Views
4 months ago

African-American Youth in The Juvenile Justice System

African-American Youth in The Juvenile Justice System

The

The percentage of black arrests and adjudications has actually increased in the last 20 years. In 1990, black youth were 15 percent of the entire youth population, but they made up 27 percent of juvenile arrests, 33 percent of adjudications and 40 percent of detentions. The only area that saw improvement by 2010 was in transfers to adult court, where black youth comprised 49 percent of transfers in 1990. The OJJDP also uses another measurement to determine the level of disproportionate contact for youth of color, known as the Relative Rate Index or RRI, which looks at white youth contact at several points in the system and compares that to minority contact. White contact is assigned the number 1 and anything above 1 would be considered disproportionate or overrepresented. A 1 to 1 ratio would indicate that white and minority youth are appearing at equal rates in the system. RRI_adjudicationsRRI data from OJJDP from 1990-2010 shows that minority youth are still overrepresented in many areas. However, detentions did fall from 1.6 in 1990 to 1.4 in 2010, and waivers fell from 1.7 to 1.4. Adjudications of black youth remained the same at 0.9, but arrests increased from 2 in 1990 to 2.1 in 2010, indicating that arrests of black youth are still occurring at twice the rate of white youth arrests. These numbers may be disheartening to many who work to reduce the disproportionate number of minority youth in the juvenile justice system, especially given that OJJDP has awarded hundreds of millions to states since 1988, when Congress mandated recipients of formula grants have plans to address disproportionate minority contact, also known as DMC. The law was later amended in 2002 to address the disproportionate number of minority youth who come into any contact with the juvenile justice system and are not just in confinement. Millions Spent To get a general sense of how much money is involved, consider that OJJDP has given more than $600 million in formula grants and other grants that have DMC components from 2007-2013 alone. The agency also spends time assisting states in training, technical assistance and evaluations. Although OJJDP gives "strong recommendations" to states on how they should spend their formula grants, the amount devoted to DMC reduction efforts varies by state, said Andrea Coleman, OJJDP's DMC coordinator. Some states allocate 80 percent, while others will set aside 20 percent or 15 percent, she added. RRI_DetentionsThe agency requires those seeking formula funds to follow their DMC Reduction Model, which begins with identifying the extent of DMC using the RRI formula, assessing what's contributing to DMC and implementing plans to reduce DMC through the use of diversion, alternatives to confinement, training or procedural changes. The final phases of the model include evaluating how effective their actions have been, monitoring to see if data reflects changes to DMC and making adjustments based on the data. Page 40 of 114

This model is often far too general, said James Bell, the founder and executive director of the W. Haywood Burns Institute, which works to eliminate racial and ethnic disparity in the juvenile justice system. "The statute that they're working with says that the OJJDP shall address DMC," Bell said. "OJJDP has gotten much better over time, but when we first started, literally ‘address’ could be you and I go together to a salad bar and talk about it. If I don't want to do anything, what I'll do is address it by giving 10 grand to a professor at a local college to come up with a study, and then put on a conference next year, or maybe an MLK breakfast." Bell said what's lacking is direction from OJJDP to look at DMC at a local level, in counties, cities, police departments and schools. The agency has also been overly focused on getting communities to learn and calculate the RRI in their community, which Bell said doesn't provide the full picture of inequality. "You have to analyze crimes in specific communities. Sometimes the problem is not racism or poverty. Sometimes the reason for DMC is they've set up a system that couldn't help anyone," Bell said. "It could be something as simple as when that jurisdiction holds court, whether it’s on a morning calendar or an afternoon calendar." graphic2-01One of the failings of the federal grant process to reduce DMC is that it's not clear where the money has been spent on a local level, added Alex Piquero, a criminology professor at the University of Texas in Dallas who has researched DMC. Success stories are also isolated, and solutions are hard to extrapolate because what may work in Santa Cruz may not work in Philadelphia or Orlando, he added. "Just because you throw money at a problem, doesn't mean it will solve the problem," Piquero said. "Dollars have to be spent wisely. We need to figure out why these statistics emerge the way they do and spend careful attention on why these kids offend at different rates or for different reasons and how the systems deal with them." Page 41 of 114

Latino and Hispanic Youth in the Juvenile Justice System
Native American Youth In The Juvenile Justice System
Juvenile Justice System and Risk Factor Data - Illinois Criminal ...
ReEngineering Juvenile Justice
A SYSTEM PRIORITY - Georgia Department of Juvenile Justice
Juvenile Justice Handbook - Texas Attorney General
Minnesota Juvenile Justice Advisory Committee - Minnesota State ...
Understanding the Juvenile Justice System and IDEIA - The Family ...
Juvenile Justice Involved Youth: Issues and Models of Coordination
Juvenile Justice System and Risk Factor Data 2008 Annual Report
Presentation on the Juvenile Justice Code - Eulex
Is Missing: - Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention
Co-Offending and Patterns of Juvenile Crime - justice studies
Restoring the Balance: Juvenile and Community Justice - National ...
Disproportionate Minority Confinement - National Criminal Justice ...
Juvenile Justice System Improvement - JDAI Helpdesk
Landmark Cases in US Juvenile Justice (New Jersey)
Your Guide to the Juvenile Justice System in Illinois - National ...
Child Welfare and Juvenile Justice – Two Sides of ... - National CASA
2006 National Report - Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency ...
Landmark Cases in US Juvenile Justice (Pennsylvania)
New Data Coordinators Training - Texas Juvenile Justice Department
improving outcomes for youth with disabilities in the juvenile justice ...
Building Community for Youth in the Juvenile Justice and ... - IIRP
African American Outreach Guide - Caring Connections
Juvenile Justice System and Risk Factor Data - Illinois Criminal ...
Meeting the Health Needs of Youth Involved in the Juvenile Justice ...
Juvenile Justice & Mental Health - Technical Assistance Partnership
Differential treatment in the youth justice system - Equality and ...