This new Consequences of Insufficient Household Income report provides a deeper level of understanding of the choices that ALICE and poverty-level families across the country make when they do not have enough income or assistance to afford basic necessities, and the consequences of those choices.
public transit ridership are among low-income (15 percent), Black (23 percent), Hispanic (15 percent), and immigrant workers (25 percent) (Pew Research Center, 2016). Consequences High cost of living: The urban areas with the best public transportation, such as New York, Seattle, and San Francisco, are also some of the most expensive places in the country to live (Tomer, Kneebone, Puentes, & Berube, 2011). Longer commutes: Because housing near public transportation is often cost-prohibitive for most ALICE and poverty-level families, many move farther away from urban centers, increasing commute times significantly. Nationally, the average travel time for commuters using public transit is 50 minutes, twice as long as the average commute for those who drive to work. In part, this is due to a longer distance travelled, but it is also due to increased inefficiencies and limitations of public transit systems – especially those farther from city centers, like rural bus routes. This is reflected in the “D” grade that the U.S. public transit system received on the American Infrastructure Report Card (American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE), 2013; Pew Research Center, 2016; American Community Survey, 2014). Limited job opportunities: Public transportation systems often do not provide routes that ALICE workers need. Transit agencies often neglect the routes that serve low-income neighborhoods, and routes often do not extend to areas outside cities where new jobs are being created. Even more importantly, in an era of increasingly flexible work scheduling, public transit often does not accommodate jobs that require working early, late, or on weekends (Taylor & Morris, 2015; Criden, 2008). 56 UNITED WAY ALICE REPORT – THE CONSEQUENCES OF INSUFFICIENT HOUSEHOLD INCOME
Additional costs of longer commutes: While public transportation can save on household transportation costs, it often adds other costs to ALICE families in terms of time spent on longer commutes, child care, and time away from work. Long commutes also reduce time for other activities such as exercise, shopping for and cooking healthy food, and community and family involvement (U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), 2014). BROADER COSTS OF UNAFFORDABLE TRANSPORTATION Transportation-related “cost-cutting” strategies have consequences not only for ALICE households, but also for the local economy and the wider community: • Long commutes reduce worker productivity and state economic competitiveness. Long commute times increase tardiness and absenteeism rates and can also have a major negative impact on job retention, adding costs to businesses. In addition, congestion from auto commuters adds travel time and costs to the trucking industry, and those costs are then passed on to consumers (Sullivan, 2015; National Economic Council and the President’s Council of Economic Advisers, July 2014). • Urban sprawl costs the American economy more than an estimated $1 trillion annually as households move farther away from job centers, according to a new study by the New Climate Economy. These costs include greater spending on infrastructure, public service delivery, and transportation. The study finds that those living in the new communities directly bear $625 billion in extra costs, and all residents and businesses, regardless of where they are located, bear an extra $400 billion in external costs. In addition, research by Colorado State University found that in Colorado, “dispersed rural residential development costs county governments and schools $1.65 in service expenditures for every dollar of tax revenue generated.” Looking just at transportation costs, development on the fringes of cities over a 15-year period costs nearly twice as much as redevelopment of inner-city transportation (Trubka, Newman, & Bilsborough, 2010; Coyne, 2003; Litman, 2015). UNITED WAY ALICE REPORT – THE CONSEQUENCES OF INSUFFICIENT HOUSEHOLD INCOME 57
ALICE: THE CONSEQUENCES OF INSUFFIC
THE ALICE RESEARCH TEAM The United
ALICE: BRINGING HARDSHIP INTO FOCUS
TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION ....
...AND FOR ALL FAMILIES IMPACT ON T