FMEDA and Proven-in-use Assessment - r. stahl

gclWqzezKG

FMEDA and Proven-in-use Assessment - r. stahl

FMEDA and Proven-in-use Assessment

Khe`[Yj6

N[cf[hWjkh[ NhWdic_jj[h Nof[ 5-4.+&,)1&)&&

$0**.,c< Ykhh[dj ekjfkj%

>kijec[h6

L* MNedjhWYj Ie*6 MN


Management summary

N^_i h[fehj ikccWh_p[i j^[ h[ikbji e\ j^[ ^WhZmWh[ Wii[iic[dj WYYehZ_d] je D@> 2-1,4 m_j^

fhel[d)_d)ki[ Yedi_Z[hWj_ed YWhh_[Z ekj ed j^[ N[cf[hWjkh[ NhWdic_jj[h Nof[ 5-4.+&,)1&)&& m_j^

^WhZmWh[ l[hi_ed L[l* = WdZ ie\jmWh[ l[hi_ed P,-),5* NWXb[ - ]_l[i Wd el[hl_[m e\ j^[

Z_\\[h[dj l[hi_edi j^Wj X[bed] je j^[ Yedi_Z[h[Z N[cf[hWjkh[ NhWdic_jj[h Nof[ 5-4.+&,)1&)&&*

N^[ ^WhZmWh[ Wii[iic[dj Yedi_iji e\ W AW_bkh[ HeZ[i( @\\[Yji WdZ ?_W]deij_Yi ecfed[dj

L[b_WX_b_jo CWdZXeea \eh Khe\_b[ -* N^[ WdWboi_i ^Wi Wbie X[[d YWhh_[Z ekj m_j^ j^[ XWi_Y \W_bkh[

hWj[i \hec j^[ M_[c[di ijWdZWhZ MI .51,,* Cem[l[h Wi j^[ YecfWh_ied X[jm[[d j^[i[ jme

ZWjWXWi[i ^Wi i^emd j^Wj j^[ Z_\\[h[dY[i Wh[ m_j^_d Wd WYY[fjWXb[ jeb[hWdY[ edbo j^[ h[ikbji

XWi[Z ed e\ j^[ %)&$" ZWjWXWi[ Wh[ b_ij[Z*

N^[ jme Y^Wdd[bi ed j^[ jme Y^Wdd[b Z[l_Y[i i^Wbb dej X[ ki[Z _d j^[ iWc[ iW\[jo \kdYj_ed( [*]*

je _dYh[Wi[ j^[ ^WhZmWh[ \Wkbj jeb[hWdY[ je WY^_[l[ W ^_]^[h MDG( Wi j^[o YedjW_d Yecced

Yecfed[dji* N^[ AH@?< Wffb_[i je [_j^[h Y^Wdd[b ki[Z _d W i_d]b[ iW\[jo \kdYj_ed* N^[ jme

Y^Wdd[bi cWo X[ ki[Z _d i[fWhWj[ iW\[jo \kdYj_edi _\ Zk[ h[]WhZ _i jWa[d e\ j^[ feii_X_b_jo e\

Yecced \W_bkh[i*

- D*M* Ddjh_di_Y MW\[jo


N^[ N[cf[hWjkh[ NhWdic_jj[h Nof[ 5-4.+&,)1&)&& _i Yedi_Z[h[Z je X[ W Nof[ = . ikXioij[c m_j^

W ^WhZmWh[ \Wkbj jeb[hWdY[ e\ ,* Aeh Nof[ = ikXioij[ci m_j^ W ^WhZmWh[ \Wkbj jeb[hWdY[ e\ , j^[

MAA i^Wbb X[ ; 5," \eh MDG . ikXioij[ci WYYehZ_d] je jWXb[ / e\ D@> 2-1,4).*


Table 2: Summary – Failure rates per IEC 61508

Failure category Failure rates (in FIT)

Profile 1

Fail Safe Detected ( SD) 0

AW_b iW\[ Z[j[Yj[Z ,

Fail Safe Undetected ( SU) 173

AW_b iW\[ kdZ[j[Yj[Z ,

Ie [\\[Yj -10


Table of Contents

HWdW][c[dj ikccWho******************************************************************************************************************.

- Kkhfei[ WdZ MYef[ ****************************************************************************************************************2

. Khe`[Yj cWdW][c[dj***************************************************************************************************************3

.*- %)&$"*******************************************************************************************************************************3

.*. Leb[i e\ j^[ fWhj_[i _dlebl[Z*******************************************************************************************3

.*/ MjWdZWhZi + G_j[hWjkh[ ki[Z*********************************************************************************************3

.*0 L[\[h[dY[ ZeYkc[dji*****************************************************************************************************3

.*0*- ?eYkc[djWj_ed fhel_Z[Z Xo j^[ Ykijec[h************************************************************3

.*0*. ?eYkc[djWj_ed ][d[hWj[Z Xo exida *********************************************************************5

/ ?[iYh_fj_ed e\ j^[ WdWbop[Z ikXioij[c ********************************************************************************-,

0 AW_bkh[ HeZ[i( @\\[Yji( WdZ ?_W]deij_Yi


1 Purpose and Scope

B[d[hWbbo j^h[[ efj_edi [n_ij m^[d Ze_d] Wd Wii[iic[dj e\ i[diehi( _dj[h\WY[i WdZ+eh \_dWb

[b[c[dji*

Option 1: Hardware assessment according to IEC 61508

Jfj_ed - _i W ^WhZmWh[ Wii[iic[dj Xo WYYehZ_d] je j^[ h[b[lWdj \kdYj_edWb iW\[jo

ijWdZWhZ$i% b_a[ D@> 2-1,4 eh DMJ -/405)-* N^[ ^WhZmWh[ Wii[iic[dj Yedi_iji e\ W AH@?< je

Z[j[hc_d[ j^[ \Wkbj X[^Wl_eh WdZ j^[ \W_bkh[ hWj[i e\ j^[ Z[l_Y[( m^_Y^ Wh[ j^[d ki[Z je YWbYkbWj[

j^[ MW\[ AW_bkh[ AhWYj_ed $MAA% WdZ j^[ Wl[hW][ KheXWX_b_jo e\ AW_bkh[ ed ?[cWdZ $KA? 2-1,4 + D@> 2-1--* N^_i efj_ed Ze[i dej _dYbkZ[ Wd Wii[iic[dj e\ j^[ Z[l[befc[dj

fheY[ii*

Option 2: Hardware assessment with proven-in-use consideration according to IEC 61508 /

IEC 61511

Jfj_ed . [nj[dZi Jfj_ed - m_j^ Wd Wii[iic[dj e\ j^[ fhel[d)_d)ki[ ZeYkc[djWj_ed e\ j^[

Z[l_Y[ _dYbkZ_d] j^[ ceZ_\_YWj_ed fheY[ii*

N^_i efj_ed \eh fh[)[n_ij_d] fhe]hWccWXb[ [b[Yjhed_Y Z[l_Y[i fhel_Z[i j^[ iW\[jo

_dijhkc[djWj_ed [d]_d[[h m_j^ j^[ h[gk_h[Z \W_bkh[ ZWjW Wi f[h D@> 2-1,4 + D@> 2-1--* Q^[d

YecX_d[Z m_j^ fbWdj if[Y_\_Y fhel[d)_d)ki[ h[YehZi( _j cWo ^[bf m_j^ fh_eh)ki[ `kij_\_YWj_ed f[h

D@> 2-1-- \eh i[diehi( \_dWb [b[c[dji WdZ ej^[h K@ \_[bZ Z[l_Y[i*

Option 3: Full assessment according to IEC 61508

Jfj_ed / _i W \kbb Wii[iic[dj Xo WYYehZ_d] je j^[ h[b[lWdj Wffb_YWj_ed ijWdZWhZ$i% b_a[

D@> 2-1-- eh @I .54 WdZ j^[ d[Y[iiWho \kdYj_edWb iW\[jo ijWdZWhZ$i% b_a[ D@> 2-1,4 eh

DMJ -/405)-* N^[ \kbb Wii[iic[dj [nj[dZi efj_ed - Xo Wd Wii[iic[dj e\ Wbb \Wkbj Wle_ZWdY[ WdZ

\Wkbj Yedjheb c[Wikh[i Zkh_d] ^WhZmWh[ WdZ ie\jmWh[ Z[l[befc[dj*

N^_i efj_ed fhel_Z[i j^[ iW\[jo _dijhkc[djWj_ed [d]_d[[h m_j^ j^[ h[gk_h[Z \W_bkh[ ZWjW Wi f[h

D@> 2-1,4 + D@> 2-1-- WdZ Yed\_Z[dY[ j^Wj ik\\_Y_[dj Wjj[dj_ed ^Wi X[[d ]_l[d je ioij[cWj_Y

\W_bkh[i Zkh_d] j^[ Z[l[befc[dj fheY[ii e\ j^[ Z[l_Y[*

This assessment shall be done according to option 2.

N^_i ZeYkc[dj i^Wbb Z[iYh_X[ j^[ h[ikbji e\ j^[ Wii[iic[dj YWhh_[Z ekj ed j^[ N[cf[hWjkh[

NhWdic_jj[h Nof[ 5-4.+&,)1&)&& m_j^ ^WhZmWh[ l[hi_ed L[l* = WdZ ie\jmWh[ l[hi_ed P,-),5*

NWXb[ - ]_l[i Wd el[hl_[m e\ j^[ Z_\\[h[dj l[hi_edi j^Wj X[bed] je j^[ Yedi_Z[h[Z N[cf[hWjkh[

NhWdic_jj[h Nof[ 5-4.+&,)1&)&&*

N^[ _d\ehcWj_ed _d j^_i h[fehj YWd X[ ki[Z je [lWbkWj[ m^[j^[h W i[dieh ikXioij[c( _dYbkZ_d]

j^[ N[cf[hWjkh[ NhWdic_jj[h Nof[ 5-4.+&,)1&)&& c[[ji j^[ Wl[hW][ KheXWX_b_jo e\ AW_bkh[ ed

?[cWdZ $KA? 2-1,4* Dj does not Yedi_Z[h Wdo YWbYkbWj_edi d[Y[iiWho \eh

fhel_d] _djh_di_Y iW\[jo*

u %)&$"!#(' BcXC MN


2 Project management

2.1 #%$"!

%)&$" _i ed[ e\ j^[ mehbZqi b[WZ_d] ademb[Z][ YecfWd_[i if[Y_Wb_p_d] _d WkjecWj_ed ioij[c

iW\[jo WdZ WlW_bWX_b_jo m_j^ el[h /,, o[Whi e\ YkckbWj_l[ [nf[h_[dY[ _d \kdYj_edWb iW\[jo*

AekdZ[Z Xo i[l[hWb e\ j^[ mehbZqi jef h[b_WX_b_jo WdZ iW\[jo [nf[hji \hec Wii[iic[dj

eh]Wd_pWj_edi WdZ cWdk\WYjkh[hi( %)&$" _i W fWhjd[hi^_f YecfWdo m_j^ e\\_Y[i WhekdZ j^[ mehbZ*

%)&$" e\\[hi jhW_d_d]( YeWY^_d]( fhe`[Yj eh_[dj[Z Yedikbj_d] i[hl_Y[i( _dj[hd[j XWi[Z iW\[jo

[d]_d[[h_d] jeebi( Z[jW_b fheZkYj WiikhWdY[ WdZ Y[hj_\_YWj_ed WdWboi_i WdZ W Yebb[Yj_ed e\ ed)b_d[

iW\[jo WdZ h[b_WX_b_jo h[iekhY[i* %)&$" cW_djW_di W Yecfh[^[di_l[ \W_bkh[ hWj[ WdZ \W_bkh[ ceZ[

ZWjWXWi[ ed fheY[ii [gk_fc[dj*

2.2 Roles of the parties involved

L* MN


T?/U 5- 4.2 ,. ., ,V,0*fZ\ NWXb[ \eh Y_hYk_j Z_W]hWc

rN[cf[hWjkh[ NhWdic_jj[h Nof[

5-4.+&,)1&)&&s 5- 4.2 ,- ., , DdZ[n

,0 e\ .-*-.*,5

T?0U Mjk[Yab_ij[ 5-4. -,)1-*n/*fZ\ KWhji b_ij \eh 5-4.

T?1U >WZijWh ) 5-4.VPWhVDR.*fZ\ Hekdj_d] b_ij \eh j^[ Z_\\[h[dj

Yed\_]khWj_edi e\ 5-4.

T?2U @djm_Yabkd]i^WdZXkY^ MH Wajk[bbVWkipk]*p_f ?[l[befc[dj ^WdZXeea

T?3U -V-VZ[VW[dZ[hkd]ifhep[ii-*fZ\ Abem Z_W]hWc rHeZ_\_YWj_ed KheY[iis

WYYehZ_d] je j^[ d[m Z[l[befc[dj

fheY[ii

T?4U -V-VZ[VW[dZ[hkd]ifhep[ii.*fZ\ Abem Z_W]hWc rHeZ_\_YWj_ed KheY[iis

WYYehZ_d] je j^[ d[m Z[l[befc[dj

fheY[ii

T?5U IA P,-)/- P,.)/-*p_f @nWcfb[i e\ j^[ ceZ_\_YWj_ed fheY[ii

T?-,U 5031 /,*3*,/*fZ\ HeZ_\_YWj_ed h[gk[ij ?JH

T?--U >^[Yab_ij[ MH K^Wi[ . x dZ[hkd] MQ-*nbi >^[Yab_ij f^Wi[ . rie\jmWh[

ceZ_\_YWj_eds

T?-.U hfjVKhz \=[h_Y^j/,.3*fZ\ @nWcfb[ e\ W h[fW_h h[fehj

T?-/U -V-VZ[VcWjh_nVh[abWcWj_ediWXm_Yabkd]*fZ\ A_[bZ ZWjW [lWbkWj_ed fheY[ii

T?-0U -V-VZ[VY^[Yab_ij[V\k[hVgkWb_jW[jiah[_i[*fZ\ >^[Yab_ij \eh j^[ \_[bZ ZWjW [lWbkWj_ed

fheY[ii

T?-1U DMfWY CQ AQ L[l_i_edi 5-4.*fZ\ C_ijeho e\ ^WhZmWh[ WdZ ie\jmWh[

h[l_i_edi

T?-2U ijz YapW^b[d 5-4.VV\z h MDG =[jhWY^jkd]*nbin e\

./*,3*,4

A_[bZ ZWjW [lWbkWj_ed $iebZ Z[l_Y[i7

ef[hWj_d] ^ekhi%

T?-3U L[abWcWj_ed[d 5-4. .,,2).,,3*nbin e\ .1*,3*,4 A_[bZ ZWjW [lWbkWj_ed $h[jkhd[Z

Z[l_Y[i%

T?-4U FkdZ[dVL[\[h[dpVG_ij[VNof 5-4.VEW^h

,2V,3*nbin e\ .4*,3*,4

G_ij e\ Wffb_YWj_edi

T?-5U >^[Yab_ij[VDcfWYj WdWboi[*p_f e\ ,-*,4*,4 DcfWYj WdWboi[i \eh ceZ_\_YWj_edi

\hec P,-),0 je P,-),4

T?.,U SkehZdkd]V H


T?.1U P[hi_ed P,-),3 pk P,-),4*p_f C_]^b_]^j[Z ie\jmWh[ Y^Wd][i \hec

l[hi_ed P,-),3 je P,-),4

T?.2U H


3 Description of the analyzed subsystem

N^[ N[cf[hWjkh[ NhWdic_jj[h Nof[ 5-4.+&,)1&)&& _i Yedi_Z[h[Z je X[ W Nof[ = ikXioij[c m_j^

W ^WhZmWh[ \Wkbj jeb[hWdY[ e\ ,*

N^[ AH@?< e\ j^[ N[cf[hWjkh[ NhWdic_jj[h Nof[ 5-4.+&,)1&)&& ^Wi X[[d YWhh_[Z ekj ed j^[

fWhji m_j^_d j^[ h[Z h[YjWd]kbWh _dZ_YWj[Z _d A_]kh[ -*

Figure 1: Block diagram of the Temperature Transmitter Type 9182/10-5*-**

A_]kh[ - _i h[fh[i[djWj_l[ \eh Wbb N[cf[hWjkh[ NhWdic_jj[h Nof[ 5-4.+&,)1&)&& b_ij[Z _d NWXb[ -*

u %)&$"!#(' BcXC MN


4 Failure Modes, Effects, and Diagnostics Analysis

N^[ AW_bkh[ HeZ[i( @\\[Yji( WdZ ?_W]deij_Y


4.2 Methodology – FMEDA, Failure rates

< AW_bkh[ HeZ[i WdZ @\\[Yji


4.2.2 Assumptions

N^[ \ebbem_d] Wiikcfj_edi ^Wl[ X[[d cWZ[ Zkh_d] j^[ AW_bkh[ HeZ[i( @\\[Yji( WdZ ?_W]deij_Y

*

# Jdbo j^[ Ykhh[dj ekjfkj 0**.,c< _i ki[Z \eh iW\[jo Wffb_YWj_edi*

# Jdbo ed[ _dfkj WdZ ed[ ekjfkj Wh[ fWhj e\ j^[ Yedi_Z[h[Z iW\[jo \kdYj_ed*

# G[WZ Xh[WaW][ Z[j[Yj_ed _i WYj_lWj[Z*

# N^[ Wffb_YWj_ed fhe]hWc _d j^[ iW\[jo be]_Y iebl[h _i Yed\_]kh[Z je Z[j[Yj kdZ[h)hWd][ WdZ

el[h)hWd][ \W_bkh[i WdZ Ze[i dej WkjecWj_YWbbo jh_f ed j^[i[ \W_bkh[i7 j^[h[\eh[ j^[i[ \W_bkh[i

^Wl[ X[[d YbWii_\_[Z Wi ZWd][heki Z[j[Yj[Z \W_bkh[i*

4.3 Results

Aeh j^[ YWbYkbWj_ed e\ j^[ MW\[ AW_bkh[ AhWYj_ed $MAA% j^[ \ebbem_d] ^Wi je X[ dej[Z6

"jejWb Yedi_iji e\ j^[ ikc e\ Wbb Yecfed[dj \W_bkh[ hWj[i* N^_i c[Wdi6

"jejWb 9 "M? ' "MO ' "?? ' "?O

MAA 9 - t "?O + "jejWb

?>? 9 "?? + $"?? ' "?O%

HN=A 9 HNNA ' HNNL 9 $- + $"jejWb ' "de fWhj%% ' .0 ^

u %)&$"!#(' BcXC MN


4.3.1 Temperature Transmitter Type 9182/*0-5*-**

N^[ AH@?< YWhh_[Z ekj ed j^[ N[cf[hWjkh[ NhWdic_jj[h Nof[ 5-4.+&,)1&)&& b[WZi kdZ[h j^[

Wiikcfj_edi Z[iYh_X[Z _d i[Yj_edi 0*.*. WdZ 0*/ je j^[ \ebbem_d] \W_bkh[ hWj[i6

Failure category Failure rates (in FIT)

Profile 1

Fail Safe Detected ( SD) 0

AW_b iW\[ Z[j[Yj[Z ,

Fail Safe Undetected ( SU) 173

AW_b iW\[ kdZ[j[Yj[Z ,

Ie [\\[Yj -10


5 Using the FMEDA results

N^[ \ebbem_d] i[Yj_ed Z[iYh_X[i ^em je Wffbo j^[ h[ikbji e\ j^[ AH@?


N^[ jejWb \W_bkh[ hWj[ \eh j^[ j[cf[hWjkh[ i[dieh Wii[cXbo m_j^ j^[ N[cf[hWjkh[ NhWdic_jj[h

Nof[ 5-4.+&,)1&)&& _i6

$ M? 9 , ADN

$ MO 9 -3/ ADN

$ ?? 9 5,, ADN ' /40 ADN 9 -.40 ADN

$ ?O 9 -,, ADN ' -13 ADN 9 .13 ADN

N^[i[ dkcX[hi YekbZ X[ ki[Z _d iW\[jo _dijhkc[dj[Z \kdYj_ed MDG l[h_\_YWj_ed YWbYkbWj_edi \eh

j^_i i[j e\ Wiikcfj_edi* Aeh j^[i[ Y_hYkcijWdY[i( j^[ MW\[ AW_bkh[ AhWYj_ed e\ j^_i j[cf[hWjkh[

i[dieh Wii[cXbo _i 41"*

5.1.2 Temperature Transmitter Type 9182/*0-5*-** with 4-wire RTD

N^[ \W_bkh[ ceZ[ Z_ijh_Xkj_ed \eh Wd LN? Wbie Z[f[dZi ed j^[ Wffb_YWj_ed m_j^ a[o lWh_WXb[i

X[_d] ijh[ii b[l[b( LN? m_h[ b[d]j^ WdZ LN? jof[ $.+/ m_h[ eh 0 m_h[%* N^[ a[o ijh[ii lWh_WXb[i

Wh[ ^_]^ l_XhWj_ed WdZ \h[gk[dj j[cf[hWjkh[ YoYb_d] Wi j^[i[ Wh[ ademd je YWki[ YhWYai _d j^[

ikXijhWj[ b[WZ_d] je Xhea[d b[WZ Yedd[Yj_ed m[bZi* Nof_YWb \W_bkh[ hWj[ Z_ijh_Xkj_edi Wh[ i^emd _d

NWXb[ -3* N^[ N[cf[hWjkh[ NhWdic_jj[h Nof[ 5-4.+&,)1&)&& m_bb Z[j[Yj ef[d Y_hYk_j WdZ i^ehj

Y_hYk_j LN? \W_bkh[i WdZ Zh_l[ _ji ekjfkj je j^[ WbWhc ijWj[ ed Z[j[Yj[Z \W_bkh[i e\ j^[ LN?*

Table 5 Failure mode distribution for 4-wire RTD, low stress environment

RTD Failure Modes – Device with extension wires Percentage

Jf[d >_hYk_j 4."

M^ehj >_hYk_j 0"

?h_\j $N[cf[hWjkh[ c[Wikh[c[dj _d [hheh% -0"

< Yecfb[j[ j[cf[hWjkh[ i[dieh Wii[cXbo Yedi_ij_d] e\ j^[ N[cf[hWjkh[ NhWdic_jj[h Nof[

5-4.+&,)1&)&& WdZ W 0)m_h[ LN? m_j^ [nj[di_ed m_h[i ikffb_[Z m_j^ j^[ N[cf[hWjkh[ NhWdic_jj[h

Nof[ 5-4.+&,)1&)&& YWd X[ ceZ[b[Z Xo Yedi_Z[h_d] W i[h_[i ikXioij[c m^[h[ \W_bkh[ eYYkhi _\

[_j^[h Yecfed[dj \W_bi* Aeh ikY^ W ioij[c( \W_bkh[ hWj[i Wh[ WZZ[Z*


5.2 Example PFDAVG calculation

Dj _i j^[ h[ifedi_X_b_jo e\ j^[ MW\[jo Ddijhkc[dj[Z AkdYj_ed Z[i_]d[h je Ze YWbYkbWj_edi \eh j^[

[dj_h[ MDA* h[Yecc[dZi j^[ WYYkhWj[ HWhael XWi[Z [nMDG[dj_W jeeb \eh j^_i fkhfei[*

N^[ \ebbem_d] h[ikbji ckij X[ Yedi_Z[h[Z _d YecX_dWj_ed m_j^ KA?


6 Proven-in-use Assessment

6.1 Supplemental information to assist in prior-use justification

2-1--)- A_hij @Z_j_ed .,,/),- i[Yj_ed --*0*0 \eh Wbb ikXioij[ci $[*]*( i[dieh(

\_dWb [b[c[dji WdZ ded)K@ be]_Y iebl[hi% [nY[fj K@ be]_Y iebl[hi j^[ c_d_ckc \Wkbj jeb[hWdY[

if[Y_\_[Z _d NWXb[ 2 e\ j^_i ijWdZWhZ cWo X[ h[ZkY[Z Xo ed[ _\ j^[ Z[l_Y[i kdZ[h Yedi_Z[hWj_ed

Yecfbo m_j^ Wbb e\ j^[ \ebbem_d]6

# j^[ ^WhZmWh[ e\ j^[ Z[l_Y[ _i i[b[Yj[Z ed j^[ XWi_i e\ fh_eh ki[ $i[[ --*1*/%

# j^[ Z[l_Y[ Wbbemi WZ`kijc[dj e\ fheY[ii)h[bWj[Z fWhWc[j[hi edbo( [*]*( c[Wikh_d] hWd][(

kfiYWb[ eh ZemdiYWb[ \W_bkh[ Z_h[Yj_ed( [jY*7

# j^[ WZ`kijc[dj e\ j^[ fheY[ii)h[bWj[Z fWhWc[j[hi e\ j^[ Z[l_Y[ _i fhej[Yj[Z( [*]*( `kcf[h(

fWiimehZ7

# j^[ \kdYj_ed ^Wi W MDG h[gk_h[c[dj b[ii j^Wd 0*

N^[ \ebbem_d] _d\ehcWj_ed YWd X[ ki[Z je Wii_ij Wd [dZ ki[h m_j^ fh_eh)ki[ `kij_\_YWj_ed e\ j^[

N[cf[hWjkh[ NhWdic_jj[h Nof[ 5-4.+&,)1&)&&*

Requirement Argumentation

Khel[ e\ gkWb_jo cWdW][c[dj

WdZ ef[hWj_d] [nf[h_[dY[


7 Terms and Definitions

?>?

?_W]deij_Y >el[hW][ e\ ZWd][heki \W_bkh[i

ADN AW_bkh[ Dd N_c[ $-n-, )5 \W_bkh[i f[h ^ekh%

AH@?< AW_bkh[ HeZ[ @\\[Yj WdZ ?_W]deij_Y


8 Status of the document

8.1 Liability

%)&$" fh[fWh[i h[fehji XWi[Z ed c[j^eZi WZleYWj[Z _d Ddj[hdWj_edWb ijWdZWhZi* AW_bkh[ hWj[i

Wh[ eXjW_d[Z \hec W Yebb[Yj_ed e\ _dZkijh_Wb ZWjWXWi[i* %)&$" WYY[fji de b_WX_b_jo m^Wjie[l[h \eh

j^[ ki[ e\ j^[i[ dkcX[hi eh \eh j^[ Yehh[Yjd[ii e\ j^[ ijWdZWhZi ed m^_Y^ j^[ ][d[hWb

YWbYkbWj_ed c[j^eZi Wh[ XWi[Z*

?k[ je \kjkh[ fej[dj_Wb Y^Wd][i _d j^[ ijWdZWhZi( X[ij WlW_bWXb[ _d\ehcWj_ed WdZ X[ij fhWYj_Y[i(

j^[ Ykhh[dj AH@?< h[ikbji fh[i[dj[Z _d j^_i h[fehj cWo dej X[ \kbbo Yedi_ij[dj m_j^ h[ikbji j^Wj

mekbZ X[ fh[i[dj[Z \eh j^[ _Z[dj_YWb fheZkYj Wj iec[ \kjkh[ j_c[*


Appendix 1: Possibilities to reveal dangerous undetected faults during the

proof test

KO /(1-"

D-,3 /(01"

D/,-)? /(-4"

N-,- /(-1"

-,," \kdYj_edWb j[ij m_j^ Z_\\[h[dj _dfkj i_]dWbi

WdZ ced_jeh_d] e\ j^[ Yehh[ifedZ_d] ekjfkj i_]dWb

-,," \kdYj_edWb j[ij m_j^ Z_\\[h[dj _dfkj i_]dWbi

WdZ ced_jeh_d] e\ j^[ Yehh[ifedZ_d] ekjfkj i_]dWb

-,," \kdYj_edWb j[ij m_j^ Z_\\[h[dj _dfkj i_]dWbi

WdZ ced_jeh_d] e\ j^[ Yehh[ifedZ_d] ekjfkj i_]dWb

-,," \kdYj_edWb j[ij m_j^ Z_\\[h[dj _dfkj i_]dWbi

WdZ ced_jeh_d] e\ j^[ Yehh[ifedZ_d] ekjfkj i_]dWb

-,," \kdYj_edWb j[ij m_j^ Z_\\[h[dj _dfkj i_]dWbi

WdZ ced_jeh_d] e\ j^[ Yehh[ifedZ_d] ekjfkj i_]dWb

-,," \kdYj_edWb j[ij m_j^ Z_\\[h[dj _dfkj i_]dWbi

WdZ ced_jeh_d] e\ j^[ Yehh[ifedZ_d] ekjfkj i_]dWb

-,," \kdYj_edWb j[ij m_j^ Z_\\[h[dj _dfkj i_]dWbi

WdZ ced_jeh_d] e\ j^[ Yehh[ifedZ_d] ekjfkj i_]dWb

-,," \kdYj_edWb j[ij m_j^ Z_\\[h[dj _dfkj i_]dWbi

WdZ ced_jeh_d] e\ j^[ Yehh[ifedZ_d] ekjfkj i_]dWb

-,," \kdYj_edWb j[ij m_j^ Z_\\[h[dj _dfkj i_]dWbi

WdZ ced_jeh_d] e\ j^[ Yehh[ifedZ_d] ekjfkj i_]dWb

-,," \kdYj_edWb j[ij m_j^ Z_\\[h[dj _dfkj i_]dWbi

WdZ ced_jeh_d] e\ j^[ Yehh[ifedZ_d] ekjfkj i_]dWb

Appendix 2: Possible proof tests to detect dangerous undetected faults

< feii_Xb[ fhee\ j[ij _i Z[iYh_X[Z _d j^[ iW\[jo cWdkWb \eh j^[ N[cf[hWjkh[ NhWdic_jj[h Nof[

5-4.+&,)1&)&& $i[[ T?/-U%* N^[ fhee\ j[ij Yel[hW][ _i Yedi_Z[h[Z je X[ 55"*

u %)&$"!#(' BcXC MN


Appendix 3: Impact of lifetime of critical components on the failure rate

2-1,4).( W ki[\kb b_\[j_c[( XWi[Z ed [nf[h_[dY[( i^ekbZ X[

Wiikc[Z*


Appendix 3: Description of the considered profiles

Appendix 3.1: electronic database

Khe\_b[ Khe\_b[ WYYehZ_d] je D@>2,210)- U N[cf[hWjkh[ >oYb[

+ /21 ZWoiU

$[nj[hdWb% $_di_Z[ Xen%

- =. /, 2, 1

. >/ .1 /, .1

/ >/ .1 01 .1

KLJADG@ -6

>WX_d[j cekdj[Z [gk_fc[dj jof_YWbbo ^Wi i_]d_\_YWdj j[cf[hWjkh[ h_i[ Zk[ je fem[h Z_ii_fWj_ed

Xkj _i ikX`[Yj[Z je edbo c_d_cWb ZW_bo j[cf[hWjkh[ im_d]i*

KLJADG@ .6

Gem fem[h [b[Yjh_YWb $jme)m_h[% \_[bZ fheZkYji ^Wl[ c_d_cWb i[b\ ^[Wj_d] WdZ Wh[ ikX`[Yj[Z je

ZW_bo j[cf[hWjkh[ im_d]i*

KLJADG@ /6

B[d[hWb $\ekh)m_h[% \_[bZ fheZkYji cWo ^Wl[ ceZ[hWj[ i[b\ ^[Wj_d] WdZ Wh[ ikX`[Yj[Z je ZW_bo

j[cf[hWjkh[ im_d]i*

u %)&$"!#(' BcXC MN


Appendix 4 to

Report No.: STAHL 07/07-23 R016

Version V2, Revision R1, January 2011

Project:

Temperature Transmitter Type 9182/*0-5*-**

(4..20mA current output)

Customer:

R. STAHL Schaltgeräte GmbH

Waldenburg

Germany

Jan Hettenbach

The document was prepared using best effort. The authors make no warranty of any kind and shall not be liable in

any event for incidental or consequential damages in connection with the application of the document.

© All rights on the format of this technical report reserved.


Appendix 4: Failure rates according to IEC 61508:2010

Table 1: Failure rates

Failure category Failure rates (in FIT)

Fail Safe Detected ( SD) 0

Fail Safe Undetected ( SU) 0

Fail Dangerous Detected ( DD) 384

Fail Dangerous Detected ("DD) 221

Fail High (H) 45

Fail Low (L) 118

Fail Annunciation Detected ("AD) 0

Fail Dangerous Undetected ( DU) 156

Fail Annunciation Undetected ("AU) 20

No effect 154

No part 234

Total failure rate (safety function) 540

SFF 1 71%

SIL AC 2 SIL2

1

The complete subsystem will need to be evaluated to determine the overall Safe Failure Fraction. The

number listed is for reference only.

2

SIL AC (architectural constraints) means that the calculated values are within the range for hardware

architectural constraints for the corresponding SIL but does not imply that all related IEC 61508

requirements are fulfilled.

© %)&$"!#(' GmbH appendix 4_stahl 9182-x3-x4 4-20ma 07-07-23 r016 v2r1.doc, April 17, 2012

Jan Hettenbach Page 2 of 3


Table 2: PFDAVG Values

Configuration T[Proof] = 1

year

T[Proof] = 3

years

T[Proof] = 5

years

T[Proof] = 10

years

9182_x3x4_current PFDAVG = 1,31E-03 PFDAVG = 2,54E-03 PFDAVG = 3,77E-03 PFDAVG = 6,86E-03

The listed PFDAVG values are calculated for a proof test coverage of 90%.

Figure 1: PFDAVG (t)

© %)&$"!#(' GmbH appendix 4_stahl 9182-x3-x4 4-20ma 07-07-23 r016 v2r1.doc, April 17, 2012

Jan Hettenbach Page 3 of 3

More magazines by this user
Similar magazines