Angelus News | January 13, 2023 | Vol. 8 No. 1
On the cover: With the death of Pope Emeritus Benedict XVI last Dec. 31 at the age of 95, the world has lost an intellectual giant, a brilliant defender of the Catholic faith, and an unlikely reformer. In this commemorative issue, Angelus contributors John Allen (Page 8), Scott Hahn (Page 14), Elise Italiano Ureneck (Page 16), and Kathryn Lopez (Page 18) offer their assessments of Pope Benedict’s life and legacy. Also: on Page 12, a report from Rome on the German pope’s final farewell; on Page 20, some of Joseph Ratzinger’s most memorable quotes.
On the cover: With the death of Pope Emeritus Benedict XVI last Dec. 31 at the age of 95, the world has lost an intellectual giant, a brilliant defender of the Catholic faith, and an unlikely reformer. In this commemorative issue, Angelus contributors John Allen (Page 8), Scott Hahn (Page 14), Elise Italiano Ureneck (Page 16), and Kathryn Lopez (Page 18) offer their assessments of Pope Benedict’s life and legacy. Also: on Page 12, a report from Rome on the German pope’s final farewell; on Page 20, some of Joseph Ratzinger’s most memorable quotes.
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
ANGELUS<br />
POPE<br />
BENEDICT<br />
XVI<br />
1927-2022<br />
<strong>January</strong> <strong>13</strong>, <strong>2023</strong> <strong>Vol</strong>. 8 <strong>No</strong>. 1
<strong>January</strong> <strong>13</strong>, <strong>2023</strong><br />
<strong>Vol</strong>. 8 • <strong>No</strong>. 1<br />
3424 Wilshire Blvd.,<br />
Los Angeles, CA 90010-2241<br />
(2<strong>13</strong>) 637-7360 • FAX (2<strong>13</strong>) 637-6360<br />
Published by the Roman Catholic Archdiocese<br />
of Los Angeles by The Tidings<br />
(a corporation), established 1895.<br />
ANGELUS<br />
Publisher<br />
ARCHBISHOP JOSÉ H. GOMEZ<br />
Vice Chancellor for Communications<br />
DAVID SCOTT<br />
Editor-in-Chief<br />
PABLO KAY<br />
pkay@angelusnews.com<br />
Multimedia Editor<br />
TAMARA LONG-GARCÍA<br />
Production Artist<br />
DIANNE ROHKOHL<br />
Photo Editor<br />
VICTOR ALEMÁN<br />
Managing Editor<br />
RICHARD G. BEEMER<br />
Assistant Editor<br />
HANNAH SWENSON<br />
Advertising Manager<br />
JIM GARCIA<br />
jagarcia@angelusnews.com<br />
ANGELUS is published biweekly by The<br />
Tidings (a corporation), established 1895.<br />
Periodicals postage paid at Los Angeles,<br />
California. One-year subscriptions (26<br />
issues), $30.00; single copies, $3.00<br />
© 2021 ANGELUS (2473-2699). <strong>No</strong> part of this<br />
publication may be reproduced without the written<br />
permission of the publisher. Events and products<br />
advertised in ANGELUS do not carry the implicit<br />
endorsement of The Tidings Corporation or the<br />
Archdiocese of Los Angeles.<br />
POSTMASTER: Send address changes to:<br />
ANGELUS, PO Box 306, Congers, NY 10920-0306.<br />
For Subscription and Delivery information, please<br />
call (844) 245-6630 (Mon - Fri, 7 am-4 pm PT).<br />
FOLLOW US<br />
facebook.com/<strong>Angelus</strong><strong>News</strong><br />
info@angelusnews.com<br />
<strong>Angelus</strong> <strong>News</strong><br />
@<strong>Angelus</strong><strong>News</strong><br />
@<strong>Angelus</strong><strong>News</strong><br />
angelusnews.com<br />
lacatholics.org<br />
Sign up for our free, daily e-newsletter<br />
Always Forward - newsletter.angelusnews.com<br />
ON THE COVER<br />
CNS/PAUL HARING<br />
With the death of Pope Emeritus Benedict XVI last Dec. 31 at the age<br />
of 95, the world has lost an intellectual giant, a brilliant defender of the<br />
Catholic faith, and an unlikely reformer. In this commemorative issue,<br />
<strong>Angelus</strong> contributors John Allen (Page 8), Scott Hahn (Page 14), Elise<br />
Italiano Ureneck (Page 16), and Kathryn Lopez (Page 18) offer their assessments<br />
of Pope Benedict’s life and legacy. Also: on Page 12, a report<br />
from Rome on the German pope’s final farewell; on Page 20, some of<br />
Joseph Ratzinger’s most memorable quotes.<br />
THIS PAGE<br />
CNS/CHRIS WARDE-JONES<br />
People hold up a sign that reads, “Santo<br />
Subito” (“Sainthood <strong>No</strong>w”) as Pope<br />
Francis concludes the funeral Mass for<br />
Pope Benedict XVI in St. Peter’s Square<br />
at the Vatican Jan. 5. More than 50,000<br />
people attended the service, which was<br />
followed by a private burial in the crypt<br />
of St. Peter’s.
CONTENTS<br />
Pope Watch............................................... 2<br />
Archbishop Gomez................................. 3<br />
World, Nation, and Local <strong>News</strong>...... 4-6<br />
In Other Words........................................ 7<br />
Scott Hahn.............................................. 36<br />
Events Calendar..................................... 37<br />
22<br />
26<br />
30<br />
32<br />
34<br />
Cathedral service remembers LA’s homeless dead by their names<br />
What this Christmas looked like inside LA Men’s Central Jail<br />
Charlie Camosy sees a way forward for pro-life politics after Roe<br />
The Catholic actress who took on ‘Fake Christmas’ 80 years ago<br />
Heather King recalls the pioneering work of Msgr. ‘Terry’ Richey<br />
<strong>January</strong> <strong>13</strong>, <strong>2023</strong> • ANGELUS • 1
POPE WATCH<br />
Lessons from the pandemic<br />
The following is adapted from the<br />
Holy Father’s message for the 56th<br />
World Day of Peace, which the Church<br />
celebrates annually on <strong>January</strong> 1.<br />
COVID-19 plunged us into a<br />
dark night. It destabilized our<br />
daily lives, upset our plans and<br />
routines, and disrupted the apparent<br />
tranquility of even the most affluent societies.<br />
It generated disorientation and<br />
suffering and caused the death of great<br />
numbers of our brothers and sisters.<br />
Amid a whirlwind of unexpected<br />
challenges and facing a situation<br />
confusing even from a scientific standpoint,<br />
the world’s health care workers<br />
mobilized to relieve immense suffering<br />
and to seek possible remedies. At the<br />
same time, political authorities had to<br />
take measures to organize and manage<br />
efforts to respond to the emergency.<br />
In addition to its physical aspects,<br />
COVID-19 led to a general malaise in<br />
many individuals and families; the long<br />
periods of isolation and the various<br />
restrictions on freedom contributed to<br />
this malaise, with significant long-term<br />
effects.<br />
<strong>No</strong>r can we overlook the fractures in<br />
our social and economic order that the<br />
pandemic exposed, and the contradictions<br />
and inequalities that it brought to<br />
the fore. It threatened the job security<br />
of many individuals and aggravated the<br />
ever-increasing problem of loneliness<br />
in our societies, particularly on the part<br />
of the poor and those in need.<br />
Three years later, what did we learn<br />
from the pandemic? What new<br />
paths should we follow to cast off the<br />
shackles of our old habits, to be better<br />
prepared, to dare new things? What<br />
signs of life and hope can we see, to<br />
help us move forward and try to make<br />
our world a better place?<br />
Certainly, after directly experiencing<br />
the fragility of our own lives and<br />
the world around us, we can say that<br />
the greatest lesson we learned from<br />
COVID-19 was the realization that<br />
we all need one another. That our<br />
greatest and yet most fragile treasure is<br />
our shared humanity as brothers and<br />
sisters, children of God. And that none<br />
of us can be saved alone.<br />
We also learned that the trust we put<br />
in progress, technology, and the effects<br />
of globalization was not only excessive,<br />
but turned into an individualistic and<br />
idolatrous intoxication, compromising<br />
the very promise of justice, harmony,<br />
and peace that we so ardently sought.<br />
In our fast-paced world, the widespread<br />
problems of inequality, injustice,<br />
poverty, and marginalization<br />
continue to fuel unrest and conflict,<br />
and generate violence and even wars.<br />
What then is being asked of us? First<br />
of all, to let our hearts be changed<br />
by our experience of the crisis, to let<br />
God, at this time in history, transform<br />
our customary criteria for viewing the<br />
world around us.<br />
We can no longer think exclusively<br />
of carving out space for our personal<br />
or national interests; instead, we<br />
must think in terms of the common<br />
good, recognizing that we belong to a<br />
greater community, and opening our<br />
minds and hearts to universal human<br />
fraternity.<br />
We cannot continue to focus simply<br />
on preserving ourselves; rather, the<br />
time has come for all of us to endeavor<br />
to heal our society and our planet, to<br />
lay the foundations for a more just<br />
and peaceful world, and to commit<br />
ourselves seriously to pursuing a good<br />
that is truly common.<br />
Papal Prayer Intention for <strong>January</strong>: We pray that educators<br />
may be credible witnesses, teaching fraternity rather than<br />
competition and helping the youngest and most vulnerable<br />
above all.<br />
2 • ANGELUS • <strong>January</strong> <strong>13</strong>, <strong>2023</strong>
NEW WORLD OF FAITH<br />
ARCHBISHOP JOSÉ H. GOMEZ<br />
<strong>No</strong>thing more beautiful<br />
On Jan. 5, Archbishop Gomez<br />
celebrated a memorial Mass for Pope<br />
Emeritus Benedict XVI, the day the late<br />
pontiff was laid to rest in Rome. The<br />
following is adapted from his homily.<br />
I<br />
have had the privilege to know and<br />
minister under three popes: St. John<br />
Paul II, Pope Benedict XVI, and<br />
now the Holy Father Pope Francis.<br />
Each has his own distinctive personality<br />
and pastoral style. In my own ministry,<br />
I draw inspiration and guidance<br />
from all of them, from their words, and<br />
even more, from their examples.<br />
I will always be grateful to Pope<br />
Benedict because he chose me to be<br />
archbishop here in Los Angeles. It has<br />
been the blessing of my life to be your<br />
shepherd and pastor.<br />
In my experience, Pope Benedict<br />
was a gentle soul, a beautiful man. It<br />
is true that he was a great teacher and<br />
biblical theologian, and one of the<br />
most brilliant minds in the history of<br />
the Church and Western civilization.<br />
But I will remember him, most of all,<br />
for his kindness to me and his deep<br />
humility.<br />
Our pope emeritus put Jesus Christ at<br />
the center of his life. And leading men<br />
and women to friendship with Jesus<br />
was the purpose of his life.<br />
In his first homily as pope, he told<br />
us, “Only when we meet the living<br />
God in Christ do we know what life<br />
is. … There is nothing more beautiful<br />
than to be surprised by the Gospel, by<br />
the encounter with Christ. There is<br />
nothing more beautiful than to know<br />
Him and to speak to others of our<br />
friendship with Him.”<br />
We see this beautiful encounter in the<br />
Gospel story of the calling of Nathanael.<br />
Our Christian life, the life of faith,<br />
always begins with an invitation. It<br />
begins in friendship, in witness. One<br />
heart speaking to another heart about<br />
the love they have found in Jesus.<br />
This story that we hear today is from<br />
the early days of Jesus’ public ministry.<br />
Philip has just met Jesus and begun<br />
to follow him. <strong>No</strong>w he goes to invite<br />
his friend, Nathanael. He says, simply,<br />
“Come and see.”<br />
Philip makes this gentle invitation,<br />
and Jesus does the rest.<br />
Pope Benedict is right: There is<br />
nothing more beautiful than to be<br />
surprised by the Gospel! <strong>No</strong>thing more<br />
beautiful than to meet Jesus!<br />
He understood that the modern world<br />
is moving away from God, that faith is<br />
fading from the hearts of many people,<br />
that our society is growing cold and<br />
intolerant toward religion.<br />
But he also knew that God is not<br />
finished with his creation, not done<br />
building his kingdom on earth. Jesus is<br />
still calling, still knocking at the door<br />
of every human heart.<br />
Pope Benedict reminded us: The<br />
Church’s mission is Christ’s mission<br />
— to seek and to save the lost. It’s not<br />
just about popes and bishops, priests<br />
and religious. All of us share in this<br />
mission! Every one of us who has been<br />
baptized.<br />
Each of us is called — in our own<br />
way and in our own lives — to be like<br />
Philip. Speaking to others of our love<br />
for Jesus and our friendship with him.<br />
Calling others to “Come and see.”<br />
It really is true: When we meet the<br />
living God in Jesus Christ and follow<br />
him, our life changes.<br />
To be surprised by the Gospel is to<br />
discover the truth about where we<br />
come from, and what we are living for.<br />
Brothers and sisters, Jesus knows and<br />
loves each one of us, just as he knew<br />
and loved Nathanael. We heard in the<br />
first reading today: “God is greater than<br />
our hearts and knows everything.”<br />
Pope Benedict’s legacy will be the countless souls<br />
who found friendship with Jesus through his love,<br />
through his gentle invitation to “Come and see.”<br />
And Jesus makes the same promise to<br />
you that he made to Nathanael: When<br />
you come to him, “you will see greater<br />
things.”<br />
When we allow his love to fill our<br />
hearts, the gate of heaven stands open<br />
before us. We see with certainty that<br />
we walk in the light of his presence, in<br />
the company of angels and saints. The<br />
little things in our everyday lives become<br />
like a ladder leading us to heaven.<br />
I am confident that Pope Benedict<br />
will be remembered among the great<br />
figures in the history of the Church.<br />
But as he looks on the face of God<br />
and hears his voice, his legacy will not<br />
be one of great words and important<br />
books.<br />
His legacy will be the countless<br />
souls who found friendship with Jesus<br />
through his love, through his gentle<br />
invitation to “Come and see.”<br />
Let us honor his memory by renewing<br />
our own friendship with Jesus, and<br />
dedicating ourselves once more to the<br />
beautiful task of bringing others to be<br />
surprised by the Gospel!<br />
May Mary Most Holy pray for us, and<br />
keep us all under the mantle of her<br />
protection.<br />
<strong>January</strong> <strong>13</strong>, <strong>2023</strong> • ANGELUS • 3
WORLD<br />
■ Eritrean Catholics get<br />
a Christmas miracle<br />
Two clergymen from Eritrea were<br />
released from more than two months<br />
in detention Dec. 28.<br />
Authorities never provided a reason<br />
for why they arrested Bishop<br />
Fikremariam Hagos Tsalim and<br />
Father Mehereteab Stefanos of the<br />
Eritrean Catholic Eparchy of Segheneity<br />
on Oct. 15 at an airport. It is still<br />
unknown whether Capuchin Friar<br />
Abbot Abraham, who was arrested<br />
with them, is still in custody.<br />
Media reports suggest the three men<br />
were targeted for criticizing human<br />
rights violations — including forced<br />
military enlistment and confiscation<br />
of property — during their homilies.<br />
“I can confirm he is free, but I do<br />
not have any further details. My other<br />
concern is that we are dealing with a<br />
very toxic state,” an unnamed Catholic<br />
priest in the region told multiple<br />
Catholic news outlets.<br />
Their release follows a <strong>No</strong>vember<br />
peace treaty that would end the civil<br />
war between the Eritrean and Ethiopian<br />
governments against regional<br />
leaders of Tigray province that began<br />
in <strong>No</strong>vember 2020.<br />
Bishop Fikremariam<br />
Hagos Tsalim. | CNS<br />
True Christmas spirit — Local residents sing Christmas carols during an air raid alarm inside a metro station in<br />
Kyiv, Ukraine, Dec. 25. More than a week later, the Russian government announced a cease-fire out of respect<br />
for Christmas in the Orthodox Christian calendar on Jan. 7. The announcement seemed to have little effect on<br />
fighting between Russian and Ukrainian forces, however. | CNS/VALENTYN OGIRENKO, REUTERS<br />
■ Canadian police say no to St. Michael<br />
Police officers in Montreal will no longer be allowed to wear images of their<br />
patron, St. Michael the Archangel, their bosses have announced.<br />
The decision came after a reassessment of the Quebec Province’s “Law 21,”<br />
or law on state secularism, that restricts the use of religious imagery in public<br />
settings.<br />
“After analysis, it was agreed that the crest of St. Michael worn by SPVM<br />
(Service de Police de la Ville de Montréal) police officers on their uniform is a<br />
religious sign within the meaning of the law,” read a SPVM memo, which asked<br />
the officers to “kindly remove from your uniforms any crest symbolizing or referring<br />
to the Archangel St. Michael.”<br />
The ruling directly followed protests related to the COP15 international forum<br />
last September, where many officers wore St. Michael badges.<br />
■ Jesuit artist was investigated,<br />
quietly disciplined after abuse probe<br />
A Jesuit priest considered one of the most popular liturgical artists in the Catholic<br />
world is at the center of a new abuse scandal.<br />
Allegations of sexual and spiritual abuse committed by Father Marko Ivan<br />
Rupnik in the 1980s and 1990s against women religious in his native Slovenia<br />
first surfaced in Italian media last month. Since then, the Society of Jesus has<br />
revealed that a secret Vatican investigation resulted in a 2020 excommunication<br />
of Father Rupnik that was quickly lifted after the priest expressed repentance.<br />
In 2021, another allegation of abuse was made by several women who belonged<br />
to the Loyola Community he served as a spiritual adviser in Slovenia,<br />
but the Vatican’s doctrinal office ruled that the statute of limitations had passed<br />
and closed the case.<br />
The sequence of events has raised questions about why the statute of limitations<br />
was not waived and about whether Pope Francis knew about the previous<br />
excommunication.<br />
Father Rupnik’s mosaics decorate important churches and chapels around the<br />
world. Jesuit Superior General Father Arturo Sosa said Father Rupnik’s priestly<br />
ministry has been restricted since the Vatican’s investigation.<br />
4 • ANGELUS • <strong>January</strong> <strong>13</strong>, <strong>2023</strong>
NATION<br />
The Museum of the Bible’s “Bethlehem Bells” exhibit<br />
this month. | MUSEUM OF THE BIBLE<br />
■ Bishops’ pro-life chair:<br />
Abortion pill decision an<br />
‘obvious tragedy’<br />
Pharmacies can now sell the “abortion<br />
pill” mifepristone following a<br />
Food and Drug Administration (FDA)<br />
policy change Jan. 3.<br />
One of two pills used in a chemical<br />
abortion, mifepristone previously<br />
could only be dispensed by certified<br />
doctors, clinics, and some mail-order<br />
pharmacies. Retail pharmacies can<br />
now opt-in to filling abortion pill prescriptions,<br />
but must abide by any state<br />
regulations.<br />
The U.S. Postal Service was also<br />
empowered to deliver mifepristone<br />
pills — despite the FDA publishing<br />
recommendations that mifepristone<br />
not be purchased online — after the<br />
Justice Department’s Office of Legal<br />
Council published a Jan. 3 opinion<br />
that enabled mailing mifepristone even<br />
to states with strict anti-abortion laws..<br />
Bishop Michael Burbidge of Arlington,<br />
Virginia, chairman of the U.S.<br />
Conference of Catholic Bishops’ Committee<br />
on Pro-Life Activities, pointed<br />
out the high rate of “serious complications”<br />
after chemical abortions and<br />
called on the Biden administration to<br />
“correct its policy priorities and stand<br />
with mothers in need.”<br />
“[The decision] not only advances<br />
the obvious tragedy of taking the lives<br />
of the preborn, but is also harmful to<br />
women in need,” said Bishop Burbidge<br />
in a Jan. 6 statement.<br />
■ Bethlehem’s crusader bells come to America<br />
A set of 12th-century bells made their first — and perhaps only — trip from the<br />
Holy Land to the United States this Christmas season.<br />
The “Bethlehem Bells,” which were originally brought by crusaders to the ancient<br />
Church of the Nativity in Bethlehem, were the subject of a special exhibit at<br />
the Museum of the Bible in Washington, D.C., open through Jan. 29.<br />
The French-made bells were originally installed in a 12-piece carillon at the<br />
Church of the Nativity, but were lost for centuries after crusaders buried them in<br />
anticipation of a Muslim counterinvasion. The bells were rediscovered in 1906 by<br />
Franciscans making repairs to the church.<br />
The exhibit required approval from Catholic, Orthodox, and Armenian church<br />
leaders, as all three churches share custody of the Church of the Nativity and the<br />
bells. This will be the bells’ first and only trip outside the Holy Land, top museum<br />
curator Jeff Kloha said.<br />
■ Priests for Life leader defrocked after years of conflict<br />
The Vatican has dismissed long time pro-life advocate and priest Frank Pavone<br />
from the clerical state after a series of scandalous episodes in recent years.<br />
Apostolic nuncio to the U.S. Archbishop Christophe Pierre told the U.S. bishops<br />
in a letter that Pavone’s laicization was due to “blasphemous communications on<br />
social media” and “persistent disobedience” of his bishop, Patrick Zurek of Amarillo,<br />
with whom he sparred since 2008.<br />
Pavone has been a vocal supporter of Donald Trump since his first presidential<br />
campaign in 2016, making controversial statements on social media. He appeared<br />
in a politically charged <strong>No</strong>vember 2016 video staged with the body of an aborted<br />
baby on what appeared to be an altar.<br />
Pavone will continue his role as national director of Priests for Life, but has<br />
stopped using the title “Father” and has canceled his livestreamed Masses.<br />
Praying for Damar — A fan attends a candlelight vigil for Buffalo Bills safety Damar Hamlin at University of<br />
Cincinnati Medical Center on Jan. 3. The country united in prayer and sympathy for Hamlin after he suffered<br />
cardiac arrest during the Bills’ Jan. 2 game against the Cincinnati Bengals. Hamlin was a 2016 graduate of Central<br />
Catholic High School in Pittsburgh. | JEFF DEAN/GETTY IMAGES<br />
<strong>January</strong> <strong>13</strong>, <strong>2023</strong> • ANGELUS • 5
LOCAL<br />
■ Mission San Gabriel arson<br />
suspect to stand trial<br />
The man accused of setting fire to Mission San Gabriel is<br />
set to stand trial 2 1/2 years since the historic church was<br />
nearly destroyed.<br />
John David Corey, 59, will be tried on two counts of arson<br />
of a structure and one count each of arson during a state of<br />
emergency and second-degree commercial burglary.<br />
“After a thorough investigation, investigators determined<br />
that Corey was responsible for the fire at the Mission San<br />
Gabriel,” the San Gabriel Fire Department announced at<br />
the time of his arrest.<br />
The newly renovated mission has been closed as workers<br />
apply the finishing touches to its restored altarpiece. It is<br />
expected to reopen for services and visits in the spring of<br />
<strong>2023</strong>.<br />
■ Another Catholic college<br />
in California to close<br />
Holy Names University in Oakland will hold its last classes<br />
at the end of the school year in May, after unsuccessful<br />
efforts to partner with another college.<br />
In a Dec. 19 announcement, the school said that “both<br />
COVID-19 and an economic downturn disproportionately<br />
impacted” students, adding to low enrollment troubles.<br />
The school said it had reached a pending agreement with<br />
Dominican University of California in San Rafael, to transfer<br />
academic programs and credits after the spring semester.<br />
“This unfortunate situation is occurring at small colleges<br />
throughout the United States,” acknowledged Oakland<br />
Bishop Michael Barber in a statement.<br />
Holy Names was founded by the Sisters of the Holy Names<br />
of Jesus and Mary, a teaching order from Canada, in 1868.<br />
Earlier this year, Marymount California University in Rancho<br />
Palos Verdes also closed permanently after a failed merger<br />
with St. Leo University, a Catholic college in Florida.<br />
Bishop Alex Aclan in 2019.<br />
| VICTOR ALEMÁN<br />
■ Bishop Aclan making ‘very<br />
positive’ progress since stroke<br />
Auxiliary Bishop Alex Aclan is making “very positive and<br />
continuing progress” in his recovery since suffering a stroke<br />
four months ago, his family said.<br />
The 71-year-old bishop was hospitalized Aug. 20 in intensive<br />
care due to a sudden stroke. Since then, his family<br />
has given occasional updates on the bishop’s condition and<br />
requested continued prayers.<br />
“Bishop Alex is now living with family members and is<br />
making very positive and continuing progress in his recuperation,”<br />
the message read. “He is fully alert and communicative<br />
and is gaining strength each day through excellent<br />
physical therapy. He now travels to the physical therapy<br />
center rather than they coming to him.”<br />
Bishop Aclan’s family thanked all who have been praying<br />
for him and expressed confidence that “the new year will<br />
see even more return to normal” in his condition.<br />
“It is obvious that faith and prayer have had an incredibly<br />
positive effect on his continuing recovery,” they said.<br />
Blessings in boxes — Michael Donaldson and Gina Vides of the Office of Life,<br />
Justice and Peace pose with a few of the growing number of boxes containing<br />
socks, blankets, and sleeping bags donated after the Dec. 21 Homeless Persons<br />
Interreligious Memorial event. The donations will be distributed to community<br />
partners supporting the homeless, including SOFESA and the Society of St.<br />
Vincent de Paul Los Angeles. See pages 22-24 for <strong>Angelus</strong>’ full coverage of the<br />
memorial event. | OFFICE OF LIFE, JUSTICE AND PEACE<br />
Y<br />
6 • ANGELUS • <strong>January</strong> <strong>13</strong>, <strong>2023</strong>
V<br />
IN OTHER WORDS...<br />
Letters to the Editor<br />
Seeing the Holy Spirit at work<br />
What a marvelous way to end the year! “Five doses of good news for<br />
Catholicism amid an otherwise bleak year,” by John L. Allen Jr., in the<br />
Dec. 30 issue, made my heart swell with gratitude for my Catholic faith and my<br />
fellow Catholics.<br />
Reading these “doses of good news” reminded me of how much good is being<br />
done that we hear little or nothing about. It was so uplifting to read about the<br />
growth of the Catholic Church and the charitable work being done in so many<br />
places. The Holy Spirit is truly at work, but often in a hidden and silent way.<br />
I feel so sorry for those Catholics who have “fallen away,” for whatever reason,<br />
and who have become indifferent or hostile toward our Holy Father or the priesthood<br />
in general, or even toward the Church as a whole. They are missing out on<br />
the joy of being part of this beautiful body of Christ. I pray that they will come<br />
back and be blessed by renewed faith in <strong>2023</strong>.<br />
— Marilyn Boussaid, St. James Church, Redondo Beach<br />
The ‘Father Terry’ that I knew<br />
Thank you to Heather King for the insightful and spot-on reminiscence of Msgr.<br />
Richey published on <strong>Angelus</strong><strong>News</strong>.com Jan. 6 (and in this issue on pages 34-35).<br />
The last several years he lived at St. Basil’s in Koreatown, Father Sergio Garcia<br />
and I found ourselves increasingly assisting Msgr. It was made so much more<br />
enjoyable with his one-liners and that he was so accepting of his situation.<br />
He was always upbeat. During the pandemic lockdown he wanted a haircut.<br />
I told him I could get a big pair of scissors or set up a guillotine in the garden,<br />
whichever he preferred. In a rather dry response, he said, “I think the guillotine<br />
may be a bit extreme.” That kind of repartee went on all of the time.<br />
— Deacon Thomas Brandlin, St. Basil Church, Koreatown<br />
Y<br />
Continue the conversation! To submit a letter to the editor, visit <strong>Angelus</strong><strong>News</strong>.com/Letters-To-The-Editor<br />
and use our online form or send an email to editorial@angelusnews.com. Please limit to 300 words. Letters<br />
may be edited for style, brevity, and clarity.<br />
Resting with the popes<br />
View more photos<br />
from this gallery at<br />
<strong>Angelus</strong><strong>News</strong>.com/photos-videos<br />
The tomb of Pope<br />
Benedict XVI in the<br />
crypt of St. Peter’s<br />
Basilica was opened<br />
to the public following<br />
his Jan. 5 burial,<br />
capping an emotional<br />
farewell lasting a<br />
whole week. | CNS/<br />
VATICAN MEDIA<br />
Do you have photos or a story from your parish that you’d<br />
like to share? Please send to editorial @angelusnews.com.<br />
“Making saints is a<br />
process of memory and<br />
interpretation.”<br />
~ Carmen Nanko-Fernández, in a Dec. 23<br />
Commonweal article on the legacies of Roberto<br />
Clemente and Jackie Robinson.<br />
“He loved art and music<br />
and cats and within his<br />
many publications there is<br />
a very strong attention to<br />
beauty.”<br />
~ Theologian Tracey Rowland, winner of the 2020<br />
Ratzinger Prize for Theology, in a Jan. 4 interview<br />
with the National Catholic Reporter.<br />
“That’s a feature, not a bug<br />
of our system.”<br />
~ Republican Rep. Mike Gallagher, a Catholic<br />
from Wisconsin, on the “messy” process to elect a<br />
Speaker of the House at the start of the year.<br />
“I felt like a student asked<br />
to play piano in front of<br />
Mozart.”<br />
~ Swiss Cardinal Kurt Koch, recalling the time he was<br />
asked to speak on the hermeneutics of the Second<br />
Vatican Council at a gathering of Pope Benedict XVI<br />
and his alumni.<br />
“I think we all have to<br />
recognize the power of<br />
prayer from coaches,<br />
players, the staff and<br />
the fans that was in that<br />
stadium, and the people<br />
watching from around the<br />
world,”<br />
~ Troy Vincent, executive vice president of football<br />
operations at the NFL, on the reaction to Buffalo<br />
Bills player Damar Hamlin’s nearly fatal on-field<br />
health scare Jan. 2.<br />
<strong>January</strong> <strong>13</strong>, <strong>2023</strong> • ANGELUS • 7
BENEDICT<br />
THE GREAT?<br />
Of the three<br />
popes so far in<br />
the 21st century,<br />
Pope Benedict’s<br />
place in history<br />
may ultimately<br />
loom the largest.<br />
BY JOHN L. ALLEN JR.<br />
Pope Benedict XVI waves as<br />
he arrives to deliver a talk at the<br />
conclusion of a Mass for the<br />
Knights of Malta in St. Peter’s<br />
Basilica at the Vatican Feb. 9,<br />
20<strong>13</strong>. | CNS/PAUL HARING<br />
8 • ANGELUS • <strong>January</strong> <strong>13</strong>, <strong>2023</strong>
ROME — New Year’s is<br />
a time for predictions,<br />
though generally they’re<br />
focused just on the year to<br />
come. Here’s one whose<br />
horizon isn’t the next 12 months, but,<br />
say, the next 100 years.<br />
I hereby forecast that in a century’s<br />
time, the early 21st-century pope<br />
whose memory will loom largest won’t<br />
be either St. Pope John Paul II or<br />
Pope Francis, both wildly charismatic<br />
figures who dominated the global<br />
stage in their day. It instead will be<br />
Pope Benedict XVI, the awkward,<br />
bookish pontiff who, in his own time,<br />
just never seemed to turn the world on<br />
with his smile.<br />
With both Pope John Paul and Pope<br />
Francis, the force of their personalities<br />
comes across best live, either in person<br />
or on TV. As is often said of contextual<br />
humor, “you had to be there” to really<br />
get the impact.<br />
Even now, it probably would be<br />
difficult for nonexperts to summon the<br />
titles of more than a couple of either<br />
pope’s writings — what people tend<br />
to remember instead are the grand<br />
gestures, the images, and the madefor-TV<br />
sound bites such as “Be not<br />
afraid!” and “Who am I to judge?”<br />
Yet the nature of this sort of fame is<br />
that it has a very brief half-life; it starts<br />
to decay, in fact, the moment you’re<br />
no longer on-air. Just ask any American<br />
today under the age of 30 about<br />
Johnny Carson, for instance, and the<br />
uncomprehending stares you’re likely<br />
to get will speak volumes.<br />
The written word, on the other<br />
hand, endures, and Cardinal Joseph<br />
Ratzinger/Pope Benedict XVI was<br />
preeminently a thinker and a writer.<br />
If you want to know either Pope John<br />
Paul or Pope Francis, you have to see<br />
them; to know Pope Benedict, on the<br />
other hand, you need to read him.<br />
As a Vatican reporter, I can testify<br />
that one key difference between Pope<br />
John Paul II and Pope Benedict on<br />
the road was that with Pope John Paul,<br />
his speeches on trips were often a bit<br />
disjointed and hard to follow from<br />
beginning to end, but they always contained<br />
that money quote that would<br />
become the day’s headline. With Pope<br />
Benedict it was the opposite — A<br />
always led to B, and B led to C, etc.,<br />
with crystalline clarity, though usually<br />
without that zinger of a sound bite.<br />
To know Pope Benedict the best, you<br />
need to read his works prior to becoming<br />
pope as well as his output in office.<br />
In 100 years’ time, it’s a good bet that<br />
several works by Cardinal Ratzinger/<br />
Pope Benedict still will be studied and<br />
dissected in seminaries, Catholic universities,<br />
think tanks, and publishing<br />
houses. Here’s a decidedly partial list<br />
— no more, really, than a sampler.<br />
“Introduction to Christianity” (1968):<br />
Essential reading for anyone seeking<br />
to understand the intellectual currents<br />
that shaped the Second Vatican Council<br />
(1962-65) and the period immediately<br />
following.<br />
“Eschatology: Death and Eternal<br />
Life” (1977): Cardinal Ratzinger once<br />
referred to this as “my most thorough<br />
work, and the one I labored over the<br />
most strenuously.”<br />
“The Spirit of the Liturgy” (1978):<br />
Liturgy was an “idée fixe” (“fixed<br />
idea”) for Cardinal Ratzinger/Pope<br />
Benedict over the entire scope of his<br />
life and career, and this volume pre-<br />
Newly elected Pope John Paul II greets Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger of Munich and Freising in St. Peter’s<br />
Square at the Vatican Oct. 22, 1978. | CNS/L’OSSERVATORE ROMANO/KNA<br />
<strong>January</strong> <strong>13</strong>, <strong>2023</strong> • ANGELUS • 9
Retired Pope Benedict XVI talks with Pope Francis during a meeting at the Vatican June 30, 2015. | CNS/L’OSSERVATORE ROMANO VIA REUTERS<br />
10 • ANGELUS • <strong>January</strong> <strong>13</strong>, <strong>2023</strong>
sents his most developed views on the<br />
nature of Catholic worship.<br />
“Church, Ecumenism and Politics”<br />
(1987): Informed in part by debates<br />
over liberation theology, this is<br />
Cardinal Ratzinger’s most developed<br />
treatment of the folly of a “political”<br />
Christianity.<br />
“Deus Caritas Est” (2005): Pope<br />
Benedict’s first encyclical, and probably<br />
the most sustained reflection ever<br />
issued by a pope on the relationship<br />
between divinity and human erotic<br />
love.<br />
“Speeches in Regensburg, Germany,<br />
2006; the Collège des Bernardins in<br />
Paris, 2008; Westminster Hall in London,<br />
2010; and the Bundestag in Germany,<br />
2011”: In these four discourses,<br />
Pope Benedict laid out a vision of the<br />
relationship between reason and faith<br />
and the role of religious faith in secular<br />
democracies. Going forward, no<br />
graduate seminary on secularity and<br />
religion likely ever will be held without<br />
at least considering these works.<br />
To be honest, it’s difficult to assemble<br />
such a list of written works by any<br />
other modern pope that are likely to<br />
pass into posterity, especially works<br />
published before they even ascended<br />
to the Throne of Peter.<br />
Arnold Toynbee, in his 1948 classic<br />
“Civilization on Trial,” put the historian’s<br />
perspective this way:<br />
“The things that make good headlines<br />
are on the surface of the stream<br />
of life, and they distract us from the<br />
slower, impalpable, imponderable<br />
movements that work below the<br />
surface and penetrate to the depths.<br />
But it is really these deeper, slower<br />
movements that make history, and it is<br />
they that stand out huge in retrospect,<br />
when the sensational passing events<br />
have dwindled, in perspective, to their<br />
true proportions.”<br />
In his time, Pope Benedict’s papacy<br />
was dominated by sensational events<br />
— Vatileaks, a furor over a Holocaust-denying<br />
traditional bishop, a<br />
surreal scandal involving fake police<br />
reports suggesting the Vatican had<br />
smeared a prominent Italian Catholic<br />
journalist, the explosion of the clerical<br />
sexual abuse scandals in Ireland and<br />
across Europe, and on and on.<br />
Pope Benedict’s original, synthetic<br />
thinking on such key Catholic themes<br />
as worship, eschatology, and reason,<br />
while never destined to generate headlines,<br />
contributed to those “deeper,<br />
slower movements” that shape destiny,<br />
the perceived importance of which<br />
likely will only grow with the passage<br />
of time.<br />
<strong>No</strong>ne of this is to suggest, of course,<br />
that either Pope John Paul or Pope<br />
Francis have been minor notes in<br />
history. On the contrary, Pope John<br />
Paul, among other things, was instrumental<br />
in the collapse of communism,<br />
while Pope Francis has revitalized<br />
the Church’s relevance in sectors of<br />
opinion where it has long faced either<br />
hostility or oblivion.<br />
Yet if the true passport to immortality<br />
is print, then of the three pontiffs so far<br />
of the early 21st century, the one who<br />
seemed maligned and overlooked in<br />
his day may well be the one whose star<br />
shines brightest over time.<br />
John L. Allen Jr. is the editor of Crux.<br />
<strong>January</strong> <strong>13</strong>, <strong>2023</strong> • ANGELUS • 11
Cardinal Giovanni Battista<br />
Re sprinkles holy water on<br />
the casket of Pope Benedict<br />
XVI as Pope Francis looks on<br />
during the late pope’s funeral<br />
Mass in St. Peter’s Square<br />
at the Vatican Jan. 5. | CNS/<br />
VATICAN MEDIA<br />
‘FRIEND OF THE BRIDEGROOM’<br />
Pope Benedict XVI greets young people as he arrives for the<br />
World Youth Day vigil service at Cuatro Vientos Airport in<br />
Madrid Aug. 20, 2011. | CNS/SUSANA VERA, REUTERS<br />
The papal funeral playbook had to be rewritten for Benedict,<br />
who was buried as a retired, not reigning, pontiff.<br />
STAFF REPORT<br />
As he asked for, Pope<br />
Benedict XVI’s funeral in<br />
St. Peter’s Square Jan. 5<br />
was a simpler affair than<br />
most papal funerals. But<br />
it also featured some unprecedented<br />
novelties. Here are some important<br />
highlights from a moment unlike any<br />
other in Church history.<br />
Diplomacy on display<br />
An estimated 50,000 people filled<br />
the square for the Thursday morning<br />
Mass. Members of the College<br />
of Cardinals sat on one side of the<br />
casket, while on the other side sat special<br />
guests, including the late pope’s<br />
closest collaborators and various<br />
representatives of faith communities.<br />
The only heads of state invited to lead<br />
delegations were those of Italy and<br />
Pope Benedict’s native Germany.<br />
However, many dignitaries — including<br />
Queen Sofia of Spain and<br />
King Philippe of Belgium — and<br />
presidents and government ministers<br />
representing more than a dozen<br />
nations were in attendance.<br />
Hong Kong Cardinal Joseph Zen<br />
Ze-kiun, who turned 91 on Jan. <strong>13</strong>,<br />
was allowed to leave China to attend<br />
the funeral of Pope Benedict, who had<br />
made him a cardinal in 2006. The retired<br />
cardinal was arrested in May and<br />
fined in <strong>No</strong>vember together with five<br />
others on charges of failing to properly<br />
register a now-defunct fund to help<br />
anti-government protesters.<br />
How to pray for a pope emeritus<br />
The Mass in St. Peter’s Square was<br />
the first time in more than 200 years<br />
that a pope celebrated the funeral of<br />
his predecessor. Pope Pius VII had<br />
celebrated the funeral of Pius VI in<br />
1802 when his remains were returned<br />
to Rome after he died in exile in<br />
France in 1799.<br />
This time, two key elements normally<br />
part of a papal funeral following the<br />
farewell prayer were missing: there<br />
were no prayers offered by representatives<br />
of the Diocese of Rome and of<br />
the Eastern Catholic churches, since<br />
those prayers are specific to the death<br />
of a reigning pope.<br />
Pope Francis presided over the Mass,<br />
giving the homily and saying most of<br />
12 • ANGELUS • <strong>January</strong> <strong>13</strong>, <strong>2023</strong>
ni Battista<br />
water on<br />
e Benedict<br />
cis looks on<br />
ope’s funeral<br />
’s Square<br />
. 5. | CNS/<br />
the prayers, but when it was time to<br />
celebrate the Liturgy of the Eucharist,<br />
88-year-old Cardinal Giovanni Battista<br />
Re, dean of the College of Cardinals,<br />
was the main celebrant at the altar.<br />
Pope Francis sat off to the side, doubtless<br />
a result of the nagging pain that<br />
continues to afflict him due to osteoarthritis<br />
in his right knee.<br />
In other words, one could say that<br />
Pope Francis “assisted” at a Mass<br />
actually “celebrated” by a cardinal.<br />
Concelebrating were some 120 cardinals<br />
(including Los Angeles’ Cardinal<br />
Roger Mahony), another 400 bishops,<br />
and 3,700 priests.<br />
Jesus at the center<br />
Pope Francis chose to dedicate his<br />
homily to Christ’s loving devotion<br />
and suffering witness, rather than on a<br />
summary of his predecessor’s life.<br />
“Feeding means loving, and loving<br />
also means being ready to suffer.<br />
Loving means giving the sheep what is<br />
truly good, the nourishment of God’s<br />
truth, of God’s word, the nourishment<br />
of his presence,” Pope Francis said,<br />
quoting his predecessor’s homily marking<br />
the start of his pontificate April 24,<br />
2005.<br />
“Holding fast to the Lord’s last words<br />
and to the witness of his entire life, we<br />
too, as an ecclesial community, want<br />
to follow in his steps and to commend<br />
our brother into the hands of the Father,”<br />
he said of Pope Benedict. “May<br />
those merciful hands find his lamp<br />
alight with the oil of the Gospel that<br />
he spread and testified to for his entire<br />
life.”<br />
“Benedict, faithful friend of the Bridegroom,<br />
may your joy be complete as<br />
you hear his voice, now and forever!”<br />
he concluded, as the crowd prayed in<br />
silence.<br />
One last ‘Benedetto!’ and burial<br />
After the final blessing, a bell tolled<br />
solemnly and the assembly applaud-<br />
ed for several minutes — with some<br />
chanting “Benedetto!” — as the<br />
pallbearers carried the casket toward<br />
St. Peter’s Basilica, where earlier in the<br />
week about 195,000 people had paid<br />
their respects to Pope Benedict over<br />
three days of public viewing.<br />
Once inside, the casket was brought<br />
to be buried in the grotto of St. Peter’s<br />
Basilica in the same tomb that held<br />
the remains of St. Pope John Paul II<br />
before his beatification. The pope was<br />
wearing a miter and the chasuble he<br />
wore for Mass at World Youth Day in<br />
Sydney in 2008.<br />
Cardinal Re led prayers and blessed<br />
the pope’s remains during the burial<br />
rite attended by a small number of senior<br />
cardinals, the retired pope’s closest<br />
aides, and others.<br />
Reporting courtesy of Catholic <strong>News</strong><br />
Service. Crux’s John L. Allen Jr. and<br />
<strong>Angelus</strong> Editor-in-Chief Pablo Kay also<br />
contributed to this story.<br />
S’<br />
for the<br />
rt in<br />
LA pays tribute to Benedict’s ‘gentle soul’<br />
Visitors pay their respects to the late Pope Benedict XVI after a Jan. 5 memorial<br />
Mass at the Cathedral of Our Lady of the Angels. | VICTOR ALEMÁN<br />
M<br />
emorial Masses for Pope Benedict XVI<br />
were celebrated in parishes around the<br />
Archdiocese of Los Angeles, including two<br />
at the Cathedral of Our Lady of the Angels<br />
on Jan. 5 and 9.<br />
At the Jan. 5 Mass, Archbishop José H. Gomez praised<br />
the late pope as “a gentle soul” and “one of the most<br />
brilliant minds in the history of the Church and Western<br />
civilization.”<br />
The cathedral liturgies included a few symbolic tributes<br />
to the late pope. Beforehand, a bell was rung eight<br />
times, one for each year of Pope Benedict’s pontificate.<br />
Later, the choir sang Mozart’s “Ave Verum Corpus,” a<br />
nod to the late German pope’s well-known affinity for<br />
the great composer and fellow countryman. Outside,<br />
the Vatican flag flew at half-mast in a sign of mourning.<br />
In his closing remarks, Archbishop Gomez said he<br />
thought “it is clear to all of us that Pope Benedict is in<br />
heaven” and invited the faithful to invoke his intercession<br />
for their needs.<br />
Then came a final surprise. What was supposed to be<br />
the final day of a historic rainstorm hitting Southern<br />
California had turned out to be a cloudy, dry morning.<br />
But as the archbishop was speaking about Pope Benedict,<br />
a burst of sunlight poured through the cathedral<br />
windows for a few seconds.<br />
It was, in the archbishop’s words, “a good sign,” an<br />
assurance that the late pope would continue “bringing<br />
this light into our lives with the light and presence of<br />
Jesus.”<br />
— Pablo Kay<br />
<strong>January</strong> <strong>13</strong>, <strong>2023</strong> • ANGELUS • <strong>13</strong>
Pope Benedict XVI is pictured at his desk in the papal residence at Castel Gandolfo, Italy, in this 2010 photo. | CNS/VATICAN MEDIA<br />
THE SCHOLAR POPE<br />
His work took biblical scholarship to another level.<br />
Christians will reap the benefits for years to come.<br />
BY SCOTT HAHN<br />
From his first moments as<br />
pope, Benedict XVI established<br />
biblical renewal as<br />
a key theme of his pontificate.<br />
In fact, he spoke<br />
at length about “scientific” biblical<br />
interpretation during his homily for<br />
the Mass in which he was installed as<br />
Bishop of Rome.<br />
This was unprecedented, and yet it arrived<br />
as a surprise to no one who knew<br />
the man’s earlier work.<br />
Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger was a<br />
product of his times, and his times<br />
were tumultuous and productive in<br />
the sacred sciences. In the years of his<br />
priestly formation, the Christian world<br />
was enjoying a renewal of biblical<br />
studies. Many of its leading academic<br />
lights, both Catholic and Protestant,<br />
were active in Germany and writing<br />
in German. An intelligent seminarian<br />
couldn’t avoid the conversation.<br />
As he pursued advanced studies, he<br />
immersed himself in the biblical interpretation<br />
of the early Church Fathers as<br />
well as the medieval masters.<br />
But his study of the sacred page was<br />
not simply an academic exercise. It<br />
informed his preaching, and it became<br />
a hallmark of his spiritual life.<br />
He served the Church as a professor<br />
of theology and then as a theological<br />
consultant (“peritus”) to the Second<br />
Vatican Council (1962-65). In this role<br />
he helped to shape the council’s Dogmatic<br />
Constitution on Divine Revelation,<br />
“Dei Verbum” (“Word of God”).<br />
“Dei Verbum” was the mature fruit<br />
of the biblical renewal. It was also a<br />
particular bugbear among the council<br />
fathers. It was debated intensely and<br />
redrafted repeatedly. Many historians<br />
credit Father Ratzinger as the greatest<br />
influence on the document’s final<br />
form. And, more than any other document,<br />
“Dei Verbum” set the agenda<br />
for biblical studies and theology in the<br />
14 • ANGELUS • <strong>January</strong> <strong>13</strong>, <strong>2023</strong>
N MEDIA<br />
decades ahead.<br />
After the council, Father Ratzinger<br />
returned to academic life, eventually<br />
taking a position at the University of<br />
Tübingen, which is renowned for its<br />
ecumenical faculty in theology. While<br />
there, he published the works that<br />
established his international reputation.<br />
In constant dialogue with his Protestant<br />
colleagues — and a very diverse Catholic<br />
faculty — Father Ratzinger developed<br />
skills and virtues that would serve<br />
him well as a scholar, bishop, Vatican<br />
official, and pope.<br />
He learned to consider theological discussions<br />
from the Reformed position —<br />
and articulate a response in terms his<br />
interlocutors could appreciate.<br />
He gained a profound<br />
appreciation for modern<br />
methods of Scripture study<br />
and an admiration for the<br />
work of non-Catholic colleagues.<br />
He was able to find<br />
what was good and useful<br />
even in the works of those<br />
with whom he disagreed.<br />
He published books and articles<br />
in many subdisciplines<br />
of theology: spiritual theology,<br />
fundamental theology,<br />
liturgical theology, historical<br />
theology, catechetics, and<br />
systematic theology.<br />
He wrote a few specifically<br />
biblical studies, including<br />
an account of the Genesis<br />
creation narratives. But all<br />
his works bear a characteristic<br />
biblical stamp. He<br />
was fully engaged with the<br />
scriptural text and the history<br />
of its interpretation. He was a biblical<br />
theologian.<br />
Then he was a bishop, and then he<br />
was prefect of the Sacred Congregation<br />
for the Doctrine of the Faith. Yet always<br />
he worked as a biblical theologian.<br />
In 1988 came a defining moment<br />
when he delivered the prestigious<br />
Erasmus Lecture. His address, “Biblical<br />
Interpretation in Crisis,” was eventually<br />
published as a book — and it became<br />
a manifesto for a movement. He called<br />
for a “critique of criticism” and a renewed<br />
appreciation for the hermeneutic<br />
of faith. For too long, Scripture study<br />
had been subject to the reductionist<br />
methods of the empirical sciences,<br />
and those methods had only limited<br />
effectiveness when applied to texts that<br />
are divinely inspired.<br />
Some professionals, in both theology<br />
and biblical studies, found Cardinal<br />
Ratzinger’s address refreshing and even<br />
inspiring. Others vehemently opposed<br />
it. <strong>No</strong> one could ignore it, however,<br />
and it remained a matter of active and<br />
lively debate for decades.<br />
The timing of his election in 2005<br />
could not have been more perfect: As<br />
pope, Benedict XVI would be able to<br />
celebrate the 50th anniversary of the<br />
promulgation of “Dei Verbum,” the<br />
Vatican II text he had done so much to<br />
shape.<br />
Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, the future Pope Benedict XVI, gives a<br />
lecture in New York in <strong>January</strong> 1988. | CNS/KNA<br />
The celebration, begun in 2005,<br />
found its most complete expression five<br />
years later in the 2010 post-synodal apostolic<br />
exhortation “Verbum Domini”<br />
(“Word of the Lord”), which is arguably<br />
the most important document on<br />
Scripture produced by the Church in<br />
many years. It is a masterpiece, almost<br />
200 pages in book form, and there are<br />
no weak words. While he affirmed “the<br />
benefits that historical-critical exegesis<br />
and other recently-developed methods<br />
of textual analysis have brought to the<br />
life of the Church,” he also said:<br />
— “authentic biblical hermeneutics<br />
can only be had within the faith of the<br />
Church, which has its paradigm in<br />
Mary’s fiat. …”<br />
— “the primary setting for scriptural<br />
interpretation is the life of the Church.<br />
This is not to uphold the ecclesial<br />
context as an extrinsic rule to which<br />
exegetes must submit, but rather is<br />
something demanded by the very nature<br />
of the Scriptures and the way they<br />
gradually came into being. …”<br />
— “The Bible is the Church’s book,<br />
and its essential place in the Church’s<br />
life gives rise to its genuine interpretation.”<br />
Here at last was a pope conversant in<br />
biblical Greek and Hebrew. It’s likely<br />
that no pope since Peter could match<br />
Pope Benedict’s knowledge of rabbinic<br />
literature. And he was using<br />
these skills in powerful new<br />
ways.<br />
In my opinion, he emerged<br />
as the great modern master<br />
of mystagogy — instruction<br />
about the sacramental<br />
mysteries and their rites. He<br />
renewed the art not only in<br />
its theory, in his official documents,<br />
but in his practice.<br />
His baptismal homilies have<br />
so far been neglected and<br />
are awaiting discovery.<br />
His papal teaching was<br />
consistently grounded in<br />
Sacred Scripture, and this<br />
has appealed to Protestant<br />
intellectuals. It was Protestant<br />
clergy who founded the<br />
Joseph Ratzinger Society<br />
of Biblical Theology in the<br />
United States. And it was<br />
a Protestant publishing<br />
house that brought out “The<br />
Theology of Benedict XVI: A Protestant<br />
Appreciation” in 2019. When he<br />
resigned his office, I was among those<br />
who deeply grieved at the silencing of<br />
his voice. Today my mourning goes<br />
deeper still.<br />
I know that in all his years as emeritus<br />
pope he was writing daily. I know that<br />
all his writing was profoundly biblical.<br />
So I wait in hope for some of it — any<br />
of it — to be published.<br />
For it’s unlikely that we’ll see a pope<br />
like him for at least another 2,000 years.<br />
Scott Hahn is founder of the St. Paul<br />
Center for Biblical Theology; stpaulcenter.com.<br />
<strong>January</strong> <strong>13</strong>, <strong>2023</strong> • ANGELUS • 15
Pope Benedict XVI greets young people as he arrives for the<br />
World Youth Day vigil service at Cuatro Vientos Airport in<br />
Madrid Aug. 20, 2011. | CNS/SUSANA VERA, REUTERS<br />
THE BENEDICT GENERATION<br />
We came of age in a time marked by different kinds of scandals and<br />
terrors. Then a new pope found a way to speak to our hearts.<br />
BY ELISE ITALIANO URENECK<br />
I<br />
was walking across the grotto<br />
in front of my college<br />
chapel when bells began<br />
to toll, one after another. It<br />
was April 2005, the end of<br />
my junior year. I stopped and looked at<br />
the assistant chaplain who was outside,<br />
speaking to some students. “We have<br />
a new pope,” he hollered, a big grin<br />
spreading across his face.<br />
A few minutes later, those of us<br />
gathered together learned that the<br />
conclave had elected Cardinal Joseph<br />
Ratzinger to succeed Pope John Paul<br />
II. I didn’t know what to make of<br />
something so novel. In the 21 years I’d<br />
been alive, there had only been one<br />
pope. What would Catholicism look<br />
like with someone else at the helm?<br />
“This is a very good thing,” the chaplain,<br />
a Dominican friar, assured us.<br />
Though born Michael, his religious<br />
name was John Paul. I erred on the<br />
side of trusting him.<br />
It’s a bit of a cliché to characterize<br />
one’s adolescence<br />
as uniquely tumultuous, but<br />
I tend to believe that as a<br />
whole, my generation was<br />
given one of the more disruptive rides<br />
into adulthood.<br />
My freshman year of high school<br />
drew to a close with the Columbine<br />
massacre. <strong>No</strong> one had ever seen such<br />
a thing. Bomb threats and shelter-inplace<br />
drills soon became the norm.<br />
16 • ANGELUS • <strong>January</strong> <strong>13</strong>, <strong>2023</strong>
for the<br />
rt in<br />
S<br />
Then the bottom really fell out from<br />
under us. My senior year of high<br />
school began with 9/11; it concluded<br />
with the Boston Globe’s Spotlight<br />
investigation. Schools, office spaces,<br />
sacristies — ordinary spaces became<br />
the loci of unspeakable trauma.<br />
And then as our friends and relatives<br />
started losing lives and limbs in Iraq<br />
and Afghanistan, we learned that the<br />
weapons of mass destruction and the<br />
terrorists at the helm of the attacks<br />
were nowhere to be found. We began<br />
to question who we could trust.<br />
Perhaps the most devastating<br />
betrayal took place in<br />
our families. I was among<br />
the generation whose Baby<br />
Boomer parents divorced in<br />
droves, the inevitable consequence<br />
of their collective<br />
self-actualization project.<br />
Without assurance that the<br />
adults in the room were<br />
going to protect us, we entered<br />
adulthood unmoored.<br />
It was in this context that<br />
the newly elected Pope<br />
Benedict XVI preached his<br />
inaugural homily. To those<br />
of us who were searching,<br />
still hoping to find secure<br />
footing, the pope’s words<br />
pierced our hearts.<br />
First, he acknowledged<br />
our weariness, as if he<br />
were touching the wounds<br />
in our sides like Thomas<br />
touched Christ’s: “[For the<br />
pastor] it is not a matter of<br />
indifference that so many<br />
people are living in the desert.<br />
And there are so many<br />
kinds of desert. There is<br />
the desert of poverty, the<br />
desert of hunger and thirst,<br />
the desert of abandonment,<br />
of loneliness, of destroyed love. …<br />
The external deserts in the world are<br />
growing, because the internal deserts<br />
have become so vast.”<br />
Next, he spoke to our uncertainty<br />
about our place in a world in which<br />
nihilism seemed plausible, suicidal<br />
ideation was rising, and the atheism of<br />
evolutionary biologists was attracting<br />
scores of disciples. To this he counseled,<br />
“Only when we meet the living<br />
God in Christ do we know what life is.<br />
We are not some casual and meaningless<br />
product of evolution. Each of us is<br />
the result of a thought of God. Each of<br />
us is willed, each of us is loved, each<br />
of us is necessary.”<br />
Finally, he gave us direction. “And<br />
so, today, with great strength and great<br />
conviction, on the basis of long personal<br />
experience of life, I say to you,<br />
dear young people: Do not be afraid<br />
of Christ! He takes nothing away, and<br />
he gives you everything. When we give<br />
ourselves to him, we receive a hundredfold<br />
in return.”<br />
Pope Benedict XVI leads Benediction of the Eucharist during the<br />
World Youth Day prayer vigil at Cuatro Vientos Airport in Madrid Aug.<br />
20, 2011. Despite enduring a downpour during the vigil, hundreds of<br />
thousands of young people from around the world spent the night on<br />
the open field. | CNS/PAUL HARING<br />
I do not exaggerate when I say that<br />
this homily changed my life. Though<br />
I was excelling in college academics<br />
and integrated into the extracurricular<br />
life on campus, I was struggling with<br />
self-worth to the point of contemplating<br />
making a permanent exit. The<br />
pope’s words prompted me to make<br />
regular visits to the college chapel on<br />
my way home from the library. There<br />
in the darkness, gazing on the dimly lit<br />
crucifix, I began to have my first real<br />
dialogues with Jesus. Before that point,<br />
I only recall two decades of monologues.<br />
<strong>No</strong>w, I was listening.<br />
Just as we await Church<br />
historians’ assessment of<br />
whether or not there has been<br />
a “Francis Effect” on the life<br />
of the Church — measured<br />
by growth, sacramental participation,<br />
and vocational commitments — it’s<br />
hard to say if they will identify a “Benedict<br />
Effect.” Eight years is not a long<br />
time to shape a generation or two. His<br />
predecessor had 26.<br />
My hunch is that we’re<br />
out there. Let me be clear:<br />
To call myself a “Benedict<br />
XVI” Catholic does not<br />
negate my filial love of<br />
Pope Francis, or make me a<br />
hard-liner (an unfortunate<br />
mischaracterization of the<br />
man and his message). In<br />
fact, my life is informed by<br />
many people of goodwill<br />
who do not practice Catholicism.<br />
Instead, it is to say that I<br />
came of age with him as my<br />
shepherd, and his writing<br />
and preaching helped me<br />
to meet the living Christ.<br />
Like many of my peers, he<br />
convinced me to shape my<br />
life around that friendship.<br />
His soft-spoken encouragement<br />
compelled many of<br />
my friends and me to get<br />
married and welcome children,<br />
enter religious orders,<br />
and become priests. He<br />
taught us to care for the poor<br />
and the planet, and prior to<br />
doing both, to pray.<br />
On the cusp of adulthood,<br />
my peers and I were looking<br />
for something or someone to cling to<br />
when the world was spinning out of<br />
control. A small number of us were<br />
still listening to the Church, even if<br />
we were skeptical of her. It was to that<br />
remnant that Pope Benedict spoke<br />
about Jesus Christ. It was, to be sure, a<br />
very good thing.<br />
Elise Italiano Ureneck is a communications<br />
consultant writing from Rhode<br />
Island.<br />
<strong>January</strong> <strong>13</strong>, <strong>2023</strong> • ANGELUS • 17
Pope Benedict XVI talks to<br />
women holding babies during<br />
his visit to Rome’s Gemelli Hospital<br />
in 2010. | CNS/L’OSSERVA-<br />
TORE ROMANO VIA REUTERS<br />
A SURPRISING MESSENGER<br />
I thought my moment with the pope would come down to ‘small talk.’<br />
But with Benedict, something else spoke louder than his words.<br />
BY KATHRYN JEAN LOPEZ<br />
calling on behalf<br />
of the Holy Father.”<br />
The priest from<br />
New Jersey working<br />
“I’m<br />
in the Vatican prefaced<br />
his words with a plea: “Please<br />
don’t hang up on me when I say what<br />
I’m about to say.”<br />
He had learned from experience that<br />
day. Someone else thought his call<br />
was a prank.<br />
It was just a week before the opening<br />
Mass of the Year of Faith at St. Peter’s<br />
Basilica, also the 50th anniversary<br />
of the closing of the Second Vatican<br />
Council. I was being invited to receive<br />
a message for all the women in the<br />
world (I kid you not).<br />
As the official invite from the<br />
Pontifical Council for Promoting the<br />
New Evangelization put it: “The Holy<br />
Father has invited you to be present<br />
… in order to receive from him a copy<br />
of the message as the representative of<br />
women throughout the world.”<br />
The message was a repeat. In 1965,<br />
at the end of the council, Pope Paul<br />
VI issued “Messages to the People of<br />
God” from the Church. Rulers, artists,<br />
laborers, and women were among<br />
those addressed.<br />
As it was explained to me, Pope Benedict<br />
XVI, at the last minute, had the<br />
18 • ANGELUS • <strong>January</strong> <strong>13</strong>, <strong>2023</strong>
ks to<br />
s during<br />
elli Hos-<br />
’OSSERVA-<br />
UTERS<br />
idea to reissue the messages. I didn’t<br />
ask him, but I assumed it was because<br />
they really hadn’t been communicated<br />
the first time around — both<br />
because of the fog of the times and a<br />
lack of receptivity in the culture.<br />
The message to women he handed<br />
me is beautiful and powerful. Some<br />
excerpts:<br />
• “...at this moment when the human<br />
race is under-going so deep a transformation,<br />
women impregnated<br />
with the spirit of the Gospel can<br />
do so much to aid mankind in not<br />
falling.”<br />
• “Our technology runs the risk of becoming<br />
inhuman. Reconcile men<br />
with life and above all, we beseech<br />
you, watch carefully over the future<br />
of our race. Hold back the hand<br />
of man who, in a moment of folly,<br />
might attempt to destroy human<br />
civilization.”<br />
• “Women of the entire universe,<br />
whether Christian or non-believing,<br />
you to whom life is entrusted at this<br />
grave moment in history, it is for<br />
you to save the peace of the world.”<br />
This message is a game changer, and<br />
is begging to be convened in Catholic<br />
education, in Catholic homes, and to<br />
the world. Women don’t need to be<br />
anything other than what they are naturally<br />
and supernaturally made to be.<br />
In the years since I received that<br />
message from Pope Benedict, I’ve<br />
thought a lot about how Pope Francis<br />
talks about the Church as mother.<br />
The Church can’t be mother without<br />
women impregnated with the spirit of<br />
the Gospel — yes, in leadership roles<br />
in the Church, but also as mothers.<br />
Being a mother is a critical leadership<br />
role in the Church and the world!<br />
I’ll always be grateful to a priest<br />
friend who asked me before I headed<br />
to Rome, “So, what are you going to<br />
say to the Holy Father?”<br />
I hadn’t even considered small talk<br />
as a possibility, but sure enough, there<br />
was. I thanked him for his triptych<br />
— that felt more appropriate than<br />
“trilogy” — on Jesus of Nazareth.<br />
And then, Pope Benedict asked me<br />
where I was from. When I told him<br />
New York, he was exuberant. With his<br />
arms he celebrated the capital of the<br />
world — that’s the only way a New<br />
Yorker could interpret it. He must<br />
have been fondly remembering his<br />
2008 trip there as pontiff. I thanked<br />
him for making our archbishop, Timothy<br />
Dolan, a cardinal.<br />
Pope Benedict offered some kind,<br />
fatherly words in response. But more<br />
than any word that was exchanged, I<br />
remember his gaze. We cannot know<br />
on this earth what it’s like to be met by<br />
the gaze of our heavenly Father.<br />
But if the way Pope Benedict looked<br />
at me that day is even one inkling of<br />
an indication of the magnificence of<br />
his love for us … we just have no idea<br />
how much we are loved! Pope Benedict<br />
didn’t know anything about me,<br />
but he knew the Father’s love for me,<br />
and his gaze was in union with that<br />
reality. What if we looked at others in<br />
such a way every day of our lives?<br />
I almost didn’t make it to meet him<br />
that day. I had travel hiccups like I’d<br />
never experienced before and never<br />
have since. I can’t even begin to tell<br />
you the travails: an angel changed my<br />
flight as I sat in traffic between two<br />
Queens airports. When I finally landed<br />
at Fiumicino Airport, that priest<br />
from New Jersey and I nearly died in<br />
a car accident on the way into the city.<br />
Few times in my life have I felt: God,<br />
you must have me here for a reason.<br />
My late friend, Kate O’Beirne,<br />
would tease me from then on about<br />
not sharing the message as much as<br />
“the representative of all the women<br />
of the world” ought to. At this time<br />
of his passing, I thank God for Pope<br />
Benedict giving me the opportunity to<br />
share it again.<br />
May he come to intercede for us<br />
women so that we can be everything<br />
God made us to be in this present moment<br />
with all its confusion and chaos.<br />
We are called to be beacons of hope<br />
in a way only women can be, and to<br />
encourage men who want us to work<br />
together in complementarity. Pope<br />
Benedict knew. May we live it.<br />
Kathryn Jean Lopez with Pope Benedict XVI at the opening Mass for the Year of Faith Oct. 11, 2012,<br />
receiving a message addressed to all the women in the world. | COURTESY IMAGE<br />
Kathryn Jean Lopez is senior fellow<br />
at the National Review Institute,<br />
editor-at-large of National Review<br />
magazine, and the author of “A Year<br />
with the Mystics: Visionary Wisdom for<br />
Daily Living” (Tan Books, $44.95).<br />
<strong>January</strong> <strong>13</strong>, <strong>2023</strong> • ANGELUS • 19
A MAN OF THE WORD<br />
The writings and speeches of Joseph Ratzinger as a<br />
professor, bishop, and later pope formed and inspired<br />
multitudes. Here are a few of his most enduring quotes.<br />
“The happiness you are<br />
seeking, the happiness you<br />
have a right to enjoy, has a<br />
name and a face: it is Jesus<br />
of Nazareth.”<br />
~ World Youth Day, Cologne, 2005<br />
“From the crisis of today<br />
the Church of tomorrow<br />
will emerge — a Church<br />
that has lost much. She will<br />
become small and will have<br />
to start afresh more or less<br />
from the beginning.”<br />
~ German radio broadcast, 1969<br />
“Do not be afraid of Christ!<br />
He takes nothing away, and<br />
he gives you everything.<br />
When we give ourselves<br />
to him, we receive a<br />
hundredfold in return.”<br />
~ Papal Inauguration Mass, Rome, 2005<br />
“In today’s world the<br />
theme of truth has all but<br />
disappeared, because truth<br />
appears too great for man,<br />
and yet everything falls<br />
apart if there is no truth.”<br />
~ Autobiography “Milestones,” 1988<br />
“I ask you to look at the face<br />
of the other and to discover<br />
that he has a soul, a history<br />
and a life, that he is a<br />
person and that God loves<br />
this person as much as he<br />
loves themself.”<br />
~ Feast of the Baptism of the Lord, Rome, 2010<br />
“Each of us is willed, each<br />
of us is loved, each of us is<br />
necessary. There is nothing<br />
more beautiful than to be<br />
surprised by the Gospel, by<br />
the encounter with Christ.”<br />
~ Papal Inauguration Mass, Rome, 2005<br />
“The love of Christ impels<br />
us to devote ourselves<br />
without reserve to<br />
proclaiming his Name<br />
throughout America,<br />
bringing it freely and<br />
enthusiastically to the<br />
hearts of all its inhabitants.<br />
There is no more rewarding<br />
or beneficial work than<br />
this.”<br />
~ Address to “Ecclesia in America” Congress, Rome,<br />
2012<br />
“The saints are the true<br />
reformers. Only from the<br />
saints, only from God does<br />
true revolution come, the<br />
definitive way to change the<br />
world.”<br />
~ World Youth Day, Cologne, 2005<br />
20 • ANGELUS • <strong>January</strong> <strong>13</strong>, <strong>2023</strong>
“Being Christian is not the<br />
result of an ethical choice<br />
or a lofty idea, but the<br />
encounter with an event, a<br />
person, which gives life a<br />
new horizon and a decisive<br />
direction.”<br />
~ Encyclical letter “Deus Caritas Est,” 2005<br />
“<strong>No</strong> one lives alone. <strong>No</strong><br />
one sins alone. <strong>No</strong> one is<br />
saved alone. The lives of<br />
others continually spill over<br />
into mine: in what I think,<br />
say, do and achieve. And<br />
conversely, my life spills<br />
over into that of others: for<br />
better and for worse.”<br />
~ Encyclical letter “Spe Salvi,” 2007<br />
“There are values which<br />
must never be abandoned<br />
for a greater value and even<br />
surpass the preservation<br />
of physical life. There is<br />
martyrdom. God is [about]<br />
more than mere physical<br />
survival.”<br />
~ Letter written as pope emeritus, 2019<br />
“Lord, I love you!”<br />
~ Last words before death on Dec. 31, 2022<br />
“The one who has hope<br />
lives differently; the one<br />
who hopes has been<br />
granted the gift of a new<br />
life.”<br />
~ Encyclical letter “Spe Salvi,” 2007<br />
Upper left: L’OSSERVATORE ROMANO VIA CNA;<br />
Above: FILIPPO MONTEFORTE/AFP VIA GETTY<br />
<strong>January</strong> <strong>13</strong>, <strong>2023</strong> • ANGELUS • 21
One thousand four-hundred sixty-two small white<br />
bags with a tea-light battery-charged candle inside<br />
were arranged in a “luminaria” along the cathedral’s<br />
south ambulatory. The bags represented the number<br />
of identified homeless persons who died on LA’s<br />
streets from <strong>January</strong> to <strong>No</strong>vember 2022.<br />
Light for a crisis<br />
Religious and community leaders joined to<br />
remember LA’s homeless dead by their names.<br />
BY TOM HOFFARTH / PHOTOGRAPHY BY VICTOR ALEMÁN<br />
Delia Johnson heard from her<br />
family contacts that Major<br />
Slaughter, the brother of her<br />
former husband, had died recently after<br />
a long struggle experiencing homelessness.<br />
Johnson knew a bit about the<br />
situation of the man best known by as<br />
“Cowboy.” But she had long since lost<br />
touch with him.<br />
Information about a service would<br />
come soon, she was told. Slaughter’s<br />
daughter had claimed his body from<br />
the coroner’s office and was waiting<br />
for it to be released for cremation. The<br />
coroner noted the 63-year-old died<br />
<strong>No</strong>v. 5, with the cause listed as “natural/unknown.”<br />
Still, the gravity of Slaughter’s passing<br />
didn’t really resonate with Johnson until<br />
she and a friend were quietly leaving<br />
the Cathedral of Our Lady of the Angels<br />
Dec. 21 following the Archdiocese<br />
of Los Angeles’ first Homeless Persons<br />
Interreligious Memorial.<br />
Those in attendance were encouraged<br />
to take with them one or more<br />
of the small white bags with a tea-light<br />
battery-charged candle inside arranged<br />
in a “luminaria” along the cathedral’s<br />
south ambulatory.<br />
As Johnson scanned the names on<br />
the bags, the one with Slaughter’s<br />
name caught her eye — one of 1,462<br />
set upon the granite-tiled floor. That<br />
number represents all those homeless<br />
who could be identified that had died<br />
on the streets of Los Angeles this past<br />
year through <strong>No</strong>v. 30.<br />
As Johnson picked up the bag, she felt<br />
the impact of the evening.<br />
“It was the work of the Holy Spirit,”<br />
said the Compton resident and longtime<br />
parishioner at St. Lawrence of<br />
Brindisi Church in Watts.<br />
“I was thinking about the procession,<br />
the reflections, the Gospel reading,<br />
and how all the ministers had shown<br />
solidarity in such a purposeful and purpose-filled<br />
occasion. But who knew my<br />
brother-in-law was spiritually calling<br />
my name? Hush, hush, somebody’s<br />
calling my name!”<br />
Johnson has been involved in an<br />
array of community organizations over<br />
the years, and today she serves on the<br />
Archdiocese of Los Angeles’ Anti-Racism<br />
Task Force. She said she was drawn<br />
to the service to support the efforts of<br />
22 • ANGELUS • <strong>January</strong> <strong>13</strong>, <strong>2023</strong>
white<br />
inside<br />
edral’s<br />
number<br />
LA’s<br />
the Office of Life, Justice and Peace<br />
(OLJP), which spent months organizing<br />
the event.<br />
More than a dozen faith leaders from<br />
around Southern California joined<br />
Archbishop José H. Gomez for the<br />
event, including representatives from<br />
Hindu, Jewish, Buddhist, Bahá’í, and<br />
Muslim traditions as well as Lutheran,<br />
Episcopal, and Church of Jesus Christ<br />
of Latter-day Saints congregations.<br />
In the front row was newly inaugurated<br />
Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass,<br />
whose campaign prioritized addressing<br />
homeless issues. Following through on<br />
a campaign promise, Bass declared a<br />
state of emergency over homelessness<br />
on her first day in office earlier this<br />
month.<br />
“The concept wasn’t meant as a<br />
Catholic experience, but for all the<br />
communities and neighborhoods in<br />
our city and county,” said OLJP Senior<br />
Director Michael Donaldson.<br />
Donaldson noted that since 1990, the<br />
National Coalition for the Homeless<br />
had been staging a National Homeless<br />
Person’s Memorial Day on Dec. 21,<br />
encouraging more participation nationally.<br />
The memorial is consciously set<br />
for the date of the winter solstice, the<br />
longest night of the year.<br />
Before reflecting on the Gospel reading<br />
of the parable of the good Samaritan<br />
in his remarks, Archbishop Gomez<br />
welcomed Mayor Bass, thanking her<br />
for prioritizing homelessness and praying<br />
that God grant her “wisdom and<br />
courage, prudence, and humility.”<br />
In his remarks, Archbishop Gomez<br />
remembered those who died on the<br />
streets, asking that “the home they<br />
could not find on earth, they now find<br />
in heaven, secure in the merciful arms<br />
of God.”<br />
He also prayed that all those present<br />
could receive the “courage and creativity<br />
that we need in order to meet the<br />
challenges of this moment in our city.”<br />
Pastor Stephanie Jaeger of the Evangelical<br />
Lutheran Synod of Southern<br />
California touted the advantage that<br />
faith-based groups have over government<br />
offices in addressing the crisis.<br />
“Faith communities are all about<br />
long-lasting relationships,” she said.<br />
“It’s something different than the services<br />
offered that can isolate and segregate.<br />
We are one with the divine that<br />
restores and renews and transforms. We<br />
bring the gift of welcome and solidarity<br />
and sacred space, and a shared sense of<br />
belonging to each other.”<br />
The memorial occurred just weeks after<br />
the Los Angeles County Crematorium<br />
Cemetery in Boyle Heights laid to<br />
rest the cremated remains of more than<br />
Counting<br />
the lost<br />
A homeless person on<br />
Wilshire Avenue near<br />
Koreatown in <strong>January</strong>.<br />
1,600 people in a mass grave — bodies<br />
unclaimed since 2019. Many among<br />
them were presumably homeless with<br />
no known family members to claim<br />
them.<br />
Father Chris Ponnet, one of several<br />
religious leaders who officiates at the<br />
burial, said such events are key to<br />
Statistics often used in media stories to quantify homelessness in LA may<br />
almost seem desensitizing, but they are worth considering when put into<br />
context:<br />
• In 2022, data from the Los Angeles Homeless Services Authority<br />
(LAHSA) shows nearly 70,000 people in LA County and more than 40,000<br />
in LA city limits were without permanent shelter. That meant they were<br />
either surviving on the streets or in parks, or huddled in RVs or parked<br />
cars. Those numbers are a more than 4% increase from the 2020 Homeless<br />
Count.<br />
LAHSA is the lead agency in the HUD-funded Los Angeles Continuum<br />
of Care, managing more than $790 million annually in federal, state,<br />
county, and city funds for programs providing shelter, housing, and services<br />
to people experiencing homelessness.<br />
The <strong>2023</strong> Greater Los Angeles Homeless Count is scheduled for Jan. 24-<br />
26. Visit TheyCountWillYou.org for more information.<br />
• The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health reports that the<br />
mortality rates among the homeless have more than doubled over the last<br />
eight years — from 630 in 2014 to more than 1,400 in its last full count of<br />
2020. The total will likely reach an all-time high of 1,600-plus for 2022.<br />
• Data shows more than 80% of those homeless who died were males.<br />
And while African Americans make up about 10% of the LA County population,<br />
they account for more than 25% of homeless deaths, according to<br />
LAHSA.<br />
• Only 1% of Los Angeles’ 3.8 million people are documented as experiencing<br />
homelessness. But LA County data showed that, during the first<br />
year of the pandemic, three times as many homeless died in this region<br />
than in New York City — 1,899 from April 2020 through March 2021.<br />
That happened despite the numbers showing New York City has more<br />
homeless people (78,000 of its 8 million total) than LA County (with 10<br />
million people).<br />
— Tom Hoffarth<br />
<strong>January</strong> <strong>13</strong>, <strong>2023</strong> • ANGELUS • 23
Interreligious representatives, and LA Mayor Karen Bass (center), attended the vigil service.<br />
acknowledging “the dignity of each<br />
person in life and in death.”<br />
“We have to realize these are people<br />
who could have died from COVID,”<br />
said Father Ponnet, pastor at the St.<br />
Camillus Center for Pastoral Care and<br />
chaplain at USC Keck Medical Center<br />
near downtown.<br />
“Hopefully this motivates people to<br />
say to the larger group: Health care is<br />
needed for all, and the homeless are<br />
our family, our neighbors. That’s the<br />
challenge for any religious group.”<br />
For more than 20 years, Jess Echeverry<br />
has guided the Westchester-based<br />
nonprofit organization SOFESA,<br />
which aims to help alleviate obstacles<br />
facing homeless and low-income families<br />
in Southern California. SOFESA<br />
and the Society of St. Vincent de Paul<br />
Los Angeles partnered with Donaldson’s<br />
office to organize the vigil.<br />
“It could have been me,” said Echeverry,<br />
who was homeless for seven years.<br />
Echeverry said that in addition to<br />
those who die from drug overdoses,<br />
assault, or even hypothermia, the<br />
homeless face a more hidden threat:<br />
the temptation to take one’s own life to<br />
end their misery and hopelessness. She<br />
said she attempted suicide twice during<br />
her homelessness.<br />
“For me, this is an important event<br />
because, in my heart, I’m doing something<br />
for the value of heaven — this<br />
has a spiritual value,” said Echeverry.<br />
“Does everyone know these names?<br />
<strong>No</strong>, but for these people who passed,<br />
I do believe they can see this and feel<br />
this. And most importantly, God sees<br />
us loving them.”<br />
Donaldson hopes such events help<br />
inspire more advocates for mental<br />
health, drug-addiction treatment, and a<br />
better system of foster care.<br />
“Parish communities can be voices for<br />
the voiceless, getting involved in their<br />
city councils and homeless committees,”<br />
said Donaldson, who worked<br />
with Chancellor Sister Mary Anncarla<br />
Costello, SND, and longtime archdiocesan<br />
Interfaith Officer Father Alexei<br />
Smith to plan the event.<br />
One of the charitable action items<br />
tied to the memorial was a QR code<br />
linking to a website where sleeping<br />
bags, socks, and blankets could be<br />
purchased for distribution. Community<br />
drives to collect items in connection to<br />
the memorial were taken up at St. Paul<br />
the Apostle in Westwood, St. Jerome<br />
Church in Westchester, St. Elizabeth<br />
Ann Seton Church in Rowland<br />
Heights, St. Linus Church in <strong>No</strong>rwalk,<br />
Dignity California Hospital Medical<br />
Center, Cantwell Sacred Heart<br />
of Mary High School, and UCLA’s<br />
Catholic Center.<br />
While venues including the Los<br />
Angeles Mission homeless shelter near<br />
Skid Row and St. Monica’s Church<br />
in Santa Monica have held regular<br />
interfaith memorials in the past, Donaldson<br />
foresees this larger-scale service<br />
continuing with a rotation of places of<br />
worship acting as hosts.<br />
“This isn’t meant to be a one-time<br />
event, but something to change the<br />
heart and mindset of how we want<br />
to remember those who died on the<br />
streets with dignity and purpose,” said<br />
Donaldson.<br />
Tom Hoffarth is an award-winning<br />
journalist based in Los Angeles.<br />
24 • ANGELUS • <strong>January</strong> <strong>13</strong>, <strong>2023</strong>
<strong>January</strong> <strong>13</strong>, <strong>2023</strong> • ANGELUS • 25
‘Jesus, is<br />
that you?’<br />
Inmates celebrated the<br />
return of a Christmas<br />
tradition to LA Men’s<br />
Central Jail with<br />
prayers, presents, and<br />
even a few laughs.<br />
BY PABLO KAY /<br />
PHOTOGRAPHY BY<br />
VICTOR ALEMÁN<br />
After the first group of 33 inmates<br />
filed into the chapel of LA<br />
Men’s Central Jail the morning<br />
of Dec. 25 came the first Christmas<br />
surprise: due to an unspecified “situation”<br />
at the jail that morning, they’d<br />
be the only ones at Mass with Archbishop<br />
José H. Gomez this year.<br />
The only ones, that is, apart from the<br />
armed LA County Sheriff’s deputies<br />
keeping watch from the windowless<br />
chapel’s choir loft.<br />
As their special pale green jumpsuits<br />
indicated, these chosen few were a<br />
group of jail “trustees,” inmates whose<br />
good behavior and personal improvement<br />
has earned them smaller<br />
freedoms — including work in the<br />
kitchen — outside of their cells. This<br />
morning, several were wearing plastic<br />
rosaries around their tattooed necks<br />
for the occasion. A few brought bags<br />
of them in hopes of getting them<br />
blessed later.<br />
Once the Mass began, cues from a<br />
female cantor and jail chaplain Father<br />
Paul Griesgraber told them when to<br />
stand. When it was time to sit, some<br />
of the inmates fidgeted in the scarred,<br />
creaky pews. Others closed their eyes<br />
in prayer. Most tried mouthing the<br />
Christmas carols in their printed<br />
booklets.<br />
After hearing Luke’s account of the<br />
birth of Jesus in the Gospel, the day’s<br />
celebrant had little trouble keeping<br />
their attention.<br />
“Christmas is the promise that God<br />
cares personally for each one of us,<br />
that he’ll never leave us alone,” began<br />
the archbishop during the homily.<br />
The archbishop explained that<br />
God chose to come to the world as a<br />
baby, “so that he doesn’t frighten us.”<br />
Archbishop José H. Gomez hands an inmate a prayer<br />
card with the words of Our Lady of Guadalupe to St.<br />
Juan Diego after Christmas Mass on Dec. 25, 2022.<br />
This same Jesus wants to give us the<br />
strength and grace to “live our lives<br />
as a living Nativity scene,” he assured<br />
them, and all we have to do is ask for<br />
it.<br />
Due to the pandemic, this was Archbishop<br />
Gomez’s first Christmas Mass<br />
at the jail since 2019. As witnesses<br />
26 • ANGELUS • <strong>January</strong> <strong>13</strong>, <strong>2023</strong>
from past years can attest, the day’s<br />
message gets across rather easily to<br />
this crowd.<br />
Jail chaplain Steve Borja, an evangelical<br />
Christian with a background<br />
in counseling, was among those at the<br />
Mass. Even during the first months<br />
of COVID-19 he was allowed to<br />
walk the “tiers,” or cell rows, to visit<br />
inmates. His Catholic counterpart,<br />
Edgar Jimenez, later arrived to join<br />
him in the summer of 2020.<br />
“When we were coming in, they<br />
were actually surprised to see a chaplain,”<br />
recalled Borja. “It was a dark<br />
gray time inside the jail.”<br />
Although different in their approaches<br />
to ministry, the pair found themselves<br />
in high demand during the<br />
pandemic. Jimenez said the inmates<br />
valued the in-person contact in a time<br />
of isolation.<br />
“I wasn’t afraid of reaching out and<br />
shaking their hands,” said Jimenez.<br />
“That right there, it means a lot to<br />
them, and to me as well.”<br />
After the Mass, Archbishop Gomez<br />
was allowed to do the same. As in<br />
years past, he walked through two of<br />
the more restricted cell rows on the<br />
jail’s third floor. This time he handed<br />
out a prayer card with the words of<br />
Our Lady of Guadalupe to St. Juan<br />
Diego and a copy of “The Whole<br />
Language: The Power of Extravagant<br />
Tenderness” (Avid Reader Press /<br />
Simon & Schuster, $27), the latest<br />
book by Father Greg Boyle, founder<br />
of Homeboy Industries.<br />
The scene on the third floor of the<br />
jail — among the “worst of the worst”<br />
in the country, according to the<br />
chaplains — was not exactly uplifting.<br />
Plastic wrappers and used Styrofoam<br />
cups littered the floors of several cells.<br />
Plenty of images were attached to the<br />
walls — some of family members,<br />
others of favorite sports teams, and<br />
still others that shouldn’t be described<br />
here. Behind the extra orange jumpsuits<br />
hung up between cell bars for<br />
privacy — a forbidden practice known<br />
as “tinting” — colorful words could<br />
be heard.<br />
One by one, the archbishop handed<br />
them their gifts and gave blessings to<br />
those who asked. He took his time<br />
to stop and chat with some, either in<br />
English or Spanish.<br />
Walking with him were several<br />
deputies, the jail captain, and Father<br />
Griesgraber, whose long white hair<br />
and beard (not cut since the start of<br />
the pandemic, he said) has made him<br />
a jail celebrity.<br />
“Jesus, is that you?” exclaimed<br />
one inmate as Father Griesgraber<br />
approached his cell alongside the<br />
archbishop.<br />
“Yeah, Jesus is right here,” the<br />
archbishop shot back, catching the<br />
joke directed at the man some call<br />
“Father Gandalf,” a reference to the<br />
gray-bearded protagonist in the J.R.R.<br />
Tolkien novels, “The Hobbit” and the<br />
“Lord of the Rings.” The inmates and<br />
deputies erupted in laughter together.<br />
Once the archbishop had visited the<br />
two pre-assigned cell rows, yells could<br />
be heard in the next one over. They<br />
had heard the commotion and wanted<br />
to see the visitor, too. With just a few<br />
seconds to decide, the guards in the<br />
entourage looked at one another in<br />
hesitation. “Why not?” seemed to be<br />
the unspoken consensus.<br />
After it was all over and Archbishop<br />
Gomez had left to celebrate his next<br />
Christmas Mass at the Cathedral of<br />
Our Lady of the Angels, Father Griesgraber<br />
offered his assessment of the<br />
morning’s proceedings.<br />
“They’re honored to be able to participate,<br />
to be able to get out,” said the<br />
priest. “They were grateful.”<br />
What came to mind were the words<br />
of the archbishop’s homily, delivered<br />
in terms the inmates could understand:<br />
the weakness of a newborn<br />
baby, the beauty of a family, and the<br />
importance of “not doing what we<br />
want, but what God wants.”<br />
“Archbishop relates at that level with<br />
them,” the priest said. “He’s got a<br />
special way of relating.”<br />
Inmates at LA Men’s<br />
Central Jail during<br />
Christmas Mass with<br />
Archbishop Gomez on<br />
Dec. 25, 2022.<br />
Father Griesgraber<br />
and Jimenez<br />
said they’ve seen<br />
God’s hand<br />
at work in the<br />
inmates.<br />
“You feel the<br />
spirit of God<br />
coming when<br />
you give them<br />
that chance, not<br />
by analyzing<br />
them, or giving<br />
them all the<br />
answers, but<br />
<strong>January</strong> <strong>13</strong>, <strong>2023</strong> • ANGELUS • 27
Archbishop Gomez greets inmates<br />
at the end of Christmas Mass at LA<br />
Men’s Central Jail Dec. 25, 2022.<br />
acknowledging them as children of<br />
God,” said Jimenez. “That’s a game<br />
changer, but you gotta give ’em that<br />
space.”<br />
Space, among other things, was a big<br />
challenge in the jail, too. But soon<br />
after the pandemic hit, thousands of<br />
low-level offenders were released from<br />
facilities around the county. That,<br />
along with the new, more lenient policies<br />
of new District Attorney George<br />
Gascon, has seen the jail population<br />
fall from its 5,000-plus capacity to<br />
around 4,000 inmates.<br />
“<strong>No</strong>w we have a different clientele<br />
that’s slightly more challenging,” said<br />
Jimenez, choosing his words carefully.<br />
“But once you get to know them,<br />
interact with them, then you start to<br />
break down that wall.”<br />
Father Griesgraber has served at the<br />
jail for the last five years. He’s learned<br />
to take things slowly with the inmates<br />
that request his services. Eventually,<br />
some Catholics will ask for confession<br />
or permission to attend weekly Mass<br />
— but only when they feel ready.<br />
“We move gracefully into the sacraments,”<br />
said the chaplain.<br />
What impresses him the most? Hearing<br />
the prayers, he said, of men who<br />
know the wrong they’re capable of<br />
doing, and the hurt they’ve caused.<br />
“They pray much better than I do,”<br />
said Father Griesgraber. “They’re<br />
praying out of their wounds.”<br />
Pablo Kay is the editor-in-chief of<br />
<strong>Angelus</strong>.
Toward<br />
true victory?<br />
The way forward<br />
for common ground<br />
on abortion in our<br />
post-Dobbs era is<br />
becoming clearer.<br />
BY CHARLIE CAMOSY<br />
A woman holds a child in 2016 at a maternity home in Riverside, New Jersey. | CNS/JEFFREY BRUNO<br />
You can be forgiven as a pro-lifer<br />
if your jubilation after the<br />
overturning of Roe has turned<br />
into something, well, let’s call it “less<br />
positive.”<br />
It is understandable even if your<br />
feelings have become quite negative.<br />
Dramatic defeats at the ballot box,<br />
pro-choice Democrats and dishonest<br />
abortion activists ruling the airwaves<br />
and social media, and feckless Republicans<br />
unwilling to fight for basic<br />
human rights have been the order of<br />
the day since June.<br />
I do not share this view, but I’ve<br />
started to see even serious pro-lifers<br />
whisper that maybe overturning Roe,<br />
while clearly a short-term victory,<br />
could be the start of our losing the<br />
broader culture. In my book on Peter<br />
Singer’s work, I note that he and many<br />
other supporters of abortion rights<br />
certainly thought that Roe provoked<br />
the kind of pro-life backlash that we<br />
otherwise would not have seen — and<br />
that a democratic process (akin to<br />
the ones that took place in Europe,<br />
Australia, and elsewhere) would more<br />
securely enshrine abortion rights in<br />
the longer term.<br />
We must not allow that to happen.<br />
That it is now more likely is all the<br />
more reason for pro-lifers to work<br />
even harder on behalf of fundamental<br />
human dignity and equality across the<br />
board, including (and especially) for<br />
prenatal children who cannot speak<br />
up in their own defense.<br />
But as I write these words during the<br />
30 • ANGELUS • <strong>January</strong> <strong>13</strong>, <strong>2023</strong>
time of Christmas, there is no better<br />
reminder of the intensely intimate<br />
relationship between a prenatal child<br />
and her mother than thinking of the<br />
(very) pregnant Mary, mother of God.<br />
Church Fathers like St. Augustine<br />
used to say that Jesus received his<br />
human flesh from the Virgin Mary.<br />
<strong>No</strong>wadays we can express this with<br />
more biological precision: She literally<br />
exchanged blood and other tissue<br />
with God!<br />
But that kind of intimate relationship<br />
should also cause pro-lifers to think,<br />
not just about protecting the prenatal<br />
child under law (though that is<br />
essential), but also about protecting<br />
and supporting her mother. And here,<br />
quite frankly, there are lots of reasons<br />
for hope in our post-Dobbs moment.<br />
Indeed, for every ignorant op-ed<br />
from professors at <strong>No</strong>tre Dame, there<br />
are dozens of thoughtful ideas coming<br />
from pro-choice people about how<br />
we might cooperate together across<br />
our differences on abortion to support<br />
women and families. After all, if someone<br />
is genuinely pro-choice — and<br />
not pro-abortion — they should and<br />
will work with us to create the kind of<br />
culture that helps women choose to<br />
keep their children.<br />
Working for this kind of common<br />
ground has been a central part of my<br />
vocation as a Catholic moral theologian<br />
and pro-life bioethicist. I’ve<br />
urged especially Catholic pro-lifers to<br />
become leaders in this search for common<br />
ground. St. Pope John Paul II, in<br />
his great social encyclical “Laborem<br />
excercens” (“Through Work”), wrote<br />
that Catholics should work to restructure<br />
labor so women do not have to<br />
choose between being mothers and a<br />
vocation they may have in the broader<br />
workforce.<br />
Writing in America magazine, John<br />
Carr and Kim Daniels — co-directors<br />
of Georgetown’s Initiative on Catholic<br />
Social Thought and Public Life —<br />
showed that expansion of the child tax<br />
credit can and should bring together<br />
pro-life Republicans and Democrats<br />
who otherwise support abortion rights.<br />
And guess who followed right behind<br />
them with the same kind of support<br />
just six days later? You guessed it: Patrick<br />
Brown and Brad Wilcox, writing<br />
in a very different magazine: First<br />
Things.<br />
Or how about publicly pro-choice<br />
voices like Mary Ziegler and Reva Seigel<br />
teaming up in the opinion pages<br />
of CNN with publicly pro-life voices<br />
like Erika Bachiochi and Daniel K.<br />
Williams to argue for a united front in<br />
favor of the “urgently needed” Pregnant<br />
Workers Fairness Act (PWFA).<br />
Also supported by the United States<br />
Conference of Catholic Bishops, this<br />
law would go a long way to shaping labor<br />
in ways that Pope John Paul asked<br />
that it be shaped so that women are<br />
not structurally forced into making a<br />
deeply painful choice between being<br />
a mother and following other aspects<br />
of her vocation in the workforce.<br />
Happily, progress is being made.<br />
While the expanded child tax credit<br />
has not (yet) passed, whatever one<br />
thinks of the new omnibus spending<br />
bill, it is fantastic news that the<br />
PWFA — after long negotiation and<br />
compromise across the aisle — was ultimately<br />
included. As was the PUMP<br />
Act, a bill which gave women who<br />
need to pump breast milk at work far<br />
more rights and access to do so. The<br />
omnibus also funds states so they can<br />
permanently extend health care coverage<br />
to poor women for 12 months<br />
after birth.<br />
These are great victories, but pro-lifers<br />
must not stop here. We must let<br />
those who we send to Congress to do<br />
our pro-life bidding to not only pass<br />
bills that restrict abortion supply but<br />
also bills that reduce abortion demand<br />
by supporting mothers and families.<br />
We need expanded child tax credits,<br />
adoption reform, help with child<br />
care (especially at home), a formal<br />
campaign against intimate partner violence<br />
(which drives many abortions),<br />
and more.<br />
For Catholics, this means that we<br />
must breathe out of both our pro-life<br />
and social justice lungs. Prenatal children<br />
— and their mothers — deserve<br />
nothing less.<br />
Charlie Camosy is professor of<br />
Medical Humanities at the Creighton<br />
University School of Medicine. In addition,<br />
he holds the Monsignor Curran<br />
Fellowship in Moral Theology at St.<br />
Joseph Seminary in New York.<br />
<strong>January</strong> <strong>13</strong>, <strong>2023</strong> • ANGELUS • 31
Faking Christmas<br />
Two classics starring Catholic actress Barbara Stanwyck<br />
challenge our superficial approach to the holiday.<br />
BY JOSEPH JOYCE<br />
Dennis Morgan and Barbara Stanwyck in “Christmas in Connecticut.” | IMDB<br />
Christmas as we know it has<br />
always been about performance.<br />
As children we are<br />
raised as shepherds with pillowcases<br />
draped over our heads. Outside the<br />
pageant we soon learn to fake enthusiasm<br />
when we open the gift box to<br />
find that, through some clerical error,<br />
Santa has given us clothes. As we<br />
mature we become Santa ourselves,<br />
chomping cookies in half to mimic<br />
his haste.<br />
We string lights outside the house,<br />
a performance of Christmas cheer<br />
that loses significance once the<br />
extended family goes home. When it<br />
comes to caroling, we basically hunt<br />
down our neighbors to inflict holiday<br />
cheer against their will. The yuletide<br />
demands an audience; if a Christmas<br />
tree falls in the woods and there’s no<br />
one around, does it make a sound?<br />
Two black-and-white films that challenge<br />
the Christmas of mere appearances<br />
are “Christmas in Connecticut”<br />
(1945) and “Remember the Night”<br />
(1940), each coincidentally showcasing<br />
my favorite movie star, Catholic<br />
convert Barbara Stanwyck.<br />
Stanwyck was a dual threat of comedienne<br />
and dramatic actress, a searing<br />
firecracker of a woman against whom<br />
I measure all past and prospective<br />
romantic partners. I guess you could<br />
say I admire her work. This piece,<br />
like most of my life, is a machination<br />
arranged just to talk about her.<br />
“Christmas in Connecticut” finds<br />
her in farcical territory, playing Elizabeth,<br />
a magazine writer beloved by<br />
housewives across the country for her<br />
homemaking and cooking tips. Her<br />
lone male fan is a convalescing veteran<br />
(Dennis Morgan) who requests,<br />
and is thus granted by her editor, a<br />
Christmas feast at her quaint country<br />
home.<br />
The only hitch is that she has no<br />
such home, or indeed any ability to<br />
cook. Such was the Wild West before<br />
LinkedIn, where a firm handshake<br />
was the only reference you needed. In<br />
classic farce fashion there are complex<br />
webs of white lies and noms de<br />
plume, thwarted engagements and<br />
busted soufflés, stolen sleigh rides and<br />
pilfered infants. Basic stuff, really.<br />
The beats are familiar to anyone<br />
with a cursory knowledge with the<br />
act structure of “Frasier,” but the film<br />
hits at something far deeper than the<br />
usual hijinks. Although Elizabeth lies<br />
to her readers, it’s merely a donation<br />
to the common lie we all maintain.<br />
The trappings of American Christmas<br />
were largely born in the wake of the<br />
Great Depression and two world wars.<br />
Think on “White Christmas,” which<br />
is a nostalgic song about nostalgia<br />
itself.<br />
On some level, the viewer knows that<br />
Elizabeth and her pastoral picaresque<br />
32 • ANGELUS • <strong>January</strong> <strong>13</strong>, <strong>2023</strong>
are fiction. The difference is we aren’t<br />
nearly as surprised as Elizabeth is to<br />
find accomplices to her charade.<br />
If “Christmas in Connecticut” is<br />
about the power of Christmas illusions,<br />
“Remember the Night” is a necessary<br />
corrective on their dangers. The<br />
latter stars Stanwyck as Lee, a shoplifter<br />
arrested just before Christmas.<br />
Sensing the jury is filled with festive<br />
pity, the district attorney Jack (Fred<br />
MacMurray, in an early pairing with<br />
Stanwyck before “Double Indemnity”)<br />
decides to postpone the trial until<br />
after Christmas. Feeling a tad guilty<br />
for his trick, especially upon learning<br />
they’re both from rural Indiana, Jack<br />
offers to drive her back home to visit<br />
her estranged family on his own way<br />
back home.<br />
The setup feels familiar, as if the<br />
film anticipated the hegemony of<br />
Hallmark movies over the American<br />
psyche. But more impressive is how<br />
it deflates those same expectations as<br />
soon as they approach. Lee’s family<br />
reunion seems destined for mawkish<br />
tears and group hugs, but the movie<br />
doesn’t hedge from brutal truths:<br />
Families don’t estrange themselves for<br />
no reason, and too often when we lay<br />
ourselves at another’s feet, they prove<br />
too small to lift us back up.<br />
Mortified at his failure, both Jack<br />
and the film pivot to his boyhood<br />
farm, where his family proves far kinder<br />
to Lee than her own.<br />
Both Lee and the audience finally<br />
feel at ease. This is how Christmas<br />
should go. The farm is a bucolic paradise,<br />
the fake Connecticut country<br />
home made reality. Corn is popped,<br />
carols are sung, the yuletide generally<br />
made gay. (Jack’s sweet hearted<br />
mother is actually played by George<br />
Bailey’s mom from “It’s a Wonderful<br />
Life.”) We see Lee blossom as their<br />
unconditional love gives her the space<br />
to relish her existence, instead of<br />
continually justifying it.<br />
When a different sort of love starts to<br />
grow between Jack and Lee, we again<br />
feel the inevitable tug of festivity.<br />
We know this path, and it ends with<br />
mistletoe. But “Remember the Night”<br />
remains special because it too feels<br />
this tug and yanks back. As Jack’s<br />
mom sees the lingering looks between<br />
the pair, she begins to fret at the<br />
thought of her son hitching his wagon<br />
to a felon.<br />
Despite her brief sojourn as part of<br />
the family, Lee is firmly reminded that<br />
she is but a guest. We understand that<br />
Lee is life’s eternal visitor, welcome so<br />
long as she doesn’t settle.<br />
If Lee is to be saved, it isn’t in the<br />
trappings of Christmas. These are<br />
mere signifiers of the season. Christmas<br />
came to Connecticut not in the<br />
promised feast, but in the conspiracy<br />
of friends that made it happen. And<br />
Christmas wasn’t found in small-town<br />
Barbara Stanwyck (second from right) in a<br />
scene from “Remember the Night.” | IMDB<br />
Indiana, arranged like the interior of<br />
a snow globe. It comes later in a frigid<br />
New York courtroom, where Jack and<br />
Lee each try to sacrifice their future so<br />
the other doesn’t have to.<br />
It’s no sin to be cozy, but to quote<br />
singer Jason Isbell, “You thought God<br />
was an architect, now you know/ he’s<br />
something like a pipe bomb ready to<br />
blow.” Jesus is the prince of peace, but<br />
sometimes it’s far easier to see him in<br />
the chaos.<br />
Joseph Joyce is a screenwriter and freelance<br />
critic based in Sherman Oaks.<br />
<strong>January</strong> <strong>13</strong>, <strong>2023</strong> • ANGELUS • 33
DESIRE LINES<br />
HEATHER KING<br />
An apostle for the addicted<br />
Editor’s note: The following column first<br />
appeared in The Tidings in July 2015. It<br />
has been updated by the author in light<br />
of Msgr. Richey’s death last month.<br />
When I came into the Church<br />
26 years ago, I wasn’t friends<br />
with a single practicing<br />
Catholic, much less a Catholic who<br />
might understand that I’d been led<br />
to Christ through my recovery from<br />
alcoholism.<br />
Msgr. Thomas Terrence Richey. | SUBMITTED PHOTO<br />
Then I met Msgr. Thomas Terrence<br />
Richey, known by recovering alcoholics<br />
and addicts throughout the archdiocese<br />
and beyond as Father Terry.<br />
Anyone who knew Father Terry knew<br />
that he was the king of the one-liner.<br />
“Drinking never made me happy —<br />
but it made me feel like I was going to<br />
be happy in 15 minutes.<br />
“The good news is God loves you.<br />
The bad news is he loves everyone else,<br />
too.”<br />
I once asked him how I’d know if<br />
I was making spiritual progress. He<br />
thought for a minute. “If crazy people<br />
aren’t afraid to come up and talk to<br />
you,” he replied, “that’s a pretty good<br />
sign.”<br />
A native of Hawthorne, Father Terry<br />
entered the seminary at 14, served as<br />
director of Alcohol/Substance Abuse<br />
Ministry for the archdiocese for many<br />
years, and throughout the decades<br />
conducted interventions, led retreats<br />
nationwide, and was a friend to many<br />
at first glance “very unpromising”<br />
people.<br />
For decades he directed alcoholics<br />
and addicts to Alcoholics Anonymous<br />
(AA). He’s also observed what happens<br />
to them once they get there.<br />
“To be a drunk and get sober,” he<br />
pointed out, “is one of the ultimate<br />
death-and-resurrection experiences.<br />
When Christ said, ‘Blessed are the<br />
poor in spirit,’ some of the people he<br />
must surely have been thinking about<br />
were alcoholics and addicts. It’s a<br />
wonderful gift for a person to see, left<br />
to his or her own devices, the depths<br />
to which we’re capable of sinking.<br />
Sometimes I don’t know how people<br />
come to a relationship with Christ<br />
without hitting bottom with some kind<br />
of addictive, obsessive behavior.”<br />
I’d lived my whole life in fear of judgment.<br />
The first time I heard Father<br />
Terry, he talked about how when we<br />
get sober, or we come into the Church,<br />
we are in fact judged. We’re judged<br />
welcome.<br />
“We welcome you and we also recognize<br />
you as a child of God with the<br />
dignity of any other person on earth.<br />
We’re judging you to be a person of<br />
high standards, a person who will not<br />
be satisfied with acting from a heart<br />
that’s anything less than entirely free.<br />
34 • ANGELUS • <strong>January</strong> <strong>13</strong>, <strong>2023</strong>
Heather King is an award-winning<br />
author, speaker, and workshop leader.<br />
And we have some principles of loving,<br />
honest, responsible behavior that we<br />
suggest you follow. You’ll stay welcome<br />
even if you don’t follow them, but —<br />
here’s the thing: you won’t care. You<br />
won’t care that you’re welcome; you’ll<br />
miss out on all the wonder, the love,<br />
the growth.”<br />
Many of us are looking to be transformed<br />
in a certain way. It helped<br />
to hear that resurrection never looks<br />
anything like we think it’s going to.<br />
“Some of us have a deeply misguided<br />
desire to be saved through excellence,”<br />
Father Terry would note with a chuckle.<br />
“We want to be spontaneous yet<br />
profound, highly intelligent yet downto-earth,<br />
well-balanced yet passionate,<br />
dignified but self-deprecating. We want<br />
to be physically fit, good-looking, calm<br />
in the face of tragedy, suave in the face<br />
of heartbreak, and to have really, really<br />
good skin. Through the incarnational<br />
mystery of being broken open by fellow<br />
alcoholics and addicts, we forget about<br />
all that. We become what we really<br />
wanted to be all along: we become<br />
human. We realize the real point of<br />
sobriety is to get in good enough shape<br />
to help another alcoholic.”<br />
Still, old habits die hard. Who would<br />
I be, I wondered, without my perfectionism?<br />
My need to control? My<br />
accusatory self-talk?<br />
Father Terry would respond, “Implicit<br />
in all self-justification is accusation:<br />
One of the names for Satan in Catholic<br />
theology, in fact, is The Accuser.<br />
That’s not God talking to us; that’s us<br />
talking to ourselves. There’s no accusation<br />
in authentic spirituality — only<br />
invitation.”<br />
Two things happen when someone<br />
comes into AA, he maintained. The<br />
first is that there’s a kind of unspoken<br />
joy in the people who welcome and<br />
greet you. “Right away they trust that<br />
you have it in you to respond to the<br />
invitation of sobriety. You don’t get<br />
the bum’s rush. <strong>No</strong> one swarms you.<br />
There’s a spiritual maturity.”<br />
“It’s not in the mind of anyone who<br />
walks through the doors of AA,” he<br />
added, “ ‘I wish someone would see<br />
my goodness, my inner essence.’ That<br />
thought isn’t conscious. But we all<br />
need so much to be welcomed and<br />
trusted and honored as free children<br />
of God. And when that happens, some<br />
real change can occur.”<br />
The second thing that happens is the<br />
spontaneous urge to carry the message<br />
and treat other people the way you’ve<br />
been treated.<br />
“We have an inborn need to love. And<br />
in AA people are drawn to, find themselves,<br />
identifying with, the other. That<br />
‘Yeah!’ to other people’s brokenness,<br />
escapades, sense of humor, remorse,<br />
and willingness to make things right is<br />
a profound spiritual experience. People<br />
feel joy that someone else is coming<br />
alive; they’re triggered into identification.<br />
Those who stay sober in AA tend<br />
to have a little bounce to their step.”<br />
Father Terry would go on to become<br />
a monsignor. I was able to visit him<br />
over Thanksgiving at the memory care<br />
facility where he spent the last year or<br />
so of his life. He died in December, on<br />
the winter solstice.<br />
He formed me — and thousands of<br />
others — deeply as a recovering alcoholic,<br />
as a follower of Christ, and as a<br />
human being.<br />
And he always, always made me<br />
laugh. One spiritual director he used<br />
for years was Mark Kennedy, himself<br />
a recovering alcoholic. “Mark used to<br />
say: ‘There’s only one unforgivable sin.<br />
And that’s to avoid God until you’re in<br />
good enough shape to fool him.’ ”<br />
<strong>January</strong> <strong>13</strong>, <strong>2023</strong> • ANGELUS • 35
LETTER AND SPIRIT<br />
SCOTT HAHN<br />
Scott Hahn is founder of the<br />
St. Paul Center for Biblical<br />
Theology; stpaulcenter.com.<br />
How sacraments started<br />
The sacraments are<br />
what God had in mind<br />
for you and me “in the<br />
beginning,” when he made<br />
the heavens and the earth.<br />
This may come as a surprise.<br />
Though we revere the<br />
sacraments, too often Catholics<br />
treat them as something<br />
the Church teased out of a<br />
few New Testament prooftexts.<br />
That, however, is precisely<br />
backward. It would be<br />
more accurate to say that the<br />
Bible is what God’s people<br />
teased out of a providential<br />
plan in which God’s New<br />
Covenant sacraments were<br />
already present from the first<br />
moments of the Old Covenant.<br />
There is a unity to the two<br />
Testaments of the Bible; and<br />
the whole of the Bible is<br />
inseparably united with the<br />
small details of the Church’s<br />
life today.<br />
Jesus himself read the Old<br />
Testament this way. He<br />
referred to Jonah (Matthew<br />
12:39), Solomon (Matthew<br />
12:42), and the Temple (John 2:19) as signs pointing to his<br />
own life. Toward the end of Luke’s Gospel, Jesus took “Moses<br />
and all the prophets” and interpreted “what referred to<br />
him in all the Scriptures” (Luke 24:27). St. Paul followed<br />
his Master in this reading of the Hebrew Scriptures (see<br />
Romans 5:14, Galatians 4:24), as did St. Peter (see 1 Peter<br />
3:20–21). St. Augustine summed up this interpretive method<br />
in a single phrase: The New Testament is concealed in<br />
the Old, and the Old is revealed in the New.<br />
What unites the two Testaments is what unites God and<br />
mankind. In the Bible, this bond is called “covenant.” A<br />
covenant, in ancient cultures, was a solemn agreement that<br />
created a family relation. Marriage was a covenant, as was<br />
the adoption of a child. When a family welcomed a new<br />
“The Institution of the Eucharist,”<br />
by Ercole de’ Roberti, 1451-1496,<br />
Italian. | WIKIMEDIA COMMONS<br />
member, both parties would<br />
seal the covenant by swearing<br />
a sacred oath, sharing a<br />
common meal, and offering<br />
a sacrifice. Periodically, the<br />
two parties might repeat the<br />
sacred oath, along with the<br />
meal and sacrifice, in order<br />
to renew the covenant bond.<br />
This is how God made his<br />
covenant with Moses, a<br />
covenant that was renewed<br />
annually in the Passover<br />
meal.<br />
<strong>No</strong>r did this arrangement<br />
end with our redemption.<br />
Indeed, the only time Jesus<br />
mentioned the New Covenant<br />
was in the context of<br />
his Last Supper — when he<br />
offered the first Eucharist<br />
(Luke 22:20). Moreover, Jesus<br />
commanded his apostles<br />
to renew the covenant with<br />
God by the same means. “Do<br />
this,” he said, “in remembrance<br />
of me” (1 Corinthians<br />
11:25).<br />
From earliest times,<br />
Christians commonly called<br />
this action by the Latin<br />
word “sacramentum.” Both<br />
Roman Christians and their<br />
pagan persecutors used the<br />
word to describe the ritual<br />
worship of the Church.<br />
And sacramentum means “oath.” The Roman governor<br />
Pliny said that the Christians in his province met before<br />
dawn to sing hymns and bind themselves by oath to Christ,<br />
as they shared “an ordinary kind of food.”<br />
Thus, in the early Church — as in the practice of our<br />
parishes today — we see the Old Covenant oaths revealed<br />
and fulfilled in the New Covenant sacramentum.<br />
For a Catholic, there’s a real sense in which little has<br />
changed since the days of the Acts of the Apostles.<br />
36 • ANGELUS • <strong>January</strong> <strong>13</strong>, <strong>2023</strong>
■ SATURDAY, JANUARY 14<br />
Martin Luther King Jr. Prayer Breakfast. Proud Bird<br />
Restaurant, 11022 Aviation Blvd., Los Angeles, 8-11 a.m.<br />
Keynote speaker: Michael Donaldson, director of the<br />
archdiocesan Office of Life, Justice and Peace. Donation:<br />
$50/person. Tickets are available online at aaccfe.org.<br />
Doorways, Portals & Prayers: A collage retreat. Holy<br />
Spirit Retreat Center, 4316 Lanai Rd., Encino, 9:30 a.m.-<br />
3:30 p.m. With Chantel Zimmerman. Visit hsrcenter.com<br />
or call 818-784-4515.<br />
■ SUNDAY, JANUARY 15<br />
Virtual Diaconate Information Day. 2-4 p.m. To register,<br />
email Deacon Melecio Zamora at dmz2011@la-archdiocese.org.<br />
The Feast of Santo Niño. Cathedral of Our Lady of the<br />
Angels, 555 W. Temple St., Los Angeles, 3 p.m. Join the<br />
36th celebration of the feast of Santo Niño. Bring Santo<br />
Niño statues for a special blessing. Celebrant: Father Rey<br />
Matunog.<br />
Dr. King’s Dream is Alive. LMU, 1 LMU Dr., Los Angeles,<br />
3-4:30 p.m. Panel discussion on ethics, biblical reflection,<br />
and the worship of Black Catholics as a beloved community.<br />
Panel will be available via livestream or in person. RSVP<br />
required. For more information, visit cal.lmu.edu/event/<br />
mlk-seminar-<strong>2023</strong>.<br />
International Thomas Merton Society Chapter Meeting.<br />
Holy Spirit Retreat Center, 4316 Lanai Rd., Encino,<br />
2-4 p.m. Hosted by Sister Chris Macado, SSS. Visit hsrcenter.com<br />
or call 818-784-4515.<br />
■ TUESDAY, JANUARY 17<br />
The Sanctuary Course for Catholics: A Conversation<br />
about Mental Health. St. Christopher Church, 629 S.<br />
Glendora Ave., West Covina, 7-9 p.m. Event runs Tuesdays<br />
in December and <strong>January</strong>. For more information, call<br />
Father Kolbe Missionaries at 626-917-0040 or email<br />
FKMs@kolbemissionusa.org.<br />
Lector Formation Sessions (St. Peter Claver). St. Peter<br />
Claver Church, 2380 Stow St., Simi Valley, 7-9 p.m.<br />
Answer the calling to be a lector. Must attend all four<br />
workshops to receive course completion (Jan. 17, 24,<br />
31, and Feb. 7). Cost: $25/person, $40/couple. For more<br />
information and to register, visit https://events.lacatholics.<br />
org/lector-formation-english-st-peter-claver-simi-valley-1.<br />
■ WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 18<br />
LACBA CFJ Veterans Record Clearing Clinic. 5-8 p.m.<br />
Zoom clinic open to Southern California veterans, assists<br />
with learning CA traffic tickets, expunging criminal<br />
records, and felony reductions. Registration required. Contact<br />
2<strong>13</strong>-896-6537 or inquiries-veterans@lacba.org.<br />
“What Catholics Believe” weekly series. St. Dorothy<br />
Church, 241 S. Valley Center Ave., Glendora, 7-8:30 p.m.<br />
Series runs Wednesdays through April 26, <strong>2023</strong>. Deepen<br />
your understanding of the Catholic faith through dynamic<br />
DVD presentations by Bishop Robert Barron, Dr. Edward<br />
Sri, Dr. Brant Pitre, and Dr. Michael Barber. Free event,<br />
no reservations required. Call 626-335-2811 or visit the<br />
Adult Faith Development ministry page at www.stdorothy.<br />
org for more information.<br />
Lector Formation Sessions (St. John Vianney). St. John<br />
Vianney Church, <strong>13</strong>45 Turnbull Canyon Rd., Hacienda<br />
Heights, 7-9 p.m. Answer the calling to be a lector. Must<br />
attend all four workshops to receive course completion<br />
(Jan. 18 and 25 and Feb. 1 and 8). Cost: $25/person,<br />
$40/couple. For more information and to register, visit<br />
events.lacatholics.org.<br />
■ THURSDAY, JANUARY 19<br />
Children’s Bureau: Foster Care Zoom Orientation. 4-5<br />
p.m. Children’s Bureau is now offering two virtual ways<br />
for individuals and couples to learn how to help children<br />
in foster care while reunifying with birth families or how<br />
to provide legal permanency by adoption. A live Zoom<br />
orientation will be hosted by a Children’s Bureau team<br />
member and a foster parent. For those who want to<br />
learn at their own pace about becoming a foster and/or<br />
fost-adopt parent, an online orientation presentation is<br />
available. To RSVP for the live orientation or to request<br />
the online orientation, email rfrecruitment@all4kids.org.<br />
■ FRIDAY, JANUARY 20<br />
Ammas, Monks, and Archetypes Weekend Retreat.<br />
Holy Spirit Retreat Center, 4316 Lanai Rd., Encino. Retreat<br />
with Father Stephen Coffey, OSB Cam., runs Friday<br />
at 5 p.m. through Sunday at 1 p.m. For more information,<br />
visit hsrcenter.com or call 818-784-4515.<br />
■ SATURDAY, JANUARY 21<br />
OneLife LA. LA State Historic Park, 1245 N. Spring St.,<br />
Los Angeles, 11 a.m.-6:30 p.m. Join LA Catholics in an<br />
annual walk beginning in Placita Olvera and culminating<br />
in a festival at LA State Historic Park with speakers,<br />
music, food trucks, and more. For more information, visit<br />
onelifela.org/register.<br />
Why Does Augustine Matter? Lecture series with<br />
Rowan Williams, Archbishop emeritus of Canterbury.<br />
St. Michael’s Abbey, 27977 Silverado Canyon Rd., Silverado,<br />
9:30 a.m.-5:30 p.m. Archbishop emeritus Rowan<br />
Williams will present two lectures on his study of St. Augustine.<br />
Free event, registration required. Includes coffee,<br />
lunch, and afternoon wine reception. Visit angelusnews.<br />
com/events-calendar/why-does-augustine-matter.<br />
Centering Prayer Introductory Workshop. Holy Spirit<br />
Retreat Center, 4316 Lanai Rd., Encino, 9 a.m.-12:30 p.m.<br />
With Marilyn <strong>No</strong>bori and the contemplative outreach<br />
team. For more information, visit hsrcenter.com or call<br />
818-815-4480.<br />
Extraordinary Minister of Holy Communion Formation.<br />
St. John Eudes Church, 9901 Mason Ave., Chatsworth,<br />
9 a.m.-3 p.m. Cost: $25/person, $40/couple. For<br />
more information and to register, visit https://events.<br />
lacatholics.org/emhc-formation-in-english.<br />
■ MONDAY, JANUARY 23<br />
Understanding the Annulment Process (Declaration<br />
of Nullity). 7-8:30 p.m. Free Zoom presentation from<br />
the archdiocesan Separated and Divorced Ministry.<br />
Presented by Mary Ann Brewer-<strong>No</strong>lan, parish minister.<br />
To register, visit family life.lacatholics.org/separated-divorced.<br />
For more information, email Julie Auzenne at<br />
jmonell@la-archdiocese.org or call 2<strong>13</strong>-637-7249.<br />
■ WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 25<br />
LACBA Family Law Clinic. 2-5 p.m. Zoom clinic will<br />
cover child support, child custody, divorce, and spousal<br />
support. Open to LA County veterans. Registration required.<br />
Call 2<strong>13</strong>-896-6537 or email inquiries-veterans@<br />
lacba.org.<br />
Items for the calendar of events are due four weeks prior to the date of the event. They may be emailed to calendar@angelusnews.com.<br />
All calendar items must include the name, date, time, address of the event, and a phone number for additional information.<br />
<strong>January</strong> <strong>13</strong>, <strong>2023</strong> • ANGELUS • 37