CubaTrade-One-Flip
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
CUBA AFTER FIDEL: THE ECONOMIC IMPACT<br />
The Magazine for Trade & Investment in Cuba<br />
December 2016<br />
CAN U.S. AGRICULTURE LIFT<br />
THE EMBARGO?<br />
Inside the mission of Devry Boughner Vorwerk,<br />
Chair of the US Agriculture Coalition for Cuba<br />
RICE COUNTRY<br />
Arkansas’ Cuba play<br />
PIONEER PLASTIC<br />
US credit cards debut<br />
PHONE HOME<br />
Telephonic expansion<br />
IN FLIGHT<br />
Havana Air aims higher
GO GLOBAL<br />
MIAMI: Trade and Logistics Hub<br />
of the Americas<br />
Trade Assistance Center Services<br />
BUYER SERVICES:<br />
n Agent/ Distributor Services<br />
n Red Carpet /VIP Meetings<br />
n Trade Missions<br />
n Trade Show Assistance<br />
PRODUCT AND MARKET ASSESSMENTS:<br />
n Product Competitiveness Assessments<br />
n Market Research Reports<br />
n Product Sourcing<br />
n Customized Training Services
AMERICAS TRADE SHOWS:<br />
The World Trade Center Miami manages two hemispheric trade shows which draw more<br />
than 17,000 buyers to Miami. Upcoming shows include the 21st annual Americas Food<br />
& Beverage Show and the 14th Biennial Air Cargo/Sea Cargo Americas Trade Show and<br />
Conference. Reported sales at these shows exceed US$239 million.<br />
The World Trade Center Miami assists other global trade shows and organizations to<br />
access the Americas marketplace by providing sales assistance overseas and by<br />
bringing foreign buyer missions to trade shows.<br />
CHARLOTTE GALLOGLY, President<br />
1007 North America Way, #500, Miami, FL 33132 n 305-871-7910 n info@worldtrade.org<br />
www.worldtrade.org
content 12/2016<br />
UP FRONT<br />
10 PANORAMA<br />
Deals, events and transactions of note<br />
for trade and investment in Cuba<br />
12 INDEX<br />
The rise of cash and good transfers<br />
14 IDEAS + INNOVATION<br />
Tapping new talent, virtual Havana<br />
& wifi cubes for hotspots<br />
16 INTERVIEW<br />
The Impact of President-elect Trump:<br />
Our Q&A with James Williams<br />
18 TRANSITIONS<br />
The death of Fidel Castro, the election<br />
of Donald Trump, and the economic<br />
implications<br />
20 REGULATIONS<br />
Details of the latest round of reduced<br />
trade sanctions<br />
26 BIOMED<br />
New regulations mean Cuban drugs<br />
can be tested and imported<br />
28 ENERGY<br />
Cuba looks to renewable resources to<br />
energize its grid<br />
30 RECREATION<br />
In the wake of last year’s exemptions<br />
for U.S. sporting events in Cuba,<br />
Florida regattas have resumed their<br />
yacht races to the island<br />
38 LEGISLATION<br />
The next steps forward are already in<br />
the Senate, waiting for the House<br />
40 TRADE<br />
In a first crack to the embargo against<br />
imports, Cuban coffee has made it to<br />
the U.S.<br />
LIFESTYLE<br />
87 REPORTER'S NOTEBOOK<br />
The initial commercial flights to Cuba<br />
have been to provincial cities, far<br />
from Havana and far less expensive<br />
than the capital<br />
DEPARTMENTS<br />
22 TOURISM<br />
Only one U.S. cruise line has tested the<br />
water so far, but others are ready to go<br />
24 TECH<br />
A workaround Cuba’s internet<br />
limitations paves the way for precious<br />
market research<br />
32 BANKING<br />
For Americans who visit Cuba, cash<br />
has been a requisite. That is now<br />
changing, as credit cards begin to be<br />
accepted<br />
34 SCIENCE<br />
The key to protecting Florida’s sharks<br />
may lie in Cuban waters<br />
36 MANUFACTURING<br />
How a celebrated plan to build a U.S.<br />
tractor factory in Cuba failed to gain<br />
approval, and what happens next<br />
90 CUBAN ART<br />
Cuban artists born after 1980, unlike<br />
their predecessors, have no desire to<br />
leave the island. And why should<br />
they? Their work would lose its value<br />
94 EVENTS<br />
More than 3,500 exhibitors from 75<br />
countries converged in Cuba for the<br />
34th Havana International Fair<br />
FINAL WORD<br />
96 IN CLOSING<br />
A New Generation for Relations<br />
By Jodi Hanson Bond,<br />
Vice President, Americas, U.S.<br />
Chamber of Commerce; President,<br />
U.S.-Cuba Business Council<br />
4 CUBATRADE DEC 2016
How do we move food<br />
from Hastings to Havana?<br />
Break down barriers.<br />
When America farmers are able to freely<br />
export their crops to other countries, it<br />
nourishes the people who need them<br />
most. Opening new markets for US<br />
agriculture boosts food production, spurs<br />
job creation and puts food on more tables<br />
across the globe. That’s why we champion<br />
open trade flows – to raise incomes for<br />
all and build local economies that thrive.<br />
Learn more at cargill.com/food-security.<br />
Cargill is committed to helping the world thrive.<br />
© 2016 Cargill, Incorporated
features<br />
42 HAVANA AIR<br />
A Tale of the Long Game: How Havana Air took<br />
off to become the largest provider of passenger<br />
traffic to Cuba<br />
49 PUERTO RICO: U.S. BRIDGE TO CUBA?<br />
As the Caribbean island that the U.S. never left,<br />
Puerto Rico has existed in a kind of parallel universe<br />
to Cuba<br />
42<br />
54 AT&T CALL HOME<br />
With help from U.S. and Chinese companies,<br />
Cuban telephony gradually unfolds<br />
54<br />
60 SEEDS OF CHANGE<br />
The agriculture community in the U.S. wants the<br />
embargo against Cuba lifted, for the benefit of both<br />
the Cuban people and American farmers<br />
71 THE ARKANSAS REPORT<br />
With Governor Asa Hutchinson at the helm,<br />
Arkansas is leading the charge to open Cuban<br />
markets for U.S. commodities<br />
ON THE COVER<br />
Devry Boughner Vorwerk, chair,<br />
U.S. Agriculture Coalition for<br />
Cuba<br />
If you tell any farmer<br />
that they cannot sell<br />
to any market, that’s<br />
a real violation of<br />
their rights...<br />
60<br />
6 CUBATRADE DEC 2016
CONGRATULATIONS<br />
CUBA TRADE<br />
MAGAZINE<br />
Your vision will serve you well<br />
as you continue to forge ahead<br />
in this worthwhile endeavor.<br />
Our Cuba Task Force attorneys are uniquely<br />
positioned to assist clients with the legal<br />
and business opportunities following the<br />
changes in U.S. public policy toward Cuba.<br />
Established in 1910, Shutts & Bowen has witnessed<br />
and participated in almost every major event in<br />
Cuba’s history since the beginning of the 20th century.<br />
No other law firm in South Florida has this experience.<br />
“U.S. business owners need to understand<br />
the process and meet the requirements of<br />
U.S. and Cuban laws. We are happy to help<br />
them navigate through these new waters.”<br />
—Aliette DelPozo Rodz, Cuba Task Force Chair<br />
Shutts & Bowen LLP<br />
200 South Biscayne Boulevard | Suite 4100<br />
Miami, Florida 33131<br />
305.358.6300<br />
www.shutts.com<br />
FORT LAUDERDALE | MIAMI | ORLANDO | SARASOTA | TALLAHASSEE | TAMPA | WEST PALM BEACH
editors note<br />
Rise of the Pragmatists<br />
Welcome to the premiere issue of Cuba Trade magazine, the<br />
first publication entirely dedicated to the expansion of trade,<br />
commerce, and culture between Cuba and the United States.<br />
Each month Cuba Trade will present its readers the stories that<br />
reflect the business opportunities in contemporary Cuba—the<br />
challenges, the strategies, and the successes—along with daily online<br />
news briefs of the most important business developments.<br />
We are launching Cuba Trade at a particularly profound moment<br />
for U.S.-Cuban relations. With the death of Fidel Castro<br />
and the election of Donald Trump as the U.S. president, the possibilities<br />
for change now abound. Cuba is already one of the most<br />
interesting places in the world today. It is a nation in transition,<br />
with astonishing human capital and a global footprint far larger<br />
than its size. Now it is suddenly even more interesting.<br />
Anyone reading these words is aware that two years ago<br />
President Barrack Obama and President Raúl Castro renewed<br />
diplomatic relations between our two nations. It was a rapprochement<br />
long overdue, and one that holds great promise. We now<br />
have a new president-elect, and the potential for even greater<br />
change on both sides of the Florida Straits.<br />
It’s no surprise that many Americans and Cubans had hoped<br />
for a Clinton White House, assuming such an administration<br />
would continue the Obama policy of engagement. And it’s<br />
also no surprise that many people, both in Cuba and the U.S.,<br />
are wary of the upcoming Trump presidency. We see the new<br />
administration as an opportunity, for multiple reasons. First and<br />
foremost, our new president is a pragmatist. Coming from a business<br />
background—and a campaign promise to increase jobs—Mr.<br />
Trump will most likely make policy choices that boost employment.<br />
This includes opening up trade with Cuba.<br />
It is also unlikely that Mr. Trump will pursue a Cuba policy<br />
that flies in the face of advances made by U.S. corporations,<br />
especially in the transportation and hospitality arenas. Another<br />
way to say this is that it will be difficult, expensive, and politically<br />
dangerous to reverse the momentum already achieved.<br />
Finally, we see an opportunity to advance the most important<br />
aspect of changing U.S.-Cuba relations—legislation to<br />
make the openings inaugurated by the Obama administration<br />
permanent. Let’s not forget that it has been Republican senators,<br />
congressmen and governors who have led the effort to rescind<br />
the embargo. Now, with both the House and the Senate—and<br />
the executive branch—in Republican hands, there is a real chance<br />
for legislation to pass. On the Cuban side, the passing of Fidel<br />
means that Raúl’s market-oriented reforms are more likely to be<br />
implemented by a rank-and-file who were previously restrained<br />
by intransigent ideology. Much like Trump, Raúl is a pragmatist<br />
more interested in results than rubrics. With the passing of<br />
Fidel’s long shadow, the two presidents are more likely to pursue<br />
a mutually beneficial opening.<br />
This magazine is dedicated to chronicling the evolution of<br />
that opening, to promoting a spirit of cooperation and mutual aid<br />
between two such close neighbors, and to showcasing the new<br />
face of Cuba as it engages with the business leaders and entrepreneurs<br />
who are pioneering this brave new world. H<br />
J.P. Faber. Editor-in-Chief<br />
Publisher<br />
Richard Roffman<br />
Editor-in-Chief<br />
J.P.Faber<br />
Managing Editor<br />
Michael Deibert<br />
Associate Editor<br />
Nick Swyter<br />
Writers<br />
Lee Ann Evans<br />
Sean Goforth<br />
Carlos Harrison<br />
Doreen Hemlock<br />
Larry Luxner<br />
Victoria McKenzie<br />
Art Director<br />
Jon Braeley<br />
Photographers<br />
Aaron Clamage<br />
Kirk Kennedy<br />
Tina Krohn<br />
Mark Matthews<br />
Matias J. Ocner<br />
Thos Robinson<br />
Production Manager<br />
Toni Kirkland<br />
Director, Corporate Relations<br />
Ana Soler<br />
Sales Executive<br />
Magguie Marina<br />
Research & Development<br />
Sydney Glanz<br />
Executive Publisher<br />
Todd Hoffman<br />
Cuba Trade Magazine is published each month by Third Circle Publishing, LLC,<br />
at 2 S. Biscayne Blvd., Suite 2450, Miami, FL USA 33131. Telephone: (786)<br />
206.8254. Copyright 2016 by Third Circle Publishing LLC. All rights reserved.<br />
Reproduction in whole or part of any text, photograph or illustration without prior<br />
written permission from the publisher is strictly prohibited.<br />
Postmaster: Send address changes to Third Circle Publishing, LLC, 2 S. Biscayne<br />
Blvd., Suite 2450, Miami, FL USA 33131. Subscription information domestic and<br />
foreign (786) 206.8254. Send general mailbox email and letters to the editor to info@<br />
cubatrademag.com. BPA International Membership applied for December 2016.<br />
Cubatrademagazine.com Thirdcirclepublishing.com<br />
8 CUBATRADE DEC 2016
PANORAMA<br />
Deals, events and transactions of note<br />
for trade and investment in Cuba<br />
Photo by Jon Braeley<br />
Roaming kicks in<br />
U.S. telecom giants AT&T and T-Mobile<br />
have begun offering direct roaming<br />
services to Cuba. Both companies signed<br />
roaming deals with ETECSA, the Cuban<br />
telecommunications monopoly, earlier<br />
this year.<br />
Top US health official visits Cuba<br />
Secretary of Health and Human Services<br />
Sylvia Burwell met with Cuban Minister<br />
of Health Roberto Morales in Havana to<br />
sign an agreement to cooperate on cancer<br />
research. Burwell also attended a regional<br />
meeting on Zika, which Cuba has successfully<br />
contained.<br />
Historic UN vote<br />
In a first, the U.S. abstained from the<br />
annual U.N. vote condemning the Cuba<br />
trade embargo. Not a single country voted<br />
against the measure, and Israel was the<br />
only other country to abstain. The vote is<br />
mostly symbolic since only Congress has<br />
the power to lift the embargo.<br />
Portuguese president visits Cuba<br />
Portuguese President Marcelo Rebelo de<br />
Sousa visited Cuba to meet with President<br />
Raúl Castro. Rebelo de Sousa also met<br />
former President Fidel Castro at his<br />
home. According to Cuban state media,<br />
Rebelo de Sousa told Fidel Castro he is<br />
against the trade embargo.<br />
Loosened regulations<br />
In mid-October President Obama further<br />
eased restrictions on Cuba, including lifting<br />
limits on bringing rum and cigars into<br />
the U.S. Among other changes, the new<br />
rules allow Cubans and Americans to do<br />
joint medical research, Cuban pharmaceutical<br />
companies to apply for U.S. regulatory<br />
approval, and cargo ships to travel with<br />
more ease between the two countries.<br />
Clinical trials for cancer vaccine<br />
Buffalo’s Roswell Park Cancer Institute<br />
won FDA approval to conduct clinical<br />
trials for CIMAvax, a lung cancer vaccine<br />
developed in Cuba. While the vaccine<br />
does not prevent lung cancer, it has shown<br />
promise in stopping the growth of cancer<br />
cells. Clinical trials will begin by year's end.<br />
Debt payments on track<br />
Cuba paid the first $40 million installment<br />
of a $2.6 billion debt plan with the<br />
Paris Club of creditor nations. The money<br />
is owed to 14 wealthy countries who<br />
agreed to forgive $8.5 billion worth of<br />
Cuba’s debt late last year. The debt will be<br />
paid over 18 years.<br />
TripAdvisor gets the green light<br />
The Office of Foreign Assets Control<br />
(OFAC) has granted TripAdvisor a<br />
license to book Cuba flights and hotels.<br />
Under the license, TripAdvisor can book<br />
travel options that fall into one of the 12<br />
categories approved by OFAC, which do<br />
not include tourism.<br />
Investment portfolio released<br />
As part of the Cuba’s plan to attract<br />
more foreign investment, the country<br />
released its 2017 investment portfolio,<br />
which identified 395 projects requiring<br />
$9.5 billion in investments. High-priority<br />
sectors include agriculture, tourism,<br />
energy, and infrastructure.<br />
10 CUBATRADE DEC 2016
Cuban oil refineries take a hit<br />
The drop in Venezuelan oil shipments<br />
to Cuba has led to a Cienfuegos refinery<br />
cutting its production in half, the Miami<br />
Herald reported. According to Venezuelan<br />
state oil company PDVSA, crude shipments<br />
to Cuba were down 40 percent in<br />
the first half of 2016. Cuba has explored<br />
the possibility of processing Algerian,<br />
Russian, and Iranian crude.<br />
Japan, Russia strike deals<br />
Japan and Russia expanded economic<br />
cooperation with Cuba by signing deals<br />
during the Havana International Fair.<br />
Russia and Cuba will create a joint venture<br />
to produce storage batteries. Japan agreed<br />
to expand its economic links to the island.<br />
New era for Cuba-EU relations<br />
A deal to expand political and economic<br />
cooperation between Cuba and the<br />
European Union was announced during<br />
the Havana International Fair. The deal,<br />
which is set to be signed December 12, is<br />
expected to change the way the EU and<br />
Cuba negotiate economic cooperation and<br />
human rights.<br />
Cuban doctors to China<br />
Companies representing Cuba and China<br />
signed a letter of intent to send Cuban<br />
doctors to China. The letter also seeks to<br />
send Chinese patients to hospitals in Cuba.<br />
Unilever in Mariel<br />
British-Dutch consumer product giant<br />
Unilever has broken ground on a $35<br />
million toothpaste and soap factory in the<br />
Mariel Special Economic Development<br />
Zone. The factory is expected to create 300<br />
local jobs and start production in 2018.<br />
Mariel approved 11 business proposals the<br />
same week Unilever broke ground.<br />
Internet in private homes<br />
Cuba’s state-run telecommunications<br />
monopoly ETECSA announced a plan to<br />
install household internet into 2,000 Old<br />
Havana homes by the end of the year. The<br />
infrastructure for the project was installed by<br />
Chinese telecommunications giant Huawei.<br />
Nationwide military drills<br />
Almost immediately after Donald Trump<br />
won the U.S. presidential election, the Cuban<br />
government announced it would hold<br />
five days of nationwide military exercises.<br />
The Cuban government did not link the<br />
exercises to the results of the election.<br />
New restaurant licenses suspended<br />
Havana’s city government temporarily<br />
stopped issuing licenses for new private<br />
restaurants, otherwise known as paladares.<br />
According to state media, the move is in<br />
response to paladares violating regulations.<br />
Paladares are required to buy their supplies<br />
at state-run markets and limit their seating<br />
to no more than 50.<br />
Ballet diplomacy<br />
Misty Copeland, the first African<br />
American woman to be a principal dancer<br />
at the American Ballet Theatre, visited<br />
Cuba as a U.S. State Department’s sports<br />
and cultural envoy. Copeland participated<br />
in dance clinics with Cuba’s cultural<br />
institutions during her trip.<br />
The Simpsons go to Cuba<br />
Reflecting the growuing awareness of<br />
Cuba by the average American, TV’s most<br />
iconic animated family ventured to Cuba<br />
to find Abe Simpson free medical care.<br />
Abe never received the care he needed in<br />
the episode, but riding a 1950s car lifted<br />
his spirits.<br />
Cuba highlights trade opportunities<br />
More than 3,500 exhibitors from 75<br />
countries participated at the 34th<br />
annual Havana International Fair at<br />
the beginning of November, the largest<br />
general-interest trade fair in Cuba. At the<br />
start of the fair, Cuba’s Minister of Foreign<br />
Trade and Commerce Rodrigo Malmierca<br />
Diaz announced that the Cuban economy<br />
will not grow significantly in 2016.<br />
Leaders of Canada and Vietnam visit Cuba<br />
Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau<br />
and Vietnamese President Tran Dai<br />
Quang visited Cuba in November to discuss<br />
trade and other issues with President<br />
Castro. Justin Trudeau’s father, former<br />
Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau, was the<br />
first NATO leader to visit the island after<br />
the revolution. H<br />
DEC 2016<br />
CUBATRADE<br />
11
INDEX<br />
THE RISE OF CASH<br />
& GOODS TRANSFERS<br />
By Nick Swyter<br />
REMITTANCES RULE THE CUBAN ECONOMY<br />
Main sectors of the Cuban economy (in millions of dollars, 2014)<br />
FASTEST GROWING REMITTANCE MARKET IN LATIN AMERICA<br />
Annual remittances to Cuba (in millions of dollars)<br />
3500<br />
3000<br />
2500<br />
2000<br />
1500<br />
1000<br />
500<br />
Exports-Sugar<br />
Exports-Tobacco<br />
Exports-Medicines<br />
Exports-Nickel<br />
0<br />
Tourism Sales<br />
Remittances-Cash<br />
Remittances-Goods<br />
1,447<br />
2008<br />
0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 3500 4000<br />
0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 3500 4000<br />
2009<br />
2010<br />
2011<br />
2012<br />
SOURCE: Havana Consulting Group<br />
2013<br />
2014<br />
3,354<br />
2015<br />
SOURCE: Havana Consulting Group<br />
Even after Cuba legalized the U.S. dollar in 1993,<br />
restrictions on money transfers made it difficult for<br />
Cuban families to receive assistance from relatives in the<br />
U.S. More than two decades later, loosened restrictions<br />
have helped make remittances one of the most valuable<br />
sectors of the Cuban economy.<br />
According to the Havana Consulting Group, cash<br />
and material remittances sent to Cuba in 2014 were<br />
worth $6.63 billion—about half of it in cash. The gross<br />
earnings from Cuba’s tourism sector and four most<br />
valuable material exports (sugar, tobacco, medicines and<br />
nickel) were, by comparison, valued at $5.17 billion.<br />
Those gross earnings are worth even less after subtracting<br />
production, operating, and commercialization costs.<br />
From 2008 to 2014, Cuba’s remittances grew by<br />
116.2 percent, the biggest increase in Latin America.<br />
Nonetheless, Cuba is only the seventh largest remittance<br />
market in the region, surpassed by Mexico, Guatemala,<br />
the Dominican Republic, El Salvador, Colombia and<br />
Honduras. Should Cuba maintain its growth rate,<br />
however, it will become the third largest remittance<br />
market in Latin America within five years.<br />
There are several reasons for Cuba’s growth,<br />
but President Obama’s decision to loosen travel and<br />
remittance restrictions for Cuban-Americans is perhaps<br />
the most significant. Some of the most recent reforms<br />
came in September 2015, when the U.S. lifted its $2,000<br />
per quarter limit on cash transfers (typically done via<br />
Western Union or through third-country banks). The<br />
$10,000 limit that travelers could carry to Cuba was also<br />
lifted. Since 2009, authorized Cuban-Americans have<br />
been able to travel to the island as many times per year as<br />
they wish.<br />
Increased migration levels have also lead to more<br />
Cubans sending money home. Some 90,000 Cubans<br />
have left the island since the U.S. and Cuba restored<br />
diplomatic relations in December 2014. According<br />
to Florida International University’s 2016 Cuba Poll,<br />
younger Cubans and more recent arrivals in Miami are<br />
more likely to send money home. H<br />
12 CUBATRADE DEC 2016
Your Cuba Banking Provider<br />
Cash Management Products<br />
Wire Transfers<br />
Credit Cards<br />
Debit Cards<br />
Our Team Will Work Hard For You!<br />
www.stonegatebank.com<br />
All credit card products are subject to credit approval. Listed products are only available to U.S. Citizens or Permanent Resident Aliens of the United States of America. Other restrictions apply.<br />
Contact your local Stonegate Bank branch for additional information. MasterCard and the MasterCard Brand Mark are registered trademarks of MasterCard International Incorporated.
IDEAS + INNOVATION<br />
Tapping New Talent<br />
In an effort to incubate tech startups in<br />
Cuba, a coalition of foundations, schools<br />
and corporations awarded 10 promising<br />
entrepreneurs with a package of prizes to<br />
help accelerate their efforts. Organized<br />
by the Cuba Emprende Foundation,<br />
CubaNow and others, and with corporate<br />
sponsors American Airlines, Dell/<br />
EMC, iTutorGroup and Rackspace, the<br />
contest drew 88 applications from across<br />
the island (see map). Winners included<br />
startups building apps for dining, advertising,<br />
bed and breakfasts, private products,<br />
and art events. Each will receive a package<br />
of technology products and all-expensepaid<br />
immersion trips to the U.S. valued<br />
at about $10,000. “The initiative is to<br />
connect the tech community in Cuba with<br />
the start-up community in America, to<br />
strengthen the tech ecosystem in Cuba,”<br />
says John McIntire, chairman of the Cuba<br />
Emprende Foundation. To learn about the<br />
winners, visit www.10x10kCuba.com<br />
–J.P. Faber<br />
Image courtesy of 10x10kCuba<br />
The Mother of Invention<br />
This year marked the inaugural London<br />
Design Biennale at Somerset House, in<br />
which 37 countries and territories presented<br />
ideas and solutions exploring the theme<br />
“Utopia by Design.” <strong>One</strong> of the more tangible<br />
ideas came from the Cuban design<br />
duo Luis Ramírez and Michel J. Aguilar,<br />
whose inspired response to the digital<br />
explosion in Cuba was a highlight of the<br />
show. The project, ParaWifi, proposes<br />
biodegradable plastic cubes that can be<br />
easily assembled in various arrangements<br />
in wi-fi hotspots. The idea is to create safe<br />
and protected digital oases; with Astroturf<br />
seats, fans in the ceiling and charging jacks<br />
(powered by solar panels in the roofs), the<br />
cube is surprisingly comfortable and private.<br />
In an ironic twist, the cube was also<br />
the only place in Somerset House that<br />
provided access to their wireless network,<br />
thus replicating the experiences of many<br />
Cubans. Learn more at www.facebook.<br />
com/parawifi.cuba/ –Lily Faber<br />
Image courtesy of Luis Ramirez<br />
Virtual Havana<br />
Anybody with an internet connection<br />
can now take a virtual tour of Havana,<br />
thanks to a high-tech startup that<br />
recently mapped the places where<br />
Google Street View cars won’t be driving<br />
anytime soon. Sweden-based Mapillary<br />
armed a team of 11 volunteers with<br />
360-degree cameras, smartphones and<br />
selfie sticks. Over the course of four<br />
days, the volunteers walked, cycled and<br />
drove through Havana to photograph<br />
hundreds of miles of the city’s streets.<br />
They then used the Mapillary app to<br />
stitch together thousands of photos into<br />
a free interactive map of the city. “Local<br />
citizens have not necessarily had access<br />
to updated maps for their city for some<br />
time, but we’re hoping to change that,”<br />
Claudio Cossio, Mapillary’s head of user<br />
growth in Latin America, told Cuba<br />
Trade. Check out www.mapilllary.com<br />
–Nick Swyter<br />
14 CUBATRADE DEC 2016
American wheat<br />
growers stand ready<br />
to meet demand<br />
in Cuba.<br />
It’s time to end<br />
the embargo.
INTERVIEW<br />
A Q&A with James Williams:<br />
The Impact of<br />
President-Elect Trump<br />
Nonprofit national coalition Engage Cuba has<br />
quickly become a major force in the effort to lift<br />
the embargo against Cuba, creating<br />
pro-engagement councils now in 15 U.S. states.<br />
We spoke with its president, James Williams, on<br />
the impact of Trump’s election as president.<br />
CUBA TRADE: Many observers are<br />
pessimistic about lifting the embargo in<br />
the near future because of what Presidentelect<br />
Donald Trump said in the final<br />
weeks before the election. Do you share<br />
that pessimism?<br />
WILLIAMS: I don’t. <strong>One</strong> thing we saw<br />
with this election, the number one concern<br />
of voters, was jobs and the economy.<br />
That’s the mandate that sent Mr. Trump<br />
to Washington, along with an anti-establishment<br />
wave. When you think of something<br />
that personifies the failed policies of<br />
the establishment, it’s the Cuba embargo.<br />
Lifting it is something he could to do end<br />
a failed policy and bring jobs back to the<br />
U.S. economy. It seems like a win-win.<br />
WILLIAMS: I think it would be difficult.<br />
There is broad support from the business<br />
community [for the openings], and even<br />
from the Cuban community. Americans<br />
are voting with their feet by getting on<br />
planes to Cuba. The idea that it’s going to<br />
be rolled back is not only unlikely but unpopular.<br />
It would serve no interest, neither<br />
here nor in Cuba. We are optimistic that it<br />
[a roll back] will not occur.<br />
CUBA TRADE: In the end, as your<br />
organization realizes, this is going to be a<br />
legislative issue. Helms-Burton must be<br />
reversed by Congress. Do you think we are<br />
making progress there?<br />
James Williams speaking at a press conference in Jackson Mississippi<br />
WILLIAMS:There will be a small and<br />
shrill minority who will continue to support<br />
the embargo. But that is the past. The<br />
American and Cuban people are moving<br />
forward. [Continuing the embargo] is<br />
the personal agenda of a few members of<br />
Congress and that’s wrong. The Senate<br />
wants to move forward and we are close in<br />
the House.<br />
Photo by Madeleine Russak<br />
CUBA TRADE: President Obama made<br />
a concerted effort to make his openings<br />
‘irreversible.’ We know that is not the case<br />
with executive orders. Nonetheless, how<br />
hard do you think it would be to reverse<br />
the momentum?<br />
WILLIAMS:This is one area where we are<br />
most excited about the election results. We<br />
gained four new pro-engagement Senators,<br />
and more than 10 pro-engagement<br />
House members, including Republicans<br />
and Democrats. People are looking for<br />
places where there is common ground to<br />
move the country forward, and this is a<br />
great place to start.<br />
CUBA TRADE: What about vocal Congressional<br />
supporters of the embargo, like<br />
Paul Ryan, Bob Menendez, and Marco<br />
Rubio?<br />
CUBA TRADE: What about the ‘lame<br />
duck’ session of Congress? Any chance<br />
that the amendment by Sen. Boozman<br />
(R-Ark) to the spending bill [to loosen<br />
restrictions on financing agricultural<br />
trade] will go forward?<br />
WILLIAMS: This is an area where<br />
it is a real no-brainer. If you look at<br />
the communities that propelled Mr.<br />
Trump’s victory, that’s who this bill is<br />
designed to help. This is for American<br />
farmer. I see no reason why it shouldn’t<br />
move forward. H<br />
16 CUBATRADE DEC 2016
BEFORE THE EMBARGO,<br />
Cuba was the top<br />
destination for our rice.<br />
LET’S GET THERE AGAIN.
TRANSITIONS<br />
ENDINGS AND BEGINNINGS<br />
(Photo by Javier Galeano | AP)<br />
Late on the evening on Friday, 25 November,<br />
Cuban President Raúl Castro,<br />
dressed in military fatigues and his<br />
voice cracking with emotion, took to<br />
the island’s state television network to<br />
announce the death of his brother, Fidel.<br />
For nearly six decades, the figure<br />
of Fidel Castro remained omnipresent<br />
on both sides of the Straits of Florida.<br />
In Cuba itself, he was the Maximum<br />
Leader who, after overthrowing dictator<br />
Fulgencio Batista in 1959, fashioned<br />
Cuba into a Communist state and ally<br />
of the Soviet Union. After the latter’s<br />
collapse and the uniquely painful período<br />
especial, Fidel gingerly began a reengagement<br />
process with the rest of the world,<br />
where he continued to play an outsized<br />
role. For his relentless head-butting with<br />
the United States, he was regarded as<br />
a hero by those Latin Americans who<br />
resent the U.S. influence on hemispheric<br />
affairs. In Miami, however, site of the<br />
world’s largest exile Cuban population,<br />
he was regarded less fondly as a dictator.<br />
For many, the preeminent question<br />
now is what effect his passing will have<br />
on the economy of Cuba and its ongoing<br />
rapprochement with the United States.<br />
In this April 19, 2011 file photo, Fidel Castro raises his brother's hand, Cuba's President Raul Castro.<br />
Raul announced Fidel's death late Friday, Nov 25, 2016, on state television.<br />
First and foremost, the death of<br />
Fidel Castro is of enormous symbolic<br />
importance. There has rarely been a<br />
national leader so thoroughly identified<br />
with the country he ruled. His death,<br />
however, is unlikely to have a major<br />
impact of current Cuban economic policies—except<br />
perhaps to accelerate them.<br />
Gravely ill for a decade, Fidel Castro<br />
ceded the day-to-day running of the<br />
country to Raúl in 2008, and the latter<br />
quickly ushered in changes that would<br />
have been all-but-unthinkable under the<br />
long-serving leader. Since then, Raúl<br />
has overseen a dramatic expansion of<br />
the private sector, with a half-million<br />
Cubans now licensed to run small businesses<br />
as independent cuentapropistas,<br />
in professions ranging from mechanics<br />
and barbers to cab drivers and restaurant<br />
operators; in his 2011 policy announcements,<br />
he set a target of transitioning<br />
the nation’s economy from complete<br />
state domination to 40 percent private<br />
enterprise.<br />
There have been numerous other<br />
reforms under Raúl, including the legal<br />
use by Cubans of cellphones and DVDs,<br />
the expansion of foreign investment and<br />
joint ventures, the spread of internet access,<br />
and permission for farmers to form<br />
private coops and to sell excess production<br />
on the open market. Moreover, it<br />
was Raúl who embraced the resumption<br />
of normal relations with the U.S.<br />
government in 2014, which has since<br />
resulted in a dramatic expansion of U.S.<br />
tourism to the island as well as access by<br />
commercial U.S. airlines.<br />
While this economic opening was<br />
being painstakingly shepherded in by<br />
Raúl Castro, Fidel had no hesitation<br />
when it came to questioning the opening<br />
and its motives, and to lob verbal volleys<br />
at President Barrack Obama and those<br />
in favor of injecting limited capitalism<br />
into the Communist model.<br />
Now, with Fidel gone, Raúl may<br />
have considerably more leverage to<br />
push forward with his market-oriented<br />
reforms. Especially in recent years,<br />
Raúl has made no secret of his frustration<br />
with the pace of change. As U.S.<br />
citizens know all too well, entrenched<br />
bureaucracies are resistant to change. In<br />
the case of Cuba, Fidel’s long shadow<br />
was a powerful support to those within<br />
the Cuban government, especially the<br />
18 CUBATRADE DEC 2016
The death of Fidel Castro and the election of Donald Trump:<br />
What they mean for the Cuban economy<br />
By Michael Deibert<br />
old guard, who were opposed to market<br />
reform and a warmer relationship with<br />
Washington. Now, reformers within the<br />
government should gain new traction.<br />
Fidel Castro’s passing, of course,<br />
takes place amid another political<br />
earthquake: The shock of Donald J.<br />
Trump’s victory over Hillary Clinton in<br />
this year’s U.S. presidential race. Though<br />
More than ever now, the<br />
U.S. should continue to<br />
expand its trade relationships<br />
with Cuba and allow<br />
our private sector to play<br />
and important role in<br />
shaping what happens."<br />
Trump spent most of his campaign<br />
declaring his support for lifting the<br />
embargo, in his final weeks of campaigning<br />
he declared that he would<br />
reverse president Obama’s initiatives to<br />
ease restrictions. More recently, Trump’s<br />
appointment to his transition team of<br />
In this November 30, 2009 photo, people walk past a poster of<br />
Fidel Castro on the streets of Old Havana<br />
Mauricio Claver-Carone, viewed as a<br />
hardline opponent of any détente with<br />
the government in Havana, was viewed<br />
as a worrying sign for continuing the<br />
“new approach” fostered by Obama and<br />
Raúl Castro.<br />
Nevertheless, as Raúl Castro enters<br />
the twilight of his political life (he is<br />
85 years old and has said publicly that<br />
he will step down as Cuba’s president<br />
when his current term ends in 2018) and<br />
Trump enters the White House, the<br />
signals are far from universally negative.<br />
With the passing of Fidel, the greatest<br />
political focal point for anti-Castro<br />
politicians and sentiments in the U.S.<br />
disappears, perhaps opening the way for<br />
a more pragmatic and less ideological<br />
dialogue.<br />
On the U.S. side, though many of<br />
Obama’s policy changes came in the<br />
form of executive actions, many of the<br />
most prominent came under the aegis of<br />
regulatory changes, such as allowing direct<br />
commercial flights and easing travel<br />
restrictions. As these changes fall under<br />
the jurisdiction of a host of government<br />
agencies—including the Departments<br />
of Commerce, Transportation and<br />
Treasury—their reversal is not a facile<br />
flick-of-a-pen fait accompli. Add to that<br />
the priorities of a president who ran on<br />
a platform of providing jobs to American<br />
workers, now faced with the task of<br />
reversing the efforts of U.S. businesses<br />
to grow their commercial operations.<br />
And, despite the hostility of some<br />
Republican congressmen and senators<br />
to any normalization of relations with<br />
Cuba, the Republican party is far from<br />
unanimous in its opposition to lifting<br />
the embargo. “With the passing of Fidel<br />
Castro, America now has the opportunity<br />
to help influence the direction<br />
of Cuba in helping lead her people to<br />
a better future,” Rep. Rick Crawford<br />
(R-Arkansas), told Cuba Trade. “More<br />
than ever now, the U.S. should continue<br />
to expand its trade relationships with<br />
Cuba and allow our private sector to<br />
play an important role in shaping what<br />
happens.”<br />
For his part, upon hearing of Castro’s<br />
death, Trump reacted by issuing a<br />
statement saying “Our administration<br />
will do all it can to ensure the Cuban<br />
people can finally begin their journey<br />
toward prosperity and liberty.”<br />
On the Cuban side, Raúl Castro<br />
appears to have groomed Miguel Díaz-<br />
Canel, the 56 year-old vice president<br />
of Cuba’s Consejo de Estado (Council<br />
of State), the 31-member ruling body<br />
of Cuba’s government, to succeed him.<br />
Díaz-Canel, born after the Cuban<br />
revolution, may not command the personal<br />
loyalty and exude the same gravitas<br />
as los hermanos Castro, but it seems<br />
unlikely that Raúl would have chosen<br />
him if he believed he would derail his<br />
reforms.<br />
After a lifetime spent speaking in<br />
public and dominating the thoughts<br />
of his countrymen, Fidel Castro’s exit<br />
was quiet and subdued. Those with an<br />
eye on Cuba, both domestically and<br />
abroad, will now wait to see what this<br />
highly symbolic milestone will mean for<br />
the country and its people. Regardless,<br />
the door that has been cracked open<br />
between Cuba and the United States,<br />
is unlikely to be slammed shut. H<br />
DEC 2016<br />
CUBATRADE<br />
19
REGULATIONS<br />
6<br />
And Now for Round<br />
What the Most Recent Round of Changes<br />
to U.S. Policy with Cuba Mean<br />
By Olga M. Pina and Alex Roe<br />
Since the resumption of relations between the U.S. and Cuba<br />
at the end of 2014, the executive office has issued six rounds of<br />
amendments further implementing a policy of opening trade<br />
and commerce between the two nations as well as promoting<br />
economic reform to grow the private sector in Cuba.<br />
Announced in October by the Office of Foreign Assets<br />
Control (OFAC) and further amending the Cuban Assets<br />
Control Regulations (CACR), these latest changes ease sanctions<br />
related to medicine, trade, investment, travel, humanitarian<br />
activities, and other activities.<br />
The changes continue to chip away at the barriers to commerce<br />
with Cuba and begin to create small openings—the most<br />
publicized being the end of limits to the importation of coveted<br />
Cuban cigars and rum by individual travelers, the most important<br />
being the opening of the U.S. market for the approval and sale of<br />
Cuban pharmaceuticals.<br />
HIGHLIGHTS OF SPECIFIC CHANGES<br />
Healthcare and Medicine<br />
Before the latest amendments, specific<br />
licenses were required for importing<br />
Cuban-origin commodities for research<br />
purposes in sample quantities only. The<br />
new amendments allow collaboration<br />
on medical research, importation of<br />
Cuban-origin pharmaceuticals, and the<br />
maintenance of Cuban bank accounts to<br />
facilitate research.<br />
Particularly noteworthy are changes<br />
allowing Cuban companies to obtain U.S.<br />
Food and Drug Administration (FDA)<br />
approval for Cuban pharmaceuticals—as<br />
well as authorization for the marketing,<br />
sales, and distribution in the U.S. of<br />
Cuban pharmaceuticals approved by the<br />
FDA. U.S. persons engaging in healthcare<br />
and medicince can also open bank<br />
accounts in Cuban financial institutions<br />
for authorized activities.<br />
Export-Related Transactions<br />
Exports (or re-exports originating from a<br />
third country) to Cuba have been expanded<br />
by dropping the requirement that such<br />
exports be “100% U.S.-origin.” Other conditions<br />
still apply to those transactions, including<br />
compliance with the Department<br />
of Commerce's Export Administration<br />
Regulations, limitations on the manner of<br />
payment for agriculture commodities, and<br />
that such transactions are NOT directly<br />
between a U.S.-owned or controlled firm<br />
in a third country and Cuba for commodities<br />
produced outside the U.S.<br />
20 CUBATRADE DEC 2016<br />
Vessel Transactions<br />
Foreign vessels that call on Cuban ports<br />
for trade purposes are no longer prohibited<br />
from entering U.S. ports for a specified<br />
duration, provided that they are carrying<br />
items permitted for sale to Cuba under<br />
the Export Administration Regulations.<br />
Contingent Contracts<br />
U.S. persons can now negotiate and enter<br />
into contingent contracts for transactions<br />
prohibited by CACR—so long as the<br />
execution of the contract is contingent on<br />
authorization being obtained or the transaction<br />
no longer requiring authorization.<br />
Importation of Cuban-Origin Merchandise<br />
The dollar limitation is now lifted on what<br />
U.S. persons can bring back from Cuba as<br />
accompanied baggage, including alcohol<br />
and tobacco products—provided the<br />
goods are for personal use.<br />
Travel<br />
The amendment authorizes U.S. persons<br />
to travel to Cuba for the purposes<br />
of attending or organizing professional<br />
meetings or conferences, and removes<br />
the requirement that the purpose of the<br />
professional meeting or conference not be<br />
for the promotion of tourism in Cuba.<br />
Remittances<br />
U.S. persons are now authorized to make<br />
remittances to third-country nationals so<br />
they can travel to, from, and within Cuba,<br />
provided that such travel would be authorized<br />
by a general license if the traveler<br />
were a U.S. person.<br />
Grants, Scholarships, and Awards<br />
OFAC added scientific research and<br />
religious activities to the categories of activities<br />
for which grants to Cuba or Cuban<br />
nationals are authorized.<br />
Services Related to Cuban Infrastructure<br />
U.S. persons are now authorized to<br />
provide Cuba or Cuban nationals with<br />
services related to developing, repairing,<br />
maintaining, and enhancing Cuban infrastructure,<br />
so long as they are authorized by<br />
the Department of Commerce.<br />
Other Amendments<br />
The definitions of prohibited officials of<br />
the Government of Cuba and prohibited<br />
members of the Cuban Communist<br />
Party have been narrowed, including for<br />
contracts, gifts and remittances. H<br />
Olga M. Pina is a partner in the Miami-based law<br />
firm Shutts & Bowen. Along with senior attorney<br />
M. Alex Roe, Pina is in charge of the Cuba practice<br />
at the firm.
TOURISM<br />
ONE IF BY SEA<br />
Only one U.S. cruise line has tested the<br />
water so far, but others are ready to go<br />
By Carlos Harrison<br />
22 CUBATRADE DEC 2016
Residents of Havana gave a warm welcome to the cruise ship Adonia<br />
<strong>One</strong> of the iconic moments of rapprochement<br />
between the U.S. and Cuba came<br />
last May, when the 704-passenger ship<br />
Adonia made port in Havana. As passengers<br />
disembarked, they were warmly welcomed<br />
by throngs of Cuban citizens, and<br />
hopes were high that the landfall augured<br />
a new era of seaborne tourists visiting not<br />
only Havana, but other ports of call such<br />
as Cienfuegos and Santiago.<br />
Flash forward six months, and Fathom,<br />
the Carnival Cruise Line subsidiary<br />
that embarked the Adonia from Miami,<br />
has now made a dozen fully-booked trips<br />
to Cuba. “Cuba as a destination holds<br />
great potential for Fathom since there is<br />
so much pent up demand to travel [there]<br />
from the U.S.,” says Tara Russell, President<br />
of Fathom. Nonetheless, it sails alone,<br />
at least from the U.S.<br />
Despite their eagerness to flood a<br />
nearly virgin market, however, none of<br />
the other cruise lines clamoring to carry<br />
Americans directly from ports in the<br />
United States to the once-forbidden<br />
island of Cuba have received permission<br />
from the Cuban government. “It’s clearly<br />
evident that the Cubans are not rushing<br />
into this,” says cruise industry expert<br />
Stewart Chiron. “They’ll do as much or<br />
as little as they want, and they don’t care<br />
what anybody thinks. They’re going to<br />
re-engage the world at their pace.”<br />
After Fathom’s maiden voyage other<br />
major cruise companies, including Royal<br />
Caribbean International and Norwegian<br />
Cruise Line, announced plans to follow<br />
suit –– only to pull back after failing to get<br />
the necessary permits.<br />
The month after Adonia’s first sailing,<br />
Royal Caribbean’s CEO said his lines’ trips<br />
could begin as early as July. It brought the<br />
1,840-passenger Empress of the Seas back<br />
from its Spanish subsidiary and reportedly<br />
spent $50 million refurbishing the ship for<br />
Miami-Havana voyages.<br />
At the end of July, it pushed bookings<br />
back to the end of October. “This is the<br />
right sized vessel for Cuba, and our intention<br />
is someday we will be going there,”<br />
Vicki Freed, Royal Caribbean's senior<br />
vice president for sales, trade services and<br />
support, said at the time. “We’re just still<br />
waiting for the nod.”<br />
Norwegian has been in the same<br />
boat. “I’m literally waiting for the phone<br />
to ring to get the final, final approval<br />
from the Cuban government,” company<br />
CEO Frank Del Rio said in July. But<br />
as of November, itineraries showed the<br />
Regatta, the ship it slotted for the Cuba<br />
trips, still floating around the island’s<br />
eastern end on a Puerto Rico, Grenada,<br />
St. Barts-plus voyage.<br />
“I’ve been writing about the cruise<br />
industry for 35, 40 years,” says U.K.-<br />
based industry analyst Tony Peisley. “For<br />
the entire 40 years, U.S. lines have been<br />
waiting for Cuba to open up. It would give<br />
such a huge boost to their business in the<br />
Caribbean.” It would also give a boost to<br />
tourism in Cuba, which has become a top<br />
priority for the Cuban government. And<br />
while cruise passengers typically spend less<br />
than land-based travelers, the cruise ships<br />
temporarily solve one of the bottle necks<br />
for the tourist sector—not enough hotel<br />
rooms to meet the demand.<br />
<strong>One</strong> reason Cuba may be holding<br />
back on allowing more cruises is for prac-<br />
Continued on page 25<br />
DEC 2016<br />
CUBATRADE<br />
23
TECH<br />
They could send emails and<br />
receive emails, but they<br />
couldn’t access the web…”<br />
Salvi Pascual, the founder of Apretaste<br />
Photo by Matias J. Ocner<br />
TAKING THE PULSE OF THE<br />
CUBAN MARKET<br />
A workaround of Cuba’s internet limitations<br />
is paving the way for precious market research<br />
By Nick Swyter<br />
<strong>One</strong> handicap that prospective investors<br />
in Cuba have is difficulty conducting<br />
consumer surveys. Now, a small Miami<br />
startup has market research based on<br />
thousands of Cubans who share their<br />
opinions on everything from the economy<br />
to the quality of high school education.<br />
That may not be noteworthy by American<br />
standards, but to gather this information<br />
the startup wiggled its way through Cuba’s<br />
spotty internet connectivity.<br />
Apretaste collects online survey<br />
responses through an app that now has<br />
24 CUBATRADE DEC 2016<br />
more than 42,000 users; Cubans use the<br />
app because it allows them to surf the web<br />
via email. Among other things Cubans<br />
use the app to check the weather, read<br />
news, and even find dates. Salvi Pascual,<br />
the founder of Apretaste, says he built the<br />
app knowing that most Cubans—stymied<br />
by high prices, slow connectivity and<br />
government regulations—use the internet<br />
only for email.<br />
“They could send emails and receive<br />
emails, but they couldn’t access the web.<br />
So I built a platform where they can interact<br />
with the web by using their email,”<br />
Pascual told Cuba Trade.<br />
Here’s how the app works: Users write<br />
a command and a search term in the subject<br />
line of an email to apretaste@apretaste.<br />
com. For example, to do a Google search<br />
on Havana, users send an email with<br />
“google la habana” written in the subject<br />
line. In return, Apretaste sends back a message<br />
with the results of a Google search on<br />
Havana.<br />
By creating Apretaste, Pascual found<br />
a clever solution to connectivity issues. He
also found a clever way to connect to<br />
citizens. In early 2016, Pascual sent questionnaires<br />
on everything from his social<br />
networking platform to how many times<br />
a month blackouts happen. Within a few<br />
days, he had hundreds of responses.<br />
The results offer a rare data-focused<br />
examination of daily life on the island.<br />
They say how many Cubans are likely to<br />
have bank accounts and what kinds of<br />
goods they would like imported into the<br />
country, with data broken down by age, sex<br />
and province.<br />
“It’s really hard to get representative<br />
samples based on the traditional means,<br />
because Cubans don’t have cell phones or<br />
telephones in a systematic way,” said Ted<br />
Henken, a Baruch College professor who<br />
specializes in entrepreneurship in Cuba.<br />
Now, Pascual hopes businesses<br />
and organizations eyeing Cuba will use<br />
Apretaste to conduct market research.<br />
“They need more information in order to<br />
minimize risk,” he said.<br />
Of course, like all surveys, Apretaste’s<br />
approach has its drawbacks. Pascual and<br />
his team are limited to the 42,000 Cubans<br />
who use the app, only a small portion of<br />
the population that uses email. The app<br />
may also need to re-invent itself if the<br />
government adds more wi-fi hotspots and<br />
lowers the prohibitive $2 per hour price of<br />
using the web.<br />
Despite its drawbacks, Pascual is<br />
confident Apretaste can offer organizations<br />
information they can’t get elsewhere;<br />
his questionnaires reach every province<br />
of Cuba, including the isolated Isla de<br />
Juventud. They also don’t require approval<br />
from the Cuban government, a process<br />
that consistently bogs down expensive and<br />
time-consuming field research.<br />
“Even if there are obstacles, this is<br />
one of the few ways to get information,”<br />
Henken said. “Like they say: in the land of<br />
the blind, the one-eyed man is king.” H<br />
Amplifying mobile phone access<br />
Continued from page 23<br />
tical reasons of capacity. A tunnel under<br />
Havana harbor, for example, limits the<br />
draft of entering vessels. And the longest<br />
of three berths in the port terminal<br />
building is only able to handle a 662-foot<br />
boat. That means it can only fit smaller<br />
cruise ships, such as Fathom’s Adonia or<br />
Norwegian’s (actually Norwegian subsidiary<br />
Oceania Cruise’s) Regatta.<br />
That means bigger ships, like Royal<br />
Caribbean’s nearly 1,200-foot-long<br />
Oasis-class ships or Carnival’s 1,000-footplus<br />
Dream-class, would have to, at best,<br />
anchor off shore and transport passengers<br />
to the city and back on tenders.<br />
“You’d have to have an infrastructure<br />
for all kinds of things,” says Peisley. “It’s<br />
not just being at the dock, it’s what are you<br />
going to do with all the passengers when<br />
they get off. You’ve got 6,000 passengers<br />
getting off, where are they going to go?<br />
How are you going to look after them?<br />
None of that is really there. You don’t have<br />
enough guides, taxis, people to take the<br />
tourists around.”<br />
<strong>One</strong> U.S.-based company,<br />
InsightCuba found a way to deal with<br />
the limitations of Cuba’s ports, and<br />
turned it into a unique offering. It uses<br />
two smaller, luxury vessels: A 177-foot<br />
sailboat that can carry 42 passengers,<br />
and a multi-level megayacht with room<br />
for 72. Capitalizing on the ships’ smaller<br />
dimensions, Insight takes Americans<br />
to ports the larger ships can’t reach,<br />
with stops at places such as Isla de la<br />
Juventud, Trinidad, Cayo Largo, and<br />
Maria La Gorda.<br />
The ships, however, don’t depart<br />
The Adonia passes Moro Castle at the entrance to Havana Harbor<br />
from or return to U.S. ports. Travelers<br />
must meet the boats in Cienfuegos,<br />
Cuba. In the end, what will be required<br />
is investment in port infrastructure,<br />
something that can’t come fast enough<br />
for U.S. cruise lines. “In my opinion,<br />
Cuba is still failing to hear from international<br />
investors that in business time<br />
is money,” says Teo Babun, president<br />
and CEO of consulting firm Cuba-<br />
Caribbean Development. H<br />
DEC 2016<br />
CUBATRADE<br />
25
BIOMED<br />
A New Global<br />
Footprint for<br />
CUBA BIOMED<br />
There isn’t another product in<br />
the world that is as effective<br />
as Heberprot-P. It is unique.<br />
Jorge Valdéz Hernandez<br />
New regulations mean<br />
Cuban drugs can be<br />
tested and imported.<br />
Diabetes, hepatitis and<br />
cancer medicines could<br />
be among the first<br />
By Michael Deibert<br />
Photo by Nick Swyter<br />
In a semi-rural suburb of Havana, where<br />
cows graze dozily by the roadside, a<br />
complex of nondescript buildings houses<br />
Cuba’s Centro de Ingeniería Genética y<br />
Biotecnología, the nation’s most important<br />
facility for medical research and production.<br />
The biotechnological and pharmaceutical<br />
group, known universally by its<br />
acronym CIGB, is the largest subsidiary<br />
of the state-run BioCubaFarma, created<br />
four years ago; it currently oversees 31<br />
companies and 64 manufacturing facilities<br />
around the island.<br />
Until 1990, the country’s biomedical<br />
industry concentrated largely on producing<br />
cheap domestic knockoffs of existing<br />
products. After the collapse of the Soviet<br />
Union, however, an increased need for<br />
economic diversification prompted an<br />
aggressive push by Cuba to modernize its<br />
biotech industry.<br />
With manufacturing facilities in the<br />
Zona Especial de Desarrollo Mariel west<br />
of Havana, BioCubaFarma currently<br />
produces around 1,000 products sold in<br />
48 countries and has 2,000 patents and<br />
technology transfer agreements granted in<br />
a variety of nations including Brazil, India,<br />
Venezuela, and Vietnam. Now the group<br />
is seeking to expand into heavily-regulated<br />
markets such as the United States, Canada,<br />
Europe, and Japan.<br />
26 CUBATRADE DEC 2016<br />
<strong>One</strong> of CIGB’s flagship medications<br />
is a breakthrough treatment for diabetes<br />
called Heberprot-P, which thus far has<br />
treated tens of thousands diabetic-foot<br />
patients in 26 countries and is in trials in<br />
Europe, where it is known as Epiprot. Trials<br />
to date suggest the drug can reduce the<br />
risk of amputation––an all-too common<br />
problem with diabetes––by up to<br />
75 percent.<br />
“It is a unique global product that has<br />
been proven to be very safe and effective,”<br />
Jorge Valdéz Hernandez, the CIGB’s<br />
vice director, told Cuba Trade during a<br />
recent interview in Havana. As he spoke<br />
in the facility’s conference room, a wall of<br />
monitors broadcasted video of workers in<br />
biohazard suits moving materials around.<br />
“It has been used on more than<br />
50,000 patients in Cuba, and more than<br />
250,000 patients on the international<br />
level,” he said. “Out of 1,000 patients that<br />
are treated, more than 750 won’t need<br />
amputation. There isn’t another product<br />
in the world that is as effective as Heberprot-P.<br />
It is unique.”<br />
Another of the CIGB’s high-profile<br />
endeavors is its partnership with French<br />
venture capital firm Truffle Capital, with<br />
which they formed Paris-based ABIVAX<br />
in an attempt to become a global leader in<br />
therapeutic vaccines and antivirals. Thus far<br />
their most promising product is NASVAC,<br />
a medicine designed to combat hepatitis<br />
B. “At this moment [NASVAC] is being<br />
coordinated for Phase 3 clinical trials in<br />
Europe,” says Valdéz. “Conversations are also<br />
being conducted with different American<br />
companies for the possible introduction of<br />
the product to the United States.”<br />
Other projects in the development<br />
stage by BioCubaFarma include CIGB<br />
500, a medicine designed for the treatment<br />
of heart attacks, as well as Heberferon,<br />
an injectable skin cancer medication<br />
that researchers hope will reduce tumors.<br />
Until recently, these and other drugs<br />
produced by Cuba’s biopharmaceutical<br />
industry have been off limits for U.S.<br />
patients. In its most recent round of regulatory<br />
changes, however, the U.S. Office<br />
of Foreign Assets Control announced<br />
that Cuban-origin pharmaceuticals could<br />
be put through FDA trials for approval,<br />
importation, and sale in the U.S.<br />
“This is very significant,” says Olga<br />
M. Pina, a partner in the Tampa office of<br />
Shutts & Bowen LLP. “It allows revenues<br />
to be produced for Cuba via exports [to the<br />
U.S.]. It could potentially be a big revenue<br />
source for them.” CIMAvax, a lung cancer<br />
drug developed by CIGB’s sister organization<br />
Centro de Immunologia Molecular, is<br />
already being tested in the U.S. H
Doing Business in Cuba - Market Entry - Partner and Joint Venture Development<br />
CUBA OPPORTUNITIES<br />
In-country executive visits with<br />
investment and partners meetings<br />
CUBA BUSINESS STRATEGY<br />
Consultation on industry targets in the<br />
newest emerging market of Cuba<br />
CUBA IMPLEMENTATION<br />
Set-up, legal processes, and<br />
business development in Cuba<br />
Kruger International, LLC is a Cuba consulting firm providing market research, sales channel<br />
execution, B2B in-country trips, and investment services for Cuba. Judy Kruger is Principal at<br />
Kruger International. Her clients range from small family-owned companies to multi-national<br />
firms who are eager to capture business in a new exciting emerging market.<br />
Judy Kruger<br />
Phone: 616-450-6925<br />
Email: Jkruger@kruger-international.com<br />
Website: www.kruger-international.com<br />
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/judykruger
ENERGY<br />
ALTERNATIVE ENERGY FOR CUBA<br />
With limited oil production, the nation looks<br />
to renewable sources to energize its grid<br />
By Victoria Mckenzie<br />
Photos by Thos Robinson<br />
This fall the “Energizing Cuba”<br />
conference, sponsored by the America’s<br />
Society and the Council of the America’s<br />
Cuba Working Group, was held in New<br />
York. The conference, a gathering of<br />
intellectual and economic luminaries,<br />
provided a detailed snapshot of the more<br />
than $4.2 billion in foreign investments<br />
Cuba is soliciting in the wind, solar,<br />
and bioelectric fields to modernize the<br />
country’s energy sector. Here are some of<br />
the insights from the conference.<br />
and this will be especially important as the<br />
country goes through energy shortages, a<br />
changing relationship with Venezuela, and<br />
a contracting economy. Of course, I think<br />
the elephant in the room is that…We<br />
still have our U.S. embargo towards Cuba.<br />
So that has implications not only for the<br />
energy sector, but also for the financing<br />
that is needed for these crucial energy<br />
projects. And so despite some regulatory<br />
loosening in this area, I think the embargo<br />
is obviously something important that we<br />
also need to keep in mind.”<br />
This is a problem, and we need to change<br />
it. The renewable energy sources only have<br />
4.5 percent [of the energy sector]. This is<br />
very low. The problem is trying to change<br />
this number… At this moment we have<br />
4.5 percent, but, in 14 years, we [hope to]<br />
multiply this number by 6, obtaining 24<br />
percent."<br />
Alana Tummino, Director of the Cuba<br />
Working group, AS/COA:<br />
“Cuba’s priority will be to raise foreign<br />
investment for these different ventures,<br />
Dr. Antonio Sarmiento Sera, Professor,<br />
Center for the Study of Renewable<br />
Energy Technologies (CETER), Higher<br />
Polytechnic University of Havana:<br />
“Ninety five percent of [Cuba’s] electricity<br />
comes from oil… and this oil comes<br />
half from Cuban oil and half from other<br />
countries [Ed. note: Cuba’s main supplier<br />
of oil is Venezuela’s Petróleos de Venezuela,<br />
S.A. (PDVSA) which has reduced exports<br />
to Cuba by at least 40 percent this year.]<br />
Carlos Fernandez-Avalli, Chief Strategy<br />
Officer, Cuba Strategies Inc.:<br />
“Cuba expects to have 780 megawatts in<br />
the next 14 years, and I think it set the<br />
pace for 14 years because they wanted<br />
to be realistic. If they can do it in three,<br />
they’d also be happy, because these<br />
28 CUBATRADE DEC 2016
investments correspond to what the<br />
grid can physically incorporate without<br />
becoming unstable. They said, ‘If we don’t<br />
have to change anything in the grid today,<br />
what is the renewable energy input that<br />
we can incorporate?’ And that has been<br />
one of the main criteria in establishing<br />
the 24 percent figure… The current<br />
installed capacity in Cuba for wind is 12<br />
megawatts, but there is a national wind<br />
energy program, so Cuba is out there<br />
buying wind turbines and developing<br />
projects…. They’ve awarded 322<br />
megawatts already to foreign investment<br />
projects, and there’s another 295<br />
megawatts to be awarded. This is the size<br />
of the already available opportunity since<br />
what was published in [the investment]<br />
portfolio in 2015… so in a way there’s a<br />
sense of urgency for those who want to<br />
use the Cuban opportunity….”<br />
A<br />
COUNTRY<br />
OF<br />
ELECTRIC<br />
ISLANDS<br />
An interview with CETER’s<br />
Dr. Antonio Sarmiento Sera<br />
Jorge R. Piñon, Director, Latin America<br />
and Caribbean Energy Program, University<br />
of Texas at Austin:<br />
“Energy is the engine of growth as far as<br />
the Cuban economy is concerned…We<br />
have to talk about energy security, we have<br />
to talk about energy reliability, we have to<br />
talk about efficiency, we have to talk about<br />
clean and sustainable energy, we have to<br />
talk about conservation––which by the<br />
way is a huge job that Cuba has done beginning<br />
in 2005. If there’s a country that’s<br />
conscious about savings and conservation<br />
of energy, it’s Cuba. Let’s hope that as the<br />
economy grows we can maintain that level<br />
of consciousness…We’re talking about<br />
secure, reliable, efficient, clean, sustainable,<br />
conservative, and competitively priced<br />
economy…Today Cuba consumes 140,000<br />
barrels a day of petroleum products, and<br />
68 percent of these petroleum products are<br />
heavy fuel oil, with 3.5 percent Sulphur,<br />
which is a very high pollutant…” H<br />
While at the Energizing Cuba conference in New York, Cuba Trade had the opportunity to<br />
speak with one of Cuba’s leading experts in the field of solar energy, Dr. Antonio Sarmiento<br />
Sera, professor at the Center for the Study of Renewable Energy Technologies (CETER) and<br />
member of the National Renewable Energy Group. CETER is one of at least a dozen working<br />
groups formed in Cuba following the Soviet collapse, when severe energy shortages spurred<br />
development of a National Energies Development Program and research into wind, solar, and<br />
bioelectric energy sources.<br />
“The CETER was created 24 years ago, and it came to be a center of research inside the<br />
Polytechnic University of Havana, dedicated to studies of new technology, especially renewable<br />
energy,” Sarmiento explained. “Because the oil that came from Russia had disappeared.”<br />
<strong>One</strong> of several institutions that has worked on the national development plan for Cuba’s<br />
renewable energy sector, CETER established a target of 24 percent inputs from renewables by<br />
2030, up from the current contribution of 4.5 percent.<br />
“[First we had to] calculate how much more energy we’ll need in 14 years,” says Sarmiento.<br />
“We’re going to have more industry, more tourism, more consumption, so we’ll need 30 percent<br />
more energy. The 24 percent attempts to meet that increase. If we need more energy, is<br />
the solution to look for more oil? No, we’ll look for more renewable energy, reduce [reliance<br />
on] oil, and improve efficiency.”<br />
Two of CETER’s most prominent programs involve solar (especially low-cost solar panels) and<br />
wind energy. Both have their advantages. While sun is available everywhere it “never lasts more<br />
than half a day,” says Sarmiento. Wind power is not limited to daylight hours, but is feasible<br />
only in the northeast of Cuba. The key strategy, says Sarmiento, is to patch the island’s relatively<br />
fragile power situation by decentralizing Cuba’s energy grid.<br />
“Sometimes, hurricanes would knock down the energy towers, and it could take days to fix.<br />
We’d be without electricity for a week,” he says. “The idea is to divide the territory into<br />
sections—here, have a plant that serves this region, here, a plant that serves a different region—<br />
to make 15 Cubas! Each province has the capability of working in isolation. We’re creating a<br />
country made up of electric islands, so that every section has independent energy.” H<br />
DEC 2016<br />
CUBATRADE<br />
29
RECREATION<br />
Racing to Cuba<br />
Photos Courtesy of Conch Republic Cup<br />
In the wake of last year’s exemptions for U.S.<br />
sporting events in Cuba, Florida regattas have<br />
resumed their yacht races to the island.<br />
By Doreen Hemlock<br />
Yachts from Key West approach the northern coast<br />
of Cuba during the Conch Republic Cup<br />
When Karen Angle sailed from Key<br />
West to Cuba’s resort city of Varadero in<br />
January, she wasn’t expecting what she<br />
found: A modern marina with quality<br />
docks, consistent electricity and water<br />
service, internet availability, and nearby<br />
hotels with rooms decked out in marble<br />
and stainless steel.<br />
Not every marina that Angle visited<br />
on her first trip to Cuba was quite so<br />
Karen Angle, executive director of<br />
the Conch Republic Cup<br />
up-to-date, yet overall, “the infrastructure<br />
was, amazingly, pretty good,” said the avid<br />
sailor. “It was far more advanced than I<br />
anticipated.”<br />
A forbidden destination for decades,<br />
the Caribbean’s largest island now is capturing<br />
the attention of the U.S. yachting<br />
community. New rules under the Obama<br />
administration eased maritime visits in<br />
September of last year, and U.S. ventures<br />
from racing groups to marina consultants<br />
are starting to tap the once off-limits<br />
market.<br />
Angle took part in the largest sailing<br />
race between the United States and<br />
Cuba since Obama liberalized yachting<br />
rules: The Conch Republic Cup. A Key<br />
West couple started the race in 1997<br />
without U.S. government approval and<br />
the venture was stopped under the Bush<br />
administration (they were arrested but the<br />
case was later dropped). Now authorized<br />
under rules that permit visits to Cuba for<br />
sporting events, the 2016 race featured<br />
60 boats with 435 people from some 25<br />
states and five countries––its biggest tally<br />
yet, said Angle, executive director for the<br />
organizing group.<br />
The Conch Republic Cup stopped<br />
first in the northern tourist hub of<br />
Varadero, where Cuba’s state company<br />
Gaviota recently built a new marina with<br />
French assistance, slated to top 1,000 slips.<br />
Next, the racers docked outside Havana<br />
at the iconic Hemingway Marina, built in<br />
the 1950s and now upgrading facilities for<br />
some 400 berths.<br />
In all, Cuba today still has fewer than<br />
2,000 slips at some 15 marinas, a small<br />
number by Caribbean standards, according<br />
to marina consultants. But the island<br />
has big plans to add another 20 marinas<br />
and at least 5,000 slips—including more<br />
berths in Varadero.<br />
That expansion will require significant<br />
foreign investment, but many investors<br />
are waiting first for Washington to end its<br />
embargo on Cuba. They want to make sure<br />
that in the long-term, Americans will be<br />
able to travel freely to Cuba, since visitors<br />
from the neighboring USA are sure to be<br />
the biggest source of traffic.<br />
There’s no denying the potential for<br />
U.S. boating. In addition to the Conch<br />
Republic Cup, regattas to Cuba in the past<br />
year have included races from Sarasota and<br />
30 CUBATRADE DEC 2016
THE VIP GUIDE<br />
Modern Facilities: The new 1,000-slip Marina Varadero<br />
In Poppa’s Shadow: At rest in Marina Hemmingway, just outside of Havana<br />
As soon as President Obama liberalized<br />
U.S. ties with Cuba, Maria Romeu saw<br />
her niche: Arranging yacht trips.<br />
Active with Cuba since the 1970s in<br />
cultural exchanges (including visits by Cuban<br />
bands to the U.S.), Cuban-American entrepreneur<br />
Maria Romeu had a strong network<br />
of contacts in her native land. In recent years<br />
she’d also built a solid base in yachting, serving<br />
first as assistant manager of a Miami Beach<br />
marina and then as crew on mega-yachts.<br />
Romeu immediately sensed the potential and<br />
flew to the island, met with yachting leaders,<br />
and within months partnered with specialist<br />
agency Cuba Tours and Travel to launch her<br />
new venture, Cuba VIP Yachts.<br />
In June, she welcomed her first client in<br />
Cuba: A U.S. family on a 147-foot yacht. The<br />
family flew to an airport in southern Cuba,<br />
met their boat there and enjoyed scuba-diving<br />
around the island, among other activities.<br />
Since then, Cuba VIP Yachts has welcomed<br />
vessels at marinas across the island, arranging<br />
for guests to partake in everything from<br />
swimming with dolphins to touring Havana in<br />
a 1950s convertible.<br />
Romeu’s VIP services don’t come cheap.<br />
They can run $2,000 to $5,000 per person<br />
per week, including meals, ground transport,<br />
lodging and special entry to museums, night<br />
clubs, shows and other spots in Cuba, like the<br />
restaurant San Cristobal where the Obamas<br />
dined. And that doesn’t include the cost of the<br />
yacht, should guests charter one instead of<br />
bringing their own.<br />
“This is a brand new market in Cuba,”<br />
Romeu says. “And with the right people on<br />
the ground, it can really take off.” H<br />
Miami. The St. Petersburg Yacht Club<br />
announced that it will resume its annual<br />
regatta to Havana in February 2017. The<br />
284-mile run from St. Pete to Morro<br />
Castle in Havana Bay originally ran from<br />
1930 to 1959. It aims to top the Conch<br />
Cup, with 70 sailboats participating.<br />
The regattas are just the tip of the<br />
iceberg, however. A University of Florida<br />
study estimates that 60,000 U.S. vessels<br />
over 25-feet long would visit Cuba in the<br />
first year after restrictions are fully lifted.<br />
(As recently as 2010, Cuba welcomed<br />
only about 2,000 foreign pleasure boats<br />
from all nations, officials said.)<br />
Already, Jose Miguel Diaz Escrich,<br />
the commodore of the yacht club at the<br />
Hemingway Marina in Havana, can<br />
quantify the impact of looser U.S. boating<br />
rules. He told Cuban media that in the<br />
first half of this year, membership at the<br />
Hemingway yacht club jumped by 195,<br />
including 164 new members from the<br />
United States.<br />
“Once this travel embargo is finished,<br />
it’s going to be a madhouse,” says marina<br />
consultant Richard Graves of Fort<br />
Lauderdale after a recent visit to the<br />
island. “There won’t be enough marinas to<br />
handle all the boats that are going to go<br />
to Cuba. And it will put a dent in boating<br />
in the Bahamas.” H<br />
Cuban VIP Yachts founder Maria Romeu<br />
Photo courtesy of Cuba VIP Yachts<br />
DEC 2016<br />
CUBATRADE<br />
31
BANKING<br />
For Americans who<br />
visit Cuba, cash has<br />
been a requisite. That<br />
is now changing, as<br />
credit cards begin to<br />
be accepted.<br />
CARD PLAY<br />
By J.P. Faber<br />
Prior to June of 2016, no credit cards<br />
issued by U.S. banks were accepted in<br />
Cuba. That was when the president and<br />
CEO of Florida-based Stonegate Bank,<br />
David Seleski, decided to become the first.<br />
“We’ve had about 750 people sign up for<br />
the card since then,” says the banker. “We<br />
did it as a convenience for our customers,<br />
and because it saves money when you<br />
make cash withdrawals in Cuba. But I had<br />
no idea of the reaction to come.”<br />
As the pioneer U.S. bank with credit<br />
cards usable in Cuba, Seleski became an<br />
overnight media celebrity, at least in the<br />
business world, with reports appearing<br />
everywhere from the Wall Street Journal<br />
and the New York Times to Forbes and<br />
CNBC. “We were getting phone calls<br />
left and right and media requests from<br />
everywhere. I don’t think anybody really<br />
anticipated Cuba being such a hot commodity.”<br />
In addition to being able to use the<br />
cards at an estimated 10,000 points of sale<br />
on the island, including major hotels and<br />
hotel restaurants, the Stonegate Master<br />
Cards can be used to withdraw cash—in<br />
Cuban currency—at ATMs in Havana.<br />
“There is still going to be a service fee of<br />
a few dollars, but you don’t have to pay<br />
the 10 percent,” says Seleski. As travelers<br />
to Cuba know, when you exchange U.S.<br />
dollars for Cuban CUCs, a 10 percent<br />
charge is taken off the top; this is the<br />
government’s fee for the expense of having<br />
32 CUBATRADE DEC 2016<br />
I think we need<br />
more banks to get<br />
involved. It’s not<br />
healthy to have<br />
one bank that’s<br />
doing most of the<br />
heavy lifting...<br />
David Seleski,<br />
CEO of Stonegate<br />
to use foreign banks to deposit the dollars,<br />
since the U.S. Treasury Department will<br />
not allow Cuban banks to have accounts<br />
with U.S. financial institutions.<br />
“We still can’t send those dollars outside,<br />
we can’t use them for our payments<br />
and we can’t even change them to another<br />
currency,” Irma Martínez Castrillón, First<br />
Vice President, Central Bank of Cuba,<br />
explained at a recent U.S. Chamber of<br />
Commerce conference in New York. “For<br />
that reason alone our country has implemented<br />
the 10 percent [penalty on dollar<br />
exchanges].” Thanks to its direct—albeit<br />
one way—relationship with Cuba’s Banco<br />
Internacional de Comercio, however,<br />
Stonegate is able to avoid those charges.<br />
The good news is that Stonegate<br />
Bank no longer has to stand alone. In<br />
August, Banco Popular of Puerto Rico<br />
began issuing MasterCards that work in<br />
Cuba, with Florida-based Natbank (the<br />
U.S. subsidiary of parent National Bank of<br />
Canada) following suit in October. Even<br />
more significantly, predictions are that JP<br />
Morgan Chase, Citibank, Bank of America,<br />
and American Express will authorize<br />
their cards for use in Cuba by the end of<br />
this year, says John Kavulich, president<br />
Continued on page 35<br />
Photo by Matias J. Ocner
SCIENCE<br />
Swimming with the<br />
(Cuban) sharks<br />
The key to protecting Florida’s<br />
sharks may lie in Cuban waters<br />
By Nick Swyter<br />
Photo by Noel Lopez Fernandez<br />
Caribbean reef sharks swim in Cuba's Gardens of the Queen<br />
<strong>One</strong> of the attractions for tourists<br />
traveling to Cuba is the island’s pristine<br />
coastline, largely unscathed by the kind<br />
of development that nearby Florida has<br />
witnessed. Marine life in Cuban waters<br />
has flourished, including the ocean’s apex<br />
predator, the shark.<br />
Now Cuban and U.S. marine scientists<br />
are working together to conserve these<br />
hunters and their ecosystems, which are<br />
expecting strains from the influx of visitors<br />
and doubled-down efforts to find domestic<br />
oil reserves. According to the Environmental<br />
Defense Fund (EDF), some shark<br />
populations have declined by as much as<br />
90 percent of their original levels.<br />
Dan Whittle, Senior Director of the<br />
EDF’s Cuba Program, has been preparing<br />
for these threats for the last 16 years.<br />
He says about 20 percent of the world’s<br />
shark species live in or near Cuban waters.<br />
Long before the U.S. and Cuba restored<br />
diplomatic relations in 2014, Whittle was<br />
working under a Treasury Department<br />
license to team up with Cuban scientists<br />
for shark protection in the Florida Straits<br />
and the Gulf of Mexico.<br />
“Neither country working alone can<br />
sustain these migratory shark species,”<br />
Whittle said, which move freely across<br />
the Florida Straits and beyond, playing an<br />
important role as top predator in Cuban<br />
and American waters.<br />
Whittle is optimistic that Cuba can<br />
strike a balance between conservation and<br />
economic development. In 2015, the EDF<br />
helped Cuba finalize a national action<br />
plan to conserve sharks. The plan calls on<br />
scientists to track migration patterns and<br />
identify breeding areas. It also calls on<br />
fishermen to scale back shark fishing on<br />
vulnerable species and keep a detailed list<br />
of their catches.<br />
“We see good numbers of sharks in<br />
these places,” said Robert Hueter, senior<br />
Cuban and American scientists prepare to measure and tag a hammerhead shark<br />
in the Gulf of Babatano, Cuba<br />
Photo by Valerie Miller<br />
34 CUBATRADE DEC 2016
esearcher at the Mote Marine Laboratory<br />
in Sarasota, Florida. “They remind me of<br />
the places I dived in the 1970s.”<br />
For Hueter, Cuba is a fresh slate for<br />
conservation. With a national plan in<br />
effect, the country has a shot at addressing<br />
environmental threats before they become<br />
irreversible. “We have a really good<br />
opportunity to get things right, instead<br />
of waiting for things to collapse and then<br />
fix it,” he said. “It’s almost like going back<br />
in time and fixing all the things we know<br />
will break down.”<br />
Even though U.S.-Cuba science<br />
exchanges are loaded with logistical challenges,<br />
each exchange is another opportunity<br />
to further train Cuban scientists while<br />
giving Americans access to rare pristine<br />
ecosystems.<br />
“We really value the collaboration and<br />
cooperation from other institutions,” said<br />
Jorge Angulo Valdes, a University of Havana<br />
marine scientist and visiting scholar<br />
at the University of Florida. “It is in the<br />
best interest of both countries to preserve<br />
the resources for our people.” H<br />
Cuban and American scientists discuss shark monitoring strategy during a scientific exchange in Cuba<br />
Photo by Kendra Karr<br />
Continued from page 32<br />
of the U.S.-Cuba Trade and Economic<br />
Council, Inc. “The change is being driven<br />
by the airlines [many now authorized to<br />
make direct flights], because they have<br />
so many transaction-based operational<br />
issues,” he says.<br />
Seleski welcomes the additional players.<br />
“I think we need more banks to get<br />
involved. It’s not healthy to have one bank<br />
that’s doing most of the heavy lifting,” says<br />
the CEO of Stonegate, which has also<br />
issued more than 100 debit cards that can<br />
be used in Cuba. “I think a lot of people<br />
wanted to see how successful we were with<br />
it and see if there were any issues.”<br />
Those ‘issues’ include a few minor inconveniences.<br />
To be able to use the cards<br />
in Cuba, for example, Bank customers<br />
must sign a form affirming that they fall<br />
into one of the 12 categories the United<br />
States authorizes for travel there.<br />
There is also an absence in Cuba of<br />
the omnipresent retail credit card culture<br />
you find in the U.S. and Europe. While<br />
Seleski says that “there are a lot more<br />
ATMs in Havana than you would think,”<br />
for the time being it will be primarily<br />
mainstream hotels and restaurants accepting<br />
the card. Smaller retailers prefer to<br />
accept payments in cash.<br />
Even the higher end hotels in Havana<br />
are still adjusting to the idea of credit<br />
cards. For several months after they were<br />
authorized, Starwood’s Four Points Hotel<br />
refused to accept the cards until Cuban<br />
banking officials made it clear that they<br />
were indeed authorized.<br />
As for Seleski, the use of Stonegate<br />
credit cards is just the beginning of banking<br />
opportunities in Cuba. He is already<br />
looking to future opportunities, including<br />
servicing U.S. businesses looking for “the<br />
ability to transfer money, letters of credit,<br />
and trade finance.” Those direct interactions<br />
between U.S. and Cuban banks<br />
are still prohibited, however, by the U.S.<br />
government.<br />
“To get the financial services working<br />
correctly you really need the embargo<br />
to be lifted,” says Seleski. “It’s very<br />
cumbersome going through a third-party<br />
country.” H<br />
Florida's Stonegate: The first to issue cards<br />
DEC 2016<br />
CUBATRADE<br />
35
MANUFACTURING<br />
A NEW FURROW<br />
How a much celebrated plan to build<br />
a U.S. tractor factory in Cuba failed to<br />
gain approval, and what happens next<br />
By Nick Swyter<br />
Photo by Jon Braeley<br />
Saul Berenthal, co-founder of farm equipment manufacturer Cleber. Inset: Cleber's simple Oggun tractor.<br />
When Saul Berenthal, co-founder of<br />
Alabama-based farm equipment manufacturer<br />
Cleber, shipped one of his tractors to<br />
last year’s Havana International Trade Fair,<br />
he could only hope the U.S. government<br />
would give his company the go-ahead to<br />
assemble and sell those tractors in Cuba.<br />
In February, the U.S. government<br />
finally granted Cleber permission to build<br />
the first U.S. factory in Cuba in more than<br />
half a century, slated for construction in<br />
the Mariel Special Economic Zone. What<br />
Cleber did not count on was the Cuban<br />
government turning down its proposal.<br />
That decision was announced just before<br />
this year’s Fair in November.<br />
Why Cuba decided not to move<br />
forward has been the subject of extensive<br />
commentary since then. The Associated<br />
Press reported that the government may<br />
want to slow down direct investment from<br />
the U.S. until the embargo is lifted. The<br />
Miami Herald explained how new deals to<br />
import tractors from China may have had<br />
a chilling effect, since Cleber would have<br />
36 CUBATRADE DEC 2016<br />
been a competitor (indeed, large Chinese<br />
tractors were prominently displayed at the<br />
entrance to this year’s Fair).<br />
According to Spanish news agency<br />
EFE, the simplicity of Cleber’s design was<br />
a big reason why it won’t be assembled in<br />
Mariel. “Mariel is looking for very hightech,<br />
advanced manufacturing, and our focus<br />
is a simple, basic tractor,” said Cleber partner<br />
Locky Catron. Another reason: Cuban<br />
farm gear uses diesel fuel, whereas the<br />
Cleber tractor uses gasoline.<br />
Regardless, Cleber hopes to export<br />
tractors and other products to Cuba<br />
through the U.S. license it has obtained.<br />
Berenthal is confident his small tractor,<br />
named “Oggun” after a Santeria spirit, is<br />
something that Cuban farmers still need,<br />
even if it isn’t assembled on the island. It is<br />
relatively cheap and easy to repair, and uses<br />
simple components—a necessity in Cuba<br />
where spare parts are rare. Currently there<br />
are an estimated 60,000 tractors in Cuba,<br />
mostly Soviet made, but some 500 are<br />
being lost each year, cannibalized for parts.<br />
“It is difficult because the structure<br />
of how they do business is different than<br />
ours, and we need to understand how it<br />
works,” Berenthal told Cuba Trade when<br />
asked if he was frustrated by the Mariel<br />
decision. “If we stop self-inflicting ourselves<br />
through the embargo, it will be less<br />
difficult and risky.”<br />
Jodi Bond, President of the U.S.<br />
Chamber’s U.S.-Cuba Business Council,<br />
says the failure of such deals to materialize<br />
in the short term is not unusual. “It’s too<br />
bad about the tractors, and it’s too bad<br />
about some of the other commercial deals,<br />
but business negotiations do take time,<br />
especially when they are in brand new<br />
territory,” said Bond.<br />
Even with the loss of the deal, the<br />
silver lining was the widespread publicity<br />
Cleber received during the many months<br />
it was pursuing approval. The profile it<br />
raised to build its Mariel assembly plant<br />
helped it raise funds for a new U.S. factory,<br />
which was scheduled to open in northeast<br />
Alabama on November 30. H
R<br />
STILL THE ONLY CUBE OF ITS KIND.<br />
Long-Standing Brands that Set the Standard<br />
www.TheLegacyCompanies.com
LEGISLATION<br />
The<br />
Legislative<br />
Outlook<br />
The next steps forward<br />
are already in the Senate,<br />
waiting for the House<br />
By Lee Ann Evans<br />
Ever since the U.S. announced that it<br />
would begin normalization of relations<br />
with Cuba on December 17, 2014, we<br />
have seen some remarkable progress.<br />
Embassies have reopened. Memoranda of<br />
Understanding (MOU) have been signed<br />
in areas such as civil aviation, maritime<br />
cooperation, agriculture, environment,<br />
homeland security, and health. The U.S.<br />
and Cuba have begun to strengthen bilateral<br />
cooperation on environmental issues,<br />
public health, and counter-narcotics.<br />
Discussions have commenced on renewable<br />
energy, intellectual property, and trade<br />
and investment. And the bilateral dialogue<br />
continues on tough issues such as property<br />
claims, human rights, and fugitives.<br />
Many of these initiatives have come<br />
from the executive office of government.<br />
While such actions are exemplary, the<br />
stage must shift to the legislature, so that<br />
the opening with Cuba becomes permanent—and<br />
deeper.<br />
The good news is that legislative<br />
initiatives are now in the works, following<br />
earlier legislation to remove restrictions on<br />
trade and investment with Cuba. Equally<br />
encouraging is that these initiatives are<br />
bipartisan. Republicans and Democrats<br />
alike have recognized the enormous<br />
potential that will come from a normal<br />
relationship with Cuba—in line with their<br />
constituents. Poll after poll shows that<br />
an overwhelming majority of Americans<br />
are in favor of opening up travel and<br />
trade with Cuba. Importantly, among Cuban-Americans<br />
in Miami-Dade County,<br />
63 percent are now in support of lifting<br />
the embargo, according to the most recent<br />
poll from Florida International University.<br />
Finally, the tides are turning in Congress.<br />
We have made huge strides in the<br />
Senate: On June 16, the U.S. Senate<br />
Appropriations Committee overwhelmingly<br />
voted to include four pro-engagement<br />
Cuba amendments in a must-pass<br />
fisccal year 2017 appropriations bill. Those<br />
amendments included one offered by U.S.<br />
Sens. John Boozman (R-AR) and Jon<br />
Tester (D-MT) to allow American farmers<br />
to extend private financing for the export<br />
of agricultural commodities to Cuba,<br />
which passed by a vote of 22-8, with the<br />
support from Committee Chairman Thad<br />
Cochran (R-MS). The amendment would<br />
also repeal a requirement that any U.S.<br />
vessel entering a port in Cuba must obtain<br />
a license to load or unload freight in the<br />
U.S. within 180 days.<br />
Another amendment offered by Sens.<br />
Patrick Leahy (D-VT) and Jerry Moran<br />
(R-KS) to end the travel ban on Cuba then<br />
passed by voice vote. Additional amendments<br />
offered by Sen. Tom Udall (D-NM)<br />
and Sen. Susan Collins (R-ME), allow for<br />
the exportation of telecommunication services<br />
and the refueling of planes at Bangor<br />
Airport for international flights en route to<br />
or from Cuba, respectively. Both amendments<br />
were passed by voice vote. This will<br />
be the subject of negotiations in the lame<br />
duck session omnibus bill.<br />
38 CUBATRADE DEC 2016
PENDING CUBA LEGISLATION<br />
On the House side, support for<br />
changing Cuba policy is growing. Even<br />
the most outspoken opponents of ending<br />
the Cuban embargo have realized that<br />
their position is no longer tenable. In July,<br />
Rep. Rick Crawford (R-AR), a leader<br />
in opening up trade and travel to Cuba,<br />
reached an agreement to find a long-term<br />
solution to provide credit for the export<br />
of agricultural commodities to Cuba<br />
with the Republican Leadership (including<br />
members from Florida) who have<br />
previously resisted changes to U.S.-Cuba<br />
policy. During the appropriations process,<br />
Crawford withdrew his bill with a promise<br />
from the opposition to negotiate. As a<br />
result of this compromise, there was no<br />
vote on the appropriations amendments<br />
offered by Reps Rick Crawford and Rep-<br />
Mark Sanford (R-SC) to remove restrictions<br />
on agricultural exports and to lift the<br />
travel ban, respectively. A hearing was held<br />
in the House Agriculture Committee on<br />
September 14, 2016. As of now, we will<br />
wait to see whether the Senate provision<br />
will prevail in conference.<br />
Our failed unilateral sanctions have<br />
caused great economic hardship for the<br />
people of Cuba and continue to put<br />
American businesses at a competitive<br />
disadvantage. The world is increasingly<br />
looking to Cuba as a key player in international<br />
affairs, through advanced medical<br />
aid, regional conflict mediation, and its<br />
re-entry in the global market. Our policy<br />
of isolation not only weakens our international<br />
credibility, but also threatens our<br />
national security, as well as our economic<br />
and human rights interests in the region<br />
and around the world. On the floor of<br />
the 32nd Plenary Meeting of the U.N.<br />
General Assembly, representatives from<br />
the international community cited the<br />
embargo as a glaring inconsistency with<br />
the recent changes in U.S. policy toward<br />
Cuba, including the reestablishment of<br />
diplomatic relations. H<br />
Lee Ann Evans is a senior policy advisor<br />
for Engage Cuba, a national coalition of<br />
private companies, organizations and state<br />
and local leaders working to lift the embargo.<br />
www.engagecuba.org.<br />
S. 299/HR 664 Freedom to Travel to Cuba Act:<br />
H Lead co-sponsors in Senate are Sens. Jeff Flake (R-AZ) and Patrick Leahy (D-VT);<br />
51 co-sponsors (40 D, 9 R, 2 I)<br />
H Rep. Mark Sanford (R-SC) leads the bill in the House; 131 Co-sponsors (111 D, 20 R)<br />
H.R. 3687 Cuba Agricultural Exports Act:<br />
H Lead co-sponsors are Reps. Rick Crawford (R-AR), Michael Conaway (R-TX), and<br />
Ted Poe (TX-2); 48 co-sponsors (25 R, 23 D)<br />
S. 1049 Agricultural Export Expansion Act of 2015:<br />
H Lead co-sponsors are Sens. John Boozman (R-AR) and Heidi Heitkamp (D-ND);<br />
16 co-sponsors (9 D, 6 R, 1 I)<br />
S. 491 Freedom to Export to Cuba Act of 2015:<br />
H Co-sponsored by Sens. Amy Klobuchar (D-MN) and Mike Enzi (R-WY);<br />
25 co-sponsors (20 D, 3 R, 2 I)<br />
S. 1543/HR 3238 The Cuba Trade Act of 2015:<br />
H Lead sponsors are Sens. Jerry Moran (R-KS) and Angus King (I-ME) in the Senate;<br />
3 co-sponsors (2 R, 1 I)<br />
H Reps. Tom Emmer (R-MN) and Kathy Castor (D-FL) in the House;<br />
25 co-sponsors (14 D, 11 R)<br />
LEGISLATIVE OUTLOOK: SENATE<br />
H June 16, 2016: U.S. Senate Appropriations Committee overwhelmingly votes to include<br />
four pro-engagement Cuba amendments in a must-pass FY 2017 appropriations bill:<br />
• An amendment to allow American farmers to extend private financing for the export of<br />
agricultural commodities to Cuba and repeal the requirement that U.S. vessels entering a<br />
port in Cuba must obtain a license to dock in the U.S. in less than 180 days<br />
• An amendment offered to end the travel ban on Cuba<br />
• An amendment to allow for the exportation of telecommunication services to Cuba<br />
• An amendment to allow refueling of planes at Bangor Airport for international flights en<br />
route to or from Cuba<br />
LEGISLATIVE OUTLOOK: HOUSE<br />
H June, 2016: Representative Rick Crawford (R-AR) submits an amendment to allow<br />
agriculture financing for Cuba in the must-pass FY 2017 appropriations bill.<br />
H July, 2016: Rep. Crawford withdraws the amendment in exchange for a promise to<br />
find a long-term solution to provide credit for agricultural commodity exports to Cuba<br />
• As a result of this compromise, there will be no vote on the appropriations amendments<br />
offered by Rep. Crawford (R-AR) and Rep. Mark Sanford (R-SC)<br />
• A hearing was held in the House Agriculture Committee on September 14, 2016, but<br />
no new amendements were intiated<br />
• If the Senate amendment prevails then it will go to conference in the House for possible<br />
inclusion in the FY 2017 appropriations bill<br />
DEC 2016<br />
CUBATRADE<br />
39
TRADE<br />
Importing<br />
the<br />
Forbidden<br />
Fruit<br />
In a first crack to the embargo against imports,<br />
how Cuban coffee made it to the U.S.<br />
By Nick Swyter<br />
U.S. supermarkets have stocked Cubanstyle<br />
coffee, like Café Bustelo’s popular<br />
espresso, for years. But the coffee itself?<br />
That came from Colombia. Now, for the<br />
first time in more than half a century,<br />
Nestle’s Nespresso is selling coffee from<br />
Cuba in the U.S. market.<br />
Pent-up interest in the coffee was<br />
so high that the first batch of Nespresso’s<br />
Cafecito de Cuba espresso capsules<br />
sold out almost as soon as they debuted<br />
in August. Since then, the capsules have<br />
sporadically returned to Nespresso’s online<br />
store. Each one sells for $1.25, which is<br />
much higher than the 70 to 80 cent price<br />
tag of most Nespresso capsules.<br />
Cafecito de Cuba reached the U.S.<br />
thanks to an April 2016 State Department<br />
decision to add coffee and textiles to<br />
the list of products that, if made by Cuban<br />
entrepreneurs, can be imported. Under the<br />
rules, entrepreneurs must have documents<br />
to prove they are not owned or controlled<br />
by the Cuban government.<br />
“Nespresso is committed to working<br />
with independent smallholder farmers,<br />
and has obtained certifications from the<br />
Cuban government and the importer<br />
40 CUBATRADE DEC 2016<br />
with whom we worked, that the coffee<br />
we bought was grown by smallholder<br />
farmers in Cuba,” Nespresso told to Cuba<br />
Trade. Cuba has increasingly embraced<br />
private agriculture since 2008, when thenrecently<br />
appointed President Raúl Castro<br />
allowed private farmers to use idle land<br />
owned by the government. Even though<br />
farmers are required to sell most of their<br />
crops to the state at prices set by the<br />
state, some products can be sold on the<br />
private market. Those moves have helped<br />
put Cuba’s coffee future into the hands<br />
of private farmers. Nespresso says more<br />
than 90 percent of the coffee grown in<br />
Cuba comes from 20,000 to 30,000 small<br />
independent farmers. “With coffee, the<br />
benefits of large-scale production are not<br />
clear,” said Frederick Royce, a University<br />
of Florida faculty member who specializes<br />
in Cuban agriculture. He says small<br />
independent farms are better suited to<br />
grow coffee because it doesn’t require<br />
heavy machinery.<br />
The Cafecito de Cuba beans were<br />
grown in the Granma and Santiago de<br />
Cuba regions of the country. However,<br />
they only reached Nespresso in Europe<br />
after the coffee giant bought them from<br />
Cuban state-enterprise CUBAEXPORT<br />
and U.K. company Cubana. The beans<br />
were roasted and packaged in Switzerland<br />
before they were shipped to the U.S.<br />
Even though the State Department<br />
allows the importation of some Cuban<br />
coffee, it may take a while for more to<br />
pour into the U.S. market. Nespresso says<br />
Cafecito de Cuba is being introduced as a<br />
limited edition product due to the limited<br />
quantity available. “We plan to explore the<br />
opportunity to make this coffee a part of<br />
the permanent range in the future,”<br />
wrote Nespresso. H
CFI<br />
US-Cuba Trade Relations &<br />
Investment<br />
“As proud members of the USACC,<br />
we support improved trade relations<br />
and thank the efforts of the coalition.”<br />
We aim to create stable and synergistic consensus,<br />
trade, and foreign direct investment<br />
partnerships.<br />
Established 2008<br />
www.ChicagoFoodsInternational.com
FLYING
HIGH<br />
A Tale of the Long Game: How<br />
Havana Air took off to become<br />
the largest provider of passenger<br />
traffic to Cuba<br />
Text by Michael Deilbert<br />
Photos by Jon Braeley
The Boeing 737 glides over the powdery beaches and<br />
condos of Miami Beach before heading south above the<br />
necklace-like string of islands that are the Florida Keys,<br />
glittering in the turquoise waters like jewels. The plane, packed<br />
with Cuban-Americans and tour groups heading to Havana,<br />
quickly traverses the Straits of Florida before descending over<br />
rolling farmland petering out at the tumbling Caribbean surf.<br />
Beneath the fiery afternoon sunset, Havana, the Caribbean’s<br />
largest city and Cuba’s pulsating capital, appears below.<br />
These are heady times for air carriers heading to Cuba from<br />
the United States. Since the U.S. normalized diplomatic relations<br />
with Cuba in December 2014, more and more U.S. citizens have<br />
been traveling to the country, eager to sample the charms of the<br />
long-forbidden Communist island. During 2015, Cuba’s government<br />
said the number of U.S. visitors increased by 77 percent, totaling<br />
161,233 for the year; estimates for 2016 more than double<br />
that figure. And with scant seafaring options, these tourists are<br />
arriving by air.<br />
For decades, there was no regularly scheduled commercial air<br />
travel between the United States and Cuba, with charter companies<br />
stepping into the breech to provide service. That<br />
is now changing, with numerous American<br />
commercial airlines being granted routes<br />
to Cuban cities. But the dominant player in<br />
air travel between the U.S. and Cuba, with<br />
regular daily flights, remains charter airline<br />
Havana Air. “We are a scheduled service airline<br />
trapped in a charter company’s body,” says<br />
President and COO Mark Elias. “We operate<br />
three or four flights a day.”<br />
Elias, partnering with his friend of 30<br />
years CEO David Nesslein, started the company<br />
in early 2009. The pair were inspired while<br />
watching President Barack Obama’s inaugural<br />
address in January of that year, during which the<br />
president spoke of a new opening to the world<br />
and working alongside “old friends and former<br />
foes.” The new administration was also more open<br />
to doing business with Cuba than the previous Bush<br />
presidency.<br />
“Under Bush, no one was getting any new licenses from<br />
OFAC (the Office of Foreign Assets Control),” says Elias, a<br />
U.S. travel industry veteran with experience in the corporate<br />
and leisure markets. "We thought it might be possible under the<br />
new administration." Even so, it would take him and Nesslein<br />
years to get the proper permits, a testimony to the long-game<br />
approach that U.S. companies need to take when doing business<br />
with Cuba.<br />
In the end it took nearly two years to obtain a coveted<br />
license from OFAC, and that was followed by years of persistent<br />
efforts in Cuba. “The OFAC license was difficult to obtain and<br />
took more than a year and a half,” says CEO David Nesslein,<br />
who ran a successful healthcare company for 33 years before<br />
selling it in 2006. “And it took almost 4 years to hammer out<br />
agreement on the Cuban side.”<br />
Throughout those negotiations the duo flew to Havana<br />
repeatedly, working out the intricacies of the deal with Celimar,<br />
a division of Havanatur, the state company that oversees tourism<br />
in Cuba. “When we went to Cuba and were proposing to begin<br />
flights, we told them we wanted to open our services to the U.S.<br />
non-Cuban audience as well as Cuban-Americans,” Elias says.<br />
“We were constantly telling them we were going to bring them<br />
the U.S. audience.” Which they did, leveraging Elias’s travel industry<br />
background. During the long process of acquiring licenses,<br />
they also honed their market intelligence by acting as sales agents<br />
for other charters.<br />
Once the company received permission to operate, another<br />
set of hurdles arose: The decades-old U.S. financial restrictions that<br />
make it difficult to transfer funds to Cuba, in this case for aircraft<br />
landing fees and ground operations. In the end, like other U.S.<br />
companies doing business with Cuba, Havana Air solved this by<br />
using third-country banks for transactions with the island nation.<br />
Finally, on Thanksgiving Day 2013, Havana Air carried its first<br />
load of passengers from Miami to Cuba’s capital. “It was trial by<br />
fire,” says Elias. “But we were fully booked on that day and passenger<br />
loads have continued to increase since then as the number<br />
of flights have grown.”<br />
Today, Havana Air averages more than two dozen<br />
flights a week heading to Cuba and carries<br />
more than 12,000 passengers a month. The<br />
company now encompasses a fully-automated<br />
online booking site, ticket purchasing, and<br />
applications for visas, all directly on line. In<br />
addition to Havana, they fly to the regional cities<br />
of Santiago, Santa Clara, Holguín and Camagüey<br />
utilizing 737-800, 160-seat aircraft operated by<br />
Eastern Airlines. Departures include Miami and<br />
Tampa, and they operate the only flights departing<br />
from Key West to Havana. They also have a ground<br />
operation, Cuba Explorations, that provides cultural<br />
tours around the island.<br />
While Havana Air is now the largest carrier of passengers<br />
between the U.S. and Cuba, however, the aviation<br />
landscape they pioneered is about to dramatically change.<br />
As of early November, ten commercial airlines had received<br />
U.S. approval to fly to Cuba, routes that are slowly being approved<br />
by the Cuban government—beginning with Jet Blue’s<br />
inaugural Santa Clara flight last August. Other airlines approved<br />
include American, Delta, United, and Alaska Airlines, with<br />
routes to Havana, Holguín, Cienfuegos, Santiago, Varadero,<br />
Camagüey and the aforementioned Santa Clara, flying from U.S.<br />
cities that include Los Angeles, New York, Miami, Tampa, and<br />
Newark.<br />
By and large, most analysts see the expansion of air service to<br />
Cuba as a positive development, including for the Cuban people<br />
and their economy. “We’re very encouraged by what’s happening<br />
because it’s an opportunity for the market and the economy to<br />
grow in a country that’s been closed off from the United States,”<br />
says Peter Cerda, regional vice president at the International Air<br />
Transport Association. “By being able to put into effect scheduled<br />
service, this is a game changer.”<br />
44 CUBATRADE DEC 2016
It was trial by fire, but we were fully<br />
booked and we’ve been full ever since.<br />
Mark Elias, president and COO, Havana Air<br />
Photo by Jon Braeley<br />
Havana Air passengers arriving at<br />
José Martí International Airport
Havana Air has carved out a uniquely competitive niche in the U.S.-Cuba<br />
travel market, based on their understanding of the passengers they serve.<br />
While few observers predict that U.S. air service to the island<br />
will be rescinded, the industry vis-à-vis Cuba is not without challenges.<br />
In September, Sens. Marco Rubio (R-Florida) and Robert<br />
Menendez (D-New Jersey) co-sponsored legislation designed to<br />
halt commercial flights from the United States to Cuba, at least<br />
until the U.S. Transportation Security Administration (TSA) can<br />
complete an analysis of airport security in Cuba and ink a deal<br />
that allows the TSA to regularly inspect them.<br />
There are also concerns that Cuba’s aviation infrastructure,<br />
especially José Martí airport in Havana, will be hard pressed to<br />
handle an influx of new passengers. This may be alleviated in the<br />
long term by contracts signed by the Cuban government with<br />
French firms Bouygues S.A. (to upgrade the facility) and Aéroports<br />
de Paris (to operate the airport). In the short term, however,<br />
facilities will be strained as Americans fly with increasing ease to<br />
Cuba. Though tourism to Cuba per se is still prohibited, OFAC<br />
grants visas for 12 categories of travel, including family visits,<br />
educational activities, religious activities, and the open-ended<br />
‘people-to-people’ trip. Unlike in previous years, travelers can now<br />
self-certify, rather than go through a formal approval process.<br />
For both the short and the long term, the founders of Havana<br />
Air are not particularly worried about the new competition.<br />
“They are the ones who are going to have to compete with us,”<br />
says CEO Nesslein. Pricing, for example, won’t be an issue.<br />
Historically, charter companies have been forced to pay substantially<br />
higher landing fees than commercial carriers, but recently,<br />
Havana Air succeeded in reaching a deal with Cuba’s government<br />
that brought these rates to parity.<br />
Indeed, Havana Air has in some ways carved out a uniquely<br />
competitive niche in the U.S.-Cuba travel market, based on<br />
their understanding of the passengers they serve. “We were both<br />
frequent flyers and airline customers for years, so we knew exactly<br />
what we wanted to do and what we didn’t want to do,” says Elias.<br />
Among those initiatives is Havana Air’s policy of accommo-<br />
46 CUBATRADE DEC 2016<br />
dating over-sized items that Cuban-Americans want to bring to<br />
relatives, such as large boxes, televisions, and bicycles (especially<br />
popular on the Camagüey route), things that commercial airlines<br />
are reluctant to take aboard. For any given flight, a long line snaking<br />
from Havana Air’s check-in counter at Miami International<br />
Airport––with travelers pushing overloaded carts––is a common<br />
site. “Simply put, we often take luggage types on board that other<br />
companies won’t,” says Elias.<br />
Another competitive advantage, he says, is scheduling. “We<br />
offer early morning flights. The scheduled airlines opt for later<br />
flights waiting for connections from other cities. But our passengers<br />
want to get down there early in the day.” Havana Air is also<br />
planning to compete with the influx of competition by catering<br />
to a more upscale market. With terminal facilities in Havana<br />
soon to be stretched to capacity, Nesslein and Elias are betting<br />
that corporate and affluent passengers will want to avoid the mess<br />
and travel by private plane. Nesslein has made substantial gains in<br />
acquiring private aircraft landing rights, and Havana Air currently<br />
facilitates about 15 private jets a month, from Hawker 850s to<br />
Gulfstream G4s, including regularly scheduled flights from Key<br />
West three times a week.<br />
The company also believes that its extensive connections on<br />
the ground in Cuba, and the personal service of Havana Air, will<br />
help them compete in the increasingly diversified Cuban aviation<br />
landscape. The company’s expertise in Cuba has been utilized by,<br />
among others, the Rolling Stones, who employed the company<br />
to move their support staff for their heralded concert in Havana’s<br />
Ciudad Deportiva this past May. A few days earlier, Havana Air<br />
had flown in the Tampa Bay Rays when they played their historic<br />
game against Cuba’s national team in front of Barack Obama and<br />
Raúl Castro. The company also sponsors Cuban reggaeton group<br />
Los Quatros for their U.S. tours and participates in several pro<br />
bono efforts to bring Cuban artists to the U.S.<br />
“I think the difference between us and a scheduled carrier<br />
is that we fly every day, 7 days a week, to Cuba,” says Elias. “We
Don’t miss any issues...<br />
SUBSCRIBE NOW!<br />
TIMELY<br />
TARGETED<br />
EFFECTIVE<br />
Everything you need to know on:<br />
Tourism Transportation Agriculture Investments<br />
Energy Manufacturing And much more …..<br />
RECEIVE 11 ISSUES DELIVERED DIRECTLY TO YOU FOR ONLY<br />
$29.99<br />
That’s like getting 6 issues FREE! *<br />
Subscribe online at cubatrademagazine.com<br />
* Newsstands price $5.99 per issue
PUERTO RICO:<br />
THE U.S. BRIDGE TO CUBA?<br />
As the Caribbean island that the U.S. never left, Puerto Rico has<br />
existed in a kind of parallel universe to Cuba. Now it wants to<br />
position itself as a conduit to its Hispanic soul mate——if it can.<br />
Story and photos by Larry Luxner<br />
The Capitol building sits in front of the San Juan Inlet
In a once-fashionable Havana suburb today known for<br />
leafy banyan trees and crumbling mansions, a handful of<br />
independentistas struggles to maintain the closest thing<br />
Puerto Rico has to an embassy in Cuba.<br />
Here, along Calle 22, right off Miramar’s stately Quinta<br />
Avenida, is the Misión de Puerto Rico en Cuba Juan Mari Brás. A<br />
Puerto Rican flag out front and a bronze plaque nailed to the<br />
freshly painted house attest to that fact.<br />
Inside, a cook peels potatoes for lunch, while in the living<br />
room—decorated with Marxist memorabilia from the time of<br />
Pedro Albizu Campos—58-year-old Edwin González Vázquez<br />
discusses his beloved island’s changing relationship with Cuba.<br />
“In the two years since diplomatic relations between the U.S.<br />
and Cuba were established, we’ve seen a lot of progress,” he told<br />
Cuba Trade. “Things are much more advanced now. I think this is<br />
only natural. And the number of Puerto Ricans visiting Cuba has<br />
increased dramatically—even without direct flights between San<br />
Juan and Havana.”<br />
González said his so-called “embassy,” established in 1966<br />
“to promote the cause of independence for Puerto Rico,” recently<br />
celebrated its 50th anniversary with speeches, art exhibits,<br />
concerts—even the unveiling of a new commemorative postage<br />
stamp. But this decidedly unofficial mission won’t be Puerto<br />
Rico’s sole outpost in Havana for much longer.<br />
Last June, the island’s pro-commonwealth governor,<br />
Alejandro García Padilla, announced that Puerto Rico would<br />
establish a trade office in Havana—similar to offices it has<br />
opened in the Dominican Republic, Panama, Peru and Colombia—in<br />
order to take advantage of new business opportunities<br />
following the resumption of diplomatic ties between Cuba and<br />
the United States.<br />
“Cuba represents a significant potential market for Puerto<br />
Rican companies in diverse industries,” declared García Padilla,<br />
the first sitting Puerto Rican governor ever to visit Cuba. He<br />
spoke on the sidelines of the 7th Association of Caribbean<br />
States summit in Havana, following a friendly meeting with<br />
Raúl Castro. “The opening of a commercial office in Havana<br />
will boost business opportunities for our entrepreneurs…<br />
connecting them to potential clients, business partners and<br />
industry representatives.”<br />
Added Héctor Ferrer, a pro-commonwealth politician who<br />
lost the Nov. 8 race to become Puerto Rico’s nonvoting resident<br />
commissioner in Washington: “We have what Cuba needs—engineers,<br />
chemists, contractors, architects, entrepreneurs, lawyers.<br />
Most of them are educated or trained in the States. So if the U.S.<br />
is going to start a relationship with Cuba, they should look to us.”<br />
Puerto Rico and Cuba are often referred to as “dos alas del<br />
mismo pajaro”—two wings of the same bird—because of their<br />
shared history under Spanish colonial rule. Both came under U.S.<br />
domination following the Spanish-American War of 1898; Cuba<br />
got its independence four years later, while Puerto Rico remained<br />
a colony and achieved commonwealth status in 1952.<br />
The two islands’ flags are of the same design, but with the<br />
blue and red reversed; Cubans and Puerto Ricans share cultural<br />
similarities as well, including their affection for everything from<br />
salsa to baseball. There’s even a sugar-mill town named Puerto<br />
Rico Libre in the Cuban province of Matanzas—tangible evidence<br />
of socialist Cuba’s longtime support for the cause of Puerto<br />
Rican independence.<br />
Yet economically and politically, the two islands could hardly<br />
be more different. Poor by U.S. standards, Puerto Rico nonetheless<br />
has a per-capita income of $28,500 and nearly two million<br />
vehicles choke its streets and highways.<br />
Even so, Puerto Rico is in an economic free-fall, while Cuba<br />
is staggering forward. The U.S. commonwealth struggles under a<br />
$68 billion mountain of debt, which comes to $15,700 per-capita—more<br />
than 10 times the average per-capita debt in the 50<br />
U.S. states. This summer Congress had to pass emergency legislation<br />
to keep the island from defaulting, including a rescue plan<br />
with an oversight board that has stirred deep resentment among<br />
many residents and revived calls for Puerto Rico to secede from<br />
the “colonist” mainland.<br />
Meanwhile, the island’s unemployment rate stands at 11.3<br />
percent. Its GDP declined by 1.6 percent in 2015 and is projected<br />
to shrink another 2 percent in both 2016 and 2017. By<br />
comparison, Cuba saw its economy grow by 4 percent last year<br />
(though predictions for oil-strapped 2016 are for 1 percent.)<br />
Violent crime and drug abuse, virtually absent in Cuba, are high<br />
in Puerto Rico, while life expectancy is now slightly lower than<br />
that of Cuba. In one telling sign, the Pew Research Center noted<br />
that the surge of Cubans arriving on U.S. shores last year (43,159<br />
compared to 24,278 in 2014) was about half the number of Puerto<br />
Ricans (83,844) entering the U.S. mainland during the same<br />
time period.<br />
It wasn’t always this way, however.<br />
Changing Times<br />
Following the 1959 revolution, Puerto Rico’s relative prosperity<br />
and Spanish-speaking culture attracted many Cuban exiles. At<br />
least 20,000 of them now live in Puerto Rico, where they have<br />
dominated certain sectors of the economy, most notably in advertising,<br />
radio stations and newspapers.<br />
We have to insert our professional sector<br />
throughout Cuba because for the Cubans,<br />
it’s better to deal with Puerto Ricans than<br />
with Americans.<br />
Puerto Rican businessman Manuel Cidre<br />
<strong>One</strong> such exile is Manuel Cidre, who recently made an<br />
unsuccessful bid for governor of Puerto Rico as an independent,<br />
self-made millionaire (he got 5.7 percent of the popular vote,<br />
coming in fourth out of six candidates; the winner was politician<br />
Ricardo Rosselló of the pro-statehood New Progressive Party).<br />
Born in the Havana suburb of Tarará, Cidre left Cuba in<br />
1962 as a young boy, settling with his parents in Puerto Rico.<br />
50 CUBATRADE DEC 2016
In one telling sign, the Pew Research Center<br />
noted that nearly twice as many Puerto Ricans<br />
relocated to the US last year (83,844) as did<br />
Cubans (43,159).<br />
Edwin González Vázquez, the unofficial ambassador for Puerto Rico's independence movement<br />
DEC 2016<br />
CUBATRADE<br />
51
Self-made millionaire Manuel Cidre<br />
Cidre launched his company, Los Cidrines, in 1978 with his<br />
brother Guillermo. Today their factory of 20,000 square feet<br />
produces frozen baked goods for supermarkets in Puerto Rico<br />
and the U.S., with $23 million in annual sales. Now fully retired<br />
(the business is run by his sons and sister), Cidre wants to devote<br />
himself to bringing prosperity back to Puerto Rico.<br />
Last year, Cidre returned to Cuba for the first time in 54<br />
years, spending three months on the island. He drove from<br />
Havana to Pinar del Río, then back to Havana and from there to<br />
Cienfuegos, Camagüey and Santiago de Cuba.<br />
“For the last two weeks of my journey, I walked in Havana<br />
every evening from 5 p.m. to midnight,” he said. “If you’d<br />
make some small changes to Havana—maybe with its energy<br />
and water systems—it would be ready to receive a big chunk of<br />
immigrants.”<br />
Cidre, who opposes the U.S. trade embargo, said it would be<br />
hard to export bread products from Puerto Rico to Cuba. But he<br />
noted that the island remains lucrative for other Puerto Rican<br />
firms. “From Pinar del Río to Santiago you will have opportunities<br />
for the next 20 years in everything from roads to condos<br />
to hotels,” said Cidre. “We have to insert our professional sector<br />
throughout Cuba because for the Cubans, it’s better to deal with<br />
Puerto Ricans than with Americans. The U.S. can use Puerto<br />
Rico as a bridge to get into Cuba, though we have to recognize<br />
that we are part of the United States.”<br />
That’s why Cidre does not believe that having a Puerto<br />
Rican trade office in Havana will accomplish much.<br />
“It would be better to have a small office at the U.S. Embassy<br />
[in Havana] representing Puerto Rico,” he said. “We need<br />
representation in Cuba as part of the federal government. We can<br />
take initiatives on our own, like opening an office in Cuba. But<br />
two years ago, when President Obama started improving the relationship<br />
between the U.S. and Cuba, that was the right moment<br />
for the resident commissioner to insert himself into the process.<br />
But they didn’t do anything… If we’re part of the United States,<br />
we have to be with the U.S. in their initiative.”<br />
Back in Havana, the socialist González agrees with the<br />
capitalist Cidre that such an office would be relatively useless—<br />
assuming the State Department allows it to be established in the<br />
first place.<br />
“Puerto Rico is a colony of the United States, so all U.S.<br />
restrictions on doing business with Cuba apply to Puerto Rico<br />
as well,” he told Cuba Trade. “Officially, I think the U.S. government<br />
will not permit this, especially now after these last elections,<br />
in which the ‘Estado Libre Asociado’ government lost to a<br />
pro-statehood party that promotes the annexation of Puerto Rico<br />
to the United States.”<br />
Excess Capacity<br />
For years, Puerto Rico’s economy was based on Section 936 of<br />
the U.S. Internal Revenue Code, which exempted U.S. firms from<br />
paying federal income taxes on profits earned by their Puerto Rico<br />
manufacturing subsidiaries. As a result, more than 2,000 factories<br />
52 CUBATRADE DEC 2016
Signs of protest against U.S. “colonialism.”<br />
were set up to produce everything from canned tuna to Viagra.<br />
While Section 936 is long gone, many of the plants<br />
have remained—especially in capital-intensive industries<br />
like pharmaceuticals. With that in mind, the Puerto Rico<br />
Manufacturer’s Association (PRMA) has already conducted<br />
two missions to Cuba through Manchester Trade Ltd., a<br />
Washington-based consulting firm. “In 2013, we started taking<br />
business missions to Cuba,” said David Lewis, Manchester’s<br />
vice-president. “Once Obama opened things up, we were able to<br />
piggyback on that because we were already prepositioned in the<br />
Cuban market. What we found was that people are very focused<br />
on all the permits and allowances from the U.S. side, but they<br />
don’t realize that, like with any other foreign country, you need to<br />
comply with Cuban rules and regulations too.”<br />
Despite three subsequent PRMA missions to Cuba,<br />
however, Puerto Rican firms are still just scratching the surface.<br />
“Last year, Puerto Rican companies had only $415,000 in<br />
sales to Cuba—and that’s mostly people who have been doing<br />
food and beverages. It’s an uphill battle, but there’s traction,”<br />
said Lewis, whose next Puerto Rico mission to Cuba is set<br />
for mid-February 2017. “We’re not talking about investment<br />
because we don’t see that happening. At best, you have a couple<br />
of U.S. companies whose distributors in Puerto Rico have had<br />
responsibility for all the Caribbean islands. So when Caterpillar<br />
announced earlier this year they’d be doing business in Cuba, it<br />
will be through [local distributor] Rimco.”<br />
Lewis observed that Cuba’s import agency Alimport just<br />
bought 3 million cases of Presidente beer from the Dominican<br />
Republic and 1 million cases of Banks beer from Barbados.<br />
“They have a deficit for everything––rice, beans, oil, packaged<br />
foods and cereals. It’s a matter of who can strike up a deal with<br />
Alimport and be guaranteed payment. So for $415,000, why<br />
open a trade office in Cuba when Virginia sells $2 million a<br />
year—and Arkansas and Louisiana even more than that—and<br />
they haven’t opened offices?”<br />
Regardless of how many outposts Puerto Rico may set<br />
up in Cuba, things are likely to improve once direct flights are<br />
launched from San Juan to Havana’s José Martí International;<br />
San Juan already has DOT approval for the route, but so far a<br />
request from Panama’s Copa Airlines has not received Cuban<br />
approval.<br />
Leading communications consultant Alex Díaz has his<br />
own theory about what needs to happen. “As long as Puerto<br />
Rico remains a U.S. territory, the winning formula is for<br />
American companies to set up shop in Puerto Rico, partner<br />
with local firms for the talent and cultural affinity with Cuba,<br />
and take advantage of Puerto Rico’s huge export incentives––<br />
Law 20 for services and Law 73 for manufacturing,” said Díaz,<br />
president of the San Juan-based export-marketing boutique<br />
firm AlexDiazEco.<br />
“Puerto Rico is the only place in the world under U.S. law<br />
that is foreign for taxation, so your product is ‘Made in the USA’<br />
but without the federal taxes,” he added. “That’s the wave I’ll be<br />
looking for in the years ahead.” H<br />
DEC 2016<br />
CUBATRADE<br />
53
Customers waiting for the<br />
doors to open at a central<br />
Havana ETECSA office<br />
AT&T CALL<br />
54 CUBATRADE DEC 2016<br />
When AT&T launched roaming coverage and direct<br />
mobile phone service for its customers in Cuba<br />
this past October, the move marked the latest in<br />
a series of agreements inked by U.S. telecom providers with<br />
Cuba’s state-run telecommunications company, the Empresa<br />
de Telecomunicaciones de Cuba S.A. (ETECSA).<br />
“The AT&T deal sort of completes the stable of service<br />
providers from the U.S.,” says Pedro Freyre, a partner at the<br />
international law firm of Akerman LLP and a specialist on<br />
U.S. business operations under the embargo in Cuba.<br />
As an AT&T customer himself, Freyre added that the<br />
new service is already making a difference, as he can now use<br />
his iPhone on the island. Previously he had to switch to an<br />
ETECSA mobile with spottier coverage.<br />
Despite the agreements—all since the announcement<br />
that the U.S. and Cuba would normalize relations in December<br />
2014—Cuba remains one of the world’s most expensive<br />
countries for accessing telecommunications services. This is<br />
true for telephony or internet use, for incoming international<br />
calls, or the domestic use of mobile phones. Currently, the<br />
cheapest way to call Cuba offered by a major U.S. carrier is an<br />
IDT Corporation plan that costs $.65 a minute.<br />
“The high cost associated with the revenue sharing deal<br />
is not likely to diminish in the near future, especially as the<br />
Cuban government looks for more liquidity,” Reuben Smith-<br />
Vaughan, executive director of the U.S. Chamber of Commerce’s<br />
US-Cuba Business Council, told Cuba Trade. Each<br />
participating telecom provider has to sign an independent<br />
agreement with ETECSA for sharing revenue from roaming<br />
and mobile services. Those revenues, Reuben-Smith notes,<br />
could fund infrastructure investments. And while short-term<br />
costs will remain high, with the full array of big U.S. telecoms<br />
now offering services on the island there could be more direct<br />
competition between the companies in the years ahead.<br />
“In that sense, it’s good,” says Freyre. “When you have<br />
big players coming in, you would expect improvement in
HOME<br />
WITH HELP FROM U.S. COMPANIES, CUBAN<br />
TELEPHONY GRADUALLY UNFOLDS<br />
By Sean Goforth<br />
Photo by Jon Braeley
services and costs to eventually come down.” Internet access is<br />
also far more expensive in Cuba than most other countries in the<br />
region. Over the last year, ETECSA, which has a monopoly over<br />
telephony and the internet in Cuba, has expanded the number of<br />
wifi hotspots where Cubans can access the internet. The stateowned<br />
firm also cut the cost of access at these locations by more<br />
than half, to 2 CUC (about $2) per hour. But in a country where<br />
the average worker makes about $25 a month, every minute<br />
online is precious time.<br />
Coming to Terms with the Pace of Change in Cuba<br />
In announcing the normalization of relations with Cuba,<br />
the White House diagnosed telecommunications and internet<br />
services as a priority area for U.S. exports. This fueled speculation<br />
that Cuba was poised to advance into the 21st century world of<br />
telecommunications, especially with regard to the internet, as<br />
loosened U.S. restrictions on sales gave way to rapid installation<br />
of a modern internet infrastructure.<br />
“As a virtual internet greenfield, Cuba has the possibility<br />
of ‘leapfrogging’ to a modern internet in service of the people,”<br />
says Larry Press, a professor of information systems at California<br />
State University-Dominguez Hills and longtime student of the<br />
internet in Cuba. “But doing so would require creative use of<br />
current technology as a stopgap measure while planning for the<br />
installation of next-generation equipment.”<br />
Press points out, however, that infrastructure improvements<br />
and clear regulations would be needed for Cuba to realize this<br />
potential. During 2015, others were more bullish, as telecom analysts<br />
touted Cuba’s amenable geography, as well as the large talent<br />
pool of Cuban engineers and computer scientists who could carry<br />
out a modernization plan. Key Cuban officials have also played<br />
up the potential for rapid improvements in internet connectivity.<br />
On the sidelines of a World Economic Forum meeting in Mexico,<br />
Cuban finance minister Lina Pedraza said that Havana was<br />
in advanced talks with the Chinese telecoms equipment maker<br />
Huawei. It seemed like a kindred pairing. Huawei is one of the<br />
few companies that could make good on a pledge to modernize<br />
an entire nation’s telecommunications sector by coupling expanded<br />
mobile and fixed-line broadband, and had previously signed<br />
a deal allowing it to sell smart phones and parts in Cuba. There<br />
also appeared to be a mutual understanding, as the Chinese were<br />
sympathetic when Pedraza expressed concern over “negative parts<br />
of the internet.”<br />
Weeks later detailed ETECSA plans, including diagrams for<br />
installing a fiber-optic “backbone” for high-speed internet across<br />
more than 20 towns on the island, were leaked onto the web.<br />
Excitement grew that the nation was on the cusp of a rapid rollout<br />
of modern internet infrastructure. And last October, ETECSA<br />
announced that it would be piloting an in-home internet<br />
program in the tourist mecca of La Habana Vieja for about 2,000<br />
households with fiber-optic technology supplied by Huawei.<br />
In an illustration of the two-steps-forward-one-step-back<br />
nature of connectivity on the island, however, ETECSA has<br />
begun routing all internet traffic through the submarine cable<br />
named ALBA-1, says Doug Madory, director of internet analysis<br />
at Dyn Research in Manchester, New Hampshire. The ALBA-<br />
1 cable connects Cuba to its close ally Venezuela. Before then<br />
ETECSA had split the volume of Cuba’s internet traffic between<br />
satellite transmission and ALBA-1. The earlier division was “both<br />
slower and more expensive,” explains Madory. With the full<br />
switch from satellite transmission to ALBA-1, Cuba could enjoy<br />
exponential increases in internet connection speeds.<br />
Hurdles to Connectivity<br />
But while the opening of new wifi hotspots has brought plenty<br />
of fanfare—along with the phenomenon of Cuba cell phone<br />
users clustering around such hotspots—the net gains in internet<br />
connectivity have been small. Though there are now 1,006<br />
More Cubans are enjoying wifi<br />
on their smartphones<br />
Mobile Subscribers in Cuba<br />
(in millions)<br />
4*<br />
*estimated year end<br />
Source: based on data from TeleGeography<br />
.3<br />
.62<br />
1<br />
1.3<br />
1.6<br />
2<br />
2.5<br />
3<br />
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015<br />
2016<br />
56 CUBATRADE DEC 2016
An internet hotspot in a park in Santa Clara; connectivity is often better outside of Havana<br />
Employees of state phone company ETECSA repair a switching box in Havana
Fixed Telephone Lines<br />
Per Capita<br />
While the use of mobile phones is increasing, many citizens still use<br />
the far less expensive fixed lines<br />
Bahamas .4<br />
Uruguay .3<br />
Aruba .3<br />
Grenada .25<br />
Dominica .23<br />
Coast Rica .19<br />
Panama .15<br />
El Salvador .15<br />
Ecuador .14<br />
Guatemala .12<br />
Peru .11<br />
Cuba .11<br />
D.R. (Dominican Republic) .11<br />
Jamaica .08<br />
Bolivia .08<br />
Honduras .07<br />
Paraguay .06<br />
Nicaragua .05<br />
Source: based on data from ITU
public access points for internet across Cuba, that figure includes<br />
ETECSA navigation rooms, public wifi hotspots, hotels, airports,<br />
post offices, and some government ministry offices.<br />
Connections speeds remain 2G, however, while the cost<br />
remains prohibitive for most Cubans. Given this, Larry Press<br />
calls the changes “a small drop in the bucket for an island of 11<br />
million people.” While ETECSA has expanded the number of<br />
wifi hotspots, and earlier this year Google very publicly installed<br />
a hotspot at the studio of a Havana artist, overall access to the<br />
internet in Cuba has barely improved. As of November there<br />
were only 54 wifi hotspots in Havana, with many sites operating<br />
at a crawl during peak hours. Surprisingly, Cuba’s provincial<br />
cities have fared better. “Sometimes the geographical balance is<br />
so much that it is not practical,” says Nelson Rodriguez Proenza,<br />
the founder of Casabe, a software programming enterprise in<br />
Havana. “The [internet] navigation experience on public hotspots<br />
is far better in other provinces than in Havana.”<br />
The 3 Classes of Telecom and Internet Users in Cuba<br />
Cost is the main tool for controlling access to telecom and<br />
internet services in Cuba, and it separates users into three classes.<br />
The first is made up of tourists and foreigners who are willing<br />
and able to pay the price for the convenience of enjoying reliable<br />
international contact to and from the island. These visitors pay a<br />
premium that has encouraged hotels to upgrade their connectivity.<br />
As a result, Cuba’s hotels are thought to rival its universities<br />
when it comes to offering high-speed DSL access.<br />
The premium that foreigners pay may offer further indirect<br />
benefits. <strong>One</strong> high-level State Department official who asked<br />
to remain anonymous said that a possible pathway of expanded<br />
telecom services might involve a “cross-subsidization” of costs.<br />
Doing so would allow ETECSA to lower costs on domestic<br />
users in step with the extra revenue it collects from roaming<br />
charges incurred by travelers.<br />
The second group of users is made up of Cubans who manage<br />
to pay for daily internet access and who also generally have a<br />
mobile phone with coverage from Cubacel, the ETECSA-owned<br />
mobile carrier. Until 2015, this group was mainly comprised of<br />
Cubans whose family members abroad provided the money to<br />
purchase internet access at an ETECSA room or hotspot.<br />
While this is the smallest class of telecom and internet<br />
users, it’s also the fastest growing thanks to a new set of entrants:<br />
Cuba’s budding community of tech entrepreneurs. “We started<br />
with almost zero connectivity,” says Rodriguez, recalling Casabe’s<br />
experience. “We were only connecting using very slow public<br />
access to the internet on very restricted hours.”<br />
Then, as the company grew over the past year, Rodriguez and<br />
his colleagues started using the internet rooms run by ETECSA.<br />
For a time, the growth of the business forced Nelson to go to<br />
hotels in order to secure internet access. Connection speeds at the<br />
hotels were faster than those offered by the ETECSA rooms, but<br />
the cost was extremely high, $6-10 an hour. Now Rodriguez and<br />
his team tend to use the new wifi hotspots. They manage their<br />
time well, working on large portions of programming jobs offline,<br />
saving their time online for the internet-intensive “testing” phase<br />
of software development. “Testing requires a lot of connectivity<br />
in order to simulate different scenarios,” he explains.<br />
Finally, the third class is made up of Cubans whose digital<br />
footprint is restricted primarily to use of Cuba’s domestic intranet,<br />
as well as unauthorized internet. Intranet offerings include<br />
Nauta, the system-wide email; a Wikipedia-style site called<br />
EcuRed, which has 161, 218 articles and counting; and access to<br />
a smattering of other sites launched from Cuba and other friendly<br />
countries like Venezuela. In addition to Nauta for email, many<br />
Cubans in this category utilize mobiles for calls and texting on<br />
the island. It’s a thin set of offerings, and it drives many to seek<br />
access through one of the unauthorized internet connections that<br />
have proliferated throughout Cuba.<br />
Forecasting the Expansion of Internet<br />
Foreign companies, be they from China or elsewhere, are needed<br />
to modernize Cuba’s internet infrastructure, and while such<br />
cooperation has long been rumored it is unclear to what degree<br />
ETECSA is working with these companies to build such an<br />
infrastructure. Most analysts acknowledge the delay is at least<br />
partly due to the Cuban government’s reluctance to embrace an<br />
open internet. At present, Cuba’s sole internet provider does not<br />
appear eager to rapidly expand connectivity. However, ETECSA’s<br />
circumspect approach to the internet may well mirror Havana’s<br />
initially cautious embrace of mobile telephony back in 2008.<br />
Shortly after Raúl Castro officially assumed power from his<br />
brother, Fidel, the Cuban government first permitted ownership<br />
of mobile phones. Then it permitted mobiles to be included in<br />
gift boxes sent from the United States. Soon mobile phones were<br />
a fixture on the island. Even when the phones were inoperable,<br />
because they didn’t have minutes on them, they served as a sort<br />
of accessory among students and other younger Cubans.<br />
As the government grew more comfortable with the spread<br />
of mobile telephony, ETECSA began introducing promotions on<br />
mobile plans. They cut the cost of activating a new mobile line.<br />
“Top-up” promotions that offered bonus minutes became more<br />
and more frequent; eventually ETECSA introduced “double topups”<br />
that dramatically increased bonus minutes as an inducement<br />
to buy a phone. As a result, from 2008-2015 the number of mobile<br />
phone subscriptions on the island increased from only 300,000 to<br />
more than 3 million. Nearly three-quarters of Cubans ages 18 to<br />
49 now have a mobile phone, according to a survey conducted last<br />
year by Bendixen & Amandi; predictions are that nearly 4 million<br />
mobile phones may be in use by year-end 2016.<br />
As the expansion of mobile telephony on the island makes<br />
clear, the decision to improve access is likely to be executed<br />
gradually at first, before it accelerates. Rather than ambitious<br />
modernization plans, however, experiments in greater internet<br />
access are likely to remain the norm for now, including the launch<br />
of more hotspots. Meanwhile, ETECSA can be expected to<br />
monitor internet use as it simultaneously works behind the scenes<br />
to build out the infrastructure needed for a more modern network.<br />
Price cuts could be introduced to pep up access at the hotspots<br />
and other ETECSA-run locations. <strong>One</strong> thing is certain: As the<br />
cost of connectivity comes within reach of more Cubans, it will<br />
further whet the appetite for internet access in more homes<br />
and businesses. H<br />
DEC 2016<br />
CUBATRADE<br />
59
Devry Boughner Vorwerk,<br />
chair of the USACC
THE<br />
SEEDS<br />
OF<br />
CHANGE<br />
The Agriculture Community in the U.S. Wants the<br />
Embargo Against Cuba Lifted. Here’s Why It Makes<br />
Sense for Both Sides.<br />
By J.P. Faber<br />
In mid-September, the House Agriculture Committee<br />
held what has become an annual event—its public<br />
hearing on U.S. agricultural trade with Cuba. This<br />
year, in spite of growing public support for ending a<br />
half-century of trade sanctions against the island nation,<br />
Agriculture Committee Chairman Mike Conaway<br />
(R-Texas) kicked off the hearing with a strident<br />
reaffirmation of his total opposition to lifting the U.S.<br />
trade embargo. “While I am very hopeful that we can<br />
find a path forward on expanding agricultural trade with<br />
Cuba, I remain firmly opposed to lifting the embargo or<br />
restrictions on travel,” Rep. Conaway said in his opening<br />
DEC 2016<br />
CUBATRADE<br />
61
Photo courtesy of USACC<br />
Photo courtesy Kansas Wheat Commission<br />
A Meeting of Minds: USACC chair Devry Boughner Vorwerk talks with<br />
Alimport president Alejandro Mustelier Zamora<br />
statement. Conaway instead maintained that United States has<br />
“secured too little in return” for the trade normalization proposals<br />
offered by the Obama administration since 2014.<br />
Few in attendance at the Congressional hearing shared those<br />
sentiments, however, including other members of the committee.<br />
“I disagree with the chairman. I would like to see the embargo<br />
lifted,” said Ranking Member Collin Peterson (D-Minn.),<br />
quickly adding, “but I am doubtful that it is politically possible to<br />
do so.”<br />
Conaway’s opening statement—and Peterson’s response—<br />
bring into focus one of the main obstacles standing in the way<br />
of trade normalization with Cuba: The refusal of a handful of<br />
lawmakers in key committees to budge on the issue, despite<br />
recent surveys that show that three-quarters of Americans want<br />
to see the embargo end.<br />
Working for Change<br />
Devry Boughner Vorwerk is one of those Americans. Vorwerk,<br />
who until recently worked in the Cuba Practice at legal powerhouse<br />
Akin Gump in Washington, D.C., also chairs the U.S.<br />
Agriculture Coalition for Cuba (USACC).<br />
“The most compelling case is that the full embargo has been<br />
in place for 55 years, and it is not serving its purpose,” says Vorwerk,<br />
who attended the Sept. 14 hearing. “That goal was to change<br />
the regime.”<br />
Counting on Greater Demand: Doug Keesling, Kansas farmer and former<br />
chairperson of the Kansas Wheat Commission<br />
Instead, says Vorwerk, the embargo has simply hurt the<br />
Cuban people.<br />
“When you travel to Cuba and go out to the depths of the<br />
countryside, and see the conditions that the Cuban citizens are<br />
up against—it’s shocking because the sanctions have everything<br />
to do this,” she says. “The Cuban people deserve the opportunity<br />
to unleash their creativity, to unleash their entrepreneurial spirit,<br />
and to engage in commercial relationships with the U.S. and the<br />
rest of the world.”<br />
And U.S. agriculture is all in favor of it, Vorwerk says. The<br />
organization she chairs, USACC, is the largest agriculture coalition<br />
in the country—and its more than 120 members, ranging<br />
from state agriculture associations to some of the biggest agribusinesses<br />
in the world, are pushing to end not only restrictions<br />
on U.S. food exports to Cuba, but also the entire embargo.<br />
“First and foremost, we—our farmers and agricultural businesses—are<br />
basically being told we are not allowed to freely trade<br />
with a willing customer,” Vorwerk says. “This is an ethical issue<br />
and sets back food security in Cuba.”<br />
The Finer Grain<br />
Being a relatively small market, it may seem surprising that Cuba<br />
should be such a focal point for American agriculture. Even Rep.<br />
Peterson—while a proponent of ending the embargo—made a<br />
point of downplaying the impact of possible market opportunities.<br />
62 CUBATRADE DEC 2016
The Cuban people deserve the opportunity<br />
to unleash their creativity, to unleash their<br />
entrepreneurial spirit, and to engage in<br />
commercial relationships with the U.S. and<br />
the rest of the world.<br />
Devry Boughner Vorwerk, chair of the USACC
The California<br />
CUBA CONNECTION<br />
The Napa Valley may be a long way from Havana, but vintners<br />
there see an opportunity in the hospitality industry in Cuba. “I fell<br />
in love with Cuba the first time I went there,” says Darius Anderson,<br />
speaking of his earliest trip there as a college student. “Cuba<br />
was a unique place and I fell in love with everything Cuban.”<br />
By his count, Anderson has been to Cuba 68 times, establishing<br />
relationships with “artists, musicians, and people on the<br />
ground,”—including restauranteurs and sommeliers who understood<br />
the business of wine in his native northern California.<br />
Once diplomatic relations were restored between the U.S.<br />
and Cuba, Anderson and wife Sarah formed the non-profit Californians<br />
Building Bridges, a group dedicated to strengthening<br />
cultural and economic ties between Cuba and California. Among<br />
their outreach programs was a visit to Sonoma and Napa by 22<br />
wine-savvy Cubans in the summer of 2014. This was followed last<br />
year by a first-ever California Wine Symposium in Havana, organized<br />
in partnership with the California Wine Institute and the<br />
Napa and Sonoma vintner associations. Also in 2014, Anderson<br />
founded U.S. Cava Exports to assist US companies in their quest<br />
to sell various food products in Cuba. But his focus has remained<br />
on California wine, which he believes will find a strong market in<br />
Cuba as tourism there expands. “We want U.S. wines to compete<br />
with the rest of the world in the Cuban market,” he says.<br />
A big part of CAVA’s mission is educational. Alimport, the<br />
Cuban government import agency, is used to importing inexpensive<br />
wine from Spain and other countries at the $4 to $10 price<br />
range. “There is not a lot in California for that price,” he says,<br />
but the tourism-driven food and wine market is moving upscale.<br />
“Americans and Canadians consume California wines, and as travel<br />
to Cuba increases there is a demand for higher quality ones.”<br />
Anderson’s first container of California wines is scheduled<br />
to ship by January, purchased by Palco, a division of Alimport that<br />
supplies diplomatic stores, diplomatic houses and other tourism<br />
related activities for diplomats. “We could do 75 containers of<br />
quality California wines over the next five years,” he says.<br />
Napa Valley grapes: Cultivating a taste for California wines in Cuba<br />
“With the exception of rice, wheat, maybe dry edible beans,<br />
lentils, the potential benefits are limited in my opinion in the<br />
short term, because Cuba is a small country and most people living<br />
there have a very limited income,” he noted at the September<br />
hearing. “So we need to keep things in balance here.”<br />
That perception may be a bit deceptive, however. With annual<br />
agriculture imports of $2 billion—Cuba imports between 75<br />
percent and 80 percent of its food needs—any opening for U.S.<br />
products could quickly result in hundreds of millions of dollars<br />
in sales. Those are not tiny numbers for farmers in the U.S. South<br />
and Midwest, especially when you consider how a small shift in<br />
demand can make a big difference in price ceilings.<br />
Doug Keesling, a farmer from Chase, Kan., and former<br />
chairman of the Kansas Wheat Commission, notes that even<br />
a slight uptick in demand for an agricultural commodity can<br />
mean a critical shift in pricing—especially when supply exceeds<br />
demand. “Right now farmers in the U.S. are in an economic<br />
collapse because prices are so low,” says Keesling, who has traveled<br />
to Cuba six times. Keesling pointed to wheat, which had a<br />
bumper crop this year, producing 90 bushels per acre compared to<br />
45 bushels per acre last year. But farmers are only grossing $180<br />
per acre, compared to $260 an acre last year. By his reckoning, a<br />
fully open Cuba, with its 11 million consumers, could absorb 10<br />
percent of the Kansas wheat crop.<br />
“It’s all about supply and demand,” says Keesling, who has<br />
also farmed soybeans, corn, and grain sorghum. “Take 10 percent<br />
[of our wheat] and ship it to Cuba, and it will raise the prices. If<br />
it moved prices up 10 or 20 cents [a bushel] it would make the<br />
difference between being in the red or the black. So when we<br />
talk about selling 10 percent to a new market, it could make the<br />
difference between profit and loss. That is very important to the<br />
farmers and producers of America.”<br />
Like other members of USACC, Keesling is in favor of fully<br />
lifting of the embargo, if for no other reason than this would give<br />
Cuban farmers the ability to sell what they are best at growing—<br />
tropical fruits, for example—into the U.S. market, thereby giving<br />
them the income to buy more U.S. farm goods.<br />
USACC co-chair Paul Johnson, one of the founders of the<br />
coalition, also serves as executive director of the Illinois Cuba<br />
Working Group. Johnson’s company, Chicago Foods International,<br />
began shipping container loads of supermarket goods to Cuba<br />
in 2008—everything from canned meat to peanut butter. Since<br />
then, he has shifted his efforts to agriculture infrastructure projects<br />
aimed at helping Cuban farmers become more productive.<br />
“The approach we should take is one of comparative<br />
advantage,” Johnson says. “We should export what we do most<br />
efficiently, and import from Cuba what they do best.” Right now,<br />
60 percent of Cuban farming is devoted to sugar, tobacco and<br />
coffee, he notes. But Johnson suggests that shifting some of that<br />
farming to fruit and vegetable production could supply the winter<br />
needs of East Coast U.S. households. He also sees aquaculture as<br />
another source for Cuban export.<br />
“Illinois farmers are saying two things. The first is that I can<br />
bring my product to Cuba,” says Johnson. “The second is, ‘That
Photo courtesy of USACC<br />
Paul Johnson, one of the founders of the USACC, in Cuba: Two-way agriculture trade would be a win-win<br />
[Cuban] farmer reminds me of how our operations were 50 years<br />
ago. I can help that guy.’”<br />
As a businessman who benefitted from the Trade Sanctions<br />
Reform and Export Enhancement Act—the law that permitted<br />
food exports to Cuba after 2001—Johnson was deeply impressed<br />
with the power of the U.S. agriculture community.<br />
“A lot of the ag companies used their muscle to get the<br />
TSRA passed,” he says. “That’s what allowed me to export food<br />
products. If we could bring the power of agricultural interests and<br />
the states’ power together, we could really get something done.”<br />
Using that power<br />
That same rallying of forces described by Johnson also led to<br />
the creation of USACC in June 2014, about one year ahead of<br />
the re-establishment of diplomatic relations between the United<br />
States and Cuba.<br />
USACC’s Vorwerk has had a major role in pushing those<br />
efforts forward. A native of California’s Salinas Valley, and holder<br />
of degrees in agricultural economics from U.C. Davis and Cornell,<br />
Vorwerk began her career as an analyst at the World Bank,<br />
where she worked with in-country negotiators to implement<br />
agriculture agreements from the Uruguay Round of GATT (the<br />
General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade). That led to a position<br />
as an agriculture analyst with the International Trade Commission,<br />
where she helped produce a report in 2000 that examined<br />
the impact of removing U.S. sanctions against Cuba.<br />
“That’s where I got my first introduction to Cuba policy,”<br />
says Vorwerk. “I was a sugar analyst at the time, so I worked on<br />
the sugar chapter, which was significant.” She took that policy<br />
background to Cargill, where years later she was tasked with<br />
exploring Cuban markets as vice president for corporate affairs.<br />
Now, after a brief stint at Akin Gump, she is back at Cargill—<br />
where USACC got its start.<br />
“After having taken several trips down to Cuba, and having<br />
recognized how difficult it was to sell food to Cuba, and also<br />
understanding that the moment was right, I called a few people<br />
in the ag community and we decided that we wanted to form a<br />
coalition,” Vorwerk says.<br />
Today that coalition consists of more than three dozen<br />
national agriculture associations, agriculture councils from more<br />
than two dozen states, ag research centers, and a who's who of<br />
prominent agribusiness players such as ADM, Butterball, Sun-<br />
Maid, Smithfield Foods, and of course, Cargill.<br />
“Our interest is twofold,” says Van Yeutter, vice president of<br />
corporate affairs for Cargill. “<strong>One</strong> is on the policy level. We care<br />
about good policy at Cargill, and the notion of including food in<br />
a sanctions regime is inappropriate. Food should never be used as<br />
a foreign policy tool.”<br />
The second concern, Yeutter says, is economical. “Even<br />
though the Cuba market is small, it is a very logical market and<br />
the U.S. is a natural supplier,” he says. “To have U.S. farmers and<br />
ag producers cut out from that market doesn’t make sense… For<br />
many years Cargill was a supplier to Cuba, but when Helms-Bur-<br />
DEC 2016<br />
CUBATRADE<br />
65
The Lessons of<br />
CUBA<br />
<strong>One</strong> area where U.S. farmers can learn from their Cuba counterparts<br />
is in organic farming. When Mimi Arnstein visited the<br />
organic farms of Cuba, what stunned her most was how self-sufficient<br />
the farmers were.<br />
“They really have a much higher level of sustainability<br />
than what we call organic. They make U.S. farmers look like<br />
consumers,” says Arnstein, who runs a five-acre certified-organic<br />
spread in Vermont called Wellspring Farm. Whereas a<br />
U.S. organic farmer may require as much as half their ‘inputs’<br />
from outside the farm—everything from organic fertilizer to<br />
tractor parts to black plastic—the Cuban farmer draws from<br />
the farm itself. “It goes beyond organic to low-input agriculture,”<br />
says Arnstein. “They can’t go out and buy supplies, so they<br />
have to produce all their own fertilizer, and supply all their own<br />
mechanical effort. Basically, they have to provide 90 percent of<br />
their agriculture inputs from the farm. That is hard to do.”<br />
In addition to joining the USACC on its fact-finding<br />
missions to Cuba, Arnstein has led other groups to meet with,<br />
and learn from, Cuban farmers. “The farmers I have met are<br />
very welcoming, very willing to share their knowledge with<br />
farmers from the outside, and proud of what they have accomplished,”<br />
she says.<br />
Margarita Fernandez, director of the Vermont Caribbean<br />
Institute, has led more than 20 delegations to Cuba over<br />
the years. She also believes that small U.S. farmers have a lot<br />
to learn from small Cuban farmers, who have mastered the<br />
art of adapting to limited resources. “Cuba is a very special<br />
case, isolated as it has been from the global economy for so<br />
long,” she says. As far as their products go, Fernandez notes<br />
that Cuban farmers produce organic citrus, coffee, chocolate<br />
and honey, all of which are currently exported to Europe as<br />
certified organic products.<br />
US Agricultural Exports to Cuba. 2005. $326 million<br />
16% Wheat<br />
15% Corn<br />
20% Poultry Meat<br />
& Products<br />
US Agricultural Exports to Cuba. 2015. $150 million<br />
52% Poultry (78m)<br />
1% Other (2m)<br />
11% Rice<br />
11% Other<br />
3% Corn (5m)<br />
11% Soybeans<br />
7% Dairy<br />
Products<br />
5% Soybean<br />
Meal<br />
4% Soybean Oil<br />
36% Soybean meal<br />
(55m)<br />
6% Soybeans (10m)<br />
World Agricultural Exports to Cuba. 2014. $1.9 billion<br />
Photo courtesy of Mimi Arnstein<br />
14% Dairy Products<br />
10% Rice<br />
11% Corn<br />
13% Wheat<br />
10% Poultry Meat<br />
& Products<br />
8% Soybean<br />
Meal<br />
5% Soybean<br />
Oil<br />
5% Feed &<br />
Fodder<br />
24% Other<br />
Mimi Arnstein (bottom) at an organic farm in Cuba<br />
Source: FAS Global Agricultural Trade System; US Trade Representative<br />
66 CUBATRADE DEC 2016
World and U.S. Agricultural Exports to Cuba 2005-2014<br />
1799<br />
1873<br />
2000*<br />
1704<br />
1731<br />
1674<br />
World<br />
911<br />
947<br />
1114<br />
1350<br />
1175<br />
Source: FAS Global Agricultural Trade System,<br />
Global Trade Atlas<br />
All figures in millions. *Estimated<br />
326<br />
336 373<br />
658<br />
570<br />
394<br />
346<br />
417 415<br />
U.S.<br />
300<br />
150<br />
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015<br />
ton [the 1996 law that strengthened the embargo] came about,<br />
Cargill’s ability to supply Cuba was basically taken away. That was<br />
not a good thing.”<br />
The Helms-Burton Act, signed into law by President Bill<br />
Clinton as he campaigned to win votes in Florida, not only<br />
tightened the embargo against Cuba but made it permanent, to<br />
be lifted only by an act of Congress.<br />
What’s at Stake<br />
Proponents of lifting the embargo note that while the size<br />
of the agricultural market in Cuba is not immense, it is sizeable<br />
enough to make an impact for specific agricultural sectors.<br />
Among these, few would see a more immediate impact than rice.<br />
Although U.S. rice production is dwarfed by that of China, India,<br />
Indonesia and Vietnam, those countries consume most of what<br />
they grow, while a huge percentage of U.S. rice is exported.<br />
“Having export markets is critical for American rice farmers,<br />
because half our rice is exported,” says Alice Gomez, a consultant<br />
for the U.S. Rice Producers Association (USRPA). “That is why<br />
we need to feed people like Cubans, because that means a new<br />
market. We may be number eleven worldwide in terms of acres of<br />
rice produced, but we are sending a lot of rice everywhere.”<br />
The USRPA has been working toward lifting trade restrictions<br />
on Cuba since it was formed 20 years ago, and helped push<br />
for the Trade Sanctions Reform Act that permitted food and<br />
medical shipments to Cuba.<br />
“During the first four years, when Cuba was able to buy, they<br />
bought enough rice to bring shipments back to high levels,” says<br />
Gomez. “But because of the reinterpretation [of TSRA] under<br />
the Bush Administration, we saw those rice shipments drop to<br />
zero.” That critical reinterpretation in 2005 required Cuba to pay<br />
cash up front—even before products were loaded—along with<br />
restrictions on using American banks.<br />
“We [the U.S.] extend credit all over the world, its part and<br />
parcel of trade,” says Gomez. “It’s an arcane provision that Cubans<br />
have to pay cash in advance, and use third-country banking<br />
institutions to pay.” That last element is particularly onerous,<br />
because Cuban banks are not allowed to have accounts in U.S.<br />
financial institutions.<br />
“Cuba was the top destination for U.S. rice pre-embargo,”<br />
notes Michael Kline, vice president for communications at USA<br />
Rice, which advocates for most of the industry, including millers,<br />
merchants and farmers. “We have always looked forward to the<br />
day we could return to this market. Why this hasn’t happened is<br />
the 600,000 metric ton question … you’d be hard-pressed to find<br />
someone who says the embargo has worked.”<br />
Lost to the Competition<br />
What riles many U.S. farmers is how foreign competitors are<br />
supplying Cuba with products they feel should be their sale. U.S.<br />
Wheat Associates estimates that Cuba imports 75 percent of its<br />
wheat from Europe and 25 percent from Canada. Total annual<br />
imports: Somewhere around 800,000 metric tons, currently<br />
valued at about $200 million a year.<br />
“We’ve been working on this issue for almost two decades<br />
as an organization, trying to do business in Cuba,” says Ben<br />
Conner, deputy director of policy for U.S. Wheat Associates,<br />
which develops export markets for wheat farmers. When TSRA<br />
DEC 2016<br />
CUBATRADE<br />
67
Illinois soy farmer Mark Albertson on a USACC trip to Cuba: We can regain the market<br />
was implemented in 2001, sales of U.S. wheat to Cuba, like rice,<br />
began to grow—until the Bush Administration changed the<br />
payment rules.<br />
“Prior to 2005 ‘cash in advance’ meant you could ship the<br />
product and once it got to the port, before unloading, the Cubans<br />
could pay for it,” says Conner. “Then in 2005 OFAC said that<br />
cash in advance meant that cash had to be paid even before the<br />
wheat got on the ships. That is highly unusual and increases commercial<br />
risk. It also exacerbated their cash problems.” Couple that<br />
with the U.S. prohibition on financing and, by 2011, wheat sales<br />
to Cuba had hit zero, where they have remained.<br />
Conner was part of a USACC delegation that went to<br />
Cuba in March of 2015, “a good will and fact finding mission,<br />
taking the first steps toward seeing the possibilities for trade in<br />
both directions.” In Cuba, Conner, Vorwerk and other USACC<br />
delegates met with the president of Alimport, Cuba’s state import<br />
agency, as well as farm groups.<br />
“Cuba is the largest wheat importer in the Caribbean,” says<br />
Conner. “Of all the U.S. commodities looking to get into Cuba,<br />
wheat has the most opportunity for growth, especially in the<br />
short term. There could be big demand for it in Cuba.”<br />
U.S. Advantage<br />
Wheat and rice are not the only U.S. ag products that Cuba<br />
needs. There is also a big demand for poultry and soy, so much<br />
so that despite the financial restrictions, they continue to buy<br />
these products from the United States.<br />
Mark Albertson is an Illinois soy farmer who participated in<br />
the USACC trips to Cuba, and who also directs strategic market<br />
development for Illinois Soybean Growers. “Chicken is the No. 1<br />
thing that Cuba imports from the U.S. right now, and soy is No.<br />
2,” says Albertson. Last year, Cuba imported $78 million worth<br />
of U.S. poultry and $65 million worth of soybean meal and oil.<br />
While those are not inconsequential numbers, they could be<br />
higher; Cuba imported in excess of $250 million worth of soy<br />
products last year, for example. “As soon as we can extend credit<br />
we think we can regain all of that market share,” says Albertson.<br />
“The industry standard is up to 180 days, but right now we can’t<br />
extend one day of credit.”<br />
Like other USACC members, Albertson’s soy association is<br />
in favor of ending the embargo, since that also would allow Cuban<br />
imports into the United States. Albertson says this is vital, because<br />
without products coming back in the shipping containers, cost goes<br />
up. “We don’t have back hauls,” Albertson says. “When we sell<br />
products to Cuba, those ships come back empty. And that means<br />
that you are paying for the freight twice. When you are dealing<br />
with ag products like soybean, freight is a big part of the cost.”<br />
Even with the added cost of empty containers coming home,<br />
proximity still provides advantages to the United States, including<br />
freshness and delivery on demand. “<strong>One</strong> consideration is the<br />
lack of storage capacity in Cuba,” says USA Rice’s Klein. “When<br />
they unload a boat from Vietnam, 15,000 to 20,000 tons of rice<br />
may be more than they can deal with—versus when they call us<br />
and say, ‘Send 1,000 or 2,000 tons,’ and can have it in a few days<br />
instead of three weeks.”<br />
68 CUBATRADE DEC 2016
Chicken is the number one thing that<br />
Cuba imports from the U.S. right now,<br />
and soy is number two.<br />
Mark Albertson, strategic market development,<br />
Illinois Soybean Association<br />
Soybean harvest in the Autumn
Photo courtesy of USACC<br />
Tobacco farmers in Cuba attend a meeting with members of the USACC<br />
A Cooperative Effort<br />
<strong>One</strong> of the hallmarks of the push to lift the embargo against<br />
Cuba has been its bipartisan nature. In the divisive political<br />
climate of the Obama years, few legislative initiatives have been<br />
supported by both major parties. Cuba is an exception.<br />
On both a state and national level, the move to lift the embargo<br />
has engendered a spirit of bipartisan cooperation. When<br />
Paul Johnson spearheaded the Illinois Cuba Working Group, it<br />
was endorsed unanimously by the state legislature, as Johnson<br />
put it, “bringing together downstate Republicans and downtown<br />
Chicago Democrats. They all agreed.”<br />
When Arkansas’s Republican Rep. Rick Crawford sponsored<br />
a bill to eliminate the financial restrictions, it was co-sponsored<br />
by Democratic colleagues.<br />
“I think it is important for Americans to know that this is<br />
an American issue, not a one-party issue or a one-state issue,”<br />
says Vorwerk. “For so long, we have yielded this policy to a<br />
narrow group. I am not a Cuban American, I am an American,<br />
and as an American I want us to be able to work toward reconciliation.”<br />
For the USACC, the idea of cooperation extends beyond<br />
the bipartisan politics in Washington. The opening of agricultural<br />
trade is also a cooperative effort between U.S. and Cuban<br />
farmers, in a way that is unprecedented between U.S. and foreign<br />
growers. “I think the opportunities are mutually beneficial,” says<br />
Mike Espy, who served as secretary of agriculture during the<br />
Clinton administration, and who was part of the USACC team<br />
which negotiated a memorandum of understanding (MOU) with<br />
the Grupo Empresarial Agricola, Cuba’s farm industry association,<br />
in May of this year.<br />
“We are in a position to deliver food and ag products to<br />
Cuba at a tremendous savings,” Espy says. “They can benefit from<br />
our value-added foods, our technology, and our equipment. In a<br />
reciprocal way, we could import their fresh fruits and vegetables,<br />
and learn what they can teach us about sustainable farming.”<br />
The MOU that Vorwerk and her team hammered out covers<br />
a common agenda, including devising solutions for finance credits<br />
and two-way trade, as well as for exchanges involving direct<br />
investments, sustainability, research and development, and farmer<br />
training. “When we signed the MOU, we set up a framework to<br />
continue the dialogue,” Vorwerk says. And USACC shared its<br />
success with members of Congress.<br />
“In everything we do, whether it’s a trip or a speech, or<br />
whether it’s going up to the Hill, we are using our collective<br />
experience, that collective force of the private sector, that knows<br />
how to do business,” Vorwerk says. “We use all of that to inform<br />
Congress, so that they can make the right decision. This embargo<br />
needs to end.” H<br />
70 CUBATRADE DEC 2016
ARKANSAS<br />
LEADS THE<br />
CHARGE<br />
How <strong>One</strong> State is<br />
Spearheading the<br />
Effort to Open<br />
Agriculture Trade<br />
with Cuba<br />
Gov. Asa Hutchinson's<br />
historic trip to Havana<br />
Sen. John Boozman’s<br />
bill to lift restrictions<br />
Rep. Rick Crawford’s<br />
push in the House<br />
Arkansas Governor Asa Hutchinson
Arkansas: Outfront on Cuba Trade<br />
Arkansas is leading the U.S. in economic and agricultural collaboration with Cuba. And because<br />
Arkansas is the nation’s number one producer of rice as well as a national leader in poultry, we’re<br />
a natural for sprinting to the front of the pack when it comes to food-source trade with Cuba.<br />
In Arkansas, we’re proud to help our neighbors to the south by sharing our resources and our<br />
expertise — which in the end will help both economies to grow and prosper.<br />
72 CUBATRADE DEC 2016
ARKANSAS<br />
AGRICULTURE<br />
DEPARTMENT<br />
aad.arkansas.gov<br />
DEC 2016<br />
CUBATRADE<br />
73
ARKANSASREPORT<br />
If you are not from Arkansas, you might not understand why Asa Hutchinson<br />
was the first U.S. governor to visit Cuba after the resumption of diplomatic<br />
relations in December 2014. If you are from Arkansas, then you get it<br />
immediately. “Between 30 and 40 percent of the commodities we raise in<br />
Arkansas are exported,” says Randy Veach, president of the Arkansas Farm<br />
Bureau. “And agriculture is the largest industry in our state. That is why we have<br />
paid a lot of attention to Cuban trade opportunities.”<br />
For Mark Isbell, a fourth generation Arkansas rice farmer,<br />
the logic is inescapable: Half of the rice in the U.S. is produced<br />
in his state, and the island of Cuba—with the highest per capita<br />
consumption of rice in the Americas—should be its natural<br />
market. In fact, it once was. Before the U.S. embargo began in<br />
1960, Cuba was Arkansas’ largest export market.<br />
“As a farmer you don’t typically export rice yourself, that’s<br />
done through the mill and the distributor,” says Isbell, whose<br />
family farms 3,000 acres outside of North Little Rock. “But<br />
based on the quantities Cuba was buying pre-embargo, I’m sure<br />
that some of the rice my grandfather grew made it there through<br />
the supply chain.”<br />
Taking back that Cuban<br />
market, with its annual demand of<br />
some 600,000 metric tons of rice,<br />
would make a critical difference for<br />
Arkansas rice farmers now facing<br />
their lowest prices in years. “We have<br />
seen price reductions as much as<br />
40 percent over the last three years,<br />
down to $4.50 a bushel. A few years<br />
back you could sell it for $7.25,” says<br />
Isbell.<br />
The fact that an increase in<br />
demand could mean the difference<br />
between profit and loss for thousands<br />
of rice farmers was a big reason that<br />
Gov. Hutchinson visited the island in<br />
the spring of 2015. A second reason<br />
was poultry, Cuba’s top import from<br />
the U.S., and a leading commodity<br />
produced in Arkansas.<br />
“It’s an opportunity for Arkansas<br />
to open up the market in Cuba,<br />
and I also think reengagement<br />
with Cuba is right from a political<br />
standpoint,” says Gov. Hutchinson.<br />
While he supported the embargo as<br />
a Republican congressman, “I have<br />
a different view as governor,” says<br />
Hutchinson. “You see it over time<br />
and you see the opportunities.”<br />
For Michael Preston, Arkansas’<br />
director of economic development, the search for global markets<br />
stretches as far as China. But Cuba, says Preston, holds a special<br />
place for the state. “We’ve had a historical trade relationship with<br />
Cuba, a strong history of trade with Cuba, and we can bring<br />
that back,” says Preston, one of the architects of the Governor’s<br />
precedent-setting trip. “Arkansas is one of the leading states in<br />
the country for agriculture production, number one for rice, and<br />
number two for poultry. Cuba just makes a lot of sense.”<br />
The fact that Arkansas is a staunchly red state made no<br />
difference to Gov. Hutchinson, who transcended party politics to<br />
support the Obama administration’s efforts to reopen trade with<br />
Cuba—one reason that Hutchinson, with a 62 percent approval<br />
rating, is among the most popular<br />
governors in the country.<br />
Agriculture is the largest<br />
industry in our state. It's a<br />
huge, huge economic engine.<br />
“We were very proud of the<br />
Governor for making that trip,” says<br />
Ben Noble, executive director of the<br />
Arkansas Rice Federation. “It was a<br />
bit of policy change for Hutchinson,<br />
since he served [as DEA director]<br />
under the Bush administration, whose<br />
policies were in the other direction.”<br />
Noble projects that if the Cuban<br />
market for rice were to reopen that<br />
Arkansas could realize $100 million<br />
in sales within a year. “It’s significant.<br />
It could easily put us in a position<br />
where they are right back as one of<br />
our top markets,” says Noble, himself<br />
a third generation rice farmer. “I<br />
remember when my dad used to talk<br />
about rice sales to Cuba.”<br />
Statewide Push<br />
Hutchinson is not alone among<br />
Arkansas politicians pushing<br />
to roll back the most damaging<br />
elements of the embargo, including<br />
the prohibitions against financing<br />
agriculture sales. Also spurring<br />
Congress to action are Arkansas Sen.<br />
John Boozman and Arkansas Rep.<br />
74 CUBATRADE DEC 2016<br />
Randy Veach, President, Arkansas Farm Bureau
We had a historic trade relationship<br />
with Cuba… we can bring that back.<br />
Michael Preston<br />
Executive Director Arkansas Economic<br />
Development Commission<br />
Mel Torres, head of Latin America for the Arkansas World Trade Center,<br />
at the Hotel Nacional: We have excellent relations with the government<br />
Gov. Asa Hutchinson at a Cohiba factory in Havana:<br />
Trade with Cuba has to be two way so that both the<br />
U.S. and Cuba can benefit<br />
DEC 2016<br />
CUBATRADE<br />
75
Out in Front<br />
Gov. Asa Hutchinson has made it his<br />
mission to open new markets abroad for<br />
the highly productive farmers of Arkansas.<br />
We spoke with him about that endeavor<br />
in Cuba, and what it means for the state’s<br />
agriculture industry.<br />
Cuba Trade: Before your trip to Cuba, did you have an<br />
epiphany where you said, "The embargo is not working<br />
anymore. We have to change our policy"?<br />
Gov. Hutchinson: What I've said is the first step that we<br />
ought to take is to lift the credit restrictions… I believe<br />
that the legislation sponsored by Rep. Crawford and Sen. Boozman, which is directed at<br />
the credit side, is our best opportunity. So that's what I pushed. I was not pushing<br />
for a full lifting of the embargo. Let’s do this first step<br />
and let's see what the response is by Cuba.<br />
Cuba Trade: As a Republican governor you were fairly out front on this issue. Did you<br />
face any sort of blowback for supporting the initiative of a Democratic president?<br />
Gov. Hutchinson: Minimal. It was well received in Arkansas, because Arkansas has always<br />
had a worldview on trade... You asked me a minute ago whether there was any epiphany.<br />
I think it was just a studied response to history and where we need to go as a nation.<br />
Cuba Trade: On your trip to Cuba, how were your meetings with government officials?<br />
Gov. Hutchinson: The Cuban government officials are still talking about the revolution<br />
and the principles of the revolution, and how they want the embargo [unilaterally]<br />
lifted… [however] beyond them making their points to us, they were very constructive<br />
meetings.<br />
Cuba Trade: Do you think we should require political concessions from Cuba before<br />
lifting the embargo?<br />
Gov. Hutchinson: Well, there are a lot of underlying issues that have to be resolved… I<br />
think that before the embargo would be [fully] lifted there needs to be some sort of<br />
resolution of the Cuban claims against the United States and vice-versa.<br />
Cuba Trade: Has there been any net change since your visit, in terms of shipments or<br />
commodities coming out of Arkansas.<br />
Gov. Hutchinson: Within one month of my return to the United States, Cuba purchased<br />
4,500 tons of [Arkansas] poultry, which was with Simmons Foods who was<br />
with me on the trip and Tyson. So that was a very tangible success. I haven't had any<br />
other reports of sales, but hopefully it will continue.<br />
Cuba Trade: What does the future hold for Arkansas and Cuba?<br />
Gov. Hutchinson: We are aggressively continuing our efforts to have a presence there…<br />
Arkansas wants to be in a position to be first in line to market our rice and poultry and<br />
have exchanges. But it’s not just that. We've got business people looking at opportunities<br />
there. And we want to make it a two-way street so that Cuba can benefit from it, as<br />
well.<br />
Cuba Trade: Do you think more open trade will liberalize the Cuban regime?<br />
Gov. Hutchinson: Well that's our hope, and certainly, it has to be acknowledged that the<br />
Cuban regime has been oppressive. And we should not ignore that side of the equation.<br />
So the objective is not just to open up our trade to benefit ourselves, but the objective<br />
is also to create an environment with more freedoms for the Cuban people.<br />
Rick Crawford. Both introduced bills<br />
to Congress to change the restrictions<br />
that make it all but impossible to do<br />
business with Cuba.<br />
“Nationwide, the rice industry<br />
accounts for 125,000 jobs and<br />
contributes more than $34 billion the<br />
U.S. economy,” said Boozman on the<br />
Senate floor earlier this year. “Rice<br />
farmers all across America would<br />
benefit from a change in policy with<br />
Cuba.”<br />
While rice is the poster child for<br />
trade between Arkansas and Cuba,<br />
it is far from the only player. On the<br />
agriculture side there is also chicken,<br />
a big ticket item for a state with a<br />
chicken population of 123 million.<br />
Even with the embargo in place,<br />
Cuba bought $147.5 million worth of<br />
chicken in 2014 from the U.S.—and<br />
$1 billion worth over the past 15<br />
years—mostly in the form of ‘broilers’<br />
for consumption, versus poultry for<br />
breeding or egg laying.<br />
Accompanying the governor<br />
to Cuba was Mark Simmons, the<br />
president and CEO of Simmons<br />
Foods, one of Arkansas’ top poultry<br />
producers. At the time of the trip<br />
Arkansas was still on the list of banned<br />
providers, a holdover from the days<br />
of the avian flu. “We met with their<br />
importers and got that ban removed,”<br />
says Simmons. “Shortly thereafter we<br />
were able to ship a boatload of product<br />
into Cuba, and subsequently we made<br />
two more shipments.”<br />
In all, Tyson sold Cuba about<br />
18 million pounds of chicken worth<br />
approximately $5 million. But don’t<br />
assume you’ll be eating any Arkansas<br />
chicken if you travel to Cuba, says<br />
Simmons. “If you go into a private<br />
restaurant in Cuba, our product is<br />
not in those channels. Our product<br />
is primarily leg quarters going into<br />
national food distribution by the<br />
government. We are missing out on<br />
a huge segment of the consumption<br />
there that is going to grow as Cuba<br />
opens up to the U.S. [tourists].”<br />
Beyond agriculture there are other<br />
opportunities, such as technologies<br />
where Arkansas has competitive<br />
advantages that match Cuban<br />
demand. The state’s number one<br />
non-agricultural industry, for example,<br />
76 CUBATRADE DEC 2016
SAM WALTON<br />
DIDN’T DISCOUNT<br />
ARKANSAS.<br />
It wasn’t by accident that Sam Walton chose Arkansas to launch his idea of a store featuring everyday,<br />
low-priced goods. He knew that this was the perfect place to build what would become the world’s<br />
largest retailer. Now Arkansas is channeling the same pioneering spirit behind companies like Walmart<br />
as we lead the United States in building business relationships in Cuba. That forward-looking vision<br />
and an attractive business climate are enabling industries from around the globe to find themselves<br />
in Good Company here.<br />
Sam Walton, Founder<br />
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.<br />
ArkansasEDC.com | 1-800-ARKANSAS<br />
DEC 2016<br />
CUBATRADE<br />
77
ARKANSASREPORT<br />
Rep. Rick Crawford (standing, right) talks to U.S. Ambassador-nominee to Cuba Jeffrey DeLaurentis (standing, left) during a meeting at the Embassy in Havana<br />
is aerospace equipment and services; here Arkansas could help<br />
with the upgrade of Cuba’s aviation facilities, currently being<br />
contracted to French and Russian companies.<br />
Another area of expertise is renewable energy—a priority<br />
for Cuba—which is why Bradley Mannis joined the governor’s<br />
mission to Cuba. Mannis is the CEO of Mannco Environmental,<br />
which installs wastewater treatment systems that turn the leftover<br />
sludge into organic fertilizers. “I saw multiple economic opportunities<br />
in Cuba,” says Mannis. “There is certainly a big opportunity<br />
for private investment because the infrastructure needs huge<br />
work.”<br />
Mannis has been invited back to Cuba several times, and has<br />
hosted Cuban officials in Little Rock, but so far has concluded no<br />
deals. The problem, he says, is the U.S. prohibition against using<br />
lines of credit. The inability to finance infrastructure projects—<br />
standard operating procedure in the U.S.—makes them almost<br />
impossible to execute.<br />
Even when capital is not an issue, the presence of the<br />
embargo—and all the legal, banking, and political challenges it<br />
imposes—is enough to kill most potential deals.<br />
Burt Hanna, CEO of Hanna’s Candle Company, traveled<br />
with the governor and has been back several times, including<br />
twice this year. Hanna’s firm manufactures up to 60 million<br />
candles a year in Arkansas, and can easily meet Cuba’s needs.<br />
“They make 10 million candles a year and they need 20 million<br />
more,” says Hanna.<br />
What Hanna proposed—and for which he signed an<br />
MOU—was to supply $1 million in manufacturing gear to a<br />
Cuban candle manufacturing company in exchange for half the<br />
profits. With his equipment, the factory could produce 6,000<br />
candlesticks an hour with two workers. “I don’t think anybody<br />
can change the world with candles, but we’d like to be a little part<br />
of it,” says Hanna. But until the embargo is lifted, he’s going to<br />
wait on the sidelines.<br />
Another frustrated investor who has traveled to Cuba<br />
repeatedly is Arkansas real estate developer Bruce Barrow,<br />
who launched a company called U.S. Cuba Holdings—only<br />
to find U.S. restrictions to be impenetrable. Beyond real estate<br />
development, he has lobbied the federal government to consider<br />
oil drilling off the coast of Cuba, only to be ignored. “I brought<br />
back maps and met with [various government officials],” says<br />
Barrow. “I never heard another word…. Someday you will wake<br />
up and there will be an oil derrick in the Gulf with the name of a<br />
Chinese or Iranian company on it.”<br />
A Warm Reception<br />
Barrow contends that most Americans are woefully ignorant<br />
about Cuba and its people. “I got down there and got off the<br />
plane and said, ‘Boy, have we been lied to.’ I expected sand bags<br />
and Beirut. But the reception was beyond belief.” Unlike his<br />
fellow Arkansans who want to open the market, Barrow says the<br />
78 CUBATRADE DEC 2016
Gov. Hutchinson (center) and Michael Preston<br />
(center front): At play with a Cuban team<br />
Wes Ward, Arkansas’ Secretary of Agriculture: Lifting the embargo is a step-by-step process<br />
View of the Capitol along the Arkansas River.<br />
DEC 2016<br />
CUBATRADE<br />
79
Crawford's Campaign<br />
Rep. Crawford (left, standing) at aCuban market.<br />
<strong>One</strong> of the leading proponents of changing the U.S. relationship<br />
with Cuba is Arkansas Congressman Rick Crawford<br />
The long march to lift trade restrictions with Cuba gained momentum<br />
earlier this year, when bill HR 3687—designed to lift the ban on agriculture<br />
credit purchases by Cuba—was successfully attached to a major house<br />
Financial Services appropriations bill with bipartisan support. While the<br />
bill was later withdrawn under intense pressure by Florida’s congressional<br />
delegation (with an agreement to bring it back next year), it was still a<br />
watershed moment for Arkansas Rep. Rick Crawford, who co-sponsored the<br />
bill.<br />
“I’ve been an advocate of this for a long time, working with Arkansas<br />
agriculture, and seeing the value proposition for our state,” says Crawford.<br />
“We are not trying to make a judgement in favor of Castro, or against<br />
Obama, this is just what is best for both countries.”<br />
Crawford is quick to point out the hypocrisy of the Cuban trade embargo.<br />
“It’s inconsistent with our relationship with China since 1972, even with<br />
the Soviet Union during the Cold War. In 1985 the US had $2.3 billion in<br />
exports to the Soviet Union, and that was at the height of the Cold War,”<br />
he says. “We fought a hot war with Vietnam for many years, but since 2001<br />
we have seen exports to Vietnam increase 1,200 percent. What has changed<br />
there? They are still a communist regime.”<br />
As for his withdrawn bill, says Crawford, “I will try to move it after the<br />
election in the lame duck section. Who knows? We might be able to get our<br />
heads together and push this across the finish line. I’m an optimist.”<br />
better play is to invest. “We have all these<br />
people running down there to sell things<br />
to Cuba, but they have no money to buy…<br />
My focus is not to go down and sell, but<br />
to create joint ventures that will create a<br />
new future.”<br />
Like Barrow, economic development<br />
director Preston did not know what to<br />
expect on the trip to Cuba. “Going down<br />
there for the first time myself I was a<br />
little apprehensive. What are we about to<br />
embark on? It’s not a country that we have<br />
dealt with. But I can’t say enough about<br />
the Cuban people and their friendliness<br />
and their welcome for us. The government<br />
officials as well… Everywhere we went we<br />
were greeted with good wishes and open<br />
arms.”<br />
As part of the Arkansas-Cuba<br />
diplomacy, Preston and the governor both<br />
played a game of basketball with a Cuban<br />
team. Despite the governor’s greying<br />
hair, he is in remarkable physical shape—<br />
something which allows him to maintain<br />
his punishing pace as a governor who<br />
likes to engage with people. Among his<br />
weekly routines is a 7 am Friday morning<br />
basketball game with staff, including<br />
Preston.<br />
“<strong>One</strong> of the fun things we did [in<br />
Cuba] was play basketball,” says the<br />
Governor. “I like pickup basketball but<br />
this was a little bit more of an organized<br />
game than I expected. And they were nice<br />
to me. They treated me like they thought<br />
a governor should be treated—a little<br />
too gingerly at first.” When Hutchinson<br />
noticed that they weren’t blocking his<br />
shots, “we actually called a timeout to say<br />
that it’s okay to foul me!”<br />
Long Term Relationships<br />
When Cuba held its annual International<br />
Fair in November, where companies from<br />
around the world set up shop at the vast<br />
ExpoCuba center outside of Havana, Arkansas’<br />
representative was Mel Torres, the<br />
head of Latin America for the Arkansas<br />
World Trade Center. While his booth<br />
carried sample bags of the state’s coveted<br />
long-grain rice, Torres was in Havana primarily<br />
to continue the dialogue with Cuba<br />
which the Governor’s trip jumpstarted.<br />
“Right now, when we talk about<br />
doing business with Cuba, we are<br />
talking about doing business with the<br />
government,” says Torres, “And we have<br />
80 CUBATRADE DEC 2016
Arkansas<br />
International Business Services<br />
Specialized global business analysis & guidance<br />
Expert trade development<br />
Customized international research<br />
Newsletters and international briefings<br />
Why Arkansas and the<br />
World Trade Center Arkansas<br />
Global recruitment and trade are key elements of Governor Asa Hutchinson strategic<br />
plan for economic development. The Arkansas Economic Development Commission<br />
is committed to attracting and retaining the best companies and the most advanced<br />
industries from around the world. Arkansas has key strategies for international<br />
activities and foreign direct investment and trade. The World Trade Center<br />
Arkansas global business development activities include:<br />
Investment promotion and targeted marketing<br />
Partnership development and collaboration<br />
Business 2 Business Matchmaking<br />
Project management<br />
Trade Research<br />
Educational Exchange<br />
Business, Embassy and Government contacts<br />
Personal introductions in foreign markets<br />
Trade mission attendance opportunities<br />
Personalized WTC Membership Card<br />
Professional Development & Networking<br />
Global Business Exchange<br />
International Connections<br />
3300 Market Street Suite 400<br />
Rogers Arkansas 72758<br />
479-418-4800 • www.arwtc.org
Sen. Boozman’s Bill<br />
After years of trying, Arkansan Sen. John<br />
Boozman was able to attach his bill easing trade<br />
restrictions with Cuba to the 2017 Senate appropriations<br />
bill. Next comes the lame duck session.<br />
“I was elected to Congress in<br />
2001 and became a member<br />
of the Cuba working group,<br />
which was half Democrat and<br />
half Republican. We were of<br />
the belief that we should be<br />
able to trade with Cuba like<br />
the rest of the world,” says<br />
Arkansas Republican Sen. John<br />
Boozman.<br />
Flash forward 15 years, and<br />
Boozman’s conviction finally<br />
materialized. Earlier this year, an<br />
amendment to allow American<br />
farmers to use private financing<br />
for exporting commodities to<br />
Cuba successfully passed the<br />
Senate Committee on Appropriations<br />
by a 22-to-8 vote.<br />
“Everyone felt we were doing<br />
the same thing [the embargo]<br />
for decades and nothing was<br />
happening,” says Boozman.<br />
“I think the way to change<br />
the world is through person<br />
relationships,” including<br />
business relationships. “We<br />
trade with people with a lot<br />
worse human rights records<br />
[than Cuba].”<br />
Sen. Boozman<br />
I think too that<br />
if you lifted the<br />
embargo today<br />
Cuba would not<br />
be ready for it. I<br />
think it’s going<br />
now at a steady<br />
pace and we are<br />
moving in the<br />
right direction.<br />
What happens next with Boozman’s amendment, which<br />
was co-sponsored by Montana Democrat Sen. Jon Tester,<br />
is that it becomes part of the final appropriations bill for<br />
next year, hammered out between the Senate and the<br />
House.<br />
“It’s a good feeling in the sense that we have gotten this<br />
far,” says Boozman. “But it will come to a head before the<br />
new year.”<br />
While Boozman feels that the process of rapprochement<br />
with Cuba is now like “a snow ball going down a hill,”<br />
he also believes that it will take more steps before the<br />
embargo is fully lifted. “I think too that if you lifted the<br />
embargo today Cuba would not be ready for it. I think it’s<br />
going now at a steady pace and we are moving in the right<br />
direction.”<br />
an excellent relationship with the Cuban government. We both<br />
have products the other wants, and we want to do business<br />
immediately. But we can’t because of the embargo.”<br />
Having said that, Arkansas is intent on growing its<br />
relationship with Cuba for the time when the embargo is lifted.<br />
Having organized the private sector trade-mission part of the<br />
Governor’s 2015 visit, Arkansas’ WTC has since arranged a visit<br />
by Cuban embassy officials to Little Rock and has led other trade<br />
missions to the island; they have also engineered the signing of<br />
several MOUs between Arkansas and Cuba.<br />
“We encourage educational exchanges, including professor<br />
and student exchanges, in addition to commercial match making<br />
and trade,” says Torres. “And it’s far from one-sided. There are<br />
many things where Cuba can supply the expertise—they have<br />
done a lot of R&D on farming organically—and they have great<br />
products that would be very appealing to the U.S. market. There<br />
are multiple synergies.”<br />
When it comes to the technology of rice and chicken<br />
growing, however, the University of Arkansas is in a class of its<br />
own—and happy to share its expertise.<br />
Dr. Mark Cochran, vice president for agriculture at the U<br />
of A, travelled with the governor to Cuba last year and returned<br />
again this past summer. As the head of agriculture research at the<br />
university, he is a proponent of intellectual exchanges with Cuba.<br />
“We are eager to play a role in creating opportunities. We are<br />
looking at faculty and student exchanges, research collaborations,<br />
and a visit from Cuban poultry scientists to spend time in our<br />
poultry labs,” he says. With its Center of Excellence for Poultry<br />
Science, U of A has a lot to offer, says Cochran. “The science<br />
behind poultry production is quite sophisticated. The notion that<br />
you have chickens running around in the yard isn’t realistic.”<br />
On the other hand, says Cochran, U of A researchers<br />
would like to learn how Cuban poultry growers have done with<br />
fewer antibiotics, as well as fewer fossil fuel inputs into their<br />
farming methods. “We are interested in what we can learn from<br />
them about that, and they can learn from us, and that is a good<br />
foundation for building relations.”<br />
To that end, one of the university’s leading rice scientists,<br />
Dr. Eric Wailes, spent three weeks in Cuba this past spring<br />
researching the rice sector. Wailes said he looked at all aspects—<br />
from growers to millers to storage to open market stores—to<br />
see how the industry might be improved. While there could be<br />
bigger yields with better genetic stock, Wailes concluded that<br />
Cuba could not develop the same kind of competitive advantages<br />
with rice that it enjoys with sugar, tobacco, coffee and tropical<br />
fruits.<br />
The other thing he discovered was that, given the choice,<br />
Cubans prefer the kinds of rice grown in Brazil and Arkansas,<br />
rather than the rice that is currently being imported from<br />
Vietnam, thanks to its generous credit terms.<br />
“Vietnamese rice is not of the quality of U.S. rice,” says<br />
Wailes. “When it’s been on a boat for a couple of months,<br />
and milled months before that, there is a deterioration of<br />
quality. So we have two things going versus Vietnam—quality<br />
competitiveness and logistic competitiveness.”<br />
The real competition is coming from Brazil, however, which<br />
has not only been exporting to the Cuban market for years, but<br />
also paid for the buildout of the Port of Mariel and retrofitted<br />
82 CUBATRADE DEC 2016
Arkansas: The State of Agriculture<br />
State Agriculture Overview<br />
Number of Farms ................43,500<br />
Acres Operated .............13.8 million<br />
Total Value of Ag Products Sold: $9.7 billion<br />
Livestock: $4.9 billion<br />
Total Crops: ........ $4.8 billion<br />
Source: USDA National Agriculture Statistic Service, as of January 2016<br />
Livestock<br />
Chicken .....................962 million<br />
Turkeys. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 27.4 million<br />
Cows .........................2.7 million<br />
Hogs ............................166,000<br />
Crops Produced (2015, value)<br />
Soybeans $1.47 billion<br />
Rice $1.10 billion<br />
Corn $330 million<br />
Sorghum $187 million<br />
Cotton $136 million<br />
Wheat $70 million<br />
Sweet Potatoes $20 million<br />
VAN<br />
BUREN<br />
FORT<br />
SMITH<br />
POULTRY<br />
ARKANSAS RIVER<br />
LITTLE<br />
ROCK<br />
R<br />
I C E<br />
From the ports of Fort Smith,<br />
Little Rock and West Memphis,<br />
commodities can head down the<br />
Arkansas and Misssissippi Rivers to<br />
New Orleans and from there to Cuba.<br />
Top Agricultural Exports (2014, value)<br />
Soybeans $995.5 million<br />
Rice $809.3 million<br />
Broiler Meat $475 million<br />
Cotton $245.8 million<br />
Soybean Meal $229 million<br />
S O Y B E A N S<br />
MISSISSIPPI RIVER<br />
OSCEOLA<br />
WEST<br />
MEMPHIS<br />
Source: USDA National Agriculture Statistic Service, as of January 2016<br />
Source: USDA ERS<br />
DEC 2016<br />
CUBATRADE<br />
83
Gary "Baseball" Heathcott<br />
Gary Heathcott, accepts the Man of the Year award at the Habanos Festival .<br />
A long-time political advisor to the Governor, Gary Heathcott is<br />
Arkansas’ Mr. Cuba.<br />
For each of the last 18 years an audience of well-heeled business leaders<br />
from some 60 countries, along with celebrities from the worlds of film, art<br />
and fashion, have gathered in Havana for the Habanos Festival. The event is<br />
a celebration of the Cuban cigar—and a fundraiser for the Cuban healthcare<br />
system. In 2015, $540 million euros were raised, including from the auction of<br />
rare, handcrafted humidors.<br />
That year also marked another event: The first time an American won the<br />
presitigious Man of the Year award. Before an audience of 1,600 (including<br />
Paris Hilton and Naomi Campbell) the award went to Gary Heathcott, a marketig<br />
consultant for Arkansas. “I had no idea I was even nominated for that<br />
award,” says Heathcott. “It was really a surprise.”<br />
Not so surprising when you consider that Heathcott has been travelling to<br />
Cuba since 1990—some 78 trips by his count—and along the way has become<br />
a minor legend on the island for his charitable efforts. Known as ‘Gary<br />
Baseball’ because of all the gloves, balls and bats he donated to Cuban kids<br />
over the years, he has also contributed heavily to Cuban healthcare, including<br />
a $34,000 pediatric gastroscope that enabled a children’s hospital to operate<br />
its Olympus endoscopy system.<br />
The award, however, was for his years of promoting the Cuban culture in<br />
some 60 published articles and though documentaries such as Footprints in<br />
the Sand: Hemingway’s Cuba, El Ritual de Los Cohiba, and Cuba’s Daiquiri—the<br />
Original (yes, he knows how it was invented).<br />
Heathcott has also worked to promote business ties between Arkansas and<br />
Cuba, including a widely publicized event in 1995 where he played a role in<br />
orchestrating the delivery of a container of Riceland rice to Cuba via the<br />
Catholic Relief Services. “U.S. ag producers couldn’t legally sell anything to<br />
Cuba, but you could contribute a container of rice to a charity. We were<br />
trying to create a little detente between the countries.”<br />
A long time friend and consultant to Gov. Asa Hutchinson, Heathcott was<br />
an advocate for his state visit to Cuba—and the back channel for the Governor's<br />
basketball game there. “We set it up with a Cuban national team,” says<br />
Heathcott. “About ten minutes into the game the governor called a time out,<br />
and said, ‘Guys don’t stand out of the way when I come in for a layup. Play!’”<br />
most of the rice production plants in<br />
Cuba.<br />
“There is no guarantee that the<br />
lowest price and best quality will<br />
gain the market. Statecraft plays an<br />
important part of that,” says Wailes.<br />
“The Arkansas Congressional delegation<br />
realizes that and is trying with great<br />
tenacity to promote relationships,<br />
to have meetings with officials, and<br />
so forth. That is an element which<br />
should not be underestimated, and why<br />
Arkansas is looking for decisions out of<br />
Washington.”<br />
Those decisions, at least from Gov.<br />
Hutchinson’s point of view, do not need to<br />
include—indeed should not include—an<br />
immediate full lifting of the embargo.<br />
Rather, the state’s policy is that the U.S.<br />
should continue to gradually roll back<br />
restrictions, beginning in the critical area<br />
of finance.<br />
“Hutchinson’s message is that you<br />
are not going to kick the door open<br />
immediately, and that is fine, because they<br />
are not ready for a complete U.S. invasion.<br />
They are still trying to figure out how to<br />
get enough toilet paper into the country<br />
for Americans,” says Rush Deacon, CEO<br />
of the Arkansas Capital Corporation<br />
Group, which is prepared to finance small<br />
businesses interested in doing business<br />
in Cuba. “I have been to Vietnam, and<br />
they have figured out how to blend<br />
Communism with Capitalism. So has<br />
China. But Cuba has not yet.”<br />
Wes Ward, the Secretary of<br />
Agriculture for the State of Arkansas,<br />
traveled with the governor in 2015 and<br />
returned for a second visit this past<br />
June. “I’ve already seen pretty significant<br />
changes. There are cruise ships in Havana<br />
now, and more Americans are coming<br />
down,” he says. “The U.S. influence is<br />
already being seen; even if it’s non-U.S.<br />
companies investing, we are creating some<br />
of those changes.”<br />
For Ward, like the governor, the<br />
ground game is one of small advances<br />
and incremental gains. “From my own<br />
perspective it’s a step by step process.<br />
The first step is lifting the financing<br />
restrictions, so there is an opportunity to<br />
normalize that trade. Then we have to lift<br />
the travel restrictions. And then just follow<br />
common sense. I think all of agriculture<br />
will benefit, in both directions.”H<br />
84 CUBATRADE DEC 2016
DEC 2016<br />
CUBATRADE 85
ARKANSAS.<br />
WHERE<br />
LEGENDS ARE<br />
BORN AND<br />
FUTURES<br />
ARE MADE.<br />
As home to business and cultural icons like Sam Walton and<br />
Johnny Cash, Arkansas’s past is quite distinguished. However,<br />
it’s our future that we’re even more excited about. The<br />
pioneering spirit that yielded these and other legends is now<br />
powering our commitment to doing business in Cuba. We look<br />
forward to strengthening our relationship and leading the<br />
United States in this venture that’s good for our state, our<br />
country and for the people of Cuba.<br />
ArkansasEDC.com • 1-800-ARKANSAS<br />
Arkansas.com/CASH • 1-800-NATURAL
notebook<br />
The initial commercial flights to Cuba have been<br />
to provincial cities, far from Havana and far less<br />
expensive than the capital.<br />
By Larry Luxner<br />
A Visit to Santa Clara<br />
In rural Santa Clara, horse-drawn carriages are still a common sight<br />
Caterpillar may be one of several U.S.<br />
multinationals hoping to do business in<br />
a post-embargo Cuba, but for now, the<br />
island’s most famous Cat is a bright yellow<br />
bulldozer atop a concrete pedestal overlooking<br />
downtown Santa Clara.<br />
In late 1958, Ché Guevara’s rebel<br />
column used this Caterpillar to rip up<br />
railroad tracks and derail a train carrying<br />
government soldiers loyal to dictator<br />
Fulgencio Batista. The ambush led to the<br />
capture of Santa Clara and Batista’s overthrow<br />
(he fled Cuba days later) ensuring<br />
the bulldozer a prized place in the annals<br />
of the Revolution.<br />
Shortly before 11 a.m. on Aug. 31,<br />
2016, Cuba’s fifth-largest city made history<br />
again when a colorful JetBlue Airbus<br />
touched down at Santa Clara’s Abel<br />
Santamaría International Airport. Flight<br />
387 from Fort Lauderdale marked the first<br />
direct commercial air service between the<br />
United States and Cuba since 1961.<br />
DEC 2016<br />
CUBATRADE<br />
87
A new chapter: A U.S. tourist shopping in Santa Clara<br />
The Cuban government is very conscious that Havana’s<br />
hotels are already maxed out, and I think it would like to<br />
see more tourism dispersed to the province...<br />
Nine days later, I boarded that same<br />
flight. Although I could no longer book<br />
the $99 introductory one-way airfares<br />
widely advertised, my $436 round-trip<br />
ticket from Baltimore, Md.—with a onehour<br />
layover in Florida—was a relative<br />
bargain; only a few years ago such a trip<br />
would have cost $900 on a charter airline,<br />
not to mention the hassle of obtaining a<br />
license to travel from the Treasury Department’s<br />
Office of Foreign Assets Control<br />
(OFAC).<br />
While the arrival of U.S. commercial<br />
flights is supposed to trigger a surge<br />
in American tourists, none of my fellow<br />
passengers were tourists in the true sense.<br />
Most appeared to be Cuban-Americans<br />
returning––some for the first time in<br />
decades––to the land of their birth.<br />
Before boarding, each of us had to<br />
fill out applications for Cuban visas ($50<br />
each, payable by credit card) and complete<br />
a form explaining the purpose of travel; a<br />
Cuba travel expert Christopher Baker<br />
JetBlue employee told me this information<br />
is sent to Cuba before the flight lands.<br />
The flight from Fort Lauderdale took<br />
just 43 minutes, and when we touched<br />
down in Santa Clara the 100 or so passengers<br />
on board applauded loudly, a few of<br />
them overcome with emotion. Many took<br />
selfies as they clambered down to board<br />
buses for the arrivals terminal.<br />
It’s not clear why Santa Clara—a<br />
sleepy provincial capital of 200,000—<br />
was chosen to receive Cuba’s first direct<br />
commercial U.S. flight. Perhaps it’s the<br />
airport’s 9,900-foot asphalt runway, or<br />
because Santa Clara is located in the<br />
center of Cuba, about 175 miles east of<br />
Havana. Whatever the reason, one thing<br />
is clear: This city is not yet crawling with<br />
American tourists—or tourists of any kind<br />
—though that prospect is one Cuba would<br />
like to see unfold.<br />
“The Cuban government is very<br />
conscious that Havana’s hotels are already<br />
maxed out, and I think it would like to see<br />
more tourism dispersed to the provinces,”<br />
says Cuba travel expert Christopher Baker,<br />
author of the Moon Cuba guidebook. “That<br />
said, the majority of passengers on these<br />
provincial flights will undoubtedly be Cuban-Americans<br />
returning to visit family<br />
outside Havana.”<br />
Santa Clara’s top tourist draw is its<br />
sprawling Che Guevara Mausoleum, a<br />
shrine to Cuba’s iconic revolutionary.<br />
Here, visitors can see artifacts that include<br />
the porcelain enamel “Villa Chichita”<br />
street sign from the Argentine village<br />
where he grew up and the black field<br />
telephone he used in the 1958 battle of<br />
Las Villas. Not far away is Tren Blindado,<br />
the site of the famous train ambush, and<br />
Parque Vidal, Santa Clara’s downtown<br />
main square lined with museums and<br />
historic buildings; Jewish tourists will be<br />
intrigued by a small Holocaust memorial<br />
on the outskirts of town. But for now, it’s<br />
ethnic travel rather than foreign tourism<br />
that will generate revenue for Santa Clarabound<br />
aircraft.<br />
“We’re thrilled with the service. It<br />
couldn’t have gone better,” said JetBlue<br />
spokeswoman Danielle Sandars, who<br />
explained why only 100 passengers were<br />
88 CUBATRADE DEC 2016
Santa Clara's top tourist attraction is the<br />
Che Guevara Mausoleum<br />
aboard an aircraft with 150 seats: Excess<br />
baggage. “On some of the flights, we’ve<br />
had weight restrictions, so we have to keep<br />
it at a lower number of passengers.”<br />
Because of Santa Clara’s relative<br />
rural isolation, horse-drawn carriages and<br />
1950s-era Chevrolets, Fords, and Buicks<br />
are far more numerous on its streets than<br />
in more modern Havana. Prices are also<br />
much lower here as well.<br />
Many shops and restaurants list<br />
prices in both moneda nacional or Cuban<br />
pesos—which are worth 24 to the dollar<br />
—and in the much more valuable pesos<br />
convertibles or CUCs, worth slightly more<br />
than a dollar each.<br />
For example, at the Rincón del<br />
Sandwich restaurant just off Parque Vidal,<br />
you can enjoy a cheeseburger for 30 pesos<br />
($1.25) or a hot dog for only 10 pesos (42<br />
cents). Drinks are priced in convertible<br />
pesos: daiquiris or mojitos for 1.50 CUC,<br />
and a glass of sangria for 1 CUC.<br />
Lodging in Santa Clara is also much<br />
cheaper than Havana. I booked a lovely<br />
room at Hostal La Caridad, a private<br />
home in walking distance of Parque Vidal,<br />
for $18 per night, or $54 for my threenight<br />
stay—the same as Airbnb’s average<br />
rate of $54 a night for a room in Havana.<br />
Transportation is also inexpensive, as<br />
long as you don’t rent a car. The day before<br />
my departure, I traveled from Santa Clara<br />
to the coastal city of Cienfuegos—onehour<br />
south—in a red 1952 Hillman for<br />
the equivalent of $10. The morning of my<br />
flight back to Fort Lauderdale, I flagged<br />
down a beat-up 1978 Lada, whose driver<br />
charged $5 for the trip to the airport.<br />
Here, thanks to recent regulatory changes,<br />
I could buy an unlimited amount of rum<br />
and cigars for personal use. That’s a far<br />
cry from the previous $100 maximum in<br />
combined alcohol and tobacco products.<br />
But until the embargo is abolished, don’t<br />
expect retail sales at Santa Clara’s airport<br />
––or anywhere else—to take off.<br />
“Any American can legally just hop<br />
on a plane to Cuba and follow their own<br />
itinerary under the people-to-people<br />
category, and all they have to do is sign an<br />
affidavit, provided by the airline, that they<br />
are doing so,” says Baker. “The majority<br />
of Americans simply aren’t aware of this.<br />
It will be a gradual process of generating<br />
such awareness, but I don’t think we’ll<br />
see wholesale change until the travel<br />
restrictions are lifted entirely.” H<br />
Santa Clara's main square is lined with historic buildings<br />
DEC 2016<br />
CUBATRADE<br />
89
LIFESTYLE<br />
Cuba Ahora:<br />
The Next<br />
Generation<br />
Cuban artists born after 1980, unlike<br />
some of their predecessors, have no desire<br />
to leave the island. And why should they?<br />
Their work would lose its value.<br />
By J.P. Faber<br />
Gabriela García Azcuy<br />
Cuban art historian<br />
and curator<br />
90 CUBATRADE DEC 2016
The new generation of Cuban visual<br />
artists who came of age in the last decade,<br />
during the reforms that began when Raul<br />
Castro became president in 2006, are<br />
markedly different from their predecessors––and<br />
not just in their new sense of<br />
aesthetics.<br />
“Raúl [Castro] has been more focused<br />
on the economic scene and less on<br />
politics,” says Cuban art historian Gabriela<br />
García Azcuy. “Everyone thinks that<br />
everything is political in Cuba, but it’s not<br />
like that today. They [the artists] are thinking<br />
instead about how to become artist-entrepreneurs<br />
and improve their lives.”<br />
Another major contrast with earlier<br />
artists is that the new generation is not<br />
as interested in leaving the island, as did<br />
many artists in the 1990s. Instead of living<br />
abroad, they are staying home, and for<br />
good reason. International art collectors<br />
today prefer to buy art created by Cuban<br />
artists in Cuba, not by exiles.<br />
“This has been a recent complaint<br />
of artists [living aboard], so much so<br />
that Cuban artists who have been living<br />
outside Cuba since the 1990’s will<br />
maintain a studio in Cuba, even if they<br />
are not there all the time,” says Ariana<br />
Hernandez-Reguant, PhD, editor of<br />
CubaCounterPoints and an expert on the<br />
business of the arts in Cuba. “There is a<br />
mystique about Cuban artists, and that is<br />
what collectors want.”<br />
The young artists of Cuba are well<br />
aware of this, says García. The generation<br />
born in the 1980s, and which grew up<br />
in the rough times of the Special Period<br />
of the 1990s, came of age with the idea<br />
that their art could be sold, first in Cuban<br />
galleries, then in international galleries.<br />
“They grew up with the art market<br />
and are very comfortable with that,” says<br />
García “They speak English and use<br />
credit cards. They have visas [to travel]<br />
but it’s more strategic to live in Cuba.<br />
That is one difference between them and<br />
the older artists.”<br />
'Holding <strong>One</strong>self, Full of Faith and Hope' by Grethell Rasúa<br />
DEC 2016<br />
CUBATRADE<br />
91
92 CUBATRADE DEC 2016<br />
There is also a big difference in visual<br />
style, which is what García sought to display<br />
with an exhibit she recently curated<br />
at Washington, DC’s Art Museum of the<br />
Americas: (Art)Xiomas – Cuba Ahora: The<br />
Next Generation. It was the first exhibit<br />
of Cuban art at the OAS museum since<br />
1962. A collection of works by 15 artists,<br />
all born in the 1980s, the show will be on<br />
display in various U.S. cities next year. The<br />
exhibit combines painting, photography<br />
and installations––all visually stunning.<br />
“In the last 10 years everything has<br />
changed in the visual arts,” she says. “The<br />
majority of their work is about who we<br />
are and our place in the world. It is very<br />
personal. But it is also devoted to the art<br />
itself. What is important are the aesthetics.<br />
All the elements of the piece have<br />
to be perfect. Earlier [Cuban] art was<br />
conceptual art.”<br />
Among the artists represented are<br />
Frank Mujica, a “traditional” painter<br />
who works only in black and white. His<br />
objective, says García, is to put the human<br />
element in otherwise non-human landscapes,<br />
such as the folded shrouds floating<br />
before a cold and distant mountain range<br />
in his 2016 “Sin título (Díptico)” – “Untitled<br />
(Diptych).”<br />
Another of the artists is Jorge Otero,<br />
who has a unique technique of sewing<br />
textures into photographs. His works in<br />
the show include three images from his<br />
2013 “War Hero” series, all depictions of<br />
the Cuban farm worker.<br />
“His series is about identity, about<br />
the new paradigm for the Cuban citizen,”<br />
says García. “The Guajiro [Cuban slang<br />
for a person from the countryside] in the<br />
popular imagination is an old person. But<br />
Otero transformed him into a strong,<br />
handsome person, a new identity.”<br />
The most arresting image of the show<br />
is a photograph by Grethell Rasúa, who<br />
provocatively “uses the parts of the body<br />
Frank Mujica’s “Sin título (Díptico)”
Two photographs (left and right)<br />
from Jorge Otero's “War Hero” series<br />
that nobody wants—blood, hair, mucous,<br />
sweat, nails—to make beautiful things,<br />
like jewelry and dresses,” says García.<br />
Her “Holding <strong>One</strong>self, Full of Faith and<br />
Hope” is a 2012 photograph of bloodied<br />
dance shoes being worn by Cuban ballerina<br />
Estheysis Menendez; it is a moving<br />
testament to the sacrifices made by individual<br />
artists in pursuit of perfection.<br />
García herself came from the same<br />
education system that produced the new<br />
generation of Cuban artists. While she<br />
graduated from the University of Havana<br />
with a degree in art history, all of the artists<br />
exhibited are graduates of the Instituto<br />
Superior de Arte (ISA). Founded in 1976<br />
by the government, ISA is considered the<br />
most prestigious arts academy in Cuba.<br />
It was García’s youth, she says, that<br />
led to the Cuba Ahora project. Three<br />
years ago García (now 27) was working<br />
as a curator for the Galliano Gallery<br />
in Havana. At the time her mother<br />
was working for the Spanish embassy,<br />
which also served as a cultural center for<br />
lectures, exhibitions and performances.<br />
I’m the youngest in the group - the artists are all older<br />
than me but somehow we are part of the same generation.<br />
The embassy held a weekly show by<br />
emerging artists entitled Los Jueves<br />
del Embajada, or Embassy Thursdays.<br />
During one of these events García was<br />
approached by cultural consul Pablo<br />
Platas, the event’s organizer.<br />
“You are a curator and very young,”<br />
García recalls being told by Platas, who<br />
had visited the gallery where she worked.<br />
“Do you want to create an exposition of<br />
these artists for us?”<br />
With funding from SPAIN arts<br />
& culture, a conduit for Spanish<br />
government grants to support the arts<br />
as a way to bridge gaps between nations,<br />
García put together a show entitled<br />
“Visitantes” (visitors). “That was the<br />
genesis of the current [Cuba Ahora]<br />
show,” she says. “I’m the youngest in<br />
Art historian and curator Gabriela García Azcuy<br />
the group—the artists are all older than<br />
me—but somehow we are part of the<br />
same generation.”<br />
It is that generation—those born<br />
in the 1980s, and who came of age after<br />
2000—which García believes represents a<br />
new wave of Cuban visual artists.<br />
For her show García coined a new<br />
word, Artxiomas, a variation of the word<br />
Axiomas, referring to the rubrics of<br />
philosophy. These works represent the<br />
axioms of art, she believes, reflecting<br />
the principles of medium rather than a<br />
political message. Prices for these works<br />
range from $3,500 to $6,000 for Otero’s<br />
“War Heroes,” to $8,000 for Rasúa’s<br />
ballet shoes (both are photographs<br />
limited to 7 editions), to $25,000 for<br />
Mujica’s painting. H<br />
DEC 2016<br />
CUBATRADE<br />
93
EVENTS<br />
Flags from scores of countries adorned the entrance of the 34th Havana International Fair.<br />
theFair<br />
A day<br />
at<br />
More than 3,500 exhibitors from 75<br />
countries converged in Cuba for the 34th<br />
Havana International Fair, one of the<br />
largest general-interest trade fairs in Latin<br />
America, in early November. The fair is an<br />
annual event designed to attract foreign<br />
companies interested in trading and<br />
investing in Cuba, and as well as sourcing<br />
from the island. Cuba had the most exhibitors,<br />
followed by Spain, Italy and Germany.<br />
Although more American companies<br />
have shown interest in trading with Cuba<br />
in the last two years, only about two dozen<br />
U.S. exhibitors attended the fair. The U.S.<br />
delegation shared a pavilion with mostly<br />
Caribbean countries in the furthest corner<br />
of the fairgrounds.<br />
Fair attendees check<br />
out smartphones made<br />
by Chinese telecom<br />
giant Huawei. The<br />
company is working<br />
with Cuba’s telecom<br />
monopoly ETECSA to<br />
install the country’s<br />
internet infrastructure.<br />
After Cuba, Spain sent<br />
the most exhibitors to<br />
the fair. The country was<br />
given four pavilions.<br />
Mexico was given its own pavilion, where companies promoted<br />
the country’s food, energy and consumer products.<br />
Caterpillar’s Puerto<br />
Rico dealer Rimco<br />
promoted its<br />
construction vehicles<br />
at the fair. Rimco is<br />
looking to enter the<br />
Cuban market.<br />
Attendees check out<br />
the Havana Club booth<br />
in the Cuba pavilion.<br />
Recent changes to U.S.<br />
regulations now allow<br />
Americans to bring<br />
rum into the country.<br />
Myron Brilliant, executive vice president and head of international<br />
affairs for the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, speaks to<br />
journalists at the Chamber’s U.S.-Cuba Business Council booth.<br />
American exhibitors shared a pavilion with Caribbean countries.<br />
94 CUBATRADE DEC 2016
in closing<br />
A New<br />
Generation<br />
for U.S.- Cuba<br />
Relations<br />
By Jodi Hanson Bond<br />
Vice President, Americas, U.S. Chamber of Commerce<br />
President, U.S.-Cuba Business Council<br />
U.S. Chamber President and CEO, Tom<br />
Donohue, first visited Havana in the late<br />
1990s. At the time he was highlighting<br />
the Chamber’s opposition to unilateral<br />
U.S. trade sanctions. As Donohue said<br />
then, and as we’ve reiterated ever since,<br />
U.S. isolationist policy toward Cuba has<br />
failed. Cuba hasn’t been isolated from the<br />
world—just from America and its business<br />
community.<br />
The U.S. private sector has long<br />
sought a commercial relationship with<br />
Cuba that offers opportunities for Americans<br />
and Cubans alike, a commercial<br />
relationship with the power to bridge differences<br />
and put both countries on a path<br />
toward productive and friendly relations<br />
befitting such close neighbors.<br />
Twenty months ago, Presidents<br />
Obama and Castro began a process of<br />
rapprochement between our two countries,<br />
and it’s already spurred historic<br />
reforms. Embassies in both countries have<br />
re-opened, regulations governing U.S.<br />
sanctions have been adjusted, and Cuba’s<br />
growing private sector—now viewed as<br />
a strategic necessity and not a necessary<br />
evil—accounts for 40 percent of its labor<br />
96 CUBATRADE DEC 2016<br />
force. The travel and tourism sector has<br />
emerged as a vibrant frontier, U.S. cruise<br />
ships are again making landfall at Cuban<br />
ports, and for the first time in over 50<br />
years, cities like Havana and Santa Clara<br />
appear as destinations on departures<br />
boards at U.S. airports.<br />
In spite of these constructive changes,<br />
there is much work left to do. It will<br />
take sustained effort from all stakeholders<br />
to make sure this historic opportunity is<br />
seized and not squandered. In this spirit<br />
the U.S. Chamber launched the U.S.-Cuba<br />
Business Council in 2015. Over the<br />
course of the last year, we’ve convened<br />
leading private-sector voices for in-depth<br />
discussions about opportunities in both<br />
markets, and we’ve committed ourselves<br />
to ambitious goals: Building a strategic<br />
commercial partnership; encouraging<br />
greater reform in Cuba; and creating a<br />
more robust bilateral trade and investment<br />
relationship.<br />
The Council has already led several<br />
business delegations to Cuba, hosted<br />
dozens of roundtable conversations about<br />
U.S.-Cuba policy with U.S. government<br />
officials, welcomed two Cuban ministers<br />
to the nation’s capital for the first time in<br />
over 50 years, and led dozens of educational<br />
meetings on Capitol Hill to explain<br />
the importance of removing U.S. sanctions<br />
on Cuba.<br />
It is now up to the U.S. Congress<br />
to lift the generations-old sanctions<br />
against Cuba. While we understand the<br />
challenges associated with advancing<br />
meaningful reform in the current political<br />
environment, it won’t dampen efforts by<br />
the U.S. Chamber and the Council to<br />
build a pragmatic conversation on the<br />
changing U.S.-Cuba landscape and the<br />
opportunities it presents for our businesses<br />
and entrepreneurs. At the same time, we<br />
continue to urge the Cuban government<br />
to build on the advancements of the<br />
past 20 months with a more ambitious<br />
economic reform agenda at home.<br />
Before us––just 90 miles off our<br />
coast––lies an extraordinary opportunity<br />
to bolster our American business<br />
community, grow our economy, and share<br />
with Cuba the principles of free enterprise<br />
that have made our nation, and our people,<br />
so strong. We invite you to join us in these<br />
historic efforts. H
EXPLORE CUBA.<br />
ALL OF IT.<br />
Now flying to six cities from Miami<br />
Whether you choose Havana, Cienfuegos, Holguin, Santa Clara,<br />
Varadero or Camaguey, now you can fly nonstop from Miami.<br />
With frequent daily flights, low fares and easy booking,<br />
American makes it easy to get there.<br />
Book today at aa.com or call your local travel agent.<br />
American Airlines and the Flight Symbol logo are marks of American Airlines, Inc.<br />
oneworld is a mark of the oneworld Alliance, LLC. © 2016 American Airlines, Inc. All rights reserved.