Download English version (pdf) - RFSU
Download English version (pdf) - RFSU
Download English version (pdf) - RFSU
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
Dialogue for Change<br />
Reference materials in support of policy dialogue<br />
on sexual and reproductive health and rights
Foreword<br />
The right to decide and exercise control over one’s own<br />
body, sexuality and reproduction is fundamental for all<br />
people. The Swedish Government therefore prioritizes<br />
sexual and reproductive health and rights (SRHR) as a key<br />
issue in Sweden’s international policy for many years. All<br />
those who represent Sweden have an important role to play<br />
in the defence and promotion of sexual and reproductive<br />
health and rights within their respective work mandates.<br />
Sweden’s international SRHR policy is pursued in different<br />
ways, using different channels. Concrete decisions and<br />
actions that have a direct impact on women, men, young<br />
people and children are implemented through policy<br />
initiatives as well as bilateral and multilateral programmes<br />
at country level. Normative dialogue that helps to develop<br />
policy is often conducted in international fora and is just<br />
as important in this work. This is why governments, the<br />
UN, the World Bank, the EU, the European Council,<br />
regional institutions and local and international NGOs are<br />
identified as important partners.<br />
On 29 February 2008 Minister Gunilla Carlsson sent out a<br />
circular instruction to all heads of department at the Ministry<br />
for Foreign Affairs and Sweden’s embassies and permanent<br />
missions abroad to inform them of the fact that the Swedish<br />
Government had raised its ambitions for pursuing issues<br />
concerning sexual and reproductive health and rights in<br />
its international work. Sweden’s representatives must be<br />
familiar with Government priorities, policies and positions<br />
in these issues. The instruction also highlighted a recognition<br />
of the need for support to employees in the Ministry for<br />
Foreign Affairs and at Sweden’s embassies and missions<br />
abroad on SRHR, including strengthening their skills and<br />
ability to conduct effective policy dialogue on these issues.<br />
The Swedish Association for Sexuality Education, <strong>RFSU</strong>,<br />
was subsequently commissioned to provide background<br />
information, and in collaboration with the Ministry for<br />
Foreign Affairs and the Swedish International Development<br />
Cooperation Agency (Sida) produce a set of materials<br />
that would facilitate and strengthen communication<br />
and dialogue surrounding SRHR issues, including a<br />
number of specific themes such as sexuality education,<br />
young people’s sexual and reproductive health and rights,<br />
combating gender-based violence, LGBT rights, maternal<br />
mortality, access to safe abortions, condoms and other<br />
methods of contraception. <strong>RFSU</strong> has more than 75 years<br />
of experience of working with issues surrounding sexual<br />
and reproductive health and rights in Sweden and internationally,<br />
both with partner organisations and decisionmakers<br />
at various levels.<br />
The purpose of this material is to strengthen the impact<br />
of Sweden’s SRHR policy by increasing the focus on<br />
communication and dialogue. Its point of departure is a<br />
rights-based perspective and approach that emphasises<br />
development and poverty reduction, but the material can<br />
also be used in many different political and policy contexts<br />
where discussions on people’s circumstances and<br />
living conditions take place.<br />
<strong>RFSU</strong> has developed this material in close collaboration<br />
with the Ministry for Foreign Affairs and Sida (Swedish<br />
International Development Cooperation Agency), and by<br />
means of a consultative process involving staff at Sweden’s<br />
embassies and missions around the world. Other ministries<br />
in the Government Offices of Sweden have commented on<br />
this material, and during the process various stakeholders<br />
in Swedish society have provided their views on its content<br />
and structure in order to ensure that it reflects the realities<br />
that representatives of Sweden experience when engaging<br />
in dialogue, presenting arguments and devising strategies<br />
to promote SRHR. Ministry officials and staff have referred<br />
to the material during training and competence-building<br />
sessions held during regional ambassadors’ meetings in<br />
the Spring of 2010.<br />
Issues surrounding sexual and reproductive health and<br />
rights are often controversial, which means that it can be<br />
difficult to discuss them at the highest political level. Representatives<br />
of Sweden need to help change this by being<br />
able to demonstrate that SRHR in fact comprises a body<br />
of quite central foreign policy issues.<br />
This material is intended for all staff in the Government<br />
Offices of Sweden, Sida and at all Swedish embassies and<br />
missions abroad.<br />
Ministry for Foreign Affairs, Stockholm, June 2010<br />
3
Contents<br />
Introduction 6<br />
Conducting effective dialogue 9<br />
Checklist for dialogue 11<br />
Thematic issues 13<br />
Maternal mortality and the work to achieve Millennium Development Goal 5 14<br />
Access to safe abortions 18<br />
Young people and SRHR 23<br />
Sexuality education 27<br />
Condoms and other methods of contraception 31<br />
HIV and AIDS 35<br />
Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender rights (LGBT rights issues) 39<br />
Gender-based violence 43<br />
Annex I SRHR: Definitions, terms and concepts 47<br />
Annex II Points of departure and mandates<br />
for work with SRHR 52<br />
Annex III SRHR and the EU 55<br />
Annex IV Organisations in the SRHR area 56<br />
Annex V Links and references 59<br />
4
Introduction<br />
The Swedish Government’s Policy for Global Development<br />
(Government Bill 2002/03:122; Government Communication<br />
2007/08:89; Government Communication 2009 /10:129)<br />
states that sexual and reproductive health and rights (srhr) are<br />
particularly relevant in the work to achieve the goal of equitable<br />
and sustainable global development. However, at the same time,<br />
srhr is a complex and often extremely sensitive issue. There are<br />
major differences of opinion and position in this area around<br />
the world, with issues concerning women’s and young people’s<br />
sexuality proving particularly controversial.<br />
Sweden places a high priority on promoting srhr. People<br />
working for the Government Offices of Sweden, Sida and<br />
Sweden’s embassies and missions abroad are responsible for<br />
promoting srhr and being able to include srhr in dialogue with<br />
governments and other actors in partner countries.<br />
This material has been produced to aid and support the<br />
work to pursue an effective dialogue on srhr issues within the<br />
framework of Sweden’s international work. It contains facts,<br />
frequently asked questions, as well as speaking points and<br />
advice for arguments for a number of the issues that srhr cover.<br />
The annexes also include definitions and concepts, international<br />
frameworks and mandates, information on srhr and the eu, as<br />
well as links and references to important documents, and to<br />
organisations and other actors that can also be of further support<br />
in this work.<br />
Why is it important to work with SRHR?<br />
srhr is essentially a political issue that has a bearing on foreign<br />
and security policy as well as development cooperation. There<br />
are widely varying differences of opinion and position among<br />
countries and various interest groups in relation to srhr issues,<br />
including sexuality education, access to safe abortions and lgbt<br />
rights. The breadth of srhr issues means that it is essential for<br />
there to be coherence of how they are treated and talked about<br />
across the different areas of Swedish policy. srhr is not only a<br />
health issue, it also encompasses a wide range of issues that<br />
are intrinsically linked not only to poverty reduction, but also<br />
to the promotion of gender equality and the rights and role of<br />
women in development. If people are subjected to violence,<br />
suffer permanent injuries as a result of pregnancy or childbirth,<br />
become infected with hiv or another sexually transmitted disease,<br />
or do not have a say about if, when or how often they want<br />
to have children, they are then also deprived of the possibility<br />
to live a life in freedom, to study, work and to shape their own<br />
lives and contribute to the development of their society.<br />
SRHR and gender equality<br />
The world’s governments have agreed in conventions and declarations<br />
that human rights apply to all people, that women and<br />
men have the same rights and must have equal opportunities.<br />
However, the observance of these international instruments is<br />
faltering in many ways, particularly when it comes to srhr. The<br />
un Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination<br />
Against Women (cedaw) came into force in 1979 and<br />
includes Article 12 about health and Article 16 about marriage<br />
and family life, which are both important for women’s right to<br />
sexual and reproductive health. Article 2(f) of cedaw obliges<br />
states to “take all appropriate measures, including legislation, to<br />
modify or abolish existing laws, regulations, customs and practices<br />
that constitute discrimination against women”. The Convention<br />
on the Rights of the Child also contains a requirement<br />
for states to take action with a view to “abolishing traditional<br />
practices prejudicial to the health of children” (Convention on<br />
the Rights of the Child, Article 24.3).<br />
The Declaration and Programme of Action adopted at the un<br />
International Conference on Population and Development (icpd),<br />
held in Cairo in 1994, points out that improving the status of<br />
women and their ability to control their fertility is a foundation<br />
stone for development. icpd also stresses the responsibility of<br />
men in issues of parenthood, sexuality and reproduction.<br />
The Declaration and Platform for Action from the un Conference<br />
on Women in Beijing in 1995 points out that women’s<br />
rights include the right to have control over their own sexuality<br />
and the right to freedom from all forms of coercion and violence,<br />
including sexual violence.<br />
Norms for what is considered male and female respectively<br />
are strongly embedded in most societies, and can limit people’s<br />
choices, opportunities and life prospects, including the ability<br />
to make decisions about their own body and sexuality. Resistance<br />
to equal conditions for women and men is often based<br />
6
on and justified by arguments based on cultural constructs of<br />
sex and gender. Power imbalances between the sexes leads to<br />
women and girls suffering the most from sexual and reproductive<br />
ill-health as men often make decisions on issues related to<br />
sexuality. This includes deciding if and when to have sex, if and<br />
what methods of contraception to use, and how many children<br />
a woman should have and when. In many instances women are<br />
both economically and socially dependent on men, which often<br />
makes it difficult or impossible for them to question decisions<br />
made by men, both in private and in public. Men and<br />
boys as well as women and girls must be involved in the work<br />
to strengthen sexual and reproductive health and rights and to<br />
promote gender equality.<br />
Social injustices, discrimination, marginalisation and inequality<br />
are some of the causes of poverty as they affect an individual’s<br />
access to, for example, information, education and health<br />
care services, and also access to the labour market. Women<br />
with disabilities often lack access to health care and seldom<br />
receive information about sexual and reproductive health.<br />
SRHR and gender equality<br />
• In Sub-Saharan Africa, 57 percent of people living with<br />
HIV are women.<br />
• Every year hundreds of thousands of women die and every<br />
minute 35 women suffer from chronic injuries as a result of<br />
pregnancy and childbirth.<br />
• A third of the world’s women have been forced to have sex<br />
at some point in their lives. 1<br />
Perceptions of SRHR in different<br />
social and cultural contexts<br />
Perceptions of srhr varies between and within different social<br />
and cultural contexts at both national and local levels. Cultures<br />
are comprised of collective values, knowledge, notions<br />
of morality, customs and traditions that have emerged so that<br />
people can understand and perceive meaning in their existence.<br />
Everyone’s behaviour is influenced by the culture in which<br />
they are fostered, and that shapes their frames of reference and<br />
their way of thinking. This is particularly true of perceptions<br />
of decency and morality associated with srhr and relationships<br />
between the sexes.<br />
In most cultures, inequality between the sexes is widespread<br />
and deeply rooted. Harmful customs and traditions that violate<br />
the sexual and reproductive rights of women and girls and put<br />
their lives and health at risk, for example child marriages and<br />
female genital mutilation, continue to be practiced in many<br />
countries, despite national laws and international regulations<br />
prohibiting them.<br />
International conventions on human rights state that these<br />
rights are universal and indivisible. The un conventions on civil<br />
and political rights point out that religious convictions and<br />
cultural practices must not be used as an excuse to violate the<br />
rights of individuals.<br />
Despite this, there is a perception in a number of countries<br />
outside Europe and North America that human rights are based<br />
solely on Western ideology and therefore do not apply to their<br />
cultures. This is particularly true of rights that are associated<br />
with women’s sexuality, physical integrity and their ability to<br />
make decisions about their own bodies. In dialogue on srhr,<br />
cultural arguments are often the most difficult to address and,<br />
just as with religion, tradition and customs are used to justify<br />
why an action such as abortion cannot be accepted, but that an<br />
action like genital mutilation is an important identity marker<br />
and must be performed.<br />
Changes in culturally-based behaviours can only take<br />
place from within and require collective changes in attitudes<br />
and behaviours. Knowledge of the local culture is needed to<br />
understand the bases and reasoning behind people’s attitudes<br />
if progress is to be made in this kind of dialogue. Strategic<br />
partnerships must also be forged with people, organisations and<br />
networks in local settings.<br />
1. unifem, Progress of the world’s women 2008/2009. Who answers to women?<br />
Gender and accountability (2008).<br />
7
Conducting effective dialogue<br />
Sweden, a strong voice in the world<br />
Dialogue is an important political tool that plays a central<br />
role in the process to promote srhr. Dialogue involves<br />
exchange and mutual listening and learning. In order to successfully<br />
influence and promote change, it requires frankness,<br />
humility and an ability to convey a clear message adapted<br />
to the specific situation. Those who represent Sweden must<br />
be able to engage actively with a process of communication,<br />
by acquiring relevant knowledge and establishing formal<br />
and informal contacts with authorities, the civil society in<br />
Sweden and in the partner country, other institutions and<br />
partners. They must also understand the specific cultural,<br />
social and political contexts in a country or region, in order<br />
to convey Sweden’s message and positions in the most successful<br />
way possible.<br />
Political dialogue is a long-term process of negotiation, which<br />
is effective if it develops within the framework of contacts and<br />
collaborative relationships where trust, mutual respect and<br />
openness are built up over a long period of time. It is especially<br />
important to prepare for dialogues and arguments, to take the<br />
time to understand both informal and formal structures and<br />
to identify who should be involved in a particular dialogue. As<br />
with other controversial or sensitive development issues, srhr<br />
issues must also be owned by the people they concern. Sweden’s<br />
srhr dialogue must be based on Swedish policy as well as international<br />
agreements in this area.<br />
Sweden is a respected development actor in the world and<br />
is considered to be a leader in a number of areas, including<br />
human rights, gender equality and srhr. Consequently, representatives<br />
of Sweden are expected to have good knowledge,<br />
qualifications and preparedness to pursue a dialogue, even<br />
when it comes to difficult and often controversial issues.<br />
srhr covers a wide spectrum of dimensions and issues. It is<br />
therefore important to focus on one or a few specific issues in<br />
different dialogues and specific contexts, for example, access<br />
to contraception, the training of midwives, access to safe abortion,<br />
sexuality education or lgbt rights. Some of these issues<br />
are more difficult to pursue than others. A common feature<br />
is that they all relate to the rights of people to make decisions<br />
about their own body, sexuality and reproduction.<br />
Contexts and entry points for dialogue<br />
Some srhr issues are less controversial than others and can<br />
therefore be used as entry points to discussion about issues<br />
that are more difficult or sensitive. For example, using the<br />
national situation and local examples of hiv and aids as a starting<br />
point and way of opening the door to extending the dialogue<br />
and be able to talk about young people’s sexuality, sexuality<br />
education and the need for access to reproductive health care.<br />
Gender-based violence can also be a good way to start talking<br />
about more complex issues concerning women’s right to make<br />
decisions about their own body, sexuality and reproduction.<br />
Effective dialogue and success can be achieved when the parties<br />
involved have the opportunity to meet in different ways in a more<br />
informal setting. Informal meetings and structures are often very<br />
conducive to dialogue, but it is also important to be aware of and<br />
consider which stakeholders are involved in the informal dialogue<br />
and which are not, and the consequences that this may have.<br />
srhr and gender equality are key issues in all sectors, particularly<br />
in the fight against poverty and other work that is essential<br />
for the development of countries. Several srhr issues obviously<br />
have a specific place in the health sector. However, these issues<br />
clearly extend beyond the health sector, and in order to achieve<br />
sexual and reproductive health and rights and gender equality,<br />
they must also be discussed and addressed within the framework<br />
of sectors such as education, human rights, the development of<br />
democracy, infrastructure, agriculture, employment and the<br />
labour market. The inclusion of srhr issues in national development<br />
or action plans serves as an excellent basis for producing<br />
strategies and indicators to achieve the desired results and impact.<br />
Planning dialogue<br />
A dialogue can form part of a long-term process or can be<br />
more limited. From the very beginning of a specific dialogue,<br />
the objective of the dialogue – determined for example with<br />
respect to a specific problem – has to be made clear to everyone<br />
involved.<br />
Setting objectives for the dialogue makes it easier to measure<br />
and present results. It is important to set both short-term and<br />
long-term objectives for the dialogue. A short-term objective<br />
could for example be that a meeting be held with dialogue<br />
9
partners or that contact has been established with a key actor,<br />
while a long-term objective could be for the dialogue to result<br />
in the conditions being put in place to provide better access for<br />
women to trained midwives in a specific geographic area as an<br />
appropriation item in the partner country’s health budget or in<br />
the sectoral budget for rural development. It is important to<br />
work with both short-term and long-term objectives in order to<br />
move the work forwards.<br />
Preparing for dialogue – Questions to consider<br />
• What is the purpose of the Swedish involvement and what<br />
responsibility and requirements does this place on the<br />
embassy, mission, Sida or relevant department in the Ministry?<br />
• What do we want to achieve/accomplish (be as concrete as<br />
possible and avoid grappling with too many issues at the same<br />
time)?<br />
• What guidelines and steering documents provide mandates<br />
and a basis for our work, for example international, regional or<br />
national commitments, including Swedish policy and positions?<br />
• What are the national legislation and the current situation in<br />
the country like? What are the consequences for various groups<br />
in the country? Look for statistics and other data and factual<br />
information to be used as arguments and link them to a specific<br />
dialogue objective.<br />
• What obstacles can be anticipated, and how can we prepare<br />
ourselves to handle them?<br />
• What are the most important and most central challenges in<br />
the country or region, in terms of srhr?<br />
Identifying opportunities<br />
It takes time to change people’s attitudes and values, as well as<br />
behaviour and social traditions. Patience is the key. It is important<br />
to set reasonable objectives and targets for different stages<br />
in a dialogue process, and to identify the opportunities that<br />
exist or that can emerge by creating political momentum and<br />
building alliances with, for example, civil society organisations<br />
and other stakeholders.<br />
It is also essential to collaborate with like-minded stakeholders<br />
and countries. Sweden may not always be able to work with<br />
the same configuration of like-minded stakeholders in all issues<br />
or fora. Different partners can support, be involved with and<br />
actively promote key srhr issues in different contexts, and with<br />
regard to specific issues and topics. Sweden is an active member<br />
in many multilateral organisations, and has been working with<br />
international ngos for many years that are also important stakeholders<br />
and partners to collaborate with on srhr issues.<br />
It is also important to support and promote dialogue among<br />
various actors and stakeholders in different ways, for example<br />
between governments, parliamentarians, multilateral organisations,<br />
civil society, as well as stakeholders in the private business<br />
sector.<br />
Sensitivity and cultural competence<br />
Understanding the political and cultural situation in which<br />
the embassy, mission, Sida or mfa department works and in<br />
which the dialogue will be carried out is essential to be able to<br />
pursue a credible and effective dialogue to help promote change<br />
from within a society. It is necessary to be respectful and to<br />
understand the srhr issues that are important, for whom they<br />
are important, as well as to determine which issues should be<br />
prioritised and with whom to engage in dialogue with respect<br />
to those issues.<br />
It is not always possible to discuss srhr issues in the same<br />
way and using the same terms and concepts we have become<br />
used to using in Sweden. Advocating what other people may<br />
regard as being an extreme and inflexible srhr policy position<br />
could result in unmanageable conflicts resulting in counterproductive<br />
polarisation and locked positions.<br />
By spending time to familiarise oneself with and preparing<br />
dialogue using language that is adapted to the cultural context,<br />
unnecessary controversy can be avoided and constructive<br />
dialogue promoted. This does not mean that you should<br />
compromise on Sweden’s positions on srhr. It is quite simply<br />
about communicating with your counterpart. The important<br />
thing is to choose your words carefully and ‘package’ arguments<br />
well, based on factual knowledge and an understanding of your<br />
counterpart’s reasoning and point of view.<br />
10
Checklist for dialogue<br />
Here is a checklist of the issues with respect to a number of<br />
policy areas that can help when building up arguments and<br />
knowledge. They can also serve as effective entry points for a<br />
dialogue on sexual and reproductive health and rights.<br />
International and regional agreements and commitments are<br />
the main starting points for dialogue. It is important to find out<br />
which international and regional agreements the country has<br />
ratified, any reservations it has registered, and the content of<br />
srhr in any of the country’s national reports to the monitoring<br />
committees of the human rights conventions, as well as the committees’<br />
conclusions and recommendations.<br />
Important sources of information can, of course, also be<br />
found in the Swedish embassies’ reports on human rights.<br />
Suggestions regarding general questions:<br />
• What is the content of national legislation or the national<br />
policy framework for the health sector or other relevant sectors<br />
with regard to srhr?<br />
• How are issues dealt with that have a bearing on maternal<br />
health, women’s access to safe abortions or young people’s<br />
access to contraception in these documents and frameworks?<br />
Areas of national policy to<br />
look at in relation to SRHR:<br />
Human rights<br />
• How are human rights instruments and commitments conformed<br />
with?<br />
• How about the rights of women? men? children? lgbt people?<br />
persons with disabilities?<br />
Legal frameworks and access to justice<br />
• Is the rule of law observed, i.e. are the legal rights of individuals<br />
respected?<br />
• How are violence and other crimes against women dealt with<br />
in the context of national legislation?<br />
• Are there laws that regulate consensual sexual activity<br />
between adults?<br />
• What is the legislation like regarding abortion? the use of<br />
contraception? maternal health?<br />
• What legislation exists for the protection and promotion of<br />
children’s rights? sexual crimes? regarding the rights and living<br />
conditions of lgbt persons?<br />
• What is the national age of majority? the legal age of sexual<br />
consent? Is there any legislation directly addressing discrimination<br />
or laws that regulate communicable disease prevention, for<br />
example, for people living with hiv and aids?<br />
Gender equality<br />
• What is the minimum age for marriage by law?<br />
• Do women have the right to divorce?<br />
• Do women have the right to own land? to inherit?<br />
• Are there laws regulating men’s responsibility for their<br />
children?<br />
• Laws regarding violence against women?<br />
Education<br />
• Is sexuality education allowed in schools and if so, what is its<br />
content?<br />
• Can condoms be distributed in schools and other public arenas?<br />
• What is the situation like for girls who become pregnant while<br />
they are still in school?<br />
Health<br />
• Do young people have access to contraception advice? confidential<br />
testing for sexually transmitted infections?<br />
• Are there different kinds of contraception to choose from?<br />
• What costs are associated with sexual and reproductive health<br />
care?<br />
• What is the situation like regarding access to contraceptive<br />
supplies, for example condoms?<br />
Public opinion, media, politicians?<br />
• Are srhr issues discussed in the media?<br />
• Which ministers deal with these issues and how do they do<br />
this?<br />
• Who officially defends these issues?<br />
• Who opposes these issues?<br />
• What is support in parliament like for various srhr issues?<br />
• Is there support among stakeholders in civil society and in<br />
local communities?<br />
11
• What point or points of view do different key stakeholders<br />
have nationally, regionally and locally?<br />
• Who has formal and informal power in society?<br />
• What role do the following play: Religious leaders?<br />
Local community leaders? Traditional leaders? Parliament?<br />
Media? Women’s organisations and networks? Certain individual<br />
men or women or groups? Human rights defenders and<br />
other associations in civil society?<br />
Attitudes and positions of international actors?<br />
• What is support like among other EU member states?<br />
• What attitudes do international stakeholders such as other<br />
countries in the donor community have?<br />
• What donors or multilateral stakeholders are active in the<br />
health sector, education sector, in the human rights area or<br />
other relevant sectors? What are their positions and bases for<br />
dialogue?<br />
• What dialogue issues have they identified?<br />
• Considering these, are there ways in which we can strengthen<br />
each other’s dialogue more effectively?<br />
• Are there like-minded donors involved in contexts where<br />
Sweden is not represented and if so, can we influence them?<br />
12
Thematic issues<br />
This section presents the eight thematic issues that the<br />
Swedish Government prioritises most highly in its work to<br />
protect and promote sexual and reproductive health and<br />
rights. These thematic issues are extremely relevant for<br />
srhr and development, but are also often controversial and<br />
sensitive, and particularly tricky to handle in dialogues due<br />
to their complexity, and the fact that they are emotionallycharged<br />
in many places in the world. These thematic issues are<br />
also closely related in many ways, which means that dialogue<br />
around one of the issues can often create an opening for<br />
discussion on other srhr issues.<br />
Each section consists of a short background based on<br />
Sweden’s position, key message, and basic information in<br />
the form of facts and figures, suggestions for entry points<br />
for dialogue, as well as examples of frequently occurring<br />
assertions and suggestions on how to address them. The<br />
thematic sections can be used separately or in combination.<br />
There is no inherent priority in the order in which they are<br />
presented here. Each mfa-department, embassy, mission, Sidaofficer<br />
or other representatives of Sweden must themselves<br />
assess the prevailing conditions and specific contexts within<br />
which the dialogue is to place, in order to decide which issues<br />
should be prioritised.<br />
13
Maternal mortality and the work<br />
to achieve Millennium Development Goal 5<br />
The link between improved maternal health and poverty reduction<br />
is very clear. Reducing maternal mortality is therefore<br />
one of the most central development issues. un Millennium<br />
Development Goal 5 aims directly to improve maternal health<br />
by reducing the maternal mortality ratio by three quarters by<br />
2015 through, inter alia universal access to reproductive health.<br />
Why is Sweden working to improve maternal<br />
health and reduce maternal mortality?<br />
Most pregnant women living in poverty or in poor countries<br />
run significant health risks in connection with pregnancy,<br />
childbirth or post-partum care after childbirth. This situation<br />
persists despite the existence of special international initiatives<br />
and actions that have been carried out to safeguard women’s<br />
health for more than 20 years. The reasons for the high maternal<br />
mortality ratio in global terms include the lack of access<br />
to adequate obstetric care, and complications following unsafe<br />
abortions. 2 Currently Millennium Development Goal 5 is the<br />
goal that is furthest from being achieved.<br />
On 17 June 2009, the UN Human Rights Council adopted<br />
the resolution, ‘Preventable maternal mortality and morbidity<br />
and human rights’. 3 This resolution points out that the high<br />
rates of maternal mortality can be prevented and that they<br />
represent a violation of women’s rights. Countries have not done<br />
enough to eradicate maternal mortality and prevent injuries<br />
resulting from pregnancy and childbirth. This resolution therefore<br />
represents an important step in establishing the extent<br />
of the scope of political responsibility, from having regarded<br />
maternal mortality as being first and foremost a health issue, to<br />
recognition that it is also an issue of ensuring women’s rights.<br />
Entry points for dialogue on<br />
actions to reduce maternal mortality<br />
Dialogue on improved maternal health is about demonstrating<br />
the important links between development, women’s health and<br />
fundamental human rights. This dialogue must also highlight<br />
the benefits and cost-effectiveness of investing in advisory services,<br />
contraception, safe abortions, combating female genital<br />
mutilation, trained midwives and better access to good quality<br />
care in connection with pregnancy and childbirth.<br />
• Some progress has been made in recent years but hundreds<br />
of thousands of women still die every year from<br />
pregnancy-related causes and as many as 8.7 million women<br />
suffer infections from childbirth every year. 4 Complications<br />
from pregnancy or childbirth are a leading cause of death for<br />
girls between the ages of 15 and 19.<br />
• Women who give birth to their first child after the age of<br />
20 and have not been subjected to genital mutilation run a<br />
much lower risk of suffering from fatal complications and<br />
infections. This also applies to women who receive information<br />
and advisory services before childbirth, and who during<br />
delivery have access to trained health care workers who are<br />
equipped to handle difficult births with complications.<br />
• 74 percent of maternal mortality can be combated through<br />
access to trained healthcare workers, clinics with sterile and<br />
adequate equipment, and advisory services for pregnant<br />
women. 5 According to the World Health Organisation, more<br />
than 700,000 midwives are needed in the world to be able to<br />
achieve Millennium Development Goal 5 for reduced maternal<br />
mortality. The important role and professional skills of<br />
midwives must be highlighted and strengthened, and more<br />
midwives who are equipped with sufficient competence must<br />
be trained. 6<br />
• More than one third of all maternal mortality in the world<br />
takes place in situations characterised by conflict, postconflict<br />
or crisis. In humanitarian crises, there is often a lack<br />
of access to contraceptives, maternity care and emergency<br />
obstetric and childbirth care.<br />
• More than 70,000 women die every year and millions suffer<br />
serious and even debilitating injuries from unsafe abortions,<br />
placing a major burden on health care systems in many<br />
developing countries. 7 Access to safe and legal abortions is<br />
essential for reducing these figures.<br />
One important entry point for dialogue on this issue is a given<br />
country’s own work on achieving un Millennium Development<br />
Goal 5 about improving maternal health. The two sub-targets of<br />
reducing maternal mortality by 75 percent by 2015 and universal<br />
access to reproductive health are both central in this context.<br />
The dialogue can also be based on the un Convention on the<br />
Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women<br />
(cedaw) which obliges states to remove all discriminatory<br />
14
Sweden’s position and key message: Reducing global maternal<br />
mortality is essential and a prerequisite for the achievement<br />
of several of the un’s Millennium Development Goals, such<br />
as eradicating poverty and reducing child mortality. Sweden<br />
believes that good maternal health is strongly linked to general<br />
issues of gender equality and women’s empowerment and<br />
ability to fully exercise and enjoy their human rights.<br />
measures that can make it difficult for women to gain access to<br />
health care, including family planning. States must also ensure<br />
that women have access to health care during pregnancy, during<br />
childbirth and after delivery (Article 12).<br />
Women’s reproductive health is also protected by the un<br />
Convention on the Rights of the Child. States need to ensure<br />
a satisfactory level of health care for mothers both before and<br />
after childbirth in order to safeguard the child’s right to enjoy<br />
the highest attainable standard of health (Article 24 (2) (d)).<br />
Issues about women’s rights with regard to health must be<br />
integrated into all social sectors as well as in humanitarian<br />
emergencies and crisis situations. In September 2009 the World<br />
Health Organisation and unfpa identified the need to integrate<br />
sexual and reproductive health into the humanitarian work<br />
being carried out in crisis situations. 8<br />
The health system is very weak in many developing countries,<br />
particularly in terms of infrastructure and health care workers.<br />
Many efforts to improve these health systems are specific to certain<br />
diseases and major resources have been directed at, for example,<br />
the treatment of hiv, malaria and tuberculosis. This can have<br />
an impact on the financing and planning of reproductive health.<br />
Development funding is increasingly being provided through<br />
budget support, sector support and other coordinated mechanisms.<br />
It is then particularly important that the reporting and<br />
monitoring of efforts to reduce maternal mortality and promote<br />
maternal health is rendered visible through the use of relevant<br />
tools and indicators. Representatives of finance ministries can<br />
be suitable dialogue partners in this regard. However, they<br />
often have limited in-depth knowledge and understanding of<br />
social sector issues. Swedish embassies and missions abroad<br />
can play an important role in creating openings and arenas for<br />
dialogue on budget and sector support by organising meetings<br />
between finance ministries and the ministries responsible for,<br />
for example, health, gender equality and youth issues. The un<br />
Population Fund unfpa and Guttmacher Institute have produced<br />
regular reports since 2003 about the costs and benefits of<br />
investing in sexual and reproductive health. The most recent<br />
report focuses on maternal health: Adding it up – The Costs<br />
and Benefits of investing in Family Planning and Maternal<br />
and Newborn Health (December 2009). This information can<br />
be used as a basis for budget dialogues with finance and other<br />
line ministers.<br />
A number of frequently heard assertions on<br />
women’s rights and health are presented below,<br />
along with suggestions on how to address them:<br />
“We cannot prioritise everything. Hunger, access to<br />
clean water and conflict resolution are quite simply<br />
more important than maternal health when looking<br />
at what people need.”<br />
There is in fact a great deal of evidence to show that investments<br />
in women leads to less hunger and fewer conflicts. The<br />
former un Secretary-General Kofi Annan pointed out as early<br />
as 2002 that challenges surrounding population issues and<br />
reproductive health have to be resolved if we are to tackle the<br />
other Millennium Development Goals, particularly the fight<br />
against hunger and extreme poverty. 9 A long succession of<br />
experts have also pointed out the strong links between a high<br />
number of births, a lack of respect for women’s and girls’ rights<br />
and poor maternal health and poverty. In other words, it is<br />
important to increase investments in maternal health in order<br />
to achieve the Millennium Development Goals. Investing in<br />
better maternal health also reduces a country’s health care costs<br />
as a whole, which could allow resources to be freed up for other<br />
important purposes.<br />
In many cases, it is women who support their families and<br />
who make sure that their children receive food, water and<br />
schooling. The health and education of families are often based<br />
on the efforts of girls and women, which is why their health is<br />
so important.<br />
“It does not pay to invest in women.”<br />
According to the World Bank, family planning and childbirth<br />
care are two of the six most cost-effective measures that lowincome<br />
and medium-income countries can take in the health<br />
sector. 10 Investing in the health and rights of young women is<br />
particularly important, and can have major positive effects on<br />
poverty reduction and development.<br />
The use of contraceptives promotes economic development.<br />
Studies from organisations such as Guttmacher Institute and<br />
15
unfpa show clearly that investing in contraception, advisory<br />
services and maternal health can significantly reduce public<br />
expenditure on health care and other social services. 11<br />
It is possible to reduce maternal mortality. Many countries<br />
have achieved this. For example, maternal mortality has fallen<br />
considerably in countries like Cuba, Egypt, Malaysia, Sri Lanka,<br />
Thailand and Tunisia. In all of these countries, investments have<br />
been made to improve women’s access to reproductive health<br />
care, skilled birth attendants and better conditions for emergency<br />
childbirth care. 12<br />
“In our culture, women should marry young.”<br />
Work against early marriage is not work against the institution<br />
of marriage in itself. We know that women who marry later in<br />
life are in a better position to be educated, suffer fewer complications<br />
from pregnancy and run a lower risk of suffering from<br />
sexually-transmitted infections and hiv and aids. 13 Changing<br />
traditions surrounding early marriage and starting a family of<br />
one’s own therefore plays an important role in the fight against<br />
poverty and maternal mortality.<br />
Families can gain a lot by allowing girls to get an education<br />
instead of being married off early, as they will be better equipped<br />
to secure a more qualified and better paid job, which will means<br />
they will better able to contribute to the family’s income.<br />
Experiences from the field<br />
Bangladesh is one of the poorest and most densely populated<br />
countries in the world. In Bangladesh there is a form of<br />
surgical abortion, ‘menstrual regulation’, that is permitted up<br />
to the ninth week of pregnancy. Rates of maternal mortality<br />
has fallen as access to menstrual regulation has increased.<br />
This provides a good basis for Sweden to further develop<br />
the dialogue and to show the positive effects on women’s<br />
health. Sweden’s support in Bangladesh is aimed at reducing<br />
maternal mortality, and Sida works in-country with other<br />
stakeholders, such as the Netherlands, the United Kingdom,<br />
WHO and UNFPA.<br />
The dialogue in Bangladesh around abortion and maternal<br />
mortality has been based on demonstrating the links between<br />
women’s health and unsafe abortions, which are responsible<br />
for a large proportion of maternal mortality. This dialogue has<br />
proved successful because menstrual regulation is permitted<br />
and accepted. Through its development cooperation in Bangladesh,<br />
Sweden has established itself as a recognised voice<br />
for maternal health and SRHR. The work of the embassy<br />
is based on the laws in Bangladesh as well as the policy<br />
documents that have been adopted by the government. The<br />
dialogue thus links Swedish viewpoints and positions to these<br />
frameworks.<br />
2. Ministry for Foreign Affairs, Sveriges internationella politik för sexuell och<br />
reproduktiv hälsa och rättigheter, p. 20 (2006).<br />
3. Human rights council Eleventh session Agenda item 3, Resolution 11/8.<br />
4. unfpa, No Woman Should Die Giving Life (2008).<br />
5. unfpa, Giving Girls Today and Tomorrow. Breaking the cycle of adolescent<br />
pregnancy (2007).<br />
6. who, Fact sheet who/mps/08.11 Skilled birth attendants (2008).<br />
7. who, Unsafe abortion, 5a. edición (2007); ippf, Death and Denial – Unsafe<br />
Abortion and Poverty (2006).<br />
8. unfpa, who, Granada Consensus on Sexual and reproductive health in protaracted<br />
crises and recovery (2009).<br />
9. Bernstein, S & Juul Hansen, C, Public Choices, Private Decisions: Sexual and<br />
Reproductive Health and the Millennium Development Goals (2006).<br />
10. The Alan Guttmacher Institute, & unfpa, Adding it up. The benefits of<br />
investing in sexual and reproductive health care (2003).<br />
11. Guttmacher Institute & unfpa, In Brief Series, No.5 (2008).<br />
12. unfpa, No woman should die giving life (2008).<br />
13. unfpa, State of the World Population (2005).<br />
16
Access to safe abortions<br />
One central dimension for ensuring that women are able to<br />
enjoy their human rights is the extent to which they can make<br />
decisions about their own body, sexuality and childbearing.<br />
All human rights and fundamental freedoms apply to women<br />
as they do to men. Women’s right – on a basis of equality of<br />
men and women – to decide when they want to have children is<br />
ensured through the un Convention on the Elimination of All<br />
Forms of Discrimination Against Women (cedaw). Women’s<br />
possibilities to claim and exercise this right is linked to and<br />
requires access to contraception in order to avoid unwanted<br />
pregnancies and prevent abortions.<br />
Why will Sweden persevere in this work and actively<br />
defend women’s access to safe and legal abortions?<br />
Unsafe abortions are carried out because of the lack of opportunities<br />
to prevent unwanted pregnancies. Of the 46 million<br />
abortions that are carried out every year, 78 percent are in<br />
developing countries. 14 Many of them are performed on girls<br />
and young women and in situations where access to sexuality<br />
education, advisory services and contraception is limited. An<br />
unwanted pregnancy often leads to a young girl being expelled<br />
from school, losing the opportunity for education and work, and<br />
running the risk of being socially stigmatised. In desperation,<br />
many young girls choose to undergo an unsafe abortion, which<br />
can cost them their lives or seriously injure them. Unsafe abortions<br />
are mainly carried out in countries where access to safe<br />
abortions is limited by legislation or other factors.<br />
Entry points for dialogue on safe abortion<br />
Maternal mortality rates among women and girls linked to<br />
pregnancy and childbirth are so high in some countries that<br />
they can be classified as constituting a public health problem.<br />
The right to abortion is not explicitly set out in any of the<br />
un conventions on human rights. However, the committees<br />
that monitor the application of these conventions have often<br />
found that several of women’s rights are threatened when<br />
their access to safe and legal abortion is restricted. States<br />
have therefore been recommended to review and amend<br />
their legislation to increase the opportunities for women to<br />
have access to safe abortions and to ensure that women who<br />
undergo an illegal abortion do not risk legal repercussions,<br />
including prison sentences.<br />
The Human Rights Committee and the cedaw Committee<br />
have made a connection between unsafe and illegal abortions<br />
and the right to life. The Committee on Economic, Social and<br />
Cultural Rights has also pointed out on many occasions that the<br />
right to health is also threatened when restrictions are placed<br />
on access to abortion and/or where abortions are unsafe.<br />
The Programme of Action from icpd does not contain any reference<br />
to the right to abortion. It states that abortion should not<br />
be promoted as a method of family planning, and that prevention<br />
of unwanted pregnancies to eliminate the need for abortion<br />
must be given the highest priority. It also states that when<br />
abortion is legal, it must be safe and women must always have<br />
access to the services that are needed to treat complications that<br />
can arise following an abortion (PoA 8.25). The five-year review<br />
of icpd stresses that unsafe abortions represent a public health<br />
problem. The Platform for Action from the Fourth Conference<br />
on Women in Beijing also encourages states to re-examine laws<br />
that punish women who have an abortion (106 (k)).<br />
Regional instruments can be an important starting point<br />
for dialogue on safe abortion. In July 2003 the African Union<br />
adopted ‘The Protocol to the African Charter on Human and<br />
Peoples’ Rights on the Rights of Women in Africa’. This regional<br />
instrument sets out the African states’ obligation to provide<br />
legal and safe abortion when a pregnancy is a result of a sexual<br />
assault, where the mental or physical health of the woman is<br />
threatened or when the woman’s or foetus’s life is in danger<br />
(Article 14 (2) (c)).<br />
The au’s Africa Health Strategy 2007–2015 was adopted in<br />
Johannesburg in April 2007, and stresses the importance of a<br />
holistic approach to important issues, such as maternal mortality,<br />
including as a result of unsafe abortions.<br />
Sweden’s position on access to abortion is considered to be<br />
an extreme standpoint by several other countries, so it can be<br />
strategic and fruitful to initiate discussions about abortion<br />
using arguments that are based on health, gender equality and<br />
the work of countries to achieve the un Millennium Development<br />
Goals, particularly goals 3, 4 and 5.<br />
In most countries, entry points can perhaps be created<br />
18
Sweden’s position and key message: Access to safe and legal<br />
abortion falls within the framework of human rights, is<br />
important to reduce maternal mortality and is a part of the<br />
work to fulfil commitments to realise the right to health.<br />
• Maternal mortality remains high in developing countries.<br />
Of the women who die every year as because of complications<br />
relating to pregnancy and childbirth, approximately<br />
13 percent die as a result of unsafe and illegal abortions. In<br />
addition almost five million women are seriously injured as a<br />
result of unsafe abortions every year. 15<br />
• 90 percent of these deaths and injuries can be prevented<br />
by simply increasing access to contraception. 16 Between<br />
1995 and 2003 the number of safe abortions fell from 25.6<br />
million to 21.9 million, while the number of unsafe abortions<br />
only fell from 19.9 million to 19.7 million. 17<br />
• In some countries women who have had abortions are<br />
criminalised. This contributes to great suffering among<br />
women, many of whom are often very young, who incur complications<br />
resulting from an unsafe abortion. Unsafe abortions<br />
are also a major economic problem for national health<br />
budgets, and often burden the local health sector by taking<br />
up a large proportion of health care resources. 18<br />
• There are only a handful of countries in the world in which<br />
abortions are totally prohibited and not permitted no matter<br />
what the reason. 19<br />
in connection with discussions on the connections between<br />
abortion legislation, women’s access to and knowledge about<br />
safe abortions and improved public health. It is also important<br />
to know as much as you can about the legislation regarding<br />
abortion in a given country, as well as how it is enforced and<br />
whether or not ordinary people are aware of it. It might then<br />
be possible to discover ways to strengthen progressive forces<br />
within the health system and civil society that want to increase<br />
accessibility, or strengthen organisations that work with providing<br />
information about the law and/or that make demands on<br />
authorities to provide the services that they are bound by law<br />
to make available.<br />
Demonstrating the links between maternal mortality and<br />
unsafe abortions is an important entry point to dialogue on<br />
abortion. Most countries want to reduce the high number of<br />
women and girls who die as a result of complications in connection<br />
with pregnancy and childbirth. Unsafe abortions represent<br />
around 13 percent of maternal mortality globally, but<br />
in many countries in Sub-Saharan Africa this figure is as high<br />
as 30–40 percent. 20 Providing access to safe abortion is therefore<br />
an essential part of the work to reduce maternal mortality.<br />
Supporting women’s access to safe abortion reduces health<br />
care costs and represents an important factor in the work to<br />
realise the right to health for everyone. Studies show that costs<br />
of maternal ill-health for hospital beds, blood banks, surgical<br />
procedures, antibiotics and other medicines, as well as doctors<br />
and other health care workers far exceed the costs of providing<br />
safe abortion. Adolescents, and poor and young women<br />
are those who mainly have no other recourse than to undergo<br />
unsafe abortions. Women from other social classes may often<br />
be able to seek out and pay for a safe abortion. This means<br />
that the consequences of unsafe abortions mostly affect poor<br />
women, which means that the issue of abortion is also an issue<br />
of poverty, justice and social equality.<br />
Experiences from Sweden’s embassies and missions abroad<br />
show that abortion is an extremely sensitive issue that must<br />
be dealt with in a strategic manner. One important entry point<br />
for dialogue can be to begin by discussing it with like-minded<br />
bodies, and by carefully highlighting experiences from Sweden’s<br />
own development, where so much has changed since the middle<br />
of the 20th century. This dialogue should highlight the links<br />
between access to safe abortion and access to contraceptives to<br />
prevent unwanted pregnancies, and the positive consequences<br />
this has on public health.<br />
A number of frequently heard assertions<br />
on abortion are presented below, along with<br />
suggestions on how to address them:<br />
“Women suffer psychological<br />
damage as a result of having an abortion.”<br />
Studies show that having an abortion is not a simple decision<br />
for women who decide to terminate a pregnancy. Most<br />
women who become pregnant at a difficult stage in their lives<br />
can feel desperation, grief or anxiety. When abortions are<br />
legal, women are able to process their feelings with the help of<br />
counselling services.<br />
The criminalisation of abortion leads to feelings of shame,<br />
fear and anxiety. It also makes it difficult for women to<br />
seek counselling in order to process their feelings, and to<br />
19
seek hospital care if complications do arise as a result of an<br />
illegal abortion.<br />
“Abortion is murder, a sin and immoral.”<br />
Using arguments such as that it is the woman herself who has<br />
the right to decide about her own body and therefore to have<br />
an abortion (which is in line with the Swedish model) can be<br />
counterproductive in a discussion with someone who thinks<br />
that abortion is murder and should be penalized. It can be<br />
more fruitful to discuss whether it is reasonable and acceptable<br />
that women die of unsafe abortions, and that they are<br />
considered to be criminals because they have had an abortion.<br />
One of the serious health consequences of denying women<br />
abortions is the fact that women instead use life-threatening<br />
methods, including taking hazardous substances, in order to<br />
provoke a spontaneous abortion or miscarriage, thereby risking<br />
premature death or disability.<br />
“Abortion not only affects the woman,<br />
but also society as a whole.”<br />
Yes, since women in most societies are the ones who look after<br />
and bring up children, it is often they who make the everyday<br />
decisions that affect their family’s health. It should be the<br />
woman herself who decides whether she wants to proceed with<br />
the pregnancy. Women are also very well aware of how their<br />
reproductive choices affect their family and whether, for example,<br />
how having more children will affect the family.<br />
The consequences of illegal and unsafe abortion are reflected<br />
in high levels of maternal deaths and suffering, and costs in<br />
terms of health care resources and lower rates of economic<br />
growth at both local and national level than would otherwise be<br />
the case.<br />
“Introducing free abortion is<br />
a Western idea, new colonialism.”<br />
Women throughout history and in all regions have chosen to<br />
terminate pregnancies when they have felt compelled to do so,<br />
irrespective of whether it has been illegal or legal. The vast<br />
majority of all injuries and deaths which occur as a result of<br />
unsafe abortions are not carried out in the West, but in developing<br />
countries where abortion is strictly regulated by law or is<br />
illegal, or where there is poor access to safe abortions. In such<br />
countries there tends also to be a high unmet need for contraceptives<br />
and family planning, especially among the poorest<br />
people, adolescents and young women. It is important to note<br />
that in order to effectively address statements and arguments<br />
such as this one, it is important to have a good understanding<br />
about the country’s abortion legislation in order to determine<br />
what possible entry points exist and can be used to open up<br />
discussion in this area.<br />
“Abortion leads to social decline and destruction of society.”<br />
The decision to have an abortion, irrespective of how safe and<br />
legal it is, is not a decision that a woman makes lightly; it is a<br />
decision she takes when she feels it is necessary or feels that she<br />
does not have any other choice. If unwanted pregnancies are to<br />
be prevented, the most effective way is to ensure that women<br />
have access to information about sexual and reproductive<br />
health, contraception and family planning, and that they have<br />
the opportunity to make decisions about their own sexuality.<br />
Prevention of unwanted pregnancies also requires that men<br />
must be encouraged to assume their responsibility.<br />
A common argument used to attack those who defend access<br />
to legal and safe abortions is to accuse them of being active<br />
abortionists or of advocating that abortions be used as contraception<br />
and method of family planning. Rather than call oneself<br />
an advocate for abortion, it is better to present oneself as a<br />
supporter of women’s right to choose and to work to ensure<br />
that those who want and need to are ensure of access to safe<br />
abortion services and care in case of complications.<br />
“Men should also have a say when it comes to abortion.”<br />
The woman is the person who becomes pregnant and is normally<br />
the one who has the primary responsibility of looking<br />
after the child, irrespective of the circumstances under which<br />
she became pregnant, her living conditions, or her capacity and<br />
ability to take care of a child. She should therefore be able to<br />
decide herself whether she wants to go through with a pregnancy<br />
or not. Of course, the man in question has the right to<br />
give his opinion (if he is known and this is possible), but in the<br />
20
end, the decision is one that must be taken by the woman herself<br />
based on her assessment of her situation and her options.<br />
Experiences from the field<br />
Zambia has relatively liberal abortion legislation, but one of<br />
the main problems is the fact that people do not know about<br />
this legislation, not even health care workers. Meetings with a<br />
large number of stakeholders who work with this issue have<br />
been important to make multilaterals in particular aware<br />
of the fact that there is a legal basis for working with safe<br />
abortions.<br />
In Uganda abortions are prohibited, but the officer there<br />
has brought the issue up in discussions with other likeminded<br />
stakeholders. In so doing however, they stress the<br />
importance of caution, due to political sensitivity and the risk<br />
of a backlash.<br />
SRHR issues have been very topical, but also extremely<br />
difficult to pursue within the framework of sector support<br />
in Central America. The issue of abortion has been particularly<br />
difficult and, according to an officer at the embassy in<br />
Nicaragua, there is more to be gained by simply not highlighting<br />
the abortion issue as an separate issue, but to put it<br />
into a context, e.g. by linking it to long-term prevention work<br />
and sexuality education at school, as well as to show the<br />
economic consequences for a society that does not invest in<br />
SRHR.<br />
14. ippf, Death and denial (2006).<br />
15. who, Unsafe abortion, Fifth edition (2007).<br />
16. unfpa, No Woman Should Die Giving Life (2008).<br />
17. Guttmacher Institute, Abortion worldwide. A decade of uneven progress (2009).<br />
18. rfsu, Breaking Through. A guide to sexual and reproductive health and rights<br />
(2004).<br />
19. E.g. Chile, El Salvador, Malta and Nicaragua.<br />
20. unfpa, Healthy expectations. Celebrating achievements of the Cairo<br />
Consensus and highlighting the urgency for action (2009).<br />
21
Young people and SRHR<br />
More than half of the world’s population is under 25, and in<br />
several developing countries, young people make up between<br />
50 percent and 60 percent of the population. Half of them live<br />
in poverty or extreme poverty. A record high generation of<br />
young people find themselves at a time in their lives when they<br />
are shaping their existence, planning their futures, learning<br />
to stand on their own two feet, and becoming sexually active.<br />
However, in many countries the practice of transferring positive<br />
traditional knowledge of sexuality has been lost. Consequently<br />
many young people lack access to correct information, the<br />
knowledge and the means to protect themselves against sexually<br />
transmitted diseases including hiv, and unintended pregnancies.<br />
Why is Sweden working to promote young people’s<br />
sexual and reproductive health and rights?<br />
Young women and men are not only recipients of health care<br />
and information, they are also active stakeholders in society who<br />
have the right and ability to be involved in decisions that affect<br />
their lives. Focusing on young women and men is also important<br />
for the promotion of gender equality. 21<br />
If young women and men are to be able to make informed<br />
decisions about their lives, they must have access to knowledge<br />
and information both about their sexuality as well as<br />
methods of avoiding risky behaviour such as unsafe sex. In all<br />
countries, social norms and values determine what attitudes<br />
to young people’s sexuality and gender identity prevail in the<br />
society. These norms have consequences for young people’s<br />
room to manoeuvre and ability to act and when it comes to<br />
the possibilities at their disposal to express their sexuality,<br />
and to protect themselves from sexually transmitted diseases<br />
and unwanted pregnancies.<br />
Entry points for dialogue on young people and SRHR<br />
Work to promote young women’s and men’s sexual and reproductive<br />
health and rights cannot be seen as an isolated issue.<br />
It is closely interrelated with young people’s living conditions,<br />
life prospects and position in society in general. As previously<br />
mentioned, a very large proportion, often close to half, of the<br />
total population in many developing countries is under 25<br />
years old. At the same time, their de facto social and political<br />
position in society are often weak. Young people often do<br />
not have a say or any influence in society and its development.<br />
This is particularly true for young people living in conditions<br />
of poverty and deprivation. It is therefore important to involve<br />
both young people and adults in an intergenerational dialogue<br />
in order to reach a common understanding of each other’s<br />
needs, challenges and potential.<br />
There is a great deal of resistance to the idea of young people<br />
making independent decisions about their bodies, sexuality<br />
and reproduction, and when it comes to their being sexually<br />
active outside the socially recognised forms of marital union<br />
that exist in various societies. In many societies, leaders and<br />
decision-makers advocate sexual abstinence and fidelity in marriage<br />
as the only alternative for sexual expression, particularly<br />
for women. They therefore believe that information on sexuality<br />
and access to condoms and contraception are unnecessary and a<br />
threat to public order.<br />
• Early marriage for girls is regarded in many societies as<br />
a way of achieving better social and financial life circumstances.<br />
However, early marriage is itself actually closely<br />
related to poverty. Postponing marriage to later in life<br />
increases young women’s opportunities for education and<br />
work. 22 Pregnancy at a young age is also associated with serious<br />
health risks and contributes to the cycle of maternal and<br />
childhood mortality. Some progress has been made, but the<br />
UN calculates that in the next decade 100 million girls will be<br />
married off before they reach the age of 18 years. 23<br />
• 45 percent of people over the age of 15 who are infected<br />
with HIV are currently between 15 and 24 years old and the<br />
vast majority live in developing countries. 24 Young women are<br />
particularly affected.<br />
• Adolescent girls aged 15 –19 account for an estimated 14%<br />
of all unsafe abortions in the developing world, and 25% of<br />
all unsafe abortions in Sub-Saharan African countries. 25<br />
Children and young people up to the age of 18 are covered<br />
by the Convention on the Rights of the Child. Article 24 of<br />
the Convention on the Rights of the Child deals with the<br />
child’s right to enjoy the highest attainable standard of health<br />
and the right to health care services and rehabilitation. One of<br />
the areas that is highlighted in particular is states’ obligation<br />
23
Experiences from the field<br />
According to a programme officer at the embassy in Lusaka,<br />
to give more weight to argumentation in dialogue on young<br />
people and SRHR, there is much to be gained by using<br />
materials and statistics from, for example, UNFPA and WHO.<br />
Information from UN bodies or research can provide more<br />
credibility than referring only to Sweden’s experiences and<br />
position.<br />
An official at the embassy in Maputo, where Sweden has<br />
supported a UNFPA-led project on the sexual and reproductive<br />
health of young people, confirms the importance of<br />
the choice of dialogue channel. This project also proved to<br />
be a good forum for dialogue on sexuality education, family<br />
planning, abortion, HIV and young people. According to<br />
this official, UN bodies are considered to have better local<br />
support than the development cooperation offices bodies of<br />
individual donor countries.<br />
to work to develop preventive health care, parental guidance,<br />
as well as education on and help with family planning and<br />
other reproductive choices (Article 24.2 (f)).<br />
The Committee on the Rights of the Child monitors states’<br />
adherence to the convention and interprets its content. In a general<br />
comment on the health and development of young people 26<br />
the Committee states that young people may not be discriminated<br />
against in the enjoyment of their rights as a result of their<br />
sexual orientation or their health status (which includes hiv<br />
and aids) and that a minimum age for sexual self-determination<br />
and medical treatment without the parents’ consent should be<br />
introduced into law. The recommended minimum age for marriage<br />
is 18 years.<br />
The Committee on the Rights of the Child also maintains<br />
that states, based on the principle of the child’s best interest,<br />
his or her right to access to information and his or her<br />
right to health, must provide young people with information<br />
about sexuality and reproduction, including contraception, hiv<br />
prevention and how to avoid being infected with other sexually<br />
transmitted infections. States are encouraged to allow<br />
young people to play an active role themselves in producing<br />
and spreading information. It is also recommended that states<br />
develop programmes to provide access to sexual and reproductive<br />
health care services, including contraception and to safe<br />
abortion where this is legal (see the thematic sheet on access to<br />
safe abortion).<br />
The icpd’s Programme of Action contains several formulations<br />
that highlight the link between young people and srhr. It<br />
stresses that young people must be involved in the planning,<br />
implementation and assessment of activities that relate to<br />
sexual and reproductive health (PoA 6.15). It also maintains<br />
that states must work to ensure that young people’s access to<br />
services and information is not constrained, and that governments<br />
must protect and promote young people’s right to<br />
sexuality education, information and health services (PoA<br />
7.45–46). The follow-up document, ‘Key Actions’, emphasises<br />
the fact that these services (which also include counselling)<br />
must protect young people’s rights to privacy, discretion and<br />
informed consent (icpd + 5 73 (a)).<br />
The Beijing Platform for Action (1995) encourages governments<br />
to meet young people’s needs to ensure that they can<br />
deal with their sexuality in a positive and responsible way<br />
(Beijing Platform for Action 108 (k)). It also includes as a<br />
strategic action, that all barriers to access to formal education<br />
for pregnant adolescents and young mothers should be removed<br />
(Beijing Platform for Action 83 (s)).<br />
The health of young people and their access to education<br />
and information are also a focus for international processes<br />
and initiatives designed for the prevention, care, support and<br />
treatment of hiv/aids such as ungass, and regional instruments<br />
such as the Mexico City Declaration on Sex Education in Latin<br />
America and the Caribbean (2008).<br />
A number of frequently heard assertions on<br />
young people and SRHR are presented below, along<br />
with suggestions on how to address them:<br />
“Sex should only take place within marriage.”<br />
No matter what people think about sexual activity among<br />
young people or outside marriage, it is a fact that young people<br />
search for intimacy and love, and that most of them will<br />
experiment with sex sooner or later. It is therefore important<br />
for young people to be informed about what sexual activity,<br />
what it involves and what emotional or direct consequences it<br />
24
Sweden’s position and key message: Young people must<br />
be guaranteed the right to make decisions about their own<br />
sexuality and given the opportunity to have a responsible,<br />
satisfying and safe sex life, without coercion, violence,<br />
discrimination or the risk of becoming involuntarily<br />
pregnant or being infected with hiv and other sexually<br />
transmitted infections.<br />
can have, in order to allow them to live fulfilling lives and to<br />
be able to make well-informed decisions on marriage and family<br />
formation. If young people know about the various consequences<br />
of being sexually active, it may also strengthen their<br />
ability to protect themselves by saying no to sex when they do<br />
not want it.<br />
“Parents are those who are responsible<br />
for their children, and they know best.”<br />
A young woman cannot make decisions about her education<br />
or gainful employment if she is being subjected to violence or<br />
for other reasons is not given the opportunity to make decisions<br />
about her own sexuality and reproduction. In concrete<br />
terms, it means that young women must be given the opportunity<br />
themselves to decide when they are ready to marry,<br />
have children and the number of children they want to have, as<br />
their decisions also affect their opportunities to continue their<br />
schooling or look after themselves and their families. However,<br />
it is important to acknowledge the fact that granting someone<br />
else this kind of power – in this case a female child, means that<br />
parents lose a measure of their own power and control over her.<br />
It is therefore a good idea to link arguments and suggestions<br />
to something that can be positive for the parents, even though<br />
they lose power over their children. For example, if daughters<br />
are educated instead of marrying early, they can have a profession<br />
and will be better able to contribute to their own and their<br />
family’s well-being.<br />
“We cannot prioritise srhr for young people. Unemployment,<br />
education and water supplies are more important.”<br />
The consequences of not investing in young people’s sexual and<br />
reproductive health and rights also lead to a depletion of valuable<br />
human resources, as well as high costs of health care due<br />
to injuries during childbirth, injuries from unsafe abortions and<br />
the treatment of sexually transmitted diseases, as well as antiretroviral<br />
drugs for young people living with hiv. This also leads<br />
to the society having a lower educated, less qualified workforce,<br />
and an increase in the financial dependency of young people on<br />
their parents and relatives. 27<br />
21. Ministry for Foreign Affairs, Sveriges internationella politik för sexuell och<br />
reproduktiv hälsa och rättigheter (2006), p. 15.<br />
22. undesa, The Millennium Development Goals Report (2008).<br />
23. unfpa, State of the World Population (2005).<br />
24. unaids, 08 Report in the Global Aids Epidemic (2008).<br />
25. Guttmacher Institute, Adding it up – The Costs and Benefits of Investing in<br />
Family Planning and Maternal and Newborn Health (2009).<br />
26. Committee on the Rights of the Child, General comment No. 4, Adolescent<br />
health and development in the context of the Convention on the Rights of the<br />
Child, crc/gc/2003/4, 1 July 2003 (2003).<br />
27. unfpa, Giving girls today and tomorrow. Breaking the cycle of adolescent<br />
pregnancy (2007).<br />
25
Sexuality education<br />
Despite the importance of sexuality education for people’s health<br />
and enjoyment of human rights, it is a controversial topic in many<br />
countries. Public discussions about sexuality, particular in relation<br />
to women’s and young people’s sexuality, are often characterised<br />
by conceptions and norms about perceptions of morality<br />
rather than factual knowledge. Resistance will of course vary<br />
depending on the specific situation, so it is therefore important to<br />
begin by understanding the relevant political and social context.<br />
Why is Sweden working to promote<br />
sexuality education internationally?<br />
Sweden’s point of departure is that sexual and reproductive<br />
ill-health, such as sexually transmitted infections, including hiv<br />
and aids, unwanted pregnancies and unsafe abortions, are due<br />
primarily to the fact that people have limited knowledge and<br />
information about their own bodies, sexuality, sexual intercourse,<br />
relationships and reproduction. Sexuality education is<br />
therefore important to reduce people’s vulnerability in these<br />
respects. Young people are obviously a primary target group for<br />
this work, but it is also important to provide adults with support<br />
and education, and to highlight vulnerable groups that may<br />
have fallen outside of the formal education system. 28<br />
Most children go to school for at least a few years in their<br />
lives and so there is great potential for sexuality education<br />
within the framework of the regular education system. Sexuality<br />
education in schools should be introduced at an early stage,<br />
partly to ensure that as many young people as possible are<br />
reached, and partly because it is more effective if it is given<br />
before young people become sexually active. 29<br />
However, 73 million children in the world do not attend<br />
school, and in developing countries as many as 50 percent do<br />
not receive an equivalent of secondary-school education. 30<br />
Neither have a very high proportion of adults ever received any<br />
sexuality education. Sexuality education is therefore not only a<br />
challenge in terms of improving knowledge among teachers, but<br />
also in terms of the development of educational programmes<br />
that reach out to those outside the formal education system.<br />
Civil society organisations often have a broad contact network<br />
as well as great deal of knowledge and experience in this<br />
respect that could be helpful.<br />
What is sexuality education?<br />
The purpose of sexuality education is to ensure that people,<br />
and in particular young people, can better understand themselves<br />
so that they can make informed choices about sex and<br />
relationships, as well as to counteract myths and false perceptions<br />
about sexuality. Sexuality education also aims to prevent<br />
sexual harassment, sexual violence, and the discrimination of<br />
lgbt people and people living with hiv and aids. Good quality<br />
sexuality education improves public health by providing information<br />
that is adapted to people’s ages and specific contexts,<br />
and that looks at relevant, real-life issues related to sex and<br />
relationships for young people. This kind of sexuality education<br />
is supportive of people’s ability to make their own choices<br />
and respect other people’s choices in terms of intimacy and<br />
sex. The most important components in good quality sexuality<br />
education are that it provides correct and factual information<br />
about the human body and sexuality, that it develops skills such<br />
as critical thinking, communication and negotiation methods,<br />
self-esteem and respect for others, and finally that it encourages<br />
self-respect and a non-judgemental and non-discriminatory<br />
attitude. 31 Discussions about feelings, love, relationships, masturbation,<br />
sexual pleasure, gender equality, gender roles, sexual<br />
orientation and gender identity, as well as methods for protecting<br />
against unwanted pregnancies and sexually transmitted<br />
diseases provide knowledge, make people feel more confident<br />
and facilitate safer sex.<br />
Relevant sexuality education requires competent and knowledgeable<br />
teachers. Those who teach sexuality education must<br />
have the trust of the pupils. Pupils should be able to rely on<br />
teachers’ respect for their thoughts, ideas and questions without<br />
judgemental accusations or ridicule, and on the teachers’<br />
willingness and ability to answer their questions with correct<br />
and unprejudiced information. Good sexuality education places<br />
high demands on teachers.<br />
Entry points for dialogue on sexuality education<br />
‘Sexuality education’ are two words that are charged with layers<br />
of meaning, and their content and meanings associated with<br />
them can be very different in various parts of the world. It is<br />
important that sexuality education be discussed in the context<br />
27
of its role in the development and maturation of children and<br />
young people, its potential as an element in the fight against<br />
poverty, and its role in promoting public health through the<br />
provision of important life skills.<br />
Young people are curious and do not normally hesitate to<br />
ask questions about their feelings or to seek information on<br />
their own or from peers if they find it difficult to talk to their<br />
parents or other adults. Studies show that many young people<br />
in both developing countries and industrial countries currently<br />
receive this information primarily from each other or from<br />
other sources, such as publications or the Internet, and that<br />
this information is often far from being factually correct. If<br />
young people receive the correct information, it is easier for<br />
them to take responsibility for their own sexual behaviour.<br />
Knowledge about relationships and sexuality leads to better<br />
communication with a partner. Schools can refer young people<br />
to clinics and also in other ways increase their awareness of<br />
the importance of seeking health services when they need to.<br />
This knowledge leads to demystifying myths about how hiv and<br />
sexually transmitted diseases are spread, and also how harmful<br />
traditions that are practiced in some countries and regions can<br />
be avoided.<br />
A useful tip<br />
A number of UN bodies, UNESCO, UNAIDS, UNFPA,<br />
UNICEF and WHO, worked together to produce a manual<br />
“International Technical Guidance on Sexuality Education”,<br />
the purpose of which is to provide useful data and guidelines<br />
for sexuality education in schools. This guide is divided<br />
into a section that contains arguments for sexuality education,<br />
which can be used in dialogues with governments and<br />
in particular health and education ministries, as well as a<br />
section that focuses on how a good and effective sexuality<br />
education programme can be designed<br />
The icpd Programme of Action highlights universal access<br />
to sexuality education as being essential for people to be able<br />
to enjoy their sexual and reproductive rights, and further,<br />
that sexuality education should be provided as part of basic<br />
education curricula as well as in other kinds of formal and nonformal<br />
education.<br />
The Human Rights Committee, the Committee on the<br />
Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women and<br />
the Committee on the Rights of the Child have linked access to<br />
sexuality education at school to the right to life, health, education<br />
and information.<br />
Regional frameworks can be important instruments. One<br />
example of this kind of framework is the ‘Mexico City Declaration<br />
on Sex Education in Latin America and the Caribbean’.<br />
Another is the ‘Maputo Plan of Action’ for the African region.<br />
In Europe, the European Committee of Social Rights, which<br />
is the monitoring body for the European Social Charter, has<br />
presented a line of argument based on principles that sexuality<br />
education must be objective, based on scientific fact and contain<br />
correct information about contraception and other issues.<br />
Sexuality education must not be discriminatory by excluding<br />
children from such education or by strengthening disparaging<br />
stereotypes and prejudices. 32<br />
A number of frequently heard assertions on<br />
sexuality education are presented below, along<br />
with suggestions on how to address them:<br />
“Sexuality education increases sexual activity and promiscuity<br />
among young people.”<br />
This is incorrect, since studies show the opposite to be true:<br />
that with more information and knowledge, a person’s sexual<br />
debut takes place later in life and that young people who have<br />
received sexuality education can and do protect themselves<br />
better against sexually transmitted infections and unwanted<br />
pregnancies. 33<br />
If sexuality education is going to be effective, it not only<br />
requires adequate actions that increase people’s knowledge and<br />
ability to discuss sexuality with their partners. It must also be<br />
supplemented with access to counselling, contraceptive methods<br />
and health care services.<br />
“Sexuality education is not necessary –<br />
young people should not be having sex anyway.”<br />
The school’s role is to disseminate objective and all-round<br />
knowledge to ensure that young people can make their own<br />
informed choices based on their own circumstances and reality.<br />
28
Sweden’s position and key message: Knowledge and<br />
information about the human body, sexuality, reproduction<br />
and relationships are fundamental to ensure that people’s<br />
sexual and reproductive health and rights are met.<br />
Knowledge about the human body, sexuality and contraception<br />
provides young people with an opportunity to take responsibility<br />
for their lives and their sexuality. Sexuality education is an<br />
effective way of increasing knowledge, and evidence shows that<br />
the sexual debut does not take place earlier among children<br />
who receive such education. 34 One-sided campaigns for young<br />
people to abstain from sex have not shown positive results. 35<br />
Most young people have sex sooner or later. In countries where<br />
neither an open discussion nor any sexuality education is<br />
allowed, young people often feel confusion, shame and guilt<br />
over their sexuality, girls are forced to finish school because<br />
they become pregnant, and people become infected with sexually<br />
transmitted diseases and hiv because they know too little<br />
about how their bodies work, about how to protect themselves<br />
and how to obtain condoms and other contraceptives. Young<br />
people have the same thoughts and questions about sexuality<br />
around the world, but they receive different answers depending<br />
on where they live.<br />
Young people must be able to protect themselves. Sexuality<br />
education increases the ability for them to do this. Lack of<br />
information makes them more vulnerable.<br />
“Teachers lose children’s respect<br />
if they have to talk about sex.”<br />
Young people’s sexuality is certainly controversial, but teachers<br />
who have received training and support in their role as<br />
sexuality educators report that it is indeed possible to include<br />
sexuality in instruction, and that they actually become<br />
popular among the pupils because they are perceived as taking<br />
the pupils seriously. In terms of the relationships between<br />
teachers and pupils, one can point out that successful sexuality<br />
education actually works as a way of increasing trust in<br />
the teacher as well as their status. A teacher or another adult<br />
who can provide good quality sexuality education gains the<br />
respect of young people.<br />
Effective sexuality education is something that is clearly<br />
useful and applicable in people’s real, everyday lives. It should<br />
be a part of discussions about e.g. social relations between<br />
the sexes, intimate relationships, gender equality and sexual<br />
harassment. These discussions are extremely important as they<br />
strengthen young people’s self-esteem and self-confidence, as<br />
well as their ability to take responsibility for their behaviour<br />
and their future.<br />
Experiences from the field<br />
At the embassy in Tanzania, the ambassador has discussed<br />
SRHR with teachers, local politicians and ministers. He has<br />
particularly pursued the importance of pregnant girls being<br />
allowed to remain in school. The issue of sexuality education<br />
does not meet with a lot of overt resistance in the public<br />
debate, but neither is it a prioritised issue. On the other hand,<br />
the arguments about preventing teenage pregnancies and<br />
allowing pregnant girls to remain at school have had a positive<br />
impact as a result of the debate. One important discovery<br />
has been that an effective way to make progress on such<br />
issues can be to use measures to influence public opinion<br />
such as e.g. press releases and newspaper articles, in combination<br />
with the forging of alliances with local organisations<br />
and decision-makers.<br />
28. Ministry for Foreign Affairs , Sveriges internationella politik för sexuell och<br />
reproduktiv hälsa och rättigheter (2006), p.23.<br />
29. Guttmacher Institute, Protecting the Next Generation in Sub-Saharan<br />
Africa (2007).<br />
30. undpi, Goal 2: Achieve Universal Primary Education (2008).<br />
31. ippf, Reference guide to policies and practice. Sexuality education in Europe<br />
(2006).<br />
32. European Committee on Social Rights interights v. Croatia (Complaint<br />
No. 45/2007).<br />
33. Guttmacher Institute, Protecting the Next Generation in Sub-Saharan<br />
Africa (2007).<br />
34. Guttmacher Institute, Protecting the Next Generation in Sub-Saharan<br />
Africa (2007).<br />
35. Human rights Watch, The less they know, the better Abstinence-Only<br />
Hiv/Aids Programs in Uganda (2005).<br />
29
Condoms and other methods of contraception<br />
Access to contraception, medicines and health care equipment<br />
and materials for sexual and reproductive health is a central<br />
feature of the goals from the Programme of Action from the<br />
International Conference on Population and Development (icpd)<br />
in Cairo in 1994, and is important for the achievement of several<br />
of the UN Millennium Development Goals.<br />
Why is Sweden working to promote access<br />
to condoms and other contraceptives?<br />
Access to contraceptives such as condoms, and information and<br />
counselling on different methods of contraception are fundamental<br />
for women’s, men’s and young people’s prospects of having<br />
a safe sex life, and of being able to decide if and when they<br />
want to have children.<br />
People’s general health status, capacity and possibility to<br />
study and work are improved considerably when they are guaranteed<br />
access to adequate and affordable sexual and reproductive<br />
health care services. Women’s and young people’s opportunities<br />
to be able to make decisions about their own lives and play<br />
an active role in society are particularly improved by access to<br />
such health services, including to contraceptive methods such<br />
as condoms. Women who are able to plan their pregnancies and<br />
protect themselves against sexually transmitted infections are<br />
also better educated and are in a better position to look after<br />
their children than those that are not. Strengthening sexual and<br />
reproductive health and rights also means that more people are<br />
able to work and therefore to contribute to the national economy<br />
and increased productivity, and that costs for health care for<br />
families as well as for nations will decrease. Guaranteeing access<br />
to condoms and other forms of contraception is considerably<br />
more cost-effective than having to provide care after unsafe<br />
abortions and complications in connection with pregnancy and<br />
birth, or after people have become infected with hiv.<br />
Entry points for dialogue on condoms,<br />
contraceptives and other health care supplies<br />
for sexual and reproductive health<br />
The importance of having access to condoms, contraceptives,<br />
medicines and health care supplies to ensure sexual and reproductive<br />
health can be linked to people’s fundamental right to<br />
the highest attainable standard of health and to being able to<br />
live a life in dignity, which is set out in several un conventions<br />
on human rights.<br />
The un Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of<br />
Discrimination Against Women (cedaw) includes the right of<br />
women to decide freely and responsibly about the number and<br />
spacing of their children and the right to access sexual information,<br />
education and the means to enable them to exercise<br />
these rights (Article 16(1)(e)). The cedaw Committee that<br />
monitors adherence to this convention has also stressed the<br />
fact that women cannot make well-informed decisions about<br />
the use of safe and reliable contraception if they have not<br />
received adequate information and do not have access to advisory<br />
servicers on contraception. 36<br />
Experiences from the field<br />
Dialogue on sexuality and gender equality with young men<br />
and local leaders in the <strong>RFSU</strong> project, “Young Men As<br />
Equal Partners” in Tanzania, Zambia, Uganda and Kenya<br />
2006 –2009, resulted in an increased demand for sexuality<br />
education and sexual and reproductive health services.<br />
Condom use increased as well as the number of visits to<br />
reproductive health clinics, which contributed to a decrease<br />
in STIs and teenage pregnancies in the project areas.<br />
Other un human rights monitoring committees have recommended<br />
that states improve access to safe and affordable<br />
contraceptives. States have also been specifically encouraged<br />
to ensure that women, men and young people have access to<br />
condoms, and that information about the use of condoms is<br />
disseminated in the context of hiv prevention programmes.<br />
Development cooperation funding for family planning has<br />
decreased. 37 Studies indicate that investments for actions to<br />
combat hiv and aids are those that currently receive the major<br />
part of international financial support in the area of srhr.<br />
Although work to prevent and combat hiv and aids can successfully<br />
be integrated into and create synergies with other srhr<br />
work, it is important not to neglect the need for funding for<br />
other srhr issues. Although some progress has been seen in, for<br />
example, maternal mortality, in some countries maternal health<br />
and access to condoms and other methods of contraception glo-<br />
31
ally must be significantly improved if un Millennium Development<br />
Goals 4, 5 and 6 are to be achieved by 2015.<br />
Dialogue on national budgets in connection with the followup<br />
of national strategies for poverty reduction, health sector<br />
support or actions plans for the strengthening of health systems<br />
can be key entry points for raising the issue of sexual and reproductive<br />
health care services. Dialogue in such contexts could<br />
for example include working actively to ensure that adequate<br />
resources are allocated and clearly designated in the budget<br />
for inter alia contraceptives, condoms, testing, advisory and<br />
counselling services, midwives, emergency contraception pills,<br />
care after unsafe abortions, maternal health care, hiv testing<br />
and anti-retroviral drugs in national budgets.<br />
The use of contraceptives promotes development at all<br />
levels, i.e. for individuals, families and local communities as<br />
well as for nations. Investments in sexual and reproductive<br />
health and contraception strengthen the ability of families to<br />
support themselves, and can reduce public expenditure for<br />
health care and other social services. Increasing the availability<br />
of condoms and contraception is thus a cost-effective way<br />
of promoting poverty reduction. In addition, several of the<br />
un Millennium Development Goals could be achieved if more<br />
resources were invested in sexual and reproductive health,<br />
including to increase the availability of and access to condoms<br />
and other contraceptives.<br />
A number of frequently occurring assertions<br />
regarding condoms and other methods of<br />
contraception are presented below, along with<br />
suggestions on how to address them.<br />
“Information on contraception and<br />
condoms leads to an increase in sexual activity.”<br />
No research or analytical studies suggest that information<br />
about condoms or contraception results in an increase in<br />
sexual activity. However, there are studies that do show that<br />
ignorance leads to an increase in risky sexual behaviour. 38<br />
The use of condoms is in many places a moral issue,<br />
whereby condoms are seen as symbolising infidelity, promiscuity<br />
and sex before marriage. However, one’s own personal<br />
religious or moral convictions should not affect other people’s<br />
ability to choose for themselves whether or not they want to<br />
use condoms. When used correctly, condoms – both male and<br />
female – are currently the only proven and effective means of<br />
prevention against the transfer of hiv and other sexually transmitted<br />
infections for individuals who are sexually active.<br />
“It does not pay to invest in contraception and condoms.<br />
Most people still want to have large families.”<br />
Most families actually want to have the number of children and<br />
a family size that they can provide adequately for. More than<br />
200 million women who want to postpone or limit their childbearing<br />
do not have access to modern contraceptives. In 2009,<br />
up to 50 percent of all pregnancies globally were unplanned and<br />
25 percent were unwanted.<br />
Studies also show that women who can plan their childbearing<br />
benefit significantly, both in terms of personal prospects<br />
and financially. In the Philippines the average income growth<br />
for women was twice as high if they had had three pregnancies<br />
compared to if they had had more than seven pregnancies. 39<br />
• Maternal mortality could be reduced by one-third simply by<br />
improving women’s access to effective contraception.<br />
• 200 million women lack access to contraception, even<br />
though they express a need for it.<br />
• The total demand for contraception is expected to increase<br />
by 40 percent in the next 15 years. 40 This is partly, but not<br />
entirely, due to a lack of financial investment in reproductive<br />
health supplies, as well as to an urgent need to reprioritise<br />
among current measures and investments.<br />
• Maternal mortality could be reduced by half and costs for<br />
health care considerably decreased if more investments were<br />
made to improve the accessibility of condoms and other<br />
methods of contraception. 41 A lack of infrastructure, such as<br />
transport options and logistics problems, also result in contraception,<br />
medicines and health care supplies for sexual and<br />
reproductive health not reaching everyone who needs them.<br />
• In Thailand, local authorities invested in a campaign for<br />
“100-percent” condom use in brothels in the 1990s. This<br />
resulted in condom use increasing from 14 to 95 percent<br />
over five years, and sexually transmitted diseases falling from<br />
400,000 to 30,000 cases per year in the same period. 42<br />
32
Sweden’s position and key message: Access to condoms<br />
and other contraception is an important way to avoid<br />
unwanted pregnancies. The use of condoms is also essential<br />
for effective prevention work against the spread of hiv and<br />
other sexually transmitted infections.<br />
36. Convention on the Elimination of Discrimination against Women,<br />
General Recommendation No. 21, Equality in marriage and family relations,<br />
(13th session, 1994).<br />
37. Eurongos, dsw, epf Euromapping, Mapping European development aid and<br />
population assistance (2008).<br />
38. Guttmacher Institute, unfpa, Adding it Up – The Costs and Benefits of Investing<br />
in Family Planning and Maternal and Newborn Health (2009).<br />
39. unfpa, State of the world population (2005).<br />
40. unfpa, No Woman Should Die Giving Life (2008).<br />
41. Guttmacher Institute, unfpa, Adding it Up – Costs and Benefits of Family<br />
Planning and Maternal and Newborn Health Services (2009).<br />
42. who, Regional office for the Western Pacific, Fact sheet: Condom facts and<br />
figures (2003).<br />
33
HIV and AIDS<br />
Combating hiv and aids requires active involvement, responsible<br />
leadership and forceful actions and measures from many different<br />
stakeholders. hiv and aids represent a complex challenge,<br />
and is one of the greatest global threats to poverty reduction<br />
and the achievement of equitable and sustainable development.<br />
However, there are positive trends: the spread of hiv seems to<br />
have stabilised in many parts of the world, and international<br />
investments and the work of different countries have meant<br />
that currently more than 4 million people living with hiv and<br />
aids in low-income and middle-income countries have access to<br />
condoms and anti-retroviral drugs. 43<br />
Why is Sweden working to combat<br />
HIV and AIDS in the context of SRHR?<br />
In 2008 the Swedish Government adopted a policy for Sweden’s<br />
International hiv and aids work; The Right to a Future. This<br />
policy stresses that human rights, work to promote gender<br />
equality and the fight against hiv and aids are closely interlinked.<br />
Individuals and groups of people become more vulnerable<br />
to hiv infection when their human rights, in particular<br />
their sexual and reproductive rights, are not respected. Consequently,<br />
respect for human rights must be strengthened, and<br />
equality between women and men must increase in order to<br />
fight hiv and aids effectively. In this policy, Sweden highlights<br />
two central areas in its hiv and aids work: to prevent the spread<br />
of hiv, and to alleviate the long-term effects of hiv and aids for<br />
individuals and societies. 44<br />
The strong stigma which currently surrounds hiv means that<br />
people living with the infection are marginalised and denied<br />
equal treatment. They and their families are often forced to live<br />
in social exclusion, and sometimes subjected to violence and<br />
harassment. This also results in many people not getting tested<br />
in order to avoid stigma and discrimination.<br />
People living with hiv must be able to enjoy the same rights<br />
as others, and to have equitable access to health care services,<br />
education, information, srhr counselling and methods of contraception<br />
such as condoms. They also have the right to avoid<br />
being subjected to violence and should be given the opportunity<br />
to play an active role in formulating and implementing hiv<br />
policies and programmes.<br />
Entry points for dialogue on HIV and AIDS<br />
hiv prevention is a prioritised Swedish issue and must be<br />
emphasised in dialogue. This can be done mainly by working to<br />
integrate a human rights perspective and a gender equality perspective<br />
in interventions, as well as by influencing and pursuing<br />
dialogue on the implementation and monitoring of existing<br />
policies, actions plans, guidelines and budgets.<br />
Discussions on hiv and aids touch upon a number of human<br />
rights, for example the right to health and to access medicines,<br />
and the right not to be discriminated against. The un Human<br />
Rights Committee has encouraged states under the heading<br />
‘Right to life’ to supply anti-retroviral drugs to people living<br />
with hiv and aids.<br />
• The poorest areas of the world have been hit hardest by<br />
HIV and AIDS. Currently there are 33 million people living<br />
with HIV, and 2.7 million more people are infected every year.<br />
Of these, 45 percent are young people between the ages<br />
of 15 and 24, the majority of whom live in poor countries. 45<br />
Poverty, lack of gender equality and sexual violence result in<br />
women and girls, in particular in Sub-Saharan Africa, being<br />
more likely to be living with HIV and AIDS than men.<br />
• HIV and AIDS cause not only personal tragedies, but also<br />
create major problems for society as a whole. The consequences<br />
of the HIV pandemic include everything from a<br />
lower GNP to a decimated teacher and civil servant corps.<br />
Most people living with HIV have been infected through<br />
sexual contact. Efforts to tackle the HIV epidemic must<br />
therefore have a focus on sexuality and on rights dimensions.<br />
In specific terms, this means that the work to prevent the<br />
spread of HIV must include sexuality education, the use of<br />
condoms and attention to the promotion of gender equality.<br />
Article 12 (2) (c) of the Covenant on Economic, Social and<br />
Cultural Rights is about the prevention, treatment and control of<br />
epidemic diseases, and implies that governments need to establish<br />
prevention and education programmes for public health problems<br />
such as sexually transmitted infections, including hiv and aids. 46<br />
In the Declaration from the un General Assembly’s special<br />
session on hiv and aids (hiv-ungass) in 2001, all un member<br />
states pledged to set up time-bound targets and regularly follow<br />
up the work on the pandemic. At the follow-up session of 2006<br />
35
a new declaration was signed with explicit text concerning<br />
general access to prevention measures, medicines and health<br />
care by 2010.<br />
hiv epidemics are very different in different parts of the<br />
world. It is therefore important to analyze and have an adequate<br />
understanding of what the epidemic is like and what factors<br />
drive the spread of hiv in a particular place, in order to identify<br />
suitable ways of opening doors for dialogue and carrying<br />
out relevant, context-specific measures. In some countries the<br />
epidemic is concentrated to specific groups, while in other countries<br />
it affects the general population to a greater extent. In Sub-<br />
Saharan Africa, 60 percent of people living with hiv are women.<br />
Many of them are infected within marriage. In other regions it<br />
is also primarily women and girls who are becoming infected to<br />
a greater extent than men and boys. Work to promote gender<br />
equality and women’s rights and to counteract the increasing<br />
feminisation of the hiv epidemic is therefore important.<br />
Experiences from the field<br />
Experience at the embassy in Pretoria has shown that good<br />
opportunities to conduct dialogues about various SRHR<br />
issues have arisen within the context of HIV and AIDS work.<br />
South Africa has relatively progressive legislation in terms<br />
of human rights, which was partly developed within the<br />
framework of national HIV and AIDS work. This has led to<br />
the work to fight stigma and discrimination of HIV-positive<br />
people becoming clearly linked to human rights issues. Due<br />
to the clearly discernible consequences of HIV and AIDS<br />
prevalence in South African society, a greater degree of<br />
openness has developed in the country around controversial<br />
issues such as sexuality education, contraception, and<br />
women’s and LGBT rights, thus providing a good foundation<br />
for continued SRHR dialogue.<br />
Men who have sex with men, women and men in prostitution,<br />
as well as injecting drugs users are often left out of hiv interventions,<br />
thereby further increasing the vulnerability and isolation<br />
of these groups. These key populations at risk must be targeted<br />
by context-specific efforts and also be given the opportunity to<br />
take active part in the design of prevention programmes.<br />
Young people’s sexuality and rights are seen as being sensitive<br />
issues and are difficult to talk about in many societies. However,<br />
it is impossible to fight poverty sustainably and achieve<br />
the un’s development goals without investing in health and<br />
rights for the large group of people that young men and women<br />
represent. Young people must receive information about how<br />
their bodies work and about sex and relationships. They also<br />
need to be given access to health care that is not judgemental or<br />
discriminatory so that they can be tested, receive counselling<br />
and gain access to contraception.<br />
When people are discriminated against because of their sex,<br />
sexual orientation or other factors, their vulnerability and risk<br />
of being infected with hiv is increased. Traditional gender roles<br />
must be challenged in order to prevent the spread of hiv. Finding<br />
ways of involving men in this work is an important part of<br />
Sweden’s work and dialogue to combat hiv and aids. For example,<br />
men and boys must be able to take responsibility for their own<br />
sexuality by respecting the human rights of women and girls, and<br />
to question their own sexual behaviour, by, for example, using<br />
condoms and by repudiating and disassociating themselves from<br />
all forms of gender-based violence towards women and girls.<br />
Women’s subordinate position and their lack of sexual<br />
bargaining power mean that the female condom is extremely<br />
important. The female condom gives women the option of controlling<br />
the use of condoms themselves and should be marketed<br />
and distributed to a much greater extent than today. At the<br />
same time, investing in producing new prevention methods, such<br />
as microbicides and vaccines should continue to be financed.<br />
However, research into them is currently still underway and it<br />
will take time before effective methods are publicly available.<br />
The major global initiatives that have been set up to stop the<br />
spread of hiv have not always included srhr, despite the obvious<br />
links between sexuality, gender equality, power and the spread<br />
of hiv. Sweden has, for example, in the Global Fund to Fight<br />
aids, Tuberculosis and Malaria 47 , worked actively with other<br />
stakeholders to ensure that organisations that work with srhr<br />
issues can access the Global Fund’s programmes and resources,<br />
and that policies and guidelines for how the funds that are<br />
distributed also ensure their availability to initiatives that have<br />
a focus on srhr. Monitoring how this work is being carried out<br />
at country and regional level is an important entry point for<br />
actions and dialogue for representatives of Sweden. It is impor-<br />
36
Sweden’s position and key message: Sweden’s international<br />
work in the area of hiv and aids must be seen in the<br />
context of sexual and reproductive health and rights (srhr)<br />
and be characterised by the obligation to strengthen respect<br />
for human rights and increase gender equality. The effects<br />
of hiv and aids do not only concern the health sector but are<br />
also manifested in other sectors and areas in society.<br />
tant to find out what stakeholders and other actors receive<br />
funding from the major global initiatives, and to require that<br />
they recognize the importance of gender equality and human<br />
rights dimensions, and that organisations, programmes and<br />
projects working with lgbt rights and young people’s rights also<br />
are given access to funding.<br />
Support for civil society organisations that work with an integrated<br />
perspective of srhr and hiv should form an important element<br />
in the design of guidelines and policies at both national and<br />
local levels. It is therefore important to influence the processes<br />
in for example the Global Fund’s Country Coordinating Mechanisms<br />
(ccm) to ensure a broad and firmly established approach<br />
to hiv prevention work that includes the use of condoms,<br />
sexuality education, gender equality and a focus on women,<br />
young people, vulnerable groups and key populations at risk.<br />
In many countries, dialogue and collaboration with progressive,<br />
pragmatic religious leaders can be extremely important.<br />
These leaders can, for example, be key figures and contacts in<br />
dialogues about girls’ rights to education and violence against<br />
women, and for involving men in the work to prevent the spread<br />
of hiv, and to promote sexual and reproductive health in general.<br />
A number of frequently occurring assertions<br />
on HIV and AIDS are presented below, along with<br />
suggestions on how to address them:<br />
“Condoms do not protect against hiv and aids.”<br />
It is not true that condoms do not protect against hiv and<br />
aids. An unbroken condom used correctly is currently the<br />
only means of prevention that effectively protects against hiv<br />
transmission. The condom is a cheap and simple way to ensure<br />
the health of the population. There is a high level of opposition<br />
to the use of condoms on religious and political grounds in<br />
many parts of the world. This is reflected in both messages and<br />
campaigns in some countries as well as in the personal attitudes<br />
and positions of political and religious representatives.<br />
“Abstinence is the only way of avoiding hiv and aids.”<br />
Not having sex at all means that the risk of hiv transmission<br />
through sexual contact is eliminated. However, this is not a<br />
long-term or realistic alternative for most people. People have<br />
sex because they are looking for intimacy and they want to have<br />
sex, but sometimes and unfortunately because it is forced upon<br />
them. Since the reality is that people do have sex, they need to<br />
know about how to protect themselves against hiv and other<br />
sexually transmitted infections.<br />
“It does not pay to invest in hiv prevention work.”<br />
This assertion could not be further from the truth. Prevention<br />
is crucial. Studies show that hiv prevention work is up to 28<br />
times more cost-effective than provision of hiv treatment and<br />
health care services. Everyone who is infected must be given<br />
access to treatment, but due to the large number of people<br />
being infected with hiv every day (7,400), major resources have<br />
to be placed on prevention work in order to effectively stop the<br />
spread. 48 For every two people who gain access to anti-retroviral<br />
drugs, there are five people who become newly infected<br />
with hiv. In other words, the number of people who are newly<br />
infected exceeds the number of people who start hiv medication.<br />
49 Investing in prevention work is therefore absolutely<br />
essential to turn this situation around. In countries where hiv<br />
prevalence is widespread in the general population, there are<br />
huge losses of human capital and institutional memory in terms<br />
of teachers, health care workers and other important social<br />
functions. This in turn leads to the education and health systems<br />
in those countries, which are already stretched, being hit<br />
even harder and puts them at risk of deteriorating completely.<br />
43. who, Towards universal access: scaling up priority hiv/aids interventions in the<br />
health sector. Progress report (2009).<br />
44. Government Offices of Sweden, Rätten till en framtid Policy för Sveriges<br />
internationella hiv- och aidsarbete (2008), p. 6.<br />
45. unaids, 08 Report on the Global Aids Epidemic (2009).<br />
46. Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, General Comment<br />
No. 14: The right to the highest attainable standard of health, e/c.12/2000/4 (2000).<br />
47. Read more about the Global Fund’s work at: www.theglobalfund.org<br />
48. Fact sheet for the High level event on the Millennium development goals,<br />
United Nations headquarters, New York, September 2008.<br />
49. un General Assembly, Sixty-fourth session, Agenda item 44, ‘Implementation<br />
of the Declaration of Commitment on Hiv/Aids and the Political Declaration<br />
on hiv/aids’, Progress made in the implementation of the Declaration of Commitment<br />
on hiv/aids and the Political Declaration on hiv/aids Report of the Secretary-<br />
General (2010).<br />
37
Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and<br />
Transgender rights (LGBT rights issues)<br />
Why is Sweden working to<br />
promote LGBT people’s rights?<br />
In many parts of the world lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender<br />
people (lgbt) are subjected to discrimination, persecution,<br />
social marginalisation and violence, including sexual assault. In<br />
some countries any manifestation of sexual orientation, gender<br />
identity or gender expression that differs from the heterosexual<br />
norm is punishable by a prison sentence, torture or execution.<br />
In order for the human rights of lgbt people to be adequately<br />
protected and respected so that they can contribute to the<br />
development of their society on the basis of equality with other<br />
people, it is important that their situation and vulnerability be<br />
made visible. 50<br />
Discrimination of lgbt people and violations of their rights<br />
occur throughout the world. Combating, for example, discriminatory<br />
legislation for lgbt rights is an important dialogue issue<br />
in bilateral cooperation, within eu collaboration and in international<br />
and global contexts.<br />
Discrimination and stigmatisation mean that lgbt people<br />
often live in social and financial exclusion as it can be difficult<br />
for them to find or maintain a job. Many lgbt people are forced<br />
to create and/or find social networks on the sidelines of established<br />
society, where they are often marginalised and isolated<br />
from family, friends, associations and other communities. 51<br />
Everyone is entitled to information, health care services and<br />
protection from being infected with sexually transmitted infections.<br />
Society’s exclusion of lgbt people means that they risk not<br />
• In more than 85 countries in the world, sexual acts<br />
between adults of the same sex are forbidden by law. 52<br />
• In eight countries, homosexuality is punishable by death. 53<br />
• The lack of adequate legal protection for LGBT people is<br />
also common in states where there is no capital or corporal<br />
punishment for LGBT people.<br />
• Harassment from police is common, as well as impunity for<br />
perpetrators.<br />
• In some parts of the world, women who do not fit the heterosexual<br />
norm risk being subjected to curative rapes, where<br />
the perpetrators’ express intent is to ‘cure’ the woman of her<br />
sexual orientation. 54<br />
being reached by information about sexual and reproductive<br />
health and rights, including safer sex and health care as well as<br />
hiv prevention. In addition, lgbt people who seek health services<br />
risk being denied care and support because of their sexual orientation<br />
or gender identity. Transgender people experience major<br />
social oppression and are seldom recognised as an important<br />
interest group in discussions about hiv prevention and sexuality.<br />
Entry points for dialogue on LGBT<br />
persons’ enjoyment of human rights<br />
Discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation or gender identity<br />
goes against the fundamental principle of everyone’s equal value<br />
and rights. Sexual orientation is not expressly set out among the<br />
forms of discrimination in un conventions. However, the committees<br />
that monitor adherence to the un’s two central conventions<br />
for human rights (iccpr and icescr) have established that the<br />
grounds for prohibiting discrimination cited in the conventions also<br />
pertain to sexual orientation, as has the European Court in reference<br />
to the ban on discrimination in Article 14 of the European<br />
Convention. 55<br />
In 2006, a number of human rights experts developed the<br />
Yogyakarta principles that show how fundamental human rights<br />
can be applied to sexual orientation and gender identity. The<br />
Yogyakarta principles include inter alia the right to life, freedom,<br />
privacy, access to justice, as well as freedom from violence,<br />
torture and arbitrary arrests. 56<br />
In December 2008, a Declaration on Decriminalising Homosexuality<br />
was launched at the un General Assembly. This declaration<br />
has so far been signed by nearly 70 countries, including<br />
the usa and all of the eu member states.<br />
States are responsible for ensuring that individuals are<br />
not discriminated against. lgbt people and their families are<br />
confronted with many risks and subjected to discrimination<br />
and violence in many countries. The justice system is undermined<br />
as impunity is common for those who perpetrate crimes<br />
of violence against lgbt people. In addition to causing a great<br />
amount of suffering for the individuals concerned, society as<br />
a whole is affected since social insecurity and social tensions<br />
increase in situations in which such violence is tolerated. Even<br />
where homosexual acts and/or manifestations of transgen-<br />
39
der identities are not criminal offenses according to national<br />
legislation, such sexual or gender expressions may be seen as<br />
behaviour that goes against prevailing cultural values and local<br />
perceptions of morality.<br />
LGBT rights – a luxury problem?<br />
lgbt issues are essentially a matter of human rights that concerns<br />
health, safety, well-being and poverty reduction, as well<br />
as countries’ prospects for achieving the goal of equitable and<br />
sustainable global development. In addition to relevant information<br />
about and a good understanding of the local context,<br />
it is helpful to be aware of and be able to refer to experiences<br />
and developments in Sweden with regard to how the situation<br />
concerning lgbt rights has changed dramatically over the<br />
years. Nowadays, negative behaviour and attitudes toward lgbt<br />
people, which used to be considered as morally correct and<br />
justified by many in Sweden, are now usually considered to be<br />
out-of-date and reactionary. Many other societies and countries<br />
in the world have undergone or are currently undergoing similar<br />
processes of changing their norms and attitudes.<br />
Experiences from the field<br />
It is difficult to work with LGBT people’s rights in Vietnam.<br />
According to the embassy in Hanoi, these issues receive very<br />
little attention if any at all. In the dialogue on HIV and AIDS,<br />
the issue of men who have sex with men has partly been<br />
highlighted to some extent.<br />
Since 2008, the embassy has been working with a Vietnamese<br />
NGO that works for LGBT rights. Sweden is the first<br />
country to support an organisation that works openly with<br />
lesbian women’s rights in Vietnam.<br />
“As a result of Sweden’s support, there is now a 15-minute<br />
slot on Radio FM live every Sunday in Vietnam that offers<br />
counselling and advice for lesbian women. The programme<br />
is a hotline for lesbians, and they can phone in directly to<br />
receive information and support.”<br />
Civil servant at the Swedish embassy in Hanoi<br />
It is important to exercise caution when collaborating with<br />
organisations in the civil society that work with lgbt rights. In<br />
countries where homosexuality is criminalised or not socially<br />
accepted, lgbt people’s very lives can be in danger if they come<br />
forward or are exposed by other people. Locally-employed<br />
staff who work with these issues at Swedish embassies can<br />
also be at risk of being subjected to threats and harassment.<br />
Working to change legislation and to provide support to human<br />
rights defenders through diplomacy and dialogue is therefore<br />
extremely important in these kinds of situations.<br />
In countries in which there is good legal protection, work<br />
with lgbt rights should primarily focus on convincing those in<br />
power about the importance of ensuring that laws are observed<br />
and enforced, and that different institutions in society do not<br />
discriminate against lgbt people.<br />
Dialogue on lgbt rights requires a preparedness to deal with<br />
both opinions based on what are clearly misconceptions or misrepresentations<br />
of facts, as well as on emotional arguments.<br />
A number of frequently occurring assertions<br />
about LGBT people are presented below, along with<br />
suggestions on how to address them:<br />
“Recognizing lgbt rights is<br />
the same as approving paedophilia.”<br />
There is a clear distinction between sexual acts between consenting<br />
adults that are an expression of reciprocal and mutual<br />
satisfaction on the one hand, and on the other hand criminal<br />
acts of assault that violate and exploit other people (such as<br />
paedophilia and other assaults on children, or rape).<br />
“Recognizing lgbt rights leads to<br />
an increase in the spread of hiv.”<br />
lgbt people run a higher risk of suffering from hiv and aids<br />
because they are discriminated against and stigmatised, and<br />
because general health care and hiv prevention measures do<br />
not reach them. Due to their vulnerability to ill-treatment,<br />
threats and violence, they may also be afraid to seek health care<br />
services. So to the contrary, openness surrounding these issues<br />
therefore has the potential to reduce the spread of hiv.<br />
“Recognizing lgbt rights undermines<br />
the existence of traditional heterosexual marriage.”<br />
Human rights apply to all people, including lgbt people. The<br />
issue is not about giving special rights to one particular group<br />
40
Sweden’s position and key message: Everyone has the<br />
right to exercise their sexual and reproductive rights<br />
and to have these rights realised. The fundamental<br />
feature of the work to promote lgbt people’s living<br />
conditions and opportunities is the general principle<br />
of non-discrimination, as well as every person’s equal<br />
value and right to equal treatment.<br />
at the expense of another. Increasing civic and social rights has<br />
led to more stable societies throughout history, with stronger<br />
development and less poverty. Neither does recognising or<br />
strengthening lgbt people’s exercise of their human rights mean<br />
that other people’s rights or opportunities for love or marriage<br />
will be restricted.<br />
“Homosexuality is unnatural, immoral and wrong.<br />
Homosexuals should not be allowed to exist.”<br />
Human rights apply to all people irrespective of their sexual<br />
orientation or the opinions of states and others about the<br />
life choices of individuals. In these issues, it is therefore not<br />
necessary to go into an argument about whether homosexuality<br />
is right or wrong, natural or unnatural. No matter what<br />
personal opinions people have about other people’s individual<br />
choice of whom they love have chosen as a life partner, there is<br />
always scope to argue that no one’s human rights can or should<br />
violated, otherwise we are all in danger of having our rights<br />
infringed upon.<br />
Prescriptive ideas about morality over time in a given society<br />
as well as within societies are changeable, just like other cultural<br />
perceptions, traditions and expressions.<br />
“Homosexuality is a Western invention,<br />
it does not exist in our culture.”<br />
lgbt people live in all countries. One reason why people might<br />
think there are more lgbt people in, for example, Europe and<br />
the usa, is because they usually have considerable protection in<br />
the law in these regions, as well as the possibility and choice of<br />
living openly with their sexual identity.<br />
50. Ministry for Foreign Affairs, Sweden’s International Policy on Sexual and<br />
Reproductive Health and Rights (2006), p. 17.<br />
51. rfsl, hbt i utveckling [lgbt in Development] (2008).<br />
52. rfsl, hbt i utveckling [lgbt in Development] (2008).<br />
53. United Arab Emirates, Iran, Yemen, Mauritius, Nigeria, Saudi Arabia,<br />
Somalia and Sudan.<br />
54. rfsl, hbt i utveckling [lgbt in Development] (2008).<br />
55. Mänskliga rättigheter i svensk utrikespolitik [Human Rights in Swedish<br />
Foreign Policy]. Regeringens skrivelse [Swedish Government Communication]<br />
2007/2008, p. 25.<br />
56. Yogyakartaprinciples.org<br />
41
Gender-based violence<br />
Why will Sweden continue to work<br />
actively to combat gender-based violence?<br />
Gender-based violence occurs throughout the world and is<br />
different from other kinds of violence as it affects individuals<br />
due to their sex or gender expression, and because of<br />
the expectations that are linked to cultural perceptions of<br />
what is male and female respectively. It is primarily men and<br />
boys who subject girls and women to gender-based violence,<br />
something that is closely related to perceptions of gender<br />
relations whereby women and girls are considered generally to<br />
be in a subordinate position compared to men and boys. Men<br />
who do not meet the norms of how a man in a given society<br />
should be or behave can also be subjected to violence by other<br />
men. Gender-based violence can be linked to violence in the<br />
name of honour and to violence against lgbt people, forms of<br />
gender-based violence that are often based on cultural values<br />
and attitudes.<br />
Much of the gender-based violence related to sexual and<br />
reproductive health and rights is invisible, for example sexual<br />
assaults in the home and rape within marriage. Gender-based<br />
violence is often deeply rooted in cultural customs and traditions.<br />
Harmful traditions and customary practices, including<br />
female genital mutilation, forced marriage and child marriage,<br />
• 20 percent of the world’s women will be subjected to a<br />
rape or attempted rape at some point in their lives.<br />
• 33 percent will be subjected to violence, harassment or<br />
assault in a close relationship.<br />
• Of these sexual assaults, 50 percent are committed<br />
against girls under the age of 15, often within forced marriage.<br />
Sexual violence contributes to the spread of sexually<br />
transmitted infections, including HIV. Violence and rape<br />
within marriage are not considered to be criminal offences in<br />
many countries. Studies also show that many women accept<br />
violence within marriage. Violence against women causes<br />
just as many deaths and serious injuries as cancer diseases<br />
among women between the ages of 15 and 44 years old. 58<br />
• In some countries, the costs of gender-based violence<br />
represent a considerable proportion of the total GNP, and<br />
not only include high costs of hospital care and other social<br />
services, but also lost productivity.<br />
restrict the right of girls and women to make decisions about<br />
their own bodies. The un defines these actions as forms of<br />
gender-based violence, and states that they cannot be defended<br />
or excused by references to culture or religion. Dialogue on<br />
these kinds of gender-based violence can be conducted within<br />
the framework of the states’ commitments to conform to and<br />
implement international, regional and national laws and agreements<br />
that prohibit harmful traditions and customs. 57<br />
Gender-based violence, rape and sexual assault cause physical<br />
and psychological trauma. In addition to physical injuries,<br />
anxiety and fear, violence limits the opportunities of women<br />
and girls to acquire an education, remunerable work and to<br />
contribute to development. Women and girls who have been<br />
subjected to sexual violence are often stigmatised and excluded<br />
from families, which can leave them completely outside of<br />
and unable to access their normal social protection networks.<br />
Since women are responsible in most societies for the care of<br />
children, the sick and the elderly, violence against women risks<br />
having a negative impact on the rest of the family, particularly<br />
for children who are born as a result of rape. It is necessary to<br />
provide support, counselling and outreach work for the women<br />
and girls affected, as well as to men, families and local communities<br />
to ensure that those who are subjected to violence will be<br />
able to receive effective help. Local women’s organisations and<br />
networks can provide a great deal of knowledge and information<br />
in this regard.<br />
Gender-based violence includes<br />
many different kinds of violence<br />
An estimated 3 million girls undergo genital mutilation every<br />
year. 59 Several kinds of genital mutilation are very dangerous<br />
to the health of girls, resulting in bleeding, severe infections<br />
and far too often in permanent damage, disability or death,<br />
for example during pregnancy and childbirth later in their<br />
lives. Genital mutilation is often linked to a girl’s future<br />
cultural identity as being a ‘real’ and adult woman and her<br />
prospects of marrying.<br />
Gender-based violence tends to increase in crisis situations,<br />
and rape and other kinds of sexual violence are often used as a<br />
conscious tactic and a weapon in war and armed conflicts. The<br />
43
opposing parties in wars and armed conflicts often use sexual<br />
violence in order to humiliate and degrade their victims, and to<br />
destroy social relations and the social fabric of local communities.<br />
Under international law, conflict-related sexual violence can be<br />
classified as a war crime or a crime against humanity. However,<br />
the level of impunity is high and it can be very difficult to<br />
prosecute and punish people who commit these criminal offences.<br />
Sexual violence in conflict and post-conflict situations is mainly<br />
committed against women and girls, but also men and boys.<br />
Women and girls who have psychological or physical disabilities<br />
can be especially vulnerable to gender-based violence. They<br />
are often dependent on their families, their partner or institutional<br />
staff, and often do not dare report violence and assaults.<br />
They often have low or no self-esteem, which can also increase<br />
their vulnerability to violence. The rights of women and girls<br />
with disabilities must be protected and promoted, including by<br />
strengthening their access to sexual and reproductive health.<br />
The most common form of gender-based violence is the violence<br />
that women are subjected to at the hands of their own<br />
partner, father, brothers or other male relatives. This kind of<br />
violence is considered to be a private matter in most societies.<br />
This prevents many women from seeking the help they need,<br />
both legal and medical (for example maternal health care),<br />
and such violence can therefore have serious consequences on<br />
their sexual and reproductive health. In some cases, women<br />
are threatened with violence if they ask their partners to use<br />
a condom or have a hiv test. In such situations, women probably<br />
avoid such negotiations, therefore exposing themselves<br />
Experiences from the field<br />
In Ethiopia there is a strong link between the level of education<br />
for women on the one hand, and on the other hand<br />
maternal and infant mortality and a high level of acceptance<br />
of violence against women. At the embassy in Addis Ababa,<br />
the dialogue has been linked to the education sector, with<br />
gender equality and gender-based violence as important<br />
issues. This has allowed connections between the issues to<br />
be highlighted, thereby expanding scope for the dialogue<br />
to also focus on gender equality, human rights, democracy<br />
and health.<br />
to greater health risks and/or an unwanted pregnancy.<br />
Violence, oppression and murder in the name of honour<br />
are forms of violence that are defended on cultural grounds<br />
because a woman or girl is considered to have brought shame on<br />
the family through behaviour linked to sexuality. This form of<br />
oppression and violence not only affects women and girls, but<br />
also young men who do not conform to the norm within the<br />
family and local norms.<br />
As it is usually men who subject women to gender-based<br />
violence, major efforts must be made to direct measures for<br />
promoting changes in the behaviour and attitudes of men and<br />
boys. Men need to understand the damage they cause when<br />
using violence against women, both physically and psychologically,<br />
and how children and the rest of the family are affected.<br />
Although the problems of gender-based violence are very<br />
widespread and generally acknowledged, both donor countries<br />
and partner countries need to do a lot more in terms of carrying<br />
out effective measures to combat such violence.<br />
Entry points for dialogue on gender-based violence<br />
Gender-based violence, and sexual violence in particular, that<br />
is carried out by men against women and girls increases the<br />
spread of hiv, the numbers of unsafe abortions and maternal<br />
mortality, and restricts women’s freedom of movement and<br />
impacts negatively on their possibilities for education, work,<br />
and ability to participate in and influence public life and<br />
political processes.<br />
Violence against women is a problem not only for individuals<br />
but for society as a whole, and has negative effects on a number<br />
of important social areas. The costs can be significant, not only<br />
economically but also in terms of suffering for the woman, her<br />
family and society as a whole.<br />
Gender-based violence is a public health problem and a<br />
security issue. It is also the issue that many multilateral bodies<br />
and women’s rights organisations around the world currently<br />
consider to be the most serious threat to women’s rights,<br />
lives, health and well-being. Several important social institutions<br />
need to work together to map the situation in specific<br />
countries and formulate effective strategies for what should be<br />
done. Research, data collection, legislation and skilled health<br />
44
Sweden’s position and key message: Gender-based<br />
violence is a major global problem. Violence restricts<br />
the opportunities for people to enjoy their human<br />
rights, undermines security and the principles of the<br />
rule of law, and leads to major economic costs for society.<br />
care workers are needed. The planning and implementation of<br />
interventions should be carried out in collaboration with local<br />
authorities and with voluntary civil society organisations, that<br />
have broad experience and knowledge of the issues and can<br />
inspire more trust than state institutions among women and<br />
girls that have been subjected to violence. It is also important<br />
to work with trade and industry and other stakeholders and<br />
actors in the private sector.<br />
In 2000, the un Security Council adopted resolution 1325<br />
on Women, Peace and Security. This resolution was accompanied<br />
by resolution 1820 (2008), and resolutions 1888 and<br />
1889 (2009), which strengthen the states’ commitments and<br />
responsibility to fight conflict-related sexual violence. These<br />
resolutions are important tools and bases for working with<br />
issues concerning women’s rights in crisis, conflict and postconflict<br />
situations.<br />
Measures to combat and prevent gender-based violence are<br />
needed at different levels and in many different areas. Political<br />
will and initiative are required first and foremost. Legislation,<br />
effective police authorities, an well-functioning judicial system<br />
and a system for health care and other social services are also<br />
needed. Gender-based violence is accepted in many places or is<br />
considered to be a private and not a public matter. This means<br />
that violence is not prioritised highly enough by decision-makers<br />
and legislators in many countries.<br />
A number of frequently occurring assertions on<br />
gender-based violence are presented below, along<br />
with suggestions on how to address them:<br />
“Violence in the home is accepted by both<br />
women and men in our society. It is a private matter<br />
and something that belongs at home in the family.”<br />
Irrespective of the cultural, religious or traditional arguments<br />
used to defend violence against girls and women, violence<br />
is forbidden by law in most countries and is a violation of<br />
people’s human rights. An important part of the fight against<br />
gender-based violence is legislation against all forms of sexual<br />
violence including domestic violence and customary practices<br />
such as female gender mutilation., as well as a state that<br />
observes the rule of law and ensures that laws are observed.<br />
“Gender-based violence is a marginal<br />
issue in the fight against poverty.”<br />
Gender-based violence has far-reaching consequences on<br />
women’s lives and health, and subsequently for families and<br />
society as a whole. In addition to the physical and psychological<br />
injuries arising from the violence itself, gender-based violence<br />
also leads to impaired reproductive health, often resulting<br />
in injuries or death during pregnancy or childbirth. Genderbased<br />
violence also means that women and girls in particular<br />
are more vulnerable to sexually transmitted infections and hiv<br />
infection. The deterioration in women’s health as a result of<br />
gender-based violence means that their productivity falls, as<br />
does their ability to look after their families. It is negative for<br />
social development and therefore also a country’s prospects of<br />
effectively combating poverty.<br />
57. Ministry for Foreign Affairs, Sweden’s International Policy on Sexual and<br />
Reproductive Health and Rights (2006), p. 17.<br />
58. unfpa, State of the World Population report (2005); who, Multi-country study<br />
on Women’s Health and Domestic Violence against Women (2005); un, Ending<br />
Violence against women: from words to action. Study of the Secretary-General<br />
(2006).<br />
59. unfpa, A Holistic Approach to the Abandonment of Female Genital Mutilation /<br />
Cutting (2007).<br />
45
Annex I SRHR: Definitions,<br />
terms and concepts<br />
When srhr issues are being discussed and negotiated at the<br />
international and global level, there is always a certain amount<br />
of opposition based on religious, traditional and political<br />
grounds. There are certain concepts and topics that are particularly<br />
questioned. It is important to be familiar with srhr concepts,<br />
including those that cause a great deal of debate internationally,<br />
even if they do not apply to all political contexts and<br />
even though different words may have different meanings in different<br />
places. This knowledge can be helpful when identifying<br />
entry points to introduce discussion on srhr issues and bringing<br />
them up in a dialogue process. For example, the concept of srhr<br />
itself is not accepted in many contexts.<br />
What is SRHR?<br />
Sexual and reproductive health is defined in the Programme<br />
of Action from the un Conference on Population and Development<br />
(icpd Programme of Action, PoA) in Cairo in 1994. In this<br />
definition, sexual health is included in the concept of reproductive<br />
health.<br />
“a state of complete physical, mental and social wellbeing<br />
and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity, in all matters<br />
relating to the reproductive system and to its functions and<br />
processes. Reproductive health therefore implies that people are<br />
able to have a satisfying and safe sex life and that they have the<br />
capacity to reproduce and the freedom to decide if, when and<br />
how often to do so. Implicit in this last condition are the right<br />
of men and women to be informed and to have access to safe,<br />
effective, affordable and acceptable methods of family planning<br />
of their choice, as well as other methods of their choice<br />
for regulation of fertility which are not against the law, and<br />
the right of access to appropriate health-care services that will<br />
enable women to go safely through pregnancy and childbirth<br />
and provide couples with the best chance of having a healthy<br />
infant.”(icpd PoA 7.2)<br />
For Sweden, it is important to stress the fact that sexuality<br />
refers not only to reproduction, which is why Sweden uses<br />
both concepts of ‘sexual’ and ‘reproductive’ health. When issues<br />
surrounding people’s sexuality are referred to and discussed in<br />
international contexts, the debate often focuses on problems<br />
and negative dimensions. The positive aspects and functions of<br />
sexuality and the fact that it can increase people’s quality of<br />
life are usually ignored. Sweden wants instead to highlight the<br />
fact that the purpose of good sexual health is to provide people<br />
with the same opportunities, rights and conditions to enable<br />
them to accept their sexuality and make informed decisions<br />
about their own bodies.<br />
Reproductive health<br />
Good reproductive health requires, for example, good maternal<br />
health care, i.e. services for maternity and childbirth care; this<br />
includes emergency obstetric care and knowledge of sexuality and<br />
reproduction, as well as access to contraception and safe abortion.<br />
Reproductive rights<br />
According to icpd, reproductive rights are defined as the right<br />
to freely decide the number, spacing and timing of children and<br />
to have the information and education, as well as the means<br />
required to be able to exercise this right.<br />
Reproductive rights are often debated and are the subject<br />
of controversy, because they also include the right to limit the<br />
number of children people have and therefore indirectly the<br />
right to contraception and to abortion. Although abortion is<br />
not included explicitly in references to reproductive rights in<br />
international human rights conventions, Sweden sees this as an<br />
important issue within the framework of, for example, women’s<br />
right to health and the right to make decisions about their own<br />
childbearing as set out in Articles 12 and 16 of the un Convention<br />
on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against<br />
Women (cedaw).<br />
Sexual rights<br />
So far, sexual rights have not been defined in international<br />
agreements. This is because issues surrounding human rights<br />
relating to sexuality are considered to be too controversial by<br />
some states.<br />
Sweden’s position is that sexual rights are part of the human<br />
rights as defined in the international framework which is comprised<br />
of the un conventions. This means that people, irrespective<br />
of sex, ethnic background, disabilities, gender identity or<br />
sexual orientation, are entitled to make decisions about their<br />
47
own body and sexuality, and should not be subjected to discrimination,<br />
harassment or violence. This includes, inter alia,<br />
the right to choose their own partner, to say yes or no to sex,<br />
and to decide if and when they want to have children.<br />
In a report from 2002, the World Health Organisation<br />
defines sexual rights as follows:<br />
Sexual rights embrace human rights that are already recognized<br />
in national laws, international human rights documents<br />
and other consensus statements. They include the right of all<br />
persons, free of coercion, discrimination and violence, to:<br />
• the highest attainable standard of sexual health, including<br />
access to sexual and reproductive health care services;<br />
• seek, receive and impart information related to sexuality;<br />
• sexuality education;<br />
• respect for bodily integrity;<br />
• choose their partner;<br />
• decide to be sexually active or not;<br />
• consensual sexual relations;<br />
• consensual marriage;<br />
• decide whether or not, and when, to have children; and<br />
• pursue a satisfying, safe and pleasurable sexual life. 61<br />
The International Planned Parenthood Federation, ippf, is<br />
an umbrella organisation that includes srhr member organisations<br />
from around the world. It has produced a declaration that<br />
presents sexual rights as human rights. The ippf declaration is<br />
based on human rights and shows how they are linked to sexuality<br />
and physical integrity. 62<br />
LGBT, sexual orientation and same-sex relationships<br />
In many countries, consensual sexual acts between two<br />
people of the same sex are criminalised and same-sex love<br />
relationships and family formations are illegal. This is basically<br />
a matter that relates to the non-discrimination principle<br />
and everyone’s equal value, human rights and the ability to<br />
take responsibility for and make decisions about their own<br />
body. It is also a democratic issue, whereby individuals on the<br />
basis of shared group identities, interests and struggles are<br />
able to work together with others to contribute to common,<br />
democratic work and discussions, without being subjected to<br />
violence or discrimination.<br />
Culture<br />
Culture includes collective values, knowledge, concepts,<br />
customs and traditions which are created and used by people<br />
to understand the world and interpret their surroundings and<br />
circumstances, and to give meaning to their existence. All<br />
people belong to and are influenced by a cultural sphere that<br />
influences their behaviour, norms and actions. Although culture<br />
affects how people think, it does not give rise to people who<br />
all think in exactly the same way. Cultural background is one<br />
of the most important identity markers for how people orient<br />
and define themselves in life. Cultures are in no way static,<br />
but are in a continual state of change. They influence and are<br />
influenced by both internal and external events and processes.<br />
Different cultures meet and interact, leading to changes in<br />
cultural patterns, traditions and values. These processes can be<br />
both enriching and frightening. Questioning your own culture<br />
and what your culture consists of can also lead to a feeling of<br />
insecurity and exclusion.<br />
References to culture and religion are often used as a way of<br />
restricting people’s rights, and this is particularly true of sexual<br />
and reproductive rights. Cultural or religious arguments are<br />
often used to counteract work towards gender equality and<br />
women’s enjoyment of their human rights.<br />
Abortion<br />
Legal and safe abortion is one of the most controversial issues,<br />
and there are no binding international agreements that portray<br />
this as a rights issue. The un Conference on Population and<br />
Development (icpd) stated that abortions must be safe where<br />
they are legal; this is as far as people have come in international<br />
negotiations. Abortions are included in negotiation texts in relation<br />
to unsafe abortions, i.e. as a health issue and not a human<br />
rights issue.<br />
Abstinence<br />
Sexual abstinence and fidelity in a heterosexual relationship are<br />
portrayed by some people as the best and only way of preventing<br />
hiv and unwanted pregnancies. However, for most people,<br />
abstinence is not a realistic alternative over a long period of<br />
time or over a lifetime.<br />
48
One-sided messages and campaigns for abstinence have not<br />
shown positive results and cannot stop unwanted pregnancies<br />
or the spread of hiv. Most women and men have sex sooner or<br />
later in their lives. Studies have shown that if people have more<br />
knowledge, their sexual debut takes place later in life, and that<br />
people who receive sexuality education and access to contraception<br />
protect themselves better against sexually transmitted<br />
infections and unwanted pregnancies.<br />
Family/Families<br />
There is currently not a uniform definition of family, even<br />
though this concept has been an important and controversial<br />
concept for a long time. In Western contexts, family is defined<br />
traditionally as the nuclear family – mother, father, child. The<br />
expression advocated by Sweden “families or various forms<br />
of the family, different types of families or other unions” is<br />
interpreted by some people as meaning same-sex relationships,<br />
which they do not accept. In many parts of the world, extended<br />
families are common and much more complex than simply the<br />
nuclear family, so it is important to talk about families and different<br />
kinds of family and not simply the nuclear family that is<br />
often presented as standard.<br />
Family planning<br />
Family planning is a concept that might not appear to be very<br />
controversial at first sight, but just as is the case with the concept<br />
of family in the discussion above, family planning can exclude<br />
people that do not belong to a traditional family formation. Family<br />
planning includes providing information, advice, methods,<br />
services and the means to allow people to plan the number of<br />
children they want and when to have them. Family planning as a<br />
concept consequently excludes people who are not married or<br />
planning a family. It is important for all people who need reproductive<br />
health services to be included regardless of their marital<br />
status, and it is also important to integrate this dimension into<br />
the prevention of sexually transmitted infections, including hiv.<br />
Rights of adults versus the rights of young people<br />
Opponents of srhr believe that parents or other adults have<br />
the right to make decisions about the sexual and reproductive<br />
health of young people. The population conference in Cairo in<br />
1994 included a great deal of discussion about young people’s<br />
rights. The final document was a compromise, where parents’<br />
rights and obligations to provide young people with health<br />
information were included, but the document also recognised<br />
the right of young people to education, information and health<br />
care in order to enable them to make their own informed<br />
decisions. The obstacles that exist for young people to gain<br />
access to information based on facts, and contraception, condoms,<br />
health care and counselling must be overcome.<br />
Couples, individuals and groups<br />
It is an individual’s right to have access to sexual and reproductive<br />
health care services. In many societies, individuals are considered<br />
to be inseparable members of a group and a context, defined<br />
in terms of specific social and cultural parameters. This means<br />
that people’s sexuality and reproduction are considered to be a<br />
collective and not a private matter. This view forms the basis for<br />
denying in particular unmarried people, women and young people<br />
the right to control over their own sex life and to the sexual and<br />
reproductive health care and services associated with this.<br />
Sexual orientation and gender identity<br />
There is still no binding international consensus document<br />
which explicitly names sexual orientation as a form of discrimination,<br />
even though documents do exist that would<br />
easily make this interpretation possible. In the un General<br />
Assembly in December 2008, a declaration on lgbt people’s<br />
rights was presented for the first time. This declaration was<br />
produced by a inter-regional group of un Member States, and<br />
has so far been signed by nearly 70 states, including all eu<br />
member states and the usa.<br />
Sexuality<br />
Sexuality is an important aspect of people’s lives. It includes<br />
sex, desire, gender identity and gender roles, sexual orientation,<br />
enjoyment, intimacy and reproduction. Sexuality is also<br />
closely linked to power, and sexuality and has been controlled<br />
in different ways throughout history. Women’s sexuality in<br />
particular has been, and often still is, controlled by traditions<br />
49
and customs. Sexuality is far more than just the act of sexual<br />
intercourse, according to the definition given by who. 63 Sexuality<br />
is a part of being a human being, but this does not mean<br />
it is something determined by nature. Sexuality is shaped and<br />
changed by religion, legislation and the historical, economic,<br />
social and culture context in which a person lives and has her or<br />
his being.<br />
60. Ministry for Foreign Affairs, Sweden’s International Policy of Sexual and<br />
Reproductive Health and Rights, p.23 (2006).<br />
61. who, Defining sexual health. Report of a technical consultation on sexual<br />
health. 28–31 January 2002, Geneva (2002).<br />
62. ippf, Sexual Rights: an ippf Declaration (2008).<br />
63. who, Defining sexual health. Report of a technical consultation on sexual<br />
health. 28 –31 January 2002, Geneva (2002).<br />
50
Annex II Points of departure<br />
and Mandates for work with SRHR<br />
The mandate and points of departure for work on sexual and<br />
reproductive health and rights can be found in several Swedish<br />
national steering documents, as well as in international frameworks<br />
and Sweden’s commitments with respect to these.<br />
Sweden was the first country in the world to adopt a specific<br />
srhr policy, Sweden’s International Policy for Sexual and Reproductive<br />
Health and Rights in 2006. This policy aims to provide<br />
the foundation for Sweden’s international bilateral, multilateral,<br />
operational and normative work in the area of sexual and<br />
reproductive health and rights. The policy sets out a number<br />
of strategic areas for Sweden’s international srhr work. They<br />
include working to strengthen women’s sexual and reproductive<br />
health and rights, young people’s health and rights, the role and<br />
responsibility of men in gender equality work, lgbt rights, safe<br />
abortions, access to contraception and sexuality education, as<br />
well as combating gender-based violence and violence against<br />
women and girls. This srhr policy is based on international<br />
agreements on human rights.<br />
Sweden’s Policy for Global Development, pgd, the aim of<br />
which is to contribute to equitable and sustainable global development.<br />
It is characterised by policy coherence across all areas<br />
of policy and political action, and forms the main basis for the<br />
Swedish Government’s development policy and for international<br />
development cooperation. The goal for development cooperation<br />
in pgd is to contribute to an environment supportive of poor<br />
people’s own efforts to improve their quality of life. Two fundamental<br />
perspectives permeate this policy: a rights perspective<br />
and the perspectives of poor people on development. The pgd<br />
states that all people, irrespective of sex, age, disability, ethnic<br />
background or sexual orientation should be able to exercise and<br />
enjoy their human rights, including their sexual and reproductive<br />
health and rights (srhr). In the Government’s pgd Communication<br />
to the Riksdag (Swedish Parliament) 2007/08:89 and<br />
2009 /10:129, srhr is included as a special focus area within the<br />
global challenges of ‘Oppression’, and essential to achieving the<br />
target of equitable and sustainable global development.<br />
The Right to a Future – Policy for Sweden’s International hiv<br />
and aids work was adopted in 2008. It states that Sweden must<br />
prioritise in particular hiv prevention work and the alleviation<br />
of long-term effects. This work must be based on the requirement<br />
for strong respect for human rights and greater gender<br />
equality. The work must mainly be aimed at promoting better<br />
conditions and opportunities for women and girls, young people<br />
and groups that run a high risk of being infected with hiv and<br />
dying prematurely of aids.<br />
UN Conventions and SRHR<br />
The un Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the subsequent<br />
central conventions on human rights stress the principles<br />
of non-discrimination and the equal value of every person. The<br />
Universal Declaration provided the international community<br />
with a common set of values on the relationship between the<br />
state and the individual, and set a standard for human rights<br />
which is superordinate to political, economic, social, cultural<br />
and religious differences. The conventions and the recommendations<br />
that have been produced in the un convention committees<br />
are important tools and bases for dialogue and collaboration,<br />
and for following up the obligations contained in the<br />
conventions.<br />
UN conferences on population<br />
and on women in the 1990s<br />
International agreements concerning srhr issues were more<br />
specifically achieved in the middle of the 1990s at two major<br />
and important un meetings: the International Conference on<br />
Population and Development icpd in Cairo in 1994 and the<br />
Fourth World Conference on Women in Beijing in 1995. icpd<br />
dealt with the individual’s possibilities of achieving the highest<br />
attainable standard of sexual and reproductive health, and<br />
inter alia stated that abortions must be safe where they are<br />
legal. The Programme of Action stated the need to invest in<br />
maternal health, sexual information, access to contraception<br />
and gender equality.<br />
The Conference on Women in Beijing confirmed the decisions<br />
taken at icpd and the importance of work for gender equality and<br />
women’s empowerment, education, work, political participation<br />
and freedom from violence. The 1995 Conference on Women<br />
also stated that women’s power and ability to decide over their<br />
own sexuality and reproduction is an important step to ensure<br />
that they can fully exercise and enjoy their human rights.<br />
52
Sweden´s Strategic Areas for International SRHR<br />
Safe and<br />
Legal<br />
Abortion<br />
Empowering<br />
Women and<br />
Girls<br />
Hiv/Aids<br />
and<br />
STIs<br />
Neonatel<br />
Care<br />
Adolescent<br />
Health and<br />
Rights<br />
Role of<br />
Men and<br />
Boys<br />
Sexual and<br />
Reproductive<br />
Health and<br />
Rights<br />
Maternity<br />
Care<br />
Contraceptives<br />
LGBT<br />
Persons<br />
Capacitybuilding<br />
Genderbased<br />
Violence<br />
Sexuality<br />
Education<br />
Prostitution/<br />
Human<br />
Trafficking<br />
UN General Assembly Special Session on HIV and AIDS<br />
In 2001 the world’s leaders gathered together for a summit on<br />
hiv and aids, the un General Assembly Special Session on hiv and<br />
aids, hiv-ungass. The Declaration from hiv-ungass 2001 points<br />
out the importance of gender equality and women’s empowerment<br />
for stopping the spread of the hiv epidemic. hiv-ungass<br />
was followed up in 2006, where it was established that all people<br />
must have access to broad prevention measures as well as health<br />
care services and treatment by 2010. The declaration also<br />
included substantial attention to the need for young people to<br />
have access to contraception and information about hiv.<br />
The Millennium Declaration<br />
and Millennium Development Goals<br />
At the un Summit in 2000, all member states adopted the Millennium<br />
Declaration. This is an agreement on global collaboration,<br />
a common agenda for global development operationalised<br />
through eight measurable and time-bound millennium goals.<br />
srhr is not included as a goal in itself but are rather largely<br />
restricted to Millennium Development Goal 5 on improving<br />
maternal health. However, srhr is of vital importance for achieving<br />
all the Millennium Development Goals, particularly the<br />
health targets for reducing child mortality (goal 4), maternal<br />
morality (goal 5) and stopping the spread of hiv/aids (goal 6).<br />
In 2002 the then un Secretary-General, Kofi Annan, commissioned<br />
a group of experts to produce a programme of action<br />
to achieve the Millennium Development Goals. Their analysis<br />
highlighted the fact that sexual reproductive health was essential<br />
to achieve the Millennium Development Goals. 64 In 2006 an<br />
important new target was added to Millennium Development<br />
Goal 5, Universal access to reproductive health.<br />
Paris Declaration on Aid Effectiveness<br />
The Paris Declaration from 2005 set new guidelines for delivering<br />
and following up development aid flows, and stressed the<br />
importance of coordination between donors within the framework<br />
of the partner country’s active ownership and leadership.<br />
The principles contained in the Paris Agenda have led to more<br />
investments in programme support and sector support, rather<br />
than investments in small-scale projects with a limited impact.<br />
The partner countries themselves must be able to manage the<br />
funds they receive based on national priorities. Sector support<br />
has many advantages and incredible potential, but some issues<br />
risk being left in the shade or disappearing completely, unless<br />
there is the knowledge, capacity and willingness to prioritise<br />
them in the partner country. Dialogue on policy is one of the<br />
most important instruments for being able to influence how aid<br />
is used.<br />
Millennium goal 5: Improve Maternal Health<br />
Target 5.A: Reduce by three quarters, between 1990<br />
and 2015, the maternal mortality ratio<br />
Indicators<br />
5.1 Maternal mortality ratio<br />
5.2 Proportion of births attended by skilled health personnel<br />
Target 5.B: Achieve, by 2015, universal access to<br />
reproductive health<br />
Indicators<br />
5.3 Contraceptive prevalence rate<br />
5.4 Adolescent birth rate<br />
5.5 Antenatal care coverage (at least one visit and at least<br />
four visits)<br />
5.6 Unmet need for family planning<br />
www.mdgmonitor.org/goal5.cfm<br />
64. Bernstein, S & Juul Hansen, C, Public Choices, Private Decisions: Sexual and<br />
Reproductive Health and the Millennium Development Goals (2006).<br />
53
Annex III<br />
SRHR and the EU<br />
The protection of human rights is a core value and central<br />
principle in the eu. The eu Charter of Fundamental Rights<br />
supplements and clarifies this principle. All eu member states<br />
are bound by human rights treaties such as the European<br />
Convention, the Convention on the Rights of the Child and the<br />
Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination<br />
Against Women. All eu member states are also united around<br />
the programmes of action from Cairo and Beijing. 65 All these<br />
instruments guarantee sexual and reproductive rights to some<br />
extent. Here are a number of examples of Council Conclusions<br />
adopted by the eu:<br />
At a gaerc (Ministerial) meeting in November 2004, policy<br />
decisions in the form of Council Conclusions were adopted for<br />
a renewed commitment to icpd and the Millennium Development<br />
Goals.<br />
“The council recognises that additional resources are needed<br />
to enable a prompt implementation of the icpd agenda by focusing<br />
in particular on sexual and reproductive health and rights,<br />
and encourages ec and Member States to provide financing<br />
through geographical and thematic instruments, multi sector<br />
support and/or budget support and through additional<br />
resources from the un and other international development<br />
agencies.”<br />
In addition to this, there are the Council Conclusions<br />
adopted at gaerc April 2007 on ‘Recently emerging issues<br />
regarding hiv/aids’, which focus on the feminisation of the hiv<br />
epidemic and the needs of young people. They also point out<br />
the importance of integrating hiv/aids into national development<br />
plans and aid programmes. During this meeting, Council<br />
Conclusions were also adopted on gender equality and women’s<br />
empowerment in development cooperation. The Council<br />
Conclusions refer to icpd, cedaw, Beijing and the Millennium<br />
Development Goals.<br />
The joint eu statement before the un General Assembly<br />
Commemoration of the 15th Anniversary of icpd on 12 October<br />
2009 stressed the importance of investing in srhr and women’s<br />
rights.<br />
“The eu recognises that the right to attain the highest<br />
standard of health, including sexual and reproductive health,<br />
is a basis for action. The incorporation of the icpd agenda into<br />
national development strategies – especially in national health<br />
policies, strategies, programmes and budgets – is a prerequisite<br />
for achieving the Millennium Development Goals.”<br />
Joakim Stymne, State Secretary, International Development<br />
Cooperation at the Swedish Ministry for Foreign Affairs.<br />
When new members join the eu, there is certain opposition<br />
to srhr, particularly with regard to the issue of abortion. Formulations<br />
that, for example, include the word ‘services’ in relation<br />
to sexual and reproductive health and rights are difficult to<br />
get accepted due to suspicions that they could represent covert<br />
language for abortions. In the eu, abortion is only completely<br />
illegal in Malta. Some other member states have restrictions on<br />
abortion, for example Poland and Ireland.<br />
Sweden has been working with other like-minded member<br />
states in the eu to actively pursue a line of action that safeguards<br />
srhr issues, defends the eu’s policy, work and acquis, and<br />
shows leadership towards and through support to non-member<br />
countries. srhr has tended to divide the eu into three groups:<br />
one group that thinks along the lines of Sweden; a group that<br />
prefers a joint eu position and is very flexible when it comes<br />
to concrete formulations about srhr; and a group that opposes<br />
texts on sexual rights or reproductive and sexual health care<br />
services because they may provide an opening to abortion.<br />
65. Malta registered a reservation in writing against the use of terms such as<br />
‘reproductive rights’ in icpd.<br />
55
Annex IV<br />
Organisations in the SRHR area<br />
Where can you find relevant<br />
information about SRHR?<br />
Information about Sweden’s srhr work can be found at the Ministry<br />
for Foreign Affairs and Sida.<br />
For countries that Sweden collaborates with in different<br />
ways, the best and most up-to-date information about the srhr<br />
situation and needs can be obtained from local stakeholders and<br />
other actors. There are also a number of national, regional and<br />
international organisations that work with policy development,<br />
methodology development and advocacy work which can provide<br />
more access to knowledge, arguments and networks. In this<br />
annex, there is information about a number of organisations and<br />
stakeholders that can provide in-depth knowledge about srhr<br />
both in Sweden and around the world.<br />
<strong>RFSU</strong><br />
(Swedish Association for Sexuality Education) is a Swedish nonprofit<br />
organisation that works with sexual and reproductive<br />
health and rights both in Sweden and abroad through information,<br />
advocacy work and partnerships in the Global South.<br />
www.rfsu.se<br />
RFSL<br />
(Swedish Federation for Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender<br />
Rights) is a national Swedish organisation that has been working<br />
for lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender rights since 1950<br />
by informing, influencing and implementing change work in<br />
Sweden and around the world.<br />
www.rfsl.se<br />
ilga<br />
rfsl is a member of the International Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual,<br />
Trans and Intersex Association, ilga, which is an umbrella organisation<br />
for lgbt rights in the world. ilga has member organisations<br />
throughout the world and a number of regional offices.<br />
www.ilga.org<br />
ippf<br />
International Planned Parenthood Federation, ippf is an umbrella<br />
organisation that includes srhr member organisations all over the<br />
world, with rfsu being the Swedish member. ippf is found in more<br />
than 150 countries and works with information, outreach work,<br />
clinic activities, advocacy work and advice in the area of srhr.<br />
ippf has its head office in London with regional offices in Nairobi<br />
(for Africa), Tunis (for the Arab world), Brussels (for Europe),<br />
New Delhi (for South Asia), Kuala Lumpur (for East Asia and<br />
Oceania) and New York (for the Western Hemisphere).<br />
www.ippf.org<br />
There are a number of un bodies that work with srhr in various<br />
ways:<br />
unfpa<br />
unfpa is the un Population Fund that works with monitoring and<br />
implementing the Programme of Action from icpd. This organisation<br />
has relevant documents relating to srhr, as well as facts<br />
and statistics on reproductive health, young people and maternal<br />
health in particular.<br />
www.unfpa.org<br />
unaids<br />
unaids works with hiv and aids and has information about policy<br />
development in this area, facts and statistics, as well as material<br />
and methodology development.<br />
www.unaids.org<br />
unicef<br />
Unicef works with children and young people and has many<br />
statistics and facts about young people’s living conditions, hiv<br />
and srhr.<br />
www.unicef.org<br />
who<br />
who works broadly with health and health promotion work, but<br />
also with srhr and related issues.<br />
www.who.int<br />
In September 2009 the UN General Assembly adopted a<br />
resolution to improve the cohesion work on gender equality and<br />
women’s rights within the un system. Four existing un bodies<br />
56
(unifem, Division for the Advancement of Women, Office of the<br />
Special Adviser on Gender Issues and un-instraw) will merge to<br />
become one, headed by an Under Secretary-General. The new<br />
entity, ‘un Women’ headed by usg Michelle Bachelet will become<br />
operational in January of 2011.<br />
A number of stakeholders in civil society work with srhr in<br />
different ways. They can be a good source of facts, arguments,<br />
information about new projects, methodology development and<br />
advocacy material:<br />
guttmacher institute<br />
Guttmacher Institute, is a research organisation that produces<br />
research reports on srhr, young people and sexuality in the usa<br />
and in developing countries. They have interesting information<br />
and research on sexuality education, contraception, abortion<br />
and teenage pregnancies.<br />
www.guttmacher.org<br />
raise<br />
raise, is a campaign that works to raise awareness of the need<br />
for srhr in humanitarian situations. It has facts, statistics and<br />
arguments for including srhr in humanitarian aid.<br />
www.raiseinitiative.org<br />
ipas<br />
ipas is an organisation that works with women’s sexual and<br />
reproductive rights and in particular with reducing abortionrelated<br />
deaths and injuries.<br />
www.ipas.org<br />
Catholics for Choice<br />
Catholics for Choice is an American organisation that works to<br />
influence legislation and attitudes regarding sexuality, contraception<br />
and abortion using a Catholic perspective. They are<br />
based in the usa, Europe and Latin America.<br />
www.catholicsforchoice.org<br />
Center for Reproductive Rights<br />
Center for Reproductive Rights is an organisation that uses<br />
the law to pursue reproductive rights, such as human rights,<br />
and work to ensure that states protect, respect and fulfil their<br />
obligations in terms of reproductive rights. The Center for<br />
Reproductive Rights works with advocacy and change work in<br />
Africa, Asia, Europe, Latin America and the Caribbean, as well<br />
as in the USA.<br />
www.reproductiverights.org<br />
Population Action International<br />
Population Action International, pai, is an American organisation<br />
that works throughout the world to secure access to<br />
sexual and reproductive health and rights. pai works with<br />
policy development in srhr and development aid and focuses on<br />
ensuring access to contraception, condoms and other healthcare<br />
equipment.<br />
www.populationaction.org<br />
International Women’s Health Coalition<br />
International Women’s Health Coalition, iwhc, is an American<br />
organisation that works with women’s rights and sexual and<br />
reproductive health and rights around the world. iwhc works<br />
with policy development and capacity building through the un<br />
system and by financing and developing advocacy work in different<br />
parts of the world.<br />
www.iwhc.org<br />
Sexuality Information and<br />
Education Council of the United States<br />
Sexuality Information and Education Council of the United<br />
States, siecus, is an American organisation that works with disseminating<br />
information about sexuality and sexual and reproductive<br />
health. siecus works with education, advocacy work<br />
and information to create support for comprehensive sexuality<br />
education.<br />
www.siecus.org<br />
Marie Stopes International<br />
Marie Stopes International, msi, is a non-profit organisation that<br />
works on improving sexual and reproductive health and rights.<br />
They are represented in 43 countries around the world and they<br />
have a large number of clinics with contraception advice, safe<br />
57
abortions, maternal and child health, as well as hiv testing and<br />
services. They also carry out policy and advocacy work at both<br />
a global and national level.<br />
www.mariestopes.org<br />
Association for Women’s Rights in Development<br />
Association for Women’s Rights in Development, awid, is an<br />
organisation that works for women’s human rights in development.<br />
awid develops and produces reports and materials to<br />
strengthen policy and work for women.<br />
www.awid.org<br />
Reproductive Health Supplies Coalition<br />
Reproductive Health Supplies Coalition is a network of state,<br />
private and non-profit organisations which aims to provide<br />
people in low- and middle-income countries with access to<br />
contraception, condoms, healthcare equipment and medicines<br />
in order to ensure reproductive health. Reproductive Health<br />
Supplies Coalition works with advocacy work, capacity building,<br />
advice and technical support around the world.<br />
www.rhsupplies.org<br />
The International Gay and<br />
Lesbian Human Rights Commission<br />
The International Gay and Lesbian Human Rights Commission,<br />
iglhrc is an advocacy organisation that works to make people<br />
aware of and fight discrimination of lgbt people around the<br />
world.<br />
www.iglhrc.org<br />
Knowledge-support and consultancy companies<br />
Knowledge-support and consultancy companies, such as the<br />
Stockholm-based InDevelop-ipm Consortium, work with studies<br />
and advisory services on gender equality and srhr issues on a<br />
commercial basis.<br />
www.indevelop-ipm.se<br />
58
Annex V<br />
Links and references<br />
Policies<br />
Sweden’s Policy for Global Development (pgd)<br />
Sweden’s International Policy for Sexual and Reproductive<br />
Health and Rights (2006)<br />
Mänskliga rättigheter i svensk utrikespolitik [Human Rights<br />
in Swedish Foreign Policy]<br />
The Right to a Future – Policy for Sweden’s International hiv<br />
and aids work (2009)<br />
Pluralism – Policy for Sweden’s Support to Civil Society in<br />
Developing Countries in Swedish Development Cooperation<br />
(2009)<br />
Change for Freedom – Policy for Democratic Development and<br />
Human Rights within Swedish Development Collaboration<br />
2010–2014<br />
On Equal footing – Policy on gender equality and the rights<br />
and role of women in Sweden’s international development<br />
cooperation 2010–2015<br />
Programmes of Action<br />
Plan of Action for Sida’s Work on Gender-Based Violence<br />
2008–2010<br />
Plan of Action for Concretising Sida’s work with lbgt-issues<br />
in Development Cooperation 2007–2009.<br />
Conventions<br />
European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and<br />
Fundamental Freedoms (European Convention) (1950)<br />
un, Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (iccpr) (1966)<br />
un, International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural<br />
Rights (icescr) (1966)<br />
un, Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of<br />
Discriminationof Women (cedaw) (1979)<br />
un, Convention on the Rights of the Child (1989)<br />
Declarations and resolutions<br />
World Conferences<br />
Programme of Action of Adopted at the International<br />
Conference on Population and Development (icpd) (1994)<br />
Beijing Declaration and Platform for Action (1995)<br />
un General Assembly<br />
Key Actions for the Further Implementation of the Programme<br />
of Action of the icpd – icpd+5 (a/res/s-21/2) (1999)<br />
Follow-up to the Programme of Action of the International<br />
Conference on Population and Development – icpd+10<br />
(e/cn.9 /2004/9) (2004)<br />
United Nations General Assembly Declaration of Commitment<br />
on HIV/AIDS (Resolution s-26/2) (– hiv ungass 2001)<br />
Political Declaration on hiv/aids (a/res/60/262)<br />
(– hiv ungass 2006)<br />
United Nations. Millennium Declaration (A/RES/55/2) (2000)<br />
oecd Paris Declaration on Aid Effectiveness 2005<br />
un Security Council<br />
Resolution 11325 on Women Peace and Security<br />
(s /res /1325 (2000))<br />
Resolution 1820 on Women Peace and Security<br />
(s /res /1820 (2008)).<br />
Resolution 1888 on Women Peace and Security<br />
(s /res /1888 (2009))<br />
Resolution 1889 on Women, Peace and Security<br />
(s /res /1889 (2009))<br />
un Human Rights Council<br />
Resolution 11/8 (2009), Preventable maternal mortality and<br />
morbidity and human rights<br />
Regional Agreements<br />
african union<br />
The Protocol to the African Charter on Human and Peoples’<br />
Rights on the Rights of Women in Africa, 2003<br />
Africa Health Strategy 2007–2015<br />
Plan of action on sexual and reproductive health and rights<br />
(Maputo Plan of Action), 2006<br />
european union<br />
Council Conclusions on the Cairo Agenda about Population<br />
and Development adopted on 23 November 2004 (15157/04)<br />
Council Conclusions on hiv/aids adopted on 23 April 2007<br />
(7225/07)<br />
59
latin america and the caribbean<br />
Mexico City Declaration on Sex Education in Latin America<br />
and the Caribbean (2008)<br />
Informative reports and publications<br />
that can give facts and guidance<br />
Bernstein, S & Juul Hansen ,C, Public Choices, Private<br />
Decisions: Sexual and Reproductive Health and the<br />
Millennium Development Goals (2006)<br />
Cornwall, Corrêa, Jolly, Development with a Body. Sexuality,<br />
Human Rights and Development (2008)<br />
Guttmacher Iinstitute, Abortion worldwide. A decade of uneven<br />
progress (2009)<br />
Guttmacher Institute, unfpa, Adding it up. The benefits of<br />
investing in sexual and reproductive health care (2003)<br />
Guttmacher Iinstitute, Adding it up. The benefits of investing in<br />
sexual and reproductive health care (2009)<br />
ippf, Charter on Sexual and Reproductive Rights (2003)<br />
ippf, Sexual rights an ippf declaration (2008)<br />
Population Action International, Funding common ground.<br />
Cost estimates for international reproductive health (2010)<br />
rfsu, Breaking Through. A guide to sexual and reproductive<br />
health and rights (2004)<br />
rfsu, Fokus Kairo [Focus Cairo]. Tio år av kamp för sexuella<br />
och reproduktiva rättigheter [Ten Year of Battle for Sexual<br />
and Reproductive Rights] (2004)<br />
rfsu, Reality counts. Focusing on sexuality and rights in the<br />
fight against hiv /aids (2004)<br />
rfsu Respect choice. Safe abortion a prerequisite for safe<br />
motherhood (2004)<br />
Sida concept paper, Sexuality a missing dimension in<br />
development (2008)<br />
unifem, Progress of the world’s women 2008/2009. Who answers<br />
to women? Gender and accountability (2008)<br />
unesco, unfpa, Unicef, who, International Technical Guidance<br />
on sexuality education. An evidence-informed approach for<br />
schools, teachers and health educators (2009)<br />
who, Defining Sexual health. Report of a technical consultation<br />
on sexual health. 28 –31 January 2002, Geneva (2002)<br />
Thematic areas<br />
Maternal mortality<br />
Human Rights Council, Eleventh session, Agenda item 3<br />
unfpa, No Woman Should Die Giving Life (2008)<br />
unfpa, Giving Girls Today and Tomorrow; Breaking the cycle of<br />
adolescent pregnancy (2007)<br />
who, Unsafe abortion, Fifth edition (2007); ippf, Death and<br />
Denial – Unsafe Abortion and Poverty (2006)<br />
unfpa, who, Granada Consensus on Sexual and Reproductive<br />
Health in Protracted crises and recovery (2009)<br />
Bernstein, S & Juul Hansen, C, Public Choices, Private<br />
Decisions: Sexual and Reproductive Health and the<br />
Millennium Development Goals (2006)<br />
The Alan Guttmacher Institute & unfpa, Adding it up<br />
– The benefits of investing in sexual and reproductive health<br />
care (2003)<br />
Guttmacher institute & unfpa In Brief 2008 Series, No.5<br />
unfpa, State of the World Population (2005)<br />
who, Fact sheet who /mps/08.11, Skilled birth attendants (2008)<br />
Access to safe abortion<br />
ippf, Death and denial (2006)<br />
who, Unsafe abortion, Fifth edition (2007)<br />
unfpa, No Woman Should Die Giving Life (2008)<br />
Guttmacher Institute, Abortion worldwide. A decade of uneven<br />
progress (2009)<br />
rfsu, Breaking Through. A guide to sexual and reproductive<br />
health and rights (2004)<br />
unfpa, Healthy expectations. Celebrating achievements of the<br />
Cairo Consensus and highlighting the urgency for action<br />
(2009)<br />
Alan Guttmacher Institute, Sharing responsibility. Women<br />
society and abortion worldwide<br />
Young people and srhr<br />
Center for Global Development, Start with a Girl: A New<br />
Agenda for Global Health (2009)<br />
undesa, The Millennium Development Goals Report (2008)<br />
unfpa, State of the World Population (2005)<br />
60
unaids, 08 Report on the Global aids Epidemic (2008)<br />
unfpa, Giving girls today and tomorrow. Breaking the cycle of<br />
adolescent pregnancy (2007)<br />
Sex education<br />
Guttmacher Institute, Protecting the Next Generation in Sub-<br />
Saharan Africa (2007)<br />
undpi, Goal 2: Achieve Universal Primary Education (2008)<br />
Human rights Watch, The less they know, the better Abstinence-<br />
Only hiv /aids Programs in Uganda (2005)<br />
ippf, Reference guide to policies and practice. Sexuality education<br />
in Europe (2006)<br />
Gender-based violence<br />
unfpa, State of the World Population (2005)<br />
unfpa, A Holistic Approach to the Abandonment of<br />
Female Genital Mutilation/Cutting (2007)<br />
Condoms and contraception<br />
unfpa, No Woman Should Die Giving Life (2008)<br />
Guttmacher Institute, unfpa. Adding it Up – Costs and Benefits<br />
of Family Planning and Maternal and Newborn Health<br />
Services (2009)<br />
hiv and aids<br />
who, Towards universal access: scaling up priority hiv /aids<br />
interventions in the health sector. September 2009. Progress<br />
report (2009)<br />
unaids, 08 Report on the Global aids Epidemic (2009)<br />
Fact sheet for the High level event on the Millennium<br />
Development Goals, United Nations headquarters, New York,<br />
September 2008<br />
un General Assembly Sixty-fourth session, Agenda item 44<br />
Implementation of the Declaration of Commitment on hiv /aids<br />
and the Political Declaration on hiv /aids. Progress made in the<br />
implementation of the Declaration of Commitment on hiv /aids<br />
and the Political Declaration on hiv /aids. Report of the<br />
Secretary-General (2010)<br />
LGBT rights<br />
rfsl, Hbt i utveckling [lgbt in Development] (2008)<br />
yogyakartaprinciples.org<br />
61
Article nr: UD 10.053<br />
ISBN: 978-91-7496-426-4<br />
E-mail: information-ud@foreign.ministry.se<br />
Web site: www.regeringen.se<br />
Telephone: Int +46 (0)8 - 405 10 00<br />
Editor: Lina Granlund<br />
Illustrations: Eva Fallström and Hans Hillerström<br />
Layout: Urbom Production AB, Ready Steady<br />
Printed by: Brommatryck & Brolins AB, Stockholm, February 2011
Utrikesdepartementet<br />
103 39 Stockholm