11.01.2015 Views

ART AWARD - Department of Arts and Museums

ART AWARD - Department of Arts and Museums

ART AWARD - Department of Arts and Museums

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

25th NATSIAA Online Education Resource 2008<br />

SILVER JUBILEE<br />

telstra national aboriginal & torres strait isl<strong>and</strong>er<br />

<strong>ART</strong> <strong>AWARD</strong><br />

education resource<br />

Museum <strong>and</strong> Art Gallery Northern Territory www.magnt.nt.gov.au Conacher Street, Fannie Bay NT 0820<br />

1


25th NATSIAA Online Education Resource 2008<br />

SILVER JUBILEE<br />

telstra national aboriginal & torres strait isl<strong>and</strong>er<br />

<strong>ART</strong> <strong>AWARD</strong><br />

Introduction<br />

There are many intersecting themes throughout this exhibition <strong>and</strong> the artworks can be appreciated <strong>and</strong> discussed<br />

around a diverse selection <strong>of</strong> them.<br />

This kit focuses on four themes to stimulate thought <strong>and</strong> discussion on the 25th NATSIAA:<br />

1. Mortuary <strong>and</strong> Murder<br />

2. Caring for Country / Back to Country<br />

3. Oral History / Dreaming<br />

4. Politics / New Histories<br />

It complements previous NATSIAA education kits, which can be found on Museum <strong>and</strong> Art Gallery Northern<br />

Territory’s website, www.magnt.nt.gov.au. Previous kits exp<strong>and</strong> other thematic areas <strong>of</strong> research for teachers<br />

<strong>and</strong> students.<br />

The kit is for students from the Primary <strong>and</strong> Middle Years <strong>and</strong> can be used by both teachers <strong>and</strong> students. It<br />

supports the Northern Territory Curriculum Frameworks with suggested activities for The <strong>Arts</strong> Learning Area.<br />

A Children’s Activity booklet is available in hard copy for students from the Early Years.<br />

The aims <strong>of</strong> the kit are to:<br />

• stimulate thought <strong>and</strong> discussion on the 25th NATSIAA by both teachers <strong>and</strong> students,<br />

• encourage engagement <strong>and</strong> response using selected artworks,<br />

• introduce broad examples <strong>and</strong> perceptions <strong>of</strong> Indigenous art practices, <strong>and</strong><br />

• link themes <strong>and</strong> ideas in Australian Indigenous culture <strong>and</strong> art with those in mainstream Australia.<br />

Museum <strong>and</strong> Art Gallery Northern Territory www.magnt.nt.gov.au Conacher Street, Fannie Bay NT 0820<br />

2


25th NATSIAA Online Education Resource 2008<br />

Mortuary <strong>and</strong> Murder<br />

Death has been a common theme in the art <strong>of</strong> all cultures since ancient times.<br />

Loss <strong>of</strong> life not only causes grief <strong>and</strong> sorrow, at times almost unbearable, but it engenders a wide range <strong>of</strong> other<br />

powerful thoughts <strong>and</strong> associated evocative images in the bereaving family or culture. These may include anger,<br />

guilt, revenge, martyrdom, justice <strong>and</strong> injustice, <strong>and</strong> heroic deeds but, inevitably, ponderings about the afterlife are<br />

prominent, perhaps pivotal, in one’s coming to terms with death.<br />

Traditional cultures seek answers to questions <strong>of</strong> mortality/immortality through religious means, myth-making<br />

<strong>and</strong> storytelling. Art is the common mode <strong>of</strong> expressing cultural perceptions beyond the limitations <strong>of</strong> language.<br />

In contemporary societies science may appear to hold sway with its conclusions; starting with the ‘big bang’, then<br />

acceptance <strong>of</strong> Darwin’s theory <strong>of</strong> evolution <strong>and</strong> finally the search for ‘a theory <strong>of</strong> everything’. However, there is<br />

<strong>of</strong>ten a cold objectiveness that accompanies scientific revolutions. The human condition yearns for the elusive other<br />

dimension or quality missing from scientific equations. Consequently traditional views <strong>and</strong> customs, particularly<br />

relating to the meaning <strong>of</strong> life <strong>and</strong> the afterlife, are still strongly held <strong>and</strong> should not be denigrated as one would a ‘flat<br />

earth’ theory.<br />

The four examples in this section explore some <strong>of</strong> the views, customs <strong>and</strong> stories centred on death from an<br />

Indigenous Australian perspective.<br />

a. Robert Namarnyilk’s bark painting Mongerrk uses traditional pigments <strong>and</strong> design to tell a horrific<br />

Dreamtime story <strong>of</strong> murder, revenge <strong>and</strong> restitution. The Dreamtime story goes something like this:<br />

Mongerrk, the main figure in the painting, kills some women by biting them in two. He is then chased by<br />

two angry men who are outraged at his killing <strong>of</strong> their promised wives. The two men catch Mongerrk <strong>and</strong><br />

spear him to death <strong>and</strong> then burn his body. Afterwards the two men join the women’s severed bodies back<br />

together, bringing them back to life.<br />

b. Samson Bonson has created a lorrkon, or hollow-log c<strong>of</strong>fin, decorated with totemic designs that relate<br />

to the deceased. A hollow-log c<strong>of</strong>fin is a place to deposit the skeletal remains / bones <strong>of</strong> the deceased.<br />

In traditional Indigenous cultures throughout the Top End, the remains are placed in hollow logs after a<br />

sequence <strong>of</strong> mortuary ceremonies.<br />

c. Yidumduma Bill Harney has also created a hollow-log c<strong>of</strong>fin. Harney, from the southern part <strong>of</strong> Arnhem L<strong>and</strong>,<br />

has made a hollow-log c<strong>of</strong>fin quite different in appearance <strong>and</strong> production.<br />

d. Nawurapu Wunungmurra has created a series <strong>of</strong> carved <strong>and</strong> painted spirit figures. In a Western context you<br />

could think <strong>of</strong> these spirit figures as ghosts, supernatural figures or demons. Ghosts are strongly evocative<br />

<strong>and</strong> may engender fear or wonder.<br />

Primary Years 4–6<br />

At the exhibition: Response & Analysis<br />

• Use adjectives to describe one <strong>of</strong> the artworks mentioned above.<br />

• What is the purpose <strong>of</strong> a hollow-log c<strong>of</strong>fin <strong>and</strong> what is the equivalent in mainstream Australia<br />

• Look at Robert Namarnyilk’s painting on bark. What effect does he get from using a paintbrush made<br />

from a grass reed<br />

• Can you identify bones in Nawurapu Wunungmurra’s carved figures<br />

Museum <strong>and</strong> Art Gallery Northern Territory www.magnt.nt.gov.au Conacher Street, Fannie Bay NT 0820<br />

3


25th NATSIAA Online Education Resource 2008<br />

At school or at home: Creating Art Ideas, <strong>Arts</strong> Skills & Processes<br />

• Create your own hollow-log c<strong>of</strong>fin using card (cardboard rolls work well) or other materials <strong>and</strong> decorate it<br />

with a design meaningful to you. You could also make some little bones to go inside your log c<strong>of</strong>fin.<br />

• Experiment with painting by using grass, reeds or similar implements as paintbrushes. You may extend this<br />

to explore bark as a surface to paint on (remember not to damage any trees). You could also grind your own<br />

pigments <strong>and</strong> mix them with some wood glue to make paint.<br />

• Draw two pictures <strong>of</strong> a ghost. In the first draw a ghost as it would be represented in a movie or on<br />

television; in the second draw it as you think a ghost might look to you. Is there any difference between the<br />

two drawings<br />

• Use shadows to create artworks that explore the afterlife … these works usually have an ephemeral quality.<br />

Middle Years 7–9<br />

At the exhibition: Response & Analysis, <strong>Arts</strong> in Context<br />

• Respond to Robert Namarnyilk painting Mongerrk. How does the story make you feel What expressions do<br />

the figures in the painting have Are these similar to how you feel when you think about the painting’s story<br />

• Analyse Namarnyilk’s painting again. Can you think <strong>of</strong> any movies or television shows that deal with<br />

similar narratives<br />

• There are a number <strong>of</strong> hollow-log c<strong>of</strong>fins in the exhibition. Select the one you prefer <strong>and</strong> explain your choice.<br />

• Compare the ways your cultural background <strong>and</strong> that <strong>of</strong> Nawurapu Wunungmurra’s represent figures from<br />

the afterlife. What similarities <strong>and</strong> differences are there<br />

At school or at home: Creating Art Idea, <strong>Arts</strong> Skills & Processes<br />

• Using a variety <strong>of</strong> art-making techniques create a c<strong>of</strong>fin for your favourite animal.<br />

• Research the way other cultures deal with people who have passed away. Think about the funeral rituals<br />

in mainstream Australia.<br />

• Create your own paints from a variety <strong>of</strong> man-made sources like cooking oil, tinned beetroot, etc. You can<br />

also make your own brushes from man-made materials such as toothbrushes. Use these to make art.<br />

• View popular culture magazines <strong>and</strong> create a collage <strong>of</strong> images that deal with death. In addition you could<br />

create a list <strong>of</strong> songs that deal with the subject <strong>of</strong> death.<br />

Museum <strong>and</strong> Art Gallery Northern Territory www.magnt.nt.gov.au Conacher Street, Fannie Bay NT 0820<br />

4


25th NATSIAA Online Education Resource 2008<br />

Caring for Country / Back to Country<br />

Indigenous Australians have a unique relationship with the Australian l<strong>and</strong>scape. This relationship spans over 40,000<br />

years <strong>and</strong> has its genesis in the mythical Dreamtime. For Indigenous Australians, l<strong>and</strong> is not a commodity to be<br />

bought <strong>and</strong> sold; rather its ownership is based on customary law. The obligations to manage <strong>and</strong> care for country are<br />

generally passed down through paternal <strong>and</strong> maternal links.<br />

Recent Australian history has seen many changes in our relationship with l<strong>and</strong>. Many Indigenous Australians have<br />

been forced or drifted away from their homel<strong>and</strong>s to live in urban environments. ‘Caring for country’ is an important<br />

means for remaking connections that vitalised <strong>and</strong> maintained traditional l<strong>and</strong>s. Indigenous Australians, by either<br />

physically going back to country or through reminiscing <strong>and</strong> story-telling, are able to care for country. The caring<br />

involves not only the ecological aspects like fire <strong>and</strong> resource management but, perhaps more importantly, the<br />

reconnection with ancestors who reside in the l<strong>and</strong>scape <strong>and</strong> ancestral stories. Artists are well placed to care for<br />

country through the act <strong>of</strong> art-making. Artists, in depicting their country either naturalistically or on cultural terms,<br />

strengthen their bonds with the l<strong>and</strong>scape.<br />

a. Wentja Napaltjarri’s Country West <strong>of</strong> Kintore is a massive painting depicting her family’s traditional<br />

hunting grounds in the s<strong>and</strong>hills <strong>of</strong> that region. Napaltjarri paints her memories <strong>of</strong> hunting in the s<strong>and</strong>hills<br />

with her father. The painting is like a topographical map that gives a ‘bird’s-eye view’ <strong>of</strong> the country.<br />

b. Omborrin’s Gullaroonari – Munja Country is a place near Derby in the north <strong>of</strong> Western Australia. The<br />

artist has depicted the escarpments where ancestral W<strong>and</strong>jina who came to create country <strong>and</strong> law reside.<br />

c. Far Away Places by Angelina George is a painting <strong>of</strong> her homel<strong>and</strong> conceived from memory rather than<br />

from being there. The artist is reminiscing about her country <strong>and</strong> depicts it in a naturalistic manner.<br />

d. Nici Cumpston’s Nookamka Rushes – Lake Bonney is a photograph <strong>of</strong> a lake in South Australia. Fed by<br />

the Murray River, Lake Bonney is testimony to the devastation <strong>of</strong> the area by drought <strong>and</strong> government water<br />

policy. Cumpston is raising awareness by linking her ancestors to the ecology <strong>of</strong> the river country, aiming to<br />

protect both the river <strong>and</strong> her culture.<br />

Primary Years 4–6<br />

At the exhibition: Response & Analysis<br />

• Why do you think Nici Cumpston has taken a photograph <strong>of</strong> a lake with dead trees What purpose does this<br />

image serve<br />

• In what ways do you ‘care for country’<br />

• Napaltjarri <strong>and</strong> George both paint pictures <strong>of</strong> their homel<strong>and</strong>s; describe their different approaches. Here are<br />

some words to help: abstract, naturalistic, graphic <strong>and</strong> realistic.<br />

• How long is Wentja Napaltjarri’s painting You can carefully measure it by stepping out the length <strong>of</strong> the<br />

painting with your feet. What is the impact <strong>of</strong> such a massive painting<br />

Museum <strong>and</strong> Art Gallery Northern Territory www.magnt.nt.gov.au Conacher Street, Fannie Bay NT 0820<br />

5


25th NATSIAA Online Education Resource 2008<br />

At school or at home: Creating Art Ideas, <strong>Arts</strong> Skills & Processes<br />

• Design a poster to promote an environmental issue you feel strongly about.<br />

• Using chalk or some other appropriate medium find a suitable site <strong>and</strong> make the most massive drawing you<br />

can; try to break the world record!<br />

• Draw a map <strong>of</strong> Australia that features the Murray/Darling River systems.<br />

• From memory, paint a picture <strong>of</strong> a place you have visited.<br />

Middle Years 7–9<br />

At the exhibition: Response & Analysis, <strong>Arts</strong> in Context<br />

• What are some differences <strong>and</strong> similarities between the way Omborrin <strong>and</strong> Angelina George have painted<br />

their country<br />

• Look at Nici Cumpston’s photograph. What environmental issue is she documenting<br />

• Napaltjarri, Omborrin <strong>and</strong> George all paint their pictures from memory rather than life. Which other works in<br />

the exhibition are painted from memory <strong>and</strong> which are from life<br />

• Identify the different media used in Cumpston’s <strong>and</strong> George’s work. How does this difference influence the<br />

impact <strong>of</strong> the two works<br />

At school or at home: Creating Art Ideas, <strong>Arts</strong> Skills & Processes<br />

• Use images from popular culture to create a collage that highlights environmental issues.<br />

• Create an artwork that depicts your earliest memory <strong>of</strong> your home.<br />

• Research the benefits that Indigenous cultural practices have on the environment.<br />

• Look up other Australian artists with a European background <strong>and</strong> consider their treatment <strong>of</strong> the l<strong>and</strong>scape.<br />

Museum <strong>and</strong> Art Gallery Northern Territory www.magnt.nt.gov.au Conacher Street, Fannie Bay NT 0820<br />

6


25th NATSIAA Online Education Resource 2008<br />

Oral History / Dreaming<br />

Indigenous Australians use the expression ‘Dreamtime’ or ‘Dreaming’ to refer to ancestral times – the ‘time before<br />

time when all things were created’.<br />

Individuals also have a particular Dreaming or several Dreamings that are pertinent to them <strong>and</strong> their country; for<br />

example, someone may have ‘Crocodile Dreaming’.<br />

In the Dreamtime ancestral spirits formed the l<strong>and</strong>scape <strong>and</strong> its plants <strong>and</strong> animals; they established relationships<br />

between people <strong>and</strong> they created laws. Stories <strong>of</strong> the Dreamtime are h<strong>and</strong>ed down from generation to generation <strong>and</strong><br />

are integral to Indigenous culture. The maintenance <strong>and</strong> telling <strong>of</strong> Dreamtime stories can be through dance, music,<br />

story <strong>and</strong> visual art.<br />

In contrast to the Dreamtime, which deals with ancestral history, ‘oral history’ is a term that refers to more<br />

recent events in living memory. Both the Dreaming <strong>and</strong> oral history feature strongly in contemporary Indigenous art<br />

practices.<br />

a. Graham Taylor’s Mission Boy is about a mission where he stayed in the 1960s. Many young Indigenous<br />

Australians were removed to missions in an effort to assimilate them. Taylor’s painting tells his own story as<br />

a boy being punished after trying to run away from the mission.<br />

b. George Dangi’s Wagilag Story is a figurative work set in the Dreamtime when two sisters travelled through<br />

Arnhem L<strong>and</strong> creating customs.<br />

c. Harts Range Rodeo Rider by Dinni Kunoth Kemarre is a painted carving. Kemarre is showing us an<br />

everyday story with which he has great affinity. Aboriginal people have a strong connection with horses from<br />

pastoralist <strong>and</strong> stockmen times.<br />

d. Jean Baptiste Apuatimi’s Jirtaka (sawfish) is a bold painting <strong>of</strong> a series <strong>of</strong> fishbones. The artist is<br />

referencing both her family <strong>and</strong> the Dreamtime.<br />

Primary Years 4–6<br />

At the exhibition: Response & Analysis<br />

• Find the marks under the window in Graham Taylor’s painting. The marks show where he tried to escape from<br />

the mission.<br />

• Count how many figures there are in George Dangi’s painting.<br />

• What do the tall things in Jean Baptiste’s painting remind you <strong>of</strong> For the artist they are fishbones.<br />

• What is the difference between the two surfaces that George Dangi <strong>and</strong> Jean Baptiste have painted on<br />

Museum <strong>and</strong> Art Gallery Northern Territory www.magnt.nt.gov.au Conacher Street, Fannie Bay NT 0820<br />

7


25th NATSIAA Online Education Resource 2008<br />

At school or at home: Creating Art Ideas, <strong>Arts</strong> Skills & Processes<br />

• Collect some bones <strong>and</strong> draw them. Keep in mind government regulations concerning the collection <strong>of</strong> native<br />

species. Fish or chicken bones from your dinner are good.<br />

• Using a cartoon format create an artwork that tells a personal story.<br />

• Using collage as a technique make an artwork about rodeos.<br />

• Use found materials to create a sculptural form <strong>of</strong> an animal.<br />

Middle Years 7–9<br />

At the exhibition: Response & Analysis, <strong>Arts</strong> in Context<br />

• Read the wall label for George Dangi’s painting to find out more about the Dreamtime story it depicts.<br />

• From the four works in this section choose the one you prefer <strong>and</strong> share your opinion.<br />

• Identify female artists in the NATSIAA exhibition. What is the ratio <strong>of</strong> male to female artists<br />

• Find examples <strong>of</strong> artworks that deal with ancient Dreamtime stories <strong>and</strong> with everyday stories.<br />

At school or at home: Creating Art Ideas, <strong>Arts</strong> Skills & Processes<br />

• Explore art-making by carving into wood; this will need to be a planned <strong>and</strong> supervised activity. Look at Dinni<br />

Kunoth Kemarre for inspiration.<br />

• Research <strong>and</strong> find other cultures that have parallel stories to the Dreamtime, expressing the ‘time before<br />

time when all things were created’. Noah’s Ark is a good example from Christian mythology.<br />

• Choose <strong>and</strong> research a Dreamtime story in depth.<br />

• Looking at Graham Taylor’s painting you can see he has made marks to show where he tried to escape. Using<br />

this idea create marks that show how you might escape from something.<br />

Museum <strong>and</strong> Art Gallery Northern Territory www.magnt.nt.gov.au Conacher Street, Fannie Bay NT 0820<br />

8


25th NATSIAA Online Education Resource 2008<br />

Politics / New Histories<br />

Most art from around the world can be seen as a commentary on society. Art historians look to art for insight into<br />

past societies. Some artists chose to use their art specifically for social commentary <strong>and</strong> this art can be critiqued<br />

as political art. Indigenous Australians are affected by many new issues that have arisen since the European arrival<br />

in Australian. These issues can be referred to as ‘new histories’ <strong>and</strong> include degradation <strong>of</strong> tribal structures, loss <strong>of</strong><br />

language, environmental damage, l<strong>and</strong>-rights, stolen generations, the impact <strong>of</strong> Western diseases, <strong>and</strong> deaths<br />

in custody.<br />

a. Bindi Cole’s How to be a Domestic Goddess is from a series <strong>of</strong> photographic works capturing the<br />

transformation <strong>of</strong> a man to a drag queen. The subject <strong>of</strong> this work is identity.<br />

b. Untitled from the Psalm Singing Suite by artist Richard Bell uses the notions <strong>of</strong> pop art to create a<br />

direct political message in response to events on Palm Isl<strong>and</strong>, Queensl<strong>and</strong>, in 2004.<br />

c. Suzy Evans has made an installation called Bengerang comprising about 60 posts. The artist is interested<br />

in the notion <strong>of</strong> the outlaw such as Ned Kelly or Robin Hood. Here she has placed the Aboriginal as outlaw<br />

amongst many.<br />

d. Danie Mellor’s Exotic lies <strong>and</strong> Sacred ties … is an installation about the colonising <strong>of</strong> Australia by<br />

Europeans in the 18th century <strong>and</strong> the associated issues. Mellor’s work employees a variety <strong>of</strong> techniques<br />

<strong>and</strong> references; it is on one level very funny <strong>and</strong> on another very serious.<br />

Primary Years 4–6<br />

At the exhibition: Response & Analysis<br />

• What is the full title <strong>of</strong> Danie Mellor’s artwork<br />

• What type <strong>of</strong> art style has influenced Richard Bell<br />

• Describe similarities between Danie Mellor’s <strong>and</strong> Suzy Evans’ artworks.<br />

• Can you find the Ned Kelly in Suzy Evans’ work (I can’t.)<br />

At school or at home: Creating Art Ideas, <strong>Arts</strong> Skills & Processes<br />

• Find out who Ned Kelly was.<br />

• Create an artwork that is an installation; remember it does not have to be massive to be successful.<br />

• Richard Bell’s style is strongly influenced by pop art. Use this art style to create your own artwork.<br />

• Explore cardboard as a material from which to make art.<br />

Museum <strong>and</strong> Art Gallery Northern Territory www.magnt.nt.gov.au Conacher Street, Fannie Bay NT 0820<br />

9


25th NATSIAA Online Education Resource 2008<br />

Middle Years 7–9<br />

At the exhibition: Response & Analysis, <strong>Arts</strong> in Context<br />

• Identify the various materials in Danie Mellor’s installation.<br />

• From the four examples above match the theme <strong>of</strong> the work from the following choices: deaths in custody,<br />

drought, colonisation <strong>and</strong> gender.<br />

• Identify other artworks in the exhibition that have a clear political message.<br />

• Bindi Cole’s photograph is a good example <strong>of</strong> a contemporary Indigenous artwork that uses a non-traditional<br />

subject <strong>and</strong> techniques. Find other contemporary artworks in the exhibition.<br />

At school or at home: Creating Art Ideas, <strong>Arts</strong> Skills & Processes<br />

• Both Suzy Evans <strong>and</strong> Danie Mellor have created installations. Write a definition <strong>of</strong> ‘installation art’.<br />

• Research the story behind Richard Bell’s painting. Here is a clue … Palm Isl<strong>and</strong>, November 2004.<br />

• Choose a political issue that is important to you <strong>and</strong> create an artwork that highlights the issue.<br />

• Choose an artwork you relate to aesthetically <strong>and</strong> create an artwork in a similar style <strong>and</strong> technique.<br />

Museum <strong>and</strong> Art Gallery Northern Territory www.magnt.nt.gov.au Conacher Street, Fannie Bay NT 0820<br />

10


25th NATSIAA Online Education Resource 2008<br />

SILVER JUBILEE<br />

telstra national aboriginal & torres strait isl<strong>and</strong>er<br />

<strong>ART</strong> <strong>AWARD</strong><br />

images<br />

Museum <strong>and</strong> Art Gallery Northern Territory www.magnt.nt.gov.au Conacher Street, Fannie Bay NT 0820<br />

11


25th NATSIAA Online Education Resource 2008<br />

Mortuary <strong>and</strong> murder<br />

a<br />

b<br />

c<br />

d<br />

Museum <strong>and</strong> Art Gallery Northern Territory www.magnt.nt.gov.au Conacher Street, Fannie Bay NT 0820<br />

12


25th NATSIAA Online Education Resource 2008<br />

Caring for Country / Back to Country<br />

a<br />

b<br />

c<br />

d<br />

Museum <strong>and</strong> Art Gallery Northern Territory www.magnt.nt.gov.au Conacher Street, Fannie Bay NT 0820<br />

13


25th NATSIAA Online Education Resource 2008<br />

Oral History / Dreaming<br />

a<br />

b<br />

c<br />

d<br />

Museum <strong>and</strong> Art Gallery Northern Territory www.magnt.nt.gov.au Conacher Street, Fannie Bay NT 0820<br />

14


25th NATSIAA Online Education Resource 2008<br />

Policies / New Histories<br />

a<br />

b<br />

c<br />

d<br />

Museum <strong>and</strong> Art Gallery Northern Territory www.magnt.nt.gov.au Conacher Street, Fannie Bay NT 0820<br />

15

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!