Angelus News | April 4, 2025 | Vol. 10 No. 7
On the cover: Parishioners of Corpus Christi Church in Pacific Palisades share a hug with kids at a recent “Roaming Catholics” Mass at Good Shepherd Church in Beverly Hills. Since losing their church and many of their homes in the Palisades Fire, parishioners have been hosted for Sunday Mass at a different LA parish every weekend. On Page 10, James Turner reports on how the Masses are keeping the parish’s scattered flock together, and helping them live tragedy with faith.
On the cover: Parishioners of Corpus Christi Church in Pacific Palisades share a hug with kids at a recent “Roaming Catholics” Mass at Good Shepherd Church in Beverly Hills. Since losing their church and many of their homes in the Palisades Fire, parishioners have been hosted for Sunday Mass at a different LA parish every weekend. On Page 10, James Turner reports on how the Masses are keeping the parish’s scattered flock together, and helping them live tragedy with faith.
Transform your PDFs into Flipbooks and boost your revenue!
Leverage SEO-optimized Flipbooks, powerful backlinks, and multimedia content to professionally showcase your products and significantly increase your reach.
ANGELUS
PILGRIM
SURVIVORS
Meet the ‘Roaming
Catholics’ scattered by
the Palisades Fire
PILGRIM
SURVIVORS
Meet the ‘Roaming
Catholics’ scattered by
the Palisades Fire
April 4, 2025 Vol. 10 No. 7
B • ANGELUS • April 4, 2025
ANGELUS
April 4, 2025
Vol. 10 • No. 7
3424 Wilshire Blvd.,
Los Angeles, CA 90010-2241
(213) 637-7360 • FAX (213) 637-6360
Published by the Roman Catholic Archdiocese
of Los Angeles by The Tidings
(a corporation), established 1895.
Publisher
ARCHBISHOP JOSÉ H. GOMEZ
Vice Chancellor for Communications
DAVID SCOTT
Editor-in-Chief
PABLO KAY
pkay@angelusnews.com
Associate Editor
MIKE CISNEROS
Multimedia Editor
TAMARA LONG GARCÍA
Production Artist
ARACELI CHAVEZ
Photo Editor
VICTOR ALEMÁN
Managing Editor
RICHARD G. BEEMER
Assistant Editor
HANNAH SWENSON
Advertising Manager
JIM GARCIA
jagarcia@angelusnews.com
ON THE COVER
JOHN RUEDA
Parishioners of Corpus Christi Church in Pacific Palisades share a
hug with kids at a recent “Roaming Catholics” Mass at Good Shepherd
Church in Beverly Hills. Since losing their church and many of
their homes in the Palisades Fire, parishioners have been hosted for
Sunday Mass at a different LA parish every weekend. On Page 10,
James Turner reports on how the Masses are keeping the parish’s
scattered flock together, and helping them live tragedy with faith.
THIS PAGE
CNS/VATICAN MEDIA
Pope Francis greets well-wishers at Rome’s
Gemelli Hospital before being discharged
March 23, after 38 days of treatment at the
hospital. On his way back to the Vatican
that day, Francis stopped in front of the Basilica
of St. Mary Major to leave a bouquet
of flowers for the Blessed Mother.
ANGELUS is published biweekly by The
Tidings (a corporation), established 1895.
Periodicals postage paid at Los Angeles,
California. One-year subscriptions (26
issues), $30.00; single copies, $3.00
© 2021 ANGELUS (2473-2699). No part of this
publication may be reproduced without the written
permission of the publisher. Events and products
advertised in ANGELUS do not carry the implicit
endorsement of The Tidings Corporation or the
Archdiocese of Los Angeles.
POSTMASTER: Send address changes to:
ANGELUS, PO Box 306, Congers, NY 10920-0306.
For Subscription and Delivery information, please
call (844) 245-6630 (Mon - Fri, 7 am-4 pm PT).
FOLLOW US
facebook.com/AngelusNews
info@angelusnews.com
Angelus News
@AngelusNews
@AngelusNews
angelusnews.com
lacatholics.org
Pope Watch.................................................................................................................................... 2
Archbishop Gomez..................................................................................................................... 3
World, Nation, and Local News.......................................................................................... 4-6
In Other Words............................................................................................................................. 7
Father Rolheiser............................................................................................................................ 8
Scott Hahn................................................................................................................................... 32
Events Calendar......................................................................................................................... 33
18
20
22
24
26
CONTENTS
Photos: Cardinal Mahony celebrates a history-making milestone
Why the Vatican’s efforts to define ‘synodality’ are far from over
Oils for the body are everywhere. What about for the soul?
Msgr. Richard Antall on the complicated Catholic immigration debate
Greg Erlandson: How my mom said goodbye at 101
Sign up for our free, daily e-newsletter
Always Forward - newsletter.angelusnews.com
28
30
‘The Last Supper’ film takes Holy Week’s Jewish roots seriously
Heather King looks at a memoir’s journey into the depths of hunger
April 4, 2025 • ANGELUS • 1
POPE WATCH
Prayers answered
On Sunday, March 23, more
than 600 people gathered outside
Rome’s Gemelli Hospital
to witness a moment millions have
been praying would happen: the end
of Pope Francis’ hospitalization.
With a very weak voice, Francis
thanked the crowd from a balcony
overlooking the square outside the
hospital, waving his hands and giving
a thumbs up.
The pope left the hospital almost
immediately after his appearance on
the balcony.
The motorcycle police leading the
pope’s motorcade turned onto the
street leading to the Vatican entrance
closest to his residence and then
turned around. Rather than go directly
home, Francis was driven through
the center of Rome to the Basilica of
St. Mary Major where he has prayed
before and after every foreign trip and
after his two previous hospitalizations
for abdominal surgery.
Francis did not go into the church
but left a bouquet of flowers to be
placed on the altar under the Marian
icon “Salus Populi Romani” or
“Health of the Roman People.”
Television footage of the pope,
seated in the front seat of a white Fiat,
showed he was using oxygen through
a nasal tube.
Just before the 88-year-old pope had
come out on the hospital balcony, the
Vatican released a text he had prepared
for the midday Angelus prayer.
The pope’s message focused on the
day’s Gospel reading of the parable
of the fig tree from Luke 13:1–9, in
which a gardener asks a landowner to
allow him to spare a fig tree that had
not borne fruit for three years; the
gardener asks to be given a year to fertilize
and care for the tree in the hope
that it would bear fruit in the future.
“The patient gardener is the Lord,
who thoughtfully works the soil of
our lives and waits confidently for our
return to him,” the pope wrote.
“In this long period of hospitalization,
I have experienced the Lord’s
patience, which I also see reflected in
the tireless solicitude of the doctors
and health care workers, as well as in
the attention and hopes of the family
members of the sick,” who also are in
Gemelli Hospital, he wrote.
“This trusting patience, anchored in
God’s love that does not fail, is indeed
necessary in our lives, especially in
facing when the most difficult and
painful situations,” Pope Francis
wrote.
Dr. Sergio Alfieri, head of the medical
team treating the pope, had told
reporters March 22 that in his rooms
at the Domus Sanctae Marthae, the
pope will continue using oxygen as
needed through a nasal tube, will be
taking medication to fight a lingering
mycosis, a fungal infection, and will
be continuing his physical therapy
and respiratory therapy.
The pope’s doctors told reporters
that they have prescribed two months
of rest and recuperation and have
urged the pope not to meet with large
groups during that time. They also
said his voice will require time to
recover.
Reporting courtesy of Catholic News
Service Rome bureau chief Cindy
Wooden.
Papal Prayer Intention for April: Let us pray that the use of
the new technologies will not replace human relationships,
will respect the dignity of the person, and will help us face
the crises of our times.
2 • ANGELUS • April 4, 2025
NEW WORLD OF FAITH
ARCHBISHOP JOSÉ H. GOMEZ
Becoming pilgrims of hope
On April 5, I will be privileged
to lead a six-mile procession
from All Souls Church in Alhambra
to the Cathedral of Our Lady
of the Angels. I hope many of you will
be able to join us.
We are calling it a “pilgrimage of
hope” and it is part of our local celebration
of the Jubilee of Hope declared
by Pope Francis to mark the 25th year
of the new Christian millennium.
Every heart needs hope in the face of
the challenges of everyday life and the
fears and uncertainties of the world.
In one of the Eucharistic prayers for
Lent, we pray for the freedom to “so
deal with the things of this passing
world as to hold rather to the things
that eternally endure.”
That freedom is the fruit of the virtue
of hope.
Hope is not just a sentiment, a warm
wish that things will work out alright
or be better in the future. Hope is a
pillar, an anchor, one of three “theological
virtues” that form the foundation
of our relationship with God and our
lives as Christians.
If you have not returned to the Catechism
in a while, I recommend it. The
short article on hope (nos. 1817–1821)
makes for inspiring spiritual reading,
especially in this Jubilee Year.
Hope turns our eyes toward heaven,
even as we live in this world of passing
things.
We can only understand the events of
our lives and the events of this passing
world accurately, if we view them in
light of God’s plan of salvation, the
kingdom that he is building in history,
through the workings of his Church.
Hope gives us this perspective. Hope
opens our eyes to see that the truth
and happiness that we all desire can
only be found in God and in the promises
of Jesus.
In Christ, we discover that we are
made by God and made for God,
through love. This is the source of our
dignity and it defines the transcendent
destiny of our lives. We are made
for heaven. It is Christ’s promise of
heaven that is the source of our hope.
My sense is that we don’t think
enough about heaven. That’s understandable.
We are all caught up in the
business of living and the demands of
work, of school, of all the responsibilities
that we have for our loved ones.
That’s why it’s important for us to be
intentional about cultivating the virtue
of hope.
Hope lifts our hearts toward heaven
and keeps our lives grounded and
following the right path on earth.
Jesus promised us that he has gone
ahead of us to prepare a place for us
in his Father’s house. And he “proved”
his love by laying down his life for us
on the cross.
So we can live with confidence,
knowing that if we follow the way that
Jesus set before us, if we love him and
seek to do the will of the Father, as
he taught us, then will be with him
forever in the glory of heaven.
When we live with hope, we remember
that we are on our way to heaven.
And when we live with that hope, the
things we do during the course of our
days take on a new and fuller meaning.
Francis is calling us in this Jubilee
Year to become “pilgrims of hope.”
This means living our faith in Jesus
with humility, joy, and love, and it
means being active in seeking ways to
share the hope that we have in him.
It means living as St. Peter talked
about: always being ready to share “the
reason for your hope … with gentleness
and reverence.”
Sharing our hope is an important
dimension of being apostles and
We can only understand the events of our lives
and the events of this passing world accurately, if
we view them in light of God’s plan of salvation.
missionary disciples in our time and
place. So many of our neighbors are
struggling and searching for meaning
in the midst of the difficulties of their
lives.
So, in this Jubilee Year, let’s look for
ways to share our hope with those who
are discouraged. Let’s let them know,
through our words and deeds, that
they are never abandoned and that
they are loved.
My prayer is that we will use this
Jubilee Year to work on growing in the
virtue of hope.
We can start by making acts of trust
in Jesus, asking him often during the
course of the day to help us to rely on
his strength and not our own.
Let’s also try to reflect more about
Our Lord’s promises of heaven, especially
as we prepare for the final days
of this sacred season, in which we remember
his passion and resurrection.
Pray for me and I am praying for you.
May our Blessed Mother Mary go
with us, and may she help us all to
live with joyful hope, and help us to
share the hope that is in us with our
neighbors.
April 4, 2025 • ANGELUS • 3
WORLD
■ Catholics in Panama
give aid to migrants
moving South
Catholic groups in Panama
are providing food, medicine,
and orientation to an influx of
migrants traveling back to South
America after being unable to
enter the U.S.
More than 2,200 migrants —
many from Venezuela — have
headed south from Mexico since
the end of January, according to
the International Organization
for Migration. Along the way,
many find themselves stopped in
Panama and Costa Rica. The Jesuit
Migrant Service, for example,
estimates 50 to 70 people a day
have been arriving in the small
town of Paso Canoas, where religious
sisters and a Catholic parish
offer free meals.
OSV News reported that
Catholic organizations are asking
governments in Central America
to facilitate the migrants’ transit
and help those who want to seek
asylum.
“We are worried that restrictions
on the movements of migrants
will increase,” Roy Arias, an
official with the Jesuit Migrant
Service in Panama, told OSV
News. “Many people could be
trapped in border towns, and they
have very limited resources to
support themselves.”
Marks of the missing — Pairs of shoes depicting victims are pictured during a vigil in front of Mexico City’s cathedral
March 15 for the victims of the clandestine mass grave recently found in Teuchitlan, in the state of Jalisco. Mexico’s
Catholic leaders prayed for the country’s missing and urged the population of the country and their political leaders to
listen to victims of violence amid outrage over the discovery of mass graves and ovens for cremating bodies on a drug
cartel compound. | OSV NEWS/SEILA MONTES, REUTERS
■ Brazilian priest’s 4 a.m. broadcast is the talk of the nation
A priest’s popular early morning live broadcast in Brazil has stoked a politicized debate
in the divided country.
Father Gilson da Silva Pupo Azevedo, or “Frei Gilson,” is a 38-year-old member of the
Carmelite Brothers, Messengers of the Holy Spirit, and a part of the Brazilian Charismatic
Catholic Renewal. For years, he has had an early morning social media broadcast,
and this Lent is leading a rosary at 4 a.m.
Gilson’s streams have reached peaks of 1.2 million simultaneous viewers. But he has
drawn critics, including for his prayers to deliver Brazil from “the scourge of communism”
and public support from former President Jair Bolsonaro and his supporters.
Some have accused him of becoming the face of right-wing Catholicism in the country.
His defenders insist his prayers are being politicized.
“Those messages of solidarity from politicians hadn’t been asked by him. They were
spontaneous,” Auxiliary Bishop Devair da Fonseca of San Paolo told Crux. “Gilson has
never had any kind of political intention with his work.”
“The Deposition of Christ,” by Andrea Mantegna. | CNS/COURTESY GOVER-
NORATE OF VATICAN CITY STATE
■ Vatican restores ‘lost’ painting
from Renaissance master
The Vatican Museums unveiled a newly restored Renaissance masterpiece
once thought lost.
“The Deposition of Christ,” by Andrea Mantegna, which depicts
Christ being laid in the tomb, was unveiled March 20.
Though historical records from the 16th century referenced Mantegna’s
work being displayed in Naples’ Basilica of San Domenico
Maggiore, it was believed lost or even nonexistent. After centuries in
obscurity, the painting resurfaced at the Shrine of the Virgin of the
Rosary in Pompei but was initially thought to be a copy.
Scientific analysis and restoration, which removed significant overpainting
atop Mantegna’s original piece, confirmed that the image is
the original.
4 • ANGELUS • April 4, 2025
NATION
■ Archbishop slams
Oregon’s ‘Abortion Provider
Appreciation Day’
The state of Oregon’s proclamation of
March 10 as “Abortion Provider Appreciation
Day” is a “celebration of death,” said
Portland’s archbishop.
The designation, signed by Gov. Tina
Kotek, is the latest in a series of moves by
the state to champion abortion access after
the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Roe v.
Wade in 2022.
“To our providers and to the patients who
live in Oregon or have been forced to retreat
to our state for care, know that I continue to
have your back,” Kotek said upon signing the
proclamation.
In a letter written in response to Kotek’s
proclamation, Archbishop Alexander
Sample said the proclamation showed a
“kind of spiritual blindness so thick that what
should be self-evident — the sheer wonder
and worth of a human life — is obscured
entirely.”
“The idea that those who make a living
ending innocent, unborn life should be publicly
honored. Thanked. Applauded. This
isn’t just moral confusion. It’s something
deeper.”
■ Maryland to host first
Eucharistic Congress
for the Deaf
A chaplain for the growing deaf ministry in
the Archdiocese of Baltimore has organized
the nation’s first Eucharistic Congress for the
Catholic Deaf Community.
The congress will take place April 4-6 at the
National Shrine of St. Elizabeth Ann Seton
in Maryland and is led by Father Mike Depcik,
one of the world’s few deaf priests.
“Several statistics have shown that 96% of
deaf people, including those baptized Catholics,
do not go to any church due to very
limited services available to them in their
own language (American Sign Language),”
Depcik told Catholic News Agency.
While the 2024 National Eucharistic
Congress in Indianapolis provided ASL
interpreters, this congress for the deaf community
will specifically focus on matching
Eucharistic devotion to the needs of the deaf
Catholic community.
■ Denver
archdiocese
looks to 2033,
launches nineyear
novena
The 2,000th anniversary
of the passion,
death, and resurrection
of Jesus Christ
isn’t until 2033, but
Catholics in one U.S.
diocese are already
getting ready.
As part of a nine-year
novena leading up to the milestone, Archbishop Samuel Aquila of Denver has
invited faithful in his diocese to join in a daily prayer directed to Mary under
the title “Mary at the Foot of the Cross,” and accompanied by an icon created
by local artist Elizabeth Zelasko of Mary under this title.
“As Mary was present with Jesus throughout his passion, she will guide us in
meditating upon these mysteries and participating in Jesus’ salvific mission
on the cross,” Archbishop Aquila said in his pastoral note announcing the
novena.
Twenty-five years ago, the archdiocese proclaimed a similar nine-year novena
in preparation for the Jubilee Year of 2000, which celebrated the second millennial
anniversary of Christ’s birth.
A Californian in the capital — Cardinal Robert W. McElroy blesses a baby as he greets representatives
of archdiocesan ministries and others at a March 11 Mass at the Basilica of the National Shrine of
the Immaculate Conception in which he was installed as the eighth archbishop of the Archdiocese of
Washington, D.C. McElroy, a San Francisco native, has lived and served for most of his life in California,
most recently as the bishop of San Diego for the last 10 years. | OSV NEWS/MIHOKO OWADA, CATHOLIC
STANDARD
Archbishop Samuel Aquila of Denver with iconographer Elizabeth Zelasko
at the March 4 unveiling of the nine-year novena icon. | DENVER CATHOLIC
April 4, 2025 • ANGELUS • 5
LOCAL
Math whiz — Gabriel Baguindoc, an eighth-grader at St. Dorothy School in Glendora, poses with Principal
Ryan Nearhoff after being presented with a medal on March 21 for his third-place national finish at the National
Catholic Schools Academic Junior High Decathlon for mathematics on March 14. | EDUARDO DUEÑAS
■ CEF raises thousands in tuition aid at LA Marathon
The Catholic Education Foundation announced it raised more than $40,000
thanks to the students and supporters who participated in LA Marathon events at
Dodger Stadium on March
15-16.
The funds will provide tuition
assistance to financially needy
students attending Catholic
schools in the Archdiocese of
Los Angeles.
The foundation’s team consisted
of 129 runners — including
students, teachers, and others
— from more than 30 local
Catholic schools that participated
in the LA Marathon, the LA
BIG5K, the LA Kids Run and
the LA Charity Half Marathon.
The youngest runner was 4 years
old, CEF said.
Following the 5K race, participants
celebrated with a taco
lunch at Cathedral High School
in Los Angeles.
To learn more, visit cefdn.org.
Sylvia Gonzalez, Andrew Mendez, Karina Mendez, Charlie Gonzalez,
and Nick Gonzalez after completing the 2025 LA Charity Half
Marathon on March 16 to help raise money for CEF. | CATHOLIC
EDUCATION FOUNDATION OF LOS ANGELES
■ Auxiliary bishop named
administrator for San
Diego diocese
Auxiliary Bishop Michael Pham has
been appointed the diocesan administrator
for the Diocese of San Diego
while awaiting a successor to Cardinal
Robert McElroy, who was appointed
to lead the Archdiocese of Washington,
D.C.
A College of Consultors, consisting
of the three auxiliary bishops and
eight priests from the diocese, selected
Pham on March 17. Pham, who became
an auxiliary bishop in 2023, will
be responsible for leading the diocese
until Pope Francis appoints its next
bishop.
Pham, 58, was born in Vietnam, but
he and his family fled the country
before settling in the United States.
He attended San Diego High School
and San Diego State University before
being ordained a priest in 1999.
■ Orange County diocese
to build apartments on
church land
A Diocese of Orange plan to build 21
apartments on the grass field at Our
Lady of Guadalupe Church in La Habra
was approved by the City Council on
March 17.
While some residents complained
about potential traffic, parking, and
safety, the council approved the project
on a 4-1 vote.
The La Habra project is the diocese’s
first foray into housing development as
faith-based organizations have begun
using their land to help shore up California’s
dire lack of housing after SB4,
the “Yes In God’s Backyard” bill, was
signed into law in 2023.
“This apartment project will provide
funding to support the church and its
good works for the next 100 years,”
Father William Goldin, administrator
at Our Lady of Guadalupe, said during
the council meeting. “We will be a
great neighbor, and this project will be
a great neighbor, both to the church
and our neighbors.”
Y
6 • ANGELUS • April 4, 2025
V
IN OTHER WORDS...
Letters to the Editor
Wait, is the pandemic really over?
Regarding the cover story of the March 21 issue titled “Five Year Checkup”
(March 21 issue of Angelus): In my parish, there are several indications
the pandemic never ended.
During the lockdown, the parish office sent emails regarding social distancing,
vaccines, masks, etc., but never sent an email when the unvaccinated could stop
wearing masks. The Mass choirs have never returned. Altar servers are rare. No
handshakes during the passing of the peace, just tepid hand waves. The Precious
Blood is still withheld from the laity. The prayer chapel remains locked and the
large baptismal font is dry. Parishioners can still sit on the patio or in their cars to
hear Mass via radio.
Ministries such as adult small groups, Sunday Mass children’s liturgy, retreats,
etc., have vanished. If the prayer groups and Bible studies have resumed, they
haven’t announced their return. This is my parish’s new normal.
— Sally Carpenter, Moorpark
The right help for the immigrants among us
Thank you for your sensitive and balanced coverage of immigration in Kimmy
Chacón’s article “Answers and Assurances” in the March 21 issue.
I have found some of President Trump’s actions and statements on immigration
during his second term to be necessary, others wrongheaded, and sometimes immoral.
But they are having real-life consequences for faithful, hardworking families
in parishes like mine, and the workshops are a prudent approach to the problem.
— Elisa Molina, Venice
Y
Continue the conversation! To submit a letter to the editor, visit AngelusNews.com/Letters-To-The-Editor
and use our online form or send an email to editorial@angelusnews.com. Please limit to 300 words. Letters
may be edited for style, brevity, and clarity.
Service with a smile
Lucia Lopez of St. Monica
Preparatory in Santa
Monica has a quick
laugh with Archbishop
José H. Gomez before
receiving her medal
from Superintendent of
Catholic Schools Paul
Escala at the Christian
Service Awards Mass
on March 18. | VICTOR
ALEMÁN
View more photos
from this gallery at
AngelusNews.com/photos-videos
Do you have photos or a story from your parish that you’d
like to share? Please send to editorial @angelusnews.com.
“They feel like children
waiting to know about their
father.”
~ Sister Anthony, of the Pious Disciples of the
Divine Master, in a March 15 Associated Press
article on the religious sisters who operate the
Vatican’s switchboard during Pope Francis’ illness.
“How could she have
known the chicken would
run at midnight?”
~ Rich Donnelly, former Major League Baseball
coach, in a March 21 National Catholic Register
article on the film, “Champions of Faith,” screening
on MLB Opening Weekend.
“It is like finding an
adolescent where you
would only expect babies.”
~ Sander Schouws, of Leiden Observatory in the
Netherlands, in a March 20 Phys.org article on
oxygen detected in the most distant known galaxy.
“People are going back into
their homes and living in a
toxic soup.”
~ Michael Jerrett, an environmental health scientist
at UCLA, in a March 12 New York Times article on
the health risks in the air following the wildfires
that burned through Southern California.
“What happens here is
between Mother Cabrini
and the Sacred Heart of
Jesus. What we do here
facilitates that.”
~ Julie Attaway of the St. Frances Cabrini Shrine in
New York City, in a March 24 National Catholic
Reporter story about how the shrine has become a
“refuge” during increased immigration enforcement.
April 4, 2025 • ANGELUS • 7
IN EXILE
FATHER RONALD ROLHEISER, OMI
Oblate of Mary Immaculate Father
Ronald Rolheiser is a spiritual
writer; ronrolheiser.com
The person of Jesus and the mystery of Christ
I
was raised a Roman Catholic and
essentially inhaled the religious
ethos of Roman Catholicism. I
went to the seminary, earned theological
degrees, and taught theology at a
graduate level for a number of years
before I ever started making a distinction
between “Jesus” and “Christ.”
For me, they were always one and the
same thing, Jesus Christ.
To my mind, Jesus Christ was the second
person of the Trinity who took on
flesh in the incarnation and is still now
our God, our advocate, and our friend
in heaven. I didn’t distinguish between
Jesus and Christ in terms of whom I
was praying to, speaking about, or relating
to. Indeed, for many years in my
writings, I simply used the words Jesus
and Christ interchangeably.
Slowly through the years this
changed, and I have begun to distinguish
more between Jesus and Christ.
It began with a deepened understanding
of what the Gospels and St. Paul
mean by the reality of Christ as a
mystery which, while always having
Jesus as its center, is larger than the
historical Jesus. This distinction and
its importance became clearer to me
when I began to have more contact
with Evangelicals, both as students
and as colleagues.
In faith fellowship with various
groups of Evangelicals, I began to see
that one of the ecclesial differences
between us, Evangelicals and Roman
Catholics, is that we, Roman Catholics,
while not ignoring Jesus, are very
much about Christ, and Evangelicals,
while not ignoring Christ, are very
much about Jesus.
How we understand the Church,
how we understand the Eucharist,
and how we understand the primary
invitation given us in the Gospels are
colored by how we perceive ourselves
in relationship to Jesus and to Christ.
What’s at stake here?
What’s the difference between saying
“Jesus” and saying “Christ”? Is there
any difference between praying to
Jesus and praying to Christ, between
relating to Jesus or relating to Christ?
There’s a difference, an important
one. Christ is not Jesus’ second name,
as in Jack Smith, Susan Parker, or
Jesus Christ. While it is correct to use
the two names together, as we do commonly
in our prayer (We pray through
Jesus Christ, Our Lord), there is an
important distinction to be made.
Jesus is a person, the second person
in the Trinity, the divine person who
became incarnate, and the person
who calls us to one-to-one intimacy
with him. Christ is a mystery of which
we are a part. The mystery of Christ
includes the person of Jesus but also
includes us. We are not part of the
body of Jesus, but we are part of the
body of Christ.
As Christians we believe that Jesus is
the body of Christ, that the Eucharist
is the body of Christ, and that we,
baptized Christians, are also the body
of Christ. St. Paul states clearly that
we, the Christian community, are the
body of Christ on earth, just as Jesus
and the Eucharist are the body of
Christ. And Paul means this literally.
We (the Christian community) are not
like a body, or some mystical or metaphorical
body; nor do we represent or
replace Christ’s body. Rather, we are
the body of Christ on earth, still giving
physical flesh to God on earth.
This has implications for Christian
discipleship: Jesus is a person, the
person who invites us to one-to-one intimacy
with him (which Evangelicals
see as the goal of Christian discipleship).
Christ is part of a larger mystery,
which includes Jesus but also includes
each of us. In this mystery we are
called to intimacy not just with Jesus,
but also with one another and with
physical creation. In Christ, the goal
of Christian discipleship is community
of life with Jesus, with one another,
and with physical creation (since the
mystery of Christ is also cosmic).
At the risk of huge oversimplification,
allow me a suggestion: Roman Catholics
and Evangelicals can learn from
each other on this.
From our Evangelical brothers and
sisters, Roman Catholics can learn to
focus as much on Jesus as we do on
Christ, so that like Evangelicals we
might realize more explicitly (as is
clear in the Gospel of John) that at the
very heart of Christian discipleship lies
the invitation to a one-to-one intimacy
with a person, Jesus, (and not just with
a mystery).
Conversely, Evangelicals can learn
from Roman Catholics to focus as
much on Christ as on Jesus, with
all this implies in terms of defining
discipleship more widely than personal
intimacy with Jesus and church more
widely than simple fellowship. Relating
to Christ points to the centrality of
the Eucharist as a communal event.
As well, it implies seeing Christian
discipleship not just as an invitation
to intimacy with Jesus, but as an
incorporation into an ecclesial body
that includes not just Jesus but the
community of all believers as well as
nature itself.
We can learn from one another
to take both Jesus and Christ more
seriously.
8 • ANGELUS • April 4, 2025
LA’S ‘ROAMING CATHOLICS’
Since the Palisades Fire, Corpus Christi Church’s
scattered parishioners are learning to embrace a
new identity — and an uncertain future.
BY JAMES TURNER
Msgr. Liam Kidney greets Corpus
Christi Church parishioners after the
Sunday, March 9 Roaming Catholics
Mass at Good Shepherd Church in
Beverly Hills. | JOHN RUEDA
Eighty-year-old Msgr. Liam Kidney,
pastor of Corpus Christi Church
in Pacific Palisades, has seen a lot
in his 57 years as a priest.
But since January, Kidney has taken
up a Sunday routine unlike anything
he could have ever imagined: celebrating
Mass at a parish not his own, but
for a congregation that is.
Since the Palisades Fire incinerated
his church — and the homes of most
of his parishioners — Kidney has
found himself a displaced shepherd to
a wandering flock.
“We’re the roaming Catholics,” said
one Corpus Christi parishioner with
a chuckle — and a hint of pride — as
Kidney’s hosts at St. Anastasia Church
in Westchester showed him around the
church’s newly renovated sanctuary.
Indeed, “Roaming Catholics” are
what the parish community of Corpus
Christi have become. With the help of
the parish website and an email chain,
10 • ANGELUS • April 4, 2025
parishioners are told week to week
where they will be gathering for Mass
on the next Sunday. This weekend was
St. Anastasia’s turn.
“They are more than welcome to
come to our church,” said St. Anastasia
pastor, Father Leszek Semik.
Days after the Palisades Fire broke
Every Sunday, Corpus Christi parishioners are
invited to celebrate a special Mass with Msgr.
Kidney at a different host parish, usually located
near LA’s Westside. | JOHN RUEDA
Sam Laganà proclaims a reading during Sunday
Mass at St. Jerome Church in Westchester on
March 16. Laganà, the stadium announcer for
the Los Angeles Rams, has belonged to Corpus
Christi since he was a child. | PABLO KAY
out, Semik read the Angelus article
about the rescue of Corpus Christi’s
tabernacle. When he learned that
Kidney was a few miles up the road to
St. Monica Church in Santa Monica,
he reached out to offer his church as
a place for Kidney and the displaced
parishioners of Corpus Christi to cele-
brate Mass together.
The experience of leading a parish in
exile has inspired a certain kind of zeal
in Kidney.
“The roaming Catholic is, to some
degree, fun. I mean, there’s a kind of
an energy to it,” he said. “What I’m
happily amazed at is the people are
sticking with it. And I say, ‘Thank you,
God.’ I mean, what a blessing.”
Kidney hopes that Corpus Christi
will be rebuilt in the future. But in the
meantime, his priority is keeping its
people together, and finding a place
where they can gather regularly.
“My worry is that [being a roaming
Catholic] is going to get old,” said
Kidney.
The challenges are many. Most of
Corpus Christi’s parishioners are Palisades
residents who lost their homes
to the fire and now face hard decisions
about where to build their futures.
Parishioners told Angelus that while
some have moved to other parts of
California, the U.S., and even abroad,
the greatest concentration of Corpus
Christi members have resettled along
LA’s Westside, in communities like
El Segundo, Manhattan Beach, and
Santa Monica. (Hence, the parishes
hosting the Sunday Masses with Kidney
have generally been in that area.)
Some parishioners have been able to
rent temporary homes with the help of
insurance, while others have moved in
with family or friends.
Sam Laganà has lived in Pacific Palisades
and belonged to Corpus Christi
since he was a child. Although he
successfully defended his home from
burning down, he doesn’t expect to
be allowed to return until at least next
year. For now, he’s been living in Santa
Monica and serving as the roaming
Catholics’ lector at Mass.
“The biggest challenge is patience,”
said Laganà, the official stadium voice
of the Los Angeles Rams. “The process
is not going to happen overnight. So,
for us to come together, in a central,
temporary, semi-permanent location
until we can rebuild, that’s going to
really help our community.”
Laganà envisions Corpus Christi being
rebuilt in the next five years, even if
its flock of Catholics will be smaller.
“Once we’re rebuilt, we could be revitalized
and do that with positivity and
April 4, 2025 • ANGELUS • 11
A couple from Corpus Christi brings up the gifts
at the March 9 Mass at Good Shepherd Church.
Most parishioners lost their homes in the Palisades
Fire, and many have temporarily resettled
along LA’s Westside. | JOHN RUEDA
A
promise,” he told Angelus after Mass.
For now, Corpus Christi’s religious
education and confirmation classes
for young people are being held at St.
Monica, which offered its facilities. Its
OCIA program (Order of Christian
Initiation, formerly known as RCIA)
has merged this year with St. Monica’s,
and Corpus Christi associate pastor
Father Valerian Menezes has joined
the formation team.
In the meantime, the scattered
parishioners say the Sunday Masses are
giving them hope, and helping keep
them together.
“Msgr. Kidney’s messages and his
homilies have just been spot on every
week,” said Rebecca Baron, who stayed
after the St. Anastasia Mass with her
husband, Juan, and their two daughters
for coffee and donuts in the courtyard
area.
She especially appreciated the consistency
it’s given her family.
“It’s been so relevant to the kind of
many different emotions our family’s
been dealing with, and losing our community,
and losing our home … just
this tragedy that we could have never
imagined.”
Will Salvini, Corpus Christi’s music
and liturgy director, said that while
the community’s losses have been
“devastating,” the welcome from each
different parish every weekend has
been “amazing.”
“It is a time for us to adjust as pilgrims,”
said Salvini. “You heard Father
Kidney use the word roaming Catholics,
but ‘refugees’ — that word fits us
as well.”
At the March 2 Mass, even the day’s
guests had guests.
Allen Villasenor’s elementary schoolage
sons had told their dad they wanted
to help Corpus Christi’s school. So
that morning, the family drove up from
San Diego after learning that members
would be at St. Anastasia.
“They wanted to do something for the
school, Corpus Christi, and we started
brainstorming what would be a good
drive to do,” said Villasenor.
The boys thought something that
might make things normal for the victims
of the fire might be either books
or board games.
“We were trying to decide one or the
other,” said the father. “We decided to
do both.”
In his homily at St. Anastasia, Kidney
recalled the days of his youth in his native
Cork, Ireland, where he discovered
an important life lesson while learning
to sail boats as a child.
“Liam, look at the top of the mast,” he
remembered his instructor telling him.
“Don’t look down, look at the top of
the mast.”
“And you would look at the top,” Kidney
continued, “and all you would see
is the top of the mast and the sky and it
was no problem.”
In the same way, “the message of our
faith is we’re always looking at the top
of the mast, we’re not looking down,’
said Kidney.
For Kidney, the need to look forward
is the one his parishioners need most
right now.
“We’re always looking at the top …
because the top is where we’re going,
and the top is where there’s peace,
security, calmness, and hope.”
James Turner is a Los Angeles-based
freelance writer.
Editor-in-chief Pablo Kay contributed
to this story.
Corpus Christi parishioners at
the March 16 Roaming Catholics
Mass at St. Jerome. | PABLO KAY
12 • ANGELUS • April 4, 2025
Altadena parishes start a slow comeback
As Easter approaches, parishioners
at Altadena’s two Catholic
churches are praying for a modest
kind of miracle: a return to normalcy.
“I think that’s what people really
want,” said Father Gilbert Guzmán,
pastor at Sacred Heart Church, about
upcoming Easter celebrations. “They
want familiarity.”
“I think if we can just kind of do the
basics, it’ll be an accomplishment,”
said Deacon Doug Cremer of St.
Elizabeth of Hungary Church, also in
Altadena. “There’s something powerful
about the ritual of the liturgy
and the Eucharist, that sometimes its
predictability and maybe even if it’s
boring, common elements are actually
a relief in an era of constant chaos and
turmoil and change.”
Even though both parishes have
returned to having Mass inside the
church, daily parish life is far from
normal in a city devastated by the
Eaton Fire in January.
Both Guzmán and Cremer estimate
that each parish has lost nearly half of
its parishioners since the fire. The water
was only recently declared safe to
use again. The air quality is hazardous
enough that Sacred Heart bought air
purifiers and St. Elizabeth’s school is
not expected to reopen until the fall.
While much of each parish’s insides
have been scrubbed and cleaned,
there is still extensive damage that
needs to be repaired.
Families continue to trickle in to
receive assistance, including from the
Archdiocese of Los Angeles’ fire relief
fund, as well as donated goods.
That’s what makes the return of
in-person gatherings so important.
“The one thing that everyone says is
what we lost was just stuff, at least we
have each other,” Guzmán said. “It’s
very beautiful, really a resounding test
of testimony to the value of relationship
versus anything material.”
Sacred Heart was able to return for
Mass on Feb. 2, only about a month
after the Eaton Fire first ignited. The
efforts of Deacon José Luis Díaz and
others have been credited with saving
the church as the fire tore through its
neighborhood.
During that first Mass, a single
candle was brought in during the
Auxiliary Bishop Brian Nunes joined
St. Elizabeth of Hungary pastor Father
Modesto Perez and parishioners for an
outdoor Sunday Mass Feb. 2 at the parish.
The church has since reopened for Mass. |
VICTOR ALEMÁN
procession.
“It was a beautiful, symbolic thing to
have our own little fire be a positive
thing versus the negative that we had
just suffered,” Guzmán said.
At St. Elizabeth, the return to Mass
inside has felt more uncomfortable.
After first doing outdoor Masses at the
parish’s Lourdes grotto, parishioners
finally got to go inside the church a
few weeks ago.
But it hasn’t quite felt the same,
Cremer said.
“It’s great to be back and kind of
doing what we do, and being with
people, and seeing each other, hearing
their stories about loss and survival and
rebuilding,” he said. “And yet it’s still
this sense of being not quite complete.
There’s a thing in the back of your
mind where you know it’s never going
to actually go back to the way it was.”
— Mike Cisneros
April 4, 2025 • ANGELUS • 13
Parishioners and survivor-victims of abuse joined Auxiliary
Bishop Matthew Elshoff for the Jan. 2024 dedication
of St. Bernadette’s healing garden on the corner of Don
Felipe and Marlton in Baldwin Hills. | PABLO KAY
PLACES OF PEACE
The healing gardens at five LA Catholic parishes
represent a quiet side to the fight against abuse.
BY MIKE CISNEROS
When St. Bernadette Church
in Baldwin Hills was deciding
where its healing garden
would be located at the parish, Deacon
Jim Carper said the original thinking
was to put it near the convent at the
back of the property.
But to really convey the importance
of the garden as a place for victims of
abuse to find some measure of healing,
it needed to be more prominent than
that.
So up it went, near the entrance to the
church on the corner of Don Felipe
and Marlton, visible by walking or
driving by.
“While we didn’t have a marching
band, we certainly placed the monument
in a conspicuous place,” said
Carper, parish life director at St. Bernadette.
“It’s created conversation without
confrontation.”
The garden at St. Bernadette (Our
Lady of the Angels Pastoral Region)
was one of the five gardens installed
in the Archdiocese of Los Angeles in
each of the pastoral regions. The other
four healing gardens are located at
Our Lady of the Assumption Church
in Ventura (Santa Barbara Pastoral
Region), St. Francis de Sales Church in
Sherman Oaks (San Fernando Pastoral
Region), Our Lady of Refuge Church
in Long Beach (San Pedro Pastoral
Region), and St. Camillus Center for
Spiritual Care in East LA (San Gabriel
Pastoral Region).
As National Child Abuse Prevention
Month gets underway this April, the
healing gardens at the five parishes —
plus an “unofficial” healing garden at
Old Mission Santa Inés in Solvang —
represent the prayerful side to the fight
against abuse.
Father Michael Wakefield, pastor at
St. Francis de Sales Church in Sher-
man Oaks, said he doesn’t always know
if the people who have visited the garden
are abuse victims, but many have
come to him with “pain” and “tears” in
their eyes.
“Just telling me kind of quietly, ‘This
is so beautiful. This is lovely and I’m so
happy that it’s here,’ ” Wakefield said.
Wakefield also likes to bring students
from the parish school to explain why
the garden is there.
“It’s a reminder that even in Christ’s
holy Church, there were people that
would do terrible things,” Wakefield
said. “This is a small way for us to say
to those people that were traumatized
and victimized how terribly sorry we
are, and no, it wasn’t your fault. No,
it should not have happened to you,
and that we hope that you will find in
this place of quiet and serenity some
semblance of peace.”
To mark National Child Abuse
Prevention Month, the archdiocese’s
Victims Assistance Ministry office plans
to send prayer cards with flower seeds
to each of the parishes with healing
gardens.
Carper believes the healing gardens
are an important way to underscore the
steps the Church has taken to make
children safer and teach people “to
keep their eyes on the prize, which is
our kids, the future of our Church.”
Carper said the garden is making a difference
even outside of the parish community.
When a prominent member of
the Baldwin Hills community walked
by recently, Carper said she stopped to
remark on the garden.
“Her response when she walked by
was, ‘Good for you,’ ” he said. “And
then there was a pause and she said,
‘Good for us.’ And I thought that statement
was powerful, good for you, but
good for us, meaning the community.”
For more information on abuse prevention
and protecting children, visit
the Office of Safeguard the Children at
lacatholics.org/safeguard.
Mike Cisneros is the associate editor of
Angelus.
14 • ANGELUS • April 4, 2025
Many of the nine teachers and 72 students honored during the 2025
Christian Service Awards Mass pose with Archbishop José H. Gomez
and Auxiliary Bishop Brian Nunes after the event on March 18.
SIGNS OF
SERVICE
Catholic school students and
teachers were honored for
their thousands of hours of
serving their communities.
PHOTOGRAPHY BY VICTOR ALEMÁN
Justin Croutch of Chaminade College Preparatory High School in Chatsworth
greets Archbishop Gomez as Paul Escala, right, superintendent of Catholic
schools, prepares to present him with his medal.
Two young ladies hug following the special Mass,
where Catholic school students were awarded for
more than 36,000 collective hours of Christian service.
16 • ANGELUS • April 4, 2025
The choir singing
during the Christian
Service Awards Mass
was comprised of
students from St.
Monica Academy in
Montrose.
Students, teachers, and supporters
pray during the 2025 Christian Service
Awards Mass, the 51st version of the
event organized by the archdiocese’s
Department of Catholic Schools.
Sophia Rodriguez, front, from St.
Genevieve High School in Panorama City,
reads the Prayers of the Faithful during
the Christian Service Awards Mass.
Behind her is Abigail Johnson from St.
Lucy’s Priory High School in Glendora,
and Isabelle Soto from Santa Clara High
School in Oxnard. To the right is Marcela
Quiju, assistant liturgy director at the
cathedral.
April 4, 2025 • ANGELUS • 17
Cardinal Roger Mahony processes
out of St. Charles Borromeo Church in
North Hollywood at the end of the 11
a.m. Sunday morning Mass March 16
celebrating his 50 years as a bishop.
A SHEPHERD’S
JUBILEE
Cardinal Roger Mahony
celebrated the 50th anniversary
of his ordination as a bishop at
the parish he grew up in.
PHOTOGRAPHY BY VICTOR ALEMÁN
Friends, parishioners, and well-wishers received blessings from Cardinal
Mahony after the March 16 Mass. He was baptized at St. Charles, and attended
elementary school there as a child.
Cardinal Mahony shares a light moment with Carmelite Sisters of the Most Sacred
Heart of Los Angeles at a post-Mass reception at St. Charles Borromeo’s parish hall.
18 • ANGELUS • April 4, 2025
Staff and members of St. Charles Borromeo’s “Welcome Home” committee with Cardinal
Mahony at the March 16 reception.
The March 16 Mass was attended by several friends, deacons, women religious, and
former colleagues from Cardinal Mahony’s quarter-century as archbishop of LA.
The pope’s
special message
Among those congratulating Cardinal Roger
Mahony on his Golden Jubilee of episcopal
ordination was Pope Francis himself.
In a special message sent from Rome dated Feb. 17,
the pope recalled “with great joy” Cardinal Mahony’s
service as a bishop in three dioceses (Fresno,
Stockton, and Los Angeles) and noted that the day of
his episcopal ordination as auxiliary bishop of Fresno,
March 19, fell on the Solemnity of St. Joseph,
the patron of the Catholic Church.
“May the Lord fill your soul with abundant blessings
and joy! I make this plea through the intercession
of the Blessed Mother of God, the Queen of the
Apostles, and that of her most chaste Spouse,” wrote
the pope.
In his homily at the March 16 anniversary Mass,
Cardinal Mahony quoted remarks the pope made
during a visit to South America about the need
for pastors to take up three positions when leading
people: “in front to mark out the road, in the middle,
to know it, and at the back to ensure nobody falls
behind.”
Cardinal Mahony said he found that an appropriate
description of servant leadership in the Church.
“I learned very early as a young bishop that no
bishop operates by himself,” he said in his homily.
“Every bishop needs to listen to the Holy Spirit, and
continue to call forth leaders from the flock to help.”
Cardinal Mahony is only the second Roman
Catholic bishop in California to have lived to reach
his 50th anniversary of episcopal ordination. The
other was Bishop John Cummins, who was an auxiliary
bishop of Sacramento from 1974 to 1977 and
the Bishop of Oakland from 1977 to 2003. Cummins
died Dec. 3, 2024, six months after marking his
Golden Jubilee.
— Angelus Staff
Cardinal Mahony was joined by bishops and priests
of the Archdiocese of Los Angeles for a Mass at St.
Charles on March 19, 50 years to the day after he was
ordained an auxiliary bishop of Fresno in 1975.
April 4, 2025 • ANGELUS • 19
Synodality now — or never
The Vatican has
announced a new
three-year plan
to implement
synodality. But
its fate will likely
depend on the
next pope.
BY CHARLES COLLINS
Cardinal Mario Grech,
secretary-general of the synod,
speaks at a news conference
at the Vatican Oct. 26, 2024. |
CNS/LOLA GOMEZ
Pope Francis has spent more than
a month in the hospital facing a
serious medical crisis, but he is
continuing to push for a more “synodal”
Church.
Francis announced the Synod on Synodality
on March 7, 2020, and it began
with diocesan and regional phases,
before holding the Vatican Synod on
Synodality at the Vatican in 2023 and
2024.
Over that time, it is still unclear what
“synodality” means in practice.
At the beginning of the process,
Francis said synodality is “a style, it is a
walk together, and it is what the Lord
expects from the Church of the third
millennium.”
In 2020, the International Theological
Commission said synodality is “the
action of the Spirit in the communion
of the Body of Christ and in the missionary
journey of the People of God.”
Admittedly, both these descriptions
aren’t very clear. But if you thought
that the discussions are over after the
final synod gathering last fall, and that
the definition of synodality can finally
form a more definable shape — well,
I’ve got a Winston Churchill quote
from 1942 for you: “This is not the
end. It is not even the beginning of the
end. But it is perhaps the end of the
beginning.”
That’s because on March 15, Synod
Secretary-General Cardinal Mario
Grech sent a letter to the world’s
bishops announcing another step in
the synodal journey, decreed by Francis
himself: A three-year phase focused on
applying the synod’s conclusions at all
levels of the Church to help integrate
synodality into daily church life before
an “ecclesial assembly” at the Vatican
in 2028.
“It is a process aimed at fostering
dialogue among Churches about the
insights developed in the implementation
phase. After a period of work at
the local level (until 2026), the goal is
to create, in a synodal style, spaces for
20 • ANGELUS • April 4, 2025
dialogue and exchange of gifts among
Churches,” Grech told Vatican News.
Grech said the new phase’s goal “is to
ensure that implementation does not
happen in isolation, as if each diocese
or eparchy were a separate entity, but
that bonds between Churches at national,
regional, and continental levels
are strengthened.”
He said the meetings planned for
2027 and early 2028 will lead toward
an Ecclesial Assembly in October
2028.
“This final assembly will then be
able to offer the Holy Father valuable
insights — fruits of a real ecclesial
experience — to aid his discernment
as the Successor of Peter, with perspectives
to propose to the entire Church,”
Grech said.
And that sentence opens up a question:
which Holy Father?
Francis is 88 and has been in the
hospital for more than a month with a
major ailment. October 2028 is more
than three years away.
With the possibility that a new pope
might be in office, the “fuzzy” definition
of synodality will play a role in
those very meetings.
That’s underlined by the fact that
among the general Catholic population,
no one is really talking about
synodality (despite the huge attention
given to it by the “professional” Catholic
class, we journalists included).
Francis himself admitted this fact over
a year ago.
“I am well aware that speaking of a
‘Synod on Synodality’ may seem something
abstruse, self-referential, excessively
technical, and of little interest to
the general public,” he said before the
2023 Synod of Bishops meeting.
Of course, it could help by looking
at the history of synods in the Church,
but that might also not be of assistance.
The Eastern Orthodox and Oriental
Orthodox churches have synods of
bishops taking place for the election of
new bishops and the establishment of
inter-diocesan laws within each province.
Eastern Catholic Churches also
use synods for such purposes.
In the West, synods were often held
in the early centuries of the Church,
and included important theological
debates. However, as the powers of the
papacy grew, the synods became less
common, although councils, like the
“Ecumenical Councils” — which are
arguably synods by a different name —
still continued.
The Western Church also has
diocesan synods — which used to be
required to happen once a decade
(admittedly, a rule observed more in
the breach than in the execution) —
Cardinals pray during Mass presided by Cardinal
Mario Grech, secretary-general of the synod, at the
altar of the Chair in St. Peter’s Basilica at the Vatican
Oct. 21, 2024. | CNS/LOLA GOMEZ
involved both clergy and laypeople.
Much like the more traditional synod,
it involved looking at local diocesan
laws and reforming them if needed.
More prominently, St. Pope Paul VI
established the Synod of Bishops in
Vatican II, which had no real authority
at all. This synod could make “proposals,”
which could be accepted or rejected
by the pontiff. Soon, these meetings
became talking shops, where many of
the participants were more interested
in Church gossip at the local restaurants
in Rome than the official issue
being discussed at the synod meeting in
the Vatican.
In many ways, Francis made “synodality”
almost a building together of
several of these ideas, even if they don’t
always fit together.
So what will “synodality” be after the
2028 meeting? Frankly, it will be whatever
the Holy Father — whether Francis
or his successor — says it means.
Charles Collins is an American
journalist currently living in the United
Kingdom, and is Crux’s managing
editor.
April 4, 2025 • ANGELUS • 21
Searching for the oil of gladness
The modern obsession with using healthy oils for food
should remind us to think more about the holy ones, too.
BY ELISE URENECK
A priest anoints a woman’s
forehead with the oil of the
sick during a healing Mass
at his parish in this 2022
file photo. | CNS/GREGO-
RY A. SHEMITZ
Two years ago, I sleepily walked
to the sink to rinse my face after
getting out of bed. I looked in
the mirror, and to my surprise, there
was a sizable yellow spot on the white
of my eye. Having no idea what it
was, I made an appointment with an
ophthalmologist.
“Do you spend a lot of time in the sun
or at the beach without sunglasses?”
she asked. “No,” I replied.” “Do you ski
a lot?” she inquired. “Not at all,” I said.
“Your eyes are severely dry and
inflamed. I think you should see a
rheumatologist,” she said. “I think you
might have Sjögren’s disease.”
A few months later, a rheumatologist
confirmed her suspicions.
I was diagnosed with an autoimmune
disorder, which attacks my exocrine
glands. In layman’s terms, anywhere
my body is supposed to have moisture,
I have little to none.
It’s unclear how long I’ve had the
disease. Until that appointment, I’d
lived my whole life assuming that I
was sensitive to things like weather
and toiletries, and that some amount
of arthritis, swollen joints, and neuropathy
was typical, based on my family
history. It turns out I have a high pain
tolerance.
Like other autoimmune diseases, I
22 • ANGELUS • April 4, 2025
experience what doctors call flares —
the sudden onset of symptoms that
range from inflamed hands, knees, and
feet, to complications with any of the
body’s systems and organs. People with
this disease are at an increased risk for
lymphoma as well as other autoimmune
diseases like lupus.
There’s no way of predicting when
or why your body will take a sudden
turn in a downward direction. I am
now among those who live scan to scan
and blood draw to blood draw. It’s a
radical invitation to live in the present
moment.
At the same time, I’ve got a family
to serve, and I’m not one to idly sit
around if something can be done. I’ve
taken to overhauling my diet in order
to reduce the inflammation in my body
and improve my health outcomes.
Thanks in part to figures like Dr.
Casey Means, Robert F. Kennedy Jr.,
and others, the public now has a better
understanding of the inflammatory
— and sometimes poisonous — ingredients
we’re ingesting en masse. A theologian
more capable than I could delineate
how our current means of food
and agricultural production should be
counted among Pope Francis’ running
list of social and structural sins.
In the age of Google, YouTube, and
podcasts, one can easily despair from
information overload. At times I’ve
been paralyzed about what to eat and
how to find time (or money) to make
the bulk of our family’s food from
scratch. I confess to becoming overly
preoccupied with swapping healthy
cooking oils for ones that are not, and
for checking every ingredient list at the
grocery store. It’s been astonishingly
easy to become consumed by it.
Despite my efforts, my symptoms have
not gone away. In fact, the disease has
flared without warning, rendering me
not quite immobile, but close to it.
During a recent, demoralizing episode,
I was leaning on my dresser for
support as I put my clothes on. I looked
up and saw a small bottle of St. Joseph
oil that I had purchased on a pilgrimage
with my late mother to St. Joseph’s
Oratory in Montreal.
Thousands of sick pilgrims were
healed during their visits with St. André
Besette at the site he commissioned
to honor St. Joseph. To this day, visitors
Dozens of bottles filled with olive oil mixed with aromatic oils in the rectory of Sts. Peter and Paul Cathedral Parish in
Indianapolis April 8, 2019. They were blessed as chrism oil during the annual chrism Mass. | CNS/SEAN GALLAGHER,
THE CRITERION
report being cured of their diseases
after going to the basilica.
Bessette encouraged pilgrims to take
home vegetable oil which had been
burned in front of a statue of Joseph.
He instructed them to rub it on
themselves and to ask Joseph for relief,
cautioning them that it was not the oil
that healed, but Jesus Christ.
After I got dressed that day, I rummaged
through my drawers and realized
that I had accumulated not only
eight bottles of that oil — some from
my late mother’s bedside, some from
my husband who had traveled there
before we were married — but that I
had vials of oil from other shrines I’d
been to in my life.
Around that same time, a good friend
stopped by with her kids for a playdate
with mine. After I mentioned my
illness, she ran into her car and came
back with a tiny bottle of St. Faustina
oil from a local shrine. “Let me know if
you need an oil change,” she said,” I’ve
got plenty more.”
I had been so focused on healthy oils
that I had forgotten about holy ones.
In the Catholic tradition, oils serve
a variety of purposes. There are holy
oils used in the sacraments — the oil
of the sick, the oil of catechumens,
and chrism oil. We believe that God
himself confers his grace through their
application.
But the Church also permits the use
of blessed oils. Like other sacramentals,
they are intended to increase our faith.
As with ashes, palms, and holy water,
they remind us of God’s closeness to
us.
Our Lord has worked wonders
through this simple gift of nature,
anointing kings, providing light for the
Maccabees, receiving it as a baby in
the manger, and again from Mary of
Bethany before his passion.
I’ve begun to take a drop or two of
these oils and rub them on my cracked
hands and fingers, my eyes, and
my joints when I am praying in the
morning and before I go to bed. I ask
for God’s healing and consolation, but
also help to make an offering of my
discomfort for others. The practice has
helped me to do what I can, and leave
the rest to him.
It’s not lost on me that my disease
presented itself most clearly in my eyes,
and that through it, God is helping
me to see — chiefly that in physical or
spiritual dryness, he is closer than I can
imagine, through the simplest of gifts.
Elise Ureneck is a contributor to Angelus
writing from Rhode Island.
April 4, 2025 • ANGELUS • 23
Caught between extremes
BY MSGR. RICHARD ANTALL
There are no simple
‘fixes’ for our
immigration system.
A Catholic approach
to the subject should
acknowledge that.
After winning the prestigious
Orwell Prize for Political
Writing for his 2023 novel “The
Picnic” (W. W. Norton & Company,
$28.95), author Matthew Longo wrote
a reflection that included one of the
most thought-provoking quotes about
immigration I’ve ever heard.
“If the money doesn’t go where the
people are, the people will go where
the money is,” said Miklos Nemeth,
the last Communist prime minister of
Hungary, in an interview with Longo
for the book. Longo never included
it in “The Picnic,” which is about the
hundreds of East Germans who fled
communism just before its collapse
in Eastern Europe, and the quote is
actually from late French historian
Alfred Sauvy, but Nemeth cited it as a
prophecy.
And I’ve been thinking about that
line — “the people will go where the
money is” — a lot lately, considering
all the dramatic developments with
immigration under our new president.
Sauvy’s quote is not just about
material things, but also opportunity.
My ancestors came to this country for
the same reason. When a Salvadoran
comes to the U.S. and his children go
to college and become professionals, I
see an echo of my family: My grand-
Cuban migrant Marielis Arosh and her family walk
with other migrants after their CBP One app asylum
appointment was canceled on the day of U.S. President
Donald Trump’s inauguration, near the border
fence in Mexicali, Mexico, Jan. 20. | OSV NEWS/
VICTOR MEDINA, REUTERS
mother was an illiterate ethnically
German girl when she arrived here;
now, her grandchildren are solidly
either middle- or upper middle-class
Americans.
People want a better life for their
children. The Mexicans I worked with
in a small town in Ohio came over
the border without registration to work
in nurseries. The money they earned
helped them build houses back in
Mexico out of cement block, instead
of adobe. Eventually, some decided
to outstay the season of work and put
down roots. Gradually, a group of them
were able to get residency and they
24 • ANGELUS • April 4, 2025
brought up their children, who themselves
were in various stages of the legal
immigration process.
So many people cannot understand
the complexity of immigration because
they have no idea of the difficulties
involved for the immigrants.
Once I was at an immigration seminar
at a local college and a suburbanite
woman angrily asked me why so many
Mexicans working in our county didn’t
just get visas to come here.
“There is a legal way in,” she insisted.
I tried explaining it was not like getting
a visa to take a vacation to Cancun, but
much more difficult.
People complain about immigration
in many parts of the developed world,
not just in the U.S. but in places like
Ireland, Colombia, and most of continental
Europe. But I have been disappointed
lately when I hear Catholics
declare they are “against” immigration
itself.
I wonder how many of them can have
ancestors who were here to greet the
Mayflower. The Draconian idea of expelling
all who came into the country
in an irregular way would cause a great
deal of havoc, not just economically,
but for families that are sometimes
mixed with members who have all their
residency resolved and those who do
not. There is an unconscious xenophobia
that regards all strangers as threatening:
hospes, hostis, as the Latin has it,
“the guest is an enemy.”
At least I hope the xenophobia is
unconscious, but sometimes I am
not sure. The hysteria about Haitians
having “Garfield” for a barbecue here
in Ohio last year — despite a glaring
lack of evidence — suggested an attitude
close to paranoia. “Open border”
policies are a mistake, I am convinced,
but not everyone who suddenly passed
through the gates without a wall was
a criminal or intent on destroying the
American way of life. To have to say
something so obvious reveals the ignorance
or at least the naiveté of some of
the more vociferous nativist voices.
As an Ohioan who supported our former
senator on several issues, I agreed
with Cardinal Timothy Dolan of New
York’s criticism in late January of Vice
President J.D. Vance’s hypothesis that
the U.S. bishops defended a federal
program that resettled migrants because
they wanted to recoup the billions paid
out in claims about clerical abuse.
It’s a shame that some so-called
Catholic “conservatives” online have
defended that scabrous accusation.
Their joy at the election results makes
them blind to the complexity of some
issues, and unwilling to recognize
when politicians overstep their bounds,
e.g., Trump’s full-throated support for
expanding access to in vitro fertilization.
In visits last year to Hispanic families
that I call friends, I was surprised at
how many immigrants voiced approval
of candidate Trump. One of them is in
a difficult migratory situation: although
raised in the United States, he was
too old to be bundled with his parents
when their papers came through. I
often think of him now, in fear of the
future.
But I am especially afraid of a future
that will be one of disastrous and acrimonious
division.
St. Thomas Aquinas said of doctrinal
debates that it was best to “Numquam
negare, raro affirmare, semper distinguere”
(“Never deny, seldom affirm, and
always distinguish”). It’s a principle that
has been neglected in the immigration
debates. One size does not fit all. Some
undocumented aliens are integrated in
families with citizenship, they are educated
and useful members of society.
Even Trump was quoted talking about
Vice President J.D. Vance speaks
during a press briefing in Damascus,
Virginia, Jan. 27, following a Jan. 26
interview where he suggested the
U.S. bishops were more concerned
about padding “their bottom line” by
resettling refugees. | OSV NEWS/BEN
CURTIS, POOL VIA REUTERS
the so-called “Dreamers,” who are contributing
members of society. But some
people seem averse to drawing those
kinds of distinctions.
The stream of immigration under the
last White House administration almost
resembled the chaos of the Children’s
Crusade in the Middle Ages (in which
droves of European children ran away
from home under the delusion they
could help knights retake the Holy
Land, and ended in disaster), a mass
movement of people without realistic
structures of evaluation or assimilation.
Now, a calmer approach must be
taken, starting with a case-by-case study
of cases and some kind of gradual
framework set in place. Politically, it
is anathema to propose some kind of
amnesty (which the sainted President
Reagan accepted), but how can it be
ruled out, at least in certain cases? We
Catholics do believe in forgiveness.
This is a problem that might take a
generation to work out. Meanwhile,
Catholic opinion should be considerate,
contextual, and careful about the
question.
Msgr. Richard Antall is pastor of Holy
Name Church in Cleveland, Ohio, and
the author of several books, including
the novel“The X-mas Files” (Atmosphere
Press, $17.99). He served as a missionary
priest in El Salvador for more than
20 years.
April 4, 2024 • ANGELUS • 25
INTERSECTIONS
GREG ERLANDSON
Farewell, for now
The author with his late mother,
Mary Casilda Erlandson, while in
hospice care. | PATTY SANCHEZ
When my mom turned 100,
I wrote these words in this
column:
Old, old age is something else entirely.
Friends and spouses may be gone.
Memories too. There is something
beautiful in the resilience of the human
spirit even after a century of life,
yet it is characterized more by patience
than rage. God’s will and time have
not yet allowed my mom to put off her
burdened flesh and ascend to brighter
heights. She waits with good humor the
destiny her faith tells her will come.
God allowed my mom to “put off
her burdened flesh” on Feb. 21 of
this year, two months after her 101st
birthday. Mary Casilda died peacefully
in her sleep. That itself was an
answered prayer. This faithful woman
simply slipped away. Almost as one
rolls over in bed, she turned into her
new life, one she had looked forward
to for decades.
We don’t know what heaven looks
like. We mortal beings cannot really
fathom eternity. But we know God is
relational. Hence the Trinity. Jesus
had friends, went to weddings, wept at
Lazarus’ death. He knows the human
heart and its absolute passion to connect
with another. This must be some
component of the life to come. This
is why my family chooses to believe
26 • ANGELUS • April 4, 2025
Greg Erlandson is the former president and
editor-in-chief of Catholic News Service.
that if she is now with God, that in
some way mom is also now with her
husband, Ted. She is with her son that
she lost 68 years ago to a brain tumor.
She is with her brother, a Trappist
monk, who died 14 years before her.
In other words, she is home.
Now she knows. Now she knows
what before she could only see
through a glass darkly, what we can
only see darkly now who have been
left behind.
As I wrote more than a year ago,
mom bore the indignities of age with
grace and good humor most days. She
was bedridden, but watched the Mass
on television. She never forgot the
words to the Our Father and the Hail
Mary, even when she might forget our
names or not recognize our faces.
In our family lore, we will now recount
the many comments she made
out of the blue that seemed to suggest
that during her last year the membrane
between mortality and immortality
was becoming porous, transparent.
“The two men told me that
I can’t bring anything with me,” she
told us at one point. A dream? Angelic
travel advice? She took it in stride,
as when she recently started talking
about her brother, whom she hadn’t
spoken of or apparently remembered
in several years.
As a mother, as a wife, my mom lived
her faith daily and simply. She was
generous and caring, and her faith
animated everything. She didn’t fear
death, and when the Lord was ready
to take her, she was ready to go.
When someone who is 101 dies, her
survivors are both happy for her and
yet still grieve. She had been through
a lot. She had paid her dues and then
some. We are grateful that we had her
for so long and sad we could not have
her still. We will miss hearing her say,
“I love you madly.”
Yet even in this winter of sorrow, joy
like a crocus reminds us all is not loss.
For as we prepared for her funeral,
we were also baptizing our newest
grandchild and her eighth great
grandchild, Peter Francesco, into the
Faith. (Can there be a more papal
name?)
In a beautiful, old, creaky church in
Pittsburgh, Peter’s parents and godparents
renounced Satan and all his
works and affirmed their faith in Jesus
Christ on his behalf. We crowded
around the baptismal font and participated
in an ancient rite welcoming
little Peter into our company with
great joy. I like to think my mom was
there too. She would appreciate the
symmetry: a great grandson gaining
entrance into our community of faith
just as she was moving on.
And when we said we believed in
“the communion of saints, the forgiveness
of sins, the resurrection of the
body, and life everlasting,” mom was
there as a witness.
Peter never met his great grandmother,
but God willing, her spirit of faith,
her joy in life, her appreciation of
family will be evident to him in the
witness of his grandparents and parents.
Mom’s witness will remain, like
some Catholic DNA passed on to the
generations to come. This mystical
body, this communion of faith, will
continue to grow and thrive, bearing
witness to what we’ve received in
faith and handed on to the best of our
ability. Amen.
April 4, 2025 • ANGELUS • 27
NOW PLAYING THE LAST SUPPER
WHEN GOD COMES TO DINNER
A surprising new film gets it: Jesus’ Last Supper, and the celebration
of Easter, can’t be understood without the Jewish Passover.
BY STEFANO REBEGGIANI
James Oliver Wheatley,
Charlie MacGechan, and
Jamie Ward in “The Last
Supper.” | PINNACLE PEAK
These are exciting times for Bible
movie lovers, with several biblical
film projects just released or
about to come out, like the Netflix film
“Mary,” which premiered in December,
and Amazon’s “House of David,”
released in February.
But I am not one of them, and I was
not expecting much from “The Last
Supper” (released in theaters March
14), written and directed by Italian
filmmaker and artist Mauro Borrelli,
and executive-produced by Christian
music star Chris Tomlin.
I was wrong. “The Last Supper” is
well worth a trip to the movies, especially
during Lent.
Yes, the film can help audiences meditate
on Jesus’ passion. But it can also
encourage Catholics to understand
and experience more fully the Easter
Vigil as well as the daily celebration of
the Mass itself. The writers’ intuition
is that we can’t fully comprehend what
happens at the Last Supper and in
Jesus’ passion, except in the light of the
Jewish Passover.
Cinematically, do not expect Mel
Gibson’s “The Passion.” But while
Jamie Ward’s performance as Jesus
is not entirely convincing, the depictions
of Judas (Robert Knepper) and
Caiaphas (James Faulkner) are.
Unlike other movies on the last moments
of Christ, this one concentrates
almost exclusively on the Last Supper,
which takes up more than half of the
film.
The Gospels are very clear that Jesus’
Last Supper was not just a somber
farewell dinner, but took place during
the Jewish Passover: a great feast celebrated
in the homes, family by family,
according to the prescriptions in the
book of Exodus, as a memorial of the
escape from Egypt.
By Jesus’ time this liturgical dinner
had evolved into a nights’ long feast
involving a complex ceremonial, the
Passover Seder, in which the different
signs (the bread, the wine, the bitter
herbs) made visible the intervention of
God in the life of his people.
Jesus followed the ritual of the Jewish
Passover but altered the prayers and
transformed the meaning of its signs.
To illustrate this process of transformation,
the film imagines that Jesus
and his disciples are hosted by a large
family.
The family celebrates the traditional
Passover in a room on the ground floor,
while Jesus and his disciples have their
supper in the upper room. The film
then alternates scenes from one room
to the other.
The first part of the Passover dinner
focused on the memory of slavery.
In the lower room, the father passes
around the bitter herbs and explains
that they signify the bitterness of enslavement,
along with the unleavened
bread, a symbol of the hasty departure
from Egypt.
In the upper room, Jesus does the
28 • ANGELUS • April 4, 2025
same sign, but his words are different:
This is my body, which will be given
up for you. The bread is no longer a
sign of the escape from Egypt, it is his
body offered on the cross for the salvation
of humanity.
In the third part of the Passover Seder,
the celebrant lifted a cup of wine and
blessed God for all his works, and
especially for the covenant he made
with the people of Israel. Jesus too
distributes the wine to his disciples, but
transforms the sign’s meaning: the cup
that is poured out for you is the new
covenant in my blood.
The movie does an effective job of
linking the Last Supper and the Resurrection.
Contrary to expectations, the
passion of Jesus is dealt with succinctly,
and only through brief flashbacks.
The scene that concludes the movie
— which I will not spoil — ties the
ritual of the Last Supper not just
with Jesus’ passion, but also with his
resurrection. This is another important
insight that is in tune with the spirit of
the Jewish Passover.
In the Jewish Passover, the bread
symbolizes the bitterness of Egypt, its
breaking signifies the end of slavery,
and the wine represents the joy of
freedom in the promised land.
In the Eucharist, the breaking of the
bread makes present Jesus’ death, but
it also looks ahead at his resurrection:
with his death and resurrection, Jesus
brings us from death to life, he introduces
us into the Promised Land.
One aspect of the Last Supper
could have received more emphasis.
The Jewish Passover is not merely a
commemoration. The point of the
celebration is not only to give thanks
and celebrate the Lord for how he
saved his people in the distant past, but
it is for the people to participate in this
salvation here and now.
That is why the Haggadah (the key
text that outlines the order of the
Passover Seder) proclaims: “In each
and every generation every person
must regard himself as though he had
come forth from Egypt as a slave.”
The salvation of God extends to every
generation.
This can only benefit believers
preparing for this year’s celebration of
Easter. Easter is not merely a commemoration
of the death and resurrection
of Jesus, but a moment when
we also can pass from death to life on
an existential level. The resurrection
of Jesus is an event of the now, not of
2,000 years ago.
As St. Paul puts it, we were dead because
of sin, and God brought us back
to life. We were plagued by envy, lust,
resentment, hatred; we were unable to
forgive or love anybody but ourselves.
Easter comes to make us experience
Christ’s victory over one’s death again:
that I can love now; that I can forgive
when forgiveness seems impossible.
“The Last Supper” is not a masterpiece,
but it offers lots of reasons not
to wait until the last season of “The
Chosen” to return to the movie theater.
Stefano Rebeggiani is an associate
professor of classics at the University of
Southern California.
Jamie Ward portrays Christ in a
scene from the movie “The Last
Supper.” | PINNACLE PEAK
April 4, 2025 • ANGELUS • 29
DESIRE LINES
HEATHER KING
An exploration of true hunger
SHUTTERSTOCK
Lent is upon us. Pray, fast, and
give alms, saith the Lord.
Apropos of fasting, I recently
read a food-based memoir that is about
very much more than food.
Agata lzabela Brewer, author of
“The Hunger Book: A Memoir from
Communist Poland” (Mad Creek
Books, $24.95), grew up in Lviv during
the 1980s with a terrifying, unstable,
alcoholic mother and a little brother
whom she adored and protected. Now
a professor at Wabash College, she
lives in Indiana with her husband and
(thoroughly Americanized) children.
She also volunteers as a court appointed
special advocate and is the founder
and chair of the organization Immigrant
Allies.
Back in Poland, her mother had
survived the war, her father took off
not long after his son was born, and
Agata lived in constant fear — both of
her physically and emotionally abusive
mother, who regularly attempted suicide,
and of being separated from her.
When she was 5 and little Tomek 3,
they found their mother in bed one
evening, seemingly comatose, stupefied
by pills and vodka. Agata dressed
her brother in his little winter coat,
grasped his hand, and trudged with
him 15 minutes through slushy snow
to the haven of their maternal grandparents
to report: “Mama won’t wake
up.”
Another time, their mother caught
the two up late coloring in their room,
and — all too awake this time — made
them stand shivering in their thin pajamas
all night without moving.
Life in Poland at the time included
food insecurity, martial law, poverty,
Soviet bloc apartments, and crime.
Still, there were allotment gardens and
makeshift vegetable stands with rutabagas,
beets, and carrots to be eaten
raw, cooked, pickled, and fermented.
Cheese, bread, dumplings, and homebrewed
vodka and wine abounded.
Plus, the entire country of Poland is
mad, it turns out, for mushroom gathering.
Whole families took off to their
favorite secret spots, laden with baskets,
30 • ANGELUS • April 4, 2025
Heather King is an award-winning
author, speaker, and workshop leader.
buckets. and small sharp knives to cut
stems. Children were versed, practically
before they were weaned, in which
kinds were poisonous, which especially
coveted.
Some of Brewer’s most cherished
childhood memories are of mushroom-gathering
in the woods with her
mother: cigarette in one hand, bucket
in the other, for once absorbed and
happy.
Brewer includes a few recipes,
but these are hardly for the upscale
gourmand. One is for Polish potato
dumplings: potatoes, eggs, flour, salt;
another for Zurek: fermented rye soup.
A whole chapter is devoted to lard.
But while food is a thread that runs
throughout — the lack of it; the unbounded
joy and relief when food was
available; the sustaining memories of
shared meals, smells, foraging, stretching,
and making do — this is really a
book about the aching, unquenchable
human longing for love, and in particular
for Brewer’s anguished longing for
the love of her mother.
There were 12 or 13 psych ward commitments,
countless rehabs, violence.
More than once, she had to be cut
down from the bathroom pipes where
she’d tried to hang herself. But a child’s
longing for motherly love transcends
any kind of abuse, whether self-abuse
or abuse of others.
She, Brewer, tries to understand. Was
her mother a victim of generational
war trauma? Was she born with a kind
of alcoholic gene, hard-wired to derail
her life and the lives of those around
her? Was the underlying problem
undiagnosed manic depression?
Young Agata is saved by books, and
by a stable, firm, and loving figure: her
grandmother, who Brewer readily credits
with saving her life. She clothed,
fed, sheltered, and set boundaries with
the children during the periods when
their mother — her daughter — was
incommunicado or unreachable.
“I lived in a gray world
of totalitarian lack — of
freedom, of hope, of basic
necessities — but also in
a wonderland of Grandma’s
kitchen, with its
tea-stained glasses and the
earthy smell of gingerbread.
As with our beloved
mushrooms, my world was
both toxic and life-giving,
and I learned to navigate
Mother’s land mines, to
receive her blows, and
to recover on Grandma’s
lap, regaining strength to
weather the next family crisis.”
When Brewer took her own walk
on the wild side for several years as
an angry and disaffected youth, her
grandmother was always in the background:
unconditionally loving but
stern; steadfast, but also quick to point
out the perils of hanging out with the
wrong crowd, and to tout the value of
education.
Still it’s the love of her mother —
whose bizarre and profane behavior
continued to shadow Brewer from
across the ocean, who died at 60, who
never apologized — for which she
continues to hunger.
“Is it possible that if she had been
transplanted into another world, perhaps
one similar to my current relative
comfort of regular bill payments, a
fully stocked fridge, a small savings
account for travel and movie nights,
she would have managed her illness.
Would she have loved us more?”
“My God, my God, why have you forsaken
me?” cried Christ from the cross,
thereby putting himself in solidarity for
all time with every abused, neglected,
abandoned child who similarly asks:
Was it my fault? Could I have done
something differently?
No. What we can do is share our
stories, as Brewer has so bravely and
generously done.
Agata lzabela Brewer. | © AGATA SZCZESZAK-BREWER
And we can try to cultivate the heart
of that saving grandmother who surely
stands, still, at the foot of the cross with
Mary.
April 4, 2025 • ANGELUS • 31
LETTER AND SPIRIT
SCOTT HAHN
Scott Hahn is founder of the
St. Paul Center for Biblical
Theology; stpaulcenter.com.
‘The Way’ to read Scripture
The Hallow app created a sensation by featuring
St. Josemaría Escrivá (1902-1975) throughout the
season of Lent this year. The two publishers of his
most popular book, “The Way” (Scepter Pubs, $11.96),
found themselves overwhelmed by orders in the tens of
thousands.
I love that book. But I say we cannot begin to understand
the spirit of Josemaría until we understand his reading of
the Scriptures.
I would go so far as to
say that the Bible always
served as Josemaría’s
primary referential language.
Though he was
steeped in the teachings
of the Fathers and
doctors of the Church,
though he was fluent in
scholastic theology, and
though he kept current
with trends in contemporary
theology, it was
to Scripture that he
consistently turned in his
preaching and writing.
He quoted frequently
from both the Old and
New Testaments, but
especially from the Gospels.
No phrases appear
so often in his writings
and homilies as those
that invoke the sacred
page: “as the Gospel tells
us”; “as the Gospel advises
…”; “Sacred Scripture
tells us …”; “the Gospels
relate …”; “Remember
the Gospel story …”
He spoke of the Scriptures
as the very measure
of his way of life, which was “as old as the Gospel but, like
the Gospel, ever new.” At the beginning of “The Way,” he
wrote: “How I wish your bearing and conversation were
such that, on seeing or hearing you, people would say: This
man reads the life of Jesus Christ.” Conversely, in discussing
those who do not live Christian charity, Josemaría said,
“They seem not to have read the Gospel.”
Study of the Scripture, then, was essential to his spirituality.
In a sermon he wrote: “In our own life we must
reproduce Christ’s life. We need to come to know him by
reading and meditating on Scripture.”
He practiced a particular method for the meditative
reading of Scripture: “I
advised you to read the
New Testament and to
enter into each scene
and take part in it, as one
more of the characters.
The minutes you spend
in this way each day
enable you to incarnate
the Gospel, reflect it in
your life and help others
to reflect it.”
With the reading of
Scripture, then, comes
the grace of transformation,
of conversion.
Reading the Bible is
not a passive act, but an
active seeking and finding.
The saint once said:
“If we do this without
holding back, Christ’s
words will enter deep
into our soul and will
really change us. For ‘the
word of God is living
and active, sharper than
any two-edged sword,
piercing to the division
St. Josemaría Escrivá. | WIKIMEDIA COMMONS
of the soul and spirit, of
joints and marrow, and
discerning the thoughts
and intentions of the
heart’ (Hebrews 4:12).”
There’s just a little bit of Lent remaining. Join the crowd
gathered at Hallow by learning Scripture from this saint, in
the pages of his most popular book.
32 • ANGELUS • April 4, 2025
■ FRIDAY, MARCH 28
24 Hours for the Lord: Pilgrims of Hope. SoCal faithful will
join churches around the world in 24 Hours for the Lord.
Twenty-four churches in the Archdiocese of Los Angeles
will remain open for 24 hours for confession and prayer
from Friday, March 28 to Saturday, March 29. Visit hope.
lacatholics.org/24-hours for locations and times.
Filipino Culture Night and Fish Fry. St. Clare of Assisi
Church, 19606 Calla Way, Santa Clarita, 4:30-8 p.m.
Includes live music and entertainment. Wear cultural attire.
Menu: 2- or 3-piece dinner of beer-battered cod, coleslaw,
fries, and dinner rolls, ceviche. Dessert, beverages, and family
pack available for purchase. Cost: $16/2-piece dinner,
$18/3-piece dinner. Proceeds benefit wildfire victims. Visit
st-clare.org.
Torrance Fish Fry. Nativity Church, 1415 Engracia Ave.,
Torrance, 5-7 p.m. Hosted by the Knights of Columbus
Council 4919, the fish fry runs Fridays in Lent. Menu: Baked
or deep fried fish, baked potato or fries, coleslaw, roll, and
cake. Cost: $15/adults, $10/seniors, $8/children under 12.
50/50 raffle as time permits. Indoor seating and takeout
service available.
Fish Fry. St. Margaret Mary Church, 25511 Eshelman Ave.,
Lomita, 5-7 p.m. Held March 7, 21, 28, and April 4 and 11.
Menu: Baked or fried cod, french fries, coleslaw, roll, dessert,
milk, and coffee. Soft drinks, beer, and wine available.
Take out available. Cost: $12/adults, $10/seniors, $6/children.
Call Joe Vicelja at 310-408-9117.
St. Barnabas Lenten Friday and Fish Fry. St. Barnabas
Church, 3955 Orange Ave., Long Beach, 5:30 p.m. Stations
of the Cross, 6 p.m. Mass, 6:15-8:30 p.m. fish fry dinner.
Runs every Friday in Lent. First Fridays include adoration.
Visit stbarnabaslb.org.
Faith and Healing Bereavement Weekend. Holy Spirit
Retreat Center, 4316 Lanai Rd., Encino, 5:30 p.m. Sunday,
March 30, 1 p.m. With Cathy Narvaez. Visit hsrcenter.com
or call 818-784-4515.
Guest Speaker Series: Father Richard Spitzer, SJ. St.
Bede the Venerable Church, 215 Foothill Blvd., La Cañada
Flintridge, 7-8:30 p.m. Visit bede.org.
Retrouvaille Ministry for Couples in Crisis Weekend.
Spanish weekend runs March 28-30. If you’re having problems
in your marriage, there’s hope. You and your spouse
can find ways to communicate and overcome adversity.
Register with Marya Perez-Carrillo at 818-723-8704 or
Carlos Perez-Carrillo at 818-741-5172.
■ SATURDAY, MARCH 29
The Mysticism of Julian of Norwich. Loyola Institute
for Spirituality, 434 S. Batavia St., Orange, 9 a.m. Lenten
mini-retreat exploring Julian of Norwich’s down-to-earth,
feminist theology using guided meditation discussion, and
writing. Email ebeall@csjorange.org.
ACTHeals: Learning and Unlearning. St. Andrew Church,
538 Concord St., El Segundo, 10 a.m.-12 p.m. Aloysius
Michael Pattian. Day of silence and stillness will focus on
reacquainting ourselves to the interior life to encounter
the indwelling presence of the Holy Spirit. Love offerings
requested.
Catholic Bible Institute: Understanding Job. Zoom, 10-
11:30 a.m. Dr. Israel McGrew of the Augustine Institute will
explore the literature and theology of the book of Job and
the problems of evil and human ignorance. Cost: $10/person.
Register at lacatholics.org/events.
Lenten Day Retreat and Mass: 100% Autistic, 100%
Catholic. Pauline Books & Media, 3908 Sepulveda Blvd.,
Culver City, 10 a.m.-3 p.m. Father Matthew Schneider, an
autistic Catholic priest, offers insights on leading fulfilling
lives in the Faith. Donation: $30. RSVP to 310-397-8676 or
email culvercity@paulinemedia.com.
■ SUNDAY, MARCH 30
John A. Swanson Art Exhibit. St. Augustine Center, 2060
N. Vermont Ave., Los Angeles, 9 a.m.-1:30 p.m. Featuring
the work of world-renowned artist and former parishioner
of Our Mother of Good Counsel Church. OMGC Centennial
and Swanson Studio event. Free. Call 310-649-1210. Visit
JohnAugustSwanson.com.
Kontrapunktus Presents “Il Nuovo Orfeo: The Legacy of
Arcangelo Corelli.” St. Andrew Church, 311 N. Raymond
Ave., Pasadena, 8 p.m. Doors open one hour prior to start.
Featuring soloist Aubree Oliverson. Cost: $25/person.
Tickets available at kontrapunktus.com/tickets.
■ TUESDAY, APRIL 1
Archdiocesan Council of Catholic Women Lenten
Retreat: Pilgrims of Hope. Mary & Joseph Retreat Center,
5300 Crest Rd., Rancho Palos Verdes, 8 a.m.-2:30 p.m.
Speaker: Father Marinello Saguin. Fellowship, continental
breakfast, light lunch, and Mass included. Donation: $40/
person. Call Marissa Reyes at 310-483-9083 or email
ACCW.SW19@gmail.com.
■ WEDNESDAY, APRIL 2
“The Word of God” weekly series. St. Dorothy Church,
241 S. Valley Center Ave., Glendora, 7-8:30 p.m. Wednesdays
through May 7. Deepen your understanding of the
Catholic faith through dynamic DVD presentations by
Bishop Robert Barron, Dr. Edward Sri, Dr. Brant Pitre, and
Dr. Scott Hahn. Free events. No reservation required. Call
626-335-2811 or visit the Adult Faith Development ministry
page at www.stdorothy.org for more information.
■ FRIDAY, APRIL 4
Taize Prayer. Holy Spirit Retreat Center, 4316 Lanai Rd.,
Encino, 7 p.m. Runs April 4 and 11. With Sister Chris
Machado, SSS, and Sister Marie Lindemann, SSS. Visit
hsrcenter.com or call 818-784-4515.
■ SATURDAY, APRIL 5
Pilgrimage of Hope. All Souls Church, 1500 W. Main St.,
Alhambra, 8 a.m. Six-mile pilgrimage to mark the jubilee
year will proceed from All Souls Church to the Cathedral
of Our Lady of the Angels, and close with 11:30 a.m. Mass
with Archbishop José H. Gomez.
Faith and Healing Bereavement Retreat. St. Mary of the
Assumption, 7215 Newlin Ave., Whittier, 9 a.m.-6 p.m. For
those struggling with the death of a loved one. Cost: $75/
person, covers all materials, supplies, continental breakfast,
snacks, and lunch. RSVP to Cathy Narvaez at bereavement.
ministry@yahoo.com or call 562-631-8844 by Sunday,
March 30.
Freedom to Change: Alexander Technique. Holy Spirit
Retreat Center, 4316 Lanai Rd., Encino, 9 a.m.-5 p.m. With
Barbara and Seth Wegher-Thompson. Visit hsrcenter.com or
call 818-784-4515.
Items for the calendar of events are due four weeks prior to the date of the event. They may be emailed to calendar@angelusnews.com.
All calendar items must include the name, date, time, address of the event, and a phone number for additional information.
April 4, 2025 • ANGELUS • 33