Movement 99
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
AIDS AND THE CHURCH . THE CULF CRISIS . lN<br />
D<br />
IA AND PAKISTAN<br />
movement<br />
I .rlli<br />
'<br />
i<br />
1<br />
.l.ii'<br />
,]:<br />
)tii tr ''<br />
lssue <strong>99</strong> o Spring 1<strong>99</strong>8<br />
f2 lFrce to Membersl<br />
#'ry<br />
Br-<br />
Y<br />
\^-.<br />
€<br />
MORE TEA FATHER?<br />
So long to Father Ted<br />
and his friends<br />
THE MYSTERIES<br />
Behind the scenes at the<br />
RSC's radical retelling of<br />
the Gospel<br />
getting beyond<br />
he<br />
on<br />
academic debat<br />
legalising cannabis<br />
THE MAGAZINE OF THE<br />
STUDENT CHRISTIAN<br />
MOVEMENT<br />
Y
t<br />
*T<br />
3 \<br />
*<br />
#<br />
j<br />
4<br />
E<br />
GET FOCUSS<br />
SCM Publications will keep Vou in focus with all the vital issues fac'<br />
ing young people today, with resources in accessible formats<br />
that give sharper resolution to what's going on.<br />
The Dying Game A Young Person's Guide to Death f5.00<br />
Significant Others Talking About Relationships f4.50<br />
Common People Rethinking Christianity & Community f4.50<br />
The F-Word A Guide to Christian Fundamentalism<br />
f3.OO<br />
No More Mr Nice Guy A New Look at Jesus<br />
f3'00<br />
Just Love The Theology of Sexuality<br />
f2.OO<br />
God Made Simple An lntroduction to ldeas about God [2.00<br />
Postage and Packing - f 1 per item (EU) / f.2 per item (overseas)<br />
Name<br />
Address<br />
Pu blications Req uested<br />
I enclose a cheque Imade payable to 'SCM'I for E<br />
RETURN TO: SCM, WESTHILL 14116 WEOLEY PARK OAK, BIRMINGHAM 829 6LL
The recent death of Dermot Morgan also brought an end to an enduring comic creation,<br />
Father Ted. Terry Orsett offers a tribute<br />
Fathe? Ted YYe<br />
,<br />
Hardly Knew Ye<br />
l^ : : :fl?'; J,T:: iit,.l"" Ini,".,"<br />
I delav the premiere of the<br />
V current series of Father Ted bv<br />
one week. lt was a decision that was,<br />
for all its good intentions, completely<br />
wrong.<br />
I suppose it was thought to be in<br />
bad taste to show it-in the same way<br />
that planners regularly postpone<br />
episodes of London's Burning because<br />
there happened to be a fire in that<br />
week's episode which resembled the<br />
one in Woking the previous Thursday.<br />
But what none of these people think<br />
about is how cathartic laughter is. And<br />
Father Zed is especially cathartic,<br />
because it's especially funny. lt would<br />
have been a fitting testament to Dermot<br />
Morgan, who in his portrayal of Father<br />
Ted has created one of this generation's<br />
most enduring comic creations, not to<br />
have postponed airing the current series.<br />
It could have been a sort of televisual<br />
wake.<br />
I was first introduced to Father Ted<br />
and his fellow denizens of the Craggy<br />
lsland parochial house by friends who<br />
were atheists. For them, the scheming<br />
but incompetent Father Ted, the clueless<br />
but sweet Father Dougal, and the<br />
catatonic but lascivious Father Jack<br />
took the mickey out of the authoritarian<br />
Catholic structure they grew up with.<br />
But it's not only those who are secular<br />
who erupt into riotous laughter. Some of<br />
the ir,ost devoted fans of the series l've<br />
encountered are the Clergy themselves.<br />
Ithink that is'the brilliance of Father<br />
Ted. lt's a comedy about the church<br />
where people on the inside and the<br />
outside of the institution can have a<br />
good laugh at it.<br />
Father Ted's creators, Graham<br />
Linehan and Arthur Matthews, have<br />
gone to extraordinary lengths not to<br />
offend people, far more than I think they<br />
needed to. Ted and Dougal are never<br />
seen conducting Mass or visitationseven<br />
conversation about their priestly<br />
functions are limited to a few isolated<br />
instances here and there. For Linehan<br />
and Matthews, the comedy is about a<br />
bunch of inept people with lots of time<br />
on their hands.<br />
Which is somewhat misleading,<br />
because these people with time on their<br />
hands are priests,<br />
and the priesthood in<br />
Father Ted is<br />
populated by people<br />
who are. frankly, not<br />
that bright. They are people<br />
like Ted, who are in an arrested<br />
state of adolescence (or, like<br />
Dougal, never even got that<br />
far). lt's sad but people like<br />
Ted exist and they became<br />
priests because, probably<br />
like Ted. they couldn't<br />
get a date while in<br />
school (with either<br />
gender) and they<br />
found a profession<br />
where not much is<br />
really required of<br />
them. ln this respect,<br />
Father led is perhaps<br />
more subversive than<br />
Jimmy McGovern's<br />
Priest: it's one thing<br />
to expose an institution<br />
for its cruelty;<br />
it's another to<br />
expose the incompetence<br />
which masks<br />
itself behind virtue<br />
and piety on a<br />
regular basis.<br />
Even so, there's<br />
another level to<br />
appreciating Father<br />
Ied which isn't<br />
discussed as much. For it's not just a<br />
comedy about authority figures, it's a<br />
comedy about being Christian. I think<br />
most of us, if we really searched our<br />
hearts, would find that we blunder<br />
through our lives and the moral conundrums<br />
as Ted does: our lies snowball on<br />
us. We are not as devout or as moral as<br />
we pretend to be. At the end of the day<br />
there's a lot of shrieking and praying<br />
and even when we win, it's a pyrrhic<br />
victory at best.<br />
My favourite episode o't Father Ted<br />
embodies some of these<br />
aspects. lt's the one<br />
where Ted and Dougal<br />
make an lrish Eurovision<br />
entry. Ted, unable to come<br />
up with a melody to<br />
gal's lyrics<br />
(about<br />
tune of an obscure Swedish song from<br />
the seventies only to discover the same<br />
song being played in the lift on the<br />
night of his performance. He ends up<br />
because the judges<br />
want the lrish entry<br />
to fail at Eurovision<br />
And<br />
that's why<br />
Father Ted is<br />
going to<br />
be<br />
missed<br />
'inmy<br />
Iife<br />
from<br />
now on:<br />
l'm going to<br />
miss the man wearing<br />
the collar of moral<br />
authority who regularly proves that<br />
he's no more or less incompetent than<br />
I am at getting out of the moral pits<br />
we dig ourselves into. Father Ted<br />
wasn't just about laughing at the<br />
church; it was about laughing at<br />
ourselves. E<br />
Terry Orsett is a writer in London<br />
movgment 1
fnovefnGnt<br />
no 98<br />
spring 1<strong>99</strong>8<br />
movement is the termlY<br />
magazine of the<br />
Student Christian<br />
<strong>Movement</strong>, distributed<br />
free of charge to members<br />
and dedicated to<br />
an open-minded exploration<br />
of Christianity<br />
editorial address<br />
PO Box 1 6735<br />
London E'l 4 6SN<br />
tel: 0958 730381<br />
MovemntSCM@aol.com<br />
SCM central office<br />
Westhill Cgllege<br />
14l15 Weoley Park Rd<br />
Selly Oak<br />
Birmingham 829 6LL<br />
tel: 0121 471 2404<br />
fax: O1 21 414 1251<br />
SCM@charis.co. uk<br />
editor<br />
Graeme Burk<br />
editorial assistant<br />
Carrie O'Grady<br />
editorial board<br />
Tim Woodcock<br />
Kate Wilson<br />
lrfan Merchant<br />
Craig Cooling<br />
Stephen Matthews<br />
disclaimer<br />
The views expressed in<br />
movement are those of<br />
the particular author<br />
and should not be taken<br />
to be the policy of the<br />
Student Christian<br />
<strong>Movement</strong><br />
SCM staff<br />
Coordinator<br />
Carolyn Clayton<br />
Project Worker - GrouPs<br />
Craig Cooling<br />
Project Worker -<br />
Mem bership Danelopment<br />
Stephen Matthews<br />
membership fees<br />
tl5 (waged)<br />
f 10 (unwaged/students)<br />
next copydate<br />
25th Junel <strong>99</strong>8<br />
rssN 0306-980X<br />
Charity No 241896<br />
o1<br />
<strong>99</strong>8 SCM<br />
A Tale of Two Conferences<br />
This year's scottish scM conference and our annual Joint conference were great<br />
successes, report James chedworth and Tim woodcock<br />
Scottish SCM Conference<br />
clasgow<br />
13th-15th February 1<strong>99</strong>8<br />
t\ I :l; 11,', l,-J":il:il'"'<br />
I \l ,n", can ertner wetcome<br />
or shun people...offer two<br />
arms or two fingers-and<br />
there is nowhere more interesting<br />
and upbeat as Scotland<br />
at the moment.<br />
ldentity is something that,<br />
try as you might, cannot be<br />
forged alone. Twenty or so<br />
SCMers (idealists. cYnics and<br />
drifters) came together to<br />
discuss such matters. lt was<br />
directed inspirationallY bY<br />
Brian Hardy (a sPrightlY Priest<br />
who was rather like the angel<br />
Clarence from lt's A<br />
Wonderful Lifel<br />
-and ranged<br />
Lesslie<br />
Newbigin:<br />
I go9- I <strong>99</strong>8<br />
1-his past February marked the passing<br />
I of an old friend of SCM. Bishop Lesslie<br />
I Newbigin was one of Britain's leading<br />
ecumenists whose varied career included<br />
work in Madras and lndia' He was a tireless<br />
proponent for Christian unity, and authored a<br />
number of books on the subject. Often he<br />
worked with the World Council of Churches'<br />
an organisation which he was associate<br />
general secretary of for a time.<br />
Bishop Newbigin accredited his commitment<br />
to ecumenism-and indeed<br />
Christianity-to his days in the Cambridge<br />
SCM, and commented on this in an interview<br />
in <strong>Movement</strong> in 1986:<br />
"As a student in my first year at college I<br />
was both welcomed and challenged by a<br />
loosely knit group of fellow-students who<br />
were willing to take me as I was, to take my<br />
questions seriously, and who in many<br />
different ways commended me to a faith<br />
which was bigger than any of the denominational<br />
expressions of it.<br />
"We still need the SCM. We can't do<br />
without it. lf the Christian faith is to find<br />
authentic expression in the specific circumsances<br />
of a student community...it needs to<br />
be a student movement, not an organisation<br />
/or students.<br />
from the parochial to the<br />
mind-bogglingly international.<br />
The sentimental to the<br />
dynamic.<br />
Light relief cam from<br />
indoor football, walks in the<br />
rain, flag-painting. trying to<br />
keep the alcoholics we were<br />
sharing the building with<br />
anonymous, and Emily's keyring<br />
torch. The latter was also<br />
a source of frustration for<br />
those of us who needed<br />
sleep.<br />
Although sometimes<br />
circular the topic threw uP a<br />
number of memorable<br />
thoughts such as: "nationality<br />
is where we've come from;<br />
faith is where we're going."<br />
We all left a bit more<br />
gemmed-up. And a bit more<br />
mixed-up.<br />
Joint Conference<br />
Birmingham<br />
19th-21st FebruarY 1<strong>99</strong>8<br />
tt iving on aPraYer"<br />
-- I was the theme of<br />
l-this year's<br />
Conference with MethSoc and<br />
the Catholic Students<br />
Association, lt was one of the<br />
most successful conferences<br />
in recent memory, with an<br />
impressive turnout of<br />
students-including a contingent<br />
of Western EuroPeans<br />
who got lost trYing to find<br />
Edgbaston late FridaY evening<br />
The highlights included the<br />
service on SundaY and indeed<br />
the worship throughout, the<br />
food. the art workshoP and<br />
especially the Celidh on<br />
Saturday night!<br />
movsmont 2<br />
li I
Say Hello To Carolynl<br />
SCM has just welcomed a<br />
new staff member in the form<br />
of Carolyn Clayion (pictured<br />
here with feline friend<br />
Tiggeil. Carolyn began her<br />
new role as SCM Coordinator<br />
in April.<br />
ln what is now become<br />
something of a tradition,<br />
We've asked Carolyn to say a<br />
few words about herself...<br />
I I elloool Mv name is<br />
H Carotyn ano I have just<br />
I I join"i scM as the new<br />
Project Worker (Coordinator)<br />
which basically means I'm in<br />
charge of keeping things<br />
ticking over at Central Office<br />
and making sure we don't<br />
spend too much money!<br />
However I will also get the<br />
chance to travel a bit with<br />
Craig and Stephen and meet<br />
as many SCMers as we can<br />
manage.<br />
l'm 23 years old and<br />
graducated from Hull<br />
University last July with a<br />
degree in History and ltalian,<br />
with a particular emphasis<br />
on History of Art. I enjoyed<br />
the variety of a joint degree<br />
which gave me the chance<br />
to dip into many different<br />
subject areas and therefore<br />
gain a wider picture<br />
of how the world in which<br />
we live came to be as it<br />
is. Unfortunately part of<br />
my course involved<br />
having to go to ltaly for<br />
a year (sobl) where I<br />
was forced to spend<br />
hours sitting in<br />
pavement cafes<br />
drinking cappuccino<br />
and calling it work...l haven't<br />
recovered yet.<br />
Spiritually I started to<br />
think about faith issues<br />
whilst in Sixth Form. This<br />
t-<br />
14-16 June<br />
SCM SUMMER RETREAT<br />
Bath<br />
Contact: Craig Cooling<br />
SCM, Westhill College<br />
14l15 Weoley Park Rd<br />
Birmingham 829 6LL<br />
0121 471 2404<br />
SCM@charis.co.uk<br />
L<br />
28 JulV-7 August<br />
EUROPEAN ECUMENICAL<br />
YOUTH GATHERING<br />
WiHhaus, Switzerland<br />
Theme: Open Your Doors<br />
Contact: WSCF Europe, Prins<br />
Hendriklaan 37, NL-1075 BA<br />
Amsterdam, Netherlands<br />
+31 20 675 4921<br />
11-13 September<br />
TRAINING PROGRAMME<br />
WEEKEND<br />
Bimingham (TBC)<br />
Ever wanted to start an SCM<br />
group? This event will focus on<br />
issues around groupwork-facilitating<br />
groups, how to form and run your<br />
own SCM group. lf you are interested<br />
in running workshops (possibly at<br />
another group near you) or if you<br />
will be running a group next year or<br />
movelnent 3<br />
was the beginning of a<br />
journey that has taken me<br />
through significant involvement<br />
in the<br />
Anglican Chaplaincy at Uni, a<br />
CMS Experience Camp to<br />
Romania, two pilgrimages to<br />
lona and seven months as the<br />
Lay Assistant to the<br />
University of the West of<br />
England in Bristol. I enjoy a<br />
wide variety of worship styles<br />
but am reluctant to tie myself<br />
down to any one. I am more<br />
interested in what we do<br />
with our beliefs and how they<br />
affect the way we live,<br />
breathe and have our being.<br />
Just at the moment I am<br />
busy finding my feet at SCM<br />
but my long-term aims<br />
involve trying to develop links<br />
with organisations with<br />
similar views to see if we can<br />
learn from and assist one<br />
another. I also want to try<br />
and extend the circulation of<br />
SCM resources and generally<br />
heighten awareness of the<br />
movement, what we stand<br />
for and what we do. I can't<br />
wait to start and look forward<br />
to meeting you all and<br />
hearing what you have to say.<br />
if you just find it interesting and<br />
want to come along then this is the<br />
event for you.<br />
Contact: Craig Cooling<br />
SCM, Westhill College<br />
14115 Weoley Park Rd<br />
Birmingham 829 6LL<br />
0121 471 2404<br />
SCM@charis.co.uk<br />
Late November<br />
SCM ANNUAL CONFERENCE<br />
Location: TBA<br />
Theme: Displacement & Deviance<br />
Contact; Craig Cooling<br />
SCM, Westhill College<br />
14l15 Weoley Park Rd<br />
Birmingham 829 6LL<br />
0121 471 2404<br />
SCM@charis.co.uk<br />
F}<br />
ō<br />
G.<br />
ro<br />
I<br />
-<br />
'C<br />
5<br />
c a<br />
C)<br />
cct<br />
o)<br />
5<br />
o.<br />
.J\<br />
g)<br />
(D<br />
(o<br />
cd(D<br />
ci<br />
o<br />
€<br />
5<br />
g)<br />
-(,t)<br />
{O<br />
9.<br />
f<br />
{O<br />
of<br />
'l
what happens when personal choice clashes with the law? You can campaign, or vou can<br />
ignore the law completely and carry on regardless. This is the route William Straw chose when<br />
h-b sold cannabis to'a reporter. colin Mason takes us through the moral and ethical haze--<br />
Smoke Gets<br />
ln Our Yes<br />
Pftj,fil;tr'"*iil,i;"'l,i*]-<br />
the 'Formula One affair' and the foreign<br />
secretary's infidelity has been unimpressive.<br />
Another embarrassment for the<br />
government was the story of Jack<br />
Straw's son's arrest for suPPlYing<br />
cannabis. The issue of decriminalising<br />
cannabis had become a live issue again<br />
thanks mainly to a campaign launched<br />
by The lndependent on SundaY<br />
newspaper. This I feel is an important<br />
campaign which needs strong<br />
consideration.<br />
Drawing lines in the sand is<br />
something we have to do as individuals.<br />
Our everyday lives involve risk to<br />
varying degrees. So it is necessary to<br />
weigh up the consequences and their<br />
possible effects on other people and<br />
ourselves. However, this is also a collective<br />
responsibility and one of the main<br />
functions of law. and there is great<br />
potential for conflict between these two<br />
decision making processes.<br />
Smoking tobacco and drinking<br />
alcohol are activities which involve<br />
potentially high degrees of risk. Tar in<br />
cigarettes is directly responsible for lung<br />
canQer and ultimately death. Passive<br />
smoking extends the risk to other<br />
people. Alcohol las its own dangers and<br />
is responsible for thousands of deaths<br />
from traffic accidents each year. These<br />
facts are well known and accepted by<br />
most people but tobacco and alcohol<br />
are still widely available and will<br />
continue to be so. There are restrictions<br />
(and taxes) but each person must make<br />
their own assessment and decision'<br />
The same cannot be said of beef on<br />
the bone. There is a minute risk of<br />
contracting the fatal disease CJD from<br />
eating this. lt is now illegal to buy it.<br />
Unpasteurised milk has also met this<br />
fate in Scotland and was seriously at<br />
risk of being banned in the rest of<br />
Britain. These were seen by many to be<br />
further examples of the<br />
'nanny state' interfering with<br />
personal choice.<br />
What happens when the<br />
personal assessment clashes<br />
with the law? The law<br />
draws lines in the sand but<br />
these may be moved through<br />
campaigns and changes in<br />
attitudes. Another possibilitY<br />
is to ignore the law<br />
completely and carrY on<br />
regardless. This is the route<br />
William Straw chose when<br />
he sold cannabis to a<br />
reporter (much to the<br />
consternation of his father<br />
Jack, the Home Secretary).<br />
The case of cannabis, a<br />
controlled class C drug, is a<br />
good example of this conflict<br />
and also of how camPaigns<br />
to change the law work.<br />
The campaign to decriminalise<br />
cannabis has been<br />
given fresh impetus in recent<br />
months by The lndePendent<br />
on Sunday's coverage. This<br />
has in turn provoked<br />
reactionary items from more<br />
conservative newsPaPers and<br />
a week of programmes on<br />
Radio 1 (interestingly, but not<br />
surprisingly, the I n depen dent<br />
did not support its sister<br />
newspaper's campaign).<br />
Publicity was also generated<br />
by the William Straw case<br />
and the alleged suppression<br />
of a World Health<br />
Organisation report into the<br />
effects of cannabis. The<br />
campaign is definitelY rolling<br />
but to where and whY?<br />
Decriminalising cannabis<br />
is in some sense a minor<br />
movement 4<br />
issue. The new government has an<br />
extremely long list of pressing matters
welfare reform, new environmental<br />
legislation, constitutional reform and so<br />
on. All of these seem more urgent<br />
because they effect us all.<br />
Decriminalised cannabis would be used<br />
mainly for recreational purposes and so<br />
seems to belong to a more selfish<br />
agenda.<br />
This is not entirely fair but it does<br />
sound reasonable. Why not then extend<br />
the issue to take in the bigger question<br />
of drugs in general? This is a big<br />
concern for most people, not least those<br />
addicted, those in prison for minor<br />
offences and those who fear the associated<br />
crime. There are huge questions<br />
about how drugs and drug policy affect<br />
the crime rate, the health of the population<br />
and the economy. Surely this is an<br />
issue fit for general consideration?<br />
Unfortunately, there are serious<br />
problems with such a suggestion. When<br />
words such as 'heroin' or 'cocaine' are<br />
mentioned the shutters go up and<br />
c4<br />
{<br />
.a<br />
,I<br />
reasoned debate is an early casualty.<br />
These words provoke an almost unparalleled<br />
moral outrage from the press. Even<br />
the Sun has written fierce leaders on<br />
the subject. ln fact the whole vocabulary<br />
is combative. We talk about a war<br />
on drugs and the image of war is that of<br />
THH WN-Tffi*"H VOCA,ffiULARY TS<br />
COMBAY$VH- Wffi TALK ABSt'T A<br />
WAfE *ru BKIJSS AI€D T*'TE frMASffi<br />
#F WAtr& HS TffiAT #F ffSftf,FfurcT<br />
ffiffissLwHffip ffiY FsmtrE AhIm ro@T<br />
#ffimAYm.<br />
conflict resolved by force and not<br />
debate.<br />
The use of the military language is<br />
no coincidence. The current President of<br />
the United States (who did<br />
not inhale) has spoken of<br />
, the war on drugs as the<br />
natural successor to the<br />
Cold War. He is simply<br />
continuing the long<br />
American tradition of a hard<br />
line stance against this<br />
'menace'. lt is in this<br />
country that the former<br />
Chief of the Los Angeles<br />
Police suggested that casual<br />
drug users should face<br />
execution; little wonder that<br />
the politlcians dance to this<br />
beat.<br />
American policy sets<br />
the agenda for Britain and<br />
indeed most of the world.<br />
The latest manifestation of<br />
this is the appointment of a<br />
drugs 'Czar' by the government<br />
(a distinctly American<br />
idea). The root of the<br />
Americans' power is the<br />
lnternational Narcotics<br />
Control Board (INCB) which<br />
they dominate. This is a UN<br />
{|i:'-<br />
#<br />
agency which has a<br />
fearsome range of powers.<br />
It can cut off the supply of<br />
any morphine-based and<br />
other medical drugs to a<br />
country which incurs its<br />
wrath. Furthermore it is<br />
willing to use its powers.<br />
Whole rafts of UN legislation<br />
restrict the freedom of<br />
countries to set their own<br />
laws. Conflict on issues of<br />
risk and freedom go all the<br />
way to the top.<br />
With this background it<br />
is impossible to have a full<br />
and unconditional debate on<br />
drugs. far less attempt any<br />
,novcmcnt 5<br />
radical reforms. Yet some countries have<br />
dared to implement reforms on the<br />
medical uses of drugs and even the<br />
recreational use of cannabis. Cannabis is<br />
a lightweight issue and so may provide<br />
a partial solution to the impasse all drug<br />
debates face.<br />
A major advantage is the fact that<br />
cannabis has a claim to be medically<br />
beneficial and people take it for this<br />
purpose. The tone of a debate must<br />
become more civilised when talking<br />
about people suffering from serious<br />
illness who are looking for a brief respite<br />
from their pains. Not only that, there is<br />
an attitude, common enough, that using<br />
cannabis is in the same risk category as<br />
drinking alcohol or smoking. The wide<br />
availability of these drugs and the<br />
illegality of the other can seem absurd.<br />
Further, usage of cannabis is sufficiently<br />
widespread for it to be part of the<br />
mainstream of society. With that<br />
background the debate has been<br />
running for several months now Many<br />
issues have been dragged into consideration.<br />
The long term medical risks have<br />
featured in a World Health Organisation<br />
report where one chapter suggested<br />
cannabis was not as dangerous as<br />
alcohol or tobacco. There were accusations<br />
of suppression on the part of the<br />
INCB and vigorous denials but the<br />
whole affair demonstrated how science<br />
is answerable to its political paymasters.<br />
Concerns about the health risks<br />
involved in smoking the drug have been<br />
raised (as well as healthier alternatives<br />
such as baking it in a cake and eating<br />
it). Drug tests after road traffic<br />
accidents are becoming more commonplace<br />
as awareness of the dangers of<br />
drugs and driving are raised. The wide<br />
variation in the enforcement of the law<br />
has been highlighted especially by Radio<br />
1's series Sorted. The punishment for<br />
possession seems to largely depend on<br />
postcodes.<br />
A lighter touch has been the list of<br />
celebrities and public figures supporting<br />
decriminalisation-a list that has been<br />
steadily growing. People have had to<br />
confront the issue and work out if they<br />
do believe cannabis is comparable with<br />
alcohol.<br />
It may be argued that the campaign<br />
to decriminalise cannabis is here proving
its worth and avoiding the charge that it<br />
does not belong to 'grown up' politics.<br />
ln some sense it is the very essence of<br />
'grown up' politics. The bigger question<br />
has been shown to be too difficult to<br />
handle. This is true of heroin and<br />
cocaine but also of ecstacy. The only<br />
thing to do is tackle an easier issue and<br />
hope that the results can be generalised.<br />
The cannabis campaign has proven<br />
interesting and informative and has been<br />
conducted with some skill and a fair<br />
dash of humour. The list of celebrities is<br />
a particularly good way of humanising<br />
the whole affair. The bigger issue and<br />
the bigger questions are lurking in the<br />
wings and this campaign will have a lot<br />
to teach us when these are addressed.<br />
lf that seems a highly artificial<br />
argument. stop to consider how easily it<br />
can be applied in other situations. The<br />
simple fact is that big changes are<br />
rarely. if ever, made in a direct manner.<br />
Consider the campaign to decriminalise<br />
homosexuality. Many of the original<br />
supporters portrayed this as an 'illness'<br />
not because they believed that to be<br />
true but they appreciated the effect it<br />
would have on a hostile public. ln this<br />
way homosexuality was humanised and<br />
homosexuals could begin to receive<br />
sympathy rather than outright hatred.<br />
Legislation did follow but it was<br />
extremely inadequate. Two men maY<br />
consent to have sex in private but the<br />
presence of anyone else rends the act<br />
illegal no matter what consent exists. lt<br />
is still perfectly legal to sack an<br />
employee for being gay. So these laws<br />
were not direct means of achieving<br />
equality; they dealt with some easier<br />
issues but the whole convoluted<br />
problem is far from solved.<br />
Another example from 'grown uP'<br />
politics is that of constitutional reform.<br />
Government ministers accept happily<br />
that there is no simple and direct<br />
answer to the West Lothian questionnamely<br />
why Scottish MPs are able to<br />
vote on domestic issues in England<br />
(controlled by Westminster) but not the<br />
equivalent issues in Scotland (controlled<br />
by the Scottish Parliament).<br />
By way of firm conclusion it can be<br />
said that considering risks is a risky<br />
business indeed..Do you agree with the<br />
law and why? lf not what is your<br />
response to be? Do you ignore it and/or<br />
work to change it? Why is it important<br />
anyway? lt begins from that first initial<br />
risk: daring to question information you<br />
have been given and being prepared to<br />
stumble into the unknown. 'Twas ever<br />
thus and as for cannabis I suspect the<br />
story has many more twists and turns<br />
left in store. @<br />
Colin Mason is a student at the<br />
University of Edinburgh<br />
Come Out, Come<br />
Out YVhoever You<br />
A1rgooo<br />
I have been asked on many occasions<br />
| *fren I first "came out" as a gay<br />
man. as though it had a precise date<br />
I and time. lt always reminds me of<br />
that breed of Christians who quite<br />
proudly recite the time and date of being<br />
"born again": "l first met the Lord on 13<br />
April 1<strong>99</strong>2, in my friend Kenny's<br />
basement... no, there were no hallucinogens<br />
involved!!"<br />
I have yet to pin down the time and<br />
date of coming out. lt begins at the first<br />
rick gorlond<br />
ties ond binds<br />
inkling of having a self-definition. I<br />
suppose. I can remember when I first<br />
used the word gay, when I first told an<br />
individual. But the second I opened my<br />
mouth for the first time to name myself,<br />
my control over my own destiny was<br />
given to anyone who knew that basic<br />
truth. Not unlike the story of the God of<br />
Moses and Miriam, who was asked to<br />
give a name of self-reference. ln that<br />
story, the name taken is simPlY "l am<br />
which I am", essentially. a non-name.<br />
The power in self-disclosure is an important<br />
theme in our religious history. And<br />
the knowledge of a name or identitY<br />
gives one power over that person.<br />
I must mark my parents as being the<br />
most pivotal point in my coming out, the<br />
point after which I honestly did not care<br />
who knew. I told them in a letter, a<br />
cowardly act which allowed for their<br />
considerable feelings to emerge and<br />
which allowed me to craft my words in<br />
a way that would not be defensive.<br />
Their response startles me to this day.<br />
They came to see me, and assured me<br />
of their love. And without saying it in<br />
words. they made it evident that they<br />
did not want to talk about this anymore.<br />
This was my great fear: silence. I was<br />
prepared for argument and conflict: that<br />
would be a sign of love to me. I was<br />
even hoping for banner waving. t-shirt<br />
sporting, pride-emblazoned-on-bumpersticker<br />
kinds of scenarios. But I got the<br />
same silence I had known for years,<br />
except it wasn't from me anymore, it<br />
was from them.<br />
The knowledge of my confession<br />
hung in the air when I saw them. I felt<br />
the burden of being their teacher, of<br />
having to accustom them to my world'<br />
But how do I do that? lt occurred to me<br />
that I was now in the parent role... and<br />
was without a clue to assist them in<br />
their education.<br />
Six years later, and mY Parents have<br />
attended their first PFLAG meeting<br />
(Parents and Friends of Lesbians and<br />
Gays). lt came out of nowhere, a call<br />
from a recruiter who knew me, and<br />
bang! Bowling was re-scheduled and off<br />
they went to their little meeting. My<br />
mom spoke to me that week and told<br />
me it was interesting and they would go<br />
back. I thought back to our first talk and<br />
saw how much had changed. how<br />
clearly they lT CAlrlE OUT OF<br />
::*J""tr' NowHERE, A<br />
fears. And I CALL FROlvt A<br />
realized RECRUITER<br />
;::il:X1 wHo Kl{Ew }rE,<br />
as well. lt AHD BANGI<br />
took them EOWLING 1YAS<br />
RE*SCHEDULED<br />
A}ID OFF THEY<br />
ItrE}IT TO THEIR<br />
LITTLE UEETING.<br />
the time they<br />
needed, and<br />
their own<br />
way to do it.<br />
They were<br />
naming<br />
themselves to me, and allowing me the<br />
power of their self-disclosure.<br />
It seems to me that coming out is an<br />
expression of change, the change that<br />
happens to all of us as we grow and<br />
redefine ourselves. lt is the courage that<br />
it takes to share this with family, friends,<br />
community. Being locked in an image is<br />
a terrible thing, no matter the context,<br />
and it is something that is as hard to<br />
realize about one's parents as it is to<br />
realize about one's children.<br />
I might even go as far as to say that<br />
God is coming out, in the person of Jesus,<br />
a personal and vulnerable incarnation of<br />
one whose image had been radicallY<br />
different to that point. This was an act<br />
that many were not able to accept, and<br />
yet which held a basic truth that could not<br />
be ignored by many as well. l'm still<br />
working on this theory! lf you agree with<br />
this, great! lf not, well. I hope it brings lots<br />
of mail to <strong>Movement</strong>l fi<br />
Rick Garland is the National Coordinator<br />
of Canadian SCM<br />
movement 6
Tne Oxford Dictionarv of Modern Slang defines the term as "an expression of contemptous or<br />
angrv rejection." There are verv good reasons why people living with Hlv and AIDS may feel this<br />
wav about the Church, as Mike Way explains<br />
The Minist<br />
Ol F?f?f?f Ofi<br />
I<br />
nce was a time when the very<br />
mention of 'AIDS' in church<br />
situations would generate an<br />
uneasy and uncomfortable<br />
atmosphere. Understandable, in so far as<br />
mention of any sexually transmitted<br />
disease in polite society might create at<br />
least some sort of hushed ripple. Clergy<br />
got fidgety, lay people waited for rescue.<br />
The unmentionable had been<br />
mentioned-a sexual disease which kills.<br />
and which brings into the light those<br />
things which were hidden in darknessabout<br />
as welcome as the incarnate<br />
Word who is held in high regard in<br />
Christian circles as having done<br />
a rather similar thing. But the<br />
exposure promised this time is<br />
the sexual exploits and misdemeanours<br />
of which other<br />
people (if it were not for this<br />
infectious disease) could have<br />
remained happily unaware or<br />
in denial.<br />
Over time, of course, the<br />
Christian compassion card<br />
became played more often<br />
than the judgement or<br />
denial card-and so courses<br />
were run, projects set up.<br />
ministries delivered, concerns<br />
expressed, suffering identified<br />
with and 'the lgve of God'<br />
signalled. The church engine<br />
had cranked into life and now<br />
AIDS could be grouped into the<br />
social, moral and prayerful<br />
conscience of the institutional<br />
churches-at least sometimes.<br />
But hopefully without it<br />
happening to any of their<br />
clergy.<br />
An 'AIDS opening' was<br />
prised in such a way that<br />
AIDS and HIV infec-<br />
tion could<br />
be 'embraced within', rather than 'kept<br />
without'. And so, at its worst,<br />
Religious were writing articles for<br />
Religious Magazines telling other<br />
Religious of how difficult this ministry<br />
among Religious was-how stressful,<br />
tiring, painful and upsetting. Written by<br />
people who were not HIV positive for<br />
people who were not HIV positive, and<br />
who<br />
movemgnt 7<br />
didn't stand a cat in hell's chance of<br />
becoming HIV positive. Many had never<br />
had sex, ever.<br />
Small wonder then. that many who<br />
are in fact living with this life-threatening<br />
condition lost patience yet again<br />
with a church which institutionally had<br />
at first rejected, stigmatised and ignored<br />
them; and which was now holding them<br />
so close it seemed that their very breath<br />
and voice was silenced beneath the<br />
imposed veil of 'unconditional' love.<br />
And this love so often given at the<br />
price of their silence, their<br />
complicity, their passivity<br />
and their expected<br />
gratitud e.<br />
Those who<br />
had been kept<br />
firmly on the<br />
outside had<br />
now been<br />
herded within<br />
the wedding<br />
feast was<br />
suddenly not<br />
full, it<br />
seemed, and<br />
those at the<br />
roadside<br />
were indeed<br />
being<br />
dragged in<br />
and<br />
compelled to<br />
sit and eat.
After all. we wanted to have fun, and<br />
we had alreadY bought the food and<br />
drink, so come and Party You mustwhether<br />
what we have to offer is what<br />
you want or not. You will accept it and<br />
be grateful!<br />
People who are HIV Positive have<br />
had to familiarise themselves too well<br />
with the territory of disempowerment.<br />
So much ministry, however well intentioned,<br />
is experienced by people with<br />
HIV and AIDS and is intrusive and highhanded<br />
because it is often ministry<br />
'with answers' when theY know from<br />
painful experience that when it comes<br />
to HIV 'there are no neat answers'.<br />
AIDS is full of uncertainties-as is lifeand<br />
mirrors the risks of daring to live in<br />
the real world and love in the real world.<br />
There is no place in reality for a 'Jim'll<br />
Fix lt ' God: to face that there maY be<br />
no justice, no fairness, no explanation,<br />
no meaning.<br />
But there is a place for the 'Ministry<br />
of Fuck Off'. lt is a learning ground for<br />
carers and ministers to have to accept<br />
that, unless they themselves are HIV<br />
positive or have AIDS, they do not know<br />
what it is like, or what someone needs.<br />
lf we can accept the rejection of those<br />
to whom we might need to have a<br />
ministry but who themselves might<br />
place us at the end of their prioritised<br />
queue of peoPle they want aroundthen<br />
maybe we have begun to learn<br />
something.<br />
All we can PossiblY bring is our own<br />
actual and real experience of rejection,<br />
pain, victimisation, illness, sex,<br />
sexuality. loss and bereavement: as well<br />
as our affirming experiences of love and<br />
acceptance. We need to be prepared to<br />
'tell our own story' without bullshit-as<br />
it is-for real. Then perhaps we might<br />
discover that ministry is not ours to<br />
give, but theirs for us to receive.<br />
Whether our common bond of humanity<br />
is to be found beyond us in the projections<br />
of a transcendent God. or to be<br />
found within our mutual companionship<br />
on this journey we call life-or both-is<br />
ours to choose. But one thing is for sure,<br />
we have no right to make that choice<br />
for anyone else. Then PerhaPs' to<br />
paraphrase Eckhart, we might begin to<br />
learn what some'with HIV know, that<br />
'Between God and AIDS, there is no<br />
between'. @<br />
Mike Way is Director of The CARA<br />
Tiust. He is an Anglican priest and has<br />
worked in education, psychotherapy and<br />
AIDS ministrY.<br />
. CARA seeks to support the spiritual<br />
exploration of those with HIV/AIDS and<br />
challenge the churches to face the<br />
issues of belief, sexuality and mortality<br />
which AIDS raises.<br />
r The CARA Trust, The Basement, 178<br />
Lancaster Road, London W11 1QU.<br />
Barbara Crowther of CAFOD explains the 'biggest campaign<br />
in the world' - Jubilee 2000<br />
Linldng Up<br />
Against Debt<br />
ebt is arguably the single biggest impediment to human development today' lt<br />
- I I i" a traoJdv and a scandal that an international financial system, which was<br />
fzl able to"fini over f 1OO billion to bail out the private banks and 'tiger'<br />
economies affected by the current Asian financial crisis, has been unable to<br />
mobilise the political will to find money to release the most impoverished countries<br />
of Africa from the slavery of their debts.<br />
ln 1<strong>99</strong>6, a new package on debt relief was agreed by the IMF' World Bank<br />
and major creditor governments of the Paris club. The Heavily lndebted Poor<br />
Country (HIPC) lnitiative was the first really comprehensive attempt at calculating<br />
all the different types of debt owed by individual countries, and reducing them to a<br />
level deemed to be sustainable. Two years later, the so-called 'robust exit from<br />
debt' is failing. of 41 HIPC countries, only uganda has reached some measure of<br />
debt relief - a reduction ol f.2O million a year (out of [190 million it is due to pay)<br />
for two years. Hardly adequate to increase spending on healthcare beyond the current<br />
US$3 a day it is able to spend, and thereby prevent one child in five dying<br />
before the age of five. Meanwhile Ethiopia, Nicaragua, Mozambique, Zambia and<br />
Tanzania are unlikely to receive any debt relief before 2000'<br />
Jubilee2OO0aimstochangethispoliticalclimate.Alreadythecampaign<br />
has been acknowledged by the World Bank as "a conscience that is holding the<br />
financial community's feet to the fire". Already, the GB world leaders (US.<br />
Canada, France, UK, Russia. China, Germany, ltaly) have had to change the agenda<br />
for their Birmingham meeting in May to accommodate the growing public concern<br />
around lack of debt relief.<br />
The goals of the camPaign are:<br />
-A debt-free start to the new Millennium for a billion people!<br />
-To collect 21 .3 million signatures in favour of debt relief , and make the Jubilee<br />
2OOO petition the biggest the world has ever seen<br />
-To mark the G8 meetings in Birmingham in May 1<strong>99</strong>8, and Cologne in June 1<strong>99</strong>9<br />
with a huge public presence pressing for substantial cancellation<br />
_To lobby ind advocate for the Hlpc lnitiative to be speeded up and reformed in<br />
favour of more generous relief, based on investing in human development - or for<br />
an alternative to be found<br />
-To increase public awareness of the effects of debt, especially on the people of<br />
Africa in order to bring about political and economic change<br />
For more information contact Jubilee 2000, P o Box 100, London sE1 7RT' Tel<br />
Ol]-1 4O1 ggg9. CAFOD also has a range of materials on debt, including petitions,<br />
action cards, posters, ideas for group discussion and worship. available from<br />
CAFOD, Romero Glose, stockwell Rd, London swg 9TY. Tel 01 71 733 7900 0r e-<br />
mail sstanes@caf od.org'uk<br />
movement B
Movemenf publishes its 100th issue this summer. <strong>Movement</strong>'s first editon viv Broughton, talks<br />
to us about how the magazine came into being and about SCM in the early 197O's<br />
Present at<br />
the Bl?th<br />
t is hard to believe, but there is no<br />
documented history of the magazine<br />
you're reading. The back<br />
issues exist (at least in a<br />
couple of complete sets),<br />
and no doubt minutes and<br />
files relating to it can be<br />
found in the SCM's<br />
archives in Selly Oak. But<br />
there is nothing said<br />
about what it was like<br />
to be around for the<br />
early days of<br />
<strong>Movement</strong>.<br />
Which was why<br />
we were so pleased<br />
to locate Viv<br />
Broughton,<br />
<strong>Movement</strong>'s first editor. Viv<br />
Broughton edited<br />
<strong>Movement</strong> for three years<br />
and was author of the<br />
column "Ear To The<br />
Ground", (a predecessor<br />
of satirical<br />
columns such as lhe<br />
Serpent), for another<br />
two years. He also<br />
designed the famous<br />
"fist" image for the<br />
1 973 "Seeds of<br />
Liberation" conference<br />
which later became the<br />
SCM logo.<br />
Following his time in<br />
SCM, Viv has had a<br />
prodigious career which<br />
has included developing<br />
the ethnic newspaper Ihe<br />
Voice (which spanned 13<br />
years) and producing a<br />
Channel 4 series on the<br />
history of Gospel Music. Viv now<br />
runs The Premises, a recording<br />
studio in Hackney, which has been<br />
the home for then-lndie bands Blur and<br />
Elastica. We gave him some back issues<br />
and started rolling the tape ...<br />
For its first two issues, <strong>Movement</strong> was<br />
a newsletter known as Bilbo. How did<br />
the one evolve into the other?<br />
Bilbo was done by Chris Duncan and<br />
Maggie Whyte, and they<br />
were the previous<br />
regime, sort of the politburo<br />
of SCM, but they<br />
were great people. There<br />
was a fairly straight<br />
Christian Marxist axis<br />
running through SCM when<br />
myself and a few other people<br />
came in and we were a bit<br />
more surreal than that<br />
and took it off in a<br />
slightly different<br />
d irection.<br />
We thought that Bilbo<br />
was a bit boring, really,<br />
and a bit too earnest. We<br />
been involved-and<br />
when I say we I mean myself<br />
and some others who had<br />
become involved in SCM-in a<br />
magazine called the Catonsville<br />
Road Runner. which was I<br />
suppose part of a mid-sixties<br />
underground newspaper type<br />
thing. lt was hooked up with<br />
the Berkeley Free Church and<br />
various other radical Christian<br />
movements going on in the<br />
States. Road Runner ran<br />
very successfully and<br />
attracted an enormous<br />
amount of interest quite<br />
out of proportion to its<br />
circulation<br />
I was hired as<br />
Communications<br />
Officer for the SCM<br />
on the strength of what<br />
d been doing with Foad<br />
Runner, and it was really to take<br />
charge of the pamphlets and the other<br />
publications of the SCM, so we<br />
launched a new magazine, which was<br />
<strong>Movement</strong>.<br />
fnovcment e<br />
<strong>Movement</strong> was a sort of slightly<br />
more grown-up version of Road Runner,<br />
a little bit more sensible. An awful lot of<br />
that stuff is extremely embarrassing<br />
when I look back on it now. But there's<br />
also some very good stuff<br />
-l mean<br />
Thomas Merton lwho had an editorial<br />
posthumously published in <strong>Movement</strong>'s<br />
first issuel you can't really argue with.<br />
Some of it's a little bit sixties, a little bit<br />
hippie/naive. I seem to remember we<br />
had great cartoons-there was a lot of<br />
humour and a lot of self-deprecating<br />
humour as well. We didn't take it all<br />
deathly seriously, which I think was its<br />
one saving grace.<br />
What was the initial reaction to<br />
<strong>Movement</strong>?<br />
Well, I think there was a certain<br />
amount of unease throughout the old<br />
guard in SCM at the new people who<br />
were coming in, particularly who were<br />
involved at Annandale. our headquarters,<br />
and I can understand that with<br />
hindsight! l've never been a student in<br />
my life, I've never been to university,<br />
and I think a number of the others who<br />
had come in had not been involved<br />
either. We came from radical Christian<br />
movements. lt's difficult to separate<br />
what was just the normal anxiety about<br />
change in <strong>Movement</strong> and what were<br />
serious objections.<br />
During <strong>Movement</strong>'s first few years, the<br />
SGM sold the Annandale offices and<br />
moved to an intentional community at<br />
Wick, near Bristol. How did that come<br />
about?<br />
There were serious objections to<br />
selling Annandale. lt was reckoned by<br />
many to be the sort of 'nest-egg'-you<br />
were killing the golden goose, basically.<br />
Annandale was this piece of prime<br />
property and it was worth quite a lot of<br />
money at that stage and I suppose there<br />
was a feeling that students can run<br />
around doing all sorts of extraordinary
things, whatever they like, as long as<br />
they didn't kill things off for the next<br />
generation who want to do their own<br />
projects.<br />
It became part of the whole debate<br />
whether a movement like SCM should<br />
be highly centralised with a London<br />
head office in an expensive suburb, or it<br />
should be something based more on the<br />
model of Taize and lona communities,<br />
where there was a spiritual core as well<br />
as an organisational core that both fed<br />
and was contributed to by the rest of<br />
the movement.<br />
So we had people coming from<br />
different directions, but it seem to make<br />
a lot of sense to sell Annandale, buy a<br />
place somewhere outside of London<br />
that's maybe more accessible to people<br />
from different parts of the country where<br />
students could come and have weekend<br />
conferences and week-long conferences.<br />
Really, it was the lona model.<br />
What happened with Wick? Reading<br />
about it today one has one of two<br />
visions of Wick-one is a legendarY<br />
magical place near Bristol and the other<br />
is this sort of highly dysfunctional<br />
community which self-destructed.<br />
Probably both are true in many respects.<br />
Both are absolutely true! lt went<br />
the same way of many communes, if<br />
you like, at the time. They are such<br />
intense places, and you have to be<br />
down to the most basic level of keeping<br />
the place clean, doing the cooking,<br />
looking after the gardens, fixing the roof<br />
through to maintaining a good relationship<br />
with the student constituency, all<br />
of whom had different expectations at<br />
Wick and what it should be. Plus, SCM<br />
is one of those dynamic movements<br />
that continually changes. So within a<br />
year or two there were new PeoPle<br />
coming in who had different<br />
expectations and it didn't necessarily<br />
work for all of them. So there were<br />
lots of pressures. We'd become, quite<br />
quickly, the headquarters, we were<br />
the establishment, and lots of people<br />
were querying that-"who are those<br />
people out in the country and what<br />
are they doing?" and that sort of<br />
thing.<br />
It drove us all right to the edge. I<br />
mean, I can look back on it now with a<br />
lot of fondness and interest and it was<br />
just one of those amazing experiences<br />
to go through, but I wouldn't go<br />
through it again! People survived it in<br />
different ways. And the children<br />
survived it in different ways. My kids<br />
are now 25,26 and they were 3 and 4<br />
when they first went to Wick, and they<br />
all remember it as just this amazing<br />
place. They all got to run around in the<br />
garden and do exciting things, but it<br />
was quite traumatic for them as well<br />
because couples split up.<br />
6fWE IUST TRIED TO BRING 11{ THE<br />
BEST OF THE NEw I'llllDS AND THE<br />
NEW THINKING... I THINK THAT'S<br />
REALLY WHAT SCl.l SHOULD BE<br />
DOING, BRIHGING TOGETHER THE<br />
CUTTING =DGE<br />
OF THEOLOGY AND<br />
POLlTlCS...tt<br />
extraordinarily strong to sustain a<br />
marriage between two people; this was<br />
almost like a marriage between fifteen<br />
people, with very small children involved<br />
and so on. Not to mention 60-1O0<br />
students descending on your house<br />
every week throughout the year. lt was<br />
extremely exciting. There were some<br />
great conferences and we put together<br />
a whole series of exciting residential<br />
courses and conventions and so on. You<br />
know it was great while it lasted.<br />
Could it iust not sustain itself by virtue<br />
of being a 'marriage of fifteen people' or<br />
were there other external factors that<br />
were around in the early seventies?<br />
I think it was more that the intensity<br />
of the community within Wick was so<br />
great in terms of just having to cope<br />
with the life of that community-right<br />
<strong>Movement</strong> in general had a tremendous<br />
amount of clout with the PeoPle You<br />
interviewed and who contributed-Dan<br />
Berrigan contributed, Dorothy Day was<br />
interviewed, Mary Daly was<br />
interviewed-was it through your<br />
connections with Road Runner?<br />
It was really trom Road Runner times<br />
I think. I remember Mary Daly came for<br />
Christmas at Wick, and it was quite an<br />
interesting Christmas! She wasn't too<br />
keen on Father Christmas if I remember<br />
rightly, although the kids were of<br />
course!<br />
We just tried to bring in the best of<br />
the new minds and the new thinking<br />
and the new theologians and so on. I<br />
think that's really what SCM should be<br />
doing is bringing together the cutting<br />
edge of theology and politics and new<br />
thought and putting them together with<br />
movgment 10<br />
this new generation that are coming up<br />
through universities. I think that's part<br />
of what SCM should alwaYs do. So we<br />
saw it absolutely within the tradition of<br />
SCM, that it wasn't ever a case of<br />
trying to lead all these students in some<br />
doctrinaire direction, but simply to put<br />
them altogether in circumstances in<br />
which they could explore those ideas<br />
and come to their own conclusions of<br />
what they thought and so on.<br />
What was the process of Putting<br />
together <strong>Movement</strong> back then, both at<br />
Annandale and at Wick?<br />
It was thrown together quite quickly.<br />
There were no computers back then' lt<br />
was typed on a typewriter in strips and<br />
we'd measure it out with pencil lines for<br />
the columns and then cut them uP and<br />
paste them on. All the headlines were<br />
done with Letraset-quite neatly as I<br />
notice now-it was verY laborious.<br />
How do you think radical Christianity, or<br />
even Christianity generally has changed<br />
in the past 25 years.<br />
l've no idea, l've moved on. I<br />
followed a different path. What I learned<br />
then in that period of my life informed<br />
what I do now, and my own relationship<br />
to the Christian Gospel is important to<br />
me and gives me a grounding, a<br />
sounding board, a reference point. But I<br />
don't really keep in touch with what's<br />
going on within radical Christian<br />
movements, simPly because l've been<br />
involved in other things. My 13 years<br />
involvement with lhe Vorce newspaper<br />
and that whole emerging generation of<br />
ethnic publications has been very very<br />
interesting, and lots of stuff that I<br />
learned back then in SCM became<br />
useful. The editing of <strong>Movement</strong> and the<br />
knowledge of how to put newspapers<br />
and magazines together became<br />
extremely useful in terms of the development<br />
of The Voice and I know lots of<br />
people who went through SCM at that<br />
time went on and can be found all over<br />
the place, all using the things the things<br />
learned then, and l'm sure that that's<br />
true with every generation of SCM. lt's<br />
a university in itself, a sort of spiritual<br />
university.<br />
How did you come up with the name<br />
<strong>Movement</strong>?<br />
Well I thought it was a bit of a dull<br />
name-it was the best we could come<br />
up with at the time. Obviously it came<br />
out of the Student Christian <strong>Movement</strong><br />
and it seemed quite a good name. But it<br />
wasn't as good as the Catonsville Road<br />
Runner.ftl<br />
oComing soon: <strong>Movement</strong> 1OO,<br />
featuring a history of the magazine and<br />
reprinting some of the best articles from<br />
the past 26 years.<br />
I
For A Friend<br />
A he was my friend and I couldn't<br />
\ rretp ner.<br />
\-,<br />
Her death was, in some ways, quick.<br />
She killed herself in just fifteen minutes.<br />
A deliberately chosen use of the<br />
maximum chunk of time allotted to her<br />
to be alone. ln other ways, though, it<br />
was the longest and slowest death<br />
-death by severe, debilitating,<br />
seemingly inescapable mental illness.<br />
This is what she was like: bold,<br />
courageous, sensitive, intelligent,<br />
generous, humorous, charming,<br />
persuasivg incisive, persistent and<br />
rebellious. The impact of institutions<br />
was stamped on her being: the military<br />
had shaped her family life; a boarding<br />
school her childhood and adolescence;<br />
the mental health system her short<br />
adulthood. All in their own ways brutal,<br />
fostering dependence then failing to fulfil<br />
their side of the bargain. Yet in many<br />
ways she was a 'light' person-wearing<br />
the impact of these institutions not as<br />
victim but as resister. Apparently just ten<br />
days before her death, on her 32nd<br />
birthday, she was ordering take-away pizza<br />
for herself and her friends in the hospital.<br />
Sitting in laceless shoes, scoffing. Just like<br />
'before' (if there was a 'before').<br />
Surfing Human Rights<br />
l\<br />
id you ever receive one of these<br />
I I rather disturbing pictures in your<br />
l/ letterbox. makiig your breakfast<br />
taste stale? Amnesty lnternational will<br />
have asked you to write a letter of<br />
support for one of the prisoners of<br />
conscience they care for. But then<br />
many of you do this already and thus<br />
need not read further.<br />
But for those among you who never<br />
felt sure about Amnesty and its work. or<br />
who want more background information<br />
about the particular situation, the<br />
answer in only a browser away:<br />
http://www.amnesty.org/. Amnesty<br />
lnternational's website not only offers<br />
you links to all its Branches onlinq but it<br />
offers information on current campaigns<br />
and background information on most<br />
countries.<br />
Amnesty's current campaigns can be<br />
found online at'http://wwwamnesty.org/<br />
campaign/ index.html. Take a look at<br />
"Kenya: Repression and Resistance" or<br />
the "UN Commission on Human Rights<br />
is 50 Years old". The report on Kenya<br />
reveals largely unknown facts about a<br />
well-loved tourist destination. For<br />
example: "Frequent police brutality goes<br />
largely unpunished. Police routinely beat<br />
suspects, while some prisoners have<br />
been subjected to sustained torture.<br />
Peaceful protesters have been violently<br />
attacked by police, and unarmed criminal<br />
*"<br />
Her death flings me back like no<br />
other. Back to school. when we were<br />
close; when she was happier. I<br />
remember the late nights, the long<br />
walks; the'meaning of life' talks. She<br />
was scary even then, sometimes; the<br />
times when she didn't come back,<br />
following the meaning deep into herself<br />
that I worried she'd never reconnect.<br />
We'd feel so close, but then she'd disappear-instantly.<br />
This death flings me back to that<br />
endless puzzle which was: what was<br />
wrong with my friend? How come none<br />
of us could help her; fix things for her?<br />
suspects have been shot dead even<br />
though they posed no threat to life."<br />
The campaign for the UN commission<br />
on Human Rights reminds us so<br />
poignantly that we do have basic rights<br />
t1<br />
olison urebster<br />
tell-tole signs<br />
lf<br />
and we must defend them. The<br />
Universal Declaration of Human Rights<br />
(http ://rights. amnesty.org/english/<br />
rights/index.html), one of the founding<br />
documents of the United Nations, is 50<br />
years old and needs as much support<br />
today as it did at its inception. Many<br />
dirk gr0tzmocher<br />
ths @ Golumn<br />
critics of this declaration claim these are<br />
"western" rights and values and do not<br />
allow for local customs and cultural<br />
differences, thus arguing that it may<br />
well be alright to deny certain rights to<br />
some groups of people, because the<br />
local custom tells you so.<br />
You can sign up to the support of<br />
these rights at http://rights.amnesty.<br />
org/. Follow the "Human Rights<br />
Caravan" round the world, and who<br />
knows, it might come round your neck<br />
of the woods.<br />
Amnesty is possibly best known for<br />
its continued campaign for the abolition<br />
of the death penalty. lt continues to do<br />
this and has a wealth of resources for<br />
Mental health is a mystery, it seems to<br />
me. lt cannot be caused-only fostered.<br />
But mental illness is scary to those of us<br />
who have never experienced it. How can<br />
we not feel this fear? ls it true that<br />
sometimes there is simply nothing we<br />
can do? Are there times in relationships<br />
when we are left powerless, or is that<br />
just an excuse?<br />
It flings me back, also, to spirituality.<br />
My first prayer in ten years: God, love<br />
her more than I would; understand her<br />
more than I could. I feel the need for the<br />
familiar structures and expressions of<br />
God-language, but find in the process of<br />
searching for it that it's now no longer in<br />
any sense familiar, so long has it lain<br />
unused. But it's the only language that<br />
can express the importance of what's<br />
happened, and I need it for that. So a<br />
friend lights a candle for me, for her.<br />
On my behalf because now I am<br />
religiously mute. @<br />
Alison Webster is a former editor of<br />
<strong>Movement</strong> and a freelance writer<br />
this campaign (http://www.amnesty.org/<br />
ailib/intcamidp/index.html) However not<br />
many of you will know about the<br />
campaign for an lnternational Criminal<br />
Court, about to be founded in Rome in<br />
May this year (http://www.amnesty.it/<br />
eventi/icc/docs/index.htm). The ICC will<br />
be the court in which international<br />
criminal crimes such as war-crimes will<br />
be heard, offering an end to the adhoc<br />
courts trying war criminals, Iike those in<br />
Bosnia and Rwanda. The court will offer<br />
stability and makes it possible to be<br />
called upon by a private person as well<br />
as states. The current discussion is<br />
raging about the exclusion of certain<br />
crimes from the agenda of the court as<br />
the powers fear prosecution on certain<br />
items, such as the possession of nuclear<br />
weapons and other weapons of mass<br />
destruction. The lnternational Court of<br />
Justice, the highest court in the world,<br />
declared nuclear weapons illegal in June<br />
of last year.<br />
Oh, yes, you may like to start closer<br />
to home: Amnesty lnternational UK<br />
(http://www.amnesty.org.uk). However,<br />
if you are interested in human rights and all<br />
its associated questions you must visit the<br />
suite of Amnesty lnternational sites. @<br />
Dirk Griitzmacher is a Ph.D. student in<br />
the University of Edinburgh. Visit his<br />
website at http://www.ed.ac.uk/ - dig<br />
movement 11
According to a 1<strong>99</strong>5 Defence White Papen the objective of Britain's securitv policv is to protect<br />
our "vital national interests". So whv has the church acquiesced over a war driven bV selfinterest<br />
as thev did during the recent Culf Crisis? lrsan Merchant explains the background to<br />
this conflict, and explains why he renouced his confirmation in the Church of Scotland<br />
Empowering<br />
the Barbarians i<br />
.{'"..s<br />
rill<br />
It isn't that<br />
there's a war on.<br />
No,<br />
The horror<br />
is that<br />
we have never known peace,<br />
And that we are<br />
only now<br />
beginning to realise.<br />
(from the Art & Revolution project)<br />
Since the Second World War, the<br />
United States' objective (with<br />
Britain) is control over Middle<br />
East oil-"a stupendous source<br />
of strategic power, and one of<br />
the greatest material prizes in<br />
history" according to the US<br />
State Department. This has<br />
created the 'new world order'-<br />
the establishment of the US as<br />
sole superpower, "the world's<br />
rent-a-cops" as one newspaPer<br />
put it. During the 1980s, with<br />
support from the West, Saddam<br />
Hussein committed his worst<br />
atrocities, including the use of<br />
chemical weapons on Kurds in<br />
1 988.<br />
Noam Chomsky writes<br />
"...the US was tilting strongly<br />
toward lraq to make sure that<br />
they won the lraq-lran war. lt<br />
continued until the one crime for<br />
which Saddam Hussein cannot<br />
be forgiven: he disobeyed orders<br />
on August 2 1<strong>99</strong>0 [the invasion<br />
of Kuwaitl. lmmediately after,<br />
within a few months, the US<br />
was supporting him again. There<br />
was no secret about it. ln<br />
March. right after the fighting<br />
stopped, when Saddam turned to<br />
crushing the Shiites in the South and<br />
then the Kurds in the North, the US<br />
stood by quietly and assisted him".<br />
Operation Desert Storm in 1<strong>99</strong>1 was<br />
not about opposing Saddam's aggression<br />
against Kuwait, but was intended<br />
to contain Third World nationalism. The<br />
current intervention is to allow the UN<br />
to inspect lraq's weapons programs<br />
though it is doubtful that this is the real<br />
intention of the West. ln 1<strong>99</strong>0 Saddam<br />
offered to destroy his chemical and<br />
biological weapons if lsrael agreed to<br />
destroy its non-conventional weaponsincluding<br />
nuclear weapons. The US<br />
welcomed the offer, but rejected the<br />
idea of linkage with lsrael as this would<br />
not be in the interests of the US. ln<br />
general, the purpose of western intervention<br />
in the Third World is both to<br />
demonstrate that 'might is right' and to<br />
justify to western populations the<br />
enormous (and highly profitable) military<br />
spending - necessary because of the<br />
moveanont 12<br />
threat from Third World nationalism.<br />
A. Sivanandan, editor of the journal<br />
Race and C/ass, wrote of the 1<strong>99</strong>1 Gulf<br />
War: "This is not our war, this is not a<br />
war of Black and Third World peoples.<br />
This is not a war for us, this is a war<br />
against us wherever we are-whether in<br />
Europe, the United States, or any part of<br />
the Third World".<br />
The recent Gulf Crisis is yet another<br />
part of the ongoing war on the Third<br />
World, arguably a racist war. As<br />
Chomsky says of racism, "When you<br />
have your boot on someone's neck, You<br />
have to have a justification for it. The<br />
justification has to be their<br />
depravity...That's why l'm doing this.<br />
*$.<br />
Maybe l'm even doing them good. And<br />
if it's their depravity there's got to be<br />
something that makes them different<br />
from me". This could be anything-such<br />
o J<br />
1<br />
o<br />
C<br />
l<br />
1
I<br />
il<br />
l6<br />
as skin colour, way of life or<br />
sexuality. Racism is a dominant<br />
discourse, vital to British society,<br />
which shapes our understanding<br />
of the world, both creating and<br />
justifying oppression.<br />
Sadly, the peace movement<br />
has often accepted the<br />
assumptions of racism<br />
unawares, even while opposing<br />
wars. Many people accept the<br />
justification for the intervention<br />
in lraq-that Saddam is too<br />
irresponsible to possess<br />
chemical and biological<br />
weapons-even if they are<br />
opposed to military action. I<br />
suggest that this is based in<br />
classical racist discourse. A<br />
discourse which upholds the<br />
West as responsible enough to<br />
possess weapons of mass<br />
destruction, while the "darkies"<br />
are irresponsible uncivilised<br />
barbarians who must be<br />
denied them. We need only<br />
remember that the US is the<br />
one country to have dropped<br />
nuclear bombs.<br />
Whenever we use a discourse about<br />
'the Other', we accept the power<br />
relations and assumptions of superiority<br />
within the discourse, whoever we are.<br />
These distinctions of 'us' and 'them' are<br />
central in the media coverage of war. A<br />
'democratic country' is one which<br />
serves western interests. A 'non-democratib<br />
country' is one which does not.<br />
'Stability in the region' and 'international<br />
peace' mban maintaining western<br />
domination. And'national interests'<br />
means the business interests of the<br />
ruling class.<br />
According to the 1<strong>99</strong>5 Defence<br />
White Paper, the objective of Britain's<br />
security policy is to protect our "vital<br />
national interests"-trade, raw materials<br />
overseas. the sea routes for trade and<br />
British investments in the rest of the<br />
world. As Malcolm Rifkind explained in<br />
1<strong>99</strong>3. the purpose of Trident. the British<br />
nuclear weapons system, is to give "an<br />
unmistakable message of our willingness<br />
to defend our vital interests to the<br />
utmost". These "interests" are largely in<br />
the Third World, so British military policy<br />
is openly a war on the Third World. This<br />
I HAVE TRIED IN THE PAST TO<br />
ARGUE THAT CHRISTIANS SHOULD<br />
BE PACIFISTS, BUT I tto LOilcER<br />
cAN, FOR I HAVE UNDIRSTOOD<br />
THAT THE REALITY OF<br />
CHRISTIANITY IS THAT IT HAS<br />
BEEI{ COMPATIBLH 1YITH SOTH<br />
PACIFISM ANT} MITITARISM.<br />
policy has been continued by both<br />
Conservative and Labour governments,<br />
so the recent nuclear threats on lraq by<br />
Robin Cook should come as no surprise<br />
-simply the ongoing policy of war.<br />
I do not trust Saddam with weapons<br />
of mass destruction, but nor do I trust<br />
Blair, Clinton or anyone else with them.<br />
As British citizens working for peace,<br />
our responsibility-and possibility-is to<br />
end British militarism.<br />
Peters makes an example of her-he<br />
presides over a violent gang rape.<br />
Washington is a pimp with many<br />
Third World nations prostituting<br />
themselves economically and culturally.<br />
lraq is a Stella, disobeying orders, and<br />
so, through violence, is made into an<br />
example for the other prostitutes. And<br />
like Stella herself, the country of lraq<br />
contains many internal conflicts and<br />
troubles.<br />
We have a choice. We can either<br />
support the pimp in his exploitation, or<br />
we can support the prostitute who<br />
stands up to the pimp. lt is not in the<br />
interest of the pimp to empower a<br />
prostitute to make choices in her life -<br />
hence there is no Western support for<br />
the lraqi democratic opposition in exile.<br />
lf we are truly to empower a prostitute.<br />
we must allow her to make her own<br />
choices and her own mistakes. To<br />
clarify, I feel we should be allowing the<br />
lraqi people freedom to choose their own<br />
system of government, their own foreign<br />
policies and their own weapons systems.<br />
To trust is always a difficult risk, but<br />
there can only be peace when we<br />
overcome our fear.<br />
ln 1<strong>99</strong>7, UNICEF estimated that<br />
over two million lraqi people had died<br />
because UN sanctions deprived the<br />
people of food, medicines and clean<br />
drinking water. Around two hundred<br />
and fifty thousand lraqi were killed or<br />
died during Operation Desert Storm.<br />
This involved aerial bombardment,<br />
lraqi conscripts buried alive by giant<br />
bulldozers, the use of napalm,<br />
nuclear threats, and. importantly.<br />
consent for all this manufactured in<br />
J<br />
o<br />
o<br />
n the recent film Stella Does Tricks,<br />
Stella is a Glaswegian teenager in<br />
London who finds security in prosti-<br />
I tuting herself for the profit of Peters,<br />
her pimp. Eventually she wants<br />
freedom, so declares that she will leave.<br />
This is a threat to Peters' power, for her<br />
action could inspire other girls. So<br />
movoment 13<br />
:ica<br />
C
the West by media lies and<br />
propaganda.<br />
The response of the Churches to the<br />
recent Gulf Crisis must be of concern to<br />
us all. On February 16, the Church Of<br />
Scotland Committee On Church And<br />
Nation sent a letter to all Scottish MPs<br />
which concluded "l would urge You<br />
to...ensure that we do not embark upon<br />
military action unless it is properly<br />
authorised by the United Nations, it is<br />
clear and limited in its objectives and<br />
will serve the wider purPoses of<br />
securing international peace". The letter<br />
is a secularised version of the 'Just War<br />
Theory' which argues that a war is<br />
theologically justified if it is a last<br />
resort, proportionate and likely to fulfil<br />
objectives of lasting Peace.<br />
Within the 'Just War' persPective of<br />
the Church. the deaths of millions of<br />
lraqi people seem acceptable so long as<br />
these deaths are authorised bY the<br />
United Nations. lt is interesting that the<br />
Church Of Scotland in 1 <strong>99</strong>5 called for<br />
the lifting of sanctions. This contradiction<br />
arises out of applying theology to a<br />
situation which can only be understood<br />
by the dynamics of politics, history and<br />
ideology. Consequently. on the 24th<br />
February I renounced my confirmation<br />
into the Church of Scotland. I cannot<br />
reconcile my perspective on the Gulf<br />
Crisis with statements rooted in the<br />
'Just War Theory'.<br />
Much theology is simply mystification,<br />
the opium of the people, and, by<br />
historical definition, Christianity is the<br />
justification for all sorts of things. I do<br />
not feel that it is honest to justify either<br />
militarism or pacifism by reference to<br />
Christianity, the Gospel or any other<br />
institution or text. I have tried in the<br />
past to argue that Christians should be<br />
pacifists, but I no longer can, for I have<br />
understood that the reality of<br />
Christianity is that it has been compatible<br />
with both pacifism and militarism.<br />
lnstead, knowing deeply my shared<br />
humanity, I feel I need no justifications<br />
for my life. For myself, I choose nonviolence<br />
passionately.<br />
And so in looking at the intervention<br />
of the West in lraq, let us not use racist<br />
discourse. Let us not speak of the UN as<br />
a peacemaker and the Third World as<br />
irresponsible barbarians. Let us not<br />
forget that the war continues in threats,<br />
sanctions and policies. Let us not<br />
confuse reality with theology, or speak<br />
of peace where there is none. Let us<br />
speak, instead, of the little children. E<br />
o This is an adaptation of a talk "The<br />
Gulf: News, Fact and Fiction" given at a<br />
public meeting on February 2O in<br />
Edinburgh.<br />
lrfan Merchant is an activist and<br />
freelance writer. He lives in Glasgow.<br />
At Peace With Our<br />
Brokenness<br />
r n 1987 Gerrv Huohes SJ wrote an<br />
articte entitled 'Tile Spirituality of<br />
I Peace'. At that time the hot issue<br />
was nuclear weapons, their potential for<br />
destruction and our attitude towards<br />
them. The focus was clear, the choice<br />
was stark: are you for them or against<br />
them? An integrated spirituality meant<br />
that if you took a stance against nuclear<br />
weapons based on religious belief you<br />
^&ii,<br />
ruth horvev<br />
soundings in<br />
spirituolity<br />
would invariably find yourself concerned<br />
also about the food you eat and where it<br />
comes from, care for the earth,<br />
domestic violence, pollution, justice in<br />
relationships ... The ripples on the water<br />
formed many concentric circles of<br />
common concern.<br />
Today the issues around peacemaking<br />
and spirituality are no less stark<br />
and the focus is no less hot. Spirituality<br />
has become a buzz word and for many it<br />
still indicates an integration of our faith<br />
with our everyday action. But in the<br />
post-Cold War. post-Greenham, post<br />
mass CND rallies days when the biggest<br />
single issue is how to care for the<br />
hounds that chase the fox, and when<br />
the voice of Tony Benn is the one we<br />
hear like a worthy but weary blast from<br />
the past, condemning the use of<br />
force(s) in the Gulf, then I have to<br />
know: who cares about spirituality and<br />
peace-making?<br />
On a cold, blue-skied day in January<br />
seven of us met at Woodbrooke College<br />
in Birmingham to share our thoughts on<br />
and experiences of 'Spirituality and<br />
Peace-Making'. This is what we came<br />
up with: spirituality is a concept, like<br />
'peace-making', which needs to be<br />
reclaimed. lt indicates a passionate way<br />
of life, including both joy and suffering,<br />
working towards abundant life and<br />
living. Spirituality is about power. when<br />
it is the kind of 'power-with'(empowerment)<br />
not 'power-over' that Jesus spoke<br />
of . Spirituality describes that place of<br />
truth, pain and discomfort where we<br />
can do no other than act.<br />
We identified a number of tensions<br />
inherent in living out a peace-making<br />
spirituality. The tension between reflection<br />
and action, when we struggle to<br />
find growth in the continual flipping<br />
between silent meditative prayer and<br />
getting our hands dirty. The tension<br />
moveanGnt 14<br />
between being an individual and being<br />
part of an institution when we feel<br />
swamped by 'the common mind' and<br />
invisible in 'the common structure', yet<br />
want to belong to a community. The<br />
tension between fun and duty when we<br />
take ourselves and our cause so<br />
seriously that we cannot relax, and<br />
when we forget that Jesus had a sense<br />
of humour. The tension between church<br />
and peace when so many of our<br />
churches have colluded with the powers<br />
of war and aggression while maintaining<br />
a commitment to Jesus, the non-violent<br />
peacemaker. And finally, the tension<br />
between'one-ness' and'brokenness'.<br />
This last tension was the thread<br />
which ran through our whole conversation.<br />
When war, violence, injustice and<br />
fighting occur we are witnessing a<br />
breaking of the connection between<br />
ourselves and the Gospel message of<br />
non-violence. lt is our task as peacemakers<br />
to SplRITUALlTy<br />
:";il*"J DEscRrBEs rHAr<br />
continually PTACE OF TRUTH<br />
to this AND pAlN<br />
i""?li""l',li: wHERE lYE cAN<br />
ness. Where DO NO OTHER<br />
there is<br />
THAITI ACT.<br />
brokenness,<br />
we are called to one-ness. And yet we<br />
are faced with the question: 'how can<br />
we recognise the vulnerability and<br />
brokenness of the world if we deny this<br />
same vulnerability within ourselves?'<br />
To be peace-makers we must first be<br />
at peace with ourselves, with our own<br />
brokenness. The search for this inner<br />
peace is a lifetime journey. Along the<br />
way we need guidance, comfort,<br />
challenge, support and opportunities to<br />
explore. To find this we may turn to<br />
spiritual leaders, companions, those who<br />
are wiser than us, those who have been<br />
on the path for some time; we may even<br />
turn to the church. ln turning out for<br />
help we are offering our own inner<br />
vulnerability as a gift to our spiritual<br />
leaders. our churches, our holy and<br />
sacred places. lt is in this turning, and in<br />
an adequate and compassionate response<br />
to our own inner vulnerability, that hope<br />
for a truly integrated, world-reforming<br />
spirituality of peace-making lies. @<br />
Ruth Harvey is the director of the CGBI<br />
Ecumenical Spirituality Project, with<br />
offices in Milton Keynes and Penrith
He was a Western student who went to Lahore and taught for a yean Ten years on, Jonathan<br />
ldle returns to Pakistan and India and reflects on the changes that have taken place both there<br />
and inside himself.<br />
Taken Fo?<br />
Granted<br />
n Nagpur Station at 5.OOam<br />
Rosie wondered if anyone<br />
would remember her ten years<br />
on, and would they care that<br />
she'd come back to see them? We<br />
needn't have worried; by lunchtime the<br />
Bishop had interrupted a staff meeting<br />
just to give us tea, and his secretary<br />
was organising our timetable. After<br />
that our main concern was being so<br />
warmly welcomed that we had no time<br />
for ourselves, attending a 'welcome<br />
dance' and hastily-arranged visits to<br />
development projects as if we were<br />
some kind of celebrity.<br />
I had had similar concerns arriving in<br />
Pakistan-who would still be around,<br />
and would it feel awkward to turn up<br />
ten years after losing touch? lt was in<br />
fact exhilarating to meet my closest<br />
friends there. the school servants. They<br />
were equally delighted, and not only<br />
invited us to their homes to eat, but<br />
gave us presents because l'd got<br />
married since l'd last seen them.<br />
We were both returning after ten<br />
years-l had come to show Rosie<br />
Pakistan and she wanted to show me<br />
lndia. We both wanted to see people<br />
and places we had memories<br />
of<br />
-memories all the more intense as<br />
she had ended our relationship when we<br />
came back, but seven years later we'd<br />
got married. We also wanted to see how<br />
our own reactions would be different<br />
this time. As time went on it was those<br />
reactions that most fascinated us. lt<br />
was exciting to note how much I had<br />
changed, by noting such intense and<br />
different reactions to what we were<br />
experiencing.<br />
We didn't simply enjoy the<br />
overwhelming welcome from friends; we<br />
went back to our guest-house and<br />
discussed the limits of cross-cultural<br />
friendship and the nature of intimacy.<br />
We discussed the dynamics of power<br />
and the intrusion of wealth and poverty<br />
into relationships. We found, most days,<br />
a quick link between our experiences<br />
that day and the big questions of life.<br />
Take poverty and our reaction<br />
to it. Mark Tully's answer when<br />
asked how he copes with<br />
poverty is "l don't have to. The<br />
poor do". An equally striking<br />
answer might be "The same as<br />
we cope with the poverty in<br />
Britain". Even the word<br />
'poverty' is too abstract and<br />
sanitised for the destitution<br />
which we find unimaginable<br />
but which is normality for<br />
millions; Tully's answer hints<br />
at the thoughtless and<br />
abstract ease of the<br />
question. My answer<br />
implies that if we don't<br />
notice poverty till we reach<br />
lndia we have closed our<br />
Eating cake in a posh hotel<br />
and then walking past a<br />
beggar feels uncomfortable,<br />
but it is logically no worse<br />
than eating cake when we<br />
can't see the beggar.<br />
whether in Britain or lndia.<br />
We all do this every day,<br />
but it feels worse when the<br />
beggars are more<br />
numerous or their situation<br />
more extreme.<br />
But who is poor?<br />
Poverty is relative, and<br />
closely related to power<br />
So whilst in some ways<br />
we are richer-more<br />
advantaged<br />
-than most<br />
of those we met, in<br />
other ways there are<br />
people whose monthly<br />
wage I could drop out of<br />
fnovcmsnt 15<br />
my pocket and not notice, but who are<br />
no poorer than me in terms of their<br />
status and access to what their<br />
society offers. I got tired of<br />
being asked
for money-whether by beggars, street<br />
sellers or charitable causes. I felt they<br />
just saw a white skin as a pot of money<br />
to be tapped - reducing us to symbols of<br />
Western wealth rather than individual<br />
human beings. But I found myself doing<br />
the same in reverse-seeing stall-holders<br />
and rickshaw drivers as needing our<br />
generosity simply because, well, here<br />
we are in lndia. So we gave some fairly<br />
arbitrary and patronising tips out while<br />
we worked out the pros and cons.<br />
We were also well aware that we<br />
had plenty of money but not much time,<br />
so why not make use of the fact that<br />
othrs had plenty of time but not much<br />
money. We were quite happy to pay<br />
people to queue for our train tickets<br />
while we went sightseeing. This also<br />
involved more trust than the average<br />
tourist experiencg as we handed over<br />
cash up front to people we'd only just<br />
met. (And who didn't let us down.) This<br />
was very different to ten years ago,<br />
when I got a buzz from doing everything<br />
as cheaply as possible. l'd gloat to<br />
myself<br />
-l<br />
bet not many Europeans came<br />
to the grubby roadside curry stall or tea<br />
shop where I felt at home, and I<br />
certainly wouldn't pay f2.OO for a<br />
comfortable bus journey when you<br />
For example, we found<br />
churches more frustrating<br />
than we do in Britain,<br />
although the frustrations<br />
were largely the same. Here<br />
it felt somehow less excusable<br />
because the form of<br />
worship was not even<br />
indigenous, but learnt<br />
from a proselytising<br />
foreign church which<br />
inseparably wrapped the<br />
central tenets of faith in<br />
their own cultural<br />
expression of them. ln a<br />
short stay we could not<br />
build up the trusting<br />
relationships which<br />
make it possible to<br />
probe critically and aloud,<br />
so we just came away and ranted to<br />
each other. What is the church for?<br />
Does it have a different purpose as a<br />
minority religion and in a place with the<br />
spiritual heritage of lndo-Pakistan?<br />
Liturgy and worship did not seem to be<br />
informed by struggling with such<br />
questions. at least from our limited<br />
experience of worship. I was disappointed<br />
that worship is based more on<br />
the middle-of-the-road Anglical worship<br />
],IOST DAYS tYE HAD AN INTEI{SE<br />
DISCUSSION OR TWO ON THE<br />
VARIOUS TOPICS YOU CAN<br />
IGNORE IN BRITAII'I BUT HERE<br />
TYERE IN YOUR FACE ON EVERY<br />
STREET<br />
could get a cramped and bumpy one for<br />
€1.50 that only took an hour longer!<br />
I hadn't quite got out of the habit.<br />
More than once I'd haggle a price<br />
downwards and then get to know the<br />
person and pay up to the original asking<br />
price. And this was partly because we<br />
assumed that because this is Pakistan,<br />
they must need our generosity. But for<br />
all we know they are doing fine. Some<br />
recipients were certainly taken aback;<br />
and irve might also have made it harder<br />
for other whites by giving the impression<br />
that yes, we'are so rich we can pay<br />
over the odds.<br />
So we reflected on poverty. ln fact, we<br />
had brought several books in preparation<br />
for long journeys and waiting for<br />
bureaucratic procedures, but we hardly<br />
read any of them. Most days we had an<br />
intense discussion or two on the various<br />
topics you can ignore in Britain but here<br />
were in your face on every street:<br />
poverty, God, organised religion, gender,<br />
world history, and personal growth. We<br />
then wondered why we thought about<br />
all this so much less in Britain.<br />
which the British brought over than on<br />
the cultural, spiritual and symbolic tradition<br />
of the sub-continent.<br />
At one lndian Catholic church we<br />
experienced lndian music, scents,<br />
decoration and symbolism as the setting<br />
for an unambiguously Christian sacramental<br />
liturgy. This was a moving and<br />
beautiful inaugural service for the new<br />
building and although they don't do all<br />
that every week it was clearly the norm<br />
to have an indigenous style of liturgy,<br />
which contrasted with some very British<br />
services elsewhere. lt was also<br />
disturbed by 20 minutes of fireworks<br />
outside when lndia hit the winning runs<br />
in a thrilling cricket final. To say I didn't<br />
mind missing it on TV is high praise for<br />
the service.<br />
I found myself wondering if there<br />
was any point in having a church, in a<br />
country dominated by other religion(s).<br />
After all, Jesus came not to start a new<br />
religion but to inspire people who<br />
already had a faith to follow it more<br />
genuinely (among other things). Then<br />
logically if Jesus came to Pakistan he<br />
movemgnt 16<br />
would encourage<br />
people to be better Muslims, and in<br />
lndia to be better Sikhs and Hindus.<br />
Ultimately, there is no need for<br />
Christianity-only for a liberation of the<br />
kind Jesus preached in First Century<br />
Jewish Palestine, and which compares<br />
to the mission of the first Gurus of<br />
Sikhism, and of Mohammed.<br />
But who am I to say how lndian and<br />
Pakistani churches should run<br />
themselves? I draw back from doing so<br />
without the context of a two-way<br />
relationship of respect. And yet<br />
outsiders sometimes make the most<br />
telling observers, whether of a church,<br />
an organisation or a culture. I hope I will<br />
listen harder to hear the reflections of<br />
outsiders when I have the chance.<br />
More to the point, if these are the<br />
questions I ask after four weeks abroad,<br />
after a mere four church services. what<br />
questions am I asking of the church I<br />
claim long-term membership of? How<br />
relevant to British life is our church and<br />
our worship? Do we know and agree on<br />
what the church is for? And what am I<br />
doing about it? The answer to all these<br />
questions is clearly not enough, if I am so<br />
struck by the urgency of such questions<br />
in someone else's church.<br />
So if it is shocking that the only<br />
woman in the pastor's meeting served the<br />
tea and was washing up while we prayed;<br />
that one of the three grand pianos in<br />
Lahore has nobody who can play it, but is<br />
merely a status symbol; and that our<br />
friends had to build their own houses but<br />
could only do so after bribing the<br />
authorities, that tells me not that we<br />
were visiting a sexist and corrupt country,<br />
but that sexism and corruption survive<br />
when they are taken for granted. And the<br />
moral for me is not to tut tut at the way<br />
'these people' do things, but to look differently<br />
at the corruption and sexism that I<br />
take for granted daily in Britain. E<br />
Jonathan ldle is a youth worker in Hackney
Postcard From the<br />
Fringes<br />
have just returned from Lithuania<br />
where I was attending a meeting at<br />
the European Youth Form and visiting<br />
the fledgling SCM in Vilnius.<br />
Contemporary Lithuania is an intriguing<br />
and beautiful country; in my conversations<br />
with the SCMers I met there I<br />
became aware of the strong sense of<br />
civic and cultural identity that has flourished<br />
in this small Baltic state since it<br />
gained its independence from the Soviet<br />
Union in 1<strong>99</strong>1 .<br />
Lithuania played a decisive role in<br />
the break-up of the Soviet Union and<br />
like many other former Soviet states, its<br />
people have had a lot of readjusting to<br />
do. The transition to social democracy<br />
has had its share of problems, but I was<br />
bowled over by the commitment of the<br />
Lithuanians I met to play a part in<br />
rebuilding their society as a fair, democratic<br />
and inclusive one.<br />
One of the first things I noticed<br />
about Vilnius is that it is a city full of<br />
churches. However, during the Soviet<br />
era many of Vilnius's most beautiful and<br />
anci.ent churches were turned into sport<br />
centres or art galleries. Now many of<br />
these fine buildiqgs are being restored<br />
to their former glories and original<br />
purposes. Walking around the streets I<br />
couldn't fail to be struck by the eclectic<br />
mixture of architectural influences-a<br />
testimony to the city's rich and varied<br />
cultural and religious diversity. The<br />
largest proportion of Christians is<br />
Roman Catholic, but Lithuania also has<br />
significant Russian Orthodox and<br />
Lutheran communities. The historical<br />
process by which Lithuania has come to<br />
have such an ethnic and religious mix<br />
does not really make happy reading and<br />
provides plenty of scope for potential<br />
conflict.<br />
ln many parts of Europe (indeed,<br />
here within the British state) the legacy<br />
of troubled histories-displaced persons,<br />
religious and ethnic discrimination.<br />
economic disparities, remote political<br />
eilidh urhiteford<br />
thinkpiece<br />
control-has been, at best, the maintenance<br />
of deep-rooted resentments and,<br />
at worst, the eruption of organised<br />
violence. Yet it seems that Lithuania has<br />
fared better than most in its attempts to<br />
acknowledge and overcome the traditionally<br />
harboured resentments that<br />
have existed between communities.<br />
But what does all this have to do<br />
with us? Lithuania is a long way away,<br />
THE MOST POWERFUL THIHG I<br />
]IIOTICED TYAS THAT THE<br />
LITHUANIAHS WHO DIED AS A<br />
RESUTT OF THE MO]'IENTOUS<br />
EVEilTS OF I<strong>99</strong> I WERE AGED<br />
BETWEE]T I8 AND 2I YEARS. IN<br />
oTHER TYORDS, lT wAS YOUNG<br />
PEOPLE WHO ACTED TO LIBERATE<br />
THEIR COUNTRY.<br />
after all. The most powerful thing I<br />
noticed in Lithuania was that young<br />
people actually seemed to feel part of<br />
their society-there was no ghetto of<br />
youth politics or youth culture to be<br />
found. As the Speaker of the Lithuanian<br />
Parliament has pointed out, almost all<br />
the Lithuanians who died as a result of<br />
the momentous events of 1<strong>99</strong>1 were<br />
aged between 1 8 and 21 years. ln other<br />
words, it was young people who acted<br />
to liberate and re-create their country.<br />
It saddens me that so many young<br />
people in Western Europe have become<br />
so deeply alienated from the civic values<br />
that, at least in the case of Lithuania,<br />
have launched one small Baltic nation<br />
on a road to positive transformation.<br />
l've never subscribed to the view that<br />
young people today are more lazy,<br />
apathetic or selfish than earlier generations,<br />
but when I find myself identifying<br />
with characters in Trainspotting ot<br />
Generation X or turning up Alanis<br />
Morrisette, I have to ask myself "what's<br />
gone wrong?"<br />
I guess that if you're reading<br />
<strong>Movement</strong> you are probably a person<br />
who is also writing letters for Amnesty<br />
lnternational, or collecting signatures for<br />
Jubilee 2000, or making soup in a soup<br />
kitchen, hanging out at a peace camp,<br />
or whatever. But why do so many<br />
people who share a commitment to a<br />
just and peaceful world feel unable to<br />
participate and feel themselves on the<br />
fringe of society? Why have such activities<br />
been marginalised from the<br />
mainstream of public life?<br />
Compared to the great bulk of<br />
humanity, we enjoy a high level of rights<br />
and privileges in this part of the world,<br />
including the freedom to make a fuss<br />
about things we don't like. We're able to<br />
make lifestyle choices that simply aren't<br />
open to young men & women in other<br />
places. Arguably, the most precious<br />
consequence of this personal liberty is<br />
that our society cares less about<br />
someone's colour, ethnicity, class,<br />
religion, sexual orientation, gender or<br />
living arrangements than in the past. Yet<br />
l'm afraid I have a nagging doubt that<br />
behind this liberal fagade lurks a less<br />
palatable symptom of our latetwentieth<br />
century cultural malaise<br />
and loss of civil identity: maybe the<br />
truth is that we just care less, full<br />
stop.<br />
What is certainly true is that we in<br />
the West could learn a great deal from<br />
the emerging democracies of Eastern<br />
and Central Europe; however, they too,<br />
as they embrace Western political and<br />
economic models might be well advised<br />
to exercise some caution, heeding the<br />
harsher lessons learnt in the West about<br />
the consequences of creating a young,<br />
alienated populace. I can only wish the<br />
Lithuanians well in their continued<br />
efforts to forge a vital and inclusive<br />
sense of cultural identity and look on<br />
with not a little envy. @<br />
Eilidh Whiteford has just received her<br />
doctorate in Scottish Literature. She is<br />
the Ghair of the European Region of the<br />
World Student Christian Federation<br />
movgmgnt 17
The Royal shakespeare companv's recent adaptation of the medieval mysterv plavs, Tne<br />
Mvsteries, retells the Biblical stories in radical new wavs. Graeme Burk spoke with writer<br />
Edward Kemp about his work on this project, and how it has changed his own thoughts<br />
uilding The<br />
D<br />
D<br />
ysteries<br />
Getting my tickets lor The<br />
Mysteries, the Royal<br />
Shakespeare Company's<br />
retelling of the medieval<br />
mystery plays, I had an experience akin<br />
to having the Riot Act read aloud. The<br />
friendly person at the Barbican's box<br />
office first said to me: "You should be<br />
aware that the performance is six hours<br />
with two intervals". Alright. Then: "The<br />
text has been radically changed from<br />
the source material so it's very<br />
different." Fine. "There's nudity,<br />
vulgarity and some swearing." Okay.<br />
Finally: "and Jesus doesn't get<br />
resurrected at the end, so if you are of<br />
strong beliefs you may be offended."<br />
ln spite of this rather daunting<br />
preamble (which is, strictly speaking,<br />
not even accurate: there is a resurrection<br />
at the end), and in spite of its<br />
appropriately Biblical length, Ihe<br />
Mysteries proved to be a phenomenal<br />
theatrical experience. People looking for<br />
a Sunday school pageant retelling of the<br />
Bible (or, indeed, a presentation of the<br />
medieval mystery plays) will come away<br />
disappointed. What this RSC production<br />
managed to do was strip away the<br />
Biblical stories to their basic, mythic, core<br />
and retell the basic story in a powerful.<br />
effective way. /see Sidebar, opposite)<br />
"What we shared was a fascination<br />
with Jesus, as a historical, totemic and<br />
religious figure,"'explains Edward Kemp.<br />
Kemp was initially brought onto the<br />
project as a "dramaturg" (a writer who<br />
basically adapts other's work) but found<br />
over two years that his role expanded,<br />
to the point where the most accurate<br />
billing for the script has been "adapted<br />
from the medieval mystery plays, with<br />
additional material from the Bible the<br />
Ou'ran, the works of Dostoyevsky and<br />
Bulgakov and with additional writing by<br />
Edward Kemp."<br />
The road to this began in 1<strong>99</strong>6<br />
when Katie Mitchell, the artistic director<br />
of the RSC's The Other Place in<br />
Stratford conceived of a season of pre-<br />
Shakesperian plays which included the<br />
medieval mystery plays and Everyman.<br />
lnitially choosing to do an amalgam<br />
of the four different English cycles,<br />
Kemp set to adapting the work, but as it<br />
progressed it was clear that the original<br />
source material was not working as well<br />
as had been expected, in part due to the<br />
polemical origins. "We kept saying 'this<br />
material is<br />
anti-<br />
Semitic,<br />
we'll have<br />
to do<br />
something<br />
about<br />
that' or<br />
'that<br />
material is<br />
misogynist,<br />
we'll<br />
have to do<br />
something<br />
about<br />
that'and<br />
we<br />
seemed to<br />
be further<br />
and<br />
further<br />
from the<br />
medievals<br />
and with<br />
every turning the medievalness, which<br />
once seemed so charming and<br />
delightful, was actually becoming a real<br />
barrier. "<br />
After infusing the text with new<br />
material-mostly from the Biblical text<br />
itself but written in rhyming verse-a<br />
new dynamic to the project came when<br />
it came to rehearsals. "We had this<br />
extraordinary rehearsal period where we<br />
found that the actors had come on the<br />
same journey as we did...and so all the<br />
discussions about the devil and evil<br />
movement 18<br />
came with the rehearsal process. We<br />
spent a lot of time discussing the<br />
theology of the piece, which was<br />
exciting. "<br />
The production opened in Stratford<br />
in 1<strong>99</strong>7 to favourable reviews, but there<br />
were still frustrations according to Kemp<br />
"What we began to discover was<br />
that the debates we had in the<br />
rehearsal room were much more<br />
dynamic and felt much more of our<br />
time than what was happening on<br />
stage." ln moving the play to<br />
London this winter, the text was<br />
completely rewritten in the hopes of<br />
reflecting these debates.<br />
Key to this was a shift to contemporary<br />
language. "ln some ways, in<br />
Stratford, we asked difficult<br />
questions, and put them on stage<br />
but because it was couched in the<br />
old language and was rather austere<br />
and beautiful, people received it as<br />
something which had not changed.
"So unless one clranged the<br />
language unless one deployed slrock<br />
tactics by having Peter swearir-rg and<br />
rluggirrg Jesus-- unless people canre at<br />
these stories fronr more oblique angles,<br />
people sir-nply wouldn't listerr. "<br />
Part of the process of getting people<br />
to listen has been to bring the stories<br />
back to their archetypal roots. The<br />
stories that ur.rfold throughout lhe<br />
Mysteries do not take place in ancient<br />
Palestine br-rt rather a war torn<br />
lar-rdscape. Tl.ris enables the story to be<br />
retained in a mythic place Jr-rdea but<br />
also our owr-r time-and seems appro<br />
priate given the bloody conflicts which act<br />
as a backdrop to nruch of the Bible,<br />
something with which Kemp colrcurs. "Tlre<br />
nloment one yoLr go into a war zone you<br />
acl.rieve sornething rnythic," he explains.<br />
"What connects the Old Testanrent and the<br />
New Gstanrent as human l-ristory together<br />
is the l.ristory of war."<br />
ln adaptlng the New Testanrent, a<br />
decision was made to reexanrine the<br />
stories of Jesr-rs for their rlythic qualities<br />
rather than trying a straightforward<br />
historical interpretation, "fhe number of<br />
verifiable I'ristorical facts about Jesus<br />
are about as rrany as Shal
-t<br />
quickios<br />
llVhat's totr fanouite pocsesll&rt<br />
My imagination<br />
What are you reading at the<br />
moment?<br />
Proust, Faulkner's Collected<br />
Short Stories, Bulgakov's<br />
The Master & Margarila,<br />
Julia Cameron's The Artist's<br />
Way, Muriel Rtrkeyser's lhe<br />
Life of Poetry, last week's<br />
newspapers ...<br />
lrllhat's ptr favourite fimi$ay?<br />
Paris, Texas ! The Cherry<br />
Orchard<br />
How do you relax?<br />
By working - the curse of<br />
letting your hobby become<br />
your lob<br />
What do you most like about<br />
yourself?<br />
My bemusement<br />
What do<br />
you most<br />
dislike about<br />
yourself?<br />
My envy<br />
What's your<br />
favourite<br />
word?<br />
Besotted<br />
ll you could be someone<br />
else who would you be7<br />
Picasso<br />
Wh€n tr you last cry?<br />
Last Sunday<br />
What's your favourite joumey? Wtlat ae yan sca€d d?<br />
Anywhere by plane Not lulfillirrg my potenlial<br />
more than you get frorn Dennis Potter's<br />
Son of Man or Jesus Christ Superstar."<br />
And yet, there are some striking<br />
reinterpretation of other figures in<br />
Christiar.r iconography.. Satarr in lhe<br />
Mysteries is simply than a nressenger<br />
angel and as such neutral in his affairs<br />
with humanity. This, explains Kemp,<br />
carne out of a reading of the Biblical<br />
text itself . "lf you ransack the Old<br />
Testament you find that Satan and the<br />
Devil are barely there at all, which<br />
seemed to us to be a bit interesting.<br />
"So what began as a bit of biblical<br />
scl.rolarship to remove the devil then<br />
became a moral issue- there is no<br />
longer a character in this story on<br />
whom one can blame anythit'rg.<br />
ln the absence of any character to<br />
blame, the focus of The Mysteries turns<br />
towards humanity and their own cruelty.<br />
The stories of the Old Testament-an<br />
expansion of the medievals, who relied<br />
only on Genesis- are stripped of any<br />
triumphalism whatsoever. The world falls<br />
into greater disarray due to human choice.<br />
Edward states that the play takes this<br />
theme from Liberation Theology: "God<br />
creatbd the world and it was good. lf it's<br />
not<br />
,W<br />
right, that is creation's fault and duty<br />
to fix it."<br />
hat's been exciting<br />
about the project<br />
overall and important<br />
about the project is<br />
to say 'these are the stories of our<br />
culture'. Even if you don't know the<br />
story of Abral.ram and lsaac-and it's<br />
fascinating to know the number of<br />
people who don't know that story who<br />
come out-that story of a father sacrificing<br />
a son in that way has informed<br />
our literature over and over again. That<br />
Descdbe a recurring dream<br />
that you have<br />
One day we will all come lo<br />
our senses<br />
What do you never miss on<br />
TV?<br />
A long list of American silcoms<br />
What music do you listen to<br />
most?<br />
This week - Ani Di Franco,<br />
The Divine Comedy. Afro-<br />
Cuban Allstars; rrext week -<br />
Janacek, New Order, Mozart<br />
and Professor Longhair<br />
What pet hates do you haveT<br />
Theatre critics<br />
What would your motto for<br />
living be?<br />
When shall we live. iJ r-tot<br />
now?<br />
was the fascinatir.rg thirrg abor.rt going<br />
back into the history bit of the Old<br />
Testament if you haven't done it before.<br />
There are er.rtire Shakespeare history<br />
plays lyirrg around in the books of Kings<br />
and Samuel. lf we lraven't gotterl it<br />
directly frorn the source, we've gotten it<br />
from a wlrole lot of other places. lt<br />
seems to me we have to keep tl-rese<br />
stories alive ir-r the same way the Greeks<br />
knew you had to keep retelling the rnyths."<br />
And yet the reaction to tlre London<br />
production oI The Mysteries has<br />
indicated sonre resistance<br />
- at least on<br />
the part of some critics and others<br />
{even, as my discr,rssion getting tickets<br />
revealed, within the RSC itself) towards<br />
retelling the Christian mytl.rs. "People l.rave<br />
no trouble when doing this with someone<br />
else's culture and its terribly nice,"<br />
observes Kemp, "but somehow when you<br />
do it to our culture, you discover that<br />
people really don't want it to change."<br />
"So the fact that we've tried to say<br />
'look these stories can be living, these<br />
stories can be alive' and what one<br />
discovers is that in this'Christian'<br />
country there are lruge numbers of intelligent<br />
people who think it's really important<br />
that Christianity doesn't change."<br />
This is something which doesn't<br />
surprise Kemp. "l think most of us have<br />
a sort of cardboard box which is called<br />
'What I believe' which somewhere<br />
towards the end of adolescence we shut<br />
up, put some string around it and put it<br />
on the shelf somewhere and it only ever<br />
comes down if we encounter some kind<br />
of a life crisis. This is something which<br />
had to be revisited by all who have<br />
been involved in The Mysteries.<br />
"What all of us had to do in this<br />
project was take that cardboard box<br />
out and see what was in it. And one of<br />
fnovemcnt 20<br />
the thirrgs we discovered during the<br />
process of doing that was all the sort of<br />
tl'rings yor-r thought yor-t could accept jLlst<br />
falls apart. "<br />
And what about Edward's owtt<br />
cardboard box? "l don't tl'rirrk the<br />
cardboard box is going bacl< ot.t the top<br />
shelf for quite some tinre and it feels<br />
like I have the contents spread around<br />
nry living roorr. I believe the process of<br />
nroving Ithe play] to London has made<br />
nre ever nrore Clrristian in that l'm rnore<br />
and nrore deeply fascir-rated by Jesr:s<br />
Christ than ever before. The overall<br />
project, and again it going to London,<br />
has rnade me more atheist, which is to<br />
me a process that began sorne years<br />
back, br-rt I sirnply realised tlrat l'd redis<br />
covered rry spiritual journey where I<br />
sirlply no longer rreeded tlre word<br />
'God'. I was very happy for other people<br />
to use the word 'God', br-rt to rne the<br />
word 'God' was a barrier to further<br />
exploration. So I kind of surrendered the<br />
word 'God', and tl.re project has<br />
constantly reaffirllred for nre persorrally<br />
to do that.<br />
"l can't at the nroment base a<br />
morality or-rtside rnyself , outside<br />
creatiorr. lcan't base nrorality on a<br />
creator. I don't yet l-rave a solution to<br />
how you create a morality based on<br />
creatior-r, because orre inevitably gets<br />
back to genetics and genetics doesn't<br />
really teach one muclr more than the<br />
fact that rnorality may be useful<br />
because it will keep the race from<br />
wiping itself out and l'm not sure if<br />
that's a very good basis of rnorality. So<br />
it's incredibly sharpened my interest in<br />
nroral questions. Tlre cardboard box is<br />
out and the contents are lyir-rg around<br />
the livir.rg room and it's made me mucl.t<br />
less morally relativist than I used to be. I<br />
find myself agreeing with people who<br />
talk about responsibilities rather than<br />
rights, which suddenly makes me step<br />
back and wonder if l've become my<br />
grandfather. "<br />
Theatre is an art form tlrat, perhaps<br />
like no other, can stimulate and<br />
challenge thought. That a play is<br />
capable of making its audience reflect<br />
on issues related to freedom, morality,<br />
cosmology and religion and make its<br />
creators do so as well is an impressive<br />
feat. The paradox of the RSC's production<br />
of The Mysteries is that it is a<br />
sensitive, powerful and thoughtful play<br />
that defies all expectations, particularly<br />
those given at the point of sale by the<br />
RSC itself . Which is a shame, as rather<br />
than offending people of strong belief , it<br />
should do the opposite. At its best, Ihe<br />
Mysteries f ulf ills Edward Kemp's belief<br />
tl.rat "Every single scene in this play is<br />
based on the core of how one can<br />
dramatise Jesus' teaching." @<br />
Graeme Burk is editor of <strong>Movement</strong>
Robert Jones samples the gospel-influenced stylings of Nick Lowe's Dig MV Mood<br />
Struggle, American Style<br />
NICK LOWE - DIG MY MOOD<br />
Produced by Nick Lowe and Neil<br />
Brockbank<br />
Demon Records<br />
first thing one notices on<br />
7he<br />
I<br />
hearing Nick Lowe's new disc is<br />
how rooted in American musical<br />
I tradition it is. lndeed, Lowe<br />
covers a lot of ground here. from Tin Pan<br />
Alley jazz balladry, Sixties soul, hardbitten<br />
folk. right down to full-on<br />
Nashville country. This is a "down<br />
home" record, a comfort record, not<br />
because it is not sophisticated in many<br />
places, but because it is obvious that<br />
the man who has crafted these songs is<br />
obviously in love with the legacy of<br />
American popular music which is<br />
celebrated on Dig My Mood As the<br />
album progresses, one can almost<br />
imagine driving down a motorway,<br />
windows rolled down, with these<br />
sounds flowing out of a car radio. Lowe<br />
carries the mantle of great American<br />
singers such as Nat King Cole, Sam<br />
Cooke and Johnny Cash with equal<br />
dexterity and in these traditions, Lowe<br />
doesn't seem like an intruder due largely<br />
to his obvious enthusiasm. Despite the<br />
sombre shading which goes to make the<br />
disc so rich in atmosphere, he really<br />
sounds like he's having a good time.<br />
Another credit to this collection is<br />
Lowe's seemingly God-given gift of<br />
being able to hear the essence of a<br />
musical style and being subsequently<br />
able to construct a sound around his<br />
mainly original compositions without<br />
compromising the basic spirit of the<br />
genre in which he is working. His many<br />
years at Stiff Records and his tenure as<br />
Elvis Costello's most revered producer<br />
have seasoned his own mastery of<br />
musical style. .<br />
ln contrast to this enthusiasm of<br />
classic American music is the undertones<br />
of loss, despair and loneliness<br />
which, on some tracks, seem to<br />
transcend the expectation that these<br />
elements are a convention of style. lt<br />
would not be out of the ordinary to<br />
expect despair in a country song such<br />
as the album's closing track, Lowe's<br />
cover of lvory Joe Hunter's "Cold Grey<br />
Light of Dawn" which starts with "That<br />
old alarm clock gives a yell/ Starting<br />
another day in Hell/Facing a world I<br />
can't face with you gone". The lyric is a<br />
model of country traditions and demonstrates<br />
Lowe's understanding of how<br />
country songs are constructed and best<br />
presented. lt is interesting to contrast<br />
this with Lowe's own, "l Must Be<br />
Getting Over You", the track which<br />
precedes it. ln this song, also a country<br />
song, the<br />
singer decides<br />
" I must be<br />
getting over<br />
you/ Because<br />
today I saw<br />
the bluebird at<br />
my window.../l<br />
saw the sun<br />
breaking<br />
through my<br />
window",<br />
these lines of<br />
hope also<br />
suggest a<br />
certain sense<br />
of tragedy; the<br />
singer doesn't<br />
sing to a<br />
lrrcK r0wE<br />
departed lover so much as he sings the<br />
song to himself as a way of getting over<br />
a cherished life once shared with<br />
someone who is palpably absent.<br />
The convention of lost love is<br />
explored on many tracks here, from the<br />
Sam Cooke-esque "Lonesome Reverie"<br />
to the equally soulful "What Lack of<br />
Love Has Done" and go to cast Lowe as<br />
the scarred troubadour, who seeks<br />
solace in singing about his fear of love<br />
and what it can do to someone who<br />
surrenders to it. lt is portrayed as<br />
something which can cause misery<br />
("Love's a hurting thing/ For I know it to<br />
be true") yet also it is seen as a<br />
motivating force, best embodied on the<br />
jazzy "You lnspire Me" as the singer<br />
proclaims "The road is long/ And it<br />
winds through the night/ But when<br />
you're near/ You let there be light" to an<br />
accompaniment of shimmering vibes,<br />
lyrical piano and rich backing vocals.<br />
The language here is religious and it is<br />
part of a trend which Lowe furthers<br />
thorough out the album; the importance<br />
of the spiritual and yet, its equally<br />
troublesome elusivity.<br />
The waning spirituality which<br />
features in many of these songs can be<br />
best seen in the Johnny Cash-inspired<br />
movemsnt 21<br />
folk song "Man That I've Become"<br />
which portrays a good man who has<br />
become an outcast to everybody<br />
including himself, because he has<br />
become spent by too much living in a<br />
harsh world. The singer explains that "<br />
He can't go to church/ 'Cause his faith's<br />
all gone/ The sweet singing of the choir/<br />
Nothing but a<br />
row". The gospelinflected<br />
"High on<br />
a Hilltop"<br />
describes a futile<br />
search for earthly<br />
spiritual fulfillment<br />
as something<br />
which is, simply,<br />
"far away". ln this<br />
vein, the grimmest<br />
track on the album<br />
is Henry<br />
McCullough's<br />
"Failed Christian"<br />
because of the<br />
underlying bitterness<br />
which runs<br />
through the song's<br />
spare, but direct lyrics "l'm a failed<br />
Christian/ And if I'm going under/ Than<br />
you're coming with me/ That much I<br />
can tell". Again, it must be mentioned<br />
that many of the themes explored here<br />
are conventional; American music has<br />
been born out of these kinds of spiritual<br />
struggles, from the gospel music of<br />
American southern churches which gave<br />
birth to the blues and to soul, to the<br />
tent-meeting hymns which evolved into<br />
modern country music. However, Lowe<br />
has captured both the essence of this<br />
music and created an emotional subtext<br />
as well, so we can see that these kinds<br />
of sentiments are still relevant to human<br />
experience and are relevant within the<br />
confines of popular song.<br />
Dig My Mood remains to be a<br />
puzzling title. ls this an invitation to mine<br />
the troubled soul of the artist himself, or<br />
is it merely to draw attention to the eclectic<br />
range of style and voices which Lowe<br />
employs? Perhaps it is enough that we are<br />
left with a solid collection of songs, well<br />
crafted originals and well chosen covers, by<br />
an artist who has a true love for music and<br />
musicians who have come before him. E<br />
Robert Jones is a writer and poet based<br />
in London
i<br />
Tim woodcock examines Steven Spielberg's historical epic, Amistad<br />
Whitewashing History<br />
AMISTAD<br />
Directed by Steven Spielberg<br />
Starring Djimon Hounsou, Anthony<br />
Hopkins, Matthew McConaughey, Pete<br />
Postlethwaite<br />
WHj,lfitfit,,,*$i'i<br />
Something like Amistad: it has<br />
compelling cinematography; a very<br />
competent cast; beautiful vignettes; a<br />
provocative and moving story, told with<br />
intelligence and compassion. Yet it<br />
doesn't satisfy. Hollywood can turn<br />
worthy themes into worthless<br />
tirades-but that is not the problem<br />
here. Nor is it caught in arty obscurity or<br />
the sludge of historical pedantry. Neither<br />
is it cheesy. idealised, simplistic or any<br />
those other usual celluloid pit-falls.<br />
Amistad simply misses the mark.<br />
Some background: Amistad is the<br />
Spanish name of a ship that mutinied<br />
during a voyage to the United States. lt<br />
is 1839, a particular moment in history:<br />
by now slave trading is illegal, unless<br />
they are 'born slaves' on a plantation.<br />
The plot goes forwards and backwards:<br />
what in legal terms should happen to<br />
this human cargo? And who are they,<br />
and where did they come from?<br />
Some would argue that Amistad is a<br />
white man's black film and there is<br />
some truth in this: a friend told me of<br />
standing in a cinema queue behind a<br />
black woman who said, "Steven<br />
Speilberg is going to tell us about<br />
ourselves again." lt would be an utterly<br />
different film if directed by Spike Lee.<br />
Amistad is more interested in apologies<br />
than empowerment; and apologies<br />
rather than repentance. Despite the<br />
numerous black'actors there are only<br />
three proper black characters and<br />
Cinque is the only fleshed-out<br />
slave-the rest are a huddle of pity, a<br />
disputed human cargo, an embarrassment<br />
for New World Americans and<br />
Spanish Merchants. The film's subject is<br />
as much the decline of a trade as the<br />
liberation of a race.<br />
Allow me to pick out three problems<br />
that muddle this potentially earthshattering<br />
film. The first one perhaps<br />
explains the other two: with<br />
Schindler's l/sf (the only comparable<br />
Spielberg film) there was Thomas<br />
Keneally's novel to whip the historical<br />
material into shape, to craft a coherent<br />
story by selecting and dramatising<br />
history. Here direct transfer of history<br />
onto screen leads to too many strands<br />
of plot, too many characters and<br />
multiple half-baked heroes. Whereas<br />
Oskar Schindler the "scoundrel-saint"<br />
was clearly the focus-in Amistad, who<br />
or what is? The lawyer Baldwin... the<br />
string-pulling politicians... the slaves?<br />
Where is it set? The courtroom... the<br />
boat from Africa...or Africa itself ? I<br />
honestly can't remember the sequence<br />
of the plot.<br />
Secondly, the Spanish speakers<br />
(although subtitled) are easily understood<br />
by their gestures; whereas the<br />
Africans' impenetrable speech is<br />
subtitled. putting a layer between them<br />
and us-and, yes, it is that explicit. The<br />
Africans are often shown as ignoble<br />
savages; as irredeemably foreign. lt was<br />
courageous to make language into a<br />
barrier. but it makes it hard to follow: a less<br />
ambitious film would have put the most<br />
eloquent speeches into a black mouth.<br />
The particularity of the legal case<br />
greatly saps the film's potential<br />
power-What should be done with<br />
illegally obtained goods (albeit human<br />
beings) when lost at sea? Under which<br />
loophole of which piece of legislation?<br />
Baldwin is a brilliant lawyer who<br />
specialises in property law There is a<br />
climactic court case in which the slaves<br />
gain their freedom-then a tedious<br />
movcmcnt 22<br />
appeal so Anthony Hopkins can do his<br />
stuff . The fidelity to historical accuracy<br />
blunts the dramatic edge. Despite<br />
Amistad having a constellation of<br />
virtues there is an underlying narrative<br />
incompetence.<br />
This film oscillates between the<br />
individual circumstances and Big<br />
Themes. rather than demonstrating one<br />
through the other. "To make a universal<br />
point one must begin with the<br />
parochial." lt is a marvellous truth of<br />
storytelling-and for me a key to understanding<br />
what the incarnation is about.<br />
The crucial scene for any Christian<br />
engagement with the film is when one<br />
of the slaves flicks through the<br />
engraved pictures in a Bible,<br />
constructing his version of what is<br />
going on: he identifies with 'a race full<br />
of suffering' and then sees, 'when He<br />
was born everything changed... he<br />
heals and protects... He walks across<br />
the sea... but he was captured and<br />
accused of a crime'. The slave has no<br />
idea who this man is. When 'He rose<br />
into the sky' the point of connection is<br />
lost-Ascension may as well be called<br />
The Day of Buggering Off. The<br />
problem comes here for us too: was<br />
Christ- another torn and beaten<br />
captive-only a prophet and a revolutionary?<br />
lf we say he is more, that is where<br />
faith begins. E<br />
Tim Woodcock is a student in Glasgow<br />
and the editor of Moziak, the magazine<br />
of the WSCF European Region
Graeme Burk puts stephen May's examination of christianity and science fiction stardust and<br />
Ashes under spectral analysis...<br />
The Truth ls Out Wherel<br />
STARDUST AND ASHES: A CHRISTIAN<br />
PERSPECTIVE ON SCIENCE FICTION<br />
Stephen May<br />
SPCK<br />
ne of the most interesting<br />
sermons I ever gave was during<br />
the first week of Lent a few<br />
years ago. The texts were the<br />
stories of the fall of humanity and the<br />
temptations of Jesus. Because it was<br />
the week of the Annual<br />
General Meeting I had<br />
five minutes to preach<br />
and, out of sheer<br />
desperation, I preached<br />
it in a Star Trek<br />
uniform.<br />
It wasn't that<br />
hard: the future<br />
presented in the early<br />
days of Star Trek:<br />
The Next Generation<br />
struggles for a<br />
prelapsarian perfection<br />
which has more<br />
or less has been<br />
abandoned in later<br />
years, and I asked<br />
why it's so hard to<br />
envision a perfect world in our culture. I<br />
also attempted to examine the various<br />
aspects of the fall and the temptations<br />
by reflecting these stories through our<br />
own cultural myths and it was surprising<br />
how compatible they were.<br />
I don't think this was just anorakishness<br />
on my part-although there is<br />
admittedly an element of that! Some<br />
time before I had attended a diocesan<br />
Synod and watched as clergy and laity<br />
(and even, I suspect, the episcopate)<br />
huriied to their cars to get home in time<br />
for the opening episode of the sixth<br />
season of Star Trek: The Next<br />
Generation and talked about it enthusiastically<br />
the next day. We may be<br />
Christians, but we are a part of a<br />
science fiction world. Science fiction is<br />
our culture's mythology and the stories<br />
of Picard, Kirk, Mulder, Scully and the<br />
inhabitants of Ringworld are as vital to<br />
us as Gilgamesh and Jason and the<br />
Argonauts were to the Mesopotamians<br />
and the Greeks.<br />
This is something which Stephen<br />
May admits in his thoughtful assessment<br />
of the science fiction genre,<br />
Stardust and Ashes. May has the<br />
unenviable task of producing the first<br />
work of serious scholarship to examine<br />
science fiction (or "sf" as it is known by<br />
aficianados, not "sci-fi" as SPCK consistently<br />
call it in their promotional<br />
material) from a Christian perspective.<br />
What emerges is a fascinating examination<br />
of Western thought from a novel<br />
point of view.<br />
For May, sf are stories humankind<br />
tell about themselves. and their hopes<br />
for self -transcendence<br />
('stardust') or their fears of<br />
self-destruction ('ashes'). ln<br />
examining sf, he looks at,<br />
and provides a lucid and<br />
intelligent critique of, the<br />
history of sf, examining the<br />
contributions of authors such<br />
as HG Wells, lsaac Asimov<br />
Philip K Dick. Ursula LeGuin<br />
and others.<br />
ln looking at the genre. May<br />
indicates some intriguing<br />
enamoured with rugged<br />
humanism, but at the same time a<br />
gnostic valuation of the mind. A genre<br />
with great emphasis on human achievement,<br />
but little consideration for<br />
ordinary humans. A genre filled with<br />
wonder, but also loneliness.<br />
ln setting the groundwork for a<br />
dialogue between sf and Christianity,<br />
May starts out with the premise that<br />
both share a common sense of wonderment<br />
with the universe. The bridge<br />
between "thy power throughout the<br />
universe displayed" to "space: the final<br />
frontier" is perhaps shorter than most<br />
would admit and it's an excellent<br />
starting point. lt's a disappointment that<br />
it is not developed better or further.<br />
movemsnt 23<br />
Rather than engaging and dialoguing<br />
with the texts that comprise sf , May<br />
decides to answer them instead, making<br />
preachy statments such is "lt is entirely<br />
understandable and natural that. in a<br />
genre which methodologically rejects<br />
the existence of God, one part of<br />
creation is given his role. But it is<br />
wrong."<br />
Which is a great pity. Much of<br />
Stardust and Ashes works effectively by<br />
standing back and examining what sf<br />
says about our culture and structuring<br />
that examination in a manner condusive<br />
for theological reflection. Providing a<br />
didactic commentary, however, is both<br />
boring and boorish. Sf is, if nothing else,<br />
a genre about diversity: it can encompass<br />
authors and points of view ranging<br />
from the fascistic Robert Heinlein to the<br />
eco-feminism of Ursula LeGuin.<br />
Engaging with such a pluralistic genre<br />
with a unilateral claim on truth seems<br />
ingenuous. lt's also unnecessary: at its<br />
best. sf, as a literary genre, credits the<br />
j'J'i'Ji3:""ffi11"r.".<br />
THE BRIDGE BETw=EN<br />
the obvious, but<br />
{5THY<br />
well-founded case POWER<br />
that sf's fascination<br />
with the "other" or THROUGHOUT THE<br />
:[?f"?ii":: ;T:',',,:"".,. u N I v E Rs E D I S P LAY E D' r<br />
[J:?i,;:.H:,Ib"l'ff To ('sPAcE: THE FINAL<br />
carr sagan,s book FRONTIERIt lS PERHAPS<br />
Contactl. He goes deeper<br />
than this, thoush, and rooks SHORT=R THAN MOST<br />
1fi"il",""J":,:Tx?l'jt!;." uf o u tD A D t*t I T<br />
reader with a great deal of intelligence.<br />
Likewise, May should credit his readers<br />
with the intelligence to draw their own<br />
conclusions.<br />
Stardust and Ashes should be<br />
applauded for looking at the mythology<br />
which is increasingly shaping our<br />
culture. lt is for the most part a<br />
delightful and intriguing look at those<br />
myths and what they say about<br />
ourselves but it is weakened by its<br />
failure to do what Captain Picard said<br />
best-"Engage". fit<br />
<strong>Movement</strong> editor Graeme Burk is a<br />
reviewer for the science fiction<br />
magazine Dreamwatch
I<br />
j ,.i.;<br />
. : li.:l<br />
i;..i<br />
, l' '!<br />
: t:<br />
itlri.l<br />
., . r-. :.1.'.1<br />
Dominic Heaney on Peter Vardy's introductory analysis of Sexual Ethics, The Puzzle of Sex<br />
Ptlzzling lt Over<br />
THE PUZZLE OF SEX<br />
Peter Vardy<br />
HarperCollins/ Fount<br />
t the outset it is worth stating<br />
that this book, one in<br />
HarperCollins"'Puzzle" series<br />
dealing with ethical and philosophical<br />
issues. and which claims to be<br />
"an outstanding introduction to the<br />
whole realm of human sexuality", would<br />
appear to have as its target audience A-<br />
level students as well as a wider general<br />
audience. Hence it is "popular theologycum-philosophy"<br />
for the chain<br />
bookstore from a chain book-publisher.<br />
But it is not so bad as this may imply<br />
to some.<br />
lndeed as an introduction to its topic,<br />
The Puzzle of Sex works reasonably<br />
well. Of greater concern are the facts<br />
that the text occasionally lapses into<br />
truism ("one cannot decide what the<br />
correct reaction should be to sexual<br />
issues as the dawning of the new<br />
millennium merely by referring to the<br />
understanding prevailing in ancient<br />
lsrael "), over-simplification, and<br />
indiscreetly over-provocative "insights"<br />
("Today any 17-year-old knows more<br />
about human bodies thant St. Augustine<br />
or St. Thomas Aquinas"). These relatively<br />
minor quibbles aside though. Vardy has<br />
succeeded in producing a book that<br />
manages to combine accessibilty of style<br />
with challenging content and a wide<br />
range of reference.<br />
The Puzzle of Sex is segmented into<br />
three sections, each followed by<br />
questions for (presumably classroom)<br />
discussion. An opening which appropriately<br />
cites historical and theological<br />
precedent for challenging conventionally<br />
accepted notions of religious truth and<br />
practice (referring to the books of Job<br />
and Jonah as well as to more recent<br />
controversies) is followed by the first<br />
section, entitled "How We Got Where<br />
We Are". Here Vardy provides a comprehensive<br />
and concise oversight of the Old<br />
Testament Hebrew and subsequent<br />
Christian attitudes and teachings<br />
relating to sexuality and sexual practice.<br />
This section is one of the highlights of<br />
the book, in which the evolution and<br />
implications of concepts such as<br />
Platonism and Natural Law are explained<br />
in terms clear to the lay reader. A significant<br />
gap may be found in the almost<br />
complete omission of Jewish teachings<br />
since the beginning of the Christian Era,<br />
but with regards to the teachings of this<br />
latter faith-in its Roman Catholic,<br />
Anglican, Protestant, and, as occurs all<br />
too rarely in British textbooks, Eastern<br />
Orthodox forms-Vardy is coherent and<br />
cogent, as he is with regard to pre-<br />
Christian Judaism.<br />
The middle section of the book,<br />
"Finding A New Way<br />
Forward", serves above all<br />
as a reasoned critique of<br />
some of the attitudes<br />
towards sex expressed in<br />
parts of the Christian<br />
communion. Above all<br />
the Thomist and Natural<br />
Law-inspired outlook<br />
that characterizes much<br />
of the stand of the<br />
Roman Catholic Church<br />
on matters sexual<br />
comes in for criticism,<br />
as do some of the<br />
more obvious consequences<br />
of society<br />
being male-dominated<br />
in structure<br />
and thought. The<br />
need for contextual<br />
understanding of doctrine<br />
\<br />
J<br />
.J<br />
THE<br />
P,....<br />
PTITR VARDY<br />
and practise is stated and restated, the<br />
logical adjunct to this argument being<br />
that there is much that Christianity<br />
might learn from modern phenomena<br />
such as psychology and psychotherapy.<br />
Vardy expresses the hope that the philosophical<br />
"advances" of the modern and<br />
post-modern dpoques would inform<br />
Christian and indeed post-Christian<br />
conceptions of morality.<br />
The closing unit, perhaps disingenuously<br />
named "Dealing With Current<br />
Problems" explores ethical and religious<br />
approaches towards what in fact are for<br />
the most part universal dilemmas of<br />
sexual ethics. The author is daring in his<br />
argumentation, going forth to outline<br />
circumstances in which. for example,<br />
adultery may be viewed as morally<br />
justifiable. At times the extent to<br />
which Vardy seeks to reject that which<br />
has gone before is such that one in<br />
inclined to accuse him of the mutiny<br />
of lvan Karamazov "lvan doesn't have<br />
(a) god, he has an idea", but on<br />
f urther inspection this is proven not<br />
to be the case. Vardy's religious or<br />
spiritual vision is rather one in which<br />
the selfhood and the inherent sexuality<br />
of each individual are respected, and in<br />
which love and trust are the essential<br />
prerequisites for intimate physical<br />
relationships. This is a "positive" image<br />
of sexuality, in contrast to that which<br />
Vardy shows<br />
to have been preached during a large<br />
part of the history of (particularly<br />
Western) Christianity. The book<br />
embodies a clear vision of<br />
sexual, and indeed<br />
social, ethics in<br />
society, one that is<br />
perhaps best<br />
summarised in the<br />
book's final sentence,<br />
emphasising "the need<br />
to be gentle with<br />
ourselves and with one<br />
,<br />
t<br />
OO<br />
another as we grapple<br />
with difficult problems,<br />
and to see that the<br />
presence of genuine, deep<br />
and committed love,<br />
humility, compassion and<br />
gentleness provide the<br />
best signs of God's<br />
presence....(that may be)<br />
found in the most<br />
unexpected places."<br />
The coverage of the<br />
book is at times patchy, perhaps<br />
excusable given the enormity of its<br />
subject-matter; there is very little on<br />
the conventions of Courtly Love, and<br />
nothing on the use of medical<br />
"knowledge" to.oppress women, eg.<br />
the issue of hysteria, to give but two<br />
examples, but this is largely counterbalanced<br />
by an impressive range of<br />
reference points and footnotes, the<br />
occasional and very welcome greeting<br />
being given to mystics such as William<br />
Blake and Vladimir Soloviev. The ethos<br />
conveyed though is small-l liberal,<br />
small-c christian yet far from being<br />
secular or materialist. Despite certain<br />
shortcomings, The Puzzle of Sex<br />
largely lives up to the claims made for<br />
it-to provide what after all is an<br />
introduction to the massive realm of<br />
sexual ethics, and one that for the<br />
greater part is written in a sensitive,<br />
impression-creating fashion. @<br />
Dominic Heaney is a student at the<br />
University of St. Andrews<br />
movement 24
LITURGY SHOCK<br />
HORROR: A headline<br />
from the lr'mes recent<br />
coverage of General<br />
Synod screamed from the<br />
front page in deathless (if<br />
not breathless) prose:<br />
"New Lord's Prayer<br />
Divides the Church". So<br />
just what is this new<br />
Lord's Prayer and why<br />
has it rent the moral<br />
fabric of the nation in<br />
two? Are they ProPosing<br />
a PC "our parental units<br />
in heaven, we just<br />
stopped by to say hello"?<br />
Or offering thanks to<br />
Sophia from whom our<br />
life matrix springs?<br />
Alas, the boffins which<br />
legislate the C of E's<br />
worship were instead<br />
debating whether or not to<br />
change to a "modern"<br />
version- "modern"<br />
meaning what the rest of<br />
English speaking<br />
Christendom has used<br />
since Spandau Ballet had<br />
a number one<br />
single<br />
- which uses<br />
"save us f rom the time<br />
of trial" instead of "lead<br />
us not into temptation".<br />
I don't know what's<br />
worse: the perception<br />
that the C of E is<br />
populated by ageing<br />
fossils rejected by the<br />
local Amateur Dramatics<br />
Society and forced to<br />
vent their desire for<br />
pretty costumes and<br />
Elizabethan verse into the<br />
Church; or that it's true.<br />
THANKS FOR THE HELP:<br />
Thought For The Day's<br />
answer to Zoe Ball, Anne<br />
Atkins prefaced a<br />
typically moderate article<br />
in the Sun last summer<br />
with:"This is not oPinion;<br />
it is fact" and Proceeded<br />
to statd that a GaY Man<br />
has a life exPectancY of<br />
43 years and theY are<br />
likely to be 17 times<br />
more likely to be a<br />
Paedophile. For this<br />
breach of accuracy and<br />
journalistic imPartialitY,<br />
the Press ComPlaints<br />
Commission made them<br />
print the results of their<br />
adjudication, which the<br />
Sun dutif ully Published<br />
somewhere near the<br />
shipping forecasts.<br />
It should be<br />
something of a victorY.<br />
except the language of a<br />
Press Complaints<br />
Commission adjudication<br />
takes a lot of the joy out<br />
of it. They tend to read<br />
something like this:<br />
"Mr S Newman of<br />
London SW7 complained<br />
to the Press Complaints<br />
Commission that an<br />
article headlined "The<br />
Earth ls Flat" failed to<br />
distinguish between<br />
comment, conjecture and<br />
fact in breach of Clause 1<br />
(Accuracy) of the Code of<br />
Practice.<br />
"The complainant<br />
argued that none of the<br />
statements were fact.<br />
They suggested that the<br />
American research upon<br />
which they suspected the<br />
claims had been based on<br />
was flawed and that<br />
Euclidian geometry. the<br />
work of Copernicus and<br />
the view from the moon<br />
contradicts this.<br />
"The newspaper and<br />
the journalist stood by the<br />
story and submitted<br />
references to academic<br />
research and calculations<br />
which they said supported<br />
the claims. However. the<br />
newspaper offered a clarification<br />
which accepted that<br />
the statistics on which the<br />
journalist had based her<br />
case had been challenged<br />
and that 'although broadly<br />
accurate' her interpretations<br />
should not be<br />
regarded as absolute.<br />
"As in previous cases,<br />
the Commission was clear<br />
that claims such as this<br />
should not be presented<br />
as fact."<br />
Still awake?<br />
THE DOUBLE LIFE OF AN<br />
EASTENDERS PRIEST<br />
Never mind Joe Wicks,<br />
the latest schizoPhrenic<br />
to hit Albert Square is<br />
Alex the Vicar. Since his<br />
introduction a year ago,<br />
Alex has the most bizarre<br />
personality switches<br />
depending on the needs<br />
of a plot.<br />
One minute he's<br />
everybody's right-on<br />
priest, straightening out<br />
Sarah Hills, taking on lan<br />
Beale and getting a<br />
Hospice built for ex-cons<br />
built in Walford. The next<br />
he's all conventional and<br />
card igan-wearing.<br />
Especially when it comes<br />
to sex.<br />
With his brief relationship<br />
with Kathy, it looked<br />
as though he was trying<br />
out for Richard<br />
Chamberlain's role in<br />
The Thorn Birds. One<br />
night of passion and<br />
soon there's so much<br />
angst and misery I<br />
thought I was watching<br />
Brookie instead.<br />
I have no idea what<br />
the BBC think Clergy do<br />
on their nights off -read<br />
Thackeray to invalids,<br />
perhaps-but it brings up<br />
an important point. I dare<br />
anyone to identify one<br />
person of the cloth on<br />
telly who does not seem<br />
like a nineteenth century<br />
stereotype when it comes<br />
to sex. Let's face it.<br />
someone needs to tell the<br />
television writers of<br />
Britain that being a goodie<br />
doesn't preclude doing<br />
the nasty now and then.<br />
THE TWIN DILEMMA:<br />
Everyone must have<br />
wondered at some time in<br />
their life if they have a<br />
doppelgdnger, a twin who<br />
has taken all the<br />
divergent paths we never<br />
took. For example, I feel<br />
certain that there's a<br />
reptillian counterpart to<br />
myself, far better<br />
adjusted, listening to<br />
Graham Kendrick and<br />
dealing in pithy aphorisms<br />
on Thought For The Day.<br />
Apparently, our mate<br />
Jesus has a twin brother,<br />
with the convenient<br />
moniker "Christ Didymus<br />
Thomas". Didymus has<br />
announced his twin<br />
divinity via e-mail to all<br />
and sundry.<br />
Didy's apologia takes<br />
up a good 1O pages chock<br />
full of Biblical proof-texts<br />
such as "Daniel<br />
12:5-then I Daniel<br />
looked, and behold, there<br />
stood other two, the one<br />
on this side of the bank of<br />
the river, and the other on<br />
that side of the bank of<br />
the river (TWO CHRIST<br />
FIGURES) I AM THE TWIN<br />
BROTHER OF JESUS."<br />
This somehow escaped<br />
my notice the first time I<br />
read it in the Bible, I must<br />
confess-perhaps I should<br />
check the original Hebrew.<br />
It would seem Didy is<br />
not like his brother, who<br />
opted for the rather<br />
impractical stance of<br />
loving one's neighbour.<br />
Didymus is something of<br />
a hardliner; Catholics in<br />
particular take up much<br />
of his ire. And while his<br />
brother had something of<br />
a knack for the odd<br />
parable or metaphor, Didy<br />
tends to be a bit more<br />
brusque in his use of<br />
language, utilising<br />
evocative turns of phrase<br />
such as "The Pope<br />
wanders the earth claiming<br />
to speak for God. Yet he is<br />
a beast child of Satan"<br />
He concludes, as so<br />
many of these people do,<br />
in upper case: "AS MY<br />
FATHER PROMISED I AM<br />
HERE TO ESTABLISH HIS<br />
KINGDOM, ALL THE<br />
WORLD WILL KNOW ME<br />
BY MY WORKS."<br />
Keep taking the tablets,<br />
Didymus.<br />
TIE ME ARCHBISHOP OF<br />
CANTERBURY DOWN.<br />
SPORT George Carey has<br />
become the softest<br />
target in religion today.<br />
Long time readers will<br />
know that I have on<br />
various occasion accused<br />
Georgie boy-last heard<br />
giving a Christmas sermon<br />
over the Tannoys at ASDA<br />
last December-of being<br />
out of touch and<br />
something of a quack.<br />
Well, tell me what l'm<br />
supposed to do when the<br />
Primate of all England<br />
says he's a bit like Rolf<br />
Harris, as he was quoted<br />
in the newspapers last<br />
month ?<br />
I'm still practicising<br />
self-restraint even now.<br />
THE SERPENT
"It's impolite to talk<br />
about religion artd<br />
politics. ))<br />
Wedo<br />
o<br />
SCM gives you a place explore faith and spirituality in an open-minded<br />
environment. Which means we don't give a toss whether it's polite or not<br />
to talk about something. SCM can allow you share insights, work for<br />
change and make friends. If you're interested by the contents of this<br />
magazine and SCM intrigues you, fill in the coupon below!<br />
't<br />
would like to join SCM (including a subscription to movemen}<br />
Name<br />
Term Time Address<br />
Permanent Address<br />
I enclose a cheque lto 'scM'l ror n 810 Istudentsl<br />
L<br />
n er5 tnon-studentsl<br />
J<br />
RETURN TO: SCM, WESTHILL COLLEGE, 14116 WEOLEY PARK ROAD,<br />
OAK, BIRMINGHAM B29 6LL