TN Musician Vol. 73, No. 3
Transform your PDFs into Flipbooks and boost your revenue!
Leverage SEO-optimized Flipbooks, powerful backlinks, and multimedia content to professionally showcase your products and significantly increase your reach.
The Official Publication of the Tennessee Music Education Association<br />
Choir During COVID-19<br />
by J.D. Frizzell, Alison Werner, and Tucker Biddlecombe<br />
p. 14<br />
Persevering Through<br />
the Pandemic<br />
by Robert Bryant<br />
p. 21<br />
Taking the Next Step:<br />
Considerations for Pursuing<br />
Graduate Studies in Music<br />
by Ryan Fisher<br />
p. 26<br />
Spotlight on<br />
Bobby Jean “B.J.” Frost<br />
p. 32<br />
Rethinking Middle Level<br />
General Music<br />
by Stephanie Cronenberg<br />
p. 42<br />
VOLUME <strong>73</strong>, NO. 3
TABLE OF CONTENTS | 2021 | VOLUME <strong>73</strong>, NO. 3<br />
PROGRAM NOTES<br />
02<br />
03<br />
07<br />
09<br />
TMEA Board and Council Directory<br />
2020-2021<br />
Tennessee <strong>Musician</strong> Advertiser Index<br />
Issue <strong>No</strong>. 3<br />
Prelude - A Message from the Editor<br />
Anna Laura Williams<br />
TMEA President’s Message<br />
Alexis Yatuzis-Derryberry<br />
BY THE NUMBERS/VERBATIM<br />
12<br />
14<br />
21<br />
26<br />
48<br />
The Institute for Composer Diversity<br />
Lisa Burden, Contributing Columnist<br />
TEACHING IN TENNESSEE<br />
Choir During COVID-19:<br />
Success Stories Across Tennessee<br />
J.D. Frizzell, Alison Werner, and Tucker Biddlecombe<br />
Persevering Through the Pandemic:<br />
Tips for Staying Hopeful in Times of Crisis<br />
Robert Bryant<br />
Taking the Next Step: Considerations for<br />
Pursuing Graduate Studies in Music<br />
Ryan Fisher<br />
TMEA Back Then<br />
March 1976<br />
32<br />
42<br />
Tennessee <strong>Musician</strong> is mailed to members four times each year at an annual<br />
subscription rate of $6.00 (included in dues).<br />
<strong>No</strong>n-member subscription rate (includes S&H): $30.00 per school year;<br />
single copies: $10.00 per issue.<br />
LEARNING FROM OUR LEGENDS<br />
Spotlight on Bobby Jean “B.J.” Frost<br />
TMEA Retired Teachers Chair<br />
GUEST FEATURE<br />
Rethinking Middle Level General Music:<br />
Five Democratic Principles to Enhance<br />
Student Engagement<br />
Stephanie Cronenberg<br />
Postmaster - Send address changes to:<br />
Tennessee <strong>Musician</strong><br />
c/o Tennessee Music Education Association<br />
2441-Q Old Fort Pkwy, #635<br />
Murfreesboro, <strong>TN</strong> 37128-4162<br />
Published by Slate Group: 6024 45th Street, Lubbock, Texas 79407.<br />
Graphic Design: Matthew Mann. Account Executive: Ian Spector (800-794-5594).<br />
<strong>No</strong>n-Profit 501(c)(3) Organization. U.S. Postage Paid at Lubbock, Texas.<br />
ISSN Number 0400-3332; EIN number 20-3325550.<br />
Copyright © 2021 Tennessee Music Education Association. Reproduction in any form<br />
is illegal without the express permission of the editor: Anna Laura Williams, Managing<br />
Editor & Advertising Manager; anna.laura.williams@tnmea.org.<br />
Tennessee Music Education Assocation | www.tnmea.org | 1
TMEA BOARD AND COUNCIL<br />
n at i o n a l executive board - nat i o n a l associat i o n for music educat i o n<br />
Southern Division Immediate Past-President<br />
Dian Eddleman<br />
deddleman@usjbruins.org<br />
t m e a executive board<br />
TMEA Executive Director<br />
Michael W. Chester<br />
michael.chester@tnmea.org<br />
TMEA President<br />
Alexis Yatuzis-Derryberry<br />
alexis.yatuzisderryberry@tnmea.org<br />
TMEA President-Elect<br />
Ryan Fisher, Ph.D.<br />
rfisher3@memphis.edu<br />
TMEA Immediate Past-President<br />
Lafe Cook<br />
lcook@k12k.com<br />
TMEA Secretary<br />
Dian Eddleman<br />
deddleman@usjbruins.org<br />
b oard of directors<br />
TMEA State General Music Chair<br />
Franklin Willis<br />
franklin.willis@mnps.org<br />
TMEA State Choral Chair<br />
Jason Whitson<br />
whitsonj@btcs.org<br />
TMEA State Orchestra Chair<br />
Anna Maria Miller<br />
amamiller@bellsouth.net<br />
TMEA State Band Chair<br />
Jacob Campos<br />
jacob.campos@wcs.edu<br />
TMEA State Higher Education Chair<br />
Robert Bryant, Ph.D.<br />
rbryan14@tnstate.edu<br />
TMEA NAfME Collegiate Chair<br />
Jody Blake, Ph.D.<br />
jblake17@utm.edu<br />
TMEA Society for Music Teacher<br />
Education/Research Chair<br />
Loneka Wilkinson Battiste, Ph.D.<br />
lbattis2@utk.edu<br />
TMEA Advocacy and<br />
Government Relations Chair<br />
Christopher Dye, Ed.D.<br />
christopher.dye@mtsu.edu<br />
TMEA Publications Editor and<br />
Advertising Manager<br />
Anna Laura Williams<br />
anna.laura.williams@tnmea.org<br />
t m e a council<br />
WTGMEA President<br />
Jennifer Proseus<br />
wtgmeamemphis@yahoo.com<br />
WTGMEA President-Elect<br />
Harrison Howle<br />
howle.harrison@hardingacademymemphis.org<br />
WTVMEA President<br />
Sharon Morris<br />
smorris@lced.net<br />
WTVMEA President-Elect<br />
Adrian Maclin<br />
maclinal@scsk12.org<br />
WTSBOA President<br />
Jennifer Cupples<br />
jennifer.cupples@wcsk12tn.net<br />
WTSBOA Past-President<br />
Ollie Liddell, Ph.D.<br />
ollie_liddell@hotmail.com<br />
MTGMEA President<br />
Rachel Lapinski<br />
lapinskir@rcschools.net<br />
MTGMEA President-Elect<br />
Corynn York<br />
corynn.york@cityschools.net<br />
MTVA President<br />
Gerald Patton<br />
pattong@rcschools.net<br />
MTVA President-Elect<br />
Lorna Pyka<br />
lornapyka@yahoo.com<br />
MTSBOA President<br />
Justin Scott<br />
justin.scott@tcsedu.net<br />
MTSBOA President-Elect<br />
J.R. Baker<br />
john.baker@rcstn.net<br />
ETGMEA President<br />
Amanda Bivens<br />
aabivens89@gmail.com<br />
ETGMEA President-Elect<br />
Bryant Adler<br />
badler@alcoaschools.net<br />
ETVA President<br />
Deborah Gouge<br />
debbie.gouge@ecschools.net<br />
ETVA President-Elect<br />
Kristen Wiram<br />
wiram_k@hcde.org<br />
ETSBOA President<br />
Donald Benton<br />
president@etsboa.org<br />
ETSBOA President-Elect<br />
Jim Burton<br />
presidentelect@etsboa.org<br />
p r oject chairs<br />
TMEA Guitar Education<br />
(Modern Band) Chair<br />
Ryan Payne<br />
payner@rcschools.net<br />
TMEA Jazz Education Policy Chair<br />
Ollie Liddell, Ph.D.<br />
ollie_liddell@hotmail.com<br />
TMEA Music in Our Schools Month Chair<br />
Tiffany Barton<br />
tntreblechoir@gmail.com<br />
TMEA Music Merchants Industry Chair<br />
Nick Averwater<br />
nick@amromusic.com<br />
TMEA Retired Teachers Chair<br />
Bobby Jean Frost<br />
bjfrost@aol.com<br />
TMEA Tri-M Chair<br />
Robbin Johnston, Ed.S.<br />
robbin.johnston@cmcss.net<br />
TMEA Webmaster<br />
John Womack<br />
john.womack@tnmea.org<br />
a l l-stat e management team<br />
<strong>TN</strong> All-State Choral Chair<br />
Brian Russell, D.M.A.<br />
brian.russell@tnmea.org<br />
<strong>TN</strong> All-State Instrumental Chair<br />
Carter <strong>No</strong>blin<br />
noblinc@wcschools.com<br />
e n s e m b l e chairs<br />
<strong>TN</strong> Treble Honor Choir Chair<br />
Tiffany Barton<br />
tntreblechoir@gmail.com<br />
<strong>TN</strong> All-State Jazz Band Chair<br />
Cord Martin<br />
corderyl.martin@gmail.com<br />
c o n f e r e n c e management team<br />
TMEA Conference Co-Chair<br />
Brad Turner<br />
brad.turner@acsk-12.org<br />
TMEA Conference Co-Chair<br />
Paul Waters<br />
paulwaters.tmea@gmail.com<br />
TMEA Conference Exhibits Chair<br />
Jo Ann Hood<br />
jhood10105@aol.com<br />
TMEA Conference Registration Chair<br />
Mark Garey<br />
mgarey86@comcast.net<br />
TMEA Conference Performance<br />
Group Chair<br />
John Mears<br />
tmeaperformancechair@gmail.com<br />
2 | TENNESSEE MUSICIAN | 2021 | <strong>Vol</strong>ume <strong>73</strong>, <strong>No</strong>. 3
TENNESSEE MUSICIAN ADVERTISER INDEX | VOLUME <strong>73</strong>, <strong>No</strong>. 3<br />
Tennessee <strong>Musician</strong><br />
The Official Publication of the<br />
Tennessee Music Education<br />
Association<br />
Inside Front Cover<br />
Amro Music Stores, Inc.<br />
Inside Back Cover<br />
Slate Group<br />
Back Cover<br />
Lee University<br />
The Tennessee Music Education<br />
Association (TMEA) was officially<br />
formed in 1945 as a voluntary, nonprofit<br />
organization representing<br />
all phases of music education at all<br />
school levels. The mission of TMEA<br />
is to promote the advancement of<br />
high-quality music education for all.<br />
Active TMEA membership is open to<br />
all persons currently teaching music<br />
and others with a special interest<br />
or involvement in music education.<br />
Collegiate memberships and<br />
retired memberships are available.<br />
Additional membership information<br />
is available on the TMEA website:<br />
www.tnmea.org.<br />
The Tennessee <strong>Musician</strong> was<br />
founded in 1948 with J. Clark Rhodes<br />
appointed by the TMEA Board of<br />
Control as inaugural editor.<br />
Tennessee <strong>Musician</strong> was preceded<br />
by an earlier publication, Tennessee<br />
Music Editors’ Downbeat, which was<br />
discontinued by the TMEA Board of<br />
Control at the spring board meeting,<br />
held in Chattanooga, Tennessee, in<br />
1948.<br />
04 | Tennessee Technological<br />
University<br />
05 | Peripole, Inc.<br />
08 | University of Tennessee<br />
at Martin<br />
10 | University of Tennessee<br />
at Knoxville School of Music<br />
11 | University of Tennessee<br />
at Knoxville Bands<br />
19 | East Tennessee<br />
State University<br />
20 | Middle Tennessee<br />
State University<br />
23 | Austin Peay<br />
State University<br />
24 | Union<br />
University<br />
30 | Yamaha Corporation<br />
of America<br />
40 | Maryville<br />
College<br />
46 | University<br />
of Memphis<br />
47 | Tennessee State<br />
University<br />
All advertising and editorial<br />
materials should be sent to<br />
Anna Laura Williams, Managing<br />
Editor and Advertising Manager;<br />
anna.laura.williams@tnmea.org;<br />
615-784-8632.<br />
Advertising information is available<br />
on the TMEA website:<br />
https://www.tnmea.org/advertising.<br />
html. Submit editorial materials by<br />
e-mail in Microsoft Word format.<br />
<strong>No</strong>n-member subscriptions and<br />
single copy orders can be placed via<br />
e-mail to the editor.<br />
Deadlines for advertisement orders<br />
and editorial materials:<br />
Issue <strong>No</strong>. 1 – Deadline: <strong>No</strong>vember 15<br />
(in home delivery: December);<br />
Issue <strong>No</strong>. 2 – Deadline: December 15<br />
(in home delivery: January/<br />
February);<br />
Issue <strong>No</strong>. 3 – Deadline: February 15<br />
(in home delivery: March/April);<br />
Issue <strong>No</strong>. 4 – Deadline: April 15<br />
(in home delivery: May/June)<br />
The views and opinions expressed in<br />
the articles included in the Tennessee<br />
<strong>Musician</strong> are those of the authors and<br />
do not necessarily reflect the official<br />
policy or position of TMEA, the<br />
members, the staff, or the advertisers.<br />
Tennessee Music Education Assocation | www.tnmea.org | 3
School of Music<br />
C80 M92 Y0 K0 (purple)<br />
www.tntech.edu/music<br />
Tennessee Tech University<br />
School of Music<br />
Box 5045, Cookeville, <strong>TN</strong> 38505<br />
(931) 372–3161<br />
music@tntech.edu<br />
Tennessee Tech does not condone and will not tolerate discrimination against any individual on the basis of race, religion, color, creed, sex, age, national origin, genetic information, disability, veteran status, and any<br />
other basis protected by federal and state civil rights law. Tennessee Tech complies with Title IX and prohibits discrimination on the basis of sex in education programs and activities, admissions or employment.<br />
For inquiries regarding non-discrimination policies, contact equity@tntech.edu; for Title IX, Title IX@tntech.edu. The TTU policy on nondiscrimination can be found at www.tntech.edu/ideaa. CFAR009-OCV-21
• Special Educator Discounts<br />
• Free Shipping on Qualifying Online Orders<br />
• Triple Guaranteed for Quality,<br />
Musical Function, and Price<br />
Contact us for a complete catalog<br />
800.443.3592<br />
PERIPOLE.COM<br />
PAR<strong>TN</strong>ERS IN MUSIC EDUCATION®<br />
Exclusive Direct Distributors:<br />
Orff Instruments<br />
Halo ® Recorder<br />
TM<br />
Classic Ukuleles<br />
by Enya<br />
®<br />
PERCUSSION
IN THIS ISSUE . . .<br />
BY THE NUMBERS/VERBATIM<br />
Ê<br />
“The Institute for Composer Diversity” by<br />
Lisa Burden highlights a practical, online<br />
repertoire resource for music educators and<br />
includes interesting data.<br />
TEACHING IN TENNESSEE<br />
Ê “Choir During COVID-19: Success Stories<br />
Across Tennessee,” by J.D. Frizzell, Alison<br />
Werner, and Tucker Biddlecombe demonstrates<br />
how choral educators at all levels of teaching and<br />
geographic areas of our state have created meaningful<br />
learning experiences during this unprecedented<br />
Ê<br />
Ê<br />
Ê<br />
time.<br />
“Persevering Through the Pandemic: Tips for<br />
Staying Hopeful in Times of Crisis,” by Robert<br />
Bryant provides encouraging reflections on ways<br />
music educators make a difference in the lives of<br />
students throughout this moment and the post-<br />
COVID-19 future ahead.<br />
“Taking the Next Step: Considerations for<br />
Pursuing Graduate Studies in Music,” by Ryan<br />
Fisher presents information regarding the graduate<br />
degree process that music teachers of all concentrations<br />
can contemplate.<br />
“TMEA Back Then: March 1976,” continues our<br />
previous issue as we learn about the<br />
sessions and events for the then-upcoming<br />
TMEA Convention in April 1976.<br />
LEARNING FROM OUR LEGENDS<br />
Ê<br />
“Spotlight on B.J. Frost” profiles her career and<br />
offers her insights for both current and retired music<br />
educators.<br />
GUEST FEATURE<br />
Ê “Rethinking Middle Level General Music:<br />
Five Democratic Principles to Enhance Student<br />
Engagement,” by Stephanie Cronenberg<br />
details concepts about student engagement that<br />
can be applicable to all areas of music education.<br />
6 | TENNESSEE MUSICIAN | 2021 | <strong>Vol</strong>ume <strong>73</strong>, <strong>No</strong>. 3
PRELUDE - A MESSAGE FROM THE EDITOR<br />
Anna Laura Williams<br />
Siegel Middle School<br />
THERE IS ALWAYS SOMETHING NEW WE CAN LEARN,<br />
AND IT DOES NOT HAVE TO BE FROM SOMEONE WHO<br />
TEACHES OUR SPECIFIC CONTENT AREA OF MUSIC.<br />
By the time you receive this publication, in a “normal” year (one<br />
unaffected by “COVID-19”), we would likely be preparing for,<br />
currently attending, or reflecting on an excellent annual TMEA<br />
Conference. Although we do not have the opportunity to attend<br />
this event during the present moment, there are still ways in<br />
which music educators can enjoy some of the aspects we typically<br />
appreciate during this season.<br />
Every year, I look forward to previewing all of our TMEA<br />
Conference session offerings. Attending sessions from other<br />
“tracks” outside of my specialization enables me to discover<br />
creative, interesting ways to enhance my own teaching. Band,<br />
Choir, General Music, Orchestra, Higher Education, Technology,<br />
Research—we have distinct approaches to music education,<br />
yet we can all gain knowledge and teaching techniques<br />
from one another. There is always something new we can<br />
learn, and it does not have to be from someone who teaches<br />
our specific content area of music.<br />
This issue of the Tennessee <strong>Musician</strong> features various perspectives<br />
from music educators representing unique backgrounds<br />
and skillsets. Discovering more about the history of the Tennessee<br />
Music Education Association and our legendary teachers is<br />
inspirational. As we develop our understanding about all components<br />
of music education, we build upon our connectedness<br />
as colleagues and the impact we make through music. While every<br />
article in this publication focuses on different elements of<br />
music teaching, each serves as a reminder that music education<br />
is making a positive difference in the lives of countless people.<br />
While preparing this publication, I have greatly enjoyed hearing<br />
from educators statewide and learning from their exceptional<br />
classrooms, ensembles, and viewpoints.<br />
It is my sincerest desire that you find the materials in this publication<br />
helpful as we continue to share our musical knowledge<br />
and exchange ideas with one another.<br />
Anna Laura Williams<br />
17th Editor, Tennessee <strong>Musician</strong><br />
Tennessee Music Education Assocation | www.tnmea.org | 7
DEDICATED Innovative INCLUSIVE<br />
APPLY & AUDITION<br />
Request to audition at any time either in person or virtually.<br />
utm.edu/audition<br />
SCHOLARSHIPS<br />
Available for music majors, music minors,<br />
and campus musicians.<br />
utm.edu/musicawards<br />
DEGREE & CERTIFICATE OPTIONS<br />
Find a full list of music degrees<br />
and certificate options at<br />
utm.edu/musicdegrees<br />
For more information: (<strong>73</strong>1)881-7402 | music@utm.edu | utm.edu/music<br />
The University of Tennessee is an EEO/AA/Title VI/Title IX/ Section 504/ADA/ADEA institution in the provision of its education and employment programs and services. All qualified applicants will receive equal consideration for employment without regard to race, color, national origin, religion, sex, pregnancy, marital status, sexual orientation, gender identity,<br />
age, physical or mental disability, or covered veteran status. Inquiries should be directed to the Office of Equity and Diversity (OED), 303 Administration Building, Martin, <strong>TN</strong> 38238, (<strong>73</strong>1) 881-3505 Office, (<strong>73</strong>1) 881-4889 TTY, Hearing Impaired, (<strong>73</strong>1) 881-3507 Fax, equityanddiversity@utm.edu, http://www.utm.edu/departments/equalopp/. In compliance with the<br />
Jeanne Clery Disclosure of Campus Security Policy and Campus Crime Statistics Act (The Clery Act), UTM’s annual security report includes statistics for the previous three years concerning reported crimes that occurred on or around the campus and UTM’s emergency response and evacuation procedures. You can view the report at http://www.utm.edu/departments/<br />
publicsafety/_pdfs/annual security report 2014 adobe.pdf or you may obtain a paper copy of the report by contacting the Office of Public Safety, 215 Hurt Street, Martin, <strong>TN</strong> 38238 or calling (<strong>73</strong>1) 881-7777. Data on intercollegiate athletics program participation rates and financial support may be found at http://www.utm.edu/about/consumer.php#3g and printed<br />
copies may be obtained through the Office of Intercollegiate Athletics, 1022 Elam Center, Martin, <strong>TN</strong> 38238 or by calling (<strong>73</strong>1) 881-7660. E05-5220-00-022-21
TMEA PRESIDENT’S MESSAGE<br />
Alexis Yatuzis-Derryberry<br />
Lascassas Elementary School<br />
TMEA LAUNCHES VIRTUAL ALL-STATE<br />
APRIL 10, 2021<br />
TMEA will honor and celebrate the accomplishments<br />
of our Tennessee All-State students with<br />
a Virtual All-State clinic experience on April 10,<br />
2021. With a slate of outstanding artists who have<br />
come together for these elite student musicians,<br />
our celebration will take place live over Zoom with<br />
opening remarks from Dr. Tim Lautzenheiser<br />
(renowned music educator, clinician, and student<br />
leadership expert).<br />
Following his remarks, students will move into<br />
break-out rooms for a live clinic experience.<br />
Choral All-State students will join Dr. Tucker<br />
Biddlecombe (Director of the Nashville Symphony<br />
Chorus and Director of Choral Activities at<br />
Vanderbilt University Blair School of Music), Dr.<br />
Julie Yu (Professor of Music and Co-Director of<br />
Choral Studies at Kansas State University), and<br />
Daniel Mertzluft (TikTok musical celebrity and<br />
New York City based composer and arranger).<br />
Orchestra and Concert Band All-State students<br />
will join musicians from the Nashville<br />
Symphony for instrument specific clinics, while<br />
the Jazz Band All-State students will join Dr.<br />
Ryan Middagh (Chair of the Department of Jazz<br />
at Vanderbilt University’s Blair School of Music),<br />
Jeff Coffin (saxophonist and member of the Dave<br />
Matthews Band), Jose Sibaja (Associate Professor<br />
of Trumpet at Vanderbilt Blair School of<br />
Music), and Bethany Merritt (DownBeat award<br />
winning jazz vocalist).<br />
Closing our event will be a message from country<br />
music artists Maddie & Tae.<br />
An undertaking of this magnitude could not be<br />
done without generous support from the Country<br />
Music Association Foundation, The Nashville<br />
Symphony, and Vanderbilt University Blair<br />
School of Music.<br />
A year ago, the world stopped.<br />
March 2020 was uncharted<br />
territory. We ordered groceries<br />
online, had Zoom ‘Happy<br />
Hours,’ and did the best we<br />
could to teach music virtually.<br />
March 2021 found the world in a<br />
much different place. Vaccines<br />
for COVID-19 are starting to<br />
roll out, the majority of schools are back to in-person instruction, but<br />
one thing hasn’t changed—your dedication to your students. I’ve proudly<br />
watched as you shared learning resources, put in countless hours to ensure<br />
your region could offer student auditions, prepared those students, and<br />
created breathtaking virtual performances. Your dedication and sacrifices<br />
have not gone unnoticed. Please know you have made a difference<br />
in your students’ lives and in your communities.<br />
March also brought Music in Our Schools Month! The theme for 2021<br />
was “Music: The Sound of My Heart.” Music in Our Schools Month began<br />
in 19<strong>73</strong> as a single statewide advocacy day in New York. This effort<br />
grew through the decades and in 1985 became a month-long celebration<br />
of school music. The Music in Our Schools month webpage, (https://<br />
nafme.org/programs/miosm/), offers many ideas to help celebrate music<br />
in your school. There are lesson plans, lesson launching points, suggested<br />
repertoire list, and even information on how to hold an “informance.” If<br />
you participated in Music In Our Schools Month, don’t forget to use the<br />
tag #MIOSM on your social media. This time of year is always a great<br />
opportunity to advocate and promote your programs to administration,<br />
community, and other stakeholders. The TMEA Executive Committee<br />
attended a virtual Hill Day in March to advocate for school music. We<br />
enjoyed sharing your stories with elected officials and other key decision<br />
makers about the impact and importance of music education programs.<br />
We have many things to look forward to in the coming months. As winter<br />
retreats and spring breathes it’s thawing breath into Tennessee, we can<br />
celebrate being a part of the best profession in the world, celebrate as<br />
things slowly begin to return to normal (even though it may be somewhat<br />
different), and celebrate the successes and positive moments YOU have<br />
brought to your students and your community.<br />
Musically,<br />
Alexis Yatuzis-Derryberry<br />
38th TMEA President<br />
Tennessee Music Education Assocation | www.tnmea.org | 9
Whatever your musical passion may be,<br />
the University of Tennessee School of<br />
Music is here to help you achieve your<br />
dreams. Pursue your aspirations with<br />
confidence by joining the <strong>Vol</strong>unteer family.
TMEA BY THE NUMBERS / VERBATIM<br />
by Lisa Burden<br />
The Institute for<br />
Composer Diversity<br />
LAST YEAR, I realized that there<br />
were two main ways that I listened to<br />
new music: at conferences (such as<br />
TMEA and Midwest) and online via the<br />
same three large publishing companies.<br />
All are excellent resources, but it made<br />
me wonder: “What else is out there?” A<br />
quick search revealed some resources I<br />
had never tapped into that I<br />
immediately became interested in.<br />
Then, this summer, I was introduced to<br />
The Institute for Composer Diversity.<br />
Their website (composerdiversity.com)<br />
offers a composer and works database<br />
that can be searched by Gender<br />
Identity, Demographic, Genre, Medium<br />
or Subgenre, and even Location! It<br />
gives access to state lists for pieces<br />
that can be used for CPA and other<br />
assessments as well as an analysis of<br />
how frequently works are performed in<br />
an orchestra season. Further, it allows<br />
for the public to submit submissions of<br />
works that can be added to their<br />
database. I view this as another source<br />
of finding quality music by composers<br />
that are sometimes difficult to find if<br />
limited to the major publishing house<br />
catalogs. What a great opportunity to<br />
do more listening and add to the list of<br />
possible works we want to expose our<br />
students to!<br />
I think we all want our<br />
students to perform and<br />
study the best music<br />
available. The problem has<br />
been many of us were<br />
trained in a very narrow<br />
way. It's part of our job as<br />
teachers to grow and to<br />
expand our repertoire so<br />
our students can have a<br />
more complete music<br />
education. The ICD<br />
databases are helpful tools<br />
to discover new music and<br />
composers.<br />
- Dr. Brandon Houghtalen,<br />
Associate Director of Bands<br />
Abilene Christian University<br />
(University of Tennessee graduate and<br />
Maryville, Tennessee, native)<br />
12 | TENNESSEE MUSICIAN | 2021 | <strong>Vol</strong>ume <strong>73</strong>, <strong>No</strong>. 3
My co-worker, Atticus Hensley, has been very interested in looking for a wide range of new compositions from a<br />
diverse set of composers. I remember last year the level of interest our students took when they were introduced<br />
to Force Field by Adrian Sims. Mr. Sims is a twenty-two-year-old African American composer who writes<br />
incredible music! The students loved that a young man so close to them in age composed a piece of literature<br />
that they got to work on. Much like when I get to hear orchestral and wind band music composed by women, I<br />
can’t help but think that there were students who especially had a sense of connection and pride in the fact that<br />
this was an African America composer. I used to think that these opportunities for my students to connect with<br />
composers who share their gender, demographic, etc. were limited at best. Thanks to this incredible resource, I<br />
now know that there are so many more offerings than I could ever imagine!<br />
Based on the 2019/2020 season of<br />
120 orchestras nationwide, here<br />
are some interesting statistics<br />
of the programming of<br />
the orchestras<br />
combined.<br />
28 | 23%<br />
12 | 10%<br />
orchestras performed three or more<br />
works by Tchaikovsky<br />
orchestras performed three or more<br />
works by Mozart<br />
Source: Institute for Composer Diversity,<br />
www.composerdiversity.com/.<br />
12 | 10%<br />
orchestras performed three or more<br />
works by Johannes Brahms<br />
4,047<br />
TOTAL PERFORMANCES<br />
OF ORCHESTRAL WORKS<br />
634 | 16%<br />
of those works composed by all living composers<br />
458 | 11%<br />
of those works composed by underrepresented composers<br />
56 | 46%<br />
orchestras performed three or more<br />
works by Beethoven<br />
434 | 10.5%<br />
of those works composed by Ludwig van Beethoven<br />
309 | 8%<br />
of those works composed by women<br />
210 | 5%<br />
of those works composed by Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart<br />
60 | 1.5%<br />
of those works composed by deceased women<br />
Tennessee Music Education Assocation | www.tnmea.org | 13
TMEA TEACHING IN TENNESSEE<br />
CHOIR DURING COVID-19:<br />
SUCCESS STORIES ACROSS TENNESSEE<br />
by J.D. Frizzell, Ph.D.,<br />
Allison Werner, and<br />
Tucker Biddlecombe, Ph.D.<br />
14 | TENNESSEE MUSICIAN | 2021 | <strong>Vol</strong>ume <strong>73</strong>, <strong>No</strong>. 3
WEST TENNESSEE<br />
J.D. Frizzell, Ph.D.<br />
High School Choir<br />
Briarcrest Christian School (Memphis, <strong>TN</strong>)<br />
video of a great professional choir performing that piece. This<br />
helped them get excited about the piece and better understand the<br />
stylistic norms of the musical period.<br />
At the beginning of the pandemic, I (like many of us) was thrust into<br />
online teaching without any preparation or resources. Hoping that<br />
we would eventually go back to school, I plowed ahead with teaching<br />
music and having students record small sections of music for<br />
us to review. We taught our entire pops concert this way over the<br />
course of a few months.<br />
It. Was. Exhausting.<br />
And if we are being honest, online rehearsals were pretty boring<br />
both for us and the kids. That summer, I started planning for the<br />
reality of remote or hybrid learning in a completely new manner.<br />
Instead of focusing only on music and performance, I started thinking<br />
outside of the box on how we could incorporate music history,<br />
music theory, cultural connections, and more.<br />
The result was a series of week-long web-based lessons that I then<br />
adapted for Google Slides, PowerPoint, and PDF. I shared my idea<br />
for these resources on Facebook and had literally thousands of comments<br />
from interested choir directors. Within a week, I launched an<br />
online marketplace for choir lessons for hybrid and remote learning.<br />
Of course, my first project was a free lesson to help as many people<br />
as possible.<br />
So what do these lessons look like? I’ll show you.<br />
1. BACKGROUND - INCLUDING COMPOSER, GEOGRAPHY, STYLISTIC<br />
PERIOD, AND COMPOSITION INFORMATION<br />
I also realized most students have no grasp on how music fits into<br />
history, so I showed how each piece fit into the western musical<br />
timeline.<br />
2. MUSIC THEORY<br />
For music theory, I would first introduce and explain a concept and<br />
then ask students to use that concept with the current piece of literature.<br />
For example, for Mozart’s Lacrimosa, I talked about texture<br />
and then asked students to identify the types of texture found in the<br />
piece. The music theory portions are typically the longest sections<br />
since there is so much that is easy to teach online in this area.<br />
I believe it is important to humanize “old” music and historical<br />
figures, so I made this section interesting and personal.<br />
I included YouTube videos of the cities in which each of the pieces<br />
was composed so students could take a deep dive into what life<br />
may have looked like for that composer. I also included a YouTube<br />
Tennessee Music Education Assocation | www.tnmea.org | 15
I ALSO REALIZED MOST STUDENTS HAVE NO<br />
GRASP ON HOW MUSIC FITS INTO HISTORY,<br />
SO I SHOWED HOW EACH PIECE FIT INTO THE<br />
WESTERN MUSICAL TIMELINE.<br />
3. VOCAL TECHNIQUE<br />
In the third section, I gave the students an opportunity to sing some<br />
of the piece of music, just not with the idea of a performance as the<br />
goal. I included keys to success for that portion of the piece.<br />
4. LISTENING AND EVALUATING<br />
In this section, I use recordings of the piece we are studying and/<br />
or other pieces of the same genre. For Lacrimosa, I included the<br />
Ockeghem Requiem, Verdi Requiem, and Brahms German Requiem<br />
excerpts. After brief videos of each, I ask students to state which<br />
one they enjoyed the most and to list musical reasons for that.<br />
These lessons address two of the three main National Core Arts<br />
Standards in depth. They still have students sing. They can be<br />
adapted for hybrid, remote, or even in-person learning. Hundreds<br />
of choir directors around the country are using them as they have<br />
embraced the idea that a different kind of classroom requires a different<br />
approach to our craft.<br />
For practicing remotely, I included sung practice tracks from ChoralTracks.<br />
These tracks are accurately sung with dynamics, articulations,<br />
etc. They are immensely helpful for student success in<br />
learning parts on their own.<br />
DR. J.D. FRIZZELL is the Director of Fine Arts<br />
and Director of Vocal Music at Briarcrest<br />
Christian School in Memphis, <strong>TN</strong>, where he is<br />
responsible for coordinating all Fine Arts programs<br />
(K2-12th grade). As the Director of Vocal<br />
Music, he teaches the Concert Choir, Advanced<br />
Women’s Choir, Men’s A Cappella, and<br />
internationally acclaimed a cappella group<br />
OneVoice. His ensembles have performed at<br />
regional, national, and international conventions. Their music has<br />
been streamed and downloaded over 100 million times. Winner<br />
of the Integrales Composition Contest, Dr. Frizzell has had many<br />
best-selling compositions and arrangements. He also co-authored<br />
A Cappella Warm-Ups and Teaching Music Through Performance<br />
In Contemporary A Cappella.<br />
16 | TENNESSEE MUSICIAN | 2021 | <strong>Vol</strong>ume <strong>73</strong>, <strong>No</strong>. 3
EAST TENNESSEE<br />
Alison Werner<br />
Middle School Choir<br />
Gibbs Middle School (Knox County Schools)<br />
First of all, I would like to say that there are so many teachers across<br />
our state doing fabulous things in the classroom and virtually, so<br />
I am honored to share a portion of what I have happened upon as<br />
successful. Regardless if you are creating a phenomenal virtual concert<br />
that received many accolades or if you are barely deciding on<br />
yet another engaging activity fifteen minutes before meeting with<br />
your students on Zoom again, YOU are one of the reasons that<br />
many students even come to school or sign-on. Having that human<br />
connection through music is unlike any other subject (you know<br />
this already), but sometimes a reminder helps that right now it is<br />
NOT the performance we are working towards: it’s the survival of<br />
that musical connection.<br />
In Spring of 2020, we were thirty minutes before opening night of<br />
our Wizard of Oz production when we found out we would have to<br />
cancel the rest of our run. Students and parents were devastated,<br />
but the show went on that night flawlessly. Once the gravity of the<br />
situation sank in, I began looking into all types of online learning<br />
platforms, maybe a little too much—I was overwhelmed. Once our<br />
school decided to be in-person in the Fall of 2020, I prepared for as<br />
many scenarios as possible. I taped off my classroom, marked spaces<br />
in an outdoor area for singing, set up online accounts, made a virtual<br />
classroom, attended virtual workshops, did everything I thought I<br />
should so that I could be ready. Little did I know how these past few<br />
months would change me as a teacher (and some days question if I<br />
should even stay in this career).<br />
For several weeks, I prepared my students technologically, but it<br />
became crystal clear that they just wanted to sing, be together with<br />
their friends, and do things physically instead of staring at a screen.<br />
So, we shifted gears. Without a performance looming, we learned<br />
fun songs, made up motions, acted silly at times, and still learned<br />
about music along the way. We did our daily stretches to student<br />
song requests (clean and preselected from a Google form of course)<br />
and decided we wanted to create a video to capture our singing at<br />
this time. I had preselected the song “I Believe,” arranged by Mark<br />
Miller, not because we are comparing our lives to the lives of a Jew<br />
in the Holocaust, but the students could relate their current situation<br />
to the text:<br />
I believe in the sun, even when it’s not shining.<br />
I believe in love, even when I don’t feel it.<br />
I believe in God, even when God is silent.<br />
I taught the melody to all grade levels and taught the harmony to<br />
the upper-level classes, as well as the descant. By prerecording<br />
the accompaniment, it was fairly easy to line up all the tracks<br />
of each choir so that all choirs could “perform” together. As an<br />
afterthought, I also asked our school’s art teacher for pictures<br />
of some of their recent projects to include in the video. My goal<br />
was to just get a snapshot of our departments.<br />
I FEEL LIKE I KNOW MY STUDENTS BETTER<br />
NOW THAN WHEN WE WOULD ALL BE SINGING<br />
TOGETHER BECAUSE OF HAVING TO RE-<br />
CREATE HOW WE TEACH AND LEARN MUSIC.<br />
VIEW OUR FINAL PRODUCT BY SCANNING THE QR CODE BELOW<br />
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0H0uGpO5wyw<br />
Soon after we recorded our video, our school went virtual. I was<br />
hoping we could do a similar video with our winter music, but instead,<br />
I was able to connect more individually with students as they<br />
sent in videos and audio recordings of sight-singing and virtual<br />
rehearsal recordings since we were not able to be in-person. I had<br />
supplied them with kazoos before we went virtual so that if they<br />
felt uncomfortable singing, they could at least get the pitches with<br />
the kazoo. I feel like I know my students better now than when we<br />
would all be singing together because of having to re-create how we<br />
teach and learn music.<br />
I do not wish for teachers in any discipline or level to endure the<br />
hardships of teaching during a pandemic, but I am grateful for the<br />
opportunities it has provided and the necessity for change.<br />
ALISON WERNER is a middle school choral<br />
director and has been teaching for 18 years<br />
in Knox County, Tennessee. She is currently<br />
at one of the newest schools in the county,<br />
Gibbs Middle School, where she is building a<br />
program that encompasses one-third of the<br />
student body in three choirs, an after-school<br />
auditioned ensemble, and a musical theatre<br />
club. She is also the Knox County Professional<br />
Development Specialist for Secondary Choral Teachers and has<br />
held several officer and chair positions for the East Tennessee Vocal<br />
Association..<br />
Tennessee Music Education Assocation | www.tnmea.org | 17
MIDDLE TENNESSEE<br />
Tucker Biddlecomb, Ph.D.<br />
Collegiate Choir<br />
Vanderbilt University (Nashville, <strong>TN</strong>)<br />
One of the most difficult aspects about the pandemic is that<br />
even when you’re back in person together in rehearsal, it creates<br />
a set of new challenges. You’re trying to take a singing<br />
breath through a mask. That makes it difficult to maintain<br />
any sense of consistent timing in singing, as you have to spend more<br />
time inhaling. As we all know, time waits for no singer. In addition,<br />
it becomes more difficult to hear anything except your own voice.<br />
Choral music’s greatest gift to us is the way our scores are laid<br />
out—we get to see ALL the parts at once along with every musical<br />
direction in real time. However, because we can see the other<br />
parts, we are now responsible to listen for them. I rehearse my<br />
top ensemble, the Vanderbilt Chorale, in our modern concert hall<br />
with the shell out for quicker aerosol clearance. It’s quiet, controlled,<br />
and mildly reverberant. Despite an ideal environment, my<br />
students simply can’t hear one another—they’re overwhelmed<br />
with their own sound reflecting back at them through the mask<br />
they’re wearing.<br />
I feel strongly that we will one day look on virtual projects<br />
as the lifeline that saved choral music, but I have a hard time<br />
watching them at this point. It takes an emotional toll to know how<br />
much work went into producing it, and how little satisfaction the<br />
performers had when they filmed in their bedroom at home. Virtual<br />
singing has been a game-changer for me, however, in learning about<br />
my singers’ voices. It’s embarrassing to think how much guessing I<br />
was doing about their vocal development.<br />
Just recently, I wanted to learn more about the state of the changing<br />
voices in my Young Men’s Chorus, a group I direct as part of<br />
the Blair Children’s Chorus at Vanderbilt. It took me about twenty<br />
minutes to sequence a piano accompaniment to Britten’s The Salley<br />
Gardens, and I put the recorded mp3 accompaniment and my voice<br />
singing it in three keys. After a little screen sharing during rehearsal<br />
and having them record with a second device, by the end of that<br />
rehearsal I had thirty individual recordings of their voices singing<br />
the same art song in an appropriate key for them. <strong>No</strong>w I can email<br />
them specifics about what I’m hearing, make better decisions about<br />
voicing, and find out how they are doing with things like musical independence<br />
and literacy. If we were in person, I’d still be guessing.<br />
We will be back, and right soon. Our transition to normal will not<br />
be overnight, however, and we should be prepared for the new challenges<br />
a post-pandemic choral ensemble will face. What gives me<br />
hope? The resilience of our singers, and the ingenuity of you—my<br />
choral colleagues.<br />
VIRTUAL SINGING HAS<br />
BEEN A GAME-CHANGER<br />
FOR ME, HOWEVER, IN<br />
LEARNING ABOUT MY<br />
SINGERS’ VOICES.<br />
DR. TUCKER BIDDLECOMBE is Director of<br />
Choral Activities at Vanderbilt University’s<br />
Blair School of Music, where he conducts the<br />
Vanderbilt Chorale and Glee Club, and serves<br />
as Coordinator of Music Teacher Education.<br />
He also serves as Director of the Nashville<br />
Symphony Orchestra Chorus. Dr. Biddlecombe<br />
is a veteran teacher and a passionate advocate<br />
for music education. Ensembles under his direction<br />
have toured nationally and internationally and have performed<br />
to acclaim at state and division conventions of ACDA. He is<br />
in demand as a conductor and clinician having served as a clinician<br />
to choirs in 25 states and was a recent guest lecturer and clinician<br />
at the Central Conservatory of Music in Beijing. A native of Buffalo,<br />
New York, Biddlecombe is a graduate of SUNY Potsdam and Florida<br />
State University, where he completed doctoral studies in choral<br />
conducting and music education with André Thomas. He resides in<br />
Nashville with his wife Mary Biddlecombe, Artistic Director of the<br />
Blair Children’s Chorus.<br />
18 | TENNESSEE MUSICIAN | 2021 | <strong>Vol</strong>ume <strong>73</strong>, <strong>No</strong>. 3
YOUR PATHWAY<br />
TO A CAREER<br />
IN MUSIC<br />
• Bachelor of Music Degrees in<br />
Performance, Music<br />
Education, and Jazz Studies<br />
• NEW Bachelor of Arts Degrees<br />
in Conducting, Applied Music,<br />
Theory & Composition, Music<br />
& Culture, Contemporary<br />
Music, and Marching Band<br />
• Nationally-recognized classical<br />
and contemporary ensembles<br />
• Award-winning faculty<br />
• Over half a million dollars in<br />
scholarships awarded annually<br />
The ETSU Department of Music<br />
is fully accredited by the National<br />
Association of Schools of Music.<br />
@GoETSUMusic<br />
Facebook.com/ETSUMusic<br />
@etsumusicdepartment<br />
etsu.edu/music<br />
#ETSUMusicFamily
Become a better music educator.<br />
Apply <strong>No</strong>w for the Master<br />
of Music in Music Education.<br />
Two-year cohort, fully online.<br />
Start Fall 2021.<br />
SCHOOL OF MUSIC<br />
615-898-2469 • Joseph.Morgan@mtsu.edu<br />
0321-9559 / Middle Tennessee State University does not discriminate on the basis of race, color, national origin, sex, or disability. See our full policy at mtsu.edu/iec.
TMEA TEACHING IN TENNESSEE<br />
SHOWING<br />
COMPASSION<br />
RADIATING<br />
GRATITUDE<br />
MANAGING<br />
EXPECTATIONS<br />
PERSEVERING<br />
THROUGH<br />
THE<br />
PANDEMIC:<br />
TIPS FOR<br />
STAYING<br />
HOPEFUL<br />
IN TIMES<br />
OF CRISIS<br />
by Robert Bryant, Ph.D.<br />
CULTIVATING<br />
CREATIVITY<br />
FOSTERING<br />
COMMUNITY<br />
Welcome to our new reality. When<br />
COVID-19 required us to shelter<br />
in place last spring, many believed<br />
this was an overreaction and that<br />
things would return to normal sooner rather<br />
than later. But when major national and international<br />
athletic events were postponed<br />
and cancelled, we suddenly knew that this<br />
outbreak was different. Next came daily<br />
news updates of viral community spread<br />
and tragic loss of life. While we seek to understand<br />
and cope with the numerous ways<br />
in which the coronavirus pandemic has altered<br />
our way of life, we in the teaching profession<br />
are committed to maintaining continuity<br />
of instruction for our students.<br />
Tennessee Music Education Assocation | www.tnmea.org | 21
...WE CAN STILL FIND NEW WAYS TO HELP<br />
OUR STUDENTS PERSEVERE AND SUCCEED<br />
UNDER THESE CIRCUMSTANCES.<br />
COVID-19 has completely changed how we work, communicate,<br />
and live our daily lives. Because we were thrust into emergency remote<br />
teaching without much notice, many of us did not have adequate<br />
time to prepare for delivering high-quality online music instruction.<br />
But now that we have had some time to learn more about<br />
virtual music learning and try different approaches with varying<br />
degrees of success, many of us can attest to how we have grown as<br />
professionals. With that being said, we can still find new ways to<br />
help our students persevere and succeed under these circumstances.<br />
Music educators are essential to help students communicate<br />
thoughts and feelings that they often cannot put into words. This<br />
speaks to music’s intrinsic value and importance as a necessary<br />
part of a comprehensive education. These past months of instability<br />
have given us time to create unique and significant learning experiences<br />
for our students. We have participated in numerous virtual<br />
performances and online gatherings that may not have happened<br />
otherwise. Many music education organizations, including TMEA,<br />
continue to offer resources and professional development during<br />
these times. This is vital to our profession as we prepare for teaching<br />
in a post-pandemic world.<br />
While I believe that it is important to acknowledge the silver lining<br />
during COVID-19, we must also recognize the setbacks this pandemic<br />
has caused. Some of us are dealing with grief from the loss<br />
of loved ones due to the virus. Others are caring for family members<br />
who have contracted the virus and are still recovering. Some of us<br />
have tested positive, and our profession continues to reel from the<br />
loss of colleagues. We have witnessed the postponement of major<br />
life events and have had to manage the economic impact of the pandemic<br />
on our communities. But even through all our sorrow and<br />
disappointment, we have continued to bring the joy and wonder of<br />
music to our students. It is with those fleeting but profound glimmers<br />
of hope in mind that I offer some suggestions to help us navigate<br />
this moment.<br />
SHOWING COMPASSION<br />
<strong>No</strong>w that we have had more than a year to adjust to teaching online,<br />
it can be easy for us to affix our old ideals onto the current situation.<br />
We may feel as if we are not doing enough to serve our students and<br />
reach our professional goals. We may overlook the fact that many<br />
of our students are still adjusting to this new approach to school.<br />
Some of our students are struggling just to have their basic needs<br />
met. It is difficult for a student to be fully engaged in learning when<br />
they are dealing with health, housing, or food insecurity. <strong>No</strong>w more<br />
than ever we need to show ourselves and our students as much compassion<br />
as possible. When appropriate, we may even want to share<br />
some of the challenges we face as teachers with our students, as<br />
well as what we are doing to overcome these challenges. I guarantee<br />
that they will empathize and work even harder for us.<br />
RADIATING GRATITUDE<br />
At the end of each workday, I reflect and try to find at least one moment<br />
to be grateful for. Some days take longer than others to think of<br />
something, but I can always find at least one moment that made me<br />
smile and remind me why I got into the teaching profession. While<br />
I could lament the many performances and presentations on my<br />
calendar that were cancelled due to the pandemic, I choose to focus<br />
on the opportunities that my students and I have had that may not<br />
have happened otherwise. Searching for just one or two things to<br />
be grateful for each day can help us persevere during this time with<br />
more hope. When we share our gratitude with our students and colleagues,<br />
we could be helping someone who desperately needs it.<br />
MANAGING EXPECTATIONS<br />
While we would all like to maintain the same high expectations for<br />
musical excellence that we had pre-COVID, we should first take<br />
a step back and reassess. Performance expectations are a major<br />
source of stress for music educators even under normal circumstances.<br />
<strong>No</strong>w that many of our most important performing opportunities<br />
are on hold, we simply have no clarity as to when, how, or even<br />
if they will happen. Let’s take this time to consider adjusting our<br />
performance expectations and think of ways that we can still provide<br />
our students with an exceptional music education that focuses<br />
on the artistic processes of creating, responding, and connecting.<br />
CULTIVATING CREATIVITY<br />
Our profession has quickly evolved through the expansion of the<br />
many virtual concerts and conferences during the pandemic. <strong>No</strong>w<br />
is a great time to discover new ways to create by fulling leveraging<br />
technology and empowering our students to build their capacity<br />
and independence as musicians. I have learned, through much<br />
trial and error, more about optimizing my teaching for online and<br />
hybrid delivery than ever before. I also feel like I am just beginning<br />
to scratch the surface of capabilities of my institution’s video conferencing<br />
and content management systems. Let’s continue to find<br />
new approaches to those tried-and-true lessons and involve our<br />
students in this process.<br />
FOSTERING COMMUNITY<br />
This can be a very isolating time for many of us, both professionally<br />
and socially. It is critical that we continue to connect, even if just<br />
virtually, on a frequent basis. A quick phone call, text, or email to<br />
check-in with a colleague can be just what we need to keep us motivated<br />
to bring our best to our classes each day. Sharing our successes<br />
and setbacks with trusted colleagues who understand what we<br />
22 | TENNESSEE MUSICIAN | 2021 | <strong>Vol</strong>ume <strong>73</strong>, <strong>No</strong>. 3
are going through is also important to decrease stress and fatigue.<br />
We should take time each week to reach out to a co-worker or mentor<br />
and discuss what is working and what is not. One practice that I<br />
have adopted since the pandemic began is writing a lesson journal.<br />
After each class, I write a few pros and cons and later share those<br />
with trusted colleagues who can lend their support and expertise.<br />
I have also relied on my tech savvy colleagues for virtual teaching<br />
solutions, and this has made a profound impact on how I approach<br />
online instruction.<br />
DEPARTMENT OF MUSIC<br />
CONCLUSION<br />
When COVID-19 suddenly upended our way of life, it also shifted<br />
how we will teach music forever. The physical, intellectual, and<br />
emotional toll of the coronavirus pandemic will be felt for generations.<br />
Nevertheless, some of the greatest innovations in music education<br />
are unfolding before our eyes. I urge that we continue to<br />
show ourselves and our students much compassion, give thanks for<br />
the opportunities we have, adjust our expectations to fit our current<br />
situation, seek new approaches to our teaching, and build a community<br />
of colleagues we can count on for support. While the future is<br />
still uncertain and we do not know what a post-pandemic world will<br />
look like, what we do know is that our world will never be the same.<br />
Let’s use this opportunity to fulfill the promise of providing an accessible<br />
and equitable music education for all students.<br />
DR. ROBERT L. BRYANT III currently serves as<br />
Music Education Coordinator at Tennessee<br />
State University. He earned degrees from Florida<br />
A&M University (B.S.), Florida State University<br />
(M.M.E.), Georgia Southern University<br />
(M.Ed.), and Mercer University (Ph.D.). Prior<br />
to his current role, Dr. Bryant taught as a middle<br />
and high school band director while also<br />
working in various roles in higher education<br />
for colleges and universities in Georgia and Alabama.<br />
As a member of the Georgia Music Educators Association, Dr. Bryant<br />
held the office of District IV Band Division Chairman in his<br />
second year of teaching. As a Nationally Certified Teacher of Music<br />
(NCTM) on euphonium, Dr. Bryant has performed at the Georgia<br />
Music Educators In-Service Conference, International Tuba Euphonium<br />
Conference, College Band Directors National Association<br />
Southern Division Conference, and the prestigious Midwest Clinic:<br />
An International Band and Orchestra Conference.<br />
Dr. Bryant is a member of the College Band Directors National Association,<br />
College Music Society, International Tuba Euphonium<br />
Association, Music Teachers National Association, National Association<br />
for Music Education, and is the advisor for the NAfME Collegiate<br />
Chapter at Tennessee State University.<br />
Dr. Bryant is the 2020-2022 TMEA Higher Education Chair.<br />
http://www.tnstate.edu/music/rbryant.aspx<br />
BACHELOR OF MUSIC<br />
Concentrations include:<br />
• Guitar Performance<br />
• Instrumental Performance<br />
• Keyboard Performance<br />
• Vocal Performance<br />
• Composition<br />
• Music Education<br />
Choral/K-12 General Music<br />
Instrumental/K-12 General Music<br />
BACHELOR OF ARTS/SCIENCE<br />
Customizable music degree plans for a<br />
variety of music and music-related careers<br />
Concentration:<br />
• Liberal Studies<br />
MASTER OF MUSIC<br />
Concentrations include:<br />
• Instrumental Performance<br />
• Vocal Performance<br />
• Instrumental Conducting<br />
• Choral Conducting<br />
• Music Education<br />
Graduate assistantships are<br />
available.<br />
Tuition waivers are available<br />
to out-of-state students.<br />
Audition dates are available at<br />
www.apsu.edu/music/graduate/auditions<br />
www.apsu.edu/music/undergraduate/auditions<br />
BE A OV!<br />
(students may pursue licensure)<br />
FOR INFORMATION, CONTACT:<br />
Department of Music<br />
P: 931-221-7818 • music@apsu.edu or<br />
visit www.apsu.edu/music<br />
Austin Peay State University does not discriminate on the basis of race, color, religion, creed, national origin, sex, sexual orientation,<br />
gender identity/expression, disability, age, status as a protected veteran, genetic information, or any other legally protected class<br />
with respect to all employment, programs and activities sponsored by APSU. http://www.apsu.edu/policy. Policy 6:003<br />
AP37/9-20/5
BE EXCELLENT. BE CHRIST-CENTERED.<br />
BE TRANSFORMED.<br />
At Union University, you will develop your musical craft under the training of highly<br />
qualified professional musicians who personally care for their students, passionately<br />
engage the artform, and are thoroughly committed to the Lord. You will experience<br />
an excellence-driven, Christ-centered music education designed to help you discover<br />
God’s unique calling and equip you for success in your life and career.<br />
Majors include: BM in Music Education, BM in Composition,<br />
BM in Performance, BM in Music Theory, BM in Commercial Music,<br />
BM in Worship Leadership and BA or BS in Music<br />
2021 Audition Dates: Jan. 23, Feb. 19, March 12, April 10<br />
NASM accredited since 1966<br />
LEARN MORE AT uu.edu/music<br />
BE TRANSFORMED
What is Social Emotional Learning?<br />
Why is it important for students?<br />
How does music education make a difference?<br />
<strong>No</strong>w more than ever, music education is critical for all students. One significant<br />
impact is how it helps students with social emotional learning.<br />
This brochure includes key talking points for music education advocates to use as<br />
they communicate with decision-makers about the place of music education in any<br />
school setting. It answers:<br />
• How are music educators well-suited to help students develop socially<br />
and emotionally?<br />
• What does research tell us?<br />
• How can public policy support music education and Social Emotional Learning?<br />
Download your brochure at bit.ly/MusicEduSEL<br />
Questions? Email advocacy@nafme.org<br />
nafme.org
TMEA TEACHING IN TENNESSEE<br />
Taking the<br />
Next Step:<br />
Considerations for<br />
Pursuing Graduate<br />
Studies in Music<br />
by Ryan Fisher, Ph.D.<br />
For many, earning a bachelor’s degree<br />
in music was a monumental achievement<br />
that required tremendous sacrifice,<br />
hard work, and perseverance.<br />
For some graduates, achieving a bachelor’s<br />
degree satisfied their academic ambitions,<br />
but many know graduate studies<br />
in music will be essential for them to<br />
advance their knowledge and skills, earn<br />
more money in their current position, or<br />
achieve their ultimate goal of teaching in<br />
higher education. The purpose of this<br />
article is to offer considerations for<br />
future and current music educators<br />
considering graduate<br />
studies in music.<br />
26 | TENNESSEE MUSICIAN | 2021 | <strong>Vol</strong>ume <strong>73</strong>, <strong>No</strong>. 3
For those contemplating graduate studies<br />
in music, there are several considerations<br />
to reflect on before taking the next steps.<br />
First, consider what you want to be when<br />
you “grow up.” Where do you envision yourself<br />
in five to ten years within the music profession?<br />
Next, consider what skills and/or<br />
knowledge you will need to achieve your vision.<br />
Depending on how you respond to this<br />
task, you may find attending specific professional<br />
development workshops or symposia<br />
may suffice in refining or enhancing the<br />
skills and knowledge you desire. Some may<br />
seek out summer professional development<br />
opportunities like conducting symposia or<br />
Orff training. These educational opportunities<br />
may be a good “trial run” to see if you feel<br />
more intensive study in these areas may be<br />
needed and/or desired. For some, attending<br />
annual professional development at music<br />
conferences and participating in a summer<br />
pedagogy workshop may meet your educational<br />
needs. Graduate school is not for everyone,<br />
but, ideally, lifelong education is a<br />
common objective all music teachers share.<br />
For those who feel like you need and/or<br />
strongly desire more intensive study in a<br />
specific area in the field of music, graduate<br />
studies may help you achieve your professional<br />
goals. Your next consideration may be<br />
quite practical—will you be able to continue<br />
teaching full-time while pursuing your<br />
graduate degree? While many graduate programs<br />
in music education offer online and/<br />
or summer delivery options, graduate studies<br />
in areas like performance, conducting,<br />
music therapy, and musicology still mainly<br />
rely on traditional, in-person coursework<br />
that may require you to suspend your music<br />
teaching career in order to complete<br />
the graduate degree requirements. Though<br />
most graduate music programs offer competitive<br />
graduate assistantship opportunities,<br />
this financial sacrifice will be something<br />
you will want to consider since no<br />
graduate assistantship will be able to match<br />
an annual teaching salary. For those who<br />
have families or certain responsibilities in<br />
your community, geographic location will<br />
be another important consideration when<br />
deciding where you might wish to study. For<br />
those in more rural areas, you might find an<br />
online delivery option may allow you more<br />
flexibility in meeting your family or community<br />
obligations.<br />
IF YOU ARE HAVING DIFFICULTY<br />
DECIDING WHICH AREA TO<br />
FOCUS ON IN A GRADUATE MUSIC<br />
PROGRAM, REFLECT ON AN AREA<br />
YOU ARE MOST INTRIGUED BY OR<br />
MOST EXCITED ABOUT.<br />
If you are having difficulty deciding which<br />
area to focus on in a graduate music program,<br />
reflect on an area you are most intrigued<br />
by or most excited about. If you love<br />
exploring ensemble repertory and enjoy<br />
refining your nonverbal communication<br />
through conducting, you might find graduate<br />
studies in conducting pairs nicely with<br />
your passion. For those who are constantly<br />
looking for effective teaching methods to<br />
enhance your students’ music skill acquisition,<br />
then studies in music education may<br />
satisfy your intrigue. Perhaps you want<br />
to focus more on your own performance<br />
ability in hopes of achieving your dream<br />
of performing alone or with a professional<br />
ensemble. If so, a master’s degree in music<br />
performance or an artist diploma may be<br />
the best fit.<br />
Understanding the areas within the field<br />
of music that truly excite you is essential<br />
to discovering a major or focus area within<br />
the graduate music degree. Next, an honest<br />
self-reflection of your strengths and weaknesses<br />
will be essential. If you struggled to<br />
make “C’s” in all of your undergraduate music<br />
theory classes, applying for a master’s<br />
degree in music theory might not be the<br />
best idea (unless, of course, you have grown<br />
exponentially in this area over the past few<br />
years). Similarly, if you despise courses<br />
with intensive reading and writing requirements,<br />
you might want to avoid graduate<br />
degrees in music education and musicology.<br />
That being said, no graduate studies in<br />
music will exempt you from taking some<br />
coursework that requires graduate-level<br />
writing and intensive reading assignments.<br />
If you have strong writing skills and an inquisitive<br />
mind, music degrees with more of<br />
a theoretical, philosophical, or research-focused<br />
emphasis like music education or<br />
music history may couple well with your<br />
skills and passion. Knowing which focus<br />
areas in graduate music degree offerings<br />
are more practice-based and those that are<br />
more research-based may be helpful when<br />
reaching your final decision.<br />
Once you have an idea of which major or<br />
concentration within the graduate music<br />
program you wish to pursue, you will<br />
want to more deeply explore the degree requirements.<br />
Though some music programs<br />
clearly outline the degree requirements on<br />
their websites, most do not. To explore the<br />
specific degree outline, including required<br />
courses, always review the most recent online<br />
graduate catalog. The catalog will typically<br />
allow you to click on certain courses in<br />
order to see a course description. This level<br />
of review gives you a better idea of areas of<br />
study the degree program requires and may<br />
show you the sequence of coursework for<br />
the program. Check to see if the degree program<br />
requires a thesis or if a project or recital(s)<br />
are accepted in lieu of a thesis. Explore<br />
if comprehensive exams are required near<br />
the end of the program and if they are oral<br />
Tennessee Music Education Assocation | www.tnmea.org | 27
or written exams. Though exploring these<br />
specific details may seem arduous, knowing<br />
this information before committing to<br />
a program may save you consternation and<br />
hardship in the future.<br />
After you feel you have a firm understanding<br />
of the required coursework, degree requirements,<br />
and sequence of coursework, you will<br />
next want to research with whom you will be<br />
primarily studying. If you will be applying for<br />
the graduate conducting program, become<br />
familiar with the educational background<br />
and professional experience and expertise of<br />
the conducting faculty member(s). For graduate<br />
music performance programs where<br />
you spend extensive time studying with one<br />
person, you may wish to schedule a sample<br />
lesson with that faculty member in order<br />
to see how they approach applied lessons<br />
and their pedagogical philosophy. You may<br />
not have had a choice in who your applied<br />
lessons professor was at the undergraduate<br />
level, but you DO have a choice at the graduate<br />
level. Do not make that decision without<br />
doing your homework and making sure you<br />
see potential for a compatible and symbiotic<br />
relationship. For those wishing to pursue<br />
graduate studies in music education, you<br />
will more than likely take coursework with<br />
several different music education scholars.<br />
Research their areas of expertise, their<br />
K-12 teaching experience, and, if accessible,<br />
read some of their published writings. This<br />
knowledge will give you a better idea of the<br />
diversity of experiences and expertise that<br />
faculty has to offer you.<br />
After you have researched the degree requirements<br />
and explored the faculty that<br />
you will be primarily studying with, you<br />
will next want to research the admissions<br />
requirements. The more performance focused<br />
graduate music degrees will more<br />
than likely require auditions. The larger<br />
graduate music programs may have two or<br />
more rounds of auditions where the first<br />
round simply requires a video-recording.<br />
These auditions typically have specific requirements<br />
regarding the repertory that<br />
must be presented. Carefully review those<br />
requirements and do not hesitate to correspond<br />
with the faculty area coordinator<br />
or music admissions coordinator if you<br />
have questions regarding the requirements.<br />
Always be professional in all communications<br />
with faculty members since first impressions<br />
are being formed with each email<br />
received. It is also highly recommended<br />
that you consult with your current or past<br />
applied music instructor regarding repertory<br />
selections that highlight your musical<br />
abilities and demonstrate your diversity as<br />
an artist.<br />
The more “academic” graduate degrees<br />
(music education, musicology, music theory,<br />
etc.) do not typically require performance<br />
auditions, but some may require an<br />
interview with faculty members from the<br />
relevant areas. Most of these programs are<br />
usually more interested in your past academic<br />
performance and your writing ability.<br />
As an example, most master’s degrees<br />
in music education require a philosophy<br />
of music education statement. Since most<br />
graduates from a bachelor’s degree program<br />
in music education already have some draft<br />
of a philosophy statement, that is often a<br />
good place to start since it would have already<br />
received feedback and editing from a<br />
past professor. Be sure the philosophy statement<br />
reflects your best writing and is truly<br />
indicative of the music teacher you ARE<br />
and not the teacher you wish you were. Doctoral<br />
music education programs will more<br />
than likely require a writing sample from a<br />
research proposal or project you may have<br />
composed during your master’s program.<br />
For these reasons, it is always advisable to<br />
28 | TENNESSEE MUSICIAN | 2021 | <strong>Vol</strong>ume <strong>73</strong>, <strong>No</strong>. 3
save all of your written submissions from<br />
past coursework. These writing samples<br />
are essential to reviewers when deciding<br />
which applicants will have the higher probability<br />
of being successful in their graduate<br />
program. Though some graduate music programs<br />
may require a minimum score on the<br />
GRE or MAT standardized tests, most graduate<br />
programs across the U.S. are removing<br />
these requirements as past academic performance<br />
is more predictive of success in<br />
graduate degree programs than scores on a<br />
standardized test. Graduate music education<br />
programs may also require evidence<br />
of your music teaching credentials and<br />
some require a minimum number of years<br />
of teaching experience to be eligible for<br />
their program.<br />
The final step after you have been successfully<br />
accepted into a graduate music program<br />
is to take every measure necessary to<br />
thrive in your program. There will be a time<br />
(or many times) when you feel unworthy to<br />
be in the program. You will sometimes feel<br />
as though your peers are more talented or<br />
more intelligent than you. You may feel the<br />
demands your professors are placing on you<br />
are overwhelming and unrealistic. In those<br />
times, remind yourself of the vision you had<br />
when you set out on your graduate adventure.<br />
Remind yourself of your strengths and<br />
weaknesses and understand that you are<br />
not alone. One of the greatest attributes of<br />
a successful graduate student is perseverance.<br />
Be engaged, be prepared, and do your<br />
best. Do not be afraid to communicate your<br />
concerns or questions to your professors<br />
and take the initiative to develop relationships<br />
with your peers. Those relationships<br />
will last throughout your music career and<br />
may prove essential in your success in completing<br />
the degree.<br />
DR. RYAN FISHER,<br />
Associate Professor<br />
of Music<br />
Education, is in<br />
his eighth year at<br />
the University of<br />
Memphis where<br />
he served as the<br />
Music Education Coordinator in the Rudi<br />
E. Scheidt School of Music before becoming<br />
the Associate Dean for Academic Affairs<br />
of the College of Communication and Fine<br />
Arts in 2018. Choirs under his direction have<br />
been featured at the Arkansas Music Educators<br />
Association conference (2010), Tennessee<br />
Music Education Association conference<br />
(2015), and ACDA Southern region<br />
conference (2020) and made frequent guest<br />
appearances with the Arkansas Symphony<br />
Orchestra, Conway Symphony Orchestra,<br />
and Germantown Symphony Orchestra. He<br />
currently directs the University of Memphis<br />
Chamber Choir and serves as artistic<br />
director of Memphis ChoralArts, a nonprofit,<br />
community choral organization that provides<br />
choral experiences for ages 8 – 80+.<br />
Dr. Fisher is an active choral clinician and<br />
researcher. He earned a B.M.E. from Lee<br />
University, a M.M. in choral conducting and<br />
a Ph.D. in music education from the University<br />
of <strong>No</strong>rth Texas. In 2016, he was named<br />
the Lee University School of Music Distinguished<br />
Alumnus of the Year. His research<br />
interests involve the male voice change,<br />
assessment in music education, and self-efficacy.<br />
His writings have been published in<br />
Oxford Press and various prestigious journals<br />
including the Journal of Research in<br />
Music Education, Bulletin of the Council for<br />
Research in Music Education, and Update:<br />
Applications of Research in Music Education.<br />
Dr. Fisher has served as the Vice President of<br />
the Choral Division of the Texas Private Music<br />
Educators Association, President-Elect<br />
of the Arkansas Music Educators Association,<br />
Higher Education Chair of the West<br />
Tennessee Vocal Music Educators Association,<br />
member of the National Association for<br />
Music Education Choral Council, member of<br />
the editorial board for Update: Applications<br />
of Research in Music Education, and Higher<br />
Education Chair of the Tennessee Music Education<br />
Association. He currently serves as<br />
President-Elect of TMEA.<br />
Tennessee Music Education Assocation | www.tnmea.org | 29
EVEN TEACHERS<br />
NEED TEACHERS<br />
As an educator, one of the most impactful ways to improve is by educating yourself. That’s<br />
why the Yamaha Educator Suite (YES) helps music teachers access professional development<br />
opportunities, music teacher resources, program health support, advocacy assistance and<br />
more. YES brings you a network of like-minded teachers, experts and professionals, who want<br />
to help you achieve your goals. Let us help you raise the bar. Go to Yamaha.io/educatorsTM<br />
30 | TENNESSEE MUSICIAN | 2021 | <strong>Vol</strong>ume <strong>73</strong>, <strong>No</strong>. 3
IN YOUR SCHOOL’S STORY<br />
TRI-M<br />
COULD BE THE<br />
MOST<br />
IMPORTANT<br />
CHAPTER<br />
Tri-M® is the only national honor society for student musicians in<br />
the country. It highlights your school’s music program and gives<br />
students the opportunity to perform, lead, and serve.<br />
Besides looking good on a college application, a Tri-M® Music<br />
Honor Society chapter is easy to start, easy to run, and benefits<br />
your students, the school, and the community.<br />
Over 2,300 Tri-M chapters already enrich the lives of over 85,000+<br />
students throughout the country and around the globe.<br />
START A CHAPTER<br />
MusicHonors.com<br />
®
TMEA LEARNING FROM OUR LEGENDS<br />
SPOTLIGHT ON<br />
BOBBY JEAN “B.J.” FROST<br />
TMEA Retired Teachers Chair<br />
32 | TENNESSEE MUSICIAN | 2021 | <strong>Vol</strong>ume <strong>73</strong>, <strong>No</strong>. 3
Brandon Heath<br />
Five-Time Grammy nominee,<br />
Contemporary Christian Artist<br />
Alumni - Hillsboro High School<br />
I wasn’t an ‘A’ or even a ‘B’ student in school. Socially, I<br />
loved it, but academically I was always a little bewildered<br />
about what I was learning. I loved music, but it never<br />
occurred to me that it could be my career. B.J. Frost<br />
showed me otherwise. She was a working composer and<br />
director in music along with being a full-time high school<br />
teacher. She was excellent at what she did and expected<br />
excellence out of us. I was a freshman and she encouraged<br />
me to audition for a national competition, which somehow<br />
I won, and found myself at the Grammy’s as a 15 year<br />
old. That was a defining opportunity in my life where I<br />
not only realized my talent, but that I should chase it for<br />
the rest of my life. I owe my work ethic and tenacity to<br />
her.<br />
Chris Brooks<br />
Vice-President, Row-Loff Productions<br />
Alumni - McGavock High School<br />
Chris Crockarell<br />
President, Row-Loff Productions<br />
Alumni - McGavock High School<br />
When you have a lifetime relationship with a<br />
teacher as I have with B.J., guess it goes<br />
without saying that she had a profound<br />
influence on me. B.J. told me several years<br />
back, “My real job was to always let you kids<br />
know that you didn’t know everything.” She<br />
had an amazing gift for doing just that, just<br />
at the right time, with the net result being<br />
that you wanted to learn more, and she<br />
always had more to knowledge give. I was a<br />
blessed young man to have her as a teacher<br />
and a mentor.<br />
Bobby Jean was such a huge musical influence<br />
on my life and career. Thanks to B.J., I<br />
was exempt from my college freshman theory<br />
class and slept through my sophomore year!<br />
:-) A tremendous, musician, educator, and<br />
friend.<br />
Tennessee Music Education Assocation | www.tnmea.org | 33
MUSIC BACKGROUND<br />
Tell us about your music<br />
teaching experience.<br />
I graduated college in 1953 and started my<br />
first teaching job at Glenn School in Nashville<br />
City Schools (now Metro Nashville<br />
Public Schools) where I taught the 5th<br />
grade music classes. I didn’t just teach them<br />
music—my classes were the ones that made<br />
the weekly Nashville City Schools’ music<br />
lesson radio broadcasts every week for<br />
classroom teachers, called “Let’s Learn Music.”<br />
At that time in Nashville City Schools,<br />
the schools would use these broadcasts to<br />
teach the students what they were supposed<br />
to learn for that week in their music classes.<br />
The Nashville City Schools music supervisor<br />
would talk about the lessons and then<br />
we would perform them for the live audio<br />
sessions.<br />
The audio equipment was brought to our<br />
school every Friday or close to the end of the<br />
week, so I had all week to make sure we got<br />
everything down during rehearsals before<br />
our weekly broadcast day. I travelled to each<br />
of the 5th grade classrooms at Glenn every<br />
day to teach and practice their music with<br />
them—I actually moved a big upright piano<br />
from classroom to classroom to teach them<br />
their music parts!<br />
During the broadcast sessions, the music<br />
supervisor for Nashville Public Schools<br />
would talk about the music, talk about the<br />
composers, and teach information about<br />
the songs. I played the piano for my students<br />
live while leading them during these<br />
sessions.<br />
I got married during my first year of teaching<br />
on December 18, 1953 – and a lot of my<br />
5th grade students came to my wedding!<br />
(It’s a good thing the church I got married<br />
in was a large church—they had plenty of<br />
room to come!) At my wedding, one of my<br />
music supervisors played the cello and my<br />
piano teacher played the organ. After that<br />
school year, I had two kids, so then I stopped<br />
teaching for a while because I wanted to be<br />
at home to raise them until they could enter<br />
school. People in Nashville City Schools<br />
asked me for years if I would come back to<br />
teaching. In 1965, I was approached again<br />
to see if I would come teach at Pearl High<br />
School. It was the right timing, so I said yes.<br />
Education & Employment<br />
Education<br />
George Peabody College<br />
Bachelor of Music in Piano Performance<br />
(Certified in School Music 1-12)<br />
Employment<br />
Nashville City Schools<br />
(now Metropolitan Nashville Public Schools)<br />
1953-1954<br />
Glenn School – Special Music Teacher<br />
1959-1960<br />
George Peabody College – Piano<br />
1965-1969<br />
Pearl High School – Title I Choral Assistant<br />
1969-1971<br />
Pearl High School – Choral Music<br />
1971-1982<br />
McGavock High School – Music Theory,<br />
Piano, Jazz-Rock Ensemble, Dept. Chair<br />
(1975-1982)<br />
1982-2002<br />
Hillsboro High School – Choral Music, Class<br />
Piano, SophistiCats, Fine Arts Chair<br />
Opryland – Music Director for 21 Years<br />
(Conductor, Pianist for Opryland<br />
Shows and Auditions)<br />
• I Hear America Singing (also wrote the<br />
choral charts and some instrumental<br />
arrangements)<br />
• For Me and My Gal<br />
• A Dixie Melody<br />
• Way Out West<br />
• I Hear America Singing<br />
Touring Production: 1975-1979<br />
• For Me and My Gal<br />
Touring Production: 1980-1986<br />
• AMOCO Network TV Special<br />
• AMOCO Convention in Hawaii<br />
Miscellaneous: Church Organist & Choir<br />
Director; Pianist for Dance Bands,<br />
Orchestras, Studio Recordings, Concerts;<br />
Soloist; Accompanist; Clinician;<br />
Adjudicator<br />
I started teaching at Pearl High School in<br />
1965, so I was teaching there during the<br />
time when Martin Luther King, Jr., was<br />
killed. I was asked to come to integrate the<br />
faculty—I was the only white teacher in the<br />
building until they integrated the faculty in<br />
1969. I will tell you that I was totally accepted<br />
and treated marvelously at Pearl High<br />
School. At that time, we had about 1,800<br />
students and a very large faculty—probably<br />
one of the best faculties I have ever worked<br />
with. They integrated the faculty at Pearl<br />
while I was there, and they began integrating<br />
the student body about two years before<br />
I left Pearl High School to begin teaching at<br />
McGavock High School in 1971. I taught at<br />
McGavock until 1982 when I began teaching<br />
at Hillsboro High School. I retired from<br />
Hillsboro in 2002. While I was teaching at<br />
McGavock and at Hillsboro High School, I<br />
also worked as a music director at Opryland<br />
for twenty-one years.<br />
What were some of your earliest music<br />
experiences?<br />
I started by taking piano lessons. Every lesson<br />
that I went to, I had to transpose pieces<br />
into all keys, sight-read, complete a theory<br />
lesson, and then play the usual scales. So, by<br />
the time I got to college, I was in really good<br />
shape on piano, and I accompanied all the<br />
groups I was in except for the band where I<br />
played percussion and marimba.<br />
Tennessee <strong>Musician</strong>, <strong>Vol</strong>. 24, <strong>No</strong>. 2<br />
December 1971<br />
Announcement of Mrs. Bobby Jean Frost as<br />
new TMEA Executive Secretary -Treasurer<br />
34 | TENNESSEE MUSICIAN | 2021 | <strong>Vol</strong>ume <strong>73</strong>, <strong>No</strong>. 3
Ensembles<br />
Pearl High School: 1969-1971<br />
Chorus (1970-1971) and Madrigal Singers (1971)<br />
MTVA Choral Festivals – I Ratings<br />
U.T. Martin Invitational Festival – I Ratings<br />
U.T. Invitational Festival – I Rating<br />
Performances<br />
Fisk University: Two Concerts<br />
Metro. Nashville Board of Education<br />
McGavock High School – Jazz-Rock: 1971-1982<br />
<br />
International Music Festivals<br />
Music Maestro Please<br />
• Chicago, IL: 1982 – Gold Medal<br />
• New York, NY: 1981 – Gold Medal<br />
• Philadelphia, PA: 1980 – Silver Medal<br />
Performing Arts Abroad<br />
• New York, NY: 1978 – Gold Medal<br />
Feature Shows<br />
• WDCN-TV (Two Shows)<br />
• WSM-TV (<strong>No</strong>on Show)<br />
Special Performances<br />
• Music Educators National Conference Southern Division<br />
Convention Concert: <strong>No</strong>rfolk, VA<br />
• Tennessee Music Education Association Convention<br />
Concerts: Knoxville; Nashville<br />
• SESAC Awards Banquet, Country Music Festival<br />
• Opryland (Two shows)<br />
• Underground Atlanta<br />
• Belmont Arts Festival<br />
Concert Tours<br />
• Mexico City, Mexico<br />
• Washington, D.C.<br />
• Atlanta, GA<br />
• Chattanooga, <strong>TN</strong><br />
Clinics/Concerts<br />
• University of Tennessee Knoxville<br />
• Paine College (Augusta, GA)<br />
• Murray State University (Murray, KY)<br />
• Middle Tennessee Vocal Association<br />
Hillsboro High School – Madrigals/SophistiCats: 1982-2002<br />
<br />
International Music Festivals<br />
• Gateway- Nassau, Bahamas: 1993 – Gold Medal<br />
Music Maestro Please (Madrigals)<br />
• New York, NY: 1992 – Silver Medal<br />
• Toronto, Canada: 1991 – Silver Medal<br />
• Chicago, IL: 1990 – Silver Medal<br />
• New York, NY: 1989 – Gold Medal<br />
• Toronto, Canada: 1988 – Silver Medal<br />
• Chicago, IL: 1987 – Gold Medal<br />
• Philadelphia, PA: 1986 – Silver Medal<br />
• New York, NY: 1986 – Silver Medal<br />
• Orlando, FL: 1983 – Silver Medal<br />
<br />
Young Americans Invitational Festival<br />
Hollywood, CA: 1985<br />
Feature Shows:<br />
• WDCN-TV (Fillers, Sign On/Off)<br />
• WSMV-TV (Channel 4 Magazine, <strong>No</strong>on Show, 5 o’clock)<br />
• WTVF-TV (Talk of the Town)<br />
Special Performances (SophistiCats)<br />
• American Association of School Personnel Administration<br />
National Conference<br />
• MNEA 20th Anniversary<br />
• Grammy in the Schools<br />
• Altrusa National Convention<br />
• Walt Disney World<br />
• Leonard Bernstein Center Inaugural Conference<br />
• IAPPW Convention<br />
• Elementary Principals Association Convention<br />
• Great American Smokeout<br />
• Metropolitan Nashville Public Schools Board of Education<br />
• London, England<br />
• Performance at Sea (Two concerts at ship captain’s request)<br />
• Euro Disney – Paris, France<br />
• Hollywood, CA<br />
Regional Festivals<br />
• University of Tennessee Martin Invitational – Superior<br />
Ratings (3)<br />
• Middle Tennessee Vocal Association – Superior Ratings (2)<br />
Regional Festivals<br />
• Tennessee Arts Commission – Superior Ratings (3)<br />
• Middle Tennessee Vocal Association – Superior Ratings (2)<br />
Tennessee Music Education Assocation | www.tnmea.org | 35
What inspired you to become a music educator?<br />
Having two children! When I was in my late<br />
teens, I was on a good track towards doing<br />
commercial recordings. I had worked on a<br />
number of recordings at the Quonset Hut<br />
in downtown Nashville [part of Nashville’s<br />
Music Row], which was the famous place to<br />
go at the time. I did recordings down there<br />
and I was playing gigs everywhere, but<br />
when I had two children, I couldn’t make<br />
the call to go anymore, so I had to give that<br />
up. But other than the one year of teaching<br />
at Glenn School when I first graduated college,<br />
I didn’t start teaching until after I was<br />
already married and had children.<br />
INNOVATIVE MUSIC ENSEMBLES:<br />
JAZZ-ROCK AND THE SOPHISTICATS<br />
Can you tell us more about what classes and<br />
ensembles you have taught?<br />
I always tell everyone that I am an instrumentalist,<br />
but I taught choral music, music<br />
theory, I had my Jazz-Rock group . . . so<br />
I never taught the exact same things more<br />
than one year! At Pearl High School, I had<br />
choral music, I had general music, and some<br />
Level I theory. When I taught at McGavock,<br />
I had three levels of music theory, class piano,<br />
and Jazz-Rock. At Hillsboro, I taught<br />
theory, chorus, three levels of piano, and the<br />
SophistiCats. I had so many different things<br />
that I taught.<br />
When I started teaching at Pearl High<br />
School, I basically “roamed” the music<br />
department. I worked with the choral director<br />
and the instrumental director (he<br />
did band and orchestra). They also had a<br />
string teacher that came to teach some<br />
string classes. I also worked with the drama<br />
teacher, and we put on the plays and the<br />
shows. For all of them, it was like having a<br />
well-rounded assistant because I could do<br />
the class work, choral work, and the instrumental<br />
work since I had the credits for all of<br />
them. I thoroughly enjoyed that experience.<br />
The choral director left after a few years, so<br />
during my last two years at Pearl, I took over<br />
the choral program. When I was at McGavock<br />
and Hillsboro, I created two unique performance<br />
groups: Jazz-Rock and the<br />
SophistiCats.<br />
You created two innovative, highly acclaimed,<br />
award-winning ensembles: Jazz-<br />
Rock and the SophistiCats. Can you tell us<br />
more about these groups?<br />
During my first year of teaching at McGavock,<br />
I started the Jazz-Rock group. The<br />
way Jazz-Rock was formed is . . . I just did<br />
it! I thought it would be fun! Jazz-Rock was<br />
made up of sixteen instrumentalists and sixteen<br />
vocalists. So, the first year I was there<br />
at McGavock, I created this group. I called<br />
the supervisor at the state Department of<br />
Education, he came and saw the group, and<br />
he cleared it for course credit. Since I was<br />
doing my own arranging, I had freedom to<br />
utilize what I was arranging based on what<br />
I had and what I needed in the group. For example,<br />
if we had great French Horn players<br />
one year, we’d incorporate them; if not, we<br />
didn’t!<br />
When I went to Hillsboro, I continued some<br />
form of that group when I created the SophistiCats<br />
because I liked to arrange that<br />
kind of music for my groups. I enjoyed the<br />
classical music equally well, but I also enjoyed<br />
the spontaneity of arranging things<br />
that were not available. I had been used to<br />
arranging for my Pearl High School chorus<br />
and for Jazz-Rock, and I found I had really<br />
enjoyed teaching popular music, too—that’s<br />
36 | TENNESSEE MUSICIAN | 2021 | <strong>Vol</strong>ume <strong>73</strong>, <strong>No</strong>. 3
what helped me figure out I wanted to create<br />
the SophistiCats. The SophistiCats was<br />
made up of about sixteen students, and this<br />
was a “double” group—it was a Madrigal<br />
group that sang classical music during the<br />
day, and it was also a popular music group<br />
that met after school. During class, we<br />
taught classical music where we did what<br />
you’d expect—we worked on tuning, we had<br />
section leaders to help rehearse the music—all<br />
the usual things. After school, the<br />
SophistiCats rehearsed pop music and choreography.<br />
I also was the one that recorded<br />
myself playing the accompaniment for this<br />
group. We had a recording studio at Hillsboro.<br />
Vic Gabany, who was the recording<br />
teacher and also worked for the Opry, was<br />
our recording technician. I laid the piano<br />
track at the recording studio, and I would<br />
call on some of my professional friends to<br />
come lay the rhythm tracks (drum and bass)<br />
because you can’t do pop music without<br />
some kind of a beat!<br />
ADVICE FOR MUSIC EDUCATORS<br />
What are essential qualities of effective<br />
music educators?<br />
Know your craft and know what you’re doing.<br />
Go in prepared every day. Make sure<br />
every kid gets an equal treatment—you cannot<br />
play favorites. Work like a dog yourself<br />
so you work harder than your students do—<br />
then, they are perfectly willing to take the<br />
work you give them because they know you<br />
Fun Facts<br />
AT 15 YEARS OLD - WON THE<br />
EUGENIA BORTON CUP IN<br />
NATIONAL PIANO PERFORMANCE<br />
COMPETITION (1970’S) AS THE<br />
REPRESENTATIVE OF THE JUNIOR<br />
MUSIC DIVISION OF THE WOMAN’S<br />
CLUB OF NASHVILLE<br />
IN 1948: WON THE HORACE HEIDT<br />
TALENT CONTEST WITH DOUGLAS<br />
WILLIAMS (MARIMBA DUO)<br />
<br />
IN COLLEGE: STUDIED<br />
COMPOSITION WITH RAY HARRIS<br />
AND PIANO WITH JAHNA HARRIS<br />
<br />
WROTE THE PUBLICATION “JAZZ-<br />
ROCK VOCAL/INSTRUMENTAL<br />
SERIES” (ALFRED PUBLISHING<br />
COMPANY)<br />
<br />
SESSION DIRECTOR AND<br />
PIANIST FOR THE WELL-KNOWN<br />
PBS EDUCATIONAL TV SHOWS<br />
“JELLYBEAN JUNCTION,” “MRS.<br />
CABOBBLE’S CABOOSE,” AND<br />
“ACTION AUCTION”<br />
<br />
ATTENDED THE 2012 GRAMMY<br />
AWARDS IN L.A. AS HER 1994-<br />
1997 STUDENT BRANDON HEATH’S<br />
DATE (BRANDON WAS NOMINATED<br />
FOR THREE AWARDS)<br />
<br />
THE SOPHISTICATS (HILLSBORO<br />
HIGH SCHOOL GROUP) WAS<br />
NAMED AS ONE OF THE TOP 100<br />
PERFORMANCE CHOIRS IN THE<br />
UNITED STATES (14,588 HIGH<br />
SCHOOLS WERE CONSIDERED)<br />
Tennessee Music Education Assocation | www.tnmea.org | 37
Professional Organizations<br />
Other Organizations<br />
TENNESSEE MUSIC EDUCATION ASSOCIATION**<br />
Executive Secretary-Treasurer: 1971-1977<br />
Convention Program Chairman: 1978<br />
Convention General Chairman: 1980<br />
Convention Program Chairman: 1981<br />
Conference Chairman: 2002-2011<br />
Retired Teachers Chairman: 2013-Present**<br />
TENNESSEE ARTS ACADEMY FOUNDATION**<br />
Treasurer: 2011-Present**<br />
PHI BETA MU**<br />
AMERICAN FEDERATION OF MUSICIANS, LOCAL 257**<br />
SIGMA ALPHA IOTA INTERNATIONAL MUSIC FRATERNITY**<br />
Province Vice-President: 1963-1968<br />
Province President: 1968-1971<br />
National Vice Chairman Bold <strong>No</strong>te 1971-1974<br />
National Chairman Bold <strong>No</strong>te Scholarship: 1974-1976<br />
DELTA KAPPA GAMMA**<br />
MUSIC EDUCATORS NATIONAL CONFERENCE (NOW NAFME)<br />
Council of State Secretaries: 1976-1977<br />
Senior High General Music Committee: 1978<br />
MIDDLE TENNESSEE VOCAL ASSOCIATION<br />
Vice President: 1970-1972<br />
President: 1972-1974<br />
Vice-President: 1974-1976<br />
MIDDLE TENNESSEE BAND AND ORCHESTRA ASSOCIATION<br />
AMERICAN CHORAL DIRECTORS ASSOCIATION<br />
NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF JAZZ EDUCATORS<br />
Vice-President: 1975-1976<br />
TENNESSEE JAZZ AND BLUES SOCIETY<br />
Secretary: 1975-1976<br />
NATIONAL EDUCATION ASSOCIATION<br />
TENNESSEE EDUCATION ASSOCIATION<br />
INTERNATIONAL PLATFORM ASSOCIATION<br />
METROPOLITAN NASHVILLE EDUCATION ASSOCIATION<br />
WOMAN’S CLUB OF NASHVILLE**<br />
Board of Directors and Executive Committee:<br />
2021-2015; 2017-2019<br />
Five-Year Planning Committee: 2019-Present**<br />
J.B. DANIELS HOUSE FOUNDATION**<br />
Board of Directors: 2010-Present**<br />
TENNESSEE MUSEUM LADIES AND GENTS COMMITTEE<br />
Awards<br />
NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF RECORDING ARTS AND SCIENCES<br />
“Music of the Heart” Educator (1 of 22 selected): 1999<br />
SIGMA ALPHA IOTA: COMMENDATION TO MUSIC THROUGH<br />
DISTINGUISHED SERVICE TO THE BLIND; SWORD OF HONOR; ROSE<br />
OF HONOR<br />
TMEA LIFETIME ACHIEVEMENT: 2012<br />
TMEA HALL OF FAME: 2007<br />
TENNESSEE ARTS ACADEMY LIFETIME ACHIEVEMENT: 2004<br />
CONTEMPORARY MUSIC PROJECT YEARLONG EVALUATION OF<br />
COMPREHENSIVE MUSICIANSHIP (FORD FOUNDATION GRANT; 12<br />
SELECTED NATIONALLY): 1972<br />
GEORGE PEABODY ALUMNI ASSOCIATION OUTSTANDING WOMEN<br />
GRADUATES (1 OF 3): 1976<br />
MIDDLE TENNESSEE HONORS CHORUS BOARD MIDDLE TENNESSEE<br />
HONOR TEACHER OF THE YEAR (FIRST PERSON TO RECEIVE THIS<br />
AWARD): 1984<br />
METROPOLITAN EDUCATION ASSOCIATION DISTINGUISHED<br />
CLASSROOM TEACHER: 1999<br />
HILLSBORO HIGH SCHOOL TEACHER OF THE YEAR: 1999<br />
ADOLESCENT SERVICE NETWORK CERTIFICATES FOR DEDICATION<br />
AND SERVICE TO ADOLESCENTS: 1983, 1987, 1988<br />
GEORGE PEABODY COLLEGE WHO’S WHO IN AMERICAN COLLEGES<br />
AND UNIVERSITIES: 1953<br />
** Denotes current membership / active participation<br />
38 | TENNESSEE MUSICIAN | 2021 | <strong>Vol</strong>ume <strong>73</strong>, <strong>No</strong>. 3
to say to other neighbors “I saw your child<br />
perform!” You want your group to be successful,<br />
and you want your parents and your<br />
community to think it is, too. My groups<br />
have performed at so many places in the<br />
community. They’ve performed at Rotary<br />
Clubs, at the mall, at Belle Meade Country<br />
Club. . . they’ve performed at an Episcopal<br />
church that wanted us to do a concert, and<br />
they’ve performed at a Baptist church. They<br />
even performed for Governor Alexander.<br />
We just did different performances everywhere<br />
we could.<br />
Do you have any other advice for current<br />
music teachers?<br />
work harder than they do! Create a sense of<br />
pride in your students in what they are doing—when<br />
they have pride in their group,<br />
they will tell you if something is going on<br />
in the group that shouldn’t be going on. Pay<br />
attention to other successful people and imitate<br />
them! Anything effective that you see—<br />
try to replicate it.<br />
What advice do you have for music teachers?<br />
Try to impress your students’ parents<br />
right off the bat at the very beginning of<br />
the school year. You can do this in a very<br />
simple way. When I left McGavock to start<br />
teaching at Hillsboro, I used the first week<br />
of school to prepare a classical and a pop<br />
tune for the Madrigal/SophistiCat group<br />
to perform. At the beginning of the second<br />
week of school, I had an Open House for the<br />
parents—I put out some punch and cookies.<br />
. . not much—and then I let those students<br />
perform for the parents. So, very quickly,<br />
before they were even expected to be able<br />
to perform, the students started off on the<br />
Tennessee <strong>Musician</strong>, <strong>Vol</strong>. 25 <strong>No</strong>. 3<br />
March 19<strong>73</strong><br />
right foot with the mentality of “We did<br />
well!” This helped me get to know the parents<br />
to begin with, too.<br />
It is very important to get to know the<br />
parents of your students. When you do<br />
this, it can help you find who will be great<br />
chaperones, booster officers, and volunteers.<br />
Learn how to handle the school<br />
finances (know all of the school rules<br />
about this) and how to make solid trip<br />
preparations that protect you, your<br />
students, and your school. If you don’t<br />
know how to do this, talk to someone who<br />
has done this a lot to find out what to do!<br />
Everyone knows someone who has done a<br />
lot of travel with groups. You need to know<br />
what to do before something happens, so<br />
then you know how to handle it.<br />
Get your students out to perform in<br />
your general neighborhood. If you show<br />
off your students in your local area, it raises<br />
awareness of your group and your school,<br />
and this will pay back. Neighbors will start<br />
In music, I think it’s all about creating an<br />
exciting atmosphere for your students. You<br />
may be funny, you may be good at demonstrating,<br />
or you may be good at something<br />
else. For example, my students always found<br />
it funny that I “never knew the words”—because<br />
I was the one accompanying them,<br />
I always told them I had to focus on the<br />
chords . . . so I would make up the words<br />
sometimes for fun! I’ve always been one of<br />
those people that try to look for the laugh or<br />
look for the funny. I think some humor is always<br />
good in the classroom. Lighten up, and<br />
try to have some fun occasionally!<br />
TMEA AND RETIRED TEACHERS<br />
When you were a teacher, what did TMEA<br />
mean to you?<br />
TMEA gave my students wonderful opportunities<br />
to compete, great opportunities to<br />
be part of the All-State groups, great performance<br />
opportunities at the conference, and<br />
some very good sessions for both younger<br />
and older teachers. I still find these to be<br />
true today.<br />
I was TMEA Executive Secretary-Treasurer<br />
from 1971-1977 while I was also a<br />
full-time teacher. I held almost every role in<br />
TMEA at the conference—I’ve been equipment<br />
chair, conference manager, auditions<br />
chair. . . you name it! When I was TMEA Executive<br />
Secretary-Treasurer, part of what I<br />
did was write TMEA correspondence, keep<br />
up with the TMEA officers’ expenses, and<br />
attend the National Conference (now the<br />
NAfME National Hill Day Conference).<br />
Tennessee Music Education Assocation | www.tnmea.org | 39
When I was TMEA Executive Secretary-Treasurer,<br />
I also had a few physical<br />
aspects to the job – one of the things I had<br />
to do was take the big sacks of the Tennessee<br />
Tennessee <strong>Musician</strong>, <strong>Vol</strong>. 27 <strong>No</strong>. 3<br />
March 1975<br />
<strong>Musician</strong> magazines to the post office every<br />
time a publication was ready to be mailed<br />
out. These were big, heavy postal sacks full<br />
of Tennessee <strong>Musician</strong> magazines. When<br />
you think of all of the people that belong to<br />
TMEA statewide, that’s a lot of magazines<br />
that need to be mailed! Sometimes my husband<br />
would help me get them loaded into<br />
my car, but he travelled for his job a lot, so<br />
sometimes he couldn’t be there. Sometimes<br />
I had to grab anyone I could get to help me<br />
load the magazine into my car. It was always<br />
funny when the post office workers saw me<br />
coming!<br />
You are still actively involved in TMEA as<br />
the TMEA Retired Teachers Chair. What<br />
would you like current teachers and retired<br />
teachers to know about the role of retired<br />
music teachers across Tennessee?<br />
I want everyone to know that there is so<br />
much good we retired teachers can do. We<br />
are a large pool of knowledge, and I don’t<br />
want us to be wasted. To our retired music<br />
teachers: I think it’s up to us to give back to<br />
the new teachers. To current teachers: you<br />
can always learn some new things from us.<br />
We just want to tell you that we’re available<br />
and we want to answer any questions you<br />
want to ask.<br />
40 | TENNESSEE MUSICIAN | 2021 | <strong>Vol</strong>ume <strong>73</strong>, <strong>No</strong>. 3
CIVIC ACTION FIELD GUIDE<br />
FOR MUSIC EDUCATION<br />
Representing music educators, students, and advocates, NAfME is<br />
dedicated to ensuring the accessibility, presence, and perseverance of<br />
quality music programs taught by certified music educators, for all students<br />
across the nation, regardless of circumstance. Through active advocacy<br />
and collaboration, we are changing the national conversation about<br />
music’s role in delivering a well-rounded education to all students.<br />
NAfME designed the Civic Action Field Guide to help music educators<br />
and education stakeholders better understand the processes behind how<br />
public education is governed and funded, with an eye toward supporting<br />
high-quality music education in districts and at the state level across the<br />
nation. With this Guide, you will be able to:<br />
• Understand how public education is governed and funded<br />
• Identify key elected officials in public education and their election<br />
cycles<br />
• Identify candidates and their stances on education issues<br />
• Register to vote<br />
• Understand the well-rounded education programs found in Title I, Title<br />
II, and Title IV, and learn how to advocate for the availability of these<br />
funding streams to your music program under ESSA (the Every Student<br />
Succeeds Act)<br />
• Contact your elected officials and advocate for music education<br />
Download your copy today at bit.ly/NAfMECivicActionFieldGuide.<br />
Questions? Email advocacy@nafme.org or call 1-800-336-3768.
TMEA GUEST FEATURE<br />
by Stephanie Cronenberg, Ph.D.<br />
The present moment in education in<br />
the United States, with its focus on<br />
standardized learning and testing,<br />
challenges educators who desire<br />
to cultivate democratic<br />
learning communities (Elliott,<br />
2016; Michelli & Jacobowitz,<br />
2016; Wall & Wall,<br />
2016). While the idea of integrating<br />
democratic principles<br />
into music education is not<br />
new (see Allsup, 2016; DeLorenzo,<br />
2016; Woodford, 2005),<br />
specific democratic principles<br />
may help to reshape middle<br />
level general music. Randall<br />
Allsup (2016) argues that “music<br />
teachers in public schools<br />
are endowed with an obligation<br />
to alter—to (re)form, to<br />
(re)musik—the quality and<br />
character of their music forms<br />
to ensure that student life and<br />
learning is enlarged, deepened,<br />
and enriched” (p. 23). In what<br />
follows, I put forward five democratic<br />
principles that, if employed, could help<br />
remusik middle level general music, increase<br />
student engagement, and potentially create a positive<br />
musical space for all students and teachers involved.<br />
MIDDLE LEVEL<br />
If you teach general music to fifth, sixth, seventh, or<br />
eighth grade students, it is likely that you have wondered<br />
something like, “What on earth went wrong<br />
during that lesson?” Hopefully, you have also had<br />
the opportunity to think, “That was great, how can<br />
I do the same thing next class?” I purposefully use<br />
the phrase “middle level” here because this term is<br />
inclusive of all students and teachers, fifth through<br />
eighth grade, regardless of school context. Students<br />
at this age—variously referred to as middle schoolers,<br />
young adolescents, or middle level learners—face a<br />
time of significant change, cognitively, physically, emotionally,<br />
and socially, as they mature into full adolescence.<br />
As a result, they can be unpredictable to their teachers,<br />
parents, and even to themselves.<br />
Educators and researchers who examine middle level education<br />
from all academic disciplines share a common goal<br />
of improving education for young adolescents. Their focus<br />
puts young adolescent developmental needs at the center<br />
of all educational decision-making (see NSMA, 2010). So,<br />
what would a general music classroom in this vein look or<br />
sound like? How might democratic principles influence<br />
classroom experiences and provide new energy to<br />
classroom curricula?<br />
42 | TENNESSEE MUSICIAN | 2021 | <strong>Vol</strong>ume <strong>73</strong>, <strong>No</strong>. 3
FIVE DEMOCRATIC PRINCIPLES FOR<br />
MIDDLE LEVEL GENERAL MUSIC<br />
I define middle level general music as developmentally appropriate<br />
musical learning for all young adolescents, music<br />
learning that inspires students to continue learning formally<br />
or informally in music. Importantly, developmentally appropriate<br />
musical learning is key to fostering student engagement both<br />
within and beyond the classroom. The ability to cultivate young<br />
adolescent engagement rests upon a foundation of five democratic<br />
principles drawn from middle level education or music<br />
education. They are:<br />
1. Educating the Whole Student<br />
2. Making Connections<br />
3. Integrating Students’ Perspectives<br />
4. Including All Musical Forms<br />
5. Teaching All Students<br />
When combined together, these five democratic principles can<br />
guide general music teaching-and-learning. Briefly, I describe<br />
each democratic principle and provide a tip for teacher<br />
development or classroom application.<br />
MIDDLE LEVEL GENERAL MUSIC EDUCATES<br />
THE WHOLE STUDENT<br />
Developmentally appropriate music<br />
learning begins with the inescapable<br />
realities of puberty. For middle level<br />
students, the onset of puberty and its<br />
subsequent developmental evolution<br />
impacts every area of their lives. Young<br />
adolescents’ cognitive abilities are deeply<br />
intertwined with their physical development,<br />
their social and emotional needs,<br />
and their evolving identity development.<br />
Michael Nakkula and Eric Toshalis (2006)<br />
argue that as adolescents develop, they<br />
are constructing their understanding<br />
of themselves and the world around<br />
them through daily experiences and<br />
the positive and negative lessons<br />
they learn when they try something<br />
new. Accordingly, our job<br />
is to serve as co-constructors<br />
of young adolescents’ identities<br />
by providing support,<br />
guidance, and correction as<br />
they explore their emerging<br />
physical, cognitive, social,<br />
and emotional potentials and<br />
construct their emerging individual<br />
identity. Therefore, it is<br />
critical that middle level general<br />
music educates the whole student,<br />
not just his/her cognitive abilities.<br />
TIP 1<br />
Develop or enhance an understanding of young adolescent<br />
development beyond stereotypes associated with<br />
puberty and middle schoolers. These developmental<br />
needs are well-outlined in several music education resources,<br />
for example: Growing <strong>Musician</strong>s: Teaching Music<br />
in Middle School & Beyond by Bridget Sweet (2016)<br />
or Engaging Musical Practices: A Sourcebook for Middle<br />
School General Music edited by Suzanne L. Burton<br />
(2012). Another great resource is the third edition of<br />
What Every Middle School Teacher Should Know by Dave<br />
F. Brown and Trudy Knowles (2014).<br />
MIDDLE LEVEL GENERAL MUSIC HELPS<br />
STUDENTS MAKE CONNECTIONS<br />
Young adolescents vacillate between concrete and abstract thought;<br />
it is critical that middle level general music helps students make<br />
connections. Middle level students’ growing facility with abstract<br />
thought (Mee & Haverback, 2016; Roney, 2005; Stevenson, 2002),<br />
along with their identity development, primes students to question<br />
what they experience in their lives. Although students are developing<br />
abstract thought, they are not always able to make connections<br />
between musical learning and other subjects, current events, or the<br />
community without help. Music teachers can make musical learning<br />
more democratic by explicitly exploring connections for those<br />
who have not yet developed abstract thought or who have not fully<br />
developed the ability to apply abstract thought across contexts.<br />
Music teachers can excite and engage middle level students in any<br />
form of musical learning if they help students see the connections<br />
to their own lives. These connections are the purpose of the “connecting”<br />
strand of the National Core Arts Standards. Doing so does<br />
not sacrifice or water-down musical learning, but rather enhances<br />
it. Taking five minutes to help students see the relevance of what<br />
they are learning can make the music classroom come alive. The<br />
music educator who helps students connect musical content to<br />
their own lives and to what they are learning in other subjects will<br />
find that students become more interested and engaged in musical<br />
learning, further inspiring them to persist musically.<br />
TIP 2<br />
Connect with your colleagues in other subjects to find out<br />
what your students learn at various times of the year. For<br />
example, perhaps the science curriculum includes a unit<br />
on acoustics and sound production. You might choose to<br />
develop a parallel music unit in which students explore<br />
sound production through the creation of invented instruments<br />
or explore acoustics using classroom instruments<br />
in various physical spaces.<br />
Tennessee Music Education Assocation | www.tnmea.org | 43
MIDDLE LEVEL GENERAL MUSIC INTEGRATES<br />
THE STUDENTS’ PERSPECTIVES<br />
As young adolescents mature, they begin to develop a sense of their<br />
place in the world. It is through this important identity development<br />
that young adolescents desire autonomy, independence, and<br />
the opportunity to articulate their own perspectives (Mee & Haverback,<br />
2016; Nakkula & Toshalis, 2006). Consequently, most middle<br />
level students seek teachers who listen to their ideas and views on<br />
almost any topic including the curriculum.<br />
Thus, music teachers might develop curriculum and pedagogy<br />
based on student interests and needs. This does not mean that a<br />
teacher allows students to choose every aspect of learning. However,<br />
it does mean that a music teacher should be attuned to his/her<br />
students and how students’ interests and needs change over time,<br />
both within one school year and with each new group of students.<br />
Accordingly, a democratic curriculum “includes not only what<br />
adults think is important [such as discipline specific knowledge],<br />
but also the questions and concerns that young people have about<br />
themselves and their world” (Beane & Apple, 2007, p. 17). When<br />
young adolescents are given opportunities to direct, co-construct,<br />
or choose learning activities, the outcome is typically a classroom of<br />
students highly engaged in a learning process they helped develop.<br />
evaluation of recorded and live performances, create music through<br />
play, improvisation, and composition, and connect their musical<br />
learning to other areas of their lives (Barrett, 2016). The National<br />
Standards support this notion of comprehensive musical content<br />
in general music (MENC, 1994; SEADAE, 2014). Whether a general<br />
music course explores American rock, Caribbean drumming, Cantonese<br />
opera, and/or Western classical music are decisions best left<br />
to teachers who know their students best. Regardless of the genre(s)<br />
selected, the musical content should allow students to experience<br />
the performing, responding, creating, and connecting components<br />
of music education that form a solid foundation for any future musical<br />
development, whether this future music learning occurs within<br />
or beyond the school walls.<br />
TIP 4<br />
Find out what students already know or what genres<br />
they prefer through a quick survey at the beginning of<br />
the quarter, semester, or year. Ask students about their<br />
musical experiences at home, place of worship, community<br />
center, etc. Then, select from familiar and unfamiliar<br />
musical forms to deepen their musical experiences and<br />
provide them with opportunities to meet the standards.<br />
TIP 3<br />
Ask students to share their own questions about music or<br />
a particular musical topic. Then, work with students to<br />
develop these questions into a unit of study that seeks to<br />
answer these questions. Additionally, have students suggest<br />
ways they might demonstrate their knowledge and<br />
understanding on a particular topic and then allow them<br />
to choose from among the suggestions for the summative<br />
assessment they will complete.<br />
MIDDLE LEVEL GENERAL MUSIC INCLUDES ALL MUSICAL FORMS<br />
Musical skills, genres, and topics covered in middle level general<br />
music should be inclusive and wide-ranging. Carlos Abril (2016)<br />
argues that “if the musical experiences in school music are singular<br />
and rigid, they fall outside of the concept of general music” because<br />
a defining characteristic of general music is the comprehensive<br />
nature of the musical content (p. 15). A middle level general music<br />
curriculum should provide students with an opportunity to engage<br />
with multiple musical forms. Of course, not all musical forms can<br />
be included in a single quarter, semester, or year of study. Teachers<br />
must make judicious choices.<br />
There is a (mis)perception expressed by some music teachers that<br />
general music is focused on singing. While singing is one component<br />
of comprehensive musical content, students should also perform<br />
on body percussion and instruments (whether existing or created<br />
from found objects), respond to music through listening and<br />
ASK YOURSELF: WHAT<br />
ARE YOU DOING<br />
WELL? WHERE ARE<br />
PLACES THAT YOU<br />
MIGHT MAKE SMALL<br />
OR LARGE CHANGES<br />
THAT COULD<br />
SIGNIFICANTLY<br />
IMPACT YOUR<br />
STUDENTS’<br />
ENGAGEMENT?<br />
44 | TENNESSEE MUSICIAN | 2021 | <strong>Vol</strong>ume <strong>73</strong>, <strong>No</strong>. 3
MIDDLE LEVEL GENERAL MUSIC IS FOR EVERYONE<br />
One of the most fundamental democratic principles of general music<br />
is that it is designed as music learning for all. Perhaps you have<br />
heard the often-used phrase from Karl Gerhkens “Music for Every<br />
Child, Every Child for Music” (Munkittrick, 2013). If musical learning<br />
is for every student, then middle level general music should also<br />
include all students. In fact, the 2015 Every Student Succeeds Act<br />
specifically states that music is an important part of a well-rounded<br />
education for all K-12 students (GovTrack.us, 2015). If all students<br />
are entitled to a well-rounded education, then general music learning<br />
should be available as an option for all students.<br />
Adherence to this democratic principle challenges music educators<br />
because it means teaching those students with no expressed desire<br />
to enroll in music alongside those with longstanding interest<br />
in music. Often, students enrolled in general music are not given<br />
a choice, but rather required to enroll. While music teachers often<br />
have no control over their schedule or course enrollments, all music<br />
teachers can decide how students are included in their classroom<br />
community. The creation of an inclusive classroom community is<br />
critical to cultivating student engagement in musical learning.<br />
TIP 5<br />
Develop a classroom community in which all students<br />
feel comfortable and supported to take risks and try new<br />
things. Differentiation is key in a heterogenous classroom.<br />
Consider how you might group students during an<br />
activity so that strong students can help those who need<br />
support. Perhaps rethink a beloved assignment in order<br />
to provide differentiation to challenge or support those<br />
who need it.<br />
CONCLUSION<br />
Building a middle level general music curriculum with the developmental<br />
needs of young adolescents at the center begins with the<br />
five democratic principles discussed above. Relatedly, ask yourself:<br />
What are you doing well? Where are places that you might make<br />
small or large changes that could significantly impact your students’<br />
engagement? Make at least one thoughtful change in the next<br />
school year. As student engagement increases, I hope that you find<br />
yourself looking forward to your middle level general music classes<br />
and to the invigorating potential of guiding students along their individual<br />
musical journeys.<br />
Reprinted from the April 2020 issue (<strong>Vol</strong>. 74, <strong>No</strong>. 3) of the TEMPO<br />
Magazine with permission from the New Jersey Music Educators<br />
Association.<br />
DR. STEPHANIE CRONENBERG, Assistant Professor<br />
of Music, was appointed to the Mason<br />
Gross School of the Arts faculty at Rutgers,<br />
The State University of New Jersey, in<br />
2016. She teaches undergraduate courses in<br />
music education with an emphasis on general<br />
music methods and graduate courses<br />
in research and pedagogy. As the Director<br />
of Clinical Experience and Practice, Dr. Cronenberg oversees all<br />
aspects of the undergraduate music education certification process.<br />
Dr. Cronenberg specializes in narrative and mixed methods<br />
approaches to social inquiry. Her research interests emerge from<br />
her teaching practice and currently focus on three primary strands:<br />
middle level general music, mixed methods research practices, and<br />
current teacher education practices. Her 2016 mixed methods dissertation,<br />
Music at the Middle: Principles that Guide Middle Level<br />
General Music Teachers, received third place in the 2017 Outstanding<br />
Dissertation Award Competition hosted by the AERA Mixed<br />
Methods Special Interest Group. Her specific research projects<br />
focus on the teaching of general music at the middle level (grades<br />
5-8) and methodological implementation of the dialectic stance in<br />
mixed methods inquiry. Her work on middle level general music<br />
has been published in several journals including the Bulletin for<br />
the Council on Research in Music Education and the International<br />
Journal of Music Education. Her work in mixed methods has been<br />
published in the Journal of Mixed Methods Research and the International<br />
Journal of Research and Method in Education. Dr. Cronenberg<br />
is currently working on a book for music teachers focused on<br />
middle level general music.<br />
Prior to her appointment at Rutgers University, Dr. Cronenberg<br />
taught 7th and 8th grade general music at Campus Middle School<br />
for Girls as well as undergraduate and graduate courses at the College<br />
of Education and School of Music at the University of Illinois<br />
at Urbana-Champaign. Prior to 2011, she served as Director of Education<br />
and Community Programs at The Choral Arts Society of<br />
Washington (D.C.) and taught 4th through 7th grade general music<br />
at Holton-Arms School in Bethesda, MD.<br />
REFERENCES<br />
Abril, C. R. (2016). Untangling general music education: Concept,<br />
aims, and practice. In C. R. Abril & B. M. Gault (Eds.), Teaching<br />
general music: Approaches, issues, and viewpoints (pp. 5–22).<br />
New York, NY: Oxford University Press.<br />
Allsup, R. E. (2016). Remixing the classroom: Toward an open philosophy<br />
of music education. Bloomington, IN: Indiana University<br />
Press.<br />
Barrett, J. R. (2016). Adopting an interdisciplinary approach to general<br />
music. In C. R. Abril & B. M. Gault (Eds.), Teaching general<br />
music: Approaches, issues, and viewpoints (pp. 168–182). New<br />
York, NY: Oxford University Press.<br />
Beane, J. A., & Apple, M. W. (2007). The case for democratic schools.<br />
In M. W. Apple & J. A. Beane (Eds.), Democratic schools: Lessons<br />
in powerful education (2nd ed., pp. 1–29). Portsmouth, NH:<br />
Heinemann.<br />
Brown, D. F., & Knowles, T. (2014). What every middle school teacher<br />
should know (3rd ed.). Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann.<br />
Tennessee Music Education Assocation | www.tnmea.org | 45
Burton, S. L. (Ed.) (2012). Engaging musical practices: A sourcebook<br />
for middle school general music. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield<br />
Education.<br />
DeLorenzo, L. C. (2016). Introduction. In L. S. DeLorenzo (Ed.), Giving<br />
voice to democracy in music education: Diversity and social<br />
justice (pp. 1–9). New York, NY: Routledge.<br />
Elliott, D. J. (2016). Artistic citizenship, personhood, and music education.<br />
In L. C. DeLorenzo (Ed.), Giving voice to democracy in<br />
music education: Diversity and social justice (pp. 13–35). New<br />
York, NY: Routledge.<br />
GovTrack.us. (2015). S. 1177 — 114th Congress: Every Student Succeeds<br />
Act. Retrieved from https://www.govtrack.us/congress/<br />
bills/114/s1177<br />
Mee, M., & Haverback, H. R. (2016). Young adolescent development.<br />
In S. B. Mertens, M. M. Caskey, & N. Flowers (Eds.), The<br />
encyclopedia of middle grades education (2nd ed., pp. 437–440).<br />
Charlotte, NC: Information Age Publishing.<br />
MENC. (1994). National standards for arts education: What every<br />
young American should know and be able to do in the arts. Lanham,<br />
MD: Rowman & Littlefield Education.<br />
Michelli, N. M., & Jacobowitz, T. (2016). Why do we educate in a democracy?:<br />
Implications for music education. In L. C. DeLorenzo<br />
(Ed.), Giving voice to democracy in music education: Diversity<br />
and social justice (pp. 36–50). New York, NY: Routledge.<br />
Munkittrick, D. (2013). Music for living: The thought and philosophy<br />
of Karl. W. Gehrkens. Journal of Historical Research in Music<br />
Education, 35(1), 21–34.<br />
Nakkula, M. J., & Toshalis, E. (2006). Understanding youth: Adolescent<br />
development for educators. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Education<br />
Press.<br />
National Middle School Association (NMSA). (2010). This we believe:<br />
Keys to educating young adolescents. Westerville, OH: Author.<br />
Roney, K. (2005). Young adolescent development. In V. A. Anfara,<br />
Jr., G. Andrews, & S. B. Mertens (Eds.) The encyclopedia of middle<br />
grades education (pp. 397–401). Westerville, OH: National<br />
Middle School Association.<br />
State Education Agency Directors of Arts Education (SEADAE).<br />
(2014). National Core Arts Standards. Dover, DE: Author.<br />
Stevenson, C. (2002). Teaching ten to fourteen year olds (3rd ed.).<br />
Boston, MA: Allyn & Bacon.<br />
Sweet, B. (2016). Growing musicians: Teaching music in middle<br />
school & beyond. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.<br />
Wall, M. P., & Wall, J. K. (2016). Artistic citizenship, personhood,<br />
and music education. In L. S. DeLorenzo (Ed.), Giving voice to<br />
democracy in music education: Diversity and social justice (pp.<br />
123–137). New York, NY: Routledge.<br />
Woodford, P. G. (2005). Democracy and music education: Liberalism,<br />
ethics, and the politics of practice. Bloomington, IN: Indiana<br />
University Press.<br />
46 | TENNESSEE MUSICIAN | 2021 | <strong>Vol</strong>ume <strong>73</strong>, <strong>No</strong>. 3
TMEA BACK THEN<br />
➣ In W. J. Julian’s opening presidential letter for the March 1976<br />
Tennessee <strong>Musician</strong>, Dr. Julian summarized pertinent updates<br />
from MENC (now NAfME). In the latter portion of his message,<br />
Dr. Julian conveyed TMEA’s sympathy regarding the thenrecent<br />
death (December 9, 1975) of historic TMEA music leader<br />
Dr. J. Clark Rhodes.<br />
➣<br />
NOTEWORTHY<br />
A section titled “In Memoriam: Dr. J. Clark Rhodes”<br />
summarized the legacy of Dr. Rhodes and outlined his<br />
contributions to the music profession at large. In addition<br />
to his profound impact in TMEA as the inaugural editor of<br />
the Tennessee <strong>Musician</strong> (1948-1950), Dr. Rhodes served as<br />
a leader for multiple national organizations (such as ACDA<br />
President, 1964-1966) and state-wide organizations (such<br />
as Tennessee State Arts Advisory Committee chairman,<br />
1955-1958) during his lifetime. As eloquently expressed<br />
at the close of this column, “Dr. Rhodes bequeathed an<br />
amazing legacy to all music educators in Tennessee;<br />
it will be an awesome responsibility to sustain and<br />
nurture this charge.”<br />
The TMEA Performing Groups were announced for the thenupcoming<br />
TMEA Convention on April 8-10, 1976:<br />
◆ Tennessee Tech. Tuba Ensemble – R. Winston Morris,<br />
Director.<br />
THE TENNESSEE MUSICIAN (MARCH 1976)<br />
<strong>Vol</strong>ume 28, <strong>No</strong>. 3 – 36 pgs.<br />
W. J. Julian, TMEA President | Lawrence “Pat” Cooney, Editor<br />
➣<br />
➣<br />
◆<br />
◆<br />
◆<br />
◆<br />
◆<br />
◆<br />
Doyle High School Mixed Chorus – John P. Ribble,<br />
Director.<br />
Science Hill High School Band – Jerry Cole, Director.<br />
Carson-Newman College Choir – Charles H. Jones,<br />
Director.<br />
Tennessee Tech. Symphony Band – Dr. Wayne Pegram,<br />
Conductor.<br />
West Hills Elementary Chorus – Hannah McDaniel,<br />
Director.<br />
The University of Tennessee Knoxville Brass Quintet.<br />
The members of this ensemble at the time of the 1976 TMEA<br />
Conference were Edgar Niedens (Trumpet), Steven<br />
Squires (Trumpet), William Bommelje (French Horn),<br />
Don Hough (Trombone), and Sande MacMorran (Tuba).<br />
Clinicians (session presenters) for the 1976 TMEA Convention<br />
were highlighted in this pre-conference publication:<br />
◆ Band – Dr. James Neilson (then-Director of the<br />
Educational Department of the G. Leblanc Corporation)<br />
◆ Choral – Donald Neuen (then-Director of Choral Activities<br />
and Professor of Music at the University of Tennessee<br />
Knoxville) and Charles H. Jones (then-Professor of Music<br />
and Director of Choral Activities at Carson-Newman College)<br />
◆ Elementary – Jeanette Crosswhite (then-Associate<br />
Professor of Music at Milligan College); Nancy Ferguson<br />
(then-Area Music Specialist/Supervisory of the Elementary<br />
Orff Music and String Programs in Memphis City Schools);<br />
Mary Ann Lowe (then-Music Resource Teacher for<br />
Chattanooga Public Schools)<br />
◆ String – William Starr (then-Professor of Music at the<br />
University of Tennessee Knoxville)<br />
◆ Middle School Junior High – Dr. Lawrence Eisman<br />
(then-chairman of the music department at Queens College<br />
in New York City)<br />
A variety of remarkable articles were featured in this issue,<br />
including the following:<br />
◆ “An All-State Jazz Band For Your Students,” by Dr.<br />
Tom Ferguson (then-Director of Bands at Memphis State<br />
University and President-Elect of the National Association<br />
for Jazz Educators)<br />
◆ “Selecting Literature for a Specific Choral Group,” by<br />
James Mintz (then-Assistant Music Education Professor,<br />
University of Tennessee Knoxville)<br />
◆ “A Bicentennial Feature Article: Sacred Harp Singing<br />
in Tennessee,” by Irving Wolfe (then-Emeritus Professor<br />
of Music, Peabody College)<br />
◆ “Four Events Mark March As ‘Music Education<br />
Month’: Music In Our Schools Day; MENC Biennial<br />
Convention; 1976 Youth Music Festival; Showcase of<br />
American Music Education,” included information that<br />
Dr. William D. Revelli (then-Director Emeritus of the<br />
University of Michigan Band) was selected to conduct the<br />
108-Member Honors Band slated to perform on March 13,<br />
1976, at the MENC (now NAfME) National Convention in<br />
Atlantic City, New Jersey.<br />
48 | TENNESSEE MUSICIAN | 2021 | <strong>Vol</strong>ume <strong>73</strong>, <strong>No</strong>. 3
you work hard at<br />
sounding good<br />
we work hard at<br />
looking<br />
good<br />
SLATE GROUP SUPPORTS<br />
MUSIC EDUCATION<br />
THROUGH WHAT WE DO BEST.<br />
PUBLICATION DESIGN<br />
PRINT<br />
DISPLAY GRAPHICS<br />
CONTACT IAN SPECTOR TODAY<br />
800.794.5594 | ian@slategroup.com<br />
slategroup.com
Tennessee Music Education Association<br />
2441-Q Old Fort Pkwy, #635<br />
Murfreesboro, Tennessee 37128-4162<br />
A Christ-centered university in southeast Tennessee<br />
dedicated to preparing tomorrow's musicians.<br />
For audition information & scholarships visit leeuniversity.edu/music