06.04.2018 Views

JANUARY 2018

The January edition of Co-op News: connecting, challenging and championing the global co-operative movement. This issue explores finding the route to collective decision-making. It also looks at gender equality, co-housing for homeless veterans and what 2018 holds in store.

The January edition of Co-op News: connecting, challenging and championing the global co-operative movement. This issue explores finding the route to collective decision-making. It also looks at gender equality, co-housing for homeless veterans and what 2018 holds in store.

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

<strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong><br />

news<br />

LEADERSHIP<br />

Finding the route<br />

to collective<br />

decision-making<br />

Plus ... Helping<br />

Looking ahead to <strong>2018</strong><br />

... Working for gender<br />

equality ... Co-housing<br />

for homeless veterans<br />

ISSN 0009-9821<br />

9 770009 982010<br />

01<br />

£4.20<br />

www.thenews.coop


news<br />

Give a fair wage<br />

to farmers and<br />

garment makers<br />

The Co-op News range of 100% organic cotton<br />

Fairtrade t-shirts provides a fair deal for farmers<br />

who receive a premium on top of the normal cotton<br />

price. In addition, 10p from every sale goes direct<br />

towards a Living Wage for garment workers.<br />

This unique partnership has been developed by<br />

Continental Clothing, which buys Fairtrade cotton<br />

from Pratima Agro co-operative in Orissa, India.<br />

It has also set up the Fair Share scheme, which<br />

passes a premium direct to the garment worker.


CONNECTING, CHAMPIONING AND<br />

CHALLENGING THE GLOBAL CO-OP<br />

MOVEMENT SINCE 1871<br />

Holyoake House, Hanover Street,<br />

Manchester M60 0AS<br />

(00) 44 161 214 0870<br />

www.thenews.coop<br />

editorial@thenews.coop<br />

EXECUTIVE EDITOR<br />

Anthony Murray<br />

anthony@thenews.coop<br />

DEPUTY EDITOR<br />

Rebecca Harvey<br />

rebecca@thenews.coop<br />

EDITORIAL<br />

Anca Voinea | anca@thenews.coop<br />

Miles Hadfield | miles@thenews.coop<br />

DESIGN: Keir Mucklestone-Barnett<br />

DIRECTORS<br />

Elaine Dean (chair), David Paterson<br />

(vice-chair), Richard Bickle, Sofygil<br />

Crew, Gavin Ewing, Tim Hartley,<br />

Erskine Holmes, Beverley Perkins and<br />

Barbara Rainford.<br />

Secretary: Ray Henderson<br />

Established in 1871, Co-operative News<br />

is published by Co-operative Press Ltd,<br />

a registered society under the Cooperative<br />

and Community Benefit Society<br />

Act 2014. It is printed every month by<br />

Buxton Press, Palace Road, Buxton,<br />

Derbyshire SK17 6AE. Membership of<br />

Co-operative Press is open to individual<br />

readers as well as to other co-operatives,<br />

corporate bodies and unincorporated<br />

organisations.<br />

The Co-operative News mission statement<br />

is to connect, champion and challenge<br />

the global co-operative movement,<br />

through fair and objective journalism and<br />

open and honest comment and debate.<br />

Co-op News is, on occasion, supported by<br />

co-operatives, but final editorial control<br />

remains with Co-operative News unless<br />

specifically labelled ‘advertorial’. The<br />

information and views set out in opinion<br />

articles and letters do not necessarily<br />

reflect the opinion of Co-operative News.<br />

@coopnews<br />

news<br />

cooperativenews<br />

Our view: Plotting a course for<br />

co-operative leadership<br />

Collective leadership is a phrase that must put fear into many managers – but this is<br />

undoubtedly the co-operative way.<br />

Co-operatives are the epitome of ‘collective leadership’ – typically this is led<br />

in collaboration between the member-elected board and the board-appointed<br />

managers. Through the act of co-operation, these two groups of people reach the<br />

common goals of the co-op.<br />

There are some gleaming examples, such as the East of England Co-op which,<br />

as a retail co-op, abolished the role of chief executive and instead established a<br />

management team, which works closely with the board.<br />

Then there are worker co-operatives, which strive for a flat structure. Bob Cannell,<br />

who was a worker-owner at Suma, says that people at Suma quickly learnt that<br />

“management is a function, not a status”.<br />

It’s not always positive. There are co-ops that operate their own elite structure, which<br />

keeps ordinary members out. But there is no one-size approach to co-operative<br />

leadership, according to business adviser Kate Whittle. She also believes that some<br />

people are fearful of leadership in a co-operative – but this is only because people<br />

assume that “command and control” is the only way to lead.<br />

As well as looking inside the co-op sector, it’s always helpful to look outside. Craig<br />

Dearden-Phillips is a long-time leader of social businesses, and he has interviewed<br />

many other leaders to figure out how leaders are categorised – and what also makes<br />

a good leader.<br />

There are many opinions on what constitutes leadership – and Bob Cannell may sum<br />

it up perfectly when he says the co-op leader is the one who says: “Listen everyone,<br />

we have a problem. What are WE going to do about it?”<br />

ANTHONY MURRAY - EXECUTIVE EDITOR<br />

Co-operative News is printed using vegetable oil-based<br />

inks on 80% recycled paper (with 60% from post-consumer<br />

waste) with the remaining 20% produced from FSC or PEFC<br />

certified sources. It is made in a totally chlorine free process.<br />

<strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong> | 3


the Co-operative Party ...<br />

Crunch time for Croatia’s<br />

Co-ops ... Has Co-ops<br />

Fortnight lost its way?<br />

ISSN 0009-9821<br />

9 770009 982010<br />

01<br />

ISSN 0009-9821<br />

9 770009 982010<br />

01<br />

news Issue #7287 SEPTEMBER 2017<br />

Connecting, championing, challenging<br />

news<br />

September 2017<br />

FOOD<br />

Celebrating<br />

British Food<br />

Fortnight<br />

Plus ... 100 years of<br />

£4.20<br />

www.thenews.coop<br />

THIS ISSUE<br />

REVIEW OF THE YEAR<br />

REVIEW OF THE<br />

YEAR 2017<br />

CLOCKWISE FROM FAR LEFT<br />

Our 32-page pull-out takes a look back at<br />

the past 12 months; Egyptian co-op Sekem<br />

is working to improve training and work<br />

opportunities for women (p20-21); Abcul’s<br />

Scottish policy officer Karen Hurst (p30-31);<br />

a former policy academy which is now home<br />

to a housing co-op to homeless US military<br />

veterans (p22-23)<br />

news<br />

2017<br />

news<br />

ING<br />

ildings<br />

sent and<br />

...<br />

e Alliance’s<br />

onference...<br />

pment in<br />

ebrating<br />

ay<br />

01<br />

10<br />

£4.20<br />

ews.coop<br />

If you did not receive your Review of The<br />

Year 2017 in this edition, please request<br />

a replacement copy by calling 0161 214<br />

0870 or visit www.thenews.coop/missing<br />

news Issue #7291 <strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong><br />

Connecting, championing, challenging<br />

news<br />

<strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong><br />

LEADERSHIP<br />

Finding the route<br />

to collective<br />

decision-making<br />

Plus ... Helping<br />

Looking ahead to <strong>2018</strong><br />

... Working for gender<br />

equality ... Co-housing<br />

for homeless veterans<br />

£4.20<br />

www.thenews.coop<br />

20-21 GENDER EQUALITY<br />

Social investment co-op Oikocredit is<br />

working with Egyptian co-op Sekem to<br />

improve opportunities for women<br />

22-23 HOUSING<br />

A co-op housing scheme has opened for<br />

homeless military veterans in the USA<br />

24-29 A NEW YEAR<br />

Leading figures from the co-op movement<br />

look back on the last 12 months and<br />

discuss their hopes for <strong>2018</strong><br />

30-31 MEET ... KAREN HURST<br />

The Scottish policy officer at ABCUL union<br />

tells how she was drawn to the movement<br />

32-45 LEADERSHIP<br />

32-35 Business expert Craig Dearden-<br />

Phillips looks at social sector leadership<br />

lessons from his time in the worker co-op<br />

movement and his work advising co-ops<br />

on leadership<br />

46-47 BIG DATA<br />

Technology is bringing opportunities and<br />

challenges to co-ops and a session at the<br />

Global Conference of the ICA discussed<br />

its transformative implications<br />

32-PAGE PULL-OUT:<br />

2017 IN REVIEW<br />

We take a look back over the past 12<br />

months – including the most-read online<br />

stories, the biggest events of the year,<br />

and how co-ops have performed in<br />

areas such as solidarity, equality and<br />

sustainability. Plus tributes to some of<br />

the key figures of the movement who<br />

have passed away<br />

REGULARS<br />

COVER: Leadership presents<br />

specific challenges for co-ops.<br />

This month we speak to experts<br />

and leaders from within and<br />

outside the movement to<br />

find some insight into how a<br />

collective model of leadership<br />

can work in practice<br />

Read more: p32-45<br />

36-39 Kate Whittle asks: “Who’s afraid<br />

of leadership?”<br />

40-41 We speak to Simon Parkinson, CEO<br />

of the the Co-operative College, and Ben<br />

Reid, CEO of Midcounties Co-operative<br />

42-45 Bob Cannell from Co-operative<br />

Business Consultants shares some of the<br />

5-13 UK updates<br />

14-19: Global updates<br />

31: Letters<br />

48-49: Reviews<br />

50: Diary<br />

4 | <strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong>


NEWS<br />

BREXIT<br />

Irish co-operative body still has concerns after Brexit border deal<br />

The last-minute agreement on the Irish<br />

border, which has allowed Brexit talks to<br />

move to the second stage, has been met<br />

with a cautious welcome from the Irish<br />

Co-operative Organisation Society (ICOS).<br />

The provisional deal avoids a hard border<br />

in Ireland, with “regulatory alignment”<br />

taking effect when the UK leaves the<br />

single market and customs union.<br />

ICOS, which is the voice for co-ops<br />

in Ireland, is concerned about possible<br />

disruption to supply chains and joint<br />

operations across Ireland and Northern<br />

Ireland, with the rural economy in the<br />

border counties supported by the €3bn<br />

(£2.5bn) cross-border trade.<br />

European affairs executive Alison<br />

Graham said: “Ireland currently has an<br />

all-island agricultural economy, with<br />

strategies, economic structures and<br />

government policies which span both the<br />

Republic and Northern Ireland.”<br />

She said many goods repeatedly cross<br />

the border before they become a finished<br />

product, with dairy co-ops “uniquely<br />

exposed” – half of the northern Irish milk<br />

is bought by co-ops in the Republic.<br />

These concerns led ICOS to call on the<br />

UK to reverse its policy and remain in<br />

the single market and customs union.<br />

But last week’s deal has eased some of<br />

these fears, said Ms Graham. She added:<br />

p The Irish dairy industry is especially exposed to disruption by Brexit<br />

“We are now able to move on to the trade<br />

talks, which was vital to overcome the<br />

uncertainty facing business, and we have<br />

also established a new default position.<br />

“Should the negotiations end with a<br />

trade deal the UK has agreed to ‘maintain<br />

full alignment’ with single market and<br />

customs union rules. This goes a long way<br />

towards easing fears on the possibility of<br />

a cliff-edge scenario, of a hard border and<br />

WTO rules”.<br />

“The alternative – regulatory divergence<br />

– is a top concern for Irish co-ops, as it<br />

would add significantly to trade costs,<br />

increase customs issues and threaten the<br />

position of EU imports to the UK.”<br />

But there is still some uncertainty<br />

surrounding the agreement. Brexit<br />

secretary David Davis was forced to clarify<br />

remarks which suggested the deal “was<br />

much more a statement of intent than<br />

it was a legally enforceable thing” and<br />

Theresa May has said that “nothing is<br />

agreed until everything is agreed”.<br />

Ms Graham warned: “The clear<br />

contradictions in the UK’s desired<br />

outcome remain. UK government stresses<br />

that it will be leaving the single market<br />

and customs union, however within the<br />

agreement it also commits to a ‘guarantee’<br />

on avoiding a hard border on the island of<br />

Ireland, while at the same time ensuring<br />

p Alison Graham<br />

‘the same unfettered access for Northern<br />

Ireland’s businesses to the whole of the<br />

United Kingdom internal market’, with no<br />

indication on how this will be achieved.”<br />

She added: “We maintain our call for<br />

transitional arrangements, which maintain<br />

the status quo, to be agreed as soon as<br />

possible to remove the uncertainty facing<br />

businesses. We also call on the EU and<br />

the UK to ensure that these commitments<br />

are fully respected and translated into a<br />

legally binding agreement.<br />

“We also very much welcome the<br />

strategy outlined in the agreement to<br />

address specific Irish issues also within<br />

the trade talks, including the matter of the<br />

transit of goods through the UK on their<br />

way to mainland Europe.”<br />

Irish co-ops rely on the UK as a land<br />

bridge into the EU, she said, because it<br />

is quicker than ferry transport, and ICOS<br />

is worried these routes would be affected<br />

once the UK leaves the customs union.<br />

“It is doubtful that the current physical<br />

infrastructure at the ports and other entry<br />

points in the EU and the UK have the<br />

sufficient space to conduct the necessary<br />

customs checks,” she warned.<br />

“Any delay would mean missed<br />

connections to further destinations,<br />

mandated rest times for drivers, and<br />

spoiled goods.”<br />

<strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong> | 5


COMMUNITY SHARES<br />

£3m boost for local communities wanting to develop their own businesses<br />

Local groups needing an extra boost to<br />

set up or grow a community business<br />

can access support and match funding<br />

through a new round of the Community<br />

Shares Booster programme.<br />

Community shares are a popular<br />

approach to raising finance, in which local<br />

people invest often small sums of money<br />

and become co-owners of vital local<br />

enterprises – from affordable housing to<br />

community pubs to green energy.<br />

A new £3m injection into the programme<br />

will support groups in England seeking<br />

to launch community share offers,<br />

potentially boost their investment and<br />

provide ongoing support.<br />

The first development grants and equity<br />

investments will be awarded from early<br />

<strong>2018</strong> as part of the five-year programme,<br />

delivered by the Community Shares Unit,<br />

a joint initiative between Co-operatives<br />

UK and Locality, and funded by Power to<br />

Change, the independent trust supporting<br />

community businesses in England.<br />

Successful applicants could receive a<br />

support grant of up to £10,000 in advance<br />

of launching their community share offer.<br />

After that, their organisation could access<br />

up to £100,000 match funding when the<br />

share offer goes live. Match funding will be<br />

in the form of equity held on equal terms<br />

with other community shareholders.<br />

The original £1m programme, which<br />

began in 2016, supported 15 community<br />

businesses. Local people were able to<br />

restore a Stretford Hall, a grade 2 Listed<br />

Victorian ballroom in Manchester, build<br />

a new green-build straw-bale roundhouse<br />

p The Shotley Pier restoration project is one of those which has received support<br />

in South Derbyshire, expand a community<br />

farm in London, build communitydeveloped<br />

homes in Leeds and save the<br />

122-year-old Shotley railway pier for<br />

community use in Suffolk.<br />

Simon Borkin from Co-operatives UK<br />

said: “The community shares market<br />

has the potential for further growth and<br />

the booster programme will provide<br />

a welcome stimulus to community<br />

businesses considering raising this form<br />

of socially aligned and patient finance.<br />

“We have already invested alongside as<br />

many as 3,000 investors and look forward<br />

to supporting many more offers.”<br />

Tony Armstrong, CEO of Locality, added:<br />

“Community shares harness the power<br />

and spirit of enterprise in communities.<br />

“We welcome this new investment to<br />

boost community shares so that more<br />

people can come together to develop new<br />

projects, and benefit local economies and<br />

thriving communities.”<br />

And Ged Devlin, programme manager<br />

at power to change, said: “Around a third<br />

of Community Shares Booster awards to<br />

date have been made to groups located<br />

in the 10% most deprived communities<br />

as identified by the Index of Multiple<br />

Deprivation and we are confident the<br />

programme has engaged groups which,<br />

but for this support, would not have<br />

considered issuing a share offer. We<br />

are looking forward to supporting more<br />

disadvantaged groups and help put<br />

businesses into community ownership.”<br />

To date, the programme has supported<br />

15 community businesses, awarding<br />

over £100,000 in development grants<br />

allowing them to develop their share offer,<br />

as well as investing over £600,000 in 11<br />

community businesses as matched equity<br />

investments, releasing as much as £1.5m<br />

into the community business market.<br />

uApply at communitysharesbooster.org.uk<br />

ENVIRONMENT<br />

Co-op Insurance’s clean cookstove programme reduces CO2 emissions in Ghana<br />

Co-op Insurance is working to offset its<br />

customers’ carbon emissions by helping<br />

to fund cleaner cookstoves in Ghana.<br />

Over 140,000 people have benefited<br />

from the project, which enables people in<br />

Ghana to gain the skills and knowledge<br />

required to manufacture, market and sell<br />

Gyapa stoves.<br />

Each month, 12,000 stoves are<br />

produced by 350 manufacturers,<br />

benefiting over 500 local retailers. The<br />

stoves reduce carbon emissions and<br />

produce less smoke. They also require<br />

60% less charcoal than traditional stoves,<br />

saving families around $100 a year in<br />

fuel costs.<br />

Mark Summerfield, chief executive of<br />

Co-op Insurance, said: “We offer new<br />

customers carbon offset as standard on all<br />

home and motor policies, at no extra cost.<br />

We have chosen this project specifically<br />

as, in addition to its environmental<br />

impact, it offers excellent long-term<br />

social benefits such as job creation and is<br />

helping to facilitate a better quality of life<br />

for thousands in the developing world.<br />

“This exciting project is one of the<br />

many ways we’re committed to doing<br />

business ethically; we already source 99%<br />

of our electricity from renewable sources<br />

(including our own wind farms), and have<br />

reduced our direct carbon footprint by<br />

46% since 2006.<br />

6 | <strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong>


CO-OP GROUP<br />

Co-op Group comes to the rescue as Costcutter’s supplier P&H collapses<br />

Local groups needing an extra boost to<br />

set up or grow a community business can<br />

access support<br />

The Co-op Group will become the<br />

exclusive wholesale supplier to Costcutter<br />

Supermarkets Group, (CSG) it has been<br />

announced.<br />

The Group jumped in to fill the gap left<br />

by the collapse last week of wholesale<br />

giant Palmer and Harvey (P&H), which<br />

supplied about 90,000 outlets around the<br />

UK including major chains, convenience<br />

stores, corner shops and petrol<br />

station forecourts.<br />

From spring <strong>2018</strong>, the Group will<br />

become the exclusive wholesale supplier<br />

to CSG and the 2,200 Costcutter, Mace,<br />

Simply Fresh, Supershop and Kwiksave<br />

convenience stores across its network.<br />

The deal will also provide the<br />

opportunity for CSG’s independent<br />

retailers to become Co-op franchisees.<br />

Given the unexpected P&H<br />

announcement, the Group says it is also<br />

looking at practical short-term ways to<br />

support independent retailers within CSG.<br />

Jo Whitfield, chief executive of Co-op<br />

Food, said: “We are operating in a dynamic<br />

market environment and this deal, coming<br />

shortly after our Nisa announcement,<br />

shows how we are positively responding<br />

to the changes occurring within the sector.<br />

Jo Whitfield, head of food at the Group”<br />

Our Food business is going from strength<br />

to strength in what is clearly a challenging<br />

retail market. We recently reported our<br />

14th consecutive quarter of like-for-like<br />

sales growth and this agreement will<br />

further strengthen our ability to offer<br />

customers great products at great prices.”<br />

“Our Food business is going from strength<br />

to strength in what is clearly a challenging<br />

retail market. We recently reported our<br />

14th consecutive quarter of like-for-like<br />

sales growth and this agreement will<br />

further strengthen our ability to offer<br />

customers great products at great prices.”<br />

She added: “While our deal with<br />

Costcutter will start formally in spring<br />

<strong>2018</strong> we are looking at practical ways we<br />

can support independent retailers during<br />

this busy trading period, in light of the<br />

news concerning P&H. It is essential that<br />

we maintain a strong independent retail<br />

sector and the Co-op is committed to<br />

playing its part, along with others in the<br />

industry, in ensuring this occurs.”<br />

Costcutter chief executive Darcy<br />

Willson-Rymer said: “With P&H no<br />

longer able to supply our stores, we have<br />

activated our contingency plans that will<br />

see our retailers supported by the Co-op<br />

and other suppliers in the run-up to our<br />

deal with the Co-op.”<br />

pJo Whitfield, head of food at the Co-op<br />

Groupq The Group will become Costcutter’s<br />

sole wholesaler.<br />

“We all have a part to play in addressing<br />

the pressing issue of climate change, and<br />

through this offer, we’re making it easier<br />

than ever for Co-op customers to make<br />

that choice.”<br />

For this project, Co-op Insurance has<br />

partnered with ClimateCare, a profit for<br />

purpose company focused on tackling<br />

climate change.<br />

Edward Hanrahan, chief executive of<br />

ClimateCare, added: “By tieing climate<br />

action into its products as standard,<br />

Co-op Insurance is showing real ambition<br />

on climate change, and driving carbon<br />

emissions reductions at scale. Through<br />

projects such as Gyapa stoves, the Co-op<br />

and ClimateCare are working together<br />

to enable scalable, locally appropriate<br />

solutions to climate change which create<br />

opportunities and develop skills in some<br />

of the world’s underserved communities.<br />

One of those benefiting from the<br />

programme is stockist Ebrahim Dowda,<br />

who said: “I can sell 900 liners a month<br />

which gives me enough money to send my<br />

son to school.”<br />

Gifty Aberig Awimpowa, a local retailer,<br />

has also managed to expand her retail<br />

network by selling the Gyapa cookstoves.<br />

These get sold for USD $10 and save the<br />

customers $100 in fuel costs each year.<br />

For each new motor policy, Co-op<br />

Insurance offsets 10% of its customers’<br />

carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions from their<br />

cars in the first year.<br />

Similarly, for each new home policy,<br />

the business offsets 10% of its customers’<br />

home energy CO2 emissions during the<br />

first year.<br />

<strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong> | 7


ENVIRONMENT<br />

East of England to sell food after Best Before date to cut food waste<br />

p Joint CEO Roger Grosvenor launches the society’s latest food waste initiative<br />

The East of England Co-op has become the<br />

first major retailer to start selling products<br />

beyond their ‘Best Before’ date with the<br />

aim of significantly reducing food waste<br />

in its stores.<br />

The biggest independent retailer in<br />

East Anglia will now sell products over<br />

their Best Before date in its 125 food stores<br />

for a nominal 10p. The move follows<br />

a successful three-month trial in 14<br />

stores and will be launched with new a<br />

campaign, “The Co-op Guide to Dating”.<br />

It is estimated that every year between<br />

30–50% of food produced globally for<br />

human consumption is wasted. East of<br />

England hopes the initiative will save at<br />

least two metric tonnes of waste a year.<br />

Shoppers will be told ‘Don’t be a<br />

binner, have it for dinner!’ and ‘It’s<br />

not nice to get dumped’ in an effort to<br />

encourage participation.<br />

Joint chief executive Roger Grosvenor,<br />

said: “This is one of many initiatives we<br />

have instigated to make the East of England<br />

Co-op as efficient as possible, reducing<br />

our impact on the environment.”<br />

The Food Standards Agency says<br />

products past their Best Before date<br />

are safe to consume but may not be<br />

at optimum quality. The products will<br />

remain on sale for one month past their<br />

Best Before date.<br />

“During our trial we found our 10p<br />

items went within hours of being reduced,<br />

sometimes quicker,” said Mr Grosvenor.<br />

“The vast majority of our customers<br />

understand they are fine to eat and<br />

appreciate the opportunity to make a<br />

significant saving.<br />

“This is not a money-making exercise,<br />

but a sensible move to reduce food waste<br />

and keep edible food in the food chain. By<br />

selling perfectly edible food we can save<br />

50,000 plus items every year.”<br />

p A slogan for the 10p food items<br />

The majority of products that use Best<br />

Before dates will be included, such as<br />

tinned goods, packets and dried food.<br />

The 10p reduced products will not include<br />

‘Use By’ dated products, which should<br />

not be consumed after the Use By date<br />

has passed.<br />

Sales data is more closely reviewed<br />

to monitor waste levels in each store, to<br />

enable the co-op to reduce products which<br />

generate excessive waste.<br />

East of England has also instigated<br />

a new Reduced to Clear policy, offering<br />

more significant discounts earlier in the<br />

day on products nearing their Use By<br />

dates to further help reduce waste.<br />

These changes are the latest in a string<br />

of environmental initiatives at the society.<br />

Customer recycling points and recycling<br />

facilities for stores help manage packaging<br />

waste, and partnerships between local<br />

suppliers in its Sourced Locally range<br />

recuce transport distances, reducing the<br />

carbon footprint.<br />

The 10p discounted food cannot be<br />

donated to charities such as food banks,<br />

as they do not accept food after its Best<br />

Before date. Instead, the society collects<br />

non-perishable food and toiletries within<br />

date in all its stores. Donations for more<br />

than 80,000 meals were collected last<br />

year, supplying 22 food banks.<br />

8 | <strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong>


FAIRTRADE<br />

‘Owned by cocoa farmers’ – Divine shouts about<br />

its ethical ownership in packaging redesign<br />

Divine Chocolate’s new packaging is<br />

putting its farmer-owners at the forefront.<br />

The ‘Owned by Cocoa Farmers’ seal<br />

is stamped on the front of all packages<br />

in the redesign, highlighting its ethical<br />

credentials and that family farmers in<br />

Ghana hold a 44% stake in the venture<br />

with board representation. Inside the<br />

packaging, each bar tells a different<br />

story about a farmer, the structure of<br />

the organisation and what the African<br />

Adinkra symbols which adorn the<br />

packaging mean.<br />

The sharing bars are hitting stores<br />

across the UK, USA and the rest of the<br />

world this month, while the rest of the<br />

product range is rolling out in <strong>2018</strong>.<br />

Divine says the design taps into<br />

consumer trends including demand<br />

for transparency on the provenance of<br />

ingredients, concern over nutritional<br />

content, and sustainability impact, all of<br />

which have grown in the past five years.<br />

Divine appointed Lewis Moberly to<br />

lead the strategic design development for<br />

the change.The company says great care<br />

was taken to maintain important brand<br />

assets such as the intricate Divine logo,<br />

accents of gold and bold colours, and the<br />

recognisable pattern of Adinkra symbols.<br />

The changes mean the brand is bolder<br />

against the cleaner one-colour pattern,<br />

it adds.<br />

“The new design also aims to boost<br />

impulse purchases by improving<br />

communication for premium chocolate<br />

decision-making,” Divine added. “The<br />

product name is more legible and more<br />

prominence is given to the percentage of<br />

cocoa. Divine research shows more than<br />

half of premium chocolate shoppers look<br />

for this when choosing quality chocolate.<br />

Divine has made ethical commitments<br />

across its range for many years, but only<br />

communicated these consistently through<br />

marketing channels.<br />

AGRICULTURE<br />

Scottish government: ‘Co-operation<br />

is good for farming –we need more’<br />

A discussion document on agriculture published by the Scottish<br />

government includes a call for more collaboration among farmers<br />

and within their supply chains.<br />

The document was produced by the agricultural champions<br />

team appointed by cabinet secretary Fergus Ewing to advise on<br />

the government’s Vision for Agriculture.<br />

It notes that “most farmers have not reaped huge benefits from<br />

the spectacular growth of Scotland’s food and drink sector in<br />

recent years.<br />

“The failings of our supply chains are well documented. But<br />

the solution must be for the various players to work together.”<br />

The paper gives credit to the work of co-op players such as<br />

the Scottish Agricultural Organisation Society (SAOS), which<br />

contributed to the research sessions.<br />

“We have discussed collaboration at length with our<br />

contributors and are struck by how many benefits it can bring:<br />

economies of scale in purchasing and selling; sharing of<br />

specialist machinery and staff; risk management; logistics;<br />

branding and marketing.<br />

“We see great potential in encouraging greater used of<br />

collaboration and building on the excellent, if sometimes<br />

unrecognised, work of the SAOS.”<br />

The paper also highlights the internship scheme run by<br />

Ringling, a business ring owned as a co-op by its members.<br />

<strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong> | 9


AGRICULTURE<br />

Farmers’ co-op brings<br />

the latest superberry<br />

to Scotland<br />

A farming co-op has been formed to bring<br />

a new crop to Scotland, the honeyberry<br />

– which has commercial potential as a<br />

health food and as a fruit wine.<br />

The Scottish Honeyberries co-op,<br />

based in Invergowrie, near Dundee, was<br />

formed in July to develop cultivation<br />

methods and spread knowledge<br />

of the crop.<br />

It is hoped the venture – created with<br />

the help of local food and drink marketing<br />

advisory service Connect Local – will<br />

help make Scotland a world leader in the<br />

production of the berry.<br />

Chairman Stewart Arbuckle, who<br />

brought the plants from Canada and<br />

has created an orchard at Invergowrie,<br />

says the co-op currently includes four<br />

farms, each cultivating between five and<br />

10 acres. He hopes this will increase to<br />

nine farms by the end of the year. “We<br />

have to start small,” he said. “It’s a<br />

question of finding out which varieties are<br />

best for Scottish soil and what is the best<br />

way to grow them.”<br />

The plan is to sell the plants to<br />

other farmers as well as marketing the<br />

berries themselves – which makes the<br />

organisation a knowledge co-operative as<br />

well as a farming co-op, says Mr Arbuckle.<br />

The intention is “to show off our growing<br />

ideas and methods, create a brand, keep a<br />

value of that brand within the co-op”, he<br />

added. “We’re trying to build that knowledge.<br />

Everyone has something to contribute.”<br />

Honeyberries Co-operative is looking at<br />

the health market to take advantage of the<br />

crop’s reputation as superberry – it is high<br />

in vitamin C and antioxidants – and has<br />

developed a frozen smoothie bag.<br />

As well as being suited to Scotland’s soil<br />

and climate, the berry has brix and tannin<br />

levels that make it ideal for winemaking.<br />

“We can’t grow grapes in Scotland,”<br />

said Mr Arbuckle, “so here’s an option for<br />

making Scottish wine.”<br />

ECONOMY<br />

Concern for city’s alternative culture as wood co-op loses its home<br />

An acclaimed wood recycling co-op is<br />

looking for a new base after its tenancy<br />

was terminated by Bristol City Council.<br />

Bristol Wood Recycling Project has been<br />

a mainstay of the city’s alternative scene<br />

for 14 years, and has been praised for<br />

creating jobs, supporting volunteers and<br />

reducing environmental impact.<br />

The council granted the co-op<br />

“meanwhile use” on the land, next to<br />

Temple Meads train station, when it<br />

formed in 2004 but now it wants to sell the<br />

site for development.<br />

Bristol City Council is selling the land<br />

to the University of Bristol to help fill a<br />

hole in its budget after cuts to central<br />

government funding for local authorities.<br />

The co-op is a sustainable business that<br />

reclaims disused wood and turns it into<br />

products including firewood to furniture.<br />

It now has nine paid employees and has<br />

saved more than 4,000 tonnes of wood<br />

from landfill over its lifetime.<br />

It success has promoted apex body<br />

Co-operatives UK to make a film highlight<br />

Bristol Wood Recycling as an example<br />

of how co-ops can make a<br />

difference.<br />

The council is working with<br />

the co-op to identify suitable<br />

site but staff and volunteers<br />

at Bristol Wood Recycling fear<br />

the move could threaten the<br />

alternative identity of the city.<br />

Workshop manager Kaleb<br />

Debbage said: “Social<br />

enterprises like ours add a<br />

valuable layer of social and<br />

environmental resilience to<br />

our communities, a kind of<br />

biodiversity.<br />

“If we continue squeezing them out<br />

of central public spaces we can expect<br />

all kinds of hidden costs as inclusive<br />

support networks and developing circular<br />

economies are marginalised.”<br />

Ed Mayo, secretary general of<br />

Co-operatives UK, said: “Bristol Wood<br />

Recycling is a shining example of how<br />

co-ops can make a difference to local<br />

areas. It has created jobs, has had a huge<br />

environmental impact and crucially it has<br />

p Co-op member Callum Burns at work on the site<br />

helped hundreds of volunteers gain skills,<br />

confidence and support.<br />

“We want to see co-ops like this<br />

springing up everywhere. It’s a shame that<br />

just as we’re calling for more people-led<br />

recycling businesses like this, the model<br />

that inspired us is under threat.”<br />

The business continues to operate as<br />

usual, six days a week, collecting wood<br />

waste, selling reclaimed timber, making<br />

bespoke furniture and hosting volunteers<br />

at Cattle Market Road.<br />

10 | <strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong>


Lincolnshire Co-op members raise £108,000 for local causes<br />

Members of Lincolnshire Co-op have<br />

raised £108,000 for local community<br />

groups through its Community Champions<br />

scheme. More than 147,000 members<br />

helped raise the total by shopping with<br />

their dividend card, with funds going<br />

to 167 groups, ranging from scouts and<br />

sports clubs to health networks.<br />

p The Scottish Parliament building<br />

CREDIT UNIONS<br />

MSPs discuss ways of<br />

working with the credit<br />

union sector<br />

MSPs have met to discuss ways the Scottish<br />

government can work with credit unions.<br />

Scotland’s Cross Party Group on Credit<br />

Unions has met to discuss how the<br />

government can work with the sector to<br />

raise awareness.<br />

This follows the commitment by the<br />

Scottish government to fund promotion<br />

of the sector, announced in this year’s<br />

Programme for Government.<br />

The group, convened by Ruth Maguire<br />

MSP, invited MSPs, credit unions and<br />

stakeholders to the session, where Kenny<br />

Pentland of the Scottish government joined<br />

a discussion which gave several credit<br />

unions the opportunity to express their<br />

view.<br />

The meeting also heard from the Scottish<br />

government on its plans to address funeral<br />

poverty, and their ambition to pilot a new<br />

funeral bond with credit unions.<br />

After the meeting, Ms Maguire said: “The<br />

discussion was engaging and insightful,<br />

and I look forward to seeing both the<br />

campaign and the funeral bond take shape<br />

over the coming months and years. I would<br />

like to thank everyone who came along for<br />

contributing to such a successful evening.”<br />

Karen Hurst, Scottish policy officer at<br />

the Association of British Credit Unions<br />

(ABCUL), which provides the secretariat to<br />

the cross-party group, said “It’s great to see<br />

credit unions in Scotland working together<br />

to influence the government in this way.<br />

We really look forward to continuing<br />

this conversation and ensuring that the<br />

campaign has as much impact as possible.”<br />

Southern Co-op raises £190,000 in funeral charity donations<br />

Branches of the Co-operative Funeralcare<br />

operated by the Southern Co-op are<br />

celebrating after raising more than<br />

£190,000 in charity donations, through<br />

their memorial webpage over the last year.<br />

The online tribute service, run in<br />

partnership with memorial charity<br />

MuchLoved, was set up after growing<br />

numbers of people asked for donations<br />

instead of flowers at funerals.<br />

Top award for Co-operative Childcare manager<br />

A Warwick-based early years professional<br />

has been named Nursery Personality<br />

of the Year at the Nursery Management<br />

Today Nursery Awards. Babita Saroy,<br />

quality excellence manager at the<br />

Co-operative Childcare, impressed<br />

the judges with her drive and passion,<br />

including her work on a programme to<br />

ensure all pre-school children are schoolready<br />

by the time they leave.<br />

Training team gong for the East of England Co-op<br />

The learning and development team<br />

at the East of England Co-operative has<br />

been named Team of the Year at the<br />

Training Journal Awards. It competed<br />

with more than 260 entrants to take the<br />

top title in the category. The team was also<br />

runner–up for the Best Organisational<br />

Development Programme.<br />

Co-op Energy praised for rescue of GB Energy customers<br />

Co-op Energy has won the Customer Care<br />

Award at the 2017 Utility Week Awards<br />

for the way it stepped in to look after<br />

customers of GB Energy when it failed late<br />

last year. Judges said it supplier “bravely<br />

took on a high-risk project, providing a<br />

retailer of last resort for customers who<br />

had nowhere else to turn”.<br />

<strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong> | 11


AWARDS<br />

Plunkett Foundation names winners of the Rural Community Co-op Awards<br />

The 2017 winners of the Rural Community<br />

Co-operative Awards have been<br />

announced by the Plunkett Foundation.<br />

Now in their fifth year, the awards<br />

showcase the co-ops that have made a<br />

real difference to individuals within their<br />

communities, from helping to overcome<br />

social isolation and loneliness, to address<br />

specific health issues.<br />

Barkers of Huby in North Yorkshire<br />

won the Yorkshire and North East England<br />

Award, sponsored by SUMA Wholefoods.<br />

Judges commended the group for:<br />

Old Crown Co-operative (The Old<br />

Crown) in Cumbria won the North West<br />

England Award, presented by Prince’s<br />

Countryside Fund.<br />

Bamford Community Society (The<br />

Angler’s Rest) in Derbyshire won the<br />

Midlands Award, sponsored by BCRS<br />

Business Loans.<br />

Rocklands Community Shop in<br />

Norfolk won the East of England Award,<br />

presented by Fram Farmers. Judges were<br />

particularly impressed with:<br />

p Winners included the Ewelme Village Store<br />

Ewelme Village Store in Oxfordshire<br />

won the South East England Award,<br />

sponsored by the Phone Co-op.<br />

Exbourne & Jacobstowe Community<br />

Association (The Burrow) in Devon won<br />

the South West England Award, sponsored<br />

by the Retail Mutual.<br />

GlenWyvis Distillery in Dingwall won<br />

the Scotland Award, sponsored by the<br />

Co-operative Group.<br />

Cletwr Shop in Machynlleth won<br />

the Wales Award, presented by Wales<br />

Co-operative Centre.<br />

Raglan Community Development &<br />

AWARDS<br />

Credit Union Awards<br />

recognise performance<br />

and education work<br />

Credit union practitioners have been<br />

honoured at the Edward Filene Credit<br />

Union Awards and the Joe Biden<br />

Development Educator Awards.<br />

The ceremony took place in London and<br />

featured Marlene Shiels, chief executive of<br />

Capital Credit Union in Edinburgh.<br />

“We have work to do,” she said at the<br />

ceremony. “Let all of us be the one who<br />

makes the difference. Share the values and<br />

ethics of credit unions with all you meet.”<br />

Ms Shiels is one of the small number of<br />

people from the credit union movement in<br />

the UK and overseas be given an OBE, for<br />

her contribution to financial services and<br />

financial inclusion.<br />

The Joe Biden Awards for Development<br />

Educators from around the world<br />

acknowledge the contribution of active<br />

graduate development educators. Their<br />

qualifications denote the development<br />

educator courses they took.<br />

This year’s winners were:<br />

Justine Lynn Limocon, PhDE, Lamac<br />

Multi-Purpose Cooperative, Cebu City,<br />

Philippines (Asia);<br />

Paul Dawson, ACDE, First Choice Credit<br />

Union, New South Wales, Australia<br />

(Australasia)<br />

Carla Decker, CUDE, DEUK, CaribDE,<br />

CanadaDE, Academic Director & Lead<br />

Facilitator, Caribbean DE programme<br />

Christina Stoneman, Dragonsavers<br />

Credit Union Ltd, Treorchy, Wales (Europe)<br />

The Edward Filene Awards for<br />

Performance Excellence recognise the<br />

work of credit unions and practitioners<br />

to demonstrate how the sector can be<br />

a viable alternative offering financial<br />

services in Great Britain and Ireland.<br />

Barry Epstein, co-trustee of the ICULD&E<br />

Foundation which promoted the awards,<br />

said: “The standard improves year on year,<br />

being a tribute to standards of delivery of<br />

products and services to the consumer,<br />

giving them an ethical, alternative choice<br />

for their financial affairs.”<br />

The winners were:<br />

Single Benefactor of the Year<br />

(organisation): Karbon Homes<br />

(Derwentside Homes), partners of<br />

Prince Bishops Community Bank,<br />

Stanley, Co. Durham<br />

Single Benefactor to a Credit Union<br />

(individual): Ian Gylee, President,<br />

Dragonsavers Credit Union Ltd, Treorchy<br />

Chief Executive Officer/General<br />

Manager of the Year: Amanda Ivey, Chief<br />

Executive Officer, Commsave Credit Union<br />

Ltd, Northampton<br />

Young Credit Union Leader, either paid<br />

or unpaid and aged between 17 and 35<br />

in 2017: Bethany Moss, South Yorkshire<br />

Credit Union Ltd., Doncaster, S. Yorks<br />

Customer Service Officer of the Year<br />

2017: Christine Bates, Dragonsavers Credit<br />

Union Ltd., Treorchy, Wales<br />

Hosting Saving Schemes for Primary<br />

and Secondary School pupils: Prince<br />

12 | <strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong>


Renovation Society in Ballymena won<br />

the Northern Ireland Award, presented by<br />

Co-operative Alternatives.<br />

Ronald Thorne from Chittlehamholt<br />

Village Shop won the People’s<br />

Choice Award, sponsored by Hastoe<br />

Housing Association. For this award,<br />

co-operatives were asked to nominate an<br />

individual who has made an outstanding<br />

contribution to their enterprise and<br />

therefore their wider community.<br />

When the Post Office in the north<br />

Devon village closed in 2008, Mr Thorne<br />

led efforts to save the service, leading<br />

negotiations which secured a 50-year<br />

lease for a site and leading a fundraising<br />

committee which brought in £10,000.<br />

Five years later, the Chittlehamholt<br />

Community Shop was formally opened.<br />

A statement from the community<br />

supporting Mr Thorne’s nomination said<br />

the shop offers “a social hub and meeting<br />

place for all, particularly the elderly and<br />

lonely. It has a coffee machine and table<br />

and chairs leading to many happy noisy<br />

sessions.<br />

“The shop is much valued and the<br />

untiring work of one man, Ron Thorne,<br />

has made it all a reality.”<br />

p Karen Arbuckle, chair of Co-operative Alternatives, presents the Northern Ireland<br />

award to Tracy Wallace and William Millar of Raglan Community Development and<br />

Renovation Society<br />

Winners will receive a party pack,<br />

sponsored by Power to Change, in the new<br />

year to celebrate their achievement with<br />

their communities.<br />

They were chosen from a shortlist by<br />

judges from the award sponsors Hastoe<br />

Housing Association, BCRS Business<br />

Loans, SUMA Wholefoods, the Phone<br />

Co-op, Co-op UK, the Retail Mutual, Fram<br />

Farmers, Co-operative & Community<br />

Finance, Charity Bank, WBC and the<br />

Co-operative College.<br />

Bishops Community Bank, Stanley,<br />

Co.Durham<br />

Achieving Business Growth without<br />

resorting to grant funding: Commsave<br />

Credit Union Ltd, Northampton<br />

Trading and Innovation: Prince Bishops<br />

Community Bank, Stanley, Co.Durham<br />

Credit Union serving as a financial<br />

incubator for seed, small and medium<br />

enterprises operated by credit union<br />

owner-members: Killarney Credit Union<br />

Ltd, Killarney, Co.Kerry, Ireland<br />

Credit Union Advocacy with local and<br />

national politicians: Joint winners –<br />

Dragonsavers Credit Union Ltd, Treorchy,<br />

Wales and Prince Bishops Community<br />

Bank, Stanley, Co.Durham<br />

Community Mobilisation and Outreach:–<br />

Killarney Credit Union Ltd, Killarney,<br />

Co.Kerry, Ireland<br />

Dispensing Financial Education to the<br />

entire Common Bond: Prince Bishops<br />

Community Bank, Stanley, Co.Durham<br />

Use of the Media: Salford Credit Union<br />

Ltd, Salford, Greater Manchester<br />

p The trophies on display before the ceremony; speaker Marlene Shiels<br />

Award for making a film describing the<br />

activity of an individual or a credit union:<br />

– Justine Limocon, Lamac Multipurpose<br />

Co-operative, Cebu City, Philippines<br />

“Beacon” Credit Union of the Year<br />

2017: Commsave Credit Union Ltd,<br />

Northampton<br />

Edward Filene Supreme Award<br />

for Social Entrepreneurship 2017:<br />

Prince Bishops Community Bank,<br />

the credit union that has achieved the<br />

highest aggregate score over all the<br />

categories of performance excellence<br />

open to it.<br />

<strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong> | 13


GLOBAL UPDATES<br />

USA<br />

NCBA CLUSA working on project to improve nutrition in Senegal<br />

The US co-op apex body NCBA CLUSA says<br />

it is continuing its development work in<br />

Senegal to develop a system of “nutritionled<br />

agriculture”.<br />

This follows the announcement of<br />

a new $40m Feed the Future project,<br />

funded by the US Agency for International<br />

Development (USAID).<br />

The Feed the Future Senegal Cultivating<br />

Nutrition Project began last month and<br />

will run through 2022, with the goal of<br />

reaching over half a million children<br />

under the age of five and their families<br />

with nutrition interventions.<br />

It will focus on nutrition and will build<br />

on the foundation of the Feed the Future<br />

Yaajeende programme, which reduced<br />

child stunting by 30% and poverty by 7%<br />

in 800 villages; this lifted approximately<br />

56,000 people above the poverty line,<br />

despite four years of recurrent drought<br />

and weather crises.<br />

Senegal has made progress in the fight<br />

against child undernutrition, according<br />

to a 2017 study by the International Food<br />

Policy Research Institute, and the Feed<br />

the Future Cultivating Nutrition project<br />

will build on this.<br />

“We are very excited that this new<br />

project will allow more Senegalese<br />

households and communities to build<br />

on what we have learned in addressing<br />

undernutrition,” said Amy Coughenour<br />

Betancourt, NCBA CLUSA’s chief operating<br />

officer for international programs.<br />

p A Senegalese couple on their rice farm (Photo Stéphane Tourné)<br />

The new project will see NCBA CLUSA<br />

train and support local institutions to<br />

lead their own community development.<br />

It hopes this will allow communities “to<br />

sustainably increase consumption of<br />

nutritious and safe diets”.<br />

Other goals are to increase the supply of<br />

diverse, micro-nutrient rich foods, increased<br />

resilience and income and increased<br />

adoption of nutrition and care practices.<br />

The project aims to improve the<br />

governance of food systems in 3,500<br />

villages across 150 communes in 10<br />

regions – reaching 285,000 households<br />

and 2.8 million people over five years.<br />

The project will build out a food systems<br />

approach pioneered by the Yaajeende<br />

Project – Nutrition Led Agriculture, which<br />

“integrates nutrition at every point of the<br />

agriculture value chain”.<br />

This will involve partnerships with<br />

local, regional and national private and<br />

public sector organisations including<br />

mother’s groups, citizen working groups,<br />

community-based solution Providers,<br />

businesses and research institutions.<br />

Partners with NCBA CLUSA on the<br />

programme are Hellen Keller International,<br />

JSI Research and Training Institute, Inc,<br />

Sheladia Associates and Dimagi.<br />

EUROPE<br />

Co-op banks<br />

urge action to create<br />

favourable regulation<br />

The European Association of Co-operative<br />

Banks (EACB) has called on the European<br />

Commission (EC) to improve regulations to<br />

help the sector offer sustainable finance.<br />

In a meeting hosted by MEP Sirpa<br />

Pietikäinen at the European Parliament,<br />

the EACB presented its latest policy paper,<br />

which includes suggestions on regulatory<br />

and supervisory changes and incentives.<br />

Co-op banks across Europe have<br />

58,000 outlets and 209m clients, and the<br />

paper highlights their role in sustainable<br />

financing. They provide sustainable<br />

investments and savings products; finance<br />

for energy transition projects; green<br />

financing to SMEs; finance for energy<br />

efficiency; and, through their social<br />

mission, reinvest significant portions of<br />

profits in the community.<br />

But the EACB warns that the complexity<br />

and continuous motion of the regulatory<br />

framework harms local co-op banks,<br />

and could lead to a less diverse banking<br />

environment. It wants a standard<br />

taxonomy for sustainable assets, and<br />

the promotion of a low-carbon market<br />

for retail banking activity with adapted<br />

commercial tools.<br />

It also calls for a stable legislative and<br />

regulatory framework that is conducive<br />

to a diverse range of business models of<br />

financial institutions, which would create<br />

an ecosystem which sustains different<br />

needs and longer-term approaches.<br />

“Acting in favour of sustainable<br />

financing is in the very nature of co-op<br />

banks whose mission is to accompany<br />

members and clients, as well as their<br />

communities, in the long term,” said<br />

Etienne Pflimlin, chair of the EACB<br />

Task Force on Sustainable Finance.<br />

14 | <strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong>


NEW ZEALAND<br />

Fonterra launches plan to improve country’s waterways<br />

New Zealand’s dairy giant Fonterra<br />

is looking to improve the quality of<br />

the country’s waterways through an<br />

environmental plan based on six strategic<br />

commitments.<br />

The co-op, which is owned by 10,500<br />

farmers, makes up 25% of the country’s<br />

exports. The initiative is part of Fonterra’s<br />

Tiaki Sustainable Dairy Programme,<br />

which touched upon farm environment<br />

plans for all suppliers, consent support,<br />

nitrogen reports, farm mapping and plans<br />

around managing riparian and effluent.<br />

Miles Hurrell, chief operating officer<br />

at Fonterra Farm Source, said: “Like<br />

all Kiwis, we want healthy rivers. Our<br />

farmers have spent over NZ$1bn on<br />

environmental initiatives over the past<br />

five years and fenced more than 98% of<br />

significant waterways on the farm. That’s<br />

a major undertaking but it highlights<br />

our commitment to getting this right and<br />

we’re already seeing that in some regions<br />

these actions are having a positive impact<br />

on water quality.<br />

“All intensive land uses have had an<br />

impact on water quality in this country.<br />

That’s why we have to work together to<br />

address the issue. Today, we’re putting<br />

up our hands and promising to work<br />

with communities to promote healthy<br />

waterways for Kiwis to enjoy. Importantly,<br />

we’re backing up our words with action<br />

and making tangible commitments that<br />

we believe will make a real difference."<br />

The co-op has also recently pledged<br />

to restore 50 key freshwater catchments.<br />

p The co-op carried out clean water projects in the Waituna lagoon (Photo: Shellie)<br />

Its six commitments include farming<br />

within regional environmental limits<br />

and encouraging strong environmental<br />

farming practices. In addition, Fonterra<br />

promises to reduce water use and improve<br />

wastewater quality at manufacturing<br />

plants and investing in science and<br />

innovation to find new solutions.<br />

Another commitment is to build<br />

partnerships to improve waterway health<br />

and make the products people value<br />

most. As part of this plan, Fonterra sets<br />

out some clear actions such as supporting<br />

regional councils to set environmental<br />

limits for water use, investing $250m to<br />

drive a 20% reduction in water use across<br />

its 26 manufacturing sites and doubling<br />

the Co-operatives Network of Sustainable<br />

Dairy Advisors.<br />

The co-op has set a target that by<br />

2025 all of its farmers will have a farm<br />

environmental plan as part of their supply<br />

agreement. Currently, 95% of its farmers<br />

have nitrogen management reports,<br />

which reduces the risk of leaching.<br />

Furthermore, around 2.4bn litres of water<br />

at its NZ manufacturing sites are recycled<br />

or reused. Overall Fonterra farmers have<br />

invested $1bn in environmental initiatives<br />

over the last five years.<br />

“We’re keen to show New Zealanders<br />

the hard work going on behind the farm<br />

gate, so on 10 December, we hosted one<br />

of New Zealand’s largest ever community<br />

open days, giving people across the<br />

country the chance to visit one of 40 farms<br />

and see what we’re doing for themselves,”<br />

added Mr Hurrell.<br />

“Households, local communities and local<br />

entrepreneurs are mobilising in favour of<br />

climate. Co-op banks are on their side.<br />

“However, international initiatives are<br />

often too focused on the capital and asset<br />

management side. We believe a greater<br />

emphasis shall be put on the retail side<br />

of sustainable financing by providing a<br />

tools and policies that are conducive of<br />

green growth in the regions via SMEs,<br />

households and local actors. Co-operative<br />

banks shall be closely involved.”<br />

Ms Pietikäinen, rapporteur for the<br />

circular economy and former Finnish<br />

minister of environment, responded:<br />

“Resource scarcity and environmental<br />

risks should be incorporated in financial<br />

legislation inter alia concerning credit<br />

ratings, capital requirements, insurances,<br />

financial product information, accounting<br />

and auditing. Capital markets can<br />

also be reoriented towards long-term<br />

sustainability through the integration of<br />

environmental factors.<br />

“These are aspects that I look forward<br />

to emphasising as the Parliament starts its<br />

deliberations on the Capital Requirements<br />

Directive. Co-op banks, with their local<br />

focus, play an important role in this<br />

and we must preserve it, for example<br />

with proportionality. I look forward to<br />

continuing this discussion with EACB.”<br />

p Sirpa Pietikäinen (Photo: Leila Paul)<br />

<strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong> | 15


p Refugee children are getting the chance to learn thanks to the school bus project (Photos: Co-operative Party)<br />

FRANCE<br />

Co-operative Schools Network supports Calais refugee bus classroom<br />

A yellow bus sponsored by the<br />

Co-operative Schools Network has become<br />

a pop-up school for refugee children in<br />

Calais, France.<br />

The initiative is based on the idea of<br />

sharing learning expertise and has been<br />

funded through a crowdfunding campaign<br />

launched by the Co-op Schools Network.<br />

Around 70 refugee children, from<br />

countries including from Eritrea, Ethiopia,<br />

Afghanistan and Libya, meet inside the<br />

bus twice a day where they take part in<br />

discussions, music sessions and other<br />

learning activities.<br />

They receive support with improving<br />

their English and touch upon themes like<br />

identity, health and well-being, art and<br />

place. The bus provides a shelter where<br />

they can play games and cards and study<br />

while staying warm. The youngest student<br />

is aged 10 and comes from Afghanistan.<br />

Upstairs on the bus are three<br />

compartments: the main teaching area<br />

supports around 20 students improving<br />

their English through themes such as<br />

Identity, Health and Well-being, Art and<br />

Place. A middle area is for games and cards,<br />

with banter and chatter shaping maths,<br />

language and problem solving experience.<br />

At the front is a quiet study room for four<br />

people, dedicated to those who need a<br />

retreat, a place for counselling or personal<br />

reflection.<br />

The bus also has onboard solar power, so<br />

the pupils to recharge their mobile phones<br />

to help them stay in touch with home.<br />

The refugee camp known as the Calais<br />

Jungle was demolished nine months ago<br />

leaving many refugee children without<br />

shelters. It is estimated that over 200 child<br />

refugees are living rough in Calais, where<br />

they have no sanitation or clean water.<br />

The project, which is run on cooperative<br />

lines, is led by a team of unpaid<br />

volunteers, including some of the refugees<br />

themselves. The driver and two lead<br />

educators are joined on the sceheme by<br />

volunteers from other projects including<br />

Help Refugees, Refugee Youth Service and<br />

Refugee InfoBus.<br />

The School Bus Project was set up in<br />

2015 to support refugee education, in<br />

response to the crisis in France. Between<br />

2015 and 2016 the team developed<br />

lesson plans, training and mobile school<br />

resources. In addition to the Big Yellow<br />

Bus, they also run a red minibus with<br />

17 seats.<br />

Now a registered UK charity, the<br />

School Bus Project has run refugee<br />

education projects in Calais as well as<br />

other countries. Over the past 12 months<br />

the team has funded four months of<br />

primary maths teaching in Northern<br />

Greece camps, provided transport for Kent<br />

Refugee Action Network field visits and<br />

curriculum enrichment and supported a<br />

UK based refugee catering employment<br />

training project.<br />

“The gist of this is that we know<br />

we cannot always deliver a heroically<br />

personal response to the massive issues<br />

of refugee needs, but we believe we can<br />

make a difference by empowering and<br />

supporting others,” wrote Jon O’Conner,<br />

UK project lead at the School Bus Project<br />

in a blog post.<br />

He added: “If you want to join us,<br />

support us, advise us or encourage us - do<br />

get in touch.”<br />

The Co-operative Schools network says<br />

the project draws on the values whcih<br />

inform thousands of co-operative schools<br />

around the world.<br />

The schools share a commitment to<br />

local accountability and to achieving<br />

the highest possible standards and best<br />

learning outcomes for their pupils, by<br />

working with their communities and with<br />

each other.<br />

16 | <strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong>


USA<br />

‘Built on the power of the co-op’: Another<br />

alliance for Texas electric co-operatives<br />

Texas Electric Co-operatives has formed<br />

an alliance with Comanche Electric<br />

Cooperative (CECA), one of North Central<br />

Texas’ top electric co-ops.<br />

The agreement brings approximately<br />

5,000 miles of line and more than 16,000<br />

meters in seven counties into areas already<br />

served by TEC alliance partnerships.<br />

“This is an important alliance,”<br />

said Johnny Andrews, chief operating<br />

officer of TEC Manufacturing &<br />

Distribution Services. “Comanche<br />

Electric Cooperative is a vital part of the<br />

infrastructure serving North Central<br />

Texans. We are eager to work with them as<br />

they deliver power to their members.”<br />

Alan Lesley, general manager of CECA,<br />

said: “Comanche Electric Cooperative is<br />

built on the power of the co-operative.<br />

Through the alliance partnership with<br />

TEC, we look forward to taking the power<br />

of the co-operative to the next level<br />

for our members.”<br />

TEC now has 22 alliance partnerships,<br />

developed to strengthen the co-op<br />

sector in a competitive market; the<br />

previous alliance, with Greenbelt Electric<br />

Co-operative, was formed in October.<br />

TEC provides members with many<br />

services, but says the alliance supply<br />

model is especially notable because it<br />

immediately reduces operational and<br />

redundant costs, benefiting each co-op’s<br />

bottom line.<br />

The partnerships also mean it can<br />

leveraging aggregation and scale to<br />

obtain high-quality products from leading<br />

manufacturers at competitive prices.<br />

Texas Electric Cooperatives, formed in<br />

1941, represents 75 electric co-ops with<br />

more than 3 million members, and offers<br />

a full line of utility supplies and services.<br />

INVESTING IN A<br />

BRIGHTER FUTURE FOR AFRICA<br />

Invest in pioneering businesses that install life-changing<br />

solar systems in Sub-Saharan Africa – bringing clean<br />

energy and economic opportunities to families, whilst<br />

aiming to generate up to 6% annual return for investors.<br />

Help people like Patience in Uganda to obtain solar<br />

systems that allow them to support their families by<br />

establishing successful businesses.<br />

Find out more – www.lendahand.co.uk<br />

Capital is at risk and returns are not guaranteed.<br />

These are fixed-term bonds and funds cannot<br />

be withdrawn until the end of the term.<br />

<strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong> | 17


SPAIN<br />

Blockchain offers competitive advantage to renewable energy co-ops<br />

A team of Spanish engineers is developing<br />

a Blockchain platform to enable renewable<br />

energy co-ops to exchange the power<br />

they generate.<br />

The Pylon Network wants to create the<br />

first open, renewable energy exchange<br />

community. Its users will be able to<br />

exchange green energy, bought directly<br />

from renewable energy co-ops.<br />

To exchange the power generated from<br />

solar panels using the decentralised<br />

platform, Pylon Network has created its<br />

own cryptocurrency – Pylon Coin.<br />

The network’s reward system is based<br />

around servers called “green miners”,<br />

said Gerard Bel, one of the founders of<br />

Pylon Network.<br />

“The green miners are like servers<br />

validating transactions,” he explained.<br />

“As in the case of Bitcoin, the miners are<br />

big computers which solve the algorithm<br />

to secure the data,” he added.<br />

A start-up working for energy solutions,<br />

Pylon Network was formed three years<br />

ago but only took off in 2016.<br />

Me Bel said the technology means<br />

users can constantly monitor their energy<br />

consumption and be charged based on<br />

a “live” electricity price; this enables<br />

them to modify their energy habits to<br />

avoid consumption during high-price<br />

pThe team hope to expand their operation to other countries<br />

periods, reducing the cost of electricity for<br />

the co-operative.<br />

To finance the project, Pylon Network<br />

launched an initial token sale of<br />

Blockchain cryptocurrency. It will now<br />

run a pilot project with a renewable energy<br />

co-op in the Basque Country, Goiener<br />

Cooperative. The pilot will last for one<br />

year, with a limited number of customers.<br />

Pylon-Token is based on Ethereum.<br />

The team behind Pylon Network has<br />

pre-mined 3,750,000 Pylon-Tokens, from<br />

which 3,250,000 will be offered at the<br />

token sale. The remaining 500,000 will be<br />

used to fund all operations of the project<br />

development by the team and partners.<br />

Investors participating in the initial<br />

sale of tokens will receive a share of the<br />

pre-mined Pylon-Tokens. For the Pylon<br />

Network purposes, Pylon-Coin is used,<br />

based – this time – on the core algorithm<br />

of FairCoin a cryptocurrency developed<br />

by FairCoop.<br />

The project is focused on the Spanish<br />

market but plans to expand to other<br />

countries, particularly the UK and<br />

Germany. There are around 20 renewable<br />

energy co-ops operating in Spain. GoiENER<br />

is a qualified and certified player in<br />

the wholesale Spanish energy market<br />

and is supporting the project by being<br />

the first adaptors during the pilot<br />

demonstration stage through the<br />

development of the project.<br />

Mr Bel thinks Blockchain has a strong<br />

appeal to renewable energy co-ops<br />

because it allows greater transparency<br />

and more security due its decentralisation.<br />

USA<br />

US agri co-ops<br />

expand soy crushing<br />

capacity to meet rising<br />

global demand<br />

Agri co-ops in the USA are building<br />

soybean crushing plants at the fastest rate<br />

in 20 years as demand soars for the crop to<br />

make livestock feed.<br />

The new plants will have the capacity<br />

to process at least 120 million bushels of<br />

the crop in 2019, an increase of 5% and the<br />

highest since 1997-8.<br />

Reuters has reported that farmers in<br />

the US, the world’s top soy producer, are<br />

planning to sow another record area.<br />

The rise of a new global middle class<br />

with money to spend on meat increased<br />

the demand for animal feed, with industry<br />

experts predicting production of soy will<br />

have to rise 20% over the next decade.<br />

This increased demand has increased<br />

margins at crushing plants to more than a<br />

$1 per bushel, the strongest for 18 months,<br />

according to financial exchange company<br />

CME Group.<br />

“Margins on soybean processing were<br />

very good, some of the best we’ve had in<br />

many years. And when the industry has<br />

good margins, you expand production,”<br />

Mark Sandeen, vice president of product<br />

marketing at farmer co-op Ag Processing<br />

Inc (AGP) told Reuters.<br />

AGP, the largest farmer-owned soybean<br />

processor in the world, has already started<br />

work a new soy plant in Aberdeen, South<br />

Dakota, that will have an annual capacity<br />

to process 40 million bushels.<br />

It is owned by local and regional co-ops<br />

representing over 250,000 farmers from<br />

16 states throughout the US. and Canada,<br />

and already operates nine soybean<br />

processing plants.<br />

Another of the new plants is being built<br />

by North Dakota Soybean Processors<br />

(NDSP), which is working on a similarsized<br />

facility on an 80-acre site near the<br />

town of Spiritwood.<br />

NDSP says the plant will offer an<br />

integrated soybean crush facility and<br />

refinery to produce soybean meal, refined,<br />

bleached and deodorised oil and biodiesel.<br />

It has completed a feasibility study and<br />

a preliminary front-end engineering<br />

and design study for the estimated $287<br />

million project.<br />

The new plants are expected to increase<br />

demand for local soybeans, which could<br />

be pushing up prices that farmers nearby<br />

will receive for their crops, and reducing<br />

transport costs.<br />

18 | <strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong>


FRANCE<br />

Co-operative<br />

cryptocurrency venture<br />

launched in France<br />

An open-source blockchain co-op has<br />

been set up in France to operate a cryptco<br />

currency.<br />

ARK Ecosystem was incorporated as a<br />

Co-operative Society of Collective Interest<br />

(SCIC), a French model, on the suggestion<br />

of François-Xavier Thoorens, one of the<br />

co-op’s 26 founding members. The team<br />

sought legal advice from a French law firm<br />

and realised the model would be the most<br />

suitable for their project.<br />

The SCIC structure allows employees,<br />

users, volunteers, public bodies,<br />

companies, and associations to act<br />

together to in a legal framework to govern<br />

an entity. The format also allows public<br />

institutions to become shareholders if<br />

seen fit by the board. As with other types<br />

of co-ops, the principle of one member,<br />

one vote applies.<br />

Another requirement is for a SCIC to<br />

keep at least 52.5% of the company’s<br />

profits as legal reserves. Since Ark plans<br />

to hold 100% of any profits for use in<br />

development, marketing, and operations,<br />

the model was seen as the perfect fit.<br />

The co-op, whose members hail from<br />

a dozen different countries, raised US<br />

$750,000 via its ARK Token Exchange<br />

Campaign (TEC). This was lower than<br />

the $1m they hoped for but the team is<br />

continuing to develop the platform.<br />

Its main objective will be to create<br />

blockchain ecosystems. The business<br />

will use technology to offer customers<br />

smart contracts, mobile wallets and faster<br />

transactions. They are also integrating<br />

different programming languages to<br />

allow more flexibility within the world<br />

of developers.<br />

Via its smart bridge technology, Ark aims<br />

to position itself as the “cryptocurrency<br />

of cryptocurrencies”, creating a platform<br />

that connects currencies and blockchains<br />

so that token holders can have a unified<br />

platform to execute smart contracts and<br />

other blockchain-based interactions.<br />

“RK has been envisioned as an<br />

ecosystem from its very beginning,”<br />

founder member and chief financial<br />

officer Lars Rensin wrote in a blog post.<br />

“The founders believe in decentralised<br />

blockchain technology — working toward<br />

a global and inclusive community. It is<br />

only fitting that our legal entity aspire<br />

to these same visions. Inclusion of<br />

all involved is the ultimate objective:<br />

companies, users, token holders,<br />

delegates of the DPoS network, technical<br />

staff, academic advisers, employees, as<br />

well as public institutions.<br />

“The SCIC is a co-operative form<br />

of incorporation that addresses this<br />

objective. This type of legal entity<br />

offers the structural framework to<br />

achieve ARK’s innovative goals as an<br />

open source software project. The cooperative<br />

structure will naturally speed<br />

up development and adoption of the<br />

technology, and strengthen the value of<br />

the ARK Token.”<br />

The Midcounties Co-operative is the largest independent co-operative in<br />

the UK and is an innovative co-operative business owned by our members.<br />

We operate across a number of sectors including, Food retail, Energy,<br />

Travel, Childcare nurseries, Healthcare and Funeral services.<br />

JOB VACANCY<br />

Chief Operating Officer<br />

Funeral Services<br />

Following a review of our Executive leadership requirements, we are now<br />

seeking the appointment of a permanent Chief Operating Officer to lead our<br />

funeral services operations. Reporting to the Chief Executive for trading, the<br />

Six figure package<br />

successful applicant will have full budgetary control for all of funeral services<br />

operations, including 83 funeral homes and logistics and support centres.<br />

Drawing from previous experience, the role holder will be accountable for all aspects of Funeral services providing direction and<br />

leadership to the operational teams ensuring they fulfil their objectives to deliver the group’s strategic objectives.<br />

Accountability will also extend to all aspects of people performance within the Funeral group, including training, development<br />

and succession planning. This will include optimising operational efficiency and standardising policies and procedures to<br />

ensure financial and overall business targets are met. Our funeral services group has an excellent reputation based on the<br />

highest standards of client service and the successful applicant will need to demonstrate a track record in service excellence<br />

along with a strong degree of understanding relating to the sector.<br />

As a member of the senior leadership team, the role holder will be expected to contribute to the wider business strategies<br />

and represent the Society within local and business communities. Candidates should be degree educated (or equivalent)<br />

from a senior funeral, service or retail background with extensive experience in managing and developing similar operations.<br />

To apply for the role, send your CV to:<br />

kelly.shorthouse@midcounties.coop<br />

<strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong> | 19


How an Egyptian co-op has made<br />

strides towards gender equality<br />

EQUALITY<br />

BY ARCHIE PEARSON,<br />

CLIENT AND OFFICE<br />

EXECUTIVE FOR<br />

OIKOCREDIT<br />

For many of the poorest people in Egypt, life can be<br />

tough. With a population of 95 million, Egypt is one<br />

of the fastest growing and most densely populated<br />

countries in the world. Competition for jobs and<br />

resources runs high. People with less education<br />

and fewer skills face tremendous obstacles to<br />

employment and can struggle to improve their<br />

living standards and lift themselves out of poverty.<br />

Additionally, societal norms expect women<br />

to stay at home and not work. Low pay, lack of<br />

access to diverse vocations, financial literacy and<br />

economic resources are just a few of the forms of<br />

discrimination affecting women.<br />

A significant proportion of the world’s poor live<br />

in rural areas, and around two billion adults lack<br />

access to the necessary financial services they need<br />

to start a business and build a path out of poverty.<br />

In September 2015, the United Nations launched<br />

the sustainable development goals (SDGs) with<br />

a vision to end poverty, overcome inequality and<br />

injustice, tackle climate change and ensure a<br />

quality education for all by 2030. The Sustainable<br />

Development Solutions Network estimates that it<br />

will cost around $1.4tn (£920bn) each year to meet<br />

these 17 goals. Governments alone will not be able<br />

to foot the total bill, so the investment community<br />

must step up. This is where the social investment<br />

co-op Oikocredit steps in, where I work as client<br />

and office executive in the UK.<br />

During a trip to the Egyptian desert, I met with<br />

one co-op that is tackling the problems in Egypt<br />

head-on is Sekem. Founded in 1977, Sekem focuses<br />

on supporting rural farming communities using<br />

social impact investment to introduce fair trade<br />

principles, adopt biodynamic farming methods,<br />

and transform areas of desert land into fertile<br />

soil for producing organic herbs, teas, spices and<br />

other crops.<br />

During the trip, I observed how impact investment<br />

can have a positive impact on disadvantaged<br />

groups while supporting the SDGs.<br />

Sekem uses impact investment to enhance the<br />

education of smallholder farmers and their families.<br />

They have established a nursery, kindergarten, and<br />

primary, secondary and vocational schools, as<br />

well as the Heliopolis University to serve the local<br />

population from childhood through to adulthood.<br />

Thomas Abouleish, son-in-law of Sekem founder,<br />

Ibrahim Abouleish, showed me one four of Sekem’s<br />

schools, citing his motto: “We are tearing down the<br />

adult gender walls, ensuring they are not rebuilt for<br />

the next generation.”<br />

20 | <strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong>


LOW PAY... FINANCIAL LITERACY<br />

AND ECONOMIC RESOURCES<br />

ARE JUST A FEW OF THE<br />

FORMS OF DISCRIMINATION<br />

AFFECTING WOMEN.<br />

From childhood to adulthood, both genders are<br />

taught the skills they need for working life, as well<br />

as a vision of gender equality as the foundation for<br />

sustainable human development.<br />

From primary school upwards, discrimination is<br />

ironed out, and messages of respect and equality<br />

are ingrained.<br />

Sekem’s vocational school is a unique<br />

educational establishment in Egypt. It provides<br />

inclusive, quality education and skills development<br />

for future employment, and gives schoolgirls an<br />

equal right to learn diverse vocations that were<br />

previously labelled as male-only.<br />

Professions such as mechanics, plumbing,<br />

carpentry, agriculture, electronic technology and<br />

welding are among those now being adopted by<br />

girls, whereas in the past they tended to choose<br />

textiles or administration partly for fear of breaking<br />

societal norms.<br />

Two Sekem girls are now apprentice carpenters;<br />

four are studying to become electricians and, for the<br />

first time, Sekem’s head of electronic technology is<br />

female. Vocational classes also extend to girls in<br />

neighbouring communities so they can learn under<br />

the tutelage of experienced professionals.<br />

For adults, ongoing<br />

technical and vocational<br />

education plays a pivotal<br />

role in teaching lifechanging<br />

skills to both<br />

genders. Courses on<br />

farming techniques,<br />

sustainable development<br />

training, supply chain<br />

management, financial<br />

literacy and money<br />

management are also<br />

held, as well as gender<br />

awareness training.<br />

Konstanze Abouleish,<br />

commercial manager for<br />

Nature Tex – an organic textile company which is<br />

part of Sekem – explains that “awareness days”<br />

give men and women an equal opportunity to voice<br />

discomfort and help develop collaboration.<br />

The children’s nursery, built in 2013, frees up<br />

local women to study, work and earn their income<br />

without having to worry about childcare. At the top<br />

end of the educational tree is Heliopolis University.<br />

Graduates have included female physicians who<br />

have gone on to run Sekem’s pharmacy and health<br />

clinic, which provide affordable services to more<br />

than 41,000 people.<br />

My last day in Egypt was spent celebrating<br />

Sekem’s 39th anniversary where men, women,<br />

boys and girls share sentiments about equality<br />

and respect. I am struck by how innovatively this<br />

co-operative has used impact investing to build an<br />

education system that addresses gender inequality<br />

at its roots, at the same time developing a network<br />

of sustainable work and economic growth for<br />

previously disadvantaged farming communities.<br />

Yet I am also reminded of how much more<br />

the investment community might need to do if we<br />

are all to achieve the global goals 13 short years<br />

from now.<br />

<strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong> | 21


HOME SWEET HOME<br />

p The new housing development is in the impressive building that once housed a police academy<br />

HOUSING<br />

BY DAVID J THOMPSON<br />

David J. Thompson has<br />

visited Soldier On twice<br />

for this piece. He has<br />

written several articles on<br />

veterans’ housing co-ops<br />

and worked on the<br />

California legislation<br />

and successful bond<br />

measure in 2014 which<br />

made $1bn available to<br />

house veterans. He is a<br />

partner in Neighborhood<br />

Partners, LLC which builds<br />

non-profit housing in<br />

California<br />

When the first 51 homeless US veterans were given<br />

the keys to their own housing co-op last month,<br />

it was a potent sign of how the movement can<br />

transform people’s lives.<br />

The co-op, in Agawam, Massachussetts, offers its<br />

new residents not just a roof over their heads, but<br />

a new start and a range of services to support them<br />

on their journey.<br />

It is the second Gordon H. Mansfield Veterans’<br />

Community to open in the state, with the first<br />

opened in nearby Pittsfield, in 2010. They are<br />

limited equity co-operatives set up by local veterans<br />

organisation, Soldier On.<br />

The Pittsfield co-op provides housing for 39<br />

veterans in a community of all newly built housing.<br />

Members must invest $2,500 to obtain a share<br />

in the co-op when they join – a problem for many<br />

homeless ex-servicemen. Fortunately, Soldier On<br />

has worked with a number credit unions and banks<br />

to create a pool of funds. Those dollars can be<br />

donated or lent to prospective members.<br />

When he moved in to Agawam, Anthony Wilson,<br />

told his case manager: “Walking into my unit<br />

brought tears to my eyes. This is my home and no<br />

one can take that away from me.”<br />

For Soldier On, based in Northampton,<br />

Massachussetts, the Agawam co-op was a key<br />

chapter at the end of a near ten-year struggle to<br />

establish the site as a veterans’ community.<br />

When the team set their eyes on the empty former<br />

home of the Western Massachusetts Regional<br />

Police Academy it was love at first sight. It had<br />

classic architecture of white columns highlighting<br />

the stately four-storey building and the seven acres<br />

of landscaped open space. It would surely be an<br />

uplifting palace for poverty-stricken veterans.<br />

The site was given to Soldier On by the State of<br />

Massachusetts for $1 in 2010, when state Lt. Gov.<br />

Timothy P. Murray said it was “a generational<br />

responsibility” to help the nation’s veterans.<br />

State Rep. Rosemary Sandlin, D-Agawam, who<br />

initiated the project and filed the state bill to allow<br />

for the sale of the property for $1, characterised the<br />

project as “a hand up, not a handout”.<br />

At the time, it was expected that the veterans<br />

would move in two years later – but delays meant it<br />

would not be until September 2017 that the Academy<br />

was re-opened as a permanent, supportive and<br />

sustainable community. A dedication ceremony<br />

last month signalled the successful move in.<br />

Just prior to the September dedication ceremony,<br />

I spoke to Bruce Buckley, chief executive of Soldier<br />

On, about the Agawam project.<br />

He said: “One of the key foundations is that every<br />

programme begins with a human relationship and<br />

that through professional support and service,<br />

Soldier On would help build a sense of community<br />

where the resident veterans would take ownership.”<br />

Numerous federal, state and local officials took<br />

part in the September dedication ceremony. After<br />

all, funds to make the community a reality were<br />

given by many different hands.<br />

The development consists of 47 one-bedroom<br />

apartments of 475 sq ft each, and four studios. Each<br />

22 | <strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong>


t Doug Field, joint<br />

CEO of East of England<br />

Co-operative<br />

p New resident Anthony Wilson<br />

p Inside one of the new apartments<br />

has been supplied with a TV that also servesas ae<br />

computer, which is tied into a Soldier On service<br />

desk where the resident veterans can get immediate<br />

help and support through Skype or text.<br />

Although these dual-purpose units are expensive<br />

to put in, Soldier On feels they will be important<br />

not to deal with emergencies or medical alerts but<br />

also to build community and announce activities.<br />

Isolation is a major source of depression for<br />

veterans and dealing with this problem that in real<br />

time will be bring positive health impacts.<br />

Homeless veterans who meet HUD VASH (HUD<br />

Veterans Affairs Supportive Housing) and lowincome<br />

housing credit income thresholds are<br />

eligible to be members. The monthly carrying<br />

charge or rent is set at one third of their income.<br />

Once they have moved in there are number of<br />

communal facilities. Mr Buckley said: “We have<br />

two patios with gas grills, a dining area for special<br />

events and social events, a 15x30 greenhouse open<br />

to all, two laundry rooms two onsite office rooms,<br />

and a converted auditorium that houses two units<br />

with the remainder being used as a library and/or<br />

meeting room.”<br />

He added: “We make every effort to use our<br />

resources to maximise the number of apartments<br />

for veterans and we make use of all of the space.<br />

“The path to permanent, independent living<br />

from institutional living requires a conscious effort<br />

to form independent relationships. We promote<br />

socialising by choice in individual apartments,<br />

as most of us do, with community events being<br />

promoted with people outside of the formerly<br />

homeless veteran community, and those in the<br />

community that fits ones interests and lifestyle.”<br />

The organisational structure of the Gordon<br />

Mansfield Agawam Veterans’ Village means the<br />

property is owned for the first 15 years by Agawam<br />

Veterans Village LLC, which used state and federal<br />

historic tax credits to obtain the equity financing.<br />

Gordon Mansfield Veterans’ Village Cooperative-<br />

Agawam is the limited equity co-op, which is the<br />

non-profit partner in the project. After the charter<br />

board, the intent is for the co-op to have four to five<br />

members elected by the residents and one or two<br />

board members appointed to the board from the<br />

Agawam community.<br />

It is named after Gordon Mansfield, a former<br />

deputy secretary of Veterans Affairs, a highly<br />

decorated Army veteran who survived two tours<br />

of duty in Vietnam. As company commander of<br />

the 101st Airborne Division, Mansfield sustained a<br />

spinal cord injury during the 1968 Tet Offensive, for<br />

which he received the Distinguished Service Cross<br />

— the second-highest personal decoration for valor<br />

in combat.<br />

Solder On President, John “Jack” Downing,<br />

conceived and spearheaded the program for<br />

limited equity housing. Just before the dedication,<br />

he said. “Agawam is a community that many of our<br />

people would be comfortable living in,” he said. “It<br />

offers a lot of supportive services, and this building<br />

is on rural property that allows our veterans to live<br />

together and do very, very well.”<br />

Many groups involved in housing veterans are<br />

beginning to take a look at the Solder On’s veteran’s<br />

co-operative housing program that promotes<br />

ownership and involvement.<br />

These two new housing co-ops are not the first<br />

of their kind but there should be many more.<br />

After World War II housing co-ops gave a home to<br />

veterans and their families, helping them to rebuild<br />

their lives.<br />

In an amazing national effort, 46 housing co-ops<br />

for veterans were built in 15 states providing 14,721<br />

units of co-operative housing for 50,000 people.<br />

u<br />

More on Soldier on at www.wesoldieron.org<br />

<strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong> | 23


Looking ahead to<br />

Co-ops offer solutions to the UK’s problems<br />

LOOKING AHEAD<br />

BY ED MAYO,<br />

SECRETARY GENERAL,<br />

CO-OPERATIVES UK<br />

Do it<br />

ourselves<br />

A National Co-operative Development Strategy<br />

pThe Do It Ourselves strategy launched<br />

by Co-operatives UK<br />

With Brexit looming and continuing economic<br />

challenges facing the county, this year has seen<br />

something of a national debate about inequality<br />

and inclusive growth in Britain.<br />

We know that co-ops offer solutions to these big<br />

issues and, in a true spirit of co-operative self-help,<br />

we as a sector took matters into our own hands with<br />

the publication of Do It Ourselves, a new 20-year<br />

strategy to give more people a voice in the economy.<br />

With input from over 500 co-ops it is a call to<br />

action for co-ops large and small. An ambitious<br />

piece of work, it focuses attention on those parts of<br />

the economy where co-operation is sorely needed –<br />

the gig economy, social care, tech workers, student<br />

housing, among others.<br />

It also puts stress on the need for existing<br />

co-ops to be exemplars of co-operation. As such,<br />

we’ve worked closely with our members to create<br />

a series of high-quality resources to help co-ops:<br />

for example, a thorough toolkit for directors, a new<br />

framework for reporting to members, and a guide to<br />

data regulations coming into effect next year. Our<br />

HR service has seen significant growth over the last<br />

twelve or so months too, with more worker co-ops<br />

subscribing to get HR advice and guidance.<br />

And we’ve seen some effective policy wins. Over<br />

the year we have revitalised the Cross Party Group<br />

in Scotland, where interest in worker ownership<br />

and community engagement is growing; we’ve<br />

seen the Labour leadership discuss policy ideas<br />

we have been developing, like co-ops for the selfemployed<br />

and taxi co-ops; and<br />

the government has agreed to<br />

increase the audit requirement<br />

threshold for medium-sized<br />

co-ops, helping to put them on<br />

a level playing field with other<br />

businesses.<br />

Looking ahead, there will<br />

Your invitation<br />

to shape a future<br />

powered by co-operation<br />

be some significant challenges<br />

for co-ops in <strong>2018</strong>. Brexit offers<br />

strategic opportunities for<br />

co-operatives, not least around<br />

co-operation as a way to help small<br />

and medium-sized businesses<br />

compete. And the continued<br />

focus on the future shape of the<br />

pEd Mayo says co-ops must take the lead<br />

economy is one where co-operatives, as people-led<br />

businesses, have a lot to offer.<br />

But the ongoing economic uncertainty of leaving<br />

the European Union, and the impact it may have on<br />

core business costs, is likely to be a worry next year<br />

that will affect what many co-ops do. And more<br />

immediate challenges, like the introduction of new<br />

data regulations in the form GDPR, will also need<br />

to be negotiated to ensure co-ops are compliant in<br />

their use of members’ information.<br />

At a sector-wide level, <strong>2018</strong> is set to be a year of<br />

experimentation in support of the Do It Ourselves<br />

strategy. We’ll be doing more to promote inspiring<br />

co-ops across the UK, with new films of amazing<br />

co-ops and campaigns around the co-operative<br />

economy and Co-operatives Fortnight.<br />

And, because developments around platforms<br />

and technology are coming fast, it’s important for<br />

existing co-ops to keep on innovating and new ones<br />

to emerge that provide fairer ways of organising<br />

in a digital economy. We will be working with<br />

members and partners to support more student<br />

housing co-ops, helping to incubate new tech coops<br />

and scoping approaches to joint procurement<br />

for co-ops.<br />

The world is moving fast at the moment. I’ve<br />

been pleased to see co-ops taking leadership on<br />

some big issues last year and it’s vital we continue<br />

to do so over the next year.<br />

24 | <strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong>


<strong>2018</strong><br />

Q&A<br />

Leading co-operators reflect on<br />

the past 12 months and discuss<br />

their hopes for the coming year<br />

Claire McCarthy, general<br />

secretary, Co-operative Party<br />

What have you been most proud of in 2017?<br />

Throughout 2017, the Party has been celebrating<br />

its centenary, in which we’ve sought to look<br />

forward, as well as back. Marching our specially<br />

commissioned banner alongside our friends from<br />

the trade union movement at Durham Miner’s Gala<br />

was a real highlight.<br />

We were also very pleased to welcome<br />

Andy Burnham – our newly elected Labour &<br />

Co-operative mayor of Manchester – to an<br />

exhibition of our history at the People’s History<br />

Museum. The year culminated at our Centenary<br />

Conference in October, where 500 visitors and<br />

delegates were addressed by Jeremy Corbyn, the<br />

first elected Labour leader to speak at Co-op Party<br />

conference since Jim Callaghan.<br />

There were also dozens of events organised<br />

by our members up and down the country to<br />

commemorate the Centenary from Cornwall, to<br />

Anglesey to Perth. 2017 has seen our membership<br />

reach a modern high of 11,000. There were over 350<br />

local Co-operative Party meetings this year – the<br />

equivalent of one a day.<br />

June’s snap General Election saw members<br />

campaigning up and down the country for the<br />

election of Labour & Co-operative MPs, having<br />

already worked tirelessly in May’s local and<br />

mayoral elections. We were proud to stand with<br />

Labour on a manifesto that committed the next<br />

Labour & Co-operative government to doubling<br />

the size of the co-operative sector. More than 1.3<br />

million people voted for a Co-operative candidate<br />

in June, securing the election of 38 MPs – the<br />

largest number in our history.<br />

What are you looking forward to in <strong>2018</strong>?<br />

Having secured a commitment to doubling the<br />

size of the co-operative sector in Labour’s General<br />

Election manifesto, we’ll be developing plans to<br />

make that ambition a reality.<br />

We’ll be working with the movement to identify<br />

opportunities for growth and to remove the barriers<br />

that hold co-operation back, as well as setting<br />

out the ‘why’ and ‘how’ for accountable public<br />

ownership in key areas including transport and<br />

utilities.<br />

We’re also looking forward to an important set<br />

of local elections in May, in which we’re hopeful of<br />

significant increases in councillors in London and<br />

in other major cities across England. The work of<br />

councils such as Preston show the huge value that<br />

co-operators in local government can bring.<br />

What challenges are you facing in <strong>2018</strong>?<br />

The Co-operative Party is working with our elected<br />

representatives to understand and mitigate the<br />

challenges and uncertainties Brexit poses for the<br />

co-operative sector, as well as seeking to ensure<br />

that co-operative values and approaches have an<br />

important role to play in Britain after March 2019.<br />

Equally, we’re acutely aware of the very real<br />

consequences of economic uncertainty, falling<br />

living standards and low productivity for millions<br />

of people. That’s why we’re continuing to champion<br />

co-operative and employee ownership as a means<br />

to ensure that our economy’s rewards, as well as<br />

risks, are fairly shared.<br />

pClaire McCarthy<br />

speaks at a private<br />

viewing on a centenary<br />

exhibition on the<br />

history of the Co-op<br />

Party at the People’s<br />

History Museum in<br />

Manchester (Photo:<br />

Co-operative Party/<br />

David Lake)<br />

<strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong> | 25


‘The relevance of<br />

employee ownership<br />

has never been greater’<br />

LOOKING AHEAD<br />

BY SARAH DEAS,<br />

DIRECTOR,<br />

CO-OPERATIVE<br />

DEVELOPMENT<br />

SCOTLAND<br />

Q&A<br />

What have you been most proud of in 2017?<br />

We believe the appetite for employee ownership<br />

has never been greater. In the last five years the<br />

number of employee-owned businesses operating<br />

in Scotland has trebled and in particular this<br />

year we have been working on a ‘deal a month’<br />

on average. Our client pipeline is expanding too,<br />

indicating take-up of the model will continue to<br />

accelerate in future years.<br />

Furthermore, there are over 16,000 Scottish<br />

businesses expected to transfer ownership in the<br />

next few years, so the opportunity for employee<br />

ownership is significant.<br />

One of the main challenges we face is a limited<br />

awareness of the model, however we’re making<br />

good progress and in <strong>2018</strong> we’re looking forward to<br />

building on the momentum we’ve created.<br />

Derek Walker, chief executive,<br />

Wales Co-operative Centre<br />

The co-op sector has continued to grow in Wales as people increasingly see<br />

the co-operative advantage. We have been pleased to help groups apply co-op<br />

values and principles to the pressing issues facing Wales today for example<br />

the need for social care, affordable housing, energy etc. Examples include:<br />

uCartrefi Cymru, Wales’ largest rural social care provider, became a co-op.<br />

This means they are now a multi stakeholder organisation whose members<br />

work together for mutual benefit. By June they had already exceeded their<br />

year-one target of 100 members.<br />

uGower Power Co-op launched a public share offer in May to put its £1m solar<br />

farm in Swansea into community ownership. It offers a projected 5% annual<br />

interest to investors and provides enough clean electricity to power over 300<br />

houses annually. The offer is now closed and raised a whopping £905,640.<br />

What are you looking forward to in <strong>2018</strong>?<br />

Next year we will continue our support for the co-op sector in Wales and<br />

look to improve what we do. We hope to launch exciting new initiatives – for<br />

example, a business advice service for new co-ops and social enterprises. We<br />

also looking to work in the agri food sector.<br />

What challenges are you/your co-op facing in <strong>2018</strong>?<br />

Preparing for Brexit a will be a key challenge for the co-op sector. Many of the<br />

most deprived communities in Wales benefit from EU Structural Funds. We will<br />

be working with these communities and with government to ensure the Welsh<br />

economy and services are supported during this challenging period.<br />

pSarah Deas wants improved succession planning<br />

Our aspiration is to achieve a tenfold increase<br />

in employee ownership in Scotland over a 10-year<br />

period. As the baby boomer generation reaches<br />

retirement age, many business owners will be<br />

considering what will happen to their business<br />

when they choose to take that step back. Starting<br />

that process early opens up more options for<br />

businesses and we’ve been working hard to reach<br />

owners at the relevant stage.<br />

Promoting employee ownership will help drive<br />

growth in Scotland’s economy and create greater<br />

wealth equality in society. This helps deliver the<br />

Scottish government’s vision to achieve inclusive<br />

growth that ‘combines increased prosperity with<br />

greater equity; that creates opportunities for all<br />

and distributes the dividends of prosperity fairly’.<br />

There is growing recognition of this potential<br />

contribution, to both the inclusive growth agenda<br />

and also to international competitiveness. As<br />

a result, the 2017 Programme for Government<br />

included a commitment to investigate the scope to<br />

expand support for the model. This commitment<br />

was reinforced by a debate in the Scottish<br />

Parliament in September at which all parties<br />

supported the motion calling for business owners<br />

to consider employee ownership in their succession<br />

planning and for further support to be given to<br />

enable take-up of the model. We were delighted<br />

to receive this cross-party recognition and will be<br />

working to maximise this in <strong>2018</strong>.<br />

Ownership succession is now a prominent<br />

issue in the UK and internationally as baby<br />

-boomers increasingly wish to exit the businesses<br />

they’ve created. The issue is compounded by the<br />

recession having slowed the market for business<br />

sales, causing a backlog of ownership transfers<br />

sometimes referred to as the ‘succession time<br />

bomb’. For these reasons, we believe the relevance<br />

of employee ownership has never been greater.<br />

u Watch a video of the parliamentary debate at<br />

s.coop/25xi5 or read the transcript at s.coop/25xi6<br />

26 | <strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong>


Q&A<br />

James Alcock, general manager,<br />

the Plunkett Foundation<br />

What have you been most proud of in 2017?<br />

It was a very good year for the Foundation, and one<br />

of strong performance and high impact. What I’m<br />

particularly proud of is the fantastic team who have<br />

continued punching above their weight to grow the<br />

rural co-op sector and raise our profile with policy<br />

makers and national and regional stakeholders.<br />

Throughout the year, we’ve seen a growth in new<br />

enquiries from community groups exploring the<br />

community co-op model to tackle a broader range of<br />

issues such as health, loneliness and wellbeing. The<br />

range of ideas and projects we are now supporting is<br />

staggering, and the specialist nature of the support<br />

being sought has grown tremendously. Our team<br />

has certainly risen to the challenges and, according<br />

to our independent evaluations, exceeded the<br />

expectations communities have had of us.<br />

Our AGM in July showcased the diversity of our<br />

activities and achievement – even more impressive<br />

given the financial challenges facing our sector.<br />

An additional highlight for me was our Rural<br />

Community Co-operative Awards. The day spent<br />

with judges, poring over the applications, and<br />

the ceremony where we hear from the shortlisted<br />

groups, is truly inspirational.<br />

What are you looking forward to in <strong>2018</strong>?<br />

Launching and delivering our new <strong>2018</strong>-22 strategy.<br />

Without giving too much away ahead of its launch<br />

in July, the Foundation will seek to continue the<br />

good work that it has been delivering in growing<br />

the sector, our reach, and our impact so that more<br />

rural communities benefit from the opportunities<br />

that community co-operatives provide.<br />

What this means is a continuation of our<br />

activities to inspire communities to consider the<br />

co-op approach while maintaining a first-class<br />

support service that meets their needs. What will<br />

be different is working in closer partnership with a<br />

range of national, regional and local organisations<br />

who can help us reach new audiences, provide<br />

complementary support, and help us to get our<br />

messages heard and give greater representation to<br />

rural communities across the UK.<br />

What challenges are you facing in <strong>2018</strong>?<br />

We will be working hard to continue providing,<br />

and securing funding for, a national service that<br />

is balanced across all parts of the UK, for all forms<br />

of enterprise, at all stages of their journey. This is<br />

an ongoing challenge, but the political uncertainty<br />

of Brexit, and the unknown fate of EU funding<br />

streams, adds concern as to what the issues facing<br />

rural communities will be, and to what extent<br />

we and our partners will have the resources to<br />

respond to them. But wherever there is change<br />

and challenge, there is also opportunity. Plunkett’s<br />

longevity is in part owing to its ability to adapt to<br />

the evolving needs of rural communities, so I have<br />

no doubt that this challenge is not insurmountable.<br />

Q&A<br />

Tiziana O’Hara,<br />

Co-operative Alternatives<br />

What have you been most proud of in 2017?<br />

2017 was a good year for Co-operative Alternatives and the co-op movement in<br />

Northern Ireland. We have been working with new co-operatives addressing<br />

urban regeneration, football ownership and community supported<br />

agriculture. Most of all, we had great fun with a tour of local co-operatives at<br />

the beginning of the year! Such was the demand for a place on the tour that<br />

we had to change the size of the bus twice! We also ended the year with a<br />

great conference, Co-operatives: Can-do, Will-do, Must-do, with Ed Mayo of<br />

Co-operatives UK visiting Northern Ireland in November.<br />

What are you looking forward to in <strong>2018</strong>?<br />

More co-operatives to come through…<br />

What challenges are you facing in <strong>2018</strong>?<br />

pPlunkett supports<br />

organisations such<br />

as the Great Oakley<br />

Community Hub in<br />

Essex, which this year<br />

bought a property to<br />

run as a restaurant –<br />

after saving village<br />

pub the Maybush Inn<br />

in 2016<br />

The local Community Shares pilot programme is coming to an end in <strong>2018</strong>.<br />

However, with over £500,000 raised over the past four years, we proved the<br />

point that community shares are an option for Northern Ireland, too.<br />

<strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong> | 27


Q&A<br />

Cicopa continues its efforts to<br />

deliver a better future at work<br />

What have you been most proud of in 2017?<br />

The Employment Report and the incoming Global<br />

Report 2015-2016 on Industrial and Services co-ops<br />

Bruno Roelants, secretary general of CICOPA,<br />

says: “Employment is one of the most important<br />

contributions made by co-operatives throughout<br />

the world.<br />

“This report shows that people involved in cooperatives<br />

constitute a sufficiently high percentage<br />

to be considered as a major actor in the United<br />

Nations 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development,<br />

as well as in the worldwide debate on the Future<br />

of Work launched by the International Labour<br />

Organization.<br />

“In addition, the intent of the study is to improve<br />

the methodology and the quality level of cooperative<br />

statistics. This is particularly timely,<br />

as the next International Congress of Labour<br />

Statisticians will take place in <strong>2018</strong>. The public<br />

authorities and the co-operative movement itself<br />

should pay particular attention to this.<br />

“We are happy to share our second two-year<br />

global report on industrial and service<br />

co-operatives, covering the years 2015 and 2016.<br />

A significant added value of this second report is<br />

that it allows us to start monitoring systematically<br />

the evolution of our global co-operative network,<br />

both in the quantitative and qualitative components<br />

of the analysis.<br />

“It is also worth pointing out that our whole<br />

exercise of reporting the situation of our<br />

co-operative network, which started with data<br />

from 2013, is the result of several years of patient<br />

preparation. We started our first general survey of<br />

members back in 2004, and our first questionnaire<br />

on economic activities, based on the UN ISIC<br />

classification system, in 2008.<br />

“In 2009, we launched our surveys on members’<br />

qualitative data in the wake of the global crisis.<br />

But it is only in 2013 that we had collected enough<br />

pieces of the puzzle to have a rather faithful (even<br />

though far from complete) picture of our network.<br />

On the other hand, during those years, our network<br />

has also been undergoing a strong geographical<br />

enlargement, jumping from 18 countries to 32<br />

countries in 15 years (including large ones like<br />

the USA and Brazil), thus making this reporting<br />

exercise increasingly meaningful.<br />

“Another added value of the report is that we<br />

have been able to provide a quantitative estimation<br />

28 | <strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong>


The international organisation of co-ops in industry and<br />

services, part of the International Co-operative Alliance,<br />

on the next steps for a world of sustainable employment<br />

of industrial and service co-operatives in the<br />

world, beyond our own network. This has been<br />

possible thanks to another big reporting exercise in<br />

which CICOPA has been involved over the last few<br />

years, namely the first and the second report on<br />

Co-operatives and Employment, in 2014 and 2017.<br />

“That series of reports, differently from the<br />

present one, deals with employment in the entire<br />

co-operative movement, but it provides us with<br />

very useful data enabling us to make an estimation<br />

of co-ops in industrial and service sectors as well.<br />

“As the reader will discover, this reality is much<br />

larger than the CICOPA network, suggesting there<br />

still is a long way to go before CICOPA can include<br />

all these co-ops (some of which are affiliated<br />

to International Co-operative Alliance member<br />

organisations, others not), and thus be able to<br />

improve its level of reporting on, and representing<br />

industrial and service co-ops in the world.”<br />

uFind the global report at s.coop/mployment<br />

What are you looking forward to in <strong>2018</strong>?<br />

The youth report and a strong presence in the debate<br />

on the future of work<br />

Elisa Terrasi, researcher at CICOPA and co-author<br />

of the Youth report, says: “A global study on youth<br />

co-operative entrepreneurship is presently being<br />

elaborated, on the basis of a desk research and the<br />

results of an online survey involving more than 60<br />

youth co-operatives organised as worker, social<br />

and producers’ coo-peratives in the five continents.<br />

“The study will bring into the debate some<br />

considerations about the main interests and<br />

challenges for establishing cooperatives among<br />

young people. It will be a source of inspiration<br />

for further debates and studies, a tool at disposal<br />

of CICOPA members and the whole co-operative<br />

movement to promote a better understanding of<br />

the potential of co-operatives for youth among<br />

policy makers.”<br />

uFind the youth report at s.coop/25xia<br />

What challenges are you facing in <strong>2018</strong>?<br />

“Finding a better inter-sectoral dynamic inside<br />

the International Co-operative Alliance and<br />

demonstrating that worker ownership is a valuable<br />

answer for current employment challenges and the<br />

future of work.”<br />

<strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong> | 29


MEET...<br />

... Karen Hurst, Scottish policy<br />

officer for ABCUL<br />

Take-up of credit union membership in Scotland is much higher than in<br />

England and Wales and the Scottish Government is strongly supportive<br />

of ABCUL’s work in raising awareness and extending membership. Recent<br />

initiatives led by Karen include a meeting with government officials and the<br />

Cross Party Group on Credit Unions to discuss further plans and policy.<br />

WHY ARE YOU INVOLVED WITH CREDIT UNIONS?<br />

I got into this by chance – I had worked in politics<br />

for a long time and decided I wanted to work in a<br />

policy-focused role. So I sort of stumbled upon this<br />

role with ABCUL and have been working with our<br />

Scottish credit unions on their policy priorities for<br />

around two years now. I think the best part is the<br />

people involved in the sector. I try to spend some<br />

time every week popping in to see our member<br />

credit unions to find out what they’re getting up to<br />

and see what the main issues are for them, and I’m<br />

always amazed that they are often run by volunteers<br />

– a role which involves ensuring compliance with<br />

some pretty challenging financial regulation –<br />

purely because they feel strongly that people in<br />

their communities should not be ripped off by high<br />

interest lenders. Credit unions come in all shapes<br />

and sizes, but there is a real shared ethos that the<br />

interests of the member not the shareholder should<br />

always be at the heart of financial services.<br />

WHAT IS THE CURRENT CLIMATE IN SCOTLAND FOR<br />

THE CREDIT UNION SECTOR?<br />

Scotland’s credit union sector has always been one<br />

of the strongest in Britain – not only do we have<br />

the highest percentage of membership (around 7%<br />

compared to around 2% in England and Wales), but<br />

Scotland is home to some of the UK’s largest and<br />

most innovative credit unions. Glasgow, where I’m<br />

based, can count around a quarter of residents as a<br />

member of a credit union. It’s an interesting time –<br />

the last couple of quarters have seen membership<br />

level out slightly, after many years of consistent<br />

growth. However, I think it’s fair to say that the<br />

sector is more than ever looking at how it can serve<br />

its membership in new ways and ensure that it<br />

“”<br />

PEOPLE FROM ALL WALKS OF<br />

LIFE ARE SEEING THE BENEFITS<br />

OF JOINING A CREDIT UNION<br />

can stay relevant. When our members get together<br />

at our forums there is always much chatter about<br />

the new websites, apps and partnerships that they<br />

are working on. We’re also, through a partnership<br />

with the Scottish government, seeing more credit<br />

unions working with schools to enable pupils to run<br />

their own branch of the credit union – the Scottish<br />

government included a target in the Programme for<br />

Government this year on how many credit union<br />

school partnerships it would like to be formed in<br />

<strong>2018</strong> – this is the first time that has happened.<br />

THE GOVERNMENT HAS ANNOUNCED PLANS TO<br />

BACK CREDIT UNIONS – WHAT DOES THIS MEAN?<br />

We’ve always enjoyed a good relationship with the<br />

Scottish government, and are fortunate enough to<br />

enjoy cross-party support. In the Programme for<br />

Government published a few months ago, it was<br />

announced there would be an awareness-raising<br />

campaign for the sector. If it is done correctly, there<br />

is a potential for it to be really positive for credit<br />

unions – the BBC broadcast a programme called<br />

A Matter of Life and Debt a few weeks ago, which<br />

looked at examples of the impact a credit union<br />

could have on members’ lives. After it was broadcast<br />

many of our credit unions saw a huge increase in<br />

enquiries from new members. Hopefully we can put<br />

something together that has that sort of impact.<br />

WHAT WOULD AN IDEAL ‘AWARENESS RAISING’<br />

CAMPAIGN FROM THE GOVERNMENT LOOK LIKE?<br />

That’s a good question. We’re hosting a meeting<br />

in the Scottish Parliament to discuss this with the<br />

30 | <strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong>


YOUR VIEWS<br />

Scottish government and credit unions, so I wouldn’t<br />

want to pre-empt that. But I think our members<br />

are keen to ensure that the campaign is led by the<br />

sector, and that it gives out a strong message about<br />

credit unions being for everyone, not just those who<br />

are not well served by mainstream banking.<br />

WHAT DOES A TYPICAL DAY LOOK LIKE FOR YOU?<br />

I work from home, so I try to balance keeping up<br />

with emails and planning at my desk, and getting<br />

out and meeting credit unions and stakeholders. At<br />

the moment we are putting together a campaign to<br />

encourage more employers to partner with credit<br />

unions – the ability to access fair lending and make<br />

savings through payroll is something that only<br />

credit unions can offer – so I am spending quite a<br />

lot of time speaking to employers already signed up<br />

to encourage them to speak publicly. I thought this<br />

might be a challenge but it’s actually been really<br />

easy to find people to say nice things about credit<br />

unions. Next week I’m going to film interviews<br />

with someone who works in HR at the NHS, and a<br />

car rental company in Lanarkshire – so you should<br />

see those interviews pop up on our social media<br />

channels early next year.<br />

WHAT ACHIEVEMENT ARE YOU MOST PROUD OF?<br />

I think the Scottish government’s continued support<br />

for whatever we take to them – be it help to set up<br />

school schemes, support in raising awareness of<br />

the sector, or help from the First Minister to target<br />

employers, is something we should be proud of.<br />

WHAT CHALLENGES HAVE YOU FACED?<br />

I think the biggest challenge for all of us involved<br />

in credit unions is how we deal with challenges<br />

from the private sector, particularly in the employer<br />

partnerships. Over the past few years we’ve seen<br />

a number of new companies appear with slick<br />

marketing materials that the credit union sector,<br />

quite honestly, just can’t afford. However, these<br />

companies are not only not co-operatives, but they<br />

usually are not able to offer a savings option to those<br />

who sign up. My message to any employer who is<br />

interested in the financial wellbeing of their staff<br />

would be to get in touch with a credit union – it will<br />

almost certainly be able to offer more to their staff.<br />

WHAT DO YOU SEE THE FUTURE OF CREDIT UNIONS<br />

IN SCOTLAND?<br />

I hope we will see membership continue to grow,<br />

and I increasingly feel that people from all walks of<br />

life are seeing the benefits of joining a credit union.<br />

THANKS TO SUPPORTERS DIRECT FOR GIVING JUSTICE TO JACQUI FORSTER<br />

In 2016 the group Justice4Jac was formed to campaign for Supporters Direct<br />

to rescind their decision to cease paying terminally ill, longest-serving<br />

employee, Jacqui Forster. Many letters were written to various places and<br />

several were printed in Co-op News.<br />

We were delighted to hear that the decision was eventually rescinded and<br />

that, bar a few individuals, the board changed almost completely with a new<br />

chair, Tom Greatrex, and a new chief executive, Ashley Brown.<br />

Justice4Jac was very quick to complain loudly and vociferously about<br />

Jacqui’s treatment but we are equally pleased to state that circumstances<br />

have changed radically.<br />

Jacqui receives ongoing treatment at the Christie Hospital in Manchester<br />

but is now made to feel a continuing employee of SD, with visits from the CEO<br />

and invitations to working events and staff meals out. We applaud this and<br />

thank the new board & CEO for putting right a very great wrong.<br />

Jacqui has also used the money raised from a Just Giving page to launch a<br />

‘Women at the Game’ initiative which is receiving excellent national coverage.<br />

We all hope that SD now pushes further forward to be the best co-operative<br />

body in the world of community club ownership.<br />

We would like to thank all those in the co-operative movement who<br />

supported Jacqui and her supporters through such a difficult time in 2016.<br />

Phil Beardmore (Birmingham City Trust), Mark Boocock (ex-chair, Bradford<br />

City Supporters Trust), John Boyle (Stafford Rangers Trust), Rob Bradley (exvice<br />

chair, SD; ex-chair, Lincoln Trust), Lou Carton Kelly (ex-vice chair, SD;<br />

ex-chair, Dons Trust), Simon Cope (ex-director, SD; ex-chair, Scarborough<br />

Athletic), Elaine Dean (ex-vice chair, SD; vice chair, RamsTrust), Alan Digby<br />

(Foxes Trust), Pete Drew (treasurer, RamsTrust), Doug Harper (chair, Leyton<br />

Orient Trust), Rick Keracher (ex-director, SD; ex-chair, Lincoln City Trust),<br />

Mark Longden (Shareholders Utd and MUST member) Paul Miller (Ilkeston<br />

Town supporter), Tanya Noon (secretary, RamsTrust), Robert Pepper (exvice<br />

chair, SD; ex-chair, Huddersfield Town ST), Linda Smith (Northampton<br />

Town Trust), Kris Stewart (ex-director, SD; founding chair, AFC Wimbledon),<br />

Tony Taylor (ex-vice chair, SD; ex-chair, Darlington Trust), Phil Tooley (exdirector,<br />

SD; acting MD, SD – and the person who appointed Jacqui Forster)<br />

Malcolm Turner (ex-director, SD) and Jim Wheeler (chair, RamsTrust)<br />

WHY US ELECTRIC CO-OPS ARE PROUD TO HELP STORM-HIT PUERTO RICO<br />

The #CoopNation is taking a stand and lending helping hands to communities<br />

in Puerto Rico during this difficult time. We are proud to be in this co-operative<br />

family where helping our members and communities are our priority.<br />

Free State Electric Co-op<br />

via Twitter<br />

Have your say<br />

Add your comments to our stories online at www.thenews.coop, get in<br />

touch via social media, or send us a letter. If sending a letter, please<br />

include your address and contact number. Letters may be edited and<br />

no longer than 350 words.<br />

Co-operative News, Holyoake House, Hanover Street,<br />

Manchester M60 0AS<br />

@coopnews Co-operative News letters@thenews.coop<br />

<strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong> | 31


HOW TO CHANGE<br />

THE WORLD<br />

By Craig Dearden-Phillips<br />

This article is based on the book ‘How<br />

to Change the World: The essential<br />

guide for social sector leaders’,<br />

published by Craig Dearden-Phillips.<br />

He is the author of three books on<br />

social sector leadership and is a Visiting<br />

Lecturer at London Cass Business<br />

School. To buy the book visit:<br />

s.coop/25xdw<br />

32 | <strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong>


What is the secret sauce to be<br />

a social leader?<br />

Everyone I have met who is a leader in the social<br />

sector starts out believing they can change the<br />

world. But they often find that making a clear,<br />

measurable difference isn’t easy. Few, by midcareer,<br />

are achieving quite as much impact as they<br />

anticipated. Some leaders settle for that and focus<br />

on having a decent career.<br />

Others don’t sit back. Instead, they look to take<br />

their effectiveness as a social sector leader to<br />

another level. But where to go for help? One sees<br />

lots of ‘Secrets of Success’ books by business gurus<br />

and entrepreneurs about being a business success.<br />

Very little exists for the social sector that explores<br />

what makes for greater success. And vanishingly<br />

little brings the wisdom of our top social sector<br />

leaders to the fore.<br />

Social sector leadership is about making<br />

the biggest possible impact on the totality of<br />

the problem you seek to address. This isn’t<br />

necessarily about creating a big organisation.<br />

In truth, few social sector organisations achieve<br />

the breakthrough scale needed to solve an<br />

entire problem.<br />

Changing the world is just as often achieved by<br />

having your ideas and work carried forward by<br />

others, including governments. A big part of social<br />

sector leadership is knowing your ‘end-game’ –<br />

figuring just how your organisation can maximise<br />

its influence on problems you exist to solve.<br />

How is leadership categorised?<br />

The book features 27 personal profiles of leaders,<br />

who often defy easy categorisation. But, for the<br />

ease of navigation, throughout the book, the author<br />

has come up with definitions for ten different types<br />

of leadership.<br />

Transformational Leadership introduces a<br />

group of leaders who have taken large organisations<br />

on a long-term journey of radical change, based<br />

on a new understanding of the world they are<br />

operating in and its needs.<br />

Entrepreneurial Leadership highlights the<br />

role that three entrepreneurial leaders have played<br />

to grow the social mission of their organisations.<br />

Interestingly this includes setting up privately<br />

owned social ventures.<br />

Digital Leadership focuses on the powerful<br />

ways in which a group of forward-thinking social<br />

sector leaders are harnessing the power of digital<br />

technology to take social impact to whole new<br />

levels, often without the need for an equivalent<br />

growth in resources.<br />

Cultural Leadership groups people who have,<br />

in a variety of ways, challenged and changed the<br />

values, beliefs and behaviours of an organisation<br />

they have led, enabling their organisations to raise<br />

their social impact.<br />

Team Leadership looks at the challenges for<br />

social sector leaders of building top quality teams<br />

who are capable of taking impact to the next level.<br />

Turnaround Leadership brings together a group<br />

of leaders who have all led a rapid improvement in<br />

their organisations’ short-term fortunes, keeping<br />

the lights on and enabling them to successfully<br />

plan for the longer term.<br />

Charismatic Leadership looks at the particular<br />

upsides and downsides of this approach to<br />

leadership in social sector organisations.<br />

Funder Leadership gives us insight into the way<br />

progressive social sector leaders in the fields of<br />

grant-making and social finance are responding to<br />

a challenging financial environment.<br />

Future Leadership asks what those who study<br />

key trends in our sector see as the key leadership<br />

challenges of the 2020s.<br />

Your Leadership is a ‘workshop’ chapter<br />

designed to help you to locate where you are now<br />

on your personal leadership journey, the difference<br />

you seek to make going forward and how you’re<br />

doing to do this.<br />

<strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong> | 33


Top ten tips<br />

So, what are the ‘Top Ten Tips’ from my book for<br />

social sector leaders seeking a bigger impact?<br />

1. Lead from behind.<br />

The most successful social sector leaders lead<br />

from behind as much as from the front. They lead<br />

organisations that people join by choice as much as<br />

financial necessity, be they staff or volunteers. So,<br />

outside of turnaround situations, leadership is more<br />

about engagement – convenor of the organisation<br />

rather than its commander.<br />

Key behaviours: Talk to more people, in more<br />

depth. Listen more than you talk.<br />

authentic, stand for particular values and that you<br />

uphold them, come what may.<br />

Key behaviours: Make clear what you believe.<br />

Prove this through your behaviour.<br />

4. Be ambitious.<br />

Leaders who are really changing the world are<br />

those with a vast ambition around the mission<br />

and how it can be grown. They create a sense<br />

of possibility beyond what is currently being<br />

achieved. Their skill is doing this without<br />

demeaning past achievement. And framing the<br />

future in a way that pays back to staff, volunteers<br />

and others, the organisation’s sense of its true<br />

purpose.<br />

Key behaviours: Think big, encourage others<br />

to do the same. Frame ambition squarely in the<br />

language of mission.<br />

5. Think impact.<br />

First-order social sector leaders are making their<br />

organisations think hard about how to capture<br />

and communicate the difference they make (or<br />

not!). For many organisations - habituated to<br />

reporting activity not results - this is difficult.<br />

But, if the world is to be changed, those leading<br />

it have to be clear on progress. The first step<br />

is tactfully making the challenge about the<br />

difference the organisation is making, in a way<br />

that people can cope with.<br />

Key behaviours: Cold honesty, openness,<br />

comfort with laying down a challenge.<br />

2. Build coalitions.<br />

If they want to make things happen, leaders in<br />

the social sector have to build coalitions both<br />

inside and beyond the organisation. The authority<br />

invested in leadership in this sector is probably less<br />

than in the private sector, where the CEO is given<br />

more latitude. To get people on board, CEOs leading<br />

big transformation need to develop strong political<br />

skills.<br />

Key behaviours: Plan who you need to deliver<br />

change. Think about what aspects will get each<br />

group on board.<br />

3. Be authentic.<br />

The most successful leaders are genuine people<br />

who stay human. It sounds simple, but we all know<br />

that the pressures in organisations often mean that<br />

leaders sometimes fail in this regard. Authenticity<br />

in social sector leadership isn’t the same thing as<br />

being liked. It’s about people knowing that you are<br />

6. Create your culture.<br />

Top social sector leaders understand that, for an<br />

organisation to make an impact, it has to have<br />

the right culture. When coming in new, social<br />

leaders often find a culture that’s getting in the<br />

way of progress. ‘Show me the Leader, Show me<br />

the Culture’ is a cliché, but one with some truth.<br />

While aspects of culture can remain immune to a<br />

leader’s influence, the best leaders waste no time<br />

setting out the attitudes and behaviour that they<br />

most value.<br />

Key behaviours: Make people aware of your<br />

values and expectations of everyone. Repeat it<br />

often and model it yourself.<br />

7. Get your team right.<br />

Successful social sector leaders put great store<br />

by a top team which is capable, even when this<br />

means tough choices. They understand that this<br />

unit is the key to success or failure, the A Team.<br />

And that a B Team won’t change the world.<br />

Therefore, finding a top team where people trust<br />

34 | <strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong>


and challenge each other, sharing in success or<br />

failure together, is essential to success.<br />

Key behaviours: Set a high bar on senior<br />

colleagues. Look for alignment or core values, but<br />

also a diverse range of perspectives.<br />

8. Coach, don’t manage.<br />

The very best social sector leaders tend to act<br />

like coaches rather than bosses. In relation to the<br />

people around them, they see their primary task<br />

as drawing out the best. They know that micromanaging<br />

is a waste of time. They understand that<br />

needing to manage someone closely is a sure sign<br />

of a bigger problem. They also use their coaching<br />

skills to help people see when it’s time to go or take<br />

on a new role.<br />

Key behaviours: Think of yourself as an enabler,<br />

not a manager. Allow people to manage their own<br />

detail.<br />

9. Be visible.<br />

The best social sector leaders are rarely found in<br />

their office. They understand that their key role is<br />

to be engaging with people both inside and beyond<br />

the organisation. Visibility is the hallmark of the<br />

successful, effective social sector CEO. This isn’t<br />

about ‘turning up’ to set-piece events, like a visiting<br />

dignitary. It’s about making yourself available to<br />

people to talk to, be questioned by. Or, if needs be,<br />

take criticism from.<br />

Key behaviours: Get out of your ‘bubble’. Move<br />

around the organisation, putting yourself ‘on the<br />

line’, even if uncomfortable.<br />

10. Look after yourself.<br />

The most successful social sector leaders work<br />

hard, but they understand this is a long game. So,<br />

they tend to look after themselves. On a simple<br />

level, this is about time-out, the right diet, sleep<br />

and exercise. But, it’s also about professional<br />

development: creating a good network of peers,<br />

working with a coach, subjecting yourself to new<br />

learning. Such is the demand on the personality of<br />

a social sector leader, that good self-care is critical.<br />

Key behaviours: Better ‘work-hygiene’,<br />

developing support beyond the organisation.<br />

<strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong> | 35


WHO’S AFRAID<br />

OF LEADERSHIP?<br />

LEADERSHIP<br />

BY KATE WHITTLE,<br />

Kate provides training<br />

and consultancy services<br />

through Cooperantics<br />

www.cooperantics.coop<br />

There is no one-size-fits-all approach to<br />

co-ope leadership, because there are so<br />

many varieties of co-operative, depending<br />

on organisational structure, sector of the<br />

economy, numbers of members and the age of<br />

the co-operative.<br />

In a consumer retail co-operative for example,<br />

the hierarchical structure pretty much dictates<br />

who holds what power and while of course there<br />

are opportunities for career development and<br />

promotion, there is less flexibility and those at<br />

the top of the tree can control the way authority is<br />

delegated to those below them.<br />

This reminds me of a story from a housing co-op<br />

event, held to promote the co-op and recruit new<br />

members. All the members – eight or nine of us –<br />

turned up at the community centre to arrange the<br />

room and get ready for our audience.<br />

There were chairs stacked against the wall, and<br />

we all started lugging them to the centre of the<br />

room – but it was soon apparent – not just to us,<br />

but to the early arrivals who began to sit down,<br />

that we had no idea how to arrange the seating, no<br />

idea how many people would turn up, no previous<br />

agreement whether we would make rows of chairs<br />

or a big circle – it was chaos.<br />

So much so that some of us began to laugh to try<br />

to make a joke of it, while others got more and more<br />

frustrated and anxious. We finally got it sorted,<br />

but it was obvious we’d made a pretty negative<br />

impression on our audience who – no matter<br />

how impressive and persuasive our subsequent<br />

presentation – had had a clear demonstration<br />

of our inability to work as a team and our lack of<br />

leadership skills.<br />

I have often remembered that moment and<br />

wondered why it happened like that. We were not<br />

totally lacking in team skills – in fact one of the<br />

impressive things about this group was the way in<br />

which they were able to pull together to organise<br />

things – but I think there was a fear of showing<br />

leadership. An idea that perhaps in a co-operative,<br />

showing leadership is wrong. I believe this is due to<br />

a misunderstanding about the nature of leadership,<br />

and an assumption that a ‘command and control’<br />

style of leadership is the only way.<br />

36 | <strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong>


How should co-ops lead?<br />

I would recommend that the CEO and chair<br />

of the board are very clear where their authority<br />

begins and ends. The role of the chair of the<br />

Board is to represent the co-operative to external<br />

bodies and to chair board meetings. The role of<br />

the CEO is to manage the day to day operations<br />

of the co-operative, and to support and<br />

supervise management.<br />

An overlap of roles – or a vacuum between<br />

them - can be the cause of conflict.<br />

In the flatter structures found in worker<br />

co-operatives leadership can be distributed, where<br />

authority is delegated to sub-groups, working<br />

parties or individuals. Sub-groups etc have<br />

autonomy and perform tasks however they see fit,<br />

as long as they understand how and when they<br />

will be held accountable to the wider membership.<br />

In her excellent article ‘How to grow distributed<br />

leadership’ Alanna Krause states that leadership<br />

begins with leading yourself – acting as an<br />

individual, collaborating with a group or as a<br />

follower. She rightly says we need to talk about<br />

power, which people acquire for a wide range of<br />

reasons, such as charisma, knowledge, or skills<br />

and expertise.<br />

This is why the famous ‘Tyranny of<br />

Structurelessness’ is so prescient. It describes how<br />

feminists in the 1970s thought they had done away<br />

with power structures, but soon found out they are<br />

always there, but without any visible organisational<br />

structure there was no means of removing people<br />

from power.<br />

In flat, democratically managed co-operatives<br />

members use good facilitation skills, well-designed<br />

systems and clear processes to co-ordinate work<br />

without establishing a hierarchy. Leadership skills<br />

are grown by the more experienced consciously<br />

creating opportunities for others to lead, and<br />

knowing when to step back and allow others<br />

to practice.<br />

Leadership theories<br />

It’s interesting to review the many theories of<br />

leadership but for our purposes here, let’s look at<br />

commonly-held assumptions about what leadership<br />

means and what leaders do. In ‘traditional’<br />

hierarchically structured organisations, power is<br />

located at the top, and leaders lead from the front.<br />

Leaders have authority, take control and attract<br />

followers. Line managers tell people what to do,<br />

who then have others that they manage in turn.<br />

In such a structure it’s hard for individuals to be<br />

innovative and creative. Someone at the top who<br />

doesn’t understand the day to day realities of work<br />

at the ‘coal face’ takes decisions which workers may<br />

not agree with but must comply with if they want<br />

to keep their jobs. Of course employees can and<br />

should join a trade union which will support them<br />

and lobby and campaign to change things, but in<br />

some circumstances, confrontational approaches<br />

can be counter-productive.<br />

So perhaps we need to get rid of the structure<br />

and the leaders and all decide everything together?<br />

Apart from the impracticability of such a step<br />

(you’d never get any work done) Jo Freeman,<br />

in ‘The Tyranny of Structurelessness’ explains<br />

how misguided it is to assume that without a<br />

structure, there will be no leaders. Leaders will<br />

always emerge, attracting followers by dint of<br />

their charisma, power, or resources, but without a<br />

structure or a system of accountability, you’ll have<br />

no way of getting rid of them.<br />

<strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong> | 37


Leadership in worker co-operatives<br />

So we need a structure. And of course, cooperatives<br />

have such a structure, where people can<br />

be elected to a management committee, or board<br />

of directors, but will have a specific term of office,<br />

and will only be re-elected if members feel they are<br />

doing a good job. However, like every democracy,<br />

it only works if people have information accessible<br />

to them about how the co-op is doing and how<br />

successful it is in achieving business, social and<br />

environmental goals. The MC then is accountable<br />

to the members, but they will also need terms of<br />

reference so they understand their roles and their<br />

delegated powers.<br />

So how do you show leadership in a<br />

worker co-operative?<br />

In contrast to a typical hierarchy, leadership<br />

in a worker co-operative is collective. It’s not just<br />

the MC who need to be leaders – anyone can show<br />

leadership at any time. But what does this mean<br />

and how can it work?<br />

The Tao of Leadership, by John Heider, provides<br />

simple and clear advice on how to be an effective<br />

leader: be unbiased, trust the process, pay<br />

attention, and inspire others to become their<br />

own leaders.<br />

For example:<br />

LEAD IN A NOURISHING<br />

MANNER<br />

• Give away control<br />

• Look for opportunities to give others control<br />

• Try to ensure that decisions are taken by the<br />

people most likely to be affected (subsidiarity)<br />

LEAD WITHOUT<br />

BEING POSSESSIVE<br />

• Lead by example rather than by telling<br />

people what to do<br />

• Avoid egocentricity<br />

• ‘Be’ rather than ‘Do‘<br />

• Be aware of what is happening in the<br />

group and act accordingly<br />

“ Specific actions are less important than the<br />

leader’s clarity or consciousness. This is why<br />

there are no exercises or formulas to ensure<br />

successful leadership”<br />

LEAD WITHOUT COERCION<br />

BE HELPFUL WITHOUT TAKING<br />

THE CREDIT<br />

• Be modest, allow others to take the credit<br />

• Promote collaboration<br />

• Provide tools for collective working<br />

• Clarify roles, authority and accountability<br />

• Delegate<br />

• Create an environment for thinking<br />

“ Run the group delicately, as if you were cooking<br />

small fish. Too much force will backfire; the<br />

leader who tries to control he group through<br />

force does not understand group process. The<br />

wise leader stays centred and grounded and<br />

uses the least force to act effectively”.<br />

38 | <strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong>


The result will be thinking, passionately proactive<br />

and creative people who communicate effectively,<br />

who understand how to work as a team, how to<br />

respond positively to conflict and how to help new<br />

members feel at home and hit the ground running.<br />

So in our housing co-op example, should we<br />

have been dreaming about the best seating layout<br />

for our meeting? Well perhaps not, of course<br />

there are circumstances where simply delegating<br />

a few tasks will avoid such a muddle. If someone<br />

had shown leadership by asking everyone what<br />

would be the best layout, then suggesting we<br />

divide up the tasks between us: someone to<br />

stick up notices so people know where to come,<br />

a couple of people organising chairs, a couple<br />

of people making tea, someone putting the<br />

recruitment leaflet on every chair – etc. Simple<br />

stuff, but someone does need to take that<br />

initial lead.<br />

Kate Whittle has been working in the social<br />

economy for over 20 years and provides training<br />

and consultancy services through Co-operantics<br />

(www.cooperantics.coop), including governance,<br />

strategic planning and conflict co-operation.<br />

She has worked with co-operatives of all kinds,<br />

social enterprises, voluntary organisations and<br />

co-operative development agencies.<br />

<strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong> | 39


LEADER Q&A<br />

Simon Parkinson,<br />

Chief Executive and Principal,<br />

Co-op College<br />

If co-operatives are different in form and function<br />

from both charitable organisations and private<br />

organisations then the leadership and management<br />

of them should look and feel different. We can take<br />

the best from other sectors and bring it together in<br />

something I refer to as a values-based, adaptive<br />

leadership approach.<br />

Co-ops at their best can be positive disruptors<br />

and the multiple ways in which they organise lends<br />

itself less to a top-down command-and-control<br />

style of leadership (rowing boat – one person<br />

barking orders and everyone else conforming)<br />

and much more to a servant leadership approach<br />

(steering from the back helping people drive the<br />

organisation in a generally agreed direction and<br />

watching out for rocks).<br />

This takes real authenticity from leaders (and<br />

leaders may be colleagues or members) and<br />

requires a strong value base and resilience. While<br />

many organisations spend a lot of time and money<br />

working out what their organisational values<br />

should be, the co-op movement already has an<br />

internationally agreed set of values. This should<br />

be part of what unites us as a movement and could<br />

be a benchmark or at least a starting point for<br />

developing co-operative leadership approaches.<br />

If co-ops and co-op leaders were truly living the<br />

values we would measure success differently and<br />

this would add to our uniqueness as a movement.<br />

The College wants to play its role in educating<br />

leaders of co-operatives and has a varied and<br />

blended approach to this which recognises the<br />

benefits of both formal and informal, accredited<br />

and unaccredited learning. So not just MBAs or<br />

even MCAs for middle and senior colleagues in<br />

co-operatives but a range of learning experiences<br />

where members and colleagues can come together<br />

and learn from each other and explore what makes<br />

co-ops different.<br />

The Co-op College runs a number of courses,<br />

such as Executive Education bit.ly/ExecEdCoop)<br />

and Persuasive Speaking (bit.ly/SpeakColl)<br />

40 | <strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong>


Ben Reid,<br />

Group Chief Executive Officer<br />

at the Midcounties Co-operative<br />

Being a leader in a co-operative environment<br />

brings with it a range of responsibilities that are<br />

unique. Expectations around how a co-op leader<br />

will act are high and based on the underlying<br />

values of the organisation. At the core of this is<br />

our commitment to openness in all that we do.<br />

This ranges from our interfaces with customers<br />

and members through to how we deal with<br />

our colleagues.<br />

A co-operative leader should be ready to explain<br />

decisions to a wider audience and that in itself<br />

imposes an additional test on all key decisions.<br />

This provides a defence against decisions being<br />

made in the dark or for personal gain.<br />

Of course, there are examples where these checks<br />

and balances have failed but I would suggest far less<br />

frequently than our competitor business models.<br />

Another key difference in our model is that<br />

co-op leaders/managers report to a board elected<br />

from the membership. This brings with it the<br />

challenge of ensuring that complex business issues<br />

are understood by a group of directors from a<br />

wide range of backgrounds.<br />

Again at the heart of this relationship is<br />

developing an open relationship, where all relevant<br />

information is shared, to allow directors to play a<br />

key role in the decision making process.<br />

There is therefore a common theme that runs<br />

through all aspects of a co-operative business. An<br />

acceptance that, in a membership organisation,<br />

there must be full transparency and leaders are<br />

liable to be held to account for all their actions.<br />

A higher standard than other leaders are<br />

measured against, but it is the aspect that makes us<br />

unique, and which has ensured that we have been<br />

able to thrive for over 150 years.<br />

<strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong> | 41


CO-OPERATIVE<br />

LEADERSHIP<br />

– IN PRACTICE<br />

LEADERSHIP<br />

BOB CANNELL,<br />

Co-operative Business<br />

Consultants<br />

People have been devising theories of<br />

co-operative leadership for at least two centuries;<br />

often reflecting the dominant culture of their<br />

times. Recently Co-op News reported the Global<br />

Women’s Leadership Network decrying a lack<br />

of women coming through ‘the pipeline’ into<br />

‘c-suite’ positions (How to cultivate more women in<br />

leadership roles in credit unions, 7 December 2017).<br />

Whatever this means, they seem to know what they<br />

want. Or do they?<br />

A lifetime of practical experience in worker<br />

co-operatives, both as a ‘manager’ (the reason<br />

for the quotes will become apparent) and as a<br />

Co-ooperative development advisor, has given<br />

me very different ideas about leadership as it is<br />

practiced IRL (In Real Life) in co-op businesses<br />

struggling to maintain order and survive.<br />

Here are some examples.<br />

No names of course<br />

I was called in to a bakery co-op with multiple<br />

business problems. They had four members and<br />

one permanent employee. I pointed out that to<br />

conform to the First Co-op Principle, they should<br />

offer membership to her as she was clearly helping<br />

to manage the business as well as being a baker,<br />

and wanted to be in the members’ meetings.<br />

‘Oh ‘A’ won’t like that,” I was told. ‘A’ being the<br />

oldest member. The next time I went, she was<br />

a member. But the others, at ‘A’s behest, had<br />

appointed themselves directors and now met as a<br />

board without her. ‘A’ apparently didn’t like any<br />

of my other suggestions either, like putting their<br />

prices up so they could pay themselves a living<br />

wage. The other members simply obeyed.<br />

42 | <strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong>


Another big and old worker co-op I discovered to<br />

be run by an elite group of members, the annointed<br />

successors of the founders. It was all quite unofficial<br />

and quite in keeping with their rules. They had<br />

member meetings and a board which achieved<br />

little, so this informal ‘executive’ just ran the show.<br />

As a new member you could spend decades on<br />

the periphery with no say in how the business is<br />

operated or developed.<br />

Members of my old co-op, Suma, always<br />

displayed a strong dislike of ‘managers’ in the<br />

sense of executives with status authority. The<br />

word was hardly used and team coordinators<br />

getting too ‘managerial’ found co-operation and<br />

goodwill being withdrawn by their team members<br />

until they became unable to do their job. New<br />

LEADING IS A FUNCTION,<br />

NOT A STATUS’. SO ANYONE<br />

AND EVERYONE CAN AND<br />

SHOULD BE DOING IT<br />

<strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong> | 43


members are still told that ‘management is a<br />

function, not a status’ at Suma. The sort of charisma<br />

authority used above by ‘A’ is rare although some<br />

individuals can block changes until they are<br />

over ruled with difficulty by elected or delegated<br />

authority. Suma has both but neither are as strong<br />

as a ‘normal’ business.<br />

Suma has just the same conflicted position<br />

with corporate leadership. People yearn for ‘good’<br />

leaders and ‘direction’ and some have a go, often<br />

with self-destructive and ineffective results. It’s<br />

a lot more complex ‘leading’ even a medium<br />

size business than it first appears. In fact I don’t<br />

think it’s possible unless you simplify the task by<br />

wielding management authority, as happens in<br />

most orthodox organisations. At least at Suma,<br />

you get told quickly if your changes are making<br />

things worse.<br />

These are all people in old-style businesses trying<br />

in their ways to make sense of guiding colleagues<br />

through collective business life. There is a flurry<br />

of new ideas and re-invented old ways to make<br />

leadership more collective and more distributed.<br />

Should it even be called ‘leadership’ any more?<br />

Unless you take a leaf from Suma and say “leading<br />

is a function, not a status”. So anyone and everyone<br />

can and should be doing it, like the Suma ideal,<br />

(if not always the reality, to be honest). I still say the<br />

44 | <strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong>


co-operative leader is the member who says “Listen<br />

everyone, we have a problem. What are WE going to<br />

do about it?” Everything else is management.<br />

Leaders need a position to lead from. A control<br />

room (or c-suite?), or at least a central position upon<br />

which the rest of the organisation is dependents<br />

so they can change the behaviour of other<br />

participants, by using charisma or status authority.<br />

But many new organisations have no centre. They<br />

are networks of self organising individuals and<br />

in the case of CoTech, the UK network of tech<br />

co-ops, RedGrafica, graphics co-ops in Argentina<br />

and the thousands of social co-operatives in Italy.<br />

As the networks of autonomous individual<br />

collectives. The idea that these should have<br />

an apex leadership is nonsensical. They may<br />

have a coordinating hub but it is subordinate<br />

to the members.<br />

Many of the growing number of so called<br />

solidarity organisations in Greece and Spain,<br />

collectively organised responses to neo-liberal<br />

austerity, are deliberatley centreless and<br />

leaderless to protect themselves from state<br />

repression and to operate outside the mainstream<br />

economy which they believe is similarly<br />

oppressive. Solidarity economy networks are<br />

growing in many countries.<br />

Even in prosperous Germany, many young<br />

people are creating informal Kollectiven, networks<br />

of unregistered worker co-operatives, to work<br />

and earn an income outside the formal state but<br />

free from the bureaucratic administrative burdens<br />

of the official co-operative movement.<br />

Clearly these are all putting into practice the<br />

anarchic, collective ideals shared by the founders<br />

of Suma and other 1970s worker co-ops. Ideals<br />

which spoke to basic human desires for personal<br />

autonomy but also, at the same time, supportive<br />

co-operative solidarity. They proved difficult to<br />

marry with the needs of 20th century business<br />

administration. Is 21st century technology<br />

finally permitting those ultra-democratic, flat<br />

hierarchy networks to deliver these ideals<br />

in a growing and increasingly borderless<br />

alternative economy?<br />

However these ideas of Co-operative Solidarity<br />

need to be further discussed to avoid these<br />

new co-operatives falling prey to the old<br />

pitfalls that have bedevilled co-operative ventures<br />

since the 19th century, commercial failure or<br />

predation by private investors. If we can now<br />

communicate so much better, we no longer<br />

need to learn slowly, painfully and wastefully,<br />

by trial and error. The Ways Forward 6 “Cooperative<br />

Solidarity” conference on 16 February in<br />

Manchester will explore the leadership issue and<br />

how we can refine the concept to meet our business<br />

development needs.<br />

<strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong> | 45


CO-OPS AND THE RISE OF<br />

BIG DATA<br />

DATA<br />

BY MILES HADFIELD<br />

As the rise of big data continues to transform<br />

the business landscape, it presents the co-op<br />

movement, with an untapped resource in the shape<br />

of a mountain of member information – but also a<br />

series of ethical issues.<br />

These boil down to the question of who should<br />

actually own the data, which becomes even<br />

more pressing in the case of member-owned<br />

organisations like co-ops. And the subject came<br />

under discussion during a session at the Global<br />

Conference of the International Co-operative<br />

Alliance in Kuala Lumpur last month.<br />

One example of how the co-op movement is<br />

rising to the opportunities and challenges of online<br />

information is Swiss co-op MIDATA, which offers<br />

members a platform to store their data. Its current<br />

focus is on health – an area of particular ethical<br />

concern when it comes to privacy.<br />

Vice president Doris Albisser told the conference<br />

session that MIDATA is “citizen-owned and<br />

controlled, not for profit, open source, transparent,<br />

secure; only account holders have access to the<br />

platform and can see who has accessed their data.”<br />

The data is used for science projects, she said,<br />

with participants’ consent. “We don’t allow data<br />

used for research to be sold,” she said. “The longterm<br />

goal is to use data to personalise medicine.<br />

The patient controls the data.”<br />

Equally sensitive is financial data. Jimmy Lin,<br />

manager of software engineering data services at<br />

Schools First Credit Union in the USA, discussed<br />

the balance of responsibility and opportunity that<br />

consumer banking data brings.<br />

“We’re working to understand the data trail to<br />

make members’ lives better,” he said. “We were<br />

able to use it to work out which members had been<br />

worst affected by the recent natural disasters in the<br />

USA – forest fires, the storms and floods – and reach<br />

out to them. But we are also working out firewalls<br />

and permissions to prevent breaches.”<br />

He added: “We’re not allowed to share data with<br />

a third party. The question is what do we use it<br />

for? We want to understand who our members are<br />

better so their financial situation is better.<br />

“We like to say we treat the members’ data like<br />

we treat the members themselves.”<br />

New tech comes to agriculture<br />

Big data is by now an established force in health<br />

and finance but it is now beginning to make itself<br />

felt in agriculture.<br />

Andrew Crane, who recently stepped down as<br />

chief executive of Australian grain storage and<br />

marketing co-op CBH, said: “Agriculture is one of<br />

last industries to get teched. It’s a physical product<br />

– how do we digitise that? But there is scope with<br />

use of data to help farmers make a return.”<br />

Dr Crane said co-ops have a role to play in<br />

championing the rights of members when it comes<br />

to their data. For instance, this date can ensure<br />

transparency on input pricing, helping smaller<br />

farmers find out if their price is competitive or not.<br />

“Who owns the data?” he asked. “Modern farm<br />

equipment captures a huge yield of data as it<br />

harvests crops. Who owns that?<br />

“Machine makers in the US say the data the<br />

machine gather belongs to them, not the farmers.<br />

We say it’s the farmers.”<br />

He said the task now is to work out how to obtain<br />

that data for farmers, perhaps by getting a tool to<br />

extract the data to buy on a statewide basis, or<br />

creating a farmer business network to “share data<br />

that farmers have already paid for”.<br />

He added: “Storage systems have data of what<br />

grain is available, what is high and low in supply.<br />

We’re under pressure to release this but it belongs<br />

to our members. Online quality data means that<br />

farmers can extract value, rather than traders.”<br />

Dr Crane said the data on the shipping and<br />

blending of grain can connect big grain buyers in<br />

China with his farmer members.<br />

He added: “The new middle class want to know<br />

the origin of their food – food counterfeiting is an<br />

46 | <strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong>


issue. How do we demonstrate the clean, green<br />

origin, of safe food? We need to control data and<br />

bring power back to our members.”<br />

But there are other difficulties, he warned. “The<br />

interests of members might diverge from those<br />

of the co-op. For instance, we buy grain from<br />

members and make a profit. We return that profit to<br />

the members as a discount to handling fees.<br />

“But we are now handing that data over to<br />

members so they can deal with the buyers directly.<br />

This is good for members but not necessarily good<br />

for our co-op.”<br />

Bob Yuill, deputy chief executive of the Scottish<br />

Agricultural Organisation Society, said: “In the last<br />

two or three years we’ve been building up a picture<br />

ourselves of the ownership of data... Ownership of<br />

date is what gives you a competitive edge.”<br />

He said “huge processes” were required to ensure<br />

access to data, the visibility of data to people who<br />

use it, and the accuracy of systems that maintain<br />

it. It is also important to “understand how you do<br />

that in co-op context,” he added. “Our values are<br />

key to this.”<br />

Mr Yuill added: “Membership loyalty in a co-op is<br />

demonstrated in ownership and understanding the<br />

strategy of that co-op. Accurate data from members<br />

allows us to drive strategy. Ownership of strategy<br />

matters – at the moment we are giving data away to<br />

large corporates.”<br />

He said there was an important learning process<br />

for co-ops when it comes to data.<br />

“We need education to make sure we don’t pass<br />

on data that takes value from members. It’s a<br />

question at board level of how we deal with these<br />

issues when things are changing so fast.”<br />

join our journey<br />

be a member<br />

New ways of building trust<br />

Looking ahead, big data is part of an information<br />

revolution that is creating new ways of working.<br />

Taynaah Reis, chief executive of Moeda, a Brazilian<br />

co-operative crypto-bank, told the session her<br />

organisation was creating “an internet of trust”.<br />

“We are working on a circular economy, testing<br />

technology and bringing it to India and Africa.<br />

We are empowering people to access finance via<br />

blockchain technology.”<br />

Again, the relationship between co-op and<br />

member is crucial. Ms Reis said: “It’s important<br />

we work with person providing data to know their<br />

needs, follow them, help them to grow.<br />

“There’s a lot of unemployment in Brazil, but<br />

we’re bringing people together in co-op system<br />

where they feel safe to share information and<br />

receive guidance, and learn to make profit with<br />

a purpose. Brazil seen as a risk, but we show<br />

transparency. Investors are happier to invest; they<br />

trust us because we are sharing that information.”<br />

news<br />

We’ve relaunched our membership,<br />

offering member-owners more opportunity to<br />

help us plot the future of our independent coverage<br />

of the co-operative movement.<br />

Find out more at:<br />

thenews.coop/join<br />

<strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong> | 47


REVIEWS<br />

Co-operation meets the civil rights movement in vision of a city’s future<br />

Jackson Rising:<br />

The struggle<br />

for economic<br />

democracy<br />

and black selfdetermination<br />

in Jackson,<br />

Mississippi<br />

Kali Akuno and<br />

Ajamu Nangwaya<br />

(Daraja Press)<br />

The use of co-operative models to rebuild struggling<br />

local economies is beginning to take root, with<br />

examples such as Cleveland in the USA and Preston<br />

in the UK. But in Jackson, Mississippi, activists are<br />

aiming for an even more radical and transformative<br />

model, which draws on the civil rights struggle and<br />

the Black Power movement.<br />

In 2013 a group of activists founded the<br />

Cooperation Jackson workers co-op which,<br />

beginning with a farm, some plots of land and<br />

community centre, aims to build a new economy for<br />

the city’s majority black population.<br />

It aims to “to develop a co-operative network<br />

based in Jackson, Mississippi that will consist of four<br />

interconnected and interdependent institutions: an<br />

emerging federation of local worker co-operatives,<br />

a developing co-operative incubator, a co-operative<br />

education and training center (the Lumumba Center<br />

for Economic Democracy and Development), and a<br />

co-operative bank or financial institution”.<br />

Cooperation Jackson’s aim is to organise and<br />

empower “the structurally under and unemployed<br />

sectors of the working class, particularly from Black<br />

and Latino communities, to build worker organised<br />

and owned co-operatives will be a catalyst<br />

for the democratization of our economy and<br />

society overall.”<br />

And it’s now the subject of this collection of essays<br />

documenting “the history and intersectionality of<br />

the co-operative movement and the Mississippi<br />

Freedom Movement”.<br />

Jackson Rising describes moves by the city’s<br />

council to engage residents in participatory<br />

democracy – for instance by giving them a say over<br />

the spending of the city budget and championing<br />

a human rights charter and comission to confront<br />

“the abuse of state power, police brutality, and<br />

inhumane policies that lead to the discrimination,<br />

inequality and gross inequities experienced by<br />

Blacks, Latinos, indigenous peoples, immigrants,<br />

workers, Muslims and other religious minorities, the<br />

homeless and members of the LGBTQI community”.<br />

Rooted in the Jackson-Kush plan, devised by Black<br />

activists between 2004 and 2010 to encourage<br />

a “democratic transition to eco-socialism”,<br />

Cooperation Jackson says its ultimate aims are to<br />

place the ownership and control over the primary<br />

means of production in the hands of the city’s black<br />

working class; to advance “ecologically regenerative<br />

forces of production”; to democratically transform<br />

the political economy of the city, and the wider state<br />

and south-eastern USA; and to advance moves<br />

to attain self-determination for people of African<br />

descent and the democratic transformation of the<br />

state of Mississippi.<br />

Ultimately, the co-op leaders say they want to<br />

transition the economy away from capitalism to a<br />

more sustainable, carbon-free model.<br />

p<br />

Co-operators in Jackson want to use the movement’s values to transform their community<br />

48 | <strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong>


p<br />

Members of Cooperation Jackson take a stand<br />

The co-op also takes on board technological<br />

advances. The book looks at the launch of a<br />

Community Production Initiative, which hopes<br />

to use digital technology automated production,<br />

3D printing and quantum computing for a<br />

manufacturing process that is collectively owned<br />

and democratically operated by members of the<br />

community.<br />

Cooperation Jackson is also working to develop<br />

co-operatives in housing, construction, childcare<br />

and solar energy, alongside green worker co-ops,<br />

which will have their own supply and value chains.<br />

The project draws on a long history – as well as<br />

taking lessons from examples overseas such as<br />

Mondragon in Spain, the book looks back at the<br />

history of black co-operatives in the USA, stretching<br />

back to the Colored Farmers’ National Alliance and<br />

Cooperative Union, formed in Texas in 1886. And it<br />

pays tribute to the work of Chokwe Lumumba, who<br />

served as mayor of Jackson from 2013 until his death<br />

in 2014 and sowed the seeds of the co-op plan.<br />

It is early days for Cooperation Jackson, and the<br />

book describes moves by the white-led Mississippi<br />

state legislature to limit the city’s autonomy. But this<br />

books is a useful look at one of the many directions<br />

the co-operative movement might take, under the<br />

influence of new technologies and combined with<br />

new political movements. In this case, in the words<br />

of Mayor Lumumba, means “the building of the<br />

new society”.<br />

Bringing crucial values back home to the business world<br />

Over the past century, a crucial set of values have<br />

been lost in the business world.<br />

Common sense business is a moral framework<br />

for-profit and non-profit firms around prudence,<br />

patience, principles and practicality, according to<br />

the author.<br />

Prudence is one of the leading traits in the book.<br />

The virtue and practice of prudence “is still a<br />

highly esteemed virtue in some realms of society”,<br />

but argues the author, “has largely left both the<br />

business vocabulary and the parlance of everyday<br />

thinking in economics”.<br />

To restore prudence would see humans flourishing<br />

at the centre of the enterprise, rather than being on<br />

the outskirts.<br />

What does common sense business mean? In<br />

economics, it is a way to save money, but today<br />

prudence/common sense is hardly the supreme<br />

virtue it once was. The idea of a noble purpose<br />

guiding our actions has been abandoned, according<br />

to the author.<br />

One of the causes is education. Studies show<br />

that MBA students leave business school with even<br />

less regard for ethical standards than they had upon<br />

arrival. They are taught that “dog-eat-dog” survival<br />

means there is not really much room for ethics<br />

in business.<br />

The book looks at the shining lights in the<br />

business world, such as the strength of Canada’s<br />

well-regulated banking system, which protected it<br />

from the recession, or Germany’s family/peopleoriented<br />

small businesses, which are champions of<br />

engagement with communities.<br />

In Japan, the author visited Ippodo – a company<br />

that sources its tea from the Nagata tea co-operative.<br />

As part of its ethical culture, it rejects chemical<br />

spraying, animal manures, chemical fertilisers,<br />

herbicides, or any pesticides. They keep to nature<br />

and stress the importance of building and keeping<br />

the soil vitality.<br />

The authors met with the managers of Ippodo –<br />

a company that stretches back over three centuries<br />

– who said their common sense plan included a<br />

150-year strategic plan. Within this document were<br />

some principles, such as how it is sensitive to its<br />

ecological environment and the communities in<br />

which they participate.<br />

Managers come from within the company,<br />

and employees feel like generations of a family,<br />

according to the authors.<br />

Common-Sense<br />

Business:<br />

Principles<br />

for Profitable<br />

Leadership<br />

Theodore Roosevelt<br />

Malloch and Whitney<br />

MacMillan (Skyhorse<br />

Publishing)<br />

<strong>JANUARY</strong> <strong>2018</strong> | 49


DIARY<br />

CLOCKWISE FROM FAR LEFT: Prof Jan<br />

Godsell speaks at the SAOS Conference in<br />

Dunblane on 25 January; Arjen van Nuland<br />

is among speakers at the Co-operative<br />

Retail Conference in Warwick on 9 March;<br />

Unicorn Grocery will be providing food<br />

at the Worker Co-op Weekend in Great<br />

Hucklow on 11-13 May; Community Energy<br />

Fortnight runs from 23 June - 8 July<br />

19 January: Restorative Approaches to<br />

Housing Conference<br />

Wales Restorative Approaches<br />

Partnership event, with host Julia<br />

Houlston Clark. The conference will look<br />

at how to take a whole organisational<br />

approach to restorative approaches.<br />

WHERE: Cardiff<br />

INFO: jessicao@restorativewales.org.uk<br />

25 January: SAOS Conference <strong>2018</strong><br />

The Scottish Agricultural Organisation<br />

looks at supply chains and how to<br />

create value through collaboration. With<br />

speakers Prof Daniel Côté, University of<br />

Montreal, and Prof Jan Godsell, University<br />

of Warwick.<br />

WHERE: Dunblane Hydro Hotel<br />

INFO: saos@saos.coop<br />

9 March: Co-operative Retail Conference<br />

With keynote presentations from industry<br />

specialists, best practice from retailers<br />

and sessions for delegates to discuss<br />

the co-operative retail environment, the<br />

conference offers networking and learning<br />

opportunities during a challenging and<br />

fast-changing time for the co-operative<br />

retail movement. Speakers include Arjen<br />

van Nuland, managing director of the<br />

Dutch National Council for Cooperatives<br />

and Jill Livesy, managing director of<br />

consumer research experts HIM.<br />

WHERE: Chesford Grange,<br />

Kenilworth, Warwick<br />

INFO: www.uk.coop<br />

9 March: Regional Co-operative Councils<br />

networking session and presentation<br />

Networking session at the Co-operative<br />

Retail Conference, offering a chance and<br />

learn more about what is happening<br />

in the different regional co-operative<br />

councils. Organised by Co-operatives<br />

East, Co-operatives East Midlands<br />

and Co-operatives West Midlands,<br />

with presentation from Jim Cook at the<br />

Co-operative Foundation on helping<br />

disadvantaged communities overcome<br />

challenges by putting co-operative<br />

values and principles into practice.<br />

WHERE: Chesford Grange,<br />

Kenilworth Warwick<br />

INFO: s.coop/25x8s<br />

18 April: Co-ops East Midlands – Visit to<br />

The Rochdale Pioneers Museum<br />

Coaches from Lincoln, Derby and<br />

Nottingham. To register interest and<br />

receive further details, please respond to<br />

Jenny de Villiers, jdevilliers@btinternet.<br />

com. A fun day out for store colleagues,<br />

members, families and all interested in<br />

the history of the Co-op<br />

WHERE: Rochdale Pioneers Museum<br />

INFO: s.coop/25x8t<br />

11-13 May: Worker Co-op Weekend<br />

The Worker Co-op Weekend, hosted by<br />

Co-operatives UK, has practical sessions<br />

covering a range of topics. Designed<br />

and run by worker co-ops for worker<br />

co-ops, with food sourced from co-ops<br />

like Essential and Suma, with bread from<br />

Infinity, beer from Bartlebys Brewery and<br />

veg from Unicorn Grocery. Vegan-friendly<br />

catering, camping and campfires.<br />

WHERE: Foundry Adventure Centre,<br />

Great Hucklow, Derbyshire<br />

INFO: www.uk.coop/wcw18<br />

LOOKING AHEAD<br />

18 May: Co-operatives UK annual general<br />

meeting (Manchester)<br />

23 June – 8 July: Community<br />

Energy Fortnight<br />

23 June: Co-operative Congress (London)<br />

50 | NOVEMBER 2017


“<br />

I’ve chosen energy from around the<br />

corner not across the ocean”<br />

100% renewable electricity and green gas.<br />

Did you know that on average your energy travels 2,500 miles to<br />

reach you? We don’t think this is good for the environment, so on<br />

average, our customers are never more than four miles away from<br />

one of our generators. Join our 100,000 customers and make the<br />

switch to reduce your carbon footprint by up to 50%.<br />

Change now to cleaner, greener, local energy.<br />

Switch today, call us on<br />

0800 254 0015<br />

goodenergy.co.uk/cpn5<br />

FREE £50<br />

John Lewis<br />

voucher<br />

Quote ‘CPN1217’<br />

when you switch<br />

Offer ends 28/02/<strong>2018</strong><br />

Find out more about:<br />

Where energy comes from: goodenergy.co.uk/energy-miles<br />

Reducing your carbon footprint by up to 50%: goodenergy.co.uk/goodstats<br />

Our 100% renewable electricity: goodenergy.co.uk/source<br />

Our Green Gas: goodenergy.co.uk/green-gas<br />

John Lewis Promotion: goodenergy.co.uk/terms-conditions


co-op<br />

Switch<br />

& fix<br />

your energy prices<br />

with<br />

Co-op Energy<br />

And<br />

receive up to<br />

£100<br />

in travel<br />

vouchers *<br />

HURRY!<br />

This tariff will only be<br />

available for a limited time.<br />

Join today:<br />

www.cooperativeenergy.coop/CoopNewsHoliday<br />

0800 093 7511<br />

co operative travel<br />

Part of The Midcounties Co-operative<br />

*Terms and conditions apply

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!