This new Consequences of Insufficient Household Income report provides a deeper level of understanding of the choices that ALICE and poverty-level families across the country make when they do not have enough income or assistance to afford basic necessities, and the consequences of those choices.
HEALTH CARE than wealthier families to become ill because their basic needs, such as living in a safe environment or having enough food, are not being met. Because they often cannot afford health care or health insurance, they also have more difficulty recovering from illnesses. Recent research clearly shows that unmet basic needs – problems such as not having enough food, living in a dilapidated or unheated apartment, or being unemployed and not having the means to support one’s family – lead to poor health. Nonhealth factors account for as much as 50 percent of poor health outcomes in the U.S (Bachrach, Pfister, Wallis, & Lipson, 2014; Berkowitz, et al., 2015; Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, 2011; Remington, Catlin, & Gennuso, 2015). ALICE and poverty-level families face a range of circumstances that make it difficult for them to achieve and maintain good health. These families are more likely STRATEGIES What do ALICE and poverty-level households do when they cannot afford health care or health insurance? • Poor living conditions. With lower incomes, ALICE families often live in housing and neighborhoods that contribute to poor health. Many less expensive housing options are located in areas with high levels of violence and crime; a high risk of flooding; high pollution levels; poor and aging infrastructure; or other hazards such as exposure to toxic chemicals, mold, and lead (Bell & Ebisu, 2012; Clark, Millet, & Marshall, 2014; U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), 2016; VanDerslice, 2011). • Toxic stress. State and national research on “toxic stress” has found that living in chronically stressful situations, such as in a dangerous neighborhood or in a family that struggles to afford daily food, damages neurological functioning, which in turn can impede a person’s ability to perform well in school, at work, and in daily life. This is especially true for young children, whose brains may never develop the executive functioning skills needed to succeed in each of these areas. Across the country, adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) are prevalent and are known risk factors for poor health outcomes including depression, risky behaviors, and suicide, in addition to being associated with poorer self-rated health and life satisfaction (Dube, Felitti, Dong, Giles, & Anda, 2003; Mersky, Topitzes, & Reynolds, 2013). 1: Forgo Health Care 2: Seek Subsidized Insurance Coverage 3: Go Without Insurance Coverage 4: Buy Minimal Insurance 5: Provide Family Caregiving This section presents the best research available on the hard choices that struggling families are making every day in order to maintain good health or treat health issues, and the consequences of those choices. These are not policy recommendations, but information and analysis that can help stakeholders create the most effective solutions for their communities. 60 UNITED WAY ALICE REPORT – THE CONSEQUENCES OF INSUFFICIENT HOUSEHOLD INCOME
• Health and financial stability are linked. Poor health can be both a consequence and a cause of financial instability. Trying to maintain a household with a low income and few assets can lead to mental stress and poor health. And being in poor health can reduce income further while increasing expenses, often causing a downward spiral that forces a family to fall into poverty (Choi, December 2009; Currie, 2011; Federal Reserve, 2014; Zurlo, Yoon, & Kim, 2014; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), 2011; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), 2014). • Poor access to health care. Low-income families have increased health needs, but it is harder for them to afford and obtain health care than it is for families with higher incomes. Despite both Medicaid and the 2014 rollout of the Affordable Care Act (ACA), the costs of health insurance and health care remain out of reach for many ALICE and poverty-level families. In addition, these families may experience access problems including language and cultural barriers, transportation challenges, and difficulty making work and child care arrangements to accommodate health care appointments (U.S. Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor & Pensions, 2012). The gap between how much ALICE families need for health care and what they can afford to spend shows up clearly in Figure 9, which compares four different monthly health care budgets for a family of four to the monthly salary of a full-time employee working as a nursing assistant. More than 2.3 million ALICE workers across the U.S. worked in health care support jobs such as nursing assistants in 2014, earning an average hourly wage of $11.33, or $22,660 annually (if full time, year-round) (Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2014). Figure 9. Monthly Health Care Costs and Percentage of an ALICE Income, 2014 Monthly Cost $2,000 $1,800 $1,600 $1,400 $1,200 $1,000 $800 $600 $400 $200 $0 30% of Income OoP + ACA Penalty (used in Household Survival Budget) 51% of Income 52% of Income OoP + Silver Plan With Subsidies OoP + Employer- Sponsored Health 98% of Income OoP + Silver Plan No Subsidies Nursing Assistant $11.33 hour ($22,660 annual) Health Insurance Out-of-Pocket Costs (OoP) ALICE Job (Monthly Wages) Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS), 2014 and 2014a; Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, 2015 • The ALICE Household Survival Budget is based on the Consumer Expenditure Survey’s nominal out-of-pocket health care spending for the household on medical services, prescription drugs, and medical supplies – a national UNITED WAY ALICE REPORT – THE CONSEQUENCES OF INSUFFICIENT HOUSEHOLD INCOME 61
ALICE: THE CONSEQUENCES OF INSUFFIC
THE ALICE RESEARCH TEAM The United
ALICE: BRINGING HARDSHIP INTO FOCUS
TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION ....
...AND FOR ALL FAMILIES IMPACT ON T
• The ALICE Threshold - a bare-mi
The purpose of this report is to pr