9_1_1
9_1_1
9_1_1
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
20 THE JOURNAL OF LIBERTARIAN STUDIES Winter<br />
also employed when the offender was strong enough to resist a tonowi's decisions.<br />
"Disease and death are the ultimate (psychosomatic) effect of this 'supernatural'<br />
p~nishment."~~<br />
This suggests one solution to the problem that might arise when a defendant<br />
refused to submit to the sanction proposed by a tonowi, an infrequent but possible<br />
outcome of the Kapauku legal process. As Fuller explained, one form of punishment<br />
in primitive societies has often been "an exercise of magical powers on<br />
the offender to purge the community of an uncleanliness. A similar purging was<br />
accomplished through the generous use of ostraci~m."~' In fact then, the use of<br />
magic was simply one form of ostracism, and another, the one mentioned in earlier<br />
discussion, was also a solution when a judgment was not accepted. Ostracism<br />
by all members of a confederation was the ultimate threat.95<br />
Rules of Change<br />
Pospisil documented two ways that legislation could occur. First, very simply,<br />
law could change as custom changed. One example of such an occurrence had<br />
to do with the Kapauku adultery laws. It was customary until a few years prior<br />
to 1954 that an adulterous woman would be executed by her husband. However,<br />
men, and particularly relatively poor men, came to realize that such a sanction<br />
was too costly because of the high price paid for a wife. As a result, the punish-<br />
ment was changed to beating or perhaps wounding the adultress. The change was<br />
made initially by relatively poor men and was resisted by rich Kapauku Papuans.<br />
However, the new customary sanction was upheld by tonowi in four adultery cases<br />
observed by Pospisil during the 1954-55 period: "Thus what started as a more<br />
economical practice among the poorer husband became customary law by being<br />
incorporated into legal decision^."^^ In a similar fashion, of course, a law that<br />
at one time is applied can loose its popular support and effectively be abolished.97<br />
A second procedure for legal change was also observed among the Kapauku.<br />
A change in one lineage's law of incest resulted from "successful legislation"<br />
by a sublineage tonowi: "He succeeded in changing an old rule of sib exogamy<br />
into a new law that permitted inuasib marriages as close as between second<br />
cousins."98 This legislation was not authoritarian in the sense that its passage<br />
forced compliance by others, of course. Rather its acceptance spread through<br />
voluntary recognition. First it was adopted by the tonowi, then by more and more<br />
young men in his sublineage, and ultimately by ronowi of other sublineages within<br />
the same lineage. The head of the confederacy, a member of that lineage, also<br />
ultimately accepted the new law, but other lineages in the same confederacy did<br />
not, and thus incest laws varied across lineages within the same c~nfederacy.~'<br />
The characteristic that distinguishes this legal change from the previous one is<br />
that it was an intentional legal innovation initiated by a tonowi. Its adoption was<br />
still voluntary, however. Popisil concluded that in primitive systems "legal<br />
phenomena are constantly changing as does the rest of the culture."100