Truckload Authority - Fall 2016
Transform your PDFs into Flipbooks and boost your revenue!
Leverage SEO-optimized Flipbooks, powerful backlinks, and multimedia content to professionally showcase your products and significantly increase your reach.
WAA: GALA IN REVIEW | TOP ROOKIE | TOP TRUCKING CONCERNS<br />
O F F I C I A L P U B L I C A T I O N o f t h e T r u c k l o a d C a r r i e r s A s s o c i a t i o n<br />
FALL <strong>2016</strong><br />
American<br />
Wife<br />
with Taya Kyle<br />
In this issue<br />
tilting the Senate<br />
Will Democrats wrest control from the GOP?<br />
cradle to Cab<br />
Answering questions about younger drivers<br />
Adopt a highway<br />
Finding ways to pay for roads and bridges
FALL | TCA <strong>2016</strong><br />
President’s Purview<br />
Your Association<br />
Who you are voting for seems to be the question of the month.<br />
How about we change the subject? Let’s talk about what your association has been up to and<br />
what is heading your way to support your business and the industry. After all, trucking is the most<br />
important economic engine of the North American economies; this needs to be respected by many<br />
and it will be!<br />
During our three-day Officer’s Planning and Strategy meeting in August, we plowed some new<br />
ground led by TCA Chairman Russell Stubbs. The budget was shaped and approved by the officers to<br />
go before the Board of Directors for its final approval, which took place on September 21. In <strong>2016</strong>-<br />
2017 we will be investing in the future of your association by being laser focused on building a bright<br />
future for your businesses.<br />
What does this investing look like? Let’s use the four-legged stool visual. What you see at the<br />
very top and what holds the four legs solidly in place is you the member. Our message is clear: There<br />
is strength in numbers, there is no free lunch, and we will no longer tolerate or accept the decision<br />
making process affecting trucking that lacks credible data, transparency, and understanding of the<br />
importance of trucking.<br />
Let’s look at the first leg: It is working with you to build value in your business. There are several<br />
ways to help you be successful; it can be better than it is today and it will be. Begin to think about<br />
what this looks like.<br />
The next leg is improving your profitability. This is an area to which I have devoted my career. I<br />
have a great deal of passion about it and know what it takes to get this done for you. You will find in<br />
this issue of <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> more information about inGuage, so please take a look at it. There is<br />
more to come. This is the time to improve your profitability, so act now!<br />
The next is retaining your skilled workforce. What is the total cost of turnover?<br />
I have heard a range of from $2,500 to $12,000. Many think it is much higher, and we need to<br />
get our heads around what goes into this calculation. We have an opportunity here to shape this into<br />
something that can really impact your culture and bottom line.<br />
The final leg is being the voice of truckload. Being an effective voice will require intimately working<br />
with all national and state trucking associations and their respective memberships on shaping the<br />
future of truckload and at the same time trucking. It will be a struggle; nothing in our history has said<br />
it will be easy, but it will be worth it. Let’s respect the past, embrace what’s before us and shape the<br />
future. As you all have heard, David Heller has been promoted to TCA’s vice president of government<br />
affairs. Please reach out to him and share your thoughts. We have a great deal of work moving things<br />
forward collaboratively as an industry and this needs to happen now!<br />
On September 20, the Nominating Committee led by Keith Tuttle interviewed four very qualified<br />
candidates to be considered as future officers. A formal application with a curriculum vitae and<br />
résumé was very helpful to bring out their outstanding qualifications as future leaders. Many thanks to<br />
Shepard Dunn since he is the architect on this new process with the help of his dedicated committee.<br />
Following that meeting was an emotional and deeply moving Wreaths Across America Gala.<br />
I would need pages to capture this evening. We had a 20 percent increase in attendees year-overyear<br />
numbering 310. Many thanks to all of you for making this such an important remembrance of our<br />
fallen who gave the ultimate sacrifice for our freedom and thanks for your hard work. You will hear<br />
more about this. Thank you to Debbie Sparks and the entire TCA team for making it a successful and<br />
memorable evening.<br />
The next day we held our board and committee meetings which were well attended and productive,<br />
as you heard earlier.<br />
John Lyboldt<br />
President<br />
<strong>Truckload</strong> Carriers Association<br />
jlyboldt@truckload.org<br />
Russell Stubbs has asked Shepard Dunn to chair the Bylaws<br />
Committee and do a comprehensive review to design a plan moving<br />
forward to make us nimble and proactive.<br />
It is the fourth quarter, first down and the goal line is in reach<br />
before time runs out. We need a touchdown; a field goal isn’t enough<br />
to extend the lead we want as a team. So I ask you, isn’t it incredible<br />
for the team to know anything is possible if we work together,<br />
focus on what’s important, give it our all and have the resources<br />
to do so? After all, the largest competitive advantage any company,<br />
association or enterprise has is teamwork. History has proven this<br />
many times over.<br />
Thank you for being an active and engaged member in helping<br />
us shape the future.<br />
Safety first, everyone.<br />
PRESIDENT’S PICKS<br />
A Clear Vision<br />
Chairman Stubbs talks about the excitement<br />
generated by President Lyboldt’s vision for TCA.<br />
Page 30<br />
Inside Out Featuring Marli Hall<br />
Get to know TCA Outreach and Engagement<br />
Manager Marli Riggs Hall.<br />
Page 36<br />
WAA: Gala in Review<br />
Fourth annual WAA Gala raises $258,000 for<br />
causes related to Wreaths Across America.<br />
Page 40<br />
TCA <strong>2016</strong> www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org | <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong>
T H h e E R O o A a d D m M a A p P<br />
summer/<strong>Fall</strong> FALL <strong>2016</strong><br />
President’s<br />
President’s Purview<br />
Purview<br />
Looking Your Association Forward by by<br />
John John<br />
Lyboldt Lyboldt | 3<br />
LegisLative<br />
LegisLative Look-in<br />
Look-in<br />
The Tilting Accountabilty the Senate Project | 6<br />
| 6<br />
Capitol Recap | 10<br />
10<br />
America Adopt a Votes Highway <strong>2016</strong> | 14<br />
| 14<br />
Happy Cradle Birthday to Cab Highway | 17<br />
| 16<br />
Presidential Promises | 18<br />
tracking the trends sponsored by skybitz<br />
tracking Highway the trends Robbery | 18<br />
sPonsored by skybitz<br />
ELDelirious Fatal Flaws |<br />
| 21<br />
19<br />
Climbing Detained<br />
to the |<br />
Top 23<br />
| 23<br />
Road Rage Rising | 25<br />
nationaL news Driving<br />
Maker Diversity | 26<br />
sPonsored by the trucker news org.<br />
eXcLusive American Wife with Taya Kyle | 25<br />
a chat with the chairman sponsored by McLeod software<br />
a chat The with 12th the Man chairMan with Russell Stubbs | 28<br />
sPonsored by McLeod software<br />
A Clear Vision with Russell Stubbs | 30<br />
member maiLroom<br />
Wreaths<br />
MeMber and<br />
MaiLrooM<br />
Meetings | 33<br />
Transporting Wreaths | 35<br />
taLking tca<br />
Inside Out taLking with Dan<br />
tca<br />
Tidwell | 34<br />
Building<br />
Inside on Success,<br />
Out with WorkForce<br />
Marli Riggs Builders<br />
Hall Conference | 36<br />
| 38<br />
See Wreaths and Be Across Seen,<br />
America, Annual Reefer<br />
Gala Meeting<br />
Recap | |<br />
40<br />
40<br />
TCA Teaming<br />
Top Up<br />
Rookie with Rolling<br />
| 42<br />
Strong | 41<br />
Small<br />
Small Talk<br />
Talk | 42<br />
43<br />
Mark<br />
Mark Your<br />
Your Calendar<br />
Calendar | 46<br />
46<br />
REACHING TRUCKING’S<br />
TOP EXECUTIVES<br />
555 E. Braddock Road, Alexandria, VA 22314<br />
Phone: <br />
(703) 838-1950 • Fax: (703) 836-6610<br />
www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org<br />
chairman chairMan of the board<br />
Russell Stubbs<br />
Chairman, FFE Holdings Corp.<br />
President<br />
executive eXecutive vice President<br />
John Lyboldt<br />
William (Bill) Giroux<br />
jlyboldt@truckload.org<br />
wgiroux@truckload.org<br />
vice President – deveLoPMent<br />
deveLoPment vice director, President– safety governMentaffairs<br />
& PoLicy<br />
Debbie Sparks<br />
Dave Heller<br />
dsparks@truckload.org<br />
dheller@truckload.org<br />
director of education<br />
first vice chair<br />
Ron Goode<br />
Rob Penner, President & COO<br />
rgoode@truckload.org<br />
Bison Transport<br />
second vice chair<br />
Thomas Witt<br />
President<br />
Roehl Transport - Flatbed & Specialized<br />
secretary<br />
Josh Kaburick<br />
CEO<br />
Earl L. Henderson Trucking Company<br />
at-Large officer<br />
Daniel Doran, President<br />
Doran Logistics, LLC.<br />
at-Large officer<br />
Aaron Tennant, President & CEO<br />
Total Solutions, Inc.<br />
treasurer<br />
Dennis Dellinger<br />
President<br />
Cargo Transporters, Inc.<br />
immediate iMMediate Past chair<br />
Keith Tuttle<br />
Founder & President<br />
Motor Carrier Service, LLC.<br />
at-Large officer<br />
John Elliott, CEO<br />
Load One, LLC.<br />
at-Large officer<br />
James Ward, President<br />
D.M. Bowman, Inc.<br />
The viewpoints and opinions of those quoted in articles in this<br />
publication are not necessarily those of TCA.<br />
In exclusive partnership with:<br />
1123 S. University Ave., Ste 320, Little Rock, AR 72204<br />
Phone: <br />
(800) 666-2770 • Fax: (501) 666-0700<br />
www.TheTrucker.com<br />
PubLisher + generaL Mgr.<br />
mgr.<br />
vice President<br />
Micah Jackson<br />
Ed Leader<br />
publisher@thetrucker.com<br />
edl@thetrucker.com<br />
adMinistrator<br />
administrator<br />
editor<br />
Leah M. Birdsong<br />
Lyndon Finney<br />
leahb@thetrucker.com<br />
editor@thetrucker.com<br />
Production + art director<br />
associate editor<br />
Rob Nelson<br />
Dorothy Cox<br />
robn@thetrucker.com<br />
dlcox@thetrucker.com<br />
Production + art assistant<br />
news rePorter<br />
Christie McCluer<br />
Jack Whitsett<br />
christie.mccluer@thetrucker.com<br />
jack.whitsett@thetrucker.com<br />
advertising and Marketing dePartMent<br />
departMent<br />
saLes director + creative director<br />
Raelee Toye Jackson<br />
raeleet@thetrucker.com<br />
“<strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> gives me UNIQUE INSIGHTS into the<br />
truckload industry which I CANNOT FIND ELSEWHERE.<br />
The CUTTING EDGE INFORMATION I get from<br />
<strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> is INVALUABLE to my company.”<br />
-TOM B. KRETSINGER, JR.<br />
PRESIDENT & CEO, AMERICAN CENTRAL TRANSPORT<br />
2013-14 CHAIRMAN, TRUCKLOAD CARRIERS ASSOCIATION<br />
TRUCKING’S MOST ENTERTAINING<br />
EXECUTIVE PUBLICATION<br />
nationaL marketing nationaL consuLtant Marketing nationaL consuLtant<br />
marketing consuLtant<br />
Kurtis Denton Kurtis Denton<br />
Kelly Brooke Drier<br />
kurtisd@thetrucker.com kurtisd@thetrucker.com<br />
kellydr@thetrucker.com<br />
© <strong>2016</strong> Trucker Publications Inc., all rights reserved. Reproduction without written permission<br />
prohibited. The publisher assumes no responsibility for unsolicited material. All advertisements<br />
and editorial materials are accepted and published by <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> and its exclusive partner,<br />
Trucker Publications, on the representation that the advertiser, its advertising company and/<br />
or the supplier of editorial materials are authorized to publish the entire contents and subject<br />
matter thereof. The publisher reserves the right to accept or reject any art from client. Such entities<br />
and/or their agents will defend, indemnify and hold <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong>, <strong>Truckload</strong> Carriers<br />
Association, Target Media Partners, and its subsidiaries included, by not limited to, Trucker<br />
Publications Inc., harmless from and against any loss, expense, or other liability resulting from<br />
any claims or suits for libel, violations of privacy, plagiarism, copyright or trademark infringement<br />
and any other claims or suits that may rise out of publication of such advertisements and/or<br />
editorial materials. Press releases are expressly covered within the definition of editorial materials.<br />
Cover Photo Courtesy:<br />
Michael Ainsworth The Trucker - The News Dallas Org. Morning News<br />
Additional Magazine Photography:<br />
additional magazine photography:<br />
Associated Press: P. 28, 29<br />
Chris Kyle Frog Foundation: P. 26, 27, 29<br />
FotoSearch: Dan Tidwell: P. 8, 17, P. 36 18, 19<br />
Fotosearch: P. 6, 8, 14, 20, 22, 23, 25, 26, 27, 33, 38, 41, 46<br />
Marli Riggs Richard Hall: K. P. Dalton: 38, 39 - McLeod P. 28, 29, Software: 30, 32 P. 45<br />
Pennsylvania Megan Crowell: Turnpike P. 42 - Omnitracs: <strong>Authority</strong>: P. P. 22<br />
44<br />
Richard TCA: P. K. 3, Dalton: 35, 38, 39, P. 40, 3, 30, 42, 31, 43, 32, 44 34<br />
TCA: The P. Trucker 3, 25, 35, News 36, 39, Org.: 40, 41, P. 43, 1644<br />
The Trucker News Org.: P. 6, 14<br />
<br />
TRUCKLOAD<br />
<strong>Truckload</strong><br />
AUTHORITY<br />
<strong>Authority</strong><br />
|<br />
| www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org 4 <strong>Truckload</strong> auThoriTy www.truckLoad.org | tca <strong>2016</strong><br />
TCA <strong>2016</strong><br />
www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org Tca <strong>2016</strong>
For more than a century, Great Dane has delivered unparalleled Americanmade<br />
products. As the times have changed, our products have changed<br />
too, incorporating smarter technology, greater innovation and better<br />
customization. But running through every refrigerated and dry freight<br />
trailer, every flatbed and every truck body we make is one thing that will<br />
never change: our commitment to helping you get the job done. Let’s go.<br />
GreatDaneTrailers.com<br />
GREAT DANE AND THE OVAL ARE REGISTERED TRADEMARKS OF GREAT DANE LIMITED PARTNERSHIP
FALL | TCA <strong>2016</strong><br />
Legislative Look-In<br />
Will the Democrats wrest control from the GOP?<br />
No one knows, but every website has an opinion.<br />
By Jack Whitsett<br />
C urrently the U.S. Senate, with two<br />
members for each of the 50 states, has 100<br />
members. The Republicans have a 54-46<br />
edge, and the Democrats’ total includes two<br />
independents, Bernie Sanders of Vermont<br />
and Angus King of Maine. Both Sanders<br />
and King caucus with the Democratic Party,<br />
meaning that although each may vote with<br />
either party on individual issues, they count<br />
themselves as Democrats for the purpose<br />
of party totals that determine which party<br />
elects a Senate leader (President Pro Tempore)<br />
and committee chairs.<br />
While the Senate is up for grabs by either<br />
party, the same can’t be said for the<br />
Republican-controlled House of Representatives.<br />
The biennial election for representatives<br />
from all 435 Congressional Districts<br />
will take place on November 8, on the same<br />
ballot as all other federal elections. Almost<br />
all states and municipalities hold their local<br />
elections the same day on the same ballot,<br />
with the occasional exception of school district<br />
elections. House winners will be sworn<br />
in to the 115th Congress in January, 2017.<br />
The GOP currently controls the U.S. House,<br />
246-186 with three vacant seats. That gives<br />
the party 28 more than the 218 needed for<br />
control, so the Democrats aren’t expected<br />
to wrest control of the chamber, though<br />
they could gain from 5-20 seats.<br />
There are as many predictions of how the<br />
Senate will look after the November elections<br />
as there are political websites, but a<br />
few trends seem to be developing. RealClear<br />
Politics, as of October 5, had the Democrats<br />
leading 47-46, with seven states, Indiana,<br />
Nevada, Pennsylvania, North Carolina, New<br />
Hampshire, Missouri and Florida rated as tossups.<br />
Another site, 270toWin, puts the<br />
Democrats ahead 45-44, but with 11<br />
tossup states. They include the<br />
seven from RealClear Politics,<br />
plus Ohio, Illinois, Wisconsin<br />
and Arizona. Larry J.<br />
Sabato’s Crystal Ball,<br />
<strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org TCA <strong>2016</strong>
ELECTRONIC LOGGING TECHNOLOGY DATA MANAGEMENT COMPLIANCE OVERSIGHT<br />
“<br />
We know drivers are the most<br />
important part of your operation<br />
and we take that trust seriously.<br />
Our driver-friendly app helps<br />
drivers transition to ELogs by using<br />
the smart devices they use everyday.<br />
And we support them 24/7 because<br />
<br />
and on the road.<br />
”<br />
Jason Goodrich<br />
Product Manager —<br />
Technology Solutions<br />
J. J. Keller & Associates, Inc.<br />
PARTNERSHIPS<br />
BEGIN WITH<br />
PEOPLE.<br />
We invite you to partner with our Hours of Service experts.<br />
Learn more at JJKeller.com/ELogs<br />
855.693.5338<br />
PC 117475
un by University of Virginia political scientist<br />
Larry Sabato, has the Republicans out<br />
front, 49-47, with tossups narrowed to four,<br />
New Hampshire, Pennsylvania, Indiana and<br />
Nevada.<br />
The Republicans, by virtue of their current<br />
comfortable Senate majority of 54<br />
seats, are coming up against a series of<br />
states that have an election (only one-third<br />
of the Senate is up for election every two<br />
years) and have Republican-held seats.<br />
There are also a large number of vulnerable<br />
Republican incumbents in <strong>2016</strong>, giving<br />
Democrats several opportunities for seat<br />
changes. Put another way, as RealClear<br />
Politics points out, Democrats have 44<br />
seats that are either not up for election or<br />
considered safe. Republicans have only 40<br />
safe or not up.<br />
Josh Katz of The New York Times stepped<br />
up and predicted a Democratic victory,<br />
based on The Times’ polls predicting a 52<br />
percent chance of the party taking control of<br />
the Senate. (This is not the same as predicting<br />
a 52-48 Democratic margin in seats. It<br />
merely predicts an edge of anywhere from<br />
one seat and up for the Democrats.)<br />
The Times’ model “suggests that the<br />
Democrats are slight favorites to win the<br />
Senate, based on the latest state and national<br />
polls,” Katz wrote October 7. Most<br />
polling websites, however, say the Senate<br />
is too close to call, based on a breakdown<br />
of state-by-state races.<br />
The tossup states include two open seats,<br />
Indiana and Nevada, where the incumbent<br />
is retiring, and all three sites rate these as<br />
too close to call. Nevada’s long-time Democratic<br />
incumbent, Harry Reid, who has<br />
served for 30 years, will be replaced either<br />
by Republican Rep. Joe Heck or Democrat<br />
Catherine Cortez Masto, the state’s former<br />
attorney general. In addition to RealClear<br />
Politics, the two other sites, 270ToWin and<br />
Sabato’s Crystal Ball, also rate the Nevada<br />
race as too close to call. In Indiana, where<br />
Republican Dan Coats is retiring, the battle<br />
is between former Democratic Sen. Evan<br />
Bayh and Rep. Todd Young, a Republican.<br />
Again, all three polls say the race is a tossup.<br />
Pennsylvania is another tossup at all<br />
three sites. Incumbent Republican Patrick<br />
Toomey faces Katie McGinty, a former secretary<br />
of the Pennsylvania Department of<br />
Environmental Protection.<br />
Illinois, once a widely rated tossup, is<br />
now trending Democratic on two sites and<br />
could be an important change of seats for<br />
the party. Incumbent Republican Mark Kirk<br />
is predicted to have a difficult time against<br />
Rep. Tammy Duckworth. Numerous analysts<br />
point to Illinois’ tendency to vote overwhelmingly<br />
for Democrats during presidential<br />
elections. Both candidates are physically<br />
disabled and often use a wheelchair.<br />
Kirk suffered a massive stroke in 2012.<br />
Duckworth, a U.S. Army veteran, lost both<br />
her legs and partial use of her right arm in<br />
2004 when the Black Hawk helicopter she<br />
was piloting in Iraq was shot down.<br />
New Hampshire remains a tossup on<br />
all three sites. Incumbent Republican Sen.<br />
Kelly Ayotte will face a significant challenge<br />
against Democratic Gov. Maggie Hassan in<br />
the general election. Again, this could be an<br />
important change of seats should the Democrat<br />
pull it out, amounting to a two-seat<br />
gain. Ayotte winning would simply maintain<br />
the status quo.<br />
North Carolina is neck-and-neck on two<br />
of the sites, but is leaning Republican on<br />
Sabato’s site. Again, this is a seat held by a<br />
Republican, Sen. Richard Burr, who is facing<br />
former North Carolina Rep. Deborah<br />
Ross. A win by Burr maintains the current<br />
count while a Ross victory would mean an<br />
important flip for the Democrats.<br />
In Missouri, Sen. Roy Blunt, a Republican,<br />
is in a tough race against Secretary of<br />
State Jason Kander. The election is a tossup<br />
on two sites, but Sabato shows Blunt with<br />
a narrow lead. Similarly, Florida, too close<br />
to call on two sites, is “leaning Republican”<br />
on Sabato’s site. Once again, a Republican,<br />
Sen. Marco Rubio, holds the seat. A loss<br />
to Democratic Rep. Patrick Murphy would<br />
be a tough flip for the Republicans, but if<br />
Sabato is right, the GOP may pull both of<br />
these out.<br />
That leaves states that are called tossups<br />
on 270toWin. Arizona Sen. John McCain,<br />
a 30-year veteran Republican, is facing<br />
Democratic Rep. Ann Kirkpatrick. While the<br />
other two sites rate this a probable Republican<br />
victory, some question this because<br />
of Republican presidential candidate Donald<br />
Trump’s perceived insulting comments<br />
about Hispanic Americans.<br />
“According to Mike Madrid, a Latino-focused<br />
Republican strategist, the results of<br />
Arizona’s Senate election will reveal whether<br />
the Republican Party has completely<br />
alienated minority voters in future elections<br />
by having Trump at the top of the ticket,”<br />
Ballotpedia.com stated. However, McCain<br />
has distanced himself from Trump, which<br />
could negate this issue.<br />
Wisconsin, rated a probable Democratic<br />
pickup by the other two sites, is still a tossup<br />
on 270toWin. Incumbent Republican<br />
Ron Johnson is seeking re-election to his<br />
second term in <strong>2016</strong> and will face Democrat<br />
Russ Feingold, who represented the<br />
state in the Senate from 1993 to 2011,<br />
when he was defeated by Johnson in the<br />
2010 election. Feingold was a popular<br />
senator who lost in a favorable Republican<br />
mid-term election, and this will be a tough<br />
challenge for the incumbent Republican.<br />
Again, should Feingold win, it will rate as a<br />
major pickup for the Democrats.<br />
Ohio, while rated safe for the Republican<br />
incumbent Rob Portman by Sabato<br />
and likely GOP by RealClear Politics, was<br />
called competitive by 270toWin October<br />
5, but moved to the Republican column<br />
in subsequent days. Despite this move,<br />
the Democrats increased their October<br />
5 lead of 45-44 to a 50-47 count, with<br />
North Carolina, Ohio and Arizona moving<br />
from tossup to Republican, and Nevada,<br />
Wisconsin, Illinois, Pennsylvania and New<br />
Hampshire dropping into the Democratic<br />
column.<br />
It is obvious that this will be a close election<br />
and counts will change daily on most<br />
sites. Much may depend on the presidential<br />
election. If Democrat Hillary Clinton, a<br />
former Secretary of State and U.S. Senator<br />
wins, she may pull enough Democratic<br />
votes with the old “coattails” political phenomenon<br />
to deliver the Senate to the party<br />
by several seats. Should New York businessman<br />
and tycoon Donald Trump succeed,<br />
the Republicans could pull it out by a<br />
seat or two. Either way, it’s fairly clear that<br />
neither party will have enough of an advantage<br />
to be able to move a solid agenda<br />
without the help of elements of the other<br />
party.<br />
However, in an important way, a single<br />
seat advantage is enough. As noted above,<br />
the majority party, no matter how slim that<br />
margin may be, is empowered to select<br />
the president pro tempore, or leader of the<br />
Senate. Even more importantly, the majority<br />
can choose every committee chairman<br />
and has a majority on every committee.<br />
Finally, there is the chance of a 50-50<br />
tie. Should this happen, the real president<br />
of the Senate, the U.S. vice president, will<br />
determine who takes the lead in Senate<br />
seats. Since the vice president of the U.S.<br />
breaks all tie votes, the winning vice presidential<br />
candidate, Democrat Tim Kaine, a<br />
U.S. Senator from Virginia, or Republican<br />
Mike Pence, Governor of Indiana, will create<br />
a Senate majority for his party.<br />
<strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org TCA <strong>2016</strong>
Data Doesn’t Make<br />
You Profitable.<br />
Knowing What to<br />
Do with It Does.<br />
The trucking industry has had a multi-layered problem with data traditionally.<br />
First, industry data has been virtually non-existent. Second, companies haven’t<br />
had robust, industry-specific tools for collecting and analyzing their corporate<br />
data. Finally, the expertise to interpret the data, find areas of profitability, and<br />
set goals to monitor success hasn’t been cultivated.<br />
<strong>Truckload</strong> Carriers Association collaborates with successful trucking<br />
executives to solve the data problem and revolutionize the industry by<br />
providing benchmarking resources that are chaning the future. Currently<br />
over 250 company leaders use the tools available through TCA.<br />
inGauge Online Benchmarking<br />
TCA’s inGauge platform harnesses industry data and<br />
anonymously ranks fleet performance based on Essential<br />
Performance Indicators (EPI). Using this online tool, you<br />
can focus on the areas that will drive profitability, efficiency,<br />
and risk mitigation for your company. With the analytical<br />
tools and statistical resources available through this service,<br />
trucking executives become active drivers of business<br />
success.<br />
Benchmarking Best Practice<br />
Groups<br />
Industry executives who have seen the value of the inGauge<br />
Online Benchmarking platform take the next step and get<br />
actively involved in Benchmarking Best Practices Groups.<br />
Teams of executives from eight to 12 non-competing<br />
companies share issues they face, talk about the challenges<br />
they have overcome, and discuss successful business<br />
strategies. These new peer relationships are supportive,<br />
creative, and motivating.<br />
You have to see the inGauge Online Benchmarking platform<br />
to truly understand its depth and breadth and how it can<br />
help you increase profitability. Sign up for a software demo<br />
at www.tcaingauge.com/bookdemo.<br />
Contact:<br />
Chris Henry<br />
TCA inGauge Program Manager<br />
888-504-6428<br />
info@tcaingauge.com<br />
“The technology within the transportation industry<br />
has provided us with access to a tremendous amount<br />
of data. Anyone can easily be overwhelmed with the<br />
abundance of information we now have access to. One<br />
can also be easily distracted with this data or simply<br />
not know where to focus their energy. Being part of<br />
benchmarking has allowed us to see where we are<br />
underperforming as well as where we are leading within<br />
our peer group. We have used this to create goals for<br />
our team members that have had a positive impact on<br />
our P&L. Benchmarking allowed us to hear the story<br />
and process behind the numbers.”<br />
Karen Smerchek<br />
Veriha Trucking<br />
Marinette, WI
CapItol recap<br />
A review of important news coming out of our nation’s capital.<br />
By Lyndon Finney and Dorothy Cox<br />
SPEED LIMITERS<br />
One thing’s for sure: A speed limiter rule is coming.<br />
The industry has known that since Congress put its<br />
foot down and told the Department of Transportation to<br />
get a rulemaking published — pronto.<br />
But exactly what will the mandated speed be?<br />
Well, the long-awaited (10 years) Notice of Proposed<br />
Rulemaking published jointly by the Federal Motor Carrier<br />
Safety Administration and the National Highway<br />
Traffic Safety Administration on August 26 would indeed<br />
require speed limiters on heavy vehicles. But regarding<br />
what speed exactly, it resembled a Chinese menu: 60,<br />
65, 68 or none of the above.<br />
Deep in the recesses of the NPRM, however, there<br />
is a hint at what the final speed might be and an admission<br />
that speed limiters might adversely impact small<br />
carriers.<br />
“Trucking fleets generally custom-order truck tractors<br />
and request speed limiting device settings from the<br />
manufacturer based on the costs and benefits of various<br />
maximum speeds,” the NPRM said. “The high number<br />
of vehicles set to 65 suggests that this is a reasonable<br />
maximum speed at which to efficiently and safely<br />
transport goods, even if it is not the optimum maximum<br />
speed for every company.”<br />
The agencies said that in deciding on a maximum<br />
speed they would also consider state speed limits and<br />
the economic impact on manufacturers and fleets including<br />
current speed limiter settings and the potential<br />
harmonization with the maximum set speed requirements<br />
of Canadian provinces of Ontario and Quebec<br />
of 65 mph.<br />
A vast majority of trucks that cross the border into<br />
the U.S. come from those two provinces.<br />
The American Trucking Associations, the <strong>Truckload</strong><br />
Carriers Association and Road Safe America, which<br />
along with ATA petitioned for speed limiters as far back<br />
as 2006, all support a 65 mph maximum speed limit.<br />
“There are several reasons, first and foremost being<br />
safety performance,” said David Heller, TCA’s vice<br />
president of government affairs. “A majority of accident<br />
reports cite the fact that the driver was going too fast for<br />
conditions, so there’s an opportunity to keep that excessive<br />
speed in check. There’s also the economic factor,<br />
as a 65 mph mandate would save fuel.”<br />
On the other hand, the Owner-Operator Independent<br />
Drivers Association has long opposed efforts to speed<br />
govern trucks and in 2014, when FMCSA and NHTSA<br />
were still debating the contents of the proposed rulemaking,<br />
asked its members to contact lawmakers and<br />
share their opposition to speed limiters.<br />
OOIDA said the proponents were attempting to force<br />
all trucks to be speed-limited so that the major trucking<br />
companies could compete for drivers with independent<br />
trucking operations that don’t have set speed limiters.<br />
Indeed, the NPRM says that the rule could adversely<br />
impact smaller carriers, primarily because of delivery<br />
times.<br />
The delivery time is based in part on the assumption<br />
that many trucks driven by independent owner-operators<br />
are not already speed limited as are those operated<br />
by large fleets, and many independent owner-operators<br />
drive the speed limit, which is 70 mph or higher in 35<br />
states.<br />
The agencies said because they do not have direct<br />
revenue figures for all carriers, power units serve as a<br />
proxy to determine the carrier size that would qualify as<br />
a small business given the Small Business Administration’s<br />
revenue threshold.<br />
According to the SBA, motor carriers of property with<br />
annual revenue of $25.5 million or less are considered<br />
small businesses.<br />
“The impact on small carriers could be significant<br />
from a competitive perspective,” the NPRM reads. “Regarding<br />
small trucking companies, the agencies predict<br />
that a speed limiting device might take away certain<br />
competitive advantages that small carriers might have<br />
over large trucking firms that already utilize speed limiting<br />
devices, but we have very limited knowledge of<br />
whether that impact is 10 percent of their business, or<br />
more, or less.<br />
“We estimated that independent owner-operators of<br />
combination trucks and single unit trucks would drive<br />
33,675 million miles annually out of 112,249 million<br />
miles traveled by these vehicles on rural and urban interstate<br />
highways. With the estimated average wage of<br />
$0.32/mile, the total annual revenue would be $10,776<br />
million. Unlike large trucking companies, small carriers<br />
with limited resources may not be able to increase<br />
the number of drivers to overcome the delay in delivery<br />
time. However, the competitive impacts are difficult<br />
to estimate. For example, with 65 mph speed limiting<br />
devices, we estimated that owner-operators would lose<br />
$50 million annually.<br />
“Accordingly, owner-operators would lose not more<br />
than 1 percent of their labor revenue. However, we note<br />
that the estimates were made based on very limited<br />
data. The agencies request comment on how large the<br />
economic impact might be on owner-operators.”<br />
With regard to truck power units, FMCSA determined<br />
in the Electronic On-Board Recorders and Hoursof-Service<br />
Supporting Documents Rulemaking Regulatory<br />
Impact Analysis that a power unit produces about<br />
$172,000 in revenue annually.<br />
The threshold of $25.5 million set by the SBA equates<br />
to 148 power units (148.26 = 25,500,000 / 172,000), according<br />
to the NPRM.<br />
Thus, FMCSA considers motor carriers of property<br />
with 148 power units or fewer to be small businesses for<br />
purposes of the analysis.<br />
FMCSA said it then looked at the number and percentage<br />
of property carriers with recent activity that<br />
would fall under that definition, and results show that<br />
over 99 percent of all interstate property carriers with<br />
recent activity have 148 power units or fewer, which<br />
amounts to about 493,000 carriers.<br />
“Therefore, the overwhelming majority of interstate<br />
carriers of property would be considered small entities,”<br />
the NPRM noted.<br />
Overall, FMCSA and NHTSA said they estimated<br />
that limiting the speed of heavy vehicles to 60 mph<br />
would save 162 to 498 lives annually; limiting the speed<br />
of heavy vehicles to 65 mph would save 63 to 214 lives<br />
annually; and limiting the speed to 68 mph would save<br />
27 to 96 lives annually.<br />
“Although we believe that the 60 mph alternative<br />
would result in additional safety benefits, we are not<br />
able to quantify the 60 mph alternative with the same<br />
confidence as the 65 mph and 68 mph alternatives,” the<br />
agencies said in the NPRM.<br />
“There are significant safety benefits to this proposed<br />
rulemaking,” U.S. Transportation Secretary Anthony<br />
Foxx said. “In addition to saving lives, the projected<br />
fuel and emissions savings make this proposal a win for<br />
safety, energy conservation and our environment.”<br />
The agencies’ proposal would establish safety standards<br />
requiring all newly manufactured U.S. trucks, buses,<br />
and multipurpose passenger vehicles with a gross<br />
vehicle weight rating more than 26,000 pounds to come<br />
equipped with speed limiting devices. The proposal discusses<br />
the benefits of setting the maximum speed at 60,<br />
65, and 68 miles per hour, but the agencies will consider<br />
other speeds based on public input.<br />
“This is basic physics,” said NHTSA Administrator<br />
Mark Rosekind. “Even small increases in speed have<br />
large effects on the force of impact. Setting the speed<br />
limit on heavy vehicles makes sense for safety and the<br />
environment.”<br />
“Safe trucking moves our economy and safe bus<br />
operations transport our loved ones,” said FMCSA Administrator<br />
T.F. Scott Darling, III. “This proposal will save<br />
lives while ensuring that our nation’s fleet of large commercial<br />
vehicles operates efficiently.”<br />
As for the implementation timeframe, the NPRM<br />
says NHTSA is proposing a lead time of three years<br />
from publication of a final rule for manufacturers to meet<br />
the proposed requirements.<br />
How long before a final rule is published would be<br />
pure speculation, but it is likely to occur no sooner than<br />
12 months given past rulemaking approval history and<br />
the fact that a new administration will take office during<br />
the preparation of the final rule.<br />
hos fix<br />
The trucking industry had hoped by this time that<br />
Congress would have passed legislation that would go a<br />
long way to settling the 34-hour restart controversy.<br />
But alas, much like a lot of other issues on the agenda<br />
of the nation’s 535 lawmakers, it wasn’t on time and the<br />
wait continued.<br />
At issue is a glitch in the FY<strong>2016</strong> omnibus spending<br />
bill passed in December 2015.<br />
The saga actually began in December 2014 when<br />
10 <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org TCA <strong>2016</strong>
Congress suspended the restart provision in the July 2013 Hours of Service rule that<br />
(1) required two consecutive 1 a.m. to 5 a.m. time periods to qualify as a restart and (2)<br />
allowed the restart provision to be utilized only once every seven days.<br />
The rule in place prior to July 2013 did not require the two consecutive overnight<br />
periods and allowed unlimited use of the restart provision.<br />
With the suspension in place, Congress set about trying to come up with a permanent<br />
restart provision and passed what lawmakers thought was a fix when they<br />
approved the FY<strong>2016</strong> omnibus appropriations bill.<br />
But uncertainty about the final disposition of the provision was unintentionally introduced<br />
by the omission of critical language that would have permanently suspended the<br />
more restrictive 34-hour restart provisions.<br />
So Congress set about trying to fix the omission in the FY2017 Transportation<br />
Housing and Urban Development and Related Agencies (THUD) appropriations bills.<br />
Eventually those bills would be agreed upon by conference committee and very<br />
likely will become part of the overall FY2017 omnibus appropriations bill.<br />
The House Appropriations Committee passed its THUD bill, but the full House never<br />
got around to voting.<br />
That would have permanently restored the 2005 restart provision that allows unlimited<br />
use of the restart provision and does not require two 1 a.m. to 5 a.m. periods<br />
in any restart.<br />
It differs from the Senate version in that it ties the future of any 34-hour restart<br />
provision directly to the results of FMCSA’s Congressionally-mandated study on the<br />
efficacy of the 2011 restart provision that was implemented July 1, 2013, and that was<br />
suspended by Congress in December 2014.<br />
The Senate version would require the study to establish that commercial motor<br />
vehicle drivers who operated under the restart provisions in effect between July 1,<br />
2013, and the day the provision was suspended, demonstrate statistically significant<br />
improvement in all outcomes related to safety, operator fatigue, driver health and longevity,<br />
and work schedules, in comparison to commercial motor vehicle drivers who<br />
operated under the restart provisions in operational effect on June 30, 2013 (i.e., the<br />
2005 restart rule).<br />
As the September 30 end to FY<strong>2016</strong> grew nearer, it became obvious that Congress<br />
would not pass an FY2017 omnibus spending bill but rather a continuing resolution<br />
keeping the government open past September 30, and that the resolution would be<br />
“clean” of controversial issues such as the restart rule.<br />
The continuing resolution runs out before the end of the 2015-<strong>2016</strong> Congressional<br />
session and most in the trucking industry believe the current Congress will pass an<br />
omnibus appropriations bill before it adjourns rather than leaving the problem up to the<br />
next Congress.<br />
ELDS<br />
The trucking industry is taking a wait-and-see attitude after oral arguments on<br />
the federal government’s electronic logging device mandate were heard in September<br />
by a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit. But both<br />
sides, for and against, hope the judges will rule in their favor.<br />
The ELD rule, released late last year and set to become effective in December<br />
2017, was challenged almost immediately by the Owner-Operator Independent Drivers<br />
Association, which got a similar rule vacated in 2011 when appeals judges agreed<br />
with OOIDA that the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration hadn’t sufficiently<br />
addressed the issue of ELDs being used to harass drivers.<br />
OOIDA, which represents small business truckers, early on had called the ELD<br />
mandate “arbitrary and capricious,” saying the mandate violated 4th Amendment rights<br />
against reasonable search and seizure, an argument OOIDA attorney Paul Cullen<br />
Sr. made again before appellate judges David Hamilton, Michael Kanne and William<br />
Bauer.<br />
OOIDA President and CEO Jim Johnston had said an ELD mandate could have “the<br />
single largest, most negative impact on the industry than anything done by FMCSA.”<br />
“The court has vacated the rule before so we are confident they will do so again,”<br />
OOIDA spokesperson Norita Taylor said.<br />
The American Trucking Associations had a different take on the oral arguments.<br />
ATA Deputy General Counsel Rich Pianka told <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> that “the threejudge<br />
panel showed little sympathy for OOIDA’s arguments in favor of overturning<br />
FMCSA’s rule requiring electronic logging devices.<br />
“In particular, the panel was extremely skeptical of OOIDA’s argument that the statu-<br />
To download our “Electronic Logs, Big Data & DOT<br />
Audits: What You Need to Know” whitepaper and<br />
learn about J. J. Keller’s Encompass® ELog system,<br />
visit JJKeller.com/ELogs or call 855.693.5338.<br />
J. J. KELLER’S ELD INSIGHTS<br />
Preparing for Audits<br />
in the Age of ELogs & Big Data<br />
Keeping up with the significant amount of data generated by electronic<br />
logging systems (ELDs) can be a challenging process. The key to<br />
managing it properly is learning how to use the information to your<br />
advantage, especially when it comes to audit preparation.<br />
When FMCSA investigates Hours of Service compliance at a carrier using<br />
electronic logs, the audit will be much different than for a carrier using<br />
paper logs. This is because the ELD data will show when the driver was<br />
driving and where, reducing the number of supporting documents the<br />
investigator will need to check.<br />
Detecting evidence of log falsification will not go away with electronic<br />
logging. The process will simply become more technical. The auditor<br />
will request and audit the electronic logs for specific drivers, including<br />
those who were involved in crashes or placed out of service, drivers who<br />
received Hours of Service violations during roadside inspections, and<br />
top performing drivers. The auditor will then focus on a few key areas:<br />
• Unassigned driver time: An investigator will examine details<br />
surrounding any recorded unassigned driving time.<br />
• Edits: An excessive number of edits or those fitting certain patterns<br />
will catch the investigator’s eye.<br />
• Driver roster: To locate ghost driver accounts, an investigator will<br />
compare drivers on your roster to drivers in the ELog system.<br />
• Device malfunctions: To determine a possible malfunction, an<br />
investigator will look at the drivers involved, hours logged at the<br />
time the failure occurred, and any noticeable patterns.<br />
• On-duty time logged as off-duty: If the driver has little or no<br />
on-duty time recorded, the investigator will ask for supporting<br />
documents and check for falsification.<br />
• Off-duty driving: Most systems allow the back office to move<br />
assigned or unassigned driving to personal conveyance and assign<br />
it to the correct driver. An investigator will verify the activity meets<br />
personal conveyance requirements.<br />
Knowing where to focus your attention will be key to proactive<br />
compliance management. To prepare for changes in the DOT audit<br />
process caused by ELogs, modify your internal auditing to look for the<br />
same issues the FMCSA investigator will be looking for during an audit.<br />
Fleet Management System<br />
with ELogs<br />
TCA <strong>2016</strong> www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org | <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> 11
tory requirement that the devices be ‘automatic’ precluded any user input whatsoever,<br />
at one point suggesting that this was tantamount to arguing that Congress mandated<br />
a ‘square circle.’”<br />
Pianka went on to say that the panel “appeared similarly unconvinced by OOIDA’s<br />
claim that ELDs will result in no compliance improvements whatsoever.”<br />
“As ATA explained in an amicus brief it filed in the case, while ELDs do not foreclose<br />
all possibility of hiding HOS noncompliance, it makes impossible any number<br />
of noncompliance scenarios that falsified paper logs could easily conceal. We look<br />
forward to the Seventh Circuit’s decision in the case and fully expect the rule to be<br />
upheld.”<br />
Both ATA and the <strong>Truckload</strong> Carriers Association have favored the ELD mandate<br />
and TCA Vice President of Government Affairs David Heller said, “TCA is anxiously<br />
waiting and hoping” the judges “uphold the final rule in favor of the agency … and we<br />
can clear up one [regulatory] log jam.”<br />
Cullen set forth five reasons why the mandate should be vacated a second time:<br />
• ELDs don’t “automatically” record Hours of Service changes-of-duty status as<br />
required by Congress<br />
• They again fall short of protecting against driver harassment<br />
• They don’t protect driver confidentiality and data, especially given that state law<br />
enforcement officers are the ones who stop drivers and check for compliance<br />
• They violate 4th Amendment rights against unreasonable search and seizure,<br />
and<br />
• It hasn’t been proven that the benefits of complying with the ELD mandate outweigh<br />
the costs.<br />
Cullen also said ELDs don’t prove HOS compliance any better than paper logs and<br />
that “there’s no way to know [with an ELD] if you’re in compliance with federal hours<br />
the first minute of driving,” to which Judge Hamilton said it would tell when a driver was<br />
past his 11 hours.<br />
Cullen replied that by FMCSA’s own admission, most accidents occur in the first<br />
two hours of a driver’s day. He added that the mandate “still has a capacity for mischief”<br />
in the area of harassment that goes beyond HOS.<br />
Joshua Waldman, an attorney for the U.S. Department of Justice representing<br />
DOT, countered that FMCSA had asked drivers what harassment meant to them and<br />
addressed those issues in its rulemaking, plus added civil penalties for using ELDs<br />
to harass drivers.<br />
At one point, Judge Hamilton told Cullen if, as OOIDA says, ELDs have to record<br />
everything drivers do, such a device “would have to be unbelievably intrusive.”<br />
Then after grilling Cullen on some of his answers, turned to Waldman and asked<br />
him if he would still maintain the ELD mandate wasn’t interfering with 4th Amendment<br />
rights if such devices were put in passenger cars to monitor drivers and he wanted to<br />
know who would look at the resulting data.<br />
If the judges rule against OOIDA’s challenge, ELDs would be required beginning<br />
in December 2017.<br />
sLEEP APNEA<br />
The Medical Review Board of the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration<br />
has made its recommendations on screening transportation professionals for sleep<br />
apnea in response to a joint Advanced Notice of Proposed Rulemaking by FMCSA<br />
and the Federal Railroad Administration (FRA) requesting data and information concerning<br />
the prevalence of moderate-to-severe obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) among<br />
individuals occupying safety-sensitive positions in highway and rail transportation, and<br />
on its potential consequences for the safety of rail and highway transportation.<br />
The recommendations are non-binding as the two agencies prepare the Notice<br />
of Proposed Rulemaking.<br />
The board recommended mandatory screening for any truck driver with a body<br />
mass index of 40 or more who has admitted fatigue or sleeping during wakeful<br />
periods, or for any drivers who have been involved in sleep-related motor vehicle<br />
accidents.<br />
Screening would also be required for anyone who possesses a BMI of 33 and<br />
has at least three of the following risk factors:<br />
• Untreated hypertension<br />
• Type 2 diabetes<br />
• Loud snoring<br />
• Witnessed apneas<br />
• Small airway/mallampati score (used to predict the ease of endotracheal intubation)<br />
• A neck size of 17 or more for males and 15.5 or more for females<br />
• Age 42 or older<br />
• Male or post-menopausal female<br />
• Untreated hypothyroidism<br />
• Stroke, coronary or artery disease, and<br />
• Micrognathia (undersized jaw) or retrognathia (abnormal posterior positioning<br />
of the maxilla or mandible, particularly the mandible, relative to the facial skeleton<br />
and soft tissues).<br />
The board also set forth recommendations as to when a driver could be immediately<br />
disqualified and referred for OSA diagnostic testing if either of the following<br />
conditions exist:<br />
• Individuals have admitted fatigue or sleepiness during the wake period, and<br />
• Individuals have been involved in a sleep-related motor vehicle crash or accident<br />
or near crash.<br />
The board said drivers found to be noncompliant with treatment regimens outlined<br />
in the recommendation should be disqualified immediately until evaluated<br />
and treated effectively.<br />
The recommendation also suggests that certified medical examiners should<br />
have the discretion to disqualify any driver who appears to be at extremely high<br />
risk, and that drivers disqualified for any of the reasons set forth above must remain<br />
disqualified until evaluated and treated effectively.<br />
The board also set forth recommendations on how a driver determined to be at<br />
risk based on his or her BMI (with or without risk factors) could be certified for a<br />
set number of days pending a sleep study and treatment if the driver is diagnosed<br />
with OSA.<br />
The Department of Transportation rulemaking calendar does not set forth a<br />
date for when the NPRM will be published.<br />
Statistics show the average height of a male in the U.S. is 5 feet 9 inches. That<br />
person would have to weigh 225 pounds to have a BMI of 33 and 275 pounds for<br />
a BMI of 40, according to the American Cancer Society.<br />
The average height of a female in the U.S. is 5 feet 4 inches. That person<br />
would have to weigh 190 pounds to have a BMI of 33 and 235 pounds to have a<br />
BMI of 40.<br />
REST BREAK<br />
The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration has quietly denied a petition<br />
from the Commercial Vehicle Safety Alliance (CVSA) asking that the Hours of Service<br />
30-minute rest break provision be removed from the regulation.<br />
The CVSA petition, filed October 28, 2015, said the rest break provision which<br />
went into effect July 1, 2013, “is difficult to effectively enforce since the inspector<br />
has no way of verifying whether or not the driver was legitimately off duty during<br />
that time or if he/she used the time to perform other work-related duties, such as<br />
fueling, inspection or loading and unloading items.”<br />
The CVSA said in the petition it did not believe there is evidence that the requirement<br />
improves a driver’s overall commercial motor vehicle operational capabilities<br />
or increases safety.<br />
The alliance also pointed out that FMCSA had issued nine exemptions to the<br />
30-minute rest break to various segments of the trucking industry and that in each<br />
of these instances, the agency indicated that an equivalent level of safety could be<br />
maintained under the exemption.<br />
CVSA is a nonprofit association comprising local, state, provincial, territorial<br />
and federal commercial motor vehicle safety officials and industry representatives.<br />
It aims to achieve uniformity, compatibility and reciprocity of commercial motor<br />
vehicle inspections and enforcement by certified inspectors dedicated to driver<br />
and vehicle safety.<br />
In a letter to CVSA Executive Director Colin Mooney, FMCSA Administrator<br />
Scott Darling said that neither scientific research relied upon to create the 30-<br />
minute rest break provision nor the roadside inspection data reviewed for the<br />
calendar years 2013, 2014 and 2015, supported the contention that the safety<br />
benefits are questionable or that enforcement is particularly difficult, even after<br />
granting exemptions for certain industry segments.<br />
In denying the petition, FMCSA also cited 2011 studies that it said demonstrated<br />
that breaks reduce the risk of crashes after a break and that while any break<br />
from driving reduces risk in the hour following the break, off-duty breaks produced<br />
that largest reduction.<br />
“The benefits of breaks from driving ranged from a 30- to 50-percent reduction<br />
in risk of a safety-critical event with the greatest occurring for off-duty (non-working)<br />
breaks,” Darling said in his letter to Mooney.<br />
In conclusion, Darling said that CVSA had not provided any data or information<br />
that would suggest that the 30-minute break provision places an undue burden<br />
either on regulated carriers or the enforcement community.<br />
12 <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org TCA <strong>2016</strong>
THREE OTHER RULEMAKINGS<br />
Three key Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration rulemakings remain in<br />
various stages of progress:<br />
• The Final Rule on Entry-Level Driver Training could well be published by year’s<br />
end;<br />
• The Notice of Proposed Rulemaking on the Commercial Driver’s License Drug and<br />
Alcohol Clearinghouse also is expected to be published before the end of <strong>2016</strong>; and<br />
• The comment period on the NPRM for Carrier Fitness Safety Determination has<br />
ended.<br />
The industry has for the most part lauded the driver training standards, and believed<br />
they couldn’t come soon enough.<br />
Under the rule, for the first time ever applicants seeking a “Class A” CDL —<br />
necessary for operating a combination tractor-trailer type vehicle weighing 26,001<br />
pounds or more — would be required to obtain a minimum of 30 hours of behindthe-wheel<br />
training from an instructional program that meets FMCSA standards,<br />
including a minimum of 10 hours of operating the vehicle on a practice driving<br />
range.<br />
The behind-the-wheel training requirement is the first such standard set forth in a<br />
formal regulation.<br />
“The <strong>Truckload</strong> Carriers Association supports this rulemaking,” said David Heller,<br />
TCA vice president of government affairs. “It will help us get better-trained drivers on<br />
our highways, a step that will reinforce with the public our commitment to safety.”<br />
There is no requirement for behind-the-wheel training in current federal regulations.<br />
That’s not the case with the Professional Truck Driver Institute (PTDI), which is managed<br />
by TCA. Since at least 1998, drivers who attended a school with a PTDI-certified<br />
course had to complete 44 hours of behind-the-wheel training.<br />
The Final Rule has been under review at the Office of Management and Budget<br />
since August 29.<br />
The industry has long asked for the drug and alcohol clearinghouse as a way to<br />
prevent the practice of drivers who’ve either failed a screening or refused a screening<br />
from merely going down the road and applying at another carrier.<br />
“We support this even though we don’t know for certain how the language will read,<br />
but reporting positive drug tests for drivers is a good thing,” Heller said. “It’s a chance for<br />
carriers to see what kind of driver they are hiring.”<br />
He said no one in the industry has any indication of the timeframe for reporting previous<br />
positive test results and/or refusals to test. “The thought process is that it would<br />
record all positive drug tests and would also record refusals to test. I don’t know how<br />
far back it would go.”<br />
The NPRM has been under review at the Office of Management and Budget since<br />
May 18.<br />
The Carrier Safety Fitness Determination NPRM is certainly not without controversy,<br />
including concerns aired by TCA.<br />
“It’s fair to note that the Carrier Safety Fitness Determination as written only affects<br />
about 15 percent of the industry or less than 75,000 motor carriers,” Heller said. “That<br />
doesn’t cut mustard.”<br />
A carrier’s safety fitness determination is based on inspection and citation data<br />
and some carriers are just not generating enough data to have a determination of their<br />
safety fitness made, Heller said.<br />
“So you’re creating a rule that doesn’t measure the majority, only a small minority.<br />
Carriers aren’t afraid to be rated, but they all want to be treated the same; there’s no<br />
sense having a program that rates such a small portion of the carriers. Those carriers<br />
that are getting inspected and thus generating data are the ones that are being<br />
judged.<br />
“The other thing is that just because a carrier is not rated unfit doesn’t mean they’re<br />
fit to operate — because if they aren’t generating data they are going to be rated as fit<br />
and that may not necessarily be the case.”<br />
In its comments to FMCSA, TCA also pointed out that without a standardized process<br />
instituted for the nation’s enforcement personnel, data generated at the roadside can<br />
often vary based upon geographic location, reliability and more often than not, the sheer<br />
absence of roadside inspections by many carriers who operate on the highways.<br />
“While roadside inspections will generate real-time, on-road performance measures,<br />
the mere incorporation of this data into determining a carrier’s safety fitness will<br />
lend itself to present a score that has proven to be at the very least, subjective in<br />
nature,” TCA said.<br />
FMCSA will use all 171 comments submitted on the NPRM to write its Final<br />
Rule.<br />
DON’T LIKE<br />
SURPRISES?<br />
Professional drivers know that CAT Scale<br />
delivers a reliable, accurate, certified weigh<br />
with an unconditional guarantee. CAT Scale is<br />
the largest truck scale network in the world<br />
with more than 1,725 locations in the<br />
United States and Canada, there’s always a<br />
CAT Scale open when your driver needs one.<br />
Find out how the Weigh My Truck App<br />
can save your drivers time weighing.<br />
1-877-CAT-SCALE (228-7225)<br />
catscale.com | weighmytruck.com<br />
Now accepting:<br />
HAS<br />
YOUR BACK
FINDING ways to pay<br />
By Dorothy Cox<br />
Upon reading a news article on philly.com a couple of years ago<br />
about the Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission financing the Turnpike’s link<br />
with I-95 by borrowing $500,000 each from Chinese investors in return<br />
for the investors and their families being granted legal immigration visas,<br />
a Facebook reader commented: “I now know I have to put down this crack<br />
pipe and dedicate myself to sobriety. You won’t believe what I thought I<br />
just read.”<br />
The heavily indebted Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission is borrowing<br />
a reported $200 million from the Chinese investors under the federal<br />
immigrant investor program that grants EB-5 visas to foreigners who<br />
provide at least $500,000 to U.S. projects that create 10 or more American<br />
jobs.<br />
Indeed, states and other local governmental and quasi-governmental<br />
entities are having to get creative to rustle up money to build new infrastructure<br />
and fix existing highways and bridges.<br />
Earlier this year trucking watched as one piece of legislation after another<br />
to fund road fixes fell in a huge pothole, never to be heard from<br />
again. Finally, Congress was able to get itself together and pull a fast<br />
one — the FAST Act or Fixing America’s Surface Transportation Act. But<br />
lawmakers have been unwilling or unable so far to come up with a way<br />
to keep the Highway Trust Fund (HTF) solvent, or a long-range funding<br />
mechanism absent the HTF to maintain U.S. roads and bridges.<br />
So states and local governments and other entities, most of which have<br />
had funding shortfalls of their own, have had to look elsewhere.<br />
Dave Heller, TCA’s vice president of government affairs, notes that<br />
since 2013, 19 states and the District of Columbia have increased their<br />
fuel taxes to fund transportation projects and that several states, including<br />
California and Oregon, have successfully deployed pilot programs on a<br />
vehicle miles traveled tax.<br />
“TCA and its members continually monitor new fundraising revenue<br />
streams so that we can stay abreast of the situation and stay on top of<br />
infrastructure funding,” he says, adding that TCA supports increasing the<br />
fuel tax and indexing it to an appropriate annual cap.<br />
Some states have advanced proposals to put “lockboxes” on all monies<br />
raised through transportation-related levies such as fuel taxes, tolls,<br />
license fees, vehicle registration fees etc., requiring those funds be spent<br />
on transportation needs.<br />
Duh.<br />
Other states have proposed additional cigarette taxes or taxing electric<br />
hybrid vehicles, which aren’t being taxed — yet.<br />
Some states want to increase vehicle registration fees or add a state<br />
tax on oil changes and auto repairs.<br />
Still others want to use any excess state tax reserves for transportation.<br />
Mississippi is discussing dedicating part of its BP Oil settlement to<br />
transportation.<br />
In general, states are looking for investments to be part of the threelegged<br />
stool of funding: federal, state and local money, says Joung Lee,<br />
director of policy for the American Association of State Highway and<br />
Transportation Officials (AASHTO).<br />
And although states may come up with funding through other means<br />
they will always need some sort of federal funding, he told <strong>Truckload</strong><br />
<strong>Authority</strong>.<br />
“You need reliable funding to pay for infrastructure,” he said. Financing,<br />
like a house mortgage, allows payments to be amortized over time:<br />
Build it now and pay over time, but financing “is contingent on some sort<br />
of revenue.”<br />
Trucking has largely favored increasing fuel taxes to raise road revenue,<br />
but many politicians have been reluctant, afraid it will cost them<br />
their seats as state and federal lawmakers.<br />
But a report released September 6 by the American Road & Transportation<br />
Builders Association (ARTBA) said a new analysis of eight states that passed<br />
legislation to increase their state motor fuel taxes in 2015 to pay for new transportation<br />
improvements showed that 98 percent of Republican and Democratic<br />
lawmakers who supported the bills won their primary races in <strong>2016</strong>.<br />
14 <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org TCA <strong>2016</strong>
for road projects<br />
“These results should dispel any notion that<br />
voting to increase the state gas tax is politically<br />
toxic,” says ARTBA Chief Economist Dr. Alison<br />
Premo Black, who conducted the research.<br />
“Voters expect lawmakers to put forward<br />
solutions to help reduce traffic congestion, improve<br />
road safety and help grow the economy.<br />
They’re also willing to pay for these expanded<br />
investments,” she adds.<br />
It sounds too good to be true.<br />
But a survey last year by the American Trucking<br />
Associations seems to show that the public is<br />
coming around.<br />
The survey found that infrastructure spending<br />
is second only to education (by a 64-60 margin),<br />
as an area on which the public thinks more<br />
money needs to be spent.<br />
Furthermore:<br />
• The number of people who believe more<br />
needs to be spent on infrastructure has risen<br />
12 points — from 48 percent in 2014 to 60 percent.<br />
• Forty percent of the public thinks infrastructure<br />
should be a top priority for federal<br />
spending.<br />
• Sixty-three percent of Americans believe<br />
roads and bridges are not being properly maintained.<br />
• And a majority of Americans — 53 percent<br />
— believe it will be necessary to raise taxes to<br />
properly maintain roads and bridges.<br />
• However, the public remains opposed to raising<br />
the fuel tax, raising income taxes, interstate<br />
tolling and adding registration fees to pay for<br />
needed maintenance, but when forced to choose<br />
—supports raising the fuel tax over tolling.<br />
The Federal Highway Administration on August<br />
30 announced $14.2 million in grants to<br />
state transportation departments to “test new<br />
ways of funding highways.”<br />
It’s called the Surface Transportation System<br />
Fund Alternatives grant program, a long name<br />
for a program to explore alternative revenue<br />
mechanisms. This will “help sustain the longterm<br />
solvency of the Highway Trust Fund,” said<br />
FHWA in announcing the grants.<br />
The funding will go to eight projects that will<br />
use a variety of options to raise revenue including<br />
on-board vehicle technologies to charge<br />
drivers based on miles traveled, multi-state or<br />
regional approaches to road user charges or<br />
RUCs, and others.<br />
The California DOT will use RUCs using payat-the-pump<br />
charging stations ($750,000).<br />
In Delaware, the state DOT will institute user<br />
fees based on on-board mileage counters in collaboration<br />
with members of the I-95 Corridor<br />
Coalition ($1,490,000).<br />
Missouri DOT will implement a new registration<br />
fee schedule based on estimated mpg<br />
($250,000).<br />
Here are some existing and potential revenue<br />
options provided by AASHTO:<br />
Container Tax – A national fee imposed<br />
on some or all containers moving through the<br />
U.S. AASHTO says this has a strong sustainability<br />
factor but that there are potential trade law<br />
conflicts.<br />
Customs Revenues – Customs duties are<br />
imposed at varying rates on various imported<br />
goods and currently go into the General Fund<br />
of the U.S. Treasury although AASHTO’s policy<br />
commission and others have suggested that a<br />
portion of the duties collected be used to supplement<br />
transportation investments.<br />
Drivers License Surcharge – Although this<br />
fee is often used to recoup the cost of administration<br />
of state licensing programs, some states<br />
are using it to finance transportation or even<br />
other programs.<br />
Freight Bill – A freight waybill tax would be<br />
like a sales tax on freight shipping costs. AASH-<br />
TO says such a tax could be modeled on the aviation<br />
system tax in which passenger and freight<br />
users who rely on the same infrastructure and<br />
carriers all would contribute.<br />
Freight Charge or Ton Mile Tax – This has<br />
historically had strong opposition from trucking<br />
as well as rail. It would charge shippers a flat fee<br />
for every ton of freight moved. Unfortunately,<br />
the tax’s impact would be the heaviest on lowvalue<br />
bulk items.<br />
Harbor Maintenance Tax – This existing<br />
revenue mechanism is similar to customs duties<br />
and fees and supports the federal Harbor Maintenance<br />
Trust Fund.<br />
Heavy Vehicle Use Tax – This annual fee is<br />
currently imposed on all trucks 55,000 pounds<br />
GVW or greater and although, says AASHTO, it’s<br />
easy and cost-effective to administer, it doesn’t<br />
raise a lot of revenue.<br />
Imported Oil Tax – The tax is on imported<br />
TCA <strong>2016</strong> www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org | <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> 15
oil and charged as either a fixed amount per barrel of oil or as a percentage<br />
on the value of imported oil. It’s a small fee that could raise a significant<br />
amount of revenue but there’s not a direct correlation between<br />
who’s taxed and what the money is used for. For example, home heating<br />
oil would be taxed for transportation.<br />
Business/Personal Income Tax – AASHTO says a national income<br />
tax for transportation could be created fairly easily and inexpensively by<br />
dedicating a portion of tax receipts to transportation, although it could<br />
negatively impact the federal budget.<br />
Motor Fuel Tax – The last time fuel taxes were increased for transportation<br />
purposes was 1993. The United States federal excise tax on<br />
gasoline is 18.4 cents per gallon and 24.4 cents per gallon for diesel fuel.<br />
The problem, of course, is that the HTF has long-term sustainability issues<br />
although on the plus side it has a large revenue yield with a small rate<br />
change and the administration mechanism is already in place.<br />
Motor Fuel Tax Indexing – This establishes an annual adjustment to<br />
motor fuel tax rates by adjusting for inflation but depends on motor fuels<br />
as the primary HTF funding source.<br />
Oil, Gas and Minerals Receipts – The federal government receives<br />
income in the form of royalties, bonus bids and other payments from the<br />
extraction of oil, natural gas and minerals from federal lands and offshore<br />
mining and some of the receipts could be dedicated to transportation purposes.<br />
Registration Fees for Light-duty Vehicles and/or Trucks – All<br />
states impose these fees and at least half the states raise more than a<br />
quarter of their dedicated transportation funds through this mechanism.<br />
It could be viewed as double taxation.<br />
Sales Tax for Auto-related Parts and Services – A national sales<br />
tax could be established on all services related to vehicle use. Although it<br />
would bring in substantial revenue, there are administrative and compliance<br />
issues as well as social equity issues, notes AASHTO.<br />
Sales Tax on Bicycles – There is currently no such tax but one idea<br />
is to use a portion of the sales tax on bicycles to fund transportation improvements,<br />
although it probably wouldn’t raise much revenue.<br />
Sales Tax on Diesel/Gas – A national sales tax on motor fuels could<br />
be imposed as a percentage of motor fuel costs. A few states already do<br />
this, most in the 4 to 6 percent range, but fuel price volatility could lead to<br />
unpredictable revenues, not to mention public opposition.<br />
Sales Tax on New/Used Light-duty Vehicles – This would most<br />
likely be levied as a percentage of the total sales price for either all new<br />
or new/used vehicle purchases.<br />
Sales Tax on Trucks/Trailers – A federal sales tax of 12 percent<br />
is imposed on the retail sales price for the first sale of all tractors and<br />
trucks over 33,000 pounds in GVW and trailers over 26,000 pounds GVW<br />
including parts and accessories associated with the sale. The revenue potential<br />
is limited and unstable but funds have strong sustainability, says<br />
AASHTO.<br />
Tire Tax/Bicycles – There’s no such tax currently; it would be very<br />
sustainable but not bring in much money.<br />
Tire Tax/Light Duty Vehicles – This would likely be implemented in<br />
conjunction with the current federal truck tire tax.<br />
Tire Tax/Trucks – A federal tax is imposed on the purchase of tires<br />
for trucks with a maximum rated load over 3,500 pounds, said to recover<br />
some of the additional system damage costs caused by heavier vehicles.<br />
The current tax rate is 9.45 cents for every 10 pounds of maximum capacity<br />
that exceeds 3,500 pounds.<br />
Transit Passenger Miles Traveled Fee – This would be a national<br />
fee on each mile of travel on transit systems across all modes and would<br />
be levied in addition to current local transit fares. There is strong public<br />
and political opposition to this fee, says AASHTO, but a strong correlation<br />
between fee and user and it would be sustainable.<br />
Vehicle Miles Traveled Fee — Drivers can be charged for the total<br />
number of miles traveled regardless of the road used or time of day.<br />
Oregon DOT’s fee system will allow up to 5,000 voluntary participants to<br />
choose from a number of ways to collect the data. Again, public and political<br />
opposition is strong, but the revenue yield is potentially high.<br />
Values Drive Performance<br />
Shared Values Can Lead to Organizational Excellence<br />
We understand you are in business to make a profit. Our Value-Driven Company modules can<br />
<br />
<br />
We believe it is everyone’s job to do what they can to prevent losses. We have developed a<br />
<br />
<br />
We see “Critical Crashes” as a risk to your company. Our Value-Driven <br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
GREAT WEST CASUALTY COMPANY<br />
The Difference is Service ® <br />
800.228.8602<br />
gwccnet.com<br />
16 <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org TCA <strong>2016</strong>
Cradle to Cab:<br />
Will Pilot answer Safety<br />
Questions about Young Drivers?<br />
By Lyndon Finney<br />
The time period has ended for trucking stakeholders to respond to the Federal<br />
Motor Carrier Safety Administration’s request for input on the agency’s proposed pilot<br />
program allowing drivers of military heavy vehicles between the ages of 18 and 21 to<br />
operate commercial motor vehicles in interstate commerce. As for the <strong>Truckload</strong> Carriers<br />
Association, the FMCSA could go one step further.<br />
“You got it,” said David Heller, vice president of government affairs, when asked<br />
if a statement in a TCA letter to the FMCSA meant the association would like to see<br />
any 18- to 21-year old with a CDL (military or otherwise) be part of the pilot.<br />
That statement reads, “TCA supports, in principle, the authorization by the FMCSA<br />
of carefully structured experimental programs for use of younger drivers (18, 19 and<br />
20), provided that such drivers have been carefully screened, received quality training<br />
from a school or training program certified by the Professional Truck Driver Institute<br />
(PTDI), and will be closely supervised and monitored by a motor carrier which<br />
has a ‘satisfactory’ safety rating and such other approvals and requirements deemed<br />
essential by FMCSA. Since 2000, TCA has advocated for the development of such a<br />
program that would begin to prove whether or not drivers who are carefully selected,<br />
trained and observed and are between the ages of 18 and 20 years old, could safely<br />
operate a commercial motor vehicle in interstate commerce.”<br />
The FMCSA said it is also proposing criteria for a working group to consult with<br />
the agency in conducting, monitoring and evaluating the pilot program. TCA would<br />
lobby to be part of that group.<br />
During the proposed three-year pilot program, the safety records of these younger<br />
drivers — known as the study group — would be compared to the records of a control<br />
group of comparable size, comprising drivers who are 21 years of age or older<br />
and who have comparable training and experience in driving vehicles requiring a CDL.<br />
The control group would consist of volunteer drivers who meet specified criteria<br />
and are employed by a participating carrier.<br />
The comparison of the two groups’ performances would help to determine whether<br />
age is a critical safety factor, the agency stated.<br />
Heller, noting that TCA had advocated a similar pilot in 2000, said TCA strongly<br />
supports the proposed pilot program.<br />
“It’s an effort to gather data on an issue for which there is no data. We left looking<br />
for data” that is just not available, Heller said, adding that the pilot would help<br />
prove whether younger drivers are as safe, safer or less safe than drivers older than<br />
21.<br />
“I can get on the roof of our building and see all over Washington, Maryland and<br />
Virginia,” he said, “but if I’m 21 or younger, I can’t drive to those locations from Virginia<br />
but I can drive all over Virginia.”<br />
Heller said if the pilot proves that drivers under 21 are capable of driving safely in<br />
interstate commerce, it would open the door for more recruiting efforts designed to<br />
draw high school graduates into the trucking profession.<br />
Efforts to lower the minimum driving age go back at least to the early 1970s<br />
when the Federal Highway Administration, FMCSA’s predecessor agency, examined<br />
the subject of the minimum age of CMV drivers as part of a comprehensive overhaul<br />
of the driver qualification requirements. FHWA conducted a literature review and<br />
analyzed crash statistics and psychological data and determined that most drivers<br />
under the age of 21 “lack the general maturity, skill and judgment that is necessary<br />
in handling commercial motor vehicles.”<br />
The report concluded that there was no support for lowering the age limit of 21.<br />
Subsequently, on October 2, 2000, TCA petitioned FMCSA to conduct a younger<br />
driver pilot program.<br />
Motor carriers, truck driver training schools, a trade association and an insurance<br />
company joined in the petition asking FMCSA to authorize a pilot program to determine<br />
if CMV drivers under age 21 could operate CMVs safely in interstate commerce,<br />
saying the pilot could help address the shortage of drivers.<br />
In February 2001 FMCSA published a notice asking six questions about the<br />
proposed pilot program and requesting public comment on the TCA proposal and<br />
received more than 1,600 comments.<br />
More than 90 percent of the commenters were opposed, most on the basis that<br />
individuals under the age of 21 lacked the maturity and judgment to operate a CMV.<br />
Very few truck drivers and motor carriers commented, but most of them also opposed<br />
the pilot program.<br />
After a 2003 Senate report questioned the need for such a pilot, FMCSA denied<br />
the TCA petition, stating that “the agency does not have sufficient information at<br />
this time to make a determination that the safety measures in the pilot program<br />
are designed to achieve a level of safety equivalent to, or greater than, the level of<br />
safety provided by complying with the minimum 21-year age requirement to operate<br />
a CMV.”<br />
The agency said in a notice to be published in the Federal Register that because<br />
many service personnel leave active duty while close to or over the age of 21, it is<br />
likely that most study group members would be reservists or National Guard members.<br />
To have a statistically valid sample of drivers under the age of 21, approximately<br />
200 study group participants are desired.<br />
Participating carriers that meet the qualifications described later in this notice<br />
would sponsor study group members and perform other duties related to the pilot,<br />
such as filing certain reports and recruiting existing drivers to participate as control<br />
group members.<br />
To reduce the administrative effort involved, FMCSA anticipates that a fairly small<br />
number of carriers would be selected to participate.<br />
For TCA’s complete comments to FMCSA about the pilot program go to<br />
reglations.gov and enter docket number FMCSA-<strong>2016</strong>-0069.<br />
TCA <strong>2016</strong> www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org | <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> 17
Presidential Promises<br />
By Cliff Abbott<br />
If the polls are to be believed, not everyone is happy about their<br />
choices for president of the United States in the upcoming election. One<br />
bipartisan group, however, is praising both the Democrat and Republican<br />
candidates for their proposals to address the country’s crumbling infrastructure.<br />
“We really believe that we’ll see an infrastructure proposal within the<br />
first 100 days of a new administration, whichever candidate is elected,”<br />
explained Kerry O’Hare, vice president and director of policy at Building<br />
America’s Future Educational Fund (BAFEF).<br />
Founded in 2008, BAFEF is a bipartisan coalition of elected officials<br />
that are working to elevate the discussion about the U.S. infrastructure.<br />
Former Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger of California, former Governor<br />
Ed Rendell of Pennsylvania and former New York City Mayor Michael<br />
Bloomberg co-founded the organization.<br />
BAFEF’s involvement with the presidential election goes beyond monitoring<br />
each candidate’s campaign for news of infrastructure policy. The<br />
group has actively participated in the process, conducting moderated<br />
discussion panels at each of the major party’s national conventions.<br />
“I was involved with the Republican National Convention (RNC), while<br />
Marsha (BAFEF President Marsha L. Hale) worked with the Democratic<br />
National Convention (DNC),” said O’Hare. At the RNC, [former U.S. Secretary<br />
of Transportation] Ray LaHood and Oklahoma City Mayor Mick<br />
Cornett joined a panel that tackled the question, “what would your advice<br />
be to the presidential candidate that is elected to advance a plan<br />
centered not just on repair and upgrade of our infrastructure but also<br />
making it more relevant to the direction so many cities are going?”<br />
Cornett is also current president of the U.S. Conference of Mayors.<br />
Sen. Deb Fischer (Nebraska), who chairs the Senate Commerce Subcommittee<br />
on Surface Transportation and Merchant Marine Infrastructure,<br />
Safety and Security and Ben Brockschmidt, vice president of policy at<br />
the Illinois Chamber of Commerce, also spoke at the event.<br />
In an exclusive interview with <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong>, O’Hare explained<br />
why she feels positive about the presidential race. “We appreciate that<br />
both presidential candidates are talking about it, which hasn’t been the<br />
case in recent elections,” she said.<br />
BAFEF intends to continue fueling the infrastructure discussion with<br />
a series of debate questions that are posted on the organization’s website<br />
at bafuture.org and submitted to the various media outlets that<br />
are hosting the presidential debates. The questions range from a basic,<br />
“What’s your plan …” to queries about how the candidates envision the<br />
use of technology, including autonomous vehicles, to bring the country’s<br />
infrastructure into the 21st century.<br />
Which candidate has the better infrastructure plan? “According to<br />
their website, the Clinton campaign seems to have more specificity, including<br />
a comprehensive funding plan,” O’Hare stated. “The Trump campaign<br />
states that infrastructure improvements are planned but does not<br />
provide much specificity, especially as regards funding.”<br />
Funding of infrastructure improvements and expansion is on a lot of<br />
minds as governing bodies wrestle with a replacement for the dwindling<br />
revenues produced by the current fuel tax system. O’Hare believes that<br />
no potential funding options should be dismissed. “All options should be<br />
on the table,” she said. Until a replacement is found, however, she said,<br />
“We have advocated for an increase in fuel taxes to offset revenue losses<br />
caused by more fuel-efficient vehicles. We encourage public-private partnerships<br />
where it makes sense and we have advocated for a National Infrastructure<br />
Bank to supplement funding raised by traditional methods.”<br />
O’Hare described some of the organization’s funding recommendations.<br />
“We’re looking at different road user charges, including a $90 million<br />
VMT (Vehicle Miles Traveled) pilot program that was included in last<br />
year’s Highway Funding bill passed by Congress. We hope that states will<br />
use the program to fast-track their own programs.”<br />
Of course, any discussion of infrastructure funding wouldn’t be complete<br />
without a discussion of tolling as a method of raising revenue.<br />
“Your readers are probably not going to like this,” she said, “but we have<br />
to have a revenue stream to build and maintain infrastructure and tolling<br />
is a part of that.”<br />
Tolling offers other benefits in addition to generating funds, she<br />
explained. “Tolling is ideal for private investment in public-private partnerships,”<br />
she stated. Attracting dollars from private investors is one<br />
way that cash-strapped governing bodies can fund improvements, and<br />
privately held companies may be able to operate tolling systems more<br />
efficiently than government bureaucrats.<br />
Tolling can provide incentives that help make better use of available<br />
roads, too. “Tolling is a congestion-reliever as variable tolls are introduced,”<br />
she said. “Tolls can be toggled to encourage use of routes that relieve congestion<br />
on other routes.” Some drivers would be willing to change their route<br />
if a savings could be realized. Variable tolls could also be used to encourage<br />
travel at non-peak hours, providing relief for “rush hour” congestion.<br />
While paying for roads and bridges would seem to be the basis of any<br />
infrastructure plan, preparing the future is another core BAFEF issue. “We<br />
encourage rapid advancement of autonomous cars and other vehicles<br />
and we try to help cities prepare infrastructure to accommodate them,”<br />
O’Hare explained. Helping cities is a key part of the plan. While the group<br />
addresses various forms of infrastructure, there is a definite focus on metropolitan<br />
areas, where infrastructure modernization will have the greatest<br />
impact. “Our focus has been on metro infrastructure, preparing cities to<br />
deal with advancements in technology. Traffic light systems, road sensors<br />
that ‘communicate’ with autonomous vehicles and other improvements<br />
will be needed.”<br />
O’Hare said that there is no specific focus on autonomous trucks or<br />
the “platooning” concept that has garnered attention in the trucking industry.<br />
Improvements in metro areas, however, would help reduce traffic<br />
bottlenecks and delays caused by congestion.<br />
While elected officials, state and local agencies and nonprofit associations<br />
comprise most of the BAFEF membership, individual members are<br />
encouraged to sign up and stay in the loop. Completing the signup form<br />
provided on the BAFEF website entitles the user to receive periodic updates<br />
on the organization’s activities. The group also informs interested<br />
parties through a Twitter feed (@BAFuture) and a Facebook page.<br />
As with any presidential election, there is plenty of discussion about<br />
the future direction of the country. O’Hare and BAFEF intend to make<br />
sure that discussion includes the topic of America’s infrastructure.<br />
18 <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org TCA <strong>2016</strong>
Sponsored by<br />
FALL | TCA <strong>2016</strong><br />
Tracking The Trends<br />
ELDelirius<br />
Implementation of Electronic Logging Rule<br />
Replaces HOS as Trucking’s No.1 Concern<br />
By Lyndon Finney<br />
The looming implementation date of the federal mandate<br />
on the use of electronic logging devices heads the list of<br />
the top 10 critical issues facing the North American trucking<br />
industry, according to a survey released October 3 by the<br />
American Transportation Research Institute.<br />
More than 65 percent of the survey respondents said they<br />
were concerned about productivity impacts the industry may<br />
experience from the full deployment of ELDs late next year.<br />
ELDs were the sixth-rated concern in 2015.<br />
The complete results of the annual survey, which generated<br />
a record 3,285 responses from motor carriers and commercial<br />
drivers, were released at the American Trucking Associations’<br />
<strong>2016</strong> Management Conference and Exhibition.<br />
The number of respondents marked a 137 percent increase<br />
over 2015.<br />
ATRI said 64.5 percent of the respondents were professional<br />
truck drivers, 27.8 percent were motor carriers and 7.7<br />
percent were other industry stakeholders with representation<br />
from the U.S., Canada and Mexico.<br />
Dropping one position from its top ranking for the past<br />
three years, Hours of Service stayed near the top of the list<br />
because of a growing uncertainty over the outcome of the restart<br />
provision.<br />
Ranking third in this year’s survey, the issue of cumulative<br />
economic impacts of trucking regulations is new to the annual<br />
list and reflects the industry’s collective frustration with<br />
increasing and often costly regulatory requirements, ATRI officials<br />
said.<br />
The concern about regulations is the first new category to<br />
hit the list since 2012, when the ELD mandate, truck parking<br />
and driver health/wellness first appeared.<br />
After ranking seventh last year, driver health/wellness fell<br />
out of the top 10 in <strong>2016</strong>.<br />
The lack of available truck parking moved up again this<br />
year to fourth place overall and the state of the nation’s economy<br />
rounds out the top five concerns on the list.<br />
CSA, which was second last year, slipped to the sixth spot<br />
this year, followed by the driver shortage (third in 2015),<br />
driver retention (fourth in 2015), infrastructure/congestion/<br />
funding (also ninth last year) and driver distraction (also 10th<br />
last year).<br />
The ATRI Top Industry Issues report also includes prioritized<br />
strategies for addressing each issue.<br />
The strategies for ELDs included (1) researching and quantifying<br />
industry impacts on safety and productivity from full<br />
deployment of ELDs, (2) assessing the landscape of appropriate<br />
and inappropriate uses of newly available ELD data, and<br />
(3) ensuring that the two-year implementation window is not<br />
extended.<br />
The report noted that there is significant uncertainty in the<br />
industry concerning the costs and benefits of industry-wide<br />
ELD deployment.<br />
With an average price of $495 per truck or more, a major<br />
hurdle for many carriers will simply be the purchase and deployment<br />
of the devices, the respondents said.<br />
And while FMCSA’s Regulatory Impact Analysis showed<br />
a savings to the industry of $2.44 billion in administrative<br />
costs, other research predicts an overall loss in productivity of<br />
between 3 and 5 percent, with this figure potentially increasing<br />
to 10 percent for small carriers.<br />
“Given the disparity in predicted impact, a vast majority<br />
of respondents (65.8 percent) want to see research that<br />
quantifies real-world industry impacts from full deployment of<br />
ELDs,” the survey report said.<br />
As for the implementation date, ATRI reported that a small<br />
portion of respondents indicated they do not want the implementation<br />
window to be extended past the current two-year<br />
period due to the unfair competitive advantages that fleets<br />
using paper logs could have over early ELD-adopting fleets.<br />
Hours of Service had ranked at the top of the concerns list<br />
for three years prior to <strong>2016</strong>.<br />
At stake is the final outcome of the 34-hour restart provision.<br />
In December 2014, Congress suspended the 2013 provision<br />
requiring two consecutive 1 a.m. to 5 a.m. shifts and<br />
limiting the restart to once every seven days, pending a Congressionally-mandated<br />
study on the efficacy of the provision.<br />
Additional uncertainty surrounding the final disposition of<br />
the HOS rules was unintentionally introduced in the December<br />
2015 omnibus appropriations bill with the omission of critical<br />
language that could have permanently suspended the more<br />
restrictive 34-hour restart provisions.<br />
That study has been completed, but its results are being<br />
held a closely-guarded secret pending the outcome of further<br />
Congressional action on the restart provision — and in<br />
preparing the FY2017 Transportation and Housing and Urban<br />
TCA <strong>2016</strong> www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org | <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> 19
Sponsored by SKYBITz<br />
SKYBITz.com | 866.922.4708<br />
Drivers and Carriers Rank the Concerns<br />
Each year when the American Transportation Research Institute conducts its survey of<br />
the top critical issues in the trucking industry, there is a hefty response from both professional<br />
truck drivers, fleet executives and other industry stakeholders.<br />
In reporting the results, in addition to an overall ranking, ATRI separates driver and motor<br />
carrier responses.<br />
In <strong>2016</strong>, each group had the same top four, but a new issue emerged as No. 9 for motor<br />
carriers — the Federal Preemption of State Regulations of Interstate Trucking, also known<br />
as F4A.<br />
The term F4A comes from the Congressionally-enacted Federal Aviation Administration<br />
Authorization Act of 1994, written to prevent states from undermining federal deregulation<br />
of interstate commerce through a patchwork of state regulations.<br />
But the Ninth Circuit Court’s July 9, 2014, decision in Dilts v. Penske Logistics holding<br />
that the FAAAA does not preempt California’s meal and rest break laws as applied to motor<br />
carriers, is contrary to the statute’s deregulatory imperative.<br />
F4A was written specifically because Congress found that “the regulation of intrastate<br />
transportation of property by the states has imposed an unreasonable burden on interstate<br />
commerce” and was intended to preempt state regulation in the areas governed by F4A.<br />
The trucking industry has come to see the decision as a serious threat to the free-market,<br />
competitive system that the FAAAA sought to create and a real burden for carriers<br />
engaged in interstate commerce.<br />
In the two years since the decision, the problems associated with operating under California’s<br />
law has gained more and more attention and efforts are under way to get Congress<br />
to pass legislation preserving the broad preemption provisions of F4A as intended.<br />
California law generally requires employers to provide a 30-minute meal break for every<br />
five hours worked, and a paid 10-minute rest break for every four hours worked, far beyond<br />
the Hours of Service requirements. Employers must provide one additional hour of<br />
pay for each day that the employer fails to provide the meal period or rest period.<br />
California’s meal and rest break laws that apply to all employers impose substantive<br />
standards related to the price, route or service of a motor carrier, and therefore preempted<br />
under the F4A.<br />
The trucking industry knows that the imposition of the burden of the California law massively<br />
impacts price, routes and service by binding motor carriers to routes, services, and<br />
schedules that it otherwise would not be bound to, interfering with the competitive market<br />
forces the F4A sought to promote.<br />
Trucking is hoping the Congress will address the F4A issue in the final version of the<br />
FY2017 Transportation Housing and Urban Development and Related Agencies appropriations<br />
bill that will ultimately become part of an omnibus spending bill.<br />
Development appropriations bill, the<br />
two branches of Congress have different<br />
ideas on how to resolve the issue.<br />
The House wants to scrap the 2013<br />
restart provision altogether.<br />
The Senate still favors letting the<br />
result of the FMCSA study dictate what<br />
will happen.<br />
Trucking stakeholders had hoped the<br />
issue would be resolved when Congress<br />
passed the FY2017 omnibus appropriations<br />
bill prior to the end of the fiscal<br />
year on September 30, but lawmakers<br />
passed a continuing resolution to keep<br />
the government operation without including<br />
any restart language.<br />
The ATRI survey report said significant<br />
negative impacts on the industry<br />
have been documented by numerous<br />
sources because of the 2013 provision.<br />
In 2013, ATRI found that 80 percent<br />
of motor carriers indicated a loss of<br />
productivity directly attributable to the<br />
now-suspended rules, and driver pay<br />
impacts were estimated to range from<br />
$1.6 billion to $3.9 billion annually.<br />
Proposed strategies for the HOS<br />
concern as listed in the report are (1)<br />
advocate for a permanent science-based<br />
fix to the 34-hour restart rule that ensures<br />
that FMCSA does not return to the<br />
more restrictive provisions requiring two<br />
overnight rest periods of 1-5 a.m. and<br />
limitation on the use of the restart to<br />
once per week; (2) continue to push for<br />
increased flexibility in the current sleeper<br />
berth provision; and (3) research and<br />
quantify the true safety and economic<br />
impacts of customer detention on truck<br />
drivers and trucking operations.<br />
“Given the growing amount of uncertainty<br />
surrounding the future of the<br />
HOS rules and the documented research<br />
showing the negative safety and productivity<br />
impacts that resulted from the<br />
34-hour restart provisions, the industry<br />
is understandably impatient for a longterm<br />
solution that does not include a<br />
return to the currently suspended provisions,”<br />
the report said. “As such, 45.7<br />
percent of respondents would like to<br />
see a resolution based on empirical evidence.”<br />
As for flexibility, the report noted<br />
drivers using the sleeper berth provision<br />
must take at least eight consecutive<br />
hours in the sleeper berth, plus a<br />
separate two consecutive hours either in<br />
the sleeper berth, off duty, or any combination<br />
of the two and that 30 percent<br />
of respondents would like to see added<br />
flexibility to this rule to allow drivers to<br />
rest when they are tired.<br />
ATRI said the emergence of the issue<br />
on the impact of regulations speaks<br />
to the industry’s growing concern for<br />
“over-regulation.”<br />
20 <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org TCA <strong>2016</strong>
Request a demo and free quote.<br />
skybitz.com/TA 888.698.1733<br />
SkyBitz Real-Time Asset Management<br />
A Win-Win Solution<br />
With intelligent trailer data, including<br />
cargo status and trends analytics from<br />
SkyBitz, Transport America now operates<br />
with more efficiency than ever before.<br />
“SkyBitz helps us find available trailers faster—<br />
equating to happier drivers, customers, and<br />
the ability to run more loads. It’s a win-win<br />
solution without sacrificing the bottom line.”<br />
Keith Klein<br />
President<br />
Transport America, Inc.
Sponsored by SKYBITz<br />
SKYBITz.com | 866.922.4708<br />
ELDs have climbed to the top of the leaderboard in the latest ATRI survey of trucking’s 10 most critical concerns.<br />
“With FMCSA’s ELD rule and the Environmental Protection Agency/National<br />
Highway Traffic Safety Administration greenhouse gas<br />
emissions rule, vehicle costs will continue to increase,” the report<br />
said. “And, productivity impacts that generate from regulatory actions,<br />
such as the HOS, speed limiter and ELD rules, all have corresponding<br />
economic effects. These and countless other regulatory<br />
actions and proposals from the numerous agencies which regulate<br />
trucking all add up to a new third place concern for the industry.”<br />
Proposed strategies for regulation concerns are (1) analyze<br />
the accuracy of federal agency regulatory impact analyses (RIA)<br />
versus actual industry costs as new regulations are proposed, (2)<br />
quantify cumulative regulatory costs incurred by the trucking industry<br />
over the past decade, broken out by each federal agency<br />
promulgating the regulations and (3) develop recommended industry<br />
metrics and model analyses for future rulemakings to better<br />
project industry costs.<br />
As required by law, a study of the potential impacts of new<br />
regulations must be conducted on the benefits and costs of implementing<br />
the proposed regulation, the report noted.<br />
“Research has documented where significant discrepancies exist<br />
between agency projections and actual industry costs,” the report<br />
said. “When reviewing the regulatory impact analysis for the HOS<br />
rules change in 2013, ATRI documented a delta of $322 million<br />
between FMCSA’s projected benefits and the industry’s costs from<br />
the more restrictive 34-hour restart provisions. Over half of respondents<br />
(51.8 percent) would like more research similar to the<br />
ATRI study in comparing the projected and actual impacts of new<br />
regulations.<br />
As for the parking shortage, the ATRI survey respondents said<br />
the growing scarcity of available truck parking creates a dangerous<br />
situation for truck drivers who are often forced to drive beyond<br />
allowable HOS rules or park in undesignated and, in many cases,<br />
unsafe locations.<br />
In response to a congressional requirement, the Federal<br />
Highway Administration (FHWA) released its Jason’s Law Truck<br />
Parking Survey Results and Comparative Analysis in August<br />
2015, which confirmed that truck parking continues to be a major<br />
issue in the United States. As such, this issue climbed one<br />
position to No. 4 overall from last year.<br />
Similarly, ATRI’s Research Advisory Committee selected Truck<br />
Parking as the most critical research need for the industry in<br />
2015.<br />
In response, ATRI released the first of a series of technical<br />
memoranda on the topic of truck parking in September 2015 highlighting<br />
driver perceptions and valuations for locating available<br />
parking.<br />
The second Tech Memo to be released in October <strong>2016</strong> analyzes<br />
detailed information on over 2,000 days of truck parking<br />
activity recorded by commercial drivers in ATRI’s “Truck Parking<br />
Diary.”<br />
Strategies for the parking issue include (1) supporting and<br />
encouraging investment in new truck parking facilities, (2) educating<br />
the public sector on the safety consequences resulting<br />
from closing public parking facilities and (3) researching the role<br />
and value of real-time truck parking information availability and<br />
truck parking reservation systems.<br />
A vast majority of survey respondents, 71.2 percent, indicated<br />
that a decline in truck parking capacity is a result of the<br />
closure of many public truck stops and rest areas. Reopening<br />
shuttered facilities and investing in new ones would help alleviate<br />
the shortages occurring in many areas, they said.<br />
ATRI said stagnant economic growth in the fourth quarter of<br />
2015, as well as slow growth thus far in <strong>2016</strong>, caused concern<br />
over the state of the nation’s economy to climb three positions<br />
to fifth overall.<br />
“This has generated significant concern among industry<br />
stakeholders, who for the past two years have ranked the economy<br />
much lower in the list of annual concerns, thanks to the<br />
strong post-Great Recession period between 2011 and 2014,”<br />
stated the survey.<br />
Proposed strategies to deal with the economy as it impacts<br />
trucking include (1) researching and quantifying the impact of<br />
the new U.S. Department of Labor overtime rules on the trucking<br />
industry, (2) advocating for reforming/repealing ineffective<br />
and burdensome regulations that add to economic costs without<br />
providing benefits and (3) continuing to advocate for policies<br />
that will stimulate the economy.<br />
To download the complete report, go to atri-online.org.<br />
22 <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org TCA <strong>2016</strong>
Climbing to<br />
By Jack Whitsett<br />
the Top<br />
Wages surpass fuel as<br />
biggest operating cost<br />
Wages have replaced fuel as the largest expense<br />
for North American motor carriers, a new<br />
study by the American Transportation Research<br />
Institute found in September. “An Analysis of the<br />
Operational Costs of Trucking,” an annual survey<br />
published since 2008 by ATRI, also showed a decline in the<br />
average marginal costs per mile. ATRI, part of the American<br />
Trucking Associations, is the trucking industry’s nonprofit<br />
research arm.<br />
Using financial data provided directly by motor carriers<br />
throughout the country, the ATRI reports document<br />
and analyze trucking costs from 2008 through 2015 and<br />
provide trucking industry stakeholders with a high-level<br />
benchmarking tool and government agencies with a<br />
baseline for future transportation infrastructure improvement<br />
analyses, ATRI officials said.<br />
And, for the first time since ATRI started collecting<br />
the industry’s operational costs data, driver<br />
costs now represent a higher percentage of overall<br />
costs than does fuel, ATRI said. The report showed<br />
driver wages represented $0.499 of the average<br />
marginal cost per mile compared with $0.403 for<br />
fuel costs. Driver benefits were $0.131 per mile.<br />
Of the total average costs per hour of $63.70,<br />
driver wages represented $19.95 of that total<br />
while fuel costs were $16.13 per hour. Driver<br />
benefits cost $5.22 per hour.<br />
Driver wages have steadily increased since<br />
the 2012 study, “in response to the growing<br />
driver shortage and to offset lost productivity,”<br />
the ATRI study stated.<br />
Wages amounted to 31 percent of total costs,<br />
surpassing fuel costs of 25 percent, lowest since<br />
the study began, while the average marginal cost<br />
per mile in 2015 was $1.59, a 6 percent decrease<br />
from the $1.70 found in 2014.<br />
This decline in average marginal cost-per-mile<br />
(CPM) is attributed mostly to the steady fall in fuel<br />
prices experienced throughout 2015, but also identifies<br />
the late 2015 economic softening that continued<br />
into <strong>2016</strong>.<br />
“The combined impact of these forces in the industry<br />
will likely continue to result in increased driver<br />
wage and benefit costs as fleets strive to keep their<br />
experienced workforce and recruit additional drivers,” the<br />
report said.<br />
“ATRI’s ‘ops cost’ research is an excellent barometer of the<br />
state of the nation’s economy, as it documented the softening<br />
TCA <strong>2016</strong> www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org | <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> 23
Sponsored by SKYBITz<br />
SKYBITz.com | 866.922.4708<br />
in 2015 but also indicates that costs will<br />
be on the rise in <strong>2016</strong>,” said Bob Costello,<br />
chief economist for ATA and a member of<br />
the ATRI Research Advisory Committee.<br />
A key finding, aside from fuel replacing<br />
wages as the top expense and an 11-<br />
cent per-mile decrease in operating CPM,<br />
concerned equipment age. In this report,<br />
“respondents reported holding all equipment<br />
types for slightly longer than was<br />
documented in 2014, which may result<br />
in a slight increase in repair and maintenance<br />
costs.”<br />
In addition to increased maintenance<br />
costs, another factor is an obvious outgrowth<br />
of holding equipment longer. Class<br />
8 truck sales have steadily declined since<br />
peaking in July 2015, and have reached<br />
historic lows this year, according to ACT<br />
Research and FTR, transportation analyst<br />
firms.<br />
The overall average fleet age increased<br />
to 8.7 years from 7.4 years in 2014, but<br />
average miles driven per truck decreased.<br />
“This trend corroborates the earlier<br />
finding that carriers are holding their<br />
equipment for longer while logging fewer<br />
miles per year, and likely explains the<br />
repair and maintenance (R&M) CPM figure<br />
remaining constant despite an older<br />
overall fleet age in years,” the ATRI report<br />
stated.<br />
Specialized carriers reported the highest<br />
driver wages, at 59.2 CPM. LTL carriers,<br />
many of which are unionized, were<br />
next at 49.0 CPM. <strong>Truckload</strong> carriers reported<br />
the lowest driver pay per mile of<br />
46.0 CPM.<br />
The report says that the higher marginal<br />
cost of wages comes at a time when<br />
the trucking industry continues to experience<br />
a severe and growing shortage of<br />
qualified drivers.<br />
“While the 2015 economy began to<br />
weaken, the American Trucking Associations<br />
still estimated a shortage of 48,000<br />
drivers in 2015, with projections that the<br />
shortage could increase to 175,000 by<br />
2025,” the report said, noting that one of<br />
the challenges facing the industry is the<br />
aging workforce.<br />
A 2014 ATRI study identified alarming<br />
demographic trends facing the industry,<br />
with 55.5 percent of its workforce 45<br />
and older, and less than 5 percent of its<br />
workforce in the 20- to 24-year-old age<br />
bracket.<br />
Additionally, the driver population is<br />
likely being impacted by strong housing<br />
and commercial real estate growth, which<br />
provide alternative higher-paying job opportunities,<br />
although these jobs are very<br />
sensitive to economic factors, the report<br />
said.<br />
For instance, many thousands of truck<br />
drivers originally lost to oil-drilling in<br />
North Dakota have returned to for-hire<br />
trucking industry jobs now that a large<br />
percentage of wells have been capped.<br />
Three new questions<br />
were added to the<br />
survey for next year:<br />
1. Based on your fleet’s IFTA data, what is your fleet-wide<br />
fuel economy in miles per gallon (MPG) for 2015 (i.e. real<br />
miles driven divided by gallons of fuel purchased)?<br />
2. For your fleet, what is your typical per-truck operating<br />
weight in pounds?<br />
3. While your vehicles are in motion, what is your fleetwide<br />
average travel speed in miles per hour (mph)?<br />
The report noted that another challenge<br />
for the driver population was the<br />
change made in July 2013 to the Hours<br />
of Service rules, which had a documented<br />
impact on carrier productivity and driver<br />
earnings. In response, some carriers reported<br />
having to increase driver wages to<br />
offset the lost productivity experienced<br />
by drivers because of the more restrictive<br />
HOS rule provisions which often forced<br />
truck drivers into morning and evening<br />
rush hour driving.<br />
Contrary to previous trends of LTL<br />
carriers reporting the highest R&M CPM,<br />
specialized carriers now have the highest<br />
CPM, at 17.4 cents in 2015, ATRI<br />
reported. LTL carriers were second at<br />
16.8 cents, followed by truckload at 14.2<br />
cents, “the only increase in R&M costs<br />
experienced among the sectors.”<br />
The report divided marginal costs into<br />
two general categories, vehicle (fuel,<br />
lease or purchase payments, repair, insurance,<br />
permits and tolls) and driver-based<br />
(wages and benefits). The report found<br />
the average cost-per-mile to be $1.593 in<br />
2015, an approximate 11 cent decrease<br />
from 2014’s $1.703. The savings were<br />
“driven almost entirely by the decline in<br />
fuel prices.”<br />
The average cost per hour was established<br />
by using an average 39.98 mph<br />
speed and amounted to $63.70 per hour,<br />
down $4.39 from 2014’s $68.09, the<br />
third-lowest total since the study was initiated,<br />
ATRI reported. Fuel cost per mile<br />
figured to 40.3 cents, the lowest reported<br />
figure since the ATRI survey began.<br />
Meanwhile truck/trailer lease or purchase<br />
payments rose to 23.0 cents per mile in<br />
2015, despite the overall decrease in CPM.<br />
“Specialized carriers reported the highest<br />
lease or purchase CPM of 28.6 cents<br />
likely due [to] the extra expense associated<br />
with specialized equipment,” the<br />
ATRI study stated. “<strong>Truckload</strong> carriers<br />
reported the second highest CPM at 23.1<br />
cents, followed by LTL carriers at 17.2<br />
cents.”<br />
Overall, after increasing by 3 percent<br />
from 2013 to 2014, total average marginal<br />
costs decreased by 6 percent from<br />
2014 to 2015, “driven almost entirely by<br />
the decline in U.S. diesel prices.”<br />
ATRI does note, however, that the cost<br />
trends noted in the report are not expected<br />
to last.<br />
“Despite an overall decline in 2015 of<br />
6 percent in a carrier’s CPM, it is highly<br />
likely that this trend will not continue.<br />
Fuel prices are projected to increase<br />
slightly throughout <strong>2016</strong>, and the driver<br />
shortage is expected to continue to grow<br />
in the face of an aging workforce and increased<br />
demand for freight.”<br />
New to this year’s report is additional<br />
information on fleet-wide fuel economy<br />
and operating speeds and the relationship<br />
between speed limiter use and fuel<br />
economy.<br />
Since its original publication in 2008,<br />
ATRI has received over 10,000 requests<br />
for the Operational Cost of Trucking report,<br />
and it continues to be one of the<br />
most popular reports among industry<br />
stakeholders. In addition to average<br />
costs per mile, ATRI’s report documents<br />
average costs per hour, cost breakouts by<br />
industry sector, and operating cost comparisons<br />
of U.S. regions.<br />
A copy of this report is available from<br />
ATRI at atri-online.org.<br />
24 <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org TCA <strong>2016</strong>
W i t h T A Y A K Y L E<br />
American Wife<br />
By Lyndon Finney<br />
TCA <strong>2016</strong> www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org | <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> 25
ought to you by The trucker news organization<br />
get your daily industry news at thetrucker.com<br />
Chris and Taya share a moment together in 2006 between his deployments to Iraq.<br />
On the Cover: Taya with her German Shepherd, Max<br />
Taya Renae Studebaker’s original plan was to conquer<br />
the world on her own.<br />
By her own admission fiercely independent and adventurous, as<br />
a young Oregonian turned Californian she just wanted to work.<br />
No encumbrances, please.<br />
She flat out didn’t want to be tied down.<br />
She just wanted to achieve great things on her own, which given<br />
her tenacity and what America has come to know as her courage in<br />
the face of tragedy, she might well have done.<br />
But then God, faith and Chris Kyle intervened.<br />
As most everyone knows, Chris, who Taya married in 2002, went<br />
on to become the most heralded military sniper in America, the subject<br />
of the best-selling book, “American Sniper,” and subsequently a<br />
blockbuster film of the same title.<br />
As if the book and film didn’t thrust Taya into the limelight perhaps<br />
more than she might have liked, Chris Kyle’s well-documented<br />
untimely and tragic death and that of his friend Chad Littlefield on<br />
February 2, 2013, at the hands of a fellow, but troubled veteran,<br />
has done so even more. And today she is on an avowed mission to<br />
honor God, country and families who serve by providing experiences<br />
that strengthen military and first-responder marriages and families<br />
through the Chris Kyle Frog Foundation (frogfoundation.org), so<br />
named to continue the legacy of Chris, himself a Navy SEAL.<br />
Her hope is that her efforts will help especially military families<br />
escape some of the marital discord she and Chris experienced during<br />
his four tours overseas, discord that caused Chris to leave the<br />
military in 2009 expressly to save their marriage.<br />
As troubling as those first seven years might have been, Taya is<br />
quick to point out that after a difficult transitional period after Chris<br />
came home from the military, the couple and their children — Bubba<br />
and Angel — had the happiest days of their lives together, realizing<br />
“how blessed we were.”<br />
Taya was born September 4, 1974, in Portland, the daughter of<br />
Kim and Kent Studebaker, who through the end of <strong>2016</strong> is serving<br />
as mayor of Lake Oswego, Oregon, a suburb of Portland.<br />
The spirit of independence that led to wanting to go it alone was<br />
present in her as a young person.<br />
She was brought up in the Episcopal Church, but her parents<br />
didn’t force it on her.<br />
“When there was a time I didn’t want to go to church, not because<br />
I didn’t believe, I wanted to sleep, they allowed me the freedom to<br />
do that,” Taya says today. “They allowed me to stretch my wings and<br />
have some freedom and make some mistakes, too, so I appreciated<br />
that.”<br />
They also taught Taya the value of kindness.<br />
“They are the type of people who you can count on, so when<br />
there’s a friend in need they are right there, they are in the mix, they<br />
are never too busy to help someone else, so all of those things,<br />
basic human kindness, the ability to forgive people, and all this was<br />
instilled in me at a pretty young age. They set very high standards<br />
for me so it’s interesting that I look back and think how grateful I am<br />
I got that mix” of independence and relationships.<br />
She was an athlete in school, playing soccer, softball, track and<br />
basketball.<br />
There were hardships.<br />
“There’s always some drama when you have young people who<br />
have hormones, no judgement, no life skills and pressure all put<br />
together,” she said.<br />
She had a boyfriend in high school, which she doesn’t recommend<br />
for anyone.<br />
“I think you should date around and have fun, but not have a serious<br />
relationship because there’s a lot of heartache there that could<br />
be avoided,” Taya said recently. “That’s<br />
a lot of responsibility for a high school<br />
student to be in a relationship and try<br />
to take care of someone else while trying<br />
to figure out who you are. And then<br />
there were other girls who would want<br />
to have a piece of your boyfriend and<br />
that was a struggle and I think my time<br />
would have been better spent having<br />
great friendships with girls that didn’t<br />
include some of that pressure.”<br />
After graduating high school, Taya<br />
attended the University of Oregon<br />
for two years before, under the guise<br />
of following the aforementioned boyfriend,<br />
she moved to Wisconsin, where<br />
she graduated from the University of<br />
Wisconsin-Milwaukee with a degree in<br />
economics and a minor in business.<br />
“It was a way to get out of Oregon,”<br />
she says today, admitting that she<br />
knew the relationship “wasn’t to be”<br />
and that it might have led to her wanting<br />
independence more and more.<br />
After graduation she took a job in<br />
Wisconsin selling advertising for a local<br />
newspaper, but soon tired of the<br />
harsh northern winters.<br />
She decided to move to California,<br />
where she took a sales position with<br />
an office supply company and then<br />
landed a job in pharmaceutical sales<br />
26 <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org TCA <strong>2016</strong>
in Long Beach, where she bought a condo and settled in.<br />
At the time, she had “this fiercely independent, adventurous spirit<br />
and I just wanted to be able to count on myself and be self-sufficient<br />
and have fun and have no real ties and work,” she said. “I love<br />
to work, and I thought it was a pretty neat idea to be a successful<br />
hard-working woman who could achieve great things and not have<br />
that traditional setup of being tied down. I don’t think I thought much<br />
further about it other than I thought it would be a fun way to go<br />
through life.”<br />
Gradually, the pressures of her job got to her and she even had a<br />
case of mild clinical depression.<br />
Being in outside sales, she had no co-workers to make friends<br />
with.<br />
She began to rethink her future with respect to being independent.<br />
“I really do feel like God brought me to my knees and showed<br />
me that is not the way He<br />
set up this world to be,”<br />
she said. “I do not believe<br />
He created people to go<br />
through life alone. Clearly, if<br />
you look in the Bible there<br />
is Adam and there is Eve<br />
and we weren’t just meant<br />
to go it solo. I felt God was<br />
telling me that in particular.<br />
And that’s when I finally<br />
humbled myself and accepted<br />
it. I remember it<br />
like it was yesterday that I<br />
prayed and I was sad and<br />
heartbroken in a way, but I<br />
knew it was by His design<br />
that I give up my silly notion.<br />
“I said, ‘I’m Yours, I get it,<br />
I’m not to go through this<br />
[alone], so just send me<br />
someone nice,’ and I kind<br />
of boiled it down to give me<br />
a man with a good heart,<br />
good values. I really don’t<br />
care what he looks like, I<br />
don’t care what he does for<br />
a living, I don’t care how<br />
old he is, I’m open. It was<br />
only a few weeks later that<br />
I met Chris.”<br />
Taya and a friend were visiting San Diego where Taya’s mother<br />
and aunt have a beach house when her friend decided they needed<br />
to go out for the evening.<br />
“That day I thought, ‘I don’t feel like going out’ but she kind of<br />
pushed the issue with me and said, ‘come on, we came all the way<br />
down here, let’s go out,’” Taya recalled.<br />
She found out later that the man who was to become the love of<br />
her life and the father of their children didn’t really want to go out that<br />
night, either, but he, too, succumbed to pressure from his friends.<br />
“He ended up going out in an old sweatshirt and some beat-up<br />
jeans not planning to meet anyone,” Taya said. “He kind of reluctantly<br />
went.”<br />
Taya balked at the cover price to get in the bar they’d chosen to<br />
visit, but her friend paid the charge and said “oh, shut up, I’ll pay it”<br />
and in they went.<br />
“I was reluctant every step of the way and I feel like God probably<br />
put a few people in place to make sure that meeting still happened,<br />
on his side and my side,” Taya says today.<br />
“I was at the bar arguing with a friend of Chris’ and I don’t even<br />
remember about what,” Taya said. “I was probably just being a little<br />
bit difficult. Chris saw me across the bar arguing with his friend and<br />
he thought, ‘Oh, I can do two things right here. I can talk to this girl<br />
who I want to talk to and save my friend from her wrath, so it will be<br />
a win-win.’”<br />
So he went over and introduced himself and we just started talking.<br />
It was only after Chris pulled her leg as the old saying goes that<br />
she found out he was a SEAL who had just graduated the Basic<br />
Underwater Demolition school.<br />
He first told her that he was a dolphin waxer, telling her that dolphins<br />
in captivity lose their ability they have in the wild to produce<br />
the wax they need to protect themselves from the elements.<br />
“So when they are in captivity they need somebody to wax them<br />
and I’m a dolphin waxer.”<br />
“I hadn’t had enough to<br />
drink to buy that one,” she<br />
said. “But I did think that was<br />
kind of witty,” she said. “And<br />
then I said, ‘Seriously, what do<br />
you do?”<br />
Chris pulled her leg further.<br />
He called her attention to an<br />
ATM machine just around the<br />
corner from the bar.<br />
“I work for the bank,” Chris<br />
told her. “Next time you go<br />
there just wave at the camera<br />
because I’m the guy in the<br />
back handing out the money.”<br />
“I definitely hadn’t been<br />
drinking enough to believe that<br />
one.” Eventually, Chris leveled<br />
with her about being a SEAL.<br />
“I thought he’s probably selfcentered,<br />
probably arrogant,<br />
glory seeking, and maybe<br />
rightfully so because they accomplish<br />
a lot and they are<br />
quite capable,” Taya said.<br />
And she expressed those<br />
very thoughts to Chris.<br />
“I’ll never forget. Chris<br />
looked at me, sort of cocked<br />
Chris taught Taya how to safely handle firearms.<br />
his head to the side and he<br />
looked at me as if I’d said the<br />
sky is green. He said, ‘I would<br />
die for my country. How is that self-centered or arrogant?’ It blew me<br />
away because I thought this guy is the real deal. A lot of people feel<br />
that way because they have motivations for the things they do. I’ve<br />
come to know that most people in the military feel the way he felt. I<br />
just hadn’t met those types of people in the past.”<br />
Taya quickly learned Chris was just the opposite of what she perceived.<br />
He was a caring, humble gentleman.<br />
So a whirlwind courtship followed.<br />
“He was kind and so unassuming,” Taya said. “He treated me with<br />
such respect and I would say there was an old-fashioned gentlemanly<br />
approach in the best possible way. And at the same time he<br />
was unabashed in letting me know he thought the world of me, he<br />
was excited about talking to me, he was interested, he couldn’t wait<br />
to see me again and that combination I feel is just so powerful and<br />
probably rare, even today. And I think it was rare then and even today<br />
that people can set their pride aside and be unabashed and at<br />
the same time be 100 percent a gentleman and putting no pressure<br />
on the other person.<br />
TCA <strong>2016</strong> www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org | <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> 27
ought to you by The trucker news organization<br />
get your daily industry news at thetrucker.com<br />
Taya, Bubba and Angel follow Chris’ casket onto the field at AT&T<br />
Stadium, home of the Dallas Cowboys, where the funeral was held<br />
through the generosity of owner Jerry Jones, who provided the<br />
building, the staff and security. Chris was an avowed Cowboy fan.<br />
“It’s a great combination.”<br />
Chris and Taya were married in 2002 just before he left for his<br />
first of four deployments to Iraq.<br />
When Chris went to Kent Studebaker and asked for his daughter’s<br />
hand in marriage, the blessing came with a warning.<br />
“When I asked my dad what he thought of Chris after Chris had<br />
already asked me for permission for that, he said, ‘I think he’s a<br />
phenomenal guy. My only concern is I believe he’s willing to go to<br />
war and war changes people,’” Taya recalled. “And I thought at the<br />
time, ‘you don’t know Chris. He’s like this amazing character that<br />
the world does not change him. He just has this special aura that<br />
is unchangeable, he’s just so unique and seems unaffected by the<br />
world around him.’”<br />
War did change Chris, Taya says now.<br />
Something Chris did when he was deployed the first time also<br />
changed Taya.<br />
“I remember asking him about God and a little more about the<br />
Bible, and I was floored to know how well he knew the Bible inside<br />
and out,” she said.<br />
Chris, the son of Sunday School teachers, carried a Bible in his<br />
ranch truck.<br />
“I didn’t know that. I married him and I knew he knew God. It just<br />
wasn’t something that came up. We were young and in love and<br />
the rest was kind of superfluous. But he started to teach me then<br />
a little more about how God says in the Bible there’s a time to draw<br />
your sword.”<br />
Taya said she started to learn a little more about God and lean<br />
into her Christian faith a little more.<br />
That faith, she said, sustained her through some seven years of<br />
pretty much constant turmoil at home. As if it weren’t bad enough<br />
that her husband was overseas on a dangerous assignment leaving<br />
her at home to raise two children, each time he came home, she<br />
and Chris didn’t necessarily agree on whether he should take another<br />
deployment or get out of the military.<br />
“I started to feel God so strongly in my weakest moments when<br />
I would just be alone,” she said. “The second deployment I would<br />
sleep with the lights on and I knew it wouldn’t do any good, there<br />
was no purpose of leaving the lights on, but I wanted something<br />
tangible to take away the fear that I felt. The more I leaned in, the<br />
more I talked to Chris and he told me the stories about people who<br />
said, ‘When it’s your time to go, it’s your time to go.’ I thought it was<br />
a cop-out at first, but then I started to really believe it because there<br />
were too many incidents when Chris should have been killed. There<br />
were mortar rounds that would drop right in front of him and smoke,<br />
but not go off. There were bullets that would fly by him and other<br />
guys all the time. There was one time when he was in a room in<br />
Iraq and he was in the middle of a gunfight and for some reason he<br />
flew backward. They were calling on the radio, ‘he’s been hit, he’s<br />
been hit,’ because nobody flies backward. The bullet whizzed right<br />
by him, barely missing him. He couldn’t explain it, he didn’t know<br />
what happened, if it’s a God thing, a guardian angel thing or what,<br />
but I know he went backward and the bullet just barely missed him.”<br />
The four deployments encompassing seven years are detailed<br />
in Taya’s book, “American Wife: A Memoir of Love, Service, Faith,<br />
and Renewal,” which she wrote to help the families of first responders<br />
and military personnel to offer knowledge and hope, something<br />
she says she didn’t necessarily have during Chris’ deployments.<br />
It was after the fourth deployment that ended in 2009 that Taya<br />
told Chris she’d had enough.<br />
Get out of the military, or she might get out of the marriage.<br />
Chris did come home for good in 2009, and the family moved to<br />
Texas, Chris’ home state.<br />
But there was an adjustment period.<br />
“I was under the illusion that when he got out of the military that<br />
it would be like when he had time off,” Taya said. “We had such a<br />
great time together, but what I didn’t account for was the transition<br />
period of leaving the military and the brotherhood. I had no idea<br />
how traumatic that would be and the toll it would take on both of us.<br />
But once we got through that part, which took a lot of work, we were<br />
very excited about having a life that was centered around our kids<br />
Taya speaks about the statue of Chris before its unveiling July 28,<br />
<strong>2016</strong>, at the Chris Kyle Memorial Plaza in Odessa, Texas. Chris<br />
was born in Odessa in 1974.<br />
28 <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org TCA <strong>2016</strong>
Taya Kyle gets a hug from San Diego Padres starting pitcher Andrew<br />
Cashner (34) after throwing out the first ceremonial pitch<br />
on Military Opening Day before a baseball game between the San<br />
Diego Padres and the San Francisco Giants in San Diego in 2015.<br />
Taya first met her husband Chris in San Diego in 2001 and they<br />
and their two children lived there until they moved to Texas after<br />
he left the military in 2009.<br />
and our family and kids’ sports and neighborhood activities with fun<br />
in the community and it was a different thing for us.<br />
“We’d been to a number of funerals and we know of the horrible<br />
injuries that people have and the loss of life and limb and for us<br />
to come out the other side of that it’s like, ‘Holy Cow! We’re here<br />
and we have our family and we have an amazing little boy and an<br />
amazing little girl that laugh and giggle and they’re healthy and we<br />
appreciated the blessing of that so much because I think there were<br />
so many times when it was in our faith that we couldn’t possibly not<br />
have it.”<br />
The year or so before he was killed brought the greatest happiness.<br />
“We had come out of the trouble we had the year before, and<br />
there was this elevated sense of peace, with the accomplishments<br />
that we made together,” Taya said. “The future looked bright and<br />
there was just a peaceful hope in what lay ahead and I felt like and I<br />
still feel like it was God’s gift to me to say to me that we were meant<br />
to be together and ‘I promise you all of what you went through didn’t<br />
change the fact that you were meant to be together. You just had<br />
trials.’ It made us closer; it made us stronger.<br />
“In that last month, I had enough faith in the joy we had been<br />
feeling that I could look back and say we were deeper and stronger<br />
than we were in that year of beginning love when we hadn’t gone<br />
through the horrible times. You just love each other. And it’s deeper<br />
because you’ve been through things and you’ve seen each other at<br />
your worst and you’ve seen each other at your best and everything<br />
in between, and nobody walked out and we came through. And to<br />
me that was such a huge gift.”<br />
Today, Taya is engrossed in her work through the Chris Kyle Frog<br />
Foundation, her speaking engagements such as at the Wreaths<br />
Across America Charitable Gala, and her work as a contributor at<br />
Fox News and her work alongside the Patriot Tour, traveling the<br />
country to teach lessons of grief, faith and love to those in need.<br />
Her strength today, as it has been these past years, is her faith.<br />
“It’s the only thing that got me through in the end, truly,” she says<br />
today. “I feel like the lessons I learned when I was with Chris and<br />
the things that we had to contemplate together with friends dying<br />
and life going on and seeing the widows that had gone before<br />
me, all of that laid the foundation for the things that I would need<br />
to get through [his death]. I also think that He promises free will to<br />
everybody and I believe that the person who took Chris’ and Chad’s<br />
life exercised his free will and that’s an example of God keeping<br />
His promise [of free will] but another promise is He’ll bring beauty<br />
through the ashes and that’s a comfort to me to see Him take<br />
something horrifying, even if it’s negatively impacting my life more<br />
than I could ever imagine, to see He could take even that, the darkest<br />
of pains, and do something beautiful with it in this world. That’s<br />
inspiring to me.”<br />
As for the future, Taya’s seeking direction from God.<br />
“I have a sense that He won’t necessarily want me to be alone<br />
the rest of my life,” she said recently. “I still want to be. That’s a<br />
hard one for me, something I have to reconcile because I don’t<br />
think His intention is for me to be alone forever. I know that I’m<br />
very resistant to that idea. I have an emotional brick wall built up to<br />
the sky. I actually pray to God to please get through to me without<br />
breaking me again. If I’m really screwing up really badly by not entertaining<br />
that thought will You gently open my eyes to it? But I feel<br />
like God’s allowing me that space right now and I’m not sure that<br />
it’s what He wants but I do have a sense that it’s what He wants.<br />
There will be an awakening at some point. It could be now if I’d be<br />
open to it but I can’t get there yet.”<br />
And you can rest assured that because of her deep faith in God,<br />
His answer to her will be loud and clear and she will follow.<br />
Taya says goodbye to Chris, who is buried in Austin, Texas, in a<br />
state cemetery that is the final resting place of notable Texans.<br />
The badges on the casket are called Tridents and are placed<br />
there by fellow SEALs. To nail them into the coffin by hand is a<br />
complete sign of respect to a fallen comrade.<br />
TCA <strong>2016</strong> www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org | <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> 29
FALL | TCA <strong>2016</strong><br />
A Chat With The Chairman<br />
A Clear Vision<br />
Foreword and Interview by Lyndon Finney<br />
The concept of organizational vision is certainly nothing new,<br />
and neither is its importance.<br />
Sometime during his reign as king of Israel from 970 BC to 931<br />
BC, Solomon wrote what is now known as the book of Proverbs,<br />
a collection of simple and concrete sayings, popularly known and<br />
repeated, that express truths based on common sense or experience.<br />
The King James Version of Proverbs 29:18 says “Where<br />
there is no vision, the people perish: but he that keepeth the law,<br />
happy is he.” The Good News Translation puts it this way: “A nation<br />
without God’s guidance is a nation without order. Happy are<br />
those who keep God’s law!”<br />
In this “Chat,” TCA Chairman Russell Stubbs speaks about the excitement<br />
among TCA officers, members and staff with respect to the<br />
clear vision President John Lyboldt has brought to the association and<br />
how that vision will lead TCA to become the voice of truckload.<br />
The chairman also speaks about the sterling success of the<br />
fourth annual Wreaths Across America Charitable Gala and about<br />
the need for association members to step up and volunteer to help<br />
transport truckloads of wreaths to veterans’ cemeteries around the<br />
country for Wreaths Across America Day December 17.<br />
The chairman closes his “Chat” discussing three critical regulatory<br />
issues facing the industry.<br />
30 <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org TCA <strong>2016</strong>
Sponsored by<br />
Mr. Chairman, you are now halfway through your chairmanship of<br />
the <strong>Truckload</strong> Carriers Association. Share with the membership the<br />
association’s accomplishments aCComplishments during the first six months.<br />
First and foremost, I have to talk about our new president,<br />
John Lyboldt, who took over in December 2015, not too long<br />
before I assumed my responsibilities the last day of the convention<br />
last March. We’ve had a lot of good things going on and a lot<br />
of good discussions concerning John’s vision for the association,<br />
which is to be the voice of the truckload industry. That’s what<br />
we’re all about and what we need to be to bring more value to being<br />
a TCA member. Other aspects of the vision include working on<br />
member profitability, continuing our educational programs and<br />
looking at the advocacy piece and determining how we can best<br />
benefit the truckload segment. During the past six months, we’ve<br />
had a great safety conference in May in Fort Worth, Texas, we had<br />
our first WorkForce Builders Conference in Indianapolis in June,<br />
we’ve seen great success with our webinars put on by Ron Goode<br />
and his group who’ve done a great job with that program, and<br />
we had our officers’ planning meeting in Jackson Hole, Wyoming,<br />
in August. As for the WorkForce Builders Conference, we didn’t<br />
have the turnout we’d hoped, but the conference content was<br />
great and we received very good feedback from the participants.<br />
We feel we have gained some good momentum for this meeting,<br />
which will be held again next June in Indianapolis. We’ve also<br />
asked Ron and his team to plan for more webinars in 2017 because<br />
we think the content is great and they are a good source<br />
of revenue for the association. Let me say a little more about the<br />
officers’ planning meeting, which was a great success. We took<br />
care of a lot of business and had great discussions on the future<br />
of the association, but the most important thing we did was to<br />
go over the FY2017 budget line-by-line, department-by-department.<br />
The staff members were there to explain their portion of<br />
the budget, which we were able to approve and move forward for<br />
the entire board to approve at its meeting in September. It is the<br />
first time in my recollection that we approved the coming year’s<br />
budget prior to our fiscal year that begins October 1. The staff<br />
along with our Financial and Long-range Planning Committee led<br />
by Dennis Dellinger did a great job of getting out in front of our<br />
fiscal year and getting the budget approved.<br />
TCA <strong>2016</strong> www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org | <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> 31
Sponsored by Mcleod software<br />
McLeodSoftware.com | 877.362.5363<br />
Right ahead of us is our role in the Capitol Christmas tree<br />
and the laying of the wreaths at national veterans cemeteries on<br />
Wreaths Across America Day December 17. This is a big thing for<br />
the association. A lot of our members participate in that cause.<br />
I plan on being at Arlington National Cemetery myself and am<br />
really looking forward to that. Of course, we’ll be watching the<br />
elections to see how the new Congress looks and begin building<br />
relationships with new senators and representatives after the<br />
first of the year to see what kind of agenda has been set in Washington<br />
with the new administration. We’ll need to keep our eyes<br />
open and any issue that threatens to knock us off the saddle we<br />
need to be ready to address.<br />
Speaking of Wreaths Across America, TCA’s fourth annual Wreaths<br />
Across America Charitable Gala was held September 20 in Washington.<br />
By all reports, the Gala, like those before, was a great success.<br />
It was fantastic. We sold out all the tables. Miss America 2000<br />
Heather French Henry served as our master of ceremonies, which<br />
is significant because she is the daughter of a disabled veteran,<br />
and we heard from Candy Martin, who is now president of American<br />
Gold Star Mothers. Taya Kyle was our keynote speaker. She<br />
talked about her relationship with her husband Chris and how it<br />
was to be at home when your loved one is overseas fighting for<br />
your country and not knowing whether or not they are safe. We<br />
raised $108,000, which included a $50,000 donation from the<br />
National Association of Independent Truckers Foundation, to help<br />
with logistics efforts this year. The $108,000 was then coupled<br />
with a $150,000 gift from the Walmart Foundation. It was just a<br />
great event as always. I want to thank Debbie Sparks and the staff<br />
planning the evening and of course we couldn’t do it without the<br />
help of Pilot Flying J and Freightliner and our other sponsors. We<br />
really appreciate them stepping up to the table and the fact that<br />
we don’t have to ask them to participate; they come forward every<br />
year and offer to help. It’s just such a great night for TCA, Wreaths<br />
Across America, our veterans and Morrill and Karen Worcester. The<br />
evening really shows what we think of our veterans.<br />
What are the things that excite you the most about President Lyboldt’s<br />
vision for the association and the leadership he has brought<br />
to TCA?<br />
John has a great passion for being the voice of truckload.<br />
When we interviewed candidates for the position in late 2014,<br />
John’s passion absolutely stood out. His passion led to great success<br />
at the National Automobile Dealers Association. He’s had<br />
experience in the advocacy world as well as the benchmarking<br />
world, and those are two important things for the association.<br />
He also understands the importance of membership in TCA and<br />
has put a renewed focus on membership. He’s made a couple of<br />
staff changes to bolster our efforts in the area of recruiting new<br />
members. Speaking of staff changes, the board in September<br />
promoted Dave Heller to the position of vice president of government<br />
affairs, which will increase our presence on Capitol Hill since<br />
John is also a registered lobbyist. There’s new leadership at the<br />
American Trucking Associations which John has embraced and<br />
the ATA leadership has embraced John and the association. We’re<br />
committed to working together and will have one voice as far as<br />
advocacy goes when we are aligned on an issue.<br />
Share with us what’s ahead for the next six months and the things<br />
you want to accomplish leading up to the 2017 convention next<br />
March.<br />
Why is it important for TCA members to become involved in the effort<br />
to transport the wreaths to Arlington National Cemetery and<br />
other national cemeteries across the country?<br />
It is very important, especially because the number of wreaths<br />
needing to be transported grows every year. The need for more<br />
power and transportation simply has increased. My company has<br />
participated and it has been a great honor not only for our company<br />
and our employees, but more so for the drivers who get to<br />
participate and be at the event and shake the hands of the people<br />
laying the wreaths. It’s a very honorable thing for our members<br />
to participate in. I would urge any member carrier who can to<br />
participate. They can contact Debbie Sparks at the TCA office.<br />
This is a very heartwarming program.<br />
September marked the first time the fall committee and board<br />
meetingS were held in conjunction with the Gala. Share with<br />
members a report on those meetings and how well the decision to<br />
have those meetings at the Gala worked out.<br />
Because of a scheduling conflict, we had to move the date for<br />
our fall meeting that is usually held during the ATA Management<br />
Conference and Exhibition. We had better attendance than usual<br />
at both our committee and board meetings, most likely because<br />
they were held in conjunction with the Gala. The attendance at<br />
our board meeting was probably 50 percent higher than it had<br />
been in the past. We also held some benchmarking meetings prior<br />
to the Gala. So all in all, it was a good opportunity to be able<br />
to gather so many members in Washington, which is right across<br />
the river from TCA headquarters in Alexandria, Virginia. Moving<br />
the meeting to September also allowed us to pass the budget prior<br />
to the beginning of the fiscal year, something that we couldn’t<br />
do when we met at the ATAMCE, which is held in October. Going<br />
forward, we are going to look at the option of doing it in conjunction<br />
with the Gala or going back to meeting at ATAMCE. That will<br />
be a board decision.<br />
32 <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org TCA <strong>2016</strong>
Sponsored by Mcleod software<br />
McLeodSoftware.com | 877.362.5363<br />
Concerning the upcoming election, why is<br />
it important for members to get to the polls<br />
November 8?<br />
As American citizens, a lot of people<br />
take for granted the right to vote. A lot of<br />
countries would envy our position. A lot of<br />
people gave their lives over 200 years ago<br />
to give us the right to vote. Participating in<br />
the election process and getting to know<br />
your elected officials, whether they are<br />
at the local, state or federal level, is our<br />
duty as American citizens, and as business<br />
owners and association members. A lot of<br />
our elected officials have no idea how important<br />
trucking is to our economy. Most<br />
of them just see trucks as these big vehicles<br />
that have wrecks, cause traffic jams,<br />
and tear up roads and bridges. They don’t<br />
see the other side of it. The more relationships<br />
our members can have with elected<br />
officials, the more we can get our message<br />
out. Voting is very important.<br />
As we close our chat, let’s talk about some<br />
regulatory issues that are currently at the<br />
forefront. First, the speed limiter Notice of<br />
Proposed Rulemaking is out and ATA says they<br />
are not going to support the proposed rule<br />
as it’s written. What is TCA’s position on the<br />
nprm?<br />
We adopted a position in 2012 that supports<br />
a speed limit of 65 mph for trucks.<br />
Several of us, including the entire TCA<br />
staff and several officers, were at the ATA<br />
meeting earlier this month and sat through<br />
the debate on this issue during the safety<br />
committee meeting and heard [ATA President<br />
and CEO] Chris Spear comment at<br />
the meeting. We agree that the proposed<br />
rule is very ambiguous. We haven’t taken<br />
a vote on the NPRM, so I can’t say whether<br />
we will or will not support it. Talking to<br />
staff and other members, I believe we all<br />
feel the NPRM is ambiguous and a lot of<br />
things will have to be defined before we’ll<br />
support the proposed rule as now written.<br />
The issue with F4A has really burst on the<br />
scene. Why is it going to be important for<br />
the industry to convince Congress to pass<br />
legislation that will ensure there is only<br />
one set of rules for trucking?<br />
You’ve just said it. There are 48 contiguous<br />
states in which most of us operate.<br />
Having different sets of rules for rest<br />
breaks, for compensation, for overtime<br />
or anything else that differs from state to<br />
state becomes an administrative nightmare,<br />
especially for those of us who operate<br />
nationally, which most truckload carriers<br />
do. But even those who are regional<br />
might cover several states during a trip.<br />
Having different rules for different states<br />
presents the potential for complaints to<br />
the National Labor Relations Board and for<br />
lawsuits. We’ve done a pretty good job as<br />
an industry at getting Federal Motor Carrier<br />
Safety Administration regulations to<br />
apply in all states. We need rules that conform<br />
everywhere.<br />
Finally, the Hours of Service rule — more<br />
specifically the 34-hour restart provision<br />
— is still up in the air. The Senate and House<br />
FY2017 appropriations bills offer differing<br />
avenues to resolve the issue. What is TCA’s<br />
position on the 34-hour restart issue?<br />
TCA and the industry continue to work<br />
toward a legislative fix on the 34-hour restart.<br />
It was apparent that logistically, we<br />
could not support two consecutive periods<br />
of 1 a.m.-5 a.m. or even the provision that<br />
only allowed for the usage of the restart<br />
once every 168 hours. That being said, our<br />
industry has worked hard in getting a correction<br />
in place that will help remedy the<br />
situation and provide us with a restart provision<br />
in the Hours of Service regulations<br />
that we can thrive on. Since Congress insisted<br />
that its recent Continuing Resolution<br />
(CR) be a clean one [meaning no riders],<br />
we remain committed to a fix that will be<br />
inserted into the massive omnibus spending<br />
bill certain to be taken up in December<br />
once the CR expires. There is pro-trucking<br />
language in both the House and Senate versions<br />
of the spending bill that supports the<br />
membership’s desire to maintain the restart<br />
provision. The full Senate has already voted<br />
on and passed language that contains<br />
a 73-hour weekly cap on hours if a driver<br />
chooses to use the restart, while the House<br />
version, which has only passed committee,<br />
contains no weekly cap. Once the omnibus<br />
bill goes to conference, we expect the two<br />
sides to come together with a version that<br />
our membership can support. What truly<br />
concerns our industry is the presence of<br />
the restart study that FMCSA conducted as<br />
prescribed by the Consolidated and Further<br />
Continuing Appropriations Act of 2015. We<br />
as an industry continue to wait for the published<br />
outcome of this study, yet the agency<br />
seems insistent on withholding the results<br />
until a legislative fix is in place. As always,<br />
we will keep our membership up-to-date as<br />
new information arises.<br />
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.<br />
You are most welcome.<br />
34 <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org TCA <strong>2016</strong>
FALL | TCA <strong>2016</strong><br />
Member Mailroom<br />
What can my company do to support National<br />
Wreaths Across America Day on December 17?<br />
For the past five years, the <strong>Truckload</strong> Carriers Association has<br />
been Wreaths Across America’s logistics partner. TCA staff members<br />
secure carriers to transport wreaths to Arlington National<br />
Cemetery as well as to more than 1,200 veterans’ cemeteries<br />
across the U.S. In 2015, nearly 300 tractor-trailers were required<br />
and that number is projected to increase by 40 percent<br />
for <strong>2016</strong>.<br />
Interested in hauling a truckload of wreaths but need more<br />
information? First, all wreaths are made in Columbia <strong>Fall</strong>s,<br />
Maine. Can’t travel to Maine? You can choose from one of the<br />
following: Kansas City, Missouri; Colona, Illinois; or Richland,<br />
Mississippi. The cross-dock locations normally coincide with the<br />
wreaths’ destinations. Example: Wreaths for Minneapolis will<br />
come from Colona, Illinois, and cross-dock depending on the<br />
number of wreaths per cemetery.<br />
Interested in seeing what loads are available? Have a specific<br />
cemetery in mind? Beginning October 24, visit www.truckloadofrespect.com<br />
to access TCA’s “load board.” Need additional<br />
help? Contact TCA staff at TCA@truckload.org.<br />
One main requirement is that haulers have a 48-foot or 53-<br />
foot dry van or refrigerated trailer.<br />
“Our commitment to Wreaths Across America runs deep, as<br />
the trucking industry tends to be very patriotic,” said TCA Vice<br />
President of Development Debbie Sparks. “From our trucking<br />
company donations of equipment and money, to our professional<br />
truck drivers’ donation of their time, we are committed to<br />
adorning these graves every year.”<br />
TCA encounters numerous drivers each year who are veterans<br />
and want to haul the wreaths but can’t financially. So if<br />
you don’t have the equipment but want to sponsor a load for an<br />
owner-operator, beginning October 20 you can visit truckloadofrespect.com<br />
to donate.<br />
TCA <strong>2016</strong> www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org | <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> 35
FALL | TCA <strong>2016</strong><br />
Talking TCA<br />
m a r l i r i g g s h a l l | o u t r e a c h a n d e n g a g e m e n t m a n a g e r<br />
B Y d o r o t h y c o x<br />
As a student at Hedgesville High School, located in the Eastern<br />
Panhandle of West Virginia, Marli Riggs Hall was on both the varsity<br />
and junior varsity softball teams for three years, playing “left field,<br />
third base, shortstop and sometimes pitcher … I wore many hats,”<br />
she says.<br />
When the upbeat and confident 30-year-old got her first job in<br />
D.C. at a publication called “Employee Benefits Adviser” in April 2011,<br />
she again wore many hats — monitoring the magazine’s social media<br />
accounts, conducting podcasts and interviewing sources in the insurance<br />
field.<br />
So when Hall interviewed with the <strong>Truckload</strong> Carriers Association<br />
to become their membership coordinator in April 2013, she was not<br />
taken aback by the fact that “they kept reiterating that I would wear<br />
a lot of hats.”<br />
And when she was named TCA’s outreach and engagement manager<br />
early this year, she welcomed a few more.<br />
But as you might imagine, when it comes to hats, it’s the more the<br />
merrier with Hall.<br />
She comes by her hard-working drive honestly. “I was raised on<br />
a beef cattle farm,” Hall says proudly. “My [immediate] family has<br />
always and still lives in Hedgesville,” on Siler Farm, which has more<br />
than 260 acres of farm land, nearly 100 head of beef cattle, and dozens<br />
of chickens.<br />
Prior to her parents taking over the farm duties in the mid-90’s,<br />
Hall’s late, great-grandmother, Eileen Francis Siler, who Hall affectionately<br />
called “Moma,” was the owner of Siler Farm when Hall was<br />
a child. Siler was employed by the General Motors plant based in<br />
Martinsburg where she worked full-time. Toward the latter part of her<br />
life, when Hall spent the majority of time with her, Siler battled Non-<br />
Hodgkin lymphoma.<br />
“[Siler] went years and years with cancer still working full-time”<br />
at the plant and as a full-time farmer, something that’s really telling<br />
about her work ethic, said Hall.<br />
Currently, Hall’s dad, John Riggs, is the full-time caretaker of Siler<br />
Farm and is “a good steward of the land.”<br />
In addition to the farm’s bull-calf operation (one bull, majority of<br />
heifers), hay, alfalfa and vegetables are plentiful. Hall’s family is especially<br />
proud of its recent accomplishment, the 2013 Berkeley County<br />
Conservation Farmer Award, for installing numerous solar-powered<br />
water filtration systems in many of its paddocks.<br />
From a young age, Hall and her sister Courtni Marie, who is seven<br />
years younger, had plenty of chores to do on the farm including chopping<br />
and splitting firewood for the family’s woodstove (which her parents<br />
still have along with their more modern conveniences), helping<br />
to move cattle, and gathering eggs from the chickens among other<br />
jobs.<br />
And more often than not, it was messy.<br />
“Muck boots are a farmer’s friend,” Hall joked. “[When] running<br />
around the barnyard, [cow patties] tend to go all up your legs and<br />
get in your shoes and your pants. It’s just everywhere, because well,<br />
it’s a barnyard.”<br />
“We have what we call moving day where we move the cows from<br />
field to field every couple of Saturdays. The cows know it’s moving<br />
day. They all line up with their noses against the gates and they’re all<br />
just waiting because they know there’s greener pastures.”<br />
Taking care of the animals taught Hall “dependability, obviously,”<br />
she says. “There are no sick days in farming. Every day although<br />
there’s always something different there are some things that never<br />
change.<br />
“You have to be motivated, hardworking … it doesn’t matter if you<br />
are sick one day, you have animals that depend on you and if you’re<br />
feeling bad you have to get up, you have to go downstairs and put on<br />
your layers and strap up your boots. You’ve got to ride up to the farm<br />
and feed the animals and water them.”<br />
“My dad,” she continues, “was a kiln operator” at Corning Glass<br />
Works in Martinsburg. He also “was a fork lift driver; he did all that<br />
stuff. He wore many hats, too, as did my mom.”<br />
As an outreach and engagement manager, Hall (with her many<br />
hats) is busy working behind the scenes and responsible for monitoring<br />
TCA’s social media accounts and ensuring the website is up-todate,<br />
as well as overseeing six award programs like Driver of the Year<br />
and Trucking’s Top Rookie. She enjoys working closely with the Dave<br />
36 <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org TCA <strong>2016</strong>
TCA <strong>2016</strong> www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org | <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> 37
Nemo Show staff and slating guests for TCA’s “Load ‘em Up, Move ‘em<br />
Out” segments. It’s important to promote TCA’s staff, such as Dave<br />
Heller, TCA’s vice president of government affairs, when they’re on<br />
the road and speaking at events, she adds.<br />
Throughout the year, Hall helps to coordinate carriers to haul the Vietnam<br />
Veterans Memorial Fund’s Wall That Heals, and around this time of<br />
the year, Hall helps with the logistics of Wreaths Across America.<br />
“As you can see, there’s a very broad spectrum of stuff that I work<br />
on, but as I always say, ‘I didn’t find trucking, trucking found me.’”<br />
But before trucking found her, Hall had wanted to be a news reporter.<br />
When in high school, Hall took a newspaper and journalism class<br />
and wrote for the student newspaper her junior and senior years.<br />
When asked why she enjoyed journalism so much, she credits her<br />
teachers, Ms. Tomasic and Mrs. Staubs.<br />
“I had two women [teachers] I gravitated toward and their passion<br />
for their respective subjects had something to do with my shaping”<br />
into wanting to be a newspaper writer, she says.<br />
In her senior year of high school, Hall even “opted out” of playing<br />
softball and signed up for a criminal law course, which yielded an<br />
internship at a public defender’s office.<br />
“I’ve always [been] one who’s felt the need to help or the need to<br />
assist people, even if it meant long hours and little pay,” she says.<br />
The public defenders, and what they did for their clients, struck a<br />
chord with Hall.<br />
After high school, Hall decided to attend West Virginia University<br />
(WVU). “As a freshman I decided to major in journalism and minor in<br />
criminology,” she says. “I had classes in juvenile delinquency [and]<br />
hate crimes; I loved all these interesting classes so I decided I wanted<br />
to be an investigative reporter.”<br />
Hall’s journalism path gradually morphed into wanting to work for<br />
a police department as a media spokesperson. “That was the goal,”<br />
she says, “but in my senior year the school of journalism did away<br />
with criminology as a minor and I said, ‘What am I going to do now?’<br />
and my advisor said, ‘just minor in sociology.’<br />
“The study of people?” Hall asked. “That’s boring.” It doesn’t seem<br />
too far-fetched, now, however.<br />
Hall wrote for WVU’s school newspaper, The Daily Athenaeum and<br />
her beat was crime. With<br />
her love of the truth and<br />
helping people, one of<br />
her stories in particular<br />
“ruffled so many feathers,”<br />
she says. It was an<br />
exposé about deplorable<br />
living conditions in some<br />
of the well-funded frat<br />
houses.<br />
After talking candidly<br />
with students about an<br />
ongoing problem, “I just<br />
exposed it and blew the<br />
Marli Hall with her parents<br />
John and Laura Riggs.<br />
roof off,” she says. “I had so many entities at WVU that were like,<br />
‘You need to stop writing about this.’ It was a pretty big deal. My editor<br />
said, ‘Run with it, because we’ve got this information and people<br />
are paying dues and paying so much money, why should they live in<br />
these conditions,’ which I agreed with,” she says.<br />
Hall takes great pride in the hard evidence of all her journalism work<br />
— a binder filled with 500 column inches which equates to 30 published<br />
stories. “I cherish that thing because that was a lot of work to do on top<br />
of all my classes … .”<br />
Upon graduating, Hall moved back home and began working as a<br />
copy desk editor and staff writer for The Journal, a daily publication<br />
where she had worked during high school. After a year and a half, she<br />
decided to “go where the money is,” and nabbed the “Employee Benefits<br />
Adviser” job in D.C.<br />
Given her current living situation back home, and being within walking<br />
distance of the commuter train station in Martinsburg, she opted to<br />
hop aboard, five hours a day, for six months.<br />
After weighing the pros and cons, she decided it was time for a move<br />
in 2012, to her current city, Alexandria, Virginia. “A friend offered to split<br />
the cost of a place [which was] perfect,” she says.<br />
Perfect for her love life and eventually her career. At the girls’ new<br />
apartment complex on March 27, a craft beer tasting event was being<br />
held at the property office. Hall met her husband Chris at the event. The<br />
two married October 8, <strong>2016</strong>, in Luray, Virginia, but when they met he<br />
Q & A With Marli Hall<br />
DATE AND PLACE OF BIRTH: February 14, 1986, in<br />
Martinsburg, West Virginia<br />
MY TRADEMARK EXPRESSION IS: Hooray!<br />
PEOPLE SAY I REMIND THEM OF: Recently, Meghan<br />
Trainor, the singer<br />
I HAVE A PHOBIA OF: Tornadoes<br />
MY GUILTY PLEASURE: Binge watching Netflix shows<br />
with sweet treats<br />
THE PEOPLE I’D INVITE TO MY FANTASY DINNER<br />
PARTY: Michael Jackson, Robin Williams, Edgar Allen Poe,<br />
Diana, Princess of Wales<br />
I WOULD NEVER WEAR: A tiara<br />
A GOAL I HAVE YET TO ACHIEVE: Owning a home<br />
THE LAST BOOK I READ: James Patterson’s “Cross” from<br />
the Alex Cross novel series<br />
LAST MOVIE I SAW: “The Purge: Election Year”<br />
MY FAVORITE SONG: “Dreams” by Fleetwood Mac<br />
IF I’VE LEARNED ONE THING IN LIFE, IT WOULD<br />
BE: To live my life and not let others hold me back<br />
MY PET PEEVE: Tedious tasks<br />
THE THING ABOUT MY OFFICE IS: A hodgepodge of<br />
accomplishments while at TCA<br />
ONE WORD TO SUM ME UP: Personable<br />
38 <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org TCA <strong>2016</strong>
Taking the family’s herd of beef<br />
cattle from one grazing area to<br />
another was a recurring task.<br />
Gathering eggs from the family<br />
farm’s chickens were one of many<br />
chores Marli and her sister Courtni<br />
Marie performed.<br />
Marli Riggs Hall with her husband<br />
Chris on their wedding day.<br />
was conducting a craft beer tasting for his then employer, Dean & DeLuca,<br />
an upscale gourmet food chain.<br />
Because of her workload at “Employee Benefits Adviser”— covering<br />
the Obamacare oral arguments at the Supreme Court — she almost<br />
didn’t attend the tasting but she was glad she did, as the two hit it<br />
off right away.<br />
“He was telling me all about these beers, only giving me two-ounce<br />
pours (the legal limit in D.C.) but meanwhile he’s handing out full<br />
beers right and left to other people because he wanted to keep talking<br />
to me,” she says. Of course, she continued to talk to him, too.<br />
Although the romance side of things was taking off in Hall’s life,<br />
she was laid off from her job at the Adviser publication. She’ll never<br />
forget the day when she called Chris and said, “I lost my job today”<br />
and to her somewhat surprise, he said, “That’s OK, we’ll get through<br />
it.” Hall says with a laugh that had the shoe had been on the other<br />
foot and he’d lost his job, she’s not sure she’d have been quite so<br />
understanding.<br />
After months of applying for jobs and getting no bites, lo and behold<br />
someone named Debbie Sparks [TCA’s vice president of development]<br />
saw Hall’s résumé on indeed.com and e-mailed Hall.<br />
“I told Chris, ‘This woman found my résumé and she invited me<br />
to come in for an interview.’ And he said, ‘What’s it for?’ And I said,<br />
‘the <strong>Truckload</strong> Carriers Association.’ And he said, ‘Let me guess, was<br />
it Debbie Sparks?’ I said, ‘how do you know?’ and he said, ‘Marli, I<br />
used to work at American Trucking Associations and I know most of<br />
the people that work at TCA.’” He worked for the association for many<br />
years in the grassroots department.<br />
After TCA’s Annual Convention in March 2014, during the Electric<br />
Carnival Parade at Walt Disney World’s Magic Kingdom, to her complete<br />
surprise, he proposed. “It was in front of 10,000 people. There were<br />
balloons and light-up toys, it was so intense. … I said yes, obviously,<br />
and we called all our friends and family and told them the news.”<br />
Some people say trucking gets in your blood. Whether or not that’s<br />
the case, it is true that Hall’s husband’s connection with ATA and her<br />
job at TCA aren’t her only trucking connections.<br />
She shares that her step great-grandfather, Melvin “MT” Plogger,<br />
who was married to “Moma,” drove a truck for Mason Dixon Trucking<br />
and the two met when he delivered parts to the General Motors plant.<br />
He retired in the late ’70s, early ’80s from the trucking company.<br />
Hall also remembers many references that her mom had made to<br />
wanting to be a truck driver because of MT. “She obviously respected<br />
MT and thought it would be a good career,” she says. “As far as actually<br />
getting in a truck and driving it and getting a CDL, she never got<br />
to that point, but it’s very interesting that as a woman in the ’80s, she<br />
was thinking about it.”<br />
So yes, trucking “found” Marli Riggs Hall. It had been waiting for her<br />
all along.<br />
www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org | <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> 39
4 th Annual<br />
WREATHS ACROSS AMERICA<br />
Charitable<br />
Gala<br />
In<br />
Review<br />
2<br />
3<br />
1<br />
4<br />
<strong>Truckload</strong> Carriers Association executives deemed successful the Fourth<br />
Annual Wreaths Across America Charitable Gala held September 20. The<br />
event raised $108,000 to support the logistics for delivering hundreds of<br />
thousands of wreaths to place on the graves of veterans December 17 and<br />
raised an additional $150,000 to support WAA’s overall mission.<br />
Keynote speaker Taya Kyle, FOX News Channel contributor, author and<br />
veterans’ activist, brought many in the audience to tears as she described<br />
how her late husband Chris Kyle, a U.S. Navy SEAL of “American Sniper”<br />
fame, died trying to help another veteran and how her family managed<br />
to survive the tragedy. She also co-authored “American Wife: A Memoir<br />
of Love, Service, Faith, and Renewal,” that details her husband’s service<br />
to his country, his murder and her struggles in the weeks and months<br />
following his untimely death.<br />
A surprise donation was given after Taya Kyle spoke: $50,000 from<br />
the National Association of Independent Truckers (NAIT) Foundation,<br />
represented by Scott Miller, managing vice president of TRANSGUARD<br />
Insurance Company of America.<br />
Other notable participants included veteran Candy Martin, whose son,<br />
1st Lt. Thomas Martin, was killed in action in Iraq in 2007, and who is<br />
now president of American Gold Star Mothers, Inc., an organization of<br />
mothers who have lost a son or daughter in service to the U.S.; Master of<br />
Ceremonies Heather French Henry, Miss America 2000 and the daughter of<br />
a disabled veteran; and Morrill and Karen Worcester, founders of Wreaths<br />
Across America.<br />
“This year, the Worcesters asked us to fundraise specifically for<br />
logistics to haul the wreaths because without their delivery, there can<br />
be no National Wreaths Across America Day. The trucking industry’s<br />
participation is absolutely essential to this effort,” said Russell Stubbs,<br />
TCA’s chairman. “We’re seeking additional involvement from those in<br />
the industry, particularly for the delivery process. We need trucking<br />
companies that can haul loads if they never have before, haul more loads<br />
than they’ve done in the past, and ask their fellow trucking company<br />
executives to help, too. Actually, any individual or company from any<br />
industry can make a financial contribution to help a participating owneroperator<br />
with fuel costs.”<br />
“We are proud to support the trucking industry’s involvement in<br />
honoring those who have paid the ultimate sacrifice via the Wreaths<br />
Across America project. In addition to the monetary contribution, our<br />
40 <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org TCA <strong>2016</strong>
5<br />
6<br />
7<br />
8<br />
9<br />
10<br />
11<br />
12<br />
13<br />
employees look forward to participating at several locations in<br />
the laying of the wreaths. We are committed to the support of our<br />
veterans and the trucking industry,” Miller said after he presented the<br />
NAIT donation.<br />
The Gala was hosted by Pilot Flying J and Freightliner Trucks and<br />
sponsored by TravelCenters of America/Petro and Randall-Reilly. After<br />
a reception and dinner, a special cake was brought out to celebrate<br />
the 25th anniversary of the Worcester family’s first wreath laying<br />
at Arlington National Cemetery. To accompany the cake, Patrick<br />
Simmons, senior director of transportation for Walmart’s Private<br />
Fleet, offered a “present” on behalf of the Walmart Foundation — a<br />
$150,000 donation check.<br />
Throughout the evening, small fundraisers brought in additional<br />
funds, such as the “wine grab” sponsored by TravelCenters of<br />
America/Petro, and a photo booth sponsored by DriverFACTS. There<br />
was also a silent auction featuring trips, electronics, jewelry, and<br />
limited edition artwork. A special video, presented by Drivewyze,<br />
honored trucking family members who sacrificed their lives to protect<br />
America’s freedom.<br />
1. Miss America 2000 Heather French Henry served as master<br />
of ceremonies. 2. Left to right, Rob Penner, Bison Transport; Kristen<br />
Bouchard and Marli Riggs Hall, TCA staff; and Josh Kaburick, Earl L.<br />
Henderson Trucking. 3. Glynn and Lisa Spangenberg, Spangenberg<br />
Partners. 4. Starla and Jim Ward, D.M. Bowman; Cari Baylor, Baylor<br />
Trucking. 5. Lindsay Lawler and Chris Roberts sing the National<br />
Anthem. 6. Master Sgt. Lorena Wilson and Lt. Col. Roy Walker, both<br />
members of the U.S. Army, were among the military guests. 7. A<br />
Monument Cruise and Dinner were among the Silent Auction items<br />
up for bid. 8. Attendees could bid on items using a smartphone. 9.<br />
The Worcester family and Taya Kyle. From left, Anne and Wayne<br />
Hanson; Sarah and Rob Worcester; Karen Worcester; Taya Kyle;<br />
Morrill Worcester; and Renee and Mike Worcester. 10. The ballroom<br />
at the Washington Hilton was sold out. 11. American Gold Star<br />
Mothers President Candy Martin, herself a veteran, received a<br />
standing ovation. 12. Bids in the Silent Auction were displayed on<br />
giant screens along with a running total of the money raised. 13.<br />
Taya Kyle brought many in the audience to tears talking about life<br />
with her late husband Chris Kyle.<br />
TCA <strong>2016</strong> www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org | <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> 41
TCA Honors America’s<br />
top rookie<br />
By Dorothy Cox<br />
Yes, trucking can be stressful when an automobile driver who<br />
doesn’t understand the physics of stopping an 80,000-pound tractortrailer<br />
cuts you off, agrees Trucking’s Top Rookie Chris Crowell. But<br />
after being “a gunner on a Humvee in Baghdad, Iraq, you can’t even<br />
compare it,” he says.<br />
The 37-year-old Crowell, who during his 13 years in the U.S. Army<br />
served in Operation Iraqi Freedom and Operation Enduring Freedom,<br />
always thought he would be career military.<br />
“I always thought I would make the military my full career, that I’d<br />
retire from it,” he says.<br />
But back problems intervened. “Lower back problems are hereditary,”<br />
he says. That on top of wearing all the heavy combat gear and<br />
banging around in a Humvee were just too much for his back.<br />
He had gone in as an Army intelligence analyst but “I didn’t get to<br />
do that; I did infantry and was in an armory unit, the combat arms<br />
type of stuff.”<br />
After exiting the military Crowell tried college but found it wasn’t<br />
for him, and while there his mom passed away from liver cancer so<br />
“schooling took a back seat.”<br />
He took care of his widowed father until his brother bought a house<br />
and moved their father in with him. It was then that this Bronze Star<br />
recipient decided to get a stop-gap job working at a pet store to<br />
support his wife and two daughters while he hunted for a stable job<br />
where he could build a career. Push came to shove when a promotion<br />
to store manager netted him a paltry 25-cent raise: Crowell knew<br />
then he had to get serious about getting “out of the retail environment,”<br />
not only because it was a dead-end job but also because he<br />
was lifting 40- 50-pound sacks of dog food daily, further exacerbating<br />
his back problems.<br />
“I went on Google to look for the most stable career choices with<br />
lots of job opportunities without a college degree and found trucking,”<br />
he recalls. “I said, ‘let me try that.’”<br />
After driver training he signed on with Werner, where he’s been for<br />
a little over a year, and loves it.<br />
Why Werner? “They’re good about hiring veterans, which is really<br />
important. Any company that was willing to hire or seeks out military<br />
is high on my priority list.”<br />
“I took to [truck driver] training like a duck to water, you could<br />
say,” he adds. “I’m typically out Sunday afternoon and get home on<br />
Friday after dinner” to see his wife Megan and their two young daughters<br />
Arya, 2, and Autumn, 1.<br />
His wife understands about his time away from home. “She’s fine<br />
with it,” he says. “She was [military] intelligence, too. We met during<br />
a deployment to Iraq; we were both working in Baghdad and we went<br />
to lunch at the same time.” After both came back from overseas the<br />
relationship continued and blossomed.<br />
And Crowell’s military experience (he was staff sergeant at the<br />
time of his exit) stands him in good stead in trucking.<br />
“The military in me says to make sure you accomplish the mission.<br />
It’s get the job done first and foremost.”<br />
Kevin Walker, Crowell’s fleet manager at Werner, says, “He always<br />
puts his job first and his account first. He puts his fellow drivers<br />
first. He’s very new to trucking but he’s very seasoned in skill<br />
level and has developed into a trainer and is teaching the future<br />
of Werner.”<br />
Crowell says he would “love to get into management” at Werner.<br />
“In the Army I was in charge of the troops; I loved taking care of<br />
their needs, to get them ready and prepared. I’d love to get into<br />
a position to take care of my fellow truck drivers. That would be<br />
great.”<br />
Trucking’s Top Rookie Chris Crowell has found that 13 years in the<br />
military (including service in Operation Iraqi Freedom and Operation<br />
Enduring Freedom) translates well into trucking. “The military in me<br />
says to make sure you accomplish the mission. It’s get the job done<br />
first and foremost.”<br />
For anyone contemplating trucking as a career, Crowell says<br />
“trucking isn’t for everyone. But if you like to get out and travel and<br />
see the country it’s a great career choice. The pay is good and it can<br />
be very rewarding.”<br />
In fact, working at Werner has given Crowell the opportunity to look<br />
into buying a house in his home state of Maine. “The financial security<br />
[of trucking] has really changed a lot of things for me,” he says.<br />
For garnering the top rookie award, Crowell received $10,000<br />
cash and another $1,000 cash award, which will certainly help in<br />
buying a house.<br />
42 <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org TCA <strong>2016</strong>
A QUICK LOOK AT IMPORTANT TCA NEWS<br />
SMALL<br />
A QUICK LOOK AT<br />
IMPORTANT TCA NEWS<br />
TALK<br />
Best Fleets Nominations Open<br />
From within the trucking industry, there are companies<br />
that stand out from the rest.<br />
Their workplace environments are considered<br />
exceptional because they feature attractive compensation<br />
and benefits, an enviable company culture, or perhaps<br />
unique perks and incentives for their employees.<br />
To identify and recognize them, our association and<br />
CarriersEdge offer Best Fleets to Drive For, an annual<br />
contest and survey now in its ninth year.<br />
Nominations must come from professional truck<br />
drivers and can be made online at BestFleetsToDrive-<br />
For.com through October 31.<br />
During the first 10 days nominations were accepted,<br />
there were 89 nominated fleets, a large amount<br />
considering there are typically from 115-120 nominations<br />
in total.<br />
Once a company accepts the nomination and<br />
agrees to participate, CarriersEdge will contact them<br />
for more details through an electronic questionnaire<br />
and telephone interview. They will speak with senior<br />
management and a random sampling of the company’s<br />
drivers to learn more about the carrier’s compensation,<br />
safety practices, benefits, equipment, training, etc.<br />
Ultimately, the survey answers reveal the innovations<br />
that have proven successful in attracting and retaining<br />
skilled personnel in the trucking industry.<br />
“This year, in addition to our usual questions,<br />
we’re going to be asking fleets about how much time<br />
their drivers spend on the road, whether they provide<br />
guaranteed pay and paid waiting time, and what in-cab<br />
amenities they offer,” said Jane Jazrawy, CEO of CarriersEdge.<br />
“We’ll also get into the topic of diversity, asking<br />
what fleets are doing to bring a more diverse driver<br />
pool to the industry. For the first time, this will have its<br />
own scored section.”<br />
John Lyboldt, TCA’s president, added that “Through<br />
our questions to the nominated fleets, we will unearth<br />
and publicize the most popular benefits and perks that<br />
are being implemented right now. These are the things<br />
that are keeping current drivers happy, while enticing<br />
potential new drivers to join our industry.”<br />
To be eligible, a for-hire fleet must have 10 or more<br />
trucks and operate in the U.S. or Canada. TCA membership<br />
is not required.<br />
The top 20 finishers will be identified as Best Fleets<br />
to Drive For and will be announced in January 2017.<br />
®<br />
From this pool, companies will then be divided into<br />
both “small” and “large” categories, and two overall<br />
winners will be recognized March 26-29, 2017, at the<br />
TCA Annual Convention in Nashville, Tennessee.<br />
In late October, companies that have been nominated<br />
(or believe they will be nominated) and are considering<br />
participating are invited to learn more about<br />
the survey requirements through a free webinar.<br />
More details will be released as they are finalized,<br />
but the event will outline the questions that surveyors<br />
will ask, data requirements, and methods for collecting<br />
better information more easily.<br />
Heller Now Vice President of<br />
Government Affairs<br />
David Heller has been promoted to vice president of<br />
government affairs.<br />
TCA Chairman Russell Stubbs made the announcement<br />
at the Board of Directors meeting held at the<br />
Washington Hilton September 21.<br />
Previously, Heller held the title of director of safety<br />
and policy. He will continue with those responsibilities<br />
Previously TCA director of safety and policy,<br />
David Heller was promoted to vice president of<br />
government affairs last month.<br />
as well as leading the association in expanding TCA’s<br />
presence on Capitol Hill and form partnerships and<br />
alliances with those who share a common vision with<br />
TCA, among other things.<br />
“This promotion is the next logical step toward<br />
ensuring that the interests of the truckload segment of<br />
the trucking industry have a clear and unified voice on<br />
the Hill,” Stubbs said. “Working collaboratively with all<br />
necessary parties, Dave will put forth initiatives that<br />
are advantageous to truckload, and he will monitor and<br />
keep us informed about policy and regulatory issues as<br />
they relate to us.”<br />
“As our board, our officers and our leadership team<br />
worked during the past year to set an effective strategic<br />
direction for our association, it became obvious<br />
rather quickly that we needed to expand our efforts in<br />
the area of advocacy on behalf of the truckload sector<br />
of our industry,” said TCA President John Lyboldt.<br />
“With his vast knowledge of regulatory issues, Dave is<br />
the perfect person to lead that effort.”<br />
“The cumulative impact of federal regulations was<br />
listed as the No. 3 concern of the trucking industry in<br />
the latest survey of critical issues facing our industry,”<br />
Heller said. “Two specific regulatory issues — the<br />
ELD mandate and Hours of Service — were No. 1 and<br />
No. 2. And although it was No. 9 on the list specific to<br />
trucking executives, F4A is emerging as a real concern<br />
that must be dealt with in the coming months. Trucking’s<br />
concern over these issues only reinforce the need<br />
for a more active presence on Capitol Hill on behalf of<br />
TCA and its membership. I look forward to leading TCA<br />
in this important work.”<br />
Heller has worked for TCA as director of safety<br />
and policy since 2005. Before that, he spent seven<br />
years as manager of safety programs for the American<br />
Trucking Associations. He is an advisor to the Federal<br />
Motor Carrier Safety Administration’s Entry Level Driver<br />
Training Advisory Committee and is one of the few<br />
association executives to earn certification from the<br />
North American Transportation Management Institute<br />
(NATMI) as a Certified Director of Safety (CDS).<br />
Top Drivers<br />
The <strong>Truckload</strong> Carriers Association and partners<br />
Overdrive and Truckers News are accepting nominations<br />
for the <strong>2016</strong> Driver of the Year competition<br />
through November 6.<br />
To nominate an owner-operator or company driver<br />
go to truckload.org/driver-of-the-year.<br />
A contestant must demonstrate a safe driving<br />
record, strong work ethic and desire to improve his or<br />
her community and the image of the trucking industry.<br />
The competition is sponsored by Cummins Inc. and<br />
Love’s Travel Stops and is divided into two categories:<br />
TCA <strong>2016</strong> www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org | <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> 43
the Company Driver of the Year contest (now in its 26th year) and the Owner-Operator<br />
of the Year contest (now in its 28th year).<br />
The two overall winners will receive $25,000 each, while the two runners-up in<br />
each division will win $2,500.<br />
Danny Smith, a professional truck driver for Big G Express, Inc., of Shelbyville,<br />
Tennessee, was a grand-prize winner in last year’s contest.<br />
“Having the title of Company Driver of the Year has impacted my life in many<br />
ways,” he said. “I have had the opportunity to be a part of national discussion panels<br />
to represent drivers. I have been honored at my state legislature with a Proclamation<br />
for my award. It validated what I do every day, which is drive safe and promote the<br />
industry. Last but not least, the money has provided a safety net and opportunity for<br />
a family trip of a lifetime. I am grateful beyond words.”<br />
Last year’s Owner-Operator of the Year, Edward “Mark” Tricco, who is leased to<br />
Bison Transport of Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada, said, “It’s been a great honor and a<br />
great experience … from a full banner at my company’s home terminal, to having a<br />
decal on my truck recognizing this accomplishment. I’ve had many conversations<br />
about that decal and what it means, from customs agents to people in truck stops. I<br />
am proud to explain what it means!”<br />
To qualify for the contests, nominees must have driven a minimum of one million<br />
consecutive, accident-free miles.<br />
Company drivers must be nominated by the motor carrier that employs them.<br />
Owner-operators may be nominated by a carrier they have been leased to for<br />
a period of three or more years, or they can nominate themselves or be nominated<br />
by a spouse.<br />
Previous grand prize winners are not eligible to enter either contest again,<br />
and other requirements can be found in the official contest rules, available on<br />
TCA’s website.<br />
In addition to the basics listed above, nominees must provide proof of operating<br />
Who<br />
Allianz that’s who.<br />
offers<br />
the most cargo<br />
protection with<br />
the least hassle?<br />
With Allianz, you<br />
get the broadest protection and the fewest exclusions of any<br />
policy on the market. You work with insurance pros who specialize<br />
in transportation. Whether it’s settling a spoilage claim or<br />
recognizing what’s unique about your operation, you talk to<br />
people who understand the challenges you face. Learn more<br />
about how Allianz can support your business.<br />
Contact Sam Rizzitelli at 203.736.1966 or<br />
samuel.rizzitelliJr@agcs.allianz.com.<br />
© <strong>2016</strong> Allianz Global Corporate & Specialty<br />
2015 Owner-Operator of the Year, Edward “Mark” Tricco, left, and 2015<br />
Company Driver of the Year Danny Smith visit with TCA Highway Angel<br />
spokesperson Lindsay Lawler at the Great American Trucking Show in<br />
Dallas in August.<br />
information, work history, and safety record.<br />
They are also asked to write a 300-word essay explaining why they are good<br />
“trucking citizens” and should be a candidate for the grand prize.<br />
For the owner-operators, additional documentation is required such as equipment<br />
specifications, business plans, and financial statements.<br />
The competition judges will examine these materials and select the three finalists<br />
for each contest, to be announced in December.<br />
Each of the six finalists will receive an all-expense paid trip to attend TCA’s<br />
Annual Convention, March 26-29, 2017, at the Gaylord Opryland in Nashville,<br />
Tennessee.<br />
There, one grand prize winner will be selected for each contest.<br />
InGauge<br />
Over the past two months, the association has been working diligently on<br />
many new features and improvements to the <strong>Truckload</strong> Carriers Association’s<br />
inGauge program.<br />
As a result, we are pleased to launch Version 1.6.<br />
When you log in, you will notice the following:<br />
Dashboard Loading Speed. As a result of server caching techniques, the loading<br />
times for each dashboard has improved by over 90 percent. Depending on your<br />
internet connection, all dashboards should load in under three seconds (which exceeds<br />
our original goal of four seconds).<br />
Action Items (Stage 1). In order to increase awareness and usage of the Action<br />
Items feature, we have added an interface directly to the dashboards, which allows<br />
primary users to add/edit Action Items below each linked metric. Further, primary<br />
users are able to assign an Action Item to a specific sub user and set a deadline. In<br />
the upcoming months, we will be introducing numerous improvements/changes to<br />
Action Items to make the process more collaborative among all users.<br />
Goal Tracking. Similar to the new interface for Action Items, we have added a<br />
simple interface below each linked metric on the Internal Dashboard to allow primary<br />
users to add/edit numeric goals. In the next two weeks, we will be adding a line<br />
chart (similar to external dashboard) to visualize your performance (over multiple<br />
intervals) versus your goal(s). Soon you will also have the option of setting goals for<br />
each fiscal month.<br />
New Navigation Toolbar. We have eliminated the bulky navigation toolbar at<br />
the top of the screen in favor of a smaller, more intuitive navigation toolbar. In the<br />
coming months, the menu area (blue area on left-hand side) will be eliminated<br />
entirely, and replaced with a more functional toolbar that will improve functionality<br />
on all devices.<br />
Value Formatting. You will now notice we have added comma separation for<br />
44 <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org TCA <strong>2016</strong>
‘thousandths’ on all displayed values and that all currency-related<br />
metrics now display “$” in front of them.<br />
BPG Bar Chart. We have changed the color for the<br />
logged-in user from red to yellow.<br />
For more information, contact TCA inGauge Program<br />
Manager Chris Henry at chris@tcaingauge.com.<br />
McLeod, TCA Partnership<br />
Working with the <strong>Truckload</strong> Carriers Association’s<br />
inGauge online benchmarking service, McLeod Software<br />
has created automated reporting functions that let our<br />
customers generate, with the click of a mouse, the monthly<br />
data exports from their LoadMaster Enterprise system,<br />
which are necessary for the Benchmarking program.<br />
This includes an automated data export for all 334 items<br />
submitted monthly by the Best Practice Group members<br />
and the 72 items submitted by the online subscribers in<br />
this program.<br />
This new product makes the accurate export of the<br />
required data as simple and fast as it can possibly be; it<br />
has been tested with the inGauge system in collecting<br />
benchmarking data. This saves labor hours and ensures<br />
consistency in creating the data imported by inGauge.<br />
“We recognize the great value that our customers are<br />
getting by participating in the TCA benchmarking initiative,”<br />
said Tom McLeod, founder and CEO of McLeod Software.<br />
“We wanted to make it easy for our customers to<br />
participate, so we have invested in helping remove most<br />
of the labor required to collect and organize the necessary<br />
inputs for the Benchmarking program. I hope that having<br />
access to this automated process will encourage even<br />
more of our customers to participate in the TCA benchmarking<br />
initiatives.”<br />
“McLeod Software understands the value of benchmarking<br />
for its customers. The launch of this new reporting<br />
tool demonstrates their commitment to helping<br />
their customers become more efficient and profitable,”<br />
stated Chris Henry, inGauge program manager. “We value<br />
McLeod’s generous support and efforts to make benchmarking<br />
a standard industry practice in trucking.”<br />
Tom McLeod<br />
TCA <strong>2016</strong> www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org | <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> 45
Mark Your<br />
Calendar<br />
December <strong>2016</strong><br />
>> December 14 — Webinar: Maintenance, Operations, Recruitment and<br />
Retention, Safety and Compliance. 12 noon-1 p.m. ET. Find more information at<br />
<strong>Truckload</strong>.org or contact TCA at (703) 838-1950.<br />
march 2017<br />
>> March 26-29 — <strong>Truckload</strong> Carriers Association Annual Convention, Gaylord<br />
Opryland, Nashville, Tennessee. Find more information at <strong>Truckload</strong>.org or<br />
contact TCA at (703) 838-1950.<br />
>> December 16 — <strong>2016</strong> Wreaths Across America Driver Appreciation Dinner,<br />
Arlington, Virginia. Find more information at <strong>Truckload</strong>.org or contact TCA at<br />
(703) 838-1950.<br />
>> December 17 — <strong>2016</strong> National Wreaths Across America Day, Arlington<br />
National Cemetery and other veterans’ cemeteries across the nation. Find more<br />
information at <strong>Truckload</strong>.org or contact TCA at (703) 838-1950.<br />
Visit TCA’s Event Calendar Page<br />
online at <strong>Truckload</strong>.org and click “Events.”<br />
trucking’s most entertaining executive public ation<br />
Tca members:<br />
This is your magazine!<br />
BEST FLEETS TO DRIVE FOR | SAFEST FLEETS | DRIVERS OF THE YEAR | HIGHWAY ANGEL<br />
INSIDE OUT FEATURING RON GOODE | HIGHWAY ANGEL TOUR | GETTING HEALTHY WITH ROLLING STRONG<br />
O F F I C I A L P U B L I C A T I O N O F T H E T R U C K L O A D C A R R I E R S A S S O C I A T I O N<br />
O F F I C I A L P U B L I C A T I O N O F T H E T R U C K L O A D C A R R I E R S A S S O C I A T I O N<br />
HEALTH FAIRS | inGAUGE LAUNCH | MEET OUR NEW MEMBER DEVELOPMENT SPECIALIST<br />
O F F I C I A L P U B L I C A T I O N O F T H E T R U C K L O A D C A R R I E R S A S S O C I A T I O N<br />
FROM WHERE WE SIT • HIGHWAY ANGEL TOUR WITH LINDSAY LAWLER • WREATHS ACROSS AMERICA GALA IN REVIEW<br />
O F F I C I A L P U B L I C A T I O N O F T H E T R U C K L O A D C A R R I E R S A S S O C I A T I O N<br />
WINTER 2015-16<br />
SPRING <strong>2016</strong><br />
SUMMER/FALL 2015<br />
MISTER<br />
MONDAY<br />
NIGHT WITH<br />
BEST FLEETS TO DRIVE FOR • NATIONAL FLEET SAFETY AWARD WINNERS • DRIVERS OF THE YEAR<br />
O F F I C I A L P U B L I C A T I O N O F T H E T R U C K L O A D C A R R I E R S A S S O C I A T I O N<br />
with international<br />
TV star MIKE ROWE<br />
Russell Stubbs is the<br />
first third-generation<br />
chairman in TCA history<br />
COACH JON GRUDEN<br />
SUMMER 2014<br />
BILL O’REILLY<br />
EXCLUSIVE<br />
NO SPIN MEDIA MOGUL<br />
WINTER<br />
2013-14<br />
CRACKING UP (NO LAUGHING MATTER) | 06<br />
RIDICULUDICROUS \ r -’dik-y -’lud-e-kres \ | 10<br />
DOWN TO BUSINESS WITH CHAIRMAN KRETSINGER | 24<br />
TCA CELEBRATES 75 YEARS: FOUNDATION OF THE FUTURE | 33<br />
IN THIS ISSUE:<br />
HIGHWAY TO HOPE<br />
Unfunded optimism<br />
FAKERZ PART 2<br />
Scam me once, shame on you.<br />
Scam me twice, shame on us.<br />
ATRI’S TOP 10<br />
The top 10 industry concerns<br />
keeping executives up at night<br />
RAISING THE BAR<br />
Entry-level driver training<br />
standards are going up<br />
ASLEEP AT THE WHEEL<br />
The industry has woken up to the dangers<br />
posed by obstructive sleep apnea<br />
OVERSTOCKED<br />
Over-supply has the new truck market limping<br />
along. Who’s paring down the inventory?<br />
IN THIS ISSUE:<br />
CSA, TAKE 2<br />
Will the second act be better than the first?<br />
YOU CAN’T PARK HERE<br />
Lack of parking continues to vex drivers<br />
BUILDING MORE VALUE<br />
with Chairman Keith Tuttle<br />
12<br />
19<br />
24<br />
EXCLUSIVE<br />
MAKE LOVE, NOT POLITICS WITH<br />
JAMES CARVILLE & MARY MATALIN<br />
TECH TAKEOVER<br />
COMING RETRACTIONS<br />
It’s all about your business, your concerns, your challenges and your lifesT yle.<br />
FIRED UP<br />
WITH CHAIRMAN SHEPARD DUNN<br />
We WanT To hear from you! Tell us how we’re doing and how we can address your needs better. Maybe there is a topic you would like to see<br />
covered or a story you think deserves attention. Feel free to email us at editor@thetrucker.com. We appreciaTe The opporTuniT y To serve you.<br />
-The Trucker and your <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> team<br />
46 <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org TCA <strong>2016</strong>
WE NEVER<br />
STOP DRIVING<br />
The best truck and trailer suspension systems and components are the<br />
ones that virtually go unnoticed. They work hard and do their job without<br />
demanding your constant attention; that’s exactly what you get when<br />
you ride on Hendrickson. We’ve become the world’s leading medium- and<br />
heavy-duty suspension, axle and brake systems manufacturer by pushing<br />
the boundaries with proprietary technical advancements in engineering<br />
and manufacturing processes for over 100 years. We never stop driving<br />
to create innovative solutions so you can do what you do best — run a<br />
productive and profitable business.
*Source EIA –US Energy Information Administration http://www.eia.gov<br />
**Based on annual on-highway diesel fuel usage and average price of fuel at $2.33 per gallon.<br />
The Engine Oil That Works As Hard As You .