08.01.2015 Views

National, International, Armenia, and Community News and Opinion

National, International, Armenia, and Community News and Opinion

National, International, Armenia, and Community News and Opinion

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

Ancient<br />

capitals are<br />

now open<br />

to visitors<br />

See story on<br />

page 16 m<br />

The ten<br />

classes of<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

See story on page 10 m<br />

Two works by<br />

Aivazovsky<br />

may fetch over<br />

$1,650,000<br />

See story on page C6 m<br />

Eastern U.S. Edition<br />

Number 109<br />

April 11, 2009<br />

the armenian<br />

reporter<br />

President Obama meets with, from left, <strong>Armenia</strong>n foreign minister Edward Nalb<strong>and</strong>ian, Swiss foreign minister (<strong>and</strong> mediator) Micheline Calmy-Rey, Turkish undersecretary of the Foreign Ministry Ertugul<br />

Apakan <strong>and</strong> Foreign Minister Ali Babacan at a reception in Istanbul on April 6. The president met with the foreign ministers to commend them on “recent progress” toward the normalization of <strong>Armenia</strong>-Turkey<br />

relations <strong>and</strong> urged them to complete a bilateral agreement. White House photo: Pete Souza.<br />

Obama, in Turkey, raises<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n issues<br />

Avoiding the word genocide the president plays up<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>-Turkey talks<br />

Visit us at reporter.am<br />

See story on page 1 m


The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | April 11, 2009


Number 109<br />

April 11, 2009<br />

the armenian<br />

reporter<br />

The ten classes of <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong><br />

The ancient capitals of Yerv<strong>and</strong>ashat <strong>and</strong> Bagaran<br />

The residents of Bagaran wake up every<br />

morning to the voices of the muezzin<br />

from the neighboring village of<br />

Halimjan. The call for prayers at the<br />

crack of dawn has been part of the<br />

lives of the residents of Bagaran for<br />

decades. The two villages are on two<br />

sides of the Akhuryan river, which<br />

separates <strong>Armenia</strong> <strong>and</strong> Turkey.<br />

<strong>Community</strong><br />

<strong>Community</strong><br />

<strong>Community</strong><br />

The two ancient cities of Yerv<strong>and</strong>ashat<br />

<strong>and</strong> Bagaran, closed off for<br />

centuries because of their strategic<br />

position, are now open to visitors<br />

who can see ancient archaeological<br />

sites dispersed throughout the region,<br />

Tatul Hakobyan reports.<br />

See story on page 16m<br />

Stem Cell Harvesting Center in Yerevan completed<br />

At the annual fund-raising event<br />

of Sipan <strong>Armenia</strong>n School, Louisa<br />

Janbazian, president of the school<br />

board, announced that the school<br />

received an Honorary Award from<br />

Spartak Seyranyan, the minister of<br />

science <strong>and</strong> education of <strong>Armenia</strong>,<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong><br />

In five years, <strong>Armenia</strong>, Iran to be connected by rail<br />

<strong>Community</strong><br />

High ranking officials from <strong>Armenia</strong><br />

<strong>and</strong> Iran are giving assurances<br />

that in five years’ time there will<br />

be a railroad linking the two countries.<br />

According to preliminary calculations,<br />

the railroad will stretch<br />

for approximately 470 kilometers,<br />

with 410 of those on <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

territory. The total cost of this undertaking<br />

is expected to run about<br />

$1.2 billion.<br />

An agreement will be signed by<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong> <strong>and</strong> Iran sometime this<br />

month when President Serge Sargsian<br />

is expected to be in Tehran for<br />

an official visit.<br />

See story on page 17m<br />

On the evening of April 2, the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

Bone Marrow Donor Registry<br />

(ABMDR) held a cocktail reception<br />

in Glendale, California, to<br />

celebrate the upcoming opening<br />

of its Stem Cell Harvesting Center<br />

in Yerevan. The event served as<br />

an opportunity to announce formally<br />

the much-anticipated launch<br />

of the Stem Cell Harvesting Center,<br />

inform guests of current <strong>and</strong><br />

future ABMDR projects, <strong>and</strong> thank<br />

supporters for helping save lives<br />

through the registry.<br />

See story on page 5m<br />

Sustainable-forestry training program prepared<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong> Tree Project (ATP) recently<br />

completed a two-year project to<br />

develop sustainable forestry training<br />

models for <strong>Armenia</strong>. Through<br />

a collaborative effort with Yale<br />

University’s Global Institute of<br />

Sustainable Forestry, ATP worked<br />

with Chadwick Oliver <strong>and</strong> Zachary<br />

Parisa to conduct an analysis of the<br />

forests around the village of Margahovit.<br />

See story on page 4m<br />

Not everyone is delighted to<br />

be there, <strong>and</strong> there are some you<br />

cannot keep away, Gregory Lima<br />

writes of the St. Gregory <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

School in White Plains, N.Y.<br />

As they grow older some can rebel<br />

against their parents’ insistence<br />

they attend class. Asking one such<br />

very young lady what she would<br />

rather do, she answered, “Sleep,”<br />

which she seemed to manage exactly<br />

where she was. Until it was<br />

time to dance. Then the sleepy<br />

girl turned into a dynamo. There<br />

was also the boy who had finished<br />

all the grades <strong>and</strong> still came back.<br />

He was drawn by the pleasure of<br />

speaking <strong>Armenia</strong>n, the cultural<br />

activities, <strong>and</strong> the friends he had<br />

made.<br />

See story on page 10m<br />

Sipan <strong>Armenia</strong>n School honored by <strong>Armenia</strong>’s<br />

Ministry of Education<br />

for its legacy of educating <strong>and</strong> nurturing<br />

the young <strong>Armenia</strong>n generation<br />

with the <strong>Armenia</strong>n spirit,<br />

<strong>and</strong> for the 30th anniversary of its<br />

founding.<br />

See story on page 6m<br />

President Obama, in Turkey,<br />

raises <strong>Armenia</strong>n issues<br />

Avoids the word<br />

genocide<br />

Asks Turkey to open<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong> border<br />

by Emil Sanamyan<br />

WASHINGTON – In a first for a U.S.<br />

president, Barack Obama used his<br />

visit to Ankara to publicly speak of<br />

the need for Turkey to address its<br />

past <strong>and</strong> improve its present relations<br />

with <strong>Armenia</strong>.<br />

But citing reports of an impending<br />

breakthrough in talks between<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong> <strong>and</strong> Turkey, Mr. Obama<br />

effectively sidestepped his pre-election<br />

promise to clearly recognize<br />

the destruction of Ottoman <strong>Armenia</strong>ns<br />

as genocide. Mr. Obama also<br />

encouraged Turkish <strong>and</strong> <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

officials “to complete an agreement”<br />

in an expeditious manner.<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n agenda<br />

without the G word<br />

In his April 6 speech at Turkey’s<br />

Gr<strong>and</strong> <strong>National</strong> Assembly <strong>and</strong> in a<br />

joint press conference with Turkish<br />

president Abdullah Gül earlier<br />

the same day, Mr. Obama became<br />

the first U.S. president to publicly<br />

air some <strong>Armenia</strong>n-American concerns<br />

on a visit to Turkey. (See<br />

transcripts below.)<br />

Addressing the parliament, Mr.<br />

Obama recalled America’s own<br />

treatment of Native Americans <strong>and</strong><br />

Serge Sargsian hopes to go to Turkey<br />

in October through open borders<br />

by Tatul Hakobyan<br />

YEREVAN – <strong>Armenia</strong>’s President<br />

Serge Sargsian stated on April 11<br />

that in terms of <strong>Armenia</strong>-Turkey<br />

relations, the ball is now in Turkey’s<br />

court. He is also hopeful that<br />

Turkey will open the border with<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong> by October.<br />

On the occasion of the first anniversary<br />

of his presidency, Mr.<br />

Sargsian held a press conference<br />

on April 11. Asked by the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

Reporter about the “red lines” the<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n side would not cross in<br />

Turkish-<strong>Armenia</strong>n relations, Mr.<br />

Sargsian said that Yerevan considers<br />

unacceptable the imposition, by<br />

Turkey, of preconditions for the establishment<br />

of relations.<br />

“We have said, <strong>and</strong> I repeat, we are<br />

ready to establish relations without<br />

preconditions. Now, in my opinion,<br />

the ball is in Turkey’s court,” the<br />

president said.<br />

“If we are talking about soccer diplomacy,”<br />

the president continued,<br />

“then we must state that the ball<br />

cannot constantly be on one side of<br />

the field, <strong>and</strong> each soccer match has<br />

a predetermined time frame.” The<br />

current round of talks with Turkey<br />

are spoken of as soccer diplomacy<br />

because Mr. Sargsian invited his<br />

Turkish counterpart, Abdullah Gül,<br />

President Obama meets with, from left, <strong>Armenia</strong>n foreign minister Edward<br />

Nalb<strong>and</strong>ian, Swiss foreign minister (<strong>and</strong> mediator) Micheline Calmy-Rey, Turkish<br />

undersecretary of the Foreign Ministry Ertugul Apakan <strong>and</strong> Foreign Minister Ali<br />

Babacan at a reception in Istanbul on April 6. The president met with the foreign<br />

ministers to commend them on “recent progress” toward the normalization of<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>-Turkey relations <strong>and</strong> urged them to complete a bilateral agreement.<br />

White House photo: Pete Souza.<br />

Blacks, <strong>and</strong> urged Turks to address<br />

the “terrible events of 1915” in a<br />

way that is “honest, open, <strong>and</strong> constructive.”<br />

Extolling the benefits of<br />

opening the border with <strong>Armenia</strong> –<br />

which was closed <strong>and</strong> is kept closed<br />

by Turkey – he said the United<br />

States “strongly supports normalization<br />

of relations between Turkey<br />

<strong>and</strong> <strong>Armenia</strong>.” He also invited Turkey<br />

to play a “constructive role” in<br />

the Karabakh peace process.<br />

At the press conference, the subject<br />

was formally prompted by Chicago<br />

Tribune <strong>and</strong> Los Angeles Times<br />

correspondent Christi Parsons,<br />

who referred to Mr. Obama’s comments<br />

on the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide<br />

as a senator <strong>and</strong> his pre-election<br />

pledges to recognize the Genocide<br />

as president. Ms. Parsons asked<br />

whether the president still held the<br />

same views <strong>and</strong> whether he asked<br />

Mr. Gül to recognize the Genocide.<br />

Mr. Obama responded that he<br />

had not changed his views, which<br />

are “on the record.” But he then<br />

turned to the subject of talks between<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong> <strong>and</strong> Turkey that<br />

could “bear fruit very quickly very<br />

soon” <strong>and</strong> which, he said, he did<br />

not want to “tilt” in favor of either<br />

side, presumably by speaking more<br />

c<strong>and</strong>idly.<br />

Continued on page m<br />

President Serge<br />

Sargsian. Photo:<br />

Photolure.<br />

to Yerevan to watch the September<br />

2008 <strong>Armenia</strong>-Turkey World Cup<br />

qualifying soccer match.<br />

“Is it possible that we have perhaps<br />

miscalculated <strong>and</strong> the Turks<br />

have now adopted another position<br />

<strong>and</strong> are attempting to place<br />

a precondition on the table Of<br />

course, this is possible,” he said.<br />

“But I believe, even in that case, we<br />

will come out of the process much<br />

stronger. Through this process<br />

we were able to once again demonstrate,<br />

as was witnessed by the<br />

international community, that we<br />

are really prepared to establish relations<br />

without preconditions.”<br />

The next <strong>Armenia</strong>-Turkey World<br />

Cup qualifying match will be held in<br />

October in Kayseri, Mr. Gül’s birthplace.<br />

Mr. Sargsian has accepted an<br />

invitation from Mr. Gül to attend.<br />

“During the negotiation process,<br />

the question of Nagorno-Karabakh<br />

or the Genocide has never been<br />

brought up,” the president said, referring<br />

to two pre-conditions long<br />

set by Turkey for the normalization<br />

of relations. He predicted that<br />

at the next soccer match, “I will either<br />

cross through open borders or<br />

we will be at that threshold.” f


The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | April 11, 2009<br />

<strong>National</strong><br />

Washington briefing<br />

by Emil Sanamyan<br />

Obama visits Turkey,<br />

calls Azerbaijan<br />

President Barack Obama visited<br />

Turkey on April 6–7 in an effort<br />

to rebuild a troubled alliance <strong>and</strong><br />

reach out to the Muslim world. The<br />

White House reported that on April<br />

7, Mr. Obama also placed a call to<br />

the president of Azerbaijan.<br />

President Obama prepares to enter<br />

Istanbul's Blue Mosque on April 7.<br />

Addressing the Turkish parliament,<br />

the U.S. president said he was<br />

“committed to renewing the alliance”<br />

that has come under strain as U.S.<br />

<strong>and</strong> Turkish policies on Iraq, Iran,<br />

<strong>and</strong> the Middle East conflict drifted<br />

further apart in recent years.<br />

Mr. Obama said his visit was evidence<br />

of the importance he placed on<br />

U.S.-Turkish relations, although no<br />

formal agreements were announced<br />

during the trip. From the first days<br />

of his administration, Mr. Obama<br />

said he wanted to reach out to the<br />

Islamic world <strong>and</strong> was expected to<br />

visit a majority-Muslim country in<br />

the first months of his presidency.<br />

In January, Turkey invited Mr.<br />

Obama to attend a United Nations<br />

conference dubbed the Alliance of<br />

Civilizations, held in Istanbul. The<br />

invitation led to an official visit to<br />

Turkey at the end of Mr. Obama’s<br />

tour of Europe.<br />

Speaking in parliament, Mr.<br />

Obama praised Turkey’s founder<br />

Mustafa Kemal Ataturk <strong>and</strong><br />

the Turkish political system, while<br />

also noting that there are disagreements<br />

<strong>and</strong> outst<strong>and</strong>ing issues such<br />

as the history of <strong>Armenia</strong>n-Turkish<br />

relations.<br />

The latter subject also featured in<br />

a “good conversation” Mr. Obama<br />

had with Azerbaijani president Ilham<br />

Aliyev, in which the “U.S commitment<br />

to a strong relationship<br />

with Azerbaijan <strong>and</strong> to supporting<br />

progress toward a resolution of the<br />

Nagorno-Karabakh conflict” were<br />

reiterated.<br />

According to Hurriyet newspaper,<br />

upset with reports of progress in<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>-Turkey talks, Mr. Aliyev refused<br />

to attend the Alliance of Civilizations<br />

meeting even after being telephoned<br />

by Secretary of State Hillary<br />

Clinton, who reportedly promised a<br />

meeting with Mr. Obama.<br />

Instead, Mr. Aliyev dispatched<br />

his daughter Leyla Aliyeva. Ms.<br />

Aliyeva serves as the Moscow representative<br />

for the Heydar Aliyev<br />

Foundation headed by her mother<br />

Mehriban Aliyeva.<br />

State Department<br />

nominee held up over<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide<br />

comments<br />

Left out of President Obama’s trip<br />

to Turkey was his pick for assistant<br />

secretary of state for Europe <strong>and</strong><br />

Eurasia, Philip Gordon. According<br />

to Foreign Policy magazine, Mr.<br />

Gordon planned to depart after confirmation<br />

by the Senate on April 3,<br />

but his nomination was held up at<br />

the last moment.<br />

In a statement issued on the<br />

same day, the <strong>Armenia</strong>n <strong>National</strong><br />

Committee of America (ANCA) welcomed<br />

the “delay as a meaningful<br />

opportunity for senators to weigh<br />

the merits of approving a nominee<br />

with a record of arguing against<br />

[U.S.] recognition of the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

genocide.” (See this page in the<br />

March 14 <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter for<br />

some of Mr. Gordon’s past comments<br />

on the subject.)<br />

During a March 27 Senate Foreign<br />

Relations Committee hearing<br />

on Mr. Gordon’s nomination,<br />

his views were scrutinized by Sen.<br />

Robert Menendez (D.-N.J.), who<br />

had previously blocked a Bush administration<br />

nominee for ambassador<br />

to <strong>Armenia</strong> over his comments<br />

on the Genocide.<br />

Silva Harotonian.<br />

But according to Foreign Policy,<br />

Mr. Menendez eventually decided<br />

not to block Mr. Gordon‘s c<strong>and</strong>idacy<br />

<strong>and</strong> abstained in the committee<br />

vote.<br />

On April 8, the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Assembly<br />

of America reported that it was<br />

Sen. John Ensign (R.-Nev.) who<br />

requested the postponement of Mr.<br />

Gordon’s confirmation. In 2007 Mr.<br />

Ensign was the main Republican cosponsor<br />

of a Senate resolution on<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide.<br />

The Senate is expected to return<br />

to consideration of the nominee after<br />

its Easter recess.<br />

Georgian opposition posters. Photo: civil.ge.<br />

U.S. joins talks with<br />

Iran, requests release of<br />

detainees<br />

In a departure from Bush administration<br />

policy, the State Department<br />

said on April 8 that the United<br />

States will formally join other<br />

permanent members of the United<br />

Nations Security Council <strong>and</strong> Germany<br />

in their ongoing talks with<br />

Iran regarding its nuclear program.<br />

Barack Obama advocated direct<br />

talks with Iran during his presidential<br />

campaign. Under George W.<br />

Bush, the United States insisted<br />

that Iran first halt nuclear fuel<br />

enrichment as a condition for U.S.<br />

participation in the talks.<br />

Incidentally, on April 9 the New<br />

York Times reported that Iran had<br />

announced just days earlier making<br />

advances in its ability to enrich<br />

uranium.<br />

On March 31 U.S. <strong>and</strong> Iranian officials<br />

met briefly during a United<br />

Nations conference on Afghanistan<br />

held in the Netherl<strong>and</strong>s. At<br />

that meeting, Iranian officials<br />

were h<strong>and</strong>ed a letter from Secretary<br />

of State Hillary Clinton<br />

requesting the release of four U.S.<br />

citizens held in Iran on what are<br />

believed to be politically motivated<br />

charges.<br />

On April 6, the State Department<br />

additionally urged Iran to<br />

release 34-year-old Silva Harotonian,<br />

an Iranian-<strong>Armenia</strong>n employee<br />

of the U.S.-funded <strong>International</strong><br />

Research <strong>and</strong> Exchanges<br />

Board (IREX) imprisoned in Iran<br />

since last June.<br />

The State Department’s acting<br />

President Obama, in Turkey, raises <strong>Armenia</strong>n issues<br />

spokesperson Robert Wood said<br />

that charges against Ms. Harotonian<br />

– of plotting against the<br />

Iranian government on behalf of<br />

the United States – were “baseless”<br />

<strong>and</strong> that “she is reportedly in<br />

poor <strong>and</strong> deteriorating health as a<br />

direct consequence of her confinement.”<br />

Ms. Harotonian’s case, first made<br />

public last January, was covered by<br />

the Los Angeles Times on April 2<br />

<strong>and</strong> ABC <strong>News</strong> on April 7. (See also<br />

the Reporter’s Feb. 28 edition.)<br />

Georgian opposition<br />

launches campaign for<br />

president’s ouster<br />

Political opponents of Georgian<br />

leader Mikheil Saakashvili began<br />

on April 9 what they promise will<br />

be continuing protests aimed at<br />

toppling the president, whom they<br />

blame for authoritarianism <strong>and</strong><br />

last year’s defeat in the war with<br />

Russia.<br />

The opposition includes a number<br />

of past allies of Mr. Saakashvili’s,<br />

including former parliament<br />

Speaker Nino Bourjanadze <strong>and</strong><br />

former Ambassador to the United<br />

Nations Irakli Alasania, the two<br />

figures seen as frontrunners in a<br />

potential early election.<br />

In a manifesto released before<br />

the campaign’s launch, the opposition<br />

pledged to guarantee Mr. Saakashvili’s<br />

personal security should<br />

he resign voluntarily. Mr. Saakashvili<br />

in turn offered dialogue to the<br />

opposition, but insists he will stay<br />

in office until his second term of<br />

office expires in 2013.<br />

f<br />

n Continued from page <br />

In his follow-up, Mr. Gül outlined<br />

some of the points of the official<br />

Turkish position, denying the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

Genocide, <strong>and</strong> seeking to shift<br />

it from the realm of law <strong>and</strong> politics<br />

to the realm of academic history.<br />

The Turkish president did not<br />

sound as upbeat as Mr. Obama<br />

about the prospect of a breakthrough<br />

in talks with <strong>Armenia</strong>,<br />

noting only that he “would like to<br />

see a good resolution of these discussions,”<br />

<strong>and</strong> adding, “we have a<br />

lot of work” to do, including resolving<br />

“issues between <strong>Armenia</strong> <strong>and</strong><br />

Azerbaijan.”<br />

Talks with <strong>Armenia</strong>:<br />

PR campaign or real<br />

progress<br />

Turkish officials <strong>and</strong> their supporters<br />

have offered contradictory opinions<br />

on the status of talks with <strong>Armenia</strong><br />

<strong>and</strong> whether they might be nearing<br />

some kind of a turning point.<br />

On the eve of Mr. Obama’s visit, a<br />

media blitz sought to play up progress<br />

in talks. Leaks by anonymous,<br />

but presumably Turkish <strong>and</strong> some<br />

U.S. officials to the Wall Street Journal<br />

even suggested April 16 as a day<br />

when an <strong>Armenia</strong>n-Turkish agreement<br />

could be signed. The story was<br />

picked up by the Washington Times,<br />

Financial Times, <strong>and</strong> others.<br />

Members of the congressional<br />

Turkey caucus spun the same story<br />

line, urging Mr. Obama to encourage<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n <strong>and</strong> Turkish leaders<br />

to reach an agreement.<br />

But speaking in London on April<br />

3, Prime Minister Recep Tayyip<br />

Erdogan said Turkey would not<br />

concede that the Ottoman treatment<br />

of <strong>Armenia</strong>ns was genocide<br />

<strong>and</strong> again linked the establishment<br />

of relations with <strong>Armenia</strong> to the<br />

Nagorno-Karabakh conflict. The<br />

next day Mr. Gül dismissed the<br />

Wall Street Journal report of the<br />

April 16 date as “false.”<br />

In a comment for the media late<br />

Sunday night, <strong>Armenia</strong>’s Foreign<br />

Minister Edward Nalb<strong>and</strong>ian<br />

stressed that there is a “mutual<br />

underst<strong>and</strong>ing” between <strong>Armenia</strong><br />

<strong>and</strong> Turkey that normalization<br />

can have no preconditions, that<br />

there would be no linkages to the<br />

Genocide or Karabakh, <strong>and</strong> that<br />

statements to the contrary “may<br />

be regarded as an attempt to impede<br />

the progress reached in the<br />

negotiations.”<br />

Mr. Nalb<strong>and</strong>ian then postponed<br />

by 24 hours his departure for Istanbul,<br />

where he was to attend the<br />

Alliance of Civilizations meeting.<br />

Upon arrival in the evening of April<br />

6, he had a brief conversation with<br />

Mr. Obama <strong>and</strong> then a four-way<br />

meeting that included the foreign<br />

ministers of Turkey <strong>and</strong> Switzerl<strong>and</strong>,<br />

which has recently hosted<br />

talks between <strong>Armenia</strong>n <strong>and</strong> Turkish<br />

officials.<br />

An unnamed but senior U.S. official<br />

told Reuters that Mr. Obama<br />

“urged [<strong>Armenia</strong>n <strong>and</strong> Turkish ministers]<br />

to complete an agreement<br />

with dispatch.”<br />

In the meantime, the Azerbaijani<br />

leadership expressed public distress<br />

over <strong>Armenia</strong>n-Turkish talks<br />

<strong>and</strong> President Ilham Aliyev refused<br />

to attend the Istanbul conference<br />

– even after being promised a<br />

meeting with Mr. Obama, Turkish<br />

media reported.<br />

On April 7, Turkish foreign minister<br />

Ali Babacan again spoke of<br />

progress made in talks, but a report<br />

carried by the Anatolia news<br />

agency referred to no timeline. In a<br />

comment that could be seen as directed<br />

to the United States, Mr. Babacan<br />

suggested that “third countries<br />

should act sensitively during<br />

this ongoing process.”<br />

Mixed community<br />

reaction<br />

Adding to the week’s confusion<br />

were the substantially different<br />

interpretations of Mr. Obama’s remarks<br />

offered by <strong>Armenia</strong>n-American<br />

advocacy groups.<br />

Aram Hamparian of the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

<strong>National</strong> Committee of<br />

America (ANCA) said in a statement,<br />

“President Obama missed<br />

a valuable opportunity to honor<br />

his public pledge to recognize the<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide.” At the same<br />

time, he welcomed as “a step in the<br />

right direction” Mr. Obama’s “willingness<br />

to raise his commitment to<br />

recognizing the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide,<br />

even indirectly.”<br />

In a comment for the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

Reporter, Ross Vartian of the U.S.-<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong> Public Affairs Committee<br />

(USAPAC) said, “President Obama<br />

made it clear that his well-known<br />

views on the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide<br />

have not changed <strong>and</strong> that Turkey<br />

needed to face its history. Yet he<br />

could have <strong>and</strong> should have said<br />

the words ‘<strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide’ at a<br />

time <strong>and</strong> place perfect for doing so.”<br />

“President Obama st<strong>and</strong>s by his<br />

pledge regarding affirmation of the<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n genocide,” ran the headline<br />

of the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Assembly of<br />

America statement released to the<br />

media. Unlike the ANCA, the Assembly<br />

offered no criticism, pointing instead<br />

to Mr. Obama’s comment that<br />

he hasn’t changed his view.<br />

The Assembly’s Bryan Ardouny<br />

noted, “For the first time, a U.S.<br />

President has delivered a direct<br />

message to Turkish officials in their<br />

own country that he st<strong>and</strong>s behind<br />

his steadfast support <strong>and</strong> strong<br />

record of affirmation of the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

Genocide.”<br />

The Assembly statement sidestepped<br />

the fact that Mr. Obama<br />

chose to sidestep the word genocide.<br />

Incidentally, on April 6 the Hawaii<br />

State House of Representatives<br />

passed a measure condemning the<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide. Mr. Obama’s<br />

home state became the 42nd U.S.<br />

state to recognize the Genocide. f


The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | April 11, 2009<br />

<strong>International</strong><br />

<br />

Telling the truth about the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide<br />

We must resist<br />

Turkish pressure to<br />

distort history.<br />

by Christopher Hitchens<br />

This article is reprinted with permission<br />

from Slate.com, where it was<br />

posted on April 6.<br />

Even before President Barack<br />

Obama set off on his visit to Turkey<br />

this week, there were the usual<br />

voices urging him to dilute the<br />

principled position that he has so<br />

far taken on the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide.<br />

April is the month in which<br />

the <strong>Armenia</strong>n diaspora commemorates<br />

the bloody initiation, in 1915,<br />

of the Ottoman Empire’s campaign<br />

to erase its <strong>Armenia</strong>n population.<br />

The marking of the occasion takes<br />

two forms: <strong>Armenia</strong>n Remembrance<br />

Day, on April 24, <strong>and</strong> the annual<br />

attempt to persuade Congress<br />

to name that day as one that ab<strong>and</strong>ons<br />

weasel wording <strong>and</strong> officially<br />

calls the episode by its right name,<br />

which is the word I used above.<br />

Genocide had not been coined in<br />

1915, but the U.S. ambassador in<br />

Constantinople, Henry Morgenthau,<br />

employed a term that was<br />

Christopher Hitchens is a columnist for<br />

Vanity Fair <strong>and</strong> the Roger S. Mertz media<br />

fellow at the Hoover Institution in<br />

Stanford, Calif.<br />

in some ways more graphic. In his<br />

urgent reports to the State Department,<br />

conveying on-the-spot dispatches<br />

from his consuls, especially<br />

in the provinces of Van <strong>and</strong> Harput,<br />

he described the systematic slaughter<br />

of the <strong>Armenia</strong>ns as “race murder.”<br />

A vast archive of evidence exists<br />

to support this claim. But every<br />

year, the deniers <strong>and</strong> euphemists<br />

set to work again, <strong>and</strong> there are<br />

usually enough military-industrial<br />

votes to tip the scale in favor of our<br />

Turkish client. (Of late, Turkey’s<br />

opportunist military alliance with<br />

Israel has also been good for a few<br />

shame-faced Jewish votes as well.)<br />

Obama’s unambivalent<br />

record<br />

President Obama comes to this issue<br />

with an unusually clear <strong>and</strong> unambivalent<br />

record. In 2006, for example,<br />

the U.S. ambassador to <strong>Armenia</strong>,<br />

John Evans, was recalled<br />

for employing the word genocide.<br />

Then-Sen. Obama wrote a letter<br />

of complaint to then-Secretary of<br />

State Condoleezza Rice, deploring<br />

the State Department’s cowardice<br />

<strong>and</strong> roundly stating that the<br />

occurrence of the <strong>Armenia</strong>n genocide<br />

in 1915 “is not an allegation, a<br />

personal opinion, or a point of view,<br />

but rather a widely documented<br />

fact supported by an overwhelming<br />

body of historical evidence.”<br />

On the campaign trail last year, he<br />

amplified this position, saying that<br />

“America deserves a leader who<br />

speaks truthfully about the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

genocide <strong>and</strong> responds forcefully<br />

to all genocides. I intend to be<br />

that president.”<br />

For any who might entertain<br />

doubt on this score, I would recommend<br />

two recent books of exceptional<br />

interest <strong>and</strong> scholarship<br />

that both add a good deal of depth<br />

<strong>and</strong> texture to this drama. The first<br />

is <strong>Armenia</strong>n Golgotha: A Memoir of<br />

the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide, by Grigoris<br />

Balakian, <strong>and</strong> the second is Rebel<br />

L<strong>and</strong>: Travels Among Turkey’s Forgotten<br />

Peoples, a contemporary account<br />

by Christopher de Bellaigue.<br />

Shattering evidence<br />

In addition, we have just learned of<br />

shattering corroborative evidence<br />

from within the archives of the<br />

Turkish state. The Ottoman politician<br />

who began the campaign of deportation<br />

<strong>and</strong> extermination, Talat<br />

Pasha, left enormous documentation<br />

behind him. His family has<br />

now given the papers to a Turkish<br />

author named Murat Bardakci,<br />

who has published a book with the<br />

somewhat dry title, The Remaining<br />

Documents of Talat Pasha. One<br />

of these “remaining documents”<br />

is a cold estimate that during the<br />

years 1915 <strong>and</strong> 1916 alone, a total<br />

of 972,000 <strong>Armenia</strong>ns simply vanished<br />

from the officially kept records<br />

of population. (See Sabrina<br />

Tavernise’s report in the New York<br />

Times of March 8, 2009.)<br />

There are those who try to say that<br />

the <strong>Armenia</strong>n catastrophe was a regrettable<br />

byproduct of the fog of war<br />

<strong>and</strong> of imperial collapse, <strong>and</strong> this<br />

might be partly true of the many<br />

more <strong>Armenia</strong>ns who were slaughtered<br />

at the war’s end <strong>and</strong> after the<br />

implosion of Ottomanism. But this<br />

is an archive maintained by the government<br />

of the day <strong>and</strong> its chief anti-<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n politician, <strong>and</strong> it records<br />

in the very early days of World War I<br />

a population decline from 1,256,000<br />

to 284,157. It is very seldom that a<br />

regime in its private correspondence<br />

confirms almost to an exactitude the<br />

claims of its victims.<br />

Ankara’s unchecked<br />

arrogance<br />

So what will the deniers say now<br />

The usual routine has been to insinuate<br />

that if Congress votes to assert<br />

the historic truth, then Turkey will<br />

inconvenience the NATO alliance by<br />

making trouble on the Iraqi border,<br />

denying the use of bases to the U.S.<br />

Air Force, or in other unspecified<br />

ways. This same kind of unchecked<br />

arrogance was on view at the NATO<br />

summit last weekend, where the<br />

Ankara government had the nerve<br />

to try to hold up the appointment<br />

of a serious Danish politician,<br />

Anders Rasmussen, as the next<br />

secretary-general of the alliance,<br />

on the grounds that as Denmark’s<br />

prime minister he had refused<br />

to censor Danish newspapers to<br />

Muslim satisfaction! It is now being<br />

hinted that if either President<br />

Obama or the Congress goes ahead<br />

with the endorsement of the genocide<br />

resolution, Turkey will prove<br />

uncooperative on a range of issues,<br />

including the normalization of the<br />

frontier between Turkey <strong>and</strong> <strong>Armenia</strong><br />

<strong>and</strong> the transit of oil <strong>and</strong> gas<br />

pipelines across the Caucasus.<br />

A matter of courage<br />

When the question is phrased in<br />

this thuggish way, it can be slyly<br />

suggested that <strong>Armenia</strong>’s own best<br />

interests are served by joining in the<br />

agreement to muddy <strong>and</strong> distort<br />

its own history. Yet how could any<br />

state, or any people, agree to abolish<br />

their pride <strong>and</strong> dignity in this<br />

way And the question is not only<br />

for <strong>Armenia</strong>ns, who are economically<br />

hard-pressed by the Turkish<br />

closure of the common border. It is<br />

for the Turks, whose bravest cultural<br />

spokesmen <strong>and</strong> writers take genuine<br />

risks to break the taboo on discussion<br />

of the <strong>Armenia</strong>n question.<br />

And it is also for Americans, who,<br />

having elected a supposedly brave<br />

new president, are being told that<br />

he – <strong>and</strong> our Congress too – must<br />

agree to collude in a gigantic historical<br />

lie. A lie, furthermore, that<br />

courageous U.S. diplomacy helped<br />

to expose in the first place.<br />

This falsification has already<br />

gone on long enough <strong>and</strong> has been<br />

justified for reasons of state. It is,<br />

among other things, precisely “for<br />

reasons of state,” in other words for<br />

the clear <strong>and</strong> vital announcement<br />

that we can’t be bought or intimidated,<br />

that April 24, 2009, should<br />

become remembered as the date<br />

when we affirmed the truth <strong>and</strong> accepted,<br />

as truth-telling does, all the<br />

consequences.<br />

f<br />

Obama: Reckoning with the past can help us seize a better future<br />

In a speech to the Turkish parliament<br />

in Ankara on April 6, President<br />

Barack Obama addressed Turkey’s<br />

reckoning with the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide<br />

<strong>and</strong> its relations with <strong>Armenia</strong>.<br />

The following is an excerpt from the<br />

president’s remarks.<br />

Another issue that confronts all<br />

democracies as they move to the<br />

future is how we deal with the past.<br />

The United States is still working<br />

through some of our own darker<br />

periods in our history. Facing the<br />

Washington Monument that I<br />

spoke of is a memorial of Abraham<br />

Lincoln, the man who freed<br />

those who were enslaved even after<br />

Washington led our Revolution.<br />

Our country still struggles with<br />

the legacies of slavery <strong>and</strong> segregation,<br />

the past treatment of Native<br />

Americans.<br />

Human endeavor is by its nature<br />

imperfect. History is often<br />

tragic, but unresolved, it can be<br />

a heavy weight. Each country<br />

must work through its past. And<br />

reckoning with the past can help<br />

us seize a better future. I know<br />

there’s strong views in this chamber<br />

about the terrible events of<br />

1915. And while there’s been a<br />

good deal of commentary about<br />

my views, it’s really about how<br />

the Turkish <strong>and</strong> <strong>Armenia</strong>n people<br />

deal with the past. And the<br />

best way forward for the Turkish<br />

<strong>and</strong> <strong>Armenia</strong>n people is a process<br />

that works through the past in<br />

a way that is honest, open <strong>and</strong><br />

constructive.<br />

We’ve already seen historic <strong>and</strong><br />

courageous steps taken by Turkish<br />

<strong>and</strong> <strong>Armenia</strong>n leaders. These<br />

contacts hold out the promise of<br />

a new day. An open border would<br />

return the Turkish <strong>and</strong> <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

people to a peaceful <strong>and</strong> prosperous<br />

coexistence that would serve<br />

both of your nations. So I want<br />

you to know that the United States<br />

strongly supports the full normalization<br />

of relations between Turkey<br />

<strong>and</strong> <strong>Armenia</strong>. It is a cause worth<br />

working towards.<br />

It speaks to Turkey’s leadership<br />

that you are poised to be the only<br />

country in the region to have normal<br />

<strong>and</strong> peaceful relations with all<br />

the South Caucasus nations. And<br />

to advance that peace, you can<br />

play a constructive role in helping<br />

to resolve the Nagorno-Karabakh<br />

conflict, which has continued for<br />

far too long.<br />

ttt<br />

Obama: I have not<br />

changed views<br />

During a joint press availability on<br />

April 6 at Cankaya Palace in Ankara,<br />

Turkey, President Barack Obama<br />

<strong>and</strong> his Turkish counterpart <strong>and</strong><br />

host Abdullah Gül took two questions.<br />

The first question was posed<br />

by Christi Parsons. Mr. Obama’s<br />

exchange with Ms. Parsons is reproduced<br />

below. Mr. Gül also responded<br />

to the question, offering a full-throated<br />

denial of the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide.<br />

President Obama: Christi Parsons,<br />

Chicago Tribune – hometown<br />

– hometown newspaper.<br />

Christi Parsons: Thank you,<br />

Mr. President. As a U.S. senator<br />

you stood with the <strong>Armenia</strong>n-<br />

American community in calling for<br />

Turkey’s acknowledgement of the<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide <strong>and</strong> you also<br />

supported the passage of the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

Genocide resolution. You<br />

said, as president you would recognize<br />

the Genocide. And my question<br />

for you is, have you changed<br />

your view, <strong>and</strong> did you ask President<br />

Gül to recognize the Genocide<br />

by name<br />

President Obama: Well, my<br />

views are on the record <strong>and</strong> I<br />

have not changed views. What I<br />

have been very encouraged by is<br />

news that under President Gül’s<br />

leadership, you are seeing a series<br />

of negotiations, a process,<br />

in place between <strong>Armenia</strong> <strong>and</strong><br />

Turkey to resolve a whole host<br />

of longst<strong>and</strong>ing issues, including<br />

this one.<br />

I want to be as encouraging as<br />

possible around those negotiations<br />

which are moving forward<br />

<strong>and</strong> could bear fruit very quickly<br />

very soon. And so as a consequence,<br />

what I want to do is not<br />

focus on my views right now but<br />

focus on the views of the Turkish<br />

<strong>and</strong> the <strong>Armenia</strong>n people. If they<br />

can move forward <strong>and</strong> deal with a<br />

difficult <strong>and</strong> tragic history, then I<br />

think the entire world should encourage<br />

them.<br />

And so what I told the president<br />

was I want to be as constructive<br />

as possible in moving these issues<br />

forward quickly. And my sense is,<br />

is that they are moving quickly.<br />

I don’t want to, as the president<br />

of the United States, preempt<br />

any possible arrangements or announcements<br />

that might be made<br />

in the near future. I just want<br />

to say that we are going to be a<br />

partner in working through these<br />

issues in such a way that the most<br />

important parties, the Turks <strong>and</strong><br />

the <strong>Armenia</strong>ns, are finally coming<br />

to terms in a constructive way.<br />

Christi Parsons: So if I underst<strong>and</strong><br />

you correctly, your view<br />

hasn’t changed, but you’ll put in<br />

abeyance the issue of whether to<br />

use that word in the future<br />

President Obama: What I’d<br />

like to do is to encourage President<br />

Gül to move forward with<br />

what have been some very fruitful<br />

negotiations. And I’m not<br />

interested in the United States<br />

in any way tilting these negotiations<br />

one way or another while<br />

they are having useful discussions.<br />

Christi Parsons: Thank you. f


4 The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | April 11, 2009<br />

<strong>Community</strong><br />

Jennifer Omartian to direct agbu Camp Nubar<br />

Reveals plans for<br />

summer 2009<br />

NEW YORK – agbu Camp Nubar<br />

has announced that Jennifer<br />

Omartian will serve as the 2009<br />

Camp Director. Jennifer first came<br />

to Camp Nubar, located in the<br />

Catskill Mountain Region of New<br />

York, in 1993 <strong>and</strong> she has returned<br />

yearly ever since. She began as a<br />

counselor for several years before<br />

going on to serve as Activities Director,<br />

Girls Head Counselor, <strong>and</strong><br />

Assistant Director. No other director<br />

in the 46-year history of Camp<br />

Nubar has spent more time at the<br />

Catskill camp than Ms. Omartian,<br />

which is a clear indication of her<br />

passion for the facility by idyllic<br />

Lake Arax.The new Camp Director<br />

grew up in Longmeadow, Massachusetts,<br />

where she attended<br />

St. Mark Church in neighboring<br />

agbu Camp Nubar Director Jennifer<br />

Omartian.<br />

Springfield, MA. She graduated<br />

from James Madison University<br />

where she received her master’s<br />

degree in Middle School Education.<br />

Ms. Omartian now resides in Virginia<br />

<strong>and</strong> attends St. Mary Church<br />

in Washington, D.C.<br />

agbu: What are your goals <strong>and</strong><br />

hopes for the summer<br />

Jennifer Omartian: Preparation<br />

is crucial for a safe <strong>and</strong> fun season.<br />

I will ensure that counselors<br />

are prepared, qualified, <strong>and</strong> ready<br />

for another successful summer.<br />

I hope to see campers <strong>and</strong> counselors<br />

work alongside one another,<br />

to grow as individuals <strong>and</strong> into one<br />

family. Campers learn from their<br />

counselors, but counselors learn<br />

from their campers as well. Every<br />

session has a unique blend of people<br />

from different places. I look forward<br />

to seeing how each session will create<br />

its own set of memories using<br />

the same resources <strong>and</strong> facilities.<br />

agbu: What are your favorite aspects<br />

of camp <strong>and</strong> do you have any<br />

favorite memories<br />

JO: I love the anticipation that<br />

surrounds camp. Throughout the<br />

year, campers <strong>and</strong> counselors anticipate<br />

the following summer, the<br />

friends they will be reunited with,<br />

the bonds they will form <strong>and</strong> the<br />

memories they will make. When<br />

camp begins, the campers <strong>and</strong><br />

counselors anxiously wait for their<br />

favorite camp event, whether it is<br />

an evening activity, a carnival, or<br />

Color War. Throughout their camp<br />

careers, campers count down the<br />

summers until they finally become<br />

a counselor.<br />

I also love seeing the camp family<br />

within the greater <strong>Armenia</strong>n community.<br />

It is such a wonderful feeling<br />

to walk into church, a basketball<br />

game, or a picnic <strong>and</strong> see campers<br />

<strong>and</strong> counselors so eager to see each<br />

other <strong>and</strong> talk about camp.<br />

My favorite camp memory was<br />

watching my very first group of G1<br />

campers mature every summer <strong>and</strong><br />

then serve as counselors.<br />

agbu: What is your current occupation<br />

<strong>and</strong> what do you enjoy<br />

about it<br />

JO: I teach sixth-grade social<br />

studies in Fairfax County, Virginia.<br />

I love the diversity at my school<br />

<strong>and</strong> the many challenges that it<br />

presents on a daily basis. I teach<br />

students from all over the world<br />

<strong>and</strong> it amazes me how they blend<br />

together <strong>and</strong> learn from each other<br />

while maintaining pride in their<br />

own identity. I see this same sense<br />

of pride in our campers. Camp Nubar<br />

excels at encouraging campers<br />

to build a sense of pride in their<br />

personal <strong>and</strong> community identities.<br />

I look forward to another amazing<br />

summer at Camp Nubar.<br />

Founded in 1963, agbu Camp<br />

Nubar is a first-rate modern facility<br />

that has been highly ranked by<br />

the American Camp Association,<br />

American Red Cross, <strong>and</strong> American<br />

Academy of Pediatrics. <br />

connect:<br />

campnubar.org<br />

1-212-319-6383<br />

atp works with Yale’s Global Institute of Sustainable Forestry<br />

on new training manual for <strong>Armenia</strong><br />

WATERTOWN – <strong>Armenia</strong> Tree<br />

Project (atp) recently completed a<br />

two-year project to develop sustainable<br />

forestry training models for <strong>Armenia</strong>.<br />

Through a collaborative effort<br />

with Yale University’s Global Institute<br />

of Sustainable Forestry, atp<br />

worked with Chadwick Oliver <strong>and</strong><br />

Zachary Parisa to conduct an analysis<br />

of the forests around the village<br />

of Margahovit.”The degradation of<br />

forested areas in <strong>Armenia</strong> necessitates<br />

a new <strong>and</strong> bold approach to<br />

forestry practices,” stated atp Executive<br />

Director Jeff Masarjian. “With<br />

Yale’s expertise, atp has been able<br />

to collaborate with forestry officials<br />

to bring cutting edge forestry training<br />

to <strong>Armenia</strong>. It is our hope that<br />

the project will literally reshape the<br />

nation’s l<strong>and</strong>scape <strong>and</strong> ensure a sustainable<br />

future for its population.”<br />

Working with students from the<br />

Agricultural Academy of <strong>Armenia</strong>,<br />

local residents of Margahovit, <strong>and</strong><br />

World Wildlife Fund, atp planted<br />

a 20 hectare model forest using indigenous<br />

tree species to be used for<br />

future sustainable forestry training.<br />

atp also presented a new Sustainable<br />

Forestry Manual to stakeholders<br />

in <strong>Armenia</strong> <strong>and</strong> developed<br />

a seminar training model to use as<br />

a guide. The manual is currently being<br />

published in Eastern <strong>Armenia</strong>n,<br />

<strong>and</strong> an English-language version is<br />

available at the atp Web site.<br />

Finally, atp assisted the local<br />

community of Margahovit in identifying<br />

non-timber forest products,<br />

bringing environmental education<br />

into the local schools, <strong>and</strong> through<br />

stakeholder meetings that outlined<br />

the benefits <strong>and</strong> challenges of community<br />

forestry. atp is currently<br />

developing a plan to conduct sustainable<br />

forestry training seminars<br />

throughout <strong>Armenia</strong>.<br />

“The project was designed to evaluate<br />

the condition of the forests in<br />

Northern <strong>Armenia</strong>, paying particular<br />

attention to the factors that are<br />

limiting the ability for regeneration,”<br />

explained Masarjian. “An assessment<br />

was made of plants, herbs,<br />

<strong>and</strong> other non-timber products<br />

that may be harvested for generating<br />

alternative income for residents<br />

living in proximity to the forests.<br />

Additional trainings on rotational<br />

grazing will also be held with livestock<br />

owners to prevent soil erosion<br />

<strong>and</strong> further degradation of forests.”<br />

“The collaboration between atp<br />

<strong>and</strong> Yale has been a great success.<br />

We worked together to create an<br />

instructional manual designed<br />

specifically for conditions in <strong>Armenia</strong><br />

that will be used to train local<br />

stakeholders in global best practices<br />

of forest management. We’re<br />

grateful for the vision <strong>and</strong> generosity<br />

of S<strong>and</strong>ra <strong>and</strong> Jim Leitner, who<br />

introduced us in the hope of creating<br />

a sustainable future for <strong>Armenia</strong>,”<br />

concluded Dr. Oliver, director<br />

of the Yale Global Institute of Sustainable<br />

Forestry.<br />

This project was funded by the<br />

Critical Ecosystem Partnership<br />

Fund, a joint program of l’Agence<br />

Francaise de Developpement, Conservation<br />

<strong>International</strong>, the Global<br />

Environment Facility, the Government<br />

of Japan, the MacArthur<br />

Foundation, <strong>and</strong> the World Bank.<br />

Since 1994, <strong>Armenia</strong> Tree Project<br />

has planted <strong>and</strong> restored more<br />

than 2,500,000 trees <strong>and</strong> created<br />

hundreds of jobs for impoverished<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>ns in tree-regeneration<br />

programs. The organization’s three<br />

tiered initiatives are tree planting,<br />

community development to reduce<br />

poverty <strong>and</strong> promote self-sufficiency,<br />

<strong>and</strong> environmental education to<br />

protect <strong>Armenia</strong>’s precious natural<br />

resources.<br />

<br />

connect:armeniatree.org<br />

Zachary Parisa (right) from Yale<br />

University gathered data on the<br />

forests in the Lori region of <strong>Armenia</strong><br />

with students from Yerevan’s<br />

Agricultural Academy.<br />

Let us know<br />

what’s on your mind.<br />

Write to us at<br />

letters@reporter.am<br />

Need extra space at home<br />

Sell your stuff with the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter<br />

classifieds@reporter.am<br />

818-955-8407


The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | April 11, 2009 5<br />

<strong>Community</strong><br />

Stem Cell Harvesting Center in Yerevan completed<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n Bone<br />

Marrow Donor<br />

Registry holds preopening<br />

celebration<br />

in Los Angeles<br />

LOS ANGELES – On the evening<br />

of April 2, the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Bone<br />

Marrow Donor Registry (abmdr)<br />

held a cocktail reception in Glendale,<br />

California, to celebrate the<br />

upcoming opening of its Stem Cell<br />

Harvesting Center in Yerevan.<br />

The event, which was attended<br />

by supporters, abmdr staff, <strong>and</strong><br />

various committee members – all<br />

of whom volunteer for the registry<br />

– served as an opportunity to announce<br />

formally the much-anticipated<br />

launch of the Stem Cell Harvesting<br />

Center, inform guests of<br />

current <strong>and</strong> future abmdr projects,<br />

<strong>and</strong> thank supporters for helping<br />

save lives through the registry.<br />

$850,000 raised<br />

In opening remarks, Dr. Frieda<br />

Jordan, president of the abmdr<br />

Board of Directors, expressed her<br />

gratitude to the numerous individual<br />

<strong>and</strong> corporate supporters who<br />

contributed to the registry’s firstever<br />

telethon, held on April 13, 2008.<br />

“Thanks to your timely assistance,<br />

the Stem Cell Harvesting Center at<br />

last became a reality,” Dr. Jordan<br />

said. “The project was realized despite<br />

being faced with so many challenges<br />

– including the Russo-Georgian<br />

war last year, because of which<br />

manufacturers could not deliver to<br />

Yerevan the machines we had purchased<br />

for the Stem Cell Harvesting<br />

Center.” She said this particular<br />

issue was eventually solved by<br />

the United <strong>Armenia</strong>n Fund, which<br />

transported all the required equipment<br />

to <strong>Armenia</strong>.<br />

“With the opening of the Stem<br />

Cell Harvesting Center, we can now<br />

save <strong>Armenia</strong>n <strong>and</strong> non-<strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

lives easily <strong>and</strong> cheaply,” Dr. Jordan<br />

continued. “This is why it’s so<br />

critical to continue supporting the<br />

work of the abmdr. In this respect,<br />

our next major project is the establishment<br />

of a transplant center.”<br />

Two years in the making, the<br />

Stem Cell Harvesting Center was<br />

made possible through lead gifts by<br />

abmdr Board member Dr. Carolann<br />

Najarian, an anonymous<br />

donor, <strong>and</strong> the Glendale Sunrise<br />

Rotary, followed by contributions<br />

from the Lincy Foundation, the<br />

Disney Foundation, VivaCell of <strong>Armenia</strong>,<br />

<strong>and</strong> various <strong>Armenia</strong>n organizations,<br />

as well as hundreds of<br />

donors responding to the abmdr<br />

Telethon. With a total of $850,000<br />

raised, the registry was able to fully<br />

renovate the Stem Cell Harvesting<br />

Krikorian reelected<br />

to school board<br />

GLENDALE, Calif. – Incumbents<br />

Ara Najarian <strong>and</strong> Frank<br />

Quintero <strong>and</strong> challenger Laura<br />

Friedman were elected to Glendale<br />

City Council on Tuesday, ending<br />

Bob Yousefian’s eight-year<br />

service on the body.<br />

They will join Dave Weaver <strong>and</strong><br />

John Drayman on the five-member<br />

City Council after a swearing-in<br />

ceremony on April 20.<br />

Each of the three winners garnered<br />

over 8,000 votes, while Mr.<br />

Yousefian <strong>and</strong> Bruce Philpott<br />

won around 6,500 votes. There<br />

were seven additional c<strong>and</strong>idates,<br />

Fimi Mekhitarian.<br />

Center site, provide it with state-<br />

Razmik Moghadasian.<br />

of-the-art equipment, <strong>and</strong> train<br />

personnel. Slated to open on April<br />

28, the center is expected to receive<br />

full accreditation by the European<br />

Federation of Immunogenetics.<br />

A dynamic <strong>and</strong> healthy<br />

registry<br />

According to Dr. Vergine Madenlian,<br />

the abmdr’s outreach <strong>and</strong><br />

development officer <strong>and</strong> a biochemistry<br />

lecturer at California State<br />

University, Northridge, the opening<br />

of the Stem Cell Harvesting<br />

Center is a medical milestone not<br />

only for <strong>Armenia</strong> <strong>and</strong> the Caucasus,<br />

but also for <strong>Armenia</strong>ns throughout<br />

the world. The center recruits bone<br />

marrow/stem cell donors from predominantly<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n populations<br />

worldwide, analyzes <strong>and</strong> determines<br />

the HLA tissue type of donors, <strong>and</strong><br />

maintains a database. Once it receives<br />

a request from a patient requiring<br />

stem cell transplantation,<br />

the abmdr finds matches in its own<br />

or other registries worldwide <strong>and</strong><br />

facilitates the transplantation.<br />

Dr. Madenlian, who has volunteered<br />

for the abmdr since 2004,<br />

including five <strong>Armenia</strong>n-Americans.<br />

An estimated 40 percent of<br />

Glendale’s population is <strong>Armenia</strong>n-<br />

American.<br />

Ron Borucki was reelected as<br />

city treasurer, holding off a challenge<br />

from former Glendale mayor<br />

Rafi Manoukian.<br />

In the School Board race, voters<br />

reelected Greg Krikorian <strong>and</strong><br />

Joylene Wagner. At the same<br />

time they elected Christine Walters.<br />

Unlike the incumbents, Ms.<br />

Walters <strong>and</strong> Eric Sahakian enjoyed<br />

the strong support of the<br />

teachers’ union <strong>and</strong> the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

<strong>National</strong> Committee of Glendale<br />

Political Action Committee.<br />

Incumbents Armine Hacopian<br />

<strong>and</strong> Anita Quinonez Gabrielian<br />

From left, Karineh Khudikian, Naz Atikian, Amalia Keoreghian, <strong>and</strong> Dr. Frieda Jordan, president of the abmdr Board of<br />

Directors.<br />

Dr. Evelyn Baghdasarian (left) <strong>and</strong> Lilit Aladadyan.<br />

were reelected as trustees of Glendale<br />

<strong>Community</strong> College. Ann Hazel<br />

Ransford was also elected. The other<br />

added that 50 percent of the registry’s<br />

over 14,000 donors are under<br />

28 years old, making the abmdr<br />

internationally recognized as one<br />

of the world’s most dynamic – <strong>and</strong><br />

healthiest – registries. “It’s just one<br />

more reason that makes volunteering<br />

for the abmdr such a spiritually<br />

rewarding experience,” she said.<br />

Following Dr. Jordan’s address,<br />

Alicia Asmarian, Naz Atikian,<br />

<strong>and</strong> Ani Azar of the abmdr announced<br />

the registry’s annual gala,<br />

“Match for Life 2009,” which will be<br />

held on July 12 at the Glendale Hilton.<br />

The event will raise funds for<br />

advocacy, education, <strong>and</strong> the registry’s<br />

ongoing life-saving services.<br />

Next to take the podium were Dr.<br />

Evelyn Baghdasarian <strong>and</strong> Lilit<br />

Aladadyan of the abmdr, who<br />

informed the guests of the registry’s<br />

next walkathon, “Walk of Life<br />

2009,” slated to take place on October<br />

3 at Glendale’s Verdugo Park.<br />

The event, which will include entertainment,<br />

music, <strong>and</strong> dancing, is<br />

being organized to raise funds for<br />

the registry’s activities as well as to<br />

recruit stem cell donors.<br />

Helping a 21-year-old<br />

man<br />

For an inside look at the abmdr’s<br />

work, Fimi Mekhitarian, a longtime<br />

volunteer <strong>and</strong> West Coast recruitment<br />

officer, spoke of a recent<br />

FaceBook appeal for a 21-year-old<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n man diagnosed with<br />

acute leukemia <strong>and</strong> requiring an urgent<br />

stem cell transplant. “There’s<br />

been an outpouring of grassroots<br />

support following the appeal,” Ms.<br />

Mekhitarian said. “Today the young<br />

man’s family <strong>and</strong> friends are organizing<br />

a stem-cell donor recruitment,<br />

<strong>and</strong> this is where we come<br />

in. In fact, we have recruitments<br />

lined up for San Francisco, Chicago,<br />

<strong>and</strong> Florida. We’re literally having a<br />

field day recruiting donors.”<br />

c<strong>and</strong>idate was Vrej Agajanian.<br />

City clerk Ardy Kassakhian,<br />

running unopposed, was reelected.<br />

The evening’s speakers also included<br />

Dr. Stuart Siegal, an early abmdr<br />

supporter who has had an instrumental<br />

role in helping Dr. Jordan<br />

establish the registry. Commenting<br />

on the launch of the Stem Cell Harvesting<br />

Center, Dr. Siegal said, “One<br />

of the most wonderful outcomes of<br />

this project is that you see tangible<br />

results in terms of saving lives.”<br />

Among the evening’s guest were<br />

many who have been impacted by<br />

life-threatening, blood-related illnesses.<br />

One such individual was<br />

Razmik Moghadasian, whose<br />

nine-year-old son lost his battle<br />

with leukemia in 2007. Even<br />

though a stem cell donor was found<br />

through the abmdr at that time, a<br />

relapse in the child’s condition<br />

prevented a transplant. “I see the<br />

abmdr as an insurance policy for<br />

everyone,” said Mr. Moghadasian,<br />

who has since volunteered for the<br />

abmdr. “If everyone had a donor<br />

[through the registry], everyone<br />

would be safe.”<br />

Established in 1999, the abmdr,<br />

a nonprofit organization, helps<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>ns worldwide survive lifethreatening<br />

blood-related illnesses<br />

by recruiting <strong>and</strong> matching donors<br />

to those requiring bone marrow<br />

stem cell transplants. To date, the<br />

registry has recruited over 14,000<br />

donors across three continents,<br />

identified 1,276 patients, found 821<br />

potential matches, <strong>and</strong> facilitated<br />

nine bone marrow transplants. <br />

connect:<br />

abmdr.am<br />

1-323-663-3609<br />

Glendale will have only one <strong>Armenia</strong>n council member<br />

Ara Najarian. Greg Krikorian. Ardy Kassakhian.<br />

Polls were slow on Election Day<br />

in Glendale.<br />

<br />

connect: glendalevotes.org.


6 The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | April 11, 2009<br />

<strong>Community</strong><br />

MY NAME IS<br />

ARMEN<br />

Auntie Rose’s Kurabia<br />

by Armen<br />

Bacon<br />

Easter is my holiday. I have a collection<br />

of whimsical bunnies, fancy<br />

placemats, a dining table that<br />

easily seats 17, <strong>and</strong> a traditional<br />

menu that includes shish kebab,<br />

pilaf, soubereg <strong>and</strong> all the trimmings.<br />

The family arrives after<br />

church <strong>and</strong> we graze on yalanchi<br />

<strong>and</strong> string cheese while everyone<br />

vows that from this year forward,<br />

we will omit all mezza (appetizers)<br />

<strong>and</strong> eat more sensibly. In the blink<br />

of an eye, second helpings are being<br />

dished out, everyone is again<br />

complaining that there is too much<br />

food, the women rise to go into<br />

the kitchen to wash dishes, <strong>and</strong><br />

the men retire to the living room,<br />

eyes at half mast, ready for afternoon<br />

naps. Their youthful counterparts,<br />

the gr<strong>and</strong>children, run wild<br />

through the house, energized from<br />

all the foil wrapped chocolate eggs<br />

they have ingested since the day<br />

began. It may all sound crazy, but<br />

the scene is a welcome tradition in<br />

our ethnic household.<br />

This year, however, Easter has<br />

moved to my sister-in-law’s house.<br />

We are in the middle of pouring<br />

concrete <strong>and</strong> l<strong>and</strong>scaping our yard;<br />

I am busy tending to my mother’s<br />

broken shoulder <strong>and</strong> subsequent<br />

recovery. Easter dinner, for this<br />

year <strong>and</strong> this year only, will be<br />

cooked <strong>and</strong> eaten elsewhere.<br />

Today, on the day I would normally<br />

be making a major grocery<br />

shopping list, I am headed to the<br />

market to purchase five simple<br />

items: one pound of unsalted butter,<br />

one pound of regular butter,<br />

shortening, a box of superfine sugar,<br />

<strong>and</strong> flour. These are the ingredients<br />

for kurabia, a traditional part<br />

of our holiday ritual. Regardless of<br />

whose house we may be celebrating<br />

this year’s holiday – my kurabia will<br />

be part of the annual tradition.<br />

I first tasted kurabia, a delicate,<br />

melt-in-your-mouth sugar cookie,<br />

at my Aunt Rose’s house. I couldn’t<br />

have been more than 6 or 7 years<br />

old at the time. She lived across<br />

the street <strong>and</strong> Saturdays were play<br />

days with our cousins. I happened<br />

to be there one day when a mystery<br />

package arrived from her relatives<br />

in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. I<br />

watched her carefully unwrap the<br />

brown wrap that revealed an old,<br />

battered Sees c<strong>and</strong>y box, you know,<br />

the shiny white box with black lettering<br />

embossed on top, including<br />

Mary Sees herself with that trademark<br />

gr<strong>and</strong>motherly smile. The<br />

box however, was not filled with<br />

c<strong>and</strong>y. Instead – two layers of neatly<br />

placed cookies were inside, each<br />

perfectly shaped <strong>and</strong> precise in<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter columnist Armen D.<br />

Bacon is senior director for communications<br />

<strong>and</strong> public relations for the Fresno<br />

County Office. Ms. Bacon lives in Fresno,<br />

California, <strong>and</strong> is a wife, mother, professional<br />

woman, <strong>and</strong> writer. Since 2004,<br />

her thoughts <strong>and</strong> reflections about life<br />

have been published in the “Valley Voices”<br />

section of The Fresno Bee as well as<br />

the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter. She also writes,<br />

produces, <strong>and</strong> hosts a radio series titled<br />

“Live, Laugh, Love” on Fresno’s K-jewel<br />

99.3 radio. She can be reached at armendbacon@aol.com.<br />

size. Aunt Rose informed me they<br />

were called kurabias or shakareeshee<br />

(shakar means sugar in <strong>Armenia</strong>n).<br />

She innocently (<strong>and</strong> quite generously)<br />

offered me a taste. So began<br />

my love affair with these heavenly,<br />

mouth-watering delicacies. For the<br />

next 30 years, I would hunt down<br />

recipes to mimic this first memorable<br />

<strong>and</strong> delicious experience.<br />

Years passed. I tried recipe after<br />

recipe, all quite unsuccessfully. Consistency<br />

was off, the sweetness <strong>and</strong><br />

texture was impossible to replicate,<br />

mine tended to have a crunchy <strong>and</strong><br />

unacceptable bite to them, quite<br />

contrary to Auntie Rose’s rendition,<br />

a secret family recipe, she had once<br />

confided. Looking back, I underst<strong>and</strong><br />

now why she hid them on the<br />

top shelf of her kitchen cabinet.<br />

One day, quite by accident, I was<br />

at an <strong>Armenia</strong>n function with my<br />

husb<strong>and</strong>’s side of the family, when<br />

one of his aunties, Auntie Lorraine,<br />

confessed that she, too, had<br />

an obsession for these cookies.<br />

But unlike me, she had stumbled<br />

upon what she described as the<br />

perfect recipe. To my delight, she<br />

was happy to share it with me. I<br />

carefully wrote down the five ingredients<br />

<strong>and</strong> then quizzed her repeatedly<br />

about the proper texture<br />

of the dough, cooking temperature,<br />

which rack seemed best suited for a<br />

perfect outcome, <strong>and</strong> so on <strong>and</strong> so<br />

forth. I wanted no detail spared. I<br />

took incessant notes.<br />

The next day, I began the arduous<br />

task of baking the cookies. I<br />

clarified the butter, measured out<br />

ingredients <strong>and</strong> was ready to sift,<br />

beat <strong>and</strong> roll. I could already taste<br />

Aunt Rose’s kurabias, despite the<br />

decades that had passed since I had<br />

been in her kitchen. I whipped the<br />

butters until their appearance was<br />

likened to whipping cream. I slowly<br />

added the sugar, patiently waiting<br />

until the consistency was just<br />

as Auntie Lorraine had described.<br />

And then the final step – adding<br />

the flour – almost 2 cups but not<br />

so much that the dough might<br />

crumble. She had suggested I close<br />

my eyes <strong>and</strong> feel it with my soul<br />

– it would be slightly wet but not<br />

too sticky. I realize now that the<br />

sensory talents of our ancestors<br />

have somehow skipped my generation<br />

<strong>and</strong> at this point I was praying<br />

for a small miracle or divine<br />

intervention. I hoped that Auntie<br />

Rose might be gracing me with a<br />

smile from heaven, cheering me on<br />

in my desire to make her family’s<br />

treasured cookies. I rolled out the<br />

dough, cutting it at an angle, until<br />

finally the cookies were ready to be<br />

placed on the cookie sheet. As they<br />

baked, the aroma filled my kitchen.<br />

The moment of truth was about<br />

to arrive. After they were sufficiently<br />

cooled, I carefully lifted a<br />

slightly disfigured one from the<br />

tray, dusted it with powdered sugar<br />

<strong>and</strong> bit into it. Melt-in-your-mouth<br />

perfection. I had succeeded. Auntie<br />

Lorraine’s recipe worked. Word<br />

travels fast. I have since become<br />

the “Kurabia Queen” of the Valley,<br />

a title I wear proudly, after years<br />

of practice <strong>and</strong> hundreds of pounds<br />

of butter <strong>and</strong> sugar purchased<br />

in the process. I am called on to<br />

bake them for weddings, baptisms,<br />

birthdays <strong>and</strong> holidays.<br />

While this year’s Easter holiday<br />

is not being celebrated at my house,<br />

I am still baking my kurabias. If you<br />

happen to be in the neighborhood,<br />

drop by <strong>and</strong> let me offer you a cup<br />

of coffee <strong>and</strong> a kurabia. I promise,<br />

it will melt in your mouth. <br />

From left, Gerard Libaridian, Mary Johnson, Ann Meade, <strong>and</strong> Richard Norsigian.<br />

Metro Detroit committee promotes<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide awareness<br />

CLINTON TOWNSHIP – Committed<br />

to promoting awareness<br />

of, <strong>and</strong> gaining U.S. recognition<br />

for, the first genocide of the 20th<br />

century, The Metro Detroit <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

Genocide Committee, in collaboration<br />

with Facing History <strong>and</strong><br />

Ourselves, organized on March 25<br />

the third educator’s workshop (in<br />

Michigan) on the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide.<br />

The Knights of Vartan, Detroit<br />

Lodge, sponsored the project<br />

initially conceived <strong>and</strong> sponsored<br />

by Edgar Hagopian, local businessperson,<br />

<strong>and</strong> his Hagopian Family<br />

Foundation.<br />

Richard Norsigian, a member of<br />

the committee as well as a principal<br />

in the South Lake School District,<br />

coordinated the event with the<br />

help of Kim Meade, Macomb Social<br />

Studies Consultant. Educators<br />

representing 13 school districts attended<br />

the March 25th workshop<br />

held at the Macomb Intermediate<br />

School District offices.<br />

Facilitor for the workshop Dr.<br />

Mary Johnson, Senior Historian<br />

for Facing History <strong>and</strong> Ourselves,<br />

used text <strong>and</strong> video to present a<br />

background on the “universe of<br />

obligation” <strong>and</strong> segued into the<br />

history of the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide.<br />

Educators using the provided<br />

resource materials were asked to<br />

participate by posing scenarios <strong>and</strong><br />

voicing their ideas <strong>and</strong> opinions on<br />

the massacre of 1.5 million <strong>Armenia</strong>ns<br />

at the h<strong>and</strong>s of the Ottoman<br />

Turks from 1915-1923, <strong>and</strong> the response<br />

at that time from the international<br />

community. Dr. Johnson<br />

then introduced guest speaker Dr.<br />

Gerard Libaridian, who holds the<br />

Alex Manoogian Chair in Modern<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n History at the University<br />

of Michigan, Ann Arbor. Dr.<br />

Libaridian also served as advisor<br />

to <strong>Armenia</strong>n President Levon Ter<br />

Petrossian from 1991 to 1997.<br />

Participants were reminded<br />

of the Second Annual <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

Genocide Essay Competition open<br />

to all Michigan Middle <strong>and</strong> High<br />

School Students, sponsored by the<br />

Hagopian Family Foundation with<br />

cash awards for both the winning<br />

student <strong>and</strong> the instructor.<br />

The Metro Detroit <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

Genocide Committee members are<br />

Edgar Hagopian, Edward Bedikian,<br />

Ray Boujoulian, Corinne Khederian,<br />

Paul Kulhanjian, Richard Norsigian,<br />

David Terzibashian <strong>and</strong> Madeline<br />

Thomasian.<br />

“The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide - a genocide<br />

that is not reflected in our history<br />

books <strong>and</strong> that on April 24,<br />

2009, represents 94 years later, even<br />

though 42 states <strong>and</strong> numerous foreign<br />

governments have recognized<br />

it, remains unacknowledged by the<br />

U.S. Government <strong>and</strong> the successors<br />

to the Ottoman Turk perpetrators,”<br />

stated Mr. Hagopian. <br />

connect:<br />

armeniangenocideessay.com<br />

Let us know what’s on your mind.<br />

Write to us at<br />

letters@reporter.am


The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | April 11, 2009 7<br />

<strong>Community</strong><br />

Sipan <strong>Armenia</strong>n School honored by <strong>Armenia</strong>’s Ministry of Education<br />

PARAMUS – On March 15, at<br />

the annual fundraising event of Sipan<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n School, Mrs. Louisa<br />

Janbazian, president of the school<br />

Board, announced that the school<br />

received an Honorary Award from<br />

Mr. Spartak Seyranyan, the Minister<br />

of Science <strong>and</strong> Education of the Republic<br />

of <strong>Armenia</strong>, for its legacy of<br />

educating <strong>and</strong> nurturing the young<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n generation with the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

Spirit, <strong>and</strong> for the 30th Anniversary<br />

of its founding. Mrs. Janbazian<br />

added that the school has<br />

earned this award because of the<br />

hard work <strong>and</strong> the dedication of the<br />

teachers <strong>and</strong> especially the principal,<br />

Mrs. Arpi Kevorkian, who teach<br />

the <strong>Armenia</strong>n children to learn <strong>and</strong><br />

love the <strong>Armenia</strong>n language <strong>and</strong><br />

our rich cultural heritage.<br />

She also thanked the Board members,<br />

the guests <strong>and</strong> the donors for<br />

their continued support for the<br />

school, <strong>and</strong> praised the founding<br />

members (<strong>Armenia</strong>n Evangelical<br />

College Students Association of<br />

Beirut, Lebanon) some of whom<br />

are still on the School Board. Thirty<br />

years ago, as new emigrants from<br />

Lebanon here in New Jersey, this<br />

group had the vision to create an<br />

environment, outside of the home,<br />

where <strong>Armenia</strong>n children could<br />

come together to learn their <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

language <strong>and</strong> history.<br />

Finally, she thanked James <strong>and</strong><br />

Maral Sahagian, who graciously<br />

hosted this fundraising event at<br />

their home in Airmont, N.Y., where<br />

the guests spent a lovely afternoon<br />

<strong>and</strong> enjoyed a delicious Lenten<br />

luncheon. The proceeds from this<br />

event, as well as the generous donations<br />

from friends <strong>and</strong> supporters,<br />

will help the school to continue<br />

with its noble mission.<br />

The Sipan <strong>Armenia</strong>n School,<br />

which meets on Friday evenings at<br />

the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Presbyterian Church<br />

of Paramus, NJ, has Pre-Nursery to<br />

seventh grades.<br />

<br />

connect:1-201-497-5096<br />

Some of the teachers <strong>and</strong> Board members of the Sipan School.<br />

N. Lael Telfeyan, Ph.D., LCSW<br />

Counseling <strong>and</strong> Psychotherapy<br />

with Individuals, Families <strong>and</strong> Couples<br />

Adults <strong>and</strong> Adolescents<br />

College student<br />

needing cash<br />

for books<br />

Part-time<br />

sales positions<br />

available. Email<br />

jobs@reporter.com<br />

140 West 97th St.<br />

New York, NY 10025<br />

By appointment 917-975-3109<br />

24 Windsor Road<br />

Great Neck, NY 11021<br />

e-mail: nlael@aol.com


8 The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | April 11, 2009<br />

<strong>Community</strong><br />

J. Michael Hagopian’s documentary The River Ran Red to be<br />

screened at Englewood Public Library April 23<br />

ENGLEWOOD – In observance<br />

of the 94th anniversary of the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

Genocide, the Cultural<br />

<br />

Committee of St. Thomas <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

Apostolic Church in Tenafly<br />

will present an award-winning 2008,<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

60-minute documentary, The River<br />

Ran Red, by award-winning filmmaker<br />

Dr. J. Michael Hagopian<br />

on Thursday, April 23, at 7:30 p.m.<br />

in the Englewood Public Library’s<br />

Mackay Room. The program is free<br />

<strong>and</strong> open to the public.<br />

The River Ran Red is the epic<br />

search for survivors of the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

Genocide along the Euphrates<br />

River, which snakes from the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

Plateau in Turkey to Syria.<br />

From his archives of 400 testimonies<br />

of survivors <strong>and</strong> eyewitnesses,<br />

documentarian Dr. Hagopian<br />

weaves a compelling story of terrifying<br />

intensity <strong>and</strong> resounding<br />

warmth. The search concludes with<br />

the discovery <strong>and</strong> testimony of the<br />

last three survivors, among several<br />

thous<strong>and</strong>, who had been stuffed<br />

into a burning cave in the forbidden<br />

desert of Der Zor.<br />

“If I succeed in translating to the<br />

viewer the experience <strong>and</strong> the pathos<br />

of those <strong>Armenia</strong>ns who were<br />

deported from their homes <strong>and</strong><br />

made it to the Euphrates River only<br />

to witness the worst kind of bloodshed,<br />

then I accomplished what I<br />

set out to do,” said Dr. Hagopian,<br />

who wrote <strong>and</strong> produced the film.<br />

A resident of Thous<strong>and</strong> Oaks,<br />

Calif., Dr. Hagopian’s hunt for<br />

survivors took him to 13 different<br />

countries on five continents over a<br />

PT ADMINISTRATIVE ASSISTANT<br />

FOR NON-PROFIT ORGANIZATION<br />

Looking for bright, mature, multi-lingual (<strong>Armenia</strong>n/French/English)<br />

individualwho is well organized <strong>and</strong> pays attention to detail. <br />

Must be computer savvy <strong>and</strong> have strong planning <strong>and</strong> problem<br />

solving skills. <br />

Potential for advancement to FT Administrative Assistant.<br />

Contact the <strong>Armenia</strong>n American Health Professional Organization (AAHPO)<br />

at 201-546-6166 or info@aahpo.org.<br />

period of four decades. He recorded<br />

such compelling accounts as the<br />

priest who returns to his birthplace<br />

<strong>and</strong> meets the man who killed his<br />

father <strong>and</strong> other family members,<br />

<strong>and</strong> people who reported seeing<br />

hundreds of bodies floating down<br />

what they described as the bloody<br />

waters of the Euphrates River.<br />

The River Ran Red, the final film<br />

in Hagopian’s Witnesses Trilogy<br />

on the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide of 1915,<br />

had its premier at the Arpa <strong>International</strong><br />

Film Festival last October<br />

24 at the Egyptian Theatre in Hollywood,<br />

Calif. – four days after Dr.<br />

Hagopian’s 95th birthday.<br />

“We are so pleased to have had<br />

this opportunity to show Dr. Hagopian’s<br />

documentary,” noted Sylvia<br />

Minassian, Arpa Film Festival<br />

Founder. “He is an amazing man.”<br />

Dr. Hagopian was honored with<br />

the Arpa Lifetime Achievement<br />

Award <strong>and</strong> the Armin T. Wegner<br />

Humanitarian Award in 2006. He<br />

also is the recipient of Jewish<br />

World Watch’s “I Witness” Award<br />

for dedicating his professional life<br />

to chronicling the history of the<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n people <strong>and</strong> commemorating<br />

victims of the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

Genocide.<br />

Dr. Hagopian himself is a Genocide<br />

survivor. As a young boy, he<br />

was hidden in a well in a mulberry<br />

grove to escape Turkish marauders<br />

<strong>and</strong> later fled, with his family, to<br />

the United States, where he eventually<br />

earned a PhD from Harvard<br />

University in 1943.He started collecting<br />

film footage about <strong>Armenia</strong>ns<br />

early on in his 60-year career<br />

as a documentary filmmaker. He<br />

established the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Film<br />

Foundation in Thous<strong>and</strong> Oaks in<br />

1979 with the help of several community<br />

leaders. He has made over<br />

70 educational films; 17 of those<br />

are about the <strong>Armenia</strong>n people,<br />

including The River Ran Red, <strong>and</strong><br />

the definitive film on the Turkish<br />

massacre of <strong>Armenia</strong>ns in 1915, The<br />

Forgotten Genocide.<br />

<br />

connect:englewoodlibrary.org<br />

You share the same<br />

community. Discover what<br />

happens when you share<br />

the same experience.<br />

For more information about<br />

Relay For Life or to join an<br />

event near you, visit<br />

www.cancer.org/RelayNYNJ<br />

or call 1.800.ACS.2345.<br />

Paint the Town Purple in<br />

celebration of Relay For Life on<br />

May 1, May Day For Relay.<br />

1.800.ACS.2345<br />

www.cancer.org/relayNYNJ


The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | April 11, 2009 9<br />

<strong>Community</strong><br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n Relief Society centennial celebrated in New York<br />

by Florence Avakian<br />

NEW YORK – It is an organization<br />

that has served <strong>Armenia</strong>ns<br />

worldwide tirelessly for 100 years,<br />

with 18,000 members in 223 chapters<br />

in 26 countries. On Saturday,<br />

March 28, the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Relief Society<br />

of the Eastern United States<br />

celebrated the hundredth anniversary<br />

of this remarkable organization<br />

at the Yale Club in New York<br />

City.<br />

Among the more than 200 people<br />

present from across the United<br />

States, were several guests of honor,<br />

including the Prelate of the Eastern<br />

Prelacy Archbishop Oshagan<br />

Choloyan, <strong>Armenia</strong>’s envoy to the<br />

United Nations Amb. Armen Martirossian,<br />

Rep. Anna G. Eshoo<br />

(D.-Calif.), <strong>and</strong> twelve Eastern region<br />

ars members who have given<br />

dedicated service for more than 50<br />

years.<br />

Warmly welcoming the attendees<br />

was the chairperson of the<br />

Centennial Banquet Committee,<br />

Sonia Bezdikian. Following<br />

the singing of the American,<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n, <strong>and</strong> ars anthems by<br />

Hooshere Bezdikian Kaligian,<br />

Archbishop Choloyan gave the<br />

invocation, <strong>and</strong> remarks were<br />

shared by the chairperson of the<br />

ars Centennial Committee Angele<br />

Manoogian, chairperson of<br />

the ars Central Executive Vicky<br />

Marashlian, <strong>and</strong> ars Eastern Regional<br />

Executive Board treasurer<br />

Ani Attar.<br />

A video presentation was shown<br />

detailing the history of the organization,<br />

<strong>and</strong> the sacrifice of the<br />

thous<strong>and</strong>s of <strong>Armenia</strong>n women<br />

who have devoted their lives to<br />

the service of the <strong>Armenia</strong>n people<br />

during the past 100 years.<br />

Twelve outst<strong>and</strong>ing<br />

members<br />

A high point of the evening came<br />

when 12 of the 115 women who<br />

have been members of the ars for<br />

more than 50 years were honored<br />

with plaques. They include Arpine<br />

Brajcovich, Anahid Dadoyan,<br />

Elizabeth Hagopian, Marie<br />

Karagullian, Alice Karjian, Arshalouys<br />

Kazanjian, Helen Parnagian,<br />

Arax Sarajian, Lucine<br />

Der Ohanesian-Sarian, Arev<br />

Sarkissian, Anais Tcholakian,<br />

<strong>and</strong> Berjoohi Yessaian.<br />

“Destiny scattered our nation all<br />

over the world, <strong>and</strong> everywhere<br />

we went we established schools,<br />

churches, <strong>and</strong> national organizations<br />

such as this one,” Amb. Martirossian<br />

said in his remarks. “The<br />

wisdom, compassion, <strong>and</strong> foresight<br />

of the founders of the ars<br />

found a fertile soil in this great<br />

country. Relations of the <strong>Armenia</strong>n-American<br />

organizations with<br />

the political institutions of the<br />

U.S. acquired a special meaning<br />

<strong>and</strong> importance after September<br />

21, 1991. The U.S. Congress has<br />

been steadfastly rendering political<br />

<strong>and</strong> financial assistance to <strong>Armenia</strong><br />

since that very first day of<br />

our independence.”<br />

Wishing the organization future<br />

success, the ambassador said, “The<br />

centennial of the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Relief<br />

Society is a great event not only<br />

here in the United States, but is<br />

also duly acknowledged in <strong>Armenia</strong>.”<br />

A congratulatory message<br />

from diaspora minister Hranush<br />

Hakobyan was also read.<br />

A congresswoman’s<br />

pride<br />

Delivering the keynote address,<br />

Ms. Eshoo poignantly paid tribute<br />

to her <strong>Armenia</strong>n roots, saying<br />

they had instilled in her “devotion<br />

to family, belief in the value<br />

of hard work, charity, community,<br />

<strong>and</strong> faith.” She recounted that 100<br />

years ago, Edgar Agnouny founded<br />

the ars in New York “to provide<br />

educational <strong>and</strong> humanitarian<br />

aid to <strong>Armenia</strong>ns throughout the<br />

world.”<br />

Ms. Eshoo pointed out that ”in<br />

the subsequent century, the ars<br />

Soloist Hooshere<br />

Bezdikian<br />

(st<strong>and</strong>ing, second<br />

from left) <strong>and</strong><br />

other guests at<br />

the centennial<br />

gala.<br />

has become an important <strong>and</strong> essential<br />

source of assistance to <strong>Armenia</strong>ns<br />

in need of a safe haven,<br />

a chance at an education <strong>and</strong> a<br />

better life, all the while preserving<br />

the identity of <strong>Armenia</strong>ns, often<br />

against those who would deny our<br />

very existence.<br />

“I am proud to be an <strong>Armenia</strong>n.<br />

I am proud to be an <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

woman,” she declared to thunderous<br />

applause. “Over the years, the<br />

ars has been one of the world’s<br />

leading women’s organizations, an<br />

extension of our capacity for love,<br />

cooperation, <strong>and</strong> good works. You<br />

are building a better world, <strong>and</strong> you<br />

are training future leaders.”<br />

A member of the congressional<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n caucus, <strong>and</strong> an original<br />

co-sponsor of House Resolution<br />

252 affirming the U.S. record on the<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide, Ms. Eshoo recalled<br />

that President Obama during<br />

his campaign had promised that as<br />

president he would recognize the<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide. “The time is<br />

ripe for the government of Turkey<br />

<strong>and</strong> the United States to put an end<br />

to the lie <strong>and</strong> face the truth about<br />

the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide,” she concluded<br />

to a st<strong>and</strong>ing ovation.<br />

The unique evening of celebration<br />

concluded with the Prelate offering<br />

the benediction, <strong>and</strong> again<br />

voicing strong support <strong>and</strong> congratulations<br />

to an outst<strong>and</strong>ing organization<br />

for its devoted 100-year<br />

service to <strong>Armenia</strong>ns around the<br />

globe.


10 The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | April 11, 2009<br />

<strong>Community</strong><br />

Nectar Munro’s second-grade class at St. Gregory <strong>Armenia</strong>n School. Photos: Gregory Lima.<br />

St. Gregory <strong>Armenia</strong>n School principal Margrit Hamparsoumian.<br />

The ten classes of <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

St. Gregory<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n School<br />

in White Plains is a<br />

positive force<br />

by Gregory Lima<br />

WHITE PLAINS, N.Y. – In a<br />

large sense every church is a school,<br />

some more than others. The beautiful,<br />

expansive church of St. Gregory<br />

the Enlightener in White Plains, New<br />

York, started as a school even before<br />

it had its own altar as a church.<br />

It started when a group of <strong>Armenia</strong>ns<br />

who had moved to the<br />

northern suburbs of New York City<br />

sought a more local place to worship<br />

<strong>and</strong> to teach their children<br />

to speak <strong>Armenia</strong>n. They found<br />

Fr. Karekin Kasparian, then the<br />

dean of the St. Nersess Seminary,<br />

recently arrived in the area, who<br />

happily obliged by setting up seminars<br />

<strong>and</strong> classes on the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

spiritual <strong>and</strong> cultural heritage<br />

along with <strong>Armenia</strong>n-language<br />

classes for adults <strong>and</strong> for children.<br />

Soon the group became a parish<br />

<strong>and</strong> Fr. Karekin became its pastoral<br />

priest. Over time the means were<br />

found to raise a church that from<br />

the outset would make very ample<br />

provision for the school that was<br />

already in existence. Today, some<br />

10 years after the consecration of<br />

the Church of St. Gregory the Enlightener,<br />

the original number of<br />

classrooms has doubled.<br />

Lydia Ochoa.<br />

Jancikian<br />

Dikran Kochian.<br />

Ani Mekenian.<br />

Caroline Mardirossian.<br />

Christina Chevian.<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n as a second<br />

language<br />

Over the many years when <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

was widely spoken at home<br />

among the immigrant communities,<br />

it was regarded as the mother tongue<br />

<strong>and</strong> taught as a first language. With<br />

generational assimilation, however,<br />

Continued on page 11 <br />

Ani Ozsolak. Second-grader Talia. Christopher Mardirossian.


The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | April 11, 2009 11<br />

<strong>Community</strong><br />

The ten classes of <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

Continued from page 10<br />

it became in fact a second language,<br />

<strong>and</strong> in many cases the forgotten<br />

language, although it was not easy<br />

to recognize it as such. The loss of<br />

language threatened the profound<br />

loss of cultural identity <strong>and</strong> with it<br />

Turkish genocidal triumph over the<br />

dispossessed survivors.<br />

The recourse was to tie language<br />

instruction to the institutional<br />

longevity <strong>and</strong> organizing power of<br />

the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Apostolic Church in<br />

America; to teach <strong>Armenia</strong>n as a<br />

second language, <strong>and</strong> to be serious<br />

about it. To be serious about it meant<br />

to separate it from Sunday school,<br />

giving it its own independent space<br />

<strong>and</strong> validated academic curriculum.<br />

It also meant replicating as closely as<br />

possible family instruction through<br />

direct, personal, one-on-one teacherstudent<br />

participation in small classes,<br />

<strong>and</strong> further, to locate <strong>and</strong> employ<br />

the best pedagogical, peer-reviewed<br />

teaching techniques. It also helped<br />

to call on the cultural resources of<br />

the community.<br />

The result as seen in the St. Gregory<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n School is ten classes<br />

of <strong>Armenia</strong>n every Saturday<br />

morning. Each class is tied to the<br />

equivalent location of the children<br />

in the public school system, the<br />

children placed in nursery, pre-kindergarten,<br />

kindergarten, then first<br />

through seventh grades. Moreover,<br />

the children stay comfortably together<br />

through the grades creating<br />

enduring, interactive friendships.<br />

They take a child at any age, place<br />

him or her in the grade appropriate<br />

to the age, the teacher making the<br />

accommodating adjustments.<br />

According to Margrit Hamparsoumian,<br />

the school principal,<br />

starting at the earliest age is<br />

preferable. That is why they include<br />

teaching <strong>Armenia</strong>n at the nursery<br />

level. But at each age the children<br />

have personal strengths that can<br />

be called upon to make learning<br />

the language natural, stimulating,<br />

<strong>and</strong> fun. There have been some excellent<br />

results at all grades.<br />

A clustered archipelago<br />

Each of the classes has a distinctive<br />

character of its own. Going from<br />

one class to another is like visiting<br />

separate isl<strong>and</strong>s in a clustered archipelago,<br />

admiring the artwork in<br />

one, listening to the recitals in another,<br />

watching a group dancing, or<br />

nodding approval at the melodious<br />

harmonies of the choral voices in<br />

others. The children are kept busy.<br />

Much of the learning is through action<br />

<strong>and</strong> interactions that are akin<br />

to group play.<br />

Each grade level has its own teacher,<br />

<strong>and</strong> where necessary, two. The<br />

variation in teacher personalities<br />

creates different class atmospherics.<br />

In some classes the teacher has an<br />

overwhelming presence <strong>and</strong> one can<br />

get the impression here that spring<br />

has come <strong>and</strong> every seed must burst<br />

into bloom, <strong>and</strong> if force of will can<br />

make it happen, it will. Another<br />

might have an autumnal feeling,<br />

a time of plenty where we simply<br />

reach out <strong>and</strong> gather the already<br />

ripened fruits. Some of the teachers<br />

have their own children in their<br />

class. As 6th-grade teacher Mari<br />

Yapoujian explained, “If I ask my<br />

children to come here, I must do my<br />

part also. I may be the teacher, but I<br />

find I learn with them, not only by<br />

preparing the class but in the class.<br />

They have better memories than I<br />

have. They become my teachers too.”<br />

Not everyone is delighted to be<br />

there, <strong>and</strong> there are some you cannot<br />

keep away. As they grow older<br />

some can rebel against their parents’<br />

insistence they attend class. Asking<br />

one such very young lady what<br />

she would rather do, she answered<br />

“Sleep,” which she seemed to manage<br />

exactly where she was. Until it<br />

was time to dance. Then the sleepy<br />

girl turned into a dynamo. There<br />

was also the boy who had finished<br />

all the grades <strong>and</strong> still came back. He<br />

was drawn by the pleasure of speaking<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n, the cultural activities,<br />

<strong>and</strong> the friends he had made.<br />

Drawing on the<br />

community<br />

Language <strong>and</strong> culture create each<br />

other until there is a fusion that it<br />

may be impossible to separate. The<br />

children may be learning the language<br />

but it is successful only to the<br />

extent they are learning <strong>and</strong> directly<br />

participating in <strong>Armenia</strong>n culture.<br />

One of the strengths of this <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

school is its ability to call upon<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n cultural resources in the<br />

New York metropolitan area. A good<br />

example of this is Rita Kahvejian<br />

of New Jersey’s Shushi Dance<br />

Group <strong>and</strong> Khoren Mekanejian,<br />

composer <strong>and</strong> choirmaster.<br />

There is a special pleasure in seeing<br />

children in full costumes rehearsing<br />

their parts in an <strong>Armenia</strong>n play. Or<br />

others in rigorous dance lessons,<br />

where only perfect posture in all<br />

body parts is acceptable, along with<br />

precisely choreographed steps. Or<br />

seeing the children rise to <strong>and</strong> meet<br />

the challenge as <strong>Armenia</strong>n music<br />

fills the auditorium. Nor is the satisfaction<br />

less when visiting Shant<br />

Mardirossian’s history class <strong>and</strong><br />

seeing the students in the physical<br />

act of h<strong>and</strong>ling coins of the realm<br />

<strong>and</strong> imagining how they were used<br />

in the different historical periods.<br />

In one of the classes there is a<br />

poster-sized photograph of Erv<strong>and</strong><br />

Kochar’s great statue of the<br />

epic hero David of Sassoon. The<br />

mighty stallion’s rear hooves<br />

st<strong>and</strong> on a small pedestal that<br />

represents current <strong>Armenia</strong> in the<br />

mind of the sculptor. The horse as<br />

it prances forward covers a much<br />

larger area beyond <strong>Armenia</strong>. Kochar<br />

saw the horse as representing<br />

the whole of the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

people, most beyond current<br />

national borders. David’s sword<br />

is not pointed at a single enemy.<br />

It is behind him, ready to swing<br />

in every direction. He is poised<br />

against a surrounding multitude.<br />

This is a brilliant statue that says<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>, its culture <strong>and</strong> spiritual<br />

values, <strong>and</strong> what it means in the<br />

lifeblood of its people will st<strong>and</strong><br />

<strong>and</strong> fight for its place in the world.<br />

St. Gregory’s <strong>Armenia</strong>n School is<br />

a positive force in that continuing<br />

struggle.


12 The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | April 11, 2009<br />

<strong>Community</strong><br />

Looking to the next generation in <strong>Armenia</strong>: agbu focus 2009<br />

honors Hye Geen Pregnant Women’s Centers<br />

Some of the hundreds of mothers <strong>and</strong> children in <strong>Armenia</strong> who have benefited<br />

from the agbu Hye Geen Pregnant Women’s Centers.<br />

CHICAGO – Since 2001, each<br />

agbu focus weekend has paid<br />

tribute to a specific agbu program<br />

that has touched the lives of<br />

young <strong>Armenia</strong>ns. Looking to the<br />

next generation in <strong>Armenia</strong>, agbu<br />

focus proudly honors agbu Hye<br />

Geen by dedicating its 2009 fundraising<br />

campaign to benefit the new<br />

Pregnant Women’s Center in Talin,<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>. The Talin Center will be<br />

the third of its kind in <strong>Armenia</strong> <strong>and</strong><br />

the first in that city. agbu focus is<br />

a biennial weekend event designed<br />

for young <strong>Armenia</strong>n professionals<br />

from all over the world to congregate<br />

<strong>and</strong> share their international<br />

perspectives, as well as provide a<br />

venue to showcase notable contributions<br />

<strong>and</strong> achievements made by<br />

agbu’s diverse youth-oriented programs.<br />

Building on the impressive<br />

achievements experienced during<br />

the premiere weekend in New York<br />

in 2001, agbu focus has since united<br />

more than 1,500 young <strong>Armenia</strong>ns<br />

from cities around the globe,<br />

with weekends hosted in New York<br />

(2001, 2007), Montreal (2003), Miami<br />

(2005), <strong>and</strong> now heading west<br />

to Chicago. Additionally, well over<br />

$125,000 has been raised for many<br />

agbu programs, including Generation<br />

Next, the Scholarship Program<br />

<strong>and</strong> the New York Summer Intern<br />

Program.<br />

From July 16-19, 2009, focus will<br />

welcome hundreds of <strong>Armenia</strong>ns<br />

to Chicago for this unique celebration.<br />

Rooms have been reserved at<br />

the Westin Michigan Avenue Hotel<br />

<strong>and</strong> a special discounted rate<br />

is available for reservations made<br />

only through agbu beginning in<br />

mid-April. Plans have also been<br />

set to host the Gala Evening, the<br />

highlight of the focus weekend, at<br />

the Art Institute of Chicago’s new<br />

modern wing, which is set to open<br />

this summer.<br />

Established by the agbu Hye<br />

Geen Committee of Los Angeles<br />

in response to the country’s high<br />

infant mortality, lack of nutrition<br />

<strong>and</strong> the shortage of resources for<br />

potential mothers, the first Hye<br />

Geen Pregnant Women’s Center<br />

opened its doors in Gyumri in<br />

2002 with the encouragement of<br />

the Republic of <strong>Armenia</strong>’s Minister<br />

for the Protection of Women <strong>and</strong><br />

Children.<br />

Two years later, a second center<br />

in Vanadzor was opened. This year,<br />

the Hye Geen Committee plans<br />

to open its third center in Talin,<br />

which is in desperate need of help,<br />

as many villages in the region are<br />

poor <strong>and</strong> practically ab<strong>and</strong>oned.<br />

These community-based health<br />

resource centers provide critical<br />

pre-natal care to pregnant women<br />

who often suffer from malnutrition,<br />

lack the funds for proper medical<br />

care, <strong>and</strong> have little access to accurate<br />

health information. Expectant<br />

mothers who gather daily at the<br />

centers benefit from vital medical<br />

exams, a congenial social atmosphere,<br />

individual meetings with<br />

counselors, nutritious meals, <strong>and</strong><br />

vitamins provided by Hye Geen.<br />

Center participants are recommended<br />

by local clinics <strong>and</strong> spend<br />

4-5 hours a day at the facilities.<br />

Meals are prepared <strong>and</strong> served by<br />

the women themselves in order to<br />

encourage good nutrition habits<br />

which are taught by the trained<br />

center staff. Each center has three<br />

local employees on staff, including<br />

a social worker, who work with the<br />

women to ensure that their babies<br />

are born healthy.<br />

Various medical personnel are<br />

invited to the centers periodically,<br />

or as required, to monitor each<br />

woman’s progress <strong>and</strong> needs. The<br />

superintendent of the centers,<br />

Nara Sahakian, who is a lecturer in<br />

psychology at Yerevan State University,<br />

travels from Yerevan for<br />

weekly visits to each center <strong>and</strong> ensures<br />

that each facility is operating<br />

at its utmost.<br />

To date, hundreds of healthy babies<br />

have been born to the mothers<br />

who have participated in the programs<br />

at the agbu Hye Geen Pregnant<br />

Women’s Centers.<br />

agbu focus believes that every<br />

child born in <strong>Armenia</strong> deserves a<br />

chance at a healthy life unfettered<br />

by preventable medical issues.<br />

Honoring agbu Hye Geen’s latest<br />

project, focus has launched a largescale<br />

pre-event fundraising effort<br />

to ensure that the Talin Center will<br />

open with all the resources it needs<br />

to carry out its mission of serving<br />

the pregnant women of <strong>Armenia</strong>.<br />

Since 1994, agbu Hye Geen in<br />

Southern California has worked to<br />

preserve <strong>and</strong> honor achievements<br />

of <strong>Armenia</strong>n women, provide a<br />

forum for them throughout the<br />

world, promote their role in family<br />

<strong>and</strong> society through research, education,<br />

<strong>and</strong> advocacy, <strong>and</strong> provide<br />

overall support to empower <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

women as carriers of the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

cultural heritage.<br />

Established in 1906, agbu is the<br />

world’s largest non-profit <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

organization. Headquartered<br />

in New York City, agbu preserves<br />

<strong>and</strong> promotes the <strong>Armenia</strong>n identity<br />

<strong>and</strong> heritage through educational,<br />

cultural <strong>and</strong> humanitarian<br />

programs, annually serving some<br />

400,000 <strong>Armenia</strong>ns on five continents.<br />

<br />

connect:<br />

agbu.org/focus 1-212-319-6383 x128.<br />

Visit us at the new<br />

reporter.am


The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | April 11, 2009 13<br />

<strong>Community</strong><br />

Calendar of Events<br />

Edward D. Jamie, Jr. Funeral Chapel, LLC<br />

208-17 Northern Blvd. Bayside, NY 11361<br />

Tel. 718-224-2390<br />

Website: www.jamiejrfuneral.com.<br />

Serving the <strong>Armenia</strong>n <strong>Community</strong> Since 1969<br />

Edward D. Jamie, Jr.-NY&NJ Licensed Funeral Director<br />

NEW YORK<br />

APRIL 16 - QUARTERLY FO-<br />

RUM SERIES - Remembering<br />

the Forgotten: The Untold Story<br />

of Clergymen Lost to the Genocide.<br />

The second forum features<br />

Yeretzgeen Joanna Baghsarian’s<br />

remarkable story of how<br />

a group of her students took a<br />

proactive role in remembering<br />

these forgotten martyrs. There<br />

is no charge for the evening, but<br />

RSVP is requested by email to<br />

events@armenia nprelacy.org or<br />

by telephone at 212-689-7810.<br />

APRIL 16 - SYMPOSIUM ON<br />

PREVENTING GENOCIDE<br />

THROUGH DIALOGUE Thursday,<br />

7:00 P.M. Fordham Law<br />

School, Amphitheater, 140 W.<br />

62nd St, NYC. Admission: $12.<br />

AASSSG 2009 Honoree, Andrew<br />

H. Tarsy, Awards given to Krieger<br />

Essay Contest winners. visit<br />

www.meaningfulworld.com, e-<br />

mail kalayjiana@aol.comor call<br />

201 941-2266.<br />

APRIL 18 - WALK ARMENIA<br />

organized by the ARS NY Erebouni<br />

& Mayr Chapters Walk to<br />

raise funds for Holy Martyrs &<br />

St. Illuminator’s Day Schools/St.<br />

Sarkis Saturday School. Regisration<br />

1:00pm @ St. Sarkis <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

Apostolic Church Douglaston,<br />

Queens/Walk begins<br />

2:00pm for approx. 4 miles. Participation<br />

Fee $25. Further info:<br />

Hasmik Israelian — 516-330-<br />

5290 or Nayda Voskeritchian<br />

516-739-0805<br />

APRIL 18 - “HELLO ELLIS<br />

ISLAND” MUSICAL ENTER-<br />

TAINMENT BY “THE WAY<br />

WE WERE” about <strong>Armenia</strong>ns<br />

coming to USA in 1920. 8PM<br />

in the Auditorium of <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

Church of the Holy Martyrs 209-<br />

15 Horace Harding Expwy in<br />

Bayside. Adults $20 – Children<br />

$10 under age 12. Refreshments<br />

following the performance. For<br />

tickets call the church office at<br />

718-225-0235 or Lolita Babikian<br />

at 347-742-4015.<br />

APRIL 30 - THE ZOHRAB<br />

CENTER FILM SERIES will<br />

view the comedy/drama “Big<br />

Story in a Small City,” on Thursday,<br />

at 7:00 pm. Wine <strong>and</strong> cheese<br />

will be served following the film.<br />

Suggested donation is $5. For<br />

more information, please email<br />

ZCFilmSeries@gmail.com or call<br />

212.686.0710. The Krikor <strong>and</strong><br />

Clara Zohrab Information Center<br />

is located at 630 Second Avenue<br />

(at 34th street) New York,<br />

New York.<br />

MAY 3 - 32ND ANNUAL GALA<br />

DINNER-DANCE. St. Illuminator’s<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n Day School, Friday,<br />

7:30 p.m. at the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

Center 69-23 47th Ave. Woodside,<br />

NY. For information call<br />

718-478-4073.<br />

MAY 15 - 1ST ANNUAL COCK-<br />

TAIL RECEPTION AT THE<br />

PRATT HOUSE, NYC. Hosted<br />

by the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Medical Fund.<br />

$125. For information call Nancy<br />

Zoraian, 908-233-7279.<br />

MAY 16 - 60TH ANNIVER-<br />

SARY DINNER/ DANCE of the<br />

New York <strong>Armenia</strong>n Home<br />

(Flushing, NY) to be held at<br />

Harbor Links Golf Course, Port<br />

Washington, NY, starting at<br />

7:30 pm. Featuring Varoujan<br />

Vartanian <strong>and</strong> B<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> Antranig<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n Dance Ensemble.<br />

Donation: $150.00 per person.<br />

Black Tie Optional. For more<br />

details, please call NYAH: (718)<br />

461-1504.<br />

MAY 16- HMADS GALA DIN-<br />

NER DANCE hosted by the<br />

“Friends” at Russo’s on the Bay,<br />

featuring Addis Harm<strong>and</strong>ian<br />

<strong>and</strong> his B<strong>and</strong>. Cocktails 7:30<br />

pm. Dinner 9:00 pm. Donation:<br />

$ 150. For Reservations please<br />

call, school office: (718) 225 4826,<br />

Negdar Arukian: (718) 423 4813.<br />

MAY 16 - SAVE THE DATE!<br />

60TH ANNIVERSARY DIN-<br />

NER DANCE OF THE NEW<br />

YORK ARMENIAN HOME,<br />

Flushing, NY. Celebration to<br />

be held at Harbor Links Golf<br />

Course, Port Washington, NY.<br />

Featuring Varoujan Vartanian<br />

<strong>and</strong> Antranig <strong>Armenia</strong>n Dance<br />

Ensemble. Details to follow or<br />

call NYAH, (718) 461-1504<br />

NEW JERSEY<br />

MAY 3 - 50TH ANNIVER-<br />

SARY CELEBRATION BAN-<br />

QUET.Sts.Vartanantz Church,<br />

Ridgefield, NJ. Donation: $50 pp<br />

- for info/reservations call 201<br />

943-2950.<br />

NOVEMBER 15 SAVE THIS<br />

DATE: “ONE NATION, ONE<br />

CULTURE” A Cultural Festival<br />

Under the Auspices of Dr. Hranush<br />

Hakobyan, Republic of <strong>Armenia</strong><br />

Minister of Diaspora, Organized<br />

by Hamazkayin Eastern<br />

USA Regional Executive, Featuring<br />

Alla Levonian from <strong>Armenia</strong><br />

<strong>and</strong> Babin Boghosian & Ensemble<br />

from Los Angeles, With the<br />

participation of Antranig Dance<br />

Ensemble of AGBU, Akh’tamar<br />

Dance Ensemble of St. Thomas<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n Church, Yeraz Dance<br />

Ensemble of St. Sarkis Church,<br />

NJ Hamazkayin Nayiri Dance<br />

Group & Arekag Children’s<br />

Choir & Dhol Group. SUNDAY,<br />

NOVEMBER 15, 2009. 4pm. Felician<br />

College, 262 S. Main St.,<br />

Lodi, NJ. Donation: $75, $50, $35,<br />

$25. For more information or<br />

tickets please contact: Hamazkayin<br />

@ 201-945-8992 or Paradon2009@gmail.com<br />

MASSACHUSETTS<br />

APRIL 26 - ARMENIAN MAR-<br />

TYRS’ DAY OBSERVANCE BY<br />

ARMENIAN GENOCIDE COM-<br />

MEMORATIVE COMMITTEE<br />

OF MERRIMACK VALLEY.<br />

3PM, North Andover High School,<br />

Route 125, North Andover, MA.<br />

Concert by Arlina Ensemble of<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>. Complimentary admission.<br />

Reception to follow.<br />

ACAA ARMENIAN HERITAGE<br />

CRUISE XIII - 2010<br />

FT. LAUDERDALE, FL - Join<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>ns worldwide on<br />

the ARMENIAN HERITAGE<br />

CRUISE XIII 2010. Sailing on<br />

Saturday, January 16-23, 2010.<br />

To San Juan, PR, St. Thomas<br />

<strong>and</strong> Gr<strong>and</strong> Caicos Isl<strong>and</strong>s on<br />

Subscription Coupon<br />

the Costa Atlantica. Prices start<br />

at $679.00 per person. Contact<br />

TravelGroup <strong>International</strong><br />

1-866-447-0750,ext 102 or 108.<br />

Westcoast: Mary Papazian 818-<br />

407-140; Eastcoast: Antranik<br />

Boudakian 718-575-0142<br />

the armenian<br />

reporter<br />

annual rates<br />

U.S.A.: First Class Mail, $125; Periodicals Mail, $75<br />

Canada: $125 (u.s.); Overseas: $250 (u.s.)<br />

name<br />

street<br />

city/state/zip<br />

Classifieds<br />

Female <strong>Armenia</strong>n-American<br />

available for part- time nanny<br />

services, located in the nyc area.<br />

Can speak fluent <strong>Armenia</strong>n,<br />

teach piano <strong>and</strong> tutor children.<br />

Call Monique at 415-297-6804.<br />

Check Enclosed OR Charge My:<br />

Mastercard Visa Amex Discover<br />

Exp.<br />

mail coupon to: armenian reporter<br />

p.o. box 129, paramus, nj 07652<br />

or<br />

fax coupon to (201) 226-1660<br />

(credit card orders only)


14 The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | April 11, 2009<br />

<strong>Community</strong><br />

Liver transplant spurs national Knights of Vartan comm<strong>and</strong>er<br />

by Tom Vartabedian<br />

WATERTOWN, Mass. – Haig<br />

Deranian is truly a knight in shining<br />

armor.<br />

Ten years ago, he was at death’s<br />

door before a liver transplant saved<br />

his life. A donor stepped forward<br />

when the situation became critical<br />

<strong>and</strong> gave him a new lease.<br />

Today, he’s the national comm<strong>and</strong>er<br />

of the Knights of Vartan,<br />

an organization that dates itself<br />

back to 451 c.e. when Vartan Mamigonian<br />

led the surge that preserved<br />

Christianity for <strong>Armenia</strong>ns.<br />

Deranian doesn’t carry a sword.<br />

He has no shield. His only weapon<br />

is the <strong>Armenia</strong>n spirit <strong>and</strong> he wears<br />

it proudly.<br />

“It was not my time <strong>and</strong> I was<br />

blessed by God,” he says of the<br />

transplant. “God decided whether<br />

I would live or die. I have a great<br />

deal of faith which was part of my<br />

upbringing.”<br />

Little is revealed about his life-ordeath<br />

struggle back a decade ago,<br />

just the way Deranian would prefer.<br />

He’s not an individualist <strong>and</strong> wants<br />

no purple heart for his survival. He<br />

puts his organization before himself.<br />

“I don’t know who the donor was,”<br />

he says. “There’s no question organ<br />

transplantation is a miracle in<br />

medicine.”<br />

But talk Knights of Vartan <strong>and</strong><br />

Deranian is all action. If he did have<br />

a sword, it would be Excalibur. And<br />

if this Knight ever came alive, well,<br />

it’s as close to a Robin Hood scenario<br />

as you can get.<br />

His Sherwood Forest is the diaspora.<br />

The mission is equality among<br />

all <strong>Armenia</strong>ns everywhere.<br />

“<strong>Armenia</strong>ns need to unite with<br />

one voice,” he points out. “I believe<br />

Haig Deranian. Photo: Knightsofvartan.org.<br />

the Knights of Vartan is the perfect<br />

organization that can cross all lines<br />

to get things done. My involvement<br />

<strong>and</strong> ultimate success are more of a<br />

team effort. I might be in the right<br />

place at the right time <strong>and</strong> was always<br />

trying to make a difference<br />

with my life.”<br />

My late pastor, Rev. Vartan<br />

Kassabian, was a Knight as well<br />

as an arf member, the leader of<br />

a church as well as an entertainer.<br />

He was the consummate <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

who would rob Peter to pay Paul.<br />

The former chairperson of our<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n <strong>National</strong> Committee of<br />

Merrimack Valley is another Knight.<br />

When Joe Dagdigian isn’t attending<br />

meetings, he’s involved with the<br />

arf Lowell Gomideh as well as the<br />

Cosmic Ray Division in <strong>Armenia</strong>. In<br />

fact, he joined the Knights to gain<br />

added clout for the crd.<br />

Deranian is also trying to make a<br />

difference. With a membership that<br />

has 23 lodges throughout the United<br />

States <strong>and</strong> Canada, along with a<br />

body of more than 3,000 Knights<br />

<strong>and</strong> Daughters, it’s Deranian who<br />

remains the catalyst.<br />

The 67-year-old has been a Watertown<br />

resident for the past 55<br />

years. He attended local schools before<br />

graduating from Northeastern<br />

University. He has a wife (Donna<br />

Pino) <strong>and</strong> three children (Gregory,<br />

Jason, <strong>and</strong> Jennifer) <strong>and</strong> is<br />

president <strong>and</strong> ceo of a company<br />

called Jad Imports, an importer of<br />

lighting products, <strong>and</strong> Deran Lamp<br />

& Shade Company, manufacturer<br />

<strong>and</strong> distributor of portable lighting<br />

products.<br />

He has taught Sunday School at<br />

St. James Church in Watertown<br />

since 1997 <strong>and</strong> has a list of credentials<br />

the length of your arm with<br />

the Knights of Vartan. No need to<br />

A community regroups after its pastor’s death<br />

repeat everything, Suffice it to say,<br />

he’s made the <strong>Armenia</strong>n community<br />

his priority.<br />

Two years ago, Deranian chaired<br />

the New Engl<strong>and</strong> Pontifical visit of<br />

His Holiness Karekin II, Catholicos<br />

of all <strong>Armenia</strong>ns.<br />

He has helped deliver school supplies<br />

to destitute schoolchildren in<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>, promoted hygiene <strong>and</strong><br />

sanitation in <strong>Armenia</strong>, sponsored<br />

<strong>and</strong> renovated schools, <strong>and</strong> distributed<br />

scholarships. Two of my ayf<br />

children were K of V recipients.<br />

According to one report, $19<br />

million has gone to school projects<br />

in <strong>Armenia</strong>. For every dollar<br />

the brotherhood raises, the World<br />

Bank matches $9.<br />

This July, the City of Boston will<br />

be converted into a metropolis for<br />

Knights from every corner of the<br />

country. More than 400 members<br />

are expected to converge at the<br />

Westin Copley from July 1 to 5.<br />

Had he been alive, Der Vartan<br />

would have played a key role as<br />

comm<strong>and</strong>er of the Arakadz Lodge<br />

of Merrimack Valley. In the entire<br />

history of this organization,<br />

no cleric has ever assumed such<br />

a leading role <strong>and</strong> the reason why<br />

he joined runs parallel with others<br />

who’ve taken an initiative.<br />

They wanted to make a difference.<br />

“We believe that the preservation<br />

of our racial, religious, <strong>and</strong> cultural<br />

heritage is our sacred obligation,”<br />

Deranian points out. “However we<br />

achieve that means is up to us.”<br />

Haig Deranian is alive today because<br />

he had God on his side. He’ll<br />

never dispute that. Nor will he ever<br />

contradict the work of his organization,<br />

much less the interaction of<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>ns everywhere, regardless<br />

of political or fraternal affiliation.<br />

For that, he is to be admired. <br />

by Tom Vartabedian<br />

Weeks after his death, a community<br />

continues to mourn the loss of<br />

its beloved pastor.<br />

The passing of Der Vartan Kassabian<br />

March 12 has sent the Merrimack<br />

Valley reeling with aftershock<br />

<strong>and</strong> cast parishioners from<br />

St. Gregory Church into a bereaved<br />

state.<br />

It’s not something anyone can<br />

forget overnight – or after an eternity.<br />

But like he would have wished,<br />

grief must be replaced by healing<br />

<strong>and</strong> the congregation must persevere.<br />

If anything, this pastor always<br />

preached vitality <strong>and</strong> encouraged<br />

his flock to settle for nothing<br />

less.<br />

As Sunday School students come<br />

to grips with reality, several are<br />

looking to the church for strength.<br />

The priest who once humored them<br />

with a casual Sunday sermon is no<br />

longer there.<br />

He taught them well. Hopefully,<br />

the lessons will guide them toward<br />

greater maturity.<br />

Local genocide-commemoration<br />

committees will miss his sturdy<br />

presence at events where prayers<br />

will mourn his loss. If anything,<br />

they will remember the man for his<br />

oratorical brilliance <strong>and</strong> the knack<br />

for always finding the right words<br />

in a dire situation.<br />

Two years ago, when v<strong>and</strong>als destroyed<br />

some genocide billboards<br />

around Greater Boston, <strong>Armenia</strong>ns<br />

everywhere were aghast.<br />

Could this be another vile Turkish<br />

prank Such v<strong>and</strong>alism made<br />

the Boston papers with pity.<br />

As the <strong>Armenia</strong>n public criticized<br />

the act, Der Vartan found a positive<br />

side. In an invocation he delivered,<br />

he told the audience that such acts<br />

were “a blessing in disguise.”<br />

“The publicity we received from<br />

this caught the eye of every sympathetic<br />

reader <strong>and</strong> underscored<br />

nine decades of intolerance by our<br />

people toward Turkey,” he pointed<br />

out. “You can’t buy this kind of<br />

press. They did us a favor.”<br />

With his pearls of wisdom, Der<br />

Vartan was like a firefly on a moonless<br />

night, casting certain radiance<br />

where there was none.<br />

The elderly continue to grieve.<br />

Each Sunday he would regale them<br />

with words of inspiration, whether<br />

it was from the altar or during a<br />

coffee hour. Shortly after his father’s<br />

death, Mgo walked into an<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n School class <strong>and</strong> sat with<br />

the younger students.<br />

His place, he felt, was with them<br />

as words of encouragement flowed<br />

from his mouth. A year ago this<br />

time, his essay on genocide recognition<br />

took first prize. As another<br />

contest took effect, he urged the<br />

students to enter, get involved,<br />

make a difference in their church,<br />

much the same way his father had<br />

intended.<br />

As another phase of a renovation<br />

project takes place inside the<br />

church, there seems to be greater<br />

initiative than ever to get the work<br />

accomplished in his memory. A better<br />

tribute couldn’t be possible.<br />

The Easter season took on greater<br />

significance this year as in the past<br />

with the death of Christ resurrecting<br />

an entire Christian nation. In<br />

some ways, the same could be said<br />

for Der Vartan’s demise.<br />

Life after death.<br />

Visiting clergy continue to do<br />

their part until a replacement is<br />

named. Every promise has been<br />

made by the hierarchy to find a<br />

suitable pastor. To walk in his<br />

shoes would be a daunting task for<br />

any cleric.<br />

Meanwhile, a congregation has<br />

been enamored to carry on the<br />

work he so delegated to others.<br />

Jesus Christ died two centuries<br />

ago. Presidents like Abe Lincoln<br />

<strong>and</strong> John F. Kennedy are gone. Our<br />

rich, classical composers, Bach,<br />

Beethoven, Mozart set their own<br />

st<strong>and</strong>ard.<br />

Are they really dead Are not<br />

their words <strong>and</strong> music still heard<br />

Der Vartan had no illusions of<br />

gr<strong>and</strong>eur, yet he was gr<strong>and</strong> in his<br />

own humble, charismatic way. The<br />

man some predicted would never<br />

make a good priest was fit to be a<br />

prince of his church.<br />

It isn’t the quantity of life – the<br />

number of years – that matters, but<br />

rather the quality, how that life was<br />

lived. Der Vartan lived his 51 years<br />

exceptionally well.<br />

In an age of takers, he was a giver.<br />

Like the coin of life, his life was<br />

dedicated to two sides, his family<br />

<strong>and</strong> his work. For that, he leaves<br />

Der Vartan<br />

Kassabian.<br />

behind a rich legacy we have all<br />

grown to appreciate.<br />

He took the time to love <strong>and</strong><br />

laugh – to serve <strong>and</strong> enjoy countless<br />

friendships. He took the time<br />

to dream, play <strong>and</strong> reflect a little<br />

more than we ordinarily would.<br />

Der Vartan didn’t need a clock<br />

in his timeless journey, or a schedule<br />

to maintain. He killed time by<br />

working it to death.<br />

What you do for yourself unfortunately<br />

dies with you. But what<br />

you do for others lives on after<br />

you. A man such as Der Vartan will<br />

never die in the eyes of a grateful<br />

community.


The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | April 11, 2009 15


E<br />

16 The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | April 11, 2009<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong><br />

Dilit<br />

Khojabek<br />

+<br />

Lake Khanchal<br />

Patara Khanchal 1997<br />

+ Satkha<br />

NINOTZMINDA<br />

Spasovka<br />

M. Karakhach<br />

2689<br />

J A V A K<br />

3054<br />

M. Aghrikar<br />

¸Didi Khanchal<br />

Katnatu<br />

Orlovka<br />

Bughdashen<br />

Bughdashen (Gorelovka)<br />

M. Madatapa<br />

2718<br />

H K R<br />

M. Dali<br />

M<br />

Swamp of Byurakn<br />

3196<br />

Saragyugh<br />

M. Achkasar<br />

The mosque at the center of this photograph is across the river <strong>and</strong> the border in Halimjan, whereas the buildings in the foreground are in <strong>Armenia</strong>. Photos: Tatul Hakobyan for the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter.<br />

M. Lorasar<br />

3008 2889<br />

M. Parakh<br />

2546<br />

Darik<br />

2956<br />

Lorasar<br />

M. Yerakatar<br />

Bavra<br />

M. Ashotskar<br />

Sizavet<br />

M. Gaylakar<br />

Tzaghkut<br />

2774<br />

M. Tsurtav<br />

2446<br />

3122<br />

2950<br />

Yeghnajur<br />

Zorakert<br />

2025<br />

Tavshut<br />

Garnaritch<br />

Aghvorik<br />

M. Karanik<br />

2843<br />

Ghazanchi<br />

10<br />

Ardenis<br />

2965<br />

3038<br />

M. Tchokhak<br />

Paghakn<br />

+<br />

M. Sevsar<br />

Res. of<br />

Arpi Lake<br />

Aravet<br />

Shaghik<br />

Berdashen<br />

Metz Sepasar<br />

Alvar<br />

Ashotsk<br />

2208<br />

Pokr Sepasar +<br />

M. Ashotsk<br />

M. Kaputkogh<br />

Zuygaghbyur<br />

3047<br />

+<br />

+ Hartashen<br />

Krasar<br />

+<br />

Swamp of Zarishat<br />

Zarishat<br />

2272<br />

Karmravan<br />

Musayelian<br />

Yerizak<br />

M. Sepasar<br />

2448<br />

P L A T E A U o f A S H O T S K<br />

Vardaghbyur<br />

Hovtun<br />

Moks (Ibish)<br />

M. Amasia<br />

Amasia<br />

Salut<br />

Swamp of Sghnakh<br />

B<strong>and</strong>ivan<br />

2312<br />

Tsoghamarg<br />

Bazargan<br />

+<br />

Bashgyugh<br />

Aregnadem<br />

Gog'hovit<br />

Lernagyugh<br />

Torosgyugh<br />

Pokr Sariar<br />

Gtashen<br />

Jradzor<br />

Hoghmik<br />

Arpeni<br />

M. Tsulasar<br />

2555<br />

M. Kaghamakhut<br />

Kamkhut<br />

2106<br />

Metz Sariar<br />

Pokrashen<br />

Hovuni<br />

+ Krashen<br />

Gyulibulagh<br />

Keti<br />

Karmrakar<br />

+ +<br />

+<br />

Kaps<br />

1987<br />

JA JUR<br />

Ajabaj<br />

Vahramaberd<br />

MAYI SIAN<br />

Jajur Pass.<br />

Lernut<br />

Dilaver Meghrashat<br />

+<br />

Shirak<br />

Mayisian +<br />

Jajur<br />

Marmashen Mon. +<br />

Khnkoyan<br />

Voghju<br />

Marmashen<br />

Hatsik<br />

+<br />

Kamo<br />

Haykavan<br />

Duran<br />

2312<br />

+<br />

GYUMRI<br />

M. Kapanak<br />

Kumayri Fort. +<br />

Arapi<br />

Karnut<br />

Moks<br />

+<br />

+<br />

Hovit<br />

Voskehask<br />

+<br />

Akhurian Karnut Res.<br />

After years of isolation, the ancient capitals of<br />

Yerv<strong>and</strong>ashat <strong>and</strong> Bagaran are now open to visitors<br />

There are many<br />

historical sites<br />

in Yeraskhadzor,<br />

where the Arax <strong>and</strong><br />

Akhurian rivers<br />

meet<br />

by Tatul Hakobyan<br />

YERVANDASHAT <strong>and</strong> BAGARAN,<br />

Armavir province, <strong>Armenia</strong> – The<br />

residents of Bagaran wake up at<br />

the crack of dawn every morning to<br />

the voices of the muezzin from the<br />

neighboring village of Halimjan.<br />

The two villages are separated by<br />

the Akhuryan river, which serves<br />

as the <strong>Armenia</strong>n-Turkish boundary.<br />

“Of course it disturbs us,” said<br />

Gevorg Margaryan, the head of<br />

Bagaran village.<br />

Bagaran is one of the oldest settlements<br />

in <strong>Armenia</strong>. It was founded<br />

by King Yerv<strong>and</strong>, the last of the Yerv<strong>and</strong>unis,<br />

in the 3rd century B.C.E.<br />

It was here that King Yerv<strong>and</strong>, or<br />

Orontes, transported pagan idols<br />

from Armavir, constructed pagan<br />

temples, <strong>and</strong> appointed his brother<br />

as high priest.<br />

For centuries – actually until<br />

1920 – Bagaran was spread along<br />

the right <strong>and</strong> left banks of the<br />

Akhuryan <strong>and</strong> also on the left bank<br />

of the Araks River.<br />

“Our forefathers crossed the<br />

Akhuryan twice, once in 1917 <strong>and</strong><br />

for the last time in 1920, never to<br />

return,” said Mr. Margaryan.<br />

At the beginning of the 20th century,<br />

Bagaran had about 800 residents.<br />

To escape from the Turkish<br />

massacres, the residents of Bagaran<br />

crossed the left bank of the<br />

Akhuryan River. When the first<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n republic was created in<br />

1918 <strong>and</strong> the territories exp<strong>and</strong>ed,<br />

the Bagarantsis returned to the<br />

right bank. At that time, Bagaran<br />

was part of the district of Surmalu.<br />

After the loss of the republic,<br />

the Western <strong>Armenia</strong>n regions of<br />

Surmalu <strong>and</strong> the region of Kars,<br />

along with the rest of the territories<br />

of Western <strong>Armenia</strong>, became<br />

part of Turkey.<br />

The apricots are<br />

delicious<br />

“Today the village has 610 resident.<br />

Apricots grow very well here. We<br />

are primarily employed in agriculture<br />

<strong>and</strong> dairy farming,” the village<br />

head explained.<br />

After the fall of the Yerv<strong>and</strong>uni<br />

Kingdom, Bagaran lost its shine<br />

<strong>and</strong> splendor <strong>and</strong> for almost a<br />

thous<strong>and</strong> years is not mentioned.<br />

In the 9th century, Bagaran is once<br />

again mentioned <strong>and</strong> the first king<br />

of the Bagratunis, Ashot I, proclaimed<br />

Bagaran the capital of the<br />

kingdom.<br />

It was only a few years ago that<br />

one had to get special permission<br />

from <strong>Armenia</strong>’s national security<br />

<strong>and</strong> border forces to travel to the<br />

oldest capitals of <strong>Armenia</strong>, Bagaran<br />

<strong>and</strong> Yerv<strong>and</strong>ashat. But today,<br />

that checkpoint has been removed<br />

<strong>and</strong> all those who wish to go <strong>and</strong><br />

visit these glorious sites, including<br />

diaspora <strong>Armenia</strong>ns <strong>and</strong> tourists,<br />

can now do so.<br />

Before traveling down to Bagaran<br />

<strong>and</strong> Yerv<strong>and</strong>ashat, it is necessary<br />

to stop at a certain distance <strong>and</strong><br />

look at the breathtaking scenery<br />

from above. This is the Yeraskhadzor<br />

Valley, where the Araks <strong>and</strong><br />

Akhuryan rivers mix together.<br />

Yerv<strong>and</strong>ashat is only one kilometer<br />

away from Bagaran. It was<br />

the last capital of the Yerv<strong>and</strong>uni<br />

Kingdom, taking over from Armavir.<br />

The city, which is spread over<br />

the two banks of the Araks River,<br />

used to have a vibrant population.<br />

Yerv<strong>and</strong>ashat was destroyed in the<br />

4th century C.E. by the forces of the<br />

Persian King Shabuh.<br />

Today, Yerv<strong>and</strong>ashat is a village<br />

of 825 residents. Since the collapse<br />

of the Soviet Union, the village<br />

has only ever had one village head,<br />

Hovan Avetisian.<br />

“I have been the village head since<br />

1991 <strong>and</strong> I don’t belong to any political<br />

party. Those who live in Yerv<strong>and</strong>ashat<br />

are natives to this village,<br />

but we also have residents from<br />

Verin Sasnashen <strong>and</strong> Sarnaghpyur<br />

of the region of Talin. The people<br />

here grow fruit trees <strong>and</strong> keep cattle<br />

– cows <strong>and</strong> sheep. The village is<br />

about 4,000 hectares but only 10<br />

percent of it is used in agriculture,”<br />

Mr. Avetisian said.<br />

The village head recalled how in<br />

Soviet times, Yerv<strong>and</strong>ashat was a<br />

very closed-off place. To come here<br />

one needed to go through several<br />

government departments to get<br />

the necessary permission. After<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>’s independence, diaspora<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>ns expressed great interest<br />

in visiting Bagaran <strong>and</strong> Yervadashad.<br />

However, these villages continued<br />

to remain difficult places to<br />

visit, once again tied off because of<br />

the different papers one needed to<br />

get.<br />

“In 2001, during the ceremonies<br />

commemorating the 1700th anniversary<br />

of the adoption of Christianity,<br />

initially there was an intention<br />

of including these two villages<br />

in the formal program of activities<br />

because there are many historic<br />

sites in the two historic capitals<br />

at the point where the Araks <strong>and</strong><br />

Akhuryan rivers meet. There is the<br />

fortress of Queen Parantsem, the<br />

grave of Gevorg Marzpetuni, which<br />

is right on the banks of the Araks<br />

River, but on the Turkish side,” Mr.<br />

Avetisian explained.<br />

For two years, a group of archaeologists<br />

have been working in Yer-<br />

+<br />

Kochkran<br />

Sosker t<br />

v<strong>and</strong>ashat <strong>and</strong> they have already<br />

discovered remains from the palace<br />

of King Yerv<strong>and</strong>, right on the +<br />

Dilan<br />

Seydijan<br />

banks of the Araks.<br />

K arakhan<br />

Kechut +<br />

“There is a program + being + developed<br />

with the U.N., so that some of<br />

+<br />

Lake Kechut<br />

the homes in the villages will<br />

Shahniler<br />

+ have<br />

Poldr van<br />

the ability to accept Korek guests, tourists<br />

<strong>and</strong> diaspora <strong>Armenia</strong>ns M. Argina <strong>and</strong> to<br />

Inja<br />

welcome them with freshly baked<br />

1816<br />

lavash from the tonir,” Mr. Oghuz Avetisian<br />

said.<br />

Gyulveran + Bashgetikler<br />

Khamsagarak<br />

+ +<br />

+<br />

The village head is convinced + +<br />

Bayraktarthat<br />

Mavrak<br />

Bagaran <strong>and</strong> Yerv<strong>and</strong>ashat represent<br />

a great historical value. There-<br />

1701<br />

M. Yerablur<br />

fore today, when there is no longer<br />

Jala<br />

Araz<br />

any restriction or difficulty + in visiting<br />

this region, which is only<br />

Ani<br />

100<br />

kilometers from Yerevan, it will A N no<br />

I<br />

Ani Cathedral<br />

Kharkov<br />

doubt be a place of great Maghasberd interest<br />

for tourists.<br />

f<br />

K alus<br />

GEORGIA<br />

TURKEY<br />

Where the Araks<br />

<strong>and</strong> Akhuryan<br />

– <strong>and</strong> <strong>Armenia</strong><br />

<strong>and</strong> presentday<br />

Turkey<br />

– meet. <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

Reporter map ©<br />

2009 <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

Reporter LLC.<br />

Y E G H N A S A R<br />

R A N G E<br />

2886<br />

RUSSIA<br />

Yeghnajur<br />

Akhurian<br />

T U R K E Y<br />

Kars<br />

Maghasberd<br />

Fort.<br />

Bajal<br />

Yengi<br />

M R E N<br />

+<br />

Ar tagers<br />

B A G A R A N<br />

Artagers Mon. Halimjan<br />

+ Bagaran<br />

Y E R V A N D A K E R T<br />

2502<br />

Geghiart Canyon<br />

Yefremovka<br />

Zhdanov<br />

Y E R V A N D A S H A T<br />

Kalinino<br />

³íßáõï Tavshut<br />

Gharibjanian<br />

+ Shorag yal<br />

Akhurik<br />

"SHIRAK"<br />

Musayelian<br />

Arevik<br />

+ Hak<br />

Demirkend<br />

Azatan<br />

Hin Argina<br />

+<br />

Getk<br />

T ikhnis Yerazgavors +<br />

+<br />

Aygabats<br />

Argina Mon.<br />

G<br />

Shatin<br />

Beniamin<br />

+<br />

+<br />

S H I R A K A V A N<br />

Par val<br />

Bay<strong>and</strong>ur<br />

Saratak<br />

Meghrashen<br />

Lusakert<br />

Hovtashen<br />

Panik<br />

Shirakavan +<br />

+<br />

+<br />

Gusanagyugh<br />

Getapi<br />

Karmirvank Mon.<br />

Horom<br />

Anushavan<br />

K armir vank<br />

Nor Kyank<br />

Ma<br />

Lusaghbyur<br />

Hayreniats ARTIK<br />

Akhurian<br />

Isahakian<br />

+ +<br />

+<br />

Res.<br />

Tazashen<br />

Haykasar<br />

Haritch N<br />

+<br />

Tufashen<br />

Aghin<br />

+<br />

+<br />

Bardzrashen<br />

Hari M<br />

MARALIK<br />

+<br />

+<br />

Pemzashen Mon.<br />

AGHIN<br />

Dzorashen<br />

+<br />

N.Jrapi<br />

+<br />

Dzorakap<br />

+ St. Arakelahimn Mon<br />

+ Jrapi<br />

Sarakap<br />

Lernakert<br />

Horomos Mon.<br />

Karaberd<br />

Haykadzor +<br />

Sarnaghbyur<br />

+<br />

B AGR AVAN<br />

Khoshavank<br />

Dzit'hankov +<br />

Mon.<br />

Lanjik<br />

Hogevank Mon.<br />

Garnhovit<br />

An ancient khatchkar or cross stone +<br />

Bagravan<br />

Zarnja<br />

Tzaghkasar<br />

the side Nor of Artik the road. +<br />

Zovasar<br />

+ +<br />

Tsamakasar<br />

Dprevank<br />

²ÜÆ<br />

+<br />

Anipemza<br />

ANI<br />

Suser<br />

Dzoragyugh<br />

1560<br />

Vosketas<br />

M. Sevsirt<br />

+ +<br />

Mastara<br />

Karmrashen<br />

Yereruyk Mon.<br />

Hatsashen<br />

+<br />

+<br />

Sorik<br />

Akunk<br />

+ Shgharshik<br />

Tlik<br />

+<br />

Areg +<br />

Yeghnik<br />

Hakko<br />

+ Irind<br />

Getap<br />

M. Metz Arteni<br />

+<br />

Gyalto 2047<br />

TALIN +<br />

+ Verin Sasnashen<br />

Katnaghbyur<br />

Barozh<br />

Davtashen +<br />

Nerkin Sasnash<br />

Satanidar Settl.<br />

Dashtadem<br />

Aragatz<br />

Ghabaghtapa +<br />

+<br />

+ Ashnak<br />

Nerkin<br />

Lusakn<br />

Shatakh<br />

Ar tavut<br />

Jrik<br />

M. Tek<br />

Akhurian<br />

AZERBAIJAN<br />

IRAN<br />

K APUY T R ANGE<br />

Araks<br />

2425<br />

M. Yeghnasar<br />

Karakhan<br />

Kechut<br />

Gharabagh<br />

Moks<br />

KOGHB (TUZLUJA)<br />

Lake Bughdashen<br />

Kaghin<br />

Chinchavat<br />

Akhurian<br />

Arteni<br />

Argina<br />

Turabi<br />

Shenik<br />

Koghbavan<br />

Yerv<strong>and</strong>ashat M. Karmirblur<br />

+<br />

1132<br />

+ +<br />

Kmlaget<br />

Tikhnis<br />

T A L<br />

I N<br />

Akhurian<br />

Voghjaget<br />

Selav Mastara<br />

P L A T<br />

E A U<br />

Surb Mari (Surmalu)<br />

Pirli<br />

Talin<br />

2107<br />

Lake Madatapa<br />

Shirak Ch.<br />

Channel<br />

+<br />

S H<br />

S H I R A K<br />

I R<br />

A K<br />

Karakert<br />

Karkatchun<br />

R A N G E<br />

Baghramian<br />

Van<strong>and</strong><br />

P L A<br />

Dalarik<br />

Artamet<br />

Koghaghbyur<br />

Shirak<br />

U<br />

T E A<br />

Ch.<br />

Lernagog<br />

Myasnikian<br />

Khonarkhach<br />

Arevadasht<br />

Talvorik<br />

Ashotsk<br />

Hushakert<br />

Vardakar<br />

Hatsik<br />

2914<br />

Kakavajur<br />

Sardarapat<br />

Araks<br />

Khanjian<br />

Nairi<br />

Dzerzhinski<br />

Amasia<br />

M. Kechut<br />

3156<br />

Karakhach Pass.<br />

Lmbatavank<br />

Armavir Great Channel<br />

Lenughi<br />

Nor Armavir<br />

Sheram<br />

Sp<br />

K<br />

L<br />

H<br />

P<br />

Lukas<br />

Norava<br />

Hoktember<br />

Karan<br />

Bambakashat<br />

+<br />

A R M A V I R<br />

Jrashen<br />

Nor Kesaria Shenavan<br />

Nor Art<br />

Nalb<strong>and</strong>ian<br />

Berkashat +<br />

Janfida<br />

Getashen<br />

Nerkin Arabkir<br />

+<br />

C havush<br />

Baraktut<br />

+<br />

Hak<br />

Zakir<br />

+<br />

A N G<br />

Ar<br />

A R A G A T Z O<br />

M


The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | April 11, 2009 17<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong><br />

In five years, <strong>Armenia</strong>, Iran to be connected by rail<br />

If this ambitious<br />

initiative<br />

materializes,<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong> could have<br />

a passage through<br />

the ports of the<br />

Persian Gulf<br />

by Tatul Hakobyan<br />

YEREVAN – High-ranking officials<br />

from <strong>Armenia</strong> <strong>and</strong> Iran are giving<br />

assurances that in five years’ time<br />

there will be a railroad linking the<br />

two countries. According to preliminary<br />

calculations, the railroad<br />

will stretch for approximately 470<br />

kilometers, with 410 of those on<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n territory. The total cost<br />

of this undertaking is expected to<br />

run about $1.2 billion.<br />

An agreement will be signed by<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong> <strong>and</strong> Iran sometime this<br />

month when President Serge<br />

Sargsian is expected to be in Tehran<br />

for an official visit. On April 3<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>’s minister of transportation,<br />

Gurgen Sargsian, <strong>and</strong> Iran’s<br />

transport <strong>and</strong> communications<br />

minister, Hamid Behbahani,<br />

signed a memor<strong>and</strong>um of underst<strong>and</strong>ing<br />

in this regard.<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>, which is currently<br />

under blockade from the west by<br />

Turkey <strong>and</strong> from the east by Azerbaijan,<br />

had a rail link with Iran during<br />

the Soviet era. The line began<br />

in Yerevan <strong>and</strong> continued along the<br />

banks of the Araks River, through<br />

Nakhichevan in the Azerbaijani<br />

republic, stretching all the way to<br />

Julfa. From there the railroad cut<br />

across the Araks River by bridge to<br />

Jolfa station in Iran. From there<br />

was connected to the Iranian railroad<br />

grid. This was the flattest <strong>and</strong><br />

shortest route: 200 km from Yerevan<br />

to the Iranian border.<br />

Mountainous terrain<br />

With passage through Nakhichevan<br />

blocked, the new rail link will have<br />

to be built across high mountain<br />

ranges – through the provinces of<br />

Vayots Dzor <strong>and</strong> Syunik. The exact<br />

route through <strong>Armenia</strong>n territory<br />

has not yet been mapped out. At a<br />

press conference with his Iranian<br />

counterpart, Mr. Gurgen Sargsian<br />

said it would be preferable to have<br />

the railroad run from the basin of<br />

Sevan toward Jermuk. Built during<br />

the Soviet era, there is today a<br />

working railroad from Yerevan all<br />

the way to the western basin of Sevan,<br />

the city of Vardenis. The portion<br />

of the railroad to be built on<br />

Iranian territory must run to the<br />

city of Mar<strong>and</strong>.<br />

Ministers Sargsian <strong>and</strong> Behbahani<br />

said that the railroad will be<br />

built in three stages. In the first<br />

stage, technical <strong>and</strong> financial studies<br />

will be carried out. This stage will<br />

require three months. The second<br />

stage will be determining the route<br />

of the railroad <strong>and</strong> the drafting of<br />

maps. The third stage will involve<br />

the actual construction. The ministers<br />

foresee that this project will<br />

take up to five years to complete.<br />

The sides expect to secure financing<br />

for this project through large<br />

banks. “Negotiations for financing<br />

have already begun with the World<br />

Bank <strong>and</strong> the Asian Development<br />

Bank,” Minister Sargsian said.<br />

If the construction of this ambitious<br />

railroad becomes a reality,<br />

then <strong>Armenia</strong> will not only be connected<br />

to its neighbor Iran through<br />

a rail link, but will be able to have<br />

transportation routes all the way to<br />

the Persian Gulf <strong>and</strong> through this<br />

Argina Mon.<br />

Horomos Mon.<br />

Khoshavank Mon.<br />

ANI<br />

Araks<br />

NINOTZMINDA<br />

Akhurian<br />

Kaputkogh fort.<br />

Yereruyk Mon.<br />

Amasia<br />

Vahramaberd fort.<br />

Marmashen Mon.<br />

Kumayri fort. GYUMRI<br />

ARTENI mnt<br />

Akhurian<br />

MARALIK<br />

2047<br />

Satanidar - paleolithic<br />

settlement<br />

TURKEY<br />

Haritchavank Mon.<br />

Hogevank Mon.<br />

ARAGATZ mnt<br />

Amberd fort.<br />

Tegher Mon.<br />

have routes to neighboring regions<br />

<strong>and</strong> states in Central Asia, the Middle<br />

East, India, <strong>and</strong> China.<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>’s railroads belong to a<br />

Russian company. The full management<br />

of <strong>Armenia</strong>’s railroad, lately<br />

renamed the South Caucasian Railway,<br />

was given to Russian Railways<br />

for a period of 30 years. Since 2001<br />

the <strong>Armenia</strong>n railroad has been<br />

a profitable operation, primarily<br />

transporting cargo from <strong>Armenia</strong><br />

to Georgia all the way to the Black<br />

Sea ports of Batumi <strong>and</strong> Poti <strong>and</strong><br />

back.<br />

Russian Railways promised to<br />

invest $570 million in <strong>Armenia</strong>’s<br />

railways. It has already stated, however,<br />

that it will not finance the <strong>Armenia</strong>-Iran<br />

initiative. The Russians<br />

will use Azerbaijan’s territory for<br />

their railway communication with<br />

Iran.<br />

A geopolitically<br />

significant project<br />

<br />

TALIN<br />

Sardarapat<br />

Monument complex<br />

GEORGIA<br />

Ashotsk<br />

H<br />

ACHKASAR mnt<br />

3196<br />

Lmbatavank Mon.<br />

Arutch<br />

karavansaray<br />

H<br />

ARMAVIR<br />

TSOLAKERT (IGDIR)<br />

Metzamor - metallurgical<br />

<strong>and</strong> observatorian complex<br />

(4-3 th. B.C.)<br />

APARAN<br />

H<br />

4092<br />

Saghmosavank Mon.<br />

Ohanavank Mon.<br />

H<br />

VAGHARSHAPAT<br />

Ejmiatzin<br />

Cathedral<br />

MASIS (GREAT ARARAT) mountain<br />

5165<br />

3925<br />

SIS (SMALL ARARAT) mountain<br />

Abel Aghabegians, a well-known<br />

economist <strong>and</strong> academician said<br />

last October that the fundamental<br />

issue surrounding the construction<br />

of the <strong>Armenia</strong>-Iran railroad would<br />

be whether the sides would be able<br />

to guarantee the required amount<br />

of cargo transport to justify the<br />

cost. He suggested that perhaps it<br />

would have preferable to renovate<br />

<strong>and</strong> shorten the distance of the <strong>Armenia</strong>-Iran<br />

automobile highway by<br />

building a few tunnels at a fraction<br />

of the cost. Mr. Aghabegians said<br />

that the cost of building this railroad<br />

could skyrocket to $2 billion because<br />

it would have to be built across<br />

treacherous territory. He hinted<br />

that perhaps the geopolitical significance<br />

of the <strong>Armenia</strong>-Iran railroad<br />

outweighs its economic benefits.<br />

During the Soviet era, <strong>Armenia</strong><br />

had several rail links with Azerbaijn.<br />

Cargo <strong>and</strong> passenger trains operated<br />

between Yerevan <strong>and</strong> Baku<br />

(this route passed along the banks<br />

of the Araks River all the way to<br />

ARTIK<br />

Dzoraget<br />

H<br />

SPITAK<br />

STEPANAVAN<br />

Pambak<br />

H<br />

H<br />

Byurakan<br />

ASHTARAK<br />

TASHIR<br />

Oshakan<br />

MASIS<br />

LORI<br />

Khuchap<br />

Mon.<br />

VANADZOR<br />

Kasakh<br />

H<br />

Hankavan<br />

ARAILER mnt<br />

2575<br />

YEGHVARD<br />

<br />

<br />

Khorakert<br />

Mon.<br />

Khor Virap<br />

Monastery<br />

Dzernak<br />

fort.<br />

LALVAR mnt<br />

2543<br />

AKHTALA<br />

H<br />

LALVAR<br />

Odzun<br />

Kecharis Mon.<br />

TZAGHKADZOR<br />

Hrazdan<br />

Debed<br />

H<br />

H<br />

ARTASHAT<br />

Garni<br />

Sanahin Mon.<br />

TUMANIAN<br />

H<br />

HRAZDAN<br />

Haghpat Mon.<br />

CHARENTSAVAN<br />

BYUREGHAVAN<br />

ABOVIAN<br />

KHOSROV<br />

reservation<br />

DILIJAN<br />

H<br />

YEREVAN<br />

VEDI<br />

H<br />

ARARAT<br />

AYRUM<br />

AZHDAHAK mnt<br />

Kirants Mon.<br />

Makaravank Mon.<br />

DILIJAN<br />

national park<br />

Haghartzin<br />

Mon.<br />

Geghard Mon.<br />

(Ayrivank)<br />

Havuts Tar Mon.<br />

St.Stepanos Mon.<br />

Hovhannes-Karapet<br />

Mon.<br />

Yeraskhavan<br />

SEVAN<br />

lake Parz<br />

Araks<br />

IRAN<br />

NOYEMBERIAN<br />

Lastiver rock<br />

Goshavank Mon.<br />

3598<br />

Sevan Mon.<br />

SEVAN<br />

national park<br />

Geghi fort.<br />

l a k e<br />

Hayravank<br />

Mon.<br />

Sulem karavansaray<br />

Nor<br />

Varagavank Mon.<br />

Noratus<br />

khachkar-field<br />

Noravank Mon.<br />

S E V A<br />

SEVAN national park<br />

VARDENIS mnt<br />

3521<br />

Julfa, then back through <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

territory at Meghri, <strong>and</strong> back once<br />

again into Azerbaijan) <strong>and</strong> Ijevan<br />

to Baku. The Yerevan-Kapan line<br />

also passed through the territories<br />

of Azerbaijan <strong>and</strong> Nakhichevan.<br />

The Yerevan-Baku <strong>and</strong> the Ichevan-<br />

Baku lines carried 80 percent of<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>’s cargo.<br />

H<br />

Aghstev<br />

H<br />

GAVAR<br />

SHARUR<br />

IJEVAN<br />

Argitchi<br />

Areni<br />

TCHAMBARAK<br />

Znaberd<br />

BERD<br />

H<br />

MARTUNI<br />

GAZAKH<br />

N<br />

Tsakhats Kar Mon.<br />

Hermon Mon.<br />

Arpa<br />

AGHSTEV<br />

YEGHEGNADZOR<br />

Khoranashat<br />

Mon.<br />

Yergevanits<br />

fort.<br />

VAYK<br />

Nakhichevan<br />

Kura<br />

St.Gevorg Mon.<br />

Vanevank Mon.<br />

Karmirvank Mon.<br />

Darashamb Surb<br />

Stepanos Mon.<br />

H<br />

Gndevank Mon.<br />

Hazarabyurats Mon.<br />

Nakhichevan<br />

(Az.)<br />

NAKHICHEVAN<br />

TOVUZ<br />

Artzvashen<br />

JERMUK<br />

JOLFA<br />

Makeniats Mon.<br />

Surb Khach Mon.<br />

St.Karapet<br />

Mon.<br />

H<br />

Hreshtakapetats Mon.<br />

GETABAK<br />

VARDENIS<br />

Amenaprkich Mon.<br />

Amenayn Srbots Mon.<br />

Yernjak fort.<br />

Áàðñóì<br />

Tzaghkotsavank Mon.<br />

JUGHA (JULFA)<br />

Charekavank Mon.<br />

KARHAT (DASHKESAN)<br />

Tanahat Mon.<br />

Surb Nshan<br />

Mon.<br />

Trtu<br />

Tzara Astvatzatzin Mon.<br />

H<br />

Áàðóì<br />

Astvatzatzin Mon.<br />

KARVATCHAR<br />

St.Tovma Mon.<br />

VORDUAR (ORDUBAD)<br />

Levonaberd fort.<br />

Shoghavank Mon.<br />

ISHKHANASAR mnt<br />

3548<br />

Karahunj<br />

observatory<br />

(4 th. B.C.)<br />

SISIAN<br />

Vorotnavank Mon.<br />

Tatev Mon.<br />

ARAMAZD mnt<br />

Dadivank Mon.<br />

Halidzor fort.<br />

Vahanavank<br />

KAPUTJUGH mnt<br />

Mon.<br />

3906<br />

KAJARAN<br />

3201<br />

KHUSTUP mnt<br />

SHIKAHOGH<br />

reservation<br />

Baghatskar Mon.<br />

Arakelots Mon.<br />

Tztiternavank Mon.<br />

Goris <strong>and</strong><br />

Khndzoresk<br />

cave-settlements<br />

Bgheno Noravank Mon.<br />

Kajkert Mon.<br />

Khatravank Mon.<br />

G<strong>and</strong>zasar Mon.<br />

Astvatzatzin Mon.<br />

Yeritsvank Mon.<br />

During that period, <strong>Armenia</strong><br />

also had rail links with Turkey at<br />

the Gyumri-Kars line, which like<br />

the other rail links to Azerbaijan,<br />

are no longer in operation because<br />

of the 20-year-old blockade. The<br />

Yerevan-Tabriz rail line has also<br />

been under blockade because a<br />

portion of that line passes through<br />

Vorotan<br />

3392<br />

H<br />

MEGHRI<br />

AGARAK<br />

H<br />

GORIS<br />

SHAKASHEN (KHANLAR)<br />

Getashen<br />

H<br />

KAPAN<br />

Horekavank Mon.<br />

Yeghishe Arakyal<br />

Gyulistan fort.<br />

Mon.<br />

MRAV mnt<br />

3348<br />

Sarsang res.<br />

Voghji<br />

Nrnadzor<br />

Araks<br />

SHAHUMIAN<br />

Kachaghakaberd fort.<br />

Ghazanchetsots<br />

church<br />

Hagari<br />

H<br />

Khachen<br />

H<br />

STEPANAKERT<br />

BERDZOR<br />

Krvaberd fort.<br />

Dzoravank Mon.<br />

KOVSAKAN<br />

MIJNAVAN<br />

Trtu<br />

Vankasar Mon.<br />

Amutegh Mon.<br />

MARGUSHEVAN<br />

H<br />

MARTAKERT<br />

Shushi fort.<br />

SHUSHI<br />

ASKERAN<br />

Mayraberd fort.<br />

"We <strong>and</strong> our Mountains"<br />

Katarovank Mon.<br />

Tovmasaberd fort.<br />

Gtchavank Mon.<br />

Aghjkaberd fort.<br />

Azokh cave<br />

HADRUT<br />

Karkar<br />

JRAKAN<br />

Khudaperin bridges<br />

AZERBAIJAN<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>’s <strong>and</strong> Nagorno-Karabakh’s railways. The borders with Turkey <strong>and</strong> Azerbaijan are closed. The only operating international rail link is with Georgia. <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

Reporter map © 2009 <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter LLC.<br />

MARTUNI<br />

Amaras Mon.<br />

VARANDA<br />

HORATIS<br />

Nakhichevan. For the past 17 years,<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong> also hasn’t had rail connection<br />

with Russia because a portion<br />

of that rail line passes through<br />

separatist Abkhazia in Georgia.<br />

That rail line, which is known as<br />

the Abkhazian railroad, has been<br />

under blockade by the Georgians<br />

since 1992.<br />

f


18 The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | April 11, 2009<br />

Editorial<br />

Commentary<br />

the armenian<br />

reporter<br />

A test of Turkey’s professed goodwill<br />

The extra-large <strong>and</strong> extra-bold headline could have been, “Obama, in Turkey, affirms the<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide.” The subheads would have noted the Turkish <strong>and</strong> <strong>Armenia</strong>n reaction.<br />

During his visit to Turkey, President Obama did not speak explicitly of the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

Genocide, although he did confirm that his views on the subject, which are “on the record,”<br />

have not changed. It is unfortunate that he did not take the opportunity to share his views<br />

with his Turkish hosts, as “close friends” – just as he shared his views on difficult topics like<br />

Turkey’s accession to the European Union with his hosts in the European Union earlier in<br />

the week, “as close friends of both Turkey <strong>and</strong> Europe.”<br />

What Mr. Obama did say, however, was significant.<br />

First, he expressed hope that the Turkish <strong>and</strong> <strong>Armenia</strong>n people “can move forward<br />

<strong>and</strong> deal with a difficult <strong>and</strong> tragic history.” This can only be taken to mean that the<br />

Turkish people must come to terms with the facts of the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide. These<br />

facts include the state’s organized effort to annihilate the <strong>Armenia</strong>n people, as well as<br />

heroic tales of Turks, Kurds, Americans, <strong>and</strong> others helping save lives. Unfortunately,<br />

President Abdullah Gul, with Mr. Obama at his side, did little to take that process forward.<br />

He put forth the classic – <strong>and</strong> patently dishonest – version of history espoused by<br />

Turkish state historians.<br />

Second, Mr. Obama told the Turkish parliament, “the United States strongly supports<br />

the full normalization of relations between Turkey <strong>and</strong> <strong>Armenia</strong>.” He said “an open border<br />

would return the Turkish <strong>and</strong> <strong>Armenia</strong>n people to a peaceful <strong>and</strong> prosperous coexistence<br />

that would serve both of your nations.”<br />

This message differs from ritual calls for reconciliation. It is an explicit call for Turkey to<br />

open the border with <strong>Armenia</strong>, which it closed unilaterally 16 years ago. By calling for “full<br />

normalization,” Mr. Obama is also asking Turkey to finally agree to establish diplomatic relations<br />

with <strong>Armenia</strong> – which <strong>Armenia</strong> has all along been willing to do.<br />

It now remains to be seen how Turkey will respond to Mr. Obama’s clear – <strong>and</strong> entirely<br />

reasonable – call for action. It will be a test of the goodwill professed by the Turkish authorities.<br />

The soccer ball<br />

Responding to a question posed by the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter’s Tatul Hakobyan, President Serge<br />

Sargsian of <strong>Armenia</strong> on April 10 insisted that the ball is now in Turkey’s court, “<strong>and</strong> if we are<br />

talking about soccer diplomacy, then we must state that the ball cannot constantly be on one<br />

side of the field <strong>and</strong> each soccer match has a predetermined time frame.”<br />

The current round of <strong>Armenia</strong>n-Turkish talks started with an invitation to a September<br />

2008 soccer match in Yerevan. Mr. Sargsian has agreed to a reciprocal invitation from Mr.<br />

Gül for the <strong>Armenia</strong>-Turkey match in Kayseri in October 2009. The question is whether he’ll<br />

go over an open border, with the new <strong>Armenia</strong>n ambassador to Turkey in tow. f<br />

Easter greeting from Archbishop Hovnan Derderian<br />

Burbank, Calif. – “Christ is Risen from the<br />

dead, Blessed is the Resurrection of Christ”<br />

The Resurrection of Christ our Lord, which<br />

provides spiritual strength in our lives as<br />

Christians, is the ultimate expression of<br />

Divine Love for humanity. This glorious triumph<br />

of Christ over death graces us continually<br />

with a renewed underst<strong>and</strong>ing of our<br />

Christian faith. This biggest miracle of all enables<br />

us to transform our God-given life into<br />

a renewed, deeper spiritual life. The Resurrection<br />

is the powerful presence of Almighty<br />

God in our lives.<br />

The glorious Resurrection of Christ our<br />

Lord is the reawakening of the Church. Indeed,<br />

the ineffable divine power of Christ’s<br />

Resurrection is difficult to underst<strong>and</strong> in<br />

mere words or logic, but could be experienced<br />

in the spiritual life of each <strong>and</strong> every faithful<br />

<strong>and</strong> the life of the Church. The Resurrection<br />

empowers us to live the Word of God in our<br />

daily lives <strong>and</strong> come closer to God.<br />

“Christ is Risen from the dead, Blessed is the Resurrection<br />

of Christ”<br />

By proclaiming that Christ is Risen from<br />

the dead we reject the deeds of darkness in<br />

our lives <strong>and</strong> turn our lives toward the empowering<br />

Light of God. Our forefathers have<br />

lived with this Faith <strong>and</strong> have taught us to<br />

live a life pleasing to God; a life that upholds<br />

the Christian faith, protects the sanctity of<br />

family, builds houses of worship <strong>and</strong> schools.<br />

This faith is complemented with our dedication<br />

to the Mother See of Holy Etchmiadzin<br />

<strong>and</strong> <strong>Armenia</strong>, <strong>and</strong> above all, our country the<br />

United States of America.<br />

The mystery of the blessed Resurrection of<br />

Christ our Lord ought to be reflected in the<br />

life of society. Inspired by the victorious Resurrection<br />

we are called to become the good<br />

h<strong>and</strong>s of Almighty God with a strong vision.<br />

If humanity has lost the vision of peace, the<br />

main reason is human greed <strong>and</strong> disrespect<br />

to our fellow human beings. The global financial<br />

crisis that societies all over the world<br />

are experience is but one dimension of this.<br />

As expressed by the newly elected head of<br />

the Russian Orthodox Church, His Holiness<br />

Patriarch Kyril: “Today, decisions have been<br />

affected by attributes such as greed, loss of<br />

control over consumption, a bid to enrich<br />

oneself by all means <strong>and</strong> have as much as<br />

possible… The crisis began when people forgot<br />

true value.”<br />

The blessed Resurrection of Christ our Lord<br />

impels us to live a miraculous life, to create<br />

<strong>and</strong> to illuminate the souls of humanity.<br />

I believe in the resurrection of the body<br />

“Christ is Risen from the dead, Blessed is the Resurrection<br />

of Christ”<br />

May the miracle of the Resurrection of<br />

Christ enrich our personal <strong>and</strong> communal<br />

life, so that we may put on the new person in<br />

Christ <strong>and</strong> walk with God, becoming co-helpers<br />

of God’s creation <strong>and</strong> to bring up our children<br />

with the mystery of the sanctified life.<br />

May the miracle of the Resurrection of<br />

Christ grant us the vision to become the<br />

living Church through the preaching of the<br />

Word of God, <strong>and</strong> working hard for the revitalization<br />

of the Church.<br />

Our faith in the Resurrection of Christ implies<br />

that we all are the living stones of the<br />

Church, thus we are challenged to begin a<br />

new life in making God the destiny of our life<br />

<strong>and</strong> above all to see the new life beyond the<br />

horizon, in the h<strong>and</strong> of God.<br />

f<br />

Bishop Manuel Batakian<br />

New York – “Since we have become one with<br />

him in dying as he did, in the same way we shall<br />

be one with him by being raised to life as he was”<br />

(Rom 6,5).<br />

Our Christian faith comm<strong>and</strong>s that we believe<br />

not only in the Resurrection of Christ<br />

but in our own resurrection as well. At first<br />

glance we sense that it is not so easy to profess<br />

such a faith. Indeed it is different - <strong>and</strong><br />

natural - to believe in the Resurrection of<br />

Christ, given that He is God, the Lord of life<br />

<strong>and</strong> death, whose power has no limit, <strong>and</strong> it<br />

is yet another thing to believe in the resurrection<br />

of a human being, who by definition<br />

is mortal, therefore subject to annihilation, if<br />

not spiritually, then at least bodily.<br />

And yet, every time that we profess the<br />

Creed, we proclaim publicly that our resurrection,<br />

soul <strong>and</strong> body, is an essential part of our<br />

faith. But to what extent we are convinced<br />

of it, in practical terms, when we are making<br />

that profession, that is another question.<br />

We cannot doubt God’s ability to keep<br />

eternally immortal the souls He himself<br />

created as immortal. But is it required for<br />

Him give the same privilege to the body,<br />

whuxh came from dust <strong>and</strong> will return to<br />

dust, as we read in the Scriptures<br />

It is normal <strong>and</strong> logical that from time to<br />

time the issue of the resurrection of the body<br />

comes into our minds, especially when we,<br />

as Christians, are preparing to celebrate the<br />

Resurrection of Christ, because these two realities<br />

are indissolubly linked to one another.<br />

If we believe that Christ has risen, we cannot<br />

ignore or deny that we too will rise .<br />

And the reason is evident, <strong>and</strong> founded on<br />

the word of Christ himself. Either we accept<br />

the words of Christ completely, or we do not.<br />

Now, we hear him saying : “I am telling you<br />

the truth... Do not be surprised, the time will<br />

come when all the dead will hear the voice<br />

of the Son of God <strong>and</strong> will come out of their<br />

graves; those who have done good will rise<br />

<strong>and</strong> live, <strong>and</strong> those who have done evil will<br />

rise <strong>and</strong> be condemned (John 5, 25-28).<br />

Yet there is a great temptation in taking<br />

these words of Christ, <strong>and</strong> thus the meaning<br />

of our Resurrection, in a metaphoric or<br />

symbolic sense, as if to say: yes, there is a<br />

resurrection of mankind, there is also a second<br />

life, but in spirit, not in body. The spirit is<br />

holy, the body is sinful. The first deserves to<br />

survive, not the latter.<br />

This doubt, or distrust, arises in the minds<br />

of some for these reasons:<br />

First, can we reasonably expect that God<br />

gives life back to us mortals So doing. in<br />

some way, we are even doubting God‘s power.<br />

We see in the Holy Bible the manifestation<br />

of Almighty God from the first moment<br />

of creation: Scripture is a uninterrupted<br />

succession of miracles. These miracles take<br />

on a pivotal role in the earthly mission of<br />

Jesus. The healing of the sick, the multiplication<br />

of bread, the calming of storms, the<br />

raising from the dead... what signs or proofs<br />

of divine power can there be stronger than<br />

these He who created the world from nothing,<br />

who raised from death not only others<br />

by also Himself, should He not be able to<br />

create all his creatures again<br />

The second argument is that it is difficult<br />

to imagine what form or shape our body will<br />

take in coming to life again.: will it have the<br />

same physical characteristics, the same intellectual<br />

<strong>and</strong> spiritual qualities as it has in the<br />

present life<br />

The theologians describe in different ways<br />

what our bodies will be like in a second life,<br />

confessing nevertheless that no one can fully<br />

know the exact reality, because the only<br />

source of our knowledge, the Holy Scriptures,<br />

does not give us any information about it.<br />

God certainly wants to keep the mystery<br />

alive until our encounter with him.<br />

Following their logic, biblical scholars<br />

imagine the raised bodies as being endowed<br />

with the highest qualities, even corporeally,<br />

because the souls will join these ‘glorified’<br />

bodies <strong>and</strong> become one with them. This conviction<br />

is shared by St. Augustine who says<br />

that we will be in heaven ‘as we are’, we will<br />

keep our identity, but in sublime, perfect proportions.<br />

We will find ourselves in a universe<br />

where we will see God face to face, without<br />

any intermediary or interpreter.<br />

It is impossible to separate the Resurrection<br />

of Christ from our own. Christ did not<br />

triumph over death for Himself but in order<br />

to save us from the clutches of death. St.<br />

Paul is categorical on this point: if Christ<br />

did not rise from the dead, our entire faith<br />

would be disrupted <strong>and</strong> reduced to nothing.<br />

And our earthly life would turn to an existence<br />

without goal <strong>and</strong> meaning.<br />

The resurrection of Christ is neither a legend<br />

nor an illusion. It is an irrefutable reality<br />

sealed by the blood of myriads of witnesses.<br />

It is at the same time the foundation of our<br />

hope that we will share his glory thanks to<br />

our own resurrection.<br />

f<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter (ISSN 0004-2358), an independent newspaper,<br />

is published weekly by <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter llc.<br />

Copyright © 2009 by <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />

Reporter llc. All Rights Reserved<br />

Gerard L. Cafesjian, President <strong>and</strong> ceo<br />

Periodicals postage paid at Paramus, N.J., <strong>and</strong><br />

additional mailing offices.<br />

POSTMASTER: Send address changes to PO Box<br />

129, Paramus, NJ 07652-0129.<br />

The views expressed, except in the editorial, are<br />

not necessarily those of the publishers.<br />

Editor Vincent Lima<br />

Associate editor Maria Titizian<br />

Washington editor Emil Sanamyan<br />

Eastern U.S. editor Lou Ann Matossian<br />

Assistant to the Editor Seda Stepanyan<br />

Copy editor Ishkhan Jinbashian<br />

Art director Grigor Hakobyan<br />

The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter is your newspaper. We urge you to send us your news <strong>and</strong> your<br />

views.<br />

<strong>News</strong>. Please send your news to .<br />

Letters. Please send your letters to Letters should be no more<br />

than 250 words long <strong>and</strong> may be edited for clarity. Please include your mailing address<br />

<strong>and</strong> daytime telephone number.<br />

Commentary. Please send your essays to Essays <strong>and</strong> articles<br />

normally should be no longer than 900 words.<br />

Photos <strong>and</strong> artwork. We require high-resolution originals. All photos <strong>and</strong> artwork<br />

must include a credit to the photographer <strong>and</strong> a signed statement granting us permission<br />

to publish.<br />

Advertising <strong>and</strong> subscriptions. Please direct questions to or<br />

call us.<br />

Our offices<br />

2727 West Alameda Blvd<br />

Burbank CA 91505<br />

1-818-955-9933 phone<br />

1-818-955-8799 fax<br />

1 Yeghvard Hwy Fl 5<br />

Yerevan 0054 <strong>Armenia</strong><br />

374-10-367-195 phone<br />

374-10-367-194 fax


The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | April 11, 2009 19<br />

Commentary<br />

You are witnesses of these things<br />

Archbishop Khajag Barsamian<br />

New York – He said to them, “These are my<br />

words which I spoke to you, while I was still with<br />

you, that everything written about me in the<br />

law of Moses <strong>and</strong> the prophets <strong>and</strong> the psalms<br />

must be fulfilled.” Then he opened their minds<br />

to underst<strong>and</strong> the scriptures, <strong>and</strong> said to them,<br />

“Thus it is written, that the Christ should suffer<br />

<strong>and</strong> on the third day rise from the dead, <strong>and</strong><br />

that repentance <strong>and</strong> forgiveness of sins should<br />

be preached in his name to all nations, beginning<br />

from Jerusalem. You are witnesses of these<br />

things.” (St. Luke 24:44-48)<br />

The new life<br />

After the bitterness of winter, after the<br />

self-restraint of Lent, after the intense emotions<br />

of Holy Week, one encounters Easter<br />

with a sense of relief. Resurrection Sunday<br />

is, after all, the soaring finale to a harrowing<br />

story - the happy ending we’ve been waiting<br />

for. Ahead of us, we might feel, lies a bright<br />

horizon, free of troubles, where everything<br />

will be set right.<br />

This is not just a matter of our own perception:<br />

the gospels affirm that something<br />

profound <strong>and</strong> final occurred in the drama of<br />

Christ’s death <strong>and</strong> return to life. “The earth<br />

did quake, the rocks rent, the graves were<br />

opened,” we read; “the saints which slept<br />

arose, <strong>and</strong> coming out of their graves after<br />

his resurrection, went into the holy city, <strong>and</strong><br />

appeared to many” (Mt 27:51-53). Even the<br />

righteous dead arise, to testify to the magnitude<br />

of what has occurred. One can hardly<br />

imagine a more “final” statement. Where<br />

could the story possibly go from there<br />

Yet, as we know, the story did go on - <strong>and</strong><br />

not just as a continuation of Scripture. The<br />

story continued in history. We inhabit its latest<br />

page, <strong>and</strong> from our vantage we can see<br />

that the resurrection of Jesus Christ - assuredly<br />

the most important <strong>and</strong> wondrous turning<br />

point in history - was not history’s end. In<br />

a scene of piercing sadness, Jesus warned his<br />

followers not to make the mistake of thinking<br />

that his sufferings would spell an end<br />

to troubles for mankind. Staggering to the<br />

cross, trailed by a company of wailing women,<br />

Jesus turned to them <strong>and</strong> said, “Daughters<br />

of Jerusalem, weep not for me, but weep<br />

for yourselves, <strong>and</strong> for your children.... For<br />

if they do these things to a green tree, what<br />

shall be done to the dry” (Lk 23:29-31).<br />

In such words, one sees that Christ’s life<br />

<strong>and</strong> passion, while serving redemptive purposes<br />

all their own, were at the same time<br />

encapsulations, concentrations, of the human<br />

condition overall. What was once the<br />

lonely burden of mortal man - the misery<br />

of every person who has suffered injustice,<br />

who has seen his friends desert him, his<br />

loved ones endangered on his account, his<br />

world reduced to ashes - all of these troubles,<br />

were shared, embraced even, by our<br />

Lord in his journey to the cross. In Jesus,<br />

the blessings of life surely take on greater<br />

meaning for us, as glimpses of a kingdom<br />

yet to come; but his words leave no doubt<br />

that the sorrows of human living will never<br />

cease to be ours, as well.<br />

As <strong>Armenia</strong>ns, we instinctively know this<br />

- <strong>and</strong> we have certainly lived it. We saw the<br />

blessed evangelization of <strong>Armenia</strong>; but also<br />

a costly defense of the first Christian nation<br />

at Avarayr. We saw the flowering of a distinctive<br />

<strong>Armenia</strong>n culture <strong>and</strong> identity; but also<br />

knew exile <strong>and</strong> subjection to alien powers.<br />

We welcomed a new political reality which<br />

would allow us to advance in society; but we<br />

also endured the Genocide.<br />

Yet if our experience <strong>and</strong> theology comprehend<br />

this aspect of Christ’s sacrifice, they<br />

comprehend a larger meaning, as well. To<br />

be sure, the resurrection does not promise<br />

us an easy life, free of troubles. But it does<br />

promise that the monotonous cycles of security<br />

<strong>and</strong> suffering, of prosperity <strong>and</strong> poverty,<br />

are not in the end meaningless. The world<br />

will remain a mix of blessings <strong>and</strong> afflictions,<br />

as it always has; but in Christ, there really<br />

will be a final state of peace, where “God will<br />

wipe away every tear,” <strong>and</strong> all things will be<br />

made new again (Rev 21:4-5).<br />

Even for the disciples who lived alongside<br />

Jesus, these things were difficult to underst<strong>and</strong>.<br />

We are told that Christ had to “open<br />

their minds” to help them grasp what they<br />

had seen. But having done so he also charged<br />

them with the duty of remembering, <strong>and</strong> of<br />

acting on that memory. “You are witnesses of<br />

these things,” he told them.<br />

He tells it to us, too. Every year, in our Easter<br />

celebration, we see the miracle of Christ’s<br />

Catholicos<br />

Karekin II<br />

performs<br />

the ritual<br />

washing of<br />

the feet in<br />

Etchmiadzin<br />

on Great<br />

<strong>and</strong> Holy<br />

Thursday.<br />

Photo:<br />

Photolure.<br />

resurrection re-enacted, re-lived, before<br />

our eyes. We see life emerge from the grave,<br />

hope emerge from despair. We are reminded<br />

of that final, peaceable kingdom, where our<br />

hearts will find rest; <strong>and</strong> of the painful sacrifice<br />

that purchased it for us.<br />

We are reminded, too, that a foretaste of<br />

God’s kingdom exists here on earth, in the<br />

Church our Lord established. Especially in an<br />

anxious, uncertain time, the church needs to<br />

be The Church: it needs to nourish its mission<br />

as a witness - it needs to act as a witness to<br />

Christ’s resurrection. We will have a chance to<br />

do so again, when we sing our Easter greeting:<br />

Krisdos haryav ee merelotz! Orhnyal eh harootiunun<br />

Krisdosee! Christ is risen from the<br />

dead! Blessed is the resurrection of Christ!<br />

This year, let us sing these words with<br />

the conviction of those who first saw our<br />

risen Lord, who touched his wounds, <strong>and</strong><br />

responded to the miracle of his resurrection.<br />

For in the deepest sense, we, too, are<br />

witnesses of these things.<br />

f<br />

Archbishop Oshagan Choloyan<br />

New York – ...we have been buried with him<br />

by baptism into death, so that, just as Christ<br />

was raised from the dead by the glory of the<br />

Father, so we too might walk in newness of life.<br />

-Romans 6:4-5<br />

Christ’s eternal presence in the world <strong>and</strong><br />

in our hearts became humankind’s possession<br />

because of His Resurrection. The first<br />

witnesses to that Resurrection were His disciples<br />

<strong>and</strong> followers. They transmitted to us<br />

what they saw to which they gave witness<br />

with dedication <strong>and</strong> faith, <strong>and</strong> for which they<br />

paid with torture <strong>and</strong> martyrdom.<br />

The miracle that we try to underst<strong>and</strong><br />

on Easter is considerably above the human<br />

mind <strong>and</strong> logic. When we believe <strong>and</strong> live<br />

accordingly, then a new person is born within<br />

us, who enters into a new life <strong>and</strong> a new<br />

way of life with Christ. The most convincing<br />

statement is made by the Apostle Paul when<br />

he says, “If we have been united with him in<br />

a death like his, we will certainly be united<br />

with him in a resurrection like his” (Romans<br />

6:5). Our defeat of sin mysteriously occurs<br />

with our baptism, after which as a new creature-this<br />

time as a faithful Christian-we live<br />

enjoying the grace that one day will take<br />

us to our resurrected life. Our life is the<br />

grace given to us by God <strong>and</strong> our salvation<br />

is God’s expressed love. Salvation is not our<br />

own doing; it is the gift of God. (Eph 2:8)<br />

Therefore, this new life has a message<br />

for us. First, it is our prime duty to be<br />

cleansed internally. This takes place when<br />

we kill sin in us, for which our Lord sacrificed<br />

His life. As long as we remain in sin,<br />

we remain slaves of sin through out desire,<br />

our greed, our ego which repels us from all<br />

humankind created in our image. On the<br />

contrary, we must go to all, have compassion<br />

<strong>and</strong> love, serve <strong>and</strong> help them, so that<br />

the sinner in us will not rule, but rather<br />

Christ Himself. “For we are what he has<br />

made us, created in Christ Jesus for good<br />

works, which God prepared beforeh<strong>and</strong> to<br />

be our way of life” (Eph 2:10).<br />

Second, after destroying the sinner in us,<br />

it is our duty to gain new life. In order to<br />

gain that life, we must sacrifice our life, if<br />

necessary, just as Christ sacrificed His life<br />

to give us new life. There is no greater proclamation<br />

than that of the Apostle Paul, “For<br />

to me, living is Christ <strong>and</strong> dying is gain (Phil<br />

1:21). Blessed are those who can gain that life,<br />

a life filled with love, enlightened by sacrifice<br />

<strong>and</strong> enriched by service.<br />

May Christ’s miraculous Resurrection be a<br />

message <strong>and</strong> reminder to us all that in order<br />

to live with Him we must completely cleanse<br />

ourselves, destroy sin, in order to be worthy<br />

of salvation, His grace, new life, <strong>and</strong> our<br />

unity with Him.<br />

Christ is risen from the dead. Blessed is the<br />

resurrection of Christ.<br />

f<br />

The resurrection of our Lord brings renewal to our lives<br />

Archbishop Moushegh<br />

Mardirossian<br />

La Crescenta, Calif. –<br />

“Christ is risen from the dead!<br />

He trampled down death by death,<br />

<strong>and</strong> by His resurrection He granted life to us.<br />

Glory to Him for all ages. Amen.” (Hymn)<br />

The enlivening spirit of rebirth <strong>and</strong> renewal<br />

resonates throughout the world once again<br />

as we Christians prepare to celebrate Christendom’s<br />

greatest <strong>and</strong> most important feast,<br />

the Glorious Resurrection of our Lord Savior<br />

Jesus Christ, <strong>and</strong> join together to exclaim<br />

“Christ is risen from the dead! Alleluia.<br />

Come ye peoples, sing unto the Lord! Alleluia.”<br />

(Hymn)<br />

The Resurrection of our Lord brings to us a<br />

profound message of rebirth <strong>and</strong> renewal. It<br />

starts with death, the crucifixion <strong>and</strong> entombment<br />

of Jesus Christ on Good Friday, <strong>and</strong> ends<br />

with life, the Glorious Resurrection on Easter<br />

Sunday. It is the conquering of death <strong>and</strong> the<br />

dawn of a new life, a reassurance that good<br />

will always triumph <strong>and</strong> hope will abound.<br />

It is very fitting that Easter comes in<br />

springtime, a season marked by the blossoming<br />

of life when the dark, harsh winter ends<br />

<strong>and</strong> the sun shines bright again. We witness<br />

the workings of nature with the death of the<br />

old <strong>and</strong> the birth of the new. As we too undergo<br />

this natural cycle of life, we will not<br />

be facing an end, but beginning a new life, a<br />

rebirth into a new state, for the Resurrection<br />

gives us this promise, “He saves us through<br />

the washing of rebirth <strong>and</strong> renewal by the<br />

Holy Spirit, whom He poured out on us generously<br />

through Jesus Christ our Savior, so<br />

that, having been justified by His grace, we<br />

might become heirs having the hope of eternal<br />

life” (Titus 3:5-7).<br />

One need not die physically to experience<br />

resurrection. The broader message of the<br />

Resurrection is that after pain <strong>and</strong> suffering<br />

comes redemption <strong>and</strong> hope. Many times<br />

in life we are overcome with obstacles, but<br />

these obstacles are just steps, passages to<br />

achieving enlightenment. Jesus Christ had<br />

to die on the cross to be resurrected, as St.<br />

Peter proclaims, “Blessed be the God <strong>and</strong> Father<br />

of our Lord Jesus Christ, Who according<br />

to His abundant mercy has begotten us again<br />

to a living hope through the resurrection of<br />

Jesus Christ from the dead” (1 Peter 1:3-4).<br />

The promise of the Resurrection raises us<br />

from the depths of our darkest hours by giving<br />

us freedom from our burdens, granting<br />

us strength, <strong>and</strong> hope for a renewed heart, a<br />

renewed soul, <strong>and</strong> a renewed life.<br />

Dear faithful,<br />

Easter is an awakening; a time of revitalization<br />

<strong>and</strong> rejuvenation.<br />

It is a spiritual rebirth, a journey towards a<br />

higher purpose that starts internally within<br />

ourselves when we accept Jesus Christ as our<br />

Savior with an open <strong>and</strong> pure heart, a journey<br />

whose significance cannot be overstated for<br />

in the words of our Savior, “Most assuredly, I<br />

say to you, unless one is born again, he cannot<br />

see the kingdom of God” (John 3:1-3).<br />

The Easter message is for all mankind. It is<br />

a transformative message that is needed now<br />

more than ever in a world that has become<br />

more despondent. The Resurrection of our<br />

Lord is a miraculous gift that restores faith to<br />

the faithless <strong>and</strong> gives hope to the hopeless;<br />

it allows us to pass from death to a life, from<br />

despair to optimism, <strong>and</strong> invites us to be reborn<br />

to be worthy of His abundant blessings<br />

<strong>and</strong> promises.<br />

Two thous<strong>and</strong> years ago Jesus brought<br />

His Light to the world. That light still shines<br />

brightly as a call to faith, love, <strong>and</strong> hope <strong>and</strong><br />

it is just as, if not more, inspiring <strong>and</strong> meaningful<br />

today.<br />

For centuries, our ancestors not only comprehended<br />

the mystery <strong>and</strong> awe of the Resurrection<br />

they lived it through their faith<br />

<strong>and</strong> deeds, thus renewing the life <strong>and</strong> spirit<br />

of the <strong>Armenia</strong>n people <strong>and</strong> nation.<br />

As His Holiness Aram I, Catholicos of the<br />

Great House of Cilicia, has proclaimed 2009<br />

the “Year of the Youth”, let us heed this call<br />

to pay special attention to the needs of our<br />

youth. Let us impart to them the uplifting<br />

<strong>and</strong> life-giving message of the Resurrection<br />

<strong>and</strong> commit ourselves to their spiritual<br />

nourishment <strong>and</strong> development not just during<br />

this time but throughout the year. Let<br />

us bridge our youth to our religious <strong>and</strong> national<br />

heritage <strong>and</strong> through them, <strong>and</strong> for<br />

them, renew <strong>and</strong> reinvigorate our mission for<br />

the survival <strong>and</strong> prosperity of our Church<br />

<strong>and</strong> nation.<br />

Let us reflect on the Easter tidings of love,<br />

hope, faith, <strong>and</strong> renewal, reaffirm our faith,<br />

<strong>and</strong> undergo spiritual rebirth <strong>and</strong> revival to<br />

live a richer <strong>and</strong> deeper quality of life.<br />

Emboldened by the message of the Resurrection,<br />

let us “put on the new man who is<br />

renewed in knowledge according to the image<br />

of Him who created him” (Col. 3:10), <strong>and</strong><br />

allow the good tidings of this glorious Feast<br />

to lift us to new life <strong>and</strong> new heights.<br />

With these sentiments, let us pray for<br />

the Lord to “Create in me a clean heart, O<br />

God, <strong>and</strong> renew a steadfast spirit within me”<br />

(Psalms 51:10).<br />

We extend our best wishes to our Clergy,<br />

Executive Council, Delegates, parish representatives,<br />

educators, sister organizations,<br />

our faithful parishioners, <strong>and</strong> to all those<br />

who labor for the splendor of our Church <strong>and</strong><br />

nation, <strong>and</strong> join you in proclaiming,<br />

“Christ is risen from the dead.<br />

Blessed be the Resurrection of Christ.” f


20 The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | April 11, 2009


The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | April 11, 2009


The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | April 11, 2009

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!