31.01.2021 Views

AAP Smal Scale Decent Change

AAP 2019-2020 Research Book: "Small Scale Decent Change"

AAP 2019-2020 Research Book: "Small Scale Decent Change"

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

AAP

RESEARCH

2019-2020

Small Scale Decent Change

A L T E R N A T I V E A R C H I T E C T U R A L P R A C T I C E S

M E F U N I V E R S I T Y G R A D U A T E P R O G R A M M E



FOREWORD

We have entered a period where there are strong signs of a radical change in the modes of

practicing architecture and also in the teaching of architecture. Architects of the future are

expected to be working more with the public interest in mind; collaborative practices within

the field and across various fields will be common; teamwork at every stage will be regular;

they will be developing projects where research and design processes are intertwined; they

will be practicing in a more pro-active environment. Within this perspective, we believe that

the main goal of architectural education particularly in the graduate level will be completely

transformed towards giving young professionals the experience of alternative architectural

practices. Only through such an education, the graduates can be empowered to discover

and craft our common future.

Through this perspective and philosophy, we are hoping that ‘Alternative Architectural

Practices’ program will contribute towards the discovery of new professional paths with

its design, research and production-based focus. Our students will be part of a real

design research process through the projects developed with our program partners from

the industry. Beyond these ‘real-world’ research-by-design projects our students will take

supportive courses leading to a rigorous graduate program.

The program consists of four semesters; however, its structure is slightly different from

other conventional graduate programs of architecture in Turkey. In the first two semesters

the students take their required courses and also the studio sequence. Student also start

developing their thesis during their second semester. In the following summer, the studio

will move to prototyping and implementation stage. Finally, in their last semester students

focus on their thesis and complete the program.

Prof. Dr. Arda Inceoglu, Dean, MEF FADA


SMALL SCALE DECENT CHANGE

An architecture soothsayer at the beginning of the twentieth century would not foresee

that architects will have to find new ways to survive as the practice itself is eaten by global

networks that once carried the architects on top of the ivory tower. Today, ideas that came

out as utopias at the beginning of the last century have to be revisited as remedies for the

ongoing global crisis. Who would imagine that small scale will offer a way out for architects

and societies, after a century full of colossal architecture?

When MoMA hosted an exhibition of architectural projects which aim to have a broad effect

on the communities they work, titled as ‘Small Scale Big Change’ in 2010, it announced

a radical break in the architecture. In 2016, the most prestigious event of architectural

world Venice Architecture Biennale, titled as ‘Reporting from the Front’, was occupied by

modest and clever projects from all over the world, that are socially engaged with the

community they belong. However, these were just the precursors of the closing of an era,

since they still used the language of the previous period that expected an unrealistic “big

change” from small projects which were fighting in the front. For the next decades, it will

get even more complex to propose architectural solutions for a society that is facing cutting

edge technological advances at one side, while on the other side being threatened by the

ongoing global economic crisis and diminishing resources. While architects will have to be

inventing alternative ways to deal with this contradictory situation, it is more realistic and

truthful to expect a decent change from small scale projects.

In MEF University’s Alternative Architectural Practices program, we develop methods for

imagining and building new paths to discover small scale architecture. In partnership with

companies from the construction industry of Istanbul, the program aims to use the potential

of the industry that has long been engaged with the global real estate market, as a tool to

design and make new architectures/structures for the emerging conditions of our world.

Sevince Bayrak, Program Co-coordinator, MEF FADA


System Kiosk K67, 1967, Saša J. Mächtig


RESEARCH I DESIGN GUIDE

AAP TEAM

Students: Ahmet Yaymanoğlu, Aysima Akın, Damla Kaleli, Dilek Yürük, Ebru Şahinkaya,

Eda Yavaş, İlayda Baydemir, Nur Gülgör, Sena Hut, Zeynep Ulusoy

Studio Instructor: Oral Göktaş

Program Coordinators: Kürşad Özdemir, Sevince Bayrak

Program Partners: Fibrobeton, Metal Yapı

2019 - 2020

MEF University Graduate Programme


CONTENTS

INTRODUCTION

5

HISTORY

STRUCTURAL DURABILITY

TECHNOLOGY

ECOLOGY

ERGONOMICS

6-65

66-119

120-171

172-219

230-287

DISCUSSIONS

288-343

BIBLIOGRAPHY

344-356



INTRODUCTION

“Human housing is a matter of mass demand. Just as it no longer occurs to 90 percent

of the population to have shoes made to measure but rather buy ready-made products

that satisfy most individual requirements thanks to refined manufacturing methods. In the

future the individual will be able to order from the warehouse the housing that is right for

him. It is possible that present-day building industry is still almost completely dependent

on traditional, crafts manly construction methods.” – Walter Gropius, Wohnhaus-Industrie,

1923

In the last 100 years, although the recent developments have widened the boundaries

of architecture and the ways of performing architecture, it still is mostly dependent on

traditional construction methods and it still looks for refined technologies to achieve readymade

housing with minimum impact on the environment. Furthermore, the majority of the

materials, including green technologies, still depend on non-renewable sources, which

creates the problem of energy scarcity. Construction, production processes, transportation,

and many other services are still heavily dependent on oil. This relates to the repeating

economic crisis as well as the reason for wars, where the governments fight to win with

the latest technology, but all other alive creatures constantly suffer. In this continuous loop,

there is something seriously unsustainable that is the perception of the earth we live on,

there is a common ignorance of accepting that it is a living organism with every single piece

of it.

In this mindset, we are searching for alternative paths. Our inquiry includes different

aspects of design. Socioeconomic problems such as upcoming economic crisis or

tense interactions between countries again for petroleum, structural durability problem

with the increasing rarity of natural disasters, catastrophic climate change consequences

that we are already facing, shaping characteristics of technology in architecture and lastly

updated requirements of living space have been among our main interests. To sum up, we

have compiled research based on all these conditions and problems. This semester, the

research has been examined through five topics; history, durability, technology, ecology,

and ergonomics. In MEF University’s Alternative Architectural Practices program, we

develop methods for imagining and building new paths to discover small scale architecture.

9


HISTORY

Over 200 years, the dwelling unit has

been transformed in many ways due to

changing human needs. Key historical

events, including disasters, housing

crisis, labour problems, and future

scenarios; provide the explanatory

information of these fundamental

requirements of shelter. Potential

solutions for the housing problem

strongly connect with the economy,

technology, and culture, which also

depends on local and global diversity.

Key features of a shelter rely on it being

easy-to-construct, affordable, portable

and deliverable.

Strandlund in front of packaged house [1]


GLOBAL TIMELINE

Thresholds

Innovations

Shelters

Culture

Acts and Events

Economy

LOCAL TIMELINE

Thresholds

Laws

Dwellings

Culture

Social Life

Economy

11


HISTORY

1624

A. THRESHOLDS

Wood shortage was occurred as a result

of deforestation crisis.

1700

The French Revolution has started in

1789 and ended in 1790s. It has played a

critical role in shaping the modern nations

by showing the power of people.

Melbourne established on the Yarra

River after an abortive bid in 1803.

1789 1835 1861

American Civil War (1861-1865) took

place between United States and 7 South

States that wanted to keep slavery. The

war ended the institution of slavery with

United States victory.

B. INNOVATIONS

1800

Voltaic pile was

the world’s first

battery. Volta was

able to prove this by

constructing a stack

of alternating zinc

and silver plates

with a piece of cloth

soaked in a salt

solution between

the individual

plates.

Jacquard has

developed

numerical control

system.

“Balloon

Frame”

Augustine

Taylor

St. Mary

Church

Chicago

1801 1833 1845

Thompson has invented PNEUMATİC

“rubber tire”

First Panellized Wood House: Shipped

from England Massachusetts as housing.

Haus des Gaertners Chaux Projekt:

Designed by Étienne-Louis Boullée

(1728-1799) and Claude-Nicolas Ledoux

(1736-1806)

“Manning Portable Colonial Cottage”

designed for immigrants by H.Manning.

American Prefabs

build in Noctorn Farm Near Uitenhage,

first documented prefabricated house.

C. SHELTERS

1624

1806

1833

1844

D. CULTURE

Lambot Reinforced Concrete Canoe

Joseph Louis Lambot

1848

1851

Harriet Stowe’s

best-selling novel

“Uncle Tom’s

Cabin” helped

popularize the anti

slavery movement.

Her novel followed

the life of black

slave Uncle Tom,

and was the second

best-selling book

of the 19th century

after the Bible.

1854

“Life

in the

Woods”

(Book)

Henry

David

Thoreau

1861

Mrs. Beeton’s

Book of

Household

Management

E. ACTS AND EVENTS

The Royal Institute of British

Architects (RIBA) was founded.

1837

Royal Commission Report was

published

Commission

reported the

condition of the

buildings in the

Great Britain cities.

They analysed poor

condition of housing

qualities and next

several years,

published emergent

public acts for

restoration.

1845

London first World Exhibition

World expositions were especially

centred on industry, and were fabled for

the show of breakthroughs and scientific

developments.

1851

Central Park Competition

The competition to design Central Park

in New York is won by Frederick Law

Olmsted and Calvert Vaux.

1858

F. ECONOMY

The Industrial Revolution was a

major turning point in history which was

marked by a shift in the world from an

agrarian and handicraft economy to one

dominated by industry and machine

manufacturing.

1760

Fourier’s phalanstere was a kind of

people’s palace, a housing complex for

1,620 residents with a plan echoing that

of Palace of Versailles.

1800s

In 1858 Andre Godin purchased 45

acres of land next to his factory and

personally designed a phalanstery,

calling it ‘‘Familiestere’’.

1858

The Second Industrial Revolution:

New innovations in steel production,

petroleum and electricity led to the

introduction of public automobiles and

airplanes. In this lesson, learn about

the key inventions that spurred this

revolution.

1870s

12


1912

Standard Oil Company John D.

Rockefeller formed Standard Oil

Company. By 1879, the company not

only 90% of America’s refining capacity.

1865 1882 1896 1900

Hippomobile, first petroleum engine by

Jean J. Lenoir

Edison’s first Electric Station

established.

Edison’s Cinema established

Invention of Radio: Guglielmo Marconi,

often receives credit based on his

device capable of ringing a bell from

9m away. On the other hand, Nikola

Tesla, an immigrant to the United

States, demonstrated a wireless radio to

audiences in St. Louis the year before

Marconi’s demonstration. Although

Tesla came first, Marconi patented his

invention in 1896 while Tesla patented

his in 1900. One year later, Marconi

transmitted the first signal to cross the

Atlantic from Europe to America.

Mushroom Slabs

The first wood wool insulating product

was made in 1908 by the Heraklith

Company in Ferndorf (Austria) using

magnesite and cement as an adhesive.

Nevertheless the first products had

several disadvantages (flammability, poor

dimensional stability) however wood wool

insulation soon spread worldwide.

Galveston Hurricane

Duralumin: an aluminium alloy -lightweight

and tough- containing 4% copper

would slowly harden when left at room

temperature for several days. Uses on

production of planes.

RESEARCH

1863

1893 1908

1909

Portable

Summer House

N.G. Rood

By the turn of the

twentieth century,

architects and

inventors had

developed

prefabricated

houses of nearly

every material to

patent.

Single Poor Concrete System designed

and patented by Thomas Edison

Sears Catalog Homes

the company sold over 100,000 homes

through their “Modern Hornes” mail-order

catalogue. House No. 146 went on sale

for 1.660 dollars

American

System

Built

Houses

Designed by

F.Lloyd

Wright, which

is never

built.

1882

1906-1919

1908-1940

1911-1917

1889

“The Seven

Lamps of

Architecture”

John Ruskin

1902

A Trip to

the Moon:

The movie

was created

by Georges

Méliès. The

scene of the

space capsule

landing in the

Moon’s eye is

one of the most

iconic images

in the history of

cinema.

1908

The Melting

Pot:

With this play,it

was used as

a metaphor

for defining

the fusion

of cultures

and ethnic

origins, and

then it became

popular in the

United States.

1911

Erector

Set

A.C.

Gilbert

mass

produced

toy kit

Paris World

Exhibition

The main

symbol of

the Fair was

the Eiffel

Tower,

which

served as

the entrance

arch to the

Fair.

“The

garden city

movement”

is a method of

urban planning

in which

self-contained

communities

are surrounded

by “greenbelts”

‘Ein Dokument deutscher Kunst’

(Darmstadt)

It was the first architecture exhibition

that entirely consisted of homes and

buildings, which themselves formed the

objects that were on display.

Ornament and

Crime was

published

Ornament and

Crime is an

essay and lecture

by modernist

architect

Adolf Loos

that criticizes

ornament in

useful objects.

1889

1898

1901

1908

1873 Economic Crisis known as ‘‘Long

Depression’’ happened. In general,

the crisis occurred as the producers in

the market increased the production in

contrast to the demand and then the

shortage of cash in the market hit the

stock market. Losses occurred and many

companies went bankrupt.

Ansonia

Apartment

Hotel (1904)

in NYC: The

Ansonia

(far advanced

for his time)

was to have a

self-sufficient

building

with its own

rooftop farm.

Ford Model T: A significant step of mass

production

Altena Castle, Germany: The first

hostel was purposed to allow young

people with lower income who were

living in the cities to stay in the hostel.

1873

1904

1908-1927

1912

13


HISTORY

F.1760 Industrial Revolution

The Industrial Revolution was one of the most

important points of the world’s history that changing

from a handicraft economy to machine dominated

manufacturing. The revolution brought greater

volume production and factory-produced products

and also raised people’s living standards which are

particularly middle and upper classes. However, for

the proletariat and poor class, life was so challenging.

With industrialization, some artisanal activities were

replaced by mechanization. Furthermore, the urban

and industrialized areas were not kept pace with

the migrating people from rural areas, therefore it

caused urban areas to transform into inadequate,

overcrowded, unhealthy spaces. While governments

introduced numerous labour reforms and the

workers gained the right to form trade unions,

conditions of working-class have improved. The

negative and positive developments of the Industrial

Revolution that changed the world can be listed in

10 items: The factory system, rise of capitalism,

urbanization,exploitation of the working class,

opportunity and increase in the standard of living,

rise of materialism and consumerism, technological

advancement, rise of socialism and Marxism, transfer

of wealth and power to the west, pollution and

destruction of environment.[2]

Image 1: Industrial Revolution [2]

B.1833 Balloon Frame System

“The balloon frame method of wood construction is arguably

the first incarnation of prefabricated construction system since it

regularized the production of houses into a palette of ready-made

units that could be assembled in fast and affordable configurations.

The balloon frame is often considered one of the first thoroughly

American forms of serial architectural production. It abandoned all

lingering traces of European influence, celebrated the abundance

of timber in the United States, and abandoned more expensive and

labour-intensive materials that were not readily available in North

America. Wood construction methods transposed to the United

States from Europe had been characterized by elaborate joineries

requiring skilled craftsmen largely unavailable in the New World.

The method is primarily attributed to the Chicago builder Augustine

Taylor, who developed the system in response to the city’s housing

shortage. The system eliminated mortised beams and fittings,

replacing them with two-by-fours and two-by-sixes set close

to one another in increments of approximately one foot spaced

horizontally. Studs and cross members were inserted in various

configurations and could be increased or decreased in number

depending on the anticipated structural integrity needed for the

project. Wooden sheathing would subsequently be placed over

the frame. Most importantly, the members were held together with

manufactured cut iron nails, similar to today’s common steel nail.

These allowed for the connection of wooden members with the

greater ease and efficiency over crafted joineries. The entire wall unit

could be delivered to a site and simply tilted upright, allowing house

construction to occur in a matter of days.” [3]

Image 2: Balloon Frame System [3]

14


E.1851 London First World Exhibition

In 1851, the Great Exhibition was held in the

Crystal Palace, London which was made from

steel and glass. From May to October during

5 months, 6 million people around the world

came to visit the exhibition. The flashy display

of artworks, inventions, gathering objects from

distant lands became the pioneer of the Great

Exhibition. Actually, some of the newspapers

have mentioned that as such. Furthermore, it

had a specific mission: Britain’s rulers had tried

to show that the technology transforms the

society and Britain was leading on the race. The

Crystal Palace was filled with surprising objects

but perhaps the most amazing things were the

gigantic exhibition halls which were integrated

with the new technology. Crowds visited to see

the glowing steam engines, which would be

used in ships and factories. [4]

Image 3: The State Opening of The Great Exhibition in 1851, colour lithograph by Louis Haghe [4]

RESEARCH

D.1854 Life in the Woods - Henry D. Thoreau

‘‘Walden (also known as Walden; or, Life in the Woods) by Henry

David Thoreau is one of the best-known non-fiction books written by

an American. Published in 1854, it details Thoreau’s life for two years,

two months, and two days in second-growth forest around the shores

of Walden Pond, on land owned by Ralph Waldo Emerson, not far

from his friends and family in Concord, Massachusetts. Walden was

written so that the stay appears to be a year, with expressed seasonal

divisions. Thoreau called it an experiment in simple living. Thoreau

lived in close geographical proximity to the town Concord: “living a

mile from any neighbour,” should be taken literally; he lived about a

mile from his neighbours. He did not go into the woods to become

a hermit, but to isolate himself from civil society in order to gain a

more objective understanding of it. Walden is neither a novel nor a

true autobiography, but a social critique of much of the contemporary

Western World, with its consumerist attitudes and its distance from

and destruction of nature.’’ [5]

Image 4: Life In Woods- Walden [6]

15


HISTORY

F.1858 Familiestere

Jean Baptiste Andre Godin was an industrialist who

had been managed a highly profitable factory that

produced ovens and stoves in Guise. In the 1840s

he joined the phalansteries as a philanthropist. In

1853, after uprising against Napoleon III, he invested

100,000 francs to the United States and then had

moved to there. Godin wanted to found a phalanstery

called “Le Reunion” near Dallas, Texas. That project

was failed. Because the enlisted colonists knew

nothing about agriculture and the soil was too bad.

And also a locust infestation destroyed most of the

crops, therefore after just a year, the colony has

dissolved. In 1858, Godin bought 45 acres of land to

design his phalanstery called “Familiestere” where was

next to his factory. Familistere, which was invented by

Godin, contained glass-covered courtyards and water

on each level, a laundry shop, a huge pool that could

also be used by children, and a garbage chute. The

cleaning service was to relieve women of households.

Also, the day nursery was to provide an opportunity

for them to work. Residents could get service for

their basic health care with 2,5 francs per month, and

also get drugs for free. There was a cooperative and

communal kitchen that residents could buy groceries

for a reasonable price. Thus Godin tried to set up an

economic model to circumvent the intermediaries

system that provides fruit, vegetables, meat, and

bread in return money. [7]

Image 5: Familistere Photo by: Stephane Chalmeau [8]

C.1906-1919 Single Pour Concrete System

Edison is one of the pioneer designers who thought it is

possible to build an entire building with just using a single

material repeatedly without do not need second material.

By this time Edison had established his reputation as a patent

leader holder in the United States, so his approach to the

construction of a house of repetitive objects is not surprising.

As a result, Edison designed a system that he would later call

“Single Pour Concrete System” in which a series of balloon

frame molds will be brought to the site and a mold system

will be installed that creates surfaces except for window and

door spaces. This scheme has illustrated in Edison’s official

patent drawing presentation perfectly. A specially designed

cylindrical rotating kiln on its wheels and a hydraulic vertical

pump system would be brought to the construction site when

the mould was finished. And then the vehicle would be pouring

the wet concrete mixture from the hole at the top of mould

and the mixture would settle to the bottom slowly. Edison

first experienced that process on a model, which known as

“chicken coop”, in his studio. Edison built about 100 houses

in and around Union, New Jersey with the funds of wealthy

manufacturer Charles Ingersoli from New Jersey.[9]

Image 6: Single Pour Concrete System [9]

Figure 1: Single Pour Concrete System, Process Detail [9]

16


F.1908 Ford Model T

Model T is an automobile that had

been produced by Ford Motor

Company from 1908 until 1927. It

was an affordable, durable, multifunctional

and easy to maintain

transportation vehicle for an ordinary

man which was designed by Henry

Ford. Model Ts had been produced

more than 15 million in Detroit and

Highland Park, Mich. Assemblyline

production allowed the cost to

decrease from $ 850 in 1908 to less

than $ 300 in 1925. At these prices,

the Model T had been 40 percent

cheaper than all models sold in the

United States. Even before it lost its

popularity against larger, powerful and

luxury cars, the Model T, popularly

known as “Tin Lizzie” or “Flivver”,

had been an icon that helped Ford

achieve its goal of democratizing the

car. [10]

Image 7: Ford Model T

Courtesy of the Ford Motor Company [10]

RESEARCH

B.1909 Duralumin

A German metallurgist, Alfred Wilm, has developed

an alloy in 1903 that including 4 percent aluminium.

Wilm discovered that the aluminium alloy would

slowly harden when it stays for several days at room

temperature. Further improvements have allowed the

appearance of “Duralumin” in 1909. That name, which

commonly used in popular science to describe the

“2000” series or Al-Cu system, was determined by the

International Alloy Designation System (IADS) in 1970.

Duralumin’s composition and its heat treatment have

published before World War I in the German scientific

literature. Even that, Duralumin had not gone beyond

Germany during World War I. German reports of use

during World War I, even in technical magazines like

Flight, could misidentify the main alloy component as

magnesium instead of copper. [11]

Image 8: The first mass-production aircraft to make

extensive use of duralumin, the armoured Junkers J.I

sesquiplane of WW I. [11]

17


HISTORY

1913

A. THRESHOLDS

World War I: The war resulted in

the death of empires and the birth of

nations, and in national boundaries being

redrawn around the world. It ushered in

prosperity for some countries, while it

brought economic depression to others.

1914-1918

Wiemer Republic is established: It was

Germany’s government from 1919 to

1933, the period after World War I until

the rise of Nazi Germany.

1919-1933

1923

Towards a New

Architecture –

Le Corbusier:

In this book

Le Corbusier

advocating for

and exploring

the concept

of modern

architecture.

Louis carried Charles Lindbergh from

New York to Paris in 33 and a half hours,

the first nonstop flight across the

Atlantic Ocean. As Charles Lindbergh

piloted the Spirit of St. Louis down the

dirt runway of Roosevelt Field in New

York on May 20, 1927.

1927

B. INNOVATIONS

1921

American

Celotex

Company

introduced

first

insulating

panels made

of bagasse

(a waste by

product of

sugar.)

Portable baby cage-Emma Read

London mothers and nannies, who did

not have an open area or garden to

leave their children comfortably, used

the baby cage hanging outside an open

window of the apartment.

1923

First PVC “polyvinyl chloride”

Waldo Semon

1927

“Desert Ship” (Wüstenschiff)

German engineer Johann Christoph

Bischoff

1927

American Army Shelter Experiment

was done for the need of shelter during

World War I.

Baukasten Walter Gropius, Adolf Mayer

would develop a system of standard,

industrially produced building elements.

Metal Prototype House,

Törten Muche and Richard Paulick

designed steel building in Dessau.

Dymaxion House designed by

Buckminster Fuller in principle of

good house could be produced as

systematically as a good car.

C. SHELTERS

1919

1923

1926

1927

D. CULTURE

1920

One Week

A newly

wedded couple

attempts

to build a

house with a

prefabricated

kit, unaware

that a rival

sabotaged the

kit’s component

numbering.

1922

Crocodile

Magazine

It was the

Soviet

Union’s most

famous and

longestrunning

illustrated

satirical

magazine.

1927

Metropolis is

a futuristic,

urban-style film

that shows a

future where

the city is

structured in

vertical layers

according to

the different

social strata.

Woman in the Moon

Fritz Lange

1929

E. ACTS AND EVENTS

The Irish Home Rule

Movement that campaigned for

self-government for Ireland within the

United Kingdom of Great Britain and

Ireland. After Parnell’s death, Gladstone

introduced the Second Home Rule Bill

in 1893.

1914

1923

Bauhaus

Exhibition in

Weimar

The exhibition

poster was

designed by

Joost Schmidt

a talented

sculpture student

who went on

to become

a Bauhaus

teacher.

CIAM established, responsible for

events and congresses arranged

across Europe by the most prominent

architects of the time, with the objective

of spreading the principles of the Modern

Movement.

1928

Le Corbusier Foundation

1928

The Foundation

in accordance

with its statutes

and its missions,

has devoted all of

its resources to

the conservation,

knowledge and

dissemination of Le

Corbusier’s work.

F. ECONOMY

Berlin Modernism Housing Estates

1913-1934

The public relations campaign “Own

Your Own Home” was launched by

the National Association of Real Estate

Boards. It was taken over by the U.S.

Department of Labour in 1917, becoming

the first federal program designed

to encourage home ownership. The

program was largely promotional; there

were no financial incentives offered to

prospective home buyers or builders.

1917

Co-op Zimmer: The minimum dwelling

by Hannes Mayer

1926

Narkomfin Building: The project for

four planned buildings was designed

by Moisei Ginzburg with Ignaty Milinis

in 1928.

1928

18


1945

World War II: The vast majority of the

world’s countries- including all the great

powers- eventually formed two opposing

military alliances: the Allies and the Axis.

A state of total war emerged, directly

involving more than 100 million people

from more than 30 countries.

IKEA is founded by Ingvar Kamprad:

IKEA is a European multinational group

that designs and sells ready-to-assemble

furniture, kitchen appliances and home

accessories, among other useful goods

and occasionally home services.

The United States detonate Atomic

bombings of Hiroshima and

Nagasaki: Bombings played a role in

the establishment of nation architecture

and the emergence of architectural

Metabolism movement as they

caused house shortages and lack of

infrastructure problems.

The Great Strike Wave were the

largest strikes in American labour

history: It was a series of massive

post-war labour strikes from 1945 to

1946 spanning numerous industries and

public utilities.

1939-1945

Wallace

Carothers

was an

American

chemist,

inventor

and credited

with the

invention of

nylon.

1943

“On Computable

Numbers”

Alan Turing

has set out

the theoretical

basis

for modern

computers.

1945

Water

Uncycle

patented

1945-1946

Superglue: While searching for materials

to make clear plastic gun sights,

Coover and his team at Eastman Kodak

examined cyanoacrylates, a material

that was used during both World Wars

(1914-1918; 1939-1945) as an alternative

to stitches on large cuts and wounds,

rejecting them as too sticky.

RESEARCH

1935

1936

1939

1942

Keck Crystal House (1933-1934)

designed and all built at full scale by

George Fred Keck.

Usonian House

Frank Lloyd Wright design for his friends

as affordable housing which cost $5,500

after citing the project.

Packaged

House

(1941-1952)

designed by

Konrad

Wachsmann

Walter

Gropius as

wood-frame

panellized

houses.

Demountable House (1944) a 6 meter

by 6 meter dimension prefabricated

house designed by Jean Prouve.

1933-1934

1936

1941-1952

1944

House of

Wheels has

all Home

Comforts

Popular

Science

1931

July

Issue

Lego

Modern Times

Charles

Chaplin

‘‘The

Fountainhead’’

Ayn Rand

Story of Howard

Roark, a brilliant

architect who

dares to stand

alone against

the hostility of

second-hand

souls.

1931

1932

1936

1943

Stockholm Exhibition

It was an

exhibition that had

a great impact on

the architectural

styles known as

Functionalism

and International

Style.

First Congress

of Soviet

Architects

Nine Chains

to the Moon,

was published

by Buckminster

Fuller.

The book

presents Fuller’s

overview of

technological

history.

New York World Fair

It was the first

exposition to be

based on the

future, with an

opening slogan

of “Dawn of

a New Day”,

and it allowed

all visitors to

take a look at

“the world of

tomorrow”.

1930

1937

1938

1939

Great Depression, worldwide economic

downturn that began in 1929 and lasted

until about 1939. It was the longest and

most severe depression ever experienced

by the industrialized Western world,

sparking fundamental changes in

economic institutions, macroeconomic

policy, and economic theory. Although it

originated in the United States, the Great

Depression caused drastic declines in

output, severe unemployment, and acute

deflation in almost every country of the

world.

Roosevelt’s

New Deal:

The New Deal

was a series

of programs,

public work

projects,

financial

reforms, and

regulations.

Bretton Woods Conference officially

known as the United Nations Monetary

and Financial Conference, was a

gathering of delegates from 44 nations

The Case Study House Program

were experiments in American

residential architecture sponsored by

Arts & Architecture magazine, which

commissioned major architects of the

day.

1929-1939

1933

1944

1945

19


HISTORY

B.1923 Portable Baby Cage Emma Read

This cage, known as the “baby cage” fora babies living

in crowded cities and apartments, It was discovered

by Robert C Lafferty. This cage, whose purpose is

to ensure that babies can benefit from daylight and

fresh air in crowded cities, is also known as the “health

cage”. In her autobiography, Eleanor Roosevelt wrote

that, due to the importance of fresh air, during the

morning nap, she left her daughter to breathe in a box

with wires in front of her rear windows, on the top and

sides. Although the cages with the same design differ

in material, they were actually fora the same purpose.

While the cages prevented the child from falling, they

were also in such a way that they could get sunlight

and fresh air. Some cages had a roof that could

protect children from snow, rain and things that could

fall from above. [12]

Image 9: Portable Baby Cage [13]

B.1927 Desert Ship

In 1927, Johann Christoph Bischoff , a

German engineer, designed a vehicle

which he called as a desert ship to

cross deserts. It has 60 meters length

with 300 passengers capacity. The

vehicle, with 15 meters of gigantic

wheels, consisted of 4 floors. It had

2 diesel engines and was designed

entirely of metal. According to a news

article from back in the day he even

went as far as filing patents in all

countries with colonial holdings. [14]

Image 10: Desert Ship [14]

20


D.1927 Metropolis

“Metropolis”, a futuristic, urban style movie that shows the future in

which the city is structured with vertical layers according to different

social layers, is one of the classics of director Fritz Lang. In the film,

which is the current state of many cities today, in a dystopian vision

of the future, the bustling Metropolis city lives in high-rise buildings

stretching to the sky, while the working classes are structured to live

and work under the ground. Although Metropolis architecture shows

a general purpose of creating a single and powerful city that radiates

power and wealth, conflict is inevitable. The architecture in this film

emphasizes the power of the city, while at the same time shaping the

values that are constantly evolving and make room fora larger events.

While the film emphasizes a city sensitive to human interests. Also film

clearly demonstrates the mediating role of architecture in ideologies,

the conflicts that lead to cultural pluralism, as well as social unity. [15]

RESEARCH

Image 11: Metropolis [16]

F.1933 Roosevelt’s New Deal

New Agreement of Roosevelt (1933) that made America the way it is

today. The New Deal, which included a series of regulations, aimed to

make America a more consumer-friendly nation. The New Deal was

designed to encourage consumer spending and promote economic

growth. At the same time, the financial industries and banking will face

further scrutiny and regulation.

Home Owners’ Loan Corporation (HOLC), It was founded in 1933 by

the former U.S. Government Agency to ensure the stability of depreciated

real estate during depression and refinance urban mortgage debt. Longterm

mortgage loans were granted to approximately 1 million landlords

who lost property. HOLC discontinued lending activities in June 1936

under the Landlords’ Loan Act. [17]

The Federal Housing Administration (FHA), being an U.S. Government

Agency, was partly created by the National Housing Act of 1934 and was

founded by President Franklin Roosevelt. The purpose of this organization

is to improve housing standards and conditions, to provide an adequate

home financing system through the insurance of mortgage loans and to

stabilize the mortgage market. FHA, sets the standards fora construction

and contracting and insures loans fora banks and other private lenders

fora housing construction. [18]

The National Housing Act, signed on 27 June 1934 by President

Franklin D. Roosevelt to reduce the rate of lien, improve housing

conditions, and make housing and mortgages more accessible and

affordable during the Great Depression. The law was also part of the New

Deal. [19]

The United States Housing Authority, It is a federal agency designed to

lend to states or communities for low cost construction, created in 1937

by the Housing Act of 1937 as part of the New Agreement within the

United States Department of Internal Affairs. [20]

Image 12: New Deal Poster Social Security poster of a woman leaning

on a fence post. [21]

21


HISTORY

E.1939 New York World Fair

Planners were allowed to develop 1,200 acres

in an old ash dump site in Queens for the World

fair, the theme of “World of Tomorrow”, held in

New York in 1939 at the peak of depression.

Government agencies, companies, civil groups

and smaller organizations from around the world

have come in large numbers, built extraordinary

pavilions and set up exhibitions. Iconic Trylon

and Perisphere structures became the symbol

of the whole fair; they hosted a diorama called

“Democracy” in the future utopian city. During

the two seasons, 44 million people attended

the fair, browsing a possible future, and enjoyed

the puppet shows and exciting journeys, girlie

shows, and the fun of choreographed aquatic

extravaganza. [22]

Image 13: New York World Fair Arlene Warner, “queen of beauty” of Elgin, Illinois, presides at the opening

ceremonies of the Elgin Time Observatory at the New York World’s Fair on May 10, 1938. She is unveiling

a heroic figure of “Time,” represented as a slave striking a gong sculptured by Bernard J. Rosenthal of

Chicago [22]

C.1941-1952 Packaged House

Packaged House of Konrad l Wachsmann

and Walter Gropius, Instead of representing

a revolution in prefabrication, it represents

the pinnacle of timber-framed, panelled

houses, which were quite common on both

sides of the Atlantic until 1942. The system

did not have ideal editing models. Instead,

he developed a palette of ten different

types, consisting of approximately 100 cm x

300 cm panels placed on 100 cm threedimensional

space frame panels that make

up all horizontal and vertical surfaces. The

panel system in general did not have enough

specificity to win the patent that Gropius

sought. In fact, they are X-shaped wedge

connectors that connect each panel against

a series of metal plates placed on the edge

of the panel, which proves to be innovative.

The essentially flat wedge has replaced the

standard Y-shaped connector due to its

three dimensions, making it more difficult and

easier to manufacture. [23]

Figure 2: Packaged House Drawing [23]

22


A.1943 IKEA

IKEA, a European multinational group, is a home design

service that designs and sells other useful products, readymade

furniture, kitchen appliances and home accessories.

IKEA, supported in Kingdom of Sweden by 17-year-old

Ingvar Kamprad in 1943, is that the world’s largest furnishings

merchandiser since 2008.

The company claims this helps reduce costs and packaging

usage by not sending air. For example, the volume of a

library is significantly less if shipped disassembled rather than

assembled. This type of packaging is also more practical for

customers who provide transportation by public transport. Flat

packs can be carried much easier.

Rather than selling pre-assembled items, majority of IKEA

furnitures are aimed to be assembled by the client. IKEA

claims to be a pioneering pressure in sustainable techniques

to mass client culture. Kamprad calls this “democratic design”,

meaning the company follows an integrated approach to

manufacturing and design (see also environmental design).

In response to the explosion of the human population and

financial expectations in the 20th and 21st centuries, the

company creates production processes that reduce the costs

and resource use by capturing material flows by applying

economies of scale. [24]

RESEARCH

Image 14: IKEA’s first store IKEA founder Ingvar Kamprad (right) shakes hands with

Hans Ax, IKEA’s first store manager in 1965 [24]

A.1945 Atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki

The United States exploded two atomic

weapons over the Japanese urban areas of

Hiroshima and Nagasaki on August 6 and

9, 1945, separately, with the assent of the

United Kingdom, as required by the Quebec

Agreement. The two bombings murdered

somewhere in the range of 129,000 and

226,000 individuals, the vast majority of

whom were regular people, and remain

the main utilization of atomic weapons in

furnished clash. After bombings Japan

faced with critical problems such as housing

shortage and destruction of infrastructural

systems. As a result, atomic bombing

brought a new word to the language

“tabula rasa”, which describes the place

where a torn-down building once stood.

Therefore, they saw this as an opportunity

for Japan itself to start over with a new,

better, structure. The Hiroshima experience

-literal for some of our protagonists, who

witness the aftermath- encourages existential

cynicism in some; others sublimate the

shock into a lifelong commitment to new

beginnings. The generation that will become

the Metabolists share, from the beginning,

the Japanese, obsession on tabula rasa. [25]

Image 15: Atomic Bombing in Hiroshima [25]

23


HISTORY

1946

A. THRESHOLDS

Turing Test: Alan Turing has introduced

many of the central concepts of AI in a

report entitled “Intelligent Machinery” that

aimed to determine if a machine was

capable of thinking.

1950

Great Smog of London: Lethal smog

that covered the city caused by a

combination of industrial pollution and

high-pressure weather conditions.

1952

Berlin

Strike

1953 1960

Foundation of OPEC: The Organization

of the Petroleum Exporting Countries

was created by Iran, Iraq, Kuwait, Saudi

Arabia and Venezuela during the Baghdad

Conference.

Timing

Electrical

Pulses

Kunststoff Messe

Styropor (Expanded polystyrene)

Computer Numerical Control

Richard Kegg

First Operated System

The IBM 704

B. INNOVATIONS

1946

1952

1952

1954

Wichita House, Kansas

Buckminster Fuller was first designed

house as prefabricated building than

adapted to emergency shelter during

war.

Case Study House No.8

Charles and Ray Eames build house

during experiment that would commission

major architects to reconsider the

modern dwelling.

Le Cabanon was designed by Le

Corbusier for himself and his wife as a

prefabricated summerhouse.

All Plastic House designed by Ionel

Schien as experimental use of plastic.

C. SHELTERS

1946

1949

1951

1956

D. CULTURE

Western Pacific, Luxurious Comfort,

Women’s Lounge, Delicious Meals.

1949

1962

“Silent

Spring”

Rachel

Carson

Documenting

the adverse

environmental

effects

caused by the

indiscriminate

use of

pesticides.

1963

Cheryomushki

/ Cherry Town

by Gerbert

Rappaport

Hungarian

version poster

of the film by

Antal Gunda

1968

2001: A Space

Odyssey

by Stanley

Kubrick

E. ACTS AND EVENTS

UN Convention relating the status of

refugees that defines who a refugee

is, and sets out the rights of individuals

who are granted asylum and the

responsibilities of nations that grant

asylum.

1951

1957

Berlin

Interbau, The

International

Building

Exhibition

It was an urban

renewal project

in West Berlin,

Germany.

1958

Brussels

World Fair

also known as

Expo 58, it was

the first major

World Expo

registered under

the Bureau

International

des Expositions

after World

War II.

Fair Housing Act, USA

“Freedom is Equal Housing Too.”

1964

F. ECONOMY

Levittown: The project – started in

1947 as America’s prototypical postwar

planned community.

1947

The HLM system was created in

1950 in response to France’s postwar

housing crisis. The new system took its

foundations from the HBM (habitation

à bon marché – “inexpensive housing”)

system, which had been created in

1889 and financed mainly by charitable

sources rather than the state.

1950

A panel hanging from a crane was

the logo of Camus-Dietsch, a French

company which opened its facility in

1954. The factory was the foundation for

prefabricated construction across many

countries.

1954

The Million Programme is the public

housing programme implemented in

Sweden between 1965 and 1974 by the

governing Swedish Social Democratic

Party to make sure everyone could have

a home at a reasonable price.

1965

24


1975

Brasilia established

Oscar Niemeyer and Lucio Costa

1960

SDI surveillance drone system

Royal Artillery

Berlin Wall construction

1961

Computer aided design (CAD) was

introduced in 1963

1969

Neil

Armstrong

and his crew

landed on

the Moon:

The historic

launch of

the Apollo

11 mission

carried three

astronauts

toward the

moon.

Apollo 8

Launched

J.Lovell,W.

Anders and

F.Borman would

be on their way

to space and

to becoming

the first three

humans to fly

around the

moon.

Hurricane Agnes: America’s costliest

natural disaster, effecting 15 states, with

119 deaths and $3 billion in damage.

1972

The first personal computer Altair

8800

RESEARCH

1962

1963

1968

1975

Habitat designed by Moshe Safdie for

World Exposition of 1967.

Futuro House Prefabricated house

designed by Matti Suuronen.

K67 kiosk designed by Saša J. Mächtig.

This street equipment design for

Slovenia.

Capsule

Tower

designed by

Kisho

Kurukowa and

completed in

Tokyo.

1967

1968

1969

1972

The first

Whole

Earth

Catalogue

Domebook

One

Lloyd Kahn

Inflatocookbook

Ant Farm

How to Build Your Own Living

Structures

Ken Isaacs

Stewart

Brand

1968

1970

1971

1972

World Design Conferance

Montreal World Fair, B.Fuller

The Biosphere is a museum dedicated

to the environment. It is located at Parc

Jean-Drapeau, on Saint Helen’s Island.

Tokyo Expo

The theme of the Expo was “Progress

and Harmony for Mankind.”

Earth Day

Exhibition

It was a day

that activists

could send a

message that

the environment

needed

protection.

1960

1967

1970

1970

End of the Bretton Woods monetary

system: On 15 August 1971, the

United States unilaterally terminated

convertibility of the US dollar to gold,

effectively bringing the Bretton Woods

system to an end and rendering the

dollar a fiat currency. At the same

time, many fixed currencies (such as

the pound sterling) also became freefloating.

Robin Hood Gardens in London

Demolition of Pruitt Igoe: By the mid-

1960s, however, the complex’s crime rate

surged, the vacancy rate rose, and living

conditions dramatically declined. On July

15, 1972, the city of St. Louis admitted

defeat and demolished 3 of the project’s

33 towers.

Oil crisis: Since oil provides the

main source of energy for advanced

industrial economies, an oil crisis can

endanger economic and political stability

throughout the global economy.

1971

1972

1972

1973

25


HISTORY

F.1947 Levittown

Levittown, a development of more than 17,000 detached houses,

started in 1947 as America’s post-war prototype community. It

has outperformed its boldest supporters and toughest detectors

today as something more complex than a monument to the glory of

the American dream or the glory and harmony of that dream. The

founder’s son, William Levitt, came home from the navy, thinking that

every young veteran who returned to the USA would need a home.

Then he decided to use the mass production strategies he learned

while building the military dwelling. Levitt and Sons, who bought about

1,800 hectares of Long Island’s potato and onion fields, went to work.

They built all the Levittown residences between 1947 and 1951.

And they started building houses every 16 minutes. Popularly, using

systems that are well known in American car manufacturing but are

new to home construction. “We are not constructors,” said straighttalking

Levitt, the activity’s driving force. “We are manufacturers.” He

even ventured to such an extreme as to proclaim his organization

“the General Motors of the lodging business”, giving families the local

segment of the American dream, similarly as GM gave them the

vehicular one. All things being equal, William Levitt called his item –

which previously sold for $7,990 with a 5% up front instalment (0% for

veterans) and accompanied an implicit TV and greetings of – “the best

house in the US”. [26]

Image 16: Levittown [26]

A.1952 Great Smog of London

Great Smog of London, a lethal event in

December 1952 that caused by industrial

pollution dependant on coal burning and

high-pressure weather conditions, which

caused polluted smog to get trapped on

the ground level of London, and resulted

in thousands of deaths while it lasted only

5 days. London always had an issue with

polluted fog, where water vapour would

connect to chemicals released from coal

burning factories and produce dark and

heavy clouds, therefore, the word smog

has invented in the early 20th century as

a combination of smoke and fog. After 4

years of the incident, British government

agreed on Clean Air Act, which has

restricted the burning of the coal in

domestic and industrial buildings. [27]

Image 17: Great Smog of London [27]

Photo: London fog, 1952 © Keystone—Hulton Archive/Getty Images

26


B.1952 Styropor (Expanded Polystyrene)

An engineer named Fritz Stastny (1908-1985),

he obtained a new raw material after World War

II. By developing pre-expanded polystyrene, it

was possible to extrude plates or molds in various

parts with this raw material, where pentane and

other aliphatic hydrocarbons were incorporated

into the beads. The patent of this technology

was registered in 1949 by Stastny and German

giant BASF. In 1952, the first introduction of the

molding technique was made at Kunststoff Messe

in Düsseldorf, while the first products were sold as

Styropor. Then, by describing the crystal structure

of isostatic polystyrene to this raw material, Giulio

Natta contributed. In 1954, Expanded polystyrene

(EPS) foam was invented. Dylite Koppers Company,

based in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, started selling

under the brand. The first foam containers were

delivered by Dart Container Company in 1960. [28]

Image 28: Expanded Polystyrene [29]

RESEARCH

C.1956 All Plastic House

All Plastic House was designed in 1956 by Architect Ilonel Schein.

The house consists of a single level, consisting of eight separate

sections that are combined at a central point. The portions stay

equivalent in span until the last four areas, so, all in all the range

become progressively enormous, shaping an arrangement which

reviews a Fibonacci-a structure (an arranged cluster which limits

or grows in non-direct interims). For the acknowledgment of an

assembled model, each cut was manufactured independently and

pulled in on eight separate trucks to be associated nearby. This

structure is a new interpretation of round house typology unlike

Fuller’s Dymaxion models. The building, which organizes itself from

the environment, is organized outwards from the centre point of the

building, for example. Maybe considerably more significant than its

proper development is the amazingly propelled utilization of plastics,

a material up to that point utilized solely in modern circumstances.

Slots are provided for glass or secondary inserts as needed for

each segment, Large single molds with enormous durability,

flexibility and strength were produced to create floors, roofs and

faces. Connections with neighbouring sections comprise of basic

screw-and-fastener frameworks. Albeit plastic was at that point

ending up being a less expensive option in contrast to conventional

structure materials, scarcely any designers thought about it for

house development. Schein’s project marks the start of an interest

for the use of plastic in lodging plan in late-1950s and 1960s

France. His work would impact endless different modellers intrigued

by the novel form making conceivable outcomes of moderate,

replicable structures and configuration objects, for example, Jean

Maneval and Eric Clements in France and Gaetano Pesce in Italy.[30]

Image 19: All Plastic House [31]

27


HISTORY

E.1960 World Design Conference

Japan wanted to introduce its

architects to the public at the World

Design Conference. It was the time

Metabolism 1960: The Proposal

for New Urbanism acquainted with

universe of engineering, Kurokawa

and Arazu sells their declaration on the

entryway and fundamental draftsmen

of the time welcomed this gathering,

for example, Jean Prouve, Paul

Rudolph, Alison, and Peter Smithson,

Louis Kahn, and so forth. Right now,

Kikutake, Ekuan, Otake, and Tange’s

himself made introductions about

their new compositional issues. The

Metabolism Movement was officially

introduced at this conference. [32]

Image 20: World Design Conference, 1960 [32]

D.1963 Cheryomushki / Cherry Town by Gerbert Rappaport

To introduce the first years of Khrushchev’s new housing

policy, “In view of the operetta of Dmitri Shostakovich (1959),

Gerbert Rappaport’s unusual film Cheryomushki (1963) was

authorized for advance the early years. The subject of the

film is an explosion that pushes his hero Boris into the new

panel circle - around the theme of destroying the old hero -

where the last standing brick house in the newly established

Cheryomushki area saw an explosion. Lidochka awaits him.

With choreographic movements of flying panels offering an

optimistic background view, brings a magical visual to the

prefabrication of large concrete residences. [33]

Image 21: Hungarian version poster of the Cherry Town by Antal Gunda, 1963 [33]

28


E. 1964 Fair Housing Act, USA

The Fair Housing Act of 1968 was signed by the

law by President Lyndon B. Johnson to prevent

discrimination against people from minority groups

when trying to rent or purchase a landlord, apply

for mortgages or receive housing benefits. This Fair

Housing Law prohibits discrimination based on family

status, race, gender, religion. The law was signed

on 11 April 1968 by President Lyndon Johnson.

This law makes it illegal for a mortgage loan to be

charged more than others in a protected group or

to change the lease or loan application standards

to buy housing. It prohibits rejection, either indirectly

or indirectly, to provide these people with shelter.

One of the events that encouraged Congress to

pass the Fair Housing Act because it could not

be enacted earlier, Rev. Fighting for fair housing in

Chicago on April 4, 1968. It was the assassination

of Martin Luther King Jr. With the implementation

of the law, although the problem seems to have

disappeared, only discrimination of housing has

actually decreased. Many of the regions in the South

and the Midwest have been racially separated. And

blacks continue to be turned down twice as much

as white for mortgage loans. [34]

Image 22: The Rev. Martin Luther King unsuccessfully fought for housing equality in Chicago [35]

RESEARCH

A.1969 Neil Armstrong on the Moon

Apollo 11, the first mission in its history, carried out 3

astronauts to the moon. Spacecraft ensured a transport

and self-sufficient place for working and living. In space

with an extremely challenging environment, Apollo had to

provide everything necessary for the journey. Apollo 11.

Protection, flight and working equipment, weather, food,

clothing, equivalence of bathrooms and more. The works

in this exhibition show creativity and planning unnecessary

for a journey from space to another world. The Apollo 11

mission had three spacecraft: Command Module Columbia, a

Service Module, and the Moon Module Eagle. As astronauts

Armstrong and Aldrin landed on the Moon in Kartal,

Michael Collins was left alone in Columbia. It served as a

communication link for 28 hours and photographed the lunar

surface. After taking Armstrong and Aldrin back from the Moon

Module’s exit phase, it was the only part of the Columbia

spacecraft that returned to Earth. [36]

Image 23: Buzz Aldrin became the second person to walk on the Moon [37]

29


HISTORY

1976

A. THRESHOLDS

Start of modern internet: ARPANET

adopted TCP/IP and from there

researchers began to assemble the

“network of networks”. The online world

then took on a more recognizable form

in 1990, when computer scientist Tim

Berners-Lee invented the World Wide

Web.

1983

Chernobyl

is a

nuclear

accident

that

happened

in Pripyat,

Ukraine.

1986

Berlin Wall Falls: Demolishing the wall

was a pivotal event as it was the most

powerful symbol of Cold War.

1989

Somali Civil War caused serious

damage to economy, infrastructure and

people.

1991

B. INNOVATIONS

Gore-Tex is a waterproof, breathable

fabric membrane and registered

trademark of W. L. Gore and Associates.

Patent

1976

1978

SIP is a sandwich

structured

composite,

consisting of an

insulating layer

of rigid core

sandwiched

between two layers

of structural board,

used as a building

material.

The history of 3D printing begins in

1981 with Dr. Hideo Kodama’s patent

application for a rapid prototyping device.

1981

World’s first Passive House in

Kranichstein, Germany

1990

C. SHELTERS

Ramot Housing

Zvi Hecker is commissioned by the

Israeli government to design it.

1972-1985

Yacht House

Richard Norden / Cherry

LeenArchitects The Yacht House is

built with aluminium and stainless steel

spars.

1972-1985

Almere House is designed by Benthem

Crouwel Architects.

1982-1984

1987

Kim

House

Waro Kishi

designed

a small

house in

the old

town of

Osaka.

D. CULTURE

1979

This Old

House

Bob Vila

Norm Abram

1982

Koyaanisqatsi

by Godfrey

Reggio

A silent film

without narration,

it’s a collage

telling the tale of

human evolution,

from nature to

the invasive

man-made world

of today.

Blade Runner by Ridley Scott

1982

1984

Façade

Design by

Nikolay

Jarsky

The design for

a nine-storey

building for

workers of

the Tashkent

aviation factory

in Uzbekistan.

E. ACTS AND EVENTS

Burning Man has started.

1986

Docomomo International was founded

in Eindhoven by Dutch architects Hubert-

Jan Henket and Wessel de Jonge

1988

1989

Galerie Patrick

Seguin was

founded

The gallery has

brought French

designers such

as Jean Prouvé,

Charlotte Perriand,

Pierre Jeanneret,

Le Corbusier and

Jean Royère into

the international

spotlight.

1990-1992

NWR-BouwRAI

Two Dutch

housing

exhibitions that

were held in the

1990s triggered

a reorientation of

the then-current

design principles

for home plans.

F. ECONOMY

The Right to Buy scheme is a policy in

the United Kingdom which gives secure

tenants of councils and some housing

associations the legal right to buy, at a

large discount, the council house they

are living in.

1979

Fannie Mae issues: the first mortgagebacks

security that will lead to the

housing crisis.

1981

1992

HOPE VI is a

program of the

United States

Department

of Housing

and Urban

Development.

It is intended to

revitalize the worst

public housing

projects into

mixed-income

developments.

Demolition of Kowloon Walled City

1993

30


2005

Dolly the sheep: The first successfully

cloned mammal, Dolly the sheep, is born

at the Roslin Institute in Scotland.

Iraq War: It has began with the invasion

of the USA and the United Kingdom.

Indian Ocean Tsunami

Indonesia Earthquake

Kashmir Earthquake

Pakistan

1996

Building information modeling (BIM)

The term ‘Building Information Model’

first appeared in a paper by G.A. van

Nederveen and F. P. Tolman.

2003-2011

The first USB (1994): The first USB

technology began development in 1994,

co-invented by Ajay Bhatt of Intel and the

USB-IF (USB Implementers Forum, Inc).

The organization is comprised of industry

leaders like Intel, Microsoft, Compaq,

LSI, Apple and Hewlett-Packard.

2004 2005

The first self-healing materials were

polymers (plastics made from long,

repeating molecules) with a kind of

embedded internal adhesive, reported

in by Scott White, Nancy Sottos, and

colleagues from the University of Illinois

at Urbana-Champaign.

In 2001, Pilkington Glass announced

the development of the first self-cleaning

windows, Pilkington Activ

RESEARCH

1992

1994

2001

2001

Kalkin

Quik

House

is

designed

by Adam

Kalkin.

Micro Compact Home

Horden Cherry Lee Architects and

Haack+Höpfner Architects designed

for short stay living for students,

business people and leisure use and for

weekender.

Paper Log House ,India

After the biggest earthquake in India in

2001, Shigeru Ban designed this Paper

Log House.

Muji House

Muji/Net Muji Housing Division Muji is

a Japanese retail company and also Muji

designed three micro homes.

2000

2001

2001

2004

Light

Architecture

Richard

Horden

Wikipedia launch as a free, web-based,

collaborative, multilingual encyclopedia

project.

Maxi Capsule Luxus

Atelier van Lieshout an entirely selfsupporting

unit that functions as a mobile

hotel room.

Birthingtent

Dre Wapenaar

The 1996

John

Dinkeloo

Memorial

Lecture

1996

2001

2002

2003

Serpentine is renowned for the

temporary summer pavilion,

commissioning since 2000 to some

of the most prominent international

architects.

Tropical

House in

Niamey :

discovery,

dismantle

and back

to France

European Housing Expo

Bo01

An expo on Ön in Malmö was planned

for 2000, however following the council’s

acquisition of the Western Harbour it was

decided that this former industrial area

would be a more suitable location.

The Dome Project: Occidental

Installation

Occidental Investor information including

news, financial reports, and quarterly

earnings.

2000

2000

2001

2004

The Spanish property bubble is

the collapsed overshooting part of a

long-term price increase of Spanish real

estate prices.

Alan Greenspan begins cutting interest

rates, encouraging US mortgage

lending.

Incremental House by ELEMENTAL

Rapid increase in sub-prime

mortgages in the US.

1996

2001

2003

2004

31


HISTORY

B.1981 3D Printing by Dr. Hideo Kodama

The concept of 3D printing was first

introduced in 1974 by David E. H.

Jones in his column, New Scientist,

in the column named Ariadne. The

term “3D printing” is a typical layer

where the material is combined or

solidified under computer control

to form a three-dimensional object,

where the material is combined (as

liquid molecules or dust particles fuse

together). The history of 3D printing,

in 1981. It starts with a patent

application for a rapid prototyping

device of Hideo Kodama. Charles

Hull is granted a patent for his system

and his company 3D Systems

Corporation launches the first

commercial 3D printer, the SLA-1. [38]

Image 24: The first 3D printer ever created

was made in 1983 by Chuck Hull. [39]

D.1984 Mosaic Façade Panel by The Jarsky Brothers

For the facade of buildings in Soviet Tashkent, the brothers Petr

Jarsky, Nikolay Jarsky and Alexander Jarsky, who created valuable

mosaic artworks, combined Soviet modernism with floral patterns

and programmed motifs. “The best place to create something new,

beautiful, and useful is a place where much is being built. At the

time, Tashkent was such a city,” After the 1966 earthquake, he wrote

in the Tashkent Evening Newspaper in 1972 to express the status of

the city. Architect Jury Miroshnichenko evaluated the work of talented

brothers with these words: “The design bewildered the architects.

Its composition, colour, and subject matter did not reflect the Uzbek

people’s popular ideas on ornamentation.” In the history of Soviet

architecture, the works of the brothers are very important due to the

unique examples of its kind. Mass production panel systems had

some kind of monotony. Tashkent was trying to distinguish each one

with relieves, ornaments and other facade elements. In some of their

works, they created concrete panel factories containing propaganda.

According to Nikolay Jarsky, the challenge was to “break the

monotony of the prefabricated mass housing series, each time with

a new image”. The techniques for producing mosaics panels are as

follows: “Petr, Alexander, and Nikolay Jarsky draw a full-size pattern

on a piece of paper. Mosaic setters then layout colourful tiles onto

the drawing, and the finished template is laid into a mould. After the

concrete is poured into the mould, the paper is removed, and the

tile pattern remains fixed on the panel. The completed panels are

delivered to the construction site and assembled.’’ [40]

Image 25: Façade design for a nine-storey building for workers of the

Tashkent aviation factory in ui. Shaykhontohur 28-30 Tashkent, Uzbekistan,

designed by Nikolay Jarsky [41]

32


A.1986 Chernobyl Disaster

Considered as the worst nuclear disaster in history, it

is one of two nuclear energy disasters whose severity

was recorded as seven on the International Nuclear

Event Scale. It is an area spread over 30 km from

the explosion zone. The Chernobyl Shelter Fund was

established in 1997 at the Denver 23rd G8 summit

to support the Asylum Implementation Plan (SIP).In

order to transform the area into an ecologically safe

area, the stabilization of the sarcophagus and then

the creation of a New Safe Constraint (NSC) were

used. A significant economic impact at the time was

the removal of 784,320 ha (1,938,100 acres) of

agricultural land and 694,200 ha (1,715,000 acres) of

forest from production. Agricultural production costs

have increased due to the need for special cultivation

techniques, fertilizers and additives, many of which

have been made available again. [42]

RESEARCH

Image 26: Effect of the explosion at the Chernobyl power plant

Photo by Volodymr Repik / Reuters [42]

E. 1986 First Burning Man Festival, USA

Burning Man, whose goal is to create a society

that connects each individual to their society with

their creative powers, to create a wider civilian

living space and to the larger world of nature that

exists beyond society, was founded by Larry

Harvey and It was created by Jerry James. It is a

festival organized as a small function by building

the first “Human”, covering nine days since Labour

Day each year, which is usually starts on Sunday

and ends the first Monday of September. During

the festival, the community focuses on ways of

expressing themselves artistically to be created by all

participants. Participation is key to society; selfless

sharing of unique talents for everyone to enjoy are

encouraged. As an example of creativity; buildings,

interactive and experimental sculptures, art cars and

performances can be given. These contributions are

inspired by a theme chosen by the organizers every

year. [43] [44]

Image 27: Uchronia, 2006 Photo by: Arne Quinze [45]

33


HISTORY

F.1993 Demolition of Kowloon Walled City

When it collapsed in 1994, Hong Kong’s two-hectare

settlement, Kowloon Walled City, hosted 35,000 people.

While it was a refuge for immigrants, it was a busy area run by

foreigners, gangsters and drug dealers. For business owners,

this was a place to avoid annoying regulations. This region

had a historical background. This residential area was built as

a trading post in the 11th century and later became a garrison

of the Chinese army. In 1898, the British government rented

a land surrounding Hong Kong Island and its current colony

in Kowloon: this also included the area around the garrison.

However, Walled City never became part of the British colony,

and Chinese officials were allowed to stay there for a long

time. Because they did not interfere with the British jurisdiction.

The walls of the city, by the Japanese occupation forces.

During the Second World War, Kai Tak was used to expand

the airport. Refugees fleeing the communist revolution settled

in this area in China in the 1950s. This area has become the

most populated place in the world because neither Britain

nor China paid much attention. Slums, factory owners and

organized crime unions also took action. The new settlers

were able to do everything they could find before replacing

the unstable huts in the 1960s with solid structures. Others

have created more than 300 interconnected foundation-laid

buildings that span 14 floors, which are not at all safe. These

structures had several windows and no ventilation. That’s why

the entrances of the city’s factories and shops often remained

open. [46]

Figure 3: Info graphic Showing of Kowloon Walled City

Courtesy of South China Morning Post [47]

C.2001 Paper Log House ,India

The design of the Paper Log House emerged

due to the earthquake that devastated Kobe

in 1995 by Shigeru Ban. Four years have

passed and he changed the Paper Log House

to meet the needs of the Turkish people with

another disaster, the 1999 earthquake. In 2001,

Ban used the Paper Log House in India after

recording the country’s largest earthquake. In

2005, SBA was invited to build the Paper Log

House for an exhibition. SAFE: At Design Takes

On Risk Products and prototypes designed

to protect the body and mind from dangerous

conditions, respond to emergencies and provide

a sense of comfort and safety are offered. The

house shown is an exact copy of the Kobe

Paper Log House in 1995. The criteria of these

residences provided by Paper Log House,

which ultimately provides temporary relief for

many families, were cheap materials, simple

construction methods, satisfactory insulation and

at the same time aesthetically pleasing. [48]

Image 28: Paper Log House, India (2001) [49]

34


F.2003 Incremental House by ELEMENTAL

Elemental’s first project was highly appreciated

in one of Chile’s largest port cities, Iquique. They

were asked to relocate the family living in 100

slums on the same plot they had occupied for

the last 30 years. But he was forced to do so

in the standard government subsidy of $ 7,500

per house. And this included infrastructure and

construction costs. [50]

Given the current values in the Chilean

construction industry, $ 7,500 only allowed 40

square meters of construction area. At the same

time, they had to pay 3 times more for the land

located in the city centre. In Chile, a middle-class

family could live in a home of about 80 square

meters, while a low-income family could survive

only in an area of 40 square meters. They cannot

own a large, “good” home, and therefore they

usually stay in smaller homes. So why were they

not given a small house instead of a half “good”

house? [51]

ELEMENTAL provided a basic house and two

rooms with a total of 40 square meters each,

with the necessary sanitary equipment. With this

framework, families built the rest of the house

after saving enough money and gradually turned

their houses into a more desirable unit than

social housing. [52]

36 m²

36 m²

72 m²

if the first half of the house cost was and the second half the final value is more than

$7,500

+ $1,000 = $20,000

Image 29: Value Increase of Quinta Monroy [53]

RESEARCH

C.2004 Muji House

Having a consistent brand philosophy, Muji is

also a Japanese retail company that designs

three micro houses. Since 2004 it has been

offering simple yet inspiring homes that cover

almost every area of life. MUJI House is a small

but highly editable “empty” box as a concept.

The small-scale appearance of MUJI, which

comes in an area of about 90 ~ 130 square

meters, has existed since the first models were

launched and long before the small house

movement.

MUJI currently offers three different house

models: “Ki no Ie (Wooden House)”, “Mado no

Ie (Window House)” and “Tate no Ie (Vertical

House).” And in September 2019, the fourth

product, Yo no Ie (Sun House), one of the most

distinctive features of all three model houses

shared is that it reinforced the concept of “oneroom

house”. the whole area is designed like

a large single room. There is no wall to divide

the rooms, and the floors are connected using

double ceilings and high windows. Furniture or

partitions can be used as dividers if required or

desired. [54]

Image 30: Muji House / Mado no Ie (Window House), 2004 [54]

35


HISTORY

2005

A. THRESHOLDS

Secure Fence Act: The Secure Fence

Act of 2006, which authorized the

construction of 700 miles of doublelayered

fencing along part of the U.S.-

Mexico border

2006

Apple iPhone released: The iPhone

is a line of smart phones designed and

marketed by Apple Inc.

2007

Great Recession (Mortgage crisis):

A global economic downturn that

devastated world financial markets as

well as the banking and real estate

industries.

2008

Starting of mass migration from Syria:

People’s riots caused by the Arab Spring,

Syria in March 2011 leaped. Assad

government in Syria, the military violently

suppress demonstrations to turn to, was

the first sign of the mass migration will

begin in Turkey.

2011

YouTube has launched Twitter has launched Google Street View launched Scientists engineer new plastics

without the use of fossil fuels

B. INNOVATIONS

2005

2006

2007

2009

Polar Lab is a temporary Research

Habitat in Antarctica.

Final Wooden House is designed by

Sou Fujimoto Architects and the architect

uses the versatility of Lumber.

The Sustainable Cabin is designed by

Texas Tech University. The project is

prefabricated, sustainable design-build

project.

Halley VI Antarctic Research Station is

designed by Hugh Broughton Architects

with AECOM.

C. SHELTERS

2005

2006

2010

2013

D. CULTURE

2007

Sorry Out Of

Gas

Glovanna

Borasi,

Mirko Zardini

is written

for an

architecture’s

response to

the 1973 oil

crisis.

2007

Amazon Kindle

The device

used an

electronic paper

display and

was able to

download books

and other digital

content from

Amazon, without

a computer

and without any

monthly fee.

Wall-E: In 2805, Earth is an abandoned,

dystopian planet covered in garbage,

with its people evacuated by megacorporation

Buy-N-Large on giant

star-liners.

2008

Black Mirror: An anthology series that

revolves around a group of people’s

personal lives and how technology

manipulates their behaviour

2011

E. ACTS AND EVENTS

Onedotzero Festival in London

create immersive environments,

producing culturally significant

experiences: merging arts, entertainment

and technology.

2008

2008

Home Delivery:

Fabricating

the Modern

Dwelling, MoMA

The exhibition, and

its accompanying

website, display

the process of

architectural design

and production

in equal measure

with the actual end

result.

2009

Dezeen

x Design

Association

Container

Design

Competition

exhibition

space in Tokyo.

Small Scale, Big Change: New

Architectures of Social Engagement,

MoMA.

Exhibition says that: ‘‘Architecture is

rediscovering its social conscience.’’

2010-2011

Real estate prices in Berlin begin to

rise

Torre David in Caracas

Founding of Airbnb: Share your flat and

rent it out for as a holiday home.

WikiHouse is an open-source project for

designing and building homes.

F. ECONOMY

2006

2007

2008

2011

36


2019

Facebook Big Data Scandal:

Cambridge Analytica has used Facebook

data to manipulate Brexit referendum in

the UK and Donald Trump presidential

elections in the USA.

ISIS Attacks: ISIS militants has

destroyed one of the best-preserved

ruins at the Syrian site of Palmyra.

Paris Agreement: Global response

to climate change by keeping a global

temperature rise this century well below

2 degrees Celsius above pre-industrial

levels.

Greta Thunberg & Climate Emergency

Protests

2014-2018

First consumer oriented AR drone was

released by Parrot.

2015

Large scale prefab MEP installation

2016

First 3D Printed House to Be Built In

Amsterdam

2019

Virtual Reality makes a comeback

RESEARCH

2010

2011

2014

2015

Alpine Shelter Skuta is designed by

OFIS Architects + AKT II + Harvard GSD

Students in extreme climatic condition.

Urban Cabin is designed by DUS

Architects and it is a research into

compact and sustainable dwelling

solutions.

MARSHA Ai Space Factory The project

offers a habitat which describes a future

of human life on Mars.

Cork House in Berkshire

Cork House was designed by Matthew

Barnett Howland with Dido Milne and

Oliver Wilton.

2015

2016

2019

2019

The Fool

(Durak)

Set in an

unnamed town

in Russia, the

film follows the

protagonist

Dima’s unavailing

attempt to rescue

a crumbling

building - and

all 820 of its

residents.

Elements of

Architecture

Rem

Koolhas

Martian

Depicts an astronaut’s lone struggle to

survive on Mars after being left behind,

and efforts to rescue him, and bring him

home to Earth.

Small Is

Beautiful:

A Tiny House

Documentary

Documentary

that explores

the complexities

of human

shelters and

shows us that

the story of a

house

2014

2014

2015

2015

Campus in

Camps was

founded.

It is an

experimental

education

program that

activates critical

learning and

egalitarian

environments

in Palestinian

refugee camps.

Nine Islands, 3rd Istanbul Design

Biennial “Are We Human?” Galata

Greek School, Istanbul.

Matters Around Architecture is a mixedmedia

installation that reflects on the

temporal and geographical origins of

architectural materiality.

MultiPly, London Design Festival: This

pavilion will delve into two of the current

global challenges – housing and climate

change - and will present the fusion

of modular systems and a responsible

choice of materials as a vital solution.

Flying

Panels

Exhibition

design by

Note Design

Studio in

Stockholm.

2013

2016

2018

2019

U.S. foreclosure crisis refers to a

widespread epidemic of improper

foreclosures initiated by large banks and

other lenders. The foreclosure crisis was

extensively covered by news outlets

beginning in October 2010, and several

large banks responded by halting their

temporarily foreclosure proceedings

in some or all states. The foreclosure

crisis caused significant investor fear in

the U.S. A 2014 study published in the

American Journal of Public Health linked

the foreclosure crisis to an increase in

suicide rates.

2010

UK Bedroom Tax: The underoccupancy

penalty results from a reform

contained in the British Welfare Reform

Act 2012 whereby tenants living in public

housing with rooms deemed “spare”

face a reduction in Housing Benefit,

resulting in them being obliged to fund

this reduction from their incomes or to

face rent arrears and potential eviction

by their landlord.

2012

Average house price in London

passes 400,000 pounds.

2014

First 3D printed neighbourhood in

Mexico: A non-profit organization New

Story ,co-op with ÉCHALE and ICON,

handled with the housing shortages.

2017

37


HISTORY

F.2008 Airbnb

Providing access to goods and services often

facilitated by a community-based online platform is

called Sharing economy. It is an economic model

defined as a peer-to-peer (P2P) based activity in

providing or sharing. [55]

Airbnb, an online market that connects people who

want to rent their homes and people looking for

accommodation in that area, now covers more than

81,000 cities and 191 countries worldwide.

For homeowners, joining Airbnb is a way to earn

some income from their property, but guests also

have the risk of damaging their home. The biggest

advantage for guests can be relatively inexpensive

accommodation. But there is also the risk that the

property is not as attractive as it appears on the list.

The advantages of Airbnb: A wide selection, free

entries, homeowners’ own prices, customization, a

wide search opportunity. Disadvantages of Airbnb:

What you see may not be what you get, potential

damage, additional fees, taxes may occur. And it is not

legal everywhere. [56]

Figure 4: Airbnb economic model scheme [57]

E. 2010-2011 Small Scale Big Change:

New Architectures of Social Engagement,

MOMA,USA

They focus on work that has recently been built or is under

construction in small-scale, large-scale, underserved

communities by 11 architects and companies. Elemental

(Chilean); Anna Heringer (Austrian); Diébédo Francis Kéré

(Burkinabé); Hashim Sarkis A.L.U.D. (Lebanese); Jorge

Mario Jáuregui (Brazilian); Frédéric Druot, Anne Lacaton &

Jean Philippe Vassal (French); Michael Maltzan Architecture

(American); Noero Wolff Architects (South African); Rural Studio

(American); Estudio Teddy Cruz (American, born Guatemala);

and Urban Think Tank (American / Austrian / Venezuelan). These

11 architects and firms have focused on this change, offering

work that has recently been built or is under construction in

communities with insufficient service worldwide. These architects

have developed projects that demonstrate the specificity of the

space after utopia, without compromising their concerns about

aesthetics. They came up with architectural solutions as a result

of close collaboration with future users and ongoing research

into local conditions. Projects involving schools, parks, housing

and infrastructure interventions have revealed an exciting

change in the long-standing dialogue between architecture and

society, as the roles, methods, approaches and responsibilities

of the architect have been significantly re-evaluated. They also

provided an expanded definition of sustainability that goes

beyond experimenting with new materials and technologies to

cover larger social and economic sustainability concepts. [58]

Image 31: Metro Cable, 2003

Courtesy of Urban-Think Tank [59]

38


B.2010 AR Drone by Parrot

Launched by the French company Parrot, the stoppable

remote control quad copter helicopter Parrot AR.Drone

is suitable for mobile or tablet operating systems,

supported in applications such as iOS or Android. It

is also designed to be controlled by unofficial software

available for Samsung Windows Phone, BADA and

Symbian devices.

It was announced at the International CES 2010 in Las

Vegas with its compatibility with iOS applications used

to control the Parrot AR Drone. Along with AR Freeflight,

the application Parrot, designed for the drone to run for

free, also released AR.Race, which allows users to take

part in solo games or interact with other drones in battle

simulations.

“The body of the AR Drone, made of carbon fibre parts

and nylon, is 57 cm (22 inches) in diameter.”

It is put together with two interchangeable bodies. One

of them is designed for indoor, the other is designed for

outdoor flight. The outdoor body is made of lightweight

plastic and provides greater manoeuvrability. The interior

body is made of EPP foam and surrounds the blades

for protection. In total, the AR Drone has six degrees of

freedom, a miniature inertial measurement unit tracks

the pitch, roll and deviation for use in stabilization. [60]

Image 32: AR Drone pre-production prototype [60]

RESEARCH

A.2011 Starting of mass migration from Syria

The Arab Spring, a series of anti-government protests

that spread to most of the Islamic world in the early

2010s, went down in history as an uprising and armed

rebellion. Starting with protests in Tunisia in 2011, it

began as a response to repressive regimes and a low

standard of living. Its influence spread to Libya, Egypt,

Yemen, Syria and Bahrain. [61]

Turkey has taken its share by hosting a growing

number of refugees from the war inside. It has shown

its effects for 7 years. [62]

When immigrants do not take refuge in temporary

protection camps when they have the opportunity

to choose, they prefer urban areas to rural areas. In

Turkey, 2.7 million Syrians under temporary protection

to only 10 percent of temporary protection sought

refuge camps, the majority of Syrian refugees living

outside the camps are living in urban areas. There are

two dimensions to problems arising from sudden and

massive mass migration in cities. On the one hand,

while immigrant masses faced a number of problems,

on the other hand, problems arising from changes in

the permanent settlements of the city emerged. [63]

Image 33: Syrian refugee men work at a textile workshop as day labourers in Istanbul [62]

39


HISTORY

F. 2011 Wikihouse

WikiHouse is an open-source housing design and

construction project. It efforts to democratize and

facilitate the construction of affordable, sustainable

and resource-light housing. In 2011, the WikiHouse

has appeared with the initiative of Alastair Parvin and

Nick Ierodiaconou, who are from a London based

strategy and design practice “00”, in collaboration with

Tav of Espians, James Arthur, and Steve Fisher from

Momentum Engineering. The project was introduced

at Gwangju Design Binnale in South Korea. It has

grown from the beginning and become a community

of contributors worldwide. The WikiHouse allows

users to download Creative Commons licensed

projects from the online library. Users can customize

that downloaded files on “SketchUp”, and create

parts of the plywood with CNC router. The frame of

the Wikihouse includes simple elements to construct

easily, so it can be built in less than a day, even by a

non-qualified person. Before the inhabitation, the frame

must be finished with cladding, insulation, plumbing

and wiring. [64]

1 4

2

5

3

6

Figure 5: Wikihouse building scheme

Courtesy of Wikihouse.cc [65]

D.2014 The Fool (Durak)

The film is about an effort by a protagonist named Dima to rescue

a crumbling building, along with apartment dwellers, in an unnamed

town in Russia. When Dima, the plumber, is called by residents to

check a pipe burst, he realizes a crack that spilling out from one side

of the apartment. “In a housing facility of unique characters, chaos,

and limited means, he is at odds with the authorities as well as the

unhindered inhabitants of a construction neglected for 30 years.”

The story is about just a single night. When Dima fights against the

most prominent odds to persuade, the film touches on the issues of

community, neglect, morality, reform, and morality. [66]

Image 34: The Fool (Durak) is a film by Yury Bykov, 2014 [67]

40


C.2019 MARSHA / Ai Space Factory

In 2019, AI Space Factory with its proposal, which is

called “MARSHA”, has been awarded first place in the

NASA Centennial Challange. The MARSHA proposes

a new habitat for humankind in the future on Mars.

The project, which was 4.5 meters high and included

three windows, was built with 3D printed technology.

The CEO of AI Space Factory, David Malott, mentions

about the proposal as: “We developed these

technologies for Space, but they have the potential to

transform the way we build on Earth. By using natural,

biodegradable materials grown from crops, we could

eliminate the building industry’s massive waste of nonrecyclable

concrete and restore our planet.” ⁣[68]

RESEARCH

Image 35: MARSHA / Ai Space Factory, 2019 [68]

A.2019 Greta Thunberg & Climate Emergency

Greta Thunberg highlighted the following in her speech at the

United Nations Climate Action Summit in September 2019;

“Entire ecosystems are collapsing. We are in the beginning of

a mass extinction and all you can talk about is money and fairy

tales of eternal economic growth. How dare you! For more

than 30 years, the science has been crystal clear. How dare

you continue to look away and come here saying that you’re

doing enough when the politics and solutions needed are still

nowhere in sight.

... The popular idea of cutting our emissions in half in 10

years only gives us a 50% chance of staying below 1.5

degrees and the risk of setting off irreversible chain reactions

beyond human control. 50% may be acceptable to you, but

those numbers do not include tipping points, most feedback

loops, additional warming hidden by toxic air pollution or the

aspects of equity and climate justice. They also rely on my

generation sucking hundreds of billions of tons of your CO 2

out of the air with technologies that barely exist. So a 50% risk

is simply not acceptable to us, we who have to live with the

consequences. How dare you pretend that this can be solved

with just business as usual and some technical solutions?

With today’s emissions levels, that remaining CO2 budget will

be entirely gone within less than eight and a half years.

... We will not let you get away with this. Right here, right now

is where we draw the line. The world is waking up and change

is coming, whether you like it or not.” [69]

Image 41: Greta Thunberg and her book “No One is Too

Small to Make a Difference” [70][71]

41


HISTORY

A BRIEF HISTORY

OF HOUSING

AFFORDABILITY

200

170

140

AUS

126

BEL

110

80

50

20

2010

(Q2)

200

170

DEU

DNK

140

132

110

80

50

20

200

170

140

110

FRA

115

GBR

80

50

20

2007

(Q4)

1979

(Q1)

House prices in real

terms between 1975 and

2014. Index numbers

(2005=100) adjustes for

inflation and cost of

living

In the last twenty years, house prices have been

sharply increasing in most Western countries

across the entire specturum of the market. The

growth was fueled, on the one hand, by financial

speculation in real estate (after 2000, returns

from stocks and bonds were at historical lows),

and, on the other, by too-easy access to credit,

and thus to mortgages.

Such inflated values have resulted in devastating

housing bubbles: first Japan and South Korea

in the early 1990s, and later US, Spain, Ireland,

and others in the late 2000s. Many of the new

dwellings, and even new towns, that had been

built in the years of the optimism are now empty.

Thousands of families who could not afford to

repay their mortgage have been forced out their

homes. [72]

200

170

140

110

80

50

20

200

170

140

110

ITA

NOR

108

2008

(Q1)

143

JPN

SWE

80

50

Source: “SQM: The Quantified Home”,

p.144-145. The diagram was taken

from the book and redrawn.

20

1975

1985

1995

2005

2013

(Q2)

1975

1985

42


43

RESEARCH

CAN

CHE

FIN

IRL

NLD

ZAF

ESP

HRV

KOR

USA

122

2014

(Q1)

143

2014

(Q1)

143

1989

(Q4)

114

2007

(Q3)

137

1992

(Q2)

119

2007

(Q1)

106

2007

(Q1)

163

1991

(Q1)

188

1991

(Q2)

130

2013

(Q4)

106

2006

(Q4)

119

2007

(Q3)

124

2007

(Q3)

109

2007

(Q3)

113

2010

(Q3)

1995

2005

1975

1985

1995

2005

2015

1975

1985

1995

2005

2015


HISTORY

5,3

Tel Aviv

5,3

Stockholm

5,5

Helsinki

6,0

Roma

6,0

Toronto

6,5

Luxemburg

6,6

Sydney

7,0

Taipei

7,1

Bermuda

7,2

Shangai

7,4

Vienna

7,7

Tortola

8,7

Amsterdam

8,9

Auckland

9,4

Copenhagen

9,6

Andorra

9,9

0,9

Monaco

1,5

London

2,4

Hong Kong

2,8

Singapore

3,0

Moscow

3,3

New York City

3,3

Geneva

3,3

Paris

4,3

Mumbai

4,4

Tokyo

18,3

Zagreb

18,2

Santiago

17,9

Talinn

17,8

Buenos Aires

17,2

Bratislava

17,2

Riga

17,2

Phnom Penh

17,1

Grande-Terre

18,7

Vilnius

19,0

Mexico City

19,1

Kuala Lumpur

19,5

Montevideo

19,7

Jakarta

20,2

Budapest

20,9

Lisbon

21

Bo

37,3

Managua

36,6

San Juan

35,6

Skopje

35,6

Kings

37,3

Chisinau

38,5

Praia

39,0

Amman

URBAN SQMS

HOW MANY SQUARE

METERS CAN YOU BUY

WITH $50,000?

Source: “SQM: The Quantified Home”,

p.154-155. The diagram was taken

from the book and redrawn.

44


Prague

9,9

Dubai

9,9

Dublin

10,2

Madrid

10,5

Athens

11,2

Berlin

11,9

Brussels

11,9

Warsaw

11,9

St. James

12,0

Grand Cayman

12,2

Cape Town

12,7

Istanbul

12,9

Providenciales

13,2

Kiev

13,3

Sao Paulo

13,5

Valletta

RESEARCH

16,8

Fort-de-France

16,5

Belgrade

16,2

Manila

15,8

Limassol

15,6

Bucharest

15,5

St. Croix

15,2

Bangkok

14,8

Ljubljana

14,3

St. Kitts

14,3

Antigua

13,8

Bahamas

13,5

Beirut

,0

gota

21,4

Trinidad

21,5

Ambergris Caye

23,1

Bonaire

24,1

Puerto Plata

24,8

Marrakesh

25,0

Panama City

26,5

Montenegro (coast)

ton

34,7

Sofia

34,4

Aruba

30,5

San Jose

27,6

Lima

26,9

St. Lucia

39,1

Quito

41,9

San Salvador

55,6

Nairobi

71,4

Dar as Salaam

60,2

Cairo

SOURCE:

Global Property Guide,

www.globalpropertyguide.

com/most-expensive-cities.

The values are based on a

120 m² apartment in a prime

central area, and refer to Q2

2014.

45


1

R

HISTORY

A TIMELINE

OF DOMESTIC

CONNECTIONS

GATESHEAD

REDRUTH

LONDO

SAN ANDREAS

SAN FRANCISCO

LOS ANGELES

CHICAGO

DALLAS

DETROIT

LOCKPORT

BROOKLINE

BOSTON

NEW YORK

WASHINGTON

SOMMERVILLE

(BRITANNY)

1792- Gas Lighting

Redruth, Cornwall

The scale of domestic

interior is the contact point

of individuals and objects

with urban, national, and

global infrastructures.

The graph represents all

the physical structures

that, one after the other,

have linked the home to

the outside world. They

are ordered according to

the year in which the first

home was connected. [72]

Source: “SQM: The Quantified Home”,

p.198-199. The diagram was taken

from the book and redrawn.

2500

BCE

2500 BCE- Flush Toilet at Home

Indus Valley (current Pakistan)

1500

BCE

1700 BCE- Clean Water Supply

Minoan Civilization (Crete)

500

BCE

100- Waste Water Connection

Roma

1778- Flush Toilet

City of London

1615- Clean Water Supply

City of London

0 500

1500 1600 1700 1800

18

46


2001- Fiber Optics

Milan and Eindhoven

(SIBERIA)

1989- Internet

Brookline, Massachussets

1978- Minitel

Brittany, France

1976- Satellite Television

San Andreas, California, and Siberia

1975- Telenet Network

Washington, Boston, New York, Chicago,

Dallas, San Francisco, Los Angeles

RESEARCH

1970- Videophone

USA

EINDHOVEN

N

MILAN

ROME

1948- Cable Television

Pennsylvania

1936- Television

London

1931- Cable Radio

Switzerland

1920- Radio

Detroit

1908- Printing Telegraph

New York City

1882- Electric Lighting (first street)

Pearl Street, New York City

1880- Electric Lighting (first house)

Gateshead, UK

1877- District Heating

Lockport, New York

1877- Telephone

Sommerville, Massachusetts

841- Gas-fired Kitchen Stove

eform Club, London

50 1900 1950 2000

47


LOCAL TIMELINE


A view from Galata Tower to the bridge in 1950s, Old İstanbul Photos archieve [73]


HISTORY

1835

A. THRESHOLDS

The Rescript of Gülhane First Constitutionalist Period Second Constitutionalist Period

1839

1876

1908

31st March Case It is a great uprising

against the administration in Istanbul

after the declaration of the Second

Constitutional Monarchy.

1909

B. LAWS

Fire Prevention Regulation

With this law, fire prevention measures

were taken for houses and stores.

Official Record

Regulations relating to this law:

Regularization and expansion of streets,

construction of public squares and docks

Encouraging the construction of masonry

houses

Height of houses: 15m (maximum)

1826-1839

Building Regulation

The opening of empty lands and

agricultural areas to the zoning is

connected to the will of the sultan.

1848-1849

Regulation on Streets

Street and Building Regulation

It is very important that the regulation will

be applied not only in Istanbul but in all

cities of the Empire. Because the zoning

movements will be based on a certain

plan from now on.

1858-1863

Regulation on Construction Methods

in Istanbul

Only the masonry construction would be

allowed in the area east of Unkapanı-

Aksaray axis. In the north of the Golden

Horn, the area where only masonry was

allowed was Galata, the coastal line

between Azapkapı and Ortaköy, and

Şişli with Cadde-i Kebir.In other regions,

if fire prevention measures are taken,

wooden buildings are constructed.

could be.

1875

The House of Bekir Reis Büyükdere

istanbul - Turkish House

Sedat Hakkı Eldem

Abus Efendi Seaside Mansion

Single rooms

First co-living places for singles

Designed by Sarkis Balyan in 1875,

Akaretler Row Houses was built

during Sultan Abdulaziz period for the

accommodation of the leading high

ranking officials of Dolmabahce Palace.

C. DWELLING

1800s

1835

1800s

1875

D. CULTURE

1835

Julia Pardoe

Beauties

of the

Bosphorus

1860-1866

Tercüman-ı

Ahvâl is the

first private

newspaper

published

in Istanbul

between

1860-1866.

1860

Şair Evlenmesi

is accepted as

the first western

work published

in Turkish

literature

1892

Muhaderat

Fatma Aliye

Turkey’s first

female novelist

Fatma Aliye

Topuz. In

this novel,

the subject of

marriage which

one is forced to

do against his

own free will is

discussed.

E. SOCIAL LIFE

William Henry Bartlett’s XIX. An

engraving of Tophane in the second half

of the 19th century

1800s

Sixth District Municipality

1857

1870

A photo taken in

1870. A Turkish

lady in her outfit.

In the hot summer

months, women

often went out

with umbrellas

to protect

themselves from

the sun.

1867

Maison Psalty

Furniture

In Beyoglu

Workshop:

The store opened

by Jean Psalty,

They adapt the

fashion lines of

Europe to the

Ottoman Empire

and sometimes

imitate them

completely.

F. ECONOMY

With the Baltalimani Foreign Trade

Agreement, a non-Muslim rich class

was formed in the country and the

economy of the country was mostly in

the hands of that sector.

1838

1856

Founding

of İstanbul

Şehramaneti:

First modern

municipal

organization

in the western

sense

Rescript of Reform: In order to save

the Ottoman Empire from collapse, it

is an edict issued during the reign of

Abdülmecid for fundamental changes

intended to be made in the areas of

political institutions, human rights and

the establishment of new institutions.

1856

Founding of Central Bank of Ottoman

1856

50


1923

The Ottoman Empire participated in

World War I as one of the Central

Powers.

19 May 1919 is the first day of the

Turkish War of Independence.

Grand National Assembly of Turkey

was established.

Proclamation of the Republic

1914

Istanbul Municipality Law

The city of Istanbul is divided into

twenty municipalities. In the previous

embodiments, when drawing superficial

boundaries,

The municipalities were both named and

bounded.

1919

Building Law

It is the first zoning law of the Ottoman

period which came into force in

1882. Differences from the previous

embodiment first code system for

buildings and detailed streets, city

planning principles and the practices are

remarkable.

1920

Building Law

This law contains important regulations

on two issues.

Types of construction: Complete wall,

half wall and wood in some parts of the

Old Town

building heights: according to the street

width

1923

The Constitution of 1921

The first constitution of the modern

Turkish state, it was ratified by the

Grand National Assembly of Turkey in

January 1921. It was a simple document

consisting of only 23 short articles.

RESEARCH

1877

1882

1891

1921

The Helbig(Doğan) Apartment House,

Galata

Botter

Apartment

House, Pera

One of the

most prominent

representatives

of the Art

Nouveau

movement in

Turkey

Vedat Tek

House

Nişantaşı:

First National

Architecture

Movement

Harikzedegân Apartment Laleli:

It was built in May 1918 with donations to

replace some 7500 homes destroyed in

the great fire in Cibali.

1894

1910

1913

1922

Kaplumbağa

Terbiyecisi

by Osman

Hamdi Bey,

Pera Museum,

Istanbul.

Osman Hamdi

Bey is an Ottoman

archaeologist,

museum, painter

and the first mayor

of Kadikoy.

Ömer Seyfettin“New Language”

Ömer Seyfettin is one of the founders

of the ‘Türkçülük’ movement and is an

advocate of simplification in the Turkish

language.

The first

Turkish

cinema

‘The

collapse of

Ayastefanos

monument’

The first

president of

the Republic

of Turkey

Mustafa

Kemal

Atatürk on

the cover

of the Time

Magazine,

4, March 24,

1923.

1906

1911

1914

1923

Levantine Barry Family, Büyükada

White Russian

Migration to

Istanbul After

the October

Revolution:

20% of

Istanbul’s

population was

refugees.

A Russian

princess who

washes laundry

‘New Family’

in the republic

period

Nuclear family

New marriage

Changing

house layout

Women’s rights

New people

concept

Republican women

Women who live a completely different

life from their grandmother.

1910

1920

1920

1923

Düyun-u Umumiye was the institution

that supervised the foreign debts of the

Ottoman Empire between 1881 and

1939.

Central Bank of Ottoman: The

Ottoman Bank was built by the architect

Alexandre Valleury in 1892 on the Galata

Banks Street in Karaköy.

Bab-ı Ali raid: The military coup that

was carried out by a group of ‘İttihat and

Terakki’ members, led by Enver Bey and

Talat Bey, in the raid of the government

building Bab-ı Ali.

İzmir Economic Congress: The

conference was held in order to

emphasize the importance of Turkish

economic development, as the country

had been shattered by years of war.

1881

1892

1913

1923

51


HISTORY

C.1800s Turkish House

The architecture of Turkish local houses is

influenced by a range of climatic and natural

resources, by the traditions of earlier homes

remaining in Anatolia from the Byzantine era,

and by traditional Turkish culture, that was

brought from Central Asia by Turks. Local

materials, each natural and inorganic, offer

Turkish homes their character and identity;

in North Anatolia, the timbered homes from

efficient forests; whereas in Central Anatolia,

the stone and sun-dried brick houses; in West

Anatolia, stone; and in South Anatolia, stone

and timbered homes. In conjunction with these

principals, the interiors of Turkish homes were

planned for different aims, just like the winter

and therefore the summer rooms. Additionally,

Islamic and Turkish customs played a big

role in shaping the house. This issue brought

on widespread project, that created Turkish

homes a lot of homogeneous, although there

have been still environmental condition and

regional variations. [74]

Image 1: Turkish House [74]

C.1922 Harikzedegân Apartment

After the infamous fireplace that

burnt off seven.500 homes within the

neighbourhoods of Cibali and Fatih on might

thirty one, 1918 a campaign was organized

to compose shelters for the victims. Apart

from the efforts of the government, civil

donations were additionally accepted for that

purpose and therefore the Harikzedegan

(the victims of the fire) apartment buildings

were planned and built from the years 1918

through 1922 by the architect Kemaleddin

Bey. The buildings are necessary examples

therein bring that event of the Turkish history

and therefore the local Turkish architecture.

The buildings were at first named “Tayyare

(Aeroplane) apartment Buildings”, the

previous name of the Turkish Aviation

League. [80]

Image 6: Harikzedegân Apartment [81]

52


B.1848 Building Regulation

In 1848 Ministry of Public Works was established in order

to construct a central authority for urban planning and

regulations. In 1848 and 1849 two building regulations were

issued, which were similar to 1839 Record with differences

in only two subjects, building heights and expropriation. The

latter one was a new concept, which allowed the widening of

roads as implied by the regulations.

1848 Building Regulation defined rules both for streets

and buildings (commercial and residential). The regulation

prohibited the projection from the buildings; therefore it was

not possible to get a building permit for a new construction

unless the required distance was left for the street. If there

was a damaged building or a public interest for demolishing

a building and the government offered to pay its price, this

regulation obliged the owner to sell or demolish the building.

The regulation included the public buildings as well. When a

public building existed in a fire-burnt area, in order to regularize

the street lines during the reconstruction, the necessary space

would be taken from the courtyard.[77]

Image 3: Plan of Aksaray after the reconstruction in 1850s (Ayverdi, 1958, map no.

C3 and C4) The Beauties of the Bosphorus [77]

RESEARCH

C.1875 Akaretler Row Houses

‘Akaretler row houses’ are situated in Besiktas district in Istanbul.

The row houses have been ordered by Ottoman Sultan Abdulaziz

to architect Sarkis Balyan in 1874 and consist of 138 housing units.

They were originally built for the accommodation of the workers of

Dolmabahce Palace. ‘Akaretler row houses’ are one of the most

important examples in Istanbul of this housing option.

The owner of the houses was General Directorate of Foundations.

The houses have changed habitants many times. They used to be

rented for many years as houses to low income earners, car repairers,

traditional grocery keepers. They were also used by a political party

and also by Faculty of Fine Arts in 1980’s. Afterwards, they have

been abandoned until about 1995 when they have been restorated

and renovated to be rented again. Finally, restoration and renovation

of the row houses complex was finished in 2008. In this complex,

56 residences in different sizes, 34 shops and also W Hotel were

opened.

The area of the row houses is situated in between Besiktas and

Nisantasi on a steep ramp. One of the end of the row houses is

Besiktas which is an traditional district, whereas the other end is a

trendy zone called Nisantasi. Soon after the opening in 2008, many

of the high society shops have been changed into coffee shops

and bars mostly thanks to the location. When you walk down to

Besiktas passing through the row houses you can find trendy bars,

coffee shops, jewellery shops, antiquarie shop, W hotel, shops like

Marni, Bottega Veneta... Arriving down to Besiktas you find traditional

restaurants such as döner, pide, traditional coffee shops, fish

markets… a mixture of colours, lights, odors of the East that compete

with Western way of communication of ‘Akaretler row houses’. [78]

Image 4: Akaretler Row Houses [78]

53


HISTORY

1923

A. THRESHOLDS

Industrial Incentive Policy

This policy has not been as useful as

expected due to the economic crisis

in the world. As a result, in 1932, the

government decided that the state

should undertake basic investments

based on production.

1923-1929

The People’s Party is the first political

party of Turkey: In 1935, the name of the

party was “Republican People’s Party”.

1924

In 1924 the Terakkiperver Cumhuriyet

Party was founded. It was closed in 1925.

1924

Nakiye Elgun: She is reading the

declaration of the rights of the child at

the Taksim Square in 1930.

1930

B. LAWS

Constitution (1924)

Rene and Raymond Danger İzmir

Master Plan (1924)

1924

Carl Christoph Lörcher’s Ankara

Plans :A City Dream Reflecting Anti-

Modernist and Authoritarian Trends

1924-1925

Industrial Incentives Law

These incentives are provided by law

for the production of private enterprises

in building materials, non-smoking

building materials produced in verilmiştir.

türkiye allow duty-free import of this law,

reinforced concrete construction with

cement and steel, the main material,

insulation materials used for flat roofs,

large construction equipment, fine

construction materials and finishing

materials have been imported.

1927

Hermann Jansen Ankara Master plan

1928

C. DWELLING

1923

Melek

Apartment

Nişantaşı

Bahçelievler Building Cooperative

Hermann Jansen, Ankara

1932

Ragıp Devres’ Villa-The Swiss-

Austrian architect Ernst Egli, Bebek

İstanbul: One of the first examples of

modern architecture in Istanbul.

1932

1933

Üçler

Apartment,

Talimhane:

First

appearance

of the

concept

of “rental

house“

D. CULTURE

How should we decorate our houses?

SÜS Magazine SAYI 48

1926

1927

Nutuk

This book

describes the

history of the

republic of

Turkey.

‘Excellent and illustrated etiquette

guide’ Book - Abdullah Cevdet

1927

1931

Peyami

Safa’s novel

Fatih-Harbiye,

the author

describes

the pain of

modernization

in society

through

objects,

individuals,

institutions and

spaces

E. SOCIAL LIFE

Civil Law

1926

Nation Gardens inspired by the French

Public Gardens after the Constitutional

Monarchy, it was designed as an

Ottoman club, library and theater

structures in order to socialize the

society.

1932

Women’s miting to thank Atatürk

1934

Beer Garden, Bomonti

1930

Founding of Real Estate Bank

The finance ministry was authorized by

the government to use budget to build

houses for civil servants

Lodging houses in the beginning

of 1930s: Social housing projects for

workers as low-cost, easy to build,

rational, affordable.

Founding of Turkish Cooperatives

Institution

F. ECONOMY

1926

1928

1930s

1931

54


1945

First Five-Year Industrialization Plan

The greatest weight was given to the

weaving sector. Most of the factories

were built with Soviet credit and

technology. Importance was given to the

construction of railways

Ismet Inonu

was elected

president.

National

Chief

Village institutes in Turkey was

established in 1940 to train primary

school teachers.

National Protection Law

Capital tax

1934

1938

1940

1940-1942

RESEARCH

Law on the Ministry and Devair

Buildings and Civil Servant

Apartments to be Built in Ankara,

1928

Land Reform, 1929

Municipal Law, 1930

Establishment of municipal zoning

committee, 1933

Municipal building and roads law,

1933

Title Deed Law, 1934

Municipality Expropriation Law

Henry Prost İstanbul masterplan

(1937)

Law on the Construction of civil

servant dwellings

The immovables deemed necessary

for the implementation of this law shall

be expropriated in accordance with the

provisions of Municipal Expropriation

Law no.

1928-1934

1934

1937

1944

Kozlu Zonguldak M.K.İ. Workers

Houses- Zonguldak

Seyfi Arkan

Kozlu Zonguldak M.K.İ. Workers

Houses- Zonguldak

Seyfi Arkan- Bauhaus style

Tüten Apartment:

There were

budgerigars in our

apartments and

flowers in front

of our windows.

The surrounding

apartments have

increased. Yet

everyone who

crossed the street

looked at this.

Daw of a New Day- Expo 39 in New

York Turkey Pavilion Sedad Hakkı

Eldem

1934

1934

1936

1946

Independent

Painters and

Sculptors

Association

Exhibition

Nation Gardens inspired by the French

Public Gardens after the Constitutional

Monarchy, it was designed as an

Ottoman club, library and theater

structures in order to socialize the

society.

Lüküs

Hayat

Musical

Aysel Bataklı Damın Kızı: The first

movie shot on villages in Turkey

1931

1932

1933

1934

Salacak Beach

Republic village project

Yapı Kredi

Bank

Poster

First housing

bonus

Poster for ‘The

Association

for

Combatting

Rudeness’’

Ihap

Hulusi

1937

1937

1944

1945

Founding of Sümerbank and

Halkbank to support of artisans housing

cooperatives.

With the National Protection Law

enacted in 1939, it was decided to

restrict housing rents and this limitation

lasted until 1963.

Civil Servants Housing: Saraçoglu

Neighbourhood by Paul Bonatz

First housing bonus has given by “Yapı

Kredi Bank” in 1944 for the first time.

1933

1939

1944

1944

55


HISTORY

D.1926 Süs Magazine

How should we decorate our houses? The article

within the magazine mentions that the furnishing of

the rooms has become more important and also

the choice of furniture requires more responsibility.

It emphasizes that the rooms aren’t designed with

some furniture like before, and also the points to be

considered in choosing the acceptable furniture.

Designed in artistic movement style, this room features

upholstered armchairs, wallpapers, a corner tea table

with tapered sections, a functional buffet and an

identical curtain and chandelier.

It is a room design with angular and infrequently

decorated with exotic materials, polished with a

highly polished finish, geometric shapes, small and

thin decorations, and cosy, easy-to-use furniture.

The room design, which is in line with the free plan

understanding, where handwork is seen from time

to time, includes both the fluid lines of art nouveau

and Bauhaus’s simplicity, is an example of art deco

approach. [85]

Image 9: Süs magazine [85]

C.1932 Bahçelievler Housing Cooperative, Hermann Jansen

Bahçelievler residential campus was designed

between 1935-38 by Hermann Jansen, who won

the international competition to plan the development

of Ankara. The campus, which was realized by

Bahçelievler Cooperative, was built on a land in

the west of Ankara, outside the boundaries of the

development plan of the period. Although Jansen’s

initial plan included single, twin and row houses

proportionally, the majority of the houses in the project

were realized as single houses within the garden,

with adaptations by local architects in line with the

demands of the members of the cooperative.

Bahçelievler Cooperative, which was an example

by leading the cooperatives established to meet the

housing needs of the rapidly increasing population of

the capital Ankara in the early years of the Republic,

was responding to the space needs of the modern life

of the bureaucrat class of the period. These houses,

with their rooms, balconies and simple facades, which

assumed different functions, offered a choice away

from traditional residential typology. The structures of

this campus, which applied the Garden City model

with its sparse settlement texture, were demolished

over time and replaced with high apartment blocks. Of

the garden dwellings of Jansen’s design, only a few

structures have survived to the present day. [86]

Image 10: Bahçelievler Housing Cooperative, Hermann Jansen [87]

56


C.1936 Tüten Apartment

The building, one of the most important examples of the struggle

for modernity given in the interior and exterior spaces of the house,

is located on Gümüssuyu, Inönü Street, one of the most important

axes of the city’s apartment building process. The building owned by

the tobacco merchant Sabri Tüten is designed by Adil Denktas. The

circular staircase of the building, consisting of ten storeys, with large

square metres of flats, is located on the side facade in an adjacent

plot. All the rooms in the apartment are drawn from both sides and

side facades and open to light and courtyards, providing natural light

and ventilation. The street facade, which gives the building its original

character, is dominated by curvilinear lines in the plan and facade

openings. Horizontal band windows that open in accordance with

the rounded facade of the hall and the outward curvilinear balcony

emphasize the curvilinear and horizontal continuity of the facade. [88]

RESEARCH

Image 11: Tüten Apartment [89]

C.1937 Republic Village Project

In the plan under both the intellectual and formal

influence of E. Howard’s garden-city theory, the

settlement was designed as circular.

In the first series of buildings surrounding the square

with a monument in the middle, there are various

public buildings and parks such as school, village

mansion, public room, cooperative, hotel, public

toilet. The second series was completely devoted

to housing. Half of the third series is devoted to

large open spaces such as nurseries, guilds, sports

fields, and public buildings such as nursery buildings

and factories. In the immediate vicinity of the village,

functions such as the cemetery, fertilizer, fairground,

forest areas, which are thought to be outside the

village, were defined. Although this project draws

attention with its architectural form, the public functions

it contains and the new rural life model it proposes are

more interesting. [90]

Image 12: Republic Village Project [91]

57


HISTORY

1945

A. THRESHOLDS

1947

Marshall

Aid

The first

substantial

aid went

to Greece

and Turkey

in January

1947.

Democratic Party founded: The DP

defended liberal regulations in economy

and politics.

1946

In 1950s started with a multi-party

system and a liberal economic

development model where priority was

given to rapid industrialization and

urbanization.

1950s

Turkey was accepted into NATO:

Turkish membership to NATO can be

regarded a solution to her security

problems, but it may well be argued

that the main cause behind that policy

was the continuation of the polices of

westernization and modernization.

1951

B. LAWS

Building Construction Incentive Law

Unlike the first law at the local level, Law

No. 5228 stipulates that land can be

produced within the boundaries of the

zoning plan at the country level.

1948

Incentive and Unauthorized Building

Construction Buildings Law

The lands belonging to the municipality

within the boundaries of the municipality

and which will become the property of

the municipality shall be determined by

the decision of the municipal council and

allocated for the construction of houses.

1953

The Condominium Law, which was

passed in 1965, encouraged the

demolition of single family housing units

to build multi-family apartment

blocks in their places.

1965

Zoning Law, 1956

Constitution State, 1961, the

characteristics of cities and

environmental conditions within the

framework of careful planning, to meet

housing needs takes measures and

supports public housing enterprises

The Condominium Law, which was

passed in 1965, encouraged the

demolition of single family housing units

to build multi-family apartment

blocks in their places.

1956-1965

Small Villa, (57,00 m 2 )

Architect Rahmi Bediz

The first slums were built by immigrants

who came to work in the city. They built

these houses by imece method

The housing estates of Emlak Kredi

Bank were built on Levent Farm, Levent

İstanbul.

German Tower Houses - İzmir 27 sqm

44 residences for Roma

C. DWELLING

1947

1947

1950-1953

1960

Füreya Koral

The first

ceramics

workshop in

Turkey

Zeki Müren ‘The Sun of Art, had his

first live concert on 26 May 1955. He

would usually wear his self-designed

clothes on stage.

First reconstruction congress

Bus Travelers

film

D. CULTURE

1951

1955

1955

1961

Porter/Tunny Akaretler Beşiktaş

Migros - Mobile Market

Village Institutes closed

Tokalon

Cream

Advertising

E. SOCIAL LIFE

1951

1954

1954

1959

Emergence of slums in Zeytinburnu,

İstanbul: With the industrialization the

communities who are migrated the

metropolitan to get jobs in factories,

settled on public lands illegally.

2nd Turkish

Economy

Congress

Bank Lottery Houses: From the

beginning of 1950s until the end of

1970s, it occurred as an important

production and development culture of

housing in Turkey.

Social Insurance Institution has built

more than 200,000 houses for workers

between 1952 and 1984.

F. ECONOMY

1947

1948

1950s

1952-1984

58


1980

The Military Coup and a liberal

economic development model

where priority was given to rapid

industrialization and urbanization.

68 generations: Yankee go home!

Student actions-Yön magazine-DISK

actions

The Military Coup

“to bring peace to a polarized society

where thousands of people were being

killed on the streets.”

24th January Decisions: Neoliberal

economic policies started with Turgut

Özal in 1980.

1960

The Squatter Law, which was passed in

1966, aimed to prevent, demolish or

rehabilitate squatter settlements which

had been widely spread in urban

areas since the 1950s.

1968

Cooperatives Law, 1969.

The Land Office, established in 1969,

aimed to produce cheap land with

infrastructure to provide low-cost housing

in cities under population

pressure.

Land and Agricultural Reform Law,

1973.

In 1977, the Constitutional Court

annulled the this law.

1980

Corporate Housing Law, 1981.

1982 Constitution

57 of the social and economic rights

section of the 1982 Constitution, we can

see that housing is regulated under the

title of housing right.

1980

Law on Metropolitan Municipalities,

1984.

Expropriation Law, 1983.

Corporate Housing and Presidency

of Public Partnership Administration

Law, 1984.

RESEARCH

1966

1969-1977

1981-1982

1983-1984

Ataköy 1st Stage

The first camp portable homes in

Turkey two rooms on the left with kitchen

and one room on the right with kitchen

Floating House Bosporus

Earthquake shelters like igloo

established by The Farben-Bayer

Company in the Gediz earthquake.

1961

1965

1970

1970

Keşanlı Ali

Destanı

Cinema

The film takes

place in a

slum called

Sineklidağ.

(Hoca Hüsrev

and Kuştepe)

Housing

Congress

Cartography

Engineers,

Electrical

Engineers,

Civil

Engineers,

Architects,

and Urban

Planners

Kapıcılar

Kralı

Cinema

Arabesque Music

1964

1974

1976

1980s

Open-air cinema, was one of Turkey’s

most important entertainment and

socializing area- Adana

Nebioğlu Resorts, the “resort” concept

was first built with tourist facilities in

Turkey

Colour television

Miltur Tatil Sitesi- Kumbağ

Kılıç Ailesi Arşivi

1968

1969

1980

1980

Condominium law: For middle-class to

had their own housing needs. It caused

to build-sell system.

First 5-year Developing Plan: The

housing problem has been dealt with

for the first time as a whole and its

relationship with development has

been established. The concept of social

housing has been discovered and ways

of making cheap and small housing have

been sought.

Effect of Oil Crisis on Turkey

National Housing Policy: It had

aimed to produce affordable housing

in accordance with Turkish-Islamic

traditions. It provided the allocation of

land, projects and basic construction

materials to public housing institutions.

1955

1963-1967

1973

1980

59


HISTORY

C.1950 Levent Neighbourhood Houses

The construction of the first houses of Levent, which forms the

core of today’s Levent district, was started in 1947 within the

framework of the housing projects of Emlak Kredi Bank and

the first neighborhood was finished in 1950. At a time when

the average monthly wage was 500 pounds, house prices

here were between 14,000 and 60,000 pounds (with 20-year

interest). Despite its relative distance from the city centre,

Levent has long been home to the middle classes and civil

servants. The Levent project, which was later continued with

the second, third and fourth neighborhoods, was completed

in 1960.

Levent, one of the few examples of the Republican period

for modern urban life (for example, another is the Saracoglu

district in Ankara), is also a very progressive ecological project

in its era, with about 30,000 trees that are now adults. For

the same reason, today, a Yesil area around the Istanbul

Metropolis is a “garden-city”.

Levent, which was influenced by the urban transformation

process that accelerated in the 1980s and the central

business areas that shifted to the north by the construction

of the Bosphorus Bridges, is today under the pressure of a

physical and social transformation. Levent is a protected area

within the Istanbul metropolis due to its very different historical,

natural and social features. [103]

Image 19: Levent in 1950 [104]

C.1969 Nebioğlu Resorts

Nebioglu Tourist Facilities was opened in 1969 in

Çesmealtı, concerning thirty kilometre from Izmir.

Also bungalow-type units have a unique position

within the contemporary architectural heritage in

Turkey because of the reinforced concrete domeshaped

rooms.

Nebioglu Tourist Facilities area unit few samples of

a contemporary era in harmony and balance with

natural life.

Even throughout the land arrangement and

construction, no huge machinery was introduced

into the land. Even during the construction process,

it is a project that considers harmony with nature.

These ecological concerns continued during the

landscaping process.[109]

Image 22: Nebioğlu Resorts [109]

60


C.1970 Floating House in Bosphorus

Koray and Gömüç’s project was praised in the newspapers

of the period in the context of having an American Bar and

referencing the two-storey chalet/Hut (Melih Koray Archive).

At this point, it should be emphasized that the interaction

between America and Turkey in the 1950s was very important.

America perceives Russia’s ideology of communism as a

threat and gives various assistance to the country to improve

its relations with Turkey, as it considers Turkey to be highly

vulnerable to this threat. For this reason, the daily life in Turkey

and the culture, art life, especially the practice of architecture

are influenced by America. Therefore, the American Bar

emphasis on this naval home can be read as a reference to

how effective post-war American everyday life and architecture

approach is still for Turkey. The emphasis on the chalet can be

attributed to the reconsideration of the wooden hut, an ancient

archetype of architecture, by the architects. In fact, it can

be thought that the architect, who seems to have followed

overseas publications and architectural approaches from

his personal archive, also reflects the idea of the weekend

house, which was often seen around the world in the 1960s.

The summer house of Jens Risom, who applied both the

practice of mass production and the concept of the chalet

project, may have inspired Melih Koray and Ergin Gömüç as

an example of the premise at this point. Thus it can be said

that the ideas of a modernist floating house and mountain are

brought together in the catamaran House. [110]

Image 23: Floating Catamaran House [110]

RESEARCH

D.1970 Iglo Shelter in Akcaalan

Gediz Earthquake occurred on March 28, 1970.

The earthquake affected an area of about 3,000

square kilometers. Approximately 3,500 houses were

completely demolished, 7,000 heavily damaged and

10600 buildings damaged. 33000 families, about

80000 people remained without shelter. Relief aid

was sent from many countries and organizations,

disasters. West Germany’s contribution to the massive

problem of restoration cant in several ways. First,

aid in the form of food was immediate. Quickly sent

115 plane-loads of supplies. Secondly, it provided

team to construct, for the first time after a disaster, a

new form that resembles an igloo. The Farben-Bayer

Company of West unique shelters, 300 of which were

assembled within days of the Akcaalan. The shelter

is a dome-shaped styrofoam shell about four thick,

with a sixteen-foot diameter on the ground. It is cast

at the styrofoam substance on an inflated balloon. The

shell is then proofing compound and can be set into

place by two men. After doorway and circular ports for

windows are cut out for plastic “igloos” appeared badly

weathered but were still being used in Akçaalan. [105]

Image 20: The Fırst Tıme Published Images Of The 1970 Gediz Earthquake [106]

61


HISTORY

1980

A. THRESHOLDS

1983

Turgut

Özal was

the ruler

alone

In 1987, the public was asked whether

politicians who were politically banned by

the provisional article of the Constitution

after the 1980 coup would be abolished.

The people wanted the bans to be lifted.

1987

Fatih Sultan Mehmet Bridge

1988

5th April Decisions

1994

B. LAWS

Law on the protection of cultural and

natural assets, 1982.

Five zoning forgiveness, 1982-1987.

1982-1987

The Mass Housing Law

The Mass Housing Law, which was

passed in 1984, was a comprehensive

law which aimed to encourage large

scale and prefabricated housing, and

for the first time was provided with an

independent budget, financial support

and an institutional framework to carry

out its mission.

1984

Law that allows foreigners to buy real

estates in Turkey, Turkey was adopted

by the Grand National Assembly.

1986

Constitutional Referendum: political

bans lifted after coup.

1987

Kemer Country

Sarıgazi, Samandıra and Sultanbeyli

developed as a slum city consisting of

illegal apartments”

First 1+1 Studio Flat- Ataköy

In 1992, thousand 300 houses in

European standards will be made with

the Esenkent project, rural origin,

Istanbul residents will be shown as an

example of city life ‘

C. DWELLING

1986

1985

1987

1992

D. CULTURE

1980

Aysegul of

family life

and the life

was like in

no turkey

conditions.

They live in

a luxurious

mansion

with a

garden,

garden of

the church.

1987

Muhsin

Bey:

Directed

by Yavuz

Turgul

Sesame Street - TRT: The aim of

Sesame Street was to have an idea

about the learning ability of children

between the ages of 3-5.

1989

Bizimkiler Series

The daily life of seven different families

living in the same apartment is a series

about their relations with each other.

1989-2002

E. SOCIAL LIFE

Consumer culture, moda,

advertisements

1986

1986

First

restaurant

of a global

fast-food

chain in

Taksim

The Jetsons in Turkey

1990

Ataköy Şirinevler Civilization Bridge

1990

Emergence of ‘post-gecekondu’:

After zoning amnesty 3 to 7 storeys

slums has been emerged.

Founding of Public Housing

Administration and Funds of Housing:

It founded by President Turgut Özal in

1984 to production of social housing.

Increasing of co-operatives: The

number of housing cooperatives

increased from 279 in 1983 to 5201 in

1987.

The Public Housing Administration

has started to produce houses for

immigrants from Bulgaria

F. ECONOMY

1982

1984

1984

1989

62


2002

Customs Union Agreement was

signed with EU.

1995

Gölcük Earthquake

1999

2001 economic crisis: It causes the

change of the government.

2001

2001

Kemal

Derviş

He resigned

from the

World Bank

and became

State Minister

in charge of

the economy.

He conducted

negotiations

with the IMF.

RESEARCH

1995 Constitutional amendment

With the constitutional amendments

of 1995 and 2001, the constitutional

guarantees for political parties were

significantly strengthened.

Following the 17th August earthquake,

the first criminal decision

was given in the cases against the

contractor. Contractor Kemal Uz, who

was responsible for Pelit Building

Cooperative, who built an apartment

in Yalova, where 20 people died, was

sentenced to 4 years in prison.

Transfer of shares controlled by

Emlak Bank to TOKİ, 2001.

Repeal of the Mass Housing Fund,

2001.

Realization of G status after the

transfer of Emlak Bank’s shares to

TOKİ.

1995

2000

2001

2002

Ataşehir- Satellite town- Emlak Bank

Alker technique-Prof. Dr. Ruhi

Kafesçioğlu İTÜ Ayazağa Campus

Paper Log House- Shigeru Ban after

marmara earthquake

TOKİ has been producing mass housing

for the 1999 earthquake

1993

1993

2000

2000

C Block- Directed by Zeki Demirkubuz

Eşkıya:

Directed

by Yavuz

Turgul

Habitat II

Istanbul

Someone is watching us

Turkey and the reality show which is a

phenomenon in the world.

1994

1996

1996

2001

Neighborhood culture: kids playing on

the street

In 28th April 1993, a methane explosion

shook a slum quarter in Ümraniye, a

district of Iıstanbul.

Alken 2000 Büyükçekmece

‘Yours New World’

Residential Marketing Strategies

1990

1993

1996

2000

Implementing Regulation on the

Production and Crediting of Mass

Housing and Urban Environment on

Municipal Lands

Gölcük Earthquake: It causes the 2001

economic crisis.

Increased state-capital cooperation:

The capitalization of the city

“Throwing the Constitution booklet”

The stock market fell by 14.6 percent,

repo interest rates jumped to 760

percent, foreign exchange outflow was

$ 7.6 billion. 510 thousand people were

unemployed. Black Wednesday

1992

1999

2000s

2001

63


HISTORY

B.1984 The Mass Housing Law

The “Right of Shelter” was included as a paragraph

heading in the 1982 Constitution for the first time:

“State takes necessary steps to provide for the

housing need within a planning context that reflects the

special characteristics and environmental conditions

of cities and also supports the construction of large

scale housing”. Thus, while in the previous period the

government acted as a regulator, the new policy was

to play an active role in the provision of housing.

The Mass Housing Law, which was passed in 1984,

was a comprehensive law which aimed to encourage

large scale and prefabricated housing, and for the

first time was provided with an independent budget,

financial support and an institutional framework to

carry out its mission. Financial support was provided

by the Mass Housing Fund, which was developed

independent of the national budget, and the Mass

Housing Administration was attached directly to the

Prime Ministry with the objective of participating in

house production. Priority was given to large scale

construction firms that used industialized construction

techniques.[113]

Image 25: Göztepe Soyak Housing Development [114]

D.1996 Istanbul Declaration on Human Settlements

We, the Heads of State or Government and the official delegations

of countries assembled at the United Nations Conference on Human

Settlements (Habitat II) in Istanbul, Turkey from 3 to 14 June 1996, take this

opportunity to endorse the universal goals of ensuring adequate shelter for all

and making human settlements safer, healthier and more liveable, equitable,

sustainable and productive. Our deliberations on the two major themes of

the Conference - adequate shelter for all and sustainable human settlements

development in an urbanizing world - have been inspired by the Charter

of the United Nations and are aimed at reaffirming existing and forging

new partnerships for action at the international, national and local levels to

improve our living environment. We commit ourselves to the objectives,

principles and recommendations contained in the Habitat Agenda and

pledge our mutual support for its implementation [121]

Image 30: HABITAT II Poster [121]

64


C.2000 Paper Log House

Shigeru Ban, noted for his paper houses in Kobe and

Rwanda, came to Turkey to help the earthquake victims. He

brought 30 grand with him. He received a promise of support

from a firm in Bursa. $1750 worth of houses, cardboard,

beer cans, fabric and plywood! The famous Japanese

architect Shigeru Ban came to Turkey to build houses out

of compressed paper with his own method. The architect,

who was carry out a joint work with the Human Settlements

Association, have built houses in Degirmendere that are

resistant to all kinds of natural disasters. Shigeru Ban collected

30,000 dollars and brought 500 tent cloths for the earthquake

victims in Turkey in his own country. The cost of the house

from the paper developed by Shigeru Ban is very low. It can

easily be made from recycled paper, even by someone with

no knowledge of construction. Construction of a house takes

two days when the necessary supplies are provided. The

purpose of these houses, which are absolutely unharmed

by hurricanes and earthquakes, is to protect people from

cold and rainy weather. The famous architect says: “I found

a company in Bursa that produces rolls made of cardboard,

which is the main material of these houses. They promised

to provide support. A house costs around $1750. I need 50

grand for these paper houses to accommodate 120 people in

the first place.” [123]

Image 31: Paper Log House

Courtesy of Shigeru Ban Architects [124]

RESEARCH

C.1993 İTÜ Alker House

Alker is an earth-based stabilized building material

produced by the addition of gypsum, lime, and water

to earth with the acceptable granulometric structure

and with a cohesive property. Unbaked and produced

on-site either as adobe blocks or by pouring into

mouldings (the rammed earth technique), it’s significant

economic and ecological advantages. The word Alker

is an abbreviation combining the primary syllables of

the Turkish words for gypsum (alçı) and adobe (kerpiç).

Alker was inspired by a conventional plaster material

consisting of a mix of earth, gypsum and lime, which

has been in use within the earthen architecture of

Anatolia since the Neolithic era thanks to its high water

resistance. At the start of those studies at Istanbul

Technical University, professor Ruhi Kafesçioglu was

found for years. [119]

Image 29: Alker House [120]

65


HISTORY

2002

AK Party wins elections

Turkey is the first country of reception for

Syrians refugees escaping the civil war.

‘Open Door’ Policy

Occupy Gezi

301 people were killed in what was

the worst mine disaster in Turkey’s

history.

A. THRESHOLDS

2002

2011

2013

2014

TOKI Reconstruction

The Law Recognizing The

Authority To Make The Plan (Slum

Transformation Project Applicable

Areas), 2004.

Tourism Incentive Law, 2003.

Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) Law,

2003.

Metropolitan Municipality Law

Law authorizing the Housing

Development Administration to make

maps and zoning plans of slum

reclamation and prevention areas

The Soil Conservation and Land Use

Law from provided a framework for the

State to regulate land uses leading to

significant soil deterioration.

B. LAWS

2003-2004

2004

2004

2005

B2 House - Han Tümertekin, a winner of

2004 Aga Khan Award for Architecture

Çanakkale

The Dark Side Of Urban Renewal:

Gentrification,Sulukule

Displacement, Spatial Exclusion

New era in architecture: LOFT

Levent Loft

Urban transformation- Istanbul

Bağdat Street

C. DWELLING

2004

2005

2006

2012

Sustainable Living Film Festival

Tahribad-ı İsyan- Rap Group Sulukule

Ekümenopolis- Documantary

Fikirtepe covered in dust” by

140journos - video

D. CULTURE

2007

2008

2011

2014

Roma of

The

Sulukule

Silent victims of urban transformation:

The Elderly

İmece House Ecovillage

New Peasantry

Çuva-Alakır River Brotherhood

E. SOCIAL LIFE

2009

2012

2013

2015

Law allowing TOKI to make zoning

plan in areas where squatter

transformation project will be

implemented

2008 economic crisis: Impacts of

mortgage crisis (great recession) on

Turkey.

At the beginning of 2010 state-capital

housing projects has increased: The

commercial value has been more than

important than exchange value.

Syrian refugee policy

F. ECONOMY

2004

2008

2010

2011

66


2019

Recep Tayyip Erdoğan is a Turkish

politician serving as President of

Turkey since 2014.

July 15 coup attempt

Global Objectives for sustainable

development

Turkish local elections

İstanbul-Ankara-İzmir

2014

The authority of the Ministry of Public

Works is transferred to TOKİ.

2015

Adoption of the law which partially

exempts Emlak Konut from all capital

market regulations applicable to other

REITs (excluding tax exemption).

2015

Municipalities have been granted wide

authority on the implementation of

urban transformation and development

projects with the amendment to

the Municipal Law.

2019

Planned Areas Zoning Regulation

One of the most significant changes

brought into effect by the Regulation is

the abolishment of studio apartments,

which are defined as dwellings that

consist of one main room and one

bathroom. every single detached

dwelling must consist of at least: (1)

one living room, (2) one bedroom, (3)

one kitchen or cooking area, (4) one

bathroom or washing area, and (5) one

toilet.

RESEARCH

2007

2007

2010

2019

Slum Apartment Urban

Transformation- Küçükçekmece

Tezek Evleri- İstanbul

Fold and Float

Istanbul Design Biennial

ReYard House

Solar Decathlon Africa Competition 2019

competition

2015

2016

2018

2019

Go home

before it’s

late

exhibition

Turkey’s zero waste project, led by

First Lady Erdogan, aims to reduce

volume of non-recyclable waste.

25 liters -

Documantary

16th Istanbul

Biennial

Unveils Artist

List For The

Seventh

Continent

Ozan Atalan- Monokrom

16th Istanbul Biennial Unveils Artist List

For The Seventh Continent

2016

2017

2019

2019

Refugee Camp Sanlıurfa

Örnekköy, Uzundere

Houses have been transformed but

habits have not changed.

Tiny House Family

New happy advertising family

Urban Transformation Advertising

2015

2016

2017

2019

Law on Transforming Areas at Risk

of Disaster

Düzce Umut Atölyesi: After the Düzce

Earthquake, the victims has organized

and they found Düzce Umut Atölyesi

in 2015.

Beginning of the stagflation: collapse

of construction sector with heavy inflation

and unemployment.

Zoning

amnesty:

To revive the

economy,

the zoning

peace law

was enacted

before the

election.

2012

2015

2018

2019

67


HISTORY

D.2011 Ecumenopolis

“Ecumenopolis: city without Limits” tells the story of

Istanbul and alternative Mega-Cities on a neo-liberal

course to destruction. It follows the story of a migrant

family from the demolition of their neighbourhood to

their on-going struggle for housing rights. The film

takes a look at city on a macro level and via the eyes

of professional, going from the crack of mushrooming

skyscrapers to the depths of the railway tunnel below

the Bosphorous strait; from the historic neighbourhoods

at intervals the south to the forests at intervals the

north; from isolated islands of impoverishment to the

villas of the wealthy. It’s an Istanbul going from fifteen

million to thirty million. It’s an Istanbul going from a pair

of million cars to eight million. It’s the Istanbul of the

longer term which can presently engulf the complete

region.[129]

Image 34: Ecumenopolis [129]

F.2015 Düzce Umut Evleri

After the 1999 Marmara earthquake, tenant earthquake

victims started their struggle for the right to housing in 2003

by establishing the ‘Homeless Earthquake Victims Housing

Cooperative’. After 15 years of struggle, the state allocated a

plot of land for the earthquake victims. Tenant earthquake victims

made an open call to co-design the neighborhood where they

lived. People from many different disciplines and colleagues

who responded to this open call founded the “Düzce Umut

Atölyesi” in 2015. Their main goal was to show that it was

possible to ‘produce together’, especially against monopolizing

housing production after 2000. In this sense, they constantly

reminded them that they are a part of this design by including the

neighborhood in the work and tried to understand the ways and

wishes of the members in order to produce user-oriented designs.

For example, the determination of the site plan, the number of

floors of the housing units, such as decisions, the residents will

live on the model is determined by the experience of the area. In

this way, the members of the cooperative developed more realistic

predictions by foreseeing the land conditions. They also played

an important role in the development of architectural projects and

public spaces. Public spaces are designed as organic garden,

community center and urban gardens. In addition, a ‘women’s

production cooperative’ was established and a cooperative

kitchen was built in order to generate revenue. As a result,

the idea put forward by Düzce Umut Atölyesi has enabled the

lowincome neighbourhoods to reach affordable housing. It went

beyond being affordable housing and offered a strong communal

life with the public and communal spaces it created. [132]

Image 37: Determining on Site Plan with Participatory Process [132]

68


E.2013 Imece House- Ecovillage

Imece house-even if it is only a temporary part- the only

conditions are to be able to get your own responsibility;

not being under psychologic treatment; not having any

addictions such as to smoking, alcohol, drugs etc; to be

an adult or accompanied by your parents; to know how to

listen rather than talk; to desire being a part of a big family

and to volunteer for any possible duties. Our expectations

from those, especially the volunteers, we share the Imece

areas with: Do not bring any substances causing addiction,

beverages with gas, any plastic covers and/or plastic bottles.

In stead of those, take your will of cooperation, your love,

your knowledge, your tolerance together with any musical

instruments you play, your tent and sleeping bag to live in

the field-only your sleeping bag is enough if you stay in the

village-, your boots, your raincoat depending on the season

and any special food you like with you!

It can be chilly in the evenings even in mid-summer. Therefore

you should take a warm top with you. You have to have a

hat to protect yourself from the sun during the day and of

course, some light and comfortable shoes. Do not forget your

swimming costume if you wish to swim in the stream or in the

pool of the water-fall to feel cooler.

You can use the WC connected to the drain if you wish to

use your own tooth-paste, shampoo and toilet paper. In all

the other areas, on the other hand, you have to use only the

products we produce for your personal cleaning to be able to

keep the nature under protection. [131]

Image 36: Ecovillage [131]

RESEARCH

C.2018 Fold&Float

Istanbul-based practice SO? has designed and built a

prototype floating structure for post-earthquake relief.

“Fold&Float” is formed of a light, temporary, foldable steel

structure specifically designed for emergency situations.

Developed off the back of emergency assembly points being

designated by the authorities in 2001, SO? questioned where

people could be housed in the event of an earthquake. The

question of where temporary buildings can be built in Istanbul

in the event of earthquake meeting areas and in case of

a possible earthquake was addressed to this project. The

questions have gained added significance in the last twenty

years, with Istanbul having privatized 70% of the land set aside

for emergency assembly. The result was a floating structure

that depends not on vacant, stable land, but on managing

water. Fold&Float is composed of 2 main parts: an upper

structure will fixed, folded furniture, and a floating concrete

pontoon. The attention to quality of living within the structure

is derived from research suggesting that earthquake and

flooding victims spend at least one year in temporary housing

following a disaster.’’The structure’s development coincides

with the ‘Hope On Water’ education project organized at the

4th Istanbul Design Biennial 2018, a collaboration between

civil engineering and sociology students from Bogaziçi

University and architecture students from MEF University.’’ [135]

Image 39: Fold & Float on the Water

Courtesy of SO? Architecture and Ideas [135]

69


STRUCTURAL DURABILITY

This chapter deals with the capability of structures

to withstand loads without unacceptable

degradation. We focus on the subject by asking

what kind of forces the single unit may be

exposed to and which type of precautions should

we take against these forces that may cause

structural damage. Within this research, we

deepen the forces that structures are exposed to

under extreme conditions such as earthquakes,

wind, snow and floods, the effects of these forces

and the precautions that can be taken against

these forces. Also, we investigate how a single

unit establishes a relationship with the ground,

what methods are used to prevent damages that

may occur during the transportation of these

units, and some alternative structural systems

from the past to the present.

Kaiser Dome, Don Ritcher, Hawaii,1957 [122]


EXTERNAL FORCES

Earthquake

Flood

Wind

Snow

FOUNDATION

Mobile

Platform

Wheeled

Sled

Fixed

Platform

Pile

TRANSPORTATION

Loading

Unloading

ALTERNATIVE SYSTEMS

71


STRUCTURAL DURABILITY

EXTERNAL FORCES

Earthquake

Turkey is at risk of earthquakes because of its geographical

position between 2 massive tectonic plates. Düzce

Earthquake has occurred on August seventeen, 1999

and injured population density and economic activity.

According to official figures, 18,337 individuals have died,

and 48,901 individuals were blistered within the earthquake.

The consequences of this earthquake are still present, and

unfortunately, the problems concerning the design of small

buildings to resist lateral forces have been largely neglected

in the engineering literature: ‘’Most of the research and the

development of mathematical tools for studying earthquake

response have concerned themselves with the larger

structures or the structures whose dynamic properties can be

rather simply expressed in mathematical terms.’’ [2]

Dynamic Conditions

During static mode, imposed load (direction is towards gravity)

is carried by slab to beams and then to columns and to foundation.

(Fig.1)

During dynamic mode, imposed load (direction is horizontal to

the floor levels) is in the form of lateral force, which is applied

at the floor level (diaphragm), transferred to the beams and

then to columns and foundations. (Fig.1) This horizontal load

quivers walls, floors, columns, beams and the connectors

that keep them together. The disparity in movement between

the base and top of buildings exerts intense tension triggering

fracturing of the supporting frame and collapsing of the entire

framework. [3]

Static Conditions

(No Earthquake)

Dynamic Conditions

(During an Earthquake)

Image 1: Aluminet tent at Burning Man festival in Nevada. [1]

Figure 1: Static and Dynamic Conditions

A force can cause an object to change its movement or

shape and it can cause permanent damage to the structure.

Building a stable structure is a challenge for designers,

especially in extreme conditions. A detailed analysis of all

forces affecting the structure should be performed. In this

section, we investigate the structure’s behaviour against

external forces such as strong winds, heavy snowfall,

floods, and earthquakes. Instead of seeing these forces as a

handicap, we are looking for ways to exist with them without

harm. As Bucky once said, “Don’t fight with the forces, use

them!”

Figure 2: Displacements of frame structure

Horizontal displacement distributions are given above for multistory

frames under earthquake loads (Fig.2). Each statistic

reflects the heights of storeys, the displacements of storeys,

and the structure’s top displacements [3]

A research analysis of the earthquakes in Turkey since the

1980s reveals that there are 3 errors during the catastrophe

causing more than 95% of the damage. These causes are

faults in building geometry and system selection (vertical

carriers do not have sufficient cross-sectional area),

construction errors and problematic details.[4]

72


RESEARCH

Image 2: Earthquake survivors survey the reconstruction efforts in Yang Liu, China [5]

Earthquake Resistant Building Design

Structural Framing: The building requires a consistent

structure in which the total weight is appropriately distributed.

If this consistency is achieved, the structure becomes stable.

Poor Design

Safer Design

Figure 3: Distribution of the mass

In different configurations of the modules, an equal distribution of the mass is

required.

Braced Frames: It adds additional elements to a frame in

order to increase the ability to withstand lateral loads. Braces

are most commonly of timber or mild steel angles which can

carry compression as well as tension (Fig.4). [6]

Figure 4 : Bracing Frames

STRAIN

‘‘Stress is a measurement of strength.

Strain is a measurement of deformation.

Stress/strain curves are used to describe

the physical properties of materials in

comparison to one another. Steel is an

expensive material when compared with

wood and concrete, but its strength-toweight

serviceability is superior. Able to

be erected quickly, steel is a prevalent

choice in prefabrication. Because of its

strength and speed of erection, steel is

the most economical and efficient material

for structuring long-span, high-rise, and

unique geometric designs.’’ [7]

Figure 5: Stress and strain curves [7]

73


STRUCTURAL DURABILITY

Lightweight Construction: Lightweight construction is

one of the most effective approach for resisting seismic

waves. Because the horizontal force applied by the

earthquake to the structure is directly proportional to the

weight of the structure.

According to Newton’s theorem, as the weight of the structure diminish theoretically,

the earthquake loads affecting the building and the possibility of the building collapse

decreases.

Inertial Response

Ground Motion

Mass

Inertial Force

Earthquake

Acceleration

Figure 6: Newton’s Law Image 3: damage caused by horizontal forces Loma Prieta earthquake, 1989 [8]

LIGHT ARCHITECTURE

Figure 7: Weights Of Buildings By Years [9]

‘‘The recent development of western society could be seen as a development towards lightness. Nothing influenced our

society in the 20th century as strongly as transportation. The concept of worldwide mobility for all became possible with

the invention and mass production of cars, bicycles and aircraft. Movement is a basic concept of the perception of space

and modern time-space automatically incorporates the concept of speed. The everyday use of cars, high speed trains and

aircraft is changing our concepts of physical space. Space becomes lighter and more open, since we can more easily

move through it. The possibilities of transportation make our globe smaller. People become closer together and are exposed

to different cultural concepts. This “being close together” will only be possible by having “light borders”, a process that the

European Community is going through today. But much more than physical borders it needs a lightness of thinking

- tolerance and open-mindedness.’’ [9]

74


RESEARCH

Image 4: Building the earthquake-proof geodesic dome. [10]

‘‘In April 2005, at the University of British Columbia in the

Department of Civil Engineering’s Earthquake Engineering

Research Facility, researchers put the wood frame of a

24 foot-diameter dome to the test on a shake table. The

table simulated several earthquake scenarios and even

heavily loaded, the dome shape enabled it to withstand the

simulations with no damage. The equal distribution of weight

throughout the structure makes it stable during earthquakes

and similar hazards.’’ [11]

1- Foundation and outside seating bench

2- Door frames acting as structural agents within

the framework

3- Wiring of the bracing frames

4- Roof construction

5- Lattice system

6- Clamping profiles connecting

bracing frames and truss system

7- Trusses

Figure 9: Axonometric view revealing the bracing frames in the masonry.[13]

Image 5: Reinforcing tool, a proposal for Building 4 Humanity Design Competition [12]

Image 6: Alternative for bracing [13]

Figure 8: Outline drawing of each emergency reinforcement method [12]

First aid: Proposal for emergency earthquake-resistant reinforcement is an

alternative bracing for wooden building with PP band: The reinforcement method

with the packing band is to provide a simple tensile bracelet. Hang the packing

band tied back using fastening hardware near the joint of columns and beam

material. (Fig.8) (Img.5) [12]

By re-imagining the use of common building materials and systems, the design

team has developed a novel structural lattice system to counter the earthquakeinduced

structural failures. ‘‘The system is based on a latticework of timber batons

that penetrate the stone wall at a grid of 105cm x 60cm. These are secured by an

exterior diagonal bracing grid of galvanized wire and reciprocated on the interior

by vertical timber members and timber boarding. The layered system counters

the effects of wall de-lamination in the event of an earthquake.’’ [13]

75


STRUCTURAL DURABILITY

DISASTER SCENARIO

‘‘This competition called on architects, engineers, designers, and students

from all over the world to design a proposal that tries to produce solutions

for possible disaster scenarios. There were 3 scenarios.’’ [14]

Scenario 1: Island countries affected by earthquakes, storms, and

flooding;

Scenario 2: Mountain and inland areas affected by earthquakes and

landslides; and (Fig.10)

Scenario 3: Coastal areas affected by storms and flooding.

This example is designed for Scenario 2. ‘‘The main challenge in this

scenario is to design a house that is not only an earthquake and landslide

resilient but it also needs to take into account the increasing remoteness

and difficulty in transport as altitude rises. The house is designed with a

heavy stone-filled retaining wall at the bottom and a light wooden structure

on the top. Materials and technologies that would be easily available in

the local context and can be easily transported via small pickup van. A

balance between local knowledge and modern construction techniques

is incorporated in order to encourage community participation and

ownership. Earthquake resilient features are integrated into the traditional

building practices with minor changes to the available skill set so that its

construction does not require expert or non-local craftsmen.’’ [14]

Hazard

Geography

Climate

Added

Challenge

Construction

Cost

Plot

SCENARIO

Earthquakes up to 7.0 on

Richter’s scale also resulting

in landslides

Mountain & inland areas

(example: Nepal, northern

India, Peru etc.)

Harsh winters and mild

summers

Terrain difficulty in

transporting heavy

construction material

Material: $120/sqm

Labour: $50/sqm

Transport: $50/sqm

Assume a 20 m x 20 m

plot size in a rocky terrain

which is part sloping (gentle

gradient)

Figure 10: Disaster Scenario [14]

Shape

The shape of the house is derived from the ratio of

1:2 to make the building profile strong. It also leads

to simplicity of plan, making a stronger earthquake

resistant structure instead of scattered blocks.

Light / Heavy

Heavier load-bearing gabion walls acting as retaining

structure for the sloped site, form the lower level of

the building. A light wooden portal frame with separate

footing inserted in the gabion retaining wall forms the

upper level of the house. Both systems are complete by

themselves giving it enough flexibility and stability during

an earthquake.

Gabion Walls

Traditional random stone masonry, which was generally

used is susceptible to damage in earthquakes.

Gabion walls as retaining structures are very efficient

in earthquake zones. The ductility of the chain-link

cage tied with binding wires and the self-weight of the

stone boulders prevents the walls from falling apart or

cracking at joints.

Portal Frame Bracing Avoiding Gable

Instead of using traditional truss systems, a portal

frame is introduced. During the earthquakes, the

heavier trusses with their rigid joints tend to remain

immobile and slide off the roof. A portal frame with

the pin joint at the junctions and a rigid joint on the

ground enables lateral forces.

Cross bracing made from twisted cables are introduced

to resist lateral forces and K bracing made from wood

to resist shear forces in the portal frame. It prevents the

structure from collapsing onto itself.

Using a hip roof instead of a free-standing gable wall is

a useful strategy to avoid damage to the walls and roof

in earthquake-prone zones. When all walls are tied to

each other, they allow for movement.

Figure 11: Resilient Features for Earthquake Resistant[14]

76


Flood

Flood Resistant Building Design

Flood load is the pressure exerted on a house when it

obstructs the flow of moving water, and it may cause serious

structural damage. These loads cause one of the most

frequent and most damaging disasters in Turkey as well as

in the world. Floods in Turkey mostly seen in April, May, and

June due to the increase in precipitation and snow melts.

Some of the factors that cause flooding are:

• Above-average rainfall

• Extreme snow melting

• Destruction of plants

• Destroying trees

• Settlements established in creek beds

• River / sea water overflow

• Sewerage and groundwater overflow

There are many methods to design a flood-resistant building

(Fig.14). While some solutions methods are related to the

organization of the whole city, others may be smaller-scale

structural interventions. During a critical flood, the structure

may be subject to the horizontal effect of the crashing waves.

This may cause serious damages. Even though there are no

apparent waves at that moment, the accumulation of flood

water around the building may still be moving with an active

current. This movement generates hydrodynamic loads that

constantly attack the structure, damaging it and meanwhile

accumulating sediments against the structure. The weight of

this sediment enhances more pressure to the building and it

contributes to the damage. [16]

Flood-resistant -or damaged resistant- is defined by the NFIP

(National Flood Insurance Program) as “any building product

[material, component or system] capable of withstanding direct

and prolonged contact with flood-waters without sustaining

significant damage.” [17]

RESEARCH

Figure 12: Forces During Flood

‘‘Many people think that if they do not live near a stream or

creek they are not in danger of flooding; however, this is not

true. Flooding is the nation’s number one natural disaster.

Flash floods, inland flooding and seasonal storms flood every

region of the country. Flood maps don’t show all areas at risk!

Flooding may often occur outside the mapped floodplain. It

can also happen along smaller streams and creeks that are

not shown on any flood maps. Non-creek flooding can occur

from overwhelmed storm sewers, low-lying areas that do not

have proper drainage or water mains that break. Much of the

true risk of flooding is its unpredictability.’’ [15]

Flooding is a natural formation that occurs within nature’s

own cycle. Annual flooding may bring benefits to some areas

through nutrient and water replenishment. The transformation

of this into a disaster is a result of the intervention of human

activities on natural balance. (Fig.13)

rate of overflowing water

urbanization

Figure 13: Relation of urbanization to flood risk

Figure 14: Flood-resistant building design [18]

77


STRUCTURAL DURABILITY

Setbacks: Setback levees are earthen embankments that are

located at a distance from a river channel in such a way to

occupy some or all of its natural floodplain during high water

events. [19]

Raised Soil: It is a method of raising land to bring structures

above the flood level.(Fig.17, Img.8)

30 x erosion rate

30 x erosion rate

First line of stable

natural vegetation

Ocean

First line of stable

natural vegetation

Figure 17: Raising Land

Image 8: In La Crosse, fill was added on

Charles Street to elevate new homes above

the floodplain. [22]

Dry Flood-proofing: Water should not be in direct contact

with the structure. In this context, using waterproof materials

provides water resistance during submersion (Fig.18, Img.9).

Primary Dune

Frontal Dune

Ocean

Toe of frontal

dune 30 x erosion rate

First line of stable

natural vegetation

Figure 18: Mobile Barriers Image 9: Mobile Barriers [23]

Ocean

Figure 15: Minimum Setback Example in North Carolina Ocean Erodible Areas [20]

‘‘Your project should be set as far back from the ocean as possible. At minimum,

all buildings must be located behind the crest of the primary dune, the landward

toe of the frontal dune or the erosion setback line’’

Wet Flood-proofing: Structures should be designed so

that the water can flow without causing permanent damage

to the structure during a rapid flood. (Like parking areas or

transportable first-floor use storage areas) (Fig. 19). Wet floodproofing

is a minimal effort and cost-effective solution, but it

is short-term; therefore, the result in the deterioration of the

building materials depends on repeated exposure to floodwaters.

Figure 19: Mobile Barriers

Image 10: Wet Flood-proofing [24]

‘‘One of the solutions is preventing excessive pressure on the walls by

allowing water flow into the basement.’’ [25]

Depending on height, space

under the house may be used

for storage or access

Figure 16: Post-Tsunami sustainable reconstruction [21]

‘‘ELEMENTAL recommends planting forests along the flood-prone areas to

dissipate the energy of waves through friction and implementing specific

restrictions on the use and layout of ground-floor spaces in the risk zone.’’ [21]

Figure 20: Mobile Barriers [25]

78


RESEARCH

Figure 8: BAT Srudio- Green House

Image 11: Adjustable Piles of Green House [26]

‘‘Constructed in an area which experiences frequent flooding, the Greenhouse That Grows Legs incorporates a novel approach to flood protection. The building is fabricated

on a bespoke steel frame with four hydraulic legs, capable of lifting the building 800mm from the ground on command.’’ [26]

Adjustable Piles: Allowing flood waters to easily flow under the

structure in order to minimise structural damage.

The direction of bracing frames is important. Bracing can

become an obstruction by increasing exposure of foundation

to wave and debris impact. Bracing is often oriented

perpendicular to the shoreline so that it is not struck broadside

by waves, debris, and velocity flow.

Figure 21: Elevating on pile

Elevating Piles | Bracing Frames: Elevating on piles is another

effective method for resisting flood loads. However, only

this sole solution may not be sufficient. As the pile rises, the

stability of the structure deteriorates and its resistance to

horizontal loads decreases. Under these circumstances, the

structure should be supported with some additional elements

called ‘‘bracing frames’’. ‘’Include knee’’ and ‘’diagonal bracing’’

are some of the common bracing methods. Knee bracing is

an effective method of improving the performance of a pile

system without creating an obstruction to the flow of water

and debris from a design event (Fig.22). [27]

Figure 23: Flood Direction | Bracing Frames

Figure 22: Knee Bracing [27]

Image 12: This house had inadequate pile embodiment and cross bracing [27]

79


STRUCTURAL DURABILITY

Amphibious architecture purpose an alternative floodresistant

approach. An amphibious foundation of the

structure maintains the building’s connection with the

ground by ensuring the structure stable under normal

conditions. During the disaster, it allows the structure

to float on the surface of flowing flood-water, instead of

struggling with flood loads. [28]

Existing Raised Home - Dry

Existing Raised Home - Flood

Figure 25: Process [29]

‘‘Traditionally, houses in the region are raised above ground to mitigate property

damage during flood events. However, as the area anticipates increasingly severe

floods, the current level of static elevation of these houses may no longer be

adequate to protect residents and their property. Rebuilding or repairing homes

after a flood event is costly and can require a lengthy period of time. During these

repairs, residents are often displaced from their homes, increasing their economic

burden and vulnerability.’’ [29]

Retrofitted Home - Dry

Retrofitted Home - Flood

Figure 24: Typical raised home in dry and flood conditions [29]

The posts of the vertical guidance system allow the house to slide up of its

foundation when water comes in and then move back down to its original place

once the water recedes.

Rear elevation of Nguyen Van Nao’s Home in dry conditions

Rear elevation of Nguyen Van Nao’s Home in flood conditions

Image 13: Dry and flood conditions [29]

80


Wind

Wind loads act on a building as uniform surface loads. These

can create both positive and negative pressure from inwards

and outwards loads on building surface (Fig.26).

The amount of wind load is dependent on the following:

• Geographical location

• The height of the structure

• Type of surrounding physical environment

• The shape of the structure

• Size of the building

Possible Damages: Even a well-designed building may

be damaged in an unexpected wind occasion (Fig.28).

Therefore, depending on various factors, the suction force can

be significant enough to cause damage to individual building

components or the structure of the building itself. [30]

RESEARCH

The wind pressure originates from two components: Mean

velocity and gust velocity. Since static mean velocities are

averaged over longer periods of time, the resulting wind

pressure is also average pressure and exerts a steady

deflection on the building. [30]

Uplift

Racking

action and reaction

Wind

Sliding/shear

Figure 28: Possible damages of strong winds

Figure 26: Wind loading

Despite their vastly different wind speeds, damage patterns

near the landfall locations of fast-moving Hurricane Charley

(Img.14) and slow-moving Hurricane Frances (Img.15) were

remarkably similar. [31]

‘‘First, positive wind pressure applies to the building

components on the side of the building that faces the

incoming wind (the “windward” direction). The windward wind

load is essentially the force of the blowing wind pressing on

the building. Secondly, the negative wind pressure applies

to the building components on the side(s) of the building that

faces away from the incoming wind (the “leeward” direction).

The negative wind pressure is also known as “suction.” The

suction force will be applied to vertical surfaces such as walls,

and also horizontal or sloped surfaces such as roofs. The

suction force can be thought of as acting like a vacuum that

pulls on a building and its components.’’ (Fig. 27) [30]

Image 14: Collapse of a large portion of a metal building (Florida, 2004) [32]

Figure 27: Pressure and Suction

Image 15: Some examples of structural damages after hurricane Frances [32]

81


STRUCTURAL DURABILITY

EFFECTS OF WIND ACCORDING TO THE SHAPE OF STRUCTURE

‘‘In the flat roof (a), the low-pressure coefficient occurs

due to the flow separation on the leading edge of the

roof, resulting in some vortices at the top of the roof.

In the case of the gabled roof (b), the low-pressure

coefficient occurs on the leeward area of the roof and

flow separation occurs at the top of the roof. The same

case is true for the pyramidal roof (c) where the lowpressure

coefficient occurs in the leeward area of the

roof. In the case of vaulted (d) and domed roofs (f), there

is not so much of a low-pressure coefficient due to the

fact that no recirculation occurs in the roof area. High

stream-wise velocity occurs at the very top of the roof,

causing a low-pressure coefficient in this area. In the

case of the wedged roof (e), the flow separation occurs

at the topmost portion of the roof and flow recirculation

occurs in the leeward area, resulting in a low-pressure

coefficient here.’’ [33]

a b c d e f

a-Flat

b-Gabled

c-Pyramidal

d-Vaulted

e-Wedged

f- Domed

Figure 29: Mean velocity and pressure coefficient contours with mean velocity vectors for different roofing designs of detached structures: (a) Flat roof, (b) Gabled roof,

(c) Pyramidal roof, (d) Vaulted roof, (e) Wedged roof, and (f) Domed roof [33]

82


Additional Material / Tension: Known as ‘‘Guy-wire’’

dissolves as a side force that resists the wind load that exerts

compressive force on some bending structure due to wind

force. They are used commonly in ship masts, radio masts,

wind turbines, utility poles, and tents (Img.18).

RESEARCH

Image 16: Yurtdome, Burning Man [34]

Figure 30: Guy-wire

The Burning Man festival, which has been held since 1986,

takes place in the Nevada Desert, known for extreme conditions

such as desert winds, dust, cold and dry nights, rain and heat.

Since 1986, Burning Man Festival develop many inspirational

shelter designs that have been produced and built quickly and

have not left a trace in the desert after the end of the festival,

relatively self-sufficient, able to withstand strong winds, cold

nights and hot days. These designs are very impressive for

the sheltering methods in temporary or extreme conditions. [35]

“These shelters have been of interest to organizations exploring

mass housing such as the United Nations High Commissioner

for Refugees, and commercial ventures such as Shelter

Systems and World Shelters.” [35] “Although many of these

concepts have roots in the experimentation of the last century,

including those of Buckminster Fuller, more recently some

innovative ideas have emerged too. For example, “yurtdomes,”

(Img.16) the folding ICOSA Pod (a structure based on triangular

tensions), or the IKEA-funded flat-packed houses (originally

produced for refugees on the Somalia/Ethiopia border by

Swedish designer Johan Karlson), have all been tested at this

festival.’’ [35]

Image 18: Wind turbine and Guy-wire [37]

Image 17: North Face releases a Geodesic Dome tent [36] Image 19: Guy wire support for extreme conditions [38]

‘‘Reinterpreting the teachings of Buckminster Fuller, North Face has announced

the latest tent in their collection; a geodesic dome tent. Thanks to the most

spatially efficient shape in architecture, it can withstand winds of up to 60 mph

as the force is spread evenly across the structure whilst even providing enough

height for an approximately 1.80m tall person to stand comfortably inside.’’ [36]

‘‘Structure is located near to a rocky ledge at about 3290m of altitude with its

characteristic hole in the rock. It is able to withstand the continuous combined

action of extreme weather conditions such as extreme weather temperatures

even below -20°C, wind speed up to 200 km/h, heavy precipitations and meters

of snow on the ground.’’ [38]

83


STRUCTURAL DURABILITY

BURNING MAN STRUCTURES

“Octayurts are an incredibly simple, and affordable

design to make a self-supported fully enclosed

building using common materials with a few simple

cuts, and no material waste. If made out of plywood,

they are animal proof, and if made out of insulation

foam board, they are light and foldable. An Octayurt

has 8 sides, and with light materials, it can be held

together with tape. The core physics principles behind

both Octayurts is that the roof stays up as long as it

has something pushing it in, and the connected outer

ring provides that stability. The roof is resistant to

too much force pushing it in because it reciprocates

against the roof pieces next to it.” [41]

Figure 31: Glamcocks Camp, Tiger’s Octayurt [41] Image 21: Inside of Glamcocks Camp, Tiger’s Octayurt [41]

84


Burning Man organized for the first time in 1986

in San Francisco and continued to be held in the

desert land called Black Rock City in Nevada in later

years. The festival is described by the organizers

as a community and art experiment which takes

its name from the temple burned at the end of the

event. It presents valuable examples of temporary

structures such as temples and shelters. Also,

these various structures and tents, which are

resistant to desert climate condition are mostly

produced just for this event.

RESEARCH

“The Metal Pods are inspired by Fuller’s geodesic

dome. These metal domes are light, strong and

easy to set-up. A recycle window curtain covers

a steel frame, while recycled painter drop cloths

are stretched on the domes. Pods take one to

two hours to set up and to take down. Three-level

structure has a kitchen with a stove on the first

floor, shower in the middle floor, and bedroom on

the top floor.” [42]

Image 22: The Octopods Anomalous by Chris Yamane and Benny Lichtner [42]

Image 20: Burning Man 2018 [39]

Image 23: Metal Pods Village by Scott Parenteau; [42]

Image 24: The Cube Village by Scott Mahoney [42]

“The Cube by Scott Mahoney is flat pack system as vocation

beyond the limits of Black Rock City to provide a fast, stackable

and expandable shelter solution in disaster-stricken areas.

This experiment in communal living would worth doing on the

architectural point of view. The Cube with its Node is a very

well designed shelter offering a temporary comfortable living

space that sustained the extreme conditions of the Black Rock

Desert. It is a great alternative for a tent as becoming flat-pack,

light and easily assembled make it easy to use. However it is

not cheap with its metal frame structure.” [42]

Image 25: The Cube by Scott Mahoney [42]

85


STRUCTURAL DURABILITY

Snow

Snow load is a force exerted by the accumulated snow on the

roof as a result of heavy snowing. When snow accumulates

on the roof, vertical loads increase and this can cause

permanent damage because this load generally does not

distribute uniformly and it adds weight.

On a flat roof, the snow load tends to be uniformly distributed.

The load is then distributed to the beams and joints that

make up the roof and then sent down to the columns that are

supporting the beam at its ends. Because the columns are

supporting at the both end of the beam, the bending moment

at the middle of the beam is the greatest; therefore, the

beam’s weakest points is at the middle. As the load presses

down onto the beam, it will experience tension on the bottom

and compression at the top going through deflection.

Possible Damages

The most common structural damage is the breaking of the

roof due to the excessive accumulation of snow. Buildings

may be vulnerable to structural failure and possible collapse

if basic preventative steps are not taken in advance of a

snow event. Some causes of structural damage from snow

accumulating on roofs are given below: [43]

• ‘‘Actual snow load significantly exceeds design snow load’’

• ‘‘Drifting and sliding snow conditions’’

• ‘‘Deficient workmanship’’

• ‘‘Insufficient operation and maintenance’’

• ‘‘Improper design (Roof geometry etc.) ’’

• ‘‘Inadequate drainage design’’

• ‘‘Roof geometry’’[43]

‘‘Unbalanced snow loading is the condition in which snow

accumulates at different depths in different locations on a

roof, resulting in differential snow load. Unbalanced snow

load poses a greater risk to the roof structural system than a

uniform snow load. Hence, the danger of drifting and sliding

snow is that both create an unbalanced snow load.’’ [43]

Figure 33: Roof break

Figure 32: Snow loading effects on the structure

Image 26: Roof break [44]

Figure 34: Unbalanced snow load from drifting and sliding snow on typical commercial or industrial building [43]

86


RESEARCH

Image 27: Illustration from Charles Francis Hall’s Arctic Researches and Life Among the Esquimaux, 1865 [45]

Snow Resistant Building Design

Accumulated snow applies force to the roof. The roof must

be resistant to this force. The main issue is to reduce the

accumulation of snow on the roof and to ensure that the

accumulated snow load is evenly distributed. At this point, the

wind direction and the shape of the roof are very important.

Gable roof prevents snow accumulation compared to

flat roofs, and as the roof slope increases, the amount of

accumulated snow decreases. Therefore, direction of the roof

slope should be determined according to the direction of the

wind force. (Fig.35).

“The igloo is a temporary winter shelter built by native Eskimos

primarily for use in winter hunting camps. Snow is used

because the air pockets trapped in it make it an insulator. On

the outside, temperatures may be as low as −45 °C (−49 °F),

but on the inside, the temperature may range from −7 to 16

°C (19 to 61 °F) when warmed by body heat alone’’ [45]

Figure 36: Configurations, Igloo Satellite Cabin [46]

Image 28: Transportation, Igloo Satellite Cabin [46]

Figure 35: Snow accumulations

‘‘Wannabe Eskimos looking for an updated version of the familiar ice dome. Igloo Satellite

Cabin, a prefabricated remote shelter designed to withstand sub-zero temperatures, high

winds, ice, and snow. The basic Igloo Satellite Cabin, weighing 250 kg and 3m wide x 2.1m

high, is pre-fabricated, insulated and made from 8 wall panels and 4-floor panels. The whole

Igloo is bolted together and secured to the ground anchors by 8 wire tie-down lines. Igloos can

be extended and interlinked with tunnels. Units can be flown fully assembled by helicopter, and

are ideal short-term accommodation for exploration, research, and ecotourism. Igloos have

been in use since 1982.’’ [46]

87


STRUCTURAL DURABILITY

The shape of the geodesic dome allows the wind to help

naturally shed snow from the dome. This is why it is used

quite often in extreme environments such as Alaska and the

like. The Eskimos build their Igloos in a dome shape for the

same reason: A Dome is the strongest and best shape for

handling snow! The total static weight that can be supported

over the entire dome is much greater than any snow load it will

have to support, as snow does not accumulate on a round

roof. [47]

The most known effect of the accumulated snow on the

ground is the prevention of entry into the structure. However,

excessive accumulation of snow between the structure and

the ground can cause structural damage. In order to prevent

this, some protrusions may be formed on the floor of the

structure in a direction not to cause snow accumulation.

(Fig. 38, Img.31)

Figure 38: Prevention of snow accumulation

Figure 37: Snow accumulation on Geodesic Dome [48]

Image 30: Maison des jeunes, designed by Gerard Grandval, Maurice Calka, 1967 [50]

With its soft, rounded shapes imitated from those that the snow itself is gathering.

The cabin-shell made of polyester-coated moulded wood protrudes against the

cavity thus reducing the accumulation of snow on the floor of the structure.

Image 29: Lightweight and Compact Shelter [49]

‘‘At an altitude of 3,800 meters, Ice-Age architects have designed and produced

a compact and lightweight shelter as the last base before climbers venture up

Mount Elbrus, the highest point in Europe. Inspired by Buckminster Fuller’s 2V

geodesic dome, it can sleep up to 16 people as they acclimatize to the altitude

and wait for the appropriate weather for the climb.’’ [49]

Image 31: Ice Huts [51]

Image 32: Ice Huts [51]

88


GEODESIC TENTS

‘‘Bruce Hamilton, who worked for the

company from 1970 to 1989, recently wrote

a few poststelling the story of the North Face

/ Buckminster Fuller connection. It began in

his first year on the job, when the company’s

owner Hap Klopp asked a friend whose family

had connections to Fuller to send the already

worldfamous architect-systems theoristinventor

a letter. Describing The North Face as

“a small company that produces what I believe

to be the finest equipment presently available,”

the friend asked Fuller for ideas on how to

improve the “archaic designs” then used to

construct tents.’’ Fuller replied: [53]

RESEARCH

“I have thought a great deal in

the past about your subject of the

compact, lightweight, back-packable

environment controlling device,”

Fuller replied. “I am accepting your

challenge.” [53]

Image 33: The North Face Geodesic Tents [52]

2018 Geodome 4

‘’Comfortably accommodates four occupants

in its unique form, while toughing out japan’s

most harshest weather.’’ The North Face kept

incorporating Fuller’s ideas into their tents,

and they hammered out the terms of direct

collaboration on a new model in 1983, a

month before Fuller died. Judgments about

other tensegrity structures — geodesic dome

homes, for example — have varied over the

years, but the Oval Intention lives on in the

form of the new Geodome 4. It can withstand

winds of up to 60 mph. The structure can be

assembled easily with only five main and one

equator poles. It is packaged in a weight of

11.07 kg. [51]

Image 34: Bucky stepping out of the door of the 3 meter, six frequency tent, 1977 [53]

Image 35: An example from The North Face correspondence with Fuller, 1977 [53]

Image 36: The North Face Geodome 4 [54]

89



Buckminster Fuller


STRUCTURAL DURABILITY

FOUNDATION

Mobile

The mobile relationship can be applicated as platform, footing,

wheeled and sled.

Platform

As we have seen in Shigeru Ban’s example, the platform

can be made with recyclable materials such as a vegetable

fruit box. This is a fast material that can be found after

the earthquake * and also creates a system that can be

assembled and produced quickly without considering the

combination details.

Figure 39: Temporary platform made by recycled vegetable boxes

Image 37: Views of the components and assemblage of the Total Filling Station [55]

In shelter design, there are many variations of the relation

with ground during setup. These variations occur according to

the climate conditions, geographical characteristics, functions,

social situations or life-styles. Shelters diversify relations in

different cases to improve its durability. This connection with

the ground can be seen as mobile or fixed.

As seen in the previous topic “external forces”, to design a

cabin as fixed is useful in windy areas that contains so much

horizontal forces, but designing as a flexible/ mobile cabin

is also better in earthquake hazard areas. There is the same

situation in geographical characteristics of an area, the way of

setup is changing according to the touching point between

the earth and cabin. Structures which are placed on rocky

areas are mostly fixed to the earth, on the other hand the

cabins that are considered on snowy areas are mostly mobile

to battle with changeable snow height. In addition, function of

a shelter is important in terms of the way of setting it up. Like

temporary cabin design for seasonal use is mobile, whereas a

permanent cabin for long time use is considered as fixed. The

temporariness is also vital in the refugee camps or disaster

relief projects and they need mobile quick shelters. Dissimilarly

to these situations, people manage their lives just for personal

desires. Some people make a stale connection with the

ground and feel belonged therefore their cabin could be fixed.

On the other hand, other people could desire more freedom

with their cabin to take it away with them and experience lots

of different places.

Image 38: Mock-up of temporary house by students of Shigeru Ban Lab at

Keio University in Japan [56]

Image 39: Mock-up of temporary house by local architects and students at

Quito in Ecuador [56]

*Temporary House is disaster relief project after the earthquake in Ecuador in

2016. [56]

92


In the Flake House project, the platform was provided with

wooden raiser placed crosswise. The raiser has protected

the cabin from rain and similar factors with adding some gap

between ground and cabin so it is easy to convert it into

another form and transport to somewhere.

The cabin that Donna Irvine photographed near Nellie Lake

could be a site specific solution created by the owner in a way

to protect it from factors such as rainfall in the area. It fixes two

large and shaped stones on top of each other and places the

cabinet on top of them.

RESEARCH

Figure 40: Mobile platfrom made by wooden sticks

Figure 42: Stone masonary platform

Figure 41: Section of Flake House by Olgga Architectes at Nantes in France [57]

Image 41: Cabin built with repurposed windows, skylight, and palettes for the floor, near

Nellie Lake in notheastern Ontario, Canada; Donna Irvine [58]

Image 40: Flake House by Olgga Architectes at Nantes in France [57]

93


STRUCTURAL DURABILITY

Footing

The feet in Ken Isaacs’ 8’Micro House are one of the

first attempts in 1974 to establish a relationship between

the ground and the cabin. Isaacs considers the cabin as a

temporarily space and illustrates it to show how this temporary

structure is designed by the user. In Figure 43, we see that

the legs called “tetrehedron” are formed by welding or brazing

the steel rods supporting the 3 surfaces in the corner of the

cabin and this structure is fixed to the plywood feet.

As shown in the example, AbleNook is made for portable

dwelling and has little touch on the surface by placed it on the

floor. The adjustable steel footing foundations allow the unit

to be placed on uneven surfaces so they can be deployed

anywhere. Numerous adjustable feet compensate for small

elevation differences or uneven terrain on the ground. [61]

Figure 44: Mobile adjustable footings

Figure 42: Mobile tetrahedron footings

Figure 45: Section of AbleNook by Sean Verdecia and Jason Ross [62]

Figure 43: Leg detail of 8’ Micro House [59]

Figure 46: Diagram of AbleNook by Sean Verdecia and Jason Ross [62]

Image 42: Replica of Ken Isaacs’s 8’ Micro House, 2010 [60]

94


Working with the concept of micro homes, Richard

Horden produces projects on this concept with his students.

Sometimes they are inspired by the arms of an insect or the

wings of a butterfly. Like these insects that have the ability

to adapt to different situations, the “fly off” project opens or

lowers its wings according to the change of the ground. It

sometimes places itself on a rock and sometimes sits on a

snowy peak.

Another micro home experiment of Richard Horden,

which he developed with his students, is the micro research

laboratory in Antarctica. The feet of the laboratory can be

adjusted according to the structure of the ground, additively it

adapts to the melting snow level with the sledges at the end

of the feet.

RESEARCH

Figure 47: Adaptable footings

Figure 49: Mobile sled footings

Image 43: 1:1 Construction detail of Fly Off, Alps [63]

Figure 50: Section of Polar Lab, Antarctica Research Habitat, Antarctica [65]

Image 44: Fly Off, Alps [63]

Image 46: Polar Lab, Antarctica Research Habitat, Antarctica [65]

Image 45: White Winter, River Saulgrub [64]

Figure 48: Adaptation diagram of Fly Off , left to right; iclined plane, water, rocky slope, cliff [63]

95


STRUCTURAL DURABILITY

INFLATOCOOKBOOK

Figure 51: Inflatocookbook, second editon by Ant Farm [66]

“For the past year Ant Farm has been a group of environmental nomads building inflatable structures/

air building/geodesic domes and developing a vocabulary of images that project architectural alternative

methods. We built about 20 inflatable polyethylene structures for schools, confrences, festivals and

gatherings from California to Vermont. The largest one, at 100’ X 100’ white and clear pillow, the smaalest

a tetrahedron that folds out of a suitcase.”[67]

96


RESEARCH

Figure 52: Inflatocookbook, second editon by Ant Farm [66]

“Searching out a means, a way of doing, a spacial expression alternatives to the rigid architectural

paths we were led down as children. Images of what environment can mean when a person takes

it in his own hands, feeling it and molding new forms. A beginning, a method so simple we can

share it at will and never lose the security of being sheltered. The INFLATOCOOKBOOK is our

attempt to gather information and skills learned in process and organize it for easy access. It is

catalyst for our thought process and further development.” [67]

97


STRUCTURAL DURABILITY

Wheeled

One of the most used mobile homes, wheeled cabins can

be transported in many different ways. As shown in figure 53,

the wheeled cabin can be turned into mobile with the help of

a hook. So it can be taken to a certain location with a vehicle

and then it can continue its life alone. So you just need a

basic vehicle to changing your location.

Mobile homes can consist a limited mobility, as shown in

the example of the kalhöfer - korschildgen (figure 55). Fahrt

ins Grüne is an additional building of old wooden house. The

location of the structure can be changed by the wheeled piles

with the rail system on the ground.

Figure 53: Mobile cabin trasported by help of a hook

Figure 55: Wheeled mobile annex on the rail system

Image 47: Moving Icon, kalhöfer - korschildgen architekten [68]

The most common example of mobile home is caravan.

The caravans, which are designed to be the living area with

the vehicle, can change their location without the need for

anything additional.

Image 49: Fahrt ins Grüne, kalhöfer - korschildgen architekten Remscheid [70]

Figure 54: Caravan

Image 48: Apollo euro star 4-seater Motorhome [69]

Image 50: Fahrt ins Grüne, kalhöfer - korschildgen architekten Remscheid [70]

98


RESEARCH

Image 51: Ice Village # 261, Neenah, Lake Winnebago, Wisconsin, USA, 2018; Richard Johnson [71]

Since 2007, photographer Richard Johnson has been traveling around Canada, documenting the architectural variations in ice fishing huts.

“As with its distant cousins the Teepee and the Igloo, the Ice Fishing Hut has its own essential purpose” Now in its eighth year, the project encompasses photographs of 800

huts from one coast of Canada to the other. Together, they form a typological study of the fishing culture and architecture across the country’s regions. “As with its distant

cousins the native Teepee and the Igloo, the Ice Fishing Hut has its own essential purpose,” says Johnson. “Sheet metal, faux wood paneling, tarpaulins, peak roofs, modified

camping trailers all fulfill the requirements for shelter.” [72]

“For me, an ice fishing hut is the most fundamental expression of architecture. It is designed and built by the owner. It is transportable. It is shelter with a hole in the floor

serving a common purpose. Yet with a similar list of design criteria each one is uniquely different; a testament to the owner’s personality.”[73]

Sled

Mobile homes are changing according to the climatic

conditions, a wheel on the soil helps to move, on the other

hand, the ski becomes a vehicle of movement in snowy areas.

As you can see in Image 52, the snowmobile can change the

location of the sled cabin with the help of a hook.

Figure 56: Fishing cabin wheeled by side surface

These fishing huts, built by the owners of the region for

fishing purposes, are valuable in their relationship with the

ground because they are located in snowy areas. As I will

exemplify in the “sled” section, the cabins provide their

mobility mostly with sled on snowy areas. The cabins which

are photographed by Richard Johnson has designed their

mobility with a different system. The walls and floors of these

huts in Ice Village #261 are interchangeable. These huts are

taken to the area with the wheels on their floors during the

relocation and then the walls become the floor and the floor

becomes the wall on the site. Although it is a wheeled cabin

during the set-up and it turns into a cabin adjacent to the

ground during fishing.

Figure 57: Fishing cabin wheeled by side surface

Image 52: Ice Hut #180 & #427a, Beaveton, Lake Simcoe, Ontario, Canada, 2008; Richard Johnson [74]

99


STRUCTURAL DURABILITY

Fixed

The setup of the fixed cabins, can be partitioned as platform

and pile according to the relation with ground.

Platform

Fixed cabins are mostly provided with fixing the structure

on the platform made of a certain material in the relation with

ground. The example shows fixing bamboo structured pavilion

with a steel fixing detail to concrete platform.

The fixed platforms can also be constructed with a material

which has no connection between the ground and platform.

As shown in the example in figure 59, a relationship where

it is fixed to the ground is possible by pouring concrete onto

the rock. In addition to the steel fixing between the platform

and the cabin, it can be secured to the ground by providing

tension with ropes in order to increase the strength in windy

areas (please check wind section).

Figure 59: Cabin fixed to concrete platform and supported by ropes

Figure 58: Structurally fixed to concrete platform

Image 54: Winter cabin on Mount Kanin by OFIS arhitekt in Slovenia [76]

Image 53: Bamboo Pavilion for the Expo Shanghai by Markus Heinsdorff in China [75]

100


As seen in the example of the Boathouse, the relationship

of the cabin with land during set-up can be not only on the

floor but also on the wall. This cabin, which was installed on

rocky terrain, was designed not as on top of the rock, but also

by taking the rock in and fixing its walls to the rock, as shown

in figure 60.

The Shed was fixed ground with the reinforced concrete

platform. The concrete platform is fixed to the ground by their

weight and also it has concrete sheets entering the earth on

each side. These sheets provide cracking caused by the soil

in concrete. After the concrete is removed from the mold, the

horizontal and vertical wooden planks are fixed to the platform.

RESEARCH

Figure 60: Cabin fixed to existing rock base

Figure 61: The platform fixed to the ground

Figure 62: The section of The Shed, NARTARCHITECTS [78]

Image 55: Boathouse (Naust paa Aure), TYIN tegnestue Architects, Norway [77]

Image 56: The Shed, NARTARCHITECTS, Nagybajom, Hungary [78]

101


STRUCTURAL DURABILITY

Pile

Fixed cabinets can be setup on the ground with piles. For

cabinets with a certain weight and square meter, piles may not

always be under the ground. The stakes can also be durable

and permanent by filling them or fixing them to a heavy foot in

place. In Beach Matrix, one of the pioneering examples of

this, most of the designed structures are fixed to the ground

by the feet that are adapted to the structure.

One of the solutions is to connect the piles to the concrete

foots so that the cabins do not lose their durability as a

result of being exposed to various weather events. In Carter

Williamson Architects’ Emergency Shelter project, the

adjustable legs that are stuck in a small concrete feet provide

both terrain compatibility and a solution for extreme conditions.

In the street exhibition of the project, instead of concrete feet,

they provided the durability of the cabin with a few sacks of

sand.

Figure 63: Piles with feets that can be buried in the sand

Figure 65: Adjustable piles

Figure 66: Section of Emergency Shelter / Sustainable house prototype by

Carter Williamson Architects at Melbourne, Australia [81]

Figure 64: Feet detail of Old Micro House [79]

Image 57: Installation view of Beach Matrix, Ken Isaacs in Westport, Connecticut [80]

Image 58: Emergency Shelter / Sustainable house prototype by

Carter Williamson Architects at Melbourne, Australia [82]

102


The cabins from Jason Vaughn’s “cabins from hide” series

was raised for a variety of reasons. Piles, which are one of

the easiest ways to gain height in a cabinet, turn into a rather

prominent object in these examples compared to the cabinet.

Piles can be perpendicular to the ground or with various cross

systems. Ladders that help to enter an elevated entrance may

in some cases be part of the pile structure.

Peak Lab is one of the projects Richard Horden has

developed together with his students for extreme conditions.

Although not constructed, the project is valuable with the idea

is developed. The cabin is fixed to the rock by horizontal steel

piles at three main points. While the connection in Detail 1

supports the ladder, we see the connection which carries the

most of the cabin in Detail 2.

RESEARCH

Figure 67: Hide cabins fixed ground by long piles

Figure 68: Cabin fixed the rock by steel piles horizontally

1

2

Figure 69: Section of Peak Lab, Zermatt [84]

Image 60: Detail 1 on the left and Detail 2 on the right of Peak Lab Project [84]

Image 59: Cabins from “Hide”, a series documentating deer stands in Wisconsin;

Jason Vaughn [83]

103


STRUCTURAL DURABILITY

The piles are not always vertical, but may also be conical. As

seen in Studio Morison’s Escape Vehicle project, conical legs

cladding with aluminium/steel panel(1) are fixed to concrete

foot. The upper legs are connected to the primary support

beams (2).[85] Approximately 2 meters long legs create a

floating feeling on the grass as well as protecting itself from

various factors in the forest area such as flooding and insects.

JR’s Hut at Kimo Estate ,is a interpretation of classical “A

frame” house fixed with classical piles, provides its relationship

with the floor with concrete strip footing(1), while the support

wooden pillars that from A form sit on the floor with concrete

pad footing (2). The wooden pillars and concrete legs are fixed

with steel fitting. The gap created between the steel fitting and

the floor is filled with pebbles and does not take the water into

the house.

Figure 70: Cabin fixed the ground by conical legs

Figure 72: Cabin fixed the ground by concrete strip footing and concrete pad footing

1

Photo name: Lorem ipsum

2

Image 61: Escape Vehicle #9: ICE by Studio Morison in Netherlands, 2018 [86]

2

Due to the fact that the structure is A form, the stakes can

also be shaped according to the form. In Robin Flack’s Nolla

Cabin project, wooden piles are fixed on existing rock base

with A form piles.

1

Figure 73: Section of JR’s Hut at Kimo Estate by

Anthony Hunt Design and Luke Stanley Architects, Gundagai, Australia [88]

Figure 71: A frame structure fixed the rock by a frame piles

Image 62: Nolla Cabin by Robin Flack at Vallisaari, Finland, 2018; Fanny Haga [87]

Image 63: JR’s Hut at Kimo Estate by

Anthony Hunt Design and Luke Stanley Architects,Gundagai, Australia [89]

104


STONE 27

RESEARCH

“Artist Benjamin Langholz created a circular staircase

of stepping stones to allow revellers to tune out the

immersive atmosphere at this year’s Burning Man and

focus on themselves. Langholz arranged 27 stones

in an ascending ring, supported by a central pillar

and three surrounding pairs of columns, to create the

installation named Stone 27. Intended to provide a

“shift into a new reality”, the journey up and around

the elevated stones was designed to take visitors on

a “floating walk to experience a moment of complete

presence”.

Image 64: Sketchbook detail, drawn by Maaz Jan [90]

“The idea of pathways of floating stones appealed

to me because you can present an alternate

reality,” explained Langholz to Dezeen. “One

where something heavy and stable suddenly

becomes light and floats in the air.”

Three pairs of columns were angled to fan outwards

from the central pillar, with each stone attached to

four points in the structure – using to over half a mile

of steel rope. At the base of steel support, a pile of

basalt rocks placed by the artist hid the structure

inserted into the ground.

Rather than removing the black basalt blocks found

on the Black Rock mountain, the artist sourced

similar local stone so as to not disturb the natural

landscape.” [92]

Image 65: Stone 27 by Benjamin Langholz at Burning Man, 2019 [91]

105


STRUCTURAL DURABILITY

TRANSPORTATION

Loading / Unloading

Heatherwick Studio’s Paperhouse is loaded and unloaded

with help of a crane. The cabin, which was built as an off-site,

is fixed and carried by the metal strong points where the crane

can be mounted. When lifting the crane, these points should

form the balance center of the structure so that the structure

does not topple over.

Figure 74: Cabin is unloaded by metal strong points

Image 67: Paperhouse by Heatherwick Studio at London, UK, 2002 [94]

Image 66: Views of the components and assemblage of the Total Filling Station [93]

Transportation is one of the important factors for cabins.

There is no meaning of designing a structure that cannot be

transported. Because of that, it is also a part of designing

process. For instance, if there is a project made with panels,

their lengths, and widths not exceed transportation vehicular

size. The limited dimensions of the vehicle create again

limited size of panels. The standardization of 2,40 m width of

containers is as reason of international maximum vehicular

width which is 2,45 m.

The one of the significant criteria is durability of the package,

as a whole cabin or separated parts, in the transportation

process even if the dimension standard was okay. There is

three different point such as loading, delivery, and unloading

according to the durability of it. It is mostly loaded with cranes

to the truck and there are lots of types to carry with them.

Although, cabins which has a central point could be carried

in that point, cabins which has multi central points such a

container could be carried by dividing its loads. The methods

of carrying are diversified according to the their connection

points and materials.

The other vital criteria is the external forces during

transportation. Most of cabins are not durable against that

forces during the delivery period because of the shape of

either panels or materials and these are should get strong

against them.

Helicopters are used when the environmental conditions do

not allow. Therefore, they are challenged with strong wind

forces.

If there is no point to fix the structure during loading and

unloading stages, it is supported by a belt to avoid damaging

the structure. Two-end cranes are used to transport the

structure without compressing.

Figure 75: Cabin is unloaded by belts

Image 68: Flake House by Olgga Architectes at Nantes in France, 2009 [95]

106


Loading prefabricated systems, such as containers, are

different from basic shaped cabins. They probably have a

bigger volume and more complicated gravity points caused

by a rectangular shape. Therefore, the divided load has a

more clear transportation process in that kind of form. Marmol

Radziner Prefab House, which is photographed by Todd Jerry,

is being hosted with three belt straps and one spreader bar to

distribute load the hydraulic crane. (Image 69)

Structures formed by folding systems tend to have easy

transportation processes. Although the higher volume or

height of the package can be problematic in the limited areas

during transportation, the folding system can overcome that

problem. MADI Home is minimized its volume to nearly a

quarter by folding technique. (Image 71) The folded form of it

creates more safe process against external impact and allows

transported more houses at the same time.

RESEARCH

Figure 76: Cabin is carried by distributing the load to three parts

Figure 77: Cabin is loaded by belts

Image 69: Marmol Radziner Prefab House, California [96]

Image 71: Loading of folded MADI Home [98]

Image 70: 24-Story modular student dormitory, O’Connel East Architects (OEA),

United Kingdom [97]

Like the previous example, the 24-Story modular student dormitory which is designed

by OEA is carried by the load distribution method to place each module.

But it is different from the previous in some points such as the connection between

the crane and container. The container has connection points to prevent

some accidents during transformation.

107


STRUCTURAL DURABILITY

Delivery

Another important factor is the situation of a part of the

structure or the whole of them should not be damaged during

the delivery. Various factors are taken into consideration such

as the size and fragility of the object being transported.

For avoiding the damage during transportation is the

sheathing of the structure. System 3 Prototype House is a

project where most of its parts are built off-site and for this

reason, its parts are designed to be transported as covered.

So that their parts do not clash during the delivery and to

prevent any foreign matter from being damaged. The sheath

is removed after reaching the site and the assembly is

completed.

During the transportation of the New Amsterdam Plein &

Pavilion, there are disadvantages such as the length of the

parts exceeding the truck width of 2.40 m and the fragility of

the form. As a solution, the parts were transported in traffic

control with an “oversize load” warning sign, and the structure

was supported by woods and ropes from inside to prevent

jolts.

Figure 79: Cabin is stabilized by woods and ropes during transportation

Figure 78: Cabin is protected by a sheath during transportation

Image 73: New Amsterdam Plein & Pavilion by UNStudio at New York, USA [100]

Delivery affects the design process. We can see an example

of that in the Snow-House project. Walter Klazs was designed

folding footing for that project for transporting easily.

Figure 80: Transportation section of Snow-House, Walter Klazs [101]

Image 72: System 3 Prototype House by Oskar Leo Kaufmann and Albert Rüf

at MoMA Exhibition, New York, USA, 2008 [99]

Figure 77: Transportation image of Snow-House, Walter Klazs [101]

108


TRANSPORTATION OF MARINE MAMMAL

‘‘Over the last 20 years, specialized marine mammal transport techniques

have been developed to cope with the unique physiology of marine

mammals. Safe, successful transportation can be achieved with proper

attention to detail and the use of appropriate technology.’’[102]

Figure x: Cutaway view of bottlenosed dolphin within transport unit.

‘‘Adequate body support techniques have

been developed to allow normal breathing

during transport. Cetaceans are now moved

in fabric stretchers, suspended in water-filled

transport units, more closely approximating

the near weightlessness provided by water.

Additionally, the widespread use of aircraft

has allowed successful movement of

cetaceans over vast distances by shortening

the amount of time the cetacean is removed

from the water environment.’’ [102]

RESEARCH

Image 74: An orca is shown being lifted from its pool [103]

The whale is placed on a canvas hanger

covered with a strong fabric, then pulled from

several points of the hanger with the help of

a crane. This is important both to distribute

the load and to avoid hurting the whale. This

canvas is attached to the transport container.

The container must be leak-proof and should

therefore be constructed of suitable corrosion

proof metal, or heavy duty plastic of sufficient

strength. Then, the Container which is handled

by crane or fork-lift, is transported by truck, ship

or aircraft.

Figure 81: Cutaway view of bottlenosed dolphin within transport unit [102]

Image 75: The whale used for dissection is lifted from the ocean [104]

Figure 82: Transport unit [102]

Image 76: A cargo plane being loaded with two Beluga whales [105]

109



Assemblage of Total Filling Station


STRUCTURAL DURABILITY

ALTERNATIVE SYSTEMS

Total Filling Station

Image 77: Assembling a Total Filling Station, Gagosian Gallery [106]

While technology develops, the human desires for creating, discovering and making increase. Cabins are the first examples of this

motivation with small scale possibilities. In this part of the research, there are some examples of alternative systems. Some of them

were forgotten despite they were very popular in their past periods, some of them are still in use with some differences such as form

or scale and many of them continue to be developed by the contribution of modern technologies. All the examples have advantages

and disadvantages in particular situations. For example, the fast assembly systems are important after a disaster situation or the

local/man-made systems are vital where transportation not possible. The examples can continue with the folding systems in the

needs of bigger areas and do it yourself methods when labour is limited.

Flying Seedpod

Image 78: A folding-out geodesic structure, Flying Seedpod, Buckminster Fuller and his team at Washington University, St. Louis, 1953 [107]

Flying Seed-pod is a structure developed by Fuller and his students at Washington University in 1953. Fuller explains the aim of

the structure with these words “The prototype of the structural principles that we may use in sending history’s first (little) scientific

dwelling to the Moon. As you see all the structural members are tightly bundled together in parallel so that they may be transported

in minimum volume within a rocket capsule.” This structure was created four years before Sputnik 1(1957) which gives a start to the

idea of space travel. Because of the aim, the team worked on a folding system that has opportunities for space-saving and easy

assembly. It is a combination of a folding system and a geodesic dome developed by Fuller again.

Flying Seed-pod formed by tripod sets that contain three magnesium tubes and each set has a ball joint. These sets can be

transported as folded and then they can be fixed by connection points. All tripod feet fastened with ball joint and each ball joint

formed by five or six tubular-tripod feet. After the connection of sets, nearly 90 kg gas pressure is applied from the head of each

tripod and the feet of the tripod is opened. [108]

112


Mud Wall / Casting

RESEARCH

Figure 83: Casting production [109] Image 79: Adobe houses in Viranşehir, Şanlıurfa [110] Image 80: İTÜ Alker building by Ruhi Kafesçioğlu 1995 [111]

Casting application method; As a mud wall element, it is poured like concrete in large wooden moulds in place, thoroughly

compacted and allowed to dry. In this method, which is made with a ramming method, the wall is completed by adding a new

mourning adobe as the stage-by-stage adobe dries.[112]

As a result of the stepwise drying of the adobe, the mould is removed and the remaining areas are completed in the same way to

form the structure. The example in Image 79. is a photograph of adobe building efforts attempted creating a city with adobe houses

in 2009 Sanliurfa, Turkey. Since it is a local material, it allows the people to build their own houses. In Image 80, there is a building

built by Ruhi Kafesçioglu in 1995, ITU. Although the adobe is known to be non-resistant to earthquakes and floods, Mr. Kafesçioglu

has proved that it can be resistant to earthquakes and floods with adding plaster to adobe (alker).[109]

Mud Wall / Brick

Figure 84: Mud-brick production [109] Figure 85: Girder types [109] Image 81: Construction of mud brick wall [113]

Mud-brick application method; The suitable consistency previously prepared for mud-brick production is usually shaped by pouring

into wooden moulds. If mud-brick wall blocks are to be produced, the mud is poured into wooden moulds beforehand and it is left

to dry and then the mud bricks are walling with different types of girders. Despite the differences from region to region, the most

commonly used adobe sizes in Turkey are the mother and baby adobe.[112]

Girder types with mud: Adobe walling methods are important. In the case of corner studs and crossover walls, the connections

must be made correctly. Particularly in earthquake zones, the details of the corners should be strengthened with wooden(a,b),

reinforced concrete(c) or wire(d) grid to make the structure more robust. Reinforced masonry continues as in Figure 85. The adobe

structures are cheap thanks to the use of local materials and a fast process through which everyone can participate in the building.

Soil as a construction material forms a sustainable structure. By additional materials, mud-brick provides resistance against rain and

earthquake.[109]

113


STRUCTURAL DURABILITY

GEODESIC DOME

Image 82: The Supine Dome, Buckminster Fuller at Black Mountaion College [114]

“Models are essential. Don’t try build a dome without first making

or studying a models. However, don’t get so involved with model

that you never try a real structure.” Domebook 1 [115]

He firstly tried the model of Geodesic dome in Black Mountaion College

University, but it fall down (Image 82). He continued to enhance that system with

different techniques and materials. First successful example of geodesic dome,

Woods Hole dome, is built with Fuller and his students. The first “Bucky”s dome

has a wooden structure, and it was using as a restaurant that years. In the Image

83, Fuller was swinging with a rope to check its durability.

After a lot of successful examples of geodesic dome had been constructed,

several dome construction guides showed up in 70s such as dome-books and

most of them focused on geodesic principles.

Geodesic dome is a “shortest path of two points on a sphere

or curved space” Rene K. Mueller [117]

“R. Buckminster Fuller spent much

of the early 20th Century looking for

ways to improve human shelter by:

Applying modern technological knowhow

to shelter construction, and

making shelter more comfortable and

efficient, and making shelter more

economically available to a greater

number of people.

After acquiring some experience in the

building industry and discovering the

traditional practices and perceptions

which severely limit changes and

improvements in construction

practices, Fuller carefully examined,

and improved, interior structure

equipment, including the toilet (similar

to the ones now used in airplanes), the

shower (which cleans more efficiently

using less water), and the bathroom as

a whole. He studied structure shells,

and devised a number of alternatives,

each less expensive, lighter, and

stronger than traditional wood, brick,

and stone buildings.” [116]

Figure 86: Simple Geodesics in Domebook 1 [115]

Image 83: Buckminster Fuller was swinging from the Woods Hole dome while it was still under construction [118] Figure 87: Geodesic Geometry in Domebook 2 [119]

114


First Geodesic Dome in the World is

engineered by Walther Bauersfeld.

Mostly geodesic dome known as Buckmister

Fuller’s innovation, but before him, Walther

Bauersfeld made first geodesic dome in Germany.

It was constructed for “planetarium” in 1926 which

is 22 years before Supine Dome. We don’t know

that Fuller was aware of Jena in those years but

he developed lots of forms of geodesics and got

patents of his works. The dome was popular with

advantages such as rapid construction, easy

adaptation, clear span etc. For example, the

erection time of Kaiser Dome, designed by Don

Ritche, was 22 hours and it was impressive for

55 meters span structure with 1957’s technology.

One year after of Kaiser, Union Tank Dome, largest

clear span structure in its period, constructed by

Fuller’s geodesic system as developed by Howard

of Synergetics.

RESEARCH

Image 84: Construction of a planetarium of Carl Zeiss in Jena (Germany) 1922 [120]

“Revolutionary new building ... The first of its kind!

The Kaiser Aluminum Dome

20 Hours and the dome was up!” [121]

Figure 88: Geodesic Dome Patent Lithograph signed by Buckminster

Fuller, Thomas Zung and Shoji Sadao of Buckminster Fuller [123]

Image 85: Erection process of the first Kaiser Aluminum Dome, Honolulu

design by Don Ritcher [122]

Figure 89: Geodesic License Agreement [115]

115


Zeiss I Supine Dome Necklace Dome Ford Rotunda Kaiser Dome Union Tank

Dome

Jena, Germany

Planetarium

Iron Structure

Sprayed Concrete

Walter Bauersferd

Black Mountain, USA

Experimental

Venetian Blend

-

B.Fuller and Students

Black Mountain, USA

Experimental

Aluminium Aircraft Tube

Vinyl-Plastic Cover

B.Fuller and Students

Dearborn, USA

Company Headquarter

Aluminium Structure

Polyester Fiber Glass

Buckminster Fuller

Honolulu, Hawaii

Multi Purpose

Aluminium Panel

Don Ritcher

Baton Rouge, Louisiana

Tank Garage

Metal Sheets

Howard of Synergetics

*First Geodesic Dome

*First test structure and it

is failed.

*First succesful large

geodesic dome building.

*It was the largest clearspan

structure in the world

of it’s time.

117 Meters

2 Years

50 Meters

6 Months

25 Meters

28 Meters

5 Weeks

14.4 Meters

Failed

4.26 m

1 Day

1 Day

1926

1948

1949

1953

1957

1958


‘‘You never change things by fighting the existing reality. To change something, build

a new model that makes the existing model obsolete.’’ R. Buckminster Fuller

Climatron

St.Louis, USA

Green House

Aluminium Pipes

Glass Panels

Howard of Synergetics

Drop City

(Great Pumpkin)

Colorado, USA

Dwelling

Recycle Metals, Woods

Recycle Materials

Droppers

Montreal

Biosphere

Montreal, Canada

Expo

Steel Tubes

Acrylic Panels

Buckmister Fuller

South Pole

Station

South Pole, Antarctica

Ice Station

Metal Framework

Aluminium Panel

Buckminster Fuller

Spaceship Earth

Epcot, USA

Planetarium

Steel Structure

Buckmister Fuller

Eden Project

St.Petersburg, Russia

Botanical Garden

Steel Frame

Therma Plastic

Grimshaw Architects

3 Years

38 - 125 Meters

26 Months

76 Meters

1.5 Years

1 Year

42 Meters

6 Months

50 Meters

50 Meters

5.5 Meters

1 Day

1960

1965

1967

1975

1982

2001


STRUCTURAL DURABILITY

Demontable House

Figure 90: Montage Diagram, Jean Prouvé: Maison Démontable 8x8 Demountable House [124]

Image 86: Jean Prouvé 8x8 Demountable House by

Galerie Patrick Seguin in Miami, USA [125]

Jean Prouvé is a French metal craftsman working on prefabrication systems and he made early examples of prefabricated home

with Demountable House. It developed for urgent home needs caused by the destruction of World War II. In that period, there was a

need for light compact dwellings assembled by a few people easily and quickly and Prouvé developed it according to these needs.

The house formed by metal-frame structure and wooden panels. There is iconic shaped steel in the center of it and the folded-steel

structure which carries to the roof compass of it. The wooden panels placed the metal frame and the house was done. The simple

process of the assembly and disassembly allows everyone to build it in terms of the conditions of the period. Nina Azzarello said in

her article on Designboom, “It sits among the contemporary and fashionable new works celebrated at Miami’s massive exhibition, yet

entirely resonates in its evident relevance to the creative sphere today — a paragon of timeless composition and design.” [126]

Total Filling Station

Figure 91: Preliminary drawing of Total Filling Station

by Atelier Jean Prouvé [127]

Image 87: Assemblage of Total Filling Station [128] Image 88: A new kind of service station [129]

After many experiences on prefabricated house, he made first prefabricated filling station in 1969 with similar techniques of

prefabrication. “The buildings used a radiating central-plan structure of galvanized sheet steel with a central cylinder and perimeter

poles.” The reason of the cylindrical shape was the diversity of the sites and the structure allows vertical expansion. “As a manifesto

for prefabricated architecture, this light and rapidly, easily assembled structure was rebuilt as a demonstration piece outside the

architecture school in Nancy in 2000.” It was popular in that period and nearly a hundred of filling station were build but, most of

them are relocated or demolished now. [130]

118


Beach Matrix

RESEARCH

Image 89: Fitting module of Beach Matrix [131] Figure 92: The Matrix System [131] Figure 93: Beach Matrix [131]

In the 70s, there was a tendency by people to make their own houses and create a village formed of them with the counter-culture

movement. For this reason, lots of do it yourself guide book published and Ken Isaacs’s “How to build your own living structure” is

the important one of them. In the book, there are lots of examples of construction steps and materials and The Beach Matrix is one

of the applied examples of them.

In this project, Isaac uses the matrix system which he developed and adapted to different systems previously and unique joints

which are produced for pipes in x,y,z axis. The structure has a potential expansion and volumes with adding new pipes and boxes in

it. When the boxes placed in these volumes, different actions can be created in both indoor and outdoor areas.

8’ Micro House

Figure 94: The assembly steps of 8’Micro House [59]

Image 90: 8’Micro House [59]

The other significant example of Ken Isaacs is the 8’Micro House. The cabin is a micro dwelling unit formed by eight deformed

wooden cubes and four tetrahedron feet. By opening gaps on wooden panels, the doors and windows are created. The deformed

cube modules have a structure itself and raised a little bit from the ground with tetrahedron feet. Isaac describes the project in his

book, “When I was first discovering & applying the Matrix Idea I couldn’t help wondering why people had to shackle themselves to

some kind of corporate clerkship for twenty years to get the money for a home in the country. Why wasn’t it possible to apply your

best consciousness & information to develop a new shelter? It had to be compact & mobile using a minimum material list & buildable

in your apartment with simple tooling. Fabricate the parts in winter, slip into a van or wagon in spring & trek to a short-termleased

spot on a farmer’s back 40 & set her up in a day. It’s kind of like “freedom now” instead of waiting until you can “afford” it.

Living put off is lost.” [59]

119


STRUCTURAL DURABILITY

Navette Bamboo Pavilion

Image 91: Navette Pavilion by Markus Heinsdorff in Munich, 2009 [132]

Navette Bamboo Pavillion is structured by bamboo tubes as a primary building material. Markus Heinsdorff combines bamboo

sticks for creating boards as well as laminates. The importance of bamboo is about its sustainable character as an old building

material. 20 meters a month, it grows faster than any other plant, and its hallow tubes mean that it is not only light and elastic, but

also a very stable and long-lasting building material. “The outside walls consist of vertical bamboo tubes and bamboo laminate bars

running horizontally around the structure which are connected using brackets.” [133]

Prada Transformer

Image 91: Transformation of Prada Transformer by OMA in Seoul, Korea, 2009; Iwan Baan [134]

Prada Transformer is a structure formed by four different shapes - a hexagon, a cross, a rectangle, and a circle - with four different

cultural activities which are represented Prada as a fashion showcase of Miuccia Prada, a cinema hall shown films selected by

Alejandro González Iñárritu, an art exhibition curated by Germano Celant, and a special event area. The 20-meter high structure

installed in the center of Seoul which is near Gyeonghui Palace. The pavilion rotated by four cranes placed in four edges during the

exhibition periodically for changing the activity. Every ground presents a different experience with different events and also, it is a roof

or a wall of other grounds. The Transformer is full of grounds and walls that are transformed into each other. [135]

120


Ten Fold

Figure 95: Expanding Structure, Ten Fold Engineering [136]

Image 92: Stealth, Ten Fold Engineering [136]

“Eight minutes. That is the length of time UK-based company Ten Fold Engineering’s self-deploying structures can transform

itself from a portable rectangular container into a fully habitable space that can be used for either the residential or service sector.

Transported by truck, the company offers a shelter that is energy efficient, eliminates labour costs, and is highly customizable

prefabrication and construction. With the only requirement for installation to have a stable ground, the options for Ten Fold’s

structures are expansive, including the ability to stack units for more space. Not only does the portable structure represent a

rethinking of residential design, but also an easily implemented solution to help communities in need. The shelters have the potential

to provide services such as mobile clinics or grocery stores.”[137]

RESEARCH

Tensairity Beam

Figure 96: A basic Tensairity beam [138]

Image 93: Development of foldable Tensairity structures.

Prospective concepts AG, 2005 [138]

Image 94: A tensairity slab, 3 m span, Empa, 2009 [138]

Tensairity is a new lightweight structural concept. It is a synergistic combination of struts, cables and an inflated membrane. The

tension and compression elements are physically separated by the air inflated beam, which – when inflated – pretensions the

tension element and stabilizes the compression element against buckling. “The outcome of this interaction between the different

elements is a structure with the load bearing capacity of conventional steel girders and the low weight of an air beam.” [139]

The “fold-able truss” is a conventional truss where the horizontal tension and compression bars are divided in two and reconnected

with an intermediate hinge (Image 93). This way, the truss becomes a mechanism. “The compression and tension bars are in the

deployable Tensairity structure continuously attached with the hull, and this way, the truss is stable when the air beam is fully inflated.

The diagonals can be included or excluded and vertical cables connecting upper and lower strut can be applied.” [140]

The innovative concept Tensairity provides more features than a few conventional structures have, such as a fast assembling/

dismantling, and a compact storage and transport volume. This technological invention creates potential mobile and temporary

architectural applications. [141]

121


STRUCTURAL DURABILITY

SPACE FRAMES

“Nature’s simplest structural system in the universe is the

tetrahedron. The regular tetrahedron does not fill all-space

by itself. The octahedron and tetrahedron complement one

another to fill all space. Together they produce the simplest,

most powerful structural system in the universe .’’

Buckminster Fuller [142]

‘’A space frame is a 3D truss formation that consists of

lightweight interlocking members that create a latticework.

Space frames are used for long-span roofs and can be formed

to make hollow columns or girder elements. Their strength-toweight

ratio is high, making this an ideal solution for few points

of support and prefabricated structures that have a high degree

of repetition’’ [143]

Alexander Graham Bell from 1898 to 1908 developed space

frames based on tetrahedral geometry and was granted a

patent for Connecting Device for the Frames of Aeriel Vehicles

and Other Structures in 1907. This patent shows a modular

octahedral-tetrahedral system “adaptable to a great variety of

structural uses.” It was used quite frequently in the automobile

and aircraft industries. In 1943, Max Mengeringhausen

developed a space grid system called ‘MERO’ in Germany,

thus initiating the use of space trusses in architecture. It was

a modular system consisting of nodes and tubes of different

sizes. The system is still in use today.

Image 95: The MERO system potential uses proposed in 1943 [144]

Image 96: Alexander Graham Bell’s Tetrahedral Kite [145]

Years later, Bucky patented his invention as an

The Octet Truss in 1961, which is widely used in

space frames today. The Octet Truss is a building

component made up of a tetrahedron and an

octahedron with equal edge lengths which are

made using struts. Space frames are attributed to

Alexander Graham Bell at the turn of the twentieth

century, but Buckminster Fuller made them

popular in architecture. [146]

Image 97: Alexander Graham Bell (right)’s tetrahedral kites, 1908 [145] Figure 97: The MERO system potential uses proposed in 1943 [142]

122


M.A.D.I Home

RESEARCH

Image 98: Assembly steps of MADI Home [98]

The M.A.D.I Home company develops a cabin that is assembled within seconds with the help of a crane. The folded form of it can

easily be shipped everywhere in a simple container and after the delivery, the crane unfolds the wooden structure by raising the top

point. The company defines a project as an earthquake proof with A-frame construction and also a possible disaster relief structure

because of the fast assembly. The cabin is formed by a frame and it does not need any foundation but it is adjustable for different

situations. After the temporary need is done, the structure can be folded in the same way and removed for another need. Although

a basic module is 27 square meters included as a ground floor and a first floor, the area can be expanded with additive panels or

changing scale.

Kiosk K67

Figure 98: The diagram of Kiosk K67 [147] Image 99: Possible layout of the K67 system [147]

Figure 99: Expansion options and combinations of Kiosk

K67, Saša Mächtig [147]

K67’s design allowed the possibility of growth and change with its modular structure, method of production and flexibility. It was

based on five modular spatial elements made of reinforces polyester that allows the possibilities of many configurations and reinvent

itself. These elements could be freely assembled. Its flexible design allows it to be used in many parts of the world, such as fastfood

stand, tobacco, flower shop, petrol stations, ski lift ticket booths and many others. The enclosures could be horizontally and

vertically assembled into linear or spatially diverse configurations (While the concept design from 1967 envisaged the stacking of

individual elements into vertical configurations, this was never realised in practice.). Kiosks K67 are therefore more than just individual

units or modules, they can form dynamic spatial structures that embody the relentless potential for change and growth.

‘‘‘Prior to the expansion of industrialisation and the development of new technologies and materials kiosks had mainly been built on

construction methods as mini architectures or houses. Sometimes even designed for a ‘’specific one-off location,” rather than as

products designed and produced according to the industrial logic of mass production.’’[149]

123


TECHNOLOGY

According to the Cambridge dictionary, technology means ‘‘knowledge,

equipment, and methods that are used in science and industry’’.

Technology is a collection of all kinds of methods and tools that have

emerged in every aspect of our lives. In this sense, it is directly related

to architecture. With the development of technology, especially in recent

years, the boundaries in which the product of architecture is defined have

begun to change. In this context, as AAP, we will explore the possibilities

that emerge with developing technologies. To investigate technology

through the architectural product and the architectural process, we will

consider the building methods, production methods, transportation ways

and material of the architectural object. Moreover, this chapter aims to

question alternative solution methods with technological opportunities.

Kugelhaus, by John William Ludowic, 1950 [1]


ALTERNATIVE BUILDING METHODS

On Site

Masonry System

Casting System

3D Printing System

Prefabrication

Frame System

Panel System

Box System

PRODUCTION METHODS

Standardisation

Mass Production

Mass Customization

TRANSPORTATION

Land

Air

Sea

ALTERNATIVE BUILDING MATERIALS

Exterior

Interior

In Between

125


TECHNOLOGY

ALTERNATIVE BUILDING METHODS

On Site

The components of the building are brought together in the

project area. The raw material that forms the building can

be moved to the project area. This raw material is usually

processed in the project area. Therefore, it is important to

organize the construction site during the construction phase of

the project. It is not possible to move the structure created in

the project area to another area. It is fixed to the ground.

In this chapter there will be three systems examined; masonry,

casting and 3D printing systems for on site projects.

5 mm

Masonry System

It is a building method, which do not have any skeletal

system and whose walls are of a carrier nature, working on

the principle of transferring the vertical loads to each other

by placing different elements on top of each other and

connecting with mortar.

The compressive strength and tensile strength of the

components are low. These materials may undergo

deformation when subjected to pressure and tensile action.

They can not withstand the tensile stresses caused by

earthquake forces or changes in the ground.

In masonry structures, the walls have both divisive and

carrying functions. The walls form both the volumes and

separate the internal partitions created by the function of the

structure. As the walls are carriers, any damage to the walls

directly affects the carrier system. [4]

With fire bricks: Earth as a building material is known to have

high compressive strength when dry, but in the presence

of water to be extremely vulnerable. Therefore, the earth

is fired at high temperature to ensure its water resistance.

Conventionally the most common structural application in the

world is the fired brick. [5]

Figure 2: Craneloft by Yorgos Rimenidis + Michalis Softas [2]

“Architecture is an art

we can not avoid. It’s

more than a shelter, a

useful commodity, a

little game. ’’

(Roth, 2006) [3]

Figure 3: Fire Brick [6]

Today, architecture is beyond architectural product.

The building methods, have changed with the changing

technologies, transforming forms, increasing number of

materials and differentiating methods of representation.

Considering both economic and usage value, alternative

building methods will be discussed in this section along

with the important breaking points in the history. In addition,

alternative building methods will be examined through current

systems and examples.

126


With earthbag: The construction process begins with a

trench opened to form the foundation. This trench is usually

filled with stones and gravel. However, it is recommended to

construct a concrete foundation in areas with an earthquake

risk. ‘‘Earthbag buildings can also be built on conventional

concrete slabs (though this is more expensive and uses

more embodied energy than a rubble trench foundation)

and can have a underground “floating” foundation like an

earthship as well.’’ [8]

The relation of earth bags that come into contact with

the ground with water should be considered. It should

be supported with material (such as gravel) to provide

waterproofing. The bags are placed cross to ensure that the

earthen bags do not slip. Earth bags are supported by nets,

barbed wires. In addition, the form of the building is also very

important. [8]

The earth can be pre-filled in bags and placed on top of the

project area, or it can be built by filling earth in tube bags

in the project area. The clay and humid soil in the bag will

ensure the stability of the structure.

RESEARCH

Image 1: Making Bricks, Masasi, 2010 [7]

Figure 4 is about making fire bricks process. Firstly, in the dry season the ground

is baked hard by the sun. Then, laying out bricks to dry, covered by straw.

Secondly, nearly ready for lighting the fires and the brick pile is a kiln with fire

inside. [7]

Figure 4: Earthbag system [9]

127


TECHNOLOGY

With earthship: Many waste materials are left to nature by

people. These wastes lead to consumption of raw material

resources beyond volumetric space. Therefore, it is very

important to recycle waste materials. In this sense, some

waste materials can be used as building materials for building.

To get rid of the waste material and to make it functional

provides many ecological benefits.

Image 3: Gimme Shelter, Michael Reynolds, 2013 [11]

Figure 5: Cappadocian Topak, illustrated by Mukund Iyer, 2017 [10]

The “Earthship” building, designed by Michael Reynolds in

new Mexico, was built by combining waste such as rubber

wheels, cans, glass bottles with earth.

‘‘The building is horseshoe-shaped due to the difficulty

of creating sharp 90 degree angles with rammed tires. In

Reynolds’s prototype at Taos, the opening of the horseshoe

faces 10-15 degrees east of south to maximize natural light

and solar-gain during the winter months, with windows on

sun-facing walls admitting light and heat. The thick and dense

walls provide thermal mass that naturally regulates the interior

temperature during both cold and hot outside temperatures.

The outer walls in the majority of Earthships are made of earthrammed

tires, but any dense material with a potential to store

heat, such as concrete, adobe, earthbags or stone, could in

principle be used to create a building similar to an Earthship.

In an effort to cut down the use of concrete even further, they

also use “squishes” tires rammed in between a tight space to

even out the course or to compensate for varying tire sizes.’’

[11]

Image 2: Cappadocian Topak, Oba Ruhu, 2017 [10]

The Cappadocian Topak was built by the Oba Ruhu. Tubes consolidates the

moist clay-containing fill and the surface of the bags was plastered with soil

belonging to the region. [10]

Image 4: Gimme Shelter, Michael Reynolds, 2013 [11]

128


Casting System

Casting is the process of pouring the liquid prepared material

into moulds prepared in desired shapes and sizes. The

liquid substance solidifies in the mould. The production is

completed by removing the moulds of the solidified part.

Casting materials are usually metals or various time setting

materials that cure after mixing two or more components

together such as epoxy, concrete, plaster and clay. Casting

provides the construction of parts that are not economical and

easy to do in the project area. It eliminates the transportation

problems in bringing big building elements to the construction

site. [4]

With rammed earth: Making rammed earth involves

compacting a damp mixture of sub soil that has suitable

proportions of sand, gravel, clay, and stabilizer, if any has

poured into a formwork (an externally supported frame or

mould). Soil mix is poured into the form work to a depth of 10

to 25 cm and then compacted to approximately 50% of its

original volume. The earth is gradually placed in the moulds.

In this layer-by-layer system, it is very important to place each

layer tightly. While tamping can be applied manually with

rammers with long compression arms, it can also be done

with machines today.

The process is not finished by completing the compression

process in the formwork. ‘‘After a wall is complete, it is

sufficiently strong to immediately remove the formwork. This

is necessary if a surface texture is to be applied, e.g., by

wire brushing, carving, or mould impression, because the

walls become too hard to work after approximately one hour.

Compressive strength of rammed earth increases as it cures.

Cement stabilised Rammed Earth is cured for a minimum

period of 28 days.’’ [12]

‘‘The construction of an entire wall begins with a temporary

frame, denominated the “formwork”, which is usually made

of wood or plywood, as a mould for the desired shape and

dimensions of each section of wall. The form must be durable

and well braced, and the two opposing faces must be

clamped together to prevent bulging or deformation caused

by the large compressing forces. Formwork plays an important

role in building Rammed Earth walls. Historically, wooden

planks tied using rope to build walls. Modern builders use

plywood and/or steel to build formwork.’’ [12]

RESEARCH

Figure 6: Rammed Earth Wall Construction [13] Image 5: Modern Rammed Earth Home in New Mexico, Signer Harris, 2012 [14]

129


TECHNOLOGY

3D Printing System

Although traditional construction methods seem to make it

difficult to adopt developing technology, many advances in

technology greatly affect the way of construction and building

materials. Therefore, it is impossible to think of architecture

and technology independently.

‘‘One steadily rising technology is 3D printing. The introduction

of this technology has already caught the attention of

many enterprises who have accelerated in designing

and printing tons of objects using a wide variety of

materials. Therefore, introducing 3D printing to the

construction industry is the focus of many pioneers who

acknowledge the potential of this technology as a new

strategic challenge. Automated printing with layers

allows for flexibility and freedom of architectural design and

more accurate applications, in addition to saving tons of

material that would otherwise to go waste in a conventional

construction site.’’ [15]

‘‘In the construction industry, 3D printing can be used to

create construction components or to ‘print’ entire buildings.

Construction is well-suited to 3D printing. The latest

emergence of building information modelling (BIM) in particular

may facilitate greater use of 3D printing. Construction with 3D

printing may allow more and more accurate construction of

complex or bespoke items as well as lowering labour costs

and producing less waste. It can also be used in a harsh or

dangerous environment.’’ [16]

Image 6: 3D Printing Detail [17]

This method involves the building material being deposited to

create a large-scale 3D model with a smooth surface finish.

‘‘Rails are installed around the building ground that will act as a

structure to direct the robotic arm. It moves back and forth to

extrude the concrete, layer-by-layer. Trowels placed on the side

and above the nozzle to flatten the extruded layers and ensure

the model’s strength.’’

‘‘In this process, conventional concrete can not be used as

it would need to be harden before you could continue the

process. If it was 3D printed it wouldn’t be able to support its

own weight. Therefore, concrete is used with quick setting

properties. The base material (a finely calibrated mix of cement,

sand, plasticizers, and other aggregates) gets poured into a

hopper at the top of the printer and flows onto the rising walls

below.’’ [16]

Figure 7: Building through 3D Printing [16]

Image 7: Casey Dunn, Census Bureau, 2018 [16]

130


DIGITAL PRODUCTION

RESEARCH

Figure 8: Jacquard Loom, 1801, [17]

“Jacquard, in 1801, developed a numerical control system for automating weaving patterns in a

loom allowing textile design and manufacture. This was accomplished by using punch cards as the

numerical input similar to numerical sequencing drives in contemporary computing.” [17]

131


TECHNOLOGY

Prefabrication

Prefabrication is the practice of the assembling whole

of the structure or its components in a factory or other

manufacturing site. Parts mounted outside the construction

site are transported to the project area. Unlike traditional onsite

construction methods, prefabrication makes construction

site conditions flexible. Production affect to a minimum from

environmental factors, weather conditions, etc.

There are 3 systems to build prefabricated building: frame,

panel and box.

The components of the prefabricated building are produced

on line up, stand, aggregate areas in factory. ‘‘The term

prefabrication also applies to the manufacturing of things

other than structures at a fixed site. It is frequently used

when fabrication of a section of a machine or any movable

structure is shifted from the main manufacturing site to another

location, and the section is supplied assembled and ready

to fit. Prefabricated parts of the body of the machine may be

called ‘sub-assemblies’ to distinguish them from the other

components.’’ [18]

Figure 9: Prefabricated System [19]

Image 8: Habitat, Moshie Safdie, 1967 [17]

Moshie Safdie designed this housing complex called “Habitat” for the 1967 World

Expo in Montreal. At age 24, Safdie developed a complex of 158 dwellings from

354 precast modular units.[17]

Figure 10: Step by Step Prefabrication [20]

132


‘‘Prefabrication avoids the need to transport so many skilled

workers to the construction site, and other restricting

conditions such as a lack of power, lack of water, exposure

to harsh weather or a hazardous environment are avoided.

Against these advantages must be weighed the cost of

transporting prefabricated sections and lifting them into

position as they will usually be larger, more fragile and more

difficult to handle than the materials and components of which

they are made.’’ [18]

RESEARCH

Figure 11: Prefabrication Building Systems [17]

‘‘Building systems are generally thought of in five different

categories: site, structure, skin, services, and space and stuff.

Prefabrication can be used to deliver everything but the site.

Most “stuff,” including furnishings and fixtures, are so easily

changed and their lifespan varies from year to year that it will

not be considered as a prefabricated system. Therefore, for

the purposes of organizing the information herein, the focus

will be on off site fabricated structure and enclosure systems

with a brief discussion of interior space and service systems

of buildings in relation to architecture.’’ [17]

‘‘The theory behind the method is that time and cost is saved

if similar construction tasks can be grouped, and assembly

line techniques can be employed in prefabrication at a

location where skilled labour is available, while congestion

at the assembly site, which wastes time, can be reduced.

The method finds application particularly where the structure

is composed of repeating units or forms, or where multiple

copies of the same basic structure are being constructed.’’ [18]

Figure 12: Cost of On-site-Off-site Construction [17]

‘‘For traditional construction loans that make draws throughout a project, off

site construction allows for a more consistent draw schedule throughout the

construction process compared with on site construction that has difficulty

anticipating the large draws that are necessary and often difficult to make cash

liquid in a short amount of time.’’ [17]

DEGREE OF PREFABRICATION

Figure 13: Degree of Prefabrication Diagram [17]

“ Prefabrication can be classified by the extent to which elements are completed prior to assembly on site. From left

to right: materials, components, panels, and modules. Generally, the benefits of prefabrication can be realized as

projects move to increasingly greater degrees of prefabrication.”[17]

133


TECHNOLOGY

PROJECT DELIVERY

Figure 14: Project Delivery Methods [17]

‘‘Design-build contracts, including integrated project

delivery in the United States, have consistently increased

in project delivery since their inception in the

1980s from a few percent of total construction projects

to just over 40 percent in 2010. On the other hand,

traditional design-bid-build contracts have steadily declined

in use. Construction manager delivery has stayed

relatively the same.’’ [17]

Figure 15: Bathroom Service Pod, Kullman Building Corporation [17]

‘‘Prefabrication of services as it relates to architecture refers to a higher level of

unitization. Services may be produced as modules that can be located in buildings.

Bathrooms, kitchens, communication rooms, utility rooms, and service walls are

out fitted in the factory and then placed efficiently inside building structures. This

bathroom service pod is fabricated with plumbing, fixtures, and finishes and

shipped to be installed as an interior module within a building structure.’’ [17]

ASSEMBLY DIAGRAM

Figure 16: Assembly Diagram, Kieran Timberlake, 2008 [17]

“Assembly diagram that has become a staple of the work of KieranTimberlake outlines the goals of the Cellophane

House, designed and built for the MOMA exhibit “Home Delivery.” While on-site methods employ many materials

and processes of construction that eventually are demolished and replaced, prefab solutions offer the potential for

disassembly and reuse.” [17]

134


SOVIET PREFABRICATED BUILDING SYSTEM

Large concrete panels received the attention of Henry

Flynt and Fluxus founder George Maciunas, who in

1965 published a pamphlet entitled ‘Communists Must

Give Revolutionary Leadership in Culture, Appendix

1’. ‘‘The pamphlet praised the Soviet panellised

prefabrication method as the most efficient way of

providing housing because it proposed design solutions

based on technological advancement rather than

national traditions or stylistic choices.’’ [21]

“For Flynt and Maciunas, the Khrushchyovkas

exemplified the three principles of revolutionary

leadership in culture: they increased productivity,

promoted equality and solidarity among workers, and

satisfied the workers’ desire to cope with reality.” (Henry

Flint, ‘Communists Must Give Revolutionary Leadership

In Culture’, 1965. Design by George Maciunas.

Published by World View Publishers. Collection Emily

Harvey Foundation.) [21]

RESEARCH

Figure 17: Soviet Prefabricated Building System, 1965 [21]

135


TECHNOLOGY

Frame System

Frame systems are installed using linear elements that

provide load transfer in vertical and horizontal. Connectors

that connect horizontal and vertical elements to one are very

important. ‘‘Steel studs are laid at on the floor and joined to

make divider edges. The divider edges are sheathed for

non-combustible construction; the divider edges are tilted

up, screwed down to the edge, and propped. The upper

stage is surrounded, then the upper dividers. At last, the roof

and rooftop are encircled similarly as in a confined house.

Prefabricated assembled trusses of edge frameworks which

are screwed or welded together are regularly used to casing

roofs and rooftops.’’ [22]

There is a different meaning between frame systems and

framing. Framing, in construction is the timber work or

steelwork that encloses and supports structural components

of a building.

Panel System

Figure 19: Panel System [24]

‘‘Panel System is one of the prefabrication systems ideal for

straight, curved or angled facade applications and has

an elegant and light appearance with smooth rounded

edges. Prefabricated panel is set in position and layer of

cement or mortar are connected to both sides. Boards

are utilized as a part of the development of outside and

inside bearing and non-load bearing dividers and floors in

a wide range of construction. The board gets its quality

and unbending nature from the inclining cross wires welded to

the welded-wire fabric on each side.’’ [22]

Figure 18: Frame System [23]

Figure 20: Panel System Assembly [25]

136


Box System

24-STUDY DORMITORY

RESEARCH

Figure 21: Box System [26]

Box system is a modern system where burden bearing

dividers give the essential vertical backing and horizontal

solidness for floors. Outside divider boards, lift centres

or staircases are utilized to give the obliged longitudinal

dependability. ‘‘Connecting parts, for example, floors, rooftops

and pillars are bolstered by the heap bearing dividers or

facade divider. In box system, components are conveyed to

site ‘in the nick of time’. Concealed joints and ties, both on a

level plane and vertically are grouted set up as the work

creates, avoiding dynamic breakdown.’’ [22]

Image 10: Study Dormitory Building Process, 2010 [17]

O’Connell East Architects (OEA) designed a 24-story

modular student dormitory for Wolverhampton

Development in the United Kingdom in 2010. ‘‘This

building contains 805 embedded steel structural

modules and was built in 27 weeks.’’ [17]

Image 9: SpaceBox, Holland Composites, 2003 [27]

137


TECHNOLOGY

PRODUCTION METHODS

The basis for the theory is to increase variety and

customization without increasing costs. More than this goal,

however, the concept has become consistent with meeting

the individual needs of customers without sacrificing efficiency,

effectiveness, and affordability.

5 mm

Image 11: K-7 Panel,1960 [28]

“In modern times

we’ve focused on new

manufacturing methods,

shifting from mass to

lean production, and

are now at the next

wave of manufacturing

innovations: mass

customization’’ (Liker,

2003) [29]

‘‘Industrialization: As related to the industrial revolution of

1848, this marked a change in an economic and societal

thinking by virtue of advanced machinery that is still pervasive

today.

Standardization: As a result of the industrialized society,

products became standardized. This was most prevalent in

developing standards related to military production.

Mechanization: This is an effort to move standardization

to greater economies of scale, but introducing additional

mechanized processes that were developed during the war

years, but furthered by virtue of more advanced mechanical

machinery, thus reducing human labour.

Mass production: Thriving on the economies of scale, this

concept is to produce as much of the same thing in order to

bring down the cost of a single item. It has grown concurrently

with consumer demand.

Automation: The development of digitally informed

manufacturing machinery via computer numerical control and

CAD/CAM software.

Mass customization: This concept brings together mass

production and automation to deliver an economy of scope.

Mass customization works to maximize the benefits of

mechanization and automation production methods, reducing

labour costs, but works to preserve the benefits of variability

and customization in the output.’’ [17]

Figure 22: Standardization to Customization [17]

This is a listing of the developments in manufacturing technology from

industrialization in the mid-1800s to today’s mass customization by virtue of

CAD/CAM technologies. These concepts are not exclusive, but represent when

concepts developed and how we understand industrialized building today. [17]

138


Standardization

‘‘Standardization is the limitation to the variety in product

produced so that machines may be able to output certain

lengths, widths, and assemblies. This removes the waste

associated with variability options and the margin of error in

end products.

Although manufacturing has moved progressively from

standardization to customization, the concepts of mass

production are the modes of production still used and

understood in design and construction today.’’ [17]

RESEARCH

The idea of architecture of machine was led to several

generalizations:

‘‘Firstly, that a well stated problem naturally finds its

solution; secondly, that since all men have the same

biological organization, they all have the same basic

needs; and thirdly, that architecture, like machinery,

should be a product of competitive selection applied

to standards which, in turn, should be determined by

logical analysis and experimentation.’’

(Collins, P.,1965 ) [30]

Figure 23: Citrohan House, Le Corbusier [17]

Figure 4, Le Corbusier’s ideas for a “machine for living” included the 1920–

1930 Citrohan House. This house was inspired by the manufacturing methods

employed in early standardized automobile production. [17]

LUSTRON HOMES

Image 12: Lustron Factory, 1949 [31]

‘‘Lustron Factory prefabricated home lie on the ground prior to installation April 16, 1949 in Columbus, Ohio. The

production of Lustron’s prefabricated home was a result of the urgency for affordable housing for veterans returning

home from the war.’’ [17]

139


TECHNOLOGY

Mass Production

Mass production is a system in which a large number of

the same products are produced, usually using assembly

lines and automation technology. The efficiency of each

standardized product has been optimized. Mechanization is

used to achieve high volume, detailed organization of material

flow, careful control of quality standards, and division of labour.

If the production is stringently monitored, mass production

results in a precision assembly as production line machines

have set parameters. Labour costs are often lower for massproduced

products. This cost savings is from the automated

assembly line production processes requiring fewer workers.

[17]

‘‘Further, assembly of mass-produced products is at a

quicker rate due to increased automation and efficiency. This

rapid assembly aids the prompt distribution and marketing

of an organization’s products with the potential to create a

competitive advantage and higher profits.’’ [32]

Figure 24: Process Mass Production [33]

Image 13: Ford Motor Company,1931 [34]

‘‘From Ford model T car to today, mass production system is used. To achieve

Henry Ford’s goal of mass consumption through mass production, productivity

needed to increase. At the factory , workers were placed at appointed stations

and the chassis was hauled along between them using strong rope. The chassis

stopped at each station, where parts were fitted, until it was finally completed. [34]

Figure 25: Construction and Architecture of Leningrad, 1964 [28]

Assembly-line system for manufacturing outer walls of Series OD at the Obikhov

combine in Leningrad (mid-1960s). [28]

140


HOUSING APPROACH OF OTHER INDUSTRIES

RESEARCH

‘‘Since Toyota Motor Co. entered the housing business in

1975, it has conducted business under the banner of “truly

wanting to make Japanese homes better”. The company

developed a line-up of detached housing products using

a variety of different building techniques and expanded its

business to include condominiums and rental housing. Their

modular homes, which go from $200k to $800k, can be

assembled in less than 45 days and come with a 60-year

guarantee.’’ [36]

Toyota Housing Corporation

İmage 14: Toyota Housing,1975 [35] İmage 15: MUJI Houses, 2004 [37]

‘‘MUJI entered the home building only in Japan to provide a

simple, compact yet highly editable, universal platform that will

last for decades. In 2014 the company launched a 15-foot-wide

three-story prefab perfect for Japan’s disposable home culture.

It sells for just $180,000. They also came out with a line of Muji

Huts three cabin-like structures more suited to be used during a

vacation rather than permanent residency. They reportedly cost

$25,000-$40,000.’’ [37]

MUJI Houses

1961

1997

2019

1975

2004

Panasonic Homes

BoKlok by IKEA

BMW And North Face Camper Concept

İmage 16: Panasonic Homes,1961 [38]

‘‘There is no business more

important than to build

home’’... ‘‘There are hundreds

of business now even so

among them all, there is one

business that I would like to

venture in. That is building

homes’’

Kōnosuke Matsushita, founder

of Panasonic

‘‘In 1961, Panasonic announced

and started sales of the Matsushita

Type-One Housing Unit with a

ground-breaking structure of bolted

steel-frame pillars and beams under

Matsushita Electric Works Co., Ltd.’’

[38]

İmage 17: BoKlok by IKEA,1939 [40]

‘‘The BoKlok (pronounced “book look”

and meaning “live smart”) concept

is simple: to provide space-saving,

functional, high-quality properties at

affordable prices IKEA and Skanska

came together to offer sustainable,

quality, low-cost home ownership. They

complete most of the houses in the

factory as they can, and try to complete

the installation on the construction site

with less heavy vehicles. They have built

more than 11,000 homes throughout

Sweden, Finland, Denmark and Norway.

On average this amounts c. 1,200

homes a year.’’ [40]

İmage 18: BMW and North Face Home, 2019 [41]

‘‘In collaboration with outdoor specialists from

The North Face, the BMW Group subsidiary

presented its innovative concept camper.

Thanks to “nano-spinning” technology, its

novel outer skin is said to be one of the

most watertight and breathable fabrics in the

world and therefore ideal for protecting the

occupants of the camper from bad weather.

Inside, the innovative trailer provides sleeping

space for two, as well as a bench, shelves,

and small windows. The fabric designed

with nano-spinning technology to withstand

extreme cold.’’ [41]

141


TECHNOLOGY

Mass Customisation

‘‘Mass customisation, in marketing, manufacturing, call

centres and management, is the use of flexible computeraided

manufacturing systems to produce custom output.

Such systems combine the low unit costs of mass production

processes with the flexibility of individual customisation.

Mass customisation is the new frontier in business for

both manufacturing and service industries. At its core is a

tremendous increase in variety and customisation without a

corresponding increase in costs. At its limit, it is the mass

production of individually customised goods and services. At

its best, it provides strategic advantage and economic value.’’

[42]

Figure 27: Mass Customisation Diagram [44]

Joseph Lampel and Henry Menitzberg‘s classification of customisation strategies.

Gray boxes indicate standardization, and the others customization.[44]

Figure 26: Increased Flexibility in Production and Manufacturing on Demand [43]

Figure 28: Cost Diagram [17]

‘‘Left: Fordist mass production relies on the economies of scale: as repetition

increases cost per unit decreases. Middle: Likewise, as variation increases,

the cost per unit exponentially grows. Right: Mass customisation suggests that

variability is possible within an acceptable margin of cost increase.’’ [17]

CASE STUDY HOUSE 18

Case Study No. 18, or house Fields is a house built

by Ellwood in 1958 with a pre-cast system. There is

a steel frame system painted in blue for structure and

panel parts for the walls. Incorporated into the structure

of terrazzo floors, wood panelling and a mosaic mural,

created by its client-oriented in the exterior wall to the

pool. [45]

Figure 29: Case Study House 18, Craig Ellwood,1958 [45]

142


LLOYDS BUILDING

TOILET PODS

RESEARCH

Figure 30: 3D Printed Housing, New Story + ICON + Échale, 2017 [46]

‘‘The world’s first 3D printed community founded underway in a remote area in

Mexico. The printer has been created as a solution to minimise homelessness

and provide safe and adequate shelter for individuals.

This community proposal will aim to produce a total of 50 homes using the 3D

printer referred to as the Vulcan II. The Vulcan II is designed to build resilient singlestorey

homes at a faster rate than traditional construction methods. The machine

uses a cement-based mix to produce the walls and has the capacity to build a

2000 sqm home if required.

The homes that are built/to be built are 500 sqm in size and the general layout will

consist of a living space, kitchen, bathroom and 2 bedrooms. The families who

will live in them have provided feedback on what they require for the community

and the homes themselves. The families that were chosen to receive these

homes are the ones that were in the most physical and financial need. The design

was built to be resilient against difficult climate conditions such as seismic activity

and flooding.’’ [46]

Image 21: Lloyds Building, Richard Rogers, 1986 [47]

‘‘This structure is less dependant on the core (stairs

and lifts) for structural support and bracing, using post,

beam & bracing. This allows for the vast majority of the

building to be prefabricated and connected into a matrix

on site. Cells can thus be changed at will, allowing

the building to be refurbished with other prefabricated

elements quickly. A further addition to this concept is the

building as a mother board with ‘Plug & Play’ pre-wired/

serviced elements quickly coupled to the frame.’’ [47]

143


TECHNOLOGY

NAKAGIN CAPSULE TOWER

‘‘The Capsule Tower architecture design,

establishment of the capsule as room and

insertion of the capsule into a mega-structure,

express its contemporaneousness with other

works of liberated architecture from the later

1960’s, in particular England’s Archigram Group,

France’s Paul Memon, and Yona Friedman.’’ [48]

Image 22: Nakagin Capsule Tower, Kisho Kurokawa, 1972 [48]

Figure 30: Nakagin Capsule Tower Plan and Detail [48]

144


LOGO OF CAMUS-DIETSCH FACTORY

‘‘A panel hanging from a crane was the logo of Camus-

Dietsch, a French company which opened its facility

in Marienau in 1954. The factory was the foundation

for prefabricated construction across many countries,

including the Soviet Union, Austria, Czechoslovakia,

Great Britain, Italy, Belgium, Japan, Iraq, Syria, Cuba,

Chile, Zaire, Gabon, Taiwan, Bahrain, and many others.

The Marienau factory closed in 1982, two years after

the passing of Raymond Camus, the inventor and

promoter of large-panel construction. Original emblem

of the Camus-Dietsch factory, circa 1960, Collection de

la Ville de Forbach.’’ [21]

RESEARCH

Figure 31: Logo of Camus-Dietsch Factory, 1954 [21]

145


TECHNOLOGY

TRANSPORTATION

Image 24: Portable modular classroom, Jennifer Sieg Country School [17]

Planning of the transportation system is important in the

design of the parts and their coming together. Elements

must be broken down to be shipped. This limits the size of

individual panels, modules, or components. The elements of

the structure to be transported must be designed separately

and then their coming together must be calculated. [17]

Image 23: Flying Panels: How Concrete Panels Changed the World [21]

In addition to transport and installation, the sequence that

affects design staging should be examined. Although ideally

off site manufactured elements are not standing still, staging

does occur on every job site. How the materials will be

protected has a importance especially if they are finished and

ready to build in.

“ The specifications

for prefabrication

should outline how

the module, panel, or

component is going to

be picked up (Smith,

2010) .” [17]

Image 25: Transportation of American Prefabs [17]

In buildings where the production of parts is designed

elsewhere and the combination of the structure is designed

elsewhere, it is very important to move the components to

the project area. Therefore we need to know the dimensions

of the vehicles that will transport these components (or the

box-produced structure itself) to the project area. In this

section, the transportation of building components or building

will be examined under the headings of land, sea and air. In

addition to these, the carrier technology has changed with

the developing technology. Today, drones are being used in

construction sites. It is interesting that projects always carry

such concern in history. The striking effect of changes in

transport technology can be understood with examples.

Figure 32: Carrying by Drone [49]

146


Land

The first method for transportation is land-way. It is an

important and quite common way of transporting prefabricated

buildings. This transportation can be differentiated by moving

the building materials to the production site or by moving the

finished architectural product (box system) to the area to be

used. At this point, it is necessary to know the limitations and

possibilities of the products to be transported to the ground as

in other transport methods. This topic will be elaborated with

different historical and current examples.

RESEARCH

Figure 33: Roll Your Own Mobile Home [50]

Figure 34: Transportation by truck, Prefab Architecture [17]

Although truck regulations vary according to state, trailers do not necessarily

vary. The three standard types of trailers used to transport components, panels,

and modules include:

Top: flat-bed trailer for longer elements

Middle: single-drop deck

Bottom: double-drop deck for tall elements.

Generally, these trailers are progressively more costly to procure from top to

bottom. [17]

Image 26: Michelle Kaufmann has designed a 16-module development, Colorado, her first modular co-housing development to date. [28]

147


TECHNOLOGY

Figure 35: Regulation for land transportation [51]

Figure 36: Dimensions for transportation [28]

Pierson College modular set crane path rehearsed in detail before actuation. The

delivery, pick, hoist, and sets were all planned in an integrated manner during the

design and fabrication process. [28]

Image 27: Transportation of t Halley VI British Antarctic Research Station [52]

Halley Research Station is located in an area has a special climate. It is used to observe the atmosphere and space. This internationally important platform is located on

the 130-meter-thick Brunt Ice Rack. An advanced research facility is divided into eight modules, each sitting on hydraulic feet with ski equipment. These can be upgraded

individually to overcome the accumulation of snow. Each module is taken to a new place independently. This method was used in the summer season of Antarctica 2016/17,

when BAS successfully placed Halley in his new home on the Brunt Ice Shelf. [52]

148


FROM BOX TO HOUSE

Pre-Mclean

1937, Global economy held back by the expense of

ocean*going freight. Trucker Malcom Mclean fumes at slow

cargo loading.

“ There has to be a better way.”

Mclean

THE EARLY

YEARS

Early Cargo Ship: 500-800

TEUs

Containers go international,

rapidly expanding after 1968

RESEARCH

1950, US Army uses containers

for supply movements

during Korean War.

1956, Maiden voyage of

Mclean’s Ideal X. Mclean’s fitting

system improves security

and loading times.

Image 28: Malcom Mclean [53]

Image 28: Conex box hoisted

onto US army truck, 1952 [54]

1970s-1980s:

Fully cellular ships:

1K-2.5K | 215X20X10m By

1973, container ships carry

4 million TEUs annually.

Image 30: Sealand Galloway, slides down

the ways, Mclean Foundation [56]

1970, ISO regulations

simulate international

container shipping.

1972, RegistWered East

Coast longshoreman has

fallen by in the 20 years.

1977, US transport

deregulation enables intermodule

companies.

1984 Carriers operate

round the world services

with larger ships.

1985 The first double

stack train service begins.

2000s

Post Panamax Plus: 6K-8K TEUs | 200x43x14.5m

International supply chains grow more intricate and inclusive, supporting

the growth of e-commerce.

2001, First residential container complex opens, other re-purposing

includes agriculture, open markets, disaster relief.

2008, HCL develops 4FOLD fold-able containers heralding new

generation of containers.

2009, Raleigh NC, tops decade’s metro growth: more new jobs are

in liveable cities, in part because of containerisation.

Image 29: Sealand Factory, the first ship to

Rotterdam, 1966 [55]

1990s

Post Panamax: 4K-5K | 200x43x14.5m

Chinese manufacturing takes off

1991, Six of the World’s ten largest ports are now in Asia.

1991, London’s Docklands opens an example of urban rejuvenation

re-using vacant dock land.

1999, China’s annual GDP per capita growth reaches up to 13%

during the 1990s.

Image 31 : The Maersk Sealand designation on the hull of the

2004-built Maersh Denver identifies photo:199-2005 era. [56]

Image 33: Container Guest House, 2010, Poteet Architects [53]

2010s

TripleE: 18K TEUs | 400x59x15.5

m

By 2013, 90% of global trade is

seaborne, shipped in 700 million

containers every year.

2017, Remote tracking systems

are predicted to reach over 1

million containers. New technology

is improving service reliability.

Image 34:The Caterpillar

House 2012 [53]

149


TECHNOLOGY

PANELS DISTRIBUTION

According to the map, distribution of the panels around the world can be observed. It is clear that the panel is

mobile, transported from different parts of the world and sent to many different places. There are many different

limiting factors in these transport stages. Panel dimensions of transport vehicles are effective in terms of labour.

Furthermore, the agreements between countries and the position of trade routes are important in ensuring this

distribution. For this reason, in some cases, the panels are subject to transfer points during transport. [21]

150


RESEARCH

Figure 37: Flying Panels: How Concrete Panels Changed the World [21]

151


TECHNOLOGY

Air

Another method of transportation is air transportation. Cargo

planes and helicopters can be used with this method.

Particularly difficult to reach places, extreme conditions, natural

disasters, reasons such as rapid access may be preferred.

With this method, box systems can be transported as well as

frame and panel systems. The size and weight characteristics

of the units are distinctive to select type of methods.

Image 35: Maisons Tropicale, Jean Prouve, 1949 [57]

Image 37: Transportation of Futuro House, Matti Suuronen [58]

Image 36: Loading of Maison Tropicale’s prefabricated elements to the aircraft

Jean Prouve, 1949-1951 [57]

Figure 38: Maison Tropicale’s prefabricated elements, Jean Prouve, 1949 [57]

Three prototype of Maisons Tropicales are designed by Jean Prouvé in 1949-

1951 . They were designed to serve for the shortage of housing and public

buildings in the French colonies in Africa. In 1949, the first prototype was built

in Niamey. Than it was exhibited at the Port Des Champs Élysées. Two years

later, other two buildings at in Brazzavile were used as office business information

for Aluminium Français and housing for director. The houses of Niamey

and Brazzaville are made from folded sheet steel and aluminium. To facilitate

transportation, all components were flat, lightweight and neatly were packed in

a cargo plane. [57]

Image 38: Micro compact home 016 Brissago, [59]

Micro compact home, M-ch 016, was located in June 2012 at Brissago, near

of Lake Maggiore, Switzerland. It was put in position with a huge helicopter and

set in just 4min 09secs using a helicopter from Heli Swiss, Eleticno based close

Locarno in May 2012. A ground group of three engineers each in radio contact

with the pilot situated the micro home into three 35mm distance across finding

gaps within the aluminum subframe. [59]

152


Sea

Another transportation method is maritime transport. This

method, which has an important place in world trade for many

years, can be done with large cargo ships. In this context,

containers occupy an important place for the transport of

various units. The standards and usage methods of the

containers that change and develop in the historical process

vary around the world. It doesn’t always have to be with big

ships, project-specific solutions can be produced.

RESEARCH

Image 39: Round house being transported down the River Thames, [50]

Designed by architect Juni Ludowici, Das Rundhaus is a prefabricated building

developed as a creative solution to the problem of overcrowding and limited

space for new buildings in urban centre. Round houses occupy the maximum

volume for a given area and make the most of a small piece of land. In addition,

the air circulates around the outer walls more easily and makes them safer in the

storm and facilitates the warming of homeowners. [50]

Figure 39: The World of International Shipping [60]

Getting Shipment From Overseas : The Process

- An order is put for goods from an abroad supplier.

- Abroad provider liaises with cargo forwarder to manage transport

from the nation to the person/company that places the

order.

- A trucking company assembles the order and puts it into a

40ft holder with other orders.

- The holder is shot closed and fitted with a tall security seal.

- The container shipping line submits shipment documentation

to government authorities in the exporting and importing countries.

- Before approaching the port, the captain presents a report to

the target government with information about the ship, the crew

and the Cargo.

- Once clearance is received, the docks at a berth close to the

cranes used to unload the Cargo.

- Customs officers who will have all the relevant documents

choose the containers for inspection. [60]

Image 40: Transportation of Futuro House, Matti Suuronen [58]

The pre-assembled Futuro Houses were frequently delivered on-site by ship. It

was developed by Suuronen in 1968 as a one-off mountain holiday home for

a friend. To supply construction work on a remote plot and install it on rough

terrain, the architects designed it as a prefabricated egg-shaped building with

16 fiberglass parts bolted each other and a reinforce structure made up for four

concrete scaffolds and a concave steel frame. [58]

153


TECHNOLOGY

WHEN PANELS LEARNED TO FLY

Image 41: [21]

Pont VI factory, worker manually hoisting a winch to de-mould a

panel. [ımg.41]

Panel transportation to a construction site on an American trailer.

[ımg.42]

Panel assembly for Building A on Lot 17 on August Normand

Street [ımg.43]

Building in Le Havre built according to Raymond Camus’s

technology. [ımg.44]

Image 42: [21]

Image 43: [21]

154


RESEARCH

Image 44: [21]

155


TECHNOLOGY

ALTERNATIVE BUILDING MATERIALS

Figure 40: Neme Studio, Matters Around Architecture, 2015 [61]

Exterior

Bamboo

Bamboo is a solid, quick developing

and profoundly maintainable fabric

that has been utilized basically for

thousands of a long time in numerous

parts of the world. In modern times,

it has the potential to be an tastefully

satisfying and cost-effective against

to more conventional materials such

as wood. It can be used in many different

functions from the formation of

the structure to its insulation. [62]

Image 41: American Bamboo Society Annual Conference [63]

Image 42: Prototype of ZERI bamboo pavilion

Simon Velez [64]

Straw Bale

Straw bale is a building material which

can be used as a framing material for

building because of good insulating

features. They can also act as soundproof

materials. Non-load bearing

walls of straw bale can be used as fill

material in between the columns, and

in between the beams frame work

is recommended. Since air can not

pass through them, straw bales also

have some resistance to fire. [65]

Image 43: Harvest [66]

Image 44: SCL Straw-Bale House [67]

156


Adobe

Adobe is actually a dried mud brick,

with the natural elements of earth,

water, and sun. It is an ancient material

as a rule made of with firmly

compressed sand, clay, and straw

or grass blended with dampness,

shaped into bricks. It dries in the

sun without an oven. Adobe’s quality

and versatility shift with its water

substance: for example much water

debilitates the brick. [68]

RESEARCH

Image 45: Casting [68]

Image 46: La Mesa Residence [69]

Earth Bags

Earth bags, sandbags are used in

military bases, near water sources,

etc. Visible. In general, bags made of

sacks are used, but they are easy to

rot, and therefore polypropylene bags

are common today. It has a good insulation

thanks to the sandbag coating.

In addition, another good feature

is that they do not ignite easily. It is

strong and can protect users from

rain, wind and sun. [70]

Image 47: Sewing bags [71]

Image 48: Earthbag Projects in Rwanda [71]

Gabion

Gabion is formed by filling a cage

or box with materials such as stone,

concrete, sand or soil. It is used for

slope stability and erosion protection

as a flexible block. Various types of

gabions are built in different engineering

structures. It is also used in different

systems in architectural structures.

[72]

Image 49: Construction [72]

Image 50: Metropolitan Park South Access [73]

Hempcrete

Hempcrete a carbon-negative material

is an alternative for contractors to

use in construction works. It is prepared

by mixing hemp shives, water,

and lime as the binding agent. Hempcrete

has low thickness and fabulous

warm and acoustic cover properties.

But Hempcrete encompasses

a compressive quality and versatile

modulus which makes it unacceptable

for bearing coordinate loads so it

needs a outline to carry the loads. [74]

Image 51: Hemt blocks[74]

Image 52: Hempcrete Homebuilding [75]

157


TECHNOLOGY

Rammed Earth

Soil is an alternative material for aesthetic,

sound control, durability, temperature

control, minimum maintenance

and fire resistance. Rammed

Earth is a system that can be constructed

by compressing moist soil of

a certain ratio and type with the help

of simple moulds. It is a natural and

powerful construction system with

thousands of years of traditional usage,

modern interface and many advantages

coming from the nature of

the material. [76]

Figure 41: Made in Earth [76]

Image 53: Construction [76]

Image 54: The Great Wall of WA [77]

Mycelium

Mycelium brick is an organic brick

consist of organic waste and cork.

Fine root-like fibers obtained from

mushrooms that extend underground

turn into super strong, water, mold

and fire resistant building materials

when dried. This material, along with

the architectural and construction industry,

has been developed over time

in multiple disciplines and is used as

a building material. [78]

Image 55: Mycelium, Aleksi Vesaluoma [79]

Image 56: Hy-Fi, Queen, The Living, [80]

Ferrock

It is produced from waste steel dust

from industrial processes. The iron

in the steel powder reacts with CO2

and corrodes and iron-carbonate is

formed. It can withstand compression

without breaking and is quite flexible.

It can resist the effects of soil movements

caused by industrial process.

[81]

Image 57: Paul Tumarkin, Tech Launch Arizona, [81]

Card Board

Cardboard has the potential to make

a valuable contribution to a more sustainable

structure in the future. It is

mainly made of post-consumer waste

paper and card, a material with limited

market availability. The carton itself

can be recycled to more cartons at

the end of its life. It is a suitable alternative

material for quick and practical

solutions.[82]

Figure 42: Paper Log House [82]

Image 58: Paper Log

House, New York [82]

Image 59: Paper Log House,Turkey [83]

158


Plywood

Plywood is a treated wood material

consisting of three or more layers.

The layers are glued together to form

a flat layer. Plywood can be produced

from softwood, hardwood, or both.

Made from hard wood, maple, oak

and mahogany. Then the log is combined

with thin wood layers with a

lathe machine. Each layer is usually 1

to 4 mm thick. [84]

RESEARCH

Image 60: Herzog & de Meuron, Plywood House [84]

Earthship

Earthship includes natural and recycled

materials. It is generally constructed

to operate independently

and is made of rubber filled with soil to

naturally regulate the indoor temperature.

They also often have their own

special natural ventilation systems. In

addition, metal cans, canned boxes,

glass bottles can be reused in different

ways. [85]

Image 62: Sustainable School, Michael Reynolds, [85]

MICHAEL REYNOLDS: CREATIVE RECYCLING

Figure 44: Earthship Materials: tire [86]

Figure 43: Plan of earthship house, Michael Reynolds [86]

“Michael Reynolds is an architect who considers waste

a natural resource. In his projects from the early 1970s,

discarded steel beverage cans and old car tires take on a

new function as building materials when remodelled into

bricks. Cans are secured together with bailing wire and

stacked into walls with mortar. Car tires are packed tight

with dirt to form rammed earth bricks.” [86]

159


TECHNOLOGY

Seaweed

Algae forms such as seaweed are a

sustainable alternative to plastics and

other materials in conjunction with the

climate crisis. Seaweed is naturally

non-flammable, resistant to decay,

carbon negative and completely waterproof

after about a year. It also insulates

the structure well, comparable

to stone wool. The result is an alternative

construction material that can be

used as a product by placing it on the

surface of the panels. [87]

Fıgure 45: Detail [87]

Image 63: Seaweed [87]

Image 64: Seaweed thatch updated into

prefab panelling, Kathryn Larsen [87]

Self Healing Concrete

A kind of self-renewing “living concrete.”

The mixture of calcium lactate

and various bacteria in its structure

initiates a reaction when it comes into

contact with water, repairing cracks,

fractures and holes on the surface or

in depth. When the cracks eventually

form, water enters and opens the

capsules. The bacteria then germinate,

multiply and feed. [88]

Figure 46: Hendrik Jonker, bio-concrete [88]

CLT Panel

(Cross Laminated Timber)

CLT cross laminated panel system is

a durable material obtained by stacking

wooden layers. With its strong

structure, it is frequently used as a

wall in the wooden building industry.

In addition, today it has become a

component used in many different areas

such as floor and ceiling material,

stairs and wind turbines. [89]

Figure 47: CLT Panels [89]

Image 65: The CLT House / KAWA DESIGN GROUP Architecture [89]

SIPs

Structural insulated panels (SIPs) is a

system used in residential and light

commercial buildings. The panels

consist of an insulating foam sandwiched

between two specially oriented

structural coating boards (OSB).

SIPs are produces under factory controlled

conditions and can be custom-built

to appropriate almost any

building design. The result is a very

strong, energy-efficient and cost-effective

structure. [90]

Image 66: Kingspan [90]

Image 67: Passivehaus home [90]

160


Papercrete

Papercrete is a type of industrial

strength material made with paper

and cardboard, sand and Portland

cement. There are many types of

Papercrete. Basically, when components

are mixed in different proportions,

it causes PaperCrete to have

various properties. It is suitable for

making low cost houses with limited

life and durability. [91]

RESEARCH

Image 68: Mixing papercrete and forming papercrete blocks. [91]

Image: 69 Papercrete House,

Rural Studio [91]

Biodegradable Materials for 3D Printing

A natural mud mixture made from soil

from the surrounding area is used

together with waste materials from

agricultural production such as straw

and rice husks. The final product is

biodegradable. If the building is not

maintained or specifically requested,

the building may re-enter the soil. The

mixture is layered using a 3D printer

suspended from a crane, forming

walls with vertical voids therein. [92]

Image 70: Printing and its area [92]

Image 71: The Gaia House, WASP, [92]

PRINTED HOUSE

Figure 48: 3D printing system [93]

“There are a variety of 3D printing methods used at construction scale, these include the following main methods:

extrusion (concrete/cement, wax, foam, polymers), powder bonding (polymer bond, reactive bond,) and additive

welding. Potential advantages of these technologies include faster construction, lower labour costs, increased

complexity and/or accuracy, greater integration of function and less waste produced.” [93]

161


TECHNOLOGY

Potato peelings into MDF

This alternative material is based on

the principle of reuse of food waste. It

is made by mixing bamboo, wood or

hops fibres into the potato peel to obtain

a binder. Unlike MDF, it does not

contain formaldehyde or other toxic

resins and chemicals. The composite

is heat pressed to a robust sheet

layer which can be used for various

purposes and is ready for use. [94]

Image 73: Compressing Chips board. [94]

Image 74: Chip[s] Board : Recycle potato

peelings into MDF [94]

Translucent Wood

A group of researchers from Royal Institute

of Technology has developed

Optically Transparent Wood, a material

that could impact the architectural

projects. This transparent wood

is created by ensuring that the wood

material is quite white by removing

the outer layer by some chemical processes.

A transparent polymer is then

added to this white porous structure.

This process matches the individual

optical properties of the cells and

makes all the material translucent. [95]

Image 75: Translucent Wood [95]

Image 76: KTH Royal Institute of Technology

[95]

PTFE & ETFE

“PTFE, commonly known as Teflon, is a film made of carbon

and fluorine. This material in non-reactive, hydrophobic,

and has a very low coefficient of friction. Because of

these non-stick, corrosion resistant, and waterproof

properties, Teflon is a material which is ideal not only

for building construction but also for other commercial

applications such as cookware. Teflon was patented in

1945, and shortly thereafter, Dupont began producing

massive quantities of material,mostly for commercial use.

Image 77: PTFE & EFTE [28]

ETFE is a film with even more impressive properties. This

fluorine-based plastic is extremely lightweight and strong,

while maintaining a high resistance to a wide temperature

range and corrosion. This product surpassed polyethylene

technology by maintaining a stronger resistance to ultraviolet

light, a benefit which was not required in the military use of

plastic but was ideal civilian applications.” [28]

Figure 49:Teflon (PTFE) [28] Figure 50: ETFE [28]

162


AN INFLATED EXPO OSAKA

“ The polyvinylchlorid (PVC)

polymer, the third most widely

produced plastic, having many

applications from inflatables to

pipes. ’’ [28]

Figure 51 : PVC [28]

RESEARCH

Image 78 : [28]

Image 79 : [28] Image 80 : [28]

“1970 : The Japan Tele-Communications Pavilion at the Osaka Expo was clad in PVC coated vinyl stretched over an

internal structure. (Img:78) The Fuji Pavilion at the Osaka Expo was the largest multi-membrane structure built up until

that time. (Img:79) The sixteen tubes, each with a diameter of four meters, were made of PVA coated on the outside with

Hypalon and on the inside with PVC. (Img:80)” [28]

163


TECHNOLOGY

Bio-Brick

Loose sand, an enzyme-producing

bacterium, and human urine are combined

in a mold that will shape the

brick. Urease induces chemical reaction.

Calcium carbonate, which is the

main component of cement, is produced

by breaking down urine. This

strengthens the bricks. The longer

they stay in their mold, the bricks get

stronger. The bricks formed as a result

of these processes can be used

as an alternative material. [96]

urine, bacteria, cement

Image 81: Production of Bio-brick [96]

Image 82: Bio-brick, University of Cape Town

(UCT) [96]

Bacteria-Textile

This material relates to the potential to

use biologically solidified knitted textile

structures as sustainable building

materials. The knitted column is made

of jute fibre and permeable polyester.

The column was mounted in a rotating

bioreactor before spraying. Thanks to

the use of bacteria, a high-strength

building material can be obtained. [97]

Image 84: Using bacteria [97]

Image 84: Production of textile

structures [97]

Image 85:The potential of using knitted textile

structures [97]

NOBILITY OF METALS

“The noble metals are a subset of the metals, but the membership in the

group is not well-defined.

The strictest definition of a noble metal is metal with a filled electron

d-band. According to this definition, gold, silver, and copper are noble

metals.

Another definition of a noble metal is one which resists oxidation and

corrosion. This excludes copper, but adds in other platinum group metals,

such as rhodium, palladium, ruthenium, osmium, and iridium.

The opposite of a noble metal is a base metal.

Noble metals are valued for use in jewellery, coinage, electronics,

medicine, and chemistry as catalysts.

The galvanic series determines the nobility of metals, the differences in

the conducting potential of metals. Electrons may be transferred from the

surface of one metal to the other. The less noble metal will corrode as a

result of the reaction. The more likely corrosion is to occur in the less noble

metal. This figure illustrates which are more likely to corrode due to galvanic

action because they are less noble.” [28]

Figure 52: Nobility of Metals [28]

164


PLASTIC FANTASTIC

“ The polyethylene

polymer. Commonly

used in plastic bags

and bottles, nearly 80

million tons of this

material are produced

every year globally.’’ [28]

RESEARCH

Figure 53: Nylon [28]

Image 86: Wallace Carothers [28]

Figure 54: Advertisement of Nylon at that years [28]

“The development of fabric Technologies for architectural

purposes occurred with the invention of plastics and synthetic

fibres at the turn of the century and their commercialization

after the Second World War. Plastics first appeared in the mid-

1800s. Parkesine, the first plastic, was patented by Alexander

Parkes in 1856. Shortly thereafter, Celluloid, also known as

imitation ivory, was patented in 1870 and rose in popularity as

the Parkesine company collapsed. Polyethylene, now the most

common plastic, was discovered by accident in 1933.” [28]

Inventor Wallace Carothers stretches sample of polyamide, a

miraculous new synthetic fabric (ımg 86).

165


TECHNOLOGY

Interior

Tadelakt

This traditional practice, which has

been used almost unchanged for

centuries, was created using limestone

in the high Atlas mountains

of Morocco. The material produced

using local construction techniques

and natural dyes is an alternative to

chemical materials. Also the word “Tadelakt”

means “caress” in Arabic. [76]

Figure 55: How to use tadelakt [76]

Image 87: Production of

tadelakt [76]

Image 88: Application of tadelakt [76]

Natural Plaster

It is ecologically important that the

building is breathable. Plasters are the

first layers that come into contact with

the air outside and inside the building.

They are effective in regulating humidity

and temperature. Applying chemical

paint prevents this exchange. Natural

plasters can be smooth, finished

with sponge. Or it can be finished

with a trowel or brush, hand-finished,

fibrous and grainy. [76]

Figure 56: How to use natural plaster [76]

Image 89: natural plaster

[76]

Image 90: Cafe interiors, Museum Road [76]

OSB

The main raw material of OSB material

is pine, mostly coniferous wood.

Chips 8 to 15 cm long are combined

to form different layers. Therefore,

OSB received such a name. Sounds

like “oriented chipboard” or OSB. The

flexibility of the material increases with

this multi-layered structure and large

size chips. Thanks to these features,

the amount of glue that brings the

material into solid wood can be reduced.

[98]

Image 77: Storage of

OSB [98]

Image 78: Bcredi Office, Arquea Arquitetos

[99]

Natural Paints

They made with raw ingredients such

as clay, marble, earth can significantly

improve the air quality in your building,

positively impacting your health.

Additives such as starch, casein, flaxseed

oil, used with plant and mineral

pigments, provide a less energy-consuming

coating. These natural ingredients

improve breath-ability of the

wall, and eliminate potentially harmful

chemicals present in conventional

paints. [76]

Figure 57: How to use n. paint [76]

Image 79: Mixing natural paint [76]

Image 80: Aditi Organics Office in India [76]

166


IN THIS CASE, POOR QUALITY

RESEARCH

Figure 58: Krokodil, 10 October 1963 [17]

“Illuminating shortcoming in the Soviet furniture Industry -

In this case, poor quality - this satirical cartoon contrasts

what one might see at an exhibition of model wares (top)

with what is actually available for purchase in shops

(bottom). The exhibition proudly offers a comment

book for visitors, and the shop - a complaint book.

While covering up her new contemporary furnishings for

fear of ruining their polished surface, this home-maker

openly displays her outdated accoutrements of decor -

the elephant figurines behind the guest just arriving, the

‘puppy dog’ adorning the television set, and the antiquelooking

clock in the upper right-hand corner.” [17]

Figure 59: Krokodil, 10 October 1963 [17]

167


TECHNOLOGY

Animal Byproducts

There are designers who choose to

recycle animal wastes rather than

remain unused. It is possible to use

animal by-products in the structure

by forming semitransparent tubes

that naturally bend around an LED luminaire.

This design creates unusual

lighting effects and draws attention to

the natural details of the organic materiall.

[100]

Image 81: animal byproduct [100] Image 82: Production [100]

Image 83: Sculptural lights made from animal

byproduct [100]

Food Waste

Every year, 1/3 of the total food

produced in the world is weighed

at 1.3 billion tons. The vast majority

of foodstuffs disposed of in the US

and Europe are in agriculture and in

final consumption processes. It is

now possible to recycle food. Fruits,

grains, vegetables, grass, leaves,

bushes are able to used for this methods.

So a variety of vast-food can turn

into different objects such as a lighting

equipments or coffee tables. [101]

Figure 60: Raw Materials [101]

Image 84: Orange Lamp, Palm Leaves Table, Onion Lamp, Ottan Studio [101]

Clothes

Used and unwanted clothes can be

turned into building materials instead

of being thrown away. Old clothes

can turn into different interior objects.

Sometimes a coffee table can sometimes

be reused as a seat. There are

also research studies in which clothes

are turned into solid outdoor panels.

In this way, the recycled fertilizers can

be reused. [102]

Image 85: Panels made from unwanted clothes

University of New South Wales [103]

Image 86: Sophie Rowley,

Denim jeans table [102]

Image 87: Harry Nuriev, Sofa with old clothing

[104]

Cork

Cork is a material preferred by many

designers and architects because of

its properties that can be combined

and recycled. The cork-mixture obtained

from the bark is brought together

and pressed. It is combined

with a layer of cotton fabric to form

a thin layer. It is then subjected to

various processes with the yarns obtained

from this fabric. This product

can be used in the construction of

many interior materials. [105]

Image 88: Production [105]

Image 89: cork lighting, Digitalab [105]

168


In-between

Cellulose

A type of wood or paper-based product

is used to fill empty spaces in

the structural part of a house to slow

down the transportation of heat or

cold. Its technically can come from

any cellular plant source, such as

corncobs or sisal. But commercial

cellulose insulations are generally derived

from wood, and more specifically

from common waste paper products.

RESEARCH

U value: 0.19W/m²K at 200mm [106]

Image 90: Foam- formed Cellulose [106] Image 91: Application of Cellulose [106]

Cotton

Cotton is a natural and renewable

resource, which makes the green insulation

products. Cotton insulation is

similar to fibreglass insulation in several

ways. According to National Cancer

Institute, unlike fibreglass, cotton

insulation does not include formaldehyde,

which scientists have linked

to some types of cancer. It wouldn’t

cause any respiratory problems. The

material is good at absorbing moisture.

Cotton insulation is also insect

repellent. [107]

Image 92: Blanket cotton [107] Image 93: Application of Cotton [107]

U-VALUE, G-VALUE, NET-TO-GROSS RATIO AND

DAYLIGHT FACTOR: THE WAR OF COEFFICIENTS

“If the modern curtain wall aesthetics of thinness is now

clearly in recession as an effect of these regulations, there

is a conflict between the U-Value and the Net-to Gross

ratio. Moreover, the increasing occlusion of daylight

due to the fenestration ratio’s exponential decrease

promises to evolve into a true war of coefficients within

these regulatory frameworks as the provision of daylight

is now considered the most important factor for energy

saving in office buildings.

Figure 61: U Value Diagram [28]

In order to solve these conflicts, the industry is

developing a variety of insulating yet thin and transparent

products: triple glazing, argon-filled glazing, and now

vacuum cavities and nanogel translucent insulation.

Products like Kalwall, Okalux nanogel glass panels, or

Litracon and Luccon translucent concrete indicate that

translucent insulation may be a solution to this brewing

conflict.” [28]

169


TECHNOLOGY

Sheep’s Wool

Sheep wool, which is a natural product,

is an alternative insulation material.

Due to the hygroscopic nature

of sheep wool, it provides a natural

insulation by controlling the condensation

levels inside the building.

It absorbs more than 35 percent

of its weight as moisture and does

not affect its thermal performance.

U Value: 0.20W/m²K at 200mm [108]

Image 94: Production of wool [108]

Image 95: Application of Sheep’s wool [108]

Expanded Cork

Cork is an all-natural, renewable, recyclable

and biodegradable material

made from the bark of the oak tree.

With cork insulation, energy consumption

is greatly reduced and energy

saving is achieved. Its features

continue for many years. Cork is a

very ecological material with its high

insulation range, stability and reducing

thermal bridging. [109]

Image 96: Harvesting - Storage [109]

Image 97: Cork Studio, Studio Bark [110]

Traditional Hemcrete

Hemcrete is a bio-composite building

material made from a combination of

hemp shive and a lime-based binder.

It is usually casted in-situ around

a timber frame to form the walls

of buildings, but is also particularly

well suited to renovation projects.

U-value : 0.19W/m²K at 300mm [111]

Image 98: lime technology [111]

Image 99: Kensington Hempcrete Home

[111]

WATERTIGHT SPECIES

Locked Species of lock-joint

standing seam metal cladding,

each with a different articulation,

sometimes subtle and sometimes

very drastic. [28]

Figure 62: Watertight Species [28]

170


INSULATION THE RISE OF THE CELLULAR

“The insulated facade is perhaps the assemblage which

is most closely tied economic ebb and flow. Over the

last 100 years, every economic downturn has seen a

subsequent thickening of the envelope and increase in

thermal resistance, whereas times of economic prosperity

have born emaciated façades which are wasteful in their

energy usage.

RESEARCH

So closely tied is insulation to economy that the energy

crises of the 1970s engendered ad national shortage of

insulation material in the United States as home owners

scrambled to increase the thermal resistance of their homes.

Crucially, there is no technology capable of producing

visual transparency and insulation at once, and therefore

insulation is inevitably linked to opacity with all its associated

semiotic: the free-flowing, borderless, transparent space

of modernism is at odds with energy saving and the

postmodern cellularization of society.” [28]

Image 100: Cellular [28]

Sunflower

The sunflower crop waste into biomaterials

for use as a sustainable insulating

material. Sunflower, which is

usually grown to produce oil, seeds

or biofuels, creates agricultural waste

that has the capacity to turn into valuable

resources. In the panels where

every part of the sunflower crop is

evaluated, a non-synthetic binder and

a non-toxic varnish are used. [112]

Image 101: Panels from sunflower [112]

Image 102: Panels aplication

Thomas Vailly, Studio Thomas Vailly [112]

Acoustic bio-panels

Panels made of material developed

from cellulose fibres of Swedish pine

and spruce trees are strong, waterproof

and lightweight. At the back of

the panels is a nano-perforated surface

that allows sound waves to enter

and trap into the hexagonal channels

on the rear surface. While applying

this surface, technologies used to

minimize the material used in aircraft

and spaceships have been used. [113]

Figure 63: Raw material alternatives for bio-panels [113]

Figure 64: BAUX & Form Us With Love [113]

171


TECHNOLOGY

SILICONE: ENABLER OF A NEW ARCHITECTURE

“New façades, desperate to develop a single exterior surface

with a perfect seal, found their greatest ally in silicone.

Silicone forms an impermeable, web-like membrane,

which is able to fill in seams and gaps between materials.

Silicone is capable of sticking strongly to nearly any modern

construction material including metal, concrete, masonry,

vinyl, and plastic yet is flexible enough to absorb the

movement of thermal cycling. Traditional oil-based caulking

compounds would no longer fit the bill, and the Word of

choice became sealant instead of caulk. ” [28]

Figure 66: Silicone [28]

Figure 65: Advertisement of that years [28]

Aerogel

Aerogel consists of a gas with almost

no thermal conductivity. NASA uses

this material to protect astronauts and

equipment from their extreme cold.

The production of different types of

aerogel varies with different types.

Aerogel, produced by replacing the

liquid component of the gel with gas,

is an alternative insulation material

used in extreme conditions. [114]

Figure 67: Aerogel Production [114]

Image 103: Aerogel [115]

Perlite

Naturally formed from siliceous rocks,

perlite is used for thermal insulation

in buildings. Perlite glass fiber with

R-value 2.7 shows insufficient performance

compared to other insulators

such as wool and cellulose. However,

it performs better than loose fill wood

products and straw. [116]

Image 104: Lightweight perlite pours easily into masonry blocks

Perlite Institute [116]

Image 105: LNG tanker, insulated with

perlite. [116]

172


A COAT SALE

RESEARCH

Image 106: A coat sale in Copenhagen, Denmark, 1936 [117]

“Overstocked with a large supply of men’s spring and winter coats, a clothier in Copenhagen, Denmark, adopted a

unique sales scheme. He erected a scaffolding around his store building and completely covered it from roof to sidewalk

with more than a thousand overcoats. The novel display attracted prospective customers in such droves that

police were summoned. Although the police ordered the proprietor to remove the display, he succeeded in selling all

the overcoats.” [117]

173


TECHNOLOGY

MARSHA

AI SpaceFactory

2018

The Volontariat Home

and MARSHA projects

are similar in terms of

local material using. In

Marsha project, the soil

of Mars is used after being

treated with 3D printer.

Similarly, in the Volontariat

Home project, local

soil was used as building

materials.

In addition, although these structures

are designed for different

technologies and purposes, the

window at the top for light indicates

that some things have not

changed.

Both projects are constructed

on site so it

means that solutions can

be produced by using local

materials.

As it can be understood from the

sections of the structures, they

have a similar form. It is interesting

to point to the similar form

according to the durability and

climatic data analyzes made with

different technological infrastructures.

174


RESEARCH

The Marsha project has been designed

with high technology by imagining

a new life on Mars. Current

high technological data are used in

construction and design. However,

the Volontariat Home project was

designed for homeless children in

India in a participatory process with

very low cost and technology with

local materials.

In addition, Marsha

Project does

not create a interior

space from a shell

in accordance with

the environmental

conditions and

needs, while this is

not the case in the

other project.

VOLONTARIAT HOME

Anupan Kundoo, India

2008

175


ECOLOGY

The ecological science and sustainability, which is a branch of biology until 1700s,

have always developed in relation to catastrophic human actions. Between 1550 and

1700, wood was the key material for heating, therefore forests had to be harvested

more than they can regenerate and caused a serious shortage in wood [1]. Following

this, sustainability was mentioned in a handbook of forestry in 1713 as “sustained yield”

that means never harvesting more than the forest can regenerate [2]. The link between

ecology and man-made disasters continued with Industrial Revolution by coal mining and

oil refining. Besides, it created the most disastrous problem, which we are currently facing

with the consequences, the climate change. Amazon rainforest wildfire in 2019 [3], is a

contemporary example of the damage of human being on ecosystem as the background

photo shows. There are two theories behind the fire that it is either caused by drought and

climate change or human action on purpose to create farmland [4].

Amazon Reinforest Wildfire in 2019 [3]


ENERGY MANAGEMENT

Solar Energy

Wind

Heat Pumps

Biomass

Generators

Case Study: Ecocapsule®

COMFORT MANAGEMENT

Heating

Ventilation

Cooling

Lighting

Case Study: MightyHouse

WATER MANAGEMENT

Drinking Water Management

Domestic Water Management

Sustainable Devices

Case Study: 6x6 Demountable House

FOOD MANAGEMENT

Production

Process

Storage

Case Study: Greenhouse dwellings

WASTE MANAGEMENT

Organic Waste

Inorganic Waste

Case Study: Street Farmhouse

177


ECOLOGY

ENERGY MANAGEMENT

70s OIL CRISIS

In 1973, an oil embargo has been imposed to the

countries that are supporting Israel in the 4th Arab-Israeli

war, including the United State and the Netherlands,

and oil-producing Arab countries cut the export of oil

by 5% in September 1973, and threaten to continue

cutting by 5% every subsequent month; however, it had

broken out after 1 month [7].

Image 1: Fuel shortage scene from 70s [8]

5 mm

Figure 1: The Carbon Brief Profile: Turkey [5]

Coal mining has started to become the main source of heating

in Great Britain, which was afterwards linked to the Industrial

Revolution in 1760s [1]. In the 19th century, new resources

and materials has emerged in daily life. Oil was one of the

most important resources, which has affected various sectors

from energy production to construction industry. However,

during the world wide economic crisis Long Depression

between 1873 and 1896, energy consumption and related to

this the cost of fossil fuels have increased, which has resulted

in thermal power plants to look for alternatives to reduce heat

losses through buildings [6].

The time period between 1914 and 1945, has included two

world wars and a devastating economic crisis in between

called the Great Depression, and ended up with shortages in

resources, which has encouraged people to recycle goods

in Europe and the USA. In 1973 OPEC, which includes Iran,

Iraq, Kuwait, Saudi Arabia and Venezuela at that time, decided

to decrease oil production by 5% and double the price per

barrel to the USA and some European countries that support

Israel on the 4th Palestine War. As a result, the price of a

barrel of oil in America has quadrupled and there has been

compulsory cuts in oil consumption, which has encouraged

people and governments in the introduction of alternative

energy measures [7].

Figure 2: Article from October 18, 1973 © The New York Times [9]

178


In the 21st century, population increase has started to

become another key aspects in terms of energy as it meant

that decreasing the energy consumption will be challenging

with increasing population. Moreover, it is predicted the

human population will rise to approximately 10 billion people

by the 2050s which is currently around 7,2 billion in 2014 [10].

Turkey has 1,0 % of the world’s population and it is estimated

that it will reach 9,3 % by 2050 [11].

Solar Energy

Solar energy is the most important renewable energy source

as the resource is the sunlight with its enormous power.

According to an interdisciplinary MIT study (The Future of

Solar Energy, 2015), it would be possible to produce all the

electricity the U.S. consume through a year by only covering

0.4% of the land area with the current PV technology.

However, the amount of solar energy generated in the U.S. is

less than 1% of total electricity generation [14].

Advantages

RESEARCH

Figure 3: Total primary energy supply by resources in 2011 [12]

Related to the population rise, rapid industrialization and urban

growth,the primary energy consumption increases. Based

on extensive research it has been estimated that 82% of the

worlds energy consumption is generated by fossil fuels in

2011[12], it may create demonstrative consequences in the

near future as it is claimed that fossil fuels have a limited time

before their exhaustion such as coal has 142 years remaining,

natural gas has 61 years, and petroleum has only 54 years

[11]. In relation to the rest of the world, Turkey is currently

ranked as the 18th country which has 1,0% of all primary

energy consumption in the world [13]. Therefore, it is a serious

issue for Turkey to be interested in energy efficiency as fossil

fuels which have a finite lifetime, constitute 52 % in Turkey’s

energy consumption in 2013 [12].

• It is a clean source of energy and there is no harmful gas

emission during the generation process [15].

• It is suitable to use solar energy for all regions of Turkey

except the Eastern Black Sea Region [15].

• Even though the mean annual global radiation decreases

from South to North of Turkey, it is still changes between

1400 to 1500 kWh per m 2 for Istanbul [16], which

represents an adequate level of solar energy.

Obstacles

• Cost is the most important limitation for solar energy

to compete with fossil fuels. There is an artificial cost

disadvantage as the fossil energy users does not pay any

penalty for the damage that is caused by emissions [14].

• Material constraint is another limitation for the solar panel

industry which depends on silicon-based materials.

However, this would be problematic only if the solar

technologies increase more than 50 times from 2013

levels [14].

• Variable power outcome is the final limitation that is

connected to the location, climate, season and time.

Therefore, it is dependent on battery technology.

TURKEY FUTURE

CLIMATE PROJECTIONS

The Mediterranean Region is identified as one of the

future climate change hotspot [17]. Turkey as a part of the

Mediterranean Region, is in the group of risky countries that

are estimated to have critical effects of climate change.

It has already started to affect temperature rise in Turkey

such as the average temperature of areas that are located

around the sea, having a slight increase between 1950-

2000; and Anatolia that is used to have fluctuations in

average temperature, has been warming up since 1993

and continues to do so [18]. Furthermore, the projections

demonstrate that the average temperature will increase

between 2.5 to 4 degrees Celsius; therefore, there will be

risk of serious drought in the south of the country, and the

level of precipitation in winter will decrease by about 20-

50% [19].

Figure 4: Future climate projections for Turkey between 2011 and 2099 [13].

179


ECOLOGY

Photovoltaic Panels

The first modern solar cells were used on a US satellite in

1958 [14]. Since then this technology relied on silicon-waferbased

approach; therefore, it is not possible for them to

make a significant contribution to global electricity generation

as a result of materials scaling considerations [14]. A typical

solar panel, which is usually 1m by 1.5m with a peak

power of 320W with the most efficient one, consists of a

glass sheet and laminated encapsulation layers for various

protection reasons, up to 96 number of individual solar cells,

a fluoropolymer back sheet and an aluminium frame for

mounting [14].

A photovoltaic panel (PV) system generates direct current

electricity (DC electricity) from radiation through the sun.

Afterwards, the inverter converts the direct electricity to

alternating current electricity (AC electricity), which is the type

of electricity home appliances need.

Solar Water Heating

Solar water heating is more practical and achievable than

space heating due to the timing of the demand as space

heating is usually required at night and in winter when there is

not sufficient sun light to generate adequate energy, whereas

hot water is used throughout the year at any time of the day

[21]. However, efficient sizing of the system gets important,

which should be calculated according to the summer potential

of the system, because if the system size defined from winter

solar heating capacity then the system will be oversized;

therefore, not economical.

The solar water heating panels should be located to the roof

with a 30 degrees of inclination and it should be orientated

to the east and west of south to get the maximum benefits

from solar radiation [21]. There two types of collectors, flat

plate collectors and evacuated tube collectors. They both

work with solar radiation to be trapped between glass sheets

and creating a greenhouse effect to warm the fluid, which

can then warm the hot water tank. However, evacuated tube

collectors are more efficient and also more expensive than flat

plat collectors as they are using a different technology for the

same process.

Batteries

Solar energy as well as wind energy are dependant on

batteries, as the electricity generation is not stable over a

time period, and it fluctuates between hours of the day or

time of the day due to solar radiation, weather situation or

wind speed. Therefore, batteries are commonly used in

combination with renewable energy systems; however, they

are usually the least efficient component of a solar energy

system as their lifetime is only up to 5 years [22].

Lead-acid batteries are more advantageous than nickelcadmium

batteries due to their wide availability in size and low

cost; therefore, they are used more often [22]. They also have

96.6% of recycling rate [22].

Figure 5: Percentages of materials that a silicone based solar panel consists [20].

SOLAR HOUSE

Starting from 1938, universities such as MIT has started

to focus on the construction of both active and passive

solar houses, which active solar house was placed with

flat-plate collectors to capture solar radiation and passive

solar house was without any mechanical hardware and only

has architecture, orientation and architectonic components

acting as heat collector and thermal storage [7].

Image 2: MIT Solar I [23].

180


SOLAR PANEL WASTE

RESEARCH

Figure 6: Estimated PV waste volumes [20].

Solar panels usage increases rapidly all over the world as the effects of climate change is getting more serious and

people are more conscious about generating energy from renewable sources and consuming it to the minimum.

Therefore, solar PV panels are the most common type of renewable energy technology that is used all over the world.

However, these panels have a life expectancy of approximately 30 years, and also the efficiency of the panels are

decreasing by 10% by every 10 years of usage [20]. For after use, they are defined as e-waste in the WEEE Directive and

the manufacturers are bound by law to meet the specific requirements so that they do not harm the environment [20].

Currently recycling efficiency is nearly 95% for silicone based PV panels; however, this should be higher in the future [20].

181


ECOLOGY

Wind

Wind is the second most important renewable energy source

after solar energy. After the 1970s energy crisis, generating

energy from wind power got seriously important, and by 2006

Denmark, Spain and Germany generated a significant amount

of electricity through wind power with 20%, 9% and 7% [24].

Even though, energy consumption is mainly based on fossil

fuels, according to International Energy Agency statistical data

[24], 2,4% and 6,5% of the electricity generation is provided by

solar energy and wind respectively in Turkey.

Wind turbine consists rotating propeller, which is rotated by

the wind, and the reason it needs to be rotated to a high

position to get into the high wind velocity area away from

ground obstacles [21]. It has benefits compared to solar energy

as there can be adequate wind to generate electricity any

time of the day or year. However, the most challenging issue

is the lack of consistency and continuity of airflow and related

to this the amount of electricity generated is not predictable

[21]. Therefore, when there is ongoing electricity generation, it

would require to be stored using batteries to be used later.

Advantages

• Clean, natural, renewable and endless source of energy.

• Possible to generate electricity any time of the year as

long as there is adequate wind.

• Suitable to use wind power for all regions of Turkey. [15]

Obstacles

• Requires considerate planning as it can cause damage to

migrating birds.

• Needs to be on a high position away from the ground

obstacles.

• Increase the noise levels as most of them are above the

ambient wind noise.

• Gives variable power outcome that is connected to the

location, climate, season and time.

ENERGY TOPIC IN GAMES

Oil crisis had affected every subject in daily life between

1973 and the mid 1980s, and alternative energy sources

were hot topic. As a result, game manufacturers turned

this to their advantage by selling three different types

of board games. First group of games treated oil as

a source of power and wealth, where the aim was to

get rich in Petropolis by owning the most oil wells such

as North Sea Oil [7]. In the second category, the story

has combined oil production with war, and focused on

exploring military manoeuvres to protect oil-producing

nations [7]. Last one like Energy Crisis Game focused

on different strategies in an oil crisis situation such as

planning the demand for oil and considering energy

saving methods in a game concept [7].

Image 3: North Sea Oil: The Oil Exploration Game, UK, 1974 [7]

Image 4: La Conquete du Petrole, Societe Fernand Nathan, France, 1973 [7] Image 5: Energy Crisis: Peppermill’s Energy Conservation Game, USA, 1977 [7]

182


RESEARCH

Image 7: Buckminster Fuller’s article on The New York Times, 17 Jan 1977 [25]

183


ECOLOGY

INTEGRAL URBAN HOUSE

Figure 8: Integral Urban House self-reliant domestic ecosystem diagram [26]

184


RESEARCH

Figure 9: Integral Urban House energy diagram [26]

The Integral Urban House was designed as a selfreliant

domestic ecosystem in an urban context. The

project, which was funded by non-profit organisation

Farallones Institute, has put into practice by retrofitting

a Victorian house in urban California [26].

The project has aimed to create a healthy natural

system and had 3 key concepts:

• Closed Loop and Negative Feedback Loop

systems of energy and resources

• Webs of alternate channels for energy and

resources, diversity of systems and species, and

built redundancies

• Multifunctional Components; permeable

boundaries between multiple systems; flexibility

and fail-safe system designs, labour-time-saving

strategies and structures [26].

The project needed constant maintenance from its

inhabitants to continue the ecosystem and it required

a new life style, which was extremely demanding for a

person who spends majority of their time in an office

building [26].

Image 6: Integral Urban House [26]

185


ECOLOGY

Heat Pumps

Heat pumps are an energy efficient solution for climates with

moderate heating and cooling needs, and they are a better

alternative to furnaces or air conditioners [27]. Their working

concept is similar to the refrigerator by electricity to transfer

heat from a cool space to a warm space and the reverse [27].

Therefore, they only transfer the heat between the ground,

air or water to the house, and they can reduce the energy

consumption for heating up to 60%, even though they don’t

generate energy [27]. There are three types of heat pump

depending on the heat transformation source; air source,

water source and geothermal.

The air-source heat pump, which transfers the heat between

the house and the outside air, has the most common usage.

There is also a ductless version that is called a mini-split heat

pump and it is suitable for homes to use it without ducts [27].

However, air source heat pumps efficiency is approximately

30% and it is the least efficient system type compared to

others.

Water source heat pumps achieve a better efficiency rate;

however, it requires to be nearby a water source, which is

quite specific requirement for an urban house.

Geothermal or ground source heat pumps are the most

efficient type by reducing the energy consumption about

approximately 60% and they are more reliable [27]. However,

they are quite expensive to install and they require either wide

area of clear land or usable deeper area as it can be applied

either vertically or horizontally.

Figure 10: Air source heat pump diagram [28]

Air source heat pump consists of a compressor and two copper coils one

inside and one outside, which are filled with liquid refrigerant and wrapped

with aluminium fins for better heat transfer [28]. The outside coils extracts

heat from the air and evaporates into a gas; afterwards indoor coils release

heat from the refrigerant as it condenses back into a liquid [29].

Advantages

• Provide running cost savings for off-grid sites with no

access to mains gas.

• Reduce fuel bills significantly, especially when it is

compared to a conventional electric heating.

• Lower carbon emissions, depending on which fuel it is

replacing with.

• Don’t require fuel deliveries.

• Provide both space heating and hot water for a dwelling.

• Requires very little maintenance.

Obstacles

• Takes longer to heat up to warm the hot water cylinder

as air source heat pumps tend to be much smaller than

traditional gas boilers in terms of heat output.

• Require the installation of an external box for air source

heat pumps, which can be obtrusive in terms of noise

and appearance.

• Consume energy during cold weather to defrost air

source heat pump, so may not be cost efficient during

extended cold periods.

• Require a significant area of external land to install the

ground loops for ground source heat pump.

• Take longer to heat the space and domestic hot water to

reach the set temperature in ground source heat pumps

as it tend to offer lower outputs.

Figure 11: Ground source heat pump diagram [30]

Ground source heat pump extracts heat from the ground to transfer this

into the house via a loop of pipe filled with fluid [30]. It consists of ground

loops that is a network of pipes buried underground; a heat pump at the

ground level with an evaporator, compressor and condenser; a mixture of

anti-freeze and water; and a water cylinder [30].

186


Biomass

Generators

Biomass is a word that means materials derived from plants

and animals [21]. Biomass boiler have developed after the

concerns about the sustainability, and minimised its carbon

footprint, which is negligible when compared to fossil fuels

and it also provides a solution for waste management and

storage [21]. There are various products that are using biomass

for energy generation such as timber, farming and packaging

waste, and these waste materials are used burned in the

biomass boiler after the process of turning them into pellets or

briquettes [21].

There are three types of generators, which are portable

generators for emergency use, inverter generators for

recreational use and home standby generators for whole

house backup [33]. All of these three types require either

natural gas, diesel or propane to generate electricity, and non

of these sources are renewable. Therefore, it is not an efficient

solution for energy generation. However, with improving

technology there are new methods of generating energy with

burning bio-oil generators or water generators, and those

systems are more sustainable than the typical generator.

RESEARCH

Bio-oil generators

Bio-oil generators are both good at generating energy from

clean sources that doesn’t harm the environment, and also

they makes the waste management easier [34].

Figure 12: Biomass system description diagram [31]

In domestic scale either wood pellets or wood chips boilers

are used for energy generation. Wood pellets, which is

manufactured from waste timber from sustainably-managed

forests, have a higher density and lower moisture content

than wood chips; therefore, they are more efficient in terms of

both energy and space savings, but less preferable as they

are more expensive [21]. The only difference of wood chips

than pellets is the method of processing that wood chips have

irregular sizes and shapes; therefore, they take more space for

storage, cheaper and they produce more ash [21].

Water generators

Figure 13: Bio-oil generator system diagram [34]

Microhydropower could be a very efficient way of generating

energy for a home, if there is a flowing water source nearby

the land that would need a turbine, pump, a generator,

regulator and wiring to deliver the electricity to unit [35].

Image 7: Wood pellets vs wood chips [32]

Figure 14: Microhydropower system diagram [35]

187


ECOLOGY

ECOCAPSULE

Ecocapsule® is a self-sustainable micro home, which can

generate its own energy. It has first designed for a competition

by Nice Architects in 2008, although the project wasn’t

awarded, it is selected as the most interesting picks by online

magazine Inhabitat. After this recognition, they got massive

amount of inquiries to develop the project further; however,

it took them 5 years to complete the prototype design with

suitable technology that can sustain long periods of time

without external resources [36].

Image 8: Ecocapsule internal photo by Michal Chudik [36]

Image 9: Ecocapsule internal photo by Michal Chudik [36]

Image 10: Ecocapsule external photo by Michal Chudik [36]

188


RESEARCH

Figure 15: Floor plan by Nice Architects [37]

Ecocapsule® is aimed to provide long term off-grid living with

minimum impact on the environment. It is 4.67m long, 2.20m

wide and 2.50m tall, which could be extended to 4.50m with

the wind turbine pole [36]. The capsule has a gross floor area

of 8.2m 2 and it weighs 1350kg when empty and 1650kg with

full water tanks. It has a compact shape with minimised heat

loss surface area so that thermal performance of the design

is almost on the level of a passive house with its steel frame

external wall structure filled with high quality polyurethane foam

insulation [36]. The capsule has a battery with 9 kWh capacity

to powered by wind turbine that provides approximately 750W

and solar panels covering the roof with 880W peak power. It

also has a central ventilation unit that provides heating, cooling

and air exchange, in addition to water filtering system either

from rainwater collection or via an external source such as a

lake, stream or camp water [36]. The capsule has a separating,

waterless toilet.

Image 11: Ecocapsule internal photo by Michal Chudik [36]

Figure 16: Energy scheme by Nice Architects [37]

189


ECOLOGY

COMFORT MANAGEMENT

Indoor environment has been an important subject since

the beginning of history as we are fragile like all mammals to

excessive heat and cold. Therefore, human beings have come

up with various strategies to avoid exposure to the extreme

weather conditions such as heat, cold, wind or rain. Comfort

has been defined as a state of physical ease and well-being

in a given environment [38]. Climate is the key driver while

assessing the necessary features for indoor comfort.

Turkey is located in a temperate climate where the main

shelter issue copes with the seasonal variations, and it

means that there is potential overheating problems in the

summer as well as over-cooling issues in winter [21]. Thus, a

shelter in Istanbul need to have a less compact form and an

optimum surface area, it can benefit from solar gains in winter

by providing wide openings with shading elements to avoid

overheating in summer.

Figure 17: Thermal comfort illustrations by Elisa Géhin for Saint-Gobain [38]

VITRUVIUS - TEN BOOKS ON ARCHITECTURE

Vitruvius explains in Ten Books on Architecture how to find South and

North by taking A as the centre, drawing a circle from the point B,

which is the location of shadow in the morning. Then in the afternoon

shadow draw point C, where the intersection of B and C will show the

North. He also mentions about how climate should shape the design

in Book 6, Chapter 1 as ‘‘If our designs for private houses are to be

correct, we must at the outset take note of the countries and climates

in which they are built. One style of house seems appropriate to built in

Egypt, another in Spain, a different kind in Pontus, one still different in

Rome and so on with lands and countries of other characteristics.’’ [39]

Figure 18: Wind direction and compass [39]

190


SICK BUILDING SYNDROME

Sick building syndrome is defined as “the situations in

which building occupants experience acute health and

comfort effects that appear to be linked to time spent in a

building, but no specific illness or cause can be identified”

[41]. There are serious health effect that can be caused by

SBS such as headache, dizziness, nausea, skin irritation,

dry cough, fatigue, allergies and asthma attacks [42].

However, it doesn’t include radon and asbestos cause

long-term diseases as these ones occur after a few years

of exposure, whereas sick building syndrome effects

occupants in shorter time periods [40].

RESEARCH

Figure 19: Best plants to fight pollution and decrease SBS [40]

Understanding responsible factors for SBS can make it

easier to find the solution. The reasons causing SBS are

chemical and biological contaminants, and inadequate

ventilation, which is especially got worse after 1970 oil

crisis as people focused on making their buildings more

energy efficient and air tight; however, they forgot about

providing sufficient ventilation rate for an indoor space [42].

Therefore, in addition to providing adequate ventilation

to prevent SBS, it is claimed that the introduction some

plants to a indoor space cleans the indoor air from harmful

substances, and act as a natural humidifiers; therefore,

creates more comfortable indoor conditions for inhabitants

[40].

Heating

Thermal comfort is defined by British Standard BS EN

ISO 7730 as ‘that condition of mind which expresses

satisfaction with the thermal environment’ and it depends on 3

parameters, which are physiological that changes depending

on various factor such as gender and age, physical in relation

to surrounding environment and socio-psychological in

connection to the feelings [38]. Architecture is interested in the

physical environment, where the human body is interacted

with the surroundings via conduction, convection or radiation

of the heat.

Indoor thermal comfort would be optimised by wrapping the

building with adequate thermal insulation, providing an air tight

envelope, balancing solar gains between space heating and

summer overheating problem, proposing an efficient ventilation

system.

Insulation

Thermal insulation is the main material in the construction that

keeps heat within the home. Examples are mineral wool, rigid

board PIR or sheep’s wool insulation. The building regulations

require that all new buildings have a minimum level of thermal

insulation. Building elements could be insulated in three

possible ways, which are internally, externally and in between

the main structure. However, external insulation is the most

efficient way as it reduces thermal bridges, which is the

additional heat loss through a junction in the building where

the insulation thins, geometry means there is extra surface

area, or an uninsulated element passes through the insulation.

Air tightness

Losing heat through uncontrolled air movement to outside is

a waste of energy and a significant contributor to poor energy

efficiency. Therefore, achieving airtightness is very important

for the thermal performance of a building and it starts with

establishing an airtightness strategy during the design.

To achieve a good practice level of airtightness it is imperative

to have one single layer acting as the air-barrier that

completely wraps the heated volume. It is very important to

have an early ‘leak finding’ test at first fix, when the air barrier

materials and connections are exposed.

Services

Airtight layer

Structure

Insulation

Wind-proof layer

Skin

Space

Figure 20: Building systems diagram showing the location of insulation and airtight layer

191


ECOLOGY

Thermal mass

Thermal mass is the ability of a material to absorb heat [21].

In winter it absorbs heat from direct sunlight and releases

that energy slowly at night. In summer, it can cool the room

if it is shaded during the day. Effectiveness of the envelope

increases due to the area of thermal mass surface with

concrete, brick or stone. However, when interiors of even high

thermal mass surfaces are isolated with lightweight finishes, it

won’t be as effective as plain surfaces with high thermal mass

[43].

Trombe wall

Thermal storage wall is actually first tested by Edward

Sylvester Morse in the 1880s, afterwards the same principle

used with water and eutectic salts as a thermal mass in MIT

house in 1947 [7]. However, none of these trials became

successful to be effective in terms of storing thermal energy

as much as Felix Trombe’s 60cm thick concrete walls in 2

houses built in France [7]. Trombe’s collaborator architect

Jacques Michel, updated the design by adding vents to the

top of the glazed wall to provide air circulation [7].

In theory, the Trombe wall is 30-60cm thick concrete wall

that is orientated to the South to store maximum amount of

solar gains during the day [7]. There is a glass panel in front

of the concrete wall to create greenhouse effect so that the

air coming through vents could be heated and risen warm

air gets in to the room. This cycle would continue during the

day; however, the vents are required to be closed at night to

prevent the room from reverse convection [7].

Figure 21: Effect of distribution of thermal mass [43]

Passive Solar Design

Passive solar design is used for using the radiation from the

sun to warm the buildings when it is needed, also protect the

living areas for excess heat. It has five key elements, aperture

that is the area to collect the sun light, absorber that is the

surfaces of direct sunlight hits, thermal mass, distribution by

using the natural heat transfer modes -conduction, convection

and radiation- and finally control that are shading devices such

as louvres or overhangs [44].

Figure 23: Principles of the Trombe-Michel solar wall from section of Solar House [7]

Figure 22: Passive solar design [44]

Figure 24: Kelbaugh House Trombe wall with greenhouse [7]

Kelbaugh House is designed in 1974 with two Trombe walls on top of

each other for the first time with the same purpose of providing heating

in winter and cooling in summer [7].

192


EARTH-SHELTERED

The term “earth-sheltered” has commonly used after 1970s for any style of building that are either earth-covered and it

is entirely sunken to the ground or berming where only one or two external walls have direct connection with the earth

without whole being below the ground level [7].

RESEARCH

Figure 25: Earth-sheltered and recessed structures [7]

193


ECOLOGY

Ventilation

The key air pollutants are gaseous pollutants such as carbon

monoxide, sulphur dioxide, nitrogen dioxide, carbon dioxide,

ozone and radon. Most of them come from vehicle exhaust

emissions, and can be found in the internal environment of a

building. The level of local pollution cannot be directly affected

by the building design, other than through the selection of

the heating system and the incorporation of electric charging

points for cars. However, building design should take into

account the level of local air quality. It should also be noted

that National Air Quality objectives and the European Directive

set limit values of 40 and 25 ug/m3 for NO2 and PM2.5

respectively. As much as external air pollutants, indoor air

quality is important because people are spending 80% of

their time indoor and the majority of this time is in their homes.

Therefore, it is very important to consider air quality in order

to minimise problems in human health such as respiratory

issues. Beyond the impact of external air quality on indoor

air quality, volatile organic compounds (VOCs) are the most

important organic chemicals to consider. These pollutants

are emitted by internal building elements such as paints,

adhesives, coatings and furniture. Therefore, a well designed

ventilation system is very important.

Figure 27: Supply and extract via single stack [43]

Mechanical ventilation with heat recovery

Mechanical Ventilation with Heat Recovery helps to provide

filtered fresh air to all residents and to recover heat from the

air extracted from each unit. Its location, specifications and

insulation around intake and exhaust ductwork are critical.

Its benefits include:

• Continuous year-round ventilation

• Reduced condensation and mould risk, reducing

potential damage to building fabric

• Less noise from outside and from intermittent fans

• Good air quality with filtered air

Figure 26: Indoor air pollutants [45]

Natural ventilation

Ventilation is fundamental for a house as it exchanges air

between indoor and outdoor spaces; therefore, provides fresh

indoor air in most cases when the outdoor air is not pollutant

[43]. There are two types of situations required for natural

ventilation, which the first one is wind pressure and the other

is stack ventilation.

Cross ventilation is a wind pressure driven system, which

circulates air through the space via adequate opening sizes.

However, it doesn’t work as efficiently when there is not

enough breeze for the air movement.

Stack ventilation on the other hand works on a vertical system,

where air let into the room from a low point and warming air

rises and leaves the room from ventilation gap on the high

located vents, and it also is the traditional form of tropical

urban buildings [43].

Figure 28: MVHR system [46]

194


DYMAXION HOUSE

RESEARCH

Figure 29: Autonomous Dymaxion House (The Estate of R. Buckminster Fuller) [47]

In 1920, Fuller designed an autonomous single family dwelling as the living machine of the future, which was has

included influential innovations especially in sustainability with its integrated mechanical ventilation system [47].

195


ECOLOGY

Cooling

Passive cooling is the least expensive means of cooling for a

home, it only needs strategical planning of passive measure

such as shading, ventilation openings and avoidance of

unnecessary artificial lighting. As Turkey, and especially

Istanbul requires both heating during winter and some sort of

cooling in summer for a comfortable indoor temperatures, it

is important to find the balance between these two weather

situations [48].

ACOUSTIC

ABSORPTION

Solar chimneys

Solar chimneys uses stack ventilation with a high designed

air passages, where the warming air rises up through the

passage and increase temperature difference between indoor

and outdoor air, which creates an air circulation [48].

Figure 30: Solar chimney diagram [48]

Earth coupling

Earth coupling provides the building from external temperature

extremes as ground temperature has lower temperatures

in summer when compared with the outdoor temperature

[48]. The effect of earth coupling could even be increased by

providing passive shading around it [48].

Figure 32: Noise transmission depending on window design [43]

Insulation materials, especially the woolly textures,

increase both the thermal performance and acoustic

comfort of a space. However, there are three conflicts

between passive design and acoustic comfort, which

are related to thermal mass, internal partitions and

ventilation openings [43]. Firstly, the use of heavyweight

materials to provide high thermal mass, increases the risk

of having a reverberant space by reducing the acoustic

absorption [43]. Second aspect is the internal partitions,

which could be weak in terms of acoustics; therefore,

it can create privacy problems. Lastly, the ventilation

openings such as trickle vents or even windows, can

cause problems if the outdoor space is noisy. Therefore,

it can affect natural ventilation negatively as the user will

shut the vents down. The figure 1 shows the influence

of window design on noise transmission that upper

window design lets the noise get in to the building

easily whereas the below one provides both acoustic

absorption and adequate ventilation [43].

Figure 31: Earth coupling diagram [48]

196


Lighting

Natural lighting is the free source of energy for lighting at

indoor spaces; however, glare and overheating especially

in summer months are the biggest concerns for maximising

daylight intake to a building. Therefore, it should be designed

careful to have an efficient balance in between all parameters.

There are various passive lighting design methods, such as

introducing shading elements or louvred vents to use this

sustainable energy more efficiently.

Anidolic ceilings

Anidolic ceiling has developed as an experimental method

after light shelf, and it has aimed to limit glare for occupants

that are directly in the path of light beam [49]. Various

measurements have been taken in the experimental module

that occupants turned on the artificial lighting seven times

lower than the reference module, which proved the increase

uniformity ratio [49]. It also showed that the system also

increased the daylight factor at the back of the room [49].

RESEARCH

Light shelf

Light shelf is a light coloured horizontal thin surface that is

positioned inside and/or outside a window, which should be

placed above eye level and prevent glare while not becoming

an obstacle for the view [21]. It usually doesn’t affect daylight

factor in the room; however, it helps to smooth the daylight

factor distribution along the depth of the room, which helps

occupants to perceive the room more lit [49].

Figure 35: Cross-section of anidolic reflector and light duct [49]

Figure 33: Light shelf drawing [21]

Light pipes

Light pipe system consists of a light collection aperture, which

redirects the light deep into the room as a passive lighting

method [21]. However, this system works the most efficient

way when it only passes a flat roof thickness; therefore, it

means that it doesn’t act more than a roof light window [49].

Image 12: Outside facade of a test module with an anidolic ceiling [49]

Artificial lighting

Artificial lighting should be designed very carefully especially

depending on the different tasks. In addition, it should also

be energy efficient such as LED lighting; however, the colour

of the light should be considered according to the time of the

day and type of activity in the designed room as the colour

and intensity of the light could harm human circadian rhythm.

Lighting control devices are also important in terms of energy

efficiency. There are technologies such as manual dimming,

photosensors, occupancy sensors and centralised controls

that could increase the energy savings rather than simple on/

off switch.

Figure 34: Light pipes drawing [21]

197


ECOLOGY

MIGHTY HOUSE

The Mighty House is a tiny Passivhaus project that is designed

by DimensionStyle. It has 23 m 2 of treated floor area with the

dimensions of approximately 2.5m by 24m as it is on wheels,

the dimension should be in suitable size for the roads and

highways [50]. By positioning in the right angle, the cabin could

reduce the energy consumption by 90% when compared to a

traditional house, and it could even get closer to achieve net

zero energy with the introduction of either a solar array or a

wind turbine [50].

Figure 36: Floor plan of Mighty House [50]

The wheeled cabin is constructed with using the least toxic

materials, which means no foams, no VOC paints, glues or

finishes [50]. Thanks to its super insulated envelope and

ductless heat recovery ventilation system, it doesn’t require any

heating or cooling system [50]. It also has a grey-water system

that is connected to the sinks and showers, and then diverting

it to the plants [50].

Architects claims that the cabin is extremely cost effective with

its minimum budget of $45,000, and without labour it is $120

per m 2 that could be a great solution for both affordable housing

projects and energy efficient buildings [50].

Figure 37: Roof and wall details of Mighty House [50]

Image 13: 3D image [50]

198


RESEARCH

Image 14: Photo before external finishes with weather proof layer [50]

Image 15:Floor construction and insulation [50]

Features of the house include:

• Annual heat demand of 4.07 kWh/m 2 yr

• Annual primary energy value of 119.87 kWh/m 2 yr

• Air tightness value of 0.6 air change per hour @50 Pa

• Super efficient building envelope (U-values of external

walls: 0.237 W/m 2 K, floor: 0.247 W/m 2 K, roof: 0.177 W/

m 2 K)

• Average window U-value of 1.136 W/m 2 K)

• Foam free construction (no EPS, XPS, Rigid Foam, Spray

Foam, etc.)

• Low formaldehyde plywood options (Columbia Forest

Products)

• No VOC paints, (American Paint Company)

• No VOC tapes (SIGA)

• Non-toxic adhesives (Eco-bond)

• Double wall mineral wool insulation assemblies (with

Roxul Comfort Board and Batt)

• High performance fiberglass windows from Alpen (525-S

Series)

• SIGA building wrap (interior and exterior)

• Ductless Highly efficient HRV (Lunos E2)

• LED lighting throughout

Image 16: Inside photo from the cabin during construction [50]

Image 17: Window detail on construction [50]

Image 18: Timber structure system [50] Image 19: Low VOC tapes for air tightness [50]

199


ECOLOGY

WATER MANAGEMENT

Drinking Water Management

Safe and readily available water is important for public health

It’s used for both drinking and food production. Contaminated

water are linked with many diseases. In 2017, 5.3 billion

people can reach safely managed drinking water services

that improved and liberated from contamination while there

are 2.2 billion people who does not have access to safely

managed services. [55]

Figure 38: Conventional Undersink Filter [56]

5 mm

“Conventional Under-sink Filter gets its water from the under-sink cold water

pipe at point A, then sends it via a flexible plastic tube to the water filter (B), It

leaves the water filter through a flexible plastic tube and is delivered to the user

through the filter’s own special faucet (C), mounted on top of the sink.

The system is under constant pressure so that when the user opens the filter’s

faucet at the sink water flows through the filter and out the faucet.

Only drinking water delivered via the special faucet is filtered” [56].

Image 20: Man-made waterfall by Olafur Eliasson [51]

For life on the planet, water is an essential resource. Only

three percent of the water resources on earth is fresh and

two-thirds of the freshwater is inside the caps and glaciers.

Remaining one percent, a fifth in remote are inaccessible

areas. [52]. At a worldwide level 70% of water is utilized for

agriculture about 25% for industry and just 6% for domestic

use. [53].

At Turkey 73% of water is used for agriculture about 11%

for industry and only 16% for domestic use. On the other

hand there is high amount of freshwater used by different

industries such as for agriculture. It was from 53% surface

water resources, 38% ground water resources were used.

For industrial usage %34.7 freshwater were used. Water

that discharged without any treatment gives serious hazard

Turkey’s main water resources. Researches shows in 2050

Turkey’s main watersheds will face with increasing water

amount %10 to %70 [54].

Activity of planning developing, distributing and managing the

optimum use of water sources called water management [53].

Figure 39: Simple Undersink Filter [56]

“Simple Under-sink Filters “In this arrangement the entire cold water supply

for the sink is diverted through the filter and filtered water is dispensed through

the regular cold water sink faucet. The hot water remains unfiltered. The simple

version without a separate ledge faucet is becoming more popular and more”

[56].

200


RESEARCH

Figure 40: Ceramic Water Filter [57]

Ceramic Water Filters are one of the cheap and effective ways of water

filtration. The ceramic material that small pore litres of water size filters to dirt flower

pot shaped filter holds than it’s collected in storage and via spigot embedded

storage, treated water can be used [57].

Figure 43: Conventional Sand Filter [60]

In Sand Filter sand and gravel layered according to their density and particle

size, It trap and strain water through the particles. Water flows 5-30 meters

per hour between the particles then it pass through and collected for next

treatment process [61].

Figure 41: The Hamster Ball-shaped Solar Ball [58]

The Hamster Ball-Shaped Solar ball was invented by graduate student

Jonathan Liow from Monash University. It uses sunlight to evaporate dirty water

then condense it on recipient walls and leaving the contaminants behind [58].

Figure 42: LifeStraw Products [59]

LifeStraw products were remove bacteria and parasites from contaminated

water that comes from streams lake etc… Creating a filter that has smaller pore

than bacteria and parasites size provides treated water. Water is able to pass but

contaminant stuck into the filter. Some LifeStraw products use a two-step filtration

process and reduce heavy metals like lead [59].

Figure 44: WaterSeer [62]

WaterSeer is a slight film sun based force module guarantees that it runs

throughout the day, and the over the ground wind turbine sends air into a build up

load. “The unit pulls moisture out of that air and uses the natural cooling of the

ground to bring the air to its condensation point.” The condensation drips down

into the underground reservoir, where it can be extracted through a hose and

pump to be used as needed or transferred to a larger water storage reservoir.

WaterSeer don’t need any infrastructure , filtration or chemical purification

process like other water systems. [62]

201


ECOLOGY

Domestic Drinking Water Management

According to TUIK 2016 data, for domestic usage, municipal

water consumption is approximately 217 litres. For member

states that the European Union, this rate is about 150 litres/

day. Percentages of amount of water that we use listed as;

26% of the water we use at home is used in toilets, 22%

in washing machines, 17% in showers, 16% in taps, 2% in

bathtubs and 3% in other areas; We lose 14% of leaks in

domestic installations [63].

The territory depends on the “foot-print” of the rooftop, which can be determined

by finding the region of the structure and including the zone of the rooftop shade.

The conveyance system is a word used for gutters and down spouts.

They are the networks of pipes for moving water from the roof to

storage tanks. Preferring both proper sizing and installation is important.

Storage Tank should keep stored collected water safe. The

tank should be located far from children and also animals.

Treatment of rainwater provides safe water to human use. The first one is

roof water quality, detecting potential contaminants in rainwater for the treatment

process. There are two steps of treatment on of them pre-storage treatment it

makes water clean before It reaches the tank. The second one is an after-storage

treatment which filters and disinfects the water for safe use [68].

Advantages

• Reduces flooding and erosion.

• Reduces water bills.

• Reduces demand on ground water.

Disadvantages

• Unpredictable rainfall.

• Initial high cost.

• Providing maintenance.

• Certain roof types may seep chemicals or animal droppings.

• Storage limits. [69]

Figure 45: Groundwater [64]

Groundwater is water that occurs below the surface of Earth, where it occupies

all or part of the void spaces in soils or geologic strata. It is also called subsurface

water. For distinguishing it from surface water, which is found in large bodies like

the oceans or lakes or which flows overland in streams. An immense measure

of groundwater is dispersed all through the world, and countless groundwater

supplies are as yet underdeveloped or uninvestigated. Furthermore, groundwater

supplies are not seriously affected by short droughts and are available in many

areas that do not have dependable surface water supplies [65].

Figure 47: Roof Footprint [70]

Figure 48: Catchment Area Calculation [70]

Figure 46: Rainwater Harvesting System [66]

Rainwater harvesting is a collection of rainwater from the roof with

pipes to tank for storing in the tank for human usage. This method also

called the rainwater collection system, rainwater catchment system or

rainwater harvesting. [67] This system has range from simple barrels to

more elaborate structures with pumps and purification systems etc...

The catchment area is related with several features. First, as a roofing material

selection metal roof is recommended because they easily shed contaminants.

Second, the slope of the roof affects how quickly water will run off during a rain

event. A steep roof will shed run-off quickly and more easily clean the roof of

contamination. Third sizing a catchment area the size of the catchment area or

roof will determine how much rainwater you can harvest.

Image 21: Fog Collector Panel [71]

Fog Harvesting works with boards made of fine-mesh nylon nets are extended

between two support poles and put in a territory where the overall breezes blow

the mist through the nets. When fog passes from the nets, water that contains in

the fog were captured. The beads drop into a collection trough and after that are

put away in a tank or cistern. Captured water can be used in different areas such

as agricultural, domestic use, etc. For better turnout from Fog harvesting systems

locations that have frequent fog periods such as coastal areas are better. Small

fog collectors cost between $ 75 and $ 200 each to build. [72]

Advantages

• It’s easy to build.

• For collecting or transporting the water, no energy is needed.

• Maintenance and repair are minimal.

• The cost is relatively inexpensive.

Disadvantages

• Community participation is needed for success.

• Distance of the collection sites from the community.

• Water may not meet drinking water quality.[72]

202


RESEARCH

Figure 49: Fog Collection [73]

WATER FLOW

Image 22: Warka Tower Arturo Vittori by [74]

Warka Tower is a lightweight, effectively developed, and infrastructureindependent

framework. The tower comprises of a bamboo outline supporting

a mesh polyester fabric inside. Rain, haze, and dew condenses against the

mesh and streams down a pipe into a store at the base of the structure. A

texture canopy shades the lower areas of the tower to prevent the collected[75].

THE NETHERLANDISH

PROVERBS

Image 23: The Netherlandish Proverbs by Pieter Brueghel [76]

“1559 Pieter Breughel the Elder, “The Netherlandish

Proverbs” The two backsides poking out of the latrine

over the bridge illustrate either the proverb “they both

crap out of the same hole (meaning to be in agreement)

or hangs like a privy over a ditch” meaning it is obvious).

To the left “to wipe one’s ass on a door” (meaning to

treat something lightly)” [76].

Figure 50: Diagram of Water Flow [77]

“Whether within a nation or space habitat, robustness

and redundancies in such meshes are key. The

habitats designed in Summer Study were intended to

be -like Asimov’s spomes largely closed with respect

to matter and open with respect to solar energy. These

closed systems relied on close attention to, and the

design of, their internal workings. As in Carson’s case

studies in Silent Spring, Water is not only crucial to

survival but also as a system of transportation for

waste in underground streams. Water used for waste

transport and other needs adds a factor of 25 to

the amount of water simply needed to sustain the

animals, plants and humans in Stanford Torus. Animal

waste, human waste, food processing waste, fish

pond waste, and the rest waste from all flushed, as

shown in a network diagram drawn for the Summer

Study report, to a node labeled “ Ware Processing.”

Since the habitat is open with respect to energy,

waste matter can be processed with energy-intensive

methods like wet oxidation. This is a system that has

been used on Earth since the 1950s to treat industrial

wastewater and sewage sludge.” [77].

203


ECOLOGY

Figure 51: Blackwater Treatment System [78]

Blackwater is water that mixed with waste from bathrooms and toilets that

contain fecal matter and urine. Blackwater requires several steps of treatment

and disinfection before reuse. For single dwelling, It can be used only outdoors,

mostly subsurface irrigation after treated and disinfected.

For blackwater usage you should:

• Minimise the use of cleaning chemicals.

• Household’s chemicals should be avoided to disposing down to

toilet.

• Use a sink strainer in the kitchen to help prevent food scraps [78].

Figure 53: Daily Water Consumption Rate [79]

According to the studies that have been conducted taking 120 litres of daily water

consumption per person, in a house with 4-5 people that uses the Greywater Recycling

System, annually up to 80.000 litres of clean water (mains water) can be saved.

Thus, annually 80.000 litres can be saved from the mains water and water costs can be

reduced to half [79].

Figure 52: Greywater Treatment System [78]

Greywater Recycling is water that comes from non-toilet plumbing fixtures

such as basins, showers, and taps. For indoor usage such as flushing and clothes

washing, greywater should properly be treated With appropriate precautions such

as using low or no sodium and phosphorus products and applying the water

below the surface greywater also be used in garden watering.

For greywater usage you should:

• Minimise the use of cleaning chemicals. Use natural cleaning products

where possible.

• Usage of chemical cleaners is important such as soaps shampoos and

detergents

• Use a lint filter.

• Not dispose of household chemicals down the sink. [78]

Image 24: Burning Man Everporation Pond Example [80]

Burning Man Evaporation Pond In Burning Man Festival It’s forbidden to leave

your greywater in the desert soil because It’s harmful to playa’s itself.” It’s some

sticks laid on the ground to hold up the edges of a black tarp. Used wash water

left behind these pools and It evaporate here then It left some sediments and

crusts behind. “That gets bundled up with the tarp and thrown away somewhere

away from the playa.” [80].

Advantages

• Saves cash.

• More conscientious water use.

• Reclamation of supplements.

• Reduced water use.

Disadvantages

• Dual plumbing is required to oblige reuse and source division. (greywater/

blackwater).

• Preventing wrong substances going down the channel.

• Well-being dangers, maintain a strategic distance from potential for

contact and additionally ingestion.

• Environmental risks.[78]

Image 25: Burning Man Evaporation Pond Example [81]

204


CLOSED SYSTEM HABITAT

Figure 54: Diagram of Energy Flow in a Closed

System [77]

Figure 55: Diagram of Water Flow in a Closed

System [77]

“On Earth, reference texts like

Brand’s Whole Earth Catalogue gave

Americans access to tools for building

their own experimental societies, and

experimental ecosystems, during the

1960s and 1970s. The Portola Institute

- a funder of the Catalog, and also

through its sister organization the Point

Foundation, a supporter of O’Neill’s

early work with Brand- was also

funding the Farallones Institute. The

institute complemented the theoretical

frameworks in Brand’s Whole Earth with

practical domestic demonstrations,

applying systems thinking to daily life.

Farallones and its founder, architect Sim

Van der Ryn, operated a rural centre

for research and teaching related to

autonomous off-the-grid living. It also

operated on urban “home-stand,” in

Berkeley, California, the subject of book

published in 1979 by the Sierra Club ,

The Integral Urban House.” [77].

RESEARCH

LIVING POD

Living pod designed by David Greene - one of the members of

Archigram- in 1966, that time human-kind had not yet landed on the

moon surface. On the other hand design of “Living Pod” suitable for

usage as both habitat and vehicle such as it complies with unidentified

environments with providing Earth’s atmosphere in a certain area. This

project leads the other experimental architecture projects in the 1960s.

“The house is designed as an appliance to be transported around with

the owner, the city becomes a machine people plug into,” wrote David

Greene.” [83].

Image 26: Multiple Organization of Living Pods [82] Image 27: Living Pod by Archigram [82]

205


ECOLOGY

Sustainable Devices

For preventing wasting water there are appliances that we

used in our daily life, these appliances offer both sustainable

and economical solutions.

FIRST “S” PIPE

Toilets

Figure 58: First “S Pipe” [76]

Image 28: Composting Toilet [84] Figure 56: Section of Composting Toilet [85]

Composting toilet is also called biological toilet or dry toilet. It has a “waterless

sewage treatment system that decomposes human excreta into an inert nitrogenrich

material similar to humus on the contrary of water use associated typical

toilets. With this system, traditional sewage systems can be redundant.”

If human waste was properly composted, there are no pathogens or viruses that

can be detected in the end product, it becomes nutrient-rich fertilizer so it can

be used on plants.

There is various type of composting toilets that have different complexity of the

design. It can be built from a simple bucket, some pieces of woof and a pile of

hay or more complex ones can be purchase [86].

In the storage/ composting chamber the wastes are reserved after the

dropping action. This is space where the poop falls awaiting the decomposition

process and also solid and liquid waste converting stable organic compounds

in this chamber.

Ventilation unit helps the making toilet predominantly aerobic so malodorous

gases can let go naturally. It designed for providing a healthy degradation process.

Allowing quick elimination of excess liquid in case of end up with mixing the

wastes leachate management mechanism was developed [87].

Advantages

• It’s an environmentally friendly.

• Compost toilets require less water usage.

• Plants in locations wherever soil change is permissible.

• Well suited to remote areas.

Disadvantages

• Poorly maintained systems can lead to odour, insects, and health hazards.

• Compost toilets usually require some type of power source. [88]

“The “S Pipe” was Patented by Alexander Cummings

in 1775. Valve closet has two defences against the

stink of the cesspit below: a releasable metal flap (the

valve) and a water seal created by the s trap curve into

the waste pipe, a revolution in plumbing that enables

the toilet -It’s odour reduced or even eliminated- to be

welcomed into architecture.” [76].

Figure 59: Dual Flush vs Low Flow Toilet [91]

There are two types of Low-Flow toilet; gravity and pressure-assistance. In

Gravity-driven toilets gravity carries the waste down and then the pipes. On the

other hand, Pressure-assisted toilets contain a pressure tank that Works like a big

water balloon. When water filled It held with pressure inside the toilet tank so the

flush valve opens pressure and gravity provide powerful flush [92].

Advantages

• It saves water.

• It helps to saving money.

Disadvantages

• Low flow toilets flush performance not good as much as regular toilet

because of less pressure and reduced volume of water that used while

flushing.

• It may not work with traditional plumbing systems.

• They are more expensive than regular toilet in case of maintaining and

installing. [93]

Fıgure 57: Eco-san Toilets [89]

The Eco-San latrine could be a closed system that does not require water, so

is an alternative to filter pit toilets in places where water is rare or where the water

table is high and the chance of groundwater defilement is expanded. The toilet is

based on the principle of recovery and reusing of supplements from excreta to

form a profitable asset for agriculture. [90].

Dual Flush Toilet contains two separate flushing volumes for disposing of

waste according to the type of excrement. There is half flush for liquid waste and

a full flush option for disposing of solid waste [94].

206


ESTABLISHMENT OF TOILET

1885 All porcelain one piece

bowl, wash down style built in S

trap

RESEARCH

1884 Thomas Crapper’s

valveless Water Waste

Preventer is the model for the

water saving elevated cistern,

with gravity-assisted flush.

1880’s The roll allready widely

in use in the US and England

before the model is patented by

S. Wheeler in 1891.

Figure 58: Water Waste Preventer [95]

Figure 1: [67]

1877 Sanitas toilet, raised on

plinth adjacent to sink, in wellappointed

bourgeois home,

illustrated by S. Stevens

Figure 59: Patent of Toilet Paper [96]

Figure 57: Establishment of Toilet [76]

1884 Standard connection

from the home to the municipal

sewage system . Drainage and

Sewerage of Dwellings. W.M.

Paul Gerhard

2014 Fast forward to the 21st

century components of the toilet

remain the same, except or

the lowered cistern. The most

generic -and normative- possible

toilet , from Wikipedia’s “toilet”

page.

“In the space of 20 years at the end of the 19th

century, all the ingredients of the fully-functioning,

hygienic toilet reach a satisfactory stage of

evolution, achieve wide public acceptance, and are

firmly embedded within architecture. The standard

components for managing excreta will not change

substantially for more than a century .The western

system - in which toilet is “wet” and the cleansing

is “dry” - will begin to spread around the world,

reversing cultures in which the toilet is dry (or uses

less water) and the cleansing is wet...” [76].

207


ECOLOGY

Image 29: Vacuum Toilet [97]

On the contrary of the typical toilet’s passive siphon system, vacuum toilet use

an active vacuum. After flushing, valve that opened in the sewer line vacuum to

stance out of the bowl and into a tank. Vacuum toilets are flush toilets that use

suction for the removal of faces and urine resulting in a minimal requirement of

water (0.5 to 1.5 litres).” With the minimized amount of flush water, a vacuum toilet

saves cost according to a typical toilet while providing the same level of comfort.

Vacuum toilets can “adaptable with separate greywater and blackwater treatment

or aerobic digestion treatment for bio-gas production.” [98].

Image 30: Space Toilet [99]

A space toilet also called zero-gravity toilet can be used in a weightless

environment. With the use of airflow “the collection and retention of liquid and

solid waste” was provided. For preventing waste doesn’t float around flowing air

were used on the contrary of the typical toilet that uses water to flush. The waste

pull away from the astronaut’s body then flushes. For removing bacteria and

odour, the air is filtered. In case of drying all moisture, wastes are compressed

and kept in storage on the board. The solid waste preserve is plastic bags while

liquid waste sent into space and also liquid wastes can be recycled with special

treatment plants [100].

THE WATER CLOSET

Figure 61: Diagram of Tiger Toilet [101]

Tiger toilets provide the same experience for the user as using a septic tank

or a pour-flush latrine. Tiger worms also called Eisenia fetida are animals that

consume waste and using these worms in the drainage layer reduces the amount

of solid above %80 and effluent quality is higher than from a septic tank [102].

Figure 60: The Water Closet [76]

“The water closet “consists of a small chamber about a

meter in width and two meters in length, resembling in

it’s shape and size a smaller room in a modern house.

Outside the intel of the room is a flagstone sloped towards

a hole, which opens into a short drain beneath the floor

and down which water could be thrown for flushing

purposes, and also the household “slops” From the

groove seen in the wall there appears to have been a

wooden seat about 57 cm from the ground.” [76].

Figure 62: Diagram of Nano-Membrane Toilet [103]

Nano-membrane Toilet removes the water from human waste so leftovers

can be used as fuel or fertilizer this process named as a pervaporation where

“mixtures of liquids are separated by vaporization through a membrane.” [104].

208


GARDEROBE TOILET

RESEARCH

Figure 63: Diagram of Garderobe Toilet [105]

“After the garderobe waste can fall either cesspit. (a), be conveyed into a

moat,(b) breteche style garderobe, (C), or evaluated in multiple styles (D)

After the garderobe waste can fall either cesspit. (a), be conveyed into a

moat,(b) breteche style garderobe, (C), or evaluated in multiple styles (D)

After the garderobe waste can fall either cesspit. (a), be conveyed into a

moat,(b) breteche style garderobe, (C), or evaluated in multiple styles (D)” [76]

Image 31:Gardorobe Toilet [106]

“We want to reinv