links, and<br />
refreshed infrastructure to nurture<br />
sound economies.<br />
…many of us do not<br />
recognize that in many other<br />
areas we are falling behind…<br />
We have helped develop personal<br />
voice for women and many others<br />
disenfranchised in oppressive systems.<br />
In some countries, we have provided<br />
security to protect that newly heard<br />
voice from retribution. Young people<br />
have looked to the future with<br />
choices to consider and understood<br />
for the first time in their country’s<br />
history the concept, opportunity, and<br />
responsibility of freedom.<br />
Many people working in<br />
international development are today,<br />
as you read this, making tangible<br />
improvements for people to live secure<br />
Nigel Atkin<br />
lives, where they can plan for their<br />
futures, not just eking out mere<br />
subsistence for their families’ very<br />
survival.<br />
There is much more to do. As paid<br />
consultants working for international<br />
donors, or as volunteers in charities<br />
and NGOs, in health service,<br />
in agriculture, and in education,<br />
as soldiers or diplomats, as corporate<br />
partners, or just working<br />
as individuals, the broad range<br />
of services delivered to make the world<br />
a better place must continue.<br />
Not Immune to Change<br />
<strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> and our communities<br />
in Canada are not immune to the<br />
forces of change.<br />
While we think that other countries<br />
are weathering conflict and emulating<br />
or even catching up to our more<br />
developed standards of living, we would<br />
be naïve to think our society was not<br />
also going through extreme, although<br />
thankfully less violent, change.<br />
While most of us recognize<br />
incremental changes afforded<br />
by advancing technology in most<br />
areas of our individual lives—smart<br />
phones, better access to entertainment<br />
and information—many of us do not<br />
recognize that in many other areas we<br />
are falling behind—in mental and<br />
physical health, in community, and<br />
public participation in our governing<br />
institutions.<br />
34 The Society of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013
In our communities, smarter parking<br />
meters or garbage collection and bus<br />
schedule apps or systems of community<br />
surveillance are implemented but there<br />
is little discussion about replacing<br />
aging municipal infrastructure and the<br />
need for raising taxes to update roads,<br />
sewerage, bridges, and other vital<br />
services.<br />
Some people are realizing the<br />
slowly growing inability of government<br />
to deliver all health and education<br />
services in an increasingly pluralistic<br />
society. Others are starting to see the<br />
consequences of constantly indulging<br />
our entertainment options as altering<br />
our psyches, behaviours, and thinking.<br />
Amused to death comes to mind.<br />
Few leaders are stopping to think<br />
of how we need to adjust to these<br />
changes and prepare for others that<br />
are inevitable.<br />
Those apparent small changes,<br />
alone and in totality, are having<br />
a profound effect on our lives. Stress<br />
in our society, especially our youth<br />
seeking sustainable and stable futures,<br />
is rapidly increasing, bringing a host<br />
of health and education challenges.<br />
People, economies, and<br />
communities are not adjusting well<br />
to the changes. They are falling<br />
behind, in poverty and isolation . . .<br />
disenfranchised.<br />
Evidence of this can be heard<br />
in numerous quarters—in women<br />
raising their children outside traditional<br />
family structures, in the streets<br />
during Idle No More demonstrations,<br />
in groups of downtown businesspeople<br />
trying to adjust to market and other<br />
societal forces.<br />
Implementing Development at Home<br />
Do we need to practise international<br />
development at home? There is no<br />
doubt about it. Can we tear a page<br />
from the international playbook and<br />
implement successful development<br />
models in our own communities?<br />
Absolutely.<br />
Canada and <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> brim<br />
with two major resources—the<br />
knowledge and wisdom of an<br />
experienced yet retired workforce and<br />
the energy and enthusiasm of young<br />
people, educated, keen on doing good<br />
and gaining experience and making<br />
a difference.<br />
Within this large pool of talent<br />
there are subject matter experts<br />
(SMEs), not unlike those who serve<br />
around the world, who would welcome<br />
domestic opportunities to be a part<br />
of change at home.<br />
Think of models of change that<br />
could be modified and adapted<br />
to needs in the most desperate First<br />
Nations or in our downtown cores,<br />
in our rural areas facing environmental<br />
and economic pressures.<br />
Some people are realizing<br />
the slowly growing inability<br />
of government to deliver<br />
all health and education<br />
services in an increasingly<br />
pluralistic society.<br />
Consider if we need a form<br />
of Peace Corps at home or Volunteers<br />
in Service to “Canada” or a form<br />
of Provincial Reconstruction Teams<br />
(PRTs) without security forces,<br />
to advance relevant education and<br />
skills training “on site,” to implement<br />
practical engineering for clean<br />
water and sewage, to train people<br />
in sustainable economic growth.<br />
Each community is different and<br />
different teams could be assembled<br />
to effect changes on the ground.<br />
One community might need<br />
construction for social infrastructure;<br />
another, public financial management;<br />
another, agriculture and natural<br />
resource experts; another, the<br />
strengthening of health systems<br />
or development of education<br />
management and administrative<br />
systems. The list can go on.<br />
Enough reports and<br />
recommendations have been written.<br />
Too many news stories clog the<br />
psyche—it’s time to get things done.<br />
There are precedents and models<br />
for effective action.<br />
Ten years ago, for instance,<br />
the <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> government<br />
provided funds, administered through<br />
the Victoria Foundation, to support<br />
Aboriginal organizations across the<br />
province (First Nations, independent<br />
Bands, Métis, and Urban Aboriginal<br />
organizations) to help transition<br />
their communities toward Aboriginal<br />
children and family program<br />
management.<br />
While that focused initiative<br />
was successful in many communities,<br />
there is much more to be done.<br />
Consider the Potential<br />
Times have changed. There is greater<br />
and wider need today, not just in First<br />
Nations but in a host of other urban<br />
and rural areas.<br />
Consider the potential to develop<br />
teams of SMEs who would be<br />
requested by the community,<br />
with clearly targeted objectives,<br />
within clearly defined time frames,<br />
to effect positive change.<br />
Teams would be recruited<br />
as needed, oriented to the project<br />
goals at hand, administered<br />
by a community foundation or other<br />
neutral organization outside<br />
a community’s immediate vested<br />
interests, and charged with a mandate<br />
and deliverables.<br />
Consider the investment in our<br />
communities as funding coming<br />
from not only taxpayers and the<br />
institutions they support, but also from<br />
corporations, banks, from charities<br />
and foundations, and other NGOs.<br />
Consider that both paid and unpaid<br />
volunteers would have their “on site”<br />
expenses covered and that they would<br />
be a focused team to “get it done.”<br />
Canada and other countries have<br />
expended extensive capital, even lives,<br />
to help other countries rebuild and<br />
adjust to a sustainable and brighter<br />
future for their people.<br />
There are lessons learned<br />
in international development and many<br />
of them can be applied in our own<br />
territory, here in <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong>. s<br />
Nigel Atkin is an international<br />
development consultant specializing<br />
in strategy, communications, and ethics.<br />
Natkin2020@gmail.com<br />
Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013 The Scrivener 35
CHaRITaBLE GIVING<br />
How to Customize<br />
your giving<br />
Because we each have<br />
personal reasons<br />
for giving, our gifts can<br />
take many forms.<br />
Many of us respond to those friendly<br />
reminders in the mail from organizations<br />
we’ve supported in the past.<br />
Our giving can be campaignspecific.<br />
Often, a friend or colleague is<br />
fundraising for a particular campaign<br />
that leads to our one-time donation.<br />
Sometimes our donation is seasonal<br />
such as supporting the Union Gospel<br />
Mission at Thanksgiving or the Empty<br />
Stocking Fund around Christmas.<br />
An event such as an earthquake,<br />
tsunami, famine, or the suffering<br />
caused by war may motivate us.<br />
Each event appeals to our sense<br />
of wanting to be able to help.<br />
Ways to Help<br />
People can donate in several ways.<br />
Most often, we think about giving<br />
in the form of cash donations—the<br />
type of contribution often needed and<br />
appreciated.<br />
Think about other ways of helping.<br />
Often, we have the skills required<br />
in the administration of organizations.<br />
Donating a few hours of our time<br />
each week or month to help with the<br />
bookkeeping and being active on<br />
a Board are ways we can share our skills<br />
and fill the demand in organizations.<br />
Another way to help any cause<br />
is by advocating. Advocating is very<br />
important. It makes the people you<br />
approach think about an issue and<br />
they may seek to do something about<br />
it—or maybe they won’t, but at least<br />
they’ve become more aware.<br />
An event such as an<br />
earthquake, tsunami, famine,<br />
or the suffering caused<br />
by war may motivate us. Each<br />
event appeals to our sense<br />
of wanting to be able to help.<br />
David Watts<br />
Vancouver Realtor Mike Rampf<br />
recently led a team of “Movember”<br />
participants—13 mustache-growers<br />
raising funds to support research<br />
for prostate cancer and raise<br />
awareness to men to get themselves<br />
checked and screened.<br />
Mike’s business partner Shawn<br />
Anderson also did a fundraiser<br />
recently, the “Run for the Cure”<br />
in support of breast cancer<br />
research and to raise awareness<br />
to promote checkups and screening.<br />
Shawn claimed that if he reached<br />
a certain fundraising goal, he would do<br />
the 5 kilometre run wearing only a pink<br />
Speedo. Clearly, he met his goal.<br />
Some of the “Movember” Group<br />
Back row, from left: Rob Zoricic, Andrew McLeod, Alex Thomas, Geoff Murphy,<br />
Brent Anderson, Dave McLeod, Jeff Devlin, Jason Lyle<br />
Front row: Peter George, Mike Rampf, Rick Henry, Manuel Avila<br />
36 The Society of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013
Shawn in pink Speedo<br />
Reasons for Giving<br />
Often we choose to help because<br />
of a situation around us where we see<br />
a need, although our options for helping<br />
are limited. It’s difficult for any one<br />
of us to think up a cure for a disease<br />
but, together, we can raise the resources<br />
to fund research and get the right tools<br />
to the right people with the right skills—<br />
and see results.<br />
On our own, our donations may<br />
not be significant but “there is<br />
strength in numbers.” You can support<br />
an organization such as the Canadian<br />
Cancer Society or the Parkinson<br />
Society BC. Find a group that<br />
has helped someone you know and<br />
help that organization continue to help<br />
others.<br />
Follow the Money<br />
Where does it go?<br />
Sometimes we’re suspicious<br />
about the way our donation money is<br />
spent. I think about that every time<br />
I get something in the mail that asks<br />
me to donate. As opposed to replying<br />
to unsolicited mail, I usually make<br />
my donations in support of friends<br />
or colleagues in their fundraising<br />
campaigns.<br />
I always wonder how much those<br />
print campaigns cost. I guess they<br />
make money on a net basis but I’m<br />
personally not a big fan of the waste<br />
of paper and the resources consumed<br />
in mail delivery. That said, I realize<br />
that the various organizations operate<br />
in different ways. I’m sure many<br />
people appreciate receiving reminders<br />
in the mail and the goodies that often<br />
accompany requests for donations.<br />
If you’re concerned about where<br />
the money goes, you can find out.<br />
Most organizations have websites<br />
where they publish their annual<br />
reports. Take a look to see how much<br />
money is spent on administration,<br />
marketing, and printing vs. special<br />
projects, research, and actual<br />
assistance. Do your due diligence on<br />
your charity. If you don’t like what you<br />
see, keep looking.<br />
On our own, our donations<br />
may not be significant<br />
but “there is strength<br />
in numbers.”<br />
In fairness, all organizations<br />
require administration. Some<br />
organizations are fairly lean and rely on<br />
volunteers. Others are professionally<br />
run. It’s sometimes ironic when<br />
these organizations call themselves<br />
“nonprofit.” There are always unlimited<br />
wants and the boundless ability<br />
to consume available funds. They<br />
have to operate on a very innovative<br />
basis and the use of entrepreneurial<br />
methods is not uncommon.<br />
Review a charity’s budget. See how<br />
much money goes to research, helping<br />
families, or preserving woodlands,<br />
for example, as a percentage of the<br />
total revenue or fundraising.<br />
Taking Action<br />
Do you support specific organizations<br />
each year?<br />
Is there a cause close to your heart that<br />
you feel comfortable getting behind?<br />
Do you have a budget for your annual<br />
giving?<br />
When was the last time you<br />
fundraised?<br />
Do you know of an organization that<br />
has a Board of Directors or office<br />
administration situation where you<br />
could help?<br />
If you’re concerned about<br />
where the money goes,<br />
you can find out. Most<br />
organizations have websites<br />
where they publish their<br />
annual reports.<br />
Do you have skills that could help an<br />
organization succeed?<br />
Do you feel better about contributing<br />
time, money, neither, or both?<br />
Can you advocate to tell people which<br />
organizations you support and why?<br />
Sometimes that gentle reminder—<br />
especially from a friend or trusted<br />
professional—is all that is needed<br />
to have people remember it’s time<br />
to give.<br />
Do you have Will? Is there a specific<br />
bequest to a charity in your Will?<br />
That’s something to think about<br />
the next time you update your Will<br />
or prepare it for the first time, if you<br />
don’t yet have one.<br />
Summary<br />
Throughout the year, we have many<br />
opportunities to give. Today is one<br />
of those opportunities. After reading<br />
this, hopefully you will take the time<br />
to assess your own giving.<br />
Are you comfortable with your current<br />
levels?<br />
Can you give more?<br />
Think about various initiatives.<br />
Can you grow a mustache or donate<br />
to someone who participates<br />
in “Movember” this year?<br />
Can you run or bike or bowl<br />
for a cause?<br />
If you feel strongly about<br />
something, can you support those<br />
who are doing something about it?<br />
We don’t have to be Terry Fox, Steve<br />
Fonyo, or Rick Hansen but we can<br />
certainly help in whatever way works<br />
for us. s<br />
David Watts is a BC Notary practising<br />
in Downtown Vancouver.<br />
david@davidnotary.com<br />
www.davidnotary.com<br />
Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013 The Scrivener 37
POWER Of aTTORNEY<br />
“Power tends to corrupt,<br />
and absolute power<br />
corrupts absolutely.”<br />
Lord Acton<br />
As most readers will know,<br />
a Power of Attorney is a legal<br />
document giving power from one<br />
person (the Adult) to someone else<br />
(called the *Attorney) to deal on his<br />
or her behalf regarding the Adult’s<br />
legal or financial affairs.<br />
The powers can either be general<br />
powers for an Attorney to do anything<br />
you can do (other than make a Last<br />
Will) or specific/limited powers—<br />
for example, close a real estate deal<br />
for you while you’re down south.<br />
• An “enduring clause” allows the<br />
Attorney either to continue to act<br />
when, or to start to act if, the<br />
Adult becomes incapable.<br />
• The former could be called an<br />
“enduring” and the latter could<br />
be called a “springing” Power<br />
of Attorney.<br />
• In either of those cases, the<br />
document is usually referred<br />
to as an Enduring Power<br />
of Attorney (EPOA).<br />
• Most of the Powers of Attorney<br />
created today are EPOAs rather than<br />
general or limited. We will use the<br />
term EPOA throughout this article<br />
to refer to a Power of Attorney.<br />
WILL PoWER CoRRUPT?<br />
Avoiding Elder Abuse<br />
by a Rogue “Attorney” *<br />
Along with a Representation<br />
Agreement—a similar document<br />
appointing a Representative to make<br />
decisions regarding personal and<br />
medical care, an EPOA is a very<br />
useful advance planning tool. Advance<br />
planning is done to protect people<br />
when they later become no longer<br />
able to look after their own affairs<br />
or speak for themselves. Although easy<br />
to create, EPOAs are very powerful<br />
documents and have been called<br />
a licence to steal.<br />
Along with a Representation<br />
Agreement…an EPOA<br />
is a very useful advance<br />
planning tool.<br />
At the BC Centre for Elder<br />
Advocacy and Support, we respond<br />
and work to prevent elder abuse.<br />
The most common form of elder<br />
abuse is financial abuse. An Attorney<br />
appointed under an EPOA may abuse<br />
his or her power or go rogue, as Sarah<br />
Palin would say.<br />
There may be a number of reasons<br />
for this.<br />
• The document may have<br />
been created in questionable<br />
circumstances.<br />
• The wrong person may be been<br />
chosen to be the Attorney.<br />
Kevin Smith<br />
• Often that Attorney was appointed<br />
with very little or no information<br />
about the Attorney’s role and<br />
responsibilities.<br />
• Family members chosen<br />
as Attorneys may believe they<br />
are “entitled” to help themselves<br />
to some of the money, either<br />
because a lot is being demanded<br />
of them or because they believe<br />
they are going to inherit it later<br />
anyway, so why not take some<br />
now?<br />
• Some people simply behave badly<br />
when there is money around<br />
for the taking and no one is<br />
looking . . .<br />
Dealing with the aftermath of<br />
an Attorney going rogue can present<br />
serious challenges. A capable Adult<br />
can revoke a Power of Attorney<br />
and sue for return of the ill-gotten<br />
gains. In some cases you can<br />
criminally charge an Attorney and<br />
seek “restitution” (See “Dealing<br />
with the Rogue Attorney.” www.<br />
cle.bc.ca/PracticePoints/WILL/10-<br />
RogueAttorney.htm)<br />
The Public Guardian and Trustee<br />
(PGT) for BC has an Assessment and<br />
Investigation Service that has the<br />
power, in the case of an incapable<br />
Adult, of revoking a Power of Attorney,<br />
demanding accounting, freezing bank<br />
accounts, and so on. Application can<br />
be made to the BC Supreme Court<br />
38 The Society of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013
to terminate an EPOA under the new<br />
section 36 of the Power of Attorney<br />
Act and ask for return of monies<br />
misappropriated. But all that may be<br />
closing the barn door after the horse<br />
has left; the money may be long gone<br />
and not recoverable.<br />
We want to review some of the<br />
steps your legal representative will<br />
take when asked to create an EPOA<br />
for you, to help guard against potential<br />
abuse.<br />
• Preliminary considerations that<br />
will be covered in an interview<br />
• Things that should be included<br />
in the document when drafted<br />
• Recommendations regarding<br />
handout materials to go along<br />
with the document<br />
First, we want to review some recent<br />
legislative changes that were intended<br />
to lessen the chances of an Attorney<br />
going rogue.<br />
Legislative Changes<br />
A package of legislative changes<br />
occurred in September 2011,<br />
dealing with advance planning issues<br />
and documents—Representation<br />
Agreements, Advance Directives, and<br />
Powers of Attorney. Two new parts<br />
were added to the Power of Attorney<br />
Act—over 30 sections—relating to the<br />
duties and powers of Attorneys, and<br />
operations of EPOAs. They were largely<br />
intended to minimize the possibility<br />
of an Attorney going rogue.<br />
The new parts include the following.<br />
1. “Statutory test” for capability<br />
of the Adult to grant an EPOA<br />
2. Limits on who can be appointed<br />
Attorney: Paid caregivers are<br />
prohibited<br />
3. Attorney to sign the document<br />
in front of witnesses<br />
(to acknowledge he or she<br />
has a positive duty to act)<br />
4. Annual limits on gifts, loans,<br />
and charitable donations<br />
5. Listing of legal duties of Attorney<br />
(section 19) and their powers<br />
(section 20)<br />
6. Record-keeping responsibilities<br />
for Attorney<br />
7. Reporting abuse or neglect and<br />
protection for whistle-blowers<br />
8. Remedies available and<br />
jurisdiction of court<br />
9. Process for changing, revoking,<br />
and terminating the EPOA<br />
Some of those provisions were<br />
always understood to be the law.<br />
But they have been specifically spelled<br />
out in the statute now, to add clarity<br />
and certainty. Other statutory duties<br />
or powers have been created for the<br />
first time; some are mandatory and<br />
some can be modified by specific<br />
terms in the EPOA.<br />
Your legal representative<br />
needs to ensure you are<br />
capable of making the<br />
Power of Attorney document.<br />
Preliminary Considerations<br />
Capability<br />
Your legal representative needs<br />
to ensure you are capable of making<br />
the Power of Attorney document.<br />
As mentioned, the 2011 amendments<br />
set out a “statutory test” for whether<br />
an Adult is mentally capable<br />
of creating a valid Power of Attorney.<br />
There are presently six parts to the<br />
test. The Adult must understand<br />
the nature and consequences of the<br />
proposed EPOA and specifically<br />
understand the following.<br />
1. The property the Adult has and<br />
its approximate value<br />
2. The obligations the Adult owes<br />
to his or her dependants<br />
3. The fact that the Adult’s Attorney<br />
will be able to do, on the Adult’s<br />
behalf, anything in respect of the<br />
Adult’s financial affairs that<br />
the Adult could do if capable,<br />
except make a Will, subject to the<br />
conditions and restrictions set out<br />
in the EPOA<br />
4. The fact that unless the Attorney<br />
manages the Adult’s business and<br />
property prudently, their value may<br />
decline<br />
5. The fact that the Attorney might<br />
misuse the Attorney’s authority<br />
6. The fact that the Adult may,<br />
if capable, revoke the EPOA<br />
At the present time, the Regulations<br />
have no other “prescribed” matters.<br />
Your legal representative would<br />
go through each of the six points,<br />
discussing them with you or asking you<br />
to restate them in your own words.<br />
• What if there is some question<br />
of your capability to understand<br />
some or all of these points?<br />
• Are you lacking mental capacity?<br />
Some legal representatives have<br />
received little training on how<br />
to conduct an assessment of capability.<br />
While mental capability may<br />
seem to be a medical determination,<br />
in this case it is a legal determination<br />
that must be made by your legal<br />
representative or ultimately a judge.<br />
A medical opinion or assessment<br />
can assist in this process, but<br />
cannot on its own decide the matter.<br />
The American Bar Association,<br />
in conjunction with the American<br />
Psychological Association, has put out<br />
a useful handbook and tool for your<br />
legal representative to assess your<br />
capability. It is available here.<br />
http://www.apa.org/pi/aging/resources/<br />
guides/diminished-capacity.pdf<br />
Undue Influence<br />
Your legal representative will want<br />
to ensure that you are not under any<br />
“undue influence” when granting<br />
such power to someone else over your<br />
financial and legal affairs. The need<br />
to avoid undue influence when creating<br />
a Power of Attorney is not spelled out<br />
in the legislation. Section 34 sets out<br />
that one of the reasons someone may<br />
report to the PGT for an investigation<br />
is when “Fraud, undue pressure<br />
or some other form of abuse or neglect<br />
is being or was used to induce an<br />
Adult to make, change or revoke an<br />
Enduring Power of Attorney.”<br />
The <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> <strong>Law</strong><br />
<strong>Institute</strong>, featured in the Cover<br />
Story interview of this magazine,<br />
has developed a tool for legal<br />
representatives who are creating Last<br />
Wills—a checklist and set of red<br />
flags to ensure undue influence<br />
isn’t affecting the will-maker when<br />
Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013 The Scrivener 39
Alternatives<br />
to Enduring Powers of Attorney<br />
Section 7 Representation Agreement<br />
An Adult who is not capable of making an EPOA might still be capable<br />
of making a section 7 Representation Agreement (RA), which can give the<br />
Representative the powers to deal not just with personal care and medical<br />
care matters but also “routine financial management.” This includes most<br />
legal and financial matters other than matters that create longer-term financial<br />
obligations—loans, mortgages, credit cards, etc. See section 2 of the Regulation<br />
to the Representation Agreement Act for what is included. The “statutory test”<br />
for capability for a section 7 RA is less onerous—the Adult can be capable<br />
of making a section 7 Representation Agreement even though he or she is<br />
incapable of making a contract; of managing health care, personal care,<br />
or legal matters; or the routine management of financial affairs. See section 8<br />
of the Representation Agreement Act for the statutory capacity test. Note that<br />
a section 7 RA does not deal with end-of-life matters. That requires a section 9<br />
Representation Agreement with a higher standard of capability.<br />
Pension Trusteeship, to assist a senior with uncomplicated finances<br />
If the senior’s only source of income is Federal Income Security Programs<br />
(OAS/CPP), and they just pay rent, food, and utilities, a pension trusteeship<br />
may be all that is needed. A capable family member or friend can sign up with<br />
Income Security Programs to receive the senior’s pension funds as trustee<br />
to pay the rent and bills.<br />
Committee (Pronounced Kaw-mit-tay)<br />
If the Adult is incapable of making either an EPOA or section 7<br />
Representation Agreement, and the matter is more complicated than<br />
just managing OAS/CPP income, a concerned family member or friend<br />
would have to apply to court to be appointed as the “legal guardian”<br />
or “conservator” of the Adult’s estate (known in BC as “Committee<br />
(kaw-mit-tay) of the Estate”). That is an expensive and time-consuming<br />
process. The Public Guardian and Trustee (PGT) may be appointed<br />
as Committee of the Estate as a last resort, either by the court<br />
or a by “Certificate of Incapability” under the Patients Property Act.<br />
Trust Agreement<br />
An Adult with an EPOA can continue to act unilaterally until found to be incapable.<br />
Often times, an older Adult, while not incapable, may be quite vulnerable to undue<br />
influence or overreaching by family members, friends, or others.<br />
We have seen many capable older Adults who are simply unable to say no<br />
to a child demanding more and more money or who is demanding to be put<br />
on title of a property. Guilt or embarrassment may also be a factor.<br />
A properly drafted trust agreement, rather than an EPOA, can put all<br />
of the Adult’s property and income in trust, which can provide a “wall<br />
of protection”—the Adult can no longer act unilaterally; the trustee will say<br />
“no” in the Adult’s stead. A trust agreement maintains very private and secure<br />
control and management of a person’s assets and affairs; an EPOA will be<br />
cancelled if a Committee is appointed, which can result in the intervention<br />
of a relative you would have never chosen or the intervention of the PGT.<br />
A trust agreement can also provide more comprehensive terms of the<br />
trustee’s specific duties and powers than an EPOA, including a framework<br />
for management of property. A trust can survive death, ensuring<br />
uninterrupted management of affairs, while an EPOA ends at the death of the<br />
Adult. There are various other tax and planning benefits to a trust, beyond<br />
the scope of this article.<br />
instructing about the contents of the<br />
Will. The checklist and the red flags<br />
are easily adapted to be used to avoid<br />
undue influence in the creation<br />
of EPOAs. It is available here. http://<br />
www.bcli.org/sites/default/files/<br />
undue%20influence_guide_final_cip.<br />
pdf<br />
Choosing the Attorney<br />
A crucial part of the process<br />
in creating an EPOA is a discussion<br />
about who should be appointed.<br />
Your legal representative will advise<br />
that you need to implicitly trust the<br />
person to whom you handing over<br />
your affairs. In a worst-case scenario,<br />
that designated individual can clean<br />
out your bank account and abscond<br />
to another jurisdiction, leaving you<br />
penniless.<br />
• Given the record-keeping and<br />
reporting requirements, when<br />
choosing children or friends to be<br />
your Attorney, we recommend you<br />
select a “fastidious nerd” over<br />
a “sloppy klutz,” assuming they<br />
are equally trustworthy.<br />
• You may think you want to be<br />
“fair” by appointing more than<br />
one friend or family member<br />
to act jointly. You may think it<br />
will help ensure some “oversight”<br />
to have more than one person<br />
involved. You should think long<br />
and hard about that. Will it work<br />
in practice? You may be setting<br />
up your friends or loved ones<br />
for an ongoing, potentially divisive<br />
struggle.<br />
• Will the EPOA say the Attorneys<br />
must act independently or only<br />
jointly? (The “default” in the<br />
legislation, subject to what the<br />
EPOA says, is that they must act<br />
unanimously.)<br />
• Will all the individuals be available<br />
when required?<br />
• How will decisions be made?<br />
• If there are conflicts, how will they<br />
be resolved?<br />
Consider naming only one trusted<br />
person as your Attorney. To keep<br />
“peace in the family,” consider naming<br />
another as an alternate Attorney.<br />
A third person could be named your<br />
40 The Society of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013
Representative under a section 9<br />
Representation Agreement regarding<br />
health and personal care. Having an<br />
alternate Attorney named is a good<br />
idea where possible, in case the first<br />
Attorney has predeceased the Adult<br />
or is unable or unwilling to serve.<br />
Restrictions on Attorneys<br />
As mentioned, certain people are not<br />
permitted to be your Attorney. That is<br />
another way to ensure there was no<br />
undue influence when the document<br />
was created.<br />
To protect vulnerable Adults<br />
in institutions, your Attorney cannot<br />
be someone who provides personal<br />
care or health care services to you<br />
for compensation, including an owner,<br />
operator, employee, contractor,<br />
or volunteer of a licensed facility<br />
in which you reside and through which<br />
you receive personal care or health<br />
care services (Community Care and<br />
Assisted Living Act). The exception is<br />
if the individual is your child, parent,<br />
or spouse.<br />
Drafting Considerations<br />
Compensating the Attorney<br />
Acting as an Attorney can be a lot<br />
of work—paying bills, banking,<br />
appearing in court, record-keeping,<br />
reporting. Many Attorneys, especially<br />
family members, do this work<br />
for free. You have a choice<br />
as to whether your Attorney will<br />
be paid for the work. Providing<br />
for some compensation may prevent<br />
your Attorney from deciding to pay<br />
him or herself under the table<br />
as “deserved” compensation. On<br />
the other hand, setting out some<br />
compensation in the document may<br />
make the Attorney inclined to take<br />
more. For larger estates, often<br />
the annual compensation will be<br />
a percentage of the money managed.<br />
Note that even if you stipulate<br />
that your Attorney is not to be<br />
compensated for acting as your<br />
Attorney, the person can still<br />
be reimbursed from your money<br />
for reasonable expenses properly<br />
incurred in acting as your Attorney,<br />
for example, fees paid, reasonable<br />
required travel expenses, and other<br />
necessary “out-of-pocket” expenses.<br />
Reporting to others?<br />
Your Attorney’s only legal obligation is<br />
to report or account to you and to the<br />
PGT or the court, when required. Other<br />
concerned family members or friends<br />
cannot force your Attorney to account<br />
to them. Your legal representative<br />
might advise a clause in the EPOA<br />
that the Attorney has a duty to report<br />
to or render accounts to the people<br />
you specify. That will help ensure<br />
some ongoing oversight and prevent<br />
things taking a turn for the worse.<br />
You will be doing your<br />
Attorney a great favour<br />
if you prepare an inventory<br />
and financial accounting<br />
yourself…<br />
gifts<br />
Gifts are an important tool in many<br />
estate plans. That area is ripe<br />
for abuse, however. The legislation<br />
limits gifts to $5000 per year, unless<br />
otherwise stated in the EPOA.<br />
Investments<br />
Investments is another area that could<br />
lead to abuse. The legislation now<br />
states that an Attorney can invest only<br />
in the type of investments in which<br />
a trustee would invest under the<br />
Trustee Act, unless otherwise stated<br />
in the EPOA.<br />
Subsequent Considerations<br />
Roles and Responsibilities<br />
Your Attorney should appreciate the<br />
task he or she is taking on and the<br />
legal responsibilities and duties.<br />
We recommend that every<br />
newly signed Power of Attorney<br />
document given to an Attorney should<br />
include information on the roles and<br />
responsibilities of an Attorney.<br />
An example of such a document can<br />
be found at the Nidus website: http://<br />
www.nidus.ca/PDFs/Nidus_Info_Role_<br />
Attorney.pdf. Notary Laurie Salvador,<br />
with Salvador Davis and Company<br />
in Sidney, BC, has created a useful<br />
handout on the Responsibilities and<br />
Requirements of an Attorney.<br />
www.salvador-davis.com<br />
Inventory/Records<br />
The amendments to the Act have<br />
strengthened the record-keeping and<br />
reporting requirements of Attorneys,<br />
which will help prevent abuse. When<br />
the time comes for your Attorney<br />
to take over your affairs, the person<br />
is required to prepare an inventory<br />
of your assets and liabilities. Then<br />
while acting, the Attorney must keep<br />
the following records.<br />
• A current list of your property and<br />
liabilities, including an estimate<br />
of their value, if it is reasonable<br />
to do so<br />
• Accounts and other records<br />
respecting the exercise of the<br />
Attorney’s authority<br />
• All invoices, bank statements, and<br />
other records necessary to create<br />
full accounts respecting the<br />
receipt or disbursement, on your<br />
behalf, of capital or income<br />
You will be doing your Attorney<br />
a great favour if you prepare an<br />
inventory and financial accounting<br />
yourself, if you haven’t already—ideally<br />
in an “electronic spreadsheet.” Keep<br />
it updated for your Attorney to take<br />
over when the need arises. An updated<br />
listing of where all your important<br />
documents can be found will also be<br />
very useful to help your Attorney get<br />
started with the record-keeping and<br />
reporting duties. It is also a good<br />
impetus for you to finally “get your<br />
affairs in order”!<br />
Conclusion<br />
We have set out some of the things<br />
to be considered in creating an EPOA,<br />
to hopefully avoid any misuse or abuse<br />
by an Attorney going rogue.<br />
To summarize, the legislation now<br />
provides more clarity and protection.<br />
Your legal representative will also help<br />
protect you and your property by<br />
• ensuring you are capable and not<br />
“under influence”;<br />
• helping you choose the right<br />
person(s) as Attorney;<br />
• putting necessary terms and<br />
conditions in the EPOA; and<br />
• ensuring your Attorney knows his<br />
or her roles and responsibilities.<br />
Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013 The Scrivener 41
IT’S MORE THAN A GIFT. IT’S TIME.<br />
LEAVE A LEGACY<br />
OF YOUR OWN<br />
and feel great about<br />
the lives you’ll save<br />
Jane Westheuser<br />
Advisor, Gift Planning<br />
(604) 730-7370<br />
jwestheuser@hsf.bc.ca<br />
heartandstroke.bc.ca<br />
We never met,<br />
but you saved<br />
my life.<br />
You lifted me out of 40 years of<br />
addiction and gave me a second<br />
life. Today, I honour your legacy<br />
through my actions. I am now<br />
sober and happily married.<br />
I became a man who loves God,<br />
a published poet, and once again,<br />
a father to my daughters.<br />
Your legacy is my life and<br />
I thank God for you, every day.<br />
- John<br />
For over 70 years, Union Gospel<br />
Mission has been feeding hope and<br />
changing lives by serving society’s<br />
most vulnerable.<br />
To learn more about bequests to UGM,<br />
please contact Dwayne Benson at<br />
604.215.5434 ext 309 or dbenson@ugm.ca<br />
Many other matters not covered<br />
by this article should be reviewed<br />
when preparing an EPOA. Special<br />
requirements for EPOAs will be<br />
used for real estate transactions,<br />
for example, the Land Title Office<br />
will review the signing and required<br />
certification. Reference should always<br />
be made to the Power of Attorney Act,<br />
available under the “<strong>Law</strong>s” tab here:<br />
http://www.bclaws.ca/.<br />
Other resources to consider<br />
reviewing are set out in the list below.<br />
BCCEAS Seniors Abuse<br />
& Information Line<br />
Telephone: 604 437-1940<br />
Toll free: 1-866-437-1940<br />
admin@bcceas.ca<br />
www.bcceas.ca s<br />
Kevin Smith is a staff lawyer with<br />
the BC Centre for Elder Advocacy<br />
and Support (BCCEAS), a nonprofit<br />
organization that works to prevent and<br />
end elder abuse.<br />
Other Resources<br />
Nidus: Numerous fact sheets on<br />
EPOAs from the Nidus website.<br />
http://www.nidus.ca/?page_id=68<br />
Attorney General of BC: Incapacity<br />
planning page. http://www.ag.gov.<br />
bc.ca/incapacity-planning/ (This<br />
page includes a downloadable<br />
PDF version of an EPOA with<br />
instructions for completion.)<br />
Public Guardian and Trustee booklet<br />
on advance planning: “It’s Your<br />
Choice.” http://www.trustee.bc.ca/<br />
pdfs/STA/It%27s_Your_Choice-<br />
Personal_Planning_Tools.pdf<br />
Ministry of Health booklet<br />
on advance care planning:<br />
“My Voice.” http://www.<br />
health.gov.bc.ca/library/<br />
publications/year/2012/MyVoice-<br />
AdvanceCarePlanningGuide.pdf<br />
Canadian Bar Association fact<br />
sheet on Power of Attorney and<br />
Representation Agreement.<br />
http://www.cba.org/bc/public_<br />
media/wills/180.aspx<br />
(Also available in simplified<br />
Chinese, Mandarin, and Punjabi)<br />
42 The Society of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013
COMMUNITIES<br />
Award for Service<br />
with Distinction<br />
When we received the<br />
invite, my husband<br />
gary and I immediately<br />
scheduled to participate as<br />
witnesses to our friend and<br />
local fisherman Phil Eidsvik.<br />
A crowd was there to see The Honourable Kerry-Lynne<br />
D. Findlay, QC, Member of Parliament for Delta-Richmond<br />
East and Associate Minister of National Defence, present the<br />
Queen Elizabeth II Diamond Jubilee Medal to Delta resident<br />
Phil Eidsvik at a special ceremony in her Ladner office.<br />
“Phil Eidsvik has served the fishing community<br />
with distinction as an outspoken and untiring advocate<br />
for fishermen and more recently in his fundraising efforts<br />
with Fishermen Helping Kids with Cancer,” said Findlay.<br />
Former Delta MLA John Cummins spoke of the integrity<br />
and character of this selfless man who has been serving the<br />
fishing community for years.<br />
From left: Gary Nakashima; John Cummins; Phil Eidsvik;<br />
The Honourable Kerry-Lynne Findlay, QC; Phil’s daughter<br />
Andrea and his wife Lynette Vawter; and Tammy Morin-Nakashima<br />
We are all lucky to have<br />
a guy like Phil in our<br />
communities.<br />
Tammy Morin-Nakashima<br />
Having worked alongside Phil, Gary and<br />
I couldn’t agree more. Because he is the<br />
kind of man who prefers light to be<br />
shone on issues or tasks at hand and not<br />
on himself, we thought it fitting to share<br />
these insights about the person clearly<br />
deserving of accolade.<br />
To quote Ms. Findlay,<br />
“Phil Eidsvik attended Simon Fraser University and is currently<br />
enrolled in the University of London’s law program. Growing<br />
up in Prince Rupert, Phil developed a keen interest in the<br />
fishery and is a licensed commercial fisherman. For the past<br />
2 decades, he has been an advocate on behalf of fishermen,<br />
working to protect fishermen’s right of access to the fishery.<br />
“Phil has developed a recognized expertise in the regulatory<br />
framework of the fishery and the need for reform. As<br />
a result he has been called to appear before Parliamentary<br />
Committees on numerous occasions and has represented<br />
fishermen’s interest before the Cohen Inquiry.<br />
“He is a member of The Vancouver Sun’s Community<br />
of Interest panel, a Director of the Commercial Salmon<br />
Advisory Board, and a Director of the Southern Area E<br />
Gillnetters Association. For many years he has been<br />
Executive Director of the BC Fisheries Survival Coalition.<br />
“Phil is a basketball coach and a co-founder of Fishermen<br />
Helping Kids with Cancer, a group that raises funds<br />
to improve the quality of life for children receiving care<br />
at BC Children’s Hospital for cancer.<br />
“This award of the Queen’s Jubilee Medal to Phil Eidsvik is<br />
a fitting tribute to his selfless efforts on behalf of fishermen<br />
and the fishery.”<br />
We are all lucky to have a guy like Phil in our<br />
communities. s<br />
Tammy Morin-Nakashima is a local BC Notary,<br />
2nd Vice President of The Society of Notaries, and member<br />
of the Board of governors of the Notary Foundation.<br />
Her husband gary Nakashima is a local Steveston<br />
businessowner of Pacific Net & Twine Ltd. and a fisherman.<br />
Tammy@richmondnotary.ca<br />
Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013 The Scrivener 43
THE REaL ESTaTE fOUNDaTION Of BC<br />
Creating Sustainable<br />
Food Systems in BC<br />
A<br />
sustainable food system<br />
is a collaborative<br />
system that integrates<br />
the production, processing,<br />
distribution, and consumption<br />
of food and waste management<br />
in a manner that enhances the<br />
environmental, economic, and<br />
social health of a community.<br />
Seann Dory, Co-Director of Sole Food<br />
Farms, sells produce grown in Vancouver’s<br />
inner city at the Kitsilano Farmers’ Market.<br />
Sustainable food systems are a vital<br />
part of vibrant, healthy communities.<br />
In recent years, there has been<br />
growing concern about the resiliency<br />
of our local and regional food systems<br />
due to the effects of factors such<br />
as mounting oil prices, climate change,<br />
In recent years, there has been<br />
growing concern about the<br />
resiliency of our local and<br />
regional food systems…<br />
Celina Owen<br />
drought, loss of biodiversity, and urban<br />
growth pressures on agricultural land.<br />
Organizations across BC are<br />
responding to the current challenges<br />
in diverse ways. There are, however,<br />
common needs—best practice guides,<br />
model bylaws, farmland inventories,<br />
legal templates, and demonstration<br />
projects that educate, set precedents,<br />
raise awareness, and smooth the way<br />
for others to work toward sustainable<br />
food systems in their own regions.<br />
The Real Estate Foundation<br />
of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> is pleased to be<br />
Kelly Lerigny, Real Estate Foundation Chair; Jack Wong, CEO; Bill Swan, project lead;<br />
and Craig Edwards, energy advisor, tour Groundswell Network Society’s<br />
Community Greenhouse in Invermere.<br />
44 The Society of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013
Campbell River<br />
Prince George<br />
Sunshine<br />
Coast<br />
Capital<br />
Regional<br />
District<br />
Lower<br />
Mainland<br />
Kelowna<br />
…the Foundation is interested<br />
in projects that approach<br />
food system questions from<br />
a land use perspective.<br />
part of progressive, practical solutions<br />
to these challenges. The examples<br />
in this article illustrate some of the<br />
projects the Foundation has funded<br />
under its Sustainable Food Systems<br />
focus area.<br />
As a grant-maker whose mission<br />
is to transform land use attitudes and<br />
practices, the Foundation is interested<br />
in projects that approach food system<br />
questions from a land use perspective.<br />
By supporting nonprofit initiatives<br />
that seek both to remove barriers<br />
and contribute new approaches,<br />
the Foundation is investing in positive<br />
change and helping create more<br />
resilient food systems in BC.<br />
One of the benefits of being<br />
a funder with a provincial mandate<br />
is that the Real Estate Foundation<br />
has somewhat of a bird’s eye view.<br />
As such, it is often able to play the<br />
role of pivotal connector—linking<br />
organizations that might benefit from<br />
one another’s experience to advance<br />
shared goals.<br />
Some of the Sustainable Food Systems grants<br />
These are just 7 of 16 Sustainable Food Systems grants awarded by the<br />
Real Estate Foundation in 2011 and 2012. The Board of governors approved<br />
$757,000 to help nonprofit organizations with their food systems-related<br />
projects—nearly 15 percent of the dollar value of all Foundation grants<br />
in the 2-year period.<br />
Cowichan Green Community Society is a hub for food security initiatives<br />
in Vancouver Island’s Cowichan Valley. As part of its multifaceted work<br />
to create “edible neighbourhoods,” with food gardens and gathering spaces,<br />
the Society is establishing a youth-led urban farm enterprise on public<br />
parkland in North Cowichan. One key aspect of the project is research<br />
to identify how local bylaws would have to change to accommodate the farm.<br />
In the Lower Mainland, Vancouver Farmers Markets continues to advance the<br />
New City Market concept with plans to create a facility that includes a yearround<br />
farmers’ market, aggregation and distribution support, and a commercial<br />
kitchen for small-scale food processing. The goal is to meet the distribution<br />
needs of farmers and the demands of consumers for fresh local food, helping<br />
to bridge rural supply and urban demand.<br />
On the Sunshine Coast, Tides Canada is working with Deer Crossing the Arts<br />
Farm to research and compile recommendations for legal, planning, and<br />
marketing mechanisms that would allow the development of shared dwellings<br />
on small farm acreages. Policy recommendations and toolkits will be developed<br />
with input from professionals and area residents. The resources are intended<br />
to assist new farmers and boost local food production, both on the Sunshine<br />
Coast and in other parts of the province.<br />
In north-central BC, Community Futures Fraser Fort George is researching farm<br />
lease models and creating land lease resource packages tailored to northern<br />
and central BC. The packages will be part of education and training that aims<br />
to improve access to the region’s farmland for new farmers in the Highway 16<br />
region from Valemount to Terrace.<br />
Vancouver-based EcoDesign Resource Society developed the Urban Farming<br />
Guidebook to help local governments throughout the province plan for the<br />
business of growing food in their towns and cities. With “stories from the<br />
field” in Campbell River, Kelowna, Vancouver, and North Vancouver, as well<br />
as examples from even farther afield, the guide discusses urban farming<br />
matters and its economics; it also offers approaches for BC municipalities<br />
based on lessons learned.<br />
The Capital Region Food and Agriculture Initiatives Roundtable (CR-FAIR—<br />
an initiative of the Community Social Planning Council of Greater Victoria) is<br />
a group that draws on the strengths of a diverse membership. Using its builtin<br />
collaborative approach, CR-FAIR is employing research, consultation, and<br />
partnerships—among the farm community, real estate professionals, local<br />
governments, and other community stakeholders—to explore ways to preserve<br />
farmland in the Capital Regional District.<br />
In Vancouver, too, land for farming is scarce and expensive. Fresh Roots<br />
Urban Farm is expanding the land access model of using school board-owned<br />
and potentially other publicly owned lands, to set up market gardens that<br />
provide food for school cafeterias, outdoor learning opportunities for school<br />
children, and viable farming enterprises in the city. To date, Fresh Roots<br />
has partnered with six Vancouver schools.<br />
Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013 The Scrivener 45
Open Your Doors<br />
to a New Wave<br />
of Customers!<br />
The Boomer-Senior Market<br />
Wants to Do Business<br />
with People They Trust . . .<br />
People Who<br />
Have Taken the Time<br />
to Learn about Their Needs!<br />
We Have Helped<br />
Thousands of Businesses Grow<br />
by Teaching<br />
What Boomers and Seniors Want<br />
and<br />
How They Wish to Be Treated!<br />
Call Us Today<br />
to Learn<br />
How We Can Help<br />
Your Business Grow!<br />
Founder,<br />
Rhonda Latreille, MBA, CPCA<br />
1-877-272-8086<br />
www.CPCAcanada.com<br />
Communities across <strong>British</strong><br />
<strong>Columbia</strong> are becoming more involved<br />
in local food issues. That is good news<br />
because it means people are paying<br />
attention to, and taking responsibility<br />
for, the way they sustain themselves.<br />
It also means questions about the<br />
entire food system are increasingly<br />
being brought into public discourse.<br />
The Real Estate Foundation<br />
will continue to be a part of the<br />
conversation on the land use challenges<br />
we are facing now, and those that may<br />
emerge in the future.<br />
Resources and Inspiration<br />
For details of the Sustainable Food<br />
Systems focus area, visit the “Grants”<br />
section of the Real Estate Foundation’s<br />
website (refbc.com/grants). Click on<br />
“Grants program focus areas” in the<br />
menu on the left.<br />
To access the Urban Farming<br />
Guidebook and other resources,<br />
hover over “Resources” and click on<br />
“Sustainable food systems” in the<br />
drop-down menu.<br />
Communities across<br />
<strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> are<br />
becoming more involved<br />
in local food issues.<br />
Published in January 2013, the guide<br />
is available in the Resources section<br />
of the Foundation’s website.<br />
To watch videos that feature the<br />
food systems work of Cowichan Green<br />
Community, Groundswell Network<br />
Society, and Sole Food Farms, go<br />
to the Foundation’s YouTube channel<br />
accessible from our website. “Creating<br />
an Edible Neighbourhood” is in the<br />
2011 Land Awards playlist; the other<br />
two projects are in the 2012 Land<br />
Awards playlist. s<br />
Celina Owen is manager,<br />
Communications & Administration, with<br />
the Real Estate Foundation of BC. Please<br />
contact her with questions about the<br />
grants program, the Land Awards, or the<br />
Real Estate Foundation in general.<br />
Telephone: 604 688-6800, X 103<br />
Toll free: 1-866-912-6800<br />
celina@refbc.com<br />
Cowichan Green Community’s Executive Director Judy Stafford and Amanda Reimer,<br />
Communications & Administration Coordinator, take Jack Wong on a tour of their activities<br />
at North Cowichan’s Kinsmen Park, site of the youth urban farm, community gardens,<br />
and the “green” retrofit of a derelict building.<br />
46 The Society of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013
LETTERS LETTERS LETTERS LETTERS<br />
Winter 2012, Volume 21, Number 4<br />
It is a beautiful issue<br />
on many levels . . .<br />
its design, its extensive<br />
and varied content,<br />
the positive and<br />
inclusive theme, and<br />
the coincidental timing<br />
of the New year! Well done.<br />
It’s good to be part of it.<br />
Nigel Atkin<br />
Natkin2020@gmail.com<br />
I enjoyed reading the<br />
latest issue of The<br />
Scrivener. It featured<br />
articles and insights<br />
about Canadian<br />
citizenship. In particular,<br />
I found the feature story<br />
“Citizens if the World, United” to be<br />
fascinating. So many facets of becoming<br />
a citizen were revealed in the Cover Story<br />
by the three BC Notaries. Also I loved<br />
reading about Vancouver’s history.<br />
Bob Reid provided many fascinating facts<br />
and anecdotes about our colourful city.<br />
Paul Avery<br />
Retired teacher of intro and abnormal<br />
psychology and group dynamics and<br />
music Therapy program at Capilano<br />
College<br />
pavery@shaw.ca<br />
We Love to Hear<br />
From You!<br />
scrivener@society.notaries.bc.ca<br />
I read the Winter<br />
Scrivener yesterday<br />
and was shocked<br />
by some of the questions<br />
[in the Keynote article]<br />
that prospective<br />
Canadian citizens<br />
must answer about citizenship. off the<br />
top of my head, I knew one answer!<br />
Canada is looking for a way to celebrate<br />
our 150th Anniversary in 2017.<br />
The Celebration Committee<br />
(I’m sure there must be one) could<br />
organize a Q&A for native-born<br />
Canadians. Everyone who can<br />
answer the questions correctly could<br />
receive something official from the<br />
government—a pin, or button, or<br />
a certificate.<br />
Pauline Buck<br />
Retired PR person<br />
www.homeontheranch.info<br />
The article “Abuse<br />
Prevention Program for<br />
older Adults” by grace<br />
Balbutin, Director<br />
of Public Education,<br />
is so timely. The story<br />
very recently aired on<br />
W5, “Crisis in Care”<br />
(http://www.ctvnews.ca/<br />
video?binId=1.811589),<br />
documents how vigilant we need to be<br />
and further demonstrates how some<br />
authorities seem to pass responsibility<br />
back and forth, creating gaps in services.<br />
our “Community Connectivity<br />
Forum” recently hosted a free forum<br />
for seniors presented by oceanside<br />
Healthy Aging Initiative and the<br />
greater Victoria Eldercare Foundation<br />
in Qualicum Beach: Be Well, Be Secure,<br />
Be Connected, Be Enriched.<br />
Elise Willson<br />
oDETT<br />
oceanside Dementia<br />
Education Task Team<br />
gladysu@telus.net<br />
CONTINUaTION<br />
Wills, Estates<br />
and Succession Act<br />
from page 7<br />
The new Act will change<br />
significantly the law of Wills<br />
and estates in our province.<br />
Here are some of the highlights.<br />
• The survivorship rule has been<br />
changed from the arbitrary “younger<br />
survives older” to have the estate<br />
pass to each person’s alternate<br />
beneficiaries.<br />
• A minimum 5-day survival rule has<br />
been added. Most Wills already<br />
have a longer (20+ day) survivorship<br />
requirements; those will still be<br />
allowed.<br />
• A spouse’s right to life estate in the<br />
spousal home on intestacy has been<br />
eliminated. Instead, the spousal share<br />
in the estate has been increased and<br />
the spouse has a right to choose the<br />
spousal home as part of his or her<br />
share of the estate.<br />
• The age of a person who can make<br />
a Will has been lowered to 16 years.<br />
• The ban on gifts to witnesses of a Will<br />
is eliminated. Such gifts are allowed,<br />
if there is evidence the deceased<br />
approved of the gift. The ban was<br />
often unfair.<br />
• The Act presumes undue influence<br />
if it is shown that the deceased<br />
was dependent on (or there was the<br />
potential for domination by) a person<br />
to whom the deceased gave a gift in<br />
the Will. This is the law for gifts given<br />
during a person’s life.<br />
• It is easier to revoke a Will. Often,<br />
people would commit acts that clearly<br />
expressed intent to revoke a Will but<br />
did not meet the formal requirements.<br />
• The court has been given the power<br />
to “cure” deficiencies in a document<br />
that does not meet the formal<br />
requirements to be considered a Will<br />
if the court is satisfied that the<br />
document expresses the true wishes<br />
of the deceased. s<br />
Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013 The Scrivener 47
©iStockphoto.com/Dragan Grkic<br />
PROPERTY IN BRITISH COLUMBIa<br />
A Day in the Life<br />
of a Real Estate Appraiser<br />
Real estate appraising<br />
is an interesting,<br />
rewarding, but sometimes<br />
misunderstood profession.<br />
People sometimes see blurred<br />
boundaries among real estate<br />
appraisers, real estate agents, and<br />
home inspectors. That is likely due<br />
to the wide diversity of the work that<br />
Appraisal <strong>Institute</strong> of Canada members<br />
undertake in providing market-value<br />
appraisals and consulting services.<br />
The question burning in the minds<br />
of Canadians is, What exactly does a real<br />
estate appraiser do in a typical day?<br />
Here is a day in the life of an<br />
appraiser in <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong>.<br />
Three properties will be inspected,<br />
including a single-family dwelling,<br />
a farm-turned-marijuana-growoperation,<br />
and a 40-unit motel.<br />
Appraisers estimate the<br />
market value of the home<br />
while home inspectors<br />
estimate the physical<br />
condition of the home.<br />
As part of the appraisal process,<br />
the appraiser completes a “preliminary<br />
investigation” of the properties prior<br />
to the inspections. That includes<br />
a search for<br />
• current or historical real<br />
estate data including sales<br />
of comparable-type properties,<br />
• municipal tax data,<br />
• physical data about the property,<br />
• survey plans,<br />
• easements or rights of way<br />
affecting the property,<br />
• zoning bylaws,<br />
• demographic data, and<br />
• a determination of what local<br />
services and utilities are in place<br />
for the properties.<br />
Paul Fischer<br />
First Inspection of the Day:<br />
A 20-year-old single-family dwelling<br />
I enter the neighbourhood, visually<br />
assessing the desirability and the<br />
Subject Property location. Yes, it<br />
really does affect the market value<br />
of your home if you are located<br />
next to a major highway or a meatrendering<br />
plant. In this case, neither<br />
factor applies and the owner greets<br />
me at the door with a dog who is<br />
not convinced I should be there.<br />
Aha! I have developed the ultimate<br />
recycling use for the biscuits my own<br />
dog will not eat. Two biscuits and the<br />
Shepherd is ready to be roommates!<br />
Real estate appraisers work<br />
primarily with exterior measurements<br />
and make adjustments within the<br />
appraisal for variations in floor plans,<br />
bedrooms, bathrooms, suites, and<br />
so on. I complete an interior and<br />
exterior inspection of the home<br />
to identify its physical characteristics<br />
and condition that I will then compare<br />
to similar homes that have sold in the<br />
neighbourhood.<br />
Dollar adjustments calculated<br />
in the report will account for the<br />
physical differences between and<br />
among the properties that have sold.<br />
Appraisers complete a visual inspection<br />
of a property to determine its condition<br />
and consider any obvious damage<br />
or known repair issues.<br />
48 The Society of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013
Unlike home inspectors, we do not<br />
complete a detailed physical inspection<br />
of all the components. Appraisers<br />
estimate the market value of the home<br />
while home inspectors estimate the<br />
physical condition of the home.<br />
In this case, the home is<br />
in good condition with no abnormal<br />
depreciation noted. The owner<br />
requests the market value estimate<br />
of the property. Appraisers prefer not<br />
to estimate the market value before<br />
completing the detailed adjustment<br />
process accounting for the differences<br />
with the comparable sale indicators<br />
in the neighbourhood.<br />
Second Stop of the Day:<br />
A farm-turned-cash-cow with<br />
a marijuana-grow-operation now<br />
dismantled and in foreclosure<br />
The preliminary investigation included<br />
review of air-quality test reports and<br />
remediation and restoration estimates<br />
provided by the client. My inspection<br />
reveals the home and barn were used<br />
for the grow-op and both require<br />
significant remediation and restoration.<br />
That is a valuation challenge because<br />
the farm land retains value and I must<br />
determine what market value remains<br />
in the damaged improvements.<br />
My Final Stop: An owner-operated<br />
motel near the entrance to town<br />
A tour of the property is provided<br />
by the owner to assess the overall<br />
layout, general condition, and<br />
characteristics of the property. After<br />
the inspection we return to the<br />
motel office where he provides me<br />
with current and historical financial<br />
statements for the property. Those<br />
items are critical because the market<br />
value of the property will be based<br />
on the information in the financial<br />
statements.<br />
I will review the statements<br />
and “stabilize” them to provide<br />
a longer-term picture of the financial<br />
performance of the property. The<br />
financial performance will then be<br />
compared with other motels that<br />
have previously transacted in the<br />
marketplace.<br />
Note: To “stabilize” the financial<br />
statements means the appraiser<br />
reviews several years of financial<br />
statements because there can<br />
be fluctuations in the year-overyear<br />
financial performance of the<br />
property. Stabilizing removes the<br />
peaks and valleys so that year-to-year<br />
variations in the financial performance<br />
of the property do not exaggerate the<br />
market value of the property either<br />
up or down. For example, a person<br />
could own a commercial property that<br />
was vacant for 6 months in 1 year but<br />
fully occupied for the next 5 years.<br />
Stabilizing removes<br />
the peaks and valleys<br />
so that year-to-year<br />
variations… do not<br />
exaggerate the market value<br />
of the property either up<br />
or down.<br />
Back to the Office<br />
The onsite inspections are now<br />
complete and I return to the office.<br />
The remainder of my week will be<br />
spent correlating information from<br />
the preliminary investigations and<br />
physical data from the inspections<br />
of the properties, with further market<br />
data research still to be completed.<br />
When sufficient information<br />
has been assembled, I will quantify<br />
my findings in appraisal reports with<br />
market-value estimates for all three<br />
properties.<br />
Tomorrow will bring an<br />
equally diverse group of properties<br />
to appraise! s<br />
Paul Fischer, AACI, PApp, CRP, is<br />
a partner in Thompson Rivers Appraisals<br />
and Vision Property Advisors. These<br />
companies provide residential and<br />
commercial Real Estate Appraisals and<br />
Strata Depreciation Reports.<br />
Telephone: 250 372-2599<br />
pfischer@trappraisals.ca<br />
Editor’s<br />
Prefer Paperless?<br />
Would you prefer to read<br />
The Scrivener online rather than<br />
receive it via Canada Post?<br />
We will add you to our secure<br />
notification list and no longer mail<br />
you a paper copy.<br />
www.notaries.bc.ca/scrivener<br />
scrivener@society.notaries.bc.ca<br />
NExT ISSuE: Summer 2013<br />
Stratas<br />
Our theme will focus on the new<br />
legislation for stratas and some<br />
interesting experiences around<br />
strata living and strata councils.<br />
The MiX<br />
The MiX showcases articles on<br />
a variety of timely topics.<br />
Considering submitting an article?<br />
Please write to<br />
scrivener@society.notaries.bc.ca.<br />
Deadline for Summer Articles:<br />
May 15<br />
To send photographs<br />
to the magazine, please . . .<br />
• go to www.graffiki.ca, and click on<br />
“Send A File.”<br />
• From the top box, delete the words<br />
“Your e-mail.”<br />
• In that now-empty box,<br />
type your email address.<br />
• Send up to 5 photos at once.<br />
• Repeat as necessary.<br />
Deadline for Advertising Space<br />
June 12<br />
scrivener@society.notaries.bc.ca<br />
Telephone: 604 985-9250<br />
www.notaries.bc.ca/scrivener<br />
Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013 The Scrivener 49<br />
©iStockphoto.com/zxcynosure
TaKE 5 fOR fITNESS<br />
Relax and<br />
Rejuvenate<br />
After a few hours in front of the computer,<br />
when you feel tired and sore in the neck,<br />
shoulders, and back, take a break.<br />
yoga helps achieve balance in other aspects of life,<br />
helping to build self-confidence and self-esteem.<br />
maryAnne models the beginner’s poses, on the left.<br />
Tree Pose<br />
Health Benefits: Improves balance and stability in the<br />
legs and pelvis, strengthens ligaments and tendons of the<br />
feet, strengthens and tones the standing leg and buttocks,<br />
strengthens hip bones and legs through weight-bearing.<br />
a. Stand with arms at sides. When balanced, bring hands<br />
in front of you with palms together.<br />
b. Bring your right foot to the inside of your left ankle,<br />
keeping your toes on the floor for balance. Stay<br />
for 30 seconds. Lower and repeat on opposite side.<br />
c. As you get stronger and develop better balance, move<br />
your foot to the inside of your left calf. Shift weight<br />
onto left leg and place sole of right foot inside left<br />
thigh; keep eyes and hips facing forward.<br />
Downward Facing Dog and Full Forward Bend<br />
Health Benefits: Builds strength, flexibility and awareness;<br />
stretches the spine and hamstrings; rests the heart.<br />
Downward Dog<br />
MaryAnne Galey<br />
Begin on hands and knees with hands shoulder-width apart<br />
and knees hip-width apart. Inhale, curl the toes under,<br />
exhale, lifting the hips up and back while straightening<br />
the legs, sit bones pointing to the sky. Inhale; lengthen the<br />
spine back through the tailbone. Stretch away from hands<br />
and wrists, bringing the abdomen closer to thighs. The head<br />
should be comfortable, with ears in-line with arms.<br />
Stretch the heels toward the floor; they do not have to touch<br />
the floor. Breathe in and out from the heels, up the legs,<br />
and through the spine; stay focused and keep the breath<br />
moving through the entire body. Hold for as long as it is<br />
comfortable.<br />
Full Forward Bend<br />
In Downward Dog pose (above), inhale, put feet together,<br />
straighten legs, exhale, push back hips, draw chest closer<br />
to thighs and relax. Rest by bringing both knees to the floor,<br />
hips on the heels, forehead on the floor, arms back beside<br />
the legs. Exhale and slowly roll up to standing.<br />
50 The Society of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013
Crescent Lunge<br />
Health Benefits: Increases heart rate, speeds up metabolism,<br />
stretches legs and hips.<br />
Standing tall, exhale and step the right foot back<br />
into a lunge position, keeping left leg just slightly bent.<br />
Inhale; raise arms straight above head. Bend deeper<br />
into left knee until the left thigh is parallel to the ground<br />
and the right knee is almost touching the ground. Exhale<br />
and return right leg to standing. Switch sides and repeat.<br />
Warrior II<br />
Health Benefits: Strengthens legs; stretches groin, chest,<br />
and shoulders; helps self-confidence.<br />
Stand tall with feet together and arms by sides. Step legs<br />
about 3 feet apart and extend arms out to the sides at<br />
shoulder height, palms facing down. Turn left foot and<br />
leg out 90 degrees to the left, lining up the heel of left foot<br />
with the arch of right foot. Inhale. As you exhale, bend left<br />
knee, forming a right angle with left thigh and shin.<br />
Stack knee directly above ankle in-line with second toe.<br />
Hint: Lining up front knee with second toe and placing thigh<br />
parallel to the floor protects and strengthens the muscles<br />
around the knee.<br />
Relax shoulders away from ears and turn head to gaze out<br />
over left hand. Reach through your arms, feeling a line<br />
of energy from the tips of right fingers through the tips<br />
of left fingers. Relax your jaw. Hold for 3 to 10 slow deep<br />
breaths. To come out of the pose, turn head to face forward,<br />
straighten left leg, and rotate it to bring feet to parallel.<br />
Turn right leg out 90 degrees to switch sides and repeat.<br />
Reverse Warrior<br />
Health Benefits: Strengthens legs and abs; stretches inner<br />
thighs, hips, groin; keeps spine flexible.<br />
Begin in Warrior II pose with right leg in front. Inhale;<br />
lower left hand to left leg and slide it down toward ankle.<br />
Exhale; turn right palm toward the ceiling and arc right arm<br />
up overhead, reaching back without moving legs. Turn gaze<br />
up. Inhale. With palms facing down, start slowly lowering<br />
right arm and lifting left arm until both are shoulder height.<br />
Switch sides and repeat.<br />
Extended Side Angle<br />
Health Benefits: Strengthens ankles, legs, core, upper arms;<br />
stretches legs, hips, chest, and shoulders; helps digestion.<br />
Begin in Warrior II pose with left knee bent. Exhale; lower<br />
left elbow to left knee; reach right arm up (as shown above).<br />
Pull shoulder blade back, reaching arm alongside right ear.<br />
Extend body in a long line from the outside of right foot<br />
through the fingertips of right hand.<br />
Open chest by turning torso up toward the ceiling from<br />
the bottom of waist, moving ribs away from the top of hip.<br />
Look up without hurting neck. Inhale and return to centre.<br />
Hold for 5 breaths. Switch sides and repeat.<br />
Happy Fitness!<br />
For more 5-Minute Fitness Tips, visit YogaRVing<br />
www.yogarving.com/5-minute-fit-tip/. s<br />
MaryAnne Galey worked with Scotiabank’s cash and treasury<br />
management services for 35 years. She is now a businessowner<br />
and co-creator of yogaRVing and yogayachting. With a good part<br />
of her day working in front of a computer and wanting to keep<br />
fit, she finds that the benefits of yoga provide her with strength,<br />
balance, and relaxation. yogaRVing is an all-season take-along<br />
fitness program to help you get even better control of your health.<br />
info@yogarving.com<br />
Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013 The Scrivener 51
SUCCESS<br />
After 22 years of research and practice<br />
about how to have a more successful life,<br />
to me these are the top-3 life habits.<br />
They don’t take much time but they make<br />
a huge difference.<br />
1. Daily Appreciations<br />
The human mind by default will focus on the negative<br />
aspects of your life, yet it’s a universal truth that what<br />
you focus on grows. That bad habit of mind will get<br />
you more of what you don’t want.<br />
Here’s what I do.<br />
Each night before sleep, I write down<br />
what I appreciate about myself and my<br />
life circumstances. It takes 2 minutes<br />
and definitely improves my sense of life<br />
satisfaction and improves my success<br />
in all areas of life because what you<br />
appreciate tends to appreciate.<br />
I invite you to try it<br />
right now.<br />
Take just 1 minute<br />
to make a list of five things you<br />
appreciate about yourself and<br />
the circumstances in your life.<br />
Notice how you feel after you do it.<br />
Carla Rieger<br />
3 Small Habits<br />
that Will Change your Life<br />
Forever<br />
The human mind by default will focus on the<br />
negative aspects of your life, yet it’s a universal<br />
truth that what you focus on grows.<br />
2. Mentally Rehearse<br />
How You Want Your Day to Go<br />
Many top achievers use this trick—pro athletes, great<br />
leaders, musicians, actors, salespeople, and so on. I start<br />
my day by running through in my mind all the things that<br />
are coming up that day and seeing them go well. It could<br />
be everything from finding a great parking spot to having<br />
a successful meeting to getting important jobs done<br />
to having a fun evening with friends. It takes<br />
only 1 to 5 minutes and it greatly increases<br />
your chances of having a great day.<br />
Try it right now.<br />
Think of how you want<br />
the next hour to go.<br />
How do you want to feel?<br />
What do you want<br />
to accomplish?<br />
What circumstances<br />
would be ideal?<br />
Notice how you feel after you do<br />
that exercise.<br />
©iStockphoto.com/Skynesher<br />
52 The Society of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013
3. Stop to<br />
Orient Yourself<br />
to “The Now”<br />
If I find myself racing around, being<br />
impatient, lost in thought, I stop<br />
for 1 minute. I orient myself to the<br />
present moment by using my five<br />
senses—sight, sound, feelings, touch,<br />
taste. Most of us spend our time<br />
planning the future or ruminating over<br />
the past. That can fragment the mind<br />
and cause disharmony and stress.<br />
Getting present even for 1 minute can<br />
trigger relaxation hormones in your bodymind<br />
system and lighten your mood.<br />
Try it right now.<br />
Time yourself for 1 minute.<br />
What do you see in front of you?<br />
Listen to the sounds nearby.<br />
Feel what it’s like to sit in your chair.<br />
Sense your emotional state right now.<br />
Notice if there are any smells<br />
in the air.<br />
Can you taste anything . . .<br />
a sip of coffee?<br />
Savour each sensory experience.<br />
Notice how you feel after you do it.<br />
Those three small habits will provide<br />
you with a big result over time! s<br />
Carla Rieger is an expert on<br />
communication skills at work and<br />
the author of Storytelling in Business.<br />
http://www.carlarieger.com/online_<br />
store/#storytelling<br />
She leads an online group-coaching<br />
method called “Winning Them over,”<br />
a step-by-step process for creating your<br />
personal marketing presentation.<br />
Telephone: 604 222-2276<br />
1-866-294-2988<br />
Carla@ArtistryofChange.com<br />
www.WinningThemover.com<br />
Publications<br />
Conveyancing<br />
Deskbook<br />
A practical how-to<br />
guide to the transfer<br />
of land in BC<br />
uPcoming courses<br />
Advanced<br />
Conveyancing<br />
Topics for Legal<br />
Support Staff<br />
June 7<br />
1.800.663.0437<br />
500 – 1155 West Pender Street<br />
Vancouver, BC V6E 2P4<br />
Wills Precedents —<br />
An Annotated<br />
Guide<br />
Draft plain language<br />
wills with ease<br />
Wills Drafting<br />
Workshop<br />
MAy 2 & 3<br />
BC Notaries<br />
Speak<br />
your Language<br />
BC Notaries around the province<br />
offer many noncontentious<br />
legal services (see page 61)<br />
in an impressive variety of languages.<br />
English<br />
Arabic<br />
Bulgarian<br />
Cantonese<br />
Croatian<br />
Dutch<br />
Farsi<br />
Filipino<br />
Flemish<br />
Fookien<br />
French<br />
German<br />
Gujarati<br />
Hindi<br />
Italian<br />
Japanese<br />
Korean<br />
Malaysian<br />
Mandarin<br />
Persian<br />
Polish<br />
Portuguese<br />
Punjabi<br />
Romanian<br />
Russian<br />
Serbian<br />
Shanghaiese<br />
Spanish<br />
Swahili<br />
Swatow<br />
Swiss<br />
Swiss German<br />
Tagalog<br />
Taiwanese<br />
Tamil<br />
Taoshan<br />
Telegu<br />
Urdu<br />
Vietnamese<br />
Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013 The Scrivener 53
MEDIaTION<br />
We hear the term<br />
mediation more and<br />
more, yet for many<br />
it remains an elusive concept.<br />
A concise, theoretical definition<br />
of mediation might be “a method<br />
of dispute resolution in which a neutral<br />
third party facilitates dialogue<br />
between two or among more disputing<br />
parties to resolve the dispute outside<br />
of traditional court processes.”<br />
After reading that, are we any<br />
closer to knowing what mediation is?<br />
Sometimes it’s easiest<br />
to begin with what mediation is not.<br />
• Mediation is not like litigation.<br />
Litigation involves a system of rules<br />
and limitations that has evolved over<br />
centuries to ensure procedural fairness<br />
between or among disputing parties.<br />
It often involves lawyers to speak<br />
for the parties and help navigate those<br />
rules and, ultimately, a judge or jury<br />
to decide the outcome. Litigation<br />
has value and will remain a necessary<br />
system, but it is not the only way.<br />
• Mediation is not a system of rules.<br />
It is a means of communication.<br />
Mediation does not involve document<br />
filings, discovery, or court appearances<br />
nor does it require a long wait<br />
or high costs. Instead, mediation is<br />
a less formal, accessible, flexible<br />
process that usually involves the<br />
WHAT IS<br />
©iStockphoto.com/Kerrick<br />
parties meeting together with<br />
a mediator in a neutral setting and<br />
working it out.<br />
The Process<br />
Generally speaking, the mediation<br />
process begins when both parties<br />
agree to mediate, and then agree<br />
on a mediator. As a public resource,<br />
Mediate BC maintains a Roster<br />
of qualified mediators for both civil<br />
and family mediation.<br />
Litigation has value and will<br />
remain a necessary system,<br />
but it is not the only way.<br />
Renee Collins Goult<br />
Typically, before the mediation<br />
begins, each side prepares a summary<br />
of the issue, which the mediator<br />
reviews, or each party meets with<br />
the mediator individually to provide<br />
some details. The new Family <strong>Law</strong><br />
Act will require a fuller pre-mediation<br />
process for family mediations to allow<br />
the mediator to screen for safety and<br />
to ensure mediation is appropriate<br />
in the circumstances.<br />
Once the pre-mediation details<br />
are completed, a meeting date and<br />
a neutral location is chosen, which<br />
can be a set of Boardrooms, an office,<br />
or even virtual online space. What<br />
happens next is entirely flexible and<br />
can be determined according to the<br />
circumstances.<br />
?<br />
Often, the mediator will begin with<br />
an introduction and invite each party<br />
to summarize why he or she is there.<br />
At this point, relations may be strained,<br />
with polite discussion only a remote<br />
possibility. The mediator helps start<br />
that discussion and assists each<br />
side in taking part. Sometimes the<br />
mediator suggests taking breaks<br />
in separate rooms so the mediator can<br />
talk with each side privately. When<br />
parties return to the table, they can<br />
discuss decisions they have made,<br />
or issues that remain problematic.<br />
A good mediator can get parties<br />
talking to each other, can help identify<br />
common goals, and ultimately find<br />
a resolution that works for all.<br />
Why Choose Mediation?<br />
In mediation, the parties themselves<br />
have input, which is both powerful<br />
and effective. Whether it involves their<br />
business, their home, their illness,<br />
or their finances, rarely does anyone<br />
know the details better than the parties<br />
themselves. The resolution becomes<br />
more meaningful and effective when<br />
the parties contribute to it.<br />
While litigation can be polarizing,<br />
mediation allows parties to preserve<br />
important relationships. Whether<br />
the dispute is with a valuable client,<br />
a supplier, a family member, or a close<br />
neighbour, the focus is on resolving<br />
the dispute in a way that keeps<br />
relationships intact. Mediators help<br />
shape the discussion to promote<br />
respect and common goals and<br />
54 The Society of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013
generate creative ideas to resolve<br />
the dispute. If not confined to the<br />
parameters of a potential judgment<br />
from the court, parties are free<br />
to come up with their own and often<br />
unique solutions.<br />
Mediation also encourages the<br />
open flow of information in a way<br />
litigation cannot. The goal is resolution,<br />
rather than the best positioning for trial.<br />
In mediation, everything shared is<br />
confidential and can’t be used against<br />
you in court. Disclosure is important<br />
if parties are to fully understand each<br />
other. Most times, once parties have<br />
had a chance to fully discuss issues,<br />
resolution becomes a real possibility.<br />
Significantly, mediation is timely,<br />
immediate, and a fraction of the<br />
cost of litigation. With this flexible<br />
process, mediation can take a single<br />
day or several days, depending on the<br />
parties’ preference and progress.<br />
Some are reluctant to give up the<br />
litigation option, fearing they will have<br />
to share too much, make too great<br />
a compromise, or fail to resolve the<br />
dispute at all. Fortunately, choosing<br />
mediation doesn’t exclude other<br />
options. Even if the mediation doesn’t<br />
fully resolve the dispute, parties<br />
often gain clarity of issues, improved<br />
communication, or even partial<br />
solutions. Resulting or continuing<br />
litigation is streamlined, more<br />
efficient, and less costly.<br />
So what is mediation? Simply put,<br />
it’s an efficient, cost-effective process<br />
of problem-solving that works. s<br />
Note: Many BC Notaries are trained<br />
as professional mediators.<br />
Renee Collins Goult is mediateBC’s<br />
Roster Program manager and<br />
a mediator and a lawyer. Before<br />
restricting her practice to mediation,<br />
she practised law in the areas of personal<br />
injury and general civil litigation.<br />
mediate BC<br />
Telephone: 604 681-6050<br />
renee.collinsgoult@mediatebc.com<br />
Quantum mediation<br />
Telephone: 604 924-1188<br />
renee@quantummediation.com<br />
Heather MacLean, BComm, CGA<br />
Senior Estate Accountant<br />
Phone: 604-524-8688<br />
Email: heather@mti-cga.com<br />
Web: www.mti-cga.com<br />
ESTATES • TAXATION • TRUSTS • ACCOUNTING<br />
Many of my clients are Executors, Notaries, and <strong>Law</strong>yers<br />
who come to me from all over BC and Canada. I help my<br />
clients understand and navigate through the complexities<br />
surrounding death and taxes.<br />
I provide essential expertise required to minimize income<br />
taxes and expedite final distributions.<br />
Our firm provides advice on and preparation of:<br />
• Unfiled prior tax returns and adjustments<br />
• Date of Death T1 (Terminal T1) and optional tax returns<br />
• Estate T3 tax returns to final distribution<br />
• Tax Clearance Certificates<br />
• Estate accounting<br />
#350 – 522 Seventh Street, New Westminster, BC V3M 5T5<br />
You’ve always been there for others.<br />
You can continue to give beyond your lifetime.<br />
Your gift<br />
Your generosity will help us<br />
be here tomorrow for those who need us.<br />
Our vision<br />
For over 30 years, we have had a clear vision:<br />
people with disabilities having genuine<br />
independence, living with dignity, and<br />
contributing and sharing in our communities.<br />
BC Coalition of People with Disabilities<br />
advocacy since 1977<br />
Please contact us about planned giving. BC Coalition of People with Disabilities<br />
Tel 604-875-0188 • TTY 604-875-8835 • nicole@bccpd.bc.ca • www.bccpd.bc.ca<br />
Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013 The Scrivener 55
SERVING SENIORS<br />
We know the<br />
numbers—by 2015,<br />
we will have more<br />
people over the age of 65<br />
than under the age of 15.<br />
No Easy Answers<br />
Called the Canadian Phenomenon,<br />
it has never happened before in our<br />
history. The aging tsunami is crashing<br />
our shores and leaving some interesting<br />
challenges in its wake.<br />
Some of the challenges are<br />
demanding a new dialogue that<br />
frankly offers up no easy answers. But<br />
nonetheless, it is a dialogue we must<br />
start to explore. The following true<br />
story is a case in point.<br />
A vital and dynamic woman<br />
in her 80s meets some friends<br />
for lunch. Upon leaving<br />
the restaurant, Mary<br />
walks past a travel<br />
agency and the<br />
lure of ships and the<br />
sea calls out to her.<br />
She has a long history<br />
of cruising and has in fact<br />
written some bestselling<br />
books while on board. The wonderful<br />
memories take over; she pops<br />
into the agency and promptly whips<br />
out her American Express card<br />
to pay for a $10,000 cruise she<br />
can ill afford and will not be able<br />
to manage.<br />
To add insult to injury, Mary<br />
declines cancellation insurance. You<br />
see, shortly after this incident, it is<br />
confirmed that Mary is suffering from<br />
the first stage of Alzheimer’s Disease.<br />
On a better day, she would never<br />
have obligated herself to such a large<br />
expense without the ability to change<br />
or cancel her plans.<br />
That is a sad story<br />
of no one doing anything<br />
“illegal” but many people<br />
letting her down.<br />
Rhonda Latreille<br />
But it is too late. She is now<br />
left with a hefty credit card<br />
charge for a cruise she will<br />
never be able to take and<br />
without cancellation<br />
insurance, she cannot<br />
be reimbursed.<br />
A friend offers<br />
to go with her on<br />
the cruise but since<br />
Mary has already<br />
cancelled, her<br />
cabin has been<br />
re-sold.<br />
That is a sad<br />
story of no one<br />
doing anything<br />
“illegal” but many<br />
people letting her<br />
down.<br />
Let’s look at the situation.<br />
• How far should a credit card<br />
company go to set reasonable<br />
credit limits?<br />
• To what extent should a financial<br />
advisor be responsible<br />
for protecting an older person’s<br />
nest egg from lavish expenditures<br />
or risky investments?<br />
• With our businesses, where does<br />
“order-taker” stop and caring<br />
community member take over?<br />
• When the travel agent takes an<br />
order from an older person who<br />
refuses cancellation insurance,<br />
what could the agent do to mitigate<br />
or even postpone the person’s<br />
risky decision to spend a large sum<br />
of money?<br />
• If the travel agent has concerns<br />
about an older person making such<br />
a large purchase without the safety<br />
net of cancellation insurance, how<br />
far should the agent go to protect<br />
or control the client?<br />
• With reference to the cruise ship<br />
line, to what standards do we want<br />
to hold our businesses, especially<br />
when a vulnerable customer is left<br />
holding the bag?<br />
• Would we feel differently about<br />
this scenario if Mary’s mental<br />
capacity and ability to pay were<br />
not in question?<br />
• What would you have done if Mary<br />
were your customer?<br />
• If Mary were your mother, how would<br />
you want the situation handled?<br />
56 ©iStockphoto.com/Laflor Photography The Society of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013
We hold some cherished values<br />
here in Canada and those values<br />
are starting to come into conflict<br />
with each other. As our population<br />
continues to age, we will be faced<br />
with the “independence versus safety”<br />
dilemma in new and distinct ways.<br />
We are, by and large, a caring<br />
and compassionate society and we<br />
pride ourselves in reaching out and<br />
helping our fellow citizens. At the<br />
same time, we also hold dear our right<br />
to self-determination.<br />
• At what point do we question an<br />
individual’s right to independently<br />
make unfortunate or just plain bad<br />
decisions?<br />
• As a caring society, when do<br />
we step in to chip away at<br />
an individual’s right to selfdetermination<br />
because of our<br />
assessment that we need to keep<br />
them safe?<br />
• By what standard are we going<br />
to judge whether a decision is<br />
bad or how safe an individual<br />
needs to be?<br />
• When does our opinion that<br />
someone needs our intervention<br />
or protection bleed over<br />
into ageism?<br />
• Would we be stepping in if the<br />
person were younger?<br />
We turn to our legal system<br />
to define what level of mental capacity<br />
is required for specific functions and<br />
we ask our privacy legislation to define<br />
what information can be shared and<br />
with whom it can be shared.<br />
Our human rights legislation and<br />
international accords, task forces, and<br />
working groups are tackling the issue<br />
of ageism and are looking at how our<br />
societies can offer a level playing field<br />
for older persons.<br />
• Do these legal and high-level<br />
responses tie our hands or do they<br />
simply provide us with fence posts<br />
within which to operate?<br />
• Are we starting to overcomplicate<br />
this—and where does good oldfashioned<br />
common sense come<br />
into play?<br />
Tough Questions. No Easy Answers.<br />
With our aging society, stories like<br />
Mary’s are becoming more frequent.<br />
The issues aren’t clean and simple.<br />
• Must we leave the definition of how<br />
we live and work together up to our<br />
legislators and legal systems?<br />
• As human beings, should we rely<br />
on dispassionate and cold “rules”<br />
to tell us how to interact with each<br />
other?<br />
• What price do we pay for not having<br />
those specific rules and guidelines?<br />
Maybe we have to come<br />
to terms with the fact<br />
that there will be gaps<br />
and grey areas and<br />
sometimes people will fall<br />
through the cracks . . .<br />
Maybe we have to come to terms<br />
with the fact that there will be gaps<br />
and grey areas and sometimes people<br />
will fall through the cracks . . . that<br />
may be the cost of our commitment<br />
to self-determination and privacy. Or<br />
perhaps that price is a $10,000 credit<br />
card charge and nothing to show for it.<br />
Ed. Note: In upcoming issues<br />
of The Scrivener, Rhonda will offer<br />
answers on ways we can assist and<br />
protect the elderly in the coming<br />
years. s<br />
Inspired by the United Nations<br />
endorsed Age-Friendly City initiatives,<br />
Age-Friendly Business® made the<br />
commitment to build upon this noble<br />
foundation and to invite businesses<br />
and professional services to participate<br />
in the Age-Friendly Revolution.<br />
To find a Certified Age-Friendly Business<br />
(CAFB)® or a Certified Professional<br />
Consultant on Aging (CPCA)® near you,<br />
go to www.AgeFriendlyBusiness.com.<br />
To find out how you can become<br />
a Certified Age-Friendly Business<br />
or a CPCA, phone toll free 1-877-272-7575.<br />
Rhonda Latreille, mBA, CPCA, is the<br />
founder of Age-Friendly Business ® .<br />
Telephone: 1-877-272-8086<br />
info@agefriendlybusiness.com<br />
Great<br />
Opportunity<br />
for Intermediate/<br />
Senior<br />
Conveyancer<br />
Langley Notary seeks<br />
person to work as Assistant<br />
and Intermediate/Senior<br />
Residential Conveyancer.<br />
Part-time or full-time<br />
position. Must be able to<br />
work independently and<br />
adapt to existing office<br />
systems. Knowledge of Wills<br />
and Estates and Powers<br />
of Attorney required.<br />
Knowledge of Pro-Suite<br />
(Notary Office) and Brief<br />
Accounting preferred.<br />
Quiet atmosphere,<br />
competitive wages, and<br />
medical/dental benefits.<br />
Contact Michael Kravetz<br />
Kravetz & Co., Notaries Public<br />
5501 Salt Lane<br />
Langley, BC V3A 4E9<br />
Tel: 604 530-2147<br />
Fax: 604 530-5922<br />
http://kravetznotary.com<br />
Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013 The Scrivener 57
OUR ENVIRONMENT<br />
Bringing Back Herring<br />
in Howe Sound<br />
Coho salmon stocks<br />
in georgia Strait<br />
plummeted in the 1980s.<br />
Since Coho spend half of their<br />
3-year life span in fresh water and half<br />
in the ocean, local volunteer groups<br />
called Streamkeepers were formed<br />
to monitor and improve the fresh-water<br />
portion of the Cohos’ life.<br />
Over several decades, the<br />
Squamish Streamkeepers played<br />
a role in expanding Coho habitat in the<br />
Squamish Valley, especially on the<br />
Ashlu River and a smaller tributary<br />
called Branch 100. Little did they<br />
know they were about to stumble<br />
onto a way to bring back herring<br />
to Howe Sound, as well.<br />
Herring had once spawned heavily<br />
in the boat harbour in the Squamish<br />
estuary called the Mamquam Blind<br />
Channel, but in the 1960s a large<br />
sawmill had destroyed the eelgrass<br />
spawning beds and the herring run<br />
was gone by the 1970s.<br />
In 2006 they received a call<br />
from a watchman at the Squamish<br />
Terminals dock that he had seen<br />
herring milt, indicating herring were<br />
spawning nearby. Apparently a few<br />
years ago, a boom of logs covered<br />
in herring roe had gone into the<br />
Mamquam Blind Channel to be sorted;<br />
many of the eggs had hatched out and<br />
were now returning to spawn.<br />
On investigation, the Streamkeepers<br />
found a small amount of herring roe on<br />
bladderwrack, an intertidal seaweed—<br />
Dr. Jonn Matsen<br />
but when they went under the dock,<br />
they found that millions of herring eggs<br />
had been laid on creosote pilings and all<br />
of them had died.<br />
With that success in mind, the<br />
Streamkeepers wrapped the<br />
171 pilings they could reach<br />
at very low Spring tides.<br />
The first thought was to put<br />
something onto the pilings that would<br />
block the seepage of creosote so that<br />
if the herring spawned there in the<br />
future, the eggs would be protected.<br />
Black-plastic sheathing was stapled<br />
over 60 of the creosote pilings but the<br />
shiny plastic surface was too slippery<br />
for herring to attach eggs; soft weedcontrol<br />
material was stapled over top<br />
of the plastic and more weed-control<br />
material was run lengthways along<br />
the pilings underwater to increase the<br />
potential spawning surface area.<br />
2007 eggs on weed control material<br />
over plastic sheeting<br />
Jonn with herring roe float line<br />
Herring roe kelp and branch<br />
In February of 2007, the<br />
Streamkeepers went under the<br />
Squamish Terminals’ dock at low<br />
tide and found all the materials were<br />
heavily spawned; the eggs hatched out<br />
successfully within several weeks.<br />
With that success in mind, the<br />
Streamkeepers wrapped the 171<br />
pilings they could reach at very low<br />
Spring tides. All the materials were<br />
then heavily spawned annually with<br />
a high hatch-out rate, so each year<br />
more materials were added.<br />
As the herring run expanded,<br />
hundreds of dolphins were soon seen<br />
frequently in Howe Sound.<br />
Eggs hatched out on weed control material<br />
over plastic<br />
58 The Society of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013
Hundreds of dolphins feeding<br />
near Lions Bay in Howe Sound<br />
In 2009 a float line of the weedcontrol<br />
material was built to run<br />
lengthways under the dock.<br />
The advantage was twofold.<br />
• The spawning surface was doubled<br />
because the herring could spawn<br />
on both sides.<br />
• The eggs were always under the<br />
water, unlike the piling wrappings<br />
that were intertidal, which meant<br />
they were exposed at low tide.<br />
In 2011 several dozen creosote<br />
pilings were damaged by a ship<br />
coming in too fast. The Terminals’<br />
plan was to replace them with new<br />
creosote pilings; they were told if the<br />
pilings were sun-dried for 5 months<br />
they would not leak creosote. That<br />
was not the case because the eggs on<br />
intertidal pilings died off in 2012 and<br />
2013. Fortunately, the Streamkeepers<br />
had dramatically increased the amount<br />
of floatline that kept the eggs under<br />
water and the run appears to be still<br />
steadily increasing in size.<br />
In 2012 the Department<br />
of Fisheries (DFO) research trawler<br />
Ricker was doing hake studies<br />
in upper Howe Sound and instead<br />
found, “on this trip, the Ricker’s net<br />
yielded older herring opposite Bowen<br />
Island, as well as a high density<br />
Jonn looking at Squamish Terminals<br />
Howe Sound dolphins off Lions Bay<br />
near the highway<br />
of 2-year-old herring in surface waters<br />
up by Squamish. One-year-old herring<br />
were abundant in Ramilles Channel,<br />
North of Anvil Island, and underyearling<br />
(young-of-the-year) herring<br />
were caught everywhere at shallow<br />
depths.”<br />
Fortunately, the<br />
Streamkeepers had<br />
dramatically increased the<br />
amount of floatline that kept<br />
the eggs under water and<br />
the run appears to be still<br />
steadily increasing in size.<br />
From that information it was<br />
realized there is a natural deepspawning<br />
herring run farther down<br />
Howe Sound at the Defence Islands<br />
as well as the newer run being<br />
enhanced in the Squamish estuary.<br />
(See Youtube Defence Island Herring<br />
Parade and Defence Island Herring<br />
Spawn.) Together the two runs have<br />
brought back life to Howe Sound<br />
because dozens of large animals from<br />
salmon to dolphins depend on herring<br />
to concentrate plankton into something<br />
large enough for them to eat.<br />
Dolphins in Georgia Strait<br />
The Squamish natives had<br />
a village called Snauq in what is now<br />
called False Creek. The importance<br />
of this village was that a major herring<br />
spawn took place there at the end<br />
of Winter, the hungriest time of the<br />
year, as salmon runs were long past<br />
and new growth was yet to come.<br />
The Squamish Streamkeepers have<br />
identified similar dead herring roe on<br />
creosote pilings in False Creek over the<br />
past 5 years and are considering trying<br />
to bring back that run, as well.<br />
Streamkeepers are unpaid<br />
volunteers. They have received some<br />
funding for materials from DFO and<br />
Telus. s<br />
Jonn Matsen is the Squamish<br />
Streamkeepers Herring Recovery<br />
Coordinator. Dr. matsen was born<br />
in Britannia Beach, raised in Squamish,<br />
and has owned and operated the North<br />
Shore Naturopathic Clinic for the last<br />
30 years. His three books on his “Eating<br />
Alive Program” have sold over 400,000<br />
copies. He lives in Ambleside in West<br />
Vancouver.<br />
drjonnmatsen@shaw.ca<br />
Herring roe on piling and linear material Herring work at night at low tide<br />
Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013 The Scrivener 59
TaxES<br />
PST, HST, gST—SoS!<br />
The morning of April 1,<br />
2013, we all experienced<br />
a return to the past: The<br />
Province of BC re-implemented<br />
the Provincial Sales Tax and the<br />
HST (Harmonized Sales Tax)<br />
became the gST (goods and<br />
Services Tax).<br />
On our breakfast and newspaper,<br />
we now pay only 5% GST instead<br />
of 12% HST, but when we buy a topof-the-line<br />
new computer system,<br />
we pay 5% GST and 7% PST on the<br />
selling price—the same 12% as we<br />
would have paid with the HST.<br />
The legislation replaces the Social<br />
Services Tax Act and is included in the<br />
new Provincial Sales Tax Act.<br />
The PST is a retail sales tax that<br />
applies when taxable goods or services<br />
are acquired for personal or business<br />
use, unless a specific exemption applies.<br />
©iStockphoto.com/Alashi<br />
PST applies<br />
• The purchase or lease of new<br />
and used goods in <strong>British</strong><br />
<strong>Columbia</strong><br />
• Goods that are delivered,<br />
sent, or brought into <strong>British</strong><br />
<strong>Columbia</strong> for use in our province<br />
• Software<br />
• Services provided to tangible<br />
personal property or services<br />
to install goods<br />
• Accommodations<br />
• Legal services<br />
• Telecommunication services<br />
• Gifts of vehicles, boats, and<br />
aircraft<br />
PST does not apply<br />
• All food for human consumption<br />
• Bicycles<br />
• Dry cleaning and tailoring<br />
• Children’s clothing and footwear<br />
• Newspaper and magazines<br />
• Most services, including<br />
transportation services, personal<br />
services, and professional<br />
services<br />
• The purchase of goods for resale<br />
• Eligible machinery and<br />
equipment<br />
• Sale of real property such<br />
as residential housing and<br />
commercial real estate<br />
• Admission and memberships<br />
Andrea Agnoloni<br />
Tax Overview<br />
General tax rate: 7%<br />
On accommodations: 8%<br />
On liquor: 10%<br />
On passenger vehicles: 7% to 10%,<br />
depending on the purchase price<br />
of the vehicle<br />
On vehicles, boats, and aircraft acquired<br />
from private individuals or non-GST<br />
registrants: 12% of the purchase<br />
If the items are gifts, the tax will be<br />
applied on the market value of the gift.<br />
• PST registration can be done<br />
online at the new e-taxbc<br />
registration service.<br />
• All businesses in BC that sell or<br />
lease taxable goods, software, or<br />
services are required to register.<br />
Businesses located in Canada but<br />
outside BC will be required<br />
to register when they sell taxable<br />
goods in BC.<br />
• Businesses that collect PST will<br />
have to remit the tax on the last<br />
day of the month following the<br />
month the tax was collected. Each<br />
business will receive a commission<br />
of up to $198 per reporting period.<br />
When PST and GST Become Payable<br />
Under the Provincial Sales Tax Act,<br />
PST on the purchase or lease of goods<br />
and services generally becomes<br />
payable the earlier of<br />
• the time when consideration<br />
becomes due, and<br />
• the time it is paid without having<br />
become due.<br />
60 The Society of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013
The consideration generally becomes<br />
due when the invoice is issued with<br />
respect to the sale.<br />
The general rule for the HST/GST<br />
is the same as PST.<br />
Transitional Rules<br />
Both the BC Government and the<br />
Federal Government have announced<br />
transitional rules on the return to the<br />
PST and the elimination of the<br />
Harmonized Sales tax. The transitional<br />
rules provide guidance on determining<br />
the application of tax to transactions<br />
in BC that straddle the April 1<br />
effective date.<br />
Generally, the invoices are subject<br />
to HST (12%) if paid or payable<br />
prior to April 1, 2013, and subject<br />
to GST (5%) and PST (7%) if paid or<br />
payable on or after April 1, 2013, with<br />
certain exceptions.<br />
Transitional measures have been<br />
released by way of bulletins that<br />
include a variety of examples to help<br />
the taxpayer determine the application<br />
of the appropriate sales tax.<br />
http://www.fin.gov.bc.ca/pst-return.htm<br />
Transitional Rules for Real Property<br />
• The general transitional rule<br />
indicates that GST at 5% rather<br />
than HST at 12% would apply<br />
if both the ownership and<br />
possession of the real property<br />
transfer on or after April 1.<br />
• HST at 12% would apply if either<br />
the ownership or possession<br />
transfers before April 1.<br />
• The tax becomes payable on the<br />
earlier of the day that ownership<br />
of the property is transferred<br />
to the purchaser and the day that<br />
possession of the property is<br />
transferred to the purchaser.<br />
Sale of New Housing<br />
• The transitional rule provides<br />
guidance on whether to apply the<br />
GST or HST rate, based on when<br />
the tax becomes payable. The<br />
transitional rule that applies to sales<br />
of real property also applies to sales<br />
of new housing. Therefore GST<br />
would apply where tax becomes<br />
payable after March 31. If the tax<br />
becomes due before April 1, then<br />
HST would apply.<br />
Transitional measures have<br />
been released by way<br />
of bulletins that include<br />
a variety of examples…<br />
• In addition to the GST, a BC<br />
transition tax may apply to the sale<br />
where the construction of a house is<br />
10% or more completed on April 1.<br />
• The BC transition tax will apply on<br />
a temporary basis where the HST<br />
does not apply on the sale of new<br />
housing and GST is due on or after<br />
April 1, 2013 and before April 1,<br />
2015. The BC transition tax is<br />
applied at a rate of 2% of the<br />
selling price.<br />
• The BC transition tax will not<br />
apply if the sale of the house<br />
was previously subject to the BC<br />
transition tax.<br />
• Builders of a house will be eligible<br />
for a BC transition rebate for<br />
properties subject to the BC<br />
transition tax and where the<br />
construction of the housing is<br />
10% or more but not more than<br />
90% completed on April 1.<br />
• Builders who build for their own<br />
personal use will not be eligible for<br />
the rebate.<br />
HST/GST Installments<br />
Businesses that are required to remit<br />
HST/GST by installments should<br />
consider calculating the installments due<br />
in 2013 to reflect the lower rate of 5%.<br />
This article is not intended to be<br />
a complete guide to the recent PST/<br />
GST/HST tax changes in <strong>British</strong><br />
<strong>Columbia</strong>. Check with your financial<br />
professional. Here is the link to the<br />
Ministry of Finance, http://www.fin.<br />
gov.bc.ca/pst-return.htm and to CRA,<br />
http://www.cra-arc.gc.ca/gncy/hrmnztn/<br />
menu-eng.html#bc s<br />
Andrea Agnoloni is a BC Notary Public<br />
practising in North Vancouver. He is also<br />
a Certified general Accountant with EPR<br />
– North Vancouver, an Independent<br />
Firm of EPR Canada group Inc.<br />
andrea@eprnv.ca<br />
Services a BC Notary<br />
Can Provide<br />
Telephone: 1-877-272-8086<br />
info@agefriendlybusiness.com<br />
Notarization/Documents<br />
• Affidavits for All Documents required<br />
at a Public Registry within BC<br />
• Certified True Copies of Documents<br />
• Execution/Authentications<br />
of International Documents<br />
• Notarizations/Attestations of Signatures<br />
• Personal Property Security Agreements<br />
• Statutory Declarations<br />
Personal Planning<br />
• Estate Planning<br />
• Health Care Declarations<br />
• Powers of Attorney<br />
• Representation Agreements<br />
• Wills Preparation<br />
• Wills Searches<br />
Travel<br />
• Authorization of minor Child Travel<br />
• Letters of Invitation for Foreign Travel<br />
• Passport Application Documentation<br />
• Proof of Identity for Travel Purposes<br />
Business<br />
• Business Purchase/Sale<br />
• Commercial Leases and Assignment<br />
of Leases<br />
• Contracts and Agreements<br />
Property matters<br />
• Easements and Rights of Way<br />
• Insurance Loss Declarations<br />
• manufactured Home Transfers<br />
• mortgage Refinancing Documentation<br />
• Purchaser’s Side of Foreclosures<br />
• Residential and Commercial Real Estate<br />
Transfers<br />
• Restrictive Covenants<br />
and Builder’s Liens<br />
• Subdivisions and<br />
Statutory Building<br />
Schemes<br />
• Zoning Applications<br />
marine<br />
• marine Bills of Sale and mortgages<br />
• marine Protestations<br />
Some BC Notaries provide these services.<br />
• marriage Licences<br />
• mediation<br />
• Real Estate Disclosure Statements<br />
Over 300 Notaries to Serve You!<br />
For the BC Notary office nearest you,<br />
please call 1-800-663-0343<br />
or visit www.notaries.bc.ca.<br />
Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013 The Scrivener 61
We assist and advise nonresidents<br />
who are investing in real estate<br />
Tel: 604-872-8883 ext 226<br />
Fax: 604-872-8889<br />
www.lamlonishio.ca<br />
Our Professional Services Include . . .<br />
• Structuring investments<br />
• Explaining Canadian income tax<br />
• Explaining GST / PST<br />
• Explaining filing options (NR6)<br />
• Preparing annual tax returns<br />
• Obtaining Certificate of Compliance<br />
(“Clearance Certificate”) upon Sale<br />
WE PROVIDE PEACE OF MIND<br />
Contact Don Nishio for our information package.<br />
We assist and advise nonresidents<br />
investing in real<br />
estate:<br />
Structuring their investment<br />
Explaining Canadian income tax<br />
Explaining GST / PST<br />
Explaining filing options (NR6)<br />
Preparing annual tax returns<br />
Obtaining Certificate of Compliance<br />
touched Weby provide peace cancer.<br />
of mind<br />
Contact Don for our information package<br />
E-mail: don@lamlonishio.ca<br />
659-G Moberly Rd., Vancouver,<br />
BC V5Z 4B2<br />
Tel: 604-872-8883 ext 226<br />
Fax: 604-872-8889<br />
www.lamlonishio.ca<br />
Discovery needs willing partners.<br />
E-mail: don@lamlonishio.ca<br />
659-G Moberly Rd.,<br />
Vancouver, BC V5Z 4B2<br />
Help create a better<br />
future for everyone<br />
When your client remembers the BC Cancer Foundation in their will,<br />
they’ll be supporting world-renowned research in BC that is shaping<br />
the future of cancer care.<br />
Please be sure to use the full legal name of our organization:<br />
BC Cancer Foundation<br />
Registration Number: 11881 8434 RR0001<br />
For more information, please contact<br />
Isabela Zabava, LL.B at 604.877.6040<br />
or legacy@bccancer.bc.ca<br />
Test your<br />
Skills!<br />
RIGHT OR WRONG?<br />
• I will send you the photo’s.<br />
8 Wrong<br />
Many people—even with a<br />
university education—tend<br />
to place an apostrophe in front<br />
of the letter “s” to make a word<br />
plural.<br />
Making a word plural?<br />
Don’t use an apostrophe.<br />
The simple plural of photo is<br />
photos. Just add “s.” That’s it!<br />
Note: Photo’s is correct if you<br />
want to show possession.<br />
• The photo’s frame was<br />
cracked. (The frame<br />
belonging to the photo)<br />
RIGHT OR WRONG?<br />
• Its’ coat was very shiny.<br />
8 Wrong<br />
The word its never has an<br />
apostrophe at the end. It does<br />
not need it to show possession.<br />
RIGHT OR WRONG?<br />
• It’s déjà vu all over again!<br />
4 Correct<br />
This time, the apostrophe is not<br />
showing possession. It is holding<br />
the place of the missing letter i<br />
in what was it is.<br />
It’s is a contraction (short form)<br />
of it is.<br />
Hasn’t is a contraction of has not.<br />
Weren’t is a contraction of were not.<br />
Can’t is a contraction of can not.<br />
4 TO RECAP . . .<br />
• Please send the photos.<br />
• The photo’s colours are drab.<br />
• Its house was made of straw.<br />
• It’s better to be correct!<br />
62 The Society of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013
COMMUNITY<br />
Building Connections<br />
on march 13,<br />
I participated in a 1-day<br />
connectivity forum<br />
sponsored by the greater<br />
Victoria Eldercare Foundation.<br />
We were asked these questions.<br />
• How can we better use<br />
our collective resources?<br />
• How can we have a caring<br />
connected community and how<br />
would that help older adults<br />
age-in-place?<br />
April<br />
Struthers<br />
Our skilled facilitator<br />
was April Struthers.<br />
The forum was hosted<br />
by Oceanside Healthy<br />
Aging Initiative,<br />
a coalition of agencies<br />
working to support<br />
healthy aging in the<br />
Oceanside area through<br />
community-based research and<br />
focused community development<br />
initiatives. The Foundation sees this<br />
area as a key starting point. We were<br />
recognized because of the strength<br />
in our respective communities—we<br />
are active; we are engaging; some<br />
of us need aging-in-place and others<br />
need dignified services that assist and<br />
support a continuum of living.<br />
Lori McLeod, in her<br />
capacity as Executive<br />
Director of the Greater<br />
Victoria Eldercare<br />
Foundation, introduced<br />
us to the philosophy<br />
of the Foundation—<br />
Lori McLeod<br />
Be Well, Be Secure,<br />
Be Connected, Be Enriched. Those<br />
words drew me to participate. They<br />
help me embrace ideas and ways<br />
to support myself and my community<br />
in the aging process. After all, I have<br />
been aging since I took my first breath.<br />
The Foundation provided funding<br />
and facilitation to have us explore the<br />
topic for our area of Oceanside, which<br />
encompasses Parksville, Qualicum<br />
Beach, Nanoose, Coombs, Errington,<br />
Bowser, and Lasqueti Island.<br />
We are journeying together<br />
on a simple pathway…<br />
Being connected with others will<br />
help me to<br />
• live in the present moment,<br />
• prepare for my aging life as I move<br />
forward into it,<br />
• have wellness and security, and<br />
• be enriched by our exchanges<br />
in the care experience.<br />
I am a care partner for my parent<br />
who is a person living with dementia.<br />
I have learned I need support with my<br />
roles and, in the process, I can also<br />
provide support.<br />
I am so grateful to live<br />
in Oceanside where we have an<br />
amazing wealth of people who are<br />
passionate about how they want to live<br />
and are generous about how they<br />
demonstrate it by giving back to their<br />
community.<br />
When I am engaged in contributing<br />
to my community, I feel I am a part<br />
of it. I need to be kind, be respectful,<br />
be inclusive—and that means having<br />
grace with myself. I was reminded<br />
by another participant that as we age,<br />
we as a population will be very vocal and<br />
accustomed to participating in matters<br />
that involve us. I have demonstrated that<br />
by advocating for my parent.<br />
Elise Willson<br />
As a group, we recognized that<br />
knowledge, education, and shared<br />
wisdom will help keep each of us open<br />
to learning and experiencing more<br />
reciprocal relationships.<br />
We are journeying together<br />
on a simple pathway, empowered<br />
by reducing, reusing, recycling, and<br />
reframing through an “Age-friendly<br />
Lens.” Eldercare has been instrumental<br />
in building intergenerational community<br />
with an initiative called “Trust Us!”<br />
that bridges the gap between teens and<br />
seniors. I picked up information cards<br />
from the Eldercare display on both<br />
“Trust Us” and “Skills for Shy Seniors.”<br />
• To whom do you connect?<br />
• Who connects to you?<br />
• Where do you enjoy reciprocal<br />
relationships?<br />
• How do your current relationships<br />
meet your needs—personally, at<br />
your work space, in your leisure,<br />
and in your volunteer activities?<br />
• Are you putting enough time and<br />
effort into activities that nurture<br />
your spirit?<br />
Someone at the forum said, “Can<br />
we define this as an ‘Age Friendly<br />
Living Lab’? That sounds so much more<br />
positive than defining Qualicum Beach<br />
as ‘God’s Beautiful Waiting Room.’ ” s<br />
Elise Willson is a community<br />
volunteer who is active with the<br />
Alzheimer Society of BC and oceanside<br />
Dementia Education Task Team. She<br />
co-facilitates, plans, hosts, and gathers<br />
resources for oDETT and its events.<br />
Her greatest accomplishment is being<br />
present in each moment!<br />
gladysu@telus.net<br />
Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013 The Scrivener 63
WILLS & ESTaTES<br />
This article reports on important new<br />
developments in the case law on<br />
severing ownership by joint tenancy.<br />
(Updating Severance of Joint Tenancies<br />
at www.disinherited.com)<br />
Back to Basics<br />
At common law, there are<br />
two main forms of joint<br />
ownership by individuals.<br />
The individual owners may hold<br />
property as either joint tenants<br />
or as tenants in common.<br />
A critical difference between<br />
these two forms of ownership<br />
is the “right of survivorship” that<br />
attaches to a joint tenancy but<br />
not to a tenancy in common.<br />
The right of survivorship means<br />
that when a joint tenant dies, his or her<br />
ownership interest passes equally to all<br />
other co-owners. To illustrate with a very<br />
common example, suppose a couple<br />
owns property as joint tenants and<br />
one partner dies. His or her ownership<br />
interest will pass automatically to the<br />
Trevor Todd<br />
Judith Milliken, QC<br />
Severance<br />
of Joint Tenancies<br />
by Course of Conduct<br />
surviving partner. If, instead, they own<br />
the property as tenants in common,<br />
when one partner dies, the interest<br />
in the property will pass directly<br />
to his or her estate rather than to the<br />
surviving spouse.<br />
The question of how<br />
common property is owned<br />
can have a very significant<br />
effect on the outcome<br />
of both matrimonial and<br />
estate litigation.<br />
Property Registered in Joint Tenancy May<br />
Have Changed its Form of Ownership<br />
We often assume that property legally<br />
registered to the owners as joint<br />
tenants will automatically pass to the<br />
surviving joint tenant(s) upon the<br />
death of one joint tenant.<br />
Legal practitioners, however,<br />
should always consider the question<br />
of whether property, apparently held<br />
in joint tenancy, indeed remained<br />
in joint tenancy at the time of death.<br />
If the joint tenancy has been<br />
somehow terminated, then the<br />
property will be held by the owners<br />
as tenants in common.<br />
The legal process of converting<br />
a joint tenancy arrangement into<br />
a tenancy in common is referred<br />
to as “severance.” The distinction<br />
is crucial because of the right<br />
of survivorship that attaches to a joint<br />
tenancy. Where a tenancy in common<br />
has been created prior to the death<br />
of one owner, the deceased’s property<br />
interest will not pass to the other<br />
owners, but will form part of the<br />
deceased’s estate.<br />
The question of how common<br />
property is owned can have a very<br />
significant effect on the outcome<br />
of both matrimonial and estate<br />
litigation. Often, the family home<br />
or real estate forms the large part<br />
of any property owned by the<br />
deceased.<br />
Severance of a Joint Tenancy<br />
The classic statement as to how<br />
to sever a joint tenancy is found<br />
in Williams v. Hensman (1861), 70 E.<br />
R. 862. In a nutshell, at page 867,<br />
Vice Chancellor Wood sets out the<br />
three possibilities.<br />
1. One joint owner may sever the<br />
joint tenancy by disposing of his<br />
or her own interest—for example,<br />
transferring that interest to himself<br />
or herself.<br />
64 The Society of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013
2. A joint tenancy may be severed<br />
by mutual agreement of the joint<br />
owners—that is, explicitly severed.<br />
3. There may be a severance by any<br />
course of dealing sufficient<br />
to intimate that the interest<br />
of all owners was mutually<br />
treated as constituting a tenancy<br />
in common—that is, implicitly<br />
severed.<br />
The third manner of severance is<br />
the subject of this article—severance<br />
that takes place implicitly, by way<br />
of conduct that evidences a mutual<br />
intention on the part of all owners.<br />
Such severance may not always be<br />
obvious and becomes crucial only<br />
when one of the parties dies.<br />
Recent Ontario Cases<br />
The Ontario Court of Appeal<br />
has recently carefully examined the law<br />
and conflicting cases and set forth the<br />
test in Ontario for determining whether<br />
there has been a severance by course<br />
of conduct. Their decision is found<br />
in Hansen v. Hansen Estate 2012 9<br />
RFL (7th) 251, 75 ETR (3d) 19.<br />
By way of background, the Hansens<br />
had married in 1983 and separated<br />
in 2010. It was a second marriage<br />
for both and both had children from<br />
previous relationships. In 2003 the<br />
Hansens purchased a property as joint<br />
tenants. Financial and marital troubles<br />
subsequently ensued, with Mrs. Hansen<br />
moving out of the home in March 2010.<br />
Mr. Hansen hired a matrimonial<br />
lawyer and signed a new Will leaving<br />
everything to his daughters alone.<br />
Mrs. Hansen also retained<br />
a lawyer who wrote the husband’s<br />
lawyer suggesting they negotiate<br />
a “swift and amicable” separation<br />
agreement with a view to conducting<br />
a “straightforward equalization of their<br />
property and incomes.” The negotiation<br />
was to include all the assets including<br />
the family home, which was to be<br />
appraised. As well, it was proposed<br />
that the husband, if he chose<br />
to remain in the family home, could buy<br />
out his wife’s interest. Otherwise, the<br />
property was to be sold.<br />
The husband’s lawyer responded<br />
immediately and appeared to agree<br />
with the suggested course of action on<br />
his client’s behalf. In particular, he took<br />
no issue to the proposed equal division<br />
of assets nor the suggestion that the<br />
husband would either buy out his wife’s<br />
interest if he chose to remain in the<br />
home or otherwise the property would<br />
have to be listed and sold.<br />
The parties began to close their<br />
joint bank accounts and prepared<br />
financial statements for exchange<br />
in furtherance of their settlement<br />
negotiations. Before any settlement<br />
could be finalized, Mr. Hansen died.<br />
The third manner<br />
of severance is the subject<br />
of this article—severance<br />
that takes place implicitly,<br />
by way of conduct that<br />
evidences a mutual intention<br />
on the part of all owners.<br />
The question of home ownership<br />
thus became crucial. On title, the<br />
couple remained registered as joint<br />
tenants but had that joint tenancy<br />
been severed?<br />
Mrs. Hansen maintained she<br />
was entitled to the family home as the<br />
surviving joint tenant. The husband’s<br />
executors maintained that the parties’<br />
course of dealing had severed that joint<br />
tenancy and therefore the husband’s<br />
interest passed into his estate.<br />
Mrs. Hansen was successful<br />
at trial but that was reversed on<br />
appeal. The Ontario Court of Appeal,<br />
in overturning that decision, made<br />
several pronouncements about<br />
severance by a course of conduct.<br />
In summary, they said the following.<br />
1. The purpose of this doctrine is<br />
to ensure that one owner does not<br />
unfairly obtain the benefit of the<br />
right of survivorship where the<br />
parties have shown a common<br />
intention to no longer treat their<br />
interests in the property as an<br />
indivisible unified whole.<br />
2. Proof of severance by course<br />
of dealing does not require<br />
proof of an explicit agreement<br />
Leave a Legacy<br />
in your in Your WiLL Will<br />
By remembering Variety – - The The<br />
Children’s Children’s Charity in in your will, will,<br />
you can help children children who have<br />
special needs in in the the province.<br />
Your generosity will will provide provide hope,<br />
hope, enrich enrich lives, and lives, build and a build better<br />
a future better for future children for like children Xander.<br />
like For Xander. more inFormation on<br />
hoW For to Leave more info a Legacy: . . .<br />
Call (604) Call 320-0505 (604) 320-0505 or<br />
Toll-free Toll-free 1(800) 1 (800) 381-2040<br />
or visit Visit our our website website at at<br />
www.variety.bc.ca/legacy<br />
www.variety.bc.ca/legacy.<br />
Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013 The Scrivener 65
to sever the joint tenancy; the<br />
mutual intention can be inferred<br />
from the course of dealing<br />
between the parties.<br />
3. Severance by a course of dealing<br />
requires that each owner knew<br />
of the other’s position and that<br />
all treated their interest in the<br />
property as no longer being held<br />
jointly; that knowledge may be<br />
inferred from communications<br />
or conduct.<br />
4. Determination of whether the<br />
mutual intention required has<br />
been shown involves a fact-specific<br />
assessment of the circumstances<br />
of the individual case. For example,<br />
negotiations between spouses<br />
during a marriage breakdown may<br />
reveal an intention to mutually<br />
treat the interests in the family<br />
home as constituting a tenancy<br />
in common (paragraph 44).<br />
The Court ruled that the trial<br />
judge erred in first treating the<br />
previous cases as if they had created<br />
recognized categories “that restrict<br />
the course of dealing analysis<br />
to established patterns of conduct”<br />
and second in concluding that because<br />
the facts did not match, severance had<br />
not been established.<br />
The Court ruled there was a course<br />
of conduct sufficient to sever the<br />
joint tenancy. In particular, it was the<br />
exchange of letters by counsel setting<br />
forth the fact that the interest in the<br />
family home was to be appraised and<br />
then divided equally. The court said,<br />
“it is hard to imagine what remained<br />
to be done except for documenting the<br />
agreement, given that the principle<br />
of equal division driving the resolution<br />
was not in dispute” (paragraph 61).<br />
The preparation of new Wills<br />
and the opening of separate bank<br />
accounts was supportive evidence<br />
in is much as it was the consistent<br />
quotes with other evidence that the<br />
spouses mutually treated their interest<br />
in the property as no longer being held<br />
jointly” (paragraph 63–64).<br />
Chief Justice Winkler at paragraph<br />
7, stated as follows.<br />
The court’s inquiry cannot<br />
be limited to matching fact<br />
patterns to those in prior cases.<br />
Rather, the court must look<br />
to the co-owners’ entire course<br />
of conduct—in other words, the<br />
totality of the evidence—in order<br />
to determine if they intended<br />
that their interests were mutually<br />
treated as constituting a tenancy<br />
in common. The evidence may<br />
manifest itself in different ways.<br />
Each case is idiosyncratic and<br />
will turn on its own facts.<br />
The court found that<br />
neither the testatrix nor her<br />
estranged husband had<br />
conducted their affairs<br />
in a way to suggest that the<br />
joint tenancies had been<br />
terminated.<br />
Following that decision was<br />
a second Ontario decision Su v. Lam<br />
2012 77 E.T.R. (3d) 278, (Ont. SCJ).<br />
In that case, the trial judge applied<br />
Hansen, however, and found that<br />
severance had not been established.<br />
The case involved a married<br />
couple who had been separated<br />
for some years—indeed the wife had<br />
a new common law husband who<br />
was the claimant. Nevertheless, the<br />
court ruled the mere fact that the<br />
testatrix and her estranged husband<br />
were separated was insufficient<br />
to establish severance. After<br />
separating, the couple had previously<br />
disposed of some of their properties<br />
and divided the proceeds but<br />
continued to hold others jointly.<br />
The court found that neither the<br />
testatrix nor her estranged husband<br />
had conducted their affairs in a way<br />
to suggest that the joint tenancies<br />
had been terminated. No evidence<br />
existed that they had entered<br />
into negotiations as to the ownership<br />
following their separation. The fact<br />
alone that the testatrix maintained<br />
the properties without assistance<br />
from her estranged husband was not<br />
evidence of severance. Accordingly,<br />
the properties passed to the estranged<br />
husband by right of survivorship.<br />
<strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> <strong>Law</strong>: Tompkins Estate<br />
Hansen Estate is contrary to the BCCA<br />
decision Tompkins Estate v. Tompkins,<br />
March 3, 1993, Vancouver Registry<br />
CA 015039. Indeed, Hansen considers<br />
and specifically rejects the reasoning<br />
in Tompkins Estate.<br />
In this decision, Southin J.A.,<br />
writing on behalf of the Court, ruled<br />
that to satisfy the test of severance<br />
by course of dealing, one party must<br />
rely, to his or her detriment, on the<br />
other’s representation that he or she<br />
no longer wants to hold the property<br />
jointly. According to Winkler J.,<br />
in Hansen she interpreted the rule<br />
“as a ‘species of estoppel’ requiring<br />
proof of detrimental reliance”<br />
(paragraph 47, Hansen).<br />
In other words, the BC law as set<br />
forth in Tompkins Estate is that the<br />
party asserting severance must prove<br />
not only that both parties treated<br />
their interests as separate, but also<br />
that he or she relied on the other’s<br />
representations or actions to his or her<br />
detriment and is therefore estopped<br />
from now asserting a joint tenancy.<br />
The Ontario court in Hansen held<br />
that such detrimental reliance was not<br />
necessary and the test could be<br />
satisfied simply by virtue of each party<br />
being aware of the other’s intentions<br />
and by both parties treating their<br />
interests in the property as no longer<br />
being held jointly.<br />
In fact Winkler CJO in Hansen<br />
in effect opined that Southin J.<br />
in Hansen misinterpreted Williams<br />
v. Hensman. Winkler CJO comments<br />
read, in part, as follows.<br />
...in describing the course of dealing<br />
test, the reasons of the Vice<br />
Chancellor in Williams v. Hensman<br />
do not refer to the doctrine<br />
of estoppel, nor do his reasons<br />
invoke the concept of detrimental<br />
reliance. It is possible that<br />
Southin J. A. may have viewed<br />
the course of dealing test of the<br />
species of estoppel because both<br />
legal principles are designed<br />
to prevent unfairness or injustice<br />
as between the parties. However,<br />
the elements of each doctrine are<br />
different as are the requirements<br />
66 The Society of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013
of proof…. The rationale for severing<br />
the joint tenancy relates to the<br />
inappropriateness of the right<br />
of survivorship in circumstances<br />
where co-owners have mutually<br />
treated their interests in the<br />
property being held in common.<br />
The rationale is not contingent on<br />
the fact that one party relied on the<br />
representation to his/her detriment<br />
(paragraphs 47–50).<br />
Given that decisions of Ontario<br />
Court of Appeal are traditionally<br />
regarded as very persuasive, our courts<br />
may in future adopt the reasoning<br />
of Hansen.<br />
Conclusion<br />
In an individual case, it will be crucial<br />
to examine the history of dealings<br />
between joint owners to determine<br />
whether or not past dealings have<br />
resulted in a severance of a joint<br />
tenancy. It is not uncommon<br />
for parties to separate and later<br />
reconcile and it may well be that<br />
a historic course of dealing effectively<br />
severed a joint tenancy of valuable<br />
Why invest the time to get to know our clients?<br />
Because we care to fully understand what you’re up<br />
against and where you want to go. We gain insight and real<br />
understanding so we can help you achieve your ambitions.<br />
property. For example, a combination<br />
of the following acts could conceivably<br />
result in the severance of a joint<br />
tenancy.<br />
1. Expressing an intention<br />
to negotiate a division of property,<br />
including the subject property,<br />
especially in equal shares<br />
2. An owner vacating the premises<br />
3. Insisting on one owner buying out<br />
the other’s interest as a condition<br />
of continued occupation<br />
4. Expressing an intention<br />
to have the property appraised<br />
for purposes of settlement<br />
negotiations<br />
5. Closing joint bank accounts and<br />
opening separate accounts<br />
6. Preparing a new Will disposing<br />
of the property, to the exclusion<br />
of the other owner<br />
In conclusion, the Hansen case<br />
underlines a vital area to be examined<br />
by estate litigators in dealing with<br />
jointly owned property after death. It<br />
can be extremely important to scratch<br />
it all starts with building<br />
a great relationship.<br />
Strong relationships with over 50,000 business clients<br />
across Canada have proven our commitment.<br />
BDO. MORE THAN YOU THINK.<br />
Assurance | Accounting | Tax | Advisory<br />
Suky Cheema, CA, Partner<br />
604 688 5421<br />
www.bdo.ca<br />
BDO Canada LLP, a Canadian limited liability partnership, is a member of BDO International Limited, a UK company limited by guarantee, and forms part of<br />
the international BDO network of independent member firms. BDO is the brand name for the BDO network and for each of the BDO Member Firms.<br />
the surface to ensure there has not<br />
been a severance of the ownership<br />
interest effected by the owners’<br />
historic course of conduct. s<br />
Trevor Todd restricts his practice<br />
to estate litigation and has practised<br />
law for 38 years. He is a past President<br />
of the Trial <strong>Law</strong>yers Association of BC,<br />
a past chair of the Wills and Trusts<br />
(Vancouver) Subsection, and a past<br />
president of the New Westminster Bar<br />
association. He frequently lectures<br />
to CLE, TLABC, the BC Notaries, and<br />
various law, business, or general<br />
public sessions on estate law issues.<br />
Disinherited.com is 17 years old.<br />
It has hundreds of blogs and articles<br />
and currently over 5600 visitors per<br />
month on average.<br />
Judith Milliken, QC, hails from<br />
Saskatchewan and has practised law<br />
for 36 years . . . initially commercial law,<br />
criminal prosecutions for over 20 years,<br />
and since 2007, estate litigation.<br />
As former senior Crown Counsel,<br />
she is a highly experienced litigator.<br />
Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013 The Scrivener 67
HISTORY Of BRITISH COLUMBIa<br />
The Sockeye Special<br />
THE SToRy oF THE STEVESToN TRAm<br />
AND EARLy LULU ISLAND<br />
The Vancouver to Steveston<br />
interurban has been the<br />
subject of stories and<br />
memories for many people<br />
from the Lower mainland.<br />
In researching Richmond history,<br />
the tram was often part of historical<br />
moments on the Island.<br />
When the BC Electric Railway<br />
(BCER) took over the CPR’s passenger<br />
service in 1905, the majority of the<br />
riders on the early morning and later<br />
afternoon runs were workers at the fish<br />
canneries in Steveston. The canneries<br />
were world renowned for canning the<br />
premium Sockeye salmon; the tram<br />
service became known as The Sockeye<br />
Special.<br />
The BCER tram from Vancouver<br />
to Steveston was an integral part<br />
of the development of early Lulu<br />
Island, taking thousands of passengers<br />
Minoru Racetrack 1910<br />
[City of Richmond Archives Photograph<br />
#2001.9.20]<br />
from Vancouver, New Westminster, and<br />
Steveston to the Minoru Racetrack.<br />
The racetrack was the site of six<br />
aeronautical firsts that took place from<br />
1910 to 1919.<br />
Brighouse Racetrack opened<br />
in 1909 and was originally named<br />
Minoru Racetrack after King Edward’s<br />
horse, a 1909 Epson Derby winner.<br />
Minoru (the horse) was named after<br />
the newborn son of Edward’s gardener.<br />
…the tram service<br />
became known as<br />
The Sockeye Special.<br />
The track, often described<br />
as having the finest racing surface<br />
in North America, was on the<br />
land owned by Sam Brighouse—<br />
one of the Three Greenhorns.<br />
It was infinitely easier to build there<br />
than on Vancouver’s forested east<br />
end. The track was built in 90 days<br />
for approximately $75,000. An<br />
estimated 7000 fans turned out<br />
for opening day, August 21, 1909,<br />
the first major racing event in the<br />
Lower Mainland.<br />
The track’s surface created<br />
a natural bounce, believed to be the<br />
result of underlying peat and a perfect<br />
mix of clay and alluvial soil. That<br />
may be the reason for the numerous<br />
Canadian horse-racing records.<br />
Ron Hyde<br />
1909 Epson Derby Winner Minoru<br />
[City of Richmond Archives]<br />
Most of the fans rode the BCER<br />
trams from Vancouver and Marpole, but<br />
others arrived in horse-drawn carriages,<br />
by horseback, or by walking for miles<br />
along the flat, dusty roads. Originally,<br />
the bookmaking system was in effect,<br />
but bookies were soon abolished and<br />
in 1910, parimutual machines—“iron<br />
men”—were installed.<br />
Parimutual betting had been<br />
outlawed in many parts of the United<br />
States and for a long time, there<br />
was no racing in the United States<br />
in the territory between Mexico and<br />
<strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong>. Some of the bestknown<br />
horsemen on the continent<br />
came to Vancouver and Richmond.<br />
In 1914, an unprecedented 90-day<br />
68 The Society of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013
Charles Hamilton lands his plane at Minoru Racetrack on March 25, 1910,<br />
for the first airplane visit west of Winnipeg. [Ron Hyde Collection]<br />
meet was held at Minoru. That<br />
contravened the law and the Attorney<br />
General fined the track $50.<br />
Minoru Racetrack’s first 11 years<br />
of operation recorded several historic<br />
events witnessed by thousands who<br />
travelled by The Sockeye Special.<br />
March 25, 1910, saw the first airplane<br />
visit and first flight west of Winnipeg<br />
by Charles K. Hamilton who flew his<br />
Curtiss pusher biplane to Minoru Park.<br />
The next day he flew to New<br />
Westminster and back. He later<br />
challenged a horse to a 1-mile<br />
race and, much to Hamilton’s<br />
embarrassment, the horse won<br />
by 10 seconds, probably due to the<br />
3<br />
⁄8 of a mile lead given to the horse.<br />
April 28, 1911: William Templeton flew<br />
a homemade biplane at Minoru. It<br />
was the first plane both built in and<br />
flown over Metropolitan Vancouver.<br />
Templeton later became the first<br />
Manager of the Vancouver International<br />
Airport.<br />
April 24, 1912: Billy M. Stark made<br />
a solo exhibition flight over Minoru.<br />
A second flight was scheduled and<br />
the BCER, anticipating large numbers<br />
of spectators, added nine extra cars<br />
to the Lulu Island Route.<br />
Although the biplane was not<br />
designed to carry passengers, James<br />
Hewitt of The Province newspaper<br />
was the first airplane passenger<br />
in <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong><br />
William Stark in his plane with James Hewitt strapped to the wing in 1912<br />
[City of Vancouver Archives, Trans N38]<br />
Recollections of Lulu Island<br />
When I was a young boy, during<br />
WWII, my mother worked at one<br />
of the fish canneries in Steveston. The<br />
women cannery workers wore white<br />
overalls and hair bandanas for their<br />
shift and —after a day of handling fish—<br />
the trip home was particularly pungent.<br />
According to my mother, the nickname<br />
Sockeye Special had more to do with<br />
the aroma on the tram than the quality<br />
of the salmon they were canning.<br />
Mom’s working life at the<br />
cannery was short-lived. The<br />
commute from North Vancouver<br />
was 2 hours each way. It was too<br />
long a day —and too little pay—for<br />
a mother with 3 young children.<br />
I also remember the tram from<br />
my trips to the racetrack with my uncle<br />
Bill—that would have been in 1946–<br />
‘47. We’d get the tram at the corner<br />
of Carrall and Hastings in Vancouver.<br />
It was an exciting ride, especially the<br />
interurban, because it went for such<br />
a long way (about 14.5 miles).<br />
I spent my time at the track<br />
picking up discarded tickets, looking<br />
for winners, and I found the odd<br />
one, too! Fatherless<br />
since my dad was<br />
killed in the War,<br />
I loved those times<br />
with my uncle.<br />
Hugh Cooper<br />
Spouse of The Scrivener’s<br />
graphic artist Marilyn MacDonald<br />
Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013 The Scrivener 69
Pilot Stark took the plane up<br />
to 600 feet and flew almost 6 miles<br />
while Hewitt sat on a board strapped<br />
next to the engine as he hung on<br />
to the rigging of the plane.<br />
May 24, 1912: The first parachute<br />
jump in Canada was made into<br />
Minoru Park by Charles Saunders.<br />
July 31, 1913: American Aviatrix Alys<br />
McKey Bryant became the first woman<br />
in Canada to make a solo flight. She<br />
was a member of the Early Birds and<br />
began taking flying lessons in the<br />
Summer of 1912.<br />
American Aviatrix Alys McKey Bryant<br />
[Smithstonian Institution Negative<br />
#A9965E]<br />
August 1919: Vancouver’s Ernest<br />
C. Hoy took off from Minoru Park<br />
for the first flight to cross the Rocky<br />
Mountains. The trip took 16 hours and<br />
42 minutes and contained the first<br />
airmail delivery across the Rockies.<br />
With the outbreak of the First<br />
World War, Minoru closed after the<br />
1914 season. It did not re-open until<br />
1920 when it became Brighouse<br />
Racetrack that attracted fans from<br />
all parts of North America; every once<br />
in a while, movie stars of the day were<br />
in attendance.<br />
That is but one of the many<br />
fascinating stories about The Sockeye<br />
Special. The tram played a major part<br />
in the life and entertainment of Lulu<br />
Island residents. In my book, you<br />
will enjoy stories of weekend trips<br />
to Vancouver theatres and operas,<br />
the many events at the Steveston<br />
Opera House and some of the famous<br />
people who played there, and the<br />
secrets of the white sands at Garry<br />
Point Park.<br />
The book, The Sockeye Special,<br />
sells for $15 (tax included) plus $5<br />
Join the fight. Leave a legacy.<br />
for mailing in Canada.<br />
The book is available<br />
through PayPal on<br />
www.sockeyespecial.<br />
com and in selected<br />
bookstores<br />
in Greater Vancouver.<br />
Information or<br />
enquiries:<br />
sockeyespecial@gmail.com s<br />
Ron Hyde is Newsletter Editor<br />
and membership Chair for the <strong>British</strong><br />
<strong>Columbia</strong> Historical Federation.<br />
membership@bchistory.ca<br />
Telephone: 604 277-2627<br />
www.sockeyespecial.com<br />
Note: We have partnered with<br />
many nonprofit groups for book<br />
signings at their events and<br />
to share the proceeds. At the Gulf<br />
of Georgia Cannery and the Richmond<br />
Museum Society, we presented the<br />
57 Richmond public and independent<br />
school libraries with a copy of The<br />
Sockeye Special so that Richmond<br />
students could learn a little bit more<br />
about Richmond’s exciting history.<br />
Gifts to the Canadian Cancer Society fund research and prevention initiatives and<br />
help families like the Kents create life-changing memories at Camp Goodtimes.<br />
Did you know that a legacy gift to the Canadian Cancer Society can fight cancer and protect your<br />
estate from tax? The Estate Tax Eliminator Clause can reduce your final taxes to zero.<br />
You can help fund the best cancer research, prevention and support programs. For your copy of<br />
the Estate Tax Eliminator Clause and a Personal Estate and Will Planning Guide, please contact<br />
Toni Andreola at tandreola@bc.cancer.ca or call 1 800 663 - 2524.<br />
cancer.ca<br />
70 The Society of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013
A Nickel<br />
for your Thoughts?<br />
We knew it was coming.<br />
The media told us<br />
to roll up our pennies<br />
and turn them in at the bank.<br />
Still, I was caught by surprise<br />
recently at a large grocery store. When<br />
I got to the till, the cashier said she<br />
was told to refuse pennies and gave us<br />
the choice to round off to the closest<br />
even denomination.<br />
I wrote to my Facebook friends to let<br />
them know history was in the making<br />
that day. I reported we would have<br />
to say goodbye to our pennies. I asked<br />
everyone for a favourite coin phrase,<br />
rhyme, and childhood saying that<br />
included the penny.<br />
As a young girl in Chicago, I loved<br />
it when my dad took our family out<br />
at Christmastime to see the window<br />
displays at Marshall Fields. We girls<br />
would sing “Christmas is coming, the<br />
goose is getting fat, please to put<br />
a penny in the old man’s hat” as we<br />
dropped our pennies into the hats<br />
of the men on the streets. We sang with<br />
all our hearts, right to them, and shook<br />
their hands as we happily passed by.<br />
I remember long Summers at the<br />
Jersey Shore, playing at the penny<br />
arcade—the same one destroyed<br />
by the hurricane forces of “Sandy” last<br />
November.<br />
On my first trip to Vegas in the<br />
‘70s at the penny slots, I carried<br />
away cupfuls of pennies, which I put<br />
into a glass penny bank shaped like<br />
a pig. I understood the piggybank<br />
design when we moved to Bermuda.<br />
The penny there is called a hog<br />
penny—a hog is engraved on the<br />
coin. The <strong>British</strong> introduced hogs<br />
to the Island when their sailing ships,<br />
transporting slaves from the West<br />
Indies, crashed on the coral reefs<br />
of what was later named Bermuda after<br />
a Spanish captain called Bermude.<br />
“…see a penny, pick it up,<br />
and all the day,<br />
you’ll have good luck.”<br />
The huge response<br />
on Facebook<br />
surprised me.<br />
Friends had many<br />
memories and<br />
comments. I’m sad<br />
the sayings could<br />
be lost forever, such<br />
as “see a penny, pick<br />
it up, and all the day,<br />
you’ll have good luck.”<br />
There will be no more “penny<br />
for your thoughts.” Penny skateboards<br />
are gone. Penny candy is a thing of the<br />
past. Things could get penny dreadful.<br />
We had penny racers, we wore penny<br />
Susan Freeborn<br />
©iStockphoto.com/peterspiro<br />
loafers, played on penny boards, had<br />
penny nails. What of the penny press?<br />
We can no longer spend a penny and<br />
save a dime. We were brought up<br />
to know the value of a penny.<br />
The <strong>British</strong> Isles have influenced<br />
many penny phrases, along with songs<br />
passed from generation to generation.<br />
The Beatles gave us Penny Lane. Brits<br />
would excuse themselves to “go pay<br />
a penny,” which meant to go to the<br />
Lu—the washroom attendant would<br />
collect a penny at the door.<br />
We used to pinch pennies. We had<br />
to be penny wise. A penny saved was<br />
a penny earned. If we didn’t watch it,<br />
we could become penniless. Playing<br />
cards, we made penny antes. Some<br />
games, meals, or movies were well<br />
worth every penny.<br />
The Irish have played<br />
many a tune on the<br />
“penny whistle” to pick<br />
up their spirits and<br />
tunes like O Danny Boy<br />
to remember their lost<br />
loved ones. Those lilting<br />
songs will ring through<br />
the ages and never be<br />
forgotten. They will live on<br />
through the games of their<br />
children’s children. s<br />
Scrivener reader Susan Freeborn<br />
is an aquatics instructor and hair stylist<br />
in North Vancouver.<br />
Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013 The Scrivener 71
aSSOCIaTION Of BC LaND SURVEYORS<br />
Chuck Salmon<br />
Fantastic Agm for 2013<br />
Board of Management<br />
Back row from left: Mike Thomson, Surveyor General; Ron Johns; Dave Harris;<br />
Nigel Hemingway, Past President; Brian Brown; Chuck Salmon,<br />
Secretary; Chad Rintoul, CAO; Brownyn Denton<br />
Sitting: Steve Buzikievich, Vice President; Ian Lloyd, President;<br />
Michael Burian, Government Appointee<br />
Newly Commissioned Land Surveyors<br />
Back from left: Brent Mayenburg, BCLS 910; Jeff Thompson, BCLS 922;<br />
Lucas Cairns, BCLS 916; Scott Todd, BCLS 913<br />
Middle row: Alex Heath, BCLS 921; Spencer Hagen, BCLS 915;<br />
Adam Arduini, BCLS 920; Tim Peterson, BCLS 911;<br />
Mark Flinta, BCLS 914; Evgeny Petushkov, BCLS 919<br />
Sitting: Roland Bircher, BCLS 912; Peter Wittstock, BCLS 917;<br />
Ross Mandeville, BCLS 918<br />
The 108 th Annual general meeting<br />
of the Association of BC Land<br />
Surveyors was held march 7<br />
and 8 at the Whistler Conference Centre<br />
and Hilton Whistler Resort & Spa.<br />
A great location for an AGM, Whistler<br />
provides an excellent layout; the people<br />
managing the facility were extremely<br />
hospitable. The event enjoyed an attendance<br />
of 165 land surveyors, spouses, delegates<br />
from land surveying associations across Canada,<br />
and special guests—400 people in all.<br />
The business sessions and continuing<br />
professional development were very well<br />
attended.<br />
Special guests at the President’s Dinner<br />
and Dance on Friday night from The Society<br />
of Notaries Public of BC included President<br />
John Eastwood and his wife Bryanne and<br />
CEO and Secretary Wayne Braid and his<br />
wife Laurie Salvador; from the Applied<br />
Science Technologists and Technicians, Vice<br />
President Dave Rutherford; and representing<br />
the Integrated Cadastral Information Society,<br />
President Ferenc and Penny Pataki.<br />
Special guest Larry Blaschuk, Registrar<br />
New Westminster and Kamloops Land Title<br />
Offices, attended the Awards Luncheon<br />
held Thursday afternoon. Certificates<br />
of Appreciation were awarded to Wayne<br />
Fromm, Examiner of Title, Kamloops Land<br />
Title Office; Maureen Johnston, Deputy<br />
Registrar, Victoria Land Title Office; and<br />
Jay Sherwood, author, for their support<br />
of the land surveying profession.<br />
72 The Society of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013<br />
The Scrivener
A Certificate<br />
of Recognition was<br />
awarded to incoming<br />
President<br />
Ian Lloyd<br />
for his<br />
work with Ian Lloyd<br />
the Board<br />
of Examiners.<br />
G. K. Burnett Awards were<br />
Brian Brown presented to Brian Brown<br />
for his work as Sergeant<br />
at Arms and Don Watson<br />
for his work with the<br />
retired land surveyors<br />
group.<br />
Don Watson<br />
O’Brian<br />
Blackall<br />
Ralph Turner<br />
Dave Morton<br />
Doug Roy<br />
Hans<br />
Troelsen<br />
The G. M. Thomson<br />
Award was presented<br />
to O’Brian Blackall for his<br />
exceptionally outstanding<br />
work in promoting the<br />
land surveying profession.<br />
Lifetime Achievement<br />
Awards were presented<br />
to Ralph Turner and<br />
Dave Morton for their<br />
long-time commitment<br />
to land surveying in BC;<br />
Doug Roy and Hans<br />
Troelsen were elected<br />
by the membership as<br />
Life Members.<br />
President Nigel<br />
Hemingway made the<br />
presentations to the<br />
13 land surveyors<br />
commissioned since our<br />
2012 AGM.<br />
Elections to the Board<br />
of Management resulted<br />
in the Board for 2013.<br />
Returning are Nigel<br />
Hemingway as Past<br />
President; Ian Lloyd<br />
as President; Steve<br />
Buzikievich as Vice<br />
President; Brian Brown<br />
and Bronwyn Denton as<br />
members at large; Michael<br />
Burian, Government<br />
Appointee; Mike Thomson,<br />
Surveyor General;<br />
and Chuck Salmon as<br />
Secretary. Elected for<br />
their first time: David<br />
Harris and Ron Johns as<br />
members at large. s<br />
A camp for children with serious and<br />
chronic illnesses and disabilities<br />
Every child should be able to experience the<br />
fun and excitement of summer camp. Zajac<br />
Ranch for Children provides an experience of<br />
a lifetime to countless campers yearly.<br />
With your support we can continue to deliver<br />
exceptional camp experiences and truly<br />
unforgettable memories in a safe and caring<br />
environment to children from across BC.<br />
The Scrivener 1/3 page square ad (4.9375 inches wide x 4.75 inches high)<br />
Thanks for<br />
helping me<br />
go to camp!<br />
www.zajacranch.com<br />
604.739.0444<br />
Each year the <strong>British</strong><br />
<strong>Columbia</strong> Society for<br />
the Prevention of Cruelty<br />
to Animals helps more<br />
than 29,000 abused, sick,<br />
homeless, injured, lost and<br />
neglected animals across the<br />
province.<br />
Your support enables the BC<br />
SPCA to be there for them,<br />
giving them a second chance<br />
at life.<br />
Please help by making a<br />
donation or leaving a gift<br />
to the animals in your Will.<br />
Please visit us at online at<br />
spca.bc.ca or contact:<br />
Yolonda Benoit<br />
Senior Manager, Gift Planning<br />
ybenoit@spca.bc.ca<br />
778.327.6821<br />
1.800.665.1868 (toll-free)<br />
Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013 The Scrivener 73
TRaVEL<br />
Colombia is Safe,<br />
But Don’t Pack Laundry Soap<br />
An experienced traveller,<br />
I will be chuckling<br />
for years about exiting<br />
Colombia via the Bogotá airport<br />
after 2 wonderful weeks.<br />
For context, you must appreciate<br />
that the entire airport is basically<br />
a dog-sniffing kennel.<br />
For context, you must<br />
appreciate that the<br />
entire airport is basically<br />
a dog-sniffing kennel.<br />
As I was about to board,<br />
I was informed that the National<br />
Police had removed my suitcase from<br />
the plane and wished to inspect it.<br />
The airline employee mentioned that<br />
was done on a total “lottery” basis.<br />
She perhaps meant random, but when<br />
I entered the bowels of the airport and<br />
met the attending police, I knew there<br />
was nothing random about it.<br />
Trevor Todd<br />
After I identified my luggage, it<br />
was carefully scrutinized. The search<br />
ended abruptly when the suspicious<br />
white powder they likely saw in the<br />
x-rays turned out to be laundry soap.<br />
We gave each other the all-knowing<br />
smile and my luggage was returned<br />
to me a few days later.<br />
It is now possible to fly direct<br />
from Vancouver to Panama City. From<br />
there, it’s only a 45-minute flight<br />
to Cartagena, Colombia. Panama itself<br />
is worth checking out; it’s the thirdmost-popular<br />
retirement centre in the<br />
world for North Americans.<br />
Cartagena reminded me<br />
of Havana without the “benefits”<br />
of 55 years of communism. The<br />
beautiful walled city is an international<br />
heritage site frequented by the cruise<br />
ships. It has charm, history, and hot<br />
Rio-like beaches.<br />
From the moment I arrived<br />
in Colombia until I left, I felt<br />
completely safe, welcome, and<br />
comfortable. In Cartagena, I noticed<br />
74 The Society of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013
Llama for children’s ride in Bogotá Eccentrically dressed man later seen<br />
as a Bogotá street-performing “Dandy”<br />
the discreet presence of police almost<br />
everywhere, while in other cities such<br />
as Bogotá, the police and the army<br />
were ever-present in what could only be<br />
described as a “show of force.”<br />
I have seen such state displays<br />
of power in many tyrannical countries<br />
but in Colombia, genuine warmth<br />
was displayed between the populace and<br />
the security forces. It was apparent that<br />
after all the decades of violence they had undergone—with<br />
50 years of guerrilla warfare against FARC to the cocaine<br />
cartels’ horrific violence until recent years—everyone<br />
was genuinely pleased to have security and peace.<br />
The “bad guys” seem to have moved on to Mexico and<br />
other destinations, while the FARC guerrillas appear to be<br />
heading toward a truce. In any event, the FARC troubles are<br />
far away from anywhere a tourist is likely to go.<br />
I visited four cities, namely coastal and tropical<br />
Cartagena; hillside and temperate Medellin; “breathtakingly”<br />
high Bogotá, the capital; and Villa de Leyva. The latter is<br />
a 500-year-old cobblestoned provincial town approximately<br />
3-and-half hours by road from Bogotá. It was certainly the<br />
highlight of the trip for me.<br />
It is a very well-educated,<br />
cultured, and polite<br />
country of 46 million that<br />
desperately wants to prove<br />
to the world that it is not<br />
what it was…<br />
All in all, I would recommend<br />
Colombia for tourism but must point<br />
out there was little English and I had<br />
nada Español. Sign language often<br />
leads to hilarity and fond memories<br />
when recalling the awkwardness of the<br />
moment.<br />
It is a very well-educated, cultured,<br />
and polite country of 46 million that<br />
desperately wants to prove to the<br />
world that it is not what it was, or what its neighbour<br />
Venezuela has increasingly become. s<br />
A wedding in Villa de Leyva Cobblestone streets of beautiful 500-year-old Villa de Leyva<br />
Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013 The Scrivener 75
TECHNOLOGY<br />
The Latest and Best<br />
for Spring 2013<br />
You’re Two-Faced!<br />
Whether or not you are a fan<br />
of microsoft’s latest operating system<br />
Windows 8 (I am slowly warming up<br />
to it), it is here and it’s centre-stage<br />
on many a hardware package.<br />
Lucky for us, that hardware is<br />
pretty cool. For example, HP Canada’s<br />
new Envy X2 laptop is a convertible<br />
system that turns into a full-function<br />
tablet PC with one single click.<br />
For your viewing pleasure, there<br />
is an 11.6" 1366 x 768 resolution<br />
display that features five-finger<br />
capacitive touch functionality. The<br />
screen is larger than the iPad (4th<br />
gen) 9.7" screen, but smaller than<br />
most laptops (13” plus). That said,<br />
it’s a pleasant balance between size<br />
and weight with the tablet weighing<br />
in at 1.51 lbs. (690 grams)<br />
and the base adding 1.60 lbs.<br />
(730 grams). Does this base<br />
make me look fat?<br />
One thing not on the skinny<br />
here is style. The Envy X2 sports<br />
a brushed aluminum lid/<br />
tablet back, as<br />
well as a brushed<br />
aluminum docking<br />
hinge and palm rest. The<br />
clamshell shape is aesthetically<br />
pleasing and feels comfortable when<br />
you carry the unit.<br />
The tight-spaced short-travel keys<br />
do take some getting used to, but with<br />
a touch-screen close at hand (see<br />
what I did above), it may not matter.<br />
When disconnected from its<br />
dock, the Envy X2 uses the standard<br />
Windows 8 virtual keyboard, which<br />
stretches across the bottom of the<br />
screen in Windows 8 mode but can<br />
be dragged around in desktop mode.<br />
Though the Envy x2 does not support<br />
an active stylus, Windows 8 does have<br />
a handwriting recognition box you can<br />
use in lieu of a keyboard.<br />
Attached to the base, the Envy X2<br />
offers two USB 2.0 ports, one fullsize<br />
HDMI connector, and a standard<br />
SD card slot. The tablet itself adds<br />
a 3.5 mm headphone jack, a microSD<br />
card slot, and a proprietary docking<br />
port that either connects to the dock or<br />
directly to the charging cable. It is to be<br />
noted there is no Ethernet port or USB<br />
3.0 port. Other ways to communicate<br />
with the outside<br />
world: 802.11n Wi-Fi,<br />
Bluetooth 4.0, and front-<br />
and rear-facing cameras<br />
(front 2 MP, rear 8 MP).<br />
Under the hood, the<br />
unit runs a 1.8-GHz Intel<br />
Atom Z2760 CPU, 2 GB<br />
of RAM, and a 64 GB SSD<br />
(solid state drive). While<br />
this processor is slower than<br />
Intel’s own i5 or even i3,<br />
performance hardly suffers. The X2<br />
will handle all your word processing,<br />
spreadsheet, and graph needs—with<br />
decent video capabilities thrown in for<br />
good measure.<br />
** HP Envy X2, www.hp.ca<br />
$849.99<br />
Akash Sablok<br />
A Smaller Face<br />
So you’re starting to get comfy with the<br />
whole Windows 8-tile theme, you see<br />
a mobile phone with the same tile theme,<br />
and you think to yourself what a wonderful<br />
world! okay, maybe you’re not doing<br />
cartwheels but the Nokia Lumia 920 is an<br />
exciting mobile device that just happens<br />
to run Windows Phone 8.<br />
The o/s (operating system) is not<br />
the full version of Windows 8—it’s<br />
been modified to fit the small form<br />
factor and work efficiently on a 4.5"<br />
768 x 1280 screen.<br />
And work it does. The 920 is<br />
a powerhouse. The Snapdragon S4<br />
runs the system fast and gives you<br />
10.8 hours of talk time (on 3G), 460<br />
hours of standby time (over 19 days),<br />
and 74 hours of sweet music in your<br />
ears. Photobugs will like the 8.7<br />
megapixel camera. Shaky photobugs<br />
will like the Nokia PureView system<br />
that stabilizes the camera inside the<br />
phone by housing it in a cage with<br />
a gyroscope.<br />
The<br />
camera also<br />
captures full<br />
HD video<br />
(1920 x 1080),<br />
76 The Society of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013
meaning you can leave your camcorder<br />
at home most of the time. Zooming is<br />
done by pinching the screen and if you<br />
feel the need to share immediately,<br />
you can share directly from the<br />
captured image to Facebook, Twitter,<br />
Skydrive, MMS, or email.<br />
Speaking of Skydrive—Microsoft’s<br />
cloud-storage offering—you can save<br />
attachments or photos and documents<br />
that you create on the phone direct<br />
to Skydrive, then access them from<br />
any PC, anywhere.<br />
http://www.nokia.com/ca-en/products/<br />
phone/lumia920/<br />
Price: Plan Dependent<br />
Look Ma, No Computer!<br />
When they say “there’s an App for<br />
that!” they can now include scanners—<br />
specifically the new Fujitsu ScanSnap<br />
iX500 Scanner.<br />
The iX500 is the latest version<br />
of the (dare I say) sexy and hottest<br />
line-up of scanners around. Ask<br />
anyone who uses one; they will tell you<br />
the ScanSnap series of machines are<br />
workhorses.<br />
Yes, they are pricey—starting<br />
at $500 plus, but you get good<br />
value for your money. For example,<br />
the iX500 utilizes a double-sided,<br />
25-page-per-minute, full-colour<br />
image sensor, comes bundled with<br />
a full version of Adobe Acrobat X for<br />
Windows, and can now scan directly<br />
to a smartphone.<br />
Feed the scanner any way you<br />
want. Documents placed upside down,<br />
backward, slightly skewed, or even<br />
blank. It doesn’t matter; the iX500 will<br />
straighten it all<br />
up. The latest<br />
version now<br />
includes<br />
an onboard<br />
processor so it can process images<br />
faster and send them to your computer<br />
or smartphone faster.<br />
The free downloadable App for<br />
iOS (iPad, iPhone, etc.) and Android<br />
devices allows you to scan images<br />
directly to your mobile device. This<br />
is perfect for IDs or a contract<br />
that you need right away and your<br />
computer is off or not available.<br />
Once you have your image(s),<br />
the included software will recognize<br />
the text within the scan. Using your<br />
computer’s search feature, you can<br />
find any word or line in a scanned<br />
document—very helpful for finding<br />
that document you scanned 2 years,<br />
3 days, and 4 hours ago.<br />
www.fujitsu.ca<br />
mSRP $549<br />
Road Tech<br />
you’ve probably guessed I love<br />
technology and I also love cars—so<br />
when the two get together, it’s, well,<br />
harmony.<br />
The 2013 Acura ILX Tech, based<br />
on the Number 1-selling vehicle<br />
in Canada, the Honda Civic, is the<br />
smallest vehicle in the Acura line-up.<br />
Previous Civic-based Acuras<br />
could have been mistaken for their<br />
Honda cousins, but not the ILX.<br />
Acura has given it a distinctive—and<br />
stylish—design.<br />
The ILX is larger, on the inside<br />
and out, than previous small-size<br />
Acuras. You can seat four adults<br />
comfortably or put in one more and<br />
hear him complain during the drive.<br />
If you choose the 2.0L inline-<br />
4 cylinder, under your right foot are<br />
150 horses. You can shift manually or<br />
let the electronics take care of it for you.<br />
I prefer the automatic—it’s smoother<br />
than I thought it would be, getting<br />
high-pitched only under full red-line<br />
acceleration. Get the auto and you get<br />
to play with steering-mounted paddleshifters.<br />
Can someone say Xbox 360?<br />
Upgrade to the Dynamic version’s<br />
2.4L DOHC i-VTEC 4-cylinder and you<br />
get 201 hp @ 7000 rpm. You also get<br />
one choice of transmission—the sixspeed<br />
manual.<br />
If you want to leave Planet Earth<br />
a little cleaner for your children, there is<br />
a hybrid model also on the options list.<br />
The 111 hp half-electric–half-gasoline<br />
engine does a decent job of moving you<br />
around and is a self-contained system<br />
that does not need to be plugged in.<br />
The Hybrid will also leave your wallet<br />
a little cleaner, adding approximately<br />
$7000 to the base price of the ILX.<br />
The ILX Technology version I drove<br />
had one of the best navigation units<br />
around. Entering a destination on the<br />
8" screen was quick and easy and the<br />
turn-by-turn directions were accurate.<br />
Of course, according to my wife,<br />
I know all the directions anyway.<br />
You can set the front seats any<br />
way you like with the 8-way poweradjustments.<br />
Once you find a position<br />
you like, you can crank the highend<br />
10-speaker stereo system. Plug<br />
in a USB stick or use a Bluetoothenabled<br />
phone/mp3 player and your<br />
playlist can be endless.<br />
Other vehicles in this category<br />
include the B250 from Mercedes-<br />
Benz, the Lexus CT, and the Lexus IS.<br />
www.acura.ca<br />
Base: $29,735<br />
Premium: $31,935<br />
Tech: $34,235<br />
Hybrid: $36,935 s<br />
Vancouver Notary Akash Sablok,<br />
AJAC (Automobile Journalists<br />
Association of Canada), practises with<br />
his father Tarlok Sablok. Akash writes<br />
regular technology and automotive<br />
columns for several publications<br />
across Canada and appears as a guest<br />
technology reviewer on TV programs,<br />
including CityTV’s Breakfast Television<br />
(BT Vancouver); omni Television (BC);<br />
TELUS TV – myTelus: Vancouver<br />
Edition; and Shaw TV’s The Rush with<br />
Fiona Forbes and a regular presenter<br />
on CTV’s Morning Live Show.<br />
akash@sablok.com<br />
Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013 The Scrivener 77
HONOURS & EVENTS<br />
Lois May Sheffield Lambert<br />
June 13, 1910,<br />
to September 10, 2011<br />
Lois passed away<br />
peacefully at 101.<br />
She attended<br />
school in Cardston<br />
and moved to<br />
Nelson, BC, for<br />
business college,<br />
where she married Buck. At that<br />
time, it was against the law for<br />
a woman to go out to work if her<br />
husband was gainfully employed,<br />
so Lois quit her job. In 1940<br />
son Bill was born. In 1963 Lois<br />
became the first female Notary<br />
Public in the Nelson District.<br />
In 1970 she became the only<br />
woman on the BC Notaries’ Board<br />
of Directors.<br />
See Lois’s story online<br />
in the Winter 2009 Scrivener:<br />
WHERE ARE THEY NOW?<br />
www.notaries.bc.ca/scrivener:<br />
Archives by Year<br />
Maia was born November 29 in<br />
Tacoma. This gorgeous Brittany Spaniel<br />
is the daughter of two champions and<br />
a real hunting dog. Maia accompanies<br />
BC Notary Andrea Agnoloni to his office<br />
from time to time. She is excellent with<br />
client relationships!<br />
PEoPLE<br />
Sally Jane Patricia O’Sullivan-Lee<br />
January 26, 1951,<br />
to December 22, 2012<br />
Sally O’Sullivan<br />
was the first female<br />
President (1996<br />
to 1998) of The<br />
Society of Notaries<br />
Public of BC. She<br />
served on the<br />
Board for a number of years and<br />
was Chair of the Notary Foundation<br />
in 1999 and 2000. She was<br />
commissioned as a BC Notary from<br />
1985 to 2003. For Sally, the most<br />
satisfying aspect of being<br />
a BC Notary was the people.<br />
Her Abbotsford practice focused<br />
on seniors’ needs. She and her<br />
husband Brian Lee loved to travel.<br />
Most important to her were her<br />
faith and her family.<br />
“My children have always been my<br />
best accomplishment. To say I am<br />
a besotted grandmother would be<br />
an understatement!”<br />
Where in the World Has The Scrivener Been?<br />
Trevor Todd (right) in Villa de Leyva, Colombia<br />
Be in the Magazine!<br />
Send your news and<br />
a photo to The Scrivener.<br />
scrivener@society.notaries.bc.ca<br />
On top of a Master’s degree in Applied<br />
Legal Studies from SFU and the<br />
additional in-depth education training<br />
it takes to become a BC Notary, plus<br />
work and family life, Beverly Carter<br />
recently found time to marry a guy<br />
named Bruce!<br />
The Scrivener and Kari Boyle, Executive<br />
Director of the Mediate BC Society,<br />
outside the new Superior Court<br />
of Justice building in Merida, a large<br />
and lovely city in the northwest Yucatan,<br />
Mexico. The locals were very upset that<br />
it didn’t fit at all with Merida’s historic<br />
Spanish colonial architecture. We<br />
thought it was amazing . . . it would suit<br />
Vancouver perfectly!<br />
78 The Society of Notaries Public of <strong>British</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Volume 22 Number 1 Spring 2013
Look Closer…<br />
What do you see people, what do you see?<br />
Is it just an old woman when you look at me?<br />
Do you see that in my life, I gave with an open hand and heart?<br />
That I raised children, that I nursed, that I mattered and I taught?<br />
That I smiled, that I danced, that I cared and I laughed?<br />
Do you know I remember the heartaches and miss the joys of the past?<br />
Now my body often fails me and my mind can be weak,<br />
The ravages of time have me sometimes cranky, sometimes meek.<br />
But my wish is to tell you, to have you realize<br />
That all that I was, I am, I still matter – see it in my eyes<br />
See that what’s now important has only come to be<br />
That you look closer, look close and…<br />
See Me.<br />
The Eldercare Foundation enhances the care,<br />
comfort, dignity and independence of hundreds<br />
of elderly residents living in care facilities and<br />
generally supports elderly persons living on<br />
Vancouver Island by funding community programs<br />
and education for seniors and their caregivers.<br />
Outdated equipment needs to be replaced,<br />
community programs that allow people to stay in<br />
their homes longer need to be funded and care<br />
facilities need to feel more like home. It will require<br />
just over one million dollars to fill these urgent<br />
needs alone.<br />
Funds to provide valuable education and research<br />
to improve the way the elderly are cared for are also<br />
urgently needed.<br />
Please consider donating today. Your legacy will help<br />
us enhance quality of life for our valued elders for<br />
generations to come.<br />
1454 Hillside Ave., Victoria, BC V8T 2B7<br />
250-370-5664 • www.gvef.org