.. ?uG

=
v9$v yv zv yv OAv {+v fv )zv h O(Fv ;yvG Sv =v =v @?+v 1vh cv IQ.2v 8v O.uv 8v .\v s1v .#v &v ,d.rv d.qv
AGQh
kv J1v :)e.1v Gz Ov 9v (v L.9v C & q -v / .8v J>v QO 7>v C bv s$v v !v LEv 7tv G v $v Ev 9 q v 7$v Ov 2v 2v 1 3 ,.v
GO(
Uv+vy
O(vFh
eOvf
C f q fhJrv
GK+v fhL?v
vzvS 9vq k
9v"v\QvAvpG
GPE
:E
$G i.qv & q v %,v 0v cv 9v
.+v
A.1v G v ,f.uv h %+v 0 o v Rv
$
xvyP
eRvzv*
Pv 2v 2v 71v v.1v
L+v C .>v
:
)1v
)#v
;jQvFGOvyG PE Qv+vwvqvAvyG
.
q C f q vG Fv.rv !v v
1v .9v kv 0vM1v ,2rv &vCh .,v
#v
mqv .#v
#v|
y?FQOyG
)1(
Qv\ :E 9v< k
Rv /h
2v 2v 71v #v CJ2v Pv
G jKv 0v e.rv bv !v -1v h O.>v .#v b.kv G IQKv bv /!v .bv %v .#v fhO G IQKv fhO fC
"Uv
%v,v1v!vb f.v+Lv1 2vlvPv!vk hC 2v$v!vb @O.v> .v$vt C %v,v& q fhQLvrv0 dv# G 2vF.v0Mv1vlv G RQ.v2v
e.vrv0
G v $v Ev u q v $v )1v 2kv .>v IMFv 8v( $v 2v !v )f.9v G v $v hLcv ,7kv
I.Yv
-v& q / R.v?v0 A.v$v!vcv!v /E fC .vrv0 :G.v z Qv1v .v&Jv(vb
C
)vEv(vk Jv9v& "vG q 2vk ,Lv#$G .v1h .v9v 2v (vk f q
,7v1Lv?8v
0 k O.v>h
)2( y.v0 3 @ Gh IJvD0v$v .v(v+ h.vEv0 f.v
v,v>
A.lv Hv
L1v C f q G v ev
H.1v G v Pv 2v 2v , )3( 71v ev
jLv?v&
3 h Qv1v .v1
xz@
vG
$G
#v jJ,v v.ev Sv v)2(v C JDv G v rv
(
WvVvHv9v$v 2vk A.v0Mv1vk G v%vuv
Gh
2kv G v \v 2v 1v 7cv $ -v& q .v#Jv(vb
)v1vrv0
Lv#$ Qv1v /E v,v> 0 k vkLvcv#
G
Ov 9v d0fv O 7qv .bv %v G IQKv h Gv .lv -Fv / kv VGL9v
G
"The conclusion that there is no deeper level of causally determined motion is just a piece of circular
reasoning since it will follow only if we assume beforehand that no such level exists." (Bohm, Causality and
Chance in Modern Physics (London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1984), p.95.
W. Mark Richardson and Gordy Slack, eds. Faith in Science: Scientists search for truth (London; New
York: Routledge, 2001), p.131.
)John Bell(
G Lv1v( )"v1
7v(vO e1964
)v#
:v9v2v;C -v&C / "v#C )v$v )v+GLv0 /v!vb C f q 3v2vO .v(v!v,v> H.v2vO$.v1 .v+ O.v>h Q.v#C 7v1vk.vG .v(v1v!vb hC .v# aLvcv0
Jvq
v HG.Vv .+v C f q >v O.,v ( f.>v )"1v 2+v G v 29v C ;v 2v :9v kv O.Pv O i.bv
Gh
vG ;v0v
2kv
Variable(
@)Hidden
Neumann( )Von
v $v 9v fv 1 q Lv G v Hv )2lv G(v1v
. &v #v )f. f.kv(
S. Bell, Speakable and(
J.
in Quantum Mechanics (Cambridge; New York: Cambridge University Press, 1987)
!)Unspeakable
)v# YR.v(v0 2vk e.v1v
v .Ev "Uv bv /!v G
JGLv1vfv9v$v G vlvHv ,7v1 q Ph vv mvSvuv1 )"v1( )vb #v\vG 2vX.v0Q 2vk J.v1.vPvD )f.v#.v&(
G
.v$ k C f q c.v(v+ G v!vb
)Gerard 't Hooft(
,)non - locality(
,)locality(
mv(v8 J.v1.vPvD ( )"v1 p Lv1ve dv1.v[ h Qv1v
%v
Zkv .[v d1v h #v (v %,v G v lv M1v .0v 2Fv G v .,v v jJ(v ( >v JQGL1v .+v ):kv
Q
,)locality(
"v1.v& 7v(vO e1999
-v;.vEv1$ 2vk G A.v0Mv1vlv G ,7v1v#.v$vuv .v+h )v# G )v0LvVv9v(v$v Lv1vPvlv9v!v G 2v$v9vEv .vuv1v&.vuv1v$v
IMvF.v>
@%u G
Gerard 't Hooft (2009). "Entangled quantum states in a local deterministic theory".
.
55
)1(
)2(
)3(