The Campaigner
The Campaigner
The Campaigner
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
38<br />
uses ECT as a conditioning technique for inducing a (Susan begins to drink from the bottle. Like all of<br />
pseudo-identity, a new persona. Tien's patients, she has not eaten for five to six hours<br />
Tien premises his brainwashing on the idea that ECT prior to shock therapy.)<br />
TIEN: Have you ever been'_ bad girl, Susan?<br />
temporarily reduces an individual to the mental state of a SUSAN: Yeah. Sure.<br />
baby, erasing neurotic ideas and memories that can be TOM: No. Susan has never been'bad.<br />
replaced with "healthy" ones. He deliberately stimulates TIEN: Right, Tom. It's Laura who was bad, not Susan.<br />
unpleasant memories immediately prior to the shock TOM: No. Susan has never been'bad.<br />
TIEN: Right, Tom. It's Laura who was bad, not Susan.<br />
treatment, so that they can be "erased." <strong>The</strong>n with baby TOM: Susan's a good girl.<br />
bottles, chocolate milk (adults prefer it to white milk, he TIEN: Tell me, Susan, did your grandmother ever make<br />
finds) and cuddling by spouse or parent, he makes the you get in a doghouse?<br />
individual receptive to "new ideas." SUSAN: W-h-a?<br />
TOM: No. Susan's grandmother never did that. Laura's<br />
One of Tien's videotaped case histories, for example, grandmother did it.<br />
documents the transfoimation of a woman called TIEN: You're a new person now. Have you ever l_een'in<br />
"Laura," who saved her marriage by becoming a an orphanage?<br />
"Susan." <strong>The</strong> full transformation required 20 shock SUSAN: No, never.<br />
It is not the ECT itself that brainwashes. Laura did<br />
treatments, administered over a period of several<br />
months. A videotape film, one of hundreds m Tien's not acquire the persona of "Susan" because of shock<br />
library, recorded one of those sessions: therapy per se. In fact, while Tien sees ECT as desirable<br />
for "psychosynthesis, " he does not insist that it is<br />
(Laura is on a treatment table in St. Lawrence<br />
Hospital, attended by Tien and a nurse who places the mandatory. <strong>The</strong> new persona is acquired by submitting<br />
electrodes that connect Laura to the shock treatment to acts of self-degradation, -- regression to infancy;<br />
machine.) becoming a work slave; eating one's excrement, etc. m<br />
in the face of pain _ i.e. to halt the pain, as B.F.<br />
TIEN: Laura, I want you to think about yourself as Laura<br />
(when you were a child). What got you so upset that you Skinner puts it in his explanation of why "'aversive<br />
had to run away from home? conditioning" works better than mere punishment or<br />
LAURA: My grandmother. I had to live with her. She threats.<br />
used to beat me and she put me in'an orphanage. <strong>The</strong> painful stimuli could be physical n ECT,<br />
TIEN: Before that, what did she do? Remember what you<br />
told me intherapy? She made y_u sit in the doghouse in' beatings, starvation, etc., or emotional -- playing upon<br />
the yard and finally made you take the dog you loved l_o fears or neuroses. This is demonstrated in a simpler form<br />
the dog pound to be destroyed. 'What's upsetting you, by a couple of Vietnamese case studies published '<br />
Laura?<br />
LAURA: Nothing I can't remember, recently in Science News:<br />
TIEN:No? You mean the bad times were so bad you got Firstly: Chronic male patients (mostly schizophrenic)<br />
all mixed up? So now you want your husband to divorce were offered freedom if they proved they Could work. Of<br />
you and take your son away?<br />
130, only 10 volunteered to work. <strong>The</strong> rest were told they<br />
LAURA: NoI You're mixing me up. I never wanted that. needed 'treatment ' and were ' given 'electroconvulsive<br />
I want the divorce and I want my son with me. shock. After a few treatments, most of the men decided<br />
TIEN: Yes, it is all mixed up, isn't it? Do you remember<br />
to work.(20)<br />
running away? Just like your father ran away? Just like<br />
your mother ran away, leaving you with your grand- Secondly: A similar experiment 'was then tried on 130<br />
mother? Remember running away from the orphanage? women. Even after each had received 20 treatments,<br />
Remember running away from the foster home? IS it all only 15 were 'willing to work. Shock treatments were<br />
coming back? You are so desperal_e sometimes, and you discontinued and food was withheld for periods of up to<br />
feel so depressed, Laura. You can't put up with this any three days. <strong>The</strong> patients were eventually cured and went<br />
more. And now you want to run away from Tom to work tending crops for the Green Berets.(21)<br />
(husband). <strong>The</strong> point is clear: the mental patients were coerced<br />
and (ADr. rubber Tienmouth administers guard is'the inserte'd electricin shock. Laura'sLaura mouth, is into acquiring a slave's persona in order to escape the<br />
wheeled into an adjoining treatment room, where Tom is pain.<br />
waiting. <strong>The</strong> nurse hands Tom a baby bottle filled _vith Chemotherapy: Drugs are the "humanitarian's"<br />
chocolate<br />
TIEN: Susan,<br />
milk.)<br />
your husband is here.<br />
psychosurgery. <strong>The</strong>y are ESB and ECT all wrapped in "<br />
(Laura/Susan opens'her eyes and looks submissively one package. Drugs do the same thing n reduce or<br />
at Tom, who cuddles h'er in his arms and attempts to feed abort mental functioning -- and they are cheaper, more<br />
her from the baby bottle.) efficient, and better geared to turning people into<br />
TOM: SUSAN Come (childishly):I on Susan, don' drink wan' your it. milk. "functioning slaves" rather than incapacitated<br />
TOM: It's good for you. You're a good girl, aren'_ you? vegetables.