03.04.2018 Views

BusinessDay 03 Apr 2018

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

A12 BUSINESS DAY<br />

C002D5556 Tuesday <strong>03</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />

FT<br />

Trump invited Putin to<br />

White House during....<br />

NATIONAL<br />

Anti-apartheid leader Winnie Madikizela-Mandela dies aged 81<br />

Ex-wife of Nelson Mandela kept South African movement alive during his imprisonment<br />

JOSEPH COTTERILL<br />

Winnie Madikizela-Mandela,<br />

the former wife of<br />

Nelson Mandela who<br />

helped keep South Africa’s antiapartheid<br />

movement alive while<br />

her husband spent 27 years in<br />

prison, has died at the age of 81.<br />

Continued from page A11<br />

had discussed a bilateral meeting in<br />

the ‘not-too-distant future’ at a number<br />

of potential venues, including the<br />

White House,” said Sarah Sanders,<br />

the press secretary.<br />

Such an invitation would mark<br />

the closest Mr Putin has come to a<br />

proper summit with Mr Trump, a<br />

goal the Kremlin has been pursuing<br />

since before Mr Trump’s inauguration<br />

in January last year. It has proved<br />

elusive, not least because of the<br />

intense political backlash in the US<br />

over Russian interference in the 2016<br />

presidential election.<br />

Mr Trump telephoned Mr Putin<br />

two days after he won another term<br />

in presidential elections, congratulating<br />

him on his victory even though<br />

he was reportedly urged not to do so<br />

by his aides.<br />

The offer of a White House summit<br />

was made just as the British<br />

government was pressing its allies<br />

to kick out Russian officials over the<br />

nerve agent attack on Sergei Skripal,<br />

a former Russian double agent, and<br />

his daughter.<br />

“This is a classic unforced diplomatic<br />

error by Trump,” said Andrew<br />

Weiss, former Russia director at the<br />

National Security Council under Bill<br />

Clinton, adding that the Kremlin’s<br />

revelation of the White House invitation<br />

opened up apparent cracks in<br />

western unity.<br />

“The Kremlin is all too happy to<br />

exploit any openings that let it plant<br />

wedges between the UK and other<br />

western countries that have registered<br />

their anger over the Skripal<br />

attack.”<br />

Mr Weiss said the revelation from<br />

the Kremlin showed continued lack<br />

of discipline inside the White House<br />

and left observers with even less faith<br />

in Mr Trump ever agreeing with his<br />

national security team on “a more<br />

tough-minded approach” on Russia.<br />

Kremlin officials started discussing<br />

options for a first meeting<br />

between the two presidents almost<br />

immediately after Mr Trump’s election<br />

victory, screening potential<br />

locations in a number of European<br />

countries seen as sufficiently neutral<br />

to make the meeting comfortable<br />

and politically acceptable to both<br />

sides.<br />

Some of Mr Putin’s aides hoped<br />

that if the two men established a<br />

positive personal relationship early<br />

on, they could improve the bilateral<br />

ties that have been deteriorating for<br />

several years.<br />

But the snowballing investigations<br />

into alleged Russian meddling<br />

in the US election and mounting<br />

public distrust of Russia, in addition<br />

to Mr Trump’s seemingly erratic<br />

foreign policy agenda, quickly destroyed<br />

Moscow’s hopes for an early<br />

meeting. Instead, the two presidents<br />

met only on the sidelines of the G20<br />

summit in Hamburg last summer.<br />

Her family said Ms Madikizela-Mandela<br />

died early on Monday<br />

morning at the Netcare Milpark<br />

Hospital in Johannesburg.<br />

“Mrs Madikizela-Mandela<br />

was one of the greatest icons of<br />

the struggle against apartheid,”<br />

the family said in the statement.<br />

“She fought valiantly against the<br />

apartheid state and sacrificed<br />

her life for the freedom of the<br />

country.”<br />

Despite Mrs Madikizela-Mandela’s<br />

role as one of the leaders<br />

of South Africa’s liberation<br />

movement, as white rule crumbled<br />

and Mr Mandela rose to<br />

become the first post-apartheid<br />

president, “Mama Winnie” also<br />

emerged as one of the most<br />

complicated and enigmatic politicians<br />

of South Africa’s young<br />

democracy.<br />

Her militancy and associations<br />

with violence earned her<br />

many enemies in Mr Mandela’s<br />

own African National Congress,<br />

Mark Zuckerberg said Facebook’s advertising and data-led business model allowed the service to reach more people<br />

Mark Zuckerberg hits back at Tim Cook over criticism<br />

Facebook founder calls Apple chief’s comments on data failure ‘extremely glib’<br />

MATTHEW GARRAHAN<br />

Mark Zuckerberg has hit back<br />

at Tim Cook’s veiled criticism<br />

of Facebook’s data policies,<br />

saying the suggestion that his company<br />

did not care about its users was<br />

“extremely glib” and “not at all aligned<br />

with the truth”.<br />

The Apple chief executive took a<br />

swipe at the Facebook founder last<br />

week in the aftermath of the Cambridge<br />

Analytica scandal, when asked what he<br />

would do if he were in the Mr Zuckerberg’s<br />

position.<br />

Mr Cook drew a distinction between<br />

Apple and Facebook, saying: “I<br />

wouldn’t be in this situation.”<br />

The iPhone maker was deliberately<br />

leaving money on the table by refusing<br />

to use data to target advertising to its<br />

hundreds of millions of customers, he<br />

told MSNBC. “We care about the user<br />

experience and we’re not going to traffic<br />

in your personal life.”<br />

But in an interview with Vox, Mr<br />

Zuckerberg defended Facebook’s advertising<br />

and data-led business model.<br />

“The reality here is that if you want<br />

to build a service that helps connect<br />

everyone in the world, then there are a<br />

lot of people who can’t afford to pay,” he<br />

said. “Having an advertising-supported<br />

model is the only rational model that<br />

can support building this service to<br />

reach people.”<br />

“If you want to build a service which<br />

is not just serving rich people, then you<br />

need to have something that people<br />

can afford,” he added.<br />

Mr Zuckerberg acknowledged that<br />

Facebook’s ambition of connecting the<br />

world had changed following the global<br />

“rise of isolationism and nationalism”.<br />

“I think it’s clear that just helping<br />

people connect by itself isn’t always<br />

positive,” he said. “A much bigger part<br />

of the focus for me now is making sure<br />

that as we’re connecting people, we<br />

are helping to build bonds and bring<br />

people closer together, rather than just<br />

focused on the mechanics of the connection<br />

and the infrastructure.”<br />

Facebook also had “a big responsibility”<br />

to “help support high-quality<br />

journalism”, he said, pointing to the<br />

importance of subscriptions as a key<br />

revenue for news organisations. “There<br />

are certainly a lot of things that we can<br />

do on Facebook to help people, to<br />

help these news organisations, drive<br />

subscriptions.”<br />

Mr Zuckerberg raised the prospect<br />

of a third party body ruling on disputes<br />

about content published on the platform.<br />

“Over the long term, what I’d<br />

really like to get to is an independent<br />

appeal,” he said. “You can imagine<br />

some sort of structure, almost like a<br />

UK banks sell asset-backed securities at fastest rate in years<br />

NICHOLAS MEGAW<br />

UK banks are selling assetbacked<br />

securities at the fastest<br />

rate in years, with activity<br />

set to increase further as the withdrawal<br />

of a Bank of England support<br />

programme forces lenders to find<br />

alternative sources of funding.<br />

Banks and building societies that<br />

had been eligible for the BoE’s Term<br />

Funding Scheme issued €4.4bn<br />

worth of securitised products —<br />

where assets such as mortgages or<br />

consumer credit are packaged together<br />

and sold like bonds — in the<br />

first quarter of <strong>2018</strong>, compared with<br />

zero in the same period last year,<br />

according to data from JPMorgan.<br />

The TFS, introduced to encourage<br />

banks to continue lending after<br />

the Brexit vote, allowed them to<br />

borrow at the central bank’s base<br />

rate, reducing the need for them to<br />

Supreme Court, that is made up of<br />

independent folks who don’t work for<br />

Facebook, who ultimately make the<br />

final judgment call on what should be<br />

acceptable speech in a community that<br />

reflects the social norms and values of<br />

people all around the world.”<br />

Facebook continues to weather the<br />

fallout from the Cambridge Analytica<br />

scandal, when it was revealed that the<br />

UK data analytics company had accessed<br />

the personal information of 50m<br />

Facebook users.<br />

The political outcry has not abated<br />

and regulators on both sides of the<br />

Atlantic are exploring tighter restrictions<br />

on social networks. Brussels is<br />

preparing to crack down on social<br />

media companies, issuing a stark warning<br />

that scandals such as the Facebook<br />

data leak threaten to “subvert our<br />

democratic systems”.<br />

Julian King, European commissioner<br />

for security, is demanding a<br />

“clear game plan” for how social media<br />

companies operate during sensitive<br />

election periods, starting with European<br />

Parliament polls in May 2019.<br />

A letter from Sir Julian to Mariya<br />

Gabriel, commissioner for the digital<br />

economy, called for more transparency<br />

on the algorithms that tech companies<br />

use to promote news stories, as well as<br />

limits on the “harvesting” of personal<br />

information for political purposes.<br />

raise funds elsewhere. The scheme<br />

ended at the end of February.<br />

Santander in March completed<br />

the largest dollar-denominated<br />

mortgage-backed security issue by<br />

any UK company since 2012, while<br />

Lloyds sold more than £500m worth<br />

of notes linked to a credit card portfolio,<br />

helping bring total issuance<br />

over the first three months of the<br />

year to its highest level since the<br />

first quarter of 2016.<br />

and her national reputation was<br />

dimmed in the decades following<br />

their divorce in 1996.<br />

In 20<strong>03</strong>, she was convicted<br />

of fraud and theft but, like an<br />

earlier charge of kidnapping,<br />

the conviction was lessened on<br />

appeal and she was given a suspended<br />

sentence.<br />

Ukrainian bank files<br />

$3bn claim against PwC<br />

for audit breaches<br />

PrivatBank asks Cypriot court to rule if auditor<br />

should have spotted decade-long fraud<br />

ROMAN OLEARCHYK<br />

PrivatBank, Ukraine’s largest<br />

commercial lender, has filed a<br />

$3bn legal claim against PwC<br />

saying that “serious and extensive<br />

breaches” at the auditing group allowed<br />

alleged accounting abuses<br />

that forced the state to nationalise<br />

the bank.<br />

The bold Ukrainian attempt to<br />

secure significant damages from<br />

PwC in a Cyprus court marks the<br />

latest reputational blow to the “Big<br />

Four” accountancy firms that has<br />

prompted regulators to intensify<br />

scrutiny through probes and hefty<br />

fines.<br />

Petr Krumphanzl, PrivatBank’s<br />

chairman, said in a statement on<br />

Monday that PwC “failed absolutely<br />

to identify the ongoing operation of<br />

the huge fraud within the bank over<br />

many years which resulted in virtually<br />

the entire corporate loan book<br />

of the bank being non-performing<br />

and without any or any adequate<br />

security”.<br />

“It will now be for the Cyprus<br />

court to determine the claims being<br />

brought by PrivatBank against PwC<br />

in due course,” he added.<br />

PrivatBank, which was previously<br />

owned by two Ukrainian oligarchs,<br />

said it had filed the legal proceedings<br />

on Friday in a Nicosia court<br />

against two PwC group affiliates, one<br />

registered in Ukraine and another<br />

in Cyprus.<br />

PrivatBank, which was nationalised<br />

in late 2016, cited a December<br />

High Court of London order freezing<br />

more than $2.5bn of “worldwide” assets<br />

belonging to the bank’s former<br />

oligarch owners Igor Kolomoisky<br />

and Gennady Bogolyubov.<br />

It described the claims against<br />

PwC as “the next significant step<br />

being taken . . . to seek to recover substantial<br />

compensation for the huge<br />

losses it has suffered, the burden of<br />

which thus far has fallen in large part<br />

on the state of Ukraine.”<br />

Ukraine’s central bank revealed<br />

in January that an investigation<br />

by corporate consultancy Kroll<br />

had found that PrivatBank was<br />

“subjected to a large scale and<br />

co-ordinated fraud over at least a<br />

10-year period . . . which resulted in<br />

a loss of at least $5.5bn” before the<br />

state stepped in.<br />

There was no immediate response<br />

from PwC, Mr Kolomoisky or<br />

Mr Bogolyubov. All have in previous<br />

comments denied wrongdoing in<br />

relation to the financial woes that<br />

occurred at PrivatBank. In July last<br />

year, Ukraine’s central bank pulled<br />

PwC’s domestic bank auditing rights,<br />

citing its alleged shortcomings in<br />

identifying the alleged fraud.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!