3 years ago

Niagara River Remedial Action Plan Stage 2 Update Report

Niagara River Remedial Action Plan Stage 2 Update Report

AOC, is also shown.

AOC, is also shown. Concentrations are for the most part undetectable or very low. Canada Geese and Mallard do not feed exclusively on benthic invertebrates or fish, but are generalist omnivores, in contrast to the diving ducks taken from the Niagara River AOC. Based on diet, it is unlikely that contaminant concentrations in dabbling ducks or Canada Geese from the Niagara River AOC will approach concentrations which exceed the Health Canada guidelines for human consumption (B. Braune, pers. comm.). Neither toxaphene nor dioxins/furans were analyzed for waterfowl in the Braune et al. (1999) study. However, toxaphene concentrations are likely too low to be of concern (Hughes, 2006). The results of the study undertaken by Braune et. al. (1999) showed, for a large sample (800 pooled samples) of waterfowl eggs, pectoral muscle and liver tissue taken all over Canada, that organochlorine and metals concentrations were either not detected or found at very low concentrations. The highest concentrations were found in birds that feed at the highest trophic levels, for example mergansers, loons, and gulls, and which are not typically taken for consumption (see section 2.1 above). The results of the Braune et al. (1999) study and a number of others led Health Canada in 1998 to conclude, that: “…contaminant levels found in samples of pectoral muscle of ducks, geese, and other gamebirds analyzed, do not pose a risk to the health of human consumers.” 2.3 Contaminants in Snapping Turtles and their Eggs (Hughes, 2004; Fernie and de Solla, 2004 Contaminants in Snapping Turtles and their eggs were assessed by MNR Wildlife Branch in 1988-89 in the Welland River watershed (Hebert et al. 1993), and by Environment Canada in 2002 in the Lyons Creek watershed. Total DDT, total PCBs, and mirex were measured in turtle muscle in 1988-89, and PCBs, non-ortho PCBs, dioxins and furans and OC pesticides were measured in turtle eggs in 2002. A summary of results is as follows: }} Welland River 1988-89- mean concentrations of all contaminants in snapping turtle muscle were low (DDT- 0.0019 ug/g, PCBs- 0.132 ug/g, mirex- 0.0004 ug/g), and within the range of levels found in snapping turtle at other Southern Ontario locations. Age of sampled turtles was unknown. }} Lyons Creek East 2002- Eggs of five snapping turtle clutches had significantly higher sum PCBs (mean concentration of 1.214 ug/g) compared to the Wheatley Harbour AOC and two reference sites (Tiny Marsh, Severn Sound and Algonquin Park). Some of the TEQs exceeded CCME Environmental Quality guidelines for the protection of wildlife. The high levels of PCBs in this watershed are related to an area of Aroclor 1254-contaminated sediment at the head of the creek. It should be noted that reference site data from Eastern Lake Erie was not available, and would probably have provided a more appropriate comparison to Lyons Creek sample sites, from a RAP perspective. 2.4 Lyons Creek Risk Assessments A screening-level human health risk assessment (HHRA) was conducted by Dillon Consulting Ltd. (2005) for the Lyons Creek East area. They summarized available data on snapping turtle consumption and estimated exposure to consumers based on estimated rates and patterns of consumption. Only one past assessment was cited on PCBs in snapping turtle muscle, eggs, heart and liver undertaken by MOE in 1996. For the reasons outlined in section 2.0 above, only consumption of muscle was considered in the HHRA. Rates and amounts of snapping turtle consumption for Lyons Creek residents were not available 150

Niagara river remedial action plan stage 2 update so they were estimated based on Health Canada data and daily intake recommendations for First Nations populations and hunters. Even with these very conservative assumptions, likely to have inflated the risk, they concluded that: }} Snapping turtle consumption from Lyons Creek East made a very minor (less than 5%) contribution to total incremental increases in lifetime cancer risk from PCB exposure. }} Consumption of snapping turtle meat is not likely to represent a significant route of exposure to PCBs. Community surveys conducted as part of a detailed HHRA for Lyons Creek East found that no respondents indicated they currently consumed snapping turtles or their eggs from within the study area or had done so in the past (Dillon Consulting Ltd., 2006b). Non-residents were not surveyed and some anecdotal information suggests that non-residents may be trapping and consuming turtles from the area. Screening-level and detailed ecological risk assessments (ERA) were completed in 2004 and 2005 for all areas of contaminated sediment noted in the RAP Stage 2 Report (Golder Associates 2003 and 2004). In terms of the risk of bioaccumulation/biomagnification of metals, mercury, or organochlorines in wildlife via the benthic food chain, or in the case of muskrat, via consumption of cattails, the only sites of concern were Lyons Creek East and West. At Lyons Creek West, a potential risk to muskrat of PCB and arsenic exposure through cattail consumption was noted, with exposure estimates exceeding the screening-level No Observable Adverse Effect Levels (NOAEL) for white-tailed deer (most conservative benchmark available). Concentrations in muskrat were estimated based on measured concentrations in cattails. It is unknown if, as a result, muskrat PCB and arsenic body burdens would pose a health risk to human consumers. A detailed HHRA was conducted for Lyons Creek West by Dillon Consulting Ltd. (2006b). They did not assess the risk of exposure to contaminants via fish and wildlife consumption, as a result of their finding (as stated in their report) that: “The site is not used for local food production, nor is there evidence that berries or other wild foods, including fish, are collected from the site.” This conclusion was based on site visits and observations of an absence of established footpaths and human traffic, as well as heavy vegetative cover including abundant poison ivy. 2.4.1 Legal Allowances for Hunting and Trapping in the Lyons Creek East and West Areas As regulated by MNR and lower-tier municipal by-laws, the following allowances are made for trapping and hunting in the Lyons Creek East and West areas (MNR area WMU 89A) ( J. Durst MNR, pers. comm.): }} trapping of wildlife is permitted in both areas } } shooting of nuisance wildlife is permitted on the lands of farmers and nursery owners in both areas, subject to a safe distance (150 m) away from residential dwellings }} Other discharges of firearms are not permitted in the Lyons Creek West area, and are only permitted in the vicinity of Lyons Creek East between a point just east of Cook’s Mills and the Black Road crossing just east of the QEW, as per City of Welland and City of Niagara Falls firearm discharge by-laws. 151

Site Management Plan Stage 2 Major Remediation Works - Sydney ...
Annual Report, Year 2 (2006) - Pecos River WPP Implementation ...
Lower Welland River Characterization Report - Niagara Peninsula ...
Upper Welland River Watershed Plan - Niagara Peninsula ...
Niagara Water Strategy Update and Action Plan November 10, 2010
Site Management Plan Stage 2 Major Remediation Works, Appendix E
Welland River Eutrophication Study – November 2010
Proposed Remedial Action Plan for Site 5 Groundwater (OU 2 ...
FINAL Remedial Action Management Plan Work Plan
Remedial Action Plan - Main Report - Planning - NSW Government
Site Management Plan Stage 2 Major Remediation Works, Appendix D
Environmental Remedial Action Plan -
Proposed Plan, Interim Remedial Action ... - Lockheed Martin
ea engineering: report: remedial action engineering work plan for ...
Site Management Plan Stage 2 Major Remediation Works, Appendix B
Remedial Action Plan - Rochford Field - Newhall Remediation Project
Interim Remedial Action Monitoring Report ... - Lockheed Martin
2010 Remedial Action Progress Report - Lockheed Martin
2005 Remedial Action Progress Report - Lockheed Martin
Hazardous Materials Remedial Action Work Plan EBC -
submit Draft Interim Remedial Action Report for Area C Groundwater
Duck Creek Implementation Plan - River Action
remedy selection plan for j-2 range - Impact Area Groundwater ...
Action Plan for the Klamath River Total Maximum Daily Loads
Interim Remedial Action Work Plan - Freedom Industries - VRP 15017 - 11-2015
Draft LCP OU-2 Remedial Design Report - New York State ...