Inside Libya
2mNC03x
2mNC03x
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
Middle East Council<br />
<strong>Inside</strong> <strong>Libya</strong><br />
Chaos in the mediterranean<br />
Kwasi Kwarteng MP<br />
Leo Docherty<br />
March 2017
Conservative Middle East Council INSIDE LIBYA: CHAOS IN THE MEDITERRANEAN
Conservative Middle East Council INSIDE LIBYA: CHAOS IN THE MEDITERRANEAN<br />
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY<br />
KEY FINDINGS<br />
• Field Marshal Haftar sees his mission as fighting jihadist terrorism.<br />
• A large degree of order and governance exists in Eastern <strong>Libya</strong>.<br />
• Despite being under pressure, the East remains stable while the West is plagued<br />
by disorder and insecurity.<br />
• The House of Representatives is a nucleus for the development of a <strong>Libya</strong>n<br />
Parliamentary system, and has a geographical reach across <strong>Libya</strong>.<br />
• Western <strong>Libya</strong>, particularly Tripoli itself, is dominated by warlords and criminal<br />
gangs; they all have an interest in prolonging the relative confusion in the West.<br />
KEY RECOMMENDATIONS<br />
• The UK should urgently engage with Haftar, the LNA and the HoR<br />
• The UK should support the LNA to secure <strong>Libya</strong>’s borders and bring an end to<br />
the illegal trafficking of people from <strong>Libya</strong>’s sea ports.<br />
• The UK should reconsider its view of the GNA and acknowledge its limited<br />
capacity to deliver any kind of governance or security for <strong>Libya</strong>.<br />
1
Conservative Middle East Council INSIDE LIBYA: CHAOS IN THE MEDITERRANEAN<br />
DELEGATION TO LIBYA – MARCH 2017<br />
OVERVIEW<br />
In the first week of March 2017 CMEC Vice Chairman Kwasi Kwarteng MP, and<br />
CMEC Director Leo Docherty, travelled to <strong>Libya</strong> to meet the Commander of the<br />
<strong>Libya</strong>n National Army (LNA) Field Marshal Khalifa Haftar. They also met the<br />
Speaker of the House of Representatives (HoR), Aguila Saleh, and members of the<br />
House of Representatives.<br />
The purpose of the delegation was to gain a deeper understanding of the situation inside<br />
<strong>Libya</strong> itself. Since the revolution and overthrow of Muammar Gaddafi in 2011 the political<br />
and economic conditions of that country remain extremely fluid. The enthusiastic optimism<br />
associated with the visit of Prime Minister David Cameron to Tripoli and Benghazi in September<br />
2011, accompanied by French President Nicolas Sarkozy, has not been sustained. For the<br />
British government, <strong>Libya</strong> became less of a priority, while responsibility for fixing <strong>Libya</strong>’s<br />
many intractable problems, mostly regarding security and political governance, were left to the<br />
UN and EU.<br />
Despite the best efforts of these organisations, <strong>Libya</strong> appears to many observers as nothing<br />
other than a failed state. Riven by militias, home to ISIS and Al Qaeda, and with unguarded<br />
borders, <strong>Libya</strong> appears simply incapable of constraining the movement of tens of thousands<br />
of migrants who travel through Africa to Europe every year. It has been plausibly argued that<br />
the UK, despite its central role in the toppling of Gaddafi, has simply not paid enough attention<br />
to <strong>Libya</strong> since 2011.<br />
The delegation travelled to <strong>Libya</strong> on a flight from Alexandria to Al Bayda. From Al Bayda the<br />
CMEC team travelled by road to Al Rajma (near Benghazi), Al Marj and Tobruk, from where a<br />
flight was eventually taken back to Alexandria. The meetings took place in Field Marshal Haftar’s<br />
Military Camp in Al Rajma, in and around the city of Al Bayda and in Tobruk. The circuitous<br />
route afforded ample opportunity to closely observe the situation on the ground.<br />
The visit took place against the background of attacks against the LNA-held oil terminals of<br />
Al Sider and Ras Lanuf, on the western edge of <strong>Libya</strong>’s oil crescent, by militias aligned with the<br />
Government of National Accord (GNA) in Tripoli but reportedly containing jihadist elements.<br />
The loss of the oil terminal is a significant operational setback for the LNA. A counter attack is<br />
now underway and the battle continues as this report goes to press.<br />
2
Conservative Middle East Council INSIDE LIBYA: CHAOS IN THE MEDITERRANEAN<br />
KEY FINDINGS<br />
1. Field Marshal Haftar sees his mission as fighting jihadist terrorism.<br />
Field Marshal Haftar has a very clear focus on the operational challenge of defeating the jihadist militias in the<br />
west of <strong>Libya</strong>. He struck the delegation very much as an operational solider, a ‘soldiers’s soldier’, who did not<br />
concern himself with grand political strategy. Despite the ongoing attacks in the oil crescent, Haftar appeared<br />
composed and confident when the delegation met him. He sees himself as a <strong>Libya</strong>n nationalist and describes his<br />
mission as ridding <strong>Libya</strong> of the multitude of militias - both Islamist and criminal - that dominate the western<br />
half of the country. Although an observant Muslim, he appears to be largely secular in his world view.<br />
Haftar appears to be a self-confident military man, who is proud of his achievements. He described to the<br />
delegation a series of military operations over the last three years, often in minute detail. He spoke about the<br />
worsening security situation in <strong>Libya</strong> and the rise of jihadist militias that encouraged him to lead a military<br />
offensive against them. This became known as Operation Karama - Dignity.<br />
In 2014 I called for people to gather in Rajma with their own weapons…300 people came. We attacked the<br />
headquarters of the Islamists in Hawari, west of Benghazi and killed their leaders…after this 3,000 people joined<br />
us. Now we have 60,000.<br />
Benghazi is now free of jihadists, only a few remain on the western edge.<br />
Haftar points out that the LNA, since taking control of the oil crescent in September 2016, has allowed the oil<br />
to flow and the revenues to continue to be paid unhindered to the National Oil Company (NOC).<br />
…the funds go to the NOC and then to the Central Bank…but they are in the hands of the militias – the militias<br />
call the shots and <strong>Libya</strong>ns are still poor…<br />
Haftar described his determination to secure the oil crescent and re-take the lost terminals. He also outlined his<br />
belief in the LNA’s ability – if enhanced militarily - to pacify the Jufra region in Southern <strong>Libya</strong>. Haftar sees his<br />
mission as a national project covering all of <strong>Libya</strong>.<br />
Both Haftar and the Speaker of the HoR described their desire for close relations with the United Kingdom.<br />
Haftar appealed for British help:<br />
We can end this chaos but we call on your government to help us…<br />
One of Haftar’s senior advisers described the suspicions many <strong>Libya</strong>ns have about the presence of UK Special<br />
Forces in <strong>Libya</strong> who, while they are known to be present in the East, are not actively engaging with the LNA.<br />
There is a large degree of scepticism over UK’s role and intentions given the discreet supported currently given<br />
by other major powers. The adviser stated:<br />
People are asking – the Egyptians are backing us, the UAE, France and the Russians are backing us…the<br />
Americans probably will do…what are the British waiting for?<br />
3
Conservative Middle East Council INSIDE LIBYA: CHAOS IN THE MEDITERRANEAN<br />
2. A large degree of order and governance exists in Eastern <strong>Libya</strong>.<br />
During the long road trips between Al Bayda, Al Rajma and Tobruk many well organised police and<br />
military check points could be seen. Traffic police were also visible. In the urban centres normal civilian<br />
life appeared to be going ahead unhindered by any security concern. Shops and restaurants were busy<br />
with customers. It was striking to the delegation that every soldier we saw appeared well equipped, and<br />
dressed in a distinctive military uniform.<br />
One unusual sight the delegation witnessed was a queue of around two hundred people outside<br />
the Wahda Bank in Al Marj. These people were waiting to take cash from their bank accounts. Such<br />
withdrawals have been severely restricted due to the withholding of funds from the East of <strong>Libya</strong> by<br />
the Central Bank of <strong>Libya</strong> in Tripoli. This is set against an economic backdrop in which <strong>Libya</strong>’s GDP<br />
has, according to some measures, roughly halved since the revolution of 2011.<br />
3. Despite being under pressure, the East remains stable while the West is<br />
plagued by disorder and insecurity.<br />
Field Marshal Haftar and the LNA complain about a lack of money.<br />
The recent successful attacks by militias against LNA forces in the oil crescent show that the LNA is<br />
militarily vulnerable. Despite the LNA reportedly receiving some military support from the UAE, Egypt,<br />
and Russia, it is by all accounts under-trained and under-equipped.<br />
Despite controlling the oil crescent since September 2016, Haftar has not stopped the flow of oil from<br />
<strong>Libya</strong>’s oil crescent. Revenues from sales of oil to the international market are still flowing to the<br />
National Oil company and the <strong>Libya</strong>n Central Bank.<br />
The LNA continues to be adversely affected by the reported failure of the <strong>Libya</strong>n Central Bank to honour<br />
its agreement to send 40% of oil revenues to Benghazi, while 60% is reportedly received by Tripoli.<br />
Meanwhile, in the west a large number of different militias – some criminal, some jihadist – prevail.<br />
These include ISIS, Ansar Al Sharia, the Derna Mujahidin Shura Council, the Islamist Ajdabiya<br />
Revolutionaries Shura Council, Tripoli Revolutionary Brigade, Special Deterrent Force (Tripoli) and the<br />
Benghazi Revolutionaries Shura Council (a coalition of Islamist militias, including Ansar Al Sharia,<br />
the 17 February Brigade and the Rafallah Al Sahati Brigade).*<br />
In the west many of the militia leaders, such as Abdelhakim Belhadj and Khaled Al Sharif, were involved<br />
with the <strong>Libya</strong> Islamic Fighting Group (LIFG), an organisation with loose links to Al Qaeda. Other<br />
leaders, such as Salah Badi and Ali Al Sallabi, were imprisoned under the Gaddafi regime. The political<br />
motivations of these different agents remain unclear. They do not have any organised political<br />
programmes, nor do they operate under party political labels. On the other hand, they have been<br />
effective at creating militias on the ground, and carving themselves positions of power and influence.<br />
* A full list of militias can be found in the Appendix on Page 11<br />
4
Conservative Middle East Council INSIDE LIBYA: CHAOS IN THE MEDITERRANEAN<br />
The commitment of such people to a strong, functioning central government in <strong>Libya</strong> is doubtful.<br />
Many people feel that these militia leaders are direct beneficiaries of the ongoing political instability in<br />
<strong>Libya</strong>. The militia men have a vested interest in prolonging the chaos.<br />
These militias reportedly derive significant income from the trafficking of migrants through <strong>Libya</strong> towards sea<br />
ports in Western <strong>Libya</strong> where they embark for Italy and Europe - in many cases perishing at sea.<br />
It is reported that the GNA and President Serraj have absolutely no control over any geographical area<br />
of Western <strong>Libya</strong>. Their means of confronting the jihadist militant groups are negligible. The GNA has<br />
conspicuously failed to secure <strong>Libya</strong>’s borders with the neighbouring countries of Chad, Niger, Algeria<br />
and Tunisia. They have consequently done little to stem the flow of illegally trafficked migrants towards<br />
the Mediterranean coast.<br />
The President of the GNA, Fayez Serraj, is derided in the East as an ineffectual figurehead who remains<br />
at the mercy of militias in and around Tripoli. The GNA has no military capability of its own, while<br />
President Serraj was dismissed to us as a foreigner of indiscriminate Levantine origin – his father<br />
was described as being a Palestinian immigrant who worked for the British Army during the Second<br />
World War. Serraj was also derided for having been an unimpressive performer in the HoR before he<br />
was selected as president; he reportedly never made a speech.<br />
Putting these statements and suggestions together, it would appear that much of Serraj’s support is<br />
derived from militia leaders, who naturally benefit from the disorder and lack of central government in<br />
the West. Militia leaders, such Abdelhakim Belhaj, are directly benefiting from the traffic in migrants.<br />
Each migrant has to pay up to US$1,000 to be trafficked to Europe. A strong central government in<br />
<strong>Libya</strong> would naturally be a threat to this nefarious line of business. The point which cannot be stressed<br />
enough is that many are benefitting financially, and in terms of status and prestige, from the continuing<br />
political chaos in the west of <strong>Libya</strong>.<br />
Security within Tripoli itself was described as “very poor”. A member of the HoR, elected to a<br />
constituency in <strong>Libya</strong>’s Southern region and former resident of Tripoli said:<br />
Tripoli is like Paris by day, like Kandahar by night<br />
Another important centre of power in the West is the city of Misrata. It is a prosperous sea port, and<br />
a significant economic centre with a large presence of various militia. Misrata is reportedly backed<br />
financially and militarily by Qatar, Turkey and Sudan. It is perhaps the largest obstacle to the LNA’s<br />
attempt to unify <strong>Libya</strong> under one command.<br />
5
Conservative Middle East Council INSIDE LIBYA: CHAOS IN THE MEDITERRANEAN<br />
4. The House of Representatives is a nucleus for the development of a <strong>Libya</strong>n<br />
Parliamentary system, and has a geographical reach across <strong>Libya</strong>.<br />
The House of Representatives (HoR) – now sitting in Tobruk after its flight from Tripoli in the summer<br />
of 2014 - is composed of 188 Members of whom around 130-150 reportedly still attend meetings.<br />
Significantly, 32 Members are women, and the HoR apparently has a broad reach across the whole of<br />
<strong>Libya</strong>. On the day the delegation visited 114 Members were reported to be sitting.<br />
Members of the HoR are a varied collection of political activists; they do not necessarily all support<br />
Haftar and the LNA. Most of the Members that the delegation met expressed gratitude that the LNA<br />
had provided the security to allow the HoR to continue sitting in Tobruk.<br />
The delegation met two female MPs, one of whom, as a representative for the Tebu tribe in Murzuq,<br />
Southern <strong>Libya</strong>, voiced her complete support for the LNA. Murzuq is roughly 1,500 km from Tobruk.<br />
Members of the HoR expressed dismay that their assembly was no longer supported by the international<br />
community. A Member representing a constituency in <strong>Libya</strong>’s Western Mountains said:<br />
We are baffled by the position of Britain…and the support given to the GNA…which is reliant on the<br />
Islamist militias…it is not democratic.<br />
The HoR, having been elected in 2014, is a flawed and somewhat disorganised body. It does, however,<br />
offer a starting point for <strong>Libya</strong>’s democratic development if the country can achieve a measure of political<br />
stability in the near future.<br />
6
Conservative Middle East Council INSIDE LIBYA: CHAOS IN THE MEDITERRANEAN<br />
RECOMMENDATIONS<br />
1. The UK should urgently engage with Haftar, the LNA and the HoR and<br />
support their efforts to defeat the Islamist militias in Western <strong>Libya</strong>. A united,<br />
democratic <strong>Libya</strong> can only progress if the country is pacified. The LNA is the<br />
only means of achieving this.<br />
2. The UK should support the LNA to secure <strong>Libya</strong>’s borders bring an end to<br />
the illegal trafficking of people from <strong>Libya</strong>’s sea ports. This is urgent on<br />
both humanitarian and security grounds.<br />
3. The UK should reconsider its view of the GNA and acknowledge its limited<br />
capacity to deliver any kind of governance or security for <strong>Libya</strong>.<br />
“I decline utterly to be impartial between the fire brigade and the fire.”<br />
SIR WINSTON CHURCHILL<br />
7
Conservative Middle East Council INSIDE LIBYA: CHAOS IN THE MEDITERRANEAN<br />
LIBYA TIMELINE 2011-17<br />
2011 January/February The Arab spring spreads to <strong>Libya</strong> and violence breaks out between<br />
security forces and anti-Gaddafi rebels.<br />
2011 March UN Security Council authorises a no-fly zone over <strong>Libya</strong> and NATO<br />
launch air strikes.<br />
2011 August The main opposition group the National Transitional Council (NTC)<br />
announce a ‘Constitutional Declaration’ to form a General National<br />
Congress (GNC) after the fall of Gaddafi.<br />
2011 October 20 Gaddafi is apprehended and killed in Sirte.<br />
2012 August The NTC transfers power to the GNC which was elected in July.<br />
A schism emerges over the direction of the new state: the role of Islam in<br />
politics and the role of the ‘revolutionary’ militias.<br />
2012 September The US Ambassador is killed in Benghazi after a wave of Islamist attacks.<br />
2013 Islamists (Muslim Brotherhood and their allies) control the GNC and push<br />
through a law expelling Gaddafi-era officials from public life.<br />
Prime Minister Ali Zeidan is temporarily kidnapped.<br />
2014 February Unrest and violence explodes after the GNC refuse to step-down after its<br />
mandate expires. In response, General Khalifa Haftar a former Gaddafi<br />
officer, who had returned to <strong>Libya</strong> in 2011, announces a failed coup on<br />
television. GNC concede to hold elections by the summer.<br />
2014 May PM Zeidan is forced from office and is replaced by Minister of<br />
Defence Abdullah AlThinni.<br />
Despite failing in his coup, General Haftar launches a military campaign<br />
(Operation Dignity) in Benghazi against Islamists responsible for<br />
assassinating liberals and security personnel.<br />
2014 June A new parliament, the House of Representatives (HoR) is elected to replace<br />
the GNC. Islamist factions are marginalised in the HoR. In response,<br />
militias aligned to the GNC launch Operation <strong>Libya</strong> Dawn to purge the<br />
capital of liberals and Haftar supporters.<br />
2014 August The campaign is successful and Islamists seize control of Tripoli and western<br />
<strong>Libya</strong>. The HoR and the government of PM AlThinni are forced to relocate<br />
to the eastern city of Tobruk and AlBayda respectively.<br />
8
Conservative Middle East Council INSIDE LIBYA: CHAOS IN THE MEDITERRANEAN<br />
2014 September Back in the capital, the Islamists reconvene the GNC and appoint the<br />
Government of National Salvation under the premiership of Omar al Hassi.<br />
<strong>Libya</strong>’s political system is divided between two rival authorities in the east<br />
and west and the country descends into civil war.<br />
2015 January The UN brokers peace talks between representatives of the GNC and HoR.<br />
2015 February Islamic State extend their influence to the western city of Sirte.<br />
2015 March HoR appoint Haftar leader of the <strong>Libya</strong>n National Army.<br />
2015 December UN <strong>Libya</strong>n Political Agreement (LPA) is signed creating a Presidency<br />
Council, Government of National Accord (GNA) under the leadership of<br />
Faiez al-Serraj and High State Council.<br />
2016 January The HoR refuses to endorse the GNA cabinet, primarily because a provision<br />
in the LPA would side-line General Haftar and place him under the control<br />
of the GNA.<br />
2016 March The GNA arrives in Tripoli by boat from Tunisia despite the threat of<br />
arrest by Khalifa Ghwell, the Prime Minister of the Government of<br />
National Salvation.<br />
2016 August The HoR vetoes the GNA cabinet for a second time.<br />
2016 September Haftar captures the Gulf of Sirte’s ‘oil crescent’ from GNA aligned militias<br />
and is promoted to Field Marshal by HoR speaker Agilah Saleh.<br />
2016 October Khalifa Ghwell of the Government of National Salvation attempts a coup<br />
against the GNA but fails due to a lack of support.<br />
2016 November Haftar meets Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov in Moscow for<br />
the second time since July to secure military support. Haftar claims that<br />
Russia will help to end the UN arms embargo.<br />
The GNA exerts little authority with the country facing an economic<br />
crisis with shortages in fuel, electricity, and medical supplies; a rise in<br />
food prices and the devaluation of the dinar.<br />
9
Conservative Middle East Council INSIDE LIBYA: CHAOS IN THE MEDITERRANEAN<br />
2016 December Militias from Misrata, aligned to the GNA, force Islamic State from Sirte.<br />
2017 January GNA deputy leader Musa Al Koni resigns citing government failure,<br />
this is followed by the resignation of Labour Minister, Ali Qalma.<br />
Oil exports hit a three-year high of 708,000bpd (output in 2010 was<br />
1.6m bpd)<br />
Haftar tours a Russian aircraft carrier and speaks to Defence Minister<br />
Sergei Shoigu. Russia previously endorsed Haftar as a future member<br />
of the <strong>Libya</strong>n leadership.<br />
Militias loyal to Al-Ghwell of the Government of National Salvation<br />
attempt another failed coup, separately, violence erupts with Haftar<br />
forces and GNA Misrata forces in the south.<br />
Egypt holds the latest in a series of meetings with <strong>Libya</strong>n and regional<br />
actors and UN envoy Martin Kobler to discuss revising the LPA to<br />
include Haftar.<br />
2017 February EU leaders in Malta discuss proposals to stem the flow of migrants, one of<br />
which is migrant camps funded by Italy. 181,000 refugees arrived in Italy in<br />
2016 – this is a 20% increase since 2015. Of the 181,000, 90% set off<br />
from <strong>Libya</strong>.<br />
10
Conservative Middle East Council INSIDE LIBYA: CHAOS IN THE MEDITERRANEAN<br />
APPENDIX - LIBYAN MILITIAS AND ISLAMIST GROUPS<br />
Ansar Al Sharia<br />
Ansar Al Sharia is a radical Islamist group formed by revolutionary fighters in 2012. The group came to<br />
prominence in Benghazi after its members led a demonstration demanding the imposition of sharia law.<br />
The group was widely believed to have been involved in the 2012 attack on the US embassy in Benghazi<br />
which resulted in the death of US Ambassador, Christopher Stevens and three of his colleagues. Ansar Al<br />
Sharia was later designated a terrorist organisation by the US. Its members are comprised of fighters who<br />
participated in the conflicts in Iraq and Syria and the group has a presence throughout <strong>Libya</strong>. The group<br />
has strong ties to Al Qaeda and has made several public statements supporting them. In 2014, Ansar Al<br />
Sharia’s Benghazi division amalgamated with other groups to form the Benghazi Revolutionary Shura<br />
Council. The group has been targeted by Field Marshal Haftar’s forces.<br />
Ahmed Abu Khattala<br />
Ahmed Abu Khattala is a Benghazi native and former Abu Slim prisoner who participated in the<br />
anti-Gaddafi rebellion in 2011. He commanded the Abu Ubaida bin al Jarrah Battalion and was accused<br />
of assassinating prominent military officer, Abd Al Fattah Yunis in July 2011. His group joined Ansar Al<br />
Sharia and participated in the 2012 assault on the US embassy in Benghazi. Khattala was accused of<br />
being a ringleader in the attack and was subsequently captured by US Special Forces in June 2014 and<br />
transferred to the United States. He is currently awaiting trial.<br />
Islamic State (ISIS)<br />
In 2014, ISIS established a presence in the east of <strong>Libya</strong> as jihadists who had fought in Iraq and Syria<br />
returned home. But it was not until 2015 that ISIS, capitalising on the civil war, extended their<br />
influence to the western city of Sirte. The group perpetrated attacks in several <strong>Libya</strong>n cities and<br />
maintained a presence in Derna, Sabratha and Benghazi. While comprising native <strong>Libya</strong>ns, the majority<br />
of ISIS’s forces came from Iraq, Syria, and Yemen among others. In May 2016, a Government of<br />
National Accord (GNA) aligned militia launched an offensive – Al Bunyan al Marsus (solid structure) -<br />
to recapture Sirte. The heavily dominated Misrata militia was supplemented with fighters from Tripoli<br />
and western <strong>Libya</strong>. The operation in Sirte was supported by American airstrikes and British Special<br />
Forces. In Benghazi, Field Marshal Haftar and his <strong>Libya</strong>n National Army, launched an offensive against<br />
ISIS with strategic support from French Special Forces. On 7 December 2016, the GNA announced<br />
that ISIS had been driven from Sirte.<br />
Former <strong>Libya</strong> Dawn Alliance<br />
In the summer of 2014, a coalition of disparate Islamist and non-Islamist militias from Misrata, Zawiya,<br />
Gharyan and Tripoli formed ‘Operation <strong>Libya</strong> Dawn’ to counter Field Marshal Haftar’s ‘Operation<br />
Dignity’. The General National Congress (GNC) backed <strong>Libya</strong> Dawn alliance included the <strong>Libya</strong> Shield<br />
Force, <strong>Libya</strong>n Revolutionary Operations Room (whose members where accused of kidnapping Prime<br />
Minister Ali Zeidan in 2013), Muslim Brotherhood, and the Amazigh tribe. Backed by Turkey, the<br />
alliance successfully drove the Zintan brigades from the capital and western <strong>Libya</strong> fell under Islamist<br />
control. In 2015, the alliance disbanded because of tensions between the Misrata and Tripoli factions.<br />
Salah Badi<br />
Salah Badi is a militia leader from Misrata commanding the Jabhat al Samud (Steadfast Front). Badi is<br />
a former Gaddafi military officer who was later imprisoned as a regime opponent. Upon his release,<br />
Badi led forces from Misrata in the anti-Gaddafi revolution. In 2012, he successfully contested the GNC<br />
elections but resigned his post in 2014. He was a key figure in the <strong>Libya</strong> Dawn alliance and supports<br />
Khalifa Ghwell. Badi is opposed to both the GNA and Field Marshal Haftar. He was credited with<br />
disrupting the arrival of the GNA to Tripoli in March 2016. Badi is a central figure in the newly formed<br />
<strong>Libya</strong>n National Guard designed to maintain Islamists in Tripoli.<br />
11
Conservative Middle East Council INSIDE LIBYA: CHAOS IN THE MEDITERRANEAN<br />
Sadiq Al Ghariani<br />
Sheikh Sadiq Al Ghariani, the grand mufti, is <strong>Libya</strong>’s highest spiritual leader. Born in Al Bayda,<br />
Ghariani is an outspoken Salafist-oriented leader, who supported the anti-Gaddafi uprising as<br />
legitimate and was later appointed to the Dar Al Ifta, <strong>Libya</strong>’s leading religious authority. He argued that<br />
voting for parties that wanted to restrict sharia to be ‘un-Islamic’. In 2013, Gharianai issued a fatwa<br />
banning unaccompanied women from travelling. The following year, Ghariani issued inflammatory<br />
statements in support of <strong>Libya</strong> Dawn and was accused of directing operations from London. Ghariani<br />
is strongly opposed to the GNA and is an ally of Khalifa Ghwell. He has also called for a jihad against<br />
Field Marshal Haftar.<br />
Khalifa Ghwell<br />
Khalifa Ghwell is the Prime Minister of the defunct Government of National Salvation, which rests on<br />
the rump of the dissolved GNC. A former engineer from the city of Misrata, Ghwell was appointed<br />
Prime Minister after Omar Al Hassi’s dismissal in March 2015. Ghwell is openly hostile to the GNA<br />
and has refused to accept their authority. In October 2016 and January 2017, militias aligned to Ghwell<br />
launched two unsuccessful coups against the GNA. The newly formed LNG - comprising of militias<br />
from Misrata and Amazigh – has backed the Government of National Salvation. In February 2017,<br />
forces aligned to Ghwell launched an unsuccessful assassination attempt on GNA Prime Minister, Fayez<br />
Serraj.<br />
Ali Al Sallabi<br />
Ali Al Sallabi is a member of the International Union of Muslim Scholars and Al Watan (Homeland)<br />
Party. The son of a founding member of the Muslim Brotherhood in Benghazi, Sallabi spent eight years<br />
in the Abu Slim prison under Gaddafi. After which he lived in exile in Qatar and later negotiated with<br />
the Gaddafi regime on behalf of the <strong>Libya</strong>n Islamic Fighting Group. Sallabi is closely tied to Abdul<br />
hakim Belhadj and was influential during the 2011 revolution, supporting the Tripoli Military Council<br />
and criticising the National Transitional Council (NTC) as ‘secular’. He is connected to controversial<br />
Muslim Brotherhood leader, Yusuf Al Qaradawi who has been accused of having links to terrorist<br />
groups. Sallabi is considered to be an important Islamist power broker and has been consulted by<br />
UN Special Representative Martin Kobler.<br />
Former <strong>Libya</strong>n Islamic Fighting Group (LIFG)<br />
The LIFG is a defunct Islamist group formed in the 1990s with the aim of overthrowing the Gaddafi<br />
regime. Many of its fighters joined the Afghan Mujahidin against the Soviet Union in the 1980s.<br />
On return to <strong>Libya</strong>, the group launched an insurgency campaign and attempted to assassinate Gaddafi<br />
on three occasions. In retaliation, the regime killed and imprisoned many of its fighters in Abu Slim.<br />
Several LIFG leaders escaped to Afghanistan where they formed ties with the Taliban and Al Qaeda.<br />
During the late 2000s, the regime released many of the LIFG’s leadership after negotiations<br />
Ali Al Sallabi. Many of these figures rose to prominence in the 2011 revolution and later became<br />
involved in <strong>Libya</strong>’s political transition participating in elections and serving in the government.<br />
The LIFG was, at the very least, loosely connected to Al Qaeda. While the leadership never publically<br />
supported Al Qaeda’s campaign against the West, and in fact, denounced a suggestion that the LIFG<br />
joined Al Qaeda in 2007, numerous LIFG members did join Al Qaeda’s ranks. One of whom,<br />
Abu Yahya Al Libi was Al Qaeda’s deputy leader.<br />
Abdel hakim Belhadj aka Abu Abdullah Al Sadiq<br />
Abdel hakim Belhadj is a former Islamist commander and current leader of the Al Watan Party.<br />
The Tripolitan participated in the Afghan war against the Soviet Union and later developed ties to both<br />
the Taliban and Al Qaeda. He was emir of the now defunct LIFG whose aim was to overthrow the<br />
Gaddafi regime. In 2004, Belhadj was arrested in a joint CIA-MI6 operation in Thailand and rendered<br />
back to <strong>Libya</strong>. He spent seven years in the Abu Slim prison. After the fall of the regime, Belhadj left the<br />
Tripoli Military Council to unsuccessfully contest the GNC elections in 2012. He took part in the<br />
dialogue that resulted in the United Nations backed <strong>Libya</strong>n Political Agreement in 2015. Belhadj<br />
is reported to have vast business interests including: health care, property, air transport and media.<br />
In January 2017, the British Supreme Court ruled that Belhadj was entitled to pursue legal action<br />
against the Government for authorising his rendition to <strong>Libya</strong>.<br />
12
Sami Al Saadi<br />
Sami Al Saadi is a former high ranking member of the LIFG and founder of the Umma al Wasat<br />
(Moderate nation) party. In 1988, the Tripolitan left for Afghanistan where he participated in the war<br />
against the Soviet Union. He was described as the LIFG’s ‘key ideologue’ and was reportedly christened<br />
the ‘sheikh of the Arabs’ by former Taliban commander Mullah Omar. In 2004, Saadi was arrested in<br />
a joint UK-US operation and rendered to <strong>Libya</strong> where he subsequently tortured at the hands of the<br />
regime. Saadi spent the next six years in prison before his release in 2010. In December 2012, the UK<br />
government paid Saadi £2.2 million in compensation but did not accept liability for his rendition. When<br />
Abdel hakim Belhadj formed the Al Watan party, Saad formed a rival more ‘Islamic’ Umma al Wasat<br />
party. In 2012 elections, his party came third in the capital. He joined Prime Minister Zeidan’s cabinet<br />
but resigned months later.<br />
Khaled Al Sharif<br />
A noted Islamist from Tripoli, Khaled Al Sharif was the deputy emir of the LIFG and spent time in<br />
Afghanistan until the United States’ intervention in 2001. In April 2003, Al Sharif was captured in<br />
Pakistan and returned to Afghanistan accused of having ties to Al Qaeda. After spending two years in<br />
a detention centre in Afghanistan, Sharif was rendered to <strong>Libya</strong> in 2005 where he spent the next<br />
five years in prison. During the revolution, Sharif formed the National Guard militia, which aimed to<br />
prevent the escape of Gaddafi loyalists and imprisoned them in its own detention centres. In early 2013,<br />
Al Sharif was appointed Deputy Defence Minister in charge of borders and protection of key facilities.<br />
He was later sacked after reportedly being involved with arming militia groups. In 2014, forces under<br />
his command participated in the <strong>Libya</strong> Dawn operation in Tripoli.<br />
Mohammed Abu Sidra<br />
Mohammed Abu Sidra is an Islamist leader from Benghazi was a GNC Member of Parliament. He was<br />
imprisoned as a regime opponent under Colonel Gaddafi. Field Marshal Haftar accused Sidra of<br />
supporting Islamic terrorism.<br />
Abdel Wahab Mohamed Qaid aka Abu Idris Al Libi<br />
Abdel Wahab Mohamed Qaid was the sixth highest ranking member of the LIFG, (and brother of late<br />
Abu Yahya Libi, the deputy leader of Al Qaeda). After spells in Tunisia, Pakistan and other Islamists<br />
training grounds, Qaid returned to <strong>Libya</strong> in 1995 where he was arrested by the Gaddafi regime and<br />
spent the next 16 years in the Abu Slim prison. In 2011, he participated in the anti-Gaddafi uprising.<br />
Qaid joined the Umma al Wasat party and in 2012 was elected to the GNC representing his home city<br />
of Murzuq. In Congress he led the hard-line Islamic and Salafist political bloc, Al Wafa (the Blood of<br />
the Martyrs).<br />
Other prominent militia groups<br />
• Benghazi Revolutionaries Shura Council (a coalition of Islamist militias operating largely in<br />
eastern <strong>Libya</strong>, including Ansar Al Sharia, the 17 February Brigade and the Rafallah Al Sahati<br />
Brigade)<br />
• Derna Mujahidin Shura Council (Derna, eastern <strong>Libya</strong>)<br />
• Islamist Ajdabiya Revolutionaries Shura Council (Ajdabiya, north-eastern <strong>Libya</strong>)<br />
• Tripoli Revolutionaries’ Brigade (Tripoli)<br />
• Special Deterrent Force (Tripoli)<br />
It should be noted that many of the groups which started in the East, such as the Benghazi Revolutionaries<br />
Shura Council, now operate in the west of <strong>Libya</strong>. Most of the militia leaders mentioned in this survey are<br />
now based in Tripoli, Misrata and the west of the country.
Middle East Council<br />
KWASI KWARTENG MP<br />
Kwasi Kwarteng is the Member of Parliament for Spelthorne in Surrey.<br />
He is the succesful author of a number of books including Ghosts of Empire:<br />
Britain’s Legacies in the Modern World.<br />
LEO DOCHERTY<br />
Leo Docherty is the Director of the Conservative Middle East Council (CMEC).<br />
He is the author of Desert of Death: A Soldier’s Journey From Iraq to<br />
Afghanistan.<br />
Conservative Middle East Council<br />
55 Tufton Street, London, SW1P 3QL<br />
t: +44 (0) 20 7340 6007<br />
e: info@cmec.org.uk<br />
w: www.cmec.org.uk<br />
@CMECnews<br />
The views expressed herein are those of the authors not of the<br />
Conservative Middle East Council or the Conservative Party.