04.11.2014 Views

SIPANewS - School of International and Public Affairs - Columbia ...

SIPANewS - School of International and Public Affairs - Columbia ...

SIPANewS - School of International and Public Affairs - Columbia ...

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

January 2012<br />

SIPANews<br />

National<br />

Identity <strong>and</strong><br />

the power <strong>of</strong><br />

perception


SIPANEWS<br />

VOLUME XXV No. 1 January 2012<br />

Published semiannually by <strong>Columbia</strong> University’s <strong>School</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>International</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>Public</strong> <strong>Affairs</strong><br />

From the Dean<br />

The quickening pace <strong>of</strong> globalization over the past two decades has undermined traditional national<br />

identities <strong>and</strong> helped to promote ethnic, social, cultural, <strong>and</strong> even transnational solidarities that compete<br />

for primacy. More than 200 million people worldwide now reside outside their country <strong>of</strong> birth.<br />

Most <strong>of</strong> the rest <strong>of</strong> the world’s population now live in cities that are becoming more <strong>and</strong> more diverse.<br />

As the essays in this issue <strong>of</strong> SIPA News demonstrate vividly, individual identities <strong>and</strong> attachments are<br />

changing on a vast scale. In some places, <strong>of</strong> course, economic crises <strong>and</strong> political tensions have fueled a<br />

revival <strong>of</strong> nationalist sentiment against outsiders, but in most <strong>of</strong> the world, urbanization, education, <strong>and</strong><br />

rising consumption are making people more cosmopolitan.<br />

In many places, identity formation has become an object <strong>of</strong> policymaking for national as well as local<br />

governments <strong>and</strong> <strong>of</strong> lobbying (or marketing) by social entrepreneurs <strong>of</strong> all kinds. Governments seek to<br />

reshape the attitudes <strong>of</strong> potential foreign investors <strong>and</strong> end up creating or perpetuating national or local<br />

mythologies, while cultural symbols <strong>and</strong> achievements, from ancient ruins <strong>and</strong> transnational religiosity<br />

to pop music <strong>and</strong> football (soccer), are being deployed by governments <strong>and</strong> non-state actors alike to<br />

create a sense <strong>of</strong> community (or <strong>of</strong> tension <strong>and</strong> confrontation) where it did not exist before. These are<br />

powerful trends, pushed along by the rapid proliferation <strong>of</strong> new means <strong>of</strong> social communication.<br />

SIPA, for example, is working hard to enhance <strong>and</strong> exp<strong>and</strong> its own community <strong>of</strong> more than 18,000<br />

alumni in 153 countries. A record number <strong>of</strong> SIPA alumni volunteered to serve on an enlarged Alumni<br />

Council that now includes active alumni representatives from around the world. You can find SIPA via<br />

Facebook, YouTube, Twitter, <strong>and</strong> LinkedIn, in addition to the Morningside Post (the student run blog<br />

space) <strong>and</strong> the SIPA web page, with its videos <strong>of</strong> timely lectures <strong>and</strong> conferences on the great public<br />

policy challenges <strong>of</strong> our times.<br />

SIPA graduates are also playing key roles in reaching out to all <strong>Columbia</strong> alumni. Karen Poniachik<br />

(MIA ’90), for example, now heads the new <strong>Columbia</strong> Global Center in Santiago, Chile. Karen is<br />

Chile’s former minister <strong>of</strong> energy <strong>and</strong> minister <strong>of</strong> mining. Ipek Cem-Taha (MIA ’93, BUS ’93), a wellknown<br />

media personality in Turkey, directs the new Global Center in Istanbul. SIPA graduates also<br />

play leading roles in <strong>Columbia</strong> University Clubs from Beijing to Bogotá. Whether you are a SIPA grad<br />

or not, don’t hesitate to get connected.<br />

John H. Coatsworth<br />

Dean, <strong>School</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>International</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>Public</strong> <strong>Affairs</strong><br />

Interim Provost, <strong>Columbia</strong> University


contents<br />

FEATURES<br />

Inside SIpA<br />

p. 2<br />

Nationalism 2.0<br />

By Ethan Wilkes<br />

p. 4<br />

Marketing Macedonia<br />

By Sara Ray<br />

p. 7<br />

Br<strong>and</strong>ing a Global<br />

City, One Campaign<br />

at a Time<br />

By Andrea Moore<br />

p. 10<br />

Rebr<strong>and</strong>ing Murder<br />

City: Mexico’s<br />

Fight to Change the<br />

Image <strong>of</strong> a Battered<br />

Border Town<br />

By Nathaniel Parish Flannery<br />

p. 13<br />

An Isl<strong>and</strong> <strong>of</strong> Open<br />

Identity: Singapore<br />

<strong>and</strong> Long-Distance<br />

Nationalism<br />

By Priyam Saraf<br />

p.16<br />

An Identity to Call Their<br />

Own: Singaporeans<br />

<strong>and</strong> the Question <strong>of</strong><br />

Immigration<br />

By Crystal Neo<br />

p.18<br />

Nation for Sale:<br />

Selling Sierra Leone<br />

By Jennifer Wilmore<br />

p.20<br />

Post-Soviet Identity<br />

<strong>and</strong> Foreign Policy<br />

Formation in Ukraine,<br />

Estonia, <strong>and</strong> Latvia<br />

By Tim S<strong>and</strong>ole<br />

p.22<br />

Reconstructing the<br />

Chinese Farmer<br />

By David Borenstein<br />

p.25<br />

Forever Young:<br />

China’s Belief<br />

in Its Own<br />

Benevolent Rise<br />

By Rebecca Chao<br />

p.28<br />

Development through<br />

Football: A Vision<br />

for the Balkans<br />

By Behar Xharra <strong>and</strong><br />

Martin Waehlisch<br />

p.31<br />

Faculty Honors<br />

<strong>and</strong> Awards<br />

By Alex Burnett<br />

p.32<br />

Leaders in Global<br />

Energy: Seeking<br />

Solutions to<br />

Sustainable Energy<br />

By Alex Burnett <strong>and</strong><br />

Michelle Chahine<br />

p.33<br />

SIPA Events<br />

Highlight Emerging<br />

Economies <strong>and</strong><br />

Economic Priorities<br />

p.34<br />

From Recipients to<br />

Donors: Brazilian<br />

Students Turn<br />

Classwork into<br />

Real-world Policy<br />

By Michelle Chahine<br />

p.35<br />

Witnesses to History:<br />

SIPA Interns around<br />

the World<br />

By Michelle Chahine<br />

p.36<br />

PhD Students Connect<br />

Climate Change <strong>and</strong><br />

Civil War<br />

By Alex Burnett<br />

SIPA Alumnae Direct<br />

New Global Centers<br />

p.37<br />

From SIPA to Iraq to<br />

Afghanistan: An Interview<br />

with Carlos Terrones<br />

by Michelle Chahine<br />

p.38<br />

Class Notes<br />

Compiled by Pat Jones<br />

p.39<br />

Donor List


nationalism 2.0<br />

By Ethan Wilkes<br />

2 SIPA NEWS


Identity matters in international affairs. How political, economic, or<br />

military power moves the affairs <strong>of</strong> state is easy to see. But it is what<br />

people believe <strong>and</strong> hold to be true—their identities—that underpins<br />

these power resources <strong>and</strong> defines their use.<br />

From transnational movements to nation br<strong>and</strong>s <strong>and</strong> even new nationhood,<br />

national identities are increasingly vying for international influence.<br />

They are being packaged for global consumption <strong>and</strong> exist inasmuch as<br />

they earn international recognition. These identities represent a new form<br />

<strong>of</strong> nationalism—what we might call “nationalism 2.0”—that is externally<br />

oriented, inclusive, <strong>and</strong> participatory.<br />

Traditionally, the notion <strong>of</strong> a “national” identity<br />

was wedded to the nation-state. It was an identity<br />

rooted in the common bonds that defined <strong>and</strong> united<br />

a national constituency, such as ethnicity, religion,<br />

<strong>and</strong> language. It was an identity that came as<br />

a birthright, produced patriots, <strong>and</strong> fought “for God<br />

<strong>and</strong> country.” It served as the je ne sais quoi that<br />

made Frenchmen French <strong>and</strong> Germans German.<br />

But anyone with an Internet connection is no longer<br />

a prisoner <strong>of</strong> geography; identities are no longer<br />

accidents <strong>of</strong> origin. The ease <strong>of</strong> access to information<br />

<strong>and</strong> international experiences has replaced the traditional<br />

notion <strong>of</strong> a national identity with something<br />

more <strong>of</strong> our own choosing. For those <strong>of</strong> us who have<br />

come <strong>of</strong> age with this exposure, our self-selected<br />

identities are increasingly wedded to nations <strong>of</strong> likeminded<br />

individuals rather than to nation-states. We<br />

are defined <strong>and</strong> united less by the national identities<br />

we are born into than by the transnational identities<br />

in which we choose to believe. We are becoming<br />

advocates rather than patriots. Our fight is increasingly<br />

for cause before country.<br />

Nowhere is this reality more apparent than in<br />

transnational movements like Free Tibet <strong>and</strong> Save<br />

Darfur. That there is scarcely an elected <strong>of</strong>ficial<br />

in the United States who would openly argue<br />

against either <strong>of</strong> these movements is indicative<br />

<strong>of</strong> the extent to which the electorate has internalized<br />

these transnational identities as part <strong>of</strong> the<br />

American national fabric.<br />

According to a 2010 CNN/ORC poll, 73<br />

percent <strong>of</strong> Americans believed that “Tibet<br />

should be an independent country.” A 2006<br />

World<strong>Public</strong>Opinion.org poll, conducted at the<br />

height <strong>of</strong> the Save Darfur campaign, found that<br />

62 percent <strong>of</strong> Americans believed that the United<br />

A Libyan woman poses with her face decorated with the French flag (left) <strong>and</strong> Libyan revolution’s colors<br />

during a march in Benghazi to support the international coalition on March 24, 2011.<br />

States “has a responsibility to help stop the killing<br />

in the Darfur region.” Interestingly, according to<br />

a CBS News/New York Times poll conducted this<br />

past fall, only 43 percent “agree with the views <strong>of</strong><br />

Occupy Wall Street,” a movement that ostensibly<br />

represents 99 percent <strong>of</strong> Americans <strong>and</strong> concerns<br />

issues far closer to home than Tibet or Darfur.<br />

What Free Tibet <strong>and</strong> Save Darfur represent, in<br />

contrast to Occupy Wall Street, is the key tenet <strong>of</strong><br />

nationalism 2.0: identities that appeal to individuals’<br />

aspirations for advocacy <strong>and</strong> provide a coherent<br />

platform in which many can participate might have<br />

a discernable impact on policy. Save Darfur proved<br />

instrumental in securing Congressional support for<br />

putting UN peacekeepers on the ground in Sudan.<br />

U.S. presidents continue to chide China over treatment<br />

<strong>of</strong> Tibetans, to the great ire <strong>of</strong> Beijing.<br />

More than a few countries have recognized the<br />

power <strong>of</strong> nationalism 2.0 <strong>and</strong> are making conscious<br />

efforts to package a coherent, consistent,<br />

<strong>and</strong> well-communicated identity to the outside<br />

world through the use <strong>of</strong> a nation br<strong>and</strong>.<br />

Some nation br<strong>and</strong>s are small <strong>and</strong> product<br />

focused, such as the Bahamas’ promotion <strong>of</strong> great<br />

tropical holidays, while others encapsulate an entire<br />

national idea like those for India <strong>and</strong> South Africa.<br />

They might be used to raise reputations, as in the<br />

cases <strong>of</strong> Ghana <strong>and</strong> South Korea, or change them,<br />

such as with the states <strong>of</strong> former Yugoslavia. They<br />

may be as explicit as China’s “Made-in-China”<br />

Times Square advertising blitz or as subtle as<br />

Dubai’s steady drumbeat <strong>of</strong> positive, well-placed<br />

business news stories positioning the city-state as an<br />

oasis <strong>of</strong> stability <strong>and</strong> opportunity in a volatile region.<br />

These diverse nation-br<strong>and</strong>ing campaigns all seek<br />

to project an internationally appealing <strong>and</strong> participatory<br />

identity that can work in support <strong>of</strong> policy objectives.<br />

Many do so through the explicit connection <strong>of</strong><br />

a product or experience with its country <strong>of</strong> origin.<br />

While not everyone can call Cape Town, Seoul,<br />

or Mumbai home, many can go on safari, own a<br />

Samsung phone, or learn yoga. The greater the<br />

appeal <strong>of</strong> these products <strong>and</strong> experiences, <strong>and</strong> an<br />

individual’s awareness <strong>of</strong> their origins, the more likely<br />

that individual might be favorably predisposed to supporting,<br />

or even advocating on behalf <strong>of</strong>, a World Cup<br />

bid for South Africa, a free trade agreement for South<br />

Korea, or a UN Security Council seat for India.<br />

Where the stakes are particularly high, countries<br />

foster nationalism 2.0 less through links with<br />

engaging products <strong>and</strong> experiences than through<br />

appeals to the values <strong>of</strong> their intended audiences.<br />

In particular, new states such as Kosovo,<br />

South Sudan, <strong>and</strong> potentially Palestine have<br />

sought to win support for nationhood by projecting<br />

identities that appeal to an American sense <strong>of</strong><br />

Wilsonian idealism. By casting their struggle for<br />

self-determination in a familiar ideational context,<br />

they have succeeded in engaging significant levels<br />

<strong>of</strong> public advocacy in the United States to support<br />

their aspirations for independence.<br />

These examples st<strong>and</strong> in stark contrast to the<br />

no less deserving independence-minded region <strong>of</strong><br />

Kurdistan. There are many reasons a Kurdish state<br />

has not materialized, not the least <strong>of</strong> which are the<br />

geopolitical ramifications for Turkey, Syria, Iraq,<br />

<strong>and</strong> Iran. But Kurdistan, like Occupy Wall Street,<br />

has also failed to project enough <strong>of</strong> an externally<br />

oriented, inclusive, <strong>and</strong> participatory identity to<br />

capture a transformative level <strong>of</strong> global advocacy<br />

for its cause.<br />

Identity, indeed, matters in international affairs.<br />

An identity that cannot travel, one that remains<br />

restricted to its national boundaries, becomes the<br />

tree that no one heard fall in the forest; its ability<br />

to affect policy will be minimal. In a world where<br />

national identities are increasingly <strong>of</strong> our own<br />

choosing, the ability <strong>of</strong> a country or cause to influence<br />

events will hinge on its capacity to cultivate<br />

nationalism 2.0. This is a world in which success<br />

will depend less on the degree <strong>of</strong> blind patriotism<br />

already existing at home, than on the extent <strong>of</strong><br />

dedicated advocacy achieved at home <strong>and</strong> abroad.<br />

Ethan Wilkes, SIPA News coeditor, is a secondyear<br />

MIA c<strong>and</strong>idate concentrating in <strong>International</strong><br />

Finance <strong>and</strong> Economic Policy. He is editor in chief<br />

<strong>of</strong> The Morningside Post <strong>and</strong> marketing director <strong>of</strong><br />

the Journal <strong>of</strong> <strong>International</strong> <strong>Affairs</strong>.<br />

SIPA NEWS 3


A 12-meter-high bronze statue <strong>of</strong><br />

Alex<strong>and</strong>er the Great st<strong>and</strong>s on the<br />

central square in Skopje, Macedonia’s<br />

capital. Alex<strong>and</strong>er the Great was born<br />

in northern Greece. Macedonia is<br />

striving to prove that it has the right<br />

to claim the warrior king as part <strong>of</strong><br />

its ancient heritage, which Greece refutes.<br />

The installation <strong>of</strong> this massive<br />

sculpture is part <strong>of</strong> a cultural project<br />

“Skopje 2014.”<br />

Marketing<br />

Macedonia By Sara Ray<br />

4 SIPA NEWS


When I was with other Peace Corps volunteers<br />

in Macedonia, we played a game we called<br />

Balkan RISK. Styled after the board game RISK,<br />

Balkan RISK pitted the Byzantine, Italian,<br />

Greek, Balkan, <strong>and</strong> Austro-Hungarian empires<br />

against each other for total control <strong>of</strong> Eastern Europe. Marching my<br />

sunflower seed armies across the map provided visual evidence <strong>of</strong> a<br />

simple fact: the Balkans were a pr<strong>of</strong>ound crossroads <strong>of</strong> empires.<br />

For centuries, the Balkan cultures have<br />

absorbed the influences <strong>of</strong> empires north <strong>and</strong><br />

south, east <strong>and</strong> west. As a result, the nation that<br />

is now the Republic <strong>of</strong> Macedonia has a culture<br />

that seems at once Turkish <strong>and</strong> Hellenistic,<br />

Slavic <strong>and</strong> European, Christian <strong>and</strong> Islamic.<br />

While this fermenting <strong>of</strong> influences has produced<br />

a varied national identity <strong>and</strong> an anthropologically<br />

fascinating culture, the Macedonians<br />

<strong>of</strong> today are faced with a curious issue: how does<br />

a culture <strong>of</strong> such diverse influence market itself<br />

to the rest <strong>of</strong> the world?<br />

In the 20 years since the breakup <strong>of</strong> Yugoslavia,<br />

many <strong>of</strong> its newly independent states have dusted<br />

<strong>of</strong>f the scars <strong>of</strong> war <strong>and</strong> made themselves attractive<br />

tourist destinations: Slovenia, Croatia, <strong>and</strong><br />

even Bosnia’s war-ravaged capital—Sarajevo—<br />

bustle with Western Europeans in the summer<br />

months. Further south, however, Macedonia’s<br />

sprawling vineyards, craggy mountains, <strong>and</strong> clear<br />

lakes are glaringly empty <strong>of</strong> tourists.<br />

In December 2008, the Macedonian government<br />

debuted a commercial campaign marketing<br />

Macedonia across Western Europe, Russia, Turkey,<br />

<strong>and</strong> the United States. “Macedonia: Timeless” was<br />

a visually stunning series depicting the natural,<br />

historical, <strong>and</strong> cultural beauty <strong>of</strong> this Vermontsized<br />

republic in the southern Balkans. But the<br />

Macedonia: Timeless campaign didn’t match up to<br />

the Macedonia <strong>of</strong> my experience. What stood out<br />

most was not the rich display <strong>of</strong> Hellenistic <strong>and</strong><br />

Christian influences, but the total <strong>and</strong> resounding<br />

absence <strong>of</strong> Macedonia’s Eastern <strong>and</strong> Islamic<br />

heritage. The Macedonia I knew was not nearly as<br />

homogenous as Macedonia: Timeless suggested,<br />

<strong>and</strong> I wondered why the government chose to<br />

present such a one-sided view <strong>of</strong> its country.<br />

Apparently, I was not alone. Macedonia:<br />

Timeless drew harsh criticism from two camps:<br />

the Muslims <strong>and</strong> the Greeks. Both contested the<br />

video’s historical accuracy, but for interestingly<br />

disparate reasons. The Muslims <strong>of</strong> Macedonia—<br />

Albanians, Roma, <strong>and</strong> Turks who, together, comprise<br />

about one-third <strong>of</strong> the population—decried<br />

their utter lack <strong>of</strong> representation. Where were the<br />

mosques? The major Albanian cities? Allusions to<br />

the 500 years <strong>of</strong> Turkish rule?<br />

The Greeks, on the other h<strong>and</strong>, accused<br />

Macedonia <strong>of</strong> overusing Hellenistic culture.<br />

Over the past several decades, the Greeks have<br />

become increasingly sensitive about Macedonia’s<br />

use <strong>of</strong> traditional Greek (or Hellenistic) imagery<br />

<strong>and</strong> nomenclature. So when one installment <strong>of</strong><br />

Macedonia: Timeless featured a woman feeding<br />

grapes to a man in a toga as he lounged in<br />

a pavilion with Ionic columns <strong>and</strong> nude statues,<br />

Greece’s outrage was quick <strong>and</strong> pointed. Surely<br />

the Macedonian government, when funding the<br />

ad campaign, knew this imagery would be inflammatory<br />

to its southern neighbors. So why did it<br />

figure so prominently in the way they represented<br />

themselves to the world?<br />

The mountain lake Labunicko in Macedonia.<br />

These two sets <strong>of</strong> questions stem from<br />

Macedonia’s post-Yugoslavian quest for a cohesive<br />

national character in the face <strong>of</strong> ongoing<br />

ethnic tension. In 2001, Macedonia erupted<br />

in a violent conflict between ethnic Albanians<br />

<strong>and</strong> ethnic Macedonians. Religious, cultural, <strong>and</strong><br />

political issues hit a boiling point, resulting in a<br />

conflict that functionally segregated the country<br />

<strong>and</strong> left the issue <strong>of</strong> Macedonian cultural identity<br />

simmering. What is a Macedonian? Can ethnic<br />

Albanians living in Macedonia call themselves<br />

Macedonians? Are Macedonians exclusively<br />

Orthodox Slavs? What determines one’s identity—ethnic<br />

culture or national citizenship?<br />

With Macedonia: Timeless, the Macedonian<br />

government walked squarely into this quagmire.<br />

The commercial series unequivocally shows<br />

Macedonia as a Christian <strong>and</strong> Western nation.<br />

Strong Hellenistic undertones, paintings <strong>of</strong><br />

Orthodox saints, <strong>and</strong> ancient hillside churches are<br />

significant <strong>and</strong> ubiquitous elements <strong>of</strong> Macedonian<br />

culture. But the absences speak volumes. Save for a<br />

brief flash <strong>of</strong> Turkish writing, there is not a single<br />

cultural fragment <strong>of</strong> the Albanians, the Turks, or<br />

the Roma. Mother Teresa, an ethnic Albanian<br />

born in Macedonia’s capital, is completely absent.<br />

The video captures none <strong>of</strong> the vibrant imagery<br />

<strong>of</strong> Tetovo’s 600-year-old Painted Mosque. No traditional<br />

Turkish dress, no smiling Albanian gr<strong>and</strong>mothers,<br />

no Bajram feasts. The government-funded<br />

Macedonia: Timeless campaign not only alienates a<br />

cultural segment <strong>of</strong> the country, it in effect erases it.<br />

Macedonia: Timeless was not designed as a<br />

political piece but rather to attract tourists to<br />

SIPA NEWS 5


Left: Muslim men bow in prayer during the month <strong>of</strong> Ramadan inside the Isa Beg Mosque in Skopje, Macedonia, in 2010. Right: A young woman in traditional western Macedonian<br />

dress prepares to participate in a wedding procession the night before the Galicnik Wedding on July 14, 2007, in Macedonia’s western village <strong>of</strong> Galicnik. The traditional Galicnik<br />

Wedding is held every year on the Orthodox St. Peter’s Day.<br />

Macedonia in the same way they’d been attracted<br />

to Croatia <strong>and</strong> Slovenia. But unlike those nations,<br />

Macedonia’s crisis <strong>of</strong> identity, particularly that <strong>of</strong><br />

ethnic identity, is still recent, fresh, <strong>and</strong> unhealed.<br />

For ten years, Macedonia has struggled to unite<br />

two cultural spheres whose history has been tense<br />

at best <strong>and</strong> violent at worst into one cohesive<br />

national identity.<br />

While the government (currently, the ethnic<br />

Macedonian–dominated VMRO-DPMNE) promotes<br />

ethnic integration, its actions are less committed.<br />

Macedonia: Timeless’ representation <strong>of</strong> a<br />

Western, Christianized nation is VMRO’s vision<br />

for Macedonia, not the country’s reality. Though<br />

the government denied any ill intent in neglecting<br />

Eastern <strong>and</strong> Islamic influences from the video,<br />

it is interesting to note how closely the release<br />

<strong>of</strong> this tourism campaign coincided with another<br />

government effort known as “Skopje 2014.”<br />

Skopje 2014 is a government-funded project<br />

whose aim is to give the nation’s capital, Skopje,<br />

a much needed facelift. As the nation’s largest<br />

city, Skopje is competing against the likes <strong>of</strong><br />

Dubrovnik, Zagreb, Sarajevo, <strong>and</strong> Ljubljana—<br />

all cities with an attractive mix <strong>of</strong> Balkan <strong>and</strong><br />

European styles. Skopje 2014 is Macedonia’s<br />

effort to put itself onto equal footing. Since<br />

2010, statues, museums, <strong>and</strong> monuments have<br />

slowly cropped up across the city center, transforming<br />

Skopje from a drab, Yugoslavian-era city<br />

into what it truly is: a European capital.<br />

Skopje 2014, however, falls prey to the same<br />

criticism as Macedonia: Timeless. The capstone<br />

statue <strong>of</strong> the project is a 12-meter rendering <strong>of</strong><br />

Alex<strong>and</strong>er the Great, a figure whose birthplace<br />

is a fiercely divisive issue between Macedonia<br />

<strong>and</strong> Greece. Other statues include leaders <strong>of</strong> the<br />

Macedonian revolution against Turkish rule, Saints<br />

Cyril <strong>and</strong> Methodius (the inventors <strong>of</strong> the Cyrillic<br />

alphabet), <strong>and</strong> a 17th-century revolutionary killed<br />

by the Turks. In a nearby park, there is a monument<br />

to the soldiers <strong>and</strong> police killed in the 2001<br />

armed conflict with ethnic Albanian militants.<br />

It is easy to attribute these omissions to a<br />

transparent political game <strong>and</strong> to cast VMRO<br />

as an ethnically homogonous villain, but this<br />

oversimplifies the issue. Macedonia: Timeless<br />

<strong>and</strong> Skopje 2014 are not fundamentally political<br />

tools: they are incentives aimed at revitalizing<br />

Macedonia’s economy <strong>and</strong> putting the country on<br />

the map for adventurous travelers. Regardless <strong>of</strong><br />

underlying political mentalities, any government<br />

should underst<strong>and</strong> that ethnic tension or violence<br />

serves only as a repellant to tourists <strong>and</strong> investors.<br />

It seems unlikely, therefore, that the Macedonian<br />

government would invest in these tourism projects<br />

by intentionally using provocative methods<br />

that have every potential to reopen old wounds.<br />

The issue, then, is the validity <strong>of</strong> a consciously<br />

formed national identity. Macedonia’s beautiful<br />

l<strong>and</strong>scape has been occupied for thous<strong>and</strong>s <strong>of</strong> years,<br />

has seen the rise <strong>and</strong> fall <strong>of</strong> dozens <strong>of</strong> empires. It has<br />

absorbed baklava from the East <strong>and</strong> pizza from the<br />

West. But Macedonia is a young nation still tasting<br />

true independence for the first time. This newfound<br />

freedom has forced the nation to ask itself: Who am<br />

I? Who are we? And perhaps most provocatively,<br />

who has the authority to answer these questions?<br />

With the goal <strong>of</strong> increasing tourism, revitalizing the<br />

country, <strong>and</strong> bringing Macedonia squarely into a<br />

European future, the Macedonian government has<br />

granted itself that authority. Macedonia: Timeless<br />

<strong>and</strong> Skopje 2014 are the government’s answer to<br />

the question <strong>of</strong> national identity: whether they will<br />

bring the nation into a new future <strong>of</strong> economic <strong>and</strong><br />

social prosperity remains to be seen.<br />

Sara Ray is an administrative assistant in SIPA’s<br />

Office <strong>of</strong> Communications <strong>and</strong> External Relations. While<br />

in the Peace Corps, she lived <strong>and</strong> worked in Macedonia as<br />

the programming coordinator <strong>of</strong> an interethnic <strong>and</strong> interfaith<br />

leadership program for young women.<br />

6 SIPA NEWS


The Guggenheim Museum in Bilbao, Spain.<br />

Br<strong>and</strong>ing a Global City,<br />

One Campaign at a Time<br />

By Andrea Moore


Throughout its colonial history, Hong Kong was<br />

known as the gateway to Asia. But with the rise<br />

<strong>of</strong> other global cities in its region like Singapore,<br />

Shanghai, <strong>and</strong> Seoul, Hong Kong faced new competition<br />

to its established identity. In response, the<br />

city launched Br<strong>and</strong> Hong Kong in 2001 to secure<br />

its place as “Asia’s World City.”<br />

Hong Kong is not alone. Increasingly, cities<br />

are making explicit efforts to employ the strategic<br />

br<strong>and</strong>ing tactics <strong>of</strong> companies to stake their claim<br />

on the world stage. This rising trend is indicative<br />

<strong>of</strong> a new urban era <strong>and</strong> is due to two major shifts<br />

that are making the global identity <strong>of</strong> a city more<br />

important than ever before.<br />

First, there are simply more people moving<br />

to cities. In 2008, more than half <strong>of</strong> the world’s<br />

population lived in urban areas for the first time<br />

in history. By 2050, the United Nations projects<br />

that the proportion <strong>of</strong> urban dwellers will reach<br />

nearly 70 percent. This migration has been<br />

called the most important since the rise <strong>of</strong> agriculture<br />

<strong>and</strong> the decline <strong>of</strong> nomadic living.<br />

Second, most <strong>of</strong> these new urban centers will<br />

not be in the traditional developed economies.<br />

In March 2011, the McKinsey Global Institute<br />

published a report that estimated that 600 urban<br />

centers generate about 60 percent <strong>of</strong> global GDP.<br />

McKinsey predicts that this proportion will still hold<br />

by 2025, but the location <strong>of</strong> these 600 cities will be<br />

markedly different. One hundred thirty-six new cities<br />

from the developing world are predicted to enter this<br />

group <strong>of</strong> 600, with 100 from China alone.<br />

Furthermore, the 2010 Global Cities Index<br />

(a collaboration between Foreign Policy, A. T.<br />

Kearney, <strong>and</strong> The Chicago Council on Global<br />

<strong>Affairs</strong>) ranked 65 cities with populations greater<br />

than a million according to “its influence on<br />

<strong>and</strong> integration with global markets, culture, <strong>and</strong><br />

innovation.” Although traditionally global cities<br />

like New York, London, <strong>and</strong> Tokyo still top the<br />

list, other emerging market cities like Beijing,<br />

Shanghai, <strong>and</strong> Buenos Aires now rank in the top<br />

25, <strong>and</strong> the authors expect the rankings to skew<br />

from the West to the East in coming years.<br />

As these simultaneous shifts occur—increasing<br />

urbanization <strong>and</strong> greater influence <strong>of</strong> the developing<br />

world—up-<strong>and</strong>-coming cities are making<br />

conscious efforts to compete for investment,<br />

human capital, <strong>and</strong> prestige on the global stage.<br />

Many cities have always had a particular<br />

ethos or identity that required no formal effort to<br />

develop. In their book, The Spirit <strong>of</strong> Cities: Why<br />

the Identity <strong>of</strong> a City Matters in a Global Age,<br />

Daniel Bell <strong>and</strong> Avner de-Shalit examine nine<br />

modern cities <strong>and</strong> their individual “spirits”—<br />

for example, religion in Jerusalem, learning in<br />

Oxford, <strong>and</strong> ambition in New York. But in recent<br />

years, cities are increasingly moving beyond<br />

organic identity development to adopt formal<br />

br<strong>and</strong>ing campaigns. Hong Kong launched its<br />

formal br<strong>and</strong> in 2001, <strong>and</strong> other well-established<br />

global cities have long pursued br<strong>and</strong>ing campaigns<br />

<strong>of</strong> their own, such as the ubiquitous “I<br />

Love New York” campaign.<br />

There are different approaches to the strategic<br />

creation <strong>of</strong> a city’s br<strong>and</strong>. Some cities are pursuing<br />

the “Bilbao effect” by building l<strong>and</strong>mark<br />

cultural destinations to remake their international<br />

urban identity. Before the Guggenheim Museum<br />

opened in Bilbao in 1997, this Spanish city<br />

<strong>of</strong> less than a million people had a struggling,<br />

industrial-based economy. The arrival <strong>of</strong> the<br />

museum was a lynchpin in its strategic international<br />

transformation. In 2010, the Guggenheim<br />

estimated that it contributed almost 200 million<br />

euros to Bilbao’s GDP directly <strong>and</strong> indirectly, as<br />

well as maintained almost 4,000 jobs. Perhaps


just as significantly, Bilbao was a finalist for the<br />

World Design Capital in 2014, along with Cape<br />

Town <strong>and</strong> Dublin. In less than two decades,<br />

Bilbao has remade—even created—its global<br />

identity. Notably, another Frank Gehry-designed<br />

Guggenheim museum is slated to open in Abu<br />

Dhabi, United Arab Emirates, in 2014, bringing<br />

worldwide attention to the Middle Eastern art<br />

scene <strong>and</strong> to Abu Dhabi as a global city.<br />

Other cities are taking advantage <strong>of</strong> major<br />

international events to catapult them onto the<br />

global stage. Rio de Janeiro is using this tactic<br />

to the extreme, with the Catholic World Youth<br />

Day in 2013, the FIFA World Cup in 2014, <strong>and</strong><br />

the Summer Olympics in 2016. Rio’s bid for the<br />

Olympics, the first to be held in South America,<br />

was—as its website proclaims—built around the<br />

theme <strong>of</strong> “passion <strong>and</strong> transformation <strong>of</strong> a city <strong>and</strong><br />

an entire country, fuelled by the renovation <strong>of</strong> the<br />

Olympic spirit, to project Brazil <strong>and</strong> Rio de Janeiro<br />

to the world.” Rio is using these international<br />

events to broaden its global image <strong>and</strong> become one<br />

<strong>of</strong> the urban gateways to the southern hemisphere.<br />

As successful as some cities’ efforts<br />

have been, the creation <strong>of</strong> an aspiring city’s<br />

global br<strong>and</strong> can still be precarious. In March<br />

2011, more than 130 artists promised to<br />

boycott the developing Guggenheim Museum<br />

in Abu Dhabi because <strong>of</strong> labor conditions for<br />

foreign workers. Such a controversy could very<br />

well <strong>of</strong>fset any effort to make Abu Dhabi a new<br />

global cultural center.<br />

Beijing also famously used its 2008<br />

Summer Olympics to boost its international<br />

identity. However, in their 2009 paper, “City<br />

Br<strong>and</strong>ing <strong>and</strong> the Olympic Effect: A Case Study<br />

<strong>of</strong> Beijing,” Li Zhang <strong>of</strong> Fudan University <strong>and</strong><br />

Simon Xiaobin Zhao <strong>of</strong> the University <strong>of</strong> Hong<br />

Kong conducted a survey about citizens’ attitudes<br />

before <strong>and</strong> after the Olympics. They found<br />

that the top-down br<strong>and</strong>ing effort by the city<br />

government, which emphasized its vision for<br />

Beijing’s development as a global city, was<br />

mismatched with the vision <strong>of</strong> the city’s residents Richard M. Daley launched the Chicago-China<br />

<strong>and</strong> had little to do with grassroots initiatives. Friendship Initiative during a two-week visit in<br />

“The city values <strong>and</strong> br<strong>and</strong>ing projects were March 2011, improving the international pr<strong>of</strong>ile<br />

selected more for their relevance to Western <strong>of</strong> Chicago’s economy with the explicit goal <strong>of</strong><br />

tourists than for their representation <strong>of</strong> actual making Chicago the most “China-friendly” city<br />

ways <strong>of</strong> life <strong>of</strong> local residents,” Zhang <strong>and</strong> Zhou in the United States. Other initiatives, like the<br />

write. Just as in the business world, building a C40 Cities Climate Leadership Group, provide an<br />

city’s global br<strong>and</strong> must still be consistent with international forum for city leaders to gather <strong>and</strong><br />

the city’s core values to achieve a long-lasting engage on global challenges outside national-level<br />

<strong>and</strong> successful outcome.<br />

discussions. While the C40 is currently chaired<br />

Moreover, a city’s global bra nd does not necessarily<br />

have to reflect the core values <strong>of</strong> its home steering committee also includes emerging global<br />

by New York’s mayor Michael Bloomberg, the<br />

nation. Discussing Amsterdam, de-Shalit emphasizes<br />

that “It was an intention <strong>of</strong> the city several which is further evidence that major cities <strong>of</strong> the<br />

cities like Jakarta, Johannesburg, <strong>and</strong> São Paulo,<br />

times, most recently in the 1910s <strong>and</strong> 1920s, to developing world already recognize the diplomatic<br />

allow as many people who wanted to live there, opportunities that globally br<strong>and</strong>ed cities enjoy.<br />

no matter their religion [or] color,” despite the<br />

As the world continues to urbanize, one thing<br />

continued conservatism <strong>of</strong> Holl<strong>and</strong>. Today, when is clear: cities are actively using br<strong>and</strong>ing <strong>and</strong><br />

a city isn’t limited by its national identity, it has diplomacy for their own political <strong>and</strong> economic<br />

greater latitude to build a competitive advantage. gain. How successful these efforts are will depend<br />

Notably, despite its location in a politically conservative<br />

region <strong>of</strong> the United States, Las Vegas has that cities are granted by their state, regional, or<br />

in part on the degree <strong>of</strong> independence <strong>and</strong> latitude<br />

successfully built a global br<strong>and</strong> as “Sin City” with federal governments. But as Hong Kong’s br<strong>and</strong>ing<br />

gambling, clubs, <strong>and</strong> other adult entertainment. plan to become “Asia’s World City” attests, cities<br />

While in the past city br<strong>and</strong>ing may have can increasingly present themselves on the international<br />

stage to tell the world what they are <strong>and</strong><br />

been primarily about attracting inward investment<br />

<strong>and</strong> tourism, today’s efforts are increasingly<br />

about positioning cities as active political governments to keep up with them.<br />

what they want—<strong>and</strong> not have to wait for national<br />

actors on the international stage. On issues<br />

from terrorism to climate change, the leaders <strong>of</strong> Andrea Moore is a second-year MIA c<strong>and</strong>idate<br />

concentrating in <strong>International</strong> Finance <strong>and</strong><br />

world cities are engaging other mayors <strong>and</strong> even<br />

national leaders in direct diplomacy to meet their Economic Policy. She is managing editor <strong>of</strong> the<br />

most pressing challenges. Former Chicago mayor Journal <strong>of</strong> <strong>International</strong> <strong>Affairs</strong>.<br />

While in the past city br<strong>and</strong>ing may have been primarily<br />

about attracting inward investment <strong>and</strong> tourism,<br />

today’s efforts are increasingly about positioning cities<br />

as active political actors on the international stage.


10 SIPA NEWS


Rebr<strong>and</strong>ing<br />

Murder City:<br />

Mexico’s Fight to Change the Image <strong>of</strong> a Battered Border Town<br />

By Nathaniel Parish Flannery<br />

Mary Korthuis, a senior executive at Genpact, a business process-exporting<br />

firm, gave me a ride from El Paso, Texas, over to her <strong>of</strong>fice in Ciudad<br />

Juárez—a place that is now considered to be the world’s most violent city.<br />

It sits at the center <strong>of</strong> one <strong>of</strong> Mexico’s most lucrative drug smuggling routes<br />

<strong>and</strong> has become a key battleground in the drug war. At night rival gangs <strong>and</strong><br />

cartel assassins kill each other in the streets. Even during the middle <strong>of</strong> the<br />

day, there is no guarantee <strong>of</strong> safety. Hit men have summarily killed police<br />

<strong>of</strong>ficers underneath the afternoon sun. As we drove towards Juárez, Mary was<br />

calm. There were only a few cars ahead <strong>of</strong> us at the border crossing. “There’s<br />

a built-up anxiousness [about crossing into Juárez], but after you’ve done it<br />

for a while, it’s really no big deal,” she told me.<br />

A volunteer rolls up a<br />

photograph during an<br />

open-air exhibition near<br />

the U.S.-Mexico border<br />

at Rio Bravo, in Ciudad<br />

Juárez, October 29, 2011.<br />

The exhibition, which<br />

is part <strong>of</strong> the global art<br />

movement “Inside Out”<br />

<strong>and</strong> shows thous<strong>and</strong>s <strong>of</strong><br />

photographs <strong>of</strong> smiling<br />

people living in Juárez,<br />

is meant to promote<br />

a positive image <strong>of</strong><br />

Cuidad Juárez.<br />

As we drove over the smooth highway overpasses,<br />

I could see the billboards for OfficeMax,<br />

Applebee’s, <strong>and</strong> other international chains that<br />

have come to Juárez’s modern shopping malls.<br />

The streets were quiet, <strong>and</strong> it was hard to imagine<br />

that eight people had been killed the day<br />

before, including a shoe shiner who was shot<br />

in front <strong>of</strong> one <strong>of</strong> the city’s main supermarkets.<br />

It was harder still to imagine that in 2010 more<br />

than 3,000 people were killed in Juárez.<br />

At a recent event promoting Juárez<br />

Competetiva, the city’s main economic development<br />

initiative, Cesar Duarte, the state governor,<br />

told the crowd that changing the public’s<br />

negative perception <strong>of</strong> Juárez is one <strong>of</strong> the main<br />

goals <strong>of</strong> his administration. “Beating this stigma<br />

is one <strong>of</strong> the government’s priorities, because<br />

Chihuahua is not a violent state, <strong>and</strong> its people<br />

are peaceful <strong>and</strong> hardworking,” he said.<br />

The next day, however, armed men toting<br />

AK-47 assault rifles shot <strong>and</strong> killed Mr. Duarte’s<br />

main medical adviser while he was driving his<br />

pickup truck in Juárez. The doctor’s elderly<br />

father was also killed in the attack.<br />

In Juárez, proximity to the United States has<br />

brought immense foreign investment <strong>and</strong> also a<br />

rising wave <strong>of</strong> drug cartel-related violence. For<br />

both legal <strong>and</strong> illegal trade, Juárez is the perfect<br />

SIPA NEWS 11


Top: Workers <strong>of</strong> an electronic assembly plant ride on a bus to their work place in Ciudad Juárez. Bottom: A man holds<br />

a bullet casing in his h<strong>and</strong> at a crime scene in Ciudad Juárez on February 24, 2011. Three girls, ages 12, 14, <strong>and</strong> 15,<br />

were shot dead by hitmen on February 23 while st<strong>and</strong>ing on a sidewalk, according to the local media.<br />

point <strong>of</strong> access. A border city that provides lowwage<br />

labor <strong>and</strong> unparalleled access to the world’s<br />

largest consumer market, Juárez has become a<br />

city <strong>of</strong> stark contrasts. Gruesome murders have<br />

captured the attention <strong>of</strong> the international media,<br />

but Juárez’s business community is arguing that<br />

there’s more to the city than cartel violence.<br />

At a national level, Mexico faces the same challenge.<br />

“Restoring Mexico’s <strong>International</strong> Reputation,”<br />

a recent report from the Woodrow Wilson Mexico<br />

Institute, a Washington, D.C.-based think tank,<br />

explains that in 2010, more than 80 percent <strong>of</strong> the<br />

stories about Mexico in the Wall Street Journal <strong>and</strong> the<br />

New York Times related to crime <strong>and</strong> corruption. Many<br />

<strong>of</strong> Mexico’s leaders think that the shortage <strong>of</strong> stories<br />

about topics other than the violence is contributing<br />

to a perception that Mexico is a failing state. In<br />

Juárez, the problem is even more acute.<br />

Especially since 2008, when the global recession<br />

caused many local employers to cut production<br />

<strong>and</strong> trim their payrolls, city <strong>of</strong>ficials have<br />

worked tirelessly to rebr<strong>and</strong> the city, stressing the<br />

investment opportunities it <strong>of</strong>fers.<br />

Local political leaders in Juárez have launched<br />

a public campaign, <strong>of</strong>ten echoing statements from<br />

the country’s president, Felipe Calderón, in order to<br />

calm international investors <strong>and</strong> help build “Br<strong>and</strong><br />

Mexico.” They want to highlight the fact that in<br />

spite <strong>of</strong> the violence, Juárez is open for business.<br />

When I met Hector Murguia, the city’s affable<br />

mayor, he was seated comfortably in his dark,<br />

wood-paneled <strong>of</strong>fice, a luxurious corner on an upper<br />

floor <strong>of</strong> Juárez’s hulking, cement city hall building.<br />

He slipped quickly into his sales pitch. “In Juárez<br />

we have the best labor force in the world,” he said.<br />

He focused mainly on telling me about the<br />

city’s universities <strong>and</strong> the high-tech skills <strong>of</strong> the<br />

factory workers. He chose his words carefully<br />

when talking about the violence. “The root cause<br />

<strong>of</strong> the insecurity is the absence <strong>of</strong> opportunities<br />

[<strong>and</strong>] jobs,” he said. The important thing,” he<br />

said, “is implementing policies that strengthen<br />

the businesses. ”At the national level, Calderón’s<br />

br<strong>and</strong>ing campaign was captured in the government-produced<br />

documentary film, Mexico: The<br />

Royal Tour, which was released earlier this year.<br />

It follows President Calderón as he gives an<br />

American journalist a seven-day tour <strong>of</strong> various<br />

tourist attractions in Mexico.<br />

“We need to change the perception about<br />

Mexico,” Calderón says to the camera.<br />

As we drove through the security checkpoint<br />

at the border, Mary, the executive from Genpact,<br />

told me, “I come over every single day; there’s<br />

no reason to be nervous.” She took me on a tour<br />

<strong>of</strong> Genpact’s facility, through rooms filled with<br />

young people working at computer stations.<br />

The violence, after all, has devastated the<br />

city’s small business community, but so far it has<br />

left the export sector <strong>and</strong> the multinationals relatively<br />

unscathed.<br />

Sylvia Longmire, a former Air Force intelligence<br />

analyst <strong>and</strong> author <strong>of</strong> a recently published<br />

book on Mexico’s cartels, told me, “a lot <strong>of</strong> U.S.<br />

businesses are operating in Mexico without problems<br />

. . . business is flourishing.”<br />

“Mexico is not a failed state,” she said.<br />

On another day, I passed through a security<br />

gate <strong>and</strong> met with Miguel Hidalgo, a senior<br />

executive at ACS, a Business Process Outsourcing<br />

company that employs 3,000 people in Juárez. He<br />

took me on a tour <strong>of</strong> the brightly painted red <strong>and</strong><br />

yellow building, through a massive room filled<br />

with employees in their twenties, dressed like typical<br />

college students in casual attire, wearing stylish<br />

t-shirts <strong>and</strong> new sneakers. Some <strong>of</strong> the young<br />

men <strong>and</strong> women had tattoos on their arms <strong>and</strong><br />

h<strong>and</strong>s. One tough looking young man, with short<br />

cropped hair <strong>and</strong> an olive green dress shirt opened<br />

at the collar to reveal a number <strong>of</strong> neck tattoos,<br />

stood confidently in front <strong>of</strong> his work station. “Sir,<br />

what I’m going to need you to do is go ahead <strong>and</strong><br />

click,” he said calmly into the microphone on his<br />

headset in an impeccable Midwestern American<br />

accent. Outside ACS’s <strong>of</strong>fice, I saw white corporate<br />

buses driving by, one after another, picking<br />

up <strong>and</strong> dropping <strong>of</strong>f workers at other corporate<br />

campuses <strong>and</strong> factories. Trucks rumbled by to line<br />

up to cross the border into the United States.<br />

By late 2011, foreign companies had signed deals<br />

to invest $17 billion in Mexico, <strong>and</strong> Juárez itself has<br />

attracted almost $600 million worth <strong>of</strong> investment<br />

from foreign companies. Mexico’s economy is projected<br />

to grow by as much as 4.8 percent in 2012.<br />

In spite <strong>of</strong> the violence, the factories that line<br />

the southern bank <strong>of</strong> the Rio Gr<strong>and</strong>e are exp<strong>and</strong>ing<br />

production, <strong>and</strong> multinational corporations<br />

are opening new facilities in Juárez. This is the<br />

image the city is trying to promote.<br />

“Juárez continues to be a magnet for investment,”<br />

Mayor Murguia told me.<br />

Nathaniel Parish Flannery is a first-year MIA<br />

c<strong>and</strong>idate.<br />

12 SIPA NEWS


Shoppers browsing through a market<br />

specially set up for Deepavali in<br />

Little India, Singapore.<br />

An Isl<strong>and</strong> <strong>of</strong> Open Identity:<br />

Singapore <strong>and</strong> Long-Distance Nationalism<br />

By Priyam Saraf<br />

Bhaskar still remembers the day when the phone rang in his old family home in the north <strong>of</strong> Kolkata. “We are pleased<br />

to <strong>of</strong>fer you a tuition grant to come study in Singapore,” said the dean <strong>of</strong> Singapore Management University. The<br />

grant came with a contract to work in a Singapore-based company for three years after graduation.<br />

The decision was not an easy one. India was the only home Bhaskar had ever known—Indian his only national<br />

identity. No one in his family held a passport, had boarded an airplane, or traveled abroad. If he accepted the grant, he<br />

would commit to spending at least seven years in a very foreign country; if he rejected it, he might miss the opportunity<br />

<strong>of</strong> a lifetime.<br />

Bhaskar doesn’t like missing opportunities.<br />

NOTE: The names in this article have been changed at the request <strong>of</strong> the interviewees.<br />

SIPA NEWS 13


People look out over the central business<br />

district skyline in Singapore.<br />

For Bhaskar, <strong>and</strong> countless other Indian<br />

immigrants to Singapore, life in the city-state<br />

is an experiment in open identities. A person<br />

can be Indian in his cultural habits, cuisine<br />

preferences, <strong>and</strong> choice <strong>of</strong> partner, but still<br />

very Singaporean in how they approach a problem,<br />

their predisposition for efficiency, <strong>and</strong><br />

their views on the government’s role in development.<br />

This is a place where long-distance<br />

nationalism thrives.<br />

“Singapore opened doors for me, while letting<br />

me keep my links to India,” says Bhaskar, now a<br />

graduate student at the Fletcher <strong>School</strong> <strong>of</strong> Law <strong>and</strong><br />

Diplomacy near Boston. “I remember celebrating the<br />

Indian Independence Day while working on a policy<br />

paper for a government agency in Singapore.”<br />

But when asked where he considers home,<br />

Bhaskar pauses before answering. “I feel connected<br />

to Singapore where my friends are,<br />

but I go back to India <strong>of</strong>ten.” He discusses<br />

Singaporean politics with as much ease as he<br />

analyzes the pros <strong>and</strong> cons <strong>of</strong> the education reservation<br />

system in India.<br />

After years <strong>of</strong> liberal immigration policies,<br />

Singapore has emerged as a pioneer in both<br />

practicing <strong>and</strong> defining open identities. It is an<br />

interesting strain <strong>of</strong> nationalism that is a product<br />

<strong>of</strong> the city-state’s historical origins. With limited<br />

human <strong>and</strong> natural resources at independence<br />

in 1965, Singapore determined that economic<br />

success would hinge on its ability to attract the<br />

skilled labor necessary for multinational companies<br />

to consider relocating to the isl<strong>and</strong>. This in<br />

turn would boost employment, driving the citystate’s<br />

economy.<br />

This is where talented immigrants like<br />

Bhaskar fit into Singapore’s impressive growth<br />

story from a Southeast Asian backwater to a<br />

global financial powerhouse. A good part <strong>of</strong> that<br />

success can be attributed to Singapore’s open<br />

attitude toward what it means to be Singaporean.<br />

A long-time resident <strong>and</strong> taxpayer <strong>of</strong> Singapore,<br />

Bhaskar felt he could choose whether to take<br />

up Singaporean citizenship or not. There was<br />

no pressure. He preferred to retain his Indian<br />

nationality, which he views as a ticket to participate<br />

in Indian politics in the future, should<br />

he choose to do so. And he is hardly alone.<br />

According to the 2011 census, Singapore counts<br />

62 percent <strong>of</strong> its population <strong>of</strong> approximately 5.1<br />

million as citizens <strong>of</strong> other countries.<br />

Some Indian immigrants have chosen different<br />

paths. Padmini came to Singapore to study<br />

engineering on a Singapore Airlines scholarship<br />

at the age <strong>of</strong> 17 <strong>and</strong> has lived there since. Unlike<br />

Bhaskar, Padmini decided to take the Singaporean<br />

citizenship available to her. Her reasons were both<br />

personal <strong>and</strong> pr<strong>of</strong>essional. “I really like Singapore,<br />

14 SIPA NEWS


<strong>and</strong> my entire social network is in Singapore,” she<br />

says. “Plus, I want to work in development, <strong>and</strong><br />

having a strong passport like Singapore helps.” She<br />

explains that as a Singaporean she does not face<br />

the same visa requirements that Indian nationals<br />

do for most countries.<br />

Still, she retains firm ties to her native India.<br />

This past October, she married Abhishek, a PhD<br />

student in metaphysics from her hometown <strong>of</strong><br />

Madurai in Southern India.<br />

The stories <strong>of</strong> Bhaskar <strong>and</strong> Padmini demonstrate<br />

the interesting interplay between personal<br />

choice <strong>and</strong> the extent <strong>of</strong> affiliation to Singapore.<br />

Highly skilled immigrants who live <strong>and</strong> work in<br />

Singapore for years may or may not be inclined<br />

to become Singaporean citizens, which m<strong>and</strong>ates<br />

two years <strong>of</strong> compulsory military service for their<br />

children. But this has not deterred Singapore from<br />

promoting an open door policy that continues to<br />

attract human capital from around the world to<br />

meet its own developmental ends.<br />

The result <strong>of</strong> this policy has been a population<br />

that is overwhelmingly pluralistic in terms <strong>of</strong> the<br />

composition <strong>of</strong> its citizenships <strong>and</strong> a decidedly<br />

21st-century view <strong>of</strong> national identity. Unlike in<br />

the past, where the state could assume the affiliation<br />

<strong>of</strong> those born within its borders, immigrants<br />

to Singapore like Bhaskar <strong>and</strong> Padmini are able<br />

to define new identities individually, which are<br />

characterized more by the sum <strong>of</strong> their parts than<br />

any accident <strong>of</strong> origin. As their stories attest—<br />

Indian upbringings <strong>and</strong> Singaporean educations,<br />

a Singaporean passport <strong>and</strong> an Indian husb<strong>and</strong>,<br />

Singaporean pr<strong>of</strong>ession <strong>and</strong> Indian political<br />

ambitions—multiple identities <strong>and</strong> long-distance<br />

nationalism are a reality they have selected for<br />

themselves.<br />

In purely economic terms, Bhaskar <strong>and</strong><br />

Padmini faced an unconstrained optimization<br />

problem: which national affiliation to choose while<br />

optimizing for multiple needs? How to define an<br />

identity while discounting factors <strong>of</strong> initial endowment,<br />

family status, ethnicity, race, religion, <strong>and</strong>,<br />

perhaps, even caste?<br />

Singapore has been smart to let them answer<br />

these questions on their own. As an isl<strong>and</strong> <strong>of</strong><br />

open identities, Singapore implicitly recognizes<br />

the weakness <strong>of</strong> geographic lock-in <strong>and</strong> the fickle<br />

nature <strong>of</strong> national affiliation stemming from<br />

this reality, especially among the small segment<br />

<strong>of</strong> highly skilled <strong>and</strong> mobile workers. Allowing<br />

those who arrive in Singapore to obtain work <strong>and</strong><br />

residence permits easily <strong>and</strong> define their level <strong>of</strong><br />

“Singaporean-ness” on their own terms makes<br />

immigrants feel at home—<strong>and</strong> prolongs their stay<br />

in the city-state as productive contributors to the<br />

local economy. They become both inputs <strong>and</strong><br />

outputs <strong>of</strong> the local culture <strong>and</strong> norms.<br />

But not all Singaporean citizens are keen<br />

on keeping Singapore such an open place for<br />

immigrants or a haven for long-distance nationalism.<br />

They feel this culture <strong>of</strong> open identities<br />

undermines the building <strong>of</strong> a unique Singaporean<br />

identity <strong>and</strong> cultivating patriotism. “Immigrants<br />

take away our jobs, but shy away from taking<br />

on responsibilities that come with citizenship,”<br />

complains Allen, a second-year Singaporean engineering<br />

student. ”Why is there a trade<strong>of</strong>f between<br />

growth <strong>and</strong> patriotism for our country? It’s unfair,”<br />

says Allen decidedly.<br />

Little India, Singapore<br />

Allen is not alone in his views. But while<br />

such concerns may yield political dividends, as<br />

evidenced by some <strong>of</strong> the anti-immigration sentiment<br />

surrounding the May 2011 general election,<br />

the emergence <strong>of</strong> an insular or exclusive<br />

nationalism in Singapore could prove not only<br />

damaging to the isl<strong>and</strong>’s growth model, but also<br />

distance it from the city-state’s founding principles<br />

<strong>of</strong> meritocracy.<br />

That fateful day Bhaskar received a phone<br />

call from the dean <strong>of</strong> Singapore Management<br />

University, he was faced with a choice. Would he<br />

enter into long-distance nationalism with India or<br />

not, even if for a measurable period <strong>of</strong> time? But<br />

as the experiences <strong>of</strong> both Bhaskar <strong>and</strong> Padmini<br />

show, this is a question many students in developing<br />

countries face today. By placing few burdens<br />

on students, Singapore makes answering<br />

this question easier. Singapore is a place where<br />

those who cross its path can feel a sense <strong>of</strong><br />

belonging <strong>and</strong> affiliation, while retaining strong<br />

connections with where they originated.<br />

The world has much to gain from Singapore’s<br />

pioneering example <strong>of</strong> open identities. By leaning<br />

toward a tried <strong>and</strong> turbulent form <strong>of</strong> ethnocentric<br />

nationalism, Singapore has much to lose.<br />

Priyam Saraf is a second-year MPA c<strong>and</strong>idate<br />

concentrating in Economic <strong>and</strong> Political Development.<br />

She is MPA president for the class <strong>of</strong> 2012.<br />

Visitors check out one <strong>of</strong> the immigration halls at Changi airport’s new Terminal 3 in Singapore.<br />

SIPA NEWS 15


An Identity to Call Their Own:<br />

Singaporeans <strong>and</strong> the<br />

Question <strong>of</strong> Immigration<br />

By Crystal Neo<br />

<strong>International</strong>ly, Singapore projects the<br />

identity <strong>of</strong> a diverse country with an<br />

open immigration policy <strong>and</strong> a multiethnic<br />

population. A survey by HSBC<br />

bank in 2010 ranked Singapore as the top<br />

country overall for expatriates—ahead <strong>of</strong> Hong<br />

Kong, the United Arab Emirates, <strong>and</strong> Canada. But<br />

domestically, the results <strong>of</strong> the general election<br />

in May 2011 <strong>and</strong> activity on social media suggest<br />

Singaporeans may be yearning for a more unified<br />

national identity to call their own.<br />

This rift between Singapore’s international image<br />

<strong>and</strong> domestic realities may have its roots in the citystate’s<br />

politicization process. In the past, a combination<br />

<strong>of</strong> depoliticization <strong>and</strong> aggressive hard sell by<br />

the government fostered the view <strong>of</strong> Singapore as an<br />

isl<strong>and</strong> <strong>of</strong> open identities. With the largest number <strong>of</strong><br />

contested seats since independence, this most recent<br />

general election saw a rise in the politics <strong>of</strong> identity<br />

about who is—<strong>and</strong> can become—Singaporean, as<br />

opposition parties vied for support.<br />

Immigration has long been an important<br />

aspect <strong>of</strong> Singapore’s population <strong>and</strong> economic<br />

strategy. Since 1987, immigration has proved a<br />

viable solution to declining birth rates <strong>and</strong> an<br />

ageing workforce. The failure <strong>of</strong> other incentives<br />

such as tax breaks, subsidies, <strong>and</strong> cash bonuses<br />

<strong>of</strong>fered to address the demographic decline<br />

resulted in an even more pressing need to increase<br />

the population replacement rate.<br />

But a surge in immigration during the boom<br />

years <strong>of</strong> 2004 to 2007 affected many Singaporeans<br />

when the economic crisis hit in 2008. Since the<br />

end <strong>of</strong> 2005, the population ballooned by about<br />

810,000, bringing the total to 5.1 million. Many<br />

Singaporeans say this liberal immigration policy<br />

resulted in crowded public transportation, more<br />

competition with new arrivals for jobs, <strong>and</strong> fewer<br />

places in choice schools for their children, as well<br />

as rising costs <strong>of</strong> public housing.<br />

The increasing voter discontent over immigration<br />

in the nation was best epitomized by<br />

the furor generated by a disagreement between<br />

a local family <strong>and</strong> their immigrant neighbors.<br />

Local news reports on an immigrant family from<br />

China complaining about the smell <strong>of</strong> curry from<br />

a Singaporean Indian neighbor’s home led to the<br />

creation <strong>of</strong> a Facebook page that attracted more<br />

than 57,600 members. As a demonstration <strong>of</strong> support<br />

for the Indian family, many said they were<br />

cooking curry the following Sunday.<br />

With more than a third <strong>of</strong> Singapore’s total population<br />

made up <strong>of</strong> foreigners <strong>and</strong> permanent residents,<br />

immigration became a hot button issue that enabled<br />

opposition parties to garner record levels <strong>of</strong> support<br />

during the May general elections. Although the ruling<br />

People’s Action Party won a l<strong>and</strong>slide victory,<br />

the reduction in its winning margin revealed that<br />

the influx <strong>of</strong> immigrants was a sore point for many<br />

Singaporeans who remain unhappy over the consequences<br />

<strong>of</strong> the liberal immigration policies.<br />

This comes as no surprise.<br />

The unhappiness over the influx <strong>of</strong> immigrants<br />

had already begun to feature in the government’s<br />

policy agenda prior to the election.<br />

A report released by the Singapore Department<br />

<strong>of</strong> Statistics in 2010 details how the government<br />

has tightened immigration policies <strong>and</strong> started<br />

to calibrate the inflow <strong>of</strong> new immigrants since<br />

the last quarter <strong>of</strong> 2009. There were 59,460 new<br />

permanent residents <strong>and</strong> 19,928 new citizens in<br />

2009, in contrast to the 79,167 new permanent<br />

residents <strong>and</strong> 20,513 new citizens in 2008.<br />

A 2010 survey conducted by the Institute <strong>of</strong><br />

Policy Studies also indicates discontent over immigration.<br />

According to the National Orientations<br />

<strong>of</strong> Singaporeans survey, 63 percent <strong>of</strong> respondents<br />

or two out <strong>of</strong> three, agreed or strongly<br />

agreed that national unity would be affected by<br />

the policy to attract more foreign talent. This<br />

contrasted sharply with the 38 percent who<br />

agreed or strongly agreed that such a policy could<br />

be a threat to national unity when a similar study<br />

was conducted in 1998.<br />

Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong addressed<br />

these concerns in a speech following the general<br />

election. During his annual National Day Rally<br />

speech in August, the prime minister promised to<br />

slow the pace <strong>of</strong> immigration by tightening curbs<br />

on some foreign workers. New immigration policies<br />

will require potential immigrants to possess<br />

better educational qualifications as well as belong<br />

to higher income brackets.<br />

This is in stark contrast to previous years’<br />

National Day Rally speeches, when the government<br />

had tried to convince citizens to accept<br />

more immigrants into the country for the sake <strong>of</strong><br />

economic growth. Political leaders have <strong>of</strong>ten publicly<br />

acknowledged multiculturalism <strong>and</strong> diversity<br />

as pillars <strong>of</strong> Singapore’s identity. In the January<br />

2011 book, Lee Kuan Yew: Hard Truths to Keep Singapore<br />

Going, former minister mentor Lee Kuan Yew<br />

described the openness <strong>of</strong> the Singaporean identity<br />

as accepting “that whoever joins us is part <strong>of</strong><br />

us.” Chief Justice Chan Sek Keong has also spoken<br />

<strong>of</strong> the multicultural nature <strong>of</strong> Singapore’s identity<br />

as defined by the country’s constitution.<br />

Yet, this form <strong>of</strong> identity hasn’t resonated with<br />

Singapore’s citizens. Instead, they have rejected<br />

the government-driven narrative <strong>of</strong> Singapore’s<br />

identity <strong>and</strong> are beginning to assert their own<br />

ideas <strong>of</strong> what it means to be Singaporean. As the<br />

“curry incident” suggests, this newfound anti-immigration<br />

stance reflects a desire by Singaporeans to<br />

differentiate themselves from non-Singaporeans.<br />

This process appears to be at odds with prior<br />

government-driven initiatives to promote an open<br />

identity, suggesting that national identities cannot<br />

be dictated in a top-down fashion. Rather, they<br />

must be desired <strong>and</strong> driven by the people.<br />

As a young nation with 46 years <strong>of</strong> independence<br />

behind it, then, it is normal for Singaporeans<br />

to desire a national identity they can call their own.<br />

Crystal Neo is a second-year MPA c<strong>and</strong>idate concentrating<br />

in Economic <strong>and</strong> Political Development.<br />

16 SIPA NEWS


Top: Nicole Seah, a c<strong>and</strong>idate<br />

from the opposition National<br />

Solidarity Party (NSP)<br />

for the Marine Parade group<br />

representation constituencies<br />

(GRC), speaks to supporters<br />

at an election rally<br />

in Singapore May 4, 2011.<br />

Bottom: Organizers <strong>of</strong> “Cook<br />

a Pot <strong>of</strong> Curry” Facebook<br />

event Stanley Wong (2nd<br />

left), Florence Leow (3rd<br />

left) <strong>and</strong> Gabriel Yeap (center)<br />

eat curry with friends, at<br />

Leow’s home in Singapore<br />

August 21, 2011. The group<br />

organized the gathering in<br />

response to a media report<br />

about a mainl<strong>and</strong> Chinese<br />

family who could not st<strong>and</strong><br />

the smell <strong>of</strong> their local<br />

Indian neighbors cooking<br />

curry, in an effort to promote<br />

underst<strong>and</strong>ing, awareness<br />

<strong>and</strong> respect between different<br />

cultural groups.<br />

SIPA NEWS 17


Nation for Sale: Selling<br />

Perched atop a lush hillside overlooking<br />

colorful ro<strong>of</strong>tops, bustling traffic, <strong>and</strong> warm<br />

Atlantic waters sits a billboard with a simple<br />

statement: “Na wi country.” This is our country.<br />

Signs like this cover the ground all throughout<br />

Sierra Leone. What remains unclear, however, is<br />

how widespread this sense <strong>of</strong> national pride actually<br />

is in this West African nation.<br />

The country has come to be defined by the<br />

11-year civil war it endured in the 1990s <strong>and</strong><br />

the devastation left in its wake. And although the<br />

conflict ended nearly a decade ago <strong>and</strong> peace has<br />

since taken hold, for many, the idea that Sierra<br />

Leone is a dangerous place still remains.<br />

As a result, when it comes to its national identity,<br />

Sierra Leone seems to have developed a bit<br />

<strong>of</strong> an inferiority complex. With nearly every news<br />

article written about their country highlighting the<br />

war, <strong>and</strong> considering Hollywood’s depiction <strong>of</strong> the<br />

conflict in the 2006 film Blood Diamond, citizens<br />

have become very mindful <strong>of</strong> how they must<br />

appear to the rest <strong>of</strong> the world.<br />

None more so than President Ernest Bai<br />

Koroma, who is keen to change the perception<br />

that the country is dangerous. He now claims<br />

that it is so safe, he walks the streets <strong>and</strong> personally<br />

drives himself around. But he also realizes<br />

that the media’s constant description <strong>of</strong><br />

Sierra Leone as a war-devastated country is not<br />

a misnomer.<br />

The war destroyed critical infrastructure <strong>and</strong><br />

chased away both investors <strong>and</strong> tourists, <strong>and</strong><br />

the economy has still not fully recovered. In<br />

response, Koroma’s administration has prioritized<br />

attracting foreign direct investment as the key to<br />

economic growth. And the president underst<strong>and</strong>s<br />

that to do so, Sierra Leone needs to undergo<br />

some serious rebr<strong>and</strong>ing.<br />

The government has begun promoting Sierra<br />

Leone as a “l<strong>and</strong> <strong>of</strong> opportunity,” as one <strong>of</strong> the<br />

most attractive destinations for investment in<br />

Africa, with untapped resources, a growing economy,<br />

fiscal incentives, a natural harbor, <strong>and</strong> hospitable<br />

people. The government has also embarked<br />

on ambitious infrastructure projects—building<br />

<strong>and</strong> repairing roads <strong>and</strong> investing in electricity<br />

production—<strong>and</strong> has focused on removing further<br />

barriers to investment by creating the Sierra<br />

Leone Investment <strong>and</strong> Export Promotion Agency<br />

(SLIEPA), which <strong>of</strong>fers free advice to prospective<br />

investors <strong>and</strong> exporters <strong>and</strong> a joint chamber <strong>of</strong><br />

commerce with the United States.<br />

What’s more, the government has cooperated<br />

with the establishment <strong>of</strong> a special economic<br />

opportunity zone by a private nonpr<strong>of</strong>it organization,<br />

which might represent the most promising<br />

model for attracting investors yet. Aptly named<br />

“First Step,” this industrial park, located just outside<br />

the capital city, Freetown, aims to facilitate<br />

foreign investment in Sierra Leone by reducing<br />

the risks <strong>and</strong> costs for international businesses to<br />

set up export processing industries. The government<br />

has committed to providing incentives for<br />

these businesses, including exemptions on import<br />

<strong>and</strong> export duties, expedited customs services,<br />

<strong>and</strong> corporate tax holidays.<br />

Not everyone is happy with the government’s<br />

policies <strong>of</strong> attracting foreign investment, however.<br />

Civil society groups accuse the government <strong>of</strong><br />

essentially selling Sierra Leone to investors <strong>and</strong><br />

sacrificing the interests <strong>and</strong> needs <strong>of</strong> ordinary<br />

Sierra Leoneans in favor <strong>of</strong> pleasing foreign companies,<br />

particularly those interested in the country’s<br />

vast mineral resources.<br />

“There is no point in throwing away your<br />

18 SIPA NEWS


Left: Soldier st<strong>and</strong>ing in front <strong>of</strong> Ministry<br />

<strong>of</strong> Tourism <strong>and</strong> Culture sign. Right: A general<br />

view <strong>of</strong> the countryside just outside<br />

Freetown, Sierra Leone.<br />

Sierra Leone By Jennifer Wilmore<br />

natural resources just because you’re in a hurry<br />

to develop,” says Abu Brima, director <strong>of</strong> the<br />

Network Movement for Justice <strong>and</strong> Development,<br />

a civil society watchdog organization. Brima, like<br />

many civil society actors, thinks Sierra Leone<br />

is needlessly missing out on huge amounts <strong>of</strong><br />

potential government revenue by granting financial<br />

concessions to companies.<br />

“Sierra Leone has decided to give a lot <strong>of</strong><br />

incentives because we think we have to encourage<br />

corporations to come. We don’t need that,” he<br />

says. “Because whether we give incentives or not,<br />

they will come. They need the resources.”<br />

And in countries with weak government ability<br />

to provide oversight <strong>and</strong> regulation, investments<br />

by foreign companies almost inevitably carry with<br />

them concerns <strong>of</strong> corporate human rights abuses.<br />

One foreign diamond mining company, Koidu<br />

Holdings, has been heavily criticized by human<br />

rights groups for improper resettlement <strong>of</strong> local<br />

communities, environmental destruction, <strong>and</strong> even<br />

the shooting deaths <strong>of</strong> two local men by security<br />

forces hired by the company.<br />

Amid concerns <strong>of</strong> food insecurity in a society<br />

where most people are subsistence farmers,<br />

accusations <strong>of</strong> “l<strong>and</strong> grabbing” have also begun<br />

to spread, touching nearly any investment venture<br />

in the country. For example, l<strong>and</strong> leases to a<br />

Swiss-owned company for a sugarcane plantation<br />

<strong>and</strong> bioethanol production plant have come under<br />

fire this year by the Sierra Leone Network on the<br />

Right to Food <strong>and</strong> by others. They accuse local<br />

government <strong>of</strong>ficials <strong>of</strong> diverting poor farmers’<br />

l<strong>and</strong> to corporate activities without adequate local<br />

community consultation <strong>and</strong> claim that the company<br />

has destroyed local water sources.<br />

In light <strong>of</strong> these concerns, it is worth asking<br />

whether the government’s attempts at selling<br />

Sierra Leone to foreign investors are working.<br />

Over the past few years, the amount <strong>of</strong> foreign<br />

investment in the country has indeed been higher<br />

than ever. Inflows <strong>of</strong> foreign direct investment<br />

exceeded $86 million last year, compared with<br />

just $10 million in 2002, when the war ended.<br />

The fact that ground was recently broken on construction<br />

<strong>of</strong> a Hilton Hotel in Freetown may also<br />

be a sign not only <strong>of</strong> an improving tourism industry,<br />

but also <strong>of</strong> the number <strong>of</strong> wealthy investors<br />

coming to the country. Any visitor to one <strong>of</strong> the<br />

white s<strong>and</strong> beaches near the capital city will tell<br />

you that the place is once again crawling with an<br />

increasing number <strong>of</strong> foreign contractors.<br />

But despite these trends, the most recent<br />

Investment Climate Statement from the U.S.<br />

Embassy in Freetown indicates that Sierra Leone<br />

has not yet escaped the stigma <strong>of</strong> war. According<br />

to the report, “the devastation <strong>of</strong> the decade-plus<br />

civil war <strong>and</strong> the daunting challenge <strong>of</strong> extreme<br />

poverty continue to impact fundamentally almost<br />

all aspects <strong>of</strong> Sierra Leone society,” including<br />

governance, institutions, <strong>and</strong> critical infrastructure<br />

like energy <strong>and</strong> communications.<br />

To overcome these challenges, huge leaps are<br />

still required not only in nominally rebr<strong>and</strong>ing the<br />

country among the international community, but<br />

also in improving infrastructure, education, job<br />

training, <strong>and</strong> fiscal management. Tackling corruption<br />

<strong>and</strong> putting in place protections for local<br />

populations <strong>and</strong> environments affected by investments<br />

are also necessary to ensure that by selling<br />

itself to investors, Sierra Leone doesn’t end up<br />

selling itself out for good.<br />

Jennifer Wilmore is a second-year MIA c<strong>and</strong>idate<br />

concentrating in Human Rights.<br />

SIPA NEWS 19


Supporters <strong>of</strong> Ukrainian<br />

opposition leader Viktor<br />

Yanukovych display his<br />

party flags, with a statue<br />

<strong>of</strong> Soviet state founder<br />

Vladimir Lenin in the<br />

background, at a campaign<br />

rally in the Crimean capital<br />

Simferopol, Ukraine, in<br />

December 2009.<br />

Post-Soviet Identity <strong>and</strong> Foreign Policy Formation<br />

in Ukraine, Estonia, <strong>and</strong> Latvia By Tim S<strong>and</strong>ole<br />

Ukraine, Estonia, <strong>and</strong> Latvia have two<br />

geopolitical similarities: each was a<br />

subject <strong>of</strong> the Soviet Union, <strong>and</strong> each<br />

shares a border with Russia. Yet despite<br />

their proximities to Russia <strong>and</strong> their respective<br />

experiences with Communism, the two Baltic states<br />

differ remarkably from Ukraine in their policy <strong>of</strong><br />

engagement with Russia <strong>and</strong> the West. Upon the<br />

Soviet Union’s disintegration, Estonia <strong>and</strong> Latvia<br />

aggressively looked west <strong>and</strong> embraced NATO,<br />

while Ukraine looked west <strong>and</strong> continued looking<br />

east, maintaining ties with its former master while<br />

attempting to create a new relationship with the<br />

United States <strong>and</strong> Western institutions. Why did<br />

these three countries, which were geographically<br />

similar from the outset <strong>of</strong> the post-Cold War era, differ<br />

so remarkably in their foreign policy orientation?<br />

Their disparate foreign policies are a direct result <strong>of</strong><br />

their respective national identities, all <strong>of</strong> which came<br />

to fruition during the Soviet Union’s disintegration.<br />

Ukraine’s “Middle-<strong>of</strong>-the-Road”<br />

Approach<br />

Ethnic Russians formed the largest minority in<br />

Ukraine, making up 22 percent <strong>of</strong> the population<br />

according to the 1989 census. Throughout the<br />

Soviet period, it was common for Russians to traverse<br />

various Soviet Socialist Republics because<br />

<strong>of</strong> favorable opportunities provided to them by<br />

the Communist Party. And even after Ukrainian<br />

independence, ethnic Russians had no reason to<br />

fear for their well-being, because Ukraine took<br />

a “middle ground” approach to policy formulation,<br />

where ethnic Russians <strong>and</strong> Ukrainians<br />

would be on an equal legal footing. <strong>Columbia</strong><br />

University pr<strong>of</strong>essor Alfred Stepan explains that<br />

Ukraine “decided to recognize <strong>and</strong> institutionally<br />

give support to more than one cultural identity,<br />

even a national identity, in the state.” This<br />

moderate approach stemmed from the makeup<br />

<strong>of</strong> Ukrainian regional identity. Nationalist <strong>and</strong><br />

anti-Russian sentiments have historically characterized<br />

western Ukrainian regions, notably in<br />

Galicia, where the Austrian Hapsburg Empire<br />

once ruled. This left a Western-oriented legacy<br />

in western Ukraine. Pro-Russian political values<br />

have been historically codified in eastern<br />

Ukraine, notably in Donetsk, as a consequence <strong>of</strong><br />

many years <strong>of</strong> Russian Czarist rule. This regional<br />

dichotomy spawned three political ideologies in<br />

the Ukrainian parliament (Verkhvna Rada) at the<br />

outset <strong>of</strong> Ukrainian independence.<br />

The political left embraced the Soviet idea<br />

<strong>of</strong> Ukrainian origin belonging to an East Slavic<br />

20 SIPA NEWS


fraternity with Russia. The right trumpeted the<br />

uniqueness <strong>of</strong> Ukrainians from the Russians <strong>and</strong><br />

was determined to break through to the West. But<br />

the ideologically amorphous center, or the “Party<br />

<strong>of</strong> Power,” eventually came to represent the popular<br />

view <strong>and</strong> defined Ukrainian foreign policy. Any<br />

time the political conversation veered too heavily<br />

to the right or left, the Party <strong>of</strong> Power would eventually<br />

bring politics back to the middle ground.<br />

Leonid Kravchuk, elected in 1991 as the first<br />

president <strong>of</strong> independent Ukraine, incorporated<br />

many <strong>of</strong> the ideological facets <strong>of</strong> the Ukrainian<br />

national revival into his foreign policy. Kravchuk<br />

allowed Ukraine to become part <strong>of</strong> NATO’s<br />

Partnership for Peace Program (PfP) in 1994, an<br />

initiative that allows partner countries to build a<br />

relationship with full NATO members. Ukraine<br />

was then able to participate in NATO activities—<br />

from defense reform to civil-military relations,<br />

education <strong>and</strong> training, military-to-military cooperation<br />

<strong>and</strong> exercises, civil emergency planning,<br />

<strong>and</strong> cooperation on scientific <strong>and</strong> environmental<br />

issues. As a PfP member, Ukraine was on the fast<br />

track to becoming a full NATO member.<br />

However, the net effect <strong>of</strong> Kravchuk’s policies<br />

made the Ukrainian left nervous. His right-<strong>of</strong>center<br />

foreign policy contributed to his defeat in<br />

the 1994 election, giving rise to Leonid Kuchma,<br />

the favorite <strong>of</strong> eastern Ukraine. “However, the new<br />

president did not lead Ukraine back to the USSR<br />

<strong>and</strong> the dominance <strong>of</strong> Russia as many had expected,”<br />

explains Volodymyr Kulyk, visiting scholar at<br />

<strong>Columbia</strong>’s Harriman Institute. In fact, Kuchma<br />

maintained a moderate foreign policy course that<br />

allowed Ukraine to keep a foothold in Russia<br />

while simultaneously raising its international status<br />

<strong>and</strong> pr<strong>of</strong>ile by engaging with NATO. Ukraine<br />

maintained its status as a de facto participating<br />

member <strong>of</strong> the Eastern-friendly Commonwealth<br />

<strong>of</strong> Independent States (CIS), which Ukraine had<br />

joined in 1991, but Ukraine never ratified the<br />

CIS charter. This was advantageous because the<br />

country benefitted economically from the organization<br />

without appearing to be too close to Russia.<br />

Similarly, the PfP strategy with NATO enabled<br />

Ukraine to receive inclusive security guarantees<br />

without being a NATO member. Therefore, the<br />

dual identity that became foreign policy reconciled<br />

both sides <strong>of</strong> the political spectrum.<br />

While Ukraine pursued inclusive policies at<br />

the outset <strong>of</strong> independence, the two Baltic states<br />

pursued an exclusive policy, energetically choosing<br />

NATO <strong>and</strong> completely jettisoning a security<br />

relationship with Russia.<br />

respective native languages. Thus, a strong anti-<br />

Russian sentiment developed during the Soviet<br />

Union’s annexation <strong>of</strong> the Baltic states in 1940,<br />

where the Soviets were perceived as an aggressive<br />

foreign occupier. When the Baltic states<br />

regained independence in 1991, Estonia <strong>and</strong><br />

Latvia had especially large ethnic Russian minorities<br />

due to migrations from Russia during the<br />

Soviet era. In the late 1980s, Russians made up<br />

a third <strong>of</strong> the population in Estonia, <strong>and</strong> half<br />

<strong>of</strong> the population in Latvia. Eager to maintain<br />

their newfound strength, Estonians <strong>and</strong> Latvians<br />

created exclusionary laws, ranging from discriminatory<br />

language policies <strong>and</strong> citizenship laws,<br />

to discriminatory hiring polices that effectively<br />

barred the Russian minority. This was the result<br />

<strong>of</strong> the traumatic collective memory Estonians <strong>and</strong><br />

Latvians internalized during the Soviet reign.<br />

They saw independence as a restoration <strong>of</strong> historical<br />

justice, a return to Europe from which they<br />

had been brutally cut <strong>of</strong>f since 1940.<br />

With a strong identification with Western<br />

Europe, Estonians <strong>and</strong> Latvians were eager to<br />

seize any opportunity to move further away from<br />

Russia. The economic chaos that characterized<br />

post-Soviet states strengthened Baltic enthusiasm<br />

for joining what they perceived as the stable<br />

<strong>and</strong> secure environment <strong>of</strong> Western institutions.<br />

However, Estonia <strong>and</strong> Latvia were roundly criticized<br />

by the very Western alliances they were<br />

trying to join because <strong>of</strong> their exclusionary laws.<br />

NATO leadership, in particular, made the two<br />

countries’ membership contingent upon their<br />

changing course. Estonia <strong>and</strong> Latvia faced a<br />

dilemma: while greater European integration <strong>and</strong><br />

NATO membership were cherished goals, so was<br />

individual Latvian <strong>and</strong> Estonian identity. They<br />

feared that by allowing Russians more rights, they<br />

were putting in jeopardy their revitalized identities,<br />

which had been suppressed for so long.<br />

Merje Kuus <strong>of</strong> George Mason University<br />

argues, “it [was] because <strong>of</strong> the Russian threat<br />

that it is possible to represent European integration<br />

as a measure for strengthening state sovereignty.<br />

Conversely, <strong>and</strong> paradoxically, it [was]<br />

also through the notion <strong>of</strong> the Russian threat that<br />

European integration is constructed as dangerous<br />

to Estonian [<strong>and</strong> Latvian] national identity.”<br />

Eventually, NATO <strong>and</strong> the EU helped mollify<br />

the strong nationalistic identity feeling in Estonia<br />

<strong>and</strong> Latvia. The West convinced the two countries<br />

that the security <strong>of</strong> Baltic identity was not<br />

zero-sum. Swayed by this, Estonia <strong>and</strong> Latvia<br />

introduced major inclusionary changes to their<br />

original legislation, a move that was viewed favorably<br />

by NATO <strong>and</strong> the EU. Estonians <strong>and</strong> Latvians<br />

became convinced they could join Western associations<br />

without risking their national identity <strong>and</strong><br />

together entered NATO in 2004.<br />

In sum, while all three nations are contiguous<br />

with present-day Russia, Ukraine has deviated<br />

significantly in its foreign policy approach<br />

compared to the two Baltic states. Ukraine’s<br />

dichotomous national identity has allowed it to<br />

engage with Russia <strong>and</strong> the West simultaneously.<br />

However, this simultaneous engagement has prevented<br />

Ukraine from becoming a full NATO<br />

member. The strong Western-oriented identities<br />

<strong>of</strong> Estonia <strong>and</strong> Latvia, on the other h<strong>and</strong>, prompted<br />

them to energetically join Western alliances,<br />

namely NATO, in order to mitigate the influence<br />

<strong>of</strong> Russia to the furthest extent possible.<br />

Timothy S<strong>and</strong>ole is a second-year MIA c<strong>and</strong>idate<br />

concentrating in <strong>International</strong> Security Policy. He has<br />

extensive experience working in Bosnia-Herzegovina with<br />

the Organization for Security <strong>and</strong> Cooperation in Europe<br />

(OSCE) as well as the Commission on Security <strong>and</strong><br />

Cooperation in Europe (U.S. Helsinki Commission) in the<br />

U.S. Congress.<br />

Baltic National Security Arrangements<br />

During the interwar period, Estonia <strong>and</strong> Latvia<br />

established a strong Baltic identity as a result<br />

<strong>of</strong> independent statehood <strong>and</strong> retention <strong>of</strong> their<br />

NATO heads <strong>of</strong> state <strong>and</strong> government pose for an <strong>of</strong>ficial photo at the NATO summit in Riga, Latvia, November 29,<br />

2006. Heads <strong>of</strong> state <strong>and</strong> government from the 26 NATO countries met for a discussion on transatlantic issues at the<br />

highest level.<br />

SIPA NEWS 21


22 SIPA NEWS<br />

Jia Ruiming is yet another college-educated person who<br />

has returned to rural roots to start an organic farm. He<br />

studied at an agricultural college, but illustrating just<br />

how few young people are going into farming, every<br />

person in his graduating class has gone onto another<br />

city-oriented pr<strong>of</strong>ession. Even he worked for many years<br />

as a teacher before deciding to give farming a try.


Reconstructing<br />

the Chinese Farmer<br />

By David Borenstein<br />

The Gao family lives in Anlong Village in<br />

Sichuan Province. Their home is filled<br />

with potted plants, orchards, drying produce,<br />

<strong>and</strong> the experiments they conduct<br />

to make their home greener <strong>and</strong> more sustainable.<br />

They have developed a manmade wetl<strong>and</strong> water<br />

filtration system, make their own compost, <strong>and</strong> use<br />

rice husks instead <strong>of</strong> soap to clean dishes. They support<br />

themselves by selling organic vegetables directly<br />

to consumers in cities. Unlike peasants elsewhere in<br />

China, they have eliminated the need to migrate to<br />

cities <strong>and</strong> work in coastal factories. Their lifestyle is<br />

part <strong>of</strong> Anlong Village’s collective effort to create a<br />

new way <strong>of</strong> living in the Chinese countryside.<br />

However, China’s unequivocal embrace <strong>of</strong> urbanization<br />

in the mid-1980s has not only caused disproportionate<br />

investment <strong>and</strong> reform in urban areas <strong>and</strong><br />

economic disparity between the city <strong>and</strong> the countryside,<br />

but has also perpetuated a negative image<br />

<strong>of</strong> the village or peasant as backward <strong>and</strong> unmodern<br />

<strong>and</strong> <strong>of</strong> the countryside as needing urbanization.<br />

Pervasive national discourse creates extreme<br />

prejudice against the rural population. The cosmopolitan,<br />

trendy urbanite is <strong>of</strong>ten considered <strong>of</strong><br />

high “suzhi” or quality, while the old-fashioned<br />

farmer is almost always considered low “suzhi.”<br />

The pervasiveness <strong>of</strong> this stereotype was apparent<br />

in a traditional rural township in Sichuan province,<br />

where peasants said they were too embarrassed to<br />

be interviewed because <strong>of</strong> their low “suzhi.”<br />

Policymakers, academics, <strong>and</strong> <strong>of</strong>ficials have promoted<br />

temporary rural migration to the cities to<br />

bring capital into the countryside <strong>and</strong> to “civilize”<br />

villagers. The theory, as explained by the party<br />

secretary <strong>of</strong> the township in Sichuan province, is<br />

that the farmers can learn from urbanites <strong>and</strong> then<br />

return to the countryside <strong>and</strong> improve their community’s<br />

“suzhi.”<br />

Unbalanced development <strong>and</strong> a decline in farming<br />

revenues have created a countryside where peasants<br />

usually have no choice but to migrate. Reinforcing this<br />

trend is a national culture that equates the urban with<br />

the civilized. As a result, most rural Chinese believe<br />

that migration is a necessary way <strong>of</strong> life—both for the<br />

economic opportunities it <strong>of</strong>fers <strong>and</strong> the chance to<br />

improve their “suzhi.”<br />

SIPA NEWS 23


This scenario has created a vicious negative<br />

cycle. In many villages most people <strong>of</strong> working<br />

age have left to work in cities, turning communities<br />

into ghost towns with virtually only young<br />

children <strong>and</strong> the elderly remaining. Some villagers<br />

unable to migrate commonly join crime networks<br />

because <strong>of</strong> the few other local economic opportunities.<br />

In many villages, sanitation <strong>and</strong> waste<br />

are growing increasingly serious because many <strong>of</strong><br />

those who remain plan to leave as soon as possible<br />

<strong>and</strong> neglect their community. As villages slowly<br />

deteriorate, it only reinforces the perception that<br />

rural life is inferior <strong>and</strong>, again, furthers the neglect.<br />

However, peasants like the Gaos have developed<br />

a method <strong>of</strong> economic production <strong>and</strong> conception<br />

<strong>of</strong> progress that are powerful challenges<br />

to China’s status quo.<br />

The Gaos operate an organic farm in Anlong<br />

Village. Working in a co-op with seven other<br />

families, they run an enterprise they have come<br />

to call “Jiankang Shucai Peisong,” or Healthful<br />

Vegetable Delivery. It involves selling produce<br />

directly to consumers while incorporating only<br />

sustainable <strong>and</strong> organic farming techniques. Once<br />

a week the Gaos’ eldest son, Gao Yicheng, delivers<br />

produce from the co-op to multiple drop <strong>of</strong>fpoints<br />

in Chengdu, 30 kilometers away.<br />

The co-op uses the term “cheng xiang hu zhu”<br />

or urban-rural mutual aid to describe its operation.<br />

The Gaos explain this concept as a method<br />

<strong>of</strong> economic production that benefits both rural<br />

<strong>and</strong> urban areas. The model has proved successful.<br />

The Gaos are able to support themselves through<br />

their operation, circumnavigating the social <strong>and</strong><br />

economic disincentives <strong>of</strong> family farming.<br />

A highly iconoclastic culture <strong>and</strong> discourse<br />

have developed in the co-op. Several <strong>of</strong> the Gaos<br />

explained that progress should not be measured<br />

in urbanization or increasing incomes. According<br />

“Our media <strong>and</strong> culture<br />

dupe us into believing<br />

we don’t want to farm,<br />

which creates bad farms<br />

<strong>and</strong> bad farmers. But we<br />

can think for ourselves<br />

<strong>and</strong> set our own path.<br />

I don’t need to migrate.”<br />

—Gao Qingrong<br />

A farmer <strong>and</strong> his daughter carry buckets <strong>of</strong> water to their drought-affected crops in a field near the village <strong>of</strong> Zhudong<br />

in Hongchang County, Henan province. The severe drought in China has added to the hardship <strong>of</strong> millions <strong>of</strong> migrant<br />

workers who every year travel from rural China to the cities seeking work. The economic downturn that has dramatically<br />

effected exports has meant that job prospects are much harder <strong>and</strong> as a result, the extra income rural families have<br />

enjoyed during the last few years will not be possible.<br />

to Gao Yicheng, “progress should be defined by<br />

the villages themselves.”<br />

Central to the Gaos’ vision <strong>of</strong> progress is a<br />

respect for their community. They have educated<br />

themselves on sustainable agricultural practices<br />

by seeking assistance from environmental NGOs<br />

<strong>and</strong> self-study. For example, instead <strong>of</strong> using a<br />

conventional toilet, they have installed an “ecological<br />

urine-diverting dry toilet.” According to<br />

So-Han Fan, a Chengdu-based NGO pr<strong>of</strong>essional<br />

who has worked with the Anlong co-op, the toilet<br />

promotes healthy aerobic composting by separating<br />

urine <strong>and</strong> feces so that they can be converted<br />

separately into different forms <strong>of</strong> fertilizer. The<br />

Gaos also created artificial wetl<strong>and</strong>s around their<br />

farm. The wetl<strong>and</strong>s purify wastewater from the<br />

house, which is then released into nearby rivers<br />

or stored in fishponds.<br />

Gao Qingrong, 32, the eldest daughter <strong>of</strong> the<br />

Gaos, was once a migrant laborer in southern<br />

China, just one <strong>of</strong> more than 230 million others.<br />

But when she came home in 2007 for the Chinese<br />

Lunar New Year, also known as the Spring<br />

Festival, <strong>and</strong> saw how difficult it was for her family<br />

to tend the farm alone, she decided to stay.<br />

She returned to Anlong just in time to attend<br />

a sustainable farming workshop conducted by a<br />

Chengdu-based environmental NGO. Something<br />

about the workshop inspired her deeply. Since<br />

then, Qingrong has devoted herself to developing<br />

sustainable, community-oriented farming practices.<br />

In 2010, her efforts caught the eyes <strong>of</strong> PeaceWomen<br />

Across the Globe, a Nobel prize-winning Swiss<br />

organization that assists women involved in activities<br />

that promote peace. The organization named<br />

Qingrong one <strong>of</strong> its 1,000 PeaceWomen fellows<br />

<strong>and</strong> provided funding for her to attend workshops<br />

on sustainable farming practices.<br />

Qingrong believes that prevailing attitudes<br />

toward the countryside hurt villages. “Our media<br />

<strong>and</strong> culture dupe us into believing we don’t want<br />

to farm, which creates bad farms <strong>and</strong> bad farmers,”<br />

she said. “But we can think for ourselves <strong>and</strong><br />

set our own path. I don’t need to migrate.”<br />

And Qingrong remains positive about the future.<br />

“There are plenty <strong>of</strong> possibilities for sustainable<br />

farming to continue exp<strong>and</strong>ing in China,” she said.<br />

“People will come to learn about the environmental<br />

<strong>and</strong> health dangers <strong>of</strong> conventional farming. Once<br />

people know about them, they’ll make a change.”<br />

The model the Gaos operate is not a solution<br />

to all <strong>of</strong> China’s rural problems. However, it is a<br />

first step in fighting the national prejudice toward<br />

the countryside <strong>and</strong> has turned an enclave in<br />

Anlong Village into not only a more desirable but<br />

also a more sustainable place to live.<br />

David Borenstein is a first-year MIA c<strong>and</strong>idate concentrating<br />

in Economic <strong>and</strong> Political Development. He<br />

has conducted extensive ethnographic research on Chinese<br />

rural development. From 2009 to 2010, David conducted<br />

fieldwork in the Sichuan countryside as a Fulbright fellow<br />

researching peasant resistance to rural development policies.<br />

24 SIPA NEWS


Forever Young:<br />

China’s Belief in Its Own Benevolent Rise<br />

By Rebecca Chao<br />

Chinese soldiers march, with a skyline<br />

<strong>of</strong> Pudong in the background.<br />

In 850 A.D., an unknown Chinese alchemist sought to produce an elixir that would grant eternal life<br />

<strong>and</strong> unwittingly discovered gunpowder. The combination <strong>of</strong> saltpeter, charcoal, <strong>and</strong> sulfur that he<br />

thought would keep him forever young succeeded only in burning down part <strong>of</strong> his house.<br />

Though some scholars disagree, China contends that this mild explosive was developed for use in<br />

firecrackers to scare away evil spirits during its New Year’s celebrations. China prefers to focus on the<br />

spread <strong>of</strong> gunpowder to Europe in the 13th century <strong>and</strong> how Europeans developed canons <strong>and</strong> guns to<br />

conquer other nations, eventually adding China to its list in the mid to late 1800s.<br />

Regardless <strong>of</strong> the facts, China believes in its own benevolence. Further, how China sees itself reflects<br />

how it views the world <strong>and</strong> the manner in which it makes foreign policy decisions. These perceptions have<br />

affected China’s foreign policy outlook in at least one way—it does not view the United States or the rising<br />

developing world, for that matter, as threats but as indispensable partners in its rise.


A Chinese military honor guard st<strong>and</strong>s at<br />

attention in front <strong>of</strong> a mural depicting the<br />

Great Wall during a welcoming cereony<br />

for President Barack Obama in Beijing on<br />

November 17, 2009. Obama <strong>and</strong> President<br />

Hu Jintao <strong>of</strong> China met in a session<br />

that signaled the central role <strong>of</strong> China on<br />

the world stage <strong>and</strong> highlighted the different<br />

approaches that it <strong>and</strong> the United<br />

States are taking on urgent problems<br />

around the globe.<br />

Partners, Not Rivals<br />

Take, for example, global attitudes towards China’s<br />

rise. The Pew Global Attitudes Project reports<br />

that among the 18 countries surveyed in 2009 <strong>and</strong><br />

2011, the median percentage that believes China<br />

will or has already dethroned the United States as<br />

the leading superpower increased from 40 to 47<br />

percent in those two years. This adversarial position<br />

assumes that the United States <strong>and</strong> China are<br />

in competition for leadership.<br />

Yet China perceives its own rise as occurring in<br />

a multipolar world. Bonnie Glaser, a senior fellow<br />

at the Center for Strategic <strong>and</strong> <strong>International</strong> Studies,<br />

argues in a 2009 paper, that “The vast majority [<strong>of</strong><br />

Chinese scholars <strong>and</strong> experts maintain] that the<br />

prevailing international structure <strong>of</strong> power will not<br />

last; it eventually will give way to a multipolar era in<br />

which China <strong>and</strong> other emerging economies have<br />

an increasing say about issues <strong>of</strong> global importance.”<br />

Susan L. Craig, a scholar at the United States<br />

Army War College’s Strategic Studies Institute,<br />

issued a study in March 2007 that examined<br />

China’s perception <strong>of</strong> traditional <strong>and</strong> nontraditional<br />

security threats. In it, she contends that throughout<br />

history, China has viewed itself as exceptional<br />

from all other states precisely because <strong>of</strong> its long<br />

26 SIPA NEWS


history <strong>of</strong> peace <strong>and</strong> anti-imperialism. As such,<br />

China behaves defensively <strong>and</strong> rarely, if ever,<br />

<strong>of</strong>fensively.<br />

China does not appear to actively challenge<br />

the United States on contentious issues nor does<br />

it seem to have any desire to recreate a Cold War<br />

st<strong>and</strong><strong>of</strong>f. Rather, it has sought primarily to allay<br />

the negative influence <strong>of</strong> Western criticisms, such<br />

as attacks on its poor human rights records or accusations<br />

<strong>of</strong> currency manipulation. China’s criticism<br />

<strong>of</strong> Western media, for example, has focused not<br />

only on its inherent contradictions but has also<br />

emphasized that the West is flawed just like China<br />

<strong>and</strong> therefore not culturally or politically superior.<br />

When the U.S. debt deliberation nearly led to<br />

a government shutdown, China used the opportunity<br />

to point out the weaknesses <strong>of</strong> democracy.<br />

Niall Fergusson, a pr<strong>of</strong>essor <strong>of</strong> history at Harvard<br />

University, reported in Newsweek that, viewed from<br />

China, the debate over the debt ceiling confirmed<br />

that “Western democracy is a form <strong>of</strong> institutionalized<br />

chaos to be avoided by all sane Asians.”<br />

Daily Beast reporter Isaac Stone Fish followed the<br />

Chinese media’s critique <strong>of</strong> the Rupert Murdoch<br />

wiretapping sc<strong>and</strong>al in the summer <strong>of</strong> 2011. The<br />

Chinese press agency Xinhua ran an article chastising<br />

the West for unethical reporting. The Shanghai<br />

Communist Party newspaper Liberation Daily questioned<br />

whether, in fact, a free press was such a<br />

prized <strong>and</strong> universal goal. The People’s Daily, considered<br />

the <strong>of</strong>ficial mouthpiece <strong>of</strong> the Communist<br />

Party, took it further by saying, “Western media<br />

doesn’t care about social morality.” Fish also spoke<br />

with Michael Anti, a Chinese media commentator,<br />

who warned that when Western media slams<br />

Chinese media for bogus reporting or propag<strong>and</strong>a,<br />

an average Chinese reader may now think, “Well,<br />

Western media is also very rotten.”<br />

This view is not exclusive to residents <strong>of</strong><br />

China. A 2006 article by Li He in Asian Perspectives<br />

reveals that Chinese students studying in the West<br />

(liuxuesheng), who were exposed to Western media’s<br />

views on China, did not significantly alter their<br />

opinions about their homel<strong>and</strong>. A large number <strong>of</strong><br />

the returnees Li interviewed believe that though<br />

Western democracy is good, it is not appropriate<br />

for China today. While political reform is necessary<br />

within the Communist Party, the returnees<br />

advocated for greater efficiency <strong>and</strong> rule <strong>of</strong> law<br />

rather than democratization. A group known as the<br />

“New Left,” comprising leading academics, most <strong>of</strong><br />

whom are returned liuxuesheng, has also emerged in<br />

China to voice its disenchantment with the West.<br />

Li writes, “They are challenging China’s unique<br />

system <strong>of</strong> state-controlled capitalism with a simple<br />

message: What they call China’s failed 20th-century<br />

experiment with communism cannot be undone in<br />

the 21st century by embracing a 19th-century style<br />

<strong>of</strong> laissez-faire capitalism.”<br />

Friend, Foe, or Just Trying to Grow?<br />

Those who view China’s rise as a threat—mostly in<br />

the West—emphasize China’s rapid military buildup.<br />

Top U.S. defense <strong>of</strong>ficials released a report<br />

in August 2011 cataloguing China’s impressive<br />

military expenditures. While Pentagon <strong>of</strong>ficials<br />

expressed concerns about China’s military intentions<br />

in the Pacific, Michael Schiffer, the deputy<br />

assistant secretary <strong>of</strong> defense for East Asia, said<br />

that there was no particular increase that led him<br />

to describe China’s overall arms buildup as “potentially<br />

destabilizing.” Schiffer instead accused China<br />

<strong>of</strong> being opaque about its military intentions.<br />

Even if Schiffer is correct, the United States<br />

responded in November 2011 by announcing a<br />

decision to deploy 2,500 marines to Australia. It<br />

seems U.S. <strong>of</strong>ficials share the view, as Glaser argues,<br />

that “If Beijing were to perceive the U.S. position<br />

as weakening, there could be fewer inhibitions for<br />

China to avoid challenging the United States where<br />

American <strong>and</strong> Chinese interests diverge.”<br />

However, U.S. <strong>of</strong>ficials <strong>and</strong> scholars like Glaser<br />

overlook China’s perceived threats in the Pacific<br />

<strong>and</strong> thus dismiss China’s arms buildup as a defensive<br />

tactic. Despite spats with Japan <strong>and</strong> China over the<br />

South China Sea, China’s threat has been economic,<br />

not military. During a nine-day visit to China in<br />

November 2011, President Obama praised Beijing<br />

for its cooperation on South China Sea disputes.<br />

While it is difficult to assess whether China’s<br />

military spending is defensive in nature—it becomes<br />

an impossible question <strong>of</strong> who started what—<br />

China’s definition <strong>of</strong> its own borders is another<br />

example <strong>of</strong> how China perceives itself as nonimperialistic<br />

<strong>and</strong> benign. China sees its claims over<br />

Tibet <strong>and</strong> Taiwan as a question <strong>of</strong> national unity,<br />

which Craig attributes to China’s colonization by<br />

the West in the 19th century. She cites a speech<br />

given by Lieutenant General Li Jijun <strong>of</strong> the Chinese<br />

Peoples’ Liberation Army at the U.S. Army War<br />

College in 1997, in which he points to a “unifying<br />

consciousness” in China, committed to “maintaining<br />

the unity <strong>of</strong> the country <strong>and</strong> its territorial integrity<br />

<strong>and</strong> sovereignty.” Craig ascribes China’s distaste<br />

for interventionism <strong>and</strong> its insistence on respecting<br />

national integrity to that period <strong>of</strong> colonization,<br />

known in China as a “century <strong>of</strong> humiliation.”<br />

China may view itself as a friendly giant,<br />

while others question whether it is just a guise.<br />

After 5,000 years <strong>of</strong> uninterrupted civilization <strong>and</strong><br />

impressive cultural continuity, it is not unlikely that<br />

China still sees itself as wielding a firecracker, not a<br />

gun. But even at 5,000 years <strong>of</strong> age, China has not<br />

fully matured as a modern nation. It remains to be<br />

seen whether China will upgrade from firecracker<br />

to firepower as it tries to figure itself out.<br />

Rebecca Chao, SIPA News coeditor, is a second-year<br />

MIA c<strong>and</strong>idate concentrating in <strong>International</strong> Security<br />

Policy <strong>and</strong> specializing in media. She is currently the features<br />

editor <strong>of</strong> the Journal <strong>of</strong> <strong>International</strong> <strong>Affairs</strong> <strong>and</strong><br />

also writes for Asia Society.<br />

SIPA NEWS 27


In Kosovo, sport is all about<br />

politics, <strong>and</strong> Uliks Emra, one <strong>of</strong><br />

the best footballers in the country,<br />

has been facing it throughout his<br />

career. Although Kosovo declared<br />

independence in 2008, it does not<br />

have an internationally recognized<br />

team. “It’s a pity that because <strong>of</strong><br />

politics, we are not able to play<br />

internationally,” Emra said.<br />

28 SIPA NEWS


Development<br />

through Football:<br />

A Vision for<br />

the Balkans<br />

By Behar Xharra <strong>and</strong> Martin Waehlisch<br />

When Dinamo Zagreb <strong>and</strong> Red Star Belgrade entered the green <strong>of</strong><br />

Maksimir stadium in Zagreb, no one could have foreseen that their<br />

game would change the world. On May 13, 1990, their football<br />

match turned into a battlefield between Croats <strong>and</strong> Serbs, helping<br />

to trigger the beginning <strong>of</strong> the war <strong>and</strong> the end <strong>of</strong> Yugoslavia. Fans<br />

<strong>of</strong> Dinamo, known as the Bad Blue Boys, <strong>and</strong> Red Star, called Delije<br />

(“heroes”), took over the stadium in one <strong>of</strong> the most brutal football<br />

riots the region had ever seen. Symbolically, their clash expressed<br />

the ethnic tensions reflecting a revival <strong>of</strong> nationalism in the Balkans.<br />

As elsewhere in the world, football (soccer<br />

to Americans) has both torn people apart <strong>and</strong><br />

brought them together. In the Balkans, sports<br />

help to shed light on the past <strong>and</strong> ongoing<br />

struggles <strong>of</strong> the region. The war in the former<br />

Yugoslavia lasted nearly a decade. What previously<br />

had been one entity now comprises<br />

eight countries—with Montenegro <strong>and</strong> Kosovo<br />

emerging as the newest independent republics.<br />

Given the region’s past, could football reconcile<br />

former factions <strong>and</strong> reverse the Balkans’<br />

negative image abroad? Could, for instance, a<br />

World Cup 2030 organized in southeast Europe<br />

make a difference? Though this vision has challenges,<br />

the resulting benefits are even greater.<br />

Emerging out <strong>of</strong> decades <strong>of</strong> conflict, the Balkans<br />

are still characterized by negative perceptions:<br />

violence, crime, nationalism, <strong>and</strong> hate. And<br />

football continues to reveal misperceptions <strong>and</strong><br />

political divergence in the region.<br />

Hooliganism <strong>and</strong> nationalism have been<br />

nurtured in the stadiums <strong>of</strong> the Balkans.<br />

Partizan Belgrade was disqualified from the<br />

UEFA Cup 2007/2008, after violence broke<br />

out among the fans in Mostar, Bosnia <strong>and</strong><br />

Herzegovina. In September 2009, a French<br />

fan <strong>of</strong> Toulouse died from attacks by hooligans<br />

in Belgrade. In October 2010, the Italy<br />

vs. Serbia EURO 2012 qualifying match in<br />

Genoa was cancelled due to riots. In February<br />

2011, Serbia’s president Boris Tadić publicly<br />

acknowledged that hooliganism is a security<br />

problem <strong>and</strong> asked for a stop to the violence.<br />

Additionally, according to the 2010 Gallup<br />

Balkan Monitor survey, more than 40 percent <strong>of</strong><br />

people in the region regard at least one <strong>of</strong> their<br />

neighbors as hostile. One notable example is<br />

Macedonia’s dispute with Greece over its <strong>of</strong>ficial<br />

name, which has heightened nationalistic<br />

frictions. The stadiums in Skopje <strong>and</strong> Athens<br />

are arenas for hostilities, where both Greek<br />

<strong>and</strong> Macedonian flags burn when the opposing<br />

teams meet.<br />

Another notable example occurred during the<br />

Euro qualifying matches in Albania, when fans<br />

<strong>of</strong> Albanian descent from across the Balkans<br />

gathered in the stadium to express their feelings<br />

<strong>of</strong> national unity. When the Albanian <strong>and</strong> Greek<br />

teams played, fans covered the stadium with a<br />

large Albanian red-black, double-headed eagle<br />

SIPA NEWS 29


Dinamo Zagreb’s captain, Zvonimir Boban, attacks a police <strong>of</strong>ficer during soccer fan riots, prior to the<br />

match against Red Star Belgrade, Zagreb, Croatia, May 13, 1990.<br />

national flag. After Albania’s win over Belarus in<br />

March 2011 for the EURO 2012, the vice-captain<br />

<strong>of</strong> the national team took the microphone to address<br />

the exuberant fans. He warned that Albanians<br />

should not attempt to gain Greek citizenship, as<br />

many have tried, in the hope <strong>of</strong> greater social benefits<br />

<strong>and</strong> a Greek pension.<br />

Lastly, Kosovo does not even have an internationally<br />

recognized team, which is indicative <strong>of</strong> the<br />

debates surrounding its newfound statehood. In<br />

October 2008, FIFA rejected the application <strong>of</strong> the<br />

Football Federation <strong>of</strong> Kosovo based on Article 10<br />

<strong>of</strong> the FIFA statutes, which stipulates that only “an<br />

independent state recognized by the international<br />

community” may be admitted (Kosovo, which<br />

declared its independence in 2008, is recognized<br />

as a state by only 85 countries). Meanwhile, leading<br />

football players from Kosovo represent Albania,<br />

Switzerl<strong>and</strong>, Finl<strong>and</strong>, Montenegro, <strong>and</strong> Sweden.<br />

A Kosovar refugee, Fatmire Bajramaj, is now representing<br />

the German Women’s National Football<br />

Team. She was placed as one <strong>of</strong> the three top<br />

players for the 2010 FIFA Ballon d’Or, an annual<br />

award presented to the best player in the world.<br />

Though football has added to a negative image<br />

<strong>of</strong> the Balkans, the chances to impact development,<br />

diplomatic ties, <strong>and</strong> exposure through this<br />

sport are immense. In addition to those players<br />

from Kosovo, the Western Balkans have produced<br />

world-renowned football players <strong>and</strong> strategists,<br />

including the Croatian former mid-fielder Zvonimir<br />

Boban, who played for Milan; the Serbian<br />

Nemanja Vidić, captain <strong>of</strong> the English Premier<br />

League club Manchester United; the Bosnian<br />

Edi Dzeko, striker <strong>of</strong> Manchester City; <strong>and</strong> the<br />

Montenegrin player <strong>and</strong> former sports director <strong>of</strong><br />

Real Madrid, Pedrag Mijatović, to name a few.<br />

The experiences <strong>of</strong> these leading athletes<br />

playing for other international teams demonstrate<br />

the powerful impact football can have on forging<br />

bonds. “The magic <strong>of</strong> football is that it has the<br />

power to bring people traveling beyond borders<br />

<strong>and</strong> continents,” commented Dragan Stojkovic<br />

at a ministerial conference on peace consolidation<br />

<strong>and</strong> economic development <strong>of</strong> the Western<br />

Balkans in 2004. Stojkovic, who had been the<br />

captain <strong>of</strong> Red Star Belgrade during the incident<br />

in 1990, rightfully noted that “football” is a word<br />

understood in all languages <strong>of</strong> the Balkans.<br />

Indeed, football can be an effective tool for<br />

public diplomacy, peace building, <strong>and</strong> economic<br />

development. Sports are strong catalysts for change<br />

in all countries <strong>of</strong> former Yugoslavia—just as<br />

proven elsewhere. South Korea <strong>and</strong> Japan cohosted<br />

the World Cup in 2002, despite resentment over<br />

a number <strong>of</strong> unsettled Japanese-Korean disputes,<br />

stemming from Japan’s occupation <strong>and</strong> annexation<br />

<strong>of</strong> Korea in the 20th century. The FIFA World Cup<br />

2010 in South Africa allowed Africans to show the<br />

world new insights into their lives, progress, <strong>and</strong><br />

achievements. The 2012 UEFA European Football<br />

Championship will be organized jointly by Pol<strong>and</strong><br />

<strong>and</strong> Ukraine. The tournament’s <strong>of</strong>ficial logo combines<br />

the traditional art <strong>of</strong> paper cutting practiced<br />

in Pol<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> rural areas <strong>of</strong> Ukraine; the competition’s<br />

slogan is “Creating History Together.” Its<br />

opening will be in Warsaw, the finals in Kiev.<br />

Imagine then the opening <strong>of</strong> a peaceful World<br />

Cup 2030 in Zagreb’s Maksimir Stadium, quarterfinals<br />

with a view <strong>of</strong> the reconstructed skyline <strong>of</strong><br />

Sarajevo, <strong>and</strong> semifinals in Pristina <strong>and</strong> Skopje,<br />

with a team bus leaving to the finals in Belgrade.<br />

Could this plan close the cycle <strong>of</strong> the Balkans’<br />

volatile history <strong>and</strong> bring an end to the strains<br />

<strong>and</strong> prejudices <strong>of</strong> the postwar legacy? Of course,<br />

political changes will depend on more than a joyful<br />

match between 22 players, kicking a ball over<br />

the green. But football is an incredible means for<br />

mobilizing internal <strong>and</strong> external support towards a<br />

common goal. In particular, football could influence<br />

the notion <strong>of</strong> how national teams confront each<br />

other: rule-based, fair, controlled, <strong>and</strong> with respect.<br />

Football can teach governments a lesson, bringing<br />

the Balkans beyond their current stalemate.<br />

A World Cup 2030 jointly organized by previously<br />

rivaling neighbors could create the conditions<br />

for a new momentum <strong>of</strong> cooperation in southeast<br />

Europe. Football could revise the way the region<br />

is seen by the rest <strong>of</strong> the world <strong>and</strong> also help to<br />

enhance the mutual underst<strong>and</strong>ing <strong>of</strong> Croats,<br />

Serbs, Bosniaks, Kosovar Albanians, Macedonians,<br />

<strong>and</strong> other ethnic groups <strong>of</strong> the Western Balkans.<br />

Realizing such a vision would be a valuable investment<br />

in the region’s future.<br />

Behar Xharra, junior fellow <strong>of</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong>’s<br />

Harriman Institute, is a 2012 MIA c<strong>and</strong>idate at<br />

<strong>Columbia</strong> University’s <strong>School</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>International</strong> <strong>and</strong><br />

<strong>Public</strong> <strong>Affairs</strong>. Being a Kosovar, he previously worked<br />

for governmental agencies in Pristina <strong>and</strong> also served<br />

as a UNDP expert at the Kosovo Assembly <strong>and</strong> the<br />

Bangladesh Parliament.<br />

Martin Waehlisch, an international lawyer, has<br />

been working on governmental <strong>and</strong> nongovernmental<br />

projects in Kosovo. He is a visiting scholar<br />

at the Harriman Institute. Both were authors <strong>of</strong><br />

the first study on Kosovo’s <strong>Public</strong> Diplomacy,<br />

published in 2011 with the USC Center on <strong>Public</strong><br />

Diplomacy at the University <strong>of</strong> Southern California.<br />

30 SIPA NEWS


inside SIPA<br />

Faculty Honors <strong>and</strong> Awards By Alex Burnett<br />

From left to right: Douglas Almond, Michael Doyle, Suresh Naidu<br />

Congratulations to SIPA Pr<strong>of</strong>essor Michael<br />

Doyle, who received the 2011 Hubert<br />

H. Humphrey Award from the American<br />

Political Science Association (APSA).<br />

The Hubert H. Humphrey Award is presented<br />

annually in recognition <strong>of</strong> notable public service by<br />

a political scientist. The 2010 recipient was David<br />

Petraeus, former comm<strong>and</strong>ing general <strong>of</strong> U.S.<br />

forces in Iraq <strong>and</strong> Afghanistan <strong>and</strong> director-designate<br />

<strong>of</strong> the Central Intelligence Agency. Previous<br />

honorees include former SIPA dean John Ruggie,<br />

SIPA alumna Madeleine Albright, Richard Cheney,<br />

Daniel Patrick Moynihan, <strong>and</strong> Brent Scowcr<strong>of</strong>t.<br />

Pr<strong>of</strong>essor Doyle is the Harold Brown Pr<strong>of</strong>essor<br />

<strong>of</strong> U.S. Foreign <strong>and</strong> Security Policy. He<br />

specializes in international relations theory,<br />

international security, <strong>and</strong> international organizations.<br />

Previously, Doyle served as assistant<br />

secretary-general <strong>and</strong> special adviser to UN<br />

Secretary-General K<strong>of</strong>i Annan.<br />

Pr<strong>of</strong>essor Douglas Almond received the 2011<br />

Garfield Economic Impact Award. Pr<strong>of</strong>essor Almond<br />

<strong>and</strong> his coauthors, Joseph J. Doyle Jr., Am<strong>and</strong>a E.<br />

Kowalski, <strong>and</strong> Heidi Williams shared the award for<br />

their paper “Estimating Marginal Returns to Medical<br />

Care: Evidence from At-Risk Newborns.”<br />

Evaluating the lifesaving benefits <strong>of</strong> advanced,<br />

research-based medical care, they found evidence<br />

that such care enables very low birth weight babies<br />

to “beat the odds,” surviving at greater rates than<br />

would be expected based on birth weight alone.<br />

Pr<strong>of</strong>essor Almond focuses on health <strong>and</strong> applied<br />

microeconomics, with a particular interest in<br />

infant health <strong>and</strong> the environment. He previously<br />

served as a staff economist at the Council <strong>of</strong> Economic<br />

Advisers during the Clinton administration<br />

<strong>and</strong> studied the health effects <strong>of</strong> air pollution in<br />

China as a Fulbright scholar.<br />

Pr<strong>of</strong>essor Suresh Naidu was awarded a<br />

two-year junior fellowship from the Canadian Institute<br />

for Advanced Research (CIFAR). The fellowships are<br />

intended to help young <strong>and</strong> gifted scholars build their<br />

research <strong>and</strong> leadership capacity early in their careers.<br />

CIFAR junior fellows are embedded in one <strong>of</strong><br />

12 interdisciplinary research programs. Pr<strong>of</strong>essor<br />

Naidu will work as a program member within<br />

“Institutions, Organizations, <strong>and</strong> Growth.”<br />

SAVE<br />

THE<br />

DATES<br />

Pr<strong>of</strong>essor Naidu teaches economics, political<br />

economy, <strong>and</strong> development at SIPA. His research<br />

focuses on the relationships between politics <strong>and</strong><br />

economics—particularly the history <strong>of</strong> slavery <strong>and</strong><br />

economic development in the U.S. South.<br />

Pr<strong>of</strong>essor John Micgiel was awarded the Comm<strong>and</strong>er’s<br />

Cross <strong>of</strong> the Order <strong>of</strong> Merit <strong>of</strong> the Republic<br />

<strong>of</strong> Pol<strong>and</strong>. President Bronisław Komorowski bestowed<br />

state decorations on 27 distinguished people at the<br />

Polish Consulate while on a visit to New York City.<br />

The medals recognize those who have rendered<br />

great service to the Polish-American community in<br />

science, culture, business, <strong>and</strong> politics, as well as<br />

their contribution to the Polish-Jewish dialogue.<br />

In addition to teaching at SIPA, Pr<strong>of</strong>essor<br />

Micgiel is director <strong>of</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong>’s East Central<br />

European Center.<br />

Alex Burnett is communications manager<br />

in SIPA’s Office <strong>of</strong> Communications <strong>and</strong><br />

External Relations.<br />

Thursday, April 26, 2012<br />

Twelfth Annual Global Leadership Awards Dinner<br />

Honoring<br />

Lisa Anderson<br />

President, The American University in Cairo<br />

Dean Emerita, SIPA<br />

Howard G. Buffett<br />

President, The Howard G. Buffett Foundation<br />

Peter G. Peterson<br />

Founder <strong>and</strong> Chairman, the Peter G. Peterson Foundation<br />

Co-Founder <strong>and</strong> Chairman Emeritus, the Blackstone Group<br />

M<strong>and</strong>arin Oriental, New York<br />

Saturday, April 28, 2012<br />

SIPA Alumni Day<br />

Featuring in-depth discussions with faculty <strong>and</strong> alumni<br />

on topics in international <strong>and</strong> public affairs, with a special<br />

celebration <strong>of</strong> the 20th anniversary <strong>of</strong> the Program in<br />

Economic Policy Management (PEPM).<br />

More information on both events will be available at<br />

www.sipa.columbia.edu<br />

SIPA NEWS 31


inside SIPA<br />

Leaders in Global Energy: Seeking Solutions to Sustainable Energy<br />

By Alex Burnett <strong>and</strong> Michelle Chahine<br />

“I’m not concerned about the future, but the<br />

transition to the future is what I worry about.”<br />

–Eduardo Souto de Moura, 2011 Pritzker<br />

Architecture Prize Laureate<br />

Portuguese architect <strong>and</strong> Pritzker Prize<br />

Laureate Eduardo Souto de Moura was one<br />

<strong>of</strong> several distinguished guests to address<br />

the SIPA community during the school’s<br />

2011 Leaders in Global Energy series.<br />

Souto de Moura highlighted his most recent<br />

design <strong>of</strong> a home, innovative use <strong>of</strong> natural light<br />

in a museum, intelligent <strong>and</strong> cost-efficient use <strong>of</strong><br />

new materials in a skyscraper, <strong>and</strong> a new approach<br />

to the construction <strong>of</strong> a soccer stadium within its<br />

natural surroundings.<br />

“If we learn the rules <strong>of</strong> nature <strong>and</strong> approximate<br />

them, we get something fantastic,” he said. “Architecture<br />

is like an iceberg,” implying that we have<br />

seen only the tip <strong>of</strong> intelligent, sustainable design.<br />

Leaders in Global Energy is the centerpiece <strong>of</strong><br />

SIPA’s initiative to identify solutions to the challenge<br />

<strong>of</strong> creating sustainable energy while protecting the<br />

environment <strong>and</strong> reaffirming corporate citizenship.<br />

Throughout the fall, SIPA welcomed thought leaders<br />

in energy from across the government, corporate,<br />

<strong>and</strong> NGO sectors. In addition to sustainable design,<br />

they addressed topics such as energy policy in Latin<br />

America, the electricity grid, the European approach<br />

to sustainability, <strong>and</strong> wind energy.<br />

“I think we have an obligation to educate folks<br />

on the complexities we’re dealing with <strong>and</strong> try to<br />

put into context what goes into your electricity<br />

bill,” said Gordon van Welie, CEO <strong>of</strong> ISO New Engl<strong>and</strong>,<br />

the region’s primary power provider.<br />

“You know, people hear <strong>and</strong> talk about climate<br />

change <strong>and</strong> environmental issues,” said van Welie.<br />

“The question is: How do you actually engineer<br />

a system that will achieve those policy goals <strong>and</strong><br />

keep the lights on?”<br />

Solutions will require collaboration by government,<br />

corporate, <strong>and</strong> NGO leaders; the adoption <strong>of</strong><br />

new technologies; <strong>and</strong> the cultivation <strong>of</strong> a new generation<br />

<strong>of</strong> thinkers who can overcome the historical<br />

barriers to socially responsible energy policymaking.<br />

“Keep interested in energy,” said Rui Cartaxo,<br />

CEO <strong>of</strong> Portugal’s Redes Energéticas Nacionais<br />

during an examination <strong>of</strong> the electricity grid <strong>and</strong><br />

Eduardo Souto de Moura shows his design for the Municipal Stadium in Braga, Spain.<br />

power distribution. “In the next 20 years, energy<br />

will be a big part <strong>of</strong> the issues.”<br />

Edison Lobão, minister <strong>of</strong> mines <strong>and</strong> energy<br />

in Brazil, the globe’s sixth largest consumer <strong>of</strong><br />

energy, emphasized the world’s continued dependence<br />

on fossil fuels.<br />

“To counter these trends, it will be necessary<br />

to get agreement from all stakeholders to achieve<br />

what has already been agreed to in the Kyoto<br />

Protocol,” he said. “Technological developments<br />

create expectations that this will happen.”<br />

“Yes, we can alter significantly the balance between<br />

fossil fuels <strong>and</strong> alternative energy,” he noted.<br />

In a discussion dedicated to wind energy,<br />

Gabriel Alonso, CEO <strong>of</strong> Horizon Wind Energy, said<br />

innovation is improving productivity. That has reduced<br />

the cost <strong>of</strong> wind drastically, <strong>and</strong> wind power<br />

is growing worldwide. In 2010, China became the<br />

largest producer <strong>of</strong> wind power <strong>and</strong> working aggressively<br />

to develop its <strong>of</strong>fshore wind power generators.<br />

“Wind is free,” said Alonso. “Our success lies<br />

in our h<strong>and</strong>s.”<br />

Energy was also the topic <strong>of</strong> SIPA’s Gabriel<br />

Silver Memorial Lecture on November 1. Yukiya<br />

Amano, director general <strong>of</strong> the <strong>International</strong> Atomic<br />

Energy Agency (IAEA), spoke about nuclear<br />

energy <strong>and</strong> the crisis that followed last year’s<br />

earthquake in Japan. The event was cosponsored<br />

by <strong>Columbia</strong>’s World Leaders Forum.<br />

“What is most damaged by this accident is<br />

confidence,” said Amano. “So we need tangible<br />

results to restore it.”<br />

“In light <strong>of</strong> recent projections, I am very confident<br />

this is not the end <strong>of</strong> nuclear power,” he noted.<br />

In addition to the Leaders in Global Energy series,<br />

SIPA is developing new course work, fieldwork, <strong>and</strong><br />

research through the Energy <strong>and</strong> Environment concentration,<br />

which provides students with the knowledge<br />

base <strong>and</strong> analytical tools needed to address the<br />

challenge <strong>of</strong> sustainably <strong>and</strong> responsibly powering the<br />

developed <strong>and</strong> developing nations <strong>of</strong> the world.<br />

Leaders in Global Energy is sponsored by<br />

EDP–Energias de Portugal, S.A. EDP’s interests in<br />

conventional <strong>and</strong> renewable power extend across<br />

11 countries on four continents, including the<br />

United States.<br />

Michelle Chahine is a program assistant in SIPA’s<br />

Office <strong>of</strong> Communications <strong>and</strong> External Relations.<br />

32 SIPA NEWS


inside SIPA<br />

SIPA Events Highlight Emerging Economies <strong>and</strong> Economic Priorities<br />

Left: Michel Temer, vice president <strong>of</strong> the Federative Republic <strong>of</strong> Brazil, being interviewed at the BRICLab conference. Right: Brazil as a Rising Power: Mario Garnero, chairman,<br />

Brasilinvest, speaks about the changing power <strong>and</strong> business dynamics brought about by the rise <strong>of</strong> Brazil. Seated from left: Thomas Trebat, executive director, Institute <strong>of</strong> Latin<br />

American Studies, <strong>Columbia</strong> University; Sergio Cabral Filho, governor, Brazilian State <strong>of</strong> Rio de Janeiro; <strong>and</strong> Marcelo Odebrecht, chairman <strong>and</strong> CEO, Odebrecht.<br />

Representing more than 40 percent <strong>of</strong> the<br />

world’s population, Brazil, Russia, India,<br />

<strong>and</strong> China, the “BRICs,” have emerged as<br />

economic powers <strong>and</strong> significant actors in<br />

the international arena.<br />

On December 2, 2011, SIPA convened the<br />

Inaugural BricLab Conference, a half-day event<br />

that examined their rising influence on global<br />

policymaking.<br />

The conference, which took place in<br />

<strong>Columbia</strong>’s Low Rotunda, brought together<br />

leading experts to discuss the strategic, political,<br />

environmental, economic, <strong>and</strong> financial<br />

consequences <strong>of</strong> their rise. Speakers included<br />

Michel Temer, vice president <strong>of</strong> Federative<br />

Republic <strong>of</strong> Brazil; Stephen King, chief economist<br />

<strong>of</strong> HSBC; Sergei Guriev, rector <strong>of</strong> the New<br />

Economic <strong>School</strong> <strong>of</strong> Moscow; Stefan Wagstyl,<br />

Emerging Markets editor <strong>of</strong> the Financial<br />

Times; Marc Uzan, executive director <strong>of</strong> the<br />

Reinventing Bretton Woods Committee; Marcelo<br />

Odebrecht, chairman <strong>and</strong> CEO <strong>of</strong> Odebrecht;<br />

Sergio Cabral Filho, governor <strong>of</strong> Brazilian State<br />

<strong>of</strong> Rio de Janeiro; <strong>and</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> University<br />

pr<strong>of</strong>essors Merit Janow, Arvind Panagariya, <strong>and</strong><br />

Thomas Trebat.<br />

The BricLab Conference was sponsored by<br />

SIPA, HSBC, <strong>and</strong> Fórum das Américas <strong>and</strong> organized<br />

by BRICLab co-directors <strong>and</strong> SIPA adjunct<br />

pr<strong>of</strong>essors Christian Deseglise (MIA ’90) <strong>and</strong><br />

Marcos Troyjo.<br />

Lawrence H. Summers, Charles W. Eliot University Pr<strong>of</strong>essor<br />

at Harvard University, former director <strong>of</strong> the White House National Economic<br />

Council, <strong>and</strong> former U.S. Secretary <strong>of</strong> the Treasury, delivered the Gabriel Silver<br />

Memorial Lecture at SIPA on December 1. Mr. Summers shared his views on<br />

the current economic situation <strong>and</strong> how to achieve growth: “If the private sector<br />

is unable or unwilling to enable <strong>and</strong> increase its spending, there is no alternative<br />

but for a government to be prepared on a temporary basis to exp<strong>and</strong> its<br />

borrowing <strong>and</strong> exp<strong>and</strong> its spending.”<br />

SIPA NEWS 33


inside SIPA<br />

From Recipients to Donors: Brazilian Students Turn Classwork into<br />

Real-World Policy By Michelle Chahine<br />

Three Brazilian students, each attending<br />

SIPA on a Lemann Fellowship, are taking<br />

the spirit <strong>of</strong> their fellowship to heart. Established<br />

by Brazilian entrepreneur Jorge Paulo<br />

Lemann, the fellowships are intended to promote<br />

student exchange between SIPA <strong>and</strong> Brazil.<br />

The three students—Karin Vazquez, Andres<br />

Lalinde, <strong>and</strong> Tatiana Cabral Schnurr (MIA ’12)—<br />

turned their final project for a management course<br />

into a strategy paper for the Brazilian government.<br />

Fellow SIPA student Xheni Shehu (MIA ’11)<br />

cowrote the project.<br />

The paper, “From a Fledgling Donor to a Powerhouse:<br />

Improving Brazil’s Development Cooperation<br />

Framework <strong>and</strong> Institution Settings,” was<br />

distributed to various government <strong>of</strong>ficials at ABC,<br />

the Brazilian Cooperation Agency; EMBRAPA, the<br />

Brazilian Agricultural Research Corporation; <strong>and</strong><br />

Caixa Econômica Federal (CAIXA), the public bank.<br />

“The Lemann Fellowship is awarded to individuals<br />

passionate about creating a better future<br />

for Brazil, either internally or externally,” explained<br />

Lalinde. “Since the project focused on Brazil’s exportation<br />

model for development <strong>and</strong> cooperation<br />

knowledge transfers, analyzing ABC’s strengths<br />

<strong>and</strong> weaknesses from a consulting perspective<br />

was an excellent avenue for three Lemann Fellows<br />

(<strong>and</strong> one non-Fellow), to recommend changes that<br />

would ultimately improve external relations abroad.<br />

The ABC project was by far the most rewarding<br />

academic endeavor I had ever accomplished.”<br />

The topic <strong>of</strong> the paper was the brainchild <strong>of</strong><br />

Vazquez, who worked in the Brazilian government<br />

before attending SIPA.<br />

“Because I was already working in the area,”<br />

she said, “I was very interested in how emerging<br />

countries are increasingly becoming donors <strong>of</strong><br />

international aid <strong>and</strong> less recipients <strong>of</strong> international<br />

aid.”<br />

“There’s this momentum around aid effectiveness,”<br />

she added, “a South-South cooperation<br />

agenda that is increasingly being seen as an alternative<br />

to the North-South model <strong>of</strong> development<br />

cooperation, possibly the future <strong>of</strong> development<br />

cooperation.”<br />

Vazquez was interested in looking at Brazil <strong>and</strong><br />

the Brazilian Agency for Development Cooperation<br />

(ABC), to see how, given this new role that Brazil<br />

was playing, the agency could improve its strategic<br />

focus <strong>and</strong> the effectiveness <strong>of</strong> its operation.<br />

The team conducted interviews with current<br />

<strong>and</strong> former employees at ABC. With the raw data<br />

they gathered, they used the frameworks they<br />

were learning in their “Strategic Thinking for<br />

General Managers” course with Pr<strong>of</strong>essor Paul<br />

Thurman to analyze the agency’s problems <strong>and</strong><br />

develop recommendations.<br />

“It was interesting because our problem tree<br />

was huge,” laughed Vazquez. One major problem<br />

the team found was the limited communication<br />

between the agency <strong>and</strong> other parts <strong>of</strong> the Brazilian<br />

government.<br />

“We actually tried to suggest a mechanism for<br />

these actors to interact more efficiently as well,”<br />

said Vazquez. “Even though the main focus was<br />

more internal to ABC, this communication channel<br />

with others was a mid- to-long-term recommendation<br />

. . . We also later found that other agencies in<br />

the government had similar problems at well.”<br />

“It was a pleasant surprise to receive the report<br />

from [the] students,” said Antonio Prado, coordinator<br />

<strong>of</strong> international cooperation at EMBRAPA,<br />

via e-mail. “This report is very useful because it<br />

contributes to the necessary reflection on how the<br />

Brazilian cooperation for development is structured,<br />

what its bottlenecks are, <strong>and</strong> how institutions<br />

such as EMBRAPA may help improve Brazil’s<br />

cooperation.”<br />

According to Prado, the report was e-mailed to<br />

all the employees <strong>of</strong> EMBRAPA’s Secretariat for<br />

<strong>International</strong> <strong>Affairs</strong>, which is responsible for the<br />

operational management <strong>of</strong> international agricultural<br />

projects.<br />

“It was such a great experience to work on<br />

a project with other Lemann Fellows because it<br />

highlighted our diversity <strong>and</strong> individual strengths,”<br />

said Cabral Schnurr. “The common denominator<br />

was a passion for the development <strong>of</strong> Brazil, which<br />

made the commitment towards finding sustainable<br />

<strong>and</strong> feasible solutions even stronger. I think the<br />

project was one <strong>of</strong> the most personally gratifying<br />

works in each <strong>of</strong> our academic careers.”<br />

Jorge Paulo Lemann c<strong>of</strong>ounded the investment banking firm Banco Garantia <strong>and</strong> helped grow it<br />

into one <strong>of</strong> Brazil’s most prestigious <strong>and</strong> innovative investment banks. In 2001, Lemann founded the Lemann<br />

Foundation, a nonpr<strong>of</strong>it organization that aims to improve education quality <strong>and</strong> opportunities in Brazil. Projects<br />

to achieve this goal include different scholarship programs, research <strong>and</strong> dissemination about best practices in<br />

education management, <strong>and</strong> training programs for educational leaders.<br />

Lemann Fellowships provide support to students participating in the <strong>School</strong>’s dual-degree program with<br />

Fundação Getulio Vargas Escola de Administração de Empresas de São Paulo, to students who live or have lived in<br />

Brazil, <strong>and</strong> for students to engage in study, research, <strong>and</strong> internships in Brazil.<br />

Visit SIPA’s Lemann Fellows webpage at http://lemannfellows.sipa.columbia.edu<br />

34 SIPA NEWS


inside SIPA<br />

Witnesses to History: SIPA Interns around the World By Michelle Chahine<br />

It is a rite <strong>of</strong> passage—second-year SIPA<br />

students return for the fall semester <strong>and</strong><br />

share the incredible experiences they had<br />

traveling around the globe for their summer<br />

internships.<br />

Christopher Reeve (MIA ’12) spent last<br />

summer interning at a Cairo newspaper, in line<br />

with his specialization in <strong>International</strong> Media,<br />

Advocacy, <strong>and</strong> Communications. He worked as<br />

a reporter at Al-Masry Al-Youm, Egypt’s leading<br />

independent newspaper, which had just launched<br />

an English edition.<br />

“There was so much news happening. News<br />

happened every day,” Christopher said. “Even<br />

when I wasn’t reporting, I was experiencing something<br />

major <strong>and</strong> consequential to the world.”<br />

It wasn’t just editorial <strong>and</strong> reporting experience<br />

that he gained from his internship. He had a<br />

front-row seat to history.<br />

“There was a happiness in the street, in the<br />

air. Everyone has hope now,” he said. “I have<br />

much more hope than I did previously.”<br />

Juontel White (MIA ’12) spent three months in<br />

Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. She worked for UNESCO<br />

as a research assistant for a large conference on<br />

teacher migration <strong>and</strong> mobility. Juontel engaged<br />

with ministers <strong>of</strong> education throughout Africa <strong>and</strong><br />

the Commonwealth <strong>and</strong> traveled to rural areas to<br />

interview students <strong>and</strong> teachers at adult literacy<br />

centers.<br />

“It was inspiring because in marginalized<br />

communities, they don’t see the importance <strong>of</strong><br />

education (for themselves <strong>and</strong> their children)<br />

until they’re invited to these centers,” she said.<br />

Jonathan Roose (MIA ’12) spent his summer<br />

in Kazakhstan <strong>and</strong> Kyrgyzstan. He interned in<br />

Almaty, Kazakhstan, for the Eurasia Foundation<br />

<strong>of</strong> Central Asia (EFCA), where he edited <strong>and</strong> assisted<br />

in proposal writing.<br />

“The experience was truly great,” he said.<br />

“I learned a ton about the developing world,<br />

Kazakhstan, Central Asia, <strong>and</strong> the post-Soviet<br />

world.” Jonathan also taught English in Almaty<br />

<strong>and</strong> Kyrgyzstan.<br />

Homa Hassan (MIA ’12) served with the<br />

United Nations Development Programme in Pristina,<br />

Kosovo, where she helped implement the<br />

five-year Common Development Plan <strong>and</strong> create<br />

an interagency knowledge portal to compile <strong>and</strong><br />

map data, statistics, <strong>and</strong> studies.<br />

“Working in Kosovo was one <strong>of</strong> the highlights<br />

<strong>of</strong> my life,” said Homa. “I gained a huge appreciation<br />

by watching one <strong>of</strong> the world’s newest<br />

nations grapple with the challenge <strong>of</strong> overcoming<br />

recent carnage with resiliency <strong>and</strong> optimism.”<br />

Nadia Hasham (MIA ’12) was in Kurnool,<br />

Andhra Pradesh, India, working on a pilot study<br />

for an SMS-based vaccination reminders project<br />

for mothers with newborns. It was a joint project<br />

between the India-based NGO Developmental<br />

Medical Foundation <strong>and</strong> the U.S.-based company<br />

Medic Mobile.<br />

“I was able to liaise with key players in the<br />

region, including UNICEF, district <strong>and</strong> state<br />

governments, the World Bank, <strong>and</strong> others,” said<br />

Nadia. “I have enjoyed this project so much that<br />

I have decided to stay on board until its completion<br />

18 months from now.”<br />

Ethan Wilkes (MIA ’12) had not one, but two,<br />

internships in China <strong>and</strong> got to rub shoulders<br />

with the number two man at the White House.<br />

Ethan began by working at Aureos Capital in<br />

Qingdao, a small provincial city in the northeast<br />

part <strong>of</strong> the country. There he put together communications<br />

material for investors <strong>and</strong> worked in<br />

fundraising.<br />

He then moved to the <strong>International</strong> Trade<br />

Administration at the American Embassy in Beijing,<br />

working on a research project looking into<br />

Chinese state-owned enterprises. Ethan said SIPA<br />

made this opportunity possible—he found it on<br />

SIPALink, the career portal for students.<br />

“We had a lot <strong>of</strong> delegations coming through,<br />

too,” he said. “As an intern, you get to sit in on<br />

these massive trade relation meetings as a fly on<br />

the wall. It’s fascinating.”<br />

One <strong>of</strong> these delegations was that <strong>of</strong> U.S. Vice<br />

President Joseph Biden. Wilkes met the vice president<br />

at an embassy meet-<strong>and</strong>-greet.<br />

“Rarely do you get the opportunity to be<br />

exposed to people <strong>of</strong> that level <strong>and</strong> listen to their<br />

thoughts,” he added.<br />

Michelle Chahine is a program assistant in<br />

SIPA’s Office <strong>of</strong> Communications <strong>and</strong> External<br />

Relations.<br />

From top: Cairo’s Tahrir Square; Juontel White;<br />

Nadia Hasham (far right); Ethan Wilkes with Vice<br />

President Biden.<br />

SIPA NEWS 35


inside SIPA<br />

PhD Students Connect Climate Change <strong>and</strong> Civil War By Alex Burnett<br />

El Niño can help spark civil war, according to<br />

research by SIPA <strong>and</strong> The Earth Institute’s<br />

PhD program in sustainable development.<br />

Kyle Meng, a PhD c<strong>and</strong>idate in the<br />

program, <strong>and</strong> Solomon Hsiang, a 2011 graduate,<br />

coauthored the study in the journal Nature,<br />

detailing their research linking the climate cycle to<br />

increases in warfare. Mark Cane, a climate scientist<br />

at <strong>Columbia</strong> University’s Lamont-Doherty Earth<br />

Observatory, was the third coauthor.<br />

The study found that the arrival <strong>of</strong> El Niño,<br />

which every three to seven years boosts temperatures<br />

<strong>and</strong> cuts rainfall, doubles the risk <strong>of</strong> civil<br />

wars across 90 tropical nations. It says El Niño<br />

may have played a role in a fifth <strong>of</strong> all worldwide<br />

conflicts during the past 50 years.<br />

This is the first study <strong>of</strong> its kind, linking global<br />

weather observations <strong>and</strong> documented violence,<br />

to point to climate as a possible cause <strong>of</strong> future<br />

destabilization. The study does not blame specific<br />

conflicts on El Niño nor address long-term climate<br />

change. But it does point to how a warming<br />

climate could contribute to existing conflicts in<br />

places like Somalia.<br />

“The most important thing is that this looks at<br />

modern times, <strong>and</strong> it’s done on a global scale,”<br />

says Hsiang.<br />

“We can speculate that a long-ago Egyptian<br />

dynasty was overthrown during a drought,” he<br />

continues. “That’s a specific time <strong>and</strong> place,<br />

which may be very different from today, so people<br />

might say, ‘OK, we’re immune to that now.’ This<br />

study shows a systematic pattern <strong>of</strong> global climate<br />

affecting conflict, <strong>and</strong> it shows it right now.”<br />

The PhD in Sustainable Development combines<br />

elements <strong>of</strong> a traditional graduate education in<br />

social science, particularly economics, with a<br />

significant component <strong>of</strong> training in the natural<br />

sciences. Students in SIPA’s Sustainable Development<br />

PhD program come from a wide variety <strong>of</strong><br />

backgrounds <strong>and</strong> are working on a diverse set<br />

<strong>of</strong> research topics, including poverty <strong>and</strong> water<br />

resources, green building, climate uncertainty <strong>and</strong><br />

policy, disaster risk reduction, low-resources health<br />

systems, <strong>and</strong> sustainable design. The program’s<br />

graduates are uniquely situated to undertake serious<br />

research <strong>and</strong> policy assessments with the goal<br />

<strong>of</strong> sustainable development.<br />

SIPA Alumnae Direct New Global Centers<br />

<strong>Columbia</strong> University launched two new<br />

Global Centers in fall 2011, each directed<br />

by a SIPA alumna: Karen Poniachik (MIA<br />

’90) in Santiago, Chile, <strong>and</strong> Ipek Cem-<br />

Taha (MIA ’93, BUS ’93) in Istanbul, Turkey.<br />

In September, Poniachik joined University<br />

President Lee C. Bollinger, Andronico Luksic, vice<br />

chairman <strong>of</strong> Banco de Chile, <strong>and</strong> Kenneth Prewitt,<br />

vice president <strong>of</strong> <strong>Columbia</strong> Global Centers, at a<br />

signing ceremony hosted by SIPA dean John H.<br />

Coatsworth. Her new role, directing the University’s<br />

first center in Latin America, adds to an<br />

impressive career in government <strong>and</strong> business.<br />

After graduating from SIPA, Poniachik served<br />

as director <strong>of</strong> business <strong>and</strong> financial programs<br />

at the Council <strong>of</strong> the Americas in New York from<br />

1995 to 2000. She moved to Chile to serve as<br />

executive vice president <strong>of</strong> the Foreign Investment<br />

Committee (2000–2006), minister <strong>of</strong> energy<br />

(2006–2007), <strong>and</strong> minister <strong>of</strong> mining (2006–<br />

2008). Her last role with the Chilean government<br />

was as special envoy in charge <strong>of</strong> negotiating<br />

Chile’s ascension to the OECD, achieved in January<br />

2010.<br />

The University launched its sixth Global Center<br />

in Istanbul in early November with a series <strong>of</strong><br />

events <strong>and</strong> scholarly panels attended by President<br />

Bollinger, Dean Coatsworth, newly appointed<br />

interim director Ipek Cem-Taha, several <strong>Columbia</strong><br />

faculty <strong>and</strong> deans, <strong>and</strong> scholars from the region.<br />

Cem-Taha is a Turkish businesswoman, journalist,<br />

<strong>and</strong> leading member <strong>of</strong> several communitybased<br />

<strong>and</strong> international organizations. From 2005<br />

to 2011, she produced <strong>and</strong> hosted the program<br />

“Global Leaders” in association with NTV, Turkey’s<br />

leading news channel. She has also served as a<br />

newspaper columnist, commenting on international<br />

trends, politics, <strong>and</strong> economics. Cem-Taha<br />

is also a co-founder <strong>and</strong> director <strong>of</strong> Melak Investments,<br />

which provides strategic advice to funds<br />

<strong>and</strong> companies looking to invest in Turkey. Previously,<br />

she was a co-founder <strong>and</strong> managing partner<br />

<strong>of</strong> Netwise/IKC Communications, an Internet<br />

services company.<br />

Ipek Cem-Taha with President Bollinger at the launch<br />

<strong>of</strong> the Global Center in Istanbul.<br />

36 SIPA NEWS


inside SIPA<br />

From SIPA to Iraq to Afghanistan: An Interview with Carlos Terrones<br />

By Michelle Chahine<br />

After his graduation from SIPA, Carlos<br />

Terrones (MPA ’08) left New York City<br />

for Iraq <strong>and</strong> Afghanistan. In Iraq, he<br />

worked for the U.S. Department <strong>of</strong> State<br />

in governance <strong>and</strong> reconstruction-development<br />

efforts. He was then asked to assist with similar<br />

work in Afghanistan.<br />

What is your work currently in Afghanistan?<br />

How long have you been there, <strong>and</strong> how long<br />

will you remain?<br />

I am currently the civilian team leader for the<br />

District Support Team in the District <strong>of</strong> Maiw<strong>and</strong>. I<br />

am the State Department representative <strong>and</strong> lead<br />

governance adviser. I lead a team <strong>of</strong> USAID <strong>and</strong><br />

U.S. Army <strong>of</strong>ficers in charge with governance <strong>and</strong><br />

reconstruction-development. I’ve been in Afghanistan<br />

for almost a year <strong>and</strong> will end my tour at the<br />

end <strong>of</strong> January 2012. I came to Afghanistan after<br />

working in Iraq from 2008 to 2010.<br />

What has your experience been, both personal <strong>and</strong><br />

pr<strong>of</strong>essional?<br />

On the personal level, working in conflict zones<br />

in Iraq <strong>and</strong> Afghanistan has increased my<br />

mental <strong>and</strong> physical strength. I spent my tours<br />

in Iraq <strong>and</strong> Afghanistan embedded with the U.S.<br />

military in combat areas far away from the large<br />

cities in Iraq <strong>and</strong> Afghanistan. Life was lonely,<br />

<strong>and</strong> I discovered encouragement through my<br />

friendship with my U.S. military counterparts,<br />

friends, <strong>and</strong> family. I almost lost my life once in<br />

Iraq <strong>and</strong> once in Afghanistan. I’ve learned how<br />

to take care <strong>of</strong> myself because I have dealt with<br />

uncertainty <strong>and</strong> violence.<br />

Despite the violence <strong>and</strong> uncertainty that<br />

I have been exposed to pr<strong>of</strong>essionally, I have<br />

learned a lot <strong>and</strong> gained substantial experience<br />

from both the international coalition <strong>and</strong> Afghan<br />

side. I’ve learned the importance <strong>of</strong> being streetwise<br />

<strong>and</strong> how to adapt to the culture’s tribal norms<br />

<strong>and</strong> expectations.<br />

My prior military experience as a marine <strong>and</strong><br />

in international development in Latin America, the<br />

Middle East, <strong>and</strong> Asia provided me with the tools<br />

to work in conflict zones. Working in tough situations<br />

has brought about my critical thinking to go<br />

outside the box, always seek self-improvement,<br />

<strong>and</strong> provide the best alternatives to assist the local<br />

communities <strong>and</strong> subnational governments.<br />

I have really enjoyed assisting in the development<br />

<strong>of</strong> the Afghan subnational government that<br />

is trying to become self-sufficient, transparent, accountable,<br />

<strong>and</strong> capable <strong>of</strong> identifying, prioritizing,<br />

<strong>and</strong> servicing the needs <strong>of</strong> the Afghan people. As I<br />

am coming to the end <strong>of</strong> my tour in Afghanistan, I<br />

am proud to have been able to turn around one <strong>of</strong><br />

the most war-torn districts in Afghanistan, which<br />

was known as one <strong>of</strong> the birthplaces <strong>of</strong> the Taliban,<br />

into one <strong>of</strong> the most supportive <strong>and</strong> engaged<br />

districts in governance <strong>and</strong> development activities.<br />

Although much work remains to be done to<br />

destabilize the Taliban shadow government, the<br />

mentorship <strong>and</strong> perseverance working side by side<br />

with our Afghan local <strong>of</strong>ficials are finally showing<br />

positive signs whereby local leaders <strong>and</strong> villagers<br />

are becoming active agents in their communities.<br />

How do you feel SIPA prepared you for this?<br />

My SIPA education was essential to this work.<br />

SIPA provided me with strong analytical tools<br />

that I have applied to development strategies in a<br />

district west <strong>of</strong> K<strong>and</strong>ahar City, which is recovering<br />

from the Taliban insurgent activity. I have a Master<br />

in <strong>Public</strong> Administration with a concentration in<br />

Economic <strong>and</strong> Political Development.<br />

Do you have advice for students who may want to<br />

work in conflict zones post-SIPA?<br />

For those interested in working in conflict zones,<br />

I recommend that they take management classes<br />

while they are at SIPA. Having a basic knowledge<br />

<strong>of</strong> management is important because <strong>of</strong> the rapidly<br />

changing policies that we continue to have <strong>and</strong><br />

adapt. With good management they will be able to<br />

adapt to crises <strong>and</strong> create solutions for their work<br />

with colleagues <strong>and</strong> local counterparts.<br />

“I’ve learned the importance<br />

<strong>of</strong> being streetwise <strong>and</strong> how<br />

to adapt to the culture’s tribal<br />

norms <strong>and</strong> expectations.”<br />

SIPA NEWS 37


class notes SIPA<br />

Class Notes Compiled by Pat Jones<br />

1974<br />

James Bruno, MIA<br />

James Bruno has published a political<br />

thriller centering on Afghanistan. Tribe is<br />

an American take on John Le Carré’s gray<br />

world <strong>of</strong> espionage, a meditation on the<br />

bigger issues <strong>of</strong> trust <strong>and</strong> betrayal <strong>and</strong> how<br />

to find room for patriotism or integrity in<br />

a world <strong>of</strong> runaway egos <strong>and</strong> ambition.<br />

James’ previous two novels, Permanent Interests<br />

<strong>and</strong> Chasm, have been steady Amazon<br />

Kindle bestsellers since late 2010. James<br />

was a Foreign Service <strong>of</strong>ficer with the U.S.<br />

Department <strong>of</strong> State, where he worked on<br />

Afghanistan for nearly five years.<br />

1982<br />

Kary Moss, MIA<br />

Kary Moss was inducted into the Michigan<br />

Women’s Hall <strong>of</strong> Fame at an awards dinner<br />

in East Lansing, Michigan on October 27.<br />

The State Bar <strong>of</strong> Michigan presented her<br />

with a 2011 Champion <strong>of</strong> Justice Award on<br />

September 14. She is the first female executive<br />

director <strong>of</strong> the ACLU <strong>of</strong> Michigan.<br />

1984<br />

Brent Feigenbaum, MIA<br />

Brent Feigenbaum has joined Centerline<br />

to head its corporate marketing<br />

communications <strong>and</strong> investor relations<br />

departments, reporting to Robert L. Levy,<br />

president <strong>and</strong> CFO. Brent is a 25-year<br />

veteran in strategic marketing communications.<br />

At Centerline he will focus on<br />

raising the firm’s visibility by elevating its<br />

marketing, public relations, <strong>and</strong> investor<br />

relations initiatives, as well as enhancing<br />

the firm’s overall internal employee<br />

communications. He is a noted expert in<br />

developing high impact integrated marketing<br />

communications programs in the<br />

financial services arena, with a particular<br />

focus on corporate banking, private<br />

banking, <strong>and</strong> commercial real estate.<br />

1986<br />

David R. Claussenius, MIA<br />

David R. Claussenius has been named<br />

Peace Corps country director <strong>of</strong> Thail<strong>and</strong>.<br />

David joined Save the Children/U.S. as<br />

deputy director for Asia Pacific region<br />

in 1988 <strong>and</strong> has held several leadership<br />

positions with the organization. David<br />

served as director <strong>of</strong> the Philippines <strong>and</strong><br />

Asia <strong>and</strong> Middle East programs, headed<br />

the program in Vietnam, <strong>and</strong> worked as<br />

regional director for South <strong>and</strong> Southeast<br />

Asia. Most recently, he was the lead project<br />

manager <strong>of</strong> an international program<br />

unit <strong>of</strong> Save the Children, implementing<br />

programs in 72 countries.<br />

Ranjini Pillay, MIA<br />

Ranjini Pillay was honored this past<br />

October at the 19th Annual Women <strong>of</strong><br />

Distinction Breakfast, presented by the<br />

Girl Scouts <strong>of</strong> Greater New York.<br />

1991<br />

Mikel Herrington, MIA, IF<br />

Mikel Herrington has been named Peace<br />

Corps country director <strong>of</strong> Bulgaria.<br />

Mikel worked for almost 14 years with<br />

the Corporation for National <strong>and</strong> Community<br />

Service, where he spent most<br />

<strong>of</strong> his time in the AmeriCorps National<br />

Civilian Community Corps (NCCC)<br />

program. Mikel has directed English<br />

language <strong>and</strong> U.S. cultural programs in<br />

China, led a team <strong>of</strong> graduate students<br />

from <strong>Columbia</strong> University on a maternal,<br />

infant, <strong>and</strong> child health care project<br />

in Belize, <strong>and</strong> served as a research fellow<br />

at the Centre for Strategic <strong>and</strong> <strong>International</strong><br />

Studies in Jakarta, Indonesia.<br />

1992<br />

Dan Viederman, MIA<br />

Dan Viederman was named Social<br />

Entrepreneur <strong>of</strong> the Year in the United<br />

States by the Geneva, Switzerl<strong>and</strong>–<br />

based Schwab Foundation for Social<br />

Entrepreneurship for his work as CEO<br />

with Verité. Verité is an international<br />

nonpr<strong>of</strong>it consulting, training, <strong>and</strong><br />

research organization that has been a<br />

leader in supply social responsibility <strong>and</strong><br />

sustainability for 15 years. Verité solves<br />

the most difficult supply chain human<br />

rights problems to help the most vulnerable<br />

workers around the world.<br />

1997<br />

Akiko Sugaya, MIA<br />

Akiko Sugaya received a Nieman Fellowship<br />

at Harvard for 2011–2012 from<br />

the Nieman Foundation for Journalism.<br />

The Nieman Fellowship is a prestigious<br />

award that gives fellows the opportunity<br />

to study <strong>and</strong> explore research topics at<br />

Harvard University for one year.<br />

2000<br />

Juan Pablo Jimenez, MIA<br />

Juan Pablo Jimenez is co-author <strong>of</strong><br />

“Macroeconomic Challenges <strong>of</strong> Fiscal<br />

Decentralization in Latin America in the<br />

Aftermath <strong>of</strong> the Global Financial Crisis,”<br />

published by the Economic Commission<br />

for Latin America <strong>and</strong> the Caribbean<br />

(ECLAC). The paper discusses how fiscal<br />

decentralization is affecting macroeconomic<br />

management in the main Latin<br />

American countries <strong>and</strong> which reforms in<br />

the existing intergovernmental systems<br />

could help strengthen their fiscal sustainability<br />

<strong>and</strong> create fiscal space for active<br />

countercyclical responses to economic<br />

shocks. The paper was prepared within<br />

the project entitled “Decentralization <strong>and</strong><br />

Governance” executed by ECLAC <strong>and</strong><br />

the German Cooperation (GIZ), where<br />

Juan is the coordinator.<br />

2002<br />

Dana Curran Mortenson, MIA<br />

Madiha Murshed, MIA<br />

Dana Curran Mortenson <strong>and</strong> Madiha<br />

Murshed are the c<strong>of</strong>ounders <strong>of</strong> World Savvy,<br />

an education nonpr<strong>of</strong>it in the United<br />

States. World Savvy educates <strong>and</strong> engages<br />

youth in community <strong>and</strong> world affairs<br />

to learn, work, <strong>and</strong> live as responsible<br />

global citizens in the 21st century. Since<br />

its founding, World Savvy has grown to<br />

serve more than 10,000 youth <strong>and</strong> 1,400<br />

teachers from three <strong>of</strong>fices nationally.<br />

Dana <strong>and</strong> Madiha recently secured a grant<br />

from the U.S. Department <strong>of</strong> State for an<br />

exchange program for students from the<br />

U.S. to visit Bangladesh to learn about<br />

climate change issues. Bangladesh is a<br />

country on the frontlines <strong>of</strong> the climate<br />

change threat. Through World Savvy’s<br />

programs, students from the United States<br />

will study climate change issues in partnership<br />

with students in Bangladesh, who<br />

will be recruited from Scholastica, a large,<br />

private English middle school in Dhaka,<br />

Bangladesh, <strong>of</strong> which Madiha Murshed is<br />

the managing director. The co-founders <strong>of</strong><br />

World Savvy would be delighted to hear<br />

from any SIPA alums who want to learn<br />

more about World Savvy or the student<br />

exchange program. For more information<br />

about World Savvy, visit http://www.<br />

worldsavvy.org/ www.worldsavvy.org.<br />

2006<br />

Veronica Conforme, MPA<br />

Veronica Conforme has been appointed<br />

by NYC <strong>School</strong>s Chancellor Dennis<br />

M. Walcott as chief operating <strong>of</strong>ficer <strong>of</strong><br />

the Department <strong>of</strong> Education (DOE).<br />

Veronica, who joined the DOE in 2003,<br />

has served as chief financial <strong>of</strong>ficer since<br />

December 2010. Her new position was<br />

effective as <strong>of</strong> November 1, 2011.<br />

Nathaniel Hurd, MIA<br />

Nathaniel Hurd has become the<br />

Washington, D.C.-based policy adviser<br />

for Conflicts <strong>and</strong> Disasters, World Vision<br />

U.S. World Vision is a leading Christian<br />

international relief <strong>and</strong> development organization,<br />

responding to disasters, conflict,<br />

poverty, <strong>and</strong> disease in more than 100<br />

countries. Nathaniel advises World Vision<br />

<strong>and</strong> represents the agency with Congress<br />

<strong>and</strong> the U.S. government, on areas such as<br />

breaking disasters, Afghanistan, Pakistan,<br />

Haiti, civil-military relations, <strong>and</strong> more.<br />

2010<br />

Andrew Kessinger, MIA, IF<br />

Andrew Kessinger is now living in Paris,<br />

after having worked for a women’s empowerment<br />

project in Sierra Leone. He<br />

is currently a communications manager<br />

in the Science, Technology, <strong>and</strong> Industry<br />

directorate at the Organization for Economic<br />

Co-operation <strong>and</strong> Development.<br />

Pat Jones is an administrative assistant in SIPA’s<br />

Office <strong>of</strong> Communications <strong>and</strong> External Relations.<br />

38 SIPA NEWS


Donor List SIPA<br />

Donor List July 1, 2010, to June 30, 2011<br />

“CERT” followed by year = graduate with certificate from a Regional Institute<br />

“IF” followed by year = graduate <strong>of</strong> the <strong>International</strong> Fellows Program<br />

“MIA” followed by year = graduate with a Master in <strong>International</strong> <strong>Affairs</strong><br />

“MPA” followed by year = graduate with a Master in <strong>Public</strong> Administration<br />

$500,000+<br />

Anonymous<br />

EDP—Energias de Portugal, S.A.<br />

Vladimir V. Kuznetsov, MIA ’91, IF ’90<br />

Jorge Paulo Lemann<br />

Andronico Luksic/E. Abaroa Foundation<br />

John Templeton Foundation<br />

$100,000–$499,999<br />

Estate <strong>of</strong> Julius G. Blocker<br />

Arminio Fraga<br />

Irish Aid<br />

Henry Luce Foundation<br />

Brett A. Olsher, MIA ’93<br />

David B. Ottaway, IF ’63<br />

Smith Richardson Foundation<br />

David John Sainsbury/The Gatsby<br />

Charitable Foundation<br />

Jeffrey L. Schmidt, IF ’79, CERT ’79/<br />

Jeffrey L. Schmidt Fellowship<br />

Charitable Trust<br />

The Spencer Foundation<br />

Maurice Samuels, MIA ’83<br />

Veolia Environnement<br />

$25,000–$99,999<br />

Amy Levine Abrams, MIA ’81, IF ’81/<br />

Abrams Foundation<br />

Georgia Adams, MIA ’83 <strong>and</strong> Charles<br />

Adams, MIA ’83<br />

William Vincent Campbell<br />

Carnegie Corporation <strong>of</strong> New York<br />

Alex<strong>and</strong>er Georgiadis, MIA ’85/Krinos<br />

Foods Canada Ltd.<br />

A. Michael H<strong>of</strong>fman, MIA ’69, IF ’69<br />

Nemir Kirdar/Investcorp<br />

Marc St. John, MIA ’84, IF ’84 <strong>and</strong> Julie<br />

Newton St. John, MIA ’85<br />

Ipek Nur Cem Taha, MIA ’93 <strong>and</strong> Shwan<br />

I. Taha<br />

$10,000–$24,999<br />

Anonymous<br />

Reed David Auerbach, MIA ’81, IF ’81<br />

<strong>and</strong> Adrienne Petite Auerbach<br />

Roger R. Baumann, IF ’84, MIA ’85 <strong>and</strong><br />

Julie Baumann<br />

Matthew Boyer, MIA ’94<br />

Kim Christopher Bradley, MIA ’83<br />

Michael James Br<strong>and</strong>meyer, MIA ’95,<br />

IF ’95<br />

Brazilian-American Chamber <strong>of</strong><br />

Commerce<br />

Edward T. Cloonan, MIA ’77 <strong>and</strong> Linda<br />

Cloonan<br />

Financial Women’s Association <strong>of</strong> NY<br />

Educational Fund<br />

Sonia Gardner/Avenue Capital<br />

Management<br />

Richard S. Goldberg<br />

Donald Loyd Holley, MIA ’59<br />

Anuradha T. Jayanti/Rev Trust <strong>of</strong><br />

Anuradha Jayanti<br />

Robert I. Kopech, MIA ’77<br />

Sidney & Robert Katzman Foundation<br />

Harley L. Lippman, MIA ’79/Genesis 10<br />

The Lucius N. Littauer Foundation<br />

James Luikart, MIA ’72 <strong>and</strong> Amira Luikart<br />

Peter Neill Marber, MIA ’87/Marber<br />

Family Charitable Fund/HSBC Global<br />

Asset Management<br />

Juan Navarro/Supermarkets Norte<br />

Investments<br />

Barbara Helen Reguero, MIA ’86<br />

Alej<strong>and</strong>ro Santo Domingo<br />

Mary <strong>and</strong> David M. Solomon<br />

Joan E. Spero, MIA ’68<br />

The Starr Foundation<br />

Mana Nabeshima Tokoi, MIA ’91<br />

Michael D. Tusiani/Poten & Partners, Inc.<br />

Jens Ulltveit-Moe, MIA ’68<br />

$5,000–$9,999<br />

Magzhan Muratovich Auezov, MIA ’98<br />

James L. Broadhead, IF ’63<br />

Pamela Casaudoumecq, MIA ’89<br />

Robert Meade Chilstrom, MIA ’69, CERT<br />

’69 <strong>and</strong> Buena H. Chilstrom<br />

Susie Gharib, MIA ’74/Nazem Family<br />

Foundation<br />

George Franz Hollendorfer, MIA ’01<br />

Alex <strong>and</strong> Juliana Krys<br />

Vuslat Sabanci, MIA ’96 <strong>and</strong> Ali Ismail<br />

Sabanci<br />

Arnold A. Saltzman/Saltzman Foundation<br />

Brent Scowcr<strong>of</strong>t<br />

David Zvi Solomon, MIA ’97/Achim<br />

Foundation<br />

Joel D. Tauber<br />

Paul Wayne Thurman<br />

Neale X. Trangucci, MIA ’81, IF ’81<br />

Enzo Viscusi<br />

$2,500–$4,999<br />

Norton <strong>and</strong> Ann Bell<br />

Laurence Dara Berger, IF ’70<br />

John William Dickey, MIA ’92<br />

Mary S. Ginsberg, MIA ’78, IF ’78<br />

Marietta Angela Ries Lavicka, MIA ’94<br />

Claudette M. Mayer, MIA ’76, IF ’76<br />

Media Rights Capital/Modi Wiczyk <strong>and</strong><br />

Assaf Satchu<br />

Mitchell Darrow Silber, MIA ’05 <strong>and</strong> Beth<br />

Ann Silber<br />

Frank C. Wong, MIA ’82<br />

Feng Jason Xu, MIA ’96<br />

$1,000–$2,499<br />

Anonymous<br />

Robert Oswald Abad, MIA ’98<br />

Lisa S. Anderson, CERT ’76<br />

Halle J. Bennett, MIA ’92<br />

Michael Paul Benz, MPA ’10<br />

Robin L. Berry, MIA ’78<br />

Blinken Foundation/Donald <strong>and</strong> Vera<br />

Blinken<br />

Elizabeth Cabot, MIA ’98 <strong>and</strong> Blake<br />

Cabot<br />

Linda K. Carlisle, MPA ’81<br />

John <strong>and</strong> Patricia Coatsworth<br />

Larry Rodney Colburn, MIA ’90<br />

Jane D. Coleman, IF ’72<br />

Anisa Kamadoli Costa, MIA ’98/Tiffany<br />

& Co.<br />

John J. Curley, IF ’63 <strong>and</strong> Ann C. Curley<br />

Gregory R. Dalton MIA ’94, IF ’94<br />

<strong>and</strong> Lucia Choi/The Dalton-Choi<br />

Family Trust<br />

John William D<strong>and</strong>ola, MPA ’10<br />

Xinhua Dang, MIA ’93<br />

Nina <strong>and</strong> Mitch Davidson<br />

Barbara Knowles Debs <strong>and</strong> Richard A.<br />

Debs/The Debs Foundation<br />

Gregory Deeds <strong>and</strong> Lisa Helen Deeds<br />

Christian Deseglise, MIA ’90<br />

Troy J. Eggers <strong>and</strong> Susan K. Glancy<br />

Peter D. Ehrenhaft, MIA ’57<br />

Habib Mohammed Enayetullah, MPA ’91<br />

Kashiyo C. Enokido, MIA ’78<br />

Ivy Lindstrom Fredericks, MIA ’98<br />

Jennifer Ann Pomeroy Fronk, MIA ’83/<br />

Fronk Family Foundation<br />

Shelley Louise Gardeniers, MIA ’96<br />

Richard N. Gardner<br />

Michael Alan Goldstein, MIA ’84<br />

Anthony C. Gooch, MIA ’05, IF ’05<br />

Erin S. Gore, MPA ’97<br />

Alex<strong>and</strong>er Juri Groushevsky, MIA ’96,<br />

IF ’96<br />

Neal H. Harwood, MIA ’61<br />

Andrew <strong>and</strong> Heather Heller<br />

Ralph O. Hellmold, MIA ’63, IF ’63<br />

Sylvia A. Hewlett <strong>and</strong> Richard S. Weinert/<br />

Center For Work-Life Policy, Inc.<br />

Peter Alex<strong>and</strong>er H<strong>of</strong>mann, MIA ’86/<br />

United Way <strong>of</strong> Central <strong>and</strong> NE<br />

Connecticut<br />

John Christopher Howe, MIA ’83/The<br />

Patriot Group<br />

Jingdong Hua, MPA ’03<br />

Constance L. Hunter, MIA ’94<br />

Douglas R. Hunter, MIA ’73<br />

Nadia M. Jabri, MIA ’98<br />

Herman N. Johnson, MIA ’99 <strong>and</strong><br />

Tamarra Matthews-Johnson<br />

Hisanori Kataoka, MIA ’98<br />

Allison C. Kellogg, IF ’72, MIA ’73<br />

Melvyn N. Klein, IF ’65<br />

Karen Young Knapp, MPA ’94<br />

Arthur Wayne Koenig, MIA ’70<br />

The Kresge Foundation<br />

Monish Kumar, MIA ’95<br />

Ziad Khalil Makkawi, MIA ’86<br />

Arfan M. K. Malas, MIA ’68/Dextar<br />

World Trade<br />

Christopher James Manogue, MIA ’98<br />

Sherwood G. Moe, MIA ’48<br />

Melineh V. Momjian, MIA ’86 <strong>and</strong> Mark<br />

Albert Momjian<br />

Thomas John Monahan, MIA ’85<br />

James William Morley<br />

Mark David O’Keefe, MIA ’95 <strong>and</strong> M.<br />

Guadalupe Gr<strong>and</strong>a, MIA ’95<br />

Kenneth Prewitt<br />

Adam <strong>and</strong> M<strong>and</strong>y Quinton<br />

Clyde E. Rankin, IF ’74<br />

Peter M. Robinson, MIA ’79, IF ’79<br />

Karen Scowcr<strong>of</strong>t, MIA ’84, IF ’84<br />

Saurin Dinesh Shah, MIA ’97 <strong>and</strong> Sara<br />

Elise Borden, MPA ’95<br />

S<strong>and</strong>ra Shahinian Leitner, MIA ’76<br />

Cass<strong>and</strong>ra A. Simmons<br />

Jonathan P. Simon <strong>and</strong> Anna C.<br />

Coatsworth<br />

Julie Lynn Siskind, MIA ’95/Jewish<br />

Communal Fund<br />

Alfred C. Stepan, IF ’65<br />

Bela Szigethy, MIA ’80, IF ’80<br />

Masanobu Taniguchi, MIA ’79, CERT ’79<br />

David James Tsui, MPA ’01<br />

Daniel B. Tunstall, MIA ’68<br />

Yuko Usami, MIA ’77<br />

Eliza <strong>and</strong> Jon Weber<br />

Allyson <strong>and</strong> Andrew Weiner<br />

Arthur M. Yoshinami, MIA ’80<br />

Ge<strong>of</strong>frey Paul Ziebart, MIA ’89, IF ’89<br />

$500–$999<br />

Colin Jeffrey Aaron, MIA ’84<br />

Patrick Kenehan Archambault, MIA ’99<br />

John Keeble Bainbridge, MPA ’91<br />

Arlene Renee Barilec, MIA ’84<br />

Jillian Barron, MIA ’88<br />

Matthias Georg Baumberger, MIA ’05<br />

Stefan Robert Benn, MIA ’95<br />

Maureen R. Berman, MIA ’73<br />

Thomas Lynch Bindley, MPA ’03<br />

Kate A. Bullinger, MIA ’94<br />

Paul H. Byers, IF ’67<br />

David C. Chaffetz, MIA ’80, IF ’80<br />

Yung-Woo Chun, MIA ’94, IF ’94<br />

John J. Costonis, IF ’64<br />

Marc P. Desautels, MIA ’66<br />

R. Anthony Elson, MIA ’64, IF ’64<br />

SIPA NEWS 39


Donor List SIPA<br />

Jennifer Ann Enslin, MIA ’02<br />

Rhonda L. Ferguson-Augustus, MIA ’79<br />

Robert Mark Finkel, MIA ’88<br />

Walter F. Frey, MPA ’08<br />

Kirsten Alysum Frivold, MPA ’03<br />

Larry S. Gage, IF ’71<br />

Sol Glasner, MIA ’76, CERT ’76<br />

John D. Greenwald, IF ’71<br />

Bruce Kirkwood Harris, MIA ’92<br />

Peter D. Hart Research Associates, Inc.<br />

Teresa Misty Hathaway, MIA ’89<br />

Mark M. Jaskowiak, IF ’77<br />

Horace P. Jen, MIA ’93, CERT ’93<br />

<strong>and</strong> Karuna Evelyne Shinsho,<br />

MIA ’94<br />

Andrea Lynn Johnson, MIA ’89<br />

Michone Trinae Johnson, MPA ’96<br />

Caroline C. Kay<br />

John J. Kerr, IF ’76<br />

Do-Hyung Kim, MIA ’00<br />

Joachim W. Kratz, MIA ’58<br />

Stephanie Beth Wolk Lawrence, MPA ’93/<br />

Boston Foundation<br />

George M. Lazarus, IF ’69<br />

Ryan S. Lester, MIA ’01 <strong>and</strong> Amy Lester<br />

Jirawat Sophon Lewprasert, MIA ’84<br />

John F. Lippmann, MIA ’49<br />

Dallas D. Lloyd, MIA ’58<br />

Eric Rogan Mason, MIA ’95<br />

Dan McIntyre<br />

Sreedhar Menon<br />

Amy L. Miller, MIA ’82<br />

David W. Miller<br />

Shalini Mimani<br />

Morgan Stanley Smith Barney Global<br />

Impact<br />

Catherine Mulder, MIA ’81<br />

Hiroko Murase, MIA ’91<br />

Ana Carolina Cabral Murphy, MIA ’09<br />

Stephanie G. Neuman/I. & B. Neuman<br />

Foundation<br />

Yigit Onat, MIA ’10 <strong>and</strong> Hahna Kim<br />

Evan Hartley Platt/Hartley Corporation<br />

Henrietta B. Pons, MIA ’64/Henrietta B.<br />

Pons Trust<br />

Clara Katingo Quintanilla, MIA ’82<br />

Ailsa Roell <strong>and</strong> Patrick Bolton<br />

Daniel Rose <strong>and</strong> Joanna S. Rose<br />

Osman Shahenshah, MIA ’97<br />

Aaron Venn Singer, MPA ’04<br />

Vikram Jeet Singh, MIA ’03, IF ’03 <strong>and</strong><br />

Dilshika Jayamaha<br />

Tara Jayne Sullivan, MPA ’86<br />

Sharyn Menegus Taylor, MIA ’85<br />

Maxwell Konrad Trautman, MIA ’92<br />

$250–$499<br />

Kaori Adachi, MIA ’99<br />

Simon K. Adamiyatt, MIA ’81, CERT ’81<br />

Kiyoshi Amada, MIA ’94<br />

Sanford Antignas<br />

Morten Arntzen, MIA ’79, IF ’79<br />

Isabelle Jacqueline Aussourd, MIA ’02<br />

Roshma A. Azeem, MPA ’04<br />

Leonard J. Baldyga, MIA ’62<br />

David A. Balzarini, IF ’62<br />

Rukiye Zeynep Basak, MPA ’05<br />

Paul Bauer, MIA ’96<br />

Robin M. Beckett, IF ’77<br />

Pieter Anton Bierkens, MIA ’92<br />

Melanie June Bixby, MIA ’91 <strong>and</strong> Robert<br />

Epstein<br />

Kenneth Herbert Blackman, MIA ’00<br />

Joseph Abraham Blady, MIA ’03<br />

Thomas H. Boast, MIA ’72<br />

John Alex<strong>and</strong>er Bodkin <strong>and</strong> Dinah K.<br />

Bodkin<br />

Patrick Francis Bohan<br />

Carolyn B. Boldiston, MPA ’89<br />

Georgy Georgovich Bovt, MIA ’92, IF ’92<br />

Joan Copithorne Bowen, MIA ’67<br />

Dwight A. Bowler, MIA ’79<br />

Scott Budde, MIA ’83<br />

Allen L. Byrum, MIA ’72<br />

Robert Christopher Callahan, MIA ’05<br />

Joan O. Camins, IF ’73<br />

Mary W. Carpenter, MIA ’51<br />

Elisa A. Charters, MIA ’02<br />

Kai J. Chin, MIA ’78<br />

Dale Christensen, MIA ’71 <strong>and</strong> Patricia<br />

Hewitt, MIA ’71<br />

Dale S. Collinson, IF ’62<br />

James Anthony Coppola, MIA ’87<br />

Karen J. Curtin, MIA ’78, IF ’78<br />

Carolyn P. Dewing-Hommes, MIA ’86,<br />

CERT ’86<br />

Richard Albert Dikeman, MPA ’99<br />

Andrew M. Dry, MIA ’80, IF ’80<br />

Judith Ann Edstrom, MIA ’72, IF ’72<br />

Allen Eisendrath, MIA ’81, IF ’81<br />

Mayada El-Zoghbi, MIA ’94, CERT ’94<br />

Cornelia Mai Ercklentz, MIA ’08<br />

Vincent A. Ferraro, MIA ’73, IF ’73 <strong>and</strong><br />

Priscilla A. M<strong>and</strong>rachia<br />

Louise R. Firestone, MIA ’79<br />

Susan H. Frieden<br />

Sridhar Ganesan, MIA ’96<br />

Hui Gao, MPA ’01<br />

John C. Garrett, IF ’66/Garrett Family<br />

Foundation<br />

Jeffrey Franklin Gay, MIA ’04<br />

Victor Gotbaum, MIA ’50<br />

Manuel G. Grace, IF ’82<br />

Carl C. Greer, IF ’63<br />

Maureen-Elizabeth Hagen, MIA ’83,<br />

CERT ’83<br />

Kay L. Hancock<br />

Peter L. Harnik, MIA ’75<br />

Gordana D. Harris, MIA ’84<br />

Ian Andrew Held, MIA ’95, IF ’95<br />

Warren E. Hewitt, MIA ’50<br />

Christopher John Hirth, MIA ’96<br />

Katherine Hale Hovde, MIA ’89 <strong>and</strong><br />

Kenneth Kulak<br />

Thomas W. Hoya, CERT ’69<br />

Christopher Ko Hu, IF ’73<br />

Yutaka Matsuura Ishizaka, CERT ’82<br />

Merit Janow<br />

Edward Van K. Jaycox, MIA ’64,<br />

CERT ’64<br />

Mary Tyler Johnson, MPA ’04/Ayco<br />

Charitable Foundation<br />

Stuart MacLean Johnson, MIA ’67<br />

Richard B. Jones, MIA ’80<br />

Nadine F. Joseph, MIA ’73<br />

Robert K. Kaplan, MIA ’83<br />

Norman D. Kass, MIA ’73 <strong>and</strong> Lani Kass<br />

Brian John Kennedy, MPA ’04<br />

Julia Metzger Kennedy, MIA ’92<br />

Lawrence S. Klitzman<br />

Susan Koch, MIA ’71<br />

Lisa Esposito Kok, MPA ’90 <strong>and</strong> George<br />

Hans Kok<br />

Mel Laytner, MIA ’72<br />

Musse Hussen Ld, MPA ’95<br />

Hyun-Koo Lee, MIA ’81<br />

Andre D. Lehmann, MIA ’73, CERT ’73<br />

Jay A. Levy, IF ’62<br />

David Chase Lopes, MIA ’92<br />

Jerrold L. Mallory, MIA ’83, CERT ’83<br />

Sonia P. Maltezou, MIA ’70<br />

Sean Rosen M<strong>and</strong>el, MPA ’07 <strong>and</strong><br />

Marian Rosen<br />

Ann E. March, MIA ’99<br />

Ludwig J. Marek, MPA ’07<br />

Jocelyn Maskow, MPA ’88<br />

John B. McGrath, MIA ’80, IF ’80,<br />

CERT ’80<br />

Milton W. Meyer, MIA ’49<br />

Marianne Mitosinka, MIA ’81<br />

Tracey Ellen Morzano, MIA ’94<br />

Yaya Moussa, MPA ’98<br />

David W. Munves, MIA ’80, IF ’80<br />

Stephen S. Nelmes, MIA ’73<br />

Carletta Nonziato, MIA ’84/<br />

Carron, LLC<br />

Dmitry Nikitin, MIA ’05<br />

Mary Agnes O’Donnell Hulme, MIA ’95<br />

Avo Erik Ora, MIA ’98, IF ’98<br />

Ruth G. Ornelas, MIA ’80, IF ’80<br />

Jennifer Hirsh Overton, MPA ’93<br />

Kush B. Patel, MIA ’05<br />

Nirmala S. Patni, MPA ’01<br />

Carol Jean Patterson, MIA ’76, CERT ’76<br />

Jon S. Pearl <strong>and</strong> Barbara S. Pearl<br />

Tas Ling Pinther, MIA ’94<br />

Thomas Guenter Plagemann, MIA ’91<br />

Peter J. Podbielski, MIA ’74<br />

Jefrey Ian Pollock, MPA ’97<br />

Robert W. Pons, MIA ’64<br />

David C. Ralph, MIA ’67<br />

Julie Ramirez, MIA ’94<br />

John M. Reid, MIA ’64<br />

Robert D. Reischauer, MIA ’66<br />

Jeremy Neal Reiskin, MIA ’87<br />

Lucius J. Riccio<br />

William James Rigler, MIA ’03, IF ’03<br />

Robert M. Rodes<br />

William A. Root, MIA ’48, CERT ’48<br />

Smedes Rose, MIA ’94<br />

Marian Rosen<br />

Anne O’Toole Salinas, MIA ’96, CERT ’96<br />

Joseph Andrew Samborsky, MPA ’04<br />

Salvatore V. Sampino, MIA ’83<br />

Julie Elizabeth Satow, MIA ’01<br />

Herbert A. Schectman, MIA ’58<br />

Deborah Gwen Schein, MIA ’88,<br />

CERT ’88<br />

Susan Ellen Schorr, MPA ’98/MGS & RRS<br />

Charitable Trust<br />

Ernst J. Schrader, MIA ’65<br />

William Schumer, CERT ’48<br />

Harold <strong>and</strong> Jeannette Segel<br />

Ryan James Severino, MIA ’04<br />

Richard M. Smith, IF ’69<br />

Delia B. Spitzer, IF ’81<br />

Marisa C. Stadtmauer, MPA ’93/Marisa<br />

<strong>and</strong> Richard Stadtmauer Family<br />

Foundation<br />

Sally J. Staley, MIA ’80<br />

Kulratan R. Stuart, MIA ’73<br />

Leonard M. Tavera<br />

Erik Matthew Tollefson, MIA ’06<br />

Elizabeth D. Trafelet, MIA ’03<br />

Jonathan Tretler<br />

Alper A. Tunca, MPA ’05<br />

Sharmila Hainum Tuttle, MIA ’05<br />

Ralph W. Usinger, MIA ’73<br />

Frederi Joseph Vagnini, MIA ’89<br />

Joseph L. Vidich, MIA ’80<br />

Gregory Alex<strong>and</strong>er Viscusi, MIA ’91,<br />

IF ’91<br />

Hans Herbert Wahl, MIA ’95<br />

Efrot Weiss, IF ’89, MIA, ’89<br />

Helgard Wienert-Cakim, MIA ’62<br />

Frank G. Wisner<br />

Anna Wojnarowska, MPA ’04<br />

Silas H. L. Wu<br />

Juliet Wurr, MIA ’89, IF ’89<br />

Hideo Yanai, MIA ’96<br />

Nan Yang, MIA ’95<br />

Zhijing Yin, MPA ’03<br />

Catherine L. Yu-Mark<br />

Up to $249<br />

Anonymous<br />

Ninfa A. Abad, MPA ’07<br />

Am<strong>and</strong>a Adames Marmolejos<br />

Can Adamoglu, MIA ’02<br />

Carl B. Adams, MIA ’72<br />

William J. Adler, MIA ’80<br />

Afua P. Adusei<br />

Alice Agoos, MIA ’80<br />

Laura Maria Agosta<br />

Christiana H. Aguiar, MIA ’89<br />

Fareez Ahmed, MIA ’09<br />

Lincoln N. Ajoku, MIA ’08<br />

Adam J. Albin, MIA ’86<br />

Delalle Nasr Strateman Alex<strong>and</strong>er,<br />

MIA ’85<br />

Don William Alex<strong>and</strong>er, MPA ’05<br />

Jordan Alex<strong>and</strong>er<br />

Karen Jeannette Alex<strong>and</strong>er, MPA ’90<br />

Keely Dean Alex<strong>and</strong>er<br />

Paula Alfonso, MIA ’11<br />

Patrice L. Allen-Gifford, MIA ’81<br />

Erasto B. Almeida, MIA ’06<br />

Douglas Vincent Almond<br />

Robert J. Alpino, MIA ’85<br />

Stephen Altheim, IF ’69<br />

Nourah Ali AITwairqi<br />

Luis Alvarez Renta, MPA ’09<br />

Daniel Alvarez, MPA ’09<br />

Elena M. Alvarez, MPA ’84<br />

Kenneth Alvord II<br />

Austin Chinegwu Amalu, MIA ’81<br />

Ryan M. Ames, MPA ’09<br />

Yotam David Amit<br />

40 SIPA NEWS


Donor List SIPA<br />

Gauri An<strong>and</strong>, MPA ’11<br />

Bridget Anderson, MPA ’04<br />

G. Norman Anderson, MIA ’60<br />

John C. Angle, IF ’69<br />

Shehriyar D. Antia, MIA ’03<br />

Iris R. Argento, CERT ’67<br />

Nikolaos Argeros, MPA ’10<br />

Sunil Arora<br />

Emily Talbot Ashton, MPA ’04<br />

Sarah S. Ashton, MIA ’93<br />

Elizabeth Athey, MIA ’71<br />

Karen Nicole Attiah<br />

Dooneshsingh Audit, MPA ’09<br />

Ana Elena Azpurua, MIA ’09<br />

Sally Baek, MPA ’85<br />

Sungwon Baik, MIA ’02<br />

Charles Edward Baker, MIA ’92<br />

Laura Shannon Ballman, MIA ’00, IF ’00<br />

Moran Banai, MIA ’06<br />

Saptarsi B<strong>and</strong>yopadhyay, MIA ’11<br />

Zdzislaw Baran<br />

Aimee Elise Keli’i Barnes, MPA ’07<br />

Wayne M. Barnstone, MIA ’79<br />

Nicole Ann Barrett, MIA ’95, CERT ’95<br />

Matthew David Barron, MPA ’10<br />

Chhitij Bashyal<br />

Justina Baskauskas, MIA ’94, IF ’94<br />

Elizabeth A. Bassan, MIA ’79, IF ’79<br />

Kevin Alan Baumert, MIA ’98<br />

Alicia Jewel Beal<br />

Kenton H. Beerman, MIA ’05<br />

Julie A. Beglin, MPA ’97<br />

Michael Arm<strong>and</strong> Beirnard<br />

W<strong>and</strong>a J. Bell, MPA ’08<br />

Scot H. Bellows, MIA ’79<br />

Nancy Hays Bendiner, IF ’72<br />

Yvette E. Benedek, MIA ’81<br />

Tudor Vlad Benga<br />

Juan Manuel Benitez-Fernel, MIA ’01<br />

Sonja Jean Bensen, MIA ’89<br />

Paul D. Berk, IF ’62<br />

Stephen Michael Berk, CERT ’72<br />

Thomas Paul Bernstein, CERT ’66<br />

Genevieve R. Besser, MIA ’86<br />

Wendy Lee Kutlow Best, MPA ’87<br />

Dorcas Jeanine Bethel, MPA ’95<br />

Richard K. Betts<br />

Peter James Biesada, MIA ’86<br />

Charles G. Billo, MIA ’67<br />

William N. Binderman, IF ’63<br />

Leopold Von Bismarck, MIA ’78<br />

Alex<strong>and</strong>ra Bokan Blair<br />

Whitney Beth Blake, MPA ’07<br />

John Langdon Blakeney, MPA ’06<br />

Lisa Zucrow Block, MPA ’81<br />

Tammy Sue Blossom, MPA ’96<br />

Alisa Blum, MPA ’00<br />

Christopher Joseph Bodington, MIA ’11<br />

Michael Drury Bodman, MIA ’96<br />

Holly Bernson Bogin, MIA ’88<br />

Andrea R. Bonime-Blanc, IF ’81,<br />

CERT ’81<br />

Robert Boothby, IF ’62<br />

Sebastian Borchmeyer<br />

Trudy E. Bower-Pirinis, MIA ’78<br />

W. Donald Bowles, CERT ’52<br />

David Daniel Boyle, MPA ’98<br />

Deirdre Grane Brennan, MIA ’01, IF ’01<br />

<strong>and</strong> Christian Grane, MIA ’01<br />

Philip Stern Brennan, MIA ’06<br />

Gretchen Stahr Breunig, MPA ’88<br />

Karl Wilhelm Brown, MIA ’06<br />

Keith Dawayne Brown, MIA ’89<br />

Keith Mac Brown, MPA ’90 <strong>and</strong> Jennifer<br />

Lyle Green, MPA ’90<br />

William C. Brown, IF ’67<br />

Michelle Nichole Browne, MPA ’92<br />

John P. Bruggen, MPA ’00<br />

Jennifer Tara Bruno<br />

Cecile R. Brunswick, MIA ’54<br />

William Ransom Bryant<br />

Laurance Nicholas Buencamino<br />

Beverley Jeanine Buford, MPA ’86<br />

Andrew Craig Buher, MPA ’10<br />

Sonia Virginie Bujas, MIA ’92, CERT ’92<br />

<strong>and</strong> Nuno Miguel C. Crisostomo,<br />

MIA ’01<br />

Leonardo Bullaro, MPA ’08<br />

Gordon Marshall Burck, MIA ’86<br />

Sarah Burd-Sharps, MIA ’87<br />

Robert K. Burghart, CERT ’79<br />

Kevin James Burgwinkle, MIA ’06, IF ’06<br />

Janet A. Burroughs, MIA ’89<br />

Marta Eugenia Cabrera, MIA ’85,<br />

CERT ’85<br />

Pierre J. Cachia<br />

Fabrizio Cadamagnani, MPA ’11<br />

Gerald A. Cady, MIA ’76, CERT ’76<br />

Kristen Klemme Cady-Sawyer, MPA ’06<br />

Michael A. Cairl, MIA ’77, IF ’77<br />

Marjorie E. Campbell<br />

Robin C. Campbell, IF ’76<br />

Jeffrey L. Canfield, MIA ’82, CERT ’82<br />

Forrest Andrew Carhartt<br />

Donald L. Carpenter, CERT ’54<br />

Nontrel Kesha Carwell, MPA ’05<br />

Elizabeth Hopkins Cashen, MIA ’01 <strong>and</strong><br />

David V. Cashen<br />

Valenice Castronovo, MIA ’80<br />

Barbara Foulke Cates, MIA ’84<br />

Mary Kathleen Catlin, MIA ’94<br />

David Michael Caughlin, MPA ’07<br />

John Joseph Cenney, MIA ’92<br />

Elizabeth Ellen Champlin Geske, MIA ’87<br />

Barbara Chan<br />

Ann H. Chaney, MIA ’91<br />

Martin A. Charwat, CERT ’65<br />

Jason Kinbon Chau, MIA ’08<br />

Swati Kumari Chaudhary<br />

Amy Li Chen<br />

Shiliang Thomas Chen<br />

Winifred Debbie Chen, MPA ’07<br />

Peter Chin, MIA ’11<br />

Muzaffar A. Chishti, MIA ’81<br />

Shachi Chopra-Nangia, MIA ’00<br />

Paul Brian Christensen, MIA ’83<br />

Ingrid D. Christophel, MIA ’83<br />

Siew Leng Chuah, MIA ’84<br />

S<strong>and</strong>ra G. Chutorian, MIA ’82, CERT ’82<br />

Jeff Geefen Chyu, MIA ’83<br />

William Ciaccio, MPA ’79<br />

Am<strong>and</strong>a Hoagl<strong>and</strong> Clark, CERT ’82<br />

Azeb G. Clark, MIA ’96<br />

Peter James Clayton, MPA ’90<br />

Matt K. Clemons<br />

Jayana J. Clerk, CERT ’77<br />

Drew Dumas Coburn, MIA ’87<br />

Natalie Greenan Coburn, MIA ’89<br />

Laurie L. N. Cochran, MIA ’79<br />

Ann-Marie C<strong>of</strong>ield, MPA ’10<br />

Daniel Moshe Cohen, MIA ’04<br />

Denise Ann Cohen, MIA ’93, CERT ’93<br />

Dillon Lockwood Cohen, MIA ’09<br />

Ellen Miriam Cohen, MPA ’03<br />

F. Bruce Cohen, MPA ’91<br />

Graham Charles Cohen, MIA ’91<br />

Neil Hayward Cohen, MPA ’89<br />

Daniela Coleman<br />

Jennifer DeRosa Collins, MPA ’05<br />

Joseph J. Collins, MIA ’80, IF ’80 <strong>and</strong><br />

Anita L. Collins<br />

Glenn L. Colville, MIA ’75<br />

Bernard Francis Condon, MIA ’91,<br />

CERT ’91 <strong>and</strong> Patricia Anne Clary,<br />

MIA ’91<br />

Susan E. Condon, MIA ’70, IF ’70,<br />

CERT ’70<br />

Marybeth Connolly, MIA ’01<br />

Maureen Considine, MIA ’86<br />

Richard Cooper, IF ’85<br />

Mary Griffiths Cooperman, MIA ’84<br />

Anthony R. Corea, MIA ’79<br />

Jeronimo Cortina, MPA ’03<br />

Richard W. Cortright, MIA ’82<br />

Steven Roy Costner, MIA ’88<br />

Jeffrey Larter Cox, MIA ’89<br />

Monica Inez Cramer, MIA ’92<br />

Helen Cregger, MPA ’92<br />

Robert S. Critchell, MIA ’70<br />

Burton C. Crow, IF ’77<br />

Matthew Russell Cruse<br />

Alvin Robert Cruz, MPA ’87<br />

Bernadette Cruz, MIA ’08<br />

Mercedes Cubas, MIA ’81<br />

Nikken Cullman, MIA ’09<br />

Victoria R. Cunningham, MIA ’75<br />

Donald J. Curry<br />

V<strong>and</strong>a Czifra, MIA ’11<br />

Aless<strong>and</strong>ra Mendes Da Silva, MIA ’89<br />

Theodore Albert D’Afflisio, MIA ’71<br />

Kevin Towne D’Albert, MIA ’90 <strong>and</strong><br />

Nancy Carney, MIA ’93<br />

Dolores J. Daly, MPA ’95<br />

Karl I. Danga, MIA ’72, IF ’71<br />

Gina Maria Dario, MIA ’00<br />

Sara Gabriela David<br />

Joel Davidow, IF ’63<br />

Adrienne D. Davis<br />

Edward N. De Lia, MIA ’87<br />

Dorothy T. de Vogel, CERT ’55<br />

Toni Elizabeth Dechario, MIA ’07<br />

Anthony Deck<strong>of</strong>f, MIA ’07<br />

Carol M. Degener, MIA ’84<br />

Katarina Deletis, MIA ’00<br />

Frank Anthony Dell’Aquila, MPA ’07<br />

Diane Leslie Demmler, MIA ’87<br />

Sonali S. Desai, MIA ’00<br />

Elinor M. Despalatovic, CERT ’59<br />

Amy K. Devaney<br />

Gary Francis Di Gesu, MIA ’89<br />

Philip E. Di Giovanni<br />

Raphael A. Diaz, MIA ’63<br />

Daniel <strong>and</strong> Belle Dicker<br />

Jessica Ephra Dickler, MPA ’04<br />

Maria Christina Dikeos, MIA ’92<br />

Alok Disa<br />

Stephen D. Docter, MIA ’60<br />

Hidayet Dogan, MIA ’82<br />

Kerry Anne Dolan, MIA ’92<br />

Lucia Adele Domville, MIA ’96<br />

Melissa Sawin Donohue, MIA ’93<br />

Christianna Casey Dove, MIA ’06<br />

Sharla Kathryn Draemel, MPA ’01<br />

Bogdan Cornel Dragulescu, MPA ’03<br />

Ruth I. Dreessen, MIA ’80<br />

Bruce H. Drossman, MIA ’82, IF ’82,<br />

CERT ’82<br />

Jennifer Bee Dudley, MPA ’04<br />

Grant M. Duers, MPA ’07<br />

Christopher William Dula<br />

Leo J. Dulacki<br />

Matthew W. Dundrea, IF ’77<br />

Cecilia Elizabeth Dunn, MPA ’93<br />

Edward K. Dzielenski<br />

E. Michael Easterly, MIA ’68<br />

Joanne Edgar, MIA ’68<br />

Wakana Nakagami Edmister, MPA ’02<br />

John Ehrman, MIA ’83<br />

William B. Eimich<br />

Isaac Manfred Elfstrom, MIA ’07<br />

Francis Granville Eliot, MIA ’11<br />

Susanne Noelle Elizer, MPA ’96<br />

Betsy Rossen Elliot, MIA ’84, IF ’84<br />

Sari J. Ellovich, MIA ’75<br />

Chase Edward Emmerson<br />

Rida Eng, MIA ’00<br />

Gordon Epstein, MIA ’75, IF ’75,<br />

CERT ’75<br />

Dara Erck, MIA ’03<br />

Amelia A. Erwitt, MPA ’06<br />

Franklin Etchu Egbe, MPA ’11<br />

Travis F. Evans<br />

James David Fahn, MIA ’02<br />

Peter Seth Falcier, MIA ’07<br />

Joshua Chaplin Farley, MIA ’90, CERT ’90<br />

Susan Silver Farley, MIA ’78<br />

Robert S. Faron, IF ’75<br />

Maheen Saleem Farooqi, MIA ’11<br />

Judy Anne Farrell, MPA ’96<br />

Antoine Faye<br />

Brent Feigenbaum, MIA ’84<br />

Aurelius Fern<strong>and</strong>ez, MIA ’59<br />

Alex<strong>and</strong>er Patrick Conrad Fern<strong>and</strong>o,<br />

MIA ’05<br />

Nancy A. Ferrante, MIA ’09<br />

Craig James Ferrantino, MIA ’92<br />

Diane P. Fink, MIA ’79<br />

Roger Ransdell Fisk, MPA ’04<br />

Kristin Raphaele Willey Fitzgerald,<br />

MIA ’94<br />

Howard Barrett Fl<strong>and</strong>ers, IF ’62<br />

H. Joseph Flatau, MIA ’61<br />

Kathryn Anne Fleury, MIA ’93<br />

Bradley Feeney Foerster, MIA ’88,<br />

CERT ’88<br />

James Fonda, MPA ’07<br />

David Stewart Fondiller, MIA ’92<br />

Anne D. Ford, MIA ’05<br />

SIPA NEWS 41


Donor List SIPA<br />

Laura Ellen Forlano, MIA ’01<br />

Edin Forto, MIA ’01, CERT ’01<br />

Laura Herbert Foster, MPA ’10<br />

Richard W. Foster, MIA ’69<br />

William S. Foster, MIA ’06<br />

Catherine Starin Foster-Anderson,<br />

MPA ’04<br />

Donald T. Fox<br />

Jackie Frankel, MPA ’09<br />

Hugh Corning Fraser, MPA ’95/<br />

Community Foundation <strong>of</strong> Greater<br />

Memphis<br />

Alex<strong>and</strong>er Mols Fraser, MPA ’90<br />

Gerald S. Freedman, IF ’62<br />

Amy Esther Friedman, MIA ’92<br />

Caroline Hearn Fuchs, MIA ’86<br />

Brian Barden Fuller, MPA ’11<br />

Robert John Gallagher, MIA ’90<br />

Alex<strong>and</strong>er Galsky, MIA ’10<br />

Matthew Phillip Gantz<br />

Karina Garcia-Casalderrey, MIA ’02<br />

Emma Gardner, MIA ’11<br />

John G. Garrard, CERT ’64<br />

Frances X. Gates<br />

Stephen Bernt Gaull, MIA ’88, CERT ’88<br />

Joseph G. Gavin, MIA ’70<br />

Benjamin D. Geber, MPA ’90<br />

Brian Houng Gee, MIA ’04<br />

Russell W. Geekie, MIA ’01<br />

Frank Hermannus Gerritzen, MIA ’94<br />

Daniel J. Gettings, MIA ’96<br />

Osama Gharizi, MIA ’11<br />

Elizabeth Schumann Ghauri, MIA ’94<br />

Christine Wrona Giallongo, MIA ’90,<br />

CERT ’90<br />

Susan C. Gigli, MIA ’87<br />

Diana Michele Glanternik, MPA ’05<br />

Vladimir Nicolas Glasinovic, MIA ’11<br />

Adam Spencer Glatzer, MPA ’07<br />

John J. Gmerek<br />

Eric Daniel Goldstein, MIA ’86<br />

Edward Daniel Gometz, MIA ’01<br />

Grace Ellen Goodell, MIA ’69<br />

Nicholas Nickfant Gouede, MIA ’86<br />

David E. Gould, IF ’94, MIA ’94<br />

Rodney E. Gould, IF ’68<br />

Allan I. Grafman, MIA ’77, IF ’77/<br />

Allmedia Ventures<br />

Ann Blumberg Graham, MIA ’81<br />

Francis Lincoln Grahlfs, CERT ’55<br />

John A. Grammer, MIA ’63<br />

Jennifer Youtz Grams, MPA ’99<br />

Carolyn B. Green, MIA ’63<br />

Karl Hans Greimel, MIA ’98<br />

Andrea Christine Griffin, MIA ’11<br />

Jill M. Grillo, MIA ’89<br />

Carole A. Grunberg, MIA ’78<br />

Guy B. Gugliotta, MIA ’73<br />

Sahil Gulati<br />

Jian Wei Guo, MPA ’04<br />

Sarita Gupta, MIA ’79, CERT ’79<br />

Daniel <strong>and</strong> Susan Gutterman<br />

Deena Jal Guzder, MIA ’08<br />

Jonathan Sullivan Gyurko, MPA ’00<br />

Viktoria Habanova, MIA ’08<br />

Michele Anke Haberl<strong>and</strong>, MPA ’04<br />

Amir Hadziomeragic, MIA ’01<br />

Brigid Flynn Haeckel, MPA ’90<br />

W. David Hager, IF ’66<br />

Robin Greene Hagey, MIA ’80<br />

Ayesha Haider-Marra, MIA ’04<br />

Mykola Haliv<br />

Scott Praeger Hall, MIA ’92<br />

Bonnie Sue Halpern, MIA ’72<br />

Joel Martin Halpern<br />

Shamsul Haque, MPA ’10<br />

Ayelet Klara Haran, MPA ’11<br />

Katherine Olivia Hardy, MIA ’97<br />

Velinda Tomelden Harjono, MIA ’97<br />

Vanessa H. Harper, MIA ’10<br />

Jonathan Harris, MIA ’59, CERT ’59<br />

Laura Suzanne Harwood, MPA ’92<br />

Md Mehdi Hassan, MIA ’00<br />

James G. Hatcher, IF ’62<br />

Gary Edward Hayes, MIA ’81, CERT ’81<br />

Maureen Hays-Mitchell, MIA ’83,<br />

CERT ’83<br />

Susan L. Hazard<br />

Lisa Ray Hecht-Cronstedt, MIA ’08<br />

Rex S. Heinke, IF ’74<br />

Elizabeth W. Heinsohn, MIA ’89<br />

Hertha W. Heiss, CERT ’51<br />

Gladys Heitin <strong>and</strong> Elliott Klitzman<br />

Joshua Rob Hepola, MIA ’00, IF ’00<br />

Alan J. Herbach, MIA ’79<br />

Richard Hermanowski<br />

Miguel Angel Hern<strong>and</strong>ez, MIA ’01<br />

Garry W. Hesser, IF ’64<br />

Andrew William Higgins, MIA ’91<br />

John F. Hildebr<strong>and</strong>, IF ’66<br />

Peter J. Hill, MPA ’11<br />

William E. Hiller, IF ’76<br />

Johanna Hjerthen, MIA ’98<br />

Nadia Man-Chuang Ho, MIA ’03<br />

Lyndell A. Hogan, MPA ’93<br />

Leif Holmberg, MIA ’08<br />

Michael A. Holubar, MIA ’77<br />

Nicole Janine Holzapfel, MIA ’94<br />

Lindsey Levit Honari, MIA ’97<br />

Joon Seok Hong, MIA ’05<br />

Janet Irene Horan, MPA ’05<br />

Pamela A. Houghtaling, MIA ’74,<br />

CERT ’74<br />

Gail Lewis Howard, MIA ’84<br />

William D. Howells, MIA ’60, CERT ’60<br />

John F. Howes, CERT ’54<br />

Kang Shih Huang, MIA ’74<br />

Christopher P. Hufstader, MIA ’96<br />

Richard W. Hull, CERT ’65<br />

Thomas N. Hull, MIA ’73, IF ’73,<br />

CERT ’73<br />

Joseph Kindall Hurd, MIA ’94, IF ’94<br />

Claire Estelle Marie Husson, MPA ’05<br />

Thomas J. Hyra, MIA ’76, IF ’76<br />

Francesco Rocco Iberg<br />

David Lee Ibsen<br />

Roberto Inda, MPA ’05<br />

Ehsan Isaac Iraniparast<br />

Helen Drew Isenberg, MIA ’54<br />

Ogniana Vassileva Ivanova, MIA ’02<br />

Thomas C. Izard<br />

Roy Christopher Jackson, MPA ’90<br />

Jennifer A. Jackson-Strage, MPA ’91<br />

Daniel N. Jacobs, CERT ’53<br />

Erik Jacobs, IF ’85, MIA ’85<br />

Eric Davis Jacobsen, MPA ’06<br />

Adam Jagelski, MIA ’95<br />

Wynne James, MIA ’71<br />

Rehan Rafay Jamil, MIA ’11<br />

Adrienne Mia Jarsvall, MPA ’11<br />

Christopher Silva Jenkins, MIA ’11<br />

Bradley Jennison<br />

Carlos Jerez-Bernal<br />

Mary Tyler Johnson, MPA ’04<br />

Richard J. Johnson, CERT ’65<br />

Sonia P. Johnson, MIA ’48<br />

Rashmi Elizabeth Jose<br />

John Charles Jove, MIA ’85<br />

Walter E. Judge, MIA ’85, IF ’85<br />

Peter H. Juviler, CERT ’54<br />

Velika Kabakchieva, MPA ’07<br />

Mark H. Kagan, MIA ’81, CERT ’81<br />

Stephanie Anne Kahn, MIA ’09<br />

Ann Dolan Kaiser, MIA ’80, IF ’80<br />

Kamil Kaluza, MPA ’06<br />

Nancy C. Kamen, MPA ’86<br />

Christopher Roger Kaminker, MIA ’09<br />

Amishi Ajay Kapadia, MIA ’02<br />

Elisa A. Kapell, MIA ’79, IF ’79, CERT ’79<br />

Alex M. Kaplan, MIA ’85<br />

Leonardo Karrer, MIA ’09 <strong>and</strong> Kristen<br />

Marie Cleven, MIA ’09<br />

Lloyd R. Kass, MPA ’98<br />

Richard G. Kass<br />

Lilian Kastner, MIA ’06<br />

Elizabeth Lynn Katkin, MIA ’92, IF ’92<br />

Peggy Ockkyung Kauh, MPA ’01<br />

Hir<strong>of</strong>umi Kawakita, MPA ’01<br />

Michael Barden Keegan, IF ’86<br />

Spurgeon M. Keeny<br />

Katherine B. Keller, MIA ’82<br />

Charles Robert Kelly, MIA ’83<br />

Donn M. Kessler<br />

Clarice J. Kestenbaum<br />

John F. Khanlian, MIA ’69<br />

Michele Llona Wray Khateri, MIA ’97<br />

Bahman Kia, CERT ’80<br />

Yoshiko Kido<br />

Mary C. King, MIA ’79<br />

Noelle King, IF ’84<br />

Brigitte Lehner Kingsbury, MIA ’89<br />

Gordon A. Kingsley, MIA ’81<br />

Molly Catherine Kinney, MIA ’93<br />

Nancy K. Kintner-Meyer, MIA ’89<br />

James Henry Kipers, MIA ’02<br />

Nina Kishore, MPA ’07<br />

Adam Ferrier Klauber, MPA ’04<br />

Jean L. Klein<br />

Bernard Klem, MIA ’63<br />

Anne R. Knulst, MIA ’51<br />

Murat Kocabas, MIA ’11<br />

Anjali Devi Kochar, MIA ’01<br />

Kari Odquist Kohl, MIA ’99<br />

Junji Koike, MPA ’11<br />

Annette Phyllis Kondo, IF ’86<br />

Paik Har Kong, MIA ’82<br />

S<strong>and</strong>ra Y. Koo, MIA ’90 <strong>and</strong><br />

Jonathan Shaw<br />

Victor Koshkin-Youritzin, IF ’65<br />

Stephanie Jane Kosmo, MIA ’84<br />

Tushar D. Kothari<br />

P. Nicholas Kourides, IF ’70<br />

Paul M. Kozar, MIA ’75<br />

Lomi Laura Kriel <strong>and</strong> Rachel Gabrielle<br />

Uranga<br />

Matt Kumparatana, MPA ’02<br />

Carlos Augusto Kuriyama, MIA ’05 <strong>and</strong><br />

Ann Mizumoto, MIA ’06<br />

Richard W. Kurz, MIA ’77<br />

Alina Kwak, MPA ’06<br />

Susanne Kyzivat, MIA ’84<br />

Elizabeth A. LaBarbera, MPA ’10<br />

Laurin L. Laderoute, IF ’66<br />

Polly Nora Lagana, MPA ’04<br />

Thomas M. Lahiff, MIA ’74<br />

Andres Lalinde<br />

James Lalremruata, MPA ’03<br />

Jose M. Lamas, MIA ’86<br />

Richard M. Lamport, MIA ’62<br />

Debbie A. L<strong>and</strong>res, MIA ’06<br />

Julie Werner Lane, MPA ’92<br />

Thomas Richard Lansner, MIA ’91<br />

Claudia Laviada, MIA ’00<br />

Eugene Kistler Lawson, CERT ’69<br />

Bozidar Lazarevic<br />

Lynn F. Lee, MIA ’57<br />

Grace Lee, MIA ’07<br />

Seung-Yeon Lee, MIA ’03<br />

Bogdan Theodore Leja, MIA ’91<br />

Philip J. Lemanski, MPA ’86<br />

Am<strong>and</strong>a V. Leness, MIA ’93<br />

Suzanna Lengyel<br />

S<strong>and</strong>ra M. Lennon, MIA ’95<br />

Oliver Andrew Lennox, MIA ’09<br />

Ignacio Leon Gil<br />

Lane Russell Leskela, MIA ’89<br />

Julia <strong>and</strong> Robert Lester<br />

Gina Patricia LeVeque, MIA ’07<br />

Sergio Levin, MIA ’79<br />

Joshua Gregory Levine, MIA ’99, IF ’99<br />

Noah M. Levine, MIA ’05<br />

Nadine Netter Levy, MIA ’70/Hess-Levy<br />

Family Foundation<br />

Deborah Jacobs Levy, MPA ’92<br />

James John Lewellis, MIA ’04<br />

David Yifong Li, MIA ’08<br />

Fiona Fangxin Li, MIA ’10<br />

Xuehui Li, MIA ’05<br />

Arthur Dominique Liacre, MIA ’04<br />

Amy Lile, MPA ’05<br />

Mony Liquard, MIA ’02<br />

Alex<strong>and</strong>re Brites Lira, MPA ’08<br />

John Joseph Lis, MIA ’96, IF ’96,<br />

CERT ’96<br />

Daniel Brown Little, MIA ’05<br />

Kai-Chun Liu, MPA ’82<br />

Victoria Liu, MIA ’75, CERT ’75<br />

Robert T. Livernash, MIA ’73, IF ’73<br />

Jennifer Catherine Livingstone, MIA ’11<br />

Emily Yottie Loebelson<br />

Ka Chun Georgina Lok, MPA ’06<br />

Jody Susan London, MPA ’90<br />

James Michael Lonergan, MPA ’92<br />

Austin Long<br />

William P. Looney<br />

Andrew David Lorber, MIA ’08<br />

William Anthony Lorenz, MIA ’99<br />

Ronald Dean Lorton, MIA ’71, IF ’71<br />

42 SIPA NEWS


Donor List SIPA<br />

Ping Fong Louie, MIA ’85<br />

Sarah Pressman Lovinger, MIA ’90<br />

Paik-Swan Low, MIA ’85 <strong>and</strong> Steven<br />

Arthur Hirsch, MPA ’85<br />

Erica Granetz Lowitz, MPA ’94<br />

Julia Y. Lu, MPA ’03<br />

William H. Luers<br />

Jessica Lustbader, MPA ’11<br />

Mark J. Lux, MIA ’79<br />

Yuwei Ma, MIA ’07<br />

Cynthia MacDonald, IF ’77<br />

Vernon L. Mack, MIA ’73<br />

Patricia M. Macken<br />

Alberta S. Magzanian, CERT ’56<br />

Harpreet Mahajan, CERT ’80<br />

Michael Thomas Maier, MIA ’08<br />

Kenneth F. Mailloux, CERT ’74<br />

Haim Malka, MIA ’01<br />

Roy Andrew Malmrose, MIA ’84<br />

Joel Nordin Maloney, MIA ’96<br />

Paulo Cesar de F. Mamede, MPA ’05<br />

Lawrence H. Mamiya, IF ’68<br />

Sarah Vanesa Manaker, MIA ’04, IF ’04<br />

Harriet Lee M<strong>and</strong>el, MIA ’85, CERT ’85<br />

Judyt L. M<strong>and</strong>el<br />

Justin M<strong>and</strong>el, MIA ’09<br />

Richard V. B. Manix, IF ’70<br />

Theodore E. Mankovich, IF ’71<br />

Roberta T. Manning<br />

Ida May H. Mantel, MIA ’64<br />

Robert B. Mantel, MIA ’63<br />

Thibaud Marcesse, MIA ’05<br />

Sarah Marchal Murray, MPA ’04<br />

Frank J. Marsella, MIA ’76<br />

Edward Adger Marshall, MIA ’03<br />

R<strong>and</strong>i Marshall, MPA ’02<br />

Zachary Blake Marshall, MIA ’91,<br />

IF ’91<br />

Michael G. Martinson, MIA ’70<br />

Raul Kazimierz Martynek, MIA ’93<br />

M. Haytham Matthews, IF ’78<br />

Anneliese Farrell Mauch, MIA ’93,<br />

CERT ’93<br />

Rebecca Lynn May<br />

Elizabeth Sheafe Mayer<br />

Toby E. Mayman, MIA ’65<br />

Glenn Edward McCartan, MPA ’11<br />

Am<strong>and</strong>a Waring McClenahan, MPA ’02<br />

Alex<strong>and</strong>er Ian McCloskey, MPA ’05<br />

Ann Hunt McDermott, MPA ’90<br />

John Lewis McDonald, MIA ’93,<br />

CERT ’93<br />

Brian C. McDonnell, MPA ’80<br />

Alan B. McDougall, MPA ’92<br />

Clifford Andrew McGadney, MPA ’06<br />

Eugenia McGill, MIA ’00<br />

Fred F. McGoldrick, MIA ’66<br />

James D. McGraw, MIA ’55<br />

John T. McGuire, MIA ’63/McGuire<br />

Family Foundation<br />

Rose W. McHenry, MIA ’62<br />

Anne N. McIntosh, MIA ’85, IF ’85<br />

Robert Calvin McKenney, MIA ’08<br />

John McKinley, MIA ’11<br />

Kathleen Roberta McNamara, MIA ’89,<br />

CERT ’89<br />

Robert E. McNulty, MIA ’83<br />

Patricia Marie McSharry, MIA ’86,<br />

CERT ’86<br />

Mary Helen McSweeney-Feld, MIA ’79<br />

Stephanie Hope Meade, MIA ’02<br />

Laila M. Mehdi, MIA ’86<br />

Neeru Mehra, MIA ’79<br />

Richard Mei, MIA ’85<br />

Claire Anne Bradt Meier, MIA ’04<br />

Joslyn Edelstein Meier, MIA ’07<br />

Hermes Elpidio Mena, MPA ’09<br />

Jack W. Mendelsohn, CERT ’77<br />

Patricia Bernadette Mendoza, MIA ’97<br />

Stephen Carlos Mercado, MIA ’88,<br />

CERT ’88<br />

Stephanie Crane Mergenthaler, MIA ’98<br />

Michael G. Merin, MIA ’84, IF ’84,<br />

CERT ’84<br />

Alex<strong>and</strong>ra Merle-Huet, MIA ’04<br />

Samuel Austin Merrill, MIA ’99, IF ’99<br />

Katherine M. Metres, MIA ’97, IF ’97<br />

Jeffrey Peter Metzler, MPA ’99<br />

Calvin Marshall Mew, IF ’72<br />

Brian R. Meyers, MPA ’06<br />

Frank J. Miceli, MIA ’92<br />

Thomas R. Michelmore, MIA ’74<br />

Adin Calis Miller, MPA ’96<br />

Charles Russell Miller, MIA ’99, CERT ’99<br />

George R. Milner, MIA ’49 <strong>and</strong> Norah<br />

Leckey Milner, MIA ’49<br />

Courtney Sara Lawrence Minard, MIA ’03<br />

Edmund M. Mitchell, MIA ’73<br />

Marilyn Mitchell<br />

Ayoti Mittra, MIA ’11<br />

Arsalan Mohajer<br />

Redmond Kathleen Molz<br />

Kathleen P. Mone, MPA ’81<br />

Jeffrey Gordon Moore, MIA ’85,<br />

CERT ’85<br />

Joanne Catherine Moore, MPA ’00 <strong>and</strong><br />

Kenneth C. Moore<br />

Charlotte T. Morgan-Cato, MIA ’67<br />

Kin W. Moy, MIA ’90<br />

Louis J. Murphy, MIA ’64<br />

Rebecca Elizabeth Myers, MPA ’07<br />

Robert O. Myhr, MIA ’62<br />

James P. Nach, MIA ’66<br />

Jonathan Jacob Nadler, MPA ’81<br />

Sawa Nakagawa, MIA ’09<br />

Sidney Nakao Nakahodo, MIA ’05<br />

Meghan E.W. Nalbo, MIA ’07<br />

Ophelie Namiech, MIA ’11<br />

Joseph Francis Napoli, MIA ’89<br />

Richard B. Nash, IF ’83<br />

Edward Joseph Naughton, MIA ’08<br />

Olga Nedeljkovic<br />

Michele Diane Needham, MPA ’92<br />

Chadwick C. Nehrt, IF ’81<br />

Oksana Dackiw Nesterczuk, MIA ’81,<br />

CERT ’81<br />

Daniel Thomas Newmann, MPA ’10<br />

Richard T. Newman, MIA ’51<br />

Tan Nguyen<br />

Ann Nicol, MIA ’77<br />

David Michael Nidus, MPA ’98<br />

Christopher K. Nikolakopoulos, MIA ’52<br />

Lila Fatemeh Noury, MIA ’06<br />

Joanna Rachel Novick<br />

Hannah Fay Nudell, MIA ’09, IF ’09<br />

Ronald W. O’Connor, IF ’64<br />

Thomas F. O’Connor, MIA ’76<br />

Noreen O’Donnell, MIA ’97<br />

Peter Damian O’Driscoll, MIA ’97<br />

James A. Oesterle, MIA ’65, IF ’65<br />

Lorelei Brooke O’Hagan, MIA ’08<br />

Harry John O’Hara, MIA ’91, IF ’91 <strong>and</strong><br />

Annika Linden O’Hara, MIA ’91<br />

Valdimir Olarte Cadavid<br />

Amber Elana Oliver, MIA ’02, IF ’02<br />

Christina Marie Oliver, MPA ’04<br />

Irvin Washington Oliver, MIA ’08, IF ’08<br />

Clarence W. Olmstead, IF ’67<br />

Paul Victor Olsson, MIA ’87<br />

Onuwabhagbe Abbey Omokhodion,<br />

MIA ’00<br />

Yalman Onaran, MIA ’93<br />

Gwynne Arian Oosterbaan, MIA ’97,<br />

CERT ’97<br />

Mary Ann Oppenheimer, MIA ’69<br />

Marie Agnes O’Reilly, MIA ’11<br />

Angela Ortiz, MIA ’08<br />

Ashley Coats Orton, MIA ’07, CERT ’07<br />

Bruce A. Ortwine, MIA ’78<br />

Joseph Osenni, MPA ’79<br />

Kimberley Ostrowski, MPA ’07<br />

Laura Otterbourg, MIA ’87<br />

Marilyn G. Ozer, MIA ’71<br />

William M. Packard, IF ’70<br />

Elizabeth Sherrerd Page, MPA ’98<br />

Angie P. Palacios<br />

Eunha Enna Park, MIA ’89<br />

Amitabh Passi, MIA ’05<br />

Amal Shashikant Patel, MIA ’02 <strong>and</strong><br />

Darcy Diane Anderson, MIA ’02<br />

Radha N. Patel, MPA ’06<br />

Grant R. Patrick, MIA ’81<br />

Susan C. Patterson, MIA ’77<br />

Kathleen A. Pauker, MIA ’79<br />

Jessica Horan Payne, MPA ’02<br />

Andrew Collins Peach, MIA ’98<br />

John Edward Peck, CERT ’91<br />

John A. Pecoul, IF ’64<br />

Barbara Pehlivanian<br />

Richard J. Pera, MIA ’79<br />

Diana Carolina Pereira<br />

Don Peretz<br />

Jack R. Perry, CERT ’58<br />

Ned King Peterson, MIA ’06, IF ’06<br />

Dennis E. Petito, MIA ’77<br />

Lawrence C. Petrowski, IF ’69<br />

Peter J. Pettibone<br />

Elizabeth M. Phillips, MIA ’79<br />

Maurice J. Picard, MIA ’61<br />

James Brian Pieri, MPA ’07<br />

Andrew J. Pierre, MIA ’57, IF ’57<br />

Monica Pina Alzugaray, MIA ’11<br />

Jeffrey M. Pines, IF ’71<br />

Daphne Anne Pinkerson, MIA ’85<br />

Vanessa Pino Lockel, MPA ’03<br />

Costantino Pischedda<br />

Am<strong>and</strong>a Pitman<br />

Robert Walter Pitulej, MPA ’96<br />

Rachel L. Pohl, MPA ’84, IF ’84<br />

Victor M. Polce, MIA ’79<br />

Sally Soo Hoo Pon, MPA ’82<br />

David L. Porter, IF ’63<br />

Margaret Edsall Powell, MIA ’01<br />

Jennifer Elise Powers-Darrington,<br />

MIA ’06<br />

Ch<strong>and</strong>ni Sivasriaumphai Prasad, MIA ’96<br />

Sarah C. Pratt<br />

Beatriz Prieto-Oramas, MIA ’05<br />

Joseph Procopio, MIA ’72<br />

Kelly Proctor, MPA ’10<br />

James Frederick Prusky, MIA ’96<br />

Sami Qadan, MPA ’07<br />

Glenda Liu Quarnstrom, MIA ’77,<br />

CERT ’77<br />

Jenik R. Radon<br />

Chitra Raghavacharya, MIA ’01<br />

Thomas Nelson Rains, MPA ’11<br />

Allison Joy Ramler, MIA ’96, CERT ’96<br />

Timothy Paul Ramsey, MIA ’93<br />

Rikha Sharma Rani, MIA ’11<br />

Andrea L. Rankin, MPA ’97<br />

David J. Ransdell, MIA ’82<br />

Adam Clive Raphaely, MPA ’07<br />

Jonathan Jellis Rawlings<br />

Gary J. Reardon, MPA ’80<br />

Eunice S. Reddick, MIA ’74, IF ’74<br />

Beth Karen Rehman, MIA ’05<br />

Richard T. Reiter, MIA ’85<br />

Jason Warren Rekate, MIA ’00<br />

Janet S. Resele-Tiden, MIA ’92<br />

Michelle D. Rexach-Subira, MPA ’96<br />

Russell E. Richey, IF ’65<br />

Scott Andrew Richman, MIA ’91<br />

Susan B. Rifkin, MIA ’69, CERT ’69<br />

Samuel Hamilton Rikkers, MIA ’04<br />

Eduardo Rivas, MIA ’04<br />

Nina Camille Robbins, MIA ’11<br />

Yoel Ephrain Robens-Paradise, MPA ’92<br />

Debra Leigh Robertson, MPA ’02<br />

Sara E. Robertson, MIA ’84<br />

Pearl Theodora Robinson, CERT ’72<br />

William Rodgers, MIA ’91<br />

Catherine Rodriguez, MPA ’10, IF ’10<br />

Dorena Lynn Rodriguez, MPA ’96<br />

Riordan J. A. Roett, MIA ’61<br />

Andrew Romay<br />

Patricia Rooney, MIA ’82<br />

Susan O. Rose, CERT ’68<br />

Kathryn Ann Rosenblum, MIA ’86<br />

Emily Glaser Ross<br />

Jay Ross, MPA ’11<br />

Susan A. S. Rosthal, MIA ’71<br />

Nathalie E. Roth, MIA ’00<br />

Elizabeth Rothkopf, MIA ’99<br />

Seymour Rotter, CERT ’49<br />

Oleg Radkov Rouptchin, MIA ’02<br />

Richard C. Rowson, MIA ’50<br />

Joanne Golden Ruchman, MIA ’77, IF ’77<br />

Moises Rudelman, MIA ’01<br />

George F. Ruffner, MIA ’72<br />

Robert R. Ruggiero<br />

Stephanie Priscilla Ruiz<br />

Andrew James Russell, MIA ’89<br />

Nona J. Russell, MPA ’85<br />

Leonas Sabaliunas, MIA ’58, CERT ’58<br />

Margaret Heflin Sabbag, MIA ’98<br />

Anthony R. Saccomano, MIA ’70<br />

Nigora Sachdeva, MIA ’11<br />

SIPA NEWS 43


Donor List SIPA<br />

Haroon Saeed, MIA ’95<br />

Carol R. Saivetz, MIA ’71, CERT ’71<br />

Simon Guadalupe Salas, MPA ’83<br />

Alex<strong>and</strong>ra Lisa Salomon, MIA ’99<br />

Emily Saltzman H<strong>of</strong>fner, MPA ’90<br />

Teresita Lucia Sanabria, MPA ’89<br />

Sybil Bess Sanchez, MIA ’97<br />

Erica S<strong>and</strong>ers<br />

Elizabeth Perschbacher S<strong>and</strong>s, MPA ’07<br />

Jahmal Liani S<strong>and</strong>s, MIA ’11<br />

Leslie Anne Santamaria, MIA ’06<br />

Ana Catalina Santos Ramos<br />

Manabu Sasaki, MIA ’01<br />

Matthew Schiavenza<br />

Carl Schieren, MIA ’67<br />

Daniele Megan Schiffman, MPA ’02<br />

Miriam Shahrzad Schive, MIA ’11<br />

Kurt A. Schreder, MIA ’93 <strong>and</strong> Caroline<br />

Paulus Schreder, MIA ’92<br />

David J. Schurman, IF ’63<br />

Chantal Schuster, MIA ’07<br />

Ana S. Schwartz, MIA ’82<br />

Frederick D. Seaton, MIA ’62, IF ’62<br />

Abilene Tralee Seguin<br />

Lynn A. Seirup, MIA ’80<br />

Kaoruko Seki, MIA ’93, IF ’93<br />

Albert Seligmann, MIA ’49<br />

Irwin S. Selnick, CERT ’78<br />

Marc Jay Selverstone, MIA ’92<br />

Nina Maria Serafino, MIA ’76<br />

Karen Serota <strong>and</strong> Lauren C. Serota,<br />

MIA ’05<br />

Katayoun Mary Shahrokhi, MIA ’08<br />

Jennifer Shaoul, MPA ’90<br />

Amita Sharma, MPA ’08<br />

Howard Jerome Shatz, MIA ’91<br />

Emy Shayo, MIA ’99<br />

Dan Ray Shepherd, MPA ’08<br />

Barnet Sherman, MPA ’82<br />

Sanford T. Sherman, MIA ’82<br />

Elisabeth Day Sherwood, MIA ’95<br />

Betsy Pollack Shimberg, MPA ’97<br />

Karlan Ison Sick<br />

Michael David Sieburg<br />

Marc J. Sievers, MIA ’80, IF ’80, CERT ’80<br />

Kathryn Angel Sikkink, CERT ’84<br />

Jennifer Marie Silvi, MIA ’09<br />

Michael Silvia, MIA ’79<br />

Melvyn J. Simburg, MIA ’71, IF ’71<br />

Kuldip K. Singh, MIA ’77<br />

Vicki Sittenfeld, MPA ’82<br />

Joseph C. Small, IF ’68 <strong>and</strong> Alice K. Small<br />

Susan V. Smith Santini, MPA ’93<br />

David Burton Snow, MIA ’98<br />

Roberto E. Socas, MIA ’55<br />

Anastasia Sochynsky<br />

Elaine Carol S<strong>of</strong>fer, MPA ’83<br />

Richard J. Soghoian, IF ’65<br />

Stephen A. Sokol, MIA ’01<br />

Debra E. Soled, MIA ’82, CERT ’82<br />

Jan Solomon, CERT ’75<br />

Andre Israel Solorzano Dimas<br />

Ellen Solowey, MIA ’86, CERT ’86<br />

Frances G. Sonkin, MIA ’75<br />

Christian R. Sonne, MIA ’62, CERT ’62<br />

Aimee Duncan Sostowski, MIA ’07<br />

Stephen H. Spahn, IF ’65<br />

Molly Catherine Spencer, MPA ’97<br />

Arthur Finn Spring, MIA ’88<br />

Daniel Sreebny, MIA ’78<br />

Charles H. Srodes, IF ’65<br />

Robert Francis Staats, MIA ’83<br />

Elizabeth Stabler, MIA ’56<br />

Marisa C. Stadtmauer, MPA ’93<br />

Claire S. Stelter<br />

Loren M. Stephens, MIA ’67<br />

Amir Abraham Sternhell MIA ’91<br />

Clyde Donald Stoltenberg, MIA ’85<br />

Hari Subhash<br />

Colin Sullivan<br />

Jennifer Jaryi Sun, MIA ’97<br />

Niamh Teresa Sweeney<br />

Alison Kimberly Swenton, MIA ’00<br />

Anne Bernadette Talley, MIA ’94<br />

Alice Ayling Tan, MPA ’01<br />

Ellie Tang, MIA ’09<br />

Florence Tatistcheff-Amzallag, MIA ’76<br />

Eda Franzetti Tato, MIA ’80<br />

William C. Taubman, IF ’63, CERT ’63<br />

Carlos Felix Terrones, MPA ’08<br />

Gweneth Michelle Thirwell, MPA ’06<br />

Paul A. Thompson, MIA ’73<br />

Anna Throne-Holst, MIA ’06<br />

David G. Timberman, MIA ’80<br />

Stephen E. Tisman, IF ’72<br />

Richard Stephen Tobin, MPA ’08<br />

Elizabeth Anne Toder, MIA ’96<br />

Alper Sadik Tokozlu, MIA ’01<br />

Nuria Tolsa Caballero, MIA ’11<br />

Rebecca Rosenblum Tolson, MIA ’94 <strong>and</strong><br />

M. Grant Tolson, MIA ’95<br />

M. Tomaszewski<br />

Gabriel Topor, MIA ’92, CERT ’92<br />

Fumitsugu Tosu, MPA ’11<br />

Jennifer Elizabeth Toth, MIA ’04<br />

Ruth E. Townsend<br />

Cathy Rivara Trezza, MIA ’85<br />

Christopher G. Trump, IF ’62<br />

Alilsa Fatma Tugberk de Macedo, MIA ’06<br />

Rebecca Hales Tunstall, MIA ’04<br />

Margaret Ann Turbett, MIA ’84<br />

Robert F. Turetsky, MIA ’72<br />

Mark Owen Turner, MIA ’95<br />

Philip Harry Tuson<br />

Melinda Macdonald Twomey, MIA ’84<br />

Natalia Udovik, MIA ’69<br />

Yuki Uehara, MIA ’04<br />

Takako Ugaya, MPA ’94<br />

Andrew Umans, MIA ’10<br />

Miguel Urquiola<br />

Ali Vakili<br />

Barbara A. Van Geyzel, MIA ’77<br />

Marten H. A. Van Heuven, MIA ’57<br />

Jorge Luis Vargas, MIA ’98<br />

Christopher Michael Vaughn, MIA ’98,<br />

IF ’98<br />

Natalia Vladimirovna Vazhenina, MIA ’11<br />

Ilona Jaramillo Vega, MIA ’94<br />

Leona Isabelle Verdadero<br />

Milka Petrovich Verhaegen, MIA ’85<br />

Neelam Verjee, MPA ’11<br />

Nimish Verma, MIA ’11<br />

Edward J. Vern<strong>of</strong>f, MIA ’69<br />

Dario Enrique Vilchez, MIA ’10<br />

Susannah Violino, MIA ’81<br />

Justin Gregory Vogt, MIA ’06, IF ’06<br />

Carrie Staub Vomacka, MIA ’06<br />

Ulric Erickson Von Allmen, MIA ’94<br />

Stephanie Von Stein, MIA ’93<br />

Clark David Wagner, MIA ’85<br />

Karen Marie Wagner, MIA ’02<br />

Linda Mary Wagner, MPA ’08<br />

Maria M. Waite-Nied, MPA ’82<br />

Sarah A. Walbert, MIA ’80<br />

Carrie Walker, MPA ’09<br />

Robert Kimball Wallace, IF ’67<br />

Jeffrey Gene Waller, MIA ’02<br />

Jesse Campoll Walter<br />

Stephen Christopher Wamback, MPA ’90<br />

Shontel Lenore Ward, MPA ’06<br />

Carl Thomas Watson, MIA ’04<br />

Robert M. Watts, MIA ’80<br />

Rebecca VanL<strong>and</strong>ingham Waugh,<br />

MIA ’00<br />

Christina Anne Way, MIA ’05<br />

Marian Lillian Weber, MPA ’07<br />

Egon E. Weck, MIA ’49<br />

Kimberly Anne Wedel, MPA ’88<br />

Benjamin Richard Weil, MIA ’92,<br />

CERT ’92<br />

Paul J. Weinstein, MIA ’87<br />

Gary Michael Weiskopf, MPA ’87 <strong>and</strong><br />

Lynn Weiskopf, MPA ’91<br />

Morton P. Weitzman<br />

Marilyn S. Wellemeyer, MIA ’68<br />

Caitlin Elizabeth Welsh, MPA ’09<br />

Marilyn L. Wertheimer, CERT ’53<br />

Szczepan Wesoly<br />

S<strong>and</strong>ra L. West-Williams, MIA ’88<br />

Rebecca Kate Wexler, MIA ’11<br />

Donald F. Wheeler, CERT ’71<br />

Erika Buraczek Whillas<br />

Raymond D. White, IF ’64<br />

Susan Keil White, MIA ’01<br />

Gordon James Whiting, IF ’93<br />

Jill Sue Wilkins, MIA ’91<br />

H. David Willey, IF ’63<br />

Eli Steven Williams<br />

Elizabeth Wilner<br />

Ellen Katherine Wilson, MIA ’93<br />

Edward S. Winsor, MIA ’54<br />

Merle Beth Wise, MPA ’88<br />

Bret Philip Woellner, MIA ’07, IF ’07,<br />

CERT ’07<br />

Ezana Haile Woldegeorgise, MIA ’09<br />

Susan Hammond Wolford, MIA ’79<br />

William D. Wolle, MIA ’51<br />

Menen Wondwosen, MIA ’11<br />

Scott G. Wong, MIA ’11<br />

Gilda Gates Wray, MIA ’66<br />

Dana Ying-Hui Wu, MPA ’92<br />

Michele M. Wucker, MIA ’93, CERT ’93<br />

Norman G. Wyc<strong>of</strong>f, MIA ’50<br />

Anastasia Xenias, CERT ’94<br />

Bernice Esi Yalley, MPA ’06<br />

Hidemasa Yamakawa, MIA ’92<br />

Joanne Stern Yaron<br />

Rebecca Yeh, MIA ’09<br />

Loretta M. Yenson, MIA ’82<br />

Sonia Eun Joo Yeo, MIA ’00<br />

David Yuriy Yesilevskiy, MIA ’09<br />

Ellis Woodworth Youdal, MIA ’95<br />

Mark Donald Young, MPA ’91<br />

Miriam A. Young, MIA ’91, CERT ’91<br />

William Jack Young, MPA ’90<br />

Ying-Yue Yung<br />

Laura Anne Zaks, MIA ’05<br />

Lawrence F. Zant, MIA ’51<br />

Michael Shiel Zdanovich, MIA ’88<br />

Marc-Claude Zeitoun, MIA ’91<br />

Mathias Zeller, MIA ’11<br />

Rachel Zenner Kane, MPA ’98<br />

Allan Jianhua Zhang, MIA ’03<br />

Chenguang Zhang, MPA ’08<br />

Siliang Zhou, MIA ’11<br />

Lauren Ziegler, MIA ’10<br />

Andrew W. Zimmerman, IF ’68<br />

Jonathan Zorach, CERT ’72<br />

Matching Gift Companies:<br />

234 Moonachie Corporation<br />

American Express Foundation<br />

Bank <strong>of</strong> America Foundation<br />

The Bank <strong>of</strong> New York Mellon<br />

Foundation<br />

Carnegie Corporation <strong>of</strong> New York<br />

Citizens Charitable Foundation<br />

Constellation Energy Group Foundation,<br />

Inc.<br />

Deloitte Foundation<br />

Deutsche Bank Americas Foundation<br />

Clevel<strong>and</strong> H. Dodge Foundation<br />

Ernst & Young Foundation<br />

ExxonMobil Foundation<br />

Fitch Ratings<br />

Goldman, Sachs & Company<br />

HSBC Bank USA<br />

IBM <strong>International</strong> Foundation<br />

J.P. Morgan Chase Foundation<br />

Juniper Networks<br />

MBIA Foundation, Inc.<br />

The McGraw-Hill Companies<br />

Foundation, Inc.<br />

MetLife Foundation<br />

The Morrison & Foerster Foundation<br />

Nomura America Foundation<br />

Pfizer Foundation<br />

<strong>Public</strong> Service Electric <strong>and</strong> Gas Company<br />

The Rockefeller Foundation<br />

The Moody’s Foundation<br />

Tyco<br />

Wells Fargo Foundation<br />

44 SIPA NEWS


SIPA News is published semiannually by SIPA’s Office <strong>of</strong> Communications <strong>and</strong><br />

External Relations.<br />

Managing Editor: JoAnn Crawford<br />

Editors: Rebecca Chao, Ethan Wilkes<br />

Contributing writers:<br />

David Borenstein, Alex Burnett, Michelle Chahine, Rebecca Chao, John H. Coatsworth,<br />

Nathaniel Parish Flannery, Pat Jones, Andrea Moore, Crystal Neo, Sara Ray, Tim S<strong>and</strong>ole,<br />

Priyam Saraf, Martin Waehlisch, Ethan Wilkes, Jennifer Wilmore, <strong>and</strong> Behar Xharra<br />

Contributing photographers: Munshi Ahmed/Bloomberg/Getty Images, Theresa Barraclough/<br />

AFP/Getty Images, Patrick Baz/AFP/Getty Images, Eileen Barroso, Alej<strong>and</strong>ro Bringas/<br />

REUTERS, Michelle Chahine, Sergei Chuzavkov/AP Photo, Susan Cook, Michael Dames,<br />

Jonathan Drake/Bloomberg/Getty Images, Gael Gonzalez/REUTERS, Jose Luis Gonzalez/<br />

REUTERS, David Gray/REUTERS, Boris Grdanoski/AP Photo, Tim Griffith, Phillip Hayson,<br />

Image Source/Getty Images, Chris Jackson/Getty Images, Blagoja Jankoski/Getty Images,<br />

Jakob Kamender, Francois Lenoir/REUTERS, Vladimir Maravic, Ben Pipe Photography/<br />

Getty Images, Christopher Reeve, William Wan/The Washington Post/Getty Images,<br />

John Wang/Getty Images<br />

Cover Photograph: Stan Honda/AFP/Getty Images<br />

Design <strong>and</strong> Production: Office <strong>of</strong> University <strong>Public</strong>ations<br />

<strong>School</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>International</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>Public</strong> <strong>Affairs</strong><br />

Dean: John H. Coatsworth<br />

Senior Associate Dean: Troy Eggers<br />

Associate Deans: Patrick Bohan, Jesse Gale, Caroline Kay, Dan McIntyre,<br />

<strong>and</strong> Shalini Mimani<br />

Office <strong>of</strong> Communications <strong>and</strong> External Relations<br />

Jesse Gale, Associate Dean, Communications <strong>and</strong> External Relations<br />

Alex Burnett, Communications Officer<br />

JoAnn Crawford, Director <strong>of</strong> <strong>Public</strong>ations <strong>and</strong> Special Events<br />

Phoebe Ford, Web Specialist<br />

Pat Jones, Administrative Assistant<br />

Scott Pesner, Director <strong>of</strong> Alumni <strong>Affairs</strong><br />

Sara Ray, Administrative Assistant<br />

Office <strong>of</strong> Alumni <strong>and</strong> Development<br />

Shalini Mimani, Associate Dean, Development<br />

Samuel Boyer, Assistant Director <strong>of</strong> Development<br />

Barbara Chan, Events <strong>and</strong> Stewardship Manager<br />

Madelyn Storms, Director <strong>of</strong> Development<br />

<strong>Columbia</strong> University<br />

<strong>School</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>International</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>Public</strong> <strong>Affairs</strong><br />

420 West 118th Street<br />

Office <strong>of</strong> Communications <strong>and</strong> External Relations:<br />

212-854-8671<br />

Fax: 212-854-8660<br />

www.sipa.columbia.edu


<strong>Columbia</strong> University<br />

<strong>School</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>International</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>Public</strong> <strong>Affairs</strong><br />

420 West 118th Street, Mail code 3328<br />

New York, NY 10027<br />

Nonpr<strong>of</strong>it Org.<br />

U.S. Postage<br />

PAID<br />

New York, NY<br />

Permit No. 3593

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!