Vol. 3, Issue 3 (September 2023)
- No tags were found...
Transform your PDFs into Flipbooks and boost your revenue!
Leverage SEO-optimized Flipbooks, powerful backlinks, and multimedia content to professionally showcase your products and significantly increase your reach.
Jodo Shinshu International<br />
Beyond Our World Views<br />
A Buddhist Quarterly<br />
<strong>Vol</strong>ume 3, <strong>Issue</strong> 3<br />
<strong>2023</strong>
MISSION STATEMENT<br />
Sharing with the world the deep and humbling joy of awakening to<br />
Amida Buddha’s Universal Aspiration that enables each and every<br />
person to live a spiritually fulfilled life.<br />
ABOUT THE MISSION STATEMENT<br />
This mission statement was articulated to convey a number of overarching<br />
themes and goals that this founding committee wanted to share with its readers<br />
through this quarterly journal. By introducing first-hand accounts of people<br />
who have experienced the warmth of Amida Buddha’s embracing Compassion,<br />
readers can be inspired by the message of Shinran Shonin, the founder of Jodo<br />
Shinshu Buddhism.<br />
Through these religious experiences and accounts from people around the<br />
world, it is our hope to spread the message of Amida Buddha’s Great Aspiration<br />
for all beings—despite race, color, creed, or any other divisions among us—to<br />
awaken to a life of spiritual fulfillment. When we awaken to this message of<br />
Amida’s universal embracement, each person can live in the here and now,<br />
with a sense of profound self-reflection, joy, and hope that will lead one to live<br />
in deepest gratitude for the Buddha’s benevolence.<br />
We are excited to be a part of a movement that will spread a message of<br />
unity and hope through Amida Buddha’s universal solidarity.<br />
Namo Amida Butsu.
<strong>Vol</strong>ume 3, <strong>Issue</strong> 3, Published August <strong>2023</strong><br />
Jodo Shinshu<br />
International<br />
A Buddhist Quarterly<br />
IN THIS ISSUE<br />
6 Nembutsu Landscapes<br />
Yotin Tiewtrakul<br />
8 Japan, A Few of My Favorite Things<br />
Amanda Goodwin<br />
10 Shandao: The Advocate of the Verbal Nembutsu<br />
Rev. Jérôme Ducor<br />
18 Reflections on the 800th and 850th Joint Celebration Service<br />
Rev. Yuika Hasebe
Jodo Shinshu International is published quarterly by the<br />
Jodo Shinshu International Office, a not-for-profit religious<br />
corporation.<br />
<strong>Vol</strong>ume 3, <strong>Issue</strong> 3.<br />
Content copyright © <strong>2023</strong> Jodo Shinshu International Office.<br />
No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in<br />
any form or by any means electronic or mechanical, including<br />
photocopy, recording, or any information storage or retrieval<br />
system, without written permission.<br />
Editors-in-Chief: Rev. Kodo Umezu, Rev. Ai Hironaka<br />
Committee: Rev. Yuika Hasebe, Rev. Dr. Takashi Miyaji<br />
Contributors: Rev. Jérôme Ducor, Amanda Goodwin,<br />
Rev. Yuika Hasebe, Yotin Tiewtrakul<br />
Design & Layout: Travis Suzaka<br />
Printing: Kousaisha, Tokyo, Japan<br />
Support: Rev. Kiyonobu Kuwahara, Madeline Kubo<br />
Image Sources: Upsplash, The British Museum, The<br />
Metropolitan Museum of Art, Wikipedia<br />
Jodo Shinshu International Office<br />
1710 Octavia Street, San Francisco, CA 94109, USA<br />
www.jsinternational.org<br />
EXPLANATION OF CALLIGRAPHY<br />
Concern one holds for worldly affairs surely arises from selfcentered<br />
concepts of good and evil.<br />
Nobukuni Atsushi<br />
Yomogi (mugwort, a type of aromatic herb of the composite family) is something that we happily use in<br />
the spring season to make yomogi mochi (rice cakes), but by summer, it grows so quickly that it gets out of<br />
hand. Although we may try to keep it under control by pulling it out wherever it sprouts, it seems that<br />
as soon as we pull out one seedling, another appears somewhere else. So it was that one day, I felt as if<br />
I heard the yomogi mocking me by saying,<br />
Ha, ha, ha. All that you can see is what is above the ground. We, however, are spread out and<br />
connected together like a net below the surface of the ground where you cannot see. And flowers,<br />
you know, do not bloom because they are seeking someone’s praise. They just bloom. Living their<br />
lives to the fullest, taking it to the utmost. You humans, however, live by the principle of “one’s<br />
own convenience.” To plants that produce flowers, you tell them how pretty they are, choose<br />
names for them, acknowledge them, and take good care of them. On the other hand, for those<br />
[plants] which you feel are a nuisance, you do not bother to give them names, but instead lump<br />
them together and call them “weeds” and forcibly yank them out. Even the same plant, you make<br />
the decision of whether they are good or bad according to your own convenience, and rob them<br />
of their life. In view of that, it is not just to flowering plants, but you are doing it here and there as<br />
well, are you not? Do you not think that you humans are petty, selfish creatures?<br />
Rev. Nobukuni, through nature and flowers, helped to make us aware of how Amida’s aspiration<br />
reaches us.<br />
I, through Amida Buddha’s light of wisdom that shines upon me, am made aware that I cannot<br />
help but view even people and all things according to my own convenience and moreover, that I<br />
make judgements based on only those areas that I can see, deciding whether things are good or bad<br />
according to my own convenience.<br />
(Excerpt from the Hongwanji Shuppansha publication Daijō, May 2003.)
FEATURED ARTICLE<br />
FEATURED ARTICLE<br />
Nembutsu<br />
Landscapes<br />
Yotin Tiewtrakul<br />
A personal reflection after the JSIO tour in May <strong>2023</strong><br />
6
YOTIN TIEWTRAKUL<br />
Interconnectedness is not limited to physical space. The<br />
pandemic has made us aware of that. Although we were<br />
confined to our homes, some had the opportunity to visit<br />
“everywhere” because many communities were setting up<br />
shop in the online world.<br />
The JSIO tour in May <strong>2023</strong> to Shinran’s life stations<br />
in Japan gave me the opportunity to meet people I had<br />
only seen on my computer screen. A friend back home<br />
said: Isn’t meeting in person way better? Isn’t that the<br />
“real deal”? Indeed, there are some experiences that<br />
cannot be had online. Especially singing requires the<br />
resonance of other breathing bodies and the echo of the<br />
space where the community sings. However, the online<br />
world and physical space are interconnected. Learning<br />
the Shoshinge in Rev. Enrique’s online chanting practice,<br />
meeting people online, studying, reading and sharing<br />
in the correspondence course, prepared us to meet each<br />
other in the actual landscapes of Shinran’s nembutsu<br />
teaching.<br />
It was an honour that people welcomed us in those<br />
places. The landscapes of Shinran’s years since the exile<br />
are particularly rich with stories and lore about his<br />
presence. At Koto Beach, where Shinran landed with a<br />
boat for his exile, we were shown a certain kind of reed<br />
which have their leaves only on one side. According to<br />
legend, even the reeds were grateful for Shinran’s stay in<br />
that area, so when it was time for him to leave, they did<br />
gassho towards him. (Having the leaves on only one side<br />
looks like the reed is putting its “hands” together in gassho.)<br />
I also had the pleasure of meeting Bettina Langner<br />
Teramoto in person for dinner. We are members of the<br />
German speaking Skype group that meets every other<br />
Sunday morning. Bettina is a Jodoshinshu priest, and she<br />
gifted me with a small statue depicting Amida-Sama. (It’s<br />
one of those home altar items that are donated to Bettina’s<br />
and her husband’s temple when the former owners die and<br />
their children don’t know what to do with it.) So from then<br />
on Amida-Sama travelled with me in my hand luggage.<br />
After the tour ended and we said our good-byes and<br />
“see you agains,” I had two more nights in Tokyo. During<br />
my last day, before my flight late in the evening, Amida-<br />
Sama walked with me to Shinjuku Chuo Park and Yoyogi<br />
Park, through crowded Harajuku and Shibuya. When<br />
I couldn’t cope with the crowds, we rested on a rooftop<br />
park. Obviously, the statue was carefully packaged in a<br />
box and the box was wrapped in a furoshiki. Still, the<br />
materiality took up a certain amount of room in my<br />
backpack, and I would always be conscious of the extra<br />
weight I was carrying.<br />
I think it’s good that we learn not to cling to material<br />
“tools” of our inner paths. However, the materiality of<br />
a statue, nenju beads, or incense smoke remind us that<br />
Great Compassion and Great Wisdom want to take up<br />
physical space in this world. In fact, the One Mind, made<br />
up of Amida’s wish shared with our ordinary mind filled<br />
with futile dreams, occupies space in this world (and<br />
everywhere in the ten directions) in the sound of Namo-<br />
Amida-Butsu. The wonderful thing about the materiality<br />
of sound is that it is a fleeting event. We won’t have to<br />
worry about it cluttering up our shelves or collecting dust.<br />
Therefore, when nembutsu appears, it always emerges as<br />
something fresh and new. Because it is connected to breath<br />
and voices, it will always be a living event.<br />
Everyone can imagine the worry of travelling with a<br />
small statue in their hand baggage on international flights.<br />
I wish we knew how much more “weighty” it would be<br />
to “carry” Namo-Amida-Butsu<br />
into the landscapes of our ordinary<br />
everyday lives. It is not a heavy gift<br />
we’re carrying around. Whenever<br />
it appears, through our breath and<br />
voice, we receive it and share it with<br />
others at the same time, since it comes<br />
not from us, but from One Mind.<br />
The places where we are in our daily<br />
everyday lives can become nembutsu<br />
landscapes as well.<br />
About the Author<br />
Yotin Tiewtrakul<br />
Yotin Tiewtrakul was born in Thailand<br />
and grew up in Hamburg, Germany,<br />
where he works as a musician in the<br />
prison chaplaincy. He is connected to<br />
the Nembutsu path via the Jodo Shinshu<br />
Correspondence Course and networks in<br />
Europe.<br />
7
POETRY<br />
Japan,<br />
A Few Of<br />
My Favorite Things<br />
Amanda Goodwin<br />
I recently had the opportunity to visit the breath-taking Japan, along with a Jodo Shinshu Tour Group, to celebrate 850th<br />
anniversary of Shinran Shonin’s birth and the 800th anniversary of the Jodo Shinshu tradition. We visited places such as<br />
Kyoto, Kanazawa and Tokyo stopping by places where Shinran Shonin himself did. I have attempted a poem, entitled:<br />
Japan, A Few of My Favorite Things.<br />
8
AMANDA GOODWIN<br />
Itadakimasu.<br />
I think of Shinran.<br />
To Tokyo skyscrapers.<br />
About the Author<br />
Arigato Gozaimasu.<br />
An invitation to learn.<br />
Every inch being used.<br />
What I heard the most.<br />
Inspired, thankful.<br />
Smart! I’ll try at home.<br />
Namo Amida Butsu<br />
Namo Amida Butsu.<br />
I bow deeply to<br />
too, of course. Embraced.<br />
And, the people! So friendly!<br />
the causes and conditions;<br />
Following in his footsteps,<br />
An O-nenju breaks,<br />
those who spent their time.<br />
The Shinran Shonin.<br />
People spring from seats<br />
Namo Amida Butsu.<br />
Amanda Goodwin<br />
Deeper understanding, and<br />
some new dharma friends.<br />
to collect the now loose beads.<br />
Impermanence, right?<br />
I could go on and on, but<br />
I shall wrap it up.<br />
Amanda Goodwin was born and raised<br />
in Spokane, WA. Never knowing about a<br />
Buddhist Temple in her hometown, she<br />
discovered the Spokane Buddhist Temple in<br />
Namo Amida Butsu.<br />
Temples, awe-inspiring;<br />
giving connection.<br />
Dharma friends replace…<br />
gratitude and compassion.<br />
In the moment, joy.<br />
The meals! Exquisite!<br />
Yes, every detail thought of.<br />
Japan, meal for souls.<br />
her late 20s. Learning about Jodo Shinshu<br />
and being welcomed by the Sangha,<br />
immediately awakened a desire within her<br />
to learn more. She was supported through<br />
school by her local temple/sangha and was<br />
A rich history.<br />
I long for my family,<br />
feeling far away.<br />
Lush green mountain tops<br />
Peaceful hot springs in nature.<br />
It’s in stark contrast,<br />
Namo Amida Butsu.<br />
Na man da bu. Na man dats.<br />
Namo Amida Butsu.<br />
installed as a Ministers Assistant at the<br />
Spokane Buddhist Temple in January of<br />
this year. She looks forward to continuing<br />
on the journey of the Jodo Shinshu path<br />
and is working towards attaining Tokudo<br />
ordination.<br />
9
FEATURED ARTICLE<br />
Shandao<br />
The Advocate of the<br />
Verbal Nembutsu<br />
Rev. Jérôme Ducor<br />
Author’s Note: Many thanks to Dr. Helen Loveday for checking my English.<br />
Shandao. Edo period. Wood sculpture with traces of color and gilt and inset glass eyes.<br />
The Metropolitan Museum of Art.<br />
10
REV. JÉRÔME DUCOR<br />
Shandao (613-681), Jap. Zendō, occupies a very special<br />
place among the Seven Eminent Masters, since he<br />
has left his name to the Chinese tradition of the Pure<br />
Land initiated by Tanluan and Daochuo, which Hōnen<br />
rediscovered in Japan and which his disciple Shinran<br />
inherited. As a matter of fact, Hōnen asserted: “I rely<br />
entirely on Master Shandao alone” (Senjakushū), while<br />
Shinran declared: “If Shandao’s comments are true, how<br />
could Hōnen’s teachings be in vain? If Hōnen’s teachings<br />
are true, what I, Shinran, say cannot be meaningless<br />
either, can it?” (Tannishō).<br />
Shinran would go even further, stating: “Shandao<br />
alone clarified the true intention of the Buddha” (Shōshinge).<br />
This needs some explanation!<br />
Shandao left five works, both doctrinal and liturgical,<br />
the most important of which is his Commentary on the Sūtra<br />
of Contemplations on the Buddha Immeasurable-Life (Kangyō-sho).<br />
His contribution focuses in particular on his definition<br />
of the arrangement of this text, i.e. the way in which its<br />
various parts are divided up, and their respective values.<br />
The first part is the Prologue, which recounts the<br />
tragedy of Queen Vaidehī, imprisoned by her own<br />
son, Ajātaśatru, who had just deposed his father, king<br />
Bimbisāra, to usurp the throne. In despair, the queen,<br />
while in jail, asked the Buddha Śākyamuni to show her<br />
a place free of affliction where she could be reborn. The<br />
Buddha then showed her in detail all the Buddha realms<br />
of the present in the ten directions. Immediately, the queen<br />
unhesitatingly chose the realm “Supreme Happiness” of<br />
the Buddha Amida and asked Śākyamuni to teach her the<br />
manner in which to contemplate it.<br />
This is where the Main Part of the sūtra begins. It<br />
starts with what Shandao calls “meditative good deeds”<br />
Shandao alone clarified the<br />
true intention of the Buddha.<br />
( jōzen), i.e. a series of thirteen contemplations set out by<br />
Śākyamuni to visualise the Pure Land of Amida not only<br />
with its scenery but also its inhabitants, including the<br />
Buddha Amida and his two assistants, the Bodhisattvas<br />
Kannon and Seishi.<br />
In the second half of the Main Part, Śākyamuni<br />
teaches Vaidehī various methods for being born after<br />
death in the Pure Land. These are non-meditative good<br />
deeds (sanzen) that adapt to the faculties of ordinary<br />
beings, who are divided into nine categories. In the first<br />
five categories, beings, whether of the Greater or Smaller<br />
Vehicle, transfer the merits they acquire in their practice<br />
by dedicating them to their birth in the Pure Land. In the<br />
last four categories, beings who are not even Buddhists<br />
meet a Buddhist good friend at the moment of death, and<br />
this friend exhorts them towards the Pure Land of Amida.<br />
The last category is that of “the lower beings of the<br />
lower class” who have committed the worst perversions,<br />
including matricide and parricide, but with the exception<br />
of slandering the Buddhist Law. They are not even able to<br />
think of the Buddha Amida, but their good friend makes<br />
them pronounce His Name ten times, and they are born<br />
in the Pure Land. This last passage thus embodies the<br />
height of Buddhist compassion and the ease of the Pure<br />
Land method, which had already so fascinated Tanluan<br />
(JSIO Magazine 3-1).<br />
After the Prologue and the Main Part, it is customary<br />
for a sūtra to include a section known as the Diffusion, in<br />
which the Buddha entrusts to a prominent member of the<br />
audience the teaching he has just preached so that he can<br />
pass it on to future generations.<br />
That said, all the masters who commented on this<br />
sūtra before Shandao considered that the heart of this text<br />
11
FEATURED ARTICLE - SHANDAO: THE ADVOCATE OF THE VERBAL NEMBUTSU<br />
Honen Shonin and Shandao. 19th century.<br />
Hanging scroll; Ink and colour on silk. The<br />
British Museum.<br />
was indeed its Main Part with the methods of visualising<br />
the Pure Land and Amida, as the title of the sūtra itself<br />
indicates: Sūtra of Contemplations on the Buddha Immeasurable-Life.<br />
And it is precisely here that Shandao’s genius comes<br />
to the fore. For him, it is not the long Main Part that<br />
constitutes the essential part of the Sūtra of Contemplations,<br />
but rather the short Diffusion! More specifically, here is the<br />
passage retained by Shandao:<br />
“The Buddha declared to Ānanda: ‘You, keep these<br />
words well! To keep these words is to keep the name of<br />
the Buddha Immeasurable-Life’.”<br />
Shandao’s comment deserves to be quoted in full:<br />
“This passage clearly shows the transmission of the<br />
name of Amida [to Ānanda] and its transmission<br />
to distant generations. Until then, [the Buddha<br />
Śākyamuni] had expounded the benefits of the dual<br />
method of meditative good deeds and non-meditative<br />
good deeds; but from the point of view of the Buddha<br />
[Amida]s’ primal vow, the intention [of the Sūtra of<br />
Contemplations] is that beings should unilaterally and<br />
exclusively pronounce (shō) the name of the Buddha<br />
Amida.” (Kangyō-sho, IV, § 34).<br />
It is in this sense that Shinran could state that “Shandao<br />
alone clarified the true intention of the Buddha”, or<br />
… “the Buddhas”. In other words, and this is Shandao’s<br />
originality, the latter interprets the Sūtra of Contemplations in the<br />
light of the Larger Sūtra on the Buddha Immeasurable-Life with the<br />
vows. But there is more. For the keeping of Amida’s name<br />
is also at the heart of the method of the Sūtra of Amida, so<br />
that Shandao would identify a doctrine common to all<br />
three sūtras, which prompted him to bring them together<br />
under the overall title “Sūtras of Birth in the Pure Land”<br />
(Ōjōkyō). These are the sūtras that Hōnen later entitled<br />
“Sūtras of the Pure Land Trilogy” (Jōdo Sambukyō).<br />
According to Shandao, their common doctrine lies in the<br />
fact that birth in the Pure Land is achieved through “the<br />
exclusive commemoration of the name of the Buddha<br />
Amida” (Kangyō-sho, III, § 12).<br />
The term commemoration (nen), found also in the<br />
expression “commemorating the Buddha” (nembutsu), is<br />
ambiguous, as it can be contemplative or recitative in<br />
nature. However, as is clear from Shandao’s quote above,<br />
for him, in the final count, the nembutsu was clearly of<br />
a recitative nature. In fact, he had taken up his master<br />
Daochuo’s interpretation of the 18th vow of Amida, which<br />
Shandao reformulated as follows: “If I should attain<br />
Buddhahood, and beings of the Ten Directions wishing<br />
to be born in my realm pronounce my name down to ten<br />
nembutsu, and should they not be born there, I would not<br />
take the perfect Awakening.”<br />
It should be pointed out that some Western authors<br />
have taken the view that, in spite of evidence, Shandao’s<br />
teaching was in fact a contemplative nembutsu (kannen)<br />
and not a recitative nembutsu (shōnen). The definitive<br />
answer is provided by Shandao himself:<br />
“Contemplation is difficult to accomplish because of<br />
the gravity of the obstacles of beings, the fineness of<br />
the object to be contemplated, the coarseness of their<br />
minds, the restlessness of their consciousness and the<br />
flights of their spirits. This is why the compassion<br />
of the Great Saint [Śākyamuni] directly exhorts us<br />
12
REV. JÉRÔME DUCOR<br />
to pronounce the name exclusively. For this good<br />
reason that the pronunciation of the name is easy, by<br />
pursuing it, we shall be born in the Pure Land.”<br />
This brings us to another important contribution by<br />
Shandao. He did not feel the need for a new classification<br />
of the Buddha’s teachings, after the one defined by<br />
Daochuo: all the teachings of Śākyamuni belongs either to<br />
the Method of the path of the saints or to the Method of<br />
the Pure Land. Instead, Shandao was keen to classify the<br />
various practices of Pure Land.<br />
He first divides all practices into “proper practices”,<br />
i.e. practices specific to the Pure Land (shōgyō), and all<br />
other practices, which he describes as sundry practices<br />
(zōgyō). There are five practices specific to the Pure Land,<br />
which are to be cultivated exclusively and from a single<br />
heart: 1° to recite the Three Pure Land Sūtras, 2° to perceive<br />
the ornaments of the Pure Land’s scenery as well as of the<br />
Buddha Amida and his Bodhisattvas, 3° to worship this<br />
Buddha, 4° to name Him vocally (ku shō), 5° to praise Him<br />
by making offerings.<br />
Of these five proper practices, Shandao explains the<br />
fourth as consisting of “commemorating the name of<br />
Amida” and he calls it the “act of true settlement” (shōjōgō),<br />
while the other four proper practices are qualified as<br />
“auxiliary acts” ( jogō). “True settlement” is understood<br />
in two ways. First of all, this act has been settled by the<br />
Vow of the Buddha Amida itself. Secondly, this act settles<br />
definitively the birth of the follower in the Pure Land.<br />
For Shandao, however, this practical dimension<br />
(kigyō) is only one of the two dimensions of the nembutsu,<br />
its second dimension being faith or, in his own words,<br />
tranquil confidence (anjin). It has two inseparable facets.<br />
The first one is the deep conviction that we are ourselves<br />
ordinary beings with the evil of our faults, always<br />
transmigrated in the cycle of births and deaths for long<br />
cosmic periods.<br />
The second facet is the deep conviction with which<br />
we entrust to the forty-eight vows, expounded in the Larger<br />
Sūtra, whose power will ensure that we shall be born in the<br />
Pure Land. According to Shandao, this second facet is also<br />
the deep conviction that in the Sūtra of Contemplations, the<br />
Buddha Śākyamuni attests to and praises the ornaments of<br />
the Buddha Amida and His Pure Land, so that beings may<br />
aspire to be born there. Finally, this second facet is also<br />
the deep conviction that in the Sūtra of Amida, the Buddhas<br />
of the ten directions are presently exhorting all ordinary<br />
beings by attesting that they will necessarily be born in the<br />
Pure Land of Amida. Here we find a combination bringing<br />
together the Buddha Amida, the Buddha Śākyamuni<br />
and the Buddhas of the ten directions that is typical of<br />
Shandao, while paralleling them with each of the Three Pure<br />
Land Sūtras. This combination is also found in the “Triple<br />
Invitation” (Sanbujō) still used today in some services of<br />
Jōdo-Shinshū and which can be traced back to Shandao’s<br />
Hymns of Liturgy (Hōjisan).<br />
When Shinran asserts that “Shandao alone clarified<br />
the true intention of the Buddha”, it was obviously in<br />
opposition to the interpretations of the Pure Land provided<br />
by masters of traditions other than the one linking<br />
Tanluan, Daochuo and Shandao. In this respect, Shandao<br />
reformulated Daochuo’s positions with great clarity,<br />
affirming, on the one hand, that the Buddha Amida and<br />
his Pure Land are of retribution and not of transformation;<br />
and on the other hand, that the Pure Land is not to be<br />
sought within the practitioner’s own heart.<br />
We are ourselves ordinary<br />
beings with the evil of our<br />
faults, always transmigrated in<br />
the cycle of births and deaths<br />
for long cosmic periods.<br />
13
FEATURED ARTICLE - SHANDAO: THE ADVOCATE OF THE VERBAL NEMBUTSU<br />
When beings remember the<br />
Buddha, the Buddha also<br />
remembers beings.<br />
Shandao also had to respond to a very specific attack<br />
from the Idealist schools. Their masters did not accept<br />
that ordinary people could be born on a level as high as<br />
Amida’s Pure Land by means of a practice as easy as verbal<br />
nembutsu. According to them, such a nembutsu is nothing<br />
more than a pious vow, not a meritorious practice. So when<br />
the sūtras do say that these beings “are born in the Pure<br />
Land”, it would be only a figure of speech, referring to a<br />
different and indefinite time in the future (betsuji) and not<br />
to simultaneity with the time of death. This attack was<br />
all the more serious because it was based on a prestigious<br />
commentary of the Yogācāra idealist school, the Summary of<br />
the Greater Vehicle (Mahāyāna-saṃgraha) by the Indian master<br />
Asaṅga (4th C.E.).<br />
Shandao answered with an exegesis of the nembutsu<br />
for which he is famous. According to him, the formula of<br />
the nembutsu “Namo Amida Butsu”, as it appears in the<br />
Sūtra of Contemplations, includes not only the vow of birth in<br />
the Pure Land but also the practice necessary for this vow<br />
to be fulfilled. For him, Namo (“Reverence to”) is the vow<br />
to be born in the Pure Land, while Amida Butsu (“Buddha<br />
Amida”) is the practice needed to fulfil this vow. In other<br />
words, the fact that the Bodhisattva Dharmākara received<br />
the title “Buddha” with the proper name “Amida” testifies to<br />
the fact that His two vows concerning His own person–vows<br />
on incommensurability of His light and longevity–have been<br />
fulfilled to perfection by His practice; so that those of His<br />
other vows concerning the birth of beings in the Pure Land<br />
have also been fulfilled and His merits are summarised<br />
within the nembutsu to be shared by those who use it.<br />
All these explanations may seem somewhat dry, but<br />
Shandao indicates also in a lively way for us:<br />
“When beings remember the Buddha, the Buddha<br />
also remembers beings. The three acts [by mind,<br />
mouth and body] of beings and those of the Buddha<br />
are no longer separate. This is why nembutsu is called<br />
‘affinity of intimacy’.”<br />
*<br />
Shandao lived during the brilliant Tang dynasty, at a<br />
time that can be considered the golden age of Buddhism<br />
in China. Information on the first part of his life is<br />
scarce and sometimes contradictory. During his youth,<br />
various events occurred without it being possible to<br />
verify their exact order. On the one hand, he discovered<br />
the method of the Pure Land when he saw one of the<br />
painted representations of it that were widespread at the<br />
time. Secondly, having received full monastic ordination<br />
(not before his twentieth year), he studied the Sūtra of the<br />
Contemplations with master Miaokai 妙 開 in order to put<br />
into practice the various meditations set out in this text.<br />
His search also led him to Mount Lushan (Jiangxi prov.).<br />
It was here, in 402, that the famous Huiyuan (334-416)<br />
had founded a community whose members, monks and<br />
laypeople alike, followed the path of the Pure Land based<br />
on the Sūtra of Samādhi of face-to-face contact with the Buddhas<br />
of the present. In this respect, the works composed by<br />
Shandao show that his first practice was precisely this type<br />
of meditation (samādhi) enabling contact to be made from<br />
our universe with a Buddha presently preaching in his<br />
own Buddha field, such as the Buddha Amida. His efforts<br />
were eventually crowned with success as he managed to<br />
visualize the setting of the Pure Land and attain samādhi.<br />
14
REV. JÉRÔME DUCOR<br />
Portrait of Shandao Dashi (Zendo<br />
Daishi). Nanbokucho period, 14th century.<br />
Hanging scroll; ink, color and gold on silk.<br />
Wikipedia.<br />
But his quest was not to end there. Having heard of<br />
Daochuo, he went to seek him out at the Xuanzhongsi<br />
temple and became his disciple. Various cross-checks<br />
place this event around 633-636, the master being in his<br />
seventies at the time, while the disciple was only a little<br />
over twenty years old.<br />
Because he has realized samādhi, Shandao did not<br />
feel the need for a human lineage from master to disciple,<br />
and his works do not even mention the name of Daochuo.<br />
Instead, Shandao concludes his famous Commentary with<br />
these words: “Whoever wishes to copy it should do so<br />
entirely as if it were a sūtra!”<br />
After the death of Daochuo, he began an intense<br />
period of preaching in the capital Chang’an itself. To<br />
achieve his goal, he used all kinds of original means,<br />
including artistic ones. He copied, or had copied, countless<br />
reproductions of the Sūtra of Amida, commissioned<br />
numerous painted representations of the Pure Land and<br />
created original liturgies, all the while working to restore<br />
Buddhist temples and monuments. According to the<br />
chronicles, his work was such that “three years after his<br />
arrival, nembutsu filled the city of Chang’an”.<br />
Shandao went down in history as an austere monk,<br />
begging for food, avoiding looking up at women and<br />
accepting no marks of respect. During his last thirty years,<br />
he did not even have a fixed residence and moved alone<br />
from one temple to another, the most famous being the<br />
Guangmingsi 光 明 寺 (Kōmyōji). Such was his reputation<br />
that emperor Gaozong honoured Shandao by choosing<br />
him as one of the two superintendents for the construction<br />
of the monumental statue of the Buddha Vairocana in<br />
Longmen, which was unveiled in 672.<br />
15
FEATURED ARTICLE - SHANDAO: THE ADVOCATE OF THE VERBAL NEMBUTSU<br />
Shandao died on the 14th day of the 3rd moon of the 2nd year of Yonglong<br />
(681). He left few personal disciples. Among them, Huaiyun 懷 惲 (640-701)<br />
erected a funerary monument to him, the origin of today’s Xiangjisi 香 積 寺<br />
temple in Chang’an, with its impressive “Shandao Pagoda” reaching a height of<br />
one hundred and eight feet.<br />
Japanese iconography most often depicts Shandao reciting the nembutsu:<br />
standing, hands clasped in gasshō, with small buddhas sometimes protruding<br />
from his mouth. Occasionally he is depicted with the lower half of his costume<br />
gold-coloured, like a Buddha, and the upper half black, like a monk. This is the<br />
form in which Shandao appeared in a dream to Hōnen, the last of the Seven<br />
Eminent Masters, to confirm the correctness of his teaching.<br />
In Jōdo-Shinshū, Shandao is depicted in a very similar way to Tanluan:<br />
sitting on a temple chair, dressed in Chinese monastic costume, and holding a<br />
fly swatter in his right hand.<br />
*<br />
In addition to the Commentary on the Sūtra of Contemplations, Shandao’s works<br />
include the Hymns in Praise of Birth in the Pure Land (Ōjō raisange), which are still<br />
recited in some services at Hongwanji; the Hymns of Liturgy (Hōjisan), which<br />
includes a commentary on the Sūtra of Amida; the Method of Contemplation on<br />
the Buddha Amida (Kannen bōmon), which provides not only visualization of the<br />
Buddha Amida but also advices on preparing and encouraging the dying; the<br />
Hymns on the Pratyutpanna-Samādhi (Hanjusan).<br />
FURTHER READINGS<br />
Chappell, David Wellington: “The Formation of the Pure Land Movement in China: Tao-ch’o<br />
and Shan-tao”; in The Pure Land Tradition: History and Development (ed. by James Foard,<br />
Michael Solomon and Richard K. Payne; Berkeley Buddhist Study Series, 3; 1996), p.<br />
139-171.<br />
Fujiwara, Ryōsetsu: The Way to Nirvana, The Concept of the Nembutsu in Shan-tao’s Pure Land Buddhism;<br />
Tôkyô, Kyōiku Shinchō Sha, 1974.<br />
- Shandao’s works translated by Hisao (Zuio) Inagaki:<br />
Shan-tao’s Kannenbōmon, The Method of Contemplation on Amida (Pure Land Bilingual Series, 1);<br />
Kyoto, Nagata Bunshodo, 2005.<br />
“Liturgy for Birth (Ojoraisan), Compiled by Monk Shan-tao”; The Pure Land, Journal of Pure Land<br />
Buddhism, New Series, No. 17 (IASBS, Dec. 2000), p. 122-195.<br />
“Hanjusan: Hymns Praising Pure Land Birth by Explaining the Method of Practice of the<br />
Pratyutpanna Samâdhi based on the Contemplation Sutra and Others, by Bhiksu Shantao”;<br />
Ryūkoku Daigaku Ronshū, no. 434-435 (Nov. 1989), p. 73-144.<br />
About the Author<br />
Rev. Jérôme Ducor<br />
Rev. Jérôme Ducor is the minister in charge of the Shingyôji<br />
temple (Geneva). He has been teaching Buddhism at McGill<br />
(Montreal) and at the universities of Geneva and Lausanne,<br />
besides being the curator of the Asia Department at the<br />
Geneva Museum. He is the author of various Buddhist<br />
publications, including a translation of Tanluan’s Commentary<br />
and his own book, Shinran and Pure Land Buddhism.<br />
16
17
FEATURED ARTICLE<br />
Reflections on the<br />
800th and 850th<br />
Joint Celebration Service<br />
Rev. Yuika Hasebe<br />
18
REV. YUIKA HASEBE<br />
The huge Founder’s Hall of Nishi Hongwanji in Kyoto was<br />
filled with people who didn’t hide their great excitement<br />
and joy. As we finally started to see the dissipation of the<br />
worldwide pandemic COVID-19, people were finally<br />
able to meet their longtime friends and enjoy the reunion<br />
by shaking each other’s hands, hugging one another and<br />
taking selfies. The fellow travelers of Nembutsu from all<br />
over the world, including the US mainland and Hawaii,<br />
Canada, Brazil, and from small villages to big cities of<br />
Japan, many gathered at the hall waiting for the once in a<br />
lifetime precious joint celebration.<br />
The clear ringing sound of kansho (calling bell)<br />
resounded throughout the hall and in the hearts of the<br />
excited attendees. The atmosphere immediately changed<br />
to a quiet and solemn deep appreciation. People of all<br />
different ages, gender identities, ethnicities and cultural<br />
backgrounds, all together bowed their heads in gassho<br />
(placing palms together) with a gesture of humble<br />
gratitude toward Amida Buddha. The special ceremony<br />
opened with a serene beauty.<br />
Shin Buddhism was developed in Japan, and the<br />
tradition traveled to many different countries and regions.<br />
In many cases, the teaching traveled with the immigrants<br />
who had a Japanese ancestral background. Like a flower<br />
that entrusts its precious seeds to the winds to find a new<br />
land to spread its beauty, the immigrants transmitted this<br />
precious teaching, treasuring and planting it in various<br />
lands. The seed of the teaching has now sprouted, grown,<br />
and has becomes the beautiful blooming flower. The<br />
beautiful flower of Nembutsu touches the people of the<br />
new land. Those people who are touched by its beauty<br />
have now gathered where this beautiful flower originated,<br />
which is Kyoto, Japan.<br />
The seed of the teaching has<br />
now sprouted, grown, and<br />
has becomes the beautiful<br />
blooming flower.<br />
In the year of <strong>2023</strong>, the Jodo Shinshu Hongwanjiha<br />
Buddhist organization, Ryukokuzan Hongwanji<br />
(also known as Nishi Hongwanji) commemorates its<br />
founder, Shinran Shonin’s 850th birthday and the 800th<br />
anniversary of the establishment of the Jodo Shinshu<br />
tradition. The members from various countries and from<br />
different regions of Japan made a great effort to plan<br />
for this pilgrimage to join the ceremony, and the Nishi<br />
Hongwanji took even greater measures to ensure the<br />
welcoming of the devoted fellow travelers. The celebration<br />
was held for 30 days, from March until May of <strong>2023</strong>.<br />
The founder, Shinran Shonin, was born in Japan<br />
in 1173 and is considered one of the most innovative<br />
religious leaders of the Kamakura period. His religious<br />
and personal endeavors created a great social reformation<br />
by re-examining the hierarchical system of Japan at the<br />
time and bucked the status quo by revealing a path of<br />
salvation for all people regardless of their social standing,<br />
but Shinran Shonin himself had never proclaimed the<br />
establishment of a new religious order. However, after<br />
the completion of the first draft of his main work, one of<br />
the most important scriptures of all Jodo Shin Buddhists,<br />
entitled, “Ken jodo shinjitsu kyogyosho monrui” or The<br />
True Teaching, Practice, and Realization of the Pure Land Way,<br />
his followers considered this as the establishment of a new<br />
tradition. These two separate celebrations of 850 years<br />
since the birth of Shinran Shonin and 800 years since the<br />
establishment of this religious institution, is a momentous<br />
opportunity for Shin Buddhists to reconfirm our faith<br />
and reflect on the meaning of a life that is embraced by<br />
the Great Compassion of Amida Buddha. From the time<br />
of Shinran Shonin, numerous people risked their lives to<br />
protect the teaching and passed this down from generation<br />
19
FEATURED ARTICLE - REFLECTIONS ON THE 800TH AND 850TH JOINT CELEBRATION SERVICE<br />
to generation with the hope that their successors would<br />
also be able to live in deep gratitude with a profound<br />
level of happiness in Amida Buddha’s embrace. Through<br />
those countless predecessors, the string of the Dharma<br />
penetrates 850 years of time and reached us who live in<br />
the world today.<br />
On the completion of the celebration on May 21,<br />
which was the day of Shinran Shonin’s birthday, the<br />
24th Monshu Kojun Ohtani shared his message. In his<br />
message, Monshu Kojun Ohtani wrote the following:<br />
Being embraced and illuminated by Amida Buddha’s<br />
light of Wisdom, we are now made to realize our<br />
true nature of possessing heavy karmic evil and<br />
blind passions, which we were not aware of before.<br />
However, at the same time, we come to awaken to<br />
Amida Buddha’s Great virtue.<br />
We come to see that we are embraced by Amida<br />
Buddha, where our sorrow is accepted as Amida<br />
Buddha’s sorrow. This makes us realize that we should<br />
recompense our evil actions and blind passions, by<br />
trying to leave the mind of attachment, even just a little.<br />
It is a transformation from a self-centered life, which<br />
only focuses on one’s personal peace and tranquility,<br />
to a life of living together with others by sharing each<br />
other’s pain. From that transformation, we reflect<br />
upon Amida Buddha’s Great Wisdom and Great<br />
Compassion as the true guidance, and it opens us to<br />
the path in accord with the true guidance to the life of<br />
the Nembutsu follower.<br />
(Hasebe translation)<br />
The world is spinning faster more than ever, and we<br />
are riding the fastest roller coaster running through the<br />
darkness, not knowing where our goal is or where we are<br />
headed. Is this not the reality of our world now? When<br />
such reality is considered, this Joint celebration gives us<br />
another perspective. This ceremony was not intended<br />
only for us to reflect on the past and appreciate our<br />
predecessors, but also to serve us as a milestone in our own<br />
journeys. We acknowledge that as we move forward we<br />
will keep planting the seed of Nembutsu for generations to<br />
come.<br />
20
We are still living in a world where we hold many weapons and hurt others<br />
often under the banner of protecting “our people.” We are still living in a<br />
world where people die due to hunger and sickness, where only certain people<br />
can have access to certain treatments while others cannot. We are living in a<br />
human societies based upon materialism and unfairness. As Monshu Kojun<br />
Ohtani wrote, there needs to be a shift from a self-centered way of life which<br />
only focuses on personal peace and tranquility. While we focus on inner-peace<br />
at the same time, we need to open our eyes to the community and world as well.<br />
The world needs to hear the message of Amida Buddha’s Great Compassion<br />
more than ever. The efforts toward internal cultivation and the approach to<br />
the external world should not be considered an “either-or” or “now or later”<br />
situation, where we prioritize one over the other. Rather, both internal and<br />
external effort be pursued simultaneously. This ceremony can be considered as<br />
the opening or start of this new endeavor.<br />
For Shin Buddhists who live in this modern society we have to face a world<br />
that Shinran Shonin probably never imagined. Nevertheless, the teaching he<br />
reveals to us will never fade and is still shining ever more brightly, and it will<br />
be a strong foundation and support for our contemporary life. Guided by Amida<br />
Buddha’s Great Compassion, let’s make this new endeavor a fruitful one.<br />
Want to learn more about JSIO?<br />
About the Author<br />
Rev. Yuika Hasebe<br />
Rev. Yuika Hasebe is the Head minister of Honpa Hongwanji<br />
Hawaii Betsuin. She graduated from Ryukoku University and<br />
started her career as a minister in 2007. She has also served<br />
at Hilo Betsuin and Hawaii Betsuin as an associate and head<br />
minister respectively.<br />
Visit jsinternational.org<br />
Free Publications<br />
Correspondance Course Info<br />
View Past Journal <strong>Issue</strong>s<br />
21
EDITOR’S POSTSCRIPT<br />
Thank you very much for reading this issue of the JSIO quarterly journal.<br />
I would also like to express my heartfelt gratitude to the contributing authors.<br />
In June, I visited Hongwanji Temple in Kyoto for the Joint Celebration<br />
of Shinran Shonin’s 850th birthday and the 800th Anniversary of the<br />
Establishment of the Jodo Shinshu Tradition. The day after arriving in Kyoto,<br />
I attended the Morning Service at 6 a.m. with members from Hawaii. To<br />
my surprise, the Amida Hall was filled with so many people that there was<br />
hardly any space to move. What I found truly remarkable was the sound of the<br />
participants’ recitation of Nembutsu amid the crowd. Each person’s utterance<br />
had its own unique tone, and as I listened to the various tunes, I was reminded<br />
of the utterance of my late grandfather and my uncle, who have already<br />
returned to Amida’s Pure Land.<br />
Amida Buddha is the Buddha of Voice. Amida became the Buddha of Voice<br />
which physically reaches my ears. The voice of the recitation manifests itself<br />
according to each individual’s tone. Before the start of the Joint Celebration<br />
Service, there was complete silence, with everyone on edge. Amidst it all, there<br />
was an individual who chanted the Nembutsu with a clear and distinctive voice.<br />
It was a powerful voice, yet never unrefined. It resonated with beauty, grace,<br />
and humility, as this person confidently and respectfully recited the Nembutsu<br />
with his unique tone, “Nan Man Da-bu, Naman Da-bu”. Some of the overseas<br />
participants may have been surprised, as it was their first experience. However,<br />
no matter how quiet and solemn the occasion may be, it is the Sangha of Jodo<br />
Shinshu that praises the voice of Nembutsu, person of Nembutsu. It felt strange<br />
that I was invited by that person’s unique Nembutsu to join in recitation myself.<br />
Beyond my own thoughts and Everyday Perceptions, I was opened my closed<br />
mouth, and Amida Buddha’s calling voice emerged from it.<br />
This journal has been able to provide high-quality articles thanks to the<br />
cooperation of many teachers, overcoming the challenges of the COVID-19<br />
pandemic. This endeavor is imbued with the wish for the journal to resonate<br />
with the Nembutsu of those who are reading it. If you were to take hold of this<br />
JSIO quarterly journal and derive pleasure from its exquisite articles, and if<br />
you were to kindly bestow even a single word of praise of Amida Buddha, there<br />
would be no greater joy for our editorial staff.<br />
Namo Amida Butsu<br />
“Beyond Our World Views.”<br />
Rev. Ai Hironaka<br />
Rev. Ai Hironaka is the resident minister of Lahaina<br />
Hongwanji Mission of Hawaii. He was born in Hiroshima,<br />
Japan and attended Ryukoku University, majoring in Shin<br />
Buddhism. He was previously assigned to the Hilo Betsuin,<br />
Aiea Hongwanji Mission, and the Hawaii Betsuin.<br />
22
Do you want to deepen your<br />
understanding of Buddhist<br />
thought and practice?<br />
Get the most out of your education with<br />
our new stackable curriculum.<br />
Degree programs:<br />
Master of Divinity, Master of Arts in Buddhist Studies,<br />
Interreligious GTU Master of Arts<br />
Online certificate programs:<br />
Certificate in Buddhist Studies, Shin Buddhist Studies,<br />
Sōtō Zen Buddhist Studies<br />
On-site certificate programs:<br />
Buddhist Chaplaincy, Theravada Studies<br />
Visit us online: www.shin-ibs.edu and learn more about what IBS has to offer.<br />
®<br />
Institute of Buddhist Studies<br />
2140 Durant Avenue Berkeley, CA 94704 Tel: (510) 809-1444 • info@shin-ibs.edu<br />
23
Jodo Shinshu International Office