INTRODUCTION TO SCHOLARLY EDITING ... - Rare Book School

Tanselle: Introduction to Scholarly Editing (2002) � Part 5: Some Noteworthy Reviews 53
Part 5
SOME NOTEWORTHY REVIEWS OF SCHOLARLY EDITIONS
(For comments on reviewing, see Angus Easson, "Reviewing Editions: Letters, Journals, Diaries," in
Literary Reviewing, ed. James O. Hoge (1987), pp. 44-67; Joseph R. McElrath, Jr., "The ADE Guidelines
for Reviewers of Editions," Documentary Editing 10.4 (December 1988): 22-23; William B. Willcox,
"Reviewing the Reviewers," Newsletter of the Association for Documentary Editing 1.1 (March 1979): 5-6;
Glenn W. LaFantasie, "Toward Better Reviewing of Local History Documentary Editions: A Nineteenth-
Century Model," Newsletter of the Association for Documentary Editing 4.1 (February 1982): 1-5; Hershel
Parker, "The Reviewing of Scholarly Editions," Editors' Notes 10.2 (Fall 1991): 16-24.)
A. Individual Editions
ADAMS. "A Dialogue: Peter Shaw and Robert J. Taylor on Editing the Adamses," Newsletter of the
Association for Documentary Editing 2.4 (December 1980): 4-9.
ANDERSON. G.T. Tanselle, "The Case Western Reserve Edition of Sherwood Anderson," Proof 4
(1975): 183-210.
BEAUMONT-FLETCHER. Philip Edwards, [Review of Bowers's edition, vol. 1], Library 5th ser. 23
(1968): 166-68. Johan Gerritsen, [Review of Bowers's edition, vol. 1], Review of English Studies n.s.
20 (1959): 84-87.
BLAKE. Santa Cruz Blake Study Group, [Review of Erdman's edition], Blake: An Illustrated Quarterly
18.1 (Summer 1984): 4-31. Stuart Curran, "The Blake Archive," Text 12 (1999): 216-19.
BRONTE. Bruce Harkness, [Review of the Clarendon Jane Eyre], Nineteenth Century Fiction 25
(1970-71): 355-69; rejoinder by Ian Jack and Margaret Smith, 26 (1971-72): 370-76. Kurt Tetzeli
von Rosdor, "Notes on Editing Victorian Novels: The Clarendon Editions of Villette and Scenes from
Clerical Life," Archiv für das Studium der Neueren Sprachen und Literaturen 224 (1987): 102-9.
BROWNING. Donald H. Reiman, [Review of Ohio University edition], Victorian Poetry 12 (1974):
86-96; reprinted in his Romantic Texts and Contexts (1987), pp. 55-68. Jacob Korg, "A Definitive
Edition of Browning's Poems [ed. Pettigrew and Collins]," Review 5 (1983): 41-48. Clyde de L.
Ryals, [Review of Longman Annotated English Poets edition], Text 8 (1995): 456-62.
BURTON. G.W. Pigman III, [Review of Clarendon Edition of the Anatomy], Huntington Library
Quarterly 54 (1991): 270-75. Ernest W. Sullivan II, [Review of Clarendon Edition], Text 7 (1994):
521-29.
BYRON. Donald H. Reiman, [Review of McGann's Oxford edition], Keats-Shelley Memorial Bulletin
34 (1983): 66-72; reprinted in Reiman's Romantic Texts and Contexts (1987), pp. 156-66.
CATHER. Keen Butterworth, [Review of Nebraska edition of O Pioneers!], Text 9 (1996): 442-46.
CHAUCER. Paul G. Ruggiers (ed.), Editing Chaucer: The Great Tradition (1984). Christian K. Zacher,
"Editorial Presence in the Variorum Chaucer," Review 6 (1984): 49-62. Roy Vance Ramsey, "F.N.
Robinson's Editing of the Canterbury Tales," Studies in Bibliography 42 (1989): 134-52.
CLEMENS. Robert C. Bray, "Tom Sawyer Once and for All," Review 3 (1981): 75-93. Guy Cardwell,
"Author, Intention, Text: The California Mark Twain," Review 11 (1989): 255-88. Philip Cohen,
"The Making and Marketing of Huck Finn," Text 8 (1995): 349-75.
COLERIDGE. Donald H. Reiman, "The Bollingen Coleridge," in his Romantic Texts and Contexts
(1987), pp. 69-84.
CONRAD. James M. Haule, "The Cambridge Conrad," Review 14 (1992): 183-90.
CRANE. Leon Howard, [Review of Bowers's edition], Nineteenth Century Fiction 25 (1970-71): 232-35.
This page is from a document available in full at http://www.rarebookschool.org/tanselle/