• k - Mungret College Past Pupils' Union

234 MUNGRET ANNUAL 1ST CLUB DEBATING SOCIETY 235
i
iI•d. " l•hd l:riiit . t .'s
iiii5-Ottliai',' Ltltiri('s \Vi' tinil I i'iaiiil i Iii(tilt'"t
but lit't'i'-'-arv factir.''1 lii' iil;t-.tt'r niio.t
shari' ill tlii' of 1n mill. anti ili\
ttidt'iit of iiit try hOist admit that ill.
ri'iatitinsiiil) if iiltii mill iiiiiti'r t'\O-lt 1
1ii'tvt't'ii lrUl&'t' and I rt'i;ihiil i t'arlv
hit' ,ixtii ('t'flhIIF\'.
ibis lit t,llltt'ht'ti iii'
t'Iainis iii irdhit't,'. It jii'tift.' I r'IncI
i'Iain ill liii Pdrrii tihilt's lit It 1 ri1 hi
\ltini,trt't aIl(I Its it'ti\'1tit'
it -tIi III i'','t'rV
dillit lii tiit'n I' 'au in u' \ I ru't from till tiit'
1, Iv l',,tl,t'r a,iiir't'-. hut iii' Irish (i\'it'
lit 111:111(1
ill \viiiu'ii ii' 1t,uiil a .ti'iLiiii,t triluiitt'
iIl(I iii'' j)art slit' piavt'ui ill
iuliiii. tii' light of tlit' I. it ust'l. lit
iii li:iit'ti liv it ri't,'ri'nt u' ti Australia xxiat'ii
i. I riIh to ) thc backhonc and rt'n,arkt 'ii
oil liii' i-i l'i'IatI011 of liii' I ti'h laity ii it'l't'
intl t'I-t'\\hle'tt' as king as lgniIht'iinI
thu
\it'rs, (.'tuihn, Mt ,lhlflhil'ss aiiul
lilt if took ti,' hilt1 in toni. I If , if - t'iiit'I
wt rk was to t'ialut nUt' ti,point, w loch
Mr. Howard hlit'hilii>hit'(I but uiil not dt'vt'iolt,
\ir. ('iiilitis va:t'i u'hiiull:u'iit( ,it Irt'linil ill
ti lt ' \Iitluli' \lr. \l'i iiiihiiit'.5 oil tin'
In-h ill ,\iistralii. \\iiil' uIr, (''('tuiiiit'il
(Iist'li'il ill clt'taii Iii' work ii
C tIiiiiiit;uiii. itid i liii' tthi'r gnat iniit ill-
It
Mr. I.yn, If
tht'ui utitt . lit'ul thu (''.i' for tiit'
)1ipuiitiitIi. I it. ltt'i_tiii h' t"kluILt ho. ijiulitirs
to itu't't intl from Iii' ft t that tiit ,.\" win'
I roTh, auiui to
\'it'\' liii' uiiatti'n iii t1111'stlOii
a'. CathuuIui', lit' iiri t.t'(I jtrtuviliu
lnant'' Itlp ,6 1' It 1 I rt'ituiti Ill till - llii"5itiii
auitl iii'- arguinciit. \vt'rt' linit'tiv
_\hiit oIt
Al tin' gnat 1lti.".iii1larv
in til t , wturiil had tht'ir iunii.tjii in
l:ratiu:&,. I rt'iand t'(tihi(l only hoist of on'.
i'ht' zt'ai of 1r&'nch Catholics in tilt- u'atit'
(if tilt' ?il'.ioiti' \Vls lillslirpO.5i'(l by thuut'
of aiiv thin u'ollllti'\'. I hi r illituli'tar\'
'u untrilitil it til. \vi'rc st't'u uII&I
I 1)'ianci
I univ Iii I lit "t' of
vo,ilcI rani aitutiut ninth,,
'I'ht' nt.iniltt'r lot Froth ji'snii'. on thi'
Mi'.".it ills V. Is ilitiiitit' tin' uiiiiuulut'r if Irish
Jt'.iiit, in uth at home and ahroad. I rt'iauiil
was langi'l inulu'lutt'ul to I'rauict' liii' thi'
pi'&'s&'r'atiiin it t hi' Faith dui'ing Itoh
ii lit's,
'tit'. Murphy from his stinv'v of thi' wi ul'ltl's
uuiiitit-tit'iui iivt' thi' palm to i"ranct,
Mr. Flanagan who followed ik'w iuiit',t of
hits t'\'iilt'ltt't' from thu sttti'tii'- it the
uIi''.itunirv 1'xhiiuition, ,nil i't'ft'i'i't'ul
to I'it'iLtialt at'tivlt\', 11 r. l"ii'i,i,,tt'i'iiui, t'hutt
i'itiit'hiultii, u''tv&'il It, provc fi'iti,i .tatisti,'.
tht' ihIlllli'hI'-u' silpt'l'lol'it\' of i"i't'iii'li ii\'t'l'
I i'i-hi 'ti j'...jt to .
In. 1t 'li\' it It lit-ti 1 a to 'tV \\'t ti'il', to t
tilt'
nit't'tini,, 11 jut tight that It'll lililt'li ti't".'.
Was Lii I tfl t it istiu,'.. lit' tlit' pp ui t it ii
toil ii tjnii'ui tilt that a t'It'\'i'i' lt,'l'sthll ''Wild
lit' tlit'nì iii siipiii.'.ticil adt'alltiLtt' \1 r.
-.tt 'iii '11'- also spoke.
Fi'. I'avi' thou, afti'i' :u Ct}flcis&' ttliti 11'u1
-uuilintry if tht' il'tuint 'oh 1 ut t lit' lilt 0 ii
to tilt ,
lit iiit'.
rt''.iilt was
Tin' I1 ,011111 mt't'tii1 of tilt ' ttt'lt'1t' itt
in I )t'ct'iutbt'i' I , 'l'ht' sltt'u'ciit'.. (.11
tilt , tt'holr (li(I nut i'i'achi hlii' staridti'th ii
tliiisi' hu';inul at thu fttrint'r ul,'hiitu', \'t't thur
\vcr'u' one of two ut taitit' i'xu:t'jutittu'.. Ill
thu aio.i'rieu' itt ill, , N I 'v, I hiuii'iiiait ti it
lilt', tin , Was 1tr,'-.uilt'tl o\'i'l' by Rev. Fr,
Kilt', Fr, I Ott ,uuud it'v, Mn. Mclii
V.11' iL t lit t 'lit.
Tin' Ili( lin fttr diu:lN..uitlt tva- that
l'i t\'t'i'tV i" Ill I ippontuhiul Iv f( )1- , rather
han clll ui i-'tit'ii' to
chii'ttctt'i'.'
:\tli r ill ,uti\'t' : -
the ult'vt 'it till, tnt of
Ni',ii it''
O'tlit'u. F. \\' '1
Thiuurnton,
In, ()'I)t'a,
,\, Mi It uii.tgh,
M. Mttlltuy,
M. uI ti,iu'al it,', W. J_t
I tpi'i'iu'd tht,' ul'h'atu.' ii' tit'Iiiuing
It ut' rI V. intl I it,' i'uliiig t tilt the p upitlar
ttflu't'i it it tO ut J tvt'rty ita Ili( 'i\', liii' t;uti
if things usn,iiiv unit with in shun di -tl'it,'ts,
Cifltt'hldt'd that huohl ih' \u'gati\'t'
.ittt'mpt to i'stahho.li tiiu'ii' ci..' uuli such it
lilt' of argunhu'nt tliu'\' wuiiulth lx' ' over-
1i'ppiflg tin' m;n'k, 'Ihi' p1101' man ittltst
work and in work ii' itt'rfi'cts hi dv, soul
and ehiai'ictt 'r, 'l'l it
I 'thiS of lux urr' atiul
it ,; accuilnit,tli\'ilLt ',ht all \t't'l't', ui,u, t nit' to it
ii',ii' IruilO Iiiiinin IN Iut'i'it'lut't',
Ai' L'NtvER,I iv I IAIi., DUBLIN
tuuitIitn \\ , sli, 11.,11 I K Iv. M. SIt tt,ttt, I. k,tt,tui,tIt,
(tnt rI I, I', 'itt ', [ \\'Itutt', I', t
It..uuu, I\t'uruu' J. J. ( ,utiuitut,, t;tt,',,'tl .1 ui ,ttrni,un
'l'ht' stht'l't'ring
tvIuicIi often accu>unjiuiiii's lit Vt 'ntt,', Ill' fl'olll
lit'iiig 111 i'\'il, i" ill .ullt\' it iuit'-.ilhg,
\\'ho Inst t'iit sulfur, lut'.t t'iit it', '
Lii'
thin t'h'alt \Vitll tilt (ih)Iu'Ctiull that lit t''t'i't\'
I lulls ignorihici', and ignu unancu' i a p Ii to
lInt,'
l'ot't'i't\' liii It uligt'r u'ut'ans igntiu'ilit:u',
\ir. "I'hiuui'ntuun hitul I'u'u'tthul'si' to lii-.huul'\' to
t'' that i'lldlhl'iili,'' if htiuiib' lian(Ishii1ihi.t'
ih\Vl\'s h)t't'l'h ru'gai'&hu'uI 15 it big fictttr
ill cllii'it'tt'I' hilIhIu,iill,,
\veikt'ii u,'Ioiractt'i'.
and infidelity to ulut t,',
" \\Iiit tenths to
lit' ,iith, " i- 'n.y ii\'nlg
t't tntr,t-4 iit'twt't'n tilt' nut''-. of
LIll ' op(
uih, t',, , tilt- Ht'ugait''.t',
lIt 'it' ft tilt 'Itt 1 a
I'
\ttrIlit'i'n
Mn, Mulctiit,' argued that ativto.it\' is
t't'i'\' liei.'t'5tl'V to tin'
ti't'lli_jtilt'llilg t if
ciiai'actt'i' it wi. ui'uh ti t i- i'ttt'ct iv iii
tilt' great -huts,
Mr. ()i) a tttutk lilt t ir t ,iiit1tii' of
siutitu' i'liunicti'rs hlact'ih ill circulllt,l)u't',
of luxury and hiinil.hj1t l'i'silt'ctjv,'i\' auth
from 16, compm'h-u tih ulrt'tv tilt ,
in f'i'' lii.'''
tlu.ut u t t'u'tv iii i'. aid cliaractt'r, hit' Ii'i-.h
-Ii ('1114t 11 of chiurit'it'r tt'.n., he llluifltui lit 'ul,
tint' uiuuiiii'' to advcl'..it v,
1' tr tilt- >,t',i,uhivi' tiu', \\'i'i)h iiu'i,'iart'd
tli,iI ittt\'t'rty, fI'tiuii it. \'eI'\' lIitliu'u', lflll-t
ii' tlt'tniuiuu'iit,ui
to ciutnittin lorniation,
I'.x1ut'nit'nct' hi , 11u, f,ii' to J)rovi.' tlui.,