Download PDF - International Center for Journalists
Download PDF - International Center for Journalists
Download PDF - International Center for Journalists
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
Making News Personal<br />
Covering Human Rights, Education,<br />
Health and other Social Issues<br />
by David Tuller
About the Author<br />
David Tuller has spent much of his journalism career writing about social issues<br />
and teaching others how to do so. Tuller is a freelance writer <strong>for</strong> The New York<br />
Times, The Washington Post, Salon.com and other publications. He previously<br />
was an editor and reporter at the San Francisco Chronicle. He has covered<br />
health care, AIDS, business, labor and workplace issues, and gay/lesbian issues.<br />
He also has conducted training programs on basic reporting skills, interviewing<br />
techniques, AIDS reporting, business reporting, social issues reporting and<br />
ethnic diversity issues. He was a Knight <strong>International</strong> Press Fellow in Russia,<br />
and has conducted other training programs in Ukraine, Armenia, Hungary,<br />
Macedonia and Albania.<br />
About the <strong>International</strong> <strong>Center</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Journalists</strong><br />
The <strong>International</strong> <strong>Center</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Journalists</strong>, a non-profit, professional organization,<br />
promotes quality journalism worldwide in the belief that independent, vigorous<br />
media are crucial in improving the human condition.<br />
Since 1984, the <strong>International</strong> <strong>Center</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Journalists</strong> has worked directly with<br />
more than 50,000 journalists from 176 countries. Aiming to raise the standards of<br />
journalism, ICFJ offers hands-on training, workshops, seminars, fellowships and<br />
international exchanges to reporters and media managers around the globe.<br />
At ICFJ, we believe in the power of journalism to promote positive change.
Contents<br />
1<br />
Preface<br />
4 Introduction<br />
6<br />
Getting Started<br />
10<br />
On the Beat<br />
12<br />
Cultivating Sources<br />
18<br />
Developing Story Ideas<br />
20<br />
Story Ideas: Going Beneath the Surface<br />
24<br />
Avoiding Stereotypes<br />
28<br />
Conducting Interviews<br />
33<br />
Choosing a Format <strong>for</strong> the Story<br />
37<br />
Finding Documents<br />
41<br />
Using Statistics<br />
44<br />
Moving Beyond Words<br />
48<br />
Following Up<br />
50<br />
Conclusion
Making News Personal<br />
Preface<br />
In its work teaching journalism all over the world, the <strong>International</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />
<strong>for</strong> <strong>Journalists</strong> has found that media—whether in the Americas, Africa, Europe<br />
or Asia—almost always give more ink or air time to the famous and the powerful<br />
than they deserve. When the president or the leader of an opposition party<br />
makes a speech, or when a movie star or a famous athlete is seen out on the<br />
town, it’s front-page news.<br />
Ordinary people—laborers and shopkeepers, nurses and students—often<br />
have only one way to get their names into the news: Commit a crime or be the<br />
victim of one. But their day-to-day lives are the lives of our readers, listeners and<br />
viewers, too. We can engage our audiences and make the newspaper, radio or<br />
TV report an essential part of their lives by covering things that matter to them.<br />
And we can positively affect our societies by shedding light on problems that<br />
would be more com<strong>for</strong>table <strong>for</strong> us to ignore.<br />
<strong>International</strong> <strong>Center</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Journalists</strong>
Preface<br />
Why are our schools turning out graduates who are not prepared <strong>for</strong> the work<br />
<strong>for</strong>ce? How are our medical facilities dealing with the growing number of people<br />
suffering from AIDS, malaria or cancer? Where are illegal immigrants to our<br />
country living, what kind of work are they doing and how is their presence<br />
affecting those who have been here their whole lives? How are ethnic or<br />
religious minorities dealing with discrimination and what ef<strong>for</strong>ts are under way to<br />
ease tensions between them and the majority population?<br />
We designed this manual to help journalists to better cover these kinds of<br />
issues, to elevate the beats that revolve around daily life to the same level of the<br />
politics, crime or entertainment beats. We have chosen to call these social<br />
issues because they deal with the way people in society interact with each<br />
other.<br />
Besides being neglected at many news organizations around the world, social<br />
issues involve special reporting challenges. Many of the issues are controversial<br />
or sensitive topics that some people would rather not discuss. They often<br />
require interviewing people who—unlike politicians and celebrities—have never<br />
been asked to talk to the media. Many of those people, such as victims of<br />
2
Making News Personal<br />
human trafficking, refugees or people with AIDS, may feel uncom<strong>for</strong>table talking<br />
to the media about their lives. Covering these kinds of stories takes special skills<br />
and a commitment to very high ethical standards.<br />
This manual was born in a series of ICFJ programs teaching journalists how to<br />
better cover the issue of human trafficking, a growing problem in regions as<br />
diverse as the Balkans, the Caucasus, Southeast Asia—and the United States.<br />
Those programs, funded by the Office of Citizen Exchanges at the U.S.<br />
Department of State’s Bureau of Educational and Cultural Affairs, aim to raise the<br />
level of media coverage of a problem that has received much international<br />
attention but is often ignored in the very countries where women are plucked<br />
from poverty, trafficked across borders and <strong>for</strong>ced to work as sex slaves.<br />
We hope this manual will help journalists like those participating in the trafficking<br />
programs and other journalists who cover similar issues. ICFJ’s Knight<br />
<strong>International</strong> Press Fellowship Program, funded by the John S. and James L.<br />
Knight Foundation, and the Department of State funded the writing and<br />
production of this manual.<br />
Many thanks to author David Tuller, to ICFJ Director of Training Ann Olson<br />
<strong>for</strong> editing this manual with me, to Communications Manager Debbie Hodges <strong>for</strong><br />
coordinating production, and to Jill Gallagher <strong>for</strong> the design. Thanks also to<br />
trainer Carolyn Robinson, to the Media Diversity Institute in London, to the<br />
Detroit Free Press, and to the Statistical Assessment Service <strong>for</strong> allowing us to<br />
reprint material in this manual.<br />
Finally, thanks to all the inspiring journalists around the world who struggle<br />
mightily to in<strong>for</strong>m their readers, listeners and viewers about social issues like<br />
human rights, health care, education and diversity. By bringing light to those<br />
neglected issues, they help make our societies better places to live <strong>for</strong> all<br />
citizens.<br />
Patrick Butler<br />
Vice President, Programs<br />
<strong>International</strong> <strong>Center</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Journalists</strong><br />
<strong>International</strong> <strong>Center</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Journalists</strong>
Introduction<br />
Introduction<br />
Don’t Panic<br />
Take a deep breath. Your editor has asked you to take a social issues<br />
beat. Perhaps you’re going to examine human trafficking, a major problem<br />
in many countries. Or maybe the assignment is to cover the AIDS epidemic and<br />
other health issues. Or education, or homelessness, or the growing popularity of<br />
new religions in your region.<br />
Whatever the topic, you know nothing about it and you’re in something of a<br />
panic. Where do you start? How can you possibly learn about your new issue<br />
quickly enough to begin producing stories? You don’t know anyone who has<br />
AIDS, or has been a trafficking victim, or lives on the street. You’ve never met<br />
anyone who has joined one of the new religious sects sprouting up in the area.<br />
4
Making News Personal<br />
Perhaps your mother is a teacher or<br />
your neighbor is a doctor, but they’re<br />
not in<br />
a position to provide you with useful<br />
in<strong>for</strong>mation. Or are they?<br />
Covering social issues can be an<br />
extremely exciting and challenging<br />
assignment, offering a chance to<br />
address topics of genuine importance<br />
and to affect the public debate. The<br />
possibilities <strong>for</strong> crafting compelling<br />
stories in a variety of <strong>for</strong>mats are<br />
limited only by the journalist’s<br />
Covering social<br />
issues can be an<br />
extremely exciting and<br />
challenging<br />
assignment, offering a<br />
chance to address<br />
topics of genuine<br />
importance and to<br />
affect the public<br />
debate.<br />
creativity, skill and resourcefulness.<br />
This manual is designed to help you<br />
make the most of the opportunity.<br />
Following ethical guidelines is critical<br />
in any journalistic endeavor, but social<br />
issues reporting can present special<br />
challenges. Part of your time, of<br />
course, will be spent talking to and<br />
quoting politicians, experts and<br />
representatives of nongovernmental<br />
organizations—people who can<br />
provide you with crucial background<br />
in<strong>for</strong>mation about the topic at hand.<br />
But if you are doing the job right, you<br />
will be interacting with real people who<br />
have real problems—a mother who<br />
has to beg <strong>for</strong> food <strong>for</strong> her children,<br />
someone suffering from drug-resistant<br />
tuberculosis, an ex-convict<br />
desperately seeking work.<br />
Such tales will make your reporting<br />
come alive. But presenting such<br />
in<strong>for</strong>mation carries with it a great<br />
responsibility. By opening up their<br />
troubles and concerns to journalists,<br />
ordinary people make themselves<br />
extremely vulnerable and exhibit<br />
genuine courage. <strong>Journalists</strong> must not<br />
betray their trust. You must be careful<br />
to present sensitive material with<br />
nuance and understanding. You must<br />
learn to empathize with, rather than<br />
pass judgment on, people whose lives<br />
may be completely different from your<br />
own. And—perhaps most important—<br />
you must resist the temptation to<br />
stereotype, sensationalize and<br />
oversimplify the complicated realities<br />
of people’s experiences. These<br />
challenges are difficult, but rewarding.<br />
<strong>International</strong> <strong>Center</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Journalists</strong>
Getting Started<br />
Getting Started<br />
When you are first assigned to cover a beat relating to social issues<br />
whether the environment, education, the AIDS epidemic or the refugee<br />
situation—you may worry you are not qualified to do the job. You might even<br />
believe that only specialists or people with advanced degrees in that field should<br />
write about the subject.<br />
The truth, however, is that someone who knows little about a subject can,<br />
ultimately, be the person best able to present the in<strong>for</strong>mation to the public in a<br />
way that is accessible to readers or viewers. Experts can become so immersed<br />
in the complexities of a field that it can be hard <strong>for</strong> them to judge what the<br />
general public may already know. They also may have difficulty explaining basic<br />
concepts and translating technical jargon into language non-specialists can<br />
understand.<br />
6
Making News Personal<br />
That doesn’t mean that learning all<br />
you need to know about a new topic is<br />
easy, or that you won’t make<br />
mistakes, particularly during the early<br />
stages. But taking over a new beat<br />
that involves such issues as<br />
trafficking, education or the homeless<br />
—or simply writing stories about such<br />
issues—can also be a terrific way to<br />
further develop your skills and keep<br />
your work interesting. Here are some<br />
tips <strong>for</strong> getting started:<br />
• Do a search of your newspaper’s or<br />
broadcast outlet’s archives to find<br />
out what kinds of stories related to<br />
your topic have been covered in the<br />
past couple of years. Critique as<br />
many as you can find. Were the<br />
stories well reported? Would they<br />
have helped the audience gain a<br />
greater awareness of the topic? Did<br />
they serve to increase<br />
understanding, or were they<br />
reported from a biased or one-sided<br />
perspective? If the topic was AIDS,<br />
<strong>for</strong> example, did they clearly explain<br />
how transmission occurs, or did they<br />
perpetuate common<br />
misconceptions? Share these<br />
stories with colleagues or friends<br />
and ask their opinions.<br />
• Examine, if possible, what other<br />
newspapers or stations have done<br />
and compare it with what your<br />
newsroom has done. In what ways<br />
is it better? In what ways is it<br />
worse? The answers to these<br />
questions can guide you as you<br />
start to prepare your own material.<br />
These stories also may give you<br />
ideas about some of the first issues<br />
you might want to tackle, either to<br />
follow up on a point left unexplored<br />
or to answer remaining questions.<br />
• Start calling some people involved<br />
in the field you will cover. These<br />
might be people mentioned or<br />
quoted in the stories you’ve read.<br />
They could be acquaintances of<br />
your newsroom colleagues, or they<br />
could be people you’ve already<br />
talked to in a professional capacity<br />
while covering some other topic. Ask<br />
them what they think of the local<br />
coverage and what aspects they<br />
think have been ignored.<br />
Someone who knows<br />
little about a subject<br />
can, ultimately, be the<br />
person best able to<br />
present the in<strong>for</strong>mation<br />
to the public in a way<br />
that is accessible to<br />
readers or viewers.<br />
• When you find people<br />
knowledgeable about your new field,<br />
ask them if they would sit down with<br />
you and provide some background<br />
in<strong>for</strong>mation. Assuming they agree,<br />
ask them whatever you wish. Don’t<br />
worry about appearing stupid; smart<br />
journalists know when they don’t<br />
know enough. Use these meetings<br />
to understand aspects of the subject<br />
that confuse you and to determine<br />
<strong>International</strong> <strong>Center</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Journalists</strong>
Getting Started<br />
some of the key issues you will want<br />
to explore.<br />
• Take advantage of the Internet,<br />
which is an incredible resource<br />
available in almost every newsroom.<br />
Use it to locate specialists or nongovernmental<br />
organizations (also<br />
known as NGOs, or nonprofit or<br />
non-commercial organizations) in<br />
your geographic area, previous<br />
articles and studies on the topic,<br />
conferences of interest that may be<br />
taking place or government reports<br />
that have addressed the issue.<br />
• As you start to learn about the topic,<br />
many people will want to convince<br />
you to listen only to them. But<br />
remember that no one has the last<br />
word. Be skeptical of everyone you<br />
talk to. Everyone has a point of view<br />
they’re interested in promoting, and<br />
it is your job to sift through all those<br />
perspectives to present an overall<br />
portrait of the issue or debate. The<br />
more you learn, the easier that<br />
should become.<br />
• Each area has its own vocabulary,<br />
its glossary of key words and<br />
concepts. When people you talk to<br />
use phrases that you don’t<br />
understand, ask them to explain.<br />
Keep a list of these important<br />
expressions to help in your<br />
reporting. When you write stories, it<br />
will be important to explain<br />
specialized terminology. Don’t<br />
assume that your audience will<br />
understand without explanation.<br />
• Read, listen to and watch everything<br />
you can about the issue. This can<br />
be other newspapers, magazines<br />
and broadcast stations, specialized<br />
journals <strong>for</strong> people in the profession,<br />
scientific studies, reports from<br />
academic institutions or nonprofit<br />
organizations. Note the names of<br />
people quoted and interviewed or<br />
the authors if you think they might<br />
become good sources.<br />
8
Making News Personal<br />
<strong>International</strong> <strong>Center</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Journalists</strong>
On the Beat<br />
On the beat<br />
A social issues beat can span a broad, almost limitless,<br />
spectrum, so a journalist with that assignment may be called<br />
upon to report about a wide variety of topics. Here are some<br />
examples of story ideas in several different subject areas.<br />
Each suggestion could easily serve as a springboard to more<br />
than one piece.<br />
10
Making News Personal<br />
Education: What types of new school<br />
textbooks are being developed and<br />
proposed? What is the process by<br />
which they get approved, and who<br />
makes the decisions about which<br />
version of historical, religious and<br />
other events is included?<br />
Health: Is drug-resistant tuberculosis<br />
becoming a big problem in your area,<br />
as it is in many parts of the world? If<br />
so, where is it most prevalent? In<br />
prisons? In certain neighborhoods? Is<br />
it a particular problem among people<br />
also infected with HIV? And what are<br />
government agencies, local and<br />
international NGOs and others doing<br />
about it?<br />
Environment: How clean is the air in<br />
your area? What are the leading<br />
causes of air pollution? Has it gotten<br />
worse with an increase in the number<br />
of automobiles? What, if anything, is<br />
the government doing about it? Have<br />
local factories and industrial facilities<br />
started any ef<strong>for</strong>ts to reduce their air<br />
pollutants?<br />
Religion: Is a holiday celebrated by a<br />
religious minority in your area coming<br />
up soon? What is it? How is it<br />
observed? What does it mean to<br />
members of the group? Were they<br />
<strong>for</strong>bidden from marking it in the past?<br />
And now?<br />
Human Rights: Are unemployment<br />
rates in your region higher among<br />
members of an ethnic minority than<br />
among members of the majority? If so,<br />
what do minority members say about<br />
the issue? What ef<strong>for</strong>ts are being<br />
made to address these differing rates<br />
of unemployment?<br />
Poverty: What is it like to live below<br />
the poverty level in your area? Spend<br />
time with a homeless person or with a<br />
family living in the poorest section of<br />
town. Describe what life is like from<br />
that perspective. How much money do<br />
they receive from the government and<br />
other sources? How do they spend it?<br />
<strong>International</strong> <strong>Center</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Journalists</strong>
Cultivating Sources<br />
Cultivating Sources<br />
Good sources are critical to reporting on social issues, just as they are to all<br />
kinds of reporting. But finding and cultivating them does not happen<br />
automatically. It is easy to quote from government statements or to contact<br />
people whose names appear on a press release. But the key to great reporting<br />
on social issues is going beyond obvious sources of in<strong>for</strong>mation.<br />
It is amazing how often journalists fail to report about the very people affected by<br />
issues in question. Why would you write about homelessness without talking with<br />
a homeless person, or at the very least with an advocate <strong>for</strong> them? Or report<br />
about teachers’ low salaries without asking teachers how they feel?<br />
This is a question not only of journalism but also of ethics. People have a right to<br />
be represented when their interests are being discussed and debated. It is<br />
critical, when reporting about anything, to get a response from those directly<br />
involved. This is a major reason that developing a full network of sources is<br />
extremely important.<br />
Another frequent shortcoming of journalists is to cultivate sources primarily from<br />
their own social or ethnic group. It is important to have a range of sources:<br />
official and unofficial, academic and political, experts as well as ordinary people<br />
whose personal histories can give the material substance, depth and credibility.<br />
Here are some suggestions on how to cultivate a diverse group of sources:<br />
• Start with the most accessible<br />
people. Meet with representatives of<br />
nongovernmental organizations who<br />
address your issue. Spend time with<br />
them to understand everything they<br />
do. Make sure you’re on their press<br />
list as someone to contact when they<br />
release a report or announce news.<br />
• Try to get to know government<br />
officials or spokespeople in the health<br />
ministry, the education department or<br />
whichever agency addresses your<br />
topic. They may be reluctant to meet<br />
with you, but if you can establish a<br />
decent relationship with them, it will<br />
help you down the road. Explain that<br />
your goal is to report accurately by<br />
gathering in<strong>for</strong>mation from all sides,<br />
including theirs.<br />
• Some sources will be reluctant to talk<br />
to you because they are suspicious<br />
of journalists; perhaps they have<br />
been misquoted or they believe the<br />
journalists they’ve dealt with be<strong>for</strong>e<br />
have been biased. One way to<br />
overcome such reluctance is to show<br />
them stories that you have done on<br />
this topic or a similar one that have<br />
been fair and balanced. Another way<br />
is to use someone as an intermediary<br />
who already trusts you. For example,<br />
if you have successfully cultivated a<br />
relationship with the leader of a<br />
human rights group, you can suggest<br />
that reluctant sources contact the<br />
source who trusts you; she will tell<br />
them that you will treat them fairly.<br />
12
Making News Personal<br />
• At a university or a research institute<br />
in the area, find out if anyone there<br />
is involved in your field. If so, call to<br />
arrange a meeting and ask them<br />
about issues or controversies that<br />
you’re thinking of covering. Make<br />
sure to seek their ideas about<br />
stories that need coverage. You<br />
don’t have to write about something<br />
just because they suggest it, but it’s<br />
a good way to get yourself thinking<br />
about the possibilities of the beat.<br />
• To be effective, social issue stories<br />
must include real people with<br />
specific problems. Without them, the<br />
material is likely to be quite dull.<br />
Finding such people takes a certain<br />
amount of creativity. NGOs are an<br />
excellent resource. An AIDS<br />
organization might refer you to one<br />
of its members, <strong>for</strong> example. An<br />
ecological group might help you find<br />
someone suffering from the effects<br />
of an environmental problem. If<br />
these organizations are reluctant to<br />
lead you to people truly affected by<br />
an issue, show them how much<br />
more powerful the story would be if<br />
it included real people. If a television<br />
report includes no one affected by<br />
an issue, it will be buried at the end<br />
of the newscast, but if it includes<br />
real people telling compelling<br />
stories, it will be displayed much<br />
more prominently.<br />
• In recent years, journalists have<br />
relied heavily on Internet searches<br />
to find sources. In chat rooms and<br />
on bulletin boards, you might find<br />
people in your country or region<br />
involved in an issue and willing to<br />
talk or meet with you. Through the<br />
Internet, you can also find<br />
international sources with whom you<br />
can conduct e-mail interviews, if<br />
necessary.<br />
• Personal contacts also can help you<br />
find sources. Perhaps your mother<br />
or husband knows someone you<br />
could interview. Ask colleagues at<br />
work if they’ve come across the kind<br />
of person you’re looking <strong>for</strong>, either in<br />
their professional or private lives.<br />
Your network of acquaintances can<br />
be a great resource you should not<br />
hesitate to use.<br />
• Read past articles on the subject,<br />
either in your publication or other<br />
ones, and try to locate the people<br />
mentioned or quoted there. They<br />
may still have strong opinions on the<br />
subject and might be interested in<br />
talking again to a reporter, if they<br />
feel they were treated fairly the first<br />
time.<br />
• If you meet people at social<br />
gatherings with interesting thoughts<br />
about your topic area, explain that<br />
you’re a journalist and ask if you can<br />
call them to talk more about the<br />
subject. Make sure to get a<br />
business card or write down how to<br />
get in touch with them. And give<br />
them your business card and<br />
encourage them to get in touch.<br />
• If someone seems reluctant to talk<br />
to you, explain that you don’t need<br />
to quote him or her by name or<br />
mention him or her at all if they don’t<br />
want you to. And then make sure<br />
you keep that promise. Protecting<br />
the identity of sources who don’t<br />
want to be identified is one of<br />
journalism’s most precious ethical<br />
rules. If they still refuse, don’t berate<br />
them. Unlike government officials,<br />
who are paid by—and should be<br />
expected to answer to—the public,<br />
private citizens are not required to<br />
talk to the press. And you have no<br />
right to demand that they do.<br />
<strong>International</strong> <strong>Center</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Journalists</strong>
Cultivating Sources<br />
• Maintain thorough records of your<br />
sources, noting their contact<br />
in<strong>for</strong>mation and their areas of<br />
expertise. Make a point of calling<br />
them from time to time to get<br />
updates or suggestions <strong>for</strong> angles<br />
that have not been covered.<br />
Maintaining an ongoing relationship<br />
with sources is a key part of<br />
covering a beat effectively.<br />
• When you talk to people, ask them if<br />
they can suggest others who might<br />
also be useful sources. Personal<br />
referral is one of the best ways to<br />
expand your network. People who<br />
feel uneasy discussing personal<br />
matters with strangers often feel<br />
much more com<strong>for</strong>table talking to<br />
reporters referred to them by friends<br />
or acquaintances they already trust.<br />
• When you come across a report<br />
written by specialists, note their<br />
names. Then find out how to get in<br />
touch with them, no matter whether<br />
you’re writing an article about that<br />
particular report. Compliment them<br />
on their work, let them know you’re<br />
interested in the subject, and ask<br />
them to send you future reports on<br />
the matter.<br />
• Make sure people you meet know<br />
how to get in touch with you. Give<br />
out your business card freely.<br />
Encourage sources to contact you<br />
with story ideas or tips. Such calls<br />
can turn into some of your most<br />
important stories.<br />
• Encourage sources to call you when<br />
your articles appear. Tell them<br />
you’re interested not just in positive<br />
feedback but in constructive<br />
criticism as well. Are there aspects<br />
you missed? Did you leave<br />
questions unanswered? Did you<br />
make any key mistakes? Your<br />
openness will strengthen your<br />
relationships with sources and their<br />
respect <strong>for</strong> you and your work.<br />
• Invite some sources to meet you at<br />
your paper or broadcast<br />
organization. Give them a tour,<br />
introduce them to colleagues,<br />
explain how the business works. By<br />
offering them insight into how you<br />
do your job, you will help them gain<br />
a better understanding of what<br />
stories and in<strong>for</strong>mation might pique<br />
your interest.<br />
• Remember that every person you<br />
interview has some reason <strong>for</strong><br />
talking with you. Understanding their<br />
motivation will help you judge how<br />
much to trust the in<strong>for</strong>mation they<br />
provide. Are they nursing a grudge<br />
against some individual or<br />
institution? Are they hoping <strong>for</strong><br />
personal gain? Or are they simply<br />
seeking to in<strong>for</strong>m readers or viewers<br />
of some important piece of<br />
in<strong>for</strong>mation out of altruism? Asking<br />
yourself such questions will help you<br />
determine what to do with the<br />
material they offer.<br />
• The best reporters are often those<br />
who know how to find and maintain<br />
good relationships with the most<br />
well-placed sources. The longer<br />
your history with particular sources,<br />
the better you will be able to judge<br />
their in<strong>for</strong>mation. Have they<br />
provided you with material that<br />
turned out to be true in the past? If<br />
so, you should feel more<br />
com<strong>for</strong>table trusting them than<br />
someone you’ve just met <strong>for</strong> the first<br />
time.<br />
• If your gut feeling is that a source is<br />
misleading you, whether on purpose<br />
14
Making News Personal<br />
or inadvertently, trust that instinct. At<br />
the very least, make sure to confirm<br />
the page in<strong>for</strong>mation through other<br />
contacts be<strong>for</strong>e using it. If someone<br />
has provided you with false<br />
in<strong>for</strong>mation in the past and has not<br />
offered an acceptable explanation<br />
as to how that happened, do not<br />
trust him or her again.<br />
• While it is important to maintain a<br />
good relationship with your sources,<br />
never offer to act in ways that<br />
violate ethical practices. Don’t slant<br />
a story in a particular way or include<br />
questionable in<strong>for</strong>mation just to gain<br />
favor with a source. You can be<br />
friendly and collegial with sources<br />
without behaving in ways that could<br />
compromise your reputation <strong>for</strong><br />
accuracy and honesty.<br />
• Sources sometimes want to know<br />
what your story will say be<strong>for</strong>e you<br />
write it. They may even ask to see it<br />
while you’re working on it. This is<br />
not a good idea. You may not know<br />
exactly what the story will be until<br />
you’ve done all your reporting. You<br />
also don’t want sources to read a<br />
story be<strong>for</strong>e publication and demand<br />
changes because they’re not happy<br />
with the result.<br />
• While it may be tempting sometimes<br />
to lie to sources to get in<strong>for</strong>mation, it<br />
is not a good idea. You can certainly<br />
tell your sources about the general<br />
theme or topic of your story. But it is<br />
unethical to assure them that a story<br />
will present only their point of view.<br />
They need to understand that your<br />
goal is to present in<strong>for</strong>mation from<br />
multiple perspectives, not to provide<br />
them an unchallenged <strong>for</strong>um <strong>for</strong><br />
disseminating their views.<br />
• You should tell sources that you are<br />
a reporter working on a story. It is<br />
often tempting to pretend to be<br />
someone other than a reporter to<br />
get access to places where<br />
reporters are barred. This is very<br />
dangerous. It can lead to a<br />
perception among the public that<br />
journalists are dishonest and use<br />
unfair tactics. While reporters who<br />
got their in<strong>for</strong>mation under cover<br />
have done some very good stories,<br />
such tactics often do more harm<br />
than good. Consult your editors and<br />
your news organization’s ethics<br />
guidelines be<strong>for</strong>e using such tactics.<br />
<strong>International</strong> <strong>Center</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Journalists</strong>
Exercise<br />
Exercise<br />
You are pursuing a story about plans to build a chemical factory on the<br />
edge of a poor neighborhood in your city. Some environmental groups<br />
have said that the plant, owned by the Chemexco multinational corporation<br />
based in the United States, will pollute the air and water in the neighborhood.<br />
You have heard that Chemexco has paid a bribe to the mayor and other<br />
officials of your city to allow the company to ignore environmental regulations<br />
to build the plant.<br />
What sources will you turn to <strong>for</strong> the story? What other sources will you use<br />
besides the people you interview? Think not only about the first story that you<br />
will write but also about sidebars and follow-ups. List your sources here, then<br />
check on Page 18 <strong>for</strong> sources you might not have thought about.<br />
Sources<br />
______________________________________________________________<br />
______________________________________________________________<br />
______________________________________________________________<br />
______________________________________________________________<br />
______________________________________________________________<br />
______________________________________________________________<br />
______________________________________________________________<br />
______________________________________________________________<br />
______________________________________________________________<br />
______________________________________________________________<br />
______________________________________________________________<br />
______________________________________________________________<br />
______________________________________________________________<br />
______________________________________________________________<br />
______________________________________________________________<br />
______________________________________________________________<br />
16
Making News Personal<br />
List of possible sources <strong>for</strong> the chemical factory story:<br />
1. Officials with Chemexco, local and international<br />
2. City officials involved in reviewing the plans<br />
3. State, provincial or national officials involved in reviewing the plans<br />
4. Leaders of the poor community most affected by the plant<br />
5. Environmental groups, local and international<br />
6. Environmental regulators<br />
7. Pro-business groups that are trying to spur economic investment in<br />
the city or country<br />
8. Academic experts who know about the product being manufactured<br />
and its potential impact on the community<br />
9. Residents of the neighborhood<br />
10. Unemployed people who might want jobs at the factory<br />
11. Consumers of the product that will be produced at the factory (either<br />
individual consumers or other companies)<br />
12. The mayor and others in his administration<br />
13. Members of opposing parties or groups<br />
14. Records of the mayor and others accused of taking bribes, such as<br />
financial records, telephone records, travel records, etc. (if available)<br />
15. Local and/or state ordinances and national laws that will be used to<br />
determine if the plant should be built and how it will be regulated<br />
16. Internet research about Chemexco and the products it plans to<br />
manufacture at the plant<br />
17. Internet research about Chemexco plants (or other companies that<br />
make the same product) in other countries and any environmental<br />
problems they have caused<br />
18. Sources in communities near other Chemexco plants that your<br />
Internet research has turned up (including journalists in those<br />
countries who have written about Chemexco)<br />
<strong>International</strong> <strong>Center</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Journalists</strong>
Developing Story Ideas<br />
Developing Story Ideas<br />
When you cover a social issues beat,<br />
part of your job is not only to write or<br />
produce the most obvious stories but<br />
also to come up with interesting ideas<br />
or angles that haven’t been covered<br />
yet. In fact, if you’re doing your job<br />
well, you should be able to think of<br />
many more story possibilities than<br />
you could possibly have time to do.<br />
Some editors assign stories that<br />
they’ve thought of themselves. Many<br />
also like it when reporters propose<br />
their own ideas. After all, it is the<br />
reporter’s job to stay in touch with<br />
sources, experts and others involved<br />
with the beat. And such contact, more<br />
often than not, is how story ideas<br />
originate.<br />
The longer you cover a beat, the<br />
easier story ideas will come. You will<br />
understand better what should be<br />
considered news, why it is important<br />
or significant, and whom you should<br />
call to get more in<strong>for</strong>mation. You will<br />
learn which sources to trust and<br />
which to treat with greater skepticism.<br />
Here are some tips <strong>for</strong> developing<br />
great story ideas:<br />
• Talk to as many people as possible.<br />
Call several sources a day—either<br />
ones you already know, or ones<br />
you don’t—and ask them about<br />
developments on your beat. Ask<br />
about any lawsuits filed, new<br />
legislation, studies being released,<br />
trends that haven’t been reported.<br />
Encourage them to call you if they<br />
come across or think of anything<br />
interesting.<br />
• Think of events in your own life or<br />
that of friends and family members.<br />
Do you have eyestrain from<br />
spending too much time reading<br />
from the computer? If you write<br />
about health, you might be able to<br />
do a story about computer-related<br />
eye problems. Does your child’s<br />
class have a textbook shortage?<br />
Find out if other schools are having<br />
the same problem. Some of the<br />
best story ideas arise from<br />
personal observations.<br />
• Keep up with how other media<br />
outlets cover your beat. If they<br />
report a story you missed, figure<br />
out if there’s a way to continue the<br />
story beyond their approach. If their<br />
story announces a new treatment<br />
<strong>for</strong> breast cancer, follow it with a<br />
story about how widely the<br />
treatment is available or whether<br />
the medication has possibilities <strong>for</strong><br />
use against other kinds of cancer.<br />
• Anniversaries of significant events<br />
can make good stories. The 10th<br />
anniversary of the Chernobyl<br />
nuclear disaster in Ukraine, <strong>for</strong><br />
example, was a good time to write<br />
about nuclear-safety concerns. If it<br />
has been a year since an important<br />
piece of social issues-related<br />
legislation was passed, use the<br />
anniversary to examine its impact,<br />
and how that compares to<br />
predictions made at the time.<br />
• Keep an eye out <strong>for</strong> conflicts, which<br />
can make compelling stories.<br />
Residents upset about a chemical<br />
factory in their neighborhood,<br />
someone fired <strong>for</strong> being HIVpositive,<br />
a controversy over sex<br />
education in the schools—these<br />
18
Making News Personal<br />
are all excellent starting points <strong>for</strong><br />
stories. Lawsuits, in particular, are a<br />
great source <strong>for</strong> story ideas.<br />
• Keep an eye out <strong>for</strong> trends. If one<br />
person has been beaten up <strong>for</strong><br />
being gay, maybe there are other<br />
such cases. If government officials<br />
are harassing representatives of<br />
one human rights group, perhaps<br />
it’s not an isolated incident. By<br />
digging a bit deeper, you can often<br />
turn news about a single event into<br />
a larger tale about a pattern of<br />
injustice or discrimination.<br />
• Keep your reader or viewer in mind.<br />
Social issues stories, in particular,<br />
should relate to their lives as much<br />
as possible. Always try to ask<br />
yourself what difference this issue<br />
makes to those you are telling about<br />
it. Why should they care? Why<br />
should it bother them? If you can’t<br />
answer, the story may not be worth<br />
pursuing.<br />
• If you see an issue discussed in a<br />
national or international publication,<br />
find out if the same problem exists<br />
in your area. The answer is likely to<br />
be yes. What are health officials in<br />
your region doing to protect<br />
consumers from mad cow disease,<br />
<strong>for</strong> example? Or how are national<br />
ef<strong>for</strong>ts to halt trafficking reflected in<br />
your community?<br />
<strong>International</strong> <strong>Center</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Journalists</strong>
Story Ideas: Going Beneath the Surface<br />
Story Ideas:<br />
Going Beneath the Surface<br />
You have been assigned to cover the growing problem in your country of<br />
trafficking in humans, many of whom are women taken from one country to<br />
another and <strong>for</strong>ced to work as sex slaves. You know some of the obvious stories:<br />
What is your government doing to stop trafficking? What is life like <strong>for</strong> women<br />
who are trafficked? But you want to go beyond these stories to explore facets of<br />
the problem that have not been reported.<br />
Here are some ideas, courtesy of journalism trainer Carolyn Robinson, that<br />
show how the problem impacts more than just the lives of individual victims.<br />
Nearly any other social issues topic will have a similar wealth of untapped story<br />
ideas.<br />
20
Making News Personal<br />
Business<br />
• What do traffickers do with their<br />
profits?<br />
• Are any international investors<br />
staying away from the region<br />
because of this problem?<br />
• How has the tourism industry been<br />
affected?<br />
• What respectable businesses are<br />
involved in trafficking, intentionally<br />
or unintentionally?<br />
Health<br />
• How is the health care system<br />
fighting the problem?<br />
• Is there any increase in sexually<br />
transmitted diseases or other<br />
illnesses because of trafficking?<br />
• What happens to pregnant trafficked<br />
women and their children?<br />
• What psychological methods are<br />
used against women, both to recruit<br />
and keep them?<br />
• What psychological treatments are<br />
used to help rehabilitate women?<br />
Education<br />
• What are schools doing to educate<br />
young people about this problem<br />
and prevent young people from<br />
becoming victims?<br />
• Do educational campaigns exist to<br />
make men aware that women they<br />
hire <strong>for</strong> sex may have been<br />
trafficked unwillingly from other<br />
countries? To make people aware<br />
that trafficked women and children<br />
are lured with lies and promises of a<br />
better life elsewhere? To help<br />
people understand that returned<br />
trafficking victims were not<br />
volunteers and need community<br />
services and support?<br />
Religion and Society<br />
• What are religious institutions doing<br />
about the problem?<br />
• How does trafficking affect the<br />
average citizen who is not directly<br />
involved?<br />
• What do residents of communities<br />
where trafficked women are <strong>for</strong>ced<br />
to work think about the issue?<br />
Science and Technology<br />
• What new scientific or technological<br />
methods are being used to fight<br />
trafficking?<br />
• What kind of technology are<br />
traffickers using to conduct their<br />
business or evade law<br />
en<strong>for</strong>cement?<br />
Politics<br />
• Have any political groups or parties<br />
joined together in the fight against<br />
trafficking?<br />
• What legislation is being discussed<br />
to fight trafficking?<br />
• What legislation does other<br />
countries have?<br />
• What are the impediments to<br />
passing anti-trafficking legislation?<br />
<strong>International</strong> Relations<br />
• What international laws prevent<br />
trafficking?<br />
• What loopholes in international law<br />
allow trafficking?<br />
• How do international groups<br />
contribute to the problem?<br />
• What sanctions do aid donor<br />
countries employ to <strong>for</strong>ce<br />
governments to crack down on<br />
traffickers and how do such<br />
sanctions affect the country?<br />
<strong>International</strong> <strong>Center</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Journalists</strong>
Story Ideas: Going Beneath the Surface<br />
• Do countries that share borders<br />
across which women are trafficked<br />
cooperate to end the practice? Do<br />
elements within governments<br />
cooperate to profit by it?<br />
• Has trafficking strained relations<br />
between different countries in the<br />
region?<br />
Labor<br />
• What industries use trafficked<br />
people other than sex-<strong>for</strong>-hire<br />
businesses?<br />
• Why do they turn to this source of<br />
labor? What legitimate workers are<br />
displaced when trafficked people<br />
are used?<br />
Transportation<br />
• How do traffickers transport their<br />
victims?<br />
• How do they organize travel across<br />
borders?<br />
• What routes do they use?<br />
Crime and Justice<br />
• How do people become traffickers?<br />
What are their motives?<br />
• How closely is trafficking in humans<br />
tied to trafficking in drugs and<br />
weapons?<br />
• How does corruption allow<br />
traffickers to work unpunished?<br />
• Are clients punished <strong>for</strong> patronizing<br />
trafficked women?<br />
• How much does it cost to<br />
investigate, prosecute and punish<br />
those involved in trafficking?<br />
Success<br />
• What approaches have worked<br />
against trafficking? In this country?<br />
In other countries?<br />
• What radical solutions have been<br />
proposed?<br />
• How do women escape from<br />
traffickers?<br />
• Where is trafficking least?<br />
successful? Why?<br />
22
Making News Personal<br />
<strong>International</strong> <strong>Center</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Journalists</strong>
Avoiding Stereotypes<br />
Avoiding Stereotypes<br />
When a category of people—an ethnic or religious group, <strong>for</strong> example—is<br />
portrayed as having one or perhaps several key characteristics, that is called a<br />
stereotype. The characteristic might be a physical trait, as in the belief that Jews<br />
have big noses. It might be a behavioral trait, as with the notion that all gay men<br />
are promiscuous or all Russians are alcoholics. While such beliefs may seem<br />
relatively harmless, they can in fact be very hurtful and even destructive.<br />
In one sense, it is completely understandable that we have stereotypes of certain<br />
groups of people. It’s part of how we come to understand the world. Most of us<br />
grow up in societies in which social, ethnic and economic groups are divided<br />
from one another, and people have little opportunity to learn about others who<br />
are not like themselves.<br />
24
Making News Personal<br />
When reporters write about social<br />
issues, however, they need to learn<br />
how to recognize the stereotypes they<br />
have. Social issues reporting involves<br />
covering people different from<br />
yourself, whether they are refugees,<br />
gays and lesbians, people with AIDS,<br />
the elderly or someone of another<br />
ethnicity. And unless you recognize<br />
the preconceived notions you may be<br />
carrying around in your head, it will be<br />
difficult to portray members of these<br />
groups as complex and distinct<br />
individuals.<br />
It’s not easy to examine your own<br />
prejudices, or even to acknowledge<br />
that you have them. In fact, such<br />
biases are frequently unconscious,<br />
and it can take courage and a certain<br />
amount of willpower to <strong>for</strong>ce yourself<br />
to challenge them. When you do,<br />
you’re likely to discover that these<br />
stereotypes are founded not on<br />
facts but on unfair generalizations.<br />
Admitting that to yourself can be<br />
painful. But it is a necessary part of<br />
the process of writing fair and effective<br />
stories about social issues.<br />
To avoid the pitfalls of stereotypes:<br />
• Don’t write about any category of<br />
people without spending as much<br />
time as possible with members of<br />
that group. You need to listen to<br />
what they tell you about their lives.<br />
You need to approach them with an<br />
open mind, so that you can actually<br />
hear what they are telling you rather<br />
than fitting everything into your own<br />
conception of who they are.<br />
• Think about the ways that other<br />
groups stereotype people of your<br />
own ethnicity, religion, economic<br />
class, profession and so on. Reflect<br />
on how that makes you feel. Are you<br />
angry? Upset? Hurt? Then imagine<br />
how people in other groups,<br />
especially disadvantaged groups,<br />
feel when they read articles or view<br />
programs in which they are<br />
portrayed in stereotypical ways.<br />
• It is always possible to find people<br />
who con<strong>for</strong>m to stereotypes. There<br />
are definitely rich Jews, gay men<br />
who like to dress in women’s<br />
clothes, Roma who are thieves and<br />
Arabs who are terrorists. It’s not<br />
unusual <strong>for</strong> stereotypes to have a bit<br />
of truth in them. But finding such an<br />
example, and including it in your<br />
article or broadcast, does nothing to<br />
prove that a stereotype is true. What<br />
usually is more interesting, <strong>for</strong> the<br />
journalist as well as the audience, is<br />
to find examples that contradict the<br />
stereotype, and to write about those.<br />
• Pay attention to language. The<br />
words that people use to describe<br />
another social or ethnic group are<br />
often not the words that members of<br />
that other group prefer. Just<br />
because a word does not sound like<br />
an insult to you, or is not meant as<br />
an insult, does not mean someone<br />
else can’t experience it that way. In<br />
general, social groups should be<br />
called by the names that their<br />
members prefer.<br />
• Social issues reporting often<br />
involves describing a conflict<br />
between two or more ethnicities,<br />
religions or other groups of people.<br />
Even if you belong to one of these<br />
groups, avoid name-calling and<br />
stereotyping those on the other side.<br />
Most conflicts cannot easily be<br />
reduced to a right-and-wrong<br />
polarity. The truth is usually far more<br />
complex. As a journalist, your job is<br />
to move beyond your own<br />
<strong>International</strong> <strong>Center</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Journalists</strong>
Avoiding Stereotypes<br />
Part of recognizing<br />
your own stereotypes<br />
is learning<br />
how to approach<br />
people with a<br />
sense of openness<br />
and humility.<br />
stereotypes and explore the<br />
nuances of a situation by talking<br />
with people involved on all sides.<br />
• Spend as much time as you can<br />
with people whose lives differ from<br />
your own. If you’re writing about the<br />
homeless, spend time with them on<br />
the street. If your story is about the<br />
lack of access to public buildings <strong>for</strong><br />
the disabled, spend a day in a<br />
wheelchair or with someone who<br />
uses one. If you’re writing about the<br />
Jewish community, attend services<br />
at the local synagogue and have<br />
Shabbat dinner with a Jewish family.<br />
If you’re covering an emerging gay<br />
rights movement, spend time with<br />
members of a gay organization.<br />
• Don’t be afraid to ask people—<br />
politely, of course—about the<br />
stereotypes used to describe their<br />
groups. Find out how they feel about<br />
the language other people use.<br />
Many people will be willing to<br />
discuss why certain words or<br />
attitudes are hurtful. They may even<br />
be grateful to have an opportunity to<br />
explain who they are, what they<br />
believe, and why they feel the<br />
stereotype is unfair or just wrong. In<br />
fact, a story about the history of a<br />
particular stereotype, and the ways<br />
in which it does not con<strong>for</strong>m to<br />
reality, could make a very interesting<br />
and provocative story.<br />
• Part of recognizing your own<br />
stereotypes is learning how to<br />
approach people with a sense of<br />
openness and humility. People can<br />
often sense if you have unfair<br />
prejudices, if you are holding onto<br />
damaging stereotypes. Your job is to<br />
try to understand the world from<br />
their perspective, not to tell them<br />
why or how they should change<br />
their behavior or lifestyle.<br />
• One way to avoid stereotypes and<br />
make sure your stories are culturally<br />
sensitive is to consult the people in<br />
your newsroom who are members<br />
of the group you are covering. If you<br />
are from the majority Christian<br />
population of a West African country<br />
and you are writing about the<br />
minority Muslim population, show<br />
your story to a Muslim colleague.<br />
She might notice that something in<br />
the story is insensitive to people of<br />
her faith, something that never<br />
would have occurred to you. This is<br />
one of many reasons why it is a<br />
good idea to have diverse<br />
population groups represented in<br />
your newsroom.<br />
26
Making News Personal<br />
Case Study<br />
Roma War in Szentpal<br />
In Somogyszentpal, the controversy between the Roma and other inhabitants of<br />
the village seems insoluble. The tension is permanent. Most people, particularly<br />
from the older population, do no even report anymore when someone breaks<br />
into their homes because they are afraid to do so. The local government has<br />
attempted to control the situation, yet until now all its attempts have failed.<br />
Dr. Sandor Berenyi, the major of Somogyszentpal, said: “Until now, the Roma<br />
living in the village have demolished several dozen empty houses; there is<br />
hardly a cellar that they have not broken into yet; they constantly steal from<br />
gardens and from the <strong>for</strong>est.”<br />
The local authority has tried everything to resolve the situation. It contacted the<br />
national organizations of ethnic minorities and it also asked the ethnic research<br />
group of the Hungarian Academy of Science to investigate the situation of the<br />
Roma in Szentpal and to suggest possible solutions. “All <strong>for</strong> nothing – they<br />
come here, look around and acknowledge that the problem is much more<br />
severe than anything they have ever seen,” said Dr. Sandor Berenyi.<br />
“None of those we have asked so far could give us any guidance as to how to<br />
resolve our problems. Now, more than 30% of the population is Roma, and<br />
public security is so bad that the entire future development of the village is in<br />
jeopardy. This is so despite the fact that there would be work <strong>for</strong> them in the<br />
village and that the local government spends nearly 30 million <strong>for</strong>ints per year<br />
on their aid.”<br />
People in Somogyszentpal even attempted to <strong>for</strong>m a “civic guard” in order to<br />
improve their feeling of security. However, even this did not lead to any<br />
improvement. After a few months, nobody was left who was willing to patrol the<br />
streets, everybody was too afraid.<br />
Dr. Sandor Berenyi said the local government keeps looking <strong>for</strong> an appropriate<br />
solution. However, if they are unsuccessful in the short term, they will resolve<br />
the long lasting problem themselves and they will expel from the village the<br />
families who cause most of the damage.<br />
Új Néplap, Budapest, Jan. 25, 2002<br />
*Reprinted with permission from Reporting Diversity Manual by David Tuller<br />
(Media Diversity Institute 2002).<br />
<strong>International</strong> <strong>Center</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Journalists</strong>
Case Study: Roma War in Szentpal<br />
This<br />
headline is misleading<br />
and inflammatory. The<br />
problem is not a Roma “war” but<br />
apparently a conflict between the<br />
Roma and other inhabitants. The<br />
headline makes the assumption that<br />
the situation is completely the fault of<br />
the Roma – and not just individual<br />
Roma but the village’s entire<br />
Roma population.<br />
Questions to Consider<br />
Keep in mind that language<br />
is very important when trying<br />
to avoid stereotypes!<br />
What is<br />
the evidence <strong>for</strong><br />
this? How can he be sure<br />
that the Roma are<br />
responsible <strong>for</strong> all the<br />
problems?<br />
Why<br />
did the reporter not contact<br />
the Hungarian Academy of Science<br />
directly to ask about the situation? Why<br />
has he not made contact with the Roma<br />
themselves to find out their<br />
perspective?<br />
Why?<br />
What happened<br />
after a few months?<br />
Was someone attacked?<br />
If not, what changed?<br />
Why were they willing<br />
to patrol at first but<br />
not later?<br />
What<br />
kind of work would<br />
be there <strong>for</strong> them? What<br />
ef<strong>for</strong>ts have been made to<br />
help them? What is the aid that<br />
they receive? Answers to<br />
these questions would<br />
improve the article.<br />
Is<br />
it just a problem<br />
with a few families? If<br />
so, why is the reporter<br />
blaming all the Roma?<br />
28
Making News Personal<br />
<strong>International</strong> <strong>Center</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Journalists</strong>
Conducting Interviews<br />
Conducting Interviews<br />
Talking to people is at the heart of good reporting, but it can pose special<br />
challenges in social issue beats. Whether the subject is religion, education,<br />
poverty, prisons, ethnic conflict, health care or environmental problems, your<br />
stories will succeed or fail depending upon the people you find to populate<br />
them—and whether the tales and in<strong>for</strong>mation they are willing to disclose to you<br />
are compelling.<br />
Readers and viewers want to learn about someone they can relate to. Without<br />
revealing personal accounts, stories about social issues remain flat and lifeless.<br />
It is your job not only to find those people but also to elicit from them material<br />
that will keep your audience’s attention. Remember that even if your interview<br />
subjects are not experts in the academic sense, they are the experts when it<br />
comes to their own lives.<br />
28
Making News Personal<br />
Beginning journalists often find<br />
themselves intimidated at the prospect<br />
of talking to people they don’t know.<br />
But they frequently find, to their<br />
surprise, that many people like being<br />
asked their opinion about something<br />
or to tell their own stories. While some<br />
may refuse to talk to you, others may<br />
be more than willing to share their<br />
ideas, thoughts and personal<br />
experiences.<br />
Here are some strategies to help you<br />
get the most out of your interviews:<br />
• Prepare as much as possible in<br />
advance <strong>for</strong> an interview. Draw up a<br />
list of questions that you’d like to<br />
ask. It is important however, to<br />
remain flexible enough to move in a<br />
different direction, depending upon<br />
the answers you receive. If an<br />
unexpected but promising line of<br />
questioning develops, pursue it.<br />
• If possible, try to meet people in<br />
their office, home or somewhere<br />
they feel com<strong>for</strong>table. When people<br />
are at ease, they often disclose<br />
more than they would in other<br />
contexts. Visiting them in their own<br />
environment will also give you a<br />
better sense of who they are, how<br />
they live and what they value.<br />
• When arranging an interview with<br />
subjects who say they are extremely<br />
busy, always ask <strong>for</strong> less time than<br />
you really want. If you ask <strong>for</strong> too<br />
much, they are likely to refuse. But<br />
more often than not, the allotted<br />
time will pass and they won’t even<br />
notice.<br />
• It is sometimes a good idea to start<br />
an interview with small talk. If you’re<br />
in someone’s office, ask about a<br />
memento or a family photo on the<br />
desk or a piece of art on the wall.<br />
This will encourage the person to<br />
start talking on a neutral subject and<br />
can be an effective way to defuse<br />
defensiveness or reluctance to talk.<br />
• With the exception of some<br />
bureaucrats and public figures, no<br />
one is obligated to talk to you, so<br />
those who take the time and open<br />
up are doing you a favor. Treat them<br />
accordingly. Remember that they<br />
may never have talked to or even<br />
met a journalist be<strong>for</strong>e, and they<br />
could be very nervous. Be gracious<br />
and accommodating. Greet them<br />
warmly, make lots of eye contact<br />
and thank them.<br />
• Approach interviews with an open<br />
mind and accept people on their<br />
own terms. Especially when it<br />
comes to social issues, many of<br />
your sources will have lives<br />
completely different from yours.<br />
They may be of a different religion,<br />
sexual orientation or ethnicity. If they<br />
feel like you’re judging them or<br />
preaching to them, they’re much<br />
less likely to open up to you and<br />
provide you with material you can<br />
use.<br />
• Don’t assume you know what<br />
someone is going to tell you.<br />
Otherwise, you may not hear the<br />
little nugget of in<strong>for</strong>mation that<br />
would surprise you or send you<br />
down a different but fruitful reporting<br />
path. Most interviews should be<br />
viewed as an opportunity <strong>for</strong> you to<br />
learn something new and not just a<br />
chance to verify something you<br />
already know.<br />
• Take meticulous notes, even if you<br />
are tape recording the conversation.<br />
Recorders have a nasty habit of not<br />
working just when you need them<br />
<strong>International</strong> <strong>Center</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Journalists</strong>
Conducting Interviews<br />
most, so it is important to have<br />
handwritten notes as a backup. It is<br />
also much less time consuming to<br />
pull a quote from a few pages of<br />
notes than to find it on a long tape<br />
recording.<br />
• Illuminating, entertaining or unusual<br />
quotes always enliven a story.<br />
Readers want to know how people<br />
express themselves, and quotes<br />
allow them to hear in their minds<br />
how people talk. Listen <strong>for</strong> phrases<br />
and sentences that convey both<br />
interesting in<strong>for</strong>mation and a sense<br />
of the person’s speaking style.<br />
• Leave the most difficult or hardhitting<br />
questions until the end. It<br />
does happen that someone being<br />
interviewed might halt an interview<br />
rather than respond to a tough<br />
question. So it is more strategic to<br />
start with softer, easier ones just to<br />
make sure you get something out of<br />
the interview. This gradual approach<br />
also may help relax the person,<br />
which could make them feel more<br />
com<strong>for</strong>table answering more difficult<br />
questions later on.<br />
Some people say the<br />
most interesting<br />
things once the <strong>for</strong>mal<br />
interview is over.<br />
• Some people say the most<br />
interesting things once the <strong>for</strong>mal<br />
interview is over. Just because<br />
you’ve shut your tape recorder off or<br />
closed your notebook doesn’t mean<br />
you should stop paying attention. If<br />
someone takes that moment to start<br />
divulging in<strong>for</strong>mation, open your<br />
notebook again and continue the<br />
interview.<br />
• Public officials understand the<br />
consequences of talking to a<br />
reporter, but many people<br />
interviewed <strong>for</strong> social issues stories<br />
have never talked to a journalist. It’s<br />
best to avoid using anonymous<br />
sources whenever possible, but<br />
sources <strong>for</strong> social issues stories<br />
may have good reasons to ask that<br />
you not use their names. Illegal<br />
immigrants or victims of sexual<br />
violence, <strong>for</strong> example, may suffer<br />
severe consequences if you use<br />
their names. You need to make sure<br />
they understand that you intend to<br />
use what they tell you in a story and<br />
to quote them by name. If they are<br />
not com<strong>for</strong>table with the<br />
consequences, try to find a different<br />
source who doesn’t mind being<br />
identified, because that always<br />
makes your story more credible.<br />
• If you do decide to quote someone<br />
anonymously, it is always important<br />
to explain as clearly as possible why<br />
they don’t want to be identified. That<br />
will help the audience determine<br />
whether the source might be using<br />
the cloak of anonymity to advance a<br />
particular political perspective or<br />
criticize someone unfairly. You also<br />
should include as much in<strong>for</strong>mation<br />
about them as they feel com<strong>for</strong>table<br />
with—<strong>for</strong> example, their profession,<br />
city of residence or whatever—as<br />
long as it wouldn’t be possible to<br />
identify them fully from that<br />
in<strong>for</strong>mation. That will also help the<br />
audience determine how credible<br />
the in<strong>for</strong>mation is.<br />
30
Making News Personal<br />
• When the interview is over, always<br />
ask whether the person knows of<br />
anyone else you might interview,<br />
whether a friend, colleague or family<br />
member. Also explain that you might<br />
get in touch again if you have any<br />
further questions. Except <strong>for</strong> cases<br />
when the interview has been<br />
confrontational, the person probably<br />
will readily encourage you to do so.<br />
<strong>International</strong> <strong>Center</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Journalists</strong>
Asking the Questions<br />
Asking the Questions<br />
Let’s say you’ve arranged to interview someone with AIDS. You want to<br />
approach the person gently, of course, but you also want to get as much<br />
in<strong>for</strong>mation as possible <strong>for</strong> your story. Here are some suggestions <strong>for</strong><br />
questions you might ask. When conducting interviews, it’s important that you<br />
remain flexible and depart from your planned list of questions if the interview<br />
takes you in an unexpected direction.<br />
1. How are you today? What feelings do you have about talking to a<br />
reporter?<br />
2. What have you told people close to you, such as your parents, siblings,<br />
children and friends, about your health?<br />
3. What kind of health care have you been receiving? How is your<br />
relationship with your doctor?<br />
4. How is your health generally these days? What specific medical problems<br />
have you had recently, if any?<br />
5. How many other people know about your condition? What problems has<br />
your condition caused at work, or in the building or neighborhood where<br />
you live?<br />
6. What did you know about HIV/AIDS be<strong>for</strong>e you found out you were<br />
infected? What was your impression about how it was transmitted?<br />
7. What stereotypes did you have about people infected with HIV be<strong>for</strong>e you<br />
found out? Has that changed?<br />
8. How do you think you became infected? What was your first reaction<br />
when you found out that you were infected?<br />
9. How have you coped since finding out? What changes have you made in<br />
your life, if any?<br />
10. How have your values in life—<strong>for</strong> example, spiritual values or attitudes<br />
toward family, love, work and so on—changed since finding out?<br />
11. Have you become involved in HIV-related organizations?<br />
12. Can you suggest any other people—including others with HIV, family<br />
members or health professionals—who would be useful to talk with?<br />
32
Making News Personal<br />
Choosing a<br />
Format <strong>for</strong> the<br />
Story<br />
Stories about social issues can take<br />
many <strong>for</strong>ms. Some are basic news<br />
stories—a study on cancer rates is<br />
released, a politician takes a stand or<br />
makes a speech <strong>for</strong> or against<br />
immigration, a conference on povertyfighting<br />
ef<strong>for</strong>ts begins. Other pieces<br />
focus on trends, such as a change in<br />
social attitudes toward an issue or<br />
other developments occurring over<br />
time. Profiles of people or institutions<br />
are a common approach, as are<br />
investigative stories.<br />
One of the exciting aspects of<br />
covering social issues is that stories<br />
can be in practically any <strong>for</strong>mat. And<br />
as you gather your material, you’ll<br />
need to think about what approach<br />
would work best. Often this will be<br />
self-evident; other times you may<br />
have several choices. The decision<br />
will depend upon the amount of<br />
in<strong>for</strong>mation you have, how much time<br />
you have to prepare the piece, and<br />
which part of the material you would<br />
like to emphasize.<br />
Here are some suggestions to help<br />
you make that decision:<br />
• News stories are the most<br />
straight<strong>for</strong>ward approach and are<br />
frequently the most appropriate. If<br />
someone were giving a speech<br />
about a social issue, this would<br />
most likely translate into a news<br />
piece. A story about a new study or<br />
report would also be likely to fall into<br />
the news <strong>for</strong>mat, but it could also<br />
take an explanatory approach. Even<br />
a news or explanatory piece,<br />
however, should include comment<br />
from other sources—those in the<br />
audience who disagree with the<br />
speechmaker, <strong>for</strong> example, or<br />
scientists whose research<br />
contradicts what the new study<br />
claims.<br />
• A news feature is generally a story<br />
about a trend or a development<br />
happening over time. The impetus<br />
<strong>for</strong> the story might be an event—the<br />
same study, <strong>for</strong> example, that could<br />
serve as the basis <strong>for</strong> a simple news<br />
story. But a news feature could<br />
develop the in<strong>for</strong>mation into a larger<br />
theme. If a report suggests that a<br />
particular lake is polluted, <strong>for</strong><br />
example, it could be a key element<br />
in a larger story about pollution<br />
throughout the region.<br />
• People love reading about or seeing<br />
other people, so profiles are often<br />
the best way to convey important<br />
in<strong>for</strong>mation. The key is to pick<br />
someone through whom you can<br />
address a particular issue. This<br />
could be an environmental activist,<br />
<strong>for</strong> example, or a politician whose<br />
prime interest is fighting<br />
discrimination against a religious<br />
minority. By focusing on an<br />
individual, you can draw the reader<br />
or viewer in while addressing a<br />
larger issue.<br />
• A question-and-answer interview<br />
<strong>for</strong>mat can be especially effective<br />
when it allows sources to express<br />
thoughts in their own words. The<br />
way they talk and their choice of<br />
expressions can convey a great<br />
deal to the audience. But this<br />
<strong>International</strong> <strong>Center</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Journalists</strong>
Choosing a Format <strong>for</strong> the Story<br />
approach works best if the<br />
interviewer is extremely well-versed<br />
in the subject and has the<br />
knowledge and skill to ask the<br />
person difficult questions. If other<br />
sources are not included, it can<br />
become a <strong>for</strong>um <strong>for</strong> a person to<br />
present one view unchallenged.<br />
• Sometimes you might want to profile<br />
not a major newsmaker but an<br />
ordinary person affected by events.<br />
Spend the day with an illegal<br />
immigrant, <strong>for</strong> example, and<br />
describe what life is like from that<br />
person’s perspective. Or spend time<br />
with a family that lives in the shadow<br />
of a chemical plant. People are<br />
interested in learning not just about<br />
authority figures or experts but also<br />
about others struggling to get by.<br />
• Whatever the <strong>for</strong>mat, the piece<br />
should be well rounded and include<br />
in<strong>for</strong>mation from all sides of a given<br />
question. No one should be allowed<br />
to disseminate his or her<br />
perspective unchallenged. It is the<br />
reporter’s job to ask tough and<br />
probing questions, to give the issue<br />
a thorough airing, and to allow<br />
anyone criticized— even a<br />
government official—a chance to<br />
respond.<br />
• Social issue stories also lend<br />
themselves to investigative pieces.<br />
Investigative journalism usually<br />
refers to stories that require a great<br />
deal of digging <strong>for</strong> in<strong>for</strong>mation and<br />
interviews with multiple sources.<br />
Investigative stories may uncover<br />
official wrongdoing, a pattern of<br />
corruption or systemic problems at<br />
an institution. An example might be<br />
a story about how tribal leaders are<br />
stealing aid money meant to raise<br />
the living standards <strong>for</strong> indigenous<br />
people. Because these kinds of<br />
stories can take a long time to<br />
report, it is usually essential to have<br />
the full support of the managers of<br />
your organization.<br />
• The <strong>for</strong>mat you have chosen <strong>for</strong><br />
your story will help determine the<br />
style you use to write it, including<br />
the crucial lead sentence. If you are<br />
writing a news story, your lead and<br />
the rest of the story will be written in<br />
a very straight<strong>for</strong>ward style that<br />
conveys the most important<br />
in<strong>for</strong>mation first. If you are writing a<br />
feature story, your lead might tell the<br />
story of a person who illustrates the<br />
issue you are covering, and it may<br />
be several paragraphs be<strong>for</strong>e you<br />
give the reader the most important<br />
in<strong>for</strong>mation.<br />
34
Making News Personal<br />
Case Study<br />
Here are four different first paragraphs <strong>for</strong> a story about a social issue: a<br />
refugee case in Canada complicated by the practice of female circumcision<br />
in Nigeria. Each represents a different approach to covering the story, using<br />
a different <strong>for</strong>mat.<br />
The first is a news story about an announcement:<br />
Immigration Canada announced Wednesday that a Nigerian refugee who<br />
has spent seven years in Montreal will be granted refugee status.<br />
Luzy Nasharo, 38, won her appeal to stay with her 7-year-old Canadian-born<br />
daughter, Hester, said Nancy Castillo, spokesman <strong>for</strong> Citizenship and<br />
Immigration Canada.<br />
Although Nasharo has no memory of a village elder circumcising her in her<br />
native Nigeria, she feared the same fate befalling her daughter if she were<br />
deported and returned with Hester, who is the subject of a court order<br />
allowing her to remain in Canada.<br />
This feature approach on the hard news gives the reader<br />
more of the flavor of the refugee’s story and struggle:<br />
Just a day after a Nigerian refugee and 20 members of the Montreal<br />
Coalition Against Poverty stormed two immigration offices, the appeal to halt<br />
her deportation was granted.<br />
“Thank you <strong>for</strong> the opportunity to contribute to this wonderful country,” said a<br />
teary Luzy Nasharo, 38, after hearing she had won her appeal to stay with<br />
her Canadian-born 7-year-old daughter.<br />
This version takes a profile approach, from the perspective<br />
of an interview with the refugee and her daughter, the<br />
main characters in the story:<br />
All day long at her Catholic school, 7-year-old Hester Nasharo prayed silently<br />
with one thought on her mind. “I said, ‘God please let us stay in the country’<br />
and it did work,” the girl said Wednesday.<br />
<strong>International</strong> <strong>Center</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Journalists</strong>
Case Study<br />
After school, Hester’s mother, Luzy Nasharo, who was to have been deported<br />
to Nigeria, told her daughter the good news. “I told her they want us to stay in<br />
Canada,” Nasharo said. “She said, ‘God, thank you so much, my wish came<br />
true.’”<br />
Nasharo, 38, and her Canadian-born daughter had been dreading having to<br />
abandon their lives here. The single mother is a failed refugee claimant. She<br />
said she feared returning home with Hester because female genital mutilation<br />
is routinely per<strong>for</strong>med on girls in her native Edo state.<br />
This version tells the story by exploring the issue at the<br />
heart of the refugee’s appeal. In this story, the refugee<br />
personifies the issue. The decision about her case is not<br />
the main thrust of the story.<br />
In some African cultures, female circumcision is seen as a way to curb sexual<br />
promiscuity. In the face of long-held tradition and custom, new laws on the<br />
books have had little success in doing away with the practice.<br />
The practice in Nigeria and current laws have become part of a very public<br />
immigration case, as a Nigerian woman seeking to remain in Canada<br />
appealed that her return would jeopardize her 7-year-old daughter.<br />
Luzy Nasharo, 38, argued that as a single mother, she would have no choice<br />
but to live with her elderly and traditional father if she returned to Nigeria. She<br />
said her father and community elders would demand that the little girl undergo<br />
the procedure, particularly since Hester was born out of wedlock.<br />
A 2003 report by the World Health Organization estimated that about 60<br />
percent of Nigeria’s female population has endured female genital mutilation.<br />
The report says that according to local experts, the “actual prevalence may be<br />
as high as 100 percent in some ethnic enclaves in the south,” which includes<br />
Edo State, which is Nasharo’s home.<br />
36
Making News Personal<br />
Finding<br />
Documents<br />
Documents are not a necessary<br />
component of all social-issues<br />
reporting. But they can add depth and<br />
authority to your stories, especially<br />
when combined with personal tales<br />
from those affected by the situation or<br />
issue at hand. And they can be used<br />
not just in large-scale investigative<br />
pieces but also with stories in other<br />
<strong>for</strong>mats as well.<br />
Different countries, of course, have<br />
different policies and laws on<br />
government and corporate papers and<br />
in<strong>for</strong>mation. And even when the law<br />
requires public disclosure of certain<br />
documents, that doesn’t mean that<br />
officials willingly make them available,<br />
especially if no effective legal<br />
mechanisms <strong>for</strong>ce their release.<br />
Confidential in<strong>for</strong>mants are often the<br />
best sources <strong>for</strong> obtaining files and<br />
documents that expose some official<br />
wrongdoing or deception. It is critical,<br />
however, to verify that documents are<br />
authentic be<strong>for</strong>e basing your material<br />
on them. It is also important to<br />
determine whether you are within your<br />
legal rights to have them and, further,<br />
to disseminate them.<br />
Here are some suggestions about<br />
what kinds of documents might be<br />
available and how you might use<br />
them:<br />
• Government materials can be<br />
among the hardest to obtain. But in<br />
newly emerging democracies, as in<br />
developed countries, official<br />
agencies often produce reports,<br />
studies and other documents<br />
available <strong>for</strong> scrutiny. Even if these<br />
documents portray a false reality or<br />
feature excessively optimistic data,<br />
you may be able to prove that the<br />
claims in them are misleading by<br />
citing studies or statistics from<br />
NGOs and other sources.<br />
• Not all documents are hidden away<br />
and accessible only through leaks.<br />
A country’s constitution, <strong>for</strong><br />
example, is a public document, and<br />
it may guarantee certain rights in the<br />
area covered by your beat.<br />
Legislation be<strong>for</strong>e elected bodies,<br />
either national or local, is also<br />
generally public, but few reporters<br />
take the time to read such<br />
documents closely. Comparing what<br />
the law requires against the reality<br />
can make a very effective story.<br />
• The health ministry may conduct<br />
evaluations of hospitals and clinics.<br />
The environmental ministry may<br />
examine how effectively businesses<br />
clean up their wastes. Get to know<br />
the people in the public agencies<br />
that deal with your subject area.<br />
Find someone who can explain how<br />
things work and what documents<br />
are created in the course of the<br />
institution’s regular functioning. That<br />
will help you decide what materials<br />
might help your reporting.<br />
• Private companies are springing up<br />
even in the most closed societies.<br />
And private companies all produce<br />
reams of documents on their<br />
operations. Many will be<br />
confidential, of course, but<br />
depending upon your country’s laws<br />
on corporate governance,<br />
companies may be required to<br />
disclose some of this material. Find<br />
out exactly what you have the right<br />
to see—and then ask <strong>for</strong> it.<br />
<strong>International</strong> <strong>Center</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Journalists</strong>
Finding Documents<br />
• Consulting with a lawyer, especially<br />
one familiar with media law, is often<br />
an important part of the process.<br />
First, you want to protect yourself by<br />
making sure that it is not illegal <strong>for</strong><br />
you to obtain and disseminate<br />
in<strong>for</strong>mation from certain documents.<br />
Second, you want to know what<br />
your rights are to see certain<br />
documents so you can feel<br />
com<strong>for</strong>table demanding them.<br />
• Don’t ignore personal documents<br />
that people can give you<br />
themselves. If you’re writing about<br />
someone with AIDS, perhaps they<br />
can give you a copy of their medical<br />
records. If someone has filed a<br />
lawsuit, they or their attorney may<br />
be able to provide you a copy, as<br />
well as supporting documentation. If<br />
you’re writing about juvenile crime, a<br />
parent might give you their child’s<br />
court documents or an NGO may be<br />
able to help you access police<br />
statistics.<br />
• If you’re writing a profile, quoting<br />
from letters, diaries and other kinds<br />
of personal papers can help the<br />
story come alive. Such documents<br />
enrich and humanize a person’s tale<br />
and can help authenticate what you<br />
have been told. And don’t <strong>for</strong>get<br />
about birth, marriage and death<br />
certificates to verify dates,<br />
relationships and other facts.<br />
• Depending upon the story, there<br />
might also be a use <strong>for</strong> such simple<br />
items as phone bills, receipts <strong>for</strong><br />
purchases made or services used,<br />
restaurant menus, insurance<br />
records and bank account<br />
statements. Creative reporters have<br />
found ways to take advantage of all<br />
these documents, although their<br />
relevance to the story must always<br />
be definitively established.<br />
• NGOs can be an excellent source<br />
<strong>for</strong> documents, either from within<br />
your country or outside. They can<br />
also help with advice on what else<br />
might be available and how you can<br />
get it. In addition, many<br />
organizations produce documents—<br />
reports, analyses, critiques—that<br />
can be useful.<br />
• If you use documents or quote from<br />
them, be sure to describe them fully<br />
and accurately. That’s the only way<br />
readers or viewers can judge the<br />
in<strong>for</strong>mation <strong>for</strong> themselves. If you<br />
obtained them through a confidential<br />
source, you can keep the person’s<br />
identity a secret. But if the person<br />
has a vested interest in having the<br />
in<strong>for</strong>mation made public, you should<br />
in<strong>for</strong>m your audience of the<br />
motivation <strong>for</strong> the disclosure.<br />
• Even if you have difficulty obtaining<br />
local documents, you might be able<br />
to find relevant material from<br />
international NGOs. They produce<br />
reports and analyses, and some<br />
may relate to the situation in your<br />
country or community. Local NGOs<br />
can lead you to affiliated<br />
international groups.<br />
• The Internet is becoming an greater<br />
resource <strong>for</strong> documents. In many<br />
countries, much in<strong>for</strong>mation <strong>for</strong>merly<br />
included only in printed reports is<br />
now available online. Even if this is<br />
not true where you live, you may be<br />
able to obtain documents elsewhere<br />
and use those if they shed light on<br />
situations at home. The Web sites of<br />
international organizations like the<br />
United Nations, the World Bank and<br />
the U.S. Agency <strong>for</strong> <strong>International</strong><br />
Development, <strong>for</strong> example, contain<br />
a wealth of in<strong>for</strong>mation on every<br />
country in the world.<br />
38
Making News Personal<br />
Finding Documents Online<br />
Your assignment is to cover poverty in your country. Where do you begin to find<br />
documents? Many international and local NGOs and government bodies provide<br />
written reports and analysis on social issues, and much of this in<strong>for</strong>mation can<br />
be found on the Internet. Below is a sample of the types of statistics you can find<br />
on poverty in your country, which could provide greater depth to your reporting<br />
or generate new ideas <strong>for</strong> stories. The same organizations offer a wealth of<br />
in<strong>for</strong>mation on their Web sites <strong>for</strong> all kinds of social issues.<br />
The World Bank — www.worldbank.org<br />
The World Bank produces annual reports and analysis on poverty (among other<br />
social issues). PovertyNet (http://www.worldbank.org/wbp/) includes regional<br />
and global statistics and trends, as well as poverty and health indicators. Here is<br />
a sample:<br />
• Almost 20% of people in Bosnia and Herzegovina lived below the poverty line<br />
in 2001-2002 (13.8% in urban areas; 19.9 % in rural areas).<br />
• In 2000, the estimated percentage of population with access to improved<br />
drinking water sources in Congo was 51% (71% in urban areas; 17% in rural<br />
areas).<br />
• In Algeria, 6% of children under 5 are malnourished.<br />
• China’s current gross domestic product rose from 946.3 billion in 1998 to 1.2<br />
trillion in 2000; however, growth was not significant from 2000 to 2002 reports.<br />
Life Expectancy of People in the Caucasus<br />
Countries 2000 2001 2002<br />
Armenia 74 74 75<br />
Azerbaijan 65 65 65<br />
Georgia 73 73 73<br />
Source: World Development Indicators database<br />
<strong>International</strong> <strong>Center</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Journalists</strong>
Finding Documents Online<br />
UNESCO Institute <strong>for</strong> Statistics —www.uis.unesco.org<br />
UNESCO’s Web site contains illiteracy rates by country, like El Salvador, and<br />
predicts future rates.<br />
Illiteracy Rates in El Salvador, Ages 15-24 (%)<br />
Year Total Male Female<br />
1990 16.2 14.9 17.4<br />
1995 13.9 12.9 14.8<br />
2000 11.8 11 12.7<br />
2005 10 9.4 10.6<br />
2010 8.4 7.9 8.8<br />
2015 7.1 6.8 7.4<br />
UNICEF — www.unicef.org<br />
The annual State of the World’s Children report provides poverty data by<br />
country. The Under-5 Mortality Rate <strong>for</strong> 2004 is the probability of a child dying<br />
between infancy and 5 years old (expressed per 1,000 live births). Here is a<br />
sample:<br />
Belarus: 20<br />
Eritrea: 89<br />
Mongolia: 71<br />
40
Making News Personal<br />
Using Statistics<br />
Statistics, including surveys and polls, can add a great deal of credibility to your<br />
stories about social issues. But they can also be misused and misinterpreted.<br />
Like all in<strong>for</strong>mation, numerical claims must be verified. The source of the<br />
statistics should be disclosed, as well as any potential biases of the source, so<br />
your audience can judge how reliable or biased the figures might be. Statistics<br />
can <strong>for</strong>m the basis of news pieces if they shed light on some important social<br />
problem. Surveys of unemployment rates, <strong>for</strong> example, tend to be widely<br />
reported in many countries. Polls of public opinion on major issues, such as<br />
attitudes toward refugees, also can be very revealing. But effective use of<br />
statistics can also strengthen social issue stories in any <strong>for</strong>mat. Here are some<br />
suggestions on using statistics to bolster your reporting:<br />
• Don’t trust every figure or poll. Many are presented or sponsored by<br />
organizations that have a significant interest in the outcome of the debate. That<br />
doesn’t automatically invalidate a statistic, but it should increase your<br />
skepticism. If you have real doubts about whether figures are accurate, you<br />
should decline to use them until you can verify them.<br />
• Learn how to evaluate a poll’s methodology. It is easy to design survey<br />
questions that generate desired responses. A different set of questions could<br />
yield apparently contradictory answers. If you’re not sure of a poll’s validity, ask<br />
the researcher to explain the design. If a set of statistics seems too good to be<br />
true, it might be.<br />
• Cultivate a source who is a statistician and who understands how to evaluate<br />
statistics and surveys. That way, when you have a question about a set of<br />
figures, you can get an objective answer as to how much weight to assign<br />
them.<br />
• If an issue is controversial, as many social problems are, any survey or set of<br />
statistics is likely to please some people and upset others. Opponents will<br />
undoubtedly attempt to challenge the methodology or the political or social<br />
perspective of a source. Such objections, if realistic, should be a part of your<br />
story and can be a starting point <strong>for</strong> discussions with the pollster.<br />
• When you’re using figures, make sure they add up. Double- and triple-check<br />
the numbers. Nothing is more embarrassing than a reader or viewer accurately<br />
pointing out that a poll’s percentages add up to more than 100 percent or other<br />
simple—and completely avoidable—mathematical or methodological mistakes.<br />
• Place figures in some sort of context, whenever possible. Numbers often make<br />
more sense when compared to something else. If the average farmer’s income<br />
declined by 50 percent last year, <strong>for</strong> example, make sure you also note from
Using Statistics<br />
which level it declined. If a new<br />
study shows that a certain<br />
percentage of heavy smokers<br />
develop diabetes, include what<br />
percentage of non-smokers develop<br />
diabetes.<br />
• Try to compare figures that you use<br />
in a story to something your<br />
audience can relate to. For<br />
example, if farmers in a jungle<br />
region of your country de<strong>for</strong>est a<br />
certain number of hectares per year<br />
to plant crops, tell your readers or<br />
viewers how big that is. The size of<br />
10 football fields? The size of the<br />
province that includes your city?<br />
Such comparisons help the<br />
audience understand numbers.<br />
• One common mistake is confusing a<br />
percentage change with a<br />
percentage point change. For<br />
example, if the poverty rate in your<br />
country increased last year from 20<br />
percent to 22 percent of the<br />
population, it did not increase by 2<br />
percent. It increased by 2<br />
percentage points, which is very<br />
different. It actually increased by 10<br />
percent. (That is, 10 percent more<br />
people lived in poverty last year<br />
than did the year be<strong>for</strong>e.)<br />
• Don’t overload your story with<br />
statistics. Figures can be a powerful<br />
element of your material, but it is<br />
hard <strong>for</strong> readers and viewers to<br />
absorb too many at once. Pick the<br />
most telling numbers and use them<br />
to prove your point, but try not to<br />
include more than a couple of<br />
statistics in a sentence or<br />
paragraph.<br />
• Use figures as a starting point, not<br />
as the only point. Statistics can<br />
guide you in preparing your<br />
material, but only the most<br />
surprising or unexpected should<br />
<strong>for</strong>m the core of your story. Flesh<br />
out the figures by finding real people<br />
who embody the issues, problems<br />
or dilemma represented by the<br />
numbers.<br />
<strong>International</strong> <strong>Center</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Journalists</strong><br />
42
Making News Personal<br />
Case Study<br />
Reporting on social trends based on the latest<br />
statistics can be tricky. Unless research data is<br />
carefully scrutinized, it is easy to misinterpret results<br />
or make false assumptions about what statistics<br />
mean.<br />
For example, on Feb. 27, 2000, The Washington Post reported on an upward<br />
trend of women making more money than their husbands.* “In a striking<br />
rewriting of the age-old compact between husbands and wives, the proportion<br />
of couples in which the woman is chief breadwinner has been increasing so<br />
markedly that nearly one in three working wives nationwide now is paid more<br />
than her husband, compared with fewer than one in five in 1980,” the Post<br />
reported.<br />
The front-page article contained anecdotes from several high-powered<br />
women in the area, including a lawyer, a cardiologist and an economist, who<br />
earned a larger salary than their spouses. What’s wrong with this story? The<br />
Statistical Assessment Service (www.stats.org) in Washington, D.C., keeps its<br />
eyes open <strong>for</strong> incorrect reporting on statistical in<strong>for</strong>mation, and they found<br />
two major flaws:<br />
1. Is this really a trend? The study showed that the number of women who<br />
were paid more than their husbands did rise— from 7 million women in 1980<br />
to 10.5 million in 1998. However, this number had barely increased since<br />
1993. Should this be considered a trend because the statistics hadn’t<br />
changed much in the previous seven years?<br />
2. Are these women accurately represented? The article portrayed women<br />
who earn more than their husbands as being lawyers and doctors. If the<br />
numbers in the survey were broken down correctly, the majority of women<br />
who made more than their husbands were not in high-powered jobs, but held<br />
working-class jobs, like waitressing. Only 9 percent of married working<br />
women had a graduate-degree education.<br />
* Reported in “Gender Income Inequalities” on www.stats.org, March 1, 2000,<br />
http://www.stats.org/record.jsp?type=news&ID=329<br />
17
Moving Beyond Words<br />
Moving Beyond Words<br />
The word is only one part of a story, whether that story appears in a newspaper<br />
or on TV, radio or the Internet. Words are powerful tools, but the images,<br />
graphics or—in the case of radio, the sounds—that accompany them can either<br />
enhance their impact or detract from it. Many print journalists believe that<br />
illustrating their stories is solely the job of the photo or graphics department. TV<br />
reporters, <strong>for</strong> their part, sometimes think that the one holding the camera should<br />
make all the decisions about the image.<br />
They’re right, in a sense, but such a limited perspective of a reporter’s<br />
responsibility does no one any favors. Because it is in your interest to reach the<br />
maximum number of people with your work, it makes much more sense to take<br />
an active role in making it appear attractive and in<strong>for</strong>mative in all respects. After<br />
44
Making News Personal<br />
all, there’s no point in working on a<br />
story exposing trafficking networks or<br />
detailing why schools are not<br />
receiving all the money they are<br />
supposed to if no one pays attention.<br />
Advance planning and coordination<br />
with others in the newsroom is critical<br />
to effective presentation.<br />
Stories about social issues concern<br />
people and factors that affect their<br />
quality of life. It is good to enhance<br />
such stories with images—and sounds<br />
—that explain or give life to the<br />
concepts and ideas they describe.<br />
And because statistics are often<br />
included—budget numbers,<br />
demographic figures, polling results—<br />
it is critical to think about displaying<br />
those details on the page or screen in<br />
a way that makes them clear and<br />
attractive.<br />
All too often, however, newspaper<br />
reporters develop a story having given<br />
no thought to how it will look on the<br />
page. At times they haven’t even<br />
in<strong>for</strong>med their editor, much less other<br />
departments, about their work. While<br />
this may enhance the reporter’s<br />
feeling of independence, it<br />
undermines the possibility that the<br />
story will receive attention it deserves,<br />
both within the newsroom and among<br />
the general public.<br />
While TV journalists are often more<br />
aware of the importance of the visual<br />
element, they, too, should think<br />
carefully about how to present stories<br />
in the most arresting ways, and they<br />
should involve producers and camera<br />
operators early in decisions on how to<br />
report a story.<br />
Radio stories, of course, don’t use<br />
visuals, but reporters should try to use<br />
natural sound in their stories to make<br />
the listener feel he or she is actually<br />
there. This means capturing the<br />
sounds of a busy street in a story<br />
about homeless people, the chattering<br />
of children in the classroom in an<br />
education story, or the background<br />
sounds of a <strong>for</strong>est in a story about<br />
preserving natural habitats.<br />
Here are some tips to ensure that<br />
material is presented in the most<br />
effective and eye-catching—or earcatching—manner:<br />
• As soon as you begin working on a<br />
story, start thinking about the visual<br />
or aural possibilities. Discuss what<br />
you are exploring with your editor or<br />
producer. If possible, meet with the<br />
staff photographer or camera<br />
operator, the graphics person and<br />
anyone else who will be involved in<br />
the process of preparing the story<br />
<strong>for</strong> publication or broadcast. Even if<br />
you have no definite ideas about<br />
visual and aural possibilities,<br />
including colleagues in the process<br />
gives you the chance to hear their<br />
ideas or suggestions about what<br />
might work best.<br />
• While you gather material, keep an<br />
eye out <strong>for</strong> the possibilities. If you<br />
receive a statistical report, decide<br />
early which figures are the most<br />
important or the easiest to present<br />
in a chart. Pass the in<strong>for</strong>mation to<br />
the graphics department so<br />
someone can start on the design. If<br />
you’re producing a radio piece, it’s<br />
best to keep statistical in<strong>for</strong>mation to<br />
a minimum.<br />
• As you interview people, think about<br />
photo, video and sound possibilities.<br />
A portrait or film of someone sitting<br />
in a chair or behind a desk is usually<br />
<strong>International</strong> <strong>Center</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Journalists</strong>
Moving Beyond Words<br />
static and boring. Are any of your<br />
sources engaged in some sort of<br />
dynamic activity, such as teaching,<br />
exercising, treating patients? Do<br />
some sources have particularly<br />
expressive or animated faces or<br />
voices? Tell them that you’d like to<br />
take their picture, film or record<br />
them. Then make the arrangements<br />
with your appropriate colleagues so<br />
that the details can be arranged well<br />
be<strong>for</strong>e deadline.<br />
• If you’re working in radio, keep your<br />
ear open <strong>for</strong> aural possibilities.<br />
Listen <strong>for</strong> sounds that augment and<br />
illustrate your story—an illegal<br />
immigrant washing dishes, <strong>for</strong><br />
example, or machinery noises <strong>for</strong> a<br />
story about plants that generate<br />
pollution. Pay attention, too, to the<br />
quality of people’s voices. If you<br />
have to choose between including<br />
tape of one person or another, make<br />
your decision based not just on what<br />
they say but on whether their<br />
intonation or the timbre of their voice<br />
is interesting.<br />
• Every photo or graphic should have<br />
a caption explaining who or what it<br />
is. It is very frustrating to readers to<br />
see a beautiful photo or wonderfully<br />
designed chart without any<br />
explanation of what it means or how<br />
it relates to the story. The journalist<br />
should write or at least approve of<br />
the captions to ensure accuracy.<br />
• Every photo should indicate who<br />
took it, and every graphic should<br />
include the source of the in<strong>for</strong>mation<br />
or statistics, whether it’s the<br />
government, an NGO, a hospital, a<br />
school or whatever. That offers<br />
readers guidance <strong>for</strong> interpreting the<br />
material.<br />
• It is a major principle of journalistic<br />
ethics that photos and video should<br />
not be manipulated or electronically<br />
altered, even if doing so makes the<br />
image more startling or compelling.<br />
Photos of criminal suspects should<br />
not be darkened, <strong>for</strong> example,<br />
because that could influence people<br />
to believe more strongly in their<br />
guilt. And it is wrong to combine two<br />
photographs to make it appear that<br />
people who never met are actually<br />
talking to each other. One exception<br />
to this principle is protecting<br />
people’s confidentiality by obscuring<br />
their faces. But make it clear to the<br />
reader or viewer that the image has<br />
been manipulated.<br />
• Because images can have such a<br />
powerful impact, it is critical that<br />
they accurately convey the essence<br />
of the story. Sometimes a photo or<br />
video image is what people will<br />
remember most; it may be the only<br />
thing they remember. So when<br />
selecting the visual elements, you<br />
want to be sure that they reflect<br />
what is actually being reported.<br />
• Just as you should avoid<br />
stereotypes in your portrayals of<br />
people from different demographic<br />
groups, it is important to follow the<br />
same principle when it comes to the<br />
visual aspect of your story. Use<br />
photographs, video and sound to<br />
challenge or surprise readers, not to<br />
rein<strong>for</strong>ce biases and prejudices. If<br />
the piece is about the Roma, <strong>for</strong><br />
example, include images of one of<br />
them at work rather than begging.<br />
Consider less common <strong>for</strong>ms of<br />
graphic presentation of your<br />
material. Look through other<br />
publications <strong>for</strong> ideas. A map of<br />
some sort is often an effective way<br />
of showing exactly where something<br />
46
Making News Personal<br />
is taking place, <strong>for</strong> example. Think<br />
about what kind of charts—bar<br />
graphs, pie charts, tables—would<br />
present the material in the clearest<br />
and most effective manner.<br />
<strong>International</strong> <strong>Center</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Journalists</strong>
Following Up<br />
Following Up<br />
Once you’ve written your first few<br />
pieces on a social issues beat, you’ll<br />
want to take stock of what you’ve<br />
done and decide how to proceed<br />
further. Hopefully, your initial stories<br />
will provide you with both sources and<br />
ideas <strong>for</strong> additional reporting. Perhaps<br />
you’ve received some calls with<br />
further tips to check out. Or maybe<br />
some action has been taken to<br />
address the problems covered in your<br />
work.<br />
In any event, a key aspect of<br />
successfully covering poverty or<br />
immigration or any social issue is<br />
knowing how and when to follow up.<br />
Here are some suggestions <strong>for</strong> doing<br />
so:<br />
• As you gather and prepare material,<br />
it will often become apparent early<br />
on that you will not be able to fit<br />
everything you’ve learned into one<br />
story. Other aspects of an issue can<br />
become the basis of follow-up<br />
pieces. They may require significant<br />
additional reporting, or you may<br />
actually have enough with just one<br />
or two extra phone calls.<br />
• In the course of reporting, you are<br />
likely to come across other ideas<br />
you want to pursue later. These<br />
clues to additional stories might<br />
arise, <strong>for</strong> example, from offhand<br />
remarks your sources make, or<br />
something you notice in a document<br />
search that is interesting but not<br />
relevant to the story at hand. Keep a<br />
running list of such ideas, and when<br />
you’re done with one story, review<br />
the list and pick the most interesting<br />
one as the next.<br />
• Pay attention to any changes that<br />
occur after a story has run. Perhaps<br />
some new legislation has been<br />
introduced, or an NGO has<br />
launched a new initiative. Once<br />
you’ve reported on a topic, sources<br />
will often contact you to keep you up<br />
to date, but you should also make a<br />
point of finding out what has<br />
happened since the piece appeared.<br />
• Continue to read everything you can<br />
about the subject, in both the local<br />
and national press. Keep track of<br />
specialized journals, reports issued<br />
by NGOs and in<strong>for</strong>mation<br />
disseminated through the Internet.<br />
The best way to come up with new<br />
story ideas is to remain current and<br />
in touch with trends and issues in<br />
the area you’re covering.<br />
• Once you start covering a topic, you<br />
are likely to receive phone calls, e-<br />
mails and letters from people with<br />
an interest in the subject. They may<br />
suggest stories themselves, or they<br />
may simply tell you about their lives<br />
and experiences. Either way, such<br />
contact is an invaluable source of<br />
ideas <strong>for</strong> future ef<strong>for</strong>ts. Consider<br />
putting your e-mail address or<br />
phone number at the end of the<br />
story to make it easier <strong>for</strong> people to<br />
contact you.<br />
48
Making News Personal<br />
Futures File<br />
If you’re covering education and the summer break is ending, you might<br />
have a list of stories that you can do as the school year progresses. Here is<br />
an example of what some reporters call a futures file—a list of reminders,<br />
potential news items and stories an education reporter might do in the future:<br />
1. September 1st: Start of the academic year. How are schools preparing?<br />
What is this year’s education budget compared to last year’s? What are<br />
the feelings of teachers and students as they get ready to return?<br />
2. Rosh Hashanah, the Jewish New Year, takes place in early fall. Do<br />
Jewish students in your region observe the holiday? Do they take the<br />
day off? Does the school take note of the event in any way?<br />
3. October 10th: The local school committee is expected to hold a hearing<br />
on how to increase access to schools <strong>for</strong> those in wheelchairs. You<br />
might think about covering the issue be<strong>for</strong>e the hearing and then report<br />
what happened—or didn’t—at the event itself. Then follow up a few<br />
months later.<br />
4. Last year members of two ethnic groups clashed at several schools.<br />
How have school administrators handled such problems this year? Have<br />
they made any ef<strong>for</strong>ts to calm the situation? Have the clashes<br />
continued?<br />
5. A professor at a local university mentioned last year that she was<br />
researching the role a parent’s interest in reading plays in a child’s<br />
acquisition of language skills. Call her to find out if it’s time to report on<br />
her findings.<br />
6. Last year you profiled a first-year teacher. Maybe it’s time <strong>for</strong> a follow-up.<br />
How is he doing this year? Has he learned any new approaches to<br />
teaching? Is he encouraged? Discouraged? What do his students think?<br />
7. November 7 is the one-year anniversary of a major protest by high<br />
school students regarding classroom overcrowding. The administration<br />
promised to hire more teachers and open temporary classrooms, but<br />
said change would not happen immediately. How much progress has<br />
been made? Are the leaders of the protest satisfied?<br />
<strong>International</strong> <strong>Center</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Journalists</strong>
Conclusion<br />
Conclusion<br />
Social issues stories are among the most challenging a journalist will cover<br />
because they often deal with sensitive, controversial topics. But those same<br />
challenges also make these stories more important and more interesting than<br />
many other stories that appear in a newspaper or a broadcast report. They are<br />
important because, almost by definition, they relate directly to the lives of<br />
readers, listeners and viewers. And they are interesting because more than<br />
almost any type of journalism, they provide the reporter an opportunity to tell<br />
compelling stories about real people.<br />
Reporters who cover social issues sometimes struggle to get their stories onto<br />
the front page or the top of the broadcast. That’s because the people who make<br />
decisions about which stories will get the biggest play often think that the only<br />
important stories are political stories, and the only stories that will entice people<br />
to buy the paper or tune into the broadcast are grisly crime stories or gossipy<br />
entertainment stories.<br />
The tips in this manual are designed to push to the <strong>for</strong>efront important stories<br />
that deal with real people rather than just the famous and the powerful. By<br />
reporting these stories thoroughly and fairly, and by telling them in a compelling<br />
manner, social issues reporters can make their stories the ones that audiences<br />
want to read, hear and see. They can impact policies on everything from<br />
education to poverty to religion to health.<br />
Then, perhaps, reporters who cover parliament or the presidential palace will<br />
clamor <strong>for</strong> the opportunity to cover refugee camps and AIDS clinics, rather than<br />
the other way around.<br />
50
1616 H Street, 3rd Floor<br />
Washington, DC 20006<br />
www.icfj.org