BusinessDay 03 Apr 2018
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
A12 BUSINESS DAY<br />
C002D5556 Tuesday <strong>03</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
FT<br />
Trump invited Putin to<br />
White House during....<br />
NATIONAL<br />
Anti-apartheid leader Winnie Madikizela-Mandela dies aged 81<br />
Ex-wife of Nelson Mandela kept South African movement alive during his imprisonment<br />
JOSEPH COTTERILL<br />
Winnie Madikizela-Mandela,<br />
the former wife of<br />
Nelson Mandela who<br />
helped keep South Africa’s antiapartheid<br />
movement alive while<br />
her husband spent 27 years in<br />
prison, has died at the age of 81.<br />
Continued from page A11<br />
had discussed a bilateral meeting in<br />
the ‘not-too-distant future’ at a number<br />
of potential venues, including the<br />
White House,” said Sarah Sanders,<br />
the press secretary.<br />
Such an invitation would mark<br />
the closest Mr Putin has come to a<br />
proper summit with Mr Trump, a<br />
goal the Kremlin has been pursuing<br />
since before Mr Trump’s inauguration<br />
in January last year. It has proved<br />
elusive, not least because of the<br />
intense political backlash in the US<br />
over Russian interference in the 2016<br />
presidential election.<br />
Mr Trump telephoned Mr Putin<br />
two days after he won another term<br />
in presidential elections, congratulating<br />
him on his victory even though<br />
he was reportedly urged not to do so<br />
by his aides.<br />
The offer of a White House summit<br />
was made just as the British<br />
government was pressing its allies<br />
to kick out Russian officials over the<br />
nerve agent attack on Sergei Skripal,<br />
a former Russian double agent, and<br />
his daughter.<br />
“This is a classic unforced diplomatic<br />
error by Trump,” said Andrew<br />
Weiss, former Russia director at the<br />
National Security Council under Bill<br />
Clinton, adding that the Kremlin’s<br />
revelation of the White House invitation<br />
opened up apparent cracks in<br />
western unity.<br />
“The Kremlin is all too happy to<br />
exploit any openings that let it plant<br />
wedges between the UK and other<br />
western countries that have registered<br />
their anger over the Skripal<br />
attack.”<br />
Mr Weiss said the revelation from<br />
the Kremlin showed continued lack<br />
of discipline inside the White House<br />
and left observers with even less faith<br />
in Mr Trump ever agreeing with his<br />
national security team on “a more<br />
tough-minded approach” on Russia.<br />
Kremlin officials started discussing<br />
options for a first meeting<br />
between the two presidents almost<br />
immediately after Mr Trump’s election<br />
victory, screening potential<br />
locations in a number of European<br />
countries seen as sufficiently neutral<br />
to make the meeting comfortable<br />
and politically acceptable to both<br />
sides.<br />
Some of Mr Putin’s aides hoped<br />
that if the two men established a<br />
positive personal relationship early<br />
on, they could improve the bilateral<br />
ties that have been deteriorating for<br />
several years.<br />
But the snowballing investigations<br />
into alleged Russian meddling<br />
in the US election and mounting<br />
public distrust of Russia, in addition<br />
to Mr Trump’s seemingly erratic<br />
foreign policy agenda, quickly destroyed<br />
Moscow’s hopes for an early<br />
meeting. Instead, the two presidents<br />
met only on the sidelines of the G20<br />
summit in Hamburg last summer.<br />
Her family said Ms Madikizela-Mandela<br />
died early on Monday<br />
morning at the Netcare Milpark<br />
Hospital in Johannesburg.<br />
“Mrs Madikizela-Mandela<br />
was one of the greatest icons of<br />
the struggle against apartheid,”<br />
the family said in the statement.<br />
“She fought valiantly against the<br />
apartheid state and sacrificed<br />
her life for the freedom of the<br />
country.”<br />
Despite Mrs Madikizela-Mandela’s<br />
role as one of the leaders<br />
of South Africa’s liberation<br />
movement, as white rule crumbled<br />
and Mr Mandela rose to<br />
become the first post-apartheid<br />
president, “Mama Winnie” also<br />
emerged as one of the most<br />
complicated and enigmatic politicians<br />
of South Africa’s young<br />
democracy.<br />
Her militancy and associations<br />
with violence earned her<br />
many enemies in Mr Mandela’s<br />
own African National Congress,<br />
Mark Zuckerberg said Facebook’s advertising and data-led business model allowed the service to reach more people<br />
Mark Zuckerberg hits back at Tim Cook over criticism<br />
Facebook founder calls Apple chief’s comments on data failure ‘extremely glib’<br />
MATTHEW GARRAHAN<br />
Mark Zuckerberg has hit back<br />
at Tim Cook’s veiled criticism<br />
of Facebook’s data policies,<br />
saying the suggestion that his company<br />
did not care about its users was<br />
“extremely glib” and “not at all aligned<br />
with the truth”.<br />
The Apple chief executive took a<br />
swipe at the Facebook founder last<br />
week in the aftermath of the Cambridge<br />
Analytica scandal, when asked what he<br />
would do if he were in the Mr Zuckerberg’s<br />
position.<br />
Mr Cook drew a distinction between<br />
Apple and Facebook, saying: “I<br />
wouldn’t be in this situation.”<br />
The iPhone maker was deliberately<br />
leaving money on the table by refusing<br />
to use data to target advertising to its<br />
hundreds of millions of customers, he<br />
told MSNBC. “We care about the user<br />
experience and we’re not going to traffic<br />
in your personal life.”<br />
But in an interview with Vox, Mr<br />
Zuckerberg defended Facebook’s advertising<br />
and data-led business model.<br />
“The reality here is that if you want<br />
to build a service that helps connect<br />
everyone in the world, then there are a<br />
lot of people who can’t afford to pay,” he<br />
said. “Having an advertising-supported<br />
model is the only rational model that<br />
can support building this service to<br />
reach people.”<br />
“If you want to build a service which<br />
is not just serving rich people, then you<br />
need to have something that people<br />
can afford,” he added.<br />
Mr Zuckerberg acknowledged that<br />
Facebook’s ambition of connecting the<br />
world had changed following the global<br />
“rise of isolationism and nationalism”.<br />
“I think it’s clear that just helping<br />
people connect by itself isn’t always<br />
positive,” he said. “A much bigger part<br />
of the focus for me now is making sure<br />
that as we’re connecting people, we<br />
are helping to build bonds and bring<br />
people closer together, rather than just<br />
focused on the mechanics of the connection<br />
and the infrastructure.”<br />
Facebook also had “a big responsibility”<br />
to “help support high-quality<br />
journalism”, he said, pointing to the<br />
importance of subscriptions as a key<br />
revenue for news organisations. “There<br />
are certainly a lot of things that we can<br />
do on Facebook to help people, to<br />
help these news organisations, drive<br />
subscriptions.”<br />
Mr Zuckerberg raised the prospect<br />
of a third party body ruling on disputes<br />
about content published on the platform.<br />
“Over the long term, what I’d<br />
really like to get to is an independent<br />
appeal,” he said. “You can imagine<br />
some sort of structure, almost like a<br />
UK banks sell asset-backed securities at fastest rate in years<br />
NICHOLAS MEGAW<br />
UK banks are selling assetbacked<br />
securities at the fastest<br />
rate in years, with activity<br />
set to increase further as the withdrawal<br />
of a Bank of England support<br />
programme forces lenders to find<br />
alternative sources of funding.<br />
Banks and building societies that<br />
had been eligible for the BoE’s Term<br />
Funding Scheme issued €4.4bn<br />
worth of securitised products —<br />
where assets such as mortgages or<br />
consumer credit are packaged together<br />
and sold like bonds — in the<br />
first quarter of <strong>2018</strong>, compared with<br />
zero in the same period last year,<br />
according to data from JPMorgan.<br />
The TFS, introduced to encourage<br />
banks to continue lending after<br />
the Brexit vote, allowed them to<br />
borrow at the central bank’s base<br />
rate, reducing the need for them to<br />
Supreme Court, that is made up of<br />
independent folks who don’t work for<br />
Facebook, who ultimately make the<br />
final judgment call on what should be<br />
acceptable speech in a community that<br />
reflects the social norms and values of<br />
people all around the world.”<br />
Facebook continues to weather the<br />
fallout from the Cambridge Analytica<br />
scandal, when it was revealed that the<br />
UK data analytics company had accessed<br />
the personal information of 50m<br />
Facebook users.<br />
The political outcry has not abated<br />
and regulators on both sides of the<br />
Atlantic are exploring tighter restrictions<br />
on social networks. Brussels is<br />
preparing to crack down on social<br />
media companies, issuing a stark warning<br />
that scandals such as the Facebook<br />
data leak threaten to “subvert our<br />
democratic systems”.<br />
Julian King, European commissioner<br />
for security, is demanding a<br />
“clear game plan” for how social media<br />
companies operate during sensitive<br />
election periods, starting with European<br />
Parliament polls in May 2019.<br />
A letter from Sir Julian to Mariya<br />
Gabriel, commissioner for the digital<br />
economy, called for more transparency<br />
on the algorithms that tech companies<br />
use to promote news stories, as well as<br />
limits on the “harvesting” of personal<br />
information for political purposes.<br />
raise funds elsewhere. The scheme<br />
ended at the end of February.<br />
Santander in March completed<br />
the largest dollar-denominated<br />
mortgage-backed security issue by<br />
any UK company since 2012, while<br />
Lloyds sold more than £500m worth<br />
of notes linked to a credit card portfolio,<br />
helping bring total issuance<br />
over the first three months of the<br />
year to its highest level since the<br />
first quarter of 2016.<br />
and her national reputation was<br />
dimmed in the decades following<br />
their divorce in 1996.<br />
In 20<strong>03</strong>, she was convicted<br />
of fraud and theft but, like an<br />
earlier charge of kidnapping,<br />
the conviction was lessened on<br />
appeal and she was given a suspended<br />
sentence.<br />
Ukrainian bank files<br />
$3bn claim against PwC<br />
for audit breaches<br />
PrivatBank asks Cypriot court to rule if auditor<br />
should have spotted decade-long fraud<br />
ROMAN OLEARCHYK<br />
PrivatBank, Ukraine’s largest<br />
commercial lender, has filed a<br />
$3bn legal claim against PwC<br />
saying that “serious and extensive<br />
breaches” at the auditing group allowed<br />
alleged accounting abuses<br />
that forced the state to nationalise<br />
the bank.<br />
The bold Ukrainian attempt to<br />
secure significant damages from<br />
PwC in a Cyprus court marks the<br />
latest reputational blow to the “Big<br />
Four” accountancy firms that has<br />
prompted regulators to intensify<br />
scrutiny through probes and hefty<br />
fines.<br />
Petr Krumphanzl, PrivatBank’s<br />
chairman, said in a statement on<br />
Monday that PwC “failed absolutely<br />
to identify the ongoing operation of<br />
the huge fraud within the bank over<br />
many years which resulted in virtually<br />
the entire corporate loan book<br />
of the bank being non-performing<br />
and without any or any adequate<br />
security”.<br />
“It will now be for the Cyprus<br />
court to determine the claims being<br />
brought by PrivatBank against PwC<br />
in due course,” he added.<br />
PrivatBank, which was previously<br />
owned by two Ukrainian oligarchs,<br />
said it had filed the legal proceedings<br />
on Friday in a Nicosia court<br />
against two PwC group affiliates, one<br />
registered in Ukraine and another<br />
in Cyprus.<br />
PrivatBank, which was nationalised<br />
in late 2016, cited a December<br />
High Court of London order freezing<br />
more than $2.5bn of “worldwide” assets<br />
belonging to the bank’s former<br />
oligarch owners Igor Kolomoisky<br />
and Gennady Bogolyubov.<br />
It described the claims against<br />
PwC as “the next significant step<br />
being taken . . . to seek to recover substantial<br />
compensation for the huge<br />
losses it has suffered, the burden of<br />
which thus far has fallen in large part<br />
on the state of Ukraine.”<br />
Ukraine’s central bank revealed<br />
in January that an investigation<br />
by corporate consultancy Kroll<br />
had found that PrivatBank was<br />
“subjected to a large scale and<br />
co-ordinated fraud over at least a<br />
10-year period . . . which resulted in<br />
a loss of at least $5.5bn” before the<br />
state stepped in.<br />
There was no immediate response<br />
from PwC, Mr Kolomoisky or<br />
Mr Bogolyubov. All have in previous<br />
comments denied wrongdoing in<br />
relation to the financial woes that<br />
occurred at PrivatBank. In July last<br />
year, Ukraine’s central bank pulled<br />
PwC’s domestic bank auditing rights,<br />
citing its alleged shortcomings in<br />
identifying the alleged fraud.