17.11.2012 Views

Eprg charter schools for new zealand report

Eprg charter schools for new zealand report

Eprg charter schools for new zealand report

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

• Another study of the Swedish system, undertaken to promote free<br />

<strong>schools</strong> in Britain, argues that there have been significant benefits<br />

from Swedish free <strong>schools</strong>, especially <strong>for</strong>-profit <strong>schools</strong>. It<br />

there<strong>for</strong>e advises the British government to reverse its policy of<br />

prohibiting <strong>for</strong>-profit <strong>schools</strong>.<br />

• Swedish <strong>for</strong>-profit free <strong>schools</strong> have become big business. One<br />

analysis illustrates how the companies that operate <strong>for</strong>-profit<br />

<strong>schools</strong> have become tradable commodities in a global battle <strong>for</strong><br />

supremacy among trans-national corporations and private<br />

investment funds.<br />

• In England, <strong>charter</strong> school equivalents, currently known as<br />

‘academies’ have been operating since the late 1980s. Some<br />

schemes have required such <strong>schools</strong> to secure partial business<br />

sponsorship. Successive government initiatives have encouraged<br />

secondary <strong>schools</strong> to become specialist <strong>schools</strong> (with expertise in<br />

particular curriculum offerings) or academies (directly funded by<br />

central government rather than administered via local government).<br />

Many of the academies that have been set up by businesses<br />

specialise in entrepreneurial education.<br />

• Since the election of the coalition government in 2010 ‘free<br />

<strong>schools</strong>’ have been introduced in England to permit parents,<br />

teachers, charities and businesses to apply to establish a primary or<br />

secondary school outside local government control. The <strong>new</strong> free<br />

<strong>schools</strong> in England have not been operating long enough <strong>for</strong><br />

thorough evaluation to take place.<br />

• The English experience overall suggests that: (i) many <strong>schools</strong><br />

which seek and are granted the equivalent of <strong>charter</strong> status do not<br />

serve the most disadvantaged students; (ii) <strong>report</strong>ed achievement<br />

gains are largely the result of managed changes over time in the<br />

school’s student composition; and (iii) less academically able<br />

students are often excluded from the <strong>new</strong> school.<br />

• Charter <strong>schools</strong> began in the USA in the 1990s in response to<br />

perceived weaknesses in many urban <strong>schools</strong>. There are now some<br />

4,000 <strong>charter</strong> <strong>schools</strong> in 40 states and they enrol more than a<br />

million students.<br />

• Numerous studies have been funded or conducted by groups that<br />

either support or oppose <strong>charter</strong> <strong>schools</strong>. Typically, the findings of<br />

<strong>charter</strong> school supporters are vehemently criticised by their<br />

opponents, and vice versa. Where study findings are based on the<br />

analysis of official databases of student characteristics and<br />

achievement outcomes, the statistical methods are invariably<br />

criticised as incomplete, misleading or flawed. For example, the<br />

Stan<strong>for</strong>d University CREDO study has been widely cited as<br />

! iii!

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!