Acco_Exhibition Catalogue_Eng
Transform your PDFs into Flipbooks and boost your revenue!
Leverage SEO-optimized Flipbooks, powerful backlinks, and multimedia content to professionally showcase your products and significantly increase your reach.
One Thousand Nights and Days<br />
Akko through the Ages<br />
Editors: Ann. E. Killebrew and Vered Raz-Romeo<br />
Hecht Museum<br />
University of Haifa
One Thousand Nights and Days – Akko through the Ages<br />
Museum director and curator Ofra Rimon<br />
Assistant to the director and curator Shunit Netter-Marmelstein<br />
Registrar Perry Harel<br />
Curators of the exhibition and editors of the catalogue Ann E. Killebrew and Vered Raz-Romeo<br />
<strong>Exhibition</strong> design Tav Group<br />
<strong>Catalogue</strong> design Noga Mizrachi<br />
<strong>Eng</strong>lish translation and editing A.M. Goldstein<br />
Hebrew editing Israel Ronen<br />
Printing Millenum Ayalon Ltd.<br />
<strong>Catalogue</strong> No. 31, Spring 2010<br />
© All rights reserved to the Hecht Museum, University of Haifa<br />
ISBN 978-965-7034-21-7
Contents<br />
5* Ofra Rimon Preface<br />
7* Ann E. Killebrew and Vered Raz-Romeo Akko’s Shared Heritage<br />
15* Michal Artzy and Ron Beeri Tel Akko<br />
25* Ron Beeri Funerary and Ancestor Worship Characteristics Identifiable<br />
at Tel Akko<br />
33* Yotam Tepper A Pagan Cemetery from the Roman Period at the Foot of<br />
Tel Akko: Evidence of the Burial of Roman Soldiers<br />
and Citizens of Colonia Ptolemais<br />
41* Eliezer Stern and Hanaa Abu-Uqsa New Archaeological Discoveries from Crusader Period Acre<br />
49* Adrian J. Boaz Daily Life in Frankish Acre<br />
55* Edna J. Stern Ceramics as a Reflection of Maritime Commercial Activity<br />
at Crusader Acre<br />
61* Yael Fuhrmann-Na'aman Conservation of the Knights Hospitaller Compound<br />
67* Danny Syon The Mint of Akko through the Ages<br />
75* Anastasia Shapiro Ottoman Period Tobacco Smoking Pipes and Nargile Heads<br />
from Excavations in the Old City of Akko<br />
81* Deborah Cvikel and Ya'acov Kahanov Underwater Excavations at Akko<br />
83* Bibliography
Fig 1: Aerial view of the Old City of Akko. (Photo: M. Eisenberg)<br />
4*
Preface<br />
The researchers, who collaborated to produce the exhibition One Thousand Nights and Days – Akko through<br />
the Ages and its catalogue, share in uncovering the hidden treasures of Akko – a city of great importance on the<br />
northern coast of the Land of Israel over the course of thousands of years. Its importance is due to its having a<br />
closed natural harbor and in being located at both maritime and continental crossroads.<br />
The absence of two researchers in this catalogue is apparent: the late Professors Moshe Dothan and Avner Raban.<br />
Dothan, who founded the Department of Archaeology at the University of Haifa in 1983, joined the late Dr. Elisha<br />
Linder and Raban in teaching at the University’s Department of Maritime Civilizations, which they had established<br />
in 1973. The joint objective of these three scholars had been to research the ancient history of northern Israel.<br />
Back in 1965, Raban had conducted the first survey and excavations of Akko harbor in the framework of the<br />
activities of the Israel Underwater Archaeological Society. In the 1970s, he continued his research of Akko harbor,<br />
this time on behalf of the Center for Maritime Studies at the University of Haifa. In the course of these underwater<br />
excavations, the remains of sea-going vessels and the ancient harbor were investigated.<br />
Between 1973 and 1989, Dothan conducted the excavations at Tel Akko. Students from the University of Haifa<br />
and volunteers from both Israel and abroad took part in this activity. At the same time, Raban directed the<br />
excavations at Areas P and F.<br />
The results of the excavations at Tel Akko, which testify to the city’s great importance and to its land and seatrade<br />
connections with neighboring countries, were published only in part. The finds are still being explored by<br />
researchers, led by Prof. Michal Artzy of RIMS (Leon Recanati Institute for Maritime Studies) and the Department<br />
of Maritime Civilizations at the University of Haifa.<br />
We wish to extend our appreciation to the curators of the exhibition and editors of the catalogue, Professor Ann<br />
E. Killebrew (Pennsylvania State University) and Dr. Vered Raz-Romeo (University of Haifa), whose personal and<br />
professional affinity to Akko is manifested in this exhibition. Their special connection flourished in within the<br />
framework of the US Department of State Wye River People-to-People program (2002-2006), a project devoted<br />
to exploring Akko’s multicultural heritage that was conducted with the support of the University of Haifa and the<br />
Israel Antiquities Authority.<br />
Our appreciation and thanks go to all researchers who contributed to the exhibition and its catalogue; to Prof.<br />
Michal Artzy, Dr. Ron Beeri, Dr. Ya'acov Kahanov, and Dr. Ezra Marcus, of the University of Haifa; to the staff<br />
members of the Israel Antiquities Authority: Eliezer Stern, Dr. Danny Syon, Dr. Edna Stern, Dr. Hava Katz, Dr. Orit<br />
Shamir, Michael Saban, Allegra Sabriago, Dr. Donald Ariel, and Gabriela Bichovsky; to Fawzi Ibrahim, curator of<br />
the Rockefeller Museum; to the Department of Museums in the Israel Ministry of Culture and Sport; and to the<br />
board of the Hecht Foundation.<br />
Ofra Rimon<br />
Museum Director and Curator<br />
5*
Fig. 2: Aerial view and map of key historic structures and sites documented by the Wye River People-to-People Heritage Project.<br />
(Photo: M. Eisenberg; drawing: K.M. Barry)<br />
6* Ann E. Killebrew and Vered Raz-Romeo
Akko’s Shared Heritage<br />
Ann E. Killebrew The Pennsylvania State University<br />
Vered Raz-Romeo University of Haifa<br />
<strong>Exhibition</strong> Curators<br />
This exhibit – One Thousand Nights and Days – Akko through the Ages – is dedicated to Akko’s rich tangible<br />
and intangible heritage, past and present. Akko’s impressive archaeological remains, historic structures, and<br />
rich cultural heritage are illustrated by a multitude of historical texts, colorful stories, and oral histories. These<br />
stories, together with Akko’s tangible heritage, serve as the centerpiece for this exhibit, which had its origins<br />
in a University of Haifa project (2001-2005) devoted to Akko’s multi cultural heritage and diverse communities.<br />
Our endeavor was part of a larger project entitled, “Recognizing and Preserving the Common Heritage of Israel<br />
and the Palestinian National Authority,” that included teams from the University of Haifa and the Palestinian<br />
Association for Cultural Exchange (PACE) in Ramallah. Supported by the United States Department of State, this<br />
project was funded by the Wye River People-to-People Exchange Program, which resulted from the Wye River<br />
Memorandum signed by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and PLO Chairman Yasser Arafat and witnessed by<br />
President Bill Clinton at the White House on October 23, 1998. The stated goals of this program included the<br />
enhancement of mutual understanding between Israelis and Palestinians and the strengthening of prospects for<br />
peaceful co-existence. In the spirit of the exchange program, Akko was selected as one of several sites where our<br />
team members met, worked, and explored the concept of a shared heritage and co-existence in the past and in<br />
the present (Fig. 2).<br />
Because of its strategic, coastal location and its natural harbor, Akko has served throughout its history as a major<br />
cross road and meeting place between east and west. During the first three millennia (Early Bronze-Hellenistic<br />
periods [ca. 3200-200 BCE]), Akko’s Canaanite and Phoenician inhabitants resided on the mound located to the<br />
east of the modern city (Fig. 3). Beginning in the Hellenistic period, Akko was renamed Ptolemais, and it expanded<br />
to the west, where it included parts of the present day Old and New City. In Byzantine times, Akko retained its<br />
importance and was the seat of a bishopric in the archdiocese of Tyre. Following the Islamic conquest in the 7th<br />
century CE, the city’s original Semitic name, Akka, was restored. During the medieval period at the beginning<br />
of the 12th century CE, Acre, as it was known during the Crusader period, was an important naval base that<br />
became the capital of the Crusader kingdom in 1191. In 1291, the Crusader stronghold was conquered and<br />
destroyed by Mamluks, led by Al-Malik al-Ashraf. Following a period of decline, Akko regained its importance<br />
as a port city during the Ottoman period. By the late 18th century, the city became the capital of the vilâyet of<br />
Sidon. Pasha Ahmad al-Jazzar transformed Akko, refortifying and building numerous public structures, including<br />
markets, inns (khans), mosques, and a sophisticated water system. Under his rule, Al-Jazzar created a political<br />
and military center strong enough to deter Napoleon in 1799 during the “Little Corporal's” unsuccessful siege<br />
of Acre, a disaster that marked the collapse of Napoleon’s expedition and conquest of the Middle East. In 1918,<br />
Akko fell under British Mandate rule. Subsequently Akko was assigned by the UN Partition Plan to the Arabs in<br />
1947 but fell to Israeli forces on May 17, 1948. Today its population of nearly 50,000 inhabitants is approximately<br />
three-fourths Jewish and one-fourth Arab (for a more detailed overview of Akko’s history, see Schur 1990).<br />
Ann E. Killebrew and Vered Raz-Romeo 7*
Fig. 3: View of the entrance to Tel Akko. (Photo: A.E. Killebrew)<br />
In recognition of Akko’s outstanding universal value, the Old City of Akko was inscribed as a World Heritage site<br />
in 2001. At present, Akko’s major stakeholders include Old Acre Development Company (a government company<br />
that receives support from the Ministry of Tourism), Amidar (Israel National Housing Company and owner of<br />
abandoned properties), UNESCO, Israel Antiquities Authority (IAA), municipality of Akko, numerous local and<br />
religious groups (including the Bahai community, which considers Akko its most holy site [Ruhe 1983]), pre-and<br />
post-1948 communities, private investors, local businesses, and academics. As in the past, 21st century Akko’s<br />
inhabitants are diverse, representing all of the major religious and cultural traditions of the region. Today the city’s<br />
most visible heritage comprises once-elegant, but deteriorating, Ottoman period villas and structures, which exist<br />
side by side with and on top of the best-preserved Crusader site in the world.<br />
Between 2001 and 2005, a University of Haifa team of archaeologists, in partnership with the IAA, implemented<br />
several projects dealing with Akko’s diverse communities. Projects included the documentation of Akko’s religious<br />
communities and their houses of worship, the digitalization of the British Mandate period archaeological archive<br />
relating to Akko that is stored in the Rockefeller Museum in Jerusalem, and the compilation of oral histories in<br />
regard to several historical residential Ottoman period villas, the families that resided in them, and the conservation<br />
of these structures as domestic residences and hotels or their conversion into community centers (see, e.g., Balter<br />
2002; Killebrew et al. 2006; Killebrew, Scham, and Weinstein-Evron in press).<br />
8* Ann E. Killebrew and Vered Raz-Romeo
Religious Communities of Akko and Their Tangible Heritage: A Snapshot<br />
Today, Akko’s religious communities include a mixed population of Christians, Jews, Muslims, Bahais, and Druze.<br />
As one aspect of the Wye River People-to-People Project, we interviewed members of these communities and<br />
documented the history of several of their houses of worship: the Jewish community/Ramchal Synagogue,<br />
Greek Orthodox community/Church of St. George, the Malkite Greek community/St. Andrew Cathedral, Muslim<br />
community/Al-Mualeq Mosque, and the Sufi Shadhiliyya-Yashrutiyya Zawiya. The University of Haifa team also<br />
studied several other Ottoman period structures, including Khan al-Umdan, the Serai, Khammar House, and the<br />
House of Crafts (Fig. 2; see Killebrew, Scham, and Weinstein-Evron in press).<br />
Jewish Akko<br />
Akko, unlike many cities in Israel, has no ancient Israelite history although it is mentioned several times in the<br />
Bible. From the 3rd century BCE onward, Akko’s Jewish community is well documented from various sources<br />
(see Be’eri 2004 for a compilation of these sources; see, also, Scham in press for a summary and detailed<br />
bibliography). During the Hellenistic and Roman periods, a vital and largely Hellenized Jewish community lived<br />
together with Greeks and Phoenicians in Ptolemais. The city was infamous for the capture of Jonathan Maccabee<br />
and the slaughter of one thousand of his troops (1 Maccabees 12: 47-48). A second disaster befell Jews in Akko<br />
during the First Jewish Revolt against the Romans, when thousands of Jews were massacred (Josephus, Jewish<br />
War II: XVIII.5). Following the two Jewish revolts, Jews flocked to the Galilee and Akko. Numerous references to<br />
Akko in Rabbinic sources, especially the Jerusalem and Babylonian Talmuds, indicate a once-flourishing Jewish<br />
community (Beeri 2004: 40-65). Several well-known rabbis of Late Antiquity (i.e., the late Roman and Byzantine<br />
periods) either visited or resided in Akko. Like most minority communities in Byzantine Eretz Israel, Akko’s<br />
Jewish community experienced a period of turmoil, which may explain its alliance with the Sassanid Persian<br />
Empire, whose troops invaded the region in the early 7th century, and its burning of Christian churches in Akko.<br />
Conditions for the Jews of Akko worsened, however, with the return of Byzantine rule, but once again improved<br />
in the aftermath of the Muslim conquest of Eretz Israel several decades later. Prior to the Crusader conquest of<br />
Akko, sources mention both a rabbinical court and a yeshiva. During Crusader rule, the city’s prosperity attracted<br />
large numbers of Jewish immigrants, who came for religious as well as economic reasons. Several important<br />
Jewish leaders visited Akko during this period, including the Rambam (Maimonides). Following the Mamluk<br />
conquest of Akko in 1291, we have little information on a Jewish community in the city until the Ottoman<br />
period. Beginning with the reign of Dhaher al-Omar in the 18th century, Jews were encouraged to settle in Akko.<br />
Jewish influence increased during the time of Ahmad<br />
al-Jazzar as best illustrated by the influential position<br />
held by Haim Fahri, who served as his chief advisor.<br />
The final century of Ottoman rule and the subsequent<br />
British Mandate represented a period of decline for<br />
the Jewish community in Akko. During the Mandate,<br />
the citadel of Acre functioned as a prison, and many<br />
Jewish underground movement activists, including<br />
Zeev Jabotinsky and Shlomo Ben-Yosef, as well as<br />
Baha’u’llah (founder of the Bahai faith), were jailed<br />
Fig. 4: Interior view of the Ramchal Synagogue.<br />
there. Following the creation of the State of Israel in<br />
(Photo: M. Eisenberg)<br />
1948, new Jewish immigrants and also Arabs from<br />
Ann E. Killebrew and Vered Raz-Romeo 9*
towns in the Galilee settled in parts of the city that had been deserted by the city’s pre-1948 Arab population<br />
(see Scham in press for a detailed description of the history of Akko’s Jewish community).<br />
Today’s Jewish community is served by two synagogues – Ohr Torah in the New City and the historic Ramchal<br />
Synagogue located in the Old City. The latter is named in honor of the great kabbalist Moshe Chaim Luzzatto<br />
(Ramchal), who arrived in 1743 and died in Akko between 1744 and 1747 (Fig. 4). <strong>Acco</strong>rding to tradition, the<br />
original synagogue was built above a large Crusader structure that had served as a gate to the Genovese Quarter.<br />
In 1758, the Bedouin ruler of Acre, Dhahar al-Omar, took over the synagogue and built the Al-Mualek Mosque<br />
on top of it. In place of the synagogue, the Jews of Akko received a small building north of the mosque. The<br />
building, a one-room, Ottoman-style structure with four arches and a domed ceiling, still functions as a house of<br />
worship and bears the name of the Ramchal. The bimah (cantor's lectern) is located against the wall facing the<br />
Torah shrine.<br />
Muslim Akka<br />
The Muslim history of Akko begins with Caliph Omar’s defeat of the Byzantine imperial army in 636 CE at the<br />
battle of the Yarmouk. Although Akko doubtlessly remained a primary port city, little from written sources is<br />
known of it during the centuries following the Islamic conquest of the region. From an account by Ahmad Ibn<br />
Tulun, Akko was unfortified when he arrived in the 9th century. However, by the 11th century, the Persian pilgrim<br />
Nisir-i-Khusrau described Akko’s strong fortifications and remarked that the city was the resting place of the<br />
Prophet Salah. During the Crusader period, most Arab texts deal with historical events; an exception was Ibn<br />
Jubair, who described the Crusader “defilement” of the city. In 1291, Mamluk forces succeeded in conquering<br />
the city and razed it to the ground as described by the Muslim geographer Abu al-Fida (Abu-Uqsa 2004; see<br />
Atrash et al. in press for a summary and detailed bibliography).<br />
In early Ottoman times, Akko was a small village; in the 17th century, it was renovated by the Druze emir<br />
Fahr a-Din. Akko’s fortunes further improved under Dhahar al-Omar, who had rebelled against Ottoman rule,<br />
established the seat of his government in the city, and built a palace on the site of the monastery of the Knights<br />
of St John. With the capture of Akko from al-Omar in 1775, Ahmad al-Jazzar was granted the title of Pasha<br />
by Ottoman authorities. His construction of the Al-Jazzar mosque, where he was later buried, indicates the<br />
significance of Akko. It is estimated that by the end of the Ottoman period, 90% of the area of Acre belonged to<br />
the Islamic wakf. Today about two-thirds of the Old City’s residents are Arab Muslims, mainly families that were<br />
relocated in the Old City from the Galilee after 1948.<br />
Old Akko’s six mosques (Al-Jazzar, Al-Bahr, Al-Raml, Al-Majadila, Al-Zaytuna, and Al-Mualeq) and one Sufi Zawiya<br />
(Al-Zawiya al-Shadhiliyya) serve as symbols of the past and as centers of spiritual life. Al-Jazzar is the most famous<br />
of Akko’s mosques, with its dome and minaret serving as noteworthy landmarks (Figs. 5, 6). The University of<br />
Haifa Shared Heritage group studied in greater detail two of the Muslim religious structures: the Al-Mualeq<br />
Mosque and the Al-Zawiaya al-Shadhiliyya.<br />
The Al-Mualeq Mosque is also known as Dhahar al-Omar Mosque in honor of its 18th century builder. As<br />
mentioned, it was built above the Crusader period gate to the Genovese Quarter and on the foundations of<br />
an earlier synagogue. After 1948, all of the mosques in Akko were closed, including Al-Mualeq, and squatters,<br />
who had lost all of their property in the war, broke in and occupied them. One of the Akko's families, whose<br />
father had worked as a guard in the mosque, took up residence in some of the rooms after his house had<br />
collapsed. In 1988, after nearly forty years of residence there, the family was persuaded to leave. Donations were<br />
10* Ann E. Killebrew and Vered Raz-Romeo
Fig. 5: General view of Al-Jazzar Mosque and the Old City, looking northwest. (Photo: A.E. Killebrew)<br />
Fig. 6: Interior of Al-Jazzar Mosque. (Photo: M. Eisenberg)<br />
Ann E. Killebrew and Vered Raz-Romeo 11*
given for renovating and restoring the mosque, which<br />
was reopened in 1989. Today the Al-Mualeq Mosque<br />
is also an important social institution that provides<br />
assistance to the neediest members of its community.<br />
Fig. 7: Entrance to the Church of St. George. (Photo: A.E. Killebrew)<br />
Fig. 8: Interior of the Church of St. George. (Photo: M. Eisenberg)<br />
Fig. 9: Western façade of St. Andrew Cathedral.<br />
(Photo: M. Eisenberg)<br />
The Al-Zawiya al-Shadhiliyya serves as a center for Sufi<br />
worshippers from around the world. The Shadhiliyya<br />
tariqa (school of Sufism) was established by Sheikh<br />
Abu al-Hassan Ali al-Shadhali. The faithful affiliated<br />
with the order are called dervishes, and members<br />
espouse a life of simplicity and modesty. The zawiya<br />
is a religious and social center that includes dwellings,<br />
an assembly hall where prayers are conducted, and a<br />
sheikh’s tomb where the founder of the brotherhood<br />
is buried. Sheikh Ali Nur al-Din al-Yashruti, the founder<br />
of the Al-Zawiya al-Shadhiliyya in Akko, was born into<br />
an affluent and respected family in Tunisia at the end<br />
of the 18th century. After the death of his mentor and<br />
his mother in the same year, he set out on a journey,<br />
during which the Prophet Yunis (Jonah) is said to have<br />
told him to “go settle in Akko.” The construction<br />
of the Al-Zawiya al-Shadhiliyya followed in 1862.<br />
After Jewish forces captured Akko in 1948, refugees<br />
arrived in the city from the surrounding Arab villages<br />
and towns and took up residence in the abandoned<br />
dwellings of the zawiya. Today the brotherhood has<br />
plans for restoring the zawiya, and the order has hopes<br />
of reviving its presence in Akko and participating fully<br />
in the life of the city.<br />
Christian Acre<br />
The first mention of Christians in Akko is the Apostle<br />
Paul’s arrival in 56 CE. In the Acts of the Apostles<br />
21: 7, Paul writes: "We arrived at Ptolemais; and we<br />
greeted the brethren and stayed with them for one<br />
day." Following Paul's visit, the Christian community<br />
grew and prospered. By the 4th century CE, Akko was<br />
important enough to be represented by its bishop,<br />
Aeneas, at Constantine’s Council of Nicaea in 325, the<br />
first ecumenical council of the Christian church. During<br />
the following decades, many of Acre's residents, who<br />
had previously been pagans, converted and replaced<br />
their temples with churches. The city’s Christian<br />
12* Ann E. Killebrew and Vered Raz-Romeo
character during the Byzantine period is reflected in a 6th century account (570 CE) by an anonymous pilgrim<br />
from Piacenza (Italy), who describes many lovely monasteries adorning the city. Following the Arab conquest of<br />
the region (ca. 640 CE), Acre was under Islamic rule for almost 500 years. The Crusader period ushered in the<br />
golden age of Christian Acre. The city played host to fourteen consecutive Catholic bishops. Many churches<br />
were founded in this period, most of them associated with either one of the Italian cities, such as Venice, Pisa,<br />
or Genoa, or one of the monastic orders, like the Dominicans, Hospitallers, or Templars. Serving as the main<br />
port of arrival for pilgrims from the west, Acre was visited by thousands of Christian pilgrims annually. The fall<br />
of Christian Acre to the Mamluks brought about its decline, and over the course of several centuries its churches<br />
and public structures fell into ruin. During Giovanni Mariti’s visit (1760) to Akko, he writes that the Church of St.<br />
Andrew, the bishop's palace, and various Christian institutions still stood in the western part of the town (Mariti<br />
1769). He describes the Greek Orthodox Church, constructed on the ruins of ancient structures, as the largest in<br />
Acre. Four Christian communities – Greek Catholic, Greek Orthodox, Roman Catholic, and Maronite – worship<br />
in Old City churches today. Two of these churches and their communities formed part of the University of Haifa<br />
Shared Heritage Project (see Beeri 2004; Raz-Romeo 2004; Beeri et al. in press).<br />
The Greek Orthodox Church of St. George was named after the famous saint of Lydda, a Roman officer who was<br />
executed for his refusal to harm other Christians (Figs. 7, 8). The Greek Orthodox community believes that it is<br />
built over the foundations of a Byzantine church from the time of Constantine that might have been destroyed<br />
by the Sassanids. The spot was, according to some writers, also the location of a synagogue between the 7th and<br />
11th centuries CE; however, no remains of either building have been found up to now. The architectural plan of<br />
the Church of St. George presents a modified Byzantine style, with a basilica and three aisles, ending in apses.<br />
The recently restored monastery to the east of the Church of St. George is constructed on groined arches and<br />
surrounds a central, rectangular space. On the ground floor of the monastery are an entrance corridor, an open<br />
courtyard, a garden, and a broad hall that now functions as a religious meeting room.<br />
Less than five years before the construction of the existing Greek Catholic Church of St. Andrew (1765), Giovanni<br />
Mariti visited the area and noted the general dilapidation of the previous church (Mariti 1769). The present<br />
cathedral of St. Andrew was constructed by special permission of Dhahar al-Omar in 1765 (Fig. 9). The 18th<br />
century incarnation of the Church of St. Andrew is, in fact, a true cathedral – in terms of its function and size<br />
and as the seat of a bishop - that served all of the Galilee during the last century and a half of Ottoman rule.<br />
Currently church ministers tend mainly to the needs of Akko’s local community, numbering 400-450 members.<br />
Today Akko continues its tradition of being a meeting place for diverse cultures and variegated backgrounds. The<br />
increased awareness and significant investment in infrastructure and tangible heritage that Akko has gained in<br />
recent years, together with its recognition as a UNESCO World Heritage Site, will hopefully serve to protect and<br />
preserve both its heritage and its communities. The Hecht Museum exhibit and the accompanying collection of<br />
essays in this catalogue on Akko’s heritage – past and present – are tributes to this great city, whose history and<br />
many communities span the past five thousand years.<br />
Ann E. Killebrew and Vered Raz-Romeo 13*
Fig. 10: Aerial Photograph of Tel Akko and its surroundings. (Photo: M. Eisenberg)<br />
14* Michal Artzy and Ron Beeri
Tel Akko<br />
Michal Artzy and Ron Beeri University of Haifa *<br />
The ancient site of Akko is situated on a kurkar hill, west of the modern city of Akko (Fig. 10). Today’s local<br />
inhabitants often refer to the mound as Tell el-Fukhar (the tell of the sherds) or "Napoleon’s Hill."<br />
The tell is situated in fertile agricultural environs, with plentiful water from natural springs. In its close vicinity<br />
are the best-protected natural anchorages along the southern Levantine coast. Geological studies showed that<br />
the site was surrounded by water on the north-west, west, and south. It has been proposed that during some<br />
periods, such as the Late Bronze age, the Na’aman (Belos) River estuary was used for anchorage nearby the<br />
tell. Whatever the situation, an estuary could well have reached the site from the sea and an anchorage been<br />
situated there (Sivan 1981; Inbar and Sivan 1984; Raban 1991; Zviely et al. 2006; Artzy 2006a). The site’s further<br />
advantageous position was that it lay at the intersection of maritime with terrestrial routes, leading eastward to<br />
the Jordan Valley and further to Cis-Jordan. This favorable geographic position encouraged trade and traders,<br />
and Akko, with few intervals, functioned as an important administrative and trading center in the cultural and<br />
geographic region of southern Syria, Phoenicia, and Eretz-Israel from the Middle Bronze II to the Ottoman Empire,<br />
or for nearly three thousand years (Beeri 2008).<br />
Excavations at Tel Akko (Fig. 11) took place intermittently from 1973-1989 under the direction of Prof. M.<br />
Dothan. The excavations included delegations from Marburg University in Germany under the direction of Prof.<br />
D. Conrad; an American team headed by Prof. A. Ritterschpach; and members of the University of Haifa’s thennamed<br />
Center for Maritime Studies. The Center’s late Prof. A. Raban and Prof. M. Artzy acted as area supervisors<br />
and assistant project directors interchangeably. In 1999, a limited study dig for students in the University of<br />
Haifa’s Archaeology and Maritime Civilizations Departments took place under the direction of Profs. M. Artzy and<br />
A.E. Killebrew. All in all, nine areas were excavated, revealing remains dating to the Early Bronze I, Middle Bronze<br />
II, Late Bronze I and II, Iron I and II, Persian, Hellenistic, and Medieval periods.<br />
Tel Akko in the Early Bronze Age<br />
The site of Akko appears in the Ebla texts, dating to ca. 2400-2250 BCE (Matthiae 1981, Fig. 9). Akko is one of<br />
several coastal sites, in addition to Byblos, Sidon, Dor, Ashdod, and Gaza, that were included on the itinerary of a<br />
merchant from Ebla. Unfortunately, no remains from that period, whether Early Bronze II or III, have been found<br />
on the mound, but ceramic remains from the Early Bronze I were documented in a survey carried out in the area<br />
of the tell.<br />
Tel Akko in the Middle Bronze Age<br />
Akko and its Semitic ruler are among the locations and individuals mentioned in the early second millennium<br />
Egyptian Execration Texts (Posner 1940: 31-34). Imports from the Lebanese coast and from Cyprus underscore<br />
the importance of Akko’s anchorage/harbor and its trading network.<br />
* Preparation of the Tel Akko material, both the artifacts for the exhibition, and the photos and drawings for our article in this catalogue, were<br />
carried out by members of the Sir Maurice and Lady Irene Hatter Laboratory of Coastal and Harbor Archaeology, directed by Prof. Michal Artzy.<br />
The Hatter and Frankel Foundations provided the financial aid.<br />
Michal Artzy and Ron Beeri 15*
Fig. 11: Map of Tel Akko, with the excavated areas marked. (Drawing: J. Quartermaine)<br />
The earliest architectural remains at Tel Akko date to the earliest phases of the Middle Bronze IIA period. The<br />
excavation on the summit of the tell exposed a rampart that was not much higher than the natural kurkar hill.<br />
On its apex, a wall was constructed either for defense or architectural purposes. From the presently available<br />
archaeological data, it seems that only a portion of the tell as it appears today was settled or artificially constructed<br />
in the early MB IIA (Fig. 12). During the latter part of the Middle Bronze IIA, settlement expanded and the<br />
ramparts were extended to the south, west, and possibly to the east. The rampart (its Phase 3) reached a height<br />
of 22 meters and a width of 60 meters. The northern part was strengthened, and a gate, named the “Sea Gate,”<br />
erected (Fig. 13) (Dothan and Raban 1980). A fortress constructed of square mud bricks, protected by a glacis,<br />
was also constructed at this time on the tell’s summit (Fig. 14). Because of the natural barrier of the sea bordering<br />
on the western and southwestern side, the ramparts were lower in height. A stone-lined “postern gate” was<br />
noted in the southern rampart under Area PH although its exact usage is questionable (Fig. 15). It is more likely<br />
a sewage outlet for superfluous fluids from the site and/or the rampart.<br />
Built graves, dating to the end of the MBIIB (MBIII, Akko Phase 2) and the earliest part of the Late Bronze period<br />
(Phase 1), were found in Areas AB and H. Imported wares found in the graves originated in Egypt, Cyprus, Syria,<br />
and Cilicia.<br />
16* Michal Artzy and Ron Beeri
Fig. 12: Section in the rampart construction. (Tel Akko archives)<br />
Fig. 13: Stairs in the entrance to the MBIIa "Sea Gate."<br />
(Tel Akko archives)<br />
Tel Akko in Late Bronze I and II,<br />
The Amarna Period<br />
During the Late Bronze Age, Akko appears in the<br />
military annals of Thutmose III, Seti I, and Ramses II,<br />
Pharaohs of the 18th and 19th Dynasties. Thus far,<br />
no destruction levels attributable to the Egyptian<br />
army campaigns have been uncovered. In Area AB on<br />
the summit of the tell, the early Middle Bronze Age<br />
fortifications have fallen into a state of disrepair and<br />
neglect. The mud brick fortress was abandoned and<br />
buried under garbage dumps and burials. Is it the Akko<br />
that Tuthmose III boasts of sacking and plundering, or<br />
had the settlement shifted and not yet been located?<br />
There seems little doubt, though, that at a later period,<br />
coinciding with increased Egyptian economic interests<br />
in the area (Redford 1990:59; Mizrachi 2005:167,<br />
266), Akko served as an active anchorage/harbor.<br />
Remains of Egyptian storage jars and ceramics from<br />
Cyprus and the Aegean dating to that period were<br />
found in Akko, testimony to an active maritime trade.<br />
Akko is mentioned 13 times in the Amarna letters<br />
found in Egypt, an indication of its mercantile and<br />
military importance. The city’s kings, like those of other<br />
cities in the area, were officially vassals of the Egyptian<br />
Pharaoh although, like those others, they evinced a<br />
pronounced ambivalence toward the Pharaoh. El<br />
Amarna letter 8 (EA 8) describes one king who sent<br />
great amounts of lapis lazuli stone to the Pharaoh,<br />
but embarrassed him by robbing a Babylonian caravan<br />
on its way to Egypt in the vicinity of Hinaton. Despite<br />
the fact that the ruler of Akko had independent<br />
military and economic relationships with the chiefs of<br />
Megiddo and Samaria, Akko’s importance to Egyptian<br />
interests reveals itself in the number of soldiers and<br />
pairs of horses received from the Pharaoh, far more<br />
than did the ruler of Byblos as is known from a letter<br />
sent by Rib-Addi of Byblos (EA 88). Egyptian Pharaohs<br />
Seti I and his son, Ramses II, each boasted that they<br />
conquered Akko. A written source found in Ugarit in<br />
the Egyptian governor’s palace at Tel Apheq-Antipatris<br />
mentions shipments of wheat from Akko.<br />
Michal Artzy and Ron Beeri 17*
Fig. 14: Mud bricks in the MBIIa rampart construction.<br />
(Tel Akko archives)<br />
Fig. 15: Postern Gate, or sewage outlet in MBIIa rampart.<br />
(Photo: M. Artzy)<br />
Tel Akko at the End of the Late Bronze (Late Bronze III) Period<br />
During the 13th century BCE, settlement patterns on the tell changed. Augmented settlement on the ramparts,<br />
pits, some lined with stones for storage, metal recycling, including jewelry production, and a purple dye industry<br />
using murex shells were all uncovered in Areas AB (Fig. 16), H (Fig. 17), and PH (Fig. 18) (Artzy 2006a, 2006b).<br />
An unusual cultic area, found on the northern rampart in Area H, included an altar bearing designs made by<br />
incisions of four ships (Artzy 2003). Three large pebbles, two of which were incised, one with a ship and a fish<br />
(dolphin?) and the other with a dolphin or tuna (Fig. 19), were found inside the altar, which was connected by a<br />
row of stones to a partially lined pit bordered by ash. Imported ceramics dating to the last part of the 13th/early<br />
12th century BCE were found in all excavated areas. All this provides ample evidence of Akko’s active maritime<br />
trade with Egypt, as well as the Aegean, but especially with Cyprus. The southern MBII gate was actively utilized<br />
in this period, as well. The anchorage was likely moved from the north-western side of the tell to the south in<br />
association with the Na’aman River estuary. Akko’s adaptation to the Iron IA period seems to have taken place<br />
with little disruption. No signs of destructions by the “Sea Peoples” or others were noted. The site continued<br />
to function and slowly bolstered habitation on its eastern side, closer to the agricultural area, as the maritime<br />
network weakened.<br />
Tel Akko in the Iron Age<br />
During the Iron I period, Tell Keisan (Tel Kison), a few kilometers further inland, may have replaced Akko as an<br />
administrative center, most likely because of the lull in maritime contact, combined with the favorable agricultural<br />
position enjoyed by Tell Keisan. Akko was not “inherited” by the Israelites (Judges 1:31-32). <strong>Acco</strong>rding to I<br />
Kings 9:12-13, the city was one of the settlements given by Solomon to Hiram, King of Tyre, as payment for the<br />
construction of the palace and the Temple in Jerusalem. Nevertheless, Akko continued to serve as an important<br />
settlement, along with other Phoenician cities, such as Tyre and Sarepta.<br />
With the growing power of the Assyrian Empire in Phoenicia, the harbor of Akko regained its importance. The<br />
city is mentioned in the Annals of Sennacherib and Essarhadon, kings of Assyria. Akko, along with Tyre and<br />
Sidon, submitted to Assyria and was eventually conquered. When Assyrian power waned, the inhabitants of<br />
Akko rebelled, only to be subdued by Assurbanipal. His boastful words describe a gory scene of hanged bodies<br />
around the parameters of the city, forced conscription into the Assyrian army, and the dispersal of the inhabitants<br />
to the land of Geshur.<br />
18* Michal Artzy and Ron Beeri
Fig. 16: Area AB of the Late Bronze II/III period. (Tel Akko archives)<br />
Fig. 17: Pit and its ceramic contents in Area H. (Photo: M. Artzy)<br />
Michal Artzy and Ron Beeri 19*
Fig. 18: Area PH pits and Cypriote imports found in one of them. (Photo: M. Artzy)<br />
A small section of a floor paved with ceramic sherds dating to the Assyrian period was found on the summit of<br />
the tell in Area A. The limited excavations in the area unearthed a few remains that could be attributed to that<br />
period.<br />
Tel Akko in the Persian Period<br />
The harbor of Akko played a major role during the Persian period. In his quest for control of Egypt, Cambyses, the<br />
Achamaenid Persian king, established Akko as his major harbor. His army included soldiers from many different<br />
nationalities as we are told both by Herodotus (Books 3, 7) and by Egyptian annals. The maritime contingent<br />
stationed in Akko consisted of seafarers, Phoenicians from the coastal Levant, Cypriotes, and possibly Greeks.<br />
The location of the Persian period harbor is still under debate. Raban felt that a Phoenician-type artificial harbor<br />
was constructed in the bay of Akko and used by Cambyses (Raban 1991, 1995). In response, the city slowly<br />
expanded westward toward the port. Another possibility is that the harbor was more of an anchorage closer to<br />
the tell. Only later, during the late Persian or early Hellenistic Period, was a harbor actually constructed in the bay.<br />
Persian period remains on the tell itself are numerous. Good stratigraphic remains of buildings were located<br />
mainly in two areas: Area AB, where ostraca, including one of the longest Phoenician texts ever unearthed in<br />
Israel (Dothan 1985), were found in an administrative building (Fig. 20); and in G, where undeciphered ostraca<br />
written in a Phoenician script were recovered from a massive construction of which only the robbers’ trenches<br />
are extant. The Phoenician-style material culture included the sherds of cremation containers, miniature glass<br />
figurines and clay figurines, and East Greek and imported Cypriot decorated ware. A large number of storage<br />
jars, often mistakenly referred to as “Persian,” was also found; most likely, they served as the standard maritime<br />
shipping containers for Phoenicians traders. The unusual number of sherds (which gave rise to the Arabic name<br />
of the site, Tell el-Fukhar) and the limited construction might indicate at least the construction on the tell of<br />
20* Michal Artzy and Ron Beeri
Fig. 19: Photograph and drawing of ships’ altar and one of the pebbles. (Photo: M. Artzy; Drawing: R. Pollak)<br />
Michal Artzy and Ron Beeri 21*
temporary shelters, possibly for Persian soldiers, whose<br />
supplies were administered by the Phoenicians.<br />
Fig. 20: Phoenician ostracon from Area AB. (Tel Akko archives)<br />
In Area F, a concentration of imported Greek ceramics<br />
was found. Among the wares are Black Figure Wares<br />
and a Red Figure krater that bears a Dionysian scene.<br />
As to whether these finds symbolize a “Greek colony”<br />
or merely imports is difficult to determine. However,<br />
one should remember that the army of Cambyses II, as<br />
Herodotus noted (III.7, 88), was assembled from many<br />
different nationalities, and some of the soldiers could<br />
well have stayed in the area to take advantage of Akko’s<br />
active maritime site.<br />
The importance of Akko harbor is indicated by the Aristeas letter: "The country has good ports providing for its<br />
needs at Ashkelon, Jaffa, Gaza, and also Ptolemais which was founded by the king…" (Rappaport 1970: 2-3;<br />
Hadas 1973). Aristeas describes Akko as one of the four major port cities of the Land of Israel and as its most<br />
important northern port via which many traders arrived in the country (Kashtan 1988: 38-40). The 4th century<br />
BCE Athenian orator Demosthenes tells of an Athenian trader who lent his friend the sum of forty mina to<br />
cover the expense of traveling to “Akkah.” Thus we know that the port of Akko was very attractive to Greek<br />
merchants prior to its conquest by Alexander of Macedon (Demosthenes: Against Klypus, Chapter 52, 20, p. 87).<br />
For somewhat more direct evidence, we hear from the Greek orator Isaeus (Isaeus: IV: 7), who lived in the 4th<br />
century BCE; he mentions a colony of Athenian merchants that was located in the city.<br />
Tel Akko in the Hellenistic Period<br />
In 332 BCE, Akko fell to Alexander of Macedonia, apparently without a struggle. This elevated the city’s status<br />
to that of Tyre and Sidon, cities that previously had been more important than Akko. Following Alexander’s<br />
death, Akko played a key role in the struggle of the Ptolemaic and Seleucid kings. In 312 BCE, it was destroyed<br />
by Ptolemy I. In 301 BCE, he renovated the city when it finally passed into his hands, and the Ptolemaic dynasty<br />
proceeded to rule Akko for the next one hundred years. His successor, Ptolemy II Philadelphus, changed the<br />
city’s name to Ptolemais, by which it was known until the time of the Arab conquest. In 200 BCE, Akko fell to<br />
Antiochus III and became the seat of the Seleucid governor of the Land of Israel. Antiochus IV Epiphanes granted<br />
the city the status of a polis and changed its name temporarily to Antiochia. The Hasmonean kings unsuccessfully<br />
attempted first to control Akko and then to convert the population of the area to Judaism.<br />
During the Hellenistic period, Greek merchants frequented and lived in Ptolemais as indicated by a 2nd century<br />
BCE short funerary inscription near the tell. It reads:<br />
Hypergenes,<br />
son of Eurymedes, Cretan<br />
from Detonion, farewell!<br />
(Dothan 1976: 39-40).<br />
22* Michal Artzy and Ron Beeri
The trade passing through the harbor of Ptolemais is noted in the Xenon Papyrus, which mentions trade in slaves,<br />
grain, oil, dried figs, wine, cheese, fish, meat, pomegranate seeds, mushrooms, honey, and fruit; and the import<br />
of cheese, walnuts, wine, and honey from Greece (Tcherikover 1959: 60-72).<br />
The Hellenistic finds on Tel Akko reflect the city’s growth and prosperity during this period, which began at the<br />
same time as the population gradually began relocating to the lower city. The scope of the finds in all of the<br />
excavation areas indicates the almost complete exploitation of the area for dwellings and the high status of the<br />
population that resided there. In almost every excavation square, objects were found attesting to trade from<br />
overseas; foremost among these objects are hundreds of imported jar handles, more than at any other site in the<br />
country, large quantities of potsherds, coins, jewelry, and figurines. From the very disturbed architectural remains,<br />
which show signs of robbery, on the tell, at least two main Hellenistic period levels were discerned. The later of<br />
these stages evinced urban planning, despite the absence of signs of destruction or the changing population that<br />
vacated areas for this construction.<br />
Tel Akko in the Roman Period<br />
Following Pompey’s conquest of the Land of Israel in 66 BCE, the country’s main maritime links were via the<br />
harbor of Akko. Despite Ptolemais’ being subject to Rome, no archaeological remains dating to the Roman period<br />
have so far been uncovered on the tell. However, on the western side, just below the tell, a Roman cemetery<br />
was recently excavated in a salvage project conducted by the Israel Department of Antiquities (see Tepper in this<br />
catalogue).<br />
Tel Akko in the Medieval Period<br />
No written sources on the role of Tel Akko during the medieval period have thus far been discovered. In Area<br />
H, located in the “krater” of the tell, foundations from the Crusader period were found. The building, which<br />
could be identified in early 20th century aerial photographs, seems to have been constructed around a large<br />
courtyard. In excavations in the vicinity of the architectural element, namely Areas H (on the rampart) and G,<br />
sherds belonging to the period 11th-13th centuries CE were noted, especially in shallow “pits” that contained<br />
mainly artifacts dating to the Persian and Hellenistic periods. The present working hypothesis is that these artifacts<br />
might be connected with the leveling of the area for construction and planting gardens.<br />
Michal Artzy and Ron Beeri 23*
Fig. 21: Three pit graves were found one above the other, beneath the floor of a house. The first grave interred a man in his mid-30s (Tomb 851).<br />
The body was laid on its right side in a fetal position. In the second grave, an infant was buried (Tomb 848) above the first skeleton. It seems that<br />
the skull and parts of the first skeleton were removed at the time of burial and interred, in secondary burial, in a bowl that was placed over the<br />
infant. A small stone anchor and two other stones were placed as a gravestone in place of the skull that had been removed.<br />
(Beeri 2008: 180-183, Fig. 6.58b)<br />
24* Ron Beeri
Funerary and Ancestor Worship<br />
Characteristics Identifiable at Tel Akko<br />
Ron Beeri University of Haifa<br />
The emigration of a population from the coast of Lebanon and Syria at the beginning of the second millennium<br />
BCE has led to a new understanding of the funerary practices that had been prevalent in the southern Levant<br />
at the end of the third millennium BCE. One of the most important changes that the new population brought<br />
with it was to move the location of the burial site from outside the settlement as had been practiced in Canaan<br />
in previous periods to inside the settlement. 1 This phenomenon had been identified on the Plain of Akko, where<br />
52 of the 59 burials that have been dated to the first half of the second millennium BCE were located inside the<br />
tells. Furthermore, the shape of the tombs was also modified. In the preceding Middle Bronze I period, it was<br />
customary to inter the deceased in shaft tombs or in burial caves outside the settlement, compared to a greater<br />
variety of burial types used during the Middle Bronze II period (first half of the second millennium BCE; Beeri<br />
2003). In the latter period, four main types of burial, described below, were prevalent on the Plain of Akko in<br />
general and at Tel Akko in particular.<br />
Pit Graves (Fig. 21) 2<br />
Plain graves were dug into the ramparts, below the floors of the houses, and in courtyards. They were intended<br />
for interring families or individuals, whether children or adults, male or female. A considerable number of the<br />
graves were marked with a large tombstone or cluster of small stones placed on top of or around the grave.<br />
Pit graves were typically used for one-time burials.<br />
The number of funerary offerings associated with this<br />
type was small, averaging two to three objects per<br />
individual. Although there was a clear preference for<br />
small pottery vessels, the offerings usually included<br />
small juglets for liquids and, to a lesser extent, dipper<br />
juglets, open serving bowls, carinated bowls, a few<br />
pieces of jewelry, and occasionally scarabs (Fig. 22).<br />
Cist Tombs<br />
Cist tombs with a rectangular or slightly rounded<br />
shape were excavated. They were lined with stones<br />
and covered with a gabled roof of stone slabs. These<br />
tombs, apparently intended for a one-time, primary<br />
burial of two or more individuals, were sealed after<br />
the interment; thus, they do not have an entrance. The<br />
number of funerary offerings in cist tombs was greater<br />
than that in pit graves, and the obvious predilection<br />
was for small vessels and serving vessels.<br />
Fig. 22: Scarab and scaraboid from Pit Grave 848, Phase 1<br />
(ascribed to LB1). (Beeri 2008: 326, Figs. 8.1, 8.10)<br />
Ron Beeri 25*
Jar Burials (Fig. 23)<br />
The jar burials from the Middle Bronze II constitute one<br />
of the more typical groups that have been documented<br />
in the Levant in general and in Canaan in particular. All<br />
of the jar burials found on the Plain of Akko in general<br />
and at Tel Akko in particular consisted of individual<br />
burials of infants two years of age or younger who<br />
had been interred inside the ramparts encircling the<br />
tell or below the floors of a house. The burial jars<br />
selected for this purpose were usually without handles,<br />
decorations, or paint. It seems that most of them had<br />
Fig. 23: Jar Burial L1045. (Based on Dothan 1990: Fig. 1;<br />
Beeri 2003: Fig. 16; Beeri 2008: Fig. 6.9)<br />
been used for storage and were adapted for burial as<br />
a secondary use (Beeri 2003: 98). The neck on most of<br />
the jars was intentionally broken to serve as the burial opening. A few offerings were also inserted in a few of<br />
the burial jars, such as a spoon, a fishing weight, cylinder seals, or beads. The burial jars were usually placed at a<br />
symbolic distance from the rest of the interred, sometimes separated from the others by a wall or circle of stones.<br />
Most of the infants were found buried on their side, in a fetal position (Beeri 2003: 99). In most instances, the<br />
head was placed next to the jar opening and the feet were resting next to its base. It is interesting to note that<br />
children over the age of two were buried alongside the jar, not inside it.<br />
Similar interment of infants in jars (in which the infant’s head almost always faced the direction of the storage<br />
container’s opening) was prevalent in Syria and Mesopotamia in the third millennium BCE (Ilan 1991: 191-193;<br />
1996: 151-250; Beeri 2003: 99; Beeri 2008: 374). Echoes of this pattern are evidenced in the jar burial uncovered<br />
at Tel Kabri and dated to the Early Bronze 1A.<br />
We can presume that in the second millennium BCE, the practice of burying in jars spread from Syria to the coast<br />
of Lebanon, and from there to the southern Levant (Beeri 2003: 101; see references cited there).<br />
Burial Chambers (Figs. 24, 25)<br />
Burial chambers are family burial cellars built beneath the ramparts or the floors of a house. Their uniqueness lies<br />
in the fact that these chambers were actually built, a rare funerary-practice phenomenon throughout the Bronze<br />
Age. Burial chambers were used during most of the Middle Bronze II and later at Tel Akko (Artzy 2006a: 119-120;<br />
Beeri 2008: 165-167, 376, 378).<br />
The tombs are built like a rectangular building, with a vertical or an inclined access shaft. The burial chamber<br />
had straight walls covered with stone slabs or a “pseudo-vault.” Some of the tombs were used for a one-time<br />
interment of one family, and therefore the burial in them was primary. Others were used for longer periods<br />
of time, and therefore the burials in most of those were secondary; these tombs also contained more objects,<br />
including items of prestige, such as scarabs and coroids (Figs. 22, 26). With each new interment, the remains of<br />
the previous burials were piled up near the walls. <strong>Acco</strong>rding to Ilan (1991: 193; 1996: 250), the burial chamber<br />
is not Canaanite in origin; its beginnings should be sought in Mesopotamia in the Early Dynastic period. It seems<br />
that the use of burial chambers spread from Mesopotamia to Syria during the Early Dynastic III and reached the<br />
Syrian-Lebanese coast, Canaan, and Egypt in the first half of the second millennium BCE (Ilan 1991: 193; Ilan<br />
1996: 250; Beeri 2008: 376, and see references cited there).<br />
26* Ron Beeri
Fig. 24: Burial Chamber L691. (Beeri 2008: Fig. 6.37)<br />
Fig. 25: Detail of Burial Chamber L691 and funerary gifts.<br />
Functions of the Burial Shaft<br />
The entrance shaft to a burial chamber, which was used in the final phase of the funeral journey, made it possible<br />
to conduct more than one burial in a tomb without having to remove the roof. The shafts functioned as more<br />
than just a means of disposing of the body. The funeral journey ended in the shaft, and therefore the remains<br />
of religious ceremonies can be identified in it, such as many clay lamps discarded in the shaft of Tomb 498 at Tel<br />
Kabri and a thick burned layer found in the shaft of Tomb 691 at Tel Akko.<br />
The shaft served symbolically as an intermediate phase between life and death; a kind of pipeline between<br />
the tangible entity of the community and the mystery of the “depths of Sheol” (Deut. 32:22). 3 The transition<br />
from the world of the living to the world of the dead was “carried out” in the sources by an act of descending<br />
(Gen. 37:35). 4 Another term for the world of the dead that resembles the burial shaft is “the depths of the pit”<br />
(Lamentations 3:55); indeed, “pit” 5 is analogous to the Akkadian bûru.<br />
A thick layer of ash that was found on the floor of the shaft of Burial Chamber 691 at Tel Akko and the broken<br />
clay lamps at the entrance to Tomb 498 at Tel Kabri are indicative of religious ceremonies conducted for the dead<br />
at the time of the funeral and possibly also afterwards. At Tell el-Dab'a, Bietak discerned that fires in honor of<br />
the dead had apparently been set in the built tombs in the Temple of the Dead of Stratum E; this is evidenced by<br />
layers of ash in the fill inside the tomb (Ziffer 1990: 115, based on Bietak 1968: 98).<br />
In addition to the above-mentioned functions, it seems that burial shafts were used as public storage for the<br />
burial chambers because many of them contained large store jars that had been placed there in clusters, and not<br />
next to one of the dead inside the tomb (Beeri 2008: 377) (Fig. 27). The storage containers and their contents<br />
were probably renewed from time to time after the burial.<br />
Ron Beeri 27*
Fig. 26: Coroid from the burial shaft of Tomb 691.<br />
(Drawing and photo: S. Zagorski, courtesy of M. Artzy, Head, Hatter Laboratory, Recanati Institute of Maritime Studies)<br />
In Mesopotamia, for example, the family attended to the sustenance and worship of their dead ancestors. There<br />
are many Akkadian texts that describe the bitter fate of the dead person whom no one provides with water or<br />
nourishment (Loewenstamm 1962: 759). In Egypt, the dead were provided with food on a permanent, daily<br />
basis; in Egyptian funerary texts, known as Pyramid Texts, there are appeals pleading that the dead arise and eat<br />
the food that the mourner has brought.<br />
Beliefs Associated with Burial<br />
Burial constituted a religious-social expression that was permanent in society and not easily changed. Essentially<br />
it manifested the belief that there is another life that follows death, and therefore the tomb is used, if only for<br />
a brief period, as a home where the deceased will be “reborn.” The location of the tomb, its structure, and its<br />
offerings are, therefore, indicative not just of the material culture but also of a significant share of the religious<br />
beliefs and social conventions that were common to all members of this society. Thus it may be possible from an<br />
archaeological standpoint to follow the origins of the burial and the social structure, religious beliefs, family ties,<br />
and social stratification of all of its members.<br />
In ancient societies, death and “rebirth” were considered part of the fertility circle (Ilan 1995: 319). This is<br />
primarily manifested in the infant jar burials (see below). <strong>Acco</strong>rding to Ugaritic mythology, Ba’al was considered<br />
the source of life and the fertility of plants, people, and the gods. When Ba’al was killed by the god Mot and<br />
descended to Sheol, the earth ceased to produce its crops for half a year, an extended hot, arid summer. Every<br />
year, Anat, the goddess of fertility and war, arrived in order to fight with Mot and return her brother Ba’al to the<br />
good, life-giving winter. When Ba’al was brought back to life, everything in the country returned to being olive<br />
trees and honey (Cassuto 1965: 46-51). In Egypt, the god Osiris fulfilled a similar function to that of Ba’al, and<br />
Seth to that of Mot (see, e.g., Raven 1982: 11; Hornung 1995: 1718, Fig. 11; Schoske 1992: Fig. 47; Ziffer 2006:<br />
423, Figs. 8-9).<br />
28* Ron Beeri
Analysis of the Beliefs behind<br />
the Burials at Akko<br />
In the burials at Tel Akko, the people<br />
were interred inside the ramparts<br />
and beneath the habitation level of<br />
residential buildings, or near them.<br />
The dead were of different ages and<br />
sex, a fact that allows us to assume<br />
that at least some of these tombs<br />
were family tombs. The common<br />
denominator of all these burials is<br />
that they were located within the<br />
precincts of the settlement, close to<br />
the community. The family graves and<br />
single graves that were found below<br />
buildings suggest the existence of<br />
close family ties among a significant<br />
number of the dead and a close<br />
connection between the living and<br />
the person buried.<br />
We can assume that the meals in<br />
the house were eaten close to the<br />
dead and that the dead probably<br />
“participated” in them by means Fig. 27: The burial shaft of Tomb 691. (Beeri 2008: Fig. 6.39)<br />
of libations conducted by the living<br />
(Ziffer 1990: 114). The relatively large<br />
number of tablewares found in the tombs likely reflects the importance of meals there. The goblets, dipper<br />
juglets, and jugs (for libation) found in the tombs most likely show the importance of the element of drinking<br />
in the meals that “the dead ate in the tombs.” A study of Ugaritic documents reveals that the souls of the dead<br />
that resided in Sheol were actually in bet haftat and spent their days feasting and drinking (Cassuto 1965: 22).<br />
In the same way, one can explain the offerings of sheep/goat, cattle, fallow deer, and fish found alongside the<br />
drinking vessels in the tombs of Tel Akko and Tel Kabri (some of the food was still in the bowls) (Lernau 2002:<br />
422; Kolska-Horwitz 2002: 397). The numerous juglets near the heads of the deceased were probably used to<br />
hold precious liquids, such as perfumes, oils, medicines, and cosmetics. The juglets were often placed near the<br />
faces of the dead, as can be seen in Tomb 848 from Tel Akko (Fig. 21). Remembering the dead and taking care<br />
to feed them are mentioned in the Panmo, King of Yadi, inscription. The king commanded his son to mention his<br />
name when the latter made a sacrifice to the god Haddad and to say, “Eat the soul of Panmo with Hadad and<br />
drink the soul of Panmo with Haddad” (Loewenstamm 1962: 759). The offerings that were placed next to the<br />
dead are known from the Mari letters as Kipsu, which were meant to silence the repha’im (ghosts or spirits) 6 or<br />
to serve them as a source of sustenance (Bayliss 1973; Skiast 1980: 123-128; Dalley 1984: 124).<br />
Ron Beeri 29*
Fig. 28: Jar Burial L868. (Beeri 2008: Fig. 6.11) (Drawing: S. Haad)<br />
The repha’im required food and drink, and there are numerous Akkadian texts that describe the fate of the<br />
man who was not served food after his death. In the Gilgamesh Epic, Enkidu, who went down to Sheol, says<br />
that the dead man who is not taken care of is forced to eat “leftovers from the pot, crumbs of bread, garbage<br />
of the streets – these are his foods” (Loewenstamm 1962: 759, based on the Gilgamesh Epic, Tablet 12, Lines<br />
151, 154).<br />
Analysis of the Beliefs behind the Jar Burials<br />
In the jar burials, we have the clearest, most unequivocal evidence of a group affiliation based on age group and<br />
social status. This type of burial was meant for premature babies and infants under the age of two, and we are<br />
specifically dealing with an age cross-section and a social identity common to extensive geographical regions<br />
during the Middle Bronze II (Ilan 1991: 202, 204). Similar burials of adults are uncommon in the Levant in the first<br />
half of the second millennium BCE. The characteristics of the jar burial reflect a belief in the concept of “rebirth”<br />
following death. The burial of infants in jars most likely symbolizes the connection among death, the fertility of a<br />
woman’s womb, and the fertility of birth from inside the womb (Fig. 28; see Ilan 1991: 206; Ilan 1996: 255-258;<br />
Beeri 2008: 374, 382-384, for a detailed description) (Figs 23, 28).<br />
30* Ron Beeri
Social Stratification<br />
No evidence whatsoever of social stratification was found in the cemeteries of Tel Akko. This determination relies<br />
on the funerary offerings in the tombs, the location of the tombs in the sites, the plan of the tombs, the kind<br />
of burial (primary or secondary), the position of the dead, and their age and sex. It is apparent that the various<br />
types of burials, save the jar burials, and the two kinds of burials (primary or secondary) that were examined were<br />
common, regardless of the age and sex of the deceased; there was also a more or less set number of funerary<br />
objects. It therefore seems that the main factors that determined the richness of the tomb are its continued use<br />
and the number of dead interred in it at a given time.<br />
Notes<br />
1 At Megiddo, for example, the eastern cemetery from the Early Bronze Age and Middle Bronze Age I was abandoned, and burials were<br />
conducted in the heart of the city, below the houses (Kempinski 1993: 200).<br />
2 All drawings are by Svetlana Zagorski and Sapir Haad, courtesy of Michal Artzy, Head of Hatter Laboratory of the Recanati Institute of Maritime<br />
Studies.<br />
3 The world of the afterlife has many names, the most well known being the southwestern Semitic term Sheol. In Akkadian, the world of the<br />
dead is called Sha’âru, which is somewhat similar to Sheol.<br />
4 An expression meaning ’going down to death’ appears in many other biblical writings and in the Ugarit texts (Proverbs 5:5; Psalms 22:30; the<br />
Ugaritic Acts of the Gods, Pl. 67=31, Lines 14-17, based on the translation by S. Rin and S. Rin, 1996).<br />
5 Proverbs 28:17; Isaiah 14:15; Isaiah 38:18; Lamentations 3:55.<br />
6 Repha’im are mentioned in the Bible, in Ugaritic letters, and in Phoenician tomb inscriptions (on the coffins of Tabnit and Eshmunazar, who<br />
were kings of the Sidonites). The word appears in a number of contexts, one of which is a name for the spirits of the dead that reside in Sheol<br />
(see S. Rin and S. Rin 1996: 841-844; Loewenstamm 1962, 404-407).<br />
Ron Beeri 31*
Fig. 29: Excavation of the cemetery, looking west. (Photo: T. Sagiv, IAA)<br />
32* Yotam Tepper
A Pagan Cemetery from the Roman Period<br />
at the Foot of Tel Akko:<br />
Evidence of the Burial of Roman Soldiers<br />
and Citizens of Colonia Ptolemais<br />
Yotam Tepper Israel Antiquities Authority 1<br />
Introduction<br />
A large cemetery from the Roman period was exposed in archaeological excavations the Israel Antiquities<br />
Authority conducted at the foot of Tel Akko. The cemetery was used for burial from the second half of the<br />
1st century CE until late 3rd century/beginning of the 4th century CE. In the article we will review briefly the<br />
archaeological finds from the tombs, the funerary offerings that were also placed above the graves and in the<br />
burial mounds, as well as the sex and age of the deceased. All of these indicate that the cemetery served a pagan<br />
population that included soldiers in the Roman army and citizens of Colonia Ptolemais.<br />
Historical Background<br />
The polis of Akko, established as Ptolemais by Ptolemy II Philadelphus, became an important port and commercial<br />
city in the Hellenistic period. During the Roman period, Claudius (41-54 CE) founded a new Roman colony<br />
at Ptolemais (51/2-54 CE), which he named Colonia<br />
Claudia Felix Ptolemais Garmanica Stabilis, and veterans<br />
discharged from four Roman legions garrisoned in<br />
Syria (Isaac 1992) settled there. 2 In 56 CE, the imperial<br />
road was paved from Antioch to Colonia Ptolemais<br />
(Goodchild 1949); a dedicatory inscription honoring<br />
Nero (54-68 CE) found at the side of the Roman road<br />
in Nahariya contains proof of a veterans’ settlement<br />
in the vicinity of the colony (Avi-Yonah 1946; Millar<br />
1990). 3 Gaius (66 CE) marched with his army along the<br />
road from Antioch to Akko, followed by Vespasian (67<br />
CE), who established his military headquarters in the<br />
city and set out from there in his campaign to conquer<br />
the Galilee and put down the rebellion. There is very<br />
little evidence about the colony’s population (Millar<br />
1990). The sole evidence we have of a noted personage<br />
residing there during the Roman period is the name<br />
of one Flavius Boethus, governor of Palestine from<br />
162-166 CE; he was a scholar and philosopher who<br />
was also interested in medicine (Isaac 1992). During<br />
Fig. 30: Schematic map of Akko and the cemeteries from the Roman<br />
the Mishnah and Talmud Period, the port of Akko was period sign on Tzaferis map. (Tzaferis 1985: 275)<br />
Yotam Tepper 33*
the Galilee’s principal outlet to the sea; although sages<br />
passed through the city, it was considered outside the<br />
bounds of the Land of Israel (Tsafrir, Di Segni, and<br />
Green 1994).<br />
B<br />
A<br />
Fig. 31: A. An in situ cremation burial. B. Cremated human bones<br />
found in the cooking pot urn. (Photo: Y. Tepper, IAA)<br />
Fig. 32: A coin next to the deceased’s skull, Roman period.<br />
(Photo: Y. Tepper, IAA)<br />
Remains of Akko from the Roman Period<br />
There are not many archaeological remains from<br />
the Roman period within the area of modern Akko.<br />
In Dothan’s excavations outside the Crusader city<br />
walls, building remains that date to the Early Roman<br />
period were uncovered in Areas E and D, west of<br />
the tell (Dothan 1993). Other architectural remains<br />
from the Roman period were exposed inside the city,<br />
near the courthouse and south of it (Goldman 1993,<br />
Applebaum 1986, Avshalom-Gorni 1997, Thatcher<br />
2000). Underwater archaeological remains reveal<br />
a city involved in commerce; the artifacts that were<br />
recovered in those excavations include, among other<br />
things, imported products from the coastal cities of<br />
Italy, Syria, and North Africa (Galili and Rosen 2008).<br />
But it seems that the most outstanding finds from the<br />
Roman period in Akko are two extensive cemeteries,<br />
one of which is located north of the city (referred<br />
to below as the northern cemetery; Fortuna 1966,<br />
Tzaferis 1986) and the other, in the area east of the<br />
modern city near the tell (the eastern cemetery; Amiran<br />
1951, Goldman 1993, Mokary 1995, Finkielsztejn 2007,<br />
Abu ‘Uqsa 2009). Within this context, we should note<br />
Memnon’s monument, which Josephus mentioned in<br />
The Jewish Wars (Shahar 2005). 4 One can assume that<br />
because of the monument’s proximity to the Belus<br />
River (Nahal Na’aman), there was a burial and ritual<br />
site there and that the Roman cemetery developed<br />
around it, east of the city (Fig. 30). 5<br />
The Eastern Cemetery – Results of the<br />
Archaeological Excavation (Fig. 29)<br />
An extensive cemetery was revealed in the excavations. 6<br />
Tombs were dug into layers of sandy ground, and a<br />
few were excavated even deeper, to the layer of kurkar<br />
and natural sand. 7 Two main burial methods were<br />
found: cremation after the corpse was burned; and<br />
inhumations, involving anatomically articulated supine<br />
burials.<br />
34* Yotam Tepper
Cremation: The excavation exposed a number<br />
of burned areas containing charred wood, ash<br />
concentrations, as well as urns that held burned<br />
human remains (Fig. 31). Cremation was the most<br />
common funerary practice among certain cultures,<br />
primarily in the western provinces during the<br />
Hellenistic and Roman periods (Audin 1960; Toynbee<br />
1971; Irion 1968). In the Land of Israel, this custom<br />
was documented in isolated instances of Phoenician<br />
archaeological remains dating to the Hellenistic period<br />
(Tepper in press) and at a number of sites that were<br />
Fig. 33: Several of the dead in the mass grave. (Photo: Y. Tepper, IAA)<br />
dated to the Roman period and associated with the<br />
presence of a pagan population and/or Roman army units (Tepper 2007). Among the other finds that were also<br />
uncovered in the excavation were clusters of pottery and glass vessels without human bones and both with and<br />
without ash marks. The funerary offerings without the remains of ashes and/or bones may indicate that their<br />
contents were completely consumed when burned or that they gradually disintegrated over the course of the<br />
years (Ubelaker and Rife 2007). 8<br />
Inhumation: Most of the dead were interred by this method and of the more than 350 tombs documented,<br />
165 of them were identified by age and sex in a complete or partial form. The inhumation was conducted by a<br />
variety of methods, including in the ground with or without a stone covering, in ceramic coffins with or without<br />
a tile covering, and in ashlar-built tombs with a slab covering; there was a single case of a jar burial. A number of<br />
mausoleums that had been dug into the ground were also found, and pieces of colored plaster and decorations<br />
in a variety of colors were discovered in the soil fill in their interior. Many of the tombs were covered with stone<br />
heaps, in which numerous artifacts were found that helped provide a date for the tomb and the funerary rites<br />
practiced at the site.<br />
Dating the Burials in the Cemetery<br />
As previously mentioned, the large cemetery dates to the Roman period. The tombs were excavated into layers of<br />
soil that yielded ceramic artifacts dating to the Persian, Hellenistic, and Roman periods. An intact discus lamp that<br />
dates to the 1st-2nd centuries CE was found in a burial structure containing two coffins that were only partially<br />
excavated. A mounted horseman is depicted on the discus. The glass vessels that were found in the excavation,<br />
including the whole vessels inside the tombs and next to the dead, date to the 1st-3rd centuries CE.<br />
The numismatic finds at the site include an assemblage of more than 100 coins that range in date from the 3rd<br />
century BCE until the 4th century CE. Some 90 coins were identified (of which more than a third are from a<br />
single hoard). More than two-thirds of these coins date to the 1st-4th centuries CE, the rest to the Hellenistic and<br />
Byzantine periods and a few to the Early Islamic and Mamluk periods. In at least one instance, a coin was found<br />
resting alongside a skull, perhaps hinting at the well-known custom practiced by pagan populations of inserting<br />
a single coin into the mouth of the deceased (Charon’s Obol) as payment to Charon, the ferryman who sailed<br />
the dead into Hades (Fig. 32; Rahmani 1993; Syon 2006).<br />
Mass Grave and a Hoard of Silver Coins from the Time of Hadrian<br />
Part of a mass grave was excavated in an area in the southwestern section of the cemetery delineated to the west<br />
and north by built walls. Sixteen individuals were identified in the excavation, all of whom were males between<br />
Yotam Tepper 35*
B<br />
A<br />
Fig. 34: A. Deceased No. 641 at the time the hoard was found. B. Part of the hoard at the time it was removed from the ground.<br />
(Photo: Y. Tepper, IAA)<br />
20 and 30 years of age. The dead were stacked atop one another and alongside each other so that the upper<br />
body was placed over and perpendicular to the body below it in a manner resembling the letter X (Fig. 33).<br />
Funerary offerings (see below) that are characteristic of the cemetery were found next to the dead, and a hoard<br />
of silver coins lay on top of the uppermost individual in the pile (Fig. 34). The hoard included 44 silver provincial<br />
tetradrachmae that were minted over a period of time, from the time of Nero (60/1 CE), during the reigns of<br />
the emperors Vespasian, Nerva, and Trajan, to the time of Hadrian (a single coin). 9 The date of the latest coin<br />
in the hoard also serves to determine the earliest date of burial of all the coins. In our case, it is also the date of<br />
the inhumations; that is, a terminus post quem of 118 CE. The 44 tetradrachmae in the hoard were equivalent<br />
to about 176 dinars, which constituted several months’ salary for a Roman soldier at that time (Watson 1969).<br />
It is unreasonable to assume that such a large sum of money was intentionally left in a wallet in the clothes of<br />
the deceased. On the other hand, the hoard was found right next to the body, which was placed at the top of a<br />
heap of other dead people, and perhaps some importance should be ascribed to the fact whether the hoard had<br />
been buried accidently or intentionally. In any event, it seems that the dead in the mass grave had all been killed<br />
and buried in the same circumstances of a single specific tragic event, such as an epidemic or, based on the sex<br />
and ages of the bodies, more likely some sort of armed conflict. On the basis of numismatic finds, it seems that<br />
the time of the interment can be dated to the beginning of Hadrian’s rule, and not before 118 CE. As we know,<br />
Jewish uprisings broke out in Cyrenaica, Egypt, and Cyprus, in what is referred to as the Diaspora Revolt or Kitos<br />
War, during the last two years of Trajan’s rule. The sources allude to unrest among the Jews of the Land of Israel at<br />
the beginning of Hadrian’s rule, which was probably also a reason that another legion was brought into Judaea,<br />
which turned into a consular province (Smallwood 1978; Smallwood 1981; Oppenheimer 1977). It is possible<br />
that the burial of soldiers in one grave, which appears to have been hasty, as well as communal, is archaeological<br />
evidence of one of the insurgencies that preceded the Bar Kokhba Revolt.<br />
36* Yotam Tepper
Fig. 35: Funerary offerings, such as the bones of animals, were<br />
apparently placed alongside a tomb. (Photo: Y. Tepper, IAA)<br />
A<br />
Fig. 36: A. A clay coffin and an offering bowl placed above it.<br />
B. Rabbit (?) bones in the bowl. (Photo: Y. Tepper, IAA)<br />
B<br />
Funerary Rites and the Ethnic Identity<br />
of the Dead<br />
Most of the dead were found covered with heaps<br />
of stones, and evidence was found between the<br />
stones and on top of the heaps of a unique ritual<br />
conducted at the cemetery. A number of the stone<br />
items are fashioned in the shape of a pedestal for a<br />
statue. Others are round and square stone altars, the<br />
upper part of some being concave and they possibly<br />
functioned as sacrificial or libation installations. The<br />
remains of offerings or the communal funerary meals<br />
that were held at the grave site were found on top of<br />
the stone heaps and alongside the graves (Fig. 35). An<br />
examination of the animal bones has shown that they<br />
belong to pigs, sheep, goats, and horses. Some exhibit<br />
signs of cutting, evidence that the animals had been<br />
slaughtered and prepared especially for the purpose<br />
of the cemetery ritual. In one instance, a ceramic<br />
bowl was found placed upside down above a clay<br />
coffin, and in it were the remains of a small mammal,<br />
probably a rabbit (Fig. 36). The fact that there are<br />
funerary offerings of non-kosher animals (e.g., rabbit<br />
and pig) suggests that the dead did not observe Jewish<br />
dietary laws (see the review and other references cited<br />
in Horwitz 1999).<br />
During the excavation of the cemetery, many clay<br />
juglets were found inside and alongside the tombs<br />
and on top of the stone heaps (Fig. 37). The juglets are<br />
round and somewhat piriform and have a tall neck. In<br />
most cases, the juglets were broken in the vicinity of<br />
the shoulder so that the neck was separated from the<br />
body. In some instances, it was possible to connect the<br />
neck of a juglet found on one side of the tomb with<br />
the body of the juglet discovered on the other side. It<br />
seems that the juglets were intentionally broken during<br />
the burial ceremony, and this is additional evidence of<br />
the funerary rites prevalent among the city’s population<br />
at that time. Burial with broken vessels was also<br />
widespread in other cemeteries of the Roman period,<br />
and it has been suggested that this phenomenon be<br />
viewed as a symbol of the end and the destruction of<br />
life itself (Tuffreau-Libre 2001: 184-187).<br />
Yotam Tepper 37*
B<br />
Fig. 37: A. A tomb and fragments of a burial juglet next to it. B. Clay<br />
juglet at the time it was removed from the ground.<br />
(Photo: Y. Tepper, IAA)<br />
A<br />
A fragment of a marble plaque inscribed with three<br />
lines of an epitaph was found next to an excavated<br />
built and plastered tomb located not far from the mass<br />
grave and the coin hoard (Fig. 38). The inscription<br />
marked the tomb of a soldier or veteran of the VII<br />
Legion Claudia. This legion had been garrisoned<br />
in Moesia from the middle of the 1st century CE.<br />
Because of epigraphic and historic considerations, we<br />
can assume that the soldier had been buried about<br />
the time of Trajan’s reign. In any event, the soldier’s<br />
name was Olpius Martidus (or Martinus), and even<br />
though much information about him was lost when<br />
the tombstone was destroyed, there is no doubt that<br />
the interred individual had served as a Roman soldier<br />
and been buried in the cemetery of Colonia Ptolemais<br />
(Eck and Tepper 2005).<br />
Gender Identify of Bodies in the Cemetery<br />
The sex and age of the dead in the entire cemetery<br />
reflect the characteristics of the population buried<br />
there. A comparison between Akko’s northern<br />
cemetery (Hellenistic-Roman-Byzantine) and the<br />
city’s eastern cemetery (Roman) shows a different<br />
distribution of sexes and ages of the dead (Nagar and<br />
Tepper 2007). In the eastern cemetery, the number of<br />
young men (90% of all dead identified), 20-30 years<br />
of age, is significantly greater than the percentage in<br />
the city’s northern cemetery. Moreover, few women and children were found in the eastern cemetery than in<br />
the northern cemetery, where the breakdown is normal and characteristic of a civilian population. It should be<br />
mentioned that the burials of children and women in the eastern cemetery occurred after the 3rd century CE and<br />
date to the second and later phase of the burials at the site. Their burials took place on top of the grave coverings<br />
and the coffins that contained the young males who had been buried earlier, and inside coffins and tombs after<br />
the bones of the dead in the earlier phase had been moved aside.<br />
Fig. 38: Epitaph for Olipius, inscribed on a marble plaque.<br />
(Photo: H. Smithline, IAA)<br />
Conclusion<br />
Many archaeological finds were discovered in the cemetery excavated at the foot of Tel Akko, and only some<br />
of them have been discussed in this short review. When the research and analysis of the excavation finds are<br />
completed, it will be possible to draw more conclusions about the identity and profession of the dead interred<br />
there. However, at this point we can summarize and state that the burial methods, particularly cremation, the<br />
funerary offerings, and especially the animal offerings, attest to the burial of a foreign, pagan population. To all<br />
of this evidence, we must add the altars and the clay juglets that apparently were intentionally broken. What we<br />
have here, it seems, is a cultic reality – one that is becoming increasingly clear – of a unique form of burial that is<br />
unknown in the Land of Israel and in the variety of burials common among the Jewish population.<br />
38* Yotam Tepper
Other artifacts, consisting of arrowheads and weapons from the Roman period, were found in the excavation,<br />
and their analysis has not yet been completed. These join the communal burial of 16 males, a hoard of silver<br />
coins from the time of Hadrian found next to them, and a fragment of a Latin epitaph for a soldier from the VII<br />
Claudia Legion. In light of all of the above, it seems that soldiers of the Roman army were buried in the cemetery.<br />
An analysis of the sex and age of the dead at the site has also reinforced this conclusion. In our opinion, the<br />
later internments of women and children at the site also indicate the burial of a foreign pagan population. In<br />
any event, the dating of the finds in the cemetery connects this burial site with the time of Colonia Ptolemais<br />
and constitutes a significant contribution to our knowledge and understanding of its population. The completion<br />
of the distribution analysis of the tombs from the Roman period around the city also constitutes an important<br />
contribution to solving the puzzle of the precise location and extent of the colony, which holds a place of honor<br />
in Akko’s glorious past.<br />
Notes<br />
1 The archaeological excavation (Permit No. A-4063/2004) on Remez Street in Akko was undertaken on behalf of the Israel Antiquities Authority<br />
and underwritten by the Yafe Nof Company for the purpose of developing infrastructures at the eastern entrance to Akko. The excavation was<br />
directed by Y. Tepper and H. Abu ‘Uqsa, with assistance from E. ‘Awawdy, A. Thatcher, N. Getzov, E. Stern, M. Hartal, L. Porat, F. Abu Zeidan,<br />
R. Abu Raya, A. Shapiro, H. Tahan, E. Bron, O. Zingboym (filed directors), and laborers of the Israel Antiquities Authority from Akko, Nazareth,<br />
and Kafr Manda. Additional assistance was provided by H. Smithline and T. Sagiv (photography), A. Hajian (drafting), D. Syon (numismatics),<br />
Y. Gorin-Rosen (glass), G. Finkielsztejn (amphorae), L. Di Segni and W. Eck (epigraphy), G. Bar Oz and N. Raban-Gerstel (archaeozoology),<br />
G. Stiebel (weapons), M. Pounting (metallurgy), M. Inbar (geomorphology), D. Bar-Yosef (mollusks), and Y. Shahar (historical sources). The<br />
treatment of the finds and cleaning of metallic artifacts were done in the laboratories of the Israel Antiquities Authority. The analysis and study<br />
of the finds are in their preliminary stages, and upon completion the final excavation report will be published on behalf of the Israel Antiquities<br />
Authority. For a preliminary publication, see also Tepper and Nagar 2009.<br />
2 Meshorer (1985: 12.2) suggested that these were the III, VI, X, and XII Legions. Indeed, four legions do appear on the standards on the city’s<br />
“founder coin,” from the year 66 CE but there is no agreement with regard to the small numbers that appear on them. See, also, Millar 1990:<br />
note 79, 25. I wish to thank Donald Z. Ariel, Alla Stein, and Danny Syon for this information (see D. Syon in this catalogue).<br />
3 In this context, Applebaum (1989) draws the boundaries of the colony and estimates that about 1,640 veterans resided there.<br />
4 "The very small river Belus runs by it, at the distance of two furlongs; near which there is Memnon's monument, and hath near it a place no<br />
larger than a hundred cubits, which deserves admiration; for the place is round and hollow, and affords such sand as glass is made of…"<br />
(The Jewish War II 10: 2). The idea of identifying the large cemetery that was found east of the modern city with the region where Memnon’s<br />
monument once stood and of associating the production of glass with the region was first proposed by Yael Gorin of the Israel Antiquities<br />
Authority and was examined by Yuval Shahar in a presentation at the Northern Studies Conference 2005, sponsored by the IAA and the<br />
University of Haifa.<br />
5 Raban (1986) has shown that the riverbed passed close to the tell during the Hellenistic and Roman periods<br />
6 The cemetery in the excavation extends between the Akko-Safed road in the north, the soccer field in the south, Tel Akko in the east, and<br />
Remez Street in the west. Tombs that date to later periods, probably to the Mamluk and Ottoman periods, were also uncovered in the western<br />
part of the excavation of the cemetery, near the modern Christian cemetery.<br />
7 The ancient channel of a small stream that once flowed to the east of Tel Akko was exposed in the middle of the excavation area. The dark<br />
layer of soil that was revealed above the level of the tombs probably represents a later deposit, possibly as a result of Nahal Na’aman flooding,<br />
which occurred after the 4th century CE.<br />
8 There is a possibility of an empty grave (cenotaph), which meant a symbolic interment of a dead person whose body was never found. The<br />
place is marked in the area and constitutes the ritual location for family members and friends of the deceased (Blamangin 1996).<br />
9 The hoard includes 5 coins from the time of Nero (Antioch), from the years 60/1-62/3 CE; 14 coins from the time of Vespasian (Antioch), from<br />
69-79 CE; 2 coins from the time of Nerva (Antioch), from 96-97 CE; 22 coins from the time of Trajan (Tyre), most of which are from 111-114<br />
CE; and a single coin from the time of Hadrian (Antioch), 118 CE. Two other tetradrachmae were found on the surface level that could not be<br />
connected with the same hoard; the first of these dates to the reign of Vespasian and the second, like that in the hoard, to the time of Hadrian<br />
and the year 118 CE.<br />
Yotam Tepper 39*
Fig. 39: The Hospitaller compound, ground level.<br />
40* Eliezer Stern and Hanaa Abu-Uqsa
New Archaeological Discoveries from<br />
Crusader Period Acre 1<br />
Eliezer Stern and Hanaa Abu-Uqsa Israel Antiquities Authority<br />
Five years after Jerusalem was conquered by Crusader forces, Baldwin I, King of Jerusalem, and the Genovese<br />
naval fleet laid siege to Acre. The city fell to the Crusaders in 1104 (Prawer 1971: 181).<br />
The Hospitallers in Acre: The earliest evidence that the Hospitallers received property in Acre during the first<br />
years of the Crusader occupation of the city is found in a document from 1110, when King Baldwin I allowed<br />
the order to keep buildings they had received as conscience contributions for the Church of the Holy Cross.<br />
Some of the order’s buildings were damaged in 1135, when the church compound was expanded to the north.<br />
This event resulted in the Hospitallers abandoning the compound and starting construction of a new center in<br />
the northwestern part of the city, next to the northern city wall. The first evidence we have of this center is a<br />
document in which Queen Melisande (1149) describes the construction of a church that is named for Saint John<br />
and located in the Hospitaller quarter south of the new center (Pringle 2009: 83).<br />
Following the Crusader defeat at the Battle of the Horns of Hattin (1187), Acre fell to the Muslims, and its<br />
Christian residents fled. They returned four years later (1191), when Richard Lion-Heart, the king of <strong>Eng</strong>land who<br />
led the Third Crusade, reconquered the city. The Hospitallers also returned to Acre; however, the buildings they<br />
had used in the early 12th century were now inadequate for their needs, because Jerusalem was no longer under<br />
Christian control. The Latin Kingdom’s new rulers, Guy de Lusignan (1192) and Henry of Champagne (1193),<br />
granted renewed concessions that allowed the Hospitallers to enlarge their center in Acre as far as the street next<br />
to the city’s northern walls and to transfer the head of the order and its headquarters to Acre (Riley-Smith 1999:<br />
43). The construction for this enterprise was started at the beginning of the 13th century and probably continued<br />
until the kingdom was vanquished by the Mamluks in 1291.<br />
Historical sources have described four main structures in the Hospitaller quarter in Acre: Brothers’ Residence,<br />
situated in the Montmusard Quarter, where the knights of the order dwelled; the Hospitaller center (its<br />
headquarters), where the head of the order and its senior members lived and also served as the order’s logistics<br />
and command center and was situated next to the city’s northern wall from the 12th century; Church of St. John,<br />
which was located south of the Hospitaller center; and the Hospitaller hospital, which was south of the church.<br />
History of the Research<br />
Prof. Joshua Prawer began the first excavations in the Hospitaller center, and these lasted from 1955-1964.<br />
Parts of what we now know as the Hospitaller center were exposed during these excavations: three halls in the<br />
northern part of the complex, a narrow corridor in the Pillared Hall, as well as the Hall of Columns (the dining<br />
room). After cracks were discovered at the site in 1990, new excavations were begun. The excavations and<br />
conservation work are now being implemented by the Israel Antiquities Authority, in cooperation with the Israeli<br />
government, the Ministry of Tourism, and the Old Acre Development Company.<br />
Eliezer Stern and Hanaa Abu-Uqsa 41*
Description of the Finds<br />
The building that was discovered in the excavations<br />
(and described below) represents the final phase of the<br />
Hospitaller center, as it was abandoned in 1291. It is<br />
important to remember that the construction of the<br />
center, which took place in several stages during the<br />
course of the period, continued throughout the 13th<br />
century.<br />
Fig. 40: The central courtyard. (Photo: D. Stern)<br />
The Central Courtyard (Fig. 39:9): This is an open<br />
central courtyard that extends over an area of 1,200<br />
sq. m. A 4.5 m deep well in the north of the courtyard<br />
probably supplied water for drinking and laundry<br />
(Fig. 40). Two shallow plastered pools, 40 cm deep,<br />
were built next to the well. The pools drained into<br />
the main sewerage conduit (see below) by means of<br />
underground channels. In its southern and western<br />
parts, the courtyard was enclosed by a series of arches<br />
that apparently supported a corridor leading to the<br />
rooms on the second story of the building. A staircase<br />
was located in the eastern part of the courtyard.<br />
The Northern Hall (Fig. 39:5a-f): This wing was<br />
constructed next to the city’s northern wall. The hall<br />
Fig. 41: The northern hall. (Photo: D. Stern)<br />
was built as a single space divided into six separate<br />
halls by walls that had arched openings incorporated<br />
in them. The halls were covered with a barrel vault measuring 10 m high (Fig. 41). The exterior walls of this<br />
compound were massively built from 3.5 m thick ashlars.<br />
Entire parts of the Northern Hall were found lying atop fill that was 3 m or more thick. Thus, it can be concluded<br />
that a collapse occurred long after the structure had been abandoned by the Hospitallers. After this fill was<br />
excavated, hundreds of pottery vessels were discovered arranged in situ in rows on the floor along the eastern<br />
wall of Hall 7. These pottery vessels are “sugar pots” – conical vessels with a drain hole in the bottom. Dozens of<br />
amphoriskoi, called “molasses jars,” were also found. The latter vessels were used at the end of the process of<br />
producing crystallized sugar, an industry that had become one of the most important enterprises in the country<br />
during the Crusader period.<br />
A stairway that led to the third story was discovered adjacent to the Southern Hall on the second story. This floor<br />
was not preserved; however, based on the extensive remains of the collapse, one can conclude that this story,<br />
built in the Gothic style, was quite splendid. Gothic style stone voussoirs were found that had been treated with<br />
plaster, on which frescos decorated in black, yellow, and red were preserved. The keystone, positioned in the spot<br />
where the ribs met in the Gothic ceiling vaults, was found alongside the voussoirs. This especially large stone was<br />
decorated with a round rosette and acanthus leaves.<br />
42* Eliezer Stern and Hanaa Abu-Uqsa
Fig. 42: The public latrine. (Photo: D. Stern)<br />
Fig. 43: The dining room. (Photo: D. Stern)<br />
The Northwestern Gate (Fig. 39:3): This gate served as a passage between the central courtyard and the<br />
northern moat. It runs through an arched gate that is defended by a massive tower built above it. The passage<br />
was covered with a barrel vault.<br />
The Northwestern Tower and the Latrine Complex (Fig. 39:2,2a): Located in the northwestern corner of the<br />
complex, this wing consists of three built stories and was used as a public latrine (Fig. 42). The first floor was an<br />
underground chamber in which the sewage was collected via dozens of gutters incorporated in the walls of the<br />
building. The gutters drained the public toilets, which were on the second and third stories. Incorporated in the<br />
outer envelope of the building’s walls are other gutters that conveyed rain water from the roofs of the complex<br />
down three stories to the collecting unit for the purpose of washing the chamber. This chamber was connected<br />
to a sewer main by means of five channels. Probes excavated throughout the city determined that this channel<br />
functioned as a central sewer line, measuring 1 m wide and more than 1.5 m high. It crossed the city from north<br />
to south and eventually discharged its contents into the sea in the vicinity of the port.<br />
The toilets on the second story were built above the sewage collecting chamber. This latrine measured 5x10 m,<br />
with a cross-vault ceiling hovering 10 m above. In this room, four rows of toilets, each with eight seats, were<br />
excavated. The toilets emptied directly into the collecting chamber.<br />
The Western Complex (Fig. 39:8): This complex has not yet been excavated. However, based on one of the walls<br />
of the rooms in this complex that was preserved on the second story, the structure originally stood at least two<br />
stories high. The architectural remains of this complex that were discovered in the ruins in the western part of the<br />
open courtyard indicate that the western complex had also been built in the Gothic style. Especially noteworthy<br />
are the basket capitals and capitals in the image of a person that are preserved on a wall of this building.<br />
Hall of Columns (the dining room) (Fig. 39:13): This hall is the most impressive room in the complex. It was<br />
exposed in excavations conducted by the National Parks Authority in the 1960s. The hall was built of eight<br />
pointed cross-vaults that rise to a height of 10 m and were supported by three round columns measuring 3 m.<br />
in diameter. The stone ribs, which support the ceiling of cross-vaults, rested on engaged capitals that were<br />
incorporated in the walls of the hall (Fig. 43). The capitals are adorned with wreaths of flowers, small baskets,<br />
or fleur de lys decorations. Carved rosettes were preserved where the ribs intersect on some of the cross-vaults.<br />
Eliezer Stern and Hanaa Abu-Uqsa 43*
This building probably served as the order’s dining<br />
room, and the hall to its east, which has not yet been<br />
excavated, as the kitchen. A system for collecting<br />
rainwater that supplied diners with drinking water<br />
was discovered below the dining room, part of which<br />
was built and part of which was hewn in the natural<br />
bedrock. The rainwater was conveyed from the roofs<br />
of the building to the reservoir via gutters that had<br />
been installed in the walls.<br />
The Pillared Hall (Fig. 39:10): This large hall,<br />
Fig. 44: The southern street. (Photo: Dafna Stern)<br />
extending across an area of 1,300 sq. m, consists of<br />
a series of 15 identical fields, covered by 8 m high<br />
cross-vaults. The vaults are supported on square pillars built of stone that are arranged in rows the length of<br />
the building. The center part of this vaulted ceiling, preserved in its original form, dates to the Crusader period.<br />
Sections of the ceiling in the southern and northern parts of the hall collapsed, probably during Ottoman building<br />
activities in the 18th century.<br />
Dungeon (Fig. 39:11): East of the Pillared Hall, this area was 2.5 m lower than the adjacent buildings, and its<br />
floor was hewn in the natural bedrock. This hall was built of a series of six cross-vaults that were 5 m high. Apart<br />
from an opening in the south, the hall had no windows or other means of lighting. Recesses, measuring about<br />
3-4 cm sq and 2-3 cm deep, had been hewn into the stones of the walls and ran the length of the walls and<br />
pillars that supported the roof. It is likely that rings used for shackling prisoners were attached to metal hooks<br />
inserted in the recesses. The fact that the room has no windows and was controlled by a guard room and an<br />
arrow loop at its entrance, corroborates the theory that the structure was a prison. That such a facility existed in<br />
the Hospitaller quarter is mentioned in a contemporary document.<br />
The Southern Street (Fig. 39:19): South of the Hospitaller complex, a city street was exposed that passed<br />
through the Hospitaller quarter along the eastern wall of the complex (Fig. 44). The street turned west and<br />
passed through the complex of the Church of St. John; after 50 m, it turned south toward the Genovese quarter.<br />
A double-wing stone gate erected at this section of the road allowed the Hospitallers to stop the public from<br />
passing along the street during times of crisis. The street, which was 4 m wide, was usually open, with short<br />
segments covered by a barrel vault. Another public street branched off from this street to the east (the King’s<br />
quarter). The latter was particularly wide (about 10 m) and paved with flagstones. A row of shops that faced the<br />
street was revealed along the southern part of the road. Three shops were exposed, but it is clear that other shops<br />
were located along the continuation of the street.<br />
Other Excavations from Crusader Period Acre<br />
Church of St. John: The construction of this church is first mentioned in a document from 1141, during the<br />
reign of Queen Melisande. The church was erected upon a series of vaults that consisted of two parts. The<br />
older, western part has two halls with barrel vaults that existed before the construction of the church. After<br />
construction began, an addition comprising four rooms covered with cross-vaults was built in the east, and later<br />
the Church of St. John above it.<br />
It was uncovered in the 1950s and two marble tombstones from the Crusader period were discovered in<br />
44* Eliezer Stern and Hanaa Abu-Uqsa
it. One tombstone bears an inscription in Latin<br />
mentioning the death of the ninth head of the<br />
Hospitallar Order (Pierre de Vieille Brioude) in 1242.<br />
The other, written in Old French, attests to the tomb<br />
of the Bishop of Nazareth, who died in 1290 and was<br />
buried in Acre. The Church of St. John, which was<br />
destroyed in 1291, was built above this structure.<br />
At the beginning of the 19th century, the Serai, an<br />
Ottoman government building, was constructed<br />
over it.<br />
Trial excavations conducted in the Serai exposed<br />
part of the church’s narthex, which includes the<br />
main threshold constructed of black granite. In the<br />
courtyard of the Serai, three marble columns and a<br />
marble Corinthian capital that had been treated with<br />
plaster and decorated with a colored fresco were<br />
uncovered. Another capital was also decorated with<br />
a colored fresco, as well as with an orange Maltese<br />
cross. Remains of the altar (bema) were exposed in<br />
the eastern part of the building. The chancel screen in<br />
front of the altar was made of hard nari and dressed in<br />
relief to resemble upright stone slabs standing against<br />
one another (Fig. 45). The remains of a splendid floor<br />
constructed of colored marble and ceramic tiles were<br />
found throughout the entire area of the church.<br />
Fig. 45: Area of the altar and part of the chancel screen that<br />
underwent conservation. (Photo: H. Smithline)<br />
Fig. 46: Templar tunnel. (Photo: D. Stern)<br />
The Templar Tunnel: The Templar quarter was situated in the southwestern part of the Old City (Fig. 46). The<br />
4 m wide tunnel, covered by a half-barrel vault, is approx. 2.5 m high and 350 m long. It began in a small bay<br />
in the west where a Templar fortress was situated in the Crusader period. The tunnel continued eastward below<br />
the Pisan quarter until it reached the port of Old Acre. This section, which is hewn in natural bedrock, split into<br />
two narrow parallel tunnels, each about 1.5 m wide and about 2 m high. It is likely that the tunnel was used as<br />
a passage for goods and people directly from the port to the Templar quarter.<br />
A Covered Street in the Genovese Quarter: A covered street of shops in the middle of the Old City, measuring<br />
some 100 m in length, was discovered during a survey conducted by B. Z. Kedar and E. Stern. Subsequent<br />
excavations exposed 40 m of this street, which was built of dressed ashlar stones and covered with a cross-vault<br />
supported by stone ribs. Openings on either side of the street led to the shops or workshops that were situated<br />
along it. The street, which dates to the Crusader period, is identified as “the covered street” in the Genovese<br />
quarter that is mentioned in several Crusader documents of the period (Kedar and Stern 1995: 105-110).<br />
Crusader Bathhouse in the Montmusard Quarter: Located about 300 m north of the Old City walls, the<br />
bathhouse is elongated (measuring 7x22 m) and aligned along an east-west axis. In the middle of the building,<br />
there is a furnace (5x5 m) with a firebox in its center. The hot room (7x14 m) bordered the furnace on the north<br />
and east and had a double floor. The structure was built of well-dressed limestone, most of which was stolen<br />
Eliezer Stern and Hanaa Abu-Uqsa 45*
Fig. 47: Northeastern corner of the tower. (Photo: D. Syon)<br />
in the Ottoman period. Remains of walls and rich ceramic finds that date to the Hellenistic period (3rd and 2nd<br />
centuries BCE) were discovered below the Crusader floors. Based on the ceramic evidence, the bathhouse has<br />
been dated to the 13th century. This date is in keeping with what we know from historical sources that describe<br />
the construction of a new Crusader quarter, called the Montmusard Quarter, north of the Crusader city walls<br />
during this century.<br />
The Courthouse: In 1991, an excavation was conducted in the area of the new courthouse. A tower (Fig. 47),<br />
moat, and well that form part of the outer fortification of the Crusader city were exposed. The northeastern<br />
corner of the tower rose to a height of two stories. The 13 m wide moat runs parallel to the line of the city wall<br />
and the tower, thus resembling the moat at Caesarea of the same period. The thick burned layer that was found<br />
in the rooms of the tower attests to a fierce conflagration, which resulted in the building’s destruction. A cluster<br />
of cooking and storage vessels on the ground floor corroborates the suggestion that this floor was used for a<br />
kitchen and store rooms while the upper floor served as the soldiers’ accommodations. <strong>Acco</strong>rding to historical<br />
sources, the outer wall of Acre was built at the beginning of the 13th century, a date confirmed by the ceramic<br />
evidence. It was destroyed by the Mamluks in 1291 (Hartal 1997).<br />
The Knights’ Hotel<br />
Two seasons of excavation, in 1995 and 2007, were conducted north of the White Souk and east of Weizmann<br />
Street as part of the project to build the Knights’ Hotel youth hostel in the Old City of Acre. The excavation<br />
exposed a residential neighborhood that dates to the time of the second Crusader kingdom (13th century CE),<br />
when Acre served as the capital of the kingdom (Fig. 48).<br />
46* Eliezer Stern and Hanaa Abu-Uqsa
Historical evidence from 1252 CE links this<br />
neighborhood to the Hospitaller complex located to<br />
the west. A system of streets, houses, commercial<br />
buildings, and workshops was exposed during<br />
the excavations. The main characteristic of the<br />
neighborhood is its simple but massive construction.<br />
The walls were built of indigenous kurkar, and the<br />
doorjambs and pillars that bore the arches and<br />
special installations were constructed of ashlar stones.<br />
Numerous repairs were discerned in the buildings and<br />
courtyards (Fig. 49). The sloppy construction attests<br />
to the absence of town planning. The plan of the<br />
neighborhood and the ceramic assemblage discovered<br />
there are similar to buildings of the same period in the<br />
south of France. A sophisticated water system was<br />
also discovered that included plastered cisterns built<br />
like a barrel vault, built and hewn wells, and a system<br />
of drainage channels that extended below the houses<br />
and streets and conveyed rainwater and wastewater<br />
into built septic pits.<br />
Fig. 48: Burned layer from 1291. (Photo: D. Syon)<br />
Fig. 49: View from above the excavation. (Photo: Sky View)<br />
One of the excavated buildings is a public structure<br />
in which a floor made of fired mudbricks arranged<br />
in different patterns survived. This building may have<br />
been used as a neighborhood church, one of 40 in<br />
Acre that are mentioned during the 13th century. It is<br />
the first time that a mudbrick floor has been discovered<br />
in a Crusader building in the country. The artifacts,<br />
mostly found in the septic pits, date between the late<br />
12th and late 13th centuries CE. The artifacts include<br />
many intact local and imported pottery vessels, glass<br />
vessels, coins, fragments of stone molds (in which lead<br />
was cast for the preparation of small bottles of the<br />
type sold to Christian pilgrims), limestone molds (for<br />
producing figurines in the image of a Crusader knight),<br />
marble colonettes, various clothing accessories made<br />
of copper, jewelry, weights, nails, and arrowheads.<br />
Note<br />
1 All the excavations described in this article were conducted on behalf of the Israel Antiquities Authority.<br />
Eliezer Stern and Hanaa Abu-Uqsa 47*
Fig. 50: View of the port. (Photo: E. Stern)<br />
48* Adrian J. Boas
Daily Life in Frankish Acre<br />
Adrian J. Boas University of Haifa<br />
Cities, like people, become important for a variety of reasons, sometimes simply for being in the right place at the<br />
right time or for other entirely fortuitous reasons. The success of Acre in the Crusader period was the outcome<br />
of a number of factors, among these its location; possession of a fairly well-protected harbor; the decisive role<br />
played in its capture by the Genoese fleet in 1104, with the resulting privileges granted to the Genoese and<br />
subsequent grants to Venetians and Pisans; the fact that after 1187, with the loss of the hinterland including the<br />
capital, Jerusalem, and the recovery of Acre in 1191, this port-city was the natural choice to replace Jerusalem<br />
as administrative capital. The importance of Acre to the Kingdom of Jerusalem, the remarkable growth and<br />
development of the city, and the resultant extensive historical and archaeological record combine to make it an<br />
excellent source for the study of daily urban life in the Crusader period; in certain ways, it is even a better subject<br />
for this topic than Jerusalem (Fig. 51).<br />
As is usual in maritime cities, it was the presence of the port, more than any other institution in Frankish Acre,<br />
that influenced daily life in the city (Fig. 50). International commerce and a large population of Italian merchants<br />
Fig. 51: Map of Crusader Acre. (Drawing: K.M. Barry)<br />
Adrian J. Boas 49*
Fig. 52: General view of the town. (Photo: E. Stern)<br />
affected the physical appearance of the city, the design of many of its buildings, the types of administrative and<br />
public institutions established, the language spoken by a large part of the population, the goods for sale and<br />
used by the populace in their daily life, and endless other aspects of life in the city.<br />
Population<br />
We cannot at present estimate the size of the population of Frankish Acre. There are too many unknown<br />
factors, such as continuing fluctuations resulting from changing conditions within the kingdom, the lack of exact<br />
knowledge of the size of the city and the density of domestic construction within it, along with the existence of<br />
a large number of part-time residents, including Italian merchants who spent half of the year in Italy and pilgrims<br />
who resided in Acre for short periods following their arrival in the Holy Land and prior to their departure.<br />
Pilgrims were already arriving in large numbers in Acre in the 12th century; the German pilgrim Theoderich<br />
records some eighty pilgrim ships docked in the port in a single day in Easter week in 1169 (Theoderich of<br />
Würzburg 1896: 60). Their presence was felt in the city throughout the Crusader period. Once they disembarked,<br />
pilgrims sought hostels, obtained provisions, changed their money, and began the process of arranging their<br />
passage to Jerusalem and other pilgrimage sites.<br />
Acre developed with the cosmopolitan social make-up typical of an important maritime city. The three Italian<br />
merchant communities of Genoa, Pisa, and Venice together represented one of the most powerful and prominent<br />
social elements in the city during this period. Quite probably, Frankish Acre resembled a medieval Italian portcity<br />
(Fig. 52). However, there were also merchants from Provençe and Catalonia, along with Franks, Oriental<br />
Christians, a small Jewish community, and some Muslim merchants. Several religious orders were established in<br />
the city, as were the five Military Orders, including, by the 13th century, the newly established Teutonic Order and<br />
the <strong>Eng</strong>lish Order of Saint Thomas.<br />
50* Adrian J. Boas
Layout and Development<br />
We know little of the town that was occupied by the Franks in 1104. Sources describing the Fatimid town<br />
are reticent although the 10th century geographer Mukaddasi briefly describes the fortifications and port<br />
(Al-Muqaddasi 1886: 29-31). Archaeology has so far added only fragmentary information that seems to suggest<br />
that the town was much smaller than the Crusader city, perhaps even smaller than Turkish Akko. Under the<br />
Franks, Acre expanded north and east; as the recent study by Benjamin Kedar has shown, it extended almost as<br />
far east as the ancient tell and some 700 meters north of the later Ottoman city wall (Kedar 1997: 157-180). Even<br />
after Acre had expanded, the former northern wall of the city remained standing and served to divide the new<br />
city (or faubourg), named Montmusard, from the old city to its south (Fig. 53). Within these two areas, which by<br />
1212 were enclosed by new concentric fortifications, the city was divided by streets and sometimes by internal<br />
fortifications into many small neighborhoods or quarters. On the periphery of the city there appear to have been<br />
open areas and gardens (as was also the case in Jerusalem). As the population of the city swelled after 1191,<br />
there was probably considerable encroachment into these areas.<br />
Defenses and Their Influence on Life in the City<br />
Our understanding of Acre’s defensive systems is still quite limited, more so than that of most other fortified<br />
cities of the Latin East. This is due to the intensive efforts made by the Mamluk conquerors in 1291 to dismantle<br />
the walls and also to the systematic removal, in the late 18th and early 19th centuries, of any surviving ruins<br />
outside the new walls of Turkish Akko. We are required to rely mainly on 14th century maps and on the few<br />
excavations that were carried out that exposed small sections of the walls and their outworks. These excavations<br />
Fig. 53: Old northern Crusader period wall with Turkish wall above. (Photo: E. Stern)<br />
Adrian J. Boas 51*
have exposed sections of the north-eastern outer and inner walls and moat and a possible section of the eastern<br />
defenses (see Dothan 1976: 207-209; Druks 1984: 2-4; Eisenberg 1999, unpublished report; Hartal 1997: 3-30).<br />
Churches, Monasteries, and Military Orders<br />
Although Acre possessed no important pilgrim sites, it was the principal port of entry for pilgrims to the Holy<br />
Land. This fact alone, along with the fact that pilgrims would, no doubt, stay in the city for at least a few days<br />
or weeks to get their bearings before setting out for Jerusalem, accounts for the presence of a number of<br />
churches in the city. Because Frankish Acre was a conglomeration of numerous ethnic and religious communities,<br />
it possessed almost as many churches as Jerusalem. Each monastic and military order had its own church, the<br />
Italian communities each had one or two churches, as did most other communities. A recent study gives the<br />
number of churches in the city during the two centuries of Frankish rule at about 81 (Pringle 2009). The most<br />
important of these was the Cathedral of the Holy Cross, which, like most of the churches in Acre, has long<br />
vanished. Those that have survived, such as the Church of St. John the Baptist and the Church of St. Andrew, are<br />
fragmentary at best and are better known to us from early illustrations than from architectural remains.<br />
Communes, Markets, and Commercial Activity<br />
Historical sources are also much more informative than archaeology with regard to commercial sites in Frankish<br />
Acre. Archaeological research has uncovered the presence of a single covered street, which may have been<br />
a market street. Starting at the Greek Church of St. George (which in the Crusader period was probably the<br />
location of the Genoese church, St. Laurence), this street crosses the Genoese quarter from west to east and ends<br />
at the town’s main suq, which was probably the border between the Genoese quarter and the Venetian quarter<br />
to its east. The street was first recorded in the survey carried out by Alex Kesten in the early 1960s (Kesten 1962:<br />
esp. Map 17). More recently, it was partly cleared by the Israel Antiquities Authority and tentatively identified<br />
as a market street, possibly the Genoese Covered Street (ruga cooperta), based on its location and the shallow<br />
recesses on either side that may have served for displaying goods for sale (Kedar and Stern 1995). What appears<br />
to have been another covered market street is known only from early 20th century aerial photographs that<br />
reveal surface remains near the shore, north of the Ottoman walls, in what had been the suburb of Montmusard<br />
(Boas 1997: 181-186). Regarding actual commercial activity in Acre, the main contribution of archaeology to<br />
our knowledge of this subject is the wealth of imported ceramics found in excavations in the town (Stern 2007).<br />
Fig. 54: Ground floor storage vaults of a palace in the Pisan Quarter.<br />
(Photo: A.J. Boas).<br />
Housing<br />
Houses in Frankish Acre ranged from grand palaces<br />
to small merchant houses and even occasional reed<br />
huts. The king and the royal court would at certain<br />
times have taken up residence in Acre. After 1191,<br />
with Jerusalem no longer in Frankish hands, the king<br />
may have resided in the citadel that was located on<br />
the old northern wall (as can be seen on 14th century<br />
maps) or in other palatial residences in the city. The<br />
Italian quarters and the quarters of the Military Orders<br />
contained large palaces, and this was probably also the<br />
case in other quarters, such as that of the Patriarch.<br />
52* Adrian J. Boas
Of all the archaeological evidence of the Crusader period in Acre, domestic buildings constitute the most<br />
numerous architectural remains (Fig. 54). In this aspect, Acre differs greatly from Jerusalem, which retains very<br />
little evidence of 12th century housing and consequently of the daily life of the Frankish residents (houses being<br />
more informative on aspects of daily life than is any other type of architecture). The large number of medieval<br />
houses of which substantial remains survive and the cosmopolitan make-up of the city’s population have resulted<br />
in a great variety of house types. Domestic architecture in Acre was influenced by the available building materials;<br />
urban conditions, such as population density, water supply, and sanitary conditions; location of industries; and<br />
the presence of the port. An additional influence was the existence of large organizations, such as the merchant<br />
communes and the Military Orders, which had to cater for the needs of the large seasonal population of pilgrims<br />
who arrived at certain times of the year and remained in the city only for short periods. Since merchants, too,<br />
were often seasonal residents, arriving in Acre in the late summer passagium (the time of the year when sea<br />
passage was comparatively safe) and returning in the spring, many communal houses had rooms or apartments<br />
that were rented out for limited periods.<br />
Houses in Acre included European-type, elongated merchant houses, with narrow shop fronts facing the street<br />
and sometimes a small internal open courtyard, and residential rooms at the back. Closed off from the street,<br />
there were also large, Eastern-type courtyard houses, which one entered via narrow, winding passageways into<br />
the courtyard and from there into the rooms. In the merchant commune quarters, houses were sometimes large,<br />
three or four-story buildings, with spacious ground-floor storage halls and shops and rooms and apartments<br />
for rent or sale on the upper floors. The design of these apartment buildings was much like that of the great<br />
merchant palaces in the mother cities (Genoa, Venice, and Pisa). There were also occasional tower houses,<br />
another architectural influence of Italy.<br />
Environment: Sanitation, Pollution, and Urban Crowding<br />
Archaeological excavations in parts of the city have revealed evidence of an organized system of sewage disposal.<br />
It is possible that it was limited to the Hospitaller compound, but it may have been more extensive. Sewage from<br />
the latrines in the Hospitaller compound ran off into a series of subterranean passages designed to facilitate its<br />
clearance into the port. Not only the Hospitallers, but also butchers, fishmongers, and various urban industries<br />
would have used the waters of the port to dispose of their waste. The name Lordemer (Filthy Sea), which was<br />
applied at the time, seems to be a reference to the polluted water of the harbor (Jacoby 1993).<br />
As noted, the periphery within the walls of the city seems to have comprised open spaces, fields, and gardens,<br />
which may have been used for open markets, small industries, and market gardens, and perhaps also for<br />
cemeteries. As the population of the city increased, these open areas would have become increasingly encroached<br />
upon by public and domestic building.<br />
Manufacture and Industry in Acre<br />
We can assume that all the usual urban industries were to be found in Acre. Ironsmiths and probably goldsmiths<br />
and silversmiths would have resided and worked in the city. The city had a mint, indeed the principal mint of<br />
the kingdom, that produced the gold bezants (bizantii acconitani), as well as lesser denominations, bearing the<br />
inscription, “struck in Acre,” in Arabic script (Malloy, Fraley-Preston, and Seltman 1994: 38-39; Jacoby 1986:<br />
426-427). A sugar refinery was located, probably, outside the walls, and soap was manufactured in Acre (Jacoby<br />
1986: 424-425). Glass vessels and ceramics were produced in the region, and workshops were possibly located<br />
in the city, as well (Fig. 55). A workshop manufacturing small lead ampullae (vessels for holy water or oil)<br />
Adrian J. Boas 53*
Fig. 55: Crusader ceramics from the German Quarter. (Photo: A.J. Boaz)<br />
was excavated in the area east of the Hospitaller Quarter (Syon 1999: 12). Workshops in Acre manufactured<br />
other keepsake items for pilgrims, but also works of fine art, such as icons, which were possibly produced in<br />
St. Catherine’s monastery (Folda 2005: 307). There is no direct evidence for the manufacture of architectural<br />
sculpture such as there appears to be in Jerusalem, but one can assume that there would have been an atelier<br />
in such a large city with many important monumental buildings. There is evidence of a scriptorium producing<br />
illuminated manuscripts (Folda 1976).<br />
Hospitals, Disease, Death, and Burial<br />
Hospitals, some intended for the actual treatment of disease, were established by the Military Orders. The<br />
Hospitallers ran the most important of these institutions, but there were also the hospitals under the auspices of<br />
the German Teutonic knights and the <strong>Eng</strong>lish Order of St. Thomas. The leper hospital of St. Lazarus was located<br />
at the far northern end of Montmusard. Probably a leper colony had existed there, as it was well away from the<br />
city until the neighbourhood expanded to that point in the late twelfth or early 13th century, from which time it<br />
came within the city walls. There are contemporary references to a number of cemeteries in the city; one of them,<br />
the cemetery of St. Nicholas, is depicted together with its chapel on the 13th century map of Matthew Paris.<br />
54* Adrian J. Boas
Ceramics as a Reflection of Maritime<br />
Commercial Activity at Crusader Acre<br />
Edna J. Stern Israel Antiquities Authority<br />
Introduction<br />
A large variety of Crusader period ceramics have been unearthed during large-scale excavations carried out by the<br />
Israel Antiquities Authority (IAA) at various sites in Acre since the early 1990s. These archaeological excavations<br />
have revealed different parts of the Crusader city of Acre, which was a thriving commercial center after the<br />
Crusader conquest of the Holy Land in 1104. With the fall of Jerusalem in 1187, Acre became the capital of the<br />
Crusader Kingdom of Jerusalem and its principal harbor. In the 13th century, Acre’s port was one of the busiest<br />
in the Frankish East and played an important role in the maritime trade with Europe, the Muslim states, and the<br />
Byzantine Empire until the fall of the Crusader Kingdom in 1291.<br />
Two large archaeological excavations, those conducted at the Hospitaller compound and at the Knights Hotel<br />
(Syon and Tatcher 1998; Syon and Tacher 2000; Stern 2002; Stern 2006; Stern and Syon Forthcoming), in<br />
addition to numerous smaller excavations, revealed a variety of public and domestic buildings, shops, and streets.<br />
The many pottery types uncovered, intended for storing, preparing, cooking, and serving food, reflect the<br />
ceramics in use by a cross-section of the population of Crusader Acre. The preservation of many of the ceramic<br />
vessels unearthed in these excavations was extraordinarily good; many vessels were whole or nearly whole. The<br />
large variety of ceramic types, combined with the high degree of preservation that facilitated the identification<br />
of the origin of the wares, is uncommon at other medieval Mediterranean port sites. Another outstanding<br />
feature of this assemblage was the wide range of ceramic ware imported from many regions throughout the<br />
Mediterranean, including artifacts from the western Mediterranean that were not previously identified in Israel.<br />
Such large-scale importation of ceramics into the Holy Land did not exist during the previous Fatimid period or<br />
during the subsequent Mamluk period. This phenomenon is unique to the time period of the Frankish presence<br />
in Acre. Therefore, the ceramic record from Acre makes it ideal for studying the trade and distribution of ceramics<br />
in the Mediterranean in the 12th and 13th centuries (Stern 2007; Stern in press).<br />
Fig. 56: "Acre Ware"; simple, unglazed wares produced in Acre.<br />
(Photo: H. Smithline; courtesy of IAA)<br />
Fig. 57: Cooking wares and glazed bowls produced in Beirut.<br />
(Photo: H. Smithline; courtesy of IAA)<br />
Edna J. Stern 55*
The Pottery Assemblage at Acre<br />
The Crusader-period pottery assemblage found in the excavations at Acre is diverse, containing a variety of local<br />
and imported types dating to the period of Frankish rule (12th-13th centuries). The local pottery includes two<br />
main groups. The first consists of simple, unglazed pottery that seems to have been produced in Acre itself,<br />
based on chemical and petrographic analyses (Fig. 56). The majority of this group of vessels mainly belongs to the<br />
“Acre Bowl” type: they are open, hemispherical, and have a short ledge rim and a flat base. Additional shapes<br />
in this group include plates, basins, and other closed forms. “Acre ware” in fact comprises most of the ceramic<br />
assemblage. The second group consists of various glazed and unglazed ware, characterized by a red fabric. These<br />
include cooking ware, glazed bowls decorated in various techniques, oil lamps, and closed vessels (Fig. 57). This<br />
group of pottery seems to have been produced in Beirut, where they are found in abundance, and as indicated<br />
by chemical and petrographic analysis (Stern and Waksman 2003; Waksman et al. 2008; Stern in press). Minor<br />
pottery groups produced at other sites in northern Israel and southern Lebanon were found, as well. Although<br />
the pottery manufactured in Beirut and its vicinity was most likely brought to Acre in ships, it is considered local,<br />
since Beirut was part of the Crusader Kingdom during the period under discussion.<br />
In addition to the local ware,<br />
ceramics imported from a wide<br />
range of regions throughout the<br />
Mediterranean were also found (Fig.<br />
58). These imported vessels, the<br />
majority of which are glazed bowls,<br />
account for some 30% of the entire<br />
pottery assemblage. Pottery was<br />
imported to Acre from Syria (Port St.<br />
Symeon Ware; Fig. 59), Asia Minor,<br />
Cyprus (Paphos-Lemba ware; Fig.<br />
60), Greece (Fine Byzantine ware<br />
and Aegean Ware), northern Italy,<br />
southern Italy, and Sicily (Protomaiolica;<br />
Fig. 61), southern France<br />
Fig. 58: Imported glazed bowls from a wide range of Mediterranean regions.<br />
(Photo: H. Smithline; courtesy of IAA)<br />
(Fig. 62), Catalonia in Spain, and<br />
North Africa (Blue and Manganese ware), as well as from beyond the Mediterranean, including China (Celadon;<br />
Fig. 63). The origin of the imported pottery types was determined by typological and analytical studies (Avissar<br />
and Stern 2005: 40-80; Stern and Waksman 2003; Stern 2007: 33-40; Stern in press). The imported pottery<br />
represents a variety of shapes, but the most common forms were glazed bowls and plates (84.7% of all the<br />
imported ware); less common were cooking vessels (11.1%) and transport amphorae (4.2%).<br />
Ceramic Trade and Distribution in the Medieval Mediterranean<br />
Archaeological excavations at coastal sites under Frankish control (in present-day Israel, Lebanon, Syria, and<br />
Cyprus) have revealed similar ceramic assemblages that include many imported types, indicating the existence of<br />
an intensive distribution system along the shores of the eastern Mediterranean during the Crusader period (Pringle<br />
1986). In addition, pottery imported from the eastern Mediterranean was found in western Mediterranean ports<br />
that were active in the trade with the Levant and that served as ports of call for the main maritime powers of the<br />
56* Edna J. Stern
time (for example, Venice: Saccardo 1998; Marseilles:<br />
Marchesi and Vallauri 1997: 57-92; and see also Stern<br />
2007: 205-210). This east-west trade apparently<br />
occurred because of a new maritime trade pattern<br />
that developed between western Mediterranean ports<br />
and the Frankish ports in the eastern Mediterranean<br />
coinciding with the establishment of the Crusader<br />
states. The maritime technology of the period<br />
necessitated stopping at various ports along the way<br />
and, as a consequence, these ports developed and<br />
flourished. The Italian merchants, predominantly<br />
those from Genoa, Pisa, and Venice, who assisted the<br />
crusading armies in capturing the coastal cities of the<br />
Holy Land, constituted the main parties involved in this<br />
trade network. During the 13th century, merchants<br />
from southern France and Catalonia joined in the<br />
new commercial activity. It is noteworthy that some<br />
historians have described this period as an age of<br />
“commercial revolution.”<br />
Over time, Latin merchants became more daring<br />
in their commercial ventures and developed more<br />
sophisticated business techniques that allowed these<br />
cities to dominate maritime transportation in the<br />
Mediterranean and also a large part of the Levantine<br />
trade. In addition, ships during this period increased<br />
in size and quality as a result of technological leaps<br />
in navigation. Innovations included the invention of<br />
the mariner's compass and the production of more<br />
sophisticated nautical charts, tables, and maps,<br />
thereby greatly improving the Mediterranean sailing<br />
routes. The result was a reduction in shipping costs and<br />
a rise in the number of ships sailing between Europe<br />
and the eastern Mediterranean. Maritime trade now<br />
consisted of long-distance trade between the Levant<br />
and Europe, which, although it had existed before the<br />
Crusades, increased in volume; mid-distance maritime<br />
trade, which connected the Levant, Egypt, and the<br />
Byzantine Empire; and local maritime trade, which<br />
was characterized by ships plying the length of the<br />
Levantine coast from Asia Minor to Egypt and buying<br />
and selling merchandise in various ports along the way<br />
(Jacoby 1998; Stern 2007: 72-74).<br />
Fig. 59: Port St. Symeon ware (Northern Syria).<br />
(Photo: M. Salzberger; courtesy of IAA)<br />
Fig. 60: Paphos-Lemba ware (Cyprus).<br />
(Photo: M. Salzberger; courtesy of IAA)<br />
Fig. 61: Proto-maiolica ware (Southern Italy and Sicily).<br />
(Photo: M. Salzberger; courtesy of IAA)<br />
Edna J. Stern 57*
As found in various underwater excavations and<br />
surveys, Mediterranean shipwrecks dating to the 12th<br />
and 13th centuries that contained pottery cargoes of<br />
the same types imported into Acre illustrate the trade<br />
and distribution of ceramics. Each ship carried either<br />
quantities of homogeneous types of pottery, usually<br />
amphora or glazed bowls, or a cargo of ceramics from<br />
different manufacturing centers (Stern 2007: 40-47).<br />
At this point, it is necessary to confront the question<br />
why large quantities of ceramics were exported to<br />
Acre from such a wide range of provenances? In order<br />
to attempt to answer this, numerous contemporary<br />
written sources were surveyed. Pottery, when<br />
mentioned, appeared only rarely in these texts and<br />
Fig. 62: Cooking vessel from southern France.<br />
then usually referred to incidentally in discussions<br />
(Photo: M. Salzberger; courtesy of IAA)<br />
of more expensive or important goods or in a list<br />
of merchandise. In fact, these sources on their own<br />
would indicate that ceramics did not constitute one<br />
of the main commodities traded during the crusader<br />
period (Stern 2007: 47-54). For this reason, other<br />
sources of information to answer the question have<br />
been sought, including modern interpretations of<br />
Hellenistic and Roman maritime trade in ceramics—a<br />
period that witnessed a peak in maritime pottery<br />
distribution – and evidence from ethnographic studies<br />
of Mediterranean maritime pottery trade in the Early<br />
Modern period. In the past, scholars have suggested<br />
Fig. 63: Chinese Celadon. (Photo: M. Salzberger; courtesy of IAA)<br />
that Hellenistic and Roman pottery, in addition to its<br />
function as a container for the export of foodstuffs,<br />
was exported by sea because of its high value. Currently, however, scholars prefer to see pottery as a low-value<br />
product, exported by sea along with other, more valuable commodities and possibly serving as “‘space fillers”<br />
or “profitable/salable ballast” (Stern 2007: 55-57). Ethnographic studies have shown that all forms of ceramics<br />
were shipped to destinations both far and near. The research also reveals that ceramics were transported as a<br />
consequence of consumer demand, as well as an exchange commodity or as a money-making sideline by ship<br />
masters or crews (Stern 2007: 57-60). The issue of ballast, mentioned above, was further investigated. Ballast<br />
is a heavy object that provided ships with greater stability and better maneuverability, and the antiquity of this<br />
practice is attested to by Mediterranean shipwrecks from the Late Bronze period onwards. Eventually it was<br />
realized that if a ship was able to take on goods that were heavy but did not take up much space, two goals could<br />
be achieved at once: a well-ballasted ship and a profit from selling the goods serving as ballast, or what has been<br />
defined as “salable ballast” (Parker 1992: 91-92; McGrail 1989: 357). In fact, Venetian lists of maritime freight<br />
charges and Genoese marine contracts classified cargo into light and heavy goods. The latter were called merces<br />
de savurra, which literally means ‘ballast goods‘ (Dotson 1982: 56-59; Stern 2007: 92-93).<br />
58* Edna J. Stern
Conclusions<br />
The excavations at Acre have revealed a large quantity of well-preserved pottery. The study of these artifacts has<br />
shown that, along with the locally produced ware, there was much imported pottery, mainly open forms. Similar<br />
pottery assemblages were recovered at other major ports throughout the Mediterranean.<br />
Contemporary written sources on maritime ceramic trade show that ceramics were not among the main<br />
commodities traded in the Crusader period. Rather, they were distributed mainly as a luxury item. However, since<br />
they are found in large quantities in excavations in Acre and in other major port cities around the Mediterranean,<br />
it has been theorized that other reasons could account for such assemblages, which originate in various regions<br />
and which bear similarity in Levantine and other Mediterranean ports.<br />
There seems to be a clear correlation between the production regions that exported pottery to Acre, the major<br />
ports active during this period, and the main 13th century Mediterranean sailing routes (Fig. 64). Therefore, it<br />
is suggested that the sailing routes were one of the most important factors that influenced the distribution of<br />
pottery throughout the Mediterranean. This conclusion derives from the fact that the pottery imported into Acre<br />
consisted of glazed table ware, mainly plates and bowls. Traded in large quantities, these vessels came in shapes<br />
that could easily be packed. Once densely packed, they were quite heavy and undoubtedly served mainly as<br />
salable ballast or space fillers. The sale of the glazed tableware could also have provided extra income along the<br />
route for the merchants, ship masters, or seafarers.<br />
With the establishment of the Latin states in the eastern Mediterranean and the new Mediterranean maritime<br />
trade pattern that developed thereafter, greater numbers of ships began sailing between the ports and along the<br />
coasts of these regions. It has been demonstrated with a high degree of certainty that the pottery arriving in Acre<br />
and other Mediterranean sites was not brought because of its intrinsic value nor was it related to the origin of the<br />
European settlers in Acre. Rather, it was transported and distributed, along with other items, by ships involved in<br />
short and long-distance trade to and among the main port cities as a consequence of that trade.<br />
The geographical origins of the many ceramic wares bear silent testimony to Acre's maritime commercial<br />
activity in the 12th and mainly 13th centuries and to the many ships that frequented its port. It also reflects the<br />
cosmopolitan character of Acre during the Crusader period. The great quantities of imported ceramics reflect the<br />
numerous ships that sailed the Mediterranean during this period.<br />
Genoa<br />
Marseille<br />
Barcelona<br />
Venice<br />
Brindisi<br />
Istanbul<br />
Ganos<br />
Troy<br />
Tunis Gela Corinth<br />
Kinet<br />
al-Mina<br />
Paphos<br />
Beirut<br />
Acre<br />
Alexandria<br />
Fig. 64: Map of the pottery production regions, the major ports and the main 13th century Mediterranean<br />
sailing routes. (Drawing: H. Tahan; courtesy of IAA)<br />
Edna J. Stern 59*
Fig. 65a: Plan of the Knights Hospitaller Compound. (Documentation: R. Kislev)<br />
60* Yael Fuhrmann-Na'aman
Conservation of the<br />
Knights Hospitaller Compound<br />
Yael Fuhrmann-Na'aman Israel Antiquities Authority<br />
As seen through UNESCO’s World Heritage lens, Old Akko (Acre, Akka) shows us the city’s present cultural<br />
significance: it preserves substantial remains of medieval Crusader buildings beneath the existing fortified<br />
Moslem town, which dates to the 18th and 19th centuries; these remains provide an exceptional picture of the<br />
layout and the structures of the Crusader city, which was the capital of the Crusader Kingdom of Jerusalem in<br />
the 13th century; and the city is also an important example of a walled Ottoman town, with such well-preserved,<br />
typical urban components as a citadel, mosques, khans, and baths, which are partly built on top of the underlying<br />
Crusader remains. These features were cited as justification for declaring Old Akko a World Heritage city in 2001;<br />
they are manifested in the best possible way in Akko's Citadel (Figs. 65a-b).<br />
In the early 1990s, the structural condition of the Hall of Pillars in the Knights Hospitaller Compound became<br />
unstable. This became apparent when cracks started to appear in the vaults in the hall, and soil and mortar fell<br />
from the vault’s core into the hall below. In the wake of engineering measures that were implemented to save<br />
the hall, the Old Akko Development Company decided to proceed with the conservation and development of<br />
the underground complex for tourism. This decision resulted in an extensive archaeological excavation (Fig. 66),<br />
which was conducted by the Israel Antiquities Authority and underwritten by the Ministry of Tourism from 1992<br />
to 1999. Most of the Knights Hospitaller Compound was exposed during this excavation. The streets east and<br />
Fig. 65b: Sections A-A, B-B,0 based on measurements. (Courtesy of architect A. Avrahami)<br />
Yael Fuhrmann-Na'aman 61*
Fig. 66: General view to the southeast, toward the prison courtyard<br />
in 1992, when the removal of earth from the central courtyard began<br />
and the Hall of Pillars was exposed. (Courtesy of A. Gil‘ad)<br />
Fig. 67: Hall of Pillars, looking east. The western entrance from the<br />
central courtyard is on the left, and the service elevator is on the right.<br />
The conservation measures implemented on the three pillars in the<br />
center of the hall are evident in the steel straps, the completion of<br />
stonework, and the mortar. (Photo: Y. Fuhrmann-Na’aman)<br />
south of the compound were also excavated, and an excavation was carried out in the Church of Saint John,<br />
which is located just to the southeast of the compound. The archaeological excavation of the Crusader remains<br />
and the exposure of a multi-period complex reveal exactly how the built-up area of the city took shape during its<br />
two golden ages – the 13th century and the 18th-19th centuries.<br />
The compound, parts of which were uncovered and treated in the 1950s and 1960s, was exposed in its full might<br />
and magnificence in the 1990s. The funding allocated by the government for the development of Akko facilitated<br />
the excavation work, which entailed removing layers of soil fill to a depth of 14 meters, and the conservation<br />
of the compound. The engineering solutions, documentation, and professional work involved in conserving the<br />
buildings were an inseparable part of both the archaeological activity and tourism development (Fig. 67).<br />
The remains of the Crusader halls at ground level extend across an area of about 8,300 square meters. They<br />
function as a single constructive complex; that is to say, there are mutual structural ties that exist between them.<br />
The Ottoman structure, which was built on top of the Crusader remains (Fig. 68), created loads that were not<br />
suitable to the earlier construction. This, in turn, compromised the structural scheme of the Crusader system and<br />
contributed to the processes of deterioration and the destruction of structural components. The engineering<br />
solution to these problems was to create a constructive separation between the Crusader and Ottoman structures.<br />
Fig. 68: The central courtyard after being exposed, looking toward<br />
the southeastern corner. The structural elements are seen to be falling<br />
apart. (Courtesy of A. Gil‘ad)<br />
Of all the halls in the Knights Hospitaller Compound,<br />
the Hall of Pillars received the most intensive<br />
conservation intervention. The hall’s remains suffered<br />
from acute stone deterioration; crushed and cracked,<br />
they were falling apart. With the loss of the building’s<br />
static scheme, the existence of the hall itself was in<br />
danger, a situation that also threatened the stability of<br />
the Ottoman building above and that of the structures<br />
adjacent to it. The condition of the halls called for<br />
immediate and serious intervention.<br />
62* Yael Fuhrmann-Na'aman
The consequent intervention in the hall entailed a broad spectrum of conservation treatments, including<br />
stabilization, restoration, and reconstruction; for example:<br />
• The conservation of the vaults included cleaning and grouting of lime-based mortar into cracks and voids.<br />
• In several panel walls, measures were taken to conserve the original material and complete the missing mortar;<br />
in other cases, the wall cores were reinforced with fieldstone and mortar (debesh).<br />
• The field pillars were stabilized utilizing modern materials. In contrast, the constructive function of the end<br />
pillars was restored using the original technology. Most of the intervention in the latter case involved the use<br />
of stone and lime-based mortar.<br />
• In a number of places where stones were missing, the void was filled by anchoring new stones to the original<br />
stonework by means of fiberglass pins.<br />
• The stone dressing for the restoration of the stonework was done using Crusader technology. In order to<br />
achieve results that resemble the original stonework, the stones were manually dressed, employing a slightly<br />
diagonal dressing technique, during the final stages of preparation by means of flat tools, such as an axe and<br />
chisels.<br />
The conservation approach adopted for the Knights Hospitaller Compound was intended to produce noticeable<br />
intervention, defining the new work from the original remains (Fig. 69). From an architectural standpoint, the<br />
intervention created a variety of new situations. The restoration activity created a gap in the height of the<br />
Fig. 69: The Northern Hall, looking east. The stonework was completed utilizing a variety of technologies.<br />
(Photo: H. Smithline).<br />
Yael Fuhrmann-Na'aman 63*
Fig. 70: Hall of Pillars, the end pillars on the eastern side of the hall, looking toward the south during the conservation and restoration work.<br />
(Photo: Y. Fuhrmann-Na’aman)<br />
stone surface between the original stone that had deteriorated and the new stone that was installed alongside<br />
it. The juxtaposition of original and new building materials in the structure created a visual dissonance that is<br />
sometimes too contrasting. The restoration of the end pillars in the Hall of Pillars created a large mass of new<br />
stone compared to the original stone mass (Fig. 70). With regard to the pillars that could be stabilized just<br />
through conservation and without replacing the stone, the results underscore the ravages of time and present<br />
the deterioration of the material.<br />
64* Yael Fuhrmann-Na'aman
Fig. 71: Hall of Pillars, looking northeast. Different levels of intervention and various solutions were employed in the conservation and rehabilitation<br />
of the hall. (Photo: Y. Fuhrmann-Na’aman)<br />
The physical condition of the components in the Knights Hospitaller Compound dictated a variety of intervention<br />
levels by the Israel Antiquities Authority’s Conservation Department, in addition to providing it with ample<br />
opportunities for learning conservation processes and methods. After 18 years of work in the Knights Hospitaller<br />
Compound utilizing both traditional and modern technologies, we can now see there a wide assortment of<br />
interventions that provided a response for the conservation of this historic monument and its presentation to<br />
visitors (Fig. 71).<br />
Yael Fuhrmann-Na'aman 65*
66* Danny Syon<br />
Fig. 72: Bronze colonial issue for Aquilia Severa, wife of Elagabalus (minted c. 220-221 CE).<br />
Obverse: Draped bust of Aquilia Severa r. Around: IVL AQVILIA SEVERA AV.<br />
Reverse: A complex portable shrine consisting of a tetrastyle temple over a hexastyle<br />
structure. In the central arch, a statue of Tyche to left, crowned by a figure of Nike on a<br />
column behind her; to left, statue of Perseus holding the head of Medusa; to right, statue<br />
of Athena; below, hexastyle portico with a central arch occupied by a statue of Zeus and<br />
with other statues. The portico rests on a series of semi-circular arches. Probably unique.<br />
(Photo courtesy of LHS Numismatik)
The Mint of Akko through the Ages<br />
Danny Syon Israel Antiquities Authority<br />
One of the privileges of a great city in antiquity was the minting of coins. Often this was done for the ruling<br />
power, but in certain periods cities minted in their own names and for their own benefit. Even when the coins<br />
were minted for the ruler, the city was usually identified on the coins, and this is how its minting history can be<br />
traced. Akko, though not the most prolific mint in the southern Levant – that title no doubt belongs to Tyre –<br />
was certainly among the longest producing mints, one of the most varied, and a mint that could count several<br />
superlatives in its minting history. In fact, the mint of Akko has – with some breaks – a 1,500 year history. Coins<br />
are miniature historical documents reflecting persons, places, and events at the time a coin was struck. As such,<br />
they can shed light on subjects that are too mundane to have occupied ancient historians, yet are priceless for<br />
the modern historian.<br />
The Alexandrine Period<br />
Some coins of the Persian period (6th-4th centuries BCE) were once thought to have been minted in Akko, but<br />
today it is almost certain that the city's minting started with Alexander the Great. This ruler effectively created<br />
a new coinage that became accepted as the universal currency throughout Alexander’s empire and the western<br />
Mediterranean. This was especially true of the silver tetradrachms, known today simply as “Alexanders,” which<br />
became so popular that they were minted in huge quantities and imitated long after Alexander's death in 323<br />
BCE. Akko was the first city in the southern Levant to mint coinage in the name of Alexander; Sidon followed<br />
suit. Both gold staters (Fig. 73) and silver tetradrachms (Fig. 74) were minted in Akko. Although the style and<br />
artistic level of the Akko mint is not considered among the finest, its importance lies in that it produced (along<br />
with Sidon) the only dated coins at the time. The dates range from “year 20” to “year 39” according to an<br />
era beginning in 346/5 BCE; that is, from 327 to 308/7 BCE, or after Alexander’s death. The coins bear the<br />
abbreviated name of Akko in Phoenician letters: åO.<br />
The Ptolemaic Period<br />
After the upheavals caused by the splitting up of Alexander’s empire among his heirs (the diadochoi), Akko<br />
became part of the Ptolemaic kingdom, centered in Egypt, sometime toward the end of Ptolemy I's reign<br />
(305-286 BCE). Minting resumed in Akko under Ptolemy II, who named the port-city Ptolemais, in honor of<br />
his father, Ptolemy I, the founder of the dynasty. Gold (Fig. 75), silver (Fig. 76), and bronze (Fig. 77) coins were<br />
Fig. 73: Gold stater of Alexander the Great (posthumous issue).<br />
Obverse: Head of Athena with Corinthian helmet. Reverse: Nike<br />
advancing left. At right, ΑΛΕΞΑΝΔΡΟΥ. At left, åO (‘AK) and date<br />
30 (317/6 BCE). (Photo courtesy of Goldberg Coins)<br />
Fig. 74: Silver tetradrachm of Alexander the Great (c. 330-327<br />
BCE). Obverse: Head of Herakles with lion's skin. Reverse: Zeus<br />
Aetophoros with sceptre seated on throne and holding an eagle on<br />
his out-stretched hand. At right, ΑΛΕΞΑΝΔΡΟΥ (of Alexander). At<br />
left, åO (‘AK). (Photo courtesy of Goldberg Coins)<br />
Danny Syon 67*
Fig. 75: Gold octodrachm of Ptolemy III (246-221 BCE). Year 6<br />
(242/241 BCE). Obverse: Diademed and veiled head of Arsinöe<br />
II, with lotus-tipped sceptre over her shoulder. Reverse: Double<br />
cornucopiae with fruit, bound with fillet. ΑΡΣΙΝΟΗΣ ΦΙΛΑΔΕΛΦΟΥ<br />
(of Arsinöe philadelphos). At left, mintmark of Akko: Ô.<br />
(Photo courtesy of Classical Numismatics Group Inc.)<br />
Fig. 76: Silver tetradrachm of Ptolemy III (246-222 BCE).<br />
Obverse: Head of Ptolemy I, with diadem and aegis around his<br />
neck. Reverse: Eagle with closed wings standing to the left on<br />
a thunderbolt. Around: ΠΤΟΛΕΜΑΙΟΥ ΣΩΤΗΡΟΣ (of Ptolemy the<br />
savior). At left, mintmark of Akko: V; at right, ligature of the name<br />
of a mint official.<br />
(Photo courtesy of Classical Numismatics Group Inc.)<br />
Fig. 77: Bronze of Ptolemy II (285-246 BCE). Obverse: Head of<br />
Zeus. Reverse: Eagle with closed wings standing to the left on a<br />
thunderbolt; behind its wings are double cornucopia. Around:<br />
ΠΤΟΛΕΜΑΙΟΥ BAΣΙΛΕΩΣ (of King Ptolemy). At left, mintmark of<br />
Akko: 1. (Photo courtesy of Classical Numismatics Group Inc.)<br />
Fig. 78: Attic weight silver tetradrachm of Seleucus IV (187-175<br />
BCE). Obverse: Diademed head of Seleucus. Reverse: Nude Apollo<br />
seated left on omphalos, leaning on a bow, and holding an arrow.<br />
At right and left, ΒΑΣΙΛΕΩΣ ΣΕΛΕΥΚΟΥ (of king Seleucus). At left, a<br />
palm branch, mintmark of Akko. Below Apollo’s arm: J (ligature<br />
of a mint official’s name). (Photo courtesy of Oliver Hoover and the<br />
American Numismatic Society)<br />
minted in Akko, however, as minting took place only<br />
for a short duration under both Ptolemy II and Ptolemy<br />
III (261-242 BCE). The Ptolemaic monetary system<br />
was a closed one, and the coin types were rather<br />
monotonous. Thus, the coins minted in Akko were<br />
practically identical to those minted in any number of<br />
Ptolemaic mints and differed only in the mintmark V,<br />
which is a ligature of the Greek letters ΠTO, the first<br />
letters of Ptolemais.<br />
The Seleucid Period (Figs. 78-83)<br />
Following the battle of Paneion (200 BCE), the<br />
Seleucid dynasty, another contender to Alexander’s<br />
heritage, took control of Phoenicia and, of course,<br />
Akko. Although the name Ptolemais remained, the<br />
city was also referred to as Aké. Royal Seleucid coins<br />
were minted in the city from the very beginning of<br />
the Seleucid rule until the late 2nd century BCE. The<br />
bronze types were numerous, and until the end of<br />
the reign of Antiochus IV (175-164 BCE), this mint<br />
was responsible for practically all the bronze currency<br />
needs of Palestine (Fig 79).<br />
Although the silver standard in the Seleucid kingdom<br />
– and in most of the Hellenistic world – was the Attic<br />
weight of c. 17 grams (Figs. 78, 80, 82), many mints in<br />
Phoenicia minted mostly, but not exclusively, according<br />
to the Ptolemaic standard of c. 14 grams (Fig 81).<br />
It is the only known example of a kingdom that<br />
concurrently struck precious metal coins based on two<br />
different standards, the reason being the economic<br />
benefits gained through trade with Egypt. Akko was<br />
the first mint to introduce the Ptolemaic standard<br />
under Antiochus V (164-162 BCE). It also minted some<br />
unusual gold coins with Ptolemaic connections: first<br />
under Alexander Balas (152-145 BCE), who rose to<br />
power with Ptolemaic help and married the Egyptian<br />
princess Kleopatra Thea, and later when the same<br />
Kleopatra married Antiochus VIII and ruled jointly with<br />
him in Akko from 125-121 BCE.<br />
Concurrently with the minting of royal coins that for<br />
the most part carried the portrait of the king on the<br />
obverse, Akko also produced a local civic coinage under<br />
68* Danny Syon
Antiochus IV that bore the heads of the dioskouroi on<br />
the obverse and a cornucopia on the reverse (Fig. 83).<br />
The attribution of Seleucid coins to mints is often<br />
difficult and rests on long, tedious scholarship that<br />
catalogued large quantities of coins from a known<br />
provenance and on studies of style, symbols, dielinks,<br />
and monograms. For Attic weight silver coins,<br />
the mintmark of Akko was the palm branch and/or<br />
a monogram known to represent a mint official of<br />
this city. On the Phoenician weight silver coins, the<br />
Akko mintmark often appears as the monogram<br />
V or the abbreviation ΠΤΟ, as well as the date. The<br />
civic coins carry an intriguing legend that has not yet<br />
been satisfactorily explained: ΑΝΤΙΟΧΕΩΝ ΤΩΝ ΕΝ<br />
ΠΤΟΛΕΜΑΙΔΙ, which roughly means “the Antiocheans<br />
who are in Ptolemais.” Here the mint of Ptolemais is<br />
clearly identified, but the identity of the “Antiocheans”<br />
remains uncertain.<br />
Civic and Autonomous Coinage<br />
Long before the last royal Seleucid coin was struck in<br />
Akko under Antiochus IX in 107/6 BCE, civic bronze<br />
coins were back in production and signaled the<br />
beginning of the most enigmatic period in the history<br />
of this mint. The coins were produced sporadically,<br />
occasionally adding titles to the city, but for some time<br />
also acknowledging Seleucid supremacy by adding<br />
the Seleucid date. Thus, the civic coins that under<br />
Antiochus IV carried the legend "the Antiocheans<br />
who are in Ptolemais" later had the epithet ieras<br />
(holy) added to the inscription, and later still the title<br />
asylou (inviolate) was added as well. The city probably<br />
received these honors from the last Seleucid rulers,<br />
who were constantly fighting each other and doing<br />
their best to hold onto the fragments of the kingdom.<br />
The Seleucid dates can be followed until c. 109 BCE,<br />
when they disappear altogether. The coin types<br />
minted are few: on the obverse appear the heads of<br />
the dioskouroi or the bust of Apollo or Zeus, while the<br />
reverse shows a lyre, cornucopia, Zeus, or Tyche, the<br />
protector-goddess of cities. A single silver coin dated<br />
112/1 BCE by the Seleucid era is considered by some<br />
Fig. 79: Bronze of Antiochus IV (175-164 BCE). Obverse: Head of<br />
Apollo. Reverse: Nude Apollo seated left on omphalos, leaning on<br />
a bow, and holding an arrow. At right and left, ΒΑΣΙΛΕΩΣ ΑΝΤΙΟΧΟΥ<br />
(of King Antiochus). At left, a palm branch, mintmark of Akko.<br />
Below: Δ. Serrated edge. (Photo courtesy of the IAA)<br />
Fig. 80: Attic weight silver tetradrachm commemorating the<br />
wedding of Alexander Balas with the Ptolemaic princess Kleopatra<br />
Thea (150 BCE). Obverse: Jugate busts of Kleopatra Thea veiled,<br />
diademed, wearing kalathos, cornucopia over her shoulder; and<br />
Alexander, diademed. Behind: a. Reverse: Zeus Nikephoros seated<br />
left, holding sceptre in his left; a small Nike, holding a thunderbolt<br />
on his outstretched right hand stands facing. At right and left,<br />
ΒΑΣΙΛΕΩΣ ΑΛΕΞΑΝΔΡΟΥ ΘΕΟΠΑΤΟΡΟΣ ΕΥΕΡΓΕΤΟΥ (of King<br />
Alexander theopator euergetes). (Photo courtesy of O. Hoover and<br />
the American Numismatic Society)<br />
Fig. 81: Ptolemaic weight silver tetradrachm of Alexander Balas<br />
(151-146/5 BCE). Obverse: Diademed head of Alexander Balas.<br />
Reverse: Eagle standing left on thunderbolt. Around: ΒΑΣΙΛΕΩΣ<br />
ΑΛΕΞΑΝΔΡΟΥ (of King Alexander). To right ΠΤΟ (Ptolemais). To left,<br />
monogram and date ΒΞΡ (151/150 BCE).<br />
(Photo courtesy of Classical Numismatics Group Inc.)<br />
Danny Syon 69*
Fig. 82: Attic weight silver tetradrachm from the joint reign of<br />
Antiochus VIII and Kleopatra Thea (125-121 BCE). Obverse: Jugate<br />
heads of Kleopatra and Antiochus. Reverse: Zeus with sceptre<br />
seated on throne, holding small Nike on his extended hand. To right<br />
and left, ΒΑΣΙΛΙΣΣΗΣ ΚΛΕΟΠΑΤΡΑΣ ΘΕΑΣ ΚΑΙ ΒΑΣΙΛΕΩΣ ΑΝΤΙΟΧΟΥ<br />
(Queen Kleopatra Thea and King Antiochus). To left, monogram of a<br />
magistrate known to have operated in Akko.<br />
(Photo courtesy of Classical Numismatics Group Inc.)<br />
Fig. 83: Bronze civic issue under Antiochus IV (c. 169-165 BCE).<br />
Obverse: Jugate heads of the Dioskouroi with a star above each.<br />
Reverse: Cornucopia with fruit. To right and left, ΑΝΤΙΟΧΕΩΝ ΤΩΝ ΕΝ<br />
ΠΤΟΛΕΜΑΙΔΙ To l. monogram. Beveled edge.<br />
(Photo courtesy of Goldberg Coins)<br />
Fig. 84: Bronze civic issue under Mark Antony (d. 30 BCE). Obverse:<br />
Bare head of Mark Antony r, in wreath. Reverse: Tyche, standing on<br />
ship’s prow, holding tiller in her right and a cornucopia in her left. At<br />
top left date, LIA (39/8 BCE). Inscription, starting on right and ending<br />
with line under date: ΠΤΟ/ΛΕ/ΜΑ [ΕΩΝ ΙΕΡΑΣ] ΚΑΙ ΑΣΥ (ΛΟΥ).<br />
(Photo courtesy of Goldberg Coins)<br />
Fig. 85: Bronze Roman provincial issue under Claudius (41-54 CE).<br />
Obverse: Head of Claudius r. Reverse: ΓEPMANI[ΕΩΝ[∙∙∙. Tyche, tiller<br />
in her right and a cornucopia in her left. Date: L-Ч (41/2 CE).<br />
(Gamla Excavations)<br />
to be an autonomous issue, but this remains uncertain.<br />
Sometime in the last years of the second or in the early<br />
1st century BCE, a unique coin appeared, bearing a<br />
legend composed of monograms and ligatures that<br />
spell out ptolemaeon iera<br />
autonomou: that is, “of<br />
P<br />
the people of Ptolemais the<br />
holy and autonomous.”<br />
The coin is dated “year nine” of an unknown era of<br />
autonomy that Akko apparently received (or took?)<br />
after the end of Seleucid rule.<br />
In the following century and a half, coins were minted<br />
that bore dates according to no fewer than four<br />
different eras. Some eras are unknown, but others are<br />
clear, such as a Caesarean era beginning in 49/8 BCE,<br />
an era of Antony and Kleopatra beginning in 37/6<br />
BCE (Fig. 84), and back to the Caesarean era after the<br />
battle of Actium, in which Antony lost to Octavian<br />
(31 BCE). In the course of this period, the legends<br />
always named the city either explicitly (ptolemaidi,<br />
ptolemaeon) or through the now familiar monogram<br />
V and its derivatives. Strangely, in the last two decades<br />
of the 1st century BCE, the ancient Semitic name AKH<br />
(Aké) reappeared on a coin of an unusual type: it<br />
shows Perseus holding the head of Medusa. Finally,<br />
coins were minted in the last few years of the Roman<br />
Emperor Claudius that bore the imperial portrait, but<br />
were dated according to the Caesarean era (Fig. 85).<br />
The Colonial Period<br />
The city of Akko was granted the status of a Roman<br />
colony probably in the year 53 or 54 CE, either in the<br />
last year of Claudius’ reign or the first year of Nero’s.<br />
The most obvious change in the coinage was the use<br />
of Latin instead of Greek for the legends. The most<br />
frequent legend on the colonial coinage is COL PTOL,<br />
short for colonia Ptolemais, but variants do exist. One<br />
of the earliest coins depicts the ceremonial founding<br />
of the colony (sulcus primigenius), showing the<br />
“founder” behind an ox and cow (Fig. 86). In this<br />
case, the scene bears an additional motif that relates<br />
to contemporaneous events: it carries the standards of<br />
four of the Roman legions that took part in quelling the<br />
70* Danny Syon
Jewish Revolt in Judea. Opinions differ as to the exact<br />
numbers appearing on the standards, but it is clear<br />
that the coin was minted in 66 CE to commemorate<br />
the arrival of the Roman general Vespasian in Akko,<br />
which formed his first base of operations.<br />
This period (53-54 to c. 268 CE) is certainly the most<br />
prolific in terms of the huge variety of types and<br />
subjects, some unique and others surprising, depicted<br />
on the coinage. In fact, the coins of this period are<br />
practically the only historical source to shed light on<br />
the physical reality of Roman Akko, as archaeology<br />
lags far behind. The coins of this period inform us<br />
about the temples, holy places, landmarks, and gods<br />
worshipped by the citizens, as well as about both<br />
mythological themes and objects of civic pride (Figs.<br />
72, 87-91). Some of the more enigmatic types include<br />
a temple surrounded by a zodiac (Fig. 92), a human<br />
foot (Fig. 93), a sacred tree, and mysterious deities. All<br />
together, some 50 coin types are known today, and<br />
unknown varieties still turn up with some regularity;<br />
some were popular for many years during that period,<br />
and others ephemeral. The coins are not dated, but<br />
can be placed in the reign of the emperor whose<br />
portrait appears on the obverse. During some reigns,<br />
especially that of Elagabal (218-222 CE), the number<br />
of types increased dramatically.<br />
Akko was one of hundreds of cities in the Roman<br />
provinces that minted civic coins. In the mid 3rd century<br />
CE, however, inflation reached such proportions<br />
that local minting became too expensive and cities<br />
gradually stopped producing their own coins. The last<br />
city coins were struck under Gallienus (253-268 CE),<br />
and Akko has the distinction that it was the very last.<br />
The Early Islamic Period<br />
No coins were minted in Akko during the Byzantine<br />
period. Following a ’dry period’ of about 450 years, a<br />
small number of bronze coins were minted in the city<br />
under the Umayyad dynasty about the year 700, when<br />
Akko was called Akka and considered of secondary<br />
importance in the Urdunn (Jordan) district. The coins<br />
are not dated, but the mint name عكا appears clearly<br />
(Fig. 94).<br />
Fig. 86: Bronze colonial issue under Nero (54-68 CE).<br />
Obverse: Laureate head of Nero r. In front star and crescent. Around:<br />
IMP NER[∙∙∙ Reverse: ‘Founder’ ploughing with a cow and an ox.<br />
Behind: the vexilla of four Roman legions (illegible). Around: DIVOS<br />
CLA[∙∙∙ Between the vexilla: COL CL.<br />
(Photo courtesy of Classical Numismatics Group Inc.)<br />
Fig. 87: Bronze colonial issue under Trajan (98-117 CE).<br />
Obverse: Laureate head of Trajan r. Around: IMP CAES NER TRAIANO<br />
OPT AVG GERM[∙∙∙ Reverse: Tyche, with turreted crown, sitting on a<br />
pile of rocks, holding a branch. At her feet, the river-god Belus reaches<br />
out. COL PTOL. (Photo courtesy of Classical Numismatics Group Inc.)<br />
Fig. 88: Bronze colonial issue under Septimius Severus (193-211<br />
CE). Obverse: Laureate and draped bust of Septimius Severus. The<br />
inscription is illegible. Reverse: Winged Thunderbolt. Above and<br />
below, COL PTOL (Photo courtesy of Classical Numismatics Group Inc.)<br />
Fig. 89: Bronze colonial issue for Iulia Maesa, sister-in-law of Septimius<br />
Severus (165-224 CE), minted between 218-222 CE.<br />
Obverse: Draped bust of Iulia Maesa r. Around: IVLIA MAESA AVGV<br />
(M in Maesa inverted). Reverse: Portable shrine containing a statue<br />
of Zeus Heliopolites. Around: COLO PTLOE.<br />
(Photo courtesy of LHS Numismatik)<br />
Danny Syon 71*
Fig. 90: Bronze colonial issue for Aquilia Severa, wife of Elagabalus<br />
(minted c. 220-221 CE). Obverse: Draped bust of Aquilia Severa<br />
r. Around: IVL AQVILIA SEVERA AV. Reverse: A complex portable<br />
shrine consisting of a tetrastyle temple over a hexastyle structure. In<br />
the central arch a statue of Tyche to left, crowned by a figure of Nike<br />
on a column behind her; to left, statue of Perseus holding the head<br />
of Medusa; to right, statue of Athena; below, hexastyle portico with<br />
a central arch occupied by a statue of Zeus and with other statues.<br />
The portico rests on a series of semi-circular arches. Probably unique.<br />
(Photo courtesy of LHS Numismatik)<br />
Fig. 91: Bronze colonial issue under Valerian (253-260 CE).<br />
Obverse: Laureate bust right, shoulder covered by round shield.<br />
Around: IMP CP LIC [VALERIANVS AVG]. Reverse: Hexastyle<br />
temple. Within central arch, Tyche to left, crowned by Nike; below,<br />
reclining river god Belus. Around: COL PTOL.<br />
(Photo courtesy Goldberg Coins)<br />
Fig. 92: Bronze colonial issue under Valerian (253-260 CE). Obverse:<br />
Radiate, draped and cuirassed bust of Valerian right. Around: [IMP<br />
CP] LIC VALERIANVS AVG. Reverse: Zodiac with Zeus-Heliopolites<br />
standing in central temple. On both sides of the temple: COL PTOL.<br />
(Photo courtesy Goldberg Coins)<br />
Fig. 93: Bronze colonial issue for Salonina, wife of Gallienus (minted<br />
c. 254-268 CE). Obverse: Bust of Salonina r. Around: CORNEL<br />
SA[LONINA AVG]. Reverse: Human foot, on top thunderbolt; at<br />
right, caduceus. Around: COL PTOL.<br />
(Photo courtesy of David Hendin)<br />
Fig. 94: Anonymous Umayyad bronze fals, c. 700 CE.<br />
Obverse: ال اله \ اال اهلل \ وحده (There is no god except Allah alone).<br />
Reverse: In center: محمد \ رسول \ اهلل (Mohammed is the messenger<br />
of Allah.) Around: بسماهلل ضرب هذا الفلس بعكا (In the name of Allah,<br />
this fals was struck in ‘Akka). (Oriental Coin Cabinet of the Friedrich-<br />
Schiller-University, Jena, Inv. No. OMJ-310-A06)<br />
Fig. 95: ‘Abbasid period cast bronze fals, issued by Ibrahim ibn<br />
.ال اله \اال اهلل وحده \ ال شريك له center: Humrān, 816 CE. Obverse: In<br />
Around: ضرب هذا الفلس بعكا سنة ماتنى (Struck in ‘Akka, year (200<br />
مما امر به االمير ابرهيم Around: محمد \رسول \ اهلل center: Reverse: In<br />
ān). (By the authority of the Emir Ibrahim ibn Humr بن حمران<br />
(Tübingen University Collection, Inv. No. AL2F5)<br />
Fig. 96: Fatimid gold dinar under Caliph al-Mustansir b'Illah, 1036<br />
CE. Obverse: In center and around: religious passages from the<br />
معد \ عبد اهلل وولىه \ االمام ابو متىم \ املستنصر center: Qoran. Reverse: In<br />
abu- (the servant of god and his companions, the Imam باهلل \ عال<br />
Tamim al-Mustansir b'Illah). Around: In the name of Allah, this<br />
dinar was struck at ‘Akka, year seven and eighty and four hundred.<br />
(Tübingen University Collection, Inv. No. CA9D2)<br />
Fig. 97: Crusader gold bezant, imitation of a Fatimid dinar of al-<br />
Amir, 12th or 13th century. The inscriptions are mostly faulty or plain<br />
gibberish. (Oriental Coin Cabinet of the Friedrich-Schiller-University,<br />
Jena, Inv. No. SB0174)<br />
72* Danny Syon
Minting under the Abbasids (750-c. 950 CE) was<br />
very brief. It apparently consisted of a single bronze<br />
emission under a local administrator who is otherwise<br />
unknown, Ibrahim ibn Humrān, in 816 CE (Fig. 95).<br />
Fig. 98: Crusader silver, imitation of an Ayyubid dirham, 1251 CE.<br />
Obverse: Cross in circle. Center: The Father and the Son. Around<br />
(partly illegible): His is the glory forever, Amen. Reverse: Center:<br />
and the Holy Ghost (In center, small Fleur de-lys). Around: One<br />
Divinity. His is the glory forever, Amen. (Photo courtesy of the IAA)<br />
Fig. 99: Crusader gold bezant with Christian legend in Arabic script,<br />
1251-1258 CE. Obverse: Center: One God. Inner circle: + The<br />
Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost. Outer circle (partly illegible):<br />
Struck in ‘Akka, in the year one thousand two hundred one and fifty<br />
of the incarnation of the Messiah. Reverse: Center: Cross. Around<br />
(begins in outer, continues in inner circle: We are glorified by the<br />
Cross of our Lord Jesus the Messiah from whom we receive our<br />
salvation and life. (Akko Municipal Museum Collection)<br />
Fig. 100: Copper pougeoise of Henry of Champagne, struck<br />
c. 1192-1197 CE. Obverse: Cross patteé. Around: +COm‰S<br />
H‰NRICVS. Reverse: Lily. Around: +PVG‰S D'ACCON.<br />
(Tübingen University Collection, Inv. No. LI-117)<br />
Under the Fatimids (950-1099 CE), gold dinars<br />
(Fig. 96) and silver dirhams were minted in Akko under<br />
the Imam al-Mustansir (1036-1094 CE).<br />
The Crusader Period<br />
The last burst of activity in the mint of Akko came during<br />
the Crusader period. The Crusaders encountered in<br />
the Holy Land a monetary system that was unknown<br />
in Europe, and so they adapted to it by imitating<br />
Fatimid gold dinars (called bezants by the Crusaders<br />
and of a lower weight) of the imam al-Amir in Akko<br />
(Fig. 97) and Ayyubid silver dirhams, both of which<br />
were anachronistic by the time they were imitated. At<br />
first, the imitations were faithful to the original; then in<br />
1250, Pope Innocent IV banned the use by Christians<br />
of the Moslem creed and date. In an ingenious move,<br />
the legends were replaced with Christian slogans<br />
and dates, still in Arabic, and crosses were added<br />
(Figs. 98-99). On some, as a result, the legends are<br />
illegible gibberish. Most of these imitations were struck<br />
in Akko, though on many the name of Damascus<br />
appears as the mint. Some scholars speculate that a<br />
very common billon denier of Aimery de Lusignan, King<br />
of Jerusalem (1163-1174), was minted posthumously<br />
in Akko in the 13th century. In fact, only a single<br />
issue of a bronze pougeoise minted from 1192-1197<br />
carries the name of the city (<strong>Acco</strong>n) in Latin letters<br />
(Fig. 100).<br />
One monetary problem that faced the Crusaders<br />
was the lack of small change. In compensation, large<br />
quantities of poorly made lead tokens without legends<br />
were minted, apparently by private initiative. Struck in<br />
a bewildering variety of types probably until the end<br />
of Crusader rule in 1291 CE, these were the very last<br />
’coins’ to be minted in Akko.<br />
Danny Syon 73*
Fig. 101: The Old City of Akko – from the top of the Ottoman wall’s Land Gate, view to the west. (Photo: A. Efremov)<br />
74* Anastasia Shapiro
Ottoman Period Tobacco Smoking Pipes<br />
and Nargile Heads from Excavations<br />
in the Old City of Akko<br />
Anastasia Shapiro Israel Antiquities Authority<br />
Archaeological documentation and recognition of Akko’s Ottoman period heritage have increased in parallel in<br />
recent years (Fig. 101). Recent excavations in the Old City of Akko conducted by the Israel Antiquities Authority<br />
have unearthed a great variety of both locally produced and imported Ottoman clay smoking pipes and nargile<br />
heads. These implements represent the popularity of tobacco smoking in Akko and throughout the Ottoman<br />
Empire from the end of the 16th/beginning of the 17th centuries (Baram 1996), when Sultan Murad II began<br />
cultivating tobacco as a novelty and a medicine. Following its introduction, pipe smoking rapidly took hold. By the<br />
mid 17th century, tobacco joined coffee, wine, and opium as one of the four "cushions on the sofa of pleasure"<br />
(Peçevî 1969). Pipe smoking increased throughout the 18th and 19th centuries. With the appearance of cigars<br />
and cigarettes as smoking items and briar as a stronger alternative material for the pipe bowl in the late 1920s,<br />
the production of clay pipes began to decline (Borio 2005).<br />
Clay smoking pipes, characteristic of the<br />
Mediterranean area during the Ottoman<br />
period, are part of the smoking set<br />
(Fig. 102), which included a mouthpiece,<br />
a long stem, and a clay bowl with a short<br />
shank (stem-socket) at its lower part,<br />
called chibouk or lüle in Turkish. The<br />
length of the stem varied from less than<br />
one meter for travelers to four meters for<br />
households (Simpson 1991). One end of<br />
the stem was inserted into the shank of<br />
the chibouk, and the other was placed<br />
in the mouthpiece (imame in Turkish).<br />
The chibouk was made of any of a great<br />
variety of materials; however, the most<br />
commonly used material was clay. Being<br />
both fragile and the most inexpensive<br />
part of the smoking set, clay chibouks<br />
were frequently found in Ottoman strata.<br />
They usually are referred to as "pipes"<br />
(this term will be used in the current<br />
paper), and many were made with a<br />
great deal of artistry (Fig. 103).<br />
Fig. 102: Smoker – "Habitant de Thessalie".<br />
(From: Stakelberg 1825)<br />
Anastasia Shapiro 75*
Fig. 103: Local (left) and imported (right) 19th century pipes from<br />
Akko excavations. (Photo: H. Smithline, IAA)<br />
Fig. 104: Early pipes from Akko excavations. (Photo: H. Smithline, IAA)<br />
Fig. 105: Imported gray clay pipes from Akko excavations.<br />
(Photo: H. Smithline, IAA)<br />
Fig. 106: Yellow, glazed, locally made pipes from Akko excavations.<br />
(Photo: H. Smithline, IAA)<br />
The chibouk was normally formed in stone or iron<br />
molds that consisted of two halves. The shank borehole<br />
and the inside of the bowl were carved out when the<br />
clay was “leather-hard.” The stem was usually pierced<br />
with a pointed tool inserted at the shank end; as a<br />
result, a tongue of clay usually lapped the inside of<br />
the bowl and was not removed on purpose. It served<br />
to prevent corking of the borehole by tobacco<br />
fragments. At the same stage of "leather-hard" clay,<br />
the pipe was decorated, and the size and quality of the<br />
decorations suggest tools similar to those employed<br />
by silversmiths or goldsmiths. Decorative techniques<br />
vary. Carved, roulette, or stamped designs appear<br />
on pipes, either together or separately. Some pipes<br />
were slipped, burnished, and then fired. Workshops<br />
that manufactured such pipes are known in Turkey,<br />
Sofia and Varna in Bulgaria, Cyprus, Malta, Greece,<br />
France, Egypt, Israel, and Russia. Manufacturing guilds<br />
regulated the main production centers (Simpson 2002).<br />
At the same time, each city or even large village could<br />
have its own pipe-maker. Large workshops usually<br />
had their own style. Smaller manufacturers would do<br />
their best to copy or imitate some of the better-known<br />
styles (Volkov and Novikova 1996).<br />
Bowl shapes and decorations vary significantly through<br />
the centuries as does as the length of the shank and<br />
the inner diameter of boreholes. The most popular<br />
bowl shape is globular, with a straight cylindrical rim;<br />
the correlation between the sizes of the globular and<br />
cylindrical sections can differ. Other shapes include<br />
simple-cylindrical, tulip-like, globular with an outflaring<br />
rim, disc-based, and lily-like forms, to mention<br />
a few. Bowl sizes – i.e., capacity – depend in reverse<br />
proportion to tobacco availability (i.e. lowering<br />
of its price), which increased through the ages of<br />
the "smoking era" (Baram 1996). Shank borehole<br />
opening diameters also increase in size with changes<br />
in decorative motifs over time. The earliest pipes<br />
are uniquely decorated, with very few parallels or<br />
similarities. Later pipes are mass produced, apparently<br />
76* Anastasia Shapiro
Fig. 107: Locally made plum-color slipped pipes from Akko excavations and sample of a pipemaker's stamp. (Photo: H. Smithline, IAA)<br />
to meet market demand, resulting in more uniform decorations for each workshop. During the final decades of<br />
the existence of clay pipes (i.e., beginning of the 20th century), decorative motifs are increasingly grotesque and<br />
crude or are absent.<br />
Clay Pipes from Akko<br />
Because of Akko’s cosmopolitan character and role as one of the major port cities of the Mediterranean during<br />
the Ottoman period, the clay pipe assemblage from this area consists of a very wide repertoire of shapes and<br />
fabrics: local pipes, manufactured in large numbers; home-made pipes of both local and imported varieties; and<br />
high-quality imported pipes, either traded in quantity or brought individually. The assemblage of clay pipes from<br />
Akko is especially significant because of the very large number of examples (more than two thousand complete<br />
and fragmentary pipes) from stratified contexts dating to the 17th and up to the early 20th centuries, when these<br />
pipes were in common use.<br />
The earliest examples, which date to the mid 17th century, are characterized by rather small bowls (owing<br />
to the high cost of tobacco), different clays used in their production, and a great variety of decorations<br />
Anastasia Shapiro 77*
(Fig. 104). These pipes were replaced by imported, grey, unglazed pipes (Fig. 105) and locally made, yellow, glazed<br />
pipes (Fig. 106) that date from the late 17th to the early 18th centuries. These local productions are characterized<br />
by larger bowls and more uniform decorations for each type; they were produced for both domestic sale and<br />
export. Makers’ marks were found on part of the assemblage of pipes from this period. As smoking increased in<br />
popularity in the region, local pipe production grew, as well.<br />
Locally made, grey or plum-color, clay slipped pipes (Fig. 107) dominate the Akko collection. Dating to the 19th<br />
century, they represent the mass-produced and commercial production of pipes. Some of these pipe types are<br />
uniformly decorated, and up to 90% are stamped, often with a horseshoe-shaped maker’s mark that appears on<br />
the right side of the shank.<br />
The use of clay pipes decreased sharply with the introduction of cigars and cigarettes during World War I. Two<br />
shapes – disc-based (Fig. 108) and lily (Fig. 109) – characterize the last local and imported clay pipes. Locally<br />
produced pipes continue the plum slip (Fig. 108, bottom; Fig. 109, top left). They usually do not have a maker’s<br />
mark. Some are richly decorated (Fig. 108, bottom left). Imported pipes from Turkey appear in especially large<br />
numbers. These pipes are characterized by an orange clay and orange self-slip (Fig. 108, top; Fig. 109, top right<br />
and bottom). Their decorations are shallow and fine or absent. Makers' marks, when present, are usually oval<br />
medallions with Arabic characters inside them.<br />
Fig. 108: Imported (top) and local (bottom) disc-based pipes from Akko excavations and a sample pipemaker’s stamp.<br />
(Photo: H. Smithline, IAA)<br />
78* Anastasia Shapiro
Nargile Heads<br />
The nargile or water pipe (also termed hookah, huka, or hooka) consists of four pieces: mouthpiece (agizlik),<br />
which was similar to that of the ”Turkish” pipes; tube (marpuç); bottle (gövde), which was filled with water;<br />
and top, or head (lüle), which was made of clay and is the part found in excavations (Fig. 110). Nargile smokers<br />
favored dark Iranian tobacco that had been washed several times. The nargile, invented in the early 17th century,<br />
first became popular in India, where it was used for smoking hashish and opium (Simpson 1991). The popularity<br />
of the nargile spread to Iran and from there to the rest of the Arab world. However, it was in Turkey where the<br />
water pipe’s design and tradition took hold and have since remained relatively unchanged (Fig. 110). Together<br />
with the tobacco pipes, the nargile became an integral part of coffee shop culture (Bakla 1985). Its popularity in<br />
Turkey, however, witnessed a decline during the Turkish republic (1923) as tobacco-lovers switched to cigarettes.<br />
After World War II, mainly old men continued smoking nargiles.<br />
Fig. 109: Imported and local (top left) lily-shaped pipes from Akko excavations and sample of a pipemaker’s stamp.<br />
(Photo: H. Smithline, IAA)<br />
Anastasia Shapiro 79*
Fig. 110: Modern nargile (photo: P. Shapiro) and two nargile heads<br />
from Akko excavations. (Photo: H. Smithline, IAA)<br />
A total of 63 complete or fragmentary nargile heads<br />
are present in the Akko collection. They are all moldmade,<br />
with visible mold seams. Some are made of the<br />
same clay used for pipes and, like pipes, are slipped<br />
and burnished. The most typical shape is flower-like<br />
(Fig. 110). The nargile is based on a cylindrical tube,<br />
which has a calyx-like cup at the top to receive the<br />
charcoal and a conical hollow base that fits on top of<br />
the bottle. A petal-like “skirt” (in some cases cut into<br />
separate petals) divides the tube approximately in the<br />
middle. The bottom of the cup has a strainer, which<br />
can be at “skirt” level or higher, close to the rim, that<br />
usually has five or six holes (one in the middle) and<br />
an iron pin sometimes stuck in the middle hole. The<br />
late 1990s witnessed a revival of all things Ottoman,<br />
including the nargile. Today both men and women,<br />
young and old, from all over the world, enjoy the<br />
calming vapors of the nargile, whose outlook has not<br />
changed during the past several hundred years, filling<br />
it with mix of tobacco and fruit molasses of different<br />
tastes and flavors.<br />
Acknowledgments<br />
The author is grateful to Eliezer Stern and Danny Syon (Israel Antiquities Authority), directors of the excavations<br />
at the Hospitallers Compound, Messika site, and "Knights' Hotel" parking lot in the Old City of Akko, who<br />
granted me permission to publish this material. Special thanks are due Edna J. Stern, who introduced me to Ann<br />
E. Killebrew and Vered Raz-Romeo, guest curators of the Akko Exhibit in the Hecht Museum. I would also like to<br />
express my gratitude to the following photographers: Howard Smithline (IAA) for photographing the collection<br />
of pipes and nargile heads; Alexander Efremov, chief editor of Photo-Travel, for generously providing Figure 101;<br />
and Peter Shapiro, my husband, for photographing the modern nargile for Figure 110. I am indebted to Ester<br />
Tal-Schwarz (secretary of the Western Galilee District, Israel Antiquities Authority) and Hanaa Abu-Uqsa (Akko<br />
inspector, Israel Antiquities Authority) for translating and editing my Hebrew abstract.<br />
80* Anastasia Shapiro
Underwater Excavations at Akko *<br />
Deborah Cvikel and Ya'acov Kahanov University of Haifa<br />
Three seasons (2006-2008) of underwater excavations in Akko harbor were conducted by the Leon Recanati<br />
Institute for Maritime Studies at the University of Haifa. Three sites were excavated simultaneously: the Akko 1<br />
and the Akko 2 shipwrecks and the submerged rampart that connects the Tower of Flies to the shore.<br />
The city of Akko (Acre, St. Jean d'Acre) is located at the northern extremity of Haifa Bay in the north of Israel.<br />
Serving as an important Mediterranean naval and trading port, it is one of the most ancient cities of the land,<br />
with over 4,000 years of history from the Early Bronze Age to the modern era.<br />
The Ottomans conquered Akko and its harbor in 1516. During the late Ottoman period, specifically between the<br />
mid 18th and the mid 19th centuries, Akko had a key role in important maritime events that took place in the<br />
Eastern Mediterranean, such as Napoleon Bonaparte and his army's siege of the town in 1799 and the combined<br />
British-Austrian-Ottoman fleet that conquered the city in 1840. These events, among others, brought ships of<br />
various types, rates, and classes from various fleets, Western European and Eastern Mediterranean, to Akko.<br />
The Akko 1 Shipwreck<br />
It is believed that the Akko 1 shipwreck was one of the ships that plied the Levant waters in those events. The<br />
wreck site is inside Akko harbor, 70 m north of the Tower of Flies, at a maximum depth of 4 m. The shipwreck<br />
remains are 23 m long from bow to stern, and 4.5 m from the keel to the turn of the bilge. Only the very lowest<br />
section of the port side of the hull survived. The remains include the keel and false keel, bow timbers, hull planks,<br />
framing timbers, ceiling planks, and a variety of artifacts.<br />
Based on the construction of the Akko 1 shipwreck and its artifacts, it seems that the ship was a small warship,<br />
about 26 m in length, with a beam of about 7 m, and a draught of 3.4 m. The ship was built of Eastern<br />
Mediterranean wood species. Its construction, which is not of Western Mediterranean tradition, together with<br />
the historical context, points to the assumption that the ship was an Eastern Mediterranean brig. Dating of the<br />
shipwreck was based on the finds and 14 C combined with dendrochronological analysis; the results suggest that<br />
the ship took part in the 1831 or 1840 naval campaign for Akko.<br />
The Submerged Rampart<br />
The submerged rampart, which connects the Tower of Flies and the shore, was excavated for three seasons.<br />
Several segments of the rampart were excavated in order to uncover the geological and geomorphological<br />
surroundings and to study its historical aspect. The depth over the rampart was 0.6-1.5 m, and it was excavated<br />
down to 5 m. A well-defined structure of sediment layers was discovered, starting with all kinds of large stones<br />
mixed with packed sand above and fine sand with small stones (limestone, schist, pebbles, and kurkar) at the<br />
bottom of the trench. At all depths, there were archaeological finds, such as pottery, organic materials, and metal<br />
finds (cannonballs and nails). High-pressure water-jetting at the bottom of the trench showed that there is no<br />
solid foundation to the structure, so it is probably based on sand.<br />
Based on the results of the underwater excavations and historical charts, it is suggested that the rampart was<br />
constructed during the Islamic period, and since then had sunk about 2 m.<br />
Deborah Cvikel and Ya'acov Kahanov 81*
Fig. 111: View of the Akko 2 shipwreck. (Photo: P. Faiferman)<br />
The Akko 2 Shipwreck<br />
Akko 2 shipwreck was discovered in September 2006, 50 m to the north of the Akko 1 shipwreck, in a water<br />
depth of 3 m, and was buried under about 1 m of sand, small shell remains, and stones. The wood remains<br />
spread over an area of 12 by 3 m. The southern part of the shipwreck was damaged by Teredo navalis, but most<br />
of the timbers were in a good state of preservation, allowing measurements and analyses. The finds, were found<br />
while removing sand and stones, included decorated clay tobacco pipes, a cannonball, small lead shots, metal<br />
objects, and fragments of ceramics.<br />
It is suggested that the Akko 2 shipwreck is the remains of a medium-sized flat-bottomed vessel approximately<br />
16 m long, that may have served as a lighter in the harbor of Akko or as a small coaster trading along the Levant<br />
coast during the 17th century.<br />
* Abstract of the Hebrew article (pp. 70-73).<br />
82* Deborah Cvikel and Ya'acov Kahanov
Bibliography<br />
Abu ‘Uqsa, H. (2004). A Selection of Arabic Sources on Akko. In: A.E. Killebrew (ed.), Shared Heritage of Akko, Preliminary Draft Report, Vol. I,<br />
Recognizing and Preserving the Common Heritage of Israel and the Palestinian National Authority, n.p.: 72-85.<br />
(2009). Tel ‘Akko, Final Report, Hadashot Arkheologiyot 121 [IAA website].<br />
Al-Muqaddasi, Muhammad ibn Ahmad (1886). Description of Syria, including Palestine, trans. G. Le Strange, London.<br />
Amiran, R. (1951). Excavation in the Government Quarter in ‘Akko, Bulletin of the Department of Antiquities of the State of Israel 3: 37 [Hebrew].<br />
Anderson, M.S. (1966). The Eastern Question 1774-1923, A Study in International Relations, London.<br />
Applebaum, S. (1986). Excavations of the New Post Office Site in ‘Akko. In: M. Yedaya (ed.), The Western Galilee Antiquities: 261-265 [Hebrew].<br />
(1989). The Roman Colony of Ptolemais-‘Ake and Its Territory, Judaea in Hellenistic and Roman Times, Studies in Judaism in Late Antiquity<br />
40: 72, 94-95.<br />
Artzy, M. (2003). Mariners and Their Boats at the End of the Late Bronze and the Beginning of the Iron Age Eastern Mediterranean at Tel Akko,<br />
Tel Aviv 30: 232-246.<br />
(2006a). “Filling in” the Void, Observations on the Habitation Pattern in Tel Akko at the End of the Late Bronze Age. In: A.M. Maeir and P.<br />
de Miroschedji (eds.),“I Will Speak the Riddles of Ancient Times”: Archaeological and Historical Studies in Honor of Amihai Mazar on the Occasion<br />
of His Sixtieth Birthday I: 115-123.<br />
(2006b). The Carmel Coast during the 2nd Part of the Late Bronze Age, A Center for Eastern Mediterranean Transshipping, Bulletin of the<br />
American Schools of Oriental Research 343: 45-64.<br />
Atrash, W., Abu-Uqsa, H., Halabi Abu Yusef, H., and Scham, S. (in press). The Muslims of Akko. In: A.E. Killebrew, S.A. Scham, and M. Weinstein-<br />
Evron, (eds.), Akko, Past and Present, Oxford.<br />
Audin, A. (1960). Inhumation et incinération, Latomus 19: 312-22, 518-532.<br />
Avi-Yonah, M. (1946). Newly-Discovered Latin and Greek Inscriptions, The Quarterly of the Department of Antiquities in Palastine 12: 84-102.<br />
Avissar, M. and Stern, E.J. (2005). Pottery of the Crusader, Ayyubid, and Mamluk Periods in Israel (IAA Reports 26), Jerusalem.<br />
Avshalom-Gorni, D. (1997). ‘Akko, The Court Parking Lot, Hadashot Arkheologiyot 107: 17-21 [Hebrew].<br />
Bakla, E. (1985). A Long-Forgotten Popular Handcraft: Clay Pipe Making, Antika 5: 12-17.<br />
Balter, M. (2002). Archaeologists Keep Joint Project Rolling. Science 297: 315-316.<br />
Baram, U. (1996). Material Culture, Commodities, and Consumption in Palestine, 1500-1900. Ph.D. dissertation submitted at the University of<br />
Massachusetts at Amherst.<br />
Bayliss, M. (1973). The Cult of Dead Kin in Assyria and Babylonia, Iraq 35: 115-125.<br />
Beeri, R. (2003). The Middle and Late Bronze Age Tombs at Tel Akko, Unpublished Master’s thesis, University of Haifa [Hebrew].<br />
(2004). A Collection of Historical Sources on Akko from the Middle Bronze Age until the Arab Conquest. In: A.E. Killebrew (ed.), Shared<br />
Heritage of Akko, Preliminary Draft Report, Vol. I, Recognizing and Preserving the Common Heritage of Israel and the Palestinian National<br />
Authority, n.p.: 1-71.<br />
(2008). Tel Akko and the Urbanization of the Plain of Akko in the First Half of the Second Millennium BCE. Ph.D. diss., University of Haifa<br />
[Hebrew].<br />
Beeri, R., Raz-Romeo, V., Zagorski, S., and Scham, S. (in press). The Christians of Akko. In: A.E. Killebrew, S.A. Scham, and M. Weinstein-Evron,<br />
(eds.), Akko, Past and Present, Oxford.<br />
Bietak, M. (1968). Vorläufiger Bericht über die erste und zweite Kampagne der Österreichishen Ausgrabungen auf Tell El-Dab'a im Ostdelta<br />
Ägyptens (1966, 1967), Mitteilungen des Deutschen Archäologischen Instituts, Abteilung Kairo 23: 79-114.<br />
Blamangin, O. (1996). Thérouanne, "le bois Robichet," Un dépô rituel des premières décennies du Ve siècle. In: H. Barbé and Y. Bourrel (eds.),<br />
Du terrain au musée... 1993-1996, Trois années de recherches archéologiques dans l'Audomarois, Musée de l'hôtel Sandelin, Saint-Omer: 54-64.<br />
83*
Boas, A.J. (1997). A Rediscovered Market Street in Frankish Acre?, ‘Atiqot 31: 181-186.<br />
Borio, G. (2005). The Tobacco Timeline.<br />
Cassuto, U. (1965). The Goddess Anath, Canaanite Epics of the Patriarchal Age, Jerusalem.<br />
Dalley, S. (1984). Mari and Karana, Two Old Babylonian Cities, London.<br />
Dothan, M. (1976). Akko, Interim Excavation Report, First Season 1973/74, Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research 224: 1-48.<br />
(1985). A Phoenician Inscription from ‘Akko, Israel Exploration Journal 35: 81-94.<br />
(1990). An Infant Jar Burial from Tel Akko, Eretz Israel 21: 148-151 [Hebrew].<br />
(1993). <strong>Acco</strong>, The Excavations in the Modern City. In: E. Stern (ed.), The New Encyclopedia of Archaeological Excavations in the Holy Land<br />
1: 23-24.<br />
Dothan, M. and Raban, A. (1980). The Sea Gate of Ancient Akko, Biblical Archaeologist 43: 35-39.<br />
Dotson, J.E. (1982). A Problem of Cotton and Lead in Medieval Italian Shipping, Speculum 57: 52-62.<br />
Druks, A. (1984). Akko Fortification [Hebrew], Hadashot Arkheologiyot 3: 2-4.<br />
Eck, W. and Tepper, Y. (2005). Ein Soldat der Legio VII Claudia in einer Grabinschrift aus <strong>Acco</strong>/Ptolemais. Scripta classica israelica XXIV: 119-123.<br />
Eisenberg, M. (1999). Remains of the the Crusader's Fortification Wall in Acre (Kaplan St., Acre), unpublished report [Hebrew].<br />
Finkielsztejn, G. (2007). ‘Akko, Remez Street, Hadashot Arkheologiyot 117 [IAA website].<br />
Flinder, A. (1985). Secrets of the Bible Seas, An Underwater Archaeologist in the Holy Land, London.<br />
Flinder, A., Linder, E. and Hall, E.T. (1966). Survey of the Ancient Harbour of Akko 1964-1966. In: M. Heltzer, A. Segal and D. Kaufman (eds.),<br />
Studies in the Archaeology and History of Ancient Israel: 199-225.<br />
Folda, J. (1976). Crusader Manuscript Illumination at Saint-Jean d’Acre, 1275-1291, Princeton.<br />
(2005), Crusader Art in the Holy Land, from the Third Crusade to the Fall of Acre, 1187-1291, Cambridge.<br />
Fortuna, M.T. (1966). Campagne di scavo ad Akko, 1961-1962, Milano.<br />
Galili, E. and Rosen, B. (2008). <strong>Acco</strong>, The Harbor. In: E. Stern (ed.), The New Encyclopedia of Archaeological Excavations in the Holy Land 5:<br />
1558-1561.<br />
Goldman, Z. (1993). <strong>Acco</strong>, The Excavations in the Modern City. In: E. Stern (ed.), The New Encyclopedia of Archaeological Excavations in the<br />
Holy Land 1: 24-27.<br />
Goodchild, R.G. (1949). The Coast Road of Phoenicia and its Roman Milestones, Berytus 9: 91-127.<br />
Hadas, M. (1973). Aristeas to Philocrates (Letter of Aristeas), New York.<br />
Hartal, M. (1997). Excavations of the Courthouse Site at ‘Akko, The Architecture and Stratigraphy in Area TA, ‘Atiqot 31: 3-30.<br />
Hornung, E. (1995). Ancient Egyptian Religious Iconography. In: J. Sasson (ed.), Civilizations of the Ancient Near East III: 1711-1730.<br />
Horwitz, L.K. (1999). The Contribution of Archaeozoology to the Identification of Ritual Sites. In: S. Pike and S. Gitin (eds.), The Practical Impact<br />
of Science on Near Eastern and Aegean Archaeology: 63-69.<br />
Ilan, D. (1991). Mortuary Practices at Tel Dan in the Middle Bronze Age, Material Culture, Society and Ideology, Master’s thesis, The Hebrew<br />
University, Jerusalem [Hebrew].<br />
(1995). The Dawn of Internationalism – The Middle Bronze Age. In: T. Levy (ed.), The Archaeology of Society in the Holy Land: 297-319.<br />
(1996). The Middle Bronze Age Tombs. In: A. Biran, D. Ilan, and R. Greenberg (eds.), Dan I, A Chronicle of the Excavations, the Pottery<br />
Neolithic, the Early Bronze Age and the Middle Bronze Age Tombs: 161-329.<br />
Inbar, M. and Sivan, D. (1984). Paleo-Urban Development and Late Quaternary Environmental Change in the Akko Area, Paléorient 9: 85-91.<br />
Irion P.E. (1968). Cremation, Philadelphia.<br />
Isaac, B. (1992). The Limits of Empire, The Roman Army in the East (rev. ed.), Oxford.<br />
Jacoby, D. (1986). A Venetian Manual of Commercial Practice from Crusader Acre. In: G. Airaldi and B. Z. Kedar (eds.), I comuni Italiani nel<br />
regnocrociato di Gerusalemme, Atti del colloquio di Gerusalemme, 24-28 maggio 1984: 401-428.<br />
84*
(1993). Three Notes on Crusader Acre, Zeitschrift des Deutschen Palästina-Vereins 109: 83-96.<br />
(1998). The Trade of Crusader Acre in the Levantine Context, An Overview, Archivio Storico del Sannio 1-2: 103-120.<br />
Kashtan, N. (1988). Akko-Ptolemais, A Maritime Metropolis in Hellenistic and Early Roman Times, 332 BCE-70 CE, as Seen through the Literary<br />
Sources. In: I. Malkin and R.L. Hohlfelder (eds.), Mediterranean Cities, Historical Perspectives: 37-53.<br />
Kedar, B.Z. (1997). The Outer Walls of Frankish Acre, ‘Atiqot 31: 157-180.<br />
Kedar, B.Z. and Stern, E. (1995). A Vaulted East-West Street in Acre’s Genoese Quarter?, ‘Atiqot 26: 105-111.<br />
Kempinski, A. (1993). Megiddo, A City-State and Royal Center in North Israel, Tel Aviv.<br />
Kesten, A. (1962). Acre, The Old City, Survey and Planning, Tel Aviv.<br />
Killebrew, A.E., (ed.) (2004). Shared Heritage of Akko, Preliminary Draft Report, Vol. I, Recognizing and Preserving the Common Heritage of Israel<br />
and the Palestinian National Authority, n.p.<br />
Killebrew, A.E., Scham, S.A., Abu-Uqsa, H., Atrash, W., Beeri, R., Hachlili, R., Halabi Abu Yusef, H., Nagar-Hillman, O., Raz-Romeo, V., and<br />
Weinstein-Evron, M. (2006). From Dialogue to Polylogue, Exploring the Israeli and Palestinian Past in the Present. Archaeologies 2/2: 7-23.<br />
Killebrew, A.E., Scham, S.A. and Weinstein-Evron, M., (eds.) (in press). Akko, Past and Present, Oxford.<br />
Kolska-Horwitz, L. (2002). Archaeozoological Remains, Animal Bones. In: A. Kempinski, N. Sheftelowitz, and R. Oren (eds.), Tel Kabri – The 1986-<br />
1993 Excavation Seasons: 395-401.<br />
Lernau, O. (2002). Fish Bones. In: A. Kempinski, N. Sheftelowitz, and R. Oren (eds.), Tel Kabri – The 1986-1993 Excavation Seasons: 409-427.<br />
Loewenstamm, S.E. (1962). Mot. In: Encyclopaedia Biblica IV, Jerusalem: 753-763 [Hebrew].<br />
Malloy, A., Fraley-Preston, I., and Seltman, A.J. (1994). Coins of the Crusader States, including the Kingdom of Jerusalem and Its Vassal States of<br />
Syria and Palestine, the Lusignan Kingdom of Cyprus (1192-1489), and the Latin Empire of Constantinople and Its Vassal States of Greece and<br />
the Archipelago, New York.<br />
Marchesi, H. and Vallauri, L. (1997). Structuration et évolution du quartier. In: H. Marchesi, J. Thiriot, and L. Vallauri (eds.), Marseille, les ateliers<br />
de potiers du XIIIe s. et le quartier Sainte-Barbe (Ve-XVIIe s.): 19-108.<br />
Mariti, G. (1769). Viaggi per l’isola di Cipro e per la Soria e Palestina, n.p.<br />
Marriott, J.A.R. (1969). The Eastern Question, An Historical Study in European Diplomacy, London.<br />
Matthiae, P. (1981). Ebla, an Empire Rediscovered, New York.<br />
McGrail, S. (1989). The Shipment of Traded Goods and Ballast in Antiquity, Oxford Journal of Archaeology 8: 353-358.<br />
Meshorer, Y. (1985). City-Coins of Eretz-Israel and the Decapolis in the Roman Period, Jerusalem.<br />
Millar, F. (1990). The Roman Coloniae of the Near East, A Study of Cultural Relations. In: H. Solin and M. Kajava (eds.), Roman Eastern Policy and<br />
Other Studies in Roman History, Proceedings of a Colloquium at Tvärminne 2-3 October 1983: 7-58.<br />
Mizrachi, Y. (2005). Egyptian Foreign Policy in the Levant during the Reign of Thutmosis III – Continuity or Change, Ph.D. dissertation submitted<br />
at the University of Haifa [Hebrew].<br />
Mokary, A. (1995). ‘Akko, Hadashot Arkheologiyot 103: 24 [Hebrew].<br />
Nagar, Y. and Tepper, Y. (2007). Skeletal Remains of Roman Soldiers in the City of Acre. In: The 7th Roman Archaeology Conference Theoretical<br />
Roman Archaeology Conference, Abstract: 9.<br />
Oppenheimer, A. (1977). The Jewish Community in Galilee during the Period of Yavneh and the Bar-Kokhba Revolt, Cathedra 4: 51-66 [Hebrew].<br />
Parker, A.J. (1992). Cargoes, Containers, and Stowage, The Ancient Mediterranean, International Journal of Nautical Archaeology 21: 89-100.<br />
Peçevî, I. (1969). Peçevî tarihi, Vol. 2. Istanbul.<br />
Posner, G. (1940). Princes et pays d’Asie et de Nubie, Textes hiératiques sur des Figurines d’envoûtement du Moyen Empire, Brussels.<br />
Prawer, J. (1971). A History of the Latin Kingdom of Jerusalem, 3rd rev. and enl. ed., 2 vols., Jerusalem.<br />
Pringle, D. (1986). Pottery as Evidence of Trade in the Crusader States. In: G. Airaldi and B.Z. Kedar (eds.), I comuni italiani nel Regno Crociato di<br />
Gerusalemme, atti del Colloquio, "The Italian Communes in the Crusading Kingdom of Jerusalem" (Jerusalem, May 24-May 28, 1984): 451-475.<br />
(2009). The Churches of the Crusader Kingdom of Jerusalem, A Corpus, Vol. 4, The Cities of Acre and Tyre with Addenda and Corrigenda<br />
to Volumes I-III, Cambridge.<br />
85*
Raban, A. (1986). A Shipwreck from Napoleon's Siege of Akko (1799). In: M. Yedaya (ed.), The Western Galilee Antiquities, Tel-Aviv: 195-208<br />
[Hebrew].<br />
(1991). The Port City of Akko in the MBII Period, Michmanim 5: 17-34.<br />
(1995). The Heritage of Ancient <strong>Eng</strong>ineering in Cyprus and the Levant. In: V. Karageorghis and D. Michaelides (eds.), Proceedings of the<br />
International Symposium “Cyprus and the Sea,” Nicosia, 25-26 September 1993: 139-189.<br />
Rahmani, L.Y. (1993). A Note on Charon's Obol, ‘Atiqot 22: 149-150.<br />
Rappaport, U. (1970). When Was the Letter of Aristas Written? In: E. Gilboa, B. Mevurach, U. Rappaport, and A. Schochat (eds.), Studies in the<br />
History of the Jewish People and the Land of Israel in Memory of Zvi Avneri I: 37-50 [Hebrew].<br />
Raven, M.J. (1982). Corn-Mummies. Oudheidkundige Mededelingen uit het Rijksmuseum van Oudheden te Leiden 63: 7-38.<br />
Raz-Romeo, V. (2004). A Selection of Crusader Sources on Akko. In: A.E. Killebrew (ed.), Shared Heritage of Akko, Preliminary Draft Report,<br />
Vol. I, Recognizing and Preserving the Common Heritage of Israel and the Palestinian National Authority, n.p.: 86-102.<br />
Redford, D.B. (1990). Egypt and Canaan in the New Kingdom, Beer-Sheva.<br />
Riley-Smith, J. (1999) Hospitallers, The History of the Order of St. John, London.<br />
Rin, S. and Rin, S. (1996). Acts of Gods, The Ugaritic Epic Poetry, Philadelphia.<br />
Ruhe, D.S. (1983). Door of Hope, A Century of the Baha'i Faith in the Holy Land, Oxford.<br />
Saccardo, F. (1998). Venezia, Le importazioni ceramiche tra XII e XIII secolo. In: S. Gelichi (ed.), Ceramiche cittá e commerci nell-Italia Tardo-<br />
Medievale. Ravello, 3-4 maggio 1993: 49-73.<br />
Scham, S.A. (in press). The Jews of Akko. In: A.E. Killebrew, S. Scham, and M. Weinstein-Evron (eds.), Akko: Past and Present.<br />
Schoske, S. (1992). “Anch,” Blumen für das Leben, Pflanzen im alten Ägypten, Munich.<br />
Schur, N. (1990). A History of Akko, Tel Aviv [Hebrew].<br />
Shahar, Y. (2005). Belus River, Memnon’s Monument and the Glass Sand Near ‘Akko, Galilee Studies, Israel Antiquities Authority and University<br />
of Haifa [Hebrew].<br />
Simpson, St.J. (1991). Smoking in Central Asia, Society for Pipe Research Newsletter 32: 16-22.<br />
(2002). Ottoman Pipes from Zir‘in (Tell Jezreel), Levant 34: 159-172.<br />
Sivan, D. (1981). Paleogeography of Akko Area in the Holocene Period, Master’s thesis, University of Haifa.<br />
Skiast, A. (1980). The Ancestor Cult and Succession in Mesopotamia. In: B. Alster (ed.), Death in Mesopotamia, Papers Read at the XXVIe<br />
Rencontre assyriologique internationale: 123-128.<br />
Smallwood, M.E. (1978). Palestine c. A.D. 115-118. In: D. Rokeah (ed.), Jewish Rebellions in the Time of Trajan, 115-117 CE, Jerusalem: 161-171<br />
[Hebrew].<br />
(1981). The Jews under Roman Rule, From Pompey to Diocletian, Leiden.<br />
Stackelberg, O.M.F. von. (1825). Costumes et usages des peuples de la Grèce moderne, gravés d'après les dessins exécutés sur les lieux en 1811,<br />
Rome.<br />
Steffy, J.R. (1983). The Napoleonic Wreck: A Workshop in Ship Construction, unpublished report.<br />
Stern, E. (2002). Excavations in Crusader Acre (1990-1999). In: M.C. Calò Mariani (ed.), Il cammino di Gerusalemme, Atti del II Convegno<br />
Internazionale di Studio, Bari-Brindisi-Trani 18-22 maggio 1999: 163-168.<br />
(2006). La Commanderie de l'Ordre des Hospitaliers à Acre, Bulletin Monumental 164: 53-60.<br />
Stern, E. and Syon, D. (Forthcoming). ‘Akko, the Excavations of 1991-1998 II, The Late Periods, (IAA Report), Jerusalem.<br />
Stern, E.J. (2007). Trade and Redistribution of Pottery Types in the Mediterranean During the 12th and 13th Centuries as Reflected in the<br />
Excavations of Crusader Acre, Ph.D. dissertation submitted at the University of Haifa.<br />
(in press). ‘Akko, the Excavations of 1991-1998 III: The Crusader Period Pottery (IAA Reports), Jerusalem.<br />
Stern, E.J. and Waksman, S.Y. (2003). Pottery from Crusader Acre, A Typological and Analytical Study. In: C. Bakirtzis (ed.), VIIe Congrés<br />
International sur la Céramique médiévale en Méditerranée, Thessaloniki, 11-16 Octobre 1999, actes: 167-180.<br />
86*
Syon, D. (1999). Souvenirs from the Holy Land, A Crusader Workshop of Lead Ampullae from Acre. In: Silvia Rozenberg (ed.), Knights of the Holy<br />
Land, The Crusader Kingdom of Jerusalem, Jerusalem: 110-115.<br />
(2006). The Coins from El-Kabri, ‘Atiqot 51: 125-29.<br />
Syon, D. and Tatcher, A. (1998). 'Akko, Hanyon Ha-Abirim, Hadashot Arkheologiyot 108: 17-24 [Hebrew].<br />
(2000), 'Akko, Ha-Abirim Parking Lot, Excavations and Surveys in Israel 20: 11*-16*.<br />
Tcherikover, V. (1959). Hellenistic Civilization and the Jews, Philadelphia.<br />
Tepper, Y. (2007). The Roman Legionary Camp at Legio, Israel, Results of an Archaeological Survey and Observations on the Roman Military<br />
Presence at the Site. In: A.S. Lewin and P. Pellegrini (eds.), The Late Roman Army in the Near East from Diocletian to the Arab Conquest:<br />
Proceedings of a Colloquium Held at Potenza, Acerenza, and Matera, Italy, May 2005: 57-71.<br />
(in press). Cremation from the Hellenistic Period at Beisamoun and Other Finds of Historic Periods. In: D. Rosenberg (ed.) An Early Pottery<br />
Neolithic Occurrence at Beisamoun, the Hula Valley, Northern Israel (BAR International Series), Oxford: 105-108.<br />
Tepper, Y. and Nagar, Y. (2009). The Roman Military Cemetery in Acre (Ptolemais), Israel [IAA website].<br />
Thatcher, A. (2000). Two Other Excavations in ‘Akko, ‘Atiqot 39: 27*-41* [Hebrew].<br />
Theoderich of Würzburg (1896). Theoderich’s Description of the Holy Places (ca. 1172 A.D.), Palestine Pilgrims’ Text Society 5/4, London.<br />
Toynbee J.M.C. (1971). Death and Burial in the Roman World, Ithaca.<br />
Tsafrir, Y., Di Segni, L., and Green, J. (1994). Tabula Imperii Romani Iudaea-Palaestina, Eretz Israel in the Hellenistic, Roman, and Byzantine Periods,<br />
Maps and Gazetteer, Jerusalem: 204-205.<br />
Tuffreau-Libre, M. (2001). Les assemblages céramiques dans les necropolis gallo-romaines. In: J.-F. Geoffroy and H. Barbé (eds.), Les nécropoles<br />
à incinérations en Gaule belgique, synthèses régionales et méthodologie, actes du XIXe Colloque international du Centre de Recherches<br />
Archéologiques de l'Université Charles-de-Gaulle–Lille 3, organisé les 13 et 14 décembre 1996: 179-187.<br />
Tzaferis, V. (1986). The Ancient Cemetery of ‘Akko-Ptolemais. In: M. Yedaya (ed.), The Western Galilee Antiquities, Tel-Aviv: 266-277 [Hebrew].<br />
Ubelaker, D.H. and Rife, J.L. (2007). The Practice of Cremation in the Roman-Era Cemetery at Kenchreai, Greece, The Perspective from Archeology<br />
and Forensic Science, Bioarchaeology of the Near East 1: 35-57.<br />
Volkov, I.V. and Novikova, G.L. (1996). Red-Fabric "Turkish" Smoking Pipes in the Collection of the Museum of History of Moscow, The<br />
Archaeological Relics of Moscow and Its Suburbs 9: 134-152 [Russian].<br />
Waksman, S.Y., Stern, E.J., Segal, I., Porat N., and Yellin, J. (2008). Elemental and Petrographic Analyses of Local and Imported Ceramics from<br />
Crusader Acre, ‘Atiqot 59: 157-190.<br />
Watson, G.R. (1969). The Roman Soldier, London.<br />
Ziffer, I. (1990). At That Time the Canaanites Were in the Land, Daily Life in the Middle Bronze Age 2, 2000-1500 B.C.E., Tel Aviv [Hebrew].<br />
(2006). Further Thoughts on the Cult Stele from Arad. In: E. Czerny, I. Hein, H. Hunger, D. Melman, and A. Schwab (eds.), Timelines,<br />
Studies in Honour of Manfred Bietak II: 417-426.<br />
Zviely, D., Sivan, D., Ecker, A., Bakler, N., Rohrlich, V., Galili, E., Boaretto, E., Klein, M., and Kit, E. (2006). Holocene Evolution of the Haifa Bay<br />
Area, Israel, and Its Influence on Ancient Tell Settlements, The Holocene 16: 849-861.<br />
87*