13.06.2014 Views

Jul/Aug 2012 - Rocky Mountain Philatelic Library

Jul/Aug 2012 - Rocky Mountain Philatelic Library

Jul/Aug 2012 - Rocky Mountain Philatelic Library

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

Ron Mitchell’s Denver Eagle Book<br />

Wins Third Gold Medal<br />

Once more an RMPL published book has won gold medals<br />

in each of the three most prominent philatelic literature<br />

competitions in the country.<br />

Ron Mitchell’s Mexico’s Denver Printing of 1914, in<br />

addition to winning gold, also won the Reserve Grand<br />

Award for Literature, as well as the APS Award for Research<br />

Literature.<br />

Ron’s gold medal at NAPEX, added to his gold medals<br />

at last year’s CHICAGOPEX and STAMPSHOW, brings the<br />

RMPL six gold medals for its two recent publications.<br />

The earlier award winner was our first publication<br />

Camp Genter, Colorado Ghost Town Mail.<br />

Our congratulations to Ron for his outstanding work.<br />

The RMPL will be printing a second run of 50 copies of the<br />

book to meet demand. Anyone wishing to purchase a copy<br />

please contact Sergio Lugo to reserve it.<br />

And if you would like to publish a book which you’ve<br />

written, please consider the RMPL. We’ll provide you with<br />

a writer’s guide and the publications committee will work<br />

with you to produce the very best product the library can<br />

publish. Contact Sergio for further details.<br />

A third book by the RMPL recently published is Peter<br />

Bergh’s Danish Ore Bicolor Issues now available at the library.<br />

Visit the RMPL Web Page<br />

www.rmpldenver.org<br />

Read all back issues of Scribblings<br />

since January 2008 online<br />

Scribblings<br />

Coil Waste - Again<br />

by Joe Lambert<br />

FAKES<br />

The picture shows a good<br />

example of a manufactured<br />

coil waste item. In this<br />

instance, Scott #494, a 3 cent<br />

Type II coil, cat. $21.50, has<br />

been made into something<br />

looking a lot like Scott #541,<br />

a perf. 11x10 coil waste item,<br />

cat. $100. Note the straight<br />

edge of the top perfs, and<br />

the slight decrease in hole<br />

depth as the perfs move to<br />

the right. The bottom edge<br />

perfs are slightly more realistic looking, but, both top<br />

and bottom, the holes do not gauge correctly. (The<br />

Specialist, or Kiusalas, gauge is excellent for these<br />

situations- more on this at a later date).<br />

This is a mediocre #494 made into a pretty good<br />

looking #541 (for this)- remember that the stamps<br />

selected by the Bureau of Engraving and Printing for<br />

coil waste manufacture were typically, by the Bureau’s<br />

admission, badly centered. The presumed end product,<br />

#541, is not a rarity or punitively expensive- this is<br />

the risk that one takes with some frequently faked<br />

items- that the item is not so expensive that the cost of<br />

certification is necessarily in line with the value of the<br />

item. Be sure that you are comfortable with the origin<br />

of such items. They were experimental and were sold<br />

only to vending machine operators.<br />

This experiment was of limited time (mostly<br />

in 1908) and of limited scope (in the case of #322,<br />

only 36,500 were issued). Moreover, according to<br />

Armstrong’s United States Coil Issues of 1906-38. “Coils<br />

were a new thing, and at first, did not receive a heartwarming<br />

greeting. Collectors and dealers maintained<br />

the attitude that a coil was even worse than a straight<br />

edge since two sides lacked perforations. Therefore,<br />

it was the general consensus that coils were of no<br />

philatelic value. How things have changed!!!<br />

This particular fake fails for a few reasons - it is<br />

too short, it is not the right color, and it is not the right<br />

type of this stamp (see Armstrong, op.cit. regarding<br />

the last two of these).<br />

Flat plate coils are undoubtedly the most<br />

frequently faked items in U.S. philately - even the<br />

lowest cataloged ones are very often faked. Beware<br />

always - and most especially beware of the rarities - of<br />

which very, very few genuine examples remain. There<br />

are many fakes out there which are considerably more<br />

deceptive than the example here- which is so silly and<br />

off the wall as to deserve its own picture and article.<br />

Page 10 11 <strong>Jul</strong>y-<strong>Aug</strong>ust <strong>2012</strong>

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!