section 4 - existing conditions and needs - Martin County, Florida
section 4 - existing conditions and needs - Martin County, Florida
section 4 - existing conditions and needs - Martin County, Florida
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
4.1 BACKGROUND<br />
SECTION 4 - EXISTING CONDITIONS AND NEEDS<br />
Section 2 - Resources <strong>and</strong> Data lists the <strong>existing</strong> information <strong>and</strong> data collected,<br />
compiled <strong>and</strong> analyzed as part of the review of the <strong>existing</strong> <strong>conditions</strong> of the stormwater,<br />
water <strong>and</strong> wastewater systems that serve the Port Salerno CRA. In Section 3 -<br />
Governing Rules <strong>and</strong> Regulations, the required Level of Service (LOS) for stormwater<br />
water quality <strong>and</strong> storm attenuation is defined as well as the required LOS for water <strong>and</strong><br />
wastewater facilities. Based on this information, an analysis has been performed <strong>and</strong><br />
exhibits have been created to show <strong>existing</strong> areas within the Port Salerno CRA that are<br />
currently deficient in providing the required LOS for stormwater, water <strong>and</strong> wastewater<br />
facilities.<br />
4.2 EXISTING STORMWATER FACILITIES<br />
A series of north-south ridges <strong>and</strong> depressions form the drainage patterns, in this area of<br />
<strong>Martin</strong> <strong>County</strong>, as described by the United States Geologic Survey (USGS) topographic<br />
maps, <strong>County</strong> records, <strong>and</strong> geologic reports procured from the South <strong>Florida</strong> Water<br />
Management District. Figure 11, “Existing Contours” illustrates the <strong>existing</strong><br />
topographic features of the Port Salerno CRA (one foot contours, as provided by <strong>Martin</strong><br />
<strong>County</strong>). The Port Salerno CRA is located adjacent to, <strong>and</strong> east of the Atlantic Coastal<br />
Ridge (see Figure 1). Figure 10, “Soils Map” provides the typical characteristics of<br />
the soil in this area.<br />
The Port Salerno CRA is in the Manatee Pocket Basin. Two principal tributaries drain the<br />
CRA; Salerno Creek (FDOT Ditch 4 <strong>and</strong> FDOT Ditch 5) west of SE Dixie Highway <strong>and</strong><br />
Manatee Creek east of SE Dixie highway. Smaller lateral ditches <strong>and</strong> local roadside<br />
swales <strong>and</strong> ditches provide drainage for the CRA. The St. Lucie River is the ultimate<br />
receiving body of water for discharge of stormwater in the area. Permitted discharge<br />
rates in this area are in the 0.68 cfs/ac range (in accordance with permits issued by<br />
SFWMD).<br />
<strong>Martin</strong> <strong>County</strong> commissioned Creech Engineers, Inc. to study the Salerno Creek Basin<br />
<strong>and</strong> recommend water quality improvements to retrofit the area. As a result of the study,<br />
a 24 acre stormwater treatment area (STA) was constructed. The STA provides<br />
approximately 53 ac-ft. of stormwater treatment volume for runoff. Captec Engineering,<br />
Inc. completed the Manatee Creek Stormwater Quality Retrofit design in 2005.<br />
Approximately 40% percent of the CRA has been retrofitted with stormwater facilities<br />
providing water quality. Currently, the remaining CRA does not have adequate<br />
stormwater facilities providing the required minimum treatment according to <strong>Martin</strong><br />
<strong>County</strong> L<strong>and</strong> Development Code or SFWMD water quality requirements.<br />
MARTIN COUNTY STORMWATER/UTILITY CRA MASTER PLAN – PORT SALERNO CRA SECTION 4-1<br />
EXISTING CONDITIONS AND NEEDS (07/03/06)
The <strong>existing</strong> stormwater infrastructure in the Port Salerno CRA is limited. The lack of<br />
stormwater treatment <strong>and</strong> adequate conveyance systems is evident in the stormwater<br />
inventory for the area. Figure 12, “Existing Stormwater Facilities” illustrates the<br />
<strong>existing</strong> stormwater facilities as identified by <strong>Martin</strong> <strong>County</strong> in their GIS system. Prior to<br />
1972 (when the <strong>County</strong> stormwater ordinances were codified) residential subdivisions,<br />
multi-family housing, <strong>and</strong> commercial property were not required to provide water quality<br />
treatment or flood attenuation for storm runoff when they were constructed.<br />
More recent development must provide drainage facilities in order to comply with the<br />
required stormwater LOS in accordance with <strong>Martin</strong> <strong>County</strong> codes <strong>and</strong> the requirements<br />
of the South <strong>Florida</strong> Water Management District (SFWMD). Table 4.2-1 <strong>and</strong> Figure 7,<br />
“South <strong>Florida</strong> Water Management District Permits” list the developments within <strong>and</strong><br />
adjacent to the Port Salerno CRA, having a SFWMD Surface Water or Environmental<br />
Resource permit. For the purpose of conducting an analysis of <strong>existing</strong> <strong>conditions</strong>, they<br />
are assumed to meet current LOS.<br />
Table 4.2-1<br />
South <strong>Florida</strong> Water Management District Permits<br />
Project Name Permit Number<br />
River Pines 43-00141-S<br />
Emerald Lakes Phases 14 & 15 43-00239-S<br />
Park Place 43-392-S-12<br />
Scammell Construction Office 43-00392-S-12<br />
FECR Fiber Optics Regenerating Facility 43-00392-S-16<br />
Castle Development Warehouse 43-00392-S-17<br />
Lot 10, Block D, Gran Park-Phase I 43-00392-S-20<br />
Lot 9, Block D, Gran Park-Phase I 43-00392-S-21<br />
H & L Marine 43-00392-S-22<br />
Gran Park Commerce 43-00392-S-23<br />
Woodridge 43-00549-S<br />
CR A1A/Salerno Road 43-00664-S<br />
Toyota of Stuart 43-00944-P<br />
Manatee Creek Stormwater Quality Retrofit 43-00971-P<br />
Ebbtide Avenue Bridge 43-00979-P<br />
Salerno Village Square 43-01105-P<br />
Port Salerno Post Office 43-01217-P<br />
Manatee Cove Road Culvert Replacement 43-01271-P<br />
MARTIN COUNTY STORMWATER/UTILITY CRA MASTER PLAN – PORT SALERNO CRA SECTION 4-2<br />
EXISTING CONDITIONS AND NEEDS (07/03/06)
Port Salerno Elementary School 43-01331-P<br />
Murray Cove 43-01375-P<br />
Cove Road Commercial Center Walgreen’s 43-01499-P<br />
Port Salerno Industrial Park 43-01755-P<br />
Salerno Cove/Cove Place 80-00119-S<br />
Grankill Apts. Azimuth St. Port Salerno 82-00033-S<br />
Greenwood Estates 82-00147-S<br />
4.3 EXISTING CONDITIONS – SPECIFIC AREAS<br />
4.3.1 New Monrovia New Monrovia is west of S.E. Dixie Highway, at the south end of the<br />
CRA. New Monrovia was identified in the Port<br />
Salerno Community Redevelopment Plan as a<br />
neighborhood with redevelopment potential. The<br />
area experienced flooding during 1995, 1999, <strong>and</strong><br />
2001. The American Red Cross <strong>and</strong> <strong>Martin</strong><br />
<strong>County</strong> logged complaints received from<br />
residents impacted by the flooding. Captec<br />
Engineering, Inc. studied the problem in the<br />
Manatee Creek Stormwater Quality Retrofit<br />
Report, <strong>and</strong> modeled storm events approximating<br />
the actual events which caused the flooding.<br />
New Monrovia would be expected to flood again<br />
should a similar event occur, due to the lack of<br />
capacity in <strong>existing</strong> swales <strong>and</strong> ditches.<br />
New Monrovia<br />
4.3.2 Rocky Point Rocky Point is east of S.E. Dixie Highway <strong>and</strong> one of the four residential<br />
areas in the CRA. Rocky Point was built prior to modern stormwater codes <strong>and</strong> ordinances<br />
requiring water quality treatment. Inter<strong>section</strong>s<br />
are known to flood due to being constructed in<br />
low areas without any drainage outlet (positive<br />
outfall). The Community Redevelopment Plan<br />
listed streets prone to flooding: Broward Street;<br />
Driftwood Avenue; George’s Way; <strong>and</strong>, S.E.<br />
Mulford Lane. <strong>County</strong> stormwater inventory<br />
indicates only 2 small swales <strong>and</strong> pipe in the<br />
area which illustrates the lack of stormwater<br />
facilities available. The soils in the area are<br />
highly permeable; however, when discharge<br />
occurs the flow goes directly into Manatee<br />
Rocky Point<br />
Pocket.<br />
MARTIN COUNTY STORMWATER/UTILITY CRA MASTER PLAN – PORT SALERNO CRA SECTION 4-3<br />
EXISTING CONDITIONS AND NEEDS (07/03/06)
4.3.3 Port Salerno Platted as Port Salerno in<br />
1912, the subdivision is one of the oldest in<br />
<strong>Martin</strong> <strong>County</strong>. The Salerno Creek Water<br />
Quality Retrofit was constructed to improve the<br />
water quality discharging into Manatee Pocket.<br />
Existing isolated roadside swales <strong>and</strong> ditches<br />
provide drainage to local streets, including S.E.<br />
Salerno Road <strong>and</strong> the Port Salerno<br />
Elementary School ditch. The <strong>County</strong> is aware<br />
of recurring flooding at the inter<strong>section</strong> of S.E.<br />
Salerno Road <strong>and</strong> Flounder Avenue. In<br />
addition, there is flooding in the upstream<br />
reaches of the elementary school ditch.<br />
Manatee Creek<br />
4.4 EXISTING CONDITIONS – STORMWATER MODEL<br />
Port Salerno<br />
4.3.4 Manatee Creek The main access to the<br />
subdivision is provided by S.E. Primrose Way<br />
at Cove Road. Dead end streets characterize<br />
the layout of the subdivision. Stormwater<br />
treatment areas recommended in the Manatee<br />
Creek Stormwater Quality Retrofit are currently<br />
under construction to provide water quality<br />
treatment to this area of the CRA. Phase I is<br />
under construction, <strong>and</strong> Phases II <strong>and</strong> III have<br />
been designed.<br />
In order to confirm reports of <strong>existing</strong> stormwater deficiencies <strong>and</strong> to identify additional<br />
areas of concern, stormwater modeling was conducted using the available data for<br />
<strong>existing</strong> <strong>conditions</strong> within the Port Salerno CRA. The model used for this <strong>existing</strong><br />
<strong>conditions</strong> study was the Interconnected Channel <strong>and</strong> Pond Routing Model (ICPR). This<br />
model was selected in order to be consistent with methodology used in the proposed<br />
Stormwater Master Plan modeling included under Section 5.<br />
The Port Salerno CRA was divided into <strong>existing</strong> drainage basins according to <strong>existing</strong><br />
contour maps, basin maps, <strong>and</strong> stormwater reports. For basins studied <strong>and</strong> not<br />
modeled, the information was incorporated where applicable. Pervious <strong>and</strong> impervious<br />
areas within each <strong>existing</strong> drainage basin were determined using building area<br />
information provided by the <strong>Martin</strong> <strong>County</strong> Tax Assessment Office with additional area<br />
MARTIN COUNTY STORMWATER/UTILITY CRA MASTER PLAN – PORT SALERNO CRA SECTION 4-4<br />
EXISTING CONDITIONS AND NEEDS (07/03/06)
calculations based on <strong>existing</strong> plans <strong>and</strong> current aerial photographs of the CRA as<br />
provided by <strong>Martin</strong> <strong>County</strong>.<br />
Based on soil <strong>conditions</strong> <strong>and</strong> depths to water tables as indicated in Figure 10, “Soils<br />
Map” along with the calculated impervious areas, a Curve Number (CN) was determined<br />
for each basin. Stage/storage calculations for the model are based on the <strong>existing</strong><br />
contour map. In order to account for the high permeability of the <strong>existing</strong> soils in the east<br />
Port Salerno area, a stage discharge rating curve was developed for those areas using<br />
the soils data <strong>and</strong> hydraulic conductivity in the <strong>Martin</strong> <strong>County</strong> Soil Survey.<br />
Stormwater models were run (see Appendix - Pre-redevelopment ICPR Model) for<br />
each basin using a 10 year 1 day design storm event of 7” inches of rainfall, the 25 year<br />
3 day design storm event of 12” inches of rainfall, <strong>and</strong> the 100 year 3 day storm event of<br />
14” inches of rainfall. The design storm rainfall totals are from the SFWMD, Volume IV,<br />
Surface Water Design Aids, Figures C-6, C-8, <strong>and</strong> C-11 (see Appendix – Rainfall<br />
Information).<br />
The stormwater model results show maximum stages within each basin for the design<br />
storms. These stages were compared to the <strong>existing</strong> contours within the basin to<br />
determine the potential level of flooding.<br />
The modeling effort is based on available information <strong>and</strong> has not been calibrated using<br />
actual specific soil test data or specific elevations within the <strong>existing</strong> basins. Therefore,<br />
the results of the modeling provide general information on potential areas of concern. In<br />
order to conduct an in-depth analysis, it would be necessary to obtain specific<br />
geotechnical information <strong>and</strong> to perform field survey the areas in question.<br />
4.5 STORMWATER SYSTEM LEVEL OF SERVICE DEFICITS<br />
Approximately 40% percent of the area within the Port Salerno CRA is served by<br />
<strong>existing</strong> conveyance <strong>and</strong> flood protection facilities providing an adequate LOS.<br />
Areas within the Port Salerno CRA currently not served by regional conveyance <strong>and</strong><br />
stormwater treatment areas/systems are considered to be deficient relative to the LOS<br />
definition. In addition, there are a number of areas serviced by inadequate infrastructure.<br />
While these systems are sufficient for providing the daily drainage <strong>needs</strong> of the area,<br />
they are insufficient when compared to the current LOS criteria needed for water quality,<br />
stormwater attenuation, <strong>and</strong> basic flood protection.<br />
In addition to the LOS considerations, the analysis included a review of nuisance<br />
flooding concerns. Although most residents do not have structure flooding, they may<br />
encounter nuisance ponding in front of their homes <strong>and</strong> businesses. It should be noted<br />
the cost of removing all the nuisance ponding may be expensive <strong>and</strong> the benefit to the<br />
drainage systems LOS may be minimal.<br />
In discussions with <strong>Martin</strong> <strong>County</strong> staff, several areas of concern were identified.<br />
Specific information on these areas is shown Section 4.6, Summary of System Deficits.<br />
The American Red Cross provided information related to flooding during 1995, 1999,<br />
<strong>and</strong> 2000. The <strong>Martin</strong> <strong>County</strong> Health Department did not indicate specific concerns<br />
about failed onsite sewage disposal (septic) systems within the Port Salerno<br />
MARTIN COUNTY STORMWATER/UTILITY CRA MASTER PLAN – PORT SALERNO CRA SECTION 4-5<br />
EXISTING CONDITIONS AND NEEDS (07/03/06)
Redevelopment Area. However, the area is identified as a wastewater system deficiency<br />
but is also an indication of stormwater concerns due to high water table levels affecting<br />
the operation of the septic systems.<br />
In addition to analyzing the <strong>existing</strong> data, stormwater modeling of the general <strong>existing</strong><br />
<strong>conditions</strong> has been conducted to confirm the <strong>existing</strong> deficiency information or identify<br />
other potential deficient areas. Methodology for <strong>existing</strong> <strong>conditions</strong> analysis is shown<br />
below in Section 4.4.<br />
Figure 13, “Existing Stormwater System Deficits” delineates the <strong>existing</strong> stormwater<br />
<strong>and</strong> conveyance system areas within the Port Salerno CRA identified as stormwater<br />
deficiencies by either <strong>Martin</strong> <strong>County</strong> staff, other regulatory agencies, or by site<br />
observations.<br />
4.6 SUMMARY OF STORMWATER SYSTEM DEFICITS<br />
A summary of deficiencies in the stormwater system is listed below in Table 4.6-1. This<br />
includes deficiency criteria on hydraulic performance, structural integrity <strong>and</strong> nuisance<br />
concerns. Each adverse condition identified during the assessment has been tabulated<br />
for each of these three categories.<br />
*Table 4.6-1<br />
Areas of Existing Stormwater Needs<br />
LOCATION CONDITION<br />
Flooding in the area of S.E. 48<br />
New Monrovia<br />
th Avenue <strong>and</strong> S.E. Field Street<br />
No stormwater infrastructure <strong>and</strong> local inter<strong>section</strong> <strong>and</strong> street<br />
Rocky Point<br />
flooding<br />
No water quality, conveyance, or flood protection in compliance<br />
Port Salerno (North of S.E. Salerno Rd.) with above.<br />
Existing swales need continued maintenance; Salerno Creek from<br />
Ebbtide Road to S.E. Dixie Highway; the Port Salerno Elementary<br />
CRA wide maintenance<br />
School ditch<br />
Fifty six (56) percent of the CRA has no known formal water<br />
quality treatment or traditional methods of flood protection. This<br />
includes developments constructed prior to 1979 that are not in<br />
Overall CRA Area Water Quality the 2 retrofitted basins.<br />
* See Figure 13 – “Existing Stormwater System Deficits”<br />
4.7 CRA PROJECT STORMWATER NEEDS<br />
Fifty six percent of the CRA does not have adequate stormwater facilities to provide the<br />
minimum treatment required by the <strong>Martin</strong> <strong>County</strong> l<strong>and</strong> Development code or to comply<br />
with the SFWMD water quality requirements. Large areas of the CRA need to be<br />
studied to determine the best way to increase the LOS provided for stormwater quality<br />
<strong>and</strong> attenuation.<br />
MARTIN COUNTY STORMWATER/UTILITY CRA MASTER PLAN – PORT SALERNO CRA SECTION 4-6<br />
EXISTING CONDITIONS AND NEEDS (07/03/06)
Each of the neighborhoods previously mentioned are identified in the Port Salerno<br />
Community Redevelopment Plan, <strong>and</strong> each has a project which is proposed to enhance<br />
the quality of life in the neighborhood. This <strong>section</strong> of the report will exp<strong>and</strong> upon the<br />
stormwater <strong>needs</strong> <strong>and</strong> opportunities associated with specific projects identified in the<br />
Community Redevelopment Plan.<br />
4.7.1 New Monrovia<br />
Flooding occurs at SE 48 th Avenue, SE Field Street, <strong>and</strong> SE Front Avenue S, according<br />
to records of <strong>Martin</strong> <strong>County</strong> <strong>and</strong> the American Red Cross. A need exists to improve<br />
drainage in the <strong>existing</strong> ditches paralleling SE 48 th Avenue, between SE Field Street <strong>and</strong><br />
SE Murray Street. There are lots available for surface water quality improvements due to<br />
55% of the subdivision consisting of vacant lots.<br />
4.7.2 Rocky Point<br />
The Rocky Point neighborhood is in need of a retrofit program to provide water quality<br />
treatment for storm runoff in the area: improvements will be designed <strong>and</strong> permitted<br />
through the agencies as outlined in Section 3. Stormwater exfiltration trenches could be<br />
used to create an acceptable <strong>and</strong> workable system for the community. Exfiltration<br />
trenches are a compatible Best Management Practice (BMP) promoting aquifer<br />
recharge, while reducing runoff <strong>and</strong> treating stormwater. Legal positive outfalls should<br />
be identified to allow the runoff to discharge after being treated. Opportunities exist to<br />
incorporate certain remedial stormwater plans addressing <strong>existing</strong> deficiencies.<br />
4.7.3 Port Salerno<br />
While the Salerno Creek Stormwater Quality Retrofit considered 179 acres of the CRA,<br />
additional improvements are needed. Projects which alleviate localized street flooding<br />
<strong>and</strong> improve connections to the Salerno Creek Stormwater Quality Retrofit project are<br />
needed. The inter<strong>section</strong> of SE Broward Street <strong>and</strong> SE Driftwood Avenue is known to<br />
flood. Salerno Creek east of SE Ebbtide Avenue, <strong>needs</strong> to have the pervasive st<strong>and</strong> of<br />
Brazilian Pepper removed as well as remedial work to replant <strong>and</strong> restore the banks.<br />
North of SE Salerno Road, the Port Salerno elementary School ditch should be enlarged<br />
<strong>and</strong> maintained. Other roads in the subdivision also have flooding problems requiring<br />
attention. Roads without drainage improvements, such as, SE Isabelita Avenue between<br />
SE Seaward Street <strong>and</strong> SE Salerno Road, should have swales or underground storm<br />
systems. A 60’ right-of-way exists which could support a swale system, according to the<br />
<strong>Martin</strong> <strong>County</strong> L<strong>and</strong> Development Code.<br />
4.7.4 Manatee Creek<br />
The Manatee Creek residential area’s stormwater quality <strong>needs</strong> have been met by the<br />
Manatee Creek Stormwater Quality Retrofit Study. However, most of the streets are<br />
dead-end streets needing to be properly connected to the water quality improvements<br />
being constructed.<br />
4.7.5 Additional Basin Studies<br />
Hydrological, geographical, <strong>and</strong> political boundaries frequently differ. The Port Salerno<br />
CRA is in seven drainage basins: all of the basins extend beyond the political <strong>and</strong><br />
MARTIN COUNTY STORMWATER/UTILITY CRA MASTER PLAN – PORT SALERNO CRA SECTION 4-7<br />
EXISTING CONDITIONS AND NEEDS (07/03/06)
geographical limits of the CRA. Salerno Creek <strong>and</strong> Manatee Creek have been studied;<br />
the remaining five have not. Approximately 56% of the CRA is in drainage basins which<br />
have not been studied. Since the CRA is downstream of the basins, caution should be<br />
exercised when proposing improvements impacting the upstream portion of the basins.<br />
Additional studies are warranted to ensure downstream improvements do not adversely<br />
impact <strong>existing</strong> <strong>and</strong> future upstream development.<br />
4.8 LEVEL OF SERVICE AND WATER QUALITY RECOMMENDATIONS<br />
The Salerno Creek <strong>and</strong> Manatee Creek water quality retrofit projects have addressed<br />
44% of the water quality <strong>needs</strong> of the CRA drainage system. The improvements have<br />
established permissible discharge rates in the CRA. Future projects should use the two<br />
projects as guidelines, where applicable, to prevent complications. The permissible<br />
discharge into Manatee Pocket from Manatee Creek is 0.47 cfs/ac. The permissible<br />
discharge into Manatee Pocket from Salerno Creek is 0.68 cfs/ac. The studies<br />
adequately provided for hydraulic capacity to h<strong>and</strong>le LOS storm events. However, the<br />
system has hydraulic problems when hydraulic connectivity is considered.<br />
Recommendations have been developed to solve the system deficiencies for LOS, water<br />
quality, <strong>and</strong> nuisance concerns. The recommendations have been compared <strong>and</strong><br />
presented in order of their importance <strong>and</strong> ease of solution. Top ranked<br />
recommendations should be considered as priority projects.<br />
Solutions to system problems <strong>and</strong> deficiencies are provided below. The<br />
recommendations will address hydraulic <strong>and</strong> water quality concerns in the CRA district.<br />
The following recommendations are prioritized based on their <strong>needs</strong> <strong>and</strong> should be<br />
considered as the necessary projects to meet LOS requirements to the fullest extent<br />
possible for Port Salerno.<br />
4.8.1 New Monrovia<br />
Open space is available throughout New Monrovia for the construction of stormwater<br />
treatment areas (STA’s) to provide water quality treatment. Specifically, the area around<br />
SE 48 th Avenue, where there have been reported flooding issues would be retrofitted<br />
with an STA to provide water quality treatment <strong>and</strong> storm runoff attenuation. The<br />
southern part of the CRA near the Charles Street Ditch may discharge into the ditch,<br />
after receiving water quality treatment <strong>and</strong> discharge through the Manatee Creek<br />
Stormwater Quality Retrofit improvements.<br />
4.8.2 Rocky Point<br />
Rocky Point has less vacant l<strong>and</strong> available than other areas in the CRA; therefore,<br />
STA’s may not be feasible. The area possesses highly permeable soils with <strong>existing</strong><br />
elevations, which would enable the use of exfiltration trench for water quality treatment.<br />
Low inter<strong>section</strong>s <strong>and</strong> streets which flood would be retrofitted with drainage structures<br />
<strong>and</strong> exfiltration trench to reduce the frequency of flooding. Finding positive outfalls for<br />
treated stormwater runoff may be difficult where there are <strong>existing</strong> bulkheads at Manatee<br />
Pocket.<br />
MARTIN COUNTY STORMWATER/UTILITY CRA MASTER PLAN – PORT SALERNO CRA SECTION 4-8<br />
EXISTING CONDITIONS AND NEEDS (07/03/06)
4.8.3 Port Salerno<br />
The Port Salerno Elementary School Ditch would be enlarged to contain the 25 year 3<br />
day storm event within its banks. Streets draining into the ditch should have swales<br />
improved to enhance attenuation. Credit for 20% of the required water quality treatment<br />
can be obtained if the swales are dry. The 60’ foot rights-of-way can be used for swales<br />
according to the <strong>County</strong> l<strong>and</strong> Development Code. There are four vacant lots between SE<br />
Isabelita Avenue <strong>and</strong> SE Grouper Avenue, which may be acquired to provide additional<br />
storage <strong>and</strong> treatment to augment the treatment provided in the swales.<br />
4.8.4 Manatee Creek<br />
The Manatee Creek Stormwater Quality Retrofit will provide water quality treatment for<br />
197 acres of the CRA; construction of the recommended Phase I improvements will<br />
begin in spring of 2006. It is anticipated hydraulic connectivity in Manatee Creek will<br />
continue to be a problem.<br />
4.8.5 Overall Stormwater Quality Port Salerno CRA<br />
To fully address the overall stormwater quality for the <strong>existing</strong> area, the area will need to<br />
follow the master plan as proposed <strong>and</strong> provide Stormwater Treatment Areas (STA)<br />
throughout the region. As a result of the ongoing Salerno Creek <strong>and</strong> Manatee Creek<br />
retrofits, issues will be resolved at the subsequent completion of the project for 44% of<br />
the Port Salerno CRA.<br />
4.9 RECOMMENDED IMPLEMENTATION<br />
The recommended improvements developed in this analysis, are a combination of LOS,<br />
water quality, <strong>and</strong> nuisance improvements. The improvements will be phased into the<br />
overall CRA improvements as development occurs. In areas where health, safety <strong>and</strong><br />
welfare concerns are critical, immediate attention will be required. In order of<br />
importance, these areas are:<br />
1. Additional Basin Studies<br />
2. Port Salerno (north of S.E. Salerno Road)<br />
3. New Monrovia<br />
4. Rocky Point<br />
5. Manatee Creek<br />
6. Additional Basin Studies<br />
MARTIN COUNTY STORMWATER/UTILITY CRA MASTER PLAN – PORT SALERNO CRA SECTION 4-9<br />
EXISTING CONDITIONS AND NEEDS (07/03/06)
4.10 SUMMARY OF OVERALL STORMWATER NEEDS OF THE PORT SALERNO<br />
COMMUNITY REDEVELOPMENT AREA<br />
The stormwater <strong>needs</strong> in the Port Salerno Community Redevelopment Area were<br />
assessed based on the water quality <strong>and</strong> water quantity criteria described in Section 3<br />
Governing Rules <strong>and</strong> Regulations. The CRA’s <strong>existing</strong> <strong>conditions</strong> indicate treatment of<br />
stormwater runoff for water quality is formally lacking: it is evident by the deficient<br />
stormwater infrastructure in the CRA, compared to the immediate surrounding areas of<br />
newer development. Attenuation of peak discharge rates after storm events is currently<br />
not provided in 56% of the CRA due to the lack of a local or regional stormwater system<br />
to protect streets from flooding <strong>and</strong> property from damage.<br />
4.11 EXISTING WATER SYSTEM<br />
4.11.1 Existing Water System<br />
The Port Salerno CRA is currently supplied water from <strong>Martin</strong> <strong>County</strong> Utilities <strong>and</strong> Solid<br />
Waste (a.k.a. <strong>Martin</strong> <strong>County</strong> Utilities). According to <strong>Martin</strong> <strong>County</strong> Utilities, they provide<br />
water to 25,000 households <strong>and</strong> 1,500 commercial developments in unincorporated<br />
<strong>Martin</strong> <strong>County</strong>, Ocean Breeze Park <strong>and</strong> Sewall’s Point. Potable water dem<strong>and</strong>s are<br />
currently met through four water treatment plants; <strong>Martin</strong> Downs, North <strong>County</strong>, Tropical<br />
Farms, <strong>and</strong> Vista Salerno; which are located throughout the <strong>County</strong>.<br />
An inventory of the <strong>Martin</strong> <strong>County</strong> Utilities water lines are included in Table 4.11-1, for a<br />
total of 658,750 linear feet of piping.<br />
Table 4.11-1<br />
Water Line Pipe Inventory*<br />
Water Line Inventory* Length<br />
6” inch 61,187 ft<br />
8” inch 169,967 ft<br />
10” inch 62,373 ft<br />
12” inch 232,554 ft<br />
16” inch 121,213 ft<br />
20” inch 8,969 ft<br />
24” inch 2,487 ft<br />
Total Length 658,750 ft<br />
*Source: <strong>Martin</strong> <strong>County</strong> Water CAD hydraulic model of the system in 2003.<br />
The <strong>existing</strong> water system includes 2” inch, 3” inch, <strong>and</strong> 4” inch PVC waterlines.<br />
However, they were not modeled since fire hydrants require a minimum 6” inch line to<br />
provide pressure for fire fighting purposes.<br />
MARTIN COUNTY STORMWATER/UTILITY CRA MASTER PLAN – PORT SALERNO CRA SECTION 4-10<br />
EXISTING CONDITIONS AND NEEDS (07/03/06)
Current <strong>County</strong> customers in the Port Salerno CRA are served through two major trunk<br />
lines. A 16” inch water line runs along SE Dixie Highway <strong>and</strong> a 20” inch water line runs<br />
along SE Cove Road as shown in Figure 8, “Existing Water Piping.” The development<br />
of Figure 8 was based on information extracted from the electronic Utility Atlas supplied<br />
by <strong>Martin</strong> <strong>County</strong> Utilities, which graphically depicts the current water lines in the Port<br />
Salerno CRA.<br />
4.11.2 Summary of Water System Needs<br />
Customers within the CRA served with <strong>existing</strong> water, are generally provided with an<br />
adequate LOS. No known operational deficiencies, such as low operational pressures or<br />
fire flows in the water system, have been identified in our discussions with the utility<br />
provider.<br />
Areas currently not served by central water service, are considered to be deficient<br />
relative to the LOS definition. In addition, there are a number of areas serviced by 2”<br />
inch, 3” inch, <strong>and</strong> 4” inch diameter water mains. While these lines may be sufficient for<br />
providing the daily <strong>needs</strong> of the customer, they are insufficient when compared to the<br />
minimum 6” inch diameter fire flow needed to support basic fire service; unless a hydrant<br />
is fed from a 6” inch line in close proximity of the structure.<br />
4.12 EXISTING SANITARY SEWER SYSTEM<br />
4.12.1 Existing Sanitary Gravity Sewer System<br />
<strong>Martin</strong> <strong>County</strong> Utilities provides wastewater within unincorporated <strong>Martin</strong> <strong>County</strong>,<br />
Seawall’s Point, <strong>and</strong> Ocean Breeze Park. Only part of the CRA is currently connected to<br />
a centralized sewer system. These areas include the neighborhoods of Manatee Creek,<br />
Murray Cove <strong>and</strong> Bollard Avenue.<br />
4.12.2 Existing Sanitary Forcemain Transmission System<br />
Port Salerno is located in <strong>Martin</strong> <strong>County</strong> Utilities South Wastewater System. The south<br />
system consists of the Tropical Farms, Parkwood, Rocky Point <strong>and</strong> North A1A service<br />
areas. Currently, the wastewater system is interconnected, where flows are divided<br />
between the Dixie Park Wastewater Treatment Plant <strong>and</strong> the Tropical Farms<br />
Wastewater Treatment Plant. <strong>Martin</strong> <strong>County</strong> Utilities plan to take the Dixie Park<br />
Wastewater Treatment Plant off-line (out of service) in the future, leaving Tropical Farms<br />
Wastewater treatment Plant the only facility in the south system. Dixie Park will be used<br />
as a master re-pumping station to redirect flows from the east side of the service area to<br />
the west for treatment.<br />
There are several lift stations within the CRA boundary; most are located in the SE<br />
<strong>section</strong> of the CRA. All the lift stations pump to an 8” inch or 6” inch forcemain: the<br />
majority of which pump to the Dixie Park WWTP. The lift station west of the Murray<br />
Middle School, has the option of being redirected to the Tropical Farms Wastewater<br />
Treatment Plant by shutting-off the forcemain valve near the School.<br />
MARTIN COUNTY STORMWATER/UTILITY CRA MASTER PLAN – PORT SALERNO CRA SECTION 4-11<br />
EXISTING CONDITIONS AND NEEDS (07/03/06)
4.12.3 Sewer System Needs<br />
The majority of the residences/lots within the CRA boundary lack connection to a<br />
centralized sewer system. The exceptions being the Manatee Creek <strong>and</strong> Murray Cove<br />
neighborhoods, as well as an 8” inch sewer main of Bollard Avenue. There are some<br />
private lift stations for some commercial <strong>and</strong> institutional buildings. In an effort to<br />
connect the CRA to the South System, a comprehensive wastewater collection system<br />
will have to be designed, permitted, <strong>and</strong> constructed.<br />
4.13 WATER AND WASTEWATER SYSTEM LEVEL OF SERVICE DEFICITS<br />
Areas currently not served by central water <strong>and</strong> sewer service are considered to be<br />
deficient relative to the LOS definition. There are a number of areas serviced by 4” inch<br />
<strong>and</strong> 2” inch diameter water mains. While these lines may be sufficient for providing the<br />
daily <strong>needs</strong> of the customer, they are insufficient compared to the minimum 6” inch<br />
diameter pipe needed to support basic fire service, unless a hydrant serviced by a 6”<br />
inch line is in close proximity of the structure.<br />
Figure 8, “Existing Water Piping”, delineates the <strong>existing</strong> central water piping system<br />
within the CRA as reported by <strong>Martin</strong> <strong>County</strong> Utilities. The water piping shown in the<br />
exhibit is limited to 6” inch diameter <strong>and</strong> larger. Areas shown in the exhibit which do not<br />
have <strong>existing</strong> piping are considered to be deficient in accordance with the LOS<br />
st<strong>and</strong>ards.<br />
Figure 9, “Existing Wastewater Piping”, delineates the <strong>existing</strong> wastewater piping<br />
system within the CRA as reported by <strong>Martin</strong> <strong>County</strong> Utilities. The gravity portion of the<br />
sewer system installed does not have any known service deficits. According to the<br />
March 2000 Forcemain System Hydraulic Analysis by Hutcheon Engineers, 100% of the<br />
lift stations within the CRA boundary are able to deliver the required flows during peak<br />
flow <strong>conditions</strong>.<br />
4.14 LEVEL OF SERVICE RECOMMENDATIONS FOR WATER AND WASTEWATER<br />
Level of Service (LOS) st<strong>and</strong>ards for the water <strong>and</strong> wastewater systems are identified<br />
through a combination of engineering st<strong>and</strong>ards, utility purveyor policies, community<br />
practices, <strong>and</strong> regulatory requirements as presented in Section 3. Throughout the CRA<br />
area (as well as other areas of the <strong>County</strong>) there are large tracts of l<strong>and</strong> lacking central<br />
water service <strong>and</strong> rely on individual wells for their water supply. Similarly, there are<br />
large areas which do not have access to a central sewer system <strong>and</strong> utilize on-site<br />
septic systems to dispose of their sewage.<br />
The intent of the CRA utility redevelopment process is to: provide central water <strong>and</strong><br />
sewer service to all parcels within the CRA; provide consistent quality potable water to<br />
all residents; provide sufficient fire flow to respond effectively to emergencies; <strong>and</strong>,<br />
eliminate operational <strong>and</strong> environmental problems associated with on-site treatment<br />
systems. Accordingly, the basic LOS st<strong>and</strong>ard for all areas within the CRA incorporates<br />
the following:<br />
MARTIN COUNTY STORMWATER/UTILITY CRA MASTER PLAN – PORT SALERNO CRA SECTION 4-12<br />
EXISTING CONDITIONS AND NEEDS (07/03/06)
− Centralized potable water service to supply the consumptive <strong>needs</strong> of all<br />
parcels within the service area<br />
− Minimum fire flow to every parcel consistent with the potential use of all<br />
parcels<br />
− Centralized Sewage collection service for all parcels<br />
Inherent in providing the LOS st<strong>and</strong>ards are implied minimum design st<strong>and</strong>ards utilized<br />
for sizing the pipes <strong>and</strong> related facilities. Design st<strong>and</strong>ards are developed from a<br />
combination of: national st<strong>and</strong>ards; <strong>Martin</strong> <strong>County</strong> policies <strong>and</strong> practices; <strong>and</strong>, regulatory<br />
requirements <strong>and</strong> guidelines. These include the following:<br />
1) Water systems<br />
a. Minimum 6” inch diameter water lines – In order to provide a basic<br />
level of fire protection, fire hydrants are required to be connected to<br />
minimum 6” inch diameter water lines. A number of areas within the CRA<br />
have 2” inch <strong>and</strong>/or 4” inch diameter lines which can provide basic water<br />
service but do not provide adequate flow for fire protection.<br />
b. Provide Fire Hydrant availability to all Parcels – Installation of fire<br />
hydrants at approximately 500’ foot intervals ensures adequate hydrant<br />
availability for each structure.<br />
c. Minimum system pressure under peak flow condition is 40 pounds<br />
per square inch (psi) – During the maximum anticipated flow condition,<br />
minimum pressure requirements at the point of the service connection<br />
provides sufficient pressure to adjacent structure plumbing systems.<br />
d. Minimum system pressure under fire flow condition is 20 psi –<br />
During a fire, the minimum requirement for 40 psi at the service<br />
connection is relaxed to 20 psi for the period required to respond to the<br />
fire. Unless unusual <strong>conditions</strong> require special consideration, it is<br />
assumed the fire flow event is run in conjunction with Maximum Day Flow<br />
on the system, rather than the peak flow condition.<br />
e. Fire Flow Requirements – Minimum st<strong>and</strong>ards include providing a 500<br />
gallon per minute (GPM) fire flow to single family residential areas <strong>and</strong> a<br />
maximum fire flow dem<strong>and</strong> of 1500 GPM to non- residential areas. While<br />
many areas of the system can obtain larger fire flows, this is the<br />
maximum the system would deliver at the most remote point on the<br />
anticipated day of the year with the highest water dem<strong>and</strong>. Dem<strong>and</strong>s in<br />
excess of this amount may require additional pumping or storage on site.<br />
2) Wastewater systems<br />
a. Wastewater Service provided by central collection system – A<br />
number of areas within the CRA boundary have an on-site treatment<br />
system (septic tanks or small package plants). It is the intent of this<br />
project to eliminate the on-site treatment systems <strong>and</strong> tie the customers<br />
into the central sewer system as a basic LOS.<br />
MARTIN COUNTY STORMWATER/UTILITY CRA MASTER PLAN – PORT SALERNO CRA SECTION 4-13<br />
EXISTING CONDITIONS AND NEEDS (07/03/06)
. Minimum 8” inch diameter gravity line – In accordance with generally<br />
accepted engineering st<strong>and</strong>ards (<strong>Florida</strong> Department of Environmental<br />
Protection Regulations, Ten State St<strong>and</strong>ards, <strong>and</strong> the Water Pollution<br />
Control Federation Manual of Practice) the minimum acceptable diameter<br />
sewer line in a system is 8” inch diameter. The vast majority of the sewer<br />
lines to be installed in the CRA area project would fall into this category.<br />
c. Minimum four 4” inch diameter force main – In accordance with<br />
generally accepted engineering st<strong>and</strong>ards <strong>Florida</strong> Department of<br />
Environmental Protection Regulations, Ten State St<strong>and</strong>ards, <strong>and</strong> the<br />
Water Pollution Control Federation Manual of Practice) the minimum<br />
acceptable nominal diameter sewer line in a force main is 4” inch<br />
diameter.<br />
d. Maximum Manhole spacing of 400’ feet – This st<strong>and</strong>ard is set by <strong>Martin</strong><br />
<strong>County</strong> Utilities <strong>and</strong> is determined by the maximum length of pipe<br />
cleaning equipment available to the system operator.<br />
MARTIN COUNTY STORMWATER/UTILITY CRA MASTER PLAN – PORT SALERNO CRA SECTION 4-14<br />
EXISTING CONDITIONS AND NEEDS (07/03/06)