A L U M N I P R O F I L E S4Two roads diverged in a woodand I–Itook the one less traveled by.When Wayne Pattersontalks about a broaderpalette <strong>of</strong> possibilitiesfor people withPhDs, he need onlypoint to his own.While a graduate student, he“imported” an inner-city math educationprogram from California to<strong>Michigan</strong> and later helped establishit nationally. He returned tohis native Canada for a time,became assistant to the DeputyPrime Minister, and eventuallyserved four years as Vice President<strong>of</strong> the national Liberal Party. Backin the states, he launched the computerscience program at the<strong>University</strong> <strong>of</strong> New Orleans,became the school’s Associate ViceChancellor for Research, thenmoved on to the <strong>University</strong> <strong>of</strong>Charleston, South Carolina as VicePresident <strong>of</strong> Research and Dean <strong>of</strong>the <strong>Graduate</strong> <strong>School</strong>.He has just returned to the<strong>University</strong> <strong>of</strong> Charleston, SouthCarolina, from a leave duringwhich he served as the Dean inResidence at the Council <strong>of</strong><strong>Graduate</strong> <strong>School</strong>s in Washington,D.C., conducting a national studyon graduate certificate programsand exhorting all and sundry toconsider more options.“I can serve this world by bringingone set <strong>of</strong> talents to differentfields,” he says. “I wouldn’t be satisfieddevoting an entire career tojust math, or just politics. The purpose<strong>of</strong> a PhD is not just to producefaculty for Research I institutions,doing the same things theirfaculty advisors did before them.The earlier that graduate studentscan see other ways to use theirdegrees, the healthier graduateeducation will be.”His intention was to become acollege mathematics pr<strong>of</strong>essorwhen he enrolled in the <strong>University</strong><strong>of</strong> <strong>Michigan</strong> Math Department’sdoctoral program in the 1960s, andthat was typical <strong>of</strong> such students atthe time. Higher education inNorth America was mushrooming,and the demand for traditionallytrained academics was high.As part <strong>of</strong> the U-M program, hewas sent to a different research– Robert Frostinstitution each summer. On one <strong>of</strong>those jaunts, to Berkeley, he metthe founder <strong>of</strong> Project SEED, aprogram that put college facultyand graduate students into innercityclassrooms to teach advancedalgebra and calculus to fifth andsixth graders. Patterson becameconsumed by the project, devoting“The earlier thatgraduate students cansee other ways to usetheir degrees, thehealthier graduateeducation will be.”40 or more hours a week to itwhile doing his thesis research intopology, although he still finishedhis PhD earlier than most <strong>of</strong> hisclassmates. “Although my ProjectSEED activities were not universallysupported by the powers thatbe in the U-M Math Department,
Photo by Jane Hamblinmy thesis advisor, Frank Raymond,and my other committee membersalways expressed confidence in mycommitment as a research mathematician.”He then devoted 10 years full-timeto Project SEED before his return toCanada and subsequent careers. Hecontinues to volunteer for the program,whose long-term results havebeen stunning.“Between 30 and 40 studies <strong>of</strong> ithave been done over the years,” hesays. “One was in the Dallas schooldistrict, and I don’t know <strong>of</strong> anyother study like this in education.They did a statistical analysis <strong>of</strong> studentswho were in Project SEED infourth, fifth and sixth grades, comparedto a matched control group,and followed them through 12thgrade. A minimum <strong>of</strong> six years later,there were still statistically significantdifferences in math achievement,fewer dropouts, better retention,more students taking collegeprep mathematics and so on. They’vebeen following up Project SEED studentsfor 10 years now, and theresults hold up.”Patterson’s current work couldprove comparably dramatic in itsown way, albeit at the other end <strong>of</strong>the educational continuum. He’s justfinished a book, based on surveydata from 200 schools, on policiesand procedures for graduatecertificate programs, just one<strong>of</strong> the many alternatives to traditionalgraduate degree programsthat have materialized inthe last decade or so.“Certificate programs generallyare shorter-term, nondegreeprograms, <strong>of</strong>fered atvarious levels by pr<strong>of</strong>essional,undergraduate, continuing educationand graduate schools,”Patterson explains. “We’ve tended touse the term graduate certificate tomean that the content <strong>of</strong> the curriculumis part <strong>of</strong> the approved graduatecurriculum <strong>of</strong> the university. Let’ssay you have a number <strong>of</strong> courses inthe master’s <strong>of</strong> public administrationprogram on geographic informationsystems. You might define a set <strong>of</strong>four or five courses as ‘geographicinformation systems’ and re<strong>of</strong>ferthem as a certificate in that area.”Patterson vividly recalls the dayswhen a master’s degree itself wasgenerally regarded as a sort <strong>of</strong> consolationprize for doctoral candidateswho, for one reason or another, fellby the wayside.But, he says, “In the last 20 years,the number <strong>of</strong> students doing whatwe would call pr<strong>of</strong>essional master’sdegrees has just exploded. We awardeight times as many master’s degreesnationally as we do doctorates. Manymore schools have a specific curriculumdesigned for the master’s. Therequirement to write a thesis for amaster’s has virtually disappeared,and that’s an indication <strong>of</strong> a morepr<strong>of</strong>essional than research orientationto that degree. This whole move tocertificates and other forms <strong>of</strong> postbaccalaureateeducation continues atrend that really started with the pr<strong>of</strong>essionalmaster’s degree.”“Post-baccalaureate education” isthe phrase <strong>of</strong> choice at the Council<strong>of</strong> <strong>Graduate</strong> <strong>School</strong>s. “It certainlyincludes our traditional models formaster’s and doctoral education,” hesays, “but it also brings in all theeducational needs a person mighthave once they’re beyond the firstdegree level. A remarkable number<strong>of</strong> two-year institutions are involvedin post-baccalaureate education, aswell as something like 1,400 corporateuniversities. The face <strong>of</strong> postgraduateeducation is really changinga great deal.”The reality is a given. Theresponse is not. “I guess the questionis whether it’s something the graduateschools in the country wish toendorse, participate in, ignore, fight,or take a leadership role in,” saysPatterson. “There are a lot <strong>of</strong> differentways <strong>of</strong> looking at it. But I talkto more and more deans who see tryingto provide alternative forms andformats for education beyond thebachelor’s degree as a necessarycomponent <strong>of</strong> what we do.”The other side <strong>of</strong> the coin is thatstudents choosing the traditionalroute need not limit themselves tothe traditional choices.“I think it’s important for peoplegoing into graduate school to recognizethat the people who come outwith PhDs can do many differenttypes <strong>of</strong> things,” Patterson says.“There are options in public service,in government, in corporations.There is something about the discipline<strong>of</strong> having to do unique andoriginal research that prepares you toproblem-solve in many differentareas, and that’s the real value <strong>of</strong> thePhD process.” ■5