Mind Chatter #165 (October, 2006) (PDF) - Centerpoint Research ...
Mind Chatter #165 (October, 2006) (PDF) - Centerpoint Research ...
Mind Chatter #165 (October, 2006) (PDF) - Centerpoint Research ...
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
INCLUDES:<br />
THIS MONTH’S<br />
MINDQUOTES<br />
GLOWING<br />
TESTIMONIAL<br />
OF THE MONTH<br />
SPECIAL<br />
ANNOUNCEMENTS<br />
ISSUE <strong>#165</strong> OCTOBER <strong>2006</strong><br />
FEATURE ARTICLE<br />
HOW TO END<br />
SUFFERING<br />
BY BILL HARRIS<br />
BOOK REVIEW<br />
GAMES PEOPLE PLAY<br />
BY ERIC BERNE, M.D.<br />
REVIEW BY MARC GILSON
OCTOBER <strong>2006</strong><br />
Welcome to Issue <strong>#165</strong> of MIND CHATTER<br />
<strong>Mind</strong> <strong>Chatter</strong> is published once a month,<br />
on or about the 16th of each month.<br />
Please send <strong>Mind</strong> <strong>Chatter</strong> to a friend, and please send us<br />
your questions, comments, and suggestions.<br />
03 MINDQUOTES<br />
Short quotes from various sources<br />
offering succinct nuggets of wisdom<br />
04 RECOMMENDATIONS<br />
A few recommendations to benefit you<br />
07 ANNOUNCEMENTS<br />
Important <strong>Centerpoint</strong>e Announcements<br />
08 HOW TO END SUFFERING<br />
By Bill Harris, Director<br />
15 Q&A SECTION<br />
Bill answers participant questions!<br />
17 BOOK REVIEW<br />
Games People Play<br />
by Eric Berne, M.D.<br />
Review by Marc Gilson<br />
MIND CHATTER contains articles about:<br />
2 MINDCHATTER <strong>October</strong> <strong>2006</strong><br />
»<br />
»<br />
»<br />
»<br />
»<br />
How you create your life—and how you<br />
can stop unconsciously creating<br />
experiences and outcomes you do not<br />
want, and instead begin to create<br />
exactly what you do want<br />
Personal and spiritual growth in general<br />
Meditation (high- and low-tech)<br />
Recovery from emotional trauma<br />
Pretty much any other subject I get<br />
excited about and want to write about.<br />
After all, it’s my company and my<br />
newsletter, and I can do whatever<br />
I want with it. So there.
MINDQUOTES<br />
One does evil enough when<br />
one does nothing good.<br />
Your vision will become clear<br />
only when you look into your<br />
heart. Who looks outside,<br />
dreams. Who looks inside,<br />
awakens.<br />
—Carl Jung<br />
—German Proverb<br />
There are times when a man<br />
should be content with what<br />
he has but never with what<br />
he is.<br />
When a man finds no peace<br />
within himself, it is useless to<br />
seek it elsewhere.<br />
—William George Jordan<br />
—L. A. Rouchefolicauld<br />
MINDCHATTER <strong>October</strong> <strong>2006</strong><br />
3
Recommendations that may benefit you<br />
» BY BILL HARRIS<br />
Live long and prosper!<br />
Unless youve been living in a cave lately,<br />
you must have seen some of the recent news about<br />
the health benefits of meditation.<br />
IT’S EVERYWHERE...<br />
An article published in the American Heart Association<br />
journal, Stroke, recently reported that meditation can<br />
reduce cholesterol buildup and the associated risk of heart<br />
attack and stroke.<br />
And another study of the elderly found that meditation<br />
actually added years to their lives.<br />
The National Institutes of Health reports that regular<br />
meditation reduces chronic pain, anxiety, high blood pressure,<br />
cholesterol, and cortisol (sometimes called the “stress<br />
hormone”) production.<br />
A University of Wisconsin-Madison study discovered<br />
meditation boosts brain function and the immune system.<br />
A recent issue of the American Journal of Hypertension<br />
featured the results of a study showing a significant lowering<br />
of blood pressure in a group of meditators compared<br />
to a control group of people who didn’t meditate. The<br />
study also reported a 23% decrease in usage of antihypertensive<br />
drugs between the group of meditators and the<br />
other group.<br />
A Harvard study also concluded that regular meditation<br />
can reduce pain, lower blood pressure, and cut production<br />
of the stress hormone, cortisol.<br />
The most recent study by The American Heart Association<br />
shows heart and artery health improved 69 percent in<br />
test groups practicing meditation.<br />
AND THIS IS JUST THE BEGINNING.<br />
Practically every time you turn around there’s another<br />
study documenting and supporting fantastic health and<br />
wellness benefits of meditation.<br />
So, what’s the quickest way to actually achieve these<br />
amazing benefits<br />
If there’s a downside to meditation it’s this... Traditional<br />
meditation can take years, even decades to master.<br />
THE HOLOSYNC SOLUTION CHANGES ALL THAT.<br />
Holosync uses advanced scientific technology to induce<br />
deep states of meditation virtually at the push of a button.<br />
Most regular users of Holosync report fabulous results in<br />
weeks rather than years.<br />
Try Holosync for yourself—for FREE!<br />
Visit http://www.centerpointe.com/ to get a FREE<br />
Holosync demo CD so you can see for yourself how this<br />
powerful technology can improve your life.<br />
Here’s an even better idea. Go ahead and order Awakening<br />
Prologue (the first level of The Holosync Solution) and<br />
get started with the real thing.<br />
With our One-Year 100% Iron-Clad Guarantee, you<br />
can do so with no risk whatsoever.<br />
Use Holosync for up to a full year and enjoy all the powerful<br />
and lasting benefits this kind of meditation brings<br />
you. And if you decide that Holosync isn’t everything we<br />
promise, simply let us know and you can return it for a<br />
full refund. It’s just that simple.<br />
If you have any interest at all in increased health and<br />
vigor, increased longevity, lower blood pressure, peace of<br />
mind, and all the other great benefits of meditation, at<br />
least give Holosync a try.<br />
Remember you can get a FREE demo CD by going to<br />
http://www.centerpointe.com/<br />
And to learn all about the science behind Holosync,<br />
check out our extensive articles section here:<br />
http://www.centerpointe.com/about/articles.php<br />
4 MINDCHATTER <strong>October</strong> <strong>2006</strong>
Recommendations that may benefit you<br />
» BY BILL HARRIS<br />
Would you have lunch<br />
with me next week<br />
I’d like you to join me in Boulder, Colorado next week<br />
for an amazing learning experience. In addition to what<br />
you’ll learn, I want to meet you in person...and even have<br />
a meal with you.<br />
But the real benefit of joining me in Boulder will be<br />
what you’ll learn about yourself and other people, about<br />
your own development as a human being, and about how<br />
the world works.<br />
You’ll learn an elegant and effective new way of seeing<br />
society, the craziness of the world situation...<br />
...AND, YOUR OWN GROWTH PROCESS<br />
This “new way” of seeing things will give you an incredible<br />
clarity about where you are, how and why you’re creating<br />
your life the way you are, and what to do next.<br />
When I learned this information, and began to apply it<br />
to my life, it changed everything.<br />
I know it will do the same for you.<br />
You’ll learn WHY people behave the way they do (in<br />
fact, why YOU behave the way you do). You’ll learn why<br />
certain things are crucially important to you, while at the<br />
same time, for some inexplicable reason...<br />
...SOMETHING COMPLETELY DIFFERENT SEEMS<br />
TO BE IMPORTANT TO OTHER PEOPLE!<br />
Bottom line, you’ll learn what many people believe to<br />
be the most clear and elegant model of human development<br />
ever conceived. I know that when I learned this<br />
model, it completely changed the way I see everything in<br />
my life, inside and out.<br />
I’ve written before about Spiral Dynamics, a developmental<br />
theory of values that explains so much about life,<br />
both societal and personal. I know you will benefit by<br />
knowing about Spiral Dynamics and understanding how it<br />
affects your life. In fact, a lot of what the great philosopher<br />
and writer Ken Wilber teaches is based on Spiral Dynamics<br />
and other similar developmental models.<br />
Though I will speak extensively (info below) this is<br />
your chance to learn about Spiral Dynamics from Dr.<br />
Don Beck, the master of Spiral Dynamics. After Dr. Beck<br />
teaches you the basics, I will speak about the connection<br />
between Spiral Dynamics and Holosync, enlightenment,<br />
mastery of your mind and what you create with it, and...<br />
...THE PROCESS OF SPIRITUAL<br />
DEVELOPMENT IN GENERAL<br />
What Dr. Beck and I will say will give you a new clarity<br />
about yourself and what you are going through in your<br />
growth. You’ll see things in a whole new way, and will<br />
develop a new clarity about your life, what it means, where<br />
you’re going, and what to do next.<br />
Best of all, I’ve convinced Dr. Beck to give anyone from<br />
<strong>Centerpoint</strong>e a HUGE discount for this training. But first,<br />
let me tell you a little bit about what you’ll learn:<br />
UNDERSTANDING SPIRAL DYNAMICS<br />
WILL ALLOW YOU TO:<br />
* Determine the most highly valued criteria of an individual<br />
or social group (if you know what is important<br />
to others, you can better connect with them, persuade<br />
them, or help them,)...<br />
* Know what drives their thinking and behavior (again,<br />
allowing you to be more effective in dealing with them)...<br />
* Know how to communicate with other people,<br />
manage them, help them, or defend yourself from them<br />
* Understand your own motives, actions, and personal<br />
MINDCHATTER <strong>October</strong> <strong>2006</strong><br />
5
Have lunch with me continued...<br />
evolution (the more you are<br />
aware of why you are doing<br />
things, the faster you will grow,<br />
and the more you will be in<br />
charge of creating what you<br />
want)...<br />
* Understand the real driving<br />
force between national<br />
and international conflicts<br />
that seem to be about religion,<br />
class, gender, politics, economics,<br />
nationalism, and other common distinctions<br />
(suddenly the muddled and complex world<br />
situation will make perfect sense to you)...<br />
* Understand why current attempts to solve these<br />
problems don’t work and what really needs to be<br />
done to resolve them.<br />
The Spiral Dynamics Integral Level One Certification<br />
Course, taught by Dr. Beck, is <strong>October</strong> 23-25. That will be<br />
followed by my part of the program, The Spiral Dynamics<br />
Level Two Personal Emergence Certification Course, of<br />
which I will teach one and a half days (there will be at least<br />
one other presenter).<br />
There’s more to tell than I have room for here, but I will<br />
tell you this: this training will blow your mind.<br />
Please, if you have any interest in Spiral Dynamics, or<br />
any interest in hearing how Spiral Dynamics and Holosync<br />
fit together, please...<br />
There’s much more I could tell you about what you’ll<br />
learn, but the Spiral Dynamics people have put it all in a<br />
web site for you. You can find out more by going to<br />
http://www.spiraldynamics.net/SDiBoulder/index.shtml<br />
Go check it out, and then sign up. Once you decide to<br />
attend, just download the registration<br />
form on the web page above, and return<br />
it to any of the addresses on the form<br />
(email attachment, fax, or regular mail).<br />
Be sure to write on the form that you<br />
are with <strong>Centerpoint</strong>e...<br />
...SO YOU CAN GET YOUR<br />
DISCOUNT<br />
When I arrive, we’ll get together and<br />
decide when and where we can meet as a<br />
group and have a meal together.<br />
This is going to be a very exciting event, and I look<br />
forward to seeing you there. Please, right now, while you’re<br />
thinking about it, check out the web site and register. The<br />
number of seats is limited, especially at this price, so please<br />
sign up today.<br />
I look forward to our lunch together.<br />
Be well.<br />
...FIGURE OUT A WAY TO BE THERE<br />
So, how big is the discount Dr. Beck is offering, you ask<br />
Other attendees will be paying $995 for the first 3-days of<br />
the training, and $850.00 for the second 3 days--$1845.00<br />
total. If these other people attend both parts, they pay<br />
$1,600.00--a bit of a discount.<br />
You, however, as a <strong>Centerpoint</strong>e participant, receive a<br />
much better deal. If you attend both the Level One Certification<br />
and the Level Two Emergence Certification, you<br />
can attend both parts...<br />
...FOR JUST $1200!<br />
And, as I said, while you’re there, I was thinking that<br />
we’d get all the <strong>Centerpoint</strong>e attendees together and go out<br />
to lunch or dinner together so we can talk about what WE<br />
like to talk about, and get to know each other better.<br />
PS: Even if you don’t think you can go, please go check<br />
out the link: http://www.spiraldynamics.net/SDiBoulder/<br />
index.shtml<br />
Find out more:<br />
http://www.spiraldynamics.net/<br />
SDiBoulder/index.shtml<br />
6 MINDCHATTER <strong>October</strong> <strong>2006</strong>
Recommendations that may benefit you<br />
» BY BILL HARRIS<br />
Michael Stillwater Launches<br />
International Power of Song Tour<br />
Award-winning singer/songwriter Michael Stillwater (winner of the John Lennon songwriting contest) is a key staff member<br />
for <strong>Centerpoint</strong>e’s twice-yearly retreats and one of the most talented songwriters and performers on the planet (really). This<br />
month, Michael launches his Power of Song Tour as an opportunity to inspire individuals and communities in the healing<br />
power of music and spirit.<br />
Because I’ve seen Michael in action for the past twelve years at <strong>Centerpoint</strong>e retreats, I can tell you that his music is<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
The P o w e r<br />
of S o n g Tour<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
Autumn/Winter Schedule<br />
Oct. 15 Asheville, NC Jubilee Community<br />
Oct. 22 Asheville, NC Unity Center<br />
Nov. 1 Seattle, WA Unity of Seattle<br />
Nov. 5 Portland, OR (see website)<br />
Nov. 10-12 Santa Cruz, CA Pacific Cultural Center<br />
Nov. 17-18 Auburn, CA Ahmbiance Center<br />
Nov 19 Petaluma, CA The Barn<br />
Nov. 24 Encinitas, CA (see website)<br />
Nov. 25-26 San Diego, CA MidTown Community<br />
Dec. 3 Ojai, CA SoulCenter<br />
Dec. 9-10 Pasadena, CA Celebration of Oneness<br />
Dec. 12 Zurich Grossmunster Cathedral<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
spellbinging (not to mention<br />
entrancing, heart-opening, and<br />
awe-inspiring). In fact, at the retreats<br />
he composes songs on the spot that<br />
sound as if they took months to<br />
create. He has the ability to help<br />
people touch the deepest parts of<br />
themselves with his music and his<br />
presence. Ram Dass called Michael’s<br />
music “a touch of grace.”<br />
Tour dates span <strong>October</strong> to<br />
December <strong>2006</strong> and hit locations<br />
including North Carolina,<br />
Washington, Oregon, Northern and<br />
Southern California, and Switzerland.<br />
Hightlights of the tour include<br />
“ChantWave,” “SoulVoice: Release<br />
the Power of Your Voice,” and “The<br />
Art of Presence.”<br />
One notable stop along Michael’s<br />
tour is the Oceans of Gratitude<br />
Carribean Cruise sponsored by the<br />
group Go Gratitude. Other speakers<br />
include Dr. Masaru Emoto (Hidden<br />
Messages in Water) and Mary Manin<br />
Morrissey (Building Your Field of<br />
Dreams).<br />
For a detailed look at when Michael<br />
will bring the healing power of song<br />
to your neighborhood, go to:<br />
http://www.innerharmony.com/<br />
schedule.htm.<br />
MINDCHATTER <strong>October</strong> <strong>2006</strong><br />
7
Important Announcements<br />
» BY BILL HARRIS<br />
<strong>Centerpoint</strong>e Returns to Glen Ivy<br />
for Spring 2007 Retreat<br />
Though spaces filled quickly for <strong>Centerpoint</strong>es Fall retreat,<br />
there are still spots open for the Spring retreat at Glen Ivy<br />
Hot Springs and Spa in Corona, California<br />
If you have a big issue you’d like to<br />
resolve, if you’re in a transition period<br />
in your life and you just can’t seem to<br />
complete it, or if you just want to take<br />
things to a higher level—one where you<br />
understand more completely how you’re<br />
creating your life—please, do yourself a<br />
favor and come spend a week with me<br />
at Glen Ivy Hot Springs and Spa.<br />
I promise that you’ll have an<br />
incredible experience you’ll never<br />
forget.<br />
I tell people they’ll receive six months<br />
of growth in just 5 days at these<br />
retreats, but they keep improving every<br />
time, and people now tell me they’ve<br />
received much more than that.<br />
I tailor each retreat to the needs of<br />
the specific people who attend (which<br />
means YOU). My goal is to help you<br />
see the ways you may be unconsciously<br />
and unintentionally creating your<br />
internal and external reality, and how<br />
easy it actually is to consciously and<br />
intentionally create the life you want,<br />
both inside and out.<br />
This is your chance to make a<br />
big change, and to work with me<br />
personally.<br />
So visit this URL for more<br />
information:<br />
www.centerpointe.com/retreats<br />
And, I guarantee results! Here’s the<br />
guarantee: Attend the entire retreat.<br />
If by the end of the retreat you don’t<br />
think it was the most incredible growth<br />
experience you’ve ever had, just see me<br />
before you leave, and I’ll refund your<br />
tuition.<br />
You do not need to be a program<br />
participant to attend (though most<br />
people who attend are). (And if you’re<br />
not a program participant, why the<br />
heck aren’t you Quit procrastinating<br />
and join.)<br />
Visit this URL for more information:<br />
www.centerpointe.com/retreats<br />
Or, you can call retreat coordinator<br />
Katie Sparks at 503-906-6027 to learn<br />
more about <strong>Centerpoint</strong>e’s retreats.<br />
“So much more than I expected...Clear, concise, well-planned. Exceptionally<br />
qualified leaders and staff. The greatest investment I have ever made. I have<br />
attended many retreats and self-help studies. For 30 years I have studied<br />
human behavior. I have never received this much information and this<br />
amount of personal change in my life.”<br />
—Kerry<br />
8 MINDCHATTER <strong>October</strong> <strong>2006</strong>
Feature Article<br />
HOW TO END<br />
SUFFERING<br />
BY BILL HARRIS, DIRECTOR<br />
Over the last few months I’ve talked a lot<br />
about the question of who you really are. I’ve<br />
made a case that the separate self you’ve always<br />
thought of as being you is an illusion, and that<br />
the real you is nothing less than the entire going<br />
on of it all, that it’s all one big process, and<br />
you’re it. The separate self is a handy creation of<br />
the mind, but when you forget that you made<br />
it up and begin to think it’s real, there are a<br />
number of consequences, most of which are<br />
unpleasant.<br />
As long as you have a mind, it’s going to do what minds<br />
do. It’s going to create a map for you, and that map<br />
includes a map of who you are. In making that map, your<br />
mind is going to create thoughts and feelings and it’s going<br />
to arbitrarily divide the world into separate events and<br />
separate things. It’s also going to name those supposedly<br />
separate things and events, or create symbols of abstract<br />
ideas that represent them. Then, unfortunately, we forget<br />
that those names and symbols are not the same as what<br />
they represent.<br />
Your mind, then, creates an alternate reality, what’s<br />
really a map of reality. If you forget that it’s just a map,<br />
you become lost in it, lost in this alternate reality—made<br />
up of ideas, concepts, and symbols—created by the mind.<br />
Now that you do know about it, however, you have some<br />
choices to make. So, assuming you’re willing to do the<br />
work to get to the point where you can see the mind<br />
and what it creates for what it really is, and tap into the<br />
no-mind world, where you see the world, and yourself,<br />
without seeing it through the filter of the mind—what can<br />
you do<br />
A great deal of what I teach is about how to operate<br />
in the world of the mind and how to direct what the<br />
mind creates, instead of just experiencing what the mind<br />
automatically creates. Once you have some facility in<br />
directing the mind, it’s time to consider the bigger reality<br />
beyond that created by the mind—and to explore how to<br />
operate in both arenas simultaneously.<br />
In Eastern philosophy, there are whole schools of yoga<br />
dedicated to developing what are called sidhis, or powers.<br />
These powers are the result of learning how to direct the<br />
power of the mind—which is a quite substantial power—<br />
and in a sense this is what my first online course, The<br />
MINDCHATTER <strong>October</strong> <strong>2006</strong><br />
9
How to End Suffering continued...<br />
Internal Map of Reality Expander, is about.<br />
Once you learn how to direct the mind, and clearly see<br />
how the mind creates your reality, it hits you that if the<br />
mind can be directed in such a way that it can create an<br />
infinite number of possible realities, then what is being<br />
created can’t be THE reality. What, then, is THE reality<br />
What, you begin to wonder, is behind, and fundamental<br />
to, all the possible realities created by the mind<br />
At this point you might begin to realize that if you<br />
could get the mind out of the way, perhaps you could see<br />
what is behind it. My method for this is meditation, and<br />
particularly Holosync® meditation, but this is, of course,<br />
not the only way to accomplish this. Personally, having<br />
tried most of them, I think Holosync is more powerful<br />
and also faster, but that’s just me.<br />
In addition, most of these methods, including Holosync,<br />
have many other benefits that affect the world created by<br />
the mind, such as improved mental health, better mental<br />
abilities, greater well-being, and so on.<br />
If you haven’t done the work involved to find out how<br />
your mind creates your reality, or the work involved<br />
to quiet the mind so as to look beyond it, then a lot of<br />
this is just theory. But as you do the work, you begin to<br />
understand, on an experiential level, the truth of what I’m<br />
saying.<br />
(By the way, as you study spiritual principles, please<br />
don’t believe anything anyone else tells you. Instead, FIND<br />
OUT for yourself by doing the necessary spiritual practice.<br />
Knowing intellectually does you no good. You must eat<br />
the strawberry to know how it tastes.)<br />
This leads me to what I call my Nine Principles for<br />
Conscious Living, a description of how to live in the world<br />
of the mind, while also being aware of the no-mind reality.<br />
For the next several articles, I’m going to take you through<br />
these Nine Principles in great depth.<br />
These principles are, in a way, like different facets of<br />
the same diamond, different ways of coming at the same<br />
thing from different perspectives. You’ll see how each<br />
principle seems to flow into the next one, and how they’re<br />
simultaneously the same principle, yet also different. Those<br />
of you who’ve been to a <strong>Centerpoint</strong>e retreat, or who have<br />
heard my talks on CD from a <strong>Centerpoint</strong>e retreat have<br />
had an introduction to these principles, but now we’re<br />
going to go into them much more deeply.<br />
The first principle is Let Whatever Happens Be<br />
Okay. If you can get this one, pretty much everything<br />
falls into place. However, there are a lot of ways people<br />
misunderstand Let Whatever Happens Be Okay, and most<br />
of them have to do with not understanding what I’ve been<br />
telling you over the last several articles—one reason why<br />
I’ve given you so much background before actually getting<br />
to these principles.<br />
THE THREE RULES<br />
There are three main rules that govern the world<br />
created by the mind. (Remember that the world created<br />
by the mind is a map of the “real” world, and as such it<br />
is a conceptual skeleton of the real world. Still, if used<br />
properly, this map can be very powerful and very useful.)<br />
The first rule is that all things created by the mind exist in<br />
time and therefore change and eventually pass away. In the<br />
world of the mind, even if you get what you want, you<br />
can’t hang onto it, because everything is always changing,<br />
coming into being and passing away.<br />
The second rule is that sometimes you don’t get what you<br />
want. And the third rule is that sometimes you get what you<br />
don’t want.<br />
These three rules are behind all suffering you create for<br />
yourself. They are another way of saying something I’ve<br />
said before—that there are consequences to creating a<br />
reality that denies the interconnectedness of everything<br />
and, instead, arbitrarily divides everything into separate<br />
things and events.<br />
Letting Whatever Happens Be Okay is one of two<br />
possible ways to approach these rules. Let’s look at the<br />
other way first. The other way is to resist these three rules,<br />
to fight against them. In previous articles I’ve called this<br />
way The Game of Black and White. Approaching life in this<br />
way means that when things change, as they always do in<br />
the world of the mind, or, when you get what you don’t<br />
want or don’t get what you do want, you don’t like it, and<br />
you resist.<br />
Of course if you knew that you were making up all those<br />
separate things and events, and that you were already the<br />
entire universe, the entire going on of it all, none of this<br />
would be necessary.<br />
But because you make up a world of separation, and<br />
because you resist what happens in that kind of world, you<br />
experience certain unpleasant emotions, and sometimes<br />
certain unpleasant physical symptoms.<br />
Sometimes you feel pushed to behave in certain ways,<br />
often with unpleasant consequences. You get angry, you<br />
become stressed, you become anxious, you become fearful.<br />
In some way, you’re attached to things being different<br />
than they really are, and you show it. This is like beating<br />
your head against a wall. Some aspect of the reality you’re<br />
creating is a certain way, but you want it to be different<br />
10 MINDCHATTER <strong>October</strong> <strong>2006</strong>
How to End Suffering continued...<br />
than it is, and you fume and fuss and suffer over the fact<br />
that it is what it is.<br />
The second method is to Let Whatever Happens Be<br />
Okay. In this method, you may prefer that things not<br />
change and pass away. You may prefer that you not get<br />
what you don’t want. You may prefer that you don’t fail to<br />
get what you do want. But when one of these three things<br />
happens (and they will) you don’t emotionally resist. You<br />
might take action to change what’s happening, or to keep<br />
it the same, if that’s possible, but you’re unattached to the<br />
outcome.<br />
INNER DIRECTED, OR OUTER DIRECTED<br />
In the first method, your internal feeling state, your<br />
happiness, your inner peace, are dependent on the<br />
outcome turning out a certain way. When you let<br />
whatever happens be okay, however, your internal state,<br />
your happiness and inner peace, are independent of the<br />
outcome, even though you may be taking action in order<br />
to create the outcome you want.<br />
One key to letting whatever happens be okay, then, is<br />
the decision that your state be inner-directed versus outerdirected,<br />
that you be in charge of whether or not your<br />
happiness and inner peace are tied to outer circumstances,<br />
or you decide to remain solidly peaceful and happy,<br />
regardless of what happens.<br />
This decision is independent of whether you do<br />
something to try to make things go the way you want, or<br />
just passively sit back and don’t do anything to influence<br />
events. Either way, you’ve already decided, “whatever<br />
happens, I remain happy and peaceful.”<br />
Buddhists have an interesting way of conveying this<br />
same idea. It’s said that when Buddha sat under the Bodhi<br />
tree and became enlightened, he then went to the Deer<br />
Park near Beneres and began to teach what he’d learned to<br />
the other ascetics he’d previously been hanging out with.<br />
These ascetics were serious meditators who were part of a<br />
tradition of detaching from the world of the mind through<br />
a process of asceticism, of depriving the body of food,<br />
shelter, sleep, or much of anything else, and the mind of<br />
any sort of stimulation. Buddha, after his enlightenment<br />
experience, thought there was an easier way, and began<br />
to teach them what have come to be known as The Four<br />
Noble Truths.<br />
WHY YOU SUFFER<br />
The first Noble Truth is a good one: all life is suffering—<br />
that is, when lived in a certain way. In fact, I already told<br />
you about the first Noble Truth when I told you the three<br />
rules of the world created by the mind: that all things are<br />
in time and eventually pass away, that you sometimes don’t<br />
get what you want, and that you sometimes get what you<br />
don’t want.<br />
These are the reasons why people who are caught in<br />
the world of the mind suffer. If you don’t get what you<br />
want, and you resist that this has happened, you suffer. If<br />
you get what you don’t want, and resist it, you also suffer.<br />
And even if you do get what you want, since everything<br />
changes and ultimately passes away, you suffer over<br />
that—if you resist.<br />
So what exactly is resistance Since resistance is<br />
something you do, what exactly are you doing when you<br />
resist Resistance is nothing more than making internal<br />
representations of what you do not want. This is the “how”<br />
of resistance. When you resist, you make internal pictures<br />
of, have internal dialog about, or in some other way make<br />
a mental representation of what you do not want.<br />
And, whenever you do this, you feel bad in some<br />
way—in other words, you suffer.<br />
So the first Noble Truth is an encapsulated description<br />
of why humans suffer. If you don’t get Employee of the<br />
Month (i.e., you don’t get what you want), and you resist,<br />
you suffer. If you get fired as an employee (you get what<br />
you don’t want), and you resist that, you suffer. And even<br />
if you get Employee of the Month and lunch with the<br />
boss, next month it will be over, and if you resist that this,<br />
like all things, will pass away, you also suffer.<br />
The second Noble Truth speaks to the cause of<br />
suffering—that suffering is caused by clinging, or<br />
attachment. The other side of the coin is true, as well,<br />
that resistance or aversion causes suffering. In other<br />
words, wanting something you can’t have or not wanting<br />
something you do have are both the same thing, and both<br />
lead to suffering.<br />
Either way, you’re making internal representations of<br />
what you do not want. (Notice, by the way, that you must<br />
adopt the perspective of being separate in order to either<br />
cling to or not want something that seems to be outside of<br />
you.)<br />
ACT WITHOUT ATTACHMENT<br />
Again, clinging, resistance, and attachment are all<br />
descriptions of the emotional response you create and<br />
experience when you make internal representations of<br />
what you don’t want—what the Buddhists describe as<br />
clinging (or it’s polar opposite, aversion).<br />
You can, however, take action without clinging to, or<br />
being resistant to, the outcome. Having a preference might<br />
MINDCHATTER <strong>October</strong> <strong>2006</strong><br />
11
How to End Suffering continued...<br />
motivate you to act, but to do so in a way that doesn’t<br />
involve suffering (in other words, that doesn’t involve<br />
making internal representations of what you don’t want).<br />
I’ll make this distinction more clear in a moment. The<br />
second Noble Truth, then, is that the cause of suffering is<br />
attachment, clinging, resistance.<br />
The third Noble Truth states that suffering can be<br />
ended by giving up attachment. In a way, the principle of<br />
Letting Whatever Happens Be Okay is a statement of the<br />
third Noble Truth: if you let whatever happens be okay,<br />
if you are not attached to the outcome (or averse to the<br />
outcome), you don’t suffer.<br />
Let’s look at this third Noble Truth a little more closely.<br />
The third Noble Truth very clearly implies that suffering<br />
does not come from your circumstances; it comes from<br />
your clinging to circumstances being a certain way.<br />
This is a very weird idea to most people, because it<br />
really does look as if circumstances cause your feelings and<br />
reactions. Recall, however, my discussion of your Internal<br />
Map of Reality, where information comes in through<br />
your senses (i.e., you have an experience), you filter it in<br />
various ways (deleting, distorting, and generalizing what<br />
comes in), and then make an internal representation with<br />
whatever is left over.<br />
These internal representations directly lead to your<br />
internal states and your behaviors, and these lead to<br />
your results in life. Most people are aware of the original<br />
sensory experience, and then the resulting internal state or<br />
behavior. Everything in between (the filtering, the making<br />
of internal representations, and the resulting generation of<br />
internal states and external behaviors) happens out of most<br />
people’s awareness.<br />
Since this entire creative process is invisible to most<br />
people, it looks as if the outside event causes the state or<br />
behavior. In reality, how the brain processes the outside event<br />
creates your internal states and your behaviors. If your<br />
processing involves clinging or resistance (making internal<br />
representations of what you don’t want), you create<br />
suffering.<br />
IT’S NOT THE CIRCUMSTANCES,<br />
IT’S THE PROCESS<br />
Let’s say we have a factory. The raw materials—wood<br />
for instance—go in one door, and later, the completed<br />
products—let’s say, picnic tables—come out the other end.<br />
You’re watching from a hill overlooking the factory, and you<br />
see the wood going in one end, and the picnic tables coming<br />
out the other. The actual factory, however, is hidden by<br />
trees and what happens inside is invisible to you. You might<br />
think, then, that the wood somehow caused the picnic<br />
tables, even though it’s what went on inside the factory that<br />
caused the wood to become picnic tables. If the process<br />
inside the factory had been different the wood might have<br />
become doors, or porch swings, or baseball bats.<br />
So it’s how circumstances are processed in your mind that<br />
creates how you feel and behave in each moment. If you<br />
process experiences by clinging or resisting, you create<br />
suffering. If, like most people, the processing going on<br />
in your Internal Map of Reality is unconscious, if your<br />
internal processes are invisible to you, you’ll create the<br />
impression that circumstances caused your suffering (called<br />
“being a victim”).<br />
When Buddha says that suffering is caused by<br />
attachment, clinging (or resistance), he’s saying that when<br />
you process outside events in a certain way, you suffer.<br />
When you process outside events by resisting the fact that<br />
what is will eventually pass away, or by not wanting things<br />
to be the way they are, you suffer.<br />
Furthermore, if you give up clinging, attachment, and<br />
resistance, if you process what comes in through your<br />
senses in a different way, you end suffering.<br />
Be very clear, though, that suffering does not come from<br />
what is being resisted or by what you are attached to or<br />
resist—even though it might look that way—but rather<br />
from the resistance or the attachment itself.<br />
This is a key point. It means that no matter what the<br />
situation, you can process what is going on in a way that<br />
avoids suffering.<br />
“BUT I HAVE NO CHOICE!”<br />
Most people, though, make the assumption that certain<br />
situations are inherently suffering-inducing, and that there’s<br />
nothing you can do about it. If you have physical pain,<br />
they say, you have no choice but to resist it, and no choice<br />
but to suffer. If your child dies, you have no choice but to<br />
be attached to your child remaining alive, and no choice<br />
but to suffer. When you come to the end of your own<br />
life, you have no choice but to be attached to life, to resist<br />
death, and to suffer over the fact that death is coming.<br />
Please do not misunderstand. I’m not saying that it<br />
isn’t normal to grieve when a loved one dies, or that it<br />
isn’t “okay” to do so. Of course it is. What I am saying,<br />
however, is that whatever suffering you experience in such<br />
a situation is a choice, and that choice is created by what<br />
you do inside, not by the situation itself.<br />
You certainly might choose (assuming you are choosing,<br />
rather than just responding automatically) to grieve and<br />
feel bad. If one of my children died, I suspect I would<br />
12 MINDCHATTER <strong>October</strong> <strong>2006</strong>
How to End Suffering continued...<br />
grieve and feel bad for a time. However, I would also<br />
acknowledge that I am choosing to do this, and that<br />
another choice is available. And perhaps it’s possible to<br />
grieve without resistance, without attachment.<br />
Let’s look at this more closely. If you have physical pain,<br />
you have a choice. You can resist it, or let it be okay. The<br />
sensation of pain will be there either way, but the suffering<br />
is there only if you resist.<br />
THREE KINDS OF INTENSITY<br />
Pain is a type of kinesthetic intensity. But there are three<br />
kinds of intensity: positive intensity, the kind you like, as<br />
with an orgasm, for instance; negative intensity, the kind<br />
you don’t like, as with physical pain; and neutral intensity,<br />
where the experience is intense, but you don’t see it as<br />
either positive or negative (remember that the dividing line<br />
between all polar opposites, including positive or negative,<br />
is arbitrary, and that nothing is intrinsically positive or<br />
negative).<br />
So what is neutral intensity It’s what happens when<br />
something is intense and you neither cling to it nor resist<br />
it. Instead you take the perspective of the neutral watcher,<br />
what I call witnessing—something we’ll look at in great<br />
depth in a later article.<br />
There is, then, a tendency to cling to things that<br />
the mind sees as having positive intensity—to cling to<br />
pleasure—and to resist things that the mind sees as having<br />
negative intensity—to resist pain. In both cases, there<br />
could be suffering. With positive intensity, we might<br />
mourn the fact that the pleasure eventually ends. We make<br />
internal representations of what we don’t want (losing the<br />
pleasure), and this generates an unpleasant internal state.<br />
With negative intensity, we suffer because we resist it,<br />
again by making internal representations of what we don’t<br />
want, which again generates an unpleasant internal state.<br />
Try this the next time you’re in pain: watch the pain,<br />
without any agenda to make it stop, but just allowing it<br />
and being curious about the sensation. Instead of resisting,<br />
just watch. You will find that it will still be intense, but the<br />
intensity will not be the same as when you were resisting<br />
it. To the degree you can do this, suffering diminishes.<br />
You may not believe that this is possible, but it is. There<br />
was a very famous saint named Sri Ramakrishna, who<br />
died in about 1880. He was a wonderful, amazing being,<br />
but he’s probably remembered mostly because one of his<br />
followers, Swami Vivekananda, was the first Easterner to<br />
bring yoga and Eastern spirituality to the West.<br />
What’s interesting about Sri Ramakrishna in terms<br />
of this discussion is that he died of throat cancer. This<br />
was before the age of pain medication and modern<br />
medical care, and he was in India, too, where the level<br />
of medical care, even at 1880 standards probably wasn’t<br />
very advanced. As he reached the last stages of his illness,<br />
his followers noted that he was, as usual, blissed-out and<br />
happy—in fact, radiantly so.<br />
Ramakrishna was asked a number of times if there was<br />
pain, and he said that, yes, there certainly was, and that, in<br />
fact, it was very intense pain, as you might imagine. But<br />
he was not resisting it. He was established in the watcher<br />
state, this state of unity consciousness, where he was seeing<br />
everything as a play. The throat cancer was what was<br />
happening to his character, but the actor, however, the real<br />
Ramakrishna, was the one energy of the entire universe.<br />
That Ramakrishna was much more than his human body,<br />
and nothing could harm that Ramakrishna.<br />
So I offer this as an example of making pain into a<br />
neutral thing. And the secret to this is how you process<br />
what happens through your Internal Map of Reality,<br />
whether when you have pain you focus on what you want<br />
or what you don’t want.<br />
You might say, “Well, yes, he was an enlightened saint.<br />
I’m just an average person.” I have used this same method<br />
myself, though, and it works. I have used it at the dentist,<br />
and the more I watched the pain sensation with awareness<br />
and curiosity, the more the suffering dissolved.<br />
If your body is in pain, and you focus on “I’ve got<br />
to make this pain stop,” you have to make internal<br />
representations of “pain.” By focusing on pain, you<br />
create more pain, or at least more intensity of pain. If<br />
you focus on feeling good, your brain figures out a way<br />
to help you get it, which might be more pain-relieving<br />
neurochemicals, or it might be something else.<br />
Remember that the key here is that your brain cannot<br />
tell what your intention is. If you are focusing on<br />
something—which, remember, means making an internal<br />
representation of it—you brain always assumes you want it<br />
and that it should figure out how to create it.<br />
With a little practice, you can develop the ability to<br />
watch what is happening from the perspective of the<br />
witness, to watch without any agenda, to just watch with<br />
curiosity. When we have an unpleasant sensation, whether<br />
physical or emotional, we generally leap right to “I’ve<br />
got to make this stop.” We instantly begin to resist. This<br />
intensifies whatever it is we’re feeling.<br />
CURIOSITY IS YOUR FRIEND<br />
But what if you really were curious about what was<br />
happening You’ve probably never really watched yourself<br />
MINDCHATTER <strong>October</strong> <strong>2006</strong><br />
13
How to End Suffering continued...<br />
be angry, for instance, or watched yourself be anxious,<br />
or watched any other unpleasant state, in order to really<br />
notice what happens. Instead, you become lost in the<br />
feeling.<br />
Aren’t you just a little bit curious to know what is going<br />
on when you have these feelings<br />
When I was about 30, I had a girlfriend who used to<br />
spend the night from time to time. We once got into<br />
a ridiculous fight in the middle of the night over the<br />
blankets and who had more of them. The whole thing<br />
was very childish and we both ended up extremely angry.<br />
I finally went and sat in the living room all by myself, at<br />
about 3 AM, fuming.<br />
I’d been learning about what I now call witnessing,<br />
and after 20 minutes of sitting there consumed by my<br />
anger, I decided I would watch the anger instead of being<br />
immersed in resisting it. I tuned into my body, and<br />
noticed where I was feeling it, and just paid attention to<br />
the sensation.<br />
I also noticed the thoughts going through my mind.<br />
Emotions are really nothing more than sensations in your<br />
body, accompanied by certain thoughts, but I’d never<br />
really thought about it that way until that moment.<br />
This time, I allowed a part of me to sit back and notice<br />
all of this from an outside perspective. I notice how the<br />
thoughts happened, how they changed, and how that<br />
affected the way I felt. I noticed how the feelings in my<br />
body happened, where they were in my body, and how<br />
they changed and moved. To my surprise, I became<br />
fascinated by the whole thing. And, the next thing I knew,<br />
I noticed that the discomfort, the anger—everything—was<br />
gone.<br />
It was very obvious to me that the suffering I was<br />
experiencing was caused by my resistance, my clinging to<br />
my girlfriend being a certain way. And, I discovered that I<br />
couldn’t resist and watch at the same time. When I shifted<br />
to the perspective of the watcher, the resistance, and the<br />
suffering that it caused, fell away.<br />
YOU CAN’T WATCH AND RESIST<br />
AT THE SAME TIME<br />
There are a number of things at work here. One is what<br />
I just said: you can’t watch and resist at the same time. You<br />
can either watch or be attached, but not both. If you start<br />
to watch yourself being attached, to the degree that you<br />
really adopt the watcher perspective, the attachment falls<br />
away.<br />
Why does this happen Because resistance doesn’t serve<br />
you. It isn’t resourceful, and you can only do something<br />
that doesn’t serve you if you do it unconsciously. Watching<br />
is being conscious, so when you do something that doesn’t<br />
serve you consciously, with awareness, you find you can’t<br />
keep doing it.<br />
When I teach the principle of Let Whatever Happens Be<br />
Okay, the most typical response I get is that certain things<br />
are impossible to let be okay. If a person is dying, or their<br />
child is dying, or if a person is going deaf, or something<br />
“really bad” is happening, it isn’t reasonable to expect a<br />
person to let that be okay.<br />
My response is that I’m not telling anyone what to<br />
do, or what is reasonable to do, or what is easy to do.<br />
I’m simply saying that in any situation, to the degree<br />
you are able to emotionally let what is happening, or has<br />
happened, be okay, you avoid suffering.<br />
To the degree you’re attached to things being different<br />
than they are, to the degree that you make internal<br />
representations at such times of what you don’t want, you<br />
suffer. This is simply a natural law. Suffering is caused<br />
by clinging or resistance, and if you stop clinging and<br />
resisting, you end suffering. With practice, with intention,<br />
and with increased conscious awareness, you can do this.<br />
It’s a choice.<br />
If your child is dying, which has to be one of the most<br />
dreadful situations anyone could face, you may lose your<br />
child. That this consequence exists is part of the situation,<br />
and there’s no getting around it. If you add your resistance<br />
to the situation, though, you compound the consequences,<br />
because now you are adding the consequences of resistance<br />
to the consequences already built in to the situation. In<br />
any situation, there are consequences, and when you<br />
cling to that situation being a certain way, you add more<br />
consequences, and these consequences almost always<br />
involve suffering.<br />
Even in what you might consider a “good” situation, if<br />
you’re attached to it lasting forever, you’ll add suffering to<br />
the situation. In my book, Thresholds of the <strong>Mind</strong>, I told a<br />
story about my first ice cream cone. I was three years old,<br />
and I was in heaven until I had finished about half the<br />
ice cream, at which point I realized that it would soon be<br />
gone. I resisted this fact and focused on what I didn’t want,<br />
which caused me to suffer—and to enjoy the last half of<br />
the ice cream much less than I’d enjoyed the first half. I<br />
was noticing for the first time that all things are in time<br />
and pass away, and that resisting this fact causes suffering.<br />
I’m not saying that you should let whatever happens be<br />
okay. I’m saying that to the degree that you don’t, you will<br />
suffer. You are in charge of what you focus on, and you can<br />
14 MINDCHATTER <strong>October</strong> <strong>2006</strong>
How to End Suffering continued...<br />
decide to take the reins of your mind and focus on what<br />
you want, or adopt the witness perspective, or both. If you<br />
do, you’ll avoid suffering.<br />
DO I HAVE TO BE PASSIVE<br />
Sometimes people assume that I’m saying they should<br />
be detached, that they should numb themselves to what<br />
is happening, or ignore what’s happening—the equivalent<br />
of plugging your ears while you sing “La la la la la la<br />
la,” as loudly as you can. This, however, isn’t at all what<br />
I’m saying. The aware person is more alive, not less. She<br />
feels everything, and plays her part to the hilt. She plays,<br />
however, from the perspective of the watcher, without<br />
attachment to the outcome. The type of detachment<br />
that happens in psychosis, or schizophrenia, or multiple<br />
personality disorders, or even with more simple<br />
dissociation, is a way of being less aware, less conscious.<br />
The person who is letting whatever happens be okay is<br />
very conscious, and is feeling and experiencing everything.<br />
They’re just not attached to certain outcomes, they are not<br />
buying into the idea that to be happy and peaceful things<br />
have to happen a certain way.<br />
I’m also not saying that you should passively let<br />
whatever happens just roll over you. By all means, be<br />
proactive. Take action. I’m one of the most proactive,<br />
make-it-happen people you’ll ever meet. Certainly the<br />
Dalai Lama is a very proactive, action-oriented person.<br />
The truth is, you can have an outcome in mind, take<br />
action to do whatever you can to make it happen, and still<br />
be unattached to the outcome. You can prefer the outcome<br />
without being attached to it.<br />
If this doesn’t seem possible for you right now, don’t let<br />
that bother you. As you practice, and as you continue to<br />
use Holosync, it will get easier. Right now, you may be<br />
reacting to what happens around you unconsciously and<br />
automatically. The first step is to begin to notice those<br />
reactions, and at those times to step back and watch,<br />
and to focus on what you want, rather than just reacting<br />
automatically.<br />
As you begin to notice the consequences of your<br />
resistance, you’ll begin to that neither resistance nor<br />
focusing on what you don’t want serves you. As you<br />
become aware of this, you’ll find it more and more difficult<br />
to do. There are consequences to everything, and if you<br />
can consciously notice these consequences, you’ll naturally<br />
begin to choose the path with the better consequences.<br />
WHAT ABOUT MOTIVATION<br />
Letting Whatever Happens Be Okay is not about giving<br />
up, or losing your motivation. You do not have to be<br />
attached to an outcome to be motivated. In fact, being<br />
attached to an outcome often generates fear, which kills<br />
motivation.<br />
One of the main reasons people procrastinate or lose<br />
their motivation is that they picture a negative outcome,<br />
or they picture the negative part of getting the outcome—<br />
the work involved, for instance. Letting Whatever<br />
Happens Be Okay actually increases motivation, because<br />
you’re now doing whatever you’re doing for the fun of it.<br />
You picture having fun doing it, and getting it. You know<br />
right at the outset that it doesn’t matter, in terms of your<br />
happiness and inner peace, what happens.<br />
Ironically, when you Let Whatever Happens Be Okay,<br />
you’re much more likely to get what you want. This is one<br />
of the real ironies of personal and spiritual growth: The<br />
less attached you are, the more likely you are to get what<br />
you want.<br />
In the beginning years of <strong>Centerpoint</strong>e, I really wanted<br />
people to respect what I was doing. At <strong>Centerpoint</strong>e<br />
retreats I was very attached to wanting participants to like<br />
me and to think that I was helping them. Of course, being<br />
attached, I suffered whenever someone didn’t like me or<br />
didn’t think that I was helping them.<br />
As the years went by, and I became more conscious, I<br />
stopped being attached. Ironically, the less attached I was,<br />
the more positive feedback I received. But at the same<br />
time, I no longer needed it. I no longer cared, at least for<br />
myself. I was grateful that I was helping people, but on a<br />
personal level I didn’t need the adulation. And the less I<br />
needed it, the more I got.<br />
This is the way life works. The more you let what<br />
happens be okay, the more the universe lines up behind<br />
you to help you create whatever it is you want to create.<br />
On the other hand, the more attached you are, the more<br />
likely you are to find a way to screw things up.<br />
Every day you have many opportunities to let whatever<br />
happens be okay. So practice, and you will get better. At a<br />
certain point, you’ll find that letting whatever happens be<br />
okay has become a habit. At that point, everything will fall<br />
into place.<br />
Be Well.<br />
MINDCHATTER <strong>October</strong> <strong>2006</strong><br />
15
Q&A Section<br />
Q:<br />
Hi Bill<br />
I read your first article on [The Law of Attraction] and<br />
have been meaning to write for a while. I understand your<br />
position on compensation and that’s how you see the world<br />
- you have to give or invest yourself before receiving back.<br />
But there was no mention of morals in what you said. Is<br />
your view of compensation morally neutral So for example<br />
if a person was making money exploiting people, say people<br />
trafficking where the people are sold into prostitution - the<br />
traffickers are making an effort and being rewarded but<br />
their morals are at best questionable. But they might make<br />
a lot of money doing this so the Universe is morally neutral<br />
regarding compensation<br />
My second question is how much is possible. So if I take<br />
myself, as a 38-year-old, if I decided to put a lot of effort<br />
into remodelling my golf swing and developing myself<br />
physically and mentally, using Holosync among other<br />
things, eating as healthy a diet as possible, getting support<br />
where needed along with whatever else it takes, is it possible<br />
that I could reach the professional touring ranks at the top<br />
level<br />
Look forward to your reply.<br />
Regards,<br />
Steve<br />
A:<br />
Steve,<br />
Morals take care of themselves. In this, too, the<br />
universe’s books are always balanced.<br />
First of all, if you provide something that someone<br />
else thinks is valuable, they will pay you for it--even<br />
if it is bad for someone else. I’m not endorsing this.<br />
It’s just a fact. If you decided to kill people for money,<br />
some people might think your sevice is valuable and<br />
pay you for it. The person who is trading the money<br />
for the goods or services gets to decide whether or not<br />
it is valuable to them. If they think it is, they will trade<br />
money for it.<br />
However, there are consequences to everything. If<br />
you do something that lacks integrity--or worse--those<br />
consequences, in one way or another, will come back to<br />
you.<br />
I’m not saying you should do whatever you want,<br />
regardless of whether it is hurtful or dishonest, or<br />
whatever. I’m just saying that to get something you have<br />
to focus on it, take action, and provide value. While you<br />
do this, other consequences may also come into play,<br />
and certainly if you are creating suffering in some way,<br />
you will create suffering for yourself, along with other<br />
potential consequences. You may not know what they<br />
are, and to observe someone who is creating suffering<br />
you might not think they are paying, but I assure you,<br />
they are. Ultimately everything is balanced, and every<br />
action creates an equal reaction.<br />
Be well.<br />
Q:<br />
Hi Bill,<br />
Some Eastern philosophies bang the drum that we are<br />
all one, that everything is the same thing etc and you<br />
very much say the same thing. This to me is a matter of<br />
conception and comprehension. The Bhagavad Gita<br />
clearly states that each individual has always existed and<br />
will continue to exist as an individual. Any object is made<br />
up of atoms etc but each of these atoms are individuals.<br />
You could say that all the atoms are one....because they<br />
are the very makeup of the chair but yet they retain their<br />
individuality.<br />
It is the same with us, yes we are part of the very makeup<br />
16 MINDCHATTER <strong>October</strong> <strong>2006</strong>
Q&A Section<br />
of the universe but yet we are still individuals.<br />
God is the same, he is both the force and intelligence<br />
underpinning everything, including our own individuality<br />
and at the same time has both a form and personality. It’s<br />
like the two sides of the same coin. Some say that, the<br />
form and person of God is a creation of the intelligence or<br />
mind of God, but actually this isn’t so. God has always<br />
understood himself as an individual person and form,<br />
therefore the person and form is equal to the force and<br />
consciousness of God and are non different.<br />
We ourselves are also eternal conceptions in the “mind”<br />
of God and therefore we are individual souls eternally.<br />
Ultimately one could say that Time, Distance and<br />
Action are illusions and unreal but this is incorrect and<br />
meaningless because Eternal Time, Distance (dimension)<br />
and Action are Eternal realities of the consciousness of God<br />
and therefore are the only reality. Even this world often<br />
rejected as unreal is actually real. Of course it depends<br />
on what you mean by Unreal. This world and universe<br />
is temporary and not of the same nature as the Eternal<br />
Realms (being part of the marginal enery of God) but it is<br />
real. That which exists directly from the mind of God is<br />
Real; unless you ascribe the term “Unreal” to any temperory<br />
thing. Ultimately that which is unreal does not exist.<br />
Everything “unreal” exists in some way, even if this way is<br />
imagined. The term Unreal is not very helpful and has<br />
negative connotations to most people. Perhaps we should<br />
simply say that things are not as they seem.<br />
When I have finished my book on these matters, I will<br />
send you a copy.<br />
experience, while you are geting yours from what<br />
someone else has said, in this case in the Gita.<br />
I would suggest that instead of making this an<br />
intellectual issue, where references are cited, you go<br />
inside and do the work to find out whether or not what<br />
I am saying is really so.<br />
To find out that everything really is one big process,<br />
and that all divisions that create individual things and<br />
events are really made in the mind, but are found<br />
nowhere in the real word, all you need to do is look<br />
around. Name one “thing” that is not intimately<br />
in inextricabley connected to everything else in the<br />
universe. For the wave to think it is separate from the<br />
ocean is an illusion.<br />
Your description contains many premises, but<br />
throughout you assume separation. You are, of course,<br />
welcome to see things in any way you want. All I ask is<br />
that you find out what is real by doing the same work<br />
mystics have done, rather than reading their words,<br />
which can be misinterpreted--especially those that were<br />
written thousands of years ago, in another culture, and<br />
in another language.<br />
Be well.<br />
Regards<br />
Allan<br />
A:<br />
Allen,<br />
The difference between your way of figuring out what<br />
is so, and my way, is that mine comes from personal<br />
MINDCHATTER <strong>October</strong> <strong>2006</strong><br />
17
Book Review<br />
» BY MARC GILSON<br />
Games People Play<br />
By Eric Berne, M.D.<br />
Grove Press, 1964<br />
THIS MONTH’S REVIEW IS OF A CLASSIC<br />
and influential book on human interaction and<br />
psychology by Dr. Eric Berne. First published<br />
in 1964, Games People Play has sold over 5<br />
million copies and continues to spark a great deal of<br />
discussion, both by psychologists and lay people, about<br />
the nature of human communication and how even<br />
routine conversations reveal much about the underlying<br />
complexities of the human psyche.<br />
Berne’s premise is simple enough: life can be seen as a<br />
series of “transactions” between individuals and groups<br />
played out as games, with the stakes being what has become<br />
popularly termed “positive strokes.”<br />
There are literally dozens of games people play with one<br />
another. In Berne’s use of the term, a “game” is neither<br />
good or bad, fun or bothersome (though most of the<br />
games described do produce problematic or dysfunctional<br />
results). It is simply a model for understanding what we<br />
already intuitively know: that human communication is<br />
amazingly intricate and often rife with subtle reflections of<br />
our internal programming.<br />
Berne’s own definition:<br />
“A game is an ongoing series of complementary ulterior<br />
transactions progressing to a well-defined, predictable outcome.<br />
Descriptively, it is a recurring set of transactions... with a<br />
concealed motivation... or gimmick.”<br />
The more we can develop an understanding of the covert<br />
meanings behind these games, according to Berne, the<br />
better equipped we are to play healthier games, rather than<br />
those that keep us stuck in dysfunction.<br />
Games People Play has its basis in a psychoanalytic<br />
theory developed earlier by Berne called Transactional<br />
Analysis. Commonly called “TA,” it is a refined, though<br />
perhaps even more pragmatic, version of Freud’s triadic<br />
composition of the “Id,” “Ego,” and “Superego,” using<br />
instead three ego states called “The Parent,” “The Adult,”<br />
and “The Child.” The dynamics of communication are<br />
diagrammed in TA according to the various possible<br />
P<br />
A<br />
C<br />
PARENT EGO STATE<br />
Behaviours, thoughts and feelings<br />
copied from parents or<br />
parent figures<br />
ADULT EGO STATE<br />
Behaviours, thoughts and feelings<br />
which are direct responses to<br />
the here and now<br />
CHILD EGO STATE<br />
Behaviours, thoughts and feelings<br />
replayed from childhood<br />
FIGURE SHOWS THE THREE STATES<br />
REPRESENTED IN TRANSACTIONAL ANALYSIS<br />
configurations. For example, in certain circumstances,<br />
Bob’s “Parent” may be communicating to Jim’s “Child.”<br />
Or, Mary’s “Adult” may be attempting to communicate to<br />
Carol’s “Parent.” The theory itself is far more sophisticated<br />
18 MINDCHATTER <strong>October</strong> <strong>2006</strong>
Book Review continued...<br />
than can be described here, but it serves as a solid backbone<br />
for the ideas presented in Games People Play. (Those of you<br />
who have taken Life Principles Integration course #3 “The<br />
Success Solution,” will note that Bill Harris uses aspects<br />
of Berne’s Transactional Analysis in the course lesson<br />
materials. For more info, visit www.centerpointe.com/life/<br />
preview)<br />
Roughly the first third of Games People Play is devoted to<br />
an introduction to Transactional Analysis and other aspects<br />
that serve as a backdrop to understanding how these games<br />
work. The remainder of the book focuses on the games<br />
themselves -- over thirty of them<br />
-- and on a deeper analysis of<br />
the significance of the games<br />
and those who play them. (It<br />
should be mentioned that while<br />
a thorough understanding of TA<br />
is not completely necessary to<br />
understand the meanings of the<br />
games, Berne does present each<br />
game within the context of the<br />
TA model.)<br />
With allowances for the rather<br />
dated language of the book,<br />
Berne communicates his ideas<br />
lucidly, and most readers will find<br />
the material easy to read and digest. Games are presented<br />
with social scenarios as examples of how each one plays out.<br />
Reading the descriptions of the games is not only<br />
fascinating, but for many readers, challenging, as virtually<br />
everyone will notice various renditions of games they’ve<br />
managed to become good at playing in their own lives;<br />
games that may cause one to become sharply aware that<br />
their seemingly direct communication style really harbors<br />
a world of information about their internal agendas,<br />
programming, and even their upbringing. So although<br />
Games People Play is not a true “self-help” book by most<br />
conventional standards, it can serve as a powerful tool (or<br />
mirror) in the hands of those willing to explore their own<br />
relationships and sense of self through the games Berne<br />
presents.<br />
An example of one of the games Berne discusses is “I Am<br />
Only Trying To Help You.” This game is sometimes played<br />
between a therapist and client (but can be applied to other<br />
kinds of transactions as well). With “I Am Only Trying<br />
To Help You,” the underlying belief of the therapist is that<br />
people are ultimately ungrateful or disappointing. So as he<br />
or she offers advice or suggestions, the client returns with<br />
the news that the feedback was unhelpful or failed to result<br />
in the desired outcome. The therapist may offer another<br />
suggestion (while holding to the underlying belief), with<br />
the same result. As the therapist recognizes his or her<br />
own frustration and bewilderment arising (the “payoff,”<br />
according to Berne) the game is completed with the spoken<br />
or unspoken idea that, “I am only trying to help you.”<br />
Interestingly, many of the games are actually defined<br />
not so much by what is expressed or withheld but by what<br />
the individual playing the<br />
game is truly focused on.<br />
If you are a <strong>Centerpoint</strong>e<br />
If you would like to Participant you’ll likely<br />
read more about or notice that one thing most<br />
games have in common<br />
order this book visit:<br />
is that they’re engendered<br />
HTTP://WWW.AMAZON. on an unconscious level<br />
COM/EXEC/OBIDOS/<br />
and can only really<br />
ASIN/0345410033/CENTERmanifest<br />
when we remain<br />
POINTER-20<br />
unconscious of them.<br />
Berne has been criticized<br />
on occasion for presenting<br />
what, on the surface, might<br />
look like a rather cynical<br />
view of the human condition. That all our “transactions”<br />
are ultimately nothing more than clever attempts at<br />
manipulating or controlling circumstances, often at the<br />
expense of others, makes for an unsavory picture of who we<br />
really are and are striving to be. But Berne’s message allows<br />
for optimism:<br />
“For certain fortunate people there is something which<br />
transcends all classifications of behavior, and that is<br />
awareness; something which rises above the programming<br />
of the past, and that is spontaneity; and something that is<br />
more rewarding that games, and that is intimacy.”<br />
Readers will find Games People Play to be an original,<br />
insightful, and eye-opening discourse on the deeper<br />
dynamics of human communication. A must-read for any<br />
student of human nature.<br />
(For another fascinating book on Transactional Analysis,<br />
consider “Scripts People Live: Transactional Analysis of Life<br />
Scripts” by Claude M. Steiner)<br />
MINDCHATTER <strong>October</strong> <strong>2006</strong><br />
19