Toyota South Africa Motors (Pty) Ltd. - GKC Online
Toyota South Africa Motors (Pty) Ltd. - GKC Online
Toyota South Africa Motors (Pty) Ltd. - GKC Online
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
Best<br />
Practice<br />
Bulletin<br />
October 2002 vol.1<br />
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY<br />
CASE STUDY<br />
Art of<br />
Revitalization<br />
<strong>Toyota</strong> <strong>South</strong> <strong>Africa</strong><br />
<strong>Motors</strong> (<strong>Pty</strong>) <strong>Ltd</strong>.<br />
2
Best Practice Bulletin vol. 1<br />
Art of Revitalization<br />
With an economically unstable climate and stiff<br />
competition from German challengers, <strong>Toyota</strong><br />
<strong>South</strong> <strong>Africa</strong> <strong>Motors</strong> (<strong>Pty</strong>) <strong>Ltd</strong>. (TSAM) faces the<br />
challenge of revitalizing its business with the<br />
launch of the Next Generation (N/G) Corolla so<br />
that it may preserve its position as <strong>South</strong><br />
<strong>Africa</strong>’s leading automotive company.<br />
Visionaries at TSAM realized that companies<br />
that enjoy enduring success have a purpose and<br />
core values that remain fixed while their<br />
business strategies and practices adapt to a continually<br />
changing world.<br />
With that in mind, launch project leader,<br />
John Nagel, and members of TSAM’s Corolla<br />
Launch Committee sought to open new channels<br />
of communication between the various business<br />
silos by developing a synergistic methodology<br />
encompassing all processes . . . ultimately<br />
creating a unified “one voice” launch strategy to<br />
transcend the company’s traditional model of<br />
business management.<br />
■No Stranger to Challenge<br />
It was the end of the day and John Nagel watched as<br />
some of the last few cars left the company parking lot<br />
as he considered how he was going to do it. As the<br />
General Manager of Marketing Planning Passenger and<br />
CBU Vehicles with TSAM he was no stranger to<br />
challenge, but this seemed different somehow.<br />
1<br />
*Corolla Launch Committee<br />
It had been only a few hours since Dr. Johan van<br />
Zyl, the President & Chief Operating Officer of TSAM,<br />
had appointed him to manage the debut of the Corolla<br />
and told him that he wanted something special. Dr. van<br />
Zyl had just recently returned from the Sales EQ<br />
(Corolla Quality) meeting in Japan. There, he learned<br />
of oobeya(ooh-bay-yuh) 1 and witnessed examples from<br />
around the globe of successful Corolla launches. He<br />
grew determined that TSAM would, likewise, be worthy<br />
of global praise. Inspired by the idea of oobeya, Dr. van<br />
Zyl decided that the organization could be renewed by<br />
a culture of innovation. Looking beyond this vehicle<br />
launch, it seemed that this guiding principle could<br />
literally revolutionize the way TSAM does business . . .<br />
it could be “the catalyst for a new era.”<br />
<strong>South</strong> <strong>Africa</strong> is a middle-income, developing<br />
country with well-developed financial, legal,<br />
communications, energy, and transport sectors, a stock<br />
exchange that ranks among the ten largest in the<br />
world, an abundant supply of resources, and a modern<br />
infrastructure supporting an efficient distribution of<br />
goods to major urban centers throughout the region.<br />
* Left to right: L. Dodkins, C. Westray, C. Taylor, M. Herb, C. Jarrard, T.Ward, J. Nagel, M. Naidoo, G. Crompton, and P. van Deventer.<br />
Not shown here: C. Rheeder, J. Thompson, L. Phieffer, T. Cownley, M.Hughes, H.Higuchi, A. Falk, and C. Kruger.<br />
1. As part of the <strong>Toyota</strong> Way in Sales and Marketing, this concept connotes “taking down walls to build ‘knowledge teams.’” The method is designed<br />
to generate innovation in an environment that encourages the sharing of ideas across divisions and sections of the company.
However, growth has not been strong enough to trim<br />
the 30% unemployment rate and the daunting<br />
economic problems remaining from the apartheid era.<br />
Indeed, there are still deep problems associated with<br />
poverty and the lack of economic empowerment<br />
among disadvantaged groups.<br />
In the automobile market, total sales declined 6.6%<br />
in 1997 (vs. the previous year) alone due to radically<br />
increased interest rates and the commensurate decline<br />
of disposable income. The market has been recovering<br />
gradually as it has again grown to a total of 367<br />
thousand units in 2001. TSAM has been the number<br />
one automobile company in <strong>South</strong> <strong>Africa</strong> for 22 years<br />
and, even during the downturn in 1997, achieved an<br />
all-time recorded volume of 101,083 units (and<br />
resulting market share of 26.4%—Figure 1) owed to the<br />
outstanding success of the Current Generation (C/G)<br />
Corolla launch.<br />
However, due to the devaluation of the Rand2 (Figure 2) and increased price competitiveness created<br />
by the <strong>South</strong> <strong>Africa</strong>n CBU/parts export incentive<br />
[Figure 1] <strong>South</strong> <strong>Africa</strong>n Automotive Market Shares (1991–2001)<br />
Still a leader in the <strong>South</strong> <strong>Africa</strong>n market, <strong>Toyota</strong> is steadily losing<br />
market share.<br />
30<br />
25<br />
●<br />
●<br />
●<br />
●<br />
●<br />
●<br />
●<br />
●<br />
● ●<br />
●<br />
●<br />
▲<br />
<strong>Toyota</strong><br />
VW<br />
20<br />
15<br />
10<br />
5<br />
★<br />
▲<br />
■ ★<br />
▲● ■<br />
◆<br />
●<br />
★<br />
▲● ■<br />
◆<br />
●<br />
★<br />
▲<br />
■● ◆<br />
●<br />
▲★ ■<br />
●<br />
◆<br />
●<br />
★<br />
▲<br />
■<br />
◆●<br />
●<br />
▲★<br />
■<br />
◆<br />
●<br />
●<br />
▲★ ■<br />
●<br />
◆<br />
●<br />
▲★ ■<br />
◆● ●<br />
▲★ ■<br />
●<br />
◆<br />
●<br />
▲★<br />
■<br />
◆<br />
●<br />
●<br />
●<br />
■<br />
★<br />
●<br />
◆<br />
Nissan (& Fiat)<br />
Delta (Opel & Isuzu)<br />
Ford<br />
BMW<br />
Mercedes Benz<br />
0<br />
91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 00 01<br />
➡<br />
2. Local currency.<br />
3. The incentive program offset tariffs on imported units/parts for equally valued exports.<br />
case study of <strong>Toyota</strong> <strong>South</strong> <strong>Africa</strong> Motor (<strong>Pty</strong>) <strong>Ltd</strong>.<br />
program, MIDP3 , there was a decline in profits that<br />
gradually placed the company in a deficit.<br />
The importance of the N/G Corolla launch is<br />
highlighted by the fact that TSAM’s C/G Corolla,<br />
introduced in 1997, was actually sold elsewhere as<br />
the ’92 Corolla—<strong>South</strong> <strong>Africa</strong> missed an entire<br />
generation of the Corolla. This launch would signify<br />
<strong>South</strong> <strong>Africa</strong>’s joining the global launch of the<br />
Corolla. In addition, once the N/G Corolla was sold<br />
and produced in <strong>South</strong> <strong>Africa</strong>, TSAM would be able<br />
to export it to other countries. TSAM realized that<br />
the launch of the Corolla, if executed properly, could<br />
signal the revitalization of TSAM and a return<br />
to profitability.<br />
■Corolla as a “Catalyst For A New Era”<br />
Traditionally, vehicle launches in <strong>South</strong> <strong>Africa</strong> were<br />
held in two separate planning sessions with minimal<br />
integration between them. Team members worked in<br />
different silos and discussions were closer to being routine<br />
than comprehensive business meetings that would<br />
[Figure 2] The Falling Rand<br />
The rapid decline of the <strong>South</strong> <strong>Africa</strong>n Rand in 2001<br />
16.00<br />
15.00<br />
14.00<br />
13.00<br />
12.00<br />
11.00<br />
●<br />
●<br />
●<br />
● ● ● ●<br />
Rand/Yen<br />
●<br />
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec<br />
●<br />
●<br />
●<br />
●<br />
2
Best Practice Bulletin vol. 1<br />
Art of Revitalization<br />
generate new thinking. These discussions included:<br />
• A marketing workshop based on a product review<br />
and the strategy presented by each process<br />
• A marketing brief communicating the overall<br />
strategy<br />
• A launch committee covering the operational<br />
implementation<br />
There had not been any changes in TSAM policy<br />
related to vehicle launch procedures in some time<br />
and the possibility of innovation arising from crossdisciplinary<br />
collaboration was stifled by process leaders<br />
reluctant to allow this type of activity to flourish.<br />
It was clear that this environment would be hostile<br />
to planning any new approaches for the Corolla<br />
launch. To address this, John Nagel decided that he<br />
should make management goals a priority for his team<br />
and from the onset, base his personal aims on the<br />
following change management principles:<br />
• Establishing a sense of urgency<br />
• Forming a powerful coalition<br />
• Creating the vision<br />
• Empowering others to act on the vision<br />
• Consolidating improvements that produce even<br />
greater changes<br />
• Planning and creating short term wins<br />
• Institutionalizing the new approach<br />
A Sense of Urgency<br />
After determining these goals, Nagel set out to<br />
establish a sense of urgency right away. As he recalls,<br />
he “was trying to create a burning platform” and make<br />
the team understand that jumping to the next platform<br />
(or changing at this juncture) was critical to the<br />
4. Active Inertia—An organization’s tendency to follow established patterns of behavior.<br />
3<br />
company’s survival. His opening presentation to the<br />
team and the company was designed to make<br />
maintaining the “status quo seem more dangerous<br />
then launching into the unknown.” His presentation<br />
outlined the following reasons why changes had to<br />
be implemented:<br />
• “Success builds active inertia4 and active inertia<br />
builds failure”—as the long-term market leader,<br />
TSAM had not found it necessary to take a hard<br />
look at itself.<br />
• TSAM’s declining profitability<br />
• Declining dealer profitability<br />
• Declining <strong>Toyota</strong> dealer market share<br />
• Declining Corolla dealer market share<br />
A Powerful Coalition<br />
Next, he developed a powerful coalition by handpicking<br />
and motivating the appropriate individuals from<br />
each silo (Figure 3) and organizing them as a single<br />
working unit. He set about overcoming the “silo<br />
mentality” by putting together this 18-member team of<br />
individuals that had management experience and<br />
marketing ability, would voice their ideas, and were<br />
still “young at heart.”<br />
Once the team was formed, he planned an agenda<br />
to build the core concept for the team’s work. The<br />
phases for this work were:<br />
1. Gather all necessary information<br />
2. Develop a strategic concept<br />
3. Produce tactics to support the strategic concept<br />
The Vision<br />
This team’s vision was to “develop a shared commitment<br />
to excellent performance through renewal.” The
key to realizing this objective lay in the mission, which<br />
was “to make the 558N Corolla the most desirable<br />
vehicle in the market” through service from world-class<br />
people, a product that delivers value and innovation.<br />
Going forward, the plan would involve some critical<br />
steps, including:<br />
1. Realigning the strategy around the most profitable<br />
customers<br />
2. Clearly defining the positioning of the Corolla<br />
sedan and hatch<br />
3. Implementing a strategy that will help sustain<br />
vehicle model life<br />
4. Critically evaluating each and every aspect of the<br />
current launch process<br />
5. Developing a synergistic methodology encompass-<br />
[Figure 3]<br />
John Nagel’s team was made up of individuals from every aspect of the business.<br />
Dr. Van Zyl<br />
Process<br />
Owners:<br />
Division<br />
Heads<br />
Coordinator<br />
John Nagel<br />
Sales<br />
Silo<br />
Supply & Demand<br />
Marketing<br />
Product<br />
Dealers<br />
Parts and Accessories<br />
Service<br />
Customer Relations<br />
Financial Services<br />
TMC<br />
case study of <strong>Toyota</strong> <strong>South</strong> <strong>Africa</strong> Motor (<strong>Pty</strong>) <strong>Ltd</strong>.<br />
ing all processes—a “one voice strategy”<br />
Empowering Others<br />
One of Nagel’s major concerns was to motivate and<br />
convince the team that their strategy would be<br />
implemented and, moreover, guide the company in a<br />
new direction. This, it seemed to some team members,<br />
was a daunting task, indeed. Nevertheless, he managed<br />
to inspire them. He concluded that he would have to<br />
motivate people and provide consistent information<br />
sharing in order to transcend the silo mindset of the<br />
organization and find the team’s “one voice.” At a<br />
special off-site meeting in a country hotel an hour and<br />
a half hour from work, the members of this new crossdisciplinary<br />
team were welcomed with a sneak preview<br />
of the Corolla and participated in a blue-sky (or<br />
Sales Training Facilitator<br />
Vehicle Logistics<br />
National Advertising<br />
Concept Generation<br />
Product Project<br />
Coordination<br />
Dealer Launches<br />
Accessories<br />
Technical Training/<br />
Warranty Service<br />
CRM/Female Market<br />
Financial and Insurance<br />
Packages<br />
TMC Rep.<br />
Specialization<br />
Fleet/Car Rental/<br />
Government<br />
Promotions/Launches<br />
Project Control/Timing<br />
Dealer Rep.<br />
Parts/Service Plans<br />
Female Market PD&P<br />
4
Best Practice Bulletin vol. 1<br />
Art of Revitalization<br />
brainstorming) session designed to begin the journey<br />
toward the Personal Aims and begin a revolution.<br />
As he puts it, Nagel tried “at every opportunity . . .<br />
to emphasize the importance of the team’s output.” At<br />
the first meeting, he asked Dr. van Zyl to make a presentation<br />
to the team requesting their full support. He<br />
also wanted to emphasize that they should take this<br />
opportunity to grow and that they were “a special<br />
group of people that would be rewarded with career<br />
growth opportunities.” In addition, all major meetings<br />
were held off premises. The final strategy session was<br />
held for two days on a private game farm. “I wanted<br />
to be sure that the members enjoyed being part of the<br />
team,” he says.<br />
Once the team understood that their strategy<br />
would be implemented, the response was very positive.<br />
He remembers that he “had problems with one or two<br />
team members, but basically choosing the correct<br />
people made this task a lot easier.” Any dissent that he<br />
[Figure 4]<br />
Perceptions of the <strong>Toyota</strong> brand by focus group participants.<br />
5. <strong>Toyota</strong> Motor Marketing Europe<br />
6. National Marketing and Sales Company (renamed from Distributor)<br />
5<br />
Positive<br />
Negative<br />
Quality<br />
Reliability<br />
Durability<br />
Practical Emotional<br />
Qualities seen as<br />
important to Corolla<br />
drivers<br />
Boring<br />
Conservative<br />
encountered was extinguished as he spoke to<br />
individuals (and, in one case, took one overseas) to<br />
reiterate the importance of this particular launch.<br />
Getting information early and actually seeing the<br />
vehicle seemed to motivate the team a great deal. Both<br />
the sedan and the hatchback received positive reviews<br />
and this helped to build a solid foundation, as the<br />
members were able to actually sense what the vehicle<br />
looks and feels like. Most of the information available<br />
to the team was based on market research so, in Nagel’s<br />
opinion, they had, “a very good understanding of our<br />
customers and our competitors’ customers.” After their<br />
initial meeting, the members embarked on a rigorous<br />
data-gathering mission.<br />
Consolidating Improvements<br />
They immediately took the opportunity to attend<br />
TMME’s5 NMSC6 information sharing session and<br />
traveled to Japan to cover Corolla launch strategies<br />
employed by other countries and the Corolla<br />
[Figure 5]<br />
Results of the product clinic—on a rating scale of one to five,<br />
the Corolla scored very well against the competition and received the<br />
highest scores both Sedan and Hatchback categories.<br />
Sedan Hatchback<br />
Kyalami Test Track<br />
20th November<br />
Corolla<br />
1.6L<br />
Jetta<br />
1.6L<br />
Astra<br />
1.6L<br />
P166<br />
1.6L<br />
Corolla<br />
GT<br />
Golf<br />
GT<br />
Focus<br />
2.0L<br />
Interior comfort (Fr) 3.97 3.62 3.00 3.08 4.08 3.75 3.27<br />
Interior comfort (Rr) 3.95 3.81 3.02 2.91 4.16 3.69 3.49<br />
Visibility 3.75 3.50 3.28 3.25 3.95 3.78 2.96<br />
Acceleration 3.50 3.02 3.18 3.16 4.35 4.41 3.04<br />
Steering Feel 3.62 3.44 3.26 3.30 4.31 4.31 3.15<br />
Brake Feel 3.61 3.25 3.16 3.13 4.12 4.12 3.23<br />
Road Holding (Corner) 3.92 3.31 3.17 3.25 4.50 4.27 2.88<br />
Road Holding (Straight) 3.87 3.54 3.29 3.30 4.54 4.23 3.18<br />
Suspension (Ride) 3.80 3.70 3.12 3.21 4.43 3.99 3.25<br />
Total 3.77 3.47 3.16 3.18 4.30 4.06 3.16
Development Group7 . They decided that in order to<br />
develop a strategic concept it was important to<br />
consider three things:<br />
• Understanding <strong>Toyota</strong>’s place in the market<br />
• Knowing the competition<br />
• Reaching the customer<br />
They conducted a product clinic and customer<br />
focus groups. From market studies and their primary<br />
research, TSAM came to understand the position of the<br />
<strong>Toyota</strong> brand, the competitive environment, and their<br />
customers. The focus group participants were drawn<br />
from pools of owners of the C/G Corolla and the<br />
current competitive set including the VW Jetta4, Opel<br />
Astra, VW Polo Playa, and the VW Golf4.<br />
Understanding <strong>Toyota</strong>’s Place in the Market<br />
The results of the primary research performed by TSAM<br />
rendered interesting, but not entirely surprising results.<br />
As expected, the <strong>Toyota</strong> brand scored well on Quality,<br />
Durability & Reliability (QDR), but continues to<br />
struggle with regard to styling and emotional appeal<br />
(Figure 4).<br />
[Figure 6]<br />
Results of the product clinic—several positive aspects of the 558N drew<br />
the attention of the respondents.<br />
Sedan Hatchback<br />
Smooth/modern styling Styling/rear design<br />
Interior space/legroom Spacious/legroom<br />
Boot space Power/acceleration<br />
Comfortable seats Responsive<br />
Rear seat/hip point Roadholding<br />
Balanced power Cornering<br />
Acceleration Dashboard design<br />
Brakes Interior design<br />
Road holding Steering wheel<br />
Interior design Center console<br />
Visibility Sporty look & specs<br />
7. Also known as Corolla Engineering Group (ZE)<br />
case study of <strong>Toyota</strong> <strong>South</strong> <strong>Africa</strong> Motor (<strong>Pty</strong>) <strong>Ltd</strong>.<br />
Obviously, the challenge here would be to establish<br />
an emotional appeal to match the QDR already<br />
associated with <strong>Toyota</strong>. The newly designed Corolla<br />
might just be the car to help <strong>Toyota</strong> take a big step in<br />
that direction. To determine the extent to which this<br />
vehicle may be able to improve the brand, it had to be<br />
compared to the rest of the competitive set from both<br />
objective and subjective points of view.<br />
Knowing the Competition<br />
During the product clinic at the Kyalami test track,<br />
the Corolla scored very well against the competition<br />
(Figure 5). In fact, it scored comparatively well in<br />
those “sporty” categories in which <strong>Toyota</strong> is reputedly<br />
weak, such as acceleration, steering, road holding,<br />
and suspension.<br />
The Corolla apparently has other obvious<br />
advantages over the competition(Figure 6) as well. In<br />
addition to enhanced styling, the vehicle has<br />
considerable interior space, greater visibility, and<br />
exceptionally comfortable seats.<br />
In so many ways, the new Corolla exceeded<br />
expectations from a product standpoint, yet it is one<br />
thing to build a superior product and quite another to<br />
market it effectively and, moreover, to provoke<br />
“feelings of passion” in your intended audience. Until<br />
Volkswagen’s (VW) introduction of their new Golf,<br />
they had quite the opposite problem.<br />
VW has been very successful at maintaining a<br />
stylish, sporty and youth-oriented image, but has<br />
suffered from a poor perception of QDR and safety<br />
amongst consumers until their recent product launch.<br />
The Golf4, equipped with four air bags as standard<br />
6
Best Practice Bulletin vol. 1<br />
Art of Revitalization<br />
equipment, had a halo effect on the entire brand,<br />
effectively raising its brand image single-handedly<br />
(Figure 7). Previously, as the second-place brand in<br />
<strong>South</strong> <strong>Africa</strong> with QDR setbacks, VW already represented<br />
a nuisance; now, it is a threat.<br />
Reaching the Customer<br />
Realizing <strong>Toyota</strong>’s image weaknesses and the opportunity<br />
that the Corolla offers (in light of the danger that<br />
a brand-enhanced VW represents), TSAM was<br />
determined to take a bolder approach. In order to<br />
enhance customer loyalty and acquire the competitor’s<br />
customers they conducted a market analysis and<br />
implemented integrated marketing. This allowed them<br />
to establish a sales launch policy to target core and<br />
strategic customers, and create a core message. The<br />
core message that they established was: “Corolla:<br />
Catalyst for a New Era.”<br />
From the beginning the team was asked to focus<br />
on an innovative launch for the Corolla. When<br />
Dr. van Zyl recognized how well the planning process<br />
[Figure 7] Perceptions of the VW brand by focus group participants<br />
The arrow signifies the brand’s movement from a negative QDR image to<br />
a relatively positive one.<br />
7<br />
Positive<br />
Negative<br />
Improved QDR<br />
and<br />
Safety Features<br />
➡<br />
Old<br />
VW<br />
Young<br />
Sporty<br />
Ecxiting<br />
Status<br />
➡<br />
Latest Design<br />
Improved Engines<br />
Improves user profile<br />
Practical Emotional<br />
Qualities seen as<br />
important to VW drivers<br />
was proceeding, he decided that TSAM’s entire<br />
revitalization should depend upon this launch strategy.<br />
In due course, this launch had, indeed, become the<br />
catalyst for a new era essentially signaling the rebirth<br />
of TSAM.<br />
Planning and Creating Short-Term Wins<br />
In order to further enhance innovative strategy<br />
creation the group was sub-divided into six teams. The<br />
teams were purposefully defined in order to disentangle<br />
themselves from the corporate structure and break<br />
from performing their duties in the same manner as<br />
they had in the past.<br />
Positioning At the core of the strategy is “the golden<br />
thread” of each brand, namely the positioning statement<br />
and what the brand stands for.<br />
Perceptions This team was responsible for all oneway<br />
communication, both above and below the line.<br />
Their objective was to reposition the Corolla and<br />
<strong>Toyota</strong> brand.<br />
Experience This team was responsible for all two-way<br />
communication, both internally and externally,<br />
including all training. Their objective was to exceed<br />
customer expectations for life.<br />
Cost This team was responsible for all financial issues<br />
relating to owning a vehicle. The aim was to look at<br />
the entire vehicle ownership cycle from purchase to<br />
re-purchase. Their objective was to ensure that the<br />
Corolla has the lowest running costs in its class.<br />
Retention This team was responsible for getting<br />
current <strong>Toyota</strong> drivers into the new product. Their<br />
objective was to convert existing <strong>Toyota</strong> drivers into<br />
Corolla drivers, and maintain their loyalty.<br />
Acquisition This team was responsible for getting<br />
current non-owners into the new product. Their
objective was to gain new and regain lost private<br />
buyers and fleet accounts.<br />
Once TSAM management agreed upon the Strategic<br />
Concept, it was handed over to the appropriate process<br />
silo and its details developed under the guidance of<br />
that silo’s representative team member. The brief on<br />
the tactical strategy covered its objectives (i.e., clarified<br />
the role of the idea to achieve the objectives), purpose,<br />
methods, and any other details. (i.e., who, what,<br />
where, when, why, how, how much, how to evaluate).<br />
Institutionalizing the New Approach<br />
Nagel decided that it was imperative to gather<br />
consistent information from the frontlines.<br />
Unfortunately, when attempting to organize the retail<br />
end of the business his biggest challenges lay ahead in<br />
the form of “ability”and “motivation.” As he put it,<br />
“there was a general sense of apathy in the dealer<br />
network.” <strong>Toyota</strong> had been the market leader in <strong>South</strong><br />
<strong>Africa</strong> for 22 years and selling a <strong>Toyota</strong> product was<br />
typically very easy as “the product almost sold itself.”<br />
Over the years the market became much more<br />
competitive as new offerings were being placed. This<br />
was further enhanced by the fact that competitors were<br />
gaining export credits that gave them a pricing<br />
advantage. For example, in <strong>South</strong> <strong>Africa</strong> the Corolla<br />
must compete directly against the BMW 318i on price.<br />
This places a great deal of pressure on the <strong>Toyota</strong><br />
dealers’ sales staffs. “The aim of the training was to<br />
enable the sales staff to take on this challenge,” Nagel<br />
says. Somehow, he had to develop support tools for<br />
salespeople coupled with a formal education process,<br />
familiarity with the PDCA cycle, 8 and awareness for<br />
8. Plan, Do, Check and Act<br />
case study of <strong>Toyota</strong> <strong>South</strong> <strong>Africa</strong> Motor (<strong>Pty</strong>) <strong>Ltd</strong>.<br />
global best practice.<br />
It was thought that a sales caravan process may be<br />
the ideal method. The idea behind this process would<br />
be to take the training to the staff so that their busy<br />
schedules are not adversely affected. It incorporates a<br />
group of five trainers that move from area to area,<br />
teaching one-day classes of 40 salespeople about the<br />
products. The focus is on practical product and skills<br />
training and seven vehicles are presented so that salespeople<br />
may receive the opportunity to test drive them.<br />
In addition, the <strong>Toyota</strong> Way and kaizen (continuous<br />
improvement) have been introduced to the sales<br />
staff to be followed by “a proper sales kaizen culture”<br />
that will be developed next year. Currently, a high level<br />
of competition exists between the different dealers and<br />
so the sharing of best practice is hampered. To help<br />
ameliorate the situation, sales tips are shared on a<br />
weekly basis and kaizen is practiced in the Sales<br />
Managers Forum where best practice is discussed.<br />
Furthermore, minimum standards have been<br />
implemented for each element of the sales process.<br />
At this point, Nagel placed several ideas in motion.<br />
To generate greater motivation and self-confidence, he<br />
implemented a personal leadership program that<br />
encouraged individual thinking through training and<br />
enforced a dress code that engendered greater pride<br />
and professionalism.<br />
Five workshops were held between TSAM<br />
Marketing, dealers and suppliers to finalize the dress<br />
code. The observed criteria were practicality, cost<br />
effectiveness, image building (in line with the <strong>Toyota</strong><br />
brand), and enhancing the customer experience. Dress<br />
8
Best Practice Bulletin vol. 1<br />
Art of Revitalization<br />
code training was on two levels: how to dress properly,<br />
and the official corporate wear. The corporate wear has<br />
been very well received with about a 70 percent<br />
adoption rate so far. In the future, the dress code is<br />
planned to become part of the franchise standard as<br />
competitors all have a basic dress code. 9<br />
Sales abilities were heightened by delivering<br />
formal sales training in the form of the <strong>Toyota</strong> Way in<br />
Sales and Marketing “Art of Selling” which was tailored<br />
specifically to the <strong>South</strong> <strong>Africa</strong>n Sales Activity process.<br />
In addition, Nagel’s efforts were focused on reinforcing<br />
product knowledge and presentation skills. An<br />
intensive follow-up program of mystery shopping,<br />
dealer check sheets, and KPI10 for Check & Action<br />
(portions of the PDCA Cycle) were put into operation.<br />
Finally, a national skills olympiad would generate a<br />
competitive atmosphere to encourage salespeople to<br />
improve their skills.<br />
■Implementation Challenges<br />
Using oobeya principles, Nagel was able to promote<br />
communication between team members to identify<br />
and eliminate challenges. While trying to integrate<br />
TSAM’s marketing functions across its silos, Nagel was<br />
presented with a suite of difficulties including a lack of<br />
human resources, and poor communication with, and<br />
among, production people, marketing and TMC’s<br />
support staff. In addition, it was a challenge to<br />
establish implementation procedures.<br />
To achieve progress toward a successful Corolla<br />
launch Nagel had to answer challenges brought to light<br />
by training team members. It became important to<br />
9. BMW, Mercedes, and VW all have strict formal dress codes.<br />
10. Key Performance Indicator<br />
9<br />
understand new operating methods that could<br />
motivate both trainers and the staff to adopt these<br />
innovations. In addition, he had to acquire TMC’s<br />
support for his efforts to create new sales tools and<br />
gather information and deal with the almost<br />
insurmountable obstacles involved in truly integrating<br />
production and marketing efforts.<br />
“The most critical issue was available time as team<br />
members were not always supported by their process<br />
leaders (managers),” claims Nagel. Although a core<br />
team of four people worked full-time on the project,<br />
the other team members were forced to perform their<br />
normal job while simultaneously doing their part in<br />
the strategy creation process.<br />
To succeed, he was determined to test each and<br />
every module for accuracy, establish standards for<br />
consistent information sharing with the production<br />
site, gain full support from top management, set up<br />
monthly progress meetings with TMC, and, perhaps<br />
most importantly, create and motivate an implementation<br />
squad whose full responsibility was to get the job<br />
done . . . and done well.<br />
■Moving Forward<br />
At the conclusion of their work the team prepared a<br />
presentation to hand the launch strategy over to<br />
TMC for review and implementation. As the team<br />
prepared this presentation, they were eager to discover<br />
how it would be received by TMC. TMC directed<br />
them to work in conjunction with its staff to leverage<br />
its progress to date and structure it in a way that<br />
would reflect the Corolla’s importance as TSAM’s best-
selling vehicle.<br />
TMC recognized that, although there were some<br />
missteps along the way, TSAM made a genuine effort to<br />
reform its launch processes for the Corolla and vehicles<br />
to follow. Nagel says that, “in retrospect, I would have<br />
changed the teams somewhat. I would have divided<br />
the experience team into internal and external<br />
experience. Internal experience would focus on the<br />
staff, including dealer staff and associate training.<br />
External experience would focus on the customer<br />
experience including promotional activities. I would<br />
have combined the retention and acquisition teams.”<br />
Essentially, there were some fundamental benefits<br />
realized from developing a cross-functional team<br />
that could more easily view the business from<br />
several perspectives.<br />
Indeed, as TSAM approached the launch of the<br />
Corolla, John Nagel could easily claim that they had<br />
accomplished something that is otherwise very difficult<br />
to do in most organizations—by faithfully implementing<br />
oobeya principles, he was able to build a team that<br />
could see beyond the limits of their silos and realize<br />
the effects of a range of decisions on the business as a<br />
whole. Selecting individuals who were open to<br />
different ways of seeing the business was also a key<br />
consideration. In short, team members were able to<br />
gain a better grasp of the big picture through shared<br />
knowledge and motivation. Although it seems that<br />
TSAM is quickly approaching an overwhelmingly<br />
successful launch, the question yet remains whether<br />
these reforms will actually generate a profound<br />
business turnaround. Unfortunately, such questions<br />
may only be answered in the future, but look for them<br />
to be answered in the very near future.<br />
case study of <strong>Toyota</strong> <strong>South</strong> <strong>Africa</strong> Motor (<strong>Pty</strong>) <strong>Ltd</strong>.<br />
Beyond the obvious improvements that were put<br />
into action at TSAM, we should observe that from a<br />
higher-level perspective, the team members there were<br />
following the <strong>Toyota</strong> Way by generating a strategy that<br />
considers the customer first, uses kaizen, and respects<br />
the opinions of others. That is why we can see this as a<br />
Best Practice . . . as a perfect example of the <strong>Toyota</strong><br />
Way in Sales and Marketing.■<br />
10
“Best practice” simply means learning from the<br />
success of others. Many distributors and dealers have<br />
implemented exceptional innovations to respond to<br />
the changing needs of customers. This Best Practice<br />
Bulletin is published for all <strong>Toyota</strong> members to share<br />
these good practices and learn from each other.<br />
The Best Practice Bulletin is about your most<br />
innovative ways of doing business. If you have any<br />
practices that you would like to share with <strong>Toyota</strong><br />
around the world, please contact us at:<br />
Best Practice Bulletin<br />
Overseas Marketing Division<br />
<strong>Toyota</strong> Motor Corporation<br />
Address<br />
4-18, Koraku 1-Chome<br />
Bunkyo-Ku, Tokyo, 112-8701, Japan<br />
Fax<br />
+81-3-3817-9037<br />
E-mail<br />
mr_bestpractice@mta.mx.toyota.co.jp<br />
■ Published by Global Knowledge Center, a division of<br />
<strong>Toyota</strong> Motor Sales, U.S.A., Inc.<br />
■ Copyright 2002 by <strong>Toyota</strong> Motor Corporation<br />
■ Contents may be reprinted by authorized distributors<br />
for internal use only.<br />
■ All rights reserved.<br />
■ Printed in Japan with soy ink on recycled paper.