ANNUAL REPORT
Atlantic_Council_Annual_Report_0513
Atlantic_Council_Annual_Report_0513
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
2015<br />
<strong>ANNUAL</strong><br />
<strong>REPORT</strong>
B<br />
ATLANTIC COUNCIL 2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
As the world has changed,<br />
so too has the Atlantic Council.<br />
Yet all along we have been<br />
driven by the conviction that<br />
if the United States shapes<br />
the future constructively with<br />
its friends and allies, the<br />
world will thrive. If we fail to<br />
do so, less benevolent forces<br />
will fill the void.<br />
2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
atlanticcouncil.org
2 ATLANTIC COUNCIL 2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
SECTION TABLE TITLE/DESCRIPTION<br />
OF CONTENTS 3<br />
TABLE OF<br />
CONTENTS<br />
06 32 58<br />
THEMATIC<br />
PROGRAMS<br />
REGIONAL<br />
CENTERS<br />
GLOBAL<br />
CONVENINGS<br />
Leadership Message<br />
04<br />
Brent Scowcroft Center on International Security<br />
08<br />
Rafik Hariri Center for the Middle East<br />
34<br />
Distinguished Leadership Awards<br />
60<br />
Board of Directors<br />
International Advisory<br />
Board<br />
Honor Roll of Contributors<br />
70<br />
71<br />
72<br />
Millennium Leadership Program<br />
14<br />
Global Energy Center<br />
18<br />
Dinu Patriciu Eurasia Center<br />
40<br />
Adrienne Arsht Latin America Center<br />
44<br />
Global Citizen Awards<br />
62<br />
Istanbul Energy & Economic Summit<br />
64<br />
Financial Summary<br />
By the Numbers<br />
74<br />
76<br />
Global Business & Economics Program<br />
22<br />
South Asia Center<br />
50<br />
Wrocław Global Forum<br />
66<br />
Future Europe Initiative<br />
28<br />
Africa Center<br />
54<br />
atlanticcouncil.org
4 ATLANTIC COUNCIL 2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
LEADERSHIP MESSAGE 5<br />
MESSAGE FROM THE CHAIRMAN AND CEO<br />
This year marks the Atlantic Council’s fifty-fifth<br />
anniversary.<br />
As the world has changed, so too has the Atlantic<br />
Council. Yet all along we have been driven by the<br />
conviction that if the United States shapes the<br />
future constructively with its friends and allies, the<br />
world will thrive. If we fail to do so, less benevolent<br />
forces will fill the void.<br />
Those founding principles were already clear in<br />
the first year of the Kennedy administration in<br />
1961, when the Atlantic Council was born. The<br />
story goes that Secretary of State Dean Rusk<br />
convened some of America’s most-prominent<br />
foreign policy leaders—among them former<br />
Secretaries of State Dean Acheson and Christian<br />
Herter, former UN General Assembly delegate<br />
Mary Pillsbury Lord, Marshall Plan architect<br />
William Clayton, and legendary diplomats<br />
Theodore Achilles and Henry Cabot Lodge.<br />
Rusk raised concerns of a historic nature. The<br />
Soviet Union had expanded its nuclear arsenal,<br />
and its leader Nikita Khrushchev was threatening<br />
Berlin’s freedom and thus the post-World War II<br />
order. Moscow was acting to advance Communist<br />
ideology and interests across the world.<br />
Rusk challenged these leaders to combine efforts<br />
in confronting the gathering threat. The result<br />
was the Atlantic Council of the United States.<br />
This new organization helped achieve historic<br />
outcomes: galvanizing constructive US<br />
leadership alongside European allies to contain,<br />
then roll back the Soviet threat, thus laying the<br />
groundwork for a Europe whole and free and to<br />
expand the rules-based international order to<br />
embrace emerging actors such as India and China.<br />
Fast forward to 2016 when threats to those<br />
historic accomplishments are rising.<br />
The Atlantic Council’s mission of “working<br />
together to secure the future” has never been<br />
more crucial. We act each day on the conviction<br />
that if the United States and its global allies and<br />
friends work more effectively together, we can<br />
forge one of the most enlightened, secure, and<br />
prosperous periods of world history, fueled by<br />
the human advances that are empowered by<br />
technological and scientific progress.<br />
If we fail, darker forces may fill the void. Witness<br />
Ukraine. Witness Syria. Witness terror in Paris<br />
and Brussels.<br />
Just as the Atlantic Council’s mission has never<br />
been more important, our capabilities have<br />
never been as robust. The past nine years have<br />
seen tremendous growth in our size and impact,<br />
with a ten-fold increase of revenue and staff. This<br />
advance has been driven by our unique culture<br />
of intellectual entrepreneurialism alongside key<br />
partners and our focus on measurable results.<br />
As described in the pages that follow, our<br />
thematic programs combine efforts with the<br />
high-impact regional centers that the Atlantic<br />
Council has created over the past decade. The<br />
ten programs and centers work together in a<br />
way that mirrors how real policy is created—<br />
not in a vacuum, but in a collaborative effort<br />
“We are driven by the conviction<br />
that if we don’t help shape the<br />
future with our friends and allies,<br />
then less benevolent forces<br />
will do so.”<br />
that draws from a range of expertise to address<br />
multiple issues and steered by an over-arching<br />
strategy and worldview.<br />
What powers all this work is a unique ability to<br />
convene at the highest and most-relevant levels<br />
demonstrated from our first annual gathering<br />
with President John F. Kennedy at the Mayflower<br />
Hotel. The pages that follow only scratch the<br />
surface of our work.<br />
We are indebted to those in our community<br />
who provide us with their wisdom and support,<br />
some of whom you will find in our Honor Role<br />
of Contributors on page 72. We thank our<br />
Board of Directors, our International Advisory<br />
Board, Atlantic Council individual and corporate<br />
members, our partners, and our impressive staff.<br />
Onward and upward,<br />
Jon M. Huntsman, Jr.<br />
Chairman<br />
Frederick Kempe<br />
President and CEO<br />
atlanticcouncil.org
6<br />
ATLANTIC COUNCIL 2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
THEMATIC PROGRAMS<br />
7<br />
THEMATIC<br />
PROGRAMS<br />
Brent Scowcroft Center on International Security<br />
08<br />
Millennium Leadership Program<br />
14<br />
Global Energy Center<br />
18<br />
Global Business & Economics Program<br />
22<br />
Future Europe Initiative<br />
28<br />
atlanticcouncil.org
8 ATLANTIC COUNCIL 2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
BRENT SCOWCROFT CENTER ON INTERNATIONAL SECURITY 9<br />
TWENTY-FIRST<br />
CENTURY STRATEGY<br />
Emerging challenges and<br />
opportunities call for new,<br />
imaginative approaches<br />
BRENT SCOWCROFT CENTER<br />
ON INTERNATIONAL SECURITY<br />
Named in honor of two-time National<br />
Security Advisor and former Atlantic<br />
Council Board Chairman, Lt. General<br />
Brent Scowcroft, the Brent Scowcroft<br />
Center on International Security pursues<br />
a foreign policy vision grounded in his<br />
legacy of American statecraft, built upon a<br />
foundation of bipartisanship and cooperation with America’s friends and allies (see<br />
Brent Scowcroft Interview page 11).<br />
The Scowcroft Center, the Atlantic Council’s flagship program under the direction of<br />
Council Vice President and Arnold Kanter Chair Barry Pavel, executes the Council’s<br />
historic mandate of uniting America’s like-minded friends and allies in creating a<br />
more secure and peaceful world. At a time of unprecedented change and instability,<br />
the Center integrates first-in-class work on NATO and transatlantic security with a<br />
future-focused global platform for understanding emerging trends, tackling rapidly<br />
evolving threats, and leveraging fresh opportunities.<br />
A high-level Atlantic Council delegation—led by board directors Paula Dobriansky and<br />
Sherri Goodman, and including Rear Admiral David Titley and US defense expert Nora<br />
Bensahel—explores Norway’s Arctic Svalbard Islands on a fact-finding mission.<br />
atlanticcouncil.org
10 ATLANTIC COUNCIL 2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
BRENT SCOWCROFT CENTER SECTION INTERNATIONAL TITLE/DESCRIPTION<br />
SECURITY 11<br />
AN INTERVIEW WITH<br />
BRENT SCOWCROFT<br />
Two-time National Security Advisor Lt. General<br />
Brent Scowcroft has been an Atlantic Council board<br />
director since the 1980s, and was the board chairman<br />
from 1998 to 1999 and 2013 to 2014. He is also the<br />
founding chairman of the International Advisory<br />
Board. Among the Council’s leading intellectual<br />
figures, Gen. Scowcroft was instrumental in the<br />
Council’s reinvention following the end of the Cold<br />
War. Pictured here, Gen. Scowcroft signs a three-ton<br />
piece of the Berlin Wall, alongside the signatures of<br />
others who helped bring it down.<br />
Q: WHAT DO YOU THINK DISTINGUISHES THE<br />
BRENT SCOWCROFT CENTER?<br />
A: The Scowcroft Center’s focus on strategy and foresight<br />
is unique. I often remind people that during the Cold War,<br />
the strategy was very clear: containment of the Soviet<br />
Union. Today, we debate tactics, but there is much less<br />
clarity about the strategic purpose behind America’s role<br />
in the world. The Scowcroft Center is making a significant<br />
contribution by fostering a debate about the grand strategy.<br />
Q: HAVE YOU EXPERIENCED A PARTICULAR<br />
MOMENT OF PRIDE IN THE COUNCIL’S WORK?<br />
[ABOVE]<br />
The Scowcroft Center every year<br />
hosts four military fellows from<br />
different branches of the US armed<br />
forces. Pictured here, General<br />
James L. Jones—chairman of the<br />
Brent Scowcroft Center, and former<br />
Atlantic Council chairman, US Marine<br />
Corps commandant, and Supreme<br />
Allied Commander Europe—joined by<br />
the Atlantic Council’s marine military<br />
fellow, leads a celebration of<br />
the Marine Corps birthday.<br />
The Brent Scowcroft Center on International Security is a leading forum for<br />
crafting smart, actionable strategies and solutions to the world’s most-daunting<br />
challenges—often through the application of innovative and unconventional<br />
tools and approaches, including 3-D printing, big-data analytics, robotics,<br />
nanotechnology, and biotechnology.<br />
In 2015, the Scowcroft Center continued to invest in its core transatlantic and<br />
NATO programming through the Transatlantic Security Initiative’s work on<br />
Europe’s rapidly evolving security environment. Two reports—The Naval Alliance:<br />
Preparing NATO for a Maritime Century and NATO’s New Strategy: Stability<br />
Generation—sparked crucial debate in Washington, Brussels, and allied capitals<br />
ahead of the 2016 Warsaw Summit and beyond.<br />
The dramatic global events of the last year proved that a reassessment of<br />
America’s overall strategic approach to world affairs is more crucial than ever. In<br />
response, the Center’s Strategy Initiative launched the Atlantic Council Strategy<br />
Papers, a series of essays designed to lay out potential strategies for America<br />
at a time when the United States is facing profound questions about its role in<br />
the world.<br />
The first paper, Dynamic Stability, set out a new approach for US foreign<br />
policy aimed at capturing America’s natural strengths within unfolding global<br />
Q: WHAT DOES THE ATLANTIC COUNCIL<br />
REPRESENT TO YOU?<br />
A: The Atlantic Council represents a unique transatlantic<br />
approach to contemporary challenges and American<br />
leadership that incorporates common interests and<br />
strengths of allies and partners. The Council is proudly<br />
nonpartisan; that is fundamental to its identity.<br />
Q: HOW DOES TODAY’S VOLATILE GLOBAL<br />
ENVIRONMENT INFLUENCE THE COUNCIL’S<br />
WORK?<br />
A: To remain dynamic in this environment, the Council<br />
produces ‘on-time’ analysis with the news cycle that’s<br />
relevant to policymakers and business leaders, who in a 24/7<br />
news environment are too busy to synthesize developments.<br />
I am also very pleased the Council has put considerable<br />
effort into strategy development and strategic foresight.<br />
This is another way to remain relevant over the long term.<br />
Q: YOU HAVE RESISTED MANY INSTITUTIONAL<br />
REQUESTS TO USE YOUR NAME. WHY DID YOU<br />
LEND YOUR NAME TO THE BRENT SCOWCROFT<br />
CENTER ON INTERNATIONAL SECURITY?<br />
A: Fred Kempe is very persuasive! When he first approached<br />
me about the idea of establishing a Scowcroft Center, I was<br />
reluctant. I was aware of the huge contributions others<br />
had made throughout the Council’s rich history…Acheson,<br />
Goodpaster, Kissinger. Fred ultimately won me over by<br />
convincing me that a Scowcroft Center would enable the<br />
Council to add significant resources and capabilities. And<br />
he was right.<br />
A: The awards dinners are always special, but 2010 was<br />
particularly poignant since my dear friend, former President<br />
George H.W. Bush, received the Distinguished International<br />
Leadership Award. It was a validation of the president’s<br />
remarkable career. That moment also showed me how<br />
significant the Atlantic Council had become—to have a<br />
former US president accept the award. And the next year,<br />
former President Bill Clinton accepted the award as well.<br />
Q: WHAT DOES YOUR PARTNERSHIP WITH THE<br />
COUNCIL MEAN TO YOU?<br />
A: My attachment to the Council reflects a shared<br />
philosophy and worldview: American leadership through<br />
our global network of alliances and partnerships is the best<br />
formula for strength and security, particularly when backed<br />
by bipartisan support at home. I am very pleased to see the<br />
Council so active and relevant today.<br />
atlanticcouncil.org
12 ATLANTIC COUNCIL 2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
BRENT SCOWCROFT CENTER ON INTERNATIONAL SECURITY 13<br />
megatrends. The President’s 2015 National<br />
Security Strategy picked up the Dynamic<br />
Stability concept—underscoring how rapid<br />
change “enables and incentivizes new forms<br />
of cooperation to establish dynamic security<br />
networks”—as one example of how the Council’s<br />
ideas help US policymakers frame America’s<br />
national interests.<br />
At the forefront of identifying and understanding<br />
long-term global trends, the Center’s Strategic<br />
Foresight Initiative outlined near-term policy<br />
recommendations to capture the benefits of<br />
disruptive innovation and mediate potential<br />
shocks. The Initiative serves as the direct analytic<br />
support for the National Intelligence Council’s<br />
work on the US government’s quadrennial<br />
twenty-year projection of global trends, and<br />
applies that same methodology to forecast<br />
futures with other Atlantic Council programs<br />
and in partnership with foreign governments,<br />
global think tanks, and corporate stakeholders.<br />
The Cyber Statecraft Initiative expanded its<br />
lead on identifying interconnected cyber risks—<br />
including the possibility of a “Lehman moment,”<br />
in which a few major failures in cyberspace<br />
could have cascading effects across the global<br />
economy—as well as the first-ever quantitative<br />
modeling on the extent to which cyber risks<br />
might be constraining the growth of global GDP.<br />
The Middle East Peace and Security Initiative’s<br />
new series of war games brought a topical<br />
twist to think tank-style analysis by employing<br />
the skills of former senior officials and regional<br />
experts in role-playing scenarios based on real<br />
global challenges, specifically the spread of<br />
ISIS. Following the effort’s success in revealing<br />
potential strengths in ISIS’s counter tactics, the<br />
Scowcroft Center added simulations and war<br />
games to its deepening analytic toolbox.<br />
A venue for policy and industry leaders to interact<br />
on developing defense priorities, the Emerging<br />
Defense Challenges initiative launched the Art<br />
of Future Warfare project (see Interview with<br />
George Lund below). The project unites the<br />
nation’s creative talent—such as bestselling<br />
World War Z novelist Max Brooks—with leading<br />
security experts—including Martin Dempsey,<br />
who as then-chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff<br />
wrote the foreword for the project’s anthology<br />
of fictional stories—and helps develop inventive<br />
responses to long-standing security dilemmas.<br />
In the Asia Security Initiative, policy-focused<br />
programming tackled growing security and<br />
defense challenges associated with changing<br />
dynamics in the Asia-Pacific region. The Council’s<br />
“Global stability is essential for all<br />
of us to survive….Without America’s<br />
leadership, I don’t think it happens.”<br />
– CHUCK HAGEL, FORMER US SECRETARY OF DEFENSE<br />
agenda-setting report on reshaping the Asia-<br />
Pacific financial architecture, part of a broader<br />
project on Asian futures, provided a set of<br />
specific policy recommendations for integrating<br />
China effectively into existing institutions in<br />
a measured but meaningful fashion.<br />
AN INTERVIEW WITH<br />
GEORGE LUND<br />
George Lund, chairman of Torch Hill Investment<br />
Partners, is the force behind the MA and George<br />
Lund Fellowship in the Scowcroft Center. The<br />
Fellowship gives voice to fresh ideas about how<br />
defense ministries and industries interact and<br />
promotes dialogue among policy leaders, industry<br />
executives, and other constituencies.<br />
Q: HOW HAS THE ATLANTIC COUNCIL EVOLVED<br />
DURING YOUR TENURE?<br />
A: The Council’s resources have grown dramatically and<br />
so has the sophistication and professionalism of its work.<br />
The Council earned a first-rate pedigree during the Cold<br />
War, and that tradition of relevance and institutional<br />
strength now has reemerged to address today’s pivotal<br />
issues. For example, Russia, which has instigated armed<br />
conflicts and reignited European tensions, is one focus<br />
of the Council’s contemporary agenda. More generally,<br />
the Council is now using its resources to respond to<br />
the evolving global context, not only in Europe but also<br />
throughout the globe.<br />
Q: HOW HAS THE LUND FELLOWSHIP HELPED THE<br />
COUNCIL MAKE AN IMPACT?<br />
A: Besides the extensive programming it organizes, I am<br />
most proud of the community it has built around Emerging<br />
Defense Challenges, and the defense industry’s contribution<br />
to addressing them. It brings together top players in<br />
government and business to help shape understanding of<br />
these issues, both among themselves and with Congress<br />
and the public at large. The initiative’s Captains of Industry<br />
Series and Defense-Industrial Policy Series have established<br />
the best venue for senior executives with something<br />
important to say.<br />
Q: WHAT MAKES THE COUNCIL’S FOCUS<br />
ON EMERGING DEFENSE CHALLENGES SO<br />
DISTINCTIVE?<br />
A: It’s the depth of expertise we bring to finding practical<br />
problems of national and international security. We<br />
provide a neutral forum where, for example, lawmakers<br />
have the chance to hear real feedback and practical<br />
suggestions from the officials who have to live with<br />
congressional action. That sort of interaction is huge. The<br />
result is better informed laws and policies, which are in<br />
the public’s best interest.<br />
Q: WHAT HAS YOUR PARTNERSHIP WITH THE<br />
COUNCIL MEANT TO YOU?<br />
A: It is immensely rewarding to be associated with a group<br />
of people who care passionately about creating a better<br />
world. On a personal level, it feels like I’m doing something<br />
worthwhile and good. On a professional level, I find the<br />
programming topical, provocative, and balanced—meaning<br />
nonpartisan and fact-based. The Council isn’t a cloister<br />
of like-minded people; it’s a forum for well-considered<br />
discussion and debate.<br />
Q: WHAT IS YOUR VISION FOR THE FUTURE?<br />
A: I see the Lund Fellowship building on the momentum<br />
we’ve established in the marketplace of defense ideas. I<br />
see the Brent Scowcroft Center on a quest to claim the<br />
top spot among conveners of decision-makers in national<br />
and international security. And I see the Atlantic Council<br />
commanding a similar convening power, but across the full<br />
range of the twenty-first century’s global challenges.<br />
atlanticcouncil.org
14<br />
ATLANTIC COUNCIL 2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
MILLENNIUM LEADERSHIP PROGRAM<br />
15<br />
RISING LEADERS FOR<br />
EMERGING CHALLENGES<br />
Empowering the next<br />
generation’s leaders<br />
to shape the future<br />
MILLENNIUM<br />
LEADERSHIP PROGRAM<br />
A Navy test pilot expanding the horizons of<br />
unmanned air-to-air combat. An urban developer<br />
overseeing the largest urban renewal project in<br />
Central Europe. A South African social entrepreneur<br />
educating the continent’s next generation of<br />
female engineers. A military veteran and storyteller<br />
bridging the civilian-military divide. These are just<br />
some of the transformational leaders of the Millennium Leadership Program, which brings<br />
together young, talented innovators from around the world.<br />
As the pace of change accelerates in the twenty-first century, tomorrow’s leaders must<br />
navigate a shifting landscape. Against this backdrop, the rising generation—one that has<br />
come of age in the midst of economic crisis, a technological revolution, and an increasingly<br />
interconnected world—will rewrite the playbook for tackling shared challenges. The<br />
Millennium Leadership Program helps them define their vision for the future and equips<br />
them to achieve it.<br />
Robert Abernethy (forward left), Atlantic Council board director and president and CEO of<br />
American Standard Development, joins some fifty young leaders for the Atlantic Council’s Future<br />
Leaders Summit.<br />
atlanticcouncil.org
16 ATLANTIC COUNCIL 2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
MILLENNIUM LEADERSHIP PROGRAM 17<br />
“The fact is that world events are influenced by people<br />
acting out of faith, passion, and a sense of who they are<br />
and where they fit.”<br />
– MADELEINE ALBRIGHT, FORMER US SECRETARY OF STATE<br />
[ABOVE]<br />
US Vice President Joseph Biden<br />
meets with the Millennium<br />
Leadership Future NATO fellows.<br />
The Atlantic Council launched the Millennium Leadership Program (MLP) in<br />
2015, recognizing that the rapidly changing world requires a new generation of<br />
globally connected, agile, and principled leaders able to build coalitions, adapt<br />
institutions, and inspire action.<br />
The program introduced two major new initiatives in its first year, the Millennium<br />
Fellowship and the Take Point Initiative, both of which identify and empower<br />
young leaders with proven potential to be transformational. United by an<br />
entrepreneurial spirit and global perspective, these leaders have already made<br />
their mark by fueling the energy and climate revolution through the application<br />
of new technologies and smarter policies, developing inclusive models of<br />
governance to reconnect citizens and institutions, pioneering new defense<br />
capabilities, and creating economic opportunity through innovation.<br />
The inaugural class of Millennium Fellows, convened thanks to crucial support<br />
from Atlantic Council board director Robert Abernethy, brought together twentyone<br />
exceptional professionals from fourteen countries across five continents.<br />
Throughout the year, fellows met with world leaders and senior policymakers,<br />
took the stage as speakers at the Council’s Istanbul Summit (see page 64) and<br />
Global Strategy Forum, travelled to Kyiv for a behind-the-scenes look at the<br />
historic challenges in Ukraine, and honed skills in master-class sessions with<br />
award-winning filmmakers, top policy experts, and best-selling authors.<br />
In MLP’s other major undertakings, the Council launched the Take Point<br />
Initiative in partnership with the Bob Woodruff Foundation to support veterans<br />
transitioning to careers as thought leaders in national security and foreign policy.<br />
With characters of resilience and comradery forged on battlefields, they bring<br />
unique perspectives and capabilities to civilian life.<br />
The initiative has already awarded more than $100,000 in grants to support<br />
projects developed by these extraordinary men and women, including works of<br />
fiction, documentary films, and veteran-focused nonprofits. One awardee was<br />
Navy veteran Justin Brown who launched his nonprofit, HillVets, in 2012 after<br />
experiencing first-hand the challenges veterans<br />
face pursuing careers on Capitol Hill. With<br />
support from Take Point and others, Justin is<br />
expanding HillVets to welcome twenty veterans<br />
to DC this summer for mentoring, internships,<br />
and transition assistance.<br />
Even while these new projects were unfolding,<br />
MLP maintained and developed long-standing<br />
programs such as the Future NATO Initiative<br />
and the Emerging Leaders in Environmental<br />
and Energy Policy (ELEEP) network.<br />
Supporting the transatlantic alliance is a core<br />
Council objective, and since 2002, the Council<br />
has partnered with NATO to engage the next<br />
generation of Atlantic leaders in shaping<br />
the future, convening rising leaders from<br />
across the Alliance in conjunction with official<br />
NATO Summits.<br />
Joining forces with NATO’s Allied Command<br />
Transformation, MLP led a full-day “design<br />
thinking” exercise and put to the test whether<br />
these next generation leaders could come<br />
up with more creative solutions for NATO’s<br />
challenges than the old pros. They did.<br />
Working with the Brent Scowcroft Center on<br />
International Security, MLP also launched its<br />
Wales2Warsaw project with the US Mission<br />
to NATO, a multi-media virtual campaign to<br />
engage Alliance citizens in informing NATO’s<br />
future. These initiatives have helped to frame<br />
the debate in the run up to the 2016 Warsaw<br />
Summit, where the Council and NATO will host<br />
a new cohort of next generation leaders.<br />
Recognizing the growing urgency for<br />
international collaboration to address climate<br />
change and energy security, the Council’s<br />
ELEEP has convened more than one hundred<br />
scientists, executives, policymakers, and<br />
entrepreneurs, inspiring publications in outlets<br />
including The Atlantic, Bloomberg, and Popular<br />
Science, and dozens of member-organized<br />
events and study tours.<br />
[ABOVE]<br />
Former US Secretary of Defense, US Senator from Nebraska,<br />
and Atlantic Council Chairman Chuck Hagel greets the<br />
2015 veterans from the Take Point Initiative.<br />
atlanticcouncil.org
18<br />
ATLANTIC COUNCIL 2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
GLOBAL ENERGY CENTER 19<br />
ENERGY UNBOUND<br />
Volatility and opportunity<br />
call for creative responses<br />
to ensure reliable,<br />
sustainable resources<br />
GLOBAL ENERGY<br />
CENTER<br />
Just a decade ago, few envisioned the sweeping<br />
changes that today are shaking the foundation<br />
of the global energy order. The unconventional<br />
hydrocarbon revolution enables the United States<br />
to shift from a future of energy scarcity and importdependence<br />
to become the world’s top producer<br />
of oil and natural gas. Simultaneously, renewable<br />
energy innovation, gains in energy efficiency, and greater use of natural gas fundamentally<br />
are changing the power sector and allowing further reductions in greenhouse-gas emissions.<br />
Large emerging economies, such as India and China, are now driving energy demand, which<br />
has far-reaching implications for global markets, climate change, and energy security. New<br />
technologies—from renewables to smart power grids and off-grid producers—are creating<br />
opportunities for decentralized and more cost-effective energy production. Yet despite<br />
all these changes, 1.2 billion people worldwide continue to live in energy poverty, and the<br />
economic and geopolitical ramifications remain uncertain.<br />
Bilfinger, an international engineering and services group based in Mannheim, Germany, is<br />
benefitting from the shale gas boom in the United States. In Scio, Ohio, the company is building a<br />
plant for the production of liquid gases. (Photo by Bilfinger SE.)<br />
atlanticcouncil.org
20 ATLANTIC COUNCIL 2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
SECTION GLOBAL TITLE/DESCRIPTION<br />
ENERGY CENTER<br />
21<br />
[ABOVE]<br />
Hamid and Majid Jafar (center and left), respectively the chairman and CEO of Iraq-based Crescent Petroleum,<br />
with former Spanish Foreign Minister Ana Palacio, at the opening ceremony of the Council’s Energy & Economic<br />
Summit in Istanbul (for more on the Summit see page 64).<br />
[ABOVE]<br />
Senator Lisa Murkowski (left) and Senator Mark Warner<br />
present their findings for the Atlantic Council’s Energy<br />
Boom and National Security Task Force.<br />
[LEFT]<br />
US Energy Secretary Ernest Moniz speaks at the annual<br />
Atlantic Council Board Dinner.<br />
Building on its long-standing work on energy<br />
security, the Atlantic Council launched the<br />
Global Energy Center in 2015 in response to<br />
a world unsettled by tectonic shifts in energy<br />
production and consumption patterns. In its<br />
first year, the Center tackled a wide range of<br />
challenges, from energy geopolitics and climate<br />
change, to emerging technologies and energyrelated<br />
conflict.<br />
Driven by the desire to turn these modern<br />
energy challenges into opportunities, the<br />
Global Energy Center—under Founding<br />
Director Richard Morningstar—generated<br />
“Gambling with the future of Earth itself<br />
when we know full well what the outcome<br />
would be is beyond reckless. It’s just<br />
plain immoral…We need to face reality:<br />
There is no planet B.”<br />
– JOHN KERRY, US SECRETARY OF STATE<br />
leading research and analysis with the purpose<br />
of catalyzing sustainable solutions.<br />
With US leaders grappling over how best to<br />
leverage new energy abundance, the Center<br />
launched a bipartisan US Energy Boom and<br />
National Security Task Force, co-chaired by<br />
Senator Lisa Murkowski (R-AK)—chairman<br />
of the Senate Energy and Natural Resource<br />
Committee—and Senator Mark Warner (D-<br />
VA). The group comprised a cross-section of<br />
foreign policy, defense, and energy experts<br />
that included former US Ambassador to the<br />
European Union Stuart Eizenstat, former Under<br />
Secretary of State Marc Grossman, and twotime<br />
US Ambassador Carlos Pascual.<br />
The task force’s July 2015 report, Empowering<br />
America: How Energy Abundance Can<br />
Strengthen US Global Leadership, laid out a<br />
pragmatic, forward-looking approach that<br />
bridged the partisan divide during the year’s<br />
contentious Congressional debates. Among<br />
its recommendations, the report argued for<br />
sustained research and investment in clean<br />
energy technology, along with greater support<br />
for energy diplomacy and technical assistance<br />
abroad. The task force also called on policymakers<br />
to repeal the crude oil export ban, which Congress<br />
subsequently did in October 2015.<br />
The Center regularly convened the most<br />
significant policy, business, and energy-expert<br />
voices. Miguel Arias Cañete, the European<br />
commissioner for energy and climate, kicked off<br />
a series of discussions on Europe’s most pressing<br />
energy security challenges. The Center’s popular<br />
CEO conversation series also brought to DC<br />
globally focused leaders to discuss the industry’s<br />
latest trends, from Crescent Petroleum CEO<br />
Majid Jafar on the need for Middle East industry<br />
reforms to Cheniere Energy CEO Charif Souki on<br />
the impact of US energy on global markets.<br />
When the historic nuclear agreement between<br />
Iran and the UN Security Council’s Permanent<br />
Members plus Germany (P5+1) sparked seismic<br />
shifts in the geopolitical energy landscape, the<br />
Energy Center was on point. The same week<br />
that the US Congress began debating the<br />
agreement, Atlantic Council senior fellows took<br />
stage to shed light on the potential impact of<br />
Iran’s natural gas reserves on Tehran’s Gulf<br />
neighbors, Europe, and Central Asia. The event<br />
was followed up with two reports, one analyzing<br />
A Post-Sanctions Iran and the Eurasia Energy<br />
Architecture and another taking a deep dive into<br />
Iran’s Energy Policy. Proposing a bold idea for<br />
how the Iran deal could result in a new strategic<br />
cooperation between rivals, the Global Energy<br />
Center also published a compelling hypothetical<br />
scenario in Crude Oil for Natural Gas: Prospects<br />
for Iran-Saudi Reconciliation.<br />
In the run-up to the Paris climate talks in<br />
December 2015, the Global Energy Center was<br />
at the forefront of linking geopolitical energy<br />
considerations to growing environmental threats.<br />
Underscoring the new Center’s rapid emergence<br />
as a leading voice on climate change, Secretary<br />
of State John Kerry chose to make a major pre-<br />
Paris climate speech at the Atlantic Council,<br />
launching the Global Energy Center’s Road<br />
to Paris series. Other leaders followed: Achim<br />
Steiner, the executive director of the United<br />
Nation’s Environmental Program; Adnan Amin,<br />
director general of the International Renewable<br />
Energy Agency (IRENA), and a host of<br />
European ambassadors.<br />
atlanticcouncil.org
22 ATLANTIC COUNCIL 2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
GLOBAL BUSINESS && ECONOMICS PROGRAM<br />
23<br />
PROSPERITY<br />
AND SECURITY<br />
Innovation and opportunity<br />
anchor global stability,<br />
but stagnation threatens<br />
the future<br />
GLOBAL BUSINESS &<br />
ECONOMICS PROGRAM<br />
trading system, or risk facing a new, insecure normal.<br />
Economic isolation is history, interdependence<br />
the increasing reality. To manage the global<br />
economy’s complexity, the United States and<br />
Europe—by far the world’s two wealthiest<br />
societies—must lead together, engaging<br />
today’s emerging economic powers to revitalize<br />
and adapt the foundations of the international<br />
Business and trade have been pillars of the modern transatlantic relationship since at least<br />
the Marshall Plan. Yet creating a genuinely barrier-free transatlantic marketplace with free<br />
exchange, regulatory convergence, and seamless investment remains a far-off ambition.<br />
The reward is more than material. Europe must open itself to greater competition<br />
and innovation to overcome a decade of mediocre growth and ensure its place as a<br />
global leader and critical partner in future challenges, whether in its internal security,<br />
international defense, or global economic governance.<br />
US Secretary of State John Kerry speaks at the Atlantic Council to make the case<br />
for American leadership of free trade agreements as critical elements for setting the rules for<br />
the twenty-first century global economy and achieving America’s foreign policy objectives.<br />
atlanticcouncil.org
24 ATLANTIC COUNCIL 2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
GLOBAL BUSINESS & ECONOMICS PROGRAM 25<br />
When US Secretary of State John Kerry needed<br />
to make a major policy speech in support of free<br />
trade, he chose the Atlantic Council as his venue,<br />
recognizing the Global Business Program’s<br />
unique ability to blend economics and security.<br />
“The Atlantic Council has become<br />
an essential forum for twenty-first<br />
century issues.”<br />
– MARILLYN HEWSON, CHAIRMAN, PRESIDENT, AND CEO,<br />
LOCKHEED MARTIN CORPORATION<br />
Pushing for the passage of Trade Promotion<br />
Authority, the secretary delivered a powerful<br />
message on the importance of free trade as a<br />
strategic tool to support international stability.<br />
He argued passionately for trade’s value in<br />
cementing alliances.<br />
The Global Business and Economics Program was<br />
founded to provide just this sort of forum. Led<br />
by former Executive Director of the International<br />
Monetary Fund Andrea Montanino, the Program<br />
convenes business leaders, government officials,<br />
and top experts to explore trends and frame<br />
policies that advance global economic growth<br />
and stability, with a particular focus on the<br />
transatlantic community.<br />
Secretary Kerry’s speech was the centerpiece<br />
of Atlantic Council programming on new<br />
free trade agreements—particularly the<br />
Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership<br />
(TTIP) and the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP).<br />
The Global Business Program’s newsletter<br />
TTIP&TRADEinAction has provided a worldwide<br />
audience with a weekly review of news<br />
and analysis of these groundbreaking trade<br />
negotiations.<br />
[ABOVE]<br />
Atlantic Council board directors Nelson Cunningham and Adrienne Arsht (left) with US Secretary of State John Kerry and<br />
Atlantic Council President and CEO Frederick Kempe. Secretary Kerry was at the Atlantic Council speaking on the central<br />
importance of TTIP and TTP to America’s security in the twenty-first century.<br />
AN INTERVIEW WITH<br />
C. BOYDEN GRAY<br />
C. Boyden Gray, former US ambassador to the European<br />
Union and White House counsel under President George H.<br />
W. Bush, founded the C. Boyden Gray Fellowship on Global<br />
Finance and Growth.<br />
Q: WHAT IS BEHIND THE COUNCIL’S PAST NINE YEARS<br />
OF TREMENDOUS GROWTH?<br />
A: The world has gotten a lot more difficult in the last many years.<br />
And the Atlantic Council is now remembering—what I grew up<br />
hearing—the clarion call of any southern lawyer: God bless the man<br />
who sues my client. The more trouble spots there are, sadly, the<br />
more necessary is the Atlantic Council in answering market needs<br />
for outside, objective expertise on these critical issues. The Council<br />
is a great organization responding to a difficult time in history.<br />
Q: WHAT ROLE DOES THE COUNCIL’S COMMUNITY OF<br />
INFLUENCE PLAY IN THE COUNCIL’S WORK?<br />
A: There is a deep bench of talent involved with the Council—both<br />
its staff and board. There is really a lot of firepower; and their<br />
practitioner’s approach sets the Council apart.<br />
Ideology, philosophy, vision and all that is very important,<br />
and we have a lot. But actually executing is paramount.<br />
My father was in government much of his life and he used<br />
to say, “any fool can think up a good idea, but it takes a<br />
genius to work it through the bureaucracy.” The Council’s<br />
community comprises people who have done the work,<br />
and that makes all the difference.<br />
Q: WHY LEND YOUR NAME TO THE BOYDEN GRAY<br />
FELLOW?<br />
A: The cornerstone of what the Atlantic Council can do is on<br />
the other side of the Atlantic Ocean. Europe is our largest<br />
trading partner and combines to form the biggest segment<br />
of global GDP. We share a common culture and common<br />
values. We should be acting as a united front against all<br />
the assaults on the key Western values of honest dealing,<br />
protection of private property and market economies, and<br />
individual liberty.<br />
We have to get the relationship straight with our European<br />
siblings—the people who naturally share our values—in<br />
order to reaffirm the prominence of those values. That’s<br />
why I’m glad the Council is refocusing its work on Europe<br />
with the Future Europe Initiative [Editor’s Note: See<br />
page 28].<br />
It’s important work to be done, and it starts—in a way—<br />
with finance and trade. If nothing else, the Great Recession<br />
showed that if we aren’t straight on the financial front, the<br />
end result will be ugly. Chris Brummer (the first Gray Fellow)<br />
has awakened everyone to the need for that coordination.<br />
Q: WHAT IS YOUR VISION FOR THE GRAY FELLOW,<br />
AND FOR THE ATLANTIC COUNCIL, GOING<br />
FORWARD?<br />
A: I hope that the Gray Fellow can contribute to a<br />
reestablishment of the historic ties with Europe, especially in<br />
connection with banking and finance. We have let those ties<br />
drift, but they are critical to the strength of the economies<br />
of both continents and to our ability to project our common<br />
values to the rest of the world.<br />
atlanticcouncil.org
26 ATLANTIC COUNCIL 2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
GLOBAL BUSINESS & ECONOMICS PROGRAM 27<br />
“The way forward is private sector<br />
diplomacy, in which business shares the<br />
stage with government and NGOs to find<br />
solutions. The Atlantic Council recognizes<br />
this need for collaboration and has been<br />
instrumental in bringing groups together.”<br />
– RICHARD EDELMAN, PRESIDENT AND CEO EDELMAN<br />
The Global Business and Economics Program<br />
also collaborates with the Atlantic Council’s<br />
other programs and centers to highlight regional<br />
perspectives on global trade issues. In June<br />
2015, the Program convened a panel discussion,<br />
Unlocking the Trans-Pacific Partnership:<br />
Views from Both Sides of the Pacific, which<br />
brought together Latin American and Asian<br />
representatives from key TPP partners. Meeting<br />
on the same day that Trade Promotion Authority<br />
cleared the US Senate, the panelists were<br />
optimistic about the final agreement, despite<br />
the emergence of political opposition in some<br />
countries (a TPP agreement was announced on<br />
October 5).<br />
The Program’s Transatlantic Finance Initiative<br />
(TFI), launched in 2013, highlights the extent<br />
of transatlantic and global interdependence in<br />
financial markets. Led by the C. Boyden Gray<br />
Fellow on Global Finance and Growth, Chris<br />
Brummer, the TFI presents conversations on<br />
the impact of regulation on financial institutions<br />
and services around the world. The Initiative’s<br />
flagship 2015 report, Renminbi Ascending,<br />
offered a groundbreaking study on the impact<br />
of the internationalization of the Chinese<br />
currency, and served as the centerpiece<br />
for launch events in Singapore, Hong Kong,<br />
Brussels, London, and Washington.<br />
The EuroGrowth Initiative is the Program’s<br />
newest effort to focus concern over slow<br />
growth into economic solutions for the<br />
European project. European leaders, experts,<br />
and policymakers have participated in the<br />
Program’s EuroGrowth Conversation Series,<br />
including European Commission Vice President<br />
Valdis Dombrovskis, International Monetary<br />
Fund Managing Director Christine Lagarde, and<br />
European Commissioner for Internal Market,<br />
[ABOVE]<br />
US Trade Representative Michael Froman (center)<br />
speaks at the Atlantic Council’s International Advisory<br />
Board Annual Meeting, co-chaired by Lockheed Martin<br />
Chairman, President, and CEO Marillyn Hewson (left) and<br />
Airbus CEO Tom Enders.<br />
[LEFT]<br />
Nobel-Laureate Joseph Stiglitz discusses the<br />
complications of sovereign debt restructuring during<br />
an event co-hosted by the Council’s Adrienne Arsht<br />
Latin America Center and the Global Business and<br />
Economics Program.<br />
[RIGHT]<br />
Edelman CEO Richard Edelman presents the findings of<br />
the Edelman Trust Barometer, which found a gap in trust<br />
that tracked closely with the global wealth divide.<br />
Industry, Entrepreneurship, and SMEs Elżbieta Bieńkowska.<br />
In a short time, this initiative has created an important<br />
forum to assess the prospects for European economic<br />
recovery and to generate ideas for catalyzing growth and<br />
innovation. As a part of the initiative’s public outreach, the<br />
weekly digital feature EconoGraphics explains economic<br />
trends and data in a quickly understandable format.<br />
atlanticcouncil.org
28<br />
ATLANTIC COUNCIL 2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
FUTURE EUROPE INITIATIVE 29<br />
EUROPE’S TEST<br />
Terror attacks, migrant<br />
waves, integration<br />
woes—a continent’s<br />
choice: lead or fall behind<br />
FUTURE EUROPE<br />
INITIATIVE<br />
As new challenges rattle the international system,<br />
Europe has had to reconcile its role as a global<br />
leader with the urgency of profound crises at,<br />
and within, its own borders—the most dramatic<br />
of which were the terrorist attacks in Paris and<br />
Brussels and the arrival of more than a million<br />
refugees.<br />
Russian aggression from the East and instability across the Middle East and North Africa<br />
have introduced a new era of uncertainty. The continent simultaneously faces growing<br />
internal challenges, from an ongoing Eurozone crisis and persistently lagging economy, to<br />
an influx of asylum-seeking refugees, to citizens increasingly alienated from established<br />
political leaders.<br />
These demands diminish Europe’s ability to lead, and the US-European partnership—a<br />
cornerstone of global democracy and stability—risks slipping adrift. America and its<br />
closest ally must use this moment to find a way to lead together.<br />
A man attends a memorial gathering near the old stock exchange in Brussels following<br />
the terrorist attacks of March 22, 2016 on the Brussels airport and Maalbeek metro station.<br />
(Photo by REUTERS/Christian Hartmann.)<br />
atlanticcouncil.org
30 ATLANTIC COUNCIL 2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
FUTURE EUROPE INITIATIVE 31<br />
[BELOW]<br />
“The growth of the Euro-Atlantic community has turned out to be one of the greatest forces in<br />
human history for advancing peace, prosperity, security, and democracy.” US Vice President Joseph<br />
Biden offers closing remarks at the conclusion of the Europe Whole and Free Conference.<br />
[ABOVE]<br />
“Reform fatigue is much worse<br />
than enlargement fatigue.” Štefan<br />
Füle (right), former European<br />
commissioner for enlargement and<br />
European neighborhood policy,<br />
speaks on a panel moderated by<br />
Frances Burwell, Atlantic Council<br />
vice president, European Union and<br />
special initiatives.<br />
The Atlantic Council’s core mission is rooted in Europe’s continued strategic<br />
importance for global prosperity and security. In response to the continent’s many<br />
challenges, the Atlantic Council launched the Future Europe Initiative, embracing<br />
and expanding upon the previous work of the Transatlantic Relations Program.<br />
Under the leadership of Vice President of European Union and Special Initiatives<br />
Frances Burwell, the Initiative draws from a robust network of expertise and<br />
resources to sustain a wide-reaching conversation on how to ensure that Europe<br />
remains an effective leader and partner to its friends around the globe.<br />
The Initiative fulfills that mission by bringing together leaders from both sides of<br />
the Atlantic for strategic conversations on Europe’s future. At a seminal conference<br />
in April 2014, US Vice President Joseph Biden, US Secretary of State John Kerry,<br />
and a host of European foreign and defense ministers set out a vision for a strong<br />
transatlantic strategy for a Europe “whole, free, prosperous, and at peace.” That<br />
event sparked a conversation that continued all the way through June 2015, when<br />
more than four hundred business and political leaders attended the Council’s sixth<br />
annual Wrocław Global Forum, the Program’s flagship annual event in Poland and<br />
home of the Atlantic Council’s Freedom Awards (see more on the Wrocław Global<br />
Forum and the Freedom Awards page 66).<br />
Throughout 2015, the Initiative pushed this crucial discussion forward by<br />
designing a series of high-level events to analyze policy and provide new<br />
recommendations for transatlantic decision-makers. European leaders<br />
ranging from then-European Commission President José Manuel Barroso,<br />
European Parliament President Martin Schulz, and UK Foreign Secretary<br />
Philip Hammond joined the Atlantic Council to share their own visions for the<br />
US-European partnership.<br />
Alongside the Initiative’s larger strategic push<br />
to reinvigorate support for strong European<br />
leadership is its commitment to deepen<br />
the European Union’s Eastern Partnership,<br />
particularly in the wake of the Ukraine crisis.<br />
In 2015, it launched the EUSource e-newsletter<br />
primarily aimed at a US audience to outline<br />
the European Union’s complex regulatory,<br />
economic, and political measures.<br />
Uniquely positioned at the center of the<br />
Council’s core mission, the Future Europe<br />
Initiative worked hand-in-hand with the Atlantic<br />
Council’s other programs and centers to infuse<br />
smart perspectives on Europe across their work.<br />
Following its own early efforts supporting<br />
trade negotiations, the Future Europe Initiative<br />
partnered with the Global Business and<br />
Economics Program to provide analysis on<br />
opportunities presented by the Transatlantic<br />
Trade and Investment Partnership and also<br />
conducted a comparative study of US-French<br />
economic competitiveness.<br />
“Advancing the lot of<br />
humanity is going to continue<br />
to depend upon, in my view,<br />
the solidarity of the Atlantic<br />
community. It’s going to fall<br />
to future generations and<br />
to organizations like the<br />
Atlantic Council to sustain<br />
this partnership.”<br />
– JOSEPH BIDEN, VICE PRESIDENT OF THE<br />
UNITED STATES<br />
With the Brent Scowcroft Center on International<br />
Security, the Initiative brought together nextgeneration<br />
Germans and Americans to discuss<br />
the tensions in that bilateral partnership.<br />
Working with the Rafik Hariri Center for the<br />
Middle East, Future Europe convened key US and<br />
European policymakers and experts to identify<br />
ways for the transatlantic partners to encourage<br />
political and economic reforms in Tunisia and<br />
across the region.<br />
atlanticcouncil.org
32<br />
ATLANTIC COUNCIL 2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
REGIONAL CENTERS<br />
33<br />
REGIONAL<br />
CENTERS<br />
Rafik Hariri Center for the Middle East<br />
34<br />
Dinu Patriciu Eurasia Center<br />
40<br />
Adrienne Arsht Latin America Center<br />
44<br />
South Asia Center<br />
50<br />
Africa Center<br />
54<br />
atlanticcouncil.org
34 ATLANTIC COUNCIL 2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
RAFIK HARIRI CENTER SECTION FOR TITLE/DESCRIPTION<br />
THE MIDDLE EAST 35<br />
CRISIS FROM<br />
THE MIDDLE EAST<br />
Failed states and civil wars<br />
cast global repercussions—<br />
and obscure opportunity<br />
RAFIK HARIRI CENTER FOR<br />
THE MIDDLE EAST<br />
The late Lebanese Prime Minister Rafik<br />
Hariri was a visionary leader who saw the<br />
potential for a prosperous and secure<br />
Middle East in which citizens share equally<br />
in dignity, freedom, and justice. As that hope<br />
took hold among those who participated in<br />
the historic Arab Spring, Rafik Hariri’s son,<br />
Bahaa, founded the Atlantic Council’s Rafik Hariri Center for the Middle East to help<br />
expand on his father’s legacy.<br />
As Middle Eastern leaders grapple with reform amid violence, the Hariri Center<br />
works with policymakers from the United States, Europe, and the Middle East<br />
to advance a global consensus on the region’s immediate needs and long-term<br />
challenges. Understanding the nuances of implementing solutions in a rapidly<br />
changing region, the Center focuses on the imperative for a strategic framework<br />
for US and European engagement.<br />
Yet, the violence all too frequently hides other revolutions. Across the Middle East<br />
and North Africa, sophisticated, technology-empowered youth are engaging in the<br />
political process. New investments in education, high-tech entrepreneurship, and<br />
novel grass-roots initiatives promise to remake Middle East societies.<br />
Smoke rises at a site allegedly hit by barrel bombs dropped by government forces in<br />
Aleppo’s Dahret Awwad neighborhood. (Photo by REUTERS/Mohamed Mounzer Masri.)<br />
atlanticcouncil.org
36<br />
ATLANTIC COUNCIL 2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong> RAFIK HARIRI CENTER FOR THE MIDDLE EAST 37<br />
[OPPOSITE TOP LEFT]<br />
Bahaa Hariri (left) confers with former US Secretary of State<br />
Madeleine Albright at the launch of the Atlantic Council’s Middle<br />
East Strategy Task Force.<br />
[OPPOSITE TOP RIGHT]<br />
Less than a month after being named a co-winner of the 2015 Nobel Prize<br />
honoring the Tunisian National Dialogue Quartet, Hussein Abassi, head of the<br />
Tunisian General Labor Union, speaks about the importance of labor unions<br />
as balancing elements in society, capable of bringing positive, lasting<br />
change to a country’s politics.<br />
What has grown apparent is that the crisis in the<br />
Middle East has become a crisis from the Middle<br />
East, with global implications that range from<br />
waves of migrants in Europe to rising extremism<br />
elsewhere. To tackle this historic challenge,<br />
the Hariri Center, led by Ambassador Francis<br />
Ricciardone, convened the Atlantic Council’s<br />
Middle East Strategy Task Force to foster a<br />
better understanding of the underlying causes<br />
of the crises and to enable a coherent strategy<br />
for US, European, and Middle Eastern partners<br />
to address them together. Co-chaired by former<br />
US Secretary of State Madeleine K. Albright<br />
and former National Security Advisor Stephen<br />
J. Hadley, the bipartisan task force launched its<br />
public work in June 2015.<br />
After months of behind-the-scenes effort with<br />
more than eighty experts and opinion leaders<br />
from around the world, the co-chairs presented<br />
their preliminary findings in December 2015<br />
to the Senate Foreign Relations Committee,<br />
attended by Chairman Bob Corker, Ranking<br />
Member Benjamin Cardin, and fourteen other<br />
committee members.<br />
Advancing its work through a listening tour of<br />
the Middle East and North Africa, the task force<br />
met with regional leaders to gather insights<br />
and support in spring 2016. The co-chairs will<br />
release their final report following the 2016 US<br />
presidential elections.<br />
To complement the Hariri Center’s work on<br />
regional strategy, Center experts also produced<br />
in-depth country and issue-specific analysis and<br />
policy recommendations on some of the more<br />
immediate challenges to the Middle East.<br />
Notably, while the Obama administration has<br />
long argued that no good options exist in Syria,<br />
the Hariri Center presented several action plans<br />
as dynamics in the country shifted, including<br />
ramping up the train-and-equip program to<br />
build a robust Syrian National Stabilization Force<br />
and leading a coalition of the willing to rapidly<br />
drive ISIS from eastern Syria (see page 38).<br />
On North Africa, the Hariri Center focused on<br />
political developments and the intersections<br />
of economic and political trends across Libya,<br />
Tunisia, Algeria, and Morocco. Karim Mezran,<br />
leading expert on North Africa, routinely<br />
convened the Libya Working Group with experts,<br />
practitioners, as well as current and former<br />
government officials to evaluate the precarious<br />
political and security situation in Libya as the<br />
country struggles to form a unity government<br />
and battle extremist threats.<br />
Hariri Center experts also focused on Tunisia, a<br />
country where the emerging democratic political<br />
system has been tested by a series of terrorist<br />
attacks and a deteriorating economy. They<br />
reported their findings in well-received reports:<br />
Tunisia: From Elected Government to Effective<br />
Governance and Tunisia: The Last Arab Spring.<br />
The Center also hosted a public conversation<br />
with Hussein Abassi, head of the Tunisian General<br />
Labor Union, and a member of Tunisia’s National<br />
Dialogue Quartet, which was awarded the 2015<br />
Nobel Peace Prize.<br />
On Egypt, the Center tackled US-Egypt<br />
diplomatic relations, the country’s economic<br />
policies, security challenges, and internal<br />
political developments, among other issues. In<br />
addition to providing analysis from Washington,<br />
nonresident fellows in Egypt provide on-theground,<br />
real-time reactions through both<br />
media appearances and publications. Notably,<br />
this analysis included To Vote or Not to Vote:<br />
Examining the Disenfranchised in Egypt’s Political<br />
[LEFT]<br />
Sultan Ahmed Al Jaber<br />
(center), minister of state<br />
in the United Arab Emirates<br />
and chairman of sustainable<br />
energy company Masdar,<br />
speaks at a breakfast hosted<br />
by Atlantic Council board<br />
director Rafic Bizri (left) and<br />
Hariri Center Director Francis<br />
Ricciardone (right).<br />
Landscape, assessing the electoral environment<br />
ahead of the fall 2015 elections.<br />
“There are green shoots, we call them,<br />
messages of hope coming out of the<br />
Middle East that need to be nurtured….<br />
They offer the hope of a more<br />
prosperous and secure Middle East.”<br />
– STEPHEN J. HADLEY, CO-CHAIR OF THE ATLANTIC COUNCIL’S<br />
MIDDLE EAST STRATEGY TASK FORCE<br />
atlanticcouncil.org
38 ATLANTIC COUNCIL 2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
RAFIK HARIRI CENTER FOR THE MIDDLE EAST 39<br />
ROAD TO STABILIZING SYRIA AND DEFEATING ISIS<br />
Senior Fellows Frederic C. Hof and Faysal Itani take a critical look at US policy toward<br />
Syria, the consequences of inaction, and opportunities for political resolution<br />
The Rafik Hariri Center for the Middle East<br />
addressed Syria’s protracted conflict and its<br />
consequences in the region with unparalleled<br />
programming and insight. Frederic C. Hof’s<br />
highly sought-after analysis on Syria, along with<br />
Faysal Itani’s distinct assessment of local actors<br />
combined to impact the debate in Washington on<br />
this highly contentious issue.<br />
Hof, a current Atlantic Council senior fellow and<br />
former special adviser for transition in Syria, has<br />
been among the most vocal advocates for increased<br />
US action in Syria. He pointed to US “non-policy” as<br />
a factor in the emergence of ISIS and its continued<br />
sway over significant territory in Syria:<br />
“This brings you full-circle to the whole question<br />
of: What is your strategy? If your objective is to<br />
degrade and ultimately destroy [ISIS], then you<br />
need to have a strategy that doesn’t produce the<br />
opposite effect,” Hof told Business Insider. “It is<br />
the lack of civilian protection that is just fattening<br />
the political wallet of ISIS.”<br />
The April 2015 release of Itani’s report, Defeating<br />
the Jihadists in Syria: Competition before<br />
Confrontation, and a panel discussion on<br />
insurgent forces in Syria galvanized thinking<br />
on how to empower nationalist rebel forces to<br />
compete effectively with ISIS. His September 2015<br />
release of “Seizing Local Opportunities in Syria,”<br />
co-authored with Syrian regime defector Bassam Barabandi,<br />
drew administration attention to possibilities in facilitating<br />
a political transition and weakening jihadists in the country.<br />
Hof also routinely convened the Syria Policy Analysis<br />
Network for private, off-the-record discussions with leading<br />
US policymakers, Syria watchers, and journalists to engage<br />
with prominent Syrian figures and opposition leaders in<br />
discussions of the latest developments on the ground.<br />
[RIGHT]<br />
Japanese Ambassador Kenichiro Sasae joined the Atlantic<br />
Council to discuss Japan’s energy priorities and Middle<br />
East policies. Rafik Hariri Center Senior Fellow Frederic<br />
Hof chaired the conference.<br />
AN INTERVIEW WITH<br />
BAHAA HARIRI<br />
Bahaa Hariri is an international business leader and the eldest son of the<br />
former Prime Minister of Lebanon Rafik Hariri, who was assassinated<br />
in 2005. Bahaa Hariri founded the Rafik Hariri Center for the Middle<br />
East at the Atlantic Council to continue his father’s legacy of building<br />
a more secure and prosperous Arab world.<br />
Q: HOW WOULD YOU DEFINE<br />
YOUR FATHER’S LEGACY?<br />
A: My father, Rafik Hariri, saw the<br />
Arab people as full of talent, initiative,<br />
and capability, and understood there<br />
was no limit to what they could<br />
achieve once they moved beyond<br />
conflict, injustice, and repression. To<br />
his last day on this earth, he believed<br />
that Lebanon could lead the way<br />
toward an era in which the great<br />
promise and potential of the Arab<br />
world would finally be realized—a<br />
world of shared dignity, creativity,<br />
and prosperity.<br />
Q: WHY DID YOU CHOOSE THE<br />
ATLANTIC COUNCIL TO TAKE<br />
UP THE MANTEL OF YOUR<br />
FATHER’S LEGACY?<br />
A: There are forces driving change in<br />
the world today. With American and<br />
European help, those forces will guide<br />
the Middle East to converge with<br />
the international community—with a<br />
robust civil society, democracy, and<br />
free markets. Without that support,<br />
the Middle East risks diverging onto<br />
a dark and unsustainable path. The<br />
Atlantic Council was the right place<br />
because it is best positioned to<br />
encourage European and American<br />
leadership as essential for the Arab<br />
world’s transition to the right path.<br />
Q: HOW HAS THE HARIRI<br />
CENTER’S WORK SHAPED THE<br />
DEBATE ON US-MIDDLE EAST<br />
STRATEGY?<br />
A: The Center provides a unique<br />
platform for debate and dialogue,<br />
producing cutting-edge analysis to<br />
support the Middle East’s stability and<br />
democratic evolution. Additionally,<br />
the Center has expanded in the<br />
region to ensure that those who are<br />
actively building a new future are<br />
heard in the United States, Europe,<br />
and beyond, so that international<br />
strategy is based on facts from those<br />
living in the region.<br />
Q: HOW DOES THE COUNCIL<br />
CULTIVATE A GLOBAL<br />
UNDERSTANDING AMONG ITS<br />
COMMUNITY?<br />
A: The Atlantic Council positions itself<br />
as an indispensable resource for<br />
senior US and foreign government officials,<br />
economists, journalists, among<br />
others who are closely following the<br />
Middle East and North Africa. With a<br />
community built on engagement and<br />
debate, the best ideas and most profound<br />
insights quickly diffuse across<br />
the network of experts.<br />
Q: WHAT IS YOUR VISION FOR<br />
THE HARIRI CENTER, AND FOR<br />
THE ATLANTIC COUNCIL, GOING<br />
FORWARD?<br />
A: The Arab world needs global<br />
citizens—like Rafik Hariri—and<br />
institutions—like the Atlantic Council<br />
and the Hariri Center—who will<br />
struggle and succeed against the<br />
odds. Arab citizens are seeking a<br />
new path. It will be long and difficult<br />
change, with many twists and turns.<br />
At times it might not be clear whether<br />
things are getting better or worse,<br />
but today is not a time for the timid<br />
or the cynical. If the people of the<br />
Arab countries can find the strength<br />
and wisdom, we can fulfill my father’s<br />
vision for a vibrant and just future.<br />
atlanticcouncil.org
40 ATLANTIC COUNCIL 2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
DINU PATRICIU EURASIA CENTER 41<br />
TECTONIC SHIFTS<br />
A revisionist Russia<br />
threatens a Europe<br />
whole and free<br />
DINU PATRICIU EURASIA<br />
CENTER<br />
Russia is at war in Ukraine.<br />
The Dinu Patriciu Eurasia<br />
Center’s report proved as<br />
much with cutting-edge<br />
digital forensic research<br />
methods novel to the<br />
think tank world—a form<br />
of intelligence gathering from open sources ranging from Facebook<br />
posts of Russian soldiers to Google Earth maps of Russian bases.<br />
Hiding in Plain Sight: Putin’s War in Ukraine, the innovative product of<br />
that work demonstrated, against Kremlin denials, that Russia’s military<br />
presence in Ukraine was responsible for the conflict in the Donbas<br />
region. Evidence of the report’s wide impact: the Russian-language<br />
version had to be temporarily removed from the Atlantic Council’s<br />
website, because the download traffic risked crashing the servers.<br />
The Patriciu Center, led by former Ambassador to Ukraine John Herbst,<br />
works to inform thinking in Washington and in European capitals on<br />
the dangers posed by a revanchist Kremlin. The Center’s analysis and<br />
convening power helps build consensus among policymakers across<br />
the Atlantic on how to best to keep alive the dream of a Europe<br />
whole and free and counter Russian President Vladimir Putin’s efforts<br />
to undermine neighboring countries’ sovereignty.<br />
Protests in the Maidan in Kyiv, Ukraine in December 2013.<br />
(Photo by Sasha Maksymmenko.)<br />
atlanticcouncil.org
42 ATLANTIC COUNCIL 2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
DINU SECTION PATRICIU TITLE/DESCRIPTION<br />
EURASIA CENTER 43<br />
The Dinu Patriciu Eurasia Center has been at the<br />
forefront of US and European efforts to better<br />
understand Russia’s increasingly activist foreign<br />
policies and ensure that post-Cold War gains in<br />
advancing and expanding European democracy<br />
are preserved.<br />
In 2015, the Patriciu Eurasia Center’s Ukraine in<br />
Europe Initiative did much to inform a growing<br />
transatlantic understanding of the historic risks<br />
that grow out of Russian President Vladimir<br />
Putin’s ambitions. As Ukraine’s internal turmoil<br />
evolved into Moscow’s annexation of Crimea<br />
and interventions in eastern Ukraine, the<br />
initiative convened regular meetings with<br />
senior officials in Washington, Ukraine, and<br />
Europe—helping to animate Western policy—<br />
while at the same time informing the public<br />
debate and legislative understanding.<br />
Advocating a strategy for resolving the conflict<br />
in Ukraine’s eastern regions and offering the<br />
country a more secure future, the Atlantic<br />
Council advanced four key elements across its<br />
international network: thwarting the Kremlin’s<br />
aggression in Ukraine’s East with a combination<br />
[LEFT]<br />
“My take is that Russia is not eager… to have<br />
peace and stability, neither in Ukraine nor in<br />
Europe,” said Ukraine’s then-Prime Minister<br />
Arseniy Yatsenyuk (right), citing as evidence a<br />
renewed offensive by Russian-backed forces, at<br />
a June 9, 2015 meeting at the Atlantic Council<br />
hosted by Atlantic Council Executive Vice<br />
President Damon Wilson.<br />
of sanctions on Russia and military support for<br />
Ukraine; promoting a host of reforms in Ukraine<br />
and economic aid from the West; maintaining<br />
policy support for Ukraine’s sovereignty in<br />
Crimea; and unmasking the impact of Moscow’s<br />
massive disinformation operation.<br />
The impact of this approach was tangible.<br />
The Ukraine initiative’s flagship publication,<br />
UkraineAlert, reached thousands of global<br />
influencers with original analysis and research. A<br />
steady stream of reports shaped public opinion;<br />
two of those reports in particular helped set the<br />
tone for the West’s response to the crisis.<br />
The first, Preserving Ukraine’s Independence,<br />
Resisting Russian Aggression: What the United<br />
States and NATO Must Do—calling for the West<br />
to more actively support Ukraine, including the<br />
provision of defensive weapons—dominated<br />
the agenda at the Munich Defense and Security<br />
Conference in February 2015. Although the<br />
Obama Administration initially rejected the<br />
suggestion to provide outright lethal defensive<br />
weapons to Ukraine, it subsequently sent much of<br />
the hardware recommended in the report, greatly<br />
increasing the assistance supplied to Ukraine. By<br />
galvanizing experts from several institutions, the<br />
report had greater impact and was ranked by<br />
the University of Pennsylvania’s annual Global<br />
Go To Think Tank Index as the number one best<br />
collaborative research paper and the number<br />
three policy report paper in the world.<br />
The second paper, Hiding in Plain Sight: Putin’s<br />
War in Ukraine, was one of the most widely read<br />
and quoted projects in the Atlantic Council’s halfcentury<br />
history, deploying a new brand of digital<br />
research techniques to trace the internet postings<br />
of Russian soldiers on VKontakte, the Russian<br />
equivalent of Facebook. It proved that Moscow<br />
was present in and responsible for the conflict<br />
in the Donbas and for fueling the hostilities in<br />
Ukraine’s East. A VICE News documentary, Selfie<br />
Soldiers, based on Hiding in Plain Sight won<br />
Columbia University’s Alfred DuPont Journalism<br />
Award (the Pulitzer Prize for television).<br />
The Eurasia Center’s top community of experts<br />
devoted to stability in Europe’s East, combined<br />
with its leading research and analysis, made the<br />
Atlantic Council the go-to venue for Ukrainian<br />
officials, as well as leading specialists and<br />
journalists working on Ukrainian and Russian<br />
issues. In 2015, both Ukrainian President Petro<br />
Poroshenko and then-Prime Minister Arseniy<br />
Yatsenyuk—along with dozens of Ukrainian<br />
officials—chose the Council as their platform for<br />
addressing the Washington policy community.<br />
This programming has broadened understanding<br />
of the importance of Ukraine’s struggle and the<br />
ongoing danger to European security. In July, the<br />
nominee for the chairmanship of the Joint Chiefs<br />
of Staff, General Joseph Dunford, testified in<br />
Congress that Moscow was the greatest security<br />
danger to the United States. More importantly,<br />
NATO decided to greatly increase its presence<br />
of troops and hardware in the Baltic States<br />
and Poland, and to conduct more exercises in<br />
the Black Sea, steps that the Center had been<br />
advocating for months.<br />
At the same time, the Eurasia Center has<br />
deepened its focus on Russia, endeavoring to<br />
understand the dynamics shaping the country<br />
and exploring ways to lessen tensions with<br />
Moscow and bring it closer to the West. The<br />
Atlantic Council has convened private and public<br />
conversations with former senior Russian officials<br />
and business leaders; the Brent Scowcroft Center<br />
on International Security published the most<br />
ambitions think tank effort of 2015 with the<br />
Russian Academy of Science’s IMEMO.<br />
The “grey zone” between Russia and NATO is<br />
another key piece of the Patriciu Eurasia Center’s<br />
work. Twice in 2015, the Atlantic Council led a<br />
delegation to Moldova and Georgia to meet with<br />
high-level officials to explore ways to strengthen<br />
their internal institutions and deepen their<br />
relationship with NATO, the European Union, and<br />
the United States as a means of better ensuring<br />
their long-term security.<br />
IN MEMORIAM<br />
DINU PATRICIU (1950-2014)<br />
Dinu Patriciu founded the Atlantic Council’s Dinu Patriciu<br />
Eurasia Center in 2009 to pursue his dream that the Black<br />
Sea region, torn apart by World War II and the Cold War,<br />
could be reunited by common values, mutual interests,<br />
and economic cooperation.<br />
He spoke passionately about the Black Sea as a “lake” that<br />
should unite instead of divide the countries on its shores—<br />
Bulgaria, Georgia, Romania, Russia, and Ukraine. As a<br />
philanthropist and as a businessman, he put his ideas into<br />
action.<br />
Dinu’s businesses ranged from energy, media, and real<br />
estate, to automotive technologies and banking. He was<br />
a pioneer of his country’s democratic evolution in the<br />
early 1990s, as founder of the National Liberal Party in<br />
Romania, and one of the most effective advocates of its<br />
NATO membership.<br />
Dinu was also one of Central Europe’s earliest<br />
philanthropists. His Dinu Patriciu Foundation has<br />
empowered thousands of young Romanians to pursue<br />
degrees and careers that have contributed positively to<br />
Romania’s democratic development. He was also a gifted<br />
architect and, in his later years, an artist.<br />
Driven by Dinu’s entrepreneurial nature, the Patriciu<br />
Eurasia Center expanded its reach to embrace issues<br />
beyond the Black Sea and launched what has become the<br />
Atlantic Council’s flagship global gathering, the Energy &<br />
Economic Summit in Istanbul.<br />
Alongside the 2014 Global Citizen Awards in New York,<br />
the Atlantic Council presented a special tribute to Dinu—<br />
received by his daughters, Ana and Maria, and his longtime<br />
partner Melanie Chen. Said Atlantic Council President<br />
and CEO Frederick Kempe, “The Atlantic Council will<br />
be forever grateful for Dinu’s wisdom, ingenuity, and<br />
generosity… We will miss his unique insights and his<br />
determination to make a difference.”<br />
atlanticcouncil.org
44<br />
ATLANTIC COUNCIL 2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
ADRIENNE ARSHT LATIN AMERICA CENTER<br />
45<br />
THE NEW LATIN AMERICA<br />
Stereotypes obscure<br />
a democratic and stable<br />
continent transformed by<br />
globalized economies<br />
ADRIENNE ARSHT LATIN<br />
AMERICA CENTER<br />
When the Organization for Economic<br />
Cooperation and Development (OECD)<br />
granted President Juan Manuel Santos’s<br />
request to begin accession negotiations,<br />
Colombia set course to become Latin<br />
America’s third member country—after<br />
Mexico and Chile—in the elite thirtyeight-nation<br />
club of industrialized economies. The moment marked a milestone of<br />
transformation for a country with double-digit manufacturing growth and a booming<br />
energy sector.<br />
Across Latin America, democracies are thriving, supported by a rising middle class.<br />
Individual countries assume larger roles on the global stage, as innovators and as<br />
trading partners. Argentina, Brazil, and Mexico are members of the Group of Twenty<br />
(G20), playing prominent roles in shaping the world economy. In Latin America, more<br />
women have achieved levels of power—presidencies and legislative assemblies—<br />
than nearly any other region. However, much of the world continues to view Latin<br />
America through outdated lenses shaped by old stereotypes, and fails to grasp the<br />
extent and meaning of the region’s dramatic transformation.<br />
Cubans gather for the opening of the US Interests Section in Havana on July 20, 2015<br />
as the two countries begin a new era of post-Cold War relations.<br />
(Photo by REUTERS/Jonathan Ernst.)<br />
atlanticcouncil.org
46 ATLANTIC COUNCIL 2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
ADRIENNE ARSHT SECTION LATIN TITLE/DESCRIPTION<br />
AMERICA CENTER 47<br />
Launched in October 2013, the Adrienne Arsht Latin America Center was founded<br />
to heighten awareness of the new Latin America as a core partner in the wider<br />
transatlantic community. Latin America’s rise comes at a time when US and<br />
European foreign policies are overextended by the onslaught of global crises,<br />
which diminish their capacity to engage adequately with dynamic Latin American<br />
societies on the full spectrum of potential opportunities—both political and<br />
economic. As a result, it has been difficult to move the policy and media discussion<br />
beyond the narrow scope of old issues—drugs, violence, and immigration. The<br />
Center aims to highlight Latin America’s transformations for a global audience<br />
and demonstrate its role as a strategic partner for friends and allies.<br />
The Adrienne Arsht Latin America Center, under the leadership of Founder<br />
Adrienne Arsht and Director Peter Schechter, takes an impact-focused approach<br />
to its work. Through extensive consultations with key regional leaders, it collects<br />
first-hand research, asks probing questions, and builds relationships with private<br />
and public sector leaders to form the foundations of its projects.<br />
The Center’s results orientation has earned it a reputation as a powerful convener<br />
and publisher capable of helping policymakers understand the extent, meaning,<br />
and potential impact of the dramatic transformations in this region.<br />
AN INTERVIEW WITH<br />
ADRIENNE ARSHT<br />
Adrienne Arsht is a business leader and<br />
philanthropist. After serving as chairman of the<br />
board of TotalBank in Miami, Florida from 1997<br />
to 2007, Arsht founded the Adrienne Arsht Latin<br />
America Center to expand awareness of the new<br />
Latin America across diverse communities of<br />
influence, both within and outside Washington,<br />
DC. Pictured here, Arsht welcomes Colombian<br />
President Juan Manuel Santos to the Atlantic<br />
Council.<br />
[BELOW]<br />
Adrienne Arsht (left)—the founder<br />
of the Adrienne Arsht Latin America<br />
Center—and the center’s director,<br />
Peter Schechter (right), host a<br />
breakfast conversation with Rio de<br />
Janeiro Mayor Eduardo Paes.<br />
No country better symbolizes Latin America’s evolution than Colombia. Indeed,<br />
when President Barack Obama hosted Colombian President Juan Manuel Santos<br />
at the White House in December 2013, the Center—barely two months old—seized<br />
the historic moment and offered President Santos the Council’s nonpartisan<br />
platform to challenge conventional Washington wisdom with the story of how his<br />
country had progressed from Medellin Cartel to Medellin Miracle.<br />
Impressed with President Santos’s success in overseeing one of the fastestgrowing<br />
economies in Latin America, and most importantly, his tireless efforts<br />
to end his country’s conflict with the Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia<br />
(FARC), the Council continued its engagement on Colombian issues by awarding<br />
President Santos its 2015 Global Citizen Award in New York, with US Vice President<br />
Q: WHAT DREW YOU TO THE ATLANTIC COUNCIL<br />
AS THE ORGANIZATION TO CULTIVATE A BETTER<br />
UNDERSTANDING OF LATIN AMERICA?<br />
A: When I moved to Washington, DC, I spoke to everyone<br />
about the need for a center focused on Latin America.<br />
The Atlantic Council listened. They came to me, saying<br />
they wanted to build upon my vision and passion to<br />
integrate Latin America with Europe and the United<br />
States, replace outdated perceptions of the region, and<br />
create new opportunities for cooperation. We started<br />
small, with a one-off study, to confirm the viability of a<br />
larger initiative. The need was confirmed, and I founded<br />
the center. The Atlantic Council has been the perfect<br />
partner.<br />
Q: HOW WOULD YOU DESCRIBE THE IMPACT<br />
OF YOUR PARTNERSHIP WITH THE ATLANTIC<br />
COUNCIL?<br />
A: The impact of the work of the center has been very far<br />
reaching. Within the first year alone, we had fifty events<br />
in eight cities; we developed eight regional and thematic<br />
practice areas; we produced fifteen publications. We<br />
have had more than two thousand mentions and opinion<br />
pieces in US and international media. The work on Cuba<br />
and energy reform in Mexico has, among other things,<br />
resulted in many of the Latin American heads of state and<br />
government officials relying on our experts. It’s thrilling to<br />
see how much impact we’ve been able to have, together, in<br />
such a short time!<br />
Q: IS THERE A PARTICULAR MOMENT OF PRIDE<br />
OR SENSE OF ACCOMPLISHMENT YOU SHARE<br />
WITH PEOPLE WHEN TALKING ABOUT THE ARSHT<br />
CENTER?<br />
A: Yes, the Cuba poll, which was the first national poll<br />
on the subject of normalization. The impact of the<br />
poll was manifested by the administration’s decision to<br />
restore relations.<br />
Q: WHAT HAS THE ATLANTIC COUNCIL MEANT TO<br />
YOU PERSONALLY?<br />
A: I have met so many people whose expertise covers<br />
the most important global topics of our time. I have had<br />
a chance to gain knowledge of issues, people, and places<br />
that I would never have been exposed to otherwise.<br />
Q: WHY IS THE WORK OF THE ARSHT CENTER<br />
IMPORTANT?<br />
A: Because it brings to the attention of everyone north of<br />
Miami that there is a continent and a people that are too<br />
often overlooked.<br />
Q: HOW DO YOU SEE THE ATLANTIC COUNCIL<br />
EVOLVING IN THE NEXT FEW YEARS?<br />
A: I think that in three years, the Council’s public profile<br />
will be even greater throughout the policy world and even<br />
more respected and in demand as a source of information,<br />
policy, and action.<br />
atlanticcouncil.org
48 ATLANTIC COUNCIL 2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
ADRIENNE ARSHT LATIN AMERICA CENTER 49<br />
[RIGHT]<br />
Colombian President Juan Manuel Santos jokes<br />
with US Commerce Secretary Penny Pritzker<br />
ahead of the private, off-the-record dinner in<br />
the president’s honor following his meeting<br />
with US President Barack Obama.<br />
CUBA POLICY: IMPACT OVER TIME<br />
The Arsht Latin America Center’s bipartisan national poll of American views on<br />
US-Cuba policy laid the groundwork for the United States’ historic policy shift<br />
Joseph Biden joining to salute President Santos<br />
and Colombia’s trajectory toward peace<br />
(see page 62).<br />
Just a few weeks earlier, and coinciding with<br />
Chinese President Xi Jinping’s first state visit to<br />
Washington, a new Arsht Center report, China’s<br />
Evolving Role in Latin America: Can it Be a Win-<br />
Win? outlined five recommendations to help<br />
both China and Latin America usher in a mutually<br />
beneficial post-commodity-boom relationship. It<br />
called for a ratcheting up of strategic planning<br />
and multilateral support so that the relationship—<br />
and the 2,000 percent increase in trade over the<br />
past fifteen years—would be a win-win for all<br />
parties, including the United States. That report<br />
led to the start of the Center’s two-year China-<br />
Latin America initiative.<br />
Recognizing the importance of under-analyzed<br />
energy security issues in Latin America, the<br />
Center stepped in to shape policy on a critical<br />
issue for US and regional prosperity. Uncertain<br />
Energy: The Caribbean’s Gamble with Venezuela<br />
urged an examination of energy alternatives<br />
for Central America and the Caribbean and<br />
triggered high-level discussions. The report’s<br />
recommendations landed the Center on the<br />
leading edge of Caribbean energy policy and<br />
in response, Vice President Biden invited the<br />
Center to partner in hosting the Caribbean<br />
Energy Security Summit in Washington, DC, in<br />
January 2015.<br />
Locked in an over fifty-year-old failed policy<br />
of isolation, US-Cuban relations had posed an<br />
intransigent challenge. However, ten months<br />
before President Obama’s historic executive<br />
order on US-Cuban relations, the Arsht Center<br />
ran the first-ever comprehensive bipartisan<br />
national poll on American public opinion of<br />
US-Cuba policy, demonstrating a new national<br />
disposition toward the Caribbean nation and<br />
marking an opportunity for change. Days before<br />
the opening of the US Embassy in Havana in<br />
August 2015, the Center provided a ten-point<br />
roadmap for Cuba’s reintegration into the global<br />
economy. With presidential races heating up, a<br />
second poll in the US heartland found majority<br />
support in both parties for opening relations<br />
with Cuba and repealing travel restrictions (see<br />
opposite page).<br />
Despite its current economic and political<br />
challenges, the Center remains bullish on Brazil’s<br />
long-term prospects. But it’s a relationship<br />
historically placed on the backburner. That’s<br />
why the Arsht Center immediately jumped into<br />
action when the Brazilian president’s official<br />
visit to the United States was announced.<br />
Building on two years of work on Brazil, the<br />
Center led an effort prior to the June 2015<br />
visit to uncover specific ways to strengthen<br />
the bilateral relationship. US-Brazil Relations: A<br />
New Beginning? How to Strengthen the Bilateral<br />
Agenda presented concrete proposals that the<br />
United States and Brazil can take to advance<br />
cooperation in innovation, goods and services<br />
trade, investment, and education.<br />
Why did a new, nonpartisan Latin America<br />
Center reach out to grab what was then the third<br />
rail of foreign policy in the United States?<br />
Because after five decades, the policy of<br />
embargo and isolation had failed and maintaining<br />
the policy constricted the scope of US relations<br />
with the broader continent.<br />
Meanwhile, sentiment toward Cuba among US<br />
citizens appeared to be changing. Seeing a<br />
gap in understanding of this change, the Arsht<br />
Latin America Center commissioned a national<br />
survey conducted by pollsters—Glen Bolger, a<br />
Republican; and Paul Maslin, a Democrat.<br />
“The Atlantic Council has been at the<br />
forefront of our reality… Your work has<br />
helped reset the conversation in the<br />
hemisphere and across the Atlantic.”<br />
– JUAN MANUEL SANTOS, PRESIDENT OF COLOMBIA<br />
Their survey of more than two thousand people<br />
nationwide found that 56 percent favored more<br />
direct US engagement with Cuba or even a<br />
normalization of relations. It also found strong<br />
bipartisan support for a number of executive<br />
actions that President Obama could take that<br />
would begin to normalize relations. Over three<br />
thousand print and broadcast outlets carried<br />
the results. Less than a year later, with the poll<br />
showing that political cover existed, President<br />
Obama undertook many of the actions indicated<br />
in the poll.<br />
As US relations with Cuba began to open up, the<br />
Center turned to the island nation’s anticipated<br />
role in the global economic community;<br />
Cuba’s Economic Reintegration: Begin with the<br />
International Financial Institutions became the<br />
first major policy publication, since the change<br />
in relations, that pushed for reengagement<br />
between Cuba and institutions, such as the<br />
World Bank, the International Monetary Fund,<br />
and the Inter-American Development Bank.<br />
But more polling was still needed. This time in<br />
four of America’s heartland states—Tennessee,<br />
Ohio, Indiana, and Iowa. With important<br />
congressional delegations or key political arenas,<br />
these states were critical for advancing the US-<br />
Cuban rapprochement. The result: bipartisan<br />
support for an even wider Cuba opening. The<br />
support in these states—important because of<br />
senior congressional delegations or weight in<br />
presidential politics—constitutes a major victory<br />
for the president’s executive actions over the<br />
past year.<br />
[ABOVE]<br />
“Air Force One will depart Andrews Air Force<br />
Base en route to Havana, Cuba. No National<br />
Security Advisor has ever said that before. No<br />
US president has traveled to Cuba since Calvin<br />
Coolidge came on a battleship 88 years ago,”<br />
said National Security Advisor Susan Rice at<br />
the Atlantic Council just days before President<br />
Barack Obama’s trip to Cuba.<br />
atlanticcouncil.org
50 ATLANTIC COUNCIL 2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
SOUTH ASIA CENTER 51<br />
ADVERSARIES AND<br />
OPPORTUNITIES<br />
From Iran to India, South<br />
Asia’s stability is a crucial<br />
piece of global security<br />
and prosperity<br />
South Asia contains one fifth of the global<br />
population and nearly half of the world’s poor; 40<br />
percent of South Asians live on less than $1.25 a day.<br />
SOUTH ASIA CENTER Policymakers struggle to create the infrastructure<br />
and jobs needed to meet the rising expectations<br />
of a growing population of young people and to<br />
prevent the rise of extremist ideology spurred by widespread unemployment and poverty.<br />
Leaders are faced with the challenge of cultivating the region’s vast economic potential<br />
while also addressing severe food and water insecurity, global nuclear tensions, and the<br />
impact of a rising China.<br />
The South Asia Center, led by Bharath Gopalaswamy, navigates these currents with a<br />
vision to bridge divides and tap the region’s full potential. Committed to working with US,<br />
European, and regional leaders, the Center builds networks for actionable policy rooted in<br />
facts on the ground.<br />
India’s Prime Minister Narendra Modi performs yoga with others to mark the International Day of<br />
Yoga, in New Delhi, India. Modi led tens of thousands of people in the yoga session in the center of<br />
the capital to showcase the country’s signature cultural export. (Photo by REUTERS/Adnan Abid.)<br />
atlanticcouncil.org
52 ATLANTIC COUNCIL 2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
SOUTH ASIA CENTER 53<br />
[LEFT]<br />
At an event co-hosted by the Atlantic Council<br />
and the United States Institute of Peace<br />
in March 2015, President Ghani offers an<br />
optimistic outlook of Afghanistan’s future,<br />
the prospects of peace with the Taliban, and<br />
improved regional connectivity.<br />
The Task Force organized conversations<br />
with some of the key actors surrounding the<br />
negotiations, including US Secretary of Energy<br />
Ernest Moniz, Iranian Foreign Minister Javad<br />
Zarif, former National Security Advisor Brent<br />
Scowcroft, Permanent Representative of Iran<br />
to the United Nations Gholamali Khoshroo,<br />
and Acting Under Secretary for Terrorism and<br />
Financial Intelligence Adam Szubin.<br />
Now that the agreement is in effect, the Task<br />
Force is building on its momentum as the<br />
Future of Iran Initiative. The Initiative explores<br />
Iran’s complex political dynamics, including its<br />
economic potential, record on human rights,<br />
and opportunities for bilateral people-topeople<br />
engagement.<br />
Atlantic Council Chairman Jon Huntsman and<br />
President and CEO Frederick Kempe also took<br />
the opportunity to meet privately with Prime<br />
Minister Narendra Modi, along with other senior<br />
Indian business executives and officials, to<br />
consider ways to strengthen collaboration across<br />
the Indo-Pacific.<br />
In November 2015, the Center returned to India<br />
to host the Megacities Security Conference<br />
in Mumbai. Opening just a week after the<br />
Paris terrorist attacks, representatives from<br />
seven countries—including the United States,<br />
Bangladesh, Singapore, Kenya, and Mexico—<br />
tackled how large cities can most effectively<br />
prepare and respond to natural and manmade<br />
disasters.<br />
The Afghanistan Rising Initiative’s October<br />
2015 issue brief, “Afghan and US Security,”<br />
emphasized the need for US forces to remain in<br />
Afghanistan, both for the nation’s security and<br />
to preserve the next American administration’s<br />
operational flexibility. Senators John McCain and<br />
Jack Reed and more than twenty former senior<br />
officials, including former cabinet secretaries<br />
Madeleine Albright and Chuck Hagel, co-signed<br />
the report, which was released days before<br />
President Obama agreed to one of its key<br />
recommendations—the retention of 10,000 US<br />
troops in Afghanistan through the end of 2016.<br />
Few events of the past year were more<br />
dramatic than the Iran nuclear negotiations<br />
and subsequent agreement. Well before the<br />
agreement was announced, the South Asia<br />
Center’s Iran Task Force, chaired by Ambassador<br />
Stuart Eizenstat and directed by Atlantic Council<br />
Senior Fellow Barbara Slavin, began developing<br />
a comprehensive understanding of a postsanctions<br />
world.<br />
“ What we are determined to do is not<br />
become victims of history, not to repeat<br />
history but to overcome it, and in the<br />
process make new history.”<br />
– ASHRAF GHANI, PRESIDENT OF AFGHANISTAN<br />
In 2015 the South Asia Center also seized the<br />
opportunity for fresh thinking on the US-India<br />
bilateral partnership following President Obama’s<br />
landmark visit to New Delhi for India’s Republic<br />
Day celebrations.<br />
Working with the US Embassy in India,<br />
Vivekananda International Foundation, and the<br />
Confederation of Indian Industry, the Center<br />
convened the Council’s first major conference in<br />
Asia in March 2015—“India-US 2015: Partnering<br />
for Peace and Prosperity.” The event activated a<br />
renewed conversation among leading American<br />
and Indian policymakers on paths for greater<br />
engagement between the two countries.<br />
India’s Foreign Secretary Dr. S. Jaishankar, in<br />
his first public remarks as foreign secretary,<br />
commented that the United States should<br />
encourage India to transform from a balancing<br />
power to a regional leader as a way of promoting<br />
the region’s wider stability and economic<br />
dynamism.<br />
In Afghanistan, the South Asia Center<br />
recognized the inauguration of Afghanistan’s<br />
unity government under President Ashraf<br />
Ghani and Chief Executive Abdullah Abdullah<br />
as a historic opportunity to break with decades<br />
of war and establish a new positive trajectory.<br />
At the same time, NATO’s pending drawdown<br />
of forces threatened to diminish the focus of<br />
Kabul’s international partners and undermine<br />
efforts to secure the country’s future.<br />
Supported by former US Ambassador to<br />
Afghanistan Zalmay Khalilzad, the Atlantic<br />
Council launched the Afghanistan Rising<br />
Initiative to sustain international support for<br />
the country’s long-term stability, security, and<br />
prosperity. Led by James Cunningham, former<br />
US ambassador to Afghanistan, as the Khalilzad<br />
Chair, the Initiative has organized meetings<br />
with President Ghani; Chief Executive Abdullah<br />
Abdullah; and Commander, Resolute Support<br />
Mission and United States Forces-Afghanistan,<br />
General John Campbell; among others.<br />
[ABOVE]<br />
Atlantic Council Chairman Jon Huntsman leads a discussion with<br />
US Ambassador to India Richard Verma and Indian Minister of State<br />
for Energy Piyush Goyal at an Atlantic Council conference in Delhi,<br />
in collaboration with the US Embassy in India, the Vivekananda<br />
Foundation, and the Confederation of Indian Industry.<br />
atlanticcouncil.org
54<br />
ATLANTIC COUNCIL 2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
AFRICA CENTER<br />
55<br />
THE NEXT AFRICA<br />
Dynamic partnerships<br />
for strengthening security<br />
and building economic<br />
and social momentum<br />
US interests in the African continent once<br />
were mired in Cold War competition<br />
or relegated to disaster relief and<br />
AFRICA CENTER<br />
humanitarian concerns over poverty, war,<br />
and natural disasters, rather than strategic<br />
imperative. In recent years, however,<br />
even long-duration violent conflicts and<br />
persistent climate concerns no longer overshadow the vitality of some African states<br />
and the deep strategic claims on security and economic investment.<br />
Indeed, although daunting security, humanitarian, and developmental challenges<br />
remain, the real story out of Africa today is one of economic dynamism—driven not<br />
only by demand for the continent’s abundant natural resources, but also positive<br />
demographic trends, innovative technologies, political reforms, and improvements<br />
in governance.<br />
A giraffe walks through the Nairobi National Park, the world’s only game reserve found<br />
within a major city, at less than four miles south of central Nairobi, Kenya’s capital city.<br />
(Photo by GETTYIMAGES/WLDavies.)<br />
atlanticcouncil.org
56 ATLANTIC COUNCIL 2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
AFRICA CENTER 57<br />
[OPPOSITE TOP]<br />
Gabonese President Ali Bongo Ondimba greets MNG Group of Companies<br />
Founder and Chairman Mehmet Nazif Günal during the president’s visit to the<br />
Atlantic Council’s offices.<br />
[OPPOSITE BOTTOM]<br />
“Nigeria has embarked on an irreversible path—there might be one step forward<br />
and half a step back, but the trend is clear—because Nigerian citizens and civil<br />
society are no longer prepared to settle for less,” said Nigeria’s Coordinating<br />
Minister for the Economy and Minister of Finance Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala during her<br />
public remarks at the Atlantic Council.<br />
President Obama recognized Africa’s growing<br />
economic clout when he welcomed leaders from<br />
across the continent to Washington in August<br />
2014 for the historic US-Africa Leaders Summit—<br />
the largest event any US president has hosted<br />
for African heads of state and government.<br />
It was the Atlantic Council that became the venue<br />
of choice for African leaders: The presidents of<br />
Ghana, Tunisia, Burkina Faso, and Niger, as well<br />
as the president of the Commission of Economic<br />
Community of West African States chose the<br />
Council as their platform for addressing the<br />
Washington policy community.<br />
Anticipating policy shifts to be in position when<br />
presidents and prime ministers need a forum<br />
is a deliberate Atlantic Council strength, and<br />
creating such a framework of engagement was<br />
“ [Our] vision has not dimmed or<br />
diminished… In fact, geopolitical<br />
partnerships are stronger than ever,<br />
and business and prosperity are<br />
exhibiting a growth that would have<br />
astonished our predecessors.”<br />
– ALI BONGO ONDIMBA, PRESIDENT OF GABON<br />
the intention of Atlantic Council board director<br />
Michael Ansari when he partnered with the<br />
Atlantic Council to launch the Africa Center in<br />
September 2009. At the time, Washington’s<br />
limited strategic engagement with privateand<br />
public-sector leaders on issues central to<br />
Africa’s future, belied the continent’s undeniable<br />
importance and risked leaving American<br />
interests behind.<br />
The Center has since become a principle<br />
conduit for the continent, addressing Africa’s<br />
complex security challenges—especially the<br />
growing specter of Islamist extremism as<br />
well as the ongoing problem of fragile states.<br />
Additionally, and perhaps more importantly, it<br />
collaborates with the public and private sectors<br />
to forge opportunities associated with Africa’s<br />
economic growth.<br />
The Africa Center’s analysis continues to<br />
capture the lingering crises of the “old Africa”<br />
while maintaining a constant eye on developing<br />
trends that are likely to shape The Next Africa—<br />
the title of Africa Center Senior Fellow Aubrey<br />
Hruby’s provocative new book on Africa’s<br />
economic rise.<br />
In December 2015, the Africa Center captured<br />
the transformative power of African trade when<br />
it launched Diversifying African Trade: The Road<br />
to Progress, also by Hruby. This forward-looking<br />
approach steered the Africa Center’s work and<br />
was a crucial resource for the media, as well<br />
as political and business communities, as they<br />
navigated the economic culture of this highly<br />
complex region.<br />
Africa Center Director J. Peter Pham was one of<br />
the first experts in Washington to fully recognize<br />
the danger of the Boko Haram threat. Together<br />
with Senior Fellow Ricardo René Larémont,<br />
Pham testified at the first-ever US congressional<br />
hearing on the group in 2011, nearly three years<br />
before the infamous abduction of more than<br />
two hundred schoolgirls in Chibok, Nigeria.<br />
In his appearances before Congressional<br />
committees in 2015, Pham urged lawmakers<br />
not to underestimate the threat of terrorism in<br />
Africa, nor to curtail engagement with African<br />
partners. Instead, he advised them on the rising<br />
demand for intelligence about and security<br />
against threats originating in the continent.<br />
The Africa Center was also among the first in<br />
Washington to forecast Morocco’s economic<br />
potential, highlighting the country’s willingness<br />
to implement reforms in pursuit of investment<br />
and noting that Morocco has become a gateway<br />
for foreign investment into sub-Saharan African<br />
states. Center experts have sought to draw the<br />
attention of policymakers to broader security<br />
and development trends that will require<br />
greater US and European attention across the<br />
continent.<br />
The analytical series Nigeria in Focus became<br />
a barometer of events in Africa’s most<br />
populous country and largest economy. As<br />
Nigeria struggled to conduct hotly contested<br />
elections against a destabilizing backdrop<br />
of Boko Haram attacks and plummeting oil<br />
prices, the Africa Center brought key Nigerian<br />
perspectives to Washington.<br />
The Center hosted Nigeria’s military and<br />
intelligence chiefs, its coordinating minister<br />
for the economy and minister of finance, its<br />
agriculture minister (who went on to win the<br />
presidency of the African Development Bank),<br />
and the country’s newly-elected President<br />
Muhammadu Buhari, during his first visit to the<br />
United States following his historic election.<br />
atlanticcouncil.org
58<br />
ATLANTIC COUNCIL 2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
GLOBAL CONVENINGS<br />
59<br />
GLOBAL<br />
CONVENINGS<br />
Distinguished Leadership Awards<br />
60<br />
Global Citizen Awards<br />
62<br />
Istanbul Energy & Economic Summit<br />
64<br />
Wrocław Global Forum<br />
66<br />
atlanticcouncil.org
60 ATLANTIC COUNCIL 2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
DISTINGUISHED SECTION LEADERSHIP TITLE/DESCRIPTION AWARDS<br />
61<br />
[CENTER]<br />
Afghanistan President Ashraf Ghani prepares to receive<br />
his 2015 Distinguished International Leadership Award<br />
from his introducer, former Secretary of State Madeleine<br />
Albright. President Ghani set the tone for the 2015 Global<br />
Citizen Awards, saying “Leadership is about sacrifice.<br />
Leadership is not about privilege.”<br />
DISTINGUISHED<br />
LEADERSHIP AWARDS<br />
The Distinguished Leadership Awards, among Washington’s premier celebrations of global affairs<br />
leadership, convenes some eight hundred government and business decision-makers from fifty<br />
countries to honor individuals who personify the sort of strong purpose, personal commitment, and<br />
character that today’s historic times require. Awardees are chosen to represent the pillars of the<br />
transatlantic relationship—political, military, business, and artistic leadership.<br />
In April 2015, we honored:<br />
Ashraf Ghani, Distinguished International Leadership Award<br />
Philip M. Breedlove, Distinguished Military Leadership Award<br />
Marillyn A. Hewson, Distinguished Business Leadership Award<br />
Toby Keith, Distinguished Artistic Leadership Award<br />
[ABOVE]<br />
Some thirty co-chairs of the 2015 Distinguished Leadership Awards dinner gather on stage to lead the audience in a<br />
surprise celebration of Gen. Brent Scowcroft’s ninetieth birthday. Pictured from left are Alexander Mirtchev, Melanie<br />
Chen, Gen. Brent Scowcroft, Marillyn Hewson, Francis Bouchard, James L. Jones, Robert Abernethy, and Adrienne Arsht.<br />
[FROM TOP]<br />
Marillyn Hewson and Gov. Jon Huntsman applaud the opening of the Distinguished Leadership Awards;<br />
counterclockwise, CNN anchor Wolf Blitzer and Atlantic Council Executive Vice Chair Adrienne Arsht chat during the<br />
dinner break; General Philip Breedlove accepts his award (and red solo cup) from his Georgia Tech fraternity brother,<br />
Admiral James Winnefeld; pictured at bottom, UAE Ambassador to the United States Yousef Al Otaiba (left) talks with<br />
Atlantic Council Executive Vice Chair Stephen J. Hadley; pictured right, Toby Keith caps the evening with a performance<br />
of “American Soldier” in honor of US service men and women.<br />
atlanticcouncil.org
62 ATLANTIC COUNCIL 2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
SECTION GLOBAL TITLE/DESCRIPTION<br />
CITIZEN AWARDS<br />
63<br />
[RIGHT]<br />
Henry Kissinger accepts the Distinguished Service<br />
Award for his lifetime of accomplishment as a<br />
strategist, diplomat, and author. In speaking of<br />
today’s global challenges, he remarked, “What<br />
sacrifices are we willing to make? Because great<br />
things cannot be achieved without some sacrifice<br />
of the present for the needs of the future.”<br />
GLOBAL CITIZEN AWARDS<br />
The Global Citizen Awards celebrate the rare individuals who contribute significantly to improving<br />
the state of the world.<br />
The 2015 awardees were:<br />
Juan Manuel Santos, President of Colombia; introduced by Joseph Biden, US Vice President<br />
Mario Draghi, President of the European Central Bank; introduced by Christine Lagarde, Managing<br />
Director of the IMF<br />
Yu Long, Artistic Director of the China Philharmonic; introduced by Victor Chu, Chairman of First<br />
Eastern Investment Group<br />
Henry Kissinger, former US secretary of state and the Atlanitic Council’s longest-serving board<br />
member, also recieved the Council’s Distinguished Service Award; introduced by Gen. Brent Scowcroft.<br />
[ABOVE]<br />
Vice President of the United States Joseph Biden presents a Global Citizen Award to Colombian President Juan Manual<br />
Santos. Vice President Biden honored President Santos as “a man of service and a man of peace… He’s a man of great<br />
vision for his country and the future of Colombia’s relationship with the United States.”<br />
[FROM TOP LEFT]<br />
Frederick Kempe (right) shows President Santos that he is wearing the cufflinks the president gave to him during<br />
his first visit to the Atlantic Council; counterclockwise, Victor Chu (left) laughs with Coca-Cola Chairman and CEO<br />
Muhtar Kent (center) and Chubb Limited CEO Evan Greenberg; to the right, Henry Kissinger and Brent Scowcroft pose<br />
backstage; bottom, Adrienne Arhst (left) and Christine Lagarde laugh with Mario Draghi; bottom right, child pianist<br />
Johnson Li performs in honor of Yu Long at the conclusion of awards ceremony; middle right, Yu Long (left) meets Mario<br />
Draghi (right), with Victor Chu (center left) and Mehmet Günal in the background.<br />
atlanticcouncil.org
64 ATLANTIC COUNCIL 2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
ISTANBUL ENERGY SECTION & TITLE/DESCRIPTION<br />
ECONOMIC SUMMIT 65<br />
[RIGHT]<br />
Millennium Leadership Fellow Naadiya Moosajee asks a<br />
question at a Summit session. A 2014 Forbes “Top Twenty<br />
Young Power Women in Africa,” Moosajee is co-founder<br />
of WomEng (Women in Engineering), which cultivates<br />
female engineers in Africa.<br />
ISTANBUL ENERGY<br />
& ECONOMIC SUMMIT<br />
The seventh annual Atlantic Council Energy<br />
& Economic Summit convened an influential<br />
community of more than five hundred corporate,<br />
government, and civil society leaders from forty<br />
countries in Istanbul from November 18-20,<br />
2015. This year’s special guests included Turkish<br />
President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, Croatian<br />
President Kolinda Grabar-Kitarović, and Albanian<br />
Prime Minister Edi Rama.<br />
The summit’s traditional focus on energy and<br />
economics was expanded to include security,<br />
specifically the global response to terrorism, to<br />
take stock of the challenges underscored by the<br />
terrorist attacks in Paris and Ankara.<br />
In addition to more than twenty formal sessions,<br />
luncheons, and exclusive dinners, almost one<br />
hundred bilateral meetings were conducted on<br />
the sidelines of the Summit. Around 120 journalists<br />
attended the Summit, which was featured in more<br />
than 2,100 news reports.<br />
[ABOVE]<br />
Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan delivers the keynote address at the seventh annual Atlantic<br />
Council Energy & Economic Summit on November 19, 2015. Describing Syrian President Bashar al-<br />
Assad’s regime as the root cause of terrorism and the migrant crisis facing Europe, Erdoğan said:<br />
“Those who are standing behind [Assad] are at least as guilty as he is.”<br />
[FROM TOP LEFT]<br />
Fatih Birol (left), Miguel Arias Cañete, Frederick Kempe, Jon Huntsman, and Carlos<br />
Pascual lead the Summit’s annual ministerial discussion; counterclockwise, Zalmay<br />
Khalilzad, (left), Michael Hayden, James L. Jones, Jon Huntsman, Ana Palacio, and<br />
Daud Saba discuss new strategies for responding to terrorism; bottom left, Atlantic<br />
Council board director Esther Brimmer poses a question during a plenary session;<br />
bottom right, a consortium of energy companies—including Türkiye Petrolleri, Bayat<br />
Energy, and Çalik Enerji—conclude an agreement with the Afghanistan Ministry<br />
of Mines and Petroleum, represented by Minister Daud Saba, to develop some of<br />
Afghanistan’s natural gas reserves; middle right, Jon Huntsman leads Antony Blinken,<br />
US deputy secretary of state, to deliver the Summit’s closing keynote address.<br />
atlanticcouncil.org
66 ATLANTIC COUNCIL 2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
WROCŁAW GLOBAL SECTION FORUM & TITLE/DESCRIPTION<br />
FREEDOM AWARDS<br />
67<br />
WROCŁAW GLOBAL FORUM<br />
& FREEDOM AWARDS<br />
The sixth Annual Wrocław Global Forum opened on June 12, 2015, to headlines dominated by global<br />
and regional challenges: Russia’s support of Ukrainian separatists, ISIS’s extremism in the Middle East,<br />
and the erosion of faith in the Europe and transatlantic projects.<br />
Some four hundred government, corporate, and civil society leaders each year come to the Forum<br />
for discussions on core transatlantic values and priorities framed within Central Europe’s growing<br />
importance as a global partner.<br />
The Forum is also home to the Atlantic Council’s Freedom Awards, a celebration of extraordinary<br />
individuals and organizations committed to the advancement of democracy.<br />
This year’s Freedom Awards honored:<br />
Carl Bildt, former prime minister and foreign minister of Sweden, presented by Radosław Sikorski,<br />
then Marshal of the Polish Sejm<br />
Donetsk National University, represented by Roman Grynyuk—rector of the university—and law<br />
student Iryna Nahorniak, presented by US Senator Jeanne Shaheen<br />
Agnieszka Holland, Polish film maker, presented by Sławomir Sierakowski, leader of Krytyka<br />
Polityczna<br />
Boris Nemtsov, posthumous award presented by Garry Kasparov and accepted by Nemtsov’s<br />
daughter, Zhanna Nemtsova<br />
Nadiya Savchenko, Ukrainian military pilot and prisoner of war—represented by her sister Vera<br />
Savchenko—also introduced by US Senator Jeanne Shaheen<br />
[ABOVE]<br />
Wrocław Mayor Rafał Dutkiewicz welcomes the participants to the 2015 Wrocław Global Forum. The Atlantic Council is<br />
represented by President and CEO Frederick Kempe, Brent Scowcroft Center Chairman James L. Jones, and Board of<br />
Directors Executive Vice Chair Stephen J. Hadley.<br />
[FROM TOP LEFT]<br />
Former Swedish Prime Minister Carl Bildt accepts his Freedom Award; counterclockwise, US Senator Jeanne Shaheen<br />
and former National Security Advisor Stephen J. Hadley discuss America’s role in Europe; bottom left, Sławomir<br />
Sierakowski, leader of Krytyka Polityczna, presents a Freedom Award to film-maker Agnieszka Holland; bottom right,<br />
Roman Grynyuk (center) and law student Iryna Nahorniak stand with Ver Savchenko after, respectively, receiving<br />
Freedom Awards on behalf of Donetsk National University and Nadiya Savchenko, a Ukrainian military pilot imprisoned<br />
in Russia; right center, Garry Kasparov presents Boris Nemtsov’s posthumous Freedom Award to Nemtsov’s daughter,<br />
Zhanna Nemtsova; top right, Kulczyk Holding board member Jarosław Sroka and Atlantic Council board director Maciej<br />
Witucki walk to the Wrocław Global Forum welcome reception.<br />
atlanticcouncil.org
68<br />
ATLANTIC COUNCIL 2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
COMMUNITY OF INFLUENCE<br />
69<br />
COMMUNITY<br />
OF INFLUENCE<br />
Board of Directors<br />
70<br />
International Advisory Board<br />
71<br />
Honor Roll of Contributors<br />
72<br />
Financial Summary<br />
74<br />
By the Numbers & Word on the Street<br />
76<br />
atlanticcouncil.org
70 ATLANTIC COUNCIL 2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
SECTION COMMUNITY TITLE/DESCRIPTION<br />
OF INFLUENCE 71<br />
BOARD OF<br />
DIRECTORS<br />
List as of April 15, 2016<br />
*Executive Committee Members<br />
INTERNATIONAL<br />
ADVISORY BOARD<br />
List as of April 19, 2016<br />
CHAIRMAN<br />
Jon M. Huntsman, Jr.*<br />
CHAIRMAN, EMERITUS,<br />
INTERNATIONAL<br />
ADVISORY BOARD<br />
Brent Scowcroft<br />
PRESIDENT AND CEO<br />
Frederick Kempe*<br />
EXECUTIVE VICE CHAIRS<br />
Adrienne Arsht*<br />
Stephen J. Hadley*<br />
VICE CHAIRS<br />
Robert J. Abernethy*<br />
Richard Edelman*<br />
C. Boyden Gray*<br />
George Lund*<br />
Virginia A. Mulberger*<br />
W. DeVier Pierson*<br />
John Studzinski*<br />
TREASURER<br />
Brian C. McK. Henderson*<br />
SECRETARY<br />
Walter B. Slocombe*<br />
DIRECTORS<br />
Stéphane Abrial<br />
Odeh Aburdene<br />
Peter Ackerman<br />
Timothy D. Adams<br />
Bertrand-Marc Allen<br />
John Allen<br />
Michael Andersson<br />
Michael Ansari<br />
Richard L. Armitage<br />
David D. Aufhauser<br />
Elizabeth F. Bagley<br />
Peter Bass<br />
Rafic Bizri*<br />
Dennis Blair<br />
Thomas L. Blair*<br />
Myron Brilliant<br />
Esther Brimmer<br />
R. Nicholas Burns*<br />
William J. Burns<br />
Richard R. Burt*<br />
Michael Calvey<br />
James E. Cartwright<br />
John E. Chapoton<br />
Ahmed Charai<br />
Sandra Charles<br />
Melanie Chen<br />
George Chopivsky<br />
Wesley K. Clark<br />
David W. Craig<br />
Ralph D. Crosby, Jr.*<br />
Nelson Cunningham<br />
Ivo H. Daalder<br />
Paula J. Dobriansky*<br />
Christopher J. Dodd<br />
Conrado Dornier<br />
Thomas J. Egan, Jr.<br />
Stuart E. Eizenstat*<br />
Thomas R. Eldridge<br />
Julie Finley<br />
Lawrence P. Fisher, II<br />
Alan H. Fleischmann<br />
Ronald M. Freeman*<br />
Laurie Fulton<br />
Courtney Geduldig<br />
Robert S. Gelbard*<br />
Thomas Glocer<br />
Sherri W. Goodman*<br />
Mikael Hagström<br />
Ian Hague<br />
Amir Handjani<br />
John D. Harris, II<br />
Frank Haun<br />
Michael V. Hayden<br />
Annette Heuser<br />
Karl Hopkins*<br />
Robert Hormats<br />
Miroslav Hornak<br />
Mary L. Howell*<br />
Wolfgang Ischinger<br />
Reuben Jeffery, III<br />
James L. Jones, Jr.*<br />
George A. Joulwan<br />
Lawrence S. Kanarek<br />
Stephen R. Kappes<br />
Maria Pica Karp<br />
Sean Kevelighan<br />
Zalmay M. Khalilzad<br />
Robert M. Kimmitt<br />
Henry A. Kissinger<br />
Franklin D. Kramer<br />
Philip Lader<br />
Richard L. Lawson*<br />
Jan M. Lodal*<br />
Jane Holl Lute<br />
William J. Lynn<br />
Izzat Majeed<br />
Wendy W. Makins<br />
Mian M. Mansha<br />
Gerardo Mato<br />
William E. Mayer<br />
Allan McArtor<br />
Eric D.K. Melby<br />
Franklin C. Miller<br />
James N. Miller<br />
Judith A. Miller*<br />
Alexander V. Mirtchev*<br />
Karl Moor<br />
Michael Morell<br />
Georgette Mosbacher<br />
Steve C. Nicandros<br />
Thomas R. Nides<br />
Franco Nuschese<br />
Joseph S. Nye<br />
Hilda Ochoa-Brillembourg<br />
Sean O’Keefe<br />
Ahmet Oren<br />
Ana Palacio*<br />
Carlos Pascual<br />
Alan Pellegrini<br />
David Petraeus<br />
Thomas R. Pickering<br />
Daniel B. Poneman<br />
Daniel M. Price<br />
Arnold L. Punaro<br />
Robert Rangel<br />
Thomas J. Ridge<br />
Charles O. Rossotti<br />
Robert Rowland<br />
Harry Sachinis<br />
John P. Schmitz<br />
Brent Scowcroft<br />
Rajiv Shah<br />
Alan J. Spence<br />
James Stavridis<br />
Richard J.A. Steele<br />
Paula Stern*<br />
Robert J. Stevens<br />
John S. Tanner<br />
Ellen O. Tauscher*<br />
Karen Tramontano<br />
Clyde C. Tuggle<br />
Paul Twomey<br />
Melanne Verveer<br />
Enzo Viscusi<br />
Charles F. Wald<br />
Jay Walker<br />
Michael F. Walsh<br />
Mark R. Warner<br />
Maciej Witucki<br />
Neal S. Wolin<br />
Mary C. Yates<br />
Dov S. Zakheim<br />
HONORARY DIRECTORS<br />
David C. Acheson<br />
Madeleine K. Albright<br />
James A. Baker, III<br />
Harold Brown<br />
Frank C. Carlucci, III<br />
Robert M. Gates<br />
Michael G. Mullen<br />
Leon E. Panetta<br />
William J. Perry<br />
Colin L. Powell<br />
Condoleezza Rice<br />
Edward L. Rowny<br />
George P. Shultz<br />
John W. Warner<br />
William H. Webster<br />
LEADERSHIP<br />
Lt. Gen. Brent Scowcroft, USAF (Ret.)<br />
Chairman<br />
International Advisory Board<br />
Governor Jon M. Huntsman, Jr.<br />
Chairman<br />
Atlantic Council<br />
Mr. Frederick Kempe<br />
President and CEO<br />
Atlantic Council<br />
Mr. Philippe Amon<br />
Chairman and CEO<br />
SICPA Holding SA<br />
Mr. Tewodros Ashenafi<br />
Founder, Chairman and CEO<br />
Southwest Energy<br />
H.E. Shaukat Aziz<br />
Former Prime Minister of Pakistan<br />
President José María Aznar<br />
Former Prime Minister of Spain<br />
H.E. Carl Bildt<br />
Former Prime Minister and Minister<br />
for Foreign Affairs of Sweden<br />
Dr. Zbigniew Brzezinski<br />
Former National Security Advisor<br />
to US President Jimmy Carter<br />
Mr. Håkan Buskhe<br />
President and CEO<br />
SAAB AB<br />
Mr. Victor L.L. Chu<br />
Chairman and CEO<br />
First Eastern Investment Group<br />
Mr. Claudio Descalzi<br />
CEO<br />
Eni<br />
Mr. Markus Dohle<br />
CEO<br />
Penguin Random House<br />
Mr. Richard Edelman<br />
President and CEO<br />
Edelman<br />
Dr. Thomas Enders<br />
CEO<br />
Airbus Group<br />
Mr. Thomas A. Fanning<br />
Chairman, President, and CEO<br />
Southern Company<br />
Ms. Orit Gadiesh<br />
Chairman of the Board<br />
Bain & Company Inc.<br />
Dr. Jim Goodnight<br />
CEO<br />
SAS<br />
Mr. Mehmet N. Günal<br />
Founder, Chairman of the Board,<br />
and President<br />
MNG Holding A.S.<br />
The Hon. Charles T. Hagel<br />
Former US Secretary of Defense<br />
Mr. Bahaa R. Hariri<br />
Ms. Marillyn A. Hewson<br />
Chairman, President and CEO<br />
Lockheed Martin Corporation<br />
Mr. Muhtar Kent<br />
Chairman and CEO<br />
The Coca-Cola Company<br />
Dr. Jan Kulczyk<br />
Chairman of the Supervisory Board<br />
Kulczyk Holding SA<br />
President Aleksander Kwaśniewski<br />
Former President of Poland<br />
H.E. Jean-David Levitte<br />
Senior Diplomatic Adviser and Sherpa to<br />
Former French President Nicolas Sarkozy<br />
Mr. Alexey A. Mordashov<br />
Chairman and CEO<br />
Severstal<br />
Mr. Robert E. Moritz<br />
Chairman and Senior Partner<br />
PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP<br />
Mr. Rupert Murdoch<br />
Executive Chairman<br />
21st Century Fox<br />
Mr. Paul Polman<br />
CEO<br />
Unilever<br />
The Rt. Hon. Lord Robertson of Port<br />
Ellen<br />
Former Secretary General<br />
of NATO<br />
Mr. Stephen A. Schwarzman<br />
Chairman, CEO, and Co-Founder<br />
The Blackstone Group<br />
Mr. Martin Senn<br />
CEO<br />
Zurich Insurance Group Ltd.<br />
Mr. James C. Smith<br />
President and CEO<br />
Thomson Reuters<br />
Sir Martin Sorrell<br />
Group Chief Executive<br />
WPP Group PLC<br />
Mr. Rob Speyer<br />
President and Co-CEO<br />
Tishman Speyer<br />
Dr. Lawrence Summers<br />
Former Director<br />
National Economic Council<br />
Mr. Jacob Wallenberg<br />
Chairman<br />
Investor AB<br />
Mr. John S. Watson<br />
Chairman and CEO<br />
Chevron Corporation<br />
Mr. John D. Wren<br />
President and CEO<br />
Omnicom Group<br />
Mr. Robert B. Zoellick<br />
Chairman, International Advisors<br />
Goldman Sachs<br />
atlanticcouncil.org
72 ATLANTIC COUNCIL 2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
SECTION COMMUNITY TITLE/DESCRIPTION<br />
OF INFLUENCE 73<br />
2015<br />
HONOR ROLL OF CONTRIBUTORS<br />
ǂ denotes a sponsor of the 2015 Wrocław Global Forum<br />
◊ denotes a sponsor of the 2015 Energy & Economic Summit<br />
† deceased<br />
$1,000,000+<br />
DONATIONS<br />
Adrienne Arsht<br />
Bahaa Hariri<br />
Brent Scowcroft<br />
$250,000 - $999,999<br />
DONATIONS<br />
Airbusǂ<br />
Carnegie Corporation<br />
of New York<br />
Center for the Study of<br />
Democratic Insitutions<br />
Cheniere Energy, Inc.◊<br />
Melanie Chen<br />
Chevron◊<br />
Dentons LLP◊<br />
Frontera Resourcesǂ<br />
Government of Sweden<br />
Kingdom of Bahrain<br />
Lockheed Martin<br />
Corporationǂ<br />
MacArthur Foundation<br />
MAPA Group◊<br />
OCP Foundation<br />
Qualcomm Inc.<br />
Raytheonǂ<br />
Smith Richardson<br />
Foundation<br />
System Capital<br />
Management Ltd.◊<br />
Thomson Reuters<br />
Turkish Ministry of Energy<br />
& National Resources◊<br />
Ukrainian World Congress<br />
United States<br />
Department of State<br />
Zurich Insurance Group<br />
$100,000 - $249,999<br />
DONATIONS<br />
Actagon AB<br />
Asfari Foundation<br />
Bayat Group◊<br />
Bob Woodruff Foundation<br />
Borsa Istanbul◊<br />
Chopivsky Family<br />
Foundation<br />
ExxonMobil◊<br />
Government of Norway<br />
C. Boyden Gray<br />
Zalmay M. Khalilzad<br />
Alexander V. Mirtchev<br />
MNG Group of Companies<br />
Morganti Group, Inc<br />
NATO ACT<br />
Nevsun Resources<br />
Ploughshares Fund<br />
Rockefeller Brothers<br />
Fund, Inc.<br />
SAAB<br />
Skoll Global Imperatives<br />
Southern Companyǂ<br />
Talent of Nations<br />
TECRO<br />
Tenaris<br />
TOBB◊<br />
Tupras◊<br />
Türkiye Halk Bankası A.S.◊<br />
United for Africa’s<br />
Democratic Future<br />
Victor Pinchuk Foundation<br />
$50,000 - $99,999<br />
DONATIONS<br />
21st Century Fox<br />
ACE Group Holding<br />
Peter Ackermanǂ<br />
ANA Holdings, Inc.<br />
Tewedros Ashenafi<br />
Attias Associates<br />
David Aufhauser<br />
Avista Capital Partners<br />
Azteca International<br />
Corporation<br />
Bruce Bedford<br />
BlackRock, Inc.<br />
Thomas L. Blair<br />
BP Petrolleri A.Ş.◊<br />
Calik Enerji Sanayi Ve<br />
Ticaret A.S.◊<br />
Patricia Cloherty<br />
DRS Technologies, Inc.<br />
Embassy of Latvia<br />
Engie<br />
Eni S.p.A.<br />
EU Commission<br />
European Union<br />
GE Ticaret◊<br />
Robert S. Gelbard<br />
Genel Energy◊<br />
Government of Lithuania<br />
Miroslav Hornak<br />
Inter-American<br />
Development Bank<br />
Krauss Maffei Wegmann<br />
McGraw Hill Financial<br />
Ministry of Finance of Japan<br />
Ministry of Foreign Affairs of<br />
the Republic of Cyprus<br />
Novartis International AG<br />
Open Society Foundations<br />
Ahmet Oren<br />
Pfizer<br />
PSJ, a.s.<br />
SAIC<br />
SGO Corporation Limited<br />
SICPA S.A.◊<br />
Tekfen İnşaat ve Tesisat A.Ş.◊<br />
Textron Inc.<br />
Thales USA<br />
The Blackstone Group<br />
The Coca-Cola Company<br />
ThyssenKrupp Marine<br />
Systems GmBHǂ<br />
Tishman Speyer<br />
Properties, LP<br />
Transatlantic Policy Network<br />
Türkerler İnşaat◊<br />
United States Navy<br />
US NATO<br />
Valero Energy Corporation<br />
$25,000 - $49,999<br />
DONATIONS<br />
Allianz Foundation for<br />
North America<br />
Allianz Sigorta A.S.◊<br />
Baker & McKenzie LLP<br />
Bank of America Corporation<br />
BP America<br />
Michael Calvey<br />
Caterpillar Inc.<br />
Centre for International<br />
Governance Innovation<br />
Deloitte Innovation<br />
Devon Energy Corporation<br />
Dornier Seawings AG<br />
Ekkou VPǂ◊<br />
Elbit Systems of America LLC<br />
Energy Capital Partners<br />
European Union Institute for<br />
Security Studies<br />
Facebookǂ<br />
First Eastern<br />
Investment Group<br />
Fluor Corporation<br />
Ronald Freeman<br />
Government of Finland<br />
Brian C. McK.Henderson<br />
Huntington Ingalls Industries<br />
Hunton & Williams<br />
Intel Security<br />
Endowment Fund<br />
L-3 Communications<br />
Leidos, Inc.<br />
LexisNexis Legal<br />
& Professional<br />
John Macomber<br />
Maroc Telematique<br />
Marsilli & Co. S.p.A.<br />
MBDA Incorporated<br />
McLarty Associates<br />
MetLife<br />
Ministry of Defense<br />
of Lithuania<br />
Moroccan-American<br />
Cultural Center<br />
Georgette Mosbacher<br />
Northrop Grumman<br />
Aerospace Systems<br />
Occidental Petroleum Corp.<br />
Hilda Ochoa-Brillembourg<br />
Penguin Random House<br />
Pioneer Natural Resources<br />
Promo Financial Group<br />
Public Gas Corporation◊<br />
Renaissance Strategic<br />
Advisors<br />
Rigoni Di Asiago S.r.l.<br />
Rolls-Royce of North America<br />
Charles O. Rossotti<br />
RTI International Metals, Inc.<br />
Safran USA<br />
Sam’s Club<br />
SAS Institute, Inc.<br />
Sempra Energy<br />
Shell<br />
Skoll Foundation<br />
SOCAR Turkey Enerji A.Ş.◊<br />
Software & Information<br />
Industry Association<br />
Statoil<br />
John Studzinski<br />
Swedish Ministry of Defense<br />
T.C. BASB◊<br />
Temasek<br />
The Boeing Company<br />
Thyssen Petroleum◊<br />
Trans Adriatic Pipeline AG◊<br />
United States Air Force<br />
United States Army<br />
United States Marines<br />
US Chamber of Commerce<br />
Enzo Viscusi<br />
Timothy Walsh<br />
Ziraat Bank◊<br />
$10,000 - $24,999<br />
DONATIONS<br />
Baker, Donelson, Bearman,<br />
Caldwell & Berkowitz, PC<br />
Ioana Belu<br />
Bloomberg, L.P.<br />
Ghalib Bradosti<br />
Business Intelligence Unit<br />
Center for Communications,<br />
Health and the Environmentǂ<br />
John Chapoton<br />
Dow Chemical<br />
Joseph Duffey<br />
Edelman<br />
Richard Edelman<br />
EP Energy Corporation<br />
Alan H. Fleischmann<br />
Mary L Howell<br />
HSBC<br />
Reuben Jeffery<br />
Jones Walker LLP<br />
JPMorgan Chase & Co.<br />
Kimberly-Clark Corporation<br />
Franklin D. Kramer<br />
Kreabǂ<br />
Jan M. Lodal<br />
LVK Okul Egitim<br />
Ogretim Danism<br />
Lynx Investment Advisory<br />
Judith A. Miller<br />
Virginia A. Mulberger<br />
National Intelligence Council<br />
NATO<br />
W. DeVier Pierson<br />
Arnold Punaro<br />
Rockefeller & Co.<br />
Scowcroft Group<br />
Sequoia Foundation<br />
for Achievement in<br />
Arts and Education<br />
Starr Foundation<br />
Stephen Shapiro<br />
Shearman & Sterling LLP<br />
Ellen O. Tauscher<br />
Telefonica<br />
William & Flora<br />
Hewlett Foundation<br />
Jean-Louis Wolzfeld<br />
$5,000 - $9,999<br />
DONATIONS<br />
Odeh Aburdene<br />
Asan Institute For<br />
Policy Studies<br />
Avascent<br />
Peter Behr<br />
Rafic A. Bizri<br />
Byron Callan<br />
Sandra Charles<br />
CNA Corporation<br />
Columbia University School<br />
of International and<br />
Public Affairs<br />
Andrew Davis<br />
Deloitte Services<br />
Lacey Neuhaus Dorn<br />
Glenn Dunmire<br />
Embassy of Germany<br />
FedEx Corporation<br />
Francis Finelli<br />
Julie Finley<br />
Laurie Fulton<br />
Richard Gelfond<br />
Sherri Goodman<br />
Chris Griner<br />
Patrick Gross<br />
Stephen J. Hadley<br />
Michael V. Hayden<br />
Loren W. Hershey<br />
Hilton Worldwide<br />
Holdings, Inc.<br />
Robert D. Hormats<br />
Intesa Sanpaolo S.p.A.<br />
Fred Kempe<br />
Robert M Kimmit<br />
Steven Klinsky<br />
Kongsberg Defense<br />
Systems Inc.<br />
Richard L. Lawson<br />
Debra Facktor Lepore<br />
Wendy W. Makins<br />
William E. Mayer<br />
Judith Miller<br />
Ministry of Foreign Affairs<br />
of Romania<br />
Joachim Mohn<br />
Thomas Nides<br />
Open Source Policy Center<br />
Michael Pillsbury<br />
David Rekhviashvili<br />
Scribe Strategies<br />
& Advisors<br />
Jeff Shell<br />
Jefferey Siegal<br />
Wayne T Smith<br />
Stroock & Stroock<br />
& Lavan LLP<br />
Symantec Corporation<br />
ThermoFisher Scientific<br />
Paul Twomey<br />
Harlan Ullman<br />
Charles F. Wald<br />
John C. Whitehead†<br />
Dov S. Zakheim<br />
$1,000 - $4,999<br />
DONATIONS<br />
Timothy D. Adams<br />
Spindrift Al Swaidi<br />
John Allen<br />
Victor Ashe<br />
Lisa B. Barry<br />
Margaret Bennett<br />
Harold Brown<br />
R. Nicholas Burns<br />
James Cartwright<br />
Central Europe<br />
Energy Partners<br />
Roger Cliff<br />
Peter Cunniffe<br />
Ivo H. Daalder<br />
Daimler◊<br />
Christopher J. Dodd<br />
Stuart E. Eizenstat<br />
Lawrence P. Fisher II<br />
Andrew D. Frank<br />
Paul R.S. Gebhard<br />
Richard Grove<br />
Hinkley Institute<br />
James Hudson<br />
Brian Hunter<br />
Robert E. Hunter<br />
William Hybl<br />
George A Joulwan<br />
Stephen R. Kappes<br />
Geraldine Kunstadter<br />
Matthew Lauer<br />
Jane Lute<br />
Eric D.K. Melby<br />
Mark Meyer<br />
Franklin C. Miller<br />
James Miller<br />
Fay Moghtader<br />
George E. Moose<br />
Michael J. Morell<br />
Eugene L. Nardelli<br />
Joseph Nye<br />
Philip A. Odeen<br />
Sean O’Keefe<br />
Maureen Orth<br />
Raul Perea-Henze<br />
Thomas R. Pickering<br />
Philip Pilevsky<br />
Daniel Price<br />
Komei Sakai<br />
Sandia National<br />
Laboratories<br />
Steven E. Schmidt<br />
Walter B. Slocombe<br />
Paula Stern<br />
John S. Tanner<br />
Alex Tiersky<br />
University of California<br />
at Los Angeles<br />
Sezen Uysal<br />
Philip Verveer<br />
Charles Wald<br />
Don Wallace Jr.<br />
Maureen White<br />
James Wildman<br />
Damon M. Wilson<br />
Mary C. Yates<br />
UP TO $999<br />
DONATIONS<br />
AIPAC<br />
Peter Ajak<br />
America To Africa, LLC<br />
Stuart Archer<br />
Katharine Baker<br />
Randolph Bell<br />
Jordan Blashek<br />
Adam Brenner<br />
Mark Brunner<br />
David Buffaloe<br />
Keith Ross Butler<br />
Center for Euro-<br />
Atlantic Studies<br />
Center For A New<br />
American Security<br />
Frances D. Cook<br />
Lauren Culver<br />
Milan Dalal<br />
James De Francia<br />
Rob de Wijk<br />
Aaron Dowd<br />
Ashlee Godwin<br />
Bharath Gopalaswamy<br />
Faruk Baturalp Gunay<br />
Gokhan Gundogdu<br />
John Haederle<br />
Scott Harris<br />
Marten Van Heuven<br />
Brittany Heyd<br />
Adam Hitchcock<br />
Jeffrey Hoffman<br />
International Center on<br />
Nonviolent Conflict<br />
Jefferson Waterman<br />
International<br />
Walter Juraszek<br />
Zuhair Khan<br />
Henry A. Kissinger<br />
Kurt J. Klingenberger<br />
David Koranyi<br />
Dana Linnet<br />
Malcolm Lovell<br />
Gerhard Mally<br />
Margarita Mathiopoulos<br />
Jeff McLean<br />
Mercury LLC<br />
Jelena Milic<br />
Jordane Millot<br />
Blazej Lech Moder<br />
Bill Monahan<br />
Andrea Montanino<br />
Powell Moore<br />
Richard Morningstar<br />
Douglas Morrison<br />
James Morrison<br />
Terence Murphy<br />
Amir Nayeri<br />
Aarya Nijat<br />
Eileen O’Connor<br />
Rita O’Connor<br />
David Oliver Jr.<br />
Christian Paasch<br />
Walter Parchomenko<br />
David Pendall<br />
Yannis Perlepes<br />
Charles Alan Peyser<br />
J. Peter Pham<br />
Francis Ricciardone<br />
Christina Rocca<br />
Barbara Opall-Rome<br />
Daniel Russell<br />
Mark Schwendler<br />
Kimberly Shaw<br />
Shahrooz Shekaraubi<br />
Mark Simakovsky<br />
Saju Skaria<br />
Kiron Skinner<br />
Richard James Sladden<br />
Pamela Smith<br />
Pamela H. Smith<br />
Daniel Speckhard<br />
Matthew Spence<br />
Walter E. Stadtler<br />
Patick Stephenson<br />
Francesco Stipo<br />
Frank Tapparo<br />
Julie Varghese<br />
Leigh Warner<br />
Stephen Whisnant<br />
Ralph Winnie<br />
John Woodworth<br />
Samuel Zega<br />
Jonathan Zittrain<br />
atlanticcouncil.org
74 ATLANTIC COUNCIL 2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
FINANCIAL SUMMARY 75<br />
2015<br />
FINANCIAL SUMMARY<br />
REVENUE<br />
Unrestricted<br />
Temporarily<br />
Restricted 2015 Total 2014 Total Growth<br />
Individual Contributions $ 1,312,247 $ 7,827,198 $ 9,139,445 $ 8,974,134<br />
Corporate Support 2,145,365 8,542,154 10,687,519 8,535,036<br />
Foundations - 2,650,493 2,650,493 1,605,324<br />
Grants and Contracts - 2,776,931 2,776,931 3,877,609<br />
In-kind Contributed Services and Materials 578,563 - 578,563 145,498<br />
Events and Other Revenue 49,720 - 49,720 68,286<br />
Investment Return Designated for Operations 364,020 471,827 835,847 571,559<br />
Net Assets Released from Restrictions 20,306,391 (20,306,391) - -<br />
TOTAL REVENUE $ 24,756,306 $ 1,962,212 $ 26,718,518 $ 23,777,446 +12.4%<br />
OPERATING EXPENSES<br />
Program/Center Services:<br />
Adrienne Arsht Latin America Center $ 1,573,458 $ - $ 1,573,458 $ 1,565,667<br />
Africa Center 870,015 - 870,015 879,109<br />
Brent Scowcroft Center on International Security 6,076,893 - 6,076,893 5,547,366<br />
Dinu Patriciu Eurasia Center 3,525,129 - 3,525,129 2,914,640<br />
Future Europe Initiative 1,509,306 - 1,509,306 1,013,367<br />
Global Business & Economics Program 814,004 - 814,004 569,251<br />
Global Energy Center 1,047,458 - 1,047,458 761,061<br />
Millennium Leadership Program 683,777 - 683,777 787,595<br />
Rafik Hariri Center for the Middle East 3,463,025 - 3,463,025 3,090,509<br />
South Asia Center 1,391,578 - 1,391,578 1,028,486<br />
Total Program/Center Service Expenses $ 20,954,643 - $ 20,954,643 $ 18,157,051<br />
Supporting Services:<br />
Combined Statement of Activities<br />
and Statement of Financial Position<br />
Years ended December 31, 2015 and 2014<br />
2015 totals are preliminary and unaudited<br />
Management and General $ 2,889,409 $ - $ 2,889,409 $ 3,249,093<br />
Fundraising 720,467 - 720,467 452,052<br />
Total Supporting Service Expenses 3,609,876 - 3,609,876 3,701,145<br />
ASSETS 2015 2014<br />
Cash and Cash Equivalents $ 3,384,531 $ 4,382,443<br />
Contributions and Grants Receivable 6,394,608 4,952,344<br />
Prepaid Expenses and Other 151,345 351,142<br />
Fixed Assets 5,679,827 6,164,932<br />
Investments 17,964,151 16,876,109<br />
TOTAL ASSETS $ 33,574,462 $ 32,726,970<br />
LIABILITIES AND NET ASSETS<br />
Liabilities:<br />
Accounts Payable $ 785,041 $ 615,651<br />
Accrued Vacation 421,709 300,199<br />
Deferred Revenue 335,000 926,327<br />
Capital Lease Obligation 74,923 102,280<br />
Deferred Rent 5,507,520 5,583,027<br />
Other Long Term Liabilities 82,823 53,189<br />
Total Liabilities $ 7,207,016 $ 7,580,673<br />
Net Assets:<br />
Unrestricted 5,678,113 5,877,693<br />
Temporarily Restricted 20,689,333 19,268,604<br />
Total Net Assets $ 26,367,446 $ 25,146,297<br />
TOTAL LIABILITIES AND NET ASSETS $ 33,574,462 $ 32,726,970<br />
DIVERSITY OF SUPPORT, REVENUE BY SOURCE<br />
40%<br />
10%<br />
11%<br />
2%<br />
3%<br />
34%<br />
Grants and Contracts<br />
In-kind Contributed<br />
Services and Materials<br />
Investment Return<br />
Designated for Operations<br />
Individual Contribution<br />
Corporate Support<br />
Foundations<br />
SUSTAINABILITY FOR THE FUTURE, ASSETS BY TYPE<br />
54%<br />
10%<br />
17%<br />
19%<br />
Cash and Cash Equivalents<br />
Contributions and Grants<br />
Receivable<br />
Fixed Assets<br />
Investments<br />
Total Operating Expenses $ 24,564,519 $ - $ 24,564,519 $ 21,858,196 +12.4%<br />
CHANGE IN NET ASSETS BEFORE<br />
NON-OPERATING ACTIVITIES<br />
NON-OPERATING ACTIVITIES<br />
$ 191,787 $ 1,962,212 $ 2,153,999 $ 1,919,250 +12.2%<br />
Investment Income $ (27,347) $ (69,656) $ (97,003) $ 716,780<br />
Investment Return Utilized for Operations (364,020) (471,827) (835,847) (571,559)<br />
A DECADE OF REVENUE AND ASSET GROWTH (IN MILLIONS)<br />
40<br />
35<br />
30<br />
25<br />
20<br />
Revenue<br />
Revenue Trend<br />
Assets<br />
Change in Net Assets (199,580) 1,420,729 1,221,149 2,064,471<br />
15<br />
Net Assets at Beginning of Year $ 5,877,693 $ 19,268,604 $ 25,146,297 $ 23,081,826<br />
10<br />
5<br />
NET ASSETS AT END OF YEAR $ 5,678,113 $ 20,689,333 $ 26,367,446 $ 25,146,297 +4.9%<br />
0<br />
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015<br />
atlanticcouncil.org
76<br />
ATLANTIC COUNCIL 2015 <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
CREDITS & ATTRIBUTIONS<br />
BY THE NUMBERS &<br />
WORD ON THE STREET<br />
FEATURED IN 13 CATEGORIES<br />
of the University of Pennsylvania’s Global Go To Think Tank Index<br />
#<br />
1 OTHER<br />
4 STAR CHARITY NAVIGATOR RATING<br />
GLOBALLY FOR BEST<br />
COLLABORATION WITH<br />
THINK TANKS<br />
#<br />
5<br />
TO<br />
#<br />
3<br />
IN<br />
THINK TANK<br />
WATCH<br />
“I think that the Council<br />
is ideally positioned to<br />
bring partners together….<br />
I think its role is critical<br />
in this environment.”<br />
– CHRISTINE LAGARDE, MANAGING DIRECTOR<br />
OF THE INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND<br />
616 EVENTS (UP 20%)<br />
MOST-ATTENDED EVENTS:<br />
POLICY <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
THE WORLD<br />
#<br />
15 THE<br />
IMPLEMENTING THE IRAN NUCLEAR DEAL<br />
THE UKRAINE CRISIS: WITHSTAND AND DETER RUSSIAN AGGRESSION<br />
THE ROAD AHEAD FOR TPP: MICHAEL FROMAN<br />
#<br />
11<br />
BEST<br />
CONFERENCE<br />
BEST MANAGED<br />
THINK TANK IN<br />
WORLD<br />
90% INCREASE IN UNIQUE<br />
WEBSITE VISITORS<br />
OVER 4 YEARS<br />
81% MORE PAGEVIEWS<br />
OVER 4 YEARS<br />
63% TWITTER AUDIENCE<br />
IS OUTSIDE THE<br />
UNITED STATES<br />
“We can always<br />
count on the<br />
Atlantic Council<br />
to be ahead of<br />
the curve and<br />
to challenge all<br />
of us to think.”<br />
– JOHN KERRY, US SECRETARY OF STATE<br />
80 PUBLICATIONS,<br />
INCLUDING 44 <strong>REPORT</strong>S<br />
(69% MORE THAN 2014)<br />
TOP ONLINE<br />
PUBLICATIONS:<br />
HIDING IN PLAIN SIGHT:<br />
PUTIN’S WAR IN UKRAINE<br />
WAR STORIES FROM<br />
THE FUTURE<br />
“If America and Europe can<br />
expand their ties and preserve<br />
their interdependent security, the<br />
Atlantic community will set an<br />
example for other parts of<br />
the world where turmoil and<br />
conflict loom so large.”<br />
– ZBIGNIEW BRZEZINSKI,<br />
FORMER NATIONAL SECURITY ADVISOR ON THE<br />
IMPORTANCE OF THE ATLANTIC COUNCIL’S WORK<br />
Editorial Director: Drew Dickson<br />
Text Editing: Susan J. Cavan, Madeleine Levey Lambert,<br />
Maureen McGrath<br />
Image Editing: Victoria Langton<br />
Layout Editing: Romain Warnault<br />
Consultants: Paige Ennis and Susan Kellam<br />
Concept and Design: Orange Element, LLC<br />
Printing: HBP<br />
Image Credits<br />
Front cover, from top left to bottom right: REUTERS/<br />
Adnan Abidi; REUTERS/Alexei Nikolsky; REUTERS/Gleb<br />
Garanich; REUTERS/Fotis Plegas G; and REUTERS/<br />
Ueslei Marcelino<br />
Back cover, from top left to bottom right: REUTERS/<br />
Michael Kappeler; REUTERS/Carlos Barria; REUTERS/<br />
Beck Diefenbach; REUTERS/Stringer; REUTERS/Kevin<br />
Lamarque; and REUTERS/Khaled Abdullah<br />
Table of Contents, from left to right: REUTERS/<br />
Marko Djurica; REUTERS/Kevin Lamarque; ATLANTIC<br />
COUNCIL<br />
Leadership Message, from left to right: Bundesarchiv,<br />
Bild 183-85458-0001/Heinz Junge/CC-BY-SA 3.0; The<br />
John F. Kennedy Presidential Library and Museum; AP/<br />
Lionel Cironneau; REUTERS/Gary Hershorn; REUTERS/<br />
Gleb Garanich; REUTERS/Yannis Behrakis<br />
Page 6, from top left to bottom right: REUTERS/<br />
Marko Djurica; REUTERS/Lucas Jackson; REUTERS/Atef<br />
Hassan; REUTERS/Cornelius Poppe/NTB Scanpix/Pool;<br />
REUTERS/Yannis Behrakis<br />
Page 32, from top left to bottom right: REUTERS/<br />
Kevin Lamarque; REUTERS/Khaled Abdullah;<br />
ATLANTIC COUNCIL; REUTERS/Adnan Abidi;<br />
REUTERS/Carlos Barria<br />
All other images not credited are property<br />
of the Atlantic Council.<br />
The Atlantic Council is a nonpartisan organization<br />
that promotes constructive leadership and<br />
engagement in international affairs based on<br />
the central role of the Atlantic community in<br />
meeting today’s global challenges.<br />
© 2016 The Atlantic Council of the United States. All<br />
rights reserved. No part of this publication may be<br />
reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means<br />
without permission in writing from the Atlantic Council,<br />
except in the case of brief quotations in news articles,<br />
critical articles, or reviews. Please direct inquiries to:<br />
Atlantic Council<br />
1030 15th Street, NW, 12th Floor,<br />
Washington, DC 20005<br />
(202) 463-7226, www.AtlanticCouncil.org<br />
atlanticcouncil.org
WORKING TOGETHER<br />
TO SECURE THE FUTURE<br />
1030 15TH STREET, NW<br />
12TH FLOOR<br />
WASHINGTON, DC 20005<br />
(202) 778-4952<br />
AtlanticCouncil.org