18.11.2014 Views

PARAQUAT

PARAQUAT

PARAQUAT

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

4.2 Terrestrial toxicity<br />

Paraquat is moderately toxic to mammals and<br />

birds (US EPA 2009).<br />

The European Commission‘s Scientifi c<br />

Committee on Plants expressed concern in 2002<br />

about the effects of paraquat on wildlife welfare,<br />

especially on hares and birds. They concluded<br />

that it “can be expected to cause lethal and<br />

sublethal effects and this is confi rmed by fi eld<br />

reports” (EC 2002).<br />

Mammals<br />

Acute toxicity – LD 50 (US EPA 1997):<br />

• male rat = 334 mg/kg bw<br />

• female rat = 283 mg/kg bw<br />

• rabbit = 110 mg/kg bw<br />

• Belgian hare = 35 mg/kg bw<br />

Based on toxicity to rodents, US EPA (1997)<br />

concluded that paraquat is moderately acutely<br />

toxic to small mammals, and lethal below<br />

25 ppm after 12 weeks exposure. Freshly<br />

sprayed foliage can induce death in rabbits, and<br />

especially the hare.<br />

Birds<br />

Paraquat is generally less toxic to birds than it is<br />

to mammals. Nevertheless exposure, especially<br />

chronic exposure, remains a risk and especially<br />

to reproduction. Eisler (1990) reported that some<br />

birds are very much more sensitive than others,<br />

with adverse effects at 10 mg/kg bw in nestlings of<br />

the American kestrel (Falco sparverius) causing<br />

reduced growth; 20 mg/kg in the diet of northern<br />

bobwhite (Colinus virginanus) causing reduced<br />

egg deposition; and 40 mg/L in the drinking water<br />

of domestic chickens (Gallus sp.) increasing the<br />

number of abnormal eggs produced. The lowest<br />

doses of paraquat causing measurable adverse<br />

effects in sensitive species of birds were 0.2<br />

mg/kg bw administered by single intravenous<br />

injection to Japanese quail, causing anemia; and<br />

0.25 mg/kg applied in oil solution to the surface<br />

of mallard eggs, producing reduced survival,<br />

reduced growth, and increased frequency of<br />

developmental abnormalities (Eisler 1990).<br />

These are considerably lower values than LD 50 s<br />

reported by FAO.<br />

Acute toxicity – LD 50 (96 hr):<br />

• unspecified = 35 mg/kg (EC 2003)<br />

• Bobwhite quail = 127 mg/kg bw (FAO 2008)<br />

• Mallard duck = 144 mg/kg bw (FAO 2008)<br />

Acute toxicity – NOEL:<br />

• Bobwhite quail = 72 mg/kg bw (FAO 2008)<br />

Dietary toxicity – LC 50 (FAO 2008):<br />

• Bobwhite quail = 711 mg/kg diet<br />

• Mallard duck = 2,932 mg/kg diet<br />

• Japanese quail = 703 mg/kg diet<br />

Reproductive toxicity – NOEC<br />

• Unspecifi ed = 30 mg/kg diet (EC 2003)<br />

• Bobwhite quail = 100 mg/kg (FAO 2008)<br />

• Mallard duck = 30 mg/kg (FAO 2008)<br />

Signs of oral paraquat intoxication in birds<br />

include excessive drinking and regurgitation,<br />

usually within 10 min of exposure. Other signs<br />

appearing after 3 hours include diarrhoea,<br />

ruffled feathers, lack of coordination, imbalance,<br />

wing drop, slowness, weakness, running and<br />

falling, constriction of pupils, and terminal<br />

convulsions. Additional signs reported after<br />

dermal exposure include blistering and cracking<br />

of skin, lacrimation, wingspread, and wing<br />

shivers. Death usually occurred between 3 and<br />

20 hours (Eisler 1990).<br />

The US EPA (1997) concluded that paraquat is<br />

moderately toxic to birds on both an acute and<br />

sub-acute dietary basis; and that it can affect<br />

reproduction or hatchability of eggs when adult<br />

birds are exposed.<br />

The European Commission‘s Scientifi c<br />

Committee on Plants stated that “the possible<br />

effects on the reproduction from spray solutions<br />

reaching eggs in nests and resulting in reduced<br />

hatching and abnormalities could be of serious<br />

concern” (EC 2002).<br />

At concentrations less than the recommended<br />

application rate, paraquat is embryotoxic to<br />

developing eggs of migratory waterfowl (0.056<br />

kg/ha) (Eisler 1990).<br />

Paraquat has caused pseudofeminization of<br />

male chicken and quail embryos; testes showed<br />

intersexual phenomena and Mullerian duct<br />

abnormalities; both sexes had a reduction in the<br />

number of gonocytes (germ cells responsible<br />

for spermatogenesis in males, and oogenesis in<br />

31

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!