31.05.2018 Views

I. Uluslararası Beyaz Et Kongresi

Bildiriler Kitabı

Bildiriler Kitabı

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Committees<br />

Program & Contents<br />

Sözlü sunumlar (Oral presentations)........................................................ 1<br />

Poster sunumlar (Poster presentations)………………………………… 309<br />

İngilizce sunumlar (Full texts presented in English)……………..…….. 431<br />

ii


Kongere Başkan (Congress President)<br />

Prof. Dr. Necmettin CEYLAN Ankara Üniversitesi<br />

Kongre Düzenleme Kurulu (Organization Committee)*<br />

Ebru ALKAZAK<br />

Banvit<br />

Özgür BAYRAM<br />

Mudurnu Piliç<br />

Tolga BİRCAN<br />

BESD-BİR<br />

Yüce CANOLER<br />

BESD-BİR<br />

Ali ÇALIŞ<br />

Bolca Hindi<br />

Asl İLGEN<br />

BESD-BİR<br />

Özgen KOCA<br />

Beypiliç<br />

Gizem ALAV ŞAPÇI Grup7 İletişim<br />

M. Berkant UĞURLU Erpiliç<br />

Ahmet YILMAZ<br />

Şeker Piliç<br />

Kongre Bilim Kurulu (Scientific Committee) *<br />

Prof. Dr. Sacit BİLGİLİ Auburn University<br />

Prof. Dr. Gökhan ÇAYCI Ankara Üniversitesi<br />

Prof. Dr. İbrahim CİFTCİ Ankara Üniversitesi<br />

Prof. Dr. Okan ELİBOL Ankara Üniversitesi<br />

Prof. Dr. Bülent GÜLÇUBUK Ankara Üniversitesi<br />

Prof. Dr. Mustafa HASÖKSÜZ İstanbul Üniversitesi<br />

Dr. Sait KOCA<br />

BESD-BİR<br />

Prof. Dr. Nuray KOLSARICI Ankara Üniversitesi<br />

Doç. Dr. Erol ŞENGÖR BESD-BİR<br />

Prof. Dr. Tansel ŞİRELİ Ankara Üniversitesi<br />

Prof. Dr. Servet YALÇIN Ege Üniversitesi<br />

Prof. Dr. Sevinç YÜCECAN Hacettepe Üniversitesi<br />

* Soyad Srasna Göre (Alphabetically ordered based on surnames)<br />

iii


iv


S001<br />

S002<br />

S003<br />

S004<br />

S005<br />

S006<br />

SÖZLÜ SUNUMLAR (ORAL PRESENTATIONS)<br />

Kesimhanelerde Veteriner Kontrolleri: Ileri Uygulamalar (Veterinary<br />

Inspection in Slaughterhouses: Future Challenges)<br />

Reinhard Fries, Berlin Freie Üniversitesi (Freie University of Berlin)<br />

Piliç <strong>Et</strong>i Sektörü: Hedefler ve Potansiyel Problemler (Poultry Meat Industry:<br />

Targets and Potential Problems)<br />

Sait Koca, BESD-BİR (Turkish Poultry Meat Association)<br />

Damzlk Broyler Beslenmesinde Temel ve Yeni Yaklaşmlar (Basic and<br />

New Approaches in Broiler Breeder Nutrition)<br />

Marcus Kenny, Broiler Damzlk Besleme Uzman (Broiler Breeder<br />

Nutritionist)<br />

Baz Kuluçka Koşullarnn Broyler Performans Üzerine <strong>Et</strong>kileri (Effects of<br />

Hatchery Management on Broiler Performance)<br />

Okan Elibol, Ankara Üniversitesi (Ankara University)<br />

Depolama Süresi ve Çevirme Sklğnn Çkş Gücü ve Broiler Performans<br />

Üzerine <strong>Et</strong>kileri (Effects of Egg Storage Time and Turning Frequency on<br />

Hatchability and Broiler Performance)<br />

Nezih Okur (Beypiliç)<br />

Uluslararas Kanatl Ürün Ticareti ve Bakanlk Uygulamalar (International<br />

Trade of Poultry Products and Ministry Prectices)<br />

Haluk Aşkaroğlu, Tarm ve Köyişleri Bakanlğ (Ministry of Agriculture)<br />

S007 <strong>Beyaz</strong> <strong>Et</strong> Sektöründe Devlet Destekli Kredi Uygulamalar (Government<br />

Supported Credits in Poultry Meat Industry)<br />

Hüsamettin Gülhan, Murat Kara, T.C. Ziraat Bankas (Agricultural Bank of<br />

the Republic of Turkey)<br />

S008<br />

S009<br />

S010<br />

S011<br />

S012<br />

Sektörde Uygulanan Yönetmelikler ve AB Uyumu Çerçevesinde Karşlaşlan<br />

Problemler (Applied Regulations for Poultry Meat Industry and Problems<br />

Faced to Harmonization Period to European Union)<br />

Çiğdem Kzlzy Karaoğlu, Ramazan Çakr (Banvit)<br />

Broiler Gübresinin Kompostlanmasnda Yeni Teknolojiler ve Yaklaşmlar<br />

(New Technologies and Approaches for Composting Broiler Manure )<br />

Harold Marion Keener, Ohio Üniversitesi (The Ohio State University)<br />

Broiler Gübresinin Türkiye Tarmndaki Önemi ve Kullanm Uygulamalr<br />

(The Use of Applications and Importance of Broiler Manure in Turkey)<br />

Gökhan Çayc, Ankara Üniversitesi (Ankara University)<br />

Broilerlerin Beslenmesinde Formulasyon Stratejilerinde Yeni Görüşler (New<br />

Concepts in Formulation Strategies in Broiler Nutrition )<br />

İbrahim Ciftci, Ankara Üniversitesi (Ankara University)<br />

Broiler Üretiminde Yem Teknolojisinin Önemi (Importance of Feed<br />

Technology in Broiler Production)<br />

Adnan Zaimoğullar, Keskinoğlu<br />

S013 Tavuklarda Solunum Sistemi Hastalklar (Distribution and Presence of<br />

Poultry Respiratory Disease Recently Seen in Turkey)<br />

Mehmet Akan, Orkun Babacan, Ankara Üniversitesi (Ankara University)<br />

1<br />

13<br />

31<br />

37<br />

42<br />

48<br />

60<br />

63<br />

67<br />

82<br />

91<br />

114<br />

120<br />

v


S014 Ülkemizde Aş Uygulamalar ve Kontrolleri (Vaccine Applications and<br />

Checks in Turkey)<br />

Güney Gökçelik (Protekt Laboratuvar)<br />

S015<br />

S016<br />

İstatistikî Verilere Dayanarak Kanatl Refah, Patolojisi ve Hastalklarnn<br />

Değerlendirilmesi (Assessing Poultry Welfare, Pathology and Disease Using<br />

Outcome Measures)<br />

Andrew Butterworth, Bristol Veteriner Fakültesi (Bristol Veterinary School)<br />

<strong>Et</strong>lik Piliç Üretiminde Is Stresinin Performans ve <strong>Et</strong> Kalitesine <strong>Et</strong>kileri<br />

(Effects of Heat Stress on Performance and Meat Quality in Broiler<br />

Production)<br />

Servet Yalçn, Ege Üniversitesi (Ege University)<br />

S017 Broiler Yetiştiriciliğinde Pratik Uygulamalar (Practical Applications in<br />

Broiler Production)<br />

Serdar Çelebi (Seral Veterinerlik)<br />

S018<br />

S019<br />

S020<br />

S021<br />

<strong>Beyaz</strong> <strong>Et</strong> ve Ürünleri Üretiminde Gda Güvenliği (Food Safety in Poultry<br />

Meat and Products from Farm to Fork)<br />

Mustafa Tayar, Uludağ Üniversitesi (Uludağ University)<br />

Kanatl <strong>Et</strong>i Kalitesine <strong>Et</strong>ki Eden Faktörler (Factors Affecting Poultry Meat<br />

Quality)<br />

Michel J. Duclos, INRA Fransa (INRA France)<br />

Kanatl <strong>Et</strong>i Endüstrisinde Salmonellann Güncel Durumu, Yönetmelikler ve<br />

Azaltma Stratejileri (Current Salmonella Situation in the Poultry Meat<br />

Industry, Regulations and Strategies for Reduction)<br />

Roel Mulder, Dünya Bilimsel Tavukçuluk Derneği Genel Sekreteri (World<br />

Poultry Science Association, Secretary General)<br />

Tüketicilerin <strong>Beyaz</strong> <strong>Et</strong> Konusundaki Sağlk ve Beslenme Alglar (Consumer<br />

Perceptions for Poultry Meat Regarding with Health and Nutrition)<br />

Dilek Boyacoğlu, İstanbul Teknik Üniversitesi (Istanbul Technical<br />

University)<br />

S022 Türkiye’de Tavuk <strong>Et</strong>i Tüketimi ve Tüketici Eğilimleri (Poultry Meat<br />

Consumption and Consumer Trends in Turkey)<br />

İsmail Durmuş, Cengizhan Mzrak, Serdar Kamanl, Şahnur E. Demirtaş,<br />

Süleyman Kalebaş, Ender Karademir, Murat Dogu, Tavukçuluk Araştrma<br />

Enstitüsü (Poultry Research Institute)<br />

S023<br />

S024<br />

Piliç <strong>Et</strong>i Tüketimini <strong>Et</strong>kileyen Faktörler ve Tüketici Tercihleri: Ankara İli<br />

Örneği (Factors Affecting the Chicken Meat Consumption and Consumer<br />

Preferences: the Case of Ankara Province)<br />

Ylmaz Aral, Erol Aydn, Pnar Demir, Ahmet Cumhur Akn, Sinem İşbilir,<br />

Yavuz Cevger, Ankara Üniversitesi (Ankara University)<br />

Broiler Yemlerinde Protein ve/veya Amino Asit Yoğunluğunu Azaltma ve<br />

Enzim İlavesinin Performans ve Kan Parametrelerine <strong>Et</strong>kileri (Effects of<br />

Protease Supplementation into Broiler Diets Decreased Level of Protein<br />

and/or Amino Acids on Performance and Blood Parameters)<br />

Necmettin Ceylan, Sait Koca, Nezih Okur, Gökhan Akdeniz, Ankara<br />

Üniversitesi ve Beypiliç (Ankara University and Beypiliç )<br />

122<br />

126<br />

138<br />

147<br />

155<br />

163<br />

170<br />

179<br />

184<br />

195<br />

202<br />

vi


S025<br />

S026<br />

S027<br />

S028<br />

Broyler Rasyonlarnda Farkl İnorganik Mineral Düzeylerinin Performans ve<br />

Mineral Atlm Üzerine <strong>Et</strong>kilerinin Karşlaştrlmas (Comparison of<br />

Different Concentrations of Inorganic Trace Minerals in Broiler Diets on<br />

Live Performance and Mineral Excretion)<br />

Z. Wang, S. Cerrate, F. Yan, Pnar Saçakl ve P.W. Waldroup, Ankara<br />

Üniversitesi (Ankara University)<br />

<strong>Et</strong>lik Civcivlerin Erken Dönem Beslenmesinde Karbonhidrat Tipi ve Amino<br />

Asit Yoğunluğunun Performans ve İnce Bağrsak Morfolojisi Üzerine<br />

<strong>Et</strong>kileri (Effects of Carbohydrate Type and Amino Acid Density on<br />

Performance and Small Intestine Morphology in Early Nutrition of Broiler<br />

Chicks)<br />

Mohammed Vadiei, İbrahim Çiftçi, Ankara Üniversitesi (Ankara University)<br />

Tüketici Beklentilerini Karşlama Açsndan Yeni Ürün Geliştirme: Kanatl<br />

<strong>Et</strong>i Endüstrisinde Yeni Ürün Geliştirmede Düşünceden Uygulamaya İşlemler<br />

ve Esaslar (New Product Development to Meet Consumer Demands: Process<br />

and Basics Principles in Poultry Meat Industry from Idea to Practice)<br />

Kezban Candoğan, Ankara Üniversitesi (Ankara University)<br />

Tavuk Göğüs ve But <strong>Et</strong>inden Pastrma Üretim Olanağ (Possibilities for<br />

Pastrma Production from Chicken Breast and Thigh Meats )<br />

Eda Demirok, Nuray Kolsarc, Ahmet Akllgil, Berrak Özşk, Zeliha<br />

Uyank, Ankara Üniversitesi (Ankara University)<br />

S029 Kuluçkahanelerde Embriyo Kontrolleri ve Problem Analizleri (Embryo<br />

Checks and Problem Analysis in Hatcheries)<br />

Jason Cormick, Kuluçka Uzman (Hatchery Specialist)<br />

S030<br />

S031<br />

S032<br />

S033<br />

Türkiye Hindi Sektörünün Dünü, Bugünü, Yarn ve Gelecekteki Zorluklar<br />

(Past, Present and Future of Turkey Meat Industry and Challanges and<br />

Opportunities)<br />

Murat Kalafat (Bolca Hindi)<br />

Ağr <strong>Beyaz</strong> (ABE) ve Amerikan Bronz (Br) Hindiler ile Bunlarn<br />

Melezlerinin (F1, F2 ve G1) Entansif ve Yar Entansif Koşullarda Karkas<br />

Maliyeti (Cost per kg of Carcass of Large White (ABE), American Bronze<br />

(Br) and their Crosses (F1, F2 and BC1 Reared Intensive (IMG) or Semi<br />

Intensive Management Conditions)<br />

Serdar Özlü, Okan Elibol, Numan Akman, Mesut Türkoğlu, Muzaffer<br />

Çördük, Ankara Üniversitesi (Ankara University)<br />

Biyogüvenlik Kanunun Hayvansal Üretime Yansmalar (Effects of National<br />

Biosecurity Law on Turkish Feed Industry)<br />

Ülkü Karakuş (Türkiye Yem Sanayicileri Birliği)<br />

Genetik Yaps Değiştirilmiş Organizmalar Konusunda Toplumun Negatif<br />

Risk Algsnn Nedenleri ve Bilimsel Gerçeklerle Çelişkiler (Reasons of<br />

People Negative Perception on Genetically Modified Organisms (GMO),<br />

Scientific Facts and Conflicts)<br />

Ali Esat Karakaya, Gazi Üniversitesi (Gazi University)<br />

S034 Broyler Yemlerinde Kamelina (Ketencik) Küspesi ve Keten Tohumu<br />

Kullanlmas ve Bakr İlavesinin <strong>Et</strong>kileri (Dietary Camelina Meal vs.<br />

Flaxseed With and Without Supplemental Copper for Broiler Chickens)<br />

Ahmet Y. Pekel, P. H. Patterson, R. M. Hulet, N. Acar, T. L. Cravener, D. B.<br />

Dowler, J. M. Hunter, İstanbul Üniversitesi (İstanbul University)<br />

214<br />

220<br />

228<br />

234<br />

240<br />

252<br />

258<br />

264<br />

272<br />

279<br />

vii


S035 Yem Katklar: Avrupa Birliğinde Yasal Durum (Feed Additives: Legal<br />

Status in European Union)<br />

Jan Koslacz, Polonya FEFANA Platformu Başkan (Chairman of the<br />

FEFANA Polish Platform)<br />

S036 <strong>Beyaz</strong> <strong>Et</strong>in Türk Halknn Sağlkl Beslenmesindeki Rolü (The Role of<br />

Poultry Meat in Healthy Nutrition of Turkish People )<br />

Sevinç Yücecan, Hacettepe Üniversitesi (Hacettepe University)<br />

S037<br />

Kümes Hayvanclğnn Krsal Kalknmada Rolü (Effects of Poultry Industry<br />

on Rural Development)<br />

Bülent Gülçubuk, Ankara Üniversitesi (Ankara University)<br />

288<br />

295<br />

299<br />

viii


P001<br />

P002<br />

P003<br />

POSTER SUNUMLAR (POSTER PRESENTATIONS)<br />

Broyler Yemine Proteaz Enzimi İlavesinin Büyüme Performans ve Besin<br />

Madde Sindirilebilirliği Üzerine <strong>Et</strong>kisi (Effect of Protease Enzyme<br />

Supplementation on Nutrient Digestibility and Growth Performance of<br />

Broiler Chickens) 309<br />

A. Y. Pekel, P. H. Patterson, İstanbul Üniversitesi ve Pennsylvania<br />

Üniversitesi (İstanbul University and The Pennsylvania State University)<br />

Tüm Dane Arpa İçeren <strong>Et</strong>lik Piliç Yemlerine Enzim İlavesinin Performans,<br />

Karkas Kompozisyonu ve Kan Yağlar Üzerine <strong>Et</strong>kileri (The Effects of<br />

Enzyme Supplementation into Broiler Diets Containing Barley on<br />

Performance, Carcass Composition and Blood Lipids) 315<br />

Selim Mert, Figen Krkpnar, Ege Üniversitesi (Ege University)<br />

İnaktif Bira Mayasnn Broyler Rasyonlarnda Vitamin-Mineral Kaynağ<br />

Olarak Kullanlmasnn Performans Üzerine <strong>Et</strong>kileri (Effects of Using<br />

Inactivated Brewer’s Yeast (Saccharomyces cereviciae) in Diets as a Source<br />

of Vitamin and Mineral in Performance of Broilers) 320<br />

Pnar Saçakl, Bekir Hakan Köksal, Ahmet Ergün, Bülent Özsoy, Ankara<br />

Üniversitesi (Ankara University)<br />

P004 Kanatl Üretiminde Diformatlarn Salmonella ve Sindirim Sistemi<br />

Mikrobiyotasna <strong>Et</strong>kisi (Effect of Diformates on Salmonella and Gut<br />

microbiota in Poultry Production) 327<br />

Christian Luckstaedt, Kurt Wegleitner, ADDCON Group, Bonn, Germany<br />

P005 Rasyon Lizin Seviyesinin Japon Bldrcnlarda Büyüme Performans ve<br />

Bağşklk Üzerine <strong>Et</strong>kisi (The Effect of Dietary Lysine Levels on Growth<br />

Performance and Immunity Parameters in Japanese Quail) 334<br />

I. Hajkhodadadi, M. Shivazad, H. Moravvej, A. Zare-Shahneh<br />

P006<br />

P007<br />

P008<br />

P009<br />

Broiler Rasyonlarna Probiotic (Bacillus subtilis DSM 17299) Katlmasnn<br />

Performans ve Sekal Mikroflora Üzerine <strong>Et</strong>kileri (Effects of Probiotic<br />

Supplementation on the Caecal Microflora and Performance in Broiler<br />

Chickens) 340<br />

Gülay Deniz, Abdülkadir Orman, Figen Çetinkaya, Hdr Gençoğlu, Yavuz<br />

Meral, İ. İsmet Türkmen, Uludağ Üniversitesi (Uludağ University)<br />

Salmonella Spp’ye Doğal Olarak Maruz Kalan <strong>Et</strong>lik Piliçlerde Organik<br />

Asitlerin <strong>Et</strong>kinliği (Citrex Efficacy on a Natural Challenge with Salmonella<br />

spp in Broiler Chickens) 349<br />

C. G. Wilsmann, F. Flores, F. L. Gazoni, F. Silveria, M. Lovato, D. Zaviezo,<br />

Citrex, Inc. Miami, FL, USA<br />

Broilerlerde, Salmonelle Enteritidis Kontrolü İçin Organik Asitlerin<br />

Kullanm (Citrx Efficacy on the control of Salmonella Enteritidis in Broiler<br />

Chickens) 353<br />

C. G. Wilsmann, F. Flores, F. L. Gazoni, F. Silveria, M. Lovsto, M.<br />

Contreras, Citrex, Inc. Miami, FL, USA<br />

<strong>Et</strong>lik Piliç Yemlerinde Farkl Seviyelerde Büyüme Uyarc Bitkisel Ekstrakt<br />

Karşm Kullanlmasnn Büyüme Performans ve Karkas Kalitesi Üzerine<br />

<strong>Et</strong>kileri (Effects of Growth Stimulating Herbal Extract Mixture on Broiler<br />

Performance and Carcass Quality) 357<br />

Ali Oğuz Kyak, Necmettin Ceylan, Muzaffer Çördük, Funda Çakmak,<br />

Shahram Golzar Adabi, Ankara Üniversitesi (Ankara University)<br />

ix


P010<br />

P011<br />

P012<br />

P013<br />

P014<br />

P015<br />

Organik Kompleks Minerallerin <strong>Et</strong>çi Piliçlerde <strong>Et</strong> Kalitesine <strong>Et</strong>kisi (Effects<br />

of Chelated Mineral Complex on Broiler meat Quality) 363<br />

Taylan Aksu, M. İrfan Aksu, M. Akif Yörük, Mevlüt Karaoğlu, Mustafa<br />

Kemal Üniversitesi (Mustafa Kemal University)<br />

Erkek <strong>Et</strong>lik Piliçlerde Apilarnil (Erkek Ar Larvas) Uygulamasnn Gelişme<br />

Performans ve İkincil Eşey Özellikleri Üzerine <strong>Et</strong>kileri (The Effects of<br />

Apilarnil (Drone Bee Larvae) Administration on Growth Performance and<br />

Secondary Sex Characteristics of Male Broilers) 370<br />

Banu Yücel, Zümrüt Açkgöz, Hakan Bayraktar, Çiğdem Şeremet, Ege<br />

Üniversitesi (Ege University)<br />

Sürü Yaş ve İnkubasyon Programnn Çkş Gücü ve Broiler Performans<br />

Üzerine <strong>Et</strong>kileri (Effects of Breeder’s Age and Incubation Programme on<br />

Hatchability of Fertile Eggs and Performance of Broilers) 376<br />

Nezih Okur, Mesut Türkoğlu, Beypiliç ve Ankara Üniversitesi (Beypiliç. and<br />

Ankara University)<br />

<strong>Et</strong>lik Piliçlerde Civciv Ağrlğ ile Kesim Performans Arasndaki İlişkiler<br />

(The Relationships Between Chick Weight and Slaughter Performance in<br />

Broilers) 384<br />

H. Cem Güler, Servet Yalçn, Ege Üniversitesi, (Ege University)<br />

Tavuk <strong>Et</strong>i Marinasyonunda Krmz Şarap, Nar Ekşisi ve Pekmez<br />

Kullanmnn Ürünün Baz Kalite Özelliklerine <strong>Et</strong>kisi (Effects of Using Red<br />

Wine, Grape Molasses and Pomegranate Concentrate in Marination of<br />

Chicken Breast Meat on Quality Characteristics) 389<br />

H. Ayça Şahin, Herdem Eyyüpoğlu, Sibel Esra Tefek, Kezban Candoğan,<br />

Ankara Üniversitesi (Ankara University)<br />

Uçucu Kekik Yağnn Taze Olarak Muhafaza Edilen Piliç <strong>Et</strong>lerinin Baz<br />

Kalite Özellikleri Üzerine <strong>Et</strong>kisi (The Effect of Oregano Essential Oil on<br />

Some Quality Characteristics of Chicken Meats) 395<br />

Lütfiye Ekici, İsmet Öztürk, Osman Sağdç, Mustafa T. Ylmaz, Hasan<br />

Yetim, Erciyes Üniversitesi (Erciyes University)<br />

P016 Türkiye’deki Hindi ve Tavuk Kesimhanelerinde Yaz Aylarnda PSE <strong>Et</strong><br />

Oluşumunun Belirlenmesi Üzerine Bir Araştrma (A Research on<br />

Determining PSE Occurance in Chicken and Turkey Meats During Summer<br />

Time in Turkey) 401<br />

Ahmet Yaman, Kezban Candoğan, Ankara üniversitesi (Ankara University)<br />

P017 Mikroenkapsülasyon Teknolojisi ve Kanatl Endüstrisindeki Uygulamalar<br />

(Microencapsulation Technology And Its Application In The Poultry<br />

Industry) 406<br />

lker Turan Akoğlu, Nuray Kolsarc, Ankara Üniversitesi (Erciyes<br />

University)<br />

P018<br />

Hindi <strong>Et</strong>lerinden İzole Edilen Salmonella Spp., Listeria Monocytogenes ve<br />

Clostridium Perfringens İzolatlarnn Antibiyotik Dirençliliğinin Belirlenmesi<br />

(Antibiotic Resistance of Salmonella Spp., Listeria Monocytogenes and<br />

Clostridium Perfringens Isolates From Turkey Meat) 410<br />

İrfan Erol, F. Seda Bilir Ormanc, N. Deniz Ayaz, Özlem İşeri, Devrim<br />

Sargüzel, Ankara Üniversitesi (Ankara University)<br />

x


P019<br />

P020<br />

Tavuklarda Mycoplasma gallisepticum infeksiyonunun polimeraz zincir<br />

reaksiyonu (PCR) ile teşhisi (Diagnosis of Mycoplasma gallisepticum<br />

infection from trachea and tracheal swap samples in chickens by polymerase<br />

chain reaction (PCR))<br />

Seyda Cengiz, Orkun Babacan, Mehmet Akan, Atatürk Üniversitesi, Ankara<br />

Üniversitesi (Atatürk University and Ankara university)<br />

Kanatllarda Msrn Yem Değerini <strong>Et</strong>kileyen Faktörler (Factors Affecting<br />

Nutritional Quality of Corn) 420<br />

Mohammed Vadiei, Ankara Üniversitesi (Ankara University)<br />

416<br />

xi


xii


" ##! $%&'()*+,&-&./&$0&1&.(,&.$2&,&1()(3$-&.($4567-+)+-+.$<br />

!"#"$%&'$()*&+,"-#%.&)%&)/0'123#"$3.1+"+4)51#1$")63'00"&2"+))<br />

!<br />

"#$%&'()!*($#+!<br />

*(#$#!,%$-#(+$./.!01!2#(3$%4!*'563.7!01!8#.#($%'(7!9#)$5$%#!<br />

!<br />

89&1$$<br />

26! +6%6:4! ;26'.! ?#(?#-#+$%)#!<br />

;-(6@')#!E#.!)#%#.$:$F4!<br />

+')#5#! A#3#%#=+#3! '%.#! :0(.#:! -#! @0+.! :0(.#:! )#%#.$:!#=3$%)#! )##(3#%)$($3#:#>!<br />

&'..'!'=+$%#!E#.!)#%#.$:$F!G6!+D(#5$!G$(!GD.D%!03'('=!#3#!'3:'3!4!G6!+D(#?.#=$!($+=3#($!<br />

0(.'7'!=07:'3!!-#!@('.$=.#!&'%A$!($+=3#($!='@+'7'5'!!G#3$(3#%:#3$)$(B!;%5'=!G6%)'%!<br />

+0%('4! AD-#%3$=! )0(63':'+!! $?$%! 67A6%! .#=%$=3#(! =633'%!3'G$3$(B! 26! .#=%$=3#(! 1'(=3!!<br />

)$+$@3$%3#()#%! ='7%'=3'%'G$3$(B! H'%'.3!! #.$! D(#.$:$4! +0%! )#(#5#! :#='%$>#! G$(!<br />

.#=%030I$7#! )'7'%:'=.')!(B! J0+.! :0(.#:! )#%#.$:)#4! 7D=+#=! &!>3!! D(#.$:! &'.3'(!%!%!<br />

7'('..!!!+0(6%3'(!$3#!='(!3'!3:'=.'!036@4!G6%6%!+0%656!)#%#.$:!#3#:'%3'(!!$?$%!'!(!<br />

G$(!7D=!036.6(:'=.')!(B!!<br />

!<br />

:;'1.+&-&,&A'&-$:,-+)/+$B1$2&,&1()($<br />

L.! )#%#.$:$! $%+'%! 67A'(3!!%!%! $3=! )U%#:3#($%)#%! G#($! 7'@!3:'=.'! 036@! )$%+#3!<br />

%#)#%3#()#%! )03'7!! -#7'! >':'%! ='-(':!! ?#(?#-#+$%)#! 7'@!3:!! 03'G$3$(B! ;-(6@'#7)#! 7'@!3:!!036@4!VWB!XD>7!3)'! 0(.'7'! ?!='%!<br />

G$3$:+#3! '%3'7!! =#+$:$! 7'@!3:!! :#:#3$3#(! $?$%! =3$%$=! -#! @'.030I$=! G$(! )#%#.$:!<br />

036.6(:'=!%0=.'+!%)'!G$(!1!(+'.!7'('.:!.!(B!TU>!=0%6+6!$=$!)#%#.$:!.#=%$$!G6AD%!)#!<br />

&'3'!A#?#(3$!03'%!)#%#.$:!.#=%$=3#($)$(B!C#?:$.#=$!?$1.3$=3#(!=D?D=!03)6=3'(!%)'%4!#.!<br />

)#%#.$:$4! &'7-'%3'(!%! G$(! '('7'! .0@3'%)!!! -#! AU>#.3#%#G$3)$$! =#+$:&'%#3#()#!<br />

7'@!3!70()6B! X'=3'!=! G$(! 7D>7!3! G076%5'4! G'3'%A!?.'! ?0=! :0)#(%! 036@4! G6! AD%=D!<br />

')!73'!EA#3#%#=+#3F!03'%!G6!)#%#.$:!#=3$%)#!?0=!1'>3'!G$(!)#$$=3$=!03:':!.!(B!<br />

!<br />

K'G30!VB!T0%!7!33'()'!)#%#.$:!-6(A6+6%6%!E'%3'7!.'%!.D=#.$:#F!)0(6!)#$$:$!!<br />

;:@$($>:!N)$%P!<br />

T0%!D(D%!)#%#.$:$!NA#3#%#=+#3P!<br />

T0%!D(D%)#%!D(#.$:!&'..!%'Y!=0%.(03!7'=3'!:!!<br />

H($.$=!D(#.$:!&'..!!)##(3#%)$(:#+$%#!)'7'3!!D(#.$:!@3'%3':'+!!<br />

"$+=3#($!='G63!#.:#=4!$7$!67A63':'3'(!%!.#+$+$!-#!)0(63':'!7033'(!!<br />

!<br />

! !


H'%'.3!! #.$! D(#.$:! >$%5$($! $?$%)#! #.! )#%#.$:$! A#?#%! 7D>7!3!%! Z[3!!$3#(3#7#%!=#+$:!&'.3'(!%!%!N0!>':'%!$?$%!]B[[[!$3'!^B[[[!G(073#(_+''.P!<br />

AD-#%$3$(3$$!-#!'3A!3':'!0('%!!-#!G6!&'.3'()'!'%.#!:0(.#:!)#%#.$:$%!)6(6:6!ND(#.$:!<br />

7#($!-#7'!=#+$:&'%#)#%!=#+$:#!=')'(P!$3#!$3A$3$!#%)$#3#(!$1')#!#)$3:$.$(B!!!<br />

!<br />

!=C=$:D$E$%F,1.F-$@&$6G9&1()$5+A-+!)!$<br />

W[#33$=3#! #=$3! V70%3'(!!'?!=3':'=!$?$%h!<br />

! \'.'3'(!%!0(.'7'!?!=:'+!%!!#%A#33#:#=!$?$%B!<br />

!<br />

VZf_d[[d! +'7!3!! XU%#.:#3$#! NLjP! AU(#4! ?$1.?$3#(! G$(! A!)'! A$($$:5$+$! 03'('=! &$>:#.!<br />

-#(:#=.#! 036@! ?$1.?$3#($%4! $%+'%3'(!%! .D=#.$:$%#! 7U%#3$=! A!)'! D(#.:#=! ':'5!73'!<br />

7#.$.$()$$! &'7-'%3'('! ='(!! 03'%! +0(6:3636=3'(!! 5$))$7#! '3!%:'3!)!(! ND(D%!<br />

+0(6:36366PB!<br />

!<br />

#=$3!VB!3#($!-#!A#($!G$3A$!+$+.#:$!<br />

!<br />

! ! ! ! ! \'7-'%3'(!<br />

! ! ! ! ! !<br />

! k$1.?$! ! ! ! ! ! !<br />

! H#+$:&'%#!<br />

!<br />

! ! ! ! !!!!*##)G'5=!NC#($!2$3)$($:P!!!!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

! 3#(3#:#!<br />

!<br />

!=H=$B,1&6.&$I(,


CU>#.$:$%$%!'%'!%0=.'3'(!%)'%!G$($4!$%+'%3'(!%!.D=#.$:$%#!67A6%!03:'7'%!&'7-'%3'(!%!<br />

-#7'! &'7-'%! +'3!!! '?!+!%)'%! ($+=! .'!7'%! N#@$)#:$=P! &'7-'%3'(!%! =#+$:&'%#7#!<br />

AU%)#($3:#+$%#!:'%$!03:'=.!(B!!<br />

26%'! #=! 03'('=4! D(#.$:$! G$(! E&'.F! 03'('=! AU(:#=4! )'&'! )#($%! G$(! '%3'7!!%! 0(.'7'!<br />

?!=:'+!%'! -#! ='%'.3!! D(#.$:! &'.3'(!%!%! AU>#.$:$%$! :D:=D%! =!3:!.!(B! H0%.(03! -#!<br />

AU>#.$:!$3#!$3A$3$!U%#:3$!&6+6+3'(!!U>#33$=3#!6%3'()!(Y!<br />

! \'7-'%3'()'=$!-#7'!=#+$3:$!&'7-'%3'()'=$!='3!%.!3'(!!<br />

! l00%0.$=!'I'%3'(!<br />

! H'%'.3!3'(!%! 7'':3'(!! G076%5'! 7'@!3'%! .#+.! +0%6?3'(!73'! @0+.! :0(.#:!<br />

3#>70%3'(!%!.#+@$.$!!<br />

! l00%0>3'(!-#!&'7-'%!&'+.'3!=3'(!!<br />

! c$(#%?!A#3$$:$!<br />

! \'7-'%!(#1'&!!=0%63'(!B!!<br />

!<br />

!=J=$%+,+1-!$&1($/&,&1()(,(,$*&/&K-&.($$<br />

CD%D:D>)#! ='%'.3!! #.$%$%! ='3$.#+$! )#)$$:$>)#! ='3!%.!4! &'7-'%! (#1'&!4! &'+.'3!=! -#!<br />

:#='%$=!#.=$3#(!$3#!$3A$3$!='(='+3'(!%!:'=(0+=0@$=!AU(D%D:D4!D(D%D%!-#!$3#:!&'..!%!%!<br />

&$I7#%$!-#!T'3:0%#33'!-#7'!j':@730G'5.#(!A$G$!@'.0I#%3#()#%!G'&+#)$70(6>!)#:#=.$(B!<br />

!<br />

2$(#7+#3! AU(+#3! )#%#.$:$%! NAU(+#3! ':'! A#(#=.$$%)#! =#+#(#=P! ':'5!! ='(='+! -#!<br />

0(A'%3'()'!'%0(:'33$=3#($%!036@!03:')!!%!!.#+@$.!#.:#=.$(B!<br />

! X06%36=4!(#%=4!=0=67'!$3$=$%!G0>6=36=3'(!!.#+@$.!#.:#=!<br />

! 3#:#!&'..!%)'%!='7%'=3'%'%!'%'!&'.'3'(!!.#+@$.!#.:#=!<br />

! TD(D%D%!D@&#!'3.!%)'!03)66!&#(!)6(6:)'4!('+.A#3#!U(%#=!'3:'=!<br />

! ,7A6%!G$(!$3#:#!&'..!!+'3':'=!<br />

!<br />

i#>70%3'(4! +')#5#! &'+.'3!=3'()'%! )#$34! '7%!! >':'%)'4! $3#.:#! =0633'(!%!%! 67A6%!<br />

03:':'+!%)'%! N.#=%0@'.$P! %'=3$7#! +!('+!%)'! N&'7-'%! (#1'&!! $?$%P! -#7'! +#(+#:3#.:#!<br />

#+%'+!%)'!)'!:#7)'%'!A#3#G$3$(B!<br />

H'%'.3!!#.$%$%!$3#:#+$!$%+'%!-#!&'7-'%!+'3!!%!!=0(6%:'3!4!&'7-'%!(#1'&!%!!)$=='.#!<br />

'3:'3!!-#!.D=#.$5$3#(#!+'3!=3!!-#!G#+$%!)##($!7D=+#=!#.!7'!)'!#.!D(D%D!+'3':'3!)!(!<br />

ND(D%!='3$.#+$PB!?$!AD-#%3$$!D>#($%)#!)6(63:'+!!A#(#=#%!G$(!G'='!=0%6)6(B!<br />

!<br />

C=$%&'()$L+11!$<br />

C=!=$?&A,F-FM($<br />

KD(3#(#!G'3!!03'('=!=#+$:&'%#!&'.3'(!%!%!#=$@:'%!-#!0.0:'+70%6!1'(=3!)!(B!XD=+#=!<br />

&!>3!! G$(! =#+$:&'%#! NVd4[[[! G(073#(_+''.#! =')'(P! ?'3!.!(:'=! $?$%! A#3$:$! G$(!<br />

.#=%030I$7#!$&.$7'?!-'()!(B!26%'!AU(#4!G$($%5$3!D(#.$:)#!G6!=#+$:&'%#3#(#!7#.#(3$!'(>!!<br />

+'3'7'5'=!A#%$!+D(D3#(!G636%:'3!)!(B!<br />

C#(#=3$!+'7!7!!='(!3'7'G$3:#=!$?$%4!7#.$.$(:#)#%4!%'=3$7#4!$%)$(:#4!'+:'4!=#+$:!-#!<br />

$3#($! $3#:#! )'&$3! .D:! '':'3'(!%! G$(G$($! $3#! G'3'%.!3!! 03:'+!! A#(#=:#=.#)$(B! 26%6%!<br />

7'%!!+!('!%'=3$7#b.#=%030I$+$%$%!G$3#!=#+$:!&'..!%'!67A6%!03:'+!!A#(#=:#=.#)$(B!;=+$!<br />

&'3)#4! G$(! ='>'! .D:! &'..!! #.=$3#7#G$3$(B! 2U73#! 7D=+#=! )#(#5#)#! A#3$:$! &'.3'(!%!<br />

#=0%0:$=! U%#:$%$! -6(A63':'7'! A#(#=! G$3#! 70=.6(B! \'.! &!>!%!%! +D(#=3$! '(.:'+!73'!<br />

G$(3$=.#!-#!G$()#%!1'>3'!-'()$7'%!%!?'3!:'+!4!&$>:#.!N&$I7#%!-#!.#=%$=P!+D(#+$%$%!)'&'!<br />

)'! =!+'3:'+!%'! 703! '?:'=.')!(B! X06%! .#=%030I$! G$($:3#(! $?$%! +0(6%! 7'('.:':'=.'!<br />

GU73#5#!G$()#%!1'>3'!.'!7!5!!7036!=633'%!3'G$3$(!&'3#!A#3:#=.#)$(B!m>#33$=3#4!='%'.3!3'(!<br />

G$($%5$3!D(#.$:!$3#!$3#:#!&'..!!'('+!%)'!#%!U%#:3$!G'3'%.!!N)$=#7P!03:'+!%'!(':#%!<br />

! H


='%'.3!3'(!! .'!7'%! 7'! )'! '.!=3'(!! AU.D(#%! =':70%3'(! )'! G6! =0%6)'! U%#:3$!<br />

:#)$'.U(3#()$(B!<br />

!<br />

TU>!=0%6+6!'':'3'(!%!&#(!G$($%)#!U%#:3$!A#3$:#3#(!='7)#)$3:$!036@!&#(!AD%!G'='!<br />

A#3$:#3#(!)#!7''%:'=.')!(Y!<br />

! H'%'.3!3'(!%!%'=3$7#+$!N&'7-'%!(#1'&!%'!AU(#!%'=3$7#P!<br />

! H#+$:!&'..!!N&'3':'!.'%=3'(!!-#!G6&'(!.#=%$=3#($P!<br />

! ?! 0(A'%3'(!%! ?!='(!3:'+!! &'..!! N&'.! &!>!%!! )'&'! )'! '(.!('%! $?! 0(A'%! ?!='(:'!<br />

.#=%$$!.'+'(!:!P!<br />

! `(D%!?#$.3#%)$(:#!N0.0:'.$=!=#+:#!&'.3'(!!=6(63:'+!P!<br />

! XU%#.$:Y! ='(='+! -#! @'(?'3'(!%! '7(!! '7(!! 7U%3#%)$($3:#+$%$! +'3'7'%!<br />

#3#=.(0%$=!.'%!:3':'!N#.$=#.3#(P!=633'%!:!!<br />

! XU%#.$:Y! TD(D)#%! +D(D7#! T'3:0%#33'! .('%+1#($%$%! U%3#%:#+$! $?$%! 30I$+.$=!<br />

=#+$:B!!<br />

!<br />

C=C=$%&'()$@&$(-&)&$*+11!$*(M5&,($$<br />

\$I7#%4! >00%0.$=! 'I'%3'(!%! #%A#33#%:#+$4! .'-6=! )#($+$! :$=(0b130('+!%!%! $3#-$! -#!<br />

7'G'%5!! :'))#3#()#%! =0(6%:'! '%3':!%'! A#3$(B! j'%3!! 'I'%3'(4! -$(D+3#(4! G'=.#($3#(4!<br />

#65'(70.+4! @(0.0>0'! -#! @'('>$.3#(! 03'('=! +!%!13'%)!(!3!(3'(B! \$I7#%! AU>#.$:$4! :0)#(%!<br />

)#%#.$:!+$+.#:3#($!$?$%)#!7#(!'3'%!=0%63'()'%!G$($)$(B!\$I7#%$=!'?!)'%4!=#+$:&'%#)#=$!<br />

U%#:3$!-#!=($.$=!%0=.'3'(!6%3'()!(Y!<br />

! \'3':'!.'%=3'(!!NG'=.#($!7D=D!0366(P!<br />

! KD7!703:'!N3'+.$=!@'(:'=!7D>#7$!.#:$>3#:#=!>0()6(P!<br />

! ?!0(A'%3'(!%!?!='(!3:'+!!NG'!(+'=!=0@:'3'(!P!<br />

! T06.:'!N+@(#7!.#=%$$%)#!G$3#!!+6!$3#!?'@('>!=0%.':$%'+70%P!<br />

!<br />

X'G'%5!! :'))#3#(! $3#! $3A$3$! 03'('=4! -#.#($%#(! 67A63':'3'(!%!%! ='3!%.!3'(!4! ?#-(#!<br />

=$(3$3$$%)#%! ='7%'=3'%'%! :'))#3#($%! 7'%!! +!('! 7'+'3! 67A63':'3'(! NGD7D:#!<br />

&!>3'%)!(!5!3'(b! ;2$%! -#($3:#:#=.#)$(BP! $3#! G'=.#($)#=$! )$(#%?! 1#%0:#%$! )#!<br />

AU>3#:!'3.!%)')!(B!<br />

!<br />

DF97-)+5+$,&/&,$F-+,$)(A.FF.6+,(9)+-+.$<br />

H'%'.3!)'=$!+.'G$3!:$=(0130('4!&'7-'%!%!)!!7D>#7$!7'%!!+!('!+$%)$($:!+$+.#:$!:$=(0b<br />

130('+!!703673'!=#+$:&'%#7#!-#!&'..'!)'&'!$3#($!%0=.'3'('!.'!%'G$3$(B!j'%3!!&'7-'%3'(!<br />

=#+$:&'%#3#()#! G'3!5'! -#! G$($%5$3! )#(#5#)#! G'=.#($7030I$=! +0(6%! ='7%'!! 036@4! +U>!<br />

=0%6+6!+0(6%6%!.#=%030I$=!03'('=!?U>D:D!$+#!'':'!'':'!03:'=.')!(Y!G$(!='%'.3!!#.$!<br />

$3#:#! @(0+#)D(D%D%! G'=.#($7030I$=! @(01$3$! :#-56.! 036@4! )#($! G6! @(01$3! $?$%! $7$! G$(!<br />

U(%#=3#:#!N%6:6%#P!:'.#(7'3$)$(B!!<br />

3#:#!+0%6%)'4!='%'.3!!NG(073#(P!)#($+$%)#=$!.0@3':!'#(0G$=!G'=.#($!@3'!!+'7!+!!30A!<br />

g_A(!)#($!5$-'(!%)')!(B!9$5(05055'5#'#4!L%.#(0=0=3'(4! )D>#%+$>!+@0(+6>!A(':!@0+$.$1!<br />

(0)3'(!-#!L%.#(0G'5.#($'5#'#!$3#:#!&'..!%)'!036'%!G'=.#($3#()$(B!<br />

!<br />

IFF,F1(A$+M+,-+.$<br />

/'07.&"00') '&8) 6'7,(0.9'-#"$4) C#%#3! 03'('=! @'.0I#%! G'=.#($3#($%! $%+'%3'(!%! )0'3!<br />

?#-(#3#($%#! G63':'+!%)'! #%! GD7D=! 7036%! ?$1.3$=3#()#%! A#3#%! &'7-'%! 0($I$%3$! A!)'3'(!<br />

03)66! ='G63! #)$3:#=.#)$(B! 26! %#)#%3#! U%5#4! $3=! AD%)#%! $.$G'(#%! 5$-5$-3#($%!<br />

=0%.':$%'+70%! '':'+!%)'%! G'3'7'('=! ?$1.3$=! &$I7#%$4! +.'G$3! ?#-(#! -#! G#+$! )U%#:$!<br />

=#+$:&'%#! -#! )$#(! 7#(3#(#! G63':'! '?!+!%)'%! U%#:! '(>! #.:#=.#)$(B! ;I'%3'(! G$(!<br />

! J


+D(D7#! 7'.'7! 03'('=! G63':'=.'! 036@! =63'(!%! 7#:$! 7#()#%! '3!(=#%! '7%!! >':'%)'!<br />

:$=(0G$7'3!=030%$>'+70%6!)'!'3:'3'(!!G63':'7!!&!>3'%)!(!(B!!<br />

j'%3!!&'7-'%3'()'!T'3:0%#33'!-#!j':@730G'5.#(#33$=3#! +='%)$%'-7'3'!U%#:!-#($3:#+$!A#(#=.$$!0(.'7'!?!='(.:!.!(B!<br />

26!G'3':)'!=#+$:!&'..!!$?$%!)#!'7%!!G#=3#%.$!:#-56..6(B!26!'7%!!>':'%)'4!>00%0.$=!<br />

'I'%3'(4! )$(#%?4! ='3!%.!3'(! -#7'! &'7-'%! &'+.'3!=3'(!! -#7'! &'7-'%! (#1'&!! $3#! $3A$3$!<br />

($+=3#($%!N)'&'!U%5#!7'@!3:!!03'%!'%'3$>3#(!.#:#3$%)#P!!1'(=!%)'3!!%!!$?#(:#=.#)$(B!!<br />

26(')'! 7$%#4! .#=%$=3#(#! -#! =0%.(03! U3?D.3#($%#! $&.$7'?! )6763:'=.')!(B! EL%! $7$!<br />

67A63':'3'(F4!''!)'!+!('3'%'%!@(0+#)D()#%!#:$%!03:'7!!A#(#=.$($(B!!<br />

! l00%0.$=!'I'%3'(!!)!'(!)'!.6.:'=!$?$%!G$0AD-#%3$=!U%3#:3#($!<br />

! 2$($%5$3!D(#.$:)#!.#('@U.$=3#($%!=633'%!:!!=0%6+6%)'!$&.$7'.3!!036%:'+!!<br />

! l$('$!:D5')#3#!$3'?3'(!%!%!7'+'3!=633'%!:!!$?$%!7$!K'(!:!,7A63':'3'(!!<br />

! =$%5$3!D(#.$:!$?$%!7$!!\$I7#%!,7A63':'3'(!!<br />

3A$3$! ($+=$! 0(.')'%! ='3)!(:'=! $?$%! &'..!%! &#(! '':'+!%)'! .D:! U%3#:3#($! 67A63':'=!<br />

A#(#=$(B!26!0@+$70%3'(!G'>#%!Eg!(3'%:'+!%!%!7'%!!+!('!@#('=#%)#!+'.!4!<br />

67A6%!)#@03':'!-#7'!#-)#!'3!%'5'=!U%3#:3#(!<br />

!<br />

2$70AD-#%3$=4! &'+.'3!=3'(! 7'! )'! &'+.'3!=! 'I'%3'(!%)'%! ='7%'=3'%'%! ($+=3#(#! ='(!!<br />

=0(67656! U%3#:3#(! 03'('=! .'%!:3'%'G$3$(! NC6%%! #.! '3B! d[[fPB! 2$70AD-#%3$=!<br />

@(0A(':3'(!!+D(D!.#:'+3'(!%!!-#7'!$%+'%3'()'%4!)$#(!+D(D3#()#%4!7'G'%$!=63'()'%!7'!<br />

)'! )$#(! &'7-'%3'()'%4! #-! &'7-'%3'(!%)'%4! '%3':'3!! $(=#.3#()#%! .#:$%! #)$3:#7#%!<br />

7#:3#()#%4! AD-#%3$! 03:'7'%! +63'()'%! 7'! )'! =0%.':$%#! #=$@:'%3'()'%!<br />

='7%'=3'%'G$3#5#=! =0%.':$%'+70%6! ! :$%$:$>#! #.:#=! $?$%! .'+'(3':!.!(! Nn;j9j*!<br />

VWWZPB!k$1.3$=!)D>#7$%)#!G$70AD-#%3$=!$3#!$3A$3$!G$(='?!'%'!$3=#!G636%:'=.')!(B!!<br />

!<br />

H=H=$2&,&1()$PQB1$/&,&1()(RS$<br />

KD:! &'7-'%3'(! '%.#! :0(.#:! -#! @0+.! :0(.#:! )#%#.$:#! .'G$! .6.636(3'(B! 2#+$! -#7'!<br />

76:6(.3':'!)U%#:$%$%!+0%'!#(:#+$%)#%!+0%('!A#(?#=3##%!)#%#.$:!&#:!?$1.3$=.#!&#:!<br />

)#! =#+$:&'%#)#! &'7-'%3'(!%! A#%#3! 03'('=! =0%.(03D%D! N'%.#! :0(.#:! )#%#.$:P! =#+$:!<br />

+0%('+!! ! $+#! ='(='+3'(!%! -#! +'='.'.3'(!%! @0+.! :0(.#:! )#%#.$:$%$! $?#($(B! `(D%)#%!<br />

N='%'.3!P!7$%#!A!)'!0@#('.U(D!+0(6:36)6(B!$<br />

! N


!<br />

K'G30!]B!k$1.3$=!)D>#7$%)#!G$0AD-#%3$=!'%'!$3=#3#($!N*($#+4!d[V[P!<br />

;3'%!N4!'3'%!%!'%'!GU3D:3#($!+$7'&!7'!)'!G#7'>!GU3A#3#(#!'7!('('=!G$%'3'(!%!<br />

)'!.!:!P!<br />

K('%+1#(3#($%! =0%.(03D! )'&$3! 03:'=! D>#(#! '7(!! GU3D:3#($! 03'%! G$%'! -#!<br />

.#+$+3#(!<br />

,7A6%!&$I7#%!.#)G$(3#($!$3#!G$(3$=.#!+D(D!7U%#.$:$!<br />

TD(D!)#$$:3#($!'('+!%)'=$!+#(-$+!@#($70)6!N-#!7D>#73#(#!67A6%!G'=!:!%!<br />

7'@!3:'+!P!<br />

K#:$>3$=!-#!)#>#%1#=+$70%!G''(!:!!<br />

;3.3!=!.#=%030I$+$!N0($I$%4!=633'%!:4!#3#:#!-#!=0%.(03P!<br />

\'+.'3!=!.'!7!5!!03'('=!7#:!-#!+64!%'=3$7#!U%5#+$!G#+3#:#!+.('.#I$3#($!<br />

K'!7!5!! 03'('=! $%+'%3'(! N'3'%! $?$%)#=$! &'(#=#.3#($! ?#(?#-#+$%)#! U%3#7$5$!<br />

.#)G$(3#(P!<br />

n'=3$7#! '('?3'(!! -#! G6%3'(!%! G63':')'=$! (033#($! N'7%!! >':'%)'! '3'%!<br />

$?$%)#P!<br />

8#.#($%#(3$=!U%3#:3#($4!?$1.3$=.#%!?$1.3$#!.('%+1#($%!U%3#%:#+$!<br />

!<br />

H=!=$U(K1-(A$/O9&5(,/&$+,1&$)F.1&)$<br />

H#+$:#!A$)#5#=!='%'.3!%!%!'%.#!:0(.#:!)#%#.$:#!.'G$!.6.636@!.6.63:'7'5'!%'!7#.=$3$!<br />

:'=':!='('(!-#($(B!c#%#.$:!?$1.3$=.#!7'@!3:':!+'4!=#+$:&'%#)#!7'@!3:'3!)!(B!H3$%$=!<br />

+#:@.0:!AU+.#(#%!&'7-'%3'(4!$%+'%3'(!%!.D=#.$:$%#!+6%63:':'3!)!(B!m>#3!':'?3'(!$?$%!<br />

=633'%!3:'+!!)6(6:6%)'4!'%.#!:0(.#:!)#%#.$:!?$1.3$=.#!7'@!3:'3!)!(B!<br />

TD(D3#($%!G$($%5$3!D(#.$:)#!)#%#.$:$4!&#:!&'7-'%3'(!%!)#%#.$:$!&#:!)#!'7(!!'7(!!+D(D!<br />

A#?:$$%#! G'=!3:'+!! #=3$%)#! A#(?#=3#$(B! T'3!=3'! $3A$3$! =($.#(3#(! $?$%! )#(3#%:#+$!<br />

A#(#=#%!1'=.U(3#(!''!)'!G#3$(.$3:$.$(Y!<br />

! H636?=')'%!?!='%!.0@3':!5$-5$-!+'7!+!!!<br />

! X#:!-#!+6!.D=#.$:$!<br />

! m3D:!0('%!!<br />

! T'3!=!G0>6=36=3'(!!U7=D+D!<br />

! K#)'-$!N$3'?3'(!-#!7#:!='.=!!:'))#3#($!)'&$3P!-#!'!3':'!A#?:$$!<br />

! R(.'3':'!AD%3D=!5'%3!!'!(3!=!'(.!!!<br />

! H66%!'!(3!!!NG$(#7+#3!'!(3!=!)'!3!:!P!<br />

! X#:!)U%DD:D!!<br />

!<br />

H=C=$%&'()*+,&$/O9&5(,/&$+,1&$)F.1&)$<br />

\'7-'%3'(4! =#%)$! 0(.':3'(!%)'=$! )#%#.$:)#%! +0%('4! =#+$:&'%#)#! )#! &'7-'%! (#1'&!!<br />

&6+6+3'(!%!!='@+'7'5'=!#=$3)#!$=$%5$!G$(!'%.#!:0(.#:!)#%#.$:#!.'G$!.6.636(3'(B!;%5'=!<br />

G6!)#%#.$:$%)#%!+'3'%'%!G$3A$3#(!:$%U(!)##()#)$(B$<br />

!<br />

H=H=$>G.'&-$VF'1$)F.1&)$/&,&1()$<br />

H'(='+!-#!0(A'%3'(!%!.D:!7D>#73#($!NAU(+#3!03'('=P4!A#5$=:#)#%!$%5#3#%:#3$)$(!NE.D:!<br />

)!! 7D>#73#(FPB! \'.! D>#($%)#! 7'@!3'%! $%5#3#:#! ;2! `7#! D3=#3#($%$%! G'>!3'(!%)'!<br />

7'()!:5!! @#(+0%#3! G'>!3'(!%)'! $+#! -#.#($%#(! &#=$:3#(! .'('1!%)'%! 7'@!3!(B! "#+:$!<br />

-#.#($%#(!&#=$:!''!)'=$3#($!G$>>'.!7'@'(Y!<br />

! ;7%!!0($I$%)#%!A#3#%!&#(!G$(!+#-=$7'.!$?$%4!=#+$:$!7'@!3'%!&'7-'%3'(!!.#:+$3!<br />

#)#5#=!+'7!)'!$?!0(A'%3'(!%!-#!='-$.#+$%$%!AD%3D=!)#%#.$:$!<br />

! T


! %+'%!.D=#.$:$%#!67A6%!03:')!!!G#7'%!#)$3#%!@'(?'3'(!%!7'!)'!.':!='(='+!%!<br />

('+.A#3#!U(%#=3#($!!<br />

! 26!&'7-'%3'(!%!#.$%$%!$%+'%!.D=#.$:$%#!67A6%!03:')!!%'!$3$=$%!&#(&'%A$!G$(!<br />

D@&#!0(.'7'!?!=.!!%)'!)$#(!A#(#=3$!$%5#3#:#3#(!!<br />

:'$!&)9.011)71'("&"+%Y!XU%#.:#3$=!:#.%$!.'('1!%)'%!)'!G#3$(.$3)$$!#=$3)#!='-$.#!<br />

:6'7#%#+$%$%!7'@!3:'+!!:D:=D%!)#$3)$(!NE)!!7D>#73#(FPB!?!0(A'%3'(!%!?!='(!3:'+!4!<br />

7'=3'!=!V[B[[[!_+''.!&!>!%)'=$!G$(!&'..'!)'(!G$(!'?!=3!=.'%!7'@!3!(!H'-$.#!:6'7#%#+$!<br />

?!='(!3'%! 0(A'%3'(!%! )#%#.$:! #3#:'%!! .'('1!%)'%! )03'73!! 03'('=! $%5#3#%:#+$! N&'.!<br />

D>#($%)#!-#7'!'7(!!G$(!.#@+$)#P!#=3$%)#!036(!-#!#=!03'('=!(#+:$!-#.#($%#(!.'('1!%)'%!<br />

('+.A#3#!U(%#=3#:#7#!)'7'%!3'('=!A#(?#=3#.$($3$(B!<br />

;"3#:3#%#%! G$(! 3#>70%6%! %#! '%3':'! A#3)$$! N-#! G'>#%! )#! G6%'! %#)#%! 03'%! '(='!<br />

@3'%!P! -#! ='(='+3'(! &'%A$! %#)#%)#%! )03'7!! 67A6%! )#$3)$(! )$7#! &'..'%! ?!='()!!:!>!!<br />

&#(!>':'%!G$3#:#7$>B!<br />

i#>70%3'(!%4! $%+'%3'('4! &'7-'%3'('! 7'! )'! ?#-(#7#! 7'('..!!! .#&3$=#_($+=#! $3$=$%!<br />

)##(3#%)$(:#3#(! +')#5#! G$(='?! -'=')'! 7'@!3:!.!(B! 2$+'$330%! -#! '(=B! Nd[[VP4!<br />

.D=#.$5$3#(#! 7U%#3$=! $?#()$=3#($! ($+=! G'=!:!%)'%! =#+$%! 03'('=! +'@.'%:!! Vg]!<br />

'G%0(:'3$.#!-#!)6(6:!NCc;jP!G#3$(3#:$.$(B!T0%6?3'(!G6!)#%#.$:!'3'%!%)'!)'&'!1'>3'!<br />

'%'3$>!7'@!3:'+!%!%!A#(#=3$!03)66%6!AU+.#(:#=.#)$(Y!<br />

! %+'%3'(!'?!+!%)'%!+'=!%5'3'(!!G$3$%:#:#=.#)$(!N%ogeP!<br />

! ;I'%4!$%+'%!&'+.'3!=3'(!!$3#!$3$=$3#%)$($3:#:$.$(!N%ogZP!<br />

! ;I'%!&#%D>!.#+@$.!#)$3:#:$.$(!N%o]P!<br />

! "$+=! XU%#.$:$! p! +#?#%#=3#(#! $&.$7'?! -'()!(! N%o]Zh! U>#33$=3#! =$:7'+'3!<br />

=0%.':$%'+70%3'()'P!<br />

! W


i#>70%3'(!%!+'@.'%:'+!4!1'(=3!!.#:#3!=0%63'('!G'3'%'G$3$(Y!<br />

! 3#.:#)#=$! N.'G'%! 7'+.!!! )#(:'.$.$4! '3.3!=! 7'%!=3'(!4! A'A'! =#+$:$%$P! -#7'!<br />

%'=3$7#)#!&'7-'%!(#1'&!!@'(':#.(#3#($!!<br />

! 3#.:#)#! &'+.'3!=3'(! 7'! )'! &$I7#%! N1'(=3!! GD7D:#! &!>!%'! -#! 03'+!! G$(!<br />

#%1#=+$70%'!$'(#.!#)#%!'!(3!=!-'(7'%+!='.+'7!+!P!<br />

! 2$(!&'+.'3!=!7'!)'!.#=%0@'.$7#!$'(#.!#)#%!@'.030I$=!'%'.0:$=!3#>70%3'(!<br />

! K#=%$=!@(0+#)D()#!&'.'!03)66%6!AU+.#(#%!=0@:'3'(4!=#:$=!=!(!3:'3'(!!!<br />

!<br />

K'G30!gB!H'%'.3!3'()'!+!=!+!=!:#7)'%'!A#3#%!3#>70%3'(4!'%3':3'(!!-#!.#+@$.3#($!!<br />

N*($#+!VWWVh!2#(A:'%%!d[[V4!67'(3'%:!!&'3$P!<br />

i#>70%! L.$030I$! ;%3':! K#+@$.!'':'+!!<br />

?!0(A'%3'(!%!<br />

?!='(!3:'+!%)'%!<br />

! ! ! U%5#! +0%('!<br />

;+$.#+! A#%#.$=4!GD7D:#!1'=.U(3#($4! q! #-#.! &'7!(!<br />

5$%+$7#.!<br />

c#($%!!c#(:'.$.$+! LB503$4!)$#(!C(':b%#A'.$13#(! q! #-#.! -#%.('3!<br />

c#($)#!676>! )#%A#+$>!G#+3#%:#4!G'=.#($4!)$#(! q! #-#.! #-#.!<br />

;3.3!=!7'%!=3'(!!N.#:'+P! !+3'=!'3.3!=!r!n\ ] ! &'7-'%! #-#.! -#%.('3)#%!<br />

(#1'&!!<br />

26(+$.$+!+.#(%'3$+! G'(!%:'4!&'7-'%3'(!%!'!(3!!! q! #-#.! -#%.('3)#%!<br />

J0)0)#(:'.$.$+! O+3'=!'3.3!=3'(!! &'7-'%! #-#.! !<br />

(#1'&!!<br />

c#($%$%!H'(+$%0:'.0>6! G$3$%:$70(! q! G'3!! !<br />

cDD=!5'%3!!'!(3!=! #%1#=+$70%!&'+.'3!=3'(!4!@'('>$.3#(! q! #-#.! #-#.!<br />

H#:$=!)#10(:'+70%6! G0)6(36=!+#%)(0:6! q! #-#.! #-#.!<br />

\'-'!=#+#+$!7'%A!+!! ! LB503$4!9750@3'+:'! q! &'7!(! N#-#.P!<br />

J#($='()$.$+! U%5#=$!A$G$! %+'%!NqP! &'7!(! #-#.!<br />

J#($&#@'.$.$+! U%5#=$!A$G$! q! &'7!(! #-#.!<br />

L%.#($.$+!<br />

@'('>$.3#(4!G'=.#($3#(4!#%1#=+$70%! q! &'7!(! #-#.!<br />

03:'7'%!-$(D+3#(!<br />

;(.($.$+! -$(D+3#(4!G'=.#($3#(! q! #-#.! #-#.!<br />

!<br />

J=C=$?OA&1()&$7567,-7A$@&$7567,'79-7A$+.+'!,/+A($6.($;G-6&$<br />

2$7030I$=! :'.#(7'3! 1'(=3!)!(B! J0+.! :0(.#:! $%5#3#:#)#4! 67A6%366%! 7'! )'!<br />

67A6%+6>366%6%! .#+@$.! #)$3:#+$! 0! =')'(! )'! =03'7! )#$3)$(4! =#+$%! =($.#(3#(! 70=.6(4!<br />

.'%!:3'('! A#(#=! -'()!(! NU(%#$%! K'G30! ^PB! TD(D3#(! .#:#3! 03'('=! +'3!=3!! G$3#! 03+'3'(4!<br />

3#>70%3'(! 0(.'7'! ?!='G$3$(B! 26%3'()'%! G'>!3'(!!+!=3!=3'! ='%'.3!! #.$! $3#%:#+$! +!('+!%)'!<br />

NG6(')'Y! G(073#(P! 1'(=! #)$3$(B! T0%! '7!(:'4! 3#>70%6%! 7'@!+!%'4! ='@+':!%'! -#! '7%!!<br />

>':'%)'! 3#>70%6%! 706%366%'! G'3!)!(B! ;7%!! >':'%)'4! 3#>70%6%! ='(='+! D>#($%)#!<br />

30='3$>'+70%6!N7#($%$%!G#3$(3#%:#+$P!U%#:3$!G$(!1'=.U(!036@!$%5#3#:#!+D(#+$%5#!)$=='.#!<br />

'3!%:'+!! A#(#=$(B! c'&'+!4! G#3$(3$! G$(! 3#>70%4! GD.D%! +D(D%D%! A#?:$$! AU>! U%D%#!<br />

'3!%:')'%! .#=! G'!%'! )##(3#%)$($3#:#>h! U(%#$%! )#%#.$:)#%! A#?:#+$! A#(#=#%! #%!<br />

)DD=!'!(3!=!N7'!'(.!=?'!'!(3!=.'!'(.'(P!'%5'=!'!(3!=!)'!3!:!%!%!7'%!!+!('!+D(D%D%!<br />

7'!!AU>!U%D%#!'3!%'('=!G#3$(3#%#G$3$(!NC'6++!)'!3!:!#($+$!.'=$@!#)$3#(#=PB!TD(D)#=$!<br />

3#>70%3'(!%!7D>)#+$!)#!&#+'G'!'3!%:'3!)!(B!<br />

m>#.3#4! :6'7#%#! +!('+!%)'4! A#%#3! G$(! ='%''.! 036.6('5'=! #=$3)#! G$(! '%0(:'33$=!<br />

AU>3#%$(+#4!!&'7-'%!%!67A6%!03:')!!!G$3)$($3:#3$!-#!D(#.$:!&'..!%)'%!?!='(.!3:'3!)!(B!<br />

!<br />

J=H=$[,K&A1(K$;F97A-7A-+.$)&A+,(A$;F97A-7A-+.+$A+.!$\$>&,&--&)&$/7.7)7$$<br />

L%1#=+$70%!='7%'=3!!-#!:#='%$=!='7%'=3!!G0>6=36=3'(!G$(G$(3#($%)#%!'7(!3:'3!)!(B!2$(!<br />

#%1#=+$70%! )6(6:6%)'! -#! f^g! +'7!3!! XU%#.:#3$=! &D=D:3#($%$%! A#(#=3#($%#! AU(#4!<br />

3#>70%6%! ='('=.#(! A#%#33#:#+$! $3#! $3A$3$! ='('(! '3!%:'+!! A#(#=3$)$(B! C#%#33#:#!<br />

)6(6:6%)'4!='(='+!67A6%+6>!03'5'=.!(B!!<br />

! Z


!<br />

J=J=$?&A$;(.$*+5@+,+$A+.!$$;O1O,$;(.$'O.O$$<br />

J0+.! :0(.#:! :6'7#%#4! .#:#3! 03'('=4! G$(#7+#3! :6'7#%#! -#! ='('(! -#(:#! =6('33'(!%'!<br />

.'G$)$(B!;%5'=4!G$(?0=!)6(6:)'4!3#>70%!%#)#%3#($!G$3$%:#>!7'!)'!=0%673'!$3A$3$!&#%D>!<br />

G$(! )##(3#%)$(:#! 7'@!3:!.!(B! c$#(! 7'%)'%4! +D(D%D%! G$(! 'I'%3'! #%1#=.#! 03:'+!!<br />

)6(6:6%)'4!3#>70%3'(!+D(D!)D>#7$%)#!G$(!#%1#=+$70%6%!03)66%6!AU+.#(#G$3$(3#(B!!<br />

%+'%! )!!%)'! G$(! @'.0I#%$%! -'(3!!! )6(6:6%)'4! G6! .D(! G$(! #%1#=+$70%! -D56)6%!<br />

)6(6:6%6! +0%! )#(#5#! 036:+6>! G$(! #=$3)#! #.=$3#7#G$3$(! -#! ='(='+!%! !+='(.'7'!<br />

?!='(.!3:'+!! A#(#=#G$3$(B! R3)6=?'! +!=! 0(.'7'! ?!='%! )6(6:! $+#4! +@#+$1$=! 03:'7'%!<br />

3#>70%3'(!%!='(='+3'(!%!'7!@3!!G636%:'3'(!%'!703!'?:'3'(!)!(B!!<br />

2$3)$($3:#+$! >0(6%36! 03'%! G$(! &'+.'3!!%! 0(.'7'! ?!=:'+!! )6(6:6%)'! NROL! 3$+.#+$P4!<br />

=#+$3#%! .D:! &'7-'%3'(! $?$%! '7(!! '7(!! ='('(! -#($3:#+$%#! A#(#=! 70=.6(B! 26! A$G$!<br />

)6(6:3'()'4!+U>!=0%6+6!+D(D3#(!7'+'3!+0%6?3'('!.'G$!036(3'(B!!<br />

!<br />

J=N=$%+.A+'$^+._+-+.!,!,$7567,'79-77$$<br />

L#(!)$#(!@'(?'3'(!03:'+!!A#(#=.$$!A$G$7+#!-#!)#%#7$:4!='3$.#!$?$%!A#(#=3$!03'%!&#(!<br />

#7! +'3'%:!! )$70(+'4! =#+$3#%! &'7-'%3'(!%! +')#5#! G#33$! @'(?'3'(!%!%! 67A6%+6>!<br />

03)66%6! )#=3'(#! #.:#=! :D:=D%)D(B! EH'3$.#F! .#($:$! G6(')'! .':':!73'! )676+'34!<br />

@'.030I$=4! :$=(0G$7030I$=! 7'! )'! =0:@0>$+70%! 7U%3#($! '%3':!%'! A#3$(B! 26!<br />

@'(':#.(#3#($%!.0@3':!!$%+'%!.D=#.$:$%#!67A6%36=!'%3':!%'!A#3$(B!!<br />

!<br />

K'G30!^B!i#>70%3'(!%!G#3$(3#%:#+$!-#!.'%!:!!N*($#+4!VWW[P!!<br />

;+$.#+Y! ! ='(!%!G0366%)'!A#%$3#:#!<br />

HD?D=!&'7-'%3'(Y!<br />

e[[bZ[[!A(!'3.!%)'=$!'!(3!=.'!5'%3!!G(073#(3#(!<br />

;%0(:'3!#=$3Y!<br />

U>#33$=3#!G'5'=3'(!-#!+.#(%6:!<br />

26(+$.$+!+.#(%'3$+Y!<br />

)#($%$%!A#%$3#:#+$4!)#($!'3.!%)'!&#:0('I$7#!-'('%!(#%=!<br />

G0>63:'+!!<br />

,76>Y!<br />

#A>':'!A$G$!s!]!5:!?'@3!!='&-#(#%A$!G'3!@#.#$!<br />

c#($%!)#(:'.$.Y!<br />

)#($%$%! +'(!b='&-#(#%A$:+$4! =!+:#%! @'(3'=! )$11D>!<br />

A#%$3#:#+$!<br />

H'%!%!.':!03'('=!'=!.!3:':'+!! ='(='+! ?0=! =076! =!(:!>!:+!! 7'! )'! A#%#3)#! :'-$b<br />

=!(:!>!:+!!<br />

T#@.$+#:$!!<br />

H'%!%!.':!03'('=!'=!.!3':':':+!%)'%!'7(!3':'>!<br />

H0@:'3'(!<br />

)#($!-#!='+!3#>70%3'(!!<br />

H!(!3:'3'(Y!<br />

=#:$=3#(!AU(D%D(!<br />

n$.#3$=!03'('=!3#>70%Y!<br />

n$5#3$=!03'('=!3#>70%Y!<br />

! ]<br />

n$5#3!U>#33$=3#($!03:'7'%!G$(!3#>70%6%!='('=.#($!<br />

i#>70%3'(!%! 706%366! -#! 30='3$>'+70%6%6%! 7'%!!+!('!<br />

3#>70%6%!7'7A!%3!!!<br />

!<br />

i0='3!&'+'(!)6(6:6%)'4!G6%)'%!30='3!3#>70%!+0(6:36)6(B!26!30='3$>#!G$(!#%1#=+$70%!<br />

$?$%!)#!)0(6!03'G$3$(B!m(%#$%4!='(!%!G0366%)'!7'%A!!03'%!!&$%)$3#(!D>#($%)#!7'@!3'%!<br />

$%5#3#:#3#(! 7'%A!%!%! ='(!%! G0366%)'! 30='3$>#! 03)66%6! AU+.#(:$.$(! N*($#+! #.! '3B!<br />

d[[^PB! 26! +0%6?3'('! )'7'%'('=4! &'-'! =#+#+$! 7'%A!+!! )6(6:6%)'! ='('(! +')#5#!<br />

:'=(0+=0@$=!3#>70%3'('!)'7'3!!03'('=!-#($3:#3$)$(B!<br />

m>#3! )6(6:3'()'4! U(%#$%! G6! .D(! @(0G3#:3#(! &$%)$! #.$! :6'7#%#+$%)#! G(073#(!<br />

+D(D3#($%$%!=#+$:$%)#=$%)#%!)'&'!+!=!0(.'7'!?!='(B!<br />

$<br />

N=$VF'1$)F.1&)$A+,+1-!$&1($/&,&1()($5+^+,$^&.'F,&-$$<br />

L.! )#%#.$:$! +!('+!%)'! @#(+0%#3! D>#($%)#=$! 7D=! '!()!(Y! $?! 0(A'%3'(!%! -#! ='(='+!%!<br />

'7(!3:'+!4! ='(='+!%! '(='! 7D>D%D%! '7%'! 7'()!:!! $3#! )#%#.$:$! -#! 7D=+#=! &!>3!! &'.3'(!


$%+'%!AU>D%D%!=0(6%:'+!>!-#!)#+.#=+$>!='3:'+!%'!703!'?'(B!J(0+#)D(D!7D=+#=!&!>3'!<br />

7#($%#! A#.$(#%! ='(:'!=! :'=$%'3'(! &'..'! +'%$7#)#! +')#5#! G$(! ='(='+!%! $%5#3#%:#+$%$!<br />

+'3'7'%!&'.!'7!(!5!3'(3'!G$3#!)#%#.$:$%!%#!=')'(!#.=$3$!-#!AD-#%3$!03)66!.'(.!!3'G$3$(B!!<br />

CU(+#3!$%5#3#:#!$3#!$3A$3$!?#$.3$!('@0(3'('!AU(#4!3#>70%3'(!%!$3#:#!&'..!%)'%!.':':#%!<br />

#3$:$%#!#)$3:#+$!:D:=D%!)#$3)$(B!264!'7%!!3#>70%6%!1'(=3!!=$$3#(!.'('1!%)'%!G$(#7+#3!<br />

03'('=!)##(3#%)$(:#+$%$%!7'%!!+!('!1'(=3!!&'.!&!>3'(!73'!)'!$3A$3$)$(!N*($#+!#.!'3B!VWWdh!<br />

*($#+!'%)!H0G#4!VWW]PB!!<br />

!<br />

26! G'3':)'4! $=$! #=$3)#! 7'%$! 7'%3!b! %#A'.$1! N!+='(.'7'! ?!='5'=! ':'! .D=#.$:! $?$%!<br />

67A6%P! -#7'4! 7'%3!b@0>$.$1! N.D=#.$:! $?$%! 67A6%! ':'! !+='(.'7'! ?!='5'=P! )#%#.$:!<br />

+0%6?3'(!! 03'G$3$(B! H'%'.3!! $3#:#+$%)#! '(.'%! &'.! &!>!73'! G$(3$=.#4! $%+'%! .'('1!%)'%!<br />

7'@!3'%! AU(+#3! )#%#.$:$%! 3$:$.3#($! 03)66%6%! 1'(=!%'! -'(:':!>! A#(#=$(B! m>#33$=3#!<br />

G(073#(! D(#.$:$%)#! &'.3'(!%! +'&$@! 03)66! 7D=+#=! &!>!! )#%A#3#7#G$3:#=! $?$%! ?#$.3$!<br />

+#?#%#=3#(!G636%:'=.')!(Y!!<br />

! i#>70%3'(!%!0(.'7'!?!=!3'(!%!%!=0%.(03!#)$3#G$3:#+$!$?$%!+D(D)#!&'+.'3!=3'(!%!<br />

U%3#%:#+$!N2$0AD-#%3$=P!<br />

! $3#.:#3#()#!.#=%$=!&'.'3'(!%!#%A#33#%:#+$!$?$%!7$!\'7-'%5!3!=!,7A63':'3'(!!<br />

=633'%!3'('=!.#=%0@'.$=!3#>70%3'(!%!U%3#%:#+$!<br />

! H#+$3#%! &'7-'%3'(!%! $3#%:#+$! +!('+!%)'! #3$:$%#! #.:#! $$%$%! '(.:'+!%'! )'!<br />

%#)#%!03'%!.#=%$=!&'.'3'(!%!U%3#%:#+$!$?$%!&'.!.#=%030I$+$%$%!A#3$.$($3:#+$!<br />

! c#%#.$:! +$+.#:3#($%$%! =#%)$! '3'%!%)'! A#3$.$($3:#+$Y! G6(')'4! &'.! &!>!%)'%!<br />

='7%'=3'%'%! 036:+6>36=3'(!! A#3#%#=+#3! #=$3)#! )#%A#3#:#=! $?$%! A#%#33$=3#!<br />

&'..!%!)$#(!.'('1!%)'!'7%'3'(4!!&'.!'7!(!5!3'(!-#7'!$(=#.!?'3!'%3'(!!N)#%#.$:!<br />

#3#:'%!! $=$3#:$! -#7'! AU(+#3! +!%!(3':'! #=3$%)#! '7%!! @(0G3#:! $3#!<br />

='(!3'5'=3'()!(P! 7#(3#.$($3:#=.#)$(B! ;3.#(%'.$1! ?U>D:4! &'3$&'>!()'!<br />

67A63'%:'=.'!03'%!G$3A$+'7'(!)#+.#=3$!=':#('!+$+.#:3#($!03'G$3$(B!NG=>!n0!ePB!<br />

! l00%0.$=! 'I'%3'(!! -#7'! ='3!%.!3'(! $3#! $3A$3$! 03'('=! $+#! :'=(0+=0@$=! $%5#3#:#!<br />

7'@!3'('=!&#(&'%A$!G$(!G$3A$7#!63'!3':':!.!(B!!<br />

!<br />

K'G30!eB!2(073#(3#(!$3#!$3A$3$!='('(!-#($3:#+$!p!L.!c#%#.$:$%)#%!-#!)$#(!.'=!:3'(!<br />

.'('1!%)'%!&'>!(3'%'%!G$3A$!10(:3'(!%'!)'7'%'('=!'7%!!='(='+!%!7#%$)#%!)#%#.$:$%)#%!<br />

#3)#!#)$3#%!+0%6?3'(!N*($#+!'%)!H0G#4!VWW]PB!<br />

L.!)#%#.$:$!+0%6?3'(!!<br />

X#%$)#%!)#%#.$:!+!('+!%)'!'7%!!!<br />

='('(!%!-#($3:#!7D>)#+$!<br />

K0@3':! 67A6%! !+='(.'! 67A6%! !+='(.'! .0@3':!<br />

VW4e]d! Vg4g[[! ^4d]d! WgBZ!t! ^ZB[!t! fgBg!t!<br />

!<br />

K'G30!ZB!L.!c#%#.$:!J#(10(:'%+!%'!-#!2''(!+!%'!L.=$!L)#%!*'=.U(3#(!N*"OLT!VWW[P!<br />

L.!)#%#.$:$!U%5#+$!<br />

! TD(D!&'7-'%5!3!!!&$I7#%$!-#!7U%#.$:!<br />

! J'(.$.#%!#3$:$%#!#)$3#5#=!3#>70%3'(!%!:$=.'(!!<br />

! n'=3$7#!#=3$%)#%!='7%'=3'%'%!3#>70%3'(!<br />

H#+$:!\'..!%!%!R(A'%$>'+70%6!-#!L=$@:'%!!<br />

! \'..'! =#+$:! $3#! $3A$3$! $%+'%'! 7'()!:5!! 03'%! -#7'! $%+'%!%! 7#($%#! A#?#%!<br />

)0%'%!:!<br />

! \'.!&!>!!<br />

! K#+$+!@#(+0%#3$!.'('1!%)'%!U%!'7!=3':'!<br />

! TD(D%D%!+.'.D+D!&'==!%)'!#.!)#%#.$:$!U%5#+$!-#($3#%!G$3A$3#(!<br />

! !#


\'..'=$!)#%#.$:!%0=.'3'(!%!%!+'7!+!!<br />

L.!c#%#.$:!R(A'%$>'+70%6!*'=.U(3#($! !<br />

! c#%#.$:!#3#:'%!%!%!@0>$+70%6!<br />

! ;)':!G'!%'!#.!)#%#.$:$!+D(#+$!<br />

! ! CD%3D=!.0@3':!+D(#!<br />

! ! 2$(!)#%#.$:!D%$.#+$%)#!A#?#%!+D(#!<br />

! ! 903'!@3'%3':'+!!<br />

k'3!:'!7#($%)#=$!1'=.U(3#(!<br />

! \'..'!03'%!:#+'1#!<br />

! k'3!:'!7#($%$%!A#%$3#.$3:#+$!!<br />

! O!=!='3$.#+$!<br />

! \$I7#%!5$&'>3'(!%!%!=6(636:6!NG!?'=3'(!%!.#:$>3#%:#+$!-#!)#>#%1#=+$70%6!b!<br />

jucP!<br />

c#%#.$:!#3#:'%!!.#5(DG#+$!<br />

H'(='+!-#!0(A'%3'(!%!=0%.':$%'+70%6%'!703!'?'%!3#>70%3'(!%!.'%!:!!!<br />

!<br />

T=$D(-6('+5+.$/&'1&A-($A+)&.+$'('1&)($<br />

c#%#.$:! #3#:'%!! .'('1!%)'%!7'@!3'%! AU(+#3! $4! &'..!%! 7D=+#=! &!>)'! 03:'+!! %#)#%$73#!<br />

70(656)6(B! \'.! D>#($%)#=$! ='(='+3'(!%! &#@+$! G$(G$($%#! G#%>#)$$%)#%4! )#%#.$:!<br />

#3#:'%3'(!! 3#>70%3'(!! AU>)#%! ='?!('G$3$(3#(B! 26! )6(6:! 7'()!:5!! +$+.#:! '('7!!%'!<br />

%#)#%!03:'=.')!(B!26%6%3'!$3A$3$!:'=$%'3'(!:#-56.!036@4!=0%6!)##(3#%)$($3:#=.#)$(B!<br />

L=! 03'('=4! 3'G0('.6-'(! .#:#33$! $%5#3#:#3#(! >':'%! '3!(B! 26! %0=.')'4! %6:6%#!<br />

'3!%:'=+!>!%!1$>$=+#3!U3?D.3#(#!AU(#!N1'(=3!!)'3A'!G073'(!%)'Y!AU(+#3!-#!=!>!3U.#+$P!&'.!<br />

D>#($! -#! A#(?#=! >':'%3!! )0%'%!:! >'.#%! :#-56..6(B! 2U73#5#! ='%'.3!! $3#:#+$%)#4!<br />

:'=$%#3#($%!7'()!:!!$3#!?#$.3$!':'?3'('!63'!3'G$3$(Y!<br />

! ;2!b!!H'3$.#!XU%#.:#3$$%#!AU(#!='3$.#!)##(3#%)$(:#+$!!<br />

! $(=#.!$?$!='3$.#!@03$.$='3'(!!7'!)'!:D.#($!.'3#@3#($%#!AU(#!='3$.#!AU>#.$:$!<br />

! i#>70%3'(4! #.! )#%#.$:! ':'?3'(!! $?$%! 7'! )'! :D.#($! .'3#@3#($%#! AU(#! ='3$.#!<br />

=0%.(03D!$?$%!U%#:3$)$(!NJ'(=!'%)!j&#%4!d[[[h!8'%!\001!'%)!L5.0(+4!d[[dP!!!<br />

! H0%.':$%'%.3'(Y!D%$.#)#!7D=+#=!T'3:0%#33'!-'(3!!!($+=$%#!$'(#.!#)#G$3#5#=!<br />

-#!E#%)#=+!p!1'=.U(F!03'('=!=633'%!3'G$3#5#=!1#='3!=0%.':$%'+70%6%!AU(D%D(!<br />

$%)$='.U(3#($!Ni'Q(#%5#!#.!'3B!d[[dh!K&0(%.0%4!d[[gPB!<br />

!<br />

a'.=$%+! -#! '(=B! NVWWWP! 7'%3!! @0>$.$1! ! N7'%$! !+='(.'P! ='(='+3'(!%! 0('%!%!%! t! gb^!<br />

03)66%6! G$3)$(:$.$(B! 26%'! #=! 03'('=4! 7'>'(3'(4! =':#('! +$+.#:3#($! D>#($%#! )#! #.=$+$!<br />

03'%! .#:$>3$=! -#! )#>#%1#=+$70%! +!('+!%)'! 0(.'7'! ?!='%! #=+.(#:! =0633'('! -6(A6!<br />

7'@:!3'()!(B!8'%!\001! '%)! L5.0(+! Nd[[dP! G$(! ='%'.3!!$3#:#!1'G($='+!%)'!G$(!AU(D!<br />

+$+.#:$%$%! @('.$=.#! %'+!3! ?'3!'5'!%!! )##(3#%)$(:$3#()$(B! X'>'(3'(4! +$+.#:$%! G'>!!<br />

3#>70%3'(! $?$%! $7$! ?'3!.!!%!4! G'>!! 3#>70%3'(! $?$%! $+#! G'>!! >0(36=3'(! 0(.'7'! ?!=.!!%!!<br />

G$3)$(:$3#()$(B! H0%673'! $3A$3$! U%! )##(3#%)$(:#3#(! -GB! T36$+! NVWWVP! -#! *($#+! Nd[[]P!<br />

.'('1!%)'%! +6%63:6.6(B! T0%6?! 03'('=! 6! '%)'! ''!)'=$! 3#>70%3'(!%! .#+@$.! #)$3#G$3$(!<br />

03)6=3'(!!G$3)$($3:$.$(Y!!<br />

! n0(:'3)#%!'>!'!(3!=.'!='(='+3'(!<br />

! c$+=030('+70%!N(#%=!G0>6=36=3'(!P!<br />

! ;%0(:'3!AU(D%.D3D!='(='+3'(!<br />

! X'('3'%:'3'(!!!<br />

!<br />

! !!


a'.=$%+!-#!'(=B!NVWWWP'3.!3:'+!!<br />

A$G$!)$#(!=0%63'('!=0%+'%.(#!03'G$3:#+$!':'5!73'4!AU(+#3!=0%.(03D%!7#($%$!0.0:'.$=!<br />

)#%#.$:!.#=%030I$+$%$%!'3:'+!!&6+6+6%6!)DD%:#=.#)$(B!<br />

!<br />

i#>70%3'(!%! .#+@$.! #)$3:#+$! -#! .D=#.$5$%$%! AD-#%$%$%! )#! +'3'%:'+!! '?!+!%)'%! G$(!<br />

AU(+#3! ='(='+! =0%.(03! +$+.#:$! A#(#=3$)$(B! ;+3!%)'! $3#.:#3#(#! AU(#! )#$#G$3:#=3#!<br />

G#('G#(!3#>70%3'(!%!AU>3#:3#%:#+$!A#(#=:#=.#)$(B!26!)'4!:'3$7#.3#($!=0%.(03!'3.!%)'!<br />

.6.:'7'! )'! 7'()!:5!! 03'%! 0.0:'.$=! $3#:#! )#+.#=3#($%$%! =633'%!3:'+!! $3#! +')#5#!<br />

:D:=D%)D(B!!<br />

!<br />

W=$"F,7_$<br />

H'%'.3!! #.$! )#%#.$:$%)#4! >$%5$($%! .D:D%)#%! #3)#! #)$3#%! U#3#(4! +D(D! -#! +D(D%D%!<br />

)6(6:6!$3#!GD7D=!(#+:$!7'%+!.!(B!26%6%!$?$%4!#11'13!=!A#(#=3$)$(Y!<br />

! TD(D%D%!=3$%$=!-#($3#($%$!-#!3#>70%3'(!%!0(.'7'!?!=:'+!!$3#!$3A$3$!@0+.!:0(.#:!<br />

-#($3#($%$!)#!$?#(#%!?$1.3$=.#%!.#:$%!#)$3#%!+'3!=!-#($3#($!<br />

! !\'7-'%!(#1'&!%!%!+'3'%)!!%'!)'$(!)#3$33#(!<br />

! K#)'-$! ':'?3!$! $3'?3'(!%! N$7$3#.$($5$P! =633'%!:!! $3#! $3A$3$! G$3A$3#($%! .#:$%!<br />

#)$3:#+$!<br />

! l00%0.$=!'I'%3'(!%!7'7A!%3!!!!<br />

!<br />

K#=%$=!&'..'%!AD-#%3$!D(D%3#(!?!=:'3!)!(B!N=D:#+!$?$%)#!G$0AD-#%3$=4!=#+$:&'%#)#!7$!<br />

\$I7#%!,7A63':'3'(!!b!C\JP!2$(!='%'.3!!+D(D+D!#%)D+.($7#3!'(.3'(!'3.!%)'4!.D:!7'':!<br />

+D(#+$! $?$%)#! =0%.(03! '3.!%)')!(! NE?$1.3$=.#%! +01('7'FPB! H0%.(03! &#:! >0(6%36!<br />

NE=0%.(03D%!=0%.(03DF!7'!)'!)$(#=.!)#%#.3#:#P!&#:!)#!)'&$3$!03'('=!7'@!3:'=.'!036@!<br />

$3A$3$! .D:! &6+6+3'(!!N%+'%! +'3!!4! &'7-'%! +'3!!! -#! &'7-'%! (#1'&!P! $?#(#%! -#! A!)'!<br />

>$%5$($%$!AD-#%$3$(!G$(! #=$3)#!7'%+!.'G$3#5#=!0(A'%$>'+70%4!='3$1$7#!@#(+0%#3!-#!'?!=!<br />

@'(':#.(#3#(! A#(#=.$(:#=.#)$(B! ;%.#! :0(.#:! )#%#.$:! +!('+!%)'! :D%1#($.! 70(6:!<br />

7'@!3!(=#%4! @0+.! :0(.#:! )#%#.$:)#! $+#! ! 70(A6%36=! -#! .D=#.$:#! 67A6%36=! 7'! )'!<br />

67A6%+6>36=!$3#!$3A$3$!=$$+#3! ='('(!'%'!&6+6+.6(B!2'>#%4!1'(=3!!GU3A#3#()#!'7!(:'! $$!<br />

1'(=3!!036(B!T.'%)'()$>'+70%!!A#(#=3$)$(B!J0+.!:0(.#:!#.!)#%#.$:$4!3#>70%3'(!$3#!$3A$3$!<br />

AU>3#:!-#!#3$:$%'+70%!&6+6+3'(!%!!$?#($(!-#!)#%#.$:!#3#:'%3'(!%)'%!='('(!-#(:#3#($!<br />

-#!#!>':'%3!!03'('=!='3$.#!$3#!$3A$3$!='7!.!7'@:'3'(!!$+.#%$(!NG$(!+0%('=$!+D(D)#!A#3$$:$!<br />

='7)#)#G$3:#=! -#7'! '!(! -'='3'(!! 0(.'7'! ?!='(.'G$3:#=! $?$%! A#($! G$3)$($:!<br />

:#='%$>:'+!P!;%5'=4!G6!'%$!='('(!!-#(:#=!=03'7!)#$3)$(!-#!&'=3'(!%)'!='('(!-#($3$@!<br />

!+='(.'7'! ?!='(.!3'%! &'7-'%3'(! ?06%36=3'! +')#5#! EG6>)'!%!%! AU(D%#%! =!+:!)!(FB!<br />

26%6%! '%3':!! &#(! G$(! &'7-'%! '7%!! 3#>70%3'(!! .'!7'G$3$(! -#! 1'(=! #)$3:#)#%! )#%#.$:!<br />

%0=.'+!%)'%! A#?#G$3$(B! J0+.! :0(.#:! G63A63'(Y! G6! -#($3#($%! )##($4! A#%#3! &'7-'%!<br />

(#1'&!%!%! N.#=%0@'.$P4! A#%#3! &'7-'%! +'3!!%!%! NU(%#$%! '!(3!=! )'!3!:!P4! &$I7#%$%!<br />

NAU(+#3! =0%.':$%'+70%4! #-$+#('+70%P! -#7'! ='3$.#! $3#! $3A$3$! &6+6+3'(!%! NU(%#$%!<br />

?D(D=3#(P!.'%!%:'+!%)'!7'.:'=.')!(B!%+'%!A!)'+!!':'?3!!7#.$.$($3#%!&'7-'%3'(!%!7'!)'!<br />

G$(! +D(D%D%! +'3!!%!%! '%3':!! @#.! ':'?3!! &'7-'%3'(!%! +'3!!%)'! )'&'! 1'(=3!! '%3':!<br />

.'!:'=.')!(B! C!)'! ':'?3!! &'7-'%3'(4! .D:! 7'':! +D(#3#($! G076%5'! +'3!=3!!<br />

='3:'3!)!(3'(Y! m>#33$=3#4! G$(! ='%'.3!! +D(D+D%)#4! G$(! &'+.'3!!%! 0(.'7'! ?!=:'+!!<br />

7''%'G$3#5#=!#%!GD7D=!='>'3'()'%!G$($!036@!>00%0>3'(!0(.'7'!?!=:':'3!4!&'7-'%3'(!<br />

$%+'%'! >'('(3!! &$?! G$(! 'I'%! 7'! )'! :'))#! N$7$3#.$($5$3#(4! >00%0.$=! 'I'%3'(! -#7'! )$(#%?!<br />

A#%3#($P! .'!:':'3!)!(3'(B! ;%5'=4! A#(#=3$! 03)66%)'! &'7-'%! (#1'&!! %#)#%3#($%$%!<br />

)!!%)'!.#)'-$!>0(6%36)6(B!;20(6%36!036@!G6%'!#=!03'('=4!<br />

! !C


7#.=$3$!:'=':3'('!#.!)#%#.$:$!A$G$!U>#3!)#%#.$:!AU(#-3#($!-#($3:$.$(B!J#(+0%#3$%!@0+.!<br />

:0(.#:!)#%#.$:)#!7#(!'3:'3'(!%'!'%5'=!U>#3!=0633'(!'3.!%)'!$>$%!-#($3$(B!<br />

!<br />

H'7%'=3'(!7'>'()'%!#3)#!#)$3#G$3$(!<br />

"#$%&'()!*($#+4!c894!c(B:#)B-#.B4!c(B!&'G$34!)$@3B!Lj8J\!!!<br />

J'%#3!8#.#($%'(7!J6G3$5!\#'3.&4!O%+.$.6.#!01!9#'.!\7A$#%#!'%)!K#5&%030A74!!<br />

*(#$#!,%$-#(+$./.!01!2#(3$%4!*'563.7!01!8#.#($%'(7!9#)$5$%#4!2(D::#(+.(B!V[4!c!VgVW^!2#(3$%4!C#(:'%7!<br />

1($#+B(#$%&'()v-#.:#)B16bG#(3$%B)#!<br />

! !H


S 002 Piliç <strong>Et</strong>i Sektörü: Hedefler ve Potansiyel Problemler<br />

Poultry Meat Industry: Targets and Potential Problems<br />

Sait Koca<br />

BESD-BİR, <strong>Beyaz</strong> <strong>Et</strong> Sanayicileri ve Damzlkçlar Birliği<br />

Piliç eti sektörü genç bir sektör. 1980 li yllardan itibaren atak yapt. Çok hzl bir<br />

büyüme göstererek Dünyada önemli bir konuma ulaşt. Modern ve ileri teknolojilerin<br />

tamamn uyguluyor. Piliç eti kalitesi Dünya standartlarnn üzerinde. Türk insannn<br />

hayvansal protein açğn kapatmada çok önemli rol oynad ve oynamaya devam<br />

ediyor.<br />

Anakaralarn Nüfuslar, Milyon<br />

1990 2000 2010 2020 2050<br />

Dünya 5.295 6.124 6.907 7.667 9.191<br />

Afrika 636 813 1.007 1.228 1.937<br />

Avrupa 788 728 715 705 644<br />

Asay-Pasifik ülkeleri 3.127 3.707 4.165 4.593 5.265<br />

Latin amerika-karayipler 444 523 599 667 783<br />

Kuzey amerika 283 315 346 375 438<br />

Kaynak: 2010 executive guide to world poultry trends<br />

Dünya nüfusu sürekli artyor. 2010 da 6,9 milyar olan nüfus 2050 de 9,2 milyar<br />

olacak. Artan nüfusun beslenmesi, ayrca daha iyi beslenmesi dünyann ana gündem<br />

maddesi. Bugün bile açlk snrnda pek çok insan varken, gelecekte beslenme<br />

sorununun nasl çözüleceği ise bir muamma.<br />

14


Dünya Piliç <strong>Et</strong>i Üretimi (Milyon Ton)<br />

Anakaralar 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009<br />

Afrika 2,8 3,0 3,1 3,1 3,2 3,3 3,4 3,5 3,6 3,6<br />

Avrupa 9,4 9,9 10,3 10,1 10,4 10,7 10,8 11,7 12,0 13,4<br />

Asya 18,2 18,7 19,7 20,5 20,5 21,6 22,5 23,6 24,5 25,4<br />

Amerika 27,2 28,2 29,3 30,0 32,2 32,7 33,7 35,2 37,1 36,2<br />

Okyanusya 0,7 0,8 0,8 0,9 0,9 0,9 0,9 1,0 1,0 1,0<br />

Toplam 58,3 60,5 63,1 64,6 67,2 69,2 71,3 75,1 78,2 79,6<br />

Kaynak: 2010 executive guide to world poultry trends<br />

Dünya piliç eti üretimindeki artş son 10 ylda % 37<br />

Dünya Piliç <strong>Et</strong>i Üretimi (Milyon Ton)<br />

Kaynak: 2010 executive guide to world poultry trends<br />

En belirgin üretim artş Asya ve Amerika ktalarnda<br />

En Fazla Piliç <strong>Et</strong>i Üreten Ülkeler(Milyon Ton)<br />

Ülke 2007 Ülke 2007<br />

1 Amerika Bir. Dev.. 16.000 11 Arjantin 1.160<br />

2 Çin 10.856 12 İspanya 1.067<br />

3 Brezilya 8.670 13 Tayland 1.050<br />

4 Meksika 2.500 14 Kanada 1.030<br />

5 Hindistan 2.200 15 Türkiye 1.012<br />

6 Rusya Federasyonu 1.722 16 Güney Afrika 0.975<br />

7 İran 1.423 17 Malezya 0.931<br />

8 Endonezya 1.331 18 Polonya 0.825<br />

9 İngiltere 1.300 19 Avustralya 0.810<br />

10 Japonya 1.290 20 Peru 0.800<br />

Kaynak: 2010 executive guide to world poultry trends<br />

Türkiye, üretimde 2007 yl itibariyle dünyada 15. Srada. 2012 ylnda 7. srada yer<br />

almamz sürpriz olmayacaktr.<br />

15


Türkiye Kanatl <strong>Et</strong>i Üretimi (ton)<br />

Köy ve Yum.<br />

Yllar Piliç <strong>Et</strong>i Hindi <strong>Et</strong>i Tavuklar, Diğer Toplam<br />

Kanatl <strong>Et</strong>i<br />

1990 162.569 0 54.190 216.759<br />

1995 313.154 2.646 101.739 417.539<br />

2000 662.096 23.265 67.021 752.382<br />

2001 592.567 38.991 41.813 673.371<br />

2002 620.581 24.582 60.043 705.206<br />

2003 768.012 34.078 51.255 853.345<br />

2004 940.889 46.248 58.295 1.045.432<br />

2005 978.400 53.530 52.850 1.084.780<br />

2006 945.779 45.750 40.250 1.031.779<br />

2007 1.012.000 33.000 55.000 1.100.000<br />

2008 1.150.000 35.000 57.000 1.242.000<br />

2009 1.180.000 30.000 60.000 1.270.000<br />

2010 1.420.000 30.000 62.000 1.512.000<br />

Kaynak: BESD-BİR<br />

Türkiye piliç eti üretimindeki artş ise son 10 ylda % 142<br />

Türkiye kanatl eti tüketimi (ton)<br />

Köy ve Yumurta<br />

Yllar Piliç <strong>Et</strong>i Hindi <strong>Et</strong>i Tavuklar, Diğer Toplam<br />

Kanatl <strong>Et</strong>i<br />

2001 580.281 38.650 41.813 662.745<br />

2002 613.824 24.118 60.043 699.987<br />

2003 759.631 33.255 51.255 846.144<br />

2004 929.793 45.633 58.295 1.035.725<br />

2005 949.773 51.547 52.850 1.056.175<br />

2006 926.967 45.431 40.250 1.014.654<br />

2007 987.784 32.233 54.392 1.076.416<br />

2008 1.103.400 33.701 54.663 1.193.772<br />

2009 1.103.063 29.047 55.305 1.189.424<br />

2010 1.313.360 28.964 53.569 1.397.903<br />

Kaynak: BESD-BİR<br />

16


Türkiye kişi başna kanatl eti tüketimi (kg)<br />

Köy ve Yum.<br />

Piliç Hindi<br />

Yllar<br />

Tavuklar, Diğer<br />

<strong>Et</strong>i <strong>Et</strong>i<br />

Kanatl <strong>Et</strong>i<br />

Toplam<br />

2001 8,91 0,59 0,64 10,17<br />

2002 9,30 0,37 0,91 10,60<br />

2003 11,36 0,50 0,77 12,65<br />

2004 13,73 0,67 0,86 15,29<br />

2005 13,85 0,75 0,77 15,40<br />

2006 13,35 0,65 0,58 14,62<br />

2007 14,06 0,46 0,77 15,32<br />

2008 15,52 0,47 0,77 16,80<br />

2009 15,34 0,40 0,77 16,54<br />

2010 18,07 0,40 0,74 19,23<br />

Kaynak: BESD-BİR<br />

Türkiye kişi başna piliç eti tüketimi (kg)<br />

Türkiye kanatl eti ihracat, ton<br />

Yllar Tavuk Hindi Diğer Ayak İşlenmiş Toplam<br />

2001 12.286 341 0 11.790 0 24.417<br />

2002 6.757 464 0 12.779 0 20.000<br />

2003 8.381 823 0 15.818 0 25.022<br />

2004 11.096 615 0 17.339 0 29.050<br />

2005 28.627 1.983 0 15.710 0 46.320<br />

2006 18.812 319 0 18.971 0 38.102<br />

2007 24.824 767 0 26.165 0 51.756<br />

2008 48.937 1.299 0 30.508 0 80.744<br />

2009 81.632 953 3 32.511 0 115.099<br />

2010 104.128 1.036 0 35.232 10.943 151.339<br />

Kaynak: DTM ve İhracatç Birlikleri<br />

17


Kanatl etinde ana ihracatç ülkeler (2009)<br />

Kaynak: 2010 executive guide to world poultry trends<br />

Türkiye’nin ihracatç ülke konumuna geçişi dş kaynaklarda da yer almaya başlad.<br />

Ülkelere göre türkiye’nin kanatl eti ihracat, ton (Ayak Hariç)<br />

2006 2007 2008 2009 2010<br />

Irak 2.182 681 9.326 50.666 71.185<br />

Türk Cumhuriyetleri 11.562 14.529 20.432 17.362 19.962<br />

İran 0 0 501 0 4.632<br />

Hong Kong 908 1.479 0 59 2.079<br />

Vietnam 1.728 4.422 8.351 3.608 2.844<br />

Bosna Hersek 2.061 2.256 4.361 3.081 2.132<br />

KKTC 72 38 846 236 589<br />

Rusya 0 0 0 0 41<br />

Diğerleri 618 2.186 6.418 7.576 12.644<br />

Toplam 19.130 25.591 50.235 82.588 116.107<br />

Kaynak: DTM ve ihracatç birlikleri<br />

18


Parasal olarak türkiye kanatl eti ihracat<br />

Yillar Ton Milyon Dolar Dolar/Ton<br />

2001 24.417 14.2 582<br />

2002 20.000 11.9 595<br />

2003 25.022 16.4 655<br />

2004 29.050 19.8 682<br />

2005 46.320 33.7 728<br />

2006 38.102 27.2 714<br />

2007 51.756 43.4 839<br />

2008 80.744 86.8 1.075<br />

2009 115.099 152.6 1.326<br />

2010 151.339 229.9 1.519<br />

Kaynak: DTM ve ihracatç birlikleri<br />

Seçilmiş ülkelerin 2010 yl kişi başna et tüketimi (kg)<br />

Ülkeler Sğr Domuz Piliç Koyun Toplam<br />

Amerika Bir. Dev. 38,6 27,9 43,0 - 109,6<br />

Arjantin 60,4 6,2 32,3 - 98,9<br />

Avrupa Birliği 16,9 42,1 17,7 2,6 79,3<br />

Brezilya 34,6 21,9 38,5 - 93,0<br />

Çin 4,1 36,9 9,3 1,8 52,2<br />

Güney Afrika 14,1 - 28,8 - 42,8<br />

Hindistan 1,7 - 2,2 - 3,9<br />

Japonya 9,8 19,6 15,4 - 44,8<br />

Msr 7,4 - 6,9 - 14,3<br />

Rusya 14,5 21,8 19,7 - 56,0<br />

Tayland 3,1 10,6 12,4 - 26,1<br />

Türkiye 8,4 - 18,1 2,2 28,7<br />

Ukrayna 8,6 17,2 17,8 - 43,6<br />

Kaynak: World Meat: FAPRI 2010 Agricultural Outlook, Türkiye<br />

rakamlar TUİK ve Besd-Bir<br />

Türkiye kişi başna piliç eti tüketiminde Avrupa Birliği’ni geçti.<br />

19


Seçilmiş ülkelerin 2019 yl kişi başna et tüketimi projeksiyonu (kg)<br />

Ülkeler Sğr Domuz Piliç Koyun Toplam<br />

Amerika Bir. Dev. 37,0 27,8 46,3 0,0 111,1<br />

Arjantin 60,1 7,1 35,6 0,0 102,8<br />

Avrupa Birliği 17,0 43,1 18,5 2,7 81,3<br />

Brezilya 42,5 15,5 30,7 0,0 96,7<br />

Çin 5,2 45,1 11,1 2,1 63,5<br />

Güney Afrika 17,2 0,0 34,6 0,0 51,8<br />

Hindistan 1,8 0,0 2,4 0,0 4,2<br />

Japonya 11,1 21,5 15,8 0,0 48,4<br />

Msr 8,0 0,0 7,7 0,0 15,7<br />

Rusya 15,1 24,8 23,5 0,0 63,4<br />

Tayland 3,6 11,9 13,9 0,0 29,4<br />

Türkiye 10,0 0,0 27,9 2,3 40,2<br />

Ukrayna 9,5 21,9 22,8 0,0 54,2<br />

Kaynak: World Meat: FAPRI 2010 agricultural outlook, türkiye rakamlar<br />

TUİK ve Besd-Bir<br />

Seçilmiş ülkelerin piliç eti üretim projeksiyonu (bin ton)<br />

2009 2011 2013 2015 2017 2019<br />

ABD 15.945 16.510 17.173 17.810 18.497 19.231<br />

Arjantin 1.500 1.581 1.653 1.724 1.795 1.972<br />

Avrupa Birliği 8.620 8.729 8.832 8.939 9.023 9.094<br />

Brezilya 11.143 11.524 11.692 11.823 11.961 12.118<br />

Çin 12.100 12.701 13.336 13.965 14.521 14.998<br />

Endonezya 890 965 1.056 1.133 1.209 1.289<br />

Filipinler 725 803 840 865 888 909<br />

Hindistan 2.550 2.704 2.841 2.960 3.073 3.180<br />

Hong Kong 10 21 22 22 23 24<br />

Japonya 1.260 1.292 1.280 1.263 1.238 1.214<br />

Rusya 1.790 2.036 2.146 2.207 2.271 2.332<br />

Suudi Ara. 507 633 677 712 745 781<br />

Tayland 1.200 1.312 1.383 1.455 1.528 1.601<br />

Türkiye 1.180 1.570 1.800 2.010 2.210 2.420<br />

Ukrayna 620 702 746 770 792 824<br />

Diğer 13.016 12.660 13.376 13.999 14.612 15.269<br />

Toplam 73.056 75.743 78.853 81.657 84.386 87.256<br />

Kaynak: World Meat: FAPRI 2010 Agricultural Outlook, Türkiye rakamlar tahmin<br />

20


Seçilmiş ülkelerin piliç eti tüketim projeksiyonu (bin ton)<br />

2009 2011 2013 2015 2017 2019<br />

ABD 12.94513.66614.182 14.675 15.160 15.690<br />

Arjantin 1.331 1.378 1.443 1.501 1.561 1.617<br />

Avrupa Birliği 8.610 8.752 8.861 8.959 9.048 9.123<br />

Brezilya 7.486 7.888 8.090 8.248 8.383 8.538<br />

Çin 12.22012.83013.540 14.247 14.873 15.415<br />

Endonezya 0.900 0.967 1.036 1.088 1.148 1.202<br />

Filipinler 1.267 1.347 1.430 1.519 1.609 1.707<br />

Hindistan 2.549 2.703 2.840 2.959 3.072 3.179<br />

Hong Kong 0.260 0.274 0.280 0.285 0.290 0.296<br />

Japonya 1.960 1.952 1.959 1.953 1.941 1.926<br />

Rusya 2.665 2.815 2.924 2.986 3.050 3.110<br />

Suudi Ara. 1.185 1.260 1.337 1.393 1.449 1.501<br />

Tayland 0.805 0.846 0.878 0.907 0.938 0.966<br />

Türkiye 1.103 1.433 1.594 1.734 1.865 2.007<br />

Ukrayna 0.812 0.822 0.871 0.911 0.946 0.971<br />

Diğer 17.03516.77017.558 18.297 19.084 19.976<br />

Toplam 73.13375.70378.823 81.662 84.417 87.224<br />

Kaynak: World Meat: FAPRI 2010 agricultural outlook, türkiye<br />

rakamlar tahmin 2011 Yl Program;<br />

Seçilmiş ülkelerin piliç eti ithalat-ihracat projeksiyonu (x1000 ton)<br />

2009 2011 2013 2015 2017 2019<br />

ABD 3.000 2.844 2.991 3.135 3.337 3.541<br />

Arjantin 169 203 210 223 234 355<br />

Avrupa Birliği 10 -23 -29 -20 -25 -29<br />

Brezilya 3.657 3.636 3.602 3.575 3.578 3.580<br />

Çin -120 -129 -204 -282 -352 -417<br />

Endonezya -10 -2 20 45 61 87<br />

Filipinler -542 -544 -590 -654 -721 -798<br />

Hindistan 1 1 1 1 1 1<br />

Hong Kong -250 -253 -258 -263 -267 -272<br />

Japonya -700 -660 -679 -690 -703 -712<br />

Rusya -875 -779 -778 -779 -779 -778<br />

Suudi Ara. -678 -627 -660 -681 -704 -720<br />

Tayland 395 466 505 548 590 635<br />

Türkiye 77 137 206 276 345 413<br />

Ukrayna -192 -120 -125 -141 -154 -147<br />

Diğer -4.019 -4.110 -4.182 -4.298 -4.472 -4.707<br />

Kaynak: World Meat: FAPRI 2010 agricultural outlook, türkiye<br />

rakamlar tahmin<br />

21


“Krmz et üretimindeki skntlar nedeniyle, tavuk eti tüketimini artrmann<br />

hedeflenmesi önem arz etmektedir.”<br />

Hükümetin bu konudaki çalşmalar bir an önce başlatmas önemli.<br />

Sektör, üretim hedeflerini 2011 yl programnda yer alan bu mantk doğrultusunda<br />

belirliyor.<br />

Türkiye kanatl eti üretim projeksiyonu, ton<br />

Köy ve Yum.<br />

Yllar Piliç <strong>Et</strong>i Hindi <strong>Et</strong>i Tavuklar, Diğer Toplam<br />

Kanatl <strong>Et</strong>i<br />

2011 1.570.000 33.000 64.000 1.667.000<br />

2012 1.690.000 36.000 66.000 1.792.000<br />

2013 1.800.000 39.000 68.000 1.907.000<br />

2014 1.910.000 42.000 70.000 2.022.000<br />

2015 2.010.000 45.000 72.000 2.127.000<br />

2016 2.110.000 48.000 74.000 2.232.000<br />

2017 2.210.000 51.000 76.000 2.337.000<br />

2018 2.310.000 54.000 78.000 2.442.000<br />

2019 2.420.000 57.000 80.000 2.557.000<br />

Kaynak: BESD-BİR<br />

Türkiye kanatl eti ihracat projeksiyonu, ton<br />

Yillar Tavuk Hindi Diğer Ayak İşlenmiş Toplam<br />

2011 135.000 1.200 0 38.681 12.000 186.881<br />

2012 170.000 1.350 0 41.638 13.000 225.988<br />

2013 205.000 1.500 0 44.348 14.500 265.348<br />

2014 240.000 1.650 0 47.058 16.000 304.708<br />

2015 275.000 1.800 0 49.276 17.500 343.576<br />

2016 310.000 1.950 0 51.493 19.000 382.443<br />

2017 345.000 2.100 0 53.957 20.500 421.557<br />

2018 380.000 2.250 0 56.420 22.000 460.670<br />

2019 415.000 2.400 0 58.884 23.500 499.784<br />

Kaynak: BESD-BİR<br />

Potansiyel Problemler<br />

Hedeflenen üretim artşlarn gerçekleştirmek kolay olmayacaktr.<br />

Yem İhtiyac<br />

Hayvanclğn en önemli girdisi yem.<br />

Bu girdiyi hedeflenen üretim artşn karşlayabilecek miktar ve kalitede temin etmek<br />

kolay olmayacaktr.<br />

22


Türkiye kanatl eti tüketim projeksiyonu, ton<br />

Yllar Piliç <strong>Et</strong>i<br />

Köy ve Yum. Tavuklar,<br />

Hindi <strong>Et</strong>i Toplam<br />

Diğer Kanatl <strong>Et</strong>i<br />

2011 1.432.884 31.800 54.116 1.520.811<br />

2012 1.518.437 34.650 54.563 1.609.662<br />

2013 1.593.590 37.500 54.910 1.688.013<br />

2014 1.668.843 40.350 55.157 1.766.364<br />

2015 1.734.196 43.200 55.304 1.834.715<br />

2016 1.799.649 46.050 55.351 1.903.066<br />

2017 1.865.202 48.900 55.298 1.971.417<br />

2018 1.930.855 51.750 55.145 2.039.768<br />

2019 2.006.608 54.600 54.892 2.118.119<br />

Kaynak: BESD-BİR<br />

Türkiye’nin kişi başna kanatl eti tüketim projeksiyonu (kg)<br />

Yllar Piliç <strong>Et</strong>i Hindi <strong>Et</strong>i Köy ve Yum. Tavuklar, Diğer Kanatl <strong>Et</strong>i Toplam<br />

2011 22,00 0,49 0,83 23,35<br />

2012 23,00 0,52 0,83 24,39<br />

2013 23,83 0,56 0,82 25,24<br />

2014 24,64 0,60 0,81 26,08<br />

2015 25,29 0,63 0,81 26,75<br />

2016 25,92 0,66 0,80 27,41<br />

2017 26,55 0,70 0,79 28,06<br />

2018 27,16 0,73 0,78 28,70<br />

2019 27,91 0,76 0,76 29,46<br />

Türkiye karma yem üretimi (bin ton)<br />

Yillar Broiler Yumurta Damizlik Hindi Büyük-<br />

Küçükbaş<br />

Diğer Toplam<br />

2001 1.503 624 223 106 2.677 44 5.177<br />

2002 1.645 586 210 56 2.626 52 5.175<br />

2003 1.845 607 228 94 3.016 62 5.852<br />

2004 2.132 624 262 146 3.665 78 6.907<br />

2005 2.127 537 271 120 3.719 61 6.835<br />

2006 2.026 494 246 106 4.517 78 7.467<br />

2007 2.471 675 293 91 5.447 176 9.153<br />

2008 2.886 693 336 102 5.378 165 9.560<br />

2009 2.967 740 357 63 5.110 181 9.418<br />

2010 3.594 821 437 110 6.302 237 11.501<br />

Kaynak: Türkiye yem sanayicileri birliği<br />

23


Türkiye karma yem üretim projeksiyonu (bin ton)<br />

Yillar Broiler Yumurta Damizlik Hindi Büyük-<br />

Küçükbaş<br />

Diğer Toplam<br />

2011 4.004 919 610 99 6.932 254 12.818<br />

2012 4.310 984 657 108 7.590 271 13.919<br />

2013 4.590 1.050 699 117 8.273 288 15.018<br />

2014 4.871 1.117 742 126 8.977 306 16.138<br />

2015 5.126 1.188 781 135 9.695 324 17.248<br />

2016 5.381 1.261 820 144 10.422 342 18.369<br />

2017 5.636 1.334 859 153 11.151 359 19.492<br />

2018 5.891 1.407 898 162 11.876 377 20.611<br />

2019 6.171 1.481 940 171 12.589 394 21.746<br />

Türkiye karma yem sektörünün hammadde ihtiyac (bin ton)<br />

Msr Arpa Buğday Soya Soya Diğer Kepek<br />

Fasulyesi Küspesi Küspeler Razmol Diğer<br />

2010 3.462 3.224 1.104 713 898 1.865 2.442 1.441<br />

2011 3.899 3.502 1.214 787 1.001 2.030 2.639 1.766<br />

2012 4.189 3.756 1.303 846 1.076 2.177 2.831 1.923<br />

2013 4.466 4.009 1.390 902 1.147 2.323 3.021 2.064<br />

2014 4.743 4.257 1.476 957 1.218 2.468 3.209 2.202<br />

2015 5.009 4.499 1.558 1.010 1.285 2.608 3.391 2.339<br />

2016 5.275 4.731 1.639 1.062 1.352 2.743 3.565 2.470<br />

2017 5.538 4.952 1.719 1.113 1.418 2.872 3.729 2.597<br />

2018 5.798 5.157 1.795 1.164 1.484 2.992 3.881 2.720<br />

2019 6.067 5.347 1.873 1.216 1.554 3.103 4.018 2.835<br />

Hammadde ihtiyacnn belirlenmesinde kendi yemini yapan hayvanclk işletmeler de<br />

dikkate alnmştr.<br />

2010 yl msr üretimi ihtiyac karşlamamştr.<br />

Ortaya çkan açk, 2011 yaz sezonunda önemli miktarda buğday kullanlarak<br />

giderilecektir.<br />

2011 yl üretiminin 2010 ylna göre daha düşük olacağ değişik kaynaklardan<br />

tarafndan bildirilmektedir.<br />

Ekim alanlarnn pamuğa kaydğ, tohumluk satclarnn aktardğ bilgilerdendir.<br />

USDA ya göre 2011 yl msr üretimi 3,2 milyon ton olarak gerçekleşecektir.<br />

Yem üretim artşna bağl olarak msr talebi artarken, msr üretiminin düşmesi;<br />

önümüzdeki yl içerisinde sektörde büyük skntlar yaşanmasna neden olacak.<br />

Bu skntnn yaşanmamas için msr ithalat yaplmas zorunluluk.<br />

“Biyogüvenlik Kanunu” nedeniyle bugün için msr ithalat mümkün değil.<br />

Biyogüvenlik Kurulu’nun msr ile ilgili başvurular en ksa zamanda değerlendirmesi<br />

ve msr ithalatnn önünü açmas şart.<br />

Bu konuda isteğimiz sadece AB ye uyum.<br />

Msr ithalat yaplamadğ takdirde sektör ihtiyac olan karma yemi üretebilmek için<br />

Buğdaya yönelmek zorunda kalacak.<br />

24


TUIK rakamlarna göre 2009/10 döneminde 2,95 milyon ton buğday ithalat<br />

gerçekleşti.<br />

Yetersiz buğdaymzn yem sanayi tarafndan da kullanlmasnn ortaya çkaracağ<br />

sorunlar aşikar.<br />

Önerimiz, halkmzn ekmeği ile oynamak yerine msr ithalatnn önünün açlmas ve<br />

gümrük vergilerinin sfrlanmas.<br />

Bu yaplamadğ takdirde yaşanacak karmaşa çok büyük olacak.<br />

Kepek-razmol ithalatndaki engeller karma yem sektörünü olumsuz etkiliyor.<br />

Bu durum, dolayl olarak piliç eti sektörünü de olumsuz etkiliyor.<br />

Neredeyse buğday fiyatna ulaşan kepek-razmol fiyatlar, doğal olarak karma yem<br />

sanayicilerini alternatif hammadde aramaya yönlendiriyor.<br />

Kanatl sektörünün kullanacağ hammaddeler, büyük-küçükbaş yemlerinde de<br />

kullanlyor.<br />

Ksr döngü sürüp gidiyor.<br />

Değirmencilik kalntlar ithalat ile ilgili yasaklarn kalkmas, gümrük vergileri nin<br />

sfrlanmas zorunluluk.<br />

Türkiye karma yem sektörü hammadde ithalat (ton)<br />

Yllar 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010<br />

Msr 18.349 1.102.147 1.133.464 464.479 434.520<br />

Arpa 0 52.180 0 11.434 2.500<br />

Balk Unu 49.870 56.225 55.167 52.282 50.771<br />

Kepek 330.069 308.200 363.101 348.725 406.342<br />

Soya Küspesi 268.715 341.540 359.556 351.832 408.369<br />

Ayçiçeği Küspesi 422.950 374.174 203.768 322.288 479.889<br />

Soya Fasulyesi 1.016.906 1.230.903 1.239.065 973.574 1.756.064<br />

Toplam 2.106.859 3.465.369 3.354.121 2.524.614 3.538.455<br />

Kaynak: Türkiye yem sanayicileri birliği<br />

Karma yem sektörü ylda 3,5 milyon ton yem hammaddesi ithal ederek üretimi<br />

sürdürüyor. Büyümeye bağl olarak, karma yem sektöründe her yl 1 milyon tonun<br />

üzerinde hammadde ihtiyac daha oluşacak. Tarm Bakanlğ bu tabloyu gözönünde<br />

bulundurmas. Üretim deseni çalşmalarnda bu hususu dikkate almas. Avrupa Birliği<br />

ile yaplan müzakerelerde, yemlerde hayvansal kökenli hammaddelerin kullanmnn<br />

yasaklanmas kapanş maddelerinden birisi. Böyle bir kararn alnmasnn ülke<br />

ekonomisine ve sektöre vereceği zarar çok büyük.Zaten protein kaynakl hammadde<br />

bulmakta sknt çeken sektör, daha da zorlanacak.<br />

Bu kadar yüksek miktardaki değerli hammaddenin üretimde kullanlamamas<br />

durumunda iki katndan çok fazla soya fasulyesi ve önemli miktarda amino asit ithali<br />

söz konusu. Yasaklamann çevreye vereceği zararlar ise düşünmek bile kötü. Mevcut<br />

durumda, kesimhane atklar çevreye hiç zarar vermeden bertaraf edilmekte.<br />

25


Türkiye tavuk et-kemik unu üretim projeksiyonu (ton)<br />

Yllar<br />

Tavuk <strong>Et</strong>-Kemik Unu<br />

2011 228.000<br />

2012 245.000<br />

2013 261.000<br />

2014 277.000<br />

2015 292.000<br />

2016 308.000<br />

2017 323.000<br />

2018 339.000<br />

2019 355.000<br />

Hammadde Fyatlar<br />

Hammadde fiyatlarndaki artş, piliç eti maliyetlerini de yükseltiyor.<br />

Baz hammaddelerin ithalat fiyatlar (USD)<br />

Yllar<br />

Soya Fasulyesi Ayçiçeği<br />

Küspesi Küspesi<br />

Soya Fasulyesi<br />

2001 223,1 120,2 209,8<br />

2002 208,1 125,9 221,1<br />

2003 234,9 110,1 270,9<br />

2004 312,7 152,8 335,0<br />

2005 262,9 127,2 285,2<br />

2006 237,6 108,3 260,4<br />

2007 287,4 176,3 332,8<br />

2008 440,6 237,4 522,9<br />

2009 433,1 144,3 441,0<br />

2010 413,7 246,1 422,8<br />

2011 467,4 277,2 524,1<br />

Kaynak : KKGM ve Dş Tic. Müs. İth.Gen.Müd. Kaytlar, TUİK<br />

Baz hammaddelerin ithalat fiyatlar (USD)<br />

Kaynak : KKGM ve Dş Tic. Müs. İth.Gen.Müd. Kaytlar, TUİK<br />

26


Hammadde fiyatlarndaki artş, sektörün en önemli darboğazlarndan birisi.<br />

Yalnz Türkiye de değil Dünya da da hammadde fiyatlar artyor. 2008 ylnda bütün<br />

dünyada artan hammadde fiyatlar, 2010 ylnn sonlarndan itibaren tekrar artş<br />

trendinde. Türkiye de % 10 dolaynda enflasyon söz konusu iken, karma yem<br />

hammaddelerindeki fiyat artş % 50 seviyelerine çkt.<br />

Karma yem fiyatlar (TL/Ton)<br />

Kaynak : Türkiye yem sanayicileri birliği<br />

Yem fiyatlar yükseliyor.<br />

Damzlk fiyatlar yükseliyor.<br />

Ambalaj malzemeleri fiyatlar yükseliyor.<br />

Enerji maliyetleri yükseliyor.<br />

İyi üretim tekniklerini uygulayarak sağladğmz başar yeterli olmuyor ve bunlarn<br />

doğal sonucu olarak piliç eti maliyeti de yükseliyor.<br />

Ama piliç eti satş fiyatlar yükselmiyor.<br />

Zira piliç eti satş fiyatlar maliyete bağl değil, zararna satşlar yaplyor.<br />

Sektör üretim planlarn yaparken krmz etin durumunu da her zaman dikkate alr.<br />

Planlar yaplrken krmz et ithalat olacağ hiç varsaylmamştr.<br />

Krmz et ithalat sonucu ülkeye giren her kg krmz et 3 kg beyaz etin pazarndan<br />

çalmştr.<br />

Bugün zararna satş yapmak durumunda kalmamzn önemli nedenlerinden birisidir,<br />

et ithalat.<br />

Sektör bu sknty ihracatla aşma çabasnda.<br />

Piliç <strong>Et</strong>i İhracat<br />

Sektörün can simidi.<br />

Durmas ya da aksamas sektörde ciddi ve onarm imkansz yaralar açar.<br />

İhracatn 2019 ylnda 500 bin tona çkmas ve 1 milyar dolarn üzerinde bir ihracat<br />

rakamna ulaşlmas hedeflenmekte.<br />

Bu hedefe ulaşabilmek için, mevcut pazarlara ilave olarak yeni pazarlar arayş<br />

sürmekte.<br />

27


Son yllarda Dünya da da görülen piliç eti maliyetlerindeki artş, Türkiye’yi dş<br />

pazarlarda daha rekabetçi konuma getirmeye başlad.<br />

Buna rağmen özellikle yeni pazarlara girişte, devletimizin sektörün yannda olmas bir<br />

zorunluluk.<br />

Bugün itibariyle, destek miktar Avrupa Birliğinde 325 Euro, Amerika Birleşik<br />

Devletlerinde 500 USD dir.<br />

Türkiye de bu rakam 2011 ylnda 55 USD ye çkarlmştr.<br />

Biz Avrupa Birliği yada ABD de olduğu kadar büyük destekler talep etmiyoruz.<br />

Sadece yeni girilecek pazarlar için süreli destekler ve mevcut pazarlar için sembolik<br />

desteklere razyz.<br />

Yeni hedef pazarlar olarak sektör, Avrupa Birliği, Suudi Arabistan ve Birleşik Arap<br />

Emirlikleri ile Çin’e önem vermektedir.<br />

Avrupa Birliği maceramz 2003 den beri sürüyor ama her ne hikmetse bir sonuca<br />

ulaştrlamad. Bu konuda Bakanlğn çaba harcadğn söylemek güç.<br />

Suudi Arabistan heyetleri geçtiğimiz günlerde denetlemelerini yaptlar, önümüzdeki<br />

günlerde raporlarn bekliyoruz.<br />

Çin en büyük tavuk ayağ alcs ülke, ancak izin işlemleri tamamlanamadğ için bu<br />

ülkeye ihracat yaplamyor. Dolayl yollardan yaplan ihracat ise masrafl oluyor ve<br />

bunun bedelini sektör ödüyor.<br />

Çin’e ihracat başlatabilme konusunu sürekli gündeme getirmemize rağmen, sorunun<br />

çözümü için herhangi bir çaba yok.<br />

Rusya gerekli izinleri vermiş olmasna rağmen bu ülkeye ihracat yapamadk.<br />

2010 ylnda yaplan ihracat sadece 41 ton. Bu da pazar test için yaplan ihracat.<br />

ABD nin düşük fiyatlar ile rekabet etmemiz mümkün değil.<br />

Devlette Rusya’ya ihracat konusunda hiç destek vermedi.<br />

İhracatta diğer bir sorunumuz da hastalklar.<br />

3-5 köy tavuğunda görülen hastalk vakalar sonucu Türkiye’nin hayvansal ürün<br />

ihracat durabilmekte.<br />

Hastalklardan ötürü ihracatn durmamas için Tarm Bakanlğnn pek çok ülkede<br />

olduğu gibi BÖLGESELLEŞME uygulamasn başlatmasn bekliyoruz.<br />

Nedense gerçekleşmiyor.<br />

Tarm Bakanlğ Koruma Kontrol Genel Müdürlüğü’nün “Hayvan Hastalklar<br />

Nedeniyle Yasak Konulan Ülkeler Ve Yasaklanan Maddeler Listesi” ne bakalm.<br />

Dünyada bölge uygulamasnn çok yaygn olduğunu görürüz.<br />

Bu uygulama sektörün önünü açacak, karamsarlktan kurtularak büyük ihracat<br />

bağlantlarna imza atmasna da ön ayak olacaktr.<br />

İsrail’de bile 6 bölge var.<br />

İhracatç ülkelerin tamamnda benzer uygulamalar bulunmakta.<br />

Türkiye’nin de 81 ili ayr bölge olarak deklare etmesi beklentimiz.<br />

Brezilya, Amerika Birleşik Devletleri ve Avrupa Birliği en önemli ihracatç ülkeler ve<br />

rakiplerimiz.<br />

Brezilya ile dş pazarlarda çok daha fazla karş karşya geliyoruz.<br />

28


Brezilya’nn hedef pazarmz olan ülkelere ihracat (bin ton)<br />

Yllar 2008 2009 2010<br />

Msr 20,1 54,1 124,5<br />

AB 322,5 311,8 281,9<br />

İran 9,6 10,9 45,0<br />

Irak 56,0 142,1 104,5<br />

Kuveyt 163,6 205,0 174,7<br />

Umman 50,4 52,6 45,0<br />

Katar 64,8 58,4 48,8<br />

Rusya 158,9 72,8 144,3<br />

Ürdün 58,5 53,9 51,1<br />

BAE 208,4 212,0 208,3<br />

Yemen 51,4 68,7 64,2<br />

Suudi Arabistan 400,4 496,4 551,0<br />

Kaynak: USDA gain report brazil 4.5.2010 ve 2.3.2011<br />

Yatrm İhtiyac<br />

Hedeflenen üretimlere ulaşabilmek için ciddi yatrmlar gerekli.<br />

Yetiştirici kümesi dşndaki yatrmlar yapmay sektör üstleniyor.<br />

Kümes yatrmlarnda devletin devrede olmas zorunluluk.<br />

Ziraat Bankasnn Tarm Bakanlğ destekli olarak vermeye başladğ krediler bu<br />

konuda yatrmlara ciddi ivme kazandrd.<br />

Son aylarda bu kredilerin verilmesinde yavaşlama olduğu bilgilerinin doğru<br />

olmadğna inanmak istiyoruz.<br />

Kümes yapmnda bürokratik engellerde en üst aşamada.<br />

İzinler çok zaman almakta.<br />

Büyük kapasiteli yatrm söz konusu olduğunda ÇED izinlerini almakta, çok sknt<br />

çekilmekte.<br />

Kümes yapmnda diğer bir sorun da İl’ler arasnda farkllk bulunmas.<br />

İmar mevzuatna göre alann % 40’na kadar inşaat izini verilirken, “Çevre Düzeni<br />

Plan” bulunan 31 ilde bu rakam % 5- % 10 lar da kalmakta.<br />

Yasal Denetlemeler<br />

Sektör, Bakanlğn yaptğ denetlemelerden mutlu.<br />

Bu denetlemelerin yaplmasna sektörün geleceği açsndan büyük önem veriyor.<br />

Sektör, kendisine çok yük getireceğini bilmesine rağmen, denetlemelerin Avrupa<br />

Birliği’ne uyumlu olmasn da desteklemektedir.<br />

Ancak son yllarda Listeria ve Salmonella konusunda uygulanan politikalardan<br />

rahatszdr.<br />

Avrupa Birliğinde çiğ etlerde Listeria kontrolü yaplmamasna rağmen ülkemizde bu<br />

kontrol edilmekte.<br />

Listeria denetlemesinin Avrupa Birliğinde olduğu gibi bizde de en ksa zamanda<br />

kaldrlmasn beklentimiz.<br />

Salmonella konusu da çözümlenmeyi bekliyor.<br />

29


Avrupa Birliği, tespitler yaparak salmonella miktarnn azaltlmas projelerini<br />

geliştirmekte.<br />

Bu işler Avrupa Birliğinde resmi otoriteler tarafndan yaplmakta.<br />

Biz sektör olarak böyle bir çalşma başlattk. zorunda kaldk.<br />

Şu anda salmonella tespit ve azaltma stratejilerini belirlemeye yönelik bir proje<br />

yürütülmekte.<br />

Proje 3 yl sürecek.<br />

Avrupa Birliğinin 15 Kasm 2005 tarihli ve 2073/2005 numaral “Gdalar için<br />

mikrobiyolojik kriterler” regulasyonunda yer alan “Proses hijyen kriterleri” başlğ<br />

altndaki 2.1.5 maddesindeki hüküm bizde de uygulanmaya alnmal.<br />

Bu maddede Broiler ve Hindi karkaslarndaki salmonella ile ilgili düzenlemeler var.<br />

30


" ##H $2+)!9-!A$D.F5-&.$D&'-&,)&'(,/&$?&)&-$@&$`&,($`+A-+!)-+.$<br />

E'+%-)'&8)H"I)J,,$.'-3"+)%&)E$.%0"$)E$""8"$)H1#$%#%.&)<br />

!<br />

9'(56+!H#%%7!<br />

;-$'A#%!i.)4!n#QG($)A#4!9$)30.&$'%4!,H!<br />

!<br />

89&1$$<br />

26! ?'3!:'%!%! ':'5!! &#:! G#+3#:#! 67A63':'3'(!%)'! &#:! )#! G(073#(! )':!>3!=3'(!%!<br />

G#+3#%:#+$!$3#!$3A$3$!0(.'7'!?!='%!7#%$!A#3$:#3#(#!A#%#3!G$(!G'=!!+'3':'=.!(B!!<br />

C%#.$=!#$3$:3#(4!:0)#(%!G(073#(3#($%4!7''!AU(#!5'%3!!'!(3!=4!7#:!)U%DD:!0('%!!-#!<br />

#.!-#($:$!A$G$! U>#33$=3#($!A#3$.$(:#7#!)#-':!#..$=3#($%$!AU+.#(:#=.#)$(B!26!%#)#%3#4!<br />

A#3#5#=.#4! :0)#(%! G(073#($%! )'&'! &!>3!! A#3$:#7#! )#-':! #)#5#$4! )'&'! -#($:3$! -#!<br />

)'&'!7'+!>!03'5'!!G#=3#%.$+$!$?$%)#!03'G$3$($>B!26!='('=.#($+.$=3#(!+')#5#!G(073#(3#(!<br />

$?$%! A#?#(3$! 03:'7!@! '7%!! >':'%)'! @'(#%.! +.0=3'(! N)':!>3!=! +D(DP! $?$%)#! A#?#(3$)$(B!<br />

T0%6?!03'('=4!G6AD%=D!)':!>3!=!+D(D3#($!G#+3#)$$:$>!)$7#.3#(!A#3#5#=!$?$%!&#(!>':'%!<br />

67A6%! 03:'7'G$3#5#$%)#%! )':!>3!=! G#+3#%:#! 67A63':'3'(!%!%! +D(#=3$! AU>)#%!<br />

A#?$($3:#+$!A#(#=:#=.#)$(B!<br />

c:!>3!=!.'-6=3'(!%!)':!>3!=!$(=#.$%$%!G#3$(3#)$$!-D56.!'!(3!!!@(01$3$%#!67A6%!03'('=!<br />

G#+3#%:#+$! U%#:3$! G$(! &6+6+.6(B! *'>3'! -D56.! '!(3!!! D(#:#! =0:@3$='+70%3'(!%'! 703!<br />

'?'(! -#! '7%!! >':'%)'! 76:6(.3':')'! 7D=+#=! G'=!:! :'3$7#.3#($! A#(#=.$($(B! c':!>3!=!<br />

+D(D3#($%!A#%#.$=!@0.#%+$7#33#($!+D(#=3$!G$(!$3#(3#:#!='7)#..$$!$?$%!''!)'=$!&6+6+3'(!<br />

)'&'!U%#:3$!&'3#!A#3:$.$(Y!<br />

! 8D56)6%!7'!(#>#(-3#($%$%!036:'+!!$?$%!7#.#(3$!#%#(I$!'3!:!%!%!.#:$%!#)$3:#+$!<br />

! ;!(!! AUD+! G$($=$:$%$%! D+.#+$%)#%! A#3:#=! $?$%! AD%3D=! @(0.#$%! r! ':$%0! '+$.!<br />

'3!:!%!%!+!%!(3'%)!(!3:'+!!<br />

;!(!!AUD+!#.$%#!+'&$@!03'%!.'-6=3'(4!='+!N@(0.#$%P!)0=6%6%!7'':'+!!$?$%!)'&'!1'>3'!<br />

#%#(I$7#! A#(#=+$%$:! 03)66%)'%4! %$+@#.#%! )'&'! 1'>3'! #%#(I$7#! A#(#=+$%$:!<br />

)67'5'=3'()!(B!26!%#)#%3#!)':!>3!=!+D(D%D%!='+!=$.3#+$%$!=0%.(03!'3.!%)'!.6.:'=!=($.$=!<br />

G$(! U%#:! '(>! #)#(B! c':!>3!=3'('! -#($3#%! )$7#.$%! G#+$%! 706%3664! -D56.!<br />

=0:@0>$+70%6%'! U%#:3$! )#(#5#)#! #.=$! #)#5#=.$(B! \#:! 7#.$.$(:#)#! &#:! )#!<br />

76:6(.3':')'!'!(!!@(0.#$%!G#+3#:#+$!1'>3'!=$307'!-#!E#.3$F!.'-6=3'('!%#)#%!036(B!;!(!!<br />

@(0.#$%! G#+3#:#+$%$%! )':!>3!=3'(! D>#($%)#=$! %#A'.$1! #.=$+$! 03)6=?'! $7$! G$(! #=$3)#!<br />

G#3A#3#%:$! 03:'=3'! G#('G#(! )'&'! 7#%$! -#($3#(4! G6! G#+3#:#%$%! )$$! )':!>3!=3'()'!<br />

:D%1#($.!':$%0!'+$.!+#-$7#+$%$!'(.!('('=!1#(.$3$.#%$%!&'.!(!!+'7!3!(!)#(#5#)#!'>'3:'+!%'!<br />

703! '?'G$3#5#$%$! AU+.#(:#=.#)$(B! X'@!3'%! +0%! )##(3#%)$(:#3#()#4! )'&'! )DD=!<br />

G#+$%+#3! @(0.#$%! +#-$7#3#($%$%! )$$3#()#! 1#(.$3$.#7$! )#+.#=3#(! 7U%)#! 03)66%6! 0(.'7'!<br />

=07:'=.')!(B!!<br />

c':!>3!=3'(!%! G$(! #%#(I$! )#@0+6! 03'('=! AU(#-! 7'@'%! 7'!! )#@03':'7'! N'G)0:$%'3P!<br />

)'&'!'>!#$3$:3$!03)66%6!G#3$(.:#=!U%#:3$)$(B!m(%#=!-#(:#=!A#(#=$(+#!##(!.'-66%!<br />

7#:!.D=#.$:$!+.(#+3$!G$(!)U%#:)#!.#&3$=#7#!A$(:$+#!-#7'!AD%3D=!#%#(I$!'3!:!!76:6(.'!!<br />

D(#.$:$%#! 7#.#(3$! A#3:$70(+'4! ! +U>! =0%6+6! #%#(I$! (#>#(-3#($%#! $&.$7'?! )6763:'=.')!(B!<br />

L#(!#%#(I$!(#>#(-3#($!7#.#(3$!)#$3+#4!G6!)6(6:)'!.'-66%!@#(10(:'%+!!036:+6>!7U%)#!<br />

#.=$3#%#G$3$(B!26!%#)#%3#4!)':!>3!=3'(!!67A6%!#%#(I$!(#>#(-3#($%$!036.6('5'=!-#!)#-':!<br />

#..$(#5#=!#=$3)#!)':!>3!!%!G#+3#%:#+$!U%#:3$)$(B!!<br />

9'(I$%'3!)D>#7)#!:$=(0!G#+$%!7#.#(+$>3$$4!+.(#+3$!)U%#:3#()#4!)':!>3!=3'(!%!-#!#.3$=!<br />

@$3$?3#($%! @#(10(:'%+!%!! U%#:3$! )#(#5#)#! #.=$3#7#G$3$(B! H'3$.#3$! -$.':$%3#(! :$%#('3!<br />

='7%'=3'(!!=633'%!3'('=!7#.#(3$!-$.':$%!-#!$>!:$%#('3!.'=-$7#+$4!)':!>3!=!@#(10(:'%+!%!!<br />

-#!7'-(63'(!%!%!7'':!AD5D%D!0@.$:$>#!#.:#)#!@'&'3!!03:'7'%!G$(!703)6(B!!<br />

! H!


L(=#=3#(! $?$%! '7(!! )$7#.! =633'%!:!! '(.!=! 03)6=?'! 7'7A!%! G$(! 67A63':')!(B! L%! +0%!<br />

)##(3#%)$(:#3#(4!)DD=!G#+$%!706%36=36!#(=#=!)$7#.3#($%$%!)'&'!7D=+#=!)U33D3D=!-#!<br />

=636?='! ('%)!:'%!%!! )#+.#=3#)$$%$! G#3$(.:#=.#)$(B! *#(.$3$.#4! .D:! )6(6:3'()'4! $3#($!<br />

7'3'()'=$!76:6(.3':'!)U%#:$%)#!#%!?0=!$3#(3#:#!='7)#.:$!03:'+!%'!(':#%4!+U>!<br />

=0%6+6!7'('(3'(!#(=#=3#(#!76:6(.'!)U%#:$%$%!G'3'%A!5!%)'!'7(!!)$7#.3#(!67A63'%)!!!<br />

>':'%!G#3$(A$%)$(B!!<br />

!<br />

:;'1.+3!=! D>#($%)#=$! #.=$+$%$%! AU>! U%D%#!<br />

'3!%:'+!!A#(#=:#=.#)$(B!<br />

! HC


90)#(%!G(073#(3#(!5'%3!!'!(3!=4!*j"!-#!@0(+$70%!-#($:$!)$=='.#!'3!%'('=!+#3#=+$70%'!<br />

.'G$!.6.63:'=.')!(B!"0++!][f4!GD7D:#)#!&#(!7!3!dV!A(':'%3'!)#$$@!<br />

)#$:#)$$%$! G#3$(3#:#=! $?$%! D?! 1'(=3!! )#%A#3$! @(0.#$%! )D>#7$4! $=$! 1'(=3!! )U%#:)#!<br />

7#)$($3:$.$(B!c#%A#3$!@(0.#$%!.#($:$4!&':!@(0.#$%!7#($%#!.':!$)#'3!':$%0!'+$.!@(01$3$!<br />

'%3':!%'!A#3$(B!K#+.!#)$3#%!)#%A#3$!@(0.#$%$%!D?!)D>#7$4!"0++!][f!$?$%!.'-+$7#!#)$3#%$%!<br />

t! f[4! t! V[[! -#! t! Vd[3!!GD7D:#=.#)$(4!)'&'!-#($:3$)$(!-#!'>!7'!$?#(#%!$%5#!<br />

G$(! -D56.! =$.3#+$%#! +'&$@.$(B! 26! U>#33$=3#(! G(073#(! G'=!! '?!+!%)'%! @0>$.$1! 03+'! )'! G6!<br />

%$.#3$=3#($%!=0%6!)':!>3!=!+D(D!03)66%)'!7#%$)#%!)##(3#%)$($3:#+$!A#(#=:#=.#)$(B!<br />

XD=+#=! )D>#7)#! @(0.#$%! $3#! G#+3#:#! #.! 1'>3'3!!%'! %#)#%! 036(=#%! #=+$=! #%#(I$3$! G$(!<br />

G#+3#:#!)DD=!-D56.!7'!(#>#(-$%#!703!'?'5'=.!(B!26!)6(6:!U>#33$=3#!7D=+#=!-#($:3$!<br />

!(=3'(!%! G#+3#%:#+$%)#! U%#:! '(>! #.:#=.#)$(B! L=+.('! ='+4! )'&'! 1'>3'! #%#(I$! $&.$7'5!!<br />

)#:#=.$(B! 26! )'! 7'! .6.:'7'! >'.#%! 1'>3'! 7'.=!%! 03:'7'%! .'-66%! #%#(I$! $&.$7'5!%!%!<br />

)'&'! )'! 1'>3'! '(.:'+!! '%3':!%'! A#3$(B! 90)#(%! )':!>3!=! G(073#(3#(! $?$%! $)#'3! )$7#.4!<br />

.'-66%! #%#(I$! $&.$7'5!%!! ='(!3'7'5'=! :$=.'()'! '%5'=! '!(!! ':$%0! '+$.! $?#(:#7#5#=!<br />

#=$3)#!03:'3!)!(B!!<br />

90)#(%! )':!>3!=3'(!%! A#%#.$$%$%! )$%':$=! 03)66! '?!=.!(4! G6! %#)#%3#! A#?:$.#!<br />

G''(!3!!03'%!G$(!)$7#.!A#3#5#=.#!)#!G''(!3!!03'5'=!)$7#!G$(!=6('3!03:')!!!AU>!U%D%#!<br />

'3!%:'3!)!(B!<br />

!<br />

2+)!9-!A$D.F5-&.$D&'-&,)&'($(_(,$^.+1(A$;(.$5+A-+!)$<br />

2#+3#%:#!6>:'%3'(!%'!+!=!+!=4!G$(!)':!>3!=!G(073#(!)$7#.$%)#!':$%0!'+$.!7'!)'!#%#(I$!<br />

706%366%6%!%#!=')'(!03:'+!!A#(#=.$$!+0(636(B!K'-6=3'(!%!0('%3'()'%!'%3':')!!%!!<br />

AU>!U%D%)#! G636%)6(:'=! U%#:3$)$(h! 0%3'(!%4! G'=!:4! GD7D:#! -#! -#($:! )'&$3! 03:'=!<br />

D>#(#! &#(! G#+$%! $?$%! G#3$(3$! $&.$7'?3'(!! -'()!(B! c':!>3!=3'(! =!+!.3!! :$=.'()'! 7#:3#!<br />

G#+3#%$(3#(4! G6! %#)#%3#! ('+70%6%! G#+$%! U>#33$=3#($4! AD%3D=! 7#:! '3!:!! AU>! U%D%)#!<br />

G636%)6(63'('=!+#?$3:#3$)$(4!U(%#$%4!#%!1'>3'!Ve[!A(':!7#:3#!G#+3#%#%!G$(!)':!>3!=!<br />

.'-6=4!VZ^!A(':!7#:!7$7#%#!AU(#!)'&'!7D=+#=!G#+$%!706%366%'!$&.$7'?!)67'(B!264!<br />

.'-6=3'(!%! AD%3D=! G#+$%! $&.$7'5!%!%! ='(!3'%:'+!%'! $3$=$%! #%! )0(6! 7'=3'!:! 036@4!<br />

)':!>3!=! $(=#.3#($! .'('1!%)'%! A$)#(#=! D>#($%)#! )'&'! ?0=! )6(63'%! G$(! 7'=3'!:)!(!<br />

N;-$'A#%!d[[ZPB!<br />

`(#.$:$%! &#(! '':'+!%)'4! ?#-(#+#3! =0633'('! AU(#! .'-66%! G#+$%! A#(#=+$%$:3#($%$!<br />

='(!3'7'5'=! G$(! 7#:$%! .'+'(3'%:'+!! -#! )'&'! +0%('! +U>! =0%6+6! 7#:3#()#! #%! ='3$.#3$!<br />

='.=!!:'))#3#($%!=633'%!3:'+!!G#+$%!6>:'%3'(!%!%!+0(6:36366)6(B!X#:!+')#5#4!G#+$%!<br />

=0:@0>$+70%6! '?!+!%)'%! )#$3! '7%!! >':'%)'! 1$>$=+#3! ='('=.#($+.$=3#(! '?!+!%)'%! )'!<br />

! HH


='('(3!! 03:'3!)!(B! X#:! .#=+.D(D! &#:! 7#:! .D=#.$:$%$! &#:! )#! G$.$($3:#! +D(#+$%$!<br />

#.=$3#7#5#=.$(B!<br />

c':!>3!=3'(!=!+!.3!!7#:3#%)$=3#($%)#%4!+D(#=3$!)#$$=3$=3#(!!-D56.!'!(3!!4!D%$10(:$.#!<br />

-#!76:6(.'!-#($:$%)#!@(0G3#:3#(#!703!'?'5'!%)'%4!)':!>3!=!G$($:$!7U%#.$5$3#($!+'G$.!<br />

-#!)D>AD%!='3$.#)#!G$(!7#:#!$&.$7'?!)67:'=.')!(3'(B!!<br />

!<br />

:)(,F$:'(1$>&.&A'(,()-&.($<br />

K$5'($! )':!>3!=! 7#:3#($! &'3#%4! '>':$! ':$%0! '+$.! )D>#73#($%$%! A#(#=#%)#%! ?0=! )'&'!<br />

7D=+#=! 03:'+!%'! %#)#%! 03'%! :$%$:6:! &':! @(0.#$%! +#-$7#3#($! $3#! 10(:D3#!<br />

#)$3:#=.#)$(B!;!(!!':$%0!'+$.!)D>#73#($!'!(!!='+!G$($=$:$%$!.#-$=!#)#G$3$(3#(4!i0@#>!<br />

-#!i##+0%!NVWW^P!'!(!!&':!@(0.#$%$%!1#(.$3$.#!D>#($%)#=$!#.=$+$%$!AU+.#(:$3#(!-#!)'&'!<br />

7'=!%!G$(!>':'%)'!j00%!-#!'(=')'3'(!!Nd[[eP!)':!>3!=3'(!%!1#(.$3$.#3#($%#!#.=$!#)#%!<br />

G$(#7+#3!':$%0!'+$.3#($!.'%!:3':!3'()!(B!<br />

c':!>3!!%!AD%3D=!+$%)$($3#G$3$(!':$%0!'+$.!A#(#=+$%$:$%$!'%3':'=!N.'G30!dP!-#!)$#(!<br />

':$%0! '+$.3#($%! 1'>3'3!!%!! :$%$:$>#! #)#(#=!7#:3#($! G6!)D>#73#($! +'3'7'5'=! #=$3)#!<br />

10(:D3#!#.:#7#!?'3!:'=!U%#:3$)$(B!m>#33$=3#4!'!(!!':$%0!'+$.$%!.'-6=3'(!D>#($%)#!#=!<br />

G$(! :#.'G03$=! 7D=! 036.6('G$3#5#=! -#! +!5'=! +.(#+$%$! $))#.3#%)$(#G$3#5#$! $?$%! 7'>!<br />

'73'(!! G076%5'! ':$%0! '+$.! A#(#=+$%$:3#($%$! ='(!3':'=! '%5'=! '!(!7'! ='?:':'=!!<br />

U%#:3$)$(B!<br />

$<br />

2+)!9-!A$D&'-&,)&'(,(,$B1-(A$V(-(_-&.$b9&.(,&$B1A('($$<br />

X6:6(.'! )U%#:$! G076%5'! 7'@!3'%! 7'%3!4! '!(!! -#! 7#.#(+$>! G#+3#:#4! )':!>3!=3'(!%!<br />

-#($:$!-#!5$-5$-!='3$.#+$!D>#($%#!?0=!U%#:3$!)#(#5#)#!#.=$!7'@'G$3$(B!26!)'4!G#+3#:#!<br />

6>:'%3'(!%!%!)0(6!G#+$%!706%36=36!)$7#.!+'3':'3'(!%!%!-#!+D(D!7U%#.$5$3#($%$%!$+#!<br />

76:6(.'! )U%#:$%)#! 67A6%! 7#:! .'&+$+$! 7'@'G$3:#3#($%$%! %#! =')'(! U%#:3$! 03)66%6!<br />

0(.'7'! =07:'=.')!(B! c':!>3!=3'()'! $3'-#! :$=(0bG#+$%3#($%! )U3! ='3$.#+$%#! 7'('(3!!<br />

03)66! AU+.#($3:$.$(! NH$))! -#! '(=')'3'(!! VWWdPB! 8$.':$%3#(! -#! $>! #3#:#%.3#(! &#:!<br />

:#.'G03$=!+D(#?3#()#!7#(!'3:'3'(!4!&#:!)#!#:G($70!A#3$$:$%$%!'7(!3:'>!G$(!@'(?'+!!<br />

03:'3'(!!%#)#%$!$3#4!+U>!=0%6+6!.$5'($!('+70%3'()'!G#+$%3#($%!+6Gb0@.$:'3!)D>#73#($%$%!<br />

7'('.'5'!! +0%656%! &#:! #G#-#7%! &#:! )#! 7'-(6%6%! @#(10(:'%+!! D>#($%)#! 036:+6>!<br />

03'5'!!G$3$%:#=.#)$(B!X'-(6!D>#($%#!)':!>3!=!G#+3#:#%$%!#.=$+$%$%!G#3$(3#%:#+$!>0(!<br />

03:'=3'! G#('G#(4! )DD=! +D(D! D%$10(:$.#+$! -#7'! =D:#+.#! ?#$.3$! 10(:3'()'=$! +.(#+!<br />

-'(3!!%)'4!G#+3#:#%$%!7'-(6!='3$.#+$!-#!@#(10(:'%+!!D>#($%)#=$!#.=$+$!U%#:3$!)D>#7)#!<br />

03'G$3$(B!<br />

8$.':$%3#(!-#!$>!#3#:#%.3#(4!)':!>3!=!7#:!:'3$7#.$%$%!7'=3'!=!t!g


K'G30!dB!L%!7D=+#=!D(#.$:!)D>#7$%)#4!)':!>3!=!G(073#(!.'-6=3'(!%!+$%)$($3#G$3$(!':$%0!<br />

'+$.!A#(#=+$%$:3#($!!<br />

;:$%0!;+$.! ;(='%+'+! ;(='%+'+! *$+&#(! n"j! ;-$'A#%!<br />

`%$-#(+$.#+$! `%$-#(+$.#+$! NVWWfP! NVWWgP! Nd[[ZP!<br />

Nd[[eP! Nd[[gP!<br />

! :A_.'-6=_AD%!<br />

\':!J(0.#$%! b! VWff[! b! VW^[[! !<br />

;(A$%$%#! V[[d! V[^W! f[]! VVV[! V[d[!<br />

O+03#65$%#! fdf! fgg! ^Wf! f^[! Ze^!<br />

i7+$%#! f^^! fff! fW]! Ze^! W^[!<br />

9#.&$0%$%#! g^^! gdZ! ]Zd! g^[! ge[!<br />

j7+.$%#! g^Z! b! b! f^[!N9rjP! f^[!N9rjP!<br />

J&#%73'3'%$%#! b! eg]! b! eV[! !<br />

K&(#0%$%#! ed[! b! ^^f! Zd[! Z[[!<br />

K(7@.0@&'%! dgg! b! Vfe! VW[! dd[!<br />

8'3$%#! ZW[! b! eW]! Z^[! fV[!<br />

!<br />

0(1+)(,-&.$@&$9$c(,&.+--&.$<br />

$))#.3$! -$.':$%! #=+$=3$$4! ?0=! ?#$.3$! )#10(:$.#3#(#! %#)#%! 03:'+!%'! -#! =636?='!<br />

-#($:$%$! #.=$3#:#+$%#! (':#%4! @('.$=.#! 7#.#(+$>! -$.':$%! -#($3:#+$! @#=! AU(D3:#>B!<br />

;%5'=4! :$=.'(! '>3!!4! ='7%'!%! ='3$.#+$4! G636%'G$3$(3$$! -#! #3-#($3$3$$! %#)#%$73#! -#!<br />

+D(D!$?$!&$7#('($!%#)#%$73#!&#+'@3'%'%)'%!!)'&'!'>!.D=#.#%!)':!>3!=3'('!G'3!!03'('=!!<br />

0(.'7'! ?!='%! :'(I$%'3! #=+$=3$=3#($! AU(:#=! ?0=.'! '3!!3:')!=! G$(! )6(6:! )#$3)$(B!<br />

X'-(63'(!=3'+$=!#=+$=3$=!+#%)(0:3'(!%!!AU+.#(:#>4!'%5'=!G6%3'(!=#%)$!@0.'%+$7#33#($%#!<br />

67A6%!@#(10(:'%+!!)'!AU+.#(#:#>3#(B!;-$'A#%#7$!'(.!(!3:!!7#:3#(3#!G#+3#%#%!5$-5$-3#($%!<br />

VV! AD%3D=! 7'.'=$! A#3$:#3#($%$%4! ! gdbg^! AD%3D=! )':!>3!=! +D(D3#()#%! #3)#! #)$3#%!<br />

5$-5$-3#(#! AU(#! )'&'! D+.D%! 03)66%6! -#! )DD=! :0(.'3$.#7#! ! +'&$@! 03)6=3'(!%!!<br />

AU+.#(:$.$(B! C#%?! '%'! )':!>3!=3'()'%! #3)#! #)$3#%! -#! 7D=+#=! )D>#7)#! -$.':$%3#!<br />

G#+3#%#%!5$-5$-3#($%!7'':!AD?3#($%$%!'(.!!!7'@!3'%!+'&'!?'3!:'3'(!%)'!AU(D3:D.D(B!<br />

H'3$.#3$! ='7%'=3'()'%! -$.':$%! -#! G$7030I$=! 7'('7!3!3!!! 7D=+#=! ='7%'=3'()'%! )'!<br />

7#.#(3$!)D>#7)#!$>!:$%#('3!+'3'%:'+!!!A#%?!@$3$?3#()#!0@.$:'3!$+=#3#.!A#3$$:$%$%!-#!<br />

+'3!=3!!G$(!G'!!=3!=!+$+.#:$!A#3$:#+$!$?$%!656>!G$(!703)6(B!<br />

!<br />

a+.A-!$B.A&A$2(5&1-&.($<br />

c'&'!U%5#!)#!'?!=3'%)!!!A$G$4!:0)#(%!)':!>3!=!G(073#(3#(!1'>3'!='+!G$($=$:$%#!)'&'!<br />

7'.=!%!036@!G6!)6(6:!U>#33$=3#!#(=#=!G(073#(3#(!$?$%!A#?#(3$)$(B!L(=#=!-D56.!'!(3!!!-#!<br />

=0%)$+70%! =0%.(03D! D(#:#! @#(10(:'%+!%!! #%! D+.! )D>#7#! ?!='(:'=! $?$%! &'7'.$! U%#:!<br />

.'!(B! ;!(!! 7'@!3!! #(=#=3#(! )'&'! '>! '=.$1! 036@! GD7D=! $&.$:'33#! G''(!3!! ?$1.3#:#!<br />

0('%3'(!!)DD=.D(B!<br />

cDD=! G#+$%! 706%36=36! #(=#=! )$7#.3#($! >':'%! >':'%! #(=#=! =0%)$+70%6%6! =0%.(03!<br />

#.:#=! -#! ?$1.3#:#! '=.$-$.#+$%$! )#+.#=3#:#=! $?$%! =633'%!3!(B! 2'>!! '('.!(:'3'(4!<br />

G#+3#:#%$%! #(=#=! 1#(.$3$.#+$%#! )0(6)'%! #.=$+$! 03'G$3#5#$%$! U%#! +D(:#=.#)$(B! ;7(!!<br />

#(=#=!7#:3#($!A#%#33$=3#!)DD=!@(0.#$%4!#%#(I$!-#!:$%#('3!$?#(:#=3#!G#('G#(4!!G6%3'(!%!<br />

G'>!3'(!!4!1#(.$3$.#7#!#.=$+$!03)66!G$3$%#%!L!-$.':$%$!-#!T#3#%76:!A$G$!:$=(0bG#+$%3#($!<br />

7D=+#=!)D>#7)#!$?#(:#=.#)$(3#(B!!<br />

T0%! )##(3#%)$(:#3#(4! #(=#=3#(! $?$%! '7(!! ('+70%! 7'@!3:'+!%!%! 1'7)'3'(!%!%! A#?!<br />

76:6(.'!)U%#:$%)#!)'&'!G#33$!03)66%6!0(.'7'!=07:'=.')!(3'(B!26!7U%)#!7'@!3'%!G$(!<br />

?'3!:'! =636?='! ('%)!:'%!%)'! t! ]


J#($-$.#33$%#! i'7#(! K#5&%$S6#! NOJ8iP! =633'%!3'('=! G3'+.0)#(:#! A$($3#(#=! +@#(:!<br />

.'('1!%)'%!7'@!3'%!G036=3'(!%!+'7!3:'+!!$3#!0(.'7'!=0%'%!+@#(:!7'':'!AD5D%)#!)#!<br />

$7$3#:#!03)66%6!AU+.#(:$.$(!`(#.$:!)U%#:$!G076%5'!76:6(.'!U(%#=3#($!.0@3'%:!4!<br />

@#($-$..#3$%#! :#:G('%'! A#?#%! +@#(:3#($%! +'7!+!! '7(!! #(=#=! 7#:$! $3#! G#+3#%#%!<br />

#(=#=3#()#! )'&'! 7D=+#=! G636%:6.6(B! 26! U>#33$=3#! $3#($! 7'3'()'=$! N7'3!!<br />

)':!>3!=3'()'P!76:6(.'!)U%#:$%)#!+0%('!)'&'!)'!G#3$(A$%)$(B!<br />

L(=#=3#(! $?$%! '7(!! )$7#.! =633'%!:!!+!('+!%)'! +U>! =0%6+6! )$7#.$%! >'7!1! 7#:! 7U%#.$:$!<br />

%#)#%$73#!G#=3#%#%!1'7)'7!!+'3'7':'7'5'!!!&6+6+6!AU>!U%D%)#!G636%)6(63:'3!)!(B!<br />

L(=#=3#(! $?$%! '7(!! 7#:)#%! ! 7'('(! +'3'%'G$3:#+$! $?$%4! #(=#=3#($%4! )$$3#($%! -#7'!<br />

)$$3#($%!#(=#=3#($%!G#+3#%:#!&'.3'(!%)'%!'7(!!.6.63:'+!!A#(#=:#=.#)$(B!L(=#=!7#:$%#!<br />

$3$=$%!)$#(!=0%63'(!$+#4!#(=#=!-#!)$$!7#:3#($%$%!='(!.!(!3:'!03'+!3!!!-#!$&.$7'5!%!'>!<br />

03:'+!! %#)#%$! $3#! #(=#=! 7#:3#($%$%! ?$1.3$=.#! 6>6%! +D(#! ='3:'+!! $3#! $3A$3$! =0%63'()!(B!<br />

L(=#=! 7#:3#($! )0(6! =633'%!3)!!%)'! -D56.! '!(3!!4! -D56.! =0%)$+70%6! -#! 1#(.$3$.#!<br />

D>#($%)#!036:36!#.=$!7'('.'5'=.!(B!<br />

!<br />

"F,7_$$<br />

T#3#=+$70%! 67A63':'3'(!! G(073#(! @#(10(:'%+!%)'! &'.!(!! +'7!3!(! )#(#5#)#! $3#(3#:#!<br />

='7)#)$3:#+$%#! 703! '?:!! 036@4! +U>! =0%6+6! )#$$=3$=3#($%! )':!>3!=! +D(D! G#+$%!<br />

$&.$7'?3'(!%'! %'+!3! #.=$! #..$$%$%! '%3'!3:'+!! )':!>3!=! +D(D! @#(10(:'%+!%!%! #%! D+.!<br />

)D>#7#!?!='(!3:'+!!$?$%!'%'&.'(!U%#:#!+'&$@.$(B!CD%D:D>!)':!>3!=3'(!%!%!)'&'!1'>3'!<br />

='+!=$.3#+$!036.6(:'!-#!)'&'!'>!7'!.6.:'!#$3$:$!)$=='.#!'3!%)!!%)'4!1'>3'!':$%0!<br />

'+$.! -#(:#:#=! -#! -D56.! 7'! (#>#(-3#($%$! 036.6(:'=! $?$%! 7#.#(3$! )D>#7)#! #%#(I$!<br />

+'3':'=!U%#:3$!&'3#!A#3:$.$(B!!<br />

\#(&'%A$! G$(! G#+$%$! '!(!! -#(:#:#=! ='7)!73'! G(073#(! )':!>3!=3'(!%! )D>#%3$! G#+$%!<br />

$&.$7'?3'(!%'! ='(!3!=! -#(#5#=! 7#:3#($%! .'+'(3'%:'+!! G#+3#:#! 6>:'%3'(!%!%!<br />

+0(6:36366! '3.!%)')!(B! ,7A6%! -#! +D(#=3$! '7%!! ='3$.#)#! 7#:! =633'%!:!! D(#.$:!<br />

:D)D(D%#! -D56.! '!(3!!! -#! @#(10(:'%+! $3#! $3A$3$! #.=$3#($! .'&:$%! #)#G$3:#! $:='%!!<br />

+'3'(B!<br />

8$.':$%!-#!$>!:$%#('33#(!+')#5#!)':!>3!=!@#(10(:'%+!!'?!+!%)'%!)#$34!'7%!!>':'%)'!<br />

7'-(6%6%!+'3!!!-#!7'':'!AD5D!'?!+!%)'%!)'!U%#:3$)$(B!9'(I$%'3!-$.':$%!#=+$=3$$4!<br />

U>#33$=3#! +.(#+! )U%#:$! G076%5'! )':!>3!=3'(! -#! G(073#(! @#(10(:'%+!! D>#($%)#! U%#:3$!<br />

G$(!#.=$!7'('.'G$3$(B!<br />

L(=#=3#(! $?$%! '7(!! )$7#.3#(4! )0(6! =633'%!3)!=3'(!%)'4! -D56.! '!(3!!! -#! =0%)$+70%!<br />

7U%#.$:$%#!7'()!:5!!036(3'(B!T0%!)##(3#%)$(:#3#(4!'7(!!#(=#=!7#:3#($%$%!A#?!)U%#:!<br />

=636?='! ('%)!:'%!! -#! )U33D3DD! )#+.#=3#)$$%$! AU+.#(:#=.#)$(B! k$1.3$=.#=$! 7#:! -#!<br />

7#:3#:#! +$+.#:3#($%$%! 7U%#.$:$4! #(=#=3#(! $?$%! '7(!! )$7#.$%! 7'('(3'(!%!! &'7'.'!<br />

A#?$($3:#=!'?!+!%)'%!=($.$=!G$(!=0%6)6(B!<br />

!<br />

%+5,+A-+.$<br />

;-$'A#%!Nd[[ZP!2(0$3#(!n6.($#%.!T@#5$1$5'.$0%+!w6%#!d[[Z!<br />

;-$'A#%!Nd[[ZP!J'(#%.!T.05=!n6.($#%.!T@#5$1$5'.$0%+!w6%#!d[[Z!<br />

j00%4! jBnB4! c#! 2##(4! 9B4! 9'%'%A$4! 9B4! i64! wB4! "#7#+4! 9B4! 2(':Q#33! HB! '%)! T6%4! wB9B! Nd[[eP! 2(0$3#(!<br />

2(##)#(! n6.($.$0%Y! K&#! ;:$%0! ;5$)! '%)! j(6)#! J(0.#$%! "#S6$(#:#%.+! 01! 2(0$3#(! 2(##)#(! &#%+! 10(!<br />

:'$%.#%'%5#4!J(0)65.$0%!'%)!*#(.$3$.7B!J(05##)$%A+!01!;(='%+'+!n6.($.$0%!j0%1#(#%5#4!"0A#(+!;(='%+'+B!<br />

*$+&#(4!jB!NVWWfP!;:$%0!;5$)!(#S6$(#:#%.+!01!G(0$3#(!G(##)#(+B!J063.(7!T5$#%5#!ZZYVdgbV]]!<br />

*3#:$%A4!LBjB4!*$+&#(4!jB!'%)!95;)':B!wB!Nd[[ZP!A#%#.$5!@(0A(#++!$%!G(0$3#(!.('$.+!p!$:@3$5'.$0%+!10(!G0)7!<br />

50:@0+$.$0%B!J(05##)$%A+!01!.&#!2($.$+&!T05$#.7!01!;%$:'3!T5$#%5#B!<br />

H$))! 9BKB4! ;%.&0%74! nB2B! '%)! i##B! TB"B! NVWWdP! J(0A#%7! @#(10(:'%5#! Q&#%! )':+! '%)! 5&$5=+! '(#! 1#)!<br />

+6@@3#:#%.'3!>$%5B!@.10#$()/-%"&-"!ZVYVd[VbVd[e!<br />

i0@#>4! CB! '%)! i##+0%B! TB! NVWW^P! "#+@0%+#! 01! G(0$3#(! G(##)#(+! .0! 30Qb@(0.#$%! )$#.+B! VB! ;)63.! G(##)#(!<br />

@#(10(:'%5#B!@.10#$()/-%"&-"!ZgYef^beWg!<br />

n'.$0%'3!"#+#'(5&!j06%5$3!NVWWgP!n6.($#%.!"#S6$(#:#%.+!01!J063.(7B!W .& !(#-B!#)B!n'.$0%'3!;5')#:7!J(#++4!<br />

a'+&$%A.0%4!cjB!<br />

! HT


!<br />

" ##J $D+9!$%7-7_A+$%F7--+.!,!,$D.F5-&.$V&.KF.)+,'!$b9&.(,&$B1A(-&.($<br />

KLL"-#+).L)M'#-3"$()A'&'2"7"&#).&)E$.%0"$)@"$L.$7'&-"!<br />

!<br />

R='%!L3$G03 ' 4!T#()'(!m>3D G 4!9#+6.!KD(=0A36 '!<br />

' J(01Bc(B!;%='('!`%$-#(+$.#+$!l$(''.!*'=D3.#+$!l00.#=%$!2U3D:D4!c!='@!b;%='('!<br />

G ;(BCU(B4!;%='('!`%$-#(+$.#+$!l$(''.!*'=D3.#+$!l00.#=%$!2U3D:D4!c!='@!b;%='('!<br />

89&1$<br />

H636?='&'%#3#()#! D>#($%)#! )6(63'%! #%! U%#:3$! =($.#(! =636?='! ('%)!:'%!)!(B! X'@!3'%!<br />

+0%!?'3!:'3'(!=636?='!U%5#+$!-#!+!('+!%)'!67A63'%'%!$3#:3#($%!G(0$3#(!@#(10(:'%+!!<br />

D>#($%#! U%#:3$! #.=$3#($! 03)66%6! AU+.#(:#=.#)$(B! 26%3'(! $?$%)#! )#@03':'! +D(#+$4!<br />

U>#33$=3#!=636?='%!%!V^B!AD%D%)#%!+0%('=$!#:G($70!+!5'=3!!!-#!5$-5$-!?!=!:!>':'%!!<br />

A$G$!G'>!!=636?='!=0633'(!!+'7!3'G$3$(B!!<br />

:,+*1+.$A&-()&-&.3!2(0$3#(4!=636?='4!)#@0!+D(#+$4!+!5'=3!=4!?!=!:!>':'%!!<br />

$<br />

:;'1.+(.($<br />

L.3$=! @$3$?! 7#.$.$($5$3$$%)#! -#($:$! 036:+6>! 7U%)#! #.=$3#7#G$3#5#=! 1'=.U(3#($%!<br />

G#3$(3#%:#+$! -#! G6%3'(!%! )D>#3.$3:#+$! 7'%!%)'! @#(10(:'%+!%! '(.!(!3:'+!%'! 7U%#3$=!<br />

?'3!:'3'(! )'! 706%! 03'('=! )#-':! #.:#=.#)$(B! 26! ?'3!:'3'(!%! ?06! D(#.$:!<br />

)U%#:$%)#=$! =0633'(! $3#! $3A$3$)$(B! 26%6%! 7'%!%)'4! =636?='! +!('+!%)'! 67A63'%'%!<br />

$3#:3#($%!G(0$3#(!@#(10(:'%+!!D>#($%#!#.=$3#($!03)66!)'!G$3$%:#=.#)$(B!26!:'='3#!)#!<br />

)#@03':'! +D(#+$4! =636?='! +!5'=3!!! -#! ?!=!:! >':'%!%!%! G(0$3#(! @#(10(:'%+!! D>#($%#!<br />

#.=$3#($%$%!G#3$(3#%:#+$%#!7U%#3$=!'('.!(:'!+0%6?3'(!!+!('+!73'!U>#.3#%:$.$(B!<br />

!<br />

"#$%&'('!)*+#,-!<br />

H636?='3!=! 76:6(.'3'()'! ?!=!! AD5D! D>#($%#! #.=$3$! 03'%! U%#:3$! 1'=.U(3#()#%! G$($+$!<br />

)#@03':'! +D(#+$)$(B! X6:6(.'3'(!%! )#@03'%:'+!! ='?!%!3:'>! G$(! 67A63':')!(B!<br />

9'=+$:6:!?!=!!AD5D!$?$%!0@.$:6:!)#@03':'!+D(#+$%$%!G#3$(3#%:#+$%)#!76:6(.'3'(!%!<br />

#3)#!#)$3)$$!'%'?!7'!!-#!)#@03':'!=0633'(!!:6.3'='!AU>!U%D%#!'3!%:'3!)!(B!26%6%3'!<br />

G$(3$=.#!7'@!3'%!G$(?0=!?'3!:')'!)#@03':'!+D(#+$4!Z!AD%!$3#!+!%!(3!!='3)!!%)'!U%#:3$!<br />

+#-$7#)#!-#($:!='7G!%!%!7''%:')!!!'%5'=!G6!+D(#%$%!D>#($%#!?!=!3)!!%)'!#:G($70!<br />

U3D:3#($%$%! '(..!!! )03'7!+!73'4! ?!=!! AD5D! -#! 5$-5$-! ='3$.#+$%$%! )D.DD!<br />

G$3)$($3:#=.#)$(B! 26! 036:+6>36=3'(!%! 7'%!%)'! )#@03':'! +D(#+$%$%! 6>':'+!! G(0$3#(!<br />

@#(10(:'%+!%!!)'!036:+6>!7U%)#!#.=$3#:#=.#)$(!NVP!NK'G30!VPB!!<br />

K'G30!V#(#!)#@03':'!+D(#+$!V!-#!Vg!AD%!03'%!76:6(.'3'()'%!#3)#!<br />

#)$3#%! 5$-5$-3#()#! gdB! AD%)#=$! 5'%3!!'!(3!=! 1'(=!! V[[! A(':!! A#?:#=.#)$(B! 2#%>#(!<br />

+0%6?3'(!;1'(!#.!'3B!NdP!-#!R=6(!#.!'3B!N]P!.'('1!%)'%!)'!.#+@$.!#)$3:$.$(B!;7(!5'!&#(!<br />

$=$! ?'3!:')'! )'! V[! AD%! G#=3#.$3#%! 76:6(.'3'()'%! #3)#! #)$3#%! AD%3D=! 5$-5$-3#()#4! V!<br />

AD%!G#=3#.$3#%3#(#!AU(#!+'(!!=#+#+$!0('%!%!%!7D=+#=4!.'3!=!-#!='('5$#(!0('%3'(!%!%!$+#!<br />

)'&'!)DD=!03)66!G#3$(3#%:$.$(B!<br />

!<br />

! HW


K'G30!VB!c#@03':'!+D(#+$%$%!G(0$3#(!5'%3!!'!(3!!%'!#.=$+$!!<br />

c#@0! TD(#+$! j'%3!!;!(3!=4!A(!<br />

NAD%P! [BAD%! VgBAD%! gdBAD%!<br />

V! gVBZ! ][e! ddVe '!<br />

Vg! gVBV! dff! dV[V G!<br />

Jz[B[^!<br />

!<br />

,>6%! +D(#! )#@03'%'%! 76:6(.'3'()'%! #3)#! #)$3#%! 5$-5$-3#()#! 5'%3!!'!(3!!%! U%#:3$!<br />

+#-$7#)#!)DD=!03:'+!%!%!%#)#%$!.':!03'('=!G$3$%:#:#=3#!G$(3$=.#!2('=#!-#!'(=B!NgP!<br />

G6! 036:+6>! #.=$7$4! 76:6(.'! $?! ='3$.#+$%$%! U>#33$=3#! )#! '3GD:$%! ='3$.#+$%$%! )#@0!<br />

+!('+!%)'! >'('(! AU(:#+$! $3#! '?!=3':!3'()!(B! 26%6%! 7'%!%)'! *'+#%=0! #.! '3B! N^P! 6>6%!<br />

+D(#! G#=3#.$3#%! 76:6(.'3'()'=$! #:G($703'()'4! =636?='! +!('+!%)'! G$(! U(%#=! #:G($70!<br />

A#3$$:$! 03:')!!4! =636?='%!%! VdB! +''.$%)#! G'>!! #:G($703'()'! &$?G$(! A#3$:#!<br />

AU(D3:#>=#%4! G'>!3'(!%)'! A#3$:#%$%! 7'-'! +#7(#..$$4! G'>!3'(!%)'! $+#! %0(:'3! G$(!<br />

A#3$:#! 03)66%6! .#+@$.! #.:$3#()$(B! 26! )6(6:! 6>6%! +D(#! G#=3#.$3#%! 76:6(.'3'()'%!<br />

#3)#!#)$3#%!5$-5$-3#($%!=636?='!+D(#3#($%$%!%#)#%!6>6%!03)66%6!'?!=3':'=3'!G$(3$=.#!<br />

G6!A#3$:#! A#($3$$4! G(0$3#(! @#(10(:'%+!%!%!036:+6>! 7U%)#! #.=$3#%:#+$%$%! G$(!G'='!<br />

%#)#%$!)#!03'G$3$(B!<br />

,>6%! +D(#! )#@03'%'%! 76:6(.'3'()'! ?!=!! AD5D%D%! #%! '>! +#-$7#)#! #.=$3#%#G$3:#+$!<br />

':'5!73'! 1'(=3!! 67A63':'3'(! 7'@!3:'=.')!(B! c#@03':'! +!('+!%)'! =636?='3!=!<br />

76:6(.'3'(!%!%'730%!.0(G'!$?$%)#!:6&'1'>'!#)$3:#+$4!76:6(.'3'(!%!+$-($!6?!76='(!)'!<br />

G#=3#.$3:#+$4! 76:6(.'3'(!%! ?#-($3:#+$4! )#@03':'! +!5'=3!!%!%! )DD(D3:#+$4!<br />

76:6(.'3'(!%! !+!.!3:'+!! G6! 67A63':'3'()'%! G'>!3'(!! 03'('=! +'7!3'G$3$(B! X6:6(.'3'(!%!<br />

%'730%! .0(G'! $?$%)#! G#=3#.$3:#+$! '3GD:$%! ='3$.#+$%$%! =0(6%:'+!%'! 7'()!:5!! 03:'=.'!<br />

-#!?!=!!AD5D%)#=$!)DDD!'>'3.:'=.')!(!NePB!26!67A63':'%!%!#.3$=!@$3$?!@#(10(:'%+!!<br />

D>#($%#! )#! #.=$+$%$! G#3$(3#:#=! ':'5!73'! 7'@!3'%! ?'3!:')'4! %'730%! .0(G')'! V[! AD%!<br />

G#=3#.$3#%!76:6(.'3'()'%!#3)#!#)$3#%!5$-5$-3#($%!=#+$:!+0%6!5'%3!!'!(3!=3'(!%!%!7$%#!<br />

'7%!!+D(#!G#=3#.$3#%!=0%.(03!A(6G6%'!AU(#!7'=3'!=!][!A(':!)'&'!7D=+#=!03)66!.#+@$.!<br />

#)$3:$.$(! NL3$G03! d[[Z4! 7'7!%3'%:':!! -#($PB! n'730%! .0(G')'! G#=3#.:#! 7'%!%)'!<br />

76='(!)'!+'7!3'%!?!=!!AD5D%D!036:36!7U%)#!#.=$3#7#%!&#(!$3#:$%!5'%3!!'!(3!=!D>#($%#!<br />

)#!A#?#(3$!03'G$3#5#$!AU>!U%D%#!'3!%'('=!?'3!:'3'('!G6!7U%)#!)#!'!(3!=!-#($3#G$3$(B!!<br />

!<br />

./&/01'!)!2'1&!!!<br />

T0%! 7!33'('! =')'(! &'-'! $3#! #:G($70! +!5'=3!!%!%! '7%!! 03)66! -'(+'7!3'('=! :'=$%#! $?!<br />

&'-'! +!5'=3!!%!! =0%.(03! #.:#%$%! 0@.$:6:! ?!=!! AD5D! -#! 5$-5$-! ='3$.#+$! $?$%! 7#.#(3$!<br />

03'5'!! )DD%D3D()DB! ;%5'=! 76:6(.'! '!(3!!%!%! '(.:'+!4! )U33D3DD%! 7D=+#3:#+$! -#!<br />

A#%#.$=!$3#(3#:#3#(!#:G($703'(!%!)'&'!1'>3'!:#.'G03$=!!+!!D(#.:#+$%#!%#)#%!03:6.6(B!<br />

X6:6(.'! )'! 7''%'%! G6! )#$$:3#(#! $3'-#! 03'('=! :'=$%#! ='@'+$.#3#($! )#! '(.:!.!(!<br />

NG$($:!'3'%)'!)'&'!1'>3'!76:6(.'PB!26%'!(':#%!:'=$%#!$?$%)#!&'-'!&'(#=#.$%$%!-#!<br />

+06.:'!='@'+$.#+$%$%!'7%!!+#-$7#)#!'(.:':'+!4!U>#33$=3#!=636?='%!%!$=$%5$!7'(!+!%)'!<br />

:'=$%#! +!5'=3!!! $3#! #:G($70! +!5'=3!!! '('+!%)'=$! 1'(=!%! GD7D:#+$%#! %#)#%!<br />

03:'=.')!(B! T0%6?.'! G6! )6(6:! :'=$%#! $?$%)#! G'>!! GU3A#3#()#! +!5'=3!!%! &0:0I#%!<br />

03'('=! )'!3:'+!%!! #%A#33#:#=.#! -#! :'=$%#! +#.! )##(3#($! )0(6! 03:'+!%'! (':#%!<br />

=636?='!('%)!:'%!!-#!5$-5$-!='3$.#+$%)#!@(0G3#:3#(!7''%:'=.')!(NZ4!f4!WPB!!<br />

CD%D:D>)#! '%0(:'3! #:G($70! A#3$$:$4! A#?! )U%#:! #:G($70! U3D:3#($%$%! '(.:'+!! -#!<br />

!+='(.'! 5$-5$-! 0('%!%!%! 7D=+#=! 03:'+!%!%! #%! U%#:3$! %#)#%$! $%=6G'+70%6%! $=$%5$!<br />

7'(!+!%)'!:'=$%#!$3#!#:G($70!+!5'=3!!!'('+!%)'=$!1'(=!%!'(.:'+!)!(B!H636?='%!%!$=$%5$!<br />

7'(!+!%)'! ='G6=! +!5'=3!!! 7D=+#=! 03'%! 76:6(.'3'()'%! #3)#! #)$3#%! 5$-5$-3#()#! +'(!!<br />

=#+#+$! '!(3!!! 7D=+#=4! %#.! '!(3!=! $+#! )'&'! )DD=! 03:'=.'4! AUG#=! .':! 03'('=!<br />

! HZ


='@'%:':'=.')!(B! 26! 5$-5$-3#()#! ='3G$%! 5'%3!! '!(3!'! 0('%!! )'! U%#:3$! +#-$7#)#!<br />

)D:#=.#)$(!NV[4!VV4!VdPB!903#%''(!#.!'3B!NV]P!7'@:!!03)6=3'(!!?'3!:')'!=636?='%!%!<br />

ZB! AD%D%)#%! +0%('! ='G6=! +!5'=3!!! 7D=+#=! N]fBW! {jP! -#! %0(:'3! N]ZBf! {jP! 03'5'=!<br />

#=$3)#! d! =636?='! :'=$%#+$%)#! $=$! +!5'=3!=! @(01$3$! 036.6(:63'()!(B! H'G6=! +!5'=3!!!<br />

7D=+#=! 03'%! 76:6(.'3'()'%! #3)#! #)$3#%! 5$-5$-3#()#4! %0(:'3! +!5'=3!=! 67A63'%'%3'('!<br />

AU(#! =#+$:! 7'!! 03'%! gdB!AD%)#! 5'%3!!'!(3!=! U%#:3$! +#-$7#)#! )DD=! G636%6(=#%! G6!<br />

&'7-'%3'()'! '+$.#+)#%! U3#%3#($%! 0('%!! )'! =0%.(03! A(6G6%)'%! d! ='.! )'&'! 7D=+#=!<br />

03:6.6(! NK'G30! dPB! ;('.!(!5!3'(4! 7D=+#=! +!5'=3!=! A(6G6%)'=$! 5$-5$-3#()#! ='3@!<br />

'!(3!!%!4!=0%.(03!A(6G6%'!AU(#!t!de!)'&'!)DD=!G#3$(3#:$3#(!-#!'+$.#+!0366:6!$3#!<br />

=636?='!+!('+!%)'!='3@!A#3$$:$!'('+!%)'!U%#:3$!G$(!$3$=$!03)66%6!G$3)$(:$3#()$(B!!<br />

!<br />

K'G30! dB! H636?=')'! 67A63'%'%! ='G6=! +!5'=3!!%!%! 5'%3!!'!(3!=! -#! U3D:! 0('%!!<br />

D>#($%#!#.=$+$B!!<br />

H'G6=!T!5'=3!!!<br />

903#%''(!#.!'3B!NV]P!<br />

\63#.!#.!'3B!NV[P!<br />

m>#33$=!<br />

XD=+#=!<br />

]ZB^{j! ]WBZ{j!<br />

n0(:'3!N]ZBf{jP!<br />

N]fBW{jP!<br />

j'%3!!'!(3!=4!A(! df^g! dfW^! ddVg! dVee!<br />

m3D:!N;+$.#+P4!t! VdB^NeBeP! fBgNdBfP! eBg]! ZB]^!<br />

!<br />

2(0$3#(!D(#.$:$%)#!'+$.#+!A$G$!-#($:!D>#($%#!036:+6>!#.=$)#!G636%'%!U%#:3$!G$(!)$#(!<br />

U>#33$=.#!G'5'=!@(0G3#:3#($)$(B!2'5'=!@(0G3#:3#($!D>#($%#!7'@!3'%!+0%!?'3!:'3'(4!G6!<br />

+0(6%6%! #:G($70! A#3$$:$! $3#! 7'=!%)'%! $3A$+$! 03)66! 7U%D%)#)$(B! X'3?!%! #.! '3B! NVgP!<br />

=636?='%!%! $3=! )U%#:$%)#! :'=$%#! $?$%)#=$! +!5'=3!=! )#$$:3#($%$%! G(0$3#(! )#! Kc!<br />

0366:6%6!'(.!()!!%!!G$3)$(:$.$(B!R-$#)0!#.!'3B!NV^P!$+#!=636?='%!%!+0%!)U%#:$%)#!<br />

7D=+#=! +!5'=3!=4! 7#.#(+$>! 0=+$I#%$%! N&'-'P4! =#:$=! A#3$$:$%$! 036:+6>! 7U%)#!<br />

#.=$3#)$$%$!-#!+0%6?.'!G'5'=!@(0G3#:3#($%$%!'(..!!%!!G$3)$(:$.$(B!;7(!5'!'('.!(!5!3'(4!<br />

5$-5$-3#($%! =636?='&'%#)#%! =D:#+#! %'=3$7#+$! +!('+!%)'! 7D=+#=! +!5'=3!'! :'(6>!<br />

='3:'3'(!! &'3$%)#! )#! G6! .$@! +0(6%3'(!%! )'&'! 706%! 03'('=! AU(D3#G$3#5#$%$!<br />

G#3$(.:$3#()$(B! H636?='%!%! VebdVB! AD%3#($%)#! 1'(=3!! ='G6=! +!5'=3!=3'(!%!%! G(0$3#(!<br />

@#(10(:'%+!! D>#($%#! #.=$+$%$! '('.!('%! \63#.! #.! '3B! NV[P4! 7D=+#=! ='G6=! +!5'=3!!%'!<br />

:'(6>!G!('=!3'%!76:6(.'3'()'%!#3)#!#)$3#%!5$-5$-3#()#4!=#+$:!7'!%)'!NgdB!AD%P!5'%3!!<br />

'!(3!!%! 036:+6>! 7U%)#! #.=$3#%)$$%$! .#+@$.! #.:$3#()$(! NK'G30! dPB! 2#%>#(! G$(! )$#(!<br />

?'3!:')'! $+#! i#=+($+0:@0%A4! #.! '3B! NVeP! =636?='%!%! +0%! &'1.'+!%)'! ='G6=! +!5'=3!!!<br />

7D=+#=! 03'%! 76:6(.'3'()'%! #3)#! #)$3#%! 5$-5$-3#($%4! dVB! AD%! 5'%3!!'!(3!!! -#! 7#:!<br />

.D=#.$:$%$%! =0%.(03! A(6G6%'!AU(#! U%#:3$! +#-$7#)#! )DD=4!U3D:!0('%!%!%! $+#! 7D=+#=!<br />

03)66%6! +'@.':!3'()!(B! ;%5'=! G6! 5$-5$-3#($%! 7#.$.$($3)$$! =D:#+3#()#! $3=! Vbd! AD%!<br />

=D:#+!'3.3!=!+!5'=3!!%!%!N]]b]^jP!7D=+#3.$3:#+$!)6(6:6%)'!7#:!.D=#.$:$%$%!'(..!!4!<br />

U3D:! 0('%!%!%! $+#! )D.DD! G#3$(.$3:$.$(B! T0%6?! 03'('=! 7D=+#=! @#(10(:'%+! $?$%!<br />

U%5#3$=3#! :'=$%#! +!5'=3!!4! ='G6=! +!5'=3!!%'! AU(#! )D>#%3#%:#3$! -#! :'=$%#! $?$%)#!<br />

='G6=!+!5'=3!!%!%!G$(!U(%#=!03:'+!!+'3'%:'3!)!(B!<br />

!<br />

3!1!(!4'('5!!!<br />

C#%#33$=3#!%0(:'3!=0633'()'!5$-5$-3#(!=636?='%!%!^[eb^V[B!+''.3#($%)#!:'=$%#3#()#%!<br />

'3!%!(3'(B! ;%5'=! G$3$%)$$! D>#(#! 5$-5$-3#(! '('+!%)'! ?!=!:! >':'%!! G'=!:!%)'%!<br />

1'(=3!3!=3'(! 03:'=.')!(B! "0++! NVZP! $)#'3! 03'('=! :'=$%#)#%! '3:'! >':'%!%)'%! ][! +''.!<br />

U%5#! 5$-5$-3#($%! tV':'+!!<br />

)6(6:6%)'! +'&')'! GD7D:#! -#! D%$10(:$.#%$%! 036:+6>! 7U%)#! #.=$3#%#5#$%$!<br />

G$3)$(:$.$(B!26!036:+6>36=!#(=#%!?!='%!5$-5$-3#($%!?!=!:!:'=$%#+$%)#!)'&'!6>6%!+D(#!<br />

! H]


G#=3#:#3#($! -#! +6! ='7G#.:#3#($! $3#! '?!=3'%'G$3$(B! ;7(!5'! "0++! NVZP! 5$-5$-3#($%!<br />

:'=$%#)#%!'3!%:'!>':'%!%)'!G'>!!5$-5$-3#($%!Nt!^!=')'(P!#%+#3#($!-#!G'>!!76:6(.'!<br />

='G6=3'(!%!%!&'3#%!%#:3$!03:'+!%!%!A#(#=3$!03)66%6!)'!G#3$(.:$.$(B!c$#(!G$(!!+3'&!<br />

1$(:'+!! 03'%! j0GG! NVfP! $+#! :'=$%#)#%! '3:'! >':'%!%)'%! d]! +''.! U%5#! Nd]b]]! +''.!<br />

'('+!%)'P!5$-5$-3#($%!t!d^6%! +D(#! G#=3#7#%!<br />

5$-5$-3#()#! '!(3!=! ='7G!! :#7)'%'! A#3)$$! -#! G6! ='7G!%! =#+$:! 7'!%'! =')'(! .#3'1$!<br />

#)$3#:#)$$%$!.#+@$.!#.:$3#()$(B!J#.#(+$:#!-#!J'+(#10(:!A$G$!U%#:3$!=636?='!:'=$%#!<br />

$:'3'.?!3'(!!)'!G6!'('.!(!5!3'('! G#%>#(! 03'('=! 0@.$:6:! G(0$3#(! @#(10(:'%+!%!%! #3)#!<br />

#)$3#G$3:#+$!$?$%4!5$-5$-$%4!='G66!=!(!@!?!=.!=.'%!+0%('!#%!=!+'!+D(#)#!Ndg!+''.P!7#:!<br />

-#!+6!$3#!G636:'+!%!%!+'3'%:'+!!A#(#=.$$%$!G#3$(.:$3#()$(B!k!=!:!>':'%!!-#!G(0$3#(!<br />

@#(10(:'%+!! '('+!%)'=$! $3$=$7$! .#+@$.! #)#G$3:#=! ':'5!73'! ;B`B! l$(''.! *'=D3.#+$!<br />

l00.#=%$! GU3D:D! '('.!(:'! G$($:$%)#! G$(! )$>$! ?'3!:'! 7D(D.D3:D.D(B! k'3!:')'4!<br />

=636?='%!%!+0%!)U%#:$%)#!5$-5$-3#($%!G$(#7+#3!03'('=!?!=!:!>':'%3'(!!G#3$(3#%:$!-#!<br />

#(=#%! NgfdB+''.$%#! =')'(! ?!='%3'(P! 4! 0(.'! N! gfdBb! gWeB! +''.3#(! '('+!P! -#! A#?! )U%#:!<br />

NgWeBb^V[B! +''.3#(! '('+!P! ?!=!:! A(6@3'(!! 036.6(63:6! -#! )'&'! +0%('! G6%3'(!%! G(0$3#(!<br />

@#(10(:'%+3'(!! ='(!3'.!(!3:!.!(B! T0%6?.'4! 5$-5$-! ?!=!:! >':'%!%!%! G(0$3#(! 5'%3!!<br />

'!(3!!! D>#($%#! #.=$3$! 03)66! G#3$(3#%:$.$(B! ;%5'=! G$3$%#%$%! '=+$%#! A#?! ?!='%!<br />

5$-5$-3#($%! =#+$:! 7'!! 5'%3!!'!(3!=3'(!4! #(=#%! -#! 0(.'! )U%#:)#! ?!='%3'('! AU(#! )'&'!<br />

)DD=4!U3D:!0('%!!$+#!)'&'!7D=+#=!03:6.6(!NK'G30!]PB!m>#33$=3#!A#?!?!='%!5$-5$-3#(4!<br />

$3=! AD%! )'&'! '!(! 03:'3'(!%'! ='(!%! G6! '-'%.'I3'(!%!! $3=! &'1.'%!%! +0%6%)'!<br />

='7G#.:$3#()$(B! 26%'! %#)#%! 03'('=! )'! G6! A(6@.'=$! &'7-'%3'(!%! D(#.$:$%! $3=!<br />

)U%#:3#($%)#!)$#(!A(6@.'=$!&'7-'%3'(!=')'(!7#:!.D=#.#:#:#3#($!$3#!'?!=3'%'G$3$(B!<br />

!<br />

K'G30!]B!k!=!:!>':'%!%!%!G(0$3#(!5'%3!!'!(3!!!-#!U3D:!0('%!!D>#($%#!#.=$+$!<br />

k!=!:!l':'%!!<br />

X'!NAD%P! L(=#%! R(.'! C#?!<br />

jB;4!A(! m3D:4!t! jB;4!A(! m3D:4!t! jB;4!A(! m3D:4!t!<br />

V! ]ZB]W! ! ]fBgg! ! ]WB^[! !<br />

Z! VegB]! [Bge! VeVBf! [B^e! V^^Be! dB]e!<br />

]^! d[e]! dBVZ! d[e[! dBZV! VWWV! ^Bg^!<br />

$<br />

"F,7_$<br />

L%.#A('+70%!$?#($+$%)#!U%#:3$!G$(!&'3='7!!036.6('%!=636?='&'%#3#()#!&#)#1!#%!)DD=!<br />

:'3$7#.!$3#!#%!7D=+#=!?!=!!AD5D!)##($%#!63''G$3:#=.$(B!;%5'=!#%.#A(#!1$(:'3'(!$?$%!<br />

='(3!3!=!AU>!U%D%#!'3!%)!!%)'!$+#!#%!U%#:3$!&#)#1!+0%!D(D%!03'%!G(0$3#(!D(#.$:$%)#=$!<br />

G''(!)!(B! 26! %#)#%3#! =636?='&'%#3#()#! 7D(D.D3#%! $3#:3#($%! +')#5#! ?!=!! AD5D! -#!<br />

5$-5$-!='3$.#+$%$!'(.!(:'=!$3#!+!%!(3!!='3:')!!4!G(0$3#(!@#(10(:'%+!!D>#($%#!)#!U%#:3$!<br />

#.=$3#($!03)66!6%6.63:':'3!!-#!G6!7U%)#!?'3!:'3'('!'!(3!=!-#($3:#3$)$(B!<br />

$<br />

%+5,+A-+.$<br />

VB! ;.#4!j4!RBL3$G034!wB!2('=#BYK&#!#11#5.!01!+.0('A#!@#($0)!01!#AA+!0%!&'.5&$%A!.$:#!'%)!G(0$3#(!<br />

@#(10(:'%5#B!||OO!a0(3)


gB! 2('=#4!wB4!a'3+&4!KB!wB4!2#%.0%4!jB!LB4!J#.$..#4!wB!nB4!9#$I#(&014!"B!'%)!J#%'3-'4!CBY!LAA!&'%)3$%A!<br />

'%)!+.0('A#B!J063.B!T5$B4!VWWZh!Zeh!VggbV^VB!<br />

^B! *'+#%=04!CB9B4!"0G$%+0%4!*BLB!'%)!j&($+.#%+#%4!8BiBY!L11#5.+!01!30%A!.#(:!+.0('A#!0%!.&#!#AA4!<br />

#:G(70! '%)! 5&$5=B! J('5.$5'3! '+@#5.+! 01! 50::#(5$'3!$%56G'.$0%!$%!@063.(7B!L)+B!c##:$%A4!cBjB!@@B]]b]WB!<br />

,BHB!d[[dB!<br />

eB! L3$G034! RBYH636?='! T0%6?3'(!%!! L.=$3#7#%! L.:#%3#(! -#! H636?='! ;=+'=3!=3'(!%!%! C$)#($3:#+$4!<br />

2#3$(3#%:#+$! `>#($%)#! ;('.!(:'3'(B! c0=.0('! K#>$B! ;%='('! `%$-#(+$.#+$! *#%! 2$3$:3#($! L%+.$.D+D4! ;%='('4!<br />

KD(=$7#B!VWWZB!<br />

ZB! i06(#%+4! ;B4! \B! -'%! )#%! 2('%)4! "B! 9#$I#(&01! '%)! 2B! H#:@! Y! L11#5.! 01! #AA+&#33! .#:@#('.6(#!<br />

)6($%A! $%56G'.$0%! 0%! #:G(70! )#-#30@:#%.4! &'.5&'G$3$.74! '%)! @0+.&'.5&! )#-#30@:#%.B! J063.B! T5$B4! d[[^h!<br />

fgYWVgpWd[B!<br />

fB! *(#%5&4! nB! ;BY! 90)#3$%A! $%56G'.$0%! .#:@#('.6(#Y! K&#! #11#5.+! 01! $%56G'.0(! )#+$A%4! #:G(70%$5!<br />

)#-#30@:#%.4!'%)!#AA!+$>#B!J063.BT5$B4!VWWZhZeYVdgpV]]B!<br />

WB! L3$G034!RB4!'%)!wB!2('=#BY!L11#5.!01!#AA!Q#$A&.!'%)!@0+$.$0%!(#3'.$-#!.0!$%56G'.0(!1'%!0%!G(0$3#(!<br />

&'.5&'G$3$.7!'%)!5&$5=!S6'3$.7B!J063.B!T5$B4!d[[fhfZYVWV]pVWVfB!<br />

V[B! \63#.4!"B4!CB!C3')7+4!cB!\$334!"B!9#$I#(&014!'%)!KB!L3bT&$#=&BY!O%136#%5#!01!#AA!+&#33!#:G(70%$5!<br />

$%56G'.$0%! .#:@#('.6(#! '%)G(0$3#(! G(##)#(! 1305=! 'A#! 0%! @0+.&'.5&! A(0Q.&! @#(10(:'%5#! '%)5'(5'++!<br />

5&'('5.#($+.$5+B!J063.B!T5$B4!d[[ZhfeYg[fpgVdB!!<br />

VVB! i#=+($+0:@0%A4!nB4!\B!"0:#(0bT'%5&#>4!JB!aB!J36:+.#')4!HB!LB2('%%'%4!'%)!wB!2('=#BY!2(0$3#(!<br />

$%56G'.$0%B!VB!L11#5.!01!#3#-'.#)!.#:@#('.6(#!)6($%A!3'.#!$%56G'.$0%!0%!G0)7!Q#$A&.!'%)!0(A'%+!01!5&$5=+B!<br />

J063.B!T5$B4!d[[ZhfeYdef^pdeWVB!<br />

VdB! X'3?$%4! TB4! LB! 2'G'5'%0A364! \B! jB! CD3#(! '%)! 9B! ;=$.BY! L11#5.+! 01! $%56G'.$0%! .#:@#('.6(#! 0%!<br />

&'.5&$%A!'%)!5'(5'++!@#(10(:'%5#!01!G(0$3#(+B!a0(3)PB!d[V[hVWbd[B!<br />

VfB! j0GGBY\'.5&#(7!9'%'A#:#%.Y!K&#!\'.5&!a$%)0QB!K#5&$5'3!*056+!N;6A6+.PB!d[[fB!$<br />

VWB! a7'..! ji4! aBcBa#'-#(4! aBiB2#'%#BY! O%136#%5#! 01! #AA! +$>#4! #AA! +&#33! S6'3$.74! '%)! @0+.&'.5&!<br />

&03)$%A!.$:#!0%!G(0$3#(!@#(10(:'%5#B!J063.(7!T5$B4!VWf^hegYd[gWbd[^^B!<br />

d[B! n$(! O4! 9B! i#-'%0%BYL11#5.! 01! @0+.&'.5&! &03)$%A! .$:#! @#(10(:'%5#! '%)! (#+$)6'3! 703=! '%)! 3$-#(!<br />

50:@0+$.$0%B!J063.(7!T5$B4!VWW]hZdYVWWgbVWWZB!<br />

! J!


" ##N $2&^F-+)+$"O.&'($@&$U&@(.)&$"!A-!!,!,$U!A!$>O3!=3'()'%! #3)#! #)$3#%! =636?='3!=! 76:6(.'3'(! =633'%!3:!.!(B! 26!<br />

76:6(.'3'(! .$5'($! G$(! =636?='&'%#)#=$! J#.#(+$:#! A#3$$:! :'=$%#3#($%#!<br />

7#(3#.$($3:#)#%! U%5#! d! -#! V[! AD%! tZ^! %$+G$! %#:! -#! Vf~j#(#! d! ?#-$(:#!<br />

+!=3!!!67A63'%:!.!(B!!V[!AD%!)#@03'%'%!76:6(.3'()'!'>'3'%!?!=!!AD5D%D%!N@z[B[^P4!<br />

We! )#1'_AD%! ?#-$(:#! $3#! $7$3#.$$! N@z[B[^P! G636%:6.6(B! V[! AD%! )#@03'%'%!<br />

76:6(.'3'()'%!#3)#!#)$3#%!5$-5$-3#()#!?!=!:!'!(3!!!7D=+#3:$!1'='.!VgB!AD%!-#!]^B!<br />

AD%! 5'%3!! '!(3!=3'(!! '>'3:!.!(B! 2#%>#(! #=$3)#! We)#1'_AD%! ?#-($3#%! 76:6(.'3'()'!<br />

VgBAD%! 5'%3!!'!(3!!! )'&'! 7D=+#=! 03:6.6(B! 26! -#($3#(! A#3$$:! )U%#:$%)#! ?#-$(:#!<br />

+!=3!!%!! '(..!(!:'%!%! ?!=!! AD5D%D! '(.!()!!%!4! G6%6%3'! G$(3$=.#! V[AD%! )#@03'%'%!<br />

76:6(.3'()'!?!=!!AD5D%D%D%!-#!G(0$3#(!@#(10(:'%+!%!%!)D.DD%D!AU+.#(:$.$(B!!!<br />

:,+*1+.$%&-()&-&.$3$2(0$3#(4!=636?='44!76:6(.'!)#@03':'4!?#-$(:#!+'7!+!!!<br />

!<br />

:;'1.+!$?$%!='7%'=3'(!:!>!!)'&'!-#($:3$!=633'%:':!>!<br />

-#!:'3$7#.$!'>'3.:'7'!?'3!:':!>!A#(#=3$)$(B!!<br />

26! ?'3!:'3'(!%! $3=! G'+':'!! 03'%! =636?='5!3!=h! ='%'.3!! D(#.$:! >$%5$($%$%! #%! 1'>3'!<br />

7'.!(!:! A#(#=.$(#%! '7(!3:'>! @'(?'3'(!%)'%! G$($)$(! -#! =636?='&'%#)#! +'3'%'5'=!<br />

! JC


@#(10(:'%+!'(.!!!5$-5$-!+'7!+!%!!'(..!('('=!A#(#=3$!)':!>3!=!+'7!+!%!4!#%#(I$4!$!AD5D!-GB!<br />

A$)#(3#($!'>'3.'5'=.!(B!!<br />

;7(!5'!G(0$3#(!5$-5$-3#($%!@#(10(:'%+!U>#33$=3#($%$!+'&')'!#%!$7$!#=$3)#!AU(#G$3:#:$>!<br />

$?$%! =636?='&'%#3#(! #%! 1'>3'! )$=='.! #)$3:#+$! A#(#=#%! 7#(3#()#%! G$($)$(B! 2(0$3#(!<br />

#%)D+.($+$%)#!7D=+#=!-#($:3$!!(=3'(!%!-#!&$G($.!#G#-#7%3#($%$%!=633'%!3:'+!73'!=636?='!<br />

-#!7#.$.$(:#!)U%#:$!@#(10(:'%+!!'('+!%)'=$!$3$=$!A$)#(#=!'(.:'7'!G'3':!.!(B!<br />

H636?='!@#(10(:'%+!!A#%#.$=4!+D(D!7'!4!&'-'!G'+!%5!4!0=+$I#%!$&.$7'5!4!+!5'=3!=4!%#:4!<br />

?#-$(:#4! )#@03':'! +D(#+$! -#! =0633'(!4! )':!>3!=3'()'=$! G'=!:! -#! G#+3#:#! =0633'(!4!<br />

&'+.'3!=! -GB! 1'=.U(3#()#%! #.=$3#%:#=.#4! ?!=!! AD5D! -#! =636?='! ('%)!:'%!! A$G$!<br />

#=0%0:$=! =($.#(3#(#! AU(#! G#3$(3#%:#=.#)$(B! H636?='&'%#)#! #%! 7D=+#=! @#(10(:'%+'!<br />

63':'=! -#! D%$10(:! GD7D=3D=.#! 5$-5$-! #3)#! #.:#=4! 76:6(.'! ='3$.#+$! $3#! #:G($70!<br />

A#3$$:$%)#=$! +'@:'3'(!%! '>'3.!3:'+!%'! G'3!)!(B! X6:6(.'! ='3$.#+$! -#! #:G($70!<br />

A#3$$:$%)#=$! )0'3! +'@:'3'(!! .#+@$.! #.:#=! -#! '%3':'=! $?$%! '('.!(:'3'(!<br />

)D>#%3#%:#=.#4!D%$10(:!G$(!=636?='!+'3':'=!$?$%!)#!#=$@:'%3'(!A#3$.$($3:#=.#)$(B!!<br />

2(0$3#(!D(#.$:$%)#!-#($:3$3$=! $+#! A#%#.$=4! +D(D! 7'!4!=636?='! 67A63':'3'(!4! )':!>3!=!<br />

-#! 7#.$.$(:#! =D:#+$%)#=$! G'=!:! -#! G#+3#:#! =0633'(!4! :#-+$:4! &'+.'3!=! -GB!<br />

1'=.U(3#()#%! #.=$3#%:#=.#! -#! 0(.'3':'! =#+$:! '!(3!!4! 7#:! )##(3#%)$(:#! +'7!+!4!<br />

7'':'!AD5D!-#!-#($:3$3$=!@6'%!!A$G$!=($.#(3#(#!AU(#!G#3$(3#%:#=.#)$(B!!<br />

`%$10(:!G$(!?!=!!AD5D!+'3':'=!-#!@#(10(:'%+.'=$!+'@:'3'(!!'>'3.:'=!$?$%!=636?='!<br />

-#! +'&'! =0633'(!%)'! $7$3#.$(:#7#! 7U%#3$=! ?'3!:'3'(! )#-':! #.:#=.#)$(B! m>#33$=3#!<br />

)':!>3!=.'%! =636?='7'! -#! =#+$:#! =')'(! 6>'7'%! +D(#?.#! 67A63'%'%! $3#:3#($%!<br />

#.=$3#($%$%!G#3$(3#%$@!?U>D:3#(!D(#.$3:#+$!A$..$=?#!U%#:!.'!:'=.')!(B!!<br />

26!'('.!(:'4!)#@03':'!+D(#+$!-#!!?#-$(:#!+!=3!!%!%!?!=!!AD5D!-#!G(0$3#(!@#(10(:'%+!!<br />

D>#($%#!#.=$3#($%$!.#+@$.!#.:#=!':'5!73'!7D(D.D3:D.D(B!!<br />

!<br />

c+1&.5+-$@&$c&1F/$<br />

c+1&.5+-$<br />

c#%#:#%$%! =636?='! '':'+!! :#(=#>$! ! 2036


03:'+!%'!U>#%!AU+.#($3:$.$(B!c#%#:#!)#4!&#(!G$(!)#@0!+D(#+$!$?$%!eB[[[!')#.!03:'=!<br />

D>#(#!.0@3':!VdB[[[!')#.!=636?='3!=!76:6(.'!=633'%!3:!.!(B!!<br />

c#@0! +D(#+$! 1'(=3!! 03'%! 76:6(.'3'(! ('+A#3#! d! #$.! @'(?'7'! GU3D%:D! -#! G$(G$($%$%!<br />

G#%>#($! d! A#3$$:! :'=$%#+$%#! =0%63:6.6(B! 9'=$%#! )#! .#@+$3#($%! &#(! G$($%#! V^[!<br />

76:6(.'! =0%:6! -#! &#(! :6':#3#! A(6G6%)'! V! .#@+$! V! .#=#((D(! +'7!3:!.!(B! K#=#((D(!<br />

+'7!+!!&#(!:6':#3#)#!d[!03:6!-#!)#%#:#)#!.0@3':!f[!.#@+$!N.#=#((D(P!=633'%!3:!.!(B!!<br />

9'=$%#3#()#%!G$($%)#!dg!')#._AD%4!)$#($%)#!$+#!We!')#._AD%!03'5'=!#=$3)#!?#-$(:#!<br />

7'@!3:!.!(! N#=$3! VPB! 9'=$%#3#()#! J#.#(+$:#! .'('1!%)'%! .'-+$7#! #)$3#%! =636?='!<br />

@(0A(':!! 67A63'%:!! -#! ?#-$(:#! +!=3!!! )!!%)'! GD.D%! ?#-(#! =0633'(!%!%! &#(! d!<br />

:'=$%#)#!)#!#$.!03:'+!!+'3'%:!.!(B!C#3$$:!)U%#:$%)#!1'(=3!!:'=$%#3#()#!G636%'%!<br />

76:6(.'3'(!.('%+1#(!$3#:$!+0%('+!%)'!'7%!!?!=!:!:'=$%#+$%#!'=.'(!3:!.!(B!!<br />

!<br />

&A(-$!=!c#%#:#%$%!,7A63':'!J3'%!!<br />

!<br />

c#@0!TD(#+$4!NAD%P! ! ! d! ! ! ! ! ! V[! ! !<br />

! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !<br />

C#3$$:! cU%#:$%)#! k#-$(:#4!!<br />

dg! ! We! ! dg! ! We!<br />

N')#._AD%P!!<br />

k!=!!%! .':':3'%:'+!%)'%! +0%('! .#@+$3#()#=$! !+='(.'! 5$-5$-3#(! $3#! ?!=!!! 03:'7'%!<br />

76:6(.'3'(! '7(!3:!.!(B! k!=!! 03:'7'%! 76:6(.'3'(! =!(!3'('=! #(=#%! )U%#:! N[bZ! AD%P4!<br />

0(.'!)U%#:!NfbVZ!AD%P4!+0%!)U%#:!NVfbdV!AD%P!#:G($70!U3D:3#($!G#3$(3#%:$!-#!G6!<br />

)##(3#()#%!7'('(3'%!3'('=!!#:G($70!U3D:!0('%3'(!4!)U33D3D=!0('%!!-#!?!=!!AD5D!.#+@$.!<br />

#)$3:$.$(B! k!=!:! 0)'+!%'! '3!%'%! g! A(6G'! '$.! 5$-5$-3#()#! ='%'.! .D7D%#! AU(#! 5$%+$7#.!<br />

'7(!:!!7'@!3!@4!&#(!A(6@!$?$%!+#?$3#%!('+.A#3#!Vd[#%3#%:$! -#! '%'3$>!<br />

+0%6?3'(!! 9$%$.'G! $+.'.$+.$=! @'=#.! @(0A(':!%)'! 7'@!3:!.!(B! *'=.U(3#($%! 0(.'3':'3'(!!<br />

'('+!%)'=$! 1'(=3!3!=3'(! $?$%! $=$3$! ='(!3'.!(:'! 7U%.#:3#($%)#%! ;m*! 7U%.#:$!<br />

=633'%!3:!.!(! NcD>AD%#! -)B! VWf]PB! c#%#:#3#()#! #3)#! #)$3$@! ;(5+$%D+!<br />

.('%+10(:'+70%6! 67A63'%'%! -#! 67A63'%:'7'%! -#($3#()#=$! U%#:3$3$=3#(! G#%>#(!<br />

?!=.!!%)'%!+0%6?3'(!A#(?#=!-#($3#(!D>#($%)#%!-#($3:$.$(B!<br />

!<br />

:.+1!.)+$D7-67-+.!$$<br />

;('.!(:')'! #3)#! #)$3#%! =636?='! -#! G(0$3#(! @#(10(:'%+!73'! $3A$3$! -#($3#($%!<br />

)##(3#%)$($3:#+$!'7(!!'7(!!7'@!3:!4!+0%6?3'(!K'G30!&'3$%)#!U>#.3#%:$.$(!NK'G30!V!-#!<br />

dPB!<br />

!<br />

?+.1!)+$@&$"F,7_!<br />

K'G30! V#(#4! d! -#! V[! AD%! )#@03'%'%! 76:6(.'3'()'! ?!=!! AD5D!<br />

+!('+!73'4! tfZB]f! -#! t! ZfB^e! 03'('=! &#+'@3'%:!! -#! 6>6%! +D(#! )#@03':'%!%! ?!=!!<br />

! JJ


AD5D%D! 036:+6>! 7U%)#! #.=$3#)$$! G#3$(3#%:$.$(B! k!=!! AD5D%)#! :#7)'%'! A#3#%! G6!<br />

U%#:3$! 1'(=4! .D:! #:G($70! U3D:! )U%#:3#($%#! )#! 7'%+!:!! -#! d! AD%! )#@03'%'%!<br />

76:6(.'3'()'4!V[!AD%!)#@03'%'%!76:6(.'3'('!AU(#!)'&'!)DD=!#(=#%!)U%#:!NteB^f!<br />

-#!tVVB[^P4!0(.'!)U%#:!Nt[B]f!-#!tVBVdP!-#!+0%!)U%#:!#:G($70!0('%3'(!!Nt^BVV!-#!<br />

tZBe]P! #3)#! #)$3:$.$(B! 26! +0%6?3'(4! G6! =0%6)'=$! A#%#3! 3$.#('.D(! G$3)$($3#($! $3#! )#!<br />

676:36!03:6.6(B!<br />

!<br />

K'G30!VB!c#@03':'!+D(#+$!-#!=636?='!)'!?#-$(:#!+!=3!!%!%!=636?='!U>#33$=3#($!#.=$+$$<br />

c#@03':'!<br />

TD(#+$!<br />

k#-$(:#!<br />

T'7!+!!<br />

L(=#%!<br />

cU%#:!<br />

m3D:3#($!<br />

R(.'!<br />

cU%#:!<br />

m3D:3#(!<br />

T0%! cU%#:!<br />

m3D:3#($!!<br />

r! H'G66%6!<br />

H!(:!!<br />

k!=!!<br />

CD5D!<br />

CD%! ')#._AD%! t! t! t! t!<br />

c#@03':'!TD(#+$!M!k#-$(:#!T'7!+!! ! ! !<br />

d! dg! ZBZg! [B]]! ^BVg! feBdW!<br />

d! We! ^Bgd! [Bgg! ^B[f! ffBgf!<br />

V[! dg! VdB[]! VBV[! ZBW[! ZZB]e!<br />

V[! We! V[B[Z! VBVg! ZB[f! ZWBZe!<br />

TL9! ! [B^[V! [BVgZ! [BgWg! [Be^g!<br />

c#@03':'!TD(#+$!L.=$+$! ! ! ! !<br />

d! ! eB^f G ! [B]W G ! ^BVV G ! fZB]f ' !<br />

V[! ! VVB[^'!<br />

VBVd ' ! ZBe] ' ! ZfB^e G !<br />

TL9! ! [B]^g! [BV[g! [B]gW! [Bge]!<br />

k#-$(:#!T'7!+!!L.=$+$! ! ! ! !<br />

! dg! WBff ' ! [BZd! eB^d! fVBfd G !<br />

! We! ZBZg G ! [BZW! eBdd! fgBVd ' !<br />

! TL9! [B]^g! [BV[g! [B]gW! [Bge]!<br />

J! !<br />

c##(3#($!<br />

! ! ! !<br />

c#@03':'!TD(#+$! [B[[[! [B[[[! [B[[[! [B[[[!<br />

k#-$(:#!T'7!+!! [B[[[! [Bedf! [B^gV! [B[[V!<br />

c#@03':'! TD(#+$! !<br />

[BZdZ! [BfV^! [Bedg! [BfZf!<br />

k#-$(:#!T'7!+!!<br />

'G !;7%!!+D.6%)'!1'(=3!!&'(13#(3#!AU+.#($3#%!0(.'3':'3'(!'('+!%)'=$!1'(=3'(!$+.'.$+.$=!<br />

03'('=!U%#:3$)$(!NJz[B[^P!<br />

!<br />

C#3$$:! )U%#:$%)#! :'=$%#)#! We! ')#._AD%! ?#-($3#%! 76:6(.'3'()'4! dg! ')#._AD%!<br />

?#-($3#%3#(#!AU(#!#(=#%!)U%#:!#:G($70!U3D:!0('%!%!%!)'&'!)DD=!NtZBZg!-#!tWBffP4!<br />

?!=!! AD5D%D%! $+#! )'&'! 7D=+#=! NtfgBVd! -#! tfVBfdP! 03)66! G#3$(3#%:$.$(! NJz[B[^P!<br />

NK'G30!dPB!<br />

=$!-#!0%!AD%!)#@03'%'%!76:6(.'3'()'%!#3)#!#)$3#%!5$-5$-3#()#!$3=!AD%!5'%3!!'!(3!!!<br />

+!('+!73'! gfB]]A! -#! gWB]eA! 03'('=! G#3$(3#%:$! -#! $=$! A(6@! '('+!%)'! 1'(=! U%#:3$!<br />

G636%:6.6(B! ;%5'=! V[! AD%! 3#&$%#! 03'%! G6! 1'(=! VgB! AD%)#! #(+$%#! )U%:D4! )#%#:#!<br />

+0%6!03'%!]^B!AD%)#!$+#!d!AD%!)#@03'%'%!A(6@4!V[!AD%!)#@03'%'%3'('!AU(#!7'=3'!=!f^!<br />

A(':!)'&'!'!(!03:6.6(!NJz[B[^PB!X#:!)##(3#%)$(:#!+'7!+!!'?!+!%)'%!$+#!]^B!AD%)#!<br />

A(6@3'(!'('+!%)'!U%#:3$!G$(!1'(=!.#+@$.!#)$3:#:$.$(B!!<br />

!<br />

! JN


K'G30!dB!c#@03':'!+D(#+$!-#!=636?='!)'!?#-$(:#!+!=3!!%!%!G(0$3#(!@#(10(:'%+(!%'!<br />

#.=$+$!<br />

c#@03':'!<br />

TD(#+$!<br />

k#-$(:#!<br />

T'7!+!!<br />

3=! CD%!<br />

j'%3!!<br />

;!(3!!!<br />

VgB!CD%!<br />

j'%3!!<br />

;!(3!!!<br />

! JT<br />

]^B!CD%!<br />

j'%3!!<br />

;!(3!!!<br />

X#:!<br />

c##(3#%)$(<br />

:#!T'7!+!4!!<br />

VgB!CD%!<br />

X#:!<br />

c##(3#%)$(:<br />

#!T'7!+!4!!<br />

]^B!CD%!<br />

m3D:!<br />

R('%!!<br />

CD%! ')#._AD%! C! C! C! ! ! t!<br />

c#@03':'! TD(#+$! M! k#-$(:#!<br />

T'7!+!!<br />

! ! ! ! !<br />

d! dg! gfBd]! gd[B^! dBV]g! VBde[! VBgW]! !<br />

d! We! gfBgg! gdZBV! dBV[]! VBdWV! VBeVV! !<br />

V[! dg! gWBVZ! ]WZBd! dB[gW! VB]gd! VB^fg! !<br />

V[! We! gWB^^! gVVBf! dB[d[! VB]][! VB^fZ! !<br />

TL9! ! [B]Zg! gBeg! d]BZ! [B[dV! [B[]W! !<br />

c#@03':'!TD(#+$!L.=$+$! ! ! ! ! !<br />

d! ! gfB]] G ! gd]Bf ' ! dBVVf ' ! VBdZ^G!<br />

VB^^d! gBg!<br />

V[! ! gWB]e ' ! g[gB^G!<br />

dB[]g G ! VB]]e ' ! VB^f^! dB^!<br />

TL9! ! [Bde! ]Bdf! VeB^! [B[V^! [B[de! !<br />

k#-$(:#!T'7!+!!L.=$+$! ! ! ! ! ! !<br />

! dg! gfBZ[! g[fBf G ! dB[WV! VB][V! VB^]f! gBf!<br />

! We! gWB[[! gVWBg ' ! dB[eV! VB]V[! VB^WW! dBV!<br />

! TL9! [Bde! ]Bdf! VeB^! [B[V^! [B[de! !<br />

J!c##(3#($! ! ! ! ! ! !<br />

c#@03':'!TD(#+$! [B[[e! [B[[[! [B[[[! [B[[W! [B]f^! !<br />

k#-$(:#!T'7!+!! [BgdW! [B[dd! [BVWe! [Beg^! [BVdg! !<br />

c#@03':'! TD(#+$! M!<br />

k#-$(:#!T'7!+!!<br />

[Bf]V! ! ! ! ! !<br />

'G ! ;7%!! +D.6%)'! 1'(=3!! &'(13#(3#! AU+.#($3#%! 0(.'3':'3'(! '('+!%)'=$! 1'(=3'(! $+.'.$+.$=! 03'('=! U%#:3$)$(!<br />

NJz[B[^P!<br />

!<br />

L3)#! #)$3#%! +0%6?3'(!%! ;%0%7:06+! NVWfVP4! L3$G03! NVWWZP4! n$3$@06(NVWWfP4! ;.#!<br />

Nd[[gP4!26.5&#(!Nd[[gP4!-#!K0%'!#.B!'3B!Nd[[gP!.'('1!%)'%!-#($3#%!G$3A$3#(!$3#!676:36!<br />

03)664! Å6$%.'%'! "#) '0G! Nd[[[P! -#! "#$+! #.B! '3B! NVWWZP! .'('1!%)'%! -#($3#%! G$3A$3#($! $+#!<br />

)#+.#=3#:#)$$!AU(D3:#=.#)$(B!<br />

k#-$(:#! +!=3!!%!%4! )#%#:#! +0%6! 03'%! ]^B! AD%)#! G(0$3#(! 5'%3!! '!(3!!! -#! 7#:!<br />

)##(3#%)$(:#!+'7!+!!D>#($%#!U%#:3$!G$(!#.=$+$%$%!03:')!!!.#+@$.!#)$3:$.$(!NK'G30!dPB!<br />

C#%#3! 03'('=! )##(3#%)$($3)$$%)#4! d! AD%! )#@03'%'%! 76:6(.'3'()'! V[! AD%!<br />

)#@03'%'%3'('! AU(#! &#:! ?!=!! AD5D! &#:)#! G(0$3#(! @#(10(:'%+!! )'&'! 7D=+#=!<br />

G636%:6.6(B!C#3$$:!)U%#:$%)#!?#-$(:#!+!=3!!%!%!'(.!(!3:'+!!Ndg!')#._AD%!7#($%#!We!<br />

')#._AD%P!$+#!=636?='!@#(10(:'%+!%!!036:36!7U%)#!#.=$3#:$.$(B!!<br />

26!+0%6?3'('!AU(#!=636?='!-#!G(0$3#(!@#(10(:'%+3'(!%!%!)'&'!$7$!&'3#!A#.$($3#G$3:#+$!<br />

$?$%! $3A$3$! ?'3!:'3'('! )#-':! #)$3:#+$4! D>#($%)#! )'&'! '7(!%.!3!! ?'3!:'3'(! 7'@!3:'+!!<br />

A#(#=.$$! )DD%D3:#=.#)$(B! 2U73#5#! D(#.$:! :'3$7#.3#($! '>'3.!3'G$3#5#=! -#! A#3$:$!<br />

D3=#3#(!-#!G6!D3=#3#()#=$!1$(:'3'('!='(!!(#='G#.!AD5D:D>!'(..!(!3'G$3#5#=.$(B!<br />

$<br />

%+5,+A-+.$$<br />

;%0%7:06+B! VWfVB! EK&#! O%136#%5#!01! a#$A&.! '%)! T.0('A#! K$:#! 01! LAA+! 0%! *#(.$3.7! 2(0$3#(! a#$A&.! '%)!<br />

\'.5&'G$3$.7FB!L6($G($)!O%10(:'.$0%!n0Y!d[fB!<br />

;.#! jB! d[[gB! EH636?='3!=! X6:6(.'3'()'! c#@03':'! TD(#+$%$%! k!=!:! l':'%!! -#! 2(0$3#(! J#(10(:'%+!%'!<br />

L.=$+$4!;%='('!`%$-#(+$.#+$!*#%!2$3$:3#($!L%+.$.D+D!XD=+#=!i$+'%+!K#>$B!<br />

20Q3$%A4!wB!;B!'%)!\0Q'(.&4!2B!VWfVB!EK&#!L11#5.!01!LM@0+$%A!2(0$3#(!2(##)#(!LAA+!.0!\$A&!K#:@#('.6(#!<br />

2#10(#!T.0('A#!0%!\'.5&'G$3$.7!'%)!T6G+#S6#%.!J#(10(:'%5#!01!j&$5=+FB!J063.(7!T5$B4!e[h!d]]]bd]]eB!<br />

26.5&#(4! CB! d[[gB! EK#5%$S6#+! 10(! L:G(70bc$'A%0+$+! '%)! c#-#30@:#%.! 01! K&#! j&$5=#%! L:G(70F4! ;T;!<br />

j0%1#(#%5#4!w'%6'(7!d[[gB!<br />

cD>AD%#4!RB4!H#+$5$4!KB!-#!CD(GD>4!*B!VWf]B!E+.'.$+.$=!9#.0)3'(!FB!;%='('!`%$-#(+$.#+$!2'+!:#-$4!;%='('B!


L3$G034! RB! VWWZB! EH636?='! T0%6?3'(!%!! L.=$3#7#%! L.:#%3#(! -#! H636?='! ;=+'=3!=3'(!%!%! C$)#($3:#+$4!<br />

2#3$(3#%:#+$!`>#($%)#!;('.!(:'3'(FB!;%='('!`%$-#(+$.#+$!*#%!2$3$:3#($!L%+.$.D+D4!c0=.0('!K#>$B!<br />

n$33$@06(4!;B!\B!'%)!26.5&#(4!CB!cB!VWWfB!EL11#5.!01!*#(.$3#!LAA!T.0('A#!c6('.$0%!'%)!LAA!J0+$.$0%$%A!0%!<br />

\'.5&'G$3$.7!'%)!2(0$3#(!J#(10(:'%5#+FB!J063.(7!T5$#%5#4!ZZY!VdgB!<br />

Å6$%.'%'4!wB!;B4!T!3-'4!9B4!"6$>4!"B4!j'>'(#+4!"B!'%)!9#($%04!"B!d[[[B!EO%136#%5#!01!\'.5&$%A!LAA!T.0('A#!<br />

0%!\'.5&'G$3$.7!'%)!2(0$3#(!j&$5=#%!J#(10(:'%5#FB!a0(3)!J063.(7!j0%A(#++4!j'%')'B!<br />

"#$+4!iB!\B4!C':'4!KB!'%)!T0'(#+4!9BjB!VWWZB!EL11#5.+!!01!T&0(.!T.0('A#!j0%)$.$0%+!'%)!2(0$3#(!2(##)#(!<br />

;A#!!0%!\'.5&'G$3$.74!\'.5&$%A!K$:#!j&$5=!a#$A&.+FB!J063.(7!T5$B4!Zeh!Vg^WbVgeeB!<br />

K0%'4!HB4!R%'AG#+'%4!RB4!H#.#3'#(#4!2B4!c#567@#(#4!LB!'%)!2(6AA#:'%4!8B!d[[gB!EL11#5.+!01!;A#!01!2(0$3#(!<br />

2(##)#(+!'%)!LAA!T.0('A#!0%!LAA!Å6'3$.74!\'.5&'G$3$.74!j&$5=!Å6'3$.74!j&$5=!a#$A&.!!<br />

$<br />

$<br />

$<br />

$<br />

$<br />

$<br />

$<br />

$<br />

$<br />

! JW


" ##T $4-7'-+.+.+'!$%+,+1-!$b.O,$?(


.(')#!(#+.($5.$0%+!)6#!.0!&#'3.&!$++6#+B!a0(3)!R(A'%$>'.$0%!10(!;%$:'3!\#'3.&!NROLP!<br />

Q&$5&!$+!(#50A%$>#)!'+!.&#!011$5$'3!'6.&0($.7!(#3'.#)!Q$.&!$%.#(%'.$0%'3!5($.#($'!$%!.&#!<br />

'%$:'3! 0($A$%! @(0)65.+! )#.#(:$%#+! .&#! &#'3.&! '%)! Q#31'(#! +.'%)'()+! $%! .&#! '%$:'3!<br />

0($A$%!@(0)65.+!'%)!.&#!:$%$:6:!5($.#($'!(#S6$(#)!10(!.(')#!'%)!'550()$%A37!A$-#+!1(##!<br />

01!)$+#'+#!506%.(74!(#A$0%!'%)!+#5.$0%!+.'.6+B!"#3'.#)!Q$.&!.&$+!+.'.6+4!)#1$%$.$0%!01!.&#!<br />

(#A$0%! 0(! +#5.$0%4! )$+$%.#A('.$0%! 1(0:! )$+#'+#! ($+=+4! 5#(.$1$5'.$0%4! $%+@#5.$0%! '%)!<br />

50%.(03! 01! .&#:4! :0%$.0($%A! '5.$-$.$#+! 10(! 5'6+#! 01! )$+#'+#! 0(! )$+#'+#4! )$'A%0+$+!<br />

5'@'5$.7!'%)!('@$)!(#'5.$0%4!50%.(03!'%)!%0.$1$5'.$0%!5'@'5$.$#+!'(#!S6#+.$0%#)B!*(##!01!<br />

@063.(7! )$+#'+#+! )#53'('.$0%! )0#+! %0.! $%536)#! '%! $%.#(%'.$0%'3! '@@(0-'3! :#5&'%$+:h!<br />

506%.($#+! )#53'(#! .&#:+#3-#+! 1(##! 01! )$+#'+#! Q$.&$%! .&#! 50%.#M.! 01! ROL! +.'%)'()+B!<br />

\0Q#-#(!.&#!'55#@.'%5#!01!.&$+!1(##!01!)$+#'+#!)#@#%)+!0%!.&#!'@@(0-'3!01!.&#!1(##!01!<br />

)$+#'+#!)#53'('.$0%!G7!.&#!$:@0(.$%A!506%.(7B!R6(!506%.(7!+&063)!&'-#!.0!500@#('.#!<br />

Q$.&!.&#!9$%$+.(7!'%)!.&#!+#5.0(!+.'=#&03)#(+!$%!0()#(!.0!$:@(0-#!'%$:'3!Q#31'(#!'%)!<br />

$%.#(%'.$0%'3!+.'%)'()+!#+@#5$'337!50%+$)#($%A!.&#!#@$)#:$5!)$+#'+#+!'.!.&#!1$(+.!&'%)!<br />

$%! 0()#(! .0! #3$:$%'.#! $%.#(%'.$0%'3! .(')#! (#+.($5.$0%+! '%)! '55#3#('.#! $%.#A('.$0%! '%)!<br />

53'++$1$5'.$0%! @('5.$5#+B! R%! .&#! 0.&#(! &'%)! 9$%$+.(7! +&063)! &'-#! .0! +.'(.!<br />

(#A$0%'3$>'.$0%! @('5.$5#+! '%)! 3#')! 6@! .&#! @063.(7! .(')#! Q$.&$%! .&#! +50@#! 01! G$3'.#('3!<br />

-#.#($%'(7!'A(##:#%.+B!<br />

!<br />

>(.($<br />

2$3$%)$$! D>#(#! 636+3'('('+!! .$5'(#.! =6('33'(!! cD%7'! K$5'(#.! m(AD.D! .'('1!%)'%!<br />

G#3$(3#%:#=.#)$(B! cD%7'! K$5'(#.! m(AD.D! 636+3'('('+!! .$5'(#.$%! U%D%)#=$! #%A#33#($%!<br />

0(.')'%!='3)!(!3'('=4!.$5'(#.$%!+#(G#+.!G$(!#=$3)#!7'@!3:'+!%!!':'?3':'=.')!(B!;%5'=!<br />

&'7-'%+'3! -#! G$.=$+#3! D(D%3#($%! .$5'(#.$! =0%6+6%)'! cD%7'! K$5'(#.! m(AD.D! =6('33'(!!<br />

G#3$(3#(=#%!$+.$+%'$!03'('=!$3A$3$!636+3'('('+!!=6(6363'(!%!=($.#(3#($%$!='G63!#.:#=.#)$(B!<br />

26! ':'?3'! cD%7'! K$5'(#.! m(AD.D! &'7-'%! -#! &'7-'%+'3! D(D%! .$5'(#.$%)#! cD%7'!<br />

\'7-'%! T'3!!! K#=$3'.!! NROLP! =($.#(3#($%$! #+'+! '3:'=.')!(B! 26! =6('33'(!%! 7'%!!+!('!<br />

G'>!!D3=#3#(!$.&'3!#)#5#=3#($!D(D%3#(!$?$%!G$3$:+#3!=6('33'(!?#(?#-#+$%)#!03:'=!=0636!<br />

$3#!#=!.'3#@3#()#!G636%'G$3:#=.#)$(B!;7(!5'!636+3'('('+!!.$5'(#..#!D3=#3#($%!'('+!%)'=$!<br />

$=$3$!$3$=$3#()#!U%!@3'%'!?!=:'=.')!(B!<br />

H'%'.3!!D(D%!$&('5'.!%)'!#%A#33#($%!G'!%)'!;-$'%!$%136#%>'!-#!n#Q5'+.3#!&'+.'3!=3'(!!<br />

A#3:#=.#)$(B! 26%6%! 7'%!!+!('! A6:G0(04! +'3:0%#33'! #%1#=+$70%3'(!! A$G$! &'+.'3!=3'()'!<br />

.$5'(#.$%! U%D%#! #%A#3! 03'('=! ?!='G$3:#=.#)$(B! m(%#=! -#(:#=! A#(#=$(+#! ;-$'%!<br />

$%136#%>')'%! '($! D3=#3#($%! -#.#($%#(! 0.0($.#3#($! +U>! =0%6+6! &'+.'3!=! $3#! #%1#=.#!<br />

D3=#3#()#%! #-5$3! -#! 7'G'%$! ='%'.3!3'(! $3#! G$(! AD%3D=! 7'.'=$! ='%'.3!3'(!%4! )':!>3!=!<br />

76:6(.'3'(!%4!#-5$3!-#!7'G'%$!='%'.3!3'('!'$.!+#:#%$%4!#-5$3!-#!7'G'%$!='%'.3!3'(!%!.'>#!<br />

#.3#($%$%4!;-$'%! $%136#%>'! -$(6+6%6%! .':! 03'('=! $:&'! #)$3:#+$%$! +'3'7'5'=! #=$3)#!<br />

$3#%:#:$! 03'%! #-5$3! -#! 7'G'%$! ='%'.3!3'(!%! #.! D(D%3#($%$%4! &'7-'%! 7#:$! 7'! )'!<br />

#%)D+.($7#3!=633'%!:!$?$%!'7(!3:!!03'%!&'7-'%+'3!0($I$%3$!!N='%'.3!P!D(D%3#($%$%!)$(#=!<br />

-#7'! $%)$(#=.! 03'('=! $.&'3'.!%!! -#7'! =#%)$! .0@('=3'(!! D>#($%)#%! .('%+$.! A#?$$%$!<br />

7'+'=3'7'G$3$(3#(B! 26! +#G#@3#()#%! )03'7!! $&('5'.!%! A#(?#=3#:#+$! $?$%! &'+.'3!=3'()'%!<br />

'($!+.'.D+D%D%!='>'%!3:'+!!A#(#=:#=.#)$(B!<br />

\#(&'%A$! G$(! &'+.'3!=! $?$%! '($3$=! +.'.D+D%D%! %'+!3! ='>'%!3'5'!%!! cD%7'! \'7-'%!<br />

T'3!!! K#=$3'.!! NROLP! '?!=3'(B! cD%7'! \'7-'%! T'3!!! K#=$3'.!! NROLP! '@4! +!!(!<br />

-#G'+!4!2TL!-#!j0%.'A$0>!20-$%#!J3#6(0@%U:0%$!&'+.'3!=3'(!!$?$%!G$(!D3=#%$%!'($!036@!<br />

03':')!!%!! A#(#=3$! )#%#.$:! -#! +6(-#7! ?'3!:'3'(!%!! 7'@'('=! $3'%! #)#G$3$(B! ;%5'=!<br />

='%'.3!!&'+.'3!=3'(!!)'!)'&$3!03:'=!D>#(#!)$#(!.D:!&'+.'3!=3'()'!D3=#4!cD%7'!\'7-'%!<br />

T'3!!! K#=$3'.!%!%! NROLP! &'+.'3!=3'! $3A$3$! '($3$=! +.'.D+D! ='>'%!3:'+!! A#(#=3$3$=3#($%$!<br />

7#($%#! A#.$(#(#=! cD%7'! \'7-'%! T'3!!! K#=$3'.!%'! NROLP! &'+.'3!=.'%! '($! 03)66%6!<br />

! J]


G$3)$($(B! 26! )6(6:! AU>! U%D%#! '3!%)!!%)'! D3=#3#($%! AD-#%$(3$3$$%$%! U%! @3'%'!<br />

?!=:'=.')!(B!`3=#%$%!#11'13!!!-#!D3=#%$%!7'@.!!!('@0(3':'%!%!AD-#%$3$(3$3$$!GD7D=!<br />

U%#:!='>'%:'=.')!(B!<br />

,36+3'('('+!! .$5'(#..#! ?0=! U%#:3$! 03'%! '($3$=! +.'.D+D! G$(! D3=#%$%! .':':!%!!<br />

='@+'7'G$3#5#$!A$G$!G#3$(3#%#%!G$(!GU3A#7$!7'!)'!G#3$(3#%#%!G$(!GU3D:D!='@+'7'G$3$(B!!<br />

H6! A($G$! &'+.'3!!! $?$%! G$(! D3=#%$%! .':':!%!%! '($3$=! +.'.D+D! ='>'%:'+!4! cD%7'!<br />

\'7-'%! T'3!!! K#=$3'.!%!%! NROLP! H'('! \'7-'%3'(!! T'3!!! H0)6%6%! V[Bg! GU3D:D!<br />

'3.!%)'!7#(!'3'%!V[BgB]!-#!V[BgBg!D%5D!:'))#3#($%#!AU(#!03:'=.')!(B!H'('!\'7-'%3'(!!<br />

T'3!!!H0)6%6%!V[Bg!GU3D:D!'3.!%)'!7#(!'3'%!V[BgB]'%!3'5'!! G#3$(.$3:$.$(B! ! ;7(!5'! H'('! \'7-'%3'(!!<br />

T'3!!! H0)6%6%! V[Bg! GU3D:D! '3.!%)'! 7#(! '3'%! V[BgBg'!A$G$!7'G'%!&'7'.!%)'%!<br />

G63''%! G$(! &'+.'3!=! $?$%! D3=#%$%! .':':!%)'! '($3$=! =0%6:6%6%! #3)#! #)$3:#+$! -#!<br />

+D()D(D3:#+$! ?0=! >0(! G$(! )6(6:)6(B! 26! ':'?3'! .$5'(#.$%! +D()D(D3#G$3:#+$! $?$%! '($!<br />

GU3D:! -#! '($! GU3A#! ='-(':3'(!! cD%7'! \'7-'%! T'3!!! K#=$3'.!! NROLP! .'('1!%)'%!<br />

0(.'7'!=0%:6!-#!+U>!=0%6+6!='-(':3'(!!cD%7'!\'7-'%!T'3!!!K#=$3'.!!NROLP!H'('!<br />

\'7-'%3'(!!T'3!!!H0)6%6%!VB]B^B!%5$!GU3D:D%)#!'?!=3'%:!.!(B!!<br />

2$(!GU3A#!-#7'!GU3D:D%!'($!03'('=!.'%!:3'%:'+!!$?$%4!''!)'!+!('3'%'%!A#(#=3$3$=3#($%!<br />

67A63'%:'+!!A#(#=:#=.#)$(B!<br />

Vb! 2$(! GU3A#%$%! ='@+':!! -#! +!%!(3'(!4! 8#.#($%#(! \$>:#.3#($! 2$($:$! .'('1!%)'%4! )0'34!<br />

7'@'7! -#! 7'+'3! +!%!(3'(! .#:#3$%)#! G#3$(3#%:#3$! -#! (#+:$! ='%'33'(3'! &'3='!<br />

)676(63:'3!)!(B!<br />

db!2U3D:#!$3$=$%!A#(#=3$3$=3#(4!8#.#($%#(!\$>:#.3#($!2$($:$!.'('1!%)'%!G$70AD-#%3$=!<br />

7U%#.$:$! -#! 7#.$.$($5$3$=! 67A63':'3'(!! A$G$! $3A$3$! =.$.#(3#(! .#:#3$%)#! G#3$(3#%:#3$!<br />

-#!(#+:$!='%'33'(3'!&'3='!)676(63:'3!)!(B!<br />

]b! ;3.! @0@63'+70%3'(! ='@+':!%)'! 7#(! '3'%! &'7-'%3'(! -#! +D(D3#($%! %#.! G$(! #=$3)#!<br />

'?!=3'%:'+!!A#(#=$(B!8#.#($%#(!\$>:#.3#($!2$($:$4!'3.!@0@63'+70%6%!.'%!:3'%:'+!!<br />

-#! '3.! @0@63'+70%6%! +'3!=! )6(6:6%6%! .'%!%:'+!! -#! +D()D(D3:#+$! $?$%! '3!%'%!<br />

U%3#:3#($!'7(!%.!3!!03'('=!G#3A#3#%)$(:#3$)$(B!<br />

gb! 2$(! GU3A#%$%! -#7'! GU3D:D%! 1'(=3!! &'7-'%! +'3!!! )6(6:6%6%! =0(6%:'+!! $?$%!<br />

A#(#=#%! =0633'(4! +U>! =0%6+6! &'+.'3!'! 67A6%! 03:'3!! -#! &'+.'3!!%!<br />

#@$)#:$7030I$+$%#4! ?#-(#+#3! 1'=.U(3#(#4! G$70AD-#%3$=! 7U%#.$:$%#4! 7#.$.$($5$3$=!<br />

67A63':'3'(!%'4!=0%.(03!U%3#:3#($%#!-#!+6(-#73'%+'!)'7'%)!(!3:'3!)!(B!<br />

^b!2U73#5#!.'%!:3'%'%!GU3A#!-#!GU3D:3#(4!H'('!\'7-'%3'(!!T'3!!!H0)6%)'!G#3$(.$3#%!<br />

U%#($3#($%!67A63'%'G$3#5#$!'3.!@0@63'+70%3'(!!.#=$3!#)#(B!<br />

cD%7'! \'7-'%! T'3!!! K#=$3'.!! NROLP! H'('! \'7-'%3'(!! T'3!!! H0)6%'! AU(#!<br />

&'+.'3!=.'%!'($!G$(!GU3A#!036.6(63'G$3:#+$!$?$%4!+6(-#73'%+!-#!$>3#:#!?'3!:'3'(!!.#:#3!<br />

'3!%'('=4!G#3$(3$!G$(!&'+.'3!'!-#7'!&'+.'3!=3'(3'!$3$=$3$!1'(=3!!&'7-'%!+'3!!!)6(6:6%'!<br />

+'&$@!G$(!&'7-'%!@0@63'+70%6%6%!G636%)66!G$(!50('1$!'3'%!G#3$(3#%$(B!2#3$(3#%#%!G6!<br />

GU3A#!$?$%4!cD%7'!\'7-'%!T'3!!!K#=$3'.!!NROLP!H'('!\'7-'%3'(!!T'3!!!H0)6%)'!<br />

G#3$(.$3#%! U%3#:3#(#! 67A6%! 03'('=4! +U>! =0%6+6! GU3A#%$%4!D3=#!+!%!(3'(!! $?#($+$%)#! 7#(!<br />

'3'%!)$#(!GU3A#3#()#%!#@$)#:$7030I$=!'7(!:!%'!03'%'=!.'%!7'%!-#!67A63'%:'=.'!03'%!<br />

7'!)'!67A63'%'G$3#5#=!@(0+#)D(3#(!G#3$(3#%$(B!!<br />

R36.6(63'%! GU3A#%$%! @0.'%+$7#3! &'+.'3!=! ='7%'=3'(!%)'%! #@$)#:$7030I$=! 03'('=!<br />

'7(!3:'+!%)'%!+0%('!GU3A#%$%!)#%#.$:$!-#!=0%.(03D!A#(?#=3#.$($3$(B!26!?'3!:'3'(!$3#!<br />

G$(3$=.#!&'+.'3!=!#.=#%$!-#7'!&'+.'3!=3'(!7U%D%)#%!7'@!3'5'=!+6(-#7!?'3!:'3'(!!7'@!3!(B!<br />

! N#


X'@!3:'+!! A#(#=#%! +6(-#7! ?'3!:'3'(!! GU3A#)#! 7#(! '3'%! .D:! &#)#1! @0@63'+70%! $3#!<br />

GU3A#)#!7#(!'3'%!.D:!=D:#+!&'7-'%!! .D(3#($%$! ='@+':'3!)!(B! T6(-#7! ?'3!:'3'(!!=U7!<br />

='%'.3!3'(!! -#! .$5'($! $3#.:#3#()#! =3$%$=4! -$(030I$=! -#! +#(030I$=! 03'('=! 7D(D.D3D(B! TU>!<br />

=0%6+6! +6(-#7! ?'3!:'3'(!! $?$%! -#.#($%#(! .#&$+! &$>:#.3#($%$%! ='@'+$.#+$%$%! 7#.#(3$!<br />

03:'+!! A#(#=:#=.#)$(B! ;7(!5'! 036.6(63'%! GU3A#)#! &'+.'3!=3'('! &!>3!! G$(! #=$3)#!<br />

:D)'&'3#! #)$3#G$3:#+$! $?$%! '5$3! :D)'&'3#4! =0%.(03! -#! G$3)$($:! ='@'+$.#+$%$%!<br />

A#3$.$($3:#+$! A#(#=:#=.#)$(B! X6='(!)'! G'&+$! A#?#%! .D:! A#(#=3$3$=3#($%! 7#($%#!<br />

A#.$($3:#+$!-#!.D:!+0%6?3'(!%!67A6%!03:'+!!)6(6:6%)'!GU3A#%$%!'($3$$!$3'%!#)$3$(B!!<br />

,36+3'('('+!! .$5'(#.$%! +D()D(D3#G$3:#+$! ':'5!73'! 036.6(63'%! '($! GU3A#7#! '$.! .D:!<br />

G$3A$3#(! $&('5'.?!! D3=#! .'('1!%)'%! $.&'3'.! 7'@:'=! $+.#7#%! D3=#7#! +6%636(! -#!<br />

#@$)#:$7030I$=!03'('=!'7(!!G$(!GU3A#!03'('=!$3#:!AU(#G$3#5#$%$!'?!=3'(B!.&'3'.?!!D3=#4!<br />

$&('5'.?!! D3=#%$%! -#.#($%#(! &$>:#.3#($! G$($:$%#! $3$=$%! G$3A$3#($4! $&('5'.?!! D3=#!<br />

.'('1!%)'%! -#($3#%! G$3A$3#(! $3#! =#%)$! '('.!(:'3'(!! ='@+':!%)'! 7D(D.D3#%! ($+=!<br />

)##(3#%)$(:#+$%$%!+0%6?3'(!%!4!+U>!=0%6+6!&'+.'3!=3'(!'?!+!%)'%!=#%)$!&'7-'%!+'3!!!<br />

)6(6:6%6! -#! )$#(! $3A$3$! ROL! +.'%)'(.3'(!%!! AU>! U%D%)#! G636%)6('('=! G#3$(3#%#%!<br />

GU3A#%$%! '($! 03'('=! ='G63! #)$3$@! #)$3:#7#5#$%$! G#3$(3#(! -#! G6! )##(3#%)$(:#%$%!<br />

+0%656%6! $&('5'.?!! D3=#! $3#! @'73'!(B! R36.6(63'%! '($! GU3A#! =0%6+6%)'! $=$! D3=#!<br />

'('+!%)'!03'+!!AU(D!'7(!3!=3'(!%!%!?U>D:3#%:#+$!$?$%4!cD%7'!\'7-'%!T'3!!!K#=$3'.!!<br />

NROLP!'%3':'>3!=!?U>D:D!:#='%$>:'+!!A$G$!:#='%$>:'3'(!:#-56..6(B!<br />

,36+3'('('+!! .$5'(#.$%! +D()D(D3#G$3:#+$! ':'5!73'! cD%7'! \'7-'%! T'3!!! NROLP!<br />

.'('1!%)'%!0(.'7'!'.!3'%!G$(!)$#(!'($3$=!+.'.D+D!)#!GU3D:+#3!'($3$=.$(B!2U3D:+#3!'($3$=!<br />

036.6(:'=! $?$%! 0(.'=! G$(! G$70AD-#%3$=! +$+.#:$! ?'.!+!! '3.!%)'! G#3$(3$! &'+.'3!=3'(!<br />

7U%D%)#%!1'(=3!!&'7-'%!+'3!!!)6(6:6%'!+'&$@!03)66!.'%!:3'%'%!-#!$3A$3$!$(=#.!$3#!<br />

$&('5'.?!! D3=#%$%! 8#.#($%#(! \$>:#.3#($! 2$($:$! $3#! 0(.'=3''! 03'('=! +D()D(D3#G$3$(3$$%!<br />

+'3'%)!!!G$(!-#7'!)'&'!1'>3'!+'7!)'=$!$3#.:#!G#3$(3#%$(B!!<br />

8#.#($%#(! &$>:#.3#($! G$($:$! $(=#.! .'('1!%)'%! GU3D:! $?#($+$%)#! 7#(! '3'5'=! $3#.:#3#(!<br />

$?$%! &'>!(3'%'%! G$70AD-#%3$=! 7U%#.$:! =!3'-6>6%6! $%5#3#(! -#! )#%#.$:! '('5!3!!73'!<br />

G$70AD-#%3$=! 7U%#.$:! =!3'-6>6%6%! #.=$%! 67A63':'+!%!%! +0%656%)'! +U>! =0%6+6!<br />

$3#.:#3#($%4! (6.$%! $3#.:#! @(0+#)D(3#($%$%! .D:! '':'3'(!%)'! #@$)#:$7030I$=! 03'('=!<br />

='@'3!! 03:'+!! $3#! 67A63'%:'=.'! 03'%! +6(-#73'%+! -#! $>3#:#! @(0A(':!! $3#! &'+.'3!=3'(!<br />

7U%D%)#%!$3#.:#3#($%!&'+.'3!=.'%!'($3$=!)6(6:6%6!0(.'7'!=07'G$3$70(!03:'+!!)6(6:6!<br />

)0(63'%!(B! 8#.#($%#(! &$>:#.3#($! G$($:$4! H'('! \'7-'%3'(!! H0)6!=0%6+6!$(=#.$%4!636+3'('('+!!.$5'(#.!':'5!73'!#@$)#:$7030I$=!03'('=!'7(!!G$(!GU3D:!<br />

#=3$%)#!$3#:!AU(#G$3#5#$%$!'?!=3'(B!<br />

;($! G$(! GU3D:! 036.6(63'G$3:#+$! $?$%! A#(#=3$! 03'%! GU3D:D%! .'%!:3'%:'+!4! GU3D:D%!<br />

@0.'%+$7#3! #%1#=+$70%! ='7%'=3'(!%)'%! #@$)#:$7030I$=! 03'('=! '7(!3:'+!4! GU3D:D%!<br />

.'%!:3'%:'+!! G'=!:!%)'%! U%#:! .'!7'%! 1'=.U(3#($%! G#3A#3#%)$($3:#+$4! GU3D:D%!<br />

)#%#.3#%:#+$! -#! =0%.(03D4! &'+.'3!=! #.=#%$! -#7'! &'+.'3!=! $?$%! +6(-#73'%+4! .'%!!<br />

='@'+$.#+$4! '5$3! .#@=$4! =0%.(03! -#! G$3)$($:! ='@'+$.#+$! '(.3'(!%!%! 7#($%#! A#.$($3:#+$!<br />

A#(#=:#=.#)$(B!2U3D:D%!.'%!:!!7'@!3!(=#%!GU3D:!$?#($+$%#!'3!%'5'=!$3#.:#3#($%!0(.'=!<br />

G$(! G$70AD-#%3$=! ?'.!+!! '3.!%)'! 03:'+!! -#! #@$)#:$7030I$=! 03'('=! G$(G$($%#! G'3!! 03'%!<br />

$3#.:#3#(! 03:'+!! A#(#=:#=.#)$(B! 2U3D:D%! .'%!:3'%:'+!! $?$%! G#3$(3#7$5$! 1'=.U(3#($%!<br />

GD7D=! G$(! GU3D:D%D! #@$)#:$7030I$=! @'(':#.(#3#(! 036.6(6(B! 26! 1'=.U(3#(h! &'+.'3!!%!<br />

G63':'! 7033'(!4! &'+.'3!'! 7'='3'%:'%!%! U%3#%:#+$%#! 7U%#3$=! U%3#:3#(4! &'+.'3!'!<br />

U>AD! 1'=.U(3#(! -#! &'+.'3!=! #.=#%$%$%! 7'7!3:'+!%!! G#3$(3#7#%! ?#-(#+#3! 1'=.U(3#(! $3#!<br />

$3$=$3$)$(B!<br />

! N!


;($!G$(!GU3D:D%!@0.'%+$7#3!&'+.'3!=!='7%'=3'(!%)'%!#@$)#:$7030I$=!03'('=!'7(!3:'+!!<br />

$?$%$&'7-'%!+'3!!!=0(6%:'+!! ':'5!!$3#!A#(#=3$!G$70AD-#%3$=!U%3#:3#($%$%!'3!%:'+!!<br />

A#(#=:#=.#)$(B! TU>! =0%6+6! G$70AD-#%3$=! U%3#:3#($! '($! GU3D:! $?#($+$%)#! 7#(! '3'%!<br />

$3#.:#3#($%!$)'($4!.#=%$=!-#!G$70AD-#%3$=!$3#!$3A$3$!A#%#3!=6('33'(!%!!-#!GU3D:#!'$.!.D:!<br />

$3#.:#3#()#! -#! G6! $3#.:#3#(! '('+!%)'=$! $3$=$3#()#! &'7-'%! &'+.'3!=! -#! >'('(3!3'(!%!%!<br />

$3#.:#7#!A$($4!?!=!!-#!7'7!3:'+!%!!#%A#33#7$5$!.#)G$(3#($!$?#(:#3$)$(B!26!#%A#33#7$5$!<br />

.#)G$(3#(! G#3$(3#%$(=#%4! '($! GU3D:D%! 7'=!%!%)'! G636%'%! -#! ($+=! '3.!%)'=$! &'7-'%!<br />

@0@63'+70%3'(!%)'%! #@$)#:$7030I$=! 03'('=! '7(!3:'+!%!! +'3':'=! $?$%! 50('1$!<br />

1'=.U(3#($%!)#!AU>)#%!A#?$($3:#+$!A#(#=3$)$(B!!<br />

TU>! =0%6+6! 50('1$! 1'=.U(3#()#h! '($! GU3D:D%! 7'=!%!%)'! 7#(! '3'%! -#7'! GU3D:! $3#!<br />

=0%.(03! #)$3#:#7#%! #@$)#:$7030I$=! G'3'%.!3'(!! G636%'%! GU3A#3#($%! &'+.'3!=! -#!<br />

>'('(3!3'(! 7U%D%)#%! )6(6:64! #%! 7'=!%)'=$! +D(D3#($%! 7#(3#$:$4! GU3D:! $?#($+$%)#=$!<br />

.#+$+3#($%! )'&'! 1'>3'! ($+=! '3.!%)'=$! +D(D3#($%! &#:#%! 7'=!%!%)'! 7#(! '3!@! '3:')!!4! G6!<br />

.#+$+3#(! '('+!%)'! )0(6)'%! .#:'+!! -#! &'-'! 703673'! G63':'7!! U%3#7#5#=! G$(! .':@0%!<br />

GU3A#%$%!036@!03:')!!4!&'+.'3!=!#.=#%3#($%$%!?#-(#+#3!G63':'+!4!$=3$:!=0633'(!!A$G$!<br />

G$(?0=!1'=.U(!U%#:!.'!(B!!<br />

2U3D:! A#(#=3$3$$! $?$%! U%! =0633'()'%! G$($! )#4! A#?#(3$! G$(! $>3#%#G$3$(3$=! +$+.#:$%$%!<br />

67A63'%:'+!)!(B!2U3D:!$?#($+$%)#=$!&'7-'%3'(!%!.D:D4!A#?:$3#($%$%!)#%#.3#%:#+$%#!<br />

03'%'=! .'%!7'5'=! #=$3)#! .'%!:3'%:!! 03:'3!)!(B! `(#.$:! +$+.#:$%#! G'3!! 03'('=!<br />

.'%!:3':'!+D(D!)D>#7$%)#!7'@!3'G$3$(B!2U3D:!$?$%#!-#!)!!%'!A#(?#=3##%!.D:!&'7-'%!<br />

&'(#=#.3#($! (#+:$! -#.#($%#(! &$>:#.3#($! G$($:$! .'('1!%)'%! 0%'73'%:!! -#!<br />

G#3A#3#%)$($3:$! 03:'3!)!(B! 2U3D:D%! .'%!:3'%:'+!! '?!+!%)'%! U%#:! .'!7'%!<br />

1'=.U(3#()#%! G$($! 03'%! G#3A#3#%)$(:#! &'7-'%! &'(#=#.! G$3A$3#($4! +D(D! D(#.$:! ='7!.3'(!4!<br />

7#:! ='7%'=3'(!4! +6(-#73'%+! .#+.3#($%#! '$.! G$3A$3#(4! U3D:! ='7!.3'(!4! >$7'(#.?$! G$3A$3#($4!<br />

&'+.'3!=! A#?:$$4! .#)'-$! 67A63':'3'(!4! '!3':'! ='7!.3'(!4! G$70AD-#%3$=! 67A63':'!<br />

='7!.3'(!4! )D>#%3#%#%! #$.$:3#(#! '$.! ='7!.3'(!! ='@+':'3!)!(B! 2U3D:D%! )#%#.$:$! -#!<br />

=0%.(03D%)#! G$70AD-#%3$$%! -#! +6(-#73'%+!%! (#+:$! )#%#.$:$4! GU3D:3#%)$(:#%$%! #%!<br />

U%#:3$!U#3#($%)#%!G$($)$(B!;($!G$(!GU3D:D%!=0%6:6%6%!+D()D(D3:#+$!'?!+!%)'%!U%#:!<br />

.'!7'%! 1'=.U(3#($%! )#%#.$:$4! +#=.U(! -#! =':6! -#.#($%#(! &$>:#.3#($! G$($:3#($! '('+!%)'!<br />

=6(63'5'=!$G$(3$$!$3#!7D(D.D3:#3$)$(B!`3=#!$?$!-#!636+3'('('+!!.$5'(#.!=0%63'(!%)'!%$&'$!<br />

7#.=$4!(#+:$!-#.#($%#(!&$>:#.3#($!G$($:$%)#)$(B!<br />

;($! GU3D:! 036.6(:'=! -#! '($3$$%! )#-':!%!! +'3':'=! $?$%! 7'@!3'%! +6(-#73'%+! (#+:$!<br />

-#.#($%#(!&$>:#.3#($!G$($:$!.'('1!%)'%4!&'+.'3!=_#%1#=+$70%!-#($3#($%$%!.0@3'%:'+!%!!-#!<br />

'%'3$>! #)$3:#+$%$! ='@+'7'5'=! #=$3)#! 7D(D.D3D(B! T6(-#73'%+! +$+.#:$! &'+.'3!!%! #(=#%!<br />

)U%#:)#! +'@.'%:'+!! +'3'7'5'=! #=$3)#! )D>#%3#%:#3$)$(B! T6(-#73'%+! +$+.#:$%$%4!<br />

cD%7'! \'7-'%! T'3!!! K#=$3'.!! NROLP! H'('! \'7-'%3'(!! T'3!!! H0)6%)'! 7#(! '3'%!<br />

ET6(-#73'%+! $?$%! C#%#3! H!3'-6>3'(F! G'3!=3!! GU3D:#! -#! +U>! =0%6+6! &'+.'3!'! U>AD!<br />

+@#+$1$=!=!3'-6>3'('!67A6%!03:'+!!A#(#=$(B!X'@!3'5'=!+6(-#7!?'3!:'+!%)'4!D3=#!-#7'!<br />

GU3A#! ;-$'%! $%136#%>'! -#7'! n#Q5'+.3#! &'+.'3!!%)'%! '($! $+#! GU3D:! $?#($+$%)#=$! 7#(!<br />

'3'%!.D:!=D:#+3#()#%!e!'7)'!G$(!d[!='%!U(%#$%#!G'=!3!(B! ;($! GU3D:! $?#($+$%)#! 7#(!<br />

'3'%! $3#.:#! ;-$'%! $%136#%>'! -#7'! n#Q5'+.3#! &'+.'3!!! :$&('=!%)'%! )03'7!! &'(#=#.!<br />

+!%!(3':'3'(!!'3.!%)'!G636%'%!G$(!'3'%!$?#($+$%)#!7#(!'3!70(!$+#h!<br />

'P! 2U3D:)#! 7#(! '3'%! .D:! ='%'.3!! $3#.:#3#($%)#=$! =D:#+3#()#%! :$&('=!%!<br />

'()!%)'%! G$(! &'1.'! $?#($+$%)#h! '=.$1! +6(-#7! $?$%! ('+.A#3#! +#?$3#%! d[! ='%'.3!)'%! ='%!<br />

U(%#$4!'=.$1!-$(030I$=!+6(-#7!$?$%!d[!.('=#'3!-#7'!U>01'($%A$'3!+Q'G!U(%#$4!d[!=30'='3!<br />

+Q'G! U(%#$! -#! ##(! =D:#+.#! &'+.'! -#7'! U3D! &'7-'%! -'(! $+#! ^! ')#.! &'+.'! -#7'! U3D!<br />

&'7-'%!%6:6%#!03'('=!'3!%:'3!)!(B!26!%6:6%#!'3!:3'(!!D3=#!.#=('(!'($!03'%'!=')'(!#%!<br />

'>!dV!AD%)#!G$(!.#=('(3'%:'3!)!(B!<br />

! NC


GP!HD:#+3#()#=$!&'7-'%3'(!%!$3#.:#!-#.#($%#(!&#=$:3#($!.'('1!%)'%!&#(!AD%!<br />

=3$%$=!.'(':'7'!.'G$!.6.63:'+!%!!+'3'%:'3!)!(B!<br />

X'@!3'%! +6(-#7! ?'3!:'3'(!%)'! .#&$+.#! G$(! U(%#=3$3$$! +'3':'=! ':'5!73'! %6:6%#!<br />

'3:'4!.#&$+!7U%.#:3#($!-#!3'G0('.6'(!.#+.3#($!ROL!='3$.#!.#:$%'.!!+.'%)'(.3'(!%'!67A6%!<br />

03'('=!A#(?#=3#.$($3:#3$)$(B!TU>!=0%6+6!.#+.3#($!7'@'%!@#(+0%#3!#$.$3:#3$)$(B!<br />

;($!GU3D:!036.6(:'=!$?$%!A#(#=3$3$=3#()#%!G$(!)$#($!$+#!'5$3!.#@=$4!=0%.(03!-#!G$3)$($:!<br />

:#='%$>:'+!%!%! 036.6(63:'+!)!(B! 26! :#='%$>:'3'(! &'+.'3!!%! &!>3!! .#&$+$4!<br />

('@0(3':'+!!-#!G$3)$($:$4!&'+.'3!=!?!=!!%)'%!='7%'=3'%'%!($+=3#($%!#%!'>'!$%)$($3:#+$!<br />

'?!+!%)'%! GD7D=! U%#:! .'!(B! TU>! =0%6+6! :#='%$>:'3'(! GU3D:D%! 7'@!+!%'! 67A6%!<br />

03:'3!4!D(#.$5$3#($%!-#!?'3!'%3'(!%!G$3)$($:$!>0(6%36!&'+.'3!=3'()'%!-#!G6!&'+.'3!=3'(!%!<br />

G$3)$($:! @(0+#)D(3#($%)#%! &'G#()'(! 03:'+!%'! 03'%'=! +'3':'3!)!(B! T6(-#73'%+! .#+.$%$!<br />

7D(D.#%! 3'G0('.6'(3'(! $+#! &'+.'3!=! +0%6?3'(!%!%! (#+:$! 7#.=$3$3#($%#! &!>3!! G$3)$($:$%#!<br />

03'%'=!.'%!7'%!+$+.#:'.$=!@(0+#)D(3#(#!+'&$@!03:'3!)!(B!;($!GU3D:!036.6(63:'+!!$?$%!<br />

D3=#%$%! 7#.=$3$! 0.0($.#+$! .'('1!%)'%!&'>!(3'%'%! :#->6'.! ='@+':!%)'!(#+:$!=6(6:3'('!<br />

:D('5''.! #)$3#(#=! @(0+#)D(! G'3'.!3!(B! "#+:$! =6(6:! 036.6(63:'+!! U%AU(D3#%! '($!<br />

GU3D:!$?$%!-#($3#%!)0=D:'%3'(!!$%5#3#)$=.#%!+0%('!$3#.:#!)#%#.$:3#($!-#!+6(-#73'%+!<br />

?'3!:'3'(!!A#(?#=3#.$($3$(B!KD:!G6!'':'3'(!%!+0%6?3'(!%!%!67A6%!03:'+!!)6(6:6%)'!<br />

GU3D:! $>%$! -#($3#(#=! GU3D:#! '$.! G$3A$3#(! (#+:$! 0.0($.#! .'('1!%)'%! )676(636(B! .&'3'.!<br />

7'@:'=! $+.#7#%! D3=#7#! '($! GU3D:! $3#! $3A$3$! .D:! G$3A$3#(! +6%636(! &#(&'%A$! G$(!<br />

676:'>3!=! )6(6:6%)'! cD%7'! \'7-'%! T'3!!! K#=$3'.!! NROLP! 676:'>3!=! ?U>D:!<br />

:#='%$>:'+!%'!G'-6(63'G$3$(B!<br />

;($! GU3A#! -#7'! GU3D:! 036.6(:'=! `3=#! +!%!(3'(!! $?#($+$%)#! &'7-'%! +'3!!! )6(6:6!<br />

G$(G$($%)#%! 1'(=3!! '3.! @0@63'+70%3'(!%! 036.6(63:'+!%!! -#! +D()D(D3:#+$%$! +'3'7'('=!<br />

636+3'('('+!! .$5'(#.#! ='.=!! +'3'(B! ;($! GU3A#! 036.6(63:'+!%)'! )$=='.! #)$3#5#=! &6+6+4!<br />

G#3$(3#%#%! GU3A#)#! 7'@!3'5'=! )#%#.$:! -#! +6(-#73#($%! &'+.'3!'! )67'(3!! .D:! .D(3#()#!<br />

7'@!3:'+!!A#(#=.$$)$(B!;($!GU3D:!036.6(:')'!$+#!G#3$(3#%#%!$3#.:#3#()#!)#%#.$:!-#!<br />

+6(-#73#(!A#(?#=3#.$($3$(B!26!?#(?#-#)#!'($!GU3D:!036.6(:'=!'($!GU3A#!036.6(:'7'!<br />

AU(#! )'&'! =03'7! G$(! 7U%.#:)$(B! ;-(6@'! 2$(3$$! D7#! D3=#3#($%#! &'7-'%+'3! D(D%!<br />

$&('5'.!%!%! 7'@!3'G$3:#+$! $?$%4! ;-(6@'! H0:$+70%6! T'3!=! -#! KD=#.$5$3#(! C#%#3!<br />

9D)D(3DD!C!)'!-#!8#.#($%#(!R1$+$!.'('1!%)'%!$&('5'.!7'@:'=!$+.#7#%!D3=#)#!7'@!3'%!<br />

)#%#.$:3#($%!67A6%!03:'+!!A#(#=:#=.#)$(B!TU>!=0%6+6!)#%#.$:3#()#!D3=#%$%!:#->6'.!<br />

'3.!7'@!+!%!%!036@!03:')!!!-#!G6!:#->6'.3'(!%!;-(6@'!2$(3$$!9#->6'.!!$3#!676:36!<br />

036@!03:')!!!$%5#3#%:#=.#)$(B!;7(!5'!7'@!3'%!)#%#.$:3#()#!$&('5'.!7'@:'=!$+.#7#%!<br />

D3=#%$%! =6(6:+'3! '3.! 7'@!+!4! G6! 7'@!! ='@+':!%)'=$! #:$(b=0:6.'! >$%5$($4! )#%#.3#:#!<br />

:#='%$>:'3'(!! A$G$! G$(?0=! =0%6! '('.!(!3:'=.')!(B! `3=#%$%! &'7-'%! +'3!!! -#!<br />

&'+.'3!=3'(3'!:D5')#3#!+.('.#I$3#($!)#!=0%.(03!#)$3$(B!TU>!=0%6+6!$%5#3#:#3#($%!67A6%!<br />

03:'+!! )6(6:6%)'! D3=#! ;-(6@'! 2$(3$$%#! $&('5'.! 7'@:'7'! 7#.=$3$! D3=#3#(! '('+!%'!<br />

'3!%!(B!<br />

;7(!5'! ;-(6@'! 2$(3$$%#! $&('5'.! 7'@:'=! $+.#7#%! .#+$+3#(! ;-(6@'! 2$(3$$! )#%#.?$3#($!<br />

.'('1!%)'%!)#%#.3#%$(B!c#%#.3#:#!+0%6?3'(!%!%!67A6%!G636%:'+!!)6(6:6%)'!.#+$+3#(!)#!<br />

;-(6@'! 2$(3$$%#! $&('5'.! 7'@:'7'! 7#.=$3$! .#+$+3#(! '('+!%'! '3!%!(B! c$#(! D3=#3#(#!<br />

$&('5'.3'()'!$+#!$>3#%#%!@(0+#)D(#!G'='5'=!036(+'=4!$3=!03'('=!$.&'3'.?!!D3=#!.'('1!%)'%!<br />

D3=#:$>#! 7U%#3.$3#%! &'7-'%! +'3!!! )6(6:6! -#! -#.#($%#(! .#=$3'.! 7'@!+!%'! $3$=$%!<br />

+0(63'(!5#-'@3'%!(B!c'&'!+0%('!$.&'3'.?!!D3=#!7#.=$3$3#($!D3=#:$>#!)'-#.!#)$3#(#=4!+U>!<br />

=0%6+6! $&('5'.! $?$%! A#(#=3$! >$7'(#.3#(! A#(?#=3#.$($3$(B! T0%6?3'(!%! 67A6%! G636%:'+!!<br />

)6(6:6%)'! $&('?! #)$3#%! D(D%#! #3$=! #)#5#=! -#.#($%#(! +'3!=! +#(.$1$='+!! D>#($%)#!<br />

:6.'G!=! ='3!%'('=! $&('5'.! A#(?#=3#.$($3$(B! 2'='%3!!:!>h! `3=#:$>)#=$! &'7-'%!<br />

+'3!!%!%! =0(6%'('=! ?$1.3$=.#%! +01('7'! AD-#%3$! A!)'%!%! 63':'+!4! )03'7!+!73'! &'3=!<br />

! NH


+'3!%!%! =0(6%:'+!! -#! `3=#:$>! $&('5'.!%!%! #%A#33#! ='(!3':':'+!! $?$%! U%5#3$=3$!<br />

03'('=!&'7-'%!&'+.'3!=3'(!!$3#!:D5')#3#7$!U%!@3'%)'!.6.:'=.')!(B!!<br />

2'='%3!!:!>! &'7-'%! &'+.'3!=3'(!! -#! >'('(3!3'(!! $3#! :D5')#3#! 7#.=$+$%$4! [WB[fBVWWV!<br />

.'($&! -#! d[W^^! +'7!3!! "#+:$! C'>#.##(#! ]! 6G#!<br />

:D)D(3DD%)#%! 0366(B! C#%#3! 9D)D(3DD:D>5#! 67A63':'7'! =0%'%! &'7-'%!<br />

&'+.'3!=3'(!! $3#! :D5')#3#! @(0A(':!4! ! .'('! )D>#7$%)#! $+#! fV! $3)#! =6(636! 3!<br />

9D)D(3D=3#($%)#!-#!G6!$33#(#!G'3!!03'('=!fge!$3?#)#!=6(636!03'%!3?#!9D)D(3D=3#($%)#!<br />

AU(#-! 7'@'%! -#.#($%#(! &#=$:3#(! $3#! -#.#($%#(! +'3!=! .#=%$+7#%$b.#=%$=#($! .'('1!%)'%!<br />

7D(D.D3:#=.#)$(B!3!-#!$3?#!9D)D(3D=3#($%$%!AU(#-3#($!2'='%3!=!.'('1!%)'%!-#($3#%!.D:!<br />

.'3$:'.3'(!! 7#($%#! A#.$(:#=! -#! &'7-'%! &'+.'3!=3'(!%!%! #(')$='+70%64! :D5')#3#! -#!<br />

=0%.(03!&$>:#.3#($%)#!2'='%3!=!.'('1!%)'%!U%AU(D3#%!@(0A(':3'(!!67A63':'=.!(B!<br />

;7(!5'! 2'='%3!!:!>'! G'3!! 03'('=! AU(#-! 7'@'%4! 9#(=#>! L.3$=! N;%='('P4! ! 20(%0-'!<br />

N>:$(P4! ! J#%)$=! N+.'%G63P4! ! T':+6%4! H0%7'4! L3'>!4! L(>6(6:! -#! ;)'%'! 8#.#($%#(!<br />

H0%.(03! -#! ;('.!(:'! L%+.$.D+D! 03:'=! D>#(#! .0@3':! f! ')#.! L%+.$.D! 9D)D(3DD! $3#!<br />

;%='(')#! ;-$'%! $%136#%>'! -#! n#Q5'+.3#! &'+.'3!!! $?$%! 636+'3! (#1#('%+! 3'G0('.6'(!<br />

>:$(!%! 7D(D..DD! H'3!%.!! H0%.(03! J(0A(':!! ='@+':!%)'!<br />

7'@!3'%!&0(:0%!'%'3$>3#($!$3#!+'3:0%#33'!&'+.'3!!!$?$%!(#1#('%+!3'G0('.6'(!$+#!;%='('! L.3$=! 8#.#($%#(! H0%.(03! -#! ;('.!(:'! L%+.$.D+D!<br />

9D)D(3DD)D(B!!<br />

C#%#3!9D)D(3DD:D>5#!&'7-'%!&'+.'3!=3'(!!$3#!:D5')#3#!='@+':!%)'!$&G'(!!:#5G6($!<br />

&'7-'%!&'+.'3!=3'(!4!ddB[VBd[VV!.'($&!-#!dZfd]!+'7!3!!"#+:$!C'>#.#!03:'+!!%#)#%$73#!&'+.'3!=3'(!$&G'(!#)$3:#:#=.#)$(B!<br />

cD%7''!<br />

&'+.'3!!!D3=#:$>)#!$3=!03'('=![^!L=$:!d[[^!.'($&$%)#!2'3!=#+$(!3$!H!>!=+'!2#3)#+$%)#!<br />

! NJ


AU(D3:D.D(B!TU>!=0%6+6!:$&('=.'!V[BVgZ!')#.!='%'.3!!&'7-'%!$.3'1!#)$3#(#=!V[gBWfe!<br />

XKi!.'>:$%'.!U)#%:$.$(B!!d[[e!7!3!!$.$G'($73#!.0@3':!^g!$3!&'+.'3!=.'%!#.=$3#%:$.$(B!<br />

Vf! $3)#! ][! :#(=#>)#! 7'G'%$! =63'()'! G$(#7+#3! -'='3'('! ('+.3'%:!4! ! gf! $3)#! d[[!<br />

:#(=#>)#! =U7! .'-6=3'(!%)'! &'+.'3!=! :$&('=!! AU(D3:D.D(B! [VB[^Bd[[e! .'($&$%)#!<br />

&'+.'3!=! .':':#%! +0%'! #(:$! -#! )6(6:! cD%7'! \'7-'%! T'3!!! K#=$3'.!%'! NROLP!<br />

G$3)$($3:$.$(B!<br />

d[[Z! 7!3!%)'! c$7'(G'=!(! -#! 2'.:'%! $33#($%)#! .0@3':! VZ! 7#(3#$:! G$($:$%)#4! ! d[[f!<br />

7!3!%)'! $+#! l0%A63)'=4! T':+6%4! T'='(7'4! T$%0@! -#! L)$(%#! $33#($%)#! 03:'=! D>#(#!<br />

.0@3':!Z!-'='!AU(D3:D.D(B!9$&('=3'()'!7'@!3'%!#@$)#:$7030I$=!'('.!(:'!+0%656%)'!<br />

.D:! :$&('=3'(!%! '-5!3!=! =U=#%3$! 7'G'%! &'7'.!%)'%! G63':'! 03)66! .#+@$.! #)$3:$.$(B!<br />

L)$(%#! 3$! @+'3'! 3?#+$%)#! AU(D3#%! +0%! &'+.'3!=! :$&('=!%!%! VdB[gBd[[f! .'($&$%)#!<br />

+U%DD! 7'@!3:!.!(B! T0%! -'='%!%! +U%D! .'($&$%)#%! +0%('! ]! '7! 7'@!3'%! $>3#:#!<br />

?'3!:'3'(!%!%! '()!%)'%! ROL)#! &'+.'3!=! .#+@$.! #)$3:#:$.$(B! \'+.'3!=3'!<br />

:D5')#3#!;-(6@'!2$(3$$!:#->6'.!%'!676:36!03'('=!&'>!(3'%'%!-#!V[B[gBd[[f!.'($&!-#!<br />

defg]! +'7!3!! "#+:$! C'>#.#'! ;5$3! L73#:! J3'%!! d[V[! 7!3!%)'!<br />

XU%#.:#3$=! ?#(?#-#+$%)#!AD%5#33#:$! -#! 7'7!%3'%'%! 2'G'='%3!=! C#%#3A#+$! $3#! .D:!<br />

=':6!=6(6:!-#!=6(6363'(!%'!$3'%!#)$3:$.$(B!<br />

`3=#:$>)#! AU(D3#%! $3=! :$&('=.'%! +0%('! &'+.'3!=3'! :D5')#3#7$! #.=$%3#.$(:#=! -#!<br />

:D5')#3#7#! :'))$! ='7%'=! +'3':'=! ':'5!73'! $=$! @(0I#! &'>!(3'%'('=! )#-(#7#!<br />

+0=63:6.6(B! 26! @(0I#3#()#%! G$($%5$+$! ;-(6@'! 2$(3$$! )#+.#=3$! EH6! C($G$%#! H'(!!<br />

\'>!(3!=!-#!9D)'&'3#!?$%!K#=%$=!X'()!:!J(0I#+$F4!)$#($!$+#!cD%7'!2'%='+!!)#+.#=3$!<br />

EH6!C($G$!-#!%+'%'!K#+$(!L)#%!T'3A!%'!H'(!!\'>!(3!=!-#!9D5')#3#!J(0I#+$)$(BF!!<br />

;-(6@'!2$(3$$!)#+.#=3$!EH6!C($G$%#!H'(!!\'>!(3!=!-#!9D)'&'3#!?$%!K#=%$=!X'()!:!<br />

J(0I#+$F! ='@+':!%)'4! 3'G0('.6'(! '3.! 7'@!+!! A#3$.$($3:#+$4! &'+.'3!=3'! :D5')#3#! #)#%!<br />

@#(+0%#33#(#! #$.$:3#(! -#($3:#+$4! .'.G$='.3'(! 7'@!3:'+!! A$G$! G$(?0=! 1''3$7#.3#(!<br />

7D(D.D3:D!036@4!+U>!=0%6+6!@(0I#!d[[f!7!3!%)'!+0%3'%:!.!(B!\'3#%!)#-':!#.:#=.#!<br />

03'%!EcD%7'!2'%='+!!)#+.#=3$!EH6!C($G$!-#!%+'%'!K#+$(!L)#%!T'3A!%'!H'(!!\'>!(3!=!<br />

-#!9D5')#3#!J(0I#+$F!='@+':!%)'h!<br />

b! V[! ')#.! :$%$GD+! '3!:!! A#(?#=3#.$($3:$4! '('?3'(!%! G$3A$! GD1#+$! &'3$%#!<br />

)U%D.D(D3:#+$! ':'5!73'! .')$3'.3'(!! 7'@!3:!! f! ')#.! 8#.#($%#(! H0%.(03! -#! ;('.!(:'!<br />

L%+.$.D! 9D)D(3DD! =00()$%'+70%6%)'! +0(6:36=! '3'%3'(!%)'=$! 3! 9D)D(3D=3#($%)#!<br />

#$.$:!?'3!:'3'(!%!!+D()D(:#=!':'5!73'!)'!.!:!!7'@!3:!.!(B!<br />

b! HU7! .'-6=?6366%)'! ($+=! '>'3.:'! ?'3!:'3'(!! ='@+':!%)'! @$30.! $3! 03'('=!<br />

G#3$(3#%#%! 2'.:'%4! 2'3!=#+$(4! H'(+! -#! H0%7'! $33#($%)#! $=$#(! =U7)#! 03:'=! D>#(#!<br />

.0@3':! f! =U7)#! 7'=3'!=! g4[f^! :#.(#='(#! ='@'3!! '3'%'! +'&$@! ! ]^Z! ')#.! =D:#+!<br />

7'@!3:!.!(B!<br />

b!HD?D=!-#!0(.'!U3?#=3$!76:6(.'5!!-#!G(0$3#(!$3#.:#3#(!$?$%!G$70AD-#%3$=.#!($+=!<br />

'3A!3':'7!! $7$3#.$(:#=! $?$%! #$.$:3#(! )D>#3#%:$! -#! G6! #$.$:3#()#! d4]^e! =$$!<br />

#$.$3:$.$(B!<br />

b! EH':6076! 2$3$%5$%$%! ;(.!(!3:'+!! -#! H00()$%'+70%! c#+.#$F! '3.! G$3##%$!<br />

='@+':!%)'!$3#.$$:!A(6G6!.'('1!%)'%!&'>!(3'%'%!-#!&#)#1!A(6@3'('!N?056=3'(4!'-5!3'(4!<br />

$3#.:#3#(4!?$1.?$3#(4!=')!%3'(4!$&G'(!&'..!P!7U%#3$=!03'('=!e!'(!')#.!'1$!-#!G(0D(4!W!'(!<br />

! NN


')#.! (')70! -#! K8! +@0.6! $3#! G$(! ')#.! G#3A#+#3! 1$3:! G'+!:!! .':':3'%'('=! )'!.!:!!<br />

7'@!3:!.!(B!<br />

b! a#G! T$.#+$! K'+'(!:!! $?$%! 1$(:'! G'>3!! .'+'(!:! )'%!:'%3!=! &$>:#.$! +'.!%! '3!:!!<br />

7'@!3'('=!+U>3#:#!?#(?#-#+$%)#!QQQB=6+A($G$BA0-B.(!!$+$:3$!Q#G!+$.#+$!036.6(63'('=!<br />

'=.$1!&'3#!A#.$($3:$.$(B!<br />

b!d[[Z!7!3!%)'!H6!A($G$!&'+.'3!!!N;-$'%!$%136#%>'P!?#(?#-#+$%)#!7'@!3'%!$.3'1!-#!<br />

$:&'!$3#:3#($!='(!3!!!='%'.3!!7#.$.$($5$3#($%#!7'@!3'5'=!.'>:$%'.!U)#:#3#($%#!$3$=$%!<br />

03'('=! .'>:$%'.! U)#:#3#($! 67A63':'! .'3$:'.!! &'>!(3'%:!4! G6! ='@+':)'! 2'.:'%! -#!<br />

c$7'(G'=!(! $33#($%)#! 7'@!3'%! $.3'1! -#! $:&'! $3#:3#($4! d[[f! 7!3!! $?#($+$%)#! l0%A63)'=4!<br />

L3'>!4! T':+6%4! H05'#3$4! T'='(7'4! T$%0@! -#! L)$(%#! $33#($%)#! 7'@!3'%! $.3'1! -#! $:&'!<br />

$3#:3#($!%#.$5#+$%)#!.0@3':!.'>:$%'.!U)#:#+$!7'@!3:!.!(B!<br />

VB! J#(+0%#3! AD-#%3$$! $?$%! A#(#=3$! :'3>#:#3#(! N?$>:#4! #3)$-#%4! 5#(('&$! :'='+4!<br />

@#%+#.4! -#.#($%#(! ?'%.'+!4! .$GG$! '.!=! @0#.$4! .#=! =633'%!:3!=! .636:4! **Jb]! =0(67656!<br />

:'+=#4! A'30! ?$>:#4! AU>3D=P4! )#>#%1#=.'%4! g^[! ')#.! )#>#%1#=+$70%! U%5#+$! '('?3'(!%!<br />

.#:$>3$$%#!7U%#3$=!7D=+#=!G'+!%?3!!'('>$!.$@$!+06=!+636!7!=':'!:'=$%#+$4!$3'?3':'!<br />

:'=$%#+$4! %6:6%#! %'=$3! ='G!4! U3)D(:#! -#! .'!:'! =0%.#7%!(!! $3#! 3'G0('.6-'(!<br />

:'3>#:#3#($!'3!:3'(!!A#(?#=3#.$($3:$.$(B!<br />

!!!!!!b!,36+3'('('+!!H6!C($G$!H0%A(#+$4!^[!')#)$!7'G'%5!!03:'=!D>#(#!.0@3':!]^[!<br />

')#.!='.!3!:5!%!%!='.!3!:!!$3#!A#(?#=3#.$($3:$.$(B!TU>!=0%6+6!=0%A(#7#!'$.!+#+3$!='7!.!<br />

)U=D:3#($! )#$1(#3#($%$! %A$3$>5#! -#! KD(=?#! 03'('=! .#(5D:#! #..$(#(#=! )#(3#%:$! -#!<br />

H0%A(#!H$.'G!!03'('=!G'+.!(!3'('=!)'!.!:!!7'@!3:!.!(B!<br />

b! H6! A($G$! $3#! :D5')#3#! ?'3!:'3'(!%)'! $.3'1! #)$3#%! ='%'.3!! &'7-'%3'(!%! )'&'!<br />

AD-#%3$! -#! ?#-(#+#3! 03'('=!='G63! #)$3#G$3$(! G$(! #=$3)#! 70=! #)$3:#+$! ':'5!73'! f! ')#.!<br />

90G$3! X'=:'! *!(!%!! NO%5$%#('.0(P! +'.!%! '3!%!3'('=! f! 8#.#($%#(! H0%.(03! -#! ;('.!(:'!<br />

L%+.$.D!9D)D(3DD#.$:!='@'+$.#+$%$%!036.6(63:'+!!-#!7'G'%!&'7'.!%)'!<br />

+6(-#7! ?'3!:'3'(!%!%! 7'@!3'G$3:#+$! ':'5!73'! d! +#.! H6! X'='3':'! ;@'('.!! '3!:!!<br />

7'@!3:!.!(B!<br />

b! d[[W! 7!3!%)'! H0%7'4! d[V[! 7!3!%)'! \'.'7! -#! >:$(! $33#($%)#! C#(?#=! l':'%3!!<br />

;-$'%!%136#%>'!K'.G$='.3'(!!)D>#%3#%:$.$(B!<br />

b! L.3$=! N;%='('P4! J#%)$=! N+.'%G63P! -#! 20(%0-'! N>:$(P! 8#.#($%#(! H0%.(03! -#!<br />

;('.!(:'! L%+.$.D! 9D)D(3D=3#($%$%! ='%'.3!! 3'G0('.6'(3'(!%!%! G$70AD-#%3$=! D?!<br />

+#-$7#+$%#! N2Tib]P! 7D=+#3.$3:#+$! $?$%! $%''.! ?'3!:'3'(!! G$.$($3:$4! #=$@:'%! '3!:3'(!!<br />

7'@!3:'=.')!(B!<br />

b! H0%7'4! ;)'%'4! T':+6%! -#! L(>6(6:! 8#.#($%#(! H0%.(03! -#! ;('.!(:'! L%+.$.D!<br />

9D)D(3D=3#($! ='%'.3!! 3'G0('.6-'(3'(!%!%! G$70AD-#%3$=! $=$! +#-$7#+$%#! N2TibdP!<br />

+#-$7#+$%#!7D=+#3.$3:#+$!$?$%!$%''.!?'3!:'3'(!%!%!\'>$('%!d[VV!'7!%)'!.':':3'%:'+!!<br />

G#=3#%:#=.#)$(B!<br />

;7(!5'! 2'='%3!!:!>4! T'3!=!2'='%3!!!-#!,njL*! $3#! $G$(3$$! $?#($+$%)#! 7D(D.D3#%!<br />

EH6!C($G$!L$.$:!k'3!:'3'(!%)'F!.0@3':!Vg]Bf[[!#$.$5$!#$.$3:$.$(B!26!#$.$5$3#(!<br />

$+#!D3=#:$>)#!.0@3':!03'('=!dB^geB^eW!&#)#1!=$$7#!63':!.!(B!<br />

n#Q5'+.3#! &'+.'3!!! $+#! D3=#:$>)#! #%)#:$=! 03'('=! AU(D3:#=.#)$(B! TU>! =0%6+6!<br />

&'+.'3!=3'! :D5')#3#! ;-(6@'! 2$(3$$! :#->6'.!%'! 676:36! 03'('=! &'>!(3'%'%! -#!<br />

[gB[dBd[[W! .'($&! -#! dZV]V! +'7!3!! "#+:$! C'>#.#!]!=$30:#.(#!03'5'=!#=$3)#!<br />

! NT


G$(!=0(6:'!'3'%!4!=0(6:'!'3'%!%!!)'!$?#(#5#=!#=$3)#!:$&('=!#.('1!%)'!7'(!?'@!!#%!'>!<br />

V[! =$30:#.(#! 03'5'=! #=$3)#! G$(! AU>#.$:! '3'%!! 036.6(6(B! TU>! =0%6+6! GU3A#3#()#!<br />

=0()0%!='('%.$%'!.#)G$(3#($!'3!%:'=.'!&'7-'%!&'(#=#.3#($!=!+!.3'%'('=!#.=$%!.#:$>3$=!-#!<br />

)#>#%1#=+$70%!$3#:3#($!7'@!3:'=.')!(B!<br />

2'='%3!!:!>5'!='%'.3!!&'+.'3!=3'(!!$3#!:D5')#3#!#.:#=!':'5!73'!036.6()66!='%'.3!!<br />

-#($! .'G'%!! )#-(#7#! +0=63:6.6(B! TU>! =0%6+6! -#($! .'G'%!! 2'='%3!!:!>5'! .D:!<br />

&'7-'%5!3!=!$3#.:#3#($%$%!='7!.!#)$3:#+$4!&'+.'3!=!.'=$@3#($%$%!7'@!3:'+!!-#!GD7D=G'!<br />

&'7-'%! &'(#=#.3#($%$%! .'=$@! #)$3:#+$! ':'5!73'! =6(63'%! K,"H8LK! -#($! .'G'%!%'!<br />

#%.#A(#! #)$3:$.$(B! H'%'.3!! -#($! .'G'%!%)'! K,"H8LK! =0%6+6! 7U%#.:#3$=! dfB[]Bd[[W! .'($&! -#! dZVf]! +'7!3!! "#+:$!<br />

C'>#.#!(3'%'%!<br />

EH6! C($G$! -#_-#7'! n#Q5'+.3#! \'+.'3!!! 2U3D:3#%)$(:#! K'3$:'.!F! $+#! d^B[eBd[V[!<br />

.'($&$%)#!7'7!%3'%:!.!(B!TU>!=0%6+6!:#->6'.!='@+':!%)'!'($!G$(!GU3D:!036.6(:'=!<br />

$+.#7#%! 1$(:'! :#->6'.3'()'! G#3$(.$3#%! #-('=3'(!! &'>!(3'7'('=! G'3!! G636%)66! 3!<br />

9D)D(3DD%#! :D('5''.! #)#(B! 3! 9D)D(3DD! #-('=! $%5#3#:#+$%)#%! +0%('! $3#.:#3#($!<br />

)#%#.3#(! -#! +6(-#7! ?'3!:'3'(!%!! G'3'.!(B! 2D.D%! G6! ?'3!:'3'(!%! 67A6%! G636%:'+!!<br />

)6(6:6%)'! GU3D:! $>%$! C#%#3! 9D)D(3D=! .'('1!%)'%! -#($3#(#=! $3'%! #)$3$(B! ;7(!5'!<br />

2'='%3!!:!>!;-$'%!$%136#%>'!-#!n#Q5'+.3#!&'+.'3!!%)'%!'($!GU3A#3#(!036.6(:'=!$?$%!<br />

)#! A#(#=3$! ?'3!:'3'('! G'3':!.!(B! ;%5'=! D3=#:$>)#! %#Q5'+.3#! &'+.'3!!%!%! =U7!<br />

.'-6=3'(!%)'! #%)#:$=! 03'('=! AU(D3:#+$! 7'@!3'5'=! +6(-#7! ?'3!:'3'(!%)'! %#Q5'+.3#!<br />

&'+.'3!!! '?!+!%)'%! '($! GU3A#! 036.6(:':!>!! >0(3'.!('5'=.!(B! ;-$'%! $%136#%>'! -#!<br />

n#Q5'+.3#! &'+.'3!!! $?$%! 036.6(63'5'=! '($! GU3A#3#($%!G#3$(3#%:#+$%)#4! +#=.U(D%! .'3#@!<br />

#..$$! fV! $3$%! &#(! G$($%$%! '7(!! '($! G$(! GU3A#! 03:'+!! =0%6+6! 2'='%3!!:!>5'! 67A6%!<br />

)##(3#%)$($3:#:#=.#)$(B! kD%=D! 036.6(63'%! '($! GU3A#3#()#! &'7-'%! &'(#=#.3#($%$%!<br />

=0%.(03! #)$3:#+$! A#(#=:#=.#! 036@4! #%1#=.#! G$(! GU3A#)#%! '($! G$(! GU3A#7#! &'7-'%!<br />

&'(#=#.3#($! =!+!.3'%:'=.')!(B! 2U3A#! +'7!+!%!%! '(.:'+!! .D:! G6! =0%.(033#($!<br />

>0(3'.!(:'=.')!(B!<br />

2'='%3!!:!>!%!7'@.!!!.'+3'=!?'3!:'3'('!AU(#!+#=.U(D%!706%3'.!!!7#(3#()#!G$()#%!<br />

1'>3'! $3$! ='@+'7'5'=! #=$3)#! '($! GU3A#3#($%! 036.6(63:'+!! @3'%3'%:'=.')!(B! 26!<br />

=0%6)'=$! ?'3!:'3'(! 2'='%3!!:!>5'! )#-':! #.:#=.#)$(B! 2'='%3!!:!>!%! ='%'.3!!<br />

$&('5'.!%!%! '=+':':'+!! $?$%! 7'@.!!! G$(! )$#(! ?'3!:'! T'3:0%#33'! H0%.(03!<br />

J(0A(':!)!(B!d[[f!7!3!%)'%!G6!7'%'!&#(!7!3!)D>#%3$!03'('=!7'7!%3'%'%!@(0A(':!d[VV!<br />

7!3!%)'! )'! )#-':! #.:#=.#)$(B! d[VV! 7!3!! @(0A(':!%!%! \'>$('%! '7!%)'! G$.$($3:#+$!<br />

@3'%3'%:!.!(B! 2'='%3!!:!>5'! @(0A(':! +0%6?3'(!! ;-(6@'! 2$(3$$! A$G$! A#(#=3$!<br />

636+3'('('+!!=6(6363'(3'!@'73'!3:'=.')!(B!<br />

;-(6@'! 2$(3$$É! %#! ='%'.3!! #.$! -#! D(D%3#($! $&('5'.!! ='@+':!%)'! ;-(6@'! H0:$+70%6!<br />

T'3!=! -#! KD=#.$5$3#(! C#%#3! 9D)D(3DD! C!)'! -#! 8#.#($%#(! R1$+$! .'('1!%)'%!<br />

AU(#-3#%)$($3#%!:$+70%!&#7#.$4!VVbd]!H'+!:!d[[W!.'($&$%)#!`3=#:$>)#!$%5#3#:#3#()#!<br />

G636%:6.6(B! TU>! =0%6+6! $%5#3#:#3#()#! ;-(6@'! 2$(3$$! 6>:'%3'(!! .'('1!%)'%4! d[[Z!<br />

7!3!%)'! A#(?#=3#.$($3#%! )#%#.$:3#()#! .#+@$.! #)$3#%! +!&&$! =#+$:! @03$.$='+!%!%!<br />

036.6(63:'+!!':'5!73'!;-(6@'!2$(3$$!:#->6'.3'(!!$3#!676:36!03'('=!;-$'%!$%136#%>'!<br />

-#! n#Q5'+.3#! &'+.'3!=3'(!! $3#! :D5')#3#! 7U%#.:#3$=3#($%$%! 7'7!%3'%:!! 03)66! .#+@$.!<br />

#)$3:$.$(B!;7(!5'!;-(6@'!2$(3$$!6>:'%3'(!%5'4!G6!&'+.'3!=3'(!%!#(=#%!'':')'!.#+@$.$!<br />

! NW


$?$%! .$5'($! $3#.:#3#()#! AD%3D=! 7#:! -#! +6! .D=#.$:$! $3#! AD%3D=! 5'%3!!'!(3!=! '(.!!%!%!<br />

.6.63)66!-#!G6!&6+6+3'(!%!2'='%3!!:!>!7#.=$3$3#($%5#!)#%#.3#%)$$!AU(D3:D.D(B!<br />

d[[W! 7!3!%)'! A#(?#=3#.$($3#%! )#%#.$:3#(! +0%656! &'>!(3'%'%! ('@0()'! $+#! ;-$'%!<br />

$%136#%>'! -#! n#Q5'+.3#! &'+.'3!!! $3#! :D5')#3#! :#->6'.!%)'! &'+.'3!=! .'%!:3'(!%!%!<br />

7#.#(+$>!03)66!-#!&'+.'3!=!:$&('=3'(!%)'!.'('!.#=$3'.!%!%!:#->6'.!!#=+$=!67A63')!!!<br />

-#! =636?='&'%#! -#! )':!>3!=! $3#.:#3#($%)#! 7!3)'! $=$! )#1'! 7'@!3:'+!! A#(#=#%!<br />

)#%#.$:3#($%!)D>#%+$>!03)66!$1')#!#)$3:$.$(B!26!='@+':)'!*8R!:$+70%!&#7#.$%$%!<br />

('@0(6! )0(63.6+6%)'! ;-$'%! %136#%>'! -#! n#Q5'+.3#! :#->6'.!%)'! 7'@!3'5'=!<br />

)#$$=3$=3#(! AU(D#! '?!3:!! 036@! +U>! =0%6+6! :#->6'.3'(!%! d[VV! 7!3!! \'>$('%! '7!%'!<br />

=')'(! 7'7!%3'%:'+!! @3'%3'%:'=.')!(B! 9#->6'.3'(!%! #=+$=+$>! G$(! #=$3)#! 67A63'%:'+!!<br />

$?$%! 3! 9D)D(3D=3#($! .'3$:'.3'%)!(!3:!.!(B! H636?='&'%#! -#! )':!>3!=! $3#.:#3#($%$%!<br />

+'3!=! )#%#.$:3#($%$%! :#->6'..'! 7'@!3'%! )#$$=3$=! $3#! 7!3)'! $=$! =#>! 7'@!3:'+!!<br />

+'3'%:!.!(B! d[[W! 7!3!! :$+70%! ('@0(6%)'! L%+.$.D! 9D)D(3D=3#($%)#! =633'%!3'%! .#&$+!<br />

:#.0.3'(!%!%! .':':!%!%! '=(#)$.#! 03:')!!! G#3$(.$3:$! 036@4! ! ,36+'3! "#1#('%+!<br />

i'G0('.6'(!! 03'%! 20(%0-'! 8#.#($%#(! H0%.(03! -#! ;('.!(:'! L%+.$.D+D! 9D)D(3DD%D%!<br />

636+3'('('+!! ($%A! .#+.3#($%#! &#(! 7!3! ='.!3!:!! .'-+$7#! #)$3:$.$(B! "'@0(! ='@+':!%)'!<br />

'=(#)$.'+70%6! .':':3'%:':!! .#&$+! :#.0.3'(!%!%4! '=(#)$.'+70%! ?'3!:'3'(!!<br />

+D()D(D3:#=.#)$(B!;7(!5'!,36+'3!"#1#('%+!i'G0('.6'(!03'%!20(%0-'!8#.#($%#(!H0%.(03!<br />

-#! ;('.!(:'! L%+.$.D+D! 9D)D(3DD! 636+3'('('+!! ($%A! .#+.3#($%#! &#(! 7!3! ='.!3:'+!! $?$%!<br />

.'3$:'.3'%)!(!3:!.!(B!<br />

;7(!5'! ('@0()'! 7#(! '3'%! #73#:! @3'%3'(!! ?#(?#-#+$%)#4! KD(=$7#!(3'%'%!-#!ddB[VBd[VV!<br />

.'($&!-#!dZfd]!+'7!3!!"#+:$!C'>#.#!(3'%:!! 036@4! #%! =!+'! +D(#)#! 7'7!%3'%:'+!!<br />

@3'%3'%:'=.')!(B!L%.#A('+70%3'(!%!G$70AD-#%3$=!+#-$7#3#($%$%!)'&'!7D=+##!?#=$3:#+$!<br />

-#!=U7!='%'.3!3'(!%)'!G6!&'+.'3!!%!#%A#33#%:#+$!':'5!73'!2'='%3!!:!>! .#:+$35$3#($!<br />

$3#!U>#3!+#=.U(!.#:+$35$3#($%$%!='.!3!:!+'3')!!!.0@3'%.!3'(!7'@!3:!.!(B!!<br />

m>#3! +#=.U(#4! D(#.$:! 7'@'%! =D:#+3#()#! ?'3!'%! @#(+0%#33#(#! G$70AD-#%3$=! U%3#:3#($!<br />

&'==!%)'! #$.$:! -#($3:#+$! .'-+$7#! #)$3:$.$(B! 2'='%3!!:!>5'! &#(! 7!3! )D>#%3$! 03'('=!<br />

7'7!%3'%'%! -#! G6! 7!3)'! dgB[dBd[VV! .'($&$%)#! 7'7!%3'%'%! E\'7-'%! \'+.'3!=3'(!! $3#!<br />

9D5')#3#!C#%#3A#+$F!$3#!3!9D)D(3D=3#($!=D:#+3#($%!706%!03)66!GU3A#3#()#=$!=U7!<br />

='%'.3!3'(!%!%!U>#3!+#=.U(!$3#!$G$(3$$!$?#($+$%)#!'!3'%:'+!!-#!%#Q5'+.3#!&'+.'3!!!$?$%!<br />

1'(=!%)'3!!%! '(.!(!3:'+!! ':'5!73'! =U7! .'-6=?6366! 7'@'%! &'3='! -#! ='%'.3!! &'7-'%!<br />

7#.$.$($5$3#($%#4!76:6(.'5!!-#!#.?$!#%.#A('+70%3'('4!7'()!:5!!+'3!=!@#(+0%#33#($%#!-#!<br />

+#(G#+.!-#.#($%#(!&#=$:3#(#!&'+.'3!=!&'==!%)'!#$.$:!?'3!:'3'(!!7'@!3:'+!!&'==!%)'!<br />

.'3$:'.!-#($3:$.$(B!<br />

C!)'!-#!8#.#($%#(!R1$+$!N*8RP!.'('1!%)'%!&'>!(3'%'%!1$%'3!('@0(6%)'!#.!$3#.:#3#($!$3#!<br />

G(0$3#(!=D:#+3#(!-#!)':!>3!=b=636?='&'%#3#($%!)D>#%3$!03'('=!)#%#.3#%:#+$!A#(#=.$$!<br />

G#3$(.$3:$.$(B! 2'='%3!!:!>! ^WWe! +'7!3!! H'%6%! ='@+':!%)'! #.! $3#.:#3#($%)#! A#(#=3$!<br />

)#%#.$:3#($! 7'@:'=! D>#(#! (#+:$! -#.#($%#(! &#=$:! AU(#-3#%)$(:$.$(B! 2(0$3#(!<br />

=D:#+3#($%$%! )#%#.$:$! d[[e! 7!3!%)'%! G6! 7'%'! )D>#%3$! 03'('=4! 2'='%3!!:!>5'!<br />

7'7!%3'%'%! d[[ebV[! +'7!3!! C#%#3A#! ='@+':!%)'! 7'@!3:'=.')!(B! 26! ='@+':)'! d[V[!<br />

7!3!%)'!7'=3'!=!VV^[[!')#.!G(0$3#(!=D:#+$%$%!ZWZg!')#.$!)#%#.3#%:$.$(B!c':!>3!=!-#!<br />

=636?='&'%#3#($%!)#%#.$:3#($%$%!7'@!3:'+!!-#!+'3!=!+#(.$1$='3'(!%!%!e!'7)'!G$(!)D>#%3$!<br />

03'('=! -#($3:#+$! ':'5!73'! A#(#=3$! :#->6'.! )#$$=3$$! 7'@!3'('=! 3! 9D)D(3D=3#($!<br />

.'3$:'.3'%)!(!3:!.!(B! TU>! =0%6+6! ('@0(! ='@+':!%)'4! !+!3! $3#:$%! )0(6! G$(! #=$3)#!<br />

! NZ


67A63'%:'+!!-#!+'3!=! +#(.$1$='3'(!%!%! )D>AD%! )03)6(63:'+!! ':'5!73'! G6! AU(#-3#($!<br />

7D(D.#%!(#+:$!-#.#($%#(!&#=$:3#(#!#$.$:3#(!)D>#%3#%#5#=.$(B!;7(!5'!O+!3!$3#:$%!)0(6!<br />

G$(!#=$3)#!67A63'%)!!%!%!=0%.(03D!':'5!73'4!D(D%3#($%!:#(=#>!+!5'=3!=3'(!%!%!AD%)#!<br />

$=$!=#>!=0%.(03!#)$3:#+$4!!+!!=0%.(03!K'G303'($%$%!(#+:$!-#.#($%#(!.'('1!%)'%!$:>'3'%!@!<br />

='#3#%:#+$! -#! =633'%!3'%! .#(:0:#.(#3#($%! ='3$G('+70%6%6%! 7'@!3:'+!! -#! G6!<br />

&6+6+3'(!%!)#%#.$:$!$?$%!A#(#=3$!:#->6'.!)#$$=3$$!7'@!3'5'=.!(B!!<br />

T0%6?!03'('=!='%'.3!!#.$!-#!D(D%3#($%$%!$&('5'.!%)'!+0(6%!7''%:':'+!!$?$%4!n#Q5'+.3#!<br />

&'+.'3!!%!%! #(')$='+70%6! ':'5!73'! 2'='%3!!:!>! 6>:'%! @#(+0%#33#($! $3#! U>#3! +#=.U(!<br />

.#:+$35$3#($%$%! ='.!3!:!! $3#! &'+.'3!!%! 636+'3! =0%.(03! -#! #(')$='+70%! @3'%!%!%!<br />

&'>!(3'%:'+!!A#(#=:#=.#)$(B!\'+.'3!=3'!:D5')#3#)#!=633'%!3:'=!D>#(#!,36+'3!\'7-'%!<br />

\'+.'3!=3'(!! K'>:$%'.! *0%6%6%! &'>!(3'%'('=! )#-(#7#! +0=63:'+!! A#(#=:#=.#)$(B!!<br />

>3#%#G$3$(3$$%! +'3'%:'+!! :'=+')!73'! 036.6(63'%! -#($! .'G'%3'(!! U>#3! +#=.U(D%! )#!<br />

='.!3!:!! $3#! A#3$.$($3:#3$4! #$.$:4! G$3A$3#%)$(:#! -#! 1'(=!%)'3!!%! '(.!(!3:'+!!<br />

?'3!:'3'(!%'! )#-':! #)$3:#3$)$(B! X'@!3'%! $&('5'.3'()'! &'+.'3!=.'%! U.D(D! D3=#:$>#!<br />

=0%63'5'=! =!+!.3':'3'()'%! #.=$3#%:#:#=! $?$%4! ! ! U>#3! +#=.U(D%! '($! GU3D:! 036.6(:'!<br />

=0%6+6%)'!A$($$:3#($%$!'(.!(:'+!!A#(#=:#=.#)$(B!<br />

! N]


" ##W $D&5+9$B1$"&A1G.O,/&$2&@-&1$2&'1&A-($%.&/($4567-+)+-+.!$<br />

O.C"$&7"&#)/1,,.$#"8)6$"8%#+)%&)@.10#$()A"'#)*&81+#$()<br />

$<br />

\D+':#..$%!CD3&'%4!96('.!H'('!<br />

l$(''.!2'%='+!!<br />

$<br />

89&1$<br />

VZ! D3=#)#! Ze! &$>:#.! %0=.'+!73'! 1''3$7#.! AU+.#(#%4! V^V! 9$37'(! Ki! '=.$1! -'(3!!4! Vd^!<br />

9$37'(! Ki! :#-)6'.! &'5:$4! VB]fZ! 6G#! +'7!+!! -#! ^e! 9$37'(! Ki'(3':'! H(#)$+$!<br />

-GBF! .'(!:+'3! =(#)$! D(D%3#($73#! 0(.'! 6>6%! -')#3$4! )DD=! 1'$>3$! 1$%'%+'3! ?U>D:3#(3#h!<br />

$3#.:#3#($%!G$($:!:'3$7#.3#($%$%!'>'3.!3:'+!%!4!='(3!3!=!-#!-#($:3$3$$%$%!'(.!(!3:'+!%!!<br />

+'3'7'('=4! +#=.U(D%! $?! -#! )!! @$7'+'3'()'! )'&'! #.=$%! G$(! (03! D+.3#%:#+$%#! )#+.#=!<br />

03:'=.')!(B!!<br />

!<br />

:;'1.+#($%)#!1'(=3!!D(#.$:!=0%6+6%)'!df!?#$.!.'(!:+'3!=(#)$!D(D%D!$3#!7'.!(!:!-#!$3#.:#!<br />

A$)#(3#($%$%! 1$%'%+:'%!%)'! A#(?#=! -#! .D>#3! =$$! .'(!:+'3! D(#.$5$3#($:$>$%! &#(! >':'%!<br />

7'%!%)')!(B!!<br />

!<br />

! T#


I(.++1$D+,A+'!f,!,$"&A1G.&$`G,&-(A$?+.!)'+-$%.&/($b.O,-&.($<br />

H'%'.3!! +#=.U(D%D%! ='@'+$.#! '(.!(!:!4! :0)#(%$>'+70%4! 7#%$! =6(636:! A$G$! 7'.!(!:'!<br />

7U%#3$=! 1$%'%+'3! $&.$7'?3'(!%!%! 7'%!! +!('4! $3#.:#! +#(:'7#+$! $&.$7'?3'(!%!%!<br />

='(!3'%:'+!%)'! )'! l$(''.! 2'%='+!4! +6%)66! 0(.'! 6>6%! -')#3$4! )DD=! 1'$>3$! 1$%'%+'3!<br />

?U>D:3#(3#h! $3#.:#3#($%! G$($:! :'3$7#.3#($%$%! '>'3.!3:'+!%!4! ='(3!3!=! -#! -#($:3$3$$%$%!<br />

'(.!(!3:'+!%!!+'3'7'('=4!+#=.U(D%!$?!-#!)!!@$7'+'3'()'!)'&'!#.=$%!G$(!(03!D+.3#%:#+$%#!<br />

)#+.#=! 03:'=.')!(B! c$#(! .'('1.'%4! D(#.$5$3#($%! 1$%'%+:'%! $&.$7'?3'(!%!%! 67A6%!<br />

=0633'(3'! ='(!3'%'G$3:#+$%$! .#:$%#%! $3A$3$! H'('(%':#3#(! ='@+':!%)'!d[[g!7!3!%)'%!<br />

G6! 7'%'! .'(!:+'3! D(#.$:#! 7U%#3$=! 7'.!(!:!-#!$3#.:#! =(#)$3#($%#! 'O;@+,'(5F,$<br />

P(,/(.()-($ K+(9S! 67A63'%:'=.'! -#! ='%'.3!! +#=.U(D%#! )#! U%#:3$! G$(! 1'$>! )#+.#$!<br />

+'3'%:'=.')!(B!!<br />

!="O;@+,'(5F,-7$%.&/(-&.$<br />

l$(''.!2'%='+!$C#!!$`!-!$"O;@+,'(5F,-7$%.&/($4567-+)+-+.!,!4$.'(!:+'3!=(#)$!5'($!<br />

6+63!-#!:#->6'.!!)'&$3$%)#!=(#)$!=633'%)!(!:!'(.3'(!%'!67'%!A#(?#=!-#!.D>#3!=$$3#(#4!<br />

d[VV_Vdg[! T'7!3!! 2'='%3'(! H6(636! H'('(!! -#! dZfZd! T'7!3!! K#G3$! ='@+':!%)'!<br />

[VB[VBd[VV!-#!]VBVdBd[VV!.'($&3#($!'('+!%)'!$3#.:#!-#!7'.!(!:!=(#)$+$!=633'%)!('('=!<br />

7D(D.:#=.#)$(B!<br />

d[VV! X!3!! +DG-'%+$70%36! =(#)$! 67A63':'3'(!! )'&$3$%)#4! ='%'.3!! +#=.U(D%#! 7U%#3$=!<br />

''!)'! )#.'73'(!! +6%63'%! '(.3'(3'! $3#.:#! -#_-#7'! 7'.!(!:! =(#)$+$! =633'%)!(!3'5'=!<br />

D(#.$5$3#(#4! 2'%='! 5'($! .'(!:+'3! =(#)$! 1'$>! 0('%!! D>#($%)#%! gN#$ F.+,!,/+$<br />

'O;@+,'(5F,$ PK+(9$ (,/(.()(S! 67A63'%'('=! 5!--!A$ gN$ K+(9$ F.+,!$ (-&! .'(!:+'3! =(#)$!<br />

=633'%)!(!3'G$3:#=.#)$(B!<br />

T#=.U(#! 7U%#3$=! +DG-'%+$70%36! .'(!:+'3! =(#)$! 67A63':'3'(!%)'4! #.! .'-664! 76:6(.'!<br />

.'-664!&$%)$4!='>4!U()#=!-#!G!3)!(5!%!$3#!$3A$3$!)':!>3!=!-#_-#7'!.$5'($!D(#.$:!7'@'5'=!<br />

$3#.:#3#(#h!!<br />

! L.3$=!@$3$?!7#.$.$($5$3$$%)#! !!!!!!!!!! ! V[B[[[!')#.!<br />

! X6:6(.'!.'-66!7#.$.$($5$3$$%)#!! ! ^B[[[!')#.!<br />

! \$%)$!7#.$.$($5$3$$%)#! !!!!!!!!!!!! ! dB^[[!')#.!<br />

! m()#=4!H'>4!2!3)!(5!%!7#.$.$($5$3$$%)#!!! dB[[[!')#.!<br />

-#! D>#($%)#! ='@'+$.#7#! +'&$@! $3#.:#3#(#! =!+'! -#! 6>6%! -')#3$! =(#)$! $:='%3'(!!<br />

+6%63:'=.'!036@4!!=N##=###=E?X3!=!$3#.:#!<br />

-#_-#7'!=636?='&'%#3#()#%!76:6(.'4!5$-5$-!-#_-#7'!7'(='!'3!:!4!7#:!'3!:!!-#!)$#(!<br />

$3#.:#! A$)#(3#($%$%! 1$%'%+:'%!! ':'5!73'! +9+)($ CJ$ +5$ @+/&-(! $3#.:#! =(#)$+$!<br />

=633'%)!(!3:'=.')!(B$<br />

l$(''.! 2'%='+!4!='%'.3!! +#=.U(D%#! 7U%#3$=! $3#.:#! =(#)$3#($%$! ED++AA+.1F! D(D%D! $3#!<br />

$3$=$3#%)$(#(#=! =633'%'%! D(#.$5$3#(#4! 2''=='(.! $3#! '%3':'3!! $7#(3#($%)#%! 5$-5$-4!<br />

7'(='4! 7#:4! -#.#($%#(3$=! &$>:#.3#($! A$G$! .'(!:+'3! A$()$3#($! QN$ +5$ K+(9'(9R$ h$ :'>0.! -#!<br />

:')#%$! 7'!!ET$ +5$ K+(9'(9R$ #)$%:#! $:=Ñ%!! +6%:'=.'4! G#3$(.$3#%! +D(#3#($%! +0%6%)'!<br />

! T!


.'&+$3! #)$3#:#7#%! .6.'(3'(! $?$%! t^[! 1'$>! +DG-'%+$70%6! $3#! .'(!:+'3! =(#)$! &#+'G!!<br />

'=.$13#.$($3:#=.#)$(B!<br />

!<br />

C=$"G9-&)&-($b.&1()$%.&/(-&.($<br />

H'%'.3!! +#=.U(D%)#! +U>3#:#3$! D(#.$:! :0)#3$! $3#! D(#.$:! 7'@'%! 1$(:'3'('! -#7'!<br />

+U>3#:#3$! D(#.$5$3#($%#! )#! +DG-'%+$70%36! $3#.:#! -#_-#7'! 7'.!(!:! =(#)$+$!<br />

=633'%)!(!3'G$3:#=.#)$(B! 26! ='@+':)'4! 1$(:'! $3#! 2'%='! '('+!%)'! =(#)$3#%)$(:#!<br />

=0633'(!%!!G#3$(3#7#%!G$(!@(0.0=03D%!$:>'3'%:'+!!A#(#=:#=.#)$(B!!<br />

$<br />

H=$-&1)&$B/(,/(.)&$%.&/('($<br />

`>#($%)#! ='%'.3!! +#=.U(D%#! 7U%#3$=! =6(636! G$(! .#+$+! G636%'%! $3#.:#3#($%!<br />

#)$%)$($3:#+$%#! 7U%#3$=! 03'('=! +9+)($ W$ 5!-$ @+/&! $3#! E3#.:#! L)$%)$(:#! H(#)$+$F!<br />

=633'%)!(!3'G$3:#=.#)$(B!H(#)$!$3#!#)$%)$($3#5#=!$3#.:#3#()#h!<br />

! K'(!:+'3!D(#.$:$%!7'@!3!70(_7'@!3'5'=!03:'+!4!!<br />

! T'.!5!_+'.!5!3'(!%!:D3=$7#.$%)#!G636%:'+!4!!<br />

! K'@6)'!='7!.3!!036@4!5$%+!.'+&$&$%$%!7'@!3:!!03:'+!4!!<br />

! `>#($%)#!&#(&'%A$!G$(!'%3':'>3!=!7'!)'!.'=7$)'.!G636%:':'+!!!<br />

'(.3'(!!'('%!(B!!<br />

!<br />

J=$L+'+1$@&$V+9+.-+)+$%.&/(-&.($<br />

`(D%! #3)#! #.:#! )U%#:$! U%5#+$! -#7'! +0%('+!%)'! =!+'! +D(#3$! %'=$.! $&.$7'5!! G636%'%!<br />

$3#.:#3#($%!@'>'(3':'!A$)#(3#($%$%!1$%'%+:'%!!':'5!73'!+9+)($T$+5$@+/&$(-&$QL+'+1$<br />

@&$V+9+.-+)+$%.&/('(R$=633'%)!(!3'G$3:#=.#)$(B!<br />

!<br />

;7(!5'4! l$(''.! 2'%='+!! +#=.U(D%! .$5'($_G$(#7+#3! )$#(! .D:! G'%='5!3!=!<br />

D(D%_&$>:#.3#($%)#!)#!67A6%!-')#!-#!1'$>!+#?#%#=3#($!$3#!7'%!%)')!(B!<br />

!<br />

H(#)$! .'3#@3#($4! D(#.$5$3#($:$>$%! .'(!:+'3! $3#.:#3#($%$%_$(=#.!<br />

:#(=#>3#($%$%_$=':#.A'&3'(!%!%! G636%)66! 7#()#=$! l$(''.! 2'%='+!! 6G#3#($%5#!<br />

)##(3#%)$($3:#=.#)$(B!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

! TC


" ##Z $"&A1G./&$4567-+,+,$`G,&1)&-(A-&.$@&$:D$457)7$U&._&@&'(,/&$$<br />

%+.!-+!-+,$V.F;-&)-&.$<br />

J,,0%"8)?"210'#%.&+)L.$)@.10#$()A"'#)*&81+#$()'&8)@$.90"7+)5'-"8)#.)<br />

M'$7.&%>'#%.&)@"$%.8)#.)K1$.,"'&)P&%.&)<br />

!<br />

k$)#:!H!>!3'7!H'('036 ' 4!"':'>'%!k'=!( G!<br />

' 2'%-$.!;BB!HC!c$(#=.U(D!<br />

G 2'%-$.!;BB!HB!L.!c$(#=.U(D!<br />

!<br />

89&1$$<br />

H'%'.3!! +#=.U(D! d[[[! 7!3!%)'%! G6AD%#! ;-(6@'! 2$(3$$! :#->6'.!! ?#(?#-#+$%)#!<br />

?'3!:'3'(! 7'@'%! -#! G6! :#->6'.'! 67A6%! D(#.$:$! ':'?! #)$%:$4! D3=#:$>! $3=! A!)'!<br />

+#=.U(3#($%)#%!G$($+$)$(BCD%D:D>)#!D3=#:$>!7U%#.:#3$=!-#!:#->6'.3'(!%!%!)'!;2!x%#!<br />

676:6!?#(?#-#+$%)#!!A#3$.$($3:#+$!A#(#=3$)$(B!E9$=(0G$7030I$=!=($.#(3#(!.#G3$$F!4!EL.!<br />

D(D%3#($!.#G3$$!E-#!.'+3'=!03'('=!7'7!%3'%:!!03'%!E\'7-'%+'3!A!)'3'(!$?$%!U>#3!&$I7#%!<br />

=6('33'(!! 7U%#.:#3$$F%)#! #3#! '3!%:'+!! A#(#=3$! 03'%! U%#:3$! =0%63'(!<br />

:#-56..6(Ni$+.#($'u+'3:0%#33'! G'=.#($+$! =($.#($h! :'($%'+70%36! D(D%3#(! -#! 9TL! $3#!<br />

$3A$33$! 67A63':'3'(! -GPB! XU%#.:#3$=! -#! .#G3$3#($:$>$%! 7#%$! C!)'! X'+'+!! $3#! G#('G#(!<br />

(#-$>70%6%)'! +#=.U(D%! AU(D! -#! U%#($3#($%! )#! )$=='.#! '3!%:'+!! +#=.U(D%! U%D%D%!<br />

'?!3:'+!!-#!;2!D3=#3#($73#!(#='G#.!#)$3#G$3:#+$!'?!+!%)'%!U%#:!.'!:'=.')!(B!<br />

!<br />

:;'1.+'.$0%! 50)#! 01! .&#!<br />

L6(0@#'%!,%$0%B!K&#(#!'(#!$:@0(.'%.!+6GI#5.+!.&'.!'(#!%#5#++'(7!.0!G#!50%+$)#(#)!$%!<br />

)#53'('.$0%+! 01! E9$5(0G$030A$5'3! 5($.#($'F4! E9#'.! @(0)65.+F! '%)! $%! .&#! (#A63'.$0%! 01!<br />

ET@#5$1$5! &7A$#%#! (63#+! 10(! '%$:'3! 0($A$%'.#)! 100)+F! Q&$5&! &'+! G##%! @6G3$+&#)! $%!<br />

)('1.! 10(:! NK&#! 5($.#($'! 10(! i$+.#($'u+'3:0%#33'4! :'($%'.#)! @(0)65.+! '%)! .&#!<br />

'@@3$5'.$0%+!$%!(#3'.$0%!.0!9c94!#.5B!5'%!G#!506%.#)!':0%A!.&#:PB!<br />

O%!.&#!(#-$+$0%!01!(#A63'.$0%+!'%)!)#53'('.$0%+!Q$.&!.&#!%#Q!*00)!3'Q4!$.!$+!$:@0(.'%.!<br />

.0!&'-#!'%)!.'=#!$%.0!50%+$)#('.$0%!.&#!-$#Q+!'%)!(#50::#%)'.$0%+!01!.&#!$%)6+.(7!10(!<br />

@'-$%A! .&#! Q'7! 10(! 06(! $%)6+.($'3! +#5.0(! '%)! 10(! #%'G3$%A! 6+! .0! 50:@#.#! Q$.&! .&#!<br />

:#:G#(!506%.($#+!01!L6(0@#'%!,%$0%B!<br />

$<br />

>(.($<br />

H'%'.3!! +#=.U(D4! +0%! 7!33'()'! D(#.$:! -#! .D=#.$:! ('=':3'(!73'! ! GD7D=! G$(! '.!3!:!<br />

$?#(+$%)#! 036@! ;2! D3=#3#($%#! ! 7'=3''%! ('=':3'('! 63':!.!(B`3=#:$>! @(0.#$%!<br />

$&.$7'5!%!%! GD7D=! ?06%366%6%! ='%'.3!! #.$73#! ='(!3'%)!!%!! )DD%)DD:D>)#!<br />

+#=.U(D%!U%#:$!0(.'7'!?!=:'=.')!(B!<br />

H'%'.3!!+#=.U(D%)#!d[[[


?'3!:'3'(!! G'3'.:!! 03'%! ! $3=! ! +#=.U(3#()#%! G$($+$! ! 03:6.6(B26%6%! +0%656! 03'('=!<br />

)#-':3!!)#%#.3#%#%!!-#!.'=$@!#)$3#%!G$(!+#=U(!&'3$%#!A#3:$.$(B!<br />

26!)#%#.$:!-#!.'=$@3#($%!)'&'!#.=$%!03'G$3:#+$!$?$%!D3=#:$>)#=$!7U%#.:#3$=4!.#G3$3#(!<br />

-#!67A63':'3'(!=!+:!%!%!)'!;2!:#->6'.!-#!XU%#.:#3$=3#($%#!67A6%!&'3#!A#.$($3:#+$!<br />

A#(#=3$)$(B! c#%#.$:3#($%! #.=$%! 03:'+!! 7'%!%)'! &#:! .D=#.$5$3#($:$>$%! D@&#! -#!<br />

=0(=63'(!%!%! A$)#($3:#+$! &#:! )#! +#=.U(D%! G6! '%3':)'! :')6(! 03:':'+!! $?$%! ;2!<br />

:#->6'.3'(!%'!67A6%!7U%#.:#3$=!-#!.#G3$3#(!!D3=#:$>!$?$%!'(.!03:6.6(B!<br />

26!=0%6)'=$!@(0G3#:3#()#%!G'&+#)#(=#%!#%!U%#:3$!=0%6!03'('=!AU()DD:D>4!KD(=!<br />

C!)'! H0)#=+$! 9$=(0G$7030I$=! =($.#(3#(! K#G3$$%)#%! G'3':'=! #%! )0(6+6! 03'5'=.!(B!<br />

9$=(0G$7030I$=! =($.#(3#(! .#G3$$%)#4! ?$! #..#! G'='! D3=#3#()#! ! '('%:'7'%! E3$+.#($'F!<br />

G'=.#($!=($.#($!!G636%:'=.')!(B!<br />

;'!)'=$! .'G30)'! )'! AU(D3#5#$! A$G$! N.'G30! VP! i$+.#($'! ;2! -#! ;2c! ?$! ='%'.3!! #.$!<br />

:#->6'.3'(!%)'!')!!&$?!A#?:#7#%!G$(!G'=.#($)$(BNH'7%'=!]!-#!gP!<br />

!<br />

K'G30!VB!;2!-#!;2c!?$!='%'.3!!#.$!:#->6'.3'(!%!%!T'3:0%#33'4!i$+.#($'!-#!<br />

j':@730G'5.#(!7U%D%)#%!$()#3#%:#+$!<br />

H($.#(!! ;2!!<br />

3#.:#3#()#!<br />

G(073#(! -#!<br />

&$%)$!<br />

='(='+3'(!%)'!<br />

$3#.:#!<br />

G'>!%)'!<br />

=($.#(3#(BN%6:<br />

%#! d^! A(! G$(!<br />

='?! ')#.!<br />

@$3$?$%!!G076%!<br />

)#($+$%)#%!P!<br />

T'3:0%#33'!! ^[! ')#.!<br />

%6:6%#)#! Z!<br />

')#.!@0>$.$1B!<br />

NtVg!P!<br />

!<br />

j':@730G'b<br />

5.#(!!<br />

i$+.#($'!! k$! #..#!<br />

H($.#(!X0=!!<br />

!;2c! $3#.:#3#($%)#!<br />

G(073#(! -#! &$%)$!<br />

='(='+3'(!%)'! $3#.:#!<br />

G'>!%)'4! 7#%$! =($.#(3#(!<br />

N\'>$('%! d[VV! 7D(D(3D#!<br />

A$(#5#=BP!<br />

! J$3$?!<br />

='(='+!%)'! ^V! ')#.!<br />

%6:6%#)#!^!')#.!@0>$.$1!!<br />

NtW4f!P!<br />

! \$%)$)#! ^e!<br />

')#.!%6:6%#)#!g!@0>$.$1!!<br />

NtZ4VP!<br />

H($.#(!X0=! VB! J$3$?!<br />

='(='+!%)'! ^V! ')#.!<br />

%6:6%#)#! f! ')#.! @0>$.$1!<br />

NtV^4ZP!<br />

dB! \$%)$)#! ^e!<br />

')#.!%6:6%#)#!]!@0>$.$1!!<br />

Nt^4]P!<br />

k$!#..#!H($.#(!X0=!<br />

;2!<br />

9'(=#..#! =!7:'!<br />

D(D%3#($! -#! #.!<br />

='(!!:3'(!!<br />

9c9! -#! L.!<br />

D(D%3#($! $?$%!<br />

=($.#(3#(!!<br />

:#-56.B!<br />

^!')#.!%6:6%)#!<br />

E[!E@0>$.$1B!<br />

H($.#(!70=B!<br />

k$! #..#! H($.#(!<br />

X0=!<br />

KD(=$7#! :'(=#..#! -#!<br />

$3#.:#)#! '7%!!<br />

=($.#(3#(! h! GD.D%!<br />

@$3$?h@'?'! @$3$?! .D:!<br />

@'(?'!='%'.3!!#.3#($B!<br />

^! ')#.! %!6:6%#)#!<br />

E[F!!@0>$.$1B!<br />

H($.#(!X0=B!<br />

^! ')#.! %!6:6%#)#! [!<br />

@0>$.$1B!<br />

!<br />

i$+.#($'! G'=.#($+$! +')#5#! @$:$! #.! D(D%3#($%)#! .'=$@! #)$3:#=.#)$(BT0%! AD%3#()#! G6!<br />

G'=.#($! +#G#G$73#! ?0=! 1'>3'! @(0G3#:! 7''%:!4! .D=#.$5$3#()#! ! &'=3!! 03'('=! D&#3#(!<br />

036:6.6(B!<br />

c$#(! .'('1.'%!D3=#:$>)#! T'3:0%#33'! G'=.#($+$%$%! '%'3$>3#($73#! $3A$3$! $3#.:#! G'>!%)'!<br />

.#+.3#()#%! >$7')#! +0%! D(D%! =0%.(033#($! 7'@!3:'=.')!(B! X$%#! ! 76='(!)'=$! .'G30)'!!<br />

AU(D3#G$3#5#$! A$G$! &#:! ;2! D3=#3#($%)#! &#:! )#! ;2c! G6! =($.#(3#(! ?06%36=3'!<br />

$3#.:#3#()#! .'=$@! #)$3:#=.#)$(B;2! x)#! +0%! D(D%! =($.#(3#($! )#! 7#(! '3:'=3'! G#('G#(4!<br />

$3#.:#!G'>!%)'!@(0+#+!!G'>!%)'!)##(3#%:#!:#-56..6(B!<br />

! TJ


c$#(!.'('1.'%!;-(6@'!2$(3$$!;2!Lj!n0!VggV_d[[Z!%6:'('3!!)$(#=.$1$%)#NH'7%'=]P!<br />

?$!#.!='(!!:3'(!%)'!K0@3':!G'=.#($)#!$3#.:#3#()#!&#(&'%A$!G$(!3$:$.!70==#%4!KD(=!<br />

C!)'! H0)#=+$! 9$=(0G$7030I$=! H($.#(3#(! K#G3$$%)#! $+#! NK#G3$! %0Yd[[W_efPNVP! G6!<br />

)##(3#(!V[[B[[[!$3#!VB[[[B[[[!'('+!%)')!(B3#.:#)#!G6!=($.#(3#(#!67A6%36=!+'3'%+'!<br />

G$3#!4!+'.!!%0=.'3'(!%)'=$!#%!61'=!+!5'=3!=!+'@:'3'(!!G6!)##($%!?0=!D>#($%#!?!=:'+!%'!<br />

+#G#@!03'G$3:#=.#)$(BT#=.U(D!!-#!D(#.$5$7$!&'=+!>!7#(#!:')6(!#)#G$3:#=.#)$(B!!<br />

2$(! )$#(! +#=.U(! $?$%! U%#:3$! =0%6! $+#4! ! 9TL! _9c9! N:#='%$=! +!7(!3:!! #.! PD(#.$:$!<br />

=!+!.3':'3'(!)!(BL%! +0%! 7#%$! .'+3'=! 7U%#.:#3$=! 03'%! E\'7-'%+'3! A!)'3'(! $?$%! U>#3!<br />

&$I7#%! =6('33'(!! 7U%#.:#3$$! E$%)#! NH'7%'=^P! 9TL! +')#5#! @$:$! #:D3+$1$7#!<br />

D(D%3#()#!=633'%!3'G$3$(!=!+!.3':'+!!=0763:6.6(!N9'))#!]V!NZPPB!<br />

26! =!+!.3':'3'(! ! ;2! :#->6'.!%)'! 70=.6(B\'..'! 7#%$! .#=%030I$3#(3#! G#('G#(! 9TL!<br />

D(#.$:$!$=$!?#$.!7'@!3'G$3:#=.#4!)DD=!G'+!%?3!!9TL!:'=$%'3'($%)'%!D(#.$3#%3#(!!$?$%!4!<br />

#.$=#.$%)#! @$$($3:#+$! A#(#=.$$! G#3$(.$3#(#=4! &'>!(3'%:!! ?$! #.! ='(!!:3'(!%)'! ! )'&$!!<br />

=633'%!3'G$3#5#$%)#%!G'&+#)$3:#=.#)$(!NH'7%'=ZPB!<br />

KD(=!C!)'!H0)#=+$!L.!D(D%3#($!.#G3$$%)#!$+#!!7$%#!.#=%$=!=($.#(3#()#!G'>!!!=!+!.3':'3'(!<br />

:#-56.B!K'-6=!=!7:'+!%!%!7'+'=!03:'+!!4!=!(:!>!!#.!)!!%)'!='-6(:'!7'@!3':':'+!!<br />

A$G$!=!+!.3':'3'(!!=0%6+6%6%!)'!!7#%$!.#G3$!?'3!:'3'(!!$3#!?U>D3#G$3#5#$!G#=3#%.$+$!<br />

$?#($+$%)#7)$=B!<br />

;%5'=! +0%! .'+3'=! ?'3!:'+!%)'! )'! 7$%#! ='-6(:'7'! -#! .'-6=! =!7:'+!%'! $>$%!<br />

-#($3:#:#=.#)$(B!<br />

c$#(! .'('1.'%! :'($%#! #.3#($%! ! '7(!! G$(! @(0G3#:! 03'('=! 0(.'7'! ?!=.!!! AU(D3:#=.#)$(B!<br />

9'($%#! @'(?'! #.! 03'('=! 7'@.!!:!>! G'-6(63'()'! #.! D(D%3#($! .#G3$$%)#=$NH'7%'=! dP!<br />

:'($%'+70%!.'%!:!!G'>!'3!%'('=4!E:'($%#!#.!D(D%3#($%)#!.6>4!7'!A$G$!A!)'!G$3##%3#($!<br />

7'! )'! 3#>>#.! -#($5$3#(! )!!%)'! G$(! ='.=!! ='.!3':'>F! )$7#! G#3$(.$3$70(B! i$.#('.D(3#()#=$!<br />

A#%#3! :'($%'+70%! .'%!:!%'! G'=!3)!!%)'! $+#! E#.3#($%! @$$(:#! +!('+!%)'! +6! .6.:'!<br />

='@'+$.#+$%$! '(..!(:'=4! ='+! 1$G($33#($%$! 76:6':'+!! $3#! )'&'! A#-(#=! -#! =03'7!<br />

?$%#%#G$3$(! D(D%3#(! #3)#! #.:#=4! D(D%)#! (#%=! -#! .#=+.D(D! $7$3#.$(:#=4! 3#>>#.! -#!<br />

'(0:'7!!A#3$.$(:#=!4!$+.#%:#7#%!:$=(0G$7'3!A#3$:#7$!=0%.(03!'3.!%'!'3!@!D(D%D%!('1!<br />

U:(D%D!6>'.:'=!-#!D(D%!?#$.3$3$$%$!'(..!(:'=!':5!73'!7'@!3'%!!$3#:3#(!GD.D%D)D(B!<br />

KD:!)D%7')'4!#.!+#=.U(D%)#!:'($%#!#.!D(D%3#($!03)6=?'!!A#%$!7#(!'3:'=.')!(!-#!?0=!<br />

?#$.3$)$(B!!;-(6@'!2$(3$$!D3=#3#($%#!$&('5'.!?'3!:'3'(!%'!G'3'%)!!%)'!G$>3#(#!A#3#%!<br />

$3=! .'3#@3#(! G6! D(D%3#(! )0(63.6+6%)'! 03:6.6(B! %A$3.#(#4! *('%+'! A$G$! G$(?0=! ;2!<br />

D3=#+$%)#%!!A#3#%!(#?#.#3#(4!G$(G$($%#!G#%>#:#=.#!-#!10+1'.4!'+=0(G'.4!+$.('.4!='(G0%'.!<br />

A$G$! 10%=+$70%#33#(! $?#(:#=.#)$(B! 26! ='.=!3'(4! KD(=! C!)'! H0)#=+$! H'.=!! :'))#3#($!<br />

.#G3$$%)#!)#!=633'%!:!!7'+'3!03'%!:'))#3#()$(B!!<br />

H633'%!3'%! .D:! A$()$3#($%! .#G3$3#(#! 67A6%4! +!%!(3'(! )'&$3$%)#! =633'%!3)!!4! +$>3#(#! -#!<br />

#.$=#..#!:D.#($3#(#!'?!=?'!G#3$(.$3)$$!G$(!)6(6:)'!E.'$!7'@!3)!!F!)DD%D3:#:#+$!<br />

A#(#=3$)$(B26!7'+'!%!)#-':!#.:#+$!4!='%'.3!!D(D%3#($%)#!!!?#$.3$3$$4!#=0%0:$=!':'!<br />

3#>>#.3$! -#! 7D=+#=! @(0.#$%! ='7%'!! ='3$.#3$! D(D%3#($%! U%D%D! =#+#5#=! -#! 76(.)!%)'!<br />

(#='G#.$! #%A#33#7#5#=! G$(! )6(6:)6(B! KD:! G6! %0=.'3'(! AU>#! '3!%)!!%)'! (#-$>#!<br />

#)$3:#=.#! 03'%! E#.! D(D%3#($! .#G3$$F! %)#! :'($%'+70%! .'%!:!! )#$.$(3:#3$! -#! ;-(6@'!<br />

2$(3$$!$3#!676:36!03:'3!)!(!NH'7%'=!fbWPB!<br />

T0%6?!03'('=!476='(!)'!+')#5#!U(%#=!03'('=!-#()$$:$>!67A63':'3'(!:#-56..6(4!X#%$!<br />

A!)'! ='%6%6%'! $+.$%')#%! 7U%#.:#3$=! -#! .#G3$3#($%! 6'%! 7#%$3#%:#+$! -#! AU>)#%!<br />

A#?$($3:#+$!'':'+!%)'7!>B!26!'':')'!U%5#3$=3#!+#=.U(!03'('=!;2!7U%#.:#3$=3#($%#!<br />

67A6%!-#!&#:!+#=.U(D!A#3$.$($5$!&#:!)#!.D=#.$5$7$!=0(67656!=6('33'(!-#!7U%#.:#3$=3#(!<br />

03:'3!)!(B!<br />

! TN


;+3!%)'! T#=.U()#%! .'+3'=! :#.$%3#(3#! $3A$3$! AU(D3#(! '3!%:'=.')!(4! AU(D3#($:$>!<br />

)##(3#%)$($3$(=#%! G$3$+#3! G'>)'! )'! 0(.'=! ?'3!:'! 7'@!3'G$3:#3$4! ='(!3!=3!!<br />

G$3A$3#%)$(:#3#(3#!=0%6%6%!.':!'%3'!3:'+!!!+'3'%:'3!)!(B!!<br />

%+5,+A-+.$<br />

VB! KD(=!C!)'!H0)#=+$!E9$=(0G$7030I$=!H($.#(3#(!K#G3$$!ENK#G3$!%0Yd[[W_efP!<br />

dB! KD(=!C!)'!H0)#=+$!EL.!`(D%3#($!K#G3$$!E!<br />

]B! j0::$++$0%!"#A63'.$0%!NLjP!%0!VggV_d[[Z!01!^!)#5#:G#(!d[[Z!<br />

;:#%)$%A!"#A63'.$0%!NLjP!%0!d[Z]_d[[^!0%!:$5(0G$030A$5'3!5($.#($'!10(!100)+.611+B!<br />

gB!c05=#.!%0!B*TOT!d[V[!b[[dW!c#@'(.:#%.!R1!;A($563.6(#!!*00)!+'1#.7!'%)!%+@#5.$0%!+#(-$5#!B*#)#('3!<br />

"#A$+.#(!8036:#!Ze4n6:G#(!^g!90%)'74!9'(5&!dV4!d[VVP!<br />

n#Q! @#(10(:'%5#! T.'%)'(.+! 10(! +'3:0%#33'! '%)! 50:@3'G'5.#(! $%! X06%A! j&$5=#%! '%)! K6(=#7! ! +3'6A&.#(!<br />

L+.'G3$+&:#%.+h!"#+@0%+#!.0!j0::#%.+!'%)!;%%06%+:#%.!01!:@3#:#%.'.$0%!T5&#)63#!!<br />

^B! E\'7-'%+'3!C!)'3'(!$?$%!m>#3!\$I7#%!H6('33'(!!XU%#.:#3$$!EK'+3'=!<br />

eB! "#A63'.$0%!NLjP!%0!f^]_d[[g!01!.&#!L6(0@#'%!J'(3$':#%.!'%)!R1!K&#!j0%5$3!01!dW!;@($3!d[[g!<br />

3'7$%A!)0Q%!!+@#5$1$5!&7A$#%#!(63#+!10(!100)!01!'%$:'3!0($A$%!B!<br />

ZB! Lj! 50::$%$5'.$0%! 1(0:! .&#! 50:$++$0%! .0! .&#! L6(0@#'%! J'(3$':#%.! ! '%)! ! .&#! 506%5$3! 0%! .&#!<br />

16.6(#!%#5#++$.7!'%)!6+#!01!:#5&'%$5'337!+#@'('.#)!:#'.!$%!&#!L6(0@#'%!,%$0%!4!$%536)$%A!.&#!$%10(:'.$0%!<br />

@03$57!.0Q'()+!50%+6:#(+BNdBVdBd[V[P!<br />

fB! ;3$! ! CD5D=036! 4H'%'.3!! #.3#($%$%! 9'($%'+70%6! ! T':+6%! R%)0=6>! 9'7!+! `%-B8#.#($%#(!<br />

*'=B2#+$%!\$I7#%$!-#!K#=%030I$+$!;2c4T':+6%!<br />

WB! jB;3-'(')04!'%)!TB95B!H##!J063.(7!9#'.!'%)!LAA!Å6'3$.7!T7:@0+$6:4!9'($%'.$0%!.0!:@(0-#!!<br />

*6%5.$0%'3!J(0@#(.$#+!'%)!+'1#.7!!01!@063.(7!:#'.B!c#@'(.:#%.!01!;%$:'3!'%)!100)!+5$#%5#+!4!K#M'+!K#5&B!<br />

,%$-#(+.7!i6GG05=!ZWg[W!'%)!c#@'(.:#%.!01!J063.(7!!+5$#%5#!;6G6(%!,%$-#(+.7!4!'6G6(%!4;i!]efgW!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

! TT


!<br />

" ##] $D.F(-&.$>O;.&'(,(,$%F)^F'1-+,)+'!,/+$`&,($?&A,F-FM(-&.$@&$<br />

`+A-+!)-+.!<br />

H"I);"-3&.0.2%"+)'&8)J,,$.'-3"+)L.$)6.7,.+#%&2)E$.%0"$)A'&1$"))<br />

\B9B!H##%#( ' 4!9'(7!\B!a$5=+ G 4!*BjB!9$5&#3 5 4!HB!L=$%5$ )!<br />

' J(01#+U(!L:#=3$!-#!2U3D:!2'='%!4!=##%#(B]v0+6B#)6!<br />

G R&$0!j0:@0+.!'%)!9'%6(#!9'%'A#:#%.!j00()$%'.0(4!c#@.B!01!*00)4!;A($563.6('34!'%)!2$030A$5'3!<br />

L%A$%##($%A4!R;"cj_K&#!R&$0!T.'.#!,%$-#(+$.74!a00+.#(4!R&$0!ggeWV!<br />

5 :$5&#3B]ev0+6B#)6!<br />

) K'(!:!9'=$%'3'(!!2U3D:D4!l$(''.!*'=D3.#+$4!TD3#7:'%!c#:$(#3!`%$-#(+$.#+$4!jD%D(!O+@'(.'!]dde[h!!<br />

!<br />

89&1$<br />

26! :'='3#4! G(0$3#(! ADG(#+$%$%! =0:@0+.3':'+!%)'%! #3)#! #)$3#%! .#5(DG#3#($! -#!<br />

>0(36=3'(!! ='@+':'=.')!(B! k'3!:'! =0:@0+.! %#:$4! n\ ] bn! ='7!@3'(!! -#! =0=6!<br />

7U%#.$:$%$! -#! $3#.:#! :'3$7#.3#($%$! '>'3.!3:'+!! D>#($%#! 706%3':'=.')!(B! 2(0$3#(!<br />

=D:#+3#($%)#%!'3!%'%!.'-6=!'3.3!=_)!=!!$3#!$3A$3$!('@0(!#)$3#%!3$.#('.D(!G$3)$($3#($4!!!%#:!<br />

$?#($$%$%!tddb!t^^!N7'!G'>P!4!'>0.!NnP!$?#($$%$%!t]b^4W!N=6(6!G'>P!-#!j_n!0('%!%!<br />

WbVd!'('+!%)'!)#$.$$%$!AU+.#(:$.$(B!T'&'!?'3!:'3'(!!-#!#=0%0:$=!'%'3$>3#(4!G(0$3#(!<br />

ADG(#+$%#!?0=!'>!-#7'!&$?!G$(!='.=!!#=3#%:#)#%!-#!G'3'%A!?!%#:$%$%!tg[!-#7'!)'&'!<br />

'>! 03)66! )6(6:)'! G(0$3#(! ADG(#+$%$%! =0:@0+.3':'+!%!%! )'&'! #=0%0:$=! 03)66%6!<br />

AU+.#(:#=.#)$(B!26!:'='3#4!n!#:$+70%3'(!!=0%.(03!#)$3$(=#%4!G(0$3#(!ADG(#+$%#!?0=!'>!<br />

-#7'!&$?!G$(!='.=!!#=3#%:#)#%!=0:@0+.3'%)!!!+$+.#:3#(3#!$3A$3$!G$3A$3#($!-#(:#=.#)$(B!<br />

26!?'3!:')'4!+.'.$=!%':36!-#7'!7!!%3'(!7'%!%)'4!+D(#=3$!-#7'!=#+$=3$!&'-'3'%)!(:'!<br />

(#I$:3#($%$%!=633'%!3)!!!?#$.3$!=0:@0+.3':'!:#.0.3'(!%!!$?#(#%!@$30.!-#!GD7D=!U3?#=3$!<br />

+'&'!?'3!:'+!!+0%6?3'(!!('@0(!#)$3:$.$(B!H'.=!!:'))#+$!#=3#%:#:$!76:6(.'5!!.'-6=!<br />

ADG(#+$%$%! =0:@0+.3':'+!! $3#! $3A$3$! ?'3!:'3'(! G(0$3#(! ADG(#+$%$%! =0:@0+.3':'+!%'!<br />

='.=!! +'3':'+!! '?!+!%)'%! .'(.!!3'5'=.!(B! ! 2$(?0=! ?'3!:'4! )DD=! %#:)#4! 7D=+#=! n!<br />

$?#($=3$! =0:@0+.! D(#.#G$3#5#=! +$+.#:3#($%! >0(3':'3!! &'-'3'%)!(:'3!! -#! :#='%$=!<br />

='(!.!(:'3!! ='@'3!! N$%b-#++#3P! +$+.#:3#(! 03)66%6! AU+.#(:$.$(B! 26! +$+.#:3#(! .':!<br />

'%3':!73'!G(0$3#(!ADG(#+$%$!=0:@0+.3':':'=.')!(!1'='.!&#:!1$)'%5!3'(!-#!G'&?!-'%3'(!<br />

&#:!)#!?$1.?$3#(#4!+.'G$3$>#!03:6!N=6(6!:'))#!='7G!!tV[bVf4eP4!%#:$!6>'=3'.!(!3:!!<br />

NtV[bVf!%#:3$P!-#!7D=+#=!'>0.!$?#($=3$!N.0@3':!n!='7G!!tVdbV^P!+'.!3'G$3$(!=0:@0+.!<br />

D(#.:#=.#)$(3#(B!!<br />

!<br />

:;'1.+


#%-$(0%:#%.! +6((06%)$%A! .&#! 50:@0+.B! T65&! '! +7+.#:! Q063)! %0.! 16337! 50:@0+.! .&#!<br />

G(0$3#(!3$..#(4!G6.!Q063)!3#')!.0!'!+.'G$3$>#)!NV[bVfBet!)(7!:'..#(!30++P4!)(7!@(0)65.!<br />

NV[bVft! :0$+.6(#P4!Q$.&! &$A&! %$.(0A#%! 50%.#%.! NVdbV^t! .0.'3! n! 30++P! .&'.! 5063)! G#!<br />

:'(=#.#)!.0!%6(+#(7:#%!'%)!A'()#%#(+4!'+!Q#33!'+!A#%#('3!1'(:#(+B!!!<br />

!<br />

>(.($<br />

T0%! 0%! 7!3)'4! ;:#($='! 2$(3#$=! c#-3#.3#($! &'7-'%5!3!=! #%)D+.($+$%)#4! D(#.$:4!<br />

)#@03':'4! 67A63':'! -#! &'7-'%+'3! '.!=3'(!%! =633'%!:!! $3#! $3$=$3$! ?#-(#+#3! +0(6%3'('!<br />

='(!!G$3$%?!A$)#(#=!'(.:'=.')!(B!m>#33$=3#!&'7-'%3'(!%!706%!03)66!GU3A#3#()#4!'!(!!<br />

ADG(#! 7D=3#:#! 0('%3'(!! 7D>#7! +63'(!%)'! %$.('.! -#! 10+10(! -#! 7#(! '3.!! +63'(!%)'! %$.('.!<br />

G$($=$:$!A$G$!+0(6%3'('!703!'?:'=.')!(B!L=!03'('=4!?$1.3$=3#()#%!7'7!3'%!@'(.$=D3!-#!A'>!<br />

#:$+70%3'(!! $3#! G#('G#(! +$%#=! 7'7!3!:!! U%#:3$! ?#-(#! +0(6%3'(!%'! 703! '?:'=.')!(B! 26!<br />

=0%63'(! ?$1.3$=! &'7-'%3'(!! #%)D+.($+$%$%! A#3$$:$! $?$%! U%#:3$! =!+!.3'()!(! -#! &'7-'%!<br />

G'(!%'!!$?$%!7#%$!7'=3'!:3'(!!-#!ADG(#!7U%#.$:$%$!>0(6%36!&'3#!A#.$(:#=.#)$(B!!<br />

2(0$3#(!ADG(#+$!'3.3!=!-#!.'-6=!)!=!+!%!%!G$3#$:$%)#%!036:'=.')!(B!;:#($='!2$(3#$=!<br />

c#-3#.3#($%#:#+$! A#%#33$=3#! .'3'! N=633'%!3'G$3$(3$$%#! G'3!!<br />

03'('=!+#(.!-#7'!76:6'=P!-#7'!1!+.!=!='G66)6(B!J'>'()'!$+.#%$3#%!G(0$3#(!'!(3!!%'!<br />

G'3!!03'('=!GD7D:#!@#($70)6!g[!$3#!e[!AD%!'('+!%)'!)#$:#=.#)$(B!K$@$=!03'('=!G$(!<br />

GD7D:#!@#($70)6!gW!AD%)D(B!`(#.$3#%!ADG(#%$%!?!='(!3:'!+!=3!!!)#$=#%)$(!-#!G$('>!<br />

)'!'3.3!!%!=633'%!3'G$3$(3$$%#!G'3!)!(B!\#(!G$(!7#.$.$(:#!@#($70)6%)'%!+0%('!=D?D=!<br />

$3#:3#(3#! ADG(#%$%! .':':!! 6>'=3'.!(!3!(=#%4! )'&'! GD7D=! $3#:3#()#4! @'>'(! $?$%!<br />

+')#5#! )!=!3'(! ='3)!(!3!(4! +0%('! %':36! 7'@!3!(4! =D:#+.#! ='3'%! ADG(#)#%! =0:@0+.!<br />

7'@!3!(B! 2$(! +0%('=$! 7#.$.$(:#! @#($70)6%)'%! U%5#! +!%!(3!! :$=.'()'! 7#%$! '3.3!=!<br />

=63'%!3:'=.')!(B! 2D7D=! $3#:3#(! $?$%4! 7'7A!%! G$(! 67A63':')'! =D?D=! .'-6=3'(! $?$%!<br />

.':':#%! G0'3.:')'%! U%5#! ^be$7#! 67A63':')'%! U%5#! A#?$5$! 03'('=! ='@'3!!<br />

7'@!3'(! '3.!%)'! )#@03'%'G$3$(! -#7'! +!>)!(:'>3!!! $7$! 03'%! G('%)'73'! U(.D3#G$3$(! -#7'!!<br />

$3#%:$! -#! U>AD%! G$(! D(D%! 03'('=! @'>'(3'%'G$3$(! N900(#! -#! '(=B4! VWW^h! 265=3$%! -#!<br />

'(=B4!d[[gPB!!<br />

CDG(#%$%!?#-(#+#3!#.=$3#($%$!'>'3.:'!-#_-#7'!='.:'!)##(!+'3'%:!!D(D%3#(!7'('.:'!<br />

@0.'%+$7#3$%#! +'&$@! .'-6=! ADG(#+$%$%! $3#%:#+$! -#7'! :6':#3#! #)$3:#+$! $?$%! 1'(=3!!<br />

.#=%030I$3#($%! #.=$%3$$%$! )##(3#%)$(#%! G$(?0=! ?'3!:'! G636%:'=.')!(B! 26(')'=$!<br />

.#=%030I$3#(! #3#=.($=! D(#.:#=! $?$%! 7'=:'7!h! :#.'%! D(#.$:$! $?$%! '%'#(0G$=! ?D(D:#7$h!<br />

A#3$:$!.'!%'G$3$(3$=!-#!=633'%!:!$?$%!@#3#.3#:#7$h!-#!=0=63'(!4!@'.0I#%3#($!-#!%#:$!<br />

'>'3.:'=!$?$%!=0:@0+.3':'7!!$?#(:#=.#)$(B!"$..#(!-#!T.#&(!Nd[[ZP!G$(?0=!.#=%030I$7$!<br />

#=0%0:$=! '?!)'%! )##(3#%)$(:$3#()$(B! ;('.!(!5!3'(! ?'3!:'! '3'%!%)'4! )#-3#.! )#+.#$!<br />

%#)#%$!$3#!63'!:!:'3$7#.3#($%$%!03:')!!!-'(+'7!3+'!G$3#4!@#3#.3#:#!-#!=0:@0+.3':'!<br />

&'($?4! :'3$7#.3#($%! A#3$($! '.!!%!! G63:63'()!(B! T#'10()4! c#3'Q'(#$! G$(! .#+$+$!<br />

&#)#13#7#%! =0:@0+.3':'! +$+.#:3#($%$%! '%'3$>$! .'!:'%!%! G$(! 1'=.U(! 03:')!!%!!<br />

AU+.#(:$.$(B! n':36! =0:@0+.3':'! +$+.#:$%$%! =633'%!3:'+!! )6(6:6%)'4! #=0%0:$=!<br />

1$>$G$3$.#%$%!ADG(#%$%!-#!='.=!!:'))#3#($%$%!:'3$7#.$%#4!$3#.:#!:'3$7#.$%#!-#!G$.:$!<br />

=0:@0+.6%! @'('=#%)#! 1$7'.!%'! G'3!! 03)66%6! G63:63'()!(B! m(%#$%4! Z4^^Ö! : b] !<br />

@'('=#%)#! 1$7'.!! $?$%4! ZfV[[[Ö! $3#! V]Ze[[[Ö! '('+!%)'! )#$#%! 7!33!=! ='(!!<br />

&#+'@3':!3'()!(B! *'G($='%!%! 7!33!=! $3#:! ='@'+$.#+$! ^W[[[! .0%)6(B! k'3!:')'4!<br />

=0:@0+.3':'!$3#:$%)#!036'%!n!='7G!!-#!:'.#(7'3!&'5$:!'>'3:'+!!$3#!$3A$3$!G$3A$3#(!<br />

-#($3:#:$.$(B!<br />

! TZ


26!:'='3#4!.$5'($!1$)'%3!=!-#!+#G>#!7#.$.$($5$3#(!&'..'!#-!+'&$@3#($!.'('1!%)'%!'('%'%!<br />

G$(! D(D%! 7'('.:'=! $?$%! =D:#+.#%! .0@3'%'%! .'-6=! ADG(#+$%$%! =0:@0+.3':'+!%!!<br />

$?#(:#=.#)$(B! ;7(!5'4! '>0.! ='7G!%!! -#! ?#-(#+#3! #.=$3#($! '>'3.'%! -#! G6%6%! 7'%!%)'!<br />

.'!:'! :'3$7#.3#($%$! '>'3.:'=! $?$%! =6(6! G$(! D(D%! #3)#! #)$3:#+$%)#! =633'%!3'%!<br />

=0:@0+.3':'!@(#%+$@3#($!-#!+$+.#:3#($!D>#($%#!706%3':'=.')!(B!<br />

$<br />

D.F(-&.$>O;.&'(,(,$89&--(A-&.($<br />

2(0$3#(!ADG(#+$%$%!U>#33$=3#($!?0=!)#$=#%)$(B!!L=$%5$!-#!'(=B!Nd[[gGP!G$(!7#.$.$(:#!<br />

@#($70)6%)'%!+0%('!NgW!AD%P!G(0$3#(!ADG(#+$%)#!7'@!3'%!'%'3$>3#()#!!t]gbg[!%#:4!fb<br />

fB]! @\4! t]^b]f! j4! t]b]BW! n4! WBZbVVBe! j_n! -#! tVZBfbVWBZ! =D3! $?#($$! )##(3#($%#!<br />

+'&$@! 03)66%6! G#3$(3#:$3#()$(B! 2(0)$#! -#! '(=B! Nd[[[P! ?'3!:'3'(!%)'! =633'%)!=3'(!!<br />

G(0$3#(!ADG(#+$%$%!tg[!%#:!-#!t]fB^!j4!t^BW!n4!Z!j_n4!'%)!tdVB]!=D3!$?#()$$%$!<br />

.#+@$.!#.:$3#()$(B!900(#!-#!'(=B!NVWW^P!G$(!?0=!?'3!:'%!%!+0%656%6!('@0(!#.:$3#(!-#!<br />

?'3!:'3'(!%)'!0(.'3':'!)##($!tdgB^!%#:4!t]ZBe!j4!t!gBV!n4!WBd!j_n!-#!t![Bde!<br />

n\ g bn! +'&$@! G(0$3#(! ADG(#+$%$! =633'%:!3'()!(B! HD3! $?#($$! =0%6+6%)'! &#(&'%A$! G$(!<br />

G$3A$!-#($3:#:$.$(B!j0%163!-#!'(=B!Nd[[eP!%#:4!@\4!n4!J!-#!H!NK'G30VP!$3#!G$(3$=.#4!<br />

+D(D! +'7+!%!%! N1305=! %6:G#(P! 10%=+$70%6! 03'('=! D(#.$3#%! )!=!! -#! ADG(#! :$=.'(3'(!%!!<br />

('@0(! #.:$3#()$(B! CDG(#)#! -#! )!=!)'! +D(D! +'7!+!! $3#! '>0.':'%!%'!&#:!)#!<br />

+D(D! +'7!+!%'! G'3!! 03'('=4! )!=!%!%! %#:! $?#($$%$%! ADG(#%$%=$%)#%! 7'=3'!=! $=$! ='.!<br />

)'&'!1'>3'!03)66%6!.#+@$.!#.:$3#()$(B!<br />

!<br />

%F)^F'1-+)+$-&)($$<br />

H0:@0+.3':'! '!(3!=3!! 03'('=! '#(0G$=! 0(.':! $?$%)#=$! 0(A'%$=! :'.#(7'33#($%!<br />

&!>3'%)!(!3:!! G$7030I$=! '7(!:'+!)!(B! 3#:! G076%5'4! :$=(00(A'%$>:'3'(! ='('(3!! -#!<br />

=633'%!3'G$3$(!0(A'%$=!:'.#(7'3!03'('=!')3'%)!(!3'%!=0:@0+.'+70%6P! -#! 03A6%3':'! '':'+!%'! AU(#! '?!=3'%:'=.')!(B!!<br />

2$($%5$3!'':'!0(A'%$=!'7(!:'%!%!?06%6%!:#7)'%'!A#3)$$!-#!7D=+#=!+!5'=3!=3'(!%!<br />

#3)#! #)$3)$$! '':')!(B! =$%5$3! '':'! )'&'! 7'-'! G$7030I$=! '=.$-$.#! -#! )'&'! )DD=!<br />

7!!%! +!5'=3!=3'(!%!%!%! 036.66! -#! G6! %#)#%3#! )'&'! 7'-'! =0:@0+.3':'%!%!<br />

A#(?#=3#.$$!'':')!(B!R3A6%3':'!'':'+!!G076%5'4!:#>01$3$=!G'=.#($3#(!Ngb]f!~jP!<br />

=0:@0+..'! 7#%$)#%! =030%$3#$(3#(B! H0:@0+.3':'! -#7'! 03A6%3':'! '':'3'(!%!%!<br />

6>6%3664! A$()$! -#! $3#:! @'(':#.(#3#($%#! NU(%#$%h! +!5'=3!=4! %#:4! 0=+$I#%! )D>#73#($4!<br />

j_n!0('%!4!@'(.$=D3!G076.6P!-#!7U%#.$:!67A63':'3'(!%'!N?#-$(:#!+!=3!!4!7!!%!G076.6!<br />

A$G$P!G'3!!03'('=!)#$:#=.#)$(B!<br />

K$@$=! G$(! =0:@0+.3':'! +$+.#:$%)#! :'.#(7'3! '=!!! #=$3! V


2'3'%A!?!<br />

.'($&$!<br />

N;7_7!3P!<br />

2$.$!<br />

.'($&$!<br />

N;7_7!3P!<br />

TD(D!<br />

N1305=P!<br />

CDG(#!!<br />

%#:$!!<br />

N7BGB4!<br />

tP!<br />

@\!<br />

!<br />

n!<br />

Nt!<br />

=BGBP!<br />

J!<br />

Nt!=BGBP!<br />

H!<br />

Nt!<br />

=BGBP!<br />

c!=!!<br />

n#:$!<br />

N7BGB4!<br />

tP!<br />

Z_[V! f_[V! V! deBV 5)#1 ! fBe! dB[f 3 ! [Bf^=!<br />

VBWZ $ ! ^]B^'G !<br />

W_[V! V[_[V! d! d]Bg & ! fBf! dBfZ = ! VBVW I ! dB^[ & ! ^]B] 'G !<br />

VV_[V! Vd_[V! ]! deBW G5)# ! fBZ! ]BVf I ! VB]f $ ! dBfZ A& ! ^^Be ' !<br />

g_[d! ^_[d! e! deBe G5)# ! fBW! ]Bfe )# ! VBfV A ! ]Bgg G5)#1 ! g]BV #1 !<br />

W_[d! V[_[d! W! dZBd G5) ! fBf! ]Beg A&$ ! dB][ 'G5 ! ]BfV G ! ^[Bf G5 !<br />

d_[]! g_[]! Vd! dgBg 1A& ! fBZ! gB]] ' ! dBVV 5)#1 ! ]B[] #1A& ! ggBf #1 !<br />

f_[]! W_[]! V^! dfBg 'G ! fBf! ]Be^A&$ ! dBde 'G5)# ! ]Bef G5) ! ggBf #1 !<br />

V_[g! d_[g! Vf! dfB] 'G ! fBW! gBV[ G ! dBVd 5)# ! ]BV^5)#1A ! ^dBZ 'G5 !<br />

R(.'3':'! ! ! deBg! ! ! ! ! geBW!<br />

'p& !5!<br />

-#7'!&$?!!+!!?!=!!!03:')!!!AU>3#%)$$%)#4!=0:@0+.!:'.#(7'3$!.0@3'%!(4!='(!.!(!3!(!-#!<br />

03A6%3':'7'! G!('=!3!(B! R3A6%3':'! +D(#+$4! @$7'+'%!%! A#(#=.$()$$! =0:@0+.6%!<br />

03A6%366%'! -#! +.'G$3$.#+$%#! G'3!)!(B! H0:@0+.3':'! +D(#5$! -#! =0:@0+.! 03A6%366!<br />

'('+!%)'=$!$3$=$!-#!+.'G$3$.#+$!G$(?0=!='7%'=.'!.'(.!!3:'=.')!(!N\'6A4!VWW]h!\0$.$%=!<br />

-#!H##%#(4!VWW]h!H##%#(!-#!'(=B4!d[[['PB!!<br />

!<br />

D.F(-&.$ >O;.&'(,(,$ %F)^F'1-+)+'!,/+$ %7--+,!-+,$ "('1&)-&.(,(,$ ?+'+.!)$ @&$<br />

`G,&1()(,(,$i^1()(9+'5F,7$$<br />

H##%#(! -#! '(=B! NVWW]4! d[[^P! G$(! .'+'(!:!%! 0@.$:$>'+70%6%6%4! 7'@!:! :'3$7#.$%#! -#!<br />

?'3!:'+!%'4! #%#(I$! =633'%!:!%'! N='7%'=3'(!%! =0(6%6:6%'P! -#7'! =$(3$3$=! )D>#73#($%#!<br />

N=0=64! .0>4! -GBP! G'3!! 03+6%! -#7'! 03:'+!%! =0:@0+.3':'! $3#:$%$%! :'.#:'.$=+#3!<br />

:0)#33#:#+$!-#!)#%#7+#3!03'('=!7'@!3'G$3)$$%$!$1')#!#.:$3#()$(B!;'!)'=$!GU3D:3#(!<br />

G(0$3#(! ADG(#+$%$%! 0@.$:6:! =0:@0+.3':'+!%'! 67A63'%'G$3#5#=! =0:@0+.3':')'!<br />

=0%.(03!#)$3#G$3$(!1'=.U(3#($%!)#%#7+#3!-#!:'.#:'.$=+#3!+0%6?3'(!%!!+6%:'=.')!(B!!<br />

! W#


$<br />

%+.!!)$i.+,-+.!$<br />

H'(!!:! $3#:3#($4! .#+$+! 0@#('.U(D%D%! $3#:! 7U%#.$:$%$! =03'73'.!(:'=! $?$%! &'5$:!<br />

G'>!%)'! 7'@!3:'=.')!(B! Rj;99! Nd[VVP! Q#G! +$.#+$4! '7(!! '7(!! :'.#(7'33#($%! -#!<br />

='(!!:3'(!%!%! &'5$:! -#! =D.3#3#($%#! G'3!! 03'('=! ='(!!:3'(!%! j4! n4! j_n4! %#:! -#!<br />

706%36=!)##(3#($%$!&#+'@3'7'%!-#!=0:@0+.!='(!.!(:'!0('%3'(!%!%!0@.$:$>'+70%6%6!<br />

N:#.($=!G$($:)#P!+'3'7'%!G$3A$+'7'(!?'3!:'!)0+7'+!%!!$?#(:#=.#)$(!NH##%#(!-#!'(=B4!<br />

d[[[GPB!26!?'3!:'!)0+7'+!%)'4!&#)#1!j_n!0('%!!oV^!-#!%#:!$?#($$ot]^!(3'%:!.!(!NK'G30!dPB!2('=#!NVWWdP!.'-6=!<br />

=D:#+$%)#!G(0$3#(!ADG(#+$%$%!=0:@0+.3':'+!!$?$%!:$%$:6:!j_n!0('%!%!%!V^!-#!%#:!<br />

$?#($$%$%! tg^! 03:'+!! A#(#=.$$%$! $'(#.! #.:$.$(B! 265=3$%! -#! '(=B! Nd[[gP! G(0$3#(!<br />

ADG(#+$%$%! ?0=! 7D=+#=! G$(! #=$3)#! 7!!3)!!%)'! 7D>)#! d[bd^! %#:)#! =#%)$3$$%)#%!<br />

!+!%)!!%!!AU>3#:3#:$3#()$(B!<br />

9'3$7#.3#($! )DD=! .6.'('=! N2(0)$#! -#! '(=B4! d[[[h! "$..#(! -#! T.#&(4! d[[ZP4! @'.0I#%!<br />

=0%.(03D!$?$%!7D=+#=!+!5'=3!=3'(!+'3'7'5'=!N265=3$%!-#!'(=B4!d[[gP4!G(0$3#(!ADG(#+$%$%!<br />

='.=!!:$=.'(!%!!'>'3.:'=!$?$%!j_n!0('%!!=633'%!3:!.!(B!K'G30!d!G(0$3#(!)!=!+!!-#!.'3'!<br />

='(!!:!%!%!dYV!&'5$:!='(!!:!0('%!%!!-#(:#=.#)$(B!!2(0)$#!-#!'(=B!Nd[[[P+'4!U%#($3#%!j_n!0('%!%)'!=0:@0+.3':'!$3#:$%)#%!7D=+#=!:$=.'()'!n\ ] bn!<br />

='7!@3'(!! :#7)'%'! A#3#5#=.$(B! H0%-'%+$70%#3! =0:@0+.3':'! @(#%+$@3#($%$! =633'%'('=!<br />

)DD=! j_n! 0('%!%)'! 7D=+#=! ':0%7'=! ='7!@3'(!%!%! :#7)'%'! A#3#G$3#5#$! G$(! ?0=!<br />

'('.!(:'5!! .'('1!%)'%! 0(.'7'! =0763:6.6(! NH$(5&:'%%! -#! a$..#(4! VWfWh! \'%+#%! -#!<br />

'(=B4! VWW]h! L3Q#33! -#! '(=B4! VWWfh! L=$%5$! -#! '(=B4! d[[[PB! m(%#$%4! \'%+#%! -#! '(=B!<br />

NVWW]P! 76:6(.'5!! .'-6=! ADG(#+$%$%! :!+!(! =0?'%!! $3#! =0:@0+.3':'+!! ?'3!:'+!%)'4!<br />

n\ ] bn! ='7!@3'(!%!%! j_n! 0('%!%!%! V^


eb^! '('+!%)'P!=0:@0+.3':'! ?'3!:'+!%)'4! tg^! %#:)#! =! )##($%$! [4[V!=A ):30++ !=A bV -+ !<br />

AD% bV! !-#!t]^!%#:)#!$+#!G6!)##($![4[[^!=A ):30++ !=A bV -+ !AD% bV! !03'('=!&#+'@3':!3'()!(B!<br />

H0:@0+.3':'!$3#:$!+!('+!%)'4!+6!#=3#%:#)$$!+D(#5#!=0:@0+.!='(!!:!!%#:!$?#($$!<br />

G'3'%A!?!%#:!$?#($$%)#%!)#!)'&'!)DD=!+#-$7#3#(#!)D#G$3$(!-#!G6!)6(6:!'7(!:'!<br />

0('%!%!%! '>'3:'+!%'! +#G#@! 036(B! L=$%5$! -#! '(=B! Nd[[g'P! =!+'! 3$13$! ='!.! '.!=3'(!%!%!<br />

NTJ*P! G(0$3#(! ADG(#+$! N2iP! $3#! =0:@0+.3'.!(!3:'+!%)'! =! )##($%$! =0:@0+.! %#:$%#!<br />

G'3!! 03'('=! C'6++! )'!3!:!! $3#! $1')#! #.:$.$(! -#! "7%=! NVWWdP! .'('1!%)'%! 0@.$:6:!<br />

03'('=! AU+.#($3#%! t^[be^! '('3!!%!%! '3.!%)'! 03'%! 67A6%! %#:! 0('%!%!! tgg4^! 03'('=!<br />

G63:63'()!(B!n#:!$?#($$!)#%=3#:$!$+#Y!<br />

d<br />

[B^àNd<br />

ggBddP _VWBfZÜ NdP!<br />

<<br />

| #<br />

d !<br />

=o= :'M !y!| j_n !y!| d !<br />

!<br />

K'G30! dB! 2(0$3#(! )!=!+!! -#! .'3'! ='(!!:!%!%4! j_n! 0('%!! oV^! -#! %#:! $?#($$ot]^!<br />

=0633'(!%!!7#($%#!A#.$(#%!:'.#($'3!:$=.'(3'(! V!<br />

! n#:!! HD3!! j! n! j_n! X06%36=! \'5$: H'(!!:!<br />

$?#($$!! $?#($$!<br />

&'5$:!!<br />

t! t!<br />

7D>)#+$!<br />

H'(!!:!V! 7BG! =BG! =BG! =BG! b! =A: b] ! : ] ! t! =A! t!<br />

2(0$3#(! g]BV! VfBf! ]eB^ ]Bfe! WB^! ^Vd! VBW^! e]! V[[[ ZZ!<br />

)!=!+!!<br />

;'?4!.'3'!<br />

N=6(6P!<br />

! WC<br />

HD.3#! H'(!!:!<br />

=D.3#!!<br />

7D>)#+$!<br />

VeB[! VB[! gWBf [BVe! ]VVB[ dZV! VBV]! ]Z! ][^! d]!<br />

T6! V[[B[! ! [B[! [B[[! ! Vefe! ! ! [! [!<br />

R(._K0@! ]eBf! V]BdZ g[Be dBZV! V^B[! gge! dBWd! ! V][^ !<br />

g[BV! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !<br />

n#:N=D3!<br />

$?#($$!!<br />

)$=='.#!<br />

'3!%:')'%P!<br />

V! L#(!.'3'!%#:$!tg[!='G63!#)$3+#7)$4!='(!!:!%#:$!tg[bgd!036()6B!H'(!!:!<br />

&'5:$%$%!GD>D3:#!1'=.U(D![4W^!.$(B!2(0)$#!-#!'(=B!Nd[[[P!70%A'!-#!.'3'!<br />

=633'%)!=3'(!!?'3!:')'!='(!!:!GD>D3:#!1'=.U(D%D![Bfg!03'('=!'3:!3'()!(B!<br />

!<br />

cDD=!0@.$:6:!%#:!0('%!!t!^d!0('%!%)'=$!7D=+#=!=D3!0('%!!$3#!$3$=$3$)$(B!H##%#(!-#!<br />

'(=B!Nd[[['4!d[[^P!#-+#3!='.!!'.!=!N9TaP!A$G$!$%#(.!+#-$7#3#($!7D=+#=!:'.#(7'33#(!-#!<br />

=!+'!3$13$!='!.!'.!=3'(!!7'!)'!.'-6=!ADG(#+$!A$G$!=D3!$?#($$!7D=+#=!:'.#(7'33#($%!%#:!<br />

$?#($$4! %0%b$%#(.! 1('=+$70%3'(!%'! G'3!! 03'('=! &#+'@3'%:'3!)!(B! L=$%5$


'(=B!Nd[[g'P!TJ*_2i!'7(!:'!0('%!%!!+!5'=3!!%!10%=+$70%6!03'('=!g[be^0j!'('3!!%)'!<br />

C'6++!)'!3!:!!$3#!$1')#!#.:$.$(!N" d !o![BW^PB!26!)#%=3#:!$+#Y!<br />

d<br />

[B^àNK5^fB]VP _VeBZdÜ<br />

| K5 #<br />

N]P!<br />

!<br />

=o= :'M !y!| j_n !y!| d$ y| K5 !<br />

!<br />

26! +0%6?3'('! )'7'%'('=! :'=+$:6:! '7(!:'! 0('%!4! =0:@0+.! +!5'=3!!%!%! ^fB] 0 j!<br />

)##($%)#!03)66%)'!:#7)'%'!A#3:#=.#)$(B!<br />

R@.$:6:! =0:@0+.! +!5'=3!!! 7!!%! G076.6%6! =0%.(03! #)#(#=! -#7'! &'-'! '=!:!%!!<br />

)D>#%3#7#(#=! N\'6A4! VWW]h! H##%#(! -#! '(=B4! VWWZP! -#! :$=(0G$7#3! '=.$-$.#! 703673'!<br />

D(#.$3#%! !+!%!%! NVf9w_=AP! 7!!%)'%! '7(!3:'+!73'! +'3'%'G$3$(B! 2$(='?! :#.(#!<br />

7D=+#=3$$%)#!-#!6>6%366%)'!03'%!7!!%3'()'!G636%'%!0(A'%$=!:'.#(7'33#(!:$%$:6:!<br />

&'-'3')!(:'! $3#! $=$! AD%)#%! )'&'! '>! G$(! +D(#! $?#($+$%)#! e[ 0 j3'! 03'%! 7!!%3'(!%! G'>#%! =#%)$3$$%)#%!<br />

7'%:'7'! %#)#%! 03)66! G$3$%:#=.#)$(B! H0:@0+.! 0366:6%)'! A#(#=3$! 03'%!<br />

&'-'3'%)!(:'!+$+.#:3#($%$%!.'+'(!:!!$?$%!.#:#3!)#%=3#:3#(!&#:!+D(#=3$!&#:!)#!'('3!=3!!<br />

&'-'3'%)!(:'!$?$%!H##%#(!-#!'(=B!NVWW]4!d[[['uG4!d[[^P!.'('1!%)'%!-#($3:$.$(B!#=$3!<br />

dÉ)#!!=0:@0+.!7'@!:!!$?$%!=633'%!3'%!D?!!:'3>#:#%$%!N!G$70+03$)_70%A'4!G'&?#!'.!=3'(!!<br />

-#! #-+#3! ='.!! '.!=3'(P! =6(6! :'))#! G'!%'! )D#%! &'5$:+#3! &'-'! )#G$! A#(#=+$%$:3#($!<br />

-#($3:$.$(! NH##%#(! -#! '(=B4! d[[^PB! ^^be[! 0 j! =0:@0+.3':'! =0633'(!%)'4! G'3'%A!?!<br />

&'-'! )#G$+$%$%! V4gV4! ]4gf! -#! [4Ze! : ] ! =A bV 50 ! AD% bV ! '3!%:'+!! A#(#=.$$! G$3)$($3:$.$(B!<br />

T0%6?3'('! AU(#! &'-'! )#G$+$! A#(#=+$%$:$! [B! AD%)#%! $.$G'(#%! dVB! AD%#! =')'(! ! g[! ='.!!<br />

'>'3:!.!(B! 2(0$3#(_)!=!! =0:@0+.3':'+!! $?$%! &'-'! )#G$+$! A#(#=+$%$:$! #=$3! d#(3$=! AU+.#(:#=.#)$(BX'.!(!:! -#! $3#.:#!<br />

:'3$7#.3#($%$!#%!'>'!$%)$(:#=!$?$%4!1'%!.'+'(!:!4!'7(!:'!$?$%!#%!67A6%!+!5'=3!!%!]b<br />

^0j#($%)#! 03:'+!%'! G'3!)!(! NH##%#(! -#! '(=B4! d[[^PB! c'+! -#! H##%#(! NVWWZP!<br />

?'3!:'3'(!%)'4! ='@'3!! +$+.#:)#! =0:@0+.3':')'! >0(6%36! &'-'3'%)!(:'! +!('+!%)'!<br />

=0:@0+.! 7!!%!%)'! ='%'33'(!%! 036.66%6! -#! ='(!.!(:'! 7'@!3:':'+!! )6(6:6%)'!<br />

-#($:+$>!G$(!=0:@0+.3':'%!%!:#7)'%'!A#3#G$3#5#$%$!G$3)$(:$3#()$(B!!<br />

ã!<br />

#=$3! dB! e[! 0 j! =0%.(03! +!5'=3!!%)'4! G'&?#! '.!=3'(!%!%! N?$:_7'@('=_?'3!3!=NC_i_2PP4!<br />

G$70+03$)_70%A'! N2T_ajP! ! -#! #-+#3! ='.!! '.!=3'(!%! N9TaP! =0:@0+.3':'+!%)'!<br />

A#(#=+$%$:! )6763'%! &'-'! )#G$3#($%$%! )##(3#%)$($3:#+$B! \'-'! )#G$+$! G'3'%A!?! =6(6!<br />

:'))#!G'!%'!: ] !AD% bV !5$%+$%)#)$(B!"#1#('%+Y!H##%#(!-#!'(=B!Nd[[^PB!!<br />

!<br />

! WH


\'6A!NVWW]P!0=+$I#%!+#-$7#+$%$%!-#!+#(G#+.!G036=!0('%!%!NP4!'7(!:'!0('%!4!=!D>#($%#!<br />

#.=$3#($%$! ?'3!:!.!(B! 2$(?0=! =0:@0+.3':'! +$+.#:$%)#4! %#:! +#-$7#+$%$%! =0%.(03!<br />

#)$3:#+$!)6(6:6%)'!G036=3'(!'('+!!0=+$I#%!+#-$7#+$!t^!-#!! $+#! @'(?'5!=!<br />

G676.6! +0(6%! 03:'>! -#! :'.#(7'3$%! .0@'=3'%:'+!%!! 0(.')'%! ='3)!(:'=! -#! A('%D3! G$(!<br />

D(D%!D(#.:#=!$?$%!:#='%$=!='(!.!(:'!7'@:'=!A#(#=$(B!<br />

$<br />

^L$$<br />

H0:@0+.3':'! $3#:$%)#! $7$! G$(! :$=(0G$7#3! 1''3$7#.! $?$%! @\3'(B! ;%5'=! n4! #%! 7'7A!%! ='7!@! #=3$! 03'%!<br />

':0%7'=!10(:6!)'&$3!03:'=!D>#(#!G$(?0=!7033'!='7G03'G$3$(B!`?!=0%+#@.4!n\ ] !='7G!%!!<br />

#%!'>'!$%)$(#G$3$(B!!<br />

!<br />

VB! cDD=!j_n!='(!!:!!$3#!n!='7G!%!!#%!'>'!$%)$(:#=!$?$%4!&'-'!)#G$+$!=0%.(03D!<br />

=($.$=! U%#:#! +'&$@.$(B! L3Q#33! -#! '(=B! Nd[[VP! )#%#7+#3! ?'3!:'3'(!%)'! n\ ] !<br />

#:$+70%3'(!!D>#($%)#!+D(#=3$!-#!'('3!=3!!&'-'3'%)!(:'%!%!#.=$+$%$!-#!)0:6>!<br />

ADG(#+$%$%! =0:@0+.3'%:'+!!+!('+!%)'! =0=6! 0366:6%6! G#3$(3#:$3#()$(B! 26!<br />

?'3!:'3'(!%! +0%6564! n\ ] ! #:$+70%6%6%! 1'%! ?'3!:'! :0)6! %#! 036(+'! 03+6%!<br />

.0@3':! &'-'! '=!:!%'! 7D=+#=! )#(#5#)#! G'3!! 03)66%6! AU+.#(:#=.#)$(B!<br />

T0%6?3'(4! '#(0G$=! =0633'()'! :6&'1'>'! +!('+!%)'! &'-'! '=!:!! '>'3!(+'! =0=6!<br />

0366:6%6%)'!'>'3)!!%!!AU+.#(:$.$(B!!H$(5&:'%%!-#!a$..#(!NVWfWP4!.'-6=!<br />

ADG(#+$%$%! =0:@0+.3'%:'+!! +!('+!%)'! N;#(0G$=0.6%!tV0.!?!=!!!03'5'=.!(B!H0:@0+.!:'3>#:#+$%$%!<br />

=6(6! 03:'+!%!! +'3':'=! -#! +.'G$3$>#! #.:#=! $?$%! &'-'! )#$$:$%$%!<br />

A#(?#=3#:#+$%#!)$=='.!#)$3:#3$)$(B!<br />

! WJ


dB! cDD=!j_n!='(!!:!!$3#!n!='7G!%!!#%!'>'!$%)$(:#=!$?$%4!7!!%!%!='@'%:'+!!<br />

$+.#%$3$(B! X!!%!%! G$(! G$%'! $?#($+$%)#! -#7'! 7'(!! A#?$(A#%! G$(! U(.D! '3.!%'!<br />

'3!%:'+!!$3#4!&'-'!'=!:!!)'&'!$7$!=0%.(03!#)$3#G$3$(!-#!7!!%!%!D+.!%0=.'3'(!%)'!<br />

7D=+#=!n\ ] !=0%+'%.('+70%3'(!! +'3'%'G$3$(B! 2U73#5#! 7!!%!7D>#7$%)#%!n\ ] !<br />

)$1D>70%6! '>'3'('=4! =0:@0+..'%! n! ='7!@3'(!! '>'3.!3'G$3$(! NH##%#(! -#! '(=B4!<br />

d[[dPB!<br />

]B! cDD=! j_n! 0('%!%'! +'&$@! ='(!!:3'()'4! =0:@0+.6%! =6(6.63:'+!! 03'+!)!(!<br />

Nj'G(#('!-#!j&$'%A4!VWWgPB!H0:@0+.!%#:!0('%!!)D.DD!>':'%!G$7030I$=!-#!<br />

=$:7'+'3!'=.$-$.#!#%A#33#%$(4!-#!D($=!'+$)$%!)U%DD:D!'>'3!(!ND($=!'+$.!!D(#!<br />

! n\ ] !r!jR d P! Nj'(#74! VWWZPB! K0@3':! &'-'! '=!:!! :$%$:$>#! #)$3$(=#%4!<br />

=6(6:'%!%! :'=+$:$>#! #)$3:#+$! NH0%+#@.! VP! $?$%4! &'-'%!%! +6! .6.:'!<br />

='@'+$.#+$%$%! '-'%.'I!%)'%! 1'7)'3'%:'=! D>#(#! 1'%3'(! e^bZ[! 0 j! '('+!%)'!<br />

=0%.(03! #)$3:#3$)$(B! ;7(!5'4! =0:@0+.6%! 7D>#7! =6(6.63:'+!! 7!!%!<br />

)U%)D(D3)DD%)#!+'3'%:'=.')!(B!!!<br />

n! ='7!@3'(!%!! '>'3.:'=! -#7'! 7'='3':'=! N5'@.6(#P! $?$%! 1'(=3!! '3.#(%'.$1! :#.0.3'(! U%#!<br />

+D(D3:D.D(B! j'(#7! NVWWZP! n\ ] ! #:$+70%3'(!%!! '+$.! $?#($+$%)#%! A#?$(:#7$! -#! n\ ] '3:'+!4! +D.! +!!(!! ADG(#+$! -#! ='(!!:! 0('%!! )D>#%3#7$5$3#(! $3#!<br />

=0:@0+.3'.!(3:'+!%)'! '('.!(!3:!.!(! N9$5&#3! -#! '(=B4! d[[gPB! L3Q#33! -#! '(=B! NVWWfP!<br />

?'3!:'3'(!%)'! &$?G$(! ='.=!! :'))#+$! $?#(:#7#%! 76:6(.'! .'-66! ADG(#+$%$%$%!<br />

=0:@0+.3'.!(!3:'+!%)'4!%#:!0('%!%!%!'%$)#%!td[!%$%!'3.!%'!)D.DD!)6(6:)'4!=6(6!<br />

:'))#! ='7!@3'(!%!%! zt! ][! 03)66%6! G#3$(3#:$3#()$(B! 2(0)$#! -#! '(=B! Nd[[[P!<br />

+.'.$=! 7!!%! -#! Q$%)(0Q! =0:@0+.3'.!(:')'! +!('+!73'! t]]! -#! t! gV! &'5$:! '>'3:'+!!<br />

G$3)$(:$.$(B!!<br />

%F)^F'1-+1!.)+$"('1&)-&.($<br />

H0:@0+.3'.!(:'!+$+.#:3#($!+.'.$=!7!!%3'(4!&'-'3'%)!(:'3!!+.'.$=!7!!%3'(4!='(!.!(:'3!!<br />

7!!%4! &'-'3'%)!(:'3!! -#! ='(!.!(:'3!!7!!%! 03'('=! +!%!13'%)!(!3'G$3$(B! O%b-#++#3! -#7'!<br />

.D%#3!+$+.#:3#($4!7!!%!-#7'!%':36#%3#:#3#($!$?#($+$%#!'3:':'3!4!'7%!!>':'%)'!#=0%0:$=!1'=.U(3#()#!<br />

)$=='.#! '3:'3!)!(B! 2(0$3#(! ADG(#+$%$%! @'>'(! )##($! 03'%! D(D%3#(#! )U%D.D(D3:#+$%)#!<br />

=633'%!3:'=.'!03'%!+$+.#:3#(!''!)'!+!('3'%:!.!(Y!!<br />

!<br />

)6'6-1! 7!!5! 8#1-&! 9:! ;0(3':'3!! &'-'3'%)!(:'! 7'@!3:')'%! :$%$:'3! ='(!.!(:'! $3#! =0:@0+.3'.!(!3:'+!!<br />

+'3'%:'=.')!($N\'6A4!VWW]h!"7%=4!VWWdPB!26!7'=3'!:!A#%#33$=3#!'%'#(0G$=!'(.3'()'!<br />

=0=6!@(0G3#:$%#!703!'?:'7'5'=!7'@('=!-#7'!G'&?#!'.!=3'(!!A$G$!7D=+#=!j_n!0('%!%'!<br />

+'&$@! Nj_n! s^[P! :'.#(7'33#(! $?$%! 67A6%)6(B! H0=6! @(0G3#:$! 036.66%)'4! 7!!%4!<br />

=0=676! U%3#7$5$! G$(! G$701$3.(#! :'.#(7'3$! $3#! U(.D3D(B! T0%! 67A63':'! U3D! &'7-'%3'(!%!<br />

=0:@0+.3'.!(!3:'+!%)'! 7!!%!%! D>#($%$! d^b^[! 5:! ='3!%3!!%)'! G$701$3.#! :'.#(7'3$! $3#!<br />

='@3'%:'+!%)'! =633'%!3:!.!(! NH##%#(! -#! '(=B4! d[[[5PB! 26! +$+.#:3#(! A#%#33$=3#! G$(!<br />

7D=3#7$5$!$3#!7D=+#=!&!>3!!'7(!:'!'':'+!%)'!G$(!=#>4!-#!G$(!=#>!)#!+.'G$3$>'+70%!-#!<br />

03A6%3':'! ':'+!! '('+!%)'! ='(!.!(!3!(B! L#(! ='(!!:! $?#($+$%)#! 0)6%! @'(?'5!=3'(!!<br />

=633'%!3!70(+'4! #3#:#! $3#:$! $3#! V! 5:'(! .'3#G$%$!<br />

! WN


'(.!(:'=.')!(B! L3#=! D+.D! :'.#(7'3! 7#%$! =0:@0+.3'.!(:'! $3#:$! $?$%! 7#%$)#%!<br />

=633'%!3'G$3$(B!<br />

2(0)$#!-#!'(=B!Nd[[[P!G(0$3#(!ADG(#+$!$?$%!+.'.$=!7!!%!+$+.#:$%$!'('.!(:!.!(B!2(0$3#(!<br />

ADG(#+$!$3#!.'3'!-#!70%A'!@'(?'5!=3'(!%!!N]Y^Y^!-_-P!='(!.!(:!3'()!(B!2'3'%A!?!%#:!<br />

0('%!! tgd! -#! j_n! 0('%!!V^!)$(B!X!!%! #=3$! g4e! :! A#%$3$=.#! -#! d4g! :! 7D=+#=3$=.#!<br />

D?A#%!=#+$.3$)$(B!X!!%![4gV!:!7D=+#=3$$%)#!70%A'!@'(?'5!!!7!!%!!D>#($%#!7'@!3:!!<br />

-#! V^! 5:! ='3!%3!!%)'! )'&'! U%5#)#%! D(#.$3#%! =0:@0+.! $3#! U(.D3:D.D(B! X!!%3'(!<br />

@'.0I#%3#($%!70=!#)$3:#+$!$?$%!A#(#=3$!7D=+#=!+!5'=3!=3'('!63':!.!(!Ns^] 0 jP!NL@+.#$%4!<br />

VWWZP!-#!d[[!AD%3D=!=0:@0+.3'.!(:'!+D(#+$%$%!+0%6%)'!&'3'!!+!%:'!='7)#)$3:$.$(B!<br />

X':6(3'('!G'3!!03'('=!]^[!AD%!+0%6%)'!%#:!0('%!!$+#!stg[!03'('=!='7)#)$3:$.$(B!<br />

H0:@0+.! $?#($+$%)#! +0%! n! 0('%!! $+#! tV4]! 03'('=! A#(?#=3#:$.$(B! 26! ?'3!:'%!%!<br />

+0%6?3'(!%'!AU(#4!G(0$3#(!ADG(#+$%$%!'?!=.'!=0:@0+.3'.!(!3:'+!!@'>'(!.'3#G$!$?$%!=6(6!<br />

-#!+.'G$3!G$(!D(D%#!)U%D:#+$%$!+'3':':'=.')!(B!!<br />

H##%#(! -#! L3Q#33! Nd[[]P! 76:6(.'! .'-66! ADG(#+$%$! j0(.! k$1.3$$%)#!<br />

=0:@0+.3'.!(!3:'+!%!! ?'3!:!3'()!(! N#=$3! gPB! CDG(#! 7!3! +0%6%)'! .0@3'%:'=.'! -#!<br />

][MWV! :! G076.3'(!%)'! Å6'%+#.! G$%'+!%'! 7#(3#.$($3:#=.#)$(B! d4^! :$370%! &'7-'%)'%!<br />

0(.'7'!?!='%!7!33!=!Zd^!.0%!ADG(#!td^!%#:$%!'3.!%)'!G$%'!$?#($+$%#!'3!%:'=.')!(B!26!<br />

G$%'! \'>$('%! VWWW! .'($&$%)#! $3#.:#7#! '3!%:!! -#! K#::6>! d[[[! .'($&$%)#! 7'%A!%!<br />

?!=:!.!(B!2$%'!$?#($+$%)#!:'.#(7'3!G$%'%!%!7'(+!%'!=')'(!.'-'%)'%!]!:!''!7'!=')'(!<br />

)03)6(63:'=.')!(B!9'.#(7'3!ebVd!'7!+0%6%)'!=0:@0+.!03'('=!+'.!3:'=.')!(B!9'.#(7'3!<br />

+!5'=3!!! ][! 5:! )#($%3$=.#! ^[b^]! 0 j! +!5'=3!=3'('! 63':!.!(B! c#@03':'! '3'%!%'!<br />

AU%)#($3#%! ADG(#%$%! %#:! )##($! tV[bd[! -#! =D3! $?#($$! $+#! t^^bgZ! )$(! -#! ADG(#%$%!<br />

G'(!%'=.'%!?!=:!!&'3$%$%!G$3#!$7$!)#(#5#)#!'7(!.!!%!!AU+.#(:#=.#)$(B!9'.#(7'3$%!=D3!<br />

$?#($$!-#!%#:!0('%!%!%!)#@03':'!+D(#+$%)#!U%#:3$!)#(#5#)#!)#$:#:#+$!G$7030I$=!<br />

'7(!:'%!%! 03)6=?'! '>! 03)66%6! AU+.#(:#=.#)$(B! `(D%D%! n! $?#($$! $+#! t! gb^4V!<br />

'('+!%)'!)#$:#=.#)$(B!H6(6!ADG(#%$%!GD7D=!7!!%3'()'!G$(!?'.!!'3.!%)'!)#@03'%:'+!!<br />

$3#!G#+$%!#3#:#%.3#($%$%!=0(6%:'+!%!!'7%!!>':'%)'!GU5#=!-#!+$%#=!@0@D3'+70%6%6%!<br />

=0%.(03!#)$3:#+$%$!+'3':'=.')!(B!;%5'=!ADG(#%$%!GD7D=!7!!%3'(!&'3$%)#!td^!%#:$%!<br />

D>#($%)#! )#@03'%:'+!! ?0=! 7D=+#=! +!5'=3!=3'('! ?!=:'+!%'! %#)#%! 03:'=.'! -#!<br />

&'-'3'%)!(:'!03:')'%!7'%A!%!03'+'3!=3'(!%!!'(.!(:'=.')!(B!$<br />

!<br />

#=$3!]B!2$($%5$!1'>!'':'+!%)'!+.'.$=!<br />

7!!%!036.6(63:'+!!N9$5&#34!d[VVP!<br />

!<br />

#=$3! gB! K'-6=! ADG(#+$! $?$%! +.'.$=!<br />

7!!%!)#@03':'!+$+.#:$!<br />

!<br />

='>'&'5?!+('&!! )6'6-1! 7!!5! 8#1-&@! A:! B:! C#($%)#!%#A'.$-#!G'+!%?!$3#!&'-'3'%)!(:'!7'@!3:'=.'!-#!<br />

! WT


!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

?!='%! A'>3'(!%! G$701$3.(#! +$+.#:$%)#%! A#?:#+$! +'3':'=.')!(! N#=$3! ePB! C#(#=3$! 03'%!<br />

&'-'3'%)!(:'!:$=.'(!!=0:@0+.3'.!(!3'5'=!D(D%#!AU(#!1'(=3!3!=!AU+.#(:#=.#)$(!NH##%#(!<br />

-#!'(=B4!VWWZ4!d[[[G4!d[[^PB!<br />

#=$3!<br />

^B!<br />

\'-'3'%)!(:'3!!+.'.$=!<br />

7!!%! +$+.#:$b! @0>$.$1!<br />

&'-'3'%)!(:'3!!!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

#=$3!<br />

eB!<br />

\'-'3'%)!(:'3!! +.'.$=!<br />

7!!%! +$+.#:$b!<br />

G$701$3.(#3$! %#A'.$1!<br />

&'-'3'%)!(:'3!!<br />

!<br />

X!!%!G076.3'(!!A#%#33$=3#!d4^!:!7D=+#=3$=!-#!][!:!<br />

'7(!:'+!%'! +#G#@! 03:'=.')!(B! X!!%! 7D=+#=3$$%$%! 67A6%! G#3$(3#%:#+$! :'.#(7'3$%!<br />

%#:!$?#($$!$?$%!03)6=?'!U%#:3$)$(!Nc'+!-#!H##%#(4!VWWZPB!!<br />

26!7'=3'!:!!=633'%'%!#%!+0%!.#=%030I$3#(4!7':6(6!A#?$(:#7#%!G036=36!A#0.#M.$3#!<br />

U(.D!=633'%!:!!$3#!=0=6!0366:6!#%A#33#%:#=.#)$(B!26!.D(!G$(!+$+.#:!CR"L!+7+.#:!<br />

03'('=!$+$:3#%)$($3#%!.$5'($!+$+.#:)$(B!26!+$+.#:)#!:'.#(7'33#(!U%!='(!.!(:')'%!+0%('4!<br />

&'-'3'%)!(:'! '3'%!%'! 7#(3#.$($3$(4! D>#($! U(.D3D! -#! dbg! &'1.'! +D(#+$%5#!<br />

&'-'3'%)!(!3:'=.')!(B! m(.D! )'&'! +0%('! ?!='(!3!(! -#! :'.#(7'3! ='(!.!(!3'('=!<br />

03A6%3'.!(:'!7!!%!%'!'3!%!(B!C0#.#M.$3#!U(.D3#(!$3#!.'-6=!ADG(#+$!=0:@0+.3'.!(!3:'+!!<br />

&'==!%)'!G$3$:+#3!G$(!'('.!(:'!G636%:':'+!%'!(':#%4!U(.D!'3.!%)'!='3'%!ADG(#)#!n!<br />

.6.63:'+!! &'==!%)'! G'>!! ='%!.3'(! G636%:'=.')!(! NJ'(#! -#! '(=B4! d[[VPB! m(.D%D%!<br />

=0:@0+.! 7D>#7$%#! G'='%! '3.! 7D>#7$%)#! 036'%! G$01$3:! '::0%7'=!! A'>3'(!! .6.670(! 03'G$3$(B! TD.! +!!(!!$3#.:#+$! ADG(#+$! $3#! 7'@!3'%! ?'3!:'4!<br />

A#0.#M.$3#! =633'%!:!%!%! '>0.! ='7!@3'(!%!! '>'3..!!%!! G$3)$($3:$.$(! NT0::#(4! d[[VPB!<br />

K'-6=! ADG(#+$%$%! =0:@0+.3'.!(!3:'+!%)'! '>0.! $?#($$%$%! >#%A$%3#.$($3:#+$! $?$%!<br />

U(.D3#($%! =633'%!:!%!%! #=0%0:$=! G$(! ?U>D:! 03:'+!%'! (':#%4! G6! 1'7)'7!! 0(.'7'!<br />

=07:'=!$?$%!$3#($!'('.!(:'3'('!A#(#=!G636%:'=.')!(B!!<br />

!<br />

.'+!6!+('&!! 7!!5) 8#1-&! E:! F:! GH6%366!=($.$=!)#$3)$(!-#!'3'%!A#(#=+$%$:$!$3#!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

#=$3! ZB! m(.D3D!<br />

&'-'3'%)!(:'3!!<br />

+.'.$=!7!!%!+$+.#:$!!<br />

C0(#! =0:@0+.3':'!<br />

+$+.#:$<br />

! WW


+!%!(3!)!(B!H'(!.!(:'3!!7!!%!+$+.#:3#($!G'&?#!'.!=3'(!%)'%!+!!(!ADG(#+$!A$G$!?0=!1'(=3!!<br />

'.!=3'(!$?$%!=633'%!3'G$3$(!)6(6:)')!(B!!<br />

H0:@0+.! @(0(0>$.#+$%$%! st][! 03:'+!! '#(0G$=! '(.3'(!%! +'3'%:'+!! $?$%! U%#:3$)$(4!<br />

?D%=D!+.'.$=!7!!%)'3'()'!03)66!A$G$!+$+.#:$%!&'-'3'%)!(!3:'+!!)0'3!=0%-#=+$70%!$3#!<br />

+'3'%:'=.')!(B! ;!(!! G036=! NstZ[P! 7!!%3'(!%! =#%)$3$$%)#%! !+!%:'+!%!!<br />

#%A#33#7#G$3:#=.#)$(! N9$5&#3! -#! '(=B4! d[[gPB! X!!%3'(!%! ='(!.!(!3:'+!! 0=+$I#%!<br />

-#($3:#+$%$!+'3'7'G$3$(!'%5'=!##(!7!!%)'!7#.#($%5#!@0(0>$.#!70=+'4!7!!%!%!:#(=#>$!<br />

'%'#(0G$=!'(.3'('! )'=$='3'(! $?$%)#!A#3:#=.#)$(! NH##%#(!-#! '(=B4! d[[^PB!H'(!.!(:'3!!<br />

7!!%3'(! =6(6! $=3$:! GU3A#3#($%)#! %#:! 0('%!! '?!+!%)'%! +!=!%.!3'('! 703! '?'G$3:#=.#)$(B!<br />

K'+'(3'%'%! G$(?0=! ='(!.!(!5!! 7D=+#=! &!>3!! =0:@0+.3'.!(:'! $?$%! A#(#=3$! %#:! 0('%!%!!<br />

+'3'7'5'=!+63':'!#=$@:'%3'(!!$3#!'=6@3#!&'3)#!G636%:'=.')!(B!!<br />

a$%)(0Q! +$+.#:3#($! +!=3!=3'! '7(!'G$3$(3$$! 7D=+#=! :'.#(7'3! =633'%!3)!!%)'! =0=6!<br />

0366:6%'! +#G#@! 03:'=.')!(B! H0=6! 0366:6%6! :$%$:$>#! #.:#%$%! G$(! 7036! 7!!%!<br />

+!5'=3!!%!!^f! 0 j!%$%!'3.!%)'!.6.:'=.!(!N9$33#(4!VWW]PB!26!)6(6:!7!!%!G076.3'(!%!%4!<br />

%#:! $?#($$%$%! -#! @0(0>$.#%$%! '7'(3'%:'+!! $3#! +'3'%'G$3$(B! 2$(! )$#(! :#.0.! $+#!<br />

7!!%3'(!%! ='?'%! =0=63'(!! .6.'%! G$(! G$701$3.(#! :'.#(7'3$! $3#! U(.D3:#+$! -#! 7!!%3'(!%!<br />

)U%)D(D3:#+$%$%!7!!%!+!5'=3!=3'(!%!%!s^f! 0 j!03)66!)6(6:'!=')'(!#(.#3#%:#+$)$(B!!!<br />

2(0)$#! -#! '(=B! Nd[[[P! G(0$3#(! ADG(#+$! $?$%! +.'.$=! 7!!%! =0:@0+.3'.!(:'! +$+.#:$%$%!<br />

@#(10(:'%+!%!! $%5#3#:$3#()$(B! 2(0$3#(! ADG(#+$%$! .'3'! -#! 70%A'! @'(?'5!!! $3#! dY]Y]!<br />

N-_-P! 0('%3'(!%)'! ='(!.!(:!3'()!(B! 2'3'%A!?! %#:! $?#($$! tgd! -#! j_n! 0('%!! Vg#($! U(.D3:#:$! -#! &#(! V[! AD%)#! G$(! )U%)D(D3:#=.#)$(B!<br />

X!!%! +!5'=3!=3'(!! 7D=+#=! +!5'=3!=3'('! #($:$! Ns^] 0 jP4! 1'='.! &#(G$(! ='(!.!(:')'%!<br />

+0%('!=!+'!+D(#3#(!$3#!p:6&.#:#3#%!)DD=!7!!%!G076.3'(!!%#)#%$73#b!)D:D.D(B!V[[!<br />

AD%! +0%6%)'! 7!!%! +!5'=3!=3'(!! 0(.':! +!5'=3!=3'(!%'! )D:D.D(B! W! '73!=!<br />

=0:@0+.3'.!(:'!+D(#+$%5#!&'5$:!'>'3:'+!!t^W!03:6.6(B!T0%!%#:!$?#($$!tdd!-#!n!<br />

0('%!! tV4[V! 03'('=! U3?D3:D.D(B! 2'3'%A!?! U3?D:3#($%#! AU(#! '>0.! ='7G!%!%! tZe!<br />

03'('=! &#+'@3'%)!!! G$3)$($3:#=.#)$(B! 26! ?'3!:'%!%! +0%6?3'(!%'! AU(#4! G(0$3#(!<br />

ADG(#+$%$%!'?!=!&'-'!'(.3'(!%)'4!='(!.!(:'3!!7!!%!+$+.#:3#($%)#!=0:@0+.3'.!(!3:'+!!<br />

7D=+#=!n!+#-$7#+$%)#4!=6(6!-#!+.'G$3!G$(!+0%!D(D%#!)U%D.D(D3#:#:#=.#)$(!-#!7D=+#=!<br />

='3$.#3$!G$(!D(D%!03'('=!@'>'()'!+!%!(3!!G$(!+#-$7#)#!='3'G$3#5#$!G$3)$($3:$.$(B!!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

#=$3! fB! k#=$3$(! .$@! #=$3! WB! X'%)'%! G0'3.:'3!! #=$3! V[B! H#%)$!<br />

='(!.!(5!3!!?#-($3#%!7!!%B! 7!!%!?#-$($5$!N9$5&#34!d[VVP! 7D(D(! ?#-$($5$!<br />

Nj0(%#33! ,%$-B4!<br />

d[VVP!<br />

!<br />

[,E@&''&-$ P&A(-$ !!h$ !Ch$ !HSE! O%b-#++#3! +$+.#:3#($! +!=3!=3'! +')#5#! =0:@0+.6!<br />

&'-'3'%)!(:'=! $?$%! )#$3! '7%!! >':'%)'! :#='%$=! 03'('=! ='(!.!(:'=! $?$%! )$>'7%!<br />

#)$3:$.$(B!K'($&+#3!03'('=4!)$=#7!+$303'(4!7'.'7!)$=)U(.A#%!7'@!3'(4!7D(D7#%!G'%.3'(!-#!<br />

)$#(3#($%)#%! 036:'=.')!(B! \'6A4! NVWW]P4! $%b-#++#3! +$+.#:3#($%$%! )#.'73'(!%!!<br />

-#(:#=.#)$(B! 26! +$+.#:3#($%! $3#.:#! @'(':#.(#3#($! \'6A! NVWW]P! -#! H##%#(! -#! '(=B!<br />

! WZ


NVWW]4!d[[^P!.'('1!%)'%!)#.'73!!03'('=!-#($3:$.$(B!26!+$+.#:$%!?'.!!'3.!%)'!A#(?#=3##%!<br />

G$(! -#(+$70%6! .D%#3! +$+.#:$)$(! -#! +$+.#:)#%! ?!='%! &'-'! .':':#%! =0%.(03! '3.!%)')!(!<br />

1'='.! ?#-$(:#! +$+.#:$! G636%:':'=.')!(! N\'6A4! VWW]PB! O%b-#++#3! +$+.#:3#($! &#(! .D(3D!<br />

:'.#(7'3!$?$%!=633'%!3'G$3$(!'%5'=!@'(.$=D3!GD7D=3DD!U%#:3$)$(B!26(')'!:''3$7#.3#($!<br />

'>'3.:'=! $?$%! U%#($3#%! ZbdV! AD%3D=! '=.$1! =0:@0+.3'.!(:'! )U%#:$%$%$%! $%b-#++#3!<br />

+$+.#:)#! A#(?#=3#.$($3:#+$%$%! '()!%)'%! 03A6%3'.!(:'! '':'+!%)'! &'-'3'%)!(:'3!!<br />

7!!%!+$+.#:$%)#!G#=3#.$3:#=.#)$(B!O%b-#++#3!+$+.#:3#($!7D=+#=!$3#.:#!-#!$3=!7'.!(!:!<br />

:'3$7#.3#($%#! +'&$@.$(! -#! $3#%#5#=! :'.#(7'34! ?#-(#+#3! +0(6:3636=3'(! -#! G$($:! D(D%!<br />

G'!%'!$3#.:#!:'+('1!!$3#!&#+'@3'%:'3!)!(B!!!<br />

H##%#(! -#! '(=B! Nd[[dP! &'-'3'%)!(:'3!! ='(!.!(:'3!! 7!!%)'! c'73'7! X6:6(.'!<br />

k$1.3$$%)#!?'3!:'3'()'!G636%:6.6(B!k$1.3$=!VBe!:$370%!.'-6=!='@'+$.#+$%)#!D(#.$:!<br />

7'@:'=.')!(B!K'-6=3'(!f!'7(!!=D:#+.#h!g!.'%#+$!V^[[[[!3$=!)##@!@$.!+$+.#:$%)#!-#!g!<br />

.'%#+$! d^[[[[! ='@'+$.#3#($! ='1#+! +$+.#:$%)#! G'%.3!! =0%-#7U(3D! ADG(#! ?!='(.:'!<br />

+$+.#:$%#!N]!AD%)#!G$(P!+'&$@.$(B!K'!%'%!ADG(#!d!'7(!!G$%'!$?#($+$%)#!G636%'%!T'3:#.!<br />

=0:@0+.! ='(!.!(!5!+!%'! +'&$@! .#+$+#4! 7D+=#=! ='3$.#3$! =6(6! ADG(#! D(#.:#=! $?$%!<br />

'3!%:'=.')!(B! H633'%!3'%! $=$! ')#.! =0:@+0.3'.!(:'! G$%'+!%)'%! G$($%5$+$4! edMVgV! :!<br />

G076.3'(!%)'!Vd!=0:@0+.!+!('+!!-#!f!#A>0+!1'%!4!$=$%5$!=0:@0+.!G$%'+!!$+#!]VMVgV!:!<br />

G076.3'(!%)'! e! +!('3!! -#! g! #A>0+! 1'%3!! +$+.#:)$(B! T$+.#:! 6! #=$3)#! $3#.$3:#=.#)$(h!<br />

&$?G$(! #=+.('! :'.#(7'3! $3#! ='(!.!(!3:'7'%! .'-6=! ADG(#+$! N%#:! $?#($$! zt^^P! .D%#3!<br />

+$+.#:$%$%! A$($$%#! 7D=3#%$(B! KD%#3$%! V_]! 3D=! $3=! =!+:!%)'! &'-'3'%)!(:'!<br />

G636%:'=.')!(B! KD%#3! $?#($+$%)#=$! :'.#(7'3! &#(! ]! AD%)#! G$(! ^e! AD%! G076%5'!<br />

='(!.!(!3!(B! \#(G$(! ='(!.!(:')'! :'.#(7'3! e! :! $3#($7#! .'!%:'=.')!(B! Vf! ='(!.!(:'!<br />

+0%6%)'! :'.#(7'3! .D%#3! )!!%)'! 03A6%3'.!(:'! GU3:#+$%#! '3!%:'=.')!(B! 2$%'!<br />

$?#($+$%)#=$! ':0%7'=! +#-$7#+$! W[bVe[! @@:! 03'('=! #A>0+! 1'%!%!%! ?'3!:'+!%'! G'3!!<br />

03'('=! )#$:#=.#)$(B! T$+.#:#! A$(#%! &':! ADG(#%$%! U>#33$=3#($! tgWb^]! %#:! $?#($$4!<br />

t][b][4Z!=D3!$?#($$4!t^4Wb^Z!n!-#!j_n!0('%!!^4[be4]'7%!&'-'!)#G$+$!zV!: ] !AD% bV !=A ): bV !<br />

03'('=! '3!%'G$3$(B! ;('3!=3!! &'-'3'%)!(:'! '>0.! ='7!@3'(!%!! '>'3.:'=! $?$%! .'-+$7#!<br />

#)$3#G$3$(B! H'.=!! $3'-#+$>! .'-6=! ADG(#+$_G(0$3#(! ADG(#+$%$%! =0:@0+.3':'+!! =0%6+6%)'!<br />

7'@!3'%! ?'3!:'3'(4! 7D=+#=! n\ ] ! +#-$7#3#($%)#! ='@'3!! G$%'3'()'=$! &'-'3'%)!(:'3!! -#!<br />

?#-$(:#3$! 7!!%3'(!%4! 0(I$%'3! '>0.6! =0(67'5'!! -#! =6(6! G$(! D(D%! #3)#! #)$3:#+$%)#!<br />

=633'%!3'G$35#$%$! AU+.#(:$.$(B! K'-6=! ADG(#+$_)!=!! $?$%4! G$.:$! =0:@0+.! tV[bVf!<br />

%#:)#!-#!t]4e!'>0.!$?#($$%)#!03'G$3:#=.#)$(B!!<br />

!<br />

! W]


#=$3! VVB! l0(3':'3!!<br />

&'-'3'%)!(:'3!! -#!<br />

?#-$(:#3$! $%b-#++#3!<br />

+$+.#:$!N"7%=4!VWWdP!<br />

#=$3! VdB! c'73'7! $3#.:#+$%)#!<br />

50:@0+.! G$%'+!! -#! ?#-$(:#!<br />

:'=$%'+!! X!!%3'(! >0(3':'3!!<br />

&'-'3'%)!(:'3!!-#!?#-$(:#3$)$(!<br />

! Z#<br />

!#=$3! V]B! c'73'7!<br />

$3#.:#+$%)#! G$.:$!<br />

50:@0+.B! H0:@0+.!<br />

%#:$! tV[btd[! -#!<br />

A('%D3#(!7'@!)')!(!!<br />

!<br />

?&&AAO.$<br />

;('.!(!5!3'(!%!:''3'(!!-#!'('.!(:'!)#+.#$!,BTB!C('$%+!j06%5$3!Vg[[!H!T.(##.4!na4!<br />

T6$.#! Vd[[4! a'+&$%A.0%4! cj! d[[[^! -#! .&#! R&$0! ;A($563.6('3! "#+#'(5&! '%)!<br />

c#-#30@:#%.! j#%.#(4! K&#! R&$0! T.'.#! ,%$-#(+$.74! a00+.#(4! R\! ggeWV'.$0%B!V[NVPYVebdfB!<br />

L=$%5$4! HB4! \B9B! H##%#(! '%)! cBiB! L3Q#33B! d[[dB! j0:@0+.$%A! +&0(.! @'@#(! 1$G#(! Q$.&! G(0$3#(! 3$..#(! '%)!<br />

'))$.$-#+B!OOB!L-'36'.$0%!'%)!0@.$:$>'.$0%!01!)#50:@0+$.$0%!('.#!-#(+6+!:$M$%A!('.$0B!j0:@0+.!T5$#%5#!u!<br />

,.$3$>'.$0%B!V[NVPYVebdfB!!<br />

L=$%5$4!HB4!\B!9B!H##%#(h!*B!jB!9$5&#34!w(Bh!cB!iB!L3Q#33B!!d[[g'B!!90)#3$%A!50:@0+.$%A!('.#!'+!'!16%5.$0%!<br />

01!.#:@#('.6(#!'%)!$%$.$'3!:0$+.6(#!50%.#%.B!!j0:@0+.!T5$#%5#!'%)!,.$3$>'.$0%B!VdNgPY]^eb]egB!!<br />

L=$%5$4! HB4! \B9B! H##%#(4! cBiB! L3Q#334! *BjB! 9$5&#34! w(B! d[[gGB! L11#5.+! 01! '#('.$0%! +.('.#A$#+! 0%! .&#!<br />

50:@0+.$%A!@(05#++B!!J'(.!O!b!LM@#($:#%.'3!+.6)$#+B!!K('%+'5.$0%+!01!;T;LB!!gZN^PY!VeWZbVZ[fB!<br />

L3Q#334!cB!iB4!\B9B!H##%#(4!cBTB!j'(#7!'%)!JBJB!T5&3'=B!!VWWfB!!!j0:@0+.$%A!6%':#%)#)!5&$5=#%!:'%6(#B!!<br />

j0:@0+.!T5$#%5#!u!,.$3$>'.$0%!eNdPY!ddb]^B!<br />

L3Q#334!cBiB4!\B9B!H##%#(4!9BjB!a$3#+4!cBjB!20(A#(!'%)!iB2B!a$33#..B!!d[[VB!R)0(06+!#:$++$0%+!'%)!0)0(!<br />

50%.(03! $%! 50:@0+.$%A! +Q$%#! :'%6(#_+'Q)6+.! :$M#+! 6+$%A! 50%.$%06+! '%)! $%.#(:$..#%.! '#('.$0%B!!<br />

K('%+'5.$0%+!01!.&#!;T;LB!ggN^PYV][ZbV]VeB!<br />

L@+.#$%4!LB!!VWWZB!K&#!+5$#%5#!01!50:@0+.$%AB!K#5&%0:$5!J6G3$+&$%A!j0:@'%74!O%5B4!i'%5'+.#(4!J;B!<br />

\'6A4! "BKB! ! VWW]B! K&#! J('5.$5'3! \'%)G00=! 01! j0:@0+.! L%A$%##($%AB! i#Q$+! J6G3$+&#(+4! 205'! "'.0%4!<br />

*iB\'%+#%4!"BjB4!\B9B!H##%#(4!jB!9'(6AA4!aB;B!c$5=4!'%)!\B;BwB!\0$.$%=B!VWW]B!j0:@0+.$%A!01!@063.(7!<br />

:'%6(#B!!@@B!!V]VbV^]B!O%Y!\B;BwB!\0$.$%=!'%)!\B9B!H##%#(!N#)+BP!T5$#%5#!'%)!L%A$%##($%A!01!j0:@0+.$%AY!!<br />

c#+$A%4! L%-$(0%:#%.'34! 9$5(0G$030A$5'3! '%)! ,.$3$>'.$0%! ;+@#5.+B! "#%'$++'%5#! J6GB4! a0(.&$%A.0%4! R\B!<br />

\0$.$%=4! \B;BwB4! '%)! \B9B! H##%#(! N#)+BPB! VWW]'B! T5$#%5#! '%)! #%A$%##($%A! 01! 50:@0+.$%AY! ! )#+$A%4!<br />

#%-$(0%:#%.'34!:$5(0G$030A$5'3!'%)!6.$3$>'.$0%!'+@#5.+B!Zdf!@B!"#%'$++'%5#!J6GB4!a0(.&$%A.0%4!R&$0B!<br />

H##%#(4! \B9B4! jB! 9'(6AA4! "BjB! \'%+#%4! '%)! \B;BwB! \0$.$%=B! ! VWW]B! ! R@.$:$>$%A! .&#! #11$5$#%57! 01! .&#!<br />

50:@0+.$%A!@(05#++B!!@B!^WbWgB!O%!\B!;B!wB!\0$.$%=!'%)!\B!9B!H##%#(!N#)+BP!T5$#%5#!'%)!#%A$%##($%A!01!


50:@0+.$%AY! c#+$A%4! #%-$(0%:#%.'34! :$5(0G$030A$5'3! '%)! 6.$3$>'.$0%! '+@#5.+B! "#%'$++'%5#! J6GB4!<br />

a0(.&$%A.0%4!R\B!<br />

H##%#(4! \B9B4! "BjB! \'%+#%! '%)! cBiB! L3Q#33B! ! VWWZB! ;$(130Q! .&(06A&! 50:@0+.Y! )#+$A%! '%)! 50+.!<br />

$:@3$5'.$0%+B!!;@@3$#)!L%AB!;A($5B!V]N]PY!]ZZb]fgB!!<br />

H##%#(4!\B9B4!aB;B!c$5=!'%)!\B;BwB!\0$.$%=B!d[[['B!j0:@0+.$%A!'%)!G#%#1$5$'3!6.$3$>'.$0%!01!50:@0+.#)!<br />

G7b@(0)65.!:'.#($'3+B!!j&'@.#(!V[B!@@B!]V^b]gVB!O%Y!wB*B!J0Q#(!#.!'3B!N#)+BP!2#%#1$5$'3!6+#+!01!'A($563.6('34!<br />

$%)6+.($'3!'%)!:6%$5$@'3!G7b@(0)65.+B!T0$3!T5$#%5#!T05$#.7!01!;:#($5'B!9')$+0%4!a$+50%+$%B!<br />

H##%#(4!\B9B4!HB!L=$%5$4!cBiB!L3Q#33!'%)!*BjB!9$5&#3BB!d[[[GB!9'.&#:'.$5+!01!50:@0+.$%Ab1'5$3$.7!)#+$A%!<br />

'%)! @(05#++! 50%.(03B! ! @@B! VegbVWZB! O%Y! JB"B! a'(:'%! '%)! 2B"B! K'730(! N#)+BP! J(05##)$%A+! $%.#(%'.$0%'3!<br />

50:@0+.$%A!+7:@0+$6:!NOjT'.$0%! )6($%A! '#(0G$5! '%)! '%'#(0G$5! :'%6(#!<br />

)#50:@0+$.$0%B!J3'%.!'%)!T0$3!VV^Y]^bgVB!<br />

9$5&#3! w(B4! *BjB4! wB;B! J#55&$'4! wB! "$A0.4! \B9B! H##%#(B! ! d[[gB! ! 9'++! '%)! %6.($#%.! 30++#+! )6($%A! .&#!<br />

50:@0+.$%A!01!)'$(7!:'%6(#!':#%)#)!Q$.&!+'Q)6+.!0(!+.('QB!!!j0:@0+.!T5$#%5#!'%)!,.$3$>'.$0%B!VdNgPY]d]b<br />

]]gB!<br />

9$5&#34! *B9B! d[VVB! j&'@.#(! gY! j0:@0+.$%A! 9#.&0)+B! d %) ! (#-B! #)B! ! R%b*'(:! j0:@0+.$%A!<br />

\'%)G00=B4n";LTb^gB!!n'.6('3!"#+06(5#4!;A($563.6(#4!'%)!L%A$%##($%A!T#(-$5#B!!O%!@(#++B!<br />

9$33#(4!*BjB!!VWW]B!9$%$:$>$%A!0)0(!A#%#('.$0%B!@B!dVWbdgV!*&)\B!;B!wB!\0$.$%=!'%)!\B!9B!H##%#(!N#)+BP!<br />

T5$#%5#! '%)! #%A$%##($%A! 01! 50:@0+.$%AY! c#+$A%4! #%-$(0%:#%.'34! :$5(0G$030A$5'3! '%)! 6.$3$>'.$0%! '+@#5.+B!<br />

"#%'$++'%5#!J6GB4!a0(.&$%A.0%4!R\B!<br />

900(#4! w(B4JB;B4! KBjB! c'%$#34! ;BnB! T&'(@3#74! '%)! jBaB! a00)B4! VWW^B! J063.(7! 9'%6(#! 9'%'A#:#%.Y!<br />

L%-$(0%:#%.'3!+06%)!0@.$0%+B!wB!T0$3!'%)!a'.#(!j0%+B!^[N]P!]dVY]dZB!!<br />

Rj;99B! d[VVB! R@.$:$>$%A! j0:@0+.! 9$M$%A! "'.$0+!! N:#.($5! 6%$.+P! &..@Y__QQQB0'()5B0&$0b<br />

+.'.#B#)6_05'::_.[Vå@'A#-$#Qd_a0(=+&0@+å'%)åj0%1#(#%5#+B&.:!Ng_Z_d[VVP!<br />

J'(Ç4! 9B4! KBjB! J'63$.>4! HB;B! T.#Q'(.B! d[[VB! j0:@0+.$%A! 01! 5(65$1#(! Q'+.#+! 6+$%A! A#0.#M.$3#! 50-#(+B!!<br />

j0:@0+.!T5$#%5#!'%)!,.$3$>'.$0%B!!803B!f4!n0B!VB!]ebg^B!<br />

"$..#(4! aB*B! '%)! iB9B! T.#&(B! d[[ZB! ! L%-$(0%:#%.'3! '%)! L50%0:$5! +6+.'$%'G3#! J03$5$#+! 10(! .&#! @063.(7!<br />

O%)6+.(7!$%!T6++#M!506%.7!c#3'Q'(#B!!O%.#(%'.$0%'3!T7:@0+$6:!0%!;$(!Å6'3$.7!'%)!a'+.#!9'%'A#:#%.!10(!<br />

;A($563.6(#B!2(00:1$#3)4!jRB!T#@.#:G#(B!;T;2L!J6G3$5'.$0%!n0B!Z[VJ[W[Z5)B!!<br />

"7%=4! "B! N#)BP! VWWdB! R%! 1'(:! 50:@0+.$%A! &'%)G00=B! ! n";LTb^gB! j00@#('.$-#! LM.#%+$0%! T#(-$5#4!<br />

n0(.&#'+.!"#A$0%'3!;A($563.6('3!L%A$%##($%A!T#(-$5#4!j0(%#33!,%$-B4!O.&'5'4!nXB!<br />

T0::#(4! TBCB!d[[VB!L11#5.!01!50:@0+.$%A!0%!%6.($#%.!30++!'%)!%$.(0A#%!'-'$3'G$3$.7!01!5'..3#!)##@!3$..#(B!!<br />

L6(0@#'%!w06(%'3!01!;A(0%0:7B!VgYVd]bV]]B!<br />

K6G'$34!HB4!iB!j&#%4!*BjB!9$5&#34!\B9B!H##%#(4!wB!"$A0.4!9B!H3$%A:'%4!cB!H0+.!'%)!aB;B!c$5=B!!d[[fB!<br />

C7@+6:! '))$.$0%+! (#)65#! '::0%$'! %$.(0A#%! 30++#+! )6($%A! 50:@0+.$%A! 01! )'$(7! :'%6(#! '%)! G$0+03$)+B!<br />

j0:@0+.!T5$#%5#!'%)!,.$3$>'.$0%B!VeNgPYdf^bdW]B!<br />

!<br />

! Z!


" #!# $B1-(A$V(-(_$>O;.&-&.(,(,$?O.A(5&$?+.!)!,/+A($8,&)($@&$<br />

%7--+,!)$4567-+)+-+.!$<br />

;3")P+").L)J,,0%-'#%.&+)'&8)*7,.$#'&-").L)E$.%0"$)A'&1$")%&);1$)#=$! )#$$=! GU3A#3#()#! U>#33$=3#! )#! 706%! .'-6=! @0@63'+70%6%'! +'&$@! #%.#A(#!<br />

G(0$3#(!$3#.:#3#($%)#!0(.'7'!?!='%!'.!=3'(!U%#:3$!?#-(#+#3!+0(6%3'(!036.6(:'=.')!(B!k#-(#7$!<br />

('&'.+!>! #)$5$! =U.D!=0=63'(! 7'7'%! '.!=!U>#33$$%)#=$!G6!.'>#!.'-6=!)!=!3'(!4!'7%!!>':'%)'!<br />

5$))$! =$(3#.$5$! #.=$3#($! %#)#%$73#! 7#('3.!! -#! 7#(D+.D! +6! ='7%'=3'(!! '?!+!%)'%! )'! ?#-(#+#3!<br />

='7A!3'(! 036.6(:'=.')!(B! c$#(! .'('1.'%! $3#.:#3#()#! )#@03':'! -#! )U%D.D(:#! 03'%'=3'(!!<br />

@#=! G636%:')!!%)'%4! '?!=.'! G0! '('>$3#()#! =0%.(03+D>! GD7D=! 7!!%3'(! #=3$%)#!<br />

G#=3#.$3:#3#($%#! G'3!! 03'('=! U%#:3$! +'3!=! @(0G3#:3#($! )#! 7'('.'G$3:#=.#)$(B! 26%6%3'!<br />

G$(3$=.#4!G(0$3#(!)!=!3'(!!67A6%!7U%.#:3#(3#!)U%DD:3#($!+'3'%)!!%)'4!D3=#:$>!.'(!:!%)'!<br />

$))#.3#! $&.$7'?! )6763'%! 0(A'%$=! ADG(#! #3)#! #)$3:#+$%)#! =633'%!3'G$3#5#=! )##(3$! G$(!<br />

&'::'))#! 03'G$3$(B! kD%=D! A#(#=! 0(A'%$=! G$3##%3#()#%! 036:'+!! A#(#=+#! )$#(!<br />

&'7-'%3'()'=$%#! 0('%3'! G'.'! n! 03:'=! D>#(#! )'&'! 1'>3'! J4! H4! j'! -#! :$=(0! #3#:#%.3#($!<br />

GD%7#+$%)#! G636%)6(:'+!! G(0$3#(! )!=!3'(!%!%! U%#:3$! G$(! @0.'%+$7#3#! +'&$@! 03)66%6!<br />

AU+.#(:#=.#)$(B!KD(=$7#!.0@('=3'(!%!%!GD7D=!?06%366%6%!0(A'%$=!:'))#5#!70=+63!03:'+!4!<br />

G(0$3#(! $3#.:#3#($%)#=$! @0.'%+$7#3$%! U%#:$%$! G$(! ='.! )'&'! '(.!(:'=.')!(B! K'>#! )!=!3'(!%!<br />

G$3#$:$!-#!:$=.'(!h!.'-6=!?#$)$4!.'-6=3'(!%!7#.$.$($3:#!#=3$4!=633'%!3'%!7#:!-#!7'.'=3!!%!<br />

U>#33$$!-#!:$=.'(!!A$G$!1'=.U(3#(#!G'3!!03'('=!)#$:#=.#)$(B!X'@!3'%!G$3$:+#3!?'3!:'3'(!-#!<br />

7''%'%!)#%#7$:3#(!.'>#!G(0$3#(!)!=!3'(!%!%!G'3'%A!?.'=$!G'>!!U>#33$=3#($!%#)#%$73#!.'(!:)'!<br />

=633'%!:!%!%!@#=!67A6%!03:')!!%!!AU+.#(:#=.#)$(B!j_n!0('%!%!%!)#%A#+$>3$$4!?U>D%#G$3$(!<br />

'>0.!:$=.'(!%!%!7D=+#=3$$!-#!10(:3'(!%!%!67A6%!03:':'+!4!@'.0I#%3#($!$?#(:#+$!.'>#!G(0$3#(!<br />

)!=!3'(!%!%!)0(6)'%!=633'%!:!%!!+!%!(3'7'%!.#:#3!1'=.U(3#()$(B!!26!7D>)#%!03A6%3':'+!%!!<br />

.':':3')!=.'%! +0%('! G(0$3#(! )!=!3'(!%!%! =633'%!:!! A#%#3! 03'('=! U%#($3:#=.#)$(B!<br />

H0:@0+.3'%)!=.'%! +0%('! ADG(#! )##($%$! 7$.$(:#)#%! 0(A'%$=! ADG(#7#! )U%D.D(D3#%! G(0$3#(!<br />

)!=!3'(!%!%! D3=#:$>$%! .'(!:+'3! '3'%3'(!%)'! -#! &#(! .D(3D! G$.=$7#! 67A6%! )0>3'()'! -#($3:#+$!<br />

:D:=D%)D(B!K'(3'!G$.=$3#($%)#!VV[[bdd[[!=A_&'4!+#G>#3#()#!V^[[b][[[!=A_&'4!:#7-#3#()#!<br />

VbZ!=A_''?4!$?!:#='%!+D+!G$.=$3#($%)#!V[[bVZ^!A_=A!+'=+!4!)!!:#='%!+D+!G$.=$3#($%)#!V[[b<br />

]^[! A_: d ! -#! ?$:! '3'%3'()'! d[[b][[! A_: d ! )D>#73#($%)#! G(0$3#(! ADG(#+$! %0(:'3! :$%#('3!<br />

ADG(#3#:#7#! $3'-#! 03'('=! =633'%!3'G$3$(B! 2(0$3#(! ADG(#+$h! +D()D(D3#G$3$(! .'(!:! G'=!:!%)'%!<br />

D3=#:$>!$?$%!)##(3#%)$($3:#+$!A#(#=#%!U%#:3$!G$(!='7%'=.!(B!!<br />

:,+*1+.$A&-()&-&.3!2(0$3#(!ADG(#+$4!G(0$3#(!)!=!+!4!=0:@0+.3':'4!.0@('=!-#($:3$3$$!!<br />

$<br />

:;'1.+


90+.! 01! 06(! 'A($563.6('3! '(#'+! '(#! @00(! Q$.&! (#A'()! .0! 0(A'%$5! :'..#(! 50%.#%.! .&#(#10(#!<br />

$:@0(.'%5#! 01! G(0$3#(! :'%6(#! @0.#%.$'3! $+! :0(#! $%5(#'+#)B! ! j0:@0+$.$0%! '%)! ':06%.! 01!<br />

G(0$3#(!3$..#(!5'%!-'(7!)#@#%)$%A!0%!:'%7!1'5.0(+!$%536)$%A!'A#!'%)!)$#.!01!.&#!1305=4!'+!Q#33!<br />

'+!@(0@#(.$#+!01!G#))$%A!:'.#($'3+!'%)!@('5.$5#+!01!@063.(7!&06+#!:'%'A#:#%.B!K&#!6+#!01!<br />

)$(#5.! '@@3$5'.$0%! 01! 1(#+&! G(0$3#(! 3$..#(! $%.0! 'A($563.6('3! 1$#3)+! $+! %0.! '@@(0@($'.#! :#.&0)!<br />

G#5'6+#!01!$.+!+0:#!6%1'-0('G3#!5&'('5.#($+.$5+!$%536)$%A!+65&!'+!6%G'3'%5#)!j_n!('.$04!&$A&!<br />

':06%.+! 01! +036G3#! %$.(0A#%! 10(:+! '%)! @'.&0A#%+B! K&'.#(+!'.!.&#!('.#+!01!VV[[bdd[[!=A_!&'4!<br />

V^[[b][[[!=A_!&'4!VbZ!=A!@#(!.(##4!V[[bVZ^!A!@#(!=A!@0.4!V[[b]^[!A_: d !'%)!d[[b][[!A_: d !10(!<br />

1$#3)! 5(0@+4! -#A#.'G3#! 5(0@+4! 1(6$.! .(##+4! $%)00(! 0(%':#%.'3+4! 06.)00(! 0(%':#%.'3+! '%)!<br />

3'Q%+4! (#+@#5.$-#37B! 2(0$3#(! :'%6(#! $+! '%! $:@0(.'%.! (#+06(5#! 10(! +6+.'$%'G3#!<br />

'A($563.6(#!$%!K6(=#7!'%)!$.!+&063)!G#!#-'36'.#)B!!<br />

%&5$dF./'3!j&$5=#%!:'%6(#4!0(A'%$5!:'%6(#4!50:@0+.$%A4!+0$3!1#(.$3$.7!<br />

$<br />

>(.($<br />

`3=#:$>)#!f[[!:$370%!)03'7!%)'!#.3$=!.'-6=!N2(0$3#(P!@0@D3'+70%6!G636%:'=.')!(!-#!<br />

&#(! 7!3! ^! [[[! [[[! .0%! )D>#7$%)#! G$(! '.!=! 0(.'7'! ?!=:'=.')!(B! K'-6=?636=!<br />

$3#.:#3#($%)#! 0(.'7'! ?!='%! -#! G'.'! ?#-(#7$! ('&'.+!>! #)$5$! =U.D! =0=63'(! 7'7'%! '.!=!<br />

U>#33$$%)#=$! G6! .'>#! .'-6=! )!=!3'(!4! '7%!! >':'%)'! 5$))$! =$(3#.$5$! #.=$+$! %#)#%$73#!<br />

G'.'! 7#('3.!! -#! 7#(D+.D! +6! ='7%'=3'(!! '?!+!%)'%! ?#-(#+#3! ($+=! 036.6(:'=.'4!<br />

$3#.:#3#()#=$! )#@03':'! -#! )U%D.D(:#! 03'%'=3'(!! @#=! G636%:')!!%)'%! '?!=.'! G0!<br />

'('>$3#()#! =0%.(03+D>! GD7D=! 7!!%3'(! #=3$%)#! G#=3#.$3:#3#($%#! G'3!! 03'('=! U%#:3$!<br />

+'3!=! @(0G3#:3#($! )#! 7'('.'G$3:#=.#)$(B! TU>! =0%6+6! G6! )6(6:3'()'%! )03'7!! ?06!<br />

>':'%!.'-6=?636=!$3#.:#3#($!$3#!.0@36:4!7#(#3!7U%#.$:3#(!-#!?#$.3$!(#+:$!=6(6363'(!<br />

'('+!%)'! +0(6%3'(! 7''%:'=.')!(B! R7+'! G(0$3#(! )!=!3'(!! 67A6%! 7U%.#:3#(3#!<br />

)U%DD:3#($!+'3'%)!!!.'=)$()#4!D3=#:$>!.'(!:!%)'!$))#.3#!$&.$7'?!)6763'%!0(A'%$=!<br />

ADG(#!#3)#!#)$3:#+$%)#!=633'%!3'G$3#5#=!)##(3$!G$(!&'::'))#!03'G$3$(B!kD%=D!A#(#=!<br />

0(A'%$=!G$3##%3#()#%!036:'+!!A#(#=+#!)$#(!&'7-'%3'()'=$%#!0('%3'!G'.'!n!03:'=!<br />

D>#(#! )'&'! 1'>3'! J4! H4! j'! -#! :$=(0! #3#:#%.3#($! GD%7#+$%)#! G636%)6(:'+!! G(0$3#(!<br />

)!=!3'(!%!%!U%#:3$!G$(!@0.'%+$7#3#!+'&$@!03)66%6!AU+.#(:#=.#)$(B!<br />

K'(!:+'3!D(#.$:)#!ADG(#%$%!@'7!%!%!t!^[pe[!'('+!%)'!03)66!G$3$%:#=.#)$(B!90)#(%!<br />

.'(!:)'! ADG(#3#:#! 7'@:')'%! 7D=+#=! -#! ='3$.#3$! D(D%! '3:'! 03'%'!! 70=.6(B! KD(=$7#!<br />

.0@('=3'(!4! $=3$:4! .0@0A('17'4! 6>6%! 7!33'()!(! G$.=$! G#+$%! :'))#3#($%$%! +U:D(D3:#+$4!<br />

7'%3!!'('>$!=633'%!:!4!0(:'%!-#!:#('!'('>$3#($%$%!70=!#)$3:#+$4!'!(!!.0@('=!$3#:#4!<br />

#=$:!%UG#.$!+$+.#:3#($%$%!67A63'%:':'+!!-#!#(0>70%!A$G$!%#)#%3#(3#!0(A'%$=!:'))#!<br />

G'=!:!%)'%! 1'=$()$(B! KD(=$7#! .0@('=3'(!%!%! ! t! Wd! +$%)#! 0(A'%$=! :'))#! #=+$=3$$!<br />

)6763:'=.')!(! -#! D3=#:$>! '?!+!%)'%! .'(!:)'! G''(!3!! 03:'%!%! #%! U%#:3$! =0636!<br />

.0@('=3'(!%!U>#33$=3#!0(A'%$=! :'))#!$?#($=3#($%$!=0(6:'=!-#!'(.!(:'=.!(B!26!%#)#%3#!<br />

76(.!$?$%)#=$!.'(!:'!)'7'3!!&#(!.D(3D!+#=.U()#%!0(.'7'!?!='%!0(A'%$=!=U=#%3$!'.!=3'(!%!<br />

0(A'%$=! ADG(#7#! )U%DD:D%D%! +'3'%)!=.'%! +0%('! .'(!:)'! =633'%!3:'+!! +0%! )#(#5#!<br />

U%#:3$)$(B! 2$3$%)$$! A$G$! 0(A'%$=! ADG(#3#(4! G$.=$! G#+$%! #3#:#%.3#($! 7'%!%)'! 0(A'%$=!<br />

:'))#! -#! 1'>3'! :$=.'(3'()'! )'! 7'('(3!! :$=(00(A'%$>:'3'(!! $?#($(3#(B! 26! 7D>)#%!<br />

0(A'%$=! ADG(#3#(! ?0=! 7U%3D! #.=$7#! +'&$@.$(B! TU>! =0%6+6! G6! .D(! ADG(#3#(! .'(!:!<br />

.0@('=3'(!%!%!1$>$=+#34!=$:7'+'3!-#!G$7030I$=!U>#33$=3#($!D>#($%#!036:36!-#!U%#:3$!#.=$!<br />

7'@'(B! k#-(#! G$3$%5$%$%! A$)#(#=! 7'7A!%3'!@! A#3$:#+$73#! AD%D:D>)#! 0(A'%$=!<br />

ADG(#3#(#!='(!!$3A$!)#!'(.:'=.')!(B!!<br />

! ZH


CD%!A#?.$=?#!'(.'%!%D16+6%!&'7-'%+'3!='7%'=3!!@(0.#$%!A#(#=+$%$:$%$!='(!3'7'G$3:#=!<br />

':'5!73'!&'7-'%5!3!!%4!U>#33$=3#!)#!A#3$$:!+D(#+$!=!+'!03'%!G(0$3#(!7#.$.$($5$3$$%$%!<br />

706%!G$(!#=$3)#!7'@!3:'+!!>0(6%36!&'3#!A#3:$.$(B!;%5'=!G6!)6(6:!U>#33$=3#!GD7D=!<br />

7#(3#$:!:#(=#>3#($%#!7'=!%!$3#.:#3#()#!?#-(#!=$(3$3$$!'?!+!%)'%!G$(!.'=!:!+0(6%3'(!!<br />

)'! G#('G#($%)#! A#.$(:$.$(B! `(#.$:! 7'@'%! $3#.:#3#()#%! ?!='%! '.!=3'(! -#! G6%3'(!%!<br />

=0%.(03+D>!)#@03'%:'+!!+0%656!036'%! +!>!%.!3'(4! +6! ='3$.#+$%$! G0>:'=.'! -#! >':'%3'!<br />

=633'%!3':'>! )6(6:'! A#.$(:#=.#)$(B! 3#.:#3#($%! ?#-(#! D>#($%#! 7'@.!!! #%! 036:+6>!<br />

#.=$4!G$(!.'=!:!G63'!5!!&'+.'3!=!#.=#%3#($%$%!='7%'!%!!036.6(:'+!)!(B!26!#.=#%3#($%!<br />

?#-(#7#!7'7!3:'!7033'(!!)0(6)'%!-#!)03'73!!#=3$%)#!03:'=.')!(B!<br />

m%5#3#($!%$+@#.#%!?0=!1'>3'!:$=.'()'!0(.'7'!?!=:'7'%!-#!G6!%#)#%3#!)0(6)'%!?'7!(b<br />

:#('! '('>$3#($! 7'! )'! .'(3'3'()'! =633'%!3'%! .'>#! ADG(#3#($%! 036.6()66! +0(6%3'(!<br />

D>#($%)#! 1'>3'! )6(63:':!.!(B! ;%5'=! AD%D:D>)#! G(0$3#(! 7#.$.$($5$3$$%$%! &!>3!! G$(!<br />

#=$3)#!A#3$:#!AU+.#(:#+$4!AD%)#%!AD%#!'(.'%!:$=.'(3'()'!'.!=3'(!%!0(.'7'!?!=:'+!!-#!<br />

G6%3'(!%!&#(&'%A$!G$(!#=$3)#!)##(3#%)$($3:#:#+$!U%#:3$!G$(!+0(6%!&'3$%#!A#3:$.$(B!<br />

;+3!%)'! G(0$3#(! )!=!3'(!4! 0(A'%$=! =U=#%3$! 03:'+!! -#! >#%A$%! G$.=$! G#+$%! :'))#+$!<br />

$?#($$%#! +'&$@! 03:'+!! %#)#%$73#! )##(3#%)$($3:#+$! A#(#=#%! U%#:3$! G$(! ='7%'=!<br />

)6(6:6%)')!(B!!<br />

$<br />

D.F(-&.$>O;.&'(,/&$b-A&)(9(,$VF1+,'(5&-($<br />

d[[W! 7!3!! ('=':3'(!! AU>! U%D%#! '3!%)!!%)'h! D3=#:$>)#! 7'=3'!=! 03'('=! f[[! :$370%!<br />

G(0$3#(!.'-66%6%!G636%)66!G$3)$($3:#=.#)$(!NHD.D=!-#!k'75!!d[V[PB!L.!D(#.$:$!$?$%!<br />

7'@!3'%!G(0$3#(!7#.$.$($5$3$$%)#!A#%#3)#!7!33!=!e!D(#.$:!)U%#:$!-#!&#(!@$3$?.#%!)U%#:!<br />

G076%5'! '3.3!=! :'.#(7'33#! G$(3$=.#! e! =A! )!=!%!%! 0(.'7'! ?!=.!!! )DD%D3D(+#! D3=#!<br />

A#%#3$%)#!^! [[[![[[! .0%'! 7'=!%! '.!!%!0(.'7'! ?!=.!!! .'&:$%! #)$3:#=.#)$(B! K'3#@! -#!<br />

$&('5'.! 03'%'=3'(!%'! G'3!! 03'('=! GD7D=! 1$(:'3'(!%! D(#.$:! ='@'+$.#3#($%$! '(..!(:'7'!<br />

?'3!:'3'(!4!A#?:$!)U%#:3#()#!=($>3#(!+#G#G$73#!D(#.$:3#($%$!)6()6(:6!$3#.:#3#($%!<br />

7'%!!+!('! G'>!! 7#%$! 1$(:'3'(!%! )'! G6! +#=.U(#! A$(:#=! $+.#:#3#($! 7D>D%)#%! A#3#5#=.#!<br />

0(.'7'! ?!='5'=! '.!=3'(!%! )'&'! )'! 1'>3'! 03'5'!! G$(! A#(?#=.$(B! KD(=$7##($%)#%! @'('+'3! ='(!3!!! 7'=3'!=! 03'('=! Z^[! [[[! [[[! Ki&,&-$89&--(A-&.($<br />

2(0$3#(! '.!=3'(!!0(A'%$=!=U=#%3$!G$(! :'.#(7'3!03)66%)'%! )0(6! =633'%!3)!!%)'! &#:!<br />

.0@('!%!1$>$=+#3!U>#33$=3#($%$%!$7$3#.$(:#+$%)#!=633'%!3'%!$7$!G$(!!+3'&!:'.#(7'3$!&#:!<br />

)#! G$.=$3#(! $?$%! $7$! G$(! G#+$%! :'))#+$! ='7%'!)!(B! 2'3'%A!?.'! G(0$3#(! $3#.:#3#($%)#!<br />

'3.3!=3'! G#('G#(! 0(.'7'! ?!='%! )!=!3'(!%! U>#33$=3#($! ?#$.3$! 1'=.U(3#(#! G'3!! 03'('=!<br />

1'(=3!3!=! AU+.#(#G$3:#=.#)$(B! K'>#! )!=!3'(!%! G$3#$:$! -#! :$=.'(!h! .'-6=! ?#$)$4!<br />

.'-6=3'(!%! 7#.$.$($3:#! #=3$4! =633'%!3'%! 7#:! -#! 7'.'=3!!%! U>#33$$! -#! :$=.'(!4!<br />

G#=3#.$3:#! N7'! )'! 03A6%3'.!(:'P! +D(#+$! A$G$! 1'=.U(3#(#! G'3!)!(! N9'($'=63'%)'$! -#!<br />

9'%$5=':! VWZ^4! R:#$('! -#! '(=B! d[[e4! ;:'%633'&! -#! '(=B! d[V[PB! K'>#! G(0$3#(!<br />

)!=!3'(!%)'=$!'>0.6%!U%#:3$!G$(!GU3D:D!Ntg[btZ[P!D($=!'+$.!-#7'!D('.!#=3$%)#7=#%4!<br />

':0%76:! -#! D(#! ?0=! )DD=! )D>#73#()#)$(B! 26! )6(6:! .'>#! )!=!%!%! )0(6)'%!<br />

=633'%!:!%!!+!%!(3'7'%! G$(! U>#33$=.$(B! K'G30! V#!G(0$3#(!)!=!3'(!%!%!G'>!!U>#33$=3#($!AU+.#($3:$.$(B!<br />

! ZJ


!<br />

%F)^F'1-+,)!$D.F(-&.$2!A!-+.!,!,$>&,&-$89&--(A-&.($<br />

XD=+#=!':0%7'=!#:$+70%6%'!+'&$@!03:'+!4!%$.('.!=$(3$3$$!036.6(:'+!4!+$%#=!-#!)$#(!<br />

@'('>$.3#(#! G#+3#%:#! -#! D(#:#! 0(.':!! 7'('.:'+!4! =U.D! =0=:'+!4! .'!%:'+!! -#!<br />

67A63'%:'+!%)'=$! AD?3D=3#(! %#)#%$73#! G(0$3#(! )!=!3'(!%!%! .'(!:)'! =633'%!:!%)'h!<br />

G#=3#.$3#(#=! )0'3! 03A6%3':'+!! +'3'%)!=.'%! -#7'! =0:@0+.3'%'('=! 0(A'%$=! ADG(#7#!<br />

)U%D.D(D3)D=.#%! +0%('! =633'%!3:'+!! A#%#3)#! U%#($3:#=.#)$(B! c$#(! .'('1.'%! .'>#!<br />

)!=!3'(!%!j_n!0('%!!?0=!)DD=!03)66%)'%!=0:@0+.3'%:'+!!+!('+!%)'!?#3.$=!='-6>6!<br />

-#!.'3'!A$G$!7D=+#=!j'3:'+!4!<br />

'.!=! &'5:$%$%! =D?D3:#+$4! +$%#=! -#! 7'G'%$! 0.! .0&6:3'(!! 5'%3!3!!%!%! #3#:$%#! 03:'+!4!<br />

&'+.'3!=!7'@!5!!>'('(3!!:$=(00(A'%$>:'3'(!%!U3:#+$!G6!'-'%.'I3'()'%!#%!U%#:3$3#($)$(!<br />

NC036#=#! VWZZ4! TQ##.#%! VWf[4! ;:'%633'&! -#! '(=B! d[V[PB! H0:@0+.3'%:!! G(0$3#(!<br />

)!=!3'(!%)'! j! -#! n! )'&'! )#%A#3$)$(4! .0@(''! 7'@!3'%! 67A63':'3'(! +0%('+!%)'!<br />

:$%#('3$>'+70%! 7'-'! A#(?#=3#.$$%)#%! n)!(!<br />

N2($%+0%!-#!'(=B!VWWg4!\'.>!-#!'(=B!d[[[PB!!!!<br />

!<br />

K'G30!VB!K'>#!G(0$3#(!)!=!+!!-#!?#3.$=!='-6>6%6%!G'>!!U>#33$=3#($!Ni#50%.#!-#!<br />

'(=B4!d[[WP!<br />

m>#33$=3#(! k#3.$=!='-6>6! K'>#!G(0$3#(!)!=!+!!<br />

@\! eB^! fB[!<br />

Lj!N:T_5:P! [Bg! gB]!<br />

KRj!NtP! gdB[! dWB[!<br />

Kn!NtP) [Bg! ]BZ!<br />

j_n! V[W! WB[!<br />

T#3D30>!NtP! ^W! e[BZ!<br />

i$A%$%!NtP! d[BW! WB^!<br />

;3!%'G$3$(!J!NA_=AP! [B[Z! gBV^!<br />

;.,0'7)"0"7"&#0"$)Q2RO;.&5&!2G,O1O.O-)&'(,/&$<br />

2(AA+1$B/(-&0(! 03'%! G$.=$! G#+$%!<br />

#3#:#%.3#($!=633'%!3'G$3$(4!)#%A#3$!G$(!&'3#!A#3$(!-#!G6!$3#:!+!('+!%)'!036'%!7D=+#=!<br />

+!5'=3!=3'! &'+.'3!=! 7'@!5!! @'.0I#%3#(! $3#! 7'G'%5!! 0.! .0&6:3'(!! 70=! #)$3:$! 036(B!<br />

! ZN


H0:@0+.6%! ='3$.#+$! .#:#3! 03'('=! =633'%!3'%! :'.#(7'3$%! U>#33$$%#4! $3#:#! -#!<br />

=0:@0+.3'.!(:'!+$+.#:$%#!G'3!)!(B!!<br />

K$5'($! '%3':)'=$! G$(?0=! =0:@0+.! 1'G($='+!! G6! .#:#3! 1'=.U(3#($%! .':! 03'('=!<br />

'%3'!3':':'+!!%#)#%$73#!='@'%:!.!(B!H0:@0+.3'.!(:'!$3#:$!G$7030I$=4!=$:7'+'3!-#!<br />

1$>$=+#3! G$(! $3#:! 03)66%)'%! =0:@0+.! 0366:6%)'! #.=$3$! 03'%! G$(?0=! 1'=.U(!<br />

G636%:'=.')!(B! 26! 1'=.U(3#()#%! U>#33$=3#! %#:4! +!5'=3!=4! j_n! 0('%!4! @\4! @'(?'5!=!<br />

GD7D=3DD4!@0(0>$.#!-#!G#+$%!:'))#3#($!+U>!=0%6+6!$3#:$%!=03'74!#=0%0:$=!-#!=0=6!<br />

036.6(63:')'%!7D(D.D3:#+$%)#!GD7D=!U%#:#!+'&$@.$(3#(B!\!>3!!G$(!=0:@0+.3':'!$?$%!<br />

U%#($3#%!+!%!(!)##(3#($!K'G30!gO;.&'(,(,$%7--+,!)!$<br />

`3=#:$>)#! A#%#3! 03'('=! ='%'.3!! &'7-'%3'()'%! #3)#! #)$3#%! 0(A'%$=! ADG(#3#(#! ='(!!<br />

D(#.$5$3#($:$>$%!&'=+!>!-#!7'%3!!U%!7'(A!3'(!!03)66!AU(D3:#=.#)$(B!;+3!%)'!G6!)6(6:!<br />

.'-6=! ADG(#3#($%$%! A#?:$! )U%#:3#()#! 7'%3!! =633'%!:3'(!%)'%! ='7%'=3'%:'=.')!(B!<br />

H'%'.3!!ADG(#3#($!$?$%)#!7#(!'3'%!G(0$3#(!ADG(#3#($%$%!)#!D3=#:$>)#!.'(!:!'3'%3'(!%)'!<br />

-#!)#$$=!7#.$.$($5$3$=!+$+.#:3#($%)#!7'7A!%!=633'%!3:')!!!G$(!A#(?#=.$(B!26!'3'%)'!<br />

7'@!3:!! '>! +'7!)'=$! '('.!(:'3'()'! 6! +0%6?3'('! ('+.3'%:'=.')!(B! ;=G'7! NVWfVP!<br />

>#%A$%!G#+$%!:'))#+$!G$3#$:$%#!+'&$@!G(0$3#(!ADG(#+$%$%!tgBW!n4!tdBV!J4!tdB]!H!-#!<br />

t^Bd! j'! $?#()$$%$! ('@0(! #.:$.$(B! ;('.!(!5!! :$%#('3! ADG(#3#(#! AU(#! G6! ADG(#%$%!<br />

.0@('!%!1'(=3!!U>#33$=3#($!D>#($%#!#.=$3#(!7'@:'+!%!%!+U>!=0%6+6!03)66%6!G$3)$(:$!<br />

-#! +6! .6.:'! ='@'+$.#+$%$! '(.!(!@! 'A(#A'+70%6! 036:36! #.=$3#:#+$! %#)#%$73#! #(0>70%'!<br />

)$(#%5$! '(.!()!!%!! '?!=3':!.!(B! ;7='%3!! NVWW^P! 7'@.!!! ?'3!:')'! LA#! 2U3A#+$#7$%)#!<br />

G(0$3#(!ADG(#+$!67A63'%)!!%)'!Ne[!.0%!)0:'.#+_&'P!#3)#!#)$3:$.$(B!#=#(!-#!K6(&'%!<br />

Nd[[eP! G'>!! 0(A'%$=! -#! $%0(A'%$=! ADG(#3#($%4! #=#(! @'%5'(!bG6)'7! #=$:! %UG#.$%)#!<br />

G6)'7!-#($:$%#!G'=$7#!#.=$3#($%$!'('.!()!=3'(!!G$(!?'3!:')'!.'-6=!ADG(#+$%$%!G'=$7#!<br />

#.=$+$%$%!)$#(!ADG(#3#()#%!)'&'!1'>3'!03)66%64!G'=$7#!#.=$%$%!67A63':'!+#-$7#+$%#!<br />

G'3!!03'('=!]!7!3!G076%5'!#.=$3$!03)66%6!('@0(!#.:$3#()$(B!X'@!3'%!G6!'('.!(:'3'(!%!<br />

#%! U%#:3$! 0(.'=! 7'%!! G(0$3#(! ADG(#+$%$%! D(D%! -#! .0@('=! D>#($%#! 036:36! #.=$3#(!<br />

7'@.!!%!%!G#3$(3#%:$!03:'+!)!(B!26!)6(6:!D3=#:$>!.'(!:!!'?!+!%)'%!D+.D%)#!)$=='.3#!<br />

)6(63:'+!!A#(#=#%!G$(!=0%6)6(B!!!!<br />

cD%7')'! @#=! ?0=! D3=#)#! $3#%:$! G(0$3#(! ADG(#3#($! ?0=! )##(3$! ADG(#! +!%!1!%'!<br />

+0=63:'=.'! -#! G6)'74! :!+!(4! @':6=4! ?#3.$=! A$G$! )#$$=! D(D%3#($%! 7#.$.$($5$3$$%)#!<br />

G''(!73'! =633'%!3'G$3#5#$! $1')#! #)$3:#=.#)$(! N20(A&$! -#! '(=B! VWW^4! 90++! -#! '(=B!<br />

d[[V4!T$+.'%$!-#!'(=B!d[[g4!9$.5&#33!-#!K6B!d[[^4!K#Q03)#!-#!'(=B!d[[W4!\0++'$%!-#!<br />

'(=B!d[V[PB!;7(!5'!G(0$3#(!ADG(#3#($%$%!0.3'=3'(!-#!?$:!'3'%3'(!%!ADG(#3#%:#+$%)#!)#!<br />

=633'%!3'G$3#5#$!G$3)$($3:#=.#)$(!NL-#(+4!VWWf4!L-#(+!-#!c05.0($'%!VWWf4!L-#(+!d[[d4!<br />

95A$%3#7! -#! '(=4! d[[g4! T.6(A#0%! d[[fPB! 26%'! ='(!%! D3=#:$>)#! A#(#=! G(0$3#(!<br />

ADG(#3#($%$%! A#(#=+#! A#%#3! 03'('=! .'-6=! ADG(#3#($%$%! =633'%!:!%'! 7U%#3$=! 1'>3'!<br />

'('.!(:'! 03:':'+!! %#)#%$73#4! '%5'=! :#-56.! +!%!(3!! -#($3#(! ?#(?#-#+$%)#! ADG(#!<br />

67A63':'!U%#($3#($%$%!7'@!3:'+!!+U>!=0%6+6!03'G$3$(B!26!='@+':)'!:$%#('3!ADG(#3#(#!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

! ZT


!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

K'G30!dB!VYV!0('%!%)'!?#3.$=!='-6>6!$3#!G(0$3#(!)!=!+!%!%!=0:@0+.3'%)!=.'%!<br />

+0%('=$!G'>!!U>#33$=3#($!Ni#50%.#!-#!'(=B4!d[[WP!<br />

m>#33$=3#(!<br />

H0:@0+.!<br />

@\!<br />

ZBd!<br />

Lj!N:T_5:P!<br />

dBW!<br />

KRj!NtP!<br />

VWBW!<br />

n\ r g bn!N:A_=AP! ^[!<br />

nR ] bn!N:A_=AP!<br />

V]W[!<br />

Kn!NtP)<br />

dBg!<br />

j_n!<br />

fB^!<br />

T#3D30>!NtP!<br />

^fB^!<br />

i$A%$%!NtP!<br />

VWBe!<br />

;3!%'G$3$(!J!NA_=AP!<br />

ZBZ!<br />

;.,0'7)"0"7"&#0"$)Q2R!#3#:#%.!$?#($$!-#!;-(6@'!=0:@0+.!+!%!(!)##(3#($!Ni#50%.#!-#!'(=B4!<br />

d[[WP!<br />

!<br />

H0:@0+.! ;-(6@'!=0:@0+.!+!%!(!)##(3#($!<br />

>!#3#:#%.3#(!N:A_=AP! ! !<br />

;+! z]B[! Vf!<br />

j)! [B]f! [BZ[b]B[!<br />

j(! z[B^! Z[bVd[!<br />

j6! VZ! Z[bg[[!<br />

\A! z[B[^! [Bgbd!<br />

90! VBd[! b!<br />

n$! dBV! d^be[!<br />

JG! VBf! g^bVf[!<br />

T#! dB]! Vd!<br />

l%! WV! d[[bV[[[!<br />

K'G30!gB!\!>3!!=0:@0+.3':'!$?$%!U%#($3#%!=0633'(!N;%0%7:06+4!d[[[PB!<br />

H063<br />

H'G63!#)$3#G$3$(!+!%!(3'( m%#($3#%!+!%!(3'(<br />

j_n d[YV!p!g[YV d^YV!p!][YV<br />

n#:!H'@+':! t!g[be^ t!^[b!e[<br />

R=+$I#%!H'@+':! t!^ t!^b!V^<br />

J'(?'5!=!2D7D=3DD!Nk'@P ]BVZb!VdBZ!:: fbVd<br />

@\ ^B^b!WB[ eB^!p!fB[<br />

T!5'=3!=!N{jP ggbee ^^b!e[<br />

! ZW


$3'-#.#%!0(A'%$=!ADG(#7#!)U%D.D(D3:D!.'-6=!ADG(#+$%$%!=633'%!3'G$3#5#$!G$.=$3#(!-#!<br />

67A63':'!)0>3'(!!K'G30!^#73#($)$(B!L3G#..#!=$!.0@('!%!-#!G$.=$%$%!<br />

U>#33$=3#($%#!G'3!!03'('=!G6(')'!U%#($3#%!:$=.'(3'(!#+'+!'3!%:'=!='7)!73'!+U>!=0%6+6!<br />

)0>3'()'!)#$$=3$#!A$)$3#G$3$(B!!<br />

K0@('=! -#! G$.=$! '%'3$>3#($h! 67A63'%'5'=! ADG(#! :$=.'(!%!%! #%! )0(6! -#! #=0%0:$=!<br />

03'('=! A#(?#=3#.$($3:#+$%)#! D@&#+$>! =$! #%! U%#:3$! @'7'! +'&$@! 03'5'=.!(B! 2(0$3#(!<br />

$3#.:#3#($%)#%! #3)#! #)$3#%! .'>#! )!=!3'(!%4! 76:6(.'! .'-6=3'(!%!%! G636%)66!<br />

$3#.:#3#()#! 0(.'7'! ?!='%! )!=!3'('! 0('%3'! )'&'! $7$! 1$>$=+#3! -#! =$:7'+'3! U>#33$=3#(#!<br />

+'&$@!03:'+!4!G6!'.!=!:'.#(7'3$%!=03'73!=3'!0(A'%$=!ADG(#7#!)U%D.D(D3:#+$!-#!='3$.#3$!<br />

0(A'%$=!ADG(#!#3)#!#)$3:#+$!$?$%!U%#:3$!'-'%.'I3'(!+6%:'=.')!(B!2(0$3#(!$3#.:#3#($%$%!<br />

G6!)6(6:6!:6.3'='!)$=='.#!'3:'3'(!!A#(#=:#=.#)$(B!<br />

$<br />

"F,7_$@&$8,&.(-&.$<br />

`3=#:$>!.'(!:!%)'!0(A'%$=!ADG(#3#(!:6.3'='!=633'%!3:'=!>0(6%)')!(B!K0@('=3'(!:!>!%!<br />

GD7D=! =!+:!%)'! 0(A'%$=! :'))#! 7#.#(+$>)$(! -#! G6%6%! $?$%! &#(! .D(3D! ='7%'=.'%! #3)#!<br />

#)$3#%!0(A'%$=!ADG(#3#(!)0(6!G$(!#=$3)#!.'(!:)'!=633'%!3:'3!)!(B!\'7-'%+'3!=U=#%3$!<br />

ADG(#3#(!$?#($+$%)#!U%#:3$!G$(!7#($!-#!@0.'%+$7#3$!03)66!)DD%D3#%!G(0$3#(!ADG(#3#($!<br />

)#! 6+63D%#!67A6%!G$(! #=$3)#! .'(!:! .0@('=3'(!%'! 67A63'%:'3!4! G6! )##(3$! :'.#(7'3$%!<br />

.'(!:! )!!! '3'%3'()'! =633'%!3:'+!! '+3'! )DD%D3:#:#3$)$(B! K'>#! G(0$3#(! )!=!3'(!%!%!<br />

03A6%3'.!(!3:')'%! )0(6)'%! .'(!:! .0@('=3'(!%'! -#($3:#+$! @#=! 67A6%! 03:':'=.')!(B!<br />

kD%=D!.'>#!)!=!)'!j_n!0('%!!67A6%!)#$3)$(4!'>0.6%!GD7D=!G$(!=!+:!!G$.=$7$!7'=!5!!<br />

D($=!'+$.!-#!D('.3'(!#=3$%)#)$(4!+U>!=0%6+6!'>0.!G$3#$=3#($!A'>!Nn\ ] P!10(:6%)'!&!>3'!<br />

='7G03:'! #$3$:$%)#)$(4! '7(!5'! +$%#=! -#! @'.0I#%3#(! ?0=! =03'7! D(#(! -#! =U.D! =0=6!<br />

@(0G3#:$! 0366(B! ;%!3'%! U>#33$=3#(! =0:@0+.3':'! +!('+!%)'! 0(.')'%! ='3=.!!%)'%! -#!<br />

03)6=?'!+.'G$3!G$(!:'.#(7'3!#3)#!#)$3)$$%)#%!G6!ADG(#%$%!.'(!:)'!=633'%!3:'+!!)'&'!<br />

)0(6)6(B!c$#(!.'('1.'%!D3=#:$>)#!G(0$3#(!ADG(#+$!$3#!$3A$3$!=633'%!:3'(!'(..!=?'4!.'(3'!<br />

)#%#:#3#($%#! G'3!! 03'('=! 1'(=3!! 7U(#3#()#! -#! G$.=$! .D(3#($%)#! :$%#('3! ADG(#3#(3#!<br />

G$(3$=.#! 7'! )'! .#=! G'!%'! 67A63'%'5'=! G(0$3#(! ADG(#+$! +#-$7#3#($%$%! )'&'! )#.'73!!<br />

G#3$(3#%:#+$! A#(#=#5#=.$(B! R(A'%$=! ADG(#3#($%! =633'%!:!%!! .#-$=! #.:#=! ':'5!73'!<br />

K'(!:! -#! HU7$3#($! 2'='%3!!%)'%! .#+5$3! '3:!! 0(A'%$=! ADG(#3#(#! )#-3#.! )#+.#$%$%!<br />

+'3'%:'+!!)##(3#%)$($3:#+$!A#(#=#%!)$#(!G$(!=0%6)6(B!<br />

K'(!:! .0@('=3'(!:!>!%! 7'%3!! =633'%!:!! +D()D=?#! -#! G'.'! =$(3#%:#4! .6>3'%:'4!<br />

#(0>70%3'! .'!%:'! A$G$! ?#$.3$! %#)#%3#(3#! -#($:! AD?3#($! )D.D=?#! 0(A'%$=! ADG(#3#($%!<br />

)##($!)'&'!$7$!'%3'!3'5'=.!(B!26%6%3'!$3A$3$!03'('=!A#3#5#=!7!33'()'!0(A'%$=!ADG(#3#(!<br />

AD%D:D>)#%!?0=!)'&'!1'>3'!'('%!(!-#!)##(3$!03'5'=.!(B!26!='@+':)'!G(0$3#(!ADG(#3#($!<br />

D3=#:$>!.'(!:!!$?$%!U%#:3$!-#!:6.3'='!)##(3#%)$($3:#+$!A#(#=#%!G$(!='7%'=.!(B!!!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

! ZZ


K'G30!^B!H0:@0+.3'%:!!.'-6=!ADG(#+$%)#%!?#$.3$!G$.=$3#(#!67A63'%!3:'+!!!<br />

U%#($3#%!:$=.'(3'(!N;%0%$:4!d[VVP!!!<br />

2$.=$3#(! m%#($3#%!:$=.'(! ,7A63':'!l':'%!!<br />

26)'7!N+636P! VV[[bV][[!=A_&'! L=$:)#%!U%5#!<br />

9!+!(! d[[[bdd[[!=A_&'! L=$:)#%!U%5#!<br />

J'.'.#+! d[[[bdd[[!=A_&'! c$=$:)#%!U%5#!<br />

k#3.$=4!;7?$?#$4!#=#(!J'%5'(!! Vf[[bd[[[!=A_&'! L=$:)#%!U%5#!<br />

J':6=! V^[[bVf[[!=A_&'! L=$:)#%!U%5#!<br />

T0'%! Vd[[bV^[[!=A_&'! L=$:)#%!U%5#!<br />

c0:'.#+4!2$G#(4!J'.3!5'%4!H'G'=! dV[[bd][[!=A_&'! c$=$:)#%!U%5#!<br />

\!7'(4!*'+637#! VW[[bdV[[!=A_&'! c$=$:)#%!U%5#!<br />

O+@'%'=4!J!('+'4!9'(634!i'&'%'! V^[[bd[[[!=A_&'! L=$:bc$=$:)#%!U%5#!<br />

\'-6?4!K6(@4!k$3#=! Vf[[bd[[[!=A_&'! L=$:bc$=$:)#%!U%5#!<br />

H'-6%4!H'(@6>! Ve[[bVf[[!=A_&'! L=$:bc$=$:)#%!U%5#!<br />

k'7! d^[[b][[[!=A_&'! T0%G'&'(4!3=G'&'(!<br />

9#7-#!;'5!! m%#($3#%!9$=.'(! H633'%!:!l':'%!!<br />

9#7-#!;'?3'(!!N=D?D=!''?PNL3:'4!;(:6.4!<br />

H'7!+!4!#1.'3$4!H$('>4!8$%#4!L($=!-GBP!<br />

Vbd!=A!''?!G'!%'! T0%G'&'(4!3=G'&'(!<br />

9#7-#!;'?3'(!!NGD7D=!''?PNL3:'4!;(:6.4!<br />

H'7!+!4!#1.'3$4!H$('>4!8$%#4!L($=!-GBP!<br />

dbg!=A!''?!G'!%'! T0%G'&'(4!3=G'&'(!<br />

2'!N7#%$!.#+$+!#)$3:$P! Vbd!=A!0:5'!G'!%'! T0%G'&'(4!3=G'&'(!<br />

2'!N:#7-#)#P! dbg!=A!0:5'!G'!%'! T0%G'&'(4!3=G'&'(!<br />

l#7.$%!N=D?D=!''?P!NGD7D=!''?P!<br />

Vb]!=A!''?!G'!%'!]b^!<br />

=A!''?!G'!%'!<br />

T0%G'&'(4!3=G'&'(!<br />

n'(#%5$7#!N=D?D=!''?P!NGD7D=!''?P!<br />

Vb]!=A!''?!G'!%'!]b^!<br />

=A!''?!G'!%'!<br />

T0%G'&'(4!3=G'&'(!<br />

%5$(! db]!=A!''?!G'!%'! T0%G'&'(4!3=G'&'(!<br />

*!%)!=! dbg!=A!05'=!G'!%'! T0%G'&'(4!3=G'&'(!<br />

96>! ^bZ!=A!05'=!G'!%'! T0%G'&'(4!3=G'&'(!<br />

TD+!2$.=$3#($!<br />

m%#($3#%!9$=.'(!<br />

k$?#=3$!c!!9#='%!NJ'(=b2'&?#P!2$.=$3#($! d^[b]^[!A_: d !<br />

R)6%+6!2$.=$3#(!-#!TD+!k'3!3'(!! V[[bVd[!A_: d !<br />

k$:!;3'%3'(! d[[b][[!A_: d !<br />

k$?#=3$!?!9#='%!NT'=+!P!2$.=$3#($!<br />

V^[bVZ^!A_=A!+'=+!!<br />

k$?#=+$>!?!9#='%!NT'=+!P!2$.=$3#($!<br />

V[[bVd[!A_=A!+'=+!!<br />

$<br />

%+5,+A-+.$<br />

;=G'74!"BY!K'-6=!CDG(#+$B!;B`BlB*B!X'7!%3'(!4!c#(3#:#3#(4!VWfVh!ZeW4!;%='('B!<br />

;:'%633'&4! 9B! 9B4! T#='(4! TB! '%)! 96.&6=($+&%'%4! JBY! J(0+@#5.+! '%)! @0.#%.$'3! 01! @063.(7! :'%6(#B! ;+$'%!<br />

w06(B!01!J3'%.!T5$#%5#+4!d[V[h!W!NgPY!VZdbVfdB!<br />

;%0%$:BY!R(A'%$5'!=633'%!:!#=3$!-#!=633'%!:!7#(3#($B4!d[VVh!&..@__QQQB0(A'%$5'B50:B.(!<br />

;%0%7:06+BY!j0:@0+.$%A!:'%6(#!'%)!0.&#(!0(A'%$5!(#+$)6#+B!d[[[h!&..@Y__!$'%(@6G+B!6%53B!#)_!Q'+.Q:A._!<br />

WV]V^B!&.:4!f!@4!n#G('+='B!<br />

;7='%3!4!`BY!R(A'%$=!ADG(#3#($%!'>0.36!ADG(#3#(3#!G$(3$=.#!=633'%!:!03'%'=3'(!4!@':6=4!G6)'7!-#!dB!D(D%!<br />

:!+!(! -#($:$%#! #.=$3#($! $3#! .0@('!%! G#+$%! G$3'%?0+6B! HU7! \$>:#.3#($! C#%#3! 9D)D(3DD! 9#%#:#%! ;('.B!<br />

L%+.B!X'7!%3'(!4!VWW^h!C#%#3!X'7!%!n0B!dVd4!"'@0(!T#($!n0B!V]W4!9#%#:#%b>:$(B!<br />

20(A&$4! 2B4! C$0()'%$4! CB4! j0(G#33$%$4! 9B4! 8'55$%04! JB4! C6#(:'%)$4! 9B! '%)! K0)#($4! CBY! O%136#%5#! 01! 5(0@!<br />

(0.'.$0%4!:'%6(#!'%)!1#(.$3$>#(+!0%!G(#')!:'=$%A!S6'3$.7!01!Q&#'.!N;$%#%-17)'"+#%C17!iBPB!L6(B!w06(B!;A(0%B4!<br />

VWW^h!g!NVPY!]Zbg^B!!!<br />

2($%+0%4!TB!LB4!j'G(#('4!9B!iB!'%)!K7+0%B!TB!jBY!;::0%$'!-03'.$3$>'.$0%!1(0:!+6(1'5#b'@@3$#)4!1(#+&!'%)!<br />

50:@0+.#)!@063.(7!:'%6(#B!J3'%.!'%)!T0$34!VWWgh!VeZY!dV]bdVfB!!<br />

j#7&'%4!B4!X03)'4!*B4!90()0'%4!nB!-#!k'=!5!4!\BY!c0:'.#+!7#.$.$($5$3$$%)#!1'(=3!!&'7-'%+'3!ADG(#3#($%!<br />

-#($:!-#!='3$.#7#!#.=$+$B!OOB!T#G>#!K'(!:!!T#:@0>76:64!d[[[h!^Vb^^4!O+@'(.'B!!<br />

L-#(+4!CB!aBY!j0:@'($+0%!01!G(0$3#(!3$..#(!'%)!50::#(5$'3!1#(.$3$>#(!10(!50'+.'3!G#(:6)'A('++!@(0)65.$0%!$%!<br />

.&#!T06.&#'+.#(%!,TB!w06(B!01!T6+.'$%'G3#!;A($5B4VWWfh!VdY!^^bZZB!<br />

L-#(+4!CB!aB'%)!c05.0($'%4!cB!TBY!J&0+@&0(6+!(#:0-'3!G7!G#(:6)'!'%)!(7#A('++bG#(:6)'!1#(.$3$>#)!Q$.&!<br />

G(0$3#(!3$..#(B!O%Y!T5'%#+4!jB4!H'%Q'(4"B4!L)+B!;%$:'3!J(0)65.$0%!T7+.#:+!'%)!.&#!L%-$(0%:#%.B!O0Q'!T.'.#!<br />

,%$-B4!;:#+B!VWWfh!VeWbVZgB!<br />

! Z]


L-#(+4!CB!aBY!"7#A('++bG#(:6)'A('++!@(0)65.$0%!'%)!%6.($#%.!6@.'=#!Q&#%!50:G$%$%A!%$.(0A#%!1#(.$3$>#(!<br />

Q$.&!G(0$3#(!3$..#(B!;(A0%Bw06(B4!d[[dh!W[^bWV[B!!<br />

C036#=#4!jB!CBY!2$030A$5'3!"#53':'.$0%!01!T03$)!a'+.#+B!"0)'3#!J(#++4!L::#%6+4!J;BVWZZB!<br />

\'A'4!HBY!9'%'A$%A!:'%6(#!0%!w'@'%#+#!3$-#+.05=!'%)!@063.(7!1'(:+B!2$05753#4!d[[Vh!gd!NePY!eeB!!<br />

\'.>4!KB!HB4!9$.5&#334!wB!JB!'%)!C$'%%$%$4!jBY!n$.(0A#%!'%)!5'(G0%!:$%#('3$>'.$0%!)7%':$5+!01!:'%6(#+!'%)!<br />

50:@0+.+B!\0(.T5$B4!d[[[h!]^Y!d[WbdVdB!<br />

\0++'$%4! ;B! KB! 9B! TB4! "'&:'%4! *B4! T'&'4! JB! HB! '%)! T03'$:'%4! ;B! "B! 9BY! d[V[B! L11#5.! 01! )$11#(#%.! 'A#)!<br />

@063.(7! 3$..#(! 0%! .&#! 7$#3)! '%)! %6.($#%.! G'3'%5#! $%! G0(0!($5#! 563.$-'.$0%B! 2'%A3')#+&! w06(B! 01! ;A($3B! "#+B4!<br />

d[V[h!]^!N]PY!gWZb^[^B!<br />

H'('4! LB! -#! L(#34! ;BY! K'-6=! ADG(#+$%$%! G'>!! .0@('=! U>#33$=3#($%#! -#! 763'1! =6(6! G$.=$! '!(3!!%'! #.=$+$B!<br />

;%')0364!w06(B!01!;;"O4!VWWWh!W!NdPY!WVbV[gB!<br />

HD.D=4!jB!-#!k'75!4!CBh!K'-6=!)!=!3'(!%!%!0(A'%$=!ADG(#7#!)U%D.D(D3:#!7U%.#:3#($B!HD:#+!\'7-'%3'(!!<br />

H0%A(#+$B!ZbW!L=$:4!H'7+#($4!d[V[h!f!+B!<br />

i#50%.#4!9B!jB!9'>>'($%04!9B!wB4!T'..$4!JB4!OA3#+$'+4!9B!jB!'%)!i'0+4!*BY!j0b50:@0+.$%A!($5#!&633+!'%)_0(!<br />

+'Q)6+.!Q$.&!@063.(7!:'%6(#!$%!nL!;(A#%.$%'B!a'+.#!9'%'A#:#%.4!d[[Wh!dWY!dggebdg^]B!<br />

9'($'=63'%)'$4!;B!'%)!9'%$5=':4!KBTBY!j&#:$+.(7!01!1#(.$3$>#(+!'%)!:'%6(#+B!;+$'!J6G3$5'.$0%!\06+#4!n#Q!<br />

X0(=4!,T;4!VWZ^h!ddgbd][B!<br />

95A$%3#74!2B!jB4!j011#74!HB4!JB4!T'6#(4!KB!wB4!C00)Q$%4!\B!iB4!\6:@&(74!wB!2B4!j0G3#%.>4!aB!HB!'%)!95G#.&4!<br />

iBwBY! j'+#! T.6)7Y! 9$%#('3! 50%.#%.! 01! 10('A#+! A(0Q%! 0%! @063.(7! 3$..#(b':#%)#)! +0$3+B! K&#! J(01#++$0%'3!<br />

T5$#%.$+.4!d[[gh!d[Y!V]ebVg^B!!!<br />

9$.5&#334!jBjB4!K64!TBY!i0%A!.#(:!#-'36'.$0%!01!@063.(7!:'%6(#!'+!'!+06(5#!01!%$.(0A#%!10(!50..0%!'%)!50(%B!<br />

;(A0%B!w06(B4!!d[[^h!WZY!]WWbg[ZB!<br />

90++4!2B!"B4!"##Q#+4!cB!aB4!i$%4!wB!jB4!K0(G#(.4!\B!;B4!95#3&#%%#74!aB!\B4!9'+=4!JB!'%)!H#>'(4!aBY!X$#3)!<br />

'%)!S6'3$.7!01!.&(##!50(%!&7G($)+!'+!'11#5.#)!G7!G(0$3#(!3$..#(!1#(.$3$>'.$0%!'%)!5(0@!:'.6($.7B!;%$:B!*##)!T5$B!<br />

K#5&B4!d[[Vh!Wg!NV_dPY!g]b^eB!!!<br />

R:#$('4!nB4!2'(G06(4!LB!HB4!n#&:#4!JB!;B4!\':')#&4!TB!HB4!l6('7=4!"B!;%)!2'+&06(4!OBY!9$5(0G$030A$5'3!<br />

'%)!5&#:$5'3!@(0@#(.$#+!01!3$..#(!1(0:!)$11#(#%.!5&$5=#%!.7@#+!'%)!@(0)65.$0%!+7+.#:+B!T5$#%5#!01!.&#!K0.'3!<br />

L%-$(0%:#%.4!d[[eh!]eZY!V^ebVedB!<br />

T$+.'%$4! HB! "B4! "0Q#4! cB! LB4! w0&%+0%4! wB! '%)! K#Q03)#4! \BY! T6@@3#:#%.'3! %$.(0A#%! #11#5.! 0%! G(0$3#(b3$..#(!<br />

1#(.$3$>#)!50..0%B;A(0%B!w06(B4!d[[gh!WeY!f[ebfVVB!!<br />

#=#(4! jB! K6(&'%B! 9B! Y! 2'>!! 0(A'%$=! -#! $%0(A'%$=! ADG(#3#($%4! #=#(! @'%5'(!bG6)'7! #=$:! %UG#.$%)#!<br />

G6)'7!%!-#($:$%#!G'=$7#!#.=$3#($B!T#3?6=!`%$-#(+$.#+$!l$(''.!*'=D3.#+$!c#(A$+$4!d[[eh!d[!N]fPY!g]bgfB!!!<br />

T.6(A#0%4!iB!LBY!*#(.$3$>#(!-'36#!01!)#%+$1$#)!G(0$3#(!3$..#(B!9'+.#(!K&#+$+B!K&#!C(')6'.#!*'563.7!01!;6G6(%!<br />

,%$-#(+$.7B!;3'G':'4!,T;Bd[[fB!<br />

TQ##.#%4!wB!9BY!a'+.#!.(#'.:#%.B!T.'.#!01!.&#!'(.B!i$-#+.05=!Q'+.#Y!;!(#%#Q'G3#!(#+06(5#B!J(05B!01!!.&#!g .& !<br />

O%.#(%'.$0%'3!T7:@0+B!0%!i$-#+.05=!a'+.#+4!;T;L4!T.B!w0+#@&4!9O4!VWf[h!]]gp]]fB!<br />

K#Q03)#4!\B4!26#&($%A4!nB4!;)#3$4!;B4!T$+.'%$4!HB!"B4!"0Q#4!cB!LB!'%)!J('.4!"BCBY!j0..0%!(#+@0%+#!5&$5=#%!<br />

3$..#(!$%!(0.'.$0%!Q$.&!50(%!$%!53'7#7!+0$3B!;A(0%B!w06(B4!d[[Wh!V[VY!edebe]gB!<br />

a'%A4!jB4!i$%4!XB4!\6'%A4!aB!;%)!j&$64!iBY!"'Q!:'.#($'3+!6+#)!10(!50:@0+.$%AB!O%Y!j0:@0+.!J(0)65.$0%B!<br />

;!:'%6'3!10(!;+$'%!1'(:#(+B!**Kj!J6G3$5'.$0%4!K'$@#$4!K'$Q'%4!d[[^h!d[p][B$<br />

! ]#


S 011 Broiler Beslenmesi Formülasyon Stratejilerinde Yeni Görüşler<br />

New concepts in Formulation Strategies in Boriler Nutrition<br />

İbrahim Çiftci<br />

Ankara Üniversitesi Ziraat Fakültesi Zootekni Bölümü 06110 Dşkap/Ankara- Türkiye<br />

Abstract<br />

Broiler chicken performances have been improved every year by genetic selection.<br />

These improvements have also resulted in reduction of marketing age at the same<br />

final body weight and changes of nutrient requirements of broiler chickens. Feed<br />

formulation is very important to satisfy to goals of broiler production. Feed<br />

formulation is center to obtain the best economic biological performances, and this is<br />

also vital for desired broiler meat quality.<br />

Recently feed ingredients prices and consumer meat quality expectations have<br />

increased. Nutritionists of most broiler integrations have used different feed<br />

formulations strategies. Feed formulations require deep knowledge on feed<br />

ingredients and feed additives, its quality aspects, princibles of animal nutrition and<br />

feed manufacturing technology. Last developments in broiler feed formulation are<br />

generally on determination of nutrient requirements in different production<br />

conditions, considering non-essential amino acids (Gly, Ser, Pro) and unconventional<br />

essential amino acids (Val, Ile), ideal AA, ideal Lys level, formulation on digestible<br />

AA base, digestible Lys/Metabolisable energy (ME) ratio and formulation of diets in<br />

different nutrient density considering Lys/ME ratios. In this text, these developments<br />

were presented and discussed with different reports of research articles, and as a<br />

conclusion some feed formulation strategies were recommended.<br />

Giriş<br />

<strong>Et</strong>lik piliçlerde modern üretim süreci içinde slah programlar sonucu performans<br />

değerleri açsndan genotiplerde çok önemli ilerlemeler sağlanmştr. Her geçen gün<br />

ideal kesim yaş giderek düşmektedir. Bu ilerlemeler etlik piliçlerin besin madde<br />

ihtiyaçlarna da yansmaktadr. Bu ihtiyaçlarn karşlanmasnda kullanlan yemler<br />

piliç eti üretim masraflar içinde yaklaşk %70-80’ini oluşturmaktadr. Özellikle son<br />

zamanlarda sadece ürün miktarna göre değil, kaliteyle ilişkili ürün üretiminde<br />

ekonomik performansn sağlanmasn önemli klmaktadr. Hzl büyüme kapasitesine<br />

sahip etlik piliçlerin besin madde ihtiyaçlarn ürün miktar ve kalitesi açsndan<br />

karşlayarak ekonomik bir üretimin elde edilmesinde karma yemlerin formülasyonu<br />

büyük önem taşmaktadr. Belirtilenlere bağl olarak etlik piliç üretiminde yem<br />

formülasyonu geçen zaman süreci içinde hiç bir zaman önemini yitirmemekte ve<br />

dinamik bir konu olarak kalmaktadr.<br />

Yem formülasyonu derin teknik bilgi yannda iyi bir gözlem yeteneğini<br />

gerektirmektedir. Kanatl beslemeciler sektörde arzulanan sonuca ulaşmada temelde<br />

kritik olan;<br />

yem ham maddelerinin yem değeri,<br />

amino asitlerin (AA) sindirilebilirliği,<br />

AA/ME oran, uygun yağ kaynaklarnn seçimi,<br />

mineral madde gereksinimlerinin karşlanmas,<br />

eletkrolit dengesi,<br />

bağşklk-besleme ilişkileri<br />

91


çevre şartlar-besleme ilişkileri konularnda devaml güncellenen yeterli bilgi ve<br />

tecrübeye sahip olmaldrlar.<br />

Broiler Yemi Förmülasyonunda Temel Yaklaşmlar<br />

Hayvan ve insan sağlğ ile ekonomik üretim açsndan uygun karma yem<br />

formülasyonunda çok sayda faktör rol oynamaktadr. Bunlar; hayvan besleme<br />

biliminin temel prensiplerini içeren konular, kullanlan yem ham madde ve katk<br />

maddelerine ait bilimsel teknik veriler ve özel tecrübelerle kazanlmş bilgilerden<br />

oluşmaktadr.<br />

Yem formülasyonu:<br />

Besin madde gereksinimlerinin belirlenmesi<br />

Kullanma uygun yem maddelerinin belirlenmesi<br />

Yem maddelerinin kullanmnda snrlamalarn belirlenmesi<br />

o Miktar olarak uygunluk (stok veya teminde uygunluk)<br />

o Fiziksel özellikler<br />

<br />

o Antibesinsel faktörler gibi besinsel snrlar<br />

Optimum ekonomik performans için gerekli olan besin madde gereksinimlerini<br />

snrlamalar ölçüsünde karşlayan yem maddelerinin karştrlmas konularn<br />

kapsamaktadr.<br />

Şekil 1’de bir yemin üretiminden etlik piliçte performansa dönüşüm aşamasna kadar<br />

geçen süreçteki yem formülasyonu açsndan etkili olan ve dikkate alnmas gerekli<br />

olan önemli unsurlar verilmiştir.<br />

Üretim/ üretici /kanatl bağlamnda; kanatllar tükketikleri yemin özelliğini 2 noktada<br />

yanstrlar. Bunlar,<br />

– Biyolojik performans<br />

– Ekonomik performansdan oluşmaktadr.<br />

Ekonomik performans üzerinde Şekil 2 de verilen faktörler rol oynamaktadr. Her bir<br />

etlik piliç etntegrasyonu açsndan bu unsurlarn says ve ağrlğ farkl olacaktr.<br />

İşletmede temel performans sorunlarnn önemli boyutda olduğu bir durumda,<br />

kesimhane verileri ve et kalitesi çok önemli bir kriter olarak dikkate alnmazken,<br />

işletmelerin temel sorunlar çözmesiyle birlikte bu yöndeki veriler ekonomik<br />

performans için daha ağrlkl bir noktaya taşnmaktadr. Şekil 1 ve 2’de yer alan<br />

ilişkilerin iyi alglanmas, tenik verilerin toplanmas, değerlendirilmesi ve<br />

uygulamaya konulmas ekonomik verim açsndan önem taşmaktadr.<br />

92


Şekil 1. <strong>Et</strong>lik piliç açsndan yem üretimine ait formülasyonda rol oynayan önemli<br />

unsurlar (Rossi 2006 dan modifiye edilmiştir)<br />

YEM FABRİKASI<br />

•Yem üretimi, ton/saat<br />

•Yem maliyeti, TL/ton<br />

SATIN ALMA BÖLÜMÜ<br />

• Enerji birim maliyeti<br />

• Protein veya ilave amino<br />

asitlerin birim maliyeti<br />

CANLI ÜRETİM/ SAHA<br />

• Canl ağrlk<br />

• Yem değerlendirme<br />

• Yem fiyat<br />

• Ü<br />

KESİMHANE<br />

• Karkas verimi<br />

• Üniformite<br />

• Göğüs ve/veya but<br />

eti oran<br />

Şekil 2. Bir entegrasyonda ekonomik etlik piliç üretiminde (ekonomik performans) yer alan önemli<br />

maliyet/kalite unsurlar<br />

93


Doku Sentezinde Enerji-Protein/ Amino Asit (AA) İlişkisi<br />

Broylerde performansnda doku brikiminde (CAA) en temel besin maddeleri, enerji<br />

ve proteindir. <strong>Et</strong>lik piliçlerde enerjinin sağlanmasnda brincil kaynak, tahllarla<br />

sağlanan karbonhidratlardan nişastadr. Enerji karbonhidrat kaynaklaryla sağlamadğ<br />

durumda eksik kalan ksm ikincil enerji kaynağ olan yağlarla sağlanmaktadr. Yağlar<br />

sadece yoğun bir enerji kaynağ olmalarnn ötesinde özellikle esansiyel yağ asitleri<br />

ihtiyaçlarnn karşlanmasnda da mutlaka kullanlmas gereken kaynaklardandr.<br />

Amino Asitler (AA)<br />

Esansiyel AA Snrl sentezlenenler Esansiyel olmayanlar<br />

Arginine<br />

Tyrosine<br />

Alanine<br />

Lysine<br />

Cystine<br />

Aspartic acid<br />

Histidine<br />

Hydroxylysine<br />

Asparagine<br />

Leucine<br />

Glutamic acid<br />

Isoleucine<br />

Glutamine<br />

Valine<br />

Hydrxyproline<br />

Methionine<br />

Glycine*<br />

Threonine<br />

Serine*<br />

Tryptophane<br />

Proline*<br />

Phenylalanine<br />

Şekil 3. <strong>Et</strong>lik piliçler açsndan esansiyel, snrl ve esansiyel olmayan AA’ler<br />

Doku sentezi için sadece proteinler ve bunlarn temel taş olan amino asitler ve<br />

peptidler yeterli olamamaktadr. Vücutda doku sentezi açsndan hem protein yap<br />

taşlar hem de enerjinin yeterli düzeyde hazr bulunmas önem taşmaktadr. Temel<br />

kural olarak enerjiye göre protein yap taşlar vücutda dengesiz bir oranda daha fazla<br />

olduğunda fizyolojik olarak protein bileşiklerinin bir ksm enerji kaynağ olarak<br />

değerlendirilmekte ve bu durum hem etlik performas üzerinde hem de sağlğ<br />

üzerinde önemli sorunlar yaratmaktadr. Protein yap taşlar olarak da sadece<br />

esansiyel amino asitlerin yeterli düzeyde sağlanmas doku sentezi için yeterli<br />

olmamakta, enerjinin ve esansiyel amino asitlerin düzeylerine bağl olarak<br />

snrlandrc düzeye ulaşabilmekte ve performans üzerinde belirleyici olabilmektedir.<br />

Belirtilen bilgiler şğnda ME/HP oranndan daha detayl olarak belirli ME başna<br />

sindilebilir AA (DAA) kavramn ideal AA kapsamnda değerlendirilmesini gündeme<br />

getirmektedir. Şekil 3 de esansiyel ve esansiyel olmayan amino asitler verilmiş olup,<br />

etlik piliçler açsndan esansiyel olmayan amino asitlerden glisin, prolin ve serin<br />

snrlandrc AA durumuna gelmektedir.<br />

94


Msr-soya esasl, %23 ham proteinli sentetik AA ilavesi yaplmamş bir etlik civciv<br />

rasyonunda (Şekil 4), NRC(1994) tarafndan bildirilen AA ihtiyaçlarndan Met + Cys<br />

ihtiyacnn yaklaşk yars, lisin AA’nin ise %80’i karşlanmakta olduğu<br />

bildirilmektedir (Kim, 2002). Benzer rasyonun sentetik AA kullanarak ve<br />

kullanlmayarak rasyon AA ihtiyaçlarn karşlayacak şekilde hazrlanmas<br />

durumunda Tablo 1’de yer alan rasyonlarn yaps ortaya çkmaktadr. Sentetik AA<br />

kullanmadan sahada asla kullanlamayacak bir rasyon ortaya çkmaktadr. Sentetik<br />

kullanlmayan rasyonda ham madde olarak AA ihtiyaçlarn karşlamak için balk unu<br />

taşlk erozyonu ve bağrsak sağlğ açsndan uygun olmayan düzeylere çkmaktadr.<br />

Ayrca srf Met+Cys ihtiyacnn karşlanmas için ham protein içeriği %23 yerine<br />

%29’a, diğer AA de ihtiyaç düzeyinin çok üzerlerine çkmaktadr. Bu da rasyondaki<br />

AA arasndaki dengeyi bozmakta ve bu rasyonda fazladan yer alan AA ler civciv için<br />

hem stres oluşturmakta, hem de AA kaynağ olarak Met+Cys düzeyinde<br />

yararlanmasna yol açmakta, Py düzeyide balk unundan gelen P dolaysyla çok<br />

yükselmekte ve sonuçta ekonomik bir üretim ve hayvan sağlğ açsndan olumsuz bir<br />

besinsel bileşim oluşturmaktadr. Bu rasyonlardaki durum etlik piliç beslemede<br />

sentetik AA kullanmnn ne kadar önemli olduğunu göstermektedir. Tarihi süreç<br />

içinde başta sentetik AA olarak metiyonin ve MHA’lar, lizin AA, treonin AA ve son<br />

zamanlarda triptofan, arginin ve valin AA’leri kullanlr hale gelmektedirler. Sentetik<br />

AA kullanm zaman içinde özellikle özel etkileri de dikkate alndğnda genel bir<br />

uygulama haline gelmiştir.<br />

Şekil 4. %23 ham proteinli msr-soya esasl rasyonun amino asit içeriği ve<br />

NRC(1994) bildirişlerine göre broylerlerin aminoasit gereksinimlerinin<br />

karşlaştrlmas durumu ( Kim, 2002)<br />

95


Tablo 1. Sentetik amino asit kullanlarak ve kullanlmadan oluşturulan iki farkl rasyonun<br />

karşlaştrlmas (etlik civciv yemi 0-2 hafta)<br />

Hammadde miktar (g/kg) Sentetik AA (-) Sentetik AA (+)<br />

Msr 454.73 552.30<br />

Soya Küspesi 344.88 319.63<br />

Balk unu 150.37 60.00<br />

Bitkisel Yağ 43.02 40.07<br />

Mermer Tozu ---- 11.12<br />

D.C.P ---- 6.37<br />

Tuz 3.50 3.50<br />

Vitamin Premiksi 2.50 2.50<br />

Mineral Premiksi 1.00 1.00<br />

DL-Metiyonin ---- 2.21<br />

L-Lisin HCL ---- 1.31<br />

Rasyon içeriği(%)<br />

Ham Protein 29.05 23.00<br />

Ham Yağ 8.12 7.53<br />

M.Enerji 3110.00 3110.00<br />

Ca 1.05 1.05<br />

P (yarar.) 0.64 0.50<br />

Metiyonin 0.57 0.62<br />

Met+Sistin 0.95 0.95<br />

Lisin 1.86 1.45<br />

Triptofan 0.34 0.26<br />

Arjinin 1.91 1.52<br />

Treonin 1.17 0.91<br />

İsolösin 1.23 0.95<br />

Lösin 2.37 1.93<br />

Histidin 0.84 0.65<br />

Na+K-Cl 306.81 281<br />

Broylerde Protein / Amino Asit İhtiyaçlarnn Karşlanma Kaynaklar ve<br />

Uygulamalar<br />

Amino asit (AA) gereksinimleri;<br />

Yem ham maddeleri ham protein yapsndan bulunan AA lerle (yararlanm<br />

ortalama %88)<br />

Sentetik amino asitlerle<br />

Yem maddelerinin yapsnda yer alan AA’lerden yararlanm artrc<br />

uygulamalarla<br />

– Sindirilebilir AA esasnda förmülasyon,<br />

– Enzim kullanmlar, saylabilir.<br />

<strong>Et</strong>lik piliç rasyonlarnda yer alan ham proteinin ana bileşenlerini protein tabiyatnda<br />

olmayan azotlu bileşikler (NPN), Sindirilmeyen AA ler (UDAA), Sindirilebilir<br />

esansiyel AA (DEAA) ve Sindirilebilir esansiyel AA’ler (DEAA) oluşturmaktadr.<br />

Bu bileşenlerden ilk ikisinin karma yemde mümkün olduğunca düşük, üçüncüsünün<br />

yüksek ve sonuncusununda DEAA düzeyine göre snrlandrc olmayacak belirli<br />

düzeylerde bulunmas optimal performans açsndan gereklidir (Tablo 2). Belirtilen<br />

bileşenlerden son ikisine rasyon için istenilen toplam AA olarak adlandrabiliriz.<br />

96


Tablo 2. <strong>Et</strong>lik piliçlerde rasyon ham proteininin ana bileşenleri<br />

Protein tabiyatnda<br />

olmayan azotlu<br />

bileşikler (NPN)<br />

Sindirilmeyen AA<br />

(UDAA)<br />

Sindirilebilir esansiyel<br />

AA (DEAA)<br />

Sindirilebilir esansiyel<br />

olmayan AA (DNEAA)<br />

Rasyon için istenilen<br />

toplam (TDAA)<br />

Yaplan bir seri çalşmada karma yemin toplam proteinin içerisinde TDAA düzeyinin<br />

artmasna bağl olarak yem değerlendirme saysnn iyileştiği bildirilmektedir (Tablo<br />

3 ve 4)<br />

Tablo 3. Rasyon toplam sindilebilir amino asit (TDAA) içeriğinin etlik piliçlerde<br />

peformans üzerine etkileri (12-32 gün) Lange et al. (2003)<br />

Deneme-I*<br />

TDAA, % 16.2 16.5 16.8 17.4<br />

CAA, g/gün 75.1 75.8 75.2 75.2<br />

YT / CAA, g/g 1.604 a 1.607 a 1.583 b 1.550 c<br />

* 2914 kcal ME, %21 HP,%1.05 D.Lys, %0.77 D.Met&Sis<br />

Deneme-II**<br />

TDAA, % 17.5 18.1 18.4<br />

CAA, g/gün 69.0 a 71.8 b 71.8 b<br />

YT / CAA, g/g 1.671 a 1.641 c 1.630 c<br />

** 2986 kcal ME, %20 HP,%1.05 D.Lys, %0.77 D.Met&Sis<br />

a-c; P


azot atlm ve scaklk stresi sorunlarnda artş görülmektedir. Ekonomik rasyon<br />

çözümü amacyla çok çeşitli ham maddelerin kullanldğ durumlarda TDAA ve<br />

UDHP oranlarnn dikkat edilmesi uygun olacaktr.<br />

Toplam, Sindirilebilir ve İdeal AA Esasnda Formülasyon<br />

Sentetik amino asitler kanatl beslemede;<br />

Yemin ham protein (HP) düzeyinin düşürülmesi<br />

düşük ham protein içerikli yem maddelerinin kullanm<br />

formülasyonu yapan kişiye esneklik<br />

ve sonuçta ekonomik yem üretimi sağlamaktadr.<br />

Yem ham protein düzeyinin düşürülmesi ise;<br />

– Azotdan yararlanm etkinliğini artrr<br />

– Dşkyla fazla azot atlmn azaltr<br />

(yem HP düzeyindeki %1’lik düşme, gübre azotunda<br />

%8-10 azalmaya yol açar)<br />

– Çevre kirliliğinin azaltlmas<br />

– Kanatllarda yüksek çevre scaklğ stresini azaltr<br />

Sentetik AA kullanmyla düşük ham proteinli broyler yemleri<br />

üretimi ve snrlar<br />

Düşük ham proteinli yemlerle niçin bazen daha düşük performans elde<br />

edilmektedir ?<br />

Değişen rasyon K veya Rasyon Elektrolit Dengesi (DEB) !<br />

Esansiyel olmayan AA (NEAA) lerin sentezi için spesifik olmayan N<br />

yetersizliği !<br />

Düşük ham proteinli yemlerin daha az tüketilmesi eğilimi<br />

Değişen EAA/NEAA oran<br />

Hzl büyüme için gerekli olan glisin benzeri NEAA lerin yetersiz sentezi<br />

Vücüt protein brikimi için tüketilen rasyon proteini ve serbest AA lerin<br />

kullanm etkenliği farkllklar<br />

Esansiyel AA (EAA) lerin bazlarnn yetersizliği<br />

Yüksek ham proteinli yeme göre düşük ham proteinli yemlerin ME ve NE<br />

arasndaki ilişkilerdeki farkllklar rol oynamaktadr.<br />

Değişen rasyon K veya Rasyon Elektrolit Dengesinin (DEB) düşük ham proteinli etlik<br />

piliç yemlerinin performans ve abdominal yağ oran üzerine etkileri araştrlmş (Han<br />

et al. (1992) ve araştrma sonuçlarna göre düşük proteinli yemlerde farkl DEB<br />

değerleri performans değerleri üzerinde snrl etki yaratmştr (Tablo 5).<br />

Düşük ham proteinli yemelere sentetik esansiyel olmayan AA (NEAA) ilavesi<br />

performans, vücut yağ ve N atlm kriterlerinde önemli etki yaratmamştr (Tablo 6).<br />

Yem değerlendirme says ve vücut yağ üzerinde saysal düzeyde etki olumlu etki<br />

yaratdğ bildirilmiştir (Bregendahl et al. 2002).<br />

Düşük ham proteinli yemlerin daha az tüketilmesi eğilimi, genelde %19 ve altnda<br />

ham protein içeren yemlerde gözlenmiştir (Şekil 5).<br />

98


Tablo 5. Msr-soya esasl düşük proteinli yemle beslenen broylerde elektrolit<br />

dengesinin (DEB) etkisi Han et al. (1992)<br />

DEB, meq/kgCAA, gCAA/YTAbdominal Yağ%<br />

g/kg<br />

Kontrol, %23 HP 233 290 a 675 a 8.9 a<br />

Düşük HP,%19 192 271 b 606 b 11.5 b<br />

Düşük HP,%19+K 233 274 b 616 b -<br />

Tablo 6. Msr soya esasl düşük ham proteinli broyler yemlerine sentetik NEAA<br />

ilavesinin etkileri Bregendahl et al. (2002)<br />

CAA,g CAA/YT Vücut<br />

g/kg yağ, %<br />

N atlm,g<br />

Kontrol, %23 HP 614 753 a 8.23 a 13.84 a<br />

Düşük HP, %19.3HP 596 711 b 12.01 b 9.35 b<br />

Düşük HP,%19+ %3 NEAA (1:1)<br />

L-Glutamik A: L-Asparagin<br />

596 723 b 10.55 b 10.88 b<br />

Yem tüketimi, g<br />

Şekil 5. Düşük ham proteinli yemlerin daha az tüketilmesi eğilimi<br />

EAA/NEAA oran yönünden; ideal orann EAA (10) + Gly, Ser, Pro (3) : NEA<br />

50:50 ile 55:45 arasnda olmas önerilmektedir (Tablo 7).<br />

Tablo 7. <strong>Et</strong>lik piliçlerde önerilen EAA/NEAA oranlar<br />

Bedford & Summers (1985) 55:45<br />

Dean et al. (2006) 57:43<br />

Fatufe et al. (2005) 47:53<br />

Jiang et al. (2005) 54:46<br />

Si et al. (2004) 56:44<br />

Moran et al. (1992) 53:47<br />

99


Glisin & Serin AA etkileri:<br />

Bitkisel protein kaynaklarna dayal, sentetik Met, Lys ve Thr ilavesiyle oluşturulan<br />

düşük proteinli yemlerde esansiyel olmayan GİLİSİN ve SERİN AA snrlandrc<br />

olabilmektedir.<br />

Glisin etlik piliçlerde, protein, glutathione, creatine, ürik asit ve hipürik asit<br />

sentezinde kullanlmaktadr.<br />

Msr-soya esasl etlik piliç yemlerinde perfomans değerleri açsndan %0.98 Gly<br />

veya %2.5-3 düzeyinde Gly & Ser AA düzeyi önerilmektedir (Tablo<br />

Tablo 8. Msr soya esasl düşük HP yeme glisin ilavesinin etkileri Jiang et al (2005)<br />

CAA, g FCR<br />

%24 HP (Kontrol), %2.28 Gly+Ser 791 a 1.259 a<br />

DHP 20 (%20HP), %1.64 Gly +Ser 684 c 1.426 c<br />

DHP 20 + %0.2 Glisin,%1.84 Gly+Ser 718 b 1.368 b<br />

DHP 16 (%16 HP), %1.06 Gly+Ser 513 e 1.645 e<br />

DHP 16 + %0.32 Glisin, %1.38 Gly+Ser 568 d 1.536 d<br />

Dean et al (2006), 0-18 gün<br />

%22.2. HP (Kontrol), %0.93Gly, %2.05Gly+Ser 555 x 1.310 y<br />

DHP 16.2 (%16.2 HP), %0.57Gly, %1.25Gly+Ser 499 z 1.400 z<br />

DHP 16.2+%0.36Glisin, 0.93Gly,%1.61Gly+Ser 551 x 1.250 x<br />

CAA/YT, g/kg<br />

Şekil 6. Msr-soya esasl yemlerde Gly+Ser düzeyinin yemden yararlanmaya etkisi<br />

Dean (2006)<br />

100


CAA, g<br />

Gereksinim: %0.98<br />

Şekil 7. Ross 508 CAA için Gly gereksinimi, 7-20 gün Corzo et al. (2004)<br />

Gilisin fazlalğ ve bağrsak mikrofloras ilişkisi:<br />

Gilisin fazlalğ sindirim sistemi mikrofloras üzerinde önemli etkiler yaratmaktadr.<br />

Artan Gly (>%1.58) düzeyi, körbağrsak Lactobacillus saysn düşürürken, ileum ve<br />

kör bağrsak C. perfringes saysn artrmştr (Tablo 9).<br />

Tablo 9. Broylerde rasyon Gly düzeyinin ileum ve cecum microfloras üzerine etkisi,<br />

14-28 gün Dahiya et al. (2005)<br />

Lactobacillus spp. C. perfringes<br />

Gly, % İleum Cecum İleum Cecum<br />

0.75 7.22 9.21 a 3.39 a 5.83 a<br />

1.58 7.07 8.93 ab 4.35 b 7.35 b<br />

3.04 6.95 8.71 b 3.99 b 8.11 c<br />

4.21 6.84 8.31 c 4.28 b 7.89 bc<br />

Rasyon ham proteini AA ile serbest AA ler arasndaki yararlanlabilirlik<br />

farkllklar:<br />

Düşük ham protein düzeyli yemlere serbest (sentetik) AA ler (EAA ve/veya<br />

NEAA) yüksek düzeylerde ilave edildiğinde; rasyon ham proteini AA lerine<br />

göre daha hzl absorbe edilmektedir. EAA ve NEAA lerin dengede olmasna<br />

rağmen, bunun sonucunda, plazma AA profilinin dengelenmesi açsndan,<br />

yüksek düzeydeki AA ler katabolize olabilmektedir.<br />

Bregendahl et al. (2002) & Jiang et al (2005) düşük proteinli yemlerde ilave<br />

sentetik EAA ve NEAA lerin performans geliştirmediğini bildirmişlerdir.<br />

Esansiyel AA (EAA) lerin bazlarnn yetersizliği:<br />

Ham protein oran düşürüldükçe, Met ve Lys sonrasnda Thr, Arg, Trp, İsole<br />

ve Val snrlandrc duruma düşmektedir.<br />

Sentetik Met, Lys ve Thr sahada yaygn olarak kullanldğndan, yemlik Arg<br />

ve Trp yeterli miktarda bulunmadğnda ve İso-le ile Val için sentetik yemlik<br />

101


formlarnn henüz piyasada yer almamas dolaysyla baz beslemeciler<br />

rasyonda ham proteini artrc etkide bulunan bu AA lerin düzeyinin<br />

düşürülmesine veya serbest braklmas yoluna gitmektedirler.<br />

Esansiyel AA (EAA) lerin bazlarnn yetersizliği:<br />

İSOLÖSİN<br />

İsolösin; msr-soya esasl broyler yemlerinde 4. snrlandrc amino asitdir.<br />

Özellikle DL-Met, L-Lys HCL ve L-Thr ilavesi yapldğnda maliyeti ve<br />

rasyon ham proteinini artrc etkide bulunmaktadr.<br />

İso-lösinin ekonomik yemlik sentetik formu bulunmadğndan rasyondaki<br />

minimum düzeyi düşürüldüğünde veya serbest brakldğnda performans<br />

açsndan sorun oluşturabilmektedir (Tablo 10).<br />

Tablo 10. Broylerlerde isölösin düzeyinin etkileri Park & Austic (2000)<br />

İsolösin,% 1 CAA,g Yem<br />

tüketimi, g<br />

FCR<br />

g:g<br />

0.50 125 210 0.59<br />

0.56 178 279 0.64<br />

0.62 236 342 0.69<br />

0.68 255 361 0.71<br />

0.74 269 386 0.70<br />

0.80 275 388 0.75<br />

0.86 264 381 0.69<br />

Belirlenen<br />

0.65 0.69 0.63<br />

isolösin gereksinim, %<br />

0-16 gün Hubbard broyler, 2985 kcal ME, % 19.2 HP, Lys %1.10<br />

1 P


Tablo 11. Broylerde (Ross 308 erkek) valin düzeyinin etkileri Corzo et al. (2008)<br />

Valine,% CAA,g YT,g FCR Ölüm,%<br />

0.75 316 427 1.37 7.5<br />

0.83 366 469 1.29 4.2<br />

0.91 376 461 1.23 2.5<br />

0.99 388 478 1.21 0.8<br />

1.07 401 477 1.19 1.7<br />

1.15 386 466 1.22 4<br />

P değeri 0.001 0.001 0.001 0.300<br />

Belirlenen gereksinim<br />

Total 1.00 0.98 0.99 0.94<br />

Sindirilebilir 0.91 0.89 0.90 0.85<br />

0-14 gün, 3075 kcal ME/kg, %20 HP, Lys % 1.30<br />

Rasyon İdeal Proteinin Oluşturulmasnda Optimum Lisin Düzeyi<br />

Optimum rasyon lisin etlik civciv başlatma yemlerinde genel olarak ham proteinin<br />

%5.3-5.5’i arasnda, arginin dikkate alndğnda ise maksimum büyüme ve yemden<br />

yararlanma için ham proteinin %5.6-5.7’si düzeyinde lisin gerekli olduğu<br />

söylenilebilir. Yemden yararlanmay optimize etmek için %21-23 ham protein içeren<br />

etlik piliç yemlerinde srasyla %1.20-1.31 lisin (ham proteinin %5.7 si düzeyinde)<br />

gerekli olmaktadr. Araştrmalar lisin gereksiniminin ham proteinin linear bir<br />

fonksiyonu olduğunu göstermektedir. Rasyon lisin AA düzeyinin canl ağrlk artş,<br />

yem değerlendirme Şekil 8, karkas verimi ve göğüs eti üzerine etkileri Şekil 9 ve<br />

ekonomik CA, karkas ve göğüs eti üretimi için lisin gereksinimleri Şekil 10’da<br />

verilmiştir.<br />

CAA, g/gün<br />

FCR, g/g<br />

İdeal lisin düzeyi, g Lisin /kg yem<br />

CAA<br />

FCR, g/g<br />

Şekil 8. Lisine göre oluşturulan dengeli protein düzeyinin broylerde canl ağrlk ve yem değerlendirme<br />

üzerine etkileri Eits et al. (2005) Lys düzeyine göre diğer AA ler dengede tutulmuştur.<br />

103


Karkas verimi, kg/kg CA<br />

Göğüs eti verimi,<br />

g/g karkas<br />

Lisin, g/kg yem<br />

Karkas verimi<br />

Göğüs eti verimi<br />

Şekil 9. Lisine göre oluşturulan dengeli protein düzeyinin broylerde karkas ve göğüs<br />

eti verimine etkileri Eits et al. (2005)<br />

Gelir / piliç<br />

Gelir<br />

Yem maliyeti / piliç<br />

Brüt kar<br />

Yem maliyeti<br />

• CA için 8.9 g/kg Lys<br />

• Karkas için 9.4 g/kg Lys<br />

• Parça et için 9.8 g/kg Lys<br />

Ekonomik<br />

düzey<br />

Lisin düzeyi, g/kg yem<br />

Şekil 10. Lisine göre oluşturulan dengeli protein düzeyinin broylerde yem fiyat, gelir<br />

ve brüt kar üzerine etkileri Eits et al. (2005)<br />

Sindirilebilir İdeal Protein<br />

(Lys göre AA düzeyleri)<br />

Yemlerin AA sindirilebilirlikleri: Yaplan çok sayda çalşma ile protein ve AA<br />

sindirilebilirlik değerleri ortaya konulmuş olmakla beraber; ham maddelerin<br />

104


özellikleri, kalite ve işleme yöntemlerine göre değişimler yer alabilmektedir.<br />

Kanatllar için baz yem maddelerinin protein ve AA sindirilebilirliği Tablo 12’de<br />

verilmiştir. Çizelge 12’den de görüldüğü üzere AA sindirlebilirliği tahllarn içinde<br />

sorgumda, baklagiller içinde AA e göre değişen bir sindilebilirlik değeri, hayvansal<br />

protein kaynaklarndan et ununda balk ununa göre daha düşük AA sindirlebilirliği<br />

göstermiştir.<br />

Sindirilebilir İdeal Protein / AA<br />

İdeal protein / AA değerlerinde sindirilebilir değerlerinin kullanlmas<br />

Çeşitli bildirişler arasnda farkllklarn yer alabileceği dikkate alnmaldr.<br />

İdeal AA değerleri;<br />

1. çeşitli araştrclar,<br />

2. kullanlan model,<br />

3. kanatl yaş<br />

4. üretim yönüne (CAA, FCR ve göğüs eti %’si) göre farkllk göstermektedir<br />

(Tablo 13 ve 14).<br />

Tablo 12. Kanatllar için baz yem maddelerinin protein ve AA sindirilebilirliği<br />

Dutch Bureau of Livestock Feeding (1994)<br />

Hammadde Ham protein (%) Sindirilebilirlik (%)<br />

Ham Protein Lizin Metyonin Sistin Treonin<br />

Msr 8.7 84 61 88 75 75<br />

Arpa 10.7 70 65 75 70 67<br />

Yulaf 11.2 75 60 76 64 63<br />

Buğday 11.9 81 84 89 84 79<br />

Sorgum 10.1 72 55 69 65 44<br />

Bezeliye 20.6 87 83 87 75 81<br />

SFK 45.0 86 87 85 81 83<br />

ATK 34.0 85 85 81 76 94<br />

Kolza<br />

küspesi<br />

34.3 76 80 84 70 78<br />

<strong>Et</strong> unu 58.6 80 78 78 69 76<br />

Balk unu 66.0 88 91 93 89 85<br />

<strong>Et</strong>lik piliçlerde yem enerji yoğunluğu<br />

Yaplan çalşmalar etlik piliçlerde yem ME yoğunluğuna bağl olarak yem<br />

tüketiminin doğrusal bir eğilim gösterdiğini ortaya çkrmştr. Bu durum en azndan<br />

yem tekstürünün yem tüketimi üzerinde etkili olduğu bilinen uç değerler arasnda<br />

kalan enerji yoğunluklarnda geçerlidir. Bunun yannda yem ME yoğunluğunun<br />

artşna bağl olarak snrl ölçüde de olsa etlik piliçlerde canl ağrlğn arttğ<br />

bildirilmektedir (Şekil 11 ve 12).<br />

105


Tablo 13. Broyler için Lisine göre İdeal AA bildirişleri (Coon 2004)<br />

Tablo 14. Broylerde 20-40 günler aras CAA, FCR ve göğüs eti için İdeal AA düzeyi (Broken<br />

Line Model) Leglerq 1999<br />

CAA için FCR için Göğüs eti %si için<br />

Deneme I II I II I II<br />

Gereksinim, %<br />

D. Lisin 0.92 0.984 1.01 1.01 0.943 0.974<br />

İdeal AA gereksinimi<br />

D. Lisin 100 100 100 100 100 100<br />

D. Arginine 103 103 105 119 101 104<br />

D. Met&Cys 74 73 66 75 67 69<br />

D. Valine 78 77 61 69 73 75<br />

D. İsolösin 66 66 58 66 69 71<br />

D. Threonin 65 64 54 60 63 65<br />

D. Triptofan 15 15 13 14 15 16<br />

106


Broyler yem tüketimi, 42 gün<br />

Yem tüketimi, kg<br />

Yem ME yoğunluğu, Mkal/kg<br />

Şekil 11. Broylerde rasyon enerji yoğunluğunun yem tüketimi üzerine etkisi, 42 gün<br />

Guevara (2004) [Msr-soya-balk unu esasl, Cobb civciv. Gereksinim olarak NRC<br />

(2004) esas alnmştr. Besin madde yoğunluklar ME başna sabit tutulmuştur]<br />

Broyler canl ağrlk, 42 gün<br />

Broyler canl ağrlk, kg<br />

Yem ME yoğunluğu, Mkal/kg<br />

Şekil 12. Broylerde rasyon enerji yoğunluğunun canl ağrlk üzerine etkisi, 42 gün<br />

Guevara (2004)<br />

107


D. Lys / ME oran ???<br />

İdeal AA kavramnda belirleyici olan lisin AA olduğuna göre, lisin AA<br />

enerjiye oranlanabilir ve ana belirleyici kriter olarak kullanlabilir mi ?<br />

Lemme ve arkadaşlar tarafndan (Lemme et al. 2004) etlik piliçlerin değişik besleme<br />

dönemleri için birim ME başna sindirilebilir lisin ve ideal ME düzeyi ile lisine göre<br />

sindirlebilir ideal AA gereksinimleri Tablo 15’de verilmiştir.<br />

Roos 308 etlik piliç besin maddesi gereksinimleri kataloğunda (Ross 2007), bildirilen<br />

AA ihtiyaçlar üzerine optimal emniyet yap olarak %5 ilavesi tavsiye edilmektedir.<br />

Ayrca ayn katalog bilgisinde bildirilen gereksinimlerin sadece bir klavuz olarak<br />

kullanlabileceği, bölgesel koşullara ve pazar şartlarna göre değişikliklerin<br />

yaplabileceği bildirilmektedir. Ksacas etlik piliçlerde her bir genotip için dahi sabit<br />

olarak tüm işletmelerde uygulanabilecek gereksinimin söz konusu olmadğ, her<br />

işletmenin kendi koşullarna uygun gereksinimleri belirlemesi ve uygulamada<br />

kullanmas yerinde olacaktr.<br />

Tablo 15. Broylerde ideal protein ve optimum rasyon lisin içeriğine göre sindirilebilir<br />

AA önerileri (Lemme et al., 2004)<br />

Dönem Başlatma I Başlatma II Geliştirme Bitirme I Bitirme II<br />

Gün aralklar 1-5 6-14 15-35 35-45 >45<br />

Standardize edilmiş ileal<br />

D. Lys, g/MJ ME 1.03 0.98 0.85 0.75 0.70<br />

Enerji, MJ ME/kg 12.6 12.8 13 13.2 13.4<br />

İleal D. Lys, %<br />

rasyonda<br />

1.30 1.25 1.11 0.99 0.94<br />

İleal D. protein, %<br />

rasyonda<br />

22.0 20.0 18.0 17.0 16.5<br />

Rasyon,<br />

Lys=100 Rasyon, Lys=100 Rasyon, Lys=100 Rasyon, Lys=100 Rasyon, Lys=100<br />

%<br />

%<br />

%<br />

%<br />

%<br />

Met 0.59 45 0.56 45 0.49 44 0.43 43 0.40 43<br />

Met + Cys 0.94 72 0.91 73 0.83 75 0.76 77 0.74 79<br />

Thr 0.82 63 0.80 64 0.72 65 0.65 66 0.63 67<br />

Trp 0.21 16 0.20 16 0.18 16 0.17 17 0.16 17<br />

Arg 1.33 102 1.29 103 1.17 105 1.06 107 1.01 107<br />

Val 1.03 79 0.99 79 0.89 80 0.80 81 0.76 81<br />

Ile 0.88 68 0.85 68 0.78 70 0.71 72 0.69 73<br />

Leu 1.39 107 1.34 107 1.19 107 1.06 107 1.01 107<br />

Lemme et al. (2004) tarafndan bildirilen gereksinimlere benzer olarak klavuz olarak<br />

değişik etlik piliç genotiplerine göre Tablo 16’da yer alan hesaplamalarda olduğu gibi<br />

ME başna toplam veya sindirilebilir AA gereksinimleri ve sindirilebilir lisin AA ine<br />

göre ideal sindirilebilir diğer AA lerin düzeyleri ile ME başna minimum ve<br />

maksimum mineral madde gereksinimleri de hesaplanabilir ve bu değerler<br />

kullanlarak (koyu olarak verilen kriter ve değerler) istenilen ideal AA ve besin<br />

madde yoğunluğu konseptinde yem formülasyonlarnn gerçekleştirilmesi söz konusu<br />

olacaktr. Sindirilebilir lisin AA ni ME başna tanmlayarak, daha sonrasnda da<br />

sindilebilir lisinne göre idael AA konseptinde diğer AA leri tanmlamak ve bunlarn<br />

yannda mineral madde gereksinimlerini de ME’ye oranlamak ideal konsepte istenilen<br />

besin madde yoğunluğunda, besin madde düzeylerinde bir değişiklik yapmadan<br />

sadece sindirilebilir lisinin ME’ye oran değerini değiştirerek istenilen besin madde<br />

yoğunluğunda formülasyon yapmak söz konusu olacaktr. Böyle bir durumda belirli<br />

108


ir ME aralğnda, örneğin etlik civciv yemi için 3000-3100 kcal/kg aralğnda ME<br />

yannda diğer besin maddeleri de ME’ye göre değişen düzeylerde, ekonomik üretim<br />

için çoklu çözüm yaratmak ve bunlarn içinden en uygununu kullanmak söz konusu<br />

olabilecektir. <strong>Et</strong>lik civciv için, AA ler yannda, 3025 kcal/kg ME’lik yemde %1.05 Ca<br />

bulunmas gerekiyorsa, 3000 kcal/kg ME’de %1.04, 3100 kcal/kg ME’de %1.08 Ca<br />

yer almş olacaktr.<br />

Tablo 16. Ross 308- 2007 <strong>Et</strong>lik civiv (0-10 gün) besin madde spefikasyonlarndan<br />

birim metabolik enerji başna hesaplanan besin madde gereksinimleri<br />

Gün 0-10<br />

ME, kcal 3025<br />

AA/ME Dig_AA/ME AA/Lys Dig_AA/DigLys<br />

Lys 0.4727 0.4198 100.0 100.0<br />

Met&Sis 0.3537 0.3107 74.8 74.0<br />

Met 0.1686 0.1554 35.7 37.0<br />

Thr 0.3107 0.2744 65.7 65.4<br />

Val 0.3603 0.3140 76.2 74.8<br />

Isole 0.3207 0.2810 67.8 66.9<br />

Arg 0.4793 0.4331 101.4 103.1<br />

Trp 0.0793 0.0661 16.8 15.7<br />

Min<br />

Mak<br />

ME/HP 137.5 121.0<br />

Ca 0.347<br />

Pav 0.165<br />

Mg 0.017 0.165<br />

Na 0.053 0.076<br />

Cl 0.053 0.076<br />

K 0.132 0.331<br />

Sonuç/ strateji/ öneriler<br />

Sonuç/ strateji/ öneri- (Yem)<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

Ham maddelerinizi kalite yönünden iyi değerlendiriniz<br />

Yem ham maddelerinin AA içeriğini ya arada analize göndererek, yada<br />

yaptğnz her bir ham madde için temel besin madde analiz değerine göre<br />

uygun denklemlerle tahminde bulununuz<br />

Hammaddelerin besin madde yararlanmnn yaşa ve stres koşullarna göre<br />

değiştiğini dikkate alnz<br />

Ham madde çeşitliliğinin AA dengesi ve rasyon ham proteininin biyolojik<br />

yararlanmn artrdğ unutulmamaldr<br />

Formülasyonda yemlerin sindirimi ve mikrobiyal populasyon ilişkisini<br />

dikkate alnz<br />

109


Sonuç/ strateji/ öneri- (İhtiyaçlar)<br />

Kanatllarn bildirilen ihtiyaçlar optimum koşullarda emniyet pay da<br />

dikkate alnarak önerilmektedir.<br />

Farkl genotipler için ihtiyaçlar farkl olduğu gibi, ayn genotip için farkl<br />

bölgeler ve farkl entegrelerde de ihtiyaçlar değişebilmektedir<br />

Çevre scaklğ protein ve AA gereksinimini etkilemektedir<br />

Farkl bakm ve idare koşullarnda da ihtiyaçlar değişebilmektedir.<br />

İhtiyaçlar yaşa göre değişmektedir<br />

İhtiyaçlar farkl üretim hedeflerine göre değişmektedir (daha iyi yem<br />

değerlendirme, göğüs eti, but eti vb.)<br />

İhtiyaçlarn belirlenmesinde et kalitesi kriterlerini (görünüş, su tutma<br />

kapasitesi vb) de dikkate alnz<br />

Karma yem formunun da ihtiyaçlar üzerinde etkili olduğu unutulmamaldr<br />

Sonuç/ strateji/ öneri- (Kontrol)<br />

Abdominal yağ, karkas parça oranlar ve ekonomik performans düzenli<br />

olarak gözden geçirilmelidir<br />

Ham madde analiz veri bankanz oluşturunuz<br />

Yem besin madde matriksinizi besin madde analizi ve yararlanlabilirlik<br />

durumlarna göre düzenleyiniz<br />

Üretim kümeslerinde belirli aralklarla sindirilebilirlik kontrolleri yapnz ve<br />

rasyonlarnz bu sonuçlar yönüyle de değerlendiriniz.<br />

Sonuç/ strateji/ öneri- (Enerji)<br />

Enerji düzeyi yerine (kcal of ME /kg yem)<br />

Besin madde yoğunluğunu dikkate alnz<br />

Besin madde yoğunluğu seçimini; ekonomik performans ve yemin fiziksel<br />

özelliklerinde olabilecek değişimleri de dikkate alarak yapnz<br />

<strong>Et</strong>lik piliçler sadece enerji ihtiyaçlarna göre değil, besin madde<br />

yoğunluğuna göre de yem tüketimlerini ayarlarlar<br />

Sonuç/ strateji/ öneri- (Amino asit)<br />

Yemlik sentetik formlar bulunmayan 4. ve 5. snrlandrc AA lerin<br />

karmadaki düzeyleri mutlaka karşlanmaldr<br />

Rasyonlar mutlaka sindirilebilir amino asit (SAA) esasnda formüle<br />

edilmelidir<br />

Sindirilebilir AA düzeyleri yemde yer alan enerjiyle (ME)<br />

ilişkilendirilmelidir<br />

110


Sonuç/ strateji/ öneri- (D. AA/ ME)<br />

<strong>Et</strong>lik piliç yemlerinde bulunmas önerilen D. Lys AA düzeyleri ME’ye<br />

oranlanmaldr<br />

D. Lisin /Mcal ME: (Ross 308- 2007)<br />

o Başlatma: 0.420<br />

o Büyütme: 0.349<br />

o Bitirme : 0.303<br />

Oranlar:<br />

o Üretim yönüne: Bütün veya parça et<br />

o Kanatl genotipi<br />

o Yem üretim teknolojisi (toz yem, pelet yem, granül yem)<br />

o Pazar talebi<br />

o Ekonomiklik: Optimal besin madde yoğunluğu seçilmelidir.<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

Sonuç/ strateji/ öneri- (İdeal AA)<br />

ME düzeyi ve D. Lys:ME oran karar verildikten sonra;<br />

Diğer tüm amino asitlerin sindirilebilir değerlerini (ihtiyaçlar) ideal protein<br />

esasna göre lisin AA’ne oranlaynz<br />

İdeal AA değerleri üretim yönü ve ekonomik verilere göre düzenlenebilir<br />

Rasyon EAA : NEAA dengesini dikkate alnz<br />

Mineral maddeleri de ME’ye oranlayabilirsiniz<br />

Besleme dönemi says da teknik ve ekonomik verilere göre seçilmelidir.<br />

Sonuç/ strateji/ öneri- (Enzimler)<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

Rasyon AA lerinden yararlanmay artrma açsndan ekonomik olduğu<br />

ölçüde enzim kullannz<br />

Aldğnz enzimlerin aktivite değerlerini kontrol ettiriniz.<br />

Enzim aktiviteleri çok çeşitli yöntemlerle belirlendiğinden farkl firmalarn<br />

enzimleri için önerdiği aktivite değerlerinin ancak ayn yöntemle<br />

yapldğnda rakamsal olarak karşlaştrlabilir bir değer taşndğn<br />

unutmaynz.<br />

Proteaz enzimi; proteini hedef almakla beraber, her bir proteazn hedef aldğ<br />

protein tipi ve AA lerin yararlanm açsndan, ham maddelere göre önerilen<br />

AA matriks değerlerini dikkate alnz.<br />

111


Sonuç/ strateji/ öneri<br />

(Enzimler-Formülasyon)<br />

Enzimlerin besin maddelerinden sağladğ yararlanmlar dikkate alarak<br />

ME’ye oranlanmş lisin ve ideal AA esasnda rasyonlarnz oluşturunuz<br />

Enzimlerin etkinliği üzerinde rolü bulunan faktörleri dikkate alnz<br />

Sonuç/ strateji/ öneri<br />

(Ekonomik üretim)<br />

Yem formülasyonlarnz teknik performans yannda, teknik performas<br />

sonuçlarn da dikkate alan ekonomik performansa göre oluşturunuz. Yem<br />

formülasyonu açsndan teknik bilgilerin üzerinde bireysel ferasetinizi<br />

kullannz ve farkllklar yakalaynz<br />

Kaynaklar<br />

Austic, R. E., 1994. Proc. Maryland Nutr. Conf. 114-130.<br />

Baker, D.H., C. M. Parsons, C. M. Fernandez, S. Aoyagi and Y. Han. 1993. Proc. Arkansas<br />

Nutr. Conf. 22-32.<br />

Baker, D. H., 1996. Nutrient Management of Food Animals to Enhance and Protect the<br />

Environment. Kornegay, E. T. (ed.), Lewis Publishers, New York, p41-53.<br />

Baker, D. H., S. R. Fernandez, C. M. Parsons, H. M. Edwards III, J. L. Emmert, and D.M.<br />

Webel, 1996. J. Nutr. 126:1844-1851.<br />

Bedford, M.R. and Summers, J.D. (1985) Influence of the ratio of essential to nonessential<br />

amino acids on performance and carcass composition of the broiler chick. British Poultry<br />

Science 26: 483-451.<br />

Bregendahl, K., Sell, J.L. and Zimmerman, D.R. (2002) Effect of low protein diet on<br />

performance and body composition of broiler chicks. Poultry Science 81: 1156-1167.<br />

Coon C. (2004) The Ideal Amino Acid Requirements and Profile for Broilers, Layers, and<br />

Broiler Breeders. ASA Technical Information. FE 153: 1-43.<br />

Corzo A., W. A. Dozier III and M. T. Kidd (2008). Valine Nutrient Recommendations for Ross<br />

-Ross 308 Broilers. Poultry Science 87:335–338.<br />

Corzo, A., Kidd, M.T., Burnham, D.J. And Kerr, J.B. (2004) Dietary glycine needs of broiler<br />

chicks. Poultry Science 83: 1382-1384.<br />

Dahiya J. P., D. Hoehler, D. C. Wilkie, A. G. Van Kessel, and M. D. Drew (2005). Dietary<br />

glycine concentration affects intestinal Clostridium perfringens and lactobacilli populations<br />

in broiler chickens. Poultry Science 84:1875–1885.<br />

Dean, D.W., Bidner, T.D. And Southern, L.L. (2006) Glycine supplementation of low protein,<br />

amino acid-supplemented diets supports equal performance of broiler chicks. Poultry Science<br />

85: 288-296.<br />

De Lange L., C. Rombouts and G. Oude Elferink (2003) Practical application and advantages of<br />

using total digestible amino acids and undigestible crude protein to formulate broiler diets.<br />

World's Poultry Science Journal 59 : pp 447-457<br />

Dutch Bureau of Livestock Feeding, (1994). Chemical composition, digestibdify and energy<br />

value of feed ingredients. Bureau of Livestock Feeding, Lelystad, The Netherlan<br />

Eits R.M., G.W.J. Gieseni, R.P. Kwakkel, M.W.A. Verstegen and L.A. Den Hartog (2005).<br />

Dietary balanced protein in broiler chickens. 2. An economic analysis. British Poultry<br />

Science 46(3):310–317.<br />

Fatufe, A.A. And Rodehutscord, M. (2005) Growth, body composition, and marginal efficiency<br />

of methionine utilization are affected by nonessential amino acid nitrogen supplementation in<br />

male broiler chicken. Poultry Science 84: 1584-1592.<br />

112


Han, Y., Suzuki, H., Parsons, C.M. and Baker, D.H. (1992) Amino acid fortification of a lowprotein<br />

corn and soybean meal diet for chicks. Poultry Science 71: 1168-1178.<br />

Jiang, Q., Waldroup, P.W. And Fritts, C.A. (2005) Improving utilization of diets low in crude<br />

protein fro broiler chicken, 1. Evaluation of specific amino acid supplementation to diets low<br />

in crude protein. International Journal Poultry Science 4(3): 115-122.<br />

Lemme A., V. Ravindran and W.L. Bryden (2004). Ileal digestibility of amino acids in feed<br />

ingredients for broilers . World’s Poultry Science Journal 60: 423-437.<br />

Mack, S., D. Bercovici, G. De Groote, B. Leclercq, M. Lippens, M. Pack, J. B. Schutte, and S.<br />

Van Cauwenberghe. 1999. Ideal amino acid profile and dietary lysine specification for<br />

broiler chickens of 20 to 40 days of age. Br. Poult. Sci. 40:257–265.<br />

Moran, E.T. Jr., Bushong, R.D. And Bilgili, S.F. (1992) Reducing dietary crude protein for<br />

broilers while satisfying amino acid requirements by least-cost formulation: live<br />

performance, litter composition, and yield of fast-food carcass cuts at six weeks. Poultry<br />

Science 71: 1687-1694.<br />

NRC (1994) Nutrient Requirements of Poultry, 9th rev. edn (Washington, DC, National<br />

Academy Press).<br />

Park B.C. and R. E. Austic (2000) Isoleucine imbalance using selected mixtures of imbalancing<br />

amino acids in diets of the broiler chick. Poultry Science 79:1782–1789.<br />

Rossi (2006). An Introduction to Least-Cost Feed Formulation Software, Feedsoft Corporation<br />

Si, J., Fritts, C.A., Burnham, D.J. And Waldroup, P.W. (2004) Extent to which crude protein<br />

may be reduced in corn-soybean meal broiler diets through amino acid supplementation.<br />

International Journal Poultry Science 3(1): 46-50<br />

113


" #!C $D.F5-&.$b.&1()(,/&$`&)$?&A,F-FM('(,(,$8,&)($<br />

*7,.$#'&-").L)5""8);"-3.&.0.2()%&)E$.%0"$)@$.81-#%.&)<br />

!<br />

;)%'%!l'$:0633'(!!<br />

H#+=$%0A36!K'-B-#!c':B!O+3B!T'%BK$5B;BTb;=&$+'(49'%$+'_K6(=#7!B*##)!9$33!9'%'A#(bJ063.(7!n6.($.$0%$+.!<br />

$<br />

:;'1.+


.&1()$?&A,F-FM('($<br />

2F9+M-+)+$<br />

EXD=+#=!.#=%030I$)#!0.0:'+70%!NJijbT5')'P$<br />

b\'.'+!>!.'(.!:!7'@:'=!$?$%!&'++'+!='%.'(3'($<br />

b\'::'))#!?#$.3$3$$%$!'(..!(:'=!$?$%!1'>3'!+'7!)'!)0>'I3':'!+$30+6!N:'3$7#.!<br />

)DD(D5D!#.=$!)#!+'3'(P!!!<br />

!b!9$=(0!#3#:#%.3#(!$?$%!:$=(0)0>'I!+$303'(!!<br />

$<br />

8O1)&$$<br />

!!b!2$(!U(%#=!='(!!:4!'(.3'%)!(:'!+!('+!%)'!G6&'()'=$!%#:$%!-#!+!5'=3!!%!%!)'&'!$7$!<br />

G$(!#=$3)#!7#:!$?$%#!%D16>!#.:#+$!-#!7#:$%!&'7-'%!'?!+!%)'%!+$%)$($3#G$3$(3$$%$%!<br />

'(..!(!3:'+!!$?$%!UD.:#!A#(#=3$)$(B!<br />

!!!b!%5#!-#!G$(!U(%#=!UD.:#!)'&'!$7$!@#3#.!D(#.$:$%#!7'()!:5!!03:'=.')!(B!<br />

!!!b!,7A6%!?'@.'!#3#=!+#?$:$!!<br />

!!!b!R@.$:6:!+'7!)'!?#=$?!=633'%!:!!-#!?#=$?3#($%!)U%D!&!>!!!<br />

!!!!!H'3$.#3$!@#3#.!7#:!#3)#!#.:#=!$?$%!UD.:#)#%!+0%('=$!@'(.$=D3!GD7D=3DD!0('%3'(!h!<br />

V!::'+70%!-#!+$%)$($3#G$3$(3$=!<br />

b!T.#($3!7#:!D(#.$:$!<br />

'(.3'%)!(:'!+D(#+$%5#!=633'%!3'%!G6&'(4!%$'+.'%!%!7'@!+!%)'!)#$$=3$=!7'('.!(!-#!G6!<br />

)6(6:!I#3'.$%$>'+70%'!%#)#%!036(B!;7%!!>':'%)'!@(0.#$%3#(!@3'+.$=+$!G$(!7'@!7'!<br />

)U%DD(4!+#3D30>!$+#!)'&'!76:6'=!G$(!7'@!7'!='-66(B!<br />

!<br />

! !!N


!<br />

!<br />

K'G30!VB!H'3!!TD(#+$%$%!w#3'.$%$>'+70%!R('%!!`>#($%)#!L.=$+$!<br />

L=$@:'%!K$@$! H'3!!+D(#+$!N+'%$7#P! w#3'.$%$>'+70%!R('%!!NtP!<br />

K#=!'1.3!!N9$33$P!H0%)D+70%#(! V^bd[! V^bd[!<br />

k$1.!H0%)D+70%#(! g[bg^! d[bd^!<br />

H')#:#3$!k'@_\!>! Vd[bVf[! g[b^[!<br />

7$!G$(!'(.3'%)!(:'!$3#!7#:!@#3#.!:'=$%#+$%#!tVebVZ!%#:!$?#($$!$3#!A$(:#3$)$(B!<br />

V&-&1-&)&$!<br />

!b!,7A6%!)$+=!+#?$:$!N]4^!::!?'@4!Z[bZ^!::!='3!%3!=P!<br />

!b!c$+=$%!)U%:#!&!>!!<br />

!b!"63#3#(!-#!)$+=!'('+!%)'=$!G036=!<br />

!b!T06.:'!!<br />

$<br />

`+$%+^-+)+$@&$B-&)&$<br />

!!b!7$!='3$.#)#!@#3#.!#3)#!#.:#=!$?$%!('+70%)'=$!7'4!+06.:'!+0%('+!%)'!='@3':'!<br />

7U%.#:$73#!67A63'%:'3!)!(B!9$=+#(#!%#!=')'(!'>!!0('%)'!7'!A$(#(+#!@#3#.!='3$.#+$!0!<br />

=')'(!$7$!036(B!<br />

!!b!,7A63'%'%!7'!%!+!5'=3!!!^^be[!+'%.$A('.!)#(#5#!'('3!!%)'!03:'3!)!(B!<br />

!!b!K0>36366!U%3#:#=!$?$%!#3#:#!7'@!3:'3!)!(B!!<br />

$<br />

>.+,O-+'5F,$@&$B-&)&$<br />

!!!!!3=!d[!AD%!7#:3#($%$%!5$-5$-3#(!.'('1!%)'%!#%!$7$!#=$3)#!)##(3#%)$($3:#+$!$?$%!<br />

@#3#.3#(!=D?D=!@'(.$=D33#(#!'7(!3:'3!)!(B!<br />

!!![bV[!AD%!7#:3#($!=D?D=!A('%D3!<br />

!!!VVbd[!AD%!7#:3#($!$($!A('%D3!<br />

!!K0>36366!U%3#:#=!$?$%!#3#:#!7'@!3:'3!)!(B!<br />

$<br />

%+-(1&$<br />

;%'!&'::'))#!A$($!='3$.#!=0%.(03!<br />

! !!T


X'%!D(D%3#(!<br />

`(D%!1$%'3!='3$.#!=0%.(03!<br />

nO"!K#=%030I$+$!!<br />

\;jjJ!67A63':'3'(!!<br />

:,+$L+))+//&$>(.($%+-(1&$%F,1.F-!<br />

c!'!.$E$D7/+5$$$!<br />

!"6.6G#.!N:'=+$:6:!tVdP!<br />

!H!(!=!)'%#!0('%!!N:'=+$:6:!t^P!<br />

!HD13#(!-#!9$=0.0=+$%3#(!!<br />

!\#=.03$.(#!<br />

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!X'G'%5!!9'))#!<br />

"F5+$%O'^&'(E?+)$`+-!$"F5+!<br />

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!J(0.#$%!-#!7'!0('%3'(!!!<br />

!J$$($3:#!)#(#5#+$!<br />

!!!!!!!!!!!D(#'>!=0%.(03DN^bV[P!<br />

!!!!!!!!!!!@0.'+76:!&$)(0=+$..#!?U>D%D(3D=NZ^bf^P!<br />

!!!!!!!!!!!.($@+$%!$%&$G$.U(D!'%'3$>$!<br />

`&)-(A$`+-+.$$$!<br />

!!!!!"6.6G#.!N:'MBt[4^P!<br />

!!!!!K0(.6!N:'MBt[4^P!<br />

!!!!!J#(0=+$.!)##($!N:'MBV[P!<br />

!!!!!K0@3':!X'!;+$.3#($!NVbe[P!<br />

!!!!!@\Ngb^P!<br />

!!!!!T'G6%!+'7!+!!N'+$.!7'3'(!%)'4!+!1!(!03:'3!P!<br />

!!!!!X'3'()'!11'!'(..!=?'!:#.'G03$=!#%#(I$!)##($!)D#(B!!!<br />

`+,$b.O,-&.$<br />

!!"#%)#($%A!D(D%3#($!N.'-6=!6%64!='%!6%64!.D7!6%6P!<br />

!!ccCT!<br />

!!H#@#=!<br />

!!,%!<br />

!!263A6(!,%6!-#!7'%!D(D%3#($!<br />

!!J$($%?!7'%!D(D%3#($!<br />

!!;KH!-#!H'%03'!HD+@#+$!<br />

! !!W


$<br />

$<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

$<br />

! !!Z


!<br />

b.O,$a(,+-$%+-(1&$%F,1.F-$@&$j[k$?&A,F-FM('($<br />

nO"!.#=%030I$+$!+'7#+$%)#!D(#.$5$7#!A$)#%!&#(!=':70%!7#:!&!>3!!G$(!#=$3)#!'%'3$>!<br />

#)$3$@!=0%.(03!0%'7!!-#($3:#=.#)$(B!!<br />

$<br />

L:llV$7567-+)+-+.!$<br />

CD%D:D>)#!='%'.3!!7#:$!D(#.$:$%)#!)#!\;jjJ!67A63':'3'(!!G'3':!.!(B!R3'+!!<br />

@(0G3#:3#($%!.#+@$.$!'?!+!%)'%!\;jjJ!67A63':'3'(!!.':!G$(!$>3#%#G$3$(3$=!<br />

+'3':'=.')!(B!$<br />

$<br />

i^1()7)$^&.KF.)+,'$E$aF.)O-+'5F,$$$$<br />

\'7-'%3'(!%!0@.$:6:!@#(10(:'%+!+'3':'+!!$?$%!+#?$3#%!&'::'))#3#(!(#&G#(!<br />

=$.'@3'()'!G636%'%!G#+$%!:'))#!$&.$7'?3'(!%!!='(!3'7'5'=!#=$3)#!3$%#'(!@(0A(':3'()'!<br />

10(:63$>#!#)$3:#=.#)$(!<br />

*0(:D3'+70%!7'@'(=#%!)$=='.!#)$3#5#=!&6+6+3'(Y!<br />

b! \'7-'%3'(!%!G#+$%!:'))#!$&.$7'?3'(!!<br />

b! H633'%!3'5'=!03'%!&'::'))#3#($%!1$7'.3'(!!-#!+.0=!)6(6:3'(!!<br />

!<br />

b! \'::'))#3#($%!='3$.#!=0%.(03!+0%6?3'(!!<br />

b! \'7-'%3'(!$?$%!036:+6>36=!7'('.'%!3$:$.3#(!<br />

b! `(#.$:!+!('+!%)'=$!)'(!G0'>3'(!N='%.'(!:$%$:6:!)##(3#($4!@#3#.!<br />

='3$.#+$!-GP!!<br />

!<br />

\'7-'%3'()'%!0@.$:6:!-#($:!#3)#!#.:#=!$?$%!G#+3#:#)#!)$=='.!#)$3#5#=!%0=.'3'(Y!<br />

!!b!!!T$%)$($3#G$3$(3$$!7D=+#=!&'::'))#3#($%!=633'%!:!!<br />

!!b!!!L.=$3$!-#!='3!5!!'%.$=0=+$)$'3!@(0A(':3'(!%!%!67A63'%:'+!!<br />

!!b!!!nTJ!#%>$:3#($!-#!*$.'>!#%>$:3#($!=633'%!:!!!<br />

%+5,+A-+.$<br />

!<br />

2#&%=#B!HBjB!VWWeB!*##)!:'%61'5.6($%A!.#5&%030A7B!j6((#%.!$++6#+!'%)!5&'33#%A#+B!<br />

;%$:'3!*##)!T5$#%5#!'%)!K#5&%030A74!803Bed4!@@!gWb^Z!<br />

\#.3'%)4!\B!;%)!j&05.4!9B!d[[]B!"03#!01!$%+036G3#!%0%b+.'(5&!@037+'55&'($)#+!$%!<br />

@063.(7!%6.($.$0%B!a0(3)+!J063.(7!T5$#%5#!;++05$'.$0%!J(05##)$%A+4!i$33#&'::#(4!<br />

n0(Q'7B!<br />

Å6#%.$%4!9B4!206-'(#34!OB!;%)!J$5'()4!9B!d[[gB!T&0(.!'%)!30%Ab.#(:!#11#5.+!01!1##)!<br />

10(:!0%!1'+.!'%)!+30QbA(0Q$%A!G(0$3#(+B!w06(%'3!01!;@@3$#)!J063.(7!"#+#'(5&4!V]Y@@!<br />

^g[b^gf!<br />

T-$&6+4!2B!,&3#%4!;B!'%)!\'(+.')4!RB!d[[^B!L11#5.!01!+.'(5&!A('%63#!+.(65.6(#4!<br />

'++05$'.#)!50:@0%#%.+!'%)!@(05#++$%A!0%!%6.($.$-#!-'36#!01!5#(#'3!+.'(5&Y!;!(#-$#QB!<br />

;%$:'3!*##)!T5$#%5#!'%)!K#5&%030A74!8036:#!Vdd4!O++6#!]bg4!@@!][]b]d[!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

! !!]


" #!H $?+@7A-+./+$"F-7,7)$"('1&)($L+'1+-!A-+.!$<br />

B%+#$%91#%.&)'&8)@$"+"&-").L)@.10#$()?"+,%$'#.$()B%+"'+")?"-"&#0()/""&)%&)<br />

;1$(.($<br />

K'-6=3'()'! #=0%0:$=! ='7!@3'('! %#)#%! 03'%! &'+.'3!=3'(!%! G'!%)'! +036%6:! +$+.#:$!<br />

$%1#=+$70%3'(!!A#3:#=.#)$(B!T036%6:!+$+.#:$!$%1#=+$70%3'(!!U>#33$=3#!G(0$3#(!+D(D3#()#!<br />

03:'=! D>#(#4! 76:6(.'5!! -#! )':!>3!=3'(! AU(D3:#=.#)$(B! \'+.'3!!%! 0(.'7'! ?!=.!!!<br />

+D(D3#()#! A#%#3! 03'('=! U3D:! 0('%!%)'! '(.!3'(! 0(.'7'! ?!='(B! 26! %#)#%3#! .#)'-$!<br />

67A63':'3'(!!03)6=?'!7'7A!%!03'('=!7'@!3!(!-#!.#)'-$!:'+('13'(!!G#=3#%#%)#%!7D=+#=!<br />

)D>#73#(#!?!='G$3$(B!2(0$3#(!+D(D3#()#4!'(.'%!:0(.'3$.#!$3#!G$(3$=.#4!G#+$!@#(10(:'%+!!)'!<br />

N7#:! )U%DD:! 0('%!4! 5'%3!! '!(3!=P! 036:+6>! #.=$3#%$(B! ;7(!5'! =#+$:&'%#! (#)!<br />

0('%3'(!%)'!)'!'(.!!='7)#)$3$(B!X6:6(.'!-#($:$%)#=$!)':!>3!=!-#!76:6(.'5!!+D(D3#()#!<br />

76:6(.'!-#($:)#!)D:#4!76:6(.'!='G6=!='3$.#+$%)#!G0>63:'4!!+='(.'!76:6(.')'!'(.!!<br />

-#! )':!>3!=! 76:6(.'3'()'! ?!=!:! ('%)!:'%!! '>'3:'! AU(D3D(B! T036%6:! +$+.#:$!<br />

$%1#=+$70%3'(!%)'! 0(.'7'! ?!='%! ='7!@3'(! )##(3#%)$($3)$$%)#h! G6! &'+.'3!=3'(!%!<br />

#=0%0:$=! '?!)'%! U%#:$! 0(.'7'! ?!=:'=.')!(B! 26! %#)#%3#4! .'-6=3'(! $?$%! +036%6:!<br />

+$+.#:$!&'+.'3!=3'(!%!%!=0%.(03D4!$3#.:#!$?$%!U%#:3$!#=0%0:$=!='>'%!:3'(!+'3'(B!!<br />

$<br />

B1(5F-FM($@&$V+1F6&,&9$<br />

K'-6=3'()'! +036%6:! +$+.#:$! &'+.'3!=3'(!%!%! #.$7030I$! ?0=! $7$! G$3$%:#+$%#! ='(!%!<br />

A#%#33$=3#! ?0=! 1'=.U(3D! 03'('=! 0(.'7'! ?!=:'+!! %#)#%$73#! ='(!!=.!(B! C#%#3! 03'('=!<br />

+036%6:! +$+.#:$! $%1#=+$70%3'(!%!%! #.$7030I$3#($! G'=.#($7#34! -$('3! -#! :$=0.$=! 03'('=!<br />

A(6@3'%'G$3$(B! 26! A(6@3'%)!(:'7'! AU(#! G'=.#($7#3! #.$7030I$3#($%#! AU(#4! :$=0@3'>:'!<br />

$%1#=+$70%3'(!4! $%1#=+$7U>! =0($>'4! .'-6=! =03#('+!! -#! 0(%$.0G'=.#($70>$+! NR"KPh! -$('3!<br />

#.$7030I$3#$%#!AU(#!J'(':7M0-$(6+!$%1#=+$70%3'(!!Nn#Q5'+.3#!&'+.'3!!!NJ'(':7M0-$(6+!<br />

.$@!VPh!J'(':7M0-$(6+!.$@!d!!$%1#=+$70%3'(!4!H'%'.3!!:#.'@%#6:0-$(6+!$%1#=+$70%3'(!!<br />

N;J8!$%1#=+$70%6h!T\TP4!;-$'%!$%136#%>'!N;OP4!%1#=+$7U>!G(0%$.$+!NO2P4!%1#=+$7U>!<br />

3'($%A0.('5&#$.$+! NOiKP! -#! ;)#%0-$(6+! $%1#=+$70%3'(!! -#! :$=0.$=! $%1#=+$70%3'()'%!<br />

;+@#(A$330>$+!+'7!3'G$3$(B!!<br />

!<br />

! !C#


K'-6=3'(!%! +036%6:! +$+.#:$! $%1#=+$70%3'(!%!! )##(3#%)$($(=#%! +')#5#!<br />

:$=(00(A'%$>:'3'(!!)#$34!+036%6:!+$+.#:$!$%1#=+$70%3'(!%!!#.=$3#7#%!)$#(!1'=.U(3#($%!<br />

)#! )##(3#%)$($3:#+$! A#(#=:#=.#)$(B! 26! 1'=.U(3#(! '('+!%)'! :$=(00(A'%$>:'3'(! '('+!!<br />

#.=$3#$:! NG'=.#($rG'=.#($4! -$(6+rG'=.#($4! '!! -$(6+6rG'=.#($! A$G$P4! $::6%+6@(#+70%4!<br />

'!!(#'=+70%3'(!!-#!?#-(#+#3!1'=.U(3#(!+'7!3'G$3$(B!!<br />

T036%6:!+$+.#:$!&'+.'3!=3'(!%!%!@'.0A#%#>$4!&'+.'3!=3'(!%!$7$!'%3'!3:'+!!G'=!:!%)'%!<br />

U%#:3$)$(B! K'-6=3'()'! D+.! +036%6:! +$+.#:$! )#-':3!! 03'('=! ?#-(#+#3! ='7%'=3'()'!<br />

G636%'%! :$=(00(A'%$>:'3'('! :'(6>! ='3!(B! ;%5'=! 67A6%! ?#-(#+#3! =0633'()'! -#!<br />

+'3!=3!! &'7-'%3'()'! &#(&'%A$! G$(! &'+.'3!=! 0(.'7! ?!=:'>B! 26%6%! %#)#%$! $+#4!<br />

&'7-'%3'(!%! :$=(00(A'%$>:'3'(!! )0'3! -#! ='>'%!3:!! +'-6%:'! :#='%$>:'3'(!! $3#!<br />

#3$:$%#!#.:#+$)$(B!T036%6:!+$+.#:$%)#!#%!U%#:3$!)0'3!G'($7#(!:6=0+$3$'(!7'@!)!(!-#!<br />

G6! 7'@!! :$=(00(A'%$>:'3'(!%! U>#33$=3#! )#! ?#-(#+#3! G'=.#($3#($%! +036%6:! +$+.#:$%#!<br />

=030%$>'+70%6%6! +!%!(3'(! -#! @'(.$=D3#(! 7'@!3'(!! #3$:$%#! #)#(B! ;!3':'3'(! +0%('+!%)'!<br />

='>'%!3'%! G'!!=3!=! )'4! :$=(00(A'%$>:'3'(!! +@#+$1$=! G'!!=3!=! :#='%$>:'3'(!! $3#!<br />

0(.')'%!='3)!(!3:'+!%)'!U%#:3$!AU(#-3#(!D+.3#%$(B!,7A6%!03:'7'%!?#-(#+#3!=0633'()'!<br />

-#_-#7'! +036%6:! +$+.#:$%$! #.=$3#7#%! $%1#=+$70%3'()'! NU>#33$=3#! :$=0@3'>:'!<br />

$%1#=+$70%3'(!P4!+$3$'!&D5(#3#($%$%!#.=$3#%:#+$!+0%656%)'!)0'3!+'-6%:'!:#='%$>:'+!!<br />

.':':#%!='7G036(!-#!$%1#=+$70%3'('!='(!!)67'(3!3!=!'(.'(B!;(.'%!)67'(3!3!=!%#)#%$73#!<br />

?#-(#+#3! ='7%'=3'()'! G636%'%! G'=.#($3#(! N?06%36=3'! KG-.0%P! 03'7'! ='(!'('=! =3$%$=!<br />

G63A63'(!%!$))#.3#%:#+$%#!-#!U3D:3#($%!0(.'7'!?!=:'+!%'!%#)#%!036(B!!<br />

$<br />

"F,7_$<br />

T036%6:! +$+.#:$! $%1#=+$70%3'(!%!%! U%#:3$! #=0%0:$=! ='7!@3'('! %#)#%! 03:'+!4!<br />

?U>D:D%D!>0(6%36!=!3:'=.')!(B!C#%#3!03'('=!?U>D:)#!&'+.'3!=!#.$7030I$3#($%$%!)0(6!<br />

+'@.'%:'+!! #%! U%#:3$! '':'7!! 036.6(6(B! 26! $3#:)#%! +0%('! )0(6! '!3':'!<br />

@(0A(':3'(!%!%!036.6(63:'+!4!#.=$%!'!3':'!-#!+036%6:!+$+.#:$!&'+.'3!=3'(!%!%!0(.'7'!<br />

?!=:'+!%!!#.=$3#7#%!)$#(!1'=.U(3#($%!=0%.(03D!A#(#=3$)$(B!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

! !C!


" #!J $b-A&)(9/&$:!$4567-+)+-+.!$@&$%F,1.F--&.($<br />

!'--%&")J,,0%-'#%.&+)'&8)63"-)#! )#! &$++#..$=4!<br />

'!3'(!%!!D(#.#:#)$=!':'!&!>3!5'!$.&'3!#)$@!=633'%)!=B!<br />

,>6%5'! +D(#4! $.&'3! &'+.'3!=! -#! '!3'(!! 76(.?'! =65'=3'(=#%4! =$(3$3$=! 036.6()66:6>6!<br />

AU(#:#)$=B! \#:#%! &#(! :'(='! -#! $?#($=3$! '!3'(!! D3=#:$>#! +0='(=#%h! A#(#=3$:$4!<br />

;-(6@')'! (6&+'.3!:!4! ':'5'! 67A6%:64! $::D%$.#)#! 7#.#(3$:$! -BGB=(!.#(3#($!<br />

)#%#.3#:#)#!A#?!='3)!=B!<br />

$:)$3#()#! '!! (6&+'.3':'3'(!%)'! U>#%3$7$>B! 26! =#>)#4! )#-3#.$%! U%)#(3$$%$4!<br />

)03'7!+!73')'4! &'+.'3!=3'(! &'($.'+!%!! -#! G6%3'('! =0(6%:')'! G$(! U(%#=3$3$$!<br />

036.6(':!70(6>B! 26! 7'@!4! &'+.'3!=3'(3'! :D5')#3#! +!('3':'+!%!%! )0(6! 7'@!3':':'+!!<br />

-#!+'-'!:)'!)'!)0(6!03:'7'%!?#$.3$3$=.#!67A63':'3'(!%!)#-':!%!!036.6(:'=.')!(B!<br />

!<br />

:;'1.+(.($<br />

H0%676! +'3!=3!! )##(3#%)$(#G$3:#=! $?$%! KD(=$7#&_)(($$<br />

VWZ^pf[!'('3!!%)'4!&'+.'3!=3'(!K$10!-#!j"c!'!(3!=3!!=0%6636(4!+')#5#!nc!-#!k$?#=!<br />

'!3':'3'(!!67A63'%!()!B!O2!)#:#=bO2c!)#:#=!7#%$!G$(!&'+.'3!=!67)6(:'=.!4!+#(030I$=4!<br />

-$(030I$=!.#+.3#($!7'@!3':!70()6B!;!3'(!!)'!70=.6B!<br />

26!.'($&3#()#4!:#-56.!5'%3!!'!3'(!!J#%)$=!-#!%'=.$1!'!3'(!)'!L3'>!!8#.#($%#(!H0%.(03!<br />

-#!;('.!(:'!#%+.$.D3#($!D(#.$:$!7D=3#%:$.$B!<br />

c'&'! +0%('3'(!4! #%! '>!%)'%! O2! -#! nc! 7U%3D! )':!>3!=3'()'! @#($70)$=! '!3':'!<br />

>0(6%36366!-#!D3=#:$>)#!D(#.$3#%!'!3'(!%!G#=3#%:#7#%!036:+6>!+0%6?3'(!!%#)#%$73#4!<br />

'!!$.&'3'.!!@'.3')!B!;:'!=0%.(03!#)$3#:#>!7'@!)'!$)$B!!<br />

! !CC<br />

_1-541.indd 138 29.02.2012 15:42


VWf^! .'($&$%)#4! 9'%$+'! ;!! `(#.$:! -#! ;('.!(:'! L%+.$.D+D! D(#.$:#! G'3')!B! KD:!<br />

='3$.#!-#!?'G'3'(!%'!='(!%4!.#(5$&!#)$3#%!$.&'3!'!3'(3'!(#='G#..#!>0(3'%)!3'(B!<br />

\'+.'3!=!.'($&?#+$%)#!$+#hVWWg3!=!1$(:'7!!KD(=$7#)#%!<br />

+$3)$B!T6?36+6!03'('=!='G63#)$3#%!"LR8!x+6%!'!3'(!%'!+'(!3)!=B!<br />

X$%#!TQ033#%!\#')!+#%)(0:!!N26!AD%!;"K!-#!K"KP!&'+.'3!!%!!)'!;-(6@'!$3#!'7%!!<br />

+D(#?.#!=65'=3')!=!-#!D(#.$3#%!K"K!'!3'(!%!!#%!&!>3!!#=$3)#!=633'%!(!03)6=B!<br />

6%6! U>#.3#7#G$3$($>! =$h! ;-(6@'3!! 03)64! ':'!<br />

'3!='%3!!:!>!03'('=4!=#%)$!$?$:$>)#=$!70(6:!-#!?U>D:!='-A'3'(!%!%!6>':'+!!>':'%!<br />

='7G#..$()$B! 26! A$G$! )6(6:3'()'=$! )'-('%!!:!>!! $()#3#(=#%! AU(D70(6>! =$! )$#(!<br />

D3=#3#()#!G#%>#($!A#5$=:#3#()#%!)'(G#3#(!'3:!3'(BVWf[!U%5#+$%)#4!%A$3.#(#4FG#%!G$(!<br />

=0(6:'3!!')'7!:4!&'+.'3!=3'(!!-#)#!)03'7!+!73'!5'%3!!'!3'(!!D3=#:#!+0=:':F!)#(=#%4!<br />

7'(!! AD-#(5$%3#($! $3#! G63'.!(!3'%! n#Q5'+.3#! +'3A!%!! %#)#%$73#! GD7D=! ='7!@3'(! -#()$B!<br />

O2c!&0.!'!3'(!%!7'+'=!03)66!VWW[!7!33'(!%)'!)'!='?'=!=633'%'('=!=0(6%:'!?'(#3#($!<br />

'(')!B!$:)$3#()#!&#:#%!.D:!'!3'(!=633'%!:)')!(B!<br />

c'&'! +0%('3'(!%)'! )'! ;-(6@'$%3$!7#(#3!+636!'!3'(!!<br />

G$3#!76()6:6>'!A$()$B!m(%#$%4!+('$35#!<br />

5$))$! =0%.(03! #)$3$70(+'! )'4! '!! ='3$.#+$! )#$3! 1$7'.3'(!! -#! U)#:#! '(.3'(!4! G#=3$)#!<br />

7'%!%)'! +6%63'%! &#)$7#3#(! =0%6636(! 03)6B! 2$(='?! D3=#! '!+!! )!!%)'!<br />

N\$%.4\!(-'.4k$%42(#>$37'BBP! D3=#:$>#! A$(:#7#%! '!! ='3:')!B9'&>6(6! 70=! )$7#!<br />

)DD%)D=4&'..'!1$7'.!$+.$=('(!!-#!(#='G#.!+0%6!='3$.#!0366(!)$7#!)DD%)D=!':'!+0%6?!<br />

G6!)#$3)$Y!<br />

!<br />

y;!3'(!%!D3=#:$>#!A$($$%)#! A#(#=+$%$:! -#! ='3$.#! U%AU(D+D! 7#($%#! +'3.!.D=#.$:! #+'+!<br />

'3!%!(!03)6B!<br />

y`3=#:$>)#! A#(#=3$! 03:'7'%! $?#($=3$! '!3'(4! GD7D=! 7#%$3$=:$! A$G$! 3'%+#! #)$3)$!<br />

Nm(%#$%h!+')#5#!;2c3#%:$!-#!&#%D>!;-(6@'#3!+63'(!!)'!='@+':'+!!'-'%.'I!A$G$!3'%+#!#)$3#%!'!!<br />

=0:G$%'+70%3'(!!A$G$P!<br />

yL%.#(0.(0@$=!nc!'!!=633'%!:!#$3$:$!AU>3#%)$4!)$#(!1$(:'3'(5'!)'!&#:#%!G#%>#($!<br />

D(#.$:3#($!7'@!3)!4!(6&+'.3'%)!B!<br />

y%'=.$1!67A63':'3'(!%!:6.36366%)'%!G'&+#)$3$70(+'!)$#(!1$(:')'!D(#..$4!7033')!B!<br />

yO2c!@36+!'!!67A63':'3'(!!7'7A!%3':!+'4!&#:#%!.D:!D(#.$5$3#(5#!E;3!G6)'!G$>)#%F!<br />

)#%)$Y!;>!@36+4!?0=!@36+4!&0.4@0.'%+$7#3$>#!-BG!?#$.3#:#3$!D(#.$:3#(!0(.'7'!?!=.!B\'..'!<br />

! !CH


$3=!3'%+#!#)$3)$$%)#F\0.!+6.6(F)#:$=#%!4!J'>'(!.#@=$+$!='(!+!%)'!E%.#(:#)$'.)#4! =633'%:':!>! A#(#=3$! 03'%! '!3'(! ?0=?'!<br />

)#%#.3#%)$!;-(6@'


'!+'3! $::D%$.#%$%! )D>#7$! -#! &!>!4! $::6%! +$+.#:! 7'%!.!%!%! #.=#%$%! &'+.'3!=!<br />

036.6(:'+!%!! #%A#33#7#(#=! AU+.#(#5#=.$(B! '(.3'(!! 036.6(63:64! AD?3D! G$(! $::6%!<br />

7'%!.4Vbd! AD%)#%! A$)#(#=! '(.!@4! =3!%$=! +#7($%! #.=$3#($%$! '>'3.'G$3$(! 7')'! 0(.')'%!<br />

='3)!('G$3$(B!<br />

;!3':'!)#-':!%)'=$!G#=3#%#%!G'!!=3!=!='3$.#+$%$4!'!3':'!'=+'=3!=3'(!%!%!U.#+$%)#Y!<br />

#%1#=+$7U>! #.=#%3#($%! -$(D3#%+$4! )0>64! #%1#=+$70%6%! 7036! -#! )#$=#%!<br />

=0:@3$='+70%3'(!!$?#(#%!#.=#%3#()#!G#3$(3#7$5$)$(B!,7A63':'3'(!+0%656%6!)#%#.3#(=#%4!<br />

G6!6%+6(3'(!%!#.=$%3$$!AU>!'()!!#)$3:#:#3$)$(B!<br />

2'!!=3!=! ='-(':!%)'4F=D:#+! G'!!=3!!F! $1')#! #)$3:#3$)$(B! HD:#+! $::D%$.#+$!<br />

.'%!:!%)'4! =D:#+$%! .':':!%!%! G$(! &'+.'3!'! )$(#%5$! '%3'!3:'3!)!(B! 26! G#=3#%.$7#!<br />

='(!%4! '!! 67A63'%'%! &#(! G$(! =D:#+.#4! G$(! =!+!:! 1#(.3#($%! '!)'%! 7'('(3'%:')!!!<br />

='G63#)$3$(B! l'7!1_)D=D%)D(4! $::D%0)#@(#++$1.$(4! '!7!! 7#.#(3$! '3':':!.!(! -BGB!<br />

c03'7!+!73'! )'4! G6! G$(#73#(! #%1#=+$70%'! &'++'+.!(3'(B! T0%6?.'4! t! V[[! =0(6%:'! @#=!<br />

03'+!!)#$3+#)#!+'&'!#%1#=+$70%3'(!%)'!$))#.!GD7D=!U3?D)#!'>'3.!3'G$3:#=.#)$(B!<br />

k06!'!3'()'!':'?!#%1#=+$70%6!+!%!(3':'=.!(4!=#+$%!=0(6:'!G#=3#%#:#>B!L%1#=+$7U>!<br />

#.=#%3#($%! #%! +0%! .#:$>3#%)$$! -#! =0%.(03! #)$3)$$! 7#(! =0%'=?!!G'!!=3!=! +$+.#:$)$(B!<br />

;!! '%.$I#%$4! -D56..'%! .':':#%! #3$:$%#! #)$3$%5#7#! )#=! '%.$=0(! D(#.$:$%#! )#-':!<br />

#)#5#=.$(B!<br />

n#!7'>!=.!(!=$h!AC!$::D%0A30GD3$%3#($%$!+'@.'7'%!:#.0)3'(4!#3$:$>)#=$!.#=!03'%'=.!(B!<br />

6!!<br />

6%6.63:':'3!)!(h! +'@.'%'%! .$(#3#($%! 67A6%! AU(D%D:D! &#(! >':'%! =0(6%:'! )D>#7$%$!<br />

.':! $1')#! #.:#:#=.#)$(B! 26%3'('! ='(!%4! 6! '%)'4! G6! .D(3D! GD7D=! +'7!3!! +D(D!<br />

7#.$.$($5$3$$%)#!)'&'!@('.$=!03'5'=!G$(!7U%.#:!G636%:':'=.')!(B!<br />

26(')'! U>#.3#:#7#! ?'3!.!!:! '!_'!3':')'=$! =$(3#%:#%$%4! U>#3)#! ?'3!:'=!<br />

)6(6:6%)'! 03'%! :#+3#=.'3'(!:5'! )'! )0(6! )##(3#%)$($3#5#$%$! 6:'(! +'7A!! -#!<br />

+#-A$3#($:$!+6%'(!:B!<br />

!<br />

! !CN


" #!N $'1+1('1(Am$0&.(-&.&$2+5+,+.+A$%+,+1-!$k&K+*!h$V+1F-FM('($@&$<br />

L+'1+-!A-+.!,!,$2&&.-&,/(.(-)&'($<br />

E$.%0"$)63%-'('(!AU(D70(3'(+'4!'3.3!!%!)6(6:6!$7$!)#$3+#!+U>!=0%6+6!<br />

+'='.3!!!U%5#)#%!.'&:$%!#.:#=!:D:=D%!03'G$3#5#=.$(B!<br />

;('.!(!5!3'(! G$(! +D(#)$(! &'7-'%! (#1'&!! $3#! $3A$3$! A#?#(3$! AU+.#(A#3#($%! \cm4! G$(! @6'%3':'! '('3!!! 036.6(:'=! :D:=D%!<br />

03'G$3$(B! 2$(#7+#3! U3?D:3#(4! D(#.$5$! -#! .D=#.$5$3#(! .'('1!%)'%! '%3':3!! -#! AD-#%$3$(!<br />

03)66! )DD%D3#%! G$(! .0@3':! @6'%! 03'5'=! #=$3)#! G$(3#.$($3#G$3$(3#(B! J6'%3'(!%!<br />

G$(3#.$(:#+$! $3#:$4! )##(3#%)$($3#%! G$3A$3#($%! GD.D%+#3! '%3':!%!%! )##($%$!<br />

'>'3.:':'3!)!(B!m(%#$%!G$(!GU3A#)#=$!?0=!)DD=!G$(!@6'%!%!)$#(!G$(!G'='!GU3A#)#!<br />

?!='%!E='G63!#)$3#G$3$(F!@6'%3'!)#%A#3#%:#+$!A$G$B!m3?D:3#($%!!G$(!?$1.3$=.#!7'@!3:'+!!<br />

$3#! G$(3$=.#! '.!3'5'=! G$(! +0%('=$! E)0'3F! ')!:! &#(! G$(! U3?D:D%! &'7-'%! (#1'&!!<br />

='@+':!%)'=$! #.=$+$%$%! )##(3#%)$($3#G$3:#+$! $?$%! +U>! =0%6+6! U3?D:3#(#! 1'(=3!! G$(!<br />

'!(3!=3!!)##(!'.1#.:#=.$(B!\'7-'%!:#(=#>3$!U3?D:3#($%!@0.'%+$7#3!1'7)'3'(!%!%!7'%!!<br />

+!('! +0(63'5'=! @#=! ?0=! +0(6! )'! 0(.'7'! ?!=:'=.')!(Y! 9'3$7#.3#($! =$:! ='(!3'7'5'=q!<br />

m3?D:3#(4! (6.$%! G$(! )##(3#%)$(:#! >':'%! ?$>#3A#+$! $?$%)#! AD-#%$3$(! G$(! #=$3)#!<br />

7'@!3'G$3$(! :$q! c#$#%! :#-+$:! =0633'(!%)'! G6! U3?D:3#(! %'+!3! 7'@!3'G$3$(q! K#=! G$(!<br />

?$1.3$=.#%!#3)#!#)$3#%!@6'%!7'('(3!!G$(!G$3A$!+'3'7'G$3$(!:$q!\'7-'%'!)'7'3!!U3?D:3#(!<br />

-'(!03'%!)##(3#%)$(:#!7U%.#:3#($!?#(?#-#+$%)#!67A63'%'G$3$(!:$q!<br />

:,+*1+.$ %&-()&-&.3$ k$1.3$=! )##(3#%)$(:#+$4! \'7-'%'! )'7'3!! U3?D:3#(4! +0%6?3'('!<br />

AU(#! 7'@!3'%! U3?D:3#(4! ='7%'=3'('! )'7'3!! U3?D:3#(4! =D:#3#:#4! 6>:'%! 1$=$(3#($4!<br />

! !CT


-#.#($%#(! .'-+$7#+$4! $)'($! )#+.#=4! &'7-'%+'3! D(D%3#($%! #.$=#.3#%:#+$4! $7$! G#+3#:#4! $7$!<br />

G'(!%:'4!+'3!=4!67A6%!)'-('%!3'(4!$3=#3#(4!=($.#(3#(B!<br />

$<br />

:;'1.+


@0>$.$1! -#! %#A'.$1! )67A6+'3! )6(6:3'(! -#! 03'73'(!! )'! $?#($(! N2(00:4! VWWeh! c6%5'%4!<br />

VWWePB! c67A6+'3! )6(6:3'(4! :0.$-#! #)$3:$! )'-('%!3'(!%! $1')#! #)$3:#+$73#! 036'%!<br />

@0>$.$1!)#%#7$:3#($!)#!$?#($(!N*;aj!VWWdP!k$1.?$3$=!67A63':'3'(!!+0%!^[!7!3)'!&!>3'!<br />

)#$:#=.#! N*'6(#! #.! '3B! d[[]P! -#! G64! D(#.$:! U>#33$=3#($! $?$%! +0%! )#(#5#! U>#3! G$(!<br />

A#%#.$=! +#3#=+$70%! $3#! G$(3#.$$%)#! A#?:$.#! 03)66! A$G$! G6AD%)#! (#1'&3'! $3A$3$!<br />

U>#33$=3#($! AU>! '()!! #)$3#%! &'7-'%3'(! 7'('.:'=.')!(B! ;+3!%)'4! +#3#=+$70%3'!<br />

7#.$.$(:#%$%! (#1'&! +0(6%3'(!%!! '>'3.:'=! $?$%! AD?3D! G$(! '('?! 03)66! Nw0%#+4! VWWZh!<br />

C('%)$%4! VWWfP! -#! @0>$.$1! $%+'%! #3$%$%! @0>$.$1! 7%)#! #.=$3#:#+$73#! 67A6%! ?#-(#+#3!<br />

>#%A$%3#:#%$%4! (#1'&!! +0%! )#(#5#! '(.!()!!! N9#%5&! VWWgh! \#:+Q0(.&! u! j03#:'%!<br />

VWWfh!w0%#+!d[[VP!A$..$=?#!1'(=!#)$3#%!G$(!&6+6+!&'3$%#!A#3:$.$(B!<br />

9#-56.!?$1.3$=!AD-#%5#!+.'%)'(.3'(!!&'7-'%!:#(=#>3$!$+.#=3#()#!G636%:'7'!G'3':!.!(!<br />

-#! ='7%'=3'('!)'7'3!!)##(3#%)$(:#3#($%4! &'7-'%! (#1'&!! $3#! $3A$3$! +0(63'(!! .':! 03'('=!<br />

5#-'@3':')'! 7#.#(+$>! ='3'G$3#5#$! '?!=?'! 0(.'7'! ?!=:'=.')!(B! ;-(6@'!3!(! N:'))#3#(P! -#! &#:#%! &#:#%! &#@+$! E?$1.3$=! ='7!.3'(!F! -#7'!<br />

E='7%'=F3'('!)'7'%!(B!N"c9PB!;%5'=4!:#-56.!+.'%)'(.!:'))#3#()#%!G'>!3'(!!U(%#$%!<br />

&'7-'%'!)'7'3!!!U3?D:!'('?3'(!!N;c9P!03:'7'!?0=!7'=!%)!(B!<br />

!<br />

:"+%73'&"(") &'


X03)'!U3D:4!gP!;!(!!>'7!13!=4!^P!L=3#:!3#>70%3'(!!_!;(.($.$+!4!eP!T#@.$+#:$!_!T036%6:!<br />

-#!ZP!X#:$!(#)!#.:#!-#!K'G'%!X'+.!!!c#(:'.$.$!N*JcP!$?$%!G$(!.#.$=3#:#!+#-$7#+$B!!<br />

CD-#%5#!+#(.$1$='+70%6!+')#5#!D3=#%$%!67A63'%'G$3$(!7'+'3!?#(?#-#+$!)'&$3$%)#!?'3!'%!<br />

?$1.3$=3#(! $?$%! 67A63'%'G$3$(B! k06! AD-#%5#! )D>#%3#:#3#($! 7'+'3! :$%$:6:!<br />

>0(6%3636=3'(!%! D>#($%)#! N&'..'! G'>#%! ?0=! D>#($%)#P! .'3#@3#(! 0(.'7'! =07)66%)'%4!<br />

AD-#%5#%$%! '+3!%)'! %#.! #.=$+$! +.'%)'(.3'(!%! A#%#33$=3#! AU%D33D! 03'('=! A#3$.$($3:#+$%$!<br />

)#+.#=3#:#=.#)$(B!\'7-'%!(#1'&!%)'=$!A#3$:#3#(4!G#(#3#%:#3#($%4!=#:$=!=!(!=3'(!%!%!<br />

-#!='%!3#=#3#($%$%!'>'3.!3:'+!!-#7'!&'+.'3!=3'('!='(!!)$(#%5$%!'(.!(!3:'+!!A$G$!7033'(3'!<br />

E='3$.#F7$! 036:36! 7U%)#! #.=$3#(! Nw0%#+4! d[[Vh! *'6(#! #.! '3B! d[[]PB! L#(! \cm!U%D%#!'3:'=!A$G$!N2633#(u!90(($+4!d[[dh!2633#(4!<br />

d[[WPB!<br />

!<br />

k&K+*!$2&&.-&,/(.)&A$_(,$j&5($8-_)&-(5(9$Y$<br />

\'7-'%3'(4! )#%#7$:3#($4! 7'(')!3!3'(!! -#! A#%#.$=! 7'@!3'(!%!%! ?#-(#73#! #.=$3#$:$!<br />

$.$G'($73#! G$(G$(3#($%)#%! 1'(=3!3!=! AU+.#($(3#(B! ;7(!5'4! 7U%#.$:$%! -#! &'7-'%3'()'%!<br />

+0(6:36!=$$%$%!#.=$+$!+')#5#!E-#($:3$3$=F!U3?D.3#($%$!)#$3!'7%!!>':'%)'!&'7-'%3'(!%!<br />

G#3$(3$! G$(! )6(6:6! )#%#7$:3#:#+$%$! )#! U%#:3$! U3?D)#! #.=$3#7#G$3$(B! 26! 7D>)#%4!<br />

='7%'=3'('! )'7'3!! U3?D:3#(! NG'(!%:'4! ='7%'=! .'&+$+$4! +.0=3':'! 706%366! A$G$!<br />

Hcm!! G'+$.! \'7-'%'! c'7'3!! m3?D:3#($%! N\cmP! =0(.$=0+.#(0$)3#(4!<br />

'=6.! 1'>! @(0.#$%3#($! -#! 6>6%! 7'':! +D(#+$%$! $?#(#%! &'7-'%! (#1'&!%!%! GD.D%3#$=!<br />

)##(3#%)$(:#+$%$%! 7'@!3'G$3:#+$! $?$%! 7#.#(3$! 03)66! U%#! +D(D3:#=.#)$(! N\6(%$=4!<br />

VWW[h! 2'(%#..! -#! \#:+Q0(.&4! VWW[h! C##(+) C") '$B4! &#(&'%A$! G$(!<br />

&'7-'%!%! (#1'&!! $?$%! ='@+':3!! G$(! AU(D! #3)#! #.:#=! $?$%! G$(! ='?! U3?D:D%! G$(3$=.#!<br />

7'@!3:'+!! A#(#=#G$3$(! Nc'Q=$%+4! VWW[h! a#G+.#(4! VWWZh! "6..#(4! VWWfPB! E2'+$.! U3?D:!<br />

7'=3'!:3'(!%!%F! >0(36=3'(!! :'36:! 03)66%)'%! A(6@3'%:!! U3?D:3#(! E.#+5$33$F! (#1'&!<br />

+#(.$1$='+70%!@(0A(':3'(!%)'!NU(%#$%!T#(G#+.!2#+$%!J(0A(':!P!N9'$%)C")'$


! \'7-'%3'(!G$(!.'=!:!)'-('%!3'(!!-#!)67A6+'3!)6(6:3'(!!$1')#!#)#G$3$70(!:6q!<br />

L3G#..#4! G6! +0(63'(! G#! U>AD(3D=! #3#:#%.$! N2(':G#334! VWe^P! ! -#! ;-(6@'! ?'@!%)'! gV!<br />

=6(6:6%! $G$(3$$73#! G#+3#%:#4! G'(!%:'4! +'3!=4! &'+.'3!=! -#! )'-('%!! A$G$! =$3$.!<br />

=0%63'('! '.!1.'! G636%:'=! $?$%! ?$1.3$=.#! -#! =#+$:&'%#)#=$! )##(3#%)$(:#! +$+.#:3#($%$!<br />

A#3$.$(#5#=!$3=#3#(!D>#($%#!=6(63:6!"#1'&!H'3$.#+$!N230=&6$+!-#!'(=GZ!d[[]P!$3#!+0%!<br />

)#(#5#! G#%>#(3$=! AU+.#(:#=.#)$(B! R%! $=$! 1'(=3!! +'3!=! -#! (#1'&! =($.#($%$! $1')#! #)#%!<br />

"#1'&! H'3$.#+$! )0:6>3'(4! ='%'.3!3'(! -#! GD7D=G'! &'7-'%3'(! $?$%! A(6@3'%:!!<br />

)##(3#%)$(:#! U3?D:3#($%$! NK'G30! VP! 7'('.:!! -#! ;-(6@'! ?'@!%)'! @#=! ?0=! +'7!)'!<br />

?$1.3$=.#!G6%3'(!!.#+.!#.:$.$(B!!<br />

!<br />

$$$K'G30!VB!"#1'&!H'3$.#+$ê!@(0.0=033#($!$?$%!.#:#3!'3!%'%!$3=#3#(!-#!=($.#(3#(!<br />

"#1'&!$3=#3#($ ! "#1'&!=($.#(3#($! !<br />

7$!G#+3#:# ! V! ,>6%!+D(#3$!'?3!!%!03:':'+!!!<br />

d! ,>6%!+D(#3$!+6+6>366%!03:':'+!!<br />

]! c$%3#%:#!+!('+!%)'!('&'.3!=!<br />

7$!G'(!%)!(:'! ! g! K#(:'3!('&'.3!=!<br />

^! \'(#=#.!=03'73!!!!<br />

e! X'('!G#(#3#($%!03:':'+!!<br />

T'3!= ! Z! \'+.'3!=3'(!%!03:':'+!!!<br />

f! XU%#.$:!@(0+#)D(3#($%)#%!='7%'=3'%'%!'5!%!%!03:':'+!!<br />

W! T0+7'3!)'-('%!3'(!%!$1')#+$!!<br />

,7A6%! V[! c$#(!)'-('%!3'(!%!$1')#+$!!<br />

)'-('%! ! VV! 7$!G$(!$%+'%b&'7-'%!$3$=$+$!<br />

Vd! `(=#=!03:':'!)6(6:6!<br />

!<br />

"#1'&! H'3$.#+$%$%! U%#:3$! ':'?3'(!%)'%! G$($! ?$1.3$=.#%! =#+$:&'%#7#! =')'(! &'7-'%!<br />

(#1'&!%!!AU>3#:3#:#=!$?$%!'('?3'(!A#3$.$(:#=.$(B!26!'('?3'(!@#=!?0=!+'7!)'!':'?!$?$%!<br />

=633'%!3'G$3$(h!<br />

! k$1.3$=3#($! )#%#.3#:#! -#! @6'%3':'7'! $>$%! -#(:#=4! D(D%D%D! +'.!%! '3)!=3'(!!<br />

&'7-'%3'(!%!(#1'&!)6(6:3'(!!&'==!%)'!.D=#.$5$7$!G$3A$3#%)$(:#=!<br />

! k$1.3$=.#%!.0@3'%'%!-#($3#(#!)'7'%'('=!?$1.?$7#!E.'-+$7#F)#!G636%:'=4!<br />

! c##(3#%)$(:#!@(0.0=03D!N:6&.#:#3#%P!=#%)$!)##(3#%)$(:#!+$+.#:3#($!$?$%)#!<br />

=':6!.D>#3!=$$3#($!.'('1!%)'%!=633'%!3'G$3$(B!!<br />

$<br />

$<br />

?+.1!)+$n$D(.$2&&.-&,/(.)&$V+1F-FM(h$L+'1+-!A$@&$L+5@+,$k&K+*!$"F,7_-+.!,!$<br />

B1A(-&)&/&$j+'!-$%7--+,!-+;(-(.$Y$<br />

2$(!\cm


!=$:/!)h$$8-_O)$PL28$@&$%28S$$<br />

C=$:/!)h$k('A$K+A1G.-&.(,(,$+,+-(9($$$<br />

H=$:/!)h$D(-6(-&,/(.)&$PO.&1(#($%)#=$!=0%.'=.!)#(:'.$..$(B!c#($!'3.3!!%!.#:'+!73'!=0763'!(!<br />

-#! +0%6?.'! )#($%! )#($! 3#>70%3'(!! 0366(B! J6'%3':'! U3?#$! N#=$3! VP! G6! 3#>70%3'(!%!<br />

5$))$7#.$%$! )##(3#%)$(:#7#! 03'%'=! +'3'(B! L%! '>!%)'%! +D(D! G'!%'! V[[! G(073#(!<br />

)##(3#%)$($3:#3$)$(!N#=$3!d!-#!]PY!=D:#+$%!V[!1'(=3!!7#($%)#%!N+636=3'('!7'=!%!d!7#(4!<br />

7#:3$=3#(#!7'=!%!d!7#(4!)6-'('!7'=!%!]!7#(!-#!+636=!-#!7#:3$=3#()#%!6>'=!N)$%3#%:#!<br />

'3'%!P!!]!7#(P!V[!')#.!@$3$?!'3!%!(B!H#+$:&'%#)#4!@$3$?3#(!=#+$:!&'..!%)'!$3#(3#(=#%!?0=!<br />

+'7!)'!'7'!!@6'%3':'=!:D:=D%)D(B!L#(!&'..!%!&!>!!)'=$=')'!Vd[!@$3$?!$+#4!0!>':'%!<br />

V[!)'=$='3!=!G$(!AU>3#:!?$1.3$=.#!=633'%!3)!!!A$G$!'7%!!@6'%!U3?#$%$!=633'%'('=!Vd[[!<br />

@$3$5$%!@6'%3'%'G$3:#+$%$!:D:=D%!=!3'(B!<br />

#1-&!GR)E$.(0"$0"$8"),.8.8"$7'#%#)Q#'9'&)('+#!!)3'+#'0!!S)%D%&),1'&0'7')=0D"%)<br />

!<br />

[! V! d! ]! g!<br />

26..#(Q0(.&4!2($+.03!`%$-#(+$.#+$!<br />

$<br />

!=$:/!)h$$8-_O)$$$<br />

B"&"#D%)K%#%7%)<br />

! J0)0)#(:'.$.3#(!$?$%!10.0('1!$%5#3#:#+$!-#!?$1.3$=!>$7'(#.$!703673'!@6'%3':'!<br />

#$.$:$!<br />

! c#%#.$:! #3#:'%3'(!! '7%!! @6'%3':'7!! A#3$.$(#%#! =')'(! #$.$:3#($! +!('+!%)'!<br />

)##(3#%)$(:#7#!.'G$!.6.636(3'(B!<br />

! ;7(!5'! )#%#.?$3#()#%4! '7%!! #=$3)#! @6'%3':'7'! )#-':! #..$=3#($%$%! =0%.(03!<br />

#)$3#G$3:#+$!$?$%!@#($70)$=!03'('=!G$(!)0(63':'!-#7'!(#1#('%+!)#%#.$:!67A63':'3'(!!<br />

$+.#%$(B!!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

! !H!


!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

#1-&!S@!@%0%D0"$%&)8.081$101,)<br />

9.'0#!07'+!)C")9=07"0"$")'0!&7'+!))<br />

:F7"+%&)3"$3'&2%)9%$)("$%&8")(':#! =0%6+6%)'! 7'()!:5!! 03'5'=! G$3A$3#($%! +'3'%:'+!! $?$%!<br />

A#(#=3$!03'%!'(='!@3'%!-#!($+=!1'=.U(3#($%$!0(.'7'!=07'%!?$1.3$=4!=D:#+!-#!+D(D!NHcmP!<br />

.'%!:3':'3'(!%!%! 7'@!3'G$3:#+$%$! +'3'7'%! G$(! ?$1.3$=! +0(6! 10(:6! -#7'! +.'%)'(.!<br />

)#%#.$:!('@0(6!?$1.3$=!.#:+$35$+$%$%!)#!='.=!3'(!73'!&'>!(3'%!(B!<br />

VB! C#%0.$@! _! +64! )':!>3!=! G(073#(! A#?:$$! -#! 7'!! A$G$! G$3A$3#($! $?#(#%! )':!>3!=!<br />

G(073#(!G$3A$3#($4!<br />

dB! H636?='&'%#4! %'=3$7#! :#+'1#+$! _! +D(#+$! -#! 5$-5$-3#(! $?$%! =636?='&'%#! '!3':'!<br />

@(0A(':!%!!$?#(#%!=636?='&'%#!G$3A$3#($4!<br />

]B! X#(3#.$($3#%! 5$-5$-3#($%! +'7!! -#! '!(3!!4! 5$%+$7#.$4! 7!3!%! &'%A$! >':'%!! 03)664!<br />

)##(3#%)$(:#!-#!=#+$:!7'!%!!$?#(#%!A#%#3!G$3A$3#(4!<br />

gB! T.0=3':'!706%366!-#!=!+!.3!!7#:3#:#!67A63':'3'(!4!=636?='!'(.3'(!4!G#+3#:#!<br />

@(01$3$! N)#.'73!P4! -$.':$%_:$%#('3! )D>#73#($4! '3.3!=! :'.#(7'3$4! 7#:3$=! -#! +636=! #=3$! _!<br />

.$@$4!'7)!%3'.:'!@(0A(':!4!=D:#+$%!7'!4!$%''.!)#.'73'(!4!&#)#1!&'-'3'%)!(:'!@(01$3$4!<br />

&'+.'3!=! -#! :#)$='+70%! A#?:$$4! '!3':'! @(0A(':! -#! +6! ='7%'!%!! $?#(#%! U>#3!<br />

&'7-'%5!3!=!67A63':'3'(!!<br />

^B! 2D7D:#! @(01$3$%$4! &'1.'3!=! :0(.'3$.#! 0('%!4! &'1.'3!=! G'5'=! @(0G3#:3$! &'7-'%3'(!!<br />

'7!(:'!!$3#:$4!&'1.'3!=!)$#(!'7!(:'!$3#:3#($%$!$?#(#%!@#(10(:'%+!G$3A$3#($!<br />

eB! =D:#+!GD7D=3DD4!&'7-'%!+'7!+!!+'7!+!!-#!G$0AD-#%3$=!U%3#:3#($%$!$?#(#%!.#+$+!_!<br />

$(=#.!&'==!%)'!G$3A$!<br />

! !HC<br />

#1-&!9@!.'!6!*O#+-5?#!1'K!6!<br />

6/6('!<br />

! M"$)+"L"$%&8")#"


N26!Hcm!+0(63'(!%)'%!?06!:#-56.!?$1.3$=!AD-#%5#!$%5#3#:#+$%$%!.#:#3$%$!036.6(6(BP!<br />

$<br />

C=$:/!)h$k('A$K+A1G.-&.(,(,$+,+-(9($$$<br />

$(=#.!N7'!)'!+$A0(.'!7'!)'!)'%!:'%3!=!+#(-$+$P!NG6!+@#+$1$=!U(%#=.#P!\cm!-#!Hcm!<br />

G$3A$3#($%$!'%'3$>!#)#G$3$(!-#h!<br />

!<br />

VB! $(=#.! $?$%)#=$! +D(D3#($%! .'G'%! 7'+.!!! )#(:'.$.$! 5$))$7#.$%$! -#! .#=('(3':'!<br />

+!=3!!%!! G636(B! T'='.3!=! +0%656! AD?+D>! ='3:!4! =D?D=! -#! 5'%! ?#=$#%! @$3$?3#($%!<br />

#=0%0:$=!#.=$+$%$%!)##(3#%)$($3:#+$!G6%'!)'&$3!#)$3$(B!C#%#3!03'('=4!##(!'7'=!.'G'%!!<br />

+0(6%3'(!! &'7-'%! (#1'&!%!%! 7'%!!+!('! $(=#.! $?$%! )#! #3#! '3!%!70(+'! ='(3!3!=! =0%6+6%)'!<br />

U%#:3$! A#3$:#3#(! ='7)#)$3#G$3$(! p! +0%! )U%#:! $.$G'($73#! G'>!! D3=#3#($%! )#%#.$:!<br />

=6(6:3'(!4! '7'=! .'G'%!! +'3!!%!%! $(=#.$%! (#1'&! @#(10(:'%+!! G#3$(3#7$5$+$! 03)66!<br />

&6+6+6%'!0)'=3'%:'7'!G'3':!3'()!(B!<br />

!<br />

dB! k$1.3$=3#(! '('+!%)'! 1'(=3!3!=! AU+.#(#%! 7U%#.$:4! =D:#+! 0(.':!4! G#+3#:#4! $3'?!<br />

.#)'-$+$4!G'=!5!3!=!-#!A#%0.$@!1'=.U(3#($%$%!.'%!:3'%:'+!%'!7'()!:5!!03:'=!$?$%!$(=#.!<br />

$?$%)#! N'7'=! .'G'%3'(!%'! $3$=$%P! E$7$F! -#! E>'7!1F! ?$1.3$=3#(! '('+!%)'! ='(!3'.!(:'!<br />

7'@!%B!<br />

!<br />

]B! *'(=3!! ?$1.3$=3#()#=$! +6! =633'%!:!%!! $%5#3#7$%! p! @$3$?! G'!%'! 1'>3'! +6! =633'%'%!<br />

?$1.3$=3#($%!N#$.!&'-'!=0633'(!%)'P!+6!+!>)!('%!+636=3'()'!$3A$3$!+$+.#:'.$=!G$(!+0(6%6!<br />

03'G$3$(B!;3.3!=3'('!'>!':'!+D(#=3$!+!>'%!+6!'7'=!.'G'%!!+'3!!%'!-#!'3.3!=!7U%#.$:$%#!<br />

5$))$!G$(!#=$3)#!>'('(!-#(#G$3$(B!<br />

!<br />

gB! K'G'%!7'+.!!!)#(:'.$.$73#!$3A$3$!03'%!G'=.#($7030I$=!@'.030I$!$%5#3#:#+$%$!7'@!%!<br />

-#! G6! G'=.#($3#($%! %'=3$7#! -#7'! ?$1.3$=! G$0AD-#%3$=! =6+6(3'(!%)'%! )03'7!!<br />

=636?='&'%#)#!0(.'7'!?!=!@!?!=':'7'5'!%!!.#+@$.!#)$%B!<br />

!<br />

H=$:/!)h$D(-6(-&,/(.)&$$@&$J=$:/!)h$k&K+*!$+.1!.)+A$(_(,$5G,&1()'&-$A+.+.-+.!$<br />

/&'1&A-&)&$<br />

k$1.?$!?$1.3$$%)#=$!.'G'%!7'+.!!!)#(:'.$.$%$%!G076.3'(!!&'==!%)'!G$3A$3#%)$($3#G$3$(!-#!<br />

>':'%!$?#($+$%)#!-#!'%'3$>)#%!+0%('4!G6!+0(6%6!%#7$%!'>'3.'5'!%'!)'$(!='('(!'3:'+!%'!<br />

7'()!:5!!03'5'=!G$(!($+=!1'=.U(3#($!:0)#3$!036'G$3$(B!C#(?#=!?$1.3$=!0(.':!%)'!+'='.3!=!<br />

$?$%!($+=!1'=.U(D!03'('=!AU+.#($3:$!1'=.U(3#(!'('+!%)'!''!)'=$3#(!+'7!3'G$3$(h!<br />

2D7D:#! 0('%!4! =#+$:$! 7'@!3'%! @$3$?3#($%! 7'!4! ('+70%)'=$! .D:! .'&!3! =633'%!:!4! 7#:!<br />

.$@$4! G$0AD-#%3$=! U%3#:3#($%$%! ='3$.#+$4! '3.3!=! )6(6:6! NU%#:3$! G$(! 1'=.U(P4! @$3$?3#($%!<br />

A#%0.$@3#($B!;7(!5'4!@$3$?3#($%!5$%+$7#.$4!7#:!=!+!.3':'!)D>#7$4!'7)!%3'.:'!#=3$!-#!!!=!<br />

706%3664!@$3$?3#($%!&'(#=#.!+#-$7#+$!-#!7#(3#$:!+!=3!!!A#(?#=!?$1.3$=!U(%#=3#($%)#!<br />

.'-6=3'()'=$! .'G'%! 7'+.!!! )#(:'.$.$! +#-$7#+$%$! =0%.(03! #.:#=! $?$%! )#$.$($3#(#=!<br />

:'%$@D3#!#)$3$(B!!<br />

2$(!&'7-'%!D%$.#+$!$?$%)#!GD.D%!U3?D:3#(!7'@!3)!!%)'4!+U>!=0%6+6!D%$.#!$?$%!A#%#3!G$(!<br />

&'7-'%!(#1'&!!)##(3#%)$(:#+$!7'@!3'G$3:#+$!$?$%!.D:#-'(!:+'3!N#=$3!gP!G$(!7'=3'!:!<br />

$>3#%$(Y!$3=!U%5#!.0@3'%'%!-#($3#(!N7'%$!&'7-'%!D%$.#+$%)#=$!1'(=3!!U3?D:3#()#%!'3!%'%!<br />

)##(3#(P!=($.#(!@6'%!%!!&#+'@3':'=!$?$%!G$(!'('7'!A#.$($3$(h!)'&'!+0%('!=($.#(!@6'%3'(!!<br />

$3=#!@6'%!!&#+'@3':'=!$?$%!G$(3#.$($3$(h!-#!#%!+0%6%)'!)'!&'7-'%!D%$.#+$!#3)#!#)$3#%!<br />

$3=#!@6'%3'(!%'!AU(#!G$(!(#1'&!='.#A0($+$%#!)'&$3!#)$3$(B!<br />

!<br />

! !HH


2,34-,"&5<br />

!"#$%&"$<br />

'&()"&(#<br />

6&()"&5<br />

,7","&5<br />

/&(.0(1,"$<br />

5<br />

8".",59""&,".9(&-"5<br />

*+"&#,, #$$"$$-".)<br />

FGH<br />

IJ<br />

D<br />

I<br />

!<br />

#1-&! ;@! 5'$!! =($.#(3#($%! )$#(3#($%)#%! )'&'! U%#:3$! 03)66%6! )##(3#%)$(:#=3#! G#('G#(!<br />

NU(%#$%4!+6+6>366%!03:':'!)6(6:6!'?3!!%!03:':'!)6(6:6%)'%!)'&'!U%#:3$)$(Ph!<br />

7$%#! )#! @6'%3'(! '('+!%)'! G$(! )#%A#3#:#! )6(6:6! 03)66%6! ='G63! #.:#:#=.#)$(3#(B!<br />

NU(%#$%4!+6+6>366%!03:':'!)6(6:6!'?3!!!.#3'1$!#)#:#>!7'!)'!.':!.#(+$PB!m>#3!G$(!<br />

0@#('.U(! Nj&0S6#.! $%.#A('3P! +U>%=0%6+6! $=$! '=!3! 7D(D.:#! &'..!%!! )$=='.#! '3:'=! $?$%!<br />

=633'%!3:!.!(BH!+'5'4! Ej&0S6#.! $%.#A('3F! :$%$:6:! @6'%! $3#! G$(! +0%('=$! @6'%!<br />

'('+!%)'=$! 1'(=!! &#+'@3'(! -#! )$=='.#! '3!%'%! '3.! =($.#(#! AU(#! G6! 1'(='! G$(! '!(3!=!<br />

NE='@'+$.#F! ')!! -#($3#%P! '.'(B! ;+@$('+70%! )##(3#($! &#(! ='.#A0($! $?$%! '7(!! '7(!!<br />

.'%!:3'%!(B!26%3'(!%!0(.'7'!=07)66!&6+6+4!?$1.3$=3#(!&#(&'%A$!G$(!='.#A0($7#!A$(:#7#!<br />

! !HJ


?'3!:'3!! -#! +0%6?.'! 9D=#::#34! C#3$:$4! H'G63! #)$3$(! N-#7'! .#:#3P! -#!<br />

T!%!13'%)!(!3:':!!N#=$3!!^P!#=3$%)#=$!g!='.#A0($)#%!G$($%)#!7#(!'3:'3!)!(3'(B!<br />

cOA&))&-3$ \'7-'%3'(!%! (#1'&!! #%! D+.! +#-$7#)#)$(B! \'7-'%! D%$.#+$! =D?D=! '7(!! G$(!<br />

@'>'('!&$.'@!#.:#=.#!036@!D>#(3#($%)#=$!#.$=#.!.D=#.$5$%$%!#%!7D=+#=!='3$.#)#!G$(!D(D%!<br />

'3)!!%!!A'('%.$!#.:#=.#)$(B!!N26!#.$=#.!&'7-'%!(#1'&!%'!$.&'1!#)$3#G$3$(BPB!<br />

>&-()($ Y! \'7-'%! (#1'&!! $7$)$(! N':'! :D=#::#3! )#$3)$(PB! 7$! 67A63':'3'(!<br />

7'@!3:'=.')!(!-#!)'&'!A#%#3!G$(!='3$.#!#.$=#.3#%)$(:#!+$+.#:$!$?#($+$%)#!$7$!+#-$7#)#!<br />

(#1'&!!A'('%.$!#.:#=!$?$%!7#.#(3$)$(B!<br />

%+;7-$ &/(-&;(-(.$ P@&5+$ 1&)&-SY! \'7-'%! (#1'&!! ='G63! #)$3#G$3$(! +#-$7#)#)$(! N7'%$4!<br />

>0(6%36!#.$=#.!$?$%!.'%!:3'%'%!'+A'($!A#(#=3$3$=3#($%!D>#($%)#P4!'%5'=!U>#3!G$(!E&'7-'%!<br />

(#1'&!%'!+'7A!F!+#(.$1$='+70%!@(0A(':!%'!A$(:#=!$?$%!7#.#(+$>)$(B!!<br />

"!,!K-+,/!.!-)+)!Y! \'7-'%! (#1'&!! )DD=.D(! -#! ='G63! #)$3#:#>! 03'('=!<br />

)##(3#%)$($3:#=.#)$(B!!<br />

IHH<br />

>H<br />

KH<br />

DH<br />

JH<br />

3RS3223.1 )OA&))&-$<br />

PC0-S 1&)&-$<br />

6&-()($<br />

3.NC.S3M<br />

./.$S2C00-L-3M<br />

'!,!K-+,/!.!-)+)!$<br />

H<br />

L33M-.; ;&'-&)&$$$$$$$$$$;+.!,)+$$$$$$$$$$$$'+-!A$$$$$$$$$$$/+@.+,!$<br />

I N/O0-.; J N3C21N G P3NCQ-/O4 D<br />

#=$3!^B!cU(.!(#1'&!='.#A0($+$!$?$%)#!?$1.3$=!U(%#=3#($! !<br />

!<br />

#=$3! ^B! k$1.3$=3#(! $?$%! 1'(=3!! @6'%! @(01$3! U(%#=3#($! p! @6'%! '('3!=3'(!%!%! G$(! ?$1.3$$%!<br />

%$&'$!+!%!13'%)!(:')'!:D=#::#34!A#3$:$4!.#:#3!-#7'!+!%!13'%)!(!3:':!!='.#A0($3#($!<br />

$?$%)#!7#(!'3:'+!%!!%'+!3!#.=$3#)$$%$!AU+.#(:#=!$?$%!=633'%!3!(G!<br />

$<br />

"F,7_-+.$<br />

\'7-'%'!)'7'3!!U3?D:3#()#!N\cmP!-#7'!A#3$:#=.#!03'%!T0%65'!)'7'3!!U3?D:!NTcmP!<br />

+$+.#:3#($! ?#(?#-#+$%)#! A#3$.$($3#%! '('?3'(! ;-(6@'!! '3'%3'()'! ?0=! GD7D=!<br />

>0(36=3'(!:#-56..6(B!;%5'=!G'>!!\cm6..'!+'7A!%!G$(!<br />

7#($!03'%!$7$!$3#($%!\cm


'?!=?'! G'>!! +0(63'(! )'! :#-56..6(B! 9'3$7#.3#($! =$:! ='(!3'7'5'=4! ! U3?D:3#(4! (6.$%! G$(!<br />

)##(3#%)$(:#! >':'%! ?$>#3A#+$! $?$%)#! AD-#%$3$(! -#! '7%!! +.'%)'(..'! 7'@!3'G$3$(! :$4!<br />

)#$#%!:#-+$:!=0633'(!%'!AU(#!G6!U3?D:3#(!%'+!3!7'@!3'G$3$(4!!.#=!G$(!?$1.3$=.#%!#3)#!<br />

#)$3#%! @6'%3'(! 7'('(3!! G$(! G$3A$! +'3'7'G$3$(! :$4! &'7-'%! .'G'%3!! U3?D:3#(! -'(! 03'%!<br />

)##(3#%)$(:#! 7U%.#:3#($! ?#(?#-#+$%)#! 67A63'%'G$3$(! :$q! \cm3'()'! A#%#3! (#1'&! )##(3#%)$(:#+$! $3#! $3A$3$! ='('(! )#+.#=! +$+.#:$Y! :0)#3! 7'@!+!! -#! '!(3!=3'%)!(:'!<br />

@(0+#)D(DPB!w06(%'3!01!;%$:'3!T5$#%5#Bf[Y!VfVWbVf]gB!<br />

2(':G#334!"B4!VWe^B!"#@0(.!01!.&#!.#5&%$5'3!50::$..##! .0!#%S6$(#!$%.0!.&#!Q#31'(#!01!'%$:'3+!=#@.!6%)#(!<br />

$%.#%+$-#!3$-#+.05=!&6+G'%)(7!+7+.#:+!N706%!5'%3!!&'7-'%!G'(!%)!(:'!+$+.#:3#($%)#!&'7-'%3'(!%!(#1'&!!$3#!<br />

$3A$3$!.#=%$=!=0:$.#!('@0(6P!B!\B9BTBRB4!i0%)0%B!<br />

2(00:4!cB9B!;%$:'3!a#31'(#!)#1$%#)!$%!.#(:+!01!'..#:@.!.0!50@#!Q$.&!.&#!#%-$(0%:#%.!N?#-(#!$3#!676:!<br />

?'G'3'(!!?#(?#-#+$%)#!&'7-'%!(#1'&!%!%!.'%!:3'%:'+!PB!;5.';A($563.6('#T5'%)$%'-$5'!NT#5.$0%!;!p!;%$:'3!<br />

T5$#%5#P!dZY!ddbdWB!NVWWePB!!<br />

2633#(4! \B! '%)! 90(($+4! jB! d[[dB! *'(:! '%$:'3! Q#31'(#! '+@#5.+! 01! .&#! j;J! NR(.'=! .'(!:! @03$.$='+!!<br />

?#(?#-#+$%)#!?$1.3$=!&'7-'%3'(!!(#1'&!%!%!G076.3'(!P4!"TJj;4!i0%)0%B!<br />

2633#(4!\B!'%)!"0#!LBwB!d[[WB!j0%+.(65.$%A!Å6'3$.7Y!n#A0.$'.$%A!*'(:!;%$:'3!a#31'(#!$%!*00)!;++6('%5#!<br />

T5&#:#+! NH'3$.#%$%! 7'@!3'%)!(!3:'+!B! C!)'! CD-#%5#! +$+.#:$! $?#($+$%)#! ?$1.3$=! &'7-'%3'(!! (#1'&!%!%!<br />

.'(.!!3:'+!P! ! J(05##)$%A+! 01! .&#! a#31'(#! Å6'3$.7ê! ;)-$+0(7! j0::$.##! 9##.$%A4! T#@.#:G#(! dg .& ! p! d^.& !<br />

d[[f4!j0@#%&'A#%B!<br />

26..#(Q0(.&4! ;B4! 8#$++$#(4! O4! ! 9'%.#5'4! wB|4! '%)! 230=&6$+4! \BwB! d[[fB! a#31'(#! K(')#! N(#1'&! K$5'(#.$PB!<br />

L6(0@#'%!,%$0%!V^4!J6G3$5!T#(-$5#!"#-$#Q!VfY^gY]W!@@!g^ebg^W!OTTn!VgZd!]]W^B!<br />

c'Q=$%+4! 9BTB! VWW[B! *(0:! '%! '%$:'3É+! @0$%.! 01! -$#QY! 90.$-'.$0%4! 1$.%#++4! '%)! '%$:'3! Q#31'(#! N2$(!<br />

&'7-'%!%!G'=!!'?!+!%)'%Y!:0.$-'+70%4!10(:)'!03:'=!-#!&'7-'%!(#1'&!PB!J+75&030A$5'3!+5$#%5#B!V]Y!VbeVB!<br />

c6%5'%4!OBwB\B!VWWeB!;%$:'3!a#31'(#!)#1$%#)!$%!.#(:+!01!1##3$%A+!N\$++#.:#=!'?!+!%)'%!&'7-'%!(#1'&!%!%!<br />

.'%!:3'%:'+!PB!;5.';A($563.6('#T5'%)$%'-$5'!NT#5.$0%!;!p!;%$:'3!T5$#%5#P!dZY!dWb]eB!!<br />

*'(:!;%$:'3!a#31'(#!j06%5$3B!VWWdB!!"#@0(.!0%!.&#!a#31'(#!01!2(0$3#(!j&$5=#%!N2(073#(!.'-6=3'(!%!(#1'&!!<br />

$3#! $3A$3$! ('@0(PB! *'(:! ;%$:'3! a#31'(#! j06%5$34! 2305=! c4! C0-#(%:#%.! 26$3)$%A+4! \00=! "$+#! T06.&4!<br />

T6(G$.0%4!T6((#7!HKe!Zn*B!<br />

*'6(#4!wB9B4!2#++#$4!aB!u!w0%#+4!"B2B!d[[]B!c$(#5.! +#3#5.$0%!10(!$:@(0-#:#%.!01!'%$:'3!Q#33bG#$%AB!O%Y!<br />

J063.(7!2(##)$%A!'%)!2$0.#5&%030A7!N='%'.3!!7#.$.$($5$3$$!-#!G$0.#=%030I$)#!&'7-'%!(#1'&!%!%!A#3$$:$!$?$%!<br />

)0(6)'%!+#3#=+$70%PB!96$(4!aB!u;AA(#74!TB!NL)+BPB!j;2!O%.#(%'.$0%'34!!@@B!ddVbdg^B!<br />

*('+#(4! cB! d[[gB;@@37$%A! +5$#%5#! .0! '%$:'3! Q#31'(#! +.'%)'()B! $%Y! J(05##)$%A+! 01! C30G'3! 50%1#(#%5#! 0%!<br />

'%$:'3!Q#31'(#Y!'%!ROL!$%$.$'.$-#!N&'7-'%!(#1'&!!+.'%)'(.3'(!%'!G$3$:+#3!67A63':'3'(Y!&'7-'%!(#1'&!!D>#($%#!<br />

A30G'3!=0%1#('%+!A#3$:#3#($Y!G$(!ROL!$%$+$7'.$1$P!4!J'($+!d]bd^!*#G(6'(74!VdVbV]^B!!<br />

C##(+4!"B4!J#.#(+#%4!2B4!\67+:'%+4!HB4!H%6('bc#+>5>='4!TB4!c#!2#5=#(4!9B4!C7:%$5&4!TB4!\#%0.4!cB4!\$++4!<br />

TB!'%)!T'6#(Q#$%4!\B!d[[]B!R%b*'(:!90%$.0($%A!01!J$A!a#31'(#!G7!;++#++:#%.!01!\06+$%A4!9'%'A#:#%.4!<br />

\#'3.&! "#50()+! '%)! J3'+:'! \'@.0A30G$%! NG'(!%:'4! 7U%#.$:4! +'3!=! ='7!.3'(!! -#! @3'>:'! \'@.0A30G$%!<br />

)##(3#%)$(:#+$!$3#!?$1.3$=3#()#!)0:6>!(#1'&!%!%!AU>3#:3#%:#+$P!B;%$:'3!a#31'(#!Vd4!eg]begZB!<br />

C('%)$%4! KB! VWWfBC#%#.$5+! '%)! .&#! 2#&'-$0(! 01! c0:#+.$5! ;%$:'3+! NL-5$3! &'7-'%3'(!%! A#%#.$$! -#!<br />

)'-('%!3'(!PB!T'%!c$#A04!,T;4!;5')#:$5!J(#++B!<br />

! !HT


\#:+Q0(.&4! JB\B! '%)! j03#:'%4! CBwB! VWWfB\6:'%bi$-#+.05=! O%.#('5.$0%+4! K&#! T.05=@#(+0%! '%)! .&#!<br />

J(0)65.$-$.7!'%)!a#31'(#!01!O%.#%+$-#37!*'(:#)!;%$:'3+!N%+'%!p!&'7-'%!$3$=$3#($4!?0G'%!-#!706%!#=$3)#!<br />

7#.$.$($3#%!&'7-'%3'(!%!-#($:3$3$=3#($!-#!(#1'&!P!B!a'33$%A10()4!,H4!j;2!O%.#(%'.$0%'3B!<br />

\6(%$=4wB*B!VWW[B!a0(3)É+!@063.(7!+5$#%5#!'++05$'.$0%!$%-$.#)!3#5.6(#Y!;%$:'3!Q#31'(#Y!#.&$5'3!'+@#5.+!'%)!<br />

@('5.$5'3! 50%+$)#('.$0%+! NcD%7'! ='%'.3!! G$3$:$! )#(%#$4! )'-#.3$! +6%6:Y! &'7-'%! (#1'&!Y! #.$=! G076.3'(!! -#!<br />

@('.$=!)##(3#%)$(:#3#(PB!J063.(7!T5$#%5#!eWY!VfdZbVf]gB!<br />

!w0%#+!"B2B!VWWZB!*#'(!'%)!c$+.(#++B!O%Y!;%$:'3!a#31'(#!N&'7-'%!(#1'&!%)'!=0(=6!-#!+.(#+PB!NL)+4!;@@3#G74!<br />

9BjB!u!\6A&#+4!2BRBPB!a'33$%A10()4!,BH4!j;2!O%.#(%'.$0%'34B@@B!Z^bfZB!<br />

w0%#+4! "B2B! d[[V! L%-$(0%:#%.'3! #%($5&:#%.! 10(! @063.(7! Q#31'(#BO%Y! O%.#A('.#)! 9'%'A#:#%.! T7+.#:+! 10(!<br />

i$-#+.05=!Nj'%3!!&'7-'%3'(!$?$%!#%.#A(#!7U%#.$:!+$+.#:3#($%)#!='%'.3!!(#1'&!!$?$%!?#-(#+#3!>#%A$%3#.$(:#PB!<br />

a'.&#+4!jB9B4!NL)BP4!2($.$+&!T05$#.7!10(!;%$:'3!T5$#%5#4!R55'+$0%'3!J6G3$5'.$0%4!n0!dfB!@@B!Vd^bV]VB!<br />

H##3$%A4! iB! '%)! T-#)G#(A4! wB! VWWWB! i#A$+3'.$0%! G'%%$%A! 50%-#%.$0%'3! G'..#(7! 5'A#+! $%! TQ#)#%! '%)! '!<br />

+6G+#S6#%.! @&'+#b06.! @(0A('::#! O%Y! J(05##)$%A+! 01! .&#! j0%A(#++! É"#A63'.$0%! 01! ;%$:'3! J(0)65.$0%! $%!<br />

L6(0@#É4! NA#3#%#=+#3! ='.3!! ='1#+! +$+.#:3#($%$%! +-#?6'.! -#! :D.#'=$@! 7D(D(3D=.#%!<br />

='3)!(:'!@(0A(':!B!H0%A(#!l'G!.3'(!4!E;-(6@'


" #!T $B1-(A$V(-(_$b.&1()(,/&$['!$"1.&'(,(,$V&.KF.)+,'$@&$B1$%+-(1&'(,&$<br />

B1A(-&.($<br />

KLL"-#+).L)M"'#)/#$"++).&)@"$L.$7'&-")'&8)A"'#)m1'0%#()%&)E$.%0"$)<br />

@$.81-#%.&)<br />

!<br />

T#(-#.!X'3?!%!<br />

LA#!`%$-#(+$.#+$!l$(''.!*'=D3.#+$!l00.#=%$!2U3D:D!<br />

$<br />

89&1$<br />

J$3$?!#.$!D(#.$:$!-#!.D=#.$:$!+0%!g[!7!3)'!&!>3!!G$(!'(.!!AU+.#(:$.$(B!26!'(.!4!D(#.$:!<br />

:'3$7#.3#($%$%! A#($3#:#+$4! #.$%! G#+$%! )##($! -#! +'3!=3!! G#+3#%:#7#! -#($3#%! U%#:$%!<br />

'(.:'+!!-#!#.$%!$3#($!$3#:#!.#=%$=3#($%$%!7'7A!%3':'+!!$3#!A#(?#=3#:$.$(B!`(#.$:!-#!<br />

.D=#.$:!)D>#7$%)#=$!G6!A#3$:#3#(#!#.3$=!@$3$?3#($%!A#3$:#!&!>!%!%!'(.:'+!!7U%D%)#!<br />

7'@!3'%! +#3#=+$70%! ?'3!:'3'(!%!%! ?0=! GD7D=! ='.=!+!! 03:6.6(B! ;%5'=4! AD%D:D>)#!<br />

=!+'!G$(!+D(#)#!=#+$:!7'!%'!63''%!@$3$?3#(!?#-(#!=0633'(!%'!-#!+.(#+#!)'&'!)67'(3!!<br />

&'3#!A#3:$3#()$(B!O+!!+.(#+$4!#.3$=!@$3$?3#($%!@#(10(:'%+!%!!-#!='(3!3!!!#%!?0=!#.=$3#7#%!<br />

+.(#+! #.:#%3#($%)#%! G$($)$(B! T')#5#! =#+$:! '!(3!!%!%! A#($3#:#+$4! =#+$:! 7'!%!%!<br />

A#5$=:#+$4! U3D:! 0('%!%!! '(.!(:'+!! )#$3! '7%!! >':'%)'! #.! ='3$.#+$%$! )#! #.=$3#7#(#=!<br />

+03A6%! #.! +#%)(0:6%'! )'! %#)#%! 03:'=.')!(B! 26! ?'3!:')'4! !+!! +.(#+$! '3.!%)'=$! #.3$=!<br />

@$3$?3#()#! @#(10(:'%+! U>#33$=3#($! -#! !+!! +.(#+$%#! '3!.!(:'! =0%6+6%)'! 7'@.!!:!>!<br />

?'3!:'3'(!U>#.3#%:$.$(B!!<br />

!<br />

:;'1.+3'!'(.'(=#%!G6!'(.!!%!)#-':!#)#5#$!-#!U>#33$=3#!?#-(#!+!5'=3!!%!%!7D=+#=!03)66!<br />

GU3A#3#()#! 706%3''5'!! )DD%D3:#=.#)$(B! L.3$=! @$3$?! D(#.$:$%$%! +!5'=! GU3A#3#()#!<br />

'(.:'+!! 7U%D%)#=$! G#=3#%.$%$%! G'3!5'! %#)#%$h! !3!:'%! $=3$:#! +'&$@! GU3A#3#()#! @$3$?!<br />

D(#.$:$%$%! -#! .D=#.$:$%$%! 7#.#(3$! 03:'+!%'! ='(!3!=! +!5'=! $=3$:! =6'!%)'! 7#(! '3'%!<br />

D3=#3#()#! &'3#%! D(#.$:! -#! .D=#.$:! '?!!%!%! 03:'+!! -#! G6! GU3A#3#()#=$! &!>3!! %D16+!<br />

'(.!!)!(B! T#3#=+$70%! ?'3!:'3'(!73'! &!>3!! 5'%3!! '!(3!=! '(.!!! +'3'%:'+!%'! (':#%!<br />

='()$70-'+=D3#(! -#! +036%6:! +$+.#:$%$%! ='@'+$.#+$%)#! )#$$:! 03:':!4! 1'='.! G6!<br />

+$+.#:3#($%! 10%=+$70%#3! 03'('=! #.=$%3$$! '(.:!.!(B! 26! )6(6:4! #.3$=! @$3$?3#($! ?#-(#!<br />

=0633'(!%'! U>#33$=3#! 7D=+#=! +!5'=3!=3'('! )'&'! )67'(3!! &'3#! A#3:#+$%#! 703! '?:!.!(B!<br />

HD(#+#3! !+!%:'! )'! )$=='.#! '3!%)!!%)'4! #.3$=! @$3$?3#()#! !+!! +.(#+$! =0%6+6%6%! +!=! +!=!<br />

! !HZ


AD%)#:#!A#3:#+$!7')!(A'%:':'3!)!(B!O+!!+.(#+$!@$3$?3#($%!=0%10(6%6!N(#1'&!%!P!G0>'(4!<br />

@#(10(:'%+!%! A#($3#:#+$%#! )03'7!+!73'! GD7D=! #=0%0:$=! ='7!@3'('! %#)#%! 036(B! O+!!<br />

+.(#+$!'3.!%)'=$!@$3$?3#()#!=#+$:)#%!+0%('!='+!&#%D>!+!5'==#%!@\!&!>3'!A#($3#(4!E+03A6%!<br />

AU(D%D3D4! +6! .6.:'! ='@'+$.#+$! )DD=! -#! =6(6! #.F! 03'('=! .'%!:3'%'%! E+03A6%! #.!<br />

+#%)(0:6%'F! NJTLP! A#3$$(! NdPB! ;:#($='! 2$(3#$=! c#-3#.3#($%)#! +03A6%! #.! +#%)(0:6!<br />

%#)#%$73#!0(.'7'!?!='%!='7!@3'(!%!+')#5#!G$(!=#+$:&'%#)#!G$(!7!3)'!gBg!:$370%!)03'(!<br />

03)66! .'&:$%! #)$3:#=.#)$(! NVVPB! O+!! +.(#+$! +!('+!%)'! U3D:! '':'+!%'! A#3$%:#+$%$%!<br />

#%A#33#%:#+$!$?$%!5'%3!!0(A'%$>:'!?#$.3$!.#@=$3#(!-#(#(#=!!+!!D(#.$:$%$!'7'(3':'7'!-#!<br />

!+!!+.(#+$%$!.03#(#!#.:#7#!?'3!!(B!26!:'='3#)#4!#.3$=!@$3$?3#($%!!+!!+.(#+$%#!.#@=$3#($4!!+!!<br />

+.(#+$%$%! @#(10(:'%+! -#! #.! ='3$.#+$%#! #.=$3#($! -#! !+!! +.(#+$%#! ')'@.'+70%3'! $3A$3$!<br />

?'3!:'3'(!U>#.3#%:$.$(B!<br />

$<br />

['!$'1.&'($@&$!! .#@=$3#(! -#($(3#(B! 26! .#@=$3#($%! 7#.#(3$! 03:')!!! %0=.')'4! :#.'G03$=!<br />

!+!%!%! -D56..'%! 6>'=3'.!(!3:'+!! >0(3'!(4! -D56.! +!5'=3!!! gd{j! %$%! D>#($%#! ?!='(! -#!<br />

gg{j! ='3'%! @$3$?3#(! !+!! D(#.$:$%$! )#%A#3#:#=!<br />

':'5!73'! G$(?0=! )'-('%!:+'3! .#@=$3#(! -#($(3#(B! HD:#+! $?$%)#! @$3$?3#(! G$(G$(3#($%)#%!<br />

6>'=3':'7'! ?'3!!(4! &'(#=#.+$>! ='3:'7!! .#(5$&! #)#(4! ='%'.3'(!%!! '?'('=! -D56.!<br />

7D>#73#($%$! A#%$3#.$(3#(B! X#:! .D=#.$:$%$! '>'3.!(3'(B! c6-'(3'('! -#! +636=3'('! 7'=!%!<br />

03:'7'!?'3!!(3'(B!O+!!+.(#+$!'3.!%)'=$!@$3$?3#(!=0(=6!)'-('%!!!)'!AU+.#($(3#(!-#!=0(=67'!<br />

-#($3#%! .#@=$! +D(#+$! N.0%$5! $::0G$3$.7P! 6>'(B! O+!! +.(#+$! '3.!%)'4! =0(=67'! -#($3#%! .#@=$!<br />

=0%6+6%)'!7'@!3'%!?'3!:'3'(!.$5'($!#.3$=!@$3$?!&'.3'(!!'('+!%)'!1'(=!03)66%6!-#!"0++!<br />

][f'=3'.!(!3!(B! H'%)'! '+$.! )D>#7$! N\ r P! 7D=+#3)$$%)#4! ! G$='(G0%'.!<br />

N\jR] b P! $70%3'(!! $3#! G$(3##(#=! ='(G0%$=! '+$.! N\ d jR ] P! 0366(h! ='(G0%$=! '+$.! &#:#%!<br />

jR d !-#!\ d R'=3'.!(!3!(=#%4!\jR] b !'+$.bG'>!)#%A#+$%$!=0(6:'=!D>#(#!-D56..'!='3!(B!T036%6:'!<br />

G'3!! '3=030+$+h! jR d ! )#%A#+$! ?#-(#! +!5'=3!!%)'%! #.=$3#(B! HD:#+! $?$! +!5'=3!!! ][{j#($%#!7D=+#3)$$%)#!@$3$?3#(!-D56.!+!5'=3!=3'(!%!!=0(67':'>3'(!-#!-D56.!+!5'=3!!%!%!<br />

'(.:'+!73'! G$(3$=.#! +036%6:! &!>!! '(.'(B! T036%6:! &!>!%!%! '(.:'+!! '=5$#(3#()#%!<br />

='(G0%)$0=+$.!NjR d P!='7G!%!!'(.!(!(=#%!='%)'!='(G0%)$0=+$.!=!+:$!G'+!%5!!N@jR d P!-#!<br />

! !H]


G$='(G0%'.! N\jR ] b P! )D>#7$! A#($3#(B! \$)(0I#%! $70%3'(!%)'=$! '>'3:'! @3'>:'! @\!<br />

)D>#7$%$!'(.!('('=!+036%6:!'3=030>$+$%#!%#)#%!036(B!8D56.!+!5'=3!!%!%!'(.:'+!!@3'>:'!<br />

+0)76:! Nn' r P! -#! =30(! Nj3 b P! )D>#7$%$! '(.!(!(=#%! @0.'+76:! NH r P! )D>#7$! A#($3#(B$<br />

2UG(#=3#(! '+$.bG'>! )#%A#+$%$! )D>#%3#:#=! $?$%! ='(G0%'.!! =30(! $3#! )#$.$($(! -#! ='%)'!<br />

=30(!!=0%+'%.('+70%6!'(.'(B!)('()'!-#!)!=!)'!H r !-#!n' r !'(.'(4!j3 b !A#($3#(B!n' r !-#!H r !<br />

'3='3$! $70%3'(! 03)66%)'%! G6! $70%3'(!%! ='7G!! '+$.3$$! '(.!(!(B! 26! %#)#%3#! U%5#!<br />

'3='30$)0+$+.#%! +0%('! '+$)0+$+! A#3$$(B! ! \!>3!! +036=! '3!@b-#(:#! ='+! '=.$-$.#+$!<br />

A#(#=.$()$$%)#%!#%#(I$!A#(#=+$%$:$!)#!'(.'(!-#!#%#(I$)#%!7'('(3'%:'!#.=$%3$$!A#($3#(B!<br />

HD:#+!$?$!+!5'=3!!!$3#!G$(3$=.#!%#:$%!7D=+#=!03:'+!!!+!!+.(#+$%$%!#.=$+$!'(.!(!(B!!<br />

H'%! A3$=0>! )D>#7$! )#! ')(#%'3$%4! %0(')(#%'3$%! -#! A3$=0=0(.$=0$)! )D>#7$%)#=$! '(.!'!<br />

G'3!! 03'('=! '(.'G$3$(B! 8D56..'! D(#.$3#%! 1'>3'! !+!%!%! 6>'=3'.!(!3:'+!%)'! (03! 07%'7'%!<br />

'(A$%$%! -'+'.0+$%! N;8KP! =0%+'%.('+70%6! )'! 7D=+#=! +!5'=3!=.'! '(.'(B! ;8K! '7%!!<br />

>':'%)'! +!5'=! +.(#+$%#! .#@=$! 03'('=! +#(G#+.! 7'! '+$.3#($%$%! :0G$3$>'+70%6%)'! (03!<br />

07%'(B! c03'7!+!73'! 7D=+#=! +!5'=3!=.'4! ='%! .($A3$+#($)! )D>#7$! A#($3#(=#%4! +#(G#+.! 7'!<br />

'+$.3#($!)D>#7$!'(.'(!NgPB!O+!!+.(#+$!'3.!%)'!@3'>:'!K ]! =0%+'%.('+70%6%6%!)D.DD4!K g :'7!! #%1#=+$70%3'('! ='(!! =0(6(3'(B! *$>7030I$=! +.(#+! '3.!%)'!<br />

+'3A!3'%'%!A3$=0=0(.$=0$.3#(!3#%10+$.3#($%!?U>D3:#+$%#!703!'?'(B!;7%!!>':'%)'!=#:$=!<br />

$3$$%)#%!+'3A!3'%'%!&#.#(01$3!+'7!+!%)'!'(.!!036(B!c03'7!+!73'!&#.#(01$3Y!3#%10+$.!0('%!!<br />

N\YiP! '(.'(=#%4! 1'A0+$.$=! -#! G'=.#($+$.! #.=$3#($! A#($3#(! N]PB! \Yi! 0('%!4! !+!! +.(#+$%$%!<br />

$))#.$%$%! G#3$(.$3:#+$%)#! =633'%!3'%! AD-#%$3$(! G$(! @'(':#.(#! 03'('=! ='G63!<br />

#)$3:#=.#)$(B! ! lD3=$13$! -#! '(=B! Nd^P! +!5'=! +.(#+$! '3.!%)'! ]! +''.! $?$%)#! \Yi! 0('%!%!%!<br />

[Bgd7030I$=! ')'@.'+70%6%! $3=! AU+.#(A#+$)$(4!<br />

)'&'! '>! G#+$%! :'))#+$%$%! .D=#.$3:#+$! -D56..'%! D(#.$3#%! !+!7!! '>'3.'5'=.!(B! X#:!<br />

.D=#.$:$%$%! A#($3#:#+$73#4! gbZ! &'1.'3'(! '('+!%)'! )'&'! '>! 5'%3!!'!(3!=! N0(.'3':'! t!<br />

]]B^P! ='>'%:!3'(! -#! 0@.$:6:! =0633'('! AU(#! =#+$:! '!(3!!! t! ddBW! 0('%!%)'!<br />

A#($3#:$.$(B! c03'7!+!73'4! 7#:)#%! 7'('(3'%:'! )'! )'! t! VgBW! 0('%!%)'! A#($3#:#!<br />

+'@.'%:!.!(B!<br />

K$5'($!&'.3'(!%!!+!!+.(#+$%#!)67'(3!3!=3'(!!1'(=3!)!(B!26!?'3!:')'!d!%036!.$5'($!&'..!%!!+!!<br />

+.(#+$%#! )'&'! )67'(3!! 03)66! )'! +'@.'%:!.!(B! O+!! +.(#+$%#! .#@=$! ##7#! AU(#! 1'(=3!3!=!<br />

AU+.#($(B!L(=#=!@$3$?3#(!)'&'!'!(!03)6=3'(!!$?$%!+.(#+#!)'&'!)67'(3!!036@4!=#+$:!'!(3!!!<br />

-#!7#:!.D=#.$:$%)#=$!A#($3#:#!)$$3#(#!AU(#!+!('+!73'h!t!dB^!-#!t!VBg!0('%!%)'!)'&'!<br />

1'>3'!03)66!G636%:6.6(!NVfPB!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

! !J#


K'G30!VB!O+!!+.(#+$!'3.!%)'=$!.$5'($!#.3$=!@$3$?!&'.3'(!%)'!(#=.'3!+!5'=3!=!N{j!P!-#!-#($:!<br />

='7!@3'(!!NtP!<br />

! ! O+!!+.(#+$!'3.!%)'!0@.$:6:!=0633'('!AU(#!t!)#$$:!!<br />

K$5'($!L.3$=! "#=.'3! H#+$:! j'%3!! '!(3!=! X#:!.D=#.$:$! X#:)#%!<br />

J$3$?!\'..!! +!5'=3!=4! '!(3!!! '(.!!!<br />

NgbZ!&'1.'P! 7'('(3'%:'!<br />

{j!<br />

NgbZ!&'1.'P!<br />

NgbZ!&'1.'P!<br />

V! r![BeV! pd[BZ! p]]B]! bddBW! bVgB^!<br />

d! r![B^Z! pd]Bd! p]^Bf! bddBf! bVfBf!<br />

]! r![Bg[! pdgBW! b!]VBg! bd]BV! bVVBe!<br />

R(.'3':'! r![B^]! bddBW! b!]]B^! bddBW! bVgBW!<br />

L#7! ! ! ! ! !<br />

c$$3#(! r![Bgd! bdVBeyyy! p]dB^! b! b!<br />

L(=#=3#(! r![Bgg! pdgBV! p]]BW! b! b!<br />

H'7%'=Y!X'3?!%!-#!'(=B!NVfP!'3:'+!%'! 703! '?'(4! AUD+! ('%)!:'%!! )U%AD+#3! +!5'=3!=.'! t! [B^4! 7D=+#=! +'G$.!<br />

+!5'=3!=.'!t!VBe!0('%!%)'!A#($3#(B!!!<br />

!<br />

K'G30!dB!O+!!+.(#+$!'3.!%)'=$!#.3$=!@$3$?3#()#!='(='+!U>#33$=3#($4!='+!A3$=0I#%!)D>#7$!-#!#.!<br />

='3$.#+$!U>#33$=3#($!<br />

HD:#+! $?$! H'(='+!U>#33$=3#($!<br />

! L.!='3$.#!U>#33$=3#($!<br />

+!5'=3!!!! H'(='+!-#($:$! CUD+!0('%!! H'+!A3$=0I#%! H'+!@\ dg! J'(3'=3!=!<br />

N]bZ!&'1.'!'('+!P! t!<br />

t! :A_A!<br />

H0%.(03! Z]Bf'! ][B['! [BVff'! eB[['! gfBWg5!<br />

dfYdd{!j V! ZdBWG! dWB^'! [BV[eG! ^BW^'G! ^]B[gG!<br />

]g{!j d! ZVB^5! dfBgG! [BV[gG! ^BfWG! ^]BWg'!<br />

V HD:#+! $?$! +!5'=3!!! AD%)D>! df{j4! A#5#! dd{j! 03'('=! =0(6%:6.6(B ! d! HD:#+! $?$!<br />

+!5'=3!!!]g{j!03'('=!=0(6%:6.6(B!<br />

H'7%'=Y!;=$.!-#!'(=B!NV!P#7$%)#!A#($3#:#7#!%#)#%!<br />

03'('=! =#+$:)#%! dg! +''.! +0%('! U3?D3#%! ='+! @\#($%)#!G$(!)##(!'3:'+!!#.!(#%A$%$%!+03A6%4!+6!<br />

.6.:'! ='@'+$.#+$%$%! )DD=!-#!#.$%!=6(6!03)66%6!AU+.#($(B! HD:#+! $?$! +!5'=3!=3'(!%!%!<br />

'(.:'+!! @\#7$%)#=$! )#$:#3#($%! =D:#+! $?$! +!5'=3!!! '(.!=?'! )'&'! G#3$(A$%! 03)66!<br />

'%3'!3:'=.')!(!NVPB!<br />

J$3$?3#($%!=D:#+.#%!=#+$:&'%#7#!.'!%:'+!!+!('+!%)'=$!0(.':!+!5'=3!!!)'!#.$%!(#%A$%$!<br />

N@'(3'=3!!%!P! -#! +6! .6.:'! ='@'+$.#+$%$! #.=$3#7#%! U%#:3$! G$(! 1'=.U()D(B! J$3$?3#($%!<br />

! !J!


=D:#+.#%! =#+$:&'%#7#! .'!%:'3'(!! $?$%! 703)'! A#?#%! +D(#! :#-+$:#! G'3!! 03'('=! #.!<br />

='3$.#+$%$!#.=$3#7#G$3:#=.#)$(!NK'G30!]PB!X'>!%!7'@!3'%!7#.$.$(:#)#!.'!:'!+D(#+$%$%!<br />

VB^!7'!)'!]!+''.!03:'+!!)$=='.#!'3!%:')'%!@\ dg !)D>#7$%$%!=!!:#-+$:$%#!AU(#!)'&'!<br />

)DD=! 03)66! +'@.'%:!.!(! Nd]! PB! H!!%! 7'@!3'%! 7#.$.$(:#)#! $+#! .'!:'! :#+'1#+$%$%!<br />

'(.:'+!!@\ dg !#7$!'('+!%)'!%#A'.$1!<br />

7U%3D! )0(6+'3! $3$=$! +'@.'%:!4! \Yi! 0('%!! '(.!=?'! ='+! @\ dg! )D>#7$! =#+$:)#%! +0%('!<br />

&!>3'! A#($3#:$.$(! NVPB! \Yi! 0('%!! $3#! ='+! (#%A$! '('+!%)'! )'! $3$=$3$! G636%:6.6(B! \Yi!<br />

[Bd


NVWPB!O+!!+.(#+$!'3.!%)'!U3D:!0('%!!t!ZBZ!$=#%!!+!!+.(#+$!'3.!%)'!'?!G!('=!3'%3'()'!U3D:!<br />

0('%!!t!gBgg!03'('=!G636%:6.6(B!X#:!+!%!(3':'+!%!%!'7%!!>':'%)'!!+!!+.(#+$!'3.!%)'!<br />

A#3$#%!=0(=676!-#!+.(#+$!)#!'>'3..!!!+'@.'%:!.!(!NK'G30!gPB!<br />

!<br />

K'G30! gB! O+!! +.(#+$! +!('+!%)'! 7#:! +!%!(3':'+!%!%! =#+$:! '!(3!!4! U3D:! 0('%!4! =0(=6!<br />

)D>#7$!-#!&#.#(01$3Y3#%10+$.!0('%!!N\YiP!D>#($%#!#.=$3#($!<br />

! H#+$:!'!(3!!! m3D:!R('%!! K0%$=!O::0G$3$.7! \Yi!<br />

A!<br />

t!<br />

+%!<br />

H0%.(03! dVe[! ]B]]! VZ^! [Bg]!<br />

O+!!+.(#+$! VWe[! ZBZZy! dWdy! [B^^y!<br />

O+!! +.(#+$! '3.!%)'! X#:! d[d[! gBgg! d[[! [BgV!<br />

+!%!(3':'+!!<br />

X'3?!%!-#!'(=B!NVWP3'!<br />

:#.'G03$=! !+!! D(#.$3#5#$! $?$%! =D:#+! $?$! +!5'=3!!! 7D=+#3$(B! J$3$?.#%! @$3$5#! (')7'%.!<br />

.('%+1#(!'(.'(!-#!)6(''%!&'-'!@$3$?3#(!'('+!%)'!+!=!!(B!<br />

]B! %&'()*+,&5&$ 1+!)+$ @&$ ;&A-&1)&3$ H#+$:)#%! U%5#! @$3$?3#($%! G#=3#.$3)$$!<br />

0(.':!%! +!5'=3!!! )'! U%#:3$)$(B! R@.$:6:! +!5'=3!=.'! GD7D.D3)D=.#%! +0%('! dd{j!#.=$3#($!5$-5$-3#($!#(=#%!7'3'()'!+!5''!'3!.!(:'!$3#!=!+:#%!<br />

'>'3.!3'G$3$(B! T!5''! '3!.!(:'4! G6&'(3':'! $3#! 03'%! !+!! ='7!@3'(!! $?$%! #$=! -D56.!<br />

+!5'=3!!%!4! )6763'G$3$(! !+!! ='7!@3'(!%!! -#! -D56.! +!-!3'(!%!%! )'!3!:!%!! #.=$3#7#%! G$(!<br />

7U%.#:! 03'('=! .'%!:3'%'G$3$(! NVePB! T!5''! '3!.!(:'! $3#! !+!! D(#.$:$! 1$>7030I$=! 03'('=!<br />

#.=$3#%$(B!L@$A#%#.$=!')'@.'+70%!03'('=!.'%!:3'7'G$3#5#$:$>!G6!03A64!A#3$$:$%!=($.$=!<br />

)U%#:3#($!03'('=!='G63!#)$3#%!#:G($70%$=!A#3$:#!+!('+!%)'!7'!)'!5$-5$-!=636?=')'%!<br />

?!=.!=.'%!&#:#%!+0%('=$!=!+'!G$(!+D(#!$?$%)#!A#%!$1')#3#($%$!NA#%!#=+@(#+70%6%6!bA#%$%!<br />

D(D%D%D%!0(.'7'!=0%:'+!%!P!#.=$3#7#5#=!=0%.(03!+$+.#:$%$%!A#3$.$($3:#+$)$(B!26!=($.$=!<br />

)U%#:)#! ?#-(#! =0633'(!%)'! 7'@!3'5'=! )#$$=3$=3#(3#! !+!! +.(#+$%#! ')'@.'+70%!<br />

+'3'%'G$3$(B!!<br />

!<br />

DO5O1)&$2G,&)(,/&$<br />

X'':!%! $3=! ^! AD%D! $?$%)#! !+!! +.(#+$%#! :'(6>! G!('=!3:'+!! 5$-5$-3#(#! K ] !<br />

=0%+'%.('+70%6%6! -#! !+!! D(#.$:$%$! '>'3.:'! 7#.#%#$! ='>'%)!('('=! !+!! +.(#+$%#!<br />

')'@.'+70%! +'3'%'G$3$(B! c$#(! G$(! $1')#! $3#! =636?=')'%! ?!=.!=.'%! +0%('=$! )U%#:)#!<br />

%0(:'3)#%! 7D=+#=! +!5'=3!=.'! G!('=!3'%! 5$-5$-3#(! !+!! .03#('%+!%!! :0)$1$7#! #)#(3#(B!<br />

2U73#5#4!!+!!+.(#+$!'3.!%)'!@#(10(:'%+3'(!%!!A#3$.$(#G$3$(3#(!-#!U3D:!0('%3'(!!A#($3#(B!!<br />

! !JH


X'&'-! -#! 9596(.(7! NVeP! ]bZ! AD%3#(! '('+!%)'! 5$-5$-3#($%! 7D=+#! +!5'=3!=3'('!<br />

)'7'%!=3!3!!%!%! '(.!(!3'G$3#5#$%$! '%5'=! #%! $7$! +0%656%! GD7D.:#! )U%#:$%$%! ]B!<br />

AD%D%)#! 5$-5$-3#($%! ]eb]ZB^{j! )#! G'(!%)!(!3:'+!! $3#! #3)#! #)$3#G$3#5#$%$!<br />

G$3)$(:$3#()$(B! X'&'-! -#! \6(Q$.>! NV^P! ^! AD%3D=! 5$-5$-3#(! dg! +''.! +D(#+$%5#! ]e{j!<br />

+!5'=3!'! :'(6>! G!('=!3)!!%)'4! gdBAD%)#! 67A63'%'%! '%$! +!5'=! +.(#+$%#! )'7'%!=3!!<br />

03)6=3'(!%!! G$3)$(:$3#()$(B! X'3?!%! -#! '(=! Nd[[VGP! GD7D.:#! )U%#:$%$%! ^BAD%D%)#!<br />

5$-5$-3#($%!]e~j!)#!dg!+''.!+D(#73#!G'(!%)!(!3:'+!%!%!]B&'1.')'%!+0%('!67A63'%'%!!+!!<br />

+.(#+$%$%! 036:+6>! #.=$3#($%$! '>'3.'('=4! =0%.(03! +!5'=3!!%)'! 7#.$.$($3#%3#(#! G#%>#(!<br />

=#+$:!'!(3!!%'!)'&'!'>!=0(=6!)D>#7$!$3#!63''G$3#5#=3#($%$!-#!#.$%!='3$.#+$%$%!N@\ dg !<br />

-#!@'(3'=3!=P!=0%.(03!$3#!G#%>#(!03)66!+'@.':!3'()!(!NK'G30!ZPB!<br />

!<br />

K'G30! ZB! O+!! +.(#+$%#! '3!.!(:'%!%! =0(=64! \Yi! 0('%!! ='+! @\! -#! @'(3'=3!=! )D>#7$%#!<br />

#.=$3#($!<br />

! H#+$:!<br />

'!(3!!!<br />

K0%$=! \Bi! @\ dg ! J'(3'=3!=!<br />

O::0G$3$.#4+!<br />

!Ng!AD%!+0%('P!<br />

H0%.(03! d^]Z'! VZ^G! [Bg]G! eB[['! ^dBfZG!<br />

O+!!T.(#+$! dggZG! dWd'! [BgW'! ^BfZG! ^^Bdg'!<br />

O+!!+.(#+$%#! d^dd'! VZ^G! [BgVG! ^BWZ'! ^VBWeG!<br />

'3!.!(:'!<br />

H'7%'=Y!X'3?!%!-#!'(=B!NVW4!d[4!dgP3!=3'('! '$.!<br />

=636?='3!=! 76:6(.'3'(!%4! =636?='%!%! V]bVZ! AD%3#($! '('+!%)'! &#(! AD%! d! +''.!<br />

!+!.!3:'+!%!%! #.3$=! @$3$?3#($%! ]]bg]! AD%3#(! '('+!%)'! +!5''! )'7'%!=3!3!!%!! '(.!()!!!<br />

+'@.'%:!.!(!NWPB!!<br />

H636?='! )U%#:$%)#! !+!! +.(#+$%#! ')'@.'+70%4! =636?='%!%! V[bd[! BAD%3#($! '('+!%)'!<br />

0@.$:6:)'%! )'&'! 7D=+#=! =636?='! +!5'=3!!! 67A63'%:'+!! $3#! +'3'%'G$3$(=#%4!<br />

#@$A#%#.$=! ')'@.'+70%! =636?=')'! $3#:$%! 7'@!3)!!! AD%! -#! +D(#7#! G'3!)!(B! i'7! -#!<br />

a$3+0%!NfP!=636?='%!%!VeBAD%D%)#!dg!+''.!+D(#73#!g[Be{j!+!5'=3!=4!OSG'3!-#!'(=B!NZP!<br />

=636?='%!%!VVbd[BAD%3#($!'('+!%)'!&#(!AD%!e!+''.!]W{j!+!5'=3!=4!X'&'-!-#!'(=B!NVZP!$+#!<br />

=636?='%!%!VebVf!AD%3#($!'('+!%)'!&#(!AD%!]!+''.!+D(#!$3#!]WB^j!+!5'=3!=!67A63':'7!!<br />

U%#(:$3#()$(B!!<br />

X'3?!%!-#!'(=B!NdV4!ddP!=636?='%!%!V[bVf!AD%3#(!'('+!%)'!76:6(.'3'(!!]fB^j#(! '!(3!=.'! G636%:63'()!(B!<br />

j$-5$-3#(#! GD7D.:#! )U%#:$%)#! ]B&'1.')'%! +0%('!!+!! +.(#+$! 67A63'%)!!%)'4! !+!! +.(#+$!<br />

'3.!%)'!)'&'!7D=+#=!'!(3!'!63'.!=3'(!!+'@.'%:!.!(!NK'G30!WPB!!<br />

!<br />

! !JJ


!<br />

K'G30! fB! H636?=')'! )U%AD+#3! 7D=+#=! +!5'=3!=! 67A63':'3'(!%!%! 5$-5$-! '!(3!!! -#!<br />

=636?='!@#(10(:'%+!%'!#.=$3#($!<br />

! j$-5$-!!<br />

'!(3!!!<br />

!A!<br />

H'3@!!<br />

'!(3!!!<br />

t!<br />

H'('5$#(!<br />

'!(3!!!<br />

!t!<br />

T'(!!=#+#+$!<br />

A!<br />

H636?='!<br />

('%)!:'%!4!<br />

t!<br />

k!=!!<br />

AD5D!<br />

t!<br />

H0%.(03!H636?='! ggB^^G! [BZ]'! dBd^'! ^BZZG! f^Bd! W^Bf!<br />

cU%AD+#3! T!5'=! geBe['! [BedG! VBfdG! eBff'! f]B]! W]B]!<br />

H636?='!<br />

X'3?!%!-#!'(=B!NdVP#%3#:#3#(3#!<br />

+'3'%'G$3)$$! A$G$4! =636?='! +!('+!%)'! #:G($703'(!%! !+!! +.(#+$%#! '3!.!(!3:'+!! $3#! )#!<br />

+'3'%'G$3#5#$!'%3'!3:'=.')!(B!L.3$=!@$3$?!D(#.$:$%)#!=633'%!3'%!.$5'($!&'.3'(!'('+!%)'!<br />

!+!!+.(#+$%#!)'7'%!=3!3!=!G'=!:!%)'%!1'(=3!3!=3'(!03)66!)'!6%6.63:':'3!)!(B!!!<br />

$<br />

%+5,+A-+.$<br />

VB! ;=$.4!9B4!X'3?!%4!TB4!m>='%4!TB4!!9#.$%4!HB4!m>)#:$(4!cBY!L11#5.+!01!.#:@#('.6(#!)6($%A!(#'($%A!<br />

'%)!5('.$%A!0%!+.(#+!@'(':#.#(+!'%)!:#'.!S6'3$.7!01!G(0$3#(+B!J063.B!T5$B4!d[[eh!f^Y!VfeZbVfZgB!<br />

dB! 2'(G6.4! TBY! j0306(! :#'+6(#:#%.+! 10(! #-'36'.$%A! .&#! @'3#! +01.! #M6)'.$-#! NJTLP! 0556((#%5#! $%!<br />

.6(=#7!:#'.B!*00)!"#+B!O%.B4!VWW]h!deY!]Wbg]B!<br />

]B! 20(A#+4! TB! ;B4! *$+5&#(! )'! T$3-'4! ;B! 8B4! 9'I0(='4! ;B4! \00A#4! cB! 9B! '%)! j6::$%A+4! HB! "BY!<br />

J&7+$030A$5'3! (#+@0%+#+! 01! G(0$3#(! 5&$5=#%+! .0! &#'.! +.(#++! '%)! )$#.'(7! #3#5.(037.#! G'3'%5#! N+0)$6:! @36+!<br />

@0.'++$6:!:$%6+!5&30($)#4!:$33$#S6$-'3#%.+!@#(!=$30A(':PB!J063.B!T5$B4!d[[gh!!f]YV^^VpV^^fB!<br />

gB! L.5&#+4!"B!wB4!w0&%!KB!9B4! '%)!C$GG$%+!;B!9B!8BY!2#&'-$06('34!@&7+030A$5'34!%#6(0#%)05($%#!<br />

'%)! :03#563'(! (#+@0%+#+! .0! &#'.! +.(#++4! #)B! c;C\O"4! nB! wB4! J063.(7! J(0)65.$0%! $%! \0.! j3$:'.#+4! j;2!<br />

O%.#(%'.$0%'34!NVWW^P!@@B!]Vpe^B!<br />

^B! *('%5$+4! jB! ;B4! 9'530')! 9B! CB4! '%)! ;%)#(+0%! wB! LB! 9BY! ;33#-$'.$0%! 01! '56.#! +.(#++! G7! 100)!<br />

Q$.&)('Q'3!0(!)'(=%#++4!2($.B!J063.B!T5$B4!VWWVh!]dY!dVWbdd^B!!<br />

eB! \'-#+.#$%4!CB!2B4!*#(=#.4!JB!"B4!Å6(#+&$4!TB!LB!Y!C(0Q.&4!3$-'G$3$.74!'%)!1##)!50%-#(+$0%!01!VW^Z!<br />

-#(+6+!d[[V!G(0$3#(+!Q&#%!1#)!(#@(#+#%.'.$-#!VW^Z!'%)!d[[V!G(0$3#(!)$#.+B!!J063.(7!T5$B4!d[[]h!fdY!V^[[b<br />

V^[fB!<br />

!<br />

ZB! OSG'34!;B4!c#567@#(#!LB4!;G)!L3!;>$:!;B4!'%)!HD&%!LB!"BY!J(#b!'%)!@0+.b&'.5&!&$A&!.#:@#('.6(#!<br />

#M@0+6(#!'11#5.+!.&#!.&7(0$)!&0(:0%#+!'%)!50(.$50+.#(0%#!(#+@0%+#!.0!'56.#!&#'.!+.(#+!$%!A(0Q$%A!5&$5=#%+!<br />

NC'336+!)0:#+.$56+P4!wB!K&#(:B!2$03B4!VWW[h!V^Y!VgWbV^]4!NPB!<br />

fB! i'74!cB!jB4!a$3+0%4!9B!LB!YB!c#-#30@:#%.!01!5&$5=#%+!'+!'!:0)#3!10(!@(#%'.'3!+.(#++B!wB!;%$:B!<br />

T5$B!d[[dh!f[Y!VW^gbVWeVB!<br />

! !JN


WB! 90('#+4! 8B! 9B! 2B4! 9'3&#$(0+4! "B! cB4! 2(6AA#:'%4! 8B4! j033$%4! ;B4! K0%'4! HB4! 8'%! ;+4! JB4!<br />

R%#AG#+'%4! RB! 9B4! 267+#4! wB! 4! c#567@#(#4! LB! '%)! 9'5'($4! 9BY! L11#5.! 01! .&#(:'3! 50%)$.$0%$%A! )6($%A!<br />

#:G(70%$5! )#-#30@:#%.! 0%! '+@#5.+! 01! @&7+$030A$5'3! (#+@0%+#+! 01! G(0$3#(+! .0! &#'.! +.(#++B! wB! K&#(:B! 2$03B!<br />

d[[]h!dfY!V]]bVg[B!<br />

V[B! 90('#+4! 8B! 9B! 2B4! 9'3&#$(0+4! "B! cB4! 2(6AA#:'%4! 8B4! j033$%4! ;B4! K0%'4! HB4! 8'%! ;+4! JB4!<br />

R%#AG#+'%4! RB! 9B4! 267+#4! wB! 4! c#567@#(#! LB4! 9'5'($4! 9BY! K&#! #11#5.! 01! .$:$%A! 01! .&#(:'3! 50%)$.$0%$%A!<br />

)6($%A! $%56G'.$0%! 0%! #:G(70! @&7+$030A$5'3! @'.':#.#(+! '%)! $.+! (#3'.$0%+&$@! .0! .&#(:0.03#('%5#! $%! ')63.!<br />

G(0$3#(!5&$5=#%+B!w06(%'3!01!K&#(:'3!2$03B4!d[[gh!dWY^^b^eB!<br />

VVB! T':+4!;B"BY!JTL_c*c!à#b:'$3Y!'+':+v@063.(7B.':6B#)6ÜB!d[[dB!;-'$3'G3#!1(0:Y!.&#!'6.&0(!'.!<br />

'+':+v!@063.(7B.':6B#)6B!<br />

VdB! T$%6('.4! ;B! JB4! 2'3%'-#4! cB4! 95c0Q#334! CB! \BY! ! C(0Q.&! @#(10(:'%5#! '%)! 50%5#%.('.$0%! 01!<br />

.&7(0$)!&0(:0%#+!'%)!A(0Q.&!&0(:0%#!$%!@3'+:'!01!G(0$3#(+!'.!&$A&!.#:@#('.6(#+B!;6+.B!wB!2$03B!T5$B4!VWfZh!<br />

g[Y!gg]bg^[B!<br />

V]B! T=0:0(65&'4!OB4!T0+%0Q='bj>'I='4!LB4!965&'5='4!"B!Y!L11#5.!01!.&#(:'3!50%)$.$0%+!0%!Q#31'(#!<br />

01!G(0$3#(!5&$5=#%+!01!)$11#(#%.!0($A$%B!;%%B!;%$:B!T5$B4!d[V[h!V[Y!gfWbgWZB!<br />

VgB! K##.#(4! "B! CB4! T:$.&4! 9B! RB! '%)! a$#(%6+>4! jB! wB4! ! "#+#'(5&! %0.#Y! 2(0$3#(! '553$:'.$0%! .0! &#'.!<br />

)$+.(#++!'%)!100)!$%.'=#!#11#5.+!0%!G0)7!.#:@#('.6(#!$%!G(0$3#(+!#M@0+#)!.0!.&#(:0%#6.('3!'%)!&$A&!':G$#%.!<br />

.#:@#('.6(#+4!J063.B!T5$B4!VWWdh!ZVY!VV[VbVV[gB!<br />

V^B! X'&'-4! TB! '%)! \6(Q$.>4! TB! Y! O%)65.$0%! 01! .&#(:0.03#('%5#! $%! ':3#! G(0$3#(! 5&5$=#%+! G7!<br />

.#:@#('.6(#!50%)$.$0%$%A!'.!'%!#'(37!'A#B!J063.B!T5$B4!VWWeh!Z^Y!g[dbg[eB!<br />

VeB! X'&'-4!TB!'%)!9596(.(74! wB! JBY! K&#(:0.03#(%5#!'5S6$+$.$0%!$%!G(0$3#(!5&$5=#%+!G7!.#:@#(.6(#!<br />

50%)$.$0%$%A!#'(37!$%!3$1#b.&#!#11#5.!01!.$:$%A!'%)!':G$#%.!.#:@#('.6(#B!J063.B!T5$B4!d[[Vh!f[Y!VeedbVeeeB!<br />

VZB! X'&'-4!TB4!j033$%4!;B4!T&$%)#(4!cB'%)!J$5'()B!9BY!K&#(:'3! :'%$@63'.$0%+!)6($%A!G(0$3#(!5&$5=!<br />

#:G(70A#%#+$+Y!L11#5.+!01!.$:$%A!'%)!.#:@#('.6(#B!J063.B!T5$B!d[[gh!f]YVW^WpVWe]B!<br />

VfB! X'3?!%4! TB4! T#..'(4! JB4! m>='%4! TB4! j'&'%#(4! ;BY! j0:@'('.$-#! #-'36'.$0%! 01! .&(##! 50::#(5$'3!<br />

G(0$3#(!+.05=+!$%!&0.!-#(+6+!.#:@#('.#!53$:'.#+B!!J063.B!T5$B4!VWWZh!ZeYWdVpWdW!<br />

VWB! X'3?!%!TB4!m>='%!T4!k'G6=!9B4!'%)!T$#A#3!JB!2BY!j($.#($'!10(!#-'36'.$%A!&6+G'%)(7!@('5.$5#+!.0!<br />

'33#-$'.#!&#'.!+.(#++!$%!G(0$3#(+4!!wB!;@@3B!J063.B!"#+B4!d[[]h!VdY!!]fdb]ffB!<br />

d[B! X'3?!%4!TB4!m>='%4! TB4! k'G6=49B4! ! 267+#4! wB4! c#567@#(#4!LB4!T$#A#34!JB!2B!YG! L11#5.! 01! J(#b'%)!<br />

@0+.b%'.'3! j0%)$.$0%$%A! .0! $%)65#! .&#(:0.03#('%5#! 0%! G0)7! Q#$A&.4! @&7+$030A$5'3! (#+@0%+#+! '%)! (#3'.$-#!<br />

'+7::#.(7!01!G(0$3#(+!0($A$%'.$%A!1(0:!706%A!'%)!03)!G(##)#(!1305=+B!J063.B!T5$B4!d[[^h!fgYWeZbWZeB!<br />

dVB! X'3?!%4$T4!j'G6=44!9B!2(6AA#:'%4!8B4!2'G'5'%0A364!LB4!267+#4!wB4!!c#567@#(#4!LB4!!T$#A#34!JB!2B!<br />

Y! ;553$:'.$0%! .0! &#'.! )6($%A! $%56G'.$0%B! VB! L:G(70%$5! :0(@&030A$5'3! .('$.+4! G300)! G$05&#:$+.(74! '%)!<br />

&'.5&$%A!@#(10(:'%5#B!J063.B!T5$B4!d[[f'h!fZYVdVWbdfB!<br />

ddB! X'3?!%4!TB4!k'G6=4!9B4!2(6AA#:'%4!8B4!2'G'5'%0364!LB4!267+#4!wB4!c#567@#(#4!LB!'%)!T$#A#34!JB!<br />

2BY! ;553$:'.$0%! .0! &#'.! )6($%A! $%56G'.$0%Y! ]B! 20)7! a#$A&.4! 530'5'3! .#:@#('.6(#+4! J063.B! T5$B4! d[[fh!<br />

fZYdeZVpdeZZB!<br />

d]B! X'3?!%4! TB! '%)B! CD3#(4! \B! jBY! ! L11#5.! 01! @(#+3'6A&.#(! .('%+@0(.! )6('.$0%! 0%! :#'.! S6'3$.7! 01!<br />

G(0$3#(+!+3'6A&.#(#)!'.!)$11#(#%.!G0)7!Q#$A&.+!'%)!+#'+0%+!b!|O|!L6(0@#'%!T7:@0+$6:!0%!.&#!Å6'3$.7!01!<br />

J063.(7!9#'.4!*$%3'%)4!dVbd^!w6%#4!d[[W4!K6(=6B!<br />

dgB! X'3?!%4TB4!!m%#%?4!;B4!m>='%4!TB4!CD3#(4!\B!jB!'%)!T$#A#34!JB!2BY!9#'.!S6'3$.7!!01!&#'.!+.(#++#)!<br />

G(0$3#(+Y!L11#5.+!01!!.&#(:'3!50%)$.$0%$%A!'.!@(#b!'%)!b@0+.%'.'3!!+.'A#+B!|8OO!.&!L6(0@#'%!T7:@0+$6:!0%!<br />

.&#!Å6'3$.7!01!J063.(7!9#'.!c00(Q#(.&4!d]bde!9'74!d[[^BK&#!n#.&#(3'%)+B!!<br />

d^B! l63=$13$4! OB4! ;S$34! ;B! ;3B4! R:'(4! ;B! "B! 4! T'$3$4! ;B! ÅB4! "'I$0%4! 9B! ;BY! j('.$%A! '%)! &#'.! +.(#+!<br />

$%136#%5#!G300)!@'(':#.#(+!'%)!&#'.!+5&05=!@(0.#$%!Z[!#M@(#++$0%!$%!G(0$3#(!5&$5=#%+!+&0Q$%A!+&0(.!0(!30%A!<br />

.0%$5!$::0G$3$.7!(#'5.$0%+B!J063.B!T5$B4!d[[Wh!ffY!gZVbgZeB!!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

! !JT


" #!W $D.F(-&.$`&1(1(.('7%!!<br />

b!k'.!4)6-'(4!@'%#3!G'3'%.!!'('3'(!%)'=$!&'-'!='?'=3'(!!<br />

b!;!3':'!$3#!$3A$3$!+636=!&'.3'(!%'!7#.#(3$!+6!G'+!%5!%!%!+'3'%:'+!!A$G$!=D:#+3#()#=$!<br />

U%#:3$!#=+$=3$=3#($!A$)#($3:#3$!-#!.#0($=!G$3A$3#(!+'3'%:'3!)!(B!!<br />

J$3$?!7#.$.$($5$3$$!7'@!3'%!.D:!=D:#+3#()#h!<br />

26! G$3A$3#(! A#(#=! G'=!:3'4! A#(#=+#! 7U%#.$:3#! $3A$3$! :0.$-'+70%! '(.!(!5!! G$(#G$(! 7')'!<br />

.0@3'%.!3'(! &'3$%)#! '=.'(!3'('=! .0@3':! ='3$.#! 7U%#.$:$! >$&%$7#.$! G#%$:+#.$3:#3$)$(B!<br />

X'%$! @'.(0%6%)'%! $?$+$%#! =')'(! .D:! @#(+0%#3$%$%! $(=#.$%! +'&$G$! A$G$! ?'3$:'+!4!<br />

H'>'?3'(!%! $+#! ='>'%b='>'%! $3=#+$%#! AU(#! @'73'!3:'+!! A#(#=.$$%$%! 7'('(3!! 03'5'!!<br />

)DD%D3:#=.#)$(B!m>AD-#%!'%3'7!!%!!&'=$:!=!3'('=4!G'=!5!3'(!%!)'!=D:#+!G'=!:!%)'!<br />

:D)'&'3#! #.:#! 03'%'!%!! +'3'%:'+!! 7'('(3!! 036(B! 26! >$&%$7#..#%! 703'! ?!='('=! @($:!<br />

+$+.#:$! $3#! @#(+0%#3$%! ='>'%?.'%! '7(!5'! A#3$(! #3)#! #.:#+$! )#! )DD%D3:#+$! A#(#=%! G$(!<br />

67A63':'!03:'3!)!(B!<br />

;'!)'! '?!=3'%'5'=! G'=!:! -#! =0(67656! U%3#:3#(3#! $3A$3$! .#0($=! -#! @('.$=! G$3A$3#($!<br />

67A63'7'('=!)'&'!$7$!!+0%6?3'(!#3)#!#)$3:#+$!:D:=D%!036(B!!<br />

!<br />

D+A!)!,$8,&)($<br />

#:')'! AU(D3)DD! A$G$! d[4[[[! ')#.! 5$-5$-)#%! f[4[[[! =A! 7#:! 7#)$(#(#=! ^[4[[[! =A!<br />

j'%3!!'!(3!=!'3!%'G$3)$$!A$G$4!W^4[[[!HA!7#:3#!)#!'7%!!+0%656!'3'G$3:#=.#7$>B!X'%$!<br />

^[4[[[! =A! 5'%3!!'!(3!=! '3'G$3:#=! $?$%! V^4[[[! =A! 7#:! .'+''((616! 7'@!3'G$3:#=.#)$(B!<br />

2U73#5#! &#:! D(#.$5$! ='>'%'5'=4! &#:! )#! :$33$! #=0%0:$7#! ='.=!:!>! 03'5'=.!(B! 26!<br />

.'+'((616!+'3'7'G$3:#)#!7#:!-#!5$-5$-!='3$.#+$%$%!U%#:$!#3G#..#!?0=!GD7D=.D(B!*'='.!<br />

G$>3#(!.'('1!%)'%!7'@!3:'+!!A#(#=#%3#(!)#!#%!'>!7#:!-#!5$-5$-!='3$.#+$!=')'(!U%#:3$)$(B!<br />

$<br />

L%!G'.'!$7$!G$(!.#:$>3$=!-#!)#>#%1#=+$70%)'%!+0%('!&'>!(3!=!'':'+!!-#!G$0!AD-#%3$=!<br />

.#)G$(3#($%#!.$.$>!G$(!#=$3)#!6763:'3!)!(B!C#(#=!&'>!(3!=!'':'+!%)'!A#(#=+#!G'=!%)'!<br />

#%! ?0=! ='(!3'.!!:!>! &'.'3'(!! -#! #%! 7D=+#=! ('%)!:'%!! '3'G$3:#=! $?$%! 7'@.!!:!>!<br />

@('.$=!67A63':'3'(!:!>!!-#!.#0($=!&'3#!A#.$()$$:$>!G$3A$3#($:$>$!+$>3#(3#!@'73':'7'!<br />

?'3!'5'!:B!<br />

!<br />

! !JW


:-1-!A$%+-(1&'($<br />

;3.3!=!k06!D(#.$5$3#(!7#:!-#!5$-5$-!='3$.#+$!D>#($%)#!U%#:3#!)6(6@!$='7#.3#($%$!)$3#!<br />

A#.$($(=#%! 7'%$! 7'')!!! GD.D%! +0(6%3'(!! 7#:! -#! 5$-5$-! ='3$.#+$%$%! G0>6=366%'!<br />

G'3'(=#%!#%!G'+$.!AU(D%#%!1'='.!+D(D)#!GD7D=!@(0G3#:3#(#!703!'?'%!'3.3!=!=0%6+6%'!<br />

A#(#=#%! U%#:$! -#(:#:#=.#)$(3#(B! m>#33$=3#! ':0.U(! 7#.$.$($5$3$$%! &'=$:! 03)66!<br />

VWW[bd[[[É3$! 7!33'()'! ?#3.$=! ='G66%'! G'3!! +0(6%3'(! &'.! +'1&')'7)!B! k#3.$=!<br />

1'G($='3'(!%)'%!?!='%!='-6>3'(!('+.A#3#!+.0=3'%)!!%)'%4!)0@03':'7'!A#(#=#%!U%#:$%!<br />

-#($3:#7$$%)#%! !+3'%:'7'! G'3!! ='('(:!4! .0@'=3'%:!! -#! =D13#%:$! 03'('=!<br />

=D:#+3#(#! A#3:#=.#7)$B! 26%6%! 7'%!%)'! ?#3.$=! ='G66%)'! GU5#=3#%:#4! 1'(#! -#! =6!<br />

@$+$3$=3#($%#!)#!('+.3'%:'=.'7)!B!CD%D:D>)#!?0=!+!=!03:'+'!)'!6>6%!+D(#!G#=3#.$3:$4!<br />

7#%$! D(#.$:$%! G'3':'+!%'! 7'=!%! )U%#:3#()#! G6! .D(! '3.3!=3'(!%! =D:#+3#(#! A#3)$$%$!<br />

AU(:#=.#7$>B!26!=0%A(#7#!A#3:#)#%!$=$!AD%!U%5#!=#%)$!=D:#+3#($:$>#!)#!G6!#=$3)#!<br />

='('(:!! -#! =D1!=0=636! ?#3.$=! ='G66! A#3)$! -#! G$>! A#($! $')#! #..$=B! 2$(! G'='! GD7D=!<br />

=D:#+!'7%!!7#()#%!A#3#%4!'7%!!+0(6%6!.'!7'%!'3.3!!!'3'('=!=D:#+$%)#!=633'%:!.!(B!<br />

26! =D:#+.#! #:')'! +!('3':!! 03)66:! +0(6%3'(3'! ='(!3'!3'5'!! =#+$%)$(B! J3'%7'!<br />

.'3'!! %#:3$! 03)66%)'4! $?#($+$%)#! .0>! .'3'! 0('%!%!! 1'>3'5'! G'(!%)!()!!%)'! )'! G'.'!<br />

'+@#(A$336+!03:'=!D>#(#!#:')'=$!+0(6%3'('!>':'%!>':'%!('+.3':'=.'7!>!2$(='?!=#>!<br />

:0G$37'!.'3'!!=633'%'%!=D:#+3#()#!=$:7'+'3!G07'3'(!%!%#)#%!03)66!.0=+$='+70%!-#!<br />

7D=+#=!U3D:3#(#!)#!('+.3')!=B!!!!!!!L%!'>!7#:!5$-5$-!='3$.#+$!=')'(!'3.3!=!='3$.#+$%$%!)#!<br />

U%#:3$!03)66%64!G6!%#)#%3#!'3.3!=!+#?$:$%)#!.$.$>3$=3#!)6(63:'+!!A#(#=.$$%$!G$(!=#>!<br />

)'&'! &'.!(3'.!70(6:B! ;%3'..!!:! +0(6%36! '3.3!!! =633'%'%! =D:#+3#()#! '=6.! U3D:3#(#!<br />

('+.3')!!:!>! A$G$! V[bVd! AD%3#()#%! $.$G'(#%! #:')'=$! +0(6%3'(!%! AU>3#! AU(D3D(! G$(!<br />

#=$3)#!=(0%$=!03'('=!7''%)!!%'!)'!'&$.!03)6=B!<br />

26!+0(6%3'(!Y!<br />

b!`%$10(:$.#)#!20>63:'!<br />

b!X#:!-#!+6!.D=#.$:$%)#!'>'3:'!<br />

b!j'%3!!'!(3!=!-#!-#($:!='7G!!<br />

b!::D%$.#)#!'>'3:'!<br />

b!;+5$.#+!!<br />

b!c$#(!L%1#=+$70%3'(!N!K0=+$='+70%4!n#=(0.$=!#%.#($.$+!82P!<br />

!<br />

['!$%+5,+!$<br />

m>#33$=3#! =!! '73'(!%)'! !+!! ='7%'!! =D:#+$%! =!+'! +D(#)#! 7#.#(3$! !+!7'! A#.$(#G$3#5#=!<br />

J(0@'%4! inj! -#7'! )0'3! A'>! 7'='%! =D:#+3#()#! 7#.#(3$! (')7'%! 03:')!!%)'! =U:D(!<br />

-#7'!1!%)!=!='G66!-G!7'='%!=D:#+3#()#!+0G'3'()'!036'%!+!=!+!=!'(!>'3'(!7')'!G'=!:!<br />

#=+$=3$$%)#%! ='7%'=3'%'%! )6(6:3'()'! 7#.#(3$! !+!! +'3'%':':'=.')!(B! 2'>!!<br />

=D:#+3#()#!$>03'+70%!7#.#(+$>3$$%#!G'3!!03'('=.'!!+!.:')'!AD?3D=!?#=$3:#=.#)$(B$<br />

O+!.:'!7#.#(+$>!03)66!>':'%Y!<br />

b!\0:0I#%!!+!!)'!3!:!!+'3'%':'>!<br />

b!O+!!7#.#(+$>3$$%#!G'3!!03'('=!$+.#%$3#%!)D>#7)#!&'-'3'%)!(:'!7'@!3':'>B!!<br />

kD%=D!:$%$:6:!$&.$7'?!)6763'%!&'-'7!!-#(+#=!G$3#!=D:#+!0(.':!!+067'5'=4!+06=!<br />

$3#! $3A$3$! +0(6%3'(! 7''%'5'=.!(B! b! O+!! )'!3!:!! &0:0I#%! 03:')!!%)'%! 5$-5$-3#(! )#!<br />

&0:0I#%!)'!3:'7'5'=4!7#:!-#!+6!.D=#.$:$%)#!)#%A#+$>3$=!03'5'=.!(B!b!26%3'('!G'3!!<br />

03'('=!D%$10(:$.#)#!G0>63:'!03'5'=.!(B!b!L=+$=!&'-'3'%)!(:'!-#!7#.#(+$>!!+!)'%!)03'7!!<br />

'3.3!=.'!%#:!G$($=#5#=!'3.3!=!!+3'%'5'=!'3.3!=!='3$.#+$!G0>63'5'=.!(B!b!;3.3!=.'!!+3'%:'!-#!<br />

':0%7'=!G$($=:#+$!+0%656%)'!:'%.'(!-#!'%'#(0G!G'=.#($3#(!D(#7#5#=.$(B!H0=+$)$70>4!<br />

n#=(0.$=!#%.#($.$+4!T'3:0%#33'!-#!-$('3!&'+.'3!=3'(!+D(D7D!=03'75'!#.=$3#7#5#=.$(B!<br />

!<br />

! !JZ


!<br />

$<br />

j&)$['!$%F.&-+'5F,7$<br />

J('.$=!03'('=!%#:!0('%!!$+.#%$3#%!)D>#7)#%!t!^!1'>3'!$+#!&$++#)$3#%!!+!!VÉ5!'(.'(B!t!^!<br />

'>!$+#!&$++#)$3#%!!+!!VÉ5!'>'3!(B!;7(!5'!1'%3'(!%!+D(#=3$!?'3!.!!%!!-'(+'7'(+'=!g[4[[[!<br />

:]_T''.! 3$=! G$(! 1'%!%! ?#=$:! AD5D%#! G'3!! 03'('=! 036'%! &'-'! '=!:!%)'%! )03'7!!<br />

&$++#)$3#%! !+!! 5$-5$-$%! 7'!%'! AU(#! [4Z^! b! V4^[É5! )#(#5#! )D#(B! 26! )##(3#(! )$=='.#!<br />

'3!%'('=!&$++#)$3#%!!+!7'!AU(#!%#:b!+!!=0(#3'+70%6%'!AU(#!G'=!:!7'@!3:'3!)!(B!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

+.#%$3#%!G'!3!%#:!0('%!73'!G$(3$=.#!$+.#%$3#%! !+!!)##(3#($!5$-5$-3#($%!7'3'(!%'!AU(#!<br />

#:')'!AU+.#($3:$.$(B!!<br />

!<br />

! !J]


!<br />

R@.$:6:!=0633'()'!t!e[!%#:!0('%!%'!='(!3!=!dZ5!3$=!!+!!$+.#%$70(+'!%#:!0('%3'(!!<br />

'(..!!%)'!-#7'!'>'3)!!%)'!$+.#%$3#%!!+!!)##(3#($!&$++#)$3#%!!+!7'!AU(#!AU+.#($3:$.$(B!!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

HD:#+! 0(.':!%)'! $)#'3! 03'%!! 0@.$:6:! !+!! -#! %#:! )##(3#($%$%! =D:#+! 0(.':!%)'!<br />

67A63'%:'+!)!(B! 2'!3! %#:)#! 0@.$:6:! )##(3#()#%! +'@:'! 03)66%)'! 7'@!3:'+!!<br />

A#(#=#%3#(h!V!b!HD:#+!0(.':!%)'=$!%#:!$+.#%$3#%!)##(3#()#%!7D=+#=+#h!<br />

b!c!!0(.':)'=$!%#:!)DD=+#!&'-'3'%)!(:'!:$=.'(!!'(.!(!3'G$3$(B!<br />

b!c!!0(.':)'=$!%#:!7D=+#=+#!&'-'3'%)!(:'7!!'(.!(:'%!%!7'('(!!03:'7'5'=.!(B!<br />

26%6%!$?$%!!+!.!5!%!%!7'%:'!-#!)#-(#)#%!?!=:'!+D(#+$%$!6>'.'G$3$($>B!m(%#$%h!!+!.!5!!<br />

dfÉ5!7'%!@!df4]É5!)#!)#-(#)#%!?!=!70(+'![4]É5!3$=!7'%:'!+D(#+$![4e!b![4ZÉ5!ëë!#=$3)#!<br />

'(.!(!3'G$3$(B!<br />

b!c$#(!G$(!+#?#%#$:$>h!!+!!+#.!)##($!)DD(D3#(#=!&$++#)$3#%!+!5'=3!!%!+'3'%:'+!%'!<br />

?'3!!3'G$3$(B!d!b!HD:#+!0(.':!%)'=$!%#:!$+.#%$3#%!)##(3#()#%!)DD=+#h!<br />

b!c!!0(.':)'=$!%#:!)DD=+#!&'-'3'%)!(:'!:$=.'(!!:$%$:6:'!)DD(D3#G$3$(B!!<br />

b!c!!0(.':)'=$!%#:!7D=+#=+#!&'-'3'%)!(:'!:$=.'(!!'(.!(!3!(B!<br />

b!O+!!+#.!)##($!7D=+#3.$3#(#=!&$++#)$3#%!+!5'=3!!%!+'3'%:'+!%'!?'3!!3'G$3$(B!<br />

b!c!!0(.':!+!5'=+'!@#)!7')'!+$+3#:#3#(!)#-(#7#!+0=63'G$3$(B!N5$-5$-$%!7'!%'!67A6%!<br />

03'('=P!!<br />

!<br />

! !N#


!<br />

$<br />

L+@+-+,/!.)+$<br />

L+@+$*!9!3$<br />

c!! 0(.':! +!5'=3!!%'! G'3!! 03'('=! +!5'=3!=! '(..!=?'! $?#($7#! A$(#%! &'-'! &!>!!<br />

)DD(D3:#3$)$(B! c!! 0(.':! &'-'! +!5'=3!!! '>'3)!=?'! &'-'! &!>!! '(.!(!3:'3$)!(B! c0'3!<br />

03'('=!=!!%!+06=.'%!=0(6%:'=!$?$%!&'-'!A$($!'3'%3'(!!'>'3'5'=!-#!&!>!'(.'5'=.!(B!26!<br />

&!>! $3#! G$(3$=.#! ':0%7'=! -#! ='(G0%)$0=+$.! A$G$! >'('(3!! A'>3'(!%! )!'(!! '.!3:'+!!<br />

=03'73''5'=.!(B! T!5'=! &'-'3'()'! &'-'! A$($! '3'%3'(!! '(.!(!3'5'=! &!>! )D#5#=! =D:#+.#!<br />

5$-5$-! +#-$7#+$%#! 7'=!%! &'-'! +#7($! +'3'%'5'=.!(B! 3#($! 7'3'()'! '!(!! +!5'=.'!<br />

:'=+$:6:! '?!=3!=! -#! :'=+$:6:! 1'%3'! &!>'! G'=:'=+!>!%! &$++#)$3#%! !+!! +'3'%:'7'!<br />

?'3!!3:'3!)!(B! T0%! ?'(#! 03'('=! .'! +06.6563'(! )#-(#7#! +0=63'('=! 0@.$:6:! +#-$7#3#(!<br />

G636%'G$3$(B!<br />

$<br />

!<br />

L+@+$>(.($c(A1+.!3$<br />

\#(!%#=')'(!G$(!1'%!%!g[4[[[!:]_\!&'-'!?#=:#!='@'+$.#+$!03)66!G$3$%+#!)#!7#.#(3$!<br />

&'-'! A$($! '3'%!! 70=+'! 1'%)'%! :'=+$:6:! &'-'7!! +'3':'=! AD?3##5#=.$(B!<br />

\'-'3'%)!(:'! 7'@!3!(=#%! #:')'=$! 10(:63#! 67A6%! 03'('=! A$(#%! &'-'! :$=.'(!! .#+G$.!<br />

#)$3$@!$&.$7'?!)6763'%!&'-'!:$=.'(!!G6%'!AU(#!-#($3:#3$)$(B!<br />

C$(#%!\'-'!9$=.'(!!N\9Po!\'-'!C$($!;3'%!!NTP!|&!>!N8P!<br />

2$(!U(%#=!-#(#5#=!036(+'=!&'-'!A$($!'3'%!!V4d!9d!'?!3:!!03'%!G$(!=D:#+.#!.#=!1'%!%!<br />

+0%! )#-$(3#! ?'3!.!!%!! )DD%#3$:B! ?#($7#! A$(#%! &'-'! &!>!! )6-'(! A$($$%)#=$! '?!=3!'!<br />

! !N!


)$(#=! .6.63'('=! U3?D3)DD%)#!d^!H9_\!03+6%B!26!)6(6:)'Y! \9oT|8! \9o!V4d!|!<br />

d^4[[[!o!][4[[[!9]_\!7'%$!=D:#+#!G$(!+''..#!][4[[[!9]!&'-'!A$($$!03:'=.')!(B!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

$<br />

c(,()7)$L+@+-+,/!.)+$<br />

HD:#+.#=$! .0@3':! 5'%3!!'!(3!'! AU(#! :$%$:6:! &'-'3'%)!(:'! 7'@!3:'3!)!(B! #=$3)#!<br />

f[[!A(':!j;!03'%!G$(!+D(D)#!&'-'3'%)!(:'!&#+'G!%!!AU(:#=.#7$>B!f[[!C(':!j;!$?$%!<br />

[4^Wg!9]_\!&'-'!A#(#=3$)$(B![4f[[!|!d[4[[[!o!Ve4[[[!HA!j'B!<br />

Ve4[[[! |! [4^Wg! o! W^[g! 9]_\! &'-'7'! $&.$7'?! -'()!(B! 2$(! U%5#=$! 10(:63)#! ][4[[[!<br />

9]_\!&'-'!A$($$%$!G63:6.6=B!W4^[g_][4[[[!o!t!]V4Z!&'-'3'%)!(:'!7D>)#+$!03'('=!<br />

='(!:!>'! ?!=:'=.')!(B! X'%$! 1'%!%! ?'3!:'! +D(#+$! ]V4Z! +'%$7#4! )6(:'! +D(#+$! ef4]!<br />

+'%$7#)$(BTD(#=3$! ?'3!'%! 1'%3'()'! $+#! t! ]V4Z! )#-$(! )D>#7$%)#! 1'%! ?'3!.!(!3:'3!)!(B!<br />

k'3!:'!-#!)6(:'!+D(#3#($!=D:#+$%!GD7D=3DD%#!AU(#!='.3'(!!'3!%'('=!67A63'%'G$3$(B!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

$<br />

l(@':'%!%)'!'?!3:'+!B!3=!A#3$.#!=D:#+#!7#(3#$:!'3'%!!<br />

03'('=!=D:#+$%!7'(!+!!.#(5$&!#)$3:#3$)$(B!ebf!AD%!+0%('!=D:#+$%!.':':!!'?!3:'3!)!(B!<br />

>03'+70%! ! -#7'! !+!.:'! @(0G3#:$! -'(+'! $3=! A#3$.#! =D:#+$%! 7#(3#$:! '3'%!%!%! V_]ÉD!<br />

=633'%!3'G$3$(B!]bg!AD%)#!d_]ÉD!'?!3:'3!!V[bVd!AD%3D==#%!=D:#+$%!.':':!!'?!3:'3!)!(B!<br />

J$3$?3#(!9dÉ)#!][b]d!HA!5'%3!!'!(3!'!63'.!!%)'!+#7(#3.:#!-#7'!=#+$:#!AU%)#(:#!<br />

! !NC


)DD%D3:#3$)$(B!k#$.3$!D3=#3#()#!][!HC_9d!$3#!gV!HA_9d!j;!G'>!'3!%:'=.')!(B!2$>!<br />

#%! $7$! ('%)!:'%!!][b]d!HA_!9d!5'%3!!'!(3!=.'!=#+$:#!+#-=!#)$3)$$%)#! '3)!=!-#!G6!<br />

#=$3)#!67A63':'7'!)#-':!#.:#=.#7$>B!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

$<br />

"!A!!A-!A1+$<br />

j$-5$-3#(! )'(! '3'%)'! 7#.$.$($3)$$%)#! -#7'! =#+$:#! j;_9d! 7D=+#=! 03'('=!<br />

AU%)#($3)$$%)#!+!=!!=3!=3'!$3A$3$!03'('=!7''%'%!+0(6%3'(!Y!<br />

b!T.(#+!<br />

b!X#:!-#!+6!.D=#.$:$%)#!'>'3:'!<br />

b!\'-'3'%)!(:')'!AD?3D=!<br />

b!;3.3!=.'!':0%7'=!-#!%#:!<br />

b!CUD+.#!7'%:'!<br />

b!C#3$:#)#!A#($3$=!<br />

b!`%$10(:$.#)#!G0>63:'!<br />

b!X#:!)U%DD:D%)#!7D=+#3:#!<br />

b!8$('3!-#!2'=.#($7'3!#%1#=+$70%3'('!&'++'+$7#.B!<br />

!<br />

$<br />

%F.7573!=!<br />

=D:#+3#($%)#%! =636?='&'%#7#! =')'(4! 7#:! %'=3$4! 7#:! '('G'3'(!%!%! )#>#%1#=+$70%6!<br />

=D:#+3#($%! 7#.#(3$! .#:$>3$=! -#! )#>#%1#=+$70%64! A$($! -#! ?!=!3'(!%! =0%.(033D! 03:'+!4!<br />

1'(#!-#!GU5#=3#(#!='(!!A#(#=3$!$3'?!-#!67A63':'3'(!%!7'@!3:'+!!A$G$!U%3#:3#($!.#=('(!<br />

AU>)#%!A#?$(#(#=!=6('33'('!.':!03'('=!6763:'+!!A#(#=$(B!!<br />

d!b!::D%$.#%$%!AD?3D!03:'+!%!!+'3':'=B!<br />

2'!%)'%! G#($! '%3'.:!! 03)66:! G'3!=3'(3'! $3A$3$! =0633'(!%! 67A63'%:'+!! $3#! >'.#%!<br />

$::D%$.#%$%!AD?3D!03:'+!%'!='.=!)'!G636%:6!03670(6>B!;7(!5'!5$-5$-3#($%!=D:#+#!<br />

$3=! A#3$$%)#%! $.$G'(#%! $::D%$.#+$%$! A#3$.$($5$! -$.':$%4! @(0G$0.$=! -#! :$%#('33#($%!<br />

! !NH


67A6%! >':'%3'()'! -#($3:#+$%)#! GD7D=! 7'('(! AU()D=B! ]! b! n#Q5'+.3#4! #%1#=+$70>!<br />

G(0%$.$+! A$G$! -$('3! &'+.'3!=3'('! ='(!! '!3':'3'(!! 6>6%! +D(#)#%! G#($! +@(#7! 03'('=!<br />

67A63':'=.'7!>B!!!!!!!g!b!T'&')'!?0=!AU(D3#%!G'=.#(7'3!-#!)$#(!#%1#=+$70%3'(!%!+!=!!<br />

.'=$G$%$!7'@'('=!m>#33$=3#!j"c4!T'3:0%#33'4!R"K4!n#=(0.$=!#%.#($.$+!A$G$!&'+.'3!=3'('!<br />

='(!! $3'-#! =0(67656! '%.$G$70.=! @(0(':3'(!! 67A63':'=.'7!>B! ,7A6%! >':'%3'()'!<br />

0.0+$3#(! 7'@'('=! G6! &'+.'3!=3'(! AU(D3)DD%)#! 3'G0('.6-'(! $G$(3$$! $3#! .#)'-$! #)$5$!<br />

'%.$G$70.$=!67A63':'+!%)'!A#?!='3:')'%!:D)'&'3#!#.:#=.#7$>B!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

! !NJ


!<br />

" #!Z $D&5+9$B1$@&$b.O,-&.($b.&1()(,/&$>!/+$>O@&,-(($<br />

5..8)/'L"#()%&)@.10#$()A"'#)'&8)@$.81-#+)L$.7)5'$7)#.)5.$'3.!3:'+!!'?!+!%)'%!?0=!U%#:3$)$(B!,7A6%!@$$(:#!$3#!='%'.3!!='(='+!!<br />

D>#($%)#! G636%'%! G$(?0=! :$=(00(A'%$>:'! U3)D(D3:#3$)$(B! L.=$%! #$.$:! @(0A(':3'(!4!<br />

&'3=!%!G$3$%5$%$%!'(..!(!3:'+!%!!+'3':'3!!-#!)'&'!AD-#%3$!='%'.3!!D(D%3#($!D(#.$:$!$?$%!<br />

D(.$5$!-#!.D=#.$5$!#3!#3#!?'3!:'3!)!(B!<br />

!<br />

:;'1.+3'!<br />

'(.:'+!4! A#3$#%! .#=%030I$7#! G'3!! ?#-(#! =$(3$3$$4! #=0%0:$=! AD?+D>3D=! -#! #$.$:!<br />

7#.#(+$>3$$! G#+3#%:#! +0(6%3'(!%!! )#($%3#.$(:#=.#! -#! AD-#%3$! A!)'! .#:$%$%$!<br />

AD?3#.$(:#=.#)$(B!!C!)'!AD-#%3$$%$%!-#!='3$.#!AD-#%5#+$%$%!+'3'%:'+!!?'G'3'(!!)'!<br />

.D=#.$5$!-#!.0@36:!+'3!!!'?!+!%)'%!GD7D=!U%#:!.'!:'=.')!(B!!<br />

KD:! )D%7')'! $%+'%3'(!%! +'3!=3!! 03:'3'(!4! 7'':3'(!%!! -#! 1$>$=+#3! A#3$$:3#($%$!<br />

+D()D(#G$3:#3#($! $?$%! 7#.#(3$! :$=.'()'! -#! AD-#%3$! A!)'7!! '3'G$3:#3#($4! 7#.#(3$! -#!<br />

)#%A#3$!G#+3#%#G$3:#3#($!A#(#=$(B!26!A#(#=+$%$:$%!A!)'3'()'%!='(!3'%:'+!!'?!+!%)'%!<br />

AD-#%3$! -#! +'3!=3!! A!)'! D(#.$:$! -#! .D=#.$:$! )#! >0(6%36)6(B!H'%'.3!! -#! ='%'.3!!<br />

D(D%3#($%$%! $%+'%3'()'=$! A!)'! =U=#%3$! #%1#=+$70%3'(!%! G$(! ='7%'!! 03)66! )#1'3'(5'!<br />

AU+.#($3:$.$(B!KD:!)D%7')'!G$3)$($3#%!A!)'!='7%'=3!!+'3A!%3'()'=$!U%#:3$!'(.!4!A!)'!<br />

AD-#%3$$! =0%6+6%)'=$! )DD%5#3#($! )#$.$(:#=.#)$(B! 9#-56.! 7'+'3! )D>#%3#:#3#($%!<br />

! !NN


7#.#(+$>! 03)66! -#! G6! #%)D+.($%$%! =#%)$! D(#..$$! A!)'3'(!%! ='3$.#+$! -#! AD-#%3$$!<br />

=0%6+6%)'=$! +0(6:36366%6%! )'&'! GD7D=! 03)66%6! ='G63! #.:#+$! A#(#=.$$! '?!=?'!<br />

0(.'7'!?!=:!.!(B!!<br />

cD%7')'! +0%! 7$(:$G#!7!3! $?$%)#4! ?06%366! &'7-'%+'3! ! 03'%! -#! $%+'%! +'3!!! $?$%!<br />

5$))$! .#&)$.3#(! 036:6! -#! &'..'! G$%3#(5#! U3D:3#! +0%6?3'%'%! A!)'! ='7%'=3!! +0(6%3'(!<br />

7''%:!.!(B! 3=! 03'('=! VWfeB!<br />

m(%#$%4!2#3?$='!G63':'!=($>$%$4!.'-6=!7#:$%)#!<br />

='%'3$>'+70%! '.!=3'(!4! .'-6=! #.$%)#! GD7D:#! '(..!(!5!! &0(:0%! =633'%!:!! -#! .#)'-$!<br />

':'?3!!=633'%!3'%!'%.$G$70.$=!='3!%.!3'(!4!G$(?0=!$3'5'!='(!!)$(#%?!='>'%:!!T'3:#%#33'!<br />

N/'07.&"00') "&#"$%#%8%+) -#! /'07.&"00') #(,3%71$%17P4! ='7%'=3!! +0(6%3'(! ! $%+'%!<br />

+'3!!%'! 5$))$! .#&3$=#_.#&)$.! 7'('.'%3'()'%! G'>!3'(!)!(B! ! L%! +0%! 03'('=! =6! A($G$!<br />

E\^nV!#%1#=+$70%6F!-#!G6%'!G'3!!03'('=!,>'=)06!`3=#3#($!-#!D3=#:$>)#!AU(D3#%!<br />

U3D:3#(!#%!706%!.'(.!!3'%!=0%63'()'%!G$(!G'='+!!03:6.6(B!!<br />

C!)'3'()'%! ='7%'=3'%'%! G6! +'3!=! +0(6%3'(!4! U3D:! -'='3'(!! -#! @0.'%+$7#3! ($+=3#(!<br />

.D=#.$5$3#()#! A!)'3'('! ='(!! GD7D=! AD-#%+$>3$=! 7'('.:!.!(B! C#(?#=.#%! )#! A#?:$.#!<br />

7''%'%! A!)'! AD-#%3$$! +0(6%3'(!! $%5#3#%)$$%)#! &'7-'%+'3! D(D%3#(! ($+=3$! D(D%3#($%!<br />

G'!%)'! 7#(! '3:'=.')!(3'(B! T0%! 7''%'%! =6! A($G$! =($>$! )#! AU+.#(:$.$(! =$! ='%'.3!!<br />

.'(!:+'3! D(#.$:! -#! A!)'! >$%5$($%)#! $>3#%#G$3$(3$=! +$+.#:3#($%$%! .#+$+! #)$3:#+$! =($>! -#!<br />

($+=!7U%#.$:$!$3#!D(#.$:$%!+D()D(D3#G$3$(3$$4!='(3!3!!!-#!7'+'3!7D=D:3D3D=3#($!7#($%#!<br />

A#.$(:#+$!'?!+!%)'%!A#(#=3$)$(B!!<br />

!<br />

D&5+9$B1$$"&A1G.O,O,$>&-(()($<br />

%+'%! G#+3#%:#+$! '?!+!%)'%! U%#:3$! G$(! 7#(! .6.'%! &'7-'%+'3! @(0.#$%$%! .#:$%$%)#!<br />

+.('.#I$=!G$(!=0%6:'!+'&$@!03'%!='%'.3!!#.3#($4!+D(#=3$!A#($3#7#%!=!(:!>!!#.!D(#.$:$%)#%!<br />

)0'%!'?!!!='@'.:'!=0%6+6%)'!U>#3!G$(!U%#:#!.'!:'=.')!(B!!J$3$?!#.$!=!(:!>!!#.!$3#!<br />

='(!3'.!()!!%)'! G#+3#%:#! '?!+!%)'%! G$(! ! '-'%.'I'! +'&$@.$(! B! 8D56)6%! $&.$7'5!! 03'%!<br />

)#:$(!-#!?$%=0!A$G$!:$%#('33#(!$3#!-$.':$%3#(!N!2 d 4!2 e 4!2 Vd !P!@$3$?!#.$%)#!G03!:$=.'()'!<br />

-'()!(B!;7(!5'4!)07:':!!7'!'+$.!0('%!!=!(:!>!!#.#!AU(#!7D=+#=!03)66%)'%!='3@!-#!<br />

)':'(!&'+.'3'(!!?#=$%:#)#%!@$3$?!#.$%$!.#(5$&!#.:#3$)$(3#(B!!<br />

`3=#:$>)#! #.3$=! @$3$?! 7#.$.$($5$3$$%)#! =633'%!3'%! D(#.$:! .#=%030I$+$! +0%! )#(#5#!<br />

:0)#(%! 036@4! &'3$&'>!()'! D(#.$:$%! 7'=3'!=! t! f[!!<br />

#.! +#=.U(D%D%! A#($3#:#+$%)#%! )0'%! D(#.$:! '?!!%!%! ='@'.!3:'+!%!! +'3':!4! G6!<br />

+'7#)#! $.&'3'.'! )'! A#(#=! ='3:':!.!(BT#=.U(D%! GD7D:#! .(#%)$! +')#5#! VWWg! -#! d[[V!<br />

=($>!7!33'(!%)'!)DD!AU+.#(:$.$(B!<br />

T'3!=3!!-#!#=0%0:$=!@(0.#$%!='7%'!!03'%!G#7'>!#.!&#(!A#?#%!AD%!.D=#.$5$)#%!)'&'!<br />

1'>3'!.'3#@!AU(:#=.#)$(!2#7'>!#.!+#=.U(D%)#!AU>3#:3#%#%!G6!.#=%030I$=!7#%$3#%:#!-#!<br />

D(#.$:!+.'%)'(.3'(!%!%!7D=+#3.$3:#+$!+D(#5$%$!036:36!#.=$3#7#%!D?!.#:#3!6%+6(!-'()!(Y!<br />

! K#&3$=#!;%'3$>$!-#!H($.$=!H0%.(03!n0=.'3'(!!T$+.#:$!N\;jjJP!!<br />

! 7$!`(#.$:!,7A63':'+!!NC9JP!A$G$!636+3'('('+!!A!)'!AD-#%3$$!+$+.#:3#($%#!<br />

A#?$!<br />

! OTR! W[[V! H'3$.#! XU%#.$:! T$+.#:$! -#! OTR! Vg[[V! k#-(#! XU%#.$:!<br />

T$+.#:3#($


%+,+1-!$%+5,+A-!$?&*-(A&-&.$<br />

C!)'!='7%'=3!!.#&3$=#3#(!1$>$=+#34!=$:7'+'3!-#!:$=(0G$7030I$=!0($I$%3$!03:'=3'!G$(3$=.#4!<br />

&'3#%! ?0=! 7'7A!%! 03'('=! .'%!%'%!4! .D=#.$5$3#(! '?!+!%)'%! #%! GD7D=! ($+=$! 036.6('%!<br />

:$=(0G$7030I$=! A!)'! ='7%'=3!! .#&3$=#3#()$(B! O%+'%3'()'=$! A!)'! ='7%'=3!! &'+.'3!=3'(!%!<br />

)D%7')'=$!-'(3!!!+0%!G$(='?!7!3)'!)D>#%3$!03'('=!'(.:!.!(B!C#3$:#=.#!03'%!D3=#3#()#!<br />

&#(! 7!3! D?! :$370%)'%! 1'>3'! ?0566%! $+&'3)#%! )03'7!! U3)DD4! -#! ?0=! )'&'! 1'>3'+!%!%!<br />

$+&'3)#%! ='7%'=3'%'%4! G#+3#%:#! G0>6=366! -#! GD7D:#! A#($3$$%)#%! )03'7!! 03)6=?'!<br />

=U.D!)6(6:)'!03)66!G#3$(3#%:#=.#)$(B!O%+'%3'()'=$!='%'.3!3'(3'!$3A$3$!G6!&'+.'3!=3'(!%!<br />

7!33!=! :'3$7#.$%$%! fV[! :$370%! )03'()'! )'&'! 1'>3'! 03)66! .'&:$%! #)$3:#=.#)$(B!!<br />

K#&3$=#3#(4! D(#.$:! ':'5!73'! ='%'.3!3'(!%! GD7D.D3:#+$4! .'!%:'+!4! $3#%:#+$!<br />

@'=#.3#%:#+$4!)'!.!:!!-#!&'>!(3'%:'+!!+!('+!%)'!0(.'7'!?!=:'=.')!(B!<br />

!<br />

%+,+1-!$$%+5,+A-!$V+1FM&,-&.$$<br />

H'%'.3!3'(! 1'(=3!!A!)'! ='7%'=3!! @'.0I#%3#($! '3'G$3:#=.#)$(3#(B! T0%! 7!33'()'=$! G$(?0=!<br />

('@0(4! $%+'%3'()'=$! ='%'.3!3'(3'! G'3'%.!3!! G'=.#($7#3! &'+.'3!=3'(!%! #%! ?0=! AU(D3#%$!<br />

T'3:0%#33'!-#!j':@730G'5.#(!03)66%6!-6(A63':'=.')!(B!j30+.($)6:!@#(1($%A#%+!-#!<br />

i$+.#($'!.D(3#($!A$G$!)$#(!G$(?0=!:$=(00(A'%$>:'4!A!)'!>$%5$($%#!A$(#G$3:#=.#)$(B!!<br />

*;R_a\R! %6%! d[[d! ! 7!3!%)'! 7'7!%3')!!! ('@0(6%)'4! A!)'! ='7%'=3!! +'3A!%!<br />

&'+.'3!=3'(!%!tde:'3'(!%! )DD=! +6! '=.$-$.#+$4! +!5'=3!=4! @\! -+B! A$G$!<br />

036:+6>! ?#-(#! =0633'(!%'! )'7'%!=3!! 03:'3'(!%'! -#! .'-6=! A'$.'+!%)'! 7D=+#=! 0('%)'!<br />

G636%:'3'(!%'! G'3'%:'=.')!(BK'>#! 03'('=! -#7'! )0%)6(63)6=.'%! G$(! +D(#! +0%('!<br />

)#@03'%!@!+'.!'!+6%63'%!.'-6=!#.3#($%$%!&$I7#%$=!='3$.#+$!D>#($%#!#.=$3$!1'=.U(3#(!=#+$:!<br />

U%5#+$! -#! =#+$:! +0%('+!! 1'=.U(3#(! #=3$%)#! $=$! .#:#3! G'3!=! '3.!%)'! .0@3'%'G$3$(B!<br />

26%3'()'%!=#+$:!U%5#+$!1'=.U(3#(!'('+!%)'!G'(!%'=3'(!%!.#:$>3$=!=0633'(!4!&'7-'%3'(!%!<br />

.D=#..$=3#($!7#:!-#!+676%!=0%.':$%'+70%!)6(6:64!&'7-'%3'(!%!A#%#3!+'3!=!)6(6:6!<br />

-#! =#+$:&'%#7#! +#-=! #+%'+!%)'=$! =0633'(! #=3$%)#! +!('3'%!(=#%! =#+$:! +0%('+!!<br />

1'=.U(3#(! $+#! =#+$:! +!('+!%)'! 67A63'%'%! @(0+#+3#()#%! .D=#.$5$7#! 63'!%5'7'! =')'(=$!<br />

+D(#5$!$?#(:#=.#)$(B!<br />

K'-6=3'(! =#+$:&'%#7#! A#3)$=3#($%)#! .D73#(! -#! )#($4! ?#$.3$! :$=(00(A'%$>:'3'(3'!<br />

7D=+#=!0('%)'!=0%.':$%#!&'3)#)$(B!26!=0%.':$%'+70%4!=#+$:$%!)#$$=!'':'3'(!%)'!<br />

67A63'%'%!$3#:3#(3#!'(.'G$3#5#$!A$G$4!.#:'+!7D>#73#($4!7!=':'!+6764!@#(+0%#3!-+B!A$G$!<br />

$3#.:#%$%! 7#.#(+$>! &$I7#%! =0633'(!! %#)#%$73#! )#! '(.:'=.')!(B! 9#-56.! :$=(0130('!<br />

7#.#(+$>! +06.:'4! )0%)6(:'! -#! 67A6%+6>! )#@03':'! =0633'(!! +0%656%)'! )'&'! )'!<br />

?0'3'('=! &#:! D(D%D%! G0>63:'+!%'4! &#:! )#! &'3=! +'3!!%!%! ($+=#! A$(:#+$%#! +#G#@!<br />

03:'=.')!(B! H'%'.3!! #.3#($%$%! +'.!'! +6%63)66! 7#(3#()#! +06=! >$%5$(! $7$! +'3'%:'3!4!<br />

AU-)#!-#!@'(?'!#.3#($%!.D=#.$5$7#!+6%63)66!!<br />

7#(3#()#=$! -$.($%3#($%! .#:$>3$$! =03'74! (#=0%.':$%'+70%'! ='(!! =0(6%'=3!! 03:'+!!<br />

A#(#=:#=.#)$(!!B!kD%=D!@($:#(!=0%.':$%'+70%3'(!%#)#%$!$3#!036'%!:$=(0130('!7#.#($>!<br />

! !NW


+06.:'4! )0%)6(:'! -#! 67A6%+6>! )#@03':'! =0633'(!! +0%656%)'! )'&'! )'! ?0'3'('=!<br />

&#:!D(D%D%!G0>63:'+!%'4!&#:!)#!&'3=!+'3!!%!%!($+=#!A$(:#+$%#!+#G#@!03:'=.')!(B!<br />

`3=#:$>)#! .'-6=! #.$! D(#.$:$%$%! '(.:!! 03:'+!%'! ='(!%! =#+$:4! $3#:#4! )#@03':'! -#!<br />

+'.!!7#(3#($%$%!&$I7#%$=!='3$.#+$!$+.#%$3#%!)D>#7#!A#.$($3#:#:$.$(B!cD%7')'!.D=#.$3#%!<br />

='%'.3!! #.$! :$=.'(!%'!G'=!3)!!%)'4!G6!D(D%3#($%!D(#.$:$4!+'.!!! -#! .D=#.$:$! #+%'+!%)'!<br />

A#(#=#%!&$I7#%$=!-#!.#=%030I$=!=6('33'('!6763:')!!!.'=.$()#!G$(?0=!$%+'%!%!='%'.3!!#.$!<br />

-#!D(D%3#($%)#%!@'.0I#%!G63':'+!!($+=$!$3#!='(!!='(!7'!='3)!!!'%3':!%'!A#3:#=.#)$(B!<br />

26! %#)#%3#! .D=#.$3#%! ='%'.3!! #.3#($%$%! &$I7#%$=! ='3$.#+$! &'3=! +'3!!! G'=!:!%)'%! +0%!<br />

)#(#5#!U%#:3$!G$(!6%+6()6(B!!<br />

!<br />

:,1(;(5F1(A$%+-!,1!$k('A($<br />

H'%'.3!! 7#.$.$($5$3$$%)#! '%.$G$70.$=3#(4! &'+.'3!=3'(!%! +''3.!:!! -#! U%3#%:#+$4!<br />

A#3$:#%$%! &!>3'%)!(!3:'+!4! -#($:$%! -#! 7#:)#%! 7'('(3'%:'%!%! '(..!(!3:'+!! ':'5!73'!<br />

=633'%!3:'=.')!(B!*;R!('@0(3'(!%'!)'7'%'('=!='%'.3!3'(!%!tf[3'%)!(!5!! 03'('=! 6>6%! +D(#! )DD=! =0%+'%.('+70%3'()'! '%.$G$70.$=! =633'%!3:'+!%'!<br />

G'3!! 03'('=4! ='%'.3!! #.3#($%)#%! +!=3!=3'! $>03#! #)$3#%! #%.#($=! @'.0I#%! G'=.#($3#($%!<br />

$%+'%3'()'! =633'%!3'%! '%.$G$70.$=3#(#! ='(!! ?'@('>! )$(#%?! A#3$.$()$$! ?#$.3$! G$3$:+#3!<br />

?'3!:'3'(3'! 0(.'7'! =0%63:6.6(B! \'7-'%3'()'! $3'?! =633'%!:!! +U>! =0%6+6! 03)66!<br />

+D(#5#4! G6%3'()'%! +'3'%'%! A!)'3'()'! $3'?! ='3!%.!3'(!%!%! G636%:'+!! -#! )#$$=!<br />

)D>#73#()#! .D=#.$5$7#! A#?:#+$! ='?!%!3:'>! G$(! 03A6)6(B! C!)'! AD-#%3$$! ='@+':!%)'!<br />

)##(3#%)$($3)$$%)#4!&'3=!+'3!!!'?!+!%)'%!?#$.3$!($+=3#(!0(.'7'!?!='G$3:#=.#)$(B!<br />

cD%7'!'%.$G'=.#($7#3!$3'?!@'>'(!%!%!V[[B[[[!$3#!d[[B[[[!.0%!'('+!%)'!03)66!.'&:$%!<br />

#)$3:#=.#)$(B! 26%6%! t^[! =')'(!! -#.#($%#(! -#! .'(!:! '3'%!%)'! =633'%!3)!!!<br />

G#3$(3#%:$.$(BJ(01$3'=.$=!-#7'!A#3$:#7$!&!>3'%)!(!5!!03'('=!=633'%!3'%!'%.$G$70.$=3#($%!<br />

?064! $%+'%! -#! &'7-'%3'()'! @'.0I#%! G'=.#($! .D(3#($! N/#',3(0.-.--1+) '1$"1+Z)<br />

K+-3"$%-3%')-.0%Z)/'07.&"00')+,,GZ)6'7,(0.9'-#"$)+,,BP!'('+!%)'!0(.'7'!?!='%!)$(#%?3$!<br />

+63'(!%!&!>3'!'(.:'+!!%#)#%$73#!=633'%!:!U:(D%D!.':':3':'=!>0(6%)'!='3:!3'()!(B!<br />

H'3!%.!! 7U%D%)#%! '%.$G$70.$=3#($%! )$#(! 1'(:'=030I$=! #.=$3$! :'))#3#(#! AU(#! )'&'!<br />

U%#:3$! 03)66! G#3$(.$3:#=.#)$(B! 26%6%! %#)#%3#($4! &'7-'%3'('! U%AU(D3#%! )0>3'()'%!<br />

1'>3'!$3'?!-#($3:#+$!-#!U>#33$=3#!)#!$3'?!67A63'%'%!&'7-'%3'(!%!$3'5!%!7'+'3!G#=3#.:#!<br />

+D(#+$%#! 6763:')'%! =#+$:#! +#-=! #)$3:#+$! 03'('=! $1')#! #)$3:#=.#)$(B! 26%6%!<br />

+0%656%)'4! '%.$G$70.$=3#($%! .':':#%! :#.'G03$>#! 03:':'+!! -#7'! -D56..'%! .':':#%!<br />

'.!3:':'+!%'! G'3!! 03'('=4! &'7-'%3'(!%! )0=6! -#! 0(A'%3'(!! $3#! G6%3'()'%! #3)#! #)$3#%!<br />

&'7-'%+'3!A!)'3'()'!'%.$G$70.$=!='3!%.!+!!G636%'G$3:#=.#)$(B!!<br />

C!)'3'()'!.03#('%+!)D>#7$%$%!D>#($%)#!G636%'%!$3'?!='3!%.!3'(!!$%+'%!+'3!!!'?!+!%)'%!<br />

.#&3$=#3$! 036@4! GU73#! A!)'3'(!%! .D=#.$3:#:#+$! A#(#=:#=.#)$(B! C!)'3'()'! $3'?!<br />

='3!%.!3'(!%'! $3$=$%! :#->6'..'.03#('%+! )D>#73#($! ?$! )0=63'()'=$! )D>#73#($!<br />

AU+.#(:#=.#)$(B!26%6%3'!G$(3$=.#!#.4!+D.!-#!76:6(.'!A$G$!&'7-'%+'3!A!)'3'(!A#%#33$=3#!<br />

)#$$=! @$$(:#! $3#:3#($! 67A63'%)!=.'%! +0%('! .D=#.$3:#=.#)$(B! k#$.3$! '('.!(:'5!3'(!<br />

.'('1!%)'%4!G'.'!'%.$G$70.$=3#(!03:'=!D>#(#4!?#$.3$!$3'?!='3!%.!3'(!%!%!)#$$=!@$$(:#!<br />

$3#:3#($! -#! )#@03':'! +!('+!%)'! 7!=!:3'%'('=! #.=$+$>! :#.'G03$.3#($%#! )U%D#G$3)$$!<br />

G$3)$($3:$.$(!!<br />

!<br />

>!/+$>O@&,-(($<br />

CD%D:D>)#! #+=$! 6+63! A!)'! $3#:#! -#! .D=#.$5$7#! +6%:'! 7'=3'!:3'(!%)'! A#(#=!<br />

.D=#.$5$%$%!G$3$%?3#%:#+$4!A#(#=+#!D3=#3#($%!A!)'!7'+'3'(!%!!E)'&'!+'3!=3!!-#!AD-#%3$!<br />

A!)'!D(#.:#F!)0(63.6+6%)'!AD%5#33#:#3#($!%#)#%$73#!?0=!U%#:3$!)#$$:3#(!:#7)'%'!<br />

! !NZ


A#3:$!-#!A!)'!AD-#%3$$!=0%6+6!+0%!7!33'(!%!#%!U%#:3$!.0@36:+'3!=0%63'(!%!%!G'!%)'!<br />

7#($%$!'3:!.!(B!!<br />

C!)'! AD-#%3$$ho! |L! äC!)'! AD-#%3$$íhä! p! A!)')'! .D=#.$:! '%!%)'! -#7'! N.D=#.$5$!<br />

.'('1!%)'%! =633'%!3)!!%)'P! A!)'! ='7%'=3!! .#&3$=#3#($%! G636%:'+!! $3#! $3A$3$)$(B! C!)'!<br />

AD-#%3$$! .#&3$=#3#($%$%! A$($$! A!)'! >$%5$($%$%! &#(&'%A$! G$(! G'+':'!%)'! 0(.'7'!<br />

?!='G$3$(4! G6! %#)#%3#! )#! A!)'! >$%5$($! G076%5'! #.=$%! G$(! =0%.(03D%! A#(?#=3#.$($3:#+$!<br />

U%#:3$)$(B! c03'7!+!73'! A!)'! AD-#%3$$4! A!)'! >$%5$($%)#! 7#(! '3'%! .D:! G$($:3#($%!<br />

='.=!+!73'! +'3'%'%! G$(! 03A6)6(B! C!)'! AD-#%3$$4! A!)'3'()'! 03'G$3#5#=! 1$>$=+#34!<br />

=$:7'+'34! G$7030I$=! -#! &#(! .D(3D! >'('(3'(!%! G#(.'('1! #)$3:#+$! $?$%! '3!%'%! .#)G$(3#(!<br />

GD.D%D%D!$1')#!#)#(B!!<br />

C!)'! AD-#%3$$! ='-(':!%)'! Q,'+,$ '+-!!,+$ 9+.+.-!$ F-)+$ /7.7)7R! GD7D=! U%#:!<br />

.'!(B! $ 26! @(#%+$@! )D>#%3#:#3#(! )#! ä+'3!'! 67A6%ä! -#7'! ä$%+'%! +'3!!%'! >'('(3!ä!<br />

03'('=! $1')#! #)$3:#=.#)$(B! 2$(! A!)'! :'))#+$%$%! $%+'%! +'3!!%'! >'('(3!! 03:'+!!<br />

)6(6:6%)'h! 7#%$3)$$! >':'%! $%+'%! -D56)6%)'! &'+.'3!=! +#:@.0:3'(!! :#7)'%'!<br />

A#.$(:#+$4! :#-56.! G0>6=36=3'(!! '(..!(:'+!! A$G$! +0%6?.'! $%+'%! +'3!!%)'! %0(:'3!<br />

03:'7'%!)#$:#3#(!#=$33#%$(B!!2$(!G'='!)#7$3#!G$(!A!)'!:'))#+$%$%!+'3!'!>'('(3!!<br />

03:'+!4! 0%6%! )0(6)'%! )0(67'! 7#%$3#G$3#5#=! G$(! &Ñ3)#! -#7'! %0(:'3! :$=.'()'!<br />

7#%)$$%)#! &'+.'3!=! :#7)'%'! A#.$(:#+$! $3#! G#3$($(B! kD%=D! A!)'! :'))#+$%$%! %0(:'3!<br />

03:'7'%! #=$3)#4! ?$! 03'('=! 7#%:#+$! -#7'! 6+63D%#! 67A6%! 03'('=! &'>!(3'%:':'+!!<br />

)6(6:6%)'!036'G$3#5#=!+#:@.0:3'(!+'3!'!>'('(3!!+'7!3:'>B!26%6%!A$G$!%0(:'3)#%!<br />

?0=!1'>3'!7#%:#+$!+0%656%)'!('&'.+!>3!=!)6763:'+!!0!A!)'!:'))#+$%$%!+'3!'!>'('(3!!<br />

03)66%'!$'(#.!#.:#>B!!<br />

C!)'%!%!$%+'%!+'3!!%!!#.=$3#:#7#5#=4!?#-(#!+0(6%3'(!!7'('.:'7'5'=!0(.':3'()'!#3)#!<br />

#)$3:#+$4! $3#%:#+$! -#! =0(6%:'+!! A#(#=$(B! C#%#3! 03'('=4! 636+3'('('+!! @3'.10(:3'()'4!<br />

D>#($%)#!6>3'!3:!!-#!='G63!#)$3:$!G$(!=6(636!.'('1!%)'%!0%'73'%:!4!'+A'($!.#=%$=!<br />

-#! +'3!=! =($.#(3#($%$! $?#(#%! D(D%3#(! 6O@&,-($ 03'('=! ='G63! #)$3$(B! CD%D:D>)#!<br />

#%)D+.($3#:#! -#! =$.3#+#3! D(#.$:4! )'&'! 6>6%! -#! )'&'! =0:@3#=+! A!)'! >$%5$(3#($%$%!<br />

0366:64!1'+.b100)!.D=#.$:$4!+0='=!+'.!5!3'(!4!$&('?!'(.!!!A!)'3'(!-#!636+3'('('+!!.$5'(#.!<br />

-#!.6($>:!$3$=$3#($%)#=$!'(.!!A$G$!%#)#%3#(!+0%656%)'!A!)'!AD-#%3$$%$!#.=$3#7#%!@#=!<br />

?0=!.#&3$=#!036:'=.')!(B!<br />

C!)'!AD-#%3$$4!A!)'3'(!%!.D=#.$:!$?$%!67A6%366!-#!.D=#.$5$3#($%!A!)'!='7%'=3!!+'3!=!<br />

($+=3#($%#! ='(!! =0(6%:'+!)!(B! C!)'! AD-#%3$$%$! #.=$3#7#%! .D:! .#&3$=#3#(4! G$7030I$=4!<br />

=$:7'+'34! 1$>$=+#3! G63':'3'()'%! -#! D(#.$:! +!('+!%)'=$! G'>!! &'.'3!! 67A63':'3'()'%!<br />

='7%'=3'%:'=.')!(B!26!%#)#%3#!EA!)'!AD-#%3$$F!A!)'!>$%5$($%)#!AU(#-!'3'%!&#(=#+$%!<br />

D>#($%#! )D#%! +0(6:36366! 7#($%#! A#.$(:#+$73#! +'3'%'G$3$(B! C!)'! AD-#%3$$! -#!<br />

='3$.#+$4! A!)'! #%)D+.($+$%)#! A!)'! AD-#%3$$! -#! ='3$.#! @(0A(':3'(!! 67A63'%'('=!<br />

)D>#%3#%#G$3$(B!<br />

!<br />

>!/+$6O@&,-(($A+-(1&$5G,&1()$'1+,/+.1-+.!!<br />

?$%)#! G636%)66:6>! 7D>7!3)'! $%+'%3'(! A!)'! +'3!=!AD-#%3$$! -#! ! ='3$.#+$%#! A$)#(#=!<br />

)'&'! )'! '(.'%! )D>#7)#! U%#:! -#($(! 03:63'()!(B! ;(.!=! .D=#.$5$3#(! +D@#(:'(=#..#%!<br />

'3)!=3'(!! -#7'! (#+.0('%3'()'! .D=#..$=3#($! A!)'3'(!%! G#3$(3$! +.'%)'(.3'()'! D(#.$3:$!<br />

03:'+!%'! )$=='.! #.:#=.#)$(3#(B! T'3!=! #%)$#+$%#! #=! 03'('=! .D=#.$5$3#(4! .D=#..$=3#($!<br />

A!)'3'(!%! ='3$.#+$%#! )#! 0)'=3'%:'7'! G'3':!3'()!(B! ;(.!=! .D=#.$5$3#(! D(#.$5$3#()#%4!<br />

A!)'! 1$(:'3'(!%)'%! -#! @#('=#%)#5$3#()#%! :D:=D%! 03'%! #%! 7D=+#=! ='3$.#7$! .'3#@!<br />

#.:#=.#)$(3#(B!C!)'!AD-#%3$$!=0%6+6%)'!.D=#.$5$3#($%!+'&$@!03)66!&'=3'(!$+#!+D(#=3$!<br />

03'('=! 7#.#(3$! A!)'7'! #($:#4! AD-#%3$! A!)'4! A!)'! D(D%3#($%#! $3$=$%! G$3A$3#%:#4!<br />

G#+3#%:#! =0%6+6%)'! .D=#.$5$! #$.$:$4! A!)'! ='7%'=3'(!! -#! G#+3#%:#! $?$%! +'3!=3!! G$(!<br />

?#-(#)#! 7'':'! -#! A!)'! D(D%3#($%#! $3$=$%! +0(6%3'(!! )676(:'! &'==!! 03'('=!<br />

+!('3'%'G$3$(B!C!)'!='3$.#+$%$%!.#+$+$!$?$%!67A63'%'%!='%6%4!.D>D=!-#!7U%#.:#3$=3#(!A!)'!<br />

! !N]


:#->6'.!! 03'('=! .'%!:3'%:'=.')!(B! C!)'3'(!%! D(D%! AD-#%3$$%$! +'3'7'%! ='3$.#!<br />

U>#33$=3#($h! +'3!=3!! 03:'4! G#+3#7$5$! 03:'4! 10%=+$70%#3! U>#33$=3#(! -#! 6>6%! ('1! U:(D!<br />

03'('=!+!('3'%:'=.')!(B!C!)'!AD-#%3$$!-#!='3$.#!'3'%!%)'!G$(?0=!636+'3!-#!636+3'('('+!!<br />

+.'%)'(.!+U>!=0%6+6)6(B!26%3'(!'('+!%)'!OTR!W[[V4!OTR!dd[[[4!OTR!VZ[d^4!!2"j!-#!<br />

O*T!!+'7!3'G$3$(B!,36+3'('('+!!A!)'!+.'%)'(.3'(!%!%!.#:#3!'3)!!!\;jjJ!-#!>3#%#G$3$(3$=!<br />

67A63':'3'(!!'!(3!=!='>'%:'=.')!(Y!<br />

!<br />

9-&,&;(-(.-(A$Q?.+3#%#G$3$(3$=! En$"#%7Z) %0"7") C") ,'>'$0'7') %0") %02%0%) +F$"-%&) 3"$) ''7'+!&8'Z) 2!8')<br />

7'88"+%&")#($%)#! AU+.#($3:#+$! 7#(! )'(3!!!<br />

%#)#%$73#! :D:=D%! 03':')!!%)'%!D(D%!&'==!%)'! +'3'%'%! G$3A$3#($%! .':! '%3':!73'!<br />

7#.#(3$!03)66!+U73#%#:#>B!<br />

C!)'! $>3#%#G$3$(3$$! A!)'! AD-#%3$$%$%! +'3'%:'+!%)'! #%! .#:#3! '('?3'()'%! G$($! 036@!<br />

&#(&'%A$!G$(!$+.#%:#7#%!)6(6:!036.66%)'!D(D%!-#!+D(#?3#($!A#($7#!)0(6!$>3#7#(#=!<br />

+0(6%!='7%'!%!%!+'@.'%:'+!%!h!$3#($7#!)0(6!$>3#7#(#=!A#($!.0@3':'!A$G$!=($>!7U%#.$:!<br />

:#='%$>:'3'(!! $?$%! A#(#=3$! G$3A$! +$+.#:$%$%! =6(63:'+!%!! &#)#13#7#%! G$(! 7'=3'!:)!(B!<br />

C!)'!.#)'($=!>$%5$($%)#!$3=!D(#.$:)#%!.D=#.$5$7#!=')'(!$>3#%#G$3$(3$=!-#!=($>!7U%#.$:$!<br />

+$+.#:3#($%$%! .#+$+! #)$3:#+$4! G'.'! ;-(6@'! 2$(3$$! 03:'=! D>#(#4! ;2c4! H'%')'4!<br />

w'@0%7'! -#! ;-6+.('37'! -#! KD(=$7#! )#! )'&$3! G$(?0=! D3=#)#! 7'+'3! )D>#%3#:#! '3.!%'!<br />

'3!%:!.!(B!!<br />

;%5'=! A!)'! $>3#%#G$3$(3$$%$%! .#+$+$4! >$%5$($%! ?0=! =0:@3#=+! 7'@!+!! -#! )'&'+!! G'>!!<br />

+#=.U(#3!+0(6%3'(!!%#)#%$73#!A#3#%#=+#3!7U%.#:3#(!-#!:#-56.!'3.7'@!3'(3'!&#)#13#%#%!<br />

':'?3'('! 63'!3'G$3:#+$! ?0=! AD?! AU>D=:#=.#)$(B! X'+'3'(3'! &#)#13#%#%! $>3#%#G$3$(3$=4!<br />

A#3#%#=+#3! N='!.! .'G'%3!P! +$+.#:3#(! 7#($%#! .D:! >$%5$(! G076%5'! &#(&'%A$! G$(! =!(!3:'!<br />

03:')'%! ?'3!:'7!! A'('%.$! '3.!%'! '3'%! #3#=.(0%$=! .'G'%3!! G$3A$! +$+.#:3#($! -#!<br />

.#=%030I$3#($%$%! =633'%!3:'+!! $3#! +'3'%'G$3$(B! CD%D:D>)#! &!>3'! G6! .D(! +$+.#:3#(!<br />

A#3$.$($3:#7#! ?'3!!3:'=.'4! '%5'=! &#%D>! .':! '%3':!73'! #.=$%4! .D:3#$=! -#! G#33$!<br />

+.'%)'(.3'('! )'7'3!! G$(! $3#7$.#%! 6>'=.'! G636%63:'=.')!(B! C!)'! $>3#%#G$3$(3$$!<br />

+$+.#:3#($%$%! G6! %#)#%3#! D(D%3#(! G'>!%)'! ='@+':3!5'! '('.!(!3:'+!! -#! +.'%)'(.3'(!%!<br />

G#3$(3#%:#+$!A#(#=3$)$(B!!<br />

C!)'!AD-#%3$$%)#! .D=#.$5$%$%! =0%.(03! :#='%$>:'+!%'! )Ñ&$3! #)$3:#)$$! $>3#%#G$3$(3$=!<br />

7'=3'!:3'(!73'! $)#'3! -#7'! $)#'3#! 7'=!%! )D>#7)#! $>3#%#G$3$(3$=! +'3':'=! 03)6=?'!<br />

AD?.D(B! 6! '%)'! )D%7'! D3=#3#($%$%! &#:#%! &#@+$%)#! 7D(D(3D=.#! 03'%! 7'+'3'()'!<br />

$>3#%#G$3$(3$=!+$+.#:3#($%$%!.D=#.$5$!$+.#$!$3#!$>3#%#G$3$(!03:'+!%!!+'3'7'5'=!&#(&'%A$!<br />

G$(! '?!=! .'%!:! +U>! =0%6+6! )#$3)$(B! `3=#3#($%! &#:#%! &#@+$%)#! A!)'! AD-#%3$$! $3#!<br />

7'+'3'()'!$>3#%#G$3$(3$=!'=.$1!03:'=.'%!>$7')#!@(0'=.$1!7'=3'!:3'(3'!$%'!#)$3:$3#()$(B!<br />

26%'! ='(!%! w'@0%7'! .D=#.$5$! 7U%#3$:3$! $>3#%#G$3$(3$$! 7D=+#=! U%5#3$=3$! 03'('=!<br />

67A63':'7'!?'3!'%!.#=!D3=#!)6(6:6%)')!(B!<br />

>3#%#G$3$(3$=!#+'+!03'('=!\;jjJ!A!)'!AD-#%3$=!+$+.#:$%$%!A#(#=3$3$=3#($%$!)'&'!#.=$%!<br />

7#($%#! A#.$(:#=! D>#(#! 036.6(63:6! G$(! 7U%.#:)$(B! H'3$.#! -#! A!)'! AD-#%3$$!<br />

! !T#


+.'%)'(.3'(!%!! ='(!3':'=! $?$%! $>3#%#G$3$(3$$%! +'3'%:'+!%)'! )$=#7! =00()$%'+70%'!<br />

A#(#=!)6763:'=.')!(B!26!=00()$%'+70%!)'!A!)'!AD-#%3$=!+$+.#:3#($%)#!G'&+#)$3:#7#!<br />

G'3'%'%! E.'(3')'%! +01('7'FN1'(:! .0! .'G3#_10(=P! .#($:$! 67A63':'3'(!! $3#!<br />

A#(?#=3#:#=.#)$(B! >3#%#G$3$(3$=! ='@+':!%)'! EAD-#%3$! A!)'F4! G$($%5$3! D(#.$:!<br />

'':'+!%)'%! G'3'7'('=! ?$1.3$=.#%! +01('7'4! .D=#.$5$7#! 63''%'! =')'(! ! A#?#%! +D(#)#!<br />

1$>$=+#34! =$:7'+'3! -#! G$7030I$=! ($+=3#($! .'!:'7'%! A!)')!(B! >3#%#G$3$(3$=! U>D%)#! G$(!<br />

E='7!.!.6.:'F!>0(6%36366!036@4!G6!+D(#?.#=$!A!)'!>$%5$($!'':'3'(!%)'!#.=$%!=0%.(03D!<br />

+'3'(B!<br />

$<br />

"F,7_!<br />

2#7'>! #.! D(#.$:$%)#! ?$1.3$=.#%! +01('7'! A!)'! AD-#%3$$%$%! ?0=! U%#:3$! 03)66!VWf[3!=3'(b7#%$! &'+.'3!=3'(4! G$70.#(U($>:! .#&)$.3#($! -#! A!)'!<br />

AD-#%3$$! =0%6+6%)'=$! #%)$#3#(! '!3:'+!! $?$%! C9J4! \;jjJ! -#! A!)'! AD-#%3$$!<br />

+.'%)'(.3'(!!U%#:3$!AD-#%5#3#(!03'G$3$(B!26!G'=!:)'%!A!)'!>$%5$($%$%!G'3'%A!?!%0=.'+!!<br />

03'%!7#:!1'G($='3'(!!.':!)0%'%!:3!!:0)#(%!.#=%030I$7#!+'&$@!3'G0('.6-'(3'(!=6('('=!<br />

&'::'))#! -#! D(D%! AD-#%3$$%$! )'&'! $3=! G'.'%! #3#! '3:'3!4! C9J! -#! \;jjJ! A$G$!<br />

+.'%)'(.3'(!! D(#.$:! &'.3'(!%'! ')'@.#! #)#(#=! ='3$.#! ?!.'+!%!! 7D=+#3.:#3$4! &!>3!! 67'(!!<br />

+$+.#:$!N('@$)!'3#(.!+7+.#:P!-#!#(=#%!67'(!!+$+.#:$!N#'(37!'3#(.!+7+.#:P!A$G$!A#3$:$!<br />

G$3A$+'7'(! 67'(!!'3'(!! $3#! 7''%:'+!! 03'+!! 03''%)!!! G$(! )6(6:'! '%!%)'! :D)'&'3#!<br />

#)#G$3:#!03'%'!%'!+'&$@!G636%:'3!)!(B!!<br />

C#3#5#=.#=$! ?'G'3'(4! .#:#3)#! '7%!! ='3'5'=! -#! 5'%3!! @$3$?3#()#! #%1#=+$70%6%!<br />

U%3#%:#+$%$4! $7$3#.$($3:$! .'=$@! @(0A(':3'(!%!%! A#3$.$($3:#+$%$! -#! &!>3!! .#+@$.!<br />

7U%.#:3#($%$! $?#(#5#=.$(B! ,>6%! )U%#:)#4! ='%'.3!! A!)'! ='7%'=3!! @'.0I#%3#($%!<br />

=030%$>'+70%6%6!)#%A#3#7#%!A#%0.$@3#(!=0%6+6%)'=$!A#3$:#3#(!:#7)'%'!A#3#5#=.$(B!<br />

;7(!5'!$3#:#!.#=%$=3#($%)#=$!036:36!A#3$:#3#(!'('5!3!!!$3#!$3#:#!+!('+!%)'!?'@('>!<br />

G63':'7!! U%3#:#=! $?$%! A#(#=#%! 7U%.#:3#(! .'=$@! #)$3#5#=.$(B! ! k$1.3$=.#%! ?'.'3'! A!)'!<br />

AD-#%3$$! @(0A(':!%!%! G''(!+!! ?$1.3$=.#=$! -#! $3#:#! .#+$+$%)#=$! @#(+0%#3! .'('1!%)'%!<br />

67A63'%'%!&$I7#%!+.'%)'(.3'(!%'!G'3!)!(B!!<br />

k$1.3$=.#%! p! ?'.'3'! ! +$+.#:$%)#4! A!)'3'(3'! $3#:#! +0%('+!! )U%#:4! A!)'! ='7%'=3!!<br />

#%1#=+$70%3'(!%!'>'3.!3:'+!!'?!+!%)'%!?0=!U%#:3$)$(B!,7A6%!@$$(:#!$3#!='%'.3!!='(='+!!<br />

D>#($%)#! G636%'%! G$(?0=! :$=(00(A'%$>:'! U3)D(D3:#3$)$(B! 26%6%3'! G$(3$=.#4!<br />

@$$($3:#7#%!-#7'!!+!.!3:'7'%!)$#(!A!)'3'()'=$!?'@('>!G63':'!AD-#%3$!03:'7'%!A!)'!<br />

$3#.:#)#!@(0G3#:3#($%!0(.'7'!?!=:'+!%'!)#+.#=!03:'=.')!(B!L.=$%!#$.$:!@(0A(':3'(!4!<br />

&'3=!%!G$3$%5$%$%!'(..!(!3:'+!%!!+'3':'3!!-#!)'&'!1'>3'!7$7#5#=!:'))#+$%$%!:$=(0G$7'3!<br />

G63':'7'!='(!!=0(%:'+!!$?$%!A#(#=3$!U3?D:3#(!7'@!3:'3!)!(B!!<br />

T0%6?!03'('=4!=0%6!$3#!$3A$3$!7'+'3'(4!AD-#%3$!A!)'!D(#.$:$%$!+'3':'=!'?!+!%)'%!'+3'!<br />

7#.#(3$! 03:'7'5'=.!(B! ;%5'=! #%)D+.($%$%! )#! D(#.$5$)#%! @#('=#%)#5$7#! =')'(! D(D%D%!<br />

AD-#%3$$%$!+'3':'!=0%6+6%)'!G$(!+0(6:36366!-'()!(B!<br />

!<br />

%+5,+A-+.$<br />

;%0%$:4!d[[VB!H'%'.3!!#.3#($!-#!A!)'!AD-#%3$$!!H'%'.3!!;"bCL!X'7!%3'(!!]!K#::6>!d[[V!2036B!<br />

;(!=G'74!jB!Nd[[VPB!C!)'!CD-#%3$$%)#!T$+.#:!X'=3'!:!!N\;jjJP!T#:$%#($bc#(+!n0.3'(!B!;%='('Y!9$33$!<br />

J(0)D=.$-$.#!9#(=#>$B!<br />

;(!=G'74!jB!Nd[[dPB!C!)'!CD-#%3$$%)#!T$+.#:!X'=3'!:!Y!\;jjJ4!QA@AS)J&'3#'$4!V^f4!gb^B!<br />

2'='7'!"4!H#+=$%!X4!H'('A0>!;4!H05!\OB!2$70AD-#%3$=B!K;*!J(#-#%.$-#!9#)$5$%#!2633#.$%!d[[Wh!fY!VZZb<br />

VfeB!<br />

j'%4\BXB4k#3$=4! KB\BY! H'%'.3!! &'7-'%! 7#.$.$($5$3$$%)#! '%.$G$70.$=! =633'%!:!! -#! ='3!%.!! ($+=$4! 8#.! \#=$:!<br />

c#(!c#(A4!ZWNgPY!]^bg[4!d[[f!<br />

j#G#5$4! lB4! 20'4! 9BY! B! J$3$?! L.$! l$%5$($%)#! 2$(! j0('1$! >3#%#G$3$(3$=! ,7A63':'+!4! ;=')#:$=! 2$3$$:!<br />

H0%1#('%+!4!6G'.!d[[W4!\'(('%!`%$-B4!B,(1'!!<br />

! !T!


j#G#5$4! lBY! ! C!)'! >3#%#G$3$(3$$%)#! 2$3A$! K#=%030I$3#($B! P01+'0) ;'$!7) :1$10#'(!Z) V^bVZ! H'+!:! d[[e4!<br />

k6=6(0-'!`%$-#(+$.#+$4!;)'%'B!2$3)$($3#(!+B!VfWbVW^B!<br />

j$-'%!LB4!m>#(!LB4!E\'7-'%+'3!C!)'!`(#.#%!3#:#3#()#!\$I7#%!H6('33'(!F4!8#.#($%'($6:4!H0%7'!\'7-'%!<br />

\'+.'3!=3'(!!;('.!(:'!L%+.$.D+D!X'7!%!4!j$3.!Y!g4!T'7!!Y!V4!R5'=b\'>$('%!VWW]4!d^bdfB!<br />

k0G'%036! *B! 4H0%'=! HB! 420>=6(.! 9B! 4KD(=$7#! L.3$=! J$3$?! T#=.U(D%D%! 9#-56.! c6(6:6! -#! cD%7'!<br />

C#%#3$%)#=$!C#3$:#3#(!4;=)#%$>!`%$-#(+$.#+$!l$(''.!*'=D3.#+$!c#(A$+$!d[[g!B4Ve!4d!4VdZbV]]B!<br />

c


" #!] $%+,+1-!$B1($%+-(1&'(,&$B1A($B/&,$a+A1G.-&.$<br />

5'-#.$+)JLL"-#%&2)@.10#$()A"'#)m1'0%#(!<br />

!<br />

9BwB!c6530+4!jB!2#(($!<br />

On";!,"[f]!"#5&#(5&#+!;-$503#+4!*b]Z]f[4!n06>$337B!<br />

!<br />

89&1$$<br />

26!.#G3$4!='%'.3!!#.$!='3$.#!@'(':#.(#3#($!$3#!$3A$3$!:#-56.!G$3A$3#($!U>#.3#:#=.#4!'%5'=!<br />

G$(! G'='! .#G3$)#! #3#! '3!%'5'=! 03'%! =0%6%6%! &$I7#%! G076.6%6! &'($?! .6.:'=.')!(B!<br />

K#G3$4! #.! ='3$.#+$%$%! G#+$%4! 0(A'%03#@.$=! -#! .#=%030I$=! @'(':#.(#3#($%$%! .'%!:!! $3#!<br />

='+!%! #.#! )U%DD:! $3#:$%$%! G$7030I$=! .#:#33#($%$%! -#! G6%6%! #.! ='3$.#+$! D>#($%)#=$!<br />

#.=$+$%$%! &'.!(3'.!3:'+!! $3#! G'3':'=.')!(B! 3#(3#7#%! =!+!:3'()'! G$(! *('%+!>! G(073#(! #.!<br />

D(#.$:! .#+$+$%)#! A#(?#=3#.$($3#%! G$(! +6(-#7)#%! #3)#! #)$3#%! G$3A$3#(! 7#(! '3:'=.')!(B!<br />

i$.#('.D()#! 7#(! '3'%! )#%#7+#3! G$3A$3#(#! -#7'! On";! ;-$'%! ;('.!(:'! 2$($:$%)#!<br />

A#(?#=3#.$($3#%! )#%#73#()#%! #3)#! #)$3#%! -#($3#(#! )'7'3!! 03'('=! #.! ='3$.#+$%)#!<br />

)#$$=3$#! 703! '?'%! 1'=.U(3#(! )#! .#G3$! $?$%)#! AU>)#%! A#?$($3:#=.#)$(B! n#.$5#)#4!<br />

GD7D:#! -#! 7#:)#%! 7'('(3'%:'! 0('%!%)'! $7$3#:#! $3#! G$(3$=.#! G(073#(! D(#.$:!<br />

@3'%3'(!%)'=$! +D(#=3$! A#3$$:$%! ='%'.3!! #.! ='3$.#+$! D>#($%)#! 036:+6>! G$(! #.=$!<br />

7'('.:')!!! +0%656%'! -'(!3:'=.')!(B! ;%5'=! #%)D+.($7#3! '(.3'(! '3.!%)'! ?0=! 1'>3'!<br />

)#$=#%3$=3#($%!:#-56.!03)66!AU>3#%:$!036@!G6!)#$=#%3#($%!+U>!=0%6+6!D(#.$:$%!<br />

+D()D(D3#G$3$(3$$%)#! $3#(3#:#! ='7)#)#G$3:#=! '?!+!%)'%! '>'3.!3:'+!! A#(#=:#=.#)$(B!<br />

H'%'.3!! >$%5$($%)#! )#$$=! '=.U(3#($! )#! ='@+'7'%! A30G'3! G$(! 7'=3'!:!%! )$=='.#!<br />

'3!%:'+!! A#(#=:#=.#)$(B! c#-':! #.:#=.#! 03'%! '('.!(:'3'(4! A#3$:$! A#%#.$=! -#7'!<br />

G#+3#:#! +.('.#I$3#($%$! 0(.'7'! =07:'=! +6(#.$73#! =0%67'! U%#:3$! U3?D)#! ='.=!!<br />

+'3'7'5'=.!(B!!<br />

$<br />

:;'1.+#+! .&#! '-'$3'G3#! =%0Q3#)A#! 0%! @063.(7! :#'.! S6'3$.7!<br />

@'(':#.#(+4!#M536)$%A!+'%$.'(7!'+@#5.+4!Q&$5&!Q$33!G#!.(#'.#)!$%!'!+#@'('.#!@'@#(B!K&#!<br />

@'@#(!+.'(.+!Q$.&!)#1$%$.$0%+!01!%6.($.$0%'34!0(A'%03#@.$5!'%)!.#5&%030A$5'3!@'(':#.#(+!<br />

01!:#'.!S6'3$.7!'%)!'!(#:$%)#(!01!.&#!G$030A$5'3!G'+$+!01!.&#!@(05#++!01!:6+53#!.0!:#'.!<br />

.('%+10(:'.$0%! '%)! $.+! $:@'5.! 0%! :#'.! S6'3$.7B! c'.'! 0G.'$%#)! )6($%A! '! +6(-#7! 01!<br />

*(#%5&!G(0$3#(!:#'.!@(0)65.$0%!@3'%.+!'(#!.&#%!@(#+#%.#)B!K&#!1'5.0(+!Q&$5&!'3.#(!:#'.!<br />

S6'3$.7! '(#! .&#%! (#-$#Q#)! G'+#)! 0%! #M@#($:#%.'3! )'.'! 5033#5.#)! $%! .&#! 3$.#('.6(#! 0(!<br />

1(0:!#M@#($:#%.+!50%)65.#)!'.!On";!;-$'%!"#+#'(5&!,%$.B!O.!$+!50%536)#)!.&'.!.&#!<br />

50%.$%606+! $:@(0-#:#%.! 01!G(0$3#(! @(0)65.$0%! +5&#:#+4! Q$.&! $:@(0-#)! A(0Q.&! ('.#!<br />

'%)!1##)!#11$5$#%574!&'+!%0.!&')!'!)#.($:#%.'3!#11#5.!0%!@063.(7!:#'.!S6'3$.7B!;!3'(A#!<br />

-'($'G$3$.7!$+!&0Q#-#(!0G+#(-#)!6%)#(!$%)6+.($'3!50%)$.$0%+4!Q&$5&!:6+.!G#!(#)65#)!.0!<br />

$:@(0-#!.&#!+6+.'$%'G$3$.7!01!.&$+!@(0)65.$0%B!;!A30G'3!'@@(0'5&!:6+.!G#!50%+$)#(#)!<br />

$:@37$%A!.&#!)$11#(#%.! '5.0(+!$%! .&#! @063.(7!5&'$%B!R%A0$%A!(#+#'(5&! Q$33! 50%.($G6.#!<br />

%0.'G37!G7!+6AA#+.$%A!$:@(0-#)!A#%#.$5!0(!%6.($.$0%'3!+.('.#A$#+B!<br />

$<br />

>(.($<br />

26!.#G3$4!='%'.3!!#.$!='3$.#!@'(':#.(#3#($!$3#!$3A$3$!:#-56.!G$3A$3#($!U>#.3#:#=.#4!'%5'=!<br />

G$(! G'='! .#G3$)#! #3#! '3!%'5'=! 03'%! =0%6%6%! &$I7#%! G076.6%6! &'($?! .6.:'=.')!(B!<br />

9#-56.! ?'3!:'! U%5#3$=3$! 03'('=! *('%+'


?0=!A#%$!G$(!D(D%! 7#3@'>#+$%$! -#! 7D=+#=! +.'%)'(..'! #%)D+.($7#3! G(073#(!D(#.$:$%)#%!<br />

'3.#(%'.$1! D(#.$:#! N'?!=! '3'%! G#+3#:#! 4! 0(A'%$=4! -GBP! ! =')'(! 1'(=3!! .D(! -#! D(#.$:!<br />

:0)#33#($%$! ='@+':'=.')!(B! 9#-56.! A#%#3! #$3$:! @'(?'! -#! $3#($! $3#:#! D(D%3#($%)#!<br />

'(.!'! A$.:#=! 7U%D%)#)$(B! TU>! =0%6+6! 1'(=3!! )6(6:3'(! $?$%! '7%!! ='3$.#! @'(':#.(#3#($!<br />

67A63'%'G$3#5#=! 03+'! )'! G6%3'(!%! $3A$3$! #.=$3#($! GD7D=! U3?D)#! 1'(=3!3!=! AU+.#(#5#=.$(B!<br />

9'='3#4! G'>!! .'%!:3':'3'(! $3#! G'3'7'5'=! 036@! )#-':!%)'! #.! ='3$.#+$! U>#33$=3#($%$%!<br />

'3.!%)'! 7'.'%! G$7030I$=! :#='%$>:'! $3#! &'.!(3'.:'3'('! 7#(! -#($3#5#=.$(B! 2(073#(! #.!<br />

='3$.#+$%#! #.=$! #)#%! )#$$=! 1'=.U(3#(4! *('%+!>! =#+$:&'%#3#($%)#! A#(?#=3#.$($3#%! G$(!<br />

+6(-#7$%!+0%6?3'(!!-#!#%!+0%6%)'!:#-56.!'('.!(:'!#$3$:3#($!$3#!$3A$3$!=!+'!G$(!U>#.!<br />

7'>!)'!7#(!'3'5'=!)$#(!&6+6+3'(!03'5'=.!(B!<br />

!<br />

?+,!)-+.$@&$B1$%+-(1&'(,(,$8-_O-)&'($$<br />

H'3$.#! ='(='+! +#-$7#+$%)#! -#7'! #.$%! =#%)$+$! AU>! U%D%#! '3!%'('=! )##(3#%)$($3#G$3$(B!<br />

H'(='+!='3$.#+$%#4!7#.$.$(:#4!G'=!:b$)'(#!-#7'!=#+$:!+!('+!%)'!0(.'7'!?!='%!&#(&'%A$!<br />

G$(!)#1#=.$!N=!(!=!='%'.!-#7'!G'5'=4!?D(D=!-#7'!:0(36=3'(4!='%':'P!7'%+!.'%!='(='+!%!<br />

)!! AU(D%DD%#! G'=!3'('=! ='('(! -#($3#G$3$(B! H'(='+! ='3$.#+$! '7%!! >':'%)'! 'G)0:$%'3!<br />

7'! -#7'! =0%10(:'+70%! NAUD+! A#3$$:$P! :$=.'(!! $3#! )#! )##(3#%)$($3#G$3$(B! L+'+!<br />

$.$G'($73#!G6!.#G3$4!G'3!!G'!%'!#.!='3$.#+$!$3#!$3A$3$!036@4!U>#33$=3#!)#!#%!7D=+#=!='.:'!<br />

)##(#!+'&$@!-#!#%!&0:0I#%!GU3A#!03'%!AUD+!#.$%$%!='3$.#+$%$!AU>!U%D%#!'3:'=.')!(B!<br />

L.4! G#+$%! ='3$.#+$! .#($:$! ?#(?#-#+$%)#! )##(3#%)$($3#%! G#+3#7$5$! )##($%)#%! )03'7!!<br />

.D=#.$3:#=.#)$(B! 2#+$%! ='3$.#+$! $?#($+$%)#! $+#! @(0.#$%! -#! 3$@$)! $?#($$! -#! ='3$.#! )$#(!<br />

:$%U(!G$3##%3#($%!:$=.'(!!N*#4!-$.':$%3#(4!-GP!$3#!G$(3$=.#!U%#:3$!@'(':#.(#3#(!03'('=!<br />

7#(!'3:'=.')!(B!!!<br />

KD=#.$5$!#.$4!'%5'=!#.$%!0(A'%03#@.$=!N)676+'3P!='3$.#+$%)#%!:#:%6%!='3:'+!!'(.!!$3#!<br />

+'.!%! '3:'=.')!(B! L.$%! )!! AU(D%DD! -#! (#%A$! )$#(! GU3A#+#3! .#(5$&3#(! $3#! G$(3$=.#!<br />

.D=#.$5$%$%! .#(5$&$%$! G#3$(3#(B! L.$%! .')!4! #=3$! -#! )0=6+6! U%#:3$! 03:'=3'! G#('G#(!<br />

.#(5$&3#(!D(D%)#%!D(D%#!-#7'!.D=#.$5$)#%!.D=#.$5$7#!)#$$=3$=!AU+.#(#G$3$(B!TU>!=0%6+6!<br />

@'(':#.(#3#(! G$(! .D=#.$5$! &#7#.$! .'('1!%)'%! -#7'! 1$>$=+#3! U3?D:3#(! %#.$5#+$%)#!<br />

)##(3#%)$($3#G$3$(B!<br />

J'(?'! -#! $3#($! $3#%:$! D(D%3#()#! 7''%'%! A#3$:#3#(! $3#! G$(3$=.#! .#=%030I$=! ='3$.#!<br />

U%#:3$! G$(! &6+6+! &'3$%#! A#3:$.$(B! J'(?'! D(D%3#(! $?$%! &0:0I#%$.#4! (#%=! .6.'(3!3!!! -#!<br />

@'(?')'%! +6! +'3!%!:!! U%#:! '(>! #.:#=.#)$(B! K#=%030I$)#=$! $3#(3#:#3#(! $3#($! $3#%:$!<br />

D(D%3#(!$?$%!U%#:3$)$(B!!<br />

T0%! ?'3!:'3'()'%! G$($%)#! J#..('55$! -#! 2'#>'! Nd[VVP4! A#3#5#=.#! ?'3!:'3'(! '('+!%)'!<br />

='(!3'.!(:'! 7'@!3'G$3:#+$%#! 03'%'=! -#(:#+$! '?!+!%)'%4! ='%'.3!! #.$! ='3$.#!<br />

U>#33$=3#($%$%! )##(3#%)$($3:#+$%)#! =633'%!3'%! :#.0)030I$3#()#! &'(:0%$>'+70%'!<br />

A$)$3:#+$%$!U%#(:#=.#)$(3#(B!!!!<br />

`(D%D%!)!!AU(D%DD!-#7'!D(#.$:!#=3$!$3#!)'&'!1'>3'!$3A$3$!03'%!)$#(!+6GI#=.$1!='3$.#!<br />

@'(':#.(#3#($! )#! U%#:3$! 036@! )$-#(+$1'='+70%'! ND(D%! ?#$.3#%)$(:#+$%#P! ='.=!!<br />

+'3':'=.')!(B! m(%#$%! *('%+'


:#.'G03$>:'7'!)U%#(B!C3$=0I#%$%!7!=!:3'%:'+!!+0%656!3'=.'=!-#!@(0.0%!'?!'!?!='(!<br />

-#! GU73#5#! #.$%! '+$)$1$='+70%6%'! ='.=!! +'3'(B! KD:! A3$=0I#%! =633'%!3)!!%)'! #.!<br />

:'=+$:6:! @\! )##($%#! N@\6P! 63':!! 036(B! ;KJ! D(#.$3)$$! +D(#5#! ='+)'! G'3'%.!!<br />

:D:=D%!036@!#.!@\6$%! -#(#%! #%)0I#%! @(0.#03$.$=!<br />

#%>$:! 1''3$7#.3#($%$%! %#.$5#+$%)#! 03A6%3':'! @(0+#+$! G'3'(B! 26! '':'! G#7'>! #..#!<br />

N='%'.3!! -#! )0:6>P! =!(:!>!! #.#! N+!!(P! AU(#! )'&'! &!>3!)!(B! n#.$5#)#! #.4! =033'I#%!<br />

:$=.'(!%'4! .D(D%#! -#! #($7#G$3$(3$$%#! G'3!! 03'('=! G#3$(3#%#%! G'>'3! +#(.3$#! 63'!(B!<br />

R3A6%3':'! '':'+!! ='%'.3!! #.$! $?$%! A#%#33$=3#! +!%!(3'%)!(!5!! 03'('=!<br />

)##(3#%)$($3:#:#=.#! 036@! G6%)'%! )03'7!! '+$)$1$='+70%! @(0+#+$! @#=! ?0=! ='3$.#!<br />

@'(':#.(#+$%$%!'%'!G#3$(3#7$5$!1'=.U(D)D(B!!!<br />

;+$)$1$='+70%! @(0+#+$! +!('+!%)'! 0(.'7'! ?!='%! &#(&'%A$! G$(! ='(!!=3!!%! ='%'.3!! #.$!<br />

='3$.#+$!D>#($%)#!GD7D=!#.=$+$!G636%:'=.')!(B!@\!)DDD%)#=$!GD7D=3D=!n0(:'34!;+$.!<br />

-#!H076!(#%=3$pT#(.bH6(6!Nc*cb!c'(=!*$(:!c(7P!#.3#(!'('+!%)'=$!1'(=!!7'('.:'=.')!(B!<br />

;+$.!#.3#(!+03A6%!(#%=3$!N7D=+#=!36:$%'%+!)##($!AU+.#(:#=.#)$(4!iyP!036@!)DD=!+6!<br />

.6.:'! ='@'+$.#+$%#! Na\jP! +'&$@.$(3#(B! ;7%!! >':'%)'! )DD=! .#=%030I$=! -#($:! $1')#!<br />

#.:#=.#)$(3#(B! 26! D(D%3#($%! ('1! U:D(3#($! 6>6%! 03:'=3'! G#('G#(! #=+D)'.$1!<br />

03:')!=3'(!%)'%! AU(D%.D3#($! ?0=! $7$! )#$3)$(B! c$#(! .'('1.'%! c*c! #.3#(! =076! (#%=3$!<br />

N)DD=!iy!)##($P4!)'&'!7D=+#=!+6!.6.:'!='@'+$.#+$%#!Na\jP!+'&$@!036@!)'&'!7D=+#=!<br />

.#=%030I$=! -#($:! AU+.#(:#=.#)$(3#(B! ;%5'=! G6! #.3#(! .'>#! #.! 03'('=! G'=.#($7#3!<br />

=0%.':$%'+70%'!)'&'!)67'(3!!036@4!=6(6!-#!+#(..$(3#(B!@\!!$3#!$3A$3$!<br />

0(.'7'!?!='%!G$(!G'='!)#1#=.!$+#!'+$.!#.3#(!$3#!'7%!!U>#33$=3#($!@'73''%!+03A6%!(#%=3$!<br />

76:6'=! #=+D)'.$1! #.! 0366:6%'! 703! '?:'+!)!(B! 26! +#%)(0:4! :'IU(! A#%3#! N&'30.'%!<br />

A#%$P!=0%.(03!#)$3)$$%)#%!)0:6>3'()'!$7$!G$(!#=$3)#!0(.'7'!=0%63:6.6(B!26!)6(6:!<br />

)DD=!@\!-#!7D=+#=!!+!!G$(3#$:$%)#%!='7%'=3'%'%!@(0.#$%!)#%'.6('+70%6%6!AU+.#($(B!<br />

TU>! =0%6+6! +#%)(0:! #%! '>!%)'%! #%)D+.($7#3! '(.3'(! '3.!%)'! ='%'.3!3'()'! N&$%)$3#(! -#!<br />

G(073#(3#(P! .'%!:3'%:!! 036@! '+$.! #.3#()#! ='(!!=3!'! 703! '?'G$3$(B! H'%'.3!! >$%5$($%)#!<br />

+U>!=0%6+6!)#1#=.3#($%!0(.'7'!?!=!!!G$(!+0%('=$!@'('A('1.'!#3#!'3!%'5'=.!(B!<br />

!<br />

a.+,'!9$%&'()$?&'('-&.(,/&$B1$%+-(1&'($V+.+)&1.&-&.(,/&A($2&((A-(A-&.$$<br />

OK;8O!-#!On";!.'('1!%)'%!+.'%)'(.!G(073#(!D(#.$:$!-#7'!@'(?'!-#!$3#($!$3#:!D(D%3#($!<br />

$?$%!)'&'!'!(!G(073#(!D(#.$:$!7'@'%!-#!7'-'4!0(.'!-#7'!&!>3!!GD7D:#!0('%!%'!+'&$@!<br />

G(073#(3#(! $3#! $3#:! 7'@'%! e! ='%'.3!! D(#.$:! A(6G6! .'('1!%)'%! .0@3'%'%! ee! @'(.$)#!<br />

.0@3':! ZW[[! ')#.! AUD+! 1$3#.0+6! D>#($%)#! GD7D=! G$(! +6(-#7! A#(?#=3#.($3:$.$(B!<br />

n0(:'3!@\6!)##(!'('3!!!^BZ!$3'!eBd!'('+!%)'!='G63!#)$3:$.$(B!XD=+#=!)##(3#(!NseBdP!<br />

c*c! #.3#(4! )DD=! )##(3#(! $+#! Nz^BZP! '+$.! #.3#(! 03'('=! ='G63! #)$3:$.$(B! L%! ?'(@!5!!<br />

+0%6?!.D:!)$#(!@'(':#.(#3#(!N(#%=4!.D.+D3#:#!@$$(:#!-#($:3$3$$4!@$:$!#.!)0=6+64!<br />

.#=%030I$=! -#($:3$3$=P! ! D>#($%)#! #.=$+$! 03'%! @\6! 5$%+$%)#%! &#.#(0I#%3$=! )6(6:6!<br />

03:6.6(B! L%! GD7D=! )#$=#%3$=4! :6&.#:#3#%! 1'(=3!! &'7-'%3'(! $3#:#! .'G$!<br />

.6.63)66%)'%!+.'%)'(.!G(073#(!D(#.$:$%)#!AU>3#:3#%:$.$(B!N]^!$3'!gZ!AD%3D=4!VB^!$3'!<br />

dBg! =A! 5'%3!! '!(3!=.'P! L%! +!=! ('+.3'%'%! )#1#=.! +03A6%! (#%=.#4! )DD=! +6! .6.:'!<br />

='@'+$.#+$%#! Na\jP! +'&$@! -#! >'7!1! .#=%030I$=! -#($:3$3$=! '(>! #)#%! '+$.! #.3#(! 036@4!<br />

G6%3'(!%! +.'%)'(.! G(073#(! D(#.$:$! $?$%)#=$! 0('%!! 7'=3'!=! tVf


=03#('+70%6%!+.'%)'(.!G(073#(3#()#![Be!03'('=!.'&:$%!#)$3#G$3:#+$%#!$>$%!-#(:#=.#)$(B!<br />

NC$A'6)!#.!'3B4!d[VVPB!<br />

!<br />

%+,+1-!$B1($%+-(1&'(,&$B1A($B/&,$a+A1G.-&.$<br />

\#:!$?+#3!&#:!)#!)!+'3!1'=.U(3#($%!#.!='3$.#+$!D>#($%)#!#.=$+$!-'()!(B!?+#3!1'=.U(3#(!<br />

A#%0.$@4! 7'4! 5$%+$7#.4! ='+! .D(D! A$G$! D(D%! -#7'! D(#.$:! +$+.#:3#($%)#! 1'(=! 7'('.'%!<br />

1'=.U(3#()$(B!!c!+'3!1'=.U(3#(!$+#!7#.$.$(:#!NG#+3#%:#4!7#.$.$(:#!:#.0)3'(!P!)#$$=!<br />

:'%$@3'+70%3'(4! %'=3$7#! -#! =#+$:! +!('+!%)'! 0(.'7'! ?!='%! 1'=.U(3#(! $3#! ='+!%! #.#!<br />

)U%DD:!@(0+#+$!+!('+!%)'=$!@0+.!:0(.#:!$3#:3#()$(B!!!<br />

!<br />

`+!,$B1A('($$<br />

H'%'.3!! D(#.$:! +$+.#:3#($%)#=$! 1'(=3!3!=3'(! .#:#3! 03'('=! A#%#.$=! +#3#=+$70%6%! =!+:$!<br />

+0%656! 03'%! 1'(=3!! GD7D:#! &!>3'(!%)'%! ='7%'=3'%!(B! 2(073#(3#(! A#%#33$=3#! G#3$(3$! G$(!<br />

5'%3!!'!(3!'!#($:#=!D>#(#!7#.$.$($3)$=3#($%)#%!1'(=3!!7'3'()'!=#+$:#!AU%)#($3$(3#(B!<br />

*('%+'!=0%6+6!1'=.U(3#(!$?$%)#!#%!U%#:3$+$!03'('=!<br />

U%#!?!=:'=.')!(B!!<br />

H#+$:3#()#!7'!%!'(.:'+!!)DD=!+036G$3$.#)#!#.!=033'I#%!$?#($$%)#!'(.!'!%#)#%!036(B!<br />

X'3'!G$(3$=.#!'7%!!>':'%)'!3$@$)!$?#($$!'>'3!(=#%!+'.6(#!7'!'+$.3#($!'(.'(B!26!)6(6:!<br />

%#)#%!Ei'G#3!"06A#F!:'(='!#.3#($%!)'&'!+!=!!G636%)66%6!-#!%#)#%!'>!+636!03:'+!%'!<br />

(':#%!)'&'!3#>>#.3$!G636%)66%6!'?!=3':'=.')!(B!N2#(($!#.!'3B4!d[[gPB!<br />

\#(&'%A$!G$(!D(#.$:!.D(D!$?#($+$%)#!'(.'%!=#+$:!7'!!A3$=0I#%!!O%5(#'+$%A!.&#!'A#!'.!<br />

+3'6A&.#(!Q$.&$%!'!@(0)65.$0%!.7@#4!)#5(#'+#+!A3750A#%!50%.#%.!'%)!.&#(#G7!$%5(#'+#+!<br />

@\6!'%)!50%+#S6#%.37!a\j!N2'Ç>'!#.!'3B4!d[V[PB!<br />

!<br />

>&,F1(^$B1A('($<br />

2#3$(3$! G$(! 7'.'! =#+$:#! AU%)#($3#%! &'7-'%3'(! $?$%! A#%0.$@4! )#$=#%3$=! '?!+!%)'%!<br />

A#%#33$=3#! U%#:3$! G$(! 1'=.U()D(B! C#%0.$@3#($%! '('+!%)'! ='(!3'.!(:'! 7'@!3)!!%)'4!<br />

GD7D:#!&!>!!-#!_!-#7'!AUD+!#.$!A#3$$:$%)#!7''%'%!$3#(3#:#%$%!+6!.6.:'!='@'+$.#+$%$!<br />

Na\jP! -#! .#=%030I$=! -#($:3$3$$! '(.!('%! )'&'! 7D=+#=! @\63#:3#%:$.$(!N2#(($!#.!'3B4!d[[VPB!2$(!L%)D+.($7#3!G(073#(3#($%!@#)$A($!@0@63'+70%6!<br />

$?#($+$%)#=$!)#$=#%3$=3#(!$3#!$3A$3$!AU>3#:3#(!AUD+!#.$!A#3$$:$%$%!.#:#3!03'('=!='+!<br />

3$1$!G076.6!$3#!'?!=3'%)!!%!!-#!!A$3$=0I#%!$?#($$%)#!'>'3:'!-#!G6%'!G'3!!03'('=!)'&'!<br />

7D=+=!@\6!)##($4!)'&'!7D=+#=!a\j!-#!)'&'!$3#($!)D>#7)#!$3#%#G$3$(3$=!U>#33$$!$3#!<br />

+0%6?3'%)!!%!!AU+.#(:#=.#)$(!N2#(($!#.!'3B4!d[[ZPB!c#%#7+#3!7'3!!-#!7'+!>!@$3$?3#(!<br />

'('+!%)'! 7'@!3'%! ='(!3'.!(:'! 7'3!3!=! $3#! ='+! A3$=0I#%! $?#($$! '('+!%)'! @0>$.$1! G$(!<br />

G'3'%.!%!%! 03)66%6! -#! %#.$5#)#! 7'+!>! @$3$?3#()#! @\6!4! AUD+! #.$! -#($:3$3$$! -#! )'&'! '>! 7'3'%:'! 7U%D%)#! 7'@!3'%! +#3#=+$70%3'(!%!<br />

G(073#(3#()#!AU>3#%#%!@\6!=0%6+6!#$3$:$%4!<br />

)##(3#(! %0(:'3! '('3!=3'()'! ='3)!!! +D(#5#! #.! ='3$.#+$%$%! .#=%030I$=! 7U%D! $.$G'($73#!<br />

A#%#33$=3#!7'('(3!!03)66!+U73#%#G$3$(B!<br />

X'@!3'%! @#=?0=! ?'3!:'4! AUD+! #.$! ='3$.#! U>#33$=3#($%$%! ='3!.+'3! 03)66%6! 0(.'7'!<br />

=07:'=.')!(B!NA#%0.$@!-#!'(.3'('!G'3!!03'('=!&d!o![B]!$3'![BeP!m>#33$=3#($%!@#=!?06!<br />

U%#:3$! U3?D)#! G$(G$($73#! $3$=$3$! 036@! +#?$:! $?$%! @\6


':'%)'!:'3$7#.3$!-#!+#3#=+$70%!@(0+#+$+$%$%!#.=$%3$3$$%$!'>'3.'%!G$(!67A63':'!03'%!<br />

'7%!! +07)'%! A#3#%3#($%! )#! N=03#.#('3P! =#+$:$%$%! 7'@!3:'+!%!! A#(#=.$(:#=.#)$(B!<br />

C#%0:$=! +#3#=+$70%'! $>$%! -#(#5#=! :03#=D3#(! :'(=!(3'(!%! $)#%.$1$='+70%6! $3#! $3A$3$!<br />

?'3!:'3'(!%!%#)#%!7D(D.D3:#7#!?'3!!3)!!%!%!+#G#G$!G6)6(!NT$G6.!#.!'3B4!d[VVPB!<br />

C#%#.$=! =0%.(03! '3.!%)'! -#! @\! )DD! 0('%!%!%! =0%.(03D! $?$%! &'7-'%3'(!%! +.(#+!<br />

#.=#%3#($%#! -#()$$! .#@=$3#(! )#! U%#:3$)$(! Nj&'G'63.! #.! '3B4! d[V[PB! \!>3!! GD7D7#%!<br />

G(073#(3#(!A#%#33$=3#!)'&'!)DD=!.#@=$3#(!-#($(=#%!7'-'!GD7D7#%!G(073#(3#(!)'&'!1'>3'!<br />

.#@=$! -#(:#=.#)$(3#(B! 26! )6(6:! )'&'! 7D=+#=! $%+$)'%+! -#! '+=!! &'..!%)'! )'&'! 1'>3'!<br />

='%'.!?!(@:'!-#!%#.$5#+$%)#!)#!#..#!(#%=!-#!a\j!G0>6=366%6%!0(.'7'!?!=:'+!!$3#!<br />

'?!=3'%'G$3$(!Nc#G6.!#.!'3B4!d[[]h!2#(($!#.!'3B4!d[[^PB!<br />

!<br />

l(,'(5&1(,$B1A('($$<br />

K'-6=3'()'! +#=+D#3! )$:0(1$>:! N##7! '7(!3!!P! )$$3#($%! '7%!! 7'.'=$! #(=#=3#(#! AU(#!<br />

)'&'! =D?D=! 03)6=3'(!%!! '%5'=! )'&'! &!>3!! GD7D:#! AU+.#()$=3#($%$! $1')#! #.:#=.#)$(h!<br />

U(%#$%! AU(#5#3$! 03'('=! )'&'! 1'>3'! AUD+! #.$! D(#.$:$! -#! '7%!! 7'.'! )'&'! 1'>3'! 7'!<br />

)#@03':'!A$G$B!c$$3#()#!A3$=0I#%!$?#($$!)'&'!7D=+#=4!@\,!)'&'!)DD=.D(B!L.3#($!$+#!<br />

)'&'!)DD=!a\j#($%)#! U%#:3$! G$(! #.=$+$! -'()!(B!<br />

"'+70%3'('! 0@.$:6:! )D>#73#()#%! )'&'! 1'>3'! 3$>$%! #=3#%:#+$! AUD+! #.$! D(#.$:$%$! -#!<br />

@\6


O,#($%)#%!#.!='3$.#+$%$!=0%.(03!#.:#=!$?$%!A3$=0I#%!)#@03':'%!%!:#(=#>$!(03D4!='+!<br />

A3$=0I#%!:#.'G03$>:'+!%!!=0%.(03!#)#%!:03#=D3#(!:#='%$>:'!$3#!$3A$3$!'('.!(:'3'(!%!<br />

0(.'7'! ?!=:'+!%'! %#)#%! 03:6.6(! NT$G6.! #.! '3B4! d[[f4! d[VVPB! c#%#7+#3! G(073#(!<br />

A#%0.$@3#($! D>#($%)#! @0>$+70%#3! -#! 10%=+$70%#3! A#%0:$=3#($%! G$(! '('7'! A#.$($3:#+$!<br />

7'=3'!:!! G6%3'(!%! .'%!:3'%:'+!%'! $>$%! -#(#5#=.$(B! TU>! =0%6+6! +0%6?3'(!%4! .#(:$%'3!<br />

7'-(63'()'! $3#($! )D>#7)#! #.! ='3$.#+$! #3)#! #)$3#G$3:#+$%#! $>$%! -#(#5#=! 67A6%! A#%3#(#!<br />

+'&$@! G(073#(! )':!>3!=3'(!%! :'(=!(! 7'()!:!! $3#! +#?$:$! $?$%! :03#=D3#(! '('?3'(!<br />

+'3'7'5'!! U%AU(D3:#=.#)$(B! 26! A#%3#($%! G#+3#%:#! -#7'! 7#.$.$(:#! $3#! %'+!3! (#AD3#!<br />

#)$3#5#$%$%! '%3'!3:'+!! #.! ='3$.#+$%$! )#$.$(#5#=! $3'-#! '('?3'(!%! )'! AD%)#:#!<br />

A#3:#+$%$! +'3'7'G$3$(B! H#+$:! +!('+!%)'! G(073#(3#($%! )$=='.3$! G$(! #=$3)#! $)'(#+$! $3#!<br />

G$(3$=.#! G6! )6(6:4! #.! ='3$.#+$%$%! U>#33$=3#($%)#! AU>3#:3#%#%! )#$$=3$=3#($%!<br />

'>'3.!3:'+!%'!='.=!!+'3'7'G$3$(B!!<br />

!<br />

"F,7_$$<br />

2D7D:#! &!>!4! 7#:)#%! 7'('(3'%:'! 0('%!%)'=$! $7$3#:#! +'7#+$%)#! G(073#(! D(#.$:!<br />

@3'%3'(!%)'=$! +D(#=3$! A#3$$:! ='%'.3!! #.! ='3$.#+$! D>#($%)#! 036:+6>! G$(! #.=$!<br />

7'('.:':'=.')!(B! ;%5'=! #%)D+.($7#3! '(.3'(! '3.!%)'4! +U>! =0%6+6! D(#.$:$%!<br />

+D()D(D3#G$3$(3$$%$%! A#3$:#! ='7)#)#G$3:#+$! $?$%! AU>3#:3#%#%! @#=! ?0=!<br />

)#$=#%3$=3#($%! '>'3.!3:'+!! A#(#=:#=.#)$(B! 26! ':'5'! 63':'=! $?$%! 7#.$.$($5$3#(4!<br />

?$1.3$=! +'&$@3#($4! 7#:! .#)'($=?$3#($! -#! =#+$:&'%#3#(! A$G$! ='%'.3!! >$%5$($%)#! 1'(=3!!<br />

'=.U(3#($!='@+'7'%!A30G'3!G$(!7'=3'!:!%!A#3$.$($3:#+$!A#(#=:#=.#)$(B!!!!<br />

!<br />

%+5,+A-+.$$<br />

;G#7#+$%A&4#!TB9B4!95H##A'%4!cBLB4!95i#:'%4!9B;B4!i0Q#4!wBjB4!c#::#(+4!KBCB4!a&$.#4!"BJB4!H('%#%4!<br />

"BaB4! -'%! 2#::#34! \B4! i'%=&''(4! wB;B4! a'.&#+4! jB9B4! d[[ZB! j0%.(033#)! '.:0+@&#(#! +.6%%$%A! 01! G(0$3#(!<br />

5&$5=#%+B!OB!L11#5.+!0%!G#&'-$06(4!@&7+$030A7!'%)!:#'.!S6'3$.7!$%!'!@$30.!+5'3#!+7+.#:!'.!'!@(05#++$%A!@3'%.B!<br />

2($.$+&!J063.(7!T5$#%5#4!gfYg[ebd]B!<br />

2'#>'4!LB4!w3'3$4!9B4!j&'(.($%4!JB4!C$A'6)4!8B4!9#(5#('%)4!*B4!c6('%)4!jB4!9#.#'64!HB4!i#!2$&'%bc6-'34!LB4!<br />

2#(($4!jB4!d[V[B!O%136#%5#!01!$%5(#'+#)!+3'6A&.#(!'A#!0%!:#'.!7$#3)!'%)!G(#'+.!:#'.!S6'3$.7!1(0:!'!&#'-7!<br />

3$%#!01!G(0$3#(!5&$5=#%B!O%Y!J(05##)$%A!01!V] .& !L6(0@#'%!J063.(7!j0%A(#++4!K06(+!N*";P4!d[V[_[f_d]bdZB!<br />

2#(($4!jB!d[[gB!2(##)$%A!'%)!S6'3$.7!01!@063.(7B!J063.(7!9#'.!J(05#++$%A!'%)!Å6'3$.74!9#')4!CBjB!NL)BP4!<br />

j&'@B!dY!dVb]ZB!j"j!J(#++4!205'!"'.0%!N,T;P4!a00)&#')!J6G3$+&$%A!i.)4!j':G($)A#!NC2"PB!<br />

2#(($4!jB4!2#+%'()4!wB4!"#3'%)#'64!jB!d[[f!O%5(#'+$%A!)$#.'(7!37+$%#!$%5(#'+#+!1$%'3!@\!'%)!)#5(#'+#+!)($@!<br />

30++!01!G(0$3#(!G(#'+.!:#'.B!J063.(7!T5$#%5#4!fZY!gf[bgfgB)<br />

2#(($4!jB4!c#G6.4!9B4!T'%.Çbi&06.#33$#(4!8B4!;(%063)4!jB4!206..#%4!2B4!T#33$#(4!nB4!2'Ç>'4!LB4!w#&34!nB4!w#A04!<br />

XB4!c6530+4!9BwB4! i#!2$&'%bc6-'34!LB!d[[^GB!8'($'.$0%+!$%!5&$5=#%!G(#'+.! :#'.!S6'3$.7!Y!$:@3$5'.$0%+!01!<br />

+.(6AA3#!'%)!:6+53#!A3750A#%!50%.#%.!'.!)#'.&B!2($.$+&!J063.(7!T5$#%5#4!geY!^Zdb^ZWB!<br />

2#(($4!jB4!i#!2$&'%bc6-'34!LB4!c#G6.4!9B4!T'%.Çbi&06.#33$#(4!8B4!2'Ç>'4! LB4!2(6%#34!8B4!w#A04!XB4!c6530+4!<br />

9BwB4!d[[ZB!j0%+#S6#%5#!01!:6+53#!&7@#(.(0@&7!0%!J#5.0('3$+!:'I0(!5&'('5.#($+.$5+!'%)!G(#'+.!:#'.!S6'3$.7!<br />

01!G(0$3#(!5&$5=#%+B!w06(%'3!01!;%$:'3!T5$#%5#4!f^Y!d[[^bd[VVB)<br />

2#(($4! jB4! i#! 2$&'%bc6-'34! LB4! C$A'6)4! 8B4! 2'#>'4! LB4! c6530+4! 9BwB4! d[V[B! K0Q'()+! .&#! $)#%.$1$5'.$0%!01!<br />

:#5&'%$+:+!6%)#(37$%A!.&#!-'($'.$0%+!01!5&$5=#%!:#'.!@(05#++$%A!'G$3$.7B!O%Y!J(05##)$%A!01!V] .& !L6(0@#'%!<br />

J063.(7!j0%A(#++4!K06(+!N*";P4!d[V[_[f_d]bdZB!<br />

2#(($4! jB4! a'5(#%$#(4! nB4! 9$33#.4! nB4! i#! 2$&'%bc6-'34! LB! d[[VB! L11#5.! 01! +#3#5.$0%! 10(! $:@(0-#)! G0)7!<br />

50:@0+$.$0%! 0%! :6+53#! '%)! :#'.! 5&'('5.#($+.$5+! 01! G(0$3#(+! 1(0:! #M@#($:#%.'3! '%)! 50::#(5$'3! 3$%#+B!<br />

J063.(7!T5$#%5#4!f[Y!f]]bf]fB!!<br />

j&'G'63.4! 9B4! C$A'6)4! 8B4! 2'#>'4! LB4! j&'(.($%4! JB4! j&'@6$+4! \B4! 2063'74! 9B4! ;(%063)4! jB4! 2#(($4! jB4! i#!<br />

2$&'%bc6-'34! LB4! d[V[B! ;%'37+$+! 01! '%! '3.#(%'.$-#! +30QbA(0Q$%A! 5&$5=#%! 3$%#! (#-#'3+! '! 3'(A#! A#%#.$5!<br />

-'($'G$3$.7! 01! 5'(5'++! '%)! :#'.! S6'3$.7! (#3'.#)! .('$.+B! O%Y! J(05##)$%A! 01! V] .& ! L6(0@#'%! J063.(7! j0%A(#++4!<br />

K06(+!N*";P4!d[V[_[f_d]bdZB!<br />

c#G6.4! 9B4! 2#(($4! jB4! 2'Ç>'4! LB4! T#33$#(4! nB4! ;(%063)4! jB4! C6Ç:#%Ç4! cB4! w#&34! nB4! 206..#%4! 2B4! w#A04! XB4!<br />

2#'6:0%.4! jB4! i#! 2$&'%bc6-'34! LB! d[[]B! 8'($'.$0%! 01! 5&$5=#%! .#5&%030A$5'3! :#'.! S6'3$.7! $%! (#3'.$0%! .0!<br />

A#%0.7@#!'%)!@(#+3'6A&.#(!+.(#++!50%)$.$0%+B!J063.(7!T5$#%5#4!fdY!VfdWbVf]fB!!<br />

! !TZ


C$A'6)!8B4!20()#'6!KB4!j&'(.($%!JB4!2'Ç>'!LB4!2#(($!jB4!d[VVBK#5&%030A$5'3!-'($'G$3$.7!01!5&$5=#%!G(#'+.!<br />

:#'.!S6'3$.7!#%506%.#(#)!$%!*('%5#!'550()$%A!.0!.&#!@(0)65.$0%!+7+.#:B!Wì:#+!w06(%Ç#+!)#!3'!"#5&#(5&#!<br />

;-$503#!4!K06(+!N*";P!4!d[[W_[]_d^bdeB!jc"0:Y![[[[^eB@)14!e^gbe^f4!OK;8O4!J'($+!N*";PB!<br />

C$A'6)4! 8B4! C#11('()4! ;B4! 2#(($4! jB4! i#! 2$&'%bc6-'34! LB4! K('-#34! ;B4! 20()#'64! KB4! d[[ZB! O:@'5.! 01! @(#b<br />

+3'6A&.#(!1'5.0(+!0%!5&$5=#%!:#'.!S6'3$.7B!|8OOO!L6(0@#'%!T7:@0+$6:!0%!.&#!Å6'3$.7!01!J063.(7!9#'.!'%)!<br />

|OO!L6(0@#'%!T7:@0+$6:!0%!.&#!Å6'3$.7!01!LAA+!'%)!LAA!@(0)65.+4!J('A6#!NjlLP4!d[[Z_[W_[db[^4!VV]b<br />

VVg4!aJT;!j>#5&!G('%5&B!<br />

C$A'6)4! 8B4! T'%.#bi&06.#33$#(4! 8B4! J'('1$.'4! LB4! i#! 2$&'%bc6-'34! LB4! 2#(($4! jB4! d[V[B! L3#5.($5'3! 0(! A'+!<br />

+.6%%$%AY! Q&$5&! 50%+#S6#%5#+! 10(! .&#! :#'.! S6'3$.7! $%! .&(##! 5&$5=#%! A#%0.7@#+q! O%Y! J(05##)$%A! 01! V] .& !<br />

L6(0@#'%!J063.(7!j0%A(#++4!K06(+!N*";P4!d[V[_[f_d]bdZB!<br />

w3'3$4!9B4!T$G6.4!8B4!C$A'6)4!8B4!T#33$#(4!nB4!K#++#('6)4!TB4!9Ç.'7#(bj06+.'()4!TB4!c6530+4!9BwB4!i#!2$&'%b<br />

c6-'34!LB4!2#(($4!jB4!d[[WB!"ÇA63'.$0%!)6!A3750Aì%#!:6+563'$(#!#.!(#3'.$0%!'-#5!3'!S6'3$.Ç!)#!3'!-$'%)#!)#!<br />

@063#.B!fì:#!w06(%Ç#+!)#!3'!"#5&#(5&#!;-$503#!4!T.!9'30!N*";P!4!d[[W_[]_d^bde4!Vgd!N"Ç+6:ÇPB!jc"0:!Y!<br />

[[[[ZZB@)14!^Vdb^Ve4!OK;8O4!J'($+!N*";PB!<br />

i#! 2$&'%bc6-'34! LB4! 2#(($4! jB4! 2'Ç>'4! LB4! 9$33#.4! nB4! 2#'6:0%.4! jB! d[[VB! L+.$:'.$0%! 01! .&#! A#%#.$5+!<br />

@'(':#.#(+!01!:#'.!5&'('5.#($+.$5+!'%)!01!.&#$(!A#%#.$5!50((#3'.$0%+!Q$.&!A(0Q.&!'%)!G0)7!50:@0+$.$0%!$%!'%!<br />

#M@#($:#%.'3!G(0$3#(!3$%#B!J063.(7!T5$#%5#4!f[Y!f]Wbfg]B!<br />

i#! 2$&'%bc6-'34! LB4! c#G6.4! 9B4! 2#(($4! jB9B4! T#33$#(4! nB4! T'%.#bi&06.#33$#(4! 8B4! w#A04! XB4! 2#'6:0%.4! jB4!<br />

d[[fB! j&$5=#%! :#'.! S6'3$.7Y! A#%#.$5! -'($'G$3$.7! '%)! (#3'.$0%+&$@! Q$.&! A(0Q.&! '%)! :6+53#! 5&'('5.#($+.$5+B!<br />

29j!C#%#.$5+4!W4!e!@4!.,"&)'--"++4)3##,4RRIIIG9%.7"8-"&#$'0G-.7Rkhbka^k_dRiR_lB)<br />

9':#($4!\B4!c6@0%.4!wB4!w06G#(.4!"B4!j033$%4!;B4!j(05&#.4!TB4!j'$33#'6b;6)06$%4!LB4!K#++#('6)4!TB4!9#.'7#(b<br />

j06+.'()!TB!d[V[B!9#5&'%$+:+!(#A63'.$%A!.&#!@#($@&#('3!6.$3$+'.$0%!01!A3650+#Y!$%-03-#:#%.!01!':@=B!O%!Y!<br />

J(05##)$%A+!01!.&#!]()!O%.#(%'.$0%'3!L;;J!T7:@0+$6:!0%!L%#(A7!'%)!J(0.#$%!9#.'G03$+:!'%)!n6.($.$0%!<br />

N$+#@P4!d[V[_[W_ebV[4!J'(:'!NOK;PB!!<br />

J#.('55$4!9B4!2'#>'!LB4!d[VVB!\'(:0%$>'.$0%!01!:#.&0)030A$#+!10(!.&#!'++#++:#%.!01!@063.(7!:#'.!S6'3$.7!<br />

1#'.6(#+B!a0(3)


" #C# $%+,+1-!$B1($B,/O'1.('(,/&$"+-)F,&--+,!,$>O,#73#($%$! '>'3.:'=! -#! G6! 0(A'%$>:'3'(!%! D(#.$:! -#! $3#:)#%! A#?$(:#!<br />

'':'3'(!%)'! )'&'! 1'>3'! 7'7!3:'! 03'+!3!!%!! '>'3.:'=! U%#:3$)$(B! ;-(6@'! 2$(3$$00%0.$=!'I'%3'(!$3#!$3A$3$!036@!.D:!='%'.3!!D(#.$:!>$%5$($%$!)#!$?#(:#=.#)$(B!26!<br />

)'4! '%'! D(#.$:! '':'+!%)'! U%3#:3#(! '3!%:'+!%'! -#! .D=#.$:#! &'>!(! 03'%! D(D%3#($%!<br />

:$=(0G$7030I$=! =0%.':$%'+70%6! $?$%! +.'%)'(.3'(!%! G#3$(3#%:#+$%#! 703! '?:!.!(B!<br />

`(#.$5$3#(4! 9#->6'.3'()'! G#3$(.$3#%! &#)#13#(#! 63':'=! $?$%! K#&3$=#! ;%'3$>$! H($.$=!<br />

H0%.(03! n0=.'+!b\;jjJb+$+.#:3#($! A$G$! &$I7#%! -#! ='3$.#! 7U%#.$:! +$+.#:3#($%)#%!<br />

7'('(3'%'G$3$(3#(B!<br />

$<br />

:;'1.+(.($$<br />

C!)'! AD-#%3$$4! .D=#.$5$3#($%! -#! .D=#.$5$! =6(6363'(!%!%! +0%! >':'%3'()'! &'7-'%5!3!=!<br />

#%)D+.($+$%)#!7''%'%!=($>3#(#!='(!!AU+.#()$=3#($!AD?3D!036:+6>!.#@=$3#($!='(!3':'=!<br />

$?$%!$3A$3$!D(#.$:!+D(#?3#($%$%!.':':3'7!5!!G$(!@'(?'+!!&'3$%#!A#3:$.$(B!KD=#.$5$3#($%4!<br />

A!)'!AD-#%3$$!-#!='3$.#+$73#!$3A$3$!.'3#@3#(#!$3'-#!03'('=!D(#.$:$%!+D()D(D3#G$3$(3$$!$3#!<br />

&'7-'%! +'3!!! -#! ?#-(#%$%! =0(6%:'+!! )'&$3! 03:'=! D>#(#! .0@36:6%! $&.$7'?! -#!<br />

! !W#


)##(3#($%$! #.=$7#%! &6+6+3'(! &'==!%)'! G'>!! #%)$#3#(! G636%:'=.')!(B! CD%D:D>)#4!<br />

D(#.$:! +D(#?3#($! 1'(=3!! A#(#=3$3$=3#($! ='(!3':'=! >0(6%)')!(B! C#(?#=.#%! AD-#%3$! 03'%!<br />

D(D%3#()#! $%+'%3'(! $?$%! @'.0I#%$=! 03'%! :$=(00(A'%$>:'3'(! N/'07.&"00'Z)<br />

6'7,(0.9'-#"$! -+BP! -#! '%.$G$70.$=4! =0=+$)$70+.'.! -#! )$#(! =$:7'+'3! :'))#3#(! -#7'!<br />

7'G'%5!! :'))#3#(! )'&$3! 03:'=! D>#(#! '%'! D(#.$:)#! =633'%!3'%! :'))#3#($%! ='3!%.!3'(!!<br />

G636%:':'=.')!(B! ;7(!5'4! G0>63:'7'! 703! '?'%! 0(A'%$>:'3'(!%! N@+"18.7.&'+Z)<br />

E$.-3.#3$%f!-+BP!-'(3!!!)'!AU>!'()!!#)$3:#:#3$)$(B!!<br />

\#:!@'.0I#%$=4!&#:!)#!G0>63:'7'!703!'?'%!:$=(00(A'%$>:'3'(!.0@36:)'!?0=!U%#:3$!<br />

#=0%0:$=!='7!@3'('!703!'?'G$3$(Y!+U>!=0%6+6!='7!@3'(!.!GG$!.#)'-$+$!03)6=?'!:'3$7#.3$!<br />

03'%!A!)'!>#&$(3#%:#+$4!$!='7G!4!D(D%3#($%!A#($!.0@3'.!3:'+!%!!A#(#=.$(#%!G0>63:'!-#!<br />

A!)'! $+('1!! 03'('=! G#3$(.$3#G$3$(B! 26%6%3'! G$(3$=.#4! +')#5#! G'=.#($3#(! :$=(0G$7'3!<br />

.#&3$=#3#(! )#$3)$(B! nU(0-$(D+! A$G$! -$(D+3#(! $%+'%3'()'! A!)'! ='7%'=3!! &'+.'3!=3'(!%!<br />

0(.'7'!?!=:'+!%!%!G$(!%#)#%$!03'('=!AU(D3:#=.#)$(B!!<br />

J0.'%+$7#3!03'('=!@'.0I#%$=!03'%!0(A'%$>:'3'(3'!$3A$3$!=':6!+'3!!%'!)'$(!G$(!#%)$#!<br />

)#4! '%.$:$=(0G$7'3! :'))#3#(#! )'7'%!=3!! +63'(!%! +'7!+!%!%! '(.:'+!)!(B! ;%.$G$70.$#!<br />

='(!! )$(#%?! A#%#.$=! :#='%$>:'73'! $3$=$3$)$(B! ;%.$:$=(0G$7'33#($%! $%+'%3'()'! -#!<br />

-#.#($%#(3$=.#! 7'7A!%! #=$3)#! =633'%!3:'+!! $%+'%3'('! G#+$%! >$%5$($73#! G63''G$3#%!<br />

)'7'%!=3!!+63'(!%!A#3$:#+$%#!='.=!!+'3'(B!!!<br />

m%D:D>)#=$! G$(! )$#(! .#&3$=#! )#! '%.$G$70.$=3#(#! ='(!! ?0=36! )$(#%5$! 03'%! &'+.'3'(!%!<br />

tZ[$:! D(#.#%! G'=.#($!<br />

.'!:'+!)!(B! 26! EC#%$! T@#=.(6:36! 2#.'! i'5.':'>! NLT2iPF! #%>$:$! ='%'.3!3'()'! -#!<br />

='%'.3!! D(D%3#($%)#! 7'A!%! #=$3)#! G636%:'=.'! -#! G6AD%! '7%!! >':'%)'! G$.=$+#3!<br />

D(D%3#()#!)#!.#+@$.!#)$3:#=.#)$(B!!<br />

L%.#A(#!=0%.(03!@(0A(':3'(!!A!)'!AD-#%3$$!A#(#=3$3$=3#($%$!GD%7#+$%)#!G'(!%)!(:'=.'!<br />

-#! ='%'.3!! D(D%3#($! G'.'! 03:'=! D>#(#4! &'7-'%+'3! 0($I$%3$! A!)'3'(!%! ='3$.#+$%$! A'('%.$!<br />

'3.!%'! '3:'=.')!(B! K#&3$=#! ;%'3$>$! H($.$=! H0%.(03! n0=.'+!! N\;jjJP! =0%+#@.$! G6!<br />

@(0A(':3'()'!!7#(!'3:'=.')!(B!!<br />

26! =0%+#@.! -#! G6%6%! G$(?0=! 67A63':'+!4! ,36+3'('('+!! H0:$+70%! .'('1!%)'%! C!)'!<br />

9'))#3#($! $?$%! m>#33$=3#(! ?#(?#-#+$%)#! G#3$(.$3:$.$(B! 26%6%3'! G$(3$=.#4! =633'%!3'%!<br />

+$+.#:! %#! 036(+'! 03+6%4! +U>! =0%6+6! +$+.#:3#($%! &#@+$! A!)'! :'))#3#($73#! $3A$3$!<br />

@0.'%+$7#3!+'3!=!($+=3#($!=0%6+6%)'!0(.'=!G$(!7U%#.$:#!+'&$@.$(B!!!!<br />

;-(6@'! 2$(3$$! =0%6+6! )$(#=.$13#(! #.$=#.3#:#4! D(D%! AD-#%$3$(3$$! -#! A#%#3! &$I7#%!<br />

=6('33'(!! $3#! $3A$3$)$(B! 9#-56.! C!)'! H'%6%6! \;jjJ! ='-(':!%!%! .#:#3! @(#%+$@3#($%$!<br />

$?#(:#=.#)$(B!X#%$!='%6%4!D(D%!.'%!:3':'!-#!='7!.!'3.!%'!'3:'!&6+6+3'(!%)'!)#%A#3$!<br />

G$(! +$+.#:! A#.$(:#=.#! 036@! G$(! A#($! $>3#:#! -#! .'=$@! :#='%$>:'+!%!! >0(6%36! &'3#!<br />

A#.$(:$.$(B!!<br />

;-(6@'! 2$(3$$%$%! .'-6=! #.$! D(#.$:$73#! $3A$3$! :#->6'.!!&!>3!! -#! +D(#=3$! A#3$#%! G$(!<br />

'3'%)!(B!;-(6@'!2$(3$$%#!D7#!03'%!D3=#3#($%!+'7!+!!'(..!=?'4!&#(=#+#!#$.!1!(+'.!-#(:#=!<br />

$?$%!=6('3!-#!7U%#.:#3$=3#()#!&'(:0%$>'+70%'!7U%#3$=!'5$3!G$(!$&.$7'?!)0:6.6(B!!!<br />

963)#(! -#! \6@=#+! Nd[[^P4! +U>=0%6+6! A!)'! :'))#3#($%$%! D(#.$:$! -#! AD-#%3$$! $?$%!<br />

=633'%!3'%! #=$@:'%! -#! .'-6=! #.3#($%#! 7U%#3$=! :#-56.! ;-(6@'! 2$(3$$! )$(#=.$13#($! -#!<br />

7U%#.:#3$=3#($73#!$3A$3$!A#(#=3$!G$3A$3#($!-#(:#=.#)$(B!!!<br />

!<br />

c&@97+1$@&$>!/+$>O@&,-(($$!<br />

C!)'! AD-#%3$$! #%! U%#:3$! .D=#.$5$! +0(6%6! 03'('=! 0(.'7'! ?!=:!! 036@4! +0%6?.'! #%!<br />

U%5#3$=3$!=0%6!&'3$%#!A#3:$.$(B!;-(6@'!2$(3$$


7D=+#=!+#-$7#)#!A!)'!AD-#%3$$4!&'7-'%!+'3!!4!&'7-'%!(#1'&!!-#!G$.=$!+'3!!%!!.#:$%!<br />

#.:#7$! ':'?3':'=.')!(B! 26! 7'=3'!:!%! 67A63'%:'+!! :#-56.! :#->6'.! -#! )$#(!<br />

$3#:3#()#!A#3$:#!='7)#)$3:#+$%$!A#(#=.$(:#=.#)$(B!!<br />

d[[[!7!3!%)'!;-(6@'!2$(3$$!A!)'73'!$3A$3$!:#->6'..'!+0%!)#(#5#!U%#:3$!G$(!)#$$=3$=!<br />

7'@!3)!!%!!)676(:6.6(B!;-(6@'!2$(3$$$%5$($%)#!$+.$=('(!-#!'?!=3!=!+'3'7'5'=!%#.!':'?3'(!0(.'7'!=0%:6.6(B!2#7'>!H'!.4!<br />

;-(6@'! 2$(3$$6'.!!A#3$.$(#5#=!-#!G6!:#->6'.'!676:!+'3'7'5'=!?#$.3$!.#)G$(3#(!$3#!G$(3$=.#!G$(!<br />

#73#:!@3'%!!0(.'7'!=07:'=.')!(B!!!<br />

\'7-'%! 7#:$4! &'7-'%! +'3!!! -#! (#1'&!4! &$I7#%4! =0%.':$%'+70%! -#! ='3!%.!3'(4! 7#%$!<br />

A!)'3'(4!='.=!!:'))#3#($4!.'.3'%)!(!5!3'(4!':G'3'I!-#!$((')7'+70%6!='@+'7'%!7#%$!7'+'3!<br />

?#(?#-#!dV!6G'.!d[[d!.'($&$%)#!NEC#%#3!C!)'!H'%6%6F!G'3!=3!!Lj_VZf_d[[d!+'7!3!!<br />

XU%#.:#3$=P!-#!='%6%6%!G$(!A#?$!)U%#:$%)#%!+0%('!V!R5'=!d[[^$('%! d[[g! .'($&$%)#! 7D(D(3D#! A$(:$.$(B! 6! '%!<br />

$.$G'($73#!&'7-'%3'()'!f!.'%#!:$=(00(A'%$>:'%!%!AU>#.$:$!>0(6%36!036@!NT'3:0%#33'4!<br />

j':@730G'5.#(4! i$+.#($'! :0%0+$.0A#%3#(4! 8KLjb! LB! j03$4! j(7@.0+@0($)$6:4!<br />

L5&$%050556+4! K($5&$%#33'4! 2(65#33'P! +U>! =0%6+6! :$=(00(A'%$>:'3'(3'! $3A$3$! ($+=3#(!<br />

)##(3#%)$($3:#3$)$(B! CU>#.$:#! .'G$! >00%0>! -#! >00%0.$=! 'I'%3'(! $3#! $3A$3$! #=! G$(! 3$+.#!<br />

30='3! #@$)#:$7030I$=! )6(6:'! G'3!! 036@! -$(D+4! G'=.#($! -#! @'('>$.! A$G$!<br />

:$=(00(A'%$>:'3'(!!='@+':'=.')!(B!!<br />

\'3$!&'>!()'!.D:!;-(6@'!2$(3$$!D7#+$!D3=#3#()#!$3#7#%!G$(!AU>#.$:!-#!=0%.(03!+$+.#:$!<br />

03:':'+!%'! (':#%4! ;-(6@'! 2$(3$$%#! D7#! D3=#3#(! ='%'.3!! -#! GD7D=G'! &'7-'%!<br />

+D(D3#($%$!AU>#.$:!'3.!%)'!.6.:'=!-#!=0%.(03!#.:#=!>0(6%)')!(B!!<br />

dVe[_d[[]! +'7!3!! XU%#.:#3$=! l00%0>! c$(#=.$1$! $3#! 7'=!%)'%! $3A$3$! 036@4! +U>! =0%6+6!<br />

7U%#.:#3$=! ! =':6! +'3!!! '?!+!%)'%! U%#:#! +'&$@! 1'(=3!! ='.#A0($3#()#=$! ='%'.3!! -#!<br />

)0:6>3'()'! 0(.'7'! ?!='%! /'07.&"00'! +@@B3!=3'()'4! 76:6(.'5!! .'-6=3'()'! -#! G(073#(3#()#!<br />

7'7A!%!03)66%'!)'$(!G$3A$!-#(:$.$(B!K'G30!V3'(3'!$3A$3$!G#%>#(!G$3A$3#($%!.0@3'%:'+!%'!)#-':!#)$3:#=.#)$(B!!!<br />

dVe[_d[[]! +'7!3!! 7U%#.:#3$$! 67A63':'=! $?$%! U>#3! 7U%#.:#3$=3#(! &'>!(3'%:!.!(B!<br />

V[[]_d[[^! +'7!3!! H0:$+70%! XU%#.:#3$$! )':!>3!=3'()'! T'3:0%#33'! -'(3!!%!%!<br />

'>'3.!3:'+!!=0%6+6%)'!NG#3$(.$3#%!^!.'%#!+#(0.$@P!&#)#13#(!G#3$(3#:#=.#)$(h!VVef_d[[e!<br />

+'7!3!!XU%#.:#3$=!$+#!76:6(.'5!!.'-6=3'()'!/'07.&"00')"&#"$%#%8%+!-#!/G)#(,3%71$%17!<br />

-'(3!!%!%! '>'3.!3:'+!! =0%6+6%)'! &#)#13#(! G#3$(3#(B! VVZZ_d[[e! +'7!3!! XU%#.:#3$=4!<br />

='%'.3!3'()'! T'3:0%#33'! $?$%! U>#3! =0%.(03! 7U%.#:3#($! =633'%!3:'+!! $3#! $3A$3$!<br />

A#(#=3$3$=3#($!0(.'7'!=07'(4!U(%#$%!'!3':'!-#7'!'%.$G$70.$=!.#)'-$+$!A$G$B!<br />

26! 7U%#.:#3$=.#4! '%.$G$70.$#! )$(#%?3$! +63'(!%! +#?$3:#+$! -#! )'!3!:!! G$(! ($+=!<br />

036.6()66%)'%!'%.$G$70.$=!=633'%!3:':'+!!.#-$=!#)$3:#=.#)$(B!T@#+$1$=!'%.$G$70.$=!<br />

=633'%!:!%'!''!)'!G#3$(.$3#%!$=$!)6(6:)'!$>$%!-#($3:#=.#)$(Y!!!<br />

! !WC


VB! C#%#.$=!03'('=!)##(3$!='%'.3!!.D(3#($%)#!!<br />

dB! H'%'.3!3'()'!=3$%$=!@(0G3#:3#(!0(.'7'!?!=.!!%)'B!!!<br />

;%.$G$70.$=3#($%! )'&'! U%5#! G#3$(.$3#%! )6(6:3'(! )!!%)'! 636+'3! T'3:0%#33'! =0%.(03!<br />

@(0A(':3'(!%)'!=633'%!3:'+!%'!$>$%!-#($3:#:#3$)$(B!!!<br />

;!3':'! T'3:0%#33'7'! ='(!! )$(#%5$! '(..!(:'=! -#! :$=(00(A'%$>:'%!%! 7'7!3:'+!%!!<br />

)6()6(:'=!$?$%!#=!G$(!U%3#:!03'('=!)DD%D3:#=.#)$(B!H#+$:! U%5#+$! G#=3#:#! +D(#+$!<br />

&'($?!03:'=!D>#(#4!GD.D%!D(#.$:!+D(#+$%5#!5'%3!!-#7'!$%'=.$-#!'!!=633'%!3:'+!%'!$>$%!<br />

-#($3$(B!j'%3!!'!3'('4!7'3%!>5'!'!!+66!+'&'!+63'(!%)'%!'7!(.!#)$3#G$3)$$!>':'%!$>$%!<br />

-#($3#G$3$(B!!!<br />

l00%0>! c$(#=.$1$%#! AU(#4! A#3#5#=.#! Nd[VVP! .'-6=! #.$! D(D%3#($%)#! j':@730G'5.#(! -#!<br />

T'3:0%#33'!-'(3!!!03:':'3!)!(!Nd^!A(!D(D%)#PB!J('.$=.#!G6%6%!'%3':!!$3'-#!U%3#:3#(!<br />

'3:')'%!+U>!=0%6+6!&#)#1#!63':'%!%!03)6=?'!>0(!03)66)6(B!3#:#!#=$@:'%3'(!%!%!<br />

0@.$:'3! =633'%!:!%! 7'%!! +!('! 7#.$.$(:#! +'1&'+!%)'! :'=+$:6:! &$I7#%! '(.3'(!%'!<br />

6763:'+!! 7#.#(3$! 03:'7!@! %$&'$! D(D%! )#=0%.':$%'+70%6%! #%A#33#%:#+$! $?$%! #=!<br />

U%3#:3#($%! '3!%:'+!! A#(#=$(B! X!33'(! $?#($+$%)#! ;-(6@'=0%6+6!-$>70%h!7U%#.$:4! '3.7'@!!$%''.!4!#=$@:'%_'('?bA#(#?4!)#%#.$:!+$+.#:3#($4!<br />

+06.:'! -#! )#@03':'4! D(D%! +!5'=3!!! -#! D(D%! +#(.$1$='+70%6! $3#! $3A$3$! .'%!:3'7!5!!<br />

&#)#13#(#! )'7'%!(B! `(D%! =0%.':$%'+70%6%6! =#+$%! 03'('=! 7'+'=3'(! NE7'3%!>5'! $?:#!<br />

+676! ='3$.#+$%)#=$! +676%! $3#:! +676! 03'('=! =633'%!3:'+!%'! $>$%! -#($3$(F4! '%5'=!<br />

76='(!)'! G#3$(.$3)$$! A$G$! #%! +0%! 7'@!3'%! )#$$=3$=3#(3#! G'>!! =0633'()'! D(D%!<br />

=0%.':$%'+70%6! ='G63! #)$3#G$3$(P! -#! &'-'! N+@(#73#:#P! $3#! +06.:'7!! .#-$=! #)#(B!<br />

NE)'3)!(:'! #=3$%)#! +06.:'! =633'%!3)!!%)'4! ?0=! +'7!)'! +@#+$1$=! '(.!%! 7#($%#!<br />

A#.$($3:#+$! A#(#=:#=.#)$(FPB! 8#.#($%#(! )#%#.?$3#($%! G$3A$! -#! )#%#7$:$73#! $3A$3$!<br />

&#)#13#($! G#3$(3#(! -#! &'%A$! D(D%! #=+$=3$=3#($%$%! $%+'%! .D=#.$:$%#! 67A6%! 03:')!!%!!<br />

+@#+$1$=!03'('=!.'%!:3'(B!!<br />

d[[f! 7!3!%)'! ;-(6@'! 2$(3$$3!! $3#:3#(! -#! )$#(! &$I7#%! =0%.(03! U%3#:3#($%$%!<br />

)0(63':'! -#! 0%'73':'! '('5!! 03'('=! =633'%!3'G$3$(B! 9$5(0G$7'3! =($.#(3#(4! ;-(6@'!<br />

2$(3$$!:#->6'.!%)'!.#&3$=#!=0%.(03!+#-$7#+$!$3#!$3A$3$!($+=!$3#.$$:$%$%!G$(!7036!03'('=!<br />

)'! =633'%!3'G$3$(B! 26! =($.#(3#(4! G'>!! @'.0I#%3#($%! ='G63! #)$3#:#>! )#(#5#)#! 7D=+#=!<br />

+#-$7#3#()#! G636%:'7'5'!%!! A'('%.$! '3.!%'! '3!(=#%! +U>! =0%6+6! @'.0I#%3#($%! &$?!<br />

G636%:':'+!%!!$+#!A'('%.$!#)#:#>B!!!<br />

C!)'!:'))#3#($!:$=(0G$7030I$=!=($.#(3#(!$3#!$3A$3$!Lj!d[Z]_d[[^!+'7!3!!XU%#.:#3$=!$=$!<br />

=($.#($!='@+':'=.')!(B!26%3'(!VB!C!)'!CD-#%3$$!H($.#($!-#!dB!3#:!\$I7#%!H($.#($B!!<br />

C!)'! CD-#%3$$! H($.#(3#($! AD%D:D>)#! .D:! A!)'! D(#.$:! >$%5$($%$! ='@+'(4! D(#.$5$3#($!<br />

=($.#(3#(#!67:'7'!E>0(3'(F!-#!A!)'!AD-#%3$$!-#!=':6!+'3!!%'!)03'73!!03'('=!='.=!)'!<br />

G636%'G$3$(B!9$=(0G$7'3!=($.#(3#(4!;2!A!)'!:#->6'.!%!%!\;jjJ!@(#%+$@3#($!-#!A!)'!$$!<br />

7'@'%! $3#.:#3#($! )#%#.3#:#=! D>#(#! A#(?#=3#.$($3#5#=! (#+:$! =0%.(033#(! A$G$! )$#(!<br />

7U%3#($!AU>!U%D%#!'3!%:')'%!)##(3#%)$($3:#:#3$)$(3#(B!NL*T;!w06(%'3!d[[ZY!ged4!Vb<br />

dWPB! 3#:! &$I7#%! =($.#(3#($4! A!)'! D(#.$:! +$+.#:3#($%)#! \;jjJ! =6('33'(!%!%! ='G63!<br />

#)$3#G$3$(! #=$3)#! 67A63'%)!!%!%! G$(! AU+.#(A#+$)$(B! cD>#3.$5$! .#)G$(3#($%! &'%A$!<br />

=0%.':$%'+70%!+#-$7#+$%)#!'3!%:'+!!A#(#=.$$%$!G#3$(3#(B!<br />

9$=(0G$7'3! =($.#(3#(! ='%'.3!3'(! )'&$3! 03:'=! D>#(#4! #.! D(D%3#($4! +D.! -#! +D.! D(D%3#($4!<br />

76:6(.'! D(D%3#($4! G'3!=! D(D%3#($! -#! +#G>#3#(4! :#7-#3#(! -#! G6%3'(!%! D(D%3#($! ='@+'(B!<br />

! !WH


;7%!! >':'%)'! U(%#=! '3:'! -#! U(%#=! &'>!(3':'! =6('33'(!! )'! .'($1! #)$3:$.$(B!<br />

XU%#.:#3$=.#!.'-6=!#.$!-#7'!76:6(.'!D(D%3#($%)#!T'3:0%#33'4!.0@3':!'#(0G$=!=030%$!<br />

+'7!3'(!!-#!!L%.#(0G'5.#($'5#'#!=030%$!+'7!3'(!!$3#!$3A$3$!=($.#(3#(#!)#!7#(!-#($3:#=.#)$(B!<br />

26!3$+.#7#!j':@730G'5.#(!)'&$3!#)$3:#:$.$(B!!!<br />

D.F5-&.$AO)&'-&.(,/&$@&$(-&)&$1&'('-&.(,/&$*(M5&,$!<br />

H#+$:#! AU%)#($3#%! 5'%3!! &'7-'%3'(! '7'=3'(!%)'4! .D73#($%)#4! )#($3#($%)#! -#!<br />

G'!(+'=3'(!%)'! ?0=! +'7!)'! :$=(00(A'%$>:'! .'!(3'(B! H#+$:! $3#:$! +!('+!%)'! =63'(!<br />

U3)D(D3D(4! ='%!! '=!.!3!(4! &'3'%!(! -#! $?! 0(A'%3'(!!?!='(!3:')'%! U%5#! .D73#($! 7036%6@!<br />

+@(#73#:#!$3#!7!='%!@!+06.636(B!c'&'!+0%('!='(='+3'(!7'!$3#($!$3#:#)#!=633'%!3'5'=!<br />

@'(?'3'('! '7(!3:'=! D>#(#! @'(?'3':'! GU3D:D%#! 7')'! .D:! ='(='+! 03'('=! @'=#.3#%$@!<br />

.#+$+.#%!?!='5'=3'(!!GU3D:#!AU%)#($3$(3#(B!`(D%3#($%!-#_-#7'!#=$@:'%3'(!%!:$=(0G$7'3!<br />

=0%.':$%'+70%6%6%! =0%.(03! #)$3:#+$! %0=.'+!%)'! G$(! ='?! =($.$=! '':'! :#-56..6(B!<br />

n'=3$7#! -#! 5'%3!! =63'(!%! '+!3:'+!!$3#:3#($%)#%! ='7%'=3'%'%! +.(#+4! -'(+'! @'.0I#%$=!<br />

:$=(00(A'%$>:'3'(!%! '(.'%! G$(! #=$3)#! +'?!3:'+!%'! %#)#%! 036(B! TU>! =0%6+6! +'?!3:'!<br />

)6(6:6! $3#%:$! D(D%3#($%! -#! #=$@:'%3'(!%! 1'>3')'%! =0%.':$%#! 03:'+!%'! %#)#%!<br />

03'G$3$(B!26!%#)#%3#!&#(!%'=3$7#)#%!+0%('!%'=3$7#!='+'3'(!%!%!-#!=0%.#7%!(3'(!%!%!#.=$3$!<br />

#=$3)#!.#:$>3#%:#+$!-#!)#>#%1#=.#!#)$3:#+$!A#(#=$(B!!!<br />

H'%'.3!3'(!%4! :0)#(%! G$(! #=$3)#! $3#:#! .'G$! .6.63:'3'(!! 7D=+#=! 0('%)'! -#($:3$3$=!<br />

+'3':'=.')!(B!T''..#!V[B[[[!')#..#%!)'&'!1'>3'!=#+$:!='@'+$.#+$!'(.!=!7'7A!%3':'=.'!<br />

036@4!+U>!=0%6+6!=#+$:!:$=.'(!%'!7'3%!>5'!7D=+#=!)#(#5#)#!:'=$%#3#:#!-#!0.0:'.$=!<br />

$3#:! &'.3'(!73'! 63'!3'G$3:#=.#)$(B! R.0:'+70%6%! )#(#5#+$%#! G'3!! 03'('=! '7(!! '7(!!<br />

$3#:#! '':'3'(!%)'! $?$3#(! ?'3!'G$3$(! -#7'! ?'3!:'>B! 3#:! +!('+!%)'4! D(D%! -#_-#7'!<br />

.#?&$>'.3'(!%!:$=(0G$7'3!=0%.':$%'+70%6%6%!=0%.(03!#)$3:#+$%)#!=($.$=!G$(!='?!'':'!<br />

:#-56..6(B! 26! '':'3'(! =63'(!%! =#+$:)#%! U%5#! 7'='3'%:'+!4! %'=3#)$3:#+$! -#!<br />

.6.63:'+!! )'&$3! 036@4! :#-56.! '(.3'(!%! =63'(!%! .D7! -#! )#($3#($%$%! 1#='3!<br />

=0%.':$%'+70%6!D>#($%)#!U%#:3$!G$(!#.=$+$! -'()!(B!26!%#)#%3#!&#(!%'=3$7#)#%!+0%('!<br />

%'=3$7#! ='+'3'(!%!%! -#! =0%.#7%!(3'(!%!%! #.=$3$! #=$3)#! .#:$>3#%:#+$! -#! )#>#%1#=.#!<br />

#)$3:#+$! A#(#=:#=.#! 036@! +64! )#.#(I'%4! #%#(I$! -#! $AD5D! =633'%!:!! G'=!:!%)'%! #%!<br />

67A6%!7U%.#:!67A63'%:'3!)!(B!!!<br />

3#:#!$3#!$3A$3$!.#=%030I$=!A#3$:#3#(!:$=(0G$7'3!=0%.':$%'+70%6%!=0%.(03!#)$3:#+$%$!<br />

=03'73'.!(:'7'! 7'()!:5!! 03'G$3$(B! k0=! '':'3!! &'3':'4! .D7! 703:'4! $?! 0(A'%3'(!!<br />

?!='(:'! .#=%030I$+$%)#! -#! .#?&$>'.3'(!%! 0.0:'.$=! 03'('=! .#:$>3#%:#+$! -#! )#>#%1#=.#!<br />

#)$3:#+$%)#!7#%$!A#3$:#3#(!='7)#)$3:$!036@!G6!#=$3)#!:$=(0G$7'3!=0%.':$%'+70%!<br />

'>'3.!3'G$3:#=.#)$(B!TU>!=0%6+6!A#3$:#3#(!1'(=3!!H($.$=!H0%.(03!n0=.'3'(!%)'!NjjJP!<br />

='(='+3'(!%!:$=(0G$7030I$=!='3$.#+$!$?$%!&'%A$!+!%!(3':'3'(!%!='G63!#)$3:#+$!A#(#=.$$!<br />

+0(6+6%6!0(.'7'!'.:'=.')!(B!!!<br />

8'(! 03'%! 0(A'%$>:'3'(!!=!+'! +D(#)#! G#3$(3#:#=! $?$%! 7#.#($%5#! &!>3!4! )0(6! -#! 67A6%!<br />

03'%!:$=(0!G$7030I$=!7U%.#:3#(4!G#3$(3#%#%!=($.$=!3$:$.3#($! $>3#:#=!-#!=0%.(03!#.:#=!<br />

':'5!73'!=633'%!3!(B!!<br />

;7(!5'4!$3#:#!.#+$+$%)#!D(D%!=0%.':$%'+70%!+#-$7#3#($%$!'7'(3':'=!$?$%!'3!%'G$3#5#=!<br />

U%3#:3#($%!=633'%!3'G$3$(3$$!+0(6+6!AD%)#:#!A#3:#=.#)$(B!`?D%5D!03'('=4!G#3$(3#%#%!<br />

3$:$.3#()#=$%)#%! )'&'! 7D=+#=! +'7!)'! :$=(00(A'%$>:'! G636%'%! D(D%3#(3#! %#3#(!<br />

7'@!3'G$3#5#$! &6+6+6! '?!=! )#$3)$(B! 26! +!%!(3':'3'()'%! )03'7!4! \;jjJ! +$+.#:$%$%!<br />

7'%!!+!('! 7$%#! '':'3!! G$(! .#&3$=#! '%'3$>$! $?#(#%! '%5'=! D(D%D%! .D=#.$3:#+$%#! G'3!!<br />

03'('=! $%+'%! +'3!!! D>#($%)#! 036:+6>! #.=$! 7'('.:'! 03'+!3!!%!! .'&:$%! #)#%!<br />

)#+.#=3#7$5$! :'&$7#..#! G$(! ='%.$.'.$1! ($+=! '%'3$>$! )#! =633'%!3:'3!)!(B! ;7%!! >':'%)'!<br />

GU73#! G$(! '%'3$>4! 67A63'%:'+!%'! $>$%! -#($3)$$! 7#(3#()#4! ='(='+! )#=0%.':$%'+70%!<br />

$3#:$!A$G$!+@#+$1$=!&$I7#%!:D)'&'3#!U%3#:3#($%$%!0(.'7'!?!='('5'!!7'('(3'(!'?!+!%)'%!<br />

G$(!AU+.#(A#!03'G$3$(B!!<br />

! !WJ


!<br />

.'+1',!?#1%56'(-5',K%5/!!<br />

;2c! -#! )$#(! D3=#3#($%! '=+$%#! ;2! D3=#3#($%)#! ='(='+! )#=0%.':$%'+70%6%'! $>$%!<br />

-#($3:#:#=.#)$(B! 26%6%3'! G$(3$=.#4! 636+3'('('+!! .$5'(#.! -#! A#3#5#=.#=$! T'3:0%#33'! -#!<br />

j':@730G'5.#(! &#)#13#($%#! 63':'7'! 7U%#3$=! )'&$3$! G'+=!3'(! )'&'! '?!=! G$(! .'-!(!<br />

'3!%:'+!%'!='.=!!+'3':!.!(B!26!=0%6!&'3$&'>!()'!2(D=+#3! =0%6+6! =$:7'+'3! :'))#3#($%! ?#-(#! D>#($%)#=$! #.=$3#($! =0%6+6%)'!<br />

#%)$#!.'!:'=.')!(B!!!!<br />

H'(='+!)#=0%.':$%'+70%6%6%!67A63':'7'!=0%63:'+!!$3#!G$(3$=.#!)D%7'!?'@!%)'!)'&'!<br />

&'(:0%$>#!G$(!$3#:#!)6(6:6!0(.'7'!?!='5'=.!(B!!<br />

!<br />

=-TK#5!>#!1'&-6#!KU5#6-(-!!<br />

H'%'.3!!D(#.$:$%$%!&#(!+'1&'+!4!76:6(.'3'(!%!.0@3'%:'+!!-#!)$#(!$3#:3#(4!='(='+3'(!%!<br />

$3#:#! .'G$! .6.63:'3'(!! )'&$3! 03:'=! D>#(#! &'7-'%3'()'%! A!)'! D(#.$:$! $?$%! =633'%!3'%!<br />

GD.D%! +$+.#:3#(! \;jjJ! =0%+#@.$! $?$%#! '3!%'G$3$(B! H($.$=! H0%.(03! n0=.'3'(!! NjjJP!<br />

D(#.$:!)U%AD+D%D%!GD.D%!'':'3'(!%)'!7#(!'3'G$3$(B!26!)6(6:)'4!\;jjJ!7'=3'!:!!<br />

7$!\$I7#%!,7A63':'3'(!!NC\JP!-#!7$!:'3'.!,7A63':'3'(!%)'=$!NC9JP!1'=.U(3#($%!<br />

G$(!=0:G$%'+70%6%)'%!0366(B!!<br />

\;jjJ! )'&$3! 03:'=! D>#(#! ='3$.#! AD-#%5#+$! +$+.#:3#($4! +')#5#! 7$! \$I7#%!<br />

,7A63':'3'(!!NC\JP!-#7'!7$!:'3'.!,7A63':'3'(!!NC9JP!$3#!$3A$3$!=6('33'('!67A6%!<br />

G$(!#=$3)#!D(#.$:!7'@!3)!!!.'=.$()#!#.=$3$!G$(!#=$3)#!67A63'%'G$3$(B!!<br />

\#:#%! &#:#%! GD.D%! A#3$:$! D3=#! &D=D:#.3#($! -#! #%)D+.($3#($4! &'7-'%+'3! 0($I$%3$!<br />

D(D%3#()#! -#! U>#33$=3#! )#! ='%'.3!! #.$4! 76:6(.'3'(! -#! 76:6(.'! D(D%3#($%)#! A!)')'%!<br />

G63''%! $%+'%! @'.0I#%3#($%$%! '>'3.!3:'+!! =0%6+6%)'! '%3':'7'! -'(:!3'()!(B! 26!<br />

@'.0I#%! '>'3.:'! @(0A(':3'(!4! +@#+$1$=! \;jjJ! @3'%3'(!%!%4! .#+$+! .#:$>3$$! -#!<br />

)#>#%1#=+$70%6! $3#! $3A$3$! +.'%)'(.! ?'3!:'! @(0+#)D(3#($%$%! -#! '%'! @'.0I#%3#(! $?$%! .#+.!<br />

@(0.0=033#($%$%!67A63'%:'+!!&6+6+3'(!%!!$?#(:#=.#)$(B!!!<br />

\;jjJ!=0%+#@.$%$%!5'%3!!&'7-'%!D(#.$:$%)#!67A63'%'G$3$(3$$!=6=636)6(B!;%5'=!+0%!<br />

)U%#:!$.$G'($73#!.'-6=!-#!&$%)$!#.!D(#.$:$%#!7U%#3$=!\;jjJ!@3'%3'(!! $3#! $3A$3$! G'>!!<br />

U(%#=3#(! 7'7!%3'%:!! 036@! 76:6(.'5!! .'-6=! ?$1.3$=3#($%)#! 67A63'%:'=! $?$%! )#! G'>!!<br />

@3'%3'(! :#-56..6(B! \;jjJ! =6('33'(!%!%! ='%'.3!! D(#.$:$%)#%! ?0=! ='%'.3!! $3#:#!<br />

1''3$7#.3#($%#!7U%#3$=!03'('=!67A63'%:'+!!?0=!)'&'!67A6%)6(B!!<br />

$<br />

"F,7_-+.$$<br />

C#%#3! C!)'! H'%6%6%'! )'7'%'%! A!)'! AD-#%3$$! $3#! $3A$3$! ;2! :#->6'.!! +0%! )#(#5#!<br />

=0:@3#=+!036@!+D(#=3$!03'('=!7#%$3#%:#=.#)$(B!!<br />

! !WN


l00%0>! XU%#.:#3$$$ Nd[[]_WWLjP! 7D(D(3D=.#)$(B! ;%5'=4! &'3=! +'3!!! '?!+!%)'%!<br />

U%#:3$! >00%0>! 'I'%3'(!%! 0(.'7'! ?!=!!%!! '>'3.:'=! -#! =0%.(03! #.:#=! ':'5!73'! #.=$3$!<br />

.#)G$(3#(! '3!%'G$3:#+$! $?$%! ! ! ?#(?#-#! :#->6'.!%)'! NLj_dVe[_d[[]P! 7#(! '3'%! G'>!!<br />

)#.'73'(!%!$?3#($%$%!)03)6(63:'+!!A#(#=:#=.#)$(B!!<br />

T'3:0%#33'!=0%6+6%)'!.#:#3!)##(3#%)$(:#!?'3!:'3'(!!7'@!3:!!-#!&'3#%!7'@!3:'=.'!<br />

036@!+U>!=0%6+6!?'3!:'3'(!;2!`7#!c#-3#.3#($00%0>!'I'%3'(!%!:#-56.!-'(3!!%!!<br />

AU+.#(:#=.#)$(B! 26! .#:#3! )##(3#%)$(:#! ?'3!:'3'(!! ?#(?#-#+$%)#! T'3:0%#33'%!%!<br />

=0%.(03!#)$3:#+$%#!7U%#3$=!&#)#13#(!&#(!G$(!`7#!)#-3#.!$?$%!1'(=3!!+0%6?3'(!+'3'7'5'=!<br />

#=$3)#!G#3$(3#%:#=.#)$(B!26!)'!;-(6@'!2$(3$$!$?$%)#!&#(=#+#!#$.!1!(+'.!-#($3:#+$%$!<br />

+'3'7'5'=!-#!='?!%!3:'>!#=$3)#!D?D%5D!D3=#3#()#%!$.&'3'.!&#)#13#($%$!G#3$(3#7#5#=.$(B!!<br />

T0%! )U%#:! $.$G'($73#! ='%'.3!3'()'! T'3:0%#33'7!! =0%.(03! #.:#=! $?$%! '%.$G$70.$=! -#!<br />

'!3'(!%! =633'%!3:'+!73'! $3A$! :#->6'.! .':':3'%:!.!(B! H'(='+! )#=0%.':$%'+70%673'!<br />

$3A$3$!:#->6'.!%!#%!=!+'!>':'%)'!.':':3'%:'+!!-#!+U>!=0%6+6!:#->6'.!%!636+3'('('+!!<br />

.$5'(#.$%! ;2! )!!%)'=$! D3=#3#(3#! 676:36! &'3#! A#.$($3:#+$%#! ='.=!)'! G636%:'+!!<br />

G#=3#%:#=.#)$(B!!<br />

d[[W! 7!3!%)'! ;-(6@'! 2$(3$$%)#4! j':@730G'5.#($0+$+! $%+'%3'()'! #%! 7'7A!%! #=$3)#!<br />

('@0(!#)$3#%!A'+.(0$%.#+.$%'3!G'=.#($7#3!@'.0I#%)$B!C!)'!:'))#3#($%)#!j':@730G'5.#(!<br />

@0>$.$1!%6:6%#3#($%!GD7D=!G$(!GU3D:D4!%6:6%#3#($%!0(.'3':'!03'('=!t]V$.$1!<br />

03)66! .'>#! ='%'.3!! #.$%)#%! ('@0(! #)$3:$.$B! j':@730G'5.#(! '7%!! >':'%)'! 5'%3!!<br />

='%'.3!3'()'4!)0:6>3'()'!-#!GD7D=G'!&'7-'%3'()'!)'!7'7A!%!#=$3)#!.#+@$.!#)$3:$.$(B!<br />

T'3:0%#330+$+4! d[[W! 7!3!%)'! #%! ?0=! ('@0(! #)$3#%! $=$%5$! @'.0I#%)$(B! Vf! D7#! )#-3#.!<br />

)':!>3!=!=D:#+!&'7-'%!!+D(D3#($%)#!;-(6@'!2$(3$$!T'3:0%#33'!&#)#1$%$!.6..6(:64!VZ!<br />

D7#!)#-3#.!76:6(.'5!!.'-6=3'(!$?$%!'>'3.:'!&#)#1$%#!63':!!-#!Vf!D7#!)#-3#.!$+#!d[VV!<br />

7!3!%)'! 63'!3:'+!! @3'%3'%'%! G(073#(3#()#! '>'3.:'! &#)#1$%$! A#(?#=3#.$(:$.$(B!<br />

T'3:0%#330+$+!-'='3'(!!G$3)$($:!0('%!%)'=$!$+.'.$+.$=+#3!03'('=!U%#:3$!)DD!#$3$:$!^B!<br />

7!3)'! )'! )#-':! #.:$.$(B! /G) "&#"$%#%8%+! '>'3:!4! /G) #(,3%71$%17! '(.:!.!(B!<br />

ET'3:0%#330+$+! -'='3'(!%)'! AU>3#:3#%#%! '>'3:'%!%! .#:#3! 03'('=! 636+'3! T'3:0%#33'!<br />

=0%.(03! @(0A(':3'(!%!%! =D:#+! &'7-'%3'(!! @0@D3'+70%3'(!%)'! G''(!73'!<br />

67A63'%:'+!%)'%!='7%'=3'%)!!! -'(+'7!3:'=3'! G#('G#(! A!)'! >$%5$($! $?#($+$%)#! '3!%'%!<br />

)$#(! =0%.(03! U%3#:3#($%$%! )#! +U>! =0%6+6! '>'3:'7'! ='.=!)'! G636%:6! 03)66!<br />

+U73#%#G$3$(BF!NL*T;!d[VVPB!<br />

$<br />

%+5,+A-+.$!<br />

;%0%4!d[[^'B!K(#'.:#%.!01!@063.(7!5'(5'++#+!Q$.&!5&30($%#!)$0M$)#4!'5$)$1$#)!+0)$6:!5&30($)#4!.($+0)$6:!<br />

@&0+@&'.#!'%)!@#(0M7'5$)+B!L*T;!w06(%'3!d[[^!dWZYVbdZh!!<br />

;%0%4!d[[^GB!L-'36'.$0%!01!.&#!#11$5'57!01!@#(0M7'5$)+!10(!6+#!'+!'%!'%.$:$5(0G$'3!+6G+.'%5#!'@@3$#)!0%!<br />

@063.(7!5'(5'++#+B!L*T;!w06(%'3!d[[^!][eYVbV[h!!<br />

;%0%4!d[[e'B!L-'36'.$0%!01!.&#!#11$5'57!01!!ir!i'5.$5!;5$)!10(!5'(5'++!)#50%.':$%'.$0%B!L*T;! w06(%'3!<br />

d[[e!]gdYVbeh!!<br />

;%0%4! d[[eGB! L-'36'.$0%! 01! .&#! #11$5'57! 01! ! T'%bJ#3! 10(! 6+#! '+! '%! '%.$:$5(0G$'3! +6G+.'%5#! '@@3$#)! 0%!<br />

5'(5'++#+!01!5&$5=#%+4!.6(=#7+4!S6'$3+4!@$A+!G##1!+&##@!A0'.+!'%)!A':#!'%)!$%!Q'+&$%A!01!+&#33+!01!#AA+B!<br />

L*T;!w06(%'3!d[[e!]^dY!Vbe!<br />

;%0%4!d[[ZB!L*T;!R@$%$0%!01!.&#!T5$#%.$1$5!J'%#3!0%!2$030A$5'3!\'>'()+!0%!:$5(0G$030A$5'3!5($.#($'!'%)!<br />

.'(A#.+!G'+#)!0%!($+=!'%'37+$+B!!L*T;!w06(%'3!d[[ZY!gedh!VbdW!<br />

;%0%4! d[V['B! K&#! j0::6%$.7! +6::'(7! (#@0(.! 0%! .(#%)+! '%)! +06(5#+! 01! >00%0+#+4! >00%0.$5! 'A#%.+! '%)!<br />

100)bG0(%#!06.G(#'=+!$%!.&#!L6(0@#'%!,%$0%!$%!d[[f4!L*T;!w06(%'3!Nd[V[P4!VgWe!<br />

;%0%4!d[V[GB!;%'37+$+!01!.&#!G'+#3$%#!+6(-#7!0%!.&#!@(#-'3#%5#!01!j':@730G'5.#(!$%!G(0$3#(!G'.5&#+!'%)!01!<br />

j':@730G'5.#(!'%)!T'3:0%#33'!0%!G(0$3#(!5'(5'++#+!$%!.&#!L,!d[[f4!J'(.!;B!j':@730G'5.#(!'%)!T'3:0%#33'!<br />

@(#-'3#%5#!#+.$:'.#+B!L*T;!w06(%'3!Nd[V[P4!fN[]P4!V^[]!<br />

;%0%4!d[VV'B!;%'37+$+!01!.&#!G'+#3$%#!+6(-#7!0%!.&#!@(#-'3#%5#!01!j':@730G'5.#(!$%!G(0$3#(!G'.5&#+!'%)!01!<br />

j':@730G'5.#(!'%)!T'3:0%#33'!0%!G(0$3#(!5'(5'++#+!$%!.&#!L,!d[[f4!J'(.!2B!;%'37+$+!01!1'5.0(+!'++05$'.#)!<br />

Q$.&!T'3:0%#33'!50%.':$%'.$0%!01!G(0$3#(!5'(5'++#+B!L*T;!w06(%'3!Nd[VVP4!WNdP4!d[V]!<br />

! !WT


!;%0%4!d[VVGB!K&#!L6(0@#'%!,%$0%!+6::'(7!(#@0(.!0%!.(#%)+!'%)!+06(5#+!01!>00%0+#+4!>00%0.$5!'A#%.+!<br />

'%)!100)bG0(%#!06.G(#'=+!$%!d[[WB!L*T;!w06(%'3!d[VV4!W!N]P4!d[W[!<br />

203)#(4!nB9B!d[[^B!L,!@#(+@#5.$-#!0%!@'.&0A#%!50%.(03!$%!@063.(7!:#'.!'%)!#AA+B!J063.(7!9#'.!'%)!LAA+!<br />

Å6'3$.7!T7:@0+$6:4!;6G6(%!,%$-#(+$.74!;6G6(%4!;3'G':'4!,T;4!w637!][b;6A6+.!]B!<br />

c$(#5.$-#!Wf_]Z_Lj!01!.&#!L6(0@#'%!@'(3$':#%.!'%)!01!.&#!j06%5$3!01!dd!w6%#!VWWf!0%!.&#!'@@(0M$:'.$0%!01!<br />

.&#!3'Q+!01!.&#!9#:G#(!T.'.#+!(#3'.$%A!.0!:'5&$%#(7!<br />

c$(#5.$-#! d[[]_WW_Lj! 01! .&#! L6(0@#'%! @'(3$':#%.! '%)! 01! .&#! j06%5$3! 01! VZ! n0-#:G#(! d[[]! 0%! .&#!<br />

:0%$.0($%A! 01! >00%0+#+! '%)! >00%0.$5! 'A#%.+4! ':#%)$%A! j06%5$3! c#5$+$0%! W[_gdg_LLj! '%)! (#@#'3$%A!<br />

j06%5$3!c$(#5.$-#!Wd_VVZ_LLj!!<br />

\;jjJ! $%! 9#'.4! J063.(7! '%)! *$+&! J(05#++$%A4! ;)-'%5#+! $%! 9#'.! "#+#'(5&4! 803! V[4! VWW^4! #)+! ;B9B!<br />

J#'(+0%!'%)!KB"B!c6.+0%4!i0%)0%4!,H4!23'5=$#!;5')#:$5!u!J(01#++$0%'3B!<br />

\;jjJ!$%!.&#!9#'.!O%)6+.(74!d[[[4!#)!9B!2(0Q%4!j':G($)A#4!,H4!a00)&#')!J6G3$+&$%A!<br />

\6A'+4! 9B4! d[[^B! T5$#%.$1$5! +.(65.6(#+! $%! L*T;! '%)! .&#! #M@#(.$+#! (#S6$(#)! 10(! "$+=! ;++#++:#%.B! |8OO .&!<br />

L6(0@#'%!T7:@0+$6:!0%!.&#!Å6'3$.7!01!J063.(7!9#'.!'%)!|O .& !T7:@0+$6:!0%!.&#!Å6'3$.7!01!LAA+!'%)!LAA!<br />

J(0)65.+4!c00(Q#(.&4!K&#!n#.&#(3'%)+4!d]bde!9'7B!<br />

9#')4!CBjB!#.!'3B!T5$#%.$1$5!'%)!.#5&%$5'3!1'5.0(+!'11#5.$%A!.&#!+#..$%A!01!T'3:0%#33'!5($.#($'!10(!('Q!@063.(7B!<br />

w06(%'3!01!*00)!J(0.#5.$0%!Z]4!V^eebV^W[!<br />

9$5(0G$'3!j0%.(03!$%!.&#!9#'.!O%)6+.(74!L,!j0%5#(.#)!;5.$0%!jK!Wg!p!Vg^e4!VWWZ4!T#($#+!L)$.0(+Y!9B\B!<br />

\$%.0%4!CBjB!9#')!'%)!jB!"0Q3$%A+4!2($+.034!,H4!,%$-#(+$.7!01!2($+.03!J(#++B!<br />

963)#(4! "BaB;BaB! '%)! \B! \6@=#+4! d[[^B! L6(0@#'%! i#A$+3'.$0%! $%! (#3'.$0%! .0! @063.(7! :#'.! '%)! #AA+B!<br />

J063.(7!9#'.!'%)!LAA+!Å6'3$.7!T7:@0+$6:4!;6G6(%!,%$-#(+$.74!;6G6(%4!;3'G':'4!,T;4!w637!][b;6A6+.!<br />

]B!<br />

J063.(7!:#'.!@(05#++$%A!'%)!S6'3$.74!d[[g4!#)!CBjB!9#')4!j':G($)A#4!,H4!a00)&#')!J6G3$+&$%A!<br />

"#A63'.$0%!NLjP!n0!VZf_d[[d!01!.&#!L6(0@#'%!J'(3$':#%.!'%)!.&#!j06%5$3!01!df!w'%6'(7!d[[d!3'7$%A!)0Q%!<br />

.&#!A#%#('3!@($%5$@3#+!'%)!(#S6$(#:#%.+!01!100)!3'Q4!#+.'G3$+&$%A!.&#!L6(0@#'%!*00)!T'1#.7!;6.&0($.7!'%)!<br />

3'7$%A!)0Q%!@(05#)6(#+!$%!:'..#(+!01!100)!+'1#.7!!<br />

"#A63'.$0%!NLjP!n0!dVe[_d[[]!01!.&#!L6(0@#'%!@'(3$':#%.!'%)!01!.&#!j06%5$3!01!V!<br />

n0-#:G#(!d[[]!0%!.&#!50%.(03!01!+'3:0%#33'!'%)!0.&#(!+@#5$1$#)!100)bG0(%#!>00%0.$5!'A#%.+!!!<br />

"#A63'.$0%! NLjP! n0! V[[]_d[[^! ! 01! ][! w6%#! d[[^! $:@3#:#%.$%A! "#A63'.$0%! Lj! dVe[_d[[]! '+! (#A'()+! '!<br />

j0::6%$.7!.'(A#.!10(!.&#!(#)65.$0%!01!.&#!@(#-'3#%5#!01!5#(.'$%!+'3:0%#33'!+#(0.7@#+!$%!G(##)$%A!1305=+!01!<br />

O'001+)2'001+)'%)!':#%)$%A!"#A63'.$0%!NLjP!n0!dVe[_d[[]!<br />

"#A63'.$0%!Lj!d[Z]_d[[^!01!V^!n0-#:G#(!d[[^!R%!:$5(0G$030A$5'3!5($.#($'!10(!100)+.611+!!<br />

"#A63'.$0%! Lj! VVef_d[[e! 01! ]V! w637! d[[e4! $:@3#:#%.$%A! "#A63'.$0%! Lj! dVe[_d[[]! '+! (#A'()+! '!<br />

j0::6%$.7! .'(A#.! 10(! .&#! (#)65.$0%! 01! .&#! @(#-'3#%5#! 01! 5#(.'$%! T'3:0%#33'! +#(0.7@#+! $%! 3'7$%A! &#%+! 01!<br />

O'001+)2'001+!'%)!':#%)$%A!"#A63'.$0%!Lj!V[[]_d[[^!<br />

"#A63'.$0%! Lj! VVZZ_d[[e! 01! V! ;6A6+.! d[[e4! $:@3#:#%.$%A! "#A63'.$0%! Lj! dVe[_d[[]! '+! (#A'()+!<br />

(#S6$(#:#%.+! 10(! .&#! 6+#! 01! +@#5$1$5! 50%.(03! :#.&0)+! $%! .&#! 1(':#Q0(=! 01! .&#! %'.$0%'3! @(0A(':+! 10(! .&#!<br />

50%.(03!01!T'3:0%#33'!$%!@063.(7B!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

! !WW


K'G30!VB!;2$.$1!G(073#(!+D(D3#($!7'7A!%3!!4!d[[^!<br />

`7#!c#-3#.! m(%#=!+'7!+!! J0>$.$1!NtP! K'&:$%$!7!33!=!7'7A!%3!=!<br />

;-6+.6(7'! ]e^! [ZBZ! [^Bg!<br />

2#3?$='! ]Z]! V^B]! VdBg!<br />

H!G(!+! dgf! V[BW! [WBV!<br />

k#=!j6:&6($7#.$! ]]g! ddB^! VWB]!<br />

c'%$:'(='! dW^! []BV! [VBe!<br />

L+.0%7'! V]V! [dBd! [dB[!<br />

*$%3'%)$7'! ]e[! [[B]! [[BV!<br />

*('%+'! ]fV! [fBW! [eBd!<br />

;3:'%7'! ]ZZ! VZBd! V^B[!<br />

X6%'%$+.'%! dg^! dZB]! dgB[!<br />

9'5'($+.'%! ]^W! e^BZ! efBd!<br />

(3'%)'! ]^V! dZBW! dZBe!<br />

.'37'! ]V]! ][Bg! dfB]!<br />

i#.0%7'! VdV! [WBV! [eBd!<br />

i$.-'%7'! V^e! [^BV! [dBW!<br />

J03'%7'! ]^Z! ^ZBZ! ^fBd!<br />

J0(.#=$>! ]eZ! gdBf! g]B^!<br />

T30-'=7'! d][! [fB]! [^BZ!<br />

T30-#%7'! ]de! []BV! [VBe!<br />

+@'%7'! ]ff! gdB]! VgBd!<br />

+-#?! dWV! [[B[! [[B[!<br />

\033'%)'! ]ed! V[Bd! [ZB^!<br />

%A$3.#(#! ]fd! V[BZ! [fBd!<br />

!<br />

K'G30!dB!;2


" #C! $?OA&1(L"08) X'-.9) /(&8$.7"!#.!+#=.U(D%)#!7''%'%!=6!A($G$!=($>$!$3=!d[[^!<br />

7!3!%)'!9'%7'+'3:'!-#!1$7'.3'()'!tg[!)D:#!<br />

AU>3#%:$!$=#%h!G6!=#>!d[[e!7!3!%)'!=($>!O)!(:'%!!$3#!7D(D..D=3#($!G''(!3!!G$(!$3#.$$:!=':@'%7'+!)!(B!<br />

$<br />

c&/5+$-&1(()($@&$:-6!-+.$<br />

C#%#3! 03'('=! :#)7'%!%! G$(! =0%676! ='@+':'+!! .D=#.$5$3#($%! ($+=! '3A!+!%!! '(.!(!(B!<br />

H6=6+6>! ($+=$%! .0@36:'! '=.'(!3:'+!! ($+=! &'==!%)'! G$3A$! -#($3$@! -#! 70(6:!<br />

7'@!3:'+!%)'!A#%#33$=3#!.0@36:6%!'%3'7'G$3#5#$!3$+'%!=633'%!(B!2$(!'%3':)'!G$3$:+#3!<br />

'?!=3':'3'(!%! .0@36:'! '=.'(!3:'+!%)'! G$(! ='%'3! -'>$1#+$! AU(D(B! \'..'! G'>!! G$3$:!<br />

$%+'%3'(!! .0@36:6%! #$.$3:#+$%)#! )#! (03#! +'&$@! 03)66%6! $3#($! +D(:#=.#)$(B! ;%5'=!<br />

:#)7'%!%! $3A$+$! .'(.!:'3!! =0%63'(! D>#($%)#)$(B! 2$3$:+#3! 1$=$(! '7(!3!=3'(!! -#! $&.$3'13'(!<br />

=!+'5'+!! G#3$(+$>3$=3#(! ! 03'%! =0%63'(!%! #3#! '3!%:'+!! U%5#3$=3$)$(B! 26! )6(6:! $+#! ($+=$%!<br />

03)66%)'%!)'&'!7D=+#=!03'('=!'3A!3'%:'+!%'!703!'?:'=.')!(!-#!\00@3'!#.=$+$!03'('=!<br />

G$3$%:#=.#)$(!N#=$3!VPB!<br />

!<br />

! !W]


!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

#3MBC.!.$2;-0-<br />

!"#$%&%'%()'<br />

'AU<br />

'-43B234<br />

V4;C.-WC0B/.2C4<br />

9/T2O,C$&


'13'.0=+$%3#($%! .'(.!:'3!! G$(! =0%6! 03:':'+!)!(h! >$('! .D:! G$3$:! $%+'%3'(!! &#:! 1$=$(!<br />

036@4!'('3'(!%)'!&#(&'%A$!G$(!$&.$3'1!70=.6(B!<br />

$<br />

B1$@&$"+-!A$:-6!-+.!$<br />

KD=#.$5$3#()#!#.!$3#!'3A!3'%'%!036:+6>36=3'(!A#%#3!03'('=!#.!.D=#.$:$!$3#!$%+'%!+'3!!!<br />

'('+!%)'=$! $3$=$!D>#($%#!=6(636!036@4!.#:#3)#!)07:6! 7'! -#! =03#+.#(03! $3#! ='3@! -#!<br />

)':'(!&'+.'3!=3'(!!-#!='%+#(!$3$=$+$!)$=='.!?#=:#=.#)$(B!H6=6+6>!.'-6=!#.$!=!(:!>!!<br />

#.#!AU(#!)'&'!'-'%.'I3!)!(B!;%5'=!D3=#3#(#!AU(#!G6!'3A!3'(!1'(=3!3!=!AU+.#(#G$3:#=.#)$(B!<br />

m(%#$%!;3:'%7'!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

#=$3!]B!KD=#.$5$3#($%!+'3!=b#.!'3A!3'(!!N2#5=#(!-#!'(=B4!d[[[PB!<br />

!<br />

;2c!!#.4!G6%6!<br />

.'=$@!#)#%!+!('!)'!G#7'>!#.!$3#!G'3!=!#.$!A#3:#=.#)$(B!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

! !Z!


!!!K'G30!VB!L.!.D=#.$:!+!=3!!!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

$<br />

$<br />

!<br />

!<br />

26%6%3'! G$(3$=.#! K'G30! d)#3#($%#! AU(#! #%! 1'>3'! G'3!=! #.$!<br />

G##%$3$(=#%4!+0%('!=!(:!>!!#.!-#!#%!'>!G#7'>!#.!G##%$3:#=.#)$(B!<br />

!<br />

K'G30!dB!2##%$!7D>)#3#($!<br />

2##%$! K'-6=!L.$! H!(:!>!!L.! 2'3!=! T'='.'.!<br />

;+3'!7#:#:! d! ]! d! dW!<br />

T#-:#:! f! g! g! df!<br />

T#-#($:! ee! ^f! gg! ]f!<br />

k0=!+#-#($:! dg! ]^! ^[! ^!<br />

;+3'!7#:#:! d! ]! d! dW!<br />

!<br />

K'-6=! #.$%$%! ='('=.#($+.$=! U>#33$=3#($! +0(A63'%)!!%)'! .'>#! AU(D%D:4! 3#>>#.! -#! =0=6!<br />

%$.#3$=3#($%$%!?0=!U%#:3$!03)66!AU>3#%:$.$(!NK'G30!]PB!K'-6=!#.$4!=!(:!>!!#.#!AU(#!<br />

)'&'!3#>>#.3$!:$!+0(6+6%'!NnoV]ZP4!='.!3!:5!3'(!%!te^#33$=3#($!<br />

! "#%=! H0=6! K'>#! i#>>#.!<br />

CU(D%D:!<br />

m%#:+$>! f! d! V! V!<br />

;>!U%#:3$! ^! ]! d! V!<br />

m%#:3$! ]f! dg! de! dZ!<br />

k0=!U%#:3$! gW! Zd! Z[! ZV!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

#=$3!gB!K'-6=!#.$%$%!3#>>#.3$3$$!<br />

!<br />

! !ZC


KD=#.$5$3#($%! A!)'! AD-#%3$$! '3A!3'(!%)'! $+#! ''!)'=$! U%#:! +!('+!%)')!(h! AU(D3)DD!<br />

ADGD!:#)7')'!7#(!'3:'7'%!)$0=+$%3#(!-#!'!(!:#.'33#(!=0%63'(!!G$3$%:#:#=.#)$(B!<br />

!<br />

K'-6=! L.$%$%!<br />

C!)'!<br />

l#&$(3#%:#3#($%#!<br />

X03!;?:'!"$+=$!<br />

s<br />

;%.$G$70.$=!<br />

\0(:0%3'(!<br />

CcR! G#+3#7$5$4! t^f!#..#!3#>>#.$%!:6.3'='!<br />

A#3$.$($3:#+$!A#(#$)$(B!!KD=#.$5$!.#(5$&3#()#!G$(!)#$$:!+U>!=0%6+6)6(!-#!G6!)#$$:!<br />

7U%#.$3:#3$)$(B! K#(5$&3#()#=$! )#$$:$%! %#)#%3#($! $3#! $3$=$3$! 1'=.U(3#(! ?#$.3$)$(h!<br />

)#$#%! 7'':! .'(>!! N\'%#)#! ?'3!'%! =')!%4! )!'(!)'! 7#:#=4! &'>!(3':'! =03'73!!4!<br />

+0+70)#:0A('1$=! 1'=.U(3#(P4! +'3!=! #%)$#3#($%$%! '(.:'+!! N)07:6! 7'4! =03#+.#(034!<br />

0G#>$.#P!-#!:#)7'!$3#.$$:$%$%!AD?3#%:#+$)$(B!<br />

2$3$:+#3! '('.!(:'3'(! +#=.U(D%! A#3#5#$%$! .'7$%! #)#5#=.$(B! C!)'! AD-#%3$$!!<br />

=0%6+6%)'=$! '('.!(:'3'(! $>3#%#G$3$(3$$%! A#3$.$($3:#+$! D>#($%#! A#%$3#:#3$! -#!<br />

$%0-'+70%!$&.$7'5!!='(!3'%:'3!)!(B!!;7(!5'!.D=#.$5$!)'-('%!3'(!%!%!$%5#3#%:#+$!-#!G$(!<br />

$3#.$$:! :0)#3$! A#3$.$($3:#+$%#! $&.$7'?! G636%:'=.')!(B! X#%$! D(D%! ?#$.3#($%$%!<br />

A#3$.$($3:#+$! $%0-'+70%! $?#(#5#=! #=$3)#4! U(%#$%! 10%=+$70%#3! #.! D(D%3#($%$%!<br />

A#3$.$($3:#+$! N90%0b@037! )07:':!! 7'! '+$)$! p! ji;! $?#($$%$%! '(.!(!3:'+!4! L!<br />

-$.':$%$4! +#3#%76:4! )#:$(P4! D>#($%#! 7U%3#%:#3$)$(B! 26! #=$3)#! .D=#.$5$3#($%! +'3!=!<br />

#%)$#3#($!='(!3'%'G$3#5#=.$(B!<br />

$<br />

%+5,+A-+.$<br />

2#5=#(4!2#%%#(!u!C3$.+5&4!2($.$+&!*00)!w06(%'34!!V[d!Nd[[[P!]Y!dgebdeeB!<br />

j#%A$>! K6(&'%! EC(06@! Z! 3#.$$:F4! ET'3!=3!! K'-6=! 2$3A$! J3'.10(:6! H6! C($G$! H($>$%$! n'+!3! XU%#..$! qF!!<br />

,36+3'('('+!!;-$'%!O%136#%>'!T#:@0>76:64!O+.'%G634!V^bVe!6G'.!d[[Z!<br />

"#+6((#55$0%4!9#'.!T5$#%5#!ee!Nd[[]P!VVpd[!<br />

"00+#%4!wB4!i6+=4!wB!iB4!u!*0M4!wB!;B!Nd[[]PB!j0%+6:#(!)#:'%)!10(!'%)!'..$.6)#+!.0Q'()!'3.#(%'.$-#!G##1!<br />

3'G#3$%A!+.('.#A$#+!$%!*('%5#4!C#(:'%7!'%)!.&#!,HB!;A($G6+$%#++4!VWNVP4!ZZpW[!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

! !ZH


" #CC $?O.A(5&f/&$?+@7A$B1($?OA&1()($@&$?OA&1(('=4!T#()'(!H':'%3!4!'&%6(!LB!c#:$(.'4!TD3#7:'%!<br />

H'3#G'!4!L%)#(!H'(')#:$(4!96('.!c0A6 !<br />

K'-6=?636=!;('.!(:'!L%+.$.D+D!<br />

!<br />

89&1$<br />

;('.!(:'4! KD(=$7#!(3'%:!.!(B!<br />

KD(=$7#


.D=#.$:$%! A#(?#=3#:#+$! G#=3#%:#=.#)$(! NdPB! *;R$37'4!V[B]f^B]]V!.0%3'!#%!1'>3'!@'7!!'3'%!D3=#3#()$(B!KD(=$7#!!#.!N+!!(4!=076%4!=#?$P!!D(#.$:$!<br />

7'@!3:'=.')!(B! 26! D3=#3#()#! d[[Z! 7!3!%)'! =$$! G'!%'! )D#%! ='%'.3!! #.$! .D=#.$:$!<br />

;2c$37'3#($%)#%! .#:$%! #..$$! .#+@$.! #)$3:$.$(! NePB! `%$-#(+$.#! U(#%5$3#($73#! 7'@!3'%!<br />

)#$$=! '('.!(:'3'()'4! .'-6=! #.$4! 76:6(.'4! )$#(! D(D%3#($%! .D=#.$:! )6(6:3'(!4!<br />

G#+3#%:#!-#!G#+$%!.D=#.$:!+!=3!=3'(!!0(.'7'!=0%63:6.6(!N!Z4f4WPB!\$%)$!#.$!D(#.$:!-#!<br />

.D=#.$:$%$%!$%5#3#%)$$!)$#(!G$(!?'3!:')'4!d[[Z!7!3!!$.$G'($73#!KD(=$7##33$=3#! &'7-'%+'3! ='7%'=3!!@(0.#$%!:$=.'(!%!%!'(..!(!3:'+!! $?$%! .D=#.$:$%$%! 7#%$)#%!<br />

AU>)#%! A#?$($3:#+$%$%! A#(#=.$$! -6(A63'%:!.!(! NVVPB! XD(D.D3#%! G6! '('.!(:'! $3#!<br />

.0@36:6%! +'3!=3!! G#+3#%:#+$! '?!+!%)'%! 03)6=?'! U%#:! '(>! #)#%! .'-6=! #.$! -#!<br />

D(D%3#($%$%!.D=#.$:$!-#!.D=#.$5$!#$3$:3#($!.#+@$.!#)$3:$.$(B!<br />

!<br />

c+1&.5+-$@&$c&1F1$<br />

;('.!(:'%!%! :'.#(7'3$%$! ='%'.3!! &'7-'%! #.$! =0%6+6%)'! .D=#.$5$3#($%! .#(5$&3#($%$!<br />

G#3$(3#:#7#! 7U%#3$=! &'>!(3'%'%! de! ')#.! +0(6)'%! 036'%! '%=#.3#(! 036.6(:6.6(B!<br />

;%=#.3#($%! KD(=$7#! .D=#.$5$! @(01$3$%$! 7'%+!.'5'=! #=$3)#! 67A63'%:'+!%!! +'3':'=!<br />

':'5!73'!KD(=$7#!+.'.$+.$=!H6(6:6!NK`HP#73#($! A$G$! )#$$=!<br />

! !ZN


1'=.U(3#(!AU>!U%D%#! '3!%'('=! eV! $3)#! ddgg!'$3#! ')(#+$! G#3$(3#%:$.$(B! J(0I#)#!AU(#-3$!<br />

.#=%$=! @#(+0%#3! '$3#3#(3#! G$(#G$(! AU(DD3#(#=! '%=#.3#(! 67A63'%:!.!(B! ;%=#.3#()#%! ]!<br />

.'%#+$! $'(#.3#:#! &'.'3'(!%)'%! )03'7!! )##(3#%)$(:#7#! '3!%:':!.!(B! L3)#! #)$3#%!<br />

-#($3#(!TJTT!VZ!@'=#.!$+.'.$+.$=!@(0A(':!73'!)##(3#%)$($3:$.$(B!!<br />

$<br />

D7-67-+.$<br />

8#($3#($%! )##(3#%)$($3:#+$! +0%656%)'4! '$3#3#()#! 7''7'%! 1#(.3#($%! 7'! A(6@3'(!4!<br />

5$%+$7#.! )'!3!:!4! A#3$(4! #$.$:! +#-$7#+$4! 0(.'3':'! '$3#! GD7D3DD%#! '$.! A#%#3! G$3A$3#(!<br />

.'G30! Vq! H$$!+'7!+!!NnP! R('%!NtP!<br />

L-#.4!!.D=#.$70(6:! dBd[d! Wf4de!<br />

\'7!(4!.D=#.:$70(6:! ]W! V4Zg!<br />

KRJi;9! dBdgV! V[[!<br />

$<br />

K'-6=! #.$! -#! D(D%3#($%$! .D=#.:#)$$%$! G#7'%! #)#%! tV4Zg! 0('%!%)'=$! '$3#%$%4! G6!<br />

D(D%3#($! .D=#.:#:#! %#)#%3#($! .'G30! ]x.#! AU(D3:#=.#)$(B! ;$3#3#($%! t]]4]]


.#=%$=3#($%$! G##%:#)$$%$! G#3$(.:$.$(B! c$#(! td^4egq!<br />

K'-6=! =#+$:$! -#! .D7! 7036:6! .#=%$=3#($%$! VV!<br />

G##%:$70(6:!<br />

dfBdV!<br />

i#>>#.$%$!G##%:$70(6:! V]! ]]B]]!<br />

8#I#.'(7#%$:! ]! ZBeW!<br />

H!(:!>!!#.!.D=#.$70(6:! d! ^BV]!<br />

c$#(! V[! d^Beg!<br />

KRJi;9! ]W! V[[!<br />

!<br />

K'-6=!#.$!-#!D(D%3#($%$!.D=#..$$%$!G#3$(.#%!dBd[d!')#.!'$3#)#!7''7'%!G$(#7!+'7!3'(!!)'!<br />

)$=='.#! '3!%'('=! 7'@!3'%! &#+'@3':')'! KD(=$7#! A#%#3$%)#! GU3A#3#(#! AU(#! )#$:#=3#!<br />

G#('G#(!0(.'3':'!7!3)'!=$$!G'!%'!Ve4eZ!=A!.'-6=!#.$!.D=#.$3)$$!G#3$(3#%:$.$(B!K'-6=!<br />

#.$!.D=#.$:$%$%!GU3A#3#(#!AU(#!)'!3!:!!$3#!$3A$3$!G$3A$3#(!.'G30!g$.$1!$3$=$!G636%:'=.')!(B!K0@36:6%!<br />

A#3$(! +#-$7#+$%#! G'3!! 03'('=! .D=#.$:! :$=.'(3'(!! )#$:#=.#)$(B! L$.$:! )D>#7$%$%!<br />

'(.!!%'!@'('3#3!03'('=!.'-6=!#.$!.D=#.$:!:$=.'(!%)'!'(.:'!AU(D3:#:#=.#)$(B!!<br />

$<br />

K'G30!gB!K'-6=!#.$!.D=#.$:$%$%!GU3A#3#(#!AU(#!)'!3!:!!<br />

2U3A#3#(!<br />

X!33!=!=$$!G'!%'!.D=#.$:!N=AP!<br />

;=)#%$>!2U3A#+$!<br />

d[BWg!<br />

H'(')#%$>!2U3A#+$!<br />

V]B^g!<br />

?!;%')036!2U3A#+$!<br />

VfBVd!<br />

9'(:'('!2U3A#+$!<br />

VeBd[!<br />

c06!;%')036!2U3A#+$! VeBZg!<br />

CD%#7!c06!;%')036!2U3A#+$! VdB]]!<br />

LA#!2U3A#+$!<br />

VdBeW!<br />

!<br />

;$3#3#($%! .'-6=! #.$! .D=#.$:! +!=3!!! 0('%3'(!! &'1.')'! G$(! ! tg]Beg4! $=$! ! t]g4ZW4! ! D?!<br />

tVe4eZ4!!)U(.!t]4^W!-#!G#!tV4]d!03'('=!)'!3!:!AU+.#(:#=.#)$(B!;$3#3#($%!7'=3'!=!<br />

7'(!+!%!%!.'-6=!#.$%$!&'1.')'!#%!'>!G$(!)#1'!.D=#..$$!AU(D3:#=.#)$(B!!<br />

K'-6=! #.$! =!+!:3'(!%!%! .D=#.$3:#! 0('%3'(!! tgg4^^! GD.D%4! t]]! G6.bG'A#.4! tVV4g[!<br />

AUD+4!te4^]!='%'.4!t]4d!@$(>03'4!t[4gV!5$#(!-#!t[4Vg!.'3!=!03'('=!G#3$(3#%:$.$(B!<br />

26!0('%3'('!'$.!G$3A$3#(!.'G30!^


K'G30!^B!K'-6=!#.$!=!+!:3'(!%!%!.#(5$&!0('%3'(!!<br />

T0(6Y! c'&'! ?0=! .'-66%! &'%A$! =!+!:3'(!%!!<br />

.#(5$&!#)$70(+6%6>q!<br />

!<br />

H$$!+'7!+!!NnP!<br />

2D.D%! WfV! ggB^^!<br />

26.b2'A#.! ZgV! ]]Be^!<br />

CUD+! d^V! VVBg[!<br />

H'%'.! Vgg! eB^]!<br />

J$(>03'! Z]! ]B]d!<br />

j$#(! W! [BgV!<br />

K'3!=! ]! [BVg!<br />

K0@3':!! dBd[d! V[[!<br />

!<br />

K'G30!eB!3#%:$!.'-6=!D(D%3#($%$%!.#(5$&!0('%3'(!!<br />

! !ZZ<br />

!<br />

R('%!NtP!<br />

T0(6Y!\'%A$!$3#%:$!.'-6=!D(D%3#($%$!.#(5$&!<br />

#)$70(+6%6>q!<br />

!<br />

H$$!+'7!+!!NnP!<br />

!<br />

R('%!NtP!<br />

$%$.>#3! VV^! VWB][!<br />

n6AA#.! g^! ZB^^!<br />

cU%#(! dVZ! ]eBgV!<br />

HU1.#b\':G6(A#(! eV! V[Bd]!<br />

T'3':bT0+$+bT656=! V^f! deB^V!<br />

K0@3':! ^We! V[[!<br />

!<br />

c$#(!='%'.3!!#.3#($%$%!.D=#.$:$!.'G30!Z4!=#=3$=!A$G$!='%'.3!!#.3#($!t^4g^! 03:'+!!<br />

.D=#.$:$!+!%!(3'%)!(:'=.')!(B!!<br />

!<br />

K'G30!ZB!K'-6=!-#!&$%)$!#.$!)!!%)'=$!)$#(!='%'.3!!#.3#($%$%!.D=#.$:!)6(6:6!<br />

T0(6Y!K'-6=!-#!&$%)$!#.$!)!!%)'!&'%A$!<br />

='%'.3!!&'7-'%!#.$%$!.D=#.$70(+6%6>q!<br />

!<br />

H$$!+'7!+!!NnP!<br />

m()#=! df! VBdZ!<br />

H#=3$=! d[! [BWV!<br />

2!3)!(5!%! ]d! VBg^!<br />

H'>! ]W! VBZZ!<br />

\#@+$! V! [B[^!<br />

\$?G$($! dB[fd! WgB^^!<br />

K0@3':! dBd[d! V[[!<br />

!<br />

R('%!NtP!<br />

!<br />

K'-6=!#.$!-#!D(D%3#($!.#:$%$!+!('+!%)'!'$3#3#($%!teZ4]^


td]4][!!.'-6=!7#:#=3#($%$%!.#(5$&!0('%3'(!!<br />

T0(6Y! i0='%.')'! 7#:#=! 7#)$$%$>! >':'%!<br />

&'%A$!.'-6=!D(D%3#($%$!.#(5$&!#)#(+$%$>q!<br />

!<br />

H$$!+'7!+!!NnP!<br />

K'-6=!)U%#(!! WZ^! ggBdf!<br />

J$3$?!?#-$(:#! dZZ! VdB^f!<br />

T636!7#:#=! def! VdBVZ!<br />

;7'=D+.D!G#+3#%:#!N*'+.b100)P! ]V! VBgV!<br />

O>A'('! e^V! dWB^e!<br />

K0@3':! dBd[d! V[[!<br />

!<br />

R('%!NtP!<br />

!<br />

;$3#3#($%! 7#.$.$(:#! #=3$%#! AU(#! =U7! .'-664! .$5'($! @$3$?! -#! 0(A'%$=! .'-66! .#(5$&!<br />

0('%3'(!! .'G30! VV


tgg4ee!3#>>#.3$!03:'+!!-#!t]4dV!0('%)'!$+#!#3)#!=#+$3:#+$)$(B!;$3#3#($%!t[4gV!0('%!!<br />

$+#!1$=$(!G#7'%!#.:#:$.$(B!!<br />

$<br />

K'G30!VVB!X#.$.$(:#!#=3$%#!AU(#!.'-6=!#.$%$%!.#(5$&!)6(6:6!<br />

T0(6Y! "#70%)'! =U7! .'-664! .$5'($! @$3$?! -#! 0(A'%$=!<br />

.'-6=!G636%:'=.')!(B!\'%A$+$%$!.#(5$&!#)#(+$%$>q!<br />

H$$!+'7!+!!NnP! R('%!<br />

NtP!<br />

K$5'($!@$3$?! ]gd! V^B^]!<br />

HU7!.'-66! VBged! eeB]W!<br />

R(A'%$=!.'-6=! ]Wf! VfB[f!<br />

K0@3':! dBd[d! V[[!<br />

!<br />

K'-6=3'(!%! &#3'3! =#+$:$! =0%6+6%)'! '$3#3#($%! )DD%5#3#($! +0(63:6! -#! G6! =0%6)'!<br />

'3!%'%!5#-'@3'(!.'G30!Vd3'!U)#:#!<br />

0('%3'(!%'! $3$=$%! G$3A$3#(! .'G30! V]3'! 03:'+!! -#! G6! 0('%)'! 1$7'.!%!%! )'! 7D=+#=! 03:'+!! ='?!%!3:'>!<br />

AU(D%:#=.#)$(B!;%=#..#!G6!D(D%#!)'&'!1'>3'!U)#:#!7'@':'7'5'!%!!G#3$(.#%!tVg4Vg!<br />

0('%!%)'=$!'$3#%$%!.#(5$&$%$%!)#$#G$3#5#$!.'&:$%!#)$3:#=.#)$(B!;$3#3#($%!tg[4ed3'!U)#:#!)6(6:6!<br />

T0(6Y! X'-'! A#3$#%! #.?$! .'-6=3'('! %#! =')'(! H$$!+'7!+!!NnP!<br />

1'>3'!U)#7#G$3$(+$%$>q!<br />

tV[!)'&'!1'>3'!U)#7#G$3$($:! ^V]! ]eB[^!<br />

td[!)'&'!1'>3'!U)#7#G$3$($:! ^ZW! g[Bed!<br />

t^[!)'&'!1'>3'!U)#7#G$3$($:! V]V! WBdV!<br />

c'&'!1'>3'!U)#:#:! d[V! VgBVg!<br />

K0@3':! VBgdg! V[[!<br />

R('%!NtP!


!<br />

;%=#.#! ='.!3'%! '$3#3#($%! tf[4fg


?+.1!)+$<br />

K'-6=! #.$! D(#.$:! '':'3'(!%)'! +'3'%'%! A#3$:#3#(3#! G$(3$=.#! A!)'! AD-#%$(3$$!<br />

'(.:!.!(B!26%6%!+0%656%)'!.0@36:)'!?#$.3$!+#G#@3#(3#!.D=#.$:!7'@:'7'%!G$(#73#(!)#!<br />

036'%! AD-#%! @(0G3#:$%$%! '!3:'+!! :D:=D%! 03'5'=.!(B! H!(:!>!! #..#! 7''%'%!<br />

+!=!%.!3'()'! AU>! U%D%#! '3!%)!!%)'! G6! =$$3#($%! .D=#.$:#! G'3'7'G$3#5#=3#($! .'&:$%!<br />

#)$3:#=.#)$(B!<br />

KD(=$7#4! k$%:!G'=!:!%)'%!&'(#=#.3$!03'%!;=)#%$>!GU3A#+$%)#!;2!!#.#!'3.#(%'.$1!03'('=!D(#.$3#%!.'-6=!#.$!+0%!)U%#:)#!&#:!D(#.$:!-#!<br />

&#:!)#!=$$!G'!%'!.D=#.$:!)##(3#($%)#!=!(:!>!!#.$%!7'=3'!=!03'('=!$=$!='.!!)D>#7$%#!<br />

63':!.!(B! K0@36:)'! .'-6=! #.$! #%! 1'>3'! GD.D%4! $=$%5$! 03'('=! $+#! G6.bG'A#.! #=3$%)#!<br />

.#(5$&! #)$3:#=.#)$(B! X'@!3'%! '('.!(:'3'()'! .0@36:6%! #$.$:! -#! A#3$(! +#-$7#+$%$%!<br />

7D=+#3:#+$73#!G$(3$=.#!GD.D%!.'-6=.'%!)'&'!>$7')#!@'(?'!#=3$%)#!03'%!.'-6=!#.3#($%$%!<br />

.#(5$&!0('%3'(!%!%!'(..!!!G$3)$($3:$.$(!N^PB!<br />

3#%:$!.'-6=!D(D%3#($!.0@36:)'!GD7D=!G$(!0('%)'!.D=#.$3:#:#=.#)$(B!26!D(D%3#(!#%!<br />

1'>3'!.'-6=!)U%#(4!)'&'!+0%('!+'3':b+0+$+b+656=!-#!$%$.>#3!#=3$%)#!.D=#.$3:#=.#)$(B!<br />

K'-6=!#.$%$%!7'%!%)'!G6!D(D%3#($%)#!.D=#.$:#!'(>!#)$3:#+$73#!G$(3$=.#!D(D%!?#$.3$3$$!<br />

'(.:!! -#! G6! )6(6:! A#%#3! 03'('=! .0@36:6%! .'-6=! #.$! .D=#.$:! :$=.'(3'(!%'! 036:36!<br />

7U%)#!#.=$)#!G636%:6.6(B!!<br />

K0@36:)'! .'-6=! -#! &$%)$! #.$! 7'%!%)'! )$#(! ='%'.3!! NU()#=4! =#=3$=4! G!3)!(5!%4! ='>P!<br />

#.3#($%$%!.D=#.$:$!03)6=?'!'>)!(B!;%=#.U(3#()#%!'3!%'%!G$3A$3#()#%!G6!)6(6:'!#%!1'>3'!<br />

.0@36:)'! .D=#.$:! '3!='%3!!%!%! 036:':'+!! -#! G6! ='%'.3!! .D(3#($%#! '$.! #.3#($%$%!<br />

$+.#%$3)$$%)#!G636%':':'+!%!(03!07%')!!!.'&:$%!#)$3:#=.#)$(B!!!<br />

K0@36:6%!.'-6=!#.$%$!.#(5$&$%)#!#%!1'>3'!+0%!=633'%:'!.'($&$!)'&'!+0%('!:'(='!#.=$3$!<br />

03:'=.')!(B!26!$=$!1'=.U(D%!U%#!?!=:'+!%)'!.0@36:!G$3$%5$%$%!'(.:'+!%!%!(03!07%')!!!<br />

)DD%D3:#=.#)$(B! K'-6=! #.$! #%! 1'>3'! &'3':'! 03'('=4! )'&'! +0%('! +!('+!73'! 1!(!%)'4!<br />

:'%A'3)'!-#!7#:#=3#(#!='.'('=!.D=#.$3$(=#%4!30='%.'!A$G$!.0@36!7#:#=!7#(3#($%)#!$+#!<br />

#%!1'>3'!.'-6=!)U%#(!03:'=!D>#(#!+!('+!73'!!>A'('4!@$3$?!?#-$(:#4!+636!7#:#=!-#!)DD=!<br />

G$(!0('%)'!$+#!1'+.b100)!#=3$%)#!.D=#.$:!#$3$:$!:#-56..6(B!<br />

\#(&'%A$! G$(! D@&#7#! 7#(! -#(:#7#5#=! #=$3)#! &'>!(3'%:!! -#! (#70%)'! D?! D(D%D%)#!<br />

&'>!(!03)66!)6(6:3'()'!GD7D=!G$(!0('%)'!=U7!.'-66!)'&'!+0%('!0(A'%$=!.'-6=!-#!<br />

.$5'($! @$3$?! .#(5$&! #)$3:#=.#)$(B! 26! )6(6:! .0@36:6%! 0(A'%$=! D(D%3#(#! 03)6=?'! $3A$!<br />

)67)66%6!AU+.#(:#=.#)$(B!;%5'=4!'%=#.U(3#()#%!'3!%'%!G$3A$3#()#!.D=#.$5$3#()#!.$5'($!<br />

@$3$?! &'($5$%)#! )#$$=! #=$33#()#! +'.!'! +6%63'%! =U7! .'-66! -#! 0(A'%$=! .'-6=! A$G$!<br />

D(D%3#(!=0%6+6%)'!AD-#%!#=+$=3$$%$%!G636%)66!-#!G6!)6(6:6%!D(#.$:)#!?#$.3$3$$%!<br />

'(..!(!3:'+!%'! 036:+6>! #.=$)#! G636%'5'!! .'&:$%! #)$3:#=.#)$(B! 3A$3$! =6(6:3'(!<br />

.'('1!%)'%! G6! AD-#%! @(0G3#:$%$%! '!3:'+!! 7U%D%)#! ?'3!:'3'(!%! 7'@!3:'+!!<br />

A#(#=:#=.#)$(B!<br />

K0@36:)'! .D=#.$:#! '(>! #)$3#%! .'-6=3'(!%! =#+$:$%$%! &#3'3! 6+633#(#! AU(#! 7'@!3)!!%!!<br />

)DD%3#($%! 7'%!%)'4! GD7D=! G$(! 0('%)'=$! .D=#.$5$! =$.3#+$! =0%676! U%#:+#)$=3#($%$! -#!<br />

#.$=#.3#()#!G#3$(.$3:#+$%$%!67A6%!03'5'!%!!7U%D%)#!AU(D!G#7'%!#.:$.$(B!KD=#.$:$%!<br />

! !]C


'(..!(!3:'+!!-#!.0@36:)'!036'%!G6!G#=3#%.$%$!='(!3'%:'+!!'?!+!%)'%!=0%6%6%!)$=='.#!<br />

'3!%'('=!A#(#=3$!)D>#%3#:#3#($%!7'@!3:'+!%!%!1'7)'3!!03'5'!!)DD%D3:#=.#)$(B!<br />

KD(=$7##($%)#! ?'3!:'! 7'@!3:'=.')!(B! X'=3'!=!<br />

03'('=!f[bW[!A$G$!G$(!G#+3#:#!+D(#+$!+0%656%)'!.D=#.$:#!'(>!#)$3#5#=!G6!.'-6=3'(!%!<br />

.0@36:6%! GD7D=! G$(! =!+:!! .'('1!%)'%! .#(5$&! #)$3#5#$! G#=3#%$3:#=.#)$(B! ;%5'=! G6!<br />

.'-6=3'(!%! 7#.$.$(:#! +D(#3#($%#! G'3!! 03'('=! :'3$7#.3#($%$%! )#! 7D=+#=! 03:'+!!<br />

='?!%!3:'>)!(B!26!D(D%3#($%!1$7'.3'(!%'!AU(#!'%=#.3#()#!.#+@$.!#)$3#%!.#(5$&!0('%3'(!%!%!<br />

)#$#G$3#5#$!.'&:$%!#)$3:#=.#)$(BK0@36:)'!)0%)6(63:6!.'-6=!#.$!.D=#.$:$!)DD=!<br />

+#-$7#3#()#!A#(?#=3#:#=.#)$(B!26!D(D%3#(!=0%6+6%)'!.0@36:6%!7#.#(3$!G$3A$7#!+'&$@!<br />

03:')!!! AU(D3:#=.#)$(B! ;%=#.U(3#()#%! '3!%'%! G$3A$3#()#%! .0@36:)'! )0%)6(63:6!<br />

A!)'7'! ='(!! U%! 7'(A!3!! G$(! 7'=3'!:!%! G636%)66! -#! G6! =0%6)'! .'.:$%! #)$5$! G$(!<br />

G$3A$3#%)$(:#!7'@!3:'+!%!%!A#(#=.$$!+0%656%'!-'(!3:!.!(B!<br />

K0@36:6%!)U(..#!G$(3$=!=!+:!!&$%)$!#.$!.D=#.:#=.#)$(B!KD=#.$:!U>#33$=3#!7!3G'3'(!%)'!<br />

706%3':'=.'!-#!GD.D%!&$%)$)#%!)'&'!>$7')#!@'(?'!&$%)$!#.$!.#(5$&!#)$3:#=.#)$(B!26!<br />

)6(6:'! #%! 1'>3'! #.=$! #)#%! 1'=.U(3#($%! &$%)$%$%! ='(='+! '!(3!!%!%! 7D=+#=! 03:'+!! -#!<br />

A#?:$! )U%#:3#(#! AU(#! '$3#3#()#=$! G$(#7! +'7!+!%!%! '>'3:'+!%!%! %#)#%! 03)66%6!<br />

+U73#:#=!:D:=D%)D(B!<br />

KD(=$7#!03'('=!7'@!3'%!&'G#(3#(!&'3=!!7'%3!!<br />

7U%3#%)$(#(#=!.'-6=!#.$!.D=#.$:!:$=.'(3'(!%!%!)D:#+$%)#!#.=$3$!03:6.6(BK'-6=!#.$!-#!<br />

D(D%3#($%$%! =':6! .'('1!%)'%! 7#.#($%5#! )#%#.3#%:#)$$! =0%6+6%)'! .0@36:)'! 7'7A!%!<br />

='%''.! G636%:'=.')!(B! ! 26! =0%6)'! G$3A$3#%)$($5$! ?'3!:'3'(!%! 7'@!3:'+!! U%#:! '(>!<br />

#.:#=.#)$(B!<br />

$<br />

"F,7_$<br />

;('.!(:'!$3#!G#3$(3#%#%!.D=#.$5$!#$3$:3#($%$%!.'-6=!#.$!D(#.$5$3#($!.'('1!%)'%!)$=='.#!<br />

'3!%:'+!73'! G$(3$=.#! .D=#.$:! :$=.'(3'(!%!%!-#!:D.#($! :#:%6%$7#.$%$%! '(.!(!3:'+!!<br />

03'%'=!)Ñ&$3$%)#!03'5'=.!(B!KD(=$7#!! #..#! 7''%!3'%! +!=!%.!3'(!%! )#-':! #.:#+$! )6(6:6%)'! .'-6=! #.$%$%!<br />

-'>A#?$3#:#>! G$(! A!)'! 03'('=! :6.1'=3'()'=$! 7#($%$! =0(67'5'!! -#! .D=#.$:!<br />

:$=.'(3'(!%!%! '(.'5'!! U%AU(D3:#=.#)$(B! K'-6=! #.$! =0%6+6%)'! G$3$%?3$! G$(! .D=#.$5$!<br />

=$.3#+$!036.6(63'G$3:#+$!-#!+'3!=3!!G$(!.0@36:!$?$%!7#.#(3$!+#-$7#)#!.'%!.!:!-#!(#=3':!<br />

1''3$7#.3#($%$%!7'@!3:'+!%)'!1'7)'!AU(D3:#=.#)$(B!!<br />

!<br />

%+5,+A-+.$<br />

VB!;%0%7:06+B!YX6:6(.'!.'-6=?6366!-#($3#($B!X6:6(.'!`(#.$5$3#($!9#(=#>!2$(3$$4!!;%='('B!d[V[B!<br />

dB!;%0%7:06+B!YL.!.'-6=?6366!-#($3#($B!2#7'>!L.!T'%'7$5$3#($!-#!c':!>3!=?!3'(!2$(3$$4!;%='('B!d[VV!<br />

]B!;%0%7:06+B!Y&..@Y__1'0+.'.B1'0B0(A_+$.#_]]W_)#1'63.B'+@M4!#($$:!.'($&$!Vgb[Vbd[VVB!<br />

gB!;(:''%4!CB4!m>)0'%4!9BY!L=030I$=!76:6(.'!-#!.'-6=!#.$%$%!.D=#.$:!#$3$:3#($!-#!.D=#.$5$!U>#33$=3#($%$%!<br />

G#3$(3#%:#+$B!\'7-'%+'3!`(#.$:4!d[[^hgeNdPYVgbdV!<br />

^B! K'.3!)$34! *B4! CD3?6G6=4! 2B4! k#3$=4! \BY! *'(=3!! A#3$(! )D>#73#($%)#=$! '$3#3#($%! .'-6=! #.$! .D=#.$:$! -#! G6%6!<br />

#.=$3#7#%!1'=.U(3#(B!,36+3'(!'('+!!K'-6=?636=!H0%A(#+$4!+.'%G63B!VWW]hggfbg^fB!<br />

eB! T'7!3!4! 9BY! H6! A($G$%$%! .D=#.$5$3#($%! .'-6=! #.$! .D=#.$:! '3!='%3!=3'(!%'! #.=$+$! NK0='.! $3$! U(%#$PB! CR,!<br />

l$(''.!*'=D3.#+$!c#(A$+$4!d[[eY!d]NdPhd^b]VB!<br />

ZB! C#-A#(4! XB4! ;('34! XB4! c#:$(4! JB4! T'(!U>='%4! TBY! ! ;%='('! `%$-#(+$.#+$! 8#.#($%#(! *'=D3.#+$! $%.#(%!<br />

U(#%5$3#($%)#! &'7-'%+'3! D(D%3#($%! .D=#.$:! )6(6:6! -#! .D=#.$5$! .#(5$&3#($B! ;%='('! `%$-B! 8#.#($%#(! *'=B!<br />

c#(AB4d[[fh^^YVfWbVWgB!<br />

! !]H


fB! m%'74! cBY! T#3?6=! `%$-#(+$.#+$! ;=#&$(! T'3!=! XD=+#=! R=636! &#:$(#3$=! U(#%5$3#($%$%! G#+3#%:#!<br />

'3!='%3!=3'(!!-#!G#+$%!.D=#.$:!+!=3!=3'(!B!*!('.!T'3!=!\$>:#.3#($!c#(A$+$4!d[V[Y^NVgPhVdZbVgeB!<br />

WB!T'(!U>='%4!TB4!C#-A#(4!XB4!c#:$(4!JB4!;('34!XBY!L(5$7#+!`%$-#(+$.#+$!8#.#($%#(!*'=D3.#+$!U(#%5$3#($%$%!<br />

&'7-'%+'3!D(D%!.D=#.$:!7'@!+!!-#!'3!='%3!=3'(!B!T'3!=!2$3$:3#($!c#(A$+$4!d[[ZY!VeN]PhVZVbVZWB!<br />

V[B!H076G#%G#4!nB4!H0%5'4!XBY!KD(=$7#!-#!;-(6@'!2$(3$$%)#!&$%)$!#.$!D(#.$:$4!.D=#.$:$!-#!!@03$.$='3'(!B!<br />

LA#!`%$-B!l$(''.!*'=B!c#(AB4!d[V[Y!gZ!NdPh!d[Vbd[WB!<br />

VVB! X':6(4! jB4! CD%#4! LBY! c#%A#3$! G#+3#%:#! '?!+!%)'%! KD(=$7#


S 023 Piliç <strong>Et</strong>i Tüketimini <strong>Et</strong>kileyen Faktörler ve Tüketici Tercihleri:<br />

Ankara İli Örneği<br />

Factors Affecting the Chicken Meat Consumption and Consumer Preferences:<br />

the Case of Ankara Province<br />

Ylmaz Aral a , Erol Aydn a , Pnar Demir b , Ahmet Cumhur Akn a , Sinem İşbilir a ,<br />

Yavuz Cevger a<br />

a Ankara Üniversitesi Veteriner Fakültesi, Hayvan Sağlğ Ekonomisi ve İşletmeciliği Anabilim Dal, Ankara<br />

b Kafkas Üniversitesi Veteriner Fakültesi, Hayvanclk Ekonomisi ve İşletmeciliği Anabilim Dal, Kars<br />

Özet<br />

Bu çalşmada, Ankara ilinde piliç etine ilişkin tüketim profilinin belirlenmesi, satn<br />

alma alşkanlklar ve tüketici tercihlerini etkileyen faktörlerin ortaya konmas<br />

amaçlanmştr. Bu araştrmann materyalini, 2008 yl içinde Ankara ili merkezinde<br />

450 hane halk yöneticisi ile yüz yüze uygulanan anketlerden elde edilen veriler<br />

oluşturmuştur. Verilerin analizinde tanmlayc istatistikler ve anketteki önem<br />

sralamalarna ilişkin olarak ağrlklandrlmş puanlamann yan sra gruplar aras<br />

istatistiksel karşlaştrmalarda Mann-Whitney U ve Kruskal-Wallis testlerinden<br />

faydalanlmştr. Araştrma kapsamnda anket uygulanan ailelerin ortalama aylk geliri<br />

1641.09 TL, hane halk tüketimine yönelik ortalama gda harcamas 414.58 TL<br />

(%25.3) olarak bulunmuştur. Çalşmada, hane halk büyüklüğü ve aylk hane halk<br />

toplam piliç eti tüketimi ortalama olarak srasyla 3.9 kişi ve 3.31 kg olarak tespit<br />

edilmiştir. Ankete katlanlarn büyük çoğunluğu hane halk toplam reel gelirlerinin<br />

%100 artmas durumunda, piliç eti tüketimlerinin ortalama %82.0 orannda artacağ<br />

yönünde görüş bildirmiştir. Diğer taraftan, hane halk yöneticilerinin %47.8’i (215<br />

kişi) ilkbahar ve yaz aylarnda piliç eti tüketimlerinin ortalama %36.3 orannda<br />

arttğn ifade etmiştir. Tüketim tercihi yönünden et türleri içerisinde piliç etini birinci,<br />

ikinci ve üçüncü srada tercih etme oranlar srasyla %32.9, %28.7 ve %24.4 olarak<br />

hesaplanmştr. Piliç eti satn almay ilk srada tercih eden hane halklar için piliç eti<br />

tüketim tercihini etkileyen en önemli faktörler srasyla; fiyat uygunluğu, lezzeti,<br />

besleyici özelliği, sağlk ile ilgili koşullar, yağllk oran ve hazrlama kolaylğ olarak<br />

saptanmştr. Sonuç olarak, piliç eti üreten entegrasyonlarn tüketici talep ve<br />

tercihlerine ilişkin araştrmalardan elde edilen bilgiler şğnda, uygun miktar, kalite<br />

ve özellikte ürün arz ederek pazar paylarn arttrabilmeleri mümkündür. Bu<br />

kapsamda, pazarlama araçlarnn daha etkin kullanm ve yeni stratejiler belirlenmesi<br />

açsndan, tüketici tercihleri ve bunu etkileyen faktörlerin saptanmas büyük önem<br />

taşmaktadr.<br />

Anahtar sözcükler: Piliç eti, hane halk, tüketim, tüketici tercihleri<br />

Abstract<br />

In this study, determination of consumption profile of chicken meat in Ankara,<br />

presentation of factors affecting the buying habits and consumer preferences are<br />

aimed. The material of this study is constituted by the data obtained from surveys<br />

applied face-to-face to 450 household chiefs in the city center of Ankara, within the<br />

year 2008. In the analysis of the data, Mann-Whitney U and Kruskal-Wallis tests for<br />

intergroup comparison, descriptive statistics and weighted scoring with relation to<br />

survey ranking of importance was applied. The average monthly income of families<br />

that have been applied a survey within the scope of this research is found as TL<br />

1641.09 and the average food expenditure of household consumption is found as TL<br />

195<br />

kitap_1-541.indd 211 29.02.2012 15:45


gVgB^f! Nd^B]tPB! O%! .&#! +.6)74! .&#! '-#('A#! +$>#! 01! &06+#&03)! '%)! .&#! .0.'3! :0%.&37!<br />

&06+#&03)!50%+6:@.$0%!01!5&$5=#%!:#'.!'(#!)#.#(:$%#)!.0!G#!]BW!@#(+0%+!'%)!]B]V!<br />

=A4! (#+@#5.$-#37B! K&#! :'I0($.7! 01! @'(.$5$@'%.+! 01! .&#! +6(-#7! &'-#! 53'$:#)! .&'.! .&#$(!<br />

'-#('A#! 5&$5=#%! :#'.! 50%+6:@.$0%! Q063)! $%5(#'+#! G7! fdB[t4! $1! .&#$(! .0.'3! (#'3!<br />

&06+#&03)! $%50:#! $%5(#'+#)! G7! V[[tB! R%! .&#! 0.&#(! +$)#4! gZBft! 01! .&#! &06+#&03)!<br />

5&$#1+!NdV^!@#0@3#P!&'-#!(#@0(.#)!.&'.!.&#$(!5&$5=#%!:#'.!50%+6:@.$0%!$%5(#'+#+!G7!<br />

]eB]t!)6($%A!+@($%A!'%)!+6::#(!.$:#+B!*(0:!.&#!-$#Q!01!50%+6:@.$0%!@(#1#(#%5#+4!<br />

.&#! ('.$0+! 01! @(#1#(($%A! 5&$5=#%! :#'.! '+! .&#! 1$(+.4! .&#! +#50%)! '%)! .&#! .&$()4! '(#!<br />

5'3563'.#)!'+!]dBWt4!dfBZt!'%)!dgBgt4!(#+@#5.$-#37B!K&#!:0+.!$:@0(.'%.!1'5.0(+!.&'.!<br />

'11#5.+!.&#!@(#1#(#%5#+!01!.&#!5&$5=#%!:#'.!50%+6:@.$0%!10(!.&#!&06+#&03)+!.&'.!1$(+.!<br />

@(#1#(!.0!G67!5&$5=#%!:#'.4!'(#!)#.#(:$%#)!'+!@($5#!+6$.'G$3$.74!.'+.#4!%6.($#%.!1#'.6(#4!<br />

&#'3.&! 5$(56:+.'%5#+4! 1'.! ('.#+! '%)! #'+#! 01! @(#@'('.$0%4! (#+@#5.$-#37B! ;+! '! (#+63.4! $%!<br />

50%+$)#('.$0%!01!.&#!06.50:#+!01!.&#!(#+#'(5&#+!(#3'.#)!.0!.&#!50%+6:#(!)#:'%)+!'%)!<br />

@(#1#(#%5#+! 01! .&#! #%.#(@($+#+! @(0)65$%A! 5&$5=#%! :#'.4! $.! $+! @0++$G3#! .0! $%5(#'+#!<br />

:'(=#.!+&'(#+!G7!+6@@37$%A!@(0)65.+!01!+6$.'G3#!':06%.4!S6'3$.7!'%)!@(0@#(.7B!a$.&$%!<br />

.&$+!+50@#4!1(0:!.&#!-$#Q!01!6+$%A!.&#!:'(=#.$%A!.003+!:0(#!#11#5.$-#37!'%)!)#1$%$%A!<br />

%#Q!+.('.#A$#+4!)#.#(:$%'.$0%!01!.&#!50%+6:#(!@(#1#(#%5#+!Q$.&!.&#!1'5.0(+!'11#5.$%A!<br />

.&#:!&'-#!'!A(#'.!$:@0(.'%5#B!<br />

%&5$dF./'3$j&$5=#%!:#'.4!&06+#&03)4!50%+6:@.$0%4!50%+6:#(!@(#1#(#%5#+B!<br />

!<br />

>(.($<br />

;(.'%!%D16+!$3#!G$(3$=.#!A!)'!'(>!%!%!='3$.#!-#!:$=.'(!7U%D%)#%!AD-#%5#!'3.!%'!'3!%:'+!!<br />

A#(#=3$3$$4!&'7-'%+'3!='7%'=3!!@(0.#$%!$&.$7'5!4!G#+3#%:#7#!G'3!!+'3!=!@(0G3#:3#($4!<br />

+'3!=3!! -#! )#%A#3$! G#+3#%:#! 7U%D%)#! '(.'%! .D=#.$5$! G$3$%5$! -#! #$3$:$! .'-6=?636=!<br />

+#=.U(D%D! )D%7'! A#%#3$%)#! U%#:3$! G$(! #%)D+.($! &'3$%#! A#.$(:$.$(BKD(=$7#!<br />

.'-6=?63664!+0%!)U%#:)#!7''%'%!#=0%0:$=!=($>3#(4!?#$.3$!+'%+'+70%#3!70(6:3'(!-#!<br />

+0%!03'('=!7''%'%!=6!A($G$!+'3A!%!!A$G$!+#G#@3#(3#!0(.'7'!?!='%!.'3#@.#=$!)'('3:'!-#!<br />

'%$! 1$7'.! )DD3#($! A$G$! 1'=.U(3#(#! ='(!%! GD7D:#=.#4! '(.'%! $&('5'.! $:='%3'(!!<br />

)0(63.6+6%)'!A#3$$:$%$!+D()D(:#=.#)$(B!<br />

CD%D:D>)#!KD(=$7#!.'-6=?6366%6%!D(#.$:4!$3#:#4!-#($:3$3$=4!.#=%030I$!=633'%!:!4!<br />

G'=!:! -#! G#+3#:#! =0633'(!4! +.'%)'()$>'+70%! A$G$! =0%63'()'! AU+.#()$$! $3#(3#:#7#!<br />

='(!%4! :#-56.! +0(6%3'(!%!%! GD7D=! ?06%366! D(#.$:! :'3$7#.3#($%$%! :$%$:$>'+70%64!<br />

'(>b.'3#@! )#%A#+$%$%! =6(63:'+!4! @'>'(3':')'! #.=$%3$$%! +'3'%:'+!! -#! )!! +'.!:)'!<br />

(#='G#.?$!G$(!=0%6:'!A#3$%:#+$!%0=.'+!%)'!)DD:3#%:#=.#)$(!NVPBKD=#.$5$3#(#!$3$=$%!<br />

5$%+$7#.4!7'4!-D56.!'!(3!!4!&'%#!7#(3#$:!7#($!N=!(+'3b=#%.+#3P4!7#:#!'3!='%3!=3'(!!-#!<br />

+0+7'3! 7'@!7'! $3$=$%! G'>!! 1'=.U(3#($%! A#%#3! 03'('=! #.! .D=#.$:! .#(5$&3#($! -#! .D=#.$:!<br />

:$=.'(!%!! #.=$3#)$$! +'@.'%:!.!(! NdPB! 2#3?$='#($%#! #.=$3$! G'3!5'! 1'=.U(3#(! 03)66!<br />

)DD%D3:#=.#)$(B!KD(=$7##7$4!.D=#.$:!<br />

'3!='%3!=3'(!4!@$3$?!#.$!.D=#.$:$%$!#.=$3#7#%!1'=.U(3#(!-#!.D=#.$5$!.#(5$&3#($!A$G$!.D=#.$:!<br />

7'@!+!%!%!'('.!(!3)!!!G$3$:+#3!?'3!:'!+'7!+!!7#.#(3$!)D>#7)#!G636%:':'=.')!(B!<br />

! !]T


;2!D3=#3#($%)#!@$3$?!#.$!.D=#.$:$!+0%!)U%#:)#4!='3$.#!-#!G#+3#7$5$!U>#33$=3#($4!D(#.$:!<br />

7U%.#:3#($!NG#+3#:#4!&'7-'%!(#1'&!!-GBP4!D(D%D%!D3=#!0($I$%$4!)0%:6b.'>#!#.!.#(5$&$4!<br />

G'.'! =6! A($G$! 03:'=! D>#(#! &'+.'3!=3'('! ='(!! ($+=! '3A!3':'+!! -GB! .#:#3$%)#!<br />

)#$:#=.#)$(B! ;7(!5'4! ;2#($%)#!7'@!3'%!G$(!'('.!(:')'4!=6!A($G$!<br />

+'3A!%3'(!! -#! 036'%! =($>3#! G$(3$=.#! '%=#.#! ='.!3'%3'(!%! t^d#7$%)#! 03'%! :'(='3!! -#!<br />

':G'3'I3!! @$3$?! #.$! +'.!%! '3:'! 0('%!%!%4! =($>! +0%('+!! )U%#:)#! tZf#.! A$G$! U3?D:D! >0(! #.! U>#33$=3#($! 7'%!%)'!<br />

#.$%! D(#.$:$%$%! 7'@!3)!!! D3=#4! D(D%! :'(='! -#! #.$=#.! G$3A$3#($! A$G$! A!)'! AD-#%3$$%$!<br />

#.=$3#)$$! )DD%D3#%! 1'=.U(3#($! )#! #.! .D=#.$:$%)#! )$=='.#! '3:'=.')!(3'(! NePB!<br />

T30-#%7'#33$=3#! )$=='.#!<br />

'3!%)!!!G#3$(.$3:$.$(!NZPB!<br />

26! ?'3!:')'4! d[[f! 7!3!! $.$G'($73#! ;%='('! $3$%)#! &'7-'%+'3! D(D%! .D=#.$:! 7'@!+!%!%!<br />

0(.'7'! =0%:'+!! ':'5!73'! 7'@!3'%! G$(! '%=#.! '('.!(:'+!%!%! @$3$?! #.$! .D=#.$:$%#! '$.!<br />

+0%6?3'(!! -#($3:$! 036@4! ;%='('! $3$%)#! @$3$?! #.$! .D=#.$:! :$=.'(!4! +'.!%! '3:'!<br />

'3!='%3!=3'(!!-#!.D=#.$5$!.#(5$&3#($%$!#.=$3#7#%!1'=.U(3#($%!G#3$(3#%:#+$!':'?3'%:!.!(B!<br />

!<br />

c+1&.5+-$@&$c&1F1$<br />

26! '('.!(:'%!%! :'.#(7'3$%$4! d[[f! 7!3!! $?$%)#! ;%='('! $3$! :#(=#>$%)#! N;3.!%)'4!<br />

k'%='7'4! L.$:#+A6.4! H#?$U(#%4! 9':'=4! T$%5'%4! X#%$! 9'&'33#! -#! CU3G'!! $3?#3#($P!<br />

%D16+!706%366%'!AU(#!.'G'='3!!.#+')D1$!U(%#=3#:#!7U%.#:$!$3#!G#3$(3#%#%!&'%#!&'3=!!<br />

7U%#.$5$3#($!$3#!7D>!7D>#!67A63'%'%!'%=#.3#()#%!#3)#!#)$3#%!-#($3#(!036.6(:6.6(B!!<br />

;('.!(:')'!U(%#=3#:!GD7D=3DD!CbJ0Q#(!]BVBd!@'=#.!@(0A(':!%)'!.#+.$%!AD5D![BW[!<br />

-#! [B[^! NK$@bV! &'.'P! ='G63! #)$3#(#=! &#+'@3'%:!! -#! %! )##($! ]^g! 03'('=!<br />

G636%:6.6(!NfPB!;%5'=!'%=#.!?'3!:'+!%)'!#3)#!#)$3#5#=!-#($3#()#!&'.'!03:'+!!-#7'!<br />

#=+$=! -#($! .0@3'%:'+!! $&.$:'3$%#! ='(!3!=! .0@3':! gfd! &'%#! &'3=!! 7U%#.$5$+$! $3#! '%=#.!<br />

?'3!:'+!! 7D(D.D3:D.D(B! C#(?#=3#.$($3#%! ]d! ')#.! '%=#.! #=+$=! -#($! $?#()$$! -#!<br />

AD-#%$3$(!G636%:')!!!$?$%!)##(3#%)$(:#!)!!!.6.63:64!GU73#3$=3#!-#($!'%'3$>$!.0@3':!<br />

g^[! '%=#.! D>#($%)#%! 7'@!3:!.!(B! \'>!(3'%'%! '%=#.! 10(:6%)'! &'%#&'3=!!<br />

7U%#.$5$3#($%)#%4!@$3$?!#.$!'73!=!.D=#.$:!:$=.'(!4!.D=#.$:!.#(5$&3#($!+!('3':'+!4!#.!+'.!%!<br />

'3:'!='('(!!-#($(=#%!&'%A$!1'=.U(3#(#!U%5#3$=3#!U%#:!-#()$$!A$G$!=0%63'()'!+0(63'%!<br />

+0(63'('!5#-'@!-#(:#+$!$+.#%:$.$(B!<br />

;%=#.! 10(:3'(!! -'+!.'+!73'! #3)#! #)$3#%! -#($3#(4! '('.!(!5!3'(! .'('1!%)'%! G$3A$+'7'(!<br />

0(.':!%)'! 9T! LM5#3! d[[Z! -#! TJTT! VVB^! 10(! a$%)0Q+! @'=#.! @(0A(':3'(!%)'!<br />

036.6(63'%! -#($! .'G'%!%'! ='7)#)$3#(#=! $3#%:$.$(B! 8#($3#($%! '%'3$>$%)#! .'%!:3'7!5!!<br />

$+.'.$+.$=3#(!-#!.D=#.$5$!.#(5$&3#($!$3#!$3A$3$!5#-'@3'(!%!U%#:!+!('3':'3'(!%'!$3$=$%!03'('=!<br />

'!(3!=3'%)!(!3:!! @6'%3':'! 7'@!3:!.!(B! ;7(!5'4! G#3$(3#%#%! @'(':#.(#3#(! $?$%! $=$!<br />

! !]W


A(6G6%! $+.'.$+.$=+#3! ='(!3'.!(!3:'+!%)'! 9'%%ba&$.%#7! ,4! D?! A(6G6%!<br />

='(!3'.!(!3:'+!%)'!$+#!H(6+='3ba'33$+!.#+.3#($!=633'%!3:!.!(!NWPB!!<br />

$<br />

D7-67-+.$<br />

;('.!(:'! ='@+':!%)'! '%=#.! 67A63'%'%! &'%#! &'3=3'(!%'! $3$=$%! G'>!! .'%!:3'7!5!!<br />

$+.'.$+.$=3#(!K'G30!V!!.'%!:3'7!5!!$+.'.$+.$=3#(B!<br />

\'%#!\'3=!! %! 9$%! 9'M! r î!/!<br />

X'!N\'%#!\'3=!!XU%#.$5$+$%$%P! ! d] ! Z] ! g[BZîWBee<br />

2D7D=3DD!NH$$P!<br />

! d ! W ! ]BWîVBdf<br />

;73!=!K0@3':!C#3$($!NKiP! ! g^[ ! ][[ ! e[[[ ! VegVB[WîW^[BVd<br />

;73!=!K0@3':!C!)'!\'(5':'+!!NKiP! ! Z[ ! d[[[ ! gVgB^fîdgWBZ[<br />

;73!=!J$3$?!L.$!KD=#.$:!K0@3':!!N=AP!<br />

! [B^ ! V[B[[ ! ]B]VîVBW]<br />

"##3!K0@3':!C#3$(!tV[[!;(..!!%)'!J$3$?!L.$!<br />

! ]V^<br />

KD=#.$:!9$=.'(!%)'=$!;(.!!NtP!!<br />

! V[ ! d[[ ! fdB[îgeBdd<br />

"##3!K0@3':!C#3$(!tV[[!;(..!!%)'!J$3$?!L.$!<br />

! d<br />

KD=#.$:!9$=.'(!%)'=$!;>'3!!NtP!!<br />

! e[ ! f[ ! Z[B[îVgBVg<br />

"##3!K0@3':!C#3$(!tV[[!;(..!!%)'!J$3$?!L.$!<br />

! V]]<br />

KD=#.$:!9$=.'(!!c#$:#>!NH$$P!<br />

! b ! b ! b<br />

3=G'&'(! -#! X'>! ;73'(!%)'! J$3$?! L.$!<br />

! dV^<br />

KD=#.$:$%)#=$!;(.!!NtP!<br />

! V[ ! V[[ ! ]eB]îVeBfg<br />

3=G'&'(! -#! X'>! ;73'(!%)'! J$3$?! L.$!<br />

! gV<br />

KD=#.$:$%)#=$!;>'3!!NtP!<br />

! V[ ! ^[ ! ]dBWîVgBf]<br />

3=G'&'(!-#!X'>!;73'(!%)'!J$3$?!L.$!KD=#.$:$!<br />

! VWV<br />

9$=.'(!!c#$:#>!NH$$P!<br />

! b ! b ! b<br />

!<br />

;%=#.!67A63'%'%!g^[!&'%#!&'3=!!7U%#.$5$+$%$%!7'!0(.'3':'+!!g[BZ4!.0@3':!&'%#!&'3=!!<br />

0(.'3':'! '73!=! A#3$($! VegVB[W! Ki4! &'%#! &'3=!! .D=#.$:$%#! 7U%#3$=! 0(.'3':'! A!)'!<br />

&'(5':'+!!gVgB^f!Ntd^B]P6!L.$!<br />

]e fB[ ]f fBg g^ V[B[ VVW deBg<br />

y! KD=#.$5$3#($%! )$#(! ='%'.3!4! G'3!=4! =#?$! -#! :'%)'! #.$! .D=#.$:! .#(5$&3#($! )$#(! #.3#(!<br />

='.#A0($+$%)#!'3!%:!.!(B!!<br />

KD=#.$:! .#(5$&$! 7U%D%)#%! #.! .D(3#($! $?#($+$%)#! @$3$?! #.$%$! G$($%5$4! $=$%5$! -#! D?D%5D!<br />

+!(')'! .#(5$&! #.:#! 0('%3'(!!+!('+!73'! t]dBW4! tdfBZ! -#! tdgBg! 03'('=! &#+'@3'%:!.!(B!<br />

c$#(! .'('1.'%4! &'%#! &'3=3'(!! A#%#3$%)#! #.! .D(3#($%$%! +'.!%! '3!%:'+!%'! $3$=$%! $3=! D?!<br />

.#(5$&$%)#!@$3$?!#.$!tfeB[!$3#!$3=!+!(')'!7#(!'3:'=.')!(B!<br />

;('.!(:'! +0%656%)'! #.! .D(3#($%$%! $3=! +!(')'! .#(5$&! #)$3:#! %#)#%3#($%#! $3$=$%!03'('=!<br />

#3)#!#)$3#%!G63A63'(!K'G30!]


$<br />

K'G30!]B!L.!.D(3#($%$%!$3=!+!(')'!.#(5$&!#)$3:#!%#)#%3#($B!<br />

K#(5$&!n#)#%$!<br />

L.$%!*$7'.!!<br />

L.$%!i#>>#.$!<br />

2#+3#7$5$!m>#33$$!<br />

T'3!=3'! 3A$3$!<br />

H0633'(!<br />

X'3!3!=!<br />

\'>!(3':'!<br />

H03'73!!y!<br />

L.$%!CU(D%.D+D!<br />

9'(='bH'3$.#!<br />

m>#33$=3#($y!<br />

T$%)$($:!<br />

H03'73!!y!<br />

cDD=! ;.!=! R('%!!<br />

N1$(#Py!<br />

9$+'1$(#! T#(-$+.#!<br />

CD>#33$=y!<br />

J$3$?!L.$!!<br />

NOP!<br />

T!!(!L.$!<br />

NOOP!<br />

! ; ! ;<br />

;<br />

! 2 ! j ! 2 ! j 2<br />

! VdgZ ! V ! Zef ! ^ V[f<br />

! ZfV ! d ! VZVf ! V ddd<br />

! Z][ ! ] ! V]gZ ! d V]W<br />

! !]]<br />

H076%bH6>6!<br />

L.$!<br />

NOOOP!<br />

ObOO! ObOOO! ObOObOOO!<br />

!<br />

! ! j ! @ ! @ ! @<br />

! ! g ! yy[B[[[ ! yy[B[[[ ! yy[B[[[<br />

! ! V ! yy[B[[[ ! yy[B[[[ ! yy[B[[[<br />

! ! d ! [B]gf ! [Bgdf ! [B^ef<br />

! e][ ! g ! e^d ! e ! VV] ! ] ! [BWVd ! [BgZ[ ! [BZe]<br />

! g[^ ! ^ ! V[[e ! ] ! Wf ! e ! [B[eW ! [B]e[ ! [BVfg<br />

! g[g ! e ! g^V ! f ! ge ! W ! [BgVZ ! y ! y<br />

! ]Vf ! Z ! Wed ! g ! V[e ! ^ ! [BdfZ ! [Bded ! [BggV<br />

! dfg ! f ! ^[Z ! Z ! ef ! Z ! [BeZV ! y ! y<br />

! dgf ! W ! dZW ! VV ! ^Z ! f ! [Be[f ! y ! y<br />

! d[d ! V[ ! ]fW ! W ! V] ! VV ! [Bfg] ! y ! y<br />

! Vgd ! VV ! dWg ! V[ ! g[ ! V[ ! [B^de ! y ! y<br />

;Y!c##(3#%)$(:#4!2YK0@3':!c##(3#%)$(:#!J6'%!4!jY!K#(5$&!T!('+!!<br />

yH076%b=6>6!#.$!$3#!$3A$3$!-#($3#()#!-#($!+'7!+!!7#.#(+$>!03)66%)'%4!$+.'.$+.$=$!<br />

'%'3$>!@$3$?!#.$!-#!+!!(!#.$!'('+!%)'!7'@!3:!.!(B!<br />

yy+.'.$+.$=+#3!03'('=!A(6@3'(!'('+!!1'(=!'%3':3!)!(!N@z[B[[VPB!<br />

!<br />

;%=#.! ='@+':!%)'! )##(3#%)$($3#%! g^[! &'%#! &'3=!%)'%! d[e! Ntg^BfP


t][Bg! 0('%!%)'! )'&'! 7D=+#=! G$(! 1$7'..'%! +'.!%! '3:'7'! &'>!(! 03)66! -6(A63'%:!.!(!<br />

NVVPB!<br />

!<br />

K'G30!gB!C#3$(!A(6@3'(!%'!AU(#!@$3$?!#.$%$!$3=!+!(')'!.#(5$&!#.:#!%#)#%3#($B!<br />

zVgWW!NKiP!NOP! V^[[s!NKiP!NOOP!<br />

ObOO!<br />

K#(5$&!n#)#%$! c##(3#%)$(:#! c##(3#%)$(:#!<br />

J6'%! T!('3':'! J6'%! T!('3':'! @!<br />

L.$%!*$7'.!!<br />

! V[[^ ! V ! d[^ ! g ! y[B[[[<br />

L.$%!i#>>#.$!<br />

! ^d[ ! ] ! deV ! V ! yy[B[gV<br />

2#+3#7$5$!m>#33$$! ! ^d^ ! d ! dgd ! ] ! yy[B[]d<br />

T'3!=3'!3A$3$!H0633'(! ! ]Z] ! g ! d^Z ! d ! yy[B[g^<br />

X'3!3!=!<br />

! dd^ ! Z ! Vf[ ! ^ ! [Bf^Z<br />

\'>!(3':'!H03'73!!! ! deg ! ^ ! Vg[ ! e ! [B[Ze<br />

L.$%!CU(D%.D+D! ! d^g ! e ! eg ! W ! [Bf[g<br />

9'(='bH'3$.#!m>#33$=3#($! ! dVV ! f ! Z] ! f ! [B]]Z<br />

T$%)$($:!H03'73!!! ! Ved ! V[ ! fe ! Z ! [BW]d<br />

cDD=!;.!=!R('%!!N*$(#P! ! Ve] ! W ! ]W ! VV ! [BV^^<br />

9$+'1$(#!T#(-$+.#!CD>#33$=! ! V[d ! VV ! g[ ! V[ ! [Beeg<br />

y+.'.$+.$=+#3! 03'('=! A(6@3'(! '('+!! 1'(=! '%3':3!)!(! N@z[B[[VP4! yy! +.'.$+.$=+#3! 03'('=!<br />

A(6@3'(!'('+!!1'(=!'%3':3!)!(!N@z[B[^PB!<br />

!<br />

K'>#!@$3$?!#.$!.D=#.$:!'3!='%3!=3'(!%'!)U%D=!03'('=!8'%!$3$%)#!#&$(!-#!=!(+'3!'3'%)'=$!<br />

&'%#!&'3=3'(!!D>#($%)#!7D(D.D3#%!)$#(!G$(!?'3!:')'h!A#3$(!+#-$7#+$!-#!#&$(3#:#%$%!<br />

@$3$?! #.$! .D=#.$:! )D>#7$! -#! '3!='%3!!! D>#($%)#! #.=$3$! 03)66! +'@.'%:!.!(B! c$#(!<br />

.'('1.'%4! G6! ?'3!:')'4! 7!33!=! &'%#! &'3=!! A#3$($%$%! 0(.'3':'! t]BW!-#!<br />

D>#($! +!=3!=.'! @$3$?! #.$! +'.!%! '3:'%!%! $+#! +!('+!73'! t^]BZ! -#! tgfBg! 0('%!%)'! 03)66!<br />

+'@.'%:!.!(!NVdPB!;7(!5'!G6!'('.!(:')'4!#&$()#=$!&'%#3#($%!teeB[!(3':'!=03'73!!!03'('=4!V^[[!Ki!-#!D+.D%)#!A#3$(#!+'&$@!&'%#!&'3=3'(!%)'!<br />

$+#! +!('+!73'h! #.$%! 3#>>#.$4! +'3!=! $3#! $3A$3$! =0633'(4! G#+3#7$5$! U>#33$$4! #.$%! 1$7'.!! -#!<br />

7'3!3!=!0('%!!03'('=!+'@.'%:!.!(B!<br />

;('.!(:')'!#.!.D(3#($!$?#($+$%)#!@$3$?!#.$%$!$3=!+!(')'!.#(5$&!#)#%!&'%#!&'3=3'(!4!A#3$(!<br />

A(6@3'(!%'! AU(#! +!%!13'%)!(!3)!!%)'! .#(5$&! +#G#@3#($! $?#($+$%)#h! #.$%! 1$7'.!4! 3#>>#.$4!<br />

G#+3#7$5$! U>#33$$! -#! +'3!=3'! $3A$3$! =0633'(! '('+!%)'=$! 1'(=! $+.'.$+.$=$! '?!)'%! '%3':3!!<br />

G636%:6.6(B"$5&'()+0%!NV]P4!?'3!:'+!%)'!#.!.D=#.$:$!D>#($%)#!'3!='%3!=3'(!%4!3#>>#.!<br />

U>#33$=3#($%$%4!+'3!=3'!$3A$3$!)DD%5#!N=03#+.#(034!7'!-GBP!-#!($+=3#($%4!#.$=#.4!:'(='!<br />

A$G$! G#3$(3#7$5$3#($%4! (#=3':4! @(0:0+70%4! .'-+$7#! N)0=.0(4! '$3#! -#! '(=')'P! A$G$!<br />

6%+6(3'(!%!(03!07%')!!%!!G$3)$(:$.$(B!<br />

*$%3'%)$7'!+!=3!=.'!#-)#!@$3$?!#.$!7#)$$!-#!)!'(!)'!@$3$?!<br />

#.$!7#:#!'3!='%3!!%!%!'7)'!G$()#%!'>!03)66!.#+@$.!#)$3:$.$(!NV[PB!;7(!5'4!.D=#.$5$!<br />

.#(5$&3#($%)#! 7#(3$! D(#.$:$%! @0>$.$1! #.=$7#! +'&$@! 03)664! )$#(! D3=#3#()#%! A#3#%! @$3$?!<br />

#.$%)#! $+#! .D=#.$5$! #$3$:$%$%! 50('1$! 7'=!%3!=! -#! #.%$=! :#(=#>3$! 03'('=! c'%$:'(='!<br />

! C##


=U=#%3$! D(D%3#(#! ='7)!!! $1')#! #)$3:$.$(B! ;7%!! ?'3!:')'4! 2(#>$37''(3':'!<br />

+.('.#I$3#($%$%! G#3$(3#%:#+$! -#! +'.!! &'5:$%$%! '(.!(!3:'+!! %0=.'+!%)'! GD7D=! U%#:!<br />

.'!)!!!6%6.63:':'3!)!(B!<br />

c$#(! .'('1.'%4! '('.!(:'3'(! +0%656%)'! #3)#! #)$3#5#=! G63A63'(4! +#=.U()#! 1''3$7#.!<br />

AU+.#(#%!G#7'>!#.!+'%'7$!$3#.:#3#($%#4!.D=#.$5$!.#(5$&!-#!G#=3#%.$3#($%#!)U%D=!03'('=!<br />

D(D%!A#3$.$(:#!-#!1'(=3!3'.!(:'!67A63':'3'(!%!!A#(?#=3#.$(:#)#!7U%!-#(#5#=.$(B!<br />

T0%6?.'4! D(#.$5$! 1$(:'3'(!%! $?! .D=#.$:! -#! )!! .$5'(#..#! .D=#.$5$! .#(5$&3#($%#! 67A6%!<br />

:$=.'(4! ='3$.#! -#! U>#33$=.#! D(D%! +'.'('=! @'>'(! @'73'(!%!! '(..!('G$3:#3#($4! .D=#.$5$!<br />

.'3#G$%#! )U%D=! 03'('=! (#=3':4! @(0:0+70%! -GB! @'>'(3':'! '('?3'(!%!! )'&'! #.=$%!<br />

=633'%'G$3:#3#($! )#! .D=#.$5$! .#(5$&3#($4! +'.!%! '3:'! )'-('%!3'(!! -#! G6%3'(!! #.=$3#7#%!<br />

1'=.U(3#($%!0(.'7'!=0%:'+!!$3#!:D:=D%!03'G$3#5#=.$(B!<br />

$<br />

%+5,+A-+.$<br />

VB! ;('34! XBY! K'-6=?636=! +#=.U(D%D%! 636+'3! #=0%0:$! $?$%)#=$! U%#:$! -#! :#-56.! +0(6%3'(B! 8#.#($%#(!<br />

K'-6=?636=!c#(%#$!9#=.6@!c#(A$+$4!d[[Wh!ZN]PY!gb^B!<br />

dB!C0++'()4!\B9B4!X0(=4!"BY!T05$'3!+.(65.6('3!$%136#%5#+!0%!:#'.!50%+6:@.$0%B!\6:'%!L5030A7!"#-$#Q4!<br />

d[[]h!V[NVPY!VbWB!<br />

]B! 8#(G#=#4! aB4! 8'5=$#(4! OBY! J(01$3#! '%)! #11#5.+! 01! 50%+6:#(! $%-03-#:#%.! $%! 1(#+&! :#'.4! 9#'.! T5$#%5#4!<br />

d[[gh!eZY!V^WbVefB!<br />

gB! 9'A)#3'$%#4! JB4! T@$#++4! 9BJB48'35#+5&$%$4! LBY! J063.(7! :#'.! 50%+6:@.$0%! .(#%)+! $%! L6(0@#B! a0(3)


" #CJ $D.F(-&.$`&)-&.(,/&$V.F1&(,$@&\@&5+$:)(,F$:'(1$`F7,-77,7$<br />

:9+-1)+$@&$V.F1&+9$-+@&'(,(,$V&.KF.)+,'$@&$%+,$V+.+)&1.&-&.(,&$<br />

B1A(-&.( $<br />

KLL"-#+).L)@$.#"'+")/1,,0"7"&#'#%.&)%&#.)E$.%0"$)B%"#+)B"-$"'+"8)T"C"0).L)<br />

@$.#"%&)'&8R.$)J7%&.)J-%8+).&)@"$L.$7'&-")'&8)E0..8)@'$'7"#"$+)<br />

!<br />

n#5:#..$%!j#73'% ' 4!T'$.!H05' ' 4!n#>$&!R=6( 5 4!CU=&'%!;=)#%$> 5!<br />

G ;%='('!`%$-#(+$.#+$!l$(''.!*'=D3.#+$!l00.#=%$!2U3D:D!<br />

5 2#7@$!;BB!<br />

!<br />

89&1$<br />

26!'('.!(:'!G'3'.:'!)U%#:$!@(0.#$%!0('%!%!!)#$.$(:#)#%4!GD7D.:#4!A#3$.$(:#!-#!<br />

G$.$(:#! 7#:3#($%$%! @(0.#$%! -#7'! @(0.#$%! -#! ':$%0! '+$.! )D>#73#($%$! @(0.#'>! #%>$:$!<br />

=633'%'('=! -#7'! =633'%:'7'('=! '>'3.:'%!%! @$3$?3#($%! @#(10(:'%+!%'! 03'%! #.=$3#($%$!<br />

'('.!(:'=! $?$%! 7D(D.D3:D.D(B! c#%#:#! Vd[[[! ')#.! "0++! ][f! 5$-5$-! $3#! e! &'1.'!<br />

+D()D(D3:D.D(B! ;('.!(:')'! #.3$=! @$3$?! 7#:3#($%$%! +')#5#! @(0.#$%! -#7'! @(0.#$%! -#!<br />

':$%0!'+$.!N:#.$70%$%!-#!3$>$%P!G$(3$=.#!!t^!-#!t!f!)D>#7$%)#!'>'3.!3:'+!!$3#!G6%3'('!<br />

#%>$:!$3'-#!#)$3#(#=!!036.6(63:6!f!('+70%!-#!G$.$(:#!7#:$!@(0.#$%!$?#($=3#($!1'(=3!!d!<br />

=0%.(03!('+70%6!03:'=!D>#(#!.0@3':!V[!1'(=3!!('+70%!)#%#%:$.$(B!!!<br />

c#%#:#)#! ('+70%! @(0.#$%! 706%366%6%! t! f'3.!3:'+!!AUD+! #.$!<br />

0('%!%)'!U%#:3$!)D>#7)#!)DD#!!703!'?'(=#%!NJz[B[^P4!)$#(!='(='+!@'(':#.(#3#($%)#!<br />

5$))$! G$(! 1'(=3!3!=! .#+@$.! #)$3:#:$.$(B! 2'3'.:'! )U%#:$%)#! @(0.#$%! =!+!.3':'+!!<br />

7'@!3:')!!%)'4! 7#:3#(#! @(0.#'>! ='.!3:'+!! @#(10(:'%+!! U%#:3$! )D>#7)#!<br />

#.=$3#:#:$.$(! N@s[4[^PB! 26%6%3'! G$(3$=.#! @#(10(:'%+! -#($3#($%$%! #%>$:! ='.!3:'7'%!<br />

A(6@3'()'! +'7!+'3! 03'('=! )'&'! =U.D! 03:'+!! -#! #%>$:! $3'-#+$! $3#! =0%.(03! A(6G6!<br />

+#-$7#+$%#! 63'!3:'+!%!%! 7'%!!+!('4! ! t^! @(0.#$%! -#! ':$%0! '+$.! 706%366! '>'3.!3'%!<br />

A(6@3'('!@(0.#'>!$3'-#!#)$3)$$%)#4!+'7!+'3!03'('=!#%!7D=+#=!)#%#:#!'!(3!!%'4!#%!$7$!<br />

7#:)#%!7'('(3'%:'7'!-#!D(#.$:!-#($:3$3$=!#%)#=+$%#!63'!3:'+!!N@s[B[^P!-#!AUD+!#.$!<br />

0('%!%)'! U%#:3$! +#-$7#)#=$! $7$3#:#! N@z[B[^P! AU>! '()!! #)$3:#:#3$)$(B! J(0.#$%! -#!<br />

':$%0! '+$.! 706%366! t! ^! )DD(D3:D! 7#:3#()#! #%>$:! $3'-#+$! )'&'! 1'7)'3!!<br />

G636%6(=#%4!t!f!+#-$7#+$%)#!#.=$+$>!='3:!!A$G$!AU(D%:#=.#)$(B!;('.!(:'!+0%6?3'(!!<br />

@(0.#$%! -#! ':$%0! '+$.! +#-$7#+$%$%! G$(3$=.#! )DD(D3:#+$%$%! )'&'! '>! )#@(#+70%3'!<br />

+0%6?3'%'5'!%!! AU+.#(:#=.#)$(B! ! 26%6%! 7'%!%)'! ! #3)#! #)$3#%! -#($3#(! ('+70%!<br />

@(0.#$%$%)#! .'+'((61! )DD%5#+$%$%! G'3'.:'! 7#:$%)#%! +0%('=$! )U%#:3#()#!<br />

67A63'%:'+!%!%4! G$3&'++'! 7#:! 1$7'.3'(!%!%! 7D=+#=! 03)66! )6(6:3'()'4! 1'7)'3!! -#!<br />

#=0%0:$=!03'G$3#5#$%$!AU+.#(:#=.#)$(B!!<br />

!<br />

:;'1.+7:#!0%!G(0$3#(!@#(10(:'%5#!Q$.&06.!5&'%A#$%A!@(0.#$%!'%)!':$%0!'5$)!)#%+$.7!$%!<br />

+.'(.#(!)$#.+B!K&$+!e!Q##=b+.6)7!$%536)#)!Vd[[[!"0++!][f!G(0$3#(!5&$5=+B!;!.0.'3!01!V[!<br />

)$#.'(7! .(#'.:#%.+! $%536)$%A! f! )$11#(#%.! )$#.+! @(#@'(#)! G7! )#5(#'+$%A! N^! '%)! f! tP!<br />

@(0.#$%! '30%#! 0(! @(0.#$%! '%)! ':$%0! '5$)! .0A#.&#(! Q$.&! 0(! Q$.&06.! #%>7:#!<br />

+6@@3#:#%.'.$0%!'%)!d!50%.(03!)$#.+!Q$.&!)$11#(#%.!@(0.#$%!50%.#%.+!Q#(#!$%-#+.$A'.#)B!!<br />

! C#C<br />

kitap_1-541.indd 218 29.02.2012 15:45


c#5(#'+$%A! @(0.#$%! 3#-#3+! 6@! .0! f! t! '1.#(! +.'(.#(! @#($0)! )$)%7:#!!'%)!@(0.#'+#!<br />

+6@@3#:#%.'.$0%!#3#-'.#)!.&$+!30Q!@#(10(:'%5#!.0!.&#!50%.(03!G$()+B!2#+$)#+!K&#!G$()+!<br />

(#5#$-#)!^t!(#)65#)!@(0.#$%!'%)!':$%0!'5$)!)#%+$.7!)$#.+!Q$.&!@(0.#'+#!+&0Q#)!G#+.!<br />

*j"!'%)!3$-#!Q#$A&.!)'.'!NJs[B[^PB!J(0.#'+#!+6@@3#:#%.'.$0%!!$:@(0-#)!!G(#'+.!:#'.!<br />

@0(.$0%! +$A%$1$5'%.37! NJz[B[^P! '+! 50:@'(#)! .0! G$()+! 1#)! )#5(#'+#)! )#%+$.7! Q$.&06.!<br />

#%>7:#B!T0!)#5(#'+$%A!)$#.'(7!@(0.#$%_':$%0!'5$)!3#-#3+!G7!^t!Q$.&!@(0.#'+#!+##:+!<br />

.0!G#!G#%#1$5$'3!Q&$3#!#%>7:#!+6@@3#:#%.'.$0%!$%!.&#!)$#.+!ft!(#)65#)!!)#%+$.7!%0.B!<br />

K&#! (#+63.+! +&0Q#)! .&'.! $%+.#')! 01! (#)65$%A! @(0.#$%! '30%#4! )#5(#'+$%A! @(0.#$%! '%)!<br />

':$%0! '5$)! )#%+$.7! .0A#.&#(! 5'6+#)! ! 3#++! )#@(#++$0%! $%! @#(10(:'%5#! 01! G(0$3#(+B! O%!<br />

'))$.$0%4!$.!5'%!G#!.&06A&.!!.&'.!!(#)65$%A!@(0.#$%!'%)!':$%0!'5$)!$%!G(0$3#(!)$#.+!'1.#(!<br />

+.'(.#(!@#($0)!$+!'!#50%0:$5!'%)!#%-$(0%:#%.!1($#%)37!@('5.$5#!!#+@#5$'337!Q&#%!@($5#+!<br />

01!@(0.#$%!+06(5#+!$+!&$A&B!<br />

!<br />

>(.($<br />

J(0.#$%! ='7%'!! &'::'))#3#()#! 76(.! )!!! G'!:3!3!!:!>!%! )'! #.=$+$73#! 7#:!<br />

:'3$7#.3#($%)#! 7''%'%! 7D=+#3$4! ='%'.3!! D(#.$:$! '?!+!%)'%! .#:#3! +!=!%.!3'(!%! G'!%)'!<br />

A#3:#=.#)$(B! d[[W! 7!3!%!%! +0%3'(!%)'! 7''%'%! CcR! =($>$! G(0$3#(! 7#:3#($%)#! @(0.#$%!<br />

='7%'=3'(!%!%! ?0=! 7D=+#=! 1$7'.3'(3'! =633'%!3:'+!%'! 703! '?:!.!(B! L.3$=! @$3$?3#($%!<br />

A#3$$:$%)#!$&.$7'?!)6763'%!@(0.#$%!:$=.'(!%!%!-#!='3$.#+$%$%!7D=+#=!03)66!-#!G6%6%!<br />

7'3'! '>'3)!!! $7$! G$3$%#%! G$(!=0%6)6(B! L.3$=! @$3$?3#($%! @#(10(:'%+3'(!%)'!)#@(#+70%'!<br />

703!'?:'7'5'=!-#!7#:!:'3$7#.$%$!)DD(#5#=!?#$.3$!67A63':'3'(!D>#($%)#!A#?:$.#%!<br />

G#($!?'3!!3:'=.')!(B!"'+70%!@(0.#$%!706%366!-#!':$%0!'+$.!)#%A#+$%$%!'7'(3'%:'+!4!<br />

=($+.'3!!':$%0!'+$.3#($%!$3'-#+$!-#!#%>$:!67A63':'3'(!!D>#($%)#!706%3'!3'%!=0%63'(!<br />

03'('=!='(!:!>'!?!=:'=.')!(B!;7(!5'!ADG(#4!!D3=#:$>)#!)#!='%'.3!!+#=.U(D%D%!U%#:3$!<br />

+0(6%3'(!%)'%! G$($! &'3$%#! A#3:$.$(! -#! ('+70%! @(0.#$%! +#-$7#+$%)#! 7'@!3'G$3#5#=!<br />

0@.$:$>'+70%! ?'3!:'3'(!%!%! ADG(#! $3#! '.!3'%! '>0.! :$=.'(!%!! )'! '>'3.'5'!!<br />

G$3$%:#=.#)$(B!<br />

"'+70%! @(0.#$%! +#-$7#+$%$%! '>'3.!3:'+!! @#(10(:'%+! -#! $.'&! D>#($%#! 036:+6>! #.=$!<br />

7'@:'=.'!-#!G6!)6(6:!.D:!#+'%+$7#3!':$%0!'+$.!$&.$7'5!!='(!3'%)!!%)'!G$3#!0(.'7'!<br />

?!='G$3:#=.#)$(B! J(0.#$%! 7#.:#>3$$%#! G'3!! )DD=! @#(10(:'%+! ?06%36=3'h! #+'%+$7#3!<br />

03:'7'%!':$%0!'+$.3#($%!+#%.#>$!$?$%!'>0.!&'-6>6%6%!7#.:#>3$$4!-D56.!='@'+$.#+$%$%!<br />

U>#33$=3#!A3$+$%4!+#($%4!@(03$%!A$G$!#+'%+$7#3!03:'7'%!':$%0!'+$.!$&.$7'5!%!!='(!3':')'!<br />

7#.#(+$>3$$4! @0.'+76:! +#-$7#+$%$%! '>'3:'+!! -#7'! $70%! )#%A#+$%$%! -#! ('+70%)'!<br />

#+'%+$7#3! ':$%0! '+$.3#(! N'(I$%$%b3$>$%4! 3$>$%b.(#0%$%4! .($@.01'%b%U.(! ':$%0! '+$.3#(P!<br />

'('+!%)'=$!0('%!%!)#$:#+$!A$G$!1'=.U(3#(#!G'3'%:'=.')!(B!*'%5&#(!-#!w#%+#%!NVWfWP!<br />

:#.$70%$%4! 3$>$%4! .(#0%$%4! '(I$%$%4! .($@.01'%! -#! @0.'+76:! G'=!:!%)'%! )#%A#3#%:$!<br />

('+70%! $3#! @#(10(:'%+.'=$! )#@(#+70%6%! .':! 03'('=! #%A#33#%#:#)$$%$! G$3)$($(=#%4!<br />

a'3)(06@! -#! '(=B4! Nd[[^P! )DD=! NtddP! @(0.#$%3$! ('+70%3'('! A3$+$%! $3'-#+$%$%!<br />

@#(10(:'%+!! $7$3#.$()$$! &'3)#! 7D=+#=! NtdgP! @(0.#$%3$! ('+70%! +#-$7#+$%#!<br />

?!='(':')!!%!! .#+@$.! #.:$3#()$(B! "'+70%! @(0.#$%! +#-$7#+$%)#=$! '>'3:'%!%! G$(!G'='!<br />

036:+6>! #.=$+$! )#! -D56..'! 7'! G$($=$:$%$! '(.!(:'+!)!(! Nn':(06)! -#! '(=B4! Nd[[fPB!<br />

! C#H


cDD=! ('+70%! @(0.#$%! +#-$7#3#($%)#=$! $.'&! '>'3:'+!!'!(!! -#7'! )#%A#+$>! ':$%0! '+$.!<br />

:$=.'(!! -#! 0%3'(!%! ='%)'=$! :#.'G03$>:'! D(D%3#($! NU(%#$%! ':0%7'=P! $3#! '3'='3!)!(B!<br />

;('.!(!5!3'(! ('+70%! @(0.#$%! +#-$7#+$%)#=$! )DDD%! ='%! ':0%7'=! +#-$7#+$%$%!<br />

7D=+#3:#+$%#4!='('5$#(!'!(3!!%!%!'(.:'+!%'!-#!='%!D($=!'+$.!+#-$7#+$%$%!)D:#+$%#!<br />

703! '?.!!%!! G$3)$(:$3#()$(B! ;:$%0! '+$.! )#%A#+$>3$$%$%! G$(! +0%656! 03'('=! ='(G0%!<br />

$+=#3#.$!@'(?'3'%:'=.'!-#!':0%7'=!0(.'7'!?!=:'=.')!(B!*'>3'!':0%7'!%!%#(0.0=+$=!<br />

#.=$+$! $.'&!%! -#! 7#:! .D=#.$:$%$%! )D:#+$%#! 703! '?:'=.'! -#! @#(10(:'%+! 036:+6>!<br />

#.=$3#%#G$3:#=.#)$(B!c03'7!+!!$3#!('+70%!@(0.#$%!+#-$7#+$%$%!'>'3.!3:'+!!#.3$=!@$3$?3#($%!<br />

@#(10(:'%+!! -#! -D56.! =0:@0>$+70%6! '?!+!%)'%! =($.$=! 03)66%)'%! %#! )D>#7)#! G$(!<br />

'>'3.:'!7'@!3'5'!!)'!U%#:3$)$(B!!<br />

X#:3#($%! +#3D30>! -#!U>#33$=3#! 1$.'.! 10+10(! $3#! ':$3'>! $%&$G$.U(D! $?#($$!-#!G6%'!G'3!!<br />

03'('=! '(.'%! #%)0I#%! +#=(#+70%4! @(0.#$%! 7'('(3'%!:!%!! '>'3.'G$3:#=.#)$(B! X#:3#(#!<br />

#%>$:! $3'-#+$%$%! G6! #%)0I#%! '>0.! ='7G!%!! '>'3..!!! G#3$(.$3:#=.#)$(B! J(0.#$%!<br />

='7%'=3'(!%!%! U>#33$=3#! )#! +07'! =D+@#+$%$%! 7'@!+!%)'! G636%'%! -#! !+!3! $3#:3#(3#!<br />

$%'=.$-#! #)$3:#7#%! '33#(I#%$=! @(0.#$%3#(! A$G$! '%.$bG#+$%+#3! U#3#(4! +$%)$($3#G$3$(3$$!<br />

)DD(:#=.#)$(!NK'::$%A'!-#!'(=B4!VWW^PB!X#:3#(#!@(0.#'>!'!(3!=3!!#%>$:3#($%!$3'-#!<br />

#)$3:#+$4! +07'! @(0.#$%3#($%$%! ?U>D%#G$3$(3$$%$! '(.!(:'=.'! -#! .($@+$%! $%&$G$.U(D%!<br />

036:+6>!#.=$3#($%$!'>'3.:'=.'!Nj'$%#!-#!'(=B4!VWWfP4!':$%0!'+$.!+$%)$($3#G$3$(3$$%$!)#!<br />

7D=+#3.:#=.#)$(! N2#(%'()! -#! 95n'G4! VWWZPB! X6! -#! '(=BNd[[ZP! .'('1!%)'%! ('+70%!<br />

@(0.#$%! +#-$7#+$%$! )DD(:#=! D>#(#! 7'@!3'%! ?'3!:'3'()'! @(0.#'>! $3'-#+$! $3#! +07'!<br />

=D+@#+$%)#! $%-$.(0! @(0.#$%! +$%)$($3#G$3$(3$$%$%! U%#:3$! )D>#7)#! $7$3##(#=! N@z[B[^P!<br />

=0%.(03! A(6G6%'! AU(#! ! t! Zf!='7%'=3'(!!=633'%'('=!7'@.!=3'(!!?'3!:')'!#%>$:!$3'-#+$%$%!<br />

A#(?#=!:#.'G03$=!#%#(I$!-#!%$.(0I#%!7'('7!3!3!!%!!#%>$:!='7%'!%'!AU(#!)#$:#=3#!<br />

G$(3$=.#! U%#:3$! )D>#7)#! '(.!()!!%!! .#+@$.! #.:$3#()$(B! l'%#33'! -#! '(=BNVWWWP! )DD=!<br />

#%#(I$! 706%36=36! ('+70%3'('! ':$3'>4! @(0.#'>! -#! =+$3'%'>! $?#($=3$! #%>$:! $3'-#+$%$%!<br />

@(0.#$%! +$%)$($3#G$3$(3$$%$! tdBW! '(.!()!!%!! G$3)$(:$3#()$(B! c03'7!+!! $3#! G(0$3#(!<br />

('+70%3'(!%)'! @(0.#'>! #%>$:$! =633'%!3:'+!%!%! @(0.#$%! 7'('(3'%!:!%!! '(.!('G$3#5#$! -#!<br />

GU73#5#!)'&'!)DD=!&':!@(0.#$%!$?#($=3$!7#:3#($%!7'@!3'G$3#5#$!U%AU(D3#G$3$(B!!<br />

26!'('.!(:')'h!9'0'#7')8=&"7%),$.#"%&).$'&!&!)8"%#%$7"8"&4!GD7D.:#4!A#3$.$(:#!<br />

-#! G$.$(:#! 7#:3#($%$%! @(0.#$%! -#7'! @(0.#$%! -#! ':$%0! '+$.! )D>#73#($%$! t! ^! -#! t! f!<br />

0('%!%)'! '>'3.:'%!%4! @(0.#'>! #%>$:$! =633'%!3!@4! =633'%!3:')!!%'! AU(#! @$3$?3#($%!<br />

@#(10(:'%+!-#!A#3$$:$!D>#($%#!#.=$3#($%$!'('.!(:'=!':'5!73'!7D(D.D3:D.D(B!!<br />

!<br />

c+1&.5+-$@&$c&1F/$<br />

;('.!(:')'!2#7@$!;BB!=636?='&'%#!D%$.#+$%)#%!!.#:$%!#)$3:$!!AD%3D=!7'.'!='(!!=!<br />

5$%+$7#..#!Vd[[[!')#.!!"0++!][f!#.3$=!!5$-5$-!=633'%!3:!.!(B!;('.!(:'!2#7@$!;BB!;(b<br />

C#!=D:#+$%)#4!&#(!G$($%)#!Vd[[!')#.!='(!!=!5$%+$7#..#!!5$-5$-!G636%'%!V[!!A(6@.'!e!'3.!<br />

A(6@36! 03'('=! .#+')D1! G30=3'(!! )#%#:#! )D>#%$%#! AU(#! 7D(D.D3:D.D(B! H636?=')'%!<br />

?!='%! 5$-5$-3#(! &#(! G$($%)#! 7#:3$=4! (')7'%.! -#! %$@#3! +636=! G636%'%! V]: d #(!#=$3)#!:!+!(b<br />

+07'! .#:#33$! 03'('=! A('%D3! -#! @#3#.! 10(:)'! &'>!(3'%:!.!(B! X#:3#()#! #%>$:! 03'('=!<br />

@(0.#'>! $?#(#%! -#! :$%$:6:! @(0.#'>! '=.$-$.#+$! Z^B[[[! @(0._A! 03'('=! G$3)$($3#%!<br />

"0%0>7:#! J(0;5.! $+$:3$! #%>$:! d[[A_.0%! +#-$7#+$%)#! =633'%!3:!.!(B! ;('.!(:')'! g!<br />

)U%#:3$! N[bVV4! Vdbd^4! deb]^! -#! ]ebgdB! AD%3#(P! G#+3#:#! @(0A(':!! 67A63'%:!! 036@4!<br />

G#+$%! :'))#+$! $&.$7'?3'(!! n"j! VWWg! -#! "0++! 1$(:'+!%!%! "0++! ][f! G(073#(! $?$%!<br />

U%#($3#($! #+'+! '3!%'('=! &'>!(3'%:!.!(B! ;('.!(:')'! =633'%!3'%! 7#:! :'))#3#($%$%!<br />

'%'3$>3#($!-#!='(:'3'(!%!&':!G#+$%!:'))#+$!'%'3$>3#($!;R;jNd[[[P


;('.!(:')'! #.3$=! @$3$?! 7#:3#($%$%! @(0.#$%! -#7'! @(0.#$%r':$%0! '+$.! N:#.$70%$%! -#!<br />

3$>$%P!+#-$7#3#($%$%!!t^!-#!tf!)D>#7$%)#!!'>'3.!3:'+!!-#!G6%3'('!#%>$:!$3'-#!#)$3#(#=!<br />

036.6(63:6! f! 1'(=3!! ('+70%! $3#! G$.$(:#! 7#:$! @(0.#$%! $?#($=3#($! 1'(=3!! d! =0%.(03!<br />

('+70%6! 03:'=! D>#(#! .0@3':! V[! A(6@! ! )#%#%:$.$(! NK'G30! VPB! 2'3'.:'! )U%#:$%)#!<br />

.D:! A(6@3'(! '7%!! 7#:$! .D=#.:$4! 7#:! @(0.#$%! -#_-#7'! ':$%0! '+$.! 0('%!%)'! ! 7'@!3'%!<br />

'>'3.:'!G'3'.:'!)U%#:$%)#%!+0%('!67A63'%:!.!(B!c#%#:#%$%!G'3'.:'!)U%#:$%)#!<br />

.D:! A(6@3'('! ! td]B^! \J! -#! ][d^=5'3_=A! 9L! $?#(#%! ! G'3'%A!?! 7#:$! ! 7#)$($3:$.$(B!<br />

j$-5$-3#($%!5'%3!!'!(3!=!.'(.!:!4!&#(!'3.!A(6@!$?$%!)#%#:#!G'!%)'!-#!)#%#:#!+0%6%)'!<br />

7'@!3:!.!(B! ;3.! ! A(6@3'(! )D>#7$%)#! 7#:! .D=#.$:3#($! )#! &#(! G$(! G#+3#:#! @#($70)6!<br />

+0%6%)'!7'@!3'%!.'(.!:3'(3'!G#3$(3#%:$.$(B!3A$3$!)U%#:3#(#!'$.!!7#:!.D=#.$:$%$%!!5'%3!!<br />

'!(3!=! '(.!!%'! GU3D%:#+$73#! G636%'%! 7#:! )##(3#%)$(:#! ='.+'7!+!! N*j"P! )'! '7%!!<br />

)U%#:3#(! ! -#! GD.D%! )#%#:#! @#($70)6! $?$%! '7(!! '7(!! &#+'@3'%:!.!(B! ;3.! A(6@3'()'!<br />

AD%3D=! 03'('=! U3#%! 5$-5$-! +'7!3'(!! ! ='7)#)$3#(#=! 7#:! .D=#.$:$! -#! 7'':'! AD5D%D%!<br />

&#+'@3'%:'+!%)'!)$=='.#!'3!%:!.!(B!;('.!(:'!+0%6%)'!$3#.:#)#!-#($:3$3$=!#%)#=+$!<br />

03'('=! G$3$%#%! `(#.$:! L.=#%3$$! L%)#=+$! NJL*P! oc#%#:#! T0%6! j'%3!!<br />

;!(3!=N=APyX'':'! CD5DP_N*j"yH#+$:! X'!NAD%PPyV[[N"0++4! d[[W! P! 10(:D3D%#!<br />

AU(#!'3.!A(6@!G'>!%)'!-#!A(6@!0(.'3':'+!!03'('=!)##(3#%)$($3:$.$(B!<br />

c#%#:#! +0%6%)'! &#(! '3.! A(6G6%! 0(.'3':'! 5'%3!!'!(3!!%'! 7'=!%! V! #(=#=! -#! V! )$$!<br />

03:'=!D>#(#!&#(!A(6@.'%!.0@3':!Vd!')#.!@$3$?!=0%.(033D!03'('=!=#+$3#(#=!+!5'=!='(='+!<br />

('%)!:'%!!&#+'@3'%:!4!'7%!!='(='+!U(%#=3#($%)#!!'G)0:$%'3!7'4!G6.!N?$1.P!-#!AUD+!<br />

#.$! ! 0('%!! .#+@$.! #)$3:$.$(B! ;G)0:$%'3! 7'! 0('%!4! G6.! ! -#! AUD+! #.$! 0('%!! ='(='+.'%!<br />

'7(!3'%! G6! @'(?'3'(!%! @$3$5$%! =#+$:! U%5#+$! 5'%3!! '!(3!!%'! 0('%!! -#! +!5'=! ='(='+!<br />

'!(3!!%'!0('%!!03'('=!'7(!!'7(!!$1')#!#)$3:$.$(B!<br />

;('.!(:')'%! :6':#3#3#(#! ! '$.! $+.'.$+.$=+#3! &#+'@3':'3'(! -#! :6':#3#3#($%! 0(.'3':'!<br />

)##(3#($! '('+!%)'=$! 1'(=3!3!=3'(!%! U%#:3$3$$! -'(7'%+! '%'3$>$! :#.0)6! NcD>AD%#! -#!<br />

'(=B4! VWW]P4! A(6@3'(! '('+!%)'=$! 1'(=3!3!!%! =0%.(03D! $+#! c6%5'%! .#+.$! Nc6%5'%4! VW^^P!<br />

)'&$3$%)#!A#(?#=3#.$($3:$.$(B!<br />

!<br />

H=$D7-67-+.$@&$?+.1!)+$<br />

('.!(:')'! #3)#! #)$3#%! @#(10(:'%+! +0%6?3'(!! K'G30! d! -#! ]'3.!3:'+!!@$3$?3#($%!':$%0!'+$.!<br />

.D=#.$:$%)#!)#%A#+$>3$#!703!'?:'=.'4!!&'7-'%3'(!'7%!!:$=.'(3'()'!7#:!.D=#.+#!G$3#4!!<br />

U>#33$=3#! 3$>$%$%! )$#(! ':$%0! '+$.3#(#! 03'%! 0('%!! )#$.$$%)#%! @#(10(:'%+! 036:+6>!<br />

#.=$3#%#G$3:#=.#)$(B! CD%D:D>)#! ='%'.3!! ('+70%3'(!%!%! $)#'3! ':$%0! '+$.! ='-(':!%'!<br />

N2'=#(4!VWWZP!AU(#!!10(:D3#!#)$3:#+$%$%!.#:#3!%#)#%3#($%)#%!G$($!)#!G6)6(B!9#-56.!<br />

'('.!(:')'=$!5'%3!!'!(3!=!+0%6?3'(!!'('+!%)'=$!1'(=3!3!=4!$+.'.$+.$=!03'('=!U%#:3$3$=!'(>!<br />

#.:#:#+$%#! (':#%! ('+70%! 706%366%6! +')#5#! @(0.#$%! G'=!:!%)'%! '>'3.:'%!%!<br />

)0(6!G$(!.#(5$&!03:')!!%!!AU+.#(:#=.#)$(B!<br />

;('.!(:')'!#%!!7D=+#=!)#%#:#!+0%6!5'%3!!'!(3!=!A#3$$:$%$%!@(0.#$%!-#!':$%0!'+$.!<br />

0('%!!G$(3$=.#!t^!)DD(D3#(#=!#%>$:!$3'-#+$!7'@!3:!!A(6@.'!0(.'7'!?!=:!.!(!NJs[B[^PB!<br />

T')#5#! @(0.#$%! 0('%!! t^! )DD(D3#%! A(6@.'! )'! #%>$:! $3'-#+$! 5'%3!!'!(3!!! $+.'.$+.$=!<br />

03'('=!U%#:3$!03:'+'!G$3#!'(.!(:!!A$G$!AU(D%:#=.#)$(!NJs[B[^PB!J(0.#$%!-#!':$%0!'+$.!<br />

0('%!%!%! t! f! )D>#7$%)#! '>'3.!3)!!! 7#:3#($! .D=#.#%! @$3$?3#($%! '!(3!!%)'! $+#! #%>$:!<br />

$3'-#+$!t^!)D>#7$%)#!=$!=')'(!G$(!$7$3#:#7#!703!'?:':!.!(B!L%>$:!$3'-#+$%$%!#.=$+$!<br />

)##(3#%)$($3)$$%)#h! +0%6?3'(! '('+!%)'=$! 1'(=3!3!=3'(! $+.'.$+.$=! 03'('=! U%#:! '(>!<br />

#.:$70(! 03+'3'(! G$3#4! )#%#:#)#! ?'3!!3'%! &'7-'%! +'7!+!%!%! ?0=366%6%! +0%6?3'(!%!<br />

! C#N


AD-#%$3$(3$$%#! 03'%! 7'%+!:'+!! 036:36! 7U%)#! 03)66%)'%4! '('.!(:'%!%! G$(! GD.D%!<br />

03'('=! 70(6:3'%:'+!%)'! 0(.'7'! ?!='%! #$3$:3#($%)#! )$=='.#! '3!%:'+!%!%! A#(#=.$$!<br />

)DD%D3#G$3$(B!!c03'7!+!!$3#!@(0.#$%!-#!':$%0!'+$.!+#-$7#+$%$%!)DD(D3:#+$!)6(6:6%)'!<br />

#%>$:! $3'-#+$%$%! @#(10(:'%+!%! .#3'1$+$%)#! $7$3#.$($5$! G$(! U%3#:! 03'('=!<br />

)DD%D3#G$3#5#$!6%6.63:':'3!)!(B!D7$+.+1!.)+/+$6G9/&,$A+_!.!-)+)+'!$6&.&A&,$<br />

;(.$ ;+A+$ *7'7'$ ('&$ &1-(A$ ^(-(_-&.$ (_(,$ ^.F1&(,$ ;(.(A()(,(,$ 'F,$ /&.&'3.:')'!<br />

G$3#! 5'%3!!'!(3!!%! ?0=! 1'>3'! A#($3#:#:#+$%$%! %#)#%$! .D:! A(6@3'(!%! '7%!! G'3'.:'!<br />

7#:$%$! .D=#.:#+$)$(B! 9#-56.! '('.!(:'%!%! =0633'(!%'! AU(#! NG'3'.:'! )U%#:$:)#!<br />

=!+!.3':'! 7'@!3:')'%P! tf! )D>#7$%)#! )'&$! ('+70%! @(0.#$%! -#! ':$%0! '+$.! 0('%!%!%!<br />

'>'3.!3'G$3#5#$%$4!':'!#=0%0:$=!=0633'(!?0=!>0(3':!70(+'!t!^!0('%!%!%!)'&'!.#)G$(3$!<br />

G$(!7'=3'!:!03)66%6!-#!#%>$:!$3'-#+$%$%!)#!@#(10(:'%+!!)D>#3.:#!'?!+!%)'%!036:36!<br />

G$(!@0.'%+$7#3#!+'&$@!03'G$3#5#$%$!+U73#:#=!:D:=D%)D(B!<br />

X#:)#%! 7'('(3'%:'! D>#($%#! :6':#3#3#($%! #.=$+$! U%#:+$>)$(! N@s[B[^PB! J(0.#$%!<br />

0('%!%!%! tf! )DD(D3:#+$! G$3#! 7#:)#%! 7'('(3'%:'! )'! U%#:3$! G$(! )#@(#+70%3'!<br />

+0%6?3'%:':!.!(B! T0%6?3'(! :6':#3#3#($%! #.=$+$! '?!+!%)'%! G#3$(A$%! G$(! #$3$:$!<br />

7'%+!.:':'=.')!(B! E1) +.&1D0'$Z) 9'0'#7') 8=&"7%&8") ,$.#"%&) C") '7%&.) '+%#)<br />

) "##33$=3#!G'3'.:'!)U%#:$!='+!<br />

-#! =#:$=! A#3$$:$%$%! ?0=! &!>3!! 03)66! G$(! )U%#:! 036@4! -D56..'! @(0.#$%! G$($=$:$!<br />

7D=+#=! )D>#7)#! 03:'=.')!(B! L.3$=! @$3$?3#()#! #(=#%! 7'3'()'! GD7D:#%$%! U%#:3$! G$(!<br />

=!+:!! ='+! -#! @(0.#$%! G$($=$:$! #=3$%)#! 03)66%)'%! =($.$=! 03'%! G6! )U%#:$%! G#+$%!<br />

=!+!.3':'+!! 7'@!3:')'%! A#?$3:#+$! $3#($=$! )U%#:3#()#! 7'@!3'%! =!+!.3':')'%! ?0=! 1'>3'!<br />

#.=$3#%:#:#3#($%$!+'3':'=.')!(B!!<br />

8#($:3$3$=! #%)#=+$! NJL*P! ('=':3'(!! $%5#3#%)$$%)#! NK'G30! ]Ph! #%>$:! $3'-#+$!<br />

7'@!3:'7'%! A(6@3'()'! )DD=! 03'%! )##($%! #%>$:! $3'-#+$! $3#! =0%.(03! A(6G6%'! G#%>#(!<br />

)##(#! 63'.!!! N@s[B[^P! AU(D3:#=.#)$(B! J(0.#$%)#! 7'@!3'%! '>'3:'! +#-$7#+$%$%! #.=$+$!<br />

)##(3#%)$($3)$$%)#! t^! '>'3.:'! G$(! =U.D3#:#7$! ?'(!.!(:'>=#%4! tf! @(0.#$%!<br />

'>'3:'+!! -#($:3$3$=! #%)#=+$%$%! )D:#+$%#! 703! '?:!! A$G$! AU(D%:#=.#)$(! N@s[B[^PB!<br />

2#+$%!:'))#+$!706%366%)'!t!f!'>'3.:'!)6(6:6%)'!-#($:3$3$=.#!G$(!)DD!#$3$:$!<br />

0(.'7'! ?!='(=#%4! t! ^! '>'3.!3:!! 7#:3#(#! #%>$:! $3'-#+$! $3#! ! -#($:3$3$=! #%)#=+$%)#!<br />

U%#:3$!0('%)'!03:'+'!G$3#!G$(!7D=+#3$!#$3$:$!-'()!(B!<br />

m3D:!0('%!!)#%#:#!G076%5'!A#%#33$=3#!G#=3#%$3#%$%!D>#($%)#!03:6.6(B!;3.!A(6@3'('!<br />

G'3!! -'(7'+70%6%! 7D=+#=! 03:'+!! %#)#%$! $3#! A(6@3'(! '('+!%)'! ('=':+'3! 1'(=3!3!=3'(!<br />

GD7D=! 03:'+!%'! (':#%! $+.'.$+.$=! 03'('=! U%#:3$! G636%:':!.!(B! m3D:! 0('%3'(!!<br />

:6':#3#3#(#! AU(#! )#! G#3$(3$! G$(! 7U%)#! +#7(#.:#:$.$(B! ! c03'7!+!! $3#! U3D:! 0('%!%)'!<br />

AU(D3#%! 1'(=3!3!=3'(!%! @(0.#$%! +#-$7#+$! 7')'! #%>$:#! G'3!! 03'('=! U%#:3$! 0('%)'!<br />

)#$.$$!7U%D%)#!G$(!7'(A!7'!A$.:#=!:D:=D%!03:':!.!(B!<br />

X#:!.D=#.$:$%$%4!$+.'.$+.$=!03'('=!U%#:3$!03:'+'!)'!('+70%!@(0.#$%!+#-$7#+$!t!^!-#!t!<br />

f! )DD(D3#%! A(6@3'()'! )$#(! A(6@3'('! AU(#! )'&'! )DD=! 03)66! .#+@$.! #)$3:$.$(!<br />

N@s[B[^PB! c#%#:#)#! =633'%!3'%! &'7-'%! +'7!+!%!%! ?0=366! -#! 7#:! .D=#.$:$%#! '$.!<br />

0(.'3':'3'(!%! @! )##($N[B[WP! )$=='.#! '3!%)!!%)'! G6! +0%6?3'(! AU>)#%! ='?!(!3:':'+!!<br />

A#(#=#%! G$(! )6(6:)6(B! "'+70%! @(0.#$%! 706%366%6! .#=! G'!%'! t! f! '>'3.:'4! 7#:!<br />

! C#T


.D=#.$:$%$%!!)D:#+$%#!703!'?:!4!t!^!'>'3.:'!)'!$+#!7#:!.D=#.$:$%)#=$!)DD!)'&'!<br />

:'=63!+!%!(3'(!$?$%)#!='3:!.!(B!!26!)DDD%!+#G#G$!$.'&!'>'3:'+!4!!'!(!!-#7'!)#%A#+$>!<br />

':$%0!'+$.!.D=#.$:$!-#!0%3'(!%!='%)'=$!:#.'G03$>:'!D(D%3#($%$%!NU(%#$%! ':0%7'=P!<br />

'(.!!!$3#!'?!=3'%:'=.')!(Nn':(06)!-#!'(=B4!d[[fPB!X#:!.D=#.$:$%)#=$!'>'3:'!+0%6?.'!<br />

A#%#3! @#(10(:'%+!%! G0>63:'+!%'! 703! '?'5'!%)'%4! 7#:! .D=#.$:$%)#! :#7)'%'! A#3#%!<br />

)#@(#+70%6!#%A#33#:#=!'?!+!%)'%!G6!?'3!:'%!%!+0%6?3'(!!)'!)$=='.#!'3!%)!!%)'h!!.#=!<br />

G'!%'!@(0.#$%!7#($%#!('+70%!@(0.#$%$!$3#!G$(3$=.#!:#.$70%$%!-#!3$>$%!0('%!%!%!)'!G#%>#(!<br />

#=$3)#!'>'3.!3:'+!!1'7)'3!!03'G$3$(B!;7(!5'!!#%>$:!$3'-#+$%$%!)#!G6!'?!)'%!1'7)'3!!G$(!<br />

.#)G$(!03'('=!)DD%D3#G$3#5#$%$!G#3$(.:#=.#!7'('(!-'()!(B!<br />

2#+3#:#!$3#!$3A$3$!7'@!3'%!)#$$=3$=3#($%!G$(!7'%+!:'+!!03'('=!@3'+:'!+#-$7#+$%)#!='%!<br />

:#.'G03$.3#($%#!G'=!3:'+!!)'! U%#:3$!-#($3#(! +'3'7'G$3:#=.#)$(4!?D%=D!#%#(I$Y@(0.#$%!<br />

0('%!%!%! GD7D:#+$! -D56..'! 3$@0I#%#+$+$! '(.!(:'=.')!(B! X'@!3'%! '('.!(:'3'()'! ('+70%!<br />

@(0.#$%! +#-$7#+$%)#=$! '>'3:'! $3#! ='%! .($A3$+#($)! :$=.'(!! '(.'(=#%! D($=! '+$.! :$=.'(!%!%!<br />

'>'3)!!NTQ#%%#%! -#! '(=B4! d[[eh! H':('%! -#! '(=B4! d[V[P4! A36=0>! +#-$7#+$%$%! $+#!<br />

)#$:#)$$NTQ#%%#%! -#! '(=B4! d[[eP! G636%:6.6(B! ;7(!5'! )DD=! @(0.#$%! -#! ':$%0!<br />

'+$.3$! G#+3#:#%$%! @$3$?3#()#! ! .0@3':! ='%! +#(6:! @(0.#$%! ! -#! '3G6:$%! +#-$7#+$%$!<br />

)DD()DD!G$3)$($3:#=.#)$(!Nj0(>0!-#!'(=B4!d[[^PB!!<br />

TQ#%%#%! -#! '(=! Nd[[^P! )DD=! @(0.#$%! $?#($$%#! +'&$@! 7#:! .D=#..$=3#($%)#! @$3$?3#($%!<br />

@(0.#$%! )#@03':'! ='G$3$7#.3#($%$! '(.!(!(=#%! )'&'! 1'>3'! @(0.#$%! .'+'((616! 7'@:'=! $?$%!<br />

':$%0! '+$.! 0=+$)'+70%6%6! )'! '>'3..!=3'(!%!! G$3)$(:$.$(B! cDD=! @(0.#$%3$! ('+70%3'(3'!<br />

G#+3#%#%!@$3$?3#(!+#(G#+.!7'!'+$.3#($!7#($%#!.#(5$&#%!='(G0%&$)('.3'(!!=633'%:'=.')!(B!<br />

26%6%!7'%!%)'!)DD=!7#:!.D=#.$:$!)03'7!+!!$3#!.#3'1$!GD7D:#+$!:#='%$>:'+!!03'('=!<br />

'>'3'%!':$%0!'+$.!0=+$)'+70%6!)'&'!#.=$3$!@(0.#$%!7'('(3'%!:!!+'3':'=.')!(B!!<br />

;('.!(:':!>)'! ='%! .0@3':! @(0.#$%! +#-$7#+$4! :6':#3#3#()#%! U%#:3$! )D>#7)#!<br />

#.=$3#%:#:$4! '%5'=! #%>$:! +#-$7#+$%$%! #.=$+$! U%#:3$! G636%:6.6(B! "'+70%! @(0.#$%!<br />

+#-$7#+$%$%!)DD(D3:#+$!='%!.0@3':!@(0.#$%!+#-$7#+$%)#!=0%.(03!A(6G6%'!AU(#!U%#:3$!<br />

0('%)'! '>'3:'7'! 703! ! '?'(=#%4! 7#:3#(#! #%>$:! $3'-#+$! ! ='%! .0.'3! @(0.#$%$%$%! U%#:3$!<br />

U3?D)#! 7D=+#3.#(#=! N@z[B[^P! =0%.(03! A(6G6! +#-$7#+$%#! ?!='(:!.!(B! 26! #.=$4! U>#33$=3#!<br />

('+70%! @(0.#$%! 706%366! tf! '>'3.!3)!!%)'! )'&'! G#3$(A$%! &'3#! A#3:$! -#! ]Bf[!<br />

:A_)i$#%4!d[[dPB!L.!='3$.#+$!<br />

D>#($%#! U%#:3$! #.=$3#($! 03'%! )$#(! ':$%0! '+$.3#(! $+#! =D=D(.3D! ':$%0! '+$.3#()$(B! L.3$=!<br />

@$3$?! 7#:3#($%)#! =D=D(.3D! ':$%0! '+$.! N:#.$0%$%r+$+.$%P! +#-$7#3#($%#! @'('3#3! 03'('=!<br />

AUD+! #.$! 0('%!%)'! '(.!! 036(=#%! 7'! 0('%!%!%! )'! )D.DD! $1')#! #)$3:$.$(! N*$+&#(!<br />

VWWgPB!9#-56.!?'3!:')'!)'!@(0.#$%!+#-$7#+$!$3#!G$(3$=.#!3$>$%!-#!=D=D(.3D!!':$%0!'+$.!<br />

706%366%)'=$! '>'3:'7'! G'3!! 03'('=! AUD+! #.$! 0('%!%)'! AU(D3#%! )DD! N@z[B[^P!<br />

('+70%'! @(0.#'>! #%>$:$! ='.!3:'+!! )6(6:6%)'! 7D=+#3%$! -#! =0%.(03! A(6G6! $3#! G#%>#(!<br />

G636%:6.6(B! 26! '?!)'%! )##(3#%)$($3)$$%)#! ='(='+! AUD+! #.$! 0('%!! G'=!:!%)'%!!<br />

('+70%!@(0.#$%!706%366%)'!7'@!3'5'=!'>'3.:'%!%!t^


)0(6! -#! 1'7)'3!! G$(! 67A63':'! 03'5'!! 7U%D%)#)$(B$ 2'3'.:'! )U%#:$%)#! %0(:'3!<br />

7#:3#:#! 7'@:'=! ='7)!! $3#! ('+70%! @(0.#$%! 706%366%6! t! f!%! N'>)'! 03+'! ! @#(10(:'%+! ='7G!!<br />

03'G$3#5#$! AU>! '()!! #)$3:#:#3$)$(P! :D:=D%! 03'G$3#5#$! -#! ('+70%! @(0.#$%!<br />

706%366%)'! 7'@!3'5'=! '>'3.:'%!%! .#=! G'!%'! 7'@!3:'+!! 7#($%#4! ':$%0! '+$.!<br />

706%366!$3#!G$(3$=.#!'7'(3'%:'+!!A#(#=.$$!+0%656%'!-'(!3:!.!(B!!<br />

;('.!(:'! +0%6?3'(!! #%>$:! $3'-#+$! 7U%D%)#%! )##(3#%)$($3)$$%)#h! ('+70%! @(0.#$%! -#!<br />

':$%0! '+$.! 706%366! t! ^! '>'3.!3:!! 7#:3#(#! @(0.#'>! ='.!3:'+!%!%! 1'7)'3!! 03'G$3:#!<br />

@0.'%+$7#3$%$%! G636%)664! G6%6%3'! G$(3$=.#! @(0.#$%! -#! ':$%0! '+$.! +#-$7#+$%$%! )'&'!<br />

1'>3'!)DD(D3:#+$!)6(6:6%)'!N:#-56.!'('.!(:')'!t!fP!@(0.#'>!#%>$:$!='.!3:'+!%!%!<br />

#.=$3$!03:')!!!)DD%D3:#=.#)$(B!<br />

$<br />

?&&AAO.$<br />

;('.!(!5!3'(! D%$-#(+$.#bU>#3! +#=.U(! $G$(3$$! ?#(?#-#+$%)#! G$3$:+#3! '('.!(:'3'(!!<br />

)#+.#=3#7#%4!;"CL!?'3!:'3'(!%'!U%#:!-#(#(#=!U%)#(3$=!#)#%!-#!:#-56.!?'3!:'%!%!<br />

7D(D.D3:#+$%$!:D:=D%!=!3'%!!2LXJ!;BB'G3#! #%#(A7! 0%! %$.(0A#%! #M5(#.$0%4! 3$..#(! 50:@0+$.$0%! '%)! G300)!<br />

@'(':#.#(+!01!G(0$3#(+B!O%.B!wB!;A($5B!2$03B4!VdY!g[Vpg[^!<br />

n':(06)4! nB*B4! T&$-'>')4! 9B! '%)! l'A&'($4! 9B! d[[fBL11#5.+! 01! *0(.$17$%A! i0Q! j(6)#! @(0.#$%! c$#.! Q$.&!<br />

j(7+.'33$%#! ;:$%0! ;5$)+! 0%! J#(10(:'%5#4! 2300)! ;::0%$'! i#-#3! '%)! LM5(#.'! j&'('5.#($+.$5+! 01! 2(0$3#(!<br />

j&$5=#%+B!J063.B!T5$B!fZYdd^[bdd^f!<br />

n'.$0%'3!"#+#'(5&!j06%5$3B!VWWgB!n6.($#%.!(#S6$(#:#%.+!01!@063.(7B!W.&!(#-B!#)B!n'.$0%'3!;5')#:7!J(#++4!<br />

a'+&$%A.0%4!cjB!<br />

TQ#%%#%4! ÅB4! CBJBwB! w'%++#%+4! TB! 9$33#.4! CB! 8'%+'%.4! LB! c#567@#(#! '%)! wB! 267+#4! d[[^B! L11#5.+! 01!<br />

+6G+.$.6.$0%! G#.Q##%! 1'.! '%)! @(0.#$%! 0%! 1##)! $%.'=#! '%)! $.+! (#A63'.0(7! :#5&'%$+:+! $%! G(0$3#(! 5&$5=#%+Y!<br />

L%)05($%#!16%5.$0%$%A!'%)!$%.#(:#)$'(7!:#.'G03$+:B!J063.B!T5$B4!fgY!V[^VpV[^Z!<br />

TQ#%%#%4!ÅB4!CBJBwB!w'%++#%+4!;B!j033$%4!LBiB!2$&'%bc6-'34!HB!8#(G#=#4!LB!c#567@#(#!'%)!wB!267+#4!d[[eB!<br />

c$#.b$%)65#)! .&#(:0A#%#+$+! '%)! A3650+#! 0M$)'.$0%! $%! G(0$3#(! 5&$5=#%+Y! O%136#%5#! 01! A#%0.7@#! '%)! )$#.!<br />

50:@0+$.$0%B!J063.B!T5$B4!f^Y!Z]VpZgd!<br />

K'::$%A'4!TB4!T5&63>#4!\B4!-'%!2(65&#:4!wB4!\6$+:'%4!wB4!VWW^B!K&#!%6.($.$0%'3!+$A%$1$5'%5#!01!#%)0A#%06+!<br />

nb30++#+!'30%A!.&#!A'+.(0b$%.#+.$%'3!.('5.!01!1'(:!'%$:'3+B!;(5&B!;%$:B!n6.(B!gf4!WpddB!<br />

! C#Z


a'3)(06@4! JBaB4! ÅB! w$'%A4! '%)! jB;B! *($..+B! d[[^B! L11#5.+! 01! A375$%#! '%)! .&(#0%$%#! +6@@3#:#%.'.$0%! 0%!<br />

@#(10(:'%5#!01!G(0$3#(!5&$5=+!1#)!)$#.+!30Q!$%!5(6)#!@(0.#$%B!O%.B!wB!J063.B!T5$B!gYd^[bd^ZB!<br />

a#3.>$#%4! LB! d[[dB! n6.($.$0%! '%)! 9'%'A#:#%.! 01! .&#! 2(0$3#(! .0! 9##.! "#.'$3#(7:#!$%536+$0%!$%!'!:'$>#p<br />

+07G#'%!)$#.!0%!G(0$3#(!@#(10(:'%5#B!;%$:'3!*##)!T5$#%5#!'%)!K#5&%030A7B!V]gh!df]pdWg!<br />

l'%#33'4! OB4! T'=0:6('4! nBHB4! T$3-#(+$)#+4! *BCB4! *$S6#$()04! ;B4! J'5=4! 9B4! VWWWB! L11#5.! 01! #%>7:#!<br />

+6@@3#:#%.'.$0%!01!G(0$3#(!)$#.+!G'+#)!0%!50(%!'%)!+07G#'%+B!J063.B!T5$B!Zf4!^eVp^efB!<br />

!<br />

K'G30!VB!c#%#:#!)$>'7%!%'!AU(#!67A63'%'%!('+70%3'(!%!@(0.#$%4!':$%0!'+$.!-#!#%#(I$!<br />

)D>#73#($!<br />

C(6@!!<br />

n0!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

2(073#(!<br />

2'3'.:'!!<br />

2D7D.:#4! C#3$.$(:#! -#! 2$.$(:#! cU%#:3#($! "'+70%! J(0.#$%4!<br />

9#.rT$+.$%4!i$>$%!-#!9L!cD>#73#($!!<br />

L!!<br />

!<br />

! ! 2D7D.:#! C#3$.$(:#! 2$.$(:#! !<br />

V! KD:!!<br />

dVB^[h![BW^hVBdgh]V^[! d[B[[h![BfehVB[Wh]d^[! d[B[[h![BfehVB[Wh]d^[! b!<br />

d! C(6@3'('! dVB^[h![BW^hVBdgh]V^[! d[B[[h![BfehVB[Wh]d^[! VfBg[h![BfehVB[Wh]d^[! b!<br />

]! t! d]! \J! -#! d[Bg]h![BW^hVBdgh]V^[! VWB[[h![BfehVB[Wh]d^[! VWB[[h![BfehVB[Wh]d^[! b!<br />

g! ][d^!9L


K'G30! dB! 2(0$3#(! 7#:3#($%)#! @(0.#$%! -#! @(0.#$%r':$%0! '+$.! +#-$7#+$%)#=$! '>'3:'%!%!<br />

@(0.#'>!$3'-#+$%#!G'3!!03'('=!5'%3!!'!(3!=!A#3$$:$%#!#.=$+$!<br />

C(6@3'(! 2j;!<br />

j;! [bd^! j;! [bgV!<br />

d^BCD%! j;;y! gVBCD%! j;;!<br />

VPH0%.(03!!NdV4^[P! g[B[[! VV]eBf! V[WeBf! dVfeBg! dVgeBg!<br />

dPH0%.(03!!NdV4^[P! ]WBWf! VVggB^! VV[gB^! dVZeB^! dV]eB^!<br />

]Pbt^\J! ]WBf^! VVVgB]! V[ZgB^! dVVeB[! d[ZeBV!<br />

gPbt^\Jbt^;;! g[B[e! VVdVB^! V[fVBg! dV^VBf! dVVVBf!<br />

^Pbt^\JrL%>$:! ]WBe]! VVVeB^! V[ZeBW! dVZVBZ! dV]dB[!<br />

ePbt^\Jb<br />

]WBZV! VV]dB]! V[WdBe! dd[VBZ! dVedB[!<br />

t^;;rL%>$:!<br />

ZPbtf\J! ]WBW]! V[WZB^! V[^ZBe! d[f^BW! d[geB[!<br />

fPbtf\Jbtf;;! ]WBZZ! VVVZBZ! V[ZZBW! dVZZBZ! dV]fB[!<br />

WPbtf\JrL%>$:! ]WBed! VVVZB[! V[ZZBg! dV^^Bd! dVV^Be!<br />

V[Pbtf\Jb ]WBZ^! VVVZBd! V[ZZBg! dVg[BV! dV[[B]!<br />

tf;;rL%>$:!<br />

J! [4eg! [BV]! [BV]]! [BVe! [BVeg!<br />

L%>$:!L.=$+$!<br />

H0%.(03!Vrd! ]WBWW! VVg[BZ[! VV[[BZ! dVfVB[[! dVg[BW[!<br />

L%>$:!3'-#+$>! ]WBW[! VVVdBf[! V[ZdBf! dV]dBW[! d[W]B[[!<br />

L%>$:!3'-#3$! ]WBef! VVd[Bf[! V[fVBV! dVeWBe[! dV][B[[!<br />

J! [B][Z! [B[Vf! [B[VW! [B]W! [B]W!<br />

\J!T#-$7#+$%$%!L.=$+$!<br />

H0%.(03!Vrd! ]WBWW! VVg[BZ[! VV[[BZ! dVfVB[[! dVg[BW[!<br />

bt!^! ]WBfV! VVdVBd[! V[fVBg! dVe[B][! dVd[B^!<br />

bt!f! ]WBZZ! VVVdB][! V[ZdBe! dV]WBZ[! d[WWBW[!<br />

J! [B^^! [B[g! [B[g! [BVW! [BVW!<br />

J(0.#$%b;:$%0!;+$.!<br />

H0%.(03!V!-#!d! ]WBWW! VVg[BZ[! VV[[BZ! dVfVB[[! dVg[BW[!<br />

T')#5#!J(0.#$%! ]WBZe! VVVVB][! V[ZVBe! dV]dBd[! d[WdBg[!<br />

cDD=!<br />

J(0.#$%!-#!;:$%0! ]WBfd! VVddBd[! V[fdB]! dVZ[Bg[! dV][B^f!<br />

;BcDD=!<br />

J! [B][! [B[d! [B[d! [BVV! [BVV!<br />

L%>$:!!-#!J(0.#$%!T#-$7#+$%#!CU(#!<br />

H0%.(03!C(6@3'(!! ]WBWW! VVg[BZ[! VV[[BZ! dVfVB[! dVg[BW!<br />

bt!^!\J!L%>$:+$>! ]WBW^! VVVZBW[! V[ZfB[! dV]]BW! d[W]BW!<br />

bt!^!\J!L%>$:3$! ]WBeZ! VVdgBg[! V[fgBZ! dVfeBZ! dVgZB[!<br />

bt!f!\J!L%>$:+$>! ]WBf^! VV[ZBe[! V[eZBZ! dV]VBf! d[WdB[!<br />

bt!f!\J!L%>$:3$! ]WBef! VVVZBV[! V[ZZBg! dVgWBd! dV[WB^!<br />

J! [B]e! [BVd! [BVd! [BVV! [BVV!<br />

yYd^BAD%!5'%3!!'!(3!!!='%.'(!('@0(3'(!%'!)'7'%)!!%)'%!$+.'.$+.$=!03'('=!1'(=3!3!=3'(!%!<br />

)##(3#%)$($3:#+$!7'@!3:':!.!(B!2j;Yc#%#:#!G'!!'!(3!!4!j;Yj'%3!!;!(3!=4!<br />

j;;Yj'%3!!;!(3!=!H'>'%5!!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

! C!#


K'G30! ]B! 2(0$3#(! 7#:3#($%)#! @(0.#$%! -#! @(0.#$%r':$%0! '+$.! +#-$7#+$%)#=$! '>'3:'%!%!<br />

@(0.#'>! $3'-#+$%#! G'3!! 03'('=! 7#:! .D=#.$:$4! 7#:)#%! 7'('(3'%:'! -#! 7'':'! AD5D!<br />

D>#($%#!#.=$+$!<br />

C(6@3'(!<br />

XK!! *j"! XK! *j"!<br />

JL*!<br />

m3D:!<br />

[bd^!CD%! [bd^! [bgV! [bgV! gVBCD%!<br />

VPH0%.(03!!NdV4^[P! Ved^BZ'! VBgf]W! ]WegBW! VBf^[f! fBe[! de^B[[!<br />

dPH0%.(03!!NdV4^[P! V^WdBdG5! VBggdd! ]WWgB^! VBfZVZ! ZBVZ! de]BWV!<br />

]Pbt^\J! VeVdBf'G! VB^[Vd! ]fWdBW! VBfZee! eB^f! d^ZBgg!<br />

gPbt^\Jbt^;;! VeV]B['G! VBgWVe! ]Wf]B]! VBffe^! eBf]! d^WB]Z!<br />

^Pbt^\JrL%>$:! Ve[VBVG5! VBgffW! ]W]]B[! VBfgZf! gB^[! dZgBZ[!<br />

ePbt^\Jb<br />

VeVWBf'! VBgf]V! ]Wf^B^! VBfgg]! ^BW[! deWB^[!<br />

t^;;rL%>$:!<br />

ZPbtf\J! V^WVB[5! VB^[ed! ]f[ZBV! VBfedV! eBd^! d^eBe^!<br />

fPbtf\Jbtf;;! VeVWBZ'! VB^[ge! ]WWZB[! VBfeWd! eBW[! deVB[[!<br />

WPbtf\JrL%>$:! VeVgB]'! VB^[VV! ]WdVBW! VBf^]f! ^BgV! defB^^!<br />

V[Pbtf\Jb<br />

Ved[Bd'! VB^[gd! ]WefB[! VBfW[f! fB[[! dgfB^[!<br />

tf;;rL%>$:!<br />

J! [B[V! [BVff! [B[W! [B^[f! [B]ge! [Bg^W!<br />

L%>$:!L.=$+$!<br />

H0%.(03!Vrd! Ve[WB[[! VBge]V'! ]WfVB[! VBfeVd! ZBff! degBgV!<br />

L%>$:!3'-#+$>! Ve[WBV[! VB^[[WG! ]Wd[Bd! VBfZ]e! eBe]! d^fBeg!<br />

L%>$:!3'-#3$! VeV]BW[! VBgWVWG! ]W^VBg! VBf^e]! ^BZe! deeB[^!<br />

J! [Bfe! [B[VZ! [BVe! [BWZ! [BV]! [BZf!<br />

\J!T#-$7#+$%$%!L.=$+$!<br />

H0%.(03!Vrd! Ve[WB[[! VBge]V! ]WfVB[! VBfeVd! ZBff! degBgV!<br />

bt!^! VeVVBZ[! VBgWVd! ]WgfBZ! VBfeB]f! ^BWe! de^Bde!<br />

bt!f! VeVVB][! VB^[g[! ]WdVBZ! VBfeZ[! eB^[! d^WBVg!<br />

J! [BWd! [B[d! [Bg[! [BWW! [BV]! [B^e!<br />

J(0.#$%!;:$%0!;+$.!<br />

H0%.(03!V!-#!d! Ve[WB[! VBge]V! ]WfVB[! VBfeVd! ZBff! degBgV!<br />

T')#5#!J(0.#$%!cDD=! Ve[gBf! VBgWW]! ]ffZBZ! VBfe[V! ^BeW! degB]^!<br />

J(0.#$%!-#!;:$%0! VeVfBd! VBgW^W! ]WfgBd! VBfZVV! eBf^! de[B[W!<br />

;BcDD=!<br />

J! [B[ee! [B[]Z! [B[V! [BZV! [B[e! [BZe!<br />

L%>$:!-#!J(0.#$%!T#-$7#+$%#!CU(#!<br />

H0%.(03!C(6@3'(!! Ve[WB[! VBge]V! ]WfVB[! VBfeVd! ZBff! degBgV!<br />

bt!^!\J!L%>$:+$>! VeVdBW! VBgWeg! ]W]fBV! VBffVe! eBZ[! d^fBg[!<br />

bt!^!\J!L%>$:3$! VeV[B^! VBgfe[! ]W^WB]! VBfgeV! ^BVg! dZdBVV!<br />

bt!f!\J!L%>$:+$>! Ve[^Bg! VB^[^g! ]W[dBd! VBfe^e! eB^g! d^fBff!<br />

bt!f!\J!L%>$:3$! VeVZBd! VB^[dZ! ]WgdBW! VBfefe! eBg^! d^WBg]!<br />

J! [BeW! [BV[! [Bee! [Bdg! [BVf! [B]]!<br />

'bGY!;7%!!+D.D%)'!1'(=3!!&'(13#($!.'!7'%!0(.'3':'3'(!'('+!%)'=$!1'(=3!3!=3'(!U%#:3$)$(!<br />

NJz[B[^P!XKYX#:!.D=#.$:$!4!*j"YX#:)#%!X'('(3'%:'Y!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

! C!!


!<br />

K'G30!gB!2(0$3#(!7#:3#($%)#!@(0.#$%!-#!@(0.#$%r':$%0!'+$.!+#-$7#+$%)#=$!!<br />

'>'3:'%!%!@(0.#'>!$3'-#+$%#!G'3!!03'('=!='%!:#.'G03$.3#($!D>#($%#!#.=$+$!<br />

C(6@3'(!<br />

H'%!K($A3$+#($)4! H'%!J(0.#$%4! H'%!`($=!;+$.4!<br />

:A_)i! :A_)i! 9A_)i!<br />

VPH0%.(03!!NdV4^[P! ^dBZ[! gBVW! eBgg!<br />

dPH0%.(03!!NdV4^[P! ^^BZ[! gBgd! eBVd!<br />

]Pbt^\J! egB[[! gBVg! ^BWg!<br />

gPbt^\Jbt^;;! eVB[[! ]BWg! gBZe!<br />

^Pbt^\JrL%>$:! ggB[[! gBdg! ZBVZ!<br />

ePbt^\Jb<br />

g^B^[! gB[W! ^Bf]!<br />

t^;;rL%>$:!<br />

ZPbtf\J! ^eB[[! ]Bf^! eBdZ!<br />

fPbtf\Jbtf;;! ^^B[[! ]BZ^! ^BZf!<br />

WPbtf\JrL%>$:! ^eB^[! gBg[! ZB[^!<br />

V[Pbtf\Jb<br />

^fB[[! gB^e! eBV^!<br />

tf;;rL%>$:!<br />

J! [Bd^e! [Bg[V! [Bgd!<br />

TL9! gBVe! [Bd^! [BZd!<br />

L%>$:!L.=$+$!<br />

H0%.(03!Vrd! ^gBd[! gB]V'! eBdZ!<br />

L%>$:!3'-#+$>! ^fBf]! ]BWdG! ^BeZ!<br />

L%>$:!3'-#3$! ^dBe^! gB]V'! eB^f!<br />

J! [B]e! [B[d! [BVf!<br />

\J!T#-$7#+$%$%!L.=$+$!<br />

H0%.(03!Vrd! ^gBd[! gB]V! eBdZ!<br />

bt!^! ^]B^[! gBV[! ^BW^!<br />

bt!f! ^ZBW]! gBV]! eB]V!<br />

J! [B]e! [B^e! [Bef!<br />

J(0.#$%!;:$%0!;+$.!<br />

H0%.(03!V!-#!d! ^gBd[! gB]V! eBdZ!<br />

T')#5#!J(0.#$%!cDD=! ^eBge! gBV^! eBe]!<br />

J(0.#$%!-#!;:$%0!<br />

^^BVZ! gB[Z! ^Bed!<br />

;BcDD=!<br />

J! [BZZ! [B]e! [BVV!<br />

L%>$:!J(0.#$%!T#-$7#+$%#!CU(#!<br />

H0%.(03!C(6@3'(!! ^gBd[! gB]V'! eBdZ!<br />

bt!^!\J!L%>$:+$>! e[Bgg! gB[]'G! ^B]^!<br />

bt!^!\J!L%>$:3$! geB^e! gBVe'G! eB^e!<br />

bt!f!\J!L%>$:+$>! ^ZB^[! ]Bf[G! eB[V!<br />

bt!f!\J!L%>$:3$! ^fBgd! gBgZ'! eBe[!<br />

J! [B[f! [B[^^! [BdZ!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

! C!C


K'G30! ^B! 2(0$3#(! 7#:3#($%)#! @(0.#$%! -#! @(0.#$%r':$%0! '+$.! +#-$7#+$%)#=$!<br />

'>'3:'%!%!@(0.#'>!$3'-#+$%#!G'3!!03'('=!='(='+!@'(':#.(#3#($!D>#($%#!#.=$+$!<br />

C(6@3'(!<br />

H'(='+!<br />

"'%)!:'%!4!<br />

t!<br />

;G)B!<br />

X'V4!<br />

t!<br />

;G)B!<br />

X'd4!<br />

t!<br />

26.V4!<br />

t!!!<br />

26.d4!<br />

t!<br />

CUD+V4!<br />

t!<br />

CUD+d4!<br />

t!<br />

VP!H0%.(03!!<br />

eWBWV! VBVd! VBe[! dfBZd! gVB[W! d^BdZ! ]eBVg!<br />

NdV4^[P!<br />

dP!H0%.(03!!<br />

eWBe[! [BWW! VBg]! dfBfe! gVB^V! deBgV! ]ZBWd!<br />

NdV4^[P!<br />

]P!t^\J! eWB]V! VBVg! VBe^! dfBVf! g[Bee! dgBWd! ]^BW^!<br />

gP!t^\Jbt^;;! efBdg! VBd^! VBfg! dfB^[! gVBZ^! d]Bdg! ]gB[Z!<br />

^Pt^\JrL%>$:! efBWg! VB[^! VB^d! dfB][! gVB[Z! dgBef! ]^BZf!<br />

eP!t^\Jb<br />

Z[BVd! VBde! VBf[! dfBZ^! gVB[V! d^Bg]! ]eBde!<br />

t^;;rL%>$:!<br />

ZP!tf\J! eWBd]! VB[Z! VB^g! dfBZ^! gVB^]! dgB[V! ]gBeZ!<br />

fP!tf\Jbtf;;! efBWd! VBd]! VBZW! dfBZd! gVBee! dgBeg! ]^BZ^!<br />

WP!tf\JrL%>$:! efBef! VBdf! VBfZ! dfBVV! g[BW^! dgBgf! ]^Be]!<br />

V[P!tf\Jb<br />

efBVZ! VB[d! VB^V! dfBdd! gVBgV! dgBdV! ]^B^[!<br />

tf;;rL%>$:!<br />

J! [BdV! [B]g! [B]W! [BfZ! [Bfe! [B[^V! [BVd!<br />

L%>$:!L.=$+$!<br />

H0%.(03!Vrd! eWBZe! VB^d! VB[Z! dfBZW! gVBdW! d^BfV'! ]eBWW'!<br />

L%>$:!3'-#+$>! efBWV! VBZV! VBVf! dfB^]! gVB]W! dgBd[G! ]^BVVG!<br />

L%>$:!3'-#3$! efBW^! VBeZ! VBVe! dfB]g! gVBVV! dgBeWG! ]^BZW'G!<br />

J! [BVf! [B]V! [Bgd! [Bg[! [BZ[! [B[V]! [B[df!<br />

\J!T#-$7#+$%$%!<br />

L.=$+$!<br />

H0%.(03!Vrd! eWBZe! VB^d! VB[Z! dfBZW! gVBdW! d^BfV'! ]eBWW'!<br />

bt!^! eWBVd! VBZV! VBVf! dfBgd! gVBV]! dgB^]G! ]^BgZG!<br />

bt!f! efBZg! VBef! VBVe! dfBg^! gVB]f! dgB]^G! ]^Bg[G!<br />

J! [BV[! [B]d! [Bgd! [B^V! [BZg! [B[dd! [B[^Z!<br />

J(0.#$%!;:$%0!<br />

! ! ! ! ! ! !<br />

;+$.!<br />

H0%.(03!V!-#!d! eWBZe! VB^d! VB[Z! dfBZW! gVBdW! d^BfV'! ]eBWW'!<br />

T')#5#!J(0.#$%! eWB[g! VBe^! VBVg! dfB]d! gVB[]! dgB^gG! ]^B^]G!<br />

cDD=!<br />

J(0.#$%!-#!;:$%0!<br />

;BcDD=!<br />

efBfd! VBZ]! VBVW! dfB^g! gVBgZ! dgB]]G! ]^BgZG!<br />

J! [BVg! [Bdg! [B]^! [B]f! [Bgg! [B[d! [B[^g!<br />

L%>$:!-#!J(0.#$%!T#-$7#+$%#!CU(#!<br />

H0%.(03!C(6@3'(!! eWBZe! VB^d! VB[Z! dfBZW! gVBdW! d^BfV'! ]eBWW!<br />

bt!^!\J!L%>$:+$>! efBZZ! VBZg! VBd[! dfB]g! gVBd[! dgB[fG! ]^B[[!<br />

bt!^!\J!L%>$:3$! eWB^]! VBee! VBVe! dfB^d! gVB[g! d^B[e'G! ]eB[]!<br />

bt!f!\J!L%>$:+$>! eWB[Z! VBeZ! VBVe! dfBZg! gVBe[! dgB]gG! ]^Bdg!<br />

bt!f!\J!L%>$:3$! efBgd! VBeW! VBVe! dfBVZ! gVBVf! dgB]^G! ]^B^Z!<br />

J! [B[f! [Be]! [BZe! [Bge! [Bf]! [B[]g! [BV[!<br />

CUD+!L.$!R('%!!VY!j'%3!!'!(3!!%!t


" #CN $D.F5-&.$k+'5F,-+.!,/+$a+.A-!$,F.6+,(A$c(,&.+-$2O9&5-&.(,(,$<br />

V&.KF.)+,'$@&$c(,&.+-$:1!-!)!$b9&.(,&$B1A(-&.(,(,$%+.!-+1!.!-)+'! +$<br />

6.7,'$%+.&).L)B%LL"$"&#)6.&-"&#$'#%.&+).L)*&.$2'&%-);$'-")A%&"$'0+)%&)<br />

E$.%0"$)B%"#+).&)T%C")@"$L.$7'&-")'&8)A%&"$'0)Kf-$"#%.&)<br />

!<br />

lB!a'%A G 4!TB!j#(('.#4!*B ! X'% G 4!JB!T'5'=3$ 5 4!JBaB!a'3)(06@ G!<br />

' a'%A4!lB4!j#(('.#4!TB4!X'%4!*B4!T'5'=3$!4!JB4!a'3)(06@4!JBaB!Nd[[fPB!j0:@'($+0%!01!c$11#(#%.!<br />

j0%5#%.('.$0%+!01!O%0(A'%$5!K('5#!9$%#('3+!$%!2(0$3#(!c$#.+!0%!i$-#!J#(10(:'%5#!'%)!9$%#('3!LM5(#.$0%B!<br />

O%.#(%'.$0%'3!w06(%'3!01!J063.(7!T5$#%5#!Z!NZPY!ed^bedWF!$+$:3$!7'7!%)'%!U>#.3#%:$.$(B!<br />

G c#@'(.:#%.!01!J063.(7!T5$#%5#4!,%$-#(+$.7!01!;(='%+'+4!*'7#..#-$33#!;"!ZdZ[V4!,T;!<br />

5 K`2K;H!G6(+6!$3#!:$+'1$(!'('.!(:'5!4!;%='('!`%$-#(+$.#+$!8#.#($%#(!*'=D3.#+$!\'7-'%!2#+3#:#!-#!<br />

2#+3#%:#!\'+.'3!=3'(!!;%'G$3$:!c'3!B!<br />

$<br />

89&1$<br />

26! '('.!(:'! 7D=+#=! +!5'=3!=! =0633'(!! '3.!%)'! 7#.$.$($3#%! #.3$=! @$3$?3#()#! 1'(=3!!<br />

:$%#('3! =0%+'%.('+70%3'(!%!%! #.=$3#($%$! $%5#3#:#=! D>#(#! 7D(D.D3:D.D(B! ;('.!(:'!<br />

%0(:'3! $>! #3#:#%.! @(#:$=+3#($%$%! NK9JP! t! [4! d[4! g[4! e[4! f[! -#! V[['3.:!.!(B! 9$%#('3! @(#:$=+$%$%! 7#:)#=$! 706%366!<br />

)DD(D3)DD%)#!G(0$3#(!)!=!+!%)'!*#4!j64!9%4!-#!l%!:$=.'(!!'>'3:!.!(B!<br />

$<br />

:;'1.+#73#()#!='.!3:'=.')!(!NO%'3!-#!'(=B4!d[[VPB!n"j!.'-+$7#3#($%$!#+'+!'3'%!-#($3#(!<br />

03)6=?'!'>!+'7!)'!036@4!GD7D=!1'(=3!3!=3'(!AU+.#(:#=.#)$(B!m(%#$%!G(073#(!5$-5$-3#(!<br />

$?$%! 9%! $&.$7'5!%!%4! Vg! NT06.&#(%! -#! 2'=#(4! VWf]'P! ^[! :A_=A! NC'336@! -#! n0(($+4!<br />

VW]WPh!l%4!Vg!NT06.&#(%!-#!2'=#(4!VWf]GP!^d!:A_=A!Ni#'+#!-#!'(=B4!VWe[P!-#!*#4!g[!<br />

! C!J


NT06.&#(%! -#! 2'=#(4! VWfdP! f[! :A_=A! N95n'6A&.0%! -#! c'74! VWZWP! '('+!%)'! 03)66!<br />

G$3)$($3:#=.#)$(B! k#-(#! =$(3$3$$! =0%6+6%)'! #%)$#3#($%! '(.:'+!! %#)#%$73#4! ='%'.3!!<br />

ADG(#+$%)#! G#+$%! :'))#! )D>#73#($%$%! '>'3.!3:'+!%'! 7U%#3$=! ?'3!:'3'(! A$)#(#=! $3A$!<br />

?#=:#=.#)$(B! C#%#3)#! G#+$%! :'))#! '.!3!:!! +@#+$1$=! G#+$%! :'))#3#($%$%! '!(!!<br />

.D=#.$3:#+$%)#%! ='?!%!3'('=! -#7'! G#+$%! :'))#3#($%$%! -D56..'! )'&'! $7$!<br />

)##(3#%)$($3:#+$%#!7U%#3$=!)#$$=3$=3#(!7'@!3'('=!'>'3.!3'G$3:#=.#)$(!N*#(=#.!-#!'(=B4!<br />

d[[dPB!J#=!?0=!?'3!:'!G(073#(3#($%!GD7D:#!@#($70.3'(!%!%!G$(!GU3D:D%)#!Na'3)(06@!<br />

-#! '(=B4! VWefh!T=$%%#(! -#! '(=B4! VWWdP!-#7'! .':':!%)'!NT&#3.0%!-#!T06.&#(%4!d[[eP!<br />

.$5'($)#! =633'%!3'%)'%! )'&'! )DD=! )D>#73#()#! :$%#('33#(3#! 7#.#(3$! G$(! #=$3)#!<br />

GD7D7#G$3#5#=3#($%$! AU+.#(:$.$(B! 2(073#(! 5$-5$-3#($%! $>! :$%#('3! $&.$7'?3'(!%!%!<br />

G#3$(3#%:#+$!&#:!?#-(#!=$(3$3$$%$%!U%3#%:#+$!&#:!)#!7#:!:'3$7#.3#($%$%!'>'3.!3:'+!!<br />

'?!+!%)'%! U%#:! .'!:'=.')!(B! 26! %#)#%3#! G6! ?'3!:')'! .$5'($! =0633'()'! G(073#(!<br />

D(#.$:$%)#! GD7D:#! @#($70)6! G076%5'! )#$$=! $%0(A'%$=! $>! :$%#('3!<br />

=0%+'%.('+70%3'(!%!!='(!3'.!(:'=!':'?3'%:!.!(B!<br />

:,+*1+.$'G9!:$%#('34!)!=!4!?#-(#!<br />

$<br />

c+1&.5+-$@&$c&1F1$<br />

26! ?'3!:')'! .':':!73'! $%0(A'%$=! $>! :$%#('3! ='(:'+!! NK'G30! VP! -#! #%! 7D=+#=!<br />

G$707'('(3'%!3'G$3$(3$$!+'3':'=!':'5!73'!$70.!)!!%)'=$!:$%#('33#($%!+D31'.!10(:3'(!!<br />

=633'%!3:!.!(B! K#:#3! ('+70%6%! $>! :$%#('3! )D>#73#($! G6AD%! G(073#(! +#=.U(D%)#!<br />

=633'%!3'%3'('!N;33'()4!d[[^P!G#%>#(!-#!)#:$(!)!!%)'=$!:$%#('3!)D>#73#($!n"j!NVWWgP!<br />

.'-+$7#3#($%$%! D>#($%)#! 03'5'=! #=$3)#! 10(:D3#! #)$3:$.$(B! T#3#%76:! '7(!5'! $3'-#!<br />

#)$3:$4! +0)76:! -#! =30(! ='7%'!! 03'('=! .6>! =633'%!3:!.!(B! "'+70%3'(! .$5'($)#!<br />

=633'%!3'%!G#+$%!:'))#!)D>#73#($%#!G#%>#(!#=$3)#!10(:D3#!#)$3:$.$(B!\#(!7'!)U%#:$!<br />

N[bVg4! Vgb]^! -#! ]^bgd! AD%3#(P! $?$%! .#=! G$(! 7#:! &'>!(3'%:!! -#! )#%#:#! 7#:3#($%$!<br />

='(!.!(:'=!$?$%!A(6@3'('!GU3D%:D.D(B!;3.!!A(6@!)#%#:#!('+70%6!t!V[[4!f[4!e[4!g[4!<br />

d[! -#! [! )D>#73#($%)#! $>! :$%#('3! ='(:'+!! $3'-#! #)$3:#=! +6(#.$73#! 036.6(63:6.6(B!<br />

K#:#3!('+70%6%!G$3#$:$!-#!G#+$%!:'))#!)D>#73#($!K'G30!d


G'=!:!! *;TT:'%! G$(! 3'G0('.6'()'! $>! :$%#('3! '%'3$>$! 7'@!3'%'! =')'(!<br />

+'=3'%:!.!(B! ! 8#($3#(! T;Tb! C#%#('3! i$%##(! 90)#3! @(0+#)D(D! NT;T! $%+.$.6.#4! VWWVP!<br />

=633'%!3'('=! .#=! 7U%3D!;nR8;! .#+.$%#! .'G$! .6.63:64! 0(.'3':'3'(! '('+!%)'=$!U%#:3$!<br />

1'(=3'(!c6%5'%!K#+.$!$3#!G#3$(3#%:$.$(B!m%#:3$3$=!)D>#73#($!Jz!B[^!='G63!#)$3:$.$(B!<br />

!<br />

K'G30!dB!K#:#3!('+70%6%!G$3#$:$!NA_=AP!-#!&#+'@3'%:!!G#+$%!:'))#!$?#($$!!<br />

X#:!9'))#3#($! [bVgAD%! Vgb]^AD%! ]^bgdAD%!<br />

T'(!!:!+!(! ^ZdBZV! ed^BWZ! eW[BWZ!<br />

H'%'.3!!7'!! ][Bg]! dfBWf! dZB]Z!<br />

T07'!=D+@#+$! ]geBd]! ][[B]d! d]fBZd!<br />

H$(#?.'!! V]BW^! VVBZ]! VVBed!<br />

c$='3+$76:!10+1'.! VZBge! V^B^W! VgBZW!<br />

T0)76:!=30(D(! ^Bee! ^BeW! ^BZd!<br />

ibK(#0%$%! [BW^! [B]V! [Bge!<br />

ibi$>$%!\j3! dBVW! VB]g! VBdV!<br />

j0G'%be[! [BZ^! [BZ^! [B[[!<br />

29cb^[! [B^[! [B^[! [B^[!<br />

;3$:#.! ]BVZ! dBfd! dBeg!<br />

2(073#(!@(#:$=+ V ! ^B[[! ^B[[! ^B[[!<br />

c#$=#% d ! VB[[! VB[[! VB[[!<br />

KRJi;9! V[[[B[[! V[[[B[[! V[[[B[[!<br />

9L4!=5'3_=A! ][f[B[[! ]V]^B[[! ]VW[B[[!<br />

\':!@(0.#$%t! ddBg[! d[Bgd! VZBff!<br />

H'3+$76:t! [BWf! [Bfe! [Bfd!<br />

X'('(3'%!3'G$3$(!Jt! [Bg^! [Bg[! [B]f!<br />

9#.$70%$%t! [Be[! [B^^! [B^V!<br />

i$>$%t! VB]f! VBVW! VB[V!<br />

K(#0%$%t! [BWg! [BfV! [BZd!<br />

V \#(!=A!7#:)#Y!-$.':$%!;!N-$.':$%!;!'5#.'.#P!ZZVg!O,h!5&03#5'35$1#(03!dd[g!O,h!-$.':$%!L!N1(0:!)3b<br />

'3@&'b! .050@&#(73! '5#.'.#P! VeB^]! O,h! -$.':$%! 2 Vd ! [B[V]! :Ah! ($G013'-$%! eBe! :Ah! %$'5$%! ]W! :Ah!<br />

@'%.0.&#%$5!'5$)!V[! :Ah! :#%')$0%#!N1(0:! :#%')$0%#!)$:#.&73@7($:$)$%03P!VB^! :Ah!103$5!'5$)![BW!<br />

:Ah! 5&03$%#! V[g[! :Ah! .&$':$%! N1(0:! .&$':$%! :0%0%$.('.#P! VB^g! :Ah! @7($)0M$%#! N1(0:! @7($)0M$%#!<br />

\j3P!dBZe!:Ah!)bG$0.$%![B[ee!:Ah!#.&0VM7S6$%!Vd^!:Ah!T#![BV!:AB!<br />

d! >!:$%#('3!='(:'+!!-#7'!7!='%:!!)#%$>!=6:6!)D>#7$B!<br />

!<br />

?+.1!)+$@&$"F,7_$<br />

c#%#:#!+0%6%)'!5'%3!!'!(3!=4!7#:!.D=#.$:$!-#!7#:)#%!7'('(3'%:'!G'=!:!%)'%!.D:!<br />

7'! )U%#:3#($%)#! %0(:'3! )D>#73#()#! :$%#('3! $3'-#+$! $3#! G#+3#%#%! &'7-'%3'(3'! )$#(!<br />

)#%#:#!A(6G6%)'=$!&'7-'%3'(!'('+!%)'!1'(=3!3!=!AU>3#%:#:$.$(B!NK'G30!]PB!>!:$%#('3!<br />

)D>#73#($! '>'3)!=?'! .$G$'! =D3D%)#! &'1$1! G$(! '>'3:'! 03:6! '%5'=! G6! $+.'.$+.$=! 03'('=!<br />

U%#:3$!G636%:':!.!(B!!<br />

! C!T


H'1#+3#()#!G#+3#%#%!#(=#=!G(073#(3#()#%!]^bgdB!AD%3#()#!.0@3'%'%!ADG(#3#()#!:$%#('3!<br />

=0%+'%.('+70%6!!K'G30!g


$<br />

K'G30! gB! H'1#+3#()#! G#+3#%#%! #(=#=! G(073#(3#()#%! ]^bgdB! AD%3#()#! .0@3'%'%!<br />

ADG(#3#()#!:$%#('3!)D>#73#($!!N:A_=A!H9P!!<br />

t!! t!! ! t!! ! t!! ! t!!<br />

%0(:'3 V !!!!!!!!*#! %0(:'39%! %0(:'3l%! %0(:'3j6! %0(:'3<br />

V[[!!!!!!!!!!!!!^^d ' ! V[[! g^g ' ! V[[! g^f ' ! V[[! ^VBZ] ' ! V[[!<br />

f[!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!^Z[ ' ! V[]Bd! gVg G ! WVBV! g]g G ! WgBZ! ^]BdV ' ! V[dBf!<br />

e[!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!gWg G ! fWB^! ]de 5 ! ZVBf! ]gV 5 ! ZgBg! g]Be[ G ! fgBd!<br />

g[!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!]Wg 5 ! ZVB]! dVd ) ! geBe! dg[ ) ! ^dBg! ]dBed 5 ! e]B[!<br />

d[!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!]WV 5 ! Z[Bf! VZd # ! ]ZBf! d[[ # ! g]BZ! dWBfd 5 ! ^ZBe!<br />

[!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!]ZZ 5 ! efB]! Vgd 1 ! ]VBd! VZd 1 ! ]ZB^! d]BZV ) ! g^Bf!<br />

TL9!!!!!!!!!!!edB]W! ! ]^BZV! ! ][Bgf! ! WB[e! !<br />

J!)##($!!!!z[B[[[V! z[B[[[V! z[B[[[V! z[B[[[V!<br />

V n0(:'3!)D>#73#()#!('+70%6%!&#(!=A! :$%#('3!<br />

$&.$7'?3'(!%!%!)0(6!G$(!#=$3)#!G#3$(3#%:#+$%$%!A#(#=3$3$$!0(.'7'!?!=:'=.')!(B!T0%6?!<br />

03'('=4!G6!?'3!:'!G(073#(!('+70%3'(!%)'!$>!:$%#('3!)D>#73#($%$%!@#(10(:'%+!D>#($%#!<br />

&#(&'%A$! G$(! 036:+6>! #.=$+$! 03:'=+!>!%! .$5'($)#! =633'%!3'%! )D>#73#(#! AU(#! U%#:3$!<br />

)#(#5#)#! '>'3.!3'G$3#5#$%$! AU+.#(:$.$(B! TU>! =0%6+6! )DD=! )D>#73#($%! $%0(A'%$=! -#!<br />

0(A'%$=! 10(:3'(!%!! ='(!3'.!('%! ?'3!:'3'(!%! 7'@!3:'+!! A#(#=:#=.#)$(B! ;7(!5'! >!<br />

:$%#('3!$3'-#+$%)#=$!G$(!'>'3:'%!%!$>!:$%#('3!'.!3!:!%!!'>'3.'5'!%!!AU+.#(:$.$(B!!!<br />

%+5,+A-+.$<br />

;33'()4!wB4!d[[^B!T.'.6+!01!G(0$3#(!%6.($.$0%!$%!.&#!,%$.#)!T.'.#+B!J'A#+Y!fgbff!$%Y!J(05B!;(=B!n6.(B!j0%1B4!<br />

"0A#(+4!;B"B!<br />

2'.'34!;B2B4!KB9B!J'((!'%)!cB\B!2'=#(4!d[[VB!l$%5!G$0'-'$3'G$3$.7!$.!.#.('G'+$5!>$%5!5&30($)#!'%)!.&#!)$#.'(7!<br />

>$%5!(#S6$(#:#%.!01!706%A!5&$5=+!1#)!'!+07!50%5#%.('.#!)$#.B!J063.B!T5$B!f[Y!fZbW[B!!<br />

26((#334!;BiB4!aB;B!c0>$#(!OOO4!;BwB!c'-$+4!9B9B!j0:@.0%4!9BLB!*(##:'%4!JB*B!8#%)(#33!'%)!KBiB!a'()4!<br />

d[[gB! "#+@0%+#+! 01! G(0$3#(+! .0! )$#.'(7! >$%5! 50%5#%.('.$0%+! '%)! +06(5#+! $%! (#3'.$0%! .0! #%-$(0%:#%.!<br />

$:@3$5'.$0%+B!2(B!J063.B!T5$B4!g^!Yd^^bde]B!<br />

*;TT4!VWWWB!C6$)#!10(!.&#!j'(#!'%)!,+#!01!;A($563.6('3!;%$:'3+!$%!;A($563.6('3!"#+#'(5&!'%)!K#'5&$%AB!<br />

V+.!(#-B!#)4!*#)#('.$0%!01!;%$:'3!T5$#%5#!T05$#.$#+4!T'-07!OiB!<br />

*#(=#.4!JB"B4!LB!-'%!\#6A.#%4!KB;BKBCB!-'%!H#:@#%!'%)!"B!;%A#34!d[[dB!n6.($.$0%'3!+.('.#A$#+!.0!(#)65#!<br />

#%-$(0%:#%.'3!#:$++$0%+!1(0:!%0%(6:$%'%.+B!wB!;%$:B!T5$B4!f[Y!LVefbLVfdB!!<br />

C'336@4!aBcB!'%)!iBjB!n0(($+4!VW]WB!K&#!':06%.!01!:'%A'%#+#!(#S6$(#)!.0!@(#-#%.!@#(0+$+!$%!.&#!5&$5=B!<br />

J063.B!T5$B4!VfY!ZebfdB!<br />

!O%'34! *B4! 2B! j0+=6%B4! nB! C63+#%! '%)! 8B! H6(.0A364! d[[VB! K&#! #11#5.+! 01! Q$.&)('Q'3! 01! -$.':$%! '%)! .('5#!<br />

:$%#('3!+6@@3#:#%.+!1(0:!3'7#(!)$#.+!0%!#AA!7$#3)!'%)!.('5#!:$%#('3!50:@0+$.$0%B!2(B!J063.B!T5$B4!gdY!ZZbf[B!<br />

i#'+#4!wBCB4!2BcB!2'(%#..4!LBwB!i#'+#!'%)!cBLB!K6(=4!VWe[B!K&#!G$030A$5'3!6%'-'$3'G$3$.7!.0!.&#!5&$5=!01!>$%5!<br />

$%!'!+#+':#!:#'3!('.$0%B!wB!n6.(B4!ZdY!eebZ[B!!<br />

9'$0(='4!;B4!;BjB!i'6(#%.$>4!LB!T'%.$%4!iB*B!;('6I0!'%)!9B!9'5'($4!d[[dB!c$#.'(7!-$.':$%!0(!:$%#('3!:$M!<br />

(#:0-'3! )6($%A! .&#! 1$%$+&#(! @#($0)! 0%! G(0$3#(! 5&$5=#%! @#(10(:'%5#B! wB! ;@@3B! J063.B! "#+B4! VVY! VdVbVdeB!<br />

95n'6A&.0%4! wBiB! '%)! LBwB! c'74! VWZWB! L11#5.! 01! )$#.'(7! *#! .0! j6! ('.$0+! 0%! &#:'.030A$5'3! '%)! A(0Q.&!<br />

(#+@0%+#+!01!G(0$3#(!5&$5=#%+B!wB!n6.(B4!V[WY!^^W^egB!<br />

n'.$0%'3!"#+#'(5&!j06%5$34!VWWgB!n6.($#%.!"#S6$(#:#%.+!01!J063.(7B!W .& !(#-B!#)B!n'.$0%'3!;5')#:7!J(#++4!<br />

a'+&$%A.0%!cB!jB!<br />

n$3$@06(4!;B\B4!"B!*'G(#A'!'%)!CBcB!26.5&#(4!VWWgB!c#.#(:$%#!.&#!#11#5.!01!Q$.&)('Q$%A!-'($06+!3#-#3+!01!<br />

-$.':$%!'%)!:$%#('3+!1(0:!.&#!G(0$3#(!:'3#!1$%$+&#(!)$#.+B!J063.B!T5$B4!Z]Y!V^]B!<br />

T;T!O%+.$.6.#4!VWWVB!T;Tê!,+#(É+!C6$)#4!T.'.$+.$5+B!8#(+$0%!eB[]!L)$.$0%B!T;T!O%+.$.6.#4!O%5B4!j'(74!njB!<br />

T&#3.0%4!wBiB!'%)!iBiB!T06.&#(%4!d[[eB!L11#5.+!01!@&7.'+#!'))$.$0%!Q$.&!0(!Q$.&06.!'!.('5#!:$%#('3!@(#:$M!<br />

0%!A(0Q.&!@#(10(:'%5#4!G0%#!(#+@0%+#!-'($'G3#+!'%)!.$++6#!:$%#('3!50%5#%.('.$0%+!$%!50::#(5$'3!G(0$3#(+B!<br />

wB!;@@3B!J063.B!"#+B4!V^Y!WgbV[dB!<br />

! C!Z


T=$%%#(4!wBKB4!;BiB!a'3)(06@!'%)!JBaB!a'3)(06@4!VWWdB!L11#5.+!01!(#:0-'3!01!-$.':$%!'%)!.('5#!:$%#('3!<br />

+6@@3#:#%.+! 1(0:! A(0Q#(! '%)! 1$%$+&#(! )$#.+! 0%! 3$-#!@#(10(:'%5#! '%)! 5'(5'++! 50:@0+$.$0%! 01! G(0$3#(+B! wB!<br />

;@@3B!J063.B!"#+B4!VY!df[bdfeB!<br />

T06.&#(%4!iBiB!'%)!cB\B!2'=#(4!VWfdB!O(0%!+.'.6+!01!.&#!5&$5=!'+!'11#5.#)!G7!L$:#($'!'5#(-63$%'!$%1#5.$0%!<br />

'%)!G7!-'($'G3#!$(0%!$%A#+.$0%B!wB!n6.(B4!VVdY!d]^]B!<br />

T06.&#(%4!iBiB!'%)!cB\B!2'=#(4!VWf]'B!L$:#($'!'5#(-63$%'!$%1#5.$0%!$%!5&$5=+!1#)!)#1$5$#%.!0(!#M5#++!3#-#3+!<br />

01!:'%A'%#+#B!wB!n6.(B4!VV]Y!VZdB!<br />

T06.&#(%4!iBiB!'%)!cB!\B!2'=#(4!VWf]GB!l$%5!.0M$5$.74!>$%5!)#1$5$#%57!'%)!>$%5b50@@#(!$%.#((#3'.$0%+&$@!$%!<br />

L$:#($'!'5#(-63$%'b$%1#5.#)!5&$5=+B!wB!n6.(B!VV]Y!effB!<br />

a'3)(06@4!JBaB4!KBLB!20Q#%4!\BiB!90(($+0%4!TBwB!\633!'%)!8BLB!K033#..4!VWefB!K&#!$%136#%5#!01!LcK;!0%!<br />

@#(10(:'%5#!01!5&$5=+!1#)!50(%b+07G#'%!:#'3!)$#.+!Q$.&!'%)!Q$.&06.!.('5#!:$%#('3!+6@@3#:#%.'.$0%B!J063.B!<br />

T5$4B!gZY!W^ebWe[B!<br />

! C!]


" #CT $B1-(A$l(@#7$!3$+$%#!AU(#!$)#'3!;;!=0%+#@.$%)#!)$=='.#!'3!%:!.!(B!c#=+.(0>!#+'+3!!7#:3#(![b<br />

V]! AD%3D=! )U%#:)#! 5'%3!!'!(3!=4! 5'%3!!'!(3!=! '(.!!! -#! 7#:! .D=#.$:$%$%! '(.!(!(=#%4!<br />

7#:!)##(3#%)$(:#!+'7!+!%!!$+#!+')#5#!$3=!&'1.'!G076%5'!$7$3#.$(:$.$(!NJz[B[^PB!26!<br />

@#(10(:'%+!@'(':#.(#3#($%$!'7%!!>':'%)'!7D=+#=!;;!706%36=36!7#:3#(!$3=!V]!AD%!<br />

G076%5'!A#3$.$(:$.$(B!C#%#3!03'('=!@#(10(:'%+!=($.#(3#($!$?$%!='(G0%&$)('.!.$@$!-#!;;!<br />

706%366!'('+!%)'=$!$%.#('=+$70%!#.=$3#(!U%#:3$!G636%:':!.!(!NJs[B[^PB!c6#)0%6:!<br />

:0(1030I$=! A#3$$:$! ='(G0%&$)('.! .$@$! -#! ;;! 706%366%)'%! #.=$3#%:$.$(! NJz[B[^PB!<br />

%.#('=+$70%! #.=$7#! G'3!! 03'('=4! )6#)0%6:! :0(1030I$=! A#3$$:3#($! )#=+.(0>! #+'+3!!<br />

7#:3#()#! )DD=! ;;! 706%366%)'%! 036:+6>! 03'('=! #.=$3#%:$! 03:'+!%'! (':#%4!<br />

:!+!(!#+'+3!!7#:3#()#!#.=$3#%:#:$.$(B!<br />

:,+*1+.$%&-()&-&.3$ L.3$=!5$-5$-4!)#+=.(0>4!':$%0!'+$.!706%3664!+$%)$($:!+$+.#:$4!<br />

#(=#%!)U%#:!G#+3#:#!<br />

!<br />

:;'1.+


(.($<br />

CD%D:D>)#! +'3'%'%! !+3'&! @(0A(':3'(!! +0%656! ?0=! &!>3!! A#3$:#! AU+.#(#%! #.3$=!<br />

@$3$?3#(h! @(0.#$%! $3#! ':$%0! '+$.! :#.'G03$>:'+!! -#! 7D=+#=! :#.'G03$=! &!>!%! +0%656!<br />

A#%#.$=! @0.'%+$7#33#($%$! :'=+$:6:! )D>#7)#! A#(?#=3#.$(:#)#! )'&'! ?0=! #%#(I$7#!<br />

$&.$7'?! )67'(3'(B! L%#(I$%$%! GD7D=! 0('%!! ('+70%)'! 7'=3'!=! 03'('=! te[! 0('%!%)'! 7#(!<br />

'3'%! ='(G0%&$)('.?'! >#%A$%! .'&!33'()'%! +'3'%:'=.')!(B! L.3$=! 5$-5$-3#(! =636?=')'%!<br />

?!=!.'%! +0%('=$! $3=! &'1.'3!=! )U%#:)#! =636?='! ?!=!! '!(3!!%!%! 7'=3'!=! g! ='.!%'!<br />

63':'=.')!(3'(B!26!&!>3!!A#3$:#7#!(':#%!$3=!$=$!&'1.')'!+$%)$($:!+$+.#:$!#%>$:3#($!<br />

G'.'! 03:'=! D>#(#! +$%)$($:! +$+.#:$! A#3$$:$! ]B! &'1.'! +0%6%'! =')'(! '%5'=!<br />

.':':3'%:'=.')!(B! j$-5$-3#($%! #(=#%! 7'! )U%#:$%)#! 0(.'7'! ?!='G$3#5#=! A#3$$:!<br />

7#.#(+$>3$$4! 7#.$.$(:#! )U%#:$! +0%6%)'! G'.'! 5'%3!! '!(3!=! 03:'=! D>#(#! 5$))$!<br />

@#(10(:'%+! A#($3$$! 7'('.'G$3:#=.#)$(B! X#:! &':! :'))#3#($%$%! %$'+.'3'(!%)'! A('%D3!<br />

G076.3'(!4!':$30>b':$30@#=.$%!0('%!!-#!':$30@#=.$%!7'@!+!!1'(=3!3!=!AU+.#(#G$3:#=.#)$(!<br />

NL3$'++0%! C6):6%)++0%4! VWWePB! n$'+.'%!%! GD7D=! G$(! 0('%!! G'!(+'!%! $3=!<br />

=!+!:3'(!%)'! +$%)$($3:#=.#)$(B! X'=3'!=! 03'('=! .'&!3! )'%#3#($%)#=$! %$'+.'%!%! tW[#%A$%!03'%!7#:3#($%!.D=#.$:$%)#4!&'7-'%!%!='%!@3'+:'+!%)'!<br />

A3$=0>!0('%!!&#:#%!'(.:'=.'4!G6%'!='(!3!=!)$#(!G#+$%!:'))#3#($!&'3#%!+$%)$($3:#:$!<br />

03'G$3:#=.#! -#! G6! )6(6:! &'7-'%!%! )$#(! G#+$%! :'))#3#($! -#! U>#33$=3#! @(0.#$%3#($%!<br />

7'('(3'%!:!%)'!#.=$3$!03'G$3:#=.#)$(!Na#6()$%A!#.!'3B4!d[[]G!PB!<br />

$<br />

c+1&.5+-$@&$`G,1&)$$<br />

;('.!(:')'!@$7'+')'%!+'3'%'%!AD%3D=!7'.'!VWd!')#.!@#(10(:'%+!$?$%!#(=#=!"0++b<br />

][f!#.3$=!5$-5$-3#(!=633'%:!.!(B!2'3'.:'!7#:$%)#!=633'%!3'%!:!+!(!-#!+07'!=D+@#+$!<br />

$3#! )#+=.(0>! '('+!%)'! @'(.$=D3! G076.6! 7U%D%)#%! GD7D=! 1'(=! 03:':'+!! $?$%! :!+!(! -#!<br />

+07'! =D+@#+$! $%5#! UD.D3D@! -#! 7D=+#=! ='(!.!(:'! ='@'+$.#3$! @(#:$=+! :$=+#($%)#!<br />

NiU)$A#b9^"bd4^!HAP!='(!.!(!3'('=!.0>!10(:)'!&'>!(3'%:!!-#!&'7-'%3'('!-#($3:$.$(B!<br />

;('.!(:')'4!$3=!V]!AD%!G076%5'!5$-5$-3#(#!-#($3:#=!D>#(#!$=$!='(G0%&$)('.!='7%'!!<br />

N:!+!(! -#7'! )#=+.(0>! :0%0&$)('.P! $3#! )#%#:#)#! =633'%!3'%! #.3$=! 5$-5$-3#(! $?$%! N"0++!<br />

][fP! U%#($3#%! N;%0%7:06+B! d[[ZP! ':$%0! '+$.! )D>#7$%$%! N3$+$%P! tVd! '3.!%)'! -#!<br />

D>#($%)#! 03:'=! D>#(#! g! 1'(=3!! .$@)#! ('+70%! &'>!(3'%:!.!(NK'G30! VPB! c#%#:#! ':$%0!<br />

'+$.! 706%36=3'(!%!%! &#+'@3'%:'+!%)'! 3$+$%#! AU(#! $)#'3! ':$%0! '+$.! #+'+!! )$=='.#!<br />

'3!%:!.!(B! "'+70%3'(!%! &'>!(3'%:'+!%)'! 7#:! &':! :'))#3#($%)#! 7'@!3'%! -#7'!<br />

&#+'@3'%'%! '%'3$>! )##(3#($! =633'%!3:!.!(B! c#%#:#! A(6@3'(!%)'=$! 5$-5$-3#($%! 5'%3!!<br />

'!(3!=! -#! 7#:! .D=#.$:3#($! dB4! gB4! ZB4! V]B! AD%3#()#! .'(.!3'('=! +'@.'%:!.!(B! K0@3':!<br />

-#($3#%!7#:! :$=.'(!%)'%! '(.'%! 7#:! :$=.'(!!?!='(.!3'('=! 7#:! .D=#.$:$! G#3$(3#%:$.$(B!<br />

c#%#:#! +D(#+$%5#!U3D:3#(! AD%3D=! 03'('=!='7)#)$3$@4! 7#:! .D=#.$:3#($! &#+'@3'%!(=#%!<br />

G6!)6(6:!AU>!U%D%#!'3!%:!.!(B!!<br />

$<br />

V'!+,'1!NU&*(&#+-5-5!U+5#1&#5(#,-!>#!W%+P%&%T-1!-52#&#(#&#+!<br />

%5#!G'!(+'=!)60)#%6:!GU3D:D%)#%!ZBAD%!:0(1030I$=!$%5#3#:#3#($%)#!=633'%!3:'=!<br />

D>#(#4! .'3!=! ?!=!!%)'%! +'1('! ='%'3!! A$($$%#! =')'(! )#-':! #)#%! )60)#%6:! 0(.'!<br />

%0=.'+!%)'%!7'=3'!=!fbV[!5:3#($!$?$%!G'!(+'=!GU3D:3#($!U(%#=3#%:#+$!&#(!A(6@.'!g!<br />

5$-5$-)#!A#(?#=3#.$($3:$.$(B!<br />

90(1030I$=! '%'3$>3#(! K'('5&'$! '%)! X':'65&$! Nd[[[P4! X':'65&$! #.! '3B! NVWWeP4! ,%$)<br />

NVWWWP! -#! C#7('! #.! '3B! Nd[[VP! .'('1!%)'%! G#3$(.$3#%! 7U%.#:3#(3#! &'>!(3'%'%!<br />

@(#@'('.3'()'4! )$A$.'3! =':#('! )#+.#=3$! :$=(0+=0@.'! 67A6%! GD7D.:#3#()#! #3)#! #)$3#%!<br />

)$I$.'3!10.0('13'(!D>#($%)#!$:'A#!'%'3$>!.#=%$$!=633'%!3'('=!A#(?#=3#.$($3:$.$(B!\#(!<br />

! CC!


G$(!=#+$.!)#!+'3':!03'('=!7#(!'3'%!#%!'>!]^!')#.!-$33$)#!A#(#=3$!U3?D:3#(!7'@!3:!!-#!<br />

G6! )##(3#($%! 0(.'3':'+!! G$(! .#=#((D(! ='G63! #)$3#(#=! &#(! G$(! A(6@! g! .#=#((D()#%!<br />

036:6.6(B!<br />

!<br />

,6'6-,6-1!'5'&-O&#+!<br />

;('.!(:'!+0%656%)'!#3)#!#)$3#%!@'(':#.(#3#(#!'$.!)##(3#(!K#+')D1!230=3'(!!c#%#:#!<br />

K#(.$G$%)#! d! 1'(=3!! ='(G0%&$)('.! ='7%'!! M! d! 1'(=3!! ':$%0! '+$.! 706%366! 1'=.U($7#3!<br />

)D>#%)#4! -'(7'%+! '%'3$>$%)#! NcD>AD%#! -#! '(=4! VWf]P! 9$%$.'G! V]B[! @'=#.!<br />

@(0A(':!%)'%! 7'('(3'%!3'('=! )##(3#%)$($3:$.$(B! C(6@3'(! '('+!%)'=$! 1'(=3!3!=3'(!%!<br />

.#+@$.$! 9+.'.bj! @(0A(':!%)'! c6%5'%! .#+.$! Nc6%5'%4VW^^P! =633'%!3'('=! 7'@!3:!.!(B!<br />

m3D:! 0('%3'(!%!%! $+.'.$+.$=$! =0%.(03D%)#! $+#! H&$bH'(#! :#.0)6! =633'%!3:!.!(!<br />

NcD>AD%#!-#!'(=4!VWf]PB!<br />

!<br />

:.+1!.)+$D7-67-+.!$<br />

X#+P%+('5,!)%5/0&'+!!<br />

c#%#:#%$%! d4! g4! Z! -#! V]BAD%D! 7'@!3'%! .'(.!:3'()'4! ='(G0%&$)('.! .$@$%$%! 5$-5$-3#($%!<br />

5'%3!!'!(3!=3'(!! D>#($%#! U%#:3$! )#(#5#)#! #.=$3$! 03)66! +'@.'%:!.!(! NJz[B[VPB! K'G30!<br />

d!#+'+3!!7#:$!.D=#.#%!A(6@3'()'!<br />

0(.'3':'! 5'%3!! '!(3!=! :!+!(! #+'+3!! 7#:3#($! .D=#.#%! A(6@3'('! AU(#! )'&'! 7D=+#=!<br />

03:6.6(B!X#:3#()#=$!;;!706%366%6%!#.=$3#($!)#%#:#%$%!gB!NJz[B[^P4!ZB!NJz[B[VP!<br />

-#! V]BAD%! NJz[B[[VP! )U%#:3#($%)#! $+.'.$+.$=$! U%#:3$! G636%6(=#%4! )$#(! )U%#:3#()#!<br />

;;!706%366%6%!#.=$3#($!U%#:3$!03:':!.!(!NJs[B[^PB!<br />

c#%#:#%$%![bgBAD%4![bZBAD%!-#![bV]BAD%!)U%#:3#($%)#!='(G0%&$)('.!='7%'!!03'('=!<br />

=633'%!3'%! )#+.(0>! :0%0&$)('.! $?#(#%! 7#:3#(3#! G#+3#%#%! 5$-5$-3#(! :!+!(! #+'+3!! 7#:3#!<br />

G#+3#%#%3#(#!AU(#!)'&'!7D=+#=!5'%3!!'!(3!=!'(.!!!AU+.#(:$.$(B!;:$%0!'+$.!706%366!<br />

5'%3!! '!(3!=! '(.!!! D>#($%#4! )#%#:#%$%! [bgBAD%! NJz[B[^P4! [bZBAD%! NJz[B[VP4! [b<br />

V]BAD%3D=! NJz[B[[VP! )U%#:3#($%)#! U%#:3$! )#(#5#)#! #.=$3#:$! 036@4! G6! )U%#:3#($%!<br />

.D:D%)#!7D=+#=!;;!706%36=36!7#:$!.D=#.#%!5$-5$-3#(!)DD=!;;!706%36=36!7#:$!<br />

.D=#.#%!5$-5$-3#(#!AU(#!)'&'!7D=+#=!5'%3!!'!(3!=!'(.!!!AU+.#(:$3#()$(B!!<br />

!<br />

c#%#:#%$%! [bgBAD%4! [bZBAD%! -#! [bV]BAD%3D=! )U%#:3#($%)#! )#+=.(0>! #+'+3!! 7#:$!<br />

.D=#.#%! 5$-5$-3#(! :!+!(! #+'+3!! 7#:$! .D=#.#%! 5$-5$-3#(#! AU(#! )'&'! 1'>3'! 7#:!<br />

.D=#.:$3#()$(B!c#%#:#!7#:3#($%$%!;;!706%366!7#:!.D=#.$:$!D>#($%#!)#%#:#%$%!<br />

[bgBAD%!NJz[B[[VP!-#![bZBAD%3D=!NJz[B[[VP!)U%#:3#($%)#!U%#:3$!)#(#5#)#!#.=$3#:$!<br />

036@4!G6!)U%#:3#($%! .D:D%)#! )DD=! ;;! 706%36=36! 7#:$! .D=#.#%! 5$-5$-3#(! 7D=+#=!<br />

;;!706%36=36!7#:$!.D=#.#%!5$-5$-3#(#!AU(#!)'&'!1'>3'!7#:!.D=#.$:$!AU+.#(:$3#()$(B!<br />

c#%#:#%$%! ! [bZBAD%3D=! )U%#:$%)#! ='(G0%&$)('.! .$@$! M! ;;! 706%366%6%! 7#:!<br />

.D=#.$:$! D>#($%#! $%.#('=+$70%! #.=$+$! $+.'.$+.$=$! U%#:3$! G636%:6.6(! NJz[B[VPB! 26!<br />

)U%#:3#()#! :!+!(! #+'+3!! 7#:3#()#! ':$%0! '+$.! 706%366! 7#:! .D=#.$:$%$! U%#:3$!<br />

#.=$3#:#>=#%4!)#=+.(0>!#+'+3!!7#:3#()#!)DD=!':$%0!'+$.!706%366!7#:!.D=#.$:$%$!<br />

'(.!(:!.!(NJz[B[^PB!<br />

!<br />

52#!V'!+,'1!VU&*(&#+-5?#!W%+P%&%T-1!Y&0*(&#+)<br />

"/%?#5/(!(%+P%&%T-1!U&0*(!?##+&#+-!<br />

c#%#:#%$%! ZBAD%D%)#! 7'@!3'%! $%5#3#:#3#(#! AU(#h! )60)#%6:! -$336+! 7D=+#=3$$! -#!<br />

-$336+! '3'%!! D>#($%)#! ='(G0%&$)('.! .$@$! U%#:3$! NJ[B[[VP! #.=$! AU+.#(:$! 036@4! G6%'!<br />

AU(#!)#=+.(0>!#+'+3!!7#:3#($!.D=#.#%!5$-5$-3#($%!-$336+!7D=+#=3$$!-#!-$336+!'3'%!!)##($!<br />

)'&'!7D=+#=!G636%:6.6(B!<br />

!<br />

! CCC


K'G30VB!L(=#%!G#+3#:#!)U%#:$%)#!N[bV]AD%P!=633'%!3'%!='(:'!7#:!G$3#$:$!<br />

c#%#:#!A(6@3'(!! V! d! ]! g!<br />

H0(G0%&$)('.!='7%'!! 9!+!(! c#+=.(0>!<br />

;:$%0!'+$.!706%366! XD=+#=! n0(:'3! XD=+#=! n0(:'3!<br />

9!+!(!<br />

c#=+.(0>!:0%0&$)('.!<br />

T07'!=D+@#+$!<br />

2'3!=!6%6!<br />

cBjBJ!<br />

H$(#?!.'!!<br />

;7?$?#=!7'!!<br />

cib:#.$70%$%!<br />

ib3$+$%!\ji!<br />

K6>!<br />

H d jR ] !<br />

H03$%bj3!tZ[!<br />

8$.':$%!U%!='(:' V !!<br />

9$%#('3!U%!='(:' d !<br />

^VBVd!<br />

b!<br />

]^BgZ!<br />

ZBf]!<br />

[B^V!<br />

[BWe!<br />

]B[[!<br />

[Bg[!<br />

[BVZ!<br />

[B]^!<br />

b!<br />

[B[d!<br />

[BV[!<br />

[B[Z!<br />

eVB][!<br />

b!<br />

][BV[!<br />

VBZ^!<br />

VBeV!<br />

VBde!<br />

b!<br />

[B]d!<br />

[Bd^!<br />

[B]^!<br />

[Bde!<br />

[B[]!<br />

[BV[!<br />

[B[Z!<br />

gBVf!<br />

g^B[[!<br />

]^BWV!<br />

VdB[W!<br />

b!<br />

[BeV!<br />

VB[f!<br />

[Bg^!<br />

[B[g!<br />

[B]^!<br />

[BV[!<br />

[B[g!<br />

[BV[!<br />

[B[Z!<br />

V]BZd!<br />

g^B[[!<br />

dVBdd!<br />

^BZ^!<br />

VBVg!<br />

[BWd!<br />

[Bfd!<br />

[B]Z!<br />

[BVd!<br />

[B]^!<br />

[B]^!<br />

[B[W!<br />

[BV[!<br />

[B[Z!<br />

KRJi;9! V[[B[[! V[[B[[! V[[B[[! V[[B[[!<br />

\#+'@3'%'%!)##(3#(!<br />

9#.'G03$=!#%#(I$B!=5'3_=A!<br />

\':!@(0.#$%!<br />

\':!7'!<br />

\':!+#3D30>!<br />

\':!=D3!<br />

j'!<br />

J!N7'('(3'%'G$3$(P!<br />

n'rHb!j34!:LS_=A!<br />

9#.$70%$%!<br />

9#.B!r!T$+.$%!<br />

i$+$%!<br />

][f^!<br />

d^BgW!<br />

eBfg!<br />

dBeZ!<br />

b!<br />

VB[V!<br />

[B^[!<br />

d][!<br />

[Bfd!<br />

VBd[!<br />

VBe[!<br />

][fe!<br />

d[B[g!<br />

eBVZ!<br />

dB^Z!<br />

b!<br />

VB[V!<br />

[B^[!<br />

d][!<br />

[Bed!<br />

[BWg!<br />

VBde!<br />

! CCH<br />

][f^!<br />

dgBf[!<br />

][dg!<br />

VBfV!<br />

b!<br />

VB[[!<br />

[B^[!<br />

d]V!<br />

[BfZ!<br />

VBd[!<br />

VBe[!<br />

][f^!<br />

VWBge!<br />

dBef!<br />

VBZd!<br />

b!<br />

VB[[!<br />

[B^[!<br />

d][!<br />

[BeZ!<br />

[BWg!<br />

VBde!<br />

V! 8$.':$%!U%!='(:'%!%!&#(!V!=A4!V^[![[[!:A!k$%=04!V[[![[[!:A!c#:$(4!d[[[[!<br />

:A!2'=!(4!V!^[[!:A!70.4!^[[!:A!H0G'3.4!d[[!:A!T#3#%76:4!V![[[!:A!903$G)#%4!^[![[[!:A!9'A%#>76:!<br />

$?#(:#=.#)$(B!<br />

H'(G0%&$)('.! .$@$%$%! )60)#%6:! 5($@.'! )#($%3$$! NJz[B[[VP! D>#($%#! #.=$+$! ;;!<br />

706%366! $%.#('=+$70%! $3$=$+$%#! G'3!! 03'('=! U%#:3$! G636%:6! 036@4! :!+!(! #+'+3!!<br />

7#:3#()#! ;;! 706%366! U%#:3$! #.=$! 7'('.:'>=#%4! )#=+.(0>! #+'+3!! 7#:3#()#! )DD=!<br />

;;! 706%366! 7D=+#=! ;;! 706%36=36! 7#:#! AU(#! )60)#%6:! 5($@.'! )#($%3$$%$!<br />

)DD(:D.D(B!8$336+!'3'%!!D>#($%#!='(G0%&$)('.!.$@$%#!G'3!!03:'=+!>!%!N$%.#('=+$70%!<br />

U%#:3$! )#$3P! ;;! 706%366! U%#:3$! #.=$! AU+.#(:$! 036@4! )DD=! ;;! 706%36=36!<br />

7#:3#! )'&'! )DD=! )60)#%6:! -$336+! '3'%!! +'@.'%:!.!(! NK'G30! gPB! X#:3#($%! ;;!<br />

706%366%6%! 5$-5$-3#($%! XcT! D>#($%#! #.=$3#($4! )#%#:#%$%! [bgBAD%4! [bZBAD%! -#! [b<br />

V]BAD%3D=! NJz[B[[VP! )U%#:3#($%)#! $+.'.$+.$=$! 03'('=! U%#:3$! G636%:6! 036@4! G6!<br />

)U%#:3#()#! 7D=+#=! ;;! 706%36=36! 7#:$! .D=#.#%! 5$-5$-3#(! )DD=! ;;! 706%36=36!<br />

7#:$!.D=#.#%!&'7-'%3'('!AU(#!)'&'!$7$!XcT!AU+.#(:$3#()$(B!<br />

m3D:! 0('%!! D>#($%#4! )#%#:#%$%! [bV]! AD%3D=! )U%#:$%)#! ='(G0%&$)('.! .$@$4! ;;!<br />

706%366! -#! ='(G0%&$)('.! .$@$! M! ;;! 706%366! $%.#('=+$70%! #.=$3#($%$%! $+.'.$+.$=$!<br />

U%#:3$!03:')!!!+'@.'%:!.!(!NJs[B[^PB!!<br />

!


K'G30!dB!L.3$=!5$-5$-3#()#!='(G0%&$)('.!.$@$!-#!':$%0!'+$.!706%366%6%$5'%3!!'!(3!=!<br />

'(.!!!D>#($%#!#.=$+$!<br />

c#%#:#! [bgBAD%! [bZBAD%! [bV]BAD%!<br />

A(6@3'(!!<br />

V! gWBfVîVBgZ! VV^B^îdB^Z! ]dWB[îeBfZ!<br />

d! gZBWgîVB[g! V[fBgîdBeg! df^B^îfBff!<br />

]! e]B]]îVBWe! V]VBVîVB[^! ]ZgBfîdBWe!<br />

g! ^WB^Vî]BV[! Vd]BeîdBWe! ]gdB^î]BdV!<br />

H'(G0%&$)('.!.$@$!<br />

9!+!(! gfBfZî[BW[! VVVBWîdB[e! ][ZBdîfBgZ!<br />

c#=+.(0>!! eVBgdîVBfg! VdZBgîVBff! ]^fBZî^BdW!<br />

;:$%0!'+$.!706%366!<br />

XD=+#=! ^eB^ZîdB]^! Vd]B]îdBZ! ]^VBWîZBZZ!<br />

cDD=! ^]BZdîdB]g! VVeB[îdBWf! ]VgB[îWBZV!<br />

J!)##(3#($!<br />

H'(G0%&$)('.! z[B[[V! z[B[[V! z[B[[V!<br />

;:$%0!'+$.! [B[df! [B[[]! z[B[[V!<br />

H(!M!;;! [BgV^! [BW]^! [B]ZV!<br />

VY:!+!(_7D=+#=! ;;! 706%36=36h! dY:!+!(_)DD=! ;;! 706%36=36h! ]Y)#=+.(0>_7D=+#=! ;;! 706%36=36h!<br />

gY)#=+.(0>_)DD=!;;!706%36=36!<br />

!<br />

?+.1!)+$@&$"F,7_$$<br />

c#%#:#)#%!#3)#!#)$3#%!+0%6?3'('!AU(#h!#.3$=!5$-5$-3#($!G'3'.:'!)U%#:$!G076%5'!NV]B!<br />

AD%#!=')'(P!)#=.(0>!#+'+3!!7#:3#(3#!G#+3#:#=!:!+!(!#+'+3!!7#:3#(#!AU(#!)'&'!7D=+#=!<br />

5'%3!! '!(3!=4! 5'%3!! '!(3!=! '(.!!4! 7#:! .D=#.$:$! -#! ZB! AD%#! =')'(! )'&'! $7$! 7#:!<br />

)##(3#%)$(:#! +'7!+!! +'3':!.!(B! X#:! )##(3#%)$(:#! 7U%D%)#%! $+#! ='(G0%&$)('.!<br />

='7%'=3'(!!'('+!%)'=$!1'(=!ZBAD%)#%!+0%('!='@'.!3:!.!(B!<br />

;:$%0!'+$.!706%366!03'('=!7D=+#=!;;!706%366%'!+'&$@!7#:3#(3#!V]BAD%#!=')'(!<br />

03'%!)U%#:3#()#!)'&'!7D=+#=!5'%3!!'!(3!=!-#!5'%3!!'!(3!=!'(.!!4!ZBAD%#!=')'(!03'%!<br />

)U%#:3#()#! $+#! )'&'! )DD=! 7#:! .D=#.$:$! -#! V]BAD%#! =')'(! )'&'! $7$! 7#:!<br />

)##(3#%)$(:#!+'7!+!!+'3'%:!.!(B!!<br />

!<br />

K'G30! ]B! L.3$=! 5$-5$-3#()#! ='(G0%&$)('.! .$@$! -#! ':$%0! '+$.! 706%366%6%$ 0(.'3':'!<br />

7#:!.D=#.$:$!NA_&'7-'%P!-#!7#:!)##(3#%)$(:#!+'7!+!!D>#($%#!#.=$+$!<br />

c#%#:#!<br />

A(6@3'(!!<br />

[bgBAD%! [bZBAD%! [bV]BAD%!<br />

! XK! XcT! XK! XcT! XK! XcT!<br />

V! g^BWVî[B^g! [BWd^î[B[dZ! V]VBWî[BWd!5! VBVg^î[B[dZ! ]W[BZîfBfd! VBVffî[B[V]!<br />

d! gWBgeî[Be]! VB[]]î[B[V]! V]gBWîdBVf!5! VBdgeî[B[dV! ]fWBZîeBW]! VB]eWî[B[df!<br />

]! ^eB]^îVBdW! [BfWVî[B[Vd! VgWBWîVB^f!G! VBVg]î[B[Vf! g^dBdî^BVV! VBd[eî[B[[W!<br />

g! eVBeVîVBWV! VB[g]î[B[]V! Ve]BWîdB[Z!'! VB]dWî[B[d! g^WBgîVBdg! VB]gdî[B[Vd!<br />

H'(G0%&$)('.!.$@! ! ! !<br />

9!+!(! gZBefî[BeZ! [BWZWî[B[dd! V]]BgîVBd! VBVWeî[B[dd! ]W[Bdî^B]^! VBdZfî[B[]V!<br />

c#=+.(0>!! ^fBWfîVB]e! [BWeZî[B[df! V^eBWîdBge! VBd]eî[B[]V! g^^BfîdBZ]! VBdZgî[B[dd!<br />

;:$%0!'+$.!706%366! ! ! !<br />

XD=+#=! ^VBV]îVBZV! [BW[fî[B[V^! Vg[BWîdBfg! VBVggî[B[V^! gdVBgîV[Bge! VBVWZî[B[[f!<br />

cDD=! ^^B^gîdB[Z! VB[]fî[B[Ve! VgWBgîgBeV! VBdfZî[B[Vf! gdgB^îVVB[]! VB]^^î[B[V^!<br />

J!)##(3#($! ! ! !<br />

H'(G0%&$)('.!! z[B[[V! [BgZ^! z[B[[V! [B[fZ! z[B[[V! [Bf[[!<br />

;:$%0!'+$.!! z[B[[V! z[B[[V! z[B[[V! z[B[[V! [B^We! z[B[[V!<br />

H(!M!;;! [B]]e! [BVW^! z[B[[V! [B[ZW! [Bgf^! [BVZV!<br />

VY:!+!(_7D=+#=! ;;! 706%36=36h! dY:!+!(_)DD=! ;;! 706%36=36h! ]Y)#=+.(0>_7D=+#=!<br />

;;!706%36=36h!gY)#=+.(0>_)DD=!;;!706%36=36!<br />

! CCJ


!<br />

H'(G0%&$)('.! .$@$! -#! ;;! 706%366%6%4! [bZ! AD%3#(! '('+!%)'4! 7#:! .D=#.$:$! D>#($%#!<br />

$%.#('=+$70%! #.=$+$! U%#:3$)$(! -#! G6! +0%65'! AU(#! :!+!(! $?#(#%! 7#:3#($! .D=#.#%!<br />

&'7-'%3'(! D>#($%#! ;;! 706%366! #.=$3$! 03:'>=#%4! )#=+.(0>! .D=#.#%! &'7-'%3'()'!<br />

':$%0! '+$.! 706%366! )D.D=?#! 7#:! .D=#.$:$! '(.:!.!(B! 96&.#:#3#%! )DD=! ;;!<br />

706%366%'! G'3!! 03'('=! ':$%0! '+$.! 7#.#(+$>3$$%$%! A$)#($3:#+$! '?!+!%)'%4! &'7-'%!<br />

7#:! .D=#.$:$%$! '(.!(:!.!(B! 9!+!(! %$'+.'+!%'! AU(#! #:$3$:! 7U%D%)#%! &'>!(! )6(6:)'!<br />

G636%'%! )#=+.(0>6%! ='%'! A#?$! +D(#+$%$%! )'&'! =!+'! 03:'+!4! 7#:)#=$! ;;!<br />

7'('(3'%'G$3$(3$$! -#7'! ;;! 706%366%6%! ='(G0%&$)('.! .$@$%#! G'3!! 03'('=!<br />

)#$.$($3:#+$%$%! )'&'! 67A6%! 03'5'!! +0%656%'! -'(!3'G$3$(B! 26! )6(6:! ='(G0%&$)('.!<br />

='7%'=3'(!%!%! A3$+#:$=+! $%)#=+! )##($%#! G'3!! 03'('=4! #.3$=! 5$-5$-! 7#:3#($%)#!<br />

G636%:'+!! A#(#=#%! ':$%0! '+$.! )D>#7$%$%! )#$.$($3:#+$! A#(#=.$$! +0%656%'!<br />

AU.D(:#=.#)$(B!<br />

X'@!3'%! '('.!(:'3'()'! 5$-5$-3#()#! =636?=')'%! ?!=!:! +0%('+!! 1'(=3!! ='(G0%&$)('.!<br />

='7%'=3'(!73'! G#+3#:#)#! NT0(G'('! #.! '3B4! d[[]h2'.'3! '%)! J'(+0%+4! d[[d'h! 2'.'3! '%)!<br />

J'(+0%+!d[[dGh!2'.'3!'%)!J'(+0%+4!d[[gh!i0%A0!#.!'3B4!d[[^ha#6()$%A!#.!'3B4!d[[]GP!<br />

)#=+.(0>! A$G$! =03'7! ?U>D%#G$3#%! ='(G0%&$)('.! ='7%'=3'(!%!%! =633'%!:!%)'! )$#(!<br />

='(G0%&$)('.! ='7%'=3'(!%'! AU(#! dVBAD%D%! +0%6%'! =')'(! 5'%3!!'!(3!=4! 5'%3!!'!(3!=!<br />

'(.!!! -#! 7#:! )##(3#%)$(:#! +'7!+!! 7U%D%)#%! )'&'! $7$! +0%6?3'(! '3!%)!!%!! G$3)$(#%!<br />

?'3!:'3'(!%!+0%6?3'(!73'4!G6!'('.!(:'%!%!+0%6?3'(!!676:!$?#($+$%)#)$(B!L.3$=!5$-5$-!<br />

7#:3#($%)#! 1'(=3!! &':! @(0.#$%! )D>#7$! -#! 1'(=3!! ':$%0! '+$.! 706%366%6%! #.=$3#($%$!<br />

0(.'7'!=07'%!-#!7D=+#=!@(0.#$%!-#_-#7'!':$%0!'+$.!$?#($=3$!7#:3#!)'&'!7D=+#=!5'%3!!<br />

'!(3!=4! 5'%3!! '!(3!=! '(.!!! -#! )'&'! $7$! 7#:! )##(3#%)$(:#! +'7!+!! #3)#! #)$3)$$!<br />

NCU=?#7(#=4!d[[gh!TQ'.+0%!#.!'3B4!d[[dh!H$))!#.!'3B4!d[[ghT'30)0!#.!'3B4!VWWWh2'.'3!<br />

'%)! J'(+0%+4! d[[dGP! 7U%D%)#=$! G$3)$($3#(4! G6! '('.!(:')'! #3)#! #)$3#%! 7D=+#=! ;;!<br />

706%36=36!7#:3#(3#!)'&'!$7$!@#(10(:'%+!+0%6?3'(!%!!)#+.#=3#:#=.#)$(B!!<br />

!<br />

K'G30! gB! L.3$=! 5$-5$-3#()#! ='(G0%&$)('.! .$@$! -#! ':$%0! '+$.! 706%366%6%B! ZBAD%!<br />

)60)#%6:!-$336+!:0(1030I$=!U>#33$=3#($!D>#($%#!#.=$+$!<br />

C(6@3'(! 8$336+!7D=+#=3$$!Nï:P! 8$336+!'3'%!!N:: d P! H($@.'!)#($%3$$!Nï:P!<br />

V! f[dB[îdgBVg! [BVd[gî[B[[gZ! V^dBWî^B^]!5!<br />

d! ZWeB[î^ZBeZ! [BVVgdî[B[V[[! VZ[Bgî]B^e!G!<br />

]! WZZBeî]B]Z! [BVW[fî[B[[V[! Vf^BWî^B[]!'!<br />

g! W^ZBfî]^B^]! [BV^WVî[B[V[Z! V^^B^î]BZf!5!<br />

H'(G0%&$)('.!.$@$!<br />

9!+!(!! ZWWB[îdfBWe! [BVVZ]î[B[[^]! VeVBeîgBgW!<br />

c#=+.(0>!! WeZBZîVeBWg! [BVZ^[î[B[[Zf! VZ[BZîeBgg!<br />

;:$%0!'+$.!706%366!<br />

XD=+#=! ffWBfî]^B[e! [BV^^eî[B[V]^! VeWBgîZBVd!<br />

cDD=!! fZeBWîg]Bf[! [BV]eZî[B[V[W! VedBWî]BZ[!<br />

J!)##(3#($!<br />

H'(G0%&$)('.!NH(P! [B[[V! z[B[[V! [B[ZV!<br />

;:$%0!'+$.!N;;P! [BZde! [B[]V! [BVfd!<br />

H(!M!;;! [Bf^[! [BVdg! z[B[[V!<br />

VY:!+!(_7D=+#=! ;;! 706%36=36h! dY:!+!(_)DD=! ;;! 706%36=36h! ]Y)#=+.(0>_7D=+#=!<br />

;;!706%36=36h!gY)#=+.(0>_)DD=!;;!706%36=36!<br />

!<br />

c#%#:#%$%!ZBAD%D%)#!7'@!3'%! $%5#3#:#3#(#! AU(#h!)#=+.(0>! #+'+3!! 7#:3#(! 5$-5$-3#($%!<br />

-$336+!7D=+#=3$$!-#!-$336+!'3'%!%!!'(.!(:!.!(B!%.#('=+$70%!$3$=$7#!G'3!!03'('=4!:!+!(!<br />

#+'+3!! 7#:3#()#! U%#:3$! 03:'>=#%4! )#=+.(0>! #+'+3!! 7#:3#()#! )DD=! ;;! 706%366!<br />

! CCN


-$336+! A#%$3$$! -#! 5($@.'! )#($%3$$%$! )DD(:D.D(B! 8$336+! '3'%!! D>#($%#! ='(G0%&$)('.!<br />

.$@$%#! G'3!! 03:'=+!>!%4! )DD=!;;!706%36=36! 7#:3#! )'&'! )DD=! )60)#%6:! -$336+!<br />

'3'%!!+'@.'%:!.!(B!H'(G0%&$)('.!.$@$!-#!;;!706%366%6%!$%.#('=+$70%!#.=$+$%#!G'3!!<br />

03'('=4!)#+=.(0>!#+'+3!!7#:3#()#!;;!706%366!U%#:3$!#.=$!7'('.:'>=#%4!:!+!(!#+'+3!!<br />

7#:3#()#!)DD=!;;!706%366!-$336+!7D=+#=3$$4!A#%$3$$!-#!'3'%!%!!'(.!(:!.!(B!<br />

C#7('! #.! '3B! Nd[[VGP#($%#!$=$!.D(!#.=$!7'('.:'=.')!(B!26%3'()'%!G$($%5$+$!#%.(0+$.!&D5(#3#($!-#!G6%'!<br />

G'3!! 03'('=! -$336+3'(!%! #:$3$:! '3'%!%!%! '(.:'+!)!(B! =$%5$+$! $+#! #@$.#3! )0=6)'!<br />

&D5(#3#($%! 7#%$3#%:#+$%#! ='.=!)'! G636%:'+!)!(B! c$#(! G$(! G'=!.'%! )#=+.(0>6%!<br />

#:$3$:$%$%! )60)#%6:)'! A#(?#=3#:#+$! )03'7!+!73'4! G6! G'!(+'=! GU3D:D%)#! -$336+!<br />

'3'%!%!%! )'&'! A#%$! 03:'+!%'! 703! '?'G$3:#=.#)$(B! c'&'! GD7D=! -$336+6%! +6G:6=0>!<br />

.'G'='!D>#($%)#!.6.6%:'+!%!!+'3':'=!$?$%!=($@.'!)#($%3$$!)#!'(.:'=.')!(B!C#7('!#.!'3B!<br />

Nd[[VGP!-#!a#6()$%A!#.!'3B!Nd[[V'!-#!d[[]'P#!10(!G(0$3#(B!;%$:'3!*##)!<br />

T5$#%5#!'%)!K#5&%030A74!VVW4!dW]b][^B!<br />

eB! c6%5'%4!cB!2B!VW^^B!963.$@3#!('%A#0%!:63.$@3#!*!.#+.B!2$0:#.($5+4!VV4VbgdB!<br />

ZB! cD>AD%#4! RB4! H#+$5$4! KB! -#! CD(GD>4! *B! VWf]B! +.'.$+.$=! 9#.0)3'(!bO4! ;B`B! l$(B! *'=B! X'7YfeV4!<br />

c#(+!H$.'G$Y!dWW4!dVf!+B!;B!`B!2'+!:#-$B!;%='('B!<br />

fB! L3$'++0%4!;B!jB!'%)!C6):6%)++0%4!9B!VWWeB!T.'(5&Y!@&7+$505&#:$5'3!'%)!16%5.$0%'3!'+@#5.+B!O%Y!<br />

L3$'++0%4!;B!jB!NL)BP4!j'(G0&7)('.#+!$%!*00)B!9'(5#3!c#==#(4!n#Q!X0(=4!g]Vp^[]B!<br />

WB! C#7('4!;B4!,%$4!lB!'%)!T=3'%V!cB!d[[VGB!L%.#(057.#!)7%':$5+!'%)!:650+'3!)#-#30@:#%.!$%!.&#!<br />

@0+.&'.5&!5&$5=B!J063.(7!T5$#%5#!f[4!ZZepZfdB!<br />

V[B! CU=?#7(#=4!cB!d[[gB!L.3$=!@$3$?3#()#!=636?=')'%!?!=!!+0%('+!!7#:#!A#?$!+D(#+$!$3#!)#$$=!&':!<br />

@(0.#$%! )D>#73#($%$%! @#(10(:'%+! -#! +$%)$($:! +$+.#:$! A#3$$:$! D>#($%#! #.=$3#($B! c0=.0('! .#>$! NG'+!3:':!PB!<br />

;%='('!`%$-#(+$.#+$4!VgV!+B4!;%='('B!<br />

VVB! H$))4!9B!K4!95c'%$#34!jB!cB4!2('%.0%4!TB!iB!9$33#(!LB!"4!20(#%!2B!2B!'%)B!*'%5&#(!2B!OB!d[[gB!<br />

O%5(#'+$%A! ':$%0! '5$)! )#%+$.7! $:@(0-#+! 3$-#! @#(10(:'%5#! '%)! 5'(5'++! 7$#3)+! 01! 50::#(5$'3! G(0$3#(+B!<br />

w06(%'3!01!;@@3$#)!J063.(7!"#+#'(5&4!V]NgP4!^W]be[gB!<br />

VdB! i0%A04!*B!;4!9#%.#%4!wB!*B!9B4!J#)(0+04!;B!;4!*$A6#$(#)04!;B!nB4!"'5'%$55$4!;B!9B!jB4!C'$0..04!<br />

wB!2B4!T0(G'('4!wB!RB!2B!d[[^B!j'(G0&7)('.#+!$%!.&#!)$#.+!01!%#Q37!&'.5&#)!5&$5=+B!"#-$+.'!2('+$3#$('!c#!<br />

l00.#5%$'b2('>$3$'%!w06(%'3!01!;%$:'3!T5$#%5#4!]gNVP4!Vd]bV]]B!<br />

V]B! T'30)04! TB4! J$S6#(4! wB4! j'+.#33'%0+4! OB4! 9#%)#>4! wB! '%)! 9'.#0+4! CB! CB! VWWWB! L11#5.+! 01! )$#.'(7!<br />

@(0.#$%! 3#-#3! 0%! @#(10(:'%5#! '%)! A'+.(0$%.#+.$%'3! .('5.! )#-#30@:#%.! $%! @0+.b&'.5&#)! G(0$3#(+B! J063.(7!<br />

T5$#%5#!N+6@@3#:#%.P!Zf4!febfZB!<br />

VgB! T0(G'('4!wB!RB!24!9#%.#%4!wB!*B!94!i0%A04!*B!;4!J#)(0+04!;B!;4!*$A6#$(#)0!;B!n4!"'5'%$55$!;B!<br />

9B!jB!'%)!C'$0..04!wB!2B!d[[]B!L11#5.+!01!)$11#(#%.!5'(G0&7)('.#+!$%!.&#!1##)!01!%#Q37!&'.5&#)!5&$5=+!0%!<br />

@#(10(:'%5#!'%)!0(A'%+!'330:#.($5!A(0Q.&B!J063.(7!T5$#%5#4!N;G+.('5.!df]PB!<br />

V^B! TQ'.+0%4!\B!HB4!C06+4!"B4!OI$4!JB!;B!'%)!l'(($%='3':4!"B!d[[dB!L11#5.!01!)$#.'(7!@(0.#$%!3#-#34!<br />

':$%0!'5$)!G'3'%5#!'%)!1##)$%A!3#-#3!0%!A(0Q.&4!A'+.(0$%.#+.$%'3!.('5.4!'%)!:650+'3!+.(65.6(#!01!.&#!+:'33!<br />

$%.#+.$%#!$%!G(0$3#(!5&$5=#%+B!;%$:'3!"#+#'(5&4!^V4!^[Vb^V^B!<br />

VeB! TQ'.+0%4!\B!HB4!C06+4!"B4!OI$4!JB!;B!'%)!l'(($%='3':4!"B!d[[dB!L11#5.!01!)$#.'(7!@(0.#$%!3#-#34!<br />

':$%0!'5$)!G'3'%5#!'%)!1##)$%A!3#-#3!0%!A(0Q.&4!A'+.(0$%.#+.$%'3!.('5.4!'%)!:650+'3!+.(65.6(#!01!.&#!+:'33!<br />

$%.#+.$%#!$%!G(0$3#(!5&$5=#%+B!;%$:'3!"#+#'(5&4!^V4!^[Vb^V^B!<br />

! CCT


VZB! K'('5&'$4! JB! '%)! X':'65&$4! HB! d[[[B! L11#5.+! 01! 36:$%'3! %6.($#%.! 'G+0(@.$0%4! $%.('36:$%'3!<br />

@&7+$5'3!+.$:63'.$0%4!'%)!$%.('-#%06+!@'(#%.#('3!'3$:#%.'.$0%!0%!.&#!(#50-#(7!(#+@0%+#+!01!)60)#%'3!-$336+!<br />

:0(@&030A7!10330Q$%A!1##)!Q$.&)('Q'3!$%!5&$5=#%+B!J063.(7!T5$#%5#4!ZWNVVP4!V^ZfbV^f^B!<br />

VfB! K&0:'+4! cB! 8B! '%)! "'-$%)('%4! 8B! d[[fB! L11#5.! 01! 5#(#'3! .7@#! 0%! .&#! @#(10(:'%5#4!<br />

A'+.(0$%.#+.$%'3!.('5.!)#-#30@:#%.!'%)!$%.#+.$%'3!:0(@&030A7!01!.&#!%#Q37!&'.5&#)!G(0$3#(!5&$5=B!w06(%'3!01!<br />

J063.(7!T5$#%5#B!g^NVP4!geb^[B!<br />

VWB! ,%$4! lB! VWWWB! *6%5.$0%'3! c#-#30@:#%.! 01! .&#! +:'33! $%.#+.$%#! $%! )0:#+.$5! G$()+Y! j#3363'(! '%)!<br />

:03#563'(!'+@#5.+B!J063.(7!'%)!;-$'%!2$030A7!"#-$#Q+4!V[N]P4!VeZbVZWB!<br />

d[B! ,%$4!lB4!T:$(%0-4!;B!'%)!T=3'%4!cB!d[[]B!J(#b!'%)!@0+.&'.5&!)#-#30@:#%.!01!A0G3#.!5#33+!$%!.&#!<br />

G(0$3#(!+:'33!$%.#+.$%#Y!L11#5.!01!)#3'7#)!'55#++!.0!1##)B!J063.(7!T5$#%5#4!fdNdP4!]d[b]dZB!<br />

dVB! a#6()$%A!"B!L4!8#3):'%4!;B4!a$33#:!;B!CB!8B4!-'%!)#(!;'(!JB!wB!'%)!9'(.$%!aB!;B!8B!d[[V'B!<br />

T.'(5&! )$A#+.$0%! ('.#! $%! .&#! +:'33! $%.#+.$%#! 01! G(0$3#(! 5&$5=#%+! )$11#(+! ':0%A! 1##)+.611+B! w06(%'3! 01!<br />

n6.($.$0%4!V]VNWP4!d]dWbd]]^B!!<br />

ddB! a#6()$%A4! "B! L4! L%.$%A4! \B! '%)! 8#(+.#A#%4! 9B! aB! ;B! d[[]'B! K&#! #11#5.! 01! +$.#! 01! +.'(5&!<br />

)$A#+.$0%!0%!@#(10(:'%5#!01!G(0$3#(!5&$5=#%+B!;%$:'3!*##)!T5$#%5#!;%)!K#5&%030A74!VV[NVbgP4!VZ^bVfgB!<br />

d]B! a#6()$%A4!"B!L4!L%.$%A4!\B!'%)!8#(+.#A#%4!9a;B!d[[]GB!K&#!(#3'.$0%!G#.Q##%!+.'(5&!)$A#+.$0%!<br />

('.#!'%)!':$%0!'5$)!3#-#3!10(!G(0$3#(!5&$5=#%+B!J063.(7!T5$#%5#4!fdNdP4!dZWbdfgB!!<br />

dgB! X':'65&$4! HB4! H':$+07':'4! \B! '%)! O++&$=$4! XB! VWWeB! L11#5.+! 01! 1'+.$%A! '%)! (#1##)$%A! 0%!<br />

+.(65.6(#+!01!.&#!$%.#+.$%'3!-$33$!'%)!#@$.&#3$'3!5#33+!$%!a&$.#!i#A&0(%!&#%+B!2($.$+&!J063.(7!T5$#%5#4!]Z4!^4!<br />

W[WbWdVB!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

! CCW


" #CW $?OA&1(


1'=.U()D(B!%0-'+70%!6>6%!-')#)#!:'3$7#.$!)DD(:#=3#!='3:'>4!'7%!!>':'%)'!='3$.#4!<br />

AD-#%3$=4! =633'%!:! =03'73!!! A$G$! U>#33$=3#($! A#3$.$($3:$! 7'!)'!$7$3#.$($3:$! D(D%!<br />

.'3#G$!03'%!.D=#.$5$!A#(#=+$%$:3#($%$!='(!3':')'!)'!U%#:!.'!(!NgPB!!<br />

CD%D:D>)#! $%0-'+70%! 0(.':!%!%! 036.6(63:'+!! -#! G6%'! G'3!! 03'('=! .#=%030I$=!<br />

A#3$:#! -#! 7#%$! D(D%! A#3$.$(:#! 7#.#%#=3#($! ='>'%:'7'! ?'3!'%! 1$(:'3'(! N^P! G6%6!<br />

G''(:'=! $?$%! '('.!(:'bA#3$.$(:#! N;(bC#P! ?'3!:'3'(!%!! )'&'! )'! U%#:+#:#=.#! -#!<br />

)$#(!+#=.U(3#()#!03)66!A$G$!$3#.:#3#($%!.#:#3!10%=+$70%3'(!%)'%!;(bC#!1''3$7#.3#($!<br />

$?$%! GD.?#)#%! '7(!3'%! @'7! AD%! A#?.$=?#! '(.:'=.')!(B! K,H! d[[W! 7!3!! ;('.!(:'! -#!<br />

C#3$.$(:#!*''3$7#.3#($!;('.!(:'+!#! ?'(@:'=.')!(B! C!)'! #%)D+.($+$%$%!<br />

G$(?0=! )'3!%)'! G6! =0%6)'! 5$))$! &'(5':'3'(! 7'@!3:'=.'! -#! 1'(=3!! ='.#A0($3#()#! ?0=!<br />

+'7!)'! 7#%$! D(D%! @$7'+'7'! '(>! #)$3:#=.#)$(B! `3=#:$>)#! $+#! 7#%$! D(D%! A#3$.$(:#!<br />

=0%6+6%)'!A!)'!+#=.U(D!A#3$:$!D3=#3#($%!A#($+$%)#!='3:!!-#!&#%D>!03:'+!!A#(#=#%!<br />

=0%6:'!63'':':!.!(B!!<br />

$<br />

a(A(./&,$4567-+)+5+$`&,($b.O,$>&-(1(.)&$<br />

X#%$!D(D%!A#3$.$(:#4!AD%D:D>!=D(#+#3!A!)'!@'>'(!%)'!(#='G#.!D+.D%3DD!+'3'%:'+!!<br />

-#!6>6%!-')#3$!1$%'%+'3!G''(!!#3)#!#)$3:#+$!'?!+!%)'%!67A6%!G$(!+.('.#I$!03'('=!.'-+$7#!<br />

#)$3$(! NZ4! fPB! `(D%! 7#%$3#$:$%$%! +#=.U()#=$! .D:! '=.U(3#($%! =0(6%'('=! A#3$$:$%!<br />

+D()D(D3:#+$%#4! @'>'(! ($+=$%$%! '>'3:'+!%'4! 1$(:'%!%! @$7'+'! )##($%$%! '(.:'+!%'! -#!<br />

(#='G#.! D+.D%3DD%D%! +'3'%:'+!%'! 7'()!:! #..$$! G$3)$($3:#=.#)$(B! 26%6%3'! G$(3$=.#4!<br />

;-(6@'!D3=#3#($!)#!)'&$3!03:'=!D>#(#!G$(?0=!D3=#)#!A!)'!-#!$?#5#=!+'%'7$%)#!)$#(!<br />

+#=.U(3#(#!AU(#!;(bC#!7'.!(!:!!)'&'!)DD=!)D>#7)#!='3:'=.'4!+#=.U(4!7#%$3#$:3#($%!<br />

@'>'('! '(>!%)'! .6.656! )'-('%:'=.'! -#! @'>'()'! (')$='3! 7#%$! D(D%3#($%! +'7!+!!<br />

+'%!3)!!%)'%!)DD=!0('%)'!03:'=.')!(!NfPB!!<br />

`(D%!A#3$.$(:#4!D(D%!=0%+#@.$73#!#=$33#%#%!D(D%!1$=($%)#%!7'%$!+076..'%4!=0%+#@..#!<br />

G#3$(.$3#%! .D:! U>#33$=3#($73#! @'>'()'! .#+.! #)$3:#7#! &'>!(! A#(?#=! D(D%#4! 7'%$! +0:6.'!<br />

=')'(!6>'%'%!&'(#=#.3$!G$(!+D(#?.$(B!X#%$!D(D%!A#3$.$(:#!G$(!1$(:'!$?$%)#!'7(!!$>03#!G$(!<br />

'=.$-$.#! 03'('=! AU(D3:#:#3$4! 1$(:'! 1#3+#1#+$4! .#:#3! $(=#.! +.('.#I$+$! -#! G$(!<br />

:63.$10%=+$70%#3!$(=#.!'=.$-$.#+$!03'('=!)DD%D3:#3$)$(!NZPB!;%3':!!.':!03'('=!-#(#%!<br />

:D=#::#3!G$(!.'%!:!03:':'+!%'!(':#%4!7#%$!D(D%!A#3$.$(:#7$!G'+$.!03'('=!E1$(:'!<br />

.'('1!%)'%! )'&'! U%5#! D(#.$3:#:$! 7'! )'! @'>'(3'%:':!! D(D%F! #=3$%)#! .'%!:3':'=!<br />

:D:=D%)D(B!c'&'!A#%$!G$(!.'%!:3':'!$3#!7#%$!D(D%!A#3$.$(:#!EG$(!1$(:'!.'('1!%)'%!<br />

)'&'! U%5#)#%! D(#.$3:#7#%! G$(! D(D%D%! A#3$.$($3:#+$! -#! @'>'('! '(>!! 7'! )'! 1$(:'!<br />

.'('1!%)'%!U%5#)#%!=#1#)$3:#7#%!G$(!@'>'('!#+=$!G$(!D(D%D%!+D(D3:#+$F!)$(!NWPB!`(D%!<br />

A#3$.$(:#! @(0+#+$%$%! GD.D%! ':'5!4! G$(! D(D%D! (#='G#.! #)#5#$! @'>'()'! G''(!! '%+!%!!<br />

'(.!(:'=!$?$%!@'>'('!#%!'>!G#3$(+$>3$=3#!+6%:'=.!(B!`(D%!A#3$.$(:#!+.('.#I$3#($!7'7A!%!<br />

! CC]


03'('=! G$3$%#%! #=3$73#4! @'>'('! %D16+! #.:#! N:#-56.! @'>'(4! :#-56.! D(D%3#(P4! @'>'(!<br />

A#3$.$(:#!N7#%$!@'>'(4!:#-56.!D(D%3#(P4!D(D%!A#3$.$(:#!N:#-56.!@'>'(4!7#%$!D(D%3#(P4!<br />

?#$.3#%)$(:#!N7#%$!D(D%3#(4!7#%$!@'>'(P!#=3$%)#!A(6@3'%)!(!3'G$3$(B!!!<br />

X#%$! D(D%! A#3$.$(:#! @(0+#+$%)#! 67A63'%:'+!! A#(#=3$! '':'3'(! 1'(=3!! ='7%'=3'()'!<br />

)#$$=!#=$33#()#!.'%!:3'%:'+!%'!(':#%!.#:#3$%)#!'7%!)!(B!#=$3!V'(3':'4!D(#.$:!-#!)'!.!:!%!.#+.!#)$3:#+$h!@'>'(3':'4!D(#.$:!-#!)'!.!:!%!<br />

+0%! #%.#A('+70%6! '('! '':'3'(!! 7#(! '3!(B! 26! '':'3'(!! ED(D%! &'==!%)'! +0%!='('(! -#!<br />

@$7'+'7'!'(>F!.'=$@!#)#(B!!<br />

H'(:'!=!G$(!@(0+#+!03'%!7#%$!D(D%!A#3$.$(:#)#!&#(!'':')'!AU(#-!7'@'%!6>:'%3'(!%!<br />

-#! AU(#-3#($%$%! $>3#%#G$3$(3$$! U%#:3$)$(B! \#(&'%A$! G$($%)#! AU(D3#%! G$(! G''(!+!>3!=!<br />

7#%$! D(D%! A#3$.$(:#! ?'G'+!%!%! G''(!+!>3!!! $3#! +0%6?3'%'G$3$(B! C#%#33$=3#! G6!<br />

+@#=.(6:)'! 0)'=3'%!3'%! =0%63'(4! .D=#.$5$! '('.!(:'+!4! ='-(':! A#3$.$(:#4! $%0-'+70%4!<br />

?0=!$3#-3$!.'=!:!?'3!:'+!4!@'>'(3':'4!7U%#.$:4!+'.!3'(4!(#=3':!-GB!67A63':'3'()!(B!<br />

X#%$!D(D%!A#3$.$(:#7#!='.!3'%!1'(=3!!10%=+$70%3'(!%!G$(!7'@G0>6%!.':':3'%:'+!!A$G$!<br />

GD.D%3#:$!03:'+!!A#(#$!&#(=#+!.'('1!%)'%!='G63!#)$3#%!G$(!A#(?#=.$(!NV[PB!!<br />

X#%$!D(D%!A#3$.$(:#!$3#:$%)#!7#(!'3'%!G6!.#:#3!'':'3'(!'('+!%)'!D(D%!-#!@(0I#%$%!<br />

=($.$=!)##(3#%)$(:#3#($!-#!G6!)##(3#%)$(:#3#(#!AU(#!D+.!7U%#.$:$%!='('(3'(!!7#(!'3!(B!<br />

26%3'(! ET.'A#bA'.#+F! 7'! )'! EH($.$=! %0=.'3'(F! 03'('=! $1')#! #)$3$(! NZ4! V[PB! ! H($.$=!<br />

%0=.'3'(! D(D%! A#3$.$(:#%$%! 5'%! )':'(3'(!)!(! -#! G6%'! G'3!! 03'('=! A#(?#=3#.$($3#%!<br />

D(D%! A#3$.$(:#! $3#:$%#! EH($.$=! `(D%! C#3$.$(:#! J(0+#+$F! ')!! -#($3$(B! kD%=D! G6!<br />

@(0+#+.#! 67A63':'3'(! =($.$=! ='('(3'('! G'3!)!(! -#! @(0I#! +D(#+$%5#! '=.$-$.#3#($%! -#!<br />

?!=.!3'(!%!=($.$=!'%'3$>$!7'@!3!(!NZPB!<br />

J'>'(3':'!+#=.U(D!'?!+!%)'%!7#%$!D(D%!A#3$.$(:#!)##(3#%)$($3)$$%)#!6%6.:':'3!)!(!<br />

=$! G''(!3!! G$(! D(D%! A#3$.$(:#! .D=#.$5$! 0)'=3!! 03:'3!)!(B! 2$(?0=! $(=#.! .D=#.$5$%$%! %#!<br />

$+.#7#5#$%$! )DD%#(#=! U%7'(A!3!! 1$=$(3#(3#! D(D%! A#3$.$(:#7#! G'3'(! -#! GD7D=! &'.'!<br />

7'@'(B!26!1$=$(3#(4!?0=!)0(6!03'G$3$(B!;%5'=4!!7'%3!!03:'!03'+!3!!!)'!?0=!7D=+#=.$(B!<br />

m>#33$=3#! =D?D=! -#! 0(.'! U3?#=3$! $3#.:#3#()#! .D=#.$5$%$%! %#! $+.#)$$! =0%6+6%)'! U%!<br />

7'(A!3!!G$(!$%'%!!-'()!(B!E?$:)#=$!&$+!G6!7#%$!D(D%D%!G''(!3!!03'5'!%!!+U73D70(F!!7'!<br />

)'! E26! D(D%! $7$! +'.'5'=! G$3$70(6:! -#! G6%6! &$++#)$70(6:F! #=3$%)#! D+.! 7U%#.$:$%!<br />

0(.'7'! '..!!! 1$=$(3#(! &'==!%)'! $))$'3!! +U>3#($! 03'G$3$(B! ;7(!5'4! U(%#$%4! .#=%030I$!<br />

'!(3!=3!!$(=#.3#()#!.#=%030I$=!$3#($!D(D%3#($%!$7$!+'.'5'!!U%!7'(A!+!!)'!03'G$3$(B!26%3'(!<br />

=#+$%3$=3#! &'.'3!! )'-('%!3'()!(B! n#7$%! $7$! +'.'5'!%!! &'%A$! D(D%D%! G''(!3!! 03'5'!%!!<br />

.D=#.$5$!G#3$(3#(!NZ4!WPB!<br />

!<br />

! CH#


!<br />

#=$3!VB!C!)'!#%)D+.($+$%)#!7#%$!D(D%!A#3$.$(:#!'':'3'(!!NZ4!WP!<br />

!<br />

26! %#)#%3#4! A#3#%#=+#3! 7#%$! D(D%! A#3$.$(:#! @(0+#+$%)#! AD%D:D>)#! G$3$$:!<br />

.#=%030I$+$%)#=$!$3#(3#:#3#($%!)#!#.=$+$73#!)'&'!)#:0=('.$=3#.$($3:$!-#!:D.#($3#($%!<br />

?0=! )'&'! '=.$1! (03! 07%')!!! 7#%$! :0)#33#(! A#3$.$($3:$.$(B! X#%$! D(D%! A#3$.$(:#)#!<br />

:D.#($3#($%! AD?3#%)$($3:#+$! N56+.0:#(! #:@0Q#(:#%.P! 7'=3'!:!%)'! 7#%$! D(D%!<br />

.#+'(!:3'(!%)'!1$=$(!036.6(:')'! -#! D(#.$3#5#=! D(D%! .'+'(!:3'(!%'!='('(!-#($3:#+$%)#!<br />

:D.#($3#($%!(03D%D%!U%#:$!-6(A63'%:'=.')!(!NVVPB!KD=#.$5$!A#(#=+$%$:3#($%$%!)$=='.#!<br />

'3!%)!!!-#!$%5#3#%#(#=!.'.:$%!#)$3:#+$%$%!+'3'%:'7'!?'3!!3)!!!)$#(!G$(!7#%$!D(D%!<br />

A#3$.$(:#! .#=%$$! H'3$.#! 3#-! H0%63'%)!(:'#3$=3#(!NAU(D%D4!<br />

.#=+.D(4! 3#>>#.! -#! =0=6P4! +'3!=! -#! 67A6%36=.6(B! T0%! >':'%3'()'! $+#! G$(! D(D%D%!<br />

.#=%030I$=4! #.$=! -#! +0+7'3! 7'%+!:'3'(!! $?$%#! '3'('=! %'+!3! D(#.$3)$$! -#! $3#%)$$! )#!<br />

U%#:3$!&'3#!A#3:$.$(!NVg4!V^PB!CD%D:D>!G$3$%?3#%#%!.D=#.$5$+$4!A#3$.$($3#%!7#%$!A!)'!<br />

D(D%3#($%#! ='(!! .#)G$(3$! -#! =6=636! G$(! 7'=3'!:! +#(A$3#:#=.#)$(B! 26%6%! %#)#%$! )#!<br />

7#%$!A#3$.$($3#%!D(D%3#($%!7'!)'!.#=%030I$3#($%!)'&'!'>!&$I7#%$=!D(D%D%!)'&'!'>!U>#%3#!<br />

D(#.$3$@4!G'>!!)DD=!='3$.#!6%+6(3'(!%!%!:'+=#3#%:#=!D>#(#!A#3$.$($3)$$!=6=6+6!$?$%#!<br />

A$(#G$3:#=.#)$(B!26!%#)#%3#4!7#%$!A#3$.$($3#%!D(D%3#($%!7'!)'!.#=%030I$3#($%!.D=#.$5$3#(!<br />

! CH!


.'('1!%)'%!G#%$:+#%:#+$!-#!='G63!#)$3:#+$!$?$%!D(D%#!='.:'!)##(!$3'-#!#)#(=#%!'7%!!<br />

>':'%)'4! 67A6%36=4! 7#:#! ='3$.#+$! -#! A!)'! AD-#%3$$4! :0)#(%! .D=#.$5$!<br />

A#(#=+$%$:3#($%$%!='(!3'%:'+!!-#!.D=#.$-$7#!$7$!3'%+#!#)$3:#+$!A#(#=:#=.#)$(!NV^PB!!<br />

H'%'.3!!#%)D+.($+$!636+'3!-#!636+3'('('+!!(#='G#.!0(.':!%)'!)$#(!#.!='7%'=3'(!73'!-#!<br />

-#I#.#(7'%! D(D%3#(3#! (#='G#.! #.:#=.#)$(B! 26! 7D=+#=! (#='G#.$%! $-:#+$73#! $3#.:#3#(!<br />

-'(3!=3'(!%!! +D()D(#G$3:#=! $?$%! .D=#.$5$! A#(#=+$%$:3#($%$! ='(!3'7'5'=! 7#%$! D(D%3#(!<br />

A#3$.$(:#3$)$(!NVPB!H'%'.3!!#.3#($!U%5#3#($!.D:!='(='+!&'3$%)#!@'>'('!+6%636(=#%!'(.!=!<br />

.D:! )D%7')'! )##(3$! @'(?'3'(! =#:$=3$! 7'! )'! =#:$=3#($%)#%! '7(!3:!! #.3#(! '7(!! '7(!!<br />

':G'3'I3!! 03'('=! @#('=#%)#! +'.!3'()'! ('G#.! AU(:#=.#)$(B! X#%$! D(D%! A#3$.$(:#%$%!<br />

7'%!! +!('! +#=.U()#! D(#.$:! &'..!%)'! D(D%! ='3$.#+$%$! $7$3#.$($5$4! D(#.$:$! &!>3'%)!(!5!4!<br />

-#($:$! -#! #.=$%3$$! '(.!(!5!! 7#%$! .#=%030I$3#(! =!+'! +D(#)#! ='G63! AU(:#=.#4! G6%'! G'3!!<br />

03'('=!.D=#.$5$7#!)'&'!='3$.#3$!-#!AD-#%3$!D(D%!+'3'%'G$3:#=.#)$(!NVePB!!<br />

;+3!%)'4!='%'.3!!#.$!#%)D+.($+$%)#!.D:!)D%7')'!G6!7U%)#!$3#(3#:#3#(!='7)#)$3:#=.#4!<br />

.'>#! -#! ='.:'! )##(! $3'-#! #)$3:$! 7'! )'! $3#($! $3#%:$! D(D%! ?#$.3$3$$! A$)#(#=!<br />

'(.:'=.')!(! NVePB! 3#($! $3#%:$! D(D%3#($%! GD7D=! ?06%366! +#?$3:$! @'>'(3'()'! '3!5!!<br />

G63:'=.'!-#!)D%7'!A#%#3$%)#!7'7!3!:!!-#!)#$$:$!D3=#)#%!D3=#7#4!G'>#%!D3=#!$?$%)#!<br />

GU3A#)#%! GU3A#7#! 1'(=3!3!=! AU+.#(:#=.#)$(B! 3#($! $3#%:$! ='%'.3!! #.! D(D%3#($!<br />

A#3$.$(:#)#! D?! .#:#3! 6%+6(! U%#:! .'!:'=.')!(Y! .#=%$=! 7#.#(3$3$=4! @'>'(! .'3#@3#($! -#!<br />

&#@+$%)#%!U%#:3$+$!:'3$7#.B!EH'.:'!)##(!$3'-#!#)$3:$F!'%3':!%)'!)'!=63'%!3'%!$3#($!<br />

$3#%:$! D(D%3#($%! A#3$.$($3:#+$%)#! D(D%3#($%! D(#.$:$%)#=$! .#=%$=! 7#.#(3$3$=! U%#:3$!<br />

03+'! )'4! 7#%$! D(D%3#($%! @'>'(3'%:'+!! -#! #=0%0:$=! '?!)'%! '7'=.'! ='3'G$3$(3$$!<br />

)DD%D3)DD%)#!$=$%5$!+!(')'!7#(!'3:'=.')!(!NVZPB!!<br />

H'%'.3!! #%)D+.($+$! $?$%! 7#%$! D(D%3#(! G'3':!%)'! )D%7')'! A!)'! .$5'(#.$%)#! #%! &!>3!!<br />

GD7D7#%! +#A:#%.3#()#%! G$($! 03'%! )0%)6(63:6! &'>!(! 7#:#=! +$+.#:3#($! ='.#A0($+$!<br />

A#3#5#=! -''.! #)#%! G$(! +#=.U()D(B! KD=#.$5$7#! #-! UD%D! $=':#+$! N&0:#! :#'3!<br />

(#@3'5#:#%.P!03'('=!'(>!#)$3#%4!&'>!(3'%:'+!!=03'74!?'G6=4!67A6%!-#!+'3!=3!!D(D%3#(!<br />

$?$%)#!U(%#$%4!:'($%#!.'-6=!AUD+!#.3#($4!1!(!%3'%:!!=!.!(!.'-6=!AUD+!@'(?'!#.3#($!-GB!<br />

D(D%3#(h! &'>!(! U3#! 7#:#$! +#.3#($! A$G$! D(D%3#(! G6! ='.#A0($)#! 7#(! '3!(! NVP! -#!<br />

>':'%+!>3!=4!7#:#=!&'>!(3':'!G#5#($+$%$%!03:':'+!!-#!7#:#=!&'>!(3':'!$+.#=+$>3$$!<br />

A$G$!)6(6:3'()'!.D=#.$5$%$%!$&.$7'?3'(!%'!5#-'@!-#($(B!!<br />

X#(#3!-#!636+'3!@'>'(3'()'!A#3#%#=3#()#%!-#!=D3.D(!#.=$3#($%)#%!='7%'=3'%'%!.D=#.$5$!<br />

A#(#=+$%$:3#($%$! ='(!3':'=! ':'5!73'! .'+'(3'%'%! -#! A#3$.$($3#%! D(D%3#($%! '7%!!<br />

>':'%)'! =D(#+#3! @'>'()'! (#='G#.! @0.'%+$7#3$! G63'G$3#5#$! G$3)$($3:#=.#)$(! NVfPB! 26!<br />

G'3':)'4! .0@36:! $%+'%!%!%!'3!='%3!=3'(!%!!='(!3':'=! -#!)#-':! #..$(:#=! ':'5!73'!<br />

='%'.3!!#.$!D(D%3#($!A#3$.$($3$(=#%!7#%$!D(D%D!7#(#3!D(D%3#(#!#%.#A(#!#)#(#=!A#3$.$(:#=!<br />

)#! '3.#(%'.$1! G$(! 67A63':'! 03'('=! ='(!:!>'! ?!=:'=.')!(B! `3=#:$>)#! G6%6%! G'>!!<br />

U(%#=3#($%$! +#=.U()#! AU(:#=.#7$>B! H'%'.3!! #%)D+.($+$%)#! 7#%$! D(D%! A#3$.$(:#)#!<br />

U>#33$=3#!+'3!=!G$3$%5$%#!+'&$@!:0)#(%!.D=#.$5$!A#(#=+$%$:3#($%$!='(!3':')'!D(D%D%!<br />

+'3!=3!3!!%!!U%!@3'%'!?!='('%!10%=+$70%#3!)0'3!='.=!!:'))#3#($73#!>#%A$%3#.$($3:$!<br />

10%=+$70%#3! D(D%3#($%! A#3$.$($3:#+$! )#! @'>'()'! G''(!! +'3'7'G$3#5#=! '3.#(%'.$1! G$(!<br />

67A63':')!(B!<br />

!<br />

"F,7_$<br />

`(D%!A#3$.$(:#!@(0+#+$!7#%$!1$=$(3#($%!U%#!+D(D3:#+$%)#4!.#+.!:'(=#..#!-#!&'..'!636+'3!<br />

@'>'('!+6%63'%'!=')'(!6>6%!-#!+D(#=3$!AU>)#%!A#?$(:#!A#(#=.$(#%!G$(!@(0+#+.$(B!`(D%!<br />

A#3$.$(:#%$%!&#(!G$(!'':'+!!7#%$!G$(!-#($!0(.'7'!=07'(!-#!D(D%!A#3$.$(:#!.'=!:!%!%!<br />

7#%$)#%! )##(3#%)$(#5#$! )6(6:3'(! AU(D3#G$3$(B! J'>'(! -#! $3#.:#! '%'3$>$! D(D%!<br />

A#3$.$(:#%$%! .D:! '':'3'(!! G076%5'! )#$=#%! .D=#.$5$! '?!+!%)'%! EG#=3#%:#7#%$F!<br />

'(':'=! ')!%'! )#-':! #)#(B! C!)'! #%)D+.($+$%)#=$! A#3$:#3#(! =6=6+6>! =$! .0@36:)'=$!<br />

! CHC


#$3$:3#()#%!U%#:3$!U3?D)#!#.=$3#%$(B!KD=#.$5$%$%!7'':!#=3$%)#=$!)#$$=3$=3#(4!A#3$(!<br />

)D>#7$!-#!='3$.#!1'(=!%)'3!!%!%!'(.:'+!!A$G$!.D:!1'=.U(3#(!D(D%!?#$.3$3$$4!?#=$5$3$$4!<br />

67A6%36=4!-#!+'3!=3!!A!)'3'(!A$G$!#$3$:3#($%!036:'+!%'!%#)#%!036(B!CD%D:D>!='%'.3!!<br />

#.$!#%)D+.($+$!.D=#.$5$!A#(#=+$%$:3#($%$!='(!3'7'5'=!7#%$!N$%0-'.$1P!D(D%3#(!A#3$.$(:#=!<br />

$?$%! ?'G'! +'(1! #.:#=.#)$(B! %0-'+70%)'! D(#.$3#%! 7#%$! 1$=$(3#()#%! G''(!3!! G$(! #=$3)#!<br />

$+.$1')#! #)$3#(#=! @'>'('! .D=#.$5$%$%! G##%#5#$! 7#%$! -#! $7$3#.$($3:$! ='.:'! )##(3$!<br />

D(D%3#(! +6%:'=! .#:#3! ':'?! 03:'3!)!(B! 26! 7'@!3!(=#%! 1$(:'! D+.! 7U%#.$:$%$%! )#+.#$!<br />

'(..!(B! K#:#3! $3#.:#! +.('.#I$+$%$%! 7'%!%)'4! 1$(:'%!%! 7#%$! D(D%! +.('.#I$+$! )#!<br />

036.6(63:'3!! -#! G$3A$! .#=%030I$+$! $3#! D(D%! D(#.$:$4! .'+'(!:! $3#:$%)#! :#(=#>)#!<br />

.6.63'('=!#%!#3-#($3$!=0633'(!+'3'%:'3!)!(B!2''(!3!!G$(!D(D%!A#3$.$(:#!'%5'=4!1$(:'!<br />

?'3!'%3'(!%!%!.D:D%D%!GD.D%3#$=!?'3!'('=!#$.!='.=!3'(!73'!A#(?#=3#.$($3#G$3$(B!<br />

!<br />

%+5,+A-+.$<br />

VB! 2'(G6.4!TBY!J063.(7!:#'.!@(05#++$%A!'%)!@(0)65.!.#5&%030A7B!O%Y!2'(G6.4!TB4!L)B!J063.(7!J(0)65.!<br />

J(05#++$%AY!;%!O%)6+.(7!C6$)#B!j"j!J(#++4!205'!"'.0%4!*i4!d[[dhVbdWB!<br />

dB! 2LTcb2"BY!2#7'>!L.!T'%'7$5$3#($!-#!c':!>3!=?!3'(!2$(3$$!H'%'.3!!T#=.U(D!m>#.!"'@0(6B!d[[Z!<br />

NQQQBG#+)bG$(B0(APB!!<br />

]B! L6(0@#'%!j0::$++$0%B!T5$#%5#4!.#5&%030A7!'%)!$%%0-'.$0%!$%!L6(0@#B!i6M#:G6(AY!R11$5#!10(!<br />

R11$5$'3!J(6G3$5'.$0%+!01!L6(0@#'%!j0::6%$.$#+4!d[[fB!<br />

gB! j'@$.'%$04! *B4! j0@@03'4! ;B4! J'+5655$4! TBY! J(0)65.! '%)! @(05#++! $%%0-'.$0%! $%! .&#! O.'3$'%! 100)!<br />

$%)6+.(7B!;A($G6+$%#++4!d[V[h!de!NgPY!^[]b^VfB!<br />

^B! 2'=.!(4! LBY! X#%$3#$:!0(.':!%!%!+'3'%:'+!4!.#=%030I$!-#!7#%$!D(D%!A#3$.$(:#B!k#(?#-#4!d[[Wh!<br />

VVfbVdVB!!<br />

eB! K,HBY!2'G'='%3!=!KD(=$7#!+.'.$+.$=!H6(6:6!\'G#(!2D3.#%$B!d[[W!7!3!!'('.!(:'!-#!A#3$.$(:#!<br />

1''3$7#.3#($!'('.!(:'+!4!+'7!Y!VfW4!VV!H'+!:!d[V[B!<br />

ZB! L'(3#4! 9B4! L'(3#4! "B4! ;%)#(+0%4! ;BY! *00)! J(0)65.! c#-#30@:#%.4! a00)&#')! J6G3B! i.)B4!<br />

j':G($)A#4!d[[VB!<br />

fB! j0+.'! 4! ;BOB;B4! w0%A#%4! aB9B*BY! n#Q! $%+A&.+! $%.0! 50%+6:#(b3#)! 100)! @(0)65.! )#-#30@:#%.B!<br />

K(#%)+!$%!*00)!T5$B!K#5&%B4!d[[eh!VZY!g^Zbge^B!<br />

WB! *633#(4!CBaB!n#Q!*00)!J(0)65.!c#-#30@:#%.Y!*(0:!j0%5#@.!.0!9'(=#.@3'5#B!j"j!J(#++4!205'!<br />

"'.0%4!*i4!VWWgB!<br />

V[B! T.('6+4! KBY! K&#! n#Q! @(0)65.! +655#++! #S6'.$0%Y! G6$3)$%A! +655#++! $%.0! .&#! %#Q! @(0)65.!<br />

)#-#30@:#%.!@(05#++B!O%Y!90+=0Q$.>4!\B"B4!T'A674!OBTB!T.('6+4!KB4!L)+B4!;%!O%.#A('.#)!;@@(0'5&!.0!n#Q!<br />

*00)!J(0)65.!c#-#30@:#%.4!j"j!J(#++4!205'!"'.0%4!*i4!d[[Wh!]bdgB!<br />

VVB! *65&+4!jB4!T5&(#$#(4!9BY!j6+.0:#(!#:@0Q#(:#%.!$%!%#Q!@(0)65.!)#-#30@:#%.B!wB!J(0)B!O%%0-B!<br />

9'%'AB4!!d[VVh!dfY!VZb]dB$<br />

VdB! ;3@.#=$%! TBLB4! K03A'4! LBY! `(D%! A#3$.$(:#! +D(#5$%)#! ?0=! ':'?3!! ='('(! -#(:#! 7'=3'!:!B! K`!!<br />

c#(A$+$_c!9D&#%)$+3$=4$d[[eh!^NePY!V^bdeB!<br />

V]B! 9'..++0%4! wBY! *00)! @(0)65.! )#-#30@:#%.Y! ;! 50%+6:#(b3#)! .#M.! '%'37.$5! '@@(0'5&! .0! A#%#('.#!<br />

@(#1#(#%5#!+.(65.6(#+B!d[[Z4!2($.$+&!*00)!wBh!V[WN]PY!dgebd^WB!<br />

VgB! C(6%#(.4! HBCBY! *6.6(#! .(#%)+! '%)! 50%+6:#(! 3$1#+.73#+! Q$.&! (#A'()! .0! :#'.! 50%+6:@.$0%B! 9#'.!<br />

T5$B4!d[[^h!Zgh!VgWbVe[B!<br />

V^B! )#!2'(5#330+!9BcB4!HDA3#(4!wBRB4!C(6%#(.4!HBCB4!a#>#:'#34!iB8B4!J#(#>bj6#.04!*BwB;B4!,#3'%)4!<br />

RB4!8#(G#=#4!aBY!L6(0@#'%!50%+6:#(+


" #CZ $?+@7A$>GO'$@&$D71$B1(,/&,$V+'1!.)+$b.&1()$i-+,+!$<br />

@.++%9%0%#%"+)L.$)@'+#!$7')@$.81-#%.&)L$.7)63%-


D(D%3#($%$%! 1$7'.3'(!%!%! 7D=+#=! 0366! %#)#%$73#! G#+3#%:#! )#! 5$))$! G$(! @(0.#$%! '?!!!<br />

G636%:'=.')!(B!<br />

m.#! 7'%)'%! =!(:!>!! #.#! =!7'+3'! )'&'! 7D=+#=! @(0.#$%4! )'&'! )DD=! 7'! -#! #%#(I$!<br />

$?#($$%#! +'&$@! =03'7! +$%)$($3#G$3$(! U>#33$=.#=$! .'-6=! #.$%$%! D3=#:$>)#=$! D(#.$:!<br />

@0.'%+$7#3$! $+#! G$(! &'73$! 7D=+#=.$(B! 2$($:! G'!%'! #3)#! #)$3#%! #.! -#($:$%$%! 03)6=?'!<br />

7D=+#=!03:'+!!%#)#%$73#!)'&'!656>!1$7'.3'!@'>'(3'%'G$3#%!G6!#.$%!NH03+'(!5!!C8G!VWW]P!<br />

D3=#:$>)#=$! .D=#.$:! 0('%!! $+#! =!(:!>!! #.#! AU(#! )DD=.D(! N;%0%$:! d[VVPB! 26!<br />

G'3':)'4!.'-6=!#.$%$%!+#-#(#=!.D=#.$3#%!-#!.D(=!.0@36:6%6%!)':'=!.')!%'!&$.'@!#)#%!<br />

G$(! #.! D(D%D! 03'%! @'+.!(:'7'! $3#%#(#=! .'-6=! #.$! .D=#.$:$%$%! -#! 7'%!!+!('! #.! D(D%D!<br />

?#$.3$3$$%$%!)#!'(.!(!3:'+!!7'@!3'%!G6!7#%$!D(D%!A#3$.$(:#!?'3!:'+!%!%!.#:#3!':'5!%!!<br />

036.6(:'=.')!(B!<br />

X#%$! #.! -#! #.! D(D%3#($! A#3$.$(:#=! $?$%! .#:#3)#! D?! +.('.#I$! +U>! =0%6+6)6(! Nw$:#%#>!<br />

j03:#%#(0!d[[Vh!;($&'('!d[[ePB!<br />

VP!H'(='+!=0:@0>$+70%6%6%!:0)$1$='+70%6!<br />

dP!k$!#.!:'.#(7'3$%$%!:'%$@D3'+70%6!<br />

]P!L.!D(D%3#($%$%!7#%$)#%!10(:D3'+70%6!<br />

26! ?'3!:')'4! ]B! .#:#3! +.('.#I$! )0(63.6+6%)'! =6(64! =D(3#%:$4! A#3#%#=+#3! ?$! #.!<br />

D(D%3#($:$>)#%! 03'%! -#! 7'@!:!%)'! ='+'@3!=! +!!(4! )'%'! -#! :'%)'! #.3#($! =633'%!3'%!<br />

@'+.!(:'7'!'3.#(%'.$1!03'('=!N;=+6!"#)'0G!d[[^h!CU=!"#)'0G)d[[fh!H$3$5!d[[Wh!KTV[ZVP4!<br />

=!(:!>!!#.!7#($%#!.'-6=!#.$!=633'%!3'('=!D(D%!10(:D3'+70%6!7#%$)#%!)D>#%3#%:$!.'-6=!<br />

@'+.!(:'+!! D(#.$:$! A#(?#=3#.$($3:$.$(B! H!(:!>!! #.#!=!7'+3'! )'&'! )DD=! 7'! $3#!<br />

=03#+.#(03!$?#($$%#!+'&$@!-#!)'&'!7D=+#=!0('%)'!?0=36!)07:':!!7'!'+$)$!$?#(#%!#.!<br />

0('%!! 7D=+#=!@($:#(! @'(?'3'()'%! .'-6=! AUD+!-#!.'-6=!G6.!#.$%$%!&'::'))#!03'('=!<br />

@'+.!(:'! D(#.$:$%)#! =633'%!3'G$3$(3$$! '('.!(!3:!! -#! $=$! 1'(=3!! 0('%)'! .6>! $?#(#%! =D(!<br />

='(!!:!!$3#!=D(3#%:$!@'+.!(:'3'(!%!D(#.$:!@(0+#+$!G076%5'!7'@!+!%)'=$!)#$$:3#(!$3#!<br />

+0%!D(D%!='3$.#+$!$%5#3#%:$.$(B!!<br />

!<br />

c+1&.5+-$0&$c&1F1$<br />

J'+.!(:'!D(#.$:$%)#!:'.#(7'3!03'('=$2#7@$!2#7@'>'(!!K'(!:+'3!`(#.$:!J'>'(3':'!-#!<br />

T'%'7$!K$5'(#.!;BB$%5$($!=!(!3:')'%!3'G0('.6-'('!A#.$($3#%!<br />

AU(D%D(! 7'3'(!%)'%! -#! =#:$=3#($%)#%! '7(!3:!! .'-6=! AUD+! -#! G6.! #.3#($!<br />

=633'%!3:!.!(B! J'+.!(:'3'(! A#3#%#=+#3! 7U%.#:3#! D(#.$3:$! -#! $=$! 1'(=3!! 0('%)'! .6>!<br />

$?#(#%!=D(!='(!!:!%!%!NHHP!Nt]!-#!tg4^P!D(D%!='3$.#+$!D>#($%#!#.=$+$!$%5#3#%:$.$(B!<br />

;('.!(:'! ='@+':!%)'! #.3#(4!K'G30!V70%6! $?$%! rg!<br />

0 j


!<br />

K'G30!VB!*'(=3!!0('%)'!.6>!$?#($$%#!+'&$@!=D(!='(!!:3'(!%)'!!<br />

=633'%!3'%!=D(!:'))#3#($!-#!0('%3'(!!<br />

!! HD(3#:#!:'))#3#($!NA_=A!#.P!<br />

!! C36=0> T'=='(0> n'nR d K6>!<br />

CUD+!#.$!b!t]É3D=!=D(!='(!!:!! V! V! [BV^! dZBf^<br />

CUD+!#.$!b!tg4^É36=!=D(!='(!!:! V! V! [BV^! gdBf^<br />

26.!#.$!b!t]É3D=!=D(!='(!!:!! V! V! [BV^! dZBf^<br />

26.!#.$!b!tg4^É36=!=D(!='(!!:!! V! V! [BV^! gdBf^<br />

$<br />

K'G30!dB$J'+.!(:'!D(#.$:$%)#!=633'%!3'%!?#:#%!&':6(6!10(:D3'+70%6!<br />

! 267!0.6!6%6! T'(!:+'=! H!(:!>!!G$G#(! T6!<br />

k#:#%!&':6(6!10(:D3'+70%6!NA_=A!#.P! V[[! Z[! ][! ][[!<br />

!<br />

D7-67-+.$<br />

*'(=3!!$=$!GU3A#!#.$%)#%!1'(=3!!0('%)'!.6>!$?#(#%!=D(!='(!!:3'(!!=633'%!3'('=!D(#.$3#%!<br />

.'-6=!@'+.!(:'3'(!%!%!G#+$%+#3!G$3#$:$%#!-#!K2;!)##($%#!$3$=$%!+0%6?3'(!K'G30!]#33$=3#! 03A6%3':'! G'+':'!%)'! A#(?#=3##%! -#! D(D%#!<br />

='('=.#($+.$=!'(0:'7!!='>'%)!('%!.#:#3!(#'=+$70%3'()'%!G$($+$)$(!NH'G'%!d[[WPB!K'-6=!<br />

@'+.!(:'3'(!%)'! 0=+$)'+70%! )D>#7$! &'==!%)'! G$3A$! -#(#%! K2;! )##(3#($%#! $3$=$%!<br />

+0%6?3'(! K'G30! ]4!=D3!$?#($$!-#!iy4!'y4!Gy!(#%=!<br />

)##(3#($%#! $3$=$%! )#$$:3#(! D(#.$:$%! .6>3':'! NgBAD%P4! =6(6.:'! NV[BAD%P! -#!<br />

?#:#%3#:#b=6(6.:'!NV^BAD%P!'':'3'(!%!%!+0%!AD%3#($%)#!'3!%'%!U(%#=3#()#!7'@!3'%!<br />

'%'3$>3#(3#! $%5#3#%:$.$(B! tg4^!<br />

$?#($$!+0%!D(D%)#!0(.'3':'!te4ZV4!G6.!@'+.!(:'+!%!%!.6>!$?#($$!$+#!0(.'3':'!tZBe^!<br />

03'('=! G#3$(3#%:$.$(! N@s[B[^PB! X'%!! +!('! tgB^! $?#($$! )'&'! 7D=+#=! G636%:6.6(! N@s[B[^PB! KT! V[ZV!$?#($$!:'=+$:6:!tf4^!03:'3!)!(!-#!.'-6=!@'+.!(:'3'(!%!%!&#(!G$($%)#!<br />

+0%!D(D%)#!G#3$(3#%#%!.6>!$?#($$!G6!=($.#(#!67A6%)6(B!2'3'%A!?.'!AUD+!#.$%)#!tVBVW!<br />

-#! G6.! #.$%)#! t[BW^! 03'('=! G#3$(3#%#%! =D3! $?#($$! D(#.$:$%! +0%6%)'! NV^BAD%P! AUD+!<br />

! CHT


@'+.!(:'+!%)'! 0(.'3':'! teBVf! -#! G6.! @'+.!(:'+!%)'! tZBdW! 03'('=! G636%:6.6(! -#!<br />

$+.'.$+.$=!03'('=!U%#:3$!G636%'%!G$(!'(.!!AU+.#(:$.$(!N@z[4[^PB$<br />

!<br />

K'G30! ]B! J'+.!(:'! D(#.$:$%)#! =633'%!3'%! &'::'))#%$%! -#! D(#.$:! +0%6%)'! #3)#!<br />

#)$3#%! AUAD+! -#! G6.! @'+.!(:'3'(!%!%! G#+$%+#3! G$3#$:$%#! -#! K2;! )##($%#! $3$=$%!<br />

+0%6?3'(!<br />

! !t!n#:! t!J(0.#$%! t!X'!<br />

! CHW<br />

K2;! N:A! 9;_=A!<br />

U(%#=P!<br />

! [B!AD% V^B!AD% [B!AD% V^B!AD% [B!AD% V^B!AD% [B!AD%! V^B!AD%!<br />

CUD+!#.$!bt]! ZdBZ^! gVBW^! dfBdZ! ggB[e! VBe^! ]BZe! [Bef! dB]g!<br />

CUD+!#.$!btgB^ ZdBZ^! geB^^! dfBdZ! ggB]Z! VBe^! ]Bff! [Bef! dBVd!<br />

26.!#.$!b!t]! Z[BVe! ]WBgf! deBZ[! g^BZ]! dBeZ! ZB]^! [BZf! ]BV^!<br />

26.!#.$!b!tgB^! Z[BVe! g[B^[! deBZ[! gVBZe! dBeZ! ZB[]! [BZf! gBdZ!<br />

!<br />

CUD+! @'+.!(:'+!%!%! iy! N'?!=3!=b=07636=P4! 'y! N=!(:!>!3!=P!-#!Gy!N+'(!3!=P! )##(3#($!<br />

+!('+!73'!0(.'3':'!]WBV[4!dBd]-#!gBZg!03'('=!G6.!@'+.!(:'+!%!%!iy4!'y!-#!Gy!)##(3#($!<br />

)#! +!('+!73'! 0(.'3':'! ]ZBVf4! ^B]^! -#! gBdf! 03'('=! G#3$(3#%:$.$(B! \#(! $=$! @'+.!(:'!<br />

'('+!%)'=$! 1'(=! iy! -#! 'y! )##(3#($! '?!+!%)'%! $+.'.$+.$=! 03'('=! 1'(=3!! G636%6(=#%!<br />

N@z[B[^P4!Gy!)##(3#($!'('+!%)'=$!1'(=!U%#:+$>)$(!N@s[4[^PB!;7(!5'!D(#.$:$%!gBh!V[B!-#!<br />

V^B!AD%3#($%)#!)#!U3?D3#%!(#%=!)##(3#($%)#!$+.'.$+.$=!03'('=!1'(=3!3!=3'(!G#3$(3#%:$.$(!<br />

N@z[B[^PB!k#:#%3#:#!'':'+!%)'%!+0%('!D(D%3#($%!'y!)##(3#($%)#!'(.!!AU>3#%$(=#%4!<br />

iy!-#!Gy!)##(3#($%)#!'>'3!!G#3$(3#%:$.$(B!<br />

`(D%)#! '(>6! #)$3#%! =D(! (#%A$%$! 036.6(:'=! -#! :$=(0G$7#3! AD-#%3$$! +'3':'=!<br />

':'5!73'! =633'%!3'%! %$.($.4! 1'>3'! =633'%!3)!!! )6(6:3'()'! %$.(0>'+70%! (#'=+$70%6!<br />

+0%656! %$.(0>':$%! 0366:6%'! ='.!3:'=.')!(! N*#(A6+0%! d[V[PB! 26! %#)#%3#! D(D%)#=$!<br />

='3!%.!!%$.($.!:$=.'(!!U%#:3$)$(!-#!G6!:$=.'(!KT!V[ZV)#! D(#.$:! &'5:$! 7D=+#=! '%5'=! .D=#.$:! 0('%!! 03)6=?'! )DD=! 03'%! .'-6=! #.$!<br />

=!(:!>!!#.#!=!7'+3'!)DD=!7'!-#!#%#(I$!$?#($$%#!+'&$@.$(B!;7(!5'!G$3#$:)#=$!#3>#:!<br />

':$%0!'+$.3#(4!2!A(6G6!-$.':$%3#($4!)#:$(!-#!10+10(4!=03'7!+$%)$($3#G$3$(!U>#33$=.#=$!G6!<br />

#.$! +'3!=3!! -#!)#%A#3$! G#+3#%:#! $?$%! U%#:3$! =!3:'=.')!(B!26!%#)#%3#!G6! ?'3!:'! $3#!<br />

A#3#%#=+#3!@'+.!(:'7'!'3.#(%'.$1!03'('=!.'-6=!@'+.!(:'+!%!%!D(#.$:!03'%'!!'('.!(!3:!!<br />

-#!G''(!3!!+0%6?3'(!#3)#!#)$3:$.$(B!cDD=!=03#+.#(03!$?#($$%#!+'&$@4!)07:':!!7'!<br />

'+$)$!0('%!!7D=+#=!.'-6=!G6.!-#!AUD+!#.$!=633'%!:!73'!A#3#%#=+#3!@'+.!(:'7'!=!7'+3'!


)'&'!)DD=!7'!$?#($$%#!+'&$@!D(D%3#($%!#3)#+$!:D:=D%)D(B!tg4^)#!&#:!='%'.3!!#.$!D(D%3#($%$%!?#$.3#%)$($3:#+$!&#:!)#!<br />

='%'.3!! #.$! .D=#.$:! 0('%!%!%! '(.!(!3:'+!! ':'5!73'! U%#:3$! G$(! ')!:! 03'5'!!<br />

)DD%D3:#=.#)$(B!<br />

!<br />

K'G30! gB! `(#.$:$%! .6>3':'! NgBAD%P4! =6(6.:'! NV[BAD%P! -#! ?#:#%3#:#b=6(6.:'!<br />

NV^BAD%P!'':'3'(!%)'!.'-6=!@'+.!(:'3'(!%)'!AU>3#%#%!G$70=$:7'+'3!)#$$:3#(!<br />

!! !! CUD+! 26.! !!<br />

!! !! t]É3D=!HH tgB^É3$=!HH t]É3D=!HH tgB^É3$=!HH R(.'3':'!<br />

gB!AD%! ^Bfd! eBVZ! eB][! eBdW! eBV^!<br />

@\!)##($! V[BAD%! ^BWg! eB[d! eB]f! eB]^! eBVZ!<br />

V^BAD%! ^BWe! eB[^! eBde! eBd[! eBVd!<br />

R(.'3':'!<br />

! ^BWV )1 ! eB[f 51 ! eB]V # ! eBdf # ! eBV^!<br />

!! eB[[ G ! eB][ ' ! !!<br />

gB!AD%! ZB[V! fBfd! eB[W! ZBde! ZB][ & !<br />

t!K6>! V[BAD%! V[Bf]! V]BV]! V[Bge! V]B^Z! VdB[[ A !<br />

V^BAD%! ^BWW! ZBg]! eBZZ! fB^d! ZBVf & !<br />

gB!AD%! gB^V! ^B]Z! ]B^]! ^BgW! gBZ] & !<br />

t!HD3! V[BAD%! ]BgW! gBg^! ^BgV! ^B]V! gBeZ & !<br />

V^BAD%! eB[g! eB]V! eBd[! fB]Z! eBZ] A !<br />

gB!AD%! gWBfZ! gfB[W! gZBWe! g^BZ^! gZBWd A !<br />

iy!)##($! V[BAD%! ]eB]d! ]gBeW! ]]BgW! ]gBgZ! ]gBZg & !<br />

V^BAD%! ]dB^]! ]]B[Z! ]VBgf! dWBW]! ]VBZ^I!<br />

R(.'3':'!<br />

! ]WB^Z! ]fBed! ]ZBeg! ]eBZd! ]fBVg!<br />

!! ]WBV[ ' ! ]ZBVf G ! !!<br />

gB!AD%! [B^W! VBV[! ]BWV! gBgW! dB^d I !<br />

'y!)##($! V[BAD%! VBf]! dB]W! gBWf! eB][! ]Bff & !<br />

V^BAD%! gBVd! ]B]V! ^B^^! eBfe! gBWe A !<br />

R(.'3':'!<br />

! dBVf 1 ! dBdZ 1 ! gBfV )# ! ^Bff 5# ! ]BZW!<br />

!! dBd] G ! ^B]^'!<br />

!!<br />

gB!AD%! VBgd! dBgf! VB[e! dB^]! VBfZ I !<br />

Gy!)##($! V[BAD%! eBdd! ^BW]! eB]V! eB^]! eBd^A!<br />

V^BAD%! ^BZ]! eBe^! gBfg! gB]W! ^Bg[ & !<br />

R(.'3':'!<br />

! gBge! ^B[d! gB[Z! gBgf! gB^V!<br />

!! gBZg! gBdf! !!<br />

'4!GY!*'(=3!!&'(13#($!.'!7'%!GU3A#!#.3#($!'('+!%)'=$!1'(=!$+.'.$+.$=!03'('=!U%#:3$)$(!N@z[B[^PB!<br />

54! )Y! ;7%!! GU3A#! #.$%)#! 1'(=3!! &'(13#($! .'!7'%! 1'(=3!! 0('%)'! .6>! $?#(#%! =D(! ='(!!:3'(!! '('+!%)'=$! 1'(=!<br />

$+.'.$+.$=!03'('=!U%#:3$)$(!N@z[B[^PB!<br />

#4! 1Y! ;7%!! 0('%)'! .6>! $?#(#%! =D(! ='(!!:!%)'! 1'(=3!! &'(13#($! .'!7'%! GU3A#! #.3#($! '('+!%)'=$! 1'(=! $+.'.$+.$=!<br />

03'('=!U%#:3$)$(!N@z[B[^PB!<br />

A4!&4!IY!*'(=3!!&'(13#($!.'!7'%!AD%3#(!'('+!%)'=$!1'(=!$+.'.$+.$=!03'('=!U%#:3$)$(!N@z[B[^PB!<br />

$<br />

! CHZ


CU(D%D<br />

V[4[[<br />

f4[[<br />

C#%#3!2##%$<br />

e4[[<br />

g4[[<br />

d4[[<br />

[4[[<br />

"#%=<br />

t]!HHbCUD+!#.$<br />

tg4^!HHbCUD+!#.$<br />

t]!HHb26.!#.$<br />

tg4^!HHb26.!#.$<br />

K#=+.D(<br />

H0=6<br />

i#>>#.<br />

#=$3! VB! *'(=3!! 0('%)'! .6>! $?#(#%! =D(! ='(!!:!! -#! $=$! 1'(=3!! GU3A#! #.$! =633'%!3'('=!<br />

D(#.$3#%!.'-6=!@'+.!(:'3'(!%'!'$.!)676+'3!'%'3$>!+0%6?3'(!$<br />

!<br />

%+5,+A-+.$<br />

;%0%$:Y!"0@U(.'IbH#+=$%036B!L($$:!.'($&$Y!V^B[]Bd[VV!QQQBA$)'&$I7#%$B50:!<br />

;R;jBY! R11$5$'3! 9#.&0)+! 01! ;%'37+$+B! ;++05$'.$0%! 01! R11$5$'3! ;%'37.$5'3! j&#:$+.+B! O;j4! ;(3$%A.0%4!<br />

8$(A$%$'B!d[[[B$<br />

;($&'('4!HBY!T.('.#A$#+!10(!)#+$A%$%A!%0-#3!16%5.$0%'3!:#'.!@(0)65.+B!9#'.!T5$#%5#4!d[[eh!ZgY!dVWbddWB!!<br />

;=+64! 9BB4! H'7'4! 9B4! R5=#(:'%4! \BaBY! L11#5.! 01! :0)$1$#)! '.:0+@&#(#! @'5='A$%A4! +.0('A#! @#($0)4! '%)!<br />

+.0('A#!.#:@#('.6(#!0%!.&#!(#+$)6'3!%$.('.#!01!+3$5#)b@'+.!(:'4!)(7!:#'.!@(0)65.4!@(0)65#)!1(0:!1(#+&!:#'.!<br />

'%)!1(0>#%_.&'Q#)!:#'.B!*00)!j&#:$+.(74!d[[]h!W]Y!d]ZbdgdB!<br />

2$#+'3+=$4!\BHBY!9#'.!'+!'!50:@0%#%.!01!'!&#'3.&7!)$#.!p!'(#!.&#(#!'%7!($+=+!0(!G#%#1$.+!$1!:#'.!$+!'-0$)#)!$%!<br />

.&#!)$#.q!9#'.!T5$#%5#4!d[[^h!Z[Y!^[Wb^dgB!<br />

*#(A6+0%4!iB"BY!9#'.!'%)!5'%5#(B!9#'.!T5$#%5#4!d[V[h!fgY!][fb]V]B!<br />

CU=4! 8B4! RG6>4! LB4! ;=='7'4! iBY! L11#5.+! 01! @'5='A$%A! :#.&0)! '%)! +.0('A#! .$:#! 0%! .&#! 5&#:$5'34!<br />

:$5(0G$030A$5'34! '%)! +#%+0(7! @(0@#(.$#+! 01! K6(=$+&! @'+.$(:'! p! ;! )(7! 56(#)! G##1! @(0)65.B! 9#'.! T5$#%5#4!<br />

d[[fh!f[Y!]]^b]ggB!<br />

w$:#%#>bj03:#%#(04! *B4! j'(G'3304! wB4! j01(')#+4! TBY! \#'3.&$#(! :#'.! '%)! :#'.! @(0)65.+Y! .&#$(! (03#! '+!<br />

16%5.$0%'3!100)+B!9#'.!T5$#%5#4!d[[Vh!^WY!^bV]B!<br />

H'G'%4!CBY!j&'%A#+!$%!.&#!50:@0+$.$0%!01!-03'.$3#!50:@06%)+!'%)!$%!:$5(0G$030A$5'3!'%)!@&7+$505&#:$5'3!<br />

@'(':#.#(+!)6($%A!@'+.!(:'!@(05#++$%AB!9#'.!T5$#%5#4!d[[Wh!fdY!VZbd]B!<br />

H#+$5$4!KB4!H05'G'4!lBY!2$70$+.'.$+.$=B!;%='('!`%$-#(+$.#+$!L5>'5!3!=!*'=D3.#+$!X'7!%3'(!B!;%='('4!KD(=$7#B!<br />

d[[ZB!<br />

H$3$54!2BY!j6((#%.!.(#%)+!$%!.(')$.$0%'3!K6(=$+&!:#'.!@(0)65.+!'%)!56$+$%#B!*00)!T5$#%5#!'%)!K#5&%030A74!<br />

d[[Wh!gdY!V^fVbV^fWB!<br />

H03+'(!5!4! nB4! K6(&'%4! HB4! '&$%4! 9BLBY! K#=%030I$=! $3#:3#($%! ='%'.3!! #.3#($%$%! G#+3#:#! )##($%#! #.=$+$B!<br />

,36+3'('('+!!K'-6=?636=!H0%A(#+$!2$3)$($!H$.'G!4!VWW]h!^[db^VfB!<br />

K'(3')A$+4!2BCB4!a'..+4!2B9B4!X06%'.&'%4!9BKB4!c6A'%4!w(BiBY!;!)$+.$33'.$0%!:#.&0)!10(!.&#!)#.#(:$%'.$0%!<br />

01!:'30%'3)#&7)#!$%!('%5$)!100)+B!w06(%'3!01!K&#!;:#($5'%!R$3!j&#:$+.+


" #C] $%7-7_A+/+$B);.(5F$%F,1.F--&.($@&$V.F;-&)$:,+-(9-&.($<br />

K79$(.)63"-!7'@:'=!D>#(#!=636?='!'('G'3'(!%!%!#%!D+.4!0(.'!-#!#%!'3.!<br />

GU3D:3#($%)#%!03:'=!D>#(#!]!%6:6%#!.#@+$!+#?$%$>B!!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

ç! K('%+1#(!+!('+!%)'!!!=3'!:6'7#%#!$3#!<br />

GD.D%!)U3+D>3#($!'7!=3'7!%!>B!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

ç! 26!.#@+$3#($!=636?='!?!=!!%)'!$>3#:#=!D>#(#!$'(#.3#7$%$>B!!<br />

! CJ#


!<br />

L:G($70!H0%.(033#($!xH!('('=B!!!!<br />

!<br />

cU3+D>!<br />

X6:6(.'!&D5(#+$!+'(!%!%!D>#($%)#!G#7'>!<br />

G#%#=!03'('=!AU(D3:#=.#)$(!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

cU33D!N#(=#%!)U%#:P!<br />

T@#(:!76:6(.'!$3#!G$(3#:$!-#!#:G($70!<br />

#=$33#%:$!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

L:G($70!H0%.(033#($!xH!('('=! X6:6(.'!H'G6=!c$$!#=$33#%:$!<br />

!<br />

96&.#:#3!T#G#@3#(Y!<br />

! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !<br />

b!c#@03'%'!-#7'!n'=3$7#!H0633'(!%!%!HU.D!R3:'+!!Nd!AD%P!!<br />

b!O+!!NH'@!3'(!%!L(=#%!;?!3:'+!P!<br />

b!cU%)D(:#%$%!#=+$=3$$!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

L:G($70!H0%.(033#($!xH!('('=


!<br />

fB!CD%! V[B!CD%! VdB!CD%! V^B!CD%!<br />

96&.#:#3!T#G#@3#(Y!<br />

! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !<br />

b!O+!!<br />

b!\'-'3'%)!(:'4!U(%#$%!WB56!AD%)#%!+0%('!jR d 3$$_7'3!!+D(D3#(#!7'%3!!67A63':'3'(!<br />

!<br />

ë!G6%3'(!#%!$7$!03'('=!76:6(.'3'(!%!!!=3'!:6'7#%#+$%)#!AU(D3D(B!<br />

!<br />

L:G($70!H0%.(033#($!xH!('('=3#%#G$3:#+$!$?$%!.#@+$3#($!$'(#.3#7$%$>!!<br />

ç! !263A63'(!!$3#7#!G$3:#=!$?$%!G$(!76:6(.'!=!(:'!='(.3'(!!=633'%!%!>!!<br />

X6:6(.'!=!(:'!='(.3'(!!U(%#$!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

! CJC


!<br />

L:G($70!H0%.(033#($!xH!('('=$+70%6%6!<br />

'3:!B!<br />

T'(!!=#+#+$!<br />

$?#($!<br />

?#=$3:#7#!<br />

G'3':!!<br />

96&.#:#3!+#G#@3#(!<br />

-! O+!%!%!7D=+#=3$$!<br />

-! "6.6G#.$%!7D=+#=3$$_\'-'3'%)!(:'%!%!7#.#(+$>3$$!!<br />

! ! X#.#(+$>!+6!='7G!!_!XD=+#=!jR Ä !<br />

!<br />

!<br />

T'(!!=#+#+$!%#(#)#7+#!<br />

.':':#%!$?#($!<br />

?#=$3:$!)6(6:)'!<br />

! CJH


L:G($70!H0%.(033#($!xH!('('=$!<br />

X6:6(.'!=!(:'!='(.!U(%#$!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

L:G($70!H0%.(033#($!xH!('('=


!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

k0=!+'7!)'!)U3+D>!76:6(.'!<br />

H!(!3'%!X6:6(.'3'(!<br />

8#($3#($%!A#%#3!#$3$:$%$%!$%5#3#%:#+$!<br />

L(=#%!!cU%#:!_!R(.'!cU%#:!_!C#?!cU%#:!m3D:3#($%!<br />

A#3$:#+$!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

L:G($70!H0%.(033#($!xH!('('=6%!R3:'+!!<br />

!<br />

! CJN


!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

H'%'.!.D73#($!6>':!!<br />

=6(6:'!<br />

! X06%!:#=0%76:!G$($=:#+$!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

V.F;-&)$:,+-(9($rl(@


!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

K'&($G'.'!%#3#($%!703!'?.!!!<br />

$%5#3#%:#3$!-#!.#+@$.!#)$3:#3$!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

! CJW


!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

K'&($G'.'!%#3#($%!703!'?.!!!$%5#3#%:#3$!-#!.#+@$.!#)$3:#3$!<br />

!<br />

K'&($G'.'!%#3#($%!703!'?.!!!$%5#3#%:#3$!-#!.#+@$.!#)$3:#3$!<br />

! CJZ


!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

J(0G3#:!;%'3$>$!xj$-5$-3#('(:!!;7'=!2$3#$!NL>$3:#P!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

96&.#:#3!+#G#@Y!j$-5$-3#($%!7D=+#=.#%!)D:#+$!<br />

!!<br />

! CJ]


96&.#:#3!+#G#@Y!j$-5$-3#($%!%'=$3!&'..!%)'!+!=!:'+!!<br />

!<br />

J(0G3#:!;%'3$>$!xj$-5$-3#('(:!!'7'=!G$3#$!x+!7(!=!'!(3!=!='7G!!<br />

!<br />

! CN#


J(0G3#:!;%'3$>$!xj$-5$-3#($!xj$-5$-3#(


" #H# $?O.A(5&$L(,/($"&A1G.O,O,$2O,Oh$D76O,Oh$`+.!,!$@&$>&-&3'! .#(5$&! #)$3$70(B! 2#+3#%:#!<br />

=0%6+6%)'! 7'! -#! =03#+.#(03! )D>#7$! )DD=! 03'%4! $3#($! $3#%:$! #.! D(#.$:$%#! 67A6%!<br />

7'@!)'=$!&$%)$!#.$%#!03'%!.'3#@!)$#(!D3=#3#()#!03)66!A$G$!D3=#:$>)#!)#!+0%!7!33'()'!<br />

A$)#(#=!'(.:'=.')!(B!T'3!=3!!-#!G#+3#7$5$!G$(!#.!-#(:#+$!&$%)$!7#.$.$($5$3$$%$!)D%7')'!<br />

03)66!A$G$!KD(=$7##3!+#=.U(#!'$.!<br />

$3=! &$%)$! #.$! D(#.#%! #%.#A(#! 1$(:'%!%! 2036)#! +#=.U(D%! $&('5''.! '%+!! 03:'=3'! G#('G#(! D(#.$:! :'3$7#.3#($%$%! 7D=+#=!<br />

03:'+!! %#)#%$73#! )#-3#.! )#+.#=3#($73#! :D:=D%)D(B! X#:! &':! :'))#! :'3$7#.3#($%$%!<br />

7D=+#=!03:'+!4!AD:(D=!-#(A$!0('%3'(!%!%!7D=+#=!03:'+!4!$&('5'.!='@!3'(!%!%!?06%6%!<br />

='@'3!! 03:'+!! +#=.U(D%! G'3!5'! +0(6%3'(!)!(B! c#-3#.$%! D(#.$5$3#($! G'>!! )DD=! 1'$>3$!<br />

$3#.:#! =(#)$3#($! $3#! )#+.#=3#:#3#($! +#=.U(D%! U%D%D! '?'5'=.!(B! ! ! 26! #=$3)#!<br />

D3=#:$>)#=$! =$$! G'!%'! 7!33!=! .D=#.$:! ;-(6@'! D3=#3#($%)#! 03)66! A$G$! ^be! HA!<br />

:$=.'(3'('!?!='G$3#5#=.$(B!<br />

!<br />

:;'1.+


(.($<br />

?O.A(5&f/&A($L(,/($`&1(1(.(!! D(#.$:$! 7'@!3:'7'!<br />

G'3'%:!.!(B!!<br />

c`k!!<br />

D(#.#(#=!+'.!!-#!)'!.!:!%!!A#(?#=3#.$(:$.$(B!!<br />

`3=#)#!&$%)$!#.$!D(#.$:$%)#!)U%D:!%0=.'+!!VWW^!7!3!%)'!U>#3!+#=.U(#!'$.!$3=!&$%)$!#.$!<br />

D(#.#%! #%.#A(#! 1$(:'%!%! 2036#3!+#=.U(#!'$.!$=$%5$!G$(!1$(:'!)'&'!>:$(!$3$!5$-'(!%)'!<br />

G6!D(#.$:#!)'&$3!03:6.6(B!!<br />

T'3!=3!! K'-6=! 2$3A$! J3'.10(:6)#! D(#.$3)$$%$!<br />

&'3='!'%3'.:'=4!.'%!.!:!-#!(#=3':!?'3!:'3'(!!7'@'('=!.D=#.$:!'3!='%3!!!#)$%)$(:#=4!<br />

0(.'7'! ?!='G$3#5#=! +0(6%3'()'! G$(3$=.#! 1$=$(! D(#.#(#=! )'&'! )0(6! -#! $7$! +0%6?3'('!<br />

63'!3:'+!%!!+'3':'7!!':'?3':!.!(B!<br />

$<br />

b-A&$b.&1()$k+A+)-+.!!<br />

m>#33$=3#! VWW^! p! VWWZ! 7!33'(!%)'! :#-56.! =D:#+! -#! G'(!%'=3'(! D(#.$:! $?$%!<br />

=633'%!3!(=#%4!#3)#!#)$3#%!&!>3!!D(#.$:!'(.!!73'!G$(3$=.#!+0%!0%!7!3)'!&$%)$!7#.$.$($5$3$$!<br />

':'5!73'! @(0I#3$! 03'('=! $%'! #)$3#%! +0%! )#(#5#! :0)#(%4! &$I7#%$=! -#! G$70bAD-#%3$=!<br />

+.'%)'(.3'(!!7D=+#=!=D:#+3#(!0(.'7'!?!=:'7'!G'3':!.!(B!<br />

`3=#:$>)#! &$%)$! -'(3!!! VWfe! p! VWWe! 7!33'(!! '('+!%)'! ]! p! ]Bd! :$370%! '('3!!%)'!<br />

)#$$:!AU+.#(:$.$(B!VWWe!7!3!%)'%!$.$G'(#%!#%.'%+$1!D(#.$:$%!'(.!!!-#!c`k&-()&$<br />

2O,5+/+$@&$b-A&)(9/&$L(,/($B1($b.&1()$k+A+)-+.!!<br />

cD%7'!&$%)$!#.$!D(#.$:$!^!:$370%!.0%!5$-'(!%)')!(B!K0@3':!='%'.3!!#.$!D(#.$:$%)#!&$%)$!<br />

! CNH


#.$!D(#.$:!:$=.'(!!tebZ$37'!7#(!<br />

'3:'=.')!(B!<br />

$<br />

?O.A(5&f/&$L(,/($`&1(1(.(


e! '7! A$G$! 6>6%! G$(! 7#.$.$(:#! )U%#:$! A#(#=.$(#%! &$%)$! 7#.$.$($5$3$$%)#! +#(:'7#!<br />

A#(#=+$%$:$! A#(#=! $3=! 7'.!(!:4! A#(#=+#! )#! 7#.$.$(:#! )U%#:$! +D(#+$! G076%5'! 7D=+#=!<br />

:$=.'(3'()')!(B!26!D(#.$:$%!'(.!(!3:'+!!-#!.#-$=!#)$3:#+$!$?$%!)#!)DD=!1'$>3$!$3#.:#!<br />

=(#)$+$!=633'%)!(!3:'+!!67A6%!03'5'=.!(B!<br />

`3=#)#! &$%)$! #.$! .D=#.$:$! ;-(6@'! D3=#3#($%$%! -#! A#3$:$! D3=#3#($%! ?0=! '3.!%)')!(B!<br />

KD=#.$:! '3!='%3!=3'(!%!%! )#$.$($3:#+$4! &$%)$! #.$%$%! +'3!=3!! G#+3#%:#! '?!+!%)'%!<br />

A#(#=3$3$$! U>#3! +#=.U(#! '$.! 1$(:'3'(5'! 7'@!3'%! (#=3':! -#! .'%!.!:3'(3'! 03)66! =')'(4!<br />

(#+:$! =6(6:3'(! .'('1!%)'%! )'! A#(?#=3#.$($3:#3$! -#! &'3=! &$%)$! #.$! .D=#.:#7#!<br />

U>#%)$($3:#3$)$(B!<br />

&('5'.!%!70=!)#%#5#=!=')'(!'>!03)66!D3=#:$>)#4!;2!67A6%36=!%0(:3'(!!7'='3'%:!!<br />

036@! )D%7'! +.'%)'(.3'(!%)'! D(#.$:! 7'@!3:'=.')!(B! T#=.U(! 7'=!%! A#3#5#=.#! ;2!<br />

D3=#3#($%$%! .'3#G$! )0(63.6+6%)'! G6! D3=#3#(#! $&('5'.'! G'3'7'5'=.!(B! 26! )'! =6=6+6>!<br />

A$()$3#($%!'(.!!73'!G#('G#(!D(#.$:#!)#+.#=!03'5'=.!(B!cD%7')'=$!='%'.3!!#.$!$.&'3'.!%!%!<br />

V_]:'%3':!! .#=%$=! #3#:'%! -#! U>#33$=3#! )#! '('! #3#:'%!<br />

+!=!%.!+!!G636%:'=.')!(B!26!)6(6:!G'=!5!!#$.$:!+#:$%#(3#($!-#!7#.$.$($5$3$=!6>:'%3!!!<br />

+#(.$1$='!@(0A(':3'(!%!%!A#(?#=3#.$($3:#+$73#!A#3$.$($3#G$3#5#=.$(B!<br />

9'(:'('4! 2'.!! H'(')#%$>! -#! LA#! 2U3A#3#($! .'-6=?636=! -#! &$%)$! 7#.$.$($5$3$$%$%!<br />

706%!-#!$?!$?#!7'@!3)!!!GU3A#3#()$(B!26!GU3A#3#()#!$3#.:#3#(!'('+!!G63':'!($+=$%$!<br />

'>'3.'5'=!U%3#:3#(!'3!%:'+!4!G$70AD-#%3$=!6%+6(3'(!%'!)'&'!)$=='.3#!7'=3'!3:'+!!-#!<br />

'!!@(0A(':3'(!%!%!036.6(63:'+!%)'!?0=!)$=='.3$!036%:'+!!A#(#=:#=.#)$(B!<br />

m>#3! +#=.U(#! '$.! .#=! G$(! '('.!(:'! A#3$.$(:#! =6(6366! G636%:'=.')!(N;"CL! ;BBPB!<br />

26%6%! A$G$! 7'7!%3'(! &'>!(3'7'%4! '('.!(:'3'(!! )#+.#=3#7#%4! A#3$:#3#($! .'=$@! #)#%!<br />

=6(6363'(!%!+'7!5'!'(.:'+!!7'('(3!!03'5'=.!(B!26!A$G$!=6(6363'(!%!D%$-#(+$.#3#($%!>$(''.!<br />

-#!-#.#($%#(!1'=D3.#3#($73#!G$(3$=.#!@(0I#3#(!&'>!(3':'+!!-#!?'3!:'+!!+'3'%:'3!)!(B!<br />

3#.:#3#($%!=6(63:'!'':'+!%)'!?#-(#7#!#%!'>!036:+6>!#.=$!7'@'5'!4!G$70AD-#%3$=!<br />

G'=!:!%)'%! +0(6%+6>! 03'%! 7#(3#()#! =6(636:6%'! $>$%! -#($3:#+$! A#(#=:#=.#)$(B! >$%!<br />

'3'('=!=6(63:6!03'%!$3#.:#3#($%!)#!+!=!!#=$3)#!)#%#.3#%:#+$!A#(#=:#=.#)$(B!<br />

`3=#)#!A#%#3!03'('=!67A63'%:'=.'!03'%!+U>3#:#3$!D(#.$:!:0)#3$%$%!@03$.$='!&'3$%#!<br />

A#.$($3:#+$! &#:! #%.#A(#! =6(6363'(!%! 7'.!(!:! :'3$7#.3#($%$! )DD(#(#=! &#:! )#!<br />

7#.$.$($5$3$=!703673'!D(#.$:#!='.!3'%!1$(:'3'('!A#3$(!+'3'7'('=!D3=#!#=0%0:$+$%#!='.=!!<br />

+'3'7'5'=.!(B!<br />

3#($! $3#%:$! D(D%3#()#! )'&'! ?#=$5$! -#! )#$$=! D(D%3#($%! 0(.'7'! ?!='(!3:'+!! -#!<br />

!+!.!3'('=! 7#%:#7#! &'>!(! ?#$.3$! A!)'3'(!%! &'>!(3'%'('=! @'>'('! +6%63:'+!73'! &$%)$!<br />

.D=#.$:! :$=.'(!%)'!'(.!! +'3'%'G$3#5#=.$(B!;7%!! #=$3)#! ('13'()'!)'&'! ?#$.3$! D(D%D%!<br />

.D=#.$5$3#(#!+6%63:'+!!G6!#.#!)6763'%!$3A$%$%!)#!'(.:'+!%'!%#)#%!03'5'=.!(B!<br />

H6=6+6>! U%D:D>)#=$! 7!33'()'! $%+'%! +'3!!%!%! U%! @3'%)'! 03)66! G$(! )U%#:!<br />

7''%'5'=.!(B! 26! G'=!:)'%! )'! =03#+.#(03! )D>#7$! )DD=4! '>! 7'3!4! =#%)$%#! &'+! G$(!<br />

'(0:'+!! 03'%! &$%)$! #.$%$%! A#(#=! GD.D%4! A#(#=+#! )#! @'(?'! #.! 03'('=! .D=#.$:$! A$)#(#=!<br />

'(.'5'=.!(B!3#($!$3#%:$!#.!D(#.$:$%)#!1$7'.!)DD(D5D!#.=$+$%$%!03:'+!!G6!D(#.$:$!)'&'!<br />

)##(3$! =!3:'=.')!(B! ;7%!! >':'%)'! A$)#(#=! A30G'33##%! -#! $! 706%366! '(.'%!<br />

)D%7':!>)'! -'=$.! )'(3!!%)'%! &!>3!! 7#:#=! 7'@:'7'! #3-#($3$4! !+!.!3'('=! 7#%#G$3#%!<br />

D(D%3#($%!$:'3'.!%'!#3-#($3$!G$(!#.!03:'+!!)'!G$(!G'='!'-'%.'I!)!(B!26!)'!&$%)$!#.$%$!<br />

.D=#.$:! ?#$.3$3$$! G'=!:!%)'%! 1'(=3!! >#-=3#(#! &$.'@! #)#G$3#%! G$(! D(D%! &'3$%#!<br />

! CNN


A#.$(:#=.#)$(B!<br />

T'3!=3!! -#! G#+3#7$5$! 03'%! &$%)$! #.$4! )D%7')'! 03)66! A$G$! KD(=$7#6! #.$%#! )#%=! =!7:#.3$! @(0.#$%! ='7%'!%!!<br />

D(#.:#=4!G#+3#:#=!:D:=D%!03:'=.')!(B!26!7U%D73#!U>#33$=3#!+0%!7!33'()'!D3=#:$>)#!<br />

7''%'%! =!(:!>!! #.! +0(6%6%6! ?0=! =!+'! +D(#)#! ?U>:#)#! #.=$%! G$(! D(#.$:! )'3!! 03'('=!<br />

AU(D3:#3$!-#!=633'%!3:'3!)!(B!T!(1!G6!7U%D73#!G$3#!D(#.$:!-#!.D=#.$:$!&#(!.D(3D!.#-$=!<br />

#)$3:#3$4!+U>3#:#3$!7#.$.$($5$3$=!)#+.#=3#%:#3$)$(B!<br />

TU>3#:#3$!D(#.$:!$+.$=('(3!!G$(!:0)#3)$(B!\$I7#%$=!-#!=0%.(033D!D(#.$:!+'7#+$%)#!A!)'!<br />

AD-#%3$$!+'3'%!(B!;%5'=!GD.D%!G6!+D(#?!$?#(+$%)#!:'3$!7D=D:3D3D=!#%.#A(#!D>#($%)#!<br />

03)66!$?$%4!#%.#A(#3#(#!:'3$!=03'73!=3'(!+'3'%:'3!)!(B!<br />

X#:! &'::'))#3#($! )03'7!+!73'! 7#:! 1$7'.3'(!! :'3$7#.3#($! ''!7'! ?#=$3#(#=! D(#.$:!<br />

:'3$7#.3#($!'>'3.!3:'3!)!(!NAD:(D=!-#(A$3#($!-#!Hc8!0('%3'(!%)'!$%)$($:3#(ëPB!<br />

KD=#.$5$!&'=3'(!!A$G$4!D(#.$5$!&'=3'(!)'!G$(!='-(':!03'('=!#3#!'3!%:'3!!#.!+'.!3'(!%)'!<br />

N.'(!:+'3! D(#.$:$%! &#@+$%)#P! :'(=#.3#($%! A#?! U)#:#! '3!='%3!=3'(!! 7'+'3'(3'!<br />

)D>#%3#%:#3$)$(B!<br />

l$('$!7'@!3':'4!=(#)$3#(4!)#+.#=3#(!$')#!-#!+DG-'%+$70%3'()'!.'-6=b&$%)$!'7(!:!!A$G$!<br />

&'.'3'(! .#=('(3'%:':'3!! -#! A$)#($3:#3$)$(B! k$1.3$=! 7'@!3':'+!! -#!<br />

(6&+'.3'%)!(!3:'3'(!%)'!&#(!.D(3D!@($:!-#!&'(?!U)#:#3#($!7D=+#=!.6.63:'!#$3$:$%)#%!<br />

6>'=3'!3:'3!4!G6!7D=!7'.!(!:3'()'!&'1$13#.$3:#3$)$(B$<br />

$<br />

*.+#33$=3#!7#:!A$()$3#($%$%!)DD(D3:#+$!U%#:3$!G$(!1'=.U()D(B!c06!<br />

D3=#3#($!-#!U>#33$=3#!=0:63'(!:!>'!'%+!:!>!)'&'!'?!=!-#!$+.#%$3#%!+#-$7#)#!03:'+'!<br />

)'!$&('5'.!03:'=.')!(B!;2!-#!;2c!)#!U>#33$=3#!7#:!:'3$7#.$%$%!656>366!-#!+'3'%'%!<br />

.#-$=3#(3#! 67A6%! =0633'()'! &$%)$7$! G6('3'('! +'3':'=.')!(B! 26! '':')'!<br />

c#-3#.$:$>$%!.#-$=3#($!G6!'%+!:!>!!'(.!('5'=.!(B!<br />

$<br />

"F,7_$<br />

\$%)$! #.$! D(#.$:$! ='%'.3!! #.$! D(#.$:$! $?#(+$%)#!A#3#5#=! -''.! #)#%! G$(!D(#.$:! =036)6(B!<br />

C#(#=! D(#.$:$%! 0.0:'+70%'! 67A6%366! -#! A#(#=+#! $&.$-'! #..$$! G#+$! )##(3#($%$%!<br />

+'3!!4! '7(!5'! G6.! #.$%$%! =!(:!>!! #.! 0366! D3=#:$>)#! )#! &'=3!! G$(! A#3#5#=!<br />

G#=3#:#=.#)$(B!!C#3$:$!D3=#3#()#!1#(.!G'!!.D=#.$:!V[!p!V^!HA!5$-'(!%)'!+#7(#)#(=#%!<br />

D3=#:$>)#! &#%D>! [4^! HA! 5$-'(!%)')!(B! ! 2D7D=! G'!=!(:!>!! #.! D(#.$:$:$>$%! &#%D>!<br />

7#.#($%5#! A#3$:#)$$! )$=='.#! '3!%)!!%)'4! .'-6=! #.$%)#%! U.#7#! G'='! G$(! #.!<br />

'(>63'%)!!%)'! &$%)$! #.$! .#(5$&! #)$3:#=.#)$(B! ! C#3$:$! D3=#3#()#! &$%)$! #.$! .D=#.$:$!<br />

='%'.3!! #.$! .D=#.$:$%$%! t! V[! p! V^)'4! 7'3%!>!<br />

D3=#:$>! $?$%! )'&$! V^[B! [[[! .0%36=! G$(! &$%)$! #.$! D(#.$:! @(0I#=+$70%6! ='(!:!>'!<br />

?!='G$3$(B! m>#33$=3#! )D%7':!>)'=$! $=3$:! )#$$=3$=3#($4! =6('=! @#($70.3'(!%! '%0%+!<br />

! CNT


#)$3:#+$4! .'(!:+'3! D(#.$:$%! :'3$7#.3#($%$! '(.!(:'=.')!(B! R7+'! &'7-'%+'3! @(0.#$%!<br />

D(#.$:$%)#! #%!656>! 7036%!='%'.3!! #.$! D(#.$:$! 03)66!-#!G6%)'!&$%)$%$%! )#! &'=3!! G$(!<br />

'-'%.'I!!03)66!+0%!AD%3#($%!?0=?'!$$.$3#%!70(6:3'(!)!(B!!`(#.$:!#+%'+!%)'!AUD+!#.$!<br />

0('%!%!%! 7D=+#=! 0366! A#3$:$! D3=#3#()#=$! .'3#G#! 7U%3#%)$($3)$$%)#! 5$))$! 1$7'.!<br />

'-'%.'I3'(!!036.66!$?$%!$&('5'.!'%+!!)'$:'!7D=+#=.$(B!!<br />

$<br />

%+5,+A-+.$<br />

;%0%$:4!d[[e!'4!2#+)!2$(!!<br />

;%0%$:4!d[[Z4!2#+)!2$(4!H'%'.3!!2$3A$3#($!X!33!!!d[[e!<br />

;%0%$:4!d[[Z'4!!2#+)!2$(!<br />

TU%:#>4!VWeW!<br />

;2c!K'(!:!2'='%3!!!N,Tc;b*;TP!<br />

$<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

! CNW


" #H! $:!.$D&5+9$P:DBS$@&$:)&.(A+,$D.F,9$PD.S$L(,/(-&.$(-&$D7,-+.!,$<br />

c&-&9-&.(,(,$Pa ! ha C $@&$> ! S$B,1+,'(K$@&$`+.!$B,1+,'(K$$<br />

%F7--+./+$%+.A+'$c+-(5&1($<br />

6.+#),"$)")QE$S)'&8)#3"%$)<br />

6$.++"+)Q5kZ)5^)'&8)E6k)?"'$"8)*&#"&+%C")Q*AOS).$)/"7%)*&#"&+%C")<br />

A'&'2"7"&#)6.&8%#%.&+)<br />

!<br />

T#()'(!m>3D ' 4!R='%!L3$G03 G 4!n6:'%!;=:'% G 4!9#+6.!KD(=036 G !-#!96>'11#(!kU()D= 5 !<br />

' ;('BCU(B4!;%='('!`%$-#(+$.#+$!l$(''.!*'=D3.#+$!l00.#=%$!2U3D:D!b!;%='('!<br />

G J(01Bc(B4!;%='('!`%$-#(+$.#+$!l$(''.!*'=D3.#+$!l00.#=%$!2U3D:D!b!;%='('!<br />

5 c0?Bc(B4!;&$!L-('%!`%$-#(+$.#+$!l$(''.!*'=D3.#+$!l00.#=%$!2U3D:D!b!H!(#&$($<br />

$<br />

89&1$<br />

26!?'3!:'!;!(!2#7'>!N;2LP4!;:#($='%!2(0%>!N2(P!-#!G6%3'(!%!1'(=3!!+#-$7#3#()#!<br />

:#3#>3#($%$%!N* V 4!* d !-#!C V P!#%.'%+$1!-#!7'(!!#%.'%+$1!7#.$.$(:#!=0633'(!%)'!GD7D:#!<br />

@#(10(:'%+!! -#! =A! ='(='+! :'3$7#.$%$! )##(3#%)$(:#=! ':'5!73'! 7D(D.D3:D.D(B!<br />

;('.!(:')'!#%.'%+$1!7#.$.$(:#!+$+.#:$![bVf!&'1.'!-#!7'(!!#%.'%+$1!7#.$.$(:#!+$+.#:$!<br />

[bd^!&'1.'!D>#($%)#%!)##(3#%)$($3:$.$(B!!=$!7#.$.$(:#!+$+.#:$%)#!)#!#%!7D=+#=!-#!#%!<br />

)DD=! 5'%3!!'!(3!=! 0(.'3':'+!!+!('+!73'! ;2L! -#! 2(! A#%0.$@3#($%)#%! #3)#! #)$3:$.$(B!<br />

L%.'%+$1!7#.$.$(:#!=0633'(!%)'!* V !-#!* d 4!7'(!!#%.'%+$1!7#.$.$(:#!=0633'(!%)'!$+#!* V !<br />

-#! C V ! :#3#>3#(! &'($?! A#%0.$@3#($%! 5'%3!! '!(3!=! 0(.'3':'3'(!! '('+!%)'=$! 1'(=3!3!=!<br />

$+.'.$+.$=! 03'('=! U%#:3$! G636%:6.6(! N@z[B[^PB! C#%0.$@3#($%! ZbVf! &'1.'3!=! )U%#:)#!<br />

7'':'! AD5D! )##(3#($! G'=!:!%)'%! #%.'%+$1! 7#.$.$(:#! +$+.#:$%)#! 1'(=3!3!=! $+.'.$+.$=!<br />

03'('=! U%#:3$! 03:':'+!%'! ='(!%! 7'(!! #%.'%+$1! 7#.$.$(:#! +$+.#:$%)#! #3)#! #)$3#%!<br />

1'(=3!3!=! $+.'.$+.$=! 03'('=! U%#:3$! G636%:6.6(! N@z[B[^PB! H'(='+! :'3$7#.$! G'=!:!%)'%!<br />

#%.'%+$1!7#.$.$(:#!+$+.#:$%)#!;2L4!7'(!!#%.'%+$1!7#.$.$(:#!+$+.#:$%)#!$+#!* V !A#%0.$@$!<br />

#%!)DD=!)##(#!+'&$@.$(B!!<br />

:,+*1+.$%&-()-&.3!&$%)$4!:#3#>3#:#4!G#+$!@#(10(:'%+!4!#%.'%+$14!7'(!b#%.'%+$1!!<br />

$<br />

:;'1.+#(#! ='%'.3!3'(!%! G'>!! G$7030I$=! U>#33$=3#($%$%! )#! ='.=!+!! -'()!(B! 26!<br />

! CNZ


U>#33$=3#()#%! $3=! '=3'! A#3#%3#(4! ='%'.3!3'(!%! D(#:#! AD5D4! GD7D:#! &!>!! -#! 7#:)#%!<br />

7'('(3'%:'! 7#.#%#$! G'=!:!%)'%! D+.D%3D=3#($)$(B! \$%)$3#($%! D(#:#! AD5D! -#! 7#:)#%!<br />

7'('(3'%:'!7#.#%#$!.'-6=!=')'(!7D=+#=!03:'+'!)'4!#3)#!#)$3#%!='(='+!%!GD7D=3DD!<br />

-#!&$%)$!#.$%$%!%$.#3$$h!&$%)$7$!U>#33$=3#!#.!+'%'7$!$?$%!U%#:3$!=!3:'=.')!(B!KD(=$7#!! 7'.!(!:5!3'(!<br />

;:#($='%! 2(0%>! A#%0.$@$%#! )'7'3!! @'3'>! D(#.$:$%#! ?'3!:!! 03+'3'(! )'4! AD%D:D>)#!<br />

#%.'%+$1! =0633'()'! D(#.$:! 7'@'%! $3#.:#3#($%! =633'%)!!! A#%0.$@3#(! ?06%36=3'! $.&'3!<br />

#)$3:#=.#)$(B! .&'3! #)$3#%! A#%0.$@3#(3#! 7'@!3'%! D(#.$:! $+#! '>! +'7!)'! #%.#A('+70%!<br />

$?#($+$%)#!A#(?#=3#.$($3:#=.#)$(B!R7+'!KD(=$7##33$=3#!#=+.'%+$1!-#!7'(!!#%.'%+$1!<br />

=0633'('!+'&$@!$3#.:#3#($%!A#3$#(#=!&$%)$!#.$!D(#.$:$%)#!='3:'3'(!!+'3'%'G$3)$$%)#4!<br />

+')#5#! =!(+'3! =#+$:)#! A#3$(! '(.!!%'! ='.=!)'! G636%63:'7'5'=4! G$(! 7'%)'%! .#=#33#:#!<br />

#$3$:$! 03'%! #%.#A('+70%! .$@$! D(#.$:#! ('=$@! 036%6(=#%4! )$#(! 7'%)'%! )'4! U>#33$=3#!<br />

0(A'%$=!&$%)$!#.$!D(#.$:$!$?$%!67A6%!G$(!>#:$%!036.6(63'G$3#5#=.$(B!H!+'5'!A#3#5#=.#!<br />

&#:! D(#.$:! :'3$7#.3#($%$! '>'3.:'4! &#:! (#='G#.$! =0(6:'! &#:! )#! &$%)$! #.$! $&.$7'5!%!!<br />

='(!3':')'! =!+:#%! 0.3'.:'7'! )'7'3!! 7'(!! #%.'%+$1! D(#.$:$%! U%#:3$! G$(! 7#(! .6.:'+!!<br />

G#=3#%#G$3$(B!<br />

26!?'3!:'73'4!$.&'3!#)$3#%!&$%)$!A#%0.$@3#($%#!G$(!'3.#(%'.$1!036.6(:')'!?#$.3$!:#3#>!<br />

A#%0.$@3#()#%! 7'('(3'%!3!@! 7'('(3'%!3':'7'5'!! =0%6+6%)'! 1$=$(! 7D(D.:#7#! $:='%!<br />

+'3'7'5'=!G$3A$3#($%!D(#.$3:#+$%#!#=!03'('=!G6!A#%0.$@3#($%!&'%A$!7#.$.$(:#!+$+.#:$!<br />

=633'%!3!(+'! $3#.:#7#! )'&'! 7D=+#=! 1'7)'! +'3'7'5'!%!%! G#3$(3#%:#+$73#! $3A$3$! G$(!<br />

.'(.!:'!0(.':!%!%!7'('.!3:'+!!':'?3'%:!.!(B! !<br />

$<br />

c+1&.5+-$@&$c&1F1$<br />

26! ?'3!:'3'(!%! #3)#! #)$3:#+$! ':'5!73'!<br />

A#(?#=3#.$($3#%! .0&6:3':'3'()'! =633'%!3'%! '%'! -#! G'G'! A#%0.$@3#($%! %#! 03)66)6(!<br />

NK'G30!VPB!!<br />

K'G30!VB!k$1.3#.$(:#3#()#!=633'%!3'%!'%'?3'(!-#!#3)#!#)$3#%!)U33#($%!A#%0.$@3#($B!<br />

2'G'!C#%0.$@$ b! 2( ;2L * V ;2L<br />

;%'!C#%0.$@$! b! 2( 2(! * V * V !<br />

cU3!C#%0.$@$! ;2Ly! 2( * V ! * d C V !<br />

yY;2L! A#%0.$@$%)#%! @'3'>3'(! '7%!! AD%! ?!=!3!! 03'5'=! #=$3)#! G$(! U>#3! $3#.:#)#%!<br />

+'3'%:!.!(B!<br />

!<br />

K'G30! V3'(! ;%='('! `%$-#(+$.#+$! l$(''.!<br />

*'=D3.#+$! l00.#=%$! 2U3D:D! H'%'.3!! ;('.!(:'! 2$($:$%)#! NHB;B2BP! GD7D.D3:D.D(B!<br />

L%.'%+$1! 7#.$.$(:#! +$+.#:$%#! 67A6%! 03'('=! &'>!(3'%'%! =D:#+.#! )#$$=! )U%#:3#()#!<br />

7#:! )##(3#%)$(:#! +'7!3'(!%!%! .#+@$.$! ':'5!73'! &#(! A#%0.$@$%! #%! '>! D?! GU3:#)#!<br />

G636%:'+!!+'3'%:!.!(B!*'='.!7'(!!#%.'%+$1!03'('=!.'%!:3'%'%!+$+.#:)#!7#.$.$($3#%3#(!<br />

$?$%! e! &'1.'3!=! 7'.'%! +0%('! GU73#! G$(! '7(!:'! A$)$3:#:$.$(B! ,7A63'%'%! 7#.$.$(:#!<br />

+$+.#:3#($%$%!G'>!!U>#33$=3#($!-#!67A63':'!'3'%!!K'G30!d


#)$3:$!03:'+!%'!(':#%4!)##(3#%)$(:#3#()#![be4!ZbVf!-#!VWbd^!&'1.'3!=!7'!)U%#:$!<br />

G$3A$3#($!=633'%!3:!.!(B!;('.!(!5!3'(!#(=#=!-#!)$$3#($%!@#(10(:'%+!)##(3#($%$!'7(!!'7(!!<br />

.#+@$.!#.:$!03+'3'(!)'4!G6!?'3!:')'!5$%+$7#.3#($%!0(.'3':'+!!)$=='.#!'3!%:!.!(B!<br />

!<br />

K'G30!dB!*'(=3!!7#.$.$(:#!+$+.#:3#($%$%!G'>!!U>#33$=3#($!<br />

m>#33$=! 2#+$! X'(!!#%.'%+$1!+$+.#:!N2#+$r;%!>!r!<br />

2#+$P!<br />

c#%#:#)#!H'3:'!<br />

TD(#+$!<br />

X#:!<br />

,7A63':'%!%!<br />

C#(?#=3#.$($3)$$!X#(!<br />

Vf!&'1.'!<br />

;)b3$G$.6:!<br />

d^!&'1.'!<br />

3=!e!&'1.'!')b3$G$.6:4!VfB!&'1.'7'!<br />

=')'(!'%!>!+0%('!')b3$G$.6:!<br />

T6! ;)b3$G$.6:! ;)b3$G$.6:!<br />

O!=!<br />

Vg!T''.!<br />

3=!e!&'1.'!Vg!+''.4!ZbVf!&'1.'!AD%!<br />

6>6%3664!+0%('!Vg!+''.!!<br />

HB;B2B!<br />

3=!e!&'1.'!HB;B24!)'&'!+0%('!*'=D3.#!<br />

;('.!(:'!,7A63':'!k$1.3$$!<br />

!<br />

c##(3#%)$(:#3#(! )#! =633'%!3'%! G'>!! G$3A$3#(! G'='! ='7%'=3'()'%! +'3'%:!.!(B!<br />

26%3'()'%! G$($4! 7#:! -#! @'3'>! A$)#($! )!!%)'=$! :'+('13'(!%! .0@3':! &'(5':'3'()'=$!<br />

@'7!)!(B! 26! )##(! T$@'&$! NdP4! .'('1!%)'%! G#! 1'(=3!! $3)#! +U>3#:#3$! D(#.$:! 7'@'%!<br />

#%.'%+$1! &$%)$! $3#.:#3#($%)#%! 7D(D.D3#%! ?'3!:')'%! +'3'%:!.!(B! TU>! =0%6+6!<br />

'('.!(:')'! 7#:! :'+('13'(!%!%! @'7!! d[[e! 7!3!%)'! tZ^B^4! d[[Z! 7!3!%)'! tZ]4! @'3'>!<br />

A$)#($%$%!@'7!!)'!'7%!!+!('73'!tV[Be!-#!tVdBZ!03'('=!&#+'@3'%:!.!(B!26!?'3!:')'!<br />

$+#!@'3'>!-#!7#:!A$)#(3#($%$%!.0@3':!A$)#(3#($%!tfZ! $?$%! 7#(3$! D(#.$5$3#()#%! '3!%:!.!(B! 9#3#>! @'3'>3'(!%! 1$7'.!! $+#! G6!<br />

$=$+$%$%!0(.'3':'+!!03'('=!='G63!#)$3:$.$(B!<br />

X#:!1$7'.3'(!!$+#4!'7(!%.!3'(!!L3$G03!#.!'3BNVP!.'('1!%)'%!7D(D.D3#%!?'3!:')'!7#(!'3'%!<br />

('+70%3'(!%! NK'G30! ]P4! AD%5#3! &'::'))#! 1$7'.3'(!! $3#! &#+'@3'%:!! )##(3#($)$(B!<br />

R(.'3':'! 7#:! 1$7'.!! K'G30! ]


2$(?0=! U>#33$=.#! A(6@3'(! '('+!! 1'(=!%! .#+@$.$%)#! -'(7'%+! '%'3$>! .#=%$$%)#%!<br />

7'('(3'%!3:!4! A(6@! 0(.'3':'3'(!! '('+!%)'=$! 1'(=!%! U%#:! =0%.(03D! c6%5'%! ?0=36!<br />

='(!3'.!(:'!.#+.$73#!7'@!3:!.!(B!X'':'!AD5D!)##(3#($%$%!='(!3'.!(!3:'+!%)'!$=$3$!<br />

0('%!='(!3'.!(:'!.#+.$!=633'%!3:!.!(B!\#+'@3':'!-#!)##(3#%)$(:#3#()#!TJTT!V]!-#!<br />

9OnOK;2!Vg!$+.'.$+.$=!@'=#.!@(0A(':3'(!%)'%!7'('(3'%!3:!.!(B!!<br />

$<br />

D7-67-+.$<br />

C#%0.$@3#($%!GD7D.:#!)U%#:$!03'('=!='G63!#)$3#G$3#5#=!eB&'1.'!'!(3!=3'(!%'!#=!03'('=!<br />

1'(=3!!7#.$.$(:#!+$+.#:3#($!$?$%!)#$$=!7'!5'%3!!'!(3!=3'(!!K'G30!g! =0%6+6! )U%#:! 7#:! .D=#.$:!<br />

)##(3#($! =633'%!3:!! $+#! )#4! A#%0.$@3#($%! G#+$)#=$! @#(10(:'%+3'(!%!%! )'&'! $7$!<br />

$>3#%#G$3:#+$! $?$%! )#$$=!)U%#:!7#:!)##(3#%)$(:#! +'7!3'(!!K'G30!^


\$%)$3#($%! G#+$! @#(10(:'%+3'(!%!%! )##(3#%)$($3:#+$%)#! 5'%3!! '!(3!=! '(.!!! -#! 7#:!<br />

)##(3#%)$(:#!+'7!+!!7'%!%)'!7'':'!AD5D%#!)#!7#(!-#($3:$.$(!NK'G30!ePB!K'G30!e!G636%6(=#%4!'%!>)'!<br />

0.3'.:'!)U%#:$%)#!;2L!-#!* d !G636%:6.6(B!<br />

C#%0.$@3#($%! 1'(=3!! 7#.$.$(:#! +$+.#:3#($! $?$%! ='(='+! ('%)!:'%!! -#! ='(='+! '!(3!=3'(!!<br />

7$%#4!L3$G03!-#!'(=B!.'('1!%)'%!A#(?#=3#.$($3#%!G$(!'('.!(:')'%!#3)#!#)$3:$!-#!K'G30!<br />

Z#33$=!<br />

T$+.#:$! ;2L! 2(! * V ! * d ! C V !<br />

H'(='+!<br />

"'%)!:'%!4t!<br />

H'(='+!<br />

;!(3!!4!=A!<br />

L%.'%+$1!N2#+$P! fdBdV! ZfBdf! f[BeV! ZWBeZ! fVB[[!<br />

X'(!!L%.'%+$1!<br />

N2#+$r;%!>r2#+$P!<br />

f[Bff! ZeBd]! ZWB[[! ZfB[f! ZWB]f!<br />

L%.'%+$1!N2#+$P! V[BW^! gBZZ! eBeZ! eBfg! fBgf!<br />

X'(!!L%.'%+$1!<br />

N2#+$r;%!>r2#+$P!<br />

V[BV[! ^BZf! ZB^W! eBfg! ZBZd!<br />

!<br />

\$%)$3#($%! )#$$=! 7'3'()'! -#! )#%#:#! +0%6! =A! ='(='+! :'3$7#.$! &#+'@3':'3'(!%)'!<br />

=633'%!3'%!)##(3#(!-#!#3)#!#)$3#%!+0%6?3'(!''!)'!.'G303'(!&'3$%)#!-#($3:$.$(!NK'G30!<br />

f!-#!WPB!<br />

!<br />

K'G30!fB!c#$$=!7'3'(!$?$%!:'3$7#.4!Ki_&'7-'%!<br />

!<br />

X'!! X#.$.$(:#!T$+.#:$!<br />

C#%0.$@!<br />

;2L! 2(! * V ! * d ! C V !<br />

J'3'>! V[B[[! eB[[! fB[[! fB[[! fB[[!<br />

eB!&'1.'! L%.'%+$1!N2#+$P! V^Bg]! V[BVV! VdB[Z! VdBde! V]BVV!<br />

L%.'%+$1!N2#+$P! eVB^W! ]^Bf]! gZBdZ! geBZd! ^eBf[!<br />

VfB&'1.'! X'(!!L%.'%+$1!<br />

N2#+$r;%!>P!<br />

dZBeV! VgB^d! VeBZf! dVB[Z! dVBd^!<br />

d^B!&'1.'!<br />

X'(!!L%.'%+$1!<br />

N2#+$r;%!>r2#+$P!<br />

e]B]g! ]^Be]! gdBgf! g]BgZ! g^B^d!<br />

K'G30!WB!C#%0.$@3#($%!1'(=3!!7#.$.$(:#!+$+.#:3#($%)#!='(='+!:'3$7#.$4!Ki_=A!<br />

X#.$.$(:#!T$+.#:$!<br />

C#%0.$@!<br />

;2L! 2(! * V ! * d ! C V !<br />

L%.'%+$1!N2#+$P!! ^Be]! ZB^V! ZB[W! eBf]! eBZ[!<br />

X'(!!L%.'%+$1!N2#+$r;%!>r2#+$P! eBdZ! eBVe! ^Be[! eB]e! ^BfW!<br />

!<br />

L%.'%+$1! 7#.$.$(:#! +$+.#:$%)#! ;2L! A#%0.$@$%)#! =A! ='(='+! :'3$7#.$! ^Be]! Ki! 03'('=!<br />

&#+'@3'%:!.!(B!;7%!!7#.$.$(:#!+$+.#:$%)#!)$#(!A#%0.$@3#($%!='(='+!:'3$7#.$!t!VWb<br />

t]g! )'&'! 7D=+#=! 03:6.6(B! 26%'! ='(!%! A#%0.$@3#($%! 7'(!! #%.'%+$1! 7#.$.$(:#!<br />

+$+.#:$%)#! GD7D.D3:#+$! +0%6%)'! ;2L! &'($?! )$#(3#($%)#! ='(='+! :'3$7#.$! '>'3:!.!(B!<br />

! CTC


L%!)DD=!='(='+!:'3$7#.$!^Be[!Ki!$3#!* V !A#%0.$@$%)#!A#(?#=3#:$4!)$#(!A#%0.$@3#($%!<br />

)##($!G6%)'%!t^btVg!)'&'!7D=+#=!03:6.6(B!!!<br />

$<br />

?+.1!)+$@&$"F,7_$<br />

C#%0.$@3#($%!$3=!e!&'1.'3!=!)U%#:$%!+0%6%)'=$!5'%3!!'!(3!=3'(!!='(!3'.!(!3)!!%)'!#%!<br />

)DD=! )##($%! 2(! #%! 7D=+#=! )##($%! $+#! ;2L! A#%0.$@$%)#! A#(?#=3#.$$! -#! :#3#>!<br />

A#%0.$@3#($%! G6! $=$! )##(! '('+!%)'! 7#(! '3)!!! AU(D3:#=.#)$(B! ;%5'=! t! ^[! ;2L!<br />

A#%0.$@$%#!+'&$@!03'%!* V! :#3#>3#($%$%!7'(!!#%.'%+$1!7#.$.$($5$3$=!+$+.#:$%)#!C V !A#%#.$=!<br />

A(6G6!=')'(!5'%3!!'!(3!'!+'&$@!03)6=3'(!!'%3'!3:'=.')!(!N@s[B[^PB!!<br />

9#3#>!&$%)$3#($%!N* V 4!* d !-#!C V P!='(='+!:'3$7#.$!7'(!!#%.'%+$1!+$+.#:)#!#%.'%+$1!+$+.#:#!<br />

AU(#! )'&'! )DD=! 03:6.6(B! m(%#$%! #%.'%+$1! 7#.$.$($5$3$=.#! A#%0.$@3#(! $?$%! ='(='+!<br />

:'3$7#.$! ^Be]Ki_=AbZB^VKi_=A! '('+!%)'! G636%6(=#%4! 7'(!! #%.'%+$1! +$+.#:)#!<br />

^Be[Ki_=AbeB]WKi_=A! '('+!%)'! 03:6.6(B! 26(')'! )$=='.$! ?#=#%! G$(! G'='! &6+6+! $+#!<br />

#%.'%+$1! +$+.#:! $3#! 7'(!! #%.'%+$1! +$+.#:)#! ='(='+! :'3$7#.$! +!('3':'+!%!%! )#$$:$)$(B!<br />

L%.'%+$1! +$+.#:)#! #%! )DD=.#%! 7D=+##! +!('3':'! ;2L4! C V4 !* d4! * V ! -#! 2(! #=3$%)#!<br />

036(=#%4!7'(!!#%.'%+$1!+$+.#:)#!+!('3':'!* V 4!C V 4!2(4!;2L!-# ! * d! #=3$%)#)$(B!!c$=='.$!<br />

?#=#%! G$(! G'='! &6+6+! )'! #%! )DD=! )##(! $3#! #%! 7D=+#=! )##(! '('+!%)'=$! 1'(=!%!<br />

)#$:#+$)$(B!L%!)DD=!)##(!$3#!#%!7D=+#=!)##(!'('+!%)'=$!1'(=!#%.'%+$1!+$+.#:)#!#%!<br />

)DD=!)##($%!t]]'%?! +'3'7':'>=#%4! ! '7%!! =0633'()'!<br />

;2L!A#%0.$@$%)#%!G$(!&$%)$!G'!%'!='>'%?!d[B^!Ki!=')'(!036(B!c$#(!A#%0.$@3#(!$?$%!<br />

G6!)##(!#%.'%+$1!=0633'()'!dBfKibeBf!Ki!'('+!%)'!)#$$(B!X'(!!#%.'%+$1!+$+.#:)#!$+#!<br />

;2L! A#%0.$@$%)#%! G$(! &$%)$! G'!%'! A#3$(! VdBg! Ki! 036(=#%4! 2(! A#%0.$@$%)#! &'7-'%!<br />

G'!%'!='>'%?!ZBZ!Ki4!* V !G'!%'!='>'%?!)'!VgBg!Ki!036(B!!!!<br />

T0%6?! 03'('=4! =633'%!3'5'=! A#%0.$@$%! G#+$! ='G$3$7#.$! ;2L! A$G$! 7D=+#=! $+#! #%.'%+$1!<br />

7#.$.$(:#! +$+.#:$! +#?$3:#3$)$(B! 2(! 7'! )'! :#3#>! A#%0.$@3#(! 7#.$.$($3#5#=! $+#! 7'(!!<br />

#%.'%+$1! +$+.#:! )'&'! 7'('(3!! 03'5'=.!(B! H!+'5'4! #3)#! #)$3#%! :#3#>! A#%0.$@3#($%! 7'(!!<br />

#%.'%+$1!7#.$.$(:#!+$+.#:$%#!)'&'!67A6%!03)66!-#!G6!7U%3D!7#.$.$(:#!+$+.#:3#($%)#!<br />

=633'%!3:'+!%!%!)'&'!#=0%0:$=!03)66!+U73#%#G$3$(B!!<br />

$<br />

%+5,+A-+.$<br />

VBL3$G034!RB4!;=:'%4!nB4!KD(=036B9B4!kU()D=4!9B!-#!C6::$4!9BY!j0:@'($+0%!01!A(0Q.&!@#(10(:'%5#+!01!<br />

;:#($5'%!2(0%>#4! i'(A#! a&$.#! .6(=#7+! '%)!.&#$(! 5(0++#!6%)#(!$%.#%+$-#!'%)!+#:$b$%.#%+$-#!:'%'A#:#%.!<br />

50%)$.$0%+B!;(5&BC#13DA#3=B4d[[WhZ]YV]bd[B!<br />

dBT$@'&$4!jBY!L%.'%+$1! \$%)$! X#.$.$($5$3$$!3#.:#3#($%)#! H'(3!3!=!-#!8#($:3$3$=!;%'3$>3#($B!c0=.0('!K#>$B!<br />

;B`BT'3!=!2$3$:3#($!L%+.B!;%='('B!d[V[B!<br />

$<br />

$<br />

$<br />

$<br />

! CTH


" #HC $D(5F6O@&,-(A$%+,7,7,$L+5@+,'+-$b.&1()&$`+,'!)+-+.!$<br />

KLL"-#+).L)H'#%.&'0)E%.+"-1$%#()T'I).&);1$#73#($%$%! AU+.#(A#3#($%)#%)$(B! cD%7')'! V! :$37'(! $%+'%!%! 7'%$! .0@3':!<br />

)D%7'! %D16+6%6%! ! tVg3$=3#(4! .#=%030I$%$%! )0(6! G$(! #=$3)#!<br />

=633'%!3':'7!!4!%D16+!706%366%6%!G'+=!+!!'?3!!%!U%#:3$!+#G#@3#($!'('+!%)')!(B!!<br />

`3=#:$>)#! $+#! $%+'%3'(!:!>!%! ='(%!%!%! )07:'+!%!%! GD7D=! 0('%)'! +'3'%:'+!! -#!<br />

'?3!=.'%! U3#%! 7#.$=$%! $%+'%! ('@0(! #)$3:#:#+$%#! (':#%4! 7#.#($%5#! )#%A#3$!<br />

G#+3#%)$$:$>$! +U73#:#=! 6! '%! $?$%! @#=! )0(6! G$(! $1')#! )#$3)$(B! m>#33$=3#! 7#%$!<br />

%#+$33#($:$>$%! +'3!=3!! A#3$$:$! $?$%! .D=#.:#3#($! A#(#=#%! &'7-'%+'3! D(D%3#($%! :$=.'(!!<br />

A#3$:$!D3=#3#()#=$!:$=.'(!%!03)6=?'!A#($+$%)#)$(!NK'G30!VPB!<br />

!<br />

K'G30!VB!KD(=$7#4!;2c!-#!;2)#=$! 7#.#(+$>! G#+3#%:#%$%! G$(! AU+.#(A#+$! 03:'=3'! G#('G#(4!<br />

&'7-'%5!3!=!+#=.U(D%D%!A#3$$:$!'?!+!%)'%!)'&'!U%D%)#!6>6%!7!33'(!%!03)66!1$=($%$!)#!<br />

-#(:#=.#)$(B!!<br />

\'7-'%+'3! D(D%3#($%! .#(5$&! #)$3:#+$4! A#3$(! )D>#7$! -#! &'7-'%+'3! D(D%! 1$7'.3'(!73'! )'!<br />

)0(6)'%! $3$=$)$(B! \'7-'%+'3! D(D%! 1$7'.3'(!%!%! 0366:6%)'! $+#! 7#:! :'3$7#.3#($%$%!<br />

#.=$+$!tZ[#7$%)#)$(B!!<br />

H'(:'! 7#:! +#=.U(D! G$.=$+#3! -#! &'7-'%+'3! D(#.$:! '('+!%)'! ?$1.?$)#%! '3)!!%!! 7$%#!<br />

?$1.?$7#!-#(#(#=!=U@(D!-'>$1#+$!AU(#%!G$(!'A(0#%)D+.($)$(B!`3=#:$>)#=$!G$.=$+#3!D(#.$:!<br />

'(.!!&!>!%!%!&'7-'%+'3!D(#.$:!'(.!!&!>!%!%!A#($+$%)#!='3:'+!!='(:'!7#:!+#=.U(D%D%!<br />

67A6%!1$7'.3'()'!7#.#(3$!&'::'))#7#!#($$:$%$!#%A#33#:$.$(B!<br />

C('1$=!VB!-#!dB#(#!VWff!7!3!%)'!]V!:$370%!.0%!<br />

03'%! &6G6G'.! D(#.$:$:$>$%! d[V[! 7!3!%)'! )'! ]V! :$370%! .0%!03)664! VWff! 7!3!%)'!d4]!<br />

:$370%! .0%! 03'%! 7'3!! .0&6:36! G$.=$! D(#.$:$:$>$%! $+#! d[V[! 7!3!%)'! d4Z! :$370%! .0%!<br />

03)66!.'&:$%!#)$3:#=.#)$(B!X'%$4!:!+!(4!'(@'4!G6)'74!?'-)'(!-#!763'1!%!7#(!'3)!!!<br />

&6G6G'.!D(#.$:$:$>)#!d[!7!3!!'=!%!+D(#)$(!G$(!'(.!!03:':!4!+07'4!'7?$?#$4!=03>'!-#!<br />

?$$.$%!7#(!'3)!!!7'3!!.0&6:36!G$.=$!D(#.$:$%)#!$+#!+')#5#!g[[!G$%!.0%


C('1$=!VB!X!33'(!$.$G'($73#!.D(=$7#!&6G6G'.!D(#.$:$!N9$370%!K0%Pyy!<br />

yy:!+!(!)'&$3!#)$3:$.$(B!<br />

H'7%'=Y!K,H!<br />

!<br />

C('1$=!dB!X!33'(!$.$G'($73#!.D(=$7#!7'3!!.0&6:36!G$.=$!D(#.$:$!N9$370%!K0%P!<br />

y!K,H!.'&:$%$!<br />

!<br />

H'7%'=Y!K,H!<br />

!<br />

\6G6G'.! -#! 7'3!! .0&6:36! G$.=$! D(#.$:$:$>)#! U%#:3$! G$(! '(.!! 03:':'+!%'! (':#%!<br />

='(:'! 7#:3#()#! Z4^! :$370%! .0%! =!3:!! -#! $.&'3'.'! 7U%#3:#!<br />

='?!%!3:'>!03:6.6(B!<br />

2'.'!+07'!-#!D(D%3#($!03:'=!D>#(#!=633'%)!!:!>!7'3!!.0&6:!=D+@#3#($%$%!GD7D=!G$(!<br />

=!+:!! ;2c4! 2(#>$37'! -#! ;(I'%.$%


C('1$=!]B!X!33'(!$.$G'($73#!.D(=$7#!='(:'!7#:!D(#.$:$!N9$370%!K0%P!<br />

!<br />

H'7%'=Y!KD(=$7#:b2$(!-#!HHC9!='7!.3'(!!<br />

!<br />

C('1$=!gB!X#:!+'%'7$%#!'$.!$.&'3'.!:$=.'(!y!N9$370%!K0%P!-#!$.&'3'.!$?$%!U)#%#%!)##(!<br />

N9$37'(!c03'(P!<br />

!<br />

y!\6G6G'.3'(4!7'3!!.0&6:!=D+@#3#($!A$G$!.#:#3!='(:'!7#:!&'::'))#3#($!-#($3:$.$(4!<br />

-$.':$%4!:$%#('3!-#!@(#:$=+3#(!)'&$3!#)$3:#:$.$(B!<br />

H'7%'=Y!cK94!K,H!<br />

!<br />

K'G30!dB!cD%7'!A#%#3$%)#!.('%+A#%$=!D(D%!#=$3$!'3'%!!N9$370%!\'BP!<br />

! VWWe! d[[^! d[[e! d[[Z! d[[f! d[[W! d[V[!<br />

C#3$:$!`3=#3#(! ! ^e! eV! e^! Z[! Zd! ZZ!<br />

C#3$:#=.#!R3'%!`3=#3#(! ! ]g! gV! gW! ^^! ed! ZV!<br />

KRJi;9! VBZ! W[! V[d! VVg! Vd^! V]g! Vgf!<br />

H'7%'=Y!OT;;;!<br />

! CTT


!<br />

K'G30!]B!m%#:3$!+07'!D(#.$5$+$!D3=#3#()#!Cc!+07'!#=$:$!N9$370%!\'BP!-#!.0@3':!+07'!<br />

#=$:$%)#=$!Cc!+07'!0('%!!NtP!<br />

Cc!T07'! VWWZ! d[[^! d[[e! d[[Z! d[[f! d[[W! d[V[!<br />

;2c! g!NV]Py! d^!NfZP! dZ!NfWP! d]!NWVP! df!NWdP! dW!NWVP! dW!NW]P!<br />

;(I'%.$%! V!Nd]P! V^!NWWP! V^!NWWP! Ve!NW^P! Vf!NWWP! VW!NWWP! d[!NV[[P!<br />

2(#>$37'! [B]!NdP! VV!NgWP! VV!N^eP! V^!NeeP! Vg!Ne^P! Ve!NZVP! Vf!NZ^P!<br />

cD%7'! ^!NV[P! ^g!Ne[P! ^W!NegP! eVNefP! ee!NZ[P! eW!NZZP! Z]!NfVP!<br />

yJ'('%.#>! $?$%)#=$! ('=':3'(! .0@3':! +07'! #=$:$! $?$%)#=$! Cc! +07'! #=$3$! t


CcR#! $.&'3'.!! ]4Z! :$370%! .0%! 5$-'(!%)'!<br />

A#(?#=3#:$.$(B!;-(6@'!2$(3$$!)#!;2c4!;(I'%.$%4!2(#>$37'4!H'%')'!-#!J'('A6'7#($%)#! 0)'=3'%'('=4! G$7030I$=! ?#$.3$3$$%! =0(6%:'+!! -#!<br />

+D()D(D3#G$3$(! =633'%!:!! D>#($%)#! 036:+6>! #.=$3#(#! +'&$@! 03'G$3#5#=! -#! :0)#(%!<br />

G$70.#=%030I$!=633'%!3'('=!#3)#!#)$3:$!03'%!)#$.$($3:$!5'%3!!0(A'%$>:'3'(!%!AD-#%3$!<br />

%'=3$4! :6':#3#+$! -#! =633'%!:!! '3'%!%)'! 7#.#(3$! G$(! =0(6:'! )D>#7$%$%! +'3'%:'+!%'!<br />

='.=!)'! G636%:'=F! ':'?3'%:!.!(B! 26! @(0.0=03#! .'('1! 03'%! D3=#:$>)#! )#4! A#%#.$=!<br />

7'@!+!! )#$.$($3:$! D(D%3#($%! G$(! .'=!:! @(0+#)D(3#()#%! A#?#(#=! $.&'3'.!%!%! -#!<br />

=633'%!:!%!%!0%'73'%:'+!4!&'3=!%!G$3A$3#%)$($3:#+$4!$%+'%!+'3!!!-#!?#-(#!D>#($%)#=$!<br />

03'+!!($+=3#($%!U%3#%:#+$!$?$%!7'@!3:'+!!A#(#=#%3#(!A$G$!=0%63'(!!='@+'7'%!-#!;26'.3'(!73'!676:36!G$(!='%6%'!-#!7U%#.:#3$=3#($%#!$&.$7'?!)6763:6.6(B!<br />

d[[[':'%=$! ')!73'! ,36+'3! 2$70AD-#%3$=! H'%6%6! .'+3'!!<br />

&'>!(3'%:!! -#! AU(D3#(#! '?!3:!4! $+.$'(#! .0@3'%.!3'(!73'! ='%6%'! +0%! #=3$! -#($3:#7#!<br />

?'3!!3!(=#%4! de! L=$:! d[[W! .'($&$%)#! G6! ='%6%! ?!='(!3:')'%! U%5#! EC!)'! -#! X#:!<br />

;:'?3!!C#%#.$=!X'@!+!!c#$.$($3:$!R(A'%$>:'3'(!-#!`(D%3#($%$%!.&'3'.!4!3#%:#+$4!<br />

&('5'.!4!H0%.(03!-#!c#%#.$:$%#!c'$(!XU%#.:#3$=F!7'7!%3'%:!.!(B!T#=.U(D:D>D%!-#!<br />

$3A$3$!=#+$:3#($%!AU(DD%#!G'-6(63:')'%!?!='(!3'%!G6!7U%#.:#3$=!7'7!%3'%)!!!.'($&.#!<br />

7D(D(3D#! A$(:$4! G$(! A#?$! +D(#5$! -#($3:#:#+$4! 67A63'%:'+!%)'=$! AD?3D=3#(4! &#%D>!<br />

&$?G$(! A#%$%! 0%'73'%:':'+!%'! (':#%! #.$=#.3#:#! 7D=D:3D3DD! A#.$($3:#+$! A$G$!<br />

?#3$=$3#(!%#)#%$73#!7#:4!&'7-'%5!3!=!-#!A!)'!+#=.U(3#($!>'('('!6('.!3:!.!(B!!<br />

26!$3=!CcR!7U%#.:#3$$!$3#!G$(3$=.#!D3=#:$>#!)0(6!A#3#%!7#:!&'::'))#+$!.'!7'%!<br />

A#:$3#(! '?!=.'! G#=3#:#7#! -#7'! (0.'3'(!%!! G'='! D3=#3#(#! ?#-$(:#7#! G'3':!.!(B!<br />

CcR! )6(6:'! A#3$%:$.$(B! .&'3! D(D%3#($%!<br />

1$7'.3'(!%!%!'(.:'+!4!.'3#G$%!7#(3$!D(#.$:!'7?$?#$!.0&6:6!=D+@#+$!-#!@':6=!.0&6:6!<br />

=D+@#+$!A$G$!:6')$33#($%#!='7:'+!!+#G#G$73#!7#(3$!D(D%!&'::'))#!1$7'.3'(!%!!)'!t][b<br />

]^! 0('%!%)'! '(.!(:!.!(B! 26! D(D%3#()#=$! 1$7'.! '(.!3'(!! #%! ?0=! ='%'.3!! +#=.U(D%D!<br />

#.=$3#:$.$(B!H'%'.3!!+#=.U(D%)#!76:6(.'!-#!G#7'>!#.!$&('5'.!%!%!'(.'('=!)#-':!#..$$!<br />

)U%#:)#! G6! 7U%#.:#3$$%! ?!='(!3:'+!4! &'7-'%+'3! D(D%! $&('5'.!:!>!! )'! +#=.#7#!<br />

! CTZ<br />

_1-541.indd 284 29.02.2012 15:48


6('.:!.!(B!26!7U%#.:#3$=3#!G#('G#(!CcR!.'(.!:'3'(!%!'3#-3#%)$$!D3=#:$>)#4!CcR!<br />

='(!.!! 03'%! 7'! )'! 03:'7'%! &#(=#+! G6! 7U%#.:#3$$%! 7D(D(3D=.#%! ='3)!(!3:'+!%!!<br />

G#=3#:$4! G6! ':'?3'! :#)7'! )'! =633'%!3'('=! G$(! G'+=!! 67A63'%:!.!(B! 26! G'+=!3'(! -#!<br />

.$5'($!='7!@3'(!%#.$5#+$%)#!$3A$3$!7U%#.:#3$=!]!=#>!)#$.$($3:$.$(B!<br />

T0(6%3'(!%! 2$70AD-#%3$=! H'%6%6D3#5#$!<br />

)DD%D3:#=.#7)$! -#! de! 9'(.! d[V[! .'($&$%)#! $+#! 2$70AD-#%3$=! H'%6%6! e! '7! +0%('!<br />

7D(D(3D#!A$(:#=!D>#(#!7'7!%3'%:!.!(B!2$70AD-#%3$=!H'%6%6!)'!D3=#:$>)#!CcRD:!<br />

A#.$(#:#:$.$(B! 2$70AD-#%3$=! H'%6%6! 7'7!%3'%)!=.'%! e! '7! +0%('! 7D(D(3D#! A$(#5#=!<br />

03:'+!! +#G#G$73#4! CcR)#!)#!<br />

0%'73'%:!! -#! .$5'(#.! G$(! :D))#.! )'&'! )#-':! #..$($3:$.$(B! ;%5'=4! .D:! G6! +D(#?!<br />

$?#($+$%)#=$!G#3$(+$>3$=3#(4!.$5'($!#%)$#3#(4!&'::'))#!1$7'.!'(.!3'(!%!)#-':!#.:#+$%#!<br />

%#)#%! 03:6.6(B! 2$70AD-#%3$=! ='%6%6! 7'7!%3'%:')'%! U%5#! K299! G'.'! 03:'=!<br />

D>#(#!?#$.3$!@3'.10(:3'()'!7'@!3'%!.0@3'%.!3'()'!AU(D3#(!'=.'(!3:!4!'%5'=!G6%3'(!%!#%!<br />

U%#:3$3#($!='G63!#)$3:#:$.$(B!2$70AD-#%3$=!H'%6%6#:$%!&'>!(3'%:!.!(B!H'%6%)'4!G$(!'%3':)'!CcR$%5$($%!=0%.(03D%D%!<br />

G'-6(6! +'&$G$%#! 7D=3#%:#+$! -#! 5#>'$! &D=D:3#($%! ?0=! '!(! 03:'+!! A$G$! %#)#%3#(4!<br />

A#%#.$$!)#$.$($3:$!0(A'%$>:'3'(!%!0%'73'%:'+!!$?$%!G'-6(6!7'@:'+!!G#=3#%#%!A#%!<br />

+'&$@3#($%$!#%)$#3#%)$(:$!-#!G'-6(6!7'@:'=.'%!='?!%:'3'(!%'!%#)#%!03:6.6(B!<br />

V]! ;6+.0+! d[V[! .'($&$%)#! 2$70AD-#%3$=! H'%6%6:'3'(! -#! `(D%3#(#! c'$(! XU%#.:#3$=F! 7'7!%3'%:!4! de! L73D3!<br />

d[V[!.'($&$%)#!2$70AD-#%3$=!H'%6%6!$3#!G$(3$=.#!7D(D(3D#!A$(:$.$(B!<br />

26! 7U%#.:#3$$%! 7D(D(3D#! A$(:#+$73#! )'&'! U%5#! 7D(D(3D=.#! 03'%! 7U%#.:#3$=!<br />

='3)!(!3:!4! CcR3$=! 0(.':!! 7#%$)#%!<br />

0(.'7'!?!=:!.!(B!`3=#!$?$!+.0=3'(!%!=633'%!3:'7'!)#-':!#)$3:#+$!$3#!036:+6>!)6(6:6%!<br />

)'&'!)'!'(.'('=!1$7'.3'(!%!'!(!!7D=+#3:#+$%$%!U%D%#!A#?$3:$4!G6!+D(#?.#!G'.'!+07'!<br />

03:'=! D>#(#! ;2#(#!G'-6(6+6!7'@!3'%!]!')#.!<br />

+07'! A#%$! de! R5'=! d[VV! .'($&$%)#! 2$70AD-#%3$=! H6(636


!<br />

K'G30!ZB!CcR#(#4!G$.=$+#3!-#!&'7-'%+'3!D(#.$:!$3#!6(''%!?$1.?$3#(#!'-'%.'I!7'('.:'+!!)DD%D3#%!<br />

G$(?0=!7#%$!A#%$%!0%'73':'+!!7'@!3:!!-#!#=$:$%#!G'3'%:!.!(B!26%3'(4!R:#A'b]!7'!<br />

'+$)$! $?#($$! 7D=+#=! +07'3'(! A$G$! G#+$%+#3! '(.!3'(! 7'('.'%! D(D%3#($%! 7'%!%)'! &#(G$+$.!<br />

)$(#%?3$!D(D%3#()#%!036:'=.')!(B!d[VV!-#!d[Vd!7!33'(!%)'!G6!D(D%3#(!7#.$.$($3$@!)D%7'!<br />

@'>'(!%'! '(>! #)$3#5#=.$(B! 26! +D(#?! 03)6=?'! =!+'! 03:'=3'! G#('G#(4! G6! D(D%3#($%!<br />

D3=#:$>)#! &#%D>! 0%'73'%:':'+!! %#)#%$73#! 7D=3#:#3#()#! G63':'3'()'%! ='7%'=3!!<br />

03'('=!.#+@$.!#)$3:#+$!)6(6:6%)'!5$))$!.$5'($!='7!@3'('!%#)#%!03'G$3#5#=.$(B!!<br />

26! .$5'($! ='7!@3'(!%! U%3#%#G$3:#+$4! &'7-'%5!3!!:!>!%! >'('(! AU(:#:#+$! $?$%4!<br />

G'-6(6+6! 7'@!3'%! A#%3#($%! 0%'7! +D(#3#($%$%! =!+'! 03:'+!4! &#%D>! 0%'73'%:':!!<br />

D(D%3#($%! G63':')'%! ='7%'=3!! 03'('=! .#+')D1$! :$=.'(3'()'! G636%'G$3#5#$! ($+=$%#!<br />

='(!3!=!G$(!.03#('%+!)##($%$%!G#3$(3#%#(#=!7D(D(3D#!=0763:'+!%'!$&.$7'?!-'()!(B!<br />

EX#:!C!)'%!%!m>D)D(F!@(#%+$G$%)#%!&'(#=#.3#!$%+'%!+'3!!4!&'7-'%!(#1'&!!-#!?#-(#!<br />

AD-#%3$$! 7#:! +'%'7$5$+$%$%! G$($%5$! U%5#3$$)$(B! H'7%'=3'(!%! #=0%0:$=! 03'('=!<br />

=633'%!3:'+!4!$+('1.'%!='?!3:'+!4!67A6%!1$7'.3'()'!AD-#%3$!7#:3#($%!&'7-'%+'3!D(#.$:#!<br />

'(>! #)$3:#+$4! .'(!:!:!>!%! +D()D(D3#G$3$(3$$! $?$%! A#(#=3$)$(B! 26! )DD%5#! )#! 03'%! 7#:!<br />

+'%'7$5$3#($! G$3$:+#3! A#(?#=3#($! +D(#=3$! .'=$@! #.:#=.#! CcR


EVb!2$7030I$=!03'('=!'=.$1!A#%3#(!-#!@(0.#$%3#(!1'(=3!!:$=.'(3'()'!G636%:'=3'!G#('G#(4!<br />

A!)'3'(!%! -#! 7#:3#($%! 0(.'=! G$3##%3#($)$(B! T$%)$($:)#%! +0%('4! &'7-'%3'(!%! -#!<br />

$%+'%3'(!%! A'+.(0$%.#+.$%'3! 7033'(!%)'! )#(&'34! =!+'! cn;! -#7'! @#@.$.! 1('A:'%3'('!<br />

$%)$(A#%:#!G'3'(!<br />

db!!CcRD%! G$3$:+#3! =0%63'()'! AU(DD%#! G'-6()66! \'7-'%! 2#+3#:#! 2$3$:!<br />

c#(%#$!)#Y!<br />

!Ec#(%#$:$>h! G6AD%#! =')'(! 7'@!3:!! G$3$:+#3! ?'3!:'3'(! -#! L*T;!! &'7-'%+'3! A!)'! .D=#.$:$%)#%! 6>'=3'.!('5'=!<br />

+@#=D3'.$1! +U73#:3#(#! $.$G'(! #)$3:#:#+$! A#(#=.$$%$! =':6076%'! '?!=3':'=.')!(F!<br />

#=3$%)#!AU(D!G$3)$(:#=.#)$(B!<br />

KD:!G6!G$3A$3#(!)0(63.6+6%)'!&'7-'%5!3!!:!>!%!+D()D(D3#G$3$(3$$!$?$%4!2$70AD-#%3$=!<br />

='%6%6!-#!G6!='%6%'!G'3!!7U%#.:#3$=3#($%!)#!;2


" #HH $>&,&1(A$`+^!'!$2&(1(.(-)($i.6+,(9)+-+.$%F,7'7,/+$?F^-7)7,$<br />

j&6+1(K$k('A$:-6!'!,!,$j&/&,-&.($@&$D(-()'&-$>&._&A-&.-&$U&-(A(-&.$<br />

?"'+.&+).L)@".,0")H"2'#%C")@"$-",#%.&).&)O"&"#%-'00()A.8%L%"8)[$2'&%+7+)<br />

QOA[SZ)/-%"&#%L%-)5'-#+)'&8)6.&L0%-#+)<br />

$<br />

;3$!L+'.!H'('='7'!<br />

C'>$!`%$-#(+$.#+$!L5>'5!3!=!*'=D3.#+$4!K0=+$=030I$!;%'G$3$:!c'3!!<br />

!<br />

89&1$<br />

C#%#.$=! 7'@!+!! )#$.$($3:$!A!)'3'(!%! AD-#%3$$! =0%6+6%)'! .0@36:6%! ($+=! '3A!+!! $3#!<br />

G$3$:+#3!A#(?#=3#(!'('+!%)'!G$(!?#3$=$!+U>!=0%6+6)6(B!K#G3$)#!G6!?#3$=$%$%!%#)#%3#($!<br />

.'(.!!3'5'=.!(B!<br />

!<br />

:;'1.+:'3'(!%!<br />

NCcRP! .'(!:+'3! D(D%3#($! D>#($%)#=$! .'(.!:'3'(! D?! '%'! =0%6! D>#($%)#!<br />

0)'=3'%:'=.')!(B! VB! k#-(#! NG$7030I$=! ?#$.3$3$=! D>#($%#! 036:+6>! #.=$P4! dB! L=0%0:$!<br />

N.0&6:'!G'!:3!3!=P4!]B!%+'%!-#!&'7-'%!+'3!!!D>#($%#!#.=$B!!<br />

d[V[!.'($&3$!-#!^WZZ!+'7!3!!2$70AD-#%3$=!H'%6%64!Cc!D(D%!#=$:$%$!7'+'=3':!.!(B!26!<br />

)6(6:)'! G$7030I$=! ?#$.3$3$=! D>#($%#! 036:+6>! #.=$! -#! .0&6:'! G'!:3!3!=! $:)$3$=!<br />

.'(.!:'!)!!%)'!='3:'=.')!(B!;%5'=!$.&'3!#)$3#%!-#!7#:!+'%'7$!)'&$3!?#$.3$!'3'%3'()'!<br />

=633'%!3'%! CcR#($%)#=$! #.=$3#($! =0%6+6%)'! .0@36:6%! G$3$:+#3!<br />

A#(?#=3#(3#! U(.D:#7#%! %#A'.$1! ($+=! '3A!+!! U%#:3$! G$(! 1'=.U(! 03'('=! ='(!:!>'!<br />

?!=:'=.')!(B!!<br />

!<br />

>2$>!/+-+.$%F,7'7,/+$c&@'3:'=.')!(B!2$70.#=%030I$!=0%6+6%)'=$!G$3A$!)D>#7$!-#!($+=!<br />

'3A!+!%!%!U3?D:D%#!7U%#3$=!03'('=!VWWe4!VWWW4!d[[d4!d[[^4!d[V[!7!33'(!%)'!7'@!3'%!^!<br />

L6(0G'(0:#.#(! ?'3!:'+!%!%! +0%6?3'(!! Cc! A!)'3'('! .D=#.$5$! )#+.#$%$%! $+.$+%'+!>!<br />

03'('=!.D:!;2!D3=#3#($%)#!'>'3)!!%!!AU+.#(:#=.#)$(B!EL6(0@#'%+!'%)!2$0.#5&%030A7!<br />

$%! d[V[F! $+$:3$! ('@0()'! G6! #$3$:! 7!33'('! AU(#! ='(!3'.!(:'3!! 03'('=! '?!=3!=3'!<br />

AU(D3:#=.#)$(! NVPB! 26! ('@0()'%! U>#.3#%#%! N]d! D3=#)#%! V[! x6P! K'G30! V! )#! ;2!<br />

D3=#3#($%)#!ECc!A!)'3'(!)#+.#=3#%:#3$)$(F!AU(DD%#!='.!3'%!.D=#.$5$3#($%!7!33'('!AU(#!<br />

'>'3'%!0('%!!AU(D3:#=.#)$(B!!<br />

K'G30! V4! $%5#3#%)$$%)#! U>#3$=3#! +0%! ^! 7!3! $?$%)#! ;2! D3=#3#($%)#! Cc! A!)'3'('! 03'%!<br />

)#+.##!03'%!'>'3!!%!&!>3'%)!!!AU(D3:#=.#)$(B!C!)'!$3A$3$!($+=3#(!=0%6+6%)'!7'@!3'%!<br />

)$#(! G$(! L6(0G'(0:#.#(! ?'3!:'+!%)'!Cc!A!)'3'()'%! #%)$#! )67'%3'(!%!%!0('%!%!dZ!<br />

D3=#!0(.'3':'+!!03'('=!d[[^!7!3!%)'!!t!ed!$=#%!G6%6%!d[V[!7!3!%)'!t!ee!7'!?!=.!!!<br />

! CWC


G$3)$($3:$.$(!NdPB!C!)'!CD-#%3$$!c#(%#$!=0%6+6)6(B!26%'!='(!%!;2c!A$G$!#.$=#.!G$3A$+$!03:')'%!-#7'!;2!D3=#3#($!<br />

-#!KD(=$7#!A$G$!#.$=#.!67A63':'+!73'!'>!-#7'!?0=!Cc!D(D%!.D=#.:#7#%!D3=#!70=.6(B!<br />

c$#(!7'%)'%!)'!)D%7')'!.('%+A#%$=!#=$:!'3'%3'(!!)'!&!>3'!'(.:'=.')!(B!VWWe!7!3!%)'!<br />

dBf! :$370%! &#=.'(! 03'%! Cc! D(D%! #=$3$! '3'%3'(!! d[V[! 7!3!%)'! Vgf! :$370%! &#=.'('!<br />

7D=+#3:$.$(B!X'3%!>!d[V[!7!3!%)'!#=$3$!'3'%!'(.!!4!Vg!:$370%!&#=.'(!)$#(!G$(!)#7$3#!<br />

t!V[!)6(B!T07'4!:!+!(4!@':6=4!='%03'!A$G$!($+=!)##(3#%)$(:#+$%)#%!A#?$@!=633'%!:'!<br />

+6%63:6! D(D%3#(4! #=$:$%! .':':!%'! 7'=!%!%!! ='@+':'=.')!(B! 26! D(D%3#()#=$!<br />

.('%+A#%$=_A#3#%#=+#3!0('%!!)'!&#(!7!3!'(.:'=.')!(B!d[V[!('=':3'(!73'!+07'%!%!!t!fV4!<br />

:!+!(!%! t! dW4! @':66%! ! t! eg4! ='%03'%!%! t! dW! #=$:! '3'%!! .('%+A#%$=! G$.=$3#(#!<br />

'7(!3:!.!(!!N^PB!<br />

T07'! -#! :!+!(!%! 7#:! +'%'7$! $?$%! -'>A#?$3:#>! =0%6:64! U>#33$=3#! +07')'! D3=#!<br />

$&.$7'5!%!%4! D(#.$:3#! ='(!3'%:'+!%!%! :D:=D%! 03:')!!! -#! Cc! +07'%!%!%! )D%7'!<br />

D(#.$:$%)#=$! @'7!! )DD%D3)DD%)#! .('%+A#%$=! D(D%! $.&'3'.!! ='?!%!3:'>! 03'('=!<br />

'(.'5'=.!(B! Cc! D(D%! $?#(#%! 7#:! $3#! G#+3#%#%! &'7-'%3'(!%! D(D%3#($! A#(#=! 636+3'('('+!!<br />

:#->6'..'! A#(#=+#! 636+'3! :#->6'.!:!>)'! G$3$:+#3! -#($3#(! !!!%)'! Cc! A!)'! 03'('=!<br />

+!%!13'%)!(!3:':'=.')!(B! ;%5'=! =0%6%6%! 6>:'%!! 03:'7'%! -#! &#(! 1!(+'..'! G$3$:! )!!!<br />

G#7'%'.3'(3'!:#)7')'!7#(!'3:'7'!?'3!'%!'=')#:$+7#%3#(!+'7#+$%)#4!.0@36:6%!%#A'.$1!<br />

($+=!'3A!+!!G6!D(D%3#(#!=')'(!6>'%:'=.')!(B!<br />

!<br />

k('A$:-6!'!,!$B1A(-&5&,$a+A1G.-&.$$<br />

"$+=! G$(! 1''3$7#..#=$! $+.#%:#7#%! +0%6?3'(!%! A#(?#=3#:#! 03'+!3!!)!(B! XD(D:#=.#%4!<br />

7#:##! =')'(! #%! G'+$.! AD%3D=! #73#:3#(! )'&$3! &#(! 1''3$7#.! G#33$! 0('%3'()'! ($+=! .'!(B!<br />

X'':!E='G63!#)$3#G$3$(!($+=F!='-(':!!$3#!+D()D(D3#G$3$(B!2$(!1''3$7#..#=$4!U(%#$%!6?'=!<br />

703566%)'=$4! ($+=$%! ='G63! #)$3#G$3$(! ($+=! +!%!(3'(!! $?$%)#! 036@! 03:')!!! .#=%$=!<br />

@'(':#.(#3#(!-#!$&.$:'3$7#.!&#+'@3'(!73'!G$3$:+#3!03'('=!.#+@$.!#)$3#G$3$(B!;%5'=!'7%!!<br />

! CWH


($+=$%! '3A!3':'+!! 6>:'%3'(! -#! 6>:'%! 03:'7'%! +0='=.'=$! $%+'%! '('+!%)'! 1'(=3'(!<br />

AU+.#($(B!Cc!A!)'!=0%6+6%)'!6>:'%3'(!%!($+=!'3A!+!4!G$3$:+#3!-#($3#(#!)'7'%)!!!$?$%!<br />

G6! ($+=$%! A#(?#=3#:#! 03'+!3!!! $3#! 676:36)6(B! Cc! A!)'! =0%6+6%)'! .0@36:6%! ($+=!<br />

'3A!+!! $+#! G$3$:+#3! A#(?#=3#(! 7#($%#! @+$=030I$=4! +0+7'3! -#! =D3.D(#3! 1'=.U(3#(3#!<br />

7U%#.$3:#=.#)$(B!K0@36:6%!A#(?#=3#(3#!676:'7'%!($+=!'3A!3'(!!:0)#(%!.#=%030I$3#($%!<br />

67A63'%:'+!! -#! 7U%#.$3:#+$! =0%6+6%)'! =':6! 7U%#.$:3#($! -#! )$#(! 67A63'7!5!3'(!%!<br />

U%D%)#=$! U%#:3$! G$(! #%A#3)$(B! 26! %#)#%3#! ($+=! '3A!+!! ?0=! 7U%3D! '('.!(:'3'(!%!<br />

=0%6+6)6(! NePB! 26! '('.!(:'3'(! ($+=! %#)#%$%$%! U>#33$=3#($%$%! )#! '3A!)'! G#3$(3#7$5$!<br />

03)66%6! AU+.#(:#=.#)$(B! ;3A!7!! G#3$(3#7#%! ($+=! U>#33$=3#($! ($+=! 6>'7!! 03'('=!<br />

')3'%)!(!3'%!)$'A(':)'!N#=$3!VP!AU+.#($3:$.$(!NZPB!<br />

!!<br />

)8;5<br />

-?0DY 3?23D;DLD<br />

-?0DY 7B0:/!A1Y58075!951/35;<br />

@515L53!3D/31/2/!:B3=53!C82!28=3<br />

-?0DY A1B6LB1<br />

(8=3!C825:152!8Y80!9/231!<br />

!.! U(%#=3#! '?!=3'(+'=! )$'A(':)'! ='%!.3'%:!! &$?G$(! >'('(!!<br />

03:':'+!%'! ='(!%! cn;! .#=%030I$+$! +')'! -#! #%! D+..#4! ='%!.3'%:!! >'('(!%'! ='(!!!<br />

+$A'('! $?$:$%$%! 7'('..!!! &'+.'3!=3'(! +03! -#! '3.! GU3D:)#! :#(=#>#! 7'=!%! 03'('=!<br />

=0%6:3'%)!(!3:'=.')!(! Ne4ZPB! 26! )'! ($+=! '3A!+!%!%! G$3$:+#3! 03'('=! ='%!.3'%:!! >'('(!<br />

A$G$! +0:6.! G$(! +0%6?! 7#($%#! @+$=030I$=4! +0+7'34! =D3.D(#3! 1'=.U(3#(! -#! )676:3'()'%!<br />

#.=$3#%#%! +076.! G$(! ='-(':! 03)66%6! AU+.#(:#=.#)$(B! cn;! .#=%030I$+$! =0%6+6%)'!<br />

($+=3#(#! 7D=3#%#%! U>#33$=3#(! ?06%36=3'! :#)7'! -#! =0%6%6%! 6>:'%!! 03:'7'%3'(!%!<br />

G$3$:+#3! A#(?#=3#(3#! ?#3$#%! +U73#:3#($! $3#! #=$33#%:#=.#)$(B! 26! )'! cn;! .#=%030I$+$!<br />

=0%6+6%)'=$! ($+=! '3A!+!%!! =0(=6! G076.6%'! )0(6! ?#=:#=.#)$(B! 26! =0(=676! G#+3#7#%!<br />

G$(!)$#(!1'=.U(!)#!.0@36:6%!=0%6)'=$!G$3A$!#=+$=3$$)$(B!m(%#=!03'('=!;-(6@'!2$(3$$!<br />

D3=#3#($%)#! d[[^! 7!3!%)'! 7'@!3'%! G$(! EL6(0G'(0:#.#(F! ?'3!:'+!! +0%6?3'(!!<br />

AU+.#($3#G$3$(B! ;%=#.$! 5#-'@3'7'%3'(!%! t! gV


G6%'!='(!%!Cc!D(D%D%!cn;!$?#()$$%$4!t!^g#7$! =0%6+6%)'! &#(&'%A$! G$(! =6=6! 03:'7'%! ;:#($='! 2$(3#$=!<br />

c#-3#.3#($#7! G$3$:+#3! )'%!:'%3'(!! -#! )67'(3!! G$(!<br />

&6=6=!+$+.#:$!:#-56..6(B!26!D3=#)#!#%!61'=!G$(!$&:'3$%!)'&$!)'-'!=0%6+6!7'@!3)!!!<br />

)$=='.#!'3!%)!!%)'!Cc!A!)'3'(!%!>'('(3'(!%'!(':#%!G'!G0!G!('=!3)!!!)DD%D3#:#>B!<br />

26! G'+$.! U(%#=3#(! )'&$! Cc! A!)'3'(! =0%6+6%)'=$! U>#33$=3#! D3=#:$>)#! 7#(3#.$($3:#7#!<br />

?'3!!3'%!($+=!'3A!+!%!%!G$3$:+#3!-#($3#(3#!?#3$.$$%$!AU+.#(:#=.#)$(B!!<br />

C#3$:$! D3=#3#()#! G$3$:$! .#:+$3! #)#%! #%! D+.! =6(636! G$3$:! '=')#:$3#($)$(B! m(%#$%!<br />

Vfe]! 7!3!%)'! =6(63'%! ;2c! ,36+'3! 2$3$:! ;=')#:$+$! G6AD%! ]


A#3$.$(:#! +'1&'+!%)'! 03'%! -#! 3'G0('.6'(!%! )!!%'! ?!=!@! .$5'(#.3#:#:$! G$(! )#%#:#!<br />

D(D%D)D(P!.0=+$+$.#!036.6()66!$))$'+!4!"07'3!T05$#.7:'%3'(!A(6G6!<br />

.'('1!%)'%! $%5#3#%:$4! $))$'%!%! G$3$:+#3! :#.0)030I$! $3#! ?#3$=$+$! AU+.#($3:$.$(B! 26!<br />

#=$3)#! G$3$:! =6(6363'(!! .'('1!%)'%! 5$))$7#! '3!%!@! $%5#3#%#%! +'3!=! =0%6+6%)'=$!<br />

$))$'3'()'%!0%'73'%'%!.#=!G$(!$))$'!70=.6(B!!<br />

CD-#%3$=! =0%6%)'! 76='(!)'=$! $1')#! )#! 7#(! '3'%! '%'&.'(! 5D:3#! E#33$=3#(!='>'%)!(!3'%!<br />

.$5'($! D(D%3#()#! 0(.'=! %0=.'! A#%! .('%+1#($! $3#:$! 7'@!3:'+!)!(B! *'(=! $+#4! A#3#%#=+#3!<br />

7U%.#:3#(3#! 7'@!3'%! $7$3#.$(:#3#()#! 7D>3#(5#! A#%)#%! 036'%! G$(! A#%! @'=#.$%$%! 7#%$!<br />

D(D%#! .('%+1#($! 7#($%#! G$70.#=%030I$! D(D%3#($%)#! ':'5'! 67A6%b$+.#%#%! A#%N3#(P$%!<br />

.('%+1#(!#)$3:#+$)$(B!#=$3!d!x)#!G6!1'(=!AU+.#($3:$.$(B!<br />

\'%A$! 7U%.#:3#! D(#.$3$(+#! D(#.$3+$%! 7#%$! D(D%D%! =$:7'+'3! 7'@!+!! )#$#5#=.$(B! 26!<br />

)#$$=3$$%! +0%656! 03'('=! )'! .0=+$+$.#! 03'('=! ')3'%)!()!!:!>! 0(A'%$>:')'! &'+'(!<br />

036.6(:'! 03'+!3!!! 03'%! 7'@!3'(! 0(.'7'! ?!='G$3#5#=.$(B! 26! %0=.')'! G$70.#=%030I$!<br />

D(D%3#($!$3#!A#3#%#=+#3!D(D%3#(!'('+!%)'!G$(!1'(=!036:'=.')!(B!2$70.#=%030I$!D(D%3#($!<br />

7#%$!G$(!.#=%030I$!03)66!$?$%!.0=+$+$.#!.#+.3#($%#!)'7'3!!($+=!)##(3#%)$(:#!+D(#5$%)#%!<br />

A#?#(#=! =633'%!:'! +6%63)66! &'3)#! A#3#%#=+#3! D(D%3#(! &#(&'%A$! G$(! AD-#%3$=! .#+.$!<br />

67A63'%:')'%! )0(6)'%! =633'%!:'! +6%63:'=.')!(B! Cc! A!)'3'(! $?$%! A#3$.$($3#%! ($+=!<br />

)##(3#%)$(:#! +.('.#I$+$4! G$70.#=%030I$! D(D%D%D%! ='(!3!!! 03'%! A#3#%#=+#3! D(D%3#(3#!<br />

1'(=3!3!!%!! .#:#3! '3:'=.')!(! N#)##(3$=! =0%+#@.$PB! X!33'()!(! $%+'%3'(! .'('1!%)'%!<br />

.D=#.$3)$$! $?$%! Cc! A!)'! ='(!3!!! 03'%! A#3#%#=+#3! D(D%! A!)'! ($+=! )##(3#%)$(:#!<br />

+D(#5$%$%! G'3'%A!?! %0=.'+!%!! 036.6(:'=.'! -#! .':! 03'('=! AD-#%3$! +'7!3:'=.')!(B!<br />

C#3#%#=+#3! 7U%.#:3#(3#! !+3'&! #)$3:$! G$.=$+#3! D(D%3#(! AD-#%3$! ='G63! #)$3$@! AD-#%3$=!<br />

.#+.3#($%)#%!A#?$($3:#)#%!)0(6)'%!=633'%!3!(=#%4!G$.=$!G$70.#=%030I$+$!$3#!A#3$.$($3#%!<br />

D(D%3#(!A#3#%#=+#3!D(D%3#(3#!1'(=3!3!=3'(!%'!G'3!!03'('=!='@+':3!!AD-#%3$=!.#+.3#($%)#%!<br />

-#!($+=!'%'3$>$!+D(#5$%)#%!A#?$($3:#=.#)$(3#(B!!2$70.#=%030I$!D(D%3#($!$?$%!G6AD%!+U>!<br />

=0%6+6! 03'%! AD-#%3$=! .#+.3#($! -#! (#AD3'+70%3'(! A#3#%#=+#3! D(D%3#(#! )#! 67A63'%+'!<br />

G6AD%!=633'%!3'%!?0=!+'7!)'!A#3#%#=+#3!D(D%!G6!.#+.3#()#%!A#?#:#>)$B!H0%676!@'.'.#+!<br />

-#!7#(!1!+.!!!U(%#$!$3#!'?!=3'7'3!:!B!<br />

J'.'.#+.#! %U(0.0=+$=! A3$=0'3='30$.3#(! 03'%! +03'%$%! -#! ='=0%$%! G636%6(B! 9$=.'(3'(!!<br />

0(.'3':'! Z^! :A_=A! @'.'.#+.$(B! 26! A3$=0'3='30$.3#(! @$:#! $3#:$! +!('+!%)'! .'&($@!<br />

03:'>3'(B!%+'%3'()'!U3)D(D5D!)0>!]be!:A_=A!-D56.!'!(3!!!03'('=!&#+'@3'%:!.!(!NZ[!<br />

=A$37'! 1!%)!!! A#%$! .'!7'%! .'(%+A#%$=!<br />

+07'%!%! '3#(I#%! @(0.#$%3#(! .'!)!!%!%! '%3'!3:'+!%)'%! +0%('! @$7'+'7'! +D(D3:#+$%)#%!<br />

-'>A#?$3:#+$! G6%6%! #%! +!=! .#=('(3'%'%! U(%#$)$(B! ;%5'=! .'!)!!! #%! '>! Z! '3#(I#%!<br />

@(0.#$%! %#)#%$73#! '%'13'=+$! A$G$! U3D:3#! +0%6?3'%'G$3#%! '3#(I$=! (#'=+$70%3'(! )'! )'&$3!<br />

+!=3!=3'! '3#(I$7#! %#)#%! 03'%! 7#(! 1!+.!!4! A#3#%#=+#3! 7U%.#:3#(3#! D(#.$3)$$! $?$%!<br />

.D=#.$5$3#($%!67'(!3:'+!!)!!%)'!&$?G$(!(#AD3'+70%'!.'G$!03:')'%!@$7'+')')!(!!NVVPB!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

! CWT


!<br />

#=$3!dB!C#3#%#=+#3!XU%.#:!-#!2$.=$!2$70.#=%030I$!!`(D%3#($%)#!C#%!K('%+1#($!<br />

U323.3LD;!;8L/28!B2B0 4508!B2B0<br />

.5759!K50<br />

#6/Y<br />

7!!<br />

:BJ152L5!<br />

K50<br />

Z<br />

,323W23,3<br />

[<br />

H53!Y?3!K50!;2/0=952!578168<br />

.5759!K50<br />

'-1


%+5,+A-+.$<br />

VbL6(0@#'%!j0::$++$0%!Y!L6(0@#'%+!'%)!2$0.#5&%030A7!$%!d[V[B!2(6++#3+!Nd[V[PB!<br />

dbL6(0@#'%!j0::$++$0%!Y!*00)b(#3'.#)!"$+=+B!2(6++#3+!Nd[V[PB!<br />

]bC!)'!CD-#%3$$!c#(%#$!Y!KD(=$7#!C!)'!CD-#%3$$!2$3A$!cD>#7$!;('.!(:'+!B!+.'%G63!Nd[[fPB!<br />

gbH'7%'(4! JB4! L:#=4! 9BY! T'3!=! '3'%!%)'! AU(#-! 7'@'%! @#(+0%#3$%! A#%#.$$! )#$.$($3:$! 0(A'%$>:'3'(3'!<br />

NCcRP!$3A$3$!G$3A$!-#!.6.6:3'(!B!OOB!C!)'!CD-#%3$$!H0%A(#+$!2$3)$($!H$.'G!B!T'71'!]VB!<br />

^bO%.#(%'.$0%'3! T#(-$5#! 10(! .&#! ;5S6$+$.$0%! 01! ;A($b2$0.#5&! ;@@3$5'.$0%+Y!<br />

QQQB$+'''B0(A_(#+06(5#+_@6G3$5'.$0%+_G($#1+_gd_@@.+3$)#+_)#1'63.B'+@!NL($$:!dW_[]_d[VVP!<br />

ebT5&:$).4!9B!Y!O%-#+.$.'.$%A!($+=!@#(5#@.$0%B!J&c!K&#+$+4!8$#%%'4!;-6+.($'B!<br />

Zb*'6+.:'%4!LB9B4!R:#%%4!CBTBY!"$+=!'++#++:#%.!$%!Y!H3''++#%4!jBcBL)B!K0M$5030A7B!K&#!2'+$5!T5$#%5#!01!<br />

J0+$0%+B!Z.&!#)B!!95C('Qb\$33B!n#Q!X0(=B!d[[f!h!V[ZbVdfB!<br />

fbL6(0@#'%!j0::$++$0%!Y!L6(0@#'%+!'%)!2$0.#5&%030A7!$%!d[[^B!2(6++#3+!Nd[[ePB!<br />

Wba0(3)! \#'3.&! R(A'%$>'.$0%Y! d[! Å6#+.$0%+! 0%! C#%#.$5'337! 90)$1$#)! *00)+B!<br />

QQQBQ&0B$%._100)+'1#.7_@6G3$5'.$0%+_G$0.#5&_d[S6#+.$0%+_#%!NL($$:!dW_[]_d[VVPB!<br />

V[ba\R! *00)! ;))$.$-#+! T#($#+Y! 90%0A('@&+! 01! .0M$5030A$5'3! #-'36'.$0%+! T03'%$%#! '%)! j&'50%$%#B!<br />

&..@Y__QQQB$%5&#:B0(A_)056:#%.+_I#51'_I#5:0%0_-][I#VWB&.:!NL($$:!dW_[]_d[VVPB!<br />

VVb;3b96&+#%4! TB! 4! j3'(=#4! ;BLB4! H'A#%4! "BTB! Y! J#'%6.! '33#(A7! Y! '%! 0-#(-$#QB! j'%')$'%! 9#)$5'3!<br />

;++05$'.$0%!w06(%'3B!d[[]h!VefYVdZWbVdfgB!!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

! CWZ


" #HJ $D.F5-&.$`&)-&.(,/&$%+)&-(,+$P%&1&,'7%!! 5$-5$-3#(! =636?=')'%! ?!=.!=.'%! +0%('! dVB! AD%#! =')'(!<br />

=633'%!3:!.!(! N%! o! dWgh! Z! 5$-5$-_(#@3$='+70%PB! V[! t! =':#3$%'! =D+@#+$! -#7'! V[! t!<br />

=#.#%!.0&6:6!!.D=#.#%!&'7-'%3'(!%!5'%3!!'!(3!=3'(!!=0%.(03!A(6G6%)'=$!&'7-'%3'(!$3#!<br />

=!7'+3'%)!!%)'! G#3$(A$%! 03'('=! )DD=! G636%:6.6(B! H0%.(03! 7#:$%$! .D=#.#%!<br />

&'7-'%3'(!%!7#:$%#!$3'-#!G'=!(!='.!3:'+!!5'%3!!'!(3!=!-#!7#:!.D=#.$:$%$!.D:!?'3!:'!<br />

G076%5'!G#3$(A$%!03'('=!'(.!(:!.!(B!V[!t!=':#3$%'!=D+@#+$%#!G'=!(!$3'-#!#)$3:#+$!)#!<br />

dVB!AD%)#!5'%3!!'!(3!!!G#3$(A$%!03'('=!'(.!(:!!NJ!z![B[[VP!'%5'=!7#:!.D=#.$:$!-#7'!<br />

7#:)#%! 7'('(3'%:'7'! G$(! #.=$+$! 03:':!.!(B! 26%3'('! $3'-#.#%! +!5'=! ='(='+! '!(3!!4!<br />

-#($:$4! -#! ='(='+! @'(?'3'(!%!%! )'! =0%.(03! 7#:$%#! G'=!(! $3'-#+$! $3#! $7$3#.$$!<br />

G#3$(3#%:$.$(B!T!5'=!='(='+!'!(3!!!-#!-#($:$!$?$%!$+.'.$=+#3!03'('=!U%#:3$!G$(!2'=!(!M!<br />

c$7#.! #.=$+$! G#3$(3#%:$! -#! G6(')'%! )'! :!+!(b+07'! '!(3!=3!! =0%.(03! 7#:$%#! G'=!(!<br />

$3'-#+$%$%! )$#(! A(6@3'('! AU(#! )'&'! D+.D%! 03)66! G#3$(3#%:$.$(B! 26%6%3'! G#('G#(!<br />

='(='+!-#($:$%$%4!=0%.(03!r!G'=!(!-#!=':#3$%'!)$7#.3#($%$!.D=#.#%3#()#!)$#(3#($%#!AU(#!<br />

)'&'! $7$! 03)66! )'! +'@.'%:!.!(B! 26! ?'3!:')'%! #3)#! #)$3#%! +0%6?3'(! $3=! ]! &'1.'!<br />

G076%5'! G(073#(! 7#:$%#! V[! t! =#.#%! .0&6:6! -#7'! V[! t! =':#3$%'! =D+@#+$!<br />

='.!3:'+!%!%! G(073#(! 5'%3!! '!(3!!%!! )DD()DD%D! AU+.#(:$.$(B! 26%6%3'! G#('G#(!<br />

=':#3$%'!=D+@#+$%$!.D=#.#%!&'7-'%3'(4!7#:#!G'=!(!+D31'.!$3'-#+$%#!5'%3!!@#(10(:'%+!-#!<br />

='(='+! @'(':#.(#3#($%)#! '(.!! $3#! ='(!3!=! -#(:$3#()$(B! 26%6%! 7'%!%)'! V[! t! =#.#%!<br />

.0&6:6! .D=#.#%! &'7-'%3'(!%! 7#:$%#! G'=!(! ! $3'-#+$! $3#! &#(! &'%A$! G$(! 1'7)'!<br />

+'3'%':':!.!(B!!<br />

:,+*1+.$A&-()&-&.Y!=':#3$%'!=D+@#+$4!=#.#%!.0&6:64!G'=!(4!G(073#(!!<br />

!<br />

:;'1.+#)! 50:@3#.#! G305=! )#+$A%! Q$.&! '! d! M! ]! 1'5.0($'3!<br />

'(('%A#:#%.! Q'+! 6+#)!Q$.&! +#-#%! (#@3$5'.#+! 1(0:! &'.5&! .0! dV! )! 01! 'A#! N%! o!dWgh!Z!<br />

5&$5=+! @#(! (#@3$5'.#PB! n#$.&#(! @#(10(:'%5#! %0(! @(05#++$%A! 7$#3)+! Q#(#! +$A%$1$5'%.37!<br />

$%136#%5#)! G7! .&#! $%50(@0('.$0%! 01! )$#.'(7! 13'M+##)! NV[tP! 0(! 5':#3$%'! :#'3! NV[tP!<br />

50:@'(#)! .0! .&#! 50%.(03! Q$.&! %0! +6@@3#:#%.'3! j6B! \0Q#-#(4! '))$.$0%! 01! j6!<br />

! CW]


+$A%$1$5'%.37!$%5(#'+#)!G0)7!Q#$A&.4!A'$%!'%)!1##)!50%+6:@.$0%!01!.&#!G$()+!1#)!.&#!<br />

50%.(03!)$#.!.&(06A&06.!.&#!#%.$(#!+.6)7B!K&#!'))$.$0%!01!j6!.0!.&#!V[t!5':#3$%'!:#'3!<br />

)$#.!$%5(#'+#)!G0)7!Q#$A&.!NJ!z![B[[VP!G6.!%0!#11#5.+!01!j6!0%!1##)!50%+6:@.$0%!0(!<br />

1##)!50%-#(+$0%!Q#(#!%0.#)!'.!dV)B!O%!'))$.$0%4!&0.!5'(5'++!Q#$A&.4!7$#3)!'%)!5'(5'++!<br />

@'(.+! Q#(#! +$A%$1$5'%.37! $%5(#'+#)! $%! G$()+! 1#)! .&#! j6! +6@@3#:#%.#)! 50%.(03! )$#.B! ;!<br />

+$A%$1$5'%.!j6!G7!)$#.!$%.#('5.$0%!Q'+!0G+#(-#)!10(!&0.!5'(5'++!Q#$A&.4!7$#3)4!5'(5'++!<br />

@'(.+!'%)!G(#'+.!7$#3)!'3+0B!c'.'!1(0:!.&#!@(#+#%.!+.6)7!)#:0%+.('.#)!.&'.!#$.&#(!V[t!<br />

5':#3$%'!:#'3!0(!13'M+##)!5'%!G#!6+#)!.&(06A&06.!.&#!1$(+.!]!Q##=+!10(!G(0$3#(+!Q$.&!<br />

3$..3#! )#.($:#%.'3! #11#5.! 0%! A(0Q.&! @#(10(:'%5#B! *6(.&#(:0(#4! .&#+#! (#+63.+! +6AA#+.!<br />

.&'.!.&#!'))$.$0%!01!j6!+631'.#!(#+63.#)!$%!$:@(0-#)!@#(10(:'%5#!01!G$()+!1#)!.&#!50(%b<br />

+07!50%.(03!'%)!V[t!5':#3$%'!:#'3!)$#.!'+!Q#33B!;))$.$0%!01!V^[!@@:!j6!1(0:!j6!<br />

+631'.#! .0! )$#.+! 50%.'$%$%A! V[t! 13'M+##)! &')! %0! G#%#1$5$'3! #11#5.! 0%! A(0Q.&!<br />

@#(10(:'%5#!.0!dV!)B!!<br />

%&5$dF./'3$5':#3$%'!:#'34!13'M+##)4!50@@#(4!G(0$3#(!<br />

$<br />

>(.($<br />

H#.#%!.0&6:6!NT%&17)1+%#'#%++%717!iBP!?0=36!)07:':!!7'!'+$.3#($%$!-#!U>#33$=3#!)#!<br />

%b]! 7'! '+$.3#($%$! N'31'b3$%03#%$=! '+$.P! 7D=+#=! 0('%3'()'! $?#(#%! 7'3!! G$(! .0&6:)6(!<br />

N;I67'&! -#! '(=B4! VWWVPB! %+'%! -D56)6! G6! 7'! '+$.3#($%$! D(#.#G$3:#! 7#.#%#$%#! +'&$@!<br />

)#$3)$(!-#!G6!7D>)#%!)#!)$7#.!$3#!)!'(!)'%!'3!%:'+!!A#(#=:#=.#)$(!Nj6%%'%#!-#!'(=B4!<br />

VWW^PB! X'@!3'%! G$(! ?0=! ?'3!:')'! ='%'.3!! #.$! -#! 76:6(.'%!%! 3$%03#%$=! '+$.! $?#($$%$%!<br />

='%'.3!!7#:3#($%$%!%b]!7'!'+$.$!$?#($$%$%!'(.!(!3:'+!!$3#!'(.!(!3'G$3#5#$!G$3)$($3:$.$(!<br />

Nj'+.0%! -#! i##+0%4! VWW[h! \'(A$+! -#! L3+Q7=4! VWW]PB! 26%6%3'! G#('G#(4! =#.#%!<br />

.0&6:6%6%!7#:#!='.!3:'!)D>#7$!-#!10(:6%'!G'3!!03'('=!NK':!.0&6:4!7'!!#=+.('=.#!<br />

#)$3:$P! &'7-'%3'()'! 5'%3!! @#(10(:'%+!! '>'3..!!! )'! G$(! ?0=! )#1'! AU+.#($3:$.$(!<br />

N9')&6+6)&'%!-#!'(=B4!VWfeh!i##!-#!'(=B4!VWWVPB!<br />

j':#3$%'! +'.$-'4! 7'3'%5!! =#.#%! .0&6:6! 03'('=! )'! ')3'%)!(!3!(4! 2('++$5'! '$3#+$%#! '$.!<br />

7D=+#=!)D>#7)#!0:#A'b]!7'!'+$.$!$?#(#%!G$(!G'='!7'3!!.0&6:)6(B!H':#3$%'!=D+@#+$!<br />

$+#!7'!%!#=+.('=.#!#)$3:#+$%)#%!+0%('!A#($7#!='3'%!7'%!D(D%)D(!-#!U>#33$=3#!+06=!<br />

@(#+! $3#! 7'!! '3!%)!!! >':'%! 0:#A'b]! 7'! '+$.3#($%)#%! >#%A$%! 03)66! $?$%! ='%'.3!!<br />

G#+3#:#)#!=#.#%!.0&6:6%'!G$(!'3.#(%'.$1!03'('=!)DD%D3#G$3$(!Nl6G(4!VWWZh!J#$(#..$!-#!<br />

9#$%#($4! d[[ZPB! 26%6%3'! G#('G#(4! =':#3$%'! =D+@#+$! A36=0+$%03'.! ')!! -#($3#%! $=$%5$3!<br />

G$.=$! :#.'G03$.3#($%$! $?#(#G$3$(! -#! G6%3'(!%! )'! G(073#(! @#(10(:'%+!%!! 036:+6>! 7U%)#!<br />

#.=$3#)$$!AU+.#($3:$.$(!NK($@'.&$!-#!9$+&('4!d[[ZPB!"7&'%#%!-#!'(=B!Nd[[ZP!G(073#(!<br />

7#:$%#! ^! -#7'! V[! t! =':#3$%'! =D+@#+$! $3'-#+$%$%! [! $3#! VgB! AD%3#(! '('+!%)'! 7#:!<br />

.D=#.$:$%$! G'+=!3'7!@! GD7D:#7$! '>'3..!!%!! G$3)$(:$3#()$(B! ! 2(073#(! 7#:3#($%#!<br />

@(01$3'=.$=! )D>#7)#! Ns! Vd^! @@:P! G'=!(! $3'-#+$%$%! &'7-'%3'()'! 5'%3!! @#(10(:'%+!!<br />

'(.!()!!!AU+.#($3:$.$(!NJ#+.$!-#!2'='33$4!VWWePB!3A$%?!G$(!#=$3)#4!)0:6>3'()'!=03>'!<br />

=D+@#+$! $?#(#%! 7#:#! d[[! @@:! G'=!(! $3'-#+$%$%! G'>!! ':$%0! '+$.3#($%! $3#'3! +$%)$($:$%$!<br />

'(.!()!!!G$3)$($3:$.$(!N"0Q'%!#.!'3B4!VWWVPB!26%6%3'!G#('G#(4!6!'%'!=')'(!=':#3$%'!<br />

=D+@#+$!-#!=#.#%!.0&6:6!$?#(#%!G(073#(!7#:3#($%#!@(01$3'=.$=!)D>#7)#!G'=!(!$3'-#+$%$%!<br />

#.=$+$%$! $%5#3#7#%! G$(! '('.!(:'7'! ('+.3'%!3:':!.!(B! 26! 7D>)#%4! G6! '('.!(:'!!!VP!<br />

7#:#!.':!=#.#%!.0&6:6!-#!=':#3$%'!=D+@#+$!='.!3:'+!%!%!5'%3!!@#(10(:'%+'!#.=$+$%$!<br />

$%5#3#:#=h! -#4! dP! =':#3$%'! =D+@#+$! -#7'! =#.#%! .0&6:6%6%! 036:+6>! #.=$3#($%$!<br />

AU(#G$3:#=!-#4!]P!:6&.#:#3!036:+6>!#.=$3#($%!@(01$3'=.$=!)D>#7)#!NV^[!@@:P!G'=!(!<br />

$3'-#+$! $3#! %0(:'3#! )U%)D(D3D@! )U%)D(D3#:#7#5#$%$! G#3$(3#:#=! D>#(#!<br />

@3'%3'%3'%:!.!(B!<br />

$<br />

$<br />

! CZ#


c+1&.5+-$@&$c&1F1$<br />

[#5#&!X+%,#?*+&#+!<br />

26! ?'3!:')'! =633'%!3'%! .D:! 7U%.#:3#(! J#%%+73-'%$'! T.'.#! `%$-#(+$.#+$! \'7-'%!<br />

2'=!:!-#!H633'%!:!!=0:$.#+$!.'('1!%)'%!0%'73'%:!.!(!NO;j,j!ñdZZf]PB!K0@3':!dWg!<br />

')#.! V! AD%3D=! 7'.'! ='(!!=! 5$%+$7#..#! G(073#(! 5$-5$-! Nj0GG! M! ;-$'%bgfP! 30='3! G$(!<br />

=636?='&'%#)#%!.#:$%!#)$3:$.$(B!mD.D3:D!=#.#%!.0&6:6!-#!=':#3$%'!=D+@#+$!.$5'($!<br />

$3#.:#3#()#%!.#:$%!#)$3:$.$(B!j$-5$-3#(!.'(.!3!@4!='%'.!G'%)!!.'=!3:!!-#!.D:!)#%#:#!<br />

A(6@3'(!%)'! G#%>#(! G$(! G'3'%A!?! '!(3!!! 03'5'=! #=$3)#! 7#(3#.$($3:$.$(B! \'7-'%3'(!<br />

=0%.(033D!?#-(#+#3!'(.3'(!!03'%!G$(!0)')'!@'+3'%:'>!?#3$=.#%!G'3'%A!?!G'.'(7'3'(!%)'!<br />

dV!AD%!G076%5'!.6.63:63'()!(B!R)'!+!5'=3!!!G'3'%A!?.'!]g j!$=#%!dVB!AD%D%!+0%6%'!<br />

)0(6!=')#:#3$!G$(!#=$3)#!de j!7#!=')'(!)DD(D3:D.D(B!c#%#:#!)$7#.3#($!NK'G30!VPY!<br />

VP!H0%.(03!N:!+!(b+07'!1'+D37#+$!G'>3!Ph!dP!H0%.(03!r!V^[!:A!_!=A!G'=!(!NG'=!(!+D31'.!<br />

='7%'=3!Ph!]P!V[!t!=#.#%!.0&6:6h!gP!V[!t!=#.#%!.0&6:6!r!V^[!:A!_!=A!G'=!(!NG'=!(!<br />

+D31'.!='7%'=3!Ph!^P!V[!t!=':#3$%'!=D+@#+$h!eP!V[!t!=':#3$%'!=D+@#+$!r!V^[!:A!_!=A!<br />

G'=!(!NG'=!(!+D31'.!='7%'=3!PB!<br />

j$-5$-3#(!&#(!G$(!GU3:#)#!Z!5$-5$-!03'%!gd!')#.!GU3:#7#!e!)$7#.!('+.A#3#!)#%=!A#3#5#=!<br />

#=$3)#!7#(3#.$($3:$.$(!NZ!GU3:#!_!)$7#.h!%!o!Z!5$-5$-!_!GU3:#PB!k'3!:'%!%!Z4!Vg!-#!<br />

dVB! AD%3#($%)#! .D:! &'7-'%3'(! G$(#7+#3! 03'('=! .'(.!3:!! -#! GU3:#! G'!! 7#:! .D=#.$:$!<br />

G#3$(3#%:$.$(B!j'%3!!'!(3!=!'(.!!!-#!7#:)#%!7'('(3'%:'!0('%3'(!!&#+'@3'%:!.!(B!KD:!<br />

5$-5$-3#($%! +6! -#! =#%)$3#($%#! '7(!3:!! 03'%! 7#:3#(#! N.0>! 10(:)'P! '8) 0%9%#17) 03'('=!<br />

63':'3'(!%'!$:='%!-#($3:$.$(B!c$7#.3#(!$>0='30($=!-#!$>0%$.(0I#%$=!03'('=!&'>!(3'%:!!<br />

-#!':$%0!'+$.3#(!n"j!%$%!G#3$(..$$!$&.$7'?3'(!%!VV^!t!$!=')'(!03'5'=!#=$3)#!10(:D3#!<br />

#)$3:$.$(! Nn"j4! VWWgPB! 2'=!(4! 7#:3$=! G'=!(! +D31'.! @#%.'&$)('.! 03'('=! 7#:#!<br />

='.!3:!.!(B! c$7#.3#(! G#+$%! :'))#+$! =0:@0>$+70%6%6! G#3$(3#:#=! $?$%! '%'3$>!<br />

#..$($3:$.$(!N2'((0Qb;A##!3'G0('.0($#+4!9#:@&$+!KnPB!c#%#:#!)$7#.3#($%$%!$?#($$!-#!<br />

G#+$%!:'))#+$!=0:@0>$+70%3'(!!K'G30!VB!)#!AU+.#($3:$.$(B!H#.#%!.0&6:6!-#!=':#3$%'!<br />

=D+@#+$%$%!G#+$%!:'))#+$!=0:@0>$+70%6!$+#!K'G30!dB!)#!AU+.#($3:$.$(B!!<br />

!<br />

.#,-(!>#!X'+0'&'('!&#(&#+-!<br />

H#+$:&'%#7#!63'!3)!=.'%!+0%('4!&'7-'%3'(!=#+$:!&'..!%'!'+!3)!4!#3#=.($=!$3#!G'7!3.!3)!!<br />

NVV!84!VV!:;4!VV+P4!:'%6#3!03'('=!+03!='(0.$)!'(.#(!-#!I6A63#(!-#%3#(!=#+$3#(#=!='%3'(!!<br />

'=!.!3)!! NVB^! )'=$='P4!&'3':'! ='>'%!%'! '3!%)!! Ned! ! j4!d!)'=$='P4!-#! +#($! .D7! 703:'!<br />

:'=$%#+$%)#! .D73#($! 7036%)6B! ?! 0(A'%3'(!%! ?!='(!3:'+!! -#! 7!=':'! $3#:3#($! :'%6#3!<br />

03'('=!7'@!3)!B!H'(='+3'(!AUD+!N)#($!-#!=#:$=!G#('G#(P4!='%'.3'(4!'7'=!NG6.!-#!G'A#.!<br />

)#($!$3#!G#('G#(P4!='G6(A'!='1#+$!-#!+!(.!=#:$$!03'('=!@'(?'3'%)!B!J'(?'3'(!'7(!3)!=.'%!<br />

+0%('4! G$(#7+#3! 03'('=! .'(.!3)!=.'%! +0%('! +!5'=! ='(='+! '!(3!!! $3#! 7D>)#! -#($:3#($!<br />

&#+'@3'%:'=!D>#(#!.0@365'!.'(.!3:!.!(B!<br />

,6'6,6-1!\5'&-O!<br />

8#($3#(! C#%#('3! i$%#'(! 90)#3+! @(0+#)D(D! NT;T! O%+.$.6.#4! d[[]P! =633'%!3'('=! d! M! ]!<br />

1'=.U($7#3! 03'('=4! '%'! #.=$3#(! )$7#.! $?#($$! -#! G'=!(4! -#! )$7#.! $?#($$! $3#! G'=!(!<br />

$%.#('=+$70%6!03'5'=!#=$3)#!'%'3$>!#)$3:$.$(B!H'1#+!GU3:#3#($!)#%#:#!D%$.#+$!03'('=!<br />

=633'%!3:!.!(B! ;%'! #.=$3#(! J! z! [B[^! )D>#7$%)#! U%#:3$! 03)66%)'! 0(.'3':'3'(!<br />

'('+!%)'=$! 1'(=3!3!=3'(! c6%5'%ã+! :63.$@3#! ('%A#! .#+.$! =633'%!3'('=! G636%:6.6(!<br />

Nc6%5'%4!VW^^PB!<br />

$<br />

"F,7_$0&$?+.1!)+$<br />

]'5&!!X#+P%+('5,!<br />

j'%3!!'!(3!=4! 7#:! .D=#.$:$! -#! 7#:)#%! 7'('(3'%:'! $3#! $3A$3$! +0%6?3'(! K'G30! ]4! g! )#!<br />

+!('+!! $3#! AU+.#($3:$.$(B! 26! ?'3!:')'! G$(! ?0=! @'(':#.(#! $?$%! )$7#.! $?#($$! M! G'=!(!<br />

! CZ!


$%.#('=+$70%6!$+.'.$=+#3!03'('=!U%#:3$!G636%)66!$?$%4!+0%6?3'(!-#!.'(.!:'!'%'!#.=$3#(!<br />

7#($%#! )#%#:#! 0(.'3':'3'(!%'! )'7'3!! 03'('=! 7'@!3'5'=.!(B! KD:! ?'3!:'! G076%5'!<br />

.0@3':! :0(.'3$.#! gB[f! t! 03:6! -#! )#%#:#! A(6@3'(!! '('+!%)'! G$(! 1'(='!<br />

('+.3'%!3:':!.$(!N-#($!AU+.#($3:#:$.$(PB!!<br />

9!+!(b+07'! 1'+D37#+$! '!(3!=3!! =0%.(03! 7#:$%#! G'=!(! $3'-#+$! $3#! ZB! NJ! z! [B[VP4! VgB! NJ!<br />

z[B[[VP! ! -#! dVB! NJ! z! [B[[[VP! AD%3#()#! )$#(! )#%#:#! A(6@3'(!%'! AU(#! )'&'! 7D=+#=!<br />

5'%3!!'!(3!=3'(!#3)#!#)$3:$.$(!NK'G30!]PB!H':#3$%'!=D+@#+$!$?#(#%!)$7#.#!G'=!(!$3'-#+$!<br />

#%!7D=+#=!$=$%5$!5'%3!!'!(3!!%!036:'+!%'!703!'?:!!-#!VgB!AD%)#!=#.#%!.0&6:6!r!<br />

G'=!(! A(6G6%)'%! )'! )'&'! 7D=+#=! G$(! 5'%3!!'!(3!'! +'&$@! 03:+.6(! NJ! z! [B[[VPB! dVB!<br />

AD%)#! 5'%3!!'!(3!=! V[! t! =':#3$%'! r! G'=!(! A(6G6%)'! G'=!(! $3'-#! #)$3:#:$! =#.#%!<br />

.0&6:6!-#!5':#3$%'!)$7#.3#($%#!AU(#!G#3$(A$%!03'('=!1'>3'!G636%:6.6(!NJ!z![B[[[VPB!<br />

26(')'%! )'! G'=!(!%! V[! t! =#.#%! .0&6:6! '3'%! &'7-'%3'()'! )#$3! )#! V[! t! =':#3$%'!<br />

=D+@#+$!'3'%!&'7-'%3'()'!@#(10(:'%+!!'(.!(:')'!#.=$3$!03)66!'%3'!3:'=.')!(B!<br />

9!+!(b+07'! 1'+D37#+$! '!(3!=3!! 7#:#! G'=!(! $3'-#+$4! ?'3!:'%!%! .D:! '':'3'(!%)'! 7#:!<br />

.D=#.$:$%$! G'=!(! $3'-#! #)$3:#7#%! :!+!(b+07'! '!(3!=3!! 7#:#! AU(#! U%#:3$! 0('%)'!<br />

'(.!(:!.!(!NK'G30!gPB!9!+!(b+07'!1'+D37#+$!'!(3!=3!!7#:#!G'=!(!$3'-#+$!$3#!#3)#!#)$3#%!<br />

7#:!.D=#.$:$!ZbVg4!VgbdV!-#!VbdVB!AD%3#(!'('+!%)'!)'!)$#(!=#.#%!.0&6:6!-#!=':#3$%'!<br />

=D+@#+$! A(6@3'(!%'! AU(#! )#! U%#:3$! 0('%)'! 1'>3'! G636%:6.6(B! H#.#%! .0&6:6! -#7'!<br />

=':#3$%'! =D+@#+$! .D=#.#%! &'7-'%3'(!%! 7#:$%#! G'=!(! $3'-#+$! ?'3!:'%!%! V! $3#! dVB!<br />

AD%3#($!'('+!%)'!7#:!.D=#.$:$%)#!&#(!&'%A$!G$(!'(.!'!%#)#%!03:':!.!(B!26(')'%!)'!!<br />

=':#3$%'!=D+@#+$%#!!G'=!(!$3'-#+$!$3#!#3)#!#)$3#%!5'%3!!'!(3!=.'=$!'(.!!%!!7#:!.D=#.$:$!<br />

$3#!$3A$3$!03:')!!!'%3'!3:'=.')!(B!<br />

H0%.(03! -#! =':#3$%'! =D+@#+$! $3#! G#+3#%#%! &'7-'%3'(!%! 7#:)#%! 7'('(3'%:'3'(!! =#.#%!<br />

.0&6:6!$3#!G#+3#%#%!&'7-'%3'('!AU(#!?'3!:'!G076%5'!NV!$3#!dV!AD%3#(!'('+!P!)'&'!$7$!<br />

03:6.6(!NK'G30!gPB!V^[!@@:!)D>#7$%)#!G'=!(!$3'-#+$!Vg!$3#!dVB!AD%3#(!'('+!!-#!.D:!<br />

@#($70..'! NV! $3#! dVB! AD%3#(! '('+!P! 7#:)#%! 7'('(3'%:'7!! G'=!(! '3:'7'%3'('! AU(#!<br />

$+.'.$+.$=+#3!03'('=!U%#:3$!0('%3'()'!$7$3#.$(:$.$(B!26%6%3'!G#('G#(!?'3!:'%!%!&$?!G$(!<br />

'':'+!%)'! 7#:)#%! 7'('(3'%:'! D>#($%#! &#(! &'%A$! G$(! )$7#.! M! j6! $%.#('=+$70%6! )'!<br />

036:':!.!(B! 26! +0%6?3'(! G'=!(! +D31'.! ='7%'=3!! V^[! @@:! G'=!(!%! V! $3#! dVB! AD%3#(!<br />

'('+!%)'=$!G$(!?0=!@#(10(:'%+!@'(':#.(#+$%$!$7$3#.$()$$%$!)#!AU+.#(:$.$(B!<br />

c'&'!U%5#!7'@!3'%!?'3!:'3'()'!V[!t!)'%!1'>3'!=#.#%!.0&6:6%6%!G(073#(!7#:3#($%#!<br />

='.!3:'+!%!%! G(073#(! A#3$$:$%$! 036:+6>! 03'('=! #.=$3#)$$! AU+.#($3:$.$(! N;I67'&! -#!<br />

'(=B4! VWWVh! i##! -#! '(=B4VWWVPB! ;3>6#.'! -#! '(=B! Nd[[]P! G(073#(! 7#:$%#! f! -#7'! Ve! t!<br />

=#.#%! .0&6:6! ='.!3:'+!%!%! V! $3#! d]B! AD%3#(! '('+!%)'! 7#:! .D=#.$:$%#! G$(! #.=$+$%$%!<br />

03:')!!! 1'='.! GD7D:#)#=$! '>'3:'%!%! &':! 7'! -#! 7'! '+$.3#($%$%! +$%)$($:$%)#=$!<br />

'>'3:')'%! $3#($! A#3)$$%$! $))$'! #.:$3#()$(B! X'@!3'%! ?'3!:'3'()'! =#.#%! .0&6:6%6%!<br />

@#(10(:'%+! D>#($%#! 03'%! 036:+6>! #.=$+$%$%! 7'@!+!%)'! G636%'%! :D+$3'I4! 3$%'.$%! -#!<br />

+$7'%0I#%$=!A36=0>$.3#($%!-'(3!!%'!G'3!!)DD=!@(0.#$%!)##(3#%)$($3#G$3$(3$$!$3#!$3A$3$!<br />

03)66!G$3)$($3:$.$(!N9')&6+6)&'%!-#!'(=B4!VWfeh!K(#-$%0!-#!'(=B4!d[[[P!<br />

=':#3$%'!=D+@#+$!.D=#.#%!&'7-'%3'(!%!7#:!.D=#.$:$!-#!7#:)#%!7'('(3'%:'3'(!!G'=!(!<br />

$3'-#!#)$3:#7#%!=0%.(03!7#:$%$!7$7#%!&'7-'%3'()'%!1'(=3!!03:':!.!(!=$!G6!"7&'%#%!<br />

-#! '(=B! Nd[[ZP! %$%! +0%6?3'(!! $3#! 676:':'=.')!(B! ;7%!! 7'>'(3'(! 7#:! .D=#.$:$%)#=$!<br />

'(.!!!=':#3$%')'!G636%'%!!A36=0+$%03'.3'('!NddB[!:03_AP!G'3':!3'()!(B!X'@.!!:!>!<br />

G6!?'3!:')'!=633'%!3'%!=':#3$%'!=D+@#+$%)#!$+#!d[B]!:03_A!A36=0+$%03'.!G636%:6!<br />

1'='.!7#:!.D=#.$:$!-#!7#:)#%!7'('(3'%:'!$3'-#!G'=!(!'3:'7'%!=0%.(03!$3#!=!7'+3'%)!!!<br />

>':'%!G$(!1'(=3!3!=!G636%:':!.!(B!!<br />

X'@!3'%!G6!?'3!:')'!=':#3$%'!=D+@#+$!-#7'!=#.#%!.0&6:6%6%!036.6(:'+!!:6&.#:#3!<br />

@#(10(:'%+! )DDD%D! '>'3.'G$3:#=! $?$%! G(073#(! 7#:$%#! V^[! @@:! G'=!(! $3'-#! #..$=B!!<br />

"0Q'%!-#!'(=B!NVWWVP!=03>'!=D+@#+$!.D=#.#%!)0:6>3'(!%!7#:$%#!d[[!@@:!G'=!(!+D31'.!<br />

! CZC


='7%'=3!! G'=!(! $3'-#+$! $3#! A36=0+$%03'.3'(!%! $3#6:)'=$! &$)(03$>$%$%! '>'3)!!%!!<br />

G$3)$(:$3#()$(B!X'@!3'%!G6!'('.!(:')'!=':#3$%'!=D+@#+$!.D=#.#%!&'7-'%3'(!%!7#:$%#!<br />

G'=!(!$3'-#+$!$3#!5'%3!!'!(3!=.'!G#3$(A$%!G$(!$7$3#:#!+'3'%:!!1'='.!=#.#%!.0&6:6!'3'%!<br />

&'7-'%3'()'! G'=!(! $3'-#+$! $3#! G$(! @#(10(:'%+! '(.!!! +'3'%:':!.!(B! 26! )'! =#.#%!<br />

.0&6:6%)'!&#(!&'%A$!G$(!A36=0+$%03'.!G636%:':'+!!-#!)#!=#.#%!.0&6:6%6%!703!'?.!!!<br />

@(0G3#:3#($%!%#)#%$%$%!)'&'!1'(=3!!03:'+!!$3#!'?!=3'%'G$3$(B!!<br />

!<br />

.'+1',!X'+'(#6+#&#+-!<br />

K'G30!^ã!.#!AU+.#($3)$$!A$G$!)$7#.$%!G$3##%3#($!$3#!G'=!(!$3'-#+$!'('+!%)'!+!5'=!='(='+4!<br />

AUD+4! ='%'.4! G'5'=! -#! AUD+! ='1#+$! '!(3!=3'(!! NJ! z! [B[VP! $3#! ='(='+! -#! AUD+!<br />

-#($:3#($! NJ! z! [B[^P! D>#($%#! U%#:3$! $%.#('=+$70%3'(! 0(.'7'! ?!=:!.!(B! ! 9!+!(b+07'!<br />

1'+D37#+$!G'>3!!7#:#!V^[!@@:!G'=!(!$3'-#3$!7#:$!.D=#.#%!&'7-'%3'(!!:!+!(b+07'!G'>3!!<br />

=0%.(03! 7#:$%$! .D=#.#%3#(#! A0(#! )'&'! 1'>3'! +!5'=! ='(='+! '!(3!!4! ='(='+! -#($:$! -#!<br />

@'(?'!-#($:$%#!+'&$@!03:63'()!(B!2'=!(!$3'-#+$%)#%!&#(!%#!=')'(!:!+!(b+07'!G'>3!!7#:!<br />

)'&'! 1'>3'! 036:36! #.=$3#%:$+#! )#! =':#3$%'! =D+@#+$! $?#(#%! 7#:#! V^[! @@:! G'=!(!<br />

$3'-#+$!$3#!)'&'!$7$!='(='+!-#!='(='+!@'(?'!'!(3!=3'(!!-#!)'&'!7D=+#=!AUD+!-#($:$!NJ!<br />

z! [B[[VP! #3)#! #)$3:$! 03:'+!! =!+:#%! )#! 03+'! G6! ?'3!:')'=$! &$@0.#>$:$>$!<br />

)0(63':'=.')!(B!<br />

T0%6?! 03'('=4! :!+!(b+07'! G'>3!! 7#:$! .D=#.#%! &'7-'%3'(!%! 7#:$%#! V^[! @@:! G'=!(!<br />

$3'-#+$! 5'%3!! '!(3!=! -#! 7#:! .D=#.$:$%$4! =':#3$%'! =D+@#+$! -#! =#.#%! .0&6:6! $3'-#!<br />

#)$3:$! 7#:3#($! .D=#.#%3#(#! AU(#! )'&'! 1'>3'! $7$3#.$(:$.$(B! n0(:'3! )D>#7)#! G'=!(!<br />

$?#(#%! =':#3$%'! =D+@#+$! -#! =#.#%! .0&6:6! )$7#.3#($%$! .D=#.#%! &'7-'%3'()'! 7#:!<br />

.D=#.$:$%$! )#$:#)#%! 5'%3!! '!(3!=3'(!%! )D.DD! +'@.'%:!.!(B! ;7%!! >':'%)'!<br />

@(01$3'=.$=!)D>#7)#!G'=!(!%!=':#3$%'!=D+@#+$!.D=#.#%!&'7-'%3'(!%!5'%3!!@#(10(:'%+!-#!<br />

='(='+! @'(':#.(#3#($%$! =#.#%! .0&6:6! $?#(#%! )$7#.$! .D=#.#%3#(#! AU(#! $7$3#.$(:#!<br />

7#.#%#$%$%! 03)66! )'! AU+.#($3:$.$(B! 26%6%3'! G$(3$=.#! G6! +0%6?3'(!%!<br />

:#='%$>:'3'(!%!%!'?!=3'%'G$3:#+$!$?$%!)'&'!$3#($!?'3!:'3'('!$&.$7'?!G636%:'=.')!(B!<br />

$<br />

%+5,+A-+.$<br />

;I67'&4!;BRB4!i##4!HB\B4!\'()$%4!"BKB4!T$:4!wBTBY!j&'%A#+!$%!.&#!7$#3)!'%)!$%!.&#!1'..7!'5$)!50:@0+$.$0%!01!<br />

Q&03#!5'(5'++!'%)!+#3#5.#)! :#'.!@0(.$0%+!01!G(0$3#(!5&$5=#%+!1#)!1633b1'.!0$3!+##)+B!J063.B! T5$B!VWWVh!Z[Y!<br />

d][gbd]VgB!<br />

;3>6#.'4! jB4! "0)($A6#>4! 9BOB4! j6.63$4! 9BKB4! "#G03#4! ;B4! R(.$>4! iBKB4! j#%.#%04! jB4! K(#-$%04! wBY! L11#5.! 01!<br />

Q&03#! '%)! )#:65$3'A#)! 3$%+##)! $%! G(0$3#(! 5&$5=#%! )$#.+! 0%! )$A#+.'! -$+50+$.74! %6.($#%.! 6.$3$>'.$0%! '%)!<br />

$%.#+.$%'3!:$5(0130('B!2($.B!J063.B!T5$B!d[[]h!ggY!eZbZgB!<br />

j6%%'%#4! TBjB4! \':')#&4! 9BwB4! i$#)#4! ;BjB4! K&0:@+0%4! iB,B4! a03#-#(4! KB9BTB4! w#%=$%+4! cBwB;BY!<br />

n6.($.$0%'3!'..($G6.#+!01!.(')$.$0%'3!13'M+##)!$%!&#'3.&7!706%A!')63.+B!;:B!wB!j3$%B!n6.(BVWW^h!eVYedbefB!<br />

j'+.0%4!iB4!i##+0%4!TBY!"#+#'(5&!%0.#Y!c$#.'(7!13'M!'%)!#AA!50:@0+$.$0%B!J063.B!T5$BVWW[h!eWYVeVZbVed[B!<br />

c6%5'%4!cB"BY!963.$@3#!('%A#!'%)!:63.$@3#!*!.#+.+B!2$0:#.($5+BVW^^h!VVYVbgdB!<br />

\'(A$+4!JB!TB4!!8'%!L3+Q7=4!9BLBY!9'%$@63'.$%A!.&#!1'..7!'5$)!50:@0+$.$0%!01!@063.(7!:#'.!'%)!#AA+!10(!.&#!<br />

&#'3.&!50%+5$06+!50%+6:#(B!a0(3)ã+!J063.B!T5$B!wBVWW]h!gWYd^VbdegB!<br />

i##4!HB4!R30:64!wB9B4!T$:4!wBTBY!i$-#!@#(10(:'%5#4!5'(5'++!7$#3)4!@(0.#$%!'%)!#%#(A7!(#.#%.$0%!01!G(0$3#(!<br />

5&$5=#%+!1#)!5'%03'!'%)!13'M!1633b1'.!+##)+!'%)!.&#!(#+.0(#)!:$M.6(#+!01!:#'3!'%)!0$3B!j'%B!wB!;%$:B!T5$B!<br />

VWWVh!ZVYfWZbW[]B!<br />

9')&6+6)&'%4! HBKB4! "':#+&4! ! wBJB4! RA'Q6'4! KB4! T'+0='4! HB4! ! T$%A&4! nBY! c#.0M$1$5'.$0%! 01! 50::#(5$'3!<br />

3$%+##)!:#'3!10(!6+#!$%!G(0$3#(!('.$0%+B!J063.B!T5$B!VWfeh!e^YVegbVZVB!<br />

n'.$0%'3!"#+#'(5&!j06%5$3BBY!n6.($#%.!"#S6$(#:#%.+!01!J063.(7B!W.&!(#-B!#)BVWWgh!n'.$0%'3!;5')#:7!J(#++4!<br />

a'+&$%A.0%4!cjB!<br />

J#$(#..$4!JBCB4!9#$%#($4!CBY!*'..7!'5$)+4!5&#:$5'3!50:@0+$.$0%!'%)!0(A'%$5!:'..#(!)$A#+.$G$3$.7!01!+##)+!'%)!<br />

-#A#.'.$-#! @'(.+! 01! 1'3+#! 13'M! Nj':#3$%'! +'.$-'! iBP! '1.#(! )$11#(#%.! 3#%A.&+! 01! A(0Q.&B! ;%$:B! *##)B! T5$B!<br />

K#5&%03B!d[[Zh!V]]Y]gVb]^[B!<br />

J#+.$4!CB9B4!!2'='33$4!"BOBY!T.6)$#+!0%!.&#!1##)$%A!01!56@($5!+631'.#!@#%.'&7)('.#!'%)!56@($5!5$.('.#!.0!G(0$3#(!<br />

5&$5=#%+B!J063.B!T5$B!VWWehZ^YV[febV[WVB!<br />

! CZH<br />

_1-541.indd 299 29.02.2012 15:49


"0Q'%4!KBCB4!i'Q(#%5#4!KBiBwB4!!H#(+&'Q4!TBwBY!L11#5.+!01!)$#.'(7!50@@#(!'%)!'!@(0G$0.$5!0%!A3650+$%03'.#!<br />

50%5#%.('.$0%!$%!$3#'3!)$A#+.'!'%)!$%!1'#5#+!01!A(0Q$%A!@$A+!A$-#%!)$#.+!G'+#)!0%!('@#+##)!:#'3+B!;%$:B!<br />

*##)!T5$B!K#5&%03B!VWWVh]^YdgZbd^fB!<br />

"7&'%#%4!LBiB4!J#(..$3'4!TB4!K6@'+#3'4!KB4!8'3'I'4!wB4!L($=++0%4!jB4!!i'(=='4!HBY!L11#5.!01!j':#3$%'!+'.$-'!<br />

#M@#33#(!5'=#!0%!@#(10(:'%5#!'%)!:#'.!S6'3$.7!01!G(0$3#(+B!wB!T5$!*00)B!;A($5B!d[[ZhfZYVgfWbVgWgB!<br />

T;T!O%+.$.6.#B!d[[]B!T;T!,+#(6#.'4!jBY!!J(0.#$%!S6'3$.7!01!3$%+##)!10(!A(0Q$%A!<br />

G(0$3#(!5&$5=+B!;%$:B!*##)!T5$B!K#5&%03B!d[[[hfgYV^^bVeeB!<br />

K($@'.&$4! 9BHB4! 9$+&('4! ;BTBY! C3650+$%03'.#+! $%! '%$:'3! %6.($.$0%Y! '! (#-$#QB! ;%$:B! *##)B! T5$B! K#5&%03B!<br />

d[[ZhV]dYVbdZB!<br />

l6G(4!wBY!R$3b+##)!5(0@Y!j':#3$%'!+'.$-'B!O%)B!j(0@+!J(0)BVWWZh!VZYVeVbVeWB!<br />

!<br />

K'G30!VBc#%#:#!7#:3#($%$%!=0:@0>$+70%6!-#!G#+$%!:'))#+$!$?#($=3#($!N)0'3!&'3)#PB V !!<br />

! H0%.(03! H#.#%!.0&6:6! H':#3$%'!<br />

t! ! ! !<br />

9!+!(! ^fB^d! ^^BVZ! ^]B^f!<br />

T*Hbgf! dgB^[! VfBZ^! VZBW[!<br />

9!+!(!A36.#%!7#:$! WB]f! V[Bf]! WBZe!<br />

\'7-'%+'3bG$.=$+#3!7'! ]B^[! VBVV! gB^W!<br />

H#.#%!.0&6:6!N1633!1'.P! b! V[B[[! b!<br />

H':#3$%'!=D+@#+$!! b! b! V[B[[!<br />

H$(#?.'!! VB]d! VB]d! VB]V!<br />

c$='3+$76:!10+1'.! VBWd! VBfZ! VBW[!<br />

K6>! [Bgg! [Bgg! [Bg]!<br />

8$.':$%b:$%#('3!@(#:$=+$ d ! [Bd[! [Bd[! [Bd[!<br />

cib9#.$70%$%! [BV^! [BV]! [BV^!<br />

ibi$>$%!\ji! [B[f! [BVZ! [BVf!<br />

\#+'@3'%'%3'(! ! ! !<br />

9L!N=5'3_=AP! ]d[[! ]d[[! ]d[[!<br />

\':!@(0.#$%4!t! d]B[[! d]B[[! d]B[[!<br />

j'4!t! VB[[! VB[[! VB[[!<br />

'J4!t! [Bg^! [Bg^! [Bg^!<br />

i7+4!t!<br />

VBV[! ! VBV[! VBV[!<br />

9#.!r!j7+4!t!<br />

[BWW! [BWW! [BWW!<br />

K(@4!t! [Bd]! [Bd]! [Bd]!<br />

;(A4!t! VB]Z! VB]Z! VB]Z!<br />

;%'3$>$!7'@!3'%3'( ] ! ! ! !<br />

H94!t! W[Bee! W[BVe! fWBg^!<br />

\':!@(0.#$%4!t! ddB[W! ddB[e! ddB^^!<br />

L.#(!#=+.('=.4!t! ^BgZ! ZB[]! fBZ[!<br />

*$G#(4!t! dBg[! ]BV[! dBf[!<br />

HD34!t! ^Bef! ^BdV! ^B^Z!<br />

j64!@@: g ! VWBdV! VWBVd! V]BdZ!<br />

V H0%.(03!o!:!+!(b+07'!1'+D37#+$!)$#.h!H#.#%!.0&6:6!o!V[!t!=#.#%!.0&6:6!)$#.h!H':#3$%'!o!<br />

V[!t!=':#3$%'!=D+@#+$!)$#.B!j0%.(03!r!j64!=#.#%!.0&6:6!r!j64!-#!=':#3$%'!=D+@#+$!r!j6!<br />

)$#.3#($%#!G'=!(!+D31'.!@#%.'&$)('.!='.!3:!!-#!+!('+!!$3#!VefBg[!@@:4!V^^Be[!@@:!-#!VZ[BW[!<br />

@@:!j6!$?#()$=3#($!+'@.'%:!.!(B!<br />

d c$7#.$%!&#(!G$(!=$30A(':!%)'Y!-$.':$%!;4!e4[[^!O,h!-$.':$%!c4!d4[[V!O,h!-$.':$%!Lh!V[B[!O,h!<br />

($G013'-$%4!gB[!:Ah!c!@'%b!.0.&#%$5!'5$)4!ZB[!:Ah!%$'5$%4!][B[d!:Ah!5&03$%#4!]^[!:Ah!-$.':$%!<br />

2Vd4!f!Ah!G$0.$%4!g[!Ah!9%4!^W!:Ah!*#4!d^!:Ah!O4![B^[!:Ah!j64!g!:Ah!l%4!^[!:Ah!T#4!V]e!<br />

AB!<br />

] ;%'3$>3#(Y!2'((0Qb;A##!3'G0('.0($#+4!9#:@&$+!Kn!]fVVeb]^[ZB!<br />

!<br />

! CZJ


!<br />

K'G30!dB!H':#3$%'!=D+@#+$!-#!=#.#%!.0&6:6%6%!G#+$%!:'))#+$!=0:@0>$+70%6!N)0'3!&'3)#PB!<br />

H0:@0>$+70% V! NtP!<br />

H':#3$%'!=D+@#+$! H#.#%!.0&6:6<br />

H9!! WdB[d! W]Bef!<br />

\J d! ! ]gBWW! d]Bgg!<br />

L.#(!#=+.('=.!! V]B^^! ]fBfg!<br />

*$G#(!! WBW[! eB[[!<br />

HD3!! ^BeZ! ]Bgf!<br />

L+'%+$7#3!':$%0!'+$.3#( d !NtP! ! !<br />

;(A! dBfe! dBd[!<br />

\$+! [Bf]! [B^V!<br />

O3#! VBd^! [BW^!<br />

i#6! dBd[! VB]^!<br />

i7+! VB^W! [BWV!<br />

9#.! [B^W! [Bg]!<br />

J&#! VBgg! VB[f!<br />

K&(! VB]g! [Bf^!<br />

8'3! VBZ^! VBVe!<br />

L+'%+$7#3!03:'7'%!':$%0!'+$.3#( d !NtP ! !<br />

;3'! VB^d! VB[^!<br />

;+@! dBf]! dBVf!<br />

j7+! [BZg! [BgV!<br />

C36! ^BZg! gBge!<br />

C37! VBZZ! VB]f!<br />

J(0! VBZZ! [Bfg!<br />

T#(! VB^V! VB[e!<br />

V ;%'3$>3#(Y!2'((0Qb;A##!3'G0('.0($#+4!9#:@&$+!Kn!]fVVeb]^[ZB!<br />

d ;%'3$>3#(Y!L-0%$=!c#A6++'!j0(@B4!H#%%#+'Q!C;!][VggB!<br />

!<br />

K'G30! ]B! 2(073#(! 7#:$%#! H':#3$%'! =D+@#+$! NV[tP4! =#.#%! .0&6:6! NV[tP! -#! G'=!(! $3'-#+$%$%!<br />

5'%3!!'!(3!=!D>#($%#!#.=$+$!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

j'%3!!'!(3!=!NAP!<br />

c$#.!!<br />

CD%!V! CD%!Z! CD%!Vg! CD%!dV!<br />

H0%.(03! geBV! VgW ' ! ]e^'!<br />

eZ^'!<br />

H#.#%!.0&6:6! g^BW! Vgg G ! ]]Z 5 ! ^W[ G !<br />

H':#3$%'!=D+@#+$! geB[! Vgd G ! ]^d G ! eV] G !<br />

TL9! [Bgd! VBW! eBZ! fBf!<br />

2'=!(!$3'-#+$! ! ! ! !<br />

bj6! g^BZ! Vgg! ]ge G ! e[d G !<br />

rj6! geB]! Vge! ]^e ' ! e^[ ' !<br />

TL9! [B]g! VBe! ^B^! ZBd!<br />

c$#.!y!j6! ! ! ! !<br />

H0%.(03!b!j6! geB[! Vg] G ! ]gf G5 ! ed[ G5 !<br />

H0%.(03!r!j6! geB]! V^^'!<br />

]fg ' ! ZdW ' !<br />

H#.#%!.0&6:6!bj6! g^Be! VgZ G ! ]g^G5 ! ^W[ 5 !<br />

H#.#%!.0&6:6!r!j6! geB]! Vg[ G ! ]dW 5 ! ^W[ 5 !<br />

H':#3$%'!=D+@#+$!b!j6! g^BZ! VgV G ! ]gZ G5 ! ^W^5!<br />

H':#3$%'!=D+@#+$!r!j6! geB]! Vgd G ! ]^f G ! !e]V G !<br />

TL9! [B^]! dBe! !eBg! VdBV!<br />

@a8""$%! ! ! ! !<br />

c$#.! [BWdZf! [B[d[g! z![B[[[V! z![B[[[V!<br />

j6!$3'-#+$! [BVWd]! [B]f[W! [B[g[f! z![B[[[V!<br />

c$#.!y!j6! [BWgWZ! [B[[g^! [B[[[g! z![B[[[V!<br />

'b5 ;7%!!+D.6%)'!1'(=3!!D+.!+$:A#!.'!7'%!)##(3#(!G$(G$($%)#%!1'(=3!)!(!N@)z![B[^PB!<br />

V! c##(3#(!&#(!G$($%)#!Z!')#.!5$-5$-!G636%'%!Z!')#.!(#@3$='+70%6%!0(.'3':'+!)!(B!<br />

! CZN


K'G3#!gB!2(073#(!7#:$%#!H':#3$%'!=D+@#+$!NV[tP4!=#.#%!.0&6:6!NV[tP!-#!G'=!(!NV^[!<br />

@@:P!$3'-#+$%$%!7#:!.D=#.$:$!D>#($%#!#.=$+$ V !<br />

!<br />

!<br />

X#:!.D=#.$:$!NAP!<br />

c$#.!<br />

CD%!VbZ! CD%!ZbVg! CD%!VgbdV! CD%!VbdV!<br />

H0%.(03! V][! ]de ' ! gWg ' ! WgW ' !<br />

H#.#%!.0&6:6! V]]! ][] G ! ggd G ! fZZ G !<br />

H':#3$%'!=D+@#+$! VdV! ]V[ 'G ! ggZ G ! fZf G !<br />

TL9! ]B^! ^Bg! VVB^! VdB^!<br />

j6!$3'-#+$! ! ! ! !<br />

bj6! VdZ! ][W! ggg G ! ffV G !<br />

rj6! Vdf! ]Ve! gZf ' ! Wd] ' !<br />

TL9! dBW! gBg! WBg! V[Bd!<br />

c$#.!y!j6! ! ! ! !<br />

H0%.(03!b!j6! VVW G ! ]V[ G5 ! g^d G ! ffd G !<br />

H0%.(03!r!j6! Vg[ ' ! ]gV ' ! ^]e ' ! V[VZ ' !<br />

H#.#%!.0&6:6!b!j6! V]e ' ! ]Ve G ! ggg G ! fWe G !<br />

H#.#%!.0&6:6!r!j6! VdW 'G ! dW[ 5 ! g]W G ! f^f G !<br />

H':#3$%'!=D+@#+$!b!j6! VdZ 'G ! ][d G5 ! g]^G!<br />

feg G !<br />

H':#3$%'!=D+@#+$!r!j6! VVe G ! ]VZ G ! g^W G ! fW] G !<br />

TL9! ^B[! ZBZ! VeB]! VZBZ!<br />

@b)##($! ! ! ! !<br />

c$#.! [B[^Zf! [B[VZ]! [B[[[^! [B[[[e!<br />

j6!$3'-#+$! [Bfg[d! [B][^^! [B[[]V! [B[VVW!<br />

c$#.!y!j6! [B[[]^! [B[[de! [B[[eW! [B[[[]!<br />

'b5 !;7%!!+D.6%)'!1'(=3!!D+.!+$:A#!.'!7'%!)##(3#(!G$(G$($%)#%!1'(=3!)!(!N@)z![B[^PB!<br />

V !c##(3#(!&#(!G$($%)#!Z!')#.!5$-5$-!G636%'%!Z!')#.!(#@3$='+70%6%!0(.'3':'+!)!(B!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

K'G30! ^B! 2(073#(! 7#:$%#! =':#3$%'! =D+@#+$! NV[tP4! =#.#%! .0&6:6! NV[tP! -#! G'=!(!<br />

NV^[!@@:P!$3'-#+$%$%!7#:)#%!7'('(3'%:'!D>#($%#!#.=$+$B V!<br />

! !<br />

*j"!NAYAP!<br />

c$#.!<br />

CD%!VbZ! CD%!ZbVg! CD%!VgbdV! CD%!VbdV!<br />

H0%.(03! VBde G ! VB^d 'G ! VBeV G ! VB^V G !<br />

H#.#%!.0&6:6! VB]e ' ! VB^Z ' ! VBZ^'!<br />

VBeV ' !<br />

H':#3$%'!=D+@#+$! VBdZ G ! VBgf G ! VBZV ' ! VB^g G !<br />

TL9! [B[d^! [B[]]! [B[]]! [B[V]!<br />

j6!$3'-#+$! ! ! ! !<br />

bj6! VB][! VB^g! VBZg ' ! VB^f ' !<br />

rj6! VBdW! VB^V! VBeg G ! VB^] G !<br />

TL9! [B[dV! [B[de! [B[dZ! [B[V[!<br />

c$#.!y!j6! ! ! ! !<br />

H0%.(03!p!j6! VBdd! VB^d! VBeg! VB^]!<br />

H0%.(03!r!j6! VBdW! VB^d! VB^f! VB^[!<br />

H#.#%!.0&6:6!p!j6! VB]^! VBe[! VBfV! VBeg!<br />

H#.#%!.0&6:6!r!j6! VB]Z! VB^]! VBeW! VB^f!<br />

H':#3$%'!=D+@#+$!b!j6! VB]g! VBgf! VBZ^! VB^Z!<br />

H':#3$%'!=D+@#+$!r!j6! VBdV! VBgf! VBee! VB^d!<br />

TL9! [B[]^! [B[g]! [B[gZ! [B[VW!<br />

@b)##($! ! ! ! !<br />

c$#.! [B[gWW! [B[ggV! [B[[[W! [B[[[V!<br />

j6!$3'-#+$! [BZfg]! [B]Z^f! [B[[d[! [B[[f[!<br />

c$#.!y!j6! [B[ee]! [B^eZZ! [BZ[We! [Bf[ee!<br />

'bG !;7%!!+D.6%)'!1'(=3!!D+.!+$:A#!.'!7'%!)##(3#(!G$(G$($%)#%!1'(=3!)!(!N@))z![B[^PB!<br />

V !c##(3#(!&#(!G$($%)#!Z!')#.!5$-5$-!G636%'%!Z!')#.!(#@3$='+70%6%!0(.'3':'+!)!(B!<br />

! CZT


K'G30!eB!j'%3!!'!(3!=4!+!5'=!='(='+!'!(3!!!-#!='(='+!@'(?'3'(!%!%!'!(3!=!-#!-#($:3#($!NdV!AD%P!<br />

!! ! T!5'=!='(='+! H'(='+!@'(?'!'!(3!=3'(!!NAP! H'(='+!@'(?'!-#($:$ f !NtP!<br />

!!<br />

j; V ! ;!(3!= d 8#($: ]<br />

!CUD+<br />

NAP! NAP! NtP!<br />

H'%'.3'(^ 2'5'=3'( e CUD+!<br />

='1#+$ Z CUD+ H'%'.3'( 2'5'=3'(! CUD+!<br />

!<br />

='1#+$!<br />

c$#.! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !<br />

!H0%.(03! efg ' ! g]W ' ! egBV ' ! V]d ' ! ^g ' ! V]f ' ! VVg ' ! ][BV! VdBg! ]VBe G ! deB[!<br />

!H#.#%!.0&6:6! ^W[ G ! ]ZV 5 ! edBf G ! V[Z 5 ! ge G ! Vd[ G ! Wf 5 ! dfBf! VdBe! ]dB] ' ! deBg!<br />

!H':#3$%'!=D+@#+$! edV G ! ]WW G ! egBd ' ! Vd[ G ! gW G ! Vde G ! V[e G ! ][BV! VdB]! ]VBe G ! deBZ!<br />

!TL9! WBg! fBZ! [Bed! dBf! [BW! dBV! ]BV! [Bdd! [BVV! [B]V! [Bd[!<br />

j6!$3'-#+$! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !<br />

!bj6! eVV G ! ]ff G ! e]Bg! VVg G ! gf G ! Vdg G ! V[]! dWBg! VdBg! ]VBW! deBe!<br />

!rj6! egW ' ! gVZ ' ! egBd! Vd^'!<br />

^d ' ! V]d ' ! V[f! ][B[! VdB^! ]VBZ! d^BW!<br />

!TL9! ZBZ! ZBV! [B^[! dB]! [B]! VBd! dB^[! [BdV! [BVV! [Bd[! [BVV!<br />

c$#.!y!j6! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !<br />

!H0%.(03!p!j6! e]d G ! g[[ G5 ! !e]Bd G5 !Vd[ G5 ! ^[ G ! VdZ G ! V[g G ! ][B[ 'G VdBg! ]VBf! d^BW!<br />

!H0%.(03!r!j6! Z]^'!<br />

gZf ' ! !e^B[ ' ! Vg^'!<br />

^W ' ! V^[ ' ! Vd^'!<br />

][B] 'G VdB]! ]VB]! deBV!<br />

!H#.#%!.0&6:6!p!j6 ^WZ G ! ]Ze G5 ! !edBW G5 !VV[ 5) ! gZ G ! VdV G ! Wf G ! dWBd 'G5 VdB^! ]dBd! deBV!<br />

!H#.#%!.0&6:6!r!j6 ^f] G ! ]ee 5 ! !edBe 5 ! V[^)!<br />

ge G ! VVf G ! WZ G ! dfB^G5 VdBe! ]dBg! deBg!<br />

! H':#3$%'!=D+@#+$!b! e[e G !<br />

j6!<br />

]ff G5 ! !egB[ 'G VVg G5) ! gf G ! Vd] G ! V[Z G ! dWBg 'G5 VdBg! ]VBf! dZBf!<br />

! H':#3$%'!=D+@#+$!r! e]^G!<br />

j6!<br />

gV[ G ! egBe ' ! Vd^G!<br />

^[ G ! VdW G ! V[^G!<br />

][Be ' ! VdB]! ]VB^! d^Be!<br />

!TL9! V]Bg! VdB]! ![BWV! gB[! VBd! ]B[! gB]! [B][! [BVV! [Bg[! [B][!<br />

@b)##($! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !<br />

!c$#.! z[B[[[V z[B[[[V [B[[[^ z[B[[[V z![B[[[V z![B[[[V ![B[[[V! [BVVZd ![B[Zee [B[Ve]! [B^V]W!<br />

!j6!$3'-#+$! z[B[[[V ![B[[]d [B[e[e [B[[df! [B[[d[! ![B[VVZ! ![B[W]d! [B[W[g ![BZgef [BgdZ^! [BVff[!<br />

!c$#.!y!j6! z[B[[[V [B[[dV! [B[gg[ [B[[dg! ![B[[df! ![B[[ZV! ![B[[dd! [B[]]d ![B][gd [Bggg]! [B[e^Z!<br />

'b) !;7%!!+D.6%)'!1'(=3!!D+.!+$:A#!.'!7'%!)##(3#(!G$(G$($%)#%!1'(=3!)!(!NJ!z![B[^PB!<br />

V j'%3!!'!(3!=4!+!5'=!='(='+!-#!='(='+!@'(?'3'(!!'(#!]!(#@3$='+70%)'=$!Z!&'7-'%!%!0(.'3':'3'(!)!(B !<br />

d T!5'=!='(='+!'!(3!!!+06.:'!.'%=!%)'%!U%5#!'3!%:!.!(B!<br />

] T!5'=!='(='+!5'%3!!'!(3!!%!7D>)#+$)$(B!<br />

g CUD+!'!(3!!!)#($!-#!=#:$=!$3#!G#('G#()$(B!<br />

^! H'%'.3'(!&6:#(6+4!(')$0b63%'!-#!:#.'='(@'3!=#:$=3#($!)#($!$3#!G#('G#(!$?#(:#=.#)$(B!<br />

e! 2'5'=4!G6.!-#!)(6:+.$5=$!)#($!$3#!G#('G#(!$?#(:#=.#)$(B!<br />

Z CUD+!='1#+$!GUG(#=3#($!)#!$?#($(B!<br />

f J'(?'!-#($:3#($!+!5'=!='(='+!'!(3!!%'!0('%3'(!)!(B!<br />

! CZW


" #HN $`&)$%+1A!-+.!3$:@.7^+$D(.-((,/&$`+'+-$27.7)$<br />

5""8)J88%#%C"+4)T"2'0)/#'#1+)%&)K1$.,"'&)P&%.&)<br />

!<br />

w'%!H0+3'5>!<br />

J030%7'!*L*;n;!J3'.10(:6!2'='%!!<br />

!<br />

89&1$<br />

;-(6@'! 2$(3$$! 7#:! $3#! $3A$3$! 03'('=! 7!33'(! $?#($+$%)#! A#3$.$($3#%! #%! ='@+':3!! 7'+'3!<br />

?#(?#-#7#! +'&$@.$(B! T0%! AD%3#()#! G$(! ?0=! )D>#%3#:#! -#! 7U%#.:#3$$4! ='@+':3!!<br />

#73#:3#(! $3#! )#$.$(:#7$! ':'?3'7'%! U%#:3$! 7'+'3! ?'3!:'3'(! 7'@!3:!.!(B! 26!<br />

1''3$7#.3#(! #+%'+!%)'! X#:! H'.=!3'(!! .#+5$3$! $3#! $3A$3$! 7#%$! +$+.#:! -#! =6('33'(! 0(.'7'!<br />

?!='(.!3:!.!(B!!<br />

X#%$! +$+.#:4! 7#:! ='.=!3'(!%!%! L*T;! N;-(6@'! C!)'! CD-#%3$=! H6(6:6P! .'('1!%)'%!<br />

A#(?#=3#.$($3#%! AD-#%3$=! )##(3#%)$($3:#+$%$! .'=$G#%! Tj*j;\! NC!)'! l$%5$($! -#!<br />

\'7-'%!T'3!!!!c'$:$!H0:$.#+$P!.'('1!%)'%!A#(?#=3#.$($3#%!($+=!7U%#.$:$!GU3D:D!$3#!<br />

7#:!='.=!+!%!%!&'7-'%!G#+3#:#+$%)#!7'+'3!=633'%!:!!$3#!$3A$3$!&D=D:3#($!$?#(#%!.#+5$3!<br />

G#7'%%':#+$%$%! -#($3:#+$! $3#! +0%6?3'%'%! +D(#?.#%! 036:'=.')!(B! L*T;00.#5&%$5'3F! '%)! E5055$)$0+.'.+! '%)!<br />

&$+.0:0%0+.'.+F4!'+!Q#33!'+!1'33$%A!Q$.&$%!.&#!+50@#!01!j0::6%$.7!C9R!3#A$+3'.$0%4!<br />

0%37!&03)#(!01!.&#!'6.&0($+'.$0%!5'%!1$(+.!@3'5#!+65&!@(0)65.!0%!.&#!L,!:'(=#.B!O%!5'+#!<br />

01!%0%b&03)#(!+@#5$1$5!'))$.$-#+4!@(0)65.+!&'-#!.0!50:@37!Q$.&!.&#!+@#5$1$5'.$0%+4!'+!<br />

$%536)#)!$%!(#3#-'%.!'6.&0($+$%A!"#A63'.$0%B!<br />

! CZZ


LM$+.$%A! @(#-$06+37! '6.&0($+'.$0%! Ea$.&06.! .$:#! 3$:$.F! $+! (#@3'5#)! G7! .&#! V[! 7#'(+!<br />

'6.&0($+'.$0%4!'1.#(!Q&$5&!@(0)65.+!%0.!+6@@0(.#)!G7!(#b(#A$+.('.$0%!)056:#%.+!Q$33!G#!<br />

(#:0-#)!1(0:!.&#!:'(=#.!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

>(.($<br />

;-(6@'! 2$(3$$4! 7#:! $3#! $3A$3$! 03'('=! 7!33'(! $?#($+$%)#! A#3$.$($3#%! #%! ='@+':3!! 7'+'3!<br />

?#(?#-#7#! +'&$@.$(B! T0%! AD%3#()#! G$(! ?0=! )D>#%3#:#! -#! 7U%#.:#3$$4! ='@+':3!!<br />

#73#:3#(!$3#!)#$.$(:#7$!':'?3'7'%!U%#:3$!7'+'3!?'3!:'3'(!7'@!3:!.!(B!m(%#$%!7#%$!<br />

?!='%! ZeZ_d[[W! NVP! +'7!3!! X#:! J'>'(3':'+!! XU%#.:#3$$4! f! ')#.! #+=$! 7'+'3!<br />

67A63':'7!!7D(D(3D=.#%!='3)!(:!.!(B!!<br />

;2! :#->6'.!%'! AU(#! +.'%)'(.! ='(:'! 7#:3#(! .#:#3! 03'('=! $=$! .$@! G$3##%)#%!<br />

036:'=.')!(Y! ! 7#:! :'))#3#($! -#! 7#:! ='.=!3'(!B! X#:! :'))#3#($! G$.=$+#3! -#7'!<br />

&'7-'%+'3! 0($I$%3$! D(D%3#(! 036@4! .#:#3! ':'?3'(!! &'7-'%3'(!%! @(0.#$%4! #%#(I$4!<br />

:'=(0:$%#('33#(4! -G! .#:#3! G#+$%! G$3##%3#($%$! $?#(#%! G#+3#%:#! $&.$7'?3'(!%!!<br />

='(!3':'=.!(B! X#:! 9'))#3#($! H'.'306! 03'('=.'! G$3$%#%! ! 7#:! :'))#3#($%$%! '?!=!<br />

3$+.#+$!dgd_d[V[!NdP!+'7!3!!7U%#.:#3$=3#!G#('G#(!7'7!%3'%:!.!(B!H'.'30=.'!7#(!'3:'7'%!<br />

&#(&'%A$! G$(! G'='! 7#:! :'))#+$! 7#:3#()#! =633'%!3:')'%! U%5#! ;-(6@'! X#:!<br />

L%)D+.($+$! K#:+$35$3#($! .'('1!%)'%! $%.#(%#..#! 7'('.!3'%! X#:! 9'))#3#($! i$+.#+$%)#!<br />

0%'73'%:!! 03:'3!)!(B! TU>=0%6+6! 3$+.#7#! G$3A$! A$($$4! '%!3'%! 7#:! :'))#+$%$! ;2!<br />

@'>'(!%'!+D(#%!.'('13'(5'!=#%)$!)$33#($%)#!7'@!3:'=.')!(B!!!<br />

X#:! ='.=!! :'))#3#($4! &'7-'%3'(!%! -#($:3$3$$%#! -#! D(D%3#(#! 036:36! ='.=!! +'3':'=!<br />

A$G$!G$(!-#7'!G$()#%!1'>3'!+@#+$1$=!':'5'!7U%#3$=!03'('=!G$3#(#=!7#:3#(#!='.!3:'=.')!(B!<br />

2$(!D(D%!'7%!!'%)'!&#:!7#:!:'))#+$!&#:)#!7#:!='.=!!:'))#+$!03':'>B!"#+:$!-#!<br />

7'+'3! G'3'7!5!3!!! 03'%! ;2! .'('1!%)'%! 0%'73'%:!! 7#:! ='.=!! :'))#3#($! 3$+.#+$! ;2!<br />

(#+:$! $%.#(%#.! +$.#+$%)#! EVf]V_d[[]F! N]P! +'7!3!! XU%#.:#3$$! NLjP! 67A6%! 03'('=!<br />

&'>!(3'%'%! ;-(6@'! 2$(3$$! X#:! H'.=!! 9'))#3#($! i$+.#+$F! ')!! '3.!%)'! 7'7!%3'%:!.!(B!<br />

TU>=0%6+6! 3$+.#%$%! $?#($$! ='.=!! :'))#3#($! $3#! $3A$3$! 7'+'3! )D>#%3#:#3#()#! 7'@!3'%!<br />

)#$$=3$=3#(#!AU(#!)D>#%3$!03'('=!AD%5#33#%:#=.#)$(B!!!<br />

!<br />

`&)$A+1A!$)+//&'($1+,!)!$@&$/(&.$5&)$;(-&&,-&.(,/&,$K+.A!$$<br />

EX#:!='.=!!:'))#3#($F!$3#!$3A$3$!(#+:$!;2!.'%!:!!E7#:!:'))#3#($!-#!U%!='(!!:3'(!!<br />

&'($?! ''!)'! G#3$(.$3#%! 10=+$70%3'()'%! G$(! -#7'! G$(='?! .':#+$%$%! A#(?#=3#:#+$!<br />

':'5!%'!7U%#3$=!03'('=!7#:!-#7'!+67'!G$3#(#=!='.!3'%!:'))#3#(4!:$=(0!0(A'%$>:'3'(!<br />

-#7'!@(#@'('.3'()!(F!!!<br />

N'P!7#:$%!U>#33$=3#($%$!036:36!7U%)#!#.=$3#(4!<br />

NGP!&'7-'%!D(D%3#($%$%!U>#33$=3#($%$!036:36!7U%)#!#.=$3#(4!<br />

N5P!+D+!G'3!=3'(!!-#!=63'(!%!%!(#%A$%$!036:36!7U%)#!#.=$3#(4!<br />

N)P!&'7-'%3'(!%!G#+$%!$&.$7'?3'(!%!!='(!3'(4!<br />

N#P!&'7-'%!D(#.$:$%!?#-(#+#3!+0%6?3'(!%!!036:36!7U%)#!#.=$3#(4!<br />

N1P! G$3&'++'! &'7-'%! 7#:$%$%! +$%)$($3#G$3$(3$$%$! -#7'! G'!(+'=! 130('+!%!! 036:36!<br />

#.=$3#7#(#=!&'7-'%!D(#.$:$4!@#(10(:'%+!!-#7'!(#1'&!%!!036:36!7U%)#!#.=$3#(!-#7'!<br />

NAP!=0=+$)$0+.'.$=!-#7'!&$+.0:0%0+.'.$=!#.=$+$!-'()!(B!<br />

\#(&'%A$! G$(! D(D%D! $3A$3$! -#! )0(6! ='.#A0($7#! 7#(3#.$(:#! ':'5!%'! 7U%#3$=! 03'('=4!<br />

7#:!:'))#3#($4!7#:!='.=!!:'))#3#($4!G$70+$)'3!D(D%3#(!-#!-#.#($%#(3$=!.!GG$!D(D%3#($!<br />

'('+!%)'=$!1'(=3'(!$3#! $3A$3$!'%'!#+'+3'(!!G#3$(.#%!(#+:$!HR9TXRn!K;8TXLiL"!<br />

NgP!d[VV!7!3!%)'!7'7!%3'%:!.!(B!TU>=0%6+6!)0=D:'%!'%!3'%!D(D%!='.#A0($3#($!$?$%!.D:!<br />

7'+'3! .'%!:3'(!! ='@+':3!! G$(! #=$3)#! U>#.3#:#=.#! 036@! '7%!! >':'%)'! '('3'(!%)'=$!<br />

D+.D%3D=! )6(6:6%6! )'! 0(.'7'! =07:'=.')!(! N! U(%#$%! 8#.#($%#(3$=! K!GG$! `(D%3#($!<br />

! CZ]


:#->6'.!! X#:! 9#->6'.!%!%! D>#($%)#)$(PB! C#%#33$=3#! &'7'..'! .':! '%3':!73'! G$(!<br />

='.#A0($)#!7#(!'3'%!D(D%3#(!03)66!A$G$!+!%!(3'()'!)03''%!D(D%3#()#!:#-56..6(B!2'>#%!<br />

67A6%!G$(!D(D%!='.#A0($+$!G#3$(3#:#=!+0%!)#(#5#!>0(!03'G$3$(!-#!7'%3!!.'%!:3':'%!%4!<br />

D(D%D! @'>'()'%! A#($! ?'!(:'=! N-#! +U>=0%6+6! :'))#! $3#! D(#.$3#%! 7#:$P! A$G$! 03'+!!<br />

+0%6?3'(!!+0%!)#(#5#!'!(!#=0%0:$=!+!=!%.!3'('!-#!D(#.$5$%$%!$.$G'(!='7G!%'!703!'?'G$3$(B!<br />

`(#.$5$3#($%! D(D%3#($%$! 67A6%! #=$3)#! +!%!13'%)!('G$3:#3#($%)#! *L*;n;! N;2! X#:!<br />

2$3##%3#($! -#! H'(!!:3'(!! ,>:'%3!=! 2$(3$$P! 7'()!:5!! 03:'=! D>#(#! G$(! G$3A$+'7'(!<br />

@(0A(':!! &'>!(3':'=.')!(B! TU>=0%6+6! @(0A(':!%! .#+.! '':'3'(!%)'! +0%'! A#3$%:$!<br />

036@4!)'&'!+0%('!*L*Ln;!$%.#(%#.!+$.#+$%)#%!D5(#.+$>!03'('=!$%)$($3#G$3#5#=.$(B!!!!<br />

X#:! ='.=!! :'))#+$! 03'('=! =633'%!3'%! =0=+$)$0+.'.$=! -#! &$+.0:0%0+.'.$=3#(! $+.$+%'!<br />

03:'=! ='7)!! $3#! d[[V_fd_Lj! N^P! +'7!3!! c$(#=.$1.#! .'%!:3'%)!!! D>#(#! $3#:#!<br />

7'()!:5!3'(!! -#! -#.#($%#(3$=! .!GG$! D(D%3#($! 7#:! ='.=!! :'))#+$! 03'('=! ='G63!<br />

#)$3:#:#=.#)$(3#(B!<br />

X#:!='.=!!:'))#3#($!Vf]V_d[[]!NeP!+'7!3!!XU%#.:#3$=.#!3$+.#3#%#%!G$(!-#7'!G$()#%!?0=!<br />

='.#A0($!$?$%)#!7#(!'3'5'=3'()!(!Y!<br />

N'P! .#=%030I$=! ='.=!! :'))#3#($! Y! .#=%030I$=! G$(! ':'?! $?$%! 7#:#! ='.!3'%! &#(&'%A$! G$(!<br />

:'))#h!<br />

NGP!)676+'3!='.=!!:'))#3#($!Y!7#:#!='.!3:'+!!$3#!G$(3$=.#!7#:$%!0(A'%'3#@.$=!N)676+'3P!<br />

U>#33$=3#($%$! -#7'! &'7-'%)'%! #3)#! #)$3#%! A!)'%!%! AU(+#3! U>#33$=3#($%$! A#3$.$(#%! -#7'!<br />

)#$.$(#%!&#(&'%A$!G$(!:'))#h!<br />

N5P!G#+$%+#3!='.=!!:'))#3#($h!<br />

N)P! >00.#=%$=! ='.=!! :'))#3#($Y! +'3!=! )6(6:6! $7$! 03'%! &'7-'%3'(!%! @#(10(:'%+!%'!<br />

036:36! 7U%)#! ='.=!! +'3':'=! -#7'! ?#-(#7$! 036:36! 7U%)#! #.=$3#:#=! $?$%! =633'%!3'%!<br />

&#(&'%A$!G$(!='.=!!:'))#+$h!<br />

N#P!=0=+$)$0+.'.$=!-#!&$+.0:0%0+.'.$=3#(B!<br />

!<br />

`&)$A+1A!$)+//&-&.(,(,$O.&1()($<br />

;2=0%6+6! D(#.$5$3#(! $3A$3$! G$($:3#(! .'('1!%)'%! 0%'73'%:'=.'! -#! =0%.(03!<br />

#)$3:#=.#)$(3#(B!<br />

;2! )!!%)'=$! D(#.$5$3#(! $?$%+#4! +U>=0%6+6! D(#.$5$3#($%! ;2'(!%'! +D(:'=.#%! +0(6:36! 03'%! )$#(! .#:+$35$! N$>3#%#G$3$(3$=!<br />

A#(#=3$3$=3#($%$! 7#($%#! A#.$(#(#=P! ;2! D7#+$! 03:'7'%! D3=#3#($%! D(#.$5$3#($%! )#! ;2=0%6+6! %6:'('! A#%#33$=3#!<br />

D(#.$5$%$%!.#:+$35$+$%$%!G636%)66!D3=#!.'('1!%)'%!-#($3$(B!!!<br />

KD:!7#:!='.=!!:'))#+$!D(#.$5$3#($!-#!'7%!!>':'%)'!)$#(!.D:!7#:!$$!$3#!$.$A'3!#)#%!<br />

.'('13'(!%4! 7#:! &$I7#%$! $3#! $3A$3$! A#(#=3$3$=3#($! G#3$(3#7#%! Vf]_d[[^! NZP! +'7!3!!<br />

XU%#.:#3$=!A#(#=3$3$=3#($%$!7#($%#!A#.$(:#3#($!A#(#=:#=.#)$(B!!!<br />

!<br />

:Df/&$5&)$A+1A!$)+//&-&.(,$F,+5-+,)+'!$$$<br />

X#:! ='.=!! :'))#+$! ='.#A0($+$! -#! $%0-'+70%'! )'7'%'('=! ;200.#=%$=! ='.=!! :'))#3#($! =0=+$)$0+.'.! -#! &$+.0:0%0+.'.!<br />

='.#A0($3#($%#! '$.! -#! C#%#.$$! c#$.$($3:$! R(A'%$>:'3'()'%! NCcRP! D(#.$3:$! -#7'!<br />

G6%3'(!! $?#(#%! -#7'! $&.$-'! #)#%! D(D%3#($%! @'>'(3'%:'+!! $3#! $3A$3$! 2$(3$=! :#->6'.!!<br />

! C]#


='@+':!%'!A$(#%!7#:!='.=!!:'))#3#($%$%!)03'!:'!'(>!#)$3:#+$%)#%!+0(6:36!=$$3#(!<br />

$3#!$3A$3$!0%'7)!(B!!!!!<br />

b!&':$3$%#!U>#3!03:'7'%!0%'7!p!&#(&'%A$!G$(!U>#3!D(#.$5$!$3#!$3A$3$!03:'7'%!0%'7B!;2!<br />

@'>'(!%)'! 7#(!'3'%! G6! .D(! 7#:! ='.=!! :'))#3#($! A#%#3! 7#:! 7'+'+!! A#(#=3$3$=3#($%#! -#!<br />

$3A$3$!XU%#.:#3$=.#!G#3$(.$3#%!='.=!!:'))#3#($!+@#+$1$='+70%3'(!!67A6%!03:'3!)!(B!!!<br />

!<br />

i,+5$'O.&! #)$3:#+$! $3#! $3A$3$! A#(#=3$! )D>#%3#:#3#($! 7'@'(! -#! C!)'!<br />

l$%5$($! -#! \'7-'%! T'3!!! c'$:$! H0:$.#+$! NTj0*j;\P! H0:$+70%'! G6! AU(#-$!<br />

+!('+!%)'!7'()!:5!!036(B!Tj0*j;\!GD%7#+$%)#!;2!H0:$+70%6!.#:+$35$+$!-#!&#(!`7#!<br />

c#-3#..#%! .#:+$35$3#(! 7#(! '3!(B! Tj0*j;\4! ?'3!:'3'(!%!%! %#.$5#+$%)#4! .D:! ;2!<br />

D3=#3#($%)#! &'7-'%! G#+3#%:#+$%)#! =633'%!3'5'=! ='.=!! :'))#3#($%$! (#+:$! 03'('=!<br />

0%'73'7'%!-#!=633'%!:!'(.3'(!%!!0(.'7'!=07'%!;2!:#->6'.!:#.%$%$!&'>!(3'%!(B!R%'7!<br />

:#->6'.!4! L*T;:'3'(! E! NCcRP! J'%#3$! 7#:! ='.=!! :'))#3#($%$%!<br />

)##(3#%)$($3:#+$!=0%6+73'!$3A$3#%$(3#(B!k'3!:'!C(6@3'(!%'!'7(!3'%!J'%#3:'%3'(!<br />

AU(#-!7'@'(B!!!!<br />

R%'7! @(0+#+$! +!('+!%)'! 7#:! ='.=!! :'))#3#($! .#:#3! 03'('=! AD-#%3$=4! =$:3$=! -#!<br />

#.=$%3$=3#($!'?!+!%)'%!)##(3#%)$($3$(3#(!N!G'>!!='.=!!:'))#3#($!='.#A0($3#($!$?$%!>0(6%36!<br />

)#$3)$(PB! 2$3#$$%! AD-#%3$$! G'3!!4! ! &#)#1! &'7-'%4! .D=#.$5$4! ?'3!'%3'(! -#! ?#-(#7$!<br />

='@+'(B!c##(3#%)$(:#4!G'-6(63'(!%!&'>!(3'%:'+!!-#!+6%63:'+!!$3#!G$(3$=.#!7#:!='.=!!<br />

:'))#3#($%$%! )##(3#%)$($3:#+$! -#! 0%'73'%:'+!! $3#! $3A$3$! )#.'73!! =6('33'(!! G#3$(3#7#%!<br />

gdW_d[[f!NfP!+'7!3!!XU%#.:#3$=!&D=D:3#($!?#(?#-#+$%)#!&'>!(3'%:'+!!A#(#=#%!G'-6(6!<br />

G#3A#3#($%#! )'7'%'('=! A#(?#=3#.$($3$(B! X6='(!)'! G'&+#)$3#%! XU%#.:#3$=!<br />

A#(#=3$3$=3#($%#! $3'-#! 03'('=! L*T;! N;-(6@'! C!)'! CD-#%3$$! R.0($.#+$P! )0+7')'! 7#(!<br />

'3'5'=! G#3A#3#($%! &'>!(3'%:'+!! $3#! $3A$3$! )#.'73!! G$(! $)'($! -#! .#=%$=! =3'-6>! N$%.#(%#.!<br />

+'71'+!%)'%!63'!3'G$3$(P!&'>!(3':!.!(B!<br />

\#)#1! &'7-'%! $?$%! 7#:! ='.=!! :'))#+$! AD-#%3$$! )##(3#%)$(:#+$! )0I! '!:!! .#+.$%#!<br />

)'7'%!3'('=! 7'@!3!(B! 2'-6(6!+'&$G$!.'-+$7#!#)$3#%!)0>)'%!V[[!='.!1'>3'!)0>'!:'(6>!<br />

G!('=!3:!! &'7-'%3'(!%! -#($:3$3$$%)#! &#(&'%A$! G$(! 036:+6>36=! 7''%:')!!%!!<br />

AU+.#(#%!.#+.!('@0(3'(!%!!$G('>!#.:#=!>0(6%)')!(B!;3.#(%'.$1!03'('=!G'-6(6!+'&$G$4!.':!<br />

&#:'.030I$!'%'3$>$!$3#!G$(3$=.#!+6%:'=!='7)!!$3#!.'-+$7#!#)$3#%!)0>)'%!V[!='.!1'>3'!)0>!<br />

-#($3#%!.#+.!+0%6?3'(!!$3#!)#!G'-6(6!7'@'G$3$(B!CD-#%3$=!:'(I!!.'-+$7#!#)$3#%!)0>6%!V[!<br />

='.!%)'%! )'&'! )DD=+#! 67A6%! G$(! AD-#%3$=! :'(I!! G#3$(3#%:#3$! -#! G#3$(3$! G$(! .D(! $?$%!<br />

! C]!


=633'%!3'5'=! 7#:#! =0%'5'=! ='.=!! :'))#+$%$%! :'=+$:6:! )0>6! XU%#.:#3$=.#!<br />

G#3$(.$3#5#=.$(B!!<br />

KD=#.$5$3#(!$?$%!AD-#%3$=!$%+'%!+'3!!!D>#($%)#!036:+6>!#.=$!7'('.'%!&'7-'%!0($I$%3$!<br />

A!)'! :'))#3#($%)#=$! ='.=!! :'))#3#($! -#7'! G6%3'(!%! :#.'G03$.! ='3!%.!3'(!%!%!<br />

)##(3#%)$($3:#+$%#! )'7'%!(B! 2'&+#=0%6! ='.=!! :'))#3#($! $?$%4! &'7-'%! 0($I$%3$! A!)'!<br />

:'))#3#($%)#! L*T;! .D=#.$5$3#($%! =0(6%:'+!! $?$%! :'=+$:6:! ='3!%.!! 3$:$.$! N9"iP!<br />

G#3$(3#%:#+$%#! A#(#=! 03:')!!%!! G#3$(.:#)$=?#! -#7'! 9"i! &'3$! &'>!()'!<br />

G#3$(3#%:#:$+#!9'=+$:6:!H'3!%.!!i$:$.$!G#3$(3#%:#3$)$(B!TU>=0%6+6!)##(3#%)$(:#!<br />

L*T;=0%6+6! )##(3#%)$(:#! L*T;! =3'-6>6! p! K#=%$=! H3'-6>!<br />

H633'%!5!3'(! _! $?$3#(! $?$%! ='.=!! :'))#+$! =633'%!:!%)'!AD-#%3$=! $3#! $3A$3$! ?'3!:'3'(! b!<br />

?#(?#-#+$%)#!7'@!3:'3!)!(!NV[PB!<br />

k#-(#! AD-#%3$$! p! A#(#=3$! 03:')!!! G#3$(.$3:#)$$! +D(#5#! NG'>!! ='.3!! :'))#3#($! $?$%P!<br />

G'-6(6!+'&$G$!&'-'4!+6!-#!.0@('=.'=$!='.=!! :'))#3#($%$%!-#7'!='3!%.!3'(!%!%!N$1('>'.!<br />

03'('=! '.!3)!!%)'P! ?#-(#! D>#($%)#! &#(&'%A$! G$(! 036:+6>! #.=$! 7'('.:')!!%!! G#3$(.#%!<br />

('@0(3'(!!$G('>!#)#5#=.$(B!TU>=0%6+6!)##(3#%)$(:#!L*T;!=3'-6>6!p!?#-(#!$?$%!7#:!<br />

='.=!! :'))#3#($! AD-#%3$$%$%! )##(3#%)$($3:#+$! $3#! $3A$3$! K#=%$=! H3'-6>! b!!<br />

?#(?#-#+$%)#!7'@!3:'3!)!(!NVVPB!!<br />

L*T;! )##(3#%)$(:#+$%$%! +0%6?3'(!! (#+:$! -#! G$3$:+#3! .'G'%3!! L*T;! CU(DD! 03'('=!<br />

7'7!%3'%!(! -#! &#(&'%A$! G$(! 7#:! ='.=!! :'))#+$! $3#! $3A$3$! )$=='.#! '3!%'%! .D:! ($+=3#($%!<br />

.'%!:!!-#!+0%6?3'(!%!!$?#($(B!TU>=0%6+6!AU(D!&'3='!'?!=!03'%!EK&#!L*T;!w06(%'3F$! $?$%! G'-6(6! +'&$G$! .'('1!%)'%! 67A63'%'%! '%'3$.$=!<br />

7U%.#:3#($%!67A6%!036@!03:')!!!)##(3#%)$($3$(B!L,"i!'7%!!>':'%)'!G6%3'(!%!(#+:$!<br />

=0%.(033#(! $?$%! 7'('(3!! 036@! 03:')!!%!! )'! =0%.(03! #)#(B! ;=.$1! =0:@0%#%.$%! G$($:!<br />

.'%!:!!-#!'%'3$.$=!7U%.#:$%!=!+'!'?!=3':'+!!)'!0%'7!XU%#.:#3$$%)#!'7(!5'!7#(!'3!(B!!!!<br />

!<br />

i,+5$`G,&1)&-(($<br />

R%'7!XU%#.:#3$$!;-(6@'!2$(3$$!"#+:$!C'>#.#+$%)#!.D:!(#+:$!)$33#()#!03:'=!D>#(#!<br />

7'7!%3'%!(! -#! 7D((D3D#! A$()$=.#%! +0%('! .D:! ;2! `7#! c#-3#.$! $?$%! 7'+'3! 03'('=!<br />

G'3'7!5!! 036(B! 2U73#! G$(! XU%#.:#3$=! 6! '%)'! &#(! G$(! ='.=!! :'))#+$! $?$%! '7(!! '7(!!<br />

&'>!(3'%:'=.'!036@!0%'73!!='.=!!:'))#+$%$%!=633'%!:!!-#!@'>'(3'%:'+!!$3#!$3A$3$!.D:!<br />

7'+'3!'(.3'(!!$?#(:#=.#)$(B!R%'7!V[!7!33!=!G$(!+D(#!$?$%!-#($3:#=.#!036@!.'3#@!#)$3:#+$!<br />

&'3$%)#!6>'.!3'G$3#5#=.$(B!!<br />

\':$3$%#! U>#3! 03:'7'%! 0%'7! $3#! $3A$3$! $3=! U(%#=! L! 8$.':$%$! $?$%! Vf]V_d[[]! +'7!3!!<br />

XU%#.:#3$=!&D=D:3#($!?#(?#-#+$%)#!-#($3#%!-#!;2!"#+:$!C'>#.#+$%)#!V^!R5'=!d[VV!<br />

.'($&$%)#! 7'7!%3'%'%! 0%'7)!(B! de_d[VV! NVdP! +'7!3!! XU%#.:#3$=.#! EFG#+3#%:#! ='.=!!<br />

:'))#3#($F! ')!! '3.!%)'=$! ='.=!! :'))#+$! ='.#A0($+$%)#! 7#(! '3'%! -#! L==0%6+6! L=.#! ;2


.050@&#(03h! G6%3'(!%! +'13!=! =($.#(3#($4! '%'3$.$=! :#.0)3'(!! -#! D?! 0%'73!! 10(:6%! ! U3?D!<br />

G$($:$!)#%=3$=3#($B!`(D%!A#%#3!$.$G'($7#3!AD-#%3$!03'('=!)##(3#%)$($3)$$!$?$%!G'='!G$(!<br />

'(.!)'&$3!#)$3:#:$.$(B!!<br />

\':$3$%#! U>#3! 03:'7'%! 7#:! ='.=!! :'))#3#($! $?$%! U%#($3#%! =!+!.3':'3'('! U(%#=! d^b<br />

&7)(0M7! 5&03#5'35$1#(03! 10(:6%)'! c! 8$.':$%$! $?$%! -#($3#%! 0%'7!)!(h! ffZ_d[[W! NV]P!<br />

'7!3!! XU%#.:#3$=B! 26! D(D%4! 7#:#! ?0=! '>! :$=.'()'! ='.!3)!!%)'%! -#! )DD=! AD-#%3$=!<br />

:'(I!%'! +'&$@! 03)66%)'%! +')#5#! U%! ='(!!:3'(! $3#! =633'%!3'G$3$(! p! U%! ='(!!:!<br />

&'>!(3':'=! $?$%! A!)'! $$! +'&$G$%$%!(#+:$! 0%'7'! +'&$@! 03:'+!!A#(#=:#=.#)$(B!\'7-'%!<br />

AD-#%3$$!%#)#%3#($%)#%!)03'7!!G6!D(D%3#(!$3A$3$!:'=+$:6:!$>$%!-#($3#%!+#-$7#!8$.B!c ] !<br />

$3#!=0:G$%'+70%!&'3$%)#!G#3$(3#%:$.$(B!N!=0:G$%'+70%6%!:'=+$:6:!$?#($$!&#(&'%A$!<br />

G$(! .D(! $?$%! .':! 7#:! :'))#+$%)#! =A! G'!%'! d^b&7)(0M75&03#5'35$1#(034! -$.':$%! c ] !<br />

N5&03#5'35$1#(03P! $3#! G$(3$=.#PB! TU>=0%6+6! D(D%D%! 8$.B! c d ! $3#! G$(3$=.#! =633'%!:!!<br />

7'+'=3'%:!.!(B!N-$.':$%!c d !x%$%!+$:63.'%#!=633'%!:!%'!$>$%!-#($3:#:#=.#)$(PB!<br />

\':$3$%#! U>#3! .#=('(! 0%'73':'! $?$%! U(%#=! VZV_d[VV! NVgP! +'7!3!! XU%#.:#3$=.$(B!<br />

J+,"$2%001+).$(>'"!cT9!Vgdd]!.'('1!%)'%!D(#.$3#%!"RnRlX9L ê !J4!eb@&7.'+#!$?$%!<br />

0%'7! +')#5#! EcT9! n6.($.$0%'3! J(0)65.+! T@B! >! 0B0! .'('1!%)'%! .#:+$3! #)$3#%! ! cT9!<br />

n6.($.$0%'3! J(0)65.+! i.)F! $?$%! -#($3:$.$(B! TU>=0%6+6! D(D%! Vf]V_d[[]! +'7!3!!<br />

XU%#.:#3$#!AU(#!7#%$)#%!)##(3#%)$($3)$$%)#!E+D(#+$>F!03'%!0%'7!+D(#+$!V[!7!3!$3#!<br />

+!%!(3'%)!(!3:!!036@!0%'7!+D(#+$!Ve!9'(.!d[dV


eB!"#A63'.$0%!NL5P!n0!Vf]V_d[[]!R1!K&#!L6(0@#'%!J'(3$':#%.!;%)!R1!K&#!j06%5$3!<br />

01!dd!T#@.#:G#(!d[[]!0%!'))$.$-#+!10(!6+#!$%!'%$:'3!%6.($.$0%!p!Rw!idef4!VfBV[Bd[[]!<br />

ZB!"#A63'.$0%!NL5P!n0!Vf]_d[[^!R1!K&#!L6(0@#'%!J'(3$':#%.!;%)!R1!K&#!j06%5$3!<br />

01!Vd!w'%6'(7!d[[^!3'7$%A!)0Q%!(#S6$(#:#%.+!10(!1##)!&7A$#%#!p!Rw!i]^4![fB[dBd[[^!<br />

fB!j0::$++$0%!"#A63'.$0%!NL5P!n0!gdW_d[[f!01!d^!;@($3!d[[f!0%!)#.'$3#)!(63#+!10(!.&#!$:@3#:#%.'.$0%!01!<br />

"#A63'.$0%!NLjP!n0!Vf]V_d[[]!01!.&#!L6(0@#'%!J'(3$':#%.!'%)!01!.&#!j06%5$3!'+!(#A'()+!.&#!@(#@'('.$0%!<br />

'%)!.&#!@(#+#%.'.$0%!01!'@@3$5'.$0%+!'%)!.&#!'++#++:#%.!'%)!.&#!'6.&0($+'.$0%!01!1##)!'))$.$-#+!!p!Rw!iV]]4!<br />

ddB[^Bd[[f!<br />

WB!K#5&%$5'3!C6$)'%5#!10(!#+.'G3$+&$%A!.&#!+'1#.7!01!'))$.$-#+!10(!.&#!50%+6:#(!b!K&#!L*T;!w06(%'3!Nd[[fP!<br />

f[V4!VbVd!<br />

V[B!K#5&%$5'3!C6$)'%5#!b!T.6)$#+!50%5#(%$%A!.&#!+'1#.7!01!6+#!01!.&#!'))$.$-#!10(!6+#(+_Q0(=#(+!b!K&#!L*T;!<br />

w06(%'3!Nd[[fP!f[d4!Vbd!<br />

VVB!K#5&%$5'3!C6$)'%5#!10(!'++#++$%A!.&#!+'1#.7!01!1##)!'))$.$-#+!10(!.&#!#%-$(0%:#%.!b!K&#!L*T;!w06(%'3!<br />

Nd[[fP!fgd4!Vbdf!<br />

VdB!j0::$++$0%!"#A63'.$0%!NL6P!n0!de_d[VV!01!Vg!w'%6'(7!d[VV!50%5#(%$%A!.&#!'6.&0($+'.$0%!01!-$.':$%!L!<br />

'+!'!1##)!'))$.$-#!10(!'33!'%$:'3!+@#5$#+!p!Rw!iVV4!V^B[VBd[VV!<br />

V]B! j0::$++$0%! "#A63'.$0%! NL5P! n0! ffZ_d[[W! 01! d^! T#@.#:G#(! d[[W! 50%5#(%$%A! .&#! '6.&0($+'.$0%! 01! '!<br />

+.'G$3$+#)! 10(:! 01! d^b&7)(0M75&03#5'35$1#(03! '+! '! 1##)! '))$.$-#! 10(! 5&$5=#%+! 10(! 1'..#%$%A4! .6(=#7+! 10(!<br />

1'..#%$%A4!0.&#(!@063.(7!'%)!@$A+!p!Rw!id^g4!deB[WBd[[W!<br />

VgB! j0::$++$0%! "#A63'.$0%! NL6P! n0! VZV_d[VV! 01! d]! *#G(6'(7! d[VV! 50%5#(%$%A! .&#! '6.&0($+'.$0%! 01! eb<br />

@&7.'+#!NLj!]BVB]BdeP!@(0)65#)!G7!;+@#(A$336+!0(7>'#!cT9!Vgdd]!'+!'!1##)!'))$.$-#!10(!@063.(7!'%)!10(!<br />

@0(5$%#! +@#5$#+! '%)! ':#%)$%A! "#A63'.$0%! NLjP! n0! d^^_d[[^! N&03)#(! 01! '6.&0($+'.$0%! cT9! n6.($.$0%'3!<br />

J(0)65.+!i.)!(#@(#+#%.#)!G7!cT9!n6.($.$0%'3!@(0)65.+!T@B!>!0B0P!p!Rw!igW4!dgB[dBd[VV!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

! C]J


#HT $D&5+9$B1(,$?O.A$L+-A!,!,$"+-!A-!$D&'-&,)&'(,/&A($kF-O$<br />

;3")?.0").L)@.10#$()A"'#)%&)M"'0#3()H1#$%#%.&).L);1$! 7'':h! 7D=+#=! ='%! G'+!%5!4! '.#(0I#%$=! ! 3$@$.! @(01$3$4! &'1$1!<br />

$:'%_$:'%! 03:'! -#! ='()$0-'+=D3#(! &'+.'3!=4! ='%+#(4! .$@! d! )$'G#.! 0366:! ($+=$%$!!<br />

'(.!('%! $=$! U%#:3$! ($+=! 1'=.U(D)D(B! 26! +0(6%3'(!! )D>#3.:#=! $?$%4! G$(#73#(! G#+3#%:#!<br />

'3!='%3!=3'(!%)'! -#! 7'':! #=3$%)#! ! )#$$=3$=3#(! 7'@:'3!h! 1$>$=+#3! '=.$-$.#7$!<br />

'(.!(:'3!4! .6>! .D=#.$:$%$! '>'3.:'3!4! 7'+!>! .'-6=4!&$%)$! -#!G'3!=!#.$4!+#G>#!-#!:#7-#!<br />

.D=#.$:$%$! '(.!(:'3!4! +'3!=3!! -D56.! '!(3!!%!! =0(6:'3!4! +$A'('! $?:#:#3$4! '3=03!<br />

=633'%:':'3!!-#7'!'3!:!%!!'>'3.:'3!)!(B!!<br />

!<br />

:;'1.+!#.!N@$3$?!-#!&$%)$!!#.$Ph!G#+$%!<br />

U#3#($!'?!+!%)'%!)##(3#%)$($3)$$%)#!)'%'!-#!=6>6!#.$%)#%!)'&'!)DD=!#%#(I$!NVd[b<br />

Vg[!=='3_V[[AP!+'3')!!4!$7$!='3$.#3$!@(0.#$%!='7%'!!03)66!-#!@(0.#$%!0('%!!7D=+#=!<br />

03)66! $?$%! #%! U%#:3$! @(0.#$%! ='7%'=3'(!! '('+!%)'! +'7!3)!!4! )'&'! )DD=! 7'! NdBfb<br />

ZBVA_V[[AP4! )'&'! )DD=! )07:6! 7'! NgVBWbg^Be! :A_V[[AP! $?#()$$! AU(D3:#=.#)$(B!<br />

;7(!5'!A#%#3!03'('=!#.3#(!!2!A(6G6!-$.':$%3#($%)#%!!%$'+$%4!-$.':$%!2 e !-#!-$.':$%!2 Vd !<br />

G'=!:!%)'%!)'!$7$!G$(!='7%'=!03'('=!)##(3#%)$($3:#=.#)$(B!<br />

8D56)6%!#%!=D?D=!@'(?'+!!03'%!!7''7'%!&D5(#%$%!-#!:#.'G03$=!.#@=$:#3#($!='.'3$>#!<br />

#)#%! #%>$:3#($%! 7'@!+!! @(0.#$%)$(B! 2D7D:#h! &D5(#3#($%! ?0'3:'+!! )#:#=! 03)66%'!<br />

AU(#! @(0.#$%! GD7D:#! $?$%! #3>#:)$(B! 8D56)6%! GD.D%! &D5(#3#($%$%! GD7D=! G$(! GU3D:D!<br />

@(0.#$%3#()#%! 7'@!3:!.!(! -#! G6! &D5(#3#(! +D(#=3$! 03'('=! )#$$@! 7#%$3#%:#=.#)$(B! 26!<br />

%#)#%3#! -D56..'%! +D(#=3$! 03'('=! G#3$(3$! :$=.'()'! @(0.#$%! )!'(!! '.!3!(B! ! 26! G'=!:)'%!<br />

-D56)6%! #%#(I$! )#@0+6! '%3':!%)'! G$(! @(0.#$%! )#@0+6! 70=.6(B! T')#5#! =!+'! +D(#3$!<br />

7#.#(+$>3$=3#($! A$)#(#G$3#5#=! '>! :$=.'()'! 7#)#=! @(0.#$%! -D56..'! +'=3'%'G$3$(B! L#(!<br />

-D56.!@(0.#$%!'3':'>+'4!7!=!3'%!&D5(#3#(!7#%$3#%#:#>B!!<br />

8D56.! @(0.#$%3#($%$%! 0366:6! $?$%! ='7%'=4! G#+$%3#($%! G$3#$:$%)#! G636%'%!<br />

@(0.#$%3#()$(B! ! 8D56)6%! ='(G0%&$)('.! -#7'! 7')'%! @(0.#$%$! 7'@:'+!! :D:=D%!<br />

03:')!!%)'%! )!'(!)'%! @(0.#$%! '3:'+!! >0(6%36)6(B! J(0.#$%3#(! GD7D=! :03#=D33#()$(B!<br />

;:$%0! '+$.3#()#%! 0366(3'(B! ;:$%0! '+$.3#(! -D56.! )0=63'(!%!%! 7'@!! .'3'(!)!(B! %+'%!<br />

! C]N<br />

_1-541.indd 311 29.02.2012 15:49


-D56)6! ':$%0! '+$.3#($! 7'@':')!!! A$G$4! ':$%0! '+$.3#($! G$($%)#%! )$#($%#!<br />

?#-$(#G$3:#=.#!+!%!(3!!G$(!7#.#%##!+'&$@.$(B!8D56)6%!)$#(!':$%0!'+$.3#($!=633'%'('=!<br />

7'@':')!!!G6!':$%0!'+$.3#($%!G#+$%3#(3#!'3!%:'+!!>0(6%36)6(B!T'7!3'(!!7#.$=$%3#(!$?$%!<br />

f4! ?056=3'(! $?$%! V[!03'('=!='G63! #)$3#%!G6!':$%0! '+$.3#(#!E#3>#:! ':$%0!'+$.3#(F! ')!!<br />

-#($3:#=.#)$(B!!C#%#33$=3#!&'7-'%+'3!G#+$%3#()#!G636%'%!@(0.#$%3#($%!#3>#:!':$%0!'+$.!<br />

G$3#$:3#($!-D56.!A#(#=+$%:#+$%#!67A6%)6(B!L3>#:!':$%0!'+$.3#($!67A6%!0('%)'!03'%!<br />

@(0.#$%3#(! +$%)$($:! +$+.#:$%)#! 1'>3'! ='7G'! 6(':')'%! -D56)'! '3!%!(3'(! -#! ':$%0!<br />

'+$.3#($%!&#@+$!G$(!'(')'!G636%)6=3'(!!$?$%!G6!':$%0!'+$.3#($%!G$(3##(#=!-D56.!@(0.#$%$!<br />

&'3$%#!A#3:#3#($!)'&'!=03'7!-#!&!>3!!036(B!L.4!@$3$?4!G'3!=4!+D.!-#!D(D%3#($%)#%!'3!%'%!<br />

@(0.#$%$%!?06%366!)'!-D56.!@(0.#$%$%#!)U%D#G$3:#=.#)$(!-#!+$%)$($3#G$3$(3$$!!t!WVb<br />

V[[3$$%#! G'3!)!(B! KD(=$7#3$$%$%!G$(!AU+.#(A#+$!03'%!7'3'(!%'!AU(#!=!+'!G0736!NG0)6(P!='G63!#)$3#%!^!7'!<br />

'3.!!?056=3'(!%!0('%!!t!V[B]!03'('=!+'@.'%:!.!(B!26!-#($3#(#!AU(#!G#!7'!%!'3.!%)'=$!<br />

&#(! V[! ?056=.'%! G$($! G0)6(! N7'!%'! AU(#! =!+'P! -#! G6! ?056=3'(!%! D?.#! G$($! )#! 5$))$!<br />

#=$3)#! G0)6()6(B! l'7!13!=! NG07'! AU(#! '!(3!!%! )DD=! 03:'+!P! U%#:3$! G$(! +0(6%!<br />

)#$3)$(h!?056=3'(!%!7D>)#!G$()#%!)'&'!'>!%!%!>'7!1!03)66!G#3$(3#%:$.$(B!k056=3'(!%!<br />

+')#5#! 7D>)#! D?D! )DD=! =$3036)6(! N7''! AU(#! '!(3!=PB! 20)6(36=4! =!(+'3! 7#(3#$:!<br />

7#(3#($%)#!-#!c06!?056=3'(!'('+!%)'!)'&'!<br />

7'7A!%)!(B!!<br />

R@.$:'3!G#+3#%:#!U%#($3#($%)#!U%#:3$!G$(!7#($!03'%!!G#7'>!#.!!#..#%!)'&'!)DD=!#%#(I$!!+'3')!!4!)'&'!)DD=!7'4!)'&'!)DD=!<br />

)07:6! 7'! $?#()$$! G$3$%:#=.#)$(B! 8D56.! 7'!%!%! .#:#3! ='7%'!! )$7#.3#! '3!%'%!<br />

7')!(B! X'@!3'%! ?'3!:'3'(! )$7#.! 7'!!$3#!-D56.!7'3'%:'+!! '('+!%)'!)0(6+'3! $3$%.$3$!<br />

03)66%'! $'(#.! #.:#=.#)$(B! KD(=$7#$.#! ='@+':!%'! A$(:#=.#)$(B! ;G)0:$%'3! 0G#>$.#!<br />

)$7'G#.!03'+!3!!%!!=')!%3'()'!]!='.4!#(=#=3#()#!VBgd!='.!7D=+#3..$$!A$G$4!=0(0%#(!='3@!<br />

&'+.'3!=3'(!! NHH\P! 03'+!3!!%'! )'! ='.=!! 7'@:'=.')!(B! H'()$70-'+=D3#(! :0(G$)$.#! -#!<br />

:0(.'3$.#%$%!G'3!5'!#.=#%3#($%)#%!G$($!03'%!)$7'G#.4!;:#($='%!H'3@!2$(3$$!.'('1!%)'%!<br />

V[!7!3!U%5#!:'IU(!($+=!1'=.U(3#($!'('+!%'!(#+:#%!'3!%:!.!(B!KD(=!L($=$%3#($%)#!H'3@!<br />

\'+.'3!!!-#!"$+=!*'=.U(3#($!NKLH\;"*P!?'3!:'+!%)'!)$7'G#.$%h!!7'4!='%!G'+!%5!!-#!<br />

+'%.('3! 0G#>$.#)#%! G'!:+!>! 03'('=! ='()$7'=! 03'73'(!! tf[! )03'7!%)'! 7D=+#3..$$!<br />

@(0+@#=.$1!03'('=!AU+.#($3:$.$(B!!!<br />

KD(=! 7#.$=$%3#($! A#(#=! A#%#.$=! %#)#%3#(! +0%6564! A#(#=+#! -$+#('3! ')$@0>$.#%$%! '3..'!<br />

7'..!!! \cib=03#+.#(03! )DD=3DD! -#! =D?D=! 706%! ici! @'(?'5!=3'(!%!%! )#%A#+$>!<br />

G$?$:)#!1'>3'!03:'+!%)'%!='7%'=3'%'%!G$(!3$@$)!($+=!@(01$3$!036.6(:'=.')!(B!26%6%3'!<br />

$3$=$3$!03'('=!:#.'G03$=!+#%)(0:'!#$3$:!AD?3D)D(!-#!HH\


7'!'>!03'%3'(!!.#(5$&!#.:#3$4!=!(:!>!!#.!7#($%#!7'!!'>!-#!?06%36=3'!)07:':!!7'!<br />

$?#(#%!@$3$?!-#!&$%)$!#.$!$3#!G'3!=!#.$!.D=#.:#3$)$(B!!<br />

c$7#..#=$! 7'! :$=.'(!4! U>#33$=3#! )07:6! 7'3'(! ='%! =03#+.#(03D%D! )$7#.!<br />

=03#+.#(03D%)#%!!)'&'!?0=!#.=$3#:#=.#)$(B!K0.'3!=03#+.#(03!V::03_i!'(.!!%)'!HH\!<br />

:0(.'3$.#+$%$%! VBg! =#>! '(.!!4! +#(6:! =03#+.#(03! =0%+'%.('+70%6! tV[! '>'3)!!%)'! ! $+#!<br />

HH\! :0(.'3$.#+$%$%! td[! '>'3)!!! G$3$%:#=.#)$(B! L@$)#:$7030I$=! -#($3#(#! AU(#4!<br />

)07:6! 7'! '+$.3#($%$%! '3!:!%)'=$!'(.!! $3#! ='()$70-'+=D3#(! &'+.'3!=! ($+=$%$%! '(.:'+!!<br />

'('+!%)'!@0>$.$1!G$(!$3$=$!-'()!(B!9#.'G03$=!?'3!:'3'()'!)$7#.!)07:6!7'!'+$)$%)#%!<br />

>#%A$%4!?0=36!)07:':!!7'!'+$.3#($%)#%!1'=$(!!$+#!+#(6:!icib=03#+.#(03!)D>#7$%$%!!<br />

)#! '(.!!! AU+.#($3:$.$(B! ;%5'=! )07:6! 7'! '+$.3#($! @3'>:'! 3$@$.! -#! 3$@0@(0.#$%!<br />

=0%+'%.('+70%6%6! ! 1'(=3!! #.=$3#7#G$3:#=.#)$(B! m>#33$=3#! VdbVe! ='(G0%! '.0:6! $?#(#%!!<br />

)07:6! 7'! '+$.3#($! ! @3'>:'! ! .0.'3! -#! icibH! =0%+'%.('+70%6%6! 7D=+#3.:#=.#)$(B!<br />

T.#'($=! '+$.! A$G$! ! VfY[! ='(G0%36! 7'! '+$.3#($! $+#! \cibH! )DD(D5D4! 3$@0@(0.#$%N'P!<br />

àiJN'PÜ!=0%+'%.('+70%6%6!'(.!(!5!!G$(!#.=$7#!+'&$@.$(B!c07:6!7'!'+$.3#($%)#%!:$($+.$=!<br />

'+$.!NVgY[P!$+#4!30($=!'+$.!NVdY[P!-#!@'3:$.$=!NVeY[P!'+$)#!=!7'+3'!=03#+.#(03D!)'&'!!!1'>3'!<br />

7D=+#3.$5$! G$(! #.=$! AU+.#($(B! X'@!3'%! ?'3!:'3'()'! )07:6! 7'! '+$.3#($%)#%! :$($+.$=!<br />

NVgY[P4! @'3:$.$=! NVeY[P! -#! +.#'($=! NVfY[P! '+$.3#()#%! >#%A$%! )$7#.! '3'%3'()'! ! =0(0%#(!<br />

'(.#(! &'+.'3!!#33$=3#! :$($+.$=! -#! @'3:$.$=!<br />

'+$)$%! '3!:!%!%! @3'>:'! .0.'3! =03#+.#(03! -#! ici! =03#+.#(03D%! 7D=+#3:#+$%#! %#)#%!<br />

03)66!G$3)$($3:#=.#)$(B!c07:6!7'!'+$.3#($%)#%!03'%!+.#'($=!'+$.!@3'>:'!=03#+.#(03!<br />

=0%+'%.('+70%6%6! #.=$3#:#:#=.#)$(B! 26%6%! %#)#%$! G6! 7'! '+$)$%$%! ='('5$#()#!<br />

)#+'.D('+70%!#%>$:$!'('5!3!!!$3#!&!>3'!03#$=!'+$)#!NVfYVP!)U%D:#+$)$(B!;%5'=!G6!7'!<br />

'+$)$%$%! @3'.#3#.3#()#=$! N@'(?'3'%:!! ='%! &D5(#3#($P! #.=$+$! %#)#%$73#! .(0:G0>!<br />

0366:6%6!&!>3'%)!()!!!G$3)$($3:$.$(B!!<br />

T!!(! -#! =6>6! #.$! 4! @$3$?! -#! &$%)$! #.$%#! ! =!7'+3'! +!('+!73'! dB^! -#! gBd! ='.! )'&'! 1'>3'!<br />

:$($+.$=! NVgY[P! '+$.! -#! VBf! -#! dBW! ='.! )'&'! 1'>3'! ! +.#'($=! NVfY[P! '+$.! N)07:6! 7'!<br />

'+$.3#($P!$?#(:#=.#)$(B!H0(0%#(!='3@!&'+.'3!!!($+=!1'=.U(3#($%#!AU(#!!U%#($3#%!!G$($%5$!<br />

G'+':'=! )$7#.$%)#! 7'+!>! =!(:!>!! #.! &'1.')'! $=$! =#>! '3!%'G$3$(4! '%5'=! )$#(! AD%3#(!<br />

)#($+$>! @$3$?4! &$%)$! -#! '-! &'7-'%3'(!%!%! #.3#($! -#! &#(! .D(3D! G'3!=! .#(5$&! #)$3:#3$)$(B!<br />

=$%5$!G'+':'=!)$7#.$%)#!$+#4!G$($%5$!G'+':'=!)$7#.$%)#%!1'(=3!!03'('=h!)07:6!7'!-#!<br />

=03#+.#(03! '3!%:'+!! )'&'! )'! =!+!.3'%:'3!4! G6! )$7#..#! =!(:!>!! #.! =#+$%3$=3#!!<br />

7#%$3:#:#3$)$(B!X$%#!)#($+$!'3!%:!!@$3$?4!&$%)$!-#!'-!&'7-'%3'(!%!%!#.3#($!-#!&#(!.D(3D!<br />

G'3!=!.#(5$&!#)$3:#3$)$(B!<br />

C#%#3! 03'('=! #.3#(! -$.':$%! 2 d ! N($G013'-$%P4! %$'+$%4! -$.':$%! 2 e ! -#! -$.':$%! 2 Vd !<br />

G'=!:!%)'%! )'! $7$! G$(! ='7%'=! 03'('=! )##(3#%)$($3:#=.#)$(B! ;7(!5'! &'7-'%+'3!<br />

7$7#5#=3#()#%! #.3#()#=$! )#:$($%! #:$3$:! 0('%!! td^b][


-#! +D.! D(D%3#($P4! g!G#+$%!G$3##%$! N.0.'3! 7'4! =03#+.#(034! +0)76:! -#! )07:6! 7'P! -#!<br />

G#+$%!?#$.3$3$$%)#%!036:'=.')!(B!26!?'3!:'3'()'!G#7'>!#.$%!=!(:!>!!#.#!0('%!!!gYV!<br />

03)66%)'!G$(#7!V[!@6'%!'3:'=.')!(B!26!!)'!G$>#!)$7#.3#!$3$%.$3$!=(0%$=!&'+.'3!=!($+=$%$!<br />

'>'3.:')'! +'3!=3!! 7#:#! U(D%.D+D%D%! %#! )#%3$! U%#:3$! 03)66%6! G$(! =#>! ! )'&'!<br />

&'.!(3'.:'=.')!(B!!<br />

!<br />

"F,7_$<br />

C#%#3!03'('=!KD(=$7#!G#+3#%:#%$%!#.=$3#)$$!A(6@3'(!%!G'!%)'!G#G#=!-#!<br />

?056=3'(4!A#%?3#(4!)06(A'%3!=!?'!%)'=$!=')!%3'(4!A#G#!-#!#:>$=3$!'%%#3#(4!7'3!3'(!-#!<br />

$?$3#(!A#3:#=.#)$(B!X#.$=$%3#()#!$+#!$:'%3!=!-#!G6%6%!>#:$%!&'>!(3')!!!&'+.'3!=3'(!<br />

U%#:3$!&'3=!+'3!!!+0(6%3'(!%)'%)!(B!!<br />

T'3!=+!>! G#+3#%:#%$%! %#)#%3#($! '('.!(!3)!!! ! >':'%4! G#+3#%:#! G$3A$3#($%)#%!<br />

70=+6%366%!GD7D=!U%#:!.'!)!!!AU(D3:#=.#)$(B!26!G'=!:)'%!+'3!=+!>!G#+3#%:#%$%!<br />

U%3#%:#+$%)#!G#+3#%:#!#$.$:$!$3#!+'3!=3!!G#+3#%:#!G$3$%5$%$%!='>'%)!(!3:'+!!GD7D=!<br />

U%#:! .'!:'=.')!(B! 26%6%! $?$%! +#=.U(3#(! -#! )$+$@3$%3#(! '('+!! +D(#=3$! G$(! ?'3!:'%!%!<br />

A#(#=3$3$$!'?!=.!(B!<br />

R@.$:'3! G#+3#%:#=! $?$%h! ?#$.3$! G#+$%3#($! .D=#.:#=4! G07'! 67A6%! G#)#%! '!(3!!%!!<br />

=0(6:'=4! )'&'! '>! 7'! -#! )'&'! '>! )07:6! 7'! .D=#.:#=4! AD%3D=! =03#+.#(03! '3!:!%!!<br />

'>'3.:'=4!)$7#..#!.':!.'&!3!D(D%3#($4!=6(6!G'=3'A$33#(4!+#G>#b:#7-#!.D=#.$:$%$!'(.!(!@4!<br />

#=#(!.D=#.$:$%$!'>'3.:'=4!AD%3D=!.6>!!!-#!+0)76:!!!.D=#.$:$%)#!'!(!7'!='?:':'=4!<br />

+!-!! .D=#.$:$%$! '(.!(:'=4! +$A'('! $?:#:#=4! '3=03! .D=#.:#:#=4! .D=#.$3$70(+'! :$=.'(!%!!<br />

'>'3.!3:'=4!'=.$1!7'':!#=3$!7'':!='3$.#+$%$!'(.!()!!!$?$%!1$>$=+#3!'=.$-$.#7$!'(.!(:'=!<br />

A#(#=:#=.#)$(B!<br />

;7(!5'! ! U>#33$=3#! @(0.#$%! A#(#=+$%$:$%$%! '(..!!4! &!>3!! GD7D:#%$%! 03)66! G#G#=3$=4!<br />

?056=36=!)U%#:3#($%)#!)$7#..#!:6.3'='!@$3$?!-#!&$%)$!#.$4!G'3!=4!+D.4!76:6(.'!A$G$!$7$!<br />

='3$.#3$!@(0.#$%!='7%'=3'(!%!%!7#(!'3:'+!!A#(#=$(B!;!(3!=!='7G!!-#!=0(6%:'+!%)'!)$7#.!<br />

7'!%!%! '>'3.!3:'+!! -#! 1$>$=+#3! '=.$-$.#! $3#! 7'! 7!=!:!%!%! &!>3'%)!(!3:'+!!<br />

U%#($3:#=.#)$(B!!H0(0%#(!='3@!&'+.'3!=3'(!%)'%!=0(6%:'=4!A#3$$:$%$!)6()6(:'=4!.!GG$!<br />

-#!5#(('&$!.#)'-$%$%!#.=$%3$$%$!'(.!(:'=!-#!&'+.'3!!%!.#=('(!%!!U%3#:#=!$?$%!$+#!7'4!<br />

)07:6! 7'4! =03#+.#(03! .D=#.$:$%$! '>'3.:'=4! .':! 7'3!! +D.4! 706(.! -#! @#7%$(! $3#!<br />

=!(:!>!!#.!-#!D(D%3#($4!)#($3$!@$3$?!#.$!-#!+'='.'.3'(!!)$7#..#!+!%!(3':'=4!.':!7'3!!+D.!<br />

D(D%3#($!7#($%#4!7'!!'>'3.!3:!!-#7'!7'+!>!+D.!D(D%3#($%$4!7'3!!#.3#(!7#($%#!7'+!>!7'!<br />

)'! 7'!! '>! 03'%3'(!! .#(5$&! #.:#=4! ! G6! %#)#%3#! U>#33$=3#! =!(:!>!! #.! 7#($%#! 7'!! -#!<br />

)07:6!7'!!'>!)#($+$>!@$3$?4!&$%)$!!!!#.3#($%$!!-#!&#(!.D(3D!G'3!=!#.$!.D=#.:#=!A#(#=$(B!<br />

R@.$:'3!G#+3#%:#!U%#($3#($%)#!U%#:3$!G$(!7#($!03'%!@$3$?!-#!&$%)$!#.$%$!!+'.!%!'3!(=#%4!<br />

&'>!(3'(=#%4!@$$($(=#%!!-#!.D=#.$(=#%!&#(!>':'%!&$I7#%#!)$=='.!#.:#3$)$(B!c#($+$>!@$3$?!<br />

-#! &$%)$! #.$%$! &#(! 7'! A(6G6! U%#($3#%! )D>#73#()#! .D=#.#G$3$(B! J$3$?! -#! &$%)$! #.$h! #.4!<br />

76:6(.'4!=6(6G'=3'A$33#(!A(6G6!$?#($+$%)#!)##(3#%)$($3:#=.#)$(B!26!A(6@!$?$%!AD%3D=!<br />

.D=#.$3:#+$!U%#($3#%!:$=.'(!7#.$=$%4!A#%?4!?056=3'(!$?$%!d!@0(+$70%4!A#G#!-#!#:>$=3$!<br />

=')!%3'(!$?$%!]!@0(+$70%)6(B!!<br />

!<br />

%+5,+A-+.$<br />

VB!c$#.4!n6.($.$0%!'%)!K&#!J(#-#%.$0%!01!j&(0%$5!c$+#'+#+B!"#@0(.!R1!'!a\R_*;R!LM@#(.!j0%+63.'.$0%4!<br />

a\R!K#5&%$5'3!"#@0(.!T#($#+YWVe4!a\R4!C#%#-'4!d[[]B!<br />

dB!c6711!"iB!C#3$.$($3:$!2#+$%!-#!2#+3#%:#!"#&G#($!E!K&#!;:#($5'%!c$#.#.$5!;++05$'.$0%


" #HW $%O)&'$L+5@+,


@03$.$='3'('F! )U%D:#=.#)$(3#(B! 26! +D(#?.#! (#1'&4! @'73'!:4! ='.!3!:5!3!=4! ?#-(#4!<br />

+D()D(D3#G$3$(!D(#.$:4!)0'%!%!=0(6%:'+!!A$G$!AU+.#(A#3#(!'!(3!=3'!0(.'7'!=0%63:'7'!<br />

G'3':!.!(B!<br />

KD(=$7#'3:'+!! =!(+'3! '3'%)'! #%! ?0=! =D?D=! D(#.$5$7$! #.=$+$! '3.!%'! '3:!.!(B!<br />

m>#33$=3#!=D?D=G'!-#!=D:#+!&'7-'%5!3!!!$3#!A#?$:$%$!+'3'7'%!D(#.$5$3#(!67A63'%'%!<br />

@03$.$='3'(! +0%656! 036:+6>! =0633'()'%! #%! ?0=! #.=$3#%#%! =#+$:! 03:6.6(B! H!(+'3!<br />

'3'%3'(!%! ='3=!%:'+!%)'4! .0@('=+!>4! '>! .0@('=3!! -#7'! '>! +'7!)'! &'7-'%! +'&$G$! 03'%!<br />

=!(+'3! &'3=! $?$%! &'7-'%5!3!=4! U%#:3$! G$(! ?U>D:! 7036! 03'('=! AU(D3:#=.#)$(B! 26%6%!<br />

$?#($+$%)#!)#!=D:#+!&'7-'%5!3!!!U>#3!G$(!U%#:#!+'&$@.$(B!TU>3#:#3$!A#(?#=3#.$($3#%!<br />

7'! )'! 7#(#3! @'>'(! =0633'(!%)'! )##(3#%)$($3:#=! ':'5!73'! A#(?#=3#.$($3#%! =D:#+!<br />

&'7-'%5!3!!!=!(+'3!'3'%)'!G$%3#(5#!'$3#%$%!.#:#3!A#?$:!='7%'!%!!036.6(:'=.')!(B!!<br />

H!(+'3!='3=!%:'!$3#!G$(#73#($%!-#!.0@36:3'(!%!+0+7'34!#=0%0:$=!-#!=D3.D(#3!7'@!3'(!%!!<br />

$7$3#.$(:#=4! +')#5#! .'(!:+'3! -#($:$%$%! '(..!(!3:'+!! $3#! +'3'%':':'=.')!(B! 26%6%3'!<br />

G$(3$=.#! G$(#73#($%! +'3!=3!! G#+3#%:#+$4! A#?$:3$=! )D>#7)#! )#! 03+'! A#?$:3#($%$%!<br />

+'3'%:'+!4! G636%)6=3'(!! 7#()#! 7'':3'(!%!! +D()D(#G$3:#3#($! -#! =6(63'5'=!<br />

$3#.:#3#(3#!$+.$&)':!7'('.!3:'+!4!='.:'!)##($%!'(..!(!3:'+!!-#!GU3A#+#3!='3=!%:'!$3#!<br />

GU3A#3#(! '('+!! 1'(=3!3!=3'(!! '>'3.!3:'+!%)'! =!(+'3! ='3=!%:'%!%! U%#:3$! G$(! '('5!)!(B! 26!<br />

'('?3'()'%!G$(!.'%#+$!)#!=D:#+!&'7-'%5!3!!!03'G$3$(B!kD%=D!A!)'!AD-#%5#+$4!70=+6336=4!<br />

)DD=! A#3$(! )D>#73#($4! '?3!=4! GU3A#3#(! '('+!! A#3$:$3$=! 1'(=3!3!=3'(!! =D:#+!<br />

&'7-'%5!3!!%!!=!(+'3)'!='3=!%:'%!%!U%#:3$!G$(!'('5!!=0%6:6%'!A#.$(#G$3:#=.#)$(B!!<br />

HD:#+! &'7-'%5!3!!! G$3$%)$$! A$G$4! &'7-'%5!3!=! +#=.U(D%D%! #%! ?0=! A#3$.$$! -#!<br />

.#=%030I$7#! )#! #%! '?!=! 03'%! '3'%3'(!%)'%! G$($)$(B! ;7%!! >':'%)'! &'7-'%+'3! @(0.#$%!<br />

'?!!%!%!='@'.!3:'+!%)'4!U>#33$=3#!=!(+'3!'3'%3'()'!'?3!=!-#!70=+63366%!'>'3.!3:'+!%)'!<br />

)D%7'%!%!#3$%)#=$!#%!7'7A!%!-#!#%!#=0%0:$=!1!(+'..!(B!H'%'.3!!#.$!D(#.$5$3$$!GD7D=!G$(!<br />

+#=.U(! &'3$%#! A#3:$.$(B! T0%! V^bd[! 7!3)'! '(.'%! .D=#.$:3#! G#('G#(! &!>3!! G$(! A#3$$:!<br />

$?#($+$%)#)$(B! 26! A#3$$:! +#=.U()#! ?'3!'%! $(=#.3#($! )#! #%.#A(#! $3#.:#3#(! &'3$%#!<br />

A#.$(:$.$(B! L%.#A(#! $3#.:#3#()#! +')#5#! =D:#+3#(! #%.#A(#! GD%7#+$%)#! )#$3)$(B! L.3$=!<br />

=D:#+!+'&$@3#($73#4!#%.#A(#3#(!'('+!%)'!1'+0%!D(#.$:!703673'!?'3!:'!7'@!3!(B!HD:#+!<br />

+'&$@3#($! )#! A#%#33$=3#! =!(+'3! '3'%3'()'! -#! =D?D=! -#7'! 0(.'! U3?#=3$! D(#.$5$3#()$(B! 26!<br />

'?!)'%!=D:#+!&'7-'%5!3!!%!%!=!(+'3!='3=!%:')'!)'!'7(!!G$(!U%#:$!-'()!(B!!<br />

$<br />

n#)#%!H!(+'3!H'3=!%:'q!<br />

X0=+6336=4! $+$>3$=4! A#3$(! 7#.:#>3$$! -#! =#%.3#:#%$%! A#.$()$$! :'3$7#.3#(! -#! )#!<br />

+'3!=+!>! G#+3#%:#! -#! A!)'! .D=#.$:$! =!(+'3! ='3=!%:'7!! 7$%#! 7#%$)#%! AD%)#:$%! $3=!<br />

+!('3'(!%'! 0.6(..6B! 26%6%! A#(?#=3#:#+$! $+#! =!(+'3! '3'%)'=$! $%+'%!%! :6.363664!<br />

$+.$&)':!4! +0+7'3! -#! =D3.D(#3! 03'%'=3'('! #($$:$4! $7$3#:$! 7'':! =0633'(!%'!<br />

='-6:'+!! $3#! 03'+!)!(B! X#($%)#! ='3'('=! .0@36:6%! +'3!=3!! G#+3#%:#+$%#! ='.=!)'!<br />

G636%'5'=! D(#.$:)#! G636%:'=4! KD(=$7#! A$G$! D3=#3#()#! =D?D=! D(#.$5$3$$%4! =!(+'3!<br />

70=+633'(!%4! '>! .0@('=3!3'(!%! D(#.$:! +D(#?3#($%#! )'&'! 1'>3'! ='.!3!:!! A#(#=3$! -#!<br />

-'>A#?$3#:#>!6%+6(3'()'%)!(B!!<br />

KD(=$7#


m>#33$=3#!=!(+'3!'3'%)'=$!+0(6%3'(!%!.#+@$.$!-#!G6!+0(6%3'('!='3!5!!?U>D:3#(!G636%:'+!!<br />

A#(#=+$%$:$! E=!(+'3! ='3=!%:'F! =0%6+6%6! D3=#:$>)#! )#! AD%)#:$%! $3=! +!('3'(!%'!<br />

0.6(.:6.6(B! 26%)'%! )03'7!! )'! =!(+'3! ='3=!%:'7'! 7U%#3$=! ?'3!:'3'(! -#! '('7!3'(!<br />

&!>3'%:!.!(B!!<br />

H!(+'3! ='3=!%:'! &#(! #7)#%! U%5#! =!(+'3! '3'%)'=$! 7'':! ='3$.#+$%$! A#3$.$(:#7$!<br />

':'?3':'=.')!(B! 50::6%$.$#+4! G7! +'.$+17$%A! .&#$(! +05$0b#50%0:$5! '%)! 563.6('3! H!(+'3!<br />

.0@3636=3'(!%! +0+70b#=0%0:$=! -#! =D3.D(#3! '+@$('.$0%+! '%)! +.(#%A.&#%$%A! .&#$(! +05$'3!<br />

0(A'%$>'.$0%4! Q&$3#! A#(#=+$%$:3#($%#! 7'%!.! -#(:#=! -#! G636%)66! )0'3! 0(.':! $3#!<br />

G'(!!=! 7'':'+!! -#! ='7%'=3'(!! +D()D(D3#G$3$(! =633'%:'+!! =!(+'3! ='3=!%:'7!! A#(#=3$!<br />

=!3:'=.')!(B! T')#5#! =!(+'3! '3'%3'(! )#$34! =#%.+#3! '3'%3'()'! G6%)'%! 7'('(3'%'5'=.!(B!<br />

H!(+'3! ='3=!%:'! ':'5!73'! 7D(D.D3#%b67A63'%'%! @(0I#3#(4! ?'3!:'3'(! +')#5#! D(#.$:$!<br />

'(.!(:'=3'!+0(6:36!03:':'3!)!(B!26(')'!)0'7!!=0(6:'4!D(#.$5$%$%!A#3$($%$!-#!(#1'&!%!!<br />

'(.!(:'4! ?#-(#! $3#! G'(!!=4! G636%)66! 0(.':'! 7'G'%5!3'.!(:'7'%! ='7A!3'(! U%! @3'%)'!<br />

03:'3!)!(B!C#3#5#=!%#+$33#($%!&#:!)0'3!='7%'=3'(!!=633'%'G$3:#+$!&#:!)#!+'3!=3!!G$(!<br />

7'':! 0(.':!%'! ='-6:'+!! $?$%! =!(+'3! ='3=!%:'! 7'=3'!:!%!%! U%5#3$=3#! #3#! '3!%:'+!!<br />

&#)#1#!63':'%!%!#%!U%#:3$!'('?3'(!%)'%!03'5'=.!(B!!!<br />

H!(+'3! ='3=!%:'! +')#5#! #=0%0:$=! -#7'! .'(!:+'3! GD7D:#7$! &#)#13#7#%! G$(! '%3'7!.'!<br />

03:':'3!)!(B! K'(!:! )!!! #=0%0:$7$! 5'%3'%)!('5'=4! .D:! .0@36:! =#+$:3#($%$!<br />

='@+'7'5'=4!=6(6:+'3!A#3$:#3#($!&!>3'%)!('5'=4!+0+7'3!1'(=3!3!=3'(!!#%!'>'!$%)$(#5#=!<br />

=!(+'3!='3=!%:'!@03$.$='3'(!!-#!67A63':'3'(!!.D:!636+3'('('+!!=6(6363'(!%!G#%$:+#)$$!<br />

7'=3'!:3'(! &'3$%#! A#3:$.$(B! 26! +D(#?.#! +0+70b#=0%0:$=! )!3'%:!3!!! 0(.')'%!<br />

='3)!(:'4! ='('(! '3:'! +D(#?3#($%#! ='.!3!:!! +'3':'4!G$(#7$%!-#!.0@36:6%!+'7A!%3!!%!!<br />

0%! @3'%'! ?!='(:'4! 7#(#3! .#=%030I$! -#! G$3A$3#(#! U%#:! -#(:#4! 70=+633'('! #%! '>!%)'%!<br />

A#?$:3$=! $! 03'%'=3'(!! +'3':'4! 7#(#3! U(AD.3#%:#3#(#b=00@#('.$13#:#7#! ='.=!)'!<br />

G636%:'4! GD.D%5D3! 7'=3'!:3'(!! )$=='.#! '3:'=! =!(+'3! ='3=!%:'7!! =03'73'.!(!5!! -#!<br />

&!>3'%)!(!5!!1'=.U(3#(!03'5'=.!(B!!!<br />

$<br />

%O)&'$L+5@+,! )'! 03+'! =#%)$%$! G#+3#:#7$! -#! D(D%3#($%$!<br />

+'.'('=!A#3$(!#3)#!#.:#7$!':'?3':'=.')!(B!!!<br />

KD(=$7##33$=3#! =!(+'3! '3'%)'! -#! G'.'! 70=+63! '$3#3#(! 03:'=!<br />

D>#(#! D(#.$:4! G#+3#%:#! -#! +#(:'7#! &'(#=#.3$3$$%$%! U%#:3$! G$(! '('5!)!(B! HD?D=!<br />

$3#.:#3#(!-#!70=+63!'$3#3#(4!&!>3!!%'=$.!'=!!!-#!)DD=!:'3$7#.!'?!+!%)'%!G'.'!='>!<br />

7#.$.$($5$3$$! 03:'=! D>#(#! =D:#+! &'7-'%5!3!!! U%#:3$! G$(! ?U>D:! 7036! 03'('=!<br />

AU(D(3#(B!26%6!&#(!#7)#%!U%5#!'$3#%$%!U>!.D=#.$:$%$!+'3':'=!-#!'%$!A$)#(3#($%$!<br />

='(!3':'=!':'5!73'!7'@'(3'(B!<br />

H!(+'3! '3'%3'(!%! ='3=!%:'+!%)'! -#! 70=+63366%! '>'3.!3:'+!%)'! -#! #%! '>!%)'%!<br />

'$3#%$%! U>! .D=#.$:$%$%! +'3'%:'+!%)'! U>#33$=3#! =D:#+! &'7-'%5!3!!%!%! U%#:$!<br />

-'()!(B!HD:#+!&'(C'&-!0!!)#.3#%#G$3$(Y!!<br />

! H#!<br />

_1-541.indd 317 29.02.2012 15:50


$B! HD:#+! &'7-'%5!3!!! D(#.$5$3#(#! )0(6)'%! 7$7#5#=! +'3'(B! X0=+633'(4!<br />

&'7-'%+'3!D(D%3#($%!G$(!=!+:!%!!.D=#.$(4!='3'%!%!!$+#!A$()$!.#:$%!#.:#=!$?$%!<br />

%'=)#!?#-$(#G$3$(B!<br />

$$B! HD:#+!&'7-'%3'(!!&#:#%!%'=)#!)U%D.D(#G$3#%!-#!70=+63366!'>'3.'%!G$(!<br />

1''3$7#.!03'G$3$(B!<br />

$$$B! H!(+'3! '3'%)'! 70=+633'(!%! 70=+636! )#%$3#%! #%! 1'=$(! =#+$:3#(! )#$$=!<br />

.D(3#()#%! &'7-'%! G#+3#7#G$3$(B! ;%5'=4! )'&'! '>! +#(:'7#! -#! A$()$!<br />

A#(#=.$()$$%)#%!=D:#+!&'7-'%5!3!!!U%#:3$!G$(!6('!!'3'%!!03'('=!='G63!<br />

#)$3#G$3$(B!kD%=D!=D:#+!&'7-'%3'(!h!<br />

! )'&'!('&'.!G#+3#%#G$3$(4!7#.$.$($3#G$3$(4!<br />

! )'&'!?'G6=!%'=$.!@'('7'!?#-($3#G$3$(4!<br />

! +'.!3:'+!!)'&'!=03'7)!(4!<br />

! G#+3#:#=!-#!G'=:'=!$?$%!1'>3'!$AD5D!A#(#=:#>4!<br />

! =D:#+! &'7-'%3'(!! )'&'! ?'G6=! GD7D=! -#! 7'-(63'(B! 26! )'! A#($! U)#:#!<br />

+D(#+$%$!'>'3.!(4!<br />

! )$#(!&'7-'%5!3!=!1''3$7#.3#($%#!AU(#!)'&'!'>!A$()$!A#(#=.$($(4!<br />

! +U>3#:#3$!7#.$.$($5$3$=.#!.'=$G$4!&'+.'3!=3'(!$3#!:D5')#3#+$!)'&'!=03'7!<br />

03'G$3$(4!!<br />

! 7#.$.$($5$3$=!$?$%!GD7D=!:#='%3'('!A#(#=!)6763:'7'G$3$(4!<br />

! '$3#! $AD5D%D! )##(3#%)$(:#)#4! A$>3$! $+$>3$$! '>'3.:')'! (03!<br />

07%'7'G$3$(B!!<br />

cD%7')'4! KD(=$7#! A$G$4! =!(+'3! 70=+63366%! 1'>3'! 03)66! D3=#3#()#4! &'7-'%5!3!=!<br />

1''3$7#.3#($! $3#! 70=+63366%! '>'3.!3:'+!%)'! @03$.$='3'(! -#! +.('.#I$3#(! A#3$.$(:#=! $?$%!<br />

=6(6:+'3! G$(! 7'@!! 036.6(63:'+!! -#! 1'(=3!! D(#.$:! +$+.#:3#($%$! G#3$(3#:#=! U%#:!<br />

.'!:'=.')!(B! 26%6%! $?$%! )#! 5$))$! -#! 67A63'%'G$3$(! $%&-6-1'! ,#0#5#1&#+-! %&/6/+('1!<br />

U5#(&-?-+@!V/!$%&-6-1'&'+!/!N-0-(?#!UO#6&#5#N-&-+R!<br />

$B! C#3$:#=.#!03'%!D3=#3#($%!?06%)'!&'7-'%+'3!D(D%3#(!A#%#3)#!.D=#.$5$7$!=0(6:'=!<br />

':'5!73'! )DD=! .6.63'G$3:#=.#)$(B! 26%)'%! &'(#=#.3#4! &'7-'%+'3! D(D%3#()#!<br />

1$7'.3'(!%!%! =!(+'3! '3'%3'()'=$! 70=+633'(!%! )'! #=0%0:$=! )6(6:6%6! AU>#.#5#=!<br />

G$?$:)#!)$=='.#!'3!%:'+!!U%#:3$)$(B!NVP!<br />

$$B! m>#33$=3#!.0@('=+!>!-#!'>!.0@('=3!!D(#.$5$3#(!$?$%!&'7-'%5!3!=.'!A$()$!.#:$%$!>0()6(B!<br />

26! D(#.$5$3#(! &'7-'%3'(!%!! ?06%36=3'! G#+3#:#)#! >0(36=! ?#=:#=.#)$(3#(B! 26!<br />

%#)#%3#4! =D:#+! &'7-'%5!3!!! $3#! 6(''%3'('! A$()$! )#+.#$%)#! G636%:'=!<br />

U%#:3$)$(B!<br />

$$$B! c'!%!=! -#! AD?+D>! )6(6:)'! G636%'%! =!(+'3! 70=+633'(!%! G$(! '('7'! A#3#(#=!<br />

U(AD.3#%:#+$! &#:! D(D%3#($%$%! )##(3#%)$($3:#+$! &#:! )#! 656>! A$()$! .#:$%$! $?$%!<br />

U%#:3$)$(B! 26! %#)#%3#4! G6%3'(!%! U(AD.3#%:#+$%)#! =03'73'.!(!5!! (03! 07%':'=! -#!<br />

)#+.#=!-#(:#=!U%#:!.'!:'=.')!(B!<br />

%CG t>"00%"0) 8"+#"


2"&%0%%&"Z)9"+0"7")C")9''(3':'!='%'33'(!4!=':6!&$>:#.3#($%$%!#.=$%3$$!-#!@'>'(3':'!7'@!+!!$%5#3#%:#3$)$(B!<br />

!<br />

"#,6#1!>#!UO#5?-+(#!,-,6#(&#+-5-5!%+6'K'!1%5/&(',!5?'!$+#h!7#.$.$(:#!:#=Ñ%3'(!%'4!<br />

.#:#3! A$()$3#(#! 67A63'%'%! )#+.#=3#(#! -#! U(AD.3#%:#7#! 7U%#3$=! =':6! @03$.$='3'(!! $3#!<br />

#+'+3'(!!0(.'7'!=0%63:'3!)!(B!<br />

H!(+'3! '3'%3'()'! 7''7'%! 70=+633'(4! #=0%0:$)#=$! '%$! )'3A'3'%:'3'()'%! -#! 1$7'.!<br />

@03$.$='3'(!%)'%!#%!1'>3'!#.=$3#%#%!=#+$:3#($%!U%!+!('3'(!%)'!7#(!'3!(B!26!)6(6:3'()'!<br />

U>#33$=3#!=D?D=G'!-#!=D:#+!&'7-'%5!3!!!G$(!A'('%.U(!AU(#-$!AU(#G$3$(B!26!$+#4!G6!.D(!<br />

&'7-'%5!3!!%!A#?$:3$=!-#7'!'$3#!.D=#.$:$!)D>#7$%)#!)#!03+'!U%#:$%$!0(.'7'!=07'(B!26!<br />

%#)#%3#4! 76='(!)'! G#3$(.$3#%! @03$.$='3'(!%! G#3$(3#%#G$3:#+$! -#! 67A63'%'G$3:#+$! $?$%!<br />

U%5#3$=3#! &'7-'%5!3!=! +$+.#:3#($%$%! $7$5#! '%'3$>! #)$3:#+$! -#! G6%3'(!%! =!(+'3!<br />

='3=!%:'7'!03'+!!='.=!3'(!%!%!)$=='.#!'3!%:'+!%!!A#(#=.$($(B!<br />

!<br />

%O)&'$L+5@+,#7)#=$! $3#.:#3#($! -#! 70=+633'(!! )'! )#($%)#%! #.=$3#:$.$(B! 26! +D(#?.#4!<br />

=!(+'3! '3'%)'=$! 70=+633'(! $?$%! U>#33$=3#! =D?D=G'! -#! =D:#+! &'7-'%5!3!!! U%#:3$! G$(!<br />

?U>D:!'('5!!03:6.6(B!<br />

\'7-'%! -'(3!!!=!(+'3! '3'%)'=$! 70=+633'(! $?$%! U%#:3$! G$(! -'(3!=! -#! +0+7'3! ='7%'=.!(B!<br />

\'7-'%5!3!=4! 70=+633'(!%! 7'':3'(!%!! +D()D(#G$3:#3#($%)#! U%#:3$)$(B! 2D7D=!<br />

U3?#=3#()#!.0@('=!+'&$G$!03:'7'%4!?0=!+'7!)'!NU>#33$=3#!=D3.D(!-#!:#3#>!!(=3'(!!$?$%P!<br />

&'7-'%!! G636%:'7'%! -#! .'(!:! )!!! A#3$(! ='7%'=3'(!! G636%:'7'%! =!(+'3! &'3=! $?$%!<br />

&'7-'%5!3!=4! U>#3! G$(! U%#:#! .'!:'=.')!(B! kD%=D! A#3$($%! -#! .0@('!%! )#%A#+$>!<br />

)'!3)!!4! =#%.3#:#%$%! ='.3'%':'>! G076.3'('! A#3)$$! D3=#:$>)#! &'7-'%5!3!=! =!(+'3!<br />

70=+633'(! $?$%! +0+7'3! -#! #=0%0:$=! )##($! G636%'%! G$(! 6('!! -#! A#?$:! ='7%'!)!(B!<br />

K'(!:+'3!$3#.:#3#($%!tW['3.!3:'=!$+.#%$3$70(+'!G6%6%!#%!<br />

U%#:3$!7036!&'7-'%5!3!=.'%!A#?:#=.#)$(B!26%3'()'%!&'(#=#.3#4!U>#33$=3#!


! +U>3#:#3$! =D:#+! &'7-'%5!3!!! 7#.$.$($5$3$$! 703673'! =!(+'3! '3'%)'!<br />

$+.$&)':! -#! A#?$:! ='7%'!! 7'('.!3:'+!%'! ='.=!)'! G636%'%! $3#.:#3#(#!<br />

)#+.#=.#!G636%63:'+!!A#(#=:#=.#)$(B!<br />

!<br />

L+5@+,'+-$b.O,-&.$-&)&$"+,+5(,(,$%!.'+-$%+-A!,)+5+$i-+'!$%+1A!-+.!$<br />

K'(!:'!)'7'3!!+'%'7$h!.D=#.$5$!.'3#@3#($%#!7U%#3$=!03'('=4!U%5#3$=3#!$%+'%!G#+3#%:#+$!<br />

-#! )$#(! A#(#=+$%$:3#($%! #=+$=3$$%$! .':':3':'=4! #3)#! #)$3#%! D(D%3#()#%! G$(!<br />

GU3D:D%D!)#$$=!10(:3'('!)U%D.D(#(#=!.D=#.$5$!G##%$+$%#!+6%:'=4!)0'%!%!G$>3#(#!<br />

5U:#(.?#!+6%)66!%$:#.3#()#%!'>':$!U3?D)#!7'('(3'%:'=!G$(!.'(!:+'3!D(#.$:!>$%5$($!<br />

)#$34! '7%!! >':'%)'! +'%'7$! -#! @'>'(3':'! +#=.U(D%D%! G$(! &'3='+!! 03'('=! ='G63!<br />

#)$3:#3$)$(B!26%'!#=!03'('=4!.'(!:'!)'7'3!!+'%'7$!$+.$&)':!+'3'7!5!!G076.673'!+0+7'3!<br />

-#!#=0%0:$=!'?!)'%!)'!GD7D=!U%#:!.'!:'=.')!(!NdPB!<br />

;'$!7') 8'('0!) +'&'(%0"$%&) 3'77'88"+%) #'$!7+'0) F$F&0"$) .0811) %D%&) '0#!07!).01$G)<br />

;'$!7')8'('0!)+'&'(%Z);F$3$$! U%3#:#=4! $&('5'.! 7036! $3#! )U-$>! A#3$(3#($%$! '(..!(:'=! -#!<br />

+'3')!!!=!(+'3!$+.$&)':! $3#! AU?!03'73'(!%!!'>'3.:'=!A$G$!G$(!?0=!U%#:3$!10%=+$70%'!<br />

+'&$@.$(!N]PB!<br />

KD(=$7#! A$G$! D3=#3#()#! ##(! &'7-'%+'3! D(D%! $3#7#%! $3#.:#3#($! =!(+'3! '3'%3'()'!<br />

7'7A!%3'.!(:'=!-#!G6%3'(!%!=!(+'3!='3=!%:'7'!='.=!3'(!%!!'(.!(:'=!$+.$70(+'=h!<br />

$<br />

(=%!.'+-$:-+,/+$:-1$`+^!$2&'1&($:.1!.!-+;(-(.$<br />

H!(+'3!'3'%3'()'=$!'3.7'@!!&$>:#.3#($!A#%#3!03'('=!=#%.+#3!-#!7'(!!=#%.+#3!'3'%3'('!AU(#!<br />

>'7!1.!(B! ;3.! 7'@!! &$>:#.3#($%$%! 7#.#(+$>3$$! -#! G6%)'%! ='7%'=3'%'%! :'3$7#.3#($%!<br />

7D=+#=3$$! G6! '3'%3'()'! 7'.!(!:! 7'@!3:'+!%!! #%A#33#7#G$3:#=.#)$(B! H!(+'3! ='3=!%:'!<br />

+.('.#I$3#($%$%! A#(?#=3#.$($3:#+$%)#! )#-3#.$%! =!(+'3! '3'%3'()'=$! '3.! 7'@!! &$>:#.3#($%$!<br />

A#3$.$(#(#=4!=#%.+#3!'3'%3'(3'!=!(+'3!'3'%3'(!%!'('+!%)'=$!1'(=!!'>'3.:'+!!A#(#=:#=.#)$(B!<br />

26%)'%! &'(#=#.3#! '3.! 7'@!! &$>:#.3#($%$4! =!(+'3! '3'%)'! =6(63'5'=! 03'%! $3#.:#3#(! G$(!<br />

=063! 03'('=! ='G63! #.:#=! A#(#=$(B! M'(C'&+'0) F$F&) %0"("&) '$0'&'9%07"+%) %D%&) 8'!#!7)<br />


,'>'$) %7#%3$! =!3'(=#%!<br />

G$(!7'%)'%!)'!G6('3'()'!G636%'%!=6(6363'(!'('+!%)'=$!G$3A$!'3!-#($$%$!&!>3'%)!('5'=!<br />

D+3#(!03'('=!='G63!#)$3#G$3$(B!26%)'%!&'(#=#.3#!)#-3#.!-#!U>#3!+#=.U(!G6!.$@!0(A'%$>#!<br />

+'%'7$! GU3A#3#($%$%! 036.6(63:'+!! $?$%! 1''3$7#.#! A#?#G$3$(B! 2U73#5#! U>#33$=3#! U>#3!<br />

+#=.U()#%! +'3'%'5'=! G$3A$%$%! )$#(! $3#.:#3#(#! '=!!! )'! &!>3!! G$(! #=$3)#! +'3'%:!!<br />

03'G$3#5#=.$(B!!<br />

!<br />

(((=$B(1()$<br />

m>#33$=3#! HR2! ='@+':!%'! A$(#%! $3#.:#3#($%! =!(+'3! '3'%3'()'! =6(63:'+!! $?$%! #$.$:!<br />

U%#:3$! G$(! AU+.#(A#)$(B! 26! #$.$:3#(! ?06%36=3'! G$(#7+#3! 7#.#%#=3#($%! A#3$.$($3:#+$4!<br />

A$($$:5$3$=! -#! A$($$:! 7U%#.$:$! $3#! @'>'(! '%'3$>$4! ='3$.#! 67A63':'3'(!4! D(#.$:!<br />

.#=%$=3#($! -GB! =0%63'(!%)'! 03:'3!)!(B! ! 8#($3#5#=! #$.$:3#($%! .#=%030I$! .('%+1#($! $3#!<br />

G$(3#.$($3:#+$!)#!=6(6363'(!%!D(#.$:!'':'+!%)'!:'3$7#.3#($%$%!)D:#+$4!-#($:3$3$$%!<br />

'(.:'+!! -#! ='3$.#%$%! $7$3#.$($3:#+$%)#! U%#:3$! (03! 07%'7'5'=! 1'=.U(3#()#%! +')#5#! G$(!<br />

='?!!03'G$3#5#=.$(B!!<br />

$<br />

(@=$ %!.'+-$ :-+,/+$ %7.7-+':'%)'! G6! $3#.:#3#(#!<br />

&'::'))#! +'3'7'5'=! 03'%! &'7-'%+'3! +#=.U(D%! A#3$.$($3:#+$%#! 7U%#3$=! ?'3!:'3'(!<br />

7'@'G$3$(B$ 26(')'! )'! U>#33$=3#! =D:#+! &'7-'%5!3!!%!%! =!(+'3! '3'%3'()'! )'&'! )'!<br />

7'7A!%3''G$3:#+$! $?$%! U>#3! U%3#:3#(! A#3$.$($3#G$3$(B! kD%=D! GD7D=G'! -#! =D?D=G'!<br />

&'7-'%5!3!!%! A#3$.$($3:#+$! $?$%! 67A63'%'%! .#-$=! U%3#:3#($%$%! G$(?06! =D:#+!<br />

&'7-'%5!3!!!$?$%!+U>!=0%6+6!03:':'=.')!(B!!<br />

`7A+.!/+$ (K+/&$ &/(-)&5&$ _+-!!-+,$ F-+'!$ 1&@(A-&.(,h$ G9&-$ G,-&)-&.(,$ G9&--(A-&$<br />

6G_O,$ 5F7,$ 5++,/!!h$ ('(9-((,$ _FA$ F-/77$ ;G-6&-&./&h$ 5G.&-&./&$<br />

7567-+,)+'!,!,$ A!.'+-$ A+-A!,)+$ +_!'!,/+,$ G,&)-($ .F-O$ @+./!.=$ D7$ A!.'+-/+$<br />

('1(*/+)$@&$6&-(.(,$+.1!.!-)+'!h+1!-$(6O! 7#.$.$($5$3$$%$%! G'=!:! -#! G#+3#:#+$! $3!<br />

! H#N


A#%#3$%)#! =')!%3'(! .'('1!%)'%! 7'@!3:'=.')!(B! X'>! '73'(!%)'! A#%$! ?'7!(3!=! '3'%3'()'!<br />

0.3'.!3'('=! G#+3#%#%! ='>3'(! H'+!:! '7!%)'! =#+$3:#=.#)$(B! H#+$3#%! -#! .#:$>3#%#%! G6!<br />

#.3#(! AD%#.#! =6(6.:'4! +'3':6('! 7'@:'! -#! )#($%! )0%)6(656)'! )0%)6(:'! A$G$!<br />

7U%.#:3#(3#! :6&'1'>'! #)$3:#=.#)$(B! H'>! #.$4! 7U(#! $%+'%!%!%! G#+3#%:#+$! '?!+!%)'%!<br />

03)6=?'! U%#:3$)$(B,>6%! =!! '73'(!%)'! G6! #.3#(! G'.'! 70=+63! '$3#3#(! 03:'=! D>#(#!<br />

'$3#3#($%! @(0.#$%! -#! #%#(I$! $&.$7'5!%!! ='(!3':'=.')!(B! `(#.$:$! 7'@!3'%! ='>3'(!%! 1'>3'!<br />

03'%!!+'.!3:'=.'!-#!#3)#!#)$3#%!G6!A#3$($!)#!=')!%3'(!=633'%:'=.')!(B!H'>!7#.$.$($5$3$$!<br />

-#!D(#.$:$!G6!%#)#%3#!7U(#)#!=')!%!%!@'('!=633'%:'!-#!.'+'((61!#.:#!'3!='%3!=3'(!%!!<br />

A#3$.$(#%!-#!)#+.#=3#7#%!G$(!1''3$7#..$(B!`(#.$:!$?#($+$%)#!7#(!'3'%!-#!G6%6%!='>'%5!%!!<br />

=#%)$+$!=633'%'G$3#%!=')!%!D(#.$5$3#($%4!'$3#!-#!.0@36:!$?#($+$%)#!+.'.D+D!)#!G6!7033'!<br />

7D=+#3:#=.#)$(B! ;()'&'%! $3$%)#! 7'=3'!=! d^[B[[[! ')#.! ='>! G636%:'=.')!(B! NgPB!!<br />

;()'&'%!$3$!='>!D(#.$:$4!KD(=$7#!D(#.$:$%$%!7'=3'!=!tV^4Z[!#.$!7#(#3!@'>'()'!A#%#3)#!)DD=!1$7'.3'!+'.!3:'=.')!(B!<br />

2D7D=! =#%.3#(#! @'>'(3':'! 03'%'!! +'3'%)!!%)'! ='.:'! )##($! )'&'! 7D=+#=! G$(!<br />

G$?$:)#!)##(3#%)$($3#G$3$(B!L.=$%!G$(!@'>'(3':'!)#+.#$!$3#!='>!#.$%$%!7#(#3!@'>'()'%!<br />

)'&'! 1'>3'! 1$7'.3'! +'.!3:'! 03'%'!! 036'G$3$(B! 26(')'! )'! AU(D3)DD! A$G$4! =D:#+!<br />

&'7'-%5!3!!! )#$$=! D(#.$:! '3'%3'(!73'! =!(+'3)'! #=0%0:$7#4! ='3=!%:'7'4! =')!%!<br />

$AD5D%D%!)##(3#%)$($3:#+$%#!='.=!3'()'!G636%'G$3$(B!!<br />

!<br />

"F,7_$n$2&&.-&,/(.)&$<br />

C#(#=!KD(=$7#3$=4! 70=+6336=4! '?3!=! )D%7'%!%!<br />

U%#:3$! G$(! GU3D:D%D%! +0(6%6! 03)66! A$G$4! KD(=$7#3$=4! 1$>$=$! AD?+D>3D=4! $+$>3$=4! )#%A#+$>! A#3$(! )'!3!:!4! +#+$%$!<br />

)676(':':'!-#!:'(I$%'33#:#!)'&'!)'!'(.:'=.')!(B!<br />

X0=+63366%! '>'3.!3:'+!! -#! ='7%'=3'(!! +!%!(3!! =!(+'3! '$3#3#($%! 7'':! ='3$.#3#($%$%!<br />

'(.!(!3:'+!4! A#3$(! )D>#73#($%$%! 7D=+#3:#+$73#! :D:=D%)D(B! C#3$(! )D>#73#($%$%!<br />

7D=+#3:#+$!$+#!.0@3636=!='3=!%:'+!4! #$.$:4! =!(+'3!=(#)$!-#! @'>'(3':'! A$G$! 6%+6(3'(!!<br />

$?#(#%4! A#(#=.$$%)#! 7'()!:3'(!! )'! U%AU(#%! G$(! +$+.#:)#! D(#.$:$%! -#! -#($:$%!<br />

'(.!(!3:'+!73'! :D:=D%! 03'G$3#5#=.$(B! 26(')'! )'! U%#:3$! G$(! '('?! 03'('=! =D:#+!<br />

&'7-'%5!3!!! )'! )#-(#7#! A$(:#=.#)$(B! X0=+6336=4! $+$>3$=4! ='3=!%'b:'b:'! +0(6%6%6%!<br />

#%! U%#:3$! U>#33$$4! .0@36:6%! 7'':!!D>#($%)#=$!#=0%0:$=4!+0+7030I$=!-#!@+$=030I$=!<br />

#.=$3#($)$(B!L#(4!KD(=$7#


=0633'()'! 7'':!%!! +D()D(:#=! >0(6%)'! $+#4! G6! A#3#5#=.#! )'&'! )'! '!(! +0(6%3'(!%!<br />

0(.'7'! ?!=:'+!%'! %#)#%! 03'5'=.!(B! 26! %#)#%3#(3#4! =03'7! #($$3#G$3$(4! 67A63'%'G$3$(!<br />

$+.$&)':4! A#3$(! 7'('.:'4! 70=+6336=3'! :D5')#3#! 7U%.#:3#($%$%! G636%:'+!!<br />

A#(#=:#=.#)$(B!26!7U%.#:3#()#%!G$(!.'%#+$!)#!=!(+'3!'3'%)'=$!70=+633'(!$?$%!U>#33$=3#!<br />

=D:#+! &'7-'%5!3!!%!%! A#3$.$($3:#+$! 03'G$3$(B! kD%=D! G#+3#%:#4! $+.$&)':4! &!>3!! %'=$.!<br />

.#:$%$4!A#3$(!='7%'!!7'('.:'+!4!=D?D=!A$($$:5$3$#!1!(+'.!-#(:#+$!-#!)DD=!:'3$7#.!<br />

%#)#%$73#!=D:#+!&'7-'%5!3!!!U%#:!.'!:'=.')!(B!!<br />

H!(+'3! '3'%)'! =6(636! G636%'%! -#7'! =6(63'5'=! 03'%! &'7-'%5!3!=! .#:#33$! $3#.:#3#($%!<br />

=!(+'3! '3'%)'! 7''7'%3'(! $?$%! $+.$&)':! +'3'7'('=! 0%3'(!%! A#3$(3#($%$! '(..!(:'%!%!<br />

7'%!%)'4!&'7-'%5!3!=!+#=.U(D%D%!='3=!%:'+!%'!)'!)0(6)'%!='.=!)'!G636%'G$3#5#=.$(B!<br />

26!='.=!4!=!(+'3!'3'%)'!='3=!%:'7'!7'()!:!#)#5#=!G$(!$+.$&)':!-#!A#3$(!'3'%!!+'3')!!!<br />

A$G$4! =!(+'3)'=$! =D?D=! .'+'((613'(!! &'(#=#.#! A#?$(#G$3$(! -#! =!(+'3! '3'%)'%! =#%.+#3!<br />

'3'%3'('!AU?D!)#!'>'3.'G$3#5#=.$(B!!<br />

!<br />

%+5,+A-+.$<br />

VbQQQB$3($B0(A!<br />

db&..@__QQQB.'($:BA0-B.(!<br />

]bcJKB4d[[VB!\'7-'%5!3!=!T#=.U(D!m>#3!&.$+'+!H0:$+70%6!"'@0(6B!2'G'='%3!=!cJK!X'7!%3'(!4!;%='('B!<br />

gb&..@Y__'()'&'%.'($:BA0-B.(!<br />

^bcJKB4d[[[B! L.! -#! L.! `(D%3#($! T'%'7$! m>#3! &.$+'+! H0:$+70%6! "'@0(6B! 2'G'='%3!=! cJK! X'7!%3'(!4!<br />

;%='('B!<br />

ebL()0'%4CB4VWWZB!KD(=$7#6(6:4!+Bdeb]]B!<br />

fbCD3?6G6=42B4!EC30G'3$>'.$0%!'%)!K&#!;A($563.6('3!i'G0(!9'(=#.!$%!K6(=#7FB!K&#!e!.&!j0%1#(#%5#!01!K&#!<br />

L6(0@#'%!T05B!;++05$'.$0%4d]bde!T#@.#:G#(!d[[]4!T@'$%B!<br />

WbCD3?6G6=42B! '%)! ;361.#=$%4! nB4! EKD(=$7#$('%b[VBK#::6>Bd[V[4!L(>6(6:B!<br />

VdbCD%#4LBb;3G'7('=49BbCD3?6G6=42B4d[[dB! KD(=$7#


_1-541.indd 324 29.02.2012 15:50


% ""& $'()*+,($-,./0,$%()1,23$403/./$+25,6/0/0$'7*7.,$%,(8)(.206!$5,$<br />

',6/0$92::,$;/0:/(/+,3,(/0,$41=/6/$<br />

!""#$%&'"&()'%#*+#&!,-./#&01223#/#,%*%4',&',&51%)4#,%&647#+%48434%.&*,9&<br />

:)';%X*!7*!


561&-! )09! ).I! ^&-&! 0/,! .6P0656;)0,(!)09!7!<br />

T%\E#ESX#!>)08-&!7+ B! &46..6/0.!5-/4!7_!96&,!)09!7_!96&,!.833(&4&0,&9!^6,I!DEE*!<br />

CEE!)09!LEE!334!3-/,&).&!^).!.6P0656;)0,(! )09! 7*! 18,! 6,! 969! 0/,! I&(3!<br />

643-/A&!,I&!P-/^,I!3&-5/-4)0;&!98-60P!EQDJ!9!3&-6/9!/5!,I&!.,89


j06A&-.6,&.6060! I)


M&.60! 4)99&(&-6060! 6(&)(! .6096-6(&16(6-(6'(&-6! A&! 7+ B ! A/(),6(6N).!<br />

.6096-6(&16(6-(6'(&-6060! 7U! 6(&! %-/LEE! P-83()-!! )-).!09)! 16-! 9&&-&! .)I63! /(988!<br />

PY-O(4O,O-#!U8-8!4)99&!.6096-6(&16(6-(6609&!/(988!P616!7!.6096-646060!9&!%-/LEE!<br />

P-81809)!7U!P-8180)!PY-&!6.,),6.,6'.&(!/()-)'!Y0&4(6!/-)09)!5)N()!T%\E#ESX!/(988!<br />

PY-O(4O,O-#!M8-)9)0!9)!LEE!334!9ON&6((&-*! 2#7#*! [6P&01&-P*! a#"#*! 76&0)1&-*! h#"#m! "0! 60&]3&0.6A&! ()1/-),/-


F)1(/!J#!M)N)(!96


F)1(/!D#!M-/


% ""J $I7.$M20,$@(N2$H,(,0$41+/=$%/+/H$-,.+,(/0,$403/.$+25,6/0/0$<br />

%,(8)(.206O$D2(=26$D).N)3/6*)0G$5,$D20$-2+2(!$>3,(/0,$41=/+,(/$<br />

@',%*4,4,7&=*)3#.&',&<br />

(#)"')/*,$#C&>*)$*++&>'/2'+4%4',&*,9&=3''9&D4249+&&<br />

!<br />

H&(64!>&-,*!:6P&0!U!-'3!0)-!<br />

[P&!j06A&-.6,&.6!<br />

$<br />

?3,1$<br />

M8! Z)(!4)9)! )-3)! 6Z&-&0! &,(6'! 36(6Z!


921,(*2+$5,$-P01,.$<br />

i)(!4)9)! 9Y-,! 48)4&(&! P-818! /(8,8-8(48,8-#! M6-60;6! P-83G! V! DE! ,O4! 9)0&! )-3)!<br />

6Z&-&0!A&!V!E#J!/-)0!09)!QP(8')0)N!&0N64(6!T"((,&;IX*!6'60;6!P-83G!V!DE!,O4!9)0&!<br />

)-3)!6Z&-&0!&0N64.6N*!OZO0;O!P-83G!V!DE!YO,O(4O!)-3)!6Z&-&0!A&!V!E#J!/-)0!09)!Q<br />

P(8')0)N! &0N64(6! A&! 9Y-9O0;O! P-83G! V! DE! YO,O(4O! )-3)! 6Z&-&0! &0N64.6N! /()-)'!<br />

I)N!-()04!,!-#!i)(!4)!D!


F)1(/!J#!2&0&4&!P-83()-!0!0!;)0(!!)!-(!'()-!!TPX!<br />

k-83()-! M)()0P!Z! J#!<br />

I)5,)!<br />

D#!<br />

I)5,)!<br />

B#!<br />

I)5,)!<br />

C#!<br />

I)5,)!<br />

S#!<br />

I)5,)!<br />

K#!<br />

I)5,)!<br />

FO4!9)0&!)-3)!<br />

&0N64(6!!<br />

CL#B!<br />

uJ!<br />

JKc#E!<br />

uS!<br />

BLD#E!<br />

uJc!<br />

LBL#E!<br />

uDC!<br />

JBLL#D!<br />

uBL!<br />

DJJE#J!<br />

uSE!<br />

DcKK#E!<br />

ucE!<br />

FO4!9)0&!)-3)!<br />

&0N64.6N!<br />

CL#D!<br />

uJ!<br />

JSE#E!<br />

uK!<br />

BcL#E!<br />

uDJ!<br />

LJB#J!<br />

uDL!<br />

JBcK#K!<br />

uCS!<br />

DEBL#E!<br />

uSR!<br />

DKKR#K!<br />

uLD!<br />

vO,O(4O!)-3)!<br />

&0N64(6!!<br />

Cc#L!<br />

uJ!<br />

JSL#S!<br />

uS!<br />

BKJ#S!<br />

uJc!<br />

LJD#D!<br />

uDB!<br />

JBDc#L!<br />

uBc!<br />

DESL#J!<br />

uCL!<br />

DKRS#L!<br />

uKc!<br />

vO,O(4O!)-3)!<br />

&0N64.6N!<br />

CK#K!<br />

uJ!<br />

JCR#R!<br />

uS!<br />

BLJ#J!<br />

uJc!<br />

LJK#J!<br />

uDC!<br />

JBLR#R!<br />

uBL!<br />

DELC#L!<br />

uSE!<br />

DcDL#D!<br />

ucE!<br />

%! E#KSBS! E#JERL! E#LDDC! E#LScC! E#KDEc! E#cRKJ! E#LJLJ!<br />

b-,)()4)()-!)-).!09)'6!5)-'(!(!'()-!6.,),6.,6'6!)Z!9)0!Y0&4.6N96-!T%rE#ESX#!<br />

!<br />

F)1(/!D#!2&0&4&!P-83()-!0!0!


F)1(/!C#!kYO.!A&!18,!&,6!1&.60!4)99&.6!6Z&-6'(&-6!TVX!A&!3+!9&&-(&-6!<br />

!<br />

k-83()-!<br />

U8-8!4)99&!! +)4!3-/,&60!! +)4!


.&-84! ,/3()4! A&! +2l! '/(&.,&-/(O! /-)0!0!! )-,!-9!!0!! A8-P8()-'&0G! 7&^4)0! A&! )-'#!<br />

TJKX!6.&!QP(8')0)N!&0N646!6()A&.6060!,/3()4!'/(&.,&-/(!A&!l2l!'/(&.,&-/(!9&&-(&-606!<br />

9OO-9OO0O!A8-P8()4!()-9!-#!!<br />

H/08Z!/()-)'!)-),!-4))-,60&N*! =#>#*! 7&^4)0*! a#U#*! 7&^4)0*! _#g#! JRRJ*! [-664! ,)-6I6m! 2/^0(/)9&9! 5-/4!<br />

t0#08,-6,6/0#/-P!1


% ""! $02=1/8$'/(2$92*26!0!0$'()*+,($T26*)0+2(!0:2$X/12./0Y9/0,(2+$<br />

D2*02!$U+2(2=$DG++20!+.26!0!0$%,(8)(.206$>3,(/0,$41=/+,(/$<br />

!""#$%+&'"&K+4,7&R,*$%4O*%#9&=)#;#)L+&J#*+%&S0*$$


^6,I!3/.6,6A&!;/0,-/(#!+&0;&*!,I6.!-&.8(,!.I/^&9!,I),!SV!60);,6A&!1-&^&-s.!O'&44&(! 16-! M! '/43(&'.! A6,)460!<br />

')


)4);!


I2(1!.2$5,$;)0GH$<br />

i)(!4)0!0!./0809)!A6,)460!A&!460&-)(!9ON&


9)I)!6(&-6!,&'06'(&-!'8(()0)-)'!4)"?baU"*!"#*!l"@a[7F?e*!"#!_#*!H"7F?7*![#*!"a"@y!hb*!l#!:#*!>"_"a?#!>#!26&,)-60&-)(! >6]! a&4/A)(! 28-60P! ,I&! :606.I&-! %&-6/9! /0! M-/6(&-! _I6;'&0! %&-5/-4)0;&#! QA& B223A& ('13%A& U#+A!<br />

JJmJDJoJDK*!TDEEDX#!<br />

>?"eeb*!a#!2#*!Ua":F*!H#!>bH_+[FF?*![#!2/.!06A&(&.!9&!l&A)98-)!9&!_&-A&N)!S0A&$#)#O4+4*#T&;/4/!<br />

3-/4/,/-!0),8-)(!9&!;-&;646&0,/!&0!3)--6((&-/.#!U#OA&B)7A&()'9A&B,4/#!JS!TDX*!KKDQKB*!TJRRSX#!<br />

>ba"l[H*!a#*!:a"7_[H_+*! >#*!Ma@:a"@*!h#![556;);b@2?*!>#!TDEELX#![55&;,!/5!9655&-&0,!(&A&(.!/5!.833(&4&0,)(!


!<br />

F)1(/!D#!2&0&4&!-).[!<br />

T';)(p'PX!9ON&0*!JSE!P!e0*!JEE!P!:&*!DE!P!_8*!J#S!P!?*!E#S!P!_/*!E#D!P!H&*!J!P!>/*!SE!P!>P!6Z&-4&',&96-#!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!JL$


F)1(/! B#! M-/


% ""K $D2021+!$>(,1/./0:,$M/8)(.21+2(!0$;2+.)0,++2$5,$;/0:/(/.$;/61,./$<br />

9/=()


60A&.,6P),&! 4)0)P&4&0,! )09! 96&,)-&-'&N6X!H)(4/0&(()s


2/()-!! ,).)--85! &96(4&.60&! 0&9&0! /();)!0!! Y0&! .O-4&',&96-#! M8! 0&9&0(&*! ')0),(!!<br />

O-&,64609&!


1)(),4)!A&!1O


M)!-.)'!46'-/5(/-).!0!0!P&(6646


$848-,)9)0! [! A&! ./9


D2*02=+2($<br />

2&.)6!2#*!%),^)-9I)0!2#!)09!a)0)9&!"#!TDEEcX!";69656&-.!60!%/8(,-


% ""L $T26*)0$\/3/0$;,5/*,6/0/0$]2N)0$'!+:!(C!0+2(:2$'7*7.,$%,(8)(.206!$<br />

5,$'2!!=+!=$>3,(/0,$41=/6/$<br />

@


A&-64(6(6606! )N)(,4)',)9!-! T_/-N/! A&! )-')9)()-!*! DEEDX#! M)()0P!Z! 96


6121/61/=6,+$@02+/3+,($<br />

M8!9&0&


1O#! TDEECX! a&.3/0.&! ,/! ()/1)! H#>#*! 7/--6.! 2#*! >)(),t&! >#H#*! >1)t6/-P8! _#"#! TDEERX! [55&;,! /5! 96&,)-


$<br />

$<br />

$<br />

$<br />

$<br />

$<br />

$<br />

$<br />

F)1(/! J#! Z&-6'(&-! A&! 96!.!-!P(O,&0!


F)1(/! D#! a).


% ""Q $'()/+,($T26*)0+2(!02$%()&-)( ) *!#.4&,!FO-'4&0 )!<br />

} M8!4)')(&!a&A8&!9&!>&96;60&!=&,&-60)6-&!9&-P6.609&!1).!(4)'!ON&-&!')18(!&96(46,6-# !<br />

) 2&3)-,4&0,!/5!"064)(!78,-6,6/0!)09!78,-6,6/0)(!26.&).&.*!:);8(,&96;60&*!@06A&-.6,!JcDRRX!/0! ,I&!P-/^,I!3&-5/-4)0;&! )09! ;)-;)..!<br />

,-)6,.!60!1-/6(&-!;I6;'&0.!)09!,/!)0)(


;)-;)..! ^&6PI,! T3\E#EJX*! -&98;&9! ,I&! 5//9! 60,)'&! ;)(;8(),&9! 5/-! K! ^&&'.! T3\E#EEJX!<br />

)09! 643-/A&9! ,I&! 5//9! ;/0A&-.6/0! -),6/.! .60;&! ,I&! C ,I ! ^&&'! ^6,I! .833(&4&0,),6/0!<br />

T3\E#EEJX#! ?0! 3)-)((&(*! .6P0656;)0,(


!<br />

9,!:&;74&51!/5!#0#&%8&51!<br />

MO,O0!I)


.&A6! JcDRRXs60! A)-(!!! 6(&! )Z!'()0)16(6-#! iO0'O! =A&<br />

+18%434+! 2H>! JcDRR! 6Z&-&0! 3-/16


1&.(&0&0! P-8180! ;)0(!!)!-(!'! ')N)0;!*! /05/-,*! h#>#*! k)--6P)*! >#m! l);,/1);6((8.! .)(6A)-68.!<br />

_F_DJRc! 3-&A&0,.! H)(4/0&(()! &0,&-6,696.! ;/(/06N),6/0! 60! ;I6;'&0.#! "33(#! [0A6-/0#! >6;-/1#*! JRRRG! KSm!<br />

CRLJQCRLK#!<br />

JD#! $)4)0*!+#*!@(8')0(6*!e#*![(4)(6*!>#*!@0)(*!$#m!FI&!&55&;,!/5!)!5&-4&0,&9!3-/16/,6;*!,I&!'&56-*!/0!<br />

60,&.,60)(!5(/-)!/5!3/8(,-&9#!=&,#*!DEEKG!JScm*!BcRQBLK#!!<br />

JB#! "09&-./0*! 2#M#*! >;! _-);'&0*! =#h#*! "460/A*! a#h#*! H643./0*! h#>#*! >);'6&*! a#h#*! =&.,&P&4*!<br />

>#g#"#*!k).'60.*!+#a#m!k8,!46;-/16/(/P


JK#! F&/*! "#$#l#*! F)0*! +#>#m! 0I616,6/0! /5! _(/.,-69684! 3&-56-60P&0.! 1#"#m!%-/16/,6;.!60!3/8(,-


F)1(/!J#!"-),!-4)9)!'8(()0!()0!)0P)0&N!CE!4P!2&46-*!KE!4P!i60'/*!S!4P!M)'!-*!E*S!4P!<br />

/0/96P(6.&-6,!


!KV$<br />

!<br />

F)1(/!D#!M-/6(&-!!-).


!KW$<br />

!<br />

F)1(/!B#!M-/6(&-!!-).


% ""V !=#&4@05&&#!=AAB*,!M)2+$U+2(2=$92(G3$D2+20$41+/=$%/+/H+,(:,$$<br />

U(R20/=$@6/1+,(/0$41=/0+//$<br />

!""4$*$.&'"&K3%)*84'%4$&',&*&5*%1)*3&>)-6)*!H)0,)!>)-6)*!aH*!M-&N6(6)46*!:l*!"M2#!!<br />

!<br />

?3,1$<br />

i)(!4)()-*!9&0&


(6A&-.!^&-&!;/((&;,&9!5/-!1);,&-6/(/P6;)(!)0)(


6Z60! -).,P&(&! )


S#! >606.,-#! _/0,-&-).#! DEEK#! [55&;,! /5! )0!<br />

8(,-)16/,6;! /0! H)(4/0&(()! ,


% ""W $'()/+,(+,(:,O$=#&4@05&&5!C0*51%*%6%($D)01()+7$H/0$U(R20/=$@6/1+,(/0$<br />

DG++20!.!$<br />

!""4$*$.&'"&K3%)*84'%4$&',&%


3/^9&-!60!,I&!96&,!5-/4!DR!,/!BS!9)?_X!1&(6-(&4&'!A&!18080*!8(,-)16


D0!/%/@$M,,(+,0:/(.,6/$<br />

LE!PO0(O'!_/11!966!1-/6(&-!36(6Z(&-&!18!9&0&)-8N!')(4)


D2*02=+2($<br />

J#!"(,&'-8.&*!H#*!7#!M)8&-*!"#!_I)0(/0P18,-)*!a#!2&H)P80*!"#!7)8P(&*!g#!H;I(/..&-*!a#!@4I/(,N*!A&!%#!<br />

gI6,&#! DEEK#! 0*3/',#33*& !,%#)4%494+! 60! 1-/6(&-! ;I6;'&0.! T&,! ,)A8'()-!09)! 0*3/',#33*& !,%#)4%494+T! *! "M2*!<br />

DEEEoDEES#![4&-P#!?05&;,#!26.#!JDmJLCLoJLSD#!<br />

D#!!b(6A&6-)*!:#!"#*!%).`8)(/,,/*!"#!%#*!H6(A)*!g#!%#*!A&!F/09/*![#!_#!DEJE#!_I)-);,&-6N),6/0!/5!0*3/',#33*&<br />

[0,&-6,696.! 6./(),&9! 5-/4! I84)0! .)43(&.! T0*3/',#33*& [0,&-6,696.s60! 60.)0! Y-0&'(&-609&0! 6N/().&,I/9.!<br />

5/-! 26(8,6/0! "0,646;-/16)(! H8.;&3,616(6,


% ""# $41+/=$%/+/H$-,.+,(/0:,$c2(=+!$;,5/*,+,(:,$'7*7.,$d*2(!C!$'/1=/6,+$<br />

4=61(2=1$D2(!!.!$DG++20!+.26!0!0$'7*7.,$%,(8)(.206!$5,$D2(=26$<br />

D2+/1,6/$>3,(/0,$41=/+,(/$<br />

!""#$%+&'"&:)';%


$<br />

F/(/$<br />

%-/16


2&0&4&9&! '8(()0!()0! 1)N)(! -).


_6A;6A! A&! 36(6Z! 9Y0&4609&!


F)1(/!J#!M)N)(![!T';)(p'PX!!<br />

BEKL#JD!<br />

BDEE#RJ!<br />

+)4!%-/,&60!*!V!! DB#EJ! DE#EJ!<br />

+)4!$)*!V! c#DJ! R#ES!<br />

_)*!V! J#EE! E#RC!<br />

$)-)-()0!()16(6-!:/.5/-!*V! E#CL! E#BL!<br />

>&,6&,X*!V! E#KK! E#SS!<br />

>&,WH6.,60!*!V! J#EE! E#LS!<br />

l6N60*!V! J#CJ! J#JS!<br />

J! J'P!


F)1(/!D#![,(6'!%6(6Z!$&4(&-60&!:)-'(!!2ON&8)4&(&(&- ç !<br />

%&-5/-4)0.!U-6,&-(&-6!<br />

FE! FDSE! FSEE! FKEE! H[> %!<br />

_)0(!! "!-(!'! "-,!!*! ! ! ! ! ! !<br />

Pp36(6Z!<br />

EQB!+)5,)()-! cLB#CD); cRK#Jc1;! LER#LB1! LDC#E1! R#RD! E#EEc!<br />

CQK!+)5,)()-! JKER#E! JKDL#C! JKDR#K! JKKE#K! DJ! E#CBL!<br />

EQK!+)5,)()-! DBRD#C)1 DCDC#K)1! DCBR#S1; DCLC#K; JK#C! E#EER!<br />

$&4!FO'&,646*!Pp36(6Z! ! ! ! ! ! !<br />

EQB!+)5,)()-! JJJL#R! JJDK#K! JJED#B! JJES#K! JB#CC E#DJB!<br />

CQK!+)5,)()-! BJEc#J! BEKB#J! BJKE#c! BJCL#c! BC#K! E#DcR!<br />

EQK!+)5,)()-! CDDK#J! CJLR#K! CDKB#E! CDSC#B! BK#C! E#JJK!<br />

$&49&0!$)-)()04)! ! ! ! ! ! !<br />

EQB!+)5,)()-! J#CDL)! J#CJS);! J#BKJ1;! J#BCD1! E#EJL E#EBR!<br />

CQK!+)5,)()-! J#RBJ! J#LLJ! J#RBR! J#LRK! E#EEK E#EED!<br />

EQK!+)5,)()-! J#cKK)! J#cDL1! J#cCc)! J#cJD1! E#EEC E#EEJ!<br />

)o; "


% "&" $U(R20/=$D).N+,=6$9/0,(2++,(/0$41H/$%/+/H+,(:,$41$D2+/1,6/0,$41=/6/$<br />

!""#$%+&'"&>'/23#G&',&=)'43#)&/#*%&V1*34%.&<br />

!<br />

F)


FI&! (&A&(! /5! /-P)06;)((


96&-!OZO!9&0&4&!P-818!/(4)'!ON&-&*!I&-16-609&!JEs)-!;6A;6A!18(80)0!Ss&-(6!)(,!P-83(8!<br />

C! )0)! P-81)! ,&.)9O5O! /()-)'! 9)!,!(9!#! +&-! )(,! P-83! J4 D s(6'! )()0()-9)*! .O-&'(6!<br />

)/9&(! Tkl>X! 4/9&(60&! P/-&! H%HH! TJKX! 3)'&,!<br />

3-/-)4!!'8(()0!()-)'!9&&-(&096-6(96#!b-,)()4)()-!)-).!09)'6!5)-'(!(!!0!Y0&4!,&.,609&!<br />

280;)0!i/'(8!U)-!(),!-4)!F&.,6*!%\E#ES!Y0&4(6(6'!9&-&;&.609&!'8(()0!(9!#!<br />

!<br />

'G+RG+2($<br />

%6(6Z(&-60! PYO.! &,6! 56(&,/()-!0)! )6,! 3+*! FM"aH! A&! -&0'! 9&&-(&-6! F)1(/! Bs,&!<br />

A&-6(46,6-#!b-P)06'!460&-)(!.&A6


-&0'! ,/08! T+}X! 9)I)! '!-4!N!! /()-)'! 1&(6-(&096#! :)-'(!! .&A6[*!T>h!'P QJ X}} ! ! JD#K! JB#E!<br />

+)4!%-/,&60!T!P!'P! QJ X! DDJ! DEE!<br />

_)*&T!P!'P! QJ X! R#E! L#E!<br />

%*&T!P!'P! QJ X! K#E! c#E!<br />

l0*!KE#E!4P!T).!>0bXG!:&*!BE#E4PG!?*!<br />

D#E!4PG!H&*!E#JS!4P#!!<br />

}}!b-P)06'!'/43(&'.!>0*!e0!)09!_8!).!M6/3(&]Q>0 F> *!M6/3(&]Qe0 F> !)09!M6/3(&]Q_8 F> !<br />

&<br />

!<br />

!QQ$


F)1(&!B#!b-P)06'!'/43(&'.!460&-)((&-60!PYO.!&,6!56(&,/.8080!3+*!FM"aH!A&!-&0'!<br />

9&&-(&-60&!&,'6.6!!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

a).0!T).!>0bX*!!7a_s060!!,)A.6 !X!<br />

460&-)(!'),'!.!!<br />

$<br />

I2(1!.2$5,$;)0GH$<br />

"-),!-4)9)0! &(9&! &96(&0! PYO.! 56(&,/()-!0)! )6,! 3+! 9&&-(&-6*! Y0;&'6! )-),!-4)()-9)!<br />

16(96-6(&0! 3+! )-)(!'()-!09)! 1&(6-(&096! TJc*JLX#! [,60! 3+s.!! 6(&! &,! ')(6,&.6! )-).!09)'6!<br />

6(6'6


FM"aH! 9&&-(&-6! 18! );6,*! >#*! U)-)/(8*! >#*! "'.8*! >#*! M!6(P60*! b#_#m! [55&;,.! /5! 96&,)-#[#*! g)-9! F#l#m! [)-(#m!FI&!&55&;,.!/5!(/^&-!(&A&(.!/5!<br />

/-P)06;)((&9*!@06A&-.6,


RQ! H)-!3!0)-!"'.8*!2#*!"'.8!F#*!vN./#m!?05(8&0;&!/5!96&,)-#%#m& l6369! /]69),6/0! 60! 3/8(,-#l#!k-)#?!*!U)-)/P(8*!>#*!U)#*![.&018P)*!7#*!>);6,*!>#m![55&;,!/5!96&,)-#:*!k)-;6)Q7&,/!>#*!l);)A)*!%#>#m%&-5/-4)0;&!)09!;/(/-!/5!1-/6(&-.!<br />

5&9! 96&,.! ;/0,)6060P! ! aI/9/;


% "&& $4(=,=$41+/=$%/+/H+,(:,$@N/+2(0/+$^4(=,=$@(!$\2(526!_$d*RG+2.26!0!0$<br />

F,+/.,$%,(8)(.206!$5,$=/0C/+$4,*$?3,++/=+,(/$>3,(/0,$41=/+,(/$<br />

@


"M2! A&! U)0)9)! I)-6Z! "M! O('&(&-609&! I)


921,(*2+$5,$-P01,.$<br />

M,0,.,$:,6,0/$$<br />

"-),!-4)9)*!Jc!PO0(O'!CE! )9&,! &-'&'! &,(6'! 36(6Z! Ta/..QBELX! '8(()0!(4!,!-#!2&0&4&!<br />

.O-&.60;&*! 36(6Z(&-! P&06(6'! A&! 9&-60(66! BE! ;4*!


'G+RG+2($5,$I2(1!.2$<br />

"!N!


TDEJEX!,&,/.,&-/0!8#a#! _/-&(()#! DEJE#! H&-84! .&]8)(! .,&-/69!<br />

I/-4/0&.!)09!(6369.!60!;/44&-;6)(!1-/6(&-.!Tk)((8.!9/4&.,6;8.X!60!_/.,)!a6;)#!h/8-0)(!/5!"33(6&9!%/8(,-)-8


7)84)00*! _#! )09! a#! M)..(&-#! JRRB#! >&,I/9&018;I*! M)09! ???#! 26&! ;I&46.;I&! 80,&-.8;I80P! A/0!<br />

58,,&-46,,&(0#!=2l@:"Q=&-()P*!2)-4.,)9,*!k&-4)0/-3I/(/P


% "&J $;7(7$-2!$5,$0=G&.8,!FO-'/(8 1!<br />

) M[$%!M&


8


Z!'!! PO;O! A&! Z!'!! PO;O0O! &,'6(&


)(!04!,!-#! F&3.6(&-9&'6! !.')-,)! ;6A;6A(&-! 6(&! Z!'!! /(4)


F)1(/!J#! _b D ! '/0,-/(! .6.,&460&! .)I63! P&(664! 4)'60&(&-609&! '().6'! A&!


F)1(/!D#!k&0Z!Q!! E#cBL! E#DJD! E#DKK! E#cEK!<br />

%!2&&-(&-6! ! ! ! ! !<br />

HO-O!$)!! E#EEE! E#DcB! E#DLC! E#EEE!<br />

U8(8Z')!%-/P-)4!! E#ECS! E#DcD! E#LSC! E#EBK!<br />

HO-O$)!]U8(8Z')%-/P-)4!! E#EDK! E#RRJ! E#CLc! E#EEc!<br />

)1 !"


$<br />

$<br />

$<br />

$<br />

$<br />

$<br />

$<br />

$<br />

$<br />

$<br />

&,'6(&966! PY-O(4O,O-! T3\E#ESX#! BD! I)5,)(!'!


D2*02=+2($<br />

"0/0#*!"'4)0*!7#*!"'!0*!$#*!_&0P6N*!:#*![-,8-8(*!>#*!:!-),(!*!_#!A&!$&0&-*!>#!JRRB)#!Ñ+)#!H)-!;)*!>#*!"-9)*!>#*![-&0.)


% "&! $41+/=$%/+/H+,(:,$S/5C/5$@!(+!!$/+,$D,6/.$%,(8)(.206!$@(26!0:2=/$<br />

+/=/+,($<br />

@


F/(/$<br />

[,(6'! 36(6Z! O-&,646!


-)0.)(!)!-(!'!)-).!09)!0&P),65!6(6'6!/(98808!16(96-&0!F/0)!A&!)-'#!TJDX!6(&!8


k-)56'! J#! _6A;6A! )!-(!!*! /-)0.)(! )!-(!'*! J#I)5,)! )!-(!!*! '&.64! )!-(!!! A&! PYO.!<br />

)!-(!!!)-).!09)'6!6(6'6(&-&!)6,!9/-8.)(!9&0'(&4(&-!<br />

$$ @$ $ $ $ $ $ '$<br />

'##<br />

$##<br />

&##<br />

()*+,*-!*!)-!.<br />

%##<br />

$##<br />

34!5*67*!*!)-!!<br />

"##<br />

"##<br />

%# &#<br />

%# &#<br />

/01201!*!)-!!<br />

/01201!*!)-!!<br />

! !<br />


K#! >&6t&-I/5*!a#m!2&56060P!)09!4&).8-60P!`8)(6,/(&0))-*!a#m![A)(8),6/0!/5!;I6;'!`8)(6,


% "&K $I25G=$41/$92(/026*)0G0:2$D!(.!3!$2(2NO$Z2($4=/6/$5,$%,=.,3$<br />

DG++20!.!0!0$>(7070$'23!$D2+/1,$?3,++/=+,(/0,$41=/6/$<br />

!""#$%+&'"&K+4,7&U#9&Y4,#C&:)*2#&F'3*++#+&*,9&('/#7)*,*%#&>',$#,%)*%#&4,&<br />

F*)4,*%4',&'"&>


F/(/$<br />

U)0),(!! .&',Y-O09&'6! &0,&P-).


&0t&'.6


!<br />

F)1(/!D#!>)-60&!,)A8'!&,(&-609&!3+*!4)-60).


!<br />

%G20<br />

#<br />

W<br />

V<br />

Q<br />

L<br />

K<br />

!<br />

J<br />

&<br />

"<br />

DM D4 I%ZM I%Z4<br />

T,0= D)=G \,33,1 -2N!$ F,0,+<br />

',,0/<br />

!<br />

&'6(! J#! >)-60&! ,)A8'! &,(&-6060! 98)-60).;U&&*! H**! "(A)-)9/*! _*m! >)-60),6/0! )09! M-6060P! /5! %/8(,-&),!H;6&0;&!"../;6),6/0!a&;63-/;)(!>&),!_/05&-&0;&*!DEEC*!JDRQJBS!<br />

S#! "(A)-)9/*!_**!>;U0&&*!H*!!>)-60),6/0!,/!?43-/A&!:80;,6/0)(!%-/3&-,6&.!)09!H)5&,&),*!%/8(,-',7)#++&'"&0#*"''9&@#$)2#$<br />

JE#! U/09)6)I! 7#*! "0t&0&


!#K$<br />

!<br />

JJ#!<br />

M-/,.'**!=6)0)*!"*!k*!b3,646N),6/0! /5! ,I&!.,6(Q4)-60),60P!3-/;&..! /5!<br />

;I6;'&0!3)-,.*!>&),!H;6&0;&*!JRRRG!SD*!DDcQDBC!!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!


% "&L $dHGCG$D,=/=$-2!0!0$I23,$U+2(2=$9GA28232$4:/+,0$%/+/H$41+,(/0/0$<br />

'23!$D2+/1,$?3,++/=+,(/$>3,(/0,$41=/6/$<br />

@


921,(*2+$5,$9,1)1$$<br />

M8!)-),!-4)9)*!N46-!'&'6'!/,8!T`)47*,1/&',4%#+X!16-!()1/-),8A)-!YO,O;O!,)-)5!09)0!<br />

'!! FM"! -&)P&0,! '8(()0!()-)'! I)N!-()0)0!<br />

6(&04&46! 3)-Z)! ')-!.!09)0! SBD! 04! /()-)'! Y(ZO(4O,O-#! H/08Z()-! 4P!<br />

4)(/096)(9&I6,!T>2"X!p!'P!08480&!;60.609&0!65)9&!&96(46,6-#!<br />

!<br />

MG*G62+$202+/3$<br />

%6(6Z! &,6! 084808&(&-6! 16-! !NP)-)! TF&5)(*! :-)0.)X! ON&-609&! B! 9)'6')! 366-6(46*! 9)I)!<br />

./0-)!-).,P&(&!16-! &'6(9&!A&!.!;)'!T


OI&096.(66! MY(O4O! 4&N80()-!! A&! 3&-./0&(X! ,)-)5!09)0! 9&&-(&096-6(46,6-#!<br />

78480&(&-! Z6! A&! 3646! I)(9&! 9&&-(&096-6(46,6-#! %646! 08480&(&-60!<br />

9&&-(&096-6(4&.6!I8.8.809)!3)0&(6.,(&-9&0!


F)1(/!J#!M8,!A&!PYO.!&,6!3+*!


'),'!.!0!0! I&4! 18,! I&49&! PYO.! &,6! 08480&(&-6060! 98


I2(1!.2$<br />

M8! Z)(!4)0!0! ./08Z()-!! 8Z8;8! '&'6'! 2*!<br />

@H"*!JRRRG!"b"_!?0,&-0),6/0)(#!<br />

JD#! H)(()4*! UI#! ?#*! ?.I6/-/.I6*! >#*! H)4&t64)*! U#m! "0,6/]69)0,! )09! )0,646;-/16)(! &55&;,.! /5! P)-(6;! 60! ;I6;'&0!<br />

.)8.)P&#!l&1&0.4#Qg6..#!8#!F&;I0/(#*!DEECG!Bcm!LCRQLSS#!<br />

JB#!>6,.84/,/*!>#*!bsP-)9#7#*!U&--&),!H;6&0;&*!DEEJG!Scm!BBJoBBK#!<br />

DE#!k6)00&0).*!?#"#*!:(/-/8Q%)0&-6*!%#*!M/,./P(/8*!7#"#*!_I-6.,)'6*![#*!H3)6.*!"#M#m![55&;,!/5!.833(&4&0,60P!5&&9!<br />

^6,I!/-&P)0/!)09p/-!Q,/;/3I&-


% "&Q $I7(=/*,k:,=/$j/0:/$5,$I25G=$D,6/.A20,+,(/0:,$-23$@*+2(!0:2$%;4$<br />

41$U+GG.G0G0$',+/(+,0.,6/$>3,(/0,$'/($@(21!(.2$<br />

B&U#+#*)$64)-(!'!:)'O(,&.6*!k!9)!>OI&096.(66!MY(O4O*!<br />

"0')-)!j06A&-.6,&.6*!>OI&096.(6'!:)'O(,&.6*!k!9)!>OI&096.(66!MY(O4O*!2!')3!!<br />

M8!Z)(!4)!H)0)


1&&0!.,896&9!60!-&;&0,!


)-).!09)! 16-! 0/',)9)! )(!0)0! Y-0&'(&-9&! Y(ZO(&0! 3+! 9&&-6060! S#Ls60! )(,!09)! /(4).!!<br />

I)(609&!%H[s(6!&,!/(884809)0!1)I.&96(&;&6!16(96-6(46,6-!TJC*JSX#!kO0O4ON9&!%H[!<br />

/(8848! 6'6! )0)! 5)',Y-&! 1)()04)',)9!-m! P&0&,6'! A&! Z&A-&.&(! 5)',Y-(&-#! k&0&,6'!<br />

5)',Y-(&-9&!YN&((6'(&!.,-&.!P&06!,)!


F)1(/!J#!+6096!A&!,)A8'!6(&,4&(&-60&!)6,!%H[s(6!&,!/-)0!}!<br />

(&,4&! 2Y0&4! 7/-4)(! %H[! %H[!TVX!<br />

F&448N! DC! K! V!DE!<br />

+6096!J! "8.,/.! DD! L! V!Dc!<br />

F&448N! JR! JJ! V!Bc!<br />

+6096!D! "8.,/.! Jc! JB! V!CB!<br />

F&448N! DS! S! V!Jc!<br />

F)A8'!J! "8.,/.! DC! K! V!DE!<br />

F&448N! BE! E! V!E!<br />

F)A8'!D! "8.,/.! DB! c! V!DB!<br />

$<br />

I2(1!.2$5,$;)0GH$<br />

$)3!()0!)-),!-4)9)!D!,)A8'!A&!D!I6096!6(&,4&.609&!,)-)0)0!Y-0&'(&-9&!/-,)()4)!V!E!<br />

6(&!V!CB!/-)0!09)!%H[s(6!&,&!-).,()04!,!-#!!<br />

+6096! 6(&,4&(&-609&'6! /-)0! VDE! 6(&! VCB! )-).!09)! 9&64&',&96-#! F)A8'!<br />

6(&,4&(&-609&!6.&!18!/-)0!VE!6(&!VDB!)-).!09)!16-!9)!(!4!PY.,&-46,6-#!'60;6!,)A8'!<br />

56-4).!09)! F&448N! )6&(06'*!>#!M#*!")1&),!H;6&0;&!cR*!CKoKB#!<br />

S#! g/&(5&(*! a#! l#*! b^&0.*! _#! >#*! +6-.;I(&-*! [#! >#*! >)-,60&NQ2)^./0*! a#! )09! H)4.! "#! a#! DEED#! FI&!<br />

;I)-);,&-6N),6/0!)09!60;69&0;&!/5!3)(&*!./5,*!)09!&]89),6A&!1-/6(&-!4&),!60!)!;/44&-;6)(!3-/;&..60P!3()0,#!<br />

%/8(,-#!M*!=)0!l));'*!a#!l#!h#!>#!)09![).,-69P&*!h#!H#!JRRL#!M6/3I#!"09!"33(&*!h#U#!%)(&*!H/5,*!)09![]89),6A&!%/8(,-&),#!?0!k8&--&-/Ql&P)--&,)*!?#![9#!<br />

+)091//'!/5!3/8(,-


JC#!M)-18,*!H#!JRRB#!_/(/8-!4&).8-&4&0,.!5/-!&A8(8),60P!,I&!3)(&!./5,!&]89),6A&!T%H[X!/;;8-&0;&!60!,8-'&


% "&V $9/=(),0=2N67+26*)0$I,=0)+)l/6/$5,$D2021+!$40:761(/6/0:,=/$<br />

d*RG+2.2+2(!$<br />

F4$)'#,$*2+13*%4',&@#$6;-/Q&0;)3.8(),6/0*!3/8(,-6'-/&0')3.O().


ï!e/-!ZYNO0&0!16(&6'(&-60!ZYNO0O-(O'(&-6060!6


$<br />

9/=()=2N67++,($<br />

M6-!46'-/')3.O(!&0!1).6,!I)(66'-/')3.O(!<br />

6Z609&'6! 4),&-


H/08Z!/()-)'*!')0),(!!&,6!O-O0(&-6060!O-&,64609&!46'-/&0')3.O(&!&96(46!4),&-6;-/&0;)3.8(),6/0!,&;I0/(/P)-,&(*! "*! +)&.&1-/8;'*! :! )09! 28;),&((&*! a#!<br />

>6;-/&0;)3.8(),&9! .I/-,Q;I)60! 5),,


!<br />

!<br />

% "&W $j/0:/$41+,(/0:,0$3)+,$4:/+,0$=#&4@05&&#!;NNiO$O%(*51%#!E@0@$.*@M505(!/5$<br />

P&@(*1%6%'4!>51?1%0M50(!3)+21+2(!0!0!@01/A&2#)")4,7#,+!<br />

!<br />

@


4)-'&,&9! 60! "0')-)*! 5-/4! h80&! DEES! ,/! h)08)-8(,63(&!)0,616/,6;!-&.6.,)0;&!^&-&!<br />

/1.&-A&9! ).! 5/((/^&9m! S! 6./(),&.! ^&-&! -&.6.,)0,! ,/! D! )0,616/,6;.*! Jc! 6./(),&.! ,/! B!<br />

)0,616/,6;.! )09! K! 6./(),&.! ,/! C! )0,616/,6;.#! F^&0,


O-&,646! S#JJB#EEE! ,/098-#! FO-'63'+%)4941/&<br />

2#)")4,7#,+& 6N/(),!! 4),&-3'+%)4941/&<br />

2#)")4,7#,+!<br />

F&,-).6'(60!TJEP*!b]/69!_FEEEBMX!! }! }! }!<br />

U(/-)45&06'/(!TBEP*!b]/69!_FEEJBMX! }! }! }!<br />

k&0,)46.60!TJEP*!b]/69!_FEEDCMX!! }! }! }!<br />

"436.6(60!TJEP*!b]/69!_FEEEBMX!!! }! }! }!<br />

F-64&,/3-64!TSP*!b]/69!_FEEcKMX! }! ! }!<br />

7)(696'.6'!).6,!TBEP*!b]/69!_FEEBJMX! }! ! }!<br />

H63-/5(/'.).60!TSP*!b]/69!_FECDSMX! }! ! }!<br />

H,-&3,/46.60!TJEP*!b]/69!_FEECcMX! }! }! !<br />

%&06.6(60!TJ@*!b]/69!_FEJSDMX! ! }! }!<br />

F-64&,/3-64p.8(5)4&,/'.)N/(! TDSP*! b]/69!<br />

_FEESDMX!<br />

!<br />

K&J$<br />

}! ! !<br />

U)0)46.60!TBEP*!b]/69!_FEEDKMX! }! ! !<br />

[-6,-/46.60!TSP*!b]/69!_FEEKKMX! ! }! !<br />

=)0'/46.60!TSP*!b]/69!_FEJLLMX! ! }! !<br />

"4/'.6.6(60!TDP*!b]/69!_FEEKEMX! ! ! }!<br />

!<br />

F-;:)-()09! .,)09)-9!0)! )


18(808-'&0*! DL! TVSE#RX! 6N/(),! &0! )N! 6'6! )0,616


16-!)0,616&),.Q%/,&0,6)(! +&)(,I! a6.'#!<br />

:a?!M-6&560P.m!://9!a&.&)-;I!?0.,6,8,&*!@06A#!/5!g6.;/0.60Q!>)96./0#*!>)-;I!DEEK#!<br />

c#! [>["*!TJRRRX#!"0,616/,6;!a&.6.,)0;&!60!,I&![8-/3&)0!@06/0!"../;6),&9!^6,I!FI&-)3&8,6;!@.&!<br />

/5! =&,&-60)-&96;60&.! a&3/-,! )09! à8)(6,),6A&! a6.'! ".&..4&0,! 1


&96;60)(!%-/98;,.#![8-/3&)0!"P&0;&96;60)(!%-/98;,.!T[>["Xp_=>%pBCDpRRQ<br />

;/--Q560)(#!JC#EK#JRRR#!c!g&.,5&--&),! H)5&,6;-/16/(#!HM+$k!<br />

$<br />

$<br />

$<br />

$<br />

$<br />

$<br />

$<br />

$<br />

$<br />

$<br />

$<br />

$<br />

$<br />

!<br />

K&L$


% "&# $I25G=+2(:2$E.$@A&#(4#!M#&&%(5A*%$'4$08,=6/*)0G0G0$%)+/.,(23$<br />

m/0C/($T,2=6/*)0G$^%ST_$/+,$I,A/6/$<br />

64*7,'+4+&'"&F.$'23*+/*&7*334+#2%4$1/&4,"#$%4',&")'/&%)*$6'-/16


05&'.6


'O4&.&! )6,! /()0()-9)! FA7*334+#2%4$1/! .3&.656'! 27"! A)-(!!! .)3,)09!#! M8! 18(P8!<br />

YN&((6'(&! Y-0&'(&4&! ))4).!09)! 46'/3()N4)! 605&'.6


D#! UI)0!>?m!>8(,63(&]!%_a!/5!"A6)0!%),I/P&06;!>/(&;8()-!M6/(/P)08)(! /5! 26)P0/.,6;! F&.,.! )09! =);;60&.! 5/-! F&--&.,-6)(! "064)(.! ! "A6)0! >/)(6;! %m! ?43-/A60P! 4


% "J" $D2021+!+2(:2$9!6!(!0$-,.$M,,(/0/$41=/+,*,0$c2=1P(+,($<br />

E*$%')+&B""#$%4,7&51%)4%4',*3&V1*34%.&'"&>'),!<br />

!<br />

>/I)44&9!=)96&6!<br />

"0')-)!j0A&-.6,&.6!e6-)),!:)'O(,&.6!e//,&'06!MY(O4O!<br />

!<br />

?3,1$<br />

U)0),(!()-!6Z60!4!.!-!0!0&!')9)-!9&&-(6!16-!I)44)99&!/(988!18!.&',Y-9&!Z)(!)0()-!<br />

,)-)5!09)0! P)6'/,/'.60(&-60! &,'6.6! 6.&! ,)I!(()-!0!<br />

06).,)!A&!


48(,63(&! 5);,/-.! 60! &A)(8),6/0! /5! ;/-0! 5&&960P!A)(8&! 48.,! 1&! ,)'&0! 60,/! );;/80,! 5/-!<br />

1&,,&-! 6,.! 8,6(6N),6/0#! FI&.&! 5);,/-.! 1&P60! 5-/4! 3()0,60P! ,/! 8.&! /5! ;/-0! 60! 3/8(,[s060! VKSs6! A&! I)4! 3-/,&60! 9&&-6060! VDEs.606! .)()4)',)9!-#!<br />

>!.!-! ,)I!(()-! 6Z&-6.609&! P&0&(9&! &0! Z/'! '8(()0!4)! .)I63! 16-! !.!-G! 189)!.!-*! ')0),(!!


ON&-60&! [0!9&&-(&-6!.)3,)04!,!-#!M8!Z)(!4)0!0!./08Z()-!G!JX!>[!9&&-(&-609&'6!5)-'(!(!'!<br />

Z/80(8'()!I61-6,!P&0/,63(&-6060!P&0&,6'!5)-'(!(!!09)0!')!.!-!0! 1&.60! 4)99&! 3-/56(6! A&! 56N6'.&(! YN&((6'(&-6*! 16,'6060! !.()I!*!


9/()?H?a!"! >?H?a!M!<br />

2)0&!1/


9)0&(&-6060! ,)4! /()-)'! /(P80()4)4).!! ./08;8! >[! A&! I)4! 3-/,&60! 9&&-(&-6060!<br />

.,)09)-9!0!)(,!09)!/(98'()-!!,&.36,!&96(46,6-#!F/3()4!(6.60!9&&-(&-609&!Z/'!A)-


I63&-,-/56! A&! I63&-3()N6! P616! 56N6


1&(6-(&046,6-#!M8080()!16-(6',&!&'./t&0!&0N64(&-60!'8(()0!4!!4!.!-!&.).(!!-).


'8-8!')18'!/-)0!*!9OO'!"%!W!56,)N!&0N64609&!60! 16-6'646*! 7%%! 9ON&[! 9&&-6! ON&-609&! /(84.8N! &,'6(&-&! .)I63! /(4)',)9!-#! M80()-)! 6()A&,&0!<br />

.!;)'(!!0!06),)!.6096-&16(6-(66!ON&-60&!Y0&4(6!&,'6.6!/(4)9!!!16(96-6(4&',&96-#!<br />

$<br />

!<br />

KJV$


9/=)1)=6/0+,(/0$,1=/6/$<br />

>!.!-! 46'/,/'.60! /(8848! 6Z60! 86'/,/'.60*!,)I!(()-!0!06).,)!A&![!T';)(p'PX! +)4!3-/,&60!TVX! $)!TVX!<br />

)0,)-(!!4!.!-! BDSD! L#B! J#S!<br />

$&4!9&&-609&!9OO!46',)-!! JSL! E#K! c#S!<br />

$&4!9&&-609&!9OO!/-)0!!V! C#K! K#c! KD#S!<br />

$<br />

D2*02=+2($<br />

J#! "&.;I1);I&-*! U#*! >&..6'/44&-*! a#! "09! >&6(&*! l#! DEES#! M,JcK! ;/-0! 60! 3/8(,-


JE#! _I/;,!>*!+8PI&.!ah*!M&95/-9!>a#JRRR#![55&;,.!/5!)!])-'&,3();&#!"2"HQ"H"H*!M)(,64/-&*!<br />

>2#!<br />

JR#! k-)084*! %#[#! )09! [.'&()09*! M#! JRLJ#! 78,-6,6/0)(! .6P0656;)0;&! /5! )4#g#! DEEJ#! H,)-;I!<br />

96P&.,6/0!-),&!60!,I&!.4)(!60,&.,60&!/5!,I&!;I6;'&0!9655&-.!)4/0P!5&&9.,855.#!h/8-0)(!78,-6,6/0*!JBJ*!DBDRQ<br />

DBBS#!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

KJ#$


ORAL<br />

S001<br />

S003<br />

S009<br />

S015<br />

S019<br />

S020<br />

S029<br />

S035<br />

POSTER<br />

P004<br />

P005<br />

P007<br />

P008<br />

FULL TEXTS PRESENTED IN ENGLISH<br />

Veterinary Inspection in Slaughterhouses: Future Challenges<br />

Reinhard Fries, Freie University of Berlin<br />

Basic and New Approaches in Broiler Breeder Nutrition<br />

Marcus Kenny, Broiler Breeder Nutritionist<br />

New Technologies and Approaches for Composting Broiler Manure<br />

Harold Marion Keener, The Ohio State University<br />

Assessing Poultry Welfare, Pathology and Disease Using Outcome<br />

Measures<br />

Andrew Butterworth, Bristol Veterinary School<br />

Factors Affecting Poultry Meat Quality<br />

Michel J. Duclos, INRA France<br />

Current Salmonella Situation in the Poultry Meat Industry,<br />

Regulations and Strategies for Reduction<br />

Roel Mulder, World Poultry Science Association, Secretary General<br />

Embryo Checks and Problem Analysis in Hatcheries<br />

Jason Cormick, Hatchery Specialist<br />

Feed Additives: Legal Status in European Union<br />

Jan Koslacz, Chairman of the FEFANA Polish Platform<br />

Effect of Diformates on Salmonella and Gut microbiota in Poultry<br />

Production 515<br />

Christian Luckstaedt, Kurt Wegleitner, ADDCON Group, Bonn,<br />

Germany<br />

The Effect of Dietary Lysine Levels on Growth Performance and<br />

Immunity Parameters in Japanese Quail 521<br />

I. Hajkhodadadi, M. Shivazad, H. Moravvej, A. Zare-Shahneh<br />

Citrex Efficacy on a Natural Challenge with Salmonella spp in Broiler<br />

Chickens 526<br />

C. G. Wilsmann, F. Flores, F. L. Gazoni, F. Silveria, M. Lovato, D.<br />

Zaviezo, Citrex, Inc. Miami, FL, USA<br />

Citrx Efficacy on the control of Salmonella Enteritidis in Broiler<br />

Chickens 529<br />

C. G. Wilsmann, F. Flores, F. L. Gazoni, F. Silveria, M. Lovsto, M.<br />

Contreras, Citrex, Inc. Miami, FL, USA<br />

442<br />

453<br />

458<br />

472<br />

483<br />

489<br />

498<br />

509


!<br />

Veterinary Inspection in Slaughterhouses: Future Challenges<br />

!<br />

"#$%&'()!*($#+!<br />

,'%#-!.#/#($%'(0!,12-$3!4#'-/&!!<br />

5%+/$/1/#!67!8#'/!409$#%#!'%)!:#3&%6-690;!!<br />

*(#$#!/!67!?#(-$%;!*'31-/0!67!.#/#($%'(0!8#)$3$%#!<br />

!<br />

1. Introduction<br />

1.1. History or: Meat Inspection in its traditional sense<br />

@8#'/!5%+A#3/$6%B!C85D!&'+!2##%!A(6+#31/#)!'-(#')0!$%!#'(-0!/$E#+!67!&1E'%!3$=$-$+'/$6%;!2#!$/!<br />

6%! '! (#-$9$61+! 2'+#! 6(! 2'+#)! 6%! /&#! 1%)#(+/'%)$%9! 67! /&#! /$E#F! G1($%9! E#)$#='-! /$E#+! $%!<br />

H1(6A#;! $%+A#3/$6%! I'+! )6%#! 6%! '! -6I! -#=#-;! '%)! $%! /&#! JK /& ! 3#%/1(0;! +3$#%/$7$3! $%+$9&/! I'+!<br />

633'+$6%! #%619&! /6! #+/'2-$+&! '! 3-$%$3'-! '%)! A'/&6-69$3'-! $%+A#3/$6%! 76(! +-'19&/#(! E'EE'-+;!<br />

26/&!67!/&#E!2#$%9!/&#!6%-0!'='$-'2-#!/#3&%$L1#+!20!/&#%F!?#3'1+#!67!+E'--!7'(E+!67!/&'/!/$E#;!<br />

85!I'+!A#(76(E#)!'/!/&#!+-'19&/#(&61+#;!I&#(#!/&#!'%$E'-+!I#(#!9'/&#(#)!'%)!62+#(=#)F!M6/!<br />

E13&!3&'%9#)!/&#%!76(!'261/!6%#!3#%/1(0;!I&$3&!E')#!/&$+!/0A#!67!$%+A#3/$6%;!$%!/&#!2#9$%%$%9!<br />

=#(0!E6)#(%;!/&#!@/(')$/$6%'-B!6%#;!'+!$/!$+!3'--#)!/&#+#!)'0+F!<br />

!<br />

:'2-#! JF! N&'%9$%9! /&#! #EA&'+$+! 67! $%+A#3/$6%! )1($%9! /&#! -'+/! )#3')#+O! @7(6E! 36%3#A/$6%! /6!<br />

36%+1EA/$6%B!<br />

HEA$($+E!C(#-$9$6%D!<br />

5%+A#3/$6%!67!/&#!#%)!A(6)13/!C/(')$/$6%'-D!<br />

*(6E!#%)!A(6)13/!/6!/&#!A(6)13/$6%!-$%#O!/&#!36%/(6-!'AA(6'3&!!!<br />

,-'%%$%9!/&#!A(6)13/$6%;!2'+#)!6%!3($/$3'-!'++#++E#%/!67!/&#!-$%#!<br />

4'=$%9!(#369%$P#)!/&#!($+Q+;!#+/'2-$+&E#%/!67!966)!A('3/$3#+!'%)!I'0+!67!=#($7$3'/$6%!<br />

!<br />

5%! /&#! RS$#+! 67! /&#! -'+/! 3#%/1(0;! 85! I'+! $%/(6)13#)! $%/6! A61-/(0! E#'/! A(6)13/$6%! 3&'$%+F!<br />

N6%3#(%+!I#(#!#TA(#++#)!6%!(#-$'2$-$/0!'%)!)#/#3/$6%!('/#!$%!7'+/!(1%%$%9!-$%#+!C'/!/&'/!/$E#!U!V!<br />

W;SSS! 2$()+X! &D! '%)! 6%! /&#! A6+$/$6%! 67! '%/#! E6(/#E! $%+A#3/$6%! CA-'3#! 67! 6($9$%! 6(! A($6(! /6!<br />

+-'19&/#(!$%!/&#!'2'//6$(DF!!<br />

!<br />

1.2. The EU- approach of control and supervision<br />

5%!/&#!KS$#+!$%!/&#!H


!<br />

Figure 1. The system of fro and back of information<br />

!<br />

! ! ! ! ! '%$E'-+!<br />

! 7'(E#(! ! ! ! ! ! !<br />

! '2'//6$(!<br />

!<br />

! ! ! ! ! 7##)!2'3Q!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

! $EA(6=#E#%/+!<br />

!<br />

1.3. Integrated Chain Systems<br />

!<br />

:&#! $)#'! 67! \$%/#9('/#)! 3&'$%! +0+/#E+@! $+! 2'+#)! 6%! $%/#((#-'/$6%+! 2#/I##%! +A#3$'-! +/'9#+! 67!<br />

A(6)13/$6%;!$F#F!&1+2'%)(0;!/('%+A6(/!'%)!A(63#++$%9F!57!/&#+#!$%/#((#-'/$6%+!/1(%!61/!/6!2#!/(1#;!<br />

'%!$EA6(/'%/!A'(/!67!/&#!+1(=#$--'%3#!'%)!36%/(6-!E'0!2#!+&$7/#)!/6!/&#!-$=$%9!'%$E'-+!6%!/&#!<br />

7'(E+!I$/&!E6(#!'331('30!C-'2!2'+#)DF!<br />

?'+$3! 36%)$/$6%! 76(! +0+/#E+! -$Q#! /&$+! $+! /&#! '='$-'2$-$/0! 67! '%! 'AA(6A($'/#! $%7('+/(13/1(#! $%!<br />

'%$E'-!A(6)13/$6%!'%)!/&#!'AA-$3'2$-$/0!67!36%/(6-!A'('E#/#(+F!!<br />

d%#!E'e6(!A6$%/!67!-$%#!+1(=#$--'%3#!$+!/6!'=6$)!/('%+A6(/!67!'%$E'-+!/6!/&#!'2'//6$(;!I&$3&!'(#!<br />

62=$61+!%6/!7$/!76(!&1E'%!36%+1EA/$6%!6(!I&$3&!3'((0!($+Q+!76(!'%$E'-!&#'-/&!C#A$)#E$3+DF!<br />

!<br />

5M!'))$/$6%;!20!1%)#(+/'%)$%9!67!/&#!A(6)13/$6%!'+!'!@-$%#B;!)##A#(!$%+$9&/!'%)!+1A#(=$+$6%!67!<br />

A61-/(0! A(6)13/$6%! -$%#+! $+! A6++$2-#F! 5EA6(/'%/! $++1#+! 67! 36%/(6-! '%)! +1(=#$--'%3#! '(#! $%!<br />

A'(/$31-'(!!<br />

(#+$)1#+!$%!+-'19&/#(!'%$E'-+!6(!'%$E'-+!!<br />

P66%6/$3!'9#%/+!<br />

/&#!#TA-'%'/$6%!67!-#+$6%+!A6+/!E6(/#E!20!/#+/!(#+1-/+!)1($%9!/&#!-$7#!67!/&#!2$()+!<br />

P66%6+#+!'%)!'%$E'-+!)$+#'+#+!<br />

6331((#%3#!67!(#+$+/'%3#!<br />

'%$E'-!I#-7'(#!$++1#+!<br />

!<br />

1.4. Targets of poultry meat inspection<br />

:&#+#!)'0+;!A61-/(0!E#'/!A(63#++$%9!&'+!/6!+'7#91'()!&1E'%!'%)!'%$E'-!&#'-/&;!E1+/!36%+$)#(!<br />

76(! '%$E'-! I#--Z2#$%9! '%)! E1+/! A(6=$)#! '! I&6-#+6E#! E#'/! 6(! E#'/! A(6)13/! 76(! 36%+1E#(+F!<br />

[6(Q#(c+!A(6/#3/$6%!E$9&/!2#!'%!'))$/$6%'-!/'+QF!!<br />

:&#!L1'-$/0!67!A61-/(0!E#'/!$%3-1)#+!$++1#+!67!(#+$)1#+;!67!'%$E'-!I#-7'(#;!67!/&#!E'3(6+36A$3!<br />

'AA#'('%3#! 67! /&#! 3'(3'++! '+! (#-'/#)! /6! )$+#'+#+! '%)! E#3&'%$3'-! $EA'3/+;! &09$#%#! 67! /&#!<br />

A(63#++$%9!-$%#!$%3-1)$%9!&09$#%#!67!/&#!A(6)13/!'+!I#--!'+!A'/&69#%+!+13&!'+!Y'-E6%#--'!6(!<br />

N'EA0-62'3/#(F!<br />

:&#!$%)$=$)1'-!=$+1'-!$%+A#3/$6%!C=$+1'-;!$7!%#3#++'(0!'-+6!20!31//$%9D!'$E+!'/!/&#!)#/#3/$6%!67!<br />

'2%6(E'-$/$#+!67!/&#!3'(3'++#+!'%)!67!/&#!6(9'%+F!!<br />

:6!)#/#3/!7'$-1(#+!(#9'()$%9!36%+$+/#%30;!36-61(;!+E#--!<br />

:6!)#/#3/!E'e6(!'2#(('/$6%+!2#3'1+#!67!/&#!A(63#++$%9!-$%#!<br />

:6!A(6=$)#!'%!'AA(6A($'/#!A(63#++$%9!-$%#!<br />

:6!+'EA-#!76(!(#+$)1#+!20!('%)6E;!$%!#=#(0!3'+#;!$7!/&#!&#()!$+!1%)#(!+1+A$3$6%F!<br />

M6/! 6%-0! -#+$6%+! 3'1+#)! 20! )$+#'+#+;! '-+6! 1%'AA(6A($'/#! 36%)$/$6%+! $%! /&#! &6-)$%9!<br />

C/#3&%6A'/&0D;!)1($%9!/('%+A6(/!C'%$E'-!I#-7'(#D!6(!'/!+/1%%$%9!E'0!2#!62+#(=#)F!Y6;!A61-/(0!<br />

E#'/!$%+A#3/$6%!(#-'/#+!/6!'%$E'-!I#-7'(#;!9#%#('-!'%$E'-!&#'-/&;!A(#=#%/$=#!E#'+1(#+!'9'$%+/!<br />

/&#! +A(#')! 67! P66%6/$3! '9#%/+;! #-$E$%'/$6%! 67! +1+A#3/#)! 3'(3'++#+)! 6(! A'(/+;! '%)! /6! A(6)13/!<br />

L1'-$/0F!!<br />

!<br />

432


!<br />

2. The Line<br />

2.1. Technology<br />

[$/&!(#+A#3/!/6!/&#!+A#3$#+;!/&#!-$%#+!)$77#(!$%!#L1$AE#%/!'%)!'1/6E'/$+'/$6%F!:6!(1%!'%!'2'//6$(!<br />

'/!&$9&!+A##)!C1A!/6!J^;SSS!2$()+X!&D!(#L1$(#+!+6A&$+/$3'/#)!/#3&%6-690F!:6!E##/!/&#!3&'--#%9#!<br />

67! A1(#! %1E2#(;! '--! +/'9#+! 7(6E! 2(##)$%9! =$'! &1+2'%)(0;! /('%+A6(/;! -'$('9#;! +-'19&/#(! f!<br />

A(63#++$%9!1A!/6!31//$%9!'%)!71(/&#(!A(63#++$%9!'(#!$%/#(36%%#3/#)F!H=#%!/('%+A6(/Z/#3&%6-690!<br />

7$/+! $%/6! /&#! +-'19&/#(! -$%#F! :&#! 6/&#(! I'0! (61%);! 6%#! '33$)#%/! E'0! '77#3/! /&#! I&6-#! -$%#F! 5/!<br />

+&61-)!2#!E6+/!1%%#3#++'(0!/6!+/(#++!/&#!#36%6E$3!$EA6(/'%3#!67!+13&!&$9&-0!')='%3#)!-$%#+F!<br />

b336()$%9-0;!$%!A($E'(0!A(6)13/$6%!I#!7$%)!-'(9#!&#()+!+1AA-0$%9!/&#+#!'2'//6$(+F!!<br />

[$/&! #=#(! 9(6I$%9! -$%#! +A##);! /&#! /$E#! 76(! +#(=$3#! C&09$#%#! '%)! /#3&%$3+D! 2#36E#+! +&6(/#(;!<br />

I$/&!/&#!-$%#+!(1%%$%9!$%!E6(#!/&'%!6%#!+&$7/F!:&#!)#%+#!/#3&%6-690!96#+!I$/&61/!'%0!&1()-#+!<br />

76(!'9#%/+;!/&1+!6A#%$%9!6A/$6%+!76(!/('%+7#(!=$'!+#=#('-!3'(($#(+F!5%!A'(/$31-'(!/&#!2$()!'+!+13&!$+!<br />

'!36%%#3/$%9!C=#(/$3'-D!-$%Q!2#/I##%!A($E'(0!A(6)13/$6%!'%)!/&#!A(63#++$%9!-$%#;!21/!'-+6!/(13Q+!<br />

3'((0$%9!/&#!2$()+!6(!61/96$%9!I'+/#!'(#!$EA6(/'%/!E#)$'/6(+F!<br />

!<br />

5%!#'3&!67!/&#+#!+/'9#+;!$EA6(/'%/!$EA(6=#E#%/+!&'=#!2##%!'3&$#=#)!'%)!'(#!+/$--!1%)#(!I'0;!<br />

#F9FO!!<br />

:('%+A6(/!67!2$()+!C'%$E'-!I#-7'(#!')e1+/#)!/('%+A6(/D!<br />

Y-'19&/#(!-$%#!C+/'9#!+3'-)$%9!/'%Q+!'%)!+/#'E!/#3&%$L1#+D!<br />

H=$+3#('/$6%!-$%#!C)#+$9%!67!#=$+3#('/$6%!/#3&%$L1#!A(6=$)$%9!#=#(!E6(#!-$%#!+A##)D!<br />

,(6)13/!)$=#(+$7$3'/$6%!C#+/'2-$+&E#%/!67!'1/6E'/$3!31//$%9!-$%#+D!<br />

8'%'9#E#%/O!


!<br />

Zoonotic agents:<br />

!"#$%&'##"("&)(*"$+,#%-"./'01(5/!$+!9#%#('--0!'9(##);!/&'/!6%#!I'0!67!A'/&69#%!2'3/#($'!$%/6!<br />

/&#! &1E'%! &'2$/'/! -##)+! =$'! 766)! 67! '%$E'-! 6($9$%! +/#E$%9! 7(6E! /&#! 7'(EF! Y6! 7$(+/-0! /&#!<br />

36%/'E$%'/$6%! +/'9#! 67! /&#! 6%#Z)'0Z3&$3Q#%+! '+! I#--! '+! &09$#%#! 67!7'(E;!+/'2-#!#%=$(6%E#%/!<br />

'%)!A#(76(E'%3#!67!/&#!7'//#%$%9!361(+#!$+!67!$EA6(/'%3#!76(!/('%+E$++$6%!$%/6!/&#!'2'//6$(+!'%)!<br />

71(/&#(!6%O!:&#!'9#%/+!I61-)!+A(#')!/&(619&!'!7-63Q!&6($P6%/'--0;!A(6E6/#)!20!/&#!2#&'=$61(!<br />

67! 2$()+! /6! A$3Q! 1A! 7##)! 7(6E! /&#! 9(61%)! '%)! +$E1-/'%#61+-0! /'Q$%9! 1A! /&#! E$3(62$6-69$3'-!<br />

36-6%$+'/$6%F!!<br />

:&#! &$9&! A(#='-#%3#! 67! Y'-E6%#--'! '%)! N'EA0-62'3/#(! $%! -$=#! A61-/(0! (#+1-/+! '-+6! $%! /&#!<br />

A(#+#%3#!67!/&#+#!'9#%/+!$%!/&#!+-'19&/#(&61+#F!Y6;!&09$#%#!E#'+1(#+!$%!/&#!+-'19&/#(&61+#!'$E!<br />

/6!)$E$%$+&!/&#!2'3/#($'-!-6')!$%!9#%#('-!/&6+#!E#'+1(#+!E$%$E$P#!/&#!6331((#%3#!67!Y'-E6%#--'!<br />

'%)!N'EA0-62'3/#(;!/66F!<br />

H+A#3$'--0!$%!Y3'%)$%'=$'!#776(/+!&'=#!2##%!E')#!/6!7$9&/!/&#!A(#='-#%3#!67!/&#+#!'9#%/+!$%!/&#!<br />

7-63Q+;! I&$3&! I'+! A($%3$A'--0! +133#++71-F! :&#+#! )'0+;! H


!<br />

?1$-)$%9+!'%)!7'3$-$/$#+!I$/&!+#A'('/#!A(#E$+#+!$%3-1)$%9!36%/(6-!67!/('%+7#(!<br />

8'%'9#E#%/!67!Q##A$%9!/&#!&#()+!$%3-1)$%9!'AA(6A($'/#!&09$#%#!E#'+1(#+!<br />

Y#(=$3#! A#($6)! 2#/I##%! +/63Q$%9! /&#! &#()+! C'%)! I$/&! 'AA(6A($'/#! /(#'/E#%/! 67!<br />

+1(7'3#+D!<br />

,#(76(E'%3#!67!3-#'%$%9!'%)!)$+$%7#3/$6%!<br />

:#3&%6-690!67!2#))$%9!C6($9$%;!1+#;!)$+3'()!'%)!36%/(6-D!<br />

*##)!'%)!I'/#(!'+!=#3/6(+;!7##)$%9!+/('/#9$#+!A($6(!/6!/('%+A6(/!<br />

41E'%+!'+!3'(($#(+!CA(#=#%/$=#!E#'+1(#+!I$/&!(#9'()!/6!E6=#E#%/+!I$/&$%!/&#!'(#'D!<br />

:('%+A6(/!=#&$3-#+!'%)!/&#$(!(6-#!$%!/('%+E$++$6%!C'-+6!I$/&$%!/&#!'(#'D!<br />

.#/#($%'(0!E#'+1(#+;!A(#=#%/$6%!67!/('%+7#(!7(6E!7'(E!/6!7'(E!<br />

!<br />

3. Surveillance (“Meat Inspection”)<br />

b7/#(!7$%$+&$%9!/&#!7'//#%$%9!6(!-'0$%9!A#($6);!/&#!$%+A#3/$6%!36%+$+/+!67!'!9#%#('-!3&#3Q!67!/&#!<br />

'%$E'-+! $%! /&#! 7'(E! 6(! 6($9$%! '+! I#--! '+! $%! /&#! '2'//6$(! C'%/#! E6(/#E! $%+A#3/$6%D! '%)! '! A6+/!<br />

E6(/#E! $%+A#3/$6%! 67! 3'(3'++! '%)! 677'-+F! b9'$%;! /&#! 766)! 6A#('/6(! $+! (#+A6%+$2-#! 76(! /&#!<br />

A(6)13/F!<br />

3.1. Ante mortem on farm level<br />

:&#! 36EA#/#%/! '1/&6($/0! E'0! )#3$)#;! I&#(#! A61-/(0! 76(! +-'19&/#(! +&'--! 2#! $%+A#3/#)! '%/#!<br />

E6(/#EF! 57! /&#! $%+A#3/$6%! &'+! %6/! 2##%! )6%#! '/! /&#! 7'(E! 67! 6($9$%;! $/! +&61-)! 2#! )6%#! '/! /&#!<br />

'2'//6$(F!b%$E'-+!)$+A-'0$%9!3-$%$3'-!+0EA/6E+;!+&'--!%6/!96!$%/6!&1E'%!36%+1EA/$6%F!5%!3'+#!<br />

67!1+#!76(!A'(/$31-'(!A1(A6+#+!C#F9F!#77$-#D;!'%/#!E6(/#E!$%+A#3/$6%!+&61-)!2#!)6%#!'/!/&#!7'(EF!!<br />

*6(! '%$E'-! &#'-/&;! #%=$(6%E#%/'-! 7'3/6(+! '(#! 67! $%/#(#+/;! /66;! '%)! 26/&! 67! /&#E! C'9#%/! '%)!<br />

#%=$(6%E#%/D! 36%/($21/#! /6! /&#! 61/2(#'Q! 67! '! )$+#'+#F! 5%+A#3/$6%! 67! &#()+! $%! /&#! A($E'(0!<br />

A(6)13/$6%! E#'%+! '! E$T/1(#! 67! 2$()! $%+A#3/$6%! '+! I#--! '+! $%+$9&/! $%/6! /&#! $%)$=$)1'-! 7-63Q!<br />

&$+/6(0F!*'3/6(+!/6!2#!9'/&#(#)!'+!&#'-/&!(#-#='%/!3($/#($'!'(#!'+!76--6I+O!<br />

5%$/$'-!%1E2#(!67!6%#Z)'0Z3&$3Q#%+!!<br />

7##)!'%)!I'/#(!36%+1EA/$6%!!<br />

E6(/'-$/0!('/#!!<br />

&#'-/&!)$+6()#(+!&$+/6(0!<br />

/(#'/E#%/!C$%3-1)$%9!)(19+!'%)!7##)!'))$/$=#+D!'%)!='33$%'/$6%!&$+/6(0!!<br />

'=#('9#!)'$-0!I#$9&/!9'$%!!<br />

2$()!I#$9&/!C$%)$=$)1'-!I#$9&/!)$+/($21/$6%D!<br />

7##)!36%=#(+$6%!!<br />

!<br />

3.2. Ante mortem at abattoir level<br />

*6--6I$%9!/&#!$%+A#3/$6%!67!/&#!'%$E'-+!$%!/&#$(!#%=$(6%E#%/;!'/!/&#!'2'//6$(!'%$E'-!I#-7'(#!$+!<br />

36=#(#)! I$/&! /&#! +#36%)! $%+A#3/$6%! 67! /&#! '%$E'-+! '%/#! E6(/#E;! 2#$%9! 6%-0! 67! E$%6(!<br />

$%76(E'/$6%!='-1#F!<br />

3.3. Visual post mortem inspection<br />

[$/&61/! )#-'0;! '--! +1(7'3#+! 67! 3'(3'++! '%)! 6(9'%+! C=$+1'-D! '(#! /6! 2#! $%+A#3/#)! CB'--! #T/#(%'-!<br />

+1(7'3#+BDF! 5%+A#3/$6%! 6%! /&#! -$%#! I61-)! 2#! )6%#! 20! '1T$-$'($#+! $%! +6E#;! 20! =#/#($%'($'%+! $%!<br />

6/&#(!8#E2#(!Y/'/#+!67!/&#!H


!<br />

2&3+'./4%&( %5( /6'( ."74/,1( 5/! $+! %6/! A6++$2-#! /6! $%+A#3/! /&#! 3'=$/0;! I&$3&! $+! (#'-$+#)! 20! /&#!<br />

I6()$%9!67!/&#!"#91-'/$6%;!/66!C@#T/#(%'-!+1(7'3#+BDF!H=$+3#('/$6%!&'AA#%+!/&(619&!'!%'(((6I!<br />

6A#%$%9!'/!'!-$%#!+A##)!67!'261/!JSFSSSX!&F!5%+A#3/$6%!67!/&#!3'=$/0!3'%!2#!)6%#!20!$%+A#3/$6%!<br />

67!/&#!A-13Q+!C$%!%'/1('-!36%%#3/$6%!6(!+#A'('/#!6%!'!/('0D!20!/&#!$%+A#3/6(+!'%)!'))$/$6%'--0!6%!<br />

'!('%)6E!+'EA-$%9!2'+#!20!/&#!d.F!<br />

8'.6&4."#(39+'07434%&1(:&#!$EA6(/'%3#!67!'!A(6A#(-0!A#(76(E#)!#=$+3#('/$6%!7$%)+!$/+!3'1+#!$%!<br />

/&#!91/+!&'(261($%9!P66%6/$3!'9#%/+F!Y6;!'%0!/#3&%6-69$3'-!7'$-1(#!C2(#'Q$%9!67!91/+D!-#')+!/6!<br />

#%&'%3#)!36%/'E$%'/$6%;!+A$--$%9!A'/&69#%+!6%!/6!/&#!+1(7'3#+F!!<br />

46I#=#(;! %6! )#/'$-#)! %1E2#(! &'+! 2##%! 9$=#%F! b/! -#'+/! USS! 3'(3'++#+! A#(! )'0! +&61-)! 2#!<br />

$%+A#3/#)F!"#-'/$6%!/6!/&#!+&$AE#%/!I61-)!2#!E6(#!'331('/#!/&'%!/6!/&#!)'$-0!I6(QF!<br />

:'.6'.;4&


!<br />

'%$E'-!I#-7'(#!A'('E#/#(+!$%!/&#!&6-)$%9!C766)!A')!)#(E'/$/$+;!-$//#(!21(%+;!61/36E#!<br />

67!2#'Q!/($EE$%9D!6(!$%!/('%+A6(/!<br />

)$+#'+#+! 6(! &09$#%#! $%! /&#! &6-)$%9! C36#77$3$#%/! 67! ='($'%3#! 67! I#$9&/+! $%)$3'/$%9! '!<br />

)$77#(#%/!9(6I/&!+A##)!'%)!'!A6++$2-#!$%7#3/$6%D!<br />

A'/&6-69$3'-!'%'/6E$3'-!-#+$6%+!$%)$3'/$%9!'!)$+#'+#!6(!/#3&%6A'/&0!!<br />

(1A/1(#+;!26%#!2(#'Q$%9+!$%)$3'/$%9!7'$-1(#+!$%!/&#!/#3&%$3'-!A(63#)1(#!!!<br />

Y6;!/&#!$%+/(1E#%/!67!A6+/!E6(/#E!$%+A#3/$6%!3'%!2#!1+#)!76(!9#%#('-!'%$E'-!I#-7'(#;!9#%#('-!<br />

'%$E'-!&#'-/&!C#F9F!I#$9&/!)$+/($21/$6%D;!&09$#%#!C=$+1'-!36%/'E$%'/$6%;!#=$+3#('/$6%D!6(!L1'-$/0!<br />

'+A#3/+!C#F9F!2(1$+#+DF!!<br />

!<br />

:'2-#!WF!g#+$6%+!7(#L1#%/-0!6331(($%9!$%!A61-/(0;!E#'%$%9!'%)!)#/#3/$6%!!<br />

C*($#+!JKKJm!?#(9E'%%!^SSJ;!')'A/#)D!<br />

5. Seizure post mortem<br />

?$6-69$3'-!E'/#($'-!$+!)$77#(#%/F!5%!A6+/ZE6(/#E!$%+A#3/$6%;!/&#!)#3$+$6%!6%!7$/%#++!6(!1%7$/%#++!<br />

$+! %6/! /&'/! #'+0;! A(#3$+#! 3($/#($'! '(#! -'3Q$%9;! )#7$%$/$6%+! '(#! %##)#)F! H=#%! $%! &#()+! 2#$%9!<br />

2'+$3'--0! &#'-/&0;! -#+$6%+! )6! 6331(F! Y6E#! 67! /&#E! I61-)! 7(#L1#%/-0! 2#! 62+#(=#)! $%! A61-/(0!<br />

E#'/!A(63#++$%9!C&#(#O!2(6$-#(+D!20!=$+1'-!$%+A#3/$6%F!!<br />

*631++$%9!6%!A6+/ZE6(/#E!$%+A#3/$6%;!/&#!)#3$+$6%!6%!7$/%#++!6(!1%7$/%#++!$+!%6/!'-I'0+!#'+0O!<br />

?$6-69$3'-!E'/#($'-!)$77#(+;!'%)!/&#!7$%'-!+#$P1(#!)#A#%)+!6%!$%/#%+$/0;!+$/#;!#T/#%+$6%!'+!I#--!'+!<br />

/&#$(!3&'('3/#(!C$%7#3/$6%!6(!/#3&%$3'-!)'E'9#!67!/&#!$%)$=$)1'-!2$()DF!M6/!'-I'0+;!I#!Q%6I!/&#!<br />

E#'%$%9!C'%)!+6E#/$E#+!'-+6!/&#!3'1+'/$=#!2'3Q9(61%)D!67!-#+$6%+!62+#(=#);!'%)!61/!67!I&'/!<br />

(#'+6%!I#!1+#!/6!(#E6=#!3'(3'++#+!7(6E!/&#!-$%#!'+!1%7$/F!!<br />

!<br />

5.1. The grey zone between fit and unfit for consumption<br />

:&#!%'/1(#!67!'!-#+$6%;!$/c+!#T/#%+$6%;!/&#!$%/#%+$/0!67!/&#!-#+$6%;!'+!I#--!'+!/&#!-63'-$P'/$6%!67!<br />

/&#!-#+$6%!6%!/&#!3'(3'++!'(#!$EA6(/'%/!7'3/6(+!I&$3&!E1+/!2#!36%+$)#(#)!)1($%9!/&#!$%+A#3/$6%F!<br />

86(#6=#(;!/&#!A'(/$31-'(!-#+$6%!3'%%6/!2#!36%+$)#(#)!I$/&61/!/&#!2'3Q9(61%)!7(6E!/&#!I&6-#!<br />

&#();!#F9F!/&#!-6I#+/!I#$9&/!I&$3&!+&61-)!A'++!/&#!$%+A#3/$6%!)#A#%)+!6%!/&#!'9#!67!/&#!&#()!<br />

CI$/&!$%3(#'+$%9!'9#;!/&#!I#$9&/!$%3(#'+#+D!'+!I#--!'+!/&#!)$+/($21/$6%!67!/&#!I#$9&/!C76--6I$%9!<br />

/&#!h'1++!)$+/($21/$6%!31(=#DF!b-+6!/&#!A#(3#%/'9#!67!'!-#+$6%!$%!'!&#()!+&61-)!2#!/'Q#%!$%/6!<br />

'3361%/F!!<br />

Y1EE'($P$%9;!$7!'%!'2%6(E'-!62+#(='/$6%!'AA#'(+!/6!2#!/&#!E'e6(!$EA(#++$6%!)1($%9!$%+A#3/$6%;!<br />

/&#!'%$E'-!+&61-)!2#!)#3-'(#)!1%7$/!'%)!+&61-)!2#!/'Q#%!61/!67!/&#!-$%#F!<br />

!<br />

437


!<br />

5.2. Infective vs. mechanical damage and the state of generalisation<br />

Y#A'('/$6%! 2#/I##%! $%7#3/$6%! '%)! E#3&'%$3'-! )'E'9#+! $+! (#36EE#%)#)F! 5%! 3'+#! 67! '%!<br />

$%7#3/$6%;!'%)!2'+#)!6%!/&#!e1)9#E#%/!(#L1$(#E#%/+!67!"#91-'/$6%!`Wa;!'!)#3$+$6%!$+!%#3#++'(0!<br />

6%!/&#!9#%#('-$+'/$6%!3&'('3/#(!67!/&#!-#+$6%F!<br />

5%!3'+#!67!'!9#%#('-$+'/$6%;!/&#!3'(3'++!+&61-)!2#!36%)#E%#)F!5%!3'+#!67!'!-63'-!)'E'9#;!/&#!<br />

-63'-!-#+$6%!96#+!'+!36%)#E%#)F!:&$+!E'0!2#!/(1#!'-+6!76(!'!-63'-$+#)!$%7#3/$6%F!b+!'%!#T'EA-#;!<br />

$%=#+/$9'/$6%+!I$/&!/1(Q#0+!+177#($%9!7(6E!3'=$/0!$%7-'EE'/$6%+!(#=#'-#);!/&'/!/&#!A(63#++!I'+!<br />

-63'-$+#)!/6!/&#!3'=$/0!C*"5HY!#/!'-F!^SSWDO!!<br />

b#(6+'331-$/$+!$+!'!36EE6%!-#+$6%!761%)!$%!&#()+!)1($%9!A61-/(0!E#'/!$%+A#3/$6%F!:6!<br />

+1AA6(/!/&#!)#3$+$6%!)1($%9!$%+A#3/$6%;!JSJ!3'(3'++#+!7(6E!/1(Q#0!&#()+!I$/&!7(#L1#%/-0!<br />

6331(($%9! '#(+'331-$/$+! C1%7$/! 76(! &1E'%! 36%+1EA/$6%! 2#3'1+#! 67! '#(+'331-$/$+D! I#(#!<br />

#T'E$%#)!'%)!K_!HF36-$Z!!$+6-'/#+!I#(#!36--#3/#)F!!<br />

:&#!$+6-'/#+!I#(#!/#+/#)!76(!H4HNX!.:HN;!$F#F!9#%!+#L1#%3#+!#%36)$%9!Y&$9'Z/6T$%!J!<br />

'%)!^;!#%/#(6&#E6-0+$%!C&-0D!'%)!$%/$E$%!C#'#DF!86(#6=#(;!/&#!85N!67!/&#!$+6-'/#+!/6!JU!<br />

=#/#($%'(0!'%/$E$3(62$'-!+12+/'%3#+!I'+!/#+/#)F!!<br />

*'3/6(+! )#/#(E$%$%9! H4HN! 6(! .:HN! I#(#! %6/! (#36=#(#)F! 85N! /6! +#=#('-! +12+/'%3#+!<br />

I#(#! &$9&#(;! (#-'/#)! /6! /&#! (#7#(#%3#! +/('$%F! "#9'()$%9! /&#! 7'(E! 1%$/+;! +6E#! 67! /&#!<br />

(#+A#3/$=#!+/('$%+!&')!E6(#!7(#L1#%/-0!&$9&#(!85NF!!<br />

?'+#)! 6%! /&#+#! (#+1-/+;! $%! 3'+#! 67! '#(+'331-$/$+;! /&#! )#3$+$6%! +&61-)! )#A#%)! 6%!<br />

E'3(6+36A$3!-#+$6%+!#T3-1+$=#-0F!!<br />

5.3. The flock vs. the individual bird<br />

?'+$3'--0;!AFEF!$%+A#3/$6%!76--6I+!/&#!(1-#+!67!/&#!$%)$=$)1'-!$%+A#3/$6%!'%)!)#3$+$6%F!46I#=#(;!<br />

$%! E'%0! 3'+#+;! (#'+6%+! 67! '! -#+$6%! '(#! %6/! Q%6I%! 6(! '! (#91-'(! '++#++E#%/! &'+! %6/! 0#/! 2##%!<br />

A#(76(E#)F!:&#!6/&#(!I'0!(61%);!$%!3'+#!67!'!7-63Q!2#$%9!$%7#3/#)!I$/&!'%!'9#%/;!-#+$6%+!E'0!<br />

(#7-#3/!+13&!'%!$%7#3/$6%!'%)!+&61-)!/&#%!2#!(#E6=#)O!57!/&#!'9#%/!$+!P66%6/$3;!/&#!3'(3'++!96#+!<br />

36%)#E%#)F!!<br />

5%! 3'+#! 67! /&#! A(#+#%3#! 67! '! %6%Z&1E'%ZA'/&69#%;! +13&! '%! $%7#3/$6%! E'0! '-/#(! /&#! 26)0!<br />

36%)$/$6%! /&'/! +#=#(#-0;! /&'/! /&#! 3'(3'++! #%)+! 1A! 36%)#E%#)F! Y6;! #=#%! $7! /&#! (#'+6%! $+! %6/!<br />

Q%6I%;! /&#! 3'(3'++! 96#+! 36%)#E%#)F! :&$+! $+! E6+/-0! /&#! 3'+#O!


!<br />

:'2-#!_F!]1)9#E#%/!67!?(6$-#(+!V!"#+1-/+!7(6E!8#'/!5%+A#3/$6%!'%)!"#Z5%+A#3/$6%!67!/&#!+'E#!<br />

N'(3'++#+!2'+#)!6%!G'/'!Y&##/+!20!6/&#(!:#'E+!C*"5HY!f!jd?H!JKKUD!<br />

Y6;!$/!E'0!36E#!/6!#$/&#(!7'-+#ZA6+$/$=#!C7$/!76(!36%+1EA/$6%!21/!36%)#E%#)D!'+!I#--!'+!7'-+#Z<br />

%#9'/$=#!C/6!2#!36%)#E%#)!21/!7$/!76(!36%+1EA/$6%D!(#+1-/+!67!$%+A#3/$6%F![$/&!9(6I$%9!-$%#!<br />

+A##)! $%! A61-/(0! A(63#++$%9;! I#! E1+/! (#'-$+#! /&#! -$E$/+! 67! =$+1'-! $%+A#3/$6%! )6%#! 20! &1E'%!<br />

2#$%9+F!Y#=#('-!6A/$6%+!67!36EA#%+'/$%9!/&#!&$9&!+A##)!-$%#+!#+A#3$'--0!$%!2(6$-#(!A(6)13/$6%!<br />

)6!#T$+/O!!<br />

,(#=#%/$6%! 67! )$+#'+#+! $%! /&#! &#()! C2$6+#31($/0D! $%! 6()#(! /6! 36%/(6-! /&#! 1A36E#! 67!<br />

-#+$6%+!<br />

,(#=#%/$6%!67!/#3&%6A'/&$3!-#+$6%+!1+$%9!h66)!41+2'%)(0!,('3/$3#!$%!6()#(!/6!'=6$)!<br />

/#3&%$3'-!7'$-1(#+!$%!/&#!&6-)$%9!<br />

5EA(6=#E#%/!67!/&#!-$%#!/#3&%6-690!$%!6()#(!/6!A(#=#%/!/#3&%$3'-!7'$-1(#!I&$3&!I61-)!<br />

!<br />

<br />

'-+6!3'1+#!$%3(#'+#)!#-$E$%'/$6%!I6(Q!)1($%9!A(63#++$%9!67!/&#!+-'19&/#(#)!2$()+!<br />

G#=#-6AE#%/! I$/&$%! /&#! 7$#-)! 67! $%+A#3/$6%! +0+/#E+! $/+#-7O! 4#(#! I#! &'=#! E6+/!<br />

7(#L1#%/!/(')$/$6%'-!36EA#%+'/$6%!+13&!'+!E$((6(+!7(6E!/&#!6/&#(!+$)#!67!/&#!-$%#;!-$%#!<br />

)$=$)#(+! 6(! /&#! $EA-#E#%/'/$6%! 67! 36EA'%0! +/'77! CI&$3&! $%! $/+#-7! 2#'(+! /&#! +'E#!<br />

A(62-#E!'+!/&#!$%+A#3/6(c+!)$-#EE'!67!=$+1'-!-$E$/'/$6%DF!b-/#(%'/$=#!+6-1/$6%+!I61-)!<br />

2#!36EA1/#(!'$)#)!3'E#('!+0+/#E+;!I&$3&!'(#!'-+6!'-(#')0!$%!A-'3#FF!<br />

N6%3#(%$%9! P66%6/$3! '9#%/+! 6(! (#+$)1#+;! %6! $%76(E'/$6%! 3'%! 2#! '3&$#=#)! 1+$%9! E'3(6+36A$3!<br />

#T'E$%'/$6%F!!<br />

!<br />

:'2-#!RF!*'3/6(+!b77#3/$%9!,#(76(E'%3#!'%)!Y133#++!67!8#'/!5%+A#3/$6%!C*"5HY!JKKSD!<br />

JF! ,($6(!/6!8#'/!5%+A#3/$6%!<br />

!! &09$#%#!67!7-63Q!&1+2'%)(0!'%)!E'%'9#E#%/O!<br />

! 'E61%/!67!-#+$6%+!/6!2#!#-$E$%'/#)!7(6E!/&#!-6/!<br />

! -#+$6%+!3'1+#)!20!/('%+A6(/!E6)'-$/$#+!<br />

^F! d(9'%$P'/$6%!'%)!HL1$AE#%/!67!/&#!Y-'19&/#(!g$%#!!<br />

! )#=$3#+!$%!/&#!-$%#!+1AA6(/$%9!6(!(#A-'3$%9!&1E'%!I6(Q!$%!/($EE$%9!<br />

-$%#!+A##)!!<br />

A(#+#-#3/$6%!20!A-'%/!+/'77!<br />

$%76(E'/$6%+!9$=#%!A($6(!/6!E#'/!$%+A#3/$6%!'261/!/&#!+/'/1+!67!/&#!7-63Q!<br />

UF! M1E2#(!67!$%+A#3/$6%!I6(Q$%9!A-'3#+!'/!/&#!-$%#!! !<br />

aF! *'3/6(+!7(6E!/&#!d(9'%$P'/$6%!67!8#'/!5%+A#3/$6%!<br />

! A6+$/$6%!67!$%+A#3/6(!<br />

! )1('/$6%!67!E#'/!5%+A#3/$6%!A#(!A#(+6%!<br />

! ! '2+6-1/#!A#(!)'0!<br />

! ! )1('/$6%!67!6%#!$%+A#3/$6%!1%$/!<br />

! ! 6(9'%$P'/$6%!67!2(#'Q+!<br />

!<br />

WF! *'3/6(+!I$/&$%!/&#!I6(Q$%9!A-'3#!<br />

! )$+/'%3#!7(6E!/&#!-$%#!<br />

! #T/#%+$6%!67!I6(Q$%9!A-'3#!<br />

! L1'-$/0!67!-$9&/!<br />

! $%+/'--'/$6%!67!&09$#%#!)#=$3#+!CNfG!67!Q%$7#+D!<br />

_F! HTA#($#%3#!67!$%+A#3/6(!<br />

RF!G#7$%$/$6%!67!-#+$6%+!(#+1-/$%9!$%!36%)#E%'/$6%!67!3'(3'++#+!'%)!6(9'%+!!!<br />

439


!<br />

7. Computer aided camera systems<br />

:&#!=$+1'-!I6(Q!)6%#!20!$%+A#3/6(+!$+!3#(/'$%-0!/$($%9!2#3'1+#!67!/&#!&$9&!+A##)!67!/&#!-$%#F!<br />

?#3'1+#!67!/&#!+$E$-'($/0!67!/&#!3'(3'++#+!/6!2#!A(#+#%/#);!$%+A#3/6(+!E$9&/!6=#(-66Q!-#+$6%+F!<br />

:&$+!A(6EA/+!/&#!+#'(3&!76(!'1T$-$'(0!+0+/#E+;!'%)!(#+A#3/$=#!E'3&$%#(0!+0+/#E+!'(#!'='$-'2-#!<br />

'%)!1%)#(!36%+$)#('/$6%F!!<br />

5%!'))$/$6%;!-'26('/6(0!2'+#)!#T'E$%'/$6%!/'Q#+!$/+!/$E#F!4#(#;!$%!-$%#!'%)!(#'-!/$E#!#L1$AE#%/!<br />

)6#+! '-(#')0! #T$+/;! /66;! I$/&61/! +'EA-$%9;! 2'+#)! 6%! A&0+$3'-! E#'%+! C)$77#(#%/! I'=#-#%9/&+O!<br />

=$+1'-;! $%7('(#)DF! Y6;! $%! A61-/(0! A(63#++$%9;! +#=#('-! A1(A6+#+! 3'%! '-(#')0! 2#! '3&$#=#)! I$/&!<br />

E'3&$%#+O!!<br />

L1'-$/0!'++#++E#%/!'33F!/6!/&#!H


!<br />

4#'-/&! (#-'/#)! )'/'! 7(6E! /&#! 7'(E! $%3-1)$%9! 3-$%$3'-! )'/'! 67! /&#! 7-63Q! '%)! A6+/!<br />

E6(/#E!)'/'!6%!/&#!6331((#%3#!67!-#+$6%+!!<br />

,(6=$)#!'%$E'-!I#-7'(#!#=$)#%3#!<br />

,(6=$)#!$%76(E'/$6%!6%!/&#!1+#!67!/&#('A#1/$3'-+!<br />

,(#='-#%3#!67!P66%6/$3!'9#%/+!<br />

!<br />

Correction vs. recording: Defining the elements of meat inspection<br />

b!A61-/(0!7-63Q!1%)#(!$%)1+/($'-!36%)$/$6%+!$+!1%)#(!36%/(6-!)1($%9!/&#!I&6-#!-$7#+A'%!C@7(6E!<br />

+/'2-#!/6!/'2-#BDF!N6%/(6-!$+!)6%#!6%!'!E'%)'/6(0!C@36%/(6-!67!36%/(6-B!6(!)$(#3/!+1A#(=$+$6%D!'+!<br />

I#--! '+! 6%! '%! $%/#(%'-! 2'+#;! (#L1$($%9! 6(9'%$+'/$6%;! +Q$--#)! A#(+6%%#-! '%)! 3-#'(! A'('E#/#(+;!<br />

I&$3&! '(#! '2-#! /6! (#7-#3/! /&#! 766)! 3&'$%! $%! '! (#-$'2-#! I'0! 36%3#(%$%9! '--! E'//#(+! 67! 36%3#(%!<br />

C&1E'%!&#'-/&;!'%$E'-!&#'-/&!'%)!'%$E'-!I#-7'(#DF!<br />

,6+/!E6(/#E!E#'/!$%+A#3/$6%!+#(=#+!$%!/&#!+#%+#!67!E6%$/6($%9!'%)!#-$E$%'/$6%;!I$/&!-#+$6%+;!<br />

$%+A#3/6(+! '(#! '+Q#)! /6! 36%)#E%! '%)! +$E1-/'%#61+-0! /6! (#36()! /&#$(! L1'-$/0! C7##)$%9! 2'3Q!<br />

E#3&'%$+E! /6! $EA(6=#! /&#! %#T/! &#()! 6(! /6! A$3Q! 61/! &#'=0! 3'+#+DF! 46I#=#(;! /&$+! $EE#)$'/#!<br />

)$#3$+$6%! $+! %6/! #'+0;! '%)! 2$()+! &'=$%9! 2##%! 36%)#E%#)! '(#! E6+/-0! 6%-0! /&#! @/$A! 67! /&#!<br />

$3#2#(9BF! 5F#F;! $%)$=$)1'-! 2$()+! E'0! 3'((0! /&#! +'E#! -#+$6%! '%)! A'++! /&#! $%+A#3/$6%! A6+/!<br />

1%%6/$3#)F!<br />

!<br />

Prevention versus correcting: Preventive veterinary medicine, the term of health<br />

*6(! 766)! '%$E'-+! 6(! '! &#();! &#'-/&! E'0! &'=#! '! )$77#(#%/! E#'%$%9! 36EA'(#)! /6! C$%)$=$)1'-D!<br />

36EA'%$6%!'%$E'-+F!*66)!'%$E'-+!+&61-)!(#E'$%!&#'-/&0!)1($%9!/&#$(!-$7#/$E#O!5%!A'(/$31-'(;!$%!<br />

'! A61-/(0! 7-63Q! '%$E'-! )$+#'+#+! '(#! '! E'e6(! '33$)#%/;! P66%6+#+! +&61-)! %6/! 6331(;! '%$E'-+!<br />

+&61-)! %6/! 2#! 3'((0$%9! '%0! '9#%/! 6(!+12+/'%3#!2#$%9!&'(E71-!/6!&1E'%+!C$F#F;!/&#('A#1/$3'-+;!<br />

P66%6/$3!'9#%/+!6(!(#+$+/'%3#!9#%#+DF!!<br />

46I#=#(;!$%!3'+#!67!%##);!31($%9!$+!%#3#++'(0!61/!67!'%$E'-!I#-7'(#!(#'+6%+F!<br />

!<br />

Internal vs. external control<br />

5%/#(%'-!36%/(6-!+0+/#E+!'(#!E'%)'/6(0!$%!/&#!H


!<br />

Basic and New Approaches in Broiler Breeder Nutrition<br />

!<br />

8'(31+!j#%%0 !<br />

b=$'9#%!g/);!M#I2($)9#;!8$)-6/&$'%;!


!<br />

/I6!)$77#(#%/!#('+!/6!)#/#(E$%#!$7!/&#!(#+A6%+#!/6!'E$%6!'3$)!-#=#-+!&')!3&'%9#)!6=#(!/$E#F!:&#!<br />

/#(E! 2'-'%3#)! A(6/#$%! (#7#(+! /6! /&#! 36EA-#/#! $)#'-! 'E$%6! '3$)! A(67$-#! ('/&#(! /&'%! /6! 3(1)#!<br />

A(6/#$%F! :&#! /&(##! -#=#-+! 67! 2'-'%3#)! A(6/#$%! /#+/#)! I#(#! `Sp;! JSSp! '%)! J^Sp! 67! /&#!<br />

(#36EE#%)'/$6%!76(!/&#!"6++!US`!Cb=$'9#%!^SSRDF!:&#!JSSp!/(#'/E#%/!&')!'!)$9#+/$2-#!-0+$%#!<br />

-#=#-! 67! JF^Rp;! JFJSp! '%)! SFKRp! $%! /&#! +/'(/#(;! 9(6I#(! '%)! 7$%$+&#(! )$#/+! (#+A#3/$=#-0F! b!<br />

36EA'($+6%!67!-$=#!I#$9&/!'%)!*N"!+&6I+!/&'/!9#%#/$3!+#-#3/$6%!&'+!(#+1-/#)!$%!'!+$9%$7$3'%/!<br />

$EA(6=#E#%/! $%! 26/&! 9(6I/&! ('/#! '%)! *N"F! :&#! )'/'! '-+6! +&6I+! /&'/! /&#! E6)#(%! 2(6$-#(!<br />

(#+A6%+#!/6!2'-'%3#)!A(6/#$%!$+!E13&!9(#'/#(!/&'%!/&#!('%)6E!2(#)!-$%#F!!!<br />

b! 36EA'($+6%! 67! 3'(3'++! 36EA6+$/$6%! +&6I+! /&#! E6)#(%! +/('$%! &')! &$9&#(! 2(#'+/! E#'/! '%)!<br />

-6I#(!3'(3'++!7'/!/&'%!/&#!('%)6E!2(#)!+/('$%F!:&#!E6)#(%!+/('$%!+&6I+!'!E13&!9(#'/#(!2(#'+/!<br />

E#'/!(#+A6%+#!/6!2'-'%3#)!A(6/#$%!/&'%!/&#!('%)6E!2(#)!+/('$%F!!!<br />

:&#!E6)#(%!2(6$-#(!$+!7'+/#(!9(6I$%9;!E6(#!#77$3$#%/!'%)!&'+!'!-#'%#(!26)0!E'++!I$/&!-#++!7'/!<br />

36%/#%/F![&$-#!/&#+#!/('$/+!'(#!A6+$/$=#!7(6E!'!2(6$-#(!A6$%/!67!=$#I!/&#+#!'//($21/#+!%##)!/6!2#!<br />

36%+$)#(#)!I&#%!E'%'9$%9!A'(#%/!+/63QF!*##)$%9!&$9&!-#=#-+!67!A(6/#$%!I$--!A(#)$+A6+#!/6!6=#(Z<br />

7-#+&$%9;!I&$-#!1%)#(!7##)$%9!#%#(90!E'0!(#+1-/!$%!-6I!26)0!7'/!(#+#(=#+F!:&$+!$+!67!A'(/$31-'(!<br />

36%3#(%! I&#%! 7##)$%9! &$9&! 0$#-)$%9! +/('$%+F! HT/('! E1+3-#! (#L1$(#+! E6(#! #%#(90! /6! E'$%/'$%;!<br />

/&$+!$%!/1(%!A-'3#+!'!71(/&#(!)#E'%)!6%!/&#!#%#(90!(#L1$(#E#%/+!67!'!2$()!/&'/!$+!'-(#')0!-#++!<br />

$%3-$%#)!/6!'331E1-'/#!7'/F!:&#!$)#'-!)$#/!76(!'!E6)#(%!2(6$-#(!2(##)#(!+&61-)!A(6=$)#!+177$3$#%/!<br />

=6-1E#!/6!E##/!/&#!#%#(90!(#L1$(#E#%/!67!/&#!2$()!I&$-#!'/!/&#!+'E#!/$E#!A(#=#%/!6=#(!7##)$%9!<br />

'E$%6!'3$)+!<br />

5/!$+!3-#'(!/&'/!/&#!9#%#/$3+!67!/&#!E6)#(%!2(##)#(!'(#!)0%'E$3!&#%3#!$/!$+!$EA6(/'%/!/6!36%+$)#(!<br />

/&'/!)$#/+!/&'/!I#(#!+133#++71-!$%!/&#!A'+/!'(#!%6/!%#3#++'($-0!+133#++71-!$%!/&#!71/1(#F!!<br />

!<br />

A Practical Approach to Broiler Breeder Nutrition<br />

:&#!%1/($/$6%$+/!$+!7(#L1#%/-0!'+Q#)!I&'/!'E$%6!'3$)!6(!#%#(90!)#%+$/0!'!2(6$-#(!2(##)#(!)$#/!<br />

+&61-)!2#F!5/!$+!$EA6(/'%/!/6!36%+$)#(!/&'/!/&#!2$()!)6#+!%6/!1%)#(+/'%)!A#(3#%/'9#+m!/&#0!&'=#!<br />

(#L1$(#E#%/+!76(!#'3&!%1/($#%/!/&'/!$%3-1)#+!E'$%/#%'%3#;!9(6I/&!'%)!A(6)13/$6%F!<br />

?(##)#(+! '(#! 7#)! (#+/($3/#)! 'E61%/+! 67! 7##)! +6! /&#! )$#/'(0! %1/($#%/! +A#3$7$3'/$6%+! %##)! /6! 2#!<br />

3&6+#%!I$/&!/&#!)'$-0!7##)!$%/'Q#+!$%!E$%);!76(!$%+/'%3#!/&#!+'E#!2$()!7#)!J_S!9('E+!'/!A#'Q!<br />

(#L1$(#+! '! 7##)! I$/&! &$9&#(! %1/($#%/! )#%+$/0! /&'%! 6%#! (#3#$=$%9! JRW! 9('E+F! :&$+! $+! /&#! E6+/!<br />

'331('/#!'AA(6'3&!$%!E##/$%9!/&#!2$()+!)'$-0!%1/($#%/!(#L1$(#E#%/!'%)!$/!$+!'%!'AA(6'3&!I&$3&!<br />

$+!2#$%9!$%3(#'+$%9-0!#EA&'+$P#)!20!/&#!2(##)$%9!36EA'%$#+!Cb=$'9#%!^SSRDF!<br />

5/!$+!/&#!%1/($/$6%$+/+!(#+A6%+$2$-$/0!/6!)#+$9%!'!7##)!/&'/!E##/+!/&#!%1/($#%/!(#L1$(#E#%/+!67!/&#!<br />

2$()!'/!#'3&!+/'9#!67!A(6)13/$6%!1%)#(!/&#$(!+#/!67!#%=$(6%E#%/'-!36%)$/$6%+!'%)!/&#%!/6!#%+1(#!<br />

/&'/!/&#!&$9&#+/!L1'-$/0!$%9(#)$#%/+!'(#!1+#)!$%!/&#+#!7##)+F!:&#!7##)!+&61-)!(#E'$%!36%+/'%/!$%;!<br />

%6/!6%-0!%1/($#%/!36EA6+$/$6%;!21/!'-+6!A&0+$3'-!3&'('3/#($+/$3+;!7##)!/#T/1(#!I$--!$%7-1#%3#!7##)!<br />

$%/'Q#!'%)!7##)!3-#'%!1A!/$E#F!!<br />

Y$%3#! /&#! 2$()+! '(#! (#+/($3/! 7#);! /&#! 2(##)#(! E'%'9#(! %##)+! '! 36%+$+/#%/! 7##)! '+! 36%/$%1'-!<br />

3&'%9#+!3(#'/#!)$77$31-/$#+!$%!E'%'9$%9!26)0I#$9&/+;!1%$76(E$/0!'%)!#99!A(6)13/$6%F!!!<br />

!<br />

Amino Acid Requirements<br />

N6EE#(3$'-! 2(##)#(! 7##)+! '(#! 67/#%! +/$--! 76(E1-'/#)! /6! E$%$E1E! 3(1)#! A(6/#$%! -#=#-+! I&$3&!<br />

(#+1-/+!$%!E6+/!'E$%6!'3$)+!-#=#-+!+$9%$7$3'%/-0!&$9&#(!/&'%!(#L1$(#)F!HT3#++!'E$%6!'3$)!-#=#-+!<br />

3'%!A(6E6/#!#T3#++!E1+3-#!)#A6+$/$6%;!g6A#P!'%)!g##+6%!CJKKWD!$--1+/('/#)!/&#!#77#3/!67!#T3#++!<br />

3(1)#!A(6/#$%!6%!7#(/$-$/0!'%)!E6(#!(#3#%/-0!N66%!#/!'-!C^SS_D!$)#%/$7$#)!$%)$=$)1'-!'E$%6!'3$)+!<br />

I&$3&!'77#3/!7#(/$-$/0!67!2(##)#(+F!<br />

!<br />

:'2-#!JF!:&#!H77#3/!67!HT3#++!,(6/#$%!6%!*#(/$-$/0!Cg6A#P!'%)!g##+6%;!JKKWD!<br />

G$#/'(0!A(6/#$%!pu! *#(/$-$/0!/6!_a!I##Q+!<br />

J_!<br />

KJF_!<br />

Ja!<br />

KUFU!<br />

J^!<br />

KWFJ!<br />

JS!<br />

KWFa!<br />

u)$#/+!36%/'$%#)!/&#!+'E#!E$%$E1E!-#=#-+!67!#++#%/$'-!'E$%6!'3$)+!'%)!#%#(90!<br />

!<br />

443


!<br />

5/!$+!$EA6(/'%/!/6!1%)#(+/'%)!/&#!)'$-0!)$9#+/$2-#!'E$%6!'3$)!(#L1$(#E#%/!67!/&#!2(##)#(!C/'2-#!<br />

^D! '%)! +/($=#! /6! 76(E1-'/#! 7##)+! /&'/! +1AA-0! /&#+#! -#=#-+! I&$-#! E$%$E$P$%9! #T3#++! 67! 6/&#(!<br />

'E$%6!'3$)+F!8##/$%9!21/!%6/!#T3##)$%9!'E$%6!'3$)!(#L1$(#E#%/+!$+!#+A#3$'--0!$EA6(/'%/!)1($%9!<br />

/&#!+1EE#(!E6%/&+!I&#%!#T3#++!'E$%6!'3$)+!3'%!(#A(#+#%/!'%!'))$/$6%'-!E#/'26-$3!21()#%!6%!<br />

/&#!2$()!'%)!#T'3#(2'/#!&#'/!+/(#++F!<br />

!<br />

:'2-#!^F!G$9#+/$2-#!'E$%6!'3$)!(#L1$(#E#%/+!67!2(6$-#(!2(##)#(!&#%+!'/!A#'Q!A(6)13/$6%F!<br />

!<br />

bE$%6!b3$)!


!<br />

Separate Male Diets<br />

b+! )$+31++#)! A(#=$61+-0;! /&#! E6)#(%! 2(6$-#(! 2(##)#(! $+! E6(#! A(#)$+A6+#)! /6! #T3#++! E1+3-#!<br />

)#A6+$/$6%m! /&$+! #+A#3$'--0! 'AA-$#+! /6! /&#! E'-#! 2(##)#(F! N6%/(6-! 67! E'-#! 26)0I#$9&/! '%)!<br />

36%)$/$6%!$+!=$/'-!$%!6()#(!/6!E'T$E$P#!(#A(6)13/$=#!A#(76(E'%3#F!d=#(!36%)$/$6%#)!E'-#+!'(#!<br />

-#++!'3/$=#!'%)!'(#!-#++!-$Q#-0!/6!E'/#!+133#++71--0F!!!<br />

g6I! %1/($#%/! )#%+$/0! E'-#! )$#/+! '(#! +6E#/$E#+! 1+#)! /6! 36%/(6-! E'-#! 36%)$/$6%! '%)! +1AA6(/!<br />

E'/$%9! '3/$=$/0F! Y6E#! (#+#'(3&! +199#+/+! /&#(#! E'0! 2#! '! )$(#3/! #77#3/! 67! %1/($#%/+! 6%! E'-#!<br />

7#(/$-$/0F!Y#A'('/#!E'-#!)$#/+!'(#!9#%#('--0!-6I#(!$%!A(6/#$%;!#%#(90!'%)!E$%#('-+!&6I#=#(!+6E#!<br />

'-+6! 36%/'$%! #-#='/#)! -#=#-+! 67! E$3(6%1/($#%/+! +13&! '+! =$/'E$%! H! '%)! Y#-#%$1E! I&$3&! '(#!<br />

Q%6I%!/6!$%7-1#%3#!7#(/$-$/0F!!<br />

"#3#%/!#='-1'/$6%+!+199#+/!/&#!2#%#7$/+!67!+#A'('/#!E'-#!)$#/+!'(#!E6(#!#=$)#%/!$%!/&#!-'/#(!A'(/!<br />

67!-'0F!d%#!+13&!#='-1'/$6%!+&6I#)!2#%#7$/+!$%!-'/#!&'/3&'2$-$/0!67!1A!/6!Up;!'++#++E#%/+!I#(#!<br />

'-+6!E')#!67!+A#(E!=$'2$-$/0!20!361%/$%9!/&#!&6-#+!E')#!20!+A#(E!'+!/&#0!#%/#(!/&#!2-'+/6)#(E!<br />

1+$%9! 5%%#(! ,#($=$/#--$%#! g'0#(! :#3&%$L1#! C5,.gDF! H99! +'EA-#+! I#(#! 36--#3/#)! 6=#(! /&#!<br />

A(6)13/$6%! A#($6);! /&#! %1E2#(! 67! +A#(E! I&$3&! A#%#/('/#)! /&#! A#($=$//#-$%#! E#E2('%#! I#(#!<br />

&$9&#(!7(6E!/&6+#!E'-#+!7#)!/&#!+#A'('/#!E'-#!)$#/;!/&$+!I'+!A'(/$31-'(-0!#=$)#%/!-'/#(!$%!-'0F!!<br />

%9#/0,(!.4'&.'!RJOJ^SJZJ^S_!<br />

g6A#P;! hF! '%)! g##+6%F! YF! CJKKWD! "#+A6%+#! 67! 2(6$-#(! 2(##)#(+! /6! -6IZA(6/#$%! )$#/+F! JF! b)1-/! 2(##)#(!<br />

A#(76(E'%3#F!>%9#/0,(!.4'&.'!RaO_`WZ_Ka!<br />

M'/$6%'-!"#+#'(3&!N61%3$-!CJKKaD!M1/($#%/!"#L1$(#E#%/+!67!,61-/(0F!K /& !(#=F!#)F!M'/$6%'-!b3')#E0!,(#++;!<br />

['+&$%9/6%;!GNF!<br />

445<br />

!


!<br />

New Technologies and Approaches for Composting Broiler Manure<br />

!<br />

4F8F!j##%#(; ; !8'(0!4F![$3Q+;!*FNF!8$3&#-;!j'E$-!H3Q$%3$!<br />

4F!8F!!j##%#(!;!,(67#++6(!HE#($/$!'%)!b++63$'/#!N&'$(;!Q##%#(FUr6+1F#)1m!!!!<br />

*FNF!8$3&#-;!b++63$'/#!,(67#++6(;!E$3&#-FU_r6+1F#)1m!!<br />

8'(0!4F![$3Q+;!d&$6!N6EA6+/!'%)!8'%1(#!8'%'9#E#%/!N66()$%'/6(;!I$3Q+FJar6+1F#)1;!G#A/F!67!*66);!<br />

b9($31-/1('-;!'%)!?$6-69$3'-!H%9$%##($%9;!db"GNX:&#!d&$6!Y/'/#!


!<br />

M1E#(61+! +/1)$#+! &'=#! #='-1'/#)! /&#! #77#3/$=#%#++! 67! )$77#(#%/! /#3&%6-69$#+! 76(! /(#'/$%9! 6(!<br />

A(63#++$%9! A61-/(0! -$//#(! /&'/! &'=#! /&#! A6/#%/$'-! /6! E$%$E$P#! #%=$(6%E#%/'-! $EA'3/+! '%)X6(!<br />

3(#'/#! ='-1#Z'))#)! A(6)13/+F! :&#+#! /#3&%6-69$#+! $%3-1)#! 21(%$%9! 76(! #-#3/($3'-! 9#%#('/$6%m!<br />

'%'#(62$3! )$9#+/$6%! 76(! E#/&'%#! A(6)13/$6%m! A#--#/$P$%9! 76(! $EA(6=#)! /('%+A6(/'2$-$/0! '%)!<br />

'AA-$3'/$6%m!'%)!36EA6+/$%9!/6!(#)13#!6)6(+;!A'/&69#%+;!'%)!E6$+/1(#F!"$//#(!'%)!Y/#&(!C^SSRD!<br />

#='-1'/#)! /&#! #36%6E$3! =$'2$-$/0! 67! +#=#('-! /#3&%6-69$#+F! ! H=#%! '++1E$%9! %6! /('%+A6(/'/$6%!<br />

36+/+!)1#!/6!+/'/#!+12+$)$#+!2#$%9!A'$)!$%!/&#!+/1)0!'(#';!/&#0!761%)!/&'/!I$/&!/&#!#T3#A/$6%!67!<br />

A#--#/$P$%9! '%)! 36EA6+/$%9;!/&#!36+/+!#T3##)#)!/&#!$%36E#!9#%#('/#)F:&#$(!#='-1'/$6%!67!/&#!<br />

b9($"#30-3#! ,-'%/! $%! Y#'76();! G#-'I'(#! $%)$3'/#)! /&'/! A#--#/$P$%9! 361-)! 9#%#('/#! $%36E#!<br />

)#A#%)$%9!6%!/&#!36+/!67!/&#!-$//#(!'%)!/&#!=6-1E#!A(63#++#)F!!!b%'-0+$+!67!36EA6+/$%9!+0+/#E+!<br />

7631+#)!6%!'!3#%/('-$P#)!7'3$-$/0!'+!/('%+A6(/'/$6%!36+/+!I#(#!%6/!'!7'3/6(F!!b++1E$%9!'!I$%)(6I!<br />

36EA6+/$%9!+0+/#E!I61-)!2#!1+#);!/&#0!761%)!/&'/!/&#!#36%6E$3!7#'+$2$-$/0!)#A#%)#)!6%!/&#!<br />

36+/!67!/&#!-$//#(!'%)!'E#%)E#%/+;!6A#('/$%9!36+/+;!'%)!/&#!(#/'$-!A($3#!67!/&#!7$%$+&#)!36EA6+/F!!<br />

*6(!#T'EA-#;!76(!(#/'$-!36EA6+/!A($3#!67!wRFWW!E ZU !/&#$(!+/1)0!+199#+/#)!(#/1(%+!67!wR`J;SSS!/6!<br />

wJ;UR_;SSS!'%%1'-!A(67$/F!!:&#!A-'%/!+$P#!&')!'%!'%%1'-!3'A'3$/0!67!WK;SSS!/F!M6!$%76(E'/$6%!$%!<br />

/&#$(! (#A6(/! I'+! +1AA-$#)! 6%! '++1EA/$6%+! 76(! =6-1E#! (#)13/$6%+! 67! E'/#($'-+! '%)! -6++! 67! M!<br />

)1($%9!/&#!36EA6+/$%9!A(63#++F!!!!<br />

:&$+! A'A#(! 61/-$%#+! /&#! 6AA6(/1%$/$#+! $%! 36EA6+/$%9! A61-/(0! -$//#(! (#E6=#)! 7(6E! /&#! 2(6$-#(!<br />

&61+#!/6!3(#'/#!'!A(6)13/!+619&/!'7/#(!20!36EE#(3$'-!%1(+#(0!'%)!=#9#/'2-#!9(6I#(+;!'+!I#--!'+!<br />

&6E#! 6I%#(+F! 5/! 7631+#+! 6%! 36EA6+/$%9! A($%3$A'-+! '%)! +0+/#E+! I&$3&! 3'%! -#')! /6! E$%$E'-!<br />

#%=$(6%E#%/'-!$EA'3/+!'%)!M!-6++#+!)1($%9!/&#!36EA6+/$%9!A(63#++!'%)!'!-6I!E6$+/1(#!A(6)13/!<br />

/6!(#)13#!/('%+A6(/'/$6%!36+/F!!<br />

!!<br />

Properties of Broiler Litter<br />

,(6A#(/$#+!67!2(6$-#(!-$//#(!C?gD!'(#!&$9&-0!='($'2-#F!!HQ$%3$!#/!'-F!C^SSa2D!(#A6(/#)!='-1#+!76(!<br />

?g!CI66)3&$A!2#))$%9D!(#E6=#)!'7/#(!J!7-63Q!CaK!)'0+D!'+!&'=$%9!UaZaSp!E6$+/1(#;!`Z`FU!A4;!<br />

UWZU`p!N;!UZUFKp!M;!KFRZJJF_!NXM;!'%)!JRF`ZJKFRp!'+&F!!?(6)$#!#/!'-F!C^SSSD!(#A6(/#)!?g!$%!<br />

/&#$(!+/1)$#+!'+!&'=$%9!aSp!E6$+/1(#;!U`FWp!N;!WFKp!M;!R!NXM;!'%)!^JFUp!'+&F!866(#!#/!'-F!<br />

CJKKWD! (#A6(/#)! (#+1-/+! 7(6E! %1E#(61+! +/1)$#+! '%)! 3$/#)! ?g! '+! &'=$%9! '%! '=#('9#! 67! ^aFWp!<br />

E6$+/1(#;!URF_!p!N;!aFJp!M;!KF^!NXM;!'%)!SF^_p!M4 a ZMF!!M6!)'/'!6%!'+&!I'+!(#A6(/#)F!N6%71-!<br />

#/!'-F!C^SS_D!(#A6(/#)!'E61%/+!67!A61-/(0!-$//#(!'%)!A61-/(0!-$//#(!3'Q#!A(6)13#)!'+!'!71%3/$6%!67!<br />

7-63Q!%1E2#(+!9#%#('/#);!'-6%9!I$/&!E6$+/1(#;!A4;!M;!,;!'%)!j!C:'2-#!JDF!!"#+1-/+!+&6I#)!M!$%!<br />

/&#!-$//#(!'%)!3'Q#!$%3(#'+#)!I$/&!7-63Q!%1E2#(+F!!M!='-1#+!('%9#)!7(6E!1%)#(!Up!C7-63Q!J!'%)!<br />

^D!/6!UF`_p!C7-63Q!_D!/6!aFUUp!C7-63Q!J^DF!M6!'+&!6(!N!)'/'!I'+!9$=#%F!!86$+/1(#!67!/&#!3'Q#!<br />

I'+!'AA(6T$E'/#-0!)612-#!/&'/!67!/&#!-$//#(;!('%9$%9!aU!/6!WWp;!'%)!='($#)!20!/$E#!67!0#'(!'+!<br />

I#--!'+!7-63Q!%1E2#(F!!<br />

!<br />

447


!<br />

:'2-#!JF!,#(3#%/!E6$+/1(#;!A4;!M;!,;!j!76(!(#303-#)!($3#!&1--!2(6$-#(!-$//#(!'%)!E6$+/1(#!76(!3'Q#!<br />

'/!/&#!#%)!67!#'3&!7-63Q!76(!+#-#3/#)!7-63Q+!J!/6!J`J;^F<br />

?#9$%!)'/#! H%)!)'/#! ! g$//#(! A4! M! ,! j! N'Q#!<br />

CE6X0(D! CE6X0(D! *-63Q 86$+/1(#! ! Cp)2D! Cp)2D! Cp)2D! E6$+/1(#CpD!<br />

CpD!<br />

RXSJ! `XSJ! J! ^_FJ 3)#7 ! `F_! ^FS`-!<br />

SF`W Q ! JFKR $ ! WUFW '2 !<br />

KXSJ! JSXSJ! ^! ^UFa & ! `F`! ^F`R Q ! JFJK e ! ^FWS & ! WUFU '2 !<br />

JJXSJ! J^XSJ! U! ^_FK 23)# ! `FR! UFJ`e!<br />

JFU`$!<br />

^F`R 9& ! WWF_ ' !<br />

aXS^! WXS^! _! ^_F_ 23)# ! `FK! UF`_ )# ! JF`J 9 ! UFaa 23)#7 ! aUFJ #7 !<br />

KXS^! JSXS^! K! ^RF^23) ! `F`! UF_a 9&$ ! ^FUS '23 ! UF`J 2 ! WSF`23 !<br />

^XSU! aXSU! J^! ^aFa 79& ! `FR! aFUU ' ! ^FJJ 3)#7 ! UFSU #79& ! aaF`#7 !<br />

`XSU! KXSU! JW! ^`Fa '2 ! `F`! UF_W 9&$ ! ^F^_ '23)# ! UF_`23) ! aaF`#7 !<br />

JXSa! ^XSa! J`! ^`FU '2 ! `FK! aFJS 2 ! ^FJ^3)# ! UFJW 3)#79 ! W^FR '23 !<br />

b=#('9#! ! ! ^_Fa! ! ! ! ! a_FK!<br />

'V& !8#'%+!I$/&$%!'!36-1E%!-'3Q$%9!'!36EE6%!+1A#(+3($A/!)$77#(!C>(x!SFSWDF!<br />

J! b)'A/#)!7(6E!N6%71-!#/!'-F;!^SS_F !<br />

^! *-63Q+!J!/6!K;!'=#('9#!67!a!A#%+m!7-63Q+!JS!/6!J`;!'=#('9#!67!U!A#%+F!<br />

N6EA6+/$%9!,(63#++!<br />

!<br />

N6EA6+/$%9! $+! /&#! '33#-#('/#)! 2$6-69$3'-! )#36EA6+$/$6%! 67! 6(9'%$3! E'/#($'-+! $%! '!<br />

A(#)6E$%'%/-0!'#(62$3!#%=$(6%E#%/F!!G1($%9!/&#!A(63#++;!E$3(66(9'%$+E+!2(#'Q!)6I%!6(9'%$3!<br />

E'/#($'-+!/6!+/'2-#;!1+'2-#!6(9'%$3!+12+/'%3#+!3'--#)!36EA6+/F!:&#!A(63#++!36%+1E#+!6T09#%!<br />

'%)!(#-#'+#+!&#'/;!I'/#(;!'%)!Nd^!C4'19;!JKK^DF!!


!<br />

36EA6+/$%9!A(63#++!'%)!36EA6+/!E'/1($/0!'%)!+/'2$-$/0!'(#!)$+31++#)!$%!%1E#(61+!(#7#(#%3#+!<br />

C4'19;!JKKUm!46$/$%Q!'%)!j##%#(;!JKKUm!'%)!j##%#(!#/!'-F;!^SSS'DF!!<br />

dA/$E$P$%9!G#+$9%!'%)!8'%'9#E#%/!67!N6EA6+/!Y0+/#E+!76(!?(6$-#(!g$//#(!<br />

j##%#(! #/! '-F! CJKKU;! ^SSWD! %6/#)! /&'/! 6A/$E$P'/$6%! 67! '! )#+$9%;! I&#/&#(! 2'+#)! 6%! 36+/! 67!<br />

36%+/(13/$6%!'%)!6A#('/$6%;!#%#(90!1+#!C36%+#(='/$6%!67!(#+61(3#+D;!6(!A6--1/$6%!-#=#-+!C6)6(+;!<br />

)1+/;!#/3FD!3'%!2#!'336EA-$+&#)!/&(619&!7$#-)!#TA#($E#%/'/$6%!'%)!E'/&#E'/$3'-!E6)#-$%9!67!<br />

/&#!36EA6+/$%9!A(63#++F!:&#!76--6I$%9!+#3/$6%+!A(#+#%/+!(#+1-/+!67!26/&!7$#-)!#TA#($E#%/'/$6%!<br />

'%)! E6)#-$%9! 6%! 36%/(6--'2-#! 7'3/6(+! $%! 36EA6+/$%9! I&$3&! 3'%! 2#! 'AA-$#)! /6! 6A/$E$P$%9!<br />

36EA6+/$%9!67!2(6$-#(!-$//#(F!!<br />

Mixing ratios<br />

8$T#+!'(#!1+1'--0!)#=#-6A#)!6%!'!=6-1E#!2'+$+!/6!E'Q#!$/!#'+$#(!76(!/&#!6A#('/6(!67!'!7'3$-$/0!/6!<br />

E'%'9#! /&#! A(63#++F! ! :&#! dNb88! C^SJJD! I#2+$/#! A(#+#%/+! '! 36EA1/#(! +A(#')+&##/;!<br />

dA/$E$P$%9! N6EA6+/! 8$T$%9! "'/$6+!! CE#/($3! 1%$/+D;! /6! 3'-31-'/#! '! E$T/1(#y+! N;! M;! NXM;!<br />

E6$+/1(#;! '%)! )#%+$/0! 2'+#)! 6%! /&#! =6-1E#+! 6(! E'++! 67! E'/#($'-+! 2#$%9! E$T#)! '%)! /&#$(!<br />

$%)$=$)1'-!A(6A#(/$#+!Cj##%#(!#/!'-F;!^SSS2DF!


!<br />

C/N and moisture content<br />

"0%Q!CJKK^D!+/'/#)!/&'/!/&#!)#+$(#)!NXM!('/$6!76(!36EA6+/$%9!$+!2#/I##%!^WOJ!'%)!aSOJ!/6!7'=6(!<br />

&$9&!9(6I/&!('/#+!67!E$3(66(9'%$+E+!'%)!/&#$(!#77$3$#%/!A(63#++$%9!67!)#9(')'2-#!6(9'%$3+!I$/&!<br />

-$E$/#)!6)6(!9#%#('/$6%F!HQ$%3$!'/("#?!C^SS^D!#='-1'/#)!/&#!#77#3/+!67!NXM!76(!A'A#(!E$--!+-1)9#!<br />

C$)#%/$7$#)! '+! t+&6(/! A'A#(! 7$2#(cD! '%)! 2(6$-#(! -$//#(! CY,*X?gD! 6%! /&#! )#36EA6+$/$6%! ('/#;! Q!<br />

CQ9 )E-6++ !Q9 ZJ =+ !)'0 ZJ DF!:&#!#L1'/$6%!$%36(A6('/$%9!NXM!C"^!l!SFKK`D!I'+!<br />

^<br />

SFW}C~N X M| UWFKaD XJJF__{ !CJD<br />

z N X M #<br />

Q!l!Q E'T !u!z NXM !<br />

:&#!E'T$E1E!)#36EA6+$/$6%!('/#;!Q E'T !;!I'+!SFJJK!Q9 )E-6++ !Q9 ZJ =+ !)'0 ZJ !'%)!6331((#)!'/!NXM!67!<br />

UWFKF!


!<br />

6331(+!$7!/&#!A$-#!$+!^ZU!E!)##A!'%)!E6$+/1(#!$+!'!E$%$E1E!67!^SZ^WpF!5/!+&61-)!2#!%6/#)!/&'/!<br />

)##A!A$-#+!I$/&!)#A/&+!ka!E!+6E#/$E#+!-#')!/6!+A6%/'%#61+!36E21+/$6%F!!<br />

*1%)'E#%/'-!#L1'/$6%!76(!)#+$9%!67!'#('/$6%!+0+/#E+!76(!36EA6+/$%9!&'=#!2##%!A(#+#%/#)!20!<br />

j##%#(!#/!'-F!CJKKU;!^SSS'f2;!^SSWD!26/&!76(!36%/$%161+!'%)!$%/#(E$//#%/!'#('/$6%F!!*$91(#!U!<br />

61/-$%#+!'$(7-6I!(#L1$(#E#%/+!A#(!)(0!E'//#(!E'++!76(!/&(##!36EA6+/!E'/#($'-+!Cj##%#(!#/!'-F;!<br />

^SSWDO!2$6+6-$)+XI66)3&$A+;!0'()!I'+/#;!'%)!8Y[F!!5%$/$'-!'$(7-6I+!I#(#!JFaJ;!UFa`!'%)!SFR_!<br />

E U !Q9 36 ZJ! )'0 ZJ ;!(#+A#3/$=#-0;!76(!36EA6+/$%9!'/!WWZ_S !6 NF!"#+1-/+!+199#+/!'$(7-6I!(#L1$(#E#%/+!<br />

3'%! )#3(#'+#! '+! E13&! '+! aSZ76-)! 7(6E! )'0! S! /6! )'0! ^JF! *6(! 2(6$-#(! -$//#(X3'Q#! 36EA6+/$%9;!<br />

'$(7-6I!(#L1$(#E#%/+!I61-)!2#!+$E$-'(!/6!8Y[!'+!A(#+#%/#)!$%!7$91(#!^F!<br />

:6! E$%$E$P#! 3'A$/'-! '%)! 6A#('/$%9! 36+/+;! 7'%! )#+$9%! +&61-)! 2#! 2'+#)! 6%! UZW 6 N! '26=#! /&#!<br />

6A/$E'-!/#EA#('/1(#!76(!)#36EA6+$/$6%!Cj##%#(;!#/!'-F;!^SSWDF!!G'+!'%)!j##%#(!CJKKRD!+&6I#)!<br />

/&'/! )1($%9! 76(3#)! '#('/$6%! 76(! $%Z=#++#-! 36EA6+/$%9! 3&'%%#-$%9! 3'%! 6331(! '%)! -#')! /6!<br />

$%#77$3$#%/!6A#('/$6%;!1%-#++!(#E$T$%9!6331(+F!<br />

10<br />

1<br />

Airflow<br />

m 3 /(kg co day)<br />

0.1<br />

G/L/B<br />

BS/WC<br />

MSW<br />

0.01<br />

0 5 10 15 20 25<br />

Composting Time, Day<br />

Ä!<br />

*$91(#!^F!H='-1'/$6%!67!'$(7-6I!(#L1$(#E#%/+!/6!36%/(6-!/#EA#('/1(#!'/!_S !6 N!76(!'!0'()!/($EE$%9!36EA6+/;!<br />

9('++X-#'=#+X2(1+&!ChXgX?D;!2$6+6-$)+XI66)3&$A!C?YX[ND!'%)!E1%$3$A'-!+6-$)!I'+/#!C8Y[DF!!b$(7-6I!$+!E U !<br />

Q9 ZJ 36 !)'0 ZJ !67!$%$/$'-!)(0!6(9'%$3!E'++F!!"#7O!j##%#(!#/!'-F!C!^SSWDF!<br />

!<br />

4'19! CJKKUD! )$+31++#)! /&#! #77#3/+! 67! 6T09#%! -#=#-! '%)! 7(##! '$(! +A'3#;! 6%! QF! *6(! E6+/!<br />

36EA6+/$%9! +0+/#E+;! /&#! ('/#! -$E$/$%9! #77#3/+! 67! /&#+#! A'('E#/#(+! '(#! '=6$)#)! $7! $%/#(+/$/$'-!<br />

6T09#%! $+! E'$%/'$%#)! '26=#! Wp! '%)! ! $+! 9(#'/#(! /&'%! UWp;! I&$3&! $+! '336EA-$+&#)! 20!<br />

36%/(6--$%9! E6$+/1(#! -#=#-+F! :0A$3'--0;! $7! #%619&! '$(! #%/#(+! '3/$=#! 36EA6+/! &#'A+! /6! 36%/(6-!<br />

/#EA#('/1(#+! 2#-6I! RS 6 N;! #%619&! 6T09#%! $+! +1AA-$#)! '+! I#--! Cj##%#(! #/! '-F;! ^SSWDF!!<br />

N6EA6+/$%9! $%! /&#! 6A#%! '$(! $+! '77#3/#)! 20! ('$%7'--! '%)! $%! +6E#! (#9$6%+! ('$%7'--! +'/1('/#+!<br />

36EA6+/! A$-#+F! :&$+! (#+1-/+! $%! -#'3&'/#! 76(E'/$6%;! 6)6(+! '%)! 6/&#(! A(62-#E+! '%)! E1+/! 2#!<br />

'=6$)#)F! ! 5%! )(0! (#9$6%+! '%)! $%! 36=#(#)! 7'3$-$/$#+;! I'/#(! -6++! '%)! -6I! E6$+/1(#+! 3'%! -#')! /6!<br />

A(63#++!$%&$2$/$6%F!!<br />

Particle Size<br />

,'(/$3-#! +$P#! '%)! )$+/($21/$6%! '(#! 3($/$3'-! 76(! 2'-'%3$%9! +1(7'3#! '(#'! 76(! 9(6I/&! 67!<br />

E$3(66(9'%$+E+! '%)! E'$%/#%'%3#! 67! ')#L1'/#! A6(6+$/0! 76(! '#('/$6%F! Y/1)$#+! 6%! A'(/$3-#! +$P#!<br />

+199#+/!'33#A/'2-#!='-1#+!/6!2#!SF`ZJF^!3E!%6E$%'-!)$'E#/#(!C"0%Q;!JKK^DF!*6(!A61-/(0!-$//#(;!<br />

A'(/$3-#! +$P#! I61-)! %6/! 2#! '%! $++1#! $7! E6$+/1(#! $+! x! aWp! '/! /&#! +/'(/! 67! /&#! A(63#++! '%)!<br />

E#3&'%$3'-!E$T$%9!$+!1+#)!)1($%9!6(!'/!/&#!#%)!67!A(63#++!/6!#-$E$%'/#!3-1EA$%9!67!E'/#($'-+!<br />

'%)!A(6)13#!'!9('%1-'(!A(6)13/F!!<br />

pH<br />

b! A4! 2#/I##%! _FR! '%)! KFS! +1AA6(/+! 966)! E$3(62$'-! '3/$=$/0! )1($%9! 36EA6+/$%9F! ! g'(9#!<br />

L1'%/$/$#+! 67! 'EE6%$'! CM4 U D;! &6I#=#(;! 3'%! 2#! -6+/! $7! /&#! A4! $+! %6/! E'$%/'$%#)! 2#-6I! RFW!<br />

!<br />

451


!<br />

CN'(#0;!JKKRDF!?(6$-#(!-$//#(X3'Q#!&'+!'!&$9&!A4!67!RFW!V!`FK!CN6%71-!#/!'-F;!^SS_m!H3Q$%3$!#/!'-F;!<br />

^SSa2D!+6!I61-)!2#!#TA#3/#)!/6!-6+#!'!&$9&!A#(3#%/'9#!67!$/+!M!'+!M4 U ZMF!!<br />

Ammonia, odor control, volume reduction<br />

8'%0!36EA6+/+!'(#!E'(Q#/#)!'%)!A($3#)!2'+#)!6%!/&#$(!%1/($/$=#!='-1#;!I&$3&!$+!7$T#)!C#T3#A/!<br />

76(!MD!20!/&#!$%$/$'-!36EA6+/!E$TF!:&$+!$+!2#3'1+#!/&#!A-'%/!%1/($#%/+!,;!j;!N';!'+!I#--!'+!&#'=0!<br />

E#/'-+;! )6! %6/! )$+'AA#'(! 7(6E! /&#! +0+/#E! '+! /&#! )(0! E'//#(! )#36EA6+#+! C1%-#++! -#'3&$%9!<br />

6331(+DF!46I#=#(;!M!$+!-6+/!=$'!%1E#(61+!A'/&I'0+;!I$/&!M4 U !2#$%9!/&#!E6+/!36EE6%F!:&(##!<br />

36%3#A/+!3'%!E$%$E$P#!M4 U !-6++F!<br />

!<br />

JF!:6!E$%$E$P#!M!-6++#+!I$/&!-6I!NXM!E$T#+;!'$(7-6I!36%/(6-!$+!3($/$3'-F!HTA#($E#%/'-!+/1)$#+!<br />

67! H-I#--! #/! '-F! C^SSJD! #TA-6(#)! /&#! #77#3/! 67! 36%/$%161+! '%)! $%/#(E$//#%/! '#('/$6%! 6%! M4 U !<br />

#E$++$6%+! '%)! 6)6(! 9#%#('/$6%! )1($%9! 36EA6+/$%9! 67! &69! E'%1(#F! "#+1-/+! 67! /&6+#! +/1)$#+!<br />

+&6I#)! M4 U ! #E$++$6%! I'+! &$9&-0! 36((#-'/#)! I$/&! /6/'-! '$(7-6I;! (#9'()-#++! 67! 7'%! 6A#('/$%9!<br />

E6)#F! "#+1-/+! '-+6! +199#+/#)! 6)6(! #E$++$6%+! I61-)! 2#! (#)13#)! $7! /&#! '$(7-6I! I#(#! (#)13#)!<br />

I&$-#! E'$%/'$%$%9! '#(62$3! 36%)$/$6%+F! j$(3&E'%%! '%)! [$//#(! CJK`KD! +&6I#)! /&'/! $7! '3$)$3!<br />

36%)$/$6%+!6331(!$%!A61-/(0!E'%1(#!36EA6+/$%9!C'%'#(62$3!=+F!'#(62$3D;!)1#!/6!#T/(#E#-0!-6I!<br />

'$(!#T3&'%9#;!-#++!/&'%!Jp!67!%$/(69#%!6($9$%'--0!A(#+#%/!I61-)!2#!#=6-=#)F!46I#=#(;!$/!+&61-)!<br />

2#!%6/#)!76(!/&#!36EA6+/$%9!E'/#($'-!/6!)(0!'%)!+/'2$-$P#;!'$(!#T3&'%9#!E1+/!6331(F!!<br />

^F! :6! E$%$E$P#! M! -6++#+! I$/&! -6I! NXM! E$T#+;! #%3-6+1(#! 67! /&#! A$-#! $+! '-+6! )#+$('2-#F! ! ?0!<br />

#%3-6+$%9!/&#!A$-#;!$%!'!21$-)$%9!6(!I$/&!+#E$ZA#(E#'2-#!36=#(+;!'$(7-6I!$+!2#//#(!36%/(6--#)!'%)!<br />

&$9&#(!-#=#-+!67!M4 U !3'%!2#!E'$%/'$%#)!'/!/&#!+1(7'3#!67!/&#!A$-#F!!:&$+!3'%!'++$+/!$%!(#)13$%9!<br />

M4 U !)$771+$6%!'I'0!7(6E!/&#!+1(7'3#!67!/&#!A$-#;!'%)!(#)13#!M!-6++!7(6E!36EA6+/!Cj##%#(!#/!<br />

'-F;!^SS^D!!<br />

UF! :6! E$%$E$P#! M! -6++#+! I$/&! -6I! NOM! E$T#+;! )(0$%9! 67! /&#! 67! /&#! 36EA6+/! $+! )#+$('2-#!<br />

CN'2(#('!'%)!N&$'%9;!JKKaDF!b+!/&#!36EA6+/!E6$+/1(#!-#=#-!)(6A+!/&#!2$6-69$3'-!'%)!3&#E$3'-!<br />

'3/$=$/0!$+!$%&$2$/#);!-6I#($%9!/&#!('/#!67!/('%+76(E$%9!1($3!'3$)!!1(#'!!M4 U !s!Nd^!CN'(#0;!<br />

JKKRDF!!!:6!E'T$E$P#!)(0$%9!('/#+!I&$-#!E$%$E$P$%9!/6/'-!'$(!7-6I!C36%3#A/!JD;!7'%+!+&61-)!2#!<br />

6A#('/#)! $%! /&#! _WZRSN! ('%9#! /6! /'Q#! ')='%/'9#! 67! '$(c+! I'/#(! &6-)$%9! 3'A'3$/0! C3'A'3$/0!<br />

)612-#+!7(6E!_S !6 N!/6!RS !6 NDF!!b-+6;!+1(7'3#!)(0$%9!67!/&#!36EA6+/!$+!#%&'%3#)!I&#%#=#(!/&#!<br />

A$-#!$+!/1(%#)F!<br />

d/&#(! '-/#(%'/$=#! E#/&6)+! &'=#! 2##%! A(6A6+#)! /6! 3'A/1(#! 6(! (#)13#! M! -6++#+F! N'(#0! CJKKRD!<br />

A(6A6+#)!'3$)!+3(122$%9!67!M4 U! #E$++$6%+!7(6E!/&#!36EA6+/$%9!A(63#++!'%)!(#/1(%$%9!/&#!M4 U !<br />

+'-/!2'3Q!/6!/&#!7$%$+&#)!36EA6+/F!!:&$+!&'+!E#($/;!21/!(#E'$%+!/6!2#!A(6=#%!36+/!#77#3/$=#F!Y/$--!<br />

6/&#(!'AA(6'3&#+!&'=#!1+#)!'-1E!CHQ$%3$;!^SS^D!'%)!90A+1E!C:12'$-!#/!'-F;!^SS`DF!!d7!/&#+#!<br />

'AA(6'3&#+;!/&#!1+#!67!90A+1E!E'0!2#!=$'2-#!76(!+6E#!6A#('/$6%+;!21/!(#L1$(#+!71(/&#(!+/1)$#+!<br />

6%!#77$3'30!I$/&!2(6$-#(!-$//#(F!!!<br />

G1($%9!36EA6+/$%9;!=6-1E#!'%)!E'++!(#)13/$6%+!67!A'(#%/!E'/#($'-+!'+!&$9&!'+!RWZ`Sp!&'=#!<br />

2##%! 3$/#)! 76(! 36EA6+/$%9! )'$(0! E'%1(#! '%)! 'E#%)E#%/! C8$3&#-! #/! '-;! ^SSaDF! Y/1)$#+! 20!<br />

H-I#--!#/!'-F!CJKK`D!6%!1%Z'E#%)#)!A61-/(0!E'%1(#!$%)$3'/#!/&'/!)(0!E'//#(!-6++#+!I61-)!2#!<br />

xUSp!$7;!)1($%9!/&#!A(63#++;!/&#!E6$+/1(#!)(6AA#)!('A$)-0!/6!1%)#(!^SpF!!?(6)$#!#/!'-F!C^SSSD!<br />

(#A6(/#)! UUp! '%)! aJp! =6-1E#! (#)13/$6%! )1($%9! +/'/$3! A$-#! '%)! I$%)(6I! 36EA6+/$%9;!<br />

(#+A#3/$=#-0F!<br />

!<br />

Compost Systems<br />

N6EA6+/$%9!+0+/#E+!3'%!2#!3-'++$7$#)!'+!+/'/$3!A$-#+;!'#('/#)!+/'/$3!A$-#+;!/1(%#)!I$%)(6I+;!'%)!<br />

'#('/#)! /1(%#)! I$%)(6I+F! :&#! /#(E+! I$%)(6I! '%)! A$-#! 3'%! 2#! 1+#)! $%/#(3&'%9#'2-0! $%! /&#+#!<br />

)#+3($A/$6%+F! ! :&#! /#(E+! $%Z=#++#-! '%)! /1%%#-! $%)$3'/#! /&'/! /&#! A$-#! 6(! I$%)(6I! $+! 36%/'$%#)!<br />

I$/&$%!'!+/(13/1(#F!:&#!+0+/#E!/&'/!(#A(#+#%/+!/&#!2#+/!/#3&%6-690!)#A#%)+!6%!/&#!E'/#($'-C+D!/6!<br />

2#!36EA6+/#)!'%)!/'Q#+!$%/6!'3361%/!%6/!6%-0!$++1#+!+13&!'+!&#'-/&;!+'7#/0;!A12-$3!%1$+'%3#;!<br />

#/3F;!21/!'-+6!/&#!#36%6E$3+F!!G#+3($A/$6%+!67!/&#!='($61+!+0+/#E+!'-6%9!I$/&!'AA-$3'/$6%+!76(!<br />

A(63#++$%9!2(6$-#(!-$//#(!76(!='-1#Z'))#)!E'(Q#/$%9!'(#!'+!76--6I+F!!<br />

Static Pile (Fig. 3, 4) —! N6EA6+/$%9! E'/#($'-! $+! A-'3#)! $%! '! A$-#! C6(! I$%)(6ID! '%)! -#7/! /6!<br />

36EA6+/!I$/&!E$%$E'-!/1(%$%9!'%)!I$/&61/!1+$%9!76(3#)!=#%/$-'/$6%!C4'19;!JKKUm!"0%Q;!JKK^DF!<br />

!<br />

452


!<br />

:&$+! 'AA(6'3&! $+! 9#%#('--0! 1+#)! I$/&! E'/#($'-+! 1%-$Q#-0! /6! 9#%#('/#! 677#%+$=#! 6)6(+! 1%)#(!<br />

'%'#(62$3! 36%)$/$6%+;! E'/#($'-+! +13&! '+! -#'=#+! '%)! 9(61%)! 0'()I'+/#! I&$3&! &'=#! &$9&! NXM!<br />

('/$6+! CkWSDF! ! [&#%! #+3'A$%9! 6)6(+! E'0! 2#! '! A(62-#E;! /&#! A$-#! $+! 3'AA#)! I$/&! '! 2$67$-/#(!<br />

E'/#($'-!/6!/('A!'%)!)#+/(60!/&#!6)6(+F!!:&$+!-'//#(!'AA(6'3&!$+!1+#)!76(!)#')!'%$E'-!36EA6+/$%9!<br />

20!3'AA$%9!/&#!A$-#!I$/&!^WZWS!3E!67!2$67$-/#(!E'/#($'-!Cj##%#(!#/!'-F;!^SSS3DF!!:&#+#!+0+/#E+!<br />

'(#!1+1'--0!/1(%#)!1+$%9!'!7(6%/Z#%)!-6')#(!6%3#!'/!/&#!#%)!67!/&#!&$9&Z('/#!A&'+#!67!36EA6+/$%9!<br />

'%)! 6%3#! 2#/I##%! /&#! +/'2$-$P$%9! A&'+#! '%)! /&#! 31($%9! +/'9#F! ! Y3(##%$%9! 67/#%! A(#3#)#+! /&#!<br />

E'(Q#/$%9!67!E'/#($'-!/6!A(6=$)#!'!1%$76(E!A(6)13/!-#++!/&'%!J!3E!$%!+$P#!$7!I66)3&$A+!'(#!1+#)!<br />

$%! /&#! E$TF! ! :&#! 6=#(! +$P#)! E'/#($'-! -#7/! 7(6E! +3(##%$%9;! $7! I66)0;! $+! 67/#%! E$T#)! I$/&! /&#!<br />

$%36E$%9!E'/#($'-!76(!71/1(#!36EA6+/$%9F!!<br />

?(6)$#!#/!'-F!C^SSSD!$%=#+/$9'/#)!+/'/$3!A$-#!36EA6+/$%9!76(!2(6$-#(!-$//#(F!:&#0!'E#%)#)!2(6$-#(!<br />

-$//#(!I$/&!+'I)1+/!'%)!I66)3&$A+!CUOWOW!=X=D;!(#+A#3/$=#-0F!5%$/$'-!E6$+/1(#!36%/#%/!I'+!a^p!<br />

'%)!NXM!67!JWF!,$-#!+&'A#!I'+!/($'%91-'(!I$/&!'!2'+#!I$)/&!67!aF_!E!'%)!&#$9&/!67!^Fa!EF!!:&#!<br />

A$-#!I'+!36%+/(13/#)!6%!SFaJ!E!)##A!-'0#(!67! I66)3&$A+!'%)!36=#(#)!I$/&!'!JW!3E!-'0#(!67!<br />

A(#=$61+-0!E')#!36EA6+/;!'%)!I'+!1%36=#(#)!/&(619&61/!/&#!+/1)0F!!,$-#+!(#'3&#)!+1+/'$%#)!<br />

&$9&!/#EA#('/1(#+!CkWU 6 ND!+177$3$#%/!/6!E##/!3($/#($'!76(!A'/&69#%!(#)13/$6%!CHA+/#$%;!JKKRD;!<br />

21/!36%/$%1#)!/6!+#-7!&#'/!'7/#(!^SSs!)'0+!I&#%!/1(%#)F!b-+6;!/&#!E6$+/1(#!36%/#%/!(#E'$%#)!<br />

&$9&!$%!/&#!A(6)13/!'%)!'/!UWS!)'0+!I'+!kaSp!)1#!/6!('$%7'--!#=#%/+F!*$%'-!M!$%!/&#!36EA6+/!<br />

I'+! JFUpF! 5%/#(A(#/$%9! (#+1-/+! 67! /&$+! +/1)0! +199#+/! 61/+$)#! +/'/$3! A$-#! 36EA6+/$%9! 67! 2(6$-#(!<br />

-$//#(!I61-)!%6/!-#')!/6!'!)(0;!&$9&!='-1#!+/'2-#!A(6)13/!76(!E'(Q#/$%9F!!<br />

j##%#(! '%)! H-I#--! C^SSUD! +/1)$#)! +/'/$3! A$-#! 36EA6+/$%9! 67! 3'9#! -'0#(! E'%1(#! '/! /&#! N6(/!<br />

*'(E+!7'3$-$/0;!Y#0E61(;!5%)$'%'F!!8'%1(#!I'+!(#E6=#)!0#'(-0!7(6E!/&#!&$9&!($+#!&61+#+!'%)!<br />

A-'3#)!$%!'!US!T!KJ!E!n16%+#/!21$-)$%9!C*$91(#!aDF!!b261/!R^W!/6%+!0( ZJ !67!E'%1(#!7(6E!^FW!<br />

E$--$6%!2$()+!I#%/!$%/6!/&#!21$-)$%9!'/!-#++!/&'%!^Wp!E6$+/1(#F!!:&$+!21$-)$%9!I'+!A-'3#)!$%!<br />

+#(=$3#!]1%#!JKKK!'%)!'!7$(#!6331((#)!$%!]1-0!^SSS;!I&$3&!I'+!A1/!61/!20!(#E6=$%9!E'/#($'-F!!<br />

dA#('/$6%'-! A(63#)1(#+! I#(#! /6! A$-#! E'%1(#! $%! -'0#(+! 6%! 6%#! +$)#! CJX^D! 67! /&#! 21$-)$%9! '%)!<br />

$%3(#'+#!A$-#!&#$9&/!/$--!I$/&$%!U!E!67!/&#!(667!67!/&#!+/(13/1(#F!8'/#($'-!I'+!/&#%!36EA6+/#)!<br />

_ZJ^!E6%/&+!2#76(#!2#$%9!(#E6=#)!'%)!+6-)F!:#EA#('/1(#+!67!/&#!E'/#($'-!(#'3&#)!WSZWU 6 N!'/!<br />

)#A/&+!kUS3EF!!*6(!E'%1(#!96$%9!$%/6!+/6('9#;!/&#!E6$+/1(#!I'+!JSZ^Sp!'%)!'+&!36%/#%/!I'+!<br />

WWZaRp;!+199#+/$%9!E'%1(#!I'+!'-(#')0!I#--!)#36EA6+#)!I&#%!(#E6=#)!7(6E!/&#!2$()!&61+#+F!!<br />

b+&! 36%/#%/! '%)! E6$+/1(#! 67! E'/#($'-! )$)! %6/! E'/#($'--0! 3&'%9#! )1($%9! +/6('9#;! +199#+/$%9!<br />

2$6-69$3'-!)#36EA6+$/$6%!I'+!=#(0!-6IF!!:&#!M!67!/&#!A(6)13/!('%9#)!7(6E!aFaZWFJpF!!5/!I'+!<br />

36%3-1)#)! /&'/! ! )##A! A$-#! +/6('9#! 67! )(0! A61-/(0! E'%1(#! 1%)#(! (667! 3'%! #77#3/$=#-0! A(6/#3/!<br />

%1/($#%/+!'%)!36%/(6-!7-0!'%)!2##/-#!A6A1-'/$6%+F!46I#=#(;!)##A!A$-#!+/6('9#!76(!E'%1(#!'26=#!<br />

^Wp!E6$+/1(#!I61-)!-$Q#-0!+#-7!&#'/!/6!=#(0!&$9&!/#EA#('/1(#+!'%);!I$/&61/!'#('/$6%;!2#36E#!<br />

I#//#(!'%)!6)6(61+!'%)!&'=#!'!&$9&#(!A(62'2$-$/0!67!7$(#F!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

*$9F!UF!Y/'/$3!A$-#!36%+/(13/$6%!!'/!+/'(/!67! *$9! aF! Y/'/$3! A$-#! +/6('9#! +0+/#E! 1+#)!<br />

A&'+#!5F!C8$3&#-;!^SJJD!<br />

76(!3'9#)!-'0#(!E'%1(#F!<br />

Aerated Static Pile (Fig. 5, 6, 7) —!N6EA6+/$%9!E'/#($'-!$+!A-'3#)!$%!A$-#+!C6(!I$%)(6I+D!I$/&!<br />

=#%/$-'/$6%! )13/$%9! 1%)#(%#'/&! /&#! A$-#+! C4'19;! JKKUm! "0%Q;! JKK^DF! ! ,'+/! +/1)$#+! 6%! '#('/#)!<br />

+/'/$3!A$-#!CbY,D!+0+/#E+!+&6I!/&#0!I6(Q!2#+/!1+$%9!76(3#)!=#%/$-'/$6%!'+!6AA6+#)!/6!@+13/$6%B!<br />

2#3'1+#!67!&$9&#(!A(#++1(#!)(6A+!'%)!'331E1-'/$6%!67!I'/#(!$%!/&#!A$A$%9!1%)#(!+13/$6%F!!H=#%!<br />

+6;!E'%0!bY,!+0+/#E+!=#%/$-'/#!20!%#9'/$=#ZA(#++1(#!6%!/&#!36EA6+/!'%)!#T&'1+/!/&#!(#+1-/$%9!<br />

453<br />

!


!<br />

9'+#+! /&(619&! '! 2$67$-/#(! +0+/#E! C*$9F! _DF! :&#! ('/#! 67! '#('/$6%! (#L1$(#)! /6! A(#=#%/! '%'#(62$3!<br />

E#/'26-$+E!I$/&$%!/&#!36EA6+/!='($#+!I$/&!/&#!A(6)13/!2#$%9!36EA6+/#)!Cj##%#(;!#/F!'-F;!JKKR;!<br />

^SSS2;!^SSWDF!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

*$9!WF!b#('/#)!+/'/$3!A$-#;!1AZ7-6I!6%!<br />

'#('/$6%!+0+/#E!<br />

!<br />

*$9F! _F! b#('/#)! +/'/$3! A$-#;! )6I%Z7-6I!<br />

'#('/$6%!361A-#)!/6!2$67$-/#(F!<br />

!<br />

*$9!RF!N6=#(#)!'#('/#)!+/'/$3!A$-#!h6(#!N6EA6+/$%9!Y0+/#E!<br />

!<br />

[$%)(6I!)$E#%+$6%+!'(#!9#%#('--0!-$E$/#)!/6!^FW!E!&#$9&/!'%)!-#++!/&'%!US!E!-#%9/&!/6!2'-'%3#!<br />

'$(7-6I!'-6%9!/&#!A$-#;!+/'/$3!A(#++1(#!)(6A+;!'%)!7'%!A6I#(!(#L1$(#E#%/+F!!YA'3$%9!67!)13/+!$+!<br />

1+1'--0!36%/(6--#)!20!A$-#!&#$9&/!+$%3#!)13/!+A'3$%9!$+!'AA(6T$E'/#-0!#L1'-!/6!/&#!&#$9&/!67!/&#!<br />

A$-#F!b!2-63Q!'AA(6'3&!$+!67/#%!1+#)!/6!E'T$E$P#!1+#!67!+A'3#!C*$9F!W!f!_DF!,$A#!+$P$%9;!26/&!<br />

&#')#(! '%)! '#('/$6%! )13/;! '%)! &6-#! A-'3#E#%/! $%! /&#! '#('/$6%! )13/! '(#! 67/#%! 3($/$3'-! 76(!<br />

+133#++71-!6A#('/$6%!67!/&$+!+0+/#E!C"0%Q;!JKK^DF!!5EA(6A#(!)#+$9%!-#')+!/6!6=#(!=#%/$-'/$6%!67!<br />

/&#! A$-#! $%! 6%#! -63'/$6%! '%)! 1%)#(! =#%/$-'/$6%! CI$/&! '336EA'%0$%9! 6)6(+! '%)! -6I!<br />

)#36EA6+$/$6%!('/#D!$%!6/&#(!A-'3#+F!8'/3&$%9!A$-#!)#A/&!/6!E'/#($'-!'%)!E6$+/1(#!67!E'/#($'-!$+!<br />

3($/$3'-!76(!/&#!+133#++!67!/&$+!+0+/#E!CG'+!'%)!j##%#(;!JKKRDF!!<br />

:&#!E6+/!(#3#%/!/#3&%6-69$#+!1+$%9!/&$+!'AA(6'3&!&'=#!')'A/#)!1+$%9!'!A6(61+;!9#6/#T/$-#!36=#(!<br />

I&$3&! +&#)+! ('$%7'--;! 21/! '-+6! (#)13#+! 6)6(! 9#%#('/$6%! '+! 9'+#+! -#'=$%9! /&#! A$-#! #%361%/#(! '!<br />

2$67$-E!6%!/&#!36=#(F!!d%#!+13&!bY,!$+!E'(Q#/#)!1%)#(!%'E#!67!hd"H!+0+/#EF!!5%!/&$+!+0+/#E!<br />

E'/#($'-! $+! A(#ZE$T#);! A1/! 6=#(! '%! '#('/$6%! )13/;! 36=#(#)! '%)! /&#%! '#('/#)! C6%Z677! 2'+#)! 6%!<br />

/#EA#('/1(#D!76(!^Za!I##Q+F!:&#!36=#(!$+!/&#%!(#E6=#)!'%)!/&#!E'/#($'-!/1(%#)!'%)!A1/!$%/6!'!<br />

31($%9! A$-#F! b-/&619&! %6! A12-$+&#)! +/1)$#+! 6%! /&#! 1+#! 67! 9#6/#T/$-#! 36=#(+! 76(! 36EA6+/$%9!<br />

A61-/(0!&'=#!2##%!761%);!/&#(#!$+!+6E#!#=$)#%3#!/&'/!/&#+#!36=#(+!E'0!2#!#77#3/$=#!$%!(#/'$%$%9!<br />

%$/(69#%!$%!/&#!36EA6+/!C,'(Å!#/!'-;!^SSJDF!:&#!2$67$-E!/&'/!36--#3/+!6%!/&#!$%+$)#!+1(7'3#!67!/&#!<br />

9#6/#T/$-#!36=#(;!E'0!&#-A!/('A!+6E#!9'+#+;!$%3-1)$%9!'EE6%$'!CM4 U DF!b!+/1)0!67!+6-$)!)##A!<br />

-$//#(!C2#))$%9!'%)!E'%1(#D!7(6E!'!)'$(0!7'3$-$/0!$%)$3'/#)!/&'/!9#6/#T/$-#!36=#(+!E'0!(#)13#!<br />

%$/(69#%! -6++! 20! -$E$/$%9! M4 U ! #E$++$6%+! CY6EE#(;! ^SSJDF! ! [&$-#! 9#6/#T/$-#! 36=#(+! &'=#! /&#!<br />

A6/#%/$'-!/6!2#!'!36+/!#77#3/$=#!E#/&6)!76(!#%&'%3$%9!/&#!%$/(69#%!36%/#%/!67!36EA6+/#)!A61-/(0!<br />

-$//#(;!'))$/$6%'-!(#+#'(3&!$+!%##)#)!/6!#='-1'/#!$/+!#77$3'30F!<br />

!<br />

Turned Windrow!(Fig. 8, 9, 10) —!N6EA6+/$%9!E'/#($'-!$+!A-'3#)!$%!'!I$%)(6I!CA$-#D!'%)!$+!<br />

/1(%#)! '/! (#91-'(! +3&#)1-#+F! ! ,$-#! &#$9&/+! '(#! 9#%#('--0! -$E$/#)! /6! JFWZ^FWE! 2#3'1+#! 67! /&#!<br />

'2$-$/0! 67! #L1$AE#%/! /6! &'%)-#! E'/#($'-! '%)! A6(6+$/0! 36%+$)#('/$6%+F! HL1$AE#%/! ('%9#+! 7(6E!<br />

!<br />

454


!<br />

/('3/6(+!I$/&!213Q#/+!/6!A'0-6')#(+!'%)!7(6E!A1--!/0A#!/1(%#(+!&'%)-$%9!JFW!E!C&#$9&/D!T!^FW!E!<br />

CI$)/&D! I$%)(6I+! /6! +/('))-#! /1(%#(+! &'%)-$%9! ^FW! E! T! U! E! I$%)(6I+F! [$%)(6I! -#%9/&! $+!<br />

9#%#('--0!%6/!3($/$3'-;!21/!I$--!)#A#%)!6%!+$/#!-63'/$6%F!!:1(%#)!I$%)(6I!C:[D!+0+/#E+!&'=#!<br />

2##%!')6A/#)!/6!&'%)-#!E'%0!/0A#+!67!E'/#($'-+!+13&!'+!0'()!/($EE$%9+!'%)!3'//-#!E'%1(#F!<br />

N6EA6+/!A6(6+$/0!kUSp!$+!$EA6(/'%/!/6!E$%$E$P#!'%'#(62$3!36%)$/$6%+!+$%3#!I$%)(6I+;!'+!I$/&!<br />

+/'/$3! A$-#+;! )#A#%)! 6%! %'/1('-! 36%=#3/$6%! C3&$E%#0! #77#3/+D! /6! =#%/$-'/#! /&#! A$-#F! ! HT3#++$=#!<br />

A6(6+$/0! CkRSpD! &6I#=#(! 3'%! A(#=#%/! /&#! I$%)(6I! 7(6E! +#-7! &#'/$%9! C8$3&#-! #/! '-F;! ^SSaDF!!<br />

:1(%$%9! /&#! A$-#! 3'%! $%36(A6('/#! 6T09#%;! 21/! $7! /&#! A$-#! -'3Q+! A6(6+$/0;! /&#! 3#%/#(! 67! /&#!<br />

I$%)(6I!2#36E#+!'%'#(62$3!$%!'!E'//#(!67!E$%1/#+!Cj##%#(!#/!'-F;!^SSWDF!:1(%#)!I$%)(6I+!3'%!<br />

+177#(!7(6E!-'3Q!67!E6$+/1(#!$%!)(0!3-$E'/#+F!8'%0!/1(%#(+!)#+$9%#)!/6)'0!$%/(6)13#!I'/#(!2'3Q!<br />

$%/6!/&#!I$%)(6I!/6!E'$%/'$%!36%)$/$6%+!7'=6('2-#!76(!&$9&!('/#!36EA6+/$%9F!<br />

[$%)(6I! +0+/#E+! 67/#%! 9#%#('/#! +6E#! 6)6(+! #'(-0! $%! /&#! A(63#++! I$/&! &$9&-0! A1/(#+3$2-#!<br />

E'/#($'-F!!d%#!E#/&6)!/6!E$%$E$P#!6)6(!$+!/6!Q##A!/&#!A$-#!/#EA#('/1(#!2#-6I!W`6N!C8$--#(;!<br />

JKKUD;! I&$3&! 3'%! 2#! ! '336EA-$+&#)! 20! (#91-'/$%9! A$-#! +$P#;! E6$+/1(#! 36%/#%/! '%)! A6(6+$/0F!<br />

b%6/&#(!E#/&6)!$+!/6!3'A!/&#!A$-#+!I$/&!'!2$67$-/#(!E'/#($'-!/6!/('A!#+3'A$%9!6)6(+!'%)!)#-'0!<br />

/1(%$%9!/&#!I$%)(6I+!1%/$-!/&#!/#EA#('/1(#!67!/&#!&$9&!('/#!A&'+#!67!36EA6+/$%9!&'+!)#3-$%#)!/6!<br />

xW`6N!'%)!6T09#%!-#=#-+!&'=#!(#36=#(#)!$%!E6+/!(#9$6%+!67!/&#!A$-#F!<br />

?(6)$#!#/!'-F!C^SSSD!$%=#+/$9'/#)!+/'/$3!A$-#!36EA6+/$%9!76(!2(6$-#(!-$//#(F!!:&#0!'E#%)#)!2(6$-#(!<br />

-$//#(!I$/&!+'I)1+/!'%)!I66)3&$A+!C^OUOU!=X=D;!(#+A#3/$=#-0F!!5%$/$'-!E6$+/1(#!36%/#%/!I'+!a^p!<br />

'%)!NXM!JaF!!,$-#!+&'A#!I'+!+#E$Z3$(31-'(!I$/&!'!2'+#!I$)/&!67!U!E!'%)!&#$9&/!67!JFW!EF!!:&#!<br />

A$-#!I'+!1%36=#(#)!/&(619&61/!/&#!+/1)0!'%)!I'+!/1(%#)!#=#(0!JS!)'0+F!!:&#!:[!(#'3&#)!&$9&!<br />

/#EA#('/1(#+! CkWU 6 ND! 21/! )(6AA#)! '7/#(! #'3&! /1(%! 76(! +&6(/! A#($6)+! 67! /$E#;! A6++$2-#! )1#! /6!<br />

+E'--!A$-#!&#$9&/F!!!:&#!A$-#!366-#)!/6!'E2$#%/!'7/#(!JSS!)'0+F!!.6-1E#!)(6AA#)!/6!WKp!'7/#(!K!<br />

E6%/&+!67!36EA6+/$%9F!*$%'-!E6$+/1(#!36%/#%/!I'+!^^p!'%)!M!JFSJpF!!5/!$+!#+/$E'/#)!2'+#)!6%!<br />

)'/'!A(6=$)#)!R_p!67!$%$/$'-!M!I'+!-6+/F!5%/#(A(#/$%9!(#+1-/+!67!/&$+!+/1)0!+199#+/!61/+$)#!:[!<br />

36EA6+/$%9!67!2(6$-#(!-$//#(!I61-)!%6/!-#')!/6!'!)(0;!+/'2-#!A(6)13/!I$/&!'!&$9&!M!-#=#-;!'%)!<br />

-$Q#-0!I61-)!&'=#!-$E$/#)!E'(Q#/$%9!6AA6(/1%$/0!'+!'!&$9&!='-1#!A(6)13/F!<br />

!<br />

*$9!`F!:1(%#)!I$%)(6I!1+$%9!A1--!/0A#!<br />

/1(%#(F!<br />

!<br />

*$9F! KF! Y$)#! )$+3&'(9#! I$%)(6I! /1(%#(F!<br />

C8$3&#-;!^SJJD!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

*$9F!JSF!Y#-7!A(6A#--#)!+/('))-#!/1(%#(F!CN6(%#--!


!<br />

!<br />

In-vessel (Fig 11, 12, 13) —! 5%Z=#++#-! +0+/#E+! '(#! 67/#%! )#+$9%#)! /6! %6/! 6%-0! '#('/#! /&#!<br />

36EA6+/! 21/! '-+6! E#3&'%$3'--0! /1(%! $/F! 4$+/6($3'--0;! $/! &'+! $%3-1)#)! 1A($9&/! +$-6+;! 7-'/!<br />

(#3/'%91-'(!+/(13/1(#+!I$/&!2'0+;!+/(13/1(#+!I$/&!I'-Q$%9!7-66(+;!'%)!6/&#(+F!4'19!CJKKUD!9$=#+!<br />

)#/'$-#)! )#+3($A/$6%+! 67! $%Z=#++#-! +0+/#E+! /&'/! &'=#! 2##%! 21$-/! '%)! 1+#)! 76(! 36EA6+/$%9F!<br />

dA#('/$%9!A($%3$A-#+!67!/&#+#!+0+/#E+!&'=#!2##%!I#--!)#7$%#)!20!4'19!CJKKUD!'%)!j##%#(;!#/!<br />

'-F! CJKKU;! ^SSWDF! ! b! (667#)! =#(+$6%! 67! /&$+! +0+/#E! $+! /&#! /1%%#-! +0+/#E;! I&$3&! 36EA-#/#-0!<br />

36%/(6-+!/&#!A'/&!67!#T&'1+/!'$(!-#'=$%9!/&#!+0+/#E;!21/!)6#+!%6/!&'=#!'!/1(%$%9!+0+/#E!C4'19;!<br />

JKKUDF! 5%Z=#++#-! +0+/#E+! 3'%! 2#! 1+#)! 76(! '--! /0A#+! 67! A(#A'(#)! E'/#($'-+;! '-/&619&! A'(/$3-#!<br />

+$P#!$+!3($/$3'-;!'%)!&'=#!/&#!3'A'2$-$/$#+!67!36%/(6--$%9!#E$++$6%+F!!b%!'AA(6'3&!1+#)!/6!(#)13#!<br />

36+/+!I$/&!+13&!/#3&%6-690!$+!/6!1+#!/I6!36EA6+/$%9!+0+/#E+O!JD!'%!$%Z=#++#-!+0+/#E!76(!RZ^J!<br />

)'0+!CA&'+#!JD!'%)!'%!'#('/#)!A$-#!1%/$-!E'/#($'-!$+!/&(619&!/&#!+#36%)'(0!A&'+#!67!36EA6+/$%9F!!<br />

5%Z=#++#-!+0+/#E+!&'=#!&$9&!7$T#)!'%)!6A#('/$%9!36+/!'%)!'(#!+#-#3/#)!2'+#)!6%!E'/#($'-+!/6!2#!<br />

36EA6+/#);!+$/#!(#L1$(#E#%/+!'%)!A(63#++$%9!36+/!A#(!1%$/!67!A(6)13/F!!<br />

j##%#(! #/! '-F! C^SS^D! +/1)$#)! /&#! '#('/#)! /1(%#)! I$%)(6I! Cb:[D! +0+/#E! -63'/#)! '/! /&#! 8')!<br />

"$=#(!7'3$-$/0!67!/&#!G'0-'0!H99!*'(E;![#+/!8'%+7$#-);!d&$6F!!:&#!7'(E!6A#('/#+!'!JF_!E$--$6%!<br />

2$()!3'9#)!-'0#(!7'3$-$/0!76(!/&#!A(6)13/$6%!67!3&$3Q#%!#99+F!!:&#!2$()+!'(#!&61+#)!$%!'!/6/'-!67!`!<br />

21$-)$%9+;!a!67!I&$3&!'(#!67!/&#!)##A!A$/!)#+$9%!I$/&!JWS;SSS!2$()+!#'3&F!!:&#!6/&#(!a!21$-)$%9+;!<br />

&61+$%9!^WS;SSS!2$()+!#'3&!$%36(A6('/#!'!2#-/!36%=#06(!+0+/#E!76(!(#E6=$%9!E'%1(#!#=#(0!U!<br />

)'0+F! ! 8'%1(#! 6%! /&#! 2#-/! $+! )#-$=#(#)! /6! ^! +#A'('/#! 21$-)$%9+! I&#(#! $/! $+! 36EA6+/#)! 1+$%9!<br />

Y'-E#/!36EA6+/#(+!CG$#/P#%2'3&;!h#(E'%0D!$%/6!'!)(0!A(6)13/!+1$/'2-#!76(!&$9&!='-1#!E'(Q#/+F!!<br />

:&#!36EA6+/$%9!21$-)$%9+!36%+$+/!67!'!J^Z-'%#!36EA6+/!21$-)$%9;!_^!E!T!JaJ!E;!I$/&!+/6('9#!<br />

'%)!`!#T&'1+/!7'%+!'%)!'!_Z-'%#!36EA6+/!21$-)$%9;!UJ!E!T!JaJ!E!I$/&!+/6('9#!'%)!a!#T&'1+/!<br />

7'%+F!dA#('/$6%'--0;!1%Z'E#%)#)!A61-/(0!E'%1(#!CxWWp!E6$+/1(#!(#L1$(#)D!$+!A$-#)!'/!/&#!$%A1/!<br />

#%)!67!'%!'#('/#)!$%Z=#++#-!36EA6+/$%9!+0+/#E!I$/&!'!/1(%#(F!:&#!7$(+/!JXU!67!/&#!2'0!$+!'#('/#);!<br />

1+$%9!'%!6%Z677!7'%!36%/(6-F!!8'/#($'-!$%!'!-'%#!$+!/1(%#)!#=#(0!U!)'0+!6=#(!'!W_Z)'0!A#($6)!'%)!<br />

E6=#)!_!E#/#(+!/6I'()!/&#!61/A1/!#%)!67!/&#!36EA6+/$%9!2'0!)1($%9!#'3&!/1(%F!b7/#(!J`!/1(%+!<br />

/&#! E'/#($'-! -#'=#+! /&#! 36EA6+/#(! '%)! $+! +/6(#)! 1%/$-! E'(Q#/#)F! M4 U ! -#=#-+! $%! /&#! 36EA6+/!<br />

21$-)$%9!E#'+1(#)!7(6E!KSZJ_S!AAE;!)#A#%)$%9!6%!#T&'1+/!7'%!6A#('/$6%F!,(6A#(/$#+!67!-'0#(!<br />

E'%1(#!#%/#($%9!/&#!+0+/#E!I#(#!aKZWUp!E6$+/1(#;!USFUZUSFRp!'+&;!WFKZWFRp!M;!'%)!WFSZ_FSU!<br />

NXMF!!,(6A#(/$#+!67!36EA6+/!-#'=$%9!/&#!+0+/#E!I#(#!JSZJ`Zp!E6$+/1(#;!UaFJZURF^p!'+&;!WF_Z<br />

_F^p!M;!'%)!WZWF`!NXMF!G(0!E'//#(!-6++!67!/&#!A61-/(0!E'%1(#!I'+!JSZJ`F_p!'%)!M!-6++!I'+!<br />

J^F^ZJWpF!?'+#)!6%!/&#!A(6A#(/$#+!67!/&#!A61-/(0!E'%1(#!2#$%9!36EA6+/#);!/&$+!+0+/#E!+&61-)!<br />

36EA6+/!'%)!)(0!2(6$-#(!-$//#(!$%!'!+$E$-'(!7'+&$6%;!9$=$%9!'!A(6)13/!I$/&!`SZKSp!67!/&#!6($9$%'-!<br />

)(0! E'//#(;! E6$+/1(#! 36%/#%/! 67! JSZJ`p;! '%)! '! M! -#=#-! kUF_p! C'++1E#+! M! 67! aFUp! $%!<br />

-$//#(X3'Q#DF!!<br />

!<br />

*$9F! JJF! 5%! =#++#-! I$/&! 76(3#)!<br />

'#('/$6%! '%)! /1(%$%9F! C"0%Q;!<br />

JKK^D!<br />

!<br />

*$9F! J^F! N6EA6+/! 21$-)$%9! f! /1(%$%9!<br />

E'3&$%#! r! G'0-'0! *'(E+F! [$%)(6I+!<br />

'(#!76(3#)!'#('/#)!'%)!/1(%#)F!<br />

!<br />

456


!<br />

!<br />

!!<br />

*$9!JUF!*$%$+&#)!36EA6+/!'/!G'0-'0!*'(E+F!!N6EA6+/#)!E'/#($'-!JSZ^Sp!E6$+/1(#!'%)!9('%1-'(!<br />

%'/1(#!<br />

Conclusions<br />

G#+$9%!67!36EA6+/$%9!+0+/#E+!/6!&'%)-#!2(6$-#(! -$//#(!(#L1$(#+!'!+0+/#E!3'A'2-#!67!&'%)-$%9;!<br />

)(0$%9;!'%)!A(#+#(=$%9!M!76(!'!E$T!I$/&!E6$+/1(#!67!^SZaSp!'%)!NXM!xJWF!!"#+1-/+!&'=#!2##%!<br />

A(#+#%/#);! '-6%9! I$/&! Q$%#/$3! )'/'! 6%! 36EA6+/$%9! E'/#($'-+! /&'/! +1AA6(/+! ('/$6%'-! )#+$9%! '%)!<br />

6A#('/$6%!67!36EA6+/$%9!+0+/#E+!76(!2(6$-#(!-$//#(F!!G#36EA6+$/$6%!('/#+!76(!+13&!E'/#($'-+!67!<br />

xSFSa! )'0 ZJ ! 361-)! 2#! #TA#3/#)! 21/! '(#! E6(#! -$Q#-0! /6! 2#! xSFSJ! )'0 ZJ F! G#+$9%! '$(7-6I! 76(! '%!<br />

'#('/#)!36EA6+/$%9!+0+/#E!I61-)!2#!xJ!E U !)'0 ZJ !Q9 )E ZJ !'/!/&#!+/'(/!67!/&#!36EA6+/$%9!A(63#++F!<br />

5%/#(E$//#%/! '#('/$6%! $+! (#36EE#%)#)! /6! E$%$E$P#! M! -6++#+F! "#+1-/+! 67! A'+/! +/1)$#+! 6%!<br />

36EA6+/$%9! 1%Z'E#%)#)! A61-/(0! E'%1(#! '%)X6(! 2(6$-#(! -$//#(! $%)$3'/#! '%! '#('/#);! /1(%#)!<br />

I$%)(6I!$%!'%!#%3-6+#)!21$-)$%9!I$/&!&$9&!M4 U !-#=#-+!3'%!A(6)13#!'!A(6)13/!/&'/!I61-)!2#!)(0!<br />

'%)!(#/'$%!E6+/!67!/&#!6($9$%'-!MF!!!*6(!A61-/(0!-$//#(X3'Q#;!/&#!7$%$+&#)!A(6)13/!I61-)!&'=#!JSZ<br />

J`p!E6$+/1(#!'%)!UF_p!MF!!<br />

!<br />

Acknowledgements<br />

!Y'-'($#+! '%)! (#+#'(3&! +1AA6(/! I#(#! A(6=$)#)! 20!


!<br />

36EA6+/$%9!A(63#++F!!,'(/!5!Z!HTA#($E#%/'-!+/1)$#+F!!:('%+'3/$6%+!67!bYbHF!!aRCWDO!J_KRZJRS`F!<br />

H-I#--;!GF!gF;!4F8F!j##%#(;!GFYF!N'(#0!'%)!,F,F!Y3&-'QF!!JKK`F!!!N6EA6+/$%9!1%'E#%)#)!3&$3Q#%!<br />

E'%1(#F!!N6EA6+/!Y3$#%3#!f!


!<br />

8'%'9#E#%/!76(!b9($31-/1(#F!!?(66E7$#-);!NdF!Y#A/#E2#(F!bYb?H!,12-$3'/$6%!M6F!RSJ,SKSR3)F!!<br />

"0%Q;!"F!C#)FD!JKK^F!!d%!7'(E!36EA6+/$%9!&'%)266QF!!M"bHYZWaF!!N66A#('/$=#!HT/#%+$6%!Y#(=$3#;!<br />

M6(/&#'+/!"#9$6%'-!b9($31-/1('-!H%9$%##($%9!Y#(=$3#;!N6(%#--!


!<br />

Assessing Poultry Welfare, Patholgy And Disease Using Outcome Measures<br />

!<br />

bF!?1//#(I6(/&!<br />


!<br />

'(#;!$9%6(#)F!!5%)##);!$/!$+!$%3(#'+$%9-0!(#369%$+#)!/&'/!+#-#3/$=#!2(##)$%9!$+!'!A6I#(71-!/66-!76(!<br />

'--#=$'/$%9!I#-7'(#!A(62-#E+!C]6%#+;!JKKRm!h('%)$%;!JKK`D!'%)!/&'/!'AA(6A($'/#!#%=$(6%E#%/'-!<br />

#%($3&E#%/;!$%3-1)$%9!A6+$/$=#!&1E'%!36%/'3/;!3'%!)('E'/$3'--0!#%&'%3#!I#-7'(#!C8#%3&!JKKam!<br />

4#E+I6(/&!f!N6-#E'%!JKK`m!]6%#+!^SSJDF!<br />

!<br />

HT$+/$%9!7'(E!'++1('%3#!+/'%)'()+!'(#!2#9$%%$%9!/6!'+Q!t'%$E'-!3#%/#(#)c!L1#+/$6%+;!'%)!$/!$+!<br />

'AA'(#%/! /&'/! (#A#/$/$=#! (#+61(3#! 2'+#)! '++#++E#%/! 3'%! 7'$-! /6! 71--0! '%+I#(! L1#+/$6%+! '261/!<br />

'%$E'-!I#-7'(#Fb!%1E2#(!67!31((#%/!'9($31-/1('-!+/'%)'()+!$%!1+#!$%!H1(6A#!1+#!2'+$3!tI#-7'(#!<br />

'++#++E#%/!/66-+c!$%!/&'/!/&#0!$%36(A6('/#!/&#!$%+A#3/6(+!=$#I!'%)!$%/#(A(#/'/$6%!67!/&#!+#=#($/0!<br />

67!$++1#+!62+#(=#)!C?1//#(I6(/&!'/("#!^SS`;!.#$++$#('/("#(^SS`DF!Y6E#!#T'EA-#+!67!'++#++E#%/!<br />

+/'%)'()+!3'%!2#!761%)!'/m!<br />

!<br />

hgd?bghb,!NNN,!CN6%/(6-!A6$%/+!'%)!36EA-$'%3#3($/#($'D!76(!N'//-#!Cf+&##AD;!<br />

)'$(036I+;!A$9+!'%)!A61-/(0!&//AOXXIIIF9-62'-9'AF6(9!<br />

!<br />

"#):('3/6(*'(Eb++1(#)N&$3Q#%!,(6)13/$6%!C":*bXbN,D!!!!<br />

&//AOXXIIIF'++1(#)3&$3Q#%F6(9F1QX3&$3Q#%!<br />

!<br />

[$/&$%/&#+#! +/'%)'()+;! /&#! E'e6($/0! 67! /&#! +/'%)'()! (#L1$(#E#%/+! '(#! I($//#%! '+! +&6(/!<br />

)#+3($A/$6%+!67!I&'/$+(#L1$(#)!C3-'1+#+D;!'%)!'(#!'-E6+/!'--!!t7'(E!(#36()c!6(!t(#+61(3#c!2'+#)!<br />

C"?8DF! 46I#=#(;! +6E#! 67! /&#! #T$+/$%9! +/'%)'()! t3-'1+#+c! '(#! =#(0! 3-6+#! /6! 2#$%9! '%$E'-!<br />

2'+#)Cb?8D!/66-+!Z!76(!#T'EA-#!<br />

!<br />

23(/6'(&9$-'0(%5(-40)3(5%9&)()'")(%&("0047"#("/(/6'(3#"9


!<br />

'9'$%+/! 3(1#-/0! /6! I#-7'(#! '%);! +#36%);! 7(6E! I#-7'(#! /6! -$7#! L1'-$/0! C?1--#(f! 86(($+;! ^SS^m!<br />

?1--#(;!^SSKDF!<br />

!<br />

What Should We ‘Measure’ to Assess Welfare?<br />

b%$E'-+! )$77#(! $%! /&#$(! #TA#($#%3#;! /#EA#('E#%/! '%)! /&#! I'0! $%! I&$3&! /&#$(! 9#%#/$3! E'Q#1A!<br />

$%/#('3/+! I$/&! /&#$(! #%=$(6%E#%/F! :&#! $%7-1#%3#! 67! E'%'9#E#%/! '%)! /&#! +/63QA#(+6%! 3'%!'-+6!<br />

)('E'/$3'--0!$%7-1#%3#!%6/!6%-0!tA(6)13/$=$/0c!E#'+1(#+;!21/!'-+6!/&#!'%$E'-+!#TA#($#%3#!67!'!<br />

A'(/$31-'(!+$/1'/$6%F!:&1+!(#+61(3#Z2'+#)!E#'+1(#+!C"?8+!-$Q#!/0A#!67!&61+$%9;!'--63'/$6%!67!<br />

(#+61(3#+;!+/63Q$%9!)#%+$/0!#/3D!6(!E'%'9#E#%/Z2'+#)!E#'+1(#+!C-$Q#!2(##)$%9!+/('/#9$#+;!&#'-/&!<br />

A-'%+!#/3D!E'0!2#!'!A66(!91'('%/##!67!&$9&!-#=#-+!67!'%$E'-!I#-7'(#!$%!'!A'(/$31-'(!+$/1'/$6%F!<br />

Y6E#! +$%9-#! b%$E'-! ?'+#)! 8#'+1(#+! Cb?8c+D! &'=#! 2##%! +199#+/#)! '+! 2#$%9! 3'A'2-#! 67!<br />

A(6=$)$%9!'%)!$%/#9('/#)!'++#++E#%/!67!'%$E'-!I#-7'(#!$%3-1)$%9m!36(/$36+/#(6$)+;!'31/#!A&'+#!<br />

A(6/#$%+;! '%)! -6%9#=$/0! C41(%$Q;! JKKSm! ?'(%#//! '%)! 4#E+I6(/&;! JKKSm! h##(+( '/( "#?;! ^SSUDF!!<br />

46I#=#(;! %6%#! 67! /&#+#! +$%9-#! E#'+1(#+! 3'%! 36=#(! '--! /&#! )$E#%+$6%+! 67! I#-7'(#F! 5/! +##E!<br />

A(62'2-#!/&'/!+#=#('-!E#'+1(#+!'(#!%#3#++'(0!/6!62/'$%!'!36EA(#&#%+$=#!=$#I!67!'%0!A'(/$31-'(!<br />

'%$E'-c+!I#-7'(#!CG'IQ$%+;!JKKSm![#2+/#(;!JKKRm!"1//#(;!JKK`DF!"#369%$+$%9!/&#!)$77$31-/$#+!67!<br />

t+$%9-#!E#'+1(#!'AA(6'3&#+c;!9(61A#)!E#'+1(#+!&'=#!2##%!1+#)!/6!')=$+#!7'(E#(+!CYÉ(#%+#%('/(<br />

"#?;!^SSJD;!$%!t2('%)#)c!I#-7'(#!3#(/$7$3'/$6%!+3&#E#+!C#F9F!*(##)6E!*66)!Y3&#E#DC8'$%('/("#?;!<br />

^SSJm!8'$%!'/("#?E^SSUD;!'%)!/6!36EA'(#!+0+/#E+!/6!A(6=$)#!$%76(E'/$6%!)1($%9!!/&#!3(#'/$6%!67!!<br />

%#I! -#9$+-'/$6%! C?('3Q#( '/( "#?;! ^SS^D! ! '%)!/6!3&#3Q!36EA-$'%3#!I$/&!-#9$+-'/$=#!(#L1$(#E#%/+!<br />

Cj##-$%9!'%)!Y=#)2#(9;!JKKKDF<br />

,('3/$3'--0! +A#'Q$%9;! $/! $+! E'0! 2#! A6++$2-#! /6! 36E2$%#! "?8+! '%)! b?8+F! *6(! #T'EA-#;! $7!<br />

'%$E'-+!'(#!-'E#!C'++#++#)!1+$%9!'%!b?8D!$/!E'0!2#!A6++$2-#!/6!A(#)$3/!-'E#%#++!$7!/&#!-$//#(!<br />

36%)$/$6%! $+! A66(! C'%! "?8DF! 46I#=#(;! /&#! A&$-6+6A&0! 67! b?8! 2'+#)! '++#++E#%/! $+! /&'/;! $7!<br />

/&#(#!$+!E#'+1(#!7(6E!/&#!'%$E'-!I&$3&!71-7$-+!/&#!36%)$/$6%+!)#+3($2#)!'26=#!CA('3/$3'-;!='-$);!<br />

(#A#'/'2-#;!(621+/D!/&#%!/&$+!+&61-)!2#!1+#)!$%!A(#7#(#%3#!/6!/&#!"?8!'-6%#!V!2#3'1+#!'!9$=#%!<br />

-$//#(!36%)$/$6%!E'0!2#!=#(0!966)!76(!6%#!'%$E'-!21/!=#(0!A66(!76(!'%6/&#(F!!<br />

!<br />

:&#!+6(/+!67!L1#+/$6%+!I&$3&;!$%!9#%#('-;!'(#!2#$%9!'+Q#)!'(#m!(<br />

- b(#!/&#!'%$E'-+!A(6A#(-0!7#)!'%)!+1AA-$#)!I$/&!I'/#(Ç!!<br />

- b(#!/&#!'%$E'-+!A(6A#(-0!&61+#)Ç!!<br />

- b(#!/&#!'%$E'-+!&#'-/&0Ç!!<br />

- N'%!/&#!'%$E'-+!#TA(#++!'!('%9#!67!2#&'=$61(+!'%)!#E6/$6%'-!+/'/#+Ç!!<br />

d7!361(+#;!/&#+#!L1#+/$6%+!L1$/#!3-6+#-0!(#+#E2-#!/&#!#-#E#%/+!67!/&#!7$=#!7(##)6E+!C?('E2#--;!<br />

JK_WD;!'%)![#-7'(#n1'-$/0!C?-6Q&1$+'/("#?E!^SSUD;!/&(619&!36--'26('/$6%!2#/I##%!aJ!$%+/$/1/#+!<br />

'3(6++! H1(6A#;! 21$-/! 6%! /&#! /&#+#! A($%3$A-#+! /6! )#=#-6A! 6%Z7'(E! '%)! +-'19&/#(! '++#++E#%/!<br />

+0+/#E+! /6! '))(#++! /&#! Q#0! '(#'+! 67! 7##)$%9;! &61+$%9;! &#'-/&! '%)! )$+#'+#! '%)! 2#&'=$61(F!<br />

[#-7'(#n1'-$/0! &'+! 3(#'/#)! 9(61A#)! '++#++E#%/! E#'+1(#+! C:'2-#! JD! 76(! A$9+;! A61-/(0! '%)!<br />

3'//-#! I&$3&! '))(#++! /I#-=#! &#'-/&! '%)! I#-7'(#! 3($/#($'! C+6E#I&'/! -$Q#! /&#! I#--! Q%6I%! 7$=#!<br />

7(##)6E+D;!'%)!&'+!/#+/#)!/&#E!6%!'!-'(9#!%1E2#(!67!7'(E+!'3(6++!H1(6A#F!!<br />

Discussion - How Could An Assessment B Used To Affect Pathology, Disease And Animal<br />

Welfare Outcomes?<br />

:&#(#!'(#!'!%1E2#(!67!t-#=#-+c!/6!'AA-$3'/$6%!67!'%!b?8F!*$(+/;!'!+/'%)'()$+#)!)#+3($A/$6%!$+!<br />

%##)#);!/&#%!'!)#+3($A/$6%!67!/&#!A('3/$3'-!'AA-$3'/$6%!67!/&#!E#/&6)!'%)!'%0!-$%Q#)!"?8+!$+!<br />

(#L1$(#);!/&#%;!7$%'--0;!/&#!I'0+!$%!I&$3&!/&#!$%76(E'/$6%!/&'/!$+!A(6)13#)!7(6E!/&#!1+#!67!/&#!<br />

b?8+!'%)!"?8+!3'%!2#!1+#)!/6!A(6E6/#!'%)!+1AA6(/!E'%'9#E#%/!)#3$+$6%+!'%)!A('3/$3#+!/6!<br />

3(#'/#!$EA(6=#E#%/+!$%!I#-7'(#F!<br />

Step 1, Measure (ABMs and RBMs) <br />

Step 2, Analyse risk factors <br />

Step 3, Inform (producer, purchaser)<br />

Step 4, Support management decisions to create improvements in welfare<br />

!<br />

462


!<br />

:'2-#!JF!:&#!A($%3$A-#+!'%)!3($/#($'!/&'/!'(#!'!2'+$+!76(!/&#![#-7'(#!n1'-$/0Ñ!A(6/636-+!<br />

[#-7'(#!A($%3$A-#+ ! [#-7'(#!3($/#($'! !<br />

h66)!7##)$%9 ! J! b2+#%3#!67!!A(6-6%9#)!&1%9#(!!<br />

^! b2+#%3#!67!!A(6-6%9#)!/&$(+/!!<br />

U! N6E76(/!'(61%)!(#+/$%9!<br />

h66)!&61+$%9! ! a! :&#(E'-!36E76(/!<br />

W! H'+#!67!E6=#E#%/!!<br />

_! b2+#%3#!67!$%e1($#+!<br />

h66)!&#'-/& ! R! b2+#%3#!67!)$+#'+#!!<br />

`! b2+#%3#!67!A'$%!$%)13#)!20!E'%'9#E#%/!A(63#)1(#+!<br />

K! HTA(#++$6%!67!+63$'-!2#&'=$61(+!!<br />

bAA(6A($'/#! JS HTA(#++$6%!67!6/&#(!2#&'=$61(+!!<br />

2#&'=$61( ! JJ h66)!&1E'%Z'%$E'-!(#-'/$6%+&$A!<br />

J^ b2+#%3#!67!7#'(71-%#++!<br />

!<br />

d%#! 67! /&#! +$9%$7$3'%/'$E+! 67! /&#! [#-7'(#n1'-$/0A(6e#3/I'+! /6! )#=#-6A/66-+! 76(! E6%$/6($%9!<br />

'%$E'-!I#-7'(#7(6E7'(E!/6!+-'19&/#(F!!:&#+#/66-+3'%2#1+#)!76(!'!%1E2#(!67!A1(A6+#+m!<br />

:6!'--6I!$%+A#3/$6%!'%)!+36($%9!67!7'(E+;!/6!$%76(E36%+1E#(+!'261/!/&#!I#-7'(#+/'/1+!<br />

67!/&#!'%$E'-+7(6EI&$3&/&#0210A(6)13/+F!!<br />

:6!9$=#!t')=$3#c!2'3Q!/6!/&#!7'(E#(2'+#)!6%!/&#!)'/'!36--#3/#)!6%!/&#!7'(EF!<br />

:&#! '++#++E#%/A(6/636-+361-)! ! CA#(&'A+D2#1+#)! 20! +/'/1/6(0! 26)$#+! $%!<br />

/&#$('++#++E#%/!67!7'(E+F!<br />

!<br />

Measure! Z! *66/! A')! )#(E'/$/$+;! G#+3($A/$6%! Z! *66/! A')! )#(E'/$/$+! C6(! A6)6)#(E'/$/$+D! $+! '!<br />

36%/'3/! )#(E'/$/$+! 761%)! 6%! /&#! +Q$%! 67! /&#! 766/;! E6+/! 36EE6%-0! 6%! /&#! 3#%/('-! A');! 21/!<br />

+6E#/$E#+!'-+6!6%!/&#!/6#+F!:&#!+Q$%!$+!/1(%#)!)'(Q!20!36%/'3/!I$/&!-$//#(!'%)!)##A!+Q$%!-#+$6%+!<br />

3'%!(#+1-/F!:&#!+36($%9!+3'-#!C*$91(#!JD!'--6I+!'%!'++#++E#%/!67!/&#!+#=#($/0!67!/&#+#!-#+$6%+Fb/!<br />

-#'+/!JSS!2(6$-#(!3&$3Q#%!A#(!7-63Q!+&61-)!2#!'++#++#)!C*$91(#+!^!'%)!UDO!!JS!2$()+!/'Q#%!7(6E!JS!<br />

'(#'+!67!/&#!&61+#!$%3-1)$%9!^!'(#'+!-63'/#)!%#'(!/6!)($%Q#(+;!^!-63'/#)!'(#'+!%#'(!/6!7##)#(+;!U!<br />

'(#'+!-63'/#)!%#'(!'!I'--;!U!'(#'+!-63'/#)!'I'0!7(6E!)($%Q#(+!'%)!7##)#(+!C(#+/$%9!'(#'DF!b/!/&#!<br />

+-'19&/#(!A-'%/!$/!$+!A6++$2-#!/6!+36(#!'!-'(9#!%1E2#(!67!7##/!'+!/&#!2$()+!A'++!6%!/&#!+-'19&/#(!<br />

-$%#F!57!/&#!-$%#!+A##)!$+!J^S!2$()+!A#(!E$%1/#;!/&#%!62+#(=$%9!76(!JS!E$%1/#+!I$--!#%'2-#!+36($%9!<br />

67!J^SS!2$()+!1+$%9!/&#!+'E#!+36($%9!+3'-#!'+!1+#)!6%!7'(EF!!<br />

!<br />

Step 1, Measure <br />

!<br />

80"4&4&


!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

S! J! ^!<br />

!<br />

U! a!<br />

?1//#(I6(/&;!'&&4&'&("++0%I4$"/'#,(AB(-40)3(4&("&("0'"(%5(/6'(6%93'?((<br />

J40)3(36%9#)(&%/(-'(6'0)')(4&/%(/6'(+'&(<br />

86'(+'&(36%9#)(-'(+#".')(K94'/#,("0%9&)("(


!<br />

!<br />

Figure 3. >"+'0(-"3')(0'.%0)4&4.;( 9+( 4&)474)9"#( -40)3( ."0'59##,( "&)( 3.%0'( /6'$( M( +#".'(<br />

/6'$(%9/34)'(%5(/6'(+'&?((<br />

*0'"/'("(34$+#'(/"-9#"/4%&(%5((/6'(&9$-'03(%5(-40)3(3.%0')(4&(<br />

'".6(5%%/(+")(."/'


!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

^D<br />

UD<br />

!<br />

aD<br />

+6E#! 361%/($#+! '(#! %6I! 2#9$%%$%9! /6! 7631+! 6%! 766/! A')! &#'-/&! '+! '! E'(Q#(! 76(!<br />

36EA'%0!I#-7'(#!A#(76(E'%3#F!!<br />

8'Q#! 36EA'($+6%+! 2#/I##%! t966)c! '%)! tA66(c! 7'(E+! CI$/&! (#+A#3/! /6! 766/! A')+D!<br />

I$/&$%! /&#! 36EA'%0! /6! &#-A! $)#%/$70! E'%'9#E#%/;! &61+#! #%=$(6%E#%/;! 7##)$%9;!<br />

E#)$3'/$6%;!+/63QE'%+&$A!'%)!9#%6/0A#!7'3/6(+!I&$3&!)$77#(!2#/I##%!/&#+#!7'(E+F!<br />

5%=#+/$9'/#!/&#!1+#!67!I'/#(!$%!)$77#(#%/!7'(E+!V!7'(E+!I$/&!$%3(#'+#)!I'/#(!1+#!A#(!<br />

2$()! C$%! #L1'-! I#'/&#(! 36%)$/$6%+D! E'0! &'=#! +0+/#E'/$3! A(62-#E+! I$/&! -#'Q$%9!<br />

)($%Q#(+F! YE'--! 'E61%/+! 67! I'/#(! -#'Q#)! 3&(6%$3'--0! $%/6! /&#! -$//#(! 3'%! +#=#(#-0!<br />

)'E'9#!/&#!E'%'9#E#%/!67!-$//#(!'%)!766/!A')!&#'-/&F!<br />

N'((0! 61/! '%! $%=#+/$9'/$6%! 67! /&#! 2'3/#($6-69$3'-! A'/&6-69$#+! -$%Q#)! I$/&! 766/! A')!<br />

)#(E'/$/$+! '%)! $)#%/$70! I&#/&#(! /&#+#! 2'3/#($'! 3'%! 6($9$%'/#! $%! /&#! &'/3&#(0;! /&#!<br />

/('%+A6(/'/$6%!6(!20!-'A+#+!$%!7'(E!2$6+#31($/0F!<br />

!<br />

Step 3, Inform and Step 4, Support management decisions to create improvements in<br />

welfare<br />

:&#!7'(E#(!3'%!2#!$%76(E#)!'261/!/&#!#T/#%)!67!766/!A')!)#(E'/$/$+!6%!&$+!7'(E;!'%);!I$/&!/$E#;!<br />

'%)! '7/#(! '%'-0+$+;! '! A'//#(%! 67! ($+Q! 7'3/6(+! E'0! #E#(9#! I&$3&! '--6I! &$E! /6! E'Q#! )#3$+$6%+!<br />

I&$3&! 3'%! (#)13#! /&$+F! *'3/6(+! I&$3&;! $%! (#'-! 7'(E! #TA#($#%3#;! &'=#! 2##%! +&6I%! /6! 2#! ($+Q!<br />

7'3/6(+!76(!-'E#%#++!$%3-1)#m!<br />

h(6I/&!('/#;!/&#!'9#!67!/&#!2$()+!'/!+-'19&/#(;!/&#!1+#!67!I&6-#!3#(#'-+!$%!/&#!)$#/;!/&#!/0A#!67!<br />

7##);!/&#!L1'-$/0!67!2$6+#31($/0!E#'+1(#+;!-$//#(!36%)$/$6%!C'%!$EA6(/'%/!7'3/6(D;!/&#!9#%6/0A#!67!<br />

/&#!2$()+F!b-+6;!/&#!9#%)#(!67!/&#!2$()+;!-#=#-+!67!7##)!(#+/($3/$6%;!/&#!-$9&/$%9!A'//#(%!'%)!-$9&/!<br />

5%/#%+$/0;! 2$()! '3/$=$/0! -#=#-+! '%)! /&#! +/63Q$%9! )#%+$/0! &'=#;! $%! (#'-! #T'EA-#+! 67! 7'(E+;! 2##%!<br />

'-/#(#)!'%!E'%$A1-'/#)!/6!36%/(6-!-#=#-+!67!766/!A')!)#(E'/$/$+!$%!/&#!3&$3Q#%+F!!<br />

!<br />

d%3#!'--!/&#!E#'+1(#+!&'=#!2##%!A#(76(E#)!6%!'%!'%$E'-!1%$/;!'!26//6EZ1A!'AA(6'3&!C*$91(#!aD!<br />

$+!76--6I#)!/6!A(6)13#!'%!6=#('--!'++#++E#%/!67!'%$E'-!I#-7'(#!6%!/&'/!A'(/$31-'(!1%$/O!7$(+/!/&#!<br />

)'/'!36--#3/#)!C$F#F!='-1#+!62/'$%#)!76(!/&#!)$77#(#%/!E#'+1(#+!6%!/&#!'%$E'-!1%$/D!'(#!36E2$%#)!<br />

/6! 3'-31-'/#! 3($/#($6%Z+36(#+m! /&#%! 3($/#($6%Z+36(#+! '(#! 36E2$%#)! /6! 3'-31-'/#! A($%3$A-#Z+36(#+m!<br />

'%)!7$%'--0!/&#!'%$E'-!1%$/!$+!'++$9%#)!/6!6%#!I#-7'(#!3'/#96(0!'336()$%9!/6!/&#!A($%3$A-#Z+36(#+!<br />

$/!62/'$%#)F!<br />

!"#$%&"$<br />

'&()"&(#<br />

/&(.0(1,"$<br />

*+"&#,, #$$"$$-".)<br />

~30 12 4<br />

1<br />

!<br />

Figure 4.J%//%$N9+( "++0%".6( 5%0( 4&/'


!<br />

)#7$%#)!I$/&!/&#EF!:&#%!#TA#(/+!I#(#!'+Q#)!/6!+36(#!=$(/1'-!)'/'+#/+!'%)!/&$+!36%+1-/'/$6%!I'+!<br />

1+#)!/6!)#7$%#!I#$9&/+!/&'/!A(6)13#!/&#!+'E#!('%Q$%9!67!7'(E+!'+!/&#!6%#!9$=#%!20!#TA#(/+F!:&#!<br />

#TA#(/+! %#=#(! 76--6I#)! '! -$%#'(! (#'+6%$%9;! #F9F! 76(! '! 9$=#%! '%6E'-0! '! JS!p! $%3(#'+#! $%! /&'/!<br />

'%6E'-0!)$)!%6/!0$#-)!/&#!+'E#!$%3(#E#%/!$%!#TA#(/!+36(#+!'/!/&#!26//6E!67!/&#!}S;JSS{!+3'-#!<br />

CI&#(#!E6+/!'%$E'-+!I#(#!'-(#')0!%6/!%6(E'-D!/&'%!'/!/&#!/6A!67!/&#!+3'-#!CI&#%!'--!'%$E'-+!<br />

I#(#!%6(E'-DF!5/!I'+!/&#(#76(#!%#3#++'(0!/6!(#+6(/!/6!%6%Z-$%#'(!71%3/$6%+!/6!A(6)13#!3($/#($6%Z<br />

+36(#+;!$%!/&$+!3'+#!5Z+A-$%#!71%3/$6%+F!5Z+A-$%#!71%3/$6%+!'--6I!3'-31-'/$6%!67!A6(/$6%+!67!31(=#+!<br />

+6! '+! /6! 62/'$%! '! (#+1-/$%9! +E66/&! $%3(#'+$%9! 31(=#! '%)! '(#! #TA(#++#)! $%! /&#! 76(E! 67! 312$3!<br />

71%3/$6%+F!!<br />

:&#!p!2$()+!E6)#('/#-0!'77#3/#)!20!766/!A')!)#(E'/$/$+!Cp!A6)6)#(E'/$/$+!JD!'%)!/&#!p!2$()+!<br />

+#=#(#-0!'77#3/#)!20!766/!A')!)#(E'/$/$+!Cp!A6)6)#(E'/$/$+!^D!'(#!1+#)!/6!3'-31-'/#!'%!$%)#TO!<br />

!<br />

2+(43(/90&')(4&/%("(3.%0'(!+(934&


!<br />

'%$E'-!A(6/#3/$6%!I&$3&!$+!%6I!#%+&($%#)!$%!#T$+/$%9!-#9$+-'/$6%!361-)!2#!t+I#A/!'I'0c!6%!/&#!'!<br />

I'=#! 67! #%/&1+$'+E! 76(! b?8+F! b+! I#--! '+! /&#! A6/#%/$'-! 2#%#7$/+! 67! /&#! 1+#! 67! '%$E'-! 2'+#)!<br />

E#'+1(#+;!/&#(#!'(#!3-#'(-0!L1#+/$6%+F[&6!I$--!3'((0!/&#!36+/;!3'%!/&#!E#'+1(#+!2#!E')#!$%!'!<br />

(#A#'/'2-#! '%)! (#-$'2-#! I'0! I$/&$%! /&#! /$E#+3'-#! 67! '%! (61/$%#! '++#++E#%/;! &6I! I61-)! /&#0!<br />

I6(Q!$%!(#-'/$6%!/6!3&'%9$%9!+#'+6%+;!3'%!'!+$%9-#!7'(EZ2'+#)!+36(#!A(6=$)#!1+#71-!$%76(E'/$6%;!<br />

'%)!3'%!b?8c+!7$/!$%/6!#T$+/$%9!'++#++E#%/!7('E#I6(Q+Ç!:&#!$%3-1+$6%!67!b?8+!$+!'!($AA-#!6(!<br />

#=6-1/$6%!C%6/!'!I'=#!67!(#=6-1/$6%D!'%)!/&#!+/'2$-$/0!'%)!36%+#(='/$+E!67!/&#!-#9$+-'/$=#!'%)!<br />

'++#++E#%/! 36EE1%$/0! I$--! #%+1(#! /&'/! $7! b?8+! )6! 2#9$%! /6! E'Q#! /&#$(! I'0! $%/6! 7'(E!<br />

'++#++E#%/! E#/&6)+! '%)! /&#! -#9$+-'/$6%;! /&#%! /&$+! I$--! /'Q#! A-'3#! 9(')1'--0! '%)! I$/&61/! /&#!<br />

(#E6='-!67!/&#!#T$+/$%9!7('E#I6(Q+!I&$3&!A(6/#3/!7'(E#)!'%$E'-+F!!<br />

!<br />

100<br />

80<br />

60<br />

40<br />

20<br />

excellent<br />

basic<br />

enhanced<br />

non classified<br />

0<br />

feeding 1 housing 2 health 3 behaviour 4<br />

!<br />

( Figure 5Examples of farms in the four welfare category<br />

Figure 5.( YI"$+#'3( %5( )455'0'&/( 3.%0'( +0%54#'3( 5%0(5"0$3( M( 93')( /%( 'I+#%0'( 6%L( "( 0"&


!<br />

?1//#(I6(/&;!bF;!.#$++$#(;!5;!!8'%/#3';!]Fz;!'%)!?-6Q&1$+;!4F]F!^SS`F![#-7'(#!:(')#F!H1(6A#'%!<br />


!<br />

Factors affecting poultry meat quality<br />

!<br />

8e!G13-6+!f!NF!?#(($!<br />

5M"b!


!<br />

5%!'!(#3#%/!(#=$#I;!,#//('33$!'%)!?'#P'!C^SJJD!A(6A6+#!'%!&'(E6%$P'/$6%!$%!/&#!E#/&6)6-69$#+!<br />

76(!'++#++$%9!A61-/(0!E#'/!L1'-$/0!7#'/1(#+;!I&$3&!+&61-)!7'3$-$/'/#!71/1(#!36EA'($+6%+!2#/I##%!<br />

+/1)$#+F!<br />

d/&#(! E6(#! +12e#3/$=#! L1'-$/0! A'('E#/#(+!'(#!'-+6!$EA6(/'%/;!I&$3&!'(#!E6(#!(#-#='%/!/6!/&#!<br />

$E'9#!67!/&#!A(6)13/!6(!/&#!A(6)13/$6%!+3&#E#;!'%)!36%/($21/#!/6!)$=#(+$7$3'/$6%F!*6(!#T'EA-#;!<br />

/&#! @g'2#-! "619#B! A(6)13/$6%! $%! *('%3#! $+! 36%+$)#(#)! 67! $EA(6=#)! L1'-$/0! 2#3'1+#! 67! '!<br />

36EA-#T!-$+/!67!(#L1#+/+!$%3-1)$%9O!9#%6/0A#;!'9#!'/!+-'19&/#(;!7(##!('%9#!'33#++;!)$#/!C$%3-1)$%9!<br />

6=#(! RSp! 67! 3#(#'-+! '%)! #T3-1)$%9! +0%/&#/$3! '))$/$=#+DF! ,(6)13#(+! 6(! (#/'$-#(+! 3'%! 9'/&#(! /6!<br />

A(6)13#! +A#3$7$3! A(6)13/+! /6! '%+I#(! I&'/! /&#0! 36%+$)#(! '+! 36%+1E#(c+! )#E'%)+! 36%3#(%$%9!<br />

'%$E'-!I#-7'(#;!766)!+'7#/0!Ch8d!7(##!)$#/D!6(!#-+#F!<br />

!<br />

Transformation of muscle to meat<br />

b/! )#'/&;! /&#! 3#++'/$6%! 67! 2-66)! +1AA-0! /6! /&#! E1+3-#! /$++1#! (#+1-/+! $%! /&#! 3#++'/$6%! 67! /&#!<br />

6T$)'/$=#!E#/'26-$+E;!'%)!/&#!E1+3-#!/1(%+!/6!9-036-0/$3!E#/'26-$+E!/6!(#9#%#('/#!b:,F!:&#!<br />

)#9(')'/$6%!67!9-0369#%!A(6)13#+!-'3/'/#!'%)!A(6/6%+!/&#(#20!36%/($21/$%9!/6!'3$)$7$3'/$6%!67!<br />

/&#!E#'/F![&#%!'--!/&#!9-0369#%!&'+!2##%!1+#)!/&#!E#'/!(#'3&#+!$/+!1-/$E'/#!A4!CA41D!='-1#F!<br />

b+!-6%9!'+!b:,!$+!A(6)13#);!(#-'/$6%!67!/&#!E1+3-#!$+!A6++$2-#;!/&#(#76(#!'+!/&#!E#'/!A(69(#++#+!<br />

/6I'()! $/+! A41;! /&#! ($96(! E6(/$+! #+/'2-$+&#+F! b7/#(! /&$+! A6$%/;! /&#! E'/1('/$6%! A(63#++! /'Q#+!<br />

A-'3#;! (#+1-/$%9! 7(6E! /&#! '3/$6%! 67! #%)69#%61+! A(6/#6-0/$3! #%P0E#+;! '--6I$%9! 76(! /&#!<br />

/#%)#($+'/$6%! A(63#++F! :&$+! A&'+#! $+! E13&! L1$3Q#(! 76(! I&$/#! CA61-/(0! '%)! A6(QD! /&'%! 76(! (#)!<br />

C2##7D! E#'/F! :&#! E#'/! 7$%'--0! (#'3&#+! $/+! 2'+'-! +/$77%#++;! I&$3&! $+! E'$%-0! )#/#(E$%#)! 20! /&#!<br />

'E61%/;!/&#!%'/1(#!'%)!/&#!+6-12$-$/0!67!36--'9#%F!:&#!E'/1('/$6%!A&'+#!$+!1+1'--0!36%+$)#(#)!<br />

%6/!/6!2#!-$E$/$%9!76(!A61-/(0!E#'/;!/&#(#76(#!/&#!'3$)$7$3'/$6%!A(63#++!$+!/&#!E'$%!)#/#(E$%'%/!<br />

67!E6+/!L1'-$/0!A'('E#/#(+F!!<br />

b%0! A#(/1(2'/$6%! $%! /&#! '3$)$7$3'/$6%! A(63#++! +/(6%9-0! $EA'3/+! 6%! A61-/(0! E#'/! L1'-$/0F! :&#!<br />

'EA-$/1)#!67!A4!7'--!E'Q#+!/&#!)$+/$%3/$6%!2#/I##%!M6(E'-;!b3$)!'%)!G'(Q!*$(E!G(0!CG*GD!<br />

E#'/+F!b3$)!E#'/+!'(#!A'-#!C+&6I$%9!'!&$9&!-1E$%'%3#!='-1#;!guD!'%)!+&6I!'!(#)13#)!I'/#(!<br />

&6-)$%9! 3'A'3$/0! C[4ND;! I&$3&! '-+6! $%)13#+! '! )#3(#'+#)! /#3&%6-69$3'-! 0$#-)F! :&#+#! E#'/+!<br />

&'=#!'!966)!+&#-7!-$7#!21/!)6!%6/!A(#+#%/!I#--!'+!/&#0!'(#!#T1)'/$=#F!?0!36%/('+/;!G*G!E#'/+!<br />

'(#! )'(Q! C-6I! gu! ='-1#D! '%)! +&6I! '%! $%3(#'+#)! [4N! '%)! '%! $EA(6=#)! /#3&%6-69$3'-! 0$#-)F!<br />

:&#0! '(#! &6I#=#(! E6(#! +#%+$/$=#! /6! 2'3/#($'-! 36%/'E$%'/$6%! '+! 7(#+&! E#'/;! )(0! '%)! +/$77F!<br />

b%6/&#(!)#7#3/!(#-'/#+!/6!'%!$%3(#'+#)!('/#!67!A4!7'--!I&$3&!-#')+!/6!,'-#!Y67/!HT1)'/$=#!E#'/+;!<br />

I&$3&!+&'(#!+6E#!3&'('3/#($+/$3+!I$/&!b3$)!E#'/F!:&$+!+0%)(6E#!&'+!2##%!I#--!)631E#%/#)!$%!<br />

A6(Q;!I&#(#!$/!$+!36%/(6--#)!20!'!E'e6(!9#%#!C/&#!&'-6/&'%#!9#%#DF!5/!$EA-$#+!/&#!)#%'/1('/$6%!67!<br />

A(6/#$%+! )1#! /6! /&#! 36%e1%3/$6%! 67! -6I! A4! '%)! &$9&! /#EA#('/1(#F! :&$+! +0%)(6E#! &'+! 2##%!<br />

)#+3($2#)!$%!A61-/(0!C/1(Q#0+!'%)!2(6$-#(+D!'/!-#'+/!1%)#(!$%)1+/($'-!36%)$/$6%+!I&#(#!$/!E'0!2#!<br />

36%761%)#)!I$/&!'3$)!E#'/F!:&#!6331((#%3#!67!/&6+#!)#7#3/+!$%!/&#!A61-/(0!3&'$%!$+!/&#!62e#3/!<br />

67!'!-'/#(!A'('9('A&F!<br />

!<br />

Variability of meat quality parameters in French slaughter plants<br />

b! -'(9#! +1(=#0! I'+! 36%)13/#)! 20! 5:b.5! '%)! 5M"b! 6%! RKSS! 2(#'+/! 7$--#/+! 7(6E! __! 2'/3&#+!<br />

36--#3/#)! 20! _! A61-/(0! A(6)13/$6%! 9(61A+! A(63#++$%9! 2(6$-#(+! I$/&! +-6I;! E#)$1E;! 6(! &$9&!<br />

9(6I/&! ('/#! 76(! +/'%)'()! 2(6$-#(! A(6)13/$6%! 6(! &#'=0! 2(6$-#(+! 76(! /&#! A(6)13/$6%! 67! 31/+! '%)!<br />

71(/&#(!A(63#++#)!A(6)13/+F!:&#!('%9#!67!%6(E'-!A41!='-1#+!I'+!36%+$)#(#)!/6!2#!7(6E!WFR!/6!<br />

_;^F! 4$9&#(! ='-1#+! Ck! _F^D! I#(#! 36%+$)#(#)! '+! G*G! E#'/+! '%)! -6I#(! ='-1#+! Cx! WFRD! '+! b3$)!<br />

E#'/+F! :&#! E6+/! +/($Q$%9! (#+1-/! I'+! /&#! &#/#(69#%#$/0! $%! /#(E! 67! A41! I&$3&! $EA'3/+! 6%! '--!<br />

6/&#(!A'('E#/#(+!C36-61(;!31($%9Z366Q$%9!0$#-)+;!/#T/1(#!67!366Q#)!E#'/;!/#3&%6-69$3'-!0$#-)DF!<br />

:&#!&$9&#+/!='($'2$-$/0!I'+!62+#(=#)!$%!+/'%)'()!2(6$-#(!A(6)13/$6%;!A6++$2-0!'+!'!(#+1-/!67!/&#!<br />

-'(9#! ='($'2$-$/0! 67! /&#! 2$()+! A(63#++#)! CUW! /6! aR! )'0+;! JFW! /6! ^Fa! Q9! -$=#! I#$9&/DF! :&#!E6+/!<br />

7(#L1#%/! )#7#3/! I'+! b3$)! E#'/+! I&$3&! I#(#! A'-#! '%)! #T&$2$/#)! '! -6I! [4N! '%)! '! A66(!<br />

/#3&%6-69$3'-!0$#-);!'(61%)!J`p!$%!+/'%)'()!2(6$-#(!A(6)13/$6%F!:&#!6331((#%3#!67!G*G!E#'/;!<br />

'-/&619&!-#++!7(#L1#%/!Cx!WpD!I'+!'-+6!%6/#)F!:&#!='($'/$6%+!67!A41!$EA'3/!6%!/&#!-1E$%'%3#!<br />

67!/&#!E#'/!I$/&!'!36((#-'/$6%!36#77$3$#%/!2#/I##%!A41!'%)!gu!67!ZSFa!/6!ZSF_!'%)!6%!/&#!/#T/1(#!<br />

!<br />

471


!<br />

67! 366Q#)! E#'/! I$/&! '! 36((#-'/$6%! 36#77$3$#%/! 2#/I##%! A41! '%)! [?Y*! 67! ! ZSF^! /6!ZSFWF!:&#!<br />

+/1)0! '-+6! '--6I#)! #+/$E'/$%9! /&#! #77#3/! 67! A41! 6%! /#3&%6-69$3'-! 0$#-)! I$/&! '! 36((#-'/$6%!<br />

36#77$3$#%/!2#/I##%!A41!'%)!0$#-)!67!SF_!$%!+/'%)'()!2(6$-#(+!Ch$9'1)!#/!'-F;!^SJJDF!<br />

!<br />

Factors affecting poultry meat quality<br />

?6/&!$%/($%+$3!'%)!#T/($%+$3!7'3/6(+!3'%!$EA'3/!6%!E#'/!L1'-$/0F!5%/($%+$3!7'3/6(+!'(#!9#%6/0A#;!<br />

'9#;! +#T;! /0A#! 67! E1+3-#! I&$3&! )$77#(#%/$'/#! /&#! A(6)13/+! 6(! A(6)13/$6%! +0+/#E+F! HT/($%+$3!<br />

7'3/6(+! '(#! /&6+#! 'AA-$#)! )1($%9! 2(##)$%9! C%1/($/$6%;! 2(##)$%9! +3&#E#+D;! &'%)-$%9;!<br />

/('%+A6(/'/$6%! '%)! +-'19&/#(! '+! I#--! '+! A6+/! E6(/#E! /(#'/E#%/! )1($%9! /&#! E1+3-#! /6! E#'/!<br />

/('%+76(E'/$6%!A(63#++F!!!<br />

!<br />

Effect of age<br />

:&#! )$=#(+$/0! 67! /&#! A61-/(0! A(6)13/$6%! +3&#E#+! $+! E'$%-0! 2'+#)! 6%! )$77#($%9! 9(6I/&! ('/#+;!<br />

I&$3&!'(#!A'(/-0!/&#!(#+1-/+!67!/&#!9#%#/$3!+#-#3/$6%F!b+!2(6$-#(+!'(#!1+1'--0!('$+#)!/6!(#'3&!'!<br />

9$=#%!-$=#!I#$9&/;!/&$+!E#'%+!/&'/!/&#0!'(#!+-'19&/#(#)!'/!)$77#(#%/!'9#+F!5%!*('%3#;!/&#!E6+/!<br />

3-'++$3'-!2(6$-#(!A(6)13/!$+!^!Q9!-$=#!26)0!I#$9&/F!G#A#%)$%9!6%!/&#!9#%6/0A#c+!9(6I/&!('/#!'%)!<br />

2(##)$%9!36%)$/$6%+!/&$+!76(E'/!$+!(#'3&#)!'/!UWZaS!)'0+!67!'9#!76(!7'+/!9(6I$%9!2(6$-#(+!'%)!`J!<br />

)'0+! 76(! +-6I! 9(6I$%9! 2(6$-#(+! +13&! '+! @g'2#-! "619#BF! Y#=#('-! 7'3/6(+! 36%/($21/#! /6! /&#!<br />

L1'-$/'/$=#!)$77#(#%3#+!2#/I##%!/&#!/I6!A(6)13/$6%+;!21/!'9#!$+!/&#!E6+/!$EA6(/'%/F!!<br />

5%3(#'+$%9! '9#! '/! +-'19&/#(! -#')+! /6! '%! $%3(#'+#! $%! E#'/! 36--'9#%! 36%/#%/! I$/&! '! -6I#(!<br />

+6-12$-$/0F!:&#!-$A$)!36%/#%/!'-+6!)#3(#'+#+!I$/&!'9#;!I&$-#!+'/1('/#)!7'//0!'3$)+!$%3(#'+#F!:&$+!<br />

$+!-$Q#-0!/6!#TA-'$%!I&0!/&#!E#'/!67!@g'2#-!"619#B!$+!761%)!7$(E#(;!-#++!e1$30!21/!I$/&!E6(#!<br />

7-'=61(!C?#(($!#/!'-F;!^SSaDF!<br />

5%3(#'+$%9! /&#! '9#! '/! +-'19&/#(! I$/&$%! '! A(6)13/$6%! /0A#;! )#3(#'+#+! 9-0369#%! 36%/#%/! '%)!<br />

/&#(#20!$%3(#'+#+!A41!'%)!36%+#L1#%/-0![4N!C?'ÅP'!#/!'-F;!^SJSDF!<br />

!<br />

Effect of genotype<br />

*6(! '%$E'-+! +-'19&/#(#)! '/! '! 9$=#%! '9#;! /&#! 9#%6/0A#! $+! 1+1'--0! '%! $EA6(/'%/! 7'3/6(! 67!<br />

='($'2$-$/0F! ?0! 36EA'($%9! 9#%6/0A#+;! I#! 62+#(=#)! /&'/! $%3(#'+#)! 9(6I/&! ('/#! '%)! 6(! 2(#'+/!<br />

E#'/!)#=#-6AE#%/!1+1'--0!-#')+!/6!&$9&#(!A41;!I&$3&!$%3(#'+#+![4N!'%)!/#3&%6-69$3'-!0$#-)!<br />

C?#(($!#/!'-F;!^SSJDF!:&#!62+#(='/$6%!67!/&#!='($'2$-$/0!I$/&$%!'!A#)$9(##!A6A1-'/$6%!67!$%)1+/($'-!<br />

2(6$-#(+!+&6I#)!/&'/!2(#'+/!9(6I/&!I'+!E'$%-0!#TA-'$%#)!20!E1+3-#!7$2(#!+$P#!'%)!(#+1-/#)!$%!<br />

)#3(#'+#)! 9-0369#%! 36%/#%/! '%)! 36%+#L1#%/-0! '! &$9&#(! A41! ='-1#;! '! &$9&#(! [4N! '%)! '%!<br />

$EA(6=#)! A(63#++$%9! '2$-$/0! C?#(($! #/! '-F;! ^SSRDF! N6EA'($%9! #TA#($E#%/'-! *'/! =#(+1+! g#'%!<br />

3&$3Q#%+!1%('=#--#)!'!A6+$/$=#!-$%Q!2#/I##%!7'/%#++!'%)!E1+3-#!9-0369#%!36%/#%/;!(#+1-/$%9!$%!<br />

&$9&#(!A41!$%!-#'%!3&$3Q#%+!CY$21/!#/!'-F;!^SS`DF![#!/&#(#76(#!&0A6/&#+$+#!/&'/!+#-#3/$6%!76(!<br />

$%3(#'+#)!9(6I/&!('/#;!2(#'+/!E#'/!0$#-)!'%)!)#3(#'+#)!')$A6+$/0!#TA-'$%+!/&#!$%3(#'+#!$%!A41!<br />

I&$3&! $+! A(#+#%/-0! 62+#(=#)! $%! $%)1+/($'-! 2(6$-#(+F! :&$+! /(#%)! $+! 9#%#('--0! 2#%#7$3$'-! /6!<br />

/#3&%6-69$3'-!'+A#3/+!67!E#'/!L1'-$/0!'+!-6%9!'+!/&#!='-1#+!(#E'$%!I$/&$%!/&#!%6(E'-!('%9#F!<br />

!<br />

b! %1E2#(! 67! +/1)$#+! (#=#'-#)! /&'/! 2(#'+/! E#'/! L1'-$/0! /('$/+! '(#! &#($/'2-#! C&^! l! SFU! /6! SF_!<br />

)#A#%)$%9!6%!9#%6/0A#!'%)!36%)$/$6%+DF!8'%0!67!/&#!/('$/+!'(#!&$9&-0!36((#-'/#)!'%)!/&#!A41!<br />

361-)!2#!36%+$)#(#)!'+!/&#!E6+/!A#(/$%#%/!A'('E#/#(!76(!+#-#3/$6%!Cg#!?$&'%ZG1='-!#/!'-F;!^SSJ;!<br />

^SS`DF!5/!)6#+!&6I#=#(!(#L1$(#!/&#!+-'19&/#($%9!67!36--'/#('-+!I&$3&!$+!36+/-0!'%)!(#)13#+!/&#!<br />

#77$3$#%30! 67! /&#! +#-#3/$6%! A(63#++F! :&$+! $+! /&#! (#'+6%! I&0! +/1)$#+! '(#! 1%)#(I'0! /6! $)#%/$70!<br />

E6-#31-'(!E'(Q#(+!I&$3&!361-)!'--6I!76(!'!9#%6E$3!+#-#3/$6%!CY$21/!#/!'-F;!^SJJDF!<br />

:&#!(#'3/$=$/0!67!'%$E'-!/6!+/(#++6(+!$+!'-+6!$EA6(/'%/!76(!/&#!36%/(6-!67!A4!7'--!('/#!'%)!1%)#(!<br />

9#%#/$3! 36%/(6-! CN&'2'1-/! #/! '-F;! ^SJSDF! *'+/! 9(6I$%9! 2(6$-#(+! 1+1'--0! +&6I! '! -6I! (#'3/$=$/0!<br />

I&$-#! +-6I! 9(6I$%9!2(6$-#(!+&6I!'!&$9&!(#'3/$=$/0!I&$3&!$+!#TA(#++#)!20!'!&$9&#(!$%3$)#%3#!<br />

'%)! )1('/$6%! 67! I$%9! 7-'AA$%9! 6%! /&#! +&'3Q-#! -$%#! '%)! 1-/$E'/#-0! -#')+! /6! /&#! 6331((#%3#! 67!<br />

E#'/!I$/&!$EA'$(#)!36-61(!'%)![4N!CG#21/!#/!'-F;!^SSUm!?#(($!#/!'-F;!^SSWDF!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

472


!<br />

Effect of sex<br />

:&#!+#T1'-!)$E6(A&$+E!$%!3&$3Q#%!$EA-$#+!/&'/!7#E'-#+!'(#!1+1'--0!+E'--#(!/&'%!E'-#+!'/!/&#!<br />

+'E#!'9#;!21/!'-+6!+&6I!E6(#!A(#363$/0;!$F#F!'!36EA'('/$=#-0!&$9&#(!2(#'+/!0$#-)!'%)!&$9&#(!7'/!<br />

)#A6+$/$6%! '/! /&#! +'E#! '9#F! *#E'-#+! +&6I! &$9&#(! 9-0369#%! 36%/#%/;! -6I#(! A41;! '%)! /&#(#20!<br />

A'-#(!E#'/!I$/&!-6I#(![4N!C]-'-$!#/!'-F;!^SSKDF!!<br />

!<br />

Effect of nutrition<br />

G$#/! &'+! '! E'(Q#)! $%7-1#%3#! 6%! 9(6I/&! '%)! 2(#'+/! E#'/! )#=#-6AE#%/F!:&#!'))$/$6%!67!+1A('!<br />

6A/$E'-! -#=#-+! 67! -0+$%#! $%! /&#! )$#/! $%3(#'+#+! 2(#'+/! E#'/! 0$#-);! A41! '%)! 'E#-$6('/#+! [4N!<br />

C?#(($!#/!'-F;!^SS`DF!5%3(#'+$%9!3(1)#!A(6/#$%!36%/#%/!$%!/&#!)$#/!$%)13#+!'!(#=#(+#!#77#3/!C]-'-$!#/!<br />

'-F;! ^SSKm! o'-Ü$%! #/! '-F;! ^SJSDF! 5%/#(#+/$%9-0;! '%! $%/#('3/$6%! I$/&! 9#%6/0A#! $+! 62+#(=#)! '+!/&#!<br />

#77#3/!67!A(6/#$%!36%/#%/!$+!62+#(=#)!$%!g#'%!21/!%6/!$%!*'/!3&$3Q#%+!C]-'-$!#/!'-F;!^SSKDF!"#3#%/!<br />

#TA#($E#%/+!2'+#)!6%!+#L1#%/$'-!7##)$%9!I$/&!)$#/+!A(6=$)$%9!#%#(90!'%)!A(6/#$%+!6%!'-/#(%'/#!<br />

)'0+;! +&6I#)! /&'/! )$77#(#%/! )$#/! 36EA6+$/$6%+! 361-)! ('A$)-0! 3&'%9#! 2(#'+/! E1+3-#! 9-0369#%!<br />

36%/#%/!'%)!$EA'3/!6%!E#'/!L1'-$/0!C8'E#($!#/!'-F;!^SSKDF!:&$+!+199#+/+!/&'/!E6)$7$3'/$6%+!$%!<br />

)$#/'(0!36EA6+$/$6%!$%!/&#!-'+/!)'0+!2#76(#!+-'19&/#(!361-)!'--6I!76(!/&#!E'%$A1-'/$6%!67!E#'/!<br />

L1'-$/0F!<br />

!<br />

Effect of handling, transportation, slaughter and cutting<br />

*##)!I$/&)('I'-!7(6E!K!/6!^W!&!3'%!$%)13#!'%!$%3(#'+#!67!A41!67!1A!/6!SFU!


!<br />

!<br />

References:<br />

b2#0#+$%9&;#! YF8F;! 83j##9'%;! GFHF;! 83g#E'%;!8FbF;! g6I#;! ]FNF;! G#EE#(+;! :FhF;! [&$/#;! "F,F;!<br />

j('%#%;! "F[F;! ='%! ?#EE#-;! 4F;! g'%Q&''(;! ]FbF;! ['/&#+;! NF8F;! ^SSRF! N6%/(6--#)! '/E6+A&#(#!<br />

+/1%%$%9!67!2(6$-#(!3&$3Q#%+F!5F!H77#3/+!6%!2#&'=$61(;!A&0+$6-690!'%)!E#'/!L1'-$/0!$%!'!A$-6/!+3'-#!<br />

+0+/#E!'/!'!A(63#++$%9!A-'%/F!?($/$+&!,61-/(0!Y3$#%3#;!a`OaS_Z^UF!<br />

?'#P';! HF;! ]-'-$;! 8F;! N&'(/($%;! ,F;! h$9'1);! .F;! 8#(3#('%);! *F;! G1('%);! NF;! 8#/#'1;! jF;! g#! ?$&'%Z<br />

G1='-;!HF;!?#(($;!NF;!^SJSF!5%7-1#%3#!67!$%3(#'+#)!+-'19&/#(!'9#!6%!E#'/!0$#-)!'%)!2(#'+/!E#'/!<br />

L1'-$/0!7(6E!'!&#'=0!-$%#!67!2(6$-#(!3&$3Q#%F!5%O!,(63##)$%9!67!JU /& !H1(6A#'%!,61-/(0!N6%9(#++;!<br />

:61(+!C*"bD;!^SJSXS`X^UZ^RF!<br />

?#(($;!NF!^SSaF!?(##)$%9!'%)!L1'-$/0!67!A61-/(0F!,61-/(0!8#'/!,(63#++$%9!'%)!n1'-$/0;!8#');!hFNF!<br />

CH)FD;! N&'AF! ^O! ^JZURF! N"N!,(#++;!?63'!"'/6%! C


!<br />

AWBRZUZBXF(<br />

8'E#($;! 4F;! G1A6%/;! ]F;! ]612#(/;! "F;! N6--$%;! bF;! N(63&#/;! YF;! N'$--#'1Zb1)61$%;! HF;! :#++#('1);! YF;!<br />

8#/'0#(ZN61+/'()! YF! ^SJSF! 8#3&'%$+E+! (#91-'/$%9! /&#! A#($A&#('-! 1/$-$+'/$6%! 67! 9-136+#O!<br />

$%=6-=#E#%/! 67! 'EAQF! 5%!O! ,(63##)$%9+! 67! /&#! U()! 5%/#(%'/$6%'-! Hbb,! Y0EA6+$1E! 6%! H%#(90!<br />

'%)!,(6/#$%!8#/'26-$+E!'%)!M1/($/$6%!C$+#AD;!^SJSXSKX_ZJS;!,'(E'!C5:bDF!!<br />

,#/('33$;!8F;!?'#P'!HF;!^SJJF!4'(E6%$P'/$6%!67!E#/&6)6-69$#+!76(!/&#!'++#++E#%/!67!A61-/(0!E#'/!<br />

L1'-$/0!7#'/1(#+F![6(-)c+!,61-/(0!Y3$#%3#!]61(%'-;!_R;!JURZJWJF!<br />

"61++#'1;!zF;!h#%#/;!GF;!8'(6/#$T;!YF;!?#(($;!NF;!h$9'1);!.F!;!^SJSF!H-#3/($3'-!+/$E1-'/$6%O!'!I'0!/6!<br />

$EA(6=#! 3&$3Q#%! 2(#'+/! 7$--#/! /#%)#(%#++F! 5%O! ,(63##)$%9! 67! JU /& ! H1(6A#'%! ,61-/(0! N6%9(#++;!<br />

:61(+!C*"bD;!^SJSXS`X^UZ^RF!<br />

Y$21/;! .F;! 4#%%#L1#/;! NF;! g#! ?$&'%ZG1='-;! HF;! 8'(/#0;! YF!;! G13-6+;! 8F]F;! ?#(($;! NF;! ^SJJF!<br />

5)#%/$7$3'/$6%!67!)$77#(#%/$'--0!#TA(#++#)!9#%#+!2#/I##%!3&$3Q#%+!)$77#($%9!76(!E1+3-#!9-0369#%!<br />

36%/#%/! '%)! E#'/! L1'-$/0?( ?8N! h#%6E$3+! J^O! JJ^F! %+'&( "..'331(<br />

6//+1ZZLLL?-4%$').'&/0"#?.%$ZWTPWNAWRTZWAZWWA(<br />

Y$21/;!.F;!g#!?$&'%ZG1='-;!HF;!:#++#('1);!YF;!h6)#/;!HF;!?6()#'1;!:F;!N'$--#'1Zb1)61$%;!HF;!N&'(/($%;!<br />

,F;!G13-6+;!8F]F;!?#(($;!NF;!^SS`F!b)#%6+$%#!E6%6A&6+A&'/#Z'3/$='/#)!A(6/#$%!Q$%'+#!$%=6-=#)!$%!<br />

='($'/$6%+!67!E1+3-#!9-0369#%!'%)!2(#'+/!E#'/!L1'-$/0!2#/I##%!-#'%!'%)!7'/!3&$3Q#%+F!]61(%'-!67!<br />

b%$E'-!Y3$#%3#;!`_;!^```Z^`K_;!%+'&("..'331(6//+1ZZ="3?5"33?%0


!<br />

Current Salmonella situation in the poultry meat industry, regulations and<br />

strategies for reduction<br />

!<br />

"F[FbF[F!81-)#( !<br />

YA#-)#(&6-/Ñ!,61-/(0!N6%+1-/$%9!'%)!"#+#'(3&;!HA#;!:&#!M#/&#(-'%)+!<br />

!<br />

Abstract<br />

*66)!+'7#/0!&'+!2#36E#!6%#!67!/&#!E6+/!$EA6(/'%/!$++1#+!I$/&!(#9'()!/6!A(6)13/+!7(6E!/&#!766)!<br />

'%$E'-! $%)1+/(0F! :69#/&#(! I$/&! '+A#3/+! 67! '%$E'-! I#-7'(#;! /&#! A(#+#%3#! 67! A6/#%/$'--0!<br />

A'/&69#%$3!E$3(6Z6(9'%$+E+!C!"#$%&'##";!*"$+,#%-"./'0!#/3D!$%!/&#+#!A(6)13/+!E6+/!$%7-1#%3#!<br />

/&#!$E'96!67!/&#+#!A(6)13/+!/6!36%+1E#(+F!,61-/(0!A(6)13/$6%!'%)!/&#(#76(#!A61-/(0!A(6)13/+!<br />

'(#! 67/#%! $%=6-=#)! &1E'%! 61/2(#'Q+! 67! 766)Z26(%#! )$+#'+#F! :&#(#76(#! $/! $+! $EA6(/'%/! /6!<br />

)#3(#'+#! /&#! -#=#-+! 67! 36%/'E$%'/$6%! $%! -$=#! 2$()+! '%)! /6! (#)13#! /&#! A6++$2$-$/$#+! 76(! 71(/&#(!<br />

+A(#')$%9!67!/&#+#!6(9'%$+E+!)1($%9!A(6)13/$6%!'%)!A(63#++$%9F!5%!/&#!H1(6A#'%!


!<br />

5%!/&#!H1(6A#'%!


!<br />

5%!/&$+!(#91-'/$6%!/&#!1+#!67!'%/$2$6/$3+!$+!9#%#('--0!)$+361('9#)!+$%3#!/&#!($+Q!76(!+#-#3/$6%!'%)!<br />

)$+/($21/$6%!67!'%/$2$6/$3!(#+$+/'%/!+/('$%+!76(E!'!($+QF!YA#3$7$3!'%/$2$6/$3!1+#!$+!A#(E$//#)!1%)#(!<br />

/I6!36%)$/$6%+O!!<br />

JF $%!3'+#!67!9#%#/$3'--0!='-1'2-#!!/0A#+!67!A61-/(0!'%)!!<br />

^F I&#%!3-$%$3'-!!A(62-#E+!$%!A61-/(0!6331(F!!<br />

:&#! 1+#! 67! '%/$2$6/$3+!+&61-)!%6/!2#!A#(E$//#)!$%!%'/$6%'-!Y'-E6%#--'!36%/(6-!A(69('E+!I$/&!<br />

#T3#A/$6%!67!2#76(#!E#%/$6%#)!+A#3$7$#)!36%)$/$6%+F!!<br />

.'33$%'/$6%!$+!36%+$)#(#)!/6!2#!'%!'))$/$6%'-!E#'+1(#!/6!$%3(#'+#!(#+$+/'%3#!'9'$%+/!Y'-E6%#--'!<br />

'%)!/6!$%&$2$/!+A(#')!67!/&#!E$3(6Z6(9'%$+EF!


!<br />

+3'-)#)! '%)! A-13Q#);! 2#76(#! /&#! =$+3#('! '(#! (#E6=#)! '%)! /&#! 3'(3'++#+! +A('0ZI'+&#)! '%)!<br />

3&$--#)F! :&#%;! /&#! 3'(3'++#+! '(#! #$/&#(! +#%/! /6! /&#! A6(/$6%$%9! )#A'(/E#%/;! 1+#)! 76(! 71(/&#(!<br />

A(63#++$%9!6(!/&#0!-#'=#!/&#!A(63#++$%9!A-'%/!'+!A'3Q'9#);!I&6-#!3'(3'++#+F!Y#=#('-!+/'9#+!'(#!<br />

3($/$3'-!$%!36%/(6--$%9!E$3(62$'-!36%/'E$%'/$6%!67!A(6)13/+!'%)!X!6(!#L1$AE#%/F!Y/(#++!$%31((#)!<br />

20! /('%+A6(/'/$6%! '%)! -$=#Z2$()! &'%)-$%9! 3'1+#+! '%! $%3(#'+#)! +&#))$%9! 67! A'/&69#%$3!<br />

E$3(66(9'%$+E+;! $7! A(#+#%/F! :&#! $%3(#'+#)! +&#))$%9! E'0! 3'1+#! '))$/$6%'-! 36%/'E$%'/$6%! 67!<br />

A(63#++#)!A(6)13/+!'%)!#L1$AE#%/F!H77#3/$=#!3-#'%$%9!'%)!)$+$%7#3/$6%!67!/&#!/('%+A6(/!3('/#+!<br />

'%)!36%/'$%#(+!$+!/&#(#76(#!%#3#++'(0!'7/#(!#'3&!e61(%#0F!!<br />

86)#(%!A61-/(0!A(63#++$%9!$EA-$#+!'!&$9&!('/#!67!/&(619&A1/F!Y-'19&/#(!3'A'3$/$#+!67!E6(#!/&'%!<br />

JS;SSS!2$()+!A#(!&61(!2#36E#!36EE6%;!'%)!3'%!6%-0!2#!(#'-$+#)!I$/&!&$9&-0!E#3&'%$+#)!'%)!<br />

'1/6E'/#)!A(63#++$%9!-$%#+F!G#A#%)$%9!6%!/&#!)#9(##+!67!'1/6E'/$6%;!/&#!$%)$=$)1'-!A(63#++$%9!<br />

+/#A+!E'0!6(!E'0!%6/!$%=6-=#!&1E'%!-'261(F!G1($%9!A(63#++$%9;!+#=#('-!+/'9#+!'(#!3($/$3'-!$%!<br />

36%/(6--$%9! E$3(62$'-! 36%/'E$%'/$6%! 67! A(6)13/+! '%)! #L1$AE#%/F! :&#+#! $%3-1)#! 3'/3&$%9;!<br />

/('%+A6(/$%9! '%)! &6-)$%9! /&#! 2$()+! 2#76(#! +-'19&/#(;! '%)! /&#! 36%)$/$6%+! /&'/! 62/'$%! &'=#! '!<br />

36%+$)#('2-#!$%7-1#%3#!6%!7'#3'-!36%/'E$%'/$6%!67!/&#!7#'/&#(+!'%)!+Q$%!67!/&#!2$()+F!N-#'%$%9!<br />

'%)!)$+$%7#3/$6%!67!/('%+A6(/!3('/#+!6(!36%/'$%#(+!'7/#(!#'3&!e61(%#0!$+!/&#(#76(#!%#3#++'(0;!'%)!<br />

+&61-)!2#!6A/$E$+#)!$%!/#(E+!67!/&#!1+#!67!I'/#(;!)#/#(9#%/+;!#%#(90!'%)!-'261(F!!<br />

:#3&%6-69$3'-! $EA(6=#E#%/+! $%! /&#! A(63#++! E'0! &#-A! /6! 7'3$-$/'/#! 36%/(6-! 67! E$3(62$'-!<br />

36%/'E$%'/$6%F! :&#(#! '(#! '-(#')0! %#I! )#=#-6AE#%/+! $%! E1-/$Z+/'9#! +3'-)$%9;! A-13Q$%9;!<br />

#=$+3#('/$6%! /#3&%6-690! '%)! /&#! '1/6E'/$3!3-#'%$%9!'%)!)$+$%7#3/$6%!67!#L1$AE#%/;!20!I&$3&!<br />

E$3(62$'-!36%/'E$%'/$6%!3'%!2#!(#)13#)F!:&#+#!)#=#-6AE#%/+!A6+#!/&#!L1#+/$6%!67!I&'/!-$E$/+!<br />

+&61-)!2#!'33#A/#)!76(!/&#!E$3(62$6-69$3'-!L1'-$/0!67!3'(3'++#+!'/!)$77#(#%/!NN,+Ç!!<br />

Y1$/'2-#! E$3(62$6-69$3'-! E#/&6)+! /&'/! '(#! ('A$)! '%)! '331('/#! #%619&! /6! )#/#(E$%#! /&#!<br />

6(9'%$+E+!A(#+#%/!I$/&$%!'!+&6(/!A#($6)!67!/$E#!'(#!%##)#)!$%!6()#(!/6!E6%$/6(!'%)!36%/(6-!/&#!<br />

3($/$3'-!-$E$/+!+#/F!<br />

:&#%;!/&#(#!$+!/&#!L1#+/$6%!67!/&#!'='$-'2$-$/0!67!36((#3/$=#!E#'+1(#+!/&'/!3'%!2#!/'Q#%!$%!/&#!<br />

A(63#++$%9!A-'%/!/6!')e1+/!-#=#-+!67!A(6)13/!36%/'E$%'/$6%F!:&$()-0;!$/!$+!%6/!3-#'(!I&'/!3'%!2#!<br />

)6%#!I$/&!A(6)13/+!/&'/!&'(261(!&$9&#(!%1E2#(+!67!E$3(66(9'%$+E+!/&'%!/&6+#!I$/&$%!/&#!+#/!<br />

-$E$/+F!?#3'1+#!67!/&#+#!-$E$/'/$6%+;!1+#!67!/&#!4bNN,!+0+/#E!+&61-)!2#!+1AA-#E#%/#)!20!'!<br />

L1'%/$/'/$=#!($+Q!'%'-0+$+;!I&$3&;!'9'$%;!$%=6-=#+!'!+/#AI$+#!'%'-0+$+!67!&'P'()+;!21/!9$=#+!'%!<br />

#+/$E'/$6%!67!/&#!A(62'2$-$/0!67!6331((#%3#!67!')=#(+#!#77#3/+!6%!&1E'%!&#'-/&!7(6E!36%+1E$%9!<br />

/&#!A(6)13/F!Y13&!'%!'%'-0+$+!3'%!'-+6!A(6=$)#!'%!$%)$3'/$6%!67!/&#!2#%#7$/+!/&'/!'(#!-$Q#-0!/6!<br />

'($+#!7(6E!+A#3$7$3!&09$#%#!$%/#(=#%/$6%!E#'+1(#+;!+13&!'+!3'(3'++!)#36%/'E$%'/$6%!/(#'/E#%/+;!<br />

I&#(#!A#(E$//#)F!<br />

!<br />

Carcass decontamination<br />

5%! 36%/('+/! I$/&! /&#!


!<br />

Hygiene and quality management<br />

b--!+0+/#E+!1+#)!76(!/&#!A(6)13/$6%!67!766)!7(6E!'%$E'-+;!$%3-1)$%9!#=#(0!'+A#3/!67!-$=#Z2$()!<br />

A(6)13/$6%;! 36--#3/$6%! '%)! &'%)-$%9! 67! #99+;! '%)! 3'(3'++! A(63#++$%9;! 3'%! 2#! 36=#(#)! 20! /&#!<br />

4bNN,! 36%3#A/F! N($/$3'-! N6%/(6-! ,6$%/+! CNN,+D! 3'%! 2#! (#369%$+#)! '/! ='($61+! +/'9#+! 67! /&#!<br />

A(6)13/$6%!303-#F!5%!/&$+!3'+#;!/&#!4bNN,!'AA(6'3&!$%=6-=#+!'!36E2$%'/$6%!67!7'3/6(+!$%!h66)!<br />

409$#%$3!,('3/$3#+!Ch4,D!'%)!h66)!8'%17'3/1($%9!,('3/$3#+!Ch8,DF!<br />

:&#! $EA-#E#%/'/$6%! 67! L1'-$/0! '++1('%3#! +0+/#E+;! $%3-1)$%9! 4bNN,;! 3'%! 6%-0! 2#! )6%#!<br />

#77#3/$=#-0;!I&#%!A(6)13/$6%!$+!'-(#')0!3'(($#)!61/!1%)#(!36)#+!76(!h4,!6(!h8,F!<br />

h6=#(%E#%/+!'%)!$%)1+/(0!$%!'-E6+/!'--!)#=#-6A#)!361%/($#+!&'=#!'9(##)!/6!(#)13#!766)Z26(%#!<br />

&1E'%! A'/&69#%+! $%! A(6)13/+! 67! '%$E'-! 6($9$%! '%)! #+A#3$'--0! $%! A61-/(0! E#'/;! #99+! '%)! #99!<br />

A(6)13/+F! :&#+#! A'/&69#%Z(#)13/$6%! A(69('EE#+!$%3-1)#! $EA-#E#%/'/$6%! 67!+A#3$7$3!4bNN,!<br />

A-'%+;!+/'%)'()!6A#('/$%9!A(63#)1(#+!76(!A-'%/!3-#'%$%9!'%)!)$+$%7#3/$6%!'%)!/#+/$%9!A(6/636-+!<br />

76(!/&#!E'e6(!A'/&69#%+F!!<br />

:&#! 7#'+$2$-$/0! 67! 'AA-0$%9! /&#! 4bNN,! 36%3#A/! $%! -$=#Z2$()! A(6)13/$6%! $+! L1#+/$6%'2-#F!<br />

"#3#%/-0;!&6I#=#(;!+6E#!#T'EA-#+!&'=#!2##%!A12-$+&#)!(#9'()$%9!4bNN,!A-'%+!76(!3&$3Q#%Z!<br />

'%)!/1(Q#0Z!E#'/!A(6)13/$6%!'%)!A-'%+!'(#!'='$-'2-#!76(!$EA-#E#%/'/$6%!6%!-'0#(!7'(E+!'+!I#--F!<br />

*6(!A61-/(0!A(63#++$%9;!/&#!'AA-$3'/$6%!67!4bNN,!A($%3$A-#+!$+!E6(#!62=$61+-0!7#'+$2-#;!/&'%!<br />

76(!A61-/(0!A(6)13/$6%F!<br />

!<br />

Conclusions<br />

H


!<br />

b%6%;!^SS_'F!H='-1'/$6%!67!/&#!#77$3'30!67!!gs!g'3/$3!b3$)!76(!3'(3'++!)#36%/'E$%'/$6%F!H*Yb!<br />

]61(%'-!^SS_!Ua^OJZ_m!!<br />

b%6%;! ^SS_2F! H='-1'/$6%! 67! /&#! #77$3'30! 67! ! Y'%Z,#-! 76(! 1+#! '+! '%! '%/$E$3(62$'-! +12+/'%3#!<br />

'AA-$#)!6%!3'(3'++#+!67!3&$3Q#%+;!/1(Q#0+;!L1'$-+;!A$9+!2##7!+&##A!96'/+!'%)!9'E#!'%)!$%!<br />

I'+&$%9!67!+&#--+!67!#99+F!H*Yb!]61(%'-!^SS_!UW^O!JZ_!<br />

b%6%;!^SSRF!H*Yb!dA$%$6%!67!/&#!Y3$#%/$7$3!,'%#-!6%!?$6-69$3'-!4'P'()+!6%!E$3(62$6-69$3'-!<br />

3($/#($'!'%)!/'(9#/+!2'+#)!6%!($+Q!'%'-0+$+F!!H*Yb!]61(%'-!^SSRO!a_^m!JZ^K!<br />

b%6%;! ^SJS'F! :&#! N6EE1%$/0! +1EE'(0! (#A6(/! 6%! /(#%)+! '%)! +61(3#+! 67! P66%6+#+;! P66%6/$3!<br />

'9#%/+! '%)! 766)Z26(%#! 61/2(#'Q+! $%! /&#! H1(6A#'%!


!<br />

"#91-'/$6%!HN!JJ_`X^SS_!67!UJ!]1-0!^SS_;!$EA-#E#%/$%9!"#91-'/$6%!HN!^J_SX^SSU!'+!(#9'()+!<br />

'!N6EE1%$/0!/'(9#/!76(!/&#!(#)13/$6%!67!/&#!A(#='-#%3#!67!3#(/'$%!Y'-E6%#--'!+#(6/0A#+!$%!<br />

-'0$%9!&#%+!67!["##93(


!<br />

:'2-#!JF!,(#='-#%3#!67!Y'-E6%#--'!A6+$/$=#!2(6$-#(!7-63Q+!$%!/&#!H


!<br />

:'2-#!^F!Y'-E6%#--'!36%/'E$%'/$6%!67!2(6$-#(!3'(3'++#+!$%!/&#!H


!<br />

Embryo Checks ‘Breakouts’!<br />

!<br />

Embryo Checks and Problem Analysis in Hatcheries<br />

!<br />

]'+6%!N6(E$3Q!<br />

4'/3&#(0!YA#3$'-$+/!,#/#(+$E#!M.!<br />

ä<br />

Y#-#3/!U!+'EA-#!/('0+!7(6E!#'3&!7-63Q!76(!'%'-0+$+!7(6E!/&#!/6A;!E$))-#!'%)!26//6E!67!<br />

/&#!+'EA-#!/(6--#0!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

ä<br />

b/!/('%+7#(!3'%)-#!'%)!(#E6=#!'--!3-#'(!#99+!<br />

!<br />

Mark these trays so they can be followed at hatch!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

485<br />

!


!<br />

Embryo Checks ‘Breakouts’<br />

ä !?(#'Q61/!/6!)#7$%#!I&#/&#(!$%7#(/$-#!6(!$7!7#(/$-#!I&#%!E6(/'-$/0!6331((#)!CH'(-0Z<br />

8$))-#Zg'/#D!<br />

Infertile<br />

:&#!6=1E!$+!+##%!'+!'!-$9&/!+A6/!6%!/&#!06-Q!!<br />

!<br />

Embryo Checks ‘Breakouts’!<br />

Categories<br />

Early Mortality<br />

!<br />

Fertile (Early)<br />

:&#!+A#(E!&'+!71+#)!I$/&!6=1E!76(E$%9!/&!<br />

#E2(06!<br />

!<br />

! !<br />

!<br />

! ?-66)!"$%9! ?-'3Q!#0#! H99!:66/&!*6(E+!<br />

!<br />

Probable Causes:!<br />

- ,66(!Y/6('9#!'%)!6(!:('%+A6(/!C^!G'0D!<br />

- :#EA#('/1(#!CdA#%$%9!G66(+!H'(-0D!<br />

- g'3Q!67!:1(%$%9!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

Embryo Checks ‘Breakouts<br />

486<br />

!


!<br />

!<br />

Mid Term – Late Mortality<br />

!<br />

! ! ! !<br />

!<br />

!<br />

Probable causes:!<br />

Z!:#EA#('/1(#!<br />

- !.#%/$-'/$6%!$F#F!&$9&!Nd^!A6+/!)'0!K!<br />

- ,6++$2-#!3'1+#+O!<br />

Z!5EA(6A#(!H99+&#--Z/#EAÇ!!4#'/ZA(6)13/$6%!67!#E2(06!$+!($+$%9!7'+/-0!3#(/'$%-0!<br />

(61%)!GJa!#E2(06!E6=#+!<br />

- 5EA(6A#(!=#%/$-'/$6%Ç!!4$9&!NS^!$%!+#36%)!&'-7!67!$%312'/$6%!+&61-)!2#!'=6$)#)!<br />

!$%3(#'+#!$%!-'/#!)#'/&+!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

Embryo Checks ‘Breakouts<br />

!<br />

:&$%!+&#--+!6(!3('3Q+!E'0!2#!)1#!/6!%1/($/$6%'-!)#7$3$#%30X6-)!7-63Q+!67!E$++Z&'%)-$%9!<br />

!<br />

Ö2#+/!+##%!I&#%!#99+!'(#!3'%)-#)!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

Embryo Checks ‘Breakouts’<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

ä<br />

!8'(Q!/('0+!/6!76--6I!1A!6%!/&#!4'/3&!G'0!<br />

487


!<br />

ä !


!<br />

N6%/'E$%'/$6%!


!<br />

Problem Analysis ‘Chicks’<br />

N&$3Q+!&'=#!2##%!&'/3&#)!/66!-6%9!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

j1-1ÜQ'!Yq(#+$%$%!å6Q!


!<br />

! !<br />

g$E2!G'E'9#!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

! !<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

g66Q!76(!I&#(#!/&#!)'E'9#!361-)!2#!<br />

3'1+#)!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

491


!<br />

!<br />

g66Q!76(!I&#(#!/&#!)'E'9#!361-)!2#!3'1+#)!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

! ! !<br />

g66Q!76(!I&#(#!/&#!)'E'9#!361-)!2#!3'1+#)!<br />

!<br />

G6%c/!'++1E#!$/c+!'!&$9&-0!/#3&%$3'-!A(62-#E!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

492


!<br />

Problem Analysis ‘Chicks<br />

"#)!463Q+!t?(1$+$%9c!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

! !<br />

"#)!&63Q+!2(1$+$%9!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!!<br />

!<br />

493


!<br />

!<br />

G6%c/!'++1E#!$/c+!'!&$9&-0!/#3&%$3'-!A(62-#E!<br />

!<br />

Problem Analysis ‘Chicks<br />

!<br />

"#)!463Q+!th('P$%9c!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

"#)!463Q+!th('P$%9c!<br />

5%+177$3$#%/!I#$9&/!-6++!<br />

!<br />

Y$E$-'(!/6!/&#!A(#=$61+!21/!3-6+#(!+3(1/$%0!/6!/&#!&63Q+!+&6I+!'!)$77#(#%/!Q$%)!67!)'E'9#!<br />


!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!?-'3Q!?1//6%!M'=#-+!<br />

4$9&!:#EAX41E$)$/0!Cg'/#!Y#//#(X4'/3&#(D!<br />

:&#!&$9&!/#EA#('/1(#!76(3#+!/&#!2$()!61/!L1$3Q#(!'%)!)6#+%c/!'--6I!$/!/$E#!/6!&#'-!A(6A#(-0!<br />

Problem Analysis ‘Chicks<br />

!<br />

81-/$Zg$E2+!<br />

! !<br />

h#%#/$3+!<br />

:#EA#('/1(#!7-13/1'/$6%!#'(-0!$%!$%312'/$6%!JZW!)'0+!<br />

!<br />

:&$+!Q$%)!67!)#7#3/!6331(+!I&#%!A(6/#$%+!'(#!9#//$%9!/&#(#!(6-#!67!I&'/!/&#0!I$--!2#!3'%!'-+6!2#!$EA'3/!<br />

)'E'9#!'/!/&'/!#'(-0!+/'9#!E6+/!-$Q#-0!/#EA!<br />

!<br />

495


!<br />

Feed Additives Legal Status in European Union<br />

!<br />

]'%!j6-'3P!<br />

N&'$(E'%!67!/&#!*H*bMb!,6-$+&!,-'/76(E;!,6-'%)!<br />

!<br />

Abstract<br />

H1(6A#'%!


!<br />

C'D!7'=61('2-0!'77#3/!/&#!3&'('3/#($+/$3+!67!7##);!<br />

C2D!7'=61('2-0!'77#3/!/&#!3&'('3/#($+/$3+!67!'%$E'-!A(6)13/+;!<br />

C3D!7'=61('2-0!'77#3/!/&#!36-61(!67!6(%'E#%/'-!7$+&!'%)!2$()+;!<br />

C)D!+'/$+70!/&#!%1/($/$6%'-!%##)+!67!'%$E'-+;!<br />

C#D!7'=61('2-0!'77#3/!/&#!#%=$(6%E#%/'-!36%+#L1#%3#+!67!'%$E'-!A(6)13/$6%;!<br />

C7D!7'=61('2-0!'77#3/!'%$E'-!A(6)13/$6%;!A#(76(E'%3#!6(!I#-7'(#;!A'(/$31-'(-0!20!'77#3/$%9!/&#!<br />

9'+/(6Z$%/#+/$%'-!7-6('!6(!)$9#+/$2$-$/0!67!7##)$%9+/177+;!6(!<br />

C9D!&'=#!'!3633$)$6+/'/$3!6(!&$+/6E6%6+/'/$3!#77#3/F!<br />

!<br />

5%!'$E!/6!'++$9%!A(6A#(-0!A'(/$31-'(!A(6)13/+!/6!/&#!(#-#='%/!3'/#96(0;!677$3$'-!Nd885YY5dM!<br />

"HNd88HMGb:5dM!CaD!#+/'2-$+&$%9!91$)#-$%#+!76(!/&#!)$+/$%3/$6%!2#/I##%!7##)!E'/#($'-+;!<br />

7##)! '))$/$=#+;! 2$63$)'-! A(6)13/+! '%)! =#/#($%'(0! E#)$3$%'-! A(6)13/+! I'+! A12-$+&#)! $%! ^SJJF!<br />

:&$+!)631E#%/!$%!36EA(#&#%+$=#!76(E!+1EE'($+#+!'--!-#9'-!)#7$%$/$6%+!76(!A'(/$31-'(!A(6)13/!<br />

3'/#96($#+!'%)!#+/'2-$+&!A(#3#)#%3#!2#/I##%!/&#E!C76(!#T'EA-#!A(#3#)#%3#!67!/&#!.#/#($%'(0!<br />

8#)$3$%'-! ,(6)13/+! -#9$+-'/$6%! 6=#(! 7##)! -#9$+-'/$6%DF! b+! 1+1'--0! $%! -$7#! 6%! /6A! 67! A(6)13/+!<br />

I&$3&!'(#!)#7$%$/#-0!I$/&$%!6%#!3'/#96(0!/&#(#!'(#!'-+6!A(6)13/+!I&$3&!'(#!6%!/&#!26()#(-$%#F!<br />

Y6E#/$E#+!$/!$+!=#(0!)$77$31-/!/6!#+/'2-$+&!A(6A#(!A(6)13/!3'/#96(0!'%)!A6++$2-#!36%+#L1#%3#+!<br />

67!I(6%9!3-'++$7$3'/$6%;!-$Q#!(#3'--!67!A(6)13/!C'%)!7##)!A(6)13#)!I$/&!$/D!7(6E!/&#!E'(Q#/;!3'%!<br />

2($%9! +#=#(#! #36%6E$3'-! '%)! (#A1/'/$6%! &'(E! /6! /&#! A(6)13#(+F! ! 5%! '$E! /6! &#-A! A(6)13#(+!<br />

3-'++$70! /&#$(! A(6)13/+! '336()$%9-0;! *H*bMb!CH


!<br />

Z!&6-)#(!+A#3$7$3!'1/&6($+'/$6%!Z!$+!-$%Q#)!/6!'!A#(+6%!(#+A6%+$2-#!76(!A1//$%9!7##)!'))$/$=#!$%/6!<br />

3$(31-'/$6%!$%!/&#!3'+#!67!'))$/$=#+!2#-6%9$%9!/6!P66/#3&%$3'-m!3633$)$6+/'/+!'%)!&$+/6E6%6+/'/+!<br />

3'/#96($#+! '%)! 67! '))$/$=#+! 7'--$%9! I$/&$%! /&#! +36A#!67!N6EE1%$/0!-#9$+-'/$6%!(#-'/$%9!/6!/&#!<br />

E'(Q#/$%9! 67! A(6)13/+! 36%+$+/$%9! 67;! 36%/'$%$%9! 6(! A(6)13#)! 7(6E! 9#%#/$3'--0! E6)$7$#)!<br />

6(9'%$+E+!Ch8d+DF!M6!A#(+6%!6/&#(!/&'%!/&#!&6-)#(!67!/&#!'1/&6($+'/$6%;!+&'--!7$(+/!A-'3#!/&#!<br />

A(6)13/!6%!/&#!E'(Q#/F!<br />

Z! %6%V&6-)#(! +A#3$7$3! '1/&6($P'/$6%! V! $+! %6/! -$%Q#)! /6! '%0! A'(/$31-'(! A(6)13#(F! Y13&! 7##)!<br />

'))$/$=#;! A-'3#)! 6%! /&#! H


!<br />

%#3#++'(0! 76(! /&#! A(6/#3/$6%! 67! 36%+1E#(+! 6(! 8"g+! &'=#! '-(#')0! 2##%! #+/'2-$+&#)F! Y13&!<br />

#='-1'/$6%!+&61-)!76--6I!(#-#='%/!H*Yb!h1$)#-$%#+!Z!:#3&%$3'-!h1$)'%3#!76(!#+/'2-$+&$%9!/&#!<br />

+'7#/0!67!'))$/$=#+!76(!/&#!36%+1E#(!CKDF!<br />

[6(Q#(+! +'7#/0! V! +'7#/0! A(6/#3/$6%! )1($%9! A(6)13/$6%;! &'%)-$%9! '%)! 1+#! 67! /&#! A(6)13/! $%!<br />

'336()'%3#!/6!/&#!(#-#='%/!H


!<br />

Conclusions<br />

5%! H1(6A#'%!


!<br />

JaF! Nd885YY5dM! "Hh


!<br />

Effect of diformates on Salmonella and gut microbiota in poultry production<br />

!<br />

N&($+/$'%!gq3Q+/>)/!'%)!j1(/![#9-#$/%#(!<br />

bGGNdM!h(61A;!?6%%;!h#(E'%0;!3&($+/$'%F-1#3Q+/'#)/r'))36%F36E!<br />

!<br />

Abstract<br />

Y'-E6%#--'!('%Q+!'E6%9!/&#!I6(-)c+!2$99#+/!/&(#'/!/6!&#'-/&F!N6%/'E$%'/$6%!I$/&!A'/&69#%$3!<br />

2'3/#($';! +13&! '+! Y'-E6%#--';! 3(#'/#+! #%6(E61+! +63$'-! '%)! #36%6E$3! 36+/+! I6(-)ZI$)#F! :&#!<br />

'%%1'-!36+/!67!Y'-E6%#--'!/6!/&#!


!<br />

Y$E$-'(! 3'-31-'/$6%+! 7(6E! G#%E'(Q! $%! ^SSJ! /66Q! /&$+! 71(/&#(;! +199#+/$%9! /&'/! +A#%)$%9! /&#!<br />

#L1$='-#%/!67!JaFJ!E$--$6%!


!<br />

$%! /&#! 3(6A! C,xSFSJD! '%)! $%/#+/$%#! C,xSFSSJD! I$/&! 26/&! /(#'/E#%/! )6+#+F! g6I#(! H%/#(62'3/#(!<br />

%1E2#(+!$%!/&#!3(6A!C,xSFSSJD!'%)!$%/#+/$%#!C,lSFJSD!76(!/&#!SF_p!/(#'/E#%/!'+!I#--!'+!&$9&#(!<br />

%1E2#(+! 67! g'3/62'3$--$! C,xSFSJD! '%)! ?$7$)62'3/#($'! C,xSFSWD! I$/&! /&#! +'E#! )6+'9#! I#(#!<br />

761%)F!86(#6=#(;!/&#!SFUp!)6+'9#!67!/&#!MG*!/#%)#)!/6!$%3(#'+#!/&#!g'3/62'3$--$!361%/!$%!/&#!<br />

+E'--!$%/#+/$%#!C,lSFSRDF!<br />

:&#!(#+1-/+!'3&$#=#)!'(#!+&6I%!$%!/&#!76--6I$%9!U!/'2-#+!Cgq3Q+/>)/!'%)!:&#62'-);!^SSKDO!<br />

!<br />

:'2-#!JF!"#+1-/+!67!='($61+!+6)$1E!)$76(E'/#!CMG*D!)6+'9#+!6%!N'EA0-62'3/#(!$%&$2$/$6%!Cp!<br />

A6+$/$=#!+'EA-#+D<br />

! N6%/(6-! MG*!SFUp! MG*!SF_p!<br />

N(6A!CE$3(62$6-FD! _S! S! S!<br />

5%/#+/$%#!CE$3(62$6-FD! `S! ^S! S!<br />

8#'/!C+#(6-FD! `S! S! S!<br />

!<br />

:'2-#! ^F! "#+1-/+! 67! ='($61+! +6)$1E! )$76(E'/#! CMG*D! )6+'9#+! 6%! Y'-E6%#--'! $%&$2$/$6%! Cp!<br />

A6+$/$=#!+'EA-#+D!<br />

! N6%/(6-! MG*!SFUp! MG*!SF_p!<br />

N(6A!CE$3(62$6-FD! ^S! S! S!<br />

5%/#+/$%#!CE$3(62$6-FD! ^S! S! S!<br />

*'#3#+!CE$3(62$6-FD! ^W! S! S!<br />

8#'/!C+#(6-FD! S! S! S!<br />

!<br />

:'2-#!UF!"#+1-/+!67!E$3(62$6-69$3'-!$%=#+/$9'/$6%!67!/&#!$%/#+/$%#!CN*


!<br />

)$76(E'/#!/(#'/E#%/!$EA(6=#)!2(6$-#(!I#$9&/!9'$%!20!_FWp!/6!JSFUp!36EA'(#)!/6!/&#!%#9'/$=#!<br />

36%/(6-F!?'+#)!6%!/&#!HEA$($3'-!"1-#!'--!)$76(E'/#!/(#'/#)!9(61A+!)$77#(#)!+/'/$+/$3'--0!7(6E!/&#!<br />

%#9'/$=#! 36%/(6-! CçéUDF! G$76(E'/#! 71(/&#(E6(#! $EA(6=#)! 7##)! 36%=#(+$6%! ('/$6! 20! RF_p!<br />

C)6+'9#O!SFJpD;!J^FSp!CSFUpD!'%)!JJFap!CSFWpD!36EA'(#)!/6!/&#!%#9'/$=#!36%/(6-!9(61AF!:&#!<br />

(#+1-/+!'(#!+1EE'($P#)!$%!:'2-#!aF!<br />

!<br />

:'2-#!aF!G6+#!)#A#%)#%/!A#(76(E'%3#!67!2(6$-#(!7#)!I$/&!)$76(E'/#!<br />

! N6%/(6-! SFJp!G$76(E'/#! SFUp!G$76(E'/#! SFWp!G$76(E'/#!<br />

[#$9&/;!)'0!^_!}9{! KSaéJW! JS__éJW! JSRKéJK! JSUKéJ`!<br />

[#$9&/;!)'0!U`!}9{! J`R^é^S! JKKUéJK! ^Saaé^a! ^S_Wé^`!<br />

*N"! JF`a! JFRS! JF_^! JF_U!<br />

Y1(=$='-!('/#!}p{! KaFU! JSS! JSS! JSS!<br />

H?5! ^aR! US^! U^W! U^R!<br />

!<br />

:&#+#!7$%)$%9+!-#')!/6!/&#!36%3-1+$6%!/&'/!'))$/$6%!67!)$76(E'/#!36%+$)#('2-0!$EA(6=#+!A61-/(0!<br />

A#(76(E'%3#! 20! $%3(#'+$%9! -$=#! I#$9&/! '%)! (#)13$%9! 7##)! 36%+1EA/$6%! '%)! /&1+! 7##)!<br />

36%=#(+$6%;! 36EA'(#)! /6! '! %#9'/$=#! 36%/(6-F! :&#! 2#+/! (#+1-/+! $%! (#+A#3/! 67! /&#+#! A'('E#/#(+;!<br />

3'-31-'/#)!'+!'!H1(6A#'%!?(6$-#(!5%)#T!CH?5D;!I#(#!62/'$%#)!76(!/&#!)6+'9#+!67!SFUp!'%)!SFWp!<br />

)$76(E'/#F!:&#!H?5!76(!SFUp!)$76(E'/#!$%3-1+$6%!$EA(6=#)!20!E6(#!/&'%!UJp!36EA'(#)!/6!/&#!<br />

%#9'/$=#!36%/(6-!9(61AF!<br />

Y6)$1E! )$76(E'/#! &'+! 2##%! 71(/&#(! /#+/#)! 1%)#(! /&#! '++1EA/$6%! 67! $EA(6=#)! A(6/#$%!<br />

)$9#+/$2$-$/0!$%!A61-/(0F!:&#(#76(#!'!%1/($#%/!E'/($T!'AA(6'3&!&'+!2##%!'AA-$#)!'/!/&#!?'%9Q6Q!<br />

b%$E'-!"#+#'(3&!N#%/#(;!:&'$-'%)!$%!6()#(!/6!#='-1'/#!/&#!#77#3/+!67!+6)$1E!)$76(E'/#!6%!$/+!<br />

A6/#%/$'-!/6!76(E1-'/#!)$#/+!I$/&!-6I#(!E#/'26-$P'2-#!#%#(90!-#=#-+!'%)!)$9#+/$2-#!'E$%6!'3$)+!<br />

CGbbDF!!<br />

J`S!%#I-0!&'/3&#)!E'-#!2(6$-#(!3&$3Q+!I#(#!('%)6E-0!'--63'/#)!/6!U!/(#'/E#%/+!I$/&!)$77#(#%/!<br />

8H! '%)! +6)$1E! )$76(E'/#! -#=#-+! ! C_! (#A-$3'/$6%+D;! A(#A'(#)! '+! 76--6I+O! ! C5D! A6+$/$=#! 36%/(6-!<br />

CA('3/$3'-! 36(%Z+60! )$#/D;! C55D! %#9'/$=#! 36%/(6-! CZRW! Q3'-XQ9! 8H! '%)! Z^FSp! GbbD! '%)! C555D!<br />

%#9'/$=#!36%/(6-!s!MG*!'/!UFS!Q9X/F!<br />

G1($%9!/&#!9(6I#(!A#($6)!C)'0!J`ZUWD;!MG*!9'=#!+$9%$7$3'%/!$EA(6=#E#%/+!C,xSFSWD!$%!I#$9&/!<br />

9'$%!C`R!9!'%)!J^a!9!'26=#!%#9'/$=#!'%)!A6+$/$=#!36%/(6-+;!(#+A#3/$=#-0D!V!C:'2-#!WDF!MG*!'-+6!<br />

+&6I#)! %1E#($3'-!$EA(6=#E#%/+!$%!*N"! CW! A6$%/+! 6=#(! /&#! %#9'/$=#! 36%/(6-! '%)! UFK! A6$%/+!<br />

6=#(! /&#! A6+$/$=#! 36%/(6-DF!d=#(! /&#! /6/'-! A#($6)! CSZUW! )'0+D;! /&#+#! (#+A6%+#+!/#%)#)! /6! 2#!<br />

+$9%$7$3'%/! C,lSFSKD;! 21/!MG*! +/$--! (#+1-/#)! $%! %1E#($3'-!$EA(6=#E#%/+!$%! I#$9&/! 9'$%! CRa! 9!<br />

'%)!JU_!9!6=#(!%#9'/$=#!'%)!A6+$/$=#!36%/(6-+;!(#+A#3/$=#-0Dm!'%)!$EA(6=#)!*N"!$%!/&#!MG*Z<br />

9(61A!C^F^!A6$%/+!6=#(!%#9'/$=#!36%/(6-!'%)!JF^!A6$%/+!6=#(!/&#!A6+$/$=#!36%/(6-DF!:&#+#!(#+1-/+!<br />

+199#+/!/&'/!/&#!1+#!67!+6)$1E!)$76(E'/#!$%!2(6$-#(!)$#/+!$+!=$'2-#!$%!1/$-$P$%9!'='$-'2-#!%1/($#%/!<br />

(#+61(3#+! E6(#! #77$3$#%/-0;! A6++$2-0! '-+6! 2#3'1+#! 67! -#++! #%#(90! 2#$%9! 1+#)! 7(6E! /&#! 91/!<br />

E$3(67-6('!V!I&$3&!&'+!2##%!#+/$E'/#)!/6!1+#!1A!/6!_p!67!/&#!%#/!#%#(90!)#-$=#(#)!/&(619&!/&#!<br />

)$#/!C]#%+#%;!JKK`DF!<br />

:&#!E6)#!67!'3/$6%!67!/&#!'3$)$7$#(!$%!A61-/(0!$+!E'$%-0!)1#!/6!$/+!'%/$E$3(62$'-!'3/$6%;!1%-$Q#!<br />

$%!A$9+!I&#(#!6%#!67!/&#!Q#0!'3/$=$/$#+!$+!/&#!(#)13/$6%!67!+/6E'3&!A4!CG#+'$!#/!'-F;!^SSRDF!5%!<br />

/&#!/($'-+!)$+31++#)!'26=#;!/&#!7$%'-!26)0!I#$9&/!67!/&#!2(6$-#(!3&$3Q#%+!7#)!)$#/+!I$/&!)612-#Z<br />

+'-/+!I'+!+$9%$7$3'%/-0!$%3(#'+#);!I&$-#!/&#!*N"!I'+!'-+6!$EA(6=#)!Z!(#+1-/$%9!$%!'%!$EA(6=#)!<br />

H1(6A#'%! ?(6$-#(! 5%)#TF! b))$/$6%'--0;! 6/&#(! /($'-+! &'=#! +&6I%! $EA(6=#)! &#'-/&! +/'/1+! $%!<br />

3&$3Q#%+;! '+! )#E6%+/('/#)! 20! '! +$9%$7$3'%/-0! $EA(6=#)! 91/! E$3(67-6('! V! (#7-#3/#)! $%! -6I#(!<br />

H%/#(62'3/#(! %1E2#(+! '%)! &$9&! g'3/62'3$--$! '%)! ?$7$)62'3/#($'! 361%/+! Cgq3Q+/>)/! '%)!<br />

:&#62'-);!^SSKDF!<br />

!<br />

:'2-#!WF!M1/($#%/!E'/($T!36%3#A/!$%!2(6$-#(!9(6I#(X7$%$+&#(!)$#/!C)'0!J`ZUWD!I$/&!6(!I$/&61/!MG*!<br />

:(#'/E#%/!! [#$9&/!9'$%;!9! *##)!$%/'Q#;!9! *N"!<br />

,6+$/$=#!36%/(6-!<br />

M#9'/$=#!36%/(6-!<br />

M#9'/$=#!36%/(6-!s!MG*!<br />

'2! ,xSFSW!<br />

JW^J 2 !<br />

JWW`2!<br />

J_aW ' !<br />

^R_R!<br />

^`W^!<br />

^KUS!<br />

JF`^J!<br />

JF`U^!<br />

JFR`^!<br />

!<br />

505


!<br />

6,34%#%)/! NF! '%)! :&#62'-)! ,F! C^SSKD! H77#3/! 67! '! 76(E$3! '3$)Z+6)$1E!76(E'/#! A(#E$T/1(#! 6%!<br />

Y'-E6%#--';! N'EA0-62'3/#(! '%)! 71(/&#(! 91/! E$3(62$6/'! $%! 2(6$-#(+F! ,(63##)$%9+! '%)!<br />

b2+/('3/+!67!/&#!JR /& !H1(6A#'%!Y0EA6+$1E!6%!,61-/(0!M1/($/$6%;!AF!^a_F!<br />

gq3Q+/>)/! NF! C^SJJD! :&#! 1+#! 67! +6)$1E! )$76(E'/#! $%! 2(6$-#(! %1/($/$6%! V! '! %1/($#%/! E'/($T!<br />

'AA(6'3&F!Y12E$//#)!/6!J`/& !,61-/(0!M1/($/$6%!Y0EA6+$1E;!:1(Q#0F!<br />

gq3Q+/>)/!NF!'%)!:&#62'-)!,F!C^SJJD!G6+#!)#A#%)#%/!#77#3/+!6%!2(6$-#(!A#(76(E'%3#;!AAF!`UZ<br />

`RF! 5%O! Y/'%)'()+! 76(! '3$)$7$#(+! V! ,($%3$A-#+! 76(! /&#! 1+#! 67! 6(9'%$3! '3$)+! $%! '%$E'-!<br />

%1/($/$6%!Cgq3Q+/>)/;!NF!#)FD!M6//$%9&'E!%9#/0,(!.4'&.'!50O!__ZRWF!<br />

8(6P!àF!C^SSWD!d(9'%$3!'3$)+!'+!A6/#%/$'-!'-/#(%'/$=#+!/6!'%/$2$6/$3!9(6I/&!A(6E6/#(+!76(!A$9+F!<br />

\)7"&.'3(4&(>%0;(>0%)9./4%&(16O!J_KZJ`^F!<br />

!<br />

506


!<br />

.$++3&#(! NF*F;! [$%/#(! ,F;! .#(+A6&-! ]F;! Y/('/E'%%ZY#-Q#! ]F;! 1(#%!'17!)$#!g#$+/1%9#%!<br />

=6%!?(6$-#(%!1%)!g#9#&#%%#%F!\0.647(5`0(['5#`


!<br />

The effect of dietary lysine levels on growth performance and immunity<br />

parameters in Japanese quail<br />

5F!4'eQ&6)')')$ u! ;!8F!Y&$='P');!4F!86('==#e;!bF!à'(#Z+&'&%#& !<br />

G#A'(/E#%/!67!b%$E'-!Y3$#%3#;!*'31-/0!67!b9($31-/1(#!'%)!M'/1('-!"#+61(3#+;!!<br />

:#&('%!


!<br />

76(!E6(/'-$/0!'%)!(#A(#+#%/+!9('E+!67!7##)!36%+1E#)!20!'--!2$()+!$%!'!A#%!)$=$)#)!20!9('E+!67!<br />

?[!9'$%!A#(!A#%F!<br />

!b/!^J!)!67!'9#;!U!2$()+!7(6E!#'3&!+#T!I#(#!I#$9&#)!'%)!366A#)!J^!&!2#76(#!A(63#++$%9F!n1'$-+!<br />

I#(#!+-'19&/#(#)!20!+#=#($%9!/&#!e191-'(!=#$%;!A-13Q#)!E#3&'%$3'--0!'7/#(!&6/!I'/#(!+3'-)$%9F!<br />

N'(3'++#+!I#(#!#=$+3#('/#)!20!&'%)F![#$9&/+!I#(#!$%)$=$)1'--0!(#36()#)!76(!/&#!3'(3'++;!/&$9&;!<br />

2(#'+/;!-$=#(!'%)!'-$E#%/'(0!/('3/!C*'/17#!#/!'-F;!^SSaDF!<br />

Blood Biochemical Parameters: b/!G'0!Ja;!/I6!2$()+!A#(!+#T!I#(#!('%)6E-0!+#-#3/#)!/&#%!<br />

JFSZEg!+1+A#%+$6%!CSFWp!=6-X=6-D!67!Y"?N!I'+!$%e#3/#)!$%/6!/&#!2(#'/&!E1+3-#F!b/!G'0!JK;!<br />

2$()+!I#(#!2-#)!/6!36--#3/!+#(1EF!b--!/&#!+'EA-#+!I#(#!$%312'/#)!'/!URëN!76(!6%#!&61(!/6!'$)!<br />

3-6//$%9! '%)! (#/('3/$6%! /&#%! 3#%/($719#)! '/! JWêSSS! 9! 76(! W! E$%! 76(! 36--#3/$6%! 67! +#('F! :&#!<br />

&'#E'99-1/$%'/$6%! '%/$26)0! C4bD! /$/(#! I'+! #+/$E'/#)! 20! '! E$3(6Z&'#E'99-1/$%'/$6%! E#/&6)!!<br />

1+$%9!/I676-)!+#($'-!)$-1/$6%+!67!+#('!C?$+I'+!#/!'-F;!^SS_D!<br />

b/!JK!)'0+!2-66)!+'EA-#+!I#(#!36--#3/#)!7(6E!/I6!2$()+!$%!#'3&!#TA#($E#%/'-!1%$/+!$%/6!/&#!<br />

&#A'($%! P#)! /12#+! 7(6E! /&#! I$%9! =#$%F! :&#! +'EA-#+! I#(#! /('%+7#((#)! /6! -'26('/6(0! 76(!<br />

E#'+1($%9!A'3Q#)!3#--!=6-1E#!'%)!)$77#(#%/$'-!2-66)!3#--!361%/+F!<br />

Statistical Analyses:<br />

G'/'!$%!/&$+!#TA#($E#%/!I#(#!#='-1'/#)!20!bMd.b!$%!'!36EA-#/#-0!('%)6E$P#)!)#+$9%F!b--!<br />

)'/'!I#(#!#T'E$%#)!76(!%6(E'-$/0!)$+/($21/$6%!76(!bMd.b!'%'-0+$+F!b--!)'/'!I#(#!'%'-0P#)!20!<br />

/&#!hg8!A(63#)1(#!67!YbY!CJKK_DF!g0+$%#!#77#3/+!C,!!SFSWD!I#(#!+#A'('/#)!1+$%9!/&#!G1%3'%!<br />

E1-/$A-#!('%9#!/#+/!6A/$6%!67!YbY!CJKK_D!I$/&!'%!!67!SFSWF!!<br />

Result and Discussion<br />

Live performance<br />

G$#/'(0!-0+$%#!'77#3/+!6%!-$=#!A#(76(E'%3#!$+!A(#+#%/#)!$%!:'2-#!^F!:&#(#!I#(#!%6!+$9%$7$3'%/!<br />

)$77#(#%3#+!C,!kSFSWD!$%!26)0!I#$9&/!67!L1'$-+!3&$3Q!'/!$%$/$'/$6%!67!/&#!#TA#($E#%/F!<br />

!G$#/'(0!-0+$%#!+$9%$7$3'%/-0!CAxSFSWD!'77#3/#)! 26)0!I#$9&/!'/!R;!Ja;!'%)!^J!)'0+!C:'2-#!^D!F!<br />

?6)0!I#$9&/!67!L1'$-+!7#)!'!)$#/!&$9&#(!/&'%!JFaW!p!)$#/'(0!-0+$%#!I'+!+$9%$7$3'%/-0!&#'=$#(!<br />

/&'%!/&6+#!7#)!'!)$#/!-6I#(!/&'%!JFaW!p!)$#/'(0!-0+$%#F!26)0!I#$9&/!9'$%!+$9%$7$3'%/-0!CAxSFSWD!<br />

'77#3/#)!20!-0+$%#!-#=#-+;!$%!9#%#('-!L1'$-+!7#)!7!JFaW!p!67!)$#/'(0!-0+$%#!&')!/&#!&#'=$#+/!26)0!<br />

I#$9&/! 9'$%F! 86(/'-$/0! I'+! I$/&$%! /&#! %6(E'-! ('%9#! '%)! %6/! '77#3/#)! 20! +#T! 21/! I#(#!<br />

+$9%$7$3'%/-0!'77#3/#)!20!g0+!/(#'/E#%/+m!2#$%9!-6I#(!76(!L1'$-+!7#)!&$9&#(!-0+$%#!-#=#-+F!<br />

:&#!)$#/'(0!-0+$%#;!+$9%$7$3'%/-0!'77#3/#)!/6/'-!7##)!$%/'Q#!C:'2-#!^D!2#$%9!&$9&#(!76(!L1'$-+!7#)!<br />

/&#!-6I#(!-#=#-+!67!-0+$%#!2#3'1+#!!L1'$-+!/&'/!)$)!%6/!9#/!')#L1'/#!-0+$%#!$%!)$#/!$%3(#'+#)!!7##)!<br />

$%/'Q#!/6!36EA#%+'/#!-6I#(!!-0+$%#!$%/'Q#!CG6P$#(!5$$!#/!'-F;!^SS`!!N6(P6!#/!'-F;!^SS^DF!!!<br />

G$#/'(0! -#=#-+! 67! -0+$%#! +$9%$7$3'%/-0! '77#3/#)! *N"F! *N"! I'+! %1E#($3'--0! $EA(6=#)! 20!<br />

$%3(#'+$%9!$%!)$#/'(0!-0+$%#!-#=#-!7(6E!J!/6!JFaWp!21/!I'+!%6/!$EA(6=#)!'7/#(!JFaW!p!)$#/'(0!<br />

-0+$%#F! d%! /&#! 6/&#(! &'%);! 26)0! I#$9&/! 9'$%! I'+! +$9%$7$3'%/-0! $EA(6=#)! I&#%! )$#/'(0! -#=#-!<br />

2#/I##%! JFaW! p! '%)! JF_S! p! F! :&#! +$E$-'(! (#+1-/! I'+! (#A6(/#)! 20! G6P$#(! #/! '-F! C^SS`D! I&6!<br />

+199#+/#)!&$9&#(!-#=#-+!67!-0+$%#!36EA'(#)!/6!MN"!76(!2(6$-#(+!7(6E!aK!/6!_U!)!F!4$9&#(!?[!<br />

9'$%! I'+! (#A6(/#)! 20! $%3(#'+$%9! $%! )$#/'(0! -0+$%#! I$/&! $EA(6=#E#%/! $%! 26/&! 7##)! $%/'Q#! '%)!<br />

7##)! 36%=#(+$6%! C*'/17#! #/! '-F;! ^SSa! '%)! Y/#(-$%9! #/! '-F;! ^SSWD! I&#(#'+! 6/&#(! (#A6(/#)! /&'/!<br />

$%3(#'+$%9! g0+! 6%-0! $EA(6=#)! 7##)! 36%=#(+$6%! I$/&61/! '77#3/$%9! 7##)! $%/'Q#! CN6(P6! #/! '-F;!<br />

^SS^D!'%)!5%!/&#!A(#+#%/!+/1)0!I#!761%)!/&#!#77#3/!67!-0+$%#!6%!26)0!I#$9&/!20!#77#3/$%9!6%!/&#!<br />

26/&!7##)!$%/'Q#!'%)!7##)!36%=#(+$6%F!!<br />

:&#!#77#3/+!67!)$#/'(0!-0+$%#!'%)!+#T!6%!3'(3'++!3&'('3/#($+/$3+!'/!^J!)!67!'9#!'(#!A(#+#%/#)!$%!<br />

:'2-#!UF!G$#/'(0!-#=#-+!67!-0+$%#;!+$9%$7$3'%/-0!'77#3/#)!0$#-)+!67!2(#'+/!'%)!/&$9&!21/!+#T!&')!%6!<br />

+$9%$7$3'%/! #77#3/! 6%! 3'(3'++! A#(76(E'%3#F! M#$/&#(! )$#/'(0! -#=#-! 67! -0+$%#! %6(! +#T! &')! '!<br />

+$9%$7$3'%/!#77#3/!6%!-$=#(!'%)!9'+/(6$%/#+/$%'-!/('3/!0$#-)F!!<br />

:&#!#77#3/+!67!)$#/'(0!-0+$%#!'%)!+#T!67!L1'$-!6%!A'3Q#)!3#--!=6-1E#!'/!^J!)!67!'9#!$+!A(#+#%/#)!<br />

$%! :'2-#! aF! G$#/'(0! -0+$%#! -#=#-! &')! %6! +$9%$7$3'%/! #77#3/! 6%! A'3Q#)! 3#--! =6-1E#! C,N.D;! /&#!<br />

E'-#+! C! URFWJ! pD! &')! E6(#! 2-66)! A'3Q#)! 3#--! =6-1E#! /&'%! /&6+#! 7(6E! 7#E'-#+! C! UJFWapD!<br />

C:'2-#!aD!F!!<br />

!<br />

509


!<br />

:&#! +#T! &'+! %6! +$9%$7$3'%/! #77#3/! 6%! (#+A6%+#! /6! +&##A! (#)! 2-66)! 3#--+! ! CY"?ND! 21/! )$#/'(0!<br />

-0+$%#!&')!+$9%$7$3'%/!C,xSFSWD!#77#3/!6%!(#+A6%+#!/6!+&##A!(#)!2-66)!3#--+!!CY"?ND!+1+A#%+$6%!!<br />

'+!&1E#('-!$EE1%$/0!67!L1'$-+m!2#$%9!&$9&#+/!76(!L1'$-+!7#)!JFaWp!)$#/'(0!-0+$%#!C:'2-#!aDF!!<br />

5%!/&#!A(#+#%/!+/1)0;!2(6Q#%Z-$%#!6(!YA-$%#!(#9(#++$6%!I'+!%6/!A#(76(E#)!/6!)#/#(E$%#!/&#!#T'3/!<br />

(#L1$(#E#%/!$%!g0+;!21/!61(!)'/'!+199#+/!$/!3'%!2#!#+/$E'/#)!/6!2#!JFaW!p!I&#%!7##)!#77$3$#%30;!<br />

9(6I/&;!'%)!26)0!36EA6+$/$6%!A#(76(E'%3#+!'(#!36%+$)#(#)!'%)!E'0!2#!'/!-#'+/!JF_S!p!I&#%!<br />

2(#'+/! E#'/! A(6A#(/$#+! '(#! /'Q#%! $%/6! '3361%/F! G$#/'(0! g0+! 7#)! %#'(! M"N! CJKKaD!<br />

(#36EE#%)'/$6%+! )$)! %6/! $%/#('3/! I$/&! $EE1%$/0! 67! 3&$3Q+F! *1(/&#(E6(#;! &1E#('-! $EE1%#!<br />

+0+/#E! 71%3/$6%+! 67! &#'-/&0! L1'$-+! I#(#! $EA(6=#)! 20! 76(/$70$%9! )$#/+! I$/&! -0+$%#! -#=#-+! $%!<br />

#T3#++! 67! M"N! CJKKaD! (#36EE#%)'/$6%+F! *1/1(#! (#+#'(3&;! &6I#=#(;! +&61-)! '))(#++! -0+$%#!<br />

%##)+!76(!$EE1%#!+0+/#E!71%3/$6%+!67!L1'$-+!(#'(#)!$%!36%=#%/$6%'-!#%=$(6%E#%/+!6(!)1($%9!'%!<br />

$%7#3/$61+!3&'--#%9#F!<br />

!<br />

Acknowledgements<br />

:&$+!+/1)0!I'+!71%)#)!20!G#A'(/E#%/!67!b%$E'-!Y3$#%3#;!*'31-/0!67!b9($31-/1(#!'%)!M'/1('-!<br />

"#+61(3#+;!:#&('%!


!<br />

:'2-#!JF!5%9(#)$#%/!'%)!3'-31-'/#)!36EA6+$/$6%!67!)$#/+!!Cp;!'+Z7#)!2'+$+D!<br />

5/#E!<br />

!-0+$%#!CpD!<br />

JFSS! JFJW! JFU! JFaW! JF_! JFRW!<br />

5%9(#)$#%/;!p! ! ! ! ! ! !<br />

N6(%!!! W^FUa! W^FUa! W^FUa! W^FUa! W^FUa! W^FUa!<br />

Y602#'%!E#'-Ca`p!D! ^_F^a! ^_F^a! ^_F^a! ^_F^a! ^_F^a! ^_F^a!<br />

N6(%!9-1/#%!E#'-! JWFJ_! JWFJ_! JWFJ_! JWFJ_! JWFJ_! JWFJ_!<br />

N'-3$1E!3'(26%'/#!! JFU_! JFU_! JFU_! JFU_! JFU_! JFU_!<br />

G$3'-3$1E!A&6+A&'/#! SF``! SF``! SF``! SF``! SF``! SF``!<br />

Y6)$1E!3&-6($)#!! SFJ_! SFJ_! SFJ_! SFJ_! SFJ_! SFJ_!<br />

Y6)$1E!2$3'(26%'/#! SFJK! SFJK! SFJK! SFJK! SFJK! SFJK!<br />

.$/'E$%!A(#E$T J! SF^W! SF^W! SF^W! SF^W! SF^W! SF^W!<br />

8$%#('-!E$%#('-^! SF^W! SF^W! SF^W! SF^W! SF^W! SF^W!<br />

gZg0+F4N-! S! SFJK! SFUK! SFWK! SF`S! JFSS!<br />

h-%!! SFRW! SF_S! SFaW! SFUS! SFJW! S!<br />

gZ:&(! SFJR! SFJR! SFJR! SFJR! SFJR! SFJR!<br />

GgZ8#/! SFSR! SFSR! SFSR! SFSR! SFSR! SFSR!<br />

5%#(/!7$--#(U ! ^FJ`! ^FJa! ^FSK! ^FSa! JFK`! JFKU!<br />

:6/'-! JSS! JSS! JSS! JSS! JSS! JSS!<br />

N'-31-'/#)!36EA6+$/$6%! ! ! ! ! ! !<br />

b8H;!!!!Q3'-XQ9! ^KSS! ^KSS! ^KSS! ^KSS! ^KSS! ^KSS!<br />

N,;!p! ^_! ^_! ^_! ^_! ^_! ^_!<br />

g0+;!p! JFSS! JFJW! JFU! JFaW! JF_! JFRW!<br />

8#/;!p! SFWW! SFWW! SFWW! SFWW! SFWW! SFWW!<br />

8#/!s!N0+;!p! SF`^! SF`^! SF`^! SF`^! SF`^! SF`^!<br />

:&(;!p! JFJ^! JFJ^! JFJ^! JFJ^! JFJ^! JFJ^!<br />

M6%A&0/'/#!!,;!p! SFU! SFU! SFU! SFU! SFU! SFU!<br />

N'-3$1E;!p! SF`! SF`! SF`! SF`! SF`! SF`!<br />

Y6)$1E;!p! SFJW! SFJW! SFJW! SFJW! SFJW! SFJW!<br />

J ! .$/'E$%! A(#E$T! $%3-1)#! A#(! Q$-69('E! 67! )$#/O! =$/'E$%! b! C=$/'E$%! b! '3#/'/#D;! U_SS! 5


!<br />

!<br />

:'2-#!^F H77#3/+!67!)$#/'(0!g0+!!6%!26)0!I#$9&/;!7##)!$%/'Q#!'%)!7##)!36%=#(+$6%!67!L1'$-!7(6E!SZ^J!67!<br />

'9# J !!!<br />

.'($'2-#!!<br />

G$#/'(0!!-0+$%#!;!p!CGgD!<br />

JFSS! JFJW! JFUS! JFaW! JF_S! JFRW!<br />

YH8^<br />

N. U! ,Z='-1#!<br />

5%$/$'-!26)0!I#$9&/;!9! JRFR_ ! JRF_^!<br />

JRF_`! JRFW_! JRFWU! JRF_a! SFa^! ^FU`! SFKRS!<br />

?6)0!I#$9&/;!9! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !<br />

R!)! ^RFKJ 2! ^`FR_ 2! ^`FSR 2! UJFW_ '! UJFJW '! USFJ_ '2 JFa_! aFKW! SFSS_!<br />

Ja!)! WSFK_ 3! WRF^W 23! W_FK_ 2! _^F^^'! _SFJW '2! _JF``'! ^FR`! aFRR! SFSSS^!<br />

^J)! KUF`U 3! JSSFSJ 23 KRF_a 3! JJSF_^'! JSRFa`'2 JJSFWJ ' WFJ^! aFK_! SFSSSW!<br />

?6)0!I#$9&/!9'$%! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !<br />

?[h;!SZ^J);!9! R^F^R 3! `JF`U 2! `aFJU '2 KUFS_ '! `KFKa '2! K^F`R '! WF`a! _F`^! SFSSSW!<br />

*##)!$%/'Q#! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !<br />

*5;!SZ^J);!9! aUF^R ' ! aUF__ ' ! aJF^`'2 aSFUK 2 aSFUR 2 ! UKFaU 2 JF``! aFWU! SFSWK!<br />

*##)!36%=#(+$6%!('/$6! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !<br />

*N";!SZ^J);!9O9! UF^U ' ! UFJa ' ! UFJ^'!<br />

^FWJ 2 ! ^FWa 2 ! ^F_R 2 ! SFJW! WF^a! xSFSSSJ!<br />

86(/'-$/0;!p!! UF^'! ^FW '! JFK '2! JFa 2! SFK`2! JFU 2! SF_W! JaFW_ xSFSSSJ!<br />

J !8#'%+!I$/&!)$77#(#%/!+1A#(+3($A/+!I$/&$%!/&#!+'E#!(6I!)$77#(!+$9%$7$3'%/-0!C,xSFSWDF!<br />

^! Y/'%)'()!#((6(!<br />

U !N6#77$3$#%/!67!='($'/$6%!<br />

!<br />

:'2-#!UF H77#3/+!67!)$#/'(0!-0+!!'%)!+#T!6%!(#-'/$=#!3'(3'++!A'(/!I#$9&/+!67!!L1'$-! J !<br />

.'($'2-#!!<br />

G$#/'(0!!-0+$%#!;!p!CGgD! Y#TCYD! Y$9%$7$3'%3#!<br />

JFSS! JFJW! JFUS! JFaW! JF_S! JFRW! 7#E'-# E'-# G g Y! Gg!êY 3=^! YH8 U !<br />

N'(3'++!<br />

`KF`K 3! `WFSJ 23 K_FaR '23 JSUFJU ' JS^FK^'<br />

KKF^W '2! K`FRW ! K_FRU u MY! MY! _FK_! _F`S!<br />

I#$9&/;!9!<br />

?(#'+/!0$#-);!<br />

^UFJa 3! ^UFaW 23 ^aF`a '23 ^aFaK '23 ^WFKK '! ^WF^S '2! ^UFKU 2! ^WFJJ ' u u! MY! RFUR! JF`S!<br />

p!<br />

:&$9&!0$#-);!<br />

JaFaa 3! JWFJ^23 JWF^^23 JaFKK 23! J_FU^'! JWFKK '2! JaF^K 2! J_FaS ' u u! MY! _FWW! JFSS!<br />

p!<br />

g$=#(!0$#-);!<br />

UFS_! UFK^! ^F`_! ^FR`! ^FKW! ^FRK! ^F`K! ^FKR M MY! MY! JSF^a SFUS!<br />

p!<br />

Y<br />

h5!0$#-);!p! J^FR_! J^FaU JJFKU! JJFK^! JJFKK! JJF_a! J^FSJ! J^F^J M MY!<br />

Y<br />

MY! JSFWR JF^`!<br />

!<br />

:'2-#!aF!H77#3/+!67!)$#/'(0!g0+!'%)!+#T!6%!E6(/'-$/0;!,N.!'%)!&1E#('-!$EE1%$/0!67!L1'$-!7(6E!SZ^J!67!'9# J !!<br />

Y$9%$7$3'%3#!67!/&#!<br />

G$#/'(0!!-0+$%#!;!pCGgD! +#TCYD!<br />

.'($'2-#!!<br />

#77#3/+!<br />

YH8 U!<br />

JFSS! JFJW JFUS JFaW JF_S JFRW 7#E'-#! E'-# Gg! Y! Gg!êY!<br />

,'3Q#)!3#--!<br />

UUF`R!UUFa` UaFWJ U_FaJ UUF_J UWF^_ UJFWa 2! URFWJ ' MY! u! MY! JSF`W UFR_!<br />

=6-1E#;!!<br />

!"#+A6%+#!/6!<br />

WF_^2! RF^W '2 RFUR '2 `FJ^' RF_^' _F`R '2 RFJ_! RFJ^! u! MY MY! ^UFJR JF_W!<br />

Y"?N!<br />

J !8#'%+!I$/&!)$77#(#%/!+1A#(+3($A/+!I$/&$%!/&#!+'E#!(6I!)$77#(!+$9%$7$3'%/-0!C,xSFSWDF!<br />

^! N6#77$3$#%/!67!='($'/$6%!<br />

U !Y/'%)'()!#((6(!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

512


!<br />

Citrex efficacy on a natural challenge with Salmonella spp in broiler chickens<br />

!<br />

NF!hF![$-+E'%%u J ;!*F!*-6(#+ J ;!*F!gF!h'P6%$ J ;!*F!Y$-=#$(' J ;!8F!g6='/6 J !'%)!GF!à'=$#P6^!<br />

J


!<br />

:&#! '$E! 67! /&$+! +/1)0! I'+! /6! #='-1'/#! /&#! #77$3'30! 67! N$/(#T;! 'AA-$#)! $%! )($%Q$%9! I'/#(;! 6%!!<br />

%'/1('-!#TA6+1(#!/6!!"#$%&'##"(+AA!$%!2(6$-#(+F!<br />

Materials And Methods<br />

:&#!#TA#($E#%/!I'+!36%)13/#)!$%!'!36EE#(3$'-!2(6$-#(!7'(E!$%!/&#!Y/'/#!67!"$6!h('%)#!)6!Y1-;!<br />

?('P$-;! I&#(#! '%! $%7#3/$6%! I$/&! !"#$%&'##"( +AA! I'+! )#/#3/#)! 1+$%9! )('9! +I'2+! C?('P$-$'%!<br />

M'/$6%'-! b=$'%! 4#'-/&! ,(69('EDF! :&#! A61-/(0! &61+#! &')! JJ;RSS! N622! 7#E'-#! 2(6$-#(+! 67! ^^!<br />

)'0+!67!'9#F!b/!/&$+!'9#;!+$T/0!Y'-E6%#--'!+AA!A6+$/$=#!2$()+!C3-6'3'-!+I'2+D!I#(#!+#-#3/#)!'%)!<br />

/'99#)F!b/!U^!)'0+!67!'9#;!/&6+#!_S!2$()+!I#(#!('%)6E-0!)$+/($21/#)!$%/6!U!/(#'/E#%/+!I$/&!a!<br />

(#A-$3'/$6%! 67! 7$=#! 2$()+! #'3&m! '%)! 7#)! /&#! +'E#! 36(%Z+60! )$#/! 7(##! 67! '%/$2'3/#($'-! '%)!<br />

'%/$71%9'-!'))$/$=#+F!:&#!/(#'/E#%/+!I#(#!'+!76--6IO!<br />

!<br />

J!Z!,6+$/$=#!36%/(6-F!Y'-E6%#--'!+AA!$%7#3/#)!2$()+F!<br />

^!Z!5%7#3/#)!2$()+!s!aSS!AAE!67!N$/(#T!$%!)($%Q$%9!I'/#(!7(6E!U^!/6!a^!)'0+!67!'9#F!<br />

U!Z!5%7#3/#)!2$()+!s!aWS!AAE!67!N$/(#T!$%!)($%Q$%9!I'/#(!7(6E!UW!/6!a^!)'0+!67!'9#F!<br />

!<br />

N-6'3'-!+I'2+!I#(#!36--#3/#)!7(6E!'--!3&$3Q#%+!'/!^^;!U^!'%)!a^!)'0+!67!'9#F!b--!2$()+!I#(#!<br />

#1/&'%$P#)!'/!a^!)'0+!67!'9#F!!N-6'3'-!+I'2+;!3#3'!'%)!-$=#(!+'EA-#+!I#(#!'+#A/$3'--0!36--#3/#)!<br />

76(!2'3/#($6-69$3'-!'%'-0+#+!'%)!+12E$//#)!76(!!"#$%&'##"!A&#%6/0A$%9;!76--6I$%9!/&#!A(6/636-!<br />

(#36EE#%)#)!20!/&#!8$%$+/(0!67!b9($31-/1(#;!g$=#+/63Q!'%)!Y1AA-0!$%!?('P$-!CWDF!:&#!A(#+#%3#!<br />

6(! '2+#%3#! 67! 36-6%$#+! I$/&! A&#%6/0A$3! 3&'('3/#($+/$3+! 67! !"#$%&'##"(+AA!I#(#!62+#(=#)!'%)!<br />

+12e#3/#)!/6!2$63&#E$3'-!'%'-0+$+F!:&#!$+6-'/#+!67!!"#$%&'##"(+AAF!I#(#!+#%/!/6!/&#!5%+/$/1/#!67!<br />

d+I'-)6!N(1P!g'26('/6(0!C"$6!)#!]'%#$(6;!?('P$-D!76(!/0A$7$3'/$6%F!<br />

:&#! A(#+#%3#X'2+#%3#! 67! !"#$%&'##"! +AA! I'+! 36EA'(#)! 1+$%9! /&#! 3&$Z+L1'(#! /#+/! Cz^D! /6!<br />

)#/#(E$%#!/&#!)$77#(#%3#!'E6%9!/(#'/E#%/+F!Y/'/$+/$3'-!+$9%$7$3'%3#!I'+!'33#A/#)!'/! >!!SFSWF!<br />

:&#!/#+/!I'+!A#(76(E#)!1+$%9!/&#!YbY!+/'/$+/$3'-!A(69('E!=#(+$6%!KFJC_DF!!<br />

Results and Discussion<br />

b/! ^^;! U^! '%)! a^! )'0+! 67! '9#! 3-6'3'-! +I'2! (#+1-/+! +&6I#)! /&'/! aWp! CKX^SD! 67! 2$()+! I#(#!<br />

A6+$/$=#!/6!!"#$%&'##"!+AA!$%!/&#!%6%ZE#)$3'/#)!36%/(6-F!:&#!'))$/$6%!67!aSS!AAE!67!N$/(#T!76(!<br />

JS!)'0+!2#76(#!+-'19&/#(!6(!aWS!AAE!76(!/&#!-'+/!R!)'0+!2#76(#!+-'19&/#(!+$9%$7$3'%/-0!(#)13#)!<br />

/&#!%1E2#(!67!!"#$%&'##"!+AA!A6+$/$=#!2$()+!/6!U!61/!67!^S!'%)!^!61/!67!^S;!(#+A#3/$=#-0!C*$91(#!<br />

JDF! N#3'-! 31-/1(#+! '-+6! +&6I#)! '! +/'/$+/$3'--0! +$9%$7$3'%/! (#)13/$6%! 67! !"#$%&'##"! +AA!<br />

36%/'E$%'/#)! 2$()+! 7(6E! aWp! $%! /&#! A6+$/$=#! 36%/(6-! CKX^SD! /6! JWp! $%! /&#! N$/(#T! /(#'/E#%/+!<br />

CUX^SDF!:&#!$+6-'/$6%!67!!"#$%&'##"!+AA!$%!/&#!-$=#(!I'+!E$%$E'-!'%)!/&#!)$77#(#%3#!62+#(=#)!<br />

2#/I##%! /&#! $%7#3/#)! 2$()+! CJWpD! '%)! /&#! $%7#3/#)! 2$()+! /(#'/#)! I$/&! N$/(#T! CWpD! I'+! %6/!<br />

+$9%$7$3'%/! C:'2-#! JDF! :&#! /I6! +/('$%+! $+6-'/#)! $%! /&#! 36EE#(3$'-! A61-/(0! 7'(E! I#(#! !?(<br />

Y&/'04/4)43! '%)! !?( !'&5/'&-'0


!<br />

UF!!d-$=#$(';!*F!bF;!,'+L1'-6//6;!bF!,F;!Y$-=';![F!,F;!'%)!:6%)6;!HF!NF!^SJSF!N&'('3/#($P'/$6%!67!<br />

!"#$%&'##"(H%/#($/$)$+!$+6-'/#)!7(6E!&1E'%!+'EA-#+F!*66)!"#+F!5%/F!Cb(/$3-#!$%!A(#++D!<br />

aF! ! *#(%í%)#PZ"12$6;! NF;! NF! d()ìî#P;! ]F! b2')Zh6%Pí-#P;! bF! h'(3$'Zh'--#96;! 8F! ,$-'(!<br />

46%(12$';!]F!]6+#!8'--6!'%)!"F!?'-'î'Z*613#F!^SSKF?1/0($3!'3$)Z2'+#)!7##)!'))$/$=#+!&#-A!<br />

A(6/#3/!2(6$-#(!3&$3Q#%+!7(6E!!"#$%&'##"(H%/#($/$)$+!$%7#3/$6%F!,61-/F!Y3$F!``OKaUVKa`F!<br />

WF! 8$%$+/(0! 67! b9($31-/1(#;! g$=#+/63Q! '%)! Y1AA-0F! ?('P$-F! ^SSUF! Y#3(#/'(0! 67! b9($31-/1(#!<br />

G#7#%+#F! M6(E'/$=#! Mï! _^;! b191+/! ^_;! ^SSUFb%'-0/$3'-! E#/&6)+! 76(! E$3(62$6-69$3'-!<br />

'%'-0+$+!76(!677$3$'-!36%/(6-!67!'%$E'-!A(6)13/+!'%)!I'/#(F!aRZW_F!<br />

_F!!YbY!5%+/$/1/#F!^SS^UF!YbYXY:b:!h1$)#!76(!,#(+6%'-!N6EA1/#(+F!.#(+$6%!KFJ!H)$/$6%F!YbY!!!!!!!<br />

5%+/$/1/#!5%3F;!N'(0;!M6(/&!N'(6-$%'F!<br />

RF! ! j6%3$3Q$;! bF;! ?F! 8'P1(Zh6%Q6I+Q';! bF! j('+%6)#2+Q'ZG#A/';! '%)! 8F! N6%/(#('+F! ^SS_F!<br />

H77#3/!67!'%!1-/('2$6/$3!6%!Y'-E6%#--'!/0A&$E1($1E!36-6%$P'/$6%!'%)!2-66)!36EA6+$/$6%!$%!<br />

/1(Q#0+!#TA#($E#%/'--0!3&'--#%9#)F!,61-/F!Y3$F!`WO!JK^!+1AA-F!JF!<br />

:'2-#!JF!H77#3/!67!N$/(#T!6%!!"#$%&'##"(+AA($+6-'/$6%!7(6E!3-6'3'-!+I'2+;!3#3'!'%)!-$=#(!67!<br />

2(6$-#(!3&$3Q#%+!'/!a^!)'0+!67!'9#F!<br />

:(#'/E#%/!<br />

M1E2#(!67!A6+$/$=#+!X!M1E2#(!67!3&$3Q#%!/#+/#)!<br />

N-6'3'-!+I'2+! N#3'! g$=#(!<br />

!"#$%&'##"!+AA!$%7#3/#)!2$()+! KX^S!'! KX^S!'! UX^S!'!<br />

5%7#3/#)!2$()+!s!aSS!AAE!N$/(#Tu!!<br />

C)'0!U^!/&(619&!a^D!<br />

UX^S!2! UX^S!2! JX^S!'!<br />

5%7#3/#)!2$()+!s!aWS!AAE!N$/(#Tu!<br />

C)'0!UW!/&(619&!a^D!<br />

^X^S!2! UX^S!2! JX^S!'!<br />

';!2 8#'%+!I$/&$%!36-1E%+!I$/&!%6!36EE6%!-#//#(!)$77#(!+$9%$7$3'%/-0!C,!SFSWD!<br />

u!N$/(#T!-$L1$)!9$=#%!$%!/&#!)($%Q$%9!I'/#(!<br />

!!!';!2!!M1E2#(+!$%!2'(+!I$/&!%6!36EE6%!-#//#(!)$77#(!+$9%$7$3'%/-0!C,!SFSWD!<br />

*$91(#!JF!,#(3#%/'9#!'%)!%1E2#(!67!3&$3Q#%+!A6+$/$=#!/6!!"#$%&'##"(+AA!)#/#3/#)!20!3-6'3'-!<br />

+I'2+!C%l^SD!'/!^^;!U^!'%)!a^!)'0+!67!'9#F!!<br />

!<br />

!<br />

515


!<br />

Citrex efficacy on the control of Salmonella Enteritidis in broiler chickens<br />

!<br />

NF!hF![$-+E'%%u J ;!*F!*-6(#+ J ;!*F!gF!h'P6%$ J ;!*F!Y$-=#$(' J ;!8F!g6='/6 J !'%)!8F!N6%/(#('+^!<br />

J


!<br />

Materials and Methods<br />

Minimum Inhibitory Concentration (MIC)<br />

:&#! 85N! )#/#(E$%'/$6%! I'+! A#(76(E#)! '336()$%9! /6! /&#! A(6/636-+! 67! /&#! N-$%$3'-! '%)!<br />

g'26('/6(0! Y/'%)'()+! 5%+/$/1/#;!


!<br />

^F!d-$=#$(';!*F!bF;!,'+L1'-6//6;!bF!,F;!Y$-=';![F!,F;!'%)!:6%)6;!HF!NF!^SJSF!N&'('3/#($P'/$6%!67!!"#$%&'##"(<br />

H%/#($/$)$+!$+6-'/#)!7(6E!&1E'%!+'EA-#+F!*66)!"#+F!5%/F!Cb(/$3-#!$%!A(#++D!<br />

UF! N6T! ]F8F;! '%)! ,'=$3F! ^SJSF! b)='%3#+! $%! #%/#(6A'/&69#%! 36%/(6-! $%! A61-/(0! A(6)13/$6%F! ]F! bAA-F!<br />

8$3(62$6-F!JS`O!RaWZRWWF!<br />

aF! 8#');! hF! NF! ^SSSF! ,(6+A#3/+! 76(! y36EA#/$/$=#! #T3-1+$6%y! /(#'/E#%/! /6! 36%/(6-! Y'-E6%#--'+! '%)! 6/&#(!<br />

766)26(%#!A'/&69#%+!$%!A61-/(0F.#/F!]F!JWKOJJJZJ^UF!<br />

WF!4#(#+;!gF;!?F!H%9#-;!4F!bF!


mposite


<strong>Beyaz</strong> <strong>Et</strong> Ilan 16X12.pdf 1 4/29/11 1:18 PM


Feed Additives<br />

Güçlü Yaklaşım<br />

İçme suyu uygulamalarında yenilikçi formüller.<br />

Kanatlı hayvanlar için, içme suyu ile uygulanan çok<br />

özel seçilmiş ve etkileri kanıtlanmış mikro katkı<br />

ürünleri sunuyoruz.<br />

Lohmann Veteriner Ürünleri Sanayi ve Ticaret AŞ.<br />

Ekinciler Cad. Erturk Sok. Onat Plaza No: 4 Kat: 7 D: 15<br />

34810 Kavacık-Beykoz, İstanbul, Türkiye<br />

Phone: +90 216 4255 131, Fax: +90 216 4255 133<br />

Anzeige_AviPro_Granule_tr.indd 1<br />

23.03.2011 14:17:35 Uhr


enviva<br />

TM<br />

EO<br />

Danisco Xylanase<br />

Danisco Animal Nutrition<br />

for healthy nutrition solutions<br />

www.danisco.com/animalnutrition


Cargill Hububat ve Yaðlý Tohumlar Tedarik Zinciri - Türkiye


mposite


Integrate your process<br />

to add maximum value<br />

Our company, a worldwide supplier of<br />

poultry processing systems, has the<br />

process knowledge and extended sales<br />

and service organization to equip and<br />

support you, adding maximum value<br />

to your process.<br />

Working continuously on innovative<br />

technology, we are able to provide<br />

solutions for poultry lines up to 13,500 bph<br />

and systems to create the desired end<br />

products and packing.<br />

We offer solutions for:<br />

• Live bird supply<br />

• Slaughtering, scalding and<br />

evisceration<br />

• Chilling<br />

• Cut-up and deboning<br />

• X-ray bone detection<br />

• Portioning and slicing<br />

• Weighing, grading and batching<br />

• Weigh price labeling<br />

• Production control software<br />

• Further processing<br />

Call to find out more: +31 485 586111<br />

info.poultry@marel.com | www.marel.com/poultry


Events<br />

Party

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!