View the presentation - Dr. Gregory L. Plett
View the presentation - Dr. Gregory L. Plett
View the presentation - Dr. Gregory L. Plett
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
Web-Assisted Learning<br />
via On-Line Course Supplements<br />
<strong>Dr</strong>s. <strong>Gregory</strong> L. <strong>Plett</strong> and Mark A. Wickert<br />
Electrical and Computer Engineering Department<br />
University of Colorado at Colorado Springs<br />
P.O. Box 7150, Colorado Springs, CO 80933–7150<br />
24 June 2003 Web-Assisted Learning via On-Line Course Supplements G. L. <strong>Plett</strong> and M. A. Wickert [1]
Overview<br />
What are course supplements? How should <strong>the</strong>y be made<br />
available (style, format, media)?<br />
¡<br />
¡<br />
The EduFile Course Supplement Management System<br />
Student perspective;<br />
Faculty perspective.<br />
Assessment via data logging and survey results.<br />
Conclusions<br />
24 June 2003 Web-Assisted Learning via On-Line Course Supplements G. L. <strong>Plett</strong> and M. A. Wickert [2]
Course Supplements<br />
Some examples: Lecture notes, lecture audio/video,<br />
homework hints, homework solutions, worked example<br />
problems, sample tests and sample computer code.<br />
The Internet is an efficient means to distribute supplements.<br />
We discuss results of a project with three main objectives:<br />
1. Develop standards of style and format for supplements;<br />
2. Develop simple means whereby <strong>the</strong> instructor may add<br />
materials to <strong>the</strong> course web-site;<br />
3. Develop automatic evaluation means to determine if <strong>the</strong><br />
on-line course supplements assist student learning.<br />
24 June 2003 Web-Assisted Learning via On-Line Course Supplements G. L. <strong>Plett</strong> and M. A. Wickert [3]
Supplement Format and Style<br />
To aid accessibility, standardize file formats and style.<br />
Style: A constant template for homework assignments and<br />
solutions, documentation standards for code segments.<br />
Consistency allows a student to decode content readily.<br />
Format: Open-standard file formats provide universal<br />
access and eliminate economic prejudice; e.g., PDF files in<br />
preference to proprietary document formats. PDF<br />
preserves fonts, formatting, graphics and color of <strong>the</strong><br />
source document. Where PDF files are not appropriate, we<br />
use standard ASCII text files where possible.<br />
24 June 2003 Web-Assisted Learning via On-Line Course Supplements G. L. <strong>Plett</strong> and M. A. Wickert [4]
Delivery Method (I): The Internet<br />
The Internet is an obvious choice: It can be accessed from<br />
anywhere at any time; it may be used to transmit programs<br />
or code segments, which must be re-typed if delivered in<br />
paper media; and it is <strong>the</strong> only reasonable way to make<br />
audio, video and data files available to large numbers of<br />
students.<br />
However, a simple file repository is an untenable solution as<br />
<strong>the</strong> number of supplements becomes large. Students lose<br />
track of which files <strong>the</strong>y have downloaded, and <strong>the</strong>re is no<br />
apparent organization.<br />
24 June 2003 Web-Assisted Learning via On-Line Course Supplements G. L. <strong>Plett</strong> and M. A. Wickert [5]
Delivery Method (II): Dynamic Documents<br />
Course materials are dynamic documents. They are<br />
developed and are modified as <strong>the</strong> semester progresses.<br />
The student needs to know when a file has been updated.<br />
An Internet site could be developed that keeps a data-base<br />
of all download activity for each student and can <strong>the</strong>n mark<br />
supplement-material files as being “not yet downloaded”,<br />
“updated since last download” or “unchanged since last<br />
download” with respect to <strong>the</strong> student querying <strong>the</strong> site.<br />
We have developed such a site.<br />
24 June 2003 Web-Assisted Learning via On-Line Course Supplements G. L. <strong>Plett</strong> and M. A. Wickert [6]
EduFile<br />
We call <strong>the</strong> web-based software created to meet <strong>the</strong><br />
aforementioned needs <strong>the</strong> “EduFile Course Supplement<br />
Management System” or simply EduFile.<br />
Technical details: EduFile is written in PERL and uses a<br />
mysql database to manage information on students,<br />
supplements, courses and so forth. We use a Linux-based<br />
platform with an Apache web server.<br />
First, we describe <strong>the</strong> students’ perspective and <strong>the</strong>n <strong>the</strong><br />
faculty / instructor perspective.<br />
24 June 2003 Web-Assisted Learning via On-Line Course Supplements G. L. <strong>Plett</strong> and M. A. Wickert [7]
ˆyk<br />
Student Log-On Screen<br />
When <strong>the</strong> student<br />
browses to <strong>the</strong> course<br />
e<br />
homepage, she sees <strong>the</strong><br />
screen to <strong>the</strong> right.<br />
(sys)<br />
k<br />
The student must<br />
register <strong>the</strong> first time she<br />
uses EduFile.<br />
yk<br />
ˆyk<br />
ˆyk<br />
ˇyk<br />
˜yk<br />
After that, she types Temporal her<br />
username and password Delay<br />
to enter <strong>the</strong> system.<br />
˜dk<br />
dk<br />
e (mod)<br />
k<br />
˜e (sys)<br />
k<br />
˜εk<br />
˜εk<br />
rk− P<br />
24 June 2003 Web-Assisted Learning via On-Line Course Supplements G. L. <strong>Plett</strong> and M. A. Wickert [8]
Student Registration<br />
The student does not automatically have access to <strong>the</strong><br />
course supplements. On registration, EduFile sends an<br />
email message to <strong>the</strong> course instructor:<br />
Student user 112233 has requested to download supplements<br />
for course ECE3510. Go to http://edufile.uccs.edu/<br />
facultyadmin/ to log in and enable this user.<br />
The instructor must “enable” access for each student.<br />
EduFile will automatically send an email:<br />
Student user account for 112233 has been enabled. Go to<br />
http://edufile.uccs.edu/?course_id=ECE3510/ to log in.<br />
Only <strong>the</strong>n may <strong>the</strong> student access <strong>the</strong> supplements.<br />
24 June 2003 Web-Assisted Learning via On-Line Course Supplements G. L. <strong>Plett</strong> and M. A. Wickert [9]
ˆyk<br />
The Main Supplement Access Page<br />
On log-on, <strong>the</strong> student<br />
accesses <strong>the</strong> main page,<br />
shown to <strong>the</strong> right.<br />
Course information is one<br />
top, supplement<br />
information is below.<br />
(sys)<br />
Supplements are<br />
annotated, and marked<br />
yk<br />
yk<br />
yk<br />
ˆyk<br />
ˇyk<br />
ˆyk<br />
˜yk<br />
˜εk<br />
as downloaded or not, rk− P<br />
updated or not. Temporal<br />
Delay<br />
˜dk<br />
dk<br />
k<br />
e (mod)<br />
k<br />
˜e (sys)<br />
k<br />
˜εk<br />
24 June 2003 Web-Assisted Learning via On-Line Course Supplements G. L. <strong>Plett</strong> and M. A. Wickert [10]
yk<br />
yk<br />
ˆyk<br />
ˆyk<br />
ˇyk<br />
ˆyk<br />
Instructor Log-On<br />
˜yk<br />
˜dk<br />
All instructor log-on is done through <strong>the</strong> browser’s<br />
dk<br />
au<strong>the</strong>ntication procedure.<br />
e<br />
The log-on dialog is shown below.<br />
(sys)<br />
k<br />
e (mod)<br />
k<br />
˜e (sys)<br />
k<br />
˜εk<br />
˜εk<br />
rk− P<br />
Temporal<br />
Delay<br />
24 June 2003 Web-Assisted Learning via On-Line Course Supplements G. L. <strong>Plett</strong> and M. A. Wickert [11]
ˆyk<br />
ˆyk<br />
ˇyk<br />
ˆyk<br />
Instructor Welcome Page<br />
˜yk<br />
˜dk<br />
dk<br />
e (sys)<br />
k<br />
e<br />
The main instructor page<br />
allows creating a course,<br />
editing a course, or<br />
viewing <strong>the</strong> student<br />
activity log (for<br />
assessment).<br />
(mod)<br />
k<br />
˜e (sys)<br />
k<br />
˜εk<br />
˜εk<br />
rk− P<br />
Temporal<br />
Delay<br />
24 June 2003 Web-Assisted Learning via On-Line Course Supplements G. L. <strong>Plett</strong> and M. A. Wickert [12]
yk<br />
yk<br />
ˆyk<br />
ˆyk<br />
Edit Courseˇyk Information<br />
ˆyk<br />
˜yk<br />
The top of <strong>the</strong> course e<br />
information page allows<br />
changing instructor,<br />
changing course<br />
description or course<br />
name.<br />
(sys)<br />
k<br />
e (mod)<br />
k<br />
˜e (sys)<br />
k<br />
˜εk<br />
˜εk<br />
rk− P<br />
Temporal<br />
Delay<br />
˜dk<br />
dk<br />
24 June 2003 Web-Assisted Learning via On-Line Course Supplements G. L. <strong>Plett</strong> and M. A. Wickert [13]
yk<br />
˜yk<br />
˜dk<br />
dk<br />
e (sys)<br />
k<br />
e (mod)<br />
˜e (sys)<br />
ˆyk<br />
ˆyk<br />
ˇyk<br />
ˆyk<br />
˜yk<br />
k ˜dk<br />
˜εk<br />
Edit Supplement/Student k Information<br />
dk<br />
˜εk<br />
e<br />
The middle of <strong>the</strong> course rk− P<br />
information page allows Temporal<br />
Delay<br />
changing supplement<br />
descriptions.<br />
The bottom allows<br />
changing student access<br />
privileges.<br />
(sys)<br />
k<br />
e (mod)<br />
k<br />
˜e (sys)<br />
k<br />
˜εk<br />
˜εk<br />
rk− P<br />
Temporal<br />
Delay<br />
24 June 2003 Web-Assisted Learning via On-Line Course Supplements G. L. <strong>Plett</strong> and M. A. Wickert [14]
Noise, vk<br />
rk<br />
uk<br />
uk<br />
ũk<br />
ũk<br />
uk<br />
ũk<br />
yk<br />
yk<br />
yk<br />
ˆyk<br />
ˆyk<br />
ˇyk<br />
ˆyk<br />
˜yk<br />
˜dk<br />
dk<br />
e (sys)<br />
k<br />
e (mod)<br />
k<br />
˜e (sys)<br />
k ˜εk<br />
˜εk<br />
Number of Documents Retrieved<br />
rk− P<br />
Temporal<br />
Delay<br />
30<br />
25<br />
20<br />
15<br />
10<br />
5<br />
Noise, vk<br />
rk<br />
uk<br />
uk<br />
ũk<br />
ũk<br />
uk<br />
ũk<br />
Student Access per Day and Week<br />
0<br />
01/20 01/27 02/03 02/10 02/17 02/24 03/03 03/10 03/17<br />
Date − mm/dd of 2002<br />
yk<br />
yk<br />
yk<br />
Data logging allows flexible assessment. ˆyk For example, <strong>the</strong><br />
ˆyk<br />
figures below show histograms of student access per day<br />
ˇyk<br />
and per week.<br />
ˆyk<br />
˜yk<br />
˜dk<br />
ECE 3610 EduFile Visits Per Day<br />
ECE 3610 EduFile Visits Per Week<br />
90<br />
dk<br />
e (sys)<br />
k<br />
e (mod)<br />
k<br />
˜e (sys)<br />
k ˜εk<br />
˜εk<br />
rk− P<br />
Number of Documents Retrieved<br />
Temporal<br />
Delay<br />
80<br />
70<br />
60<br />
50<br />
40<br />
30<br />
20<br />
10<br />
0<br />
01/01 02/01 03/01 04/01<br />
Date − mm/dd of 2002<br />
24 June 2003 Web-Assisted Learning via On-Line Course Supplements G. L. <strong>Plett</strong> and M. A. Wickert [15]
k<br />
rk<br />
uk<br />
uk<br />
ũk<br />
ũk<br />
uk<br />
ũk<br />
yk<br />
yk<br />
yk<br />
ˆyk<br />
ˆyk<br />
ˇyk<br />
ˆyk<br />
˜yk<br />
˜dk<br />
dk<br />
e (sys)<br />
k<br />
e (mod)<br />
k<br />
˜e (sys)<br />
k ˜εk<br />
˜εk<br />
rk− P<br />
Temporal<br />
Number of Documents Retrieved<br />
90<br />
80<br />
70<br />
60<br />
50<br />
40<br />
30<br />
20<br />
10<br />
yk<br />
Student Access yk by Hour<br />
ˆyk<br />
Surprisingly, most students observed ˇyk reasonable hours.<br />
ˆyk<br />
Most downloads occurred directly after class.<br />
˜yk<br />
˜dk<br />
ECE 3610 EduFile Visits by Hour dk ECE 3610 EduFile Visits by Hour on Thursdays<br />
0<br />
0<br />
18:00 00:00 06:00 12:00 18:00 00:00<br />
18:00 00:00 06:00 12:00 18:00 00:00<br />
Delay Delay<br />
Time − hh/mm<br />
Time − hh/mm on Thursdays<br />
k<br />
rk<br />
uk<br />
uk<br />
ũk<br />
ũk<br />
uk<br />
ũk<br />
yk<br />
ˆyk<br />
e (sys)<br />
k<br />
e (mod)<br />
k<br />
˜e (sys)<br />
k ˜εk<br />
˜εk<br />
rk− P<br />
Temporal<br />
24 June 2003 Web-Assisted Learning via On-Line Course Supplements G. L. <strong>Plett</strong> and M. A. Wickert [16]<br />
Number of Documents Retrieved<br />
30<br />
25<br />
20<br />
15<br />
10<br />
5
Noise, vk<br />
rk<br />
uk<br />
uk<br />
ũk<br />
ũk<br />
uk<br />
ũk<br />
yk<br />
yk<br />
yk<br />
Scatter Plot<br />
Scatter plotsˆyk of student grades versus number of<br />
ˆyk<br />
downloads showed ˇyk no linear correlation between grades<br />
and supplements ˆyk (except that more downloads seemed to<br />
˜yk<br />
result in a passing grade).<br />
˜dk<br />
dk<br />
e (sys)<br />
k<br />
e (mod)<br />
k<br />
˜e (sys)<br />
k<br />
˜εk<br />
˜εk<br />
rk− P<br />
Temporal<br />
Delay<br />
Student Final Average Percent<br />
100<br />
95<br />
90<br />
85<br />
80<br />
75<br />
70<br />
65<br />
60<br />
55<br />
ECE 3610 EduFile Score vs Downloads Scatter Plot<br />
50<br />
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35<br />
Number of Documents Retrieved<br />
24 June 2003 Web-Assisted Learning via On-Line Course Supplements G. L. <strong>Plett</strong> and M. A. Wickert [17]
Survey Responses<br />
We conducted a survey to evaluate EduFile.<br />
Students indicated that <strong>the</strong>y frequently downloaded<br />
homework assignments, solutions, and sample exams—<br />
simulation files and updated lecture notes less frequently.<br />
The utility of <strong>the</strong> supplements was highly rated, especially<br />
for homeworks, homework solutions and practice exams.<br />
They were very pleased with <strong>the</strong> convenience and were not<br />
concerned with “invasion” of privacy (by logging accesses).<br />
The most frequent comments in <strong>the</strong> write-in section were<br />
“please add more practice exams”, “please add worked<br />
problems” and “please add solutions to practice exams”.<br />
24 June 2003 Web-Assisted Learning via On-Line Course Supplements G. L. <strong>Plett</strong> and M. A. Wickert [18]
Conclusions<br />
EduFile is an Internet-based supplement management<br />
system that we have designed and implemented.<br />
We hypo<strong>the</strong>sized that benefit to student learning would be<br />
significant; however, our findings were statistically<br />
inconclusive as to whe<strong>the</strong>r grades were improved.<br />
Survey responses indicate that <strong>the</strong> students <strong>the</strong>mselves<br />
believed <strong>the</strong> supplements to be very helpful, and <strong>the</strong><br />
Internet system to be very convenient.<br />
Our plan is to incrementally add courses to <strong>the</strong> EduFile<br />
system, as we teach <strong>the</strong>m.<br />
24 June 2003 Web-Assisted Learning via On-Line Course Supplements G. L. <strong>Plett</strong> and M. A. Wickert [19]
Acknowledgment<br />
This work was supported in part by a grant from <strong>the</strong><br />
University of Colorado at Colorado Springs’ Teaching and<br />
Learning Center. Any opinions, findings, and conclusions or<br />
recommendations expressed in this paper are those of <strong>the</strong><br />
authors and do not necessarily reflect <strong>the</strong> views of <strong>the</strong><br />
University of Colorado at Colorado Springs, or of <strong>the</strong><br />
Teaching and Learning Center.<br />
The majority of <strong>the</strong> code in EduFile was written under<br />
subcontract by Mat<strong>the</strong>w Long of Mat<strong>the</strong>w Long Enterprises,<br />
http://www.mat<strong>the</strong>w-long.com.<br />
24 June 2003 Web-Assisted Learning via On-Line Course Supplements G. L. <strong>Plett</strong> and M. A. Wickert [20]