MIT Platform Report 2022
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
RIDING<br />
THE<br />
PLATFORM<br />
WAVE<br />
The <strong>2022</strong> <strong>MIT</strong> <strong>Platform</strong> Strategy Summit tracked<br />
where we’ve been and where we’re heading.
CONTENTS<br />
Ellen Herlacher, principal at LRV Health, was<br />
among the speakers at the first healthcare<br />
platform summit event.<br />
<strong>Platform</strong> Summit co-chairs, from left, Marshall<br />
Van Alstyne, Peter Evans and Geoffrey Parker<br />
04 A Ripple Becomes a Cresting Wave<br />
The 10th annual <strong>MIT</strong> <strong>Platform</strong> Strategy Summit reflected<br />
on a decade-long rise of platforms that have upended<br />
traditional markets and created whole new ecosystems.<br />
06 <strong>Platform</strong>s Opens Up<br />
What a difference a decade makes. Summit co-chairs<br />
Peter Evans, Geoffrey Parker and Marshall Van Alstyne,<br />
along with Elizabeth J. Altman, outline the key trends to<br />
watch.<br />
09 The Tide Turns for Healthcare <strong>Platform</strong>s<br />
Can digital platforms cure and create opportunities for the<br />
U.S. healthcare sector? A half-day program explored both<br />
the tech progress and the regulatory challenges keeping<br />
healthcare on a slow but steady path to platform adoption.<br />
10 <strong>Platform</strong> Review and Forecast<br />
Network effects have played a key role in the rise of<br />
platforms from B2C to B2B sectors. Are the metaverse<br />
and Web3 the next frontiers?<br />
12 Keynote Address<br />
Dr. Alex Ng, VP of China’s Tencent Healthcare, described<br />
a new platform designed to accentuate valid healthcare<br />
information to encourage and improve patient care.<br />
13 The New Digital Divide<br />
Panelists discuss how geopolitical powers differ on the<br />
best ways to approach the digital layers of marketing<br />
systems and platforms.<br />
14 MyLearning NFT<br />
The trouble with training is that people forget much<br />
of what they’ve learned. A new, non-fungible token,<br />
demonstrated by co-founder Hari Abburi, aims to fix this<br />
by financially rewarding continuous training.<br />
15 Web3, Tokens, and <strong>Platform</strong>s<br />
The debate is on: Is Web3 just a collection of niche<br />
products? Or will technologies, including blockchain and<br />
the metaverse, permeate today’s marketplaces?<br />
16 <strong>Platform</strong>s Fuel Enterprise Talent Strategy<br />
<strong>Platform</strong>s promise to connect organizations with qualified<br />
workers. Panelists including Tapaswee Chandele of<br />
Coca-Cola Co. and Anant Argawal of 2U discussed their<br />
progress with internal and external talent platforms—and<br />
what still needs to be done.<br />
17 Fireside Chat: Fidelity Investments<br />
Joanna Rotenberg, president of personal investing<br />
at Fidelity Investments, explains how her group is<br />
adapting to big shifts—technological and otherwise—<br />
in the finance business.<br />
19 The Future of the Retail Experience<br />
Customer data is the big wave in retail. That’s leading to a<br />
new business model that’s based not on selling products,<br />
but instead on providing unique customer experiences.<br />
Executives and analysts take a deep dive into these<br />
immersive ideas.<br />
19 Technology that Serves Society<br />
For a different perspective, Dava Newman, director of the<br />
<strong>MIT</strong> Media Lab, led a journey that brought the internet<br />
deep into the ocean, made oxygen on Mars and implanted<br />
AI into human brains.<br />
20 Resources for the Next Decade<br />
Prepare for the next 10 years of platform revolution with<br />
these books and articles to read and IDE links to explore.<br />
Look for the<br />
icon to watch full sessions<br />
A DECADE OF PLATFORM<br />
PROLIFERATION<br />
Global platforms have become so ubiquitous we barely take<br />
notice: engaging with social media, online shopping and—even<br />
for the reticent—banking and conducting business on sprawling<br />
ecosystems of partners have become the norm.<br />
The <strong>MIT</strong> <strong>Platform</strong> Strategy Summit has tracked this swift economic<br />
transformation for the past 10 years. This year, we look at the past,<br />
present and future of digital platforms, examining how they can<br />
continue to broaden access and opportunities in every sector.<br />
OPENING<br />
REMARKS<br />
The <strong>Platform</strong> Summit on July 14, <strong>2022</strong>,<br />
marked its 10th anniversary as a go-to<br />
source of information, analysis and<br />
forecasts about the rapid-fire changes<br />
of the platform economy. More than<br />
1,000 online and in-person attendees<br />
learned how digital platforms continue<br />
to transform industries, the economy<br />
and workers.<br />
<strong>MIT</strong> IDE Associate Director Devin Cook<br />
welcomed in-person attendees to the 10th<br />
annual <strong>Platform</strong> Summit.<br />
2<br />
3
PLATFORM DECADE IN REVIEW<br />
A RIPPLE BECOMES<br />
A CRESTING WAVE<br />
The <strong>MIT</strong> <strong>Platform</strong> Strategy Summit celebrates its 10th anniversary this<br />
year. Here’s a quick look at the last decade of Summit events and all-star<br />
participants, courtesy of Summit co-chair Geoffrey Parker.<br />
2013<br />
The first <strong>MIT</strong> <strong>Platform</strong> Summit was organized by<br />
“platform evangelists”– young academics who<br />
developed a theory to solve the pricing puzzle of<br />
“free” software and related business models. Google,<br />
Facebook, Amazon and Netflix were testing the<br />
platform waters.<br />
2017<br />
As platforms gained traction, the Summit attracted<br />
speakers from the mainstream finance industry<br />
and incumbent organizations, including GE Global<br />
Research, Philips, SAP and Schlumberger.<br />
2020<br />
Due to the COVID-19<br />
pandemic, the Summit<br />
pivoted to an online-only<br />
format. Nevertheless,<br />
platform leaders from<br />
Intuit, Mayo Clinic and<br />
Ping An Bank addressed<br />
global concerns and<br />
challenges.<br />
2014<br />
Gaining global momentum and sharing knowledge,<br />
the Summit attracted Ming Zeng, chief strategy<br />
officer of China’s (then) leading platform, Alibaba,<br />
and speakers from Deloitte, Upwork and others.<br />
2018<br />
This Summit highlighted the platform-transformation<br />
vanguard, including Airbnb and Uber, and also legacy<br />
brands Kaiser Permanente, Rolls-Royce and Siemens.<br />
2021<br />
The Summit was online-only for a second year.<br />
Mainstream organizations continued to make the<br />
platform transition, while others—such as EVgo<br />
and entertainment platforms—took the plunge as<br />
platform natives.<br />
2016<br />
2015<br />
Drilling down into infrastructure issues, the Summit<br />
drew a diverse group of executives from Cognizant,<br />
Duolingo, edX and Samsung as well as other<br />
platform innovators.<br />
The tide continued to rise with the publication of <strong>Platform</strong><br />
Revolution by Geoffrey Parker, Marshall Van Alstyne and<br />
Sangeet Paul Choudary—heading to a second edition.<br />
Peter Evans and Annabelle Gawer also published “The<br />
Rise of the <strong>Platform</strong> Enterprise,” the first global survey of<br />
platform companies.<br />
2019<br />
Policy presentations by the U.S. Army and the<br />
Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency<br />
added some sobering perspectives to the heady pace<br />
of change. In addition, Amazon Web Services, eBay<br />
and Facebook offered insights on staying afloat.<br />
<strong>2022</strong><br />
The Summit goes hybrid, returning to <strong>MIT</strong>’s campus<br />
with in-person and virtual attendees. As platform<br />
ranks swell, panels examined what’s next for<br />
Web3, regulation, labor markets and healthcare.<br />
Investments continue to break records.<br />
4<br />
5
Summit co-chair Geoffrey Parker took attendees<br />
through 10 years of platform progress and<br />
examined where it’s headed in the next decade..<br />
reassure ourselves we weren’t crazy. These business<br />
models are real, and they will have a significant impact on<br />
the world economy.”<br />
Fast-forward 10 years and the accuracy of the hypothesis is<br />
undeniable. As more than 150 in-person plus nearly a thousand<br />
online attendees of this year’s summit heard, platforms are<br />
now transforming—or poised to transform—entire industries<br />
as well as HR and marketing.<br />
“In this environment, which is changing at unprecedented and<br />
unexpected levels, agility and the productive use of data is<br />
more important than ever,” said Svenja Falk, managing director<br />
of Accenture Research and one of the day’s moderators. But<br />
new issues have surfaced as platforms proliferate, too.<br />
Stretching the Global Boundaries<br />
Falk’s panel explored several regulatory and geopolitical<br />
barriers to sharing data. One factor raising these barriers: The<br />
U.S., European Union and China each have very different ideas<br />
about how—or whether—data should be shared.<br />
Panelist Peter Weckesser, chief digital officer of Schneider<br />
Electric, pointed out that in a traditional business like his,<br />
data operates in two dimensions: internally, where data needs<br />
to be accessible for insights across the organization; and<br />
externally, as part of an open platform. That’s why Schneider<br />
is experimenting with a new practice it calls “power couples,”<br />
in which data projects are co-owned by both business-process<br />
and IT platform leaders. “The data layer,” Weckesser added, “is<br />
the foundation for any business process.”<br />
Far from daily business constraints, prognosticators<br />
anticipated what Web3 might bring in the not-too-distant<br />
future. Led by Peter Evans, managing partner of the <strong>Platform</strong><br />
Strategy Institute and a Summit co-chair, the panel debated<br />
blockchain, the metaverse, AI, virtual reality and more. To date,<br />
they’ve attracted both advocates and skeptics.<br />
“The metaverse is a set of possibilities and promises, but it<br />
doesn’t exist yet,” said Lauren Lubetsky, co-author of a recent<br />
Deloitte white paper on the topic. “It’s hard to imagine a world<br />
of complete decentralization, where everyone owns everything<br />
and no one is the central owner. That scares CIOs.”<br />
At the same time, others noted that many businesses are<br />
already experimenting with Web3 technologies. “We’re always<br />
looking for new technologies that could displace current<br />
technologies,” said Adam Schouela, head of emerging tech at<br />
the Fidelity Center for Applied Technology. “Then we roll up our<br />
sleeves, try it, and figure out what it means for us.”<br />
The Retail Experience<br />
The platform landscape varies among industries and follows<br />
economic trends. For example, a panel on the future of retail<br />
included a fascinating emphasis on experiential marketing. To<br />
Jonathan Yaffee, a former marketing executive with Red Bull<br />
and currently co-founder and CEO of experience relationship<br />
management agency AnyRoad, “We’re transforming from a<br />
‘things’ economy to an ‘experience’ economy.”<br />
Yaffee and others cited Dick’s Sporting Goods, which has<br />
turned its stores into sports places; Nike, which has outfitted<br />
some of its retail stores with basketball courts; and Michaels<br />
Companies, which created an online arts-and-crafts teaching<br />
platform that reaches more than 1 million students a year.<br />
These platforms not only create communities of loyal (and bigspending)<br />
customers, they also provide the companies with<br />
all-important data about those customers. As Yaffee explained,<br />
businesses can then use that data to predict a customer’s<br />
lifetime value, the new metric of success. The physical stores<br />
are less about product sales—which can be done online—than<br />
building on these experiences.<br />
REVIEW<br />
PLATFORMS<br />
OPEN UP<br />
It’s taken a decade for organizations to stop hoarding their<br />
data and start sharing it. After years of watching and waiting,<br />
mainstream organizations in a wide range of industries—<br />
including education, manufacturing, finance and retail—are<br />
finally getting on board with platform markets that unlock<br />
data’s value.<br />
That was a central theme of this year’s <strong>MIT</strong> <strong>Platform</strong> Strategy<br />
Summit, a hybrid live/online event hosted on July 14, <strong>2022</strong>,<br />
by the <strong>MIT</strong> Initiative on the Digital Economy (IDE). Leading<br />
organizations have tapped into the power of platforms, using<br />
open APIs and other applications to share data in internal<br />
and external ecosystems. As a result, they’re benefitting from<br />
The <strong>2022</strong> <strong>MIT</strong> <strong>Platform</strong> Strategy Summit<br />
tracked the rise of open data and<br />
business transformation.<br />
network effects and revolutionizing markets as diverse as<br />
social media, electric vehicles and healthcare.<br />
While platforms are still emerging in a few sectors, they’re<br />
vastly more accepted than they were a decade ago. That’s<br />
when Geoffrey Parker, a professor of engineering at Dartmouth<br />
College, and Marshall Van Alstyne, a professor of information<br />
economics at Boston University, realized that the rise of online<br />
companies such as Amazon, Facebook and Google resulted<br />
from their new business models based on platforms.<br />
“One reason we launched this event,” said Parker, a Summit cochair<br />
and research fellow at the IDE, “was to create a forum to<br />
Hard platform problems have one underlying<br />
cause: Network effects (NFX)<br />
Understanding NFX gives power to explain, predict and control<br />
1<br />
2<br />
3<br />
4<br />
Structure/ Why do platforms have such high market cap but so few assets or employees?<br />
NFX drive inverted firms that harness external products and assets not usually counted on balance<br />
sheets.<br />
Strategy/ Why does traditional product strategy fail in platform markets?<br />
NFX mean community is a key asset. <strong>Platform</strong>s want community, permissionless entry, not<br />
competitor barriers to entry.<br />
Regulation/ Why does antitrust fail in platform markets?<br />
NFX increase in scale, not in breakup or splitting across competitors.<br />
Fake news/ Why is misinformation such a hard problem?<br />
NFX cause market failures, which need interventions not allowed by First Amendment speech<br />
protections.<br />
5 Future/ Can decentralized autonomous organizations (DAOs) dethrone platforms?<br />
NFX require governance, which most DAOs don’t provide.<br />
6<br />
7
HEALTHCARE AND PLATFORMS<br />
THE TIDE TURNS FOR<br />
HEALTHCARE PLATFORMS<br />
During the inaugural healthcare platform summit, speakers bemoaned the industry’s<br />
lack of platform progress, but expressed hope for future investments and regulations.<br />
More than 150 in-person attendees were able to interact with peers and<br />
appreciate the lessons learned during two days of sessions.<br />
PLATFORMS OPEN UP CONTINUED<br />
Learning New Lessons<br />
Additionally, platforms for education and training were a<br />
hot topic—and one close to home for the academics at the<br />
event. “Can universities become platforms?” asked moderator<br />
Marshall Van Alstyne, a professor at Boston University and a<br />
Summit co-chair. “Or are [universities] doomed to shrink?”<br />
Chris Dellarocas, Associate Provost for Digital Learning at<br />
Boston University, thinks the big brand universities will win<br />
and small universities will only survive by specializing in niche<br />
content. The university trump card is a deep relationship with<br />
students that they should continue as lifelong learning centers.<br />
The question is more than hypothetical. Anant Agarwal is<br />
the founder of edX and now chief open education officer of<br />
2U, a global online learning platform. His company’s more<br />
than 4,000 courses have reached over 44 million learners<br />
worldwide. There should be fewer universities, he believes.<br />
“The teaching model is changing,” Agarwal said. “The old<br />
lecture model of a ‘sage on a stage’ can be done more<br />
effectively online.” But coaching of students is still done<br />
side-by-side in person. That hybrid approach is “the future of<br />
education,” in his view.<br />
Tapaswee Chandele, Coca-Cola Co.’s global VP of talent<br />
and development, provided a corporate perspective. The<br />
giant multinational company takes its platform approach so<br />
seriously that it has created a platform services organization<br />
and is now launching an internal talent marketplace. “Skills<br />
have become currency,” Chandele said.<br />
Investing in the Future<br />
A chat between co-chair Geoffrey Parker and Joanna<br />
Rotenberg, president of personal investing at Fidelity<br />
Investments, showed how high the platform stakes are for<br />
legacy corporations. Rotenberg’s group handles investments<br />
for one in every six Americans and is responsible for some<br />
$4 trillion in assets under management.<br />
Rotenberg and her associates find many traditional<br />
transactions at the 75-year-old company are outdated.<br />
Today’s young customers won’t phone a Fidelity agent, nor<br />
will they personally visit their local office. Instead, they expect<br />
to transact with Fidelity via their PCs, tablets and smartphones,<br />
often over social media. “We’ve got to meet our clients of<br />
today—and tomorrow—where they are,” Rotenberg said.<br />
The Summit was capped by a mind-expanding presentation<br />
by Dava Newman, director of the <strong>MIT</strong> Media Lab. She<br />
discussed such far-out topics as the search for life elsewhere<br />
in the universe, making oxygen on Mars, a concept known as<br />
Earth Embassy (complete with its own operating system), and<br />
plans to surgically implant AI systems in the human brain. “It’s<br />
all about design and action for the future we want to live in,”<br />
Newman said.<br />
Searching for life in outer space certainly isn’t among the<br />
daily concerns of most businesspeople. But it illustrates that<br />
when data is open and shared, it can finally deliver on its<br />
promise of value.<br />
The U.S. healthcare sector could use a dose of its<br />
own medicine to cure its high costs, poor access and<br />
bureaucratic lethargy. Could the elixir involve digital<br />
platforms?<br />
That was a main topic at the inaugural <strong>Platform</strong> Revolution<br />
Comes to Healthcare event, held on July 13 as a new spinoff<br />
of the <strong>MIT</strong> <strong>Platform</strong> Strategy Summit.<br />
The upshot? “Healthcare is more than a decade behind<br />
other industries in [platform] adoption,” said Vince Kuraitis,<br />
principal and founder of consultants Better Health<br />
Technologies. He cited a 2015 study by consultants<br />
McKinsey & Co. showing that when it came to digital<br />
adoption, healthcare ranked a poor 19 among 22 industries.<br />
One serious hurdle to greater adoption is the simple force<br />
of habit. Pharmaceutical salespeople are used to freely<br />
walking into doctors’ offices, patients are used to going<br />
to doctors they know, and doctors are used to making<br />
referrals to their peers. “It’s all very personal and hard<br />
to break,” said Adam Grossman, a partner in healthcare<br />
investment firm Deerfield Management Co. Tight regulation<br />
is another longstanding obstacle.<br />
Sea Changes Coming<br />
Nonetheless, the industry’s tides are turning and evolution<br />
is under way. Healthcare is “beginning to understand<br />
the economic power and value of exchanging data,” said<br />
Randall Williams, managing director of consulting firm<br />
Digital Care Advisors.<br />
Evidence comes in the form of growing investment. Nearly<br />
$30 billion in capital worldwide was invested in 2021, an<br />
increase over the previous year of 25%, according to seed<br />
fund Rock Health.<br />
Even the U.S. government, known for its sluggish<br />
bureaucracy, understands the value proposition platforms<br />
offer for better medical care and data access. Starting later<br />
this year, the U.S. Fast Healthcare Interaction Regulation<br />
(FHIR, pronounced “fire”) will require all certified healthcare<br />
providers to make their electronic health record APIs<br />
available to others.<br />
“We’re still a long way from perfect integration,” admitted<br />
Micky Tripathi, national coordinator for health IT at the U.S.<br />
Dept. of Health and Human Services. “But standardization<br />
is improving, and the ecosystem is opening up.”<br />
Rapid Growth<br />
of <strong>Platform</strong><br />
Investments<br />
12%<br />
41%<br />
DIGITAL HEALTH<br />
INVESTMENTS<br />
2017<br />
2021<br />
88%<br />
59%<br />
HEALTHCARE<br />
INVESTMENTS<br />
In 2021, platforms accounted for 41% of digital<br />
health investments compared with 12% in 2017.<br />
In additon, one-third of the CB Insights Top 150<br />
digital health companies are platforms.<br />
Source: Summit Health, <strong>Platform</strong>s in Digital Health, 2021<br />
Year-end <strong>Report</strong><br />
8<br />
9
PANEL<br />
PLATFORM REVIEW<br />
AND FORECAST<br />
Elizabeth J. Altman Assistant Professor, Manning School of<br />
Business, University of Massachusetts, Lowell<br />
Peter C. Evans Managing Partner, <strong>Platform</strong> Strategy Institute;<br />
<strong>Platform</strong> Strategy Summit Co-Chair<br />
Geoffrey Parker Professor of Engineering, Dartmouth College;<br />
Visiting Scholar, <strong>MIT</strong> IDE; <strong>Platform</strong> Strategy Summit Co-Chair<br />
Marshall Van Alstyne Questrom Professor of Management,<br />
Questrom School of Business, Boston University; Visiting Scholar,<br />
<strong>MIT</strong> IDE; <strong>Platform</strong> Strategy Summit Co-Chair<br />
“My goal today has been<br />
to give you one simple<br />
idea: Network effects give<br />
you the power to explain<br />
what has happened,<br />
predict what will happen,<br />
and control the outcome.”<br />
Marshall Van Alstyne<br />
The Summit’s academic organizers gave high-level<br />
overviews of the platform revolution and its impact.<br />
Geoffrey Parker described his own revelation around<br />
2005 when he and his colleagues noticed that a group<br />
of fast-charging new companies, including Amazon,<br />
Facebook and Google, were operating with new business<br />
models. And unlike the failed models of the dot-com<br />
crash, these models made sense and could be selfsustaining.<br />
They were platforms. Going forward, expect<br />
B2B platforms to adopt the same focus on reducing<br />
transaction costs and increasing network effects just as<br />
B2C platforms have done.<br />
Manning School professor Elizabeth Altman emphasized<br />
how platforms are transforming the workforce. Today, up<br />
to half an organization’s employees can be contractors,<br />
freelancers, consultants and gig workers. These workers are<br />
increasingly hired and connected on platform ecosystems,<br />
she noted.<br />
Peter Evans said the rise of Web3 is already playing a<br />
central role in three platform examples: crypto exchanges,<br />
NFT marketplaces and metaverse worlds. Many are growing<br />
rapidly. For example, tokens for just three metaverse<br />
platforms—Decentraland, Sandbox, and Otherside—have a<br />
market capitalization of $4.3 billion. Additionally, Web3 is<br />
beginning to reshape the way brands engage customers.<br />
Nike’s Nikeland store, set up in the Roblox virtual<br />
environment, attracted 6.7 million visitors in its first four<br />
months and is now an experience in Nike’s New York store.<br />
A combination of virtual worlds and non-fungible tokens will<br />
power new platform experiences, Evans said.<br />
Marshall Van Alstyne said that most platform roadblocks<br />
have a single underlying cause: network effects or<br />
“externalities.” For example, why is platform strategy so<br />
different from product firms? The orchestration of positive<br />
externalities means inviting value producers onto the<br />
platform rather than building barriers to keep them out.<br />
Why is fake news such a difficult problem to solve? Mainly,<br />
because the negative externalities occur off-platform.<br />
These externalities create market failures that in turn<br />
require intervention. The tricky issue is to address these<br />
concerns while maintaining free speech. To break this<br />
impasse, he expects, new forms of regulation or laws will<br />
be required.<br />
Emerging Trends<br />
Elizabeth Altman of the Manning School<br />
explained how platforms can transform<br />
the workforce.<br />
Web3/ The true economics of cryptocurrencies and<br />
the metaverse will become clearer in the next few years.<br />
Regulation/ Data privacy and security issues will remain<br />
top-of-mind. Labor markets/ Hiring and the nature of<br />
work itself will continue to transform. Sector growth/<br />
No industry or sector is immune to platform incursion.<br />
10<br />
11
The Tencent Healthcare platform provides<br />
impartial, fact-checked medical information<br />
using WeChat and other social media to reach<br />
hundreds of millions of patients in China. The<br />
platform also offers live streaming with doctors<br />
and medical professionals.<br />
Dr. Alex Ng<br />
Vice President, Tencent Healthcare<br />
KEYNOTE<br />
HOW TENCENT<br />
FIGHTS MEDICAL<br />
MISINFORMATION<br />
Tencent Healthcare, a unit of China-based conglomerate Tencent<br />
Holdings and a service platform on that company’s WeChat service,<br />
set out to solve one big problem, then quickly found itself battling<br />
another. The first problem was the general malaise of Chinese<br />
healthcare. Dr. Ng, who is also a physician, explained that China is<br />
plagued by imbalances between supply and demand, long waiting<br />
times for care, complex processes, and crowded hospitals.<br />
But just as Tencent began testing its medical app, the COVID-19<br />
pandemic hit, accompanied by a great deal of medical<br />
misinformation. At that point, Tencent shifted its primary platform<br />
focus to establish an authoritative source of information as a way to<br />
fight misinformation. The new resource offers fact-checked travel and<br />
health information, including articles, videos and animations.<br />
“What we can<br />
actually do is drown<br />
out misinformation<br />
by offering a<br />
centralized source<br />
of good information.<br />
Everything has been<br />
verified and triplechecked<br />
by our<br />
editors and in-house<br />
doctors to make<br />
sure the information<br />
we provide is true;<br />
information that’s<br />
comfortable for my<br />
mom to read.”<br />
Dr. Alex Ng<br />
PANEL<br />
THE NEW<br />
DIGITAL DIVIDE<br />
Peggy Gulick Director of Digital Transformation Operations, Kohler Co.<br />
Peter Weckesser Chief Digital Officer, Schneider Electric<br />
Helmuth Ludwig former CIO of Siemens; Professor, Edwin Cox School<br />
of Business, Southern Methodist University<br />
Supheakmungkol “Mungkol” Sarin Head of Data and AI Ecosystems,<br />
World Economic Forum<br />
Svenja Falk Panel Moderator; Managing Director, Accenture Research<br />
This panel was based on research conducted over the past year<br />
with a simple premise: Every physical system has a digital layer.<br />
In addition, the major geopolitical powers—specifically, China, the<br />
European Union, and the U.S.—have dramatically different ideas about<br />
how this digital layer should be designed.<br />
Reflecting their diverse backgrounds, the panelists addressed global<br />
disparities with a wide spectrum of ideas. Among their common<br />
concerns and priorities are: How to scale innovation; how to monetize<br />
data; and what a successful platform ecosystem looks like.<br />
Svenja Falk of Accenture Research (at left) led<br />
a lively panel on scaling innovation, monetizing<br />
data and more.<br />
“We need to make<br />
sure that some<br />
of the largest<br />
companies share<br />
their best practices<br />
around data. What<br />
is the data principle?<br />
What is their data<br />
governance? Those<br />
best practices can be<br />
shared and learned.”<br />
Mungkol Sarin<br />
12<br />
13
Hari Abburi, co-founder of MyLearningNFT,<br />
explains why learning needs to be<br />
continual—and how it can be driven by a<br />
dynamic non-fungible token.<br />
Hari Abburi<br />
Co-Founder, MyLearningNFT<br />
Managing Partner, The Preparation Co.<br />
PRESENTATION<br />
MYLEARNINGNFT<br />
“You have two challenges.<br />
Challenge number one is how<br />
do you know the participants<br />
[of a training event] keep on<br />
learning? We have no idea.<br />
The second challenge is<br />
that you have the forgetting<br />
curve. And it’s very real.”<br />
Hari Abburi<br />
Every year, nearly $200 billion is spent in the United<br />
States on employee training and development.<br />
However, the results aren’t obvious when it comes to<br />
what people learn in those trainings, how much they<br />
actually remember and use, and how much value<br />
businesses get from their huge investments.<br />
Hari Abburi and his colleagues at MyLearningNFT<br />
(including Peter Evans) believe they have the answer.<br />
They’ve created a dynamic non-fungible token (NFT)<br />
that motivates holders to learn something every 90<br />
days. The approach is now in pilot testing, and Summit<br />
attendees were invited to join the limited, free test.<br />
The underlying idea is that the most effective way<br />
to address the “forgetting curve” is with continual<br />
training. In other words, receive basic training, then<br />
augment it with additional learning, whether by reading<br />
a book or article on a related topic, attending a class,<br />
or listening to a podcast or webinar.<br />
Participants in MyLearningNFT receive tokenized<br />
certificates that gain or lose value based on the<br />
learning actions they take after a training course<br />
or event. If a participant takes no action, their NFT<br />
degrades. But if they take learning actions, such as<br />
listening to a relevant podcast or reading a related<br />
article, their NFT appreciates. The NFT provides a<br />
mechanism to reward continuous learning and ward<br />
off the depreciation of knowledge associated with the<br />
natural effects of forgetting. All participants at the<br />
<strong>MIT</strong> <strong>Platform</strong> Strategy Summit were eligible to receive<br />
a dynamic learning NFT to encourage continuous<br />
learning about platforms.<br />
PANEL<br />
WEB3, TOKENIZATION,<br />
AND PLATFORMS<br />
Lauren Lubetsky Strategy Manager, Monitor Deloitte<br />
Tim Rice Co-founding CEO, CoinMetrics<br />
Skip Roncal Global Lead, Salesforce & AWS Solutions, CME and Gaming<br />
Industries, Salesforce.com<br />
Adam Schouela Head of Emerging Technologies, Fidelity Center for<br />
Applied Technology<br />
Peter C. Evans Panel Moderator<br />
“There’s been $120 billion<br />
invested this year in the<br />
metaverse and Web3.<br />
That’s more than double what<br />
we saw invested last year.”<br />
Lauren Lubetsky<br />
Web3 enters the mainstream<br />
Crypto<br />
Cryptocurrencies held by 300 million<br />
people across Asia, North and South<br />
America, Europe and Africa<br />
Investment<br />
Venture capital firms invested $33<br />
billion in Web3 startups in 2021<br />
How will Web3—a catchall term for new<br />
technologies including blockchain and<br />
the metaverse—affect platforms? The<br />
conversation also addressed the related<br />
issues around Web3 products: are they<br />
niche only, or are they headed for<br />
the mainstream?<br />
Lauren Lubetsky at Monitor Deloitte sees<br />
both Web3 bulls and bears. And because<br />
Web3 technologies are still so new, she<br />
believes both sides can learn a lot from<br />
each other.<br />
Fidelity not only looks for emerging<br />
technologies but actually rolls up its<br />
collective sleeves to build them, said Adam<br />
Schouela about his group at the financial<br />
services provider. His team believes<br />
experimentation is the only way to determine<br />
whether a new technology can help Fidelity,<br />
and if so, how.<br />
CoinMetrics’ Tim Rice explained how<br />
blockchain technology can be used to verify<br />
the ownership of Bitcoin or other digital<br />
currencies, what he referred to as asset<br />
provenance. “If you want to understand if your<br />
address has Bitcoin on it, we have the tools<br />
for you to see that,” he said.<br />
Salesforce is exploring the use of eventstreaming<br />
architectures currently employed<br />
by gaming companies to better understand<br />
its own customers, according to Skip Roncal.<br />
The goal: a unified view of customers across<br />
both physical and virtual worlds. “If you look<br />
over the history of our platform,” he said, “you<br />
can see that most of our innovations were<br />
customer-driven.”<br />
NFTs<br />
Non-fungible tokens (NFTs) transaction<br />
volume grew to $40 billion in 2021<br />
Mergers & Acquisition<br />
Microsoft acquired Activision Blizzard for<br />
$68.7 billion to enhance its metaverse plans<br />
14<br />
15
Panel moderator Marshall Van Alstyne (left) listens as<br />
Tapaswee Chandele describes Coca-Cola’s dedicated<br />
<strong>Platform</strong> Services organization.<br />
“Companies need<br />
to focus on lifelong<br />
learning for their<br />
employees. And<br />
individuals need to<br />
focus on continually<br />
refreshing themselves,<br />
rather than living on<br />
degrees they earned<br />
30 or 40 years ago.”<br />
Anant Agarwal<br />
Joanna Rotenberg of Fidelity tells moderator Geoffrey<br />
Parker, “We have to meet clients where they are.”<br />
PANEL<br />
PLATFORMS POWER<br />
ENTERPRISE TALENT<br />
STRATEGY<br />
Anant Agarwal Founder, edX; Professor, <strong>MIT</strong>; Chief Open<br />
Education Officer, 2U<br />
Tapaswee Chandele Global VP of Talent and Development,<br />
Coca-Cola Co.<br />
Chris Dellarocas Associate Provost for Digital Learning and<br />
Innovation, Boston University<br />
Patrick Petitti Co-founder and CEO, Catalant Technologies<br />
Marshall Van Alstyne Panel Moderator<br />
This panel discussed how platforms are changing<br />
education and what the implications for established<br />
universities are. Can they become platforms, or are<br />
they doomed to shrink?<br />
Chris Dellarocas is bullish on platform adoption.<br />
Universities not only match students with programs,<br />
they also develop deep relationships with those<br />
students. That needn’t stop with graduation, he said.<br />
Boston University, for example, has some 350,000<br />
alumni who could potentially become lifelong career<br />
coaches offering programs and support.<br />
Anant Agarwal agreed, but also argued against allowing<br />
each university to create its own platform. “That would<br />
just duplicate the crazy situation we’ve had for 300<br />
years,” he said. A better approach, he added, would be<br />
the creation of an open-source consortium.<br />
In the private sector, Pat Petitti explained Catalant is<br />
already creating a platform that matches independent<br />
consultants with organizations that need very targeted<br />
help. The company says its customers enjoy 30% to<br />
50% savings compared to what they’d spend engaging<br />
a larger consulting firm.<br />
At Coca-Cola, Tapaswee Chandele is committed to<br />
platform models via a dedicated <strong>Platform</strong> Services<br />
organization. The company is also about to launch<br />
a talent marketplace using a platform previously<br />
developed for another use.<br />
FIRESIDE CHAT<br />
MAKING INVESTMENT<br />
PERSONAL<br />
Joanna Rotenberg President of Personal Investing, Fidelity Investments<br />
Geoffrey Parker Panel Moderator<br />
Joanna Rotenberg explained how her group, which<br />
helps retail customers with their personal investments,<br />
is adapting to big market shifts caused by the rise of AI,<br />
blockchain, and 5G. On top of that, half of Americans<br />
are now millennials or younger, and they spend a lot<br />
of time on their connected devices. The days when a<br />
customer would call Fidelity on the phone or visit a local<br />
Fidelity office are ending, Rotenberg said, replaced by<br />
a massive shift online. “We have to meet clients where<br />
they are,” she added.<br />
That’s a tall order, given that parent company Fidelity<br />
Investments manages $11 trillion in assets, employs<br />
tens of thousands of people, and does business on<br />
average with one in every six Americans. For being such<br />
a large company, it still feels like a family,” Rotenberg<br />
said. “Our ability to make the digital experience<br />
seamless, both person-to-person and across our<br />
platforms, is job one.”<br />
“Data is everything for us. We spend a lot of time on<br />
enriching our data, making sure it’s high-quality...<br />
because it’s such an important foundation.”<br />
Joanna Rotenberg<br />
16<br />
17
PANEL<br />
THE FUTURE OF<br />
THE RETAIL<br />
EXPERIENCE<br />
Tom McFadyen President, CEO and Founder, McFadyen Digital<br />
Mert Damlapinar Director, eRetail Strategic Insights and Tech<br />
Products, L’Oreal USA<br />
Jonathan Yaffe Co-Founder and CEO, AnyRoad<br />
Peter C. Evans Panel Moderator<br />
Tom McFadyen explained that there are now hundreds<br />
of huge global marketplaces—ranging from the trilliondollar<br />
Alibaba to the half-trillion-dollar Amazon to the<br />
$30 billion Mercado Libre in Latin America. Compared<br />
with conventional retailers, they are generally much more<br />
profitable, faster to market, and realize value and revenue<br />
much more quickly.<br />
By contrast, traditional product companies often know<br />
little about their end customers: Buy a bottle of shampoo<br />
at your local drugstore and the company that makes that<br />
shampoo won’t learn your name, age, address or much<br />
of anything else about you. But that’s changing rapidly as<br />
consumer-products makers lean into the power of data<br />
and platforms.<br />
L’Oreal, for instance, recently launched its own B2B<br />
marketplace, called SalonCentric. As Mert Damlapinar<br />
explained, the platform attracted some 500 vendors in<br />
just its first month. And it’s not only for hair products;<br />
there’s also food, furniture, fitness and more. L’Oreal is<br />
also exploring the use of the metaverse, he said.<br />
Jonathan Yaffe provided another example from The<br />
Michaels Companies. AnyRoad helped Michaels build<br />
a marketplace for arts and crafts classes that attracted<br />
20,000 art teachers who provide painting and other<br />
classes. Michaels has scaled this experience and<br />
learning platform to more than a million art students<br />
per year, who not only pay for classes but also buy<br />
their supplies through Michaels. The company handles<br />
fulfillment and gains critical new customer data.<br />
“Bucky [Buckminster<br />
Fuller] got it right when<br />
he said, ‘Make the<br />
world work for 100%<br />
of humanity in the<br />
shortest possible time,<br />
through spontaneous<br />
cooperation, without<br />
ecological offense<br />
or disadvantage to<br />
anyone.’ It’s a big ask,<br />
but we’re on it.”<br />
“I think traditional retail is completely dying. The retailers<br />
that will be around in 10 years will all be experiential<br />
companies that happen to sell goods on the side.”<br />
Jonathan Yaffe<br />
Dava Newman<br />
Director, <strong>MIT</strong> Media Lab; Apollo Program<br />
Professor of Astronautics, <strong>MIT</strong><br />
<strong>MIT</strong> MEDIA LAB<br />
TECHNOLOGY THAT<br />
SERVES SOCIETY<br />
The day’s final presentation boldly took Summit<br />
attendees where no attendees had gone before–<br />
into the ocean, off to Mars, and even into the<br />
human brain.<br />
<strong>MIT</strong>’s Media Lab is famous for its creative projects,<br />
and that tradition continues. One recent experiment,<br />
called Moxie, aims to make oxygen on Mars, explained<br />
Dava Newman, Media Lab director. Another Media<br />
Lab project created a 3D knitting machine that can<br />
make spacesuits for astronauts that are both flexible<br />
and lightweight (about 44 pounds vs. the current 260),<br />
yet still safe enough for trips to outer space. Also<br />
under way: creating an Internet of Things to be used<br />
in the oceans to determine the exact makeup and<br />
composition of the undersea world.<br />
Looking further into the future, Newman also outlined<br />
what she called “human augmentation”—the process<br />
of surgically implanting an AI system in a human<br />
being’s brain. It may sound like science fiction, but <strong>MIT</strong><br />
engineers believe this surgery could be achievable<br />
within the next 10 years.<br />
18<br />
Dava Newman<br />
19
RESOURCES<br />
RESOURCES FOR<br />
THE NEXT DECADE<br />
Prepare yourself for the next 10 years of platform<br />
proliferation with these valuable resources.<br />
<strong>Platform</strong> Revolution: How<br />
Networked Markets are<br />
Transforming the Economy—<br />
and How to Make Them Work<br />
for You<br />
A book by Geoffrey Parker,<br />
Marshall Van Alstyne, and<br />
Sangeet Paul Choudary (W.W.<br />
Norton, 2016). Second edition<br />
(pictured) is in progress.<br />
Marketplace Best Practices:<br />
Transforming Commerce in<br />
the <strong>Platform</strong> Economy<br />
A book by Tom McFayden<br />
(McFayden Digital, 2021).<br />
THANK YOU<br />
This year’s <strong>Platform</strong> Strategy Summit was made possible by<br />
the generous contributions of our IDE Corporate Members,<br />
individual donors, and our foundation partners.<br />
Supporters<br />
Accenture (Founding Member) • 3M Company • Akkodis • AB InBev<br />
Autodesk • Boston Globe Media • Capgemini • General Motors • IRC4HR<br />
Meta • Netflix Inc. • Schneider Electric<br />
Foundations<br />
Ewing Marion • Kauffman Foundation • Google.org • <strong>MIT</strong>-IBM Watson AI Lab<br />
Nasdaq • New Venture Fund • TDF Foundation<br />
Individuals<br />
Nobuo N. Akiha • Joe Eastin • Michael Even • Wesley Chan • Aaron Cowen<br />
Ellen and Bruce Herzfelder • Reid Hoffman • Richard B. Homonoff<br />
Edward S. Hyman Jr. • Gustavo Pierini • Gustavo Marini • Tom Pappas<br />
Jeff & Liesl Wilke • and other individuals who prefer to remain anonymous<br />
Rise of the <strong>Platform</strong> Enterprise<br />
A global survey by Peter C.<br />
Evans and Annabelle Gawer<br />
(Center for Global Enterprise,<br />
2016).<br />
Electric Vehicles Are a <strong>Platform</strong> Business: What Firms Need<br />
to Know, an article by Edward Anderson, Hemant Bhargava,<br />
Jonas Boehm and Geoff Parker (California Management<br />
Review, <strong>2022</strong>).<br />
Can NFTs Spark Continuous Learning? an article by Peter C.<br />
Evans, Geoff Parker, and Marshall Van Alstyne (Medium, <strong>2022</strong>).<br />
Unlocking Business Model Innovation through Advanced<br />
Manufacturing, a white paper by Jag Srai, Geoff Parker,<br />
Nitin Joglekar, Maja Bärring, Jonas Boehm, Eric Enselme,<br />
Maria Basso, Francisco Betti, and Benjamin Schönfuß (World<br />
Economic Forum, <strong>2022</strong>).<br />
Q&A: How a Decade of <strong>Platform</strong>s has Upended the Global<br />
Economy, an interview with the <strong>Platform</strong> Strategy Summit cochairs<br />
(<strong>MIT</strong> IDE, <strong>2022</strong>).<br />
A Whole New World? The Metaverse and What it Could Mean<br />
to You, a white paper by Alan Blau, Lauren Lubetsky, et al.<br />
(Deloitte, <strong>2022</strong>).<br />
Will <strong>Platform</strong>s Cure Healthcare Ills? a blog post by Paula Klein<br />
(Medium, <strong>2022</strong>).<br />
Open Data Propels <strong>Platform</strong>s, a blog post by Peter Krass<br />
(Medium, <strong>2022</strong>).<br />
Preparing the Next Generation<br />
of <strong>Platform</strong> Leaders: Staffing<br />
and Training the Inverted Firm<br />
A paper by Peter C. Evans,<br />
Geoffrey Parker, Marshall<br />
Van Alstyne, and Dyan<br />
Finkhousen (SSRN Electronic<br />
Journal, 2021).<br />
Digital Transformation Changes How Companies Create<br />
Value, a digital article by Marshall Van Alstyne and Geoffrey<br />
Parker (Harvard Business Review, 2021).<br />
Making Sense of the NFT Marketplace, a strategy paper by<br />
Peter C. Evans and Pavel Kireyev (Harvard Business Review,<br />
2021).<br />
‘In Situ’ Data Rights, a research paper by Marshall Van Alstyne,<br />
Georgios Petropoulos, Geoffrey Parker and Betin Martens<br />
(Communications of the ACM, 2021).<br />
Free Speech, <strong>Platform</strong>s & the Fake News Problem, a research<br />
paper by Marshall Van Alstyne (SSRN, 2021).<br />
<strong>MIT</strong> 2021 <strong>Platform</strong> Strategy Summit Special <strong>Report</strong>:<br />
<strong>Platform</strong>s Mean Business (<strong>MIT</strong> IDE, 2021).<br />
Workforce Systems: A New Strategic Approach to the Future<br />
of Work, a survey report by Elizabeth J. Altman, Jeff Schwartz,<br />
et al. (<strong>MIT</strong> Sloan Management Review, 2021).<br />
The Future of Work is Through Workforce Ecosystems, a<br />
research highlight by Elizabeth J. Altman, David Kiron, et al.<br />
(<strong>MIT</strong> Sloan Management Review, 2021).<br />
<strong>Platform</strong>s and Ecosystems: Enabling the Digital Economy,<br />
a white paper by Michael Jacobides, Arun Sundararajan and<br />
Marshall Van Alstyne (World Economic Forum, 2019).<br />
CONNECT WITH US<br />
FIND US ON MEDIUM<br />
Read articles on the impact of<br />
digital technology on business, the<br />
economy and society.<br />
Read ><br />
BROWSE OUR WORK<br />
Check out cutting-edge books,<br />
research briefs, special reports<br />
and more.<br />
Browse ><br />
Content by Peter Krass and Paula Klein. Event photography by Andrew Kubica.<br />
The IDE explores how people and businesses work, interact,<br />
and prosper in an era of profound digital transformation. We<br />
conduct research, convene events, offer courses, and provide<br />
fellowships that let bright minds collaborate with our research<br />
teams. We are part of the <strong>MIT</strong> Sloan School of Management.<br />
LISTEN<br />
Listen to the IDE podcast: The<br />
Digital Insider with Sinan Aral.<br />
Listen ><br />
20<br />
21