30.06.2013 Views

Folie 1 - TU Berlin

Folie 1 - TU Berlin

Folie 1 - TU Berlin

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

December 6th, 2009<br />

May 6th, 2011<br />

Qasr al-Mushatta<br />

research and<br />

restoration project<br />

A common effort of<br />

Jordan and Germany<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


The famous desert castles in Jordan – more are available<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Desert castles:<br />

Qastal and Kharana<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Desert castles: Kharana<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Desert castles: Qusair Amra<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Desert castles: Qusair Amra<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Desert castles: Qasr al-Tuba<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Desert castles: Qasr al-Tuba<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Desert castles: Qasr al-Tuba<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Desert castle: Qasr al-Mushatta.<br />

The site before 1903 in the<br />

steppe with no human<br />

settlements around<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


The site next to Amman Queen Alia<br />

International Airport from the airplane<br />

threatened by industrial building<br />

activities<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Qasr al-Mushatta -<br />

shared heritage in Jordan and Germany<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


1. Research strategies<br />

- Evaluation of historic documents<br />

- Surveying<br />

- Documentation<br />

- Archaeology<br />

- Buildings archaeology<br />

- investigation of the surface<br />

- collection of the graffiti<br />

- research in the emerging Islamic art history<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Now in the new National Museum<br />

More in Kuwait, Jerusalem and<br />

Marocco; some disappeared<br />

Identification of dispersed elements<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


What has been done since 1903:<br />

clearance work<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


aerial archaeology and landscape survey<br />

geodetic survey, mapping of the entire<br />

surfaces<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


exact drawing of the remains: south façade in Jordan<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


exact drawing of the remains: south façade in <strong>Berlin</strong><br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


exact drawing of the remains: Detail south façade<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Archaeology in order to<br />

identify the original<br />

ground plan<br />

Yellow: Bujard 2000<br />

Magenta: <strong>TU</strong> <strong>Berlin</strong> 2010<br />

Mosaic tesserae<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Trench I_03_a.<br />

Foundation East-West.<br />

Looking east; Oct. 2010<br />

Foundations and finds<br />

Axonometric drawing of the foundations in trench I_03_a<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Excavation in the quarter of the mosque<br />

Foundation of partition wall; Oct.<br />

2010<br />

Trench VIII_08_a.<br />

Looking southwest and<br />

south; Oct. 2010<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Historic building techniques: brickwork and limestone masonry<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


ickwork: two different<br />

sizes of the bricks<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


lime stone masonry: headers and stretchers<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Detailed study of the construction<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


High quality surface of the brickwork with one brick<br />

showing an inscription of unknown message<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Refinement of the limestone masonry:<br />

Embellishment of the joints found<br />

throughout the entire castle<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Refinement of the brickwork:<br />

Numerous remains of plaster<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Refinement of<br />

the walls and<br />

flooring:<br />

colourful mosaic<br />

tesserae<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Refinement of the flooring: big green<br />

marble slabs<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Refinement of the decoration: red colour in the rosettas of the palace<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Numerous fragments of<br />

sculpture in the palace<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Results of the research project<br />

- Complete documentation of the actual situation of the ruin<br />

- Archaeological evidence concerning ground plan<br />

- The palace did not remain a ruin but was finished and used<br />

in the central area<br />

- Reconsidering the dating of Mushatta<br />

Foundations<br />

finished<br />

Definitely<br />

completely<br />

finished<br />

Eventually<br />

finished<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project<br />

Only<br />

trenches<br />

of foundations<br />

finished


Excavation in the central court of the castle<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Location of the excavation<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Earthquake has thrown down the arches<br />

of the facade and twisted the pillars<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Coin of around 760<br />

under the pavement of<br />

the court and under the<br />

stones of the arches<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


2. Restoration strategies<br />

- Safeguarding the existing fabric by conservation<br />

- Stop further loss of precious works of art<br />

- Improve the understanding of the ruin for visitors by<br />

° Rebuilding the facade of the palace<br />

° Rebuilding the inner arch of the audience hall<br />

° Closing the gap of the main gate<br />

° Site management and visitor center<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Current restoration project:<br />

repair of the old brickwork in the elevation with old bricks<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Mortar is produced from lime,<br />

sand, crushed bricks, a bit of<br />

clay and with lots of ashes –<br />

the use of cement in a<br />

historic monument is a<br />

crime against heritage<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Current restoration project:<br />

repair of the brickwork in the wall tops with new bricks<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


How to produce<br />

new bricks:<br />

First study the<br />

old ones: brick<br />

with special<br />

traces; bricks<br />

with stamp –<br />

unique find<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Brick production is not easy: numerous ingredients like clay, sand, straw<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Brick production: forming the adobes<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Brick production: filling the kiln<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Brick production in a very traditional way:<br />

Kiln before firing bricks for two full days,<br />

after this the kiln will cool down for<br />

another 10 days – slow production.<br />

100.000 bricks needed 18 months.<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Selection of old bricks – numerous different colors<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Old and new brick – color is similar<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Old bricks inside, new<br />

bricks on the surface as<br />

sacrifice layer<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Current restoration project: repair of the brickwork – results achieved<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Future Project 1: raising<br />

the western elevation in order<br />

to obscure the ugly industrial<br />

zone<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Hedjaz railway track<br />

Mushatta is threatened<br />

by a growing industrial<br />

zone approaching the<br />

ruin – the visual integrity<br />

is highly endangered<br />

Air cargo access<br />

to the airport<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Environmental aspects 1: Plants and flowers<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Environmental aspects 2:<br />

Animals - various birds and lizzards<br />

falcon<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Current restoration project: Anastylosis of the facade of the palace<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


location of various<br />

line drawings<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Line drawings –<br />

sketch of the<br />

arcade, not to scale<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


econstruction of the colonnaded court,<br />

superimposed with the line drawings<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


lime stone masonry: headers and stretchers<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


line drawing for a decoration inside the palace, scale 1:1<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


line drawing of a design for a decoration, scale 1:1,<br />

superimposed on the south façade<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


line drawing of an arch, scale 1:1<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


line drawing, scale 1:1, superimposed on the three-arched façade<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


layout superimposed on the realized reconstruction<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Detailed planning for the scaffolding<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Reinforced brickwork<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Sophisticated technology<br />

inside the brickwork:<br />

reinforcement against<br />

earthquake challenges<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Rosetta reassembled from<br />

five different fragments<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Rosettas reassembled<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


New stones are brilliant<br />

white as the old ones have<br />

been more than thousand<br />

years ago. New stone glued<br />

to an old one.<br />

New stones for the arches<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Continuous use of traditional<br />

techniques: liquid mortar<br />

filled into the masonry –<br />

channels prepared for fill-in<br />

in the stones for the arches<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Future Project 1: Rebuilding the inner arch of the reception hall<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Stones of the arch of the audience hall<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Stones are reduced and<br />

looted in various ways<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Unfinished decoration of<br />

the inner arch of the<br />

audience hall<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Rebuilding the arch of<br />

the audience hall<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Future Project 3: Closing the gap of the main gate. Situation as today<br />

and in 1903 before dismanteling the western wing for transport to Germany<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Present situation after anastylosis of the palace façade<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Solution 2: volume of the 1903 situation<br />

rebuilt in solid limestone masonry with<br />

abstracted decoration including original<br />

elements still found on the site<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Solution 3: augmented reality as app for smartphone<br />

current situation superimposed with photograph of before 1903<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Thank you for your attention<br />

Thanks to everybody who supported the project, namely the<br />

Department of Antiquities of Jordan, and the entire staff of Jordan,<br />

Germany, <strong>Berlin</strong> National Museums and <strong>Berlin</strong> Institute of<br />

Technology together with those who provided the financial means:<br />

German Research Foundation and German Foreign Office<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Bauwerke zum Thema, die man<br />

gesehen haben sollte (5)<br />

Fachhochschule Wildau<br />

Anderhalten Architekten<br />

War: Lokomotivenfabrik<br />

Ist: Hochschulgebäude<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!