November 2007 - Vol. 36, No. 11 - Philadelphia Bar Association

Bar Announces Ratings for Judicial Election
Chancellor Jane Dalton and Shelley
R. Smith, Chair of the Association’s
Commission on Judicial Selection and
Retention, have announced the results of
the Commission’s investigation into the
qualifications of candidates for Philadelphia’s
Court of Common Pleas and
Municipal Court in the Nov. 6 general
election.
In addition, the Judicial Commission
also released the results of a poll of
all Philadelphia lawyers conducted for
the Bar Association earlier this year by
Votenet. The poll invited respondents
to rate specific aspects of the judicial
performance of each of the retention
judges. Under the bylaws of the Association,
the poll is not binding upon the
Commission’s deliberations, although it
must be published with the Commission’s
findings. The complete poll results are
available from the Bar Association.
Dalton pointed out that the Association’s
Campaign for Qualified Judges has
launched a pop-up window that appears
whenever anyone visits the Association’s
Web site. The window lists ratings that
can be printed out and taken to the polls
on Nov. 6. The Web site also features a
complete “Voters Guide to the Judicial
Elections.” Dalton said the Association
wants voters to know “not just who to
vote for but why the judicial elections are
so important and why we invest so much
time and energy in reviewing and rating
these candidates. This is the one place for
voters to find thorough, non-partisan,
objective ratings of the candidates.”
The Commission on Judicial Selection
and Retention is independent and
non-partisan. It includes lawyers and
non-lawyers. Among the members of
the Commission are the chief public defender,
the president judges of the Common
Pleas and Municipal Courts, and
representatives from the Asian, Hispanic
and African American legal groups.
The ratings by the 30-member Judicial
Commission follow extensive study and
investigation by five-member panels of
the Commission’s own 120-member
investigative division, which includes
40 non-lawyer members. Those found
Recommended satisfied a cumulative review
of criteria including legal ability and
training, trial experience, character and
integrity, judicial temperament, mental
and physical capacity and community
WebCheck
involvement. The complete criteria are
available from the Bar Association.
The following judges, listed alphabetically,
were found RECOMMENDED
for retention to the Court of Common
Pleas:
Mark I. Bernstein
Gary DiVito
John W. Herron
C. Darnell Jones II
Barbara A. Joseph
Shelley Robins New
Rosalyn K. Robinson
Peter F. Rogers
M. Teresa Sarmina
Edward R. Summers
The following judges, listed alphabetically,
were found RECOMMENDED
for retention to Municipal Court:
Teresa Carr Deni
Ronald B. Merriweather
Wendy L. Pew
Louis J. Presenza
The following judges, listed alphabetically,
were found NOT RECOM-
MENDED for retention to the Municipal
Court:
Georganne V. Daher
Deborah S. Griffin
The Commission reiterated its ratings
of the following candidates who have
been found RECOMMENDED for
election to the Court of Common Pleas:
Linda Carpenter
Alice Beck Dubow
Michael Erdos
Joyce Eubanks
Ellen Green-Ceisler
The Commission reiterated its rating
of the following candidate who has been
found RECOMMENDED for election
to the Municipal Court:
Joseph J. O’Neill
The Commission reiterated its rating
of the following candidate who has been
found NOT RECOMMENDED for
election to the Municipal Court:
Jacquelyn Frazier-Lyde
For a complete guide to the Judicial
Elections, visit philadelphiabar.org.
AN AMERICAN BRASSERIE
$19 THREE-COURSE EXPRESS LUNCH, AVAILABLE M-F, 11AM-2PM
Park Hyatt Philadelphia at the Bellevue. 19th Floor. Broad and Walnut Streets. Philadelphia. PA 19102
TELEPHONE
215.790.1919 www.nineteenrestaurant.com
6 Philadelphia Bar Reporter November 2007 philadelphiabar.org