Views
5 years ago

COLLEGE OF SOCIAL SCIENCE

COLLEGE OF SOCIAL SCIENCE

within the action arena

within the action arena consider the costs and benefits of various behaviors, and act according to their personal preferences and perceived incentives. Their aggregate patterns of interaction lead to outcomes that can be evaluated according to socially relevant criteria. Outcomes dynamically feed back to both the action arena and to higher levels, potentially causing pressures that ultimately change the rules-in-use or contextual variables, hence feeding back to change perceived incentives within the action arena. Attributes of Physical Characteristics Attributes of Community Institutions Action Arena Action Situation Actors Patterns of Interaction Source: Ostrom et al. (1994) Figure 1. Institutional Analysis and Development Framework Outcomes Strength and Appropriateness of IAD framework The IAD framework is one of highly recommended framework for students to analyze policy change aspects (Sabatier 1999; Schlager and Blomquist 1996). Individuals do strategic actions by calculating their costs and benefits based upon the information and environments. Policy change is driven by these individual actions in a certain action situation. IAD framework is useful to analyze these strategic behavior and their consequent choices as well as to address collective action problems. In addition, they 21

argue that it is a strong framework to apply at the state and local level policy change (Schlager and Blomquist 1996; see also Koontz 2005). Thus, in the land use political market, this framework is useful to analyze land use policy area at the local level. This framework has been successful to examine various policy arenas such as metropolitan organizations, rural infrastructures, ocean and lake fisheries, groundwater provision, and forest management (Gibson et al. 2000; Imperial 1999; Ostrom et al. 1994). However, there have been no studies of local land use policy change based upon this framework with few exceptions such as Koontz (2005) 30 , who used IAD framework directly for zoning issues. This is because land use policy is different from those policies that IAD have tested so far. Different types of policies produce different mechanisms and interactions on policy decision making processes (Wilson 1980). As Feiock (1999) and Lubell et al. (2005) argue, the land use policy provides distributional consequences when it is changed. There should be winners and losers because of a change of land use policy. Decision making of local land use is made up from the interactions in the local political market. As I mentioned earlier, this research is to construct a more comprehensive framework for local land use policy change using political market framework. The political market framework explains local land use policy change is the outcome from the interactions between aggregate political demands of community and aggregate supply of local governments (Lubell et al. 2005). Thus, it is useful to apply political market framework based upon the IAD framework to examine local land use policy change to preserve and provide environmental goods in local communities. Local Land Use Political Market: Theoretical Underpinnings Action Arena: Political Market, Demanders, and Suppliers The framework needs to establish the action arena in advance. Applying political market framework based on the IAD framework needs the information of numerous 30 There is a difference between Koontz’s (2005) approach and mine. Koontz explicitly said he just use organizing concept of the IAD framework, not the logics of the framework. The fact that the framework provides three variable sets that easily help researchers to categorize the variables is the motivation of his using the framework. In addition, while he used qualitative analysis on the Ohio zoning issues, this research bases on a quantitative analysis on local comprehensive plan amendments. 22

The Rural Policy - College of Social Sciences and International ...
school of social science - Hampshire College
afPE Trainee/Student Membership - College of Social Sciences and ...
speech and respect - College of Social Sciences and International ...
Community, Care and Social Sciences - City of Glasgow College
isipta '11 - College of Humanities and Social Sciences - Carnegie ...
Constitutional Fundamentals - College of Social Sciences and ...
Dia 1 - Division of Social Sciences
The Electoral Process - Social Sciences - Miami-Dade County ...
Scholars for the Community - College of Health and Social Sciences ...
December - College of Humanities and Social Sciences - California ...
The Inheritance of the Common Law - College of Social Sciences ...
Farm Diversification in England 2002 - College of Social Sciences ...
HAMLYN - College of Social Sciences and International Studies ...
Judicial Activism - College of Social Sciences and International ...
Pragmatism and Theory in English Law - College of Social Sciences ...
Part 1 - College of Social Sciences and International Studies ...
FREEDOM UNDER THE LAW - College of Social Sciences and ...
college of social sciences, health, and education ... - Xavier University
Spring 2012 • - College of Humanities and Social Sciences - Indiana ...
english law the new dimension - College of Social Sciences and ...
The state of farming of Exmoor 2004 - College of Social Sciences ...
View PDF - College of Letters, Arts, and Social Sciences - California ...
CLEP Social Sciences and History Exam Secrets: CLEP Test Review for the College Level Examination Program
Lawyer and Litigant in England - College of Social Sciences and ...
Maladministration and its Remedies - College of Social Sciences ...
Spring 2012 - College of Social and Behavioral Sciences ...
Choice and Regulation in Private Life - College of Social Sciences ...
Punishment, Prison and the Public - College of Social Sciences and ...
The British Tradition in Canadian Law - College of Social Sciences ...