9 months ago

The Star: June 01, 2017

6 Thursday

6 Thursday June 1 2017 Latest Christchurch news at www. .kiwi The Star News Brownlee put on spot over knowledge • By David Fisher TENSION OVER the rules governing the release of Government-held information to the public have led to questions over Gerry Brownlee’s knowledge of the Official Information Act. Mr Brownlee the Minister of Foreign Affairs, told the New Zealand Herald he had experienced “frustration” over uncertainty about when information could be released to the public and when it could be properly withheld. In an effort to get more details, Mr Brownlee, the former Minister supporting Christchurch Regenertion, sent the Office of the Ombudsman an Official Information Act request. The problem? A basic principle of the OIA is that offices of Parliament – including the Office of the Ombudsman – are not covered by the legislation. Documents released to the Herald show Mr Brownlee’s request failed to result in the documents he asked for and instead led to a meeting with Chief Ombudsman Judge Peter Boshier – who he called “Mr Boshier” throughout an interview on the UNEASE: Gerry Brownlee and Chief Ombudsman Judge Peter Boshier. issue with the Herald. Herald: “It’s Judge Boshier isn’t it?” Mr Brownlee: “I don’t think so.” Herald: “He’s still a judge.” Mr Brownlee: “You can call him what you want. I don’t believe he has a warrant.” Judge Boshier – and, yes, he retains his title – would not be interviewed for this story but documents released through the Official Information Act show reflected tensions inside the Government. He wrote that after meeting Mr Brownlee he was “genuinely worried” the Government believed the rules had changed and the Office of the Ombudsman wanted “everything released”. The Official Information Act is designed to make Ministers and officials accountable, and to allow the public greater involvement in the creation and operation of laws and policies. But it has come under pressure in recent years with changes in Government structure, practice and changes in technology. As a result, a 2015 review by the Office of the Ombudsman found “ministerial officials pressured agencies to alter their responses” and mixed advice on how to respond to requests. It followed a State Services Commission survey which found just 24 per cent of public servants were familiar with the Ombudsman’s Official Information Act guidelines. And it came after criticism over the Government’s handling of OIA requests, including former Prime Minister John Key’s admission the Government deliberately delayed releasing information if it suited its purposes to do so. Mr Brownlee told the Herald: “Of course I know the Office [of the Ombudsman] is not subject to the OIA. “I was trying to make the point that if you want to have a truly free and open society . . . the Ombudsman’s office is not a Star Chamber or an inquisitor. It’s a body that’s designed to treat all New Zealanders fairly and that means us [government] too.” He said he had “discussions with Mr Boshier that left me with questions” and he hoped the OIA request would provide answers. The paper trail between Mr Brownlee’s office and the Office of the Ombudsman showed he made his OIA request after learning Judge Boshier had overturned a decision by the Earthquake Commission to withhold information being sought under the OIA. Mr Brownlee is Minister Responsible for the EQC. Mr Brownlee referred to a statement that the Office of the Ombudsman intended to carry out a series of “proactive investigations” into OIA practices by those subject to the Act. He stated that he sought “under the provisions of the OIA” any “memos, emails, phone records, meeting agendas, dates on which this matters was discussed and any other material relating to proactive ongoing investigations.” WINDOWS 10 OPTIONS ON ALL EX LEASE COMPUTERS i3 Desktop Cyclone 20’’ screen, Ex Lease • i3 Intel CPU • 4GB RAM • 500GB Hard Drive • Desktop case • Keyboard & Mouse corded • Windows 10 option • DVD writer • 20” screen • 6 Months Warranty • Ex Lease HP 430 i3 Slim Laptop Ex Lease • i3 CPU • 4GB Ram • 500GB Hard Drive • 13.3” Screen • Slim line design • Windows 10 professional • Light weight Ultra laptop • Ex Lease We service & repair laptops, tablets and smartphones, including broken screens. Ring us first for a quote. serving christchurch for over 28 years Unit 1/100 Fitzgerald Ave (Next to Cartridge World) Phone: 379 3428 Open Monday-Friday, 9am-5pm $599 incl GST $599 incl GST i5 Desktop Cyclone 20’’ screen, Ex Lease • i5 Intel CPU • 4GB RAM • 500GB Hard Drive • Desktop case • Keyboard & Mouse corded • Windows 10 option • DVD writer • 20” screen • 6 Months Warranty • Ex Lease HP9470 HP EliteBook Folio Ex Lease • Intel i5 • 4GB Ram • 500GB Hard Drive • 14” Screen • Windows 10 • Slim line design • Light weight Ultra laptop • Ex Lease Upgrade to 240GB SSD Drive for $799 incl GST Shop online at: $699 incl GST $599 incl GST Q Card lending criteria, terms and conditions, and fees apply *All work carried out in our workshop. Home pcs only. Pay with Q Card or Farmers Card. National Online Classic Car Auction 1969 Volkswagen Kombi Camper 1912 Unic Landaulette ENTRIES FROM AROUND NEW ZEALAND Concludes this Monday June 5th from 7.30pm FOR VEHICLE DETAILS, PHOTOS AND BIDDING INSTRUCTIONS SEE Heat Pump Specials Heat Pump Specials GE35 4kW Heat Pump from only $2,299 WINTER GE35 4kW Heat Pump from only $2,299 GE50 HEAT 5.8kW Heat PUMP Pump SPECIALS from only $2,749 GE50 Phone 5.8kW now Heat for Pump prompt from only expert $2,749 FH50 6.0kW advice Heat and Pump installation from only $3,499 FH50 6.0kW Heat Pump from only $3,499 (we can install the same week) Technology Technology INCLUDES INSTALLATION. CONDITIONS APPLY. INCLUDES INSTALLATION. CONDITIONS APPLY. 379-3589 379-3589 1967 Jaguar E-Type Serving Canterbury for 33 years 196 Wordsworth Street, 196 Wordsworth Street, Christchurch Christchurch Heat Pump Installation/Repairs • Refrigeration Design, Build, Repairs Heat Pump Installation/Repairs Refrigeration Design, Build, Repairs

The Star Latest Christchurch news at www. .kiwi Thursday June 1 2017 7 of Official Information Act In response, Judge Boshier said: “I am heartened by your interest in this area.” While he added that he would “greatly appreciate the opportunity to discuss this with you in person”, none of the information Mr Brownlee sought was supplied. Instead, Judge Boshier and Mr Brownlee met on September 8 in a conversation that left the Chief Ombudsman with a feeling of “unease”. The comment is revealed in an email from Judge Boshier to Andrew Kibblewhite, chief executive of the Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet, who had a staff member at the meeting. Judge Boshier wrote: “Unless I am mistaken, there is a perception that our Office wants everything released. The Minister approached this meeting in quite a businesslike fashion, and I think the reason for that was a genuine perception that the rules have changed and that we are pushing for a wider range of ministerial advice and briefings to be released. “I am genuinely worried about this perception.” He told Mr Kibblewhite he hoped the briefing he got from his staffer showed “the rules have not changed at all”. Judge Boshier took over the role in December 2015 and has been regarded by some as overseeing a sea-change in the Office of the Ombudsman, which was struggling under the burden of a massive workload and investigations which were long-delayed. But his approach has caused nervousness in some parts of government after the office’s support for the release of information traditionally believed to be safe from scrutiny. That has included advice from officials, legal advice and other closely held material. Mr Brownlee told the Herald he felt “frustration,” rejecting any suggestion his ill-aimed OIA request was placing pressure on the Office of the Ombudsman. “I appreciate the importance of the OIA in a democracy,” he said. He said there was a lack of certainty around when information should be withheld from public release in cases of “free and frank advice” from officials - withheld so as to promote open advice to ministers – or commercial information, which was also considered sensitive. He said he accepted everything that was done in government would be made public eventually - but some information needed to operate under a cloak to be most effective for citizens. Auckland University of Technology lecturer Greg Treadwell, who has carried out doctoral research on the OIA, viewed Mr Brownlee’s letter to the Office of the Ombudsman and asked: “What’s he doing?” At first glance, he said it appeared Mr Brownlee didn’t know basic OIA principles even though he was approaching the end of a third term as Cabinet minister. “This is why I think it is a deliberate shot across the bows. He appears to be angry with the Ombudsman’s [EQC] decision and that seems almost inappropriate to start demanding voluminous amounts of information. That’s not quite ministerial behaviour.” Labour’s Megan Woods, who speaks on Canterbury issues, said during Mr Brownlee’s period as Minister for the EQC, people in Christchurch had resorted to using the OIA to get updates on their claims over earthquake damage. “The ability to do that was hugely important to people.”​ – NZ Herald CCTV cameras for Woolston • By Noah Graham STREET surveillance cameras have gone up on Ferry Rd in an attempt to thwart robberies in the Woolston Village. Last week, city council installed two sets of CCTV cameras on traffic lights outside Cycle Around Again and the Woolston Tavern to help monitor the road and protect Woolston Village shops. The Woolston Discounter has been a frequent target over the past year with nine robberies taking place in seven months. It was hit again on Sunday when a man armed with a pistol attempted to take cigarettes and lollies but dropped most of the items on the way out of the store. Store owner Sujan Barra said he had not been told of the surveillance cameras but hoped they would prevent his shop from being a frequent target. The Ferry Rd Night ‘n Day store has also been a target, having been robbed 10 times in the past nine months. Owner of the convenience store David Lee said with the cameras installed he “certainly feels safer.” Still trying to get your EQ damage or repair issues sorted We’ve helped hundreds of homeowners get what their policy promises. Talk to us about our “no win-no fee” approach. NO WIN NO FEE Ph: 03 377 8855 | 127 Ferry Road, Christchurch City E: | W: