Download - Society for Cardiothoracic Surgery

19 theBulletin
December 2011
O B I T U A R Y
Matthias Paneth 1921-2011
Cardiothoracic Surgeon, The Brompton Hospital
Matthias Paneth (universally known as MP) died peacefully on
1st September 2011 after a brief illness. He was born in
Amsterdam on 30th April 1921, where his father, a doctor, was
on a course in tropical medicine. The family then departed to
Sumatra where Paneth senior was Medical Officer to a Dutch
rubber plantation. As was customary with expatriate life, MP
was sent to school in the United Kingdom at the age of 13. A
fellow pupil at Gordonstoun School in Scotland was the Duke of
Edinburgh.
Following school, he went up to Christ Church, Oxford to read
Medicine. On completion of his undergraduate training he
served short stints as a houseman and senior house officer at
the Radcliffe Infirmary in Oxford, the Royal Cancer Hospital and
the Hammersmith Hospital. On moving to the Brompton Hospital
he was house surgeon to Lord Russell Brock and Oswald Tubbs.
He was appointed Senior Registrar at the Brompton in 1957. Two
years later he joined the staff as a Consultant, to remain there for
the rest of his professional career.
For almost 30 years he strode the corridors and wards of the
Brompton as an intellectual and professional giant. Physically he
was imposing too. He was a man of great charisma, always
immaculately attired and possessed of a reassuringly booming
voice. He was admired by all who worked with him and the
mutual respect that existed between him and his colleagues was
one of the factors that led to the development of the Brompton
as a centre of clinical and educational excellence. Although many
of his colleagues may not have always seen eye to eye with him
- and vice versa - his presence was such that the Brompton
surgeons always presented a united front in the face of any
“outsider”.
On soliciting the views of several of my contemporaries, I was
constantly reminded of his surgical skill, the dedication to
training young surgeons, the seamless and continuous nature of
the way that he cared for his patients, the intellectual sharpness
allied to great wit, loyalty and paternal instinct. He possessed
great style. Despite being well over six feet tall, he looked
completely at ease with the seat right back in his Porsche. A man
and his car in perfect harmony!
The year that he spent as a Fulbright Scholar in Minneapolis in
1955 undertaking research into the development of the
heart/lung machine and techniques of cardiopulmonary bypass
made him a leading figure in the development of open-heart
surgery at the Brompton and the evolution of surgical
techniques for valve replacement and repair. This enabled him to
dispense with spending hours oxygenating bags of blood on a
Sunday in order to be able to perform “smash and grab” aortic
valvotomies in infants in the absence of cardiopulmonary
bypass. As trainees we heard endless stories of his early
experiences of the pre-bypass era. Despite the fact that his
career began in the pre-coronary artery grafting era, he quickly
became expert in all the new techniques that were emerging. He
was always willing to pass on his knowledge to those who
worked with him.
He used to hold court
every morning in the
theatre manager’s
office next to the
operating theatres. This
was an opportunity for
junior surgeons to
highlight concerns,
seek advice on patient
management or simply
discuss one’s career
options. His work-rate was difficult to keep up with - ten
operating sessions a week, daily ward rounds on the ITU at 7.00
am during weekdays and 11.00 am at weekends. We started the
mornings in ITU and progressed to the wards. If phone calls
came we were able to say that he was on Elizabeth now but
would be with Rose later. He had a totally disarming sense of
humour, which never left him, even during the middle of an
emergency operation. On one occasion when a patient had to be
returned to theatre for bleeding, the Senior House Officer whose
ligature on a side branch of the saphenous vein had slipped was
suitably admonished and naturally nicknamed “side branch”.
This moniker has stuck to this day - and the SHO is now a leading
congenital cardiac surgeon.
His training of junior surgeons was rigorous and he led by
example. Once he judged the skill of the trainee he was
magnanimous and patient in allowing the registrars to “spread
their wings”. He was above all a kind and generous man. This
side of him extended to staff outside the surgical fraternity. An
ex-theatre nurse remarked to me recently how much of an
impact MP had on her life. When she got married in the chapel at
the Brompton hospital, MP readily agreed to give the bride away
since her family were living abroad and unable to attend the
wedding. “I have been waiting to give you away for a long time
Vicky,” he quipped. Never an opportunity missed for that
humour.
Matthias Paneth leaves behind his wife Shirley, daughters Claire
and Sarah and two grandsons. In addition, countless numbers of
cardiothoracic surgeons who were trained by him over the years
owe a great debt of gratitude and consider it a privilege to have
known him. Mr Matthias Paneth was a colossus.
Mr Ravi Pillai
Consultant Cardiothoracic Surgeon