Bank of Ireland Munster Senior Challenge Cup Final
Nenagh Ormond RFC v Young Munster RFC
Nenagh Ormond RFC v Young Munster RFC
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
BANK OF IRELAND<br />
MUNSTER SENIOR CHALLENGE CUP<br />
FINAL 2022/2023<br />
NENAGH ORMOND RFC<br />
VERSUS<br />
YOUNG MUNSTER RFC<br />
THURSDAY 16TH MARCH | THOMOND PARK | KO 7.30PM<br />
#MSCC<br />
BANK OF IRELAND MUNSTER SENIOR CHALLENGE CUP 2022/23 1
2 WWW.MUNSTERRUGBY.IE
PRESIDENT’S<br />
MESSAGE<br />
It’s my pleasure to welcome everyone<br />
attending tonight’s game here in Thomond<br />
Park, in particular a welcome to players,<br />
management and all involved with Nenagh<br />
and Young <strong>Munster</strong> for what promises to be a<br />
very exciting <strong>Bank</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Ireland</strong> <strong>Munster</strong> <strong>Senior</strong><br />
<strong>Challenge</strong> <strong>Cup</strong> <strong>Final</strong>.<br />
Nenagh are the first Tipperary team to contest<br />
the final since Rockwell College in 1908 and<br />
face holders Young <strong>Munster</strong>. Both clubs have<br />
a long history but this is the first time they<br />
have faced each other in the final. The first<br />
ever game in this competition was played on<br />
Tuesday 23rd February 1886 in the Markets<br />
Field in Limerick, and one <strong>of</strong> today’s finalists,<br />
Nenagh, played Garryowen, with Garryowen<br />
winning on a score <strong>of</strong> two goals and three<br />
points to nil – there is a lot <strong>of</strong> history attached<br />
to this great competition.<br />
I would like to wish Willie C<strong>of</strong>fey, captain <strong>of</strong><br />
Nenagh, Alan Kennedy, captain <strong>of</strong> Young<br />
<strong>Munster</strong>, all the players, coaches and<br />
management the best <strong>of</strong> luck in today’s final.<br />
<strong>Munster</strong> <strong>Senior</strong> <strong>Cup</strong> medals are hard to come<br />
by and hard earned, today will be no different<br />
with both sides giving it all to lift the trophy and<br />
collect the much sought after medal. This has<br />
all the makings <strong>of</strong> another cracking game.<br />
Once again, this year’s competition is<br />
sponsored by <strong>Bank</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Ireland</strong> and I would<br />
like to acknowledge their support from the<br />
pr<strong>of</strong>essional game and all through the amateur<br />
game, your continued support is very much<br />
appreciated. Thank you to the <strong>Senior</strong> Clubs and<br />
Competitions committee for organising this<br />
year’s competition.<br />
To the people in the background who oversee<br />
the match day arrangements, the pr<strong>of</strong>essional<br />
staff, grounds people, all the volunteers who<br />
made today possible, thank you one and all.<br />
<strong>Final</strong>ly, a thank you to the <strong>Munster</strong> Association<br />
<strong>of</strong> Referees for your ongoing <strong>of</strong>ficiating at all<br />
levels throughout the season.<br />
Best <strong>of</strong> luck to Shane Kierans in tonight’s<br />
game. We need more referees, so for those<br />
<strong>of</strong> you sitting in the stands tonight – some<br />
food for thought! You could be the next Joy<br />
Neville or Andy Brace. I hope whoever you are<br />
supporting and cheering on, you have a very<br />
enjoyable night. May the best team win.<br />
Ger McNamara<br />
President,<br />
<strong>Munster</strong> Branch IRFU<br />
President Ger McNamara Vice President Michael Carroll Junior Vice President Brendan Foley<br />
Hon. Secretary Muiris Mahon Hon. Treasurer Tom Kinirons Chief Executive Officer Ian Flanagan<br />
Head Coach Graham Rowntree Team Manager Niall O’Donovan<br />
BANK OF IRELAND MUNSTER SENIOR CHALLENGE CUP 2022/23 3
MUNSTER SENIOR CUP A TO Z<br />
By Frank Byford,<br />
Former Hon. Secretary,<br />
<strong>Munster</strong> Branch<br />
A - After a lapse <strong>of</strong> 31 years Bohemians regained the trophy in 1958 when they defeated<br />
Highfield who were making their initial appearance in the decider at Thomond Park,<br />
the successful XV was Paddy Downes, Paddy Moran (captain), Christy English, Basil<br />
Fitzgibbon, Maurice Mortell, Mick English, Tom Cleary, William Slattery, Dermot Geary,<br />
John Nagle, John Mulcahy, Ted Watson, John Ryan, Caleb Powell, Billy Hurley.<br />
B - Bandon under the captaincy <strong>of</strong> Frank Levis became the first winners <strong>of</strong> the trophy in<br />
1886 defeating Garryowen in a replay at the Cork Park.<br />
C - <strong>Cup</strong>, the original trophy in 1886 was procured through the house <strong>of</strong> Messrs Martin Hall<br />
& Co. <strong>of</strong> Sheffield. It was made specially to order and was described as ‘a valuable prize<br />
and a beautiful exhibition <strong>of</strong> the silversmith’s art and skill’. It was valued at £65 sterling.<br />
When the Branch replaced the famous old trophy in 1994, the cost had risen to 13K punts.<br />
D - Draw for the initial competition in 1886 resulted as follows: Garryowen FC v Nenagh<br />
RFC, Clanwilliam FC v Tralee RFC, Cork Football Club v Bandon RFC and Queen’s College<br />
RFC v Limerick Football Club.<br />
E - Equaliser – one <strong>of</strong> the most dramatic scores to draw a final occurred in the 1967<br />
meeting <strong>of</strong> Cork Constitution and Highfield - Tony Loughry landed the equalising penalty<br />
from the half way line with the last kick <strong>of</strong> the match, the ball going over after hitting the<br />
crossbar – it was all the more remarkable as Loughry had been down injured for what<br />
seemed like ages, before he was helped from the ground, dusted himself down before he<br />
earned the ‘field’ a deserved draw.<br />
F - Fire Station, Roches Street, Limerick, was the venue for the draw for the initial<br />
competition in 1886.<br />
G - Garryowen FC, found in 1884, became the first Limerick side to lift the trophy in 1889,<br />
going on a dominant run with a further eight triumphs before the turn <strong>of</strong> the century.<br />
H - Highfield won the first <strong>of</strong> their two titles in 1966 with a team that included Tony<br />
O’Brien, Tony Loughry, Gary O’Reilly, Pierce McNamara, Donal Kiely, Billy O’Lehan, Finny<br />
Pope, Sean Hayes, Liam Ormonde, Jim Dennehy, Joe McDonnell (captain), Dougie<br />
Burke, Denis Dennehy, Terry Moore, Gary ‘Hank’ O’Reilly.<br />
I - Initial match in the competition was played on Tuesday 23rd, February, 1886, at the<br />
Markets Field, Limerick when Garryowen beat Nenagh Ormond by two goals and three<br />
tries to nil.<br />
J - Jack Horgan led University College Cork to victory in the 1950 decider over a fancied<br />
Garryowen XV in Limerick.<br />
K - Kiernan, Tom won seven cup winners medals between 1963 – 1973, the first with<br />
University College Cork, and the remainder with Cork Constitution, while his brother Jim<br />
was on the successful winning UCC (1955) and Cork Constitution (1957) XVs.<br />
L - Last occasion that a final was refereed by an <strong>of</strong>ficial from outside the province was<br />
1936, when R.A.C. Barrett (Leinster Branch) took control <strong>of</strong> the University College Cork<br />
and Cork Constitution decider.<br />
4 WWW.MUNSTERRUGBY.IE
M - Midleton RFC reached the final <strong>of</strong> the competition in 2003, their only appearance<br />
to date, and despite their best efforts they went down to Shannon on a 22 points to 13<br />
scoreline.<br />
N - Noel Glynn had the honour <strong>of</strong> leading Shannon to victory over Garryowen in the 1986<br />
final, the centenary year <strong>of</strong> the competition.<br />
O - Old Crescent have yet to win the trophy, having been losing finalists in 1955, 1962 and<br />
2009.<br />
P - Personalities who have won senior cup medals include John Skehan (Radio Eireann<br />
broadcaster) and D.J.Fitzgibbon (Din Joe <strong>of</strong> “Take the Floor” fame) both with Dolphin in<br />
1948, while the late Richard Harris was a medal winner with Garryowen in 1952.<br />
Q - Quaide, Des led Garryowen to victory in 1975 over Cork Constitution, the occasion<br />
being notable that it was the first time in 35 years that a Limerick club had won a senior<br />
cup final in Cork.<br />
R - Rockwell College lost the finals <strong>of</strong> 1897, 1902, 1904 and 1908, one <strong>of</strong> their prominent<br />
players at the time was Eamonn de Valera, who was later to become leader <strong>of</strong> Fianna Fail<br />
and then President <strong>of</strong> <strong>Ireland</strong>.<br />
S - Suspended – following a drawn final in 1892 between Garryowen and Queen’s College<br />
Cork, it transpired that the replay never took place, as both clubs could not agree on<br />
a venue. Subsequently the <strong>Munster</strong> Football <strong>Challenge</strong> <strong>Cup</strong> committee declared the<br />
competition null and void.<br />
T - Tipperary. This evening’s match, featuring Nenagh Ormond RFC and Young <strong>Munster</strong><br />
RFC is the fifth occasion a team from the Premier County has contested a final. Rockwell<br />
College, then competing as a club side, made it to four finals between 1897 and 1908.<br />
U - University College Cork XV won the trophy in 1976 against Dolphin which was the last<br />
occasion <strong>of</strong> an all Cork final – Joe Fitzgerald, Danny Buckley, Peter Rolls, Pat Parfrey,<br />
Jack Shorten, Moss Finn, Eddie Cogan, Paul Turner, Gerry Hurley, Garrett Fitzgerald,<br />
Charlie McCarthy, Jerry Holland, Christy Cantillon, Richard Kennefick (captain), Anthony<br />
O’Leary.<br />
V - Victory margin – the largest margin <strong>of</strong> victory in a decider came in 1974, when<br />
Garryowen had 29 points to spare over Shannon in the final.<br />
W - Wall, Henry who passed away recently captained Dolphin in the 1964 final against<br />
Cork Constitution – the laurels going to the Temple Hill side who were led by Noel<br />
Murphy.<br />
X - XV - Dolphin team who won the club’s last <strong>Senior</strong> <strong>Cup</strong> in 1956 after defeating<br />
Sunday’s Well in a replay was Gerry Rearden, Flor Crowley, Billy Mason, Pat Crowley,<br />
Dave McCormick, Norman Colman (Captain), Tim Harrington, Derry Donnery, Dave Barry,<br />
Bob Dowley, Mick Sullivan, Jerry O’Sullivan, Jerry Healy, Dick Hyde, Paddy O’Callaghan.<br />
Y - Young <strong>Munster</strong> bridged a gap <strong>of</strong> 42 years in 1980, when they regained the trophy at<br />
the expense <strong>of</strong> Bohemians, the successful XV - Ger McNamara, Michael Moore, Pat Cross,<br />
Francis Brosnihan, Derek McCarthy, Gerry Casey, Eddie Costello, Branden O’Connor, Pat<br />
McGrath, John Murphy, Richie Daly (captain), Brian O’Connor, Eamonn Madden, Michael<br />
Sheehan, Jim McNamara. It is worth noting that on the following day John Murphy won a<br />
<strong>Munster</strong> Junior <strong>Cup</strong> medal with Thomond.<br />
Z - Zero score, <strong>of</strong> the 125 finals to date only seven have finished scoreless, those being in<br />
1886, 1890, 1892, 1907, 1914 and 1933 (twice).<br />
BANK OF IRELAND MUNSTER SENIOR CHALLENGE CUP 2022/23 5
PREVIOUS SENIOR CHALLENGE CUP WINNERS<br />
1886 Bandon<br />
1887 Queen’s College, Cork<br />
1888 Queen’s College, Cork<br />
1889Garryowen<br />
1890 Garryowen<br />
1891 Garryowen<br />
1892 Not Awarded<br />
1893 Garryowen<br />
1894 Garryowen<br />
1895 Garryowen<br />
1896 Garryowen<br />
1897 Queen’s College,Cork<br />
1898 Garryowen<br />
1899 Garryowen<br />
1900 Queen’s College,Cork<br />
1901 Queen’s College,Cork<br />
1902 Garryowen<br />
1903 Garryowen<br />
1904 Garryowen<br />
1905 Cork Constitution<br />
1906 Cork Constitution<br />
1907 Cork Constitution<br />
1908 Garryowen<br />
1909 Garryowen<br />
1910 Cork Constitution<br />
1911 Garryowen<br />
1912 UCC<br />
1913 UCC<br />
1914 Garryowen<br />
1915-19 Suspended<br />
1920 Garryowen<br />
1921 Dolphin<br />
1922 Cork Constitution<br />
1923 Cork Constitution<br />
1924 Garryowen<br />
1925 Garryowen<br />
1926 Garryowen<br />
1927 Bohemian<br />
1928 Young <strong>Munster</strong><br />
1929 Cork Constitution<br />
1930 Young <strong>Munster</strong><br />
1931 Dolphin<br />
1932 Garryowen<br />
1933 Cork Constitution<br />
1934 Garryowen<br />
1935 UCC<br />
1936 UCC<br />
1937 UCC<br />
1938 Young <strong>Munster</strong><br />
1939 UCC<br />
1940 Garryowen<br />
1941 UCC<br />
1942 CorkConstitution<br />
1943 Cork Constitution<br />
1944 Dolphin<br />
1945 Dolphin<br />
1946 Cork Constitution<br />
1947 Garryowen<br />
1948 Dolphin<br />
1949 Sunday’s Well<br />
1950 UCC 1951 UCC<br />
1952 Garryowen<br />
1953 Sunday’s Well<br />
1954 Garryowen<br />
1955 UCC<br />
1956 Dolphin<br />
1957 Cork Constitution<br />
1958 Bohemian<br />
1959 Bohemian<br />
1960 Shannon<br />
1961 Cork Constitution<br />
1962 Bohemian<br />
1963 UCC<br />
1964 Cork Constitution<br />
1965 Cork Constitution<br />
1966 Highfield<br />
1967 Cork Constitution<br />
1968 Highfield<br />
1969 Garryowen<br />
1970 Cork Constitution<br />
1971 Garryowen<br />
1972 Cork Constitution<br />
1973 Cork Constitution<br />
1974 Garryowen<br />
1975 Garryowen<br />
1976 UCC<br />
1977 Shannon<br />
1978 Shannon<br />
1979 Garryowen<br />
1980 Young <strong>Munster</strong><br />
1981 UCC<br />
1982 Shannon<br />
1983 Cork Constitution<br />
1984 Young <strong>Munster</strong><br />
1985 Cork Constitution<br />
1986 Shannon<br />
1987 Shannon<br />
1988 Shannon<br />
1989 Cork Constitution<br />
1990 Young <strong>Munster</strong><br />
1991 Shannon<br />
1992 Shannon<br />
1993 Garryowen<br />
1994 Sunday’s Well<br />
1995 Garryowen<br />
1996 Shannon<br />
1997 Garryowen<br />
1998 Shannon<br />
1999 Garryowen<br />
2000 Shannon<br />
2001 Shannon<br />
2002 Shannon<br />
2003 Shannon<br />
2004 Shannon<br />
2005 Shannon<br />
2006 Shannon<br />
2007 Garryowen<br />
2008 Shannon<br />
2009 Cork Constitution<br />
2010 Young <strong>Munster</strong><br />
2011 Bruff<br />
2012 Garryowen<br />
2013 Cork Constitution<br />
2014 Cork Constitution<br />
2015 Cork Constitution<br />
2016 Cork Constitution<br />
2017 Cork Constitution<br />
2018 Garryowen<br />
2018/19 Cork Constitution<br />
2019/20 Cork Constitution<br />
2020/21 Young <strong>Munster</strong><br />
2021/22 Young <strong>Munster</strong><br />
6 WWW.MUNSTERRUGBY.IE
NENAGH ORMOND<br />
FINAL STAGES<br />
QUARTER-FINAL: Garryowen 22 Nenagh Ormond 28 - Dooradoyle<br />
SEMI-FINAL: Nenagh Ormond 28 Highfield 5 - Nenagh<br />
YOUNG MUNSTER<br />
FINAL STAGES<br />
QUARTER-FINAL: Clonmel 7 Young <strong>Munster</strong> 67 – Clonmel<br />
SEMI-FINAL: Young <strong>Munster</strong> 19 Cork Constitution 13 – Tom Clifford Park<br />
BANK OF IRELAND MUNSTER SENIOR CHALLENGE CUP 2022/23 7
NENEAGH ORMOND RFC<br />
1 Mike Doran<br />
2 Dylan Murphy<br />
3 Jack O’Keeffe<br />
4 Kevin O’Flaherty<br />
5 Jake O’Kelly<br />
6 Rob Buckley<br />
7 John O’Flaherty<br />
8 John Hayes<br />
9 Nicky Irwin<br />
10 Derek Corcoran<br />
11 Dave Gleeson<br />
12 John Healy<br />
13 Willie C<strong>of</strong>fey<br />
14 Patrick Scully<br />
15 Josh Rowland<br />
Replacements:<br />
16 Peter O’Connor<br />
17 Seán Frawley<br />
18 Evan Murphy<br />
19 Joe C<strong>of</strong>fey<br />
20 John Brislane<br />
21 Cian Ryan<br />
22 Conor O’Brien<br />
Match O<br />
Referee: Sh<br />
AR1: Eddie Hog<br />
AR2: Kev<br />
4th: David<br />
5th: Ia<br />
Teams correct at time <strong>of</strong> publication<br />
8<br />
WWW.MUNSTERRUGBY.IE
YOUNG MUNSTER RFC<br />
fficials<br />
ane Kierans<br />
an O’Connell,<br />
in C<strong>of</strong>fey<br />
Hennessy<br />
n Coll<br />
1. David Begley<br />
2. George Jacobs<br />
3. Conor Bartley<br />
4. Sean Rigney<br />
5. Alan Kennedy (c)<br />
6. Bailey Faloon<br />
7. Ronán O’Sullivan<br />
8. John Foley<br />
9. Jack Lyons<br />
10. Evan Cusack<br />
11. Shay Mc Carthy<br />
12. Luke Fitzgerald<br />
13. Harry Fleming<br />
14. Conor Hayes<br />
15. Patrick Campbell<br />
Replacements:<br />
16 Mark O’Mara<br />
17 Paul Allen<br />
18 Conor Moloney<br />
19 James Horrigan<br />
20 Donnchadh O’Callaghan<br />
21 Werner H<strong>of</strong>fman<br />
22 Stephen Lyons<br />
BANK OF IRELAND MUNSTER SENIOR CHALLENGE CUP 2022/23<br />
9
PRESIDENT’S WORD<br />
THERESA HASSEY<br />
Nenagh Ormond RFC President<br />
“There’s <strong>of</strong>f the charts excitement. We never<br />
thought we’d be at this stage this time <strong>of</strong> the year.<br />
“It’s a combination <strong>of</strong> things. We have a really<br />
good coaching team and structure. A lot <strong>of</strong><br />
underage players have come up through the<br />
ranks this year. We’ve a really good strong<br />
home support base and like everything, when<br />
you’re doing well, the support comes out<br />
in force. We have huge support in the local<br />
community.<br />
TRISH MONTGOMERY<br />
Young <strong>Munster</strong> RFC President<br />
“Excitement levels are pretty high. This<br />
would be our third year in a row which is<br />
unprecedented, so that’s a big thing. For me<br />
personally, this is my first (final as President)<br />
obviously!<br />
“It’s very exciting and I think it’s brilliant<br />
that Nenagh have reached this stage as you<br />
would <strong>of</strong>ten have the same old, same old<br />
antagonists year in, year out. It’s nice to<br />
have it spread more around the province.<br />
“This is huge for Nenagh to get into the<br />
<strong>Senior</strong> <strong>Cup</strong>, there’s a lot <strong>of</strong> older people in the<br />
club who never would <strong>of</strong> thought they would<br />
see something like this in Nenagh. It was the<br />
first time ever to get into the semi-final and<br />
that was huge for us and this is epic for us<br />
really.”<br />
“We’re doing a lot <strong>of</strong> stuff, trying to promote<br />
the final, ticket sales and that kind <strong>of</strong> thing.<br />
We’re holding <strong>of</strong>f a little bit and just trying<br />
to get over this game (v Ballymena on<br />
Saturday 4th March). And it’s even the same<br />
with promotion, we’re not looking at charts<br />
and not looking at league tables, we’re just<br />
focusing on one game.<br />
“It’s very difficult to do because you’re there<br />
after the match and all you’re waiting for is<br />
scores to be updated and where did we end<br />
up! We never thought we would be in that<br />
position because this time last year, we were<br />
at the opposite end <strong>of</strong> the scale, we were<br />
fighting to stay up, we went into the play<strong>of</strong>fs<br />
to stay in this Division.<br />
“Young <strong>Munster</strong> have a lot <strong>of</strong> empathy with<br />
Nenagh because your coach Derek Corcoran<br />
played with Young <strong>Munster</strong> and some <strong>of</strong><br />
the lads; Mikey Doran would have played<br />
20s with us. So there’s a lot <strong>of</strong> connections<br />
there. It’s great to see it ending so well.<br />
Obviously, we still want to win! But it’s nice.<br />
“We always expect a tough game. You know<br />
yourself, if you are classed as the underdog,<br />
not saying ye are, ye will fight that bit more<br />
you know? I don’t think our lads will take<br />
anything for granted but at the same time,<br />
you want them to be at a 100% straight<br />
away.<br />
“We’ll have to see what happens on the day<br />
but that’s the excitement <strong>of</strong> it. Anything<br />
really could happen. Obviously, we hope<br />
that it will happen in our favour.”<br />
“To be, a year later, fighting for the promotion<br />
play<strong>of</strong>fs is great and is a testament to all <strong>of</strong><br />
the hard work that they have put in.”<br />
WWW.MUNSTERRUGBY.IE
MATCH PREVIEW<br />
By Eolan Allen<br />
Today will be a historic day for both<br />
clubs, most notably Nenagh Ormond<br />
who are making their first ever<br />
appearance in the <strong>Bank</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Ireland</strong><br />
<strong>Munster</strong> <strong>Senior</strong> <strong>Challenge</strong> <strong>Cup</strong> <strong>Final</strong><br />
and will be the first Tipperary based<br />
team to compete in the final since<br />
Rockwell College over a century ago.<br />
For Young <strong>Munster</strong>, they made their<br />
first ever successful defence <strong>of</strong> the<br />
trophy last season and will be bidding<br />
to make it three titles in a row.<br />
Nenagh Ormond go into today’s game<br />
unbeaten since the New Year and are<br />
making a strong push for promotion<br />
from Division 2A <strong>of</strong> the men’s All<br />
<strong>Ireland</strong> League.<br />
They opened the <strong>Senior</strong> <strong>Cup</strong> campaign<br />
by defeating fellow Division 2A side<br />
Old Crescent 29-10. It was a tight first<br />
half with Nenagh establishing a 10-0<br />
lead with tries by Dylan Murphy and<br />
a conversion and penalty by James<br />
Finn. Ronan McKenna pegged them<br />
back with all <strong>of</strong> Crescent’s scores.<br />
The Tipperary club pulled away with a<br />
dominant second-half display courtesy<br />
<strong>of</strong> tries by Jack O’Keeffe, Willie C<strong>of</strong>fey,<br />
and John Healy.<br />
This set up a quarter-final away<br />
to Garryowen. Nenagh won 28-23<br />
although it was a far more convincing<br />
win than the score suggests. Ormond<br />
took control <strong>of</strong> the game scoring four<br />
converted tries to take a 28-3 lead.<br />
David Gleeson, John O’Flaherty, C<strong>of</strong>fey<br />
and Niall O’Gorman all got over the line<br />
with Finn converting all <strong>of</strong> them. While<br />
Garryowen did fight back, time ran out<br />
and Nenagh deservedly progressed.<br />
The semi-final at home to Highfield<br />
saw Nenagh produce an outstanding<br />
BANK OF IRELAND MUNSTER SENIOR CHALLENGE CUP 2022/23 11
display to win 28-5.<br />
C<strong>of</strong>fey maintained his<br />
record <strong>of</strong> scoring a try in<br />
each round; with Josh<br />
Rowland also touching<br />
down. Patrick Scully<br />
kicked a conversion and<br />
penalty before the break<br />
before converting his<br />
own try after the interval.<br />
Two penalties by Conor<br />
O’Brien wrapped up the<br />
win.<br />
Young <strong>Munster</strong> had one<br />
less game to reach the<br />
final as they received<br />
a walkover in the first<br />
round. The second<br />
round encounter saw<br />
them travel down to<br />
south Tipperary to take<br />
on Division 2B side<br />
Clonmel. The gulf in<br />
class and quality told<br />
and the Cookies were<br />
relentless, giving out an<br />
early message that they<br />
were eager to retain this<br />
trophy once more.<br />
Jack Harrington and<br />
Stephen Lyons each<br />
ran in for a hat-trick <strong>of</strong><br />
tries. There were four<br />
other try scorers with<br />
Conor Bartley, Conor<br />
O’Shaughnessy, Dan<br />
Walsh, and Peter Hickey<br />
also touching down. Evan<br />
Cusack and Cian Casey<br />
split the kicking duties to<br />
help their side secure a<br />
67-7 win.<br />
The semi-final pitted<br />
<strong>Munster</strong>’s against archrivals<br />
Cork Constitution.<br />
Tom Clifford Park hosted<br />
a tight, compelling<br />
encounter with Con<br />
eager to avoid being<br />
eliminated by Young<br />
<strong>Munster</strong> for the third time<br />
in a row.<br />
With a vociferous home<br />
crowd behind them, tries<br />
by Stephen Lyons and<br />
Bailey Faloon along with<br />
an Evan Cusack penalty,<br />
established a 13-6 halftime<br />
lead for the hosts.<br />
The Limerick side needed<br />
to hold their nerve amidst<br />
a Con onslaught and<br />
Cusack penalties either<br />
side <strong>of</strong> a Billy Crowley try<br />
for Con was enough to<br />
see the Cookies emerge<br />
victorious.<br />
12 WWW.MUNSTERRUGBY.IE
Young <strong>Munster</strong>’s Alan<br />
Kennedy in action in last<br />
season’s Bateman <strong>Cup</strong><br />
<strong>Final</strong> in Musgrave Park<br />
A HISTORY OF THE BATEMAN CUP<br />
The <strong>Cup</strong> was presented<br />
to the IRFU by Godfrey<br />
Bateman, in memory <strong>of</strong> his<br />
sons Major Reginald John<br />
Godfrey Bateman, Canadian<br />
Infantry, who was killed in<br />
battle, in Dury, France, on<br />
the 3rd <strong>of</strong> September 1918,<br />
aged 34, and Captain Arthur<br />
Cyril Bateman, M.B. Dublin<br />
University, who died near<br />
Cambrai in France on 28th<br />
March 1918.<br />
The competition was<br />
played annually between<br />
the four provincial <strong>Senior</strong><br />
<strong>Cup</strong> winners on the last<br />
weekend <strong>of</strong> the season, with<br />
the exception <strong>of</strong> 1933 and<br />
1934 when a number <strong>of</strong> the<br />
provincial cup campaigns<br />
had not been completed<br />
on time. The tournament<br />
was finally terminated at<br />
the outbreak <strong>of</strong> the Second<br />
World War owing to the<br />
restriction on travel.<br />
Garryowen Football Club<br />
ran a once <strong>of</strong>f Bateman<br />
<strong>Cup</strong> style competition in<br />
the spring <strong>of</strong> 1975, this in<br />
conjunction with the IRFU<br />
Centenary Celebrations, the<br />
laurels eventually rested with<br />
St. Mary’s College.<br />
For the season 2010/11,<br />
the IRFU reverted back to<br />
the provincial structure<br />
having run with an open<br />
draw All-<strong>Ireland</strong> <strong>Senior</strong> <strong>Cup</strong><br />
competition for the five<br />
previous seasons.<br />
The Trophy has come to<br />
<strong>Munster</strong> on 11 occasions<br />
– Young <strong>Munster</strong> in 1928,<br />
University College Cork<br />
eight years later, Bruff in<br />
2011, Garryowen in 2012 and<br />
2019, and Cork Constitution<br />
in 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016,<br />
2017 and 2020 (shared with<br />
Lansdowne).<br />
Cork Constitution (1922),<br />
by Frank Byford<br />
Garryowen (1925) and (1926)<br />
all fell to Leinster opposition<br />
at the final hurdle, before<br />
Young <strong>Munster</strong> came in<br />
1928, the boys from the<br />
‘Yellow Road’ won the<br />
<strong>Munster</strong> <strong>Senior</strong> <strong>Cup</strong> for the<br />
first time in thrilling fashion<br />
that year. Many pundits<br />
were <strong>of</strong> the opinion that this<br />
would be the limit <strong>of</strong> their<br />
ambitions, however, they<br />
surprised all and sundry by<br />
going on and winning the<br />
coveted trophy.<br />
Lansdowne who had<br />
enjoyed a very successful<br />
season, losing only 5 <strong>of</strong><br />
their 29 starts were the<br />
warmest <strong>of</strong> favourites<br />
to lift the trophy for the<br />
second time. As Instonians<br />
the Ulster standard<br />
bearers had withdrawn<br />
from the competition, the<br />
headquarters side were<br />
expected to have an easy<br />
passage. Young <strong>Munster</strong><br />
BANK OF IRELAND MUNSTER SENIOR CHALLENGE CUP 2022/23 13
Garryowen’s Niall Horan celebrates after<br />
winning the Bateman <strong>Cup</strong><br />
having got the better <strong>of</strong><br />
the rugged challenge <strong>of</strong><br />
Galwegians the previous day<br />
stood toe to toe with their<br />
more vaunted opponents,<br />
who boosted seven<br />
internationals in their ranks<br />
and gained a meritorious<br />
and highly deserving victory<br />
by two tries, courtesy <strong>of</strong><br />
Joe McNeice and Mick<br />
O’Flaherty to a penalty goal.<br />
The contest was rated as<br />
one <strong>of</strong> the best to have been<br />
played in the competition,<br />
Mr. Godfrey Bateman the<br />
donor <strong>of</strong> the cup, who was<br />
himself a <strong>Munster</strong> man born<br />
in Co. Kerry, in presenting<br />
the trophy, warmly<br />
congratulated both teams.<br />
He continued by saying that<br />
as this was the first occasion<br />
that the cup had gone South,<br />
and the fact that the winners<br />
were now the undisputed<br />
champions <strong>of</strong> Irish Rugby,<br />
would do an immense<br />
amount <strong>of</strong> good for the game<br />
in the province.<br />
The victory was celebrated<br />
in Limerick the following<br />
day. As the train drew into<br />
the station fog signals<br />
exploded and thousands <strong>of</strong><br />
people who congregated on<br />
the streets outside and on<br />
the platform gave vent to<br />
their jubilation in frequent<br />
rounds <strong>of</strong> cheering. The<br />
team were congratulated by<br />
the mayor (Mr.J.G.O’Brien)<br />
on their achievement in<br />
bringing the trophy South<br />
for the first time since it was<br />
presented for competition.<br />
The team was subsequently<br />
entertained to dinner at<br />
the Glentworth Hotel. The<br />
successful XV was – Murty<br />
King, Mick O’Flaherty,<br />
Martin Cosgrove, Paddy<br />
Deegan, Joe McNeice, Joe<br />
O’Dea, Michael ‘Danaher’<br />
Sheehan, Charlie St.George,<br />
Frank Garvey, Fonnie Neilan<br />
(captain), Henry Raleigh,<br />
Tom Hickey. John Joe<br />
Connery, Jerry Killeen,<br />
James ‘Ter’ Casey. The<br />
referee was W. Harland<br />
(Ulster Branch).<br />
Eight years later University<br />
College Cork produced an<br />
outstanding team, a hattrick<br />
<strong>of</strong> senior cups, senior<br />
league champions, and<br />
charity cup wins culminated<br />
in a Bateman <strong>Cup</strong> success in<br />
1936. Five <strong>of</strong> the team were<br />
to represent <strong>Ireland</strong>, while<br />
many others wore the red<br />
<strong>of</strong> <strong>Munster</strong>. The defeat <strong>of</strong><br />
Clontarf in the semi-final was<br />
something <strong>of</strong> a staggering<br />
surprise. There may have<br />
been an overwhelming<br />
confidence in their ranks<br />
that influenced them to rest<br />
their star player scrum half<br />
George Morgan, and, if so,<br />
they paid a galling price in<br />
their defeat at the hands <strong>of</strong><br />
University College Galway<br />
by the narrowest <strong>of</strong> margins<br />
following extra time.<br />
The other semi-final proved<br />
to be a hectic struggle<br />
between the students<br />
<strong>of</strong> Cork and Belfast, the<br />
exchanges were fought<br />
out with relentless vigour –<br />
14 WWW.MUNSTERRUGBY.IE
entering the closing stages<br />
the southern men lost<br />
Laycock who was put <strong>of</strong>f for<br />
shoving in the lineout, with<br />
Billy O’Sullivan and Dave<br />
O’Loughlin carrying injuries<br />
the winners had to injure<br />
many anxious moments<br />
before the referee blew for<br />
no side with the Cork side<br />
ahead on the scoreboard by<br />
nine points to eight.<br />
The efforts <strong>of</strong> the previous<br />
day eventually told on the<br />
reserves <strong>of</strong> endurance <strong>of</strong> the<br />
Galway students, following a<br />
scoreless first half, a scoring<br />
burst in the last quarter<br />
which yielded 17 points<br />
gave the trophy to UCC over<br />
their Galway counterparts.<br />
The College team that<br />
brought the first ever<br />
Bateman <strong>Cup</strong> to Cork was –<br />
Con Moloney (Roscrea), Ben<br />
McKenna (PBC), David Lane<br />
(CBC), Barry Collins (PBC),<br />
Joe O’Connor (Rockwell<br />
College), Brendan O’Brien<br />
captain (Blackrock College),<br />
Robert McClement (PBC),<br />
T.Reid, Denis Rearden<br />
(Castleknock College),<br />
Donagh Tierney (CBC),<br />
Dick Bergin (Blackrock<br />
College), Jack Russell (St.<br />
Colman’s College, Fermoy),<br />
Joe Laycock (Clongowes<br />
Wood College), Jim Buckner<br />
(Clongowes Wood College),<br />
Tom McDermott (PBC).<br />
In 2010, Bruff confronted<br />
the critics by winning<br />
the <strong>Munster</strong> <strong>Senior</strong> <strong>Cup</strong><br />
defeating renowned cup<br />
fighters Garryowen in the<br />
first final to be staged in<br />
the re-furbished Thomond<br />
Park, many keen observers<br />
rated it the best deciders for<br />
many years, it is also worth<br />
noting that the winners<br />
are only campaigning in<br />
senior ranks for the last five<br />
seasons. They followed this<br />
up with a thrilling victory<br />
over centenary celebrating<br />
University College Dublin<br />
in the penultimate stages<br />
and finished the job by<br />
getting the better <strong>of</strong> Ulster<br />
representatives Dungannon<br />
in the final to finish <strong>of</strong>f a<br />
memorable campaign.<br />
In season 2011/12<br />
Garryowen continued<br />
<strong>Munster</strong>’s dominance <strong>of</strong><br />
the Ulster <strong>Bank</strong> All-<strong>Ireland</strong><br />
Bateman <strong>Cup</strong>. Having<br />
reversed the result <strong>of</strong> the<br />
previous season’s <strong>Senior</strong><br />
<strong>Cup</strong> final loss to Bruff,<br />
the light blues saw <strong>of</strong>f the<br />
challenge <strong>of</strong> the Connacht<br />
representatives Buccaneers<br />
at Dubarry Park.<br />
In 2019, Garryowen claimed<br />
the Bateman <strong>Cup</strong> for the<br />
first time since 2012 with<br />
brothers Neil and Liam<br />
Cronin combining for three<br />
tries in their 45-21 win over<br />
first-time finalists City <strong>of</strong><br />
Armagh last season.<br />
In most recent times,<br />
Cork Constitution shared<br />
the Bateman <strong>Cup</strong> with<br />
Lansdowne in 2020 after the<br />
season was cancelled due to<br />
the Covid-19 pandemic. This<br />
year, Young <strong>Munster</strong> lost out<br />
to Terenure College in the<br />
semi-final.<br />
BATEMAN ALL-IRELAND<br />
SENIOR CUP WINNERS<br />
1922 – Lansdowne<br />
1923 – Bective Rangers<br />
1924 – Queen’s University<br />
1925 – Bective Rangers<br />
1926 – Dublin University<br />
1927 – Instonians<br />
1928 – Young <strong>Munster</strong><br />
1929 – Lansdowne<br />
1930 – Lansdowne<br />
1931 – Lansdowne<br />
1932 – Queen’s University<br />
1933/1934 – Suspended<br />
1935 – North <strong>of</strong> <strong>Ireland</strong> FC<br />
1936 – University College Cork<br />
1937 – Queen’s University<br />
1938 – University College Dublin<br />
1939 – Blackrock College<br />
1940/1974 – Suspended<br />
1975 – St.Mary’s College<br />
1976/2009 – Suspended<br />
2010/2011 – Bruff<br />
2011/2012 – Garryowen<br />
2012/2013 – Cork Constitution<br />
2013/2014 – Cork Constitution<br />
2014/2015 – Cork Constitution<br />
2015/2016 – Cork Constitution<br />
2016/2017 – Cork Constitution<br />
2017/2018 – Lansdowne<br />
2018/2019 – Garryowen<br />
2019/2020 - Cork Constitution /<br />
Lansdowne.<br />
2020/2021 - N/A.<br />
2021/2022 - Lansdowne.<br />
2022/2023 Terenure College<br />
BANK OF IRELAND MUNSTER SENIOR CHALLENGE CUP 2022/23 15
<strong>Bank</strong> breaking up with you?<br />
Time to find someone new.<br />
To get over your old banking partner, download<br />
our step-by-step guide to moving banks.<br />
Search <strong>Bank</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Ireland</strong> Big Move<br />
16 WWW.MUNSTERRUGBY.IE<br />
<strong>Bank</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Ireland</strong> is regulated by the Central <strong>Bank</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Ireland</strong>.