AUTUMN 2008 • NUMBER 140 • FORTIETH ANNIVERSARY 1968-2008 PAUL ADDISON • ANDREW ALEXANDER • PAUL ALKON LARRY P. ARNN • RANDY BARBER • PIERS BRENDON GEORGE W. BUSH • JOHN CHARMLEY RANDOLPH S. CHURCHILL • BILL CLINTON • DAVID DILKS MICHAEL DOBBS • DAVID FREEMAN • LAURENCE S. GELLER MARTIN GILBERT • DOUGLAS HALL CAMERON HAZLEHURST • WILLIAM C. IVES WARREN F. KIMBALL • NIGEL KNOCKER • JAMES LANCASTER RICHARD M. LANGWORTH • JOHN LUKACS WILLIAM MANCHESTER • JOHN MAURER DALTON NEWFIELD • ALLEN PACKWOOD ROBERT L. PFALTZGRAFF JR. • ROBERT PILPEL JOHN G. PLUMPTON • INDER DAN RATNU • PHIL REED ANDREW ROBERTS • MARY SOAMES • DAVID STAFFORD IAN STEELE • HERBERT VIVIAN • MANFRED WEIDHORN
Number 140 • Autumn 2008 ISSN 0882-3715 www.winstonchurchill.org ____________________________ Barbara F. Langworth, Publisher barbarajol@gmail.com Richard M. Langworth CBE, Editor malakand@langworth.name Post Office Box 740 Moultonborough, NH 03254 USA Tel. (603) 253-8900 Dec.-March Tel. (242) 335-0615 ___________________________ David A. Turrell, Deputy Editor daturrell@verizon.net 19955 Alexandra’s Grove Drive Ashburn VA 20147-3112 Res. Tel. (703) 724-4928 ___________________________ Editor Emeritus: Ron Cynewulf Robbins Senior Editors: Paul H. Courtenay James R. Lancaster James W. Muller News Editor: John Frost Contributors Alfred James, Australia Terry Reardon, Canada Antoine Capet, France Paul Addison, <strong>Winston</strong> S. <strong>Churchill</strong>, Robert A. Courts, Sir Martin Gilbert CBE, Allen Packwood, United Kingdom David Freeman, Ted Hutchinson, Warren F. Kimball, Michael McMenamin, Don Pieper, Christopher Sterling, Manfred Weidhorn, United States ___________________________ • Address changes: Help us keep your copies coming! Please update your membership office when you move. All offices for The <strong>Churchill</strong> Centre and Allied national organizations are listed on the inside front cover. __________________________________ Finest Hour is made possible in part through the generous support of members of The <strong>Churchill</strong> Centre and Museum, the Number Ten Club, and an endowment created by the <strong>Churchill</strong> Centre Associates (listed on page 2). ___________________________________ Published quarterly by The <strong>Churchill</strong> Centre, offering subscriptions from the appropriate offices on page 2. Permission to mail at nonprofit rates in USA granted by the United States Postal Service, Concord, NH, permit no. 1524. Copyright 2007. All rights reserved. Produced by Dragonwyck Publishing Inc. FORTIETH ANNIVERSARY NUMBER, 1968-2008 1968 1983 1988 1998 COVER “To <strong>Winston</strong>, with affectionate birthday greetings from his old friend and castigator—Low.” First published in Illustrated, 20 November 1954. Australian-born cartoonist David Low had produced <strong>Churchill</strong>-skewering political cartoons for the Star and other left-wing papers since the early 1920s. But victim and victimizer retained an abiding respect for one another and WSC wrote fondly of Low in his essay “Cartoons and Cartoonists” in Thoughts and Adventures. As Sir <strong>Winston</strong> turned eighty, David Low returned the compliment. FORTY YEARS ON: VIEWS OF CHURCHILL SINCE 1968 14 Part I: Paul Addison, Paul Alkon, Larry P. Arnn, Piers Brendon 18 Part II: John Charmley, David Dilks, Michael Dobbs, David Freeman 28 Part III: Martin Gilbert, Cameron Hazlehurst, Warren F. Kimball, John Lukacs 38 Part IV: John Maurer, Allen Packwood, Robert L. Pfaltzgraff Jr., Robert Pilpel 49 Part V: Phil Reed, Andrew Roberts, David Stafford, Manfred Weidhorn FROM THE PAGES OF FINEST HOUR 12 FH 51: <strong>Churchill</strong> and Family: “Command the Moment to Remain” • Mary Soames 21 FH 66: <strong>Churchill</strong> and History: Generational Chauvinism • William Manchester 32 FH 77: <strong>Churchill</strong> and Achievement: A Nation of <strong>Churchill</strong>s • Bill Clinton 41 FH 123: <strong>Churchill</strong> and Liberty • George W. Bush 52 FH 40: <strong>Churchill</strong> and the Media: “Come Come, Mr. <strong>Churchill</strong>...” • Andrew Alexander ARTICLES 22 The Fifty Best Books of the Last Forty Years • Paul Addison and the Editor 33 The Hundred Best Finest Hour Articles in the Last Forty Years • Michael Richards 44 Past Glories: <strong>Churchill</strong> Conferences of the Last Century • Richard M. Langworth 54 Climacterics in the Life of Finest Hour: Turning Points in the Story of a Small Journal 58 <strong>Churchill</strong> and the Future • Laurence S. Geller at the 2008 Boston Conference 59 The Last Memory, 1965 • Edmund Murray in 1992 CHURCHILL PROCEEDINGS 66 Nimitz, MacArthur, and Coalition Warfare in the Pacific • Craig L. Symonds 74 Election 1945: Why <strong>Winston</strong> <strong>Churchill</strong> Lost • Gordon W. Walker QC BOOKS, ARTS AND CURIOSITIES 60 David Jablonsky reviews perhaps the best book yet on <strong>Churchill</strong> and his Generals 62 FH 16: <strong>Churchill</strong> and Stamps: Cuba, 1895 and Maximo Gomez • Dalton Newfield 64 FH 37: <strong>Churchill</strong> in Wedgwood: Barlaston’s <strong>Churchill</strong>iana • Michael Richards DEPARTMENTS 5/ Editor’s Essay • 6/ Despatch Box • 8/ Datelines • 10/ Around & About 11, 20/ Leading <strong>Churchill</strong> Myths • 17/ Wit & Wisdom • 37/ Riddles, Mysteries, Enigmas 42/ Action This Day • 61/ <strong>Churchill</strong> Quiz • 78/ Ampersand • 79/ Regional Organizations FINEST HoUR 140 / 4
- Page 2 and 3: THE JOURNAL OF WINSTON CHURCHILL AU
- Page 6 and 7: E D I T O R ’ S E S S AY “Forty
- Page 8 and 9: “...The Belgian government is als
- Page 10 and 11: Incidentally, Clementine Churchill
- Page 12 and 13: Dresden, VE-Day, Potsdam). 1945 Aug
- Page 14 and 15: ical activities alone would have fi
- Page 16 and 17: Golden Scholarship vs. Leaden Readi
- Page 18 and 19: Questioning Generals “I presume t
- Page 20 and 21: expect that gratitude or admiration
- Page 22 and 23: FINEST HOUR 66, FIRST QUARTER, 1990
- Page 24 and 25: 1992, 494 pages, Zoller A539. A sta
- Page 26 and 27: decade.” Kimball, Warren F., ed.
- Page 28 and 29: Severance, John. Sir Winston Church
- Page 30 and 31: Committee, which took some of the m
- Page 32 and 33: Remnant Connection JOHN LUKACS One
- Page 34 and 35: 1968-2008 The Hundred Best Finest H
- Page 36 and 37: Lancaster, James “Churchill’s F
- Page 38 and 39: RIDDLES, MYSTERIES, ENIGMAS TR’s
- Page 40 and 41: Shaper of the Present ALLEN PACKWOO
- Page 42 and 43: FINEST HOUR 123, SUMMER 2004 Church
- Page 44 and 45: in a great party…I know you wd do
- Page 46 and 47: 45A: R, no crop Above left: Jane an
- Page 48 and 49: 47a R, crop L&R celia Right: Bill M
- Page 50 and 51: FORTY YEARS ON (5) WSC Since 1968 H
- Page 52 and 53: sittings grumbling about his Cabine
- Page 54 and 55:
news flash. British and German batt
- Page 56 and 57:
The End of the End Finest Hour 33,
- Page 58 and 59:
humor, optimism, pride in country
- Page 60 and 61:
for which we are grateful. Please s
- Page 62 and 63:
THE CHURCHILL QUIZ JAMES R. LANCAST
- Page 64 and 65:
CHURCHILL AND STAMPS... ancient all
- Page 66 and 67:
lower half, “Wedgwood England”
- Page 68 and 69:
Suspicious by nature, Stalin feared
- Page 70 and 71:
and just as he would try to hold th
- Page 72 and 73:
then Halsey’s 3rd Fleet led the a
- Page 74 and 75:
it at 8:22 am, some 320 miles to th
- Page 76 and 77:
75a R, crop L&R CAMPAIGNING, 1945:
- Page 78 and 79:
77A E, no crops VINDICATION, OCTOBE
- Page 80:
Churchill Centre Regional and Local