Contact Magazine Vol.20 No.1 - May 2023
The Colours of the Economy - a Trinidad and Tobago perseptive
The Colours of the Economy - a Trinidad and Tobago perseptive
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
Vol. 20 No. 1 - <strong>May</strong> <strong>2023</strong><br />
The Voice of BUSINESS in Trinidad & Tobago<br />
THE COLOURS OF THE ECONOMY<br />
- a Trinidad and Tobago perspective<br />
Meet Monte Wyatt, international best-selling author<br />
Contributions from Harvard Business Review and MckInsey & Company<br />
How are Trinidad & Tobago businesses innovating?
TTCIC President’s Message<br />
President’s<br />
Message<br />
COUTRTESY TTCIC<br />
The Trinidad and Tobago Chamber of Industry and<br />
Commerce (TTCIC) represents a diverse number<br />
of business sectors in our national community. We<br />
are the voice of our members on 40 working groups,<br />
taskforces, boards, and national councils. This is<br />
how we continuously seek the best interests of our<br />
members. Our voice is not divorced from the wellbeing<br />
of the national community.<br />
Sixty years after becoming an independent State,<br />
Trinidad and Tobago faces economic and social issues<br />
and global events that are converging to place us at a<br />
nexus. There are no economic models for uncertainty.<br />
The business landscape is constantly evolving,<br />
and we must adapt to these changes in order to<br />
succeed. We need to be responsive and proactive<br />
and remember that it’s not the ‘big that eats the small’<br />
but ‘the fast that eats the slow’. The global events of<br />
the last three years have underscored the importance<br />
of agility and resilience.<br />
What does our resilience strategy look like? How will<br />
we deal with the risk of high inflation and economic<br />
downturn? Digital disruption? Geopolitical risks?<br />
How do we create the framework for a business<br />
environment that fosters the principles of shared<br />
prosperity that is committed to promoting diversity,<br />
equity, and inclusion?<br />
To meet these challenges, we must:<br />
• Develop innovative financial models to unleash our economic<br />
potential. This can include blended finance and social impact<br />
investing, which will help increase economic participation.<br />
• Enhance environmental, social and governance (ESG)<br />
protocols – activities in this area is being led by the Chamber’s<br />
ESG Committee.<br />
• Embrace and increase the adoption of digital technology.<br />
The Chamber’s newly formed Digital Business and Technology<br />
Committee has already begun to consider – Where is artificial<br />
intelligence taking us? How do we deal with cybercrime,<br />
cryptocurrency, and emerging ICT risks?<br />
• Provide a forum for shared learning; the Chamber has a<br />
series of events, conferences, publications, and seminars which<br />
support this.<br />
• Expand the entrepreneurial ecosystem in a meaningful way.<br />
Micro, small and medium-sized companies (MSMEs) are the<br />
backbone of many global economies, especially in developing<br />
countries. The vital role of MSMEs goes beyond the economic<br />
benefit to social impacts as they engage in community and<br />
family life. They need assistance with funding and competing<br />
economies of scale, and we need to provide support.<br />
• Develop strategies to build markets focusing on value chain<br />
development, export promotion, and green supply chains, which<br />
can mitigate the risks of climate change by moving towards a<br />
zero-emission policy.<br />
There are hidden opportunities for economic advancement by<br />
catalysing our tourism sector. Not only beaches and carnival. Let’s go<br />
deeper: cultural tourism, eco-tourism, literary tourism, and wellness<br />
tourism. What about the orange economy? This is an area where we<br />
can become globally competitive and generate jobs for the creative<br />
industries.<br />
2 MAY <strong>2023</strong> CHAMBER.ORG.TT
TTCIC President’s Message<br />
More public-private partnerships (PPPs)<br />
are needed to advance these sectors.<br />
The challenges of everyday life also impact<br />
the business community:<br />
• Crime – is a plague that we must stamp<br />
out, and it can be done if there is the will<br />
to implement measures to address it. A<br />
detection rate of seven per cent is not<br />
good enough; we need to act urgently<br />
and collaboratively.<br />
• Food security and food prices - the<br />
Central Statistical Office (CSO) reported<br />
inflation rates of eight per cent in<br />
February this year. In January, it was at 8.3<br />
per cent. We must be cognizant of what<br />
contributes to a desired cost of living<br />
overall. Can we be less reliant on imported<br />
goods? We need to ensure that the agricultural space is<br />
preserved and developed and further our relations with<br />
the Ministry of Agriculture, Land and Fisheries and the<br />
farming community.<br />
• Regional integration must be at the front and centre of<br />
what we do if we are to survive. The CARICOM Single<br />
Market and Economy (CSME) framework needs to evolve<br />
with the global business environment. At the TTCIC, we<br />
are planning a few good surprises to strengthen our global<br />
competitiveness and regional cooperation. Stay tuned!<br />
• Are we serious about improving the ‘Ease of Doing<br />
Business’? We must be relentless in communicating<br />
how we solve some of the current bugbears and employ<br />
strategies to set us straight. We need to abandon the<br />
’shop talk’ and get our hands dirty. Collaborating with<br />
the government, our CSME partners and members of<br />
the diplomatic corps will guarantee that we get where we<br />
need to be.<br />
We must also actively work to develop our workforce to<br />
ensure that they have the skills and knowledge needed to<br />
compete in today’s market.<br />
Are we committed to the enhancement of our social fabric?<br />
As the private sector, are we acknowledging and supporting<br />
our non-governmental organisations (NGOs) and civil<br />
society actors who work tirelessly to maintain stability and<br />
ignite hope?<br />
Our country needs a drastic shift. If we are to survive, we<br />
must recognise that we are ultimately in charge of creating<br />
our environment and outcomes.<br />
The challenges identified are not insurmountable. We are<br />
interconnected, and we must embrace transformation and<br />
engage all stakeholders.<br />
As the newly elected President of the TTCIC for the <strong>2023</strong> -<br />
2024 term, I will work with the Chamber’s team to advocate<br />
for and implement recommendations to address these<br />
challenges and improve the local business environment. As<br />
one of my first acts, I am delighted to re-launch CONTACT<br />
magazine, our flagship publication. As you explore the<br />
colours of our economy, I hope that you will discover, new<br />
ideas, insights and opportunities.<br />
Let’s roll up our sleeves and do what we have to for the<br />
prosperity of our beautiful country, Trinidad and Tobago<br />
because there’s no place we’d rather be than ‘Sweet T&T’.<br />
Kiran Maharaj<br />
President<br />
Trinidad & Tobago Chamber of Industry & Commerce (TTCIC)<br />
CHAMBER.ORG.TT MAY <strong>2023</strong><br />
3
Editor’s Note<br />
The Colours of the Economy - a Trinidad & Tobago perspective<br />
Welcome back! The Trinidad and Tobago Chamber of<br />
Industry and Commerce is excited to re-launch<br />
magazine. On a hiatus due to the COVID-19 pandemic, this<br />
trusted national brand, published since the 1990s, was missed.<br />
has a 30-year track record covering a broad range<br />
of topics; our stories focus on critical business issues impacting<br />
Trinidad and Tobago and the Caribbean region. This year we will<br />
partner with the private and public sectors across big themes,<br />
including economic development, finance, energy, healthcare,<br />
globalisation, and sustainability.<br />
There are many approaches to classifying the economy.<br />
Colour coding different economic perspectives links the<br />
colours of the economy to the United Nation’s Sustainable<br />
Development Goals (SDGs). In this issue of<br />
, we<br />
focus on the 10 colours expected to impact Trinidad and<br />
Tobago’s economic development.<br />
Our editorial team is also excited to announce that we have<br />
obtained permission to reprint articles from the Harvard Business<br />
Review and McKinsey & Company. We hope that these articles<br />
will give you insights and best practices to help meet business<br />
challenges and advance your career.<br />
Meet Monte Wyatt, who wrote and published “Pulling Profits<br />
out of a Hat” – a best-seller according to Wall Street Journal, and<br />
feature speaker at the Chamber’s Annual Business Meeting held<br />
in April.<br />
In the Voice of Business, we learn how three businesses are<br />
innovating; and in the Top Five Facts we analyse Trinidad and<br />
Tobago’s exports. Chamber Directors weigh in on the best app<br />
on their smartphone in the new Leadership Insights spotlight.<br />
The Chamber’s Trade and Business Development Unit evaluated<br />
global, regional and local performance in the Economic Outlook.<br />
Finally, in a new feature, we look back at the Chamber’s Annual<br />
Business Meeting held last month. We invite you to enter, explore,<br />
and learn with us.<br />
Natalie Dookie<br />
Editor<br />
The Green Economy<br />
contains many<br />
diverse approaches<br />
to enhance<br />
efficiency,<br />
eliminate<br />
pollution<br />
and recycle waste.<br />
(changeoracle.com)<br />
The Blue Economy<br />
refers to efforts to<br />
preserve the finite<br />
resources in the<br />
oceans and waterways.<br />
Biotechnology, fisheries,<br />
and aquaculture are all<br />
part of this economy.<br />
(changeoracle.com)<br />
The Golden Economy<br />
explicitly addresses<br />
the destructive<br />
impacts of<br />
the economy by<br />
replacing fossil fuels<br />
with non-fossil energy/<br />
renewable energy<br />
sources.<br />
(changeoracle.com)<br />
The Purple Economy<br />
encompasses critical<br />
social issues that<br />
improve everyone’s<br />
quality of life. This<br />
includes care activities<br />
and services, such as<br />
education, healthcare,<br />
and<br />
women’s empowerment.<br />
(changeoracle.com)<br />
The White Economy<br />
is the health industry.<br />
It includes hospitals, the<br />
pharmaceutical industry,<br />
the medical supply<br />
sector as well as<br />
providers<br />
of medical equipment.<br />
(changeoracle.com)<br />
The Silver Economy<br />
is the sum of the<br />
economic activities of<br />
people over 50. This<br />
includes the products<br />
and services they<br />
purchase and the<br />
economic<br />
activity this generates.<br />
(changeoracle.com))<br />
The Red Economy<br />
economic model is<br />
focused on reducing<br />
production costs by<br />
employing a linear<br />
business model of<br />
extracting resources<br />
and producing waste.<br />
(changeoracle.com)<br />
The Grey Economy<br />
is diverse economic<br />
activities that may<br />
be legal but evade<br />
taxes. It can include<br />
street vendors and<br />
unregistered factory<br />
workers to larger<br />
‘off the books’<br />
transactions.<br />
(changeoracle.com)<br />
The Black Economy<br />
is illegal or unauthorised<br />
economic activities,<br />
including human<br />
trafficking and<br />
smuggling<br />
of weapons. It can<br />
apply to any product<br />
prohibited by a given<br />
country’s laws.<br />
(changeoracle.com)<br />
The Orange Economy<br />
is a production model<br />
where goods and<br />
services have intellectual<br />
value because they are<br />
the product of the ideas<br />
and expertise of their<br />
creators.<br />
(santander.com)<br />
4 MAY <strong>2023</strong> CHAMBER.ORG.TT
Contents<br />
<strong>Vol.20</strong> No.4 - <strong>May</strong> <strong>2023</strong><br />
TTCIC’s President’s Message 2<br />
Kiran Maharaj<br />
Editor’s Note 4<br />
Natalie Dookie<br />
Leadership<br />
Monte Wyatt – how to add zeros to your profits 8<br />
Actions the best CEOs are taking in <strong>2023</strong> 13<br />
c. McKinsey & Company. Reprint<br />
Carolyn Dewar, Scott Keller, Vikram Malhotra, Kurt Strovink<br />
White Economy<br />
Shaping healthcare in Trinidad and Tobago today<br />
for the patients of tomorrow 19<br />
Dr Damion Basdeo, Dr Andrew Lakhan, Dr Penelope Paltoo<br />
Golden Economy<br />
A glimmer of gold: decentralising T&T’s energy<br />
infrastructure 22<br />
Ryan Assiu<br />
Your biggest cybersecurity risks could be inside<br />
your organization 26<br />
c. Harvard Business Review. Reprint<br />
Bret Arsenault<br />
Purple Economy<br />
Social cohesion - a pillar of economic growth<br />
and development 29<br />
Tonni Brodber<br />
Orange Economy<br />
Lights, Camera, Action! Exploring the potential of<br />
Trinidad and Tobago’s creative industries 32<br />
Leslie-Ann Wills-Caton<br />
Top 5 Facts<br />
T&T’s exports - performance and prospects 36<br />
Leeooi-Oneika Howard, Brian Benoit<br />
Black Economy<br />
Shining light on Trinidad & Tobago’s underground<br />
economy 39<br />
Dr Timothy Affonso<br />
Red Economy<br />
KC kickstarts the next 100 years of<br />
export-led growth 43<br />
Asha Javeed<br />
Voice of Business 46<br />
Ria Chaitram<br />
Grey Economy<br />
Doubling down on T&T’s grey economy 48<br />
Asha Javeed<br />
Blue Economy<br />
Diving into the blue economy! Transitioning<br />
to sustainability 52<br />
Sarah Mahadeo<br />
Leadership Insights 55<br />
What’s the best app on your smartphone, and why?<br />
Silver Economy<br />
The business of ageing: unlocking the possibilities<br />
of the silver economy 56<br />
Dr Jennifer Rouse<br />
Green Economy<br />
Finding balance between the planet and profits 60<br />
Rudolph Hanamji<br />
Economic Outlook 65<br />
Rianna E Paul<br />
Chamber Events 68<br />
For Your Bookshelf 70<br />
CHAMBER.ORG.TT MAY <strong>2023</strong><br />
5
Club ad for T&T Chamber magazine.pdf 1 22/03/<strong>2023</strong> 8:18 AM<br />
Welcome Home<br />
to Caribbean Club<br />
C<br />
M<br />
Y<br />
CM<br />
MY<br />
CY<br />
CMY<br />
K<br />
• Select lounges across our network<br />
• Priority check-in and boarding<br />
• 5 Date change penalty fee waiver vouchers<br />
• Discounts at 50+ hotels, restaurants, and retailers<br />
Janetta Boodoosingh<br />
3000000695<br />
VALID THRU 12/<strong>2023</strong><br />
Club
The Voice of BUSINESS in Trinidad & Tobago<br />
Published by<br />
Columbus Circle, Westmoorings, Port of Spain,<br />
Trinidad and Tobago<br />
P.O. Box 499, Port of Spain | Tel: (868) 637-6966 | Fax: (868) 622-4475<br />
Email: chamber@chamber.org.tt | Website: chamber.org.tt<br />
Tobago Division<br />
ANSA McAL Building, Milford Road, Scarborough, Tobago<br />
Tel: (868) 639-2669 | Fax: (868) 639-2669<br />
Email: tobagochamber@chamber.org.tt<br />
Publisher TTCIC<br />
Executive Editor Kiran Maharaj<br />
Editor Natalie Dookie<br />
Page Layout & Design Kathryn Duncan<br />
Coordinator Ria Chaitram<br />
Advertising TTCIC<br />
DISCLAIMER<br />
Opinions expressed in CONTACT are those of the authors, and not<br />
necessarily of the Trinidad and Tobago Chamber of Industry and<br />
Commerce or its partners or associates.<br />
LIDIAN NEELEMAN/SHUTTERSTOCK.COM<br />
CONTACT is published by the Trinidad and Tobago Chamber<br />
of Industry and Commerce (TTCIC). It is available online at<br />
https://chamber.org.tt/media/the-contact-business-magazine<br />
© <strong>2023</strong> TTCIC. All rights reserved. No part of this magazine<br />
may be reproduced in any form without the written<br />
permission of the publisher.
Monte<br />
Wyatt –<br />
how to<br />
add zeros<br />
to your<br />
profits<br />
COURTESY MONTE WYATT<br />
8 MAY <strong>2023</strong> CHAMBER.ORG.TT
Leadership<br />
interviews Monte Wyatt, award-winning executive<br />
leadership coach. Co-author of “Pulling Profits Out of a Hat”,<br />
Wyatt achieved best-seller status with Wall Street Journal<br />
and USA Today. His organisation, AddingZEROS Executive<br />
Development, has helped numerous companies achieve<br />
Executives that work with Monte Wyatt have lauded praise on his innovative techniques. They often<br />
describe the experience as “adding clarity on how to lead and manage an organisation and teams.” Wyatt has taught and<br />
also challenged executives using differentiated leadership and management concepts. Leadership creates passionate,<br />
focused team members with influence. Management creates competent, productive team members. Both leadership and<br />
management are needed today more than ever. These behavioural teaching concepts have helped leaders think more<br />
clearly. Over the last 30 years, Monte has made a lasting impact on CEOs and executives across the globe.<br />
As an Executive Development Facilitator, tell us about what you do.<br />
AddingZEROS is an international executive and organisational development firm with facilitators worldwide.<br />
My facilitators and I help CEOs and leadership teams with execution planning and how to think strategically.<br />
This includes organisational discipline and executive coaching and development. The AddingZEROS concepts<br />
I created are driven by a belief and practice of making complex subjects simple.<br />
AddingZEROS focuses on growing zeros in revenues and profits. I believe teams should be growing zeros<br />
(AddingZEROS) in every aspect of an organisation – culture, employee relations, customer acquisition and<br />
retention, community involvement, and revenues and profits. My process creates organisational discipline in<br />
strategy, business development, people, execution, and mission.<br />
What are “The Five Disciplines”?<br />
A great business is defined as one that is sustainable, predictable, stable, consistent and has an emotional<br />
connection. To achieve this, a great business must be disciplined, and executives and teams must have<br />
organisational and personal discipline. There are Five Disciplines that every organisation needs to possess to<br />
be successful. They are strategy, business development, people, execution, and mission. Organisations must<br />
make decisions in these areas and stick to those decisions. This is where discipline comes into play.<br />
Your business strategy leads to sustainability in your organisation. It’s how you articulate the way you do<br />
business. It’s where you want to go and the roadmap to get you there. Strategy is about skilful management<br />
to achieve your goals and create longevity.<br />
There are Five Disciplines that every organisation needs<br />
to possess to be successful. They are strategy, business<br />
development, people, execution, and mission<br />
CHAMBER.ORG.TT MAY <strong>2023</strong><br />
9
Leadership<br />
Business development leads to predictability. Predictability comes from understanding the causes of past<br />
growth to calculate future exponential growth. Effective business development and predictability come from<br />
testing and measuring numbers in three essential areas – marketing, sales, and customer service. It’s about<br />
gaining and retaining customers.<br />
The discipline of people leads to stability. You create an environment where people know their role and feel<br />
appreciated. A business can do this by investing in leadership, talent development, and recruitment. It’s about<br />
employee growth and engagement.<br />
Execution leads to consistency. Consistency provides familiarity and assurance that you have your act<br />
together, are in control, and are dependable. You know when a business is consistent – when you, as a<br />
customer, employee or stakeholder, are treated ‘the right way’ all the time, and you can count on this in your<br />
dealings with the business. It’s about organisational efficiency and processes.<br />
The discipline of mission creates an emotional connection inside and outside a company. A company<br />
should spotlight its impact on the world. It should have an answer for employees who ask, ‘Why do I go to<br />
work every day?’ The mission is why the company does what it does. The discipline of mission enables people<br />
to connect with your company. It comprises three main ideas which define your organisation – core values,<br />
purpose, and giving back.<br />
These five disciplines focus on improving things that can be measured – often in areas that might have been<br />
overlooked and can be used to foster growth.<br />
AddingZEROS focuses on growing zeros in revenues<br />
and profits. I believe teams should be growing zeros<br />
(AddingZEROS) in every aspect of an organisation – culture,<br />
employee relations, customer acquisition and retention,<br />
community involvement, and revenues and profits.<br />
What is the best thing about the work you do?<br />
One of my key messages is ‘strategic thinking, execution planning’. You must learn how to think long-term<br />
and focus on the bigger picture. Every team needs to be taught how to think strategically. A major gap is<br />
implementation. Many of us make great plans, however we get distracted and lose focus on our follow-through.<br />
You must plan your implementation and execution - who does what and by when. Create communication and<br />
accountability practices that lead to making progress. Lead people and manage processes. Lead people to<br />
become inspired and understand their impact. Manage processes to ensure that you are moving forward and<br />
accomplishing desired results.<br />
What’s the next big goal for AddingZEROS?<br />
We have a 10-year vision to impact one million executives around the world. We want to help them become<br />
better leaders, managers, thinkers, and doers. Executives have a significant influence on growing people and<br />
their behaviours. When we impact one million executives, we will impact the world.<br />
Learn more, visit: www.AddZerosNow.com<br />
CHAMBER.ORG.TT MAY <strong>2023</strong><br />
11
Strategy & Corporate Finance Practice<br />
Actions the best CEOs<br />
are taking in <strong>2023</strong><br />
Corporate leaders are addressing the risks while finding<br />
the opportunities in digital disruption, the economy, and<br />
geopolitical uncertainties.<br />
by Carolyn Dewar, Scott Keller, Vikram Malhotra, and Kurt Strovink<br />
March <strong>2023</strong><br />
CHAMBER.ORG.TT MAY <strong>2023</strong><br />
13
“Anyone can hold the helm when the sea is calm.”― Publilius Syrus<br />
In his 2017 book, Hit Refresh, Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella writes that great leaders “recognize<br />
the true signal within a lot of noise” and act accordingly. Fast forward to <strong>2023</strong>, and the torrent of<br />
trends, ideas, and information that leaders now face makes knowing what matters more difficult<br />
than ever.<br />
It’s against this backdrop that McKinsey conducted its latest CEO Excellence Survey, to take the<br />
pulse of leading CEOs’ evolving priorities and the actions they’re taking in response. We started<br />
by asking a group of the world’s top-performing CEOs (see sidebar, “Survey methodology”)<br />
which trends will have the biggest impact on how they lead their business in <strong>2023</strong> compared with<br />
past years. Their answers suggest that three “true signals” matter most: digital disruption, the<br />
economy, and geopolitics (exhibit).<br />
Second, we asked about the specific and pragmatic actions they are taking as a result of these<br />
signals. Here we found that a consistent mix of defensive (protecting against risks) and offensive<br />
(capturing new opportunities) maneuvers create a powerful playbook for leaders in <strong>2023</strong>, the<br />
details of which we discuss in this article.<br />
Web <br />
<br />
Exhibit<br />
Exhibit of <br />
Top CEOs identify disruptive technology, the economy, and geopolitics as the<br />
most important trends to act on in <strong>2023</strong>.<br />
Trends that have the biggest impact on how CEOs are leading their organizations in <strong>2023</strong>, 1<br />
% of respondents (n = 73)<br />
Rise of disruptive digital technologies<br />
Risk of prolonged high inflation and economic downturn<br />
58<br />
56<br />
Escalation of geopolitical risks<br />
47<br />
War for talent<br />
Shifts in the way we work<br />
Increased importance of climate change and net-zero transition<br />
30<br />
29<br />
34<br />
Increase in supply chain disruptions<br />
14<br />
Higher expectation for companies to have social purpose<br />
11<br />
Persistence of the gender and racial gap in the economy<br />
7<br />
Emergence of blockchain and Web3<br />
1<br />
Other<br />
11<br />
100<br />
1<br />
Question: From your perspective as a current or former CEO, which of the following trends will have the biggest impact on how you lead/would lead your<br />
organization in <strong>2023</strong> and beyond, compared with past years? Respondents selected their three most important trends.<br />
Source: McKinsey CEO Excellence Survey<br />
McKinsey & Company<br />
2 Actions the best CEOs are taking in <strong>2023</strong><br />
14 MAY <strong>2023</strong> CHAMBER.ORG.TT
Survey methodology<br />
To conduct this survey, we first<br />
determined analytically 200 of the best<br />
corporate CEOs of the past 15 years. 1<br />
To do so, we started with the list of all<br />
current and former CEOs of the 1,000<br />
largest public companies during that time<br />
frame. 2 We then filtered this list based<br />
on tenure, including only those who had<br />
completed at least six years in the role,<br />
demonstrating a consistent track record of<br />
success. Next, we applied a performance<br />
filter to only include CEOs who, in their<br />
tenure, delivered results in the top two<br />
quintiles of excess TSR. 3 From there, we<br />
further filtered for those who had been<br />
recognized by one or more “best CEO”<br />
lists, 4 which take into account factors such<br />
as the individual’s societal, environmental,<br />
and ethical conduct, as well as employee<br />
sentiment. Finally, to better reflect the<br />
diversity of today’s business landscape,<br />
we included additional CEOs from outside<br />
the 1,000 largest public companies in<br />
underrepresented segments who met a<br />
high bar of performance and reputation.<br />
This methodology is consistent with the<br />
approach used in the New York Times<br />
bestseller CEO Excellence (Scribner, 2022).<br />
In the survey itself, each CEO was asked<br />
to identify the top three trends that will<br />
have the biggest impact on how they lead/<br />
would lead their organization in <strong>2023</strong> and<br />
beyond. (For retired CEOs, we asked them<br />
to share the advice they are giving sitting<br />
CEOs.) Based on the trends selected,<br />
the CEOs were then asked to select the<br />
top three changes (from a list of seven to<br />
ten, of which “other” was also a choice) that<br />
they will drive across their organization<br />
in <strong>2023</strong> to address the trend. This survey<br />
was fielded from December 9, 2022, to<br />
February 15, <strong>2023</strong>.<br />
1<br />
As individual CEO Excellence Survey responses are confidential, all company data and attributed CEO quotes in this article are from publicly available information, primarily<br />
earnings transcripts, letters to shareholders, and press statements.<br />
2<br />
Top 1,000 companies in the global Forbes 2000 list as of April 2022 that ranks largest companies in the world based on a composite of revenue, profits, assets, and<br />
market capitalization.<br />
3<br />
TSR over tenure in excess of the return their industry peers delivered, adjusted for geographical variations in growth.<br />
4<br />
Fortune’s Most Powerful Women in Business, Harvard Business Review’s Best-Performing CEOs, Barron’s Top CEOs, CEOWORLD’s Most Influential CEOs, and Forbes’s<br />
America’s 100 Most Innovative Leaders.<br />
1. Actions to deal with digital disruption<br />
The mindset with which CEOs are approaching digital trends was well summarized by one<br />
CEO’s written survey comment: “A CEO also has to be the chief technology architect. Think of<br />
the executive team—not just the chief digital officer—as owning the technology strategy of the<br />
company. There is too much at stake.”<br />
This focus on digital disruption is being put into practice in three ways:<br />
— Developing advanced analytics (62 percent of CEOs 1 ): OpenAI’s introduction of ChatGPT in<br />
late 2022 put gasoline on the already well-lit fire of companies looking to leverage advanced<br />
analytics for competitive advantage. Companies such as the beverage maker Diageo are<br />
already seeing the value of applying advanced analytics: its use of geolocation data to<br />
personalize and target content for consumers has led to a 17 percent increase in media spend<br />
ROI. And at the financial services giant Sun Life, the use of predictive analytics now allows it<br />
1<br />
Percentage of CEOs who selected this trend as important and who report this as among the top three actions they are taking.<br />
Actions the best CEOs are taking in <strong>2023</strong><br />
3<br />
CHAMBER.ORG.TT MAY <strong>2023</strong><br />
15
‘Act early to lower costs and<br />
protect the balance sheet so<br />
that you are stronger and leaner<br />
when the economy begins<br />
to turn more favorably.’<br />
–CEO Excellence Survey respondent<br />
to process 60 percent of its life insurance policies without lab testing, creating a dramatically<br />
improved experience for its customers.<br />
— Enhancing cybersecurity (48 percent): JPMorgan Chase has been one of the most<br />
outspoken firms on why spending billions on cyber-related changes—ranging from<br />
modernizing infrastructure and developer tools, to embedding cybersecurity controls into the<br />
business, to training employees to be vigilant—is vital. “Cyberthreats pose extreme hazards<br />
to our company and our country,” CEO Jamie Dimon asserts in a letter to shareholders. “This<br />
has become even more evident as the cost of ransomware has increased dramatically. … And<br />
it is evident to everyone, with the war in Ukraine, that grave damage could be inflicted if cyber<br />
is used as a tool of war.”<br />
— Automating work (45 percent): As Morgan Stanley CEO James Gorman explained when<br />
speaking to analysts, “Tech spend is going up … but that’s good because it’s displacing<br />
things we would otherwise be doing manually, which we shouldn’t be doing manually.”<br />
Healthcare provider Humana, for example, has reduced nursing turnover by leveraging<br />
technology to reduce administrative tasks. Walmart has used automation to cut in half the<br />
number of steps needed to ship products at some of its e-commerce distribution centers.<br />
2. Actions to deal with the risk of high inflation and economic downturn<br />
As one CEO worried about economic uncertainty put it in the survey response: “Act early<br />
to lower costs and protect the balance sheet so that you are stronger and leaner when the<br />
economy begins to turn more favorably.” McKinsey research supports this view. Companies that<br />
outperformed peers during the 2008 crisis cut operating costs by 1 percent before the downturn,<br />
while the others expanded costs by the same percentage. The best performers also reduced<br />
their debt by $1 for every $1 of book capital before the downturn.<br />
— Reduce operating expenses (76 percent): The technology sector has already shed more<br />
than 100,000 jobs in <strong>2023</strong>. However, at General Motors, CEO Mary Barra has taken a<br />
more modest approach to workforce reductions, focusing cuts on 500 executive-level<br />
4 Actions the best CEOs are taking in <strong>2023</strong><br />
16 MAY <strong>2023</strong> CHAMBER.ORG.TT
and salaried positions and looking deeply into other, non-personnel-related expense<br />
areas. Examples of this broader set of levers the best CEOs are using include supply chain<br />
renegotiations, tax optimization, deferring capital spending, tightening expense policies, and<br />
increasing employee productivity. Amgen CEO Robert Bradway told investors that by using a<br />
combination of such methods, he believes his company’s <strong>2023</strong> operating expenses will stay<br />
flat despite increasing sales volumes and inflationary pressures on costs.<br />
— Redesign products and services (61 percent): The aforementioned cost discipline frees<br />
up cash that CEOs can use to improve products and services to better attract and retain<br />
customers. At the beauty products company Shiseido, for example, Masahiko Uotani has<br />
undertaken “a shift from defense to offense,” making proactive investment for top-line<br />
growth. Shantanu Narayen, CEO of software maker Adobe, is doing likewise with his push to<br />
find ways to give customers more value through existing products.<br />
— Reassess strategic and economic assumptions (54 percent): CEOs are revisiting their<br />
strategies on an ongoing basis. Said one survey respondent, “Stay nimble. Creating agility<br />
and adaptability is critical.” Many, including E. Scott Santi, CEO at Illinois Tool Works, have<br />
acted quickly on their pricing strategies, adjusting prices around the world to offset cost<br />
increases during the most significant inflationary cycle of the last 40 years.<br />
3. Actions to deal with the escalation of geopolitical risks<br />
One CEO’s survey comment summed up the consensus on this trend: “Globalization is changing,<br />
but it’s not disappearing. We’re entering an era with new dynamics around China and Russia, and<br />
Africa will also play a bigger role. We need to plan for multiple scenarios and have a game plan for<br />
each contingency.”<br />
— Build robust compliance capabilities (65 percent): Many companies are building up their<br />
trade compliance organizations and improving how they screen different customers and<br />
companies. While a defensive posture for most, it’s an opportunity for others. Rob Fauber,<br />
CEO of the integrated risk assessment firm Moody’s, confirmed, “There’s an intense<br />
demand right now for tools that help not only with sanctions compliance but also with better<br />
understanding the risk of who you’re connecting to, who you’re doing business with … and so<br />
we’re really leaning into that.”<br />
— Create resilience in supplier networks (62 percent): The best CEOs have already addressed<br />
potential points of failure in their supply chains. Now they are working to continuously<br />
improve resilience in this area. As Tim Cook, CEO of Apple, has stated, “We build our products<br />
everywhere. There are component parts coming from many different countries in the world,<br />
and the final assembly coming from three countries on just the iPhone. … We’ll continue to<br />
optimize it over time and change it to improve.”<br />
— Invest in monitoring and response capabilities (56 percent): Successful leaders know that<br />
having good early-warning indicators and the ability to act quickly during a crisis can turn a<br />
threat into an opportunity. Being properly prepared can also have implications for society<br />
as well. Norway’s biggest energy company, Equinor, for example, has increased its state of<br />
alert based on its assessment of threats given that energy production from the Norwegian<br />
continental shelf is crucial to Europe’s energy security.<br />
Actions the best CEOs are taking in <strong>2023</strong><br />
5<br />
CHAMBER.ORG.TT MAY <strong>2023</strong><br />
17
Find more content like this on the<br />
McKinsey Insights App<br />
Scan • Download • Personalize<br />
Beyond the top three trends<br />
The three trends discussed above are clearly ranked as the highest “signal within the noise”<br />
by the best CEOs. There is, however, a second block of three trends that a meaningful number<br />
of CEOs also flagged as important: talent, ways of working, and climate change. Here is how<br />
numerous successful CEOs are approaching these areas:<br />
— Talent: While the talent market remains tight, our survey respondents indicated they feel<br />
the time has come to refocus on employee performance, after several years of focusing<br />
more on helping employees weather the pandemic and other challenges. As Meta CEO<br />
Mark Zuckerberg has told his company’s employees, workers should prepare to have their<br />
“performances graded more intensely.” While this will be uncomfortable for some, the best<br />
CEOs believe that talented employees are by and large welcoming of such a stance.<br />
— Ways of working: In line with the topic of talent, on balance the best CEOs are also expecting<br />
employees to spend more time in the office or with customers in <strong>2023</strong>. The rationale is that<br />
doing so is ultimately good for both employees and customers: it increases mentorship, builds<br />
community, sparks innovation, and creates a stronger sense of meaning in the workplace.<br />
Many firms, including JPMorgan Chase, Starbucks, and Apple, have already made their<br />
intentions public.<br />
— Climate change: CEOs remain committed to thoughtfully making the net-zero transition. They<br />
are not interested, however, in getting caught up in “check the box” exercises related to ESG<br />
rankings and ratings. As BlackRock’s CEO Larry Fink has said in a letter to shareholders, “We<br />
focus on sustainability not because we’re environmentalists, but because we are capitalists<br />
and fiduciaries to our clients.” Leaders are paying particular attention to areas where<br />
revenue can be generated by focusing on sustainability. Russia’s invasion of Ukraine has also<br />
reinforced that being a socially responsible company means ensuring reliable, affordable<br />
traditional products can be provided during the transition.<br />
As United States President Franklin D. Roosevelt put it, “A smooth sea never made a skilled<br />
sailor.” The CEOs we surveyed are veterans who have experience steering their organizations<br />
through challenging environments. We hope that by sharing their perceptions of the true signals<br />
amid the noise, and the actions they are taking as a result, we can help all leaders navigate the<br />
turbulent waters of <strong>2023</strong> and beyond.<br />
Carolyn Dewar is a senior partner in McKinsey’s Bay Area office, Scott Keller is a senior partner in the Southern<br />
California office, and Vik Malhotra and Kurt Strovink are senior partners in the New York office.<br />
The authors would like to thank Blair Epstein, Selin Neseliler, Tanmay Tapase, Jen Whitaker, and Jessica Zehren<br />
for their contributions to this article.<br />
Designed by McKinsey Global Publishing<br />
Copyright © <strong>2023</strong> McKinsey & Company. All rights reserved.<br />
6 Actions the best CEOs are taking in <strong>2023</strong><br />
18 MAY <strong>2023</strong> CHAMBER.ORG.TT
The WHITE Economy<br />
Shaping healthcare in Trinidad and Tobago<br />
today for the patients of tomorrow<br />
By<br />
Dr Damion Basdeo MBBS (UWI),<br />
SCE Acute Medicine (UK)<br />
President <strong>2023</strong>. Trinidad & Tobago<br />
Medical Association (T&TMA)<br />
Dr Andrew Lakhan MBBS (UWI)<br />
T&TMA Chairperson for Climate<br />
Change and Health Advocacy<br />
Subcommittee, T&TMA<br />
By 2050 about 30 per cent of Trinidad and Tobago’s<br />
population is expected to be above age 60. This presents an<br />
urgent need to develop a sustainable, efficient, and effective<br />
healthcare sector. How are we reforming healthcare to meet<br />
the needs of tomorrow?<br />
The white economy refers to the services, products and activities relating to<br />
healthcare and care of the dependent, disabled and elderly. In 2005, Trinidad<br />
and Tobago’s Gross Domestic Product (GDP) was US$15.98 billion, and according<br />
to the Pan-American Health Organization (PAHO), the government invested only<br />
3.75 per cent of this in the healthcare sector. This was considerably lower compared<br />
to other islands in the region (the Caribbean and Latin America), which had an<br />
average of 5 per cent GDP attributed to healthcare. Fortunately, the percentage of<br />
GDP dedicated to healthcare has increased over the years, partially attributed to the<br />
implementation of the National Insurance System (NIS).<br />
Dr Penelope Paltoo MBBS (UWI)<br />
East Branch Member, T&TMA<br />
Investing in healthcare<br />
In 2009, the then Prime Minister, The Honourable Patrick Manning, prioritised<br />
healthcare alongside improvements in connectivity and technology. That year the<br />
HIV/AIDS Programme was also launched; it has been renamed the HIV and AIDS<br />
Coordinating Unit (HACU). This initiative has since expanded to five Regional Health<br />
Authorities (RHAs) across Trinidad and Tobago. Project implementation covered the<br />
development of policies for national HIV testing, prevention of mother-to-child<br />
transmission and post-exposure prophylaxis. Today free services available<br />
COURTESY TRINIDADEXPRESS.COM<br />
in the public sector include HIV testing, antiretroviral therapy, and care<br />
for all ages.<br />
The white economy of Trinidad and Tobago has supported digital<br />
transformation in the healthcare system through the development<br />
of electronic medical records, such as the Cellma healthcare<br />
administration system. Although the COVID-19 pandemic<br />
hindered its implementation, it accelerated telemedicine adoption,<br />
ensuring continuous patient care. The public healthcare sector<br />
provides free medication to citizens with chronic diseases through<br />
the Chronic Disease Assistance Programme (CDAP). As reported by<br />
the World Bank in 2019, this, along with other initiatives increased the<br />
government’s spending on healthcare to 7.02 per cent of GDP.<br />
CHAMBER.ORG.TT MAY <strong>2023</strong><br />
19
The WHITE Economy<br />
Biggest business opportunities<br />
Although government expenditure has increased, Trinidad and Tobago’s white economy still requires significant investment in<br />
genetic analysis and local research to enhance patient care and guide treatment. This includes sponsoring research focusing<br />
on unique local settings that may assist with patient management instead of using foreign data. Some imaging studies, such<br />
as Positron Emission Tomography (PET) scans, are only available in the private sector, creating a financial barrier to accessing<br />
care. Private hospitals and clinics contribute significantly to the economy by offering specialised treatments and procedures<br />
unavailable in the public sector, employing many persons, and contributing to economic growth. However, the high cost of<br />
private healthcare services limits access, highlighting the need to improve affordability and accessibility.<br />
Preventative medicine is critical to reducing the prevalence of chronic diseases and cancers, which account for a significant<br />
number of deaths locally and regionally. We need to invest in health programmes such as increased public health awareness,<br />
cancer screening and exercise competitions, which will aid in addressing modifiable risk factors. Approximately 30 per cent<br />
of the population is expected to be above the age of 60 by 2050, leading to a growing need for reliable health insurance and<br />
plans. While digital transformation can enhance efficiency in the healthcare system and decrease medical errors, there is a lack<br />
of good health information systems available in the region. Production of technologically advanced medical equipment and<br />
pharmaceuticals can decrease import burdens and create job opportunities in the healthcare sector. CARICOM should consider<br />
further exploring this possibility as a new niche market for trade and investment.<br />
20 MAY <strong>2023</strong> CHAMBER.ORG.TT
The WHITE Economy<br />
COUTRTESY TRINIDAD & TOBAGO MEDICAL ASSOCIATION<br />
T&TMA member outreach activities <strong>2023</strong><br />
Achieving the goal of a sustainable<br />
white economy requires a<br />
collaborative effort between the<br />
government and non-governmental<br />
organisations to promote the<br />
advancement of the healthcare sector<br />
in Trinidad and Tobago to holistically<br />
support vulnerable groups.<br />
Advancing the healthcare sector<br />
Medical tourism is one of the opportunities that has room for expansion<br />
in Trinidad and Tobago. As highlighted by the Ministry of Health in<br />
2013, there are various local specialisations where we have an excellent<br />
track record, such as cardiac surgery, joint replacement, and dentistry.<br />
In fact, medical tourists can even originate from the regional diaspora.<br />
This is an avenue we need to explore further and capitalise on in the<br />
constantly advancing field of medicine.<br />
Trinidad and Tobago’s high-income status makes it challenging<br />
to obtain international financial aid. Despite continuous efforts to<br />
advance the medical field and healthcare systems, there is room for<br />
improvement. The country’s vulnerability to climate change, including<br />
rising sea levels, requires the development of a more resilient and<br />
sustainable healthcare sector. This was underscored at the 27 th<br />
Conference of the Parties of the UNFCCC (COP 27) Health Pavilion<br />
held in Egypt last year. While the PAHO “SMART Hospital” Toolkit is<br />
available for use, implementation requires significant investment in<br />
both financial and human resources. Achieving the goal of a sustainable<br />
white economy requires a collaborative effort between the government<br />
and non-governmental organisations to promote the advancement of<br />
the healthcare sector in Trinidad and Tobago to holistically support<br />
vulnerable groups.<br />
Medical tourism is one of the<br />
opportunities that has room for<br />
expansion in Trinidad and Tobago.<br />
As highlighted by the Ministry of<br />
Health in 2013, there are various local<br />
specialisations where we have an<br />
excellent track record, such as<br />
cardiac surgery, joint replacement,<br />
and dentistry.<br />
CHAMBER.ORG.TT MAY <strong>2023</strong><br />
21
The GOLDEN Economy<br />
A glimmer of gold:<br />
decentralising T&T’s energy infrastructure<br />
The T&T government has implemented several policy and fiscal measures to create an<br />
enabling environment for energy diversification. Our aid development partners are also<br />
supporting this move to a golden economy. How are we responding?<br />
What more needs to be done?<br />
By Ryan Assiu, Climate Finance Specalist - USAID/Eastern & Southern Caribbean.<br />
Award-winning environmental consultant. Director at the Trinidad and Tobago Association<br />
of Energy Engineers (TTAEE) and the Sustainability Institute of Trinidad and Tobago (SITT).<br />
COURTESY MINISTRY OF PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT<br />
The “golden economy” or “sunshine economy” uses renewable<br />
energy (RE) sources as its primary energy supply and encourages<br />
the widespread public distribution of RE energy infrastructure.<br />
Whereas ‘green’ and ‘blue’ economies hold low-carbon, clean<br />
energy as a core feature of their definition, the ‘golden’ economy<br />
places specific emphasis on RE dominance in the energy mix and<br />
the decentralisation of energy infrastructure. This article posits that<br />
Trinidad and Tobago’s economy has only a glimmer of gold based<br />
on the current market and regulatory factors and presents<br />
recommendations for improving the economy’s lustre.<br />
The Sunshine State?<br />
In Trinidad and Tobago (T&T), the potential for<br />
solar photovoltaics (PV) is high. The World Bank’s<br />
Global Photovoltaic Power Potential Study (2020)<br />
ranks T&T 93 rd of 194 countries because it has 100<br />
per cent electricity grid coverage, a favourable<br />
practical solar photovoltaic potential of 4.4 kWh/<br />
kWp, and 74 per cent of its land area suitable for<br />
installations. Globally, solar PV technologies have<br />
become cheaper and more efficient annually. The<br />
Inter-American Development Bank (2015) noted that the<br />
‘soft costs’ of taxes, labour, and transactions outweighed<br />
the hardware costs of solar PV installations for small-scale<br />
residential systems in T&T – meaning that most of the economic<br />
benefit of decentralised solar PV value chains is kept within the local<br />
economy.<br />
22 MAY <strong>2023</strong> CHAMBER.ORG.TT
The GOLDEN Economy<br />
The current state of the national energy supply mix and the distribution of<br />
renewable energy generation capacity do not meet the criteria of a ‘sunshine<br />
economy.’ Presently, 0.01 per cent, or three megawatts, of T&T’s energy supply<br />
mix is provided by RE – far from being the dominant source of power that defines<br />
a golden economy. Although the construction of two solar plants with a combined<br />
solar PV generating capacity of 112-megawatts, dubbed ‘Project Lara’, will<br />
introduce RE into the national energy supply mix in T&T, it would not significantly<br />
displace gas-powered electricity as the dominant contributor. Decentralisation<br />
of RE infrastructure in T&T is also limited by current legislation, which does not<br />
allow for RE power generation by independent power producers (IPPs) without<br />
consent from the State-owned utility. Combined with the subsidised cost of<br />
electricity, the business case for solar PV mini-grids or standalone home systems<br />
is tenuous.<br />
Notwithstanding, the adoption of residential solar PV is steadily increasing<br />
within T&T. There are over a dozen solar PV installers and small businesses<br />
established, and the market is growing due to middle to high-income early<br />
adopters. Presently, a solar PV system for a two-bedroom house costs about<br />
TT$50,000 and has a return on investment of eight years – an unpalatable cost<br />
for the average person. RE mainstreaming is stymied by a lack of commercial<br />
financing instruments, RE standards, and capacity among market actors.<br />
The Yellow Brick Road<br />
The T&T government has introduced some policy and fiscal measures to create<br />
an enabling environment for RE growth and alludes to an impending economicwide<br />
shift towards RE. There is a glimmer of gold on the horizon.<br />
In the <strong>2023</strong> budget presentation the T&T government announced that a<br />
Renewable Energy Policy is being developed with a target of 30 per cent<br />
renewable energy supply by 2030. Concurrent with this announcement was<br />
the declaration that a Feed-in-Tariff (FIT) policy was at an advanced stage of<br />
development. The FIT would facilitate residential and commercial RE generation<br />
by allowing decentralised IPPs to sell excess energy back into the grid.<br />
The T&T government also established new fiscal measures to incentivise RE<br />
uptake in key sectors. A TT$25,000 rebate for approved agricultural holdings<br />
using RE technology was introduced, as well as the removal of value added tax<br />
(VAT) on new RE-using equipment for manufacturing companies. These add<br />
to longstanding fiscal measures such as the zero-rated VAT granted for solar<br />
PV panels, wear and tear allowance on 150 per cent expenditure incurred on<br />
solar PV systems and supporting equipment, and tax allowances for companies<br />
engaging with Energy Service Companies.<br />
Presently, 0.01 per cent, or three<br />
megawatts, of T&T’s energy supply<br />
mix is provided by RE – far from<br />
being the dominant source of power<br />
that defines a golden economy.<br />
Energy Sector<br />
Reform Project<br />
The Energy Sector Reform (ESR)<br />
project is an over US$10 million<br />
initiative launched on February<br />
27th <strong>2023</strong>, by USAID. It covers 13<br />
Caribbean territories, including<br />
Trinidad and Tobago. Under this<br />
project, technical assistance will be<br />
provided to utilities, ministries, and<br />
regulators to develop policies, laws,<br />
tools and processes to make national<br />
energy systems more resilient and<br />
modern. By bolstering regional energy<br />
systems, countries can become more<br />
productive and enjoy diverse and<br />
sustainable economic growth. The<br />
work plan for supporting Trinidad and<br />
Tobago under the ESR project is under<br />
development.<br />
CHAMBER.ORG.TT MAY <strong>2023</strong><br />
23
24 MAY <strong>2023</strong> CHAMBER.ORG.TT
The GOLDEN Economy<br />
Golden Nuggets<br />
Realising the golden economy requires legislative reform as well as market-building. Multiple<br />
studies commissioned by the T&T government have identified the following interventions as<br />
critical:<br />
1. Amending the Trinidad & Tobago Electricity<br />
Commission (T&TEC) Act and the<br />
Regulated Industries Commission (RIC) Act<br />
to allow independent power producers to<br />
contribute to the grid.<br />
2. Approving the FIT for grid-connected smallscale<br />
solar PV facilities and/or mini-grids.<br />
3. Developing specific financial instruments<br />
and strategies for lowering the cost of<br />
capital for residential/commercial solar PV.<br />
4. Building RE knowledge and technical<br />
capacity among market players such as<br />
financiers, suppliers, utilities, regulators,<br />
and homeowners.<br />
5. Increasing the electricity rate to encourage<br />
energy conservation and grid parity.<br />
The T&T government has made meaningful efforts towards these goals in collaboration with<br />
donors such as the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP), the Inter-American<br />
Development Bank (IDB), and the European Union (EU). With USAID’s recently launched Energy<br />
Sector Reform regional project, even more support is available. However, citizens need to adopt<br />
a more conservative attitude towards energy, utilise the fiscal measures available, and advocate<br />
for the approval of critical legislative changes. Getting to gold is within our grasp; let’s go for it!<br />
Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in this paper are those of the author and not<br />
necessarily the views and opinions of the United States Agency for International Development<br />
(USAID).<br />
CHAMBER.ORG.TT MAY <strong>2023</strong><br />
25
Your Biggest Cybersecurity Risks<br />
Could Be Inside Your Organization<br />
by Bret Arsenault<br />
Tek Image/Science Photo Library/Getty Images<br />
As the digital world continues to grow, so do the volume,<br />
variety, and velocity of cyber threats and attacks. The<br />
world is awash in data, and there is always someone<br />
trying to turn it into their own virtual currency.<br />
Today malware and ransomware are hitting everything<br />
from our personal cell phones to mission-critical<br />
infrastructure and supply chains. Whether it’s<br />
phishing, smishing, or vishing, attackers are getting more<br />
sophisticated too, using details about our personal and<br />
work lives to tempt us to share our data.<br />
But in a world where everyone is a target, companies<br />
also need to understand their exposure to risks that<br />
come from inside their organizations. Today more than<br />
300 million people are working remotely — creating,<br />
accessing, sharing, and storing data wherever they go —<br />
and data breaches arising from insider threats and simple<br />
mishaps can cost businesses an average of $7.5 million<br />
annually. Consider the 2022 data breach of Cash App,<br />
where a former employee accessed customer financial<br />
reports after being terminated. The breach likely affected<br />
8.2 million current and former customers.<br />
Ultimately it doesn’t matter if the breach was intentional<br />
or accidental. Insider risk programs should be part of<br />
every company’s security strategy. To be successful,<br />
organizations should lead with their employees as<br />
26 MAY <strong>2023</strong> CHAMBER.ORG.TT
partners in the effort and supplement their program with<br />
advanced tools that detect and mitigate insider risks<br />
wherever they arise.<br />
Here are four lessons I’ve learned as CISO at Microsoft,<br />
managing our insider risk program as it grew from a small<br />
internal initiative into a business unit that reports to the CEO.<br />
1. Prioritize Employee Trust and Privacy<br />
This point comes first for a reason. In business and in life,<br />
trust is the key to any functioning relationship. The best<br />
insider risk programs emphasize the balance between<br />
employee privacy and company security. It’s critical to<br />
come up with privacy controls and policies that maintain,<br />
and even boost, trust.<br />
Setting up tools to indiscriminately sift through employee<br />
activities for wrongdoing is not only ineffective and<br />
counterproductive — it’s just plain wrong. It’s an<br />
invasion of privacy that creates anxiety and erodes the<br />
relationship. Organizations need to be able to detect<br />
insider risks, but they need to do it the right way, acting<br />
transparently and within a narrowly defined scope to<br />
demonstrate respect and extend trust to employees.<br />
Setting up privacy controls that protect identities at<br />
work — even during investigations — lets people know<br />
you’re protecting them too. Using role-based access<br />
for insider risk management tools also helps ensure<br />
that the right person is reviewing compliance alerts,<br />
keeping unwarranted suspicion from creeping into the<br />
organization.<br />
2. Collaborate across functions<br />
While IT and security groups will lead the way, insider risk<br />
is a business problem that involves the entire company. At<br />
Microsoft, we learned this over time. What started as an<br />
initiative in our security organization evolved into a unified<br />
effort across the business groups, including legal, HR,<br />
and senior leadership.<br />
This broad involvement helps ensure wider buy-in and<br />
provides additional perspectives and resources, such as<br />
the legal department prioritizing emerging regulations<br />
and HR facilitating training programs and surveys. An<br />
insider risk committee or ombudsperson can help get<br />
the conversation going. One of their first tasks should be<br />
creating a response plan that outlines how information<br />
is shared, when and what each group contributes, who<br />
makes which decisions, and who is accountable.<br />
It’s also important to have shared goals with clear<br />
measures of success. You can fine tune the process by<br />
quantifying key metrics such as the number of cases<br />
raised, the true positive and false positive flags, and<br />
actions taken as the result of findings. If you have a<br />
high number of false positives, you risk burdening your<br />
HR and legal teams with unnecessary and expensive<br />
investigations.<br />
3. Recognize that employees are the last line of<br />
defense<br />
Getting employees to engage with data protection and<br />
compliance training can be challenging, but it’s important<br />
that they know how to mitigate security risks and why<br />
it’s a priority. Trainings that emphasize stewardship of<br />
data show that the organization is extending its trust to<br />
employees as they serve the business.<br />
Train people on how to handle the organization’s data<br />
properly, and repeat that message regularly so it’s always<br />
fresh. It also helps to make it personal. Most people<br />
immediately understand and engage on how to protect<br />
their own financial and health care data. Infusing a<br />
personal aspect into the training connects the dots on the<br />
importance of data protection for the business as well.<br />
Training people on the principle of “see something, say<br />
something” in a risk-free way is a critical capability for an<br />
insider program. By improving data security education<br />
and training, companies can empower employees as<br />
a first and last line of defense that is complemented by<br />
detection tools.<br />
CHAMBER.ORG.TT MAY <strong>2023</strong><br />
27
4. Use machine learning tools to do more with less<br />
Gartner defines insider risk management as “the<br />
tools and capabilities to measure, detect, and contain<br />
undesirable behavior of trusted accounts within the<br />
organization.” And insider risk management tools have<br />
gotten much more precise and effective in recent years.<br />
Older tools tend to overlook subtle indicators that can<br />
identify a bad actor trying to hide their tracks. They also<br />
often feature overly strict controls that lower productivity<br />
and encourage workarounds. Today a new breed of<br />
insider risk management tools is emerging with adaptive<br />
security capabilities that can detect risky activities and<br />
mitigate any potential impact while staying out of the way<br />
and keeping user information private.<br />
Where an activity like printing a confidential file might<br />
not show intent, a sequence of connected activities like<br />
renaming the file and then deleting it after printing could<br />
indicate something more serious. Using machine learning,<br />
these tools can separate the signal from the noise and<br />
identify subtle actions, reducing the false positives that<br />
can bog down the organization.<br />
A successful insider risk program focuses on the<br />
people, processes, and technologies<br />
Managing both internal and external risks is vital to the<br />
security of any organization. Each comes with their own<br />
challenges, but what makes insider risk management<br />
especially tricky is the need to balance people, processes,<br />
and technologies.<br />
Powerful tools can help impede, detect, and respond to<br />
insider risks — but they won’t address the root causes.<br />
That’s where detailed onboarding, security trainings,<br />
team-building exercises, and work-life balance programs<br />
are useful. Building a healthy work environment helps<br />
reduce the risk of an employee intentionally engaging in<br />
dangerous behavior. But at the end of the day, striking the<br />
balance between people and technology matters most of<br />
all. Risk management has to be proactive and continuous,<br />
and it takes trust, transparency, and collaboration to<br />
keep that engine running. This philosophy — people first,<br />
backed by powerful technology — is the only way to<br />
prevent incidents before they happen, detect them if they<br />
do, and respond to them quickly and effectively.<br />
———<br />
Bret Arsenault is Microsoft’s chief<br />
information security officer, responsible<br />
for enterprise-wide digital security and<br />
resiliency.<br />
For more great articles, go to HBR.org.<br />
c.<strong>2023</strong> Harvard Business Review. Distributed by The New<br />
York Times Licensing Group.<br />
Copyright:<br />
c.<strong>2023</strong> Harvard Business Review<br />
28 MAY <strong>2023</strong> CHAMBER.ORG.TT
The PURPLE Economy<br />
Social cohesion -<br />
a pillar of economic growth and development<br />
In the Caribbean, the employment rate is lower for women<br />
than for men; this gap is especially large in Trinidad and Tobago.<br />
The Purple Economy supports a multidisciplinary approach to<br />
economics and social development that improves the quality<br />
of everyone’s life. How are we bridging the gaps?<br />
By Tonni Brodber, Representative,<br />
UN Women Multi-Country Office<br />
(MCO) - Caribbean<br />
The human experience is multifaceted, and so are the colours of our<br />
economy. For many years, the discourse on economic growth siloed<br />
what was deemed ‘soft’ issues from the more critical issue of ‘work’. Work,<br />
by definition, included very little of what takes place in the home and the<br />
definition focused on outside of the home, but in fact there is work that<br />
mirrors that done in the home, such as parental leave, paid childcare,<br />
healthcare, and education. While these areas are touted as necessary, they<br />
are not remunerated in ways that reflect their inherent value.<br />
Defining vulnerability<br />
The journey towards sustainable development is one that decision-makers<br />
note is only possible if no one is left behind. But who is left behind and why,<br />
and who is deemed vulnerable? Vulnerability has been defined as the result<br />
of a combined effect of risks to which people may be exposed, the sensitivity<br />
of their particular livelihoods to those risks, and their ability (or lack of) to<br />
adapt to, cope with or recover from the impacts of external shocks (Prowse,<br />
2003; Adger et al., 2005).<br />
Human beings are born vulnerable and dependent on their families and<br />
communities, yet they are also full of potential. The lack of a comprehensive<br />
approach to economic and sustainable development in the ‘purple economy’<br />
often results in marginalisation. The process where certain groups are<br />
systematically disadvantaged because they are discriminated against on the<br />
basis of their sex, ethnicity, race, religion, sexual orientation, caste, gender<br />
identity, age, disability, HIV status, migrant status or because of where they<br />
live (Rogers et al., 1995; Atkinson, 1998).<br />
Of great concern are the costs communities and countries incur by not<br />
valuing the work that has been made invisible or the people who have been<br />
marginalised. According to the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and<br />
Development (OECD), gender-based discrimination in social institutions<br />
costs the world economy US$6 trillion. McKinsey also noted, “True gender<br />
equality everywhere would raise global GDP by up to US$28 trillion.”<br />
About UN Women<br />
UN Women is the United Nations entity<br />
dedicated to gender equality and the<br />
empowerment of women. A global<br />
champion for women and girls, UN Women<br />
was established to accelerate progress on<br />
meeting their needs worldwide. UN Women<br />
supports UN Member States as they set<br />
global standards for achieving gender<br />
equality and works with governments<br />
and civil society to design laws, policies,<br />
programmes and services needed to<br />
ensure that the standards are effectively<br />
implemented and truly benefit women and<br />
girls worldwide. The UN Women Multi-<br />
Country Office (MCO) – Caribbean, located<br />
in Barbados, covers 22 countries - the<br />
CARICOM Member States, Dutch Caribbean<br />
Islands and British Overseas Territories. UN<br />
Women MCO - Caribbean has developed<br />
programming based on four priority<br />
areas: international normative standards;<br />
ending violence against women; economic<br />
empowerment; and climate change, disaster<br />
risk resilience and humanitarian response.<br />
According to the Organisation<br />
for Economic Cooperation and<br />
Development (OECD), genderbased<br />
discrimination in social<br />
institutions costs the world<br />
economy US$6 trillion.<br />
CHAMBER.ORG.TT MAY <strong>2023</strong><br />
29
The PURPLE Economy<br />
Recently UN Women MCO - Caribbean collected data across<br />
the Caribbean on the costs of Violence Against Women and<br />
Girls (VAWG) to our economies. In Jamaica, the total cost of<br />
VAWG in 2018 was JM$102 billion (more than US$1 billion). This<br />
represents an astounding 6.49 per cent of Jamaica’s GDP.<br />
In the Caribbean, more women could engage in paid work if<br />
families had access to safe and affordable childcare services.<br />
Globally, women spend on average 4.1 hours/day on unpaid care<br />
and domestic work, compared to 1.7 hours/day for men. Women<br />
also make up 70 per cent of the paid global health care workforce.<br />
The inclusion of everyone’s contribution to economies is<br />
critical. Purple is one of the colours adopted by women’s<br />
movements in some parts of the world. A purple economy<br />
calls for an economic system that accounts for the value<br />
of care work and enables it to sustainably contribute to<br />
countries’ national economic growth.<br />
Strengthening shortcomings<br />
UN Women has supported several recommendations<br />
addressing the gaps presented by the purple economy.<br />
The Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of<br />
Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW) is an international<br />
legal instrument that requires countries to eliminate<br />
discrimination against women and girls in all areas and<br />
promotes women’s and girls’ equal rights. All Caribbean<br />
States have ratified the CEDAW and are obligated to<br />
implement and report on their progress in achieving the<br />
recommendations of the CEDAW Committee. The Beijing<br />
Declaration and Platform for Action, the most progressive<br />
blueprint for advancing women’s rights, guides how best<br />
to integrate care, education, and healthcare into our<br />
economies.<br />
UN Women MCO - Caribbean has assisted several<br />
governments in the Caribbean region through costing of<br />
the expansion of subsidised childcare, gender-responsive<br />
budgeting and collecting and analysing data to better<br />
inform evidence-based decision making. Civil society<br />
in the region often champions elements of the purple<br />
economy. UN Women MCO - Caribbean supports Civil<br />
Society Organisations (CSOs) through financing, capacity<br />
strengthening and data gathering. As a critical player in<br />
the creation of social norms, behaviours and attitudes, the<br />
private sector has suffered much of the losses borne by<br />
not addressing the gaps in the purple economy. Through<br />
the Women’s Empowerment Principles UN Women has<br />
been able to collaborate with leaders in the private sector<br />
to promote parental leave and policies to support inclusion.<br />
COUTRTESY UN WOMEN MULTI-COUNTRY OFFICE (MCO) - CARIBBEAN<br />
Courtesy UN Women’s ‘Share the Care’ campaign<br />
Globally, women spend on average<br />
4.1 hours/day on unpaid care and<br />
domestic work, compared to 1.7<br />
hours/day for men. Women also make<br />
up 70 per cent of the paid global<br />
healthcare workforce.<br />
CHAMBER.ORG.TT MAY <strong>2023</strong><br />
31
The ORANGE Economy<br />
Lights, Camera, Action!<br />
Exploring the potential of Trinidad<br />
and Tobago’s creative industries<br />
As reported on CreativeTT’s site, music, film, and fashion have collectively<br />
generated TT$824 million in revenue. Creativity is a business that offers<br />
significant opportunities for sustainable economic growth and job creation.<br />
The orange economy is full of infinite possibilities; let’s explore.<br />
By Leslie Ann Wills-Caton,<br />
General Manager, FilmTT/Film Commissioner<br />
Roll out the red carpet! Trinidad and Tobago’s orange economy is<br />
ready for its close-up. Bursting with creativity and talent, this dynamic<br />
industry is an export-ready melting pot of music, art, fashion, and film.<br />
The orange economy has many opportunities for growth, business, and<br />
investment. From product placement to strategic brand alignment, the<br />
possibilities are endless. Grab your popcorn and explore the colourful<br />
world of Trinidad and Tobago’s orange economy.<br />
COURTESY FILMTT<br />
Trinidad and Tobago Film Festival 2022<br />
Our rich cultural heritage provides a unique,<br />
diverse source of inspiration for artists and<br />
creatives. Trinidad and Tobago’s strategic<br />
location in the Caribbean makes it an ideal<br />
hub for creative and cultural exchange.<br />
Race to amazing opportunities<br />
Recognition of the impact of the orange economy is rapidly growing<br />
in Trinidad and Tobago for several reasons. Our rich cultural heritage<br />
provides a unique, diverse source of inspiration for artists and creatives.<br />
Trinidad and Tobago’s strategic location in the Caribbean makes it an ideal<br />
hub for creative and cultural exchange. Furthermore, Trinidad and Tobago<br />
has invested in developing support infrastructure, such as establishing the<br />
Trinidad and Tobago Creative Industries Company Limited (CreativeTT)<br />
and the National Intellectual Property Training Centre.<br />
Investors can also benefit from the Production Expenditure Rebate<br />
Programme offered by FilmTT®. This programme gives businesses a<br />
rebate of up to 35 per cent on qualifying local spend, with 20 per cent<br />
cash back on the hire of local labour. This is a cost-effective way to invest<br />
in local talent and participate in the orange economy.<br />
Our film industry has attracted foreign investment, generated<br />
employment opportunities, and promoted Trinidad and Tobago as a tourist<br />
destination. In fact, on 14 th October 2020, ‘Trinidad’ and ‘Tobago’ were the<br />
most searched words on Google during the premiere of “The Amazing<br />
Race” series, Season 32, filmed on location in both islands.<br />
32 MAY <strong>2023</strong> CHAMBER.ORG.TT
The ORANGE Economy<br />
Branding for success<br />
Brands that align themselves with creative output from the cultural<br />
and creative industries benefit from the innovation and creativity of<br />
the orange economy while tapping into the passion and loyalty of fans<br />
and audiences. Intellectual property is also often incorporated into<br />
marketing strategies. This generates buzz and interest in the brand<br />
and supports the indigenous creative community.<br />
Strategic brand alignment through product placement in films has<br />
become a popular marketing strategy in Trinidad and Tobago. This<br />
approach involves integrating a brand’s products or services into a film<br />
or television show’s storyline to increase brand awareness and create<br />
a positive association with the audience. Both local and international<br />
brands have embraced product placement in Trinidad and Tobago’s<br />
film industry. This trend provides a new revenue stream for filmmakers.<br />
It enables brands to tap into a captive audience and create a unique<br />
emotional connection with consumers. As the film industry in Trinidad<br />
and Tobago continues to grow, we expect to see more brands adopting<br />
this strategic approach of aligning their brand with the stories and<br />
characters on the big screen.<br />
Financing the Orange Economy<br />
An approach that could support the further<br />
development of the orange economy is the<br />
establishment of a Creative Industries Fund. This<br />
Fund would support artists and creatives financially<br />
to develop projects and businesses. The Fund could<br />
also be supported by public and private sector<br />
investment, with applications for financing evaluated<br />
by a panel of industry experts. The aim is to ensure<br />
the growth and sustainability of the orange economy<br />
in Trinidad and Tobago and support the development<br />
of new talent and innovative ideas.<br />
In recent years, the film industry in Trinidad and<br />
Tobago has seen significant growth, with local<br />
productions gaining international recognition and<br />
acclaim. In 2019, the locally produced film “Green<br />
Days by the River”, an adaptation of a local literary<br />
work, earned over TT$1.4 million (US$206,000) at the<br />
box office.<br />
This success is a testament to the profitability of<br />
these intangible assets. It underscores the potential<br />
of the creative industries in Trinidad and Tobago.<br />
THE CREATIVE ECONOMY: BENEFITS<br />
COURTESY GREEN DAYS BY THE RIVER FILM LIMITED<br />
INTELLECTUAL<br />
PROPERTY<br />
CULTURAL<br />
PROMOTION<br />
JOB<br />
CREATION<br />
INNOVATION<br />
ECONOMIC<br />
GROWTH<br />
TOURISM<br />
DIPLOMACY<br />
(NATIONAL<br />
IMAGE/VALUES)<br />
Actors and main set, Green Days by the River<br />
In recent years, the film industry in Trinidad and Tobago<br />
has seen significant growth, with local productions<br />
gaining international recognition and acclaim. In 2019,<br />
the locally produced film “Green Days by the River”,<br />
an adaptation of a local literary work, earned over<br />
TT$1.4 million (US$206,000) at the box office.<br />
CHAMBER.ORG.TT MAY <strong>2023</strong><br />
33
The ORANGE Economy<br />
Businesses can collaborate with digital media professionals<br />
and content creators to further tap into the growing orange<br />
economy in Trinidad and Tobago. With the rise of social<br />
media, audiences value the insight and recommendations of<br />
peers and industry professionals. By working with specialised<br />
service providers and investing in local talent, businesses<br />
can leverage their influence to reach wider audiences and<br />
contribute to the growth of the creative industries.<br />
The future is orange<br />
The creative capital and intangible assets that underpin<br />
the creative industries are unique in their value proposition.<br />
However, they are also vulnerable to external pressures. In<br />
particular, the rapidly changing technological landscape<br />
and the shift towards digital distribution have increased the<br />
risks associated with investing in the creative industries.<br />
Therefore, the industry must receive continuous support for<br />
marketing and promotional activities whilst also working to<br />
mitigate the risks of investing in this unique valuable sector.<br />
By collaborating with industry stakeholders and leveraging<br />
local expertise, we can build a sustainable, thriving orange<br />
economy that benefits everyone involved.<br />
To ensure the continued growth and success of the orange<br />
economy, we need increased investment in the industry,<br />
including funding for artists and creatives, infrastructure, as<br />
well as education and training programmes. We must develop<br />
policies and regulations that protect intellectual property<br />
rights and prevent copyright infringement. This will help to<br />
ensure that artists and creatives are fairly compensated for<br />
their work and can continue to innovate and create.<br />
The orange economy provides numerous economic, cultural,<br />
and social benefits, such as job creation and the promotion<br />
of cultural exchange. It drives innovation and contributes<br />
to overall economic growth. Businesses, investors, and<br />
policymakers need to recognise its value and support<br />
continued growth and development. The creative industries<br />
are open for business.
Top 5 Facts<br />
T&T’s exports –<br />
performance and prospects<br />
Are you interested in exporting? Want to know which products and markets have significant<br />
potential for growth? The Chamber’s Trade and Business Development Unit has all the answers.<br />
By Leeooi-Oneika Howard, Trade Specialist,<br />
Trade and Business Development Unit,<br />
Trinidad and Tobago Chamber of Industry<br />
and Commerce (TTCIC)<br />
By Brian Benoit, Regulatory Affairs<br />
(Monitoring) Officer, Trade and Business<br />
Development Unit, Trinidad and Tobago<br />
Chamber of Industry and Commerce (TTCIC)<br />
1. What are Trinidad and Tobago’s<br />
top export markets and products?<br />
In 2021, Trinidad and Tobago (T&T) exported US$8.6 billion<br />
in goods, of which 41.6 per cent was exported to the United<br />
States of America (USA). The chart below identifies T&T’s<br />
top 10 export destinations and their share of total exports.<br />
Guyana and Jamaica, both CARICOM territories, ranked<br />
second and tenth, respectively. T&T’s leading products<br />
for export are oil and gas by-products such as ammonia,<br />
anhydrous or in aqueous solution, acyclic alcohols,<br />
petroleum oils and gas, iron and steel, and fertilisers. Nonenergy<br />
products in the top 10 exports were ships, boats<br />
and floating structures, beverages, spirits and vinegar, and<br />
preparations of cereals, flour, starch, and milk.<br />
Figure 1: Trinidad and Tobago - top export markets 2021<br />
Jamaica, 2%<br />
Brazil, 3%<br />
Morocco,3%<br />
Rest of the<br />
World, 25%<br />
Korea, Republic of, 3%<br />
Source: ITC Trade Map<br />
Colombia, 3%<br />
Belgium, 4%<br />
France, 4%<br />
Guyana, 7%<br />
Mexico, 4%<br />
United States<br />
of America, 42%<br />
COURTESY YARA<br />
Ammonia hub at Point Lisas Industrial Estate, Trinidad<br />
2. Which markets and products have<br />
the most potential for export growth?<br />
According to the International Trade Centre’s (ITC)<br />
Export Potential Map, products with the greatest export<br />
prospects from Trinidad and Tobago to the rest of the<br />
world are chemicals and fertilisers such as methanol<br />
‘methyl alcohol’, anhydrous ammonia, and mixtures of urea<br />
and ammonium nitrate.<br />
Non-energy products with substantial export potential<br />
are food products (processed or preserved) and beverages.<br />
As seen in Figure 2, the markets with considerable<br />
promise for Trinidad and Tobago’s exports in all categories<br />
of products are the USA, Guyana, and Brazil. Guyana<br />
displays the largest absolute difference between potential<br />
and actual exports in value terms, leaving room to realise<br />
additional exports worth US$764 million.<br />
36 MAY <strong>2023</strong> CHAMBER.ORG.TT
Top 5 Facts<br />
Figure 2: Markets with greatest potential for Trinidad and Tobago exports 2022<br />
Source: ITC Export Potential Map<br />
The markets with considerable promise for Trinidad and Tobago’s<br />
exports in all categories of products are the USA, Guyana, and Brazil.<br />
3. Which services are<br />
exported from Trinidad<br />
and Tobago to the rest of<br />
the world?<br />
Although data for trade in<br />
services is limited, the following<br />
graph reveals the trends for<br />
the top services exported from<br />
Trinidad and Tobago, for the<br />
period 2019 to 2021, to the rest<br />
of the world. There is a notable<br />
decline in services exports<br />
over this period due to the<br />
COVID-19 pandemic and the<br />
overall downturn in the global<br />
economy.<br />
USD Thousand<br />
90000<br />
80000<br />
70000<br />
60000<br />
50000<br />
40000<br />
30000<br />
20000<br />
10000<br />
0<br />
Source: ITC Trade Map<br />
Figure 3: Trinidad and Tobago’s top services exports 2019-2021<br />
2019 2020 2021<br />
Commercial services<br />
Insurance and pension services<br />
Transport<br />
Travel<br />
Other business services<br />
Government goods and services<br />
Telecommunications,<br />
computer and information<br />
services<br />
Financial Services<br />
Charges for the use<br />
of intellectual property<br />
CHAMBER.ORG.TT MAY <strong>2023</strong><br />
37
Top 5 Facts<br />
4. What incentives are there in Trinidad<br />
and Tobago for export diversification?<br />
eTecK’s Phoenix Park Industrial Estate (PPIE) is part of<br />
the government’s export diversification strategy. The<br />
park offers factory shells and land lots for businesses<br />
operating in industries such as manufacturing, logistics<br />
and distribution, and emerging technologies. Tenanting at<br />
this park gives local and foreign direct investors the added<br />
benefit of a 12-month moratorium, guided regulatory<br />
and commercial facilitation, access to global consumer<br />
markets, and access to regional and worldwide ports to<br />
assist with the affordable export of goods and services.<br />
Another option for export diversification is the Special<br />
Economic Zone (SEZ). The SEZ Act passed in 2021 aims to<br />
establish a new legislative, administrative, and institutional<br />
framework for domestic and foreign investors to expect<br />
increased transparency, predictability, and security for<br />
their investments.<br />
5. What are the opportunities for export<br />
diversification in the Blue and Green Economies?<br />
As this is a relatively new concept, Caribbean countries are<br />
still in the early phase of establishing their blue and green<br />
economies agenda; however, they are better positioned<br />
than any other region in the world to capitalise on the blue<br />
and green economies for export diversification.<br />
With more than 80 per cent of its Gross Domestic Product<br />
(GDP) generated in coastal areas, Jamaica is taking steps<br />
to protect its highly vulnerable coastal communities and<br />
infrastructure to support sustainable trade, tourism, and<br />
development. With the United Nations Environment<br />
Programme (UNEP) support, Jamaica has identified the<br />
following focus sectors for green transition: agriculture,<br />
fishing, forestry, construction, and tourism.<br />
Trinidad and Tobago is right behind, advancing its<br />
progress toward a sustainable blue and green economy<br />
through a partnership with the Commonwealth Blue<br />
Charter as well as a targeted assessment by the UNEP<br />
and the Ministry of Energy and Energy Industries of the<br />
roadmap for a Green Hydrogen Economy to assess this<br />
county’s capability in that area.<br />
38 MAY <strong>2023</strong> CHAMBER.ORG.TT
The BLACK Economy<br />
Shining light on Trinidad &<br />
Tobago’s underground economy<br />
It is estimated that crime proceeds in Trinidad and Tobago are valued at three to seven billion<br />
dollars annually. What drives the black economy? How is Government responding? Here, we<br />
analyse the causes, effects and strategies needed to reduce the size of this shadow economy.<br />
By Dr Timothy Affonso,<br />
Dean (Ag.) Faculty of Law, The University<br />
of the West Indies, St. Augustine Campus<br />
The black economy refers to illegal economic activity and<br />
includes endeavours which earn undeclared and untaxed<br />
revenue. The Government of the Republic of Trinidad and<br />
Tobago (GORTT) tackled this issue in part in 2019, when it<br />
replaced the $100 paper note with the new polymer note.<br />
Everyone with the old $100 bills had to have them changed.<br />
This exercise was undertaken to deal with income derived<br />
from activities such as money laundering, counterfeiting, and<br />
tax evasion. In 2016, a similar approach was adopted by India<br />
as an attack on ‘black money’ (money earned from the black<br />
economy). However, as in India, and based on local reports,<br />
Trinidad and Tobago’s decision resulted in only a few cases<br />
of public suspicion regarding business enterprises such as a<br />
church with $29 million and a barber with $1 million.<br />
RAWPIXEL.COM<br />
CHAMBER.ORG.TT MAY <strong>2023</strong><br />
39
The BLACK Economy<br />
There is research which demonstrates that the black<br />
economy thrives when taxes are increased. Furthermore,<br />
when the middle-to-low-income sectors of the economy<br />
face additional burdens from government policies, there<br />
tends to be a push towards illicit conduct.<br />
The major weakness of this demonetisation policy was that it did<br />
not address the causes of the economic activity itself. Furthermore,<br />
the strategy had no impact on situations where the illegal money<br />
from the black economy had already been integrated into the<br />
lawful financial systems. Based on a 2020 financial crime report,<br />
it was estimated that crime proceeds in Trinidad and Tobago are<br />
valued at between three to seven billion dollars annually. In <strong>2023</strong>,<br />
we must confront the reality of the black economy and its wider<br />
impact.<br />
Pursuits of the black economy<br />
There is research which demonstrates that the black economy<br />
thrives when taxes are increased. Furthermore, when the middleto-low-income<br />
sectors of the economy face additional burdens<br />
from government policies, there tends to be a push towards illicit<br />
conduct. This push is caused by the ability to earn additional<br />
income with the added benefit of circumventing taxation.<br />
Therefore, as much as this is an economic issue, it is also a<br />
national security issue. This could be why GORTT implemented<br />
the demonetisation strategy on the grounds of national security.<br />
Turning to the type of activities which operate in the black<br />
economy, research shows that the major contributors are money<br />
laundering, corruption, and terrorism financing. It should also<br />
be noted that the black economy is stratified, in the sense that<br />
even within the space of illicit conduct there are areas which<br />
are known but incalculable. There have also been allegations of<br />
linkages between motor vehicle theft and illegal car part sales.<br />
The issue of motor vehicle fraud was recently highlighted by<br />
the Transport Division (Ministry of Works and Transport), as for<br />
years vehicles with duplicate chassis numbers and plates were<br />
inspected, passed, and driven on the nation’s roads. There are<br />
also dimensions of illegality such as forgery and bribes where<br />
State actors are rumoured to be facilitating, to some extent, land<br />
fraud, drug trafficking and identity fraud.<br />
Strategies to reduce the size<br />
of the black economy<br />
Businesses are not powerless in the black economy.<br />
The most effective way to stifle the black economy<br />
is to transition to electronic payments. If financial<br />
institutions can support micro, small and mediumsized<br />
enterprises (MSMEs) with remote/cashless<br />
transaction capabilities, there will be a further blow<br />
to the black economy. This presents opportunities for<br />
the integration of technology and business beyond<br />
what may already have been realised as a result<br />
of the COVID-19 pandemic. Ventures which focus<br />
on telephone applications and remote devices for<br />
payment can also help in this vein.<br />
Approximately 81 per cent of the population has<br />
access to a bank account, less than 50 per cent have<br />
debit cards, and only 16 per cent of adults in Trinidad<br />
and Tobago own a credit card.<br />
If efforts are made to move to a virtual financial<br />
sector, there must be a simplification of the process<br />
to open bank accounts and obtain debit and credit<br />
cards. Additionally, where government policies<br />
demand the source of funds for cash deposits this<br />
will present an increased challenge for ‘black money’.<br />
Furthermore, liberalisation of regulations and<br />
attempts to make the economy more competitive<br />
reduce incentives for corruption. Even at an individual<br />
level consumers can help stamp out the black<br />
economy by asking for receipts.<br />
The most effective way to stifle the black<br />
economy is to transition to electronic<br />
payments. If financial institutions can<br />
support micro, small and medium-sized<br />
enterprises (MSMEs) with remote/cashless<br />
transaction capabilities, a further blow to<br />
the black economy.<br />
40 MAY <strong>2023</strong> CHAMBER.ORG.TT
The BLACK Economy<br />
Human rights and environmental violations<br />
On the topical issue of alleged State-actor involvement in<br />
human trafficking, it could be argued that high-level influence<br />
might affect reporting and it may not show up in the<br />
estimated financial scope of the black economy. On<br />
the tangential issue of the sex working industry<br />
which operates behind façades of legitimate<br />
establishments, these enterprises could also be<br />
used as a money-cleaning business model which<br />
allows for the re-integration of ‘black money’<br />
back into the economy. This reveals a connection<br />
between some aspects of the black economy<br />
and major human rights and national security<br />
threats, as the issues of human trafficking and<br />
forced sex work overlaps with the issue of migrants<br />
and undocumented workers. There are even purportedly<br />
established connections between the illegal trade of wildlife<br />
and the funding of larger criminal enterprises, which links the<br />
black economy to the environmental harm of our ecosystem.<br />
For many, human rights are seen as an esoteric concept for<br />
developed countries with ‘first world problems.’ The reality,<br />
however, is that human rights are a ‘dollars and cents’ matter<br />
and violations persist nationally because there are financial<br />
benefits to these activities.<br />
In order to tackle the many dimensions of the black economy<br />
we require increased efforts by those responsible for addressing<br />
criminal activity in society. However, the ability of the police to<br />
meaningfully tackle the black economy is greatly undermined<br />
by burdensome economic policies and reputed complicity in<br />
illegality. This indirect State facilitation of the black economy<br />
could result in the perpetuation of illegal activities and could<br />
drive legitimate businesses out. It can breed increasing levels<br />
of social instability, criminality, taxation due to lost national<br />
revenue, emigration, ‘brain drain’ and disincentivised business<br />
activity. In essence, a thriving black economy is a signpost<br />
of a compromised socio-economic system. It is therefore<br />
necessary to confront the causes and consequences of the<br />
black economy to protect citizens. Failure to urgently tackle<br />
this threat can result in a sacrifice of the rule of law with a rule<br />
by lawlessness.<br />
RAWPIXEL.COM<br />
CHAMBER.ORG.TT MAY <strong>2023</strong><br />
41
The RED Economy<br />
KC kickstarts the next 100<br />
years of export-led growth<br />
Does Trinidad and Tobago have a<br />
red economy? How is the government<br />
incentivising the manufacturing sector?<br />
KC Confectionery’s CEO reflects on its<br />
innovative manufacturing model, ESG<br />
position and plans for the future.<br />
By Asha Javeed, Journalist<br />
Asha is an award-winning journalist, with over 20<br />
years of experience in the media; her work focuses<br />
on truth, transparency and governance.<br />
The red economy is about mass production and consumption;<br />
it is derived from Fordism, named after Henry Ford, who<br />
operated as though environmental resources were unlimited.<br />
This economic model focuses on reducing production costs<br />
by employing a linear business model of extracting resources<br />
and producing waste. It is hostile to social and environmental<br />
concerns, making it an unsustainable economic system.<br />
Trinidad and Tobago does not have a red economy. Instead,<br />
our manufacturing models support economic advancement<br />
and environmental considerations where business is based on<br />
competitive environments and a free enterprise system.<br />
Riding the wave of innovation<br />
For candymaker KC Confectionery, this holds true, having<br />
successfully balanced competitive operations alongside<br />
sustainability factors for the past 100 years. KC’s future is<br />
in export markets; it’s the only way for the Couva-based<br />
business to achieve economies of scale. As it stands, the<br />
100 year-old company only utilises 40 per cent of its existing<br />
capacity. Despite already having a global footprint - it exports<br />
to 22 countries, and 70 per cent of its sales comes from<br />
exports - chief executive officer Satnarine Bachew believes<br />
there is room to expand and improve its product offerings.<br />
Expansion entails finding the right product for each market<br />
- for example, in Trinidad and Tobago, the ‘dinner mint’ is the<br />
popular candy choice, while in the USA, the more attractive<br />
option is the ginger mint.<br />
COURTESY KC CONFECTIONERY<br />
Satnarine Bachew, CEO, KC Candy at the launch of its 100-year commemorative stamp<br />
“We are always searching for the new wave, and this is where<br />
we are right now, searching for what will propel KC into the<br />
future, where the growth will come from. We are putting a lot<br />
of emphasis on developing our markets. The export market is<br />
the key to KC’s future because the local market is small; it’s<br />
only 1.3 million people. In contrast, the export market makes<br />
up the rest of the world,” said Bachew. He also noted that<br />
there is a natural synergy between innovation, expansion,<br />
and growth, “what KC did successfully in the markets they<br />
entered was undertake market research, understand the<br />
needs of each market, understand the different tastes and<br />
packaging, and all the vagaries of new markets.” “Depending<br />
on where you go, the popularity of the product changes,” he<br />
said.<br />
CHAMBER.ORG.TT MAY <strong>2023</strong><br />
43
The RED Economy<br />
Risk taker, sustainability champion<br />
KC takes pride in its ability to engage the community and<br />
provide support for non-governmental organisations (NGOs)<br />
and others who come knocking at its door. Bachew said that<br />
long before the environmental, social and governance (ESG)<br />
agenda became a corporate buzzword, KC was a company<br />
that lived the sustainability experience. “In today’s world,<br />
sustainability is defined as meeting the needs of the present<br />
without compromising the ability of future generations<br />
to meet their own needs. KC has been engaging in these<br />
practices, where decisions are made from a shareholder<br />
perspective and a stakeholder perspective, where one<br />
considers the wider society and the environment, alongside<br />
the economics of making decisions.”<br />
“KC has built long lasting relationships with its suppliers,<br />
financiers, customers, and employees. After the fire in 2005,<br />
during this challenging period, we were able to lean on<br />
some of those relationships; when decisions are made in<br />
that context, where it is sustainability centric, it leads to the<br />
longevity of organisations. Looking back at how KC survived<br />
over the years, it has been through innovation. It has been<br />
through the willingness to take risks, to go out into the<br />
export market, to invest in capital expenditure and plant and<br />
equipment, and build long lasting relationships. Those are<br />
some of the main attributes that contribute to the company’s<br />
success and its ability to withstand the vicissitudes of the<br />
business environment over 100 years,” he noted.<br />
Internationally known, T&T owned<br />
On the issue of inputs, the base of KC’s products is sugar. The<br />
Ukraine/Russia war is impacting not only energy prices but<br />
food as well, including sugar and, of course, your favourite<br />
KC candy. “We used to import glucose from Ukraine but<br />
have had to shift. We now import from Turkey, Brazil, and<br />
the USA. The same with sugar; we buy through an importer,<br />
and they bring it in based on where it’s available such as<br />
Guatemala, Mexico, and Brazil. Sourcing changes depending<br />
on availability and the price,” he added.<br />
Bachew stated that the company hopes to grow by 50 per<br />
cent in the next few years. “Even with that development,<br />
based on our current production, we will utilise just about 40<br />
KC: Internationally Known... T&T Owned<br />
Company of the Year<br />
Champions of Business 2022<br />
Looking back at how KC survived over the<br />
years, it has been through innovation. It has<br />
been through the willingness to take risks, to go<br />
out into the export market, to invest in capital<br />
expenditure and plant and equipment, and build<br />
long lasting relationships.<br />
per cent of our capacity. If we can expand our export markets<br />
and ramp up production, this will move our utilisation rate to<br />
80 per cent, and we will be able to achieve very competitive<br />
economies of scale,” he said.<br />
In 2022, KC Confectionery was awarded the ‘Internationally<br />
Known... T&T Owned Company of the Year’ honoured<br />
by the Trinidad and Tobago Chamber of Industry and<br />
Commerce for its development from a cottage industry to an<br />
international export-driven company. Over the years, KC has<br />
championed entering new markets with globalisation and<br />
trade liberalisation. “Export markets were embraced, and the<br />
growth started from there; it was the recipe. Today the same<br />
thing applies, especially given the limitations of local market<br />
size. Growth in the future will be through product innovation<br />
and increasing economies of scale, and that can only come<br />
from scaling up the export market,” he said.<br />
How government can support growth<br />
For businesses to thrive, Bachew believes that more work<br />
needs to be done to improve the ease of doing business.<br />
“There has been some improvement, but we still have a long<br />
way to go,” he said.<br />
“Digitisation will help, and the government has started that<br />
process. But there are still lengthy periods at the ports to get<br />
goods in. Then we have the VAT refunds discussion, which<br />
has been ongoing, this significantly impacts companies’<br />
cash flow, especially smaller companies such as KC where<br />
you have to expend large chunks of money, and there’s a<br />
long cycle before it returns,” he declared.<br />
44 MAY <strong>2023</strong> CHAMBER.ORG.TT
The RED Economy<br />
“Some level of government support is also needed to tackle<br />
trade issues. Smaller countries and smaller companies<br />
need protection from dumping, for example. This impacts<br />
our ability to compete because the larger manufacturers<br />
with economies of scale can afford to dump products in<br />
our market. And yes, we have dumping legislation, but from<br />
previous experience, that is a very long and costly process.<br />
We need to dig a little deeper. How can we protect smaller<br />
businesses? The big countries do it through non-tariff<br />
barriers and so on. There are many ways in which they<br />
protect their indigenous businesses, and smaller countries<br />
need to do more of that. So, we can encourage companies<br />
like KC to grow and minimise our risk, especially as we do<br />
not have access to economies of scale at the level of global<br />
companies.”<br />
Ministry of Trade and Industry – incentives, initiatives, and funds<br />
According to data from the Central Statistical Office, in 2022, total exports were estimated at TT$83.2 billion, which far surpasses the export growth in<br />
2019 (pre-pandemic) valued at TT$48.6 billion, a 71 per cent increase in exports.<br />
Energy exports in 2022 were valued at TT$66.4 billion, while non- energy exports were valued at TT$16.8 billion which is a 29 per cent increase over<br />
the pre-COVID levels in 2019. The top export markets were the United States of America, Belgium, Morocco, Guyana, Mexico, Brazil, Jamaica, and<br />
Suriname. Trinidad and Tobago demonstrated a strong export performance in the non-energy manufacturing sector showing significant increases<br />
from 2021 to 2022 for: iron and steel (6%); food and beverage (21%); wood and wood related (29%); paper and paper related products (48%); basic<br />
chemicals and fertilisers (37%); and plastic and rubber products (55%).<br />
To move the export sector forward, the Ministry of Trade and Industry (MTI) is continuing the implementation of initiatives aimed at achieving a further<br />
increase in non-energy exports in <strong>2023</strong>.<br />
The Ministry of Trade and Industry has made it a priority to expand market access and deepen trade with targeted countries and markets of interest.<br />
This is being done through ongoing negotiations with Chile and Curaçao respectively for Partial Scope Trade Agreements. Further, negotiations are<br />
ongoing for the expansion of the CARICOM – Colombia Trade Economic and Technical Cooperation Agreement.<br />
The MTI will continue to support private sector enterprises through the provision of a suite of incentives targeting the growth of the non-energy sector.<br />
These facilities are:<br />
• The Export Booster Initiative (EBI), comprising of three broad strategic areas namely, Export Promotion, Capacity Building, and Institutional<br />
Strengthening. Under this initiative, the International Certification Fund (ICF) aims to help exporters achieve international certification in food/<br />
beverage and other product compliance to meet the quality and safety standards of international markets allowing them to gain market presence<br />
and thereby resulting in increased exports.<br />
• The Grant Fund Facility (GFF) designed to assist the growth of small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) particularly those that are engaged<br />
in the manufacture of non-energy exports. It provides 50 per cent of funding to SMEs up to TT$250,000 per applicant for the acquisition of new<br />
machinery and equipment, and in some instances technology/software and tools.<br />
• The Steelpan Manufacturing Grant Fund Facility (SGFF) which allows steelpan manufacturers to access up to a maximum of TT$250,000 per<br />
tranche, not exceeding TT$1 million per entity, to fund the acquisition of new machinery, equipment, software, tools, raw materials, and training. The<br />
fund focuses on promoting the manufacturing and exports of the steelpan and its complimentary products.<br />
Several major initiatives to be implemented for <strong>2023</strong> which will redound to the further enhancement of our trade and exports prospects include:<br />
• The establishment of a Trade and Investment Promotion Agency. This new institutional arrangement will ensure a more streamlined, cost effective<br />
and targeted approach to trade and investment promotion in Trinidad and Tobago. The design of the new agency is in keeping with international<br />
best practices.<br />
• The establishment of Commercial Offices (in the United States of America, United Kingdom, and Panama) and appointment of Commercial<br />
Attachés (in China, Guyana, Jamaica, and South Africa) will provide the in-country support such as market intelligence and navigating through the<br />
regulatory frameworks which is much needed by exporters.<br />
• The establishment of the Special Economic Zones and the operationalisation of the Special Economic Zones (SEZ) Authority will also ultimately<br />
have a positive impact on exports.<br />
CHAMBER.ORG.TT MAY <strong>2023</strong><br />
45
Voice of Business<br />
Innovating through the pandemic:<br />
creating sustainable breakthroughs<br />
How is your business innovating?<br />
What are the challenges and successes?<br />
What advice would you give to others?<br />
By Ria Chaitram, Public Affairs and Media<br />
Relations Officer, Trinidad and Tobago<br />
Chamber of Industry and Commerce<br />
COURTESY TTCIC<br />
Therefore, we turned to the local market<br />
for support and established a supply<br />
chain relationship with Angostura.<br />
Having sought the necessary approvals<br />
from the Ministry of Trade and Industry,<br />
we were able to successfully provide<br />
this product to the market. Rising<br />
shipping costs and the unavailability<br />
of materials due to factory shutdowns<br />
in China also prompted us to shift our<br />
sourcing to Dubai, Turkey, and India.<br />
I encourage other businesses to start<br />
with a goal that satisfies a need in<br />
the marketplace. Start small but think<br />
big. Learn as you go and as you grow.<br />
Recruit team members with strengths<br />
and disciplines you need to improve.<br />
Be patient and stay focused; success<br />
is guaranteed.<br />
COURTESY RAMPS LOGISTICS<br />
Langston Roach<br />
Executive Chairman<br />
Langston Roach Industries Ltd<br />
Business Hall of Fame Inductee 2022<br />
Champions of Business Awards<br />
At Langston Roach, we have always<br />
employed the “Kaizen” concept, a<br />
Japanese approach to continuous<br />
incremental improvement. Every day<br />
we consider how we can improve and<br />
become more efficient and productive.<br />
Innovation is part of our DNA.<br />
When the COVID-19 pandemic<br />
hit, the demand for hand sanitisers<br />
increased instantly. However, due to<br />
supply chain disruptions, we could not<br />
access much-needed raw materials<br />
from one of our international suppliers.<br />
Watch the exclusive interview<br />
with Langston Roach here<br />
We employ a lot of young people,<br />
mainly from depressed areas in<br />
Trinidad, creating a workforce that is<br />
highly productive, cooperative, and<br />
able to perform. In order to expand<br />
export-led growth, we contracted<br />
manufacturing services from various<br />
entities across the Caribbean. Today,<br />
Langston Roach has become perhaps<br />
the largest and most successful<br />
company in our industry. For the last<br />
two years, we have been working on<br />
entering the Latin American market,<br />
and I am happy to share that we<br />
recently obtained approvals to send<br />
our products to Colombia for testing.<br />
Shaun Rampersad<br />
Chief Executive Officer<br />
Ramps Logistics Ltd<br />
Internationally Known...T&T Owned<br />
Company of the Year Award 2020<br />
The COVID-19 pandemic allowed<br />
us to adopt new technology in<br />
the business, this helped support<br />
the scaling of the company in a<br />
sustainable manner. To a large extent,<br />
innovation today is digital—it involves<br />
46 MAY <strong>2023</strong> CHAMBER.ORG.TT
Voice of Business<br />
building a digital infrastructure<br />
and having a solid research and<br />
development function. At Ramps,<br />
we do a lot of our coding, software<br />
engineering and data management.<br />
We have been trying to scale the<br />
business up in a relatively small<br />
market, but we are also quite fortunate<br />
to operate in a location with a worldclass<br />
oil and gas sector. We have<br />
always explored opportunities to scale<br />
the business outside Trinidad and<br />
Tobago. With scale and growth, you<br />
need to have the infrastructure and the<br />
business growing at the same rate, and<br />
that can be challenging at times.<br />
Watch the exclusive interview<br />
with Shaun Rampersad here<br />
At Ramps, we built an operational digital<br />
platform, “Laser”, and our customers<br />
interact with us there. It integrates our<br />
transportation management system<br />
and our enterprise resource planning<br />
system; it runs the commercial part of<br />
our business. Our goal this year is to<br />
better understand artificial intelligence<br />
(AI) and how to integrate this into our<br />
business. For us, understanding the<br />
potential impact of AI on our business<br />
and customer experience is exciting<br />
right now.<br />
Businesses need to understand<br />
what digital infrastructure means,<br />
what the new world of work looks like,<br />
and what productivity is. You need to<br />
understand how productivity impacts<br />
your competitiveness. Who is going<br />
to win the digital race? That is a good<br />
question, and while there are many<br />
opportunities, there are also many<br />
threats. Therefore, you must be clear<br />
about what you need to build into your<br />
business to compete globally.<br />
Anthony and June-Ann Henry<br />
Entrepreneurs/Owners<br />
A&J Homemade Ice Cream Co Ltd<br />
Entrepreneurship Award<br />
Champions of Business 2022<br />
A&J’s vision was to create unique,<br />
unusual ice cream flavours. We also<br />
incorporate local foods and fruits,<br />
which is a big selling point. This gave<br />
us a competitive advantage, and it<br />
helped with brand identification. The<br />
differentiation in the flavours and the<br />
distinctiveness of our products helped<br />
solidify the brand further. Innovation<br />
for us is continuous.<br />
COURTESY TTCIC<br />
One of our challenges has been<br />
striking a balance between family<br />
and business. The business is also<br />
like a child; it is very demanding<br />
regarding time and money. Scaling<br />
and growing the company also<br />
presents challenges. With the onset<br />
of the COVID-19 pandemic and the<br />
subsequent shutdown of businesses,<br />
we had to pivot and experiment with<br />
new operational methods to keep the<br />
business alive. We kept changing and<br />
adjusting our distribution channels<br />
to ensure the products reached<br />
customers.<br />
Watch the exclusive interview with<br />
Anthony and June-Ann Henry here<br />
We are proud of how we developed<br />
the business, taking it from its humble<br />
beginnings to where it is today. A&J<br />
started with a plastic table, selling ice<br />
cream at the side of the road. The fact<br />
that we opened a storefront, expanded<br />
to a second location, and created<br />
jobs in more than one community is<br />
a significant accomplishment. The<br />
brand is becoming a household name<br />
not just with customers but also<br />
with the business community; being<br />
recognised by the T&T Chamber at<br />
the 2022 Champions of Business was<br />
a susbtantive milestone.<br />
Our advice to fellow entrepreneurs<br />
- being an entrepreneur is not an easy<br />
road to travel; there are many sacrifices<br />
such as time, energy, and sleep among<br />
other things, but keep God first, and<br />
everything else will follow.<br />
CHAMBER.ORG.TT MAY <strong>2023</strong><br />
47
The GREY Economy<br />
Doubling down on<br />
T&T’s informal economy<br />
Informal businesses often do not contribute to the tax base, and tend to remain<br />
small, with low productivity and limited access to finance. Workers also lack<br />
protection and experience high inequality. There are many benefits for supporting<br />
the formalisation of these entities, including increased economic growth.<br />
What is the grey economy?<br />
The informal or ‘grey’ economy consists<br />
of activities that have market value but<br />
are not formally registered. The informal<br />
economy embraces professions as<br />
diverse as minibus drivers, market<br />
stands, and hawkers found at traffic<br />
lights all over the world. In advanced<br />
economies, examples can range from<br />
gig and construction workers, through<br />
domestic workers, to registered firms<br />
that engage in informal activities.<br />
The International Labour Organization<br />
estimates that about 2 billion workers,<br />
or over 60 per cent of the world’s adult<br />
labour force, operate in the informal<br />
sector - at least part time. The informal<br />
economy is a global phenomenon, but<br />
there is great variation within and across<br />
countries. On average, it represents 35<br />
per cent of GDP in low- and middleincome<br />
countries versus 15 per cent in<br />
advanced economies. Latin America<br />
and sub-Saharan Africa have the highest<br />
levels of informality, and Europe and<br />
East Asia are the regions with the lowest<br />
levels of informality.<br />
Source: IMF<br />
By Asha Javeed, Journalist<br />
Asha is an award-winning journalist, with over 20<br />
years of experience in the media; her work focuses<br />
on truth, transparency and governance.<br />
Doubles is a dish that unites the cultural divide in Trinidad and Tobago.<br />
However, some doubles and other food vendors operate in that “open<br />
secret” area, where, unlike salaried employees or registered businesses,<br />
they may pay no or very little taxes to the State. Most food vendors<br />
have minimal overheads given that they may not pay rent or taxes. In<br />
addition, the price of these products fluctuate depending on the cost of<br />
raw materials. Despite this, price of ‘street food’ is inelastic and people<br />
still line up to buy it.<br />
Fixing your food craving<br />
At a mid-year budget analysis forum in 2018, PwC’s Territory Tax Services<br />
Leader, Angelique Bart, boldly posited that doubles vendors should be<br />
made to pay taxes like everyone else. Bart pointed out that a doubles<br />
vendor operating at the side of the road may earn tens of thousands of<br />
dollars a month yet they may not pay taxes such as Pay As You Earn<br />
(PAYE) as other individual workers, or corporation tax as in the case of<br />
businesses.<br />
48 MAY <strong>2023</strong> CHAMBER.ORG.TT
The GREY Economy<br />
In Trinidad and Tobago, food vending is just one example of the grey economy which exists and<br />
thrives. It is an economic activity that is legal, and unrecorded. While the sale of ‘street food’<br />
provides employment and falls under the services sector, it’s an unregulated market. According to<br />
World Economics, the size of Trinidad and Tobago’s informal economy is estimated to be 31.6 per<br />
cent which represents approximately $11 billion at Gross Domestic Product based on purchasing<br />
power parity levels (GDP PPP).<br />
FREEPIK.COM<br />
It is common knowledge that examples of businesses that often evade taxes include domestic<br />
workers, creatives, influencers, hairdressers, photographers, freelancers in all industries, and<br />
small pop-up market vendors to an array of food items for sale at pharmacies and supermarkets<br />
birthed by micro or cottage industries. Unless formalised, they are outside the bracket of people<br />
who pay taxes. And unless creatively incentivised to do so, they will not choose to be part of the<br />
formalised system.<br />
Pandemic and economic impacts<br />
In an IDB Report of August 2017, Amos Peters points out that, “There are many factors that<br />
might determine the size and character of the informal economy, chief among them the tax and<br />
regulatory burden they create. High taxes on business or labour reduce the incentives to operate<br />
in the formal economy because the returns on effort or for enterprise become relatively lower in<br />
the formal sector. The regulatory burden operates in a similar way by increasing the economic<br />
costs of formal sector participation. Along this line, business cycles can impact the size of the<br />
informal economy. In times of high growth and prosperity, opportunities in the formal sector for<br />
work and business abound, whereas in recessionary times, high levels of unemployment can<br />
induce individuals to supplement their incomes in the informal economy.” Between 1990 to 2014,<br />
the findings for Trinidad and Tobago showed that the range of the informal sector was between<br />
31 to 41 per cent of total economic activity.<br />
CHAMBER.ORG.TT MAY <strong>2023</strong><br />
49
The GREY Economy<br />
The plight of the pandemic has highlighted the economic<br />
crisis in the Caribbean region and an ILO report of 2021<br />
substantiates the fact that “informal workers, women, young<br />
people, people with lower levels of qualifications, and the<br />
micro- and small enterprises have been disproportionately<br />
affected by the crisis, which has amplified the labour and<br />
social deficits that existed before the outbreak of the<br />
pandemic in the region.” The Government of Trinidad and<br />
Tobago was forced to reckon with this during its COVID-19<br />
management, as it created Income Support Grants for<br />
persons not registered with the National Insurance System.<br />
Linkages between the grey and black economy<br />
There are dangers within the informal economy which<br />
shows the need to urgently re-examine some of the<br />
sectors which are categorised within it. The presence of PH<br />
(private hire) taxi drivers is another example of the informal<br />
economy. The Government recognised taxi-drivers have<br />
an “H” at the beginning of their number plates. All other<br />
vehicles at taxi stands with “P” are operating illegally. PH<br />
taxi drivers proliferate the country. While providing a mode<br />
of transport in often underserved communities, they may<br />
also pay no taxes to the State. In this case it is an illegal<br />
activity which is tolerated because it serves people who<br />
may otherwise not have access to public transport.<br />
This issue received national attention in December 2020,<br />
when the body of 18 year-old Ashanti Riley was found<br />
four days after she disappeared boarding a PH taxi cab.<br />
In February 2021 the kidnapping and murder of 22 yearold<br />
Arima court clerk Andrea Bharatt further heightened<br />
the call for streamlining licensed taxi drivers. The TT Taxi<br />
Drivers Network also called on illegal PH drivers to take<br />
steps to become legal taxis. In June 2021 in response to a<br />
question in Parliament, Minister of Works and Transport,<br />
Senator Rohan Sinanan said consultations were still<br />
ongoing and work was being done to finalise the legislation<br />
to be tabled in Parliament to regulate PH taxi drivers.<br />
15 reasons to join the TTCIC<br />
Be part of the largest network of businesses in Trinidad & Tobago!<br />
1<br />
Advocacy &<br />
Lobbying:<br />
The Voice of BUSINESS<br />
2<br />
Public Consultation:<br />
representation on >40<br />
councils, taskforces<br />
3<br />
Committees:<br />
7 strategic<br />
sectoral groups<br />
4<br />
Business Development:<br />
Trade Missions, Roundtable<br />
Discussions, JV/Partnership<br />
facilitation<br />
5<br />
Assistance to<br />
access funding such<br />
as grants, loans<br />
6<br />
Business Insight Seminar<br />
Series/On-demand<br />
Library, Training<br />
7<br />
Newsletters, Market<br />
Intelligence Reports,<br />
CONTACT magazine<br />
8<br />
Networking Opportunities/<br />
Events: Conferences,<br />
Annual Business Meeting,<br />
Champions of Business<br />
9<br />
Certificates<br />
of<br />
Origin<br />
10<br />
Group Life &<br />
Health<br />
Insurance Plan<br />
11<br />
Membership Value-Added<br />
Programme/Card (B2B<br />
discounts and savings)<br />
12<br />
Rental of Meeting Rooms<br />
& Conference Hall (30%<br />
member discount)<br />
13<br />
Office<br />
Rental<br />
Spaces<br />
14<br />
Access to our<br />
Membership List<br />
(>500 members)<br />
15<br />
Access to the<br />
Dispute Resolution<br />
Centre services<br />
Why join? | How to join?<br />
| Complete the application form<br />
Questions? Call 637-6966 Ext. 1230<br />
50 MAY <strong>2023</strong> CHAMBER.ORG.TT
The GREY Economy<br />
“The focus of the Ministry is on improving the<br />
legal framework for the operation of taxis. Further<br />
to this, in an effort to gather information for the<br />
development of a policy to address the efficient<br />
operations of a taxi system in Trinidad and<br />
Tobago, the Ministry, over the period March to<br />
<strong>May</strong> 2021, conducted several consultations with<br />
various stakeholders; law enforcement, [the]<br />
insurance and banking sector, [the] transport<br />
academy, the PH taxi drivers, the Chamber of<br />
Commerce and the Regional Corporations and<br />
also the Tobago House of Assembly.” In April<br />
2022 the policy was under review by Attorney<br />
General and Minister of Legal Affairs, Senator<br />
Reginald Armour.<br />
NANDANI BRIDGLAL/SHUTTERSTOCK.COM<br />
Finding solutions that work<br />
Bart indicated that, “There is a significant<br />
amount of revenue that is not filtering into<br />
the tax system. So rather than overburden the<br />
people who are already burdened with high<br />
rates, very low deductions or incentives in some<br />
cases [and] the individual person, the employed<br />
persons like myself... it becomes a real and<br />
a very relevant question for the question of<br />
revenue generation.”<br />
The fact that it has taken over two years to<br />
come to a formal position about PH drivers<br />
is indicative of Government’s acceptance or<br />
even tolerance of such illegal activity and<br />
unwillingness to impact and affect the status<br />
quo of what currently takes place. As it exists,<br />
there are no penalties for operating in the grey<br />
economy. What occurs now is an imbalance<br />
of registered businesses paying taxes while<br />
unregistered ones are allowed to operate with<br />
impunity. The onus for enforcement is on the<br />
Board of Inland Revenue. The establishment<br />
and operationalisation of the Trinidad and<br />
Tobago Revenue Authority (TTRA) is meant to<br />
address leakages in the system.<br />
Characteristics of the Caribbean’s informal economy<br />
The CARICOM Competition Network (CCN) agreed that there are several<br />
characteristics of the informal economy in the region.<br />
These characteristics include:<br />
i. Many small economic agents (i.e. normally one person with no<br />
employees).<br />
ii. The informal businesses are fragmented – i.e. acting individually.<br />
iii. The businesses pay no corporate taxes or import duties.<br />
iv. The markets within which the informal businesses operate mainly<br />
supply homogeneous goods. In most of the countries, the agriculture<br />
sector is a good example of where informality is high.<br />
v. The markets are easy to enter and exit.<br />
vi. Except for agriculture, the informal businesses are mobile with no<br />
fixed corporate addresses.<br />
vii. The informal businesses are not strictly prohibited under national<br />
laws unless they pose a health or safety risk to consumers. Some<br />
governments may view this liberal approach to informality as<br />
encouraging entrepreneurship and creativity in their economies.<br />
The International Labour Office attributes the persistence of informality in<br />
the Caribbean to several factors including:<br />
i. A perceived heavy tax burden imposed on businesses;<br />
ii. The perceived high cost of registration of businesses;<br />
iii. Weak enforcement capabilities of the State;<br />
iv. Informal business activity is fleeting – i.e. agents have no plans to stay<br />
in business long;<br />
v. Lack of information about how to register a business;<br />
vi. Lack of understanding of the relevant sector regulations; and<br />
vii. Lack of understanding of the benefits of formalisation.<br />
Source: OECD<br />
CHAMBER.ORG.TT MAY <strong>2023</strong><br />
51
The BLUE Economy<br />
Diving into the blue economy!<br />
Transitioning to sustainability<br />
A United Nations Environment Programme<br />
(UNEP) Rapid Readiness Assessment<br />
(RRA) pilot project to establish the<br />
readiness of Trinidad and Tobago to<br />
transition to a sustainable blue economy<br />
was released March <strong>2023</strong>. It declared that<br />
Trinidad and Tobago was indeed ready.<br />
What does a sustainable blue economy for<br />
Trinidad and Tobago look like, and how do<br />
we transition?<br />
By Sarah Mahadeo,<br />
Research Fellow, Sasakawa Global Ocean Institute,<br />
World Maritime University, Sweden<br />
FREEPIK.COM<br />
Trinidad and Tobago has always had a prosperous<br />
ocean-based economy linked primarily to the oil<br />
and gas industry and to activities focused on<br />
coastal and marine tourism, fisheries and the<br />
shipping and boating sectors. As a ‘large ocean<br />
state’ with 14 times more sea space than land, the<br />
possibilities for growth and diversification through<br />
a Sustainable Blue Economy (SBE) are immense.<br />
A SBE encourages the development of ocean and<br />
coastal resources and the promotion of sustainable<br />
livelihoods and economies while safeguarding the<br />
ocean’s health to support our development needs,<br />
now and in the future.<br />
52 MAY <strong>2023</strong> CHAMBER.ORG.TT
The BLUE Economy<br />
Potential, promise, and opportunities<br />
Several emerging sectors and opportunities for<br />
growth in existing ones could play a role in the<br />
transition to a SBE. Developing these would require<br />
considerable investment and the requisite policy and<br />
regulatory mechanisms to manage the industries.<br />
Among emerging sectors, a recent assessment<br />
conducted by The University of the West Indies (The<br />
UWI) found that there is the potential to generate<br />
up to 25-gigawatt (GW) from offshore wind in the<br />
Trinidad and Tobago Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ).<br />
Mariculture, which is farming of marine organisms for<br />
food and other products, while in the early stages of<br />
research and development at the Institute of Marine<br />
Affairs (IMA), can be viable within a comprehensive<br />
SBE strategy. Among existing sectors, offshore oil and<br />
gas offer several opportunities in post-operational<br />
industries, including infrastructure decommissioning<br />
and carbon capture and storage (CCS), which uses<br />
depleted oil fields by using reservoirs for carbon<br />
storage. While the current tourism product is heavily<br />
focused on sun, sea, sand and culture, ecotourism<br />
can become part of a sustainable tourism sector for<br />
both islands.<br />
Alongside sectoral growth is the need to focus efforts<br />
on research, innovation, and capacity development.<br />
Digital transformation can impact all SBE industries<br />
and, with the growth of maritime activities, will be<br />
driven by technology. A Maritime Blue Innovation<br />
Technology Park is being considered in Tobago.<br />
Such ventures should be encouraged along with<br />
partnerships between industry and higher education<br />
institutions to develop skills for future blue jobs.<br />
Capacity development is one of the main drivers<br />
of growth in the maritime economy, and a skilled<br />
local workforce will be essential for advancing a<br />
SBE. Additionally, the development of micro, small,<br />
and medium-sized enterprises (MSMEs) can be an<br />
important vehicle for a SBE in Trinidad and Tobago,<br />
where partnerships can connect enterprises to<br />
investors for collaboration.<br />
Among emerging sectors, a recent assessment<br />
conducted by The University of the West Indies<br />
(The UWI) found that there is the potential to<br />
generate up to 25-gigawatt (GW) from offshore<br />
wind in the Trinidad and Tobago Exclusive<br />
Economic Zone (EEZ).<br />
What is the Blue Economy?<br />
The blue economy is part of the wider economy, it involves<br />
human activities at sea as well as land-based upstream and<br />
downstream energy activities and the people connected with<br />
these. A sustainable blue economy creates prosperity and<br />
increases social equity at all levels of society while protecting,<br />
regenerating, and maintaining the integrity of coastal and marine<br />
ecosystems (UNEP, 2021).<br />
8 Marine Spatial Planning and the Sustainable Blue Eco<br />
Factors promoting the development of<br />
3. Developing a sustainable Blue Economy<br />
Marine<br />
Spatial<br />
Planning<br />
Adapting to<br />
the effects<br />
of Climate<br />
Change<br />
a sustainable blue economy<br />
Financing<br />
and<br />
Investment<br />
Integrated,<br />
Multi-level<br />
Governance<br />
Sustainable<br />
Blue Economy<br />
Monitoring,<br />
Control and<br />
Surveillance<br />
Stakeholder<br />
Partnerships<br />
Resources<br />
and<br />
Capacity<br />
Science,<br />
Research and<br />
Technology<br />
Development<br />
Figure 2<br />
Factors promoting Reference: the development IOC-UNESCO/MSPglobal, of a sustainable Blue 2021 Economy<br />
© IOC-UNESCO/MSPglobal, 2021.<br />
also between policy makers and researche<br />
CHAMBER.ORG.TT<br />
Integrated, multi-level ocean governance: Making the<br />
harnessing the potential of the ocean will<br />
MAY <strong>2023</strong><br />
53<br />
technological advances. Enabling techno<br />
transition to a sustainable Blue Economy starts with good potential to improve efficiency and produ
The BLUE Economy<br />
Mitigating challenges and risks<br />
The development of sustainable ocean-based activities faces several environmental challenges which must<br />
be urgently addressed. Pollution from maritime and land-based sources, including oil, plastics, sewage,<br />
and chemicals, pose a significant threat to the health of critical ecosystems such as reefs, mangroves,<br />
and seagrass beds. Recently, vast beach standings of the Sargassum seaweed have disrupted coastal<br />
and marine activities, most notably tourism, fisheries, and maritime transport. Climate change is another<br />
significant challenge, with ocean acidification and rising sea surface temperatures causing changes in<br />
marine ecosystems structure and functioning, altering the distribution of ocean-related human uses, and<br />
increasing the number and intensity of tropical storms and hurricanes.<br />
The fisheries and tourism sectors are particularly adversely impacted, and through the SBE, targeted<br />
actions for climate adaptation and mitigation should be explored. Additionally, fundamental knowledge gaps<br />
on the coastal and marine environment and human uses at sea and the lack of financing for implementing<br />
laws, policies, conservation, and restoration activities are all constraints to effective ocean management.<br />
Sustainable finance and investment are avenues to be explored for addressing these challenges.<br />
Developing a SBE transition framework<br />
The transition to a SBE starts with good ocean governance. As a necessary first<br />
step, the State has a critical role in advancing efforts towards developing an<br />
enabling governance framework, including policy and regulations for integrated<br />
ocean management. While recognised as necessary for the diversification<br />
of Trinidad and Tobago’s economy, several legislative and policy instruments<br />
supporting and promoting the transition to a SBE are pending approval. Most<br />
notable of these are the Shipping Bill (2019); the Fisheries Management Bill (2020);<br />
the Draft Integrated Coastal Zone Management Policy Framework (ICZM) (2020);<br />
and the draft National Maritime Policy and Strategy (NMPS) (2021), approval of<br />
all of which would signal the country’s commitment to developing a SBE.<br />
The transition from a<br />
traditional ocean economy,<br />
as we know it, to a SBE<br />
will be a complex, longterm<br />
undertaking. How<br />
this transition unfolds will<br />
depend mainly on the<br />
response from the public<br />
and private sectors to the<br />
many opportunities and<br />
challenges.<br />
A SBE offers a pathway for economic diversification for Trinidad and Tobago; blue growth does not mean<br />
compromising sustainability. The transition from a traditional ocean economy, as we know it, to a SBE will be<br />
a complex, long-term undertaking. How this transition unfolds will depend mainly on the response from the<br />
public and private sectors to the many opportunities and challenges. Strong leadership is critical to achieving<br />
favourable outcomes. The State must articulate its position and be committed to developing a shared vision<br />
with all stakeholders for a SBE in Trinidad and Tobago. Developing a Blue Economy Roadmap and filling the<br />
critical gaps in the governance framework are priorities for action. An inclusive and participatory transition<br />
to a SBE that is fair and equitable is dependent on cooperation among all stakeholders. Collaboration<br />
among the various users of the ocean space creates a positive, enabling environment for sustainable and<br />
thriving economic activity. Multi-stakeholder partnerships across government, industry, academia, and civil<br />
society can catalyse momentum and change towards a prosperous SBE in Trinidad and Tobago.<br />
54 MAY <strong>2023</strong> CHAMBER.ORG.TT
Leadership Insights<br />
What’s the best app<br />
on your smartphone<br />
and why?<br />
Marc G. Persaud<br />
Finance & Investment Strategist/<br />
Entrepreneur<br />
“In my downtime, I watch many<br />
educational videos on YouTube and<br />
listen to business podcasts. I created a<br />
library where I saved several docuseries<br />
on equity trading, valuation business cases<br />
and how to build Excel evaluation models.<br />
Aswath Damodaran is a guru on valuation,<br />
so I try to watch one of his series regularly.<br />
ColdFusion has great content on the crash<br />
of Enron and the rise and fall of Elizabeth<br />
Holmes. Financial Times also has a lot of<br />
good videos, most recently on inflation<br />
in Europe. I enjoy comedy; it keeps me<br />
sane. Therefore, I often start my day with a<br />
morning laugh on YouTube from John Oliver<br />
or Stephen Colbert. YouTube is mobile,<br />
the content is designed so you don’t have<br />
to watch the video; you can listen to it<br />
anywhere, at the gym or in traffic.”<br />
Sonji Pierre Chase<br />
Senior Partner<br />
Johnson, Camacho & Singh<br />
“Fitbit is the best app on my smartphone.<br />
It’s an app that I scan daily and perhaps<br />
even more than once per day. It gives<br />
me insight into how I am managing my<br />
work-life balance. I put in very long hours<br />
at the office at a primarily sedentary job.<br />
Therefore, knowing that I am getting<br />
some level of physical activity is extremely<br />
important as it helps me to master the<br />
stresses associated with my professional<br />
life. Throughout the day, I can easily<br />
monitor how I balance work with taking<br />
care of myself. It was perhaps even more<br />
useful during the COVID-19 pandemic as<br />
gyms were closed. I had access to support<br />
from the Fitbit community, receiving<br />
regular reminders to keep moving. Despite<br />
the challenges, it helped ensure I got my<br />
‘steps’ in. Fitbit has become an essential<br />
part of my life.”<br />
Dr Christian Stone<br />
Chief Executive Officer<br />
Term Finance (SME TT)<br />
“The best app on my smartphone<br />
is WhatsApp. It’s a powerful<br />
communication tool which is simple<br />
to use. It also has significant global<br />
penetration. Quite recently, I examined its<br />
usage statistics, and it’s estimated that<br />
almost three billion people worldwide<br />
use WhatsApp. In Trinidad and Tobago,<br />
it’s the most used voice and chat app. It<br />
lets me keep in touch with family, friends,<br />
and business contacts. Furthermore, I<br />
can access all my work contacts in one<br />
place. It’s an app that marries very well the<br />
ability to use it for business and personal<br />
objectives. It also has a more friendly,<br />
relaxed connotation. I use it every day –<br />
it’s my number one app. I also work with<br />
SMEs locally, and in the Caribbean region,<br />
many of whom have incorporated this app<br />
into their operations as a major marketing<br />
tool.”<br />
CHAMBER.ORG.TT MAY <strong>2023</strong><br />
55
The SILVER Economy<br />
The business of ageing:<br />
unlocking the possibilities of the silver economy<br />
The IDB expects that in the coming<br />
decades, the Latin America and Caribbean<br />
region will experience the highest rate<br />
of ageing population in the world. How<br />
is Trinidad and Tobago preparing for the<br />
challenges and opportunities this will bring?<br />
By Dr. Jennifer Rouse,<br />
Gerontologist (Retired), Advisor,<br />
Trinidad & Tobago Association of Retired Persons (TTARP)<br />
COURTESY TTARP<br />
TTARP’s Cooler Fete <strong>2023</strong> held at The Anchorage<br />
According to Trinidad and Tobago’s Population<br />
Census (Central Statistical Office, 2011), 13.4 per<br />
cent (177,676) of our total population was 60 years<br />
and over; that cohort is projected to increase to 17.1 per<br />
cent by 2025 and 33.3 per cent by 2050 (World Health<br />
Organization, 2000). The phenomenon of ‘Population<br />
Ageing’ is caused by low fertility and mortality rates and<br />
net migration. A population is considered ageing when<br />
more than 10% of its total population is 60 years and<br />
above.<br />
Changing workplace demographics is a significant<br />
challenge in the silver economy since the parallel system<br />
of contract employees operates alongside permanent<br />
staff. This has resulted in employers coordinating four<br />
generations from different backgrounds to create<br />
collaborative teams. Data sourced from Delta College<br />
Corporate Services (2010), states that the modern<br />
workforce comprises: Traditionalists (1925-1945)<br />
represent 5 per cent, Baby Boomers (1946-1964) 47<br />
per cent, Generation X (1965-1980) 30 per cent, and<br />
Generation Y or Millennials (1981-1995) 18 per cent.<br />
However, in tomorrow’s workforce, the expected<br />
trajectory is Traditionalists representing 7 per cent, Baby<br />
Boomers at 33 per cent, Generation X at 30 per cent, and<br />
Millennials at 30 per cent.<br />
56 MAY <strong>2023</strong> CHAMBER.ORG.TT
The SILVER Economy<br />
Boomers to Zoomers<br />
‘Boomers’ can become ‘Zoomers’ by defying the norms of<br />
their generational group and incorporating traits that cut<br />
across the divide of all four generations. How can employers<br />
improve the inclusion and acceptance of persons over 60<br />
years in today’s workforce? Businesses must consider the<br />
following:<br />
• Are we flexible and open to new information, input, and<br />
ideas from all age groups and willing to act on them?<br />
• Are we adaptable and quick to adjust to change?<br />
• Are we aware of the changes in industry trends,<br />
employee and client expectations, and government<br />
needs? Can we readily respond?<br />
• Are we malleable and prepared to be shaped into<br />
something new?<br />
• What is our relationship to process and structure? Do<br />
we respect the Traditionalist methods while meeting the<br />
needs of the Millennials?<br />
Challenges of ageing<br />
Labour supply has declined due to a decrease in Trinidad and<br />
Tobago’s population growth rate from 2.73 per cent to 0.49 per cent<br />
(Central Statistical Office, 2011), applying further pressures to the<br />
working aged population. Increasing taxes for the working population<br />
to maintain pensions can negatively impact their disposable<br />
income and savings. In some cases, post-retirement years are more<br />
prolonged than working years; therefore, it’s essential to re-consider<br />
the non-contributory public sector pension scheme.<br />
The vulnerability of the ‘Baby Boomers’ cohort to co-morbidities,<br />
based on work/life imbalance, unhealthy lifestyle choices, and<br />
neglect of self-care, gives rise to an increasing number of persons<br />
aged 50 and over with mental health disorders, diabetes, and kidney<br />
failure. Ill health is often carried over into retirement, resulting in<br />
dependence on family, places of worship, and even the State for<br />
financial support. More recently, the dependency ratio has shown a<br />
partial role reversal. Pensioners often perform unpaid childcare duties<br />
to support their working-age children who may be unemployed/<br />
under-employed/unemployable/incarcerated/divorced/disabled.<br />
The vulnerability of the ‘Baby Boomers’<br />
cohort to co-morbidities, based on<br />
work/life imbalance, unhealthy lifestyle<br />
choices, and neglect of self-care, gives<br />
rise to an increasing number of persons<br />
aged 50 and over with mental health<br />
disorders, diabetes, and kidney failure.<br />
Developing Assisted Living<br />
Facilities<br />
Over the past decade, there has been<br />
an increased demand for home care<br />
services and care homes for senior<br />
citizens in Trinidad and Tobago (Source:<br />
Division of Ageing, Ministry of Social<br />
Development and Family Services, Data).<br />
Overrepresented were older women living<br />
alone and vulnerable to the vagaries of<br />
crime and mental health disorders.<br />
The Assisted Living Facility (ALF) is a<br />
model of care for seniors, which could<br />
become a lucrative business opportunity<br />
for investors since the critical mass of<br />
interested seniors is from the ‘Baby<br />
Boomers’ cohort, comprising returning<br />
nationals and those who reside here.<br />
Middle-class professionals who are<br />
unmarried and childless and ‘empty<br />
nesters’ have also expressed interest in this<br />
model of care.<br />
Additionally, the ALFs could serve as an<br />
adult daycare for elderly parents of working<br />
adult children, where they could socialise<br />
with the residents and be stimulated by<br />
various activities.<br />
CHAMBER.ORG.TT MAY <strong>2023</strong><br />
57
NIS funds are expected to be entirely depleted by 2040<br />
unless there is reform, such as increasing monthly<br />
contributions, freezing the existing monthly quantum of<br />
TT$3,000, and increasing the retirement age to 65 years.<br />
The expected impact of an ageing population on the National Insurance Scheme (NIS), which provides benefits to<br />
the working population, is as follows:<br />
• NIS contributors will decrease from 4.3 per cent to 1.3 per cent over the next 50 years.<br />
• NIS pensioners will increase from 161,051 in 2011 to 412,423 in 2060.<br />
• NIS funds are expected to be entirely depleted by 2040 unless there is reform, such as increasing monthly<br />
contributions, freezing the existing monthly quantum of TT$3,000, and increasing the retirement age to 65 years.<br />
(Source: Trinidad and Tobago – Ninth Actuarial Review of the National Insurance System as of 30 June 2013, ENAP<br />
International, June 2015).<br />
Rise of the silver economy<br />
The Trinidad & Tobago Association of Retired Persons (TTARP) proposes a multi-pronged approach structured<br />
around the following recommendations, which have the potential to stimulate the growth of the silver economy:<br />
• Establish more superannuation funds tailored for contract workers with no security of tenure.<br />
• Measure the impact of extending the retirement age beyond 65.<br />
• Develop attractive/affordable health insurance options for Generation X (who start retiring in 2025).<br />
• Create term policies for ‘Baby Boomers’ who want to re-tool and re-skill.<br />
• Collaborate with the Town and Country Planning Division to advance proposed reforms for building codes<br />
which support the aged population.<br />
• Establish agencies throughout Trinidad and Tobago which can provide trained caregivers to deliver homecare<br />
services.<br />
• Invest in establishing Assisted Living Facilities (i.e. independent living in a communal setting) for persons 55<br />
years and over.<br />
• Provide annuities for members of the protective services as they can retire between 45 to 55 years.<br />
• Host Retirement Planning Seminars and include appropriate Non-Governmental Organisations (NGOs),<br />
Faith-based Organisations (FBOs), and Community-based Organisations (CBOs).<br />
• Co-sponsor research studies on age-related issues to inform national development plans and policies.<br />
For further assistance or to source a copy of the National Policy on Ageing, contact the Division of Ageing, Ministry<br />
of Social Development and Family Services, toll-free at 800-OPIC/6742 or divisionofageing@gmail.com.<br />
.<br />
CHAMBER.ORG.TT MAY <strong>2023</strong><br />
59
FREEPIK.COM<br />
60 MAY <strong>2023</strong> CHAMBER.ORG.TT
The GREEN Economy<br />
Finding balance between<br />
the planet and profits<br />
With more than 100 years of oil production, what’s next<br />
for Trinidad and Tobago? There is an urgent call by<br />
the business community to open up new sectors and<br />
diversify the economy. Can green growth deliver much<br />
needed sustainable economic development?<br />
By Rudolph Hanamji, Senior Manager -<br />
Business Development Lead Caribbean, EY<br />
Over three decades ago, a group of leading<br />
environmental economists first coined the term<br />
‘green economy’ in a pioneering report for the<br />
UK Government. This built upon research and<br />
practice in environmental economics for the last<br />
century. Subsequent work expanded the concept<br />
that economics can and should aid environmental<br />
policy by focusing on the global economy’s<br />
problems at that time and today, such as climate<br />
change, ozone depletion, tropical deforestation,<br />
and resource loss in the developing world.<br />
The standard definition of a green economy is ‘an<br />
economy in which all stakeholders – from investors<br />
to business owners to consumers – prioritise<br />
environmental stability as high as economic<br />
growth’. Put another way; it seeks to balance the<br />
planet, natural capital, and profits, financial capital.<br />
Most business leaders in Trinidad and Tobago<br />
(T&T) agree that humanity generally exists in<br />
a joint reality. Firstly, in the last 100 years, we<br />
have advanced more than all of human history,<br />
overcoming diseases, advancing technological<br />
convergence, successfully splitting seawater to<br />
produce green hydrogen, and so much more.<br />
However, simultaneously there are still close to<br />
one billion persons living in extreme poverty (with<br />
21-45 million trapped in some form of slavery), plus<br />
growing inequality, exponential climate change<br />
and biodiversity loss, with an estimated one million<br />
species threatened with extinction.<br />
While it would have been patently illogical for<br />
T&T not to take advantage of our natural resources,<br />
to develop our people and position ourselves as a<br />
global leader (despite our size), the fact that we<br />
are #17 in the top 20 CO2 emitters (metric tons per<br />
capita), should offer enough motivation to do more<br />
as we transition to a sustainable development<br />
model.<br />
CHAMBER.ORG.TT MAY <strong>2023</strong><br />
61
The GREEN Economy<br />
Like other ‘small island developing<br />
states’ (SIDS), T&T is increasingly<br />
vulnerable to natural disasters and<br />
the impacts of climate change;<br />
however, it has the unique ability to<br />
invest oil and gas earnings into green<br />
sectors and greening environmentally<br />
T&T’s Renewable<br />
Energy Transition<br />
Point Lisas continues to offer broad-based<br />
energy boons – as it promises to be a<br />
centre for hydrogen and downstream green<br />
products, given that T&T has several other<br />
critical components that can position the<br />
nation as a hub for regional green hydrogen<br />
and ammonia.<br />
In November 2022 the ‘Roadmap for a<br />
Green Hydrogen Economy in T&T’ was<br />
launched by the Ministry of Energy and<br />
Energy Industries (MEEI), after a year-long<br />
study by the National Energy Corporation of<br />
Trinidad and Tobago Ltd, the Inter-American<br />
Development Bank (IDB) and KBR Inc. The<br />
summary findings support T&T expanding<br />
and augmenting its energy portfolio with<br />
low-carbon products, and investing in the<br />
upstream development of the hydrogen<br />
value chain. This will help T&T meet its 2030<br />
Paris Agreement decarbonisation goals, and<br />
offer revolutionary investment options for<br />
small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs)<br />
and individuals.<br />
unfriendly ones<br />
Placing the environment at the centre of social and economic<br />
development<br />
Like other ‘small island developing states’ (SIDS), T&T is increasingly<br />
vulnerable to natural disasters and the impacts of climate change;<br />
however, it has the unique ability to invest oil and gas earnings into<br />
green sectors and greening environmentally unfriendly ones.<br />
Theme #5 of our national development plan – ‘Vision 2030’ – is ‘Placing<br />
the Environment at the Centre of Social and Economic Development’.<br />
Therein, it is stated that “as a responsible member of the global<br />
community, Trinidad and Tobago will continue to support international<br />
efforts to tackle shared environmental challenges which include climate<br />
change... biodiversity loss... as these issues also affect the wellbeing of<br />
our nation. Protection and wise use of our environment and growing of<br />
our economy are complementary and, therefore, innovative solutions<br />
are necessary to mutually reinforce the environment and the economy.<br />
In order to secure national prosperity, every effort will be made to<br />
ensure that the economic potential of this country is realised without<br />
jeopardising the integrity, diversity or productivity of our environment.”<br />
Further, the revised National Environmental Policy (NEP) (2018),<br />
outlines six priorities critical to achieving environmental sustainability<br />
(aligned to the UN’s Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)). Priority 4:<br />
‘Evolving a Green Economy’ outlines policy actions to support economic<br />
transformation through greening existing and new economic activities<br />
while generating green jobs.<br />
T&T’s green economy grade: 40%<br />
The average of T&T’s scores from the ‘Green Economy Tracker’ is ~42<br />
per cent, which some may deem a ‘fail’, and others a ‘bare pass’. It is<br />
certainly far from an ‘A’.<br />
In each pillar, there is room for public agencies, private corporations,<br />
and the citizenry to effect change - if we are to leverage the untapped<br />
potential of the Green Economy. It should be noted that T&T’s<br />
highest score (4/5) was for ‘safe and accountable banks’, followed<br />
by ‘small business support’, ‘participatory policymaking’, ‘innovative<br />
social protection’, and ‘ocean and land conservation’, all receiving 3/5.<br />
These areas bode well for green business development and growth<br />
opportunities.<br />
62 MAY <strong>2023</strong> CHAMBER.ORG.TT
The GREEN Economy<br />
Local Green Enterprises (LGEs)<br />
Local Green Enterprises (LGEs) - a form of ‘social enterprise’<br />
- sustainably leverages natural resources to create social,<br />
environmental, and economic benefits for all stakeholders.<br />
T&T was the home of the Santa Cruz Declaration, which was<br />
a “call to action from manufacturers, producers, business<br />
owners, entrepreneurs, innovators, and local communities in<br />
recognition of the vital importance of smaller businesses to<br />
addressing global challenges.”<br />
A few well-known LGEs are PlastiKeep, the Fondes<br />
Amandes Community Reforestation Project, and IAM<br />
Movement. Private sector for-profit enterprises (e.g.<br />
HADCO Experiences) are beginning to identify as LGEs,<br />
and myriad prospects exist in renewable energy, green<br />
buildings, sustainable transport, water management, waste<br />
management, and land management.<br />
Several multi-million USD facilities and projects exist in the<br />
regional market, which would welcome private investors and<br />
joint implementation between the private and public sectors.<br />
Green is the new black gold<br />
The green economy aligns perfectly with the Environmental,<br />
Social and Governance (ESG) strategies that corporations are<br />
rapidly adopting in response to shareholder and consumer<br />
demands – which are equally calling for the replacement of<br />
black energy (oil and coal) with ‘green’ alternatives, such as<br />
green hydrogen and renewables.<br />
Therefore, it is important that all stakeholders unite behind<br />
business solutions that will ensure a sustainable future for<br />
T&T, the Caribbean region, and the world.<br />
03<br />
<br />
01<br />
02<br />
04<br />
Encourages more<br />
sustainable development :<br />
facilitates setting and achieving<br />
sustainable development goals.<br />
Helps fight climate change:<br />
fosters more effective collaboration<br />
between government and the<br />
private sector to mitigate climate<br />
change.<br />
Improves the ecosystem:<br />
directly increases conservation<br />
of biodiversity.<br />
Increases equity:<br />
encourages equity<br />
for all.<br />
Clean transit<br />
options: mandated<br />
resource efficiency in<br />
all sectors, including<br />
transportation.<br />
<br />
<br />
01<br />
Green building<br />
standards: sustainable<br />
architecture and construction.<br />
Renewable energy<br />
sources: renewables<br />
powering transportation,<br />
manufacturing, and<br />
production processes.<br />
04<br />
Sustainable management<br />
of resources: recycling<br />
resources (circular production)<br />
and aiming for maximum<br />
sustainability.<br />
03<br />
02<br />
Source: MasterClass<br />
CHAMBER.ORG.TT MAY <strong>2023</strong><br />
63
Advertorial<br />
64 MAY <strong>2023</strong> CHAMBER.ORG.TT
Economic Outlook<br />
Economic outlook:<br />
tracking recovery and growth<br />
after the pandemic<br />
Growth in Latin America and the Caribbean is projected to slow to 1.3 per cent in <strong>2023</strong><br />
before recovering to 2.4 per cent in 2024. Economic activity in Trinidad and Tobago is<br />
anticipated to improve in <strong>2023</strong>, bolstered by the energy sector. Here the Chamber’s Trade<br />
& Business Development Unit analyses global, regional and local economic performance.<br />
By Rianna E Paul, Manager - Trade and Business<br />
Development Unit, Trinidad and Tobago Chamber of<br />
Industry and Commerce (TTCIC)<br />
Does recovery lie ahead?<br />
The world economy<br />
The International Monetary Fund (IMF) in its World Economic<br />
Outlook (WEO) <strong>2023</strong> noted that the cumulative effects<br />
of the adverse shocks experienced in the last three years<br />
have caused confidence to remain weak across all regions.<br />
Uncertainty is high, and the balance of risks has shifted to the<br />
downside due to the collapse of confidence in Credit Suisse<br />
in March <strong>2023</strong>, which has agitated financial markets.<br />
The WEO also stated that the world economy is not currently<br />
expected to return over the medium term to the rates of<br />
growth that prevailed before the pandemic. Forecasting<br />
ahead to 2028, global growth is expected to be 3.0 per cent<br />
- the lowest medium-term growth forecast published in all<br />
WEO reports since 1990.<br />
Growth forecasts<br />
Global growth will bottom out<br />
at 2.8 per cent this year before<br />
rising modestly to 3.0 per cent<br />
in 2024.<br />
Global inflation will decrease,<br />
although more slowly than<br />
initially anticipated, from 8.7 per<br />
cent in 2022 to 7.0 per cent in<br />
<strong>2023</strong> and 4.9 per cent in 2024.<br />
World Economic Outlook <strong>2023</strong>,<br />
Internationally Monetary Fund<br />
Growth in Latin America and the<br />
Caribbean is projected to slow from<br />
an estimated 3.6 per cent in 2022 to<br />
1.3 per cent in <strong>2023</strong> before recovering<br />
somewhat to 2.4 per cent in 2024.<br />
The sharp deceleration of growth<br />
reflects efforts by the region’s monetary<br />
authorities to tame inflation and<br />
spillovers from weakening global growth.<br />
Global Economic Prospects, January<br />
<strong>2023</strong>, World Bank Group<br />
Economic activity is anticipated<br />
to improve in <strong>2023</strong>, bolstered by<br />
activity in the energy sector.<br />
Domestic inflation is likely to<br />
continue to edge up in early<br />
<strong>2023</strong>, and moderate thereafter in<br />
line with global developments.<br />
Economic Bulletin January <strong>2023</strong>,<br />
Central Bank of Trinidad and<br />
Tobago<br />
CHAMBER.ORG.TT MAY <strong>2023</strong><br />
65
Economic Outlook<br />
Latin America and the Caribbean<br />
For the emerging market and developing economies in<br />
the Latin America and Caribbean region, the IMF projects<br />
growth of 1.6 per cent in <strong>2023</strong>, 2.2 per cent in 2024 and 2.3<br />
per cent in 2028.<br />
For Latin America, the overall recovery includes countries<br />
such as Chile, Colombia, Costa Rica, and the Dominican<br />
Republic which witnessed better post-pandemic recovery<br />
than the rest of the world. Conversely, GDP growth for Mexico<br />
and Venezuela from 2019 to 2022 is not likely to be sufficient<br />
to bring those economies back to pre-pandemic levels.<br />
Table 1: Emerging market and developing economies: real GDP<br />
Selected Latin America economies<br />
Projections<br />
2019 2020 2021 2022 <strong>2023</strong> 2024 2028<br />
Costa Rica 2.4 -4.3 7.8 4.3 2.7 3.2 3.2<br />
Chile 0.7 -6.1 11.7 2.4 -1.0 1.9 2.5<br />
Colombia 3.2 -7.3 11.0 7.5 1.0 1.9 3.3<br />
Dominican<br />
Republic<br />
5.1 -6.7 12.3 4.9 4.2 5.0 5.0<br />
Mexico -0.2 -8.0 4.7 3.1 1.8 1.6 1.8<br />
Panama 3.0 -17.9 15.3 10.0 5.0 4.0 4.0<br />
Venezuela -27.7 -30.0 0.5 8.0 5.0 4.5 -<br />
Source: International Monetary Fund<br />
Growth in Caribbean economies depends on an ongoing<br />
resurgence in the tourism sector and investments in the<br />
energy sector.<br />
For Trinidad and Tobago and Guyana, increased energy<br />
production and higher international commodity prices are<br />
expected to drive recovery. The IMF’s Staff Concluding<br />
Statement published in September 2022 noted that Guyana<br />
was poised for accelerated growth with the start of oil<br />
production in 2019. However, the pandemic led to non-oil<br />
Gross Domestic Product (GDP) contraction, particularly in<br />
construction and services. A rebound of oil GDP in 2020 led<br />
to an overall growth of 43.5 per cent.<br />
In its Staff Concluding Statement of the <strong>2023</strong> Article IV<br />
Mission for Trinidad and Tobago, the IMF noted that real<br />
GDP is estimated to have expanded by 2.5 per cent in 2022,<br />
supported by the non-energy sector, which was partially<br />
offset by an unexpected weak performance of the energy<br />
sector. Recovery is expected to gain broad-based momentum<br />
in <strong>2023</strong> with a 3.2 per cent GDP expansion. Over the medium<br />
term, new energy projects will come into production.<br />
However, as oil and gas fields mature, potential growth will<br />
slow to 1.5 per cent.<br />
Table 2: Emerging market and developing economies: real GDP<br />
Selected Caribbean economies<br />
Projections<br />
2019 2020 2021 2022 <strong>2023</strong> 2024 2028<br />
Barbados -0.5 -13.3 -0.2 10.0 4.9 3.9 2.0<br />
Grenada 0.7 -13.8 4.7 6.0 3.7 4.1 2.8<br />
Guyana 5.4 43.5 20.1 62.3 37.2 45.3 3.3<br />
Jamaica 1.0 -9.9 4.6 4.0 2.2 2.0 1.6<br />
Suriname 1.1 -15.9 -2.7 1.3 2.3 3.0 3.0<br />
Trinidad and<br />
Tobago<br />
Source: International Monetary Fund<br />
0.1 -7.7 -1.0 2.5 3.2 2.3 1.5<br />
Globally, a fall in fuel and energy commodity prices,<br />
particularly for the United States of America, the Euro area,<br />
and Latin America, has contributed to declining global<br />
headline inflation. However, both headline and core inflation<br />
remain at double their pre-2021 levels.<br />
Domestic prices<br />
In Trinidad and Tobago, data from the<br />
Central Statistical Office’s (CSO) Index<br />
of Retail Prices showed that headline<br />
inflation moved from 4.9 per cent in June<br />
2022 to 8.0 per cent in November 2022,<br />
which was driven by high international<br />
food commodity prices, supply disruptions<br />
and adverse local weather.<br />
HANANEKOSTUDIO/SHUTTERSTOCK.COM<br />
Inflation<br />
eroded<br />
household<br />
purchasing<br />
power.<br />
66 MAY <strong>2023</strong> CHAMBER.ORG.TT
Economic Outlook<br />
Table 3: Year on year percentage (%) change<br />
in consumer prices – February <strong>2023</strong><br />
compared to February 2022<br />
Section<br />
% Change<br />
All Items 7.5<br />
Food and non-alcoholic beverages 13.8<br />
Alcoholic beverages and tobacco -0.3<br />
Clothing and footwear -0.1<br />
Housing, water, electricity, gas &<br />
other fuels<br />
2.9<br />
Home ownership 3.6<br />
Rent 1.8<br />
Water, electricity, gas & other fuels 0.0<br />
Food and non-alcoholic beverages<br />
The Index for Food and Non-Alcoholic Beverages decreased by 1.7 per<br />
cent from January <strong>2023</strong> to February <strong>2023</strong>. Contributing significantly to this<br />
decrease was the general downward movement in the prices of tomatoes,<br />
pumpkin, celery, chives, whole fresh chickens, mixed fresh seasoning,<br />
carrots, cucumbers, sweet peppers, and cabbage.<br />
However, the full impact of these price decreases was offset by the<br />
general increases in the prices of chilled or frozen beef, fresh beef, chilled<br />
or frozen pork, sweet potatoes, ochroes, fresh carite, oranges, evaporated<br />
milk, fresh king fish and melon.<br />
Going forward, inflation is expected to slow to 4.5 per cent by the end of<br />
<strong>2023</strong> and will continue declining with international prices.<br />
Furnishings, household equipment<br />
and routine maintenance of the house<br />
6.7<br />
Figure 1: Real GDP and inflation trend for Trinidad and Tobago 1980 -2028<br />
Health 1.6<br />
Transport 14.0<br />
Communication 0.2<br />
Recreation and culture 11.0<br />
Education 0.0<br />
Hotels, cafés and restaurants 10.0<br />
Miscellaneous goods and services 7.4<br />
Source: Central Statistical Office<br />
Domestic inflation is likely<br />
to continue to edge up in<br />
early <strong>2023</strong>, and moderate<br />
thereafter in line with global<br />
developments.<br />
Source: International Monetary Fund Data Mapper, April <strong>2023</strong><br />
CHAMBER.ORG.TT MAY <strong>2023</strong><br />
67
Chamber Events<br />
<strong>2023</strong><br />
Annual Business Meeting Panel<br />
The Chamber hosted its<br />
Annual Business Meeting (ABM)<br />
on April 20 th <strong>2023</strong>.<br />
The new Chamber President, Kiran Maharaj, and the Board of Directors<br />
were elected for the <strong>2023</strong> - 2024 term. International leadership coach and<br />
author Monte Wyatt delivered the keynote address, ‘The Leadership Mindset<br />
– the Discipline of Adding Zeros’, to a packed audience. An engaging panel<br />
discussion on leadership in trinidad and Tobago followed this. After the formal<br />
proceedings, Chamber members networked at the ‘Mix & Mingle’.<br />
Kiran Maharaj<br />
TTCIC President <strong>2023</strong> - 2024<br />
Monte Wyatt delivers the keynote address<br />
Election of the Board of Directors<br />
68 MAY <strong>2023</strong> CHAMBER.ORG.TT
Chamber Events<br />
Annual Business Meeting<br />
Mix and Mingle<br />
CHAMBER.ORG.TT MAY <strong>2023</strong><br />
69
For Your Bookshelf<br />
ALL BOOKS AVAILABLE ON AMAZON.COM<br />
The Amazing Race to<br />
Entrepreneurial Freedom<br />
Georgina Terry<br />
As a consultant and coach, Georgina’s expertise in<br />
aligning passion, performance and profits, helps<br />
dreamers get ready – emotionally, financially<br />
and psychologically – for their Amazing Race to<br />
Entrepreneurial Freedom. Using carefully-crafted<br />
exercises, Georgina guides readers through a<br />
thought-provoking process to help them start<br />
envisioning, thinking and taking action to create<br />
the life and business they deserve and desire.<br />
Sustainable Development<br />
Thinking it Through; Making it Happen<br />
Bhoendradatt Tewarie<br />
The articles and speeches in this book<br />
represent a poignant collection of thoughts<br />
and ideas which address the challenge of<br />
sustainable development - a major concern of<br />
the international community at this time. Written<br />
from the point of view of the Caribbean, small<br />
island developing states and the developing<br />
and emerging world, this collection focuses<br />
on sustainable development solutions through<br />
human imagination, innovation, collaboration,<br />
participation and engagement.<br />
We Like It So? The Cultural Roots<br />
of Economic Underachievement in<br />
Trinidad and Tobago<br />
Terrence W. Farrell<br />
Terrence W. Farrell explores the socio-cultural<br />
factors which have been negatively influencing<br />
the economic performance of Trinidad and<br />
Tobago and arguably the other former colonial<br />
territories in the West Indies. It is intended for a<br />
wide readership of Caribbean leaders, persons<br />
with an interest in the Caribbean, as well as<br />
economists and other social scientists exploring<br />
the resurgent area of culture and economic<br />
development.<br />
70 MAY <strong>2023</strong> CHAMBER.ORG.TT